Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673 / U# 11-24
INVESTIGATION
NUMBER:
Log# 1045673 / U# 11-24
INVOLVED
OFFICER:

“Officer A” (Chicago Police Officer); Male/White; 40 years old;
On-Duty; In Uniform; Year of Appointment – 2006

INVOLVED
OFFICER’S
INJURIES:

None.

INVOLVED
SUBJECT:

“Subject 1”; Female/Black; 29 years old

INVOLVED
SUBJECT’S
INJURIES:

Two gunshot wounds to the left breast, one gunshot wound to the
right back, non-fatal.

INITIAL
INCIDENT:

Armed Robbery.

DATE/TIME:

25 MAY 11, 2230 hours

LOCATION:

10 N. Kilbourn Avenue – gas station
Beat 1113

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
SUMMARY OF INCIDENT:
On 25 May 2011, a male subject, now known as Subject 2, entered a McDonald’s
restaurant at 5656 W. Irving Park Road and committed an armed robbery. Subject 2 fled
the restaurant and jumped into a getaway car driven by a female now known as Subject 1.
On the same date at approximately 2230 hours, Officer A, Officer B, and Officer C,
assigned to Beat 4430A, were on routine patrol and monitored an OEMC broadcast of a
police pursuit involving a black Lincoln that had been used during the armed robbery of
the McDonald’s restaurant. The officers learned that the pursued vehicle was traveling
eastbound on Madison Street. The officers observed the black Lincoln driving in their
direction and then turning into the Citgo Gas Station at 10 N. Kilbourn Avenue using the
entrance adjacent to Madison Street Beat 4430A turned northbound onto Kilbourn
Avenue from Madison Street As the officers approached the gas station, they observed
the black Lincoln driving through the area between fueling islands 7/8 and 9/10. Beat
4430A then turned westbound onto an entrance/ exit apron of the gas station that accesses
Kilbourn Avenue
Believing the driver of the Lincoln, Subject 1, was bringing the vehicle to a stop,
Officer A exited the squad car. Rather than bringing the vehicle to a stop, Subject 1
accelerated her vehicle in the direction of Officer A, who was positioned to the north of
his marked squad car. In fear of his life, Officer A discharged his weapon at Subject 1.
Subject 1 continued northbound until stopping the vehicle at 44 N. Kilbourn Avenue.
Subject 1 sustained two gunshot wounds to the left breast and one gunshot wound to the
right back. Subject 1 was placed into custody and transported by a Chicago Fire
Department (CFD) ambulance to Mt. Sinai Hospital.

Page 2 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
INVESTIGATION:
The Arrest Report of Subject 1 documents that she was arrested and charged
with Attempted Murder, Armed Robbery with a Firearm, Aggravated Fleeing/ Bodily
Injury, and Aggravated Assault to a Government Employee. It is reported that Subject 1
was placed into custody after she drove her vehicle into the path of Officer A, attempting
to injure him. In addition to Officers A, B, and C, CPD Sergeant 1, and Officers D, E, F,
G, H, I, J, and K, assisted in the arrest. 1
The Case Supplementary Report documents that Officers A, B, and C were in
uniform and assigned to a three man marked squad car. Officer B was the driver of the
vehicle, Officer A was the front passenger, and Officer C was the rear passenger. The
officers told detectives that they heard an Office of Emergency Management and
Communications (OEMC) broadcast regarding a police pursuit of a Lincoln Town Car
that was involved in an armed robbery of a McDonald’s restaurant. The officers
observed the vehicle driving toward them. As they neared the vehicle, the officers
observed the passenger’s door of the Lincoln Town car open and a black male subject
hanging outside the car while the vehicle was moving.
Officer B then made a U-turn and followed the subject’s vehicle from about two
blocks behind with lights and sirens activated. As the officers approached Kilbourn
Avenue, they observed the subject’s vehicle enter the Madison Street entrance to the
Citgo Gas Station located at 10 N. Kilbourn Avenue followed by pursuing police
personnel. Officer B then turned onto Kilbourn Avenue and pulled the squad car into the
Kilbourn Avenue entrance/exit to the Citgo Gas Station while the subject’s vehicle
slowed and maneuvered between fueling islands 7/8 and 9/10. Believing that the driver,
Subject 1, was bringing her vehicle to a stop, Officer A exited the front passenger’s side
of the squad car, followed by Officer C and Officer B.
Officer A told detectives that after he exited the driver’s seat of the police vehicle
and moved toward Subject 1’s vehicle, he saw that there was only one visible occupant.
Officer A then realized that Subject 1 was not bringing the vehicle to a stop, but rather
now accelerating in his direction. Officer A yelled, “Police, stop, police;” however,
Subject 1 continued driving in Officer A’s direction. Believing that Subject 1 was going
to run him down and kill or seriously injure him and other officers, Officer A discharged
his firearm five times in the direction of Subject 1. Subject 1 continued driving onto
Kilbourn Avenue where her vehicle came to a stop. Responding officers ordered Subject
1 to exit the vehicle. Subject 1 exited the vehicle and was taken to the ground by
responding officers.
Officer B told detectives that as he prepared to exit the front driver’s seat of his
squad car, he observed Subject 1 accelerate her vehicle in the direction of Officer A.
Officer B then heard about five gunshots. Officer B exited the squad car and saw Subject

1

Subject 2 jumped out of the vehicle during the course of the incident. See statement of Subject 1, Att.
104.

Page 3 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
1’s vehicle driving onto Kilbourn Avenue, subsequently rolling to a stop at
approximately 44 N. Kilbourn Avenue.
Officer C told detectives that as he exited the rear driver’s side of the squad car
he heard gunshots. Officer C then observed Subject 1’s vehicle pulling onto Kilbourn
Avenue and slowing to a stop at 44 N. Kilbourn Avenue. Officer C and additional
responding officers ran toward the Lincoln, at which time Subject 1 exited the front
driver’s side of the vehicle and was taken into custody.
In a statement to IPRA on 05 November 2013, Officer A provided details
concerning his involvement in this incident in a manner consistent with Department
reports, witness statements and the summary contained in this report.
In statements to IPRA, Officers B, C, D, G, and J provided information
consistent with Department Reports and statements made by Officer A.
In statements to IPRA, Officers E, F, and H each stated that they heard gunshots
as they pulled up to the scene; however, none of them observed Officer A fire his
weapon.
In statements to IPRA, Officers I, K, and CPD Sergeant 1 each stated that they
arrived on scene after the weapon’s discharge.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer A documents that he discharged his
firearm at Subject 1 after she became an assailant and used her vehicle as a weapon.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer B documents that he utilized an Open
Hand Strike on Subject 1 after she pulled away.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer C documents that he performed an
Open Hand Strike and executed a Take Down/ Emergency Handcuffing on Subject 1
after she pulled away.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer G documents that he executed a Take
Down/ Emergency Handcuffing on Subject 1 after she became an active resister and
pulled away.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer D documents that he executed a Take
Down/ Emergency Handcuffing and deployed his Taser on Subject 1 after she pulled
away and refused to show her hands.
The Tactical Response Report of Officer K documents that he deployed his
Taser on Subject 1 after she pulled away and refused to show her hands.
The Taser Download Reports document that Officer D deployed his Taser twice
and Officer K deployed his Taser three times.

Page 4 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
A Traffic Crash Report documents that during the police pursuit, Subject 1’s
Lincoln Town Car struck a motorist. The motorist’s vehicle spun out of control and
struck a CPD vehicle. The CPD vehicle then struck a wooden fence and a rod iron fence
before coming to rest. Subject 1 continued driving her vehicle down the alley of 4400 W.
Monroe. 2
The Arrest Report of Subject 2 documents that he was arrested and charged
with two counts of Armed Robbery with a Firearm, Aggravated Fleeing/ Bodily Injury,
and Unlawful Use of a Weapon by a felon after he and Subject 1 purportedly committed
an armed robbery at McDonald’s. Officers set up a point of surveillance near Subject 2’s
residence and placed him in custody on 26 May 2011, at 0300 hours, at 3605 W. Fifth
Avenue.
The OEMC recordings contain calls to 911 and CPD radio transmissions.
Analysis of the calls and transmissions are consistent with Department reports and
witness accounts. Additionally, OEMC was immediately notified of the officer’s weapon
discharge.
The CFD Ambulance Report documents that Subject 1 was transported to Mt.
Sinai Hospital and received treatment for a Taser and gunshot wounds.
Evidence Technician photographs depict Subject 1, her vehicle, recovered
evidence, and various angles of the scene.
Medical records document that Subject 1 was treated for one gunshot wound to
her left chest through and through, and one gunshot wound to her right upper back.
Medical personnel also removed Taser spikes from Subject 1 and treated her for injuries
sustained during a motor vehicle crash. A medical evaluation revealed that Subject 1 has
Moyamoya disease.3
On 17 October 2011, a Trajectory Analysis was performed on Subject 1’s
vehicle. The purpose of the analysis was to determine whether there was a violation of
the Department’s Use of Deadly Force policy relative to firing at or into a moving
vehicle. The trajectory rods were placed in the impact locations as allowed. A Leica
Scan of the vehicle was conducted after the trajectory rod placement. The measurements
of the trajectory rods were taken. The analysis results established no evidence to prove
Officer A fired at Subject 1’s vehicle after the imminent threat of death or great bodily
harm had passed. The analysis results did not establish the specific location of Officer A
when he fired and/or if there was a means of escape. While it is important to note that the
angle measurements are +/- 7°, none of the analysis results indicate that Officer A fired at
the vehicle after it passed.
2

The Traffic Pursuit was investigated by the Bureau of Internal Affairs under Log #1045811.
Moyamoya disease is “a rare blood vessel (vascular) disorder in which a ring of blood vessels at the base
of your brain (the circle of Willis) progressively narrows, causing blood flow to your brain to become
blocked.” (www.mayoclinic.org)

3

Page 5 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
Video obtained from Citgo Gas Station depicts the Lincoln enter the lot of the
gas station via its south driveway and cut through the lot. Marked police vehicles enter
the gas station lot and follow the Lincoln. As the Lincoln drives across the lot, a marked
police vehicle pulls up to the lip of the east entrance. As that police vehicle comes to a
stop, the front passenger door opens and an officer exits the vehicle. Due to the
graininess of the images, the identity and physical characteristics of the officer who exits
the vehicle cannot be determined. Additionally, it cannot be determined if the same
officer is holding a gun in his hand.
The Lincoln exits the gas station lot via the east drive way and heads north onto
Kilbourn Avenue. The Lincoln then comes to a stop but the view of the camera to that
location is obstructed by foliage on the gas station lot. Several squad cars then converge
on the Lincoln and gas station lot. Due to where the Lincoln came to a stop, no further
portion of the incident is observed.
In-car video obtained from Beat 1195 produced no additional information.
In-car video obtained from Beat 1122 depicts the Lincoln driving through the gas
station. Simultaneously, a marked squad car pulls up from Kilbourn Avenue and stops at
the mouth of the gas station. The squad car’s passenger and driver’s side doors open as
the Lincoln makes its way out of the gas station and turns onto Kilbourn Avenue. Given
the image quality of the video, the position of the in-car camera, and the abrupt sequence
of events, Officer A’s location in relation to the Lincoln and the actual shooting cannot be
seen. The Lincoln comes to a stop on Kilbourn Avenue and Subject 1 is placed into
custody.
A canvass of the vicinity of the incident identified Citgo Gas Station employees
Witness 1 and Witness 2 as witnesses to the shooting. Additionally, a manager at JR
Plaza’s Hotel stated that room 224, occupied by a guest named “Witness 3,” has a view
of the Citgo Gas Station.
Citgo Employee Witness 1 related that he heard multiple gunshots and dropped
to the floor; however, he did not witness the actual shooting.
Attempts to interview Witness 3 were unsuccessful.
In an interview with IPRA on 25 January 2012, Witness 2, a security officer with
TNT Security Company, stated that on the date and time of the incident, he was working
security at Citgo Gas Station. Witness 2 was outside smoking a cigarette when he was
alerted by the sound of police sirens. Soon after, he saw a Lincoln enter the gas station
followed by approximately four squad cars. Witness 2 identified the driver of the
Lincoln as a female and noted that she was the sole occupant of the car. As the Lincoln
pulled into the gas station from the Madison Street entrance, a squad car pulled around to
the Kilbourn Avenue exit.

Page 6 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
The Lincoln traveled around an island of gas pumps. As the Lincoln headed
toward the Kilbourn Avenue exit, it slowed down for a few seconds and then resumed a
normal speed. Simultaneously Witness 2 heard four to five gunshots. Witness 2 ducked
and did not see where the bullets hit. The Lincoln maneuvered around the squad car that
was partially blocking the exit, and exited onto Kilbourn Avenue. Witness 2 saw the
driver of the squad car exit the vehicle, but he did not see the passenger/s exit. The driver
of the Lincoln then brought the vehicle to a stop.
Witness 2 stated that the driver exited the Lincoln with her hands up and an
officer threw her to the ground. Numerous officers surrounded the driver and yelled at
her to stop resisting. Witness 2 stated that he heard the “pop” of a taser gun while the
driver was on the ground.
The Case Supplementary Report documents that during a canvass, the
detectives located one eye witness, Witness 2. Witness 2 provided detectives an account
of the incident which was consistent with the statement he provided to IPRA.
Additionally, Witness 2 stated that when a squad car drove up and partially blocked the
Kilbourn Avenue exit, Subject 1 accelerated toward that squad car. It appeared that she
was going to strike the squad car but swerved at the last second. Witness 2 stated that he
heard four or five gunshots but could not tell who was shooting.
In an interview with IPRA on 14 June 2011, Subject 1 stated that on the date of
this incident she was traveling west on Madison Avenue while being chased by the
police. Subject 1 said she fled because she was scared. Her boyfriend, Subject 2, jumped
out of the car earlier during the chase. Subject 1 turned into the lot of a Citgo Gas
Station. While driving through the gas station, a squad car blocked Subject 1’s path.
Subject 1 drove around that vehicle. Subject 1 stated she did not know whether any
police officers were standing in front of her vehicle as she exited out to the street. Subject
1 then heard two shots but did not know who fired the shots or at whom they were
directed. Once she pulled out of the gas station she realized she had been shot. Subject 1
pulled her vehicle to the side of the street and exited. An officer took her to the ground.
Subject 1 stated that she landed on her front torso with her hands under her stomach.
Officers tried to pull her arms behind her back but she could not move her arms because
she was hampered by the pain. As she rolled onto her right side in an attempt to place her
left hand behind her back, she was tasered. Subject 1 then rolled onto her left side to free
her right hand and was tasered a second time, and again a third time after she was
handcuffed.
The Case Supplementary Report documents that Subject 1 told detectives that
her boyfriend, Subject 2, asked her to take him to do a “job,” which she knew to be a
robbery. Subject 1 agreed. Subject 1 drove Subject 2 to a McDonald’s restaurant and
parked on the street. Subject 2 exited the vehicle and returned a few minutes later with a
bag. As Subject 1 left the area, a police car followed them with lights and sirens on.
Subject 2 told her to keep driving. Subject 2 eventually jumped out of the car while
Subject 1 kept driving with the police in pursuit. Subject 1 stated that she tried to turn
around in a Citgo Gas Station. She entered the gas station, maneuvered through the

Page 7 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
pump islands and past cars, and attempted to exit at Kilbourn Avenue. When she realized
the exit was blocked by a squad car, she tried to go around and pass the squad car.
Subject 1 stated that as she drove in the direction of the police car and tried to
exit, she observed a police officer standing near the front of the squad car pointing
something at her. She then heard gunshots and realized she had been shot. She stopped
the car by the alley and the police ordered her out of the vehicle. Officers tackled her to
the ground, tasered her and handcuffed her.
The Case Supplementary Report documents that detectives observed two
apparent bullet holes in the front windshield of Subject 1’s vehicle, and an apparent bullet
hole in the rear passenger’s side center post. The passenger’s side rear window was
shattered. There were five fired 9 millimeter cartridge cases recovered at the scene.
Inspection by the CPD Mobile Crime Lab revealed that Officer A’s weapon was five
cartridges short of being fully loaded. At the Emergency Room, the Mobile Crime Lab
recovered one fired bullet that fell from Subject 1’s clothing. Hospital personnel reported
that Subject 1 sustained two gunshot wounds to her left chest, one of which exited
through her upper back.
A report from the Illinois State Police Division of Forensic Services dated 14
July 2011 documents that Officer A’s 9 millimeter Glock was test fired and found to be
in firing condition. Further testing revealed that five fired cartridge casings, one fired
bullet fragment, and two fired bullet jackets were fired from Officer A’s weapon.

Page 8 of 9

 Independent Police Review Authority
Log# 1045673/ U# 11-24
CONCLUSION AND FINDING:
This investigation found that Officer A’s use of deadly force was in compliance
with Chicago Police Department policy. According to the Chicago Police Department’s
General Order 03-02-03, II:
A. “a sworn member is justified in using force likely to cause death or great
bodily harm only when he or she reasonably believes that such force is
necessary:
1.

to prevent death or great bodily harm to the sworn member or to
another person, or;

2.

to prevent an arrest from being defeated by resistance or escape
and the sworn member reasonably believes that the person to be
arrested:
a. has committed or has attempted to commit a forcible felony
which involved the infliction, threatened infliction, or
threatened use of physical force likely to cause death or great
bodily harm, or;
b. is attempting to escape by use of a deadly weapon, or;
c. otherwise indicates that he or she will endanger human life or
inflict great bodily harm unless arrested without delay.”

Officer A’s actions were in accordance with the conditions of CPD’s deadly force policy.
All available evidence corroborates statements made by Officer A, in that Officer A fired
at Subject 1 after she drove her vehicle toward Officer A, placing Officer A in imminent
fear of great bodily harm or death.

Page 9 of 9