POLICE DEPARTMENT
.   a  LEGAL BUREAU
6197' F.O.I.L. Unit, Room 110C
0{ One Police Plaza

W??fm New York, New York 10038

October 27, 2015

Shawn Musgrave
MuckRock News
DEPT MR 15845
PO. Box 55819
Boston, MA 02205

RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAW
REQUEST: LBF 

Dear Mr. Musgrave:

This letter is in further response to your letter dated February 4, 2015, requesting
disclosure, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law of ?all 24-hour and 90-day
shooting incident reports completed from January 1, 2010 through December 31, 2014.? This
letter is also pursuant to the remand of this matter to the undersigned as noted in the Records
Access Appeals Of?cer?s October 8, 2015 appeal determination.

Your request is granted to the extent that the requested records will be disclosed subject
to redaction and withholding of material that is exempt from disclosure under FOIL. The
requested records contain identifying details regarding shooting incidents that are exempt from
disclosure pursuant to Public Of?cers Law (POL) Section 87(2)(f) because disclosure thereof
could endanger the safety of any person, and pursuant to POL Section 87(2)(b) because
disclosure thereof would create an unwarranted invasion of privacy. Also, disclosure of some of
the requested material would interfere with ongoing investigations and/or judicial proceedings,
and, therefore, is exempt from disclosure pursuant to POL Section In addition, some of
the requested material is used to evaluate of the performance of a police of?cer in connection
with continued employment or promotion, and, therefore, barred from disclosure by Civil Rights
Law Section 50-a. Moreover, some of the requested material is exempt from disclosure pursuant
to POL Section 87(2)(g) because the information is non-?nal, intra?agency, and pre-decisional,
and pursuant to POL Section 87 to the extent that disclosure thereof would reveal non-
routine criminal investigative techniques or procedures.

It is estimated that the copying fee for preparation of the requested copies, including
redaction and copying thereof, is $42,000. Preparation of the copies will commence upon receipt
of payment of in the form of a check or money order in the amount of $42,000, payable to New
York City Police Department. Payment should be mailed to Records Access Of?cer, One Police
Plaza, Room 110C, New York, New York 10038. Please note the ?le number, 15PL1411, on

your payment.

You may appeal this decision in writing, within thirty (30) days of the date of this
letter. Any appeal should be addressed to Mr. Jonathan David, Records Access Appeals
Of?cer, NYPD, One Police Plaza, Room 1406, New York, NY 1003 8-1497.

Sincerely, 
0? a/
Richard antellino

Lieutenant
Records Access Of?cer