UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Government in camera Motion toRedact or Delete Classi?ed Informationfrom Evidence Made Availableto the Accused under MRE 505(g)(2)and for an Additional Protective Orderfor Classi?ed InformationManning, Bradley E.PFC, U.S. Army,HHC, U.S. Army Garrison, under MRE 505(g)(1)Joint Base Myer-Henderson HallFort Myer, Virginia 22211 26 October 2012Enclosure 14UNCLASSQFEED APPELLATE PAGE REFERENCED:PAGE OF PAGES UNCLASSHHEDFord, Arthur Jr CW2 USARMY (US)From: Fein, Ashden MAJ USARMY MDW (US)Sent: Monday, August 06, 2012 6:24 PMTo: David CoombsCc: Hurley, Thomas MAJ OSD OMC Defense; Tooman, Joshua CPT USARMY Morrow,JoDean (Joe) CPT USARMY USAMDW Overgaard, Angel CPT USARMY Whyte, Hunter CPT USARMY von Elten, Alexander (Alec) CPT USARMY Ford, Arthur Jr CW2 USARMY (US)Subject: Production and Discovery UpdateDavid,This email serves as an update and recap of the productions from the last week, includingtoday, and outstanding discovery requests the United States is tracking.1. Classified Productions.a. Tracking #2 7986 8499 9626 (delivered on 2 Aug) containing: NGA documents (13Documents, BATES 00449582 - 00449764); and Joint Staff documents (4512 Documents,BATES 00449943 - 00471793); HQDA documents (1318 Documents, BATES 00471794 00479054);DIA documents (4825 Documents, BATES 00479055 - 00504418); ATF document (1 Document, BATES00504419 - 00504420).b. Tracking #2 7938 6252 6592 (delivered on 3 Aug) containing: DIA documents (53Documents, BATES 00504653 - 00505060) and other classified documents, includingassessments by DTRA, USITC, DEA, and PIAB, and various CID documents (BATES #2 00505061 -00505183).c. Tracking 7938 6938 4403 (delivery scheduled for 7 August 2012) containing: (1) Disk1- damage documents (BATES 00505205 00505256); other law enforcement documentsincluding enemy information and documents relating to one dataset (BATES 00505258 -00505322); (2) Disk 2- other documents related to another dataset along with an attestationcertificate (BATES 00505323 - 00505808); (3) Disk 3- "Info Extracted from the FBI Disk?(explained below); and (4) Disks 4 through 7 containing the classified enclosures to theGovernment Motion to PreAdmit 2.d. On Friday, 3 August 2012, CPT Morrow sent via SIPR a classified memorandum to all threedefense security experts (Hall, Ganiel, and Robillard), but addressed to you, titled"Discovery Production". The purpose of this memorandum is to notify the defense that certainforensic evidence is available for the defense and your forensic computer experts to view,but on an identified computer. The memorandum explains what the evidence is and how it willbe made available. The underlying forensic evidence is for the four documents found at BATES00505208-0050529. Additionally, these four documents reference two files that were alsoextracted and produced on a separate classified CD labeled "Info Extracted from the FBI Disk"(referenced above).2. Unclassified Productions.a. Tracking 7986 8527 6520 (delivered on 2 August 2012) containing: Various documents,including confinement recordings and logs, IA and ATRRS training records, 201 file pages thatwere not previously produced with BATES numbers but were included in the court filings, andInt3!ink log attestation (BATES 00504421 - 00504481).1UNCLASSHUEDUNCLASSIFEEDb. Tracking #2 7938 6321 2778 (delivered 3 August 2012) containing: Miscellaneousdocuments and attestation certificate, including prior classification declaration and CIDmemos (BATES 00505184 - 00505204).c. Tracking 7938 6660 9289 (delivered 6 August 2012) containing the Int3!ink logattestation re?produced with an updated BATES number and an MFR explaining the re?numbering(BATES 00505257 - 00505257).3. NSA Document Review. Per CPT Morrow?s email at 1129 on 3 August 2012, please coordinatewith Mr. Erik Dodson to inspect the NSA document.4. Gap in Production Numbers. we are going through the damage assessment/impact reviewswhich we provided for defense inspection and applying BATES As of now, only the DIA(BATES 00504532?00504652) and Dos (BATES 00504482-00504531) documents have been givenBATES #5 and we will manually BATES the specially controlled documents and provide duringthe next session.5. Delivery to MAJ Hurley. we attempted to deliver the classified material to MAJ Hurley onboth 3 August 2012 and 6 August 2012, but he is not in the office. when he returns, we willcoordinate delivery. we will continue to send the information to NNC.6. Discovery Request, dated 9 July 2012. The prosecution is working with Quantico to searchfor the requested video. Thus far, Quantico has been unsuccessful in its search. we willlet you know if the video is found or when we exhaust all available resources. Theprosecution intends to respond to your request by the end of the week, but as of now we havebeen told that the memory card was reallocated and cannot be found.7. Discovery Request, dated 1 August 2012. Understanding the urgency on this request, weare currently working with Quantico MCB to determine what information still exists and isavailable, especially considering most leaders have departed this summer. Once we ascertainthis information, we will then be able to quickly reply and expect to reply by the end of theweek. we will provide the defense with an update on Wednesday afternoon.8. Article 13 Redactions. The only information that CPT von Elten identified that should beredacted is information pursuant to the Court's order pertaining to individuals? names andtheir duty positions, in order to protect their identify (not parties to the litigation).His list should help you identify the places that we found while reading the pleading, but wedid not scrub the list to ensure that you complied with the Court's order.9. Discovery Production. The prosecution is working to locate and produce the smock,mattress, and blanket, per the Court?s order.10. Unclassified Damage Assessments. The prosecution continues to coordinate with thoseorganizations that provided a classified damage assessment. A majority of thoseorganizations have denied the defense?s request, while others are vetting the requestthroughout the organization to provide the prosecution an answer to the defense?s request.Should any organization provide an unclassified version of their document, the prosecutionwill disclose that material as soon as possible.11. Speedy Trial witness List. The prosecution will provide you with a response regardingthe filing date for the defense?s Speedy Trial witness List tomorrow.Thank you!v/rAshden2UNCLASSIFIEDUNCLASSIFIEDFedEx Express Us. Mail: PO Box 727Customer Trace Memphis. TN 38194-46433875 Airways vardModule H. 4th Floor le hone: 901-3%-3600E30955 Merrphie, TN 38116 August 72012Dear Customer.The tolrowing is the proot-or-delivery for tracking number 793869384403.Delivery Information:Statue: Delivered Delivered to: ShippingmeoetvingSigned for by: RWEGIEL Delivery baton: 12 CHANDLER STNEWPORT, RI 02841Service type: Priority Envelope Delivery date: Aug 7, 2012 09:58 lnforme?on: Trucking number: 793869384403 Ship date: Aug 6. 2012Welght 0.5 IbsI0.2 kgRecipient. President ATTN: Military JusticeNaval War Cottage OSJA. 686 CUSHING RD 103 3rd AvenueNEWPORT, RI 02841 US 32 Suite 100Fort McNair. DC 20319 USThank you for choosing FedEx Express.FedEx Worldwide Customer Service1.80o.GoFedEx 1.800.463.3339UNCLASSIFIEDUNCLASSIFIEDTRANSMITTAL RECORDFor use of nus Ic:m, see AR 25-50, the prupcnent agency is DCSPER1. SECURITY CLASSIFICAIION 2 SHIPMENT NO3 TITLEEFILEIDENTIFICATIONSec BLOCK for 0| CD55 SHIPMENT DATE4. AS or one 6 AUTHORITY FOR SHIPMENT7 NUMBER OF RECORDS TRANSMITTEDI2 CD58 PERSON 10 CONTACT (Nameanoveleohone)CW2 Arthur Ford 9 REQUIREMENT CONTROL SYMBOL 335 I5) I0 SHIPPED IIS Army nI Washingum()I11:c 0" the 32. huzlc hm I IIC 11 SHIPPED TOMAJ ?I1mmas Hurley()fI'icc of the I555 Suite Du: :1 >0;\rIInv1on 22 209 below and return copy to sender)RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED (When not .--.ma TYPED NAME: AND OF SENDERSt i'I? Aanhcr McI.umh11a IYPED NAME AND TITLE OF RECEIVERHUI Icy 110 SIGNATURE OF RECEIVER AND DATEJ?v1a444 /sM':r1eoPIE 0: serum? /o/gr//54HARD COPY PUNCHED CARDSCASSETTES(?Ix ya rz?. MICROFILM PHOTOFICHE3. NUMBER OF BOXES (Packages)14. NUMBER OF ITEMSI2 Cl)\MEI HUD OF SHIPMENTcoumen FIRST cussPARCEL POST cm: cu \1;mEXPRESS MAIL REGISTEREDSPECIAL INSTRUCTIONSOr17 ?run; USED data;Imk I Dusk 2 Did I 7)l)'xtISI -3 from HSI l)nIDusk Iulurusavmr HSC 0151? (C) J2 Dusk 22 dr 40 L4-33ll IS) Passport -Mcuunl IS) DA FORM 200. SEP 1998PREVIOUS EDITIONS ARE OBSOLETEUNCLASSIFIEDVT '41 --