United States Department of State Washington, D. C. 20520 ser 3 0 ans Case No. Segment: Bradley P. Moss, Esq. Mark S. Zaid, RC. 1250 Connecticut Ave, NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20036 Dear Messrs. Moss and Zaid: In response to your clients? request dated September 24, 2012, under the Freedom of Information Act (the 5 USC ?5 52, we initiated a search of the Of?ce of Information Programs and Services. The search of the records of the Of?ce of Information Programs and Services is ongoing and has resulted in the retrieval of 59 documents responsive to your request. After reviewng these documents, we have determined that 2 may be released in full and 57 may be released with excisions. All released material is enclosed. An enclosure explains the OIA exemptions and other grounds for withholding material. Where we have made excisions, the applicable exemptions are marked on each document. In some cases, two or more exemptions may apply to the same document. All non-exempt material that is reasonably segregable from the exempt material has been released. We will keep you informed as your case progresses. If you have any questions, please contact Trial Attorney Lisa Olson at 202-514-5633, Lisa.Olson@usdoj. gov. Please refer to the civil action number, lS-cv-00363, and case number, 36691, in all correspondence regarding this case. Sincerely, For John F. Hackett, Director Of?ce of Information Programs and Services Enclosures: As stated. TIFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 00535122? Date: 0912912015 Mike Allen From: Philippe Rel nes Sent: To: Subject: father Wednesday, April 21, 2010 3:37 PM . a IN FULL One of the dif?cult parts of my WT Public Lives pro?le was that I talked about my father, which until then i 1 had onl done mabe a handful of times over 35 years. Suddenly, was in a newspaper read by millions and everone I knew somethimgi had kept serzret, and was ashamed of Was awkward, but in the end very freeing and I am glad i did. From that point on it felt less terrible. HOpe what you're reading about you and your dad works out the same way for you The rest of it about you is sterling, and well-deserved. What i love most is that thousand words later, none of I 5 really how anything more about you than we did this moming on the questions we ask most, like How does he do it Still a lovable my5tery Enjoy the aeholades UNCLASSIFIED us. Department of State REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara? Nielsen. sEnior Reviewer .- Case No. [52012-36691 DOC No. 00585122? Date: 09l'29f2015 C05 8 5 1 4 U.S. Department of State Case No' F--2012-36691 Doc Nu. (305851423 Date. 09/29/2015 From: Harm, am [51m mimme Sent: wainesday, March 03, 2010 3:30 PM To: names, 7 7 Subject Cummimms 910396 for wnokunsowmm [flimsy FUL HI vhiuipe, 5min. March 15, wz'll he lemming 25 mp Washington mess my. cm whoxunsawmm. We've and" to include yuu IS an: of mos' Influential foiks In the We'll be emu-mung our readers lo crow-imam a profile mm (as always, all on WhoflunxGuv'com is fanthecked below going Ilve)' Canyon send me a photo and resume, so lean yuurpmfile surmd in pveparafion lathe mum? Hunks and couvmiauons, Beth Mariowe REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Revilwer End av Forwalded M5521: UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of Slate Doc No. (305851423 Date: 09/29/2015 'ulnn. Strlim C05 8 5 5 US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. 005851151 Date: 0912912015 Frnm': Tapper, aka Sent: Thursday, April I. 2010 4:11 PM To: Philippe Reinesl Subject: have a sec? IRELEASE IN PART ?36 Barbara Nielsenfs?? Reviewer 1 UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851151 Date: 09129i2015 86; 5 8 5 1 1 52FIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. 005351152 Date: 09299015 - From: Tapper, lake I F?d?y.Ap?i. 2, 2010 8:31 AM Tn: Phliippe Remesf?? Subject: Fw RELEASE IN PART 136 u_l .- From: Tapper. Jake ?ail . BS Subject: NEXT For NEXT Surday's THIS WEEK (Apr? 11}. maybe would Inlgawiew Sealer-aw C?mn Prague? Thursday or Friday? REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nieisen. Senipr gReviewer UI?'TJapamnent of sate; case No. Doc No. 005851152 Date: 09:29:2015 0 5 8 5 1 62FIED U.S. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. (305851162 Date: 5 From: Van Sustcren, Greta Sent: Saturday, April 3, 2010 7:23 PM To: Philippe Reines! BB 5mm? RELEASE PARTI 35 I Du yuu wanl'lu be my guest a! white house complain dinner? REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nielsen. Senior 11- .-. a UNCLASSIFIED us; DepartmentE?tate Case ?ung-2261256691 Doc N-o. (305851162 Date: 0912912015 5 8 5 7 5 FIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851175 Date: 09/29/2015 Front: Margaret Carlson Sent: Thursday. April 8. 2010 LS6 PM I To: Philippe Rcircsl I i Subject: Can you come? . . Attath: mageOOl jpg. HIE WEEK Opinion Awards RELEASE IN pAR-r I BS In your pile c! ?was, one a tram me. WE wsex Opimon Awards dinner is abust great night, tun and ef?cient, an unusual commotion. You can be out more ten. we! tea and mm, this . Sen. Amy Kbbuchar and Gov. to Item?, wuh color mammary by Joe and mud :0 Margaret - .. REVIEW AUTHORIW: Barbara Nansen, Senior Reviewer . UNCLASSIFIED us. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851175 Date: 09/29/2515 CO 58 5 8 US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851182 Date: 09/29/2015 From: Howard, Cory . Seat: thy, A1111 9, 2010 7.47 PM To: . Phnlippc Remcsl 86 Cc: Howard, Cory t Su bj?u: Rt From: Sue-mth 1?30 . .. . . noun?.- ?i .- . From: FIR (Flinn; To: LeibDVIch, Mari: Sent: Tue Apr 13 03:35:29 2010 Subject: Re: Ofcomse- canHuma mplcofhcm? nut-?hnuu? From: 'I.?ibovich, Mnrk" Date: Wed, 2010 20.47.19 -0400 To: I Date: Wed, 14 Apr 2010 20:4?t19 -D400 . T0: Sent: Wed Apr 14 14:33:24 2010 Subject: 2, 3, 4 1} I told Laura Rozen Friday afternoon that the chances are ?Less than none. And that ?Something being a sexy media story shouldn?t be confused with truth. 4 2} Playbook on Saturday includes: ?Good Saturday morning. For brunch convo: Why isn?t Secretary Clinton on the media- sI'im't-tists for the Court?? 3} ?Clinton's spokesman, P.J. Crowley, initially seemed UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. C05851196 Date: 09/291'2015 U.S. Department of State Case NO. 52012?36691 DOC No. (305851195 Date: 092912.015 to fiirt with the idea. Clinton ?loves her present job and is not looking for another one." he said. adding, "I'm sure she appreciates Sen. Hatch's kind words." am 90% that "initially seemed to ?irt with the idea" was originally written as "hardly a no - but still the same point, he would have taken any response to mean what he wanted it to; it was at this point that Tommy and I ended it] 4} POL Breaking News: Squashing speculation the President Barack Ohama Could nominate Hillary Clinton to the Supreme Court, White House spokesman Tommy Vietor says the president "thinks Secretary Clinton is doing an excellent job as Secretary of State and wants her to remain in that position." UNCLASSIFIED U.S. Department of State Case NO. Doc No. 005851196 Date: 09092015 IED US. Department of State Case NO. Doc No. (305851199 Date: 09f29f2015 From: Leibovich, Mark Sent: Thursdayt April 2010 12'26 PM - To: Philippe Reines I 35 Subject: RE Going on the record Wall, 1 that you had a beef thrush loo"? Manage-m- i From. FIR I 86 Sent:Tht1rsdoy.Apnl I5. . Letbovrch. Marl?: Subject Re: Going on the record 1 shirt to Laura EELEASE IN PART ljust don't want Laura named I need to keep my beef them contained to Ben, not some any man exploding ul Politico And btw, you should call Ben out for coiling it a trial hallo-m1 . the Wh told him HRC was never more than their imagination Enema!? AUTHORITY: Barbara Nielsen. enior Reviewer From Mark Letbot'tch FIR 'Sublect RE Going on the record Sent Apr li? I?m gust donng a really fast, punchy traitth of the episode . Now wait, Is that ?new media line" something you said to luuru. or are saying to me"? Message?"- From' PIRI BB San: Thurutlay,Apt-il 112010120913?: . To Marl; Subject Going on the remrd have to lure Laura so don't want to call her out by name, but 11? you want to say When asked on Friday afternoon by Politico whether there was any chance Clinton would be nominated, Reines said. "Less than none.? And added, ?Something being a nary media story shouldn't be con?ned with truth.? BUT. if you are mentioning Ben Smith and the PJ late a sentence or two later - which you should - then need you to somehow note that he saw at PJ's statement what he wanted to (basncally took advantage of tom), and at that pom! 1 piekod up the plume lo the WH so we could all shut them down l'muliy Can't you in passmg note the! Smith has taken "an unusual interest :11 hitting" Reine-t UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. (305351199 Date: CO 5 8 5 1 9 Department of State Case No. Doc No. 005851199 Dat?: 0912912015 Menage?m- From Mark PIR can In} lb?. (11 1h: retard?" Apr I5. 20") l'23 AM Iuld Lax-I Ruun lenv I?er?uun Illa! the man-n1 an: "Ln-m! lhan mne.? And 111.1) *Sc-meihm; hung a mcdu story- shouldln he 1mm.? UNCLASSIFIED US Department of State Case No. Doc NO. 005851199 Date: 0 5 8 5 12 0 1IED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851201 Date: 09/29/2015 From: . Michael, Renee Sent: Thursday. April 15, 2010 9:00 PM i To: Philippe Reines - 86. Subject: Re NY Times Magazine Fact-Checking Queries/l Philippe Reines - RELEASE Thanks BS On 4/lS/l0 m, magic: wrote 86 Hi there!) Spelled correctly. though I'd self identify as 'advisor' rather than spokesman - but the latter is ?ne if it works for the storyZ) Yes3) Yes (though since it was via email I can tell you in the spirit of 100% accuracy that] used "shouldn?t" rather than "should not") From: "Michael, Renee" Date: Thu 1' 20:39:11 -0400 To: m: Subject: Piece on HIRC Thought you might appreciate this one, Philippe. Hope you are well. EELEASE IN PART REVIEW :t . to rntzo om t2 tne ee rte exist?insults o~3?lD?a ad-t -w Barbara Nielsen. enior Reviewer In the White House, it?s still possible to hear someone dismissing Hillary as a foreign-policy lightweight. ?She has no real strategic vision," says an NSC of?cial. "But she'll get done what she has to do. She?s the good little Methodist girl. In the and she'll have her list of the nine or ID things she has to do and check them off one by one." Qbama's Bad Cop Jon Meaham?s Newsweek is in a time warp and so is the author of ?Bad Cop," Misting Hirsch. In an article that whipsaws back and forth between camps, after beginning on a positive team note that makes you think they?re going to break new ground, the Newsweek crewjust can?t seem to help themselves. Just when you think we were out of the Obama v. Clinton era, they pull us back in. But Clinton has added a new sobriety to the administration?s approach to the world. "Her point about the 3-o?cloclt-in-the-moming phone call wasn?t entirely wrong,? says one senior State of?cial, referring to Clinton?s infamous campaign slap at Obama's inexperience. In an article that hits all the scar spots, you have to wonder what Newsweek?s real goal is here. Michael Hirsch making sure to invoke everything from sexist insults to Pres. W1C, then on to the 3:00 am. primary ad, ?nding truth enough to break open old wounds long since healed. And by all means, let the anonymous sourcing fly. So, if there was any doubt that the book ?Game Change" broke the anonymous source door of? its hinges in the era of Obama-Clinton, in order to get the story of the most fascinating duo to occupy an Administration in decades puts that notion to rest. "The good little Methodist girl spewing from the Iips of one NSC ?source? must have made Meacham come right out of his chair with excitement. Could it be more condescending to a woman charged with the world diplomatic mission of the United States? No, and that?s why it was offered up. Cover makes brave people out of cowards, a dripping cheap shot easy to utter under the cloak of covert swipes. This anonymous national security of?cial, no doubt, now substituting for what used to be called fairness when peeple had the spine to talk on the reserd. That Newsweek enjoys using quotes like these in a story that starts out revealing a moment where Obama and Clinton truly come together is revealing. But both sides gets shots in, anonymous or not, with Nmsweek only to happy to divide the Obama and Clinton teams even a year after they 've begun their work. It begins on a high note in Copenhagen. The former political rivals suddenly morphed into a diplomatic version of Starsky and Hutch. feh a particular responsibility since I had urged the president to come," Clinton said. ?Because I knew nothing was going to happen unless we gave it Our all Striding down the hallway, with the Chinese protocol of?cer sputtering protests behind them, America?s two beeteknown politicians barged into the meeting room. There they found Wen conferring secretly with thelggie?rsho? Brazil, India, and South "A??ica'jbeli??l'i?e?s?cenes, Beijing had been trying to block all efforts to impose standards for measuring, reporting, and_verifying progress on carbon reduction. Smiling and-shaking hands, Obama and Clinton worked the room together, as they had each done so many times before as contending politicians. Then A the president sat down and started negotiating with Clinton sliding position papers to him as needed. When the Chinese ?nally caved, both Obama and Clinton knew that it wasn'tjust because they had ?t us. Depanmentof State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851263 Date: U.S. Department of State Case No. Doc No. 005851268 Date: 0912922015 crashed the meeting. Two days before, the secretary of state had ?own in to Copenhagen by surprise to deliver a sweetener to help win over deveIOping countries. In essence, it was a global bribe: $100 billion a year from rich nations by 2020 to help poorer countries cope with climate controls. It was political . hardball, Hillary style, and it had helped to isolate Beijing. New Obama was closing the deal Clinton had set up Michael Hirsch attempts to put together an in depth article offering all sides of the (Shaina-Hillary story. But what results is what I?ve come to expect from News-week?s Jon Meacham. At least the tin on behind the seen 3 photo gallery is better. Making sure to get the quote that puts William Jefferson Clinton never far out of mind, even if he is way out (if sight, another anonymous source evening out the competitive sport rhetoric. Yet the on-the-record effusions of good feeling don?t tell the whole story. There?s a wariness in both - I camps that may never completely disappear. The giant Clinton entourage once known as Hillaryland, now relocated to the wood-paneled corridor on the seventh ?oor at Foggy Bottom, remains to some 1 degree a place and mindset unto itself. It is still dominated by Hillary and, of course, her husband?who has remained surprisingly out of view, even if his advice is often sought throughout the Obama administration, as Hillary herself acknowledges. ?When they say on the seventh ?oor, ?We need to run this by the president,? that phrase doesn't necessarily refer to Obama,? remarks one former Clinton administration of?cial And that?s just the way it is. Within the piece, if you dig hard enough, are noteworthy themes hit upon before. The eatiy criticisms of Clinton's in?uence are clearly no longer in play. However, what still lingers is whatl wrote about last month. That for all her efforts at State, including the morale after a horrible situation under Bush-Cheney, as well as positive budget exploitation, even now there are quesuons about the absence of Clinton putting her personal stamp on one identifying is5ue on a canvas that is her own. Hirsh gets a response from Clinton on this charge. Even now there are questions about how much she's putting her personal stamp on things. ?it?s a mystery to me why she hasn't taken a big issue and totally owned it,? says one devoted aide who has worked for her on and off since Clinton was first lady. ?She always has before. This is a'woman who never faced questions about whether she has too little in?uence. She's never been without in?uence before." Clinton Says she no longer has the ?luxury? of focusing on one issue; her agenda is too "enormous." One person willing to go on the record, for which he deserves credit, is Leslie Gelb, whojudges Clinton smart but no strategist. Leslie Gelb, the former president of the Council on Foreign Relations, says he doesn?t think Clinton is of the caliber of James Baker, the George H.W. Bush secretary of state who was perhaps the last real Superstar in thejob. ?She?s very smart,? he says "She understands all these issues. You can have a good discussion with her on almost any [subject]. But she doesn't pretend to be, nor is she, a strategist. When she goes to the National Security Council, she doesn?t bring that to the table." (General Jones, for the record, disagrees, saying, ?Those of us who have worked with her are grateful for her strategic vision?) - Remembering Mr: me wonder if that is what 6er is actuallymissingt-It wasn't until Hillary Clinton ran for president that she became the natural from person; as there wasn't a time in her life she wasn?t playing a supporting ?lms been migrating at times to watch during her tenure of envoys. Baker?s swaggersand bravado, his natural-place in the Order of all things Bushrwas always his lead. Clinton never having that opportunity until 2008, because even as New York senator she was the work horse, not the show UNCLASSIFIE Li's. Departmeni?of State Case No. NET?Eds?tt?sizea Date: osr2912015 5 8 5 2 6 US. Department of State Case NO. F-2012-36691 DOC No. 005851263 Date: 092912015 i? horse like others in the Senate. Because it?s simply preposterous to say that Clinton isn?t strategic. It?s just simply not her presidency. Her relationship with SecDef Cjates on Afghanistan moved Obama to put in more troups. as well as her strong stance on Iran that moves Obarna away from diplomacy only, because she pushed for tough sanctions early on; then there is Russia, even Haiti, all proving Gelb wrong. But it?s on Israel and the settlements, particularly talking to PM thanyahu that Clinton's real have shown through. The trust she long ago built up allowing her to talk tough to Israel, where Obama's lack of history won't allow to go. Asked about such criticisms, Clinton reveals a glimmer of the testy feelings she is uSUaliy so successful at concealing. think when you inherit the range of problems that we have, from one end of the world to the other-uthe threats that we faced, the two wars that we inherited?I think trying to have a very clear approach to actually dealing with those problems [and promoting] American leadership at this time in our history is about as big an idea as you can get," she says. It?s the partnership with Gates that may be her de?ning strategic branding, with the upcoming troop surge in Afghanistan meeting a lot of push back on both sides of the aisle, with Clinton's very good friend Vice President Joe Biden on the opposite side. A lot depends on the outcome of Obama's focus in that country, which right now isn?t producing results that comfort few. As a staunch supporter of Obama?s Afghan policy, since Karzai ?s dubi0us re-election, plus more talk about creatingjobs in that country, the mission creep on top of corniption is softening my own belief that Obama?s team has gone severely off course. Clinton?s instincts at the beginning about the Administrati on?s Obama choir, however, mimicked what many on the outside were also feeling, though it?s still not made a dent with the hard core. She "was not in the inner circle. That was clear," says one aide who, like several others quoted in this story, did not want to be named discussing internal politics. Her bluntness abroad occasionally caused consternation in the West Wing. and Clinton, in turn, "complained about a lack of dissenting voices in the administration," says an old friend who knows her from her ?rst-lady days. qutaposed against en'n? recent fawnin ra Pres. 0b ma ein undera rec' at least Hirsh was able to o??er candid truths that are troubling to many foreign policy watchers that long ago were thank?rl Clinton's pragmatic dealmaking approach is somewhere within the President?s reach. ?The administration, frankly, overpromised and underdelivered in the ?rst year," says the cm cial. ?Some people around Obama view him as a transfonnational ?gure, and transactions are seen as somehow a little unseemly. But it turns out transfonnational foreign policy is complicated. It's hard sometimes to turn this enormous public appeal [of Obama's] into actual leverage.? This is the reason the QWM is still required, because Pres. Obama, for all his remarkable gifts,just doesn?t do get down to it tough very well. The lady with the lists, ticking off what must be done to move forward, even as she annoys lesser men who bridle at her ef?ciency of accomplishing the task she sets out to do, is coming into her own amidst an Administration that sorely needed her stealth, strength and experience on the world stage. It?s once again the story of Hillary?s work horse ethics amidst a show horse presidency. Intent isn?t enough. You have to know how to manifest yOur goals. There isn't anywhere on Pres. Obama?s diplomatic canvas where Sect. Hillary Rodham Clintoli?s inflating? cannot be seen?ri'r?feltZ She?s touched all iiu'a'rfe'fs, 'while putti hg the ship of State back into running order. She?sjust not the front man so many wanted her to be. Making you wonder what might have been if Hillary Rodham Clinton had??t put William Jefferson Cl inton?s career before her own. Because it?s clear that her wide ranging portfolio at State, the responsibilities she?s taken on making up for the damage in a post Bush?Cheney- UNCLASSIFIED us. originator State Case No. Doc N01005851268 Date: 09/292015 US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-3669?l Doc No. 005851268 Date: 09/29/2915 agenda, is demanding work at a time when Clinton might be looking to make her own mark. TAVIS SMILEY That opens the door for the obvious question, what would Hillary Clinton want to do when she is no longer Secretary of State? HTLEARY CLINTON: Oh, i, there's so many things I'm interested in, I mean, really going back to private life and spending time reading, and writing, and maybe teaching, doing some personal travel, not the kind of travel where you bring along a couple of hundred people with you. Just focusing on, on issues of women, girls, families, the kind of intersection between what?s considered ?real politique? and real life politics, which has always fascinated me. Thinking hard about her own foundation, one that would focus on women, girls and continue the work she began in her Beijing speech when she said ?women?s rights are human rights," it?s clear she's not through. If: realized, ala foundation, we may yet see a star Hillary turn around the globe on a canvas she can ?nally call her own. Taylor Marsh Political Analyst. Washington, DC Twitter: taylomiarsh memories us. oe'eartm'ent of State Case No. F-Edi2-36691 Doc No?. 005851268 Date: 09:2912015 U.S. Department of State Case Nq. Doc No. 005851269 Date: 09i29i20?15 From: Taylor Marsh Sent: Wedms?ay,hmii 23,2010 To: Phi Iippe Rama: 5i. bjecl: RE- Piece an HRC You be: RELEASE IN PART BB Imam; farrvud In th: mac dinner Inniylt. as il shouId beqmte surnth in; 86 Taylur Marsh MEJMwJuior-manll.mm Puma mum, Dc REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nielsen, Senior 1 Twitter: Renews-r ??Ongmal Message?- From: FIR I In Sam: Warranty. April ?28, In?) 216 PM To: Taylor Marsh whim: Ra' Frau: on NBC Thank n. UNCLASSIFIED Department of State Case NO. DOC No. C05351269 Date: 'IFIED US Department of State Case No. F-2012-3669?l Doc No. .-.- -- (305851342 Date: DQIZQIZD15 From: 'I'upeer1 Jab: Sent: Tinned-13y. April 29. tom 3:52 PM Tn: 36 Subject: RELEASE IN es Am not arguing. Just reminding you that some of us were fair to Madam Sea-etarv. From: FIR Sent: Thursday, April 29, 1 :44 PM To: Tapper, Jake Subject: Re: . IREVIEW AurHoeiTY: Barbara Nielsen, Senior Reviewer BB This isn?t worth arguing about . When you get new chairs, I?m sure the WH will send a cabinet member too . . .. . sm-A- u? - . L-"nn . . From: 'Tapper, Jake" Date: Thu, 29 A 1' 2010 19:29'40 +0000 To: Sent: Thu Apr 29 15:06:06 2010 Subject: Re: I35 Credit to her for not living in the past From: "Tapper, Jake? .. Date: Thu, 29 Apr 2010 19:05:25 +0000 Subject: Re: '36 .. 005851342 Date: 091292015 UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. FIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851342 Date: 09/299915 Hers didn't mention sexist and unfair coverage of the campaign In. anyFrom: FIR Sent: Thu Apr 29 15:02:45 2010 Subject: Re: Virginia already used thejoke, and it wasn't all that funny the ?rst time 'luv! a From: "Tapper, Jake? Date: Thu, 29AM 2.010 .18 57:37 +0000 To: wrote: Couple "its interesting you would assume I would ambush you with something like this when i never have and never would do such a thing. Apparently three years of working with me hasn't taught a thing. Sad. --lt?s true and you know it. ?t was giving you a head?s up that Iwas reporting this, earlier in the process than anyone else have and you reward me by Emailing my boss. I?m surprised didn't call your Mikey to put it in Playbook. whatta mensch. From: Reina. Philippe (Clinton) Sent: Monday, Deoernber 22, 2008 1:04 AM To: Glenn Thrush . . Subject: Re: Idon't think I love the 'heads up? at 10pm, which I take to mean l'll read this tomorrow So you're contention is that I am ohastising people for their negative comments and simultaneously encouraging them? Utterly absurd and completer untrue. You're about to?moye squarely Into the realm of reporting blatant lies without any regard for the truth. And the worst part is Glenn. I suspect you know that - but in your desperation to meet your montth quota of 'news' you just don?t care"nu?w - w- "h 1 -- From: Glenn Thrush To: Reines, Philippe (Clinton) 'SEntE'Su?n' 5" blast-*1 . .. . - The story about guys ordering anti ok proxies to shut up is true-- And l've'hoard the tire people urging people to he tough on slimline- i .- . UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. 005851373 Date: 0912912015 5 8 5 3 7 US. Department of State Case ND. Doc No. C058513T3 Date: 0999/2015 Jug! giving 3 beds up UNCLASSHED i175.? department of State Case No. F-2o12?36?51 Doc No. cos?'siam Date: 09:29:20?15 IED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851375 Date: 09/29/2015 horn: arolme Adler Sent: a, 2010 10.52 PM To: Philippe Reines To: Leibowich. Mark Sent: Set Mat (5 12:09:38 2010 to 8m REVIEW AUT?oliI'w: ?Barbara Nielsen. Senior Reviewer From: Reins, Philippe (Clinton) Sent: Tuesday, Decenber 30, 2008 2:55 PM To:? . Subject: Re: Moron My checking the box that I'd come in contact with livestock almost took care of that .From: Ben Smith To: Reines. Phiippe (Clinton) Sent: Tue Dec 30 14:47:58 2008 Subject: RE: Moron Well. at least I can't have you nested when the ?xghl lands BaISmith litico.oomlbl dbemnith/ 36 will B6 - ?Original Message?- From. Runes. Philippe (canton) Sent' Tue 12/30/2008 2.46 PM To: Ben Smith Subject. Moron I'm sorry Ben, you?re right. Was out of line. My npologim. Just been frustrating playing whack a mole with tlus. feels like the epitome ofpeople minglhewmstofmnot gzvingherthe bene?tofthedoubl when infect it wuss machinethateut'l?Sdeecks nutomaucally. _But you weren't the trigger. should have made my point more constructively. you would have been Open to the aplanation without the rnnung. Ilhinkyou weretherecipnauofmy displeasuxewith Delta Airlines forlhe lShour ?ightlendured Forwa'r??d Message . UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851391 Date: 09/29/2015 0 5 8 5 4 1 IED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851411 Date: Plum: Tapptr, lake Sent: mall 12, mm PM To: Hull?): Reines {pram-54: Subject: Why Wmile you rather huh: lacy clmlon do miu'bcll'thnn This Wed: with me? RELEASE IN PART 0mm BE How REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nielsen, Senior Reviewer UNCLASSIFIED us?; Department of State Case No; F-2012-36691 Doe No. cosas?? 1' ?Datei 09:29iz'b15 BB IED US. Department of State Case NO. DOC No. 005851414 Date: 099912015 . From: Tapper, Jake Sent: Saturday, March 2010 10:31 AM To: Philippe Reines Date: Sat,13 Mar 2010 14:24:55 +0000 - To: Date: Sat, 13 Mar 2010 02:06:02 H1000 - To: Subject: Fw: W-nuFrom: Le?J?vich, Mark To: Reine-.5, Philippe I Sent: Tue Mar 16 14:55:27! 2010 Subject: Best Politico piece of all lime out in A . .. . Case No. F-2012-36691 DocNo.C(15851424 Date: 09292015 0 5 8 5 4 2 US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851425 Date: 09/29/2015 From: Marlowe. Beth Sent: Tuesday, March 16. 20l0?3z32 PM - To: Philippe Reines wrote: Oh, I meant the one without mccain. Don't want repub?s messing up the Dem photo thanks - Beth Marlowe From: Philippe Reines . 86 Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 3:25 PM To: Marlowe, Beth Subject: 2 great Photos UNCLASSIFIED us. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. C05851427 Date: 09/29/2015 FIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. (305851428 Date: 0912912015 From: Marlowc, Bah Sam: Tmsdalearch Tn: . Philippe llamas 35 Subject: th0 Attach.- wm??al you and hr: wailu'ng dawn I11: lull (512': In yellow). Indy to semen grub BE ?-Ungmal Message-m- mm m: B6 S?l? The 11612010 8'33 Mulm've, Hem . mum n: Phnlo - Which mam?! Manage? Frour ?Mn-1m. Hath" lhc?Tuc. l6 Marlow l5:3 To Philippe mine: B6 Subjm-R?z?mn From; mm mam 35 Sent. Tuesday. March I To Marl-awe. [km Pholu REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nieisen, Seni? Reviawer case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851428 Date109f29f2015 0 5 8 5 4 3 US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. (305851434 Date: From: Karl. Jonathan Sam: wmhhiarch n.2qu l'l8 PM To: - Phihppz Ram-3 RELEASE IN PART I What are the odds of getting the Searetary as our guest on 1his Week on Sunday? REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nietsen, Senior Reviewer 1 Case No. Doc No. 005855434 Date109f29i2015 .. UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State 86 CO 5 8 5 4 3 6LIFIED U.S. Dgpartment of State Case No. F-2012-3669?l Doc No. (305851436 Date: 09.998015 From: Tapper, Jake 5cm: 19.2010 Tn: Philippe Subject: HRC BB RELEASE IN PART I 85..1didn'l II. Bu: dolin- mam umil augun Wnuld 105': to do it on the mad with the Sccy Kn .35 REWEW Barbara Reviewer UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No yr- Doc No. C05851436 Date: 5 IFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851438 Date: 09/29/2015 From: Ubengrj ?7 Sent: Fnday, March 19. 2010 10.50AM To: Phippe Relnes re?nessttategov Subject: from lloyd grove fldaaly beast RELEASE IN PART n: I Wm. rm wrung up 3 quick pro?le today 0! hasan nemazeo. wpponec 0! Secretary Clinton Would she have anything to say abou hum? ml lion REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nielsen, Senior @eviewer 0. C05851438 Date: 09/29/2015 . US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc - 83% FIED US. Department of State Case No. Dec No. 005851439 Date: 091290015 From: Tapper. Jake Sent: Friday, Man]: 19, 2010 7'23 PM To: Philip}: Reine: Subject: Re HRC RELEASE IN PART marl Any good mp: pier-led Ion-1" Either way weal-t1 low to have her :11 I guest smellme slum -- Origins! Fran. PER. 4pm: To. Tapper. Jake . up com: Sent: Fri Mar 1919:1141? Semen: Re: Inmaumnlime. REVIEW AUTHORITY: Barbara Nietsen. Senior Reviewer .. .- UNCLASSIFIED US. Department of State Case No. F-2012-36691 Doc No. 005851439 Date: 0912912015 BS 86 FIED US. Department of State Case No. Doc No. (305851440 Date: 09/29/2015 From: Tapper, Jake Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 7:31 PM To: Philippe Reincsl . BS Subject: Re: HRC RELEASE IN PART Wuuld gladly. go In any of lime: iu her for TW 55 O?gmel Mama Fram: FIR