U. S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation O?iCe offlie Chief?rvision Counsel 1 DOWBH Springs Knoxville, Tennessee 37909 July 16,2015 Neely Callaghan Attn: Richard Neely, Esq. 159 Summers Street Charleston, West Virginia 25301-2134 RE: Touhy Letter on Behalf of John Stanton Verble Dear Mr. Neely: In June, 2012, John Stanton Verble began voluntarily providing information to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) related to allegations of possible insider trading involving his employer, Morgan Stanley. On August 28, 2012, the FBI and the Internal Revenue Service traveled to Atlanta, Georgia and met with the US. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to discuss potential investigative matters, including the information provided by Verble. Sincerely, Edward Reinhold Special Agent in Charge is? 41.4,- Andrew Fisher Special Agent