'

I

IN Tl II <'() l m I ( JI· 1\ll JI 1,\ f ·J; 11\I) f\11\VI : I ii.; I 1.jI '.1\ 1.,
,1
\l)l)l.
Sl:.'SIONS .J!l!Xil :. N,,\N1· /\:,J.\ S."\1111\.

·-~·,•r"•.-

---------------------------

SFSSIONS

'1\SI · N .·102 !JI· ~00 1J.

I

~

Sl~SS IONS 1'1{11\I NU .

o,..200

1).

--..--.. ------ ..
'l '11.:St,1lt.:

Vs.

IVJS l. 1\ !i I i.1 )Jib i IV I Jc I J/ /\ :-:l ii q. { ': 1:, l c (' I1Ii s 11.111.
l{L·sidcnt lil . / 11.1,.11.ii, ( '11:1•. \Jn 1, /'.\ ."i:1d.11
I ~111ka11J

S~tf1ib.

---------------------C,,st· I· I.ft NO 32(1/200')
Unde r SL'c.~ 1J5-l', P.P ·
I'S Si!d.,r

N.111k:111:1

-------------- -----

-

----

,•

/"

S,1111/i

--

I

..;,,

·,.

.. '

.i

t:J1allancd by the

l:1vv 11·i:1I

(PW - I)

tftib lo

i11 ( ':1st'

Jiir !he :ilkg111ior1

ur lk·livc,

i111
•. dt:1, _!~:1l11ry/ubiL:L'l
io1,:1hlc
1

n.:111t1rks
lnw:irds lht: 1l ol~· Prnphct ( Jl!H 111) :11: I 11,,ly ()11r:111.
')

1::h. i>A/1 Jodgt:d h) ():11i tluli: 1111111:1d
:'-:a:,l.1111 111:11
011 J ·1.6.:00<J.

lla.: cumphin:int

or this c1sc

,ire th,11 J\J·,t .,\ ,,1,, 1311,iwi/',:

l\.fosih wl10 is :1 Chris 1i:1111:,dy :llld

the other lmfjt.:: ( PWs)

orllit:

liom !he g:1rclc11belonging

:1

(lrt\ .':liiq

C'J11
·i:,ti,111rm.:.1cltn ,d,mgwith

. i !l;1gc \\·er: i~nl,~ki.11·, hilsa

v' .

(~ ~

)

f;•·'. 1.1d
tf~j
~J~011
i \~'
(?:::;
to ·one , luh,im1
ldrc·.:~;'
o 1\li
1

@'-

~I

ttT.Jfi'Xl?:1.·r::.~-:
~~
--:·• . ,)'{ '.) ~~: :.:~}::r--.:11
,:\.::2.;::1
--rl.:r ; ..,~:·...~-, G''·:r/~::·)
-,•

: .::

:

 )

./

rcrnad(s towards Lhc l loly Pr phc t ( J>l.3UlI)
PrnpheL or Lhe , luslims
l'oh,1

:1noz [3il la (

st:1Li11gtha t the Holy

11.:11
ill on· 111\lnth prior tu hi s cle~llh nnu

-;v1
_Iv
_j_;?l~?

) ti c insect s no 1rishc I in his

1111w1l1
;1nc.lc:ii· She furlhcr : l:111.:dlh :11 lh1..:l l1>ly Prnphd
•

...1-

[VI: L. 1\.·i.1 Uibi th.:l1wn..:d the..:ckrogut )ry

1\h1rn.:cl. Th1..:said a ·cuscd

.

•

I

( Pb lJ I I)

•

111,11"J"1t:d
with I la:1.rnl l'h:1dcjn l~:11.11\ l l:1h /\nhil ( V;:.,.;tif1',1) jus t 1·nr
hc1· \ e:ilth .ind ,tlkr

by liim . She w:1s

thaL the s~n1c \\'<ts lmncd

d1:, · 1nh:d b_ !ii111
. Shi..: lunh-:1 . 1,111.:d
;1h 1ul tltL' I Inly Qur~111th:11 lh1..
·
I lol_ ()llJ'tlll

is

1101 thi;

buul· nl ' ,\ ln1q;hty

I

ll:tl1 hul ii ,s a sclltm,111

~vbl. 1\·l;ili.1 Bihi ,rnd IVlsl. Y:1!-.111cc.n

111.1dch o l·. l'vlst. A fin nihi,

l:3ibi etc. tol d al l these to the cn111pl.ii11.111L
.ind th,; ol11cr peop le

or

Lh\.:vi I !age.

·~
-'

"

L/!!
...

3.
called

the bdy act:U:j ·d

On 19.6.2009,

or LIe

by the in ha b itant s

So, the accused

i

ls1. 1\ sia Bib i was

and :1skcd about

vill;1ge

ncc 11-rcnc.:,.:
wl 1.:rcin she coiilc::,;cd her guil t
the apology.

1

·111d

s li ·

the
for

1tqL1cslctl

Isl. 1\s1a 8ib i has comm iu cc.J 1hc

I

b la:-;phcrny and has als11 cx11..:mlcd tlw d c ro1•:11ory a nd s:ll'l.:
.:1s1ic.:

I

rcm;1rks l1)w.ircls lhe I Joly 13001-.

Muhamma l Ri:1.w.111SI (JJ\V-5) h:1d rec ir dcd the
formnl fJR

l~xh.PA/ 1 without

any addition

or 0111ission

and

lhcrea ncr h

,:11·

S.

Inves ti ga ti on)

. hcil hupura

he cl

lhi!l case ,,vho

dq1 )'iCd on 0~1th that
( ln vcstig.ation

investigation

11

2~'" .lun\.', 2009, he was posted :1s SI>

Shcikhupura.

dalccJ 26.6 .2009

St, the 10

issued

On llic

s : 1111l· d:1y.

v id c !t:ILcr No. I 8S2J

by DIC/ 1~1'0 R,111gc . Shci\...hupur:1. Lhc.:

orthi s c;:isc \·vas c11Lrusted lo

hi111as the olfo.:c

or·SP

...

(lnvcstig:1tio11). N:111ka
11,1 S:il11u w:1:; v:1c:111l. 011 29.Ci.200(), he
su111111011ctl
holll the pal'li1.:s ;1L his nlfo.:12.27 people

l'rom the

cu111pl.1innnl party and S persons 1'10111the .1 ·.;use I p:1rty :1ppcared
!~.".
:<·

r

l

!'l!\ \ /

\:!·)'
;

-i1~ \i

l.i

I '

~1 w

\ .I

I'..:,.L

j.

:. I--:··~.
. .:,l·~
/i}lv,
.\...·~·.. ,.,
·~i....~·,·"t?"~·: .
1.,

,I

(I'"~

t ..t..

.

•~~::.::: :~\ ~~~) ·~~:--:~:~<::;~1E~
\:.~ .~,~

 -,
\

I

.•i

hcforc..:him. Fiv · pt:rs ns !rom thi.: ..:,11npbinant silk n:cunkd

st:1Lc111c
11s u/s 161 Cr.P.C. before him.
thoroughly.

i..:ourt l~xh .PB, hc recorded

the stall'llll'Jll

l~ibi in the .Jt•il on 0~.7-~009.
Uj)l)ll

hin, lhnl

1n

I le i11vc..::;
l16 a!c d the c.:,
1sc

!ht.: pc1m is ·i

After obtaining

Durin'

lh1.: l\ d sa ( ~(;,)

their

)11

1·rom the

or lhc

:onccrned

m:cuscd Msl. /\s i a

his i nves1 i v.;1Lini1, il 1·cv ·,ilcd
li1.:ltl o,\ 11·ti by Muh:11nrnud

ldrecs. lh~ ladies ol' tht: vill:1gc 111cl11tl111t~1lw ;1-:l·11scd:111dth\.' l 'W :-;

-vcn: p1c.sc.1t thcrc vho st<1rtcd to d iscus:, propl1c:t.sand n:ligiou s etc.
'I he ac:u1s ·d

·u dcrn!.!,atory

Isl. /\sia Bibi \,vlio i.s :, Chris1ia11deliver

n:m.1rks bcf" re Lhc o her bdics \\lm:h contl~ under lli ddinitio11 of'

The owner or 1hc said field

blasphemy.

~1:1tc111c1llu/s

iwmc ly Jdrecs ( whose

Cr.J>.C. scp:.11·:11cly rccordi.;d

I(> l

hy

) :il:m

him

allr:11.:tcd Lnw~mls th' sai I ladi1..':--.bcl'n1c 111111,
Ll1c J>vV
s ( l:.1dit:s )
narr:Jtctl th1..111,lllcr, who i11qu1rcclfrom lhc :tcl:uscd JV!sl. /\si,, 13ibi

,1bou1 lwr narr:1 ion uron

wi11d1 sh·

lh ..1L she hud

·0 11lc:;scd

tkl i vc1cd !ht.: dcrng ..Lory rem.irks, however . .she bc:_i,gcd p:mlon.

Arter his invc.:s1ga1i n uncl prnb\., hL· dcchrcd

/\si.1 l-3ibi

,1s l:;llilly

Lile :1ccu:-.cd Mst.

ol' bl.ispl11.:111y
011 O(J.7.2009 ..iml ullcring Lhc.:

dcrngnt,>ry rc111;1rks:1bo11ltht.: l l,11~
· l'rPpl1ct ( J>IHJJI) a11d lilt.: I loly
wlcdgc 1h:1l

p1·inr In his

clc,Hh and

I

tk!ivc11.:d/crc,1tcd in his llll>t:Lliand c:1r. I he accused

!'urlh cr s1.11cd

thal I l:1:1.rnll'v uhn111111:
1d l l' IHJ I I J 1 ,1111
r:H.:Lcd111:,rriagc \vi h I l:111"1l

Khadcja R:.11.i/\llc.lh J\nha 111 111d1.:r tn lool and accurnulalc
wealth "nd aflcr
Rtv.i

1\llah

looling

/\nha.

her

the :-;;1111c.
he disG1rdcd I l:izr:11 l'h:iclcj a

Th1.: ;1ccw,cd

1·u1lht: r

slated

th·1L l lazr:1L

d l'!Hll I) w.1:, 111IIH· li.d,11 ,ii lll..:IL. I lit: ;1c.i.;
u:,1.:tl lu1 lhi.;r
1lul1:1111111.

to ld Lh:ll the I le ly

uran is 1111 a divilll.' bouk l>uL it i:, lll:lll

!,.. J \/

,·

\~, !·11....., '·.

111;10 '.

I.

l ..

(~L

,1::r:-~
·=·:.::,-~r.
:j :',
,-;:-...,_~':T~·;~
~·~ ·:: .
;.2.~~j~:O~~.:
"'
J

."?'~.. •
.. ::- ...
,...:.:\

:..~;a•:~~

 \

I
tow,1rd~ lhc Holy

ljrophcL ( P13UlI) ,ind l loly Our,111. 11,ilso came

inLo his knowledge

th:1t du ring lhc inv1.::-;t1g;1t1011,
the accusu.l Ms!.

1\ sia 131bi look thl: st.1ncc that the: 11\Vi,had kvdcd

against her ~s lhcy tried In
:ilkgalion

the ,ilh.:g,1Li 11

her l\'ltl:di111:11alllll ln.:rl l'.l\1:;al, ll c

111:1~c

w,ts 111tde bul the same sl.111ccL,tl en by the ;1c used Msl.

1\si:1 nihi w:1s 111)(pnl\'t'd.

th;1t the rclq;ious

l·urthn 111111l·,
1t r.1111c111tn111:;knmvkdgc
w.,s s1:1rkd wlwn

discussini

1li

•

01· Ille I W

fl\,lu-.;lirn J:idy ) itskcd !'rn· tl!c w·1t1.:1:111din 1cspo11sc, 1hc .1cc11:-;cd
l\lsi. 1\si;1 nibi

\l 1 :1s

p1 '!,1..'lll<..:d1'11:w:1lt.:I',

lht.:

s:1itl

11 \\'

n.:lusi.:cl I

h:1, t•/d1inl· ii f"rom the h:111dnl a< ' hn :-.1i.11, l:1d, .
the in , ·s11g:1tirn :111J clcclc1ri11gthe

/\rtcr' conducting

.iccusccl

llst. Asic Bibi ~1:g 1ilty, he srnl b.tck the lilc or this

the SH

PS concerned.

>.

l'vluh:1111111:1d
.\rsl,,1d

Sl-1 J had

,ilsu

Cl1t1du

C,ISC

Lo

·1cd lhc

he was poslcc.l <tl I'S .'ad:1r N;rnk.11;1 "i;il1ib. Thi; l'vll IC' ol lhc PS

rl ace :m I h

rccnrckc.l Lhc slntcmcnls

oi' the P \ ':; 1111,kr:,l'<.ll\111

I(, i ( '1.P . ·. :inti

prepare I rough sil1.: pl.. 11L:-:h l'C. l·lc :me.sled the :H.:i.:uscd wi1h the

h · Ip or Lwo l:.1dy constables

who wrn:

in hi:-; :1cc0111p;.111y.
I le

presented Lhc :1ccusccl 1wi-su11 hl·l°,11l· lltl· .ludi..:i:tl

th1.:11scn l h~r lo judici:d I Kkup.

for the.: 111cdiculcxamin.ition
ln be 111c..:dic:1lly
examined

l\l.1gi::tr:1t

·

.111d

I k :1bu :-.ullll1iuc..:I ;111:1pplicL1tiun

ol lhl' :1c·used wlm ( accus~d)

rcruscc.l

Thl· :1pplk.il1lrn is 1·, h 1'1). 1\ lkr Lhul,
~:.;"""')"';'
-·- -r.,.",}
·,9!i!:1
r• •,. 1:~ •.(;
' ",......J,.,
u
!..~ G
..;1 1•

-~···' ·,---·..(.._...Jt.
/J~....
~- .··-·---,
,•. "' . .
-.
~ ~r::~·~
..~~ ..~1 r;:·.··--:·:
~:~,_'.;
,}·::.~:t
i .·~
,'\

t,

... . , .( .•

~ •. • l. • ,: , ... ~;{. ~ #:. ·-··

r..::-~.:,~
~-:
J C:.;.:'v.-S-:.,

 ,,
-!5
c ·-.

l lll\ 'l'S li~:tli 111) Sh.:il·lnqrnr;i

7
;1g;1111st
the

\

dcc11s1.: I 011

13.10.20()'), l'or which he plc:1ded

.ind d ·111amk I her trial when: :Iller 111Sltppo1 lo!' its

,u j lly

110L

f'ullowing

c:1sc,

wit,wsscs were produced by the proscc ut i,)n.
PW- I Oari 1\tl11ha111111::id
S:1.ila111is the cornr lai na 11t
th is

or

Ci\5l'.

P_W-2iV1.l. :\!,ilia l~i bi is

: 111 c_'l'

,.\flncss ol"this t: .1sc.

i: .. d:,11 :111cy ·

I'\\!- If\ l:,l.1\:.~1Jlili!

ol lli1s

\·\-llllt::,:;

c:1.sc.
l'W-..J Mu lrnmmacl

conks.

i

>11 111;1dchy

luhamm:1d

.J

l'ormal I IR

r.""-

1\1'1.:1 I

n['

thc

i:; the v. i l ncs:-. o 1·c~ tr.1 .iud ici :ii

1!1l':11..·cusc<lb ·!'me li1111.
Pi,.w:l!.}_SI h~,clcll;1\kcd out the

i11:-.l:1nt

·L1-;c.

F,ivcn up being u1H1l'c ·ss:1ry by th...:k:11'!1<..:t.l
.'\l )P li for th..: St:it..: .111cl

:dkr

th:ll the lc.1r11cd ClH111scl l0r Lhc co1npl:1inu 11l h~1ul:loscd

prnscl't 1t 1on l'

9.

1 lcncdcasc

thl'

.

In her sla lcmcnt recorded

under

]l l :! Cr.P.C,

section

thl.'.v1.:r:,io11
ol the ucc.:ust:d w·1s as 1111de1:-

" I nm m~ 1-ricd \\ 0111~1
11 h,wi1 ,g lwo d;1ughtcrs.
husband is

Lhc planls

,1

l\r\y

poor labourer . I u~:cd Ln plul.'.k 1:~ds:1 i'rom

orKlu h:11111n:1d
ldr ~c:: .tl o11gwi1 ll
1

.... ,,.._-

or

11u111bcr

_,

•? "'

(t')

<,'.) 'J

·ry

fi\

f•

\,\ I

1,:J < \,

l'

"\\'.•L

!,,J

-~

-~----..r<i(v·~.....''

\°,~ · ~·..~,,.. ,,,,.,;,it-II\,..•,,',,..,'
•

.,,

•

"'_.,~~\ ,_'·,:~

,

...

,t,.

..

-#

, -

•••

s 4. , ... '\

•

•

 /0

v _

t;o r
., ......

l~il i and

Isl./ \ . 111;1
l !ihi

ove r ktching

l'Ws qt1:1r n.:kd wiLh 111•

w·1tc1 w l11ch was o!kre d h_, 1111..:
Ln hnng

I'm ihL·ni h111ilil:y ll'l°11.'ccl,.1y1n r th;1t 'ii
1,

t tt'l'

I :1111

1 the hand o l'
'hristic111,. n, the) never lot1I w,th:r J'ro11
'h1 isti,111.Over thi:--.q11,111\:Iw:1:; i11
su1.:d and

~0 1111.: !tot

lO\ 'a rcls \ ere c-..:cJ1.111gcd
heL\\CCllll l_'Sc ) r ,lllll titc

P \Vs ladies The!'\\:

then :1ppnwche d

S,1ala111

0,111

co m pla inant through h;:-; \ •iii.:who remai ned tc:1chin

I

the both lad ies. 1lcn c, the l' Ws \.Vere com,pi ring w it h
( ,1ri '.1nl:i111got a l:ilsc. l;il ri.::llcd, :111dlic t it i us

111:
,1a1h lo

'asc :111:1i11sl
111L'.I nlTnccl

police on

131bk thal I h:1d never p:1. scd suc!t dc:rog: 1lnr_1 .t11d
shumcl'ul

n;ma r ks

I !o ly Prnphc t ( Pl3UI I)

;i • ..1111.sllite

;ind the I loly Ou1-.u, I ha

gn ..;:11respect and honou r

l'

to the J loly Prop het ( 1'11 JI I) :1•: we ll as I lo ly Qt 1r:1n
and si nce police h:icl co11:,1ired

it1ll'rl'.'lcd

JlLTSl)ll

lt:,11...hi11gI lul)
;11~

wit h the i.;0111
1 ln in: 1nt.

,11Hlliuth !he l:1dit:s r •111:1i1
1c d

()ur:111 l1n111li 1s w i ll:

Jiv r11µin tl ,is vrl lag~

S i ll

·c

c 1e;i l1

My l'orcl':ilhc r:,
11o !"l' :1k i s t an. I

:1111:11:,il:1h,111l Ill yc.11· · ,ild .iml s 111t.:cth e :ti k g~d
OtTllrrcni.:l·.

ag; 1im,l

tlil'

1111crnnp
J

am

l:11111
1,k '\\ iM· th is 111.·vcr ,.:x isl

ll ll Ctltll'..lll.'l

i

ltld

110 p ri L" ' (

urtile

t '111
isti:111. .\11much •;ti, lliL·1 · i rm t:hurd1

r'· .,~ . ~.

1 -~

or

1

'r'- t1 lf

r,

~·
'- ~

' 'J

Q_v___
..
. ,,· ,,
•

o

:·

'
\

~

- ~-L ....

!

;

 I "l. 1111
1L· I I 1111r· •.I 11,Ii II v l' .111I 11:, 1.·

·,

11L I 1 1. I 111
11:;y

tk-r11~•;11ury
n.:111:11
k:,; .1f:1i11:,1lliL· hcl1l\vd
( PIHJl I ol, \llal1 and tht.: I )r-. 1111.:Uoo!

Qur:in. PVv' lc.Jrccs i~;:ils,

. 111
d

Jl1opl1l'I
1loly

VI/

,1 111tcrcslcd witnc•:s

who

lw.·

close fr1n1i/y links with Lheir ~tbovt: s.iicl l:1dies".

I ().

either Lht: :1ccuscd opted 10 pn duce dcli..·11c1.:
cvi kn -c
1101lo appeur umh..:r section 3...JO
(2) Cr.I'.(.
I l.
The lc::1rncd counsel lc1r Liie..·l'u 111
plc1i 11;111[;ugucd I l iu t
1

the 1:,dy ac<.;usccl J\Js1. 1\:;i:1 nihi h:1s l 1111111iL1cd
1/11,,·
hl:1splirn y ·111

olfr11c · uh; ~')5-C, PP(' ;111dii;1s Llll•·rcd du n1::11oryrc111:11
/ :- l1,w: 11ds
1l1v l /1ily lhitil ,111d /i;,s cu111111illl..:d
1i1l'.11/lc11cc u/s 29:i-U. Pl'(·. 1k:

,,

l'11rtiil'.r:1rgllL'd th: 11lhi.: prP.'l'L'tlli1111 h:1:,p10,Td it·, ·.i:..c h1·yn11dtlu:
n.:.1so11:1hk doubt with ll1<.:
hl'lJl o/ cyl' \\ 1111c:·st:s,hl'linc wlinn1, the

.'

'
•.:'

:1cc1.1scd 1.idv tillered

dcrogntory

;ind

s: 1rc..·:
1stic

·cn1;11k:; wl111l;

.I

phr<..:killf the 1:;ils:1 111 thi.; bi.':1 Ci:1rdc..·11.
I le further prc:,cicd 111to
service

lhal lhc matter ,vas invi;sti[,:llcd

b)/ 'P ( lnvc :,;tig:11ini1 )

Shc ikh upm.i who :tiler thoruugl1 invc:,ti~.itin11 :ind p11ihc dcl'l:rn ..:d

ht., si~1Bil I accu. eel ~is guilty. Thu~. the P\.V-(, lus
vcrsior o/' f)rosecu
wrthm 1L nny
unnnirnous

cc111r11IL'd the

dou

in Lime,
I:;

corllr.rdio11s in bc tw ccr
;1sst:r11bly was b:1ptizL·d
w.is c;:1/lcd

111

;ind .'ihc :1lso

pa rd on. I le :llso opined

the.: vill:r~,L· wlrL-rL·i11 lhL: :1ccu:,L'd prr~;1111
co11ks.-;L'd

the .·:1nic vi 1!.1.1,L" :don/.:' with
incident

or suc h

lier

llrnt there :11·cSP

1

singll:

Mu:;1111 1;;

t',11if1

:1ud

f"L"l)l11:1:1i: I 101

'.hr i."li:111
:. !1•:111;.•

n1:11 1)

:.iri,·~· !:'L'IH.:r:1111111
hul

rr1

101 :1

natu re look pl:11.:cin the p:1st l1011i Ilic.:

1rntio11s i.e. Chris t i:1ns :111d f'vlwili111o.;
.rn·
rcl1girnrs kelings

110

111

:i nd . fo1l h Pl . t::1ch u1l1n.

111!cr:11H·clm•,:11d:; ihc

l l;1d :111, i11c1dc..·r11
111"

hl;1•,plwr11y I 1..·c,1lr:1ppc11cd or 11ccun1..·d 1111111..·p:isl,
,.,,·

•

J

~

lhc1c "liould
\.

C":
\

I'

....:.

t·'\
tJ •\. •

·~:~:l <1

(rJ,t
-. .

.'

\.. l;,
M'Ot ,,'l

 n
havL: been cri111i11;1]
cases or rc li~1ous altcrG1tion 111the vi11~1gcare
iiv111r

it)

:1

n.;ligious

with

S:1111<.:
village

;t

lJllilc

l ff ..:spc 'liVC nf' thei r

lltll'lllOllY

of J'uiths .rnc.Jemotions.

di ffcrcnccs

IL was a unique ~,nd

l,1cly

1midc11 1r11..:idcmin lhc history or the vii Inge t hat :1 Christian
did the offcn<.:i.: or blas1 hcmv. sn. tlH.:1l', 1:1s no rh:ec.l on tl1c

r,ul or"

con pl.1i11;1111
,tn d the P\:\/s lo 1-c11ortthe m:1llcr Lo lhc po l ice. They

,hould h:1d n0l 11:;kncd Ilic s:11m·.

I It.:1'1
1rllH:r l.'..'il;!hlishc I 1!1:11r1dl

is no any pn;v1ou:,

vigllr

tlt:ll there

1..:01111

l;1in:111L. P\\'s

·ind or th.

enmity

i11

hcLWL'(l

t

lhc.:

r,111il: or J;1dy (H..:<.:uscd which

11H
licnli..:s Lh:1t then: is no nnlalidc

rn· ultcl'lur 1110Livc rn the pa1 l

Ilic l·nmpl:iin:1111:ind PWs !11,,•;1rds tliL· hdy
sl,ltcs that nothing has been produced

or

,1<.:n1:-;cd. I le li.1rlht.:r

by the be.I, accused in his

dt:l't:nc,: which aJ.-o rnrtili ·d th-: l.!.llill nl' lht.: :1t.:cusr.:d. f ft: su111111
cd
ur his s1;1ncc ancr suhmitling
'

:111·

lhal hoth the P\Vs i.e. PW-2 and fJW-

1111111:u
I wd ;incl :11.1JP1 1•i1 I: :11HI 11,· :11: ii tile P:ird:1 1 !:1.shc.:e11

~,:

hox \\hik

). They slwu ld 1wL hcc11 p11t Lhc111selvcs in the witncs .·

c 1111i
11t' i11 lliL· cnurl l\'.:1,·IK·r~. ii" the i11cidc11l h;id no l

hci.:11 ot·c111Ted rn be th the I'\\/:,; 1.1tf not l1stcnctl

tile sarc;1stic

r ·111:1rk-;
or blasphemy Su, !h<.:k:1r1wd L·oun:;cl rn1ph;1~i1.cd th:1L 11lc

h·d1·1.il { ;ov ·1111m·111pririr lo tlil' l'L')',1::!1.,111i1101· tli1:, L,1:;c :111d Ilic
. :11m:li:,s 11111been nbt;1im:d bcl'nrl'
1

l, · :1; il,1li..:d rn1 the

scnr·

th: 1l 1hl

10

the lndt~ing ol' Lile 1:iy., sccn 11c.ll
y

orllit.:r:111kol"SI'

can invc~.lig:tlc

1!1c ·:1:--1.:l,f'hl.i:;pliL'.111_)'
liul lllily 1\:--l li:1:: i11vc:--Li~·:1Lcdlilt.: case. Th ,11

:111the P\V:-; :m: int erested

,vilncsscs

' I l1cy ha c 11c1L
wit11csscd or

11:-.l·11t.:cltile hL1sphc 111
y . 130 Ii the.:gi r ls :111d the curnplain,rnl llimscll'
:111..:
Iii· interes ted witnesses.
tonk ph.:c on 14.6.~0 9

I le l'urLhLT. t:1tcd lhal nn nllcrc:nion

;11lli<.: f-als:1 Ci;11clo.:n
in

bctwcrn

Lhc P\.Vs

,:. ..... • ., zI.);:•\..:.• 1·0:
"-•.1,

t-·.i...)

\i

......,,.-' .

,-

. ..
I

•,•

t:

~-

 :111d tht· l:1dy ;1ccuscd u11 fi.:1cl1i11t1 1l1l· ,,.1 11.T.111d ii 1:, pc1Li1w111 tn
t1H.:11tio11
here lh:1l th1; f\lusli111 l:idic:; 1·L·/w1.·dlt1 tl1111k water at the

hi111tl

nr !ml

acrnscJ

is :1 C'11 is1i.111 :111d just lo s,1Lisly the

"ho

gnrdgc and just to teach the lesson to the l hristii\11 l:1d_,. l'\V s ,me!
the cn111pl:1in,1nt has concocted

the :~111r
y

bf: 1sphc111_v
just

l) r

10

hook

th e 1.idy :tcc11sed in :1 c1i111111:tl
c:1sc :inti tu gL·t h:r pu11i.-h1.:d u11Lkr a
111.::l\)' \\'l'ighl

cfl.1q,!,1;. l:v c11 tHhcr\\'isc,

and no derogatory
from the mouth

11(1

oc ·u ri c ncc took pl:1cc

rcmn rks nnd s;1rcastii.: rcm:.irl·s ha vc be

uttered

'11

f the :::iccused toward s the J-loly pronhct <llld ho ly

f3ool ·. I le l'urth1.;r st n..:sscd that tlii.· 1:; :1 J;1nci Jul dr~1111c
1 against the

Christi:111 m1no11l) s1:11_t,L·d
by th.:
h:1s bcc 11pl:111tcd a a nuci:il

i\lll:,li111 1\b j t11ity :111dlh\.: dr:1111:1

li111cwhen

:-.t) 111a11y

sul'11 like 1ncidc11ts

l1:1vc IK·c11 fi:1ppL·111
..:d 111u111 b1.:lnvL·d 1.·1n111l1) nf':· ucli 11,llmc .

I k f'urlhL·1 p1L'.-!-l'd 111ln st

1•

in:

th.it lht.·1-c i:;

;1

s h<.:cr

L:ontr:id1 ctio11 in bc;t\ 'ec.:11lhi.: s L;111.:1n<.:111
: ul' ;ill 1lw l'Ws 0 11 Lile sco ,·c

or11umbcr of

lhc people ga thered

111 th·

public g::ilhcring

l:1dy ,1ccuscd was ulso surn1 11011cd it11d "line

• lr,1 .111dici,ll 1.:1nrcs s io 11. P\V - 1

she made

11:11r:1t ·d th e

where the

so ca lled

m1111
bcr 111'pcnpk

g.illicrcd there as IOOi- ,•:hill! l'\V- :2 op 111cd IL ,ls 1000/- :u1d PW-J
11:isill' ·L irt.·d II :1s ~O(Hl/
Luo!

pl:1.'

Oil

ti ·l1j1n:1tinn. ·1he I ·:1rncd ddi.' 11t. • c,H111·,1·I c l1'.,nl h1:; ;1q•t1;1w111shy
sl:i li11~ lh:11 Llic.:p1osi.:cut11,11misL·1al il_ f.11' Ltl st :111don it s )\\111legs

;111
d to prnvc

tlte gu ilt u l LhL· I.HI) ,1cl·11. cd

con fidc11cc.:in. piring cvidcn

'l',

hence, ;1s lhc

w11i1 lllls lwkc,tblc
rL·

is nu p1cvious

.i11d

rccmd

of"s 11d1 c;1scs 0 11 lhc p·,,1 0 1· the :1cc11·;ccl, siil' IL' :1n r111l ll'd r1 )Ill

1

lh1;

t: I 1:1ri ,l.:.
1

F: !·'.
•.
'1
&..,I

I:::- ;....
~
·--........ . ; '
...\

i .

...

(i.~!·;·

~.\ .~,·~,,.
•l
,,

 •..,·.,..,.-

I;
c1H111-.;d
l"nrboth lhc p:1rt1cs :111<1
h:lh' :11...o pcn,sed !he t'l'co,d .

Lc;.1Jncd th:lencc.: t: 1•111si..:I
.,.,hik

L1rgu i11g r.ii_·ccJ tow

111:1,ior
nbjcctions .

Thn the invc: , tir :1lio11w:1s 1H1lC\111luctcd by an);·

I)

'P rank Orticcr

only

II J

.1 'ub-!11 . j)lTl,11

'1''1:11

1111

l'l'

;111d

·1111·.::11111

Prnvinr.:ial r Crntr:il

:,l'

\\ , 1:,

·kcd

JOV Tn111cn1

rcg.1st1,1Lio11or tile i11:,1:111l
case

15.
w,1;

by

buL w:1s 1;1Lhc1 concluctcd

t,y

till'

prior ro Lhc

which

wns

'o for as Lhc lirsl objection is Clmt.:cl'llcd. t he c..:,1sc
f.t<..lu,dly invc::;tigatcd by Mr. J foh:1111111:,d
1\111i11
Uukh:1ri. SP (

l11vcsl1g,1lio11) SltcikhupurL 1. l le \\'hik ,11111L:1ringin li1l· wi1111..::;sbox

a: P

-(>

sl.1Lcd th:1t the 111vcs1ig:1lio11nl' Ilic c1sc 11;1:;cntruslcd

ltim vitk

10

I ·Ltt:r No.18523 d:1tcd ~(>.<>.209 i~sucd hy DJG/1\PO

Shcil·hupL11.i and he i11vt:slig:ilcd Lht: c:1::-: ll1 llougl!ly :111d1..:c..:01d..:d
tht: slalc111c11Ls
under

section

I (JI Cr.P.l '.

So, lht:1l· 1s 111 rurt:c.: in

1h1s ohjL-c1io11 :111d

Ilic.: very bc.:ginnin

•• 1I11.:

k,11netl counsd did

, hire 11)1111
.
I (1.

I :v

11

Olhc.:n isc.:, lhi..:L:llll'I !1.111ccl l Si:cl1
1

is lo be given in case of

~in

)11

196 Cr.11.C .

offence.: u/s '.295-1\, PPC but SC\..Lion295-

C, l'PC wns not r>rcscnt therein, so, lo n.:,1clsection 295- • ·1sp.,n o J'
scc.:
1i >n I ()6 Cr.I' .(.
kgi:,;l.11 ion. \Visdom

w1 uld

amount

or lcgisl.1Lu1c

111

i11lcrJ'1..:rcIll

i 11 1hls 1\:gard

S(

iri t of

co ul d IH>L I c.:

ch.ilkng.c I.
17.

fJms~1.:u ion rroc.luccd botlt the 1:idici; vl1t :ire Ll1' eye.:

- ...-••

' '

-- ·~·,

.

'

! ,.· .. ,,._

. :.'J

 ,.

., ,,..

n.:111.1rk.
I ( l~l:1:,1111:111)) 1\1..·11.:111.1ddu1t,.:a:d. l'W-]

and J>\V.J, I\IJst.

1

l'vlitli.i l3ibi and r--1:,l 1\~111aI ihi wiiik ;1p1c;1ri11gi,1 the wrlnc~s box

narrntcd ~11Lhcy lisLcrn.:d. PW-2 i'.Jst.

'J:1li:1131bi has clc;p scd on

o:11h that on 14.6.2009 Suncl:1y, she ·:Jong with I l:.;L.Asma IJibi,

field

orhilsa

h) 1c:ligi1111.

in the vil l;1gc. The ;1ccusc:d Is. /\si: 1 Bibi is Ch rislian
1"11c :tl'CllM.:d

·J:-;t. 1\s1:1 l31!i1 1 rcscnl

<.:ou
n ·tatecl

111 the

beli>rc him :incJ others llwt l l,1zr:1l I •luh:1111111:id
(PU Ul 1) I'd! 111o,
lhc bed une 1110111hpr ior tn li,·. dc:1111:111d

llill;1h (

N:1tHl/,

).

the i11scc1s were dcvc/opctl,c1 c.1h:d in !1i:-.111uutli :md c::1r. Th(;
;11..·cusctll'urth1:r st:1lctl 111.11f l:11ral ,\folt :11
rnnad (l'13U J [) cnnl rnclcd

111:11Ti:11'c
\\ ith f-lnra Kh.iclcj:1 R~1/i1\Jlah Anlia just in order lo fool
her wr:lith :111dat'lcr I ot111g lhe :nmc. the I loly PropJ1ct cliscarclecJ
J h1z1al

I 'Jrnck~j,1Ra;,j /\ll:1h /\n h:1. .Slw i'urlhcr lo/d that lhc Holy

Our.in 1:· not

:1

divi11l' ho /.; but it has bcl'n wrilLcn/co111pilcd by you,

i\luslim s. ' ! lie PW 11,tn.iLc:cl:t!J lhic; Ill l)Jn

If~

\1a J:1111.Mu h~1m111uci

1

/'<J..

l/,il ;111d1 1til lit:1r /\h1111..·d
L'lc. wl n t':111·d :1 public i~:1Lh1.·1
i11gin tht.:
vill:1l'c \\·lier' lhc: :1cLw,cd /Vlst. 1

~1.1

ll1h1 w.i:, aJ.,o brouw.ht :111dshe

1.·111ilt.·!,
Td lier P11ilt in 1l1c pllhlr1. r:11/w1111g :111d:,;lie :lisn n.:qucslcd
the p:1rdn11
J>V-J

,lC(.;USC.:cl
l'vl~,l. /\si:1 f3ibi

p lt1c.:k
i11' lhe J<'alsa.·1ht.: accus1..:cfMsl. 1\si:1 P ibi i;j Christ ian

r1..:
li1~io11.I urin g the plucking

nr Fak1,

y

the :1ccuscd Mst. !\sia IJibi

n:11r:1tt:d bclc>rc her and olhers th.it J l:v.r:1LI\ l ul1:1111nwd
( 1'13UJ I) lcl/

ill on lilt bed ont mouth prior lo his dc:ith ,llld the insects were
h:111.·h-:d lrnlll his mouth and c..ir. She lunl 1cr 1.kclarcd lh i! l I l:t%ral
Muhammad

I

c1,.1

s,1111e,

{Pl

H) conlructcd the in:1n i:1gc wilfi l l.t%rat Khadej:i

/\ll<1h 1\nha in orde r lo loo t her wc,tlth um! nfkr fooling lhc
.:h' has cliscardcc.J by the l loly Prui l:c:l (PB UI I). Sile f't1rlh1.:r

.(i]

. .....

-

~

·, ·.,}

:~ ••· :.

-.:·":

..

~

~••

J,. ...

-~

... J~Y

.·,:::·J·;;

 mcnliom:d

that the I lu ly
b Hk

()ur:111

i:; l\cll

'he .ilo11~', ·ith

.i

di\ 111· ~,nd I lul) !Jouk but iL

is

111;111 m;idc

Lhcr P\Vs 111formccl the nrnltcr

lo

()'1ri S:1:ib111. the co111pl:1i11:1111.luh·111111wd1\ f/ ..JI ·111dMukhtar

w,.:rc .ilsn prc:-icm there . l'hcy man~1gcd a public gathering

in Lhc

vil!:,gc when: lhc ~1ccl1scd [\ JsL. 1\s1.1 l~il i , w:,s :1lso l>1ougl11 :ind slh.:
conlcsscd

her guilL Lhcn: and she ulsn n:qucsLccl r·or the pardon. Tin.:

:t.ill:mcnl

or PW

\ :1s recorded

h ·1'1rT 1l1e 10 rntk:r section

I<>I

r.

I le.:di I

C'r.P.
PW- I <bri S:1:d:1111i:-.the complain.111L himscl

' l).

nol

actually

listen the derogatory

1c11wrl-s di rcclly but through

Lhc.:

PW -2 .ind PW-J, so the status ol"hi~ lc:-:timony is or" Hearsay"

I W-4 is Muhrn11mad 1\l>:il s n

t

.

I' 11uham111·1I Tu rail.

I l • ,s lhl.! l'W (lf cxtr: r Judicial conlc:-;:,i (111
. I le sL:11ctl i11witnc:,s hox
tlrnt he \\'ilS \.ery mui..:h p, cscnl 111Iii· p11hic g:llhl.!1 ing held
1111
..:1dc11l

wl1c1l'.111lhl'. acL·11.·cd I:

1

1\•,1:1 11ibi

.i

rt r

h1m11:,l1l illld

w:1s

the
sl11.:

l·nnk:,:l·d her gui ll :111tl1cq1tl'Sll'd l"nr !he J :mlon.
~I.

CW- I w.1s an 1111ponant \\ itncss n~1111clyMuha111111.1d

Jdrl.'.csso n or! l~1ji/\hmcd Din. tht: 1wn1.:1 of the F:ilsa Garden while

:1ppl·:1ri11gin lilt: , ilncss-l o .. he cst:1hlishcd

a: on 1,.1.6.2009. he

was present ii

!Jibt, tvlsl.

v~1sn1ccn l1ib1

lllt:d t.:Ul llC

to

him

1111<.Imural

·01111ct.:Lio11

wilh

lhc tlo.:rog,1loryand
lltl· I lllly l'rnplicl

( 11 1\lll IJ .111dI l1ily l,lur;111 11lil·tnl hy llll· prcscnl

:1cl'.11:;cdIVlst. /\sia

in the housc
puhlir

l3ibi

or Mukhl,1

)n I 'J.(1.'.:00<),:1 puhltc g:1tli

·1 irig

was held

1 1\11111cd;111dlit: was :ilsu pn:st:11l in the

•allil.'.ri11g. Tht: :1t:l'11.·l·dfvl:;t

1

Chrislia11,

\::i.1 I !ih1 whu w:1.· :,

w:ts bnH1f1 h1 there vvho conl"cs:,cd her guilt bcli re him as" she hus
1.·01111111llcdthe blasphemy

:ind has delivered

lhe improper

and

dnol_'.:1loryrrn1;11'ks:1hl1t1l lhl· l lol_\ ()ur: 111. lc.:l lier 11ard on • . I lis
s1:1Lc1m·111
, :1s ,ds(l

rL·t:mlktl hcl"nrc tile 10.

·-. '.

• .....

•j

l

•

-

.

(

.•.
..·.

 . ,)1

- Lt7I It l'mph:1s1/l'd th:il
before

him

i111111·di:1tcly

1

I

1st ,\·,i.i 11ihi co ,rcssnl her guilt

\

L.

..I

,,··,.,.

the dcrngatory rem.irks

:tfler her dd1w1111g

lll\v;1rds the I Joly l'r phL:t ( J>I lJ I I) :111dthe I Joly l3uuk, .is whL:11
tile l>Cl.lllTCIILe

l(H k pl~lt:l',

he lC'Vl-1)

w:1:; Llit.:\, 'I'}' fir :,l ( 111:il• )

the lJ' 11cr uf Lh1: licit! who i1111ncdiatcly allr:1ctcd

pcr:;011 being

Iowan.ls th1: wr::ingling Jud1cs us he w~1s prc:;c nt there in his Ciclc.1.
23 .

I !i s presence there nt Lhc pl:1cc

11.1lural. The

owners usu:tl ly remain

Olli'

:it th\.:

socicl_r ;111(1f)ill'licul:11 ly hl' 0\\'11 'J;i

Cl!'

or occ11rrc11cc is qui te

pl:1cc 1,rtheir tusincs · in
lite inlll

f',,IJ'(.k Jl!s

in \)l'dCr

lll 11:1\L' n vi!.',il,1111 watch upon the ir l:1h1>1
11 :111
d m onk:r lo avoid

:iny

Ll,t:1'1
on the h:111dof'thc l:1hourrrs :llld I :1rtind:1rly when l:1lly lnll · is
\ lll

\\'ork . I le h:1s :ilsn 1111l'n111i1, with

l;1dy l:tlH1111( :JL't 11sctl ) :111d

:he is doing th job under lrn; C111ploy

111L'1ll

since a long. I le :1lso

banished lhe accu ·cc.Irrom h1:; Fuls:1 fidd upon h<..:1
conl.css ion ,111d
till'

s:1111t:w:1s also quill' n:11u1:d rc:;1 011:sc on hi:, p:11l. 'o . h1:

lcslinm11)

is q11il1: trustworthy

hy lhL' dclcncc; during

"1,J

,111d11:1L11r:il.
1 (' dL·11lw;1s also crc:11l'd

lhl' crnss-c.-,;:1111i11,11iu11.

So , I'\. '-::'. :ind

JJ V

ll1L' .:y,: \\'it11c:,scs :ire quite

i.

u11:111i111
n1s .iboul lhl' clnug.1ll1ry rc 111
:11k· ,111d:1bnul Lill' time, d;llc.
Ii ·Id,

l;1y l>I'

i111prnv~'llll't1l in ll ·

110[

I illl l'

is 110 any rrcvious

l:1clic:-)

cn n

;111dlite lady accu ·ed. There 1s ,ilso n :111yc11111
ily 111between the
J>\V-1, l'\.V-,1, CW- I a11d Lhc :1ccusc:d l:1dy due tu whif..'h they

dcposL·d 1g:1insl 'her ur ~1g:1i1u :111· other 111:ilc111c111bi.:r
,Jf' the
ilCl:llS

25

·d l.idy.
W-'2 nnd PW -]

:11
·c

1.",irls wli , :ire :il:-.o

1!1c young

t111111;11
1icd Tit ·ir prcsc11~·L·in Ilic l·\d::;1 li1·ld ,il0111c~
w1tl1 the ilt:L'11scd
l:1dy

is q11itc 11a111rnl:1s llw _v

11:;t·cl lo

\1·11d:1linl' :1:. l:1ho11rn :111d

1:;il:;:1 pl11ckc1:; . l'IH:y .in: tH>l lhc 11111.:,cskI :ind cli:111cv,,i l11c:,sl's

,,.,

~

• .·•
..

r.

·@(.f
t

•

•

I

 26.

1110111 sm:kty. 1111111:ill:, th~: l,1di1:s :1v~1idL) 1nclul •c in

crimin:il

lhc

c: 1ses even :1s ro111pl:1111.i11L
111 vilm.::sc.· p:11ticul~11ly

r

p~trcnts

the un 1arricd and young

girl

never

al lo v Lhcir

d~n1g hlcr s lo go LO the police st:1tio11.sur Lo :1ppc.ir before the Police
Onic<.::rs or

in

COltrLs in order

their st:1lc111c11t.sor Lo l~1ct:

lo rrcurd

questions of lhc :1tlv >c:1Lc.s.Dul in lhc in.slant ca ·c.:,

LhL' ri lkulous

th<.::l:1dics (PW-2 ,111dPW-3) l ok ,di Lile :;Leps as they

bear the blasphemy .

oufd nol

1

lst Ya ·mcen l3ibi 0110Lher l:1d, who w:1 · PW

con.st.1111ly·1ppcan.:d in the cou1t but

!•ivcn

\\;t:,;

un-

up being

n ·ccssar,>.

27.

There is also anolhc1 import, n t ,1.spccl of the c,1sc as

lsL.J\sin Bibi, Lh :1ceu::;cd buy in her st:1Lc111c11
1 u/s 342

r.P.C.
lo.7 why this c;Jsc :1g:ii11st you, herself

in un.swer 10 Question

,1(111illcd her guilt when she p SILJ!atc.s ·1s

" 1 alonb with nu111bc1

r I 1c.lics v Tc

worl i11g in the

field. Hoth the l,1cli·:,;\•lst l'vl.!11;113ibi and l\llst. /\sma

l, 1bi P\V.s quarrck
which

\\1;1. l

I with inc l)Vcr l'ctc.:hin,, wnlcr

l'Jcn.:d h

In hl'lfl]..!.1'01 them bu t they

lllC

rcruscd s:1~ing that s111G
.:, I :un Christi:111,so . they
never ook wnter

orChristi:111. Over

from t..h1;1i~1nd

this,

WhL'II lfl'

re

l]U:1!11.:I .· t:1rlllf

ilusli111s ladies

l'rnn,

li1i111 lliL' 1d'11:,;il

tltL' hands

pltc11u111L't1awas ultimatcl:

l\r

ur tl1i11killl',

W;ltL·1 by llJe

:1 ( 'hri~,11:111 l:1cly,

:wit.cl1ed into , cligious

.~o, Ilic

111:1llcr..111dJ lot

'Wmd.s sliould h:td 1101 bL·c11othc t ll1a11Lite b la:;1 fic111y.

'Jc
so rn:iny

IL is alsl not oul of place tu 111c11tiL)J1
hcrt: 1h,1t lhcr'

arc

'hrist iat s living tn the s:1111evillage ,ilong, with fVl uslims

si 11cc gc11cr:1Lionhut tl<ll

.i

single tlll :iclc11t ol' such 11:1lurctook I /,1c1.:
- ,.., i ·J

'

, ~·

~

~:.:\\; rJ

,·

~

Li

L

•

\

\.J

.._... .,.•.

.... . ...

' '·

I_
,
\;. ••~

(,

 Lolc1;111cL'
l W,lrcfs the rt:l1gi '.Hts r·clings and foitli

rbl:isphemy

,.tny inciden t

JJ"L';ll ..h Olh1.;1 I hd

or clcrog,1 ory rcnwrl:

en happened or

occu rn:d i11the past by ,111y111lwbita11l or the ,·ilbgc

Lhcrc sJ, ulcJ

have been criminal cases or rcl1g1ou · ~illcrc:1t ion in lhc vi llngc.

o,

at present, there should ha 1 c bcc11the blusrihcmy, clue to ,,vhich the

c.isc w: 1s n.:gistcn:d ,ind Ilic publi · g:1 hcring w:1s g:1lhcr d and the
he t:1lk o

mcidenl bccam

10.

nf

l0\\ 'll ;111d

:1r u1111d .

ll is ,tlso f1LTli11L·1i1 In 111c11L
i on hcrL'

.iccuscd lady produced

dch,cc

her

ror11pl i:111c• tu scclio111• /0 (...,) l'1

1

1

cvidc 11
cc

lh:11 11ci1'1cr Ilic
11 )!"

she g;1 vc

.<.'.111dis1 ruuJ' il't lic :1lk

g<1tiom;

lcvelctl agn111sLher.

J l.

The

or

c rux

the above

1s tha t

disc uss ion

proserntion lws proved its case h9ond

·111y

shadow of de ubt. /\ll

the I W: have corroborated the p10sccuti o11vc rsi 11 inn
m:rnnc1 .

convincing

lady ,ind in bc i \\ ·c11

·111d tftl' .iu : usnl

~o. the chances ol raise

bl th

r

ha; bccn

J <.:nmit ,

till'

Lhc

ogcnt and

und 111between the PWs
cldt.·1s 0 1 l;1rnilic.s 0 1· Lhc

11111l 1c;1t1nr1

or tl1L· :rcc uscd

111 the

i11sl,111L
case a,c totally nrlcd ou1. No 11111
ig,ll111i:;cin : umsL ..11cc.s arc
the nccu cd MsL

till her dcnth . J Jowcv

.

u11lcss ·on lirmed by lli1.; I lon'bk

.

l ,ahm · I l1i; l1 Court,

.

is/ l'C.S<.:lllbe lore the cour l 111t"ll.Slody

C()fl \'ill

sl1 · i.:,111lilt

wliu

j.

LJ;il10n.:.

Th·

inror mecl th:.1t

a11 ,1ppc11I ngainst thi s jL.1
:'L~1~1c1~1wi1lii11 seven days .
1 Ln, _

•. 1.,

She: is nlso ordered lo p,1 , R ·. / ,00,000/.{;111d i11tk:);1ult whereof', she

or six

underg

w il l rurlhcr

S.I. for :1 pl..'.nod

suppli d to lhc convict free

ju cJgmcnl shall b

co ns1gnctl to lhe rec rd room al'lcr 1t::; clue c

i-f

n

.

ro~A.111~
.l' 'M1<:Cd
.

•!i,.

"'\.e:_,!i)~ i,'.;i

•~.,, .

tt:

l~\1\\\•

1,•

,,. ··-

I"

,''""~I'
,,)j!-0.,:

.,

.. •• •
..

,'! .... ..... ...

·~I ,; • .

I

.

, "~
,,";.1;;"'..
(;.1n
c

\, .

("

] ] •

•

I ,,

'· '-' I
" '

., .. I i

1 ' ·- r•d

. L. I( .

· · · t I. ,··.~
1 1 l.

•

·t

I
I
• ,}t -:,.,,

...

]I

,,., ..

l,".)
.

ur cos

.

File be

mpktion.

..

o,·.r .2010.

, ...,....,..,.,.,~

. ~~ t•it.-,

11onths. Copy or this

I . I

\•.' J l

r;;... .

,

'•

L
.'

I

I

'
11