UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ENIGMA SOFTWARE GROUP USA, LLC, Case No. 1:16-cv-00057 (PAE) -against- BLEEPING COMPUTER LLC and DOES 1-10? FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT Defendants. Plaintiff Enigma Software Group USA, LLC by its attorneys, for its First Amended Complaint against Defendants Bleeping Computer LLC (?Bleeping?) and Does 1-10, respectfully alleges as follows: SUMMARY OF THE CASE 1. This is an action for civil remedies, including injunctive relief and damages, under the federal Lanham Act and under New York State law, arising out of the malicious publication in this District of false, disparaging, and defamatory statements by Bleeping and Does 1-10 regarding ESG and its SpyHunter software product. 2. Bleeping owns and operates a website at (the ?Bleeping Website?) that Bleeping tells the public is a ?technical support site and a self- education tool for the novice user to learn basic concepts about Computer Technology.? 3. In reality, Bleeping uses the Bleeping Website to promote and recommend products for which it receives commissions and pushes users to those products through hyperlinks that, with only a few clicks, take a user from the Bleeping Website to the websites of the product seller from whom Bleeping receives a commission. And upon information and belief, such sales have been generated in this District. 4. One of the products Bleeping promotes -- and a product it receives commissions for selling -- is sold by Malwarebytes, an ESG competitor. 5. Bleeping does not receive and has never received commissions from ESG. 6. Thus, Bleeping has a direct financial interest in driving traffic and sales to Malwarebytes and driving traffic and sales away from ESG. 7. To further that interest, Bleeping has intentionally disparaged ESG and its products while simultaneously recommending that its ?novice? forum members use Malwarebytes programs for which it admittedly is paid a commission. 8. Bleeping not only has unlawfully bene?ted from its smear campaign to the detriment of ESG, it has damaged the reputation of ESG by refusing to take down its false and misleading statements which have been reposted numerous times on other anti-spyware related forums and websites. 9. ESG brings this lawsuit to put an end to the smear campaign it has unjusti?ably endured at the hands of Bleeping and its associates. THE PARTIES 10. Plaintiff ESG is a Connecticut limited liability company. ESG does business in this District, but none of members is a resident or citizen of the State of New York. 11. Upon information and belief, Defendant Bleeping is a New York limited liability company with a business address at PO. Box 1025, Melville, New York 11747. 12. Upon information and belief, Defendants Does 1?10 are entities and individuals that have acted on behalf of or in conjunction with Bleeping in carrying out the acts complained of herein. JURISDICTION AND VENUE 13. This action arises under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1051 et seq. and the laws of the State of New York. This Court has subject matterjurisdiction, inter alia, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1331, 1332, 1338, and 1367. 14. Venue is proper in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1391. LCTS Background 15. ESG develops and markets computer security products with a particular focus on protecting its millions of customers from malware and other security threats. 16. As described by the Federal Trade Commission ?[m]alware, short for ?malicious software,? includes viruses and spyware that can steal personal information, send spam, and commit fraud. Criminals use appealing websites, desirable downloads, and compelling stories to lure consumers to links that will download malware especially on computers that don?t use adequate security software. Spyware is one type of malware that can monitor or control your computer use. It may be used to send consumers pop-up ads, redirect their computers to unwanted websites, monitor their Internet sur?ng, or record their keystrokes, which, in turn, could lead to identity theft.? l7. ESG protects its customers from these risks by providing software that detects and removes malware, enhances Internet privacy, and eliminates other security threats. 18. ?agship anti-malware product is a software program called SpyHunter, which presently is in version 4. l9. ESG sells licenses to SpyHunter solely over the Internet, including at its website, ESG enjoys worldwide sales of SpyHunter, including sales to citizens of the State of New York. 20. SpyHunter is an adaptive spyware detection and removal tool that provides rigorous protection against the latest spyware threats including malware, Trojans, rootkits, and other malicious software. Consumers can download a free scanning version of SpyHunter through a link entitled ?Download Free Scanner.? The scanner detects whether a computer has malware or other threats. 22. E86 informs consumers that they also have the choice to buy a license to the full version of SpyHunter and provides consumers with a ?Buy Now? link. The full version of SpyHunter includes the scanner, tools to remove malware and other security protection tools. 23. SpyHunter product has received top industry certi?cations. 24. SpyHunter has received the Checkmark Certi?cation from West Coast Labs. Checkmark Certi?cation is a highly regarded accreditation program, recognized globally by vendors, end users, and government agencies as providing reliable confirmation of a product?s effectiveness in an ever-changing threat landscape. Checkmark Certification validates the functionality and performance of both content and network security technologies in a range of threat scenarios and attack vectors from standard baseline benchmarking tests against accepted industry standards. 25. ESG is a Better Business Bureau accredited business. Better Business Bureau accreditation standards include a ?commitment to make a good faith effort to resolve any consumer complaints.? ESG has received an rating from the Better Business Bureau. Bleeping Is A Commercial Enterprise That Earns Commissions By Peddling Products 26. Defendant Bleeping holds itself out as an expert in computer security matters. 27. Upon information and belief, Bleeping and its members are not computer security experts, but rather they are software resellers purporting to give consumer advice. 28. Bleeping controls the Bleeping Website which is divided into several sections: (1) News; (2) Downloads; (3) Virus Removal Guides; (4) Tutorials; (5) Deals; (6) Forums; and (7) More. 29. In the ?About BleepingComputer? portion of its website, which can be accessed only from a link at the very bottom of the Bleeping Website, BSC explains that it uses ?Af?liate Links? that ?generate a commission for [Bleeping] if [a user] use[s] them to purchase a product.? See Ex. 1. 30. Upon information and belief, Bleeping generally does not include this disclosure elsewhere on the Bleeping Website, including on its security forums. 31. To create Af?liate Links, Bleeping uses a program called ?Viglinks? that automatically transforms posted links and certain keywords into af?liate links. 32. By providing Af?liate Links, Bleeping earns a commission if a consumer simply clicks on the link and then clicks on a link to purchase the product that Bleeping is peddling. 33. Bleeping pushes consumers to products that earn them commissions through its ?Virus Removal Guides,? which ?use programs and utilities that generate commissions for [Bleeping] when [a user] purchase[s] them.? See Ex. 1. Upon information and belief, Bleeping does not disclose its self?interest in the products used in its Virus Removal Guides within the Guides themselves. 34. In its ?Downloads? section, Bleeping provides ?special offers and af?liate links that will generate a commission for [Bleeping] if [the user] purchase[s] the software.? See Ex. 1. Upon information and belief, Bleeping does not disclose its self-interest in the products that Bleeping provides in the Download section the Bleeping Website. 35. Similarly, Bleeping provides Tutorials that ?may discuss or require speci?c hardware or software that contain af?liate links that will generate a commission for [Bleeping] if [a user] purchase[s] them.? See Ex. 1. Upon information and belief, Bleeping does not disclose its self-interest in the products used in its Tutorials within the Tutorials themselves. 36. Bleeping uses Af?liate Links not only in the Virus Removal Guides, Downloads, and Tutorials sections that it offers consumers, but also on its messages boards where users comment on and post information about topics related to computer technology. 37. Notably, Bleeping admits in its ?About Us? section that ?the products that we [Bleeping] routinely use in our guides and that we receive af?liate commissions from are MalwareBytes, Emsisoft, and SuperAntiSpyware.? See Ex. 1. Bleeping And Its Moderators Control, Directly And/Or Indirectly, The Content On Message Boards 38. As part of controlling, directly and/or indirectly, the forum on the Bleeping Website, Bleeping has established a hierarchy of ?member groups? that informs users of the forum about the status of person who is posting, including whether they are a designee to act on behalf of Bleeping. See EX. 2. 39. Bleeping provides its members with a ?current list? of the users who are in each ?member group.? 40. The highest level ?member group? is ?Admin Site Admins.? Lawrence Abrams, the owner of Bleeping, is the overall ?Admin? ofthe Bleeping Website and forums and has the ?nal say when appointing all other staff positions. 41. The second-highest level ?member group? is ?Global Moderator Moderators.? 42. Bleeping holds Global Moderators out to its members as follows: A Bleeping Computer Global Moderator or Moderator is someone granted special powers by the Admins to enforce the rules of Bleeping Computer Forums. All moderators on all forums can move discussions to different sections of the forum, ?close? discussions to prevent users from continuing to discuss them, as well as edit the content of individual posters. Moderators of both levels answer questions (or help people with problems), and ?pin? discussions so they remain visible in their forum section even if no new postings are made to them. Global Moderators have a few additional powers above that of regular Moderators, the most important of which is the ability to suspend forum posting privileges of members who violate forum rules. See Ex. 2. 43. Upon information and belief, Bleeping?s Global Moderators are expected to post on Bleeping?s message boards and when a Global Moderator makes a posting, Bleeping clearly identifies that the post has been made by a Global Moderator. 44. Upon information and belief, currently there are only three Global Moderators. 45. One of Bleeping?s Global Moderators is known as ?Quietman7.? 46. In March 2006, Bleeping announced to its users that it had appointed Quietman7 as an advisor -- the third-highest ?member group? on the Bleeping website. See Ex. 3. 47. Bleeping made the announcement with a post entitled ?New Advisor--quietman7? in which Bleeping stated: ?Quietman7 has quietly been added to the staff here at BC [Bleeping Computer] as an advisor. Now we can shout a warm Congratulations, welcome, and thanks for becoming an even larger asset for BC [Bleeping See Ex. 3. 48. Mr. Abrams responded to the March 2006 post by congratulating Quietman7 and thanking him ?for accepting the position? to which Quietman7 responded ?it is a pleasure to be part ofthe BC [Bleeping Computer] staffSeptember 2007, Mr. Abrams himself created a post entitled ?Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman7? in which he announced to Bleeping?s message board users that Quietman7 had accepted the ?position, of Global Moderator here at BC [Bleeping ComputerQuietman7 responded to the announcement as follows: Thanks everyone and thanks Grinler [Abrams? username] for offering the sentence I mean position. There are not many [web]sites who will give an ex-cop, now a ?Bleepin? Janitor? the keys to the kingdom. Usually I only get the keys to the broom closet and back door so I can take out the trash. Bleeping Makes False And Defamatory Statements Both Directly And Indirectly About 51. ESG And Its SpyHunter Product In the forums that Bleeping maintains on its website, Bleeping, and in particular posts by Bleeping?s appointed Global Moderator, Quietman7, purport to convey factual information about ESG and its products, but instead assert outright falsehoods that are repeated in multiple topics on the forum and over multiple years. See Exs. 5-7. In these posts, Bleeping makes the following assertions falsely and without any reasonable basis to believe that the statements were true when made: That SpyHunter 4 or ESG engage in ?deceptive advertising which violates several consumer protection laws in many states?; That SpyHunter 4 or ESG has a ?history of employing aggressive and deceptive advertising?; That SpyHunter 4 is a ?rogue product?; That SpyHunter 4 or ESG have not cooperated in submitting their program for testing ?most likely due to the program?s ineffectiveness and high rate of false positives?; That SpyHunter 4 or ESG engage in deceptive pricing; That most users of SpyHunter 4 ?are not aware that when purchasing SpyHunter, they have agreed to a subscription service with an automatic renewal policy?; and That SpyHunter 4 is ?malware? or ?rogue security software? despite not being classi?ed as such by security vendors. See Exs. 5-7. 52. Each of those statements is false and was false when made. 53. Upon information and belief, Bleeping and Quietman7 have never tested SpyHunter4 to determine the effectiveness of the program or its rate of false positives. 54. Bleeping knew, or should have known, that the statements were false when made. The statements rely upon third-hand information that is between 7-10 years old and that was generated by a group of individuals who began an anticompetitive campaign against ESG in 2004. 55. ESG spent years engaging these individuals in discourse, providing full and accurate information to them, which the individuals admitted they did not have, and ultimately proving each claim to be false. 56. Upon information and belief, Bleeping knew or should have known that ESG already proved these claims false years before Bleeping made them. 57. Nonetheless, Bleeping has used and continues to use these false and disparaging statements for its own economic benefit. 58. In same paragraph in which Bleeping falsely tells its users that SpyHunter4 is a ?dubious program with a high rate of false positives,? Bleeping instructs its users to ?remove? SpyHunter and ?replace it? with Malwarebytes? software. 59. In connection with instructing users to replace SpyHunter4 with Malewarebytes? software, Bleeping provides a single hyperlink for Malwarebytes? website that, if clicked, takes a user directly to the page where the user can click one more link to purchase Malewarebytes? competing product. Once purchased, Bleeping earns its ?Affiliate Commission.? 60. Upon information and belief, the webpage hosts additional false and defamatory articles and third-party comments solicited by the false and defamatory statements made by Bleeping. 61. Upon information and belief, Defendants Does 1?10 have carried out the aforesaid acts at the direction of, on behalf of, and with full knowledge of Bleeping. 62. These postings by Defendants are all the more egregious as they represent a clear pattern of making false and unsubstantiated claims, including salacious claims of violations of consumer protection laws which can carry criminal penalties, over multiple topics, in multiple areas of the forum, over a period of multiple years. 63. ESG, through counsel, has sent a written demand to Bleeping to cease and desist its unlawful conduct, but it has refused to do so. 64. Bleeping not only has refused to take down the offending post, but Bleeping and Quietman7 have given permission to others to post the false information on other forums, causing further harm to ESG. 65. Defendants? conduct is willful and malicious. 66. Upon information and belief, Defendants? unlawful conduct is causing and will continue to cause harm to ESG and its products. 67. ESG has no adequate remedy at law for certain of the relief requested below. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION (Violations of Lanham Act 43(a)) 68. ESG repeats and incorporates by reference all of the foregoing paragraphs as if fully set forth herein. 69. Defendants? publication of false and misleading statements about ESG and SpyHunter constitutes false advertising in violation of 15 U.S.C. 1 70. Defendants? publication of false statements about ESG and SpyHunter is likely to deceive consumers as to the nature and quality of ESG and SpyHunter, including causing 10 consumers to believe that SpyHunter itself is a form of malware. 71. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants? unlawful acts, ESG has suffered and will continue to suffer signi?cant monetary and reputational injury in amounts that will be proven at trial but that are believed to exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION (Trade Libel/Commercial Disparagement) 72. ESG repeats and incorporates by reference all of the foregoing paragraphs as if fully set forth herein. 73. Defendants have maliciously published false statements that disparage ESG and its SpyHunter product. 74. These statements constitute injurious falsehoods and trade libel, which inter alia impugn the integrity of ESG and the quality of SpyHunter. These statements were expressly directed at ESG. 75. Defendants have published their false statements to the public by means of the Internet and speci?cally the Bleeping Website. 76. There can be no question that the readers of Defendants? statements understand Defendants? defamatory meaning and understand that Defendants? statements are directed at ESG and its products. 77. ESG has been specifically harmed by Defendants? defamatory statements. 78. Defendants have no privilege to make their false and harmful statements. 79.- As a direct and proximate result of Defendants? unlawful acts, ESG has suffered and will continue to suffer significant monetary and reputational injury in amounts that will be proven at trial but that are believed to exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. 11 THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION (Defamation) 80. ESG repeats and incorporates by reference all of the foregoing paragraphs as if fully set forth herein. 81. Defendants? published statements concerning ESG and SpyHunter are false and bring ESG into disrepute or contempt and impeach its integrity and reputation. Speci?cally, Defendants assert, inter alia, that ESG engages in ?deceptive advertising which violates several consumer protection laws?; that ESG ?has a history of employing aggressive and deceptive advertising?; and that SpyHunter 4 is a ?rogue product.? 82. Defendants have published their false statements to the public by means of the Internet and speci?cally, at least the Bleeping Website. 83. Defendants are at fault because they maliciously made such statements. 84. Defendants have no privilege to make such statements. 85. ESG has been and continues to be damaged by these statements. 86. ESG is a for-profit corporation, and Defendants? statements prejudice ESG in the conduct of its business and/or to deter others from dealing with it. 87. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants? unlawful acts, ESG has suffered and will continue to suffer signi?cant monetary and reputational injury in amounts that will be proven at trial but that are believed to exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. PRAYER FOR RELIEF WHEREFORE, ESG respectfully requests that the Court enter judgment in its favor as follows: a. Declaring that Defendants? conduct violates 15 U.S.C. 1125(a); b. Declaring that Defendants? conduct constitutes trade libel and/or 12 commercial disparagement under the laws of the State of New York; 0. Declaring that Defendants? conduct constitutes defamation of a corporation under the laws of the State of New York; d. Permanently enjoining Defendants from publishing the false advertising statements identi?ed above in relation to e. Permanently enjoining Defendants from publishing the statements constituting trade libel and/0r commercial disparagement identified above in relation to f. Permanently enjoining Defendants from publishing the statements constituting defamation of a corporation identi?ed above in relation to g. Awarding ESG damages in an amount proven at trial and believed to be in excess of $75,000, plus interest; h. Awarding ESG its attorneys? fees and costs incurred in bringing this action; and i. Awarding such other and further relief as the Court deems proper. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ESG demands atrial by jury of all issues so triable in this action. Dated: New York, New York Respectfully submitted, January 8, 2016 By: Eric A. Prager Eric A. Prager (BF-0964) GATES LLP 599 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10022 Telephone: 212.536.3900 Facsimile: 212.536.3901 eric.prager@klgates.com Attorneys for Plaintl?fs 13 Exhibit 1 . avian m< aa?tmmegs gm 5de . . . .gvagoscg??ri a: ma??uggwg w. .S 3.x. ~32? mg ??32?;ng . dam zo?dquZmIde EOPUAE 03h .H. van ?4.2m . .12. $42.1 a $2.3 no $5.3m 3 ?.aey?a?? 3.930. . .., ?in A 31cc 53.6.. 2. . 55.3 h. .. Haw. .. 3 $2.11.:M6ru 3 . ivgx sit; "a 2m. .u T. .o 920m .. mung . #233 x. id c. .3 its. as}: . ?gap it. . tinge; . my; why.an I. 5:5 32539 . a. (.25xvi; . w. ?3 .5. 596$ ?gume @5238 a f& ?Zita5.3 1.523. .33 . n31 ?33m gei?vfiuu?r?o ii}; M. .6 Ear. a iv :3 my: ?b ?33 tuna?:2. .. 36 wgvlaa wait?: 9.34% 33:! a 3231 .u rd an?? . . . . . 52w ?Ei?g?ig??soz 13.5 $5Mme :2 tut .aqxxau?m 2.8% .. 5.. . v. .16 mum mini w. lawn? an. J. #:314 .E?oun?? 3.52? 1.3 Max}; :32 ?an any.? 162.? v6 my $3 51.x? 5 ?5.3 #3 .E . xii. who 253.2.9.2: 2.3wanws? v52 Q.qu $5 ?P?uwca??ha $5 .Q?kaE kw 54" {venucp/xn?w ?zz maria/3. maoiw?.? . .. 3.0.5. 3.2.1" .93 .avxxk." 5 .uecm 3.. 3.3.. at: run v. m3. xv fixing Ext 5.2qu . 93545 as a. . ?r3, x. if. . ?ayes233 .513 aging. in}: :53 Emma .w v?mw??x w? .934 ?$wi Emma 932 22.. .. Exhibit 2 Bleeping Computer Membership Descriptions - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions BteepingComputercom Members Tutoriats Startup List Forum Rules View New Content 9? BteepingComputercom General Topics ?a BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions Welcome to BIeepingComputer, a free community where people" likefyoursetf come together todiscuss and'learn; bow. to use their computers. Using the asks is easy and fun. As a guest, you can browse and view the various discussions inthe forums," but can not: create a new topic or repty to an existing one unless you are logged in. Other bene?ts of registering an topics and forums, creatihga blog, and having no ads shown anywhere on the siteClick-hereto Register a free account now! or read our Welcome Guide to learn how to use this; site. Bleeping Computer Membership Descriptions Animal . Feb i351": 1255;}? 32:" A Animal 7 .. meets?? Animinlon {Lift February 22:9: 52:32.23.? A common question we receive on the site is from people wondering what the various members groups are and how they can join them. As a service to our members we have created this post to answer these questions. The Bleeping Computer Member groups and descriptions are as follows: Admin Site Admins Site Admin The Bleeping Computer Owner, and overall Admin of the site and forums. is Grinler. Grinler. or Lawrence Abrams, manages the operational aspects of Bleeping Computer. Grinler is the highest ranking Staff Member, followed by the I Gender? Male Site Admins. The Admins have the final say when appointing all other staff positions and are involved in approving Location: vt?here You tea-st Expect Me "lo Be Local time: 03:33 PM Malware Response Trainee/Team candidates. The Admin(s) handle all aspects of the site's day-to?day operations. This includes setting configuration options, managing user accounts, and fixing site problems. The Admin(s) are also responsible for virtually all of the inner workings of the forum software features. The Admins are the final arbiter in any decisions affecting the Bleeping Computer forums operational aspect. The current list of Admins can be found ?ww?hgnu Global Moderators Moderators A Bleeping Computer Global Moderator or Moderator is someone granted special powers by the Admins to enforce the rules of Bleeping Computer Forums. All moderators on all forums can move discussions to different sections of the forum, "close" discussions to prevent users from continuing to discuss them, as well as edit the content of individual postings. Moderators of both levels answer questions (or help people with problems), and "pin" discussions so they remain visible in their forum section even if no new postings are made to them. Global Moderators have a few additional powers above that of regular Moderators, the most important of which is the ability to suspend forum posting 15 3:33:54 Bleeping Computer MemberShip Descriptions - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions privileges of members who violate forum rules. The current list of Global Moderators can be found -The current list of Moderators can be found here. Bleeping Computer Advisor Bleeping Computer Advisors are regular forum contributors who have been nominated by other current Advisors or other members of the staff as a result of their consistently high quality and expert responses to people's questions in the forums; Advisors can be trusted to give correct and understandable answers to our member's questions. Advisors also assist the Moderators with overseeing that the forum is running properly, and smoothly. The current list of Bleeping Computer Advisors can be found here. Malware Response Instructor A Bleeping Computer Malware Response Instructor is a Malware Response Team member who has been selected by the Admin(s) to teach the trainees about computer security and how to use specialized tools for malware removal and analysis. The Instructors also play a pivotal role in determining how the trainee program evoives. Trainees look to a Malware Response Instructor for advice and guidance throughout the course. Instructors have moderator capabilities In all Malware removal related forums, including the Study Hall. The Team instructors have the job of deciding when trainees have sufficiently proven they are ?Malware Response Team" material, and make recommendations to the Admins when such a time has come. The current list of Maiware Response Instructors can be found here. Malware Response Team Member A Bleeping Computer Malware Response Team Member is a volunteer who has permission to respond to Maiware removal logs in the Bleeping Computer Malware removal forum. These members have proven themselves to be highly quali?ed in the removal of malware and are thus given permission to help people with spwvare removal via Malware removal logs. A Malware Response Team Member has moderator abitities in Malware removal related forums allowing them to open, close, or merge topics together. The main ethos of the group is the word "team"; these volunteers will often ask various other team members for help if needed. As staff members. the team often works with the moderators by reporting spam posts or informing of members who have broken the site rules. The Malware Response Team members also play a part in the running of the Study Hall. where they are encouraged to answer the questions posted by trainees. The current list of Malware Response Team members can be found Malware Study Hall Admin A Bleeping Computer Malware Study Hall Admin oversees the Malware Response Instructors as well as the trainees along with managing the curriculum and learning tools for the Malware Removal Training program. The Study Hall Admin is the staff member who promotes the trainees as they progress through the stages of the Study Hail using input from the Instructor team. They also handle the requests to join the Study Hall with the help ofthe Admin team. The current list of Malware Study Hall Admins can be found here. Malware Trainees A Bleeping Computer Malware Study Hall Trainee is a member who has volunteered and has been accepted to join the Bleeping Computer Malware Study Hall training program, which involves gaining the knowledge and studying the theory behind the analysis of Malware removal logs, with the aim of eventually joining the Malware Response Team when Admins and Malware Response Instructors feel they have reached a sufficient level of ability. A trainee has no [12/ 7/2015 3:33:54 Bleeping Computer Membership Descriptions - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions moderator privileges. The trainee program is split up into three groups, the "Malware Study Hall Sophomore", the "Malware Study Hall Junior" and the "Maiware Study Hall Senior". An explanation of the three groups follows. While the distinctions are very fine, all trainees work in a community, with the aim of helping each other in their goal to join the Malware Response Team. Malware Study Hall Sophomore A Malware Study Hall Sophomore is a trainee in the use of specialized malware removal applications at the entry level. They work on understanding the basics of security and become familiarized with the basic tools of the trade. This is where all new trainees start theirjourney. The current list of Malware Study Hall Sophomores can be found beta. Malware Study Hall Junior A Maiware Study Hall Junior is a trainee that has progressed to the intermediate levet. After the basics have been covered and the trainees become more familiar with the tools and the theory, they are moved up to Junior level. That is where the practical aspect of the program is applied. These trainees work actively with the instructing staff and other Team members on example logs and exercises to help them further thei;r learning. When they have reached the end of this part of the program with satisfaction, they are moved up to the next level. The current list of Malware Study Hall Juniors can be found here. Malware Study Hall Senior A Bleeping Computer Malware Study Hall Senior has proven that he or she is dedicated to the task at hand, and has shown promising signs of progressing through the trainee program. These trainees work actively with the instructors and other team members and you will find them on the open forums hetping members with problems under the assistance and supervision of instructors. That is where they can get the real world experience they need before they are given Team member status. Once the admins and instructing staff are satisfied that they are ready, they are moved up to Malware Response Team member status. The current list of Malware Study Hall Seniors can be found Member A Bleeping Computer Member is someone who registers and validates their membership and utilizes the site to their advantage. Some members are active participants while others are not as active; but all members are vafued for whatever they bring to the forum/site and community at large. It is not a requirement of membership to be active on the forums. Banned Member A Bleeping Computer Banned member is someone who has violated the terms of use of Bleeping Computer in such manner that it is deemed necessary for the protection of the site and the membership to ban the member. Being banned removes the ability to View or post or interact with Bleeping Computer in any manner. Deactivated Member A deactivated member is one who has asked to have their account deactivated. When this occurs we place the user in this group, change their password to a random one, and remove all topic or forum subscriptions. In the future if they would like to reactivate their account they can notify us. ?dited by Animai, ?t3 May 2014 ~01:$3 PM. Ctanfy Adviser nomination process. The Internet is so big, so powerful and pointless that for- some people it is a complete substitute for life. 7/2015 3:33 :54 Bleeping Computer Membership Descriptions - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions Andrew Brown (1938- 1994) Annihilth A immng uxgmfem?e is one qfthoxe {kings 0'73: in}: "You know rim! ?ring 'l'rmju? 5121?? Don?t do (hint Dwight fidamr gi?53-Zd0lj "M?dummw?x i? ?mm imi'mm?? 1: Iimlit?i! limtgin?lion (?flf?k?a (he (Hiker! [filmem {1379-4055} Follow on: i ?xagiw. magnet 'iL?gi?- i-o Remake} BleepingCOmputer.oom Register to remove ads Back to BieepingComputer Announcements, Comments: Suggestions 1 user(s) are reading this topic 0 members: 1' guests, 0 anonymous users BleepingCompoieream General Topics BieepingCompuler Announcements. Comments. Suggestions Ruies I Privacy Policy - Help I Advertise About Us UserAgreement l- Piivacy Policy-'13 Sitemap i Chat 3 RSS Feeds Contact Us HuTech-Siipport'Forums Virus RemovaiGuides 5 Downloads Tutorials The Computer Glossary} 'Uninslall List Startups The File Database}: 2004-2015 Au. Rights Reserved Bleeping Computer Silo: Changeiog . Community Forum Software by W?oord [12/ 1 7/20 1 5 3:33:54 Exhibit 3 New Advisor--quiennan7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions a Sign In I BleepingComputercom Forums Members Tutoriais Startup List More 7 - Forum Rules View New Content 9 BteepingComputerLom m? Geno-rat Topics BieepingComputer Announcements. Comments??Suggestions Weicome'to BieepingComputer, a free community where people like yourself come: together to'discuss- and learn how to use their computers. Using the site is-easy and fun. As a guest. you can browse aodaview theivarious giscussions-in_ the forums, but can not create a new topic or reply to an existing one uniess you are logged in. Other bene?ts of registering anV'acmunt-aresuoscfibing'to topics and forums, creating a blog, and having no ads shown anywhere on the site - Click here to Register a free account nowteor reaci"'our Welcome Guide to learn how to use this site. Advisor--quietman7 i waoemo MaiE?i "20:65 Ne NEXT Ptease log in to repiy Papakid r- Guru at being; 3 Newbie Ma?a -- Quietman7 has quietly been added to the staff here at BC as an advisor. Now we can shout a warm Congratulations, welcome, and thanks for becoming an even larger asset for f: :a i as; :2 Gender: Mate Local time: 05:31 PM BC AoBot {Login to Remove) - ieepingComputer.com Register to remove ads - #2 ?Grinier 4 Lawrence Abrams i'io'steo' .4. Mat?d?i 2er -- t?z? 2333!: Congrats quietman. First i want to thank you for accepting the position and second I want to wish you a big welcome 3:32:16 New Advisor-?quierrnan7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions in?nite- Gender: Male Location: USA Local time: 06:31 PM acHan aleepin' cat?s meow Members .A A Mew Gender: Not Location: Eaton Rouge= La. Local time: 06:31 PM Pandy Members rm. 93x33 posts Gender: Fema?e Local time: 07781 PM onsaevr Members 53312 paste Lawrence Abrams Become a BEeapingComputer fan: 5am MW Everyone should do this! Everyone must read this? rn #3 w: 23 its-tarantt at}! Congratulations quietman7. Good to have you on the team. (so? (EGGS is: any?: *4 A ?Ha; y. .5 4.4x} 3th A: (if-in qt, QuietmanTl! lwould just like to thank you so very much for accepting us at BC, for taking part and contributing so much here. Do not anticipate trouble, or worry about what may never happen. Keep in the sunlight. Hide not your talents. They for use were made. What's a sundial in the shade? Benjamin Franklin I am a Bleeping Computer fan! Are you? maggots. Wining: -, 5-) ,L?f meat-3s?: time-?6; . Congrats on your promotion, [12/ 17/2015 3:32:16 Us New Advisor?-quiet1nan7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions Gender: Femaie Location: East Coast Local time: (37:31 PM -David- Members 16,603 posts Gender: Male Location: London Local time: 32:31 AM jgweed Staff Emeritus Gender: Male Location: Chicago, ii. Local time: 06:15?: PM quietman?? Sleepin' Janitor Mm: :55: Global Moderator Gender: Male Location: Virginia. USA Local time: PM 7; Scarlett Posted 21 March 2005 'ittri?} Mil Hi quietman7ll What a superb choice and i warmiy welcome you to the team thanks for using your expertise to help others, and i hope you continue doing so! You are an asset to BleepingComputer, and thanks for all the wonderful security news you have given us. David U. . ,v an?, vested A ?vaamir ace-:2 i am always pleased to see someone of your talents receive a well-deserved recognition, QuietmanT, and want to add my thanks, as well, for all that you contribute towards making BC what it is. Congratulations. John Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one shoutd be silent. stars?; a 2:26 Fit-ii Posted 2? March :1 Thanks everyone for the warm welcome. It is a pleasure to be part of the BC staff and I look forward to working with you all. Best regards (Russ) Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2015 Member of Liking Uni?ed Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators A ss- 3:32: 16 New Advisor--quietman7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions -v 01:47 Bleeping, Diva Posted 21 quietman, I am just so very pleased that you have accepted. Welcome to the staff. Members 7479 posts Gender: Female Location: As always l?m beside myself Local time: 06:31 PM sienan'ger Congrats quietman?r'. Well deserved Members Olivier an.? . ?3:13) Location: France Local time: 01:31 AM qumnnan7.y Bleepin' Janitor Thank you Scarlett and Olivier. Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2015 Global Moderator Member of Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators Location: ?Jitylaa? USA Local time: 05 (-31 PM Joshuaoat" 01001010 01000011 2: eta-mm 063.42 Congrats? JC BC Adviser 3:32:16 #10 #11 #12; mt; New Advisor--quietman7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions poets Gender: Male Location: Ontario, Canada Local time: 07:31 PM "mama BEeepin' Conundrum Staff Emerit US Gender: Male Location: 86 mites due East of the "2Loglc Free Zone", in Md, USA Local time: 07:31 PM phang Learning Daily Members 3341') 2'39323; Location: USA Local time: 03:31 PM ?ohn Members posts Local time: 07:31 PM 3:32: 16 Posted 21 March 0 Thanks again Quietman? for all you do here at the "fee ort?v easy claw a, A: - a, ., . RAGmatch "aim; -- i-r As I stumble ever onward gaining information, it's nice to know quiet words of caution, catculated appraisais and advice to others will continue now, with Quietman? BC Advisor ever watchful to help. Thank You! stei?entiy paie'o?ltng, ptertfy of gsersisant {3%8'33 n? tenements Congrats Quietman? Please be patient in not private they Wm a post ii on the board. Fm; c. woessm' . as} New Advisor--quietman7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions mm 1 a? 2 2 NEXT Back to BleepingComputer Announcements. Comments, Suggestions 0 user(s) are reading this topic 0 members? 0 guests, 0 anonymous users BleepingComputer.com Genera! Tagaics - BEeepingCompufar Announcements. Comments, 6: Suggestions Ruies - Privacy Pciicy Adver?ise Aboutucs" Sitemap I chat'f'gi?Rss F??jad?' p;..cmactfus{ Ted} Suppori Forums Virus RemovalGuEde3 Oownfoads 5: Tutori??s'] The Computer Glosmry Unihstall List Siartubs The File Database 2004 Ail Righis Reserved Bieeping Compu?er LLC Site Changelog Ccmmunify qum Sa?wzgre by 3:32: 16 Exhibit 4 Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman7 - BleepingComputer Announcements. Comments, Suggestions This topic BleepingComputercom Forums Members I Tutorials Startup List More .v Forum Rules View New Content 9 BleepingCompu-ter.com General Tonics BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments. Welcome to BieepmgComputer, a free community where people; like yourself come together to discuss and team how to use their computers. Usmg the e. site is easy and fun. As a guest. you can browse'an?d' view the variousdiscussione'in the forums, but can netcreatej a new topic'orj reply teen existing ?a one unless you are logged in. Other bene?ts afregietering an account are subscribing to topics and forums; creating ?a biog; and having no ads shown anywhere on the site-f 3.Click here to Register aft-6e account now! or?read our Weicome Guide to learn how to use this site. Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman? Gr?nleg' $ep 1.8 09:58 My? vin; \w NEXT log in to reply Genky,s Lawrence Abrams Posted 38 205}? 5'33 ljust wanted to thank Quietman? for accepting the sentence, I mean position, of Global Moderator here at BC. Thanks again for everything you do here. Lawrence Abrams Become a Bleeping-Computer fan: Em Hang with gs on LgckerDome Everyone shoutd do this? Gender: Male . - t. - gag; gag! wage to keep you: commuter safe angl segue 5233 the Internet Everyone must reeo one! Location: USA Local time: 06.34 PM BleepingComputercom Register to remove acts KoanyoreluBieepin' Conundrum 33 Seetenmer 200.7 to AM. 17/2015 3:35:21 Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman? - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions Congrats Thanks for all your hard work here understand you ve now given up all your rites now? Staff Emeritus (that's not a misspelling above.) . t, t, t. . may cit-2y was yesterday. it I Gende? Male some do: some some won?t Location: 65 mites due East of the ":Logic Free Zone", in Md, USA Local time: 07:34 PM ghsmurray ?58 ?ames?ntsar -- 18:15.] AM Congrats. Quietman?! Members u_ \RkohJ fl??zxu Location: 6,378 km above the Earth?s core Local ttme: 67:34 PM jgweed ?3 130?}? @622? AM Congratulations and thanks for accepting the position (life sentence). John Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one should be silent. Staff Emeritus 5.0.52: v? elf/391.53 Gender: Mate it. Locatton: 0 Local time: 51 DSTM @537 Eli's?: .m Fx.? Posted it"? ?Bleeotn? Aussie Addict? Congratulations 'Quietman?? on your well deserved Promotion. 17/2015 3:35:21 3 9.9.- Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman'l - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions Members 3.64-3 posts . ems- Gender: Mate Location: AUSTRALEA Local time: 30:34 AM I qua-amt? Bleepin' Janitor Gtobat Moderator .A: ?512.03?; 03,553. Gender: Mate Location: Virginia, USA Local time: 08:34 PM lusitano Portuguese Malware Fighter Members ?43 5205??: Gender: Male Location: Portugal Yourhighness the 886 Malware Fighter goo? ?#2133? Jake? Thanks everyone and thanks Grinler for offering the mean position. There are not many sites who will give an ex-cop, now a "Bleepin' Janitor" the keys to the kingdom. Usually I only get the keys to the broom closet and back door so I can take out the trash. Member of u?ng, Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators "Congratulations 'Quietman?? on your'well deserved Promotion. UNITE Unified l-letwm?k of Instructors and Trusted Eliminators Please do not PM me asking for support. Please be courteous. petite, and say thank you. Piease post the final results, good or had. We like to know?43' Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman? BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions grows goon?; Gender: Mala Location: Hamburg Local time: 01:34 AM oldf@rt Posted '18 Swimmer 296'? PM Congratulations!. "i'he says a? alE 59 hat-56mg; permanently 114 M: WARMNG Rinks migln ot-auso ?Fringe Members u. [y 510638 Gender: Male Location: Arizona Local time: 04:34 PM oAsos__= Malware hunter $33-$36 ?2 - Thank Security Colleague Stelios i I. 53:? 3:5 2: OFFEINE Gender: Male I Location: Greece romm from kmmih canal Biz-w 32553:?; semi? ?sh Local time: 01:34 AM Unified l'letwork of Instructors and Trusted Eliminators {Salt} .a r? "7 .. ., mom; :8 400: a;le Congrats quietmanT, and thanks a lot for looking after BCH 5 3:35:21 #11 a Ki: Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman? - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions 3,003 costs Gender: Male Location: The Netherlands Local time: 05:34 PM To Insanity and Beyond lit a. Giobal Moderator Gender: Mate Location: USA Local time: 65:34 PM 'Da-Vld? Members w: - you.? Gender: Male Location: London Local time: 12:34 AM ogel noviser "?2944 Gender: Mate Location: South Carotlna - USA Local time: 07:34 PM 5 3:35 :21 ?osteo' ?18 September 2052'? {33:03 PM Congrats an excellent choice WIN #12 et- Fortne time will come when men will not put up with sound doctrine lnsteed, to suit their own desires): they witl around them a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to Becoz'ste a fan: faggot;th Have you seen?ejgot max romeo i3 mmemeea mm 54 PM Congratulations quietman! Well #13 #14 Big Thank You To Our Newest Global, Quietman7 - BleepingComputer Announcements, Comments, Suggestions .4 Bieepin? Janitor 18 .- Thank you all for the kind words. Global Moderator . mm Member of M, Uni?ed Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators Gender: Maie Location: Virginia, USA Local time: 06:34 PM Back to BieepingComputer Announcements. Comments, Suggestions 0 user(s) are reading this topic 0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users Genera! iopics Blee int (JorngiuterAnnouncements, Comments. 8: Suggent?ons i 3 Rules - Privacy Poiicy Help I aAcigreriisell?boutUs i i Sitemap 3 Chat 3 RSS Feeds Centaurus? Tech Support Forums :f?3 VirusR?niovei Guides 1 Downloads Tuiorials' :1 The Computersiosesary UninsiaiiList i Fiie Database 2004-2015 Ail Rights'?eserved Bleeping Computer LLC . . Site Changeiog I Corim?eunify Forum Sofiw?sre in! IPBoar? 12/17/2015 3:35:21 Exhibit 5 spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software wees? em BieepingCornputer.com Forums Members Tutorials Startup List More .v Forum Rules View New Content BleepingComputer.com Security v? Anti-Virus, Anti-Maiware. and Privacy Software 3 Welcome to BleepingComputer, a free community where people like yourseEf come together-toldiscuss'and learn how to use their, computers. Usmg the I site is easy and fun. As {a guest; you. can browse and View the various discussions in the forums, but can not create?a new topioor'reply to an existing-z [one unless you-arelogged in. Other bene?ts of registering an account are subscribing to topics and forums. Greetings blog, and having no ads shown .. anywhere on the site: 1' Click here to?z'Register'a free ascount now! or react our Welcome Guide to learn how to use this site. spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit him-ed is}; terzeicimi. . 20 34 uses an? 9tease log in to reply 2 NEXT khafan??l #1 Posts/'have Avira internet security i want to install anti Malware spy too Members i test this three soft spyhunter and malwarebytes and iobit but i have problem with each of These . malwarebytes its magi?) I make system too slow i! spyhunter use more of 250mb Ram and I dont trust that :d .. Local time: 03.07 AM Whats your Recommend 8C: A?Bot (Legit? to Remove) .. BieepingComputer.com Register to remove ads #2 Condobloke I I - if Outback Aussie 33.0886" 903m: 2.0M - 02. AM 8.1471494? G'day khafani 1, and Welcome to BC. 3:38:20 spyhunter vs vs iobit - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software from If your system is running slowly, it is not the fault of may have other Members it} posts m" 6v iobit is garbage. Gender: Mate Local time, 10,37 AM spyhunter Is no longer recommended by BC if you are having problems with your PC, please describe those problems to me Condobloke Cutback Austraiian .1 a? vs titii't .. so that: one at of opposing evidenc any :tcnvintaztg crises-ii of a in. Mn u: amt; r, .: . s. g. gem}. lg. gut; :titCE y?Oua 3:32? G: (insert, 51;: sumaiQi'l .8 not :53 ?333$ng qu?ietman? as ?5 (at) \EE?Qfgiisbc: tat-- Bieepin? Janitor SpyHunter by Enigma Software Group USA, LLC is a program that was previously listed as a rogue product on the because of the company's history of employing aggressive and deceptive advertising 1. it has since been deiisted but some users have reported they still engage in deceptive advertising 3-. Newer versions of SpyHunter instail it's own "Compact 05" and uses Grub4Dos loaderiito execute on Global Moderator 4r: boot up. The user no longer sees the normal Windows boot menu but instead sees the GRUB menu. In some cases this has caused the computer to go into a continuous loop or experience other issues when attempting to boot. Gender: Male Location: Virginia, USA. Local time: 06:73? PM Unfortunately, Ag-Test has not included SpyHunter in their comprehensive testing analysis. If Enigmasoftware's SpyHunter was included, which we hope they attempt to do so, we would get a much clearer picture as to how it compares to other anti?spyware programs in terms of protection. detection, repair and While there are mixed reviews for Spyi?lunter, some good and some bad, my main concern is the reports by customers of deceptive pricing, continued demands for payment after requesting a refund, lack of adequate customer support, removal (uninstall) problems and various other issues with their computer as a result of using this product 53. For example, some users are not aware that when purchasing SpyHunter, they have agreed to a subscription service with an automatic renewal poiicy This information is in fine print at the bottom of the mirage"; Eurcttasa?eteement. Quote SpyHunter is a 6 month subscription spyware detection/removal service. By making this purchase. customers agree, for their convenience, to be autorenewed every 6 months in order to receive ongoing spyware protection, definition program updates, custom fixes to their specific spyware probiems, and advanced technical support from our Spyware-i-lelpdesk. You wilt receive an e-maii notification to opt-out, if you do not wish to be autorenewed. v! You may want to read some of the user comments posted on the group to see why there are so many concerns regarding this product. Further, when searching for new malware or malware removal assistance (and removal guides) on the Internet, it is not unusual to find numerous hits from untrustworthy sites that provide inadequate removal instructions and then offer a tool that a visitor must purchase before it removes anything. These sites recommend a pay-to-clean program, 17/2015 3:38:20 spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software rather than a free-to-clean program, because the site owner will make a commission on the sale of the program. SpyHunter (SpyHunter-lnstallerexe) is one of the most common removal tools pushed by these sites. I r? l?i or modems and other antivirus and antimalware vendors do not target it for removal. Those security vendors which have tried in the past received threats of legal action for attempting to do so or agreed to legal settlements as a result of litigation brought forth by Enigma Software 3. See this Iable..o?1breats..aud?emands which identifies Enigma as one of the companies to make repeated "Cease and Desist" demands against those companies which detect, remove, and/or criticize their product. Enigma also appears to consider online community security sites as competitors for evaluating legal WW Mustsi? In maimed SpyHunter is a dubious program with a high rate of tatseposittves 3. If you have downloaded and scanned with SpyHunter, detection results should be analyzed carefully before you remove anything. Based on this information, it is in my opinion that you remove this program and replace it with highly regarded alternatives such as Melwarehytes??atuare or Ems?ott?nti?alware If you want to uninstall SpyHunter, then use the guides and information below to help The correct way to remove SpyHunter per the vendor, Enigma Software Group, is from within its program group Uninstall shortcut in Start Menu All Programs or by using Programs and Featgres (Agleemgve Erggrams) in Control Panel. - Alternatively, you can use a third-party utility like Note: Sometimes the uninstall works more effectively if you first (and associated processes) or perform the removal in mm so there are less processes which can interfere with the uninstallation. SpyHunter4 creates the following scheduled task which should be disabled/removed before uninstalling. SpyHunter48tartup "Cz?xEsc-gzam Software /s - a Task - orD cl ll in windows lf you have imitations or Qgeamt installed, you can also use those tools to disable and remove tasks. Some users have reported that you may need to open Windows Explorer, navigate to the following location, look for and delete a SpyHunter related file named SHSetup.exe before uninstalling from Programs and Features (Add/Remove Programs) in Control Panel. -- C:\Documents and SettingsllLocal -- Vista, Windows 7/8: name>lAppDatalLocallTemp if the suggested removal methods you need to Contact E36 Technical Suocort Team and submit a ticket. Submitting support tickets is only for customers who purchased ESG products. If you are not a paid customer or not able to logon to their members section, you can try contacting ESG through the page. If you feel that that SpyHunter or the developer has engaged in deceptive marketing, then i also suggest you write about your issues on the and send 3:38:20 spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software Enigma an email if you read through those comments. you will notice that Enigma Representatives will respond to those making comptaints. Quote I am the Vice President of Technical Support and Research at Enigma Software Group read the post above and woutd like to let you know that we have an email speci?cally for complaints. You or anyone can submit a complaint and I can assure you that we will ?nd a suitabte solution for any problem that is related to SpyHunter or to our service. If you have any questions or complaints, please send us an email to I personally read all emails from that account At Enigma Software Group, we work hard to maintain the best level of service and make sure that every customer becomes a satis?ed customer. Regards, Alec Maiaspina Enigma Software Group USA, LLC. have referred several other members to follow the above instructions and all were successfully assisted by ESG Tech Support with removing SpyHunter. References?omt ?sjijs rum 6? 1 lift to .. . .. ra?masuateuyiesoia . Member of Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators quietmanf I I. #4 Bleeptn' Janitor in regards to (EvonSoftcom) products, please read: - - tQMedaJ?L?a?y noon. Gtobat Moderator QMW - iObi?t: Trusting Your Antivirals Vendor Gender: 1? . Location: Local time: (X3237 PM .tEStMaMQ?cLQeawM?Q?e?w Quote 3 Poor maiware removal left many executabies, some actually still running. Poor malware blocking did not prevent installation of doesn't do thejob of removing malware or preventing malware installation. Although, the Malwarebytes team no longer has an issue with IObit, the vendor's dubious methods would not warrant a recommendation from me to use or trust their software. Further, IOBIT has even been placed into the insta?eLsJ-ta? 3:38:20 spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Anti?Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software ,of?heme. Mlcrosoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2015 Member of LJNITE, Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators khafan't?l' #5 a: Posted 238 Sierpterrzber 12014 ?:t222 AM thanks for your Description i back to malwarebytes and disable real-time protection malware protection . 7- works fine and system not slow it i should enable this options right? Members A Edited by khafantt, 28 September 2614 - 11:23 AM. Local time: 03:07 AM quietmanY . - - #6 we. Bleepin? Janitor 28 23613; Are you saying that you have disabled the real-time protection module in Malwarebytes Premium (Pro)? If so, you are losing it's primary benefits. at Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2915 ?Ll??amm Member of Unified Network of Instructors and Trusted Eliminators Gender: Mate Location: Virginia, USA Local time: 0623'? PM khafant?t - 4 . I #7 at: quietmanT, on 28 Sept 2014 -1;07 PM, said: Are you saying that you have disabled the real?time protection module in Malwarebytes Premium (Pro)? if so, you are losing its primary benefits Members yes. i think not good compilation with avira Local time: 03:07 AM 3:38:20 spyhunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Ami-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software catamaan Bleapin' Janitor Global Moderator Gender: Male Location: Virginia, USA Local time: 05:37 PM Superware?f . Memb GFS ?40. lul Local time: 0537 PM quietmal? Bleepin' Janitor Global Moderator 42?: costs #8 if: Malwarebytes Premium is meant to supplement your existing anti?virus. The following quote is a statement from the Malwarebytes Team. Quote Maiwarebytes Anti-Malware is not meant to be a replacement for antivirus software. Malwarebytes Anti-Malware is a complementary but essential program which detects and removes zero?day malware and "Malware in the Wild". This includes malicious programs and ?les, such as viruses, worms, trojans, rootkils. dialers, spyware, and rogue applications that many antivirus programs do not detect or cannot fully remove. It is important to note that Malwarebytes Anti-Malware works well and should run alongside antivirus software without conflicts. in some rare instances, exclusions may need to be set for your speci?c antivirus product to achieve the best possible system performance. Larry Tate Product Support A similar statement is in this HelpDesk Article: Wyies Anti?Malware replace antivirgis so?ware? Microsoft MVP ?Consumer Security zoornzots if? Member of 1.11911}; Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators Someone help me please. Nothing could remove SpyHunter, i don't wanna buy Could anyone help 7025; ii: That information is here in m. Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2015 ?1 Member of Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators 3:38:20 spyhumer vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software Gender: Male Location: Virginia. USA Local time: 06:3? PM Is? 1Pw= Posted 21? February 2011-} @3230 PM Hello khafant 1: I have personally used Avira's Free Antivirus with Malwarebytes Pro/Premium, and all options enabled. on a Windows Me?be}; 7 x64 system for years. posts When that system is idle, CPU usage is frequently between 0 and Ge de Hale . . . . . 3 If a MBAM "Clean Re-Install" does not correct your issue, your system may requrre expert troubleshooting assustance. Location: North of the 38m parallel. Local time: 03:3? PM quietmanY? 'i #12 at]; Bleepin' Janitor February Gift/rig? .i'aa?u't Useless posting removed. . ?15? Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007-2015 We? Global Moderator Member of 1.13115. Uni?ed Network of Instructors and Trusted Eliminators Gender: Male Location: Virginia, USA Local time: 06:13? PM georgehenry - I are: die/:3. i- I don't know how I got it, but spyhunter 4 appeared on my win? laptop. Because of my hamfisted attempt to get rid of it, it disappeared from "features and programs" and hid itself away somewhere. tried looking in all sorts of places. all to no avail. It kept popping up and doing unwanted scans. In desperation I downloaded it again, and then deleted it I from the"programs and features". So far it has not reappeared, If this is a well known way to handle this, just ignore it. in my defence. I saw a note on your site asking people to tell how they did things. g; Edited by georgehenry, 31 July 2515 08:50 AM. Gender: Male Location: New Romney, Kent. Engtend. Local time: 11:37 PM 17/2015 3:38:20 spy'nunter vs malwarebytes vs iobit - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software Bleepin? Janitor Posted at Ju?y ?i :48 provided removal instructions in Emilia, along with contact info for E86 Technical Support if normal removal fails. Anyway, glad to hear you were able to sort it out yourself. Giobal Moderator it ?in, 490,85 900$ Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security 2007?2015 - Member of ME, Unified Network of instructors and Trusted Eliminators Gender: Male Location: Virginia, USA Local time; 06:37 PM SteveDalias ,m a; Spyhunter is still engaged in decpetive ads and deceptive billing. i just clicked on a product from them for $29.xx and my credit card was charged $69.xx They will not help you with this. You have to contact their payment processor and the payment processor has limited hours and are not 24/7 like most legitimate payment processors. This is fraud to me and I will never activate and use the product. i also suspect that many of the items that showed up in the scan Members were not correct. .., J- 520 {3?3 Local time: 05:37 PM Back to Anti?Virus, Antl-Maiware. and Privacy Software ?3 user(s) are reading this topic 0 members, 9 guests, 0 anonymous users BteepingComputer.corn Security - Andie/true. .Altti-i?daiware. and Software D. a Faisacy Potter; i-telp AboutUs i User Agreement i Privacy Policy Sitemap Chat RSS Feeds i Contact Us . i . Tech Support Forums E"Virltie"Removai Guides Downloads Tutorials The Computer Glossary. Uninstaii List Startups The File Database 2004~2o1sarr orgasms?road Bleeping Computer LLC . - Qommunity Forum Esottware ERstard [12/ 17/201 5 3:38:20 Exhibit '6 1/5/2016 unter cannot remove infections Anti-Malware. and Privacy Software BleephigColn puterxom "ii Swarm Primes-Software f? Welcome to BleepingComputer, a hoe eommunity when: people like you rself come together to discuss and?ieam how to use their computers. Using v' the site. is easy and. fun. As a guest, you can'btowse and View the Various discussions in the forums, but can not create a new topic ortepiy to an existing one uniess yon are logged in. Otherbene?te of registering an accountant: subscribing to topics and forums, creating a blog, and having no ads shown anywhere on thesite. . - . I. Click hem to_chister a free account now: or reed our Welcome Guide to loom to use this site. SpyHunter cannot remove infections Started. in; itiizzixiro it) 202;; xoziom?xi ittinndro Posted to December 2013 iozzo AM I have been using this program very successfully for a month or so. It ?nds and removes tons of and malware no other software sees. Today it found about 600 items, including Conduit search and others which keep creeping in. When I click the FIX button and the computer reboots, I keep getting a pro-booting scrolling with a message Spyhunter fix not found". As a matter of fact, the spyware is still there on the next soan.Same scenario when I reboot . How can I solve this problem? Ittiandro Boning: ,?aog?inm Remove) Remove Malware - Free Quick Malware Removal in 2 minutes. Free Download (Highly Recommended) 3.33 {3 Uninstall Spy Hunter. F?osl'exl to Deactier 2mg - 21:03 AM install MBAM Free: Maigret. ailow it to delete whatever it PUPS. hitter: .?iit?r-Maiwere Free {hit on" reipvtesxn?e 1' precincts? Run a scan and Use these two programs for finding and nninstaliing adware. 5-: "Wt Downturn? {hitorz? ?"Whieeo? Woo" re Remove; lifx'ioi {Em-mined {tub?if?: 4 Spy Hunter's 600 items most likely included 3rd Party/ Ari?Tracking cookies. You can block those from instaliing. Ones you have blocked from installing, use Ccleaner to remove the ones presently installed and clean up the temporary files and logs including Ad cookies in Flash. Be sure to watch for and UN check offers of toolbars, etc. 0 need to use the Registry Cleaning 001 as it may cause more problems. giggible minim cookies in Firefox. and Chrome i How To fhowto.cne1:.mml 8mi? 03 ?2&5 fox~and~gmgie~chrome Q?isnmr: mm ..izatinuntnigeoitng..-.fires 1/4 1/5/2016 unter cannot remove infections - Anti-Vlrus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software Posted amass: 22:35.3 11:04 em quietman? hut Enigma still engages in deceptive advertising which violates several consumer protection laws in many states. In my opinion it is a dubious program which is not very effective compared to others with a proven track record and I would not trust all the detections provided by its scanning engine. Unfortunately, dE?est?O?-tggs; .1 2933 5 not included SpyHunter in their comprehensive testing analysis. If Enigmasoftware's SpyHunter was included, wln'ch we hope they attempt to do so, we would get a much clearer picture as to how it compares to other anti-spyware programs in terms of protection, detection, repair and usability. Newer versions of SpyI-Iunter apparently install it's own "Compact and uses Grub4Dos loader to execute on boot up. The user no longer sees the normal Windows boot menu but instead sees the GRUB menu. For some folks this has resulted in Spyl-lunter causing a continuous loop when attempting to boot and other issues. Further, when searching for new malware or malware rem0val assistance (and removal guides) on the Internet, it is not unusual to ?nd numerous hits from untrustworthy sites that provide inadequate removal instructions and then offer a tool that a visitor must purchase before it removes anything. These sites recommend a pay-to?clean program, rather than a free?to?clean program, because the site owner will make a commission on the sale of the program. SpyHunter (SpyHunter-Installer.exe) is one of the most common removal tools pushed by these sites. Ifyou have downloaded and scanned with Spyl-lunter, any detection results should be reviewed carefully. My personal recommendation would be to remove the program and replace it with a trustworthy alternative. How to Uninstall Snvl?lunter Trustworthy alternatives. wareb es ute .coxn vi'uwremoval howetonus anal I mag wareMtutor-ial! . tantalize imandro {guisfnz?n? on 193233923 51:64 ass, said: Newer versions of SpyHunter apparently installs it's own "Compact and uses Grub4Doa loader to execute onboot up. The user no longer sees the normal Windows boot menu but instead sees the GRUB menu. For some folks this has resulted in SpyHunter causing a continuous 1009 when attempting to boot. if you have downloaded and scanned with SpyHunter, any detection results should be viewed with suspicion. My personal endati on would he to remove the program and replace it with a trustworthy alternative. I-iow to [Enigma l? Sow-lung; (into: 1' ggiasg 'itwarexxim snvhun [er-uni 'g "trustworthy alternatives. bleenl if *SUPFR?-ntiqijmvarefq szr'iwrsi' :4 2% ?argcta'mut?u? sore ["375 31; ova: X?X?'kt?hl'i?s if)l?l3l 1? do have but I still haven't lost ALL my bones with Spyliunter and I'd like to give myself some more time to use it because it has picked up infected Registry entries which no other apps had previously founder-mail; I have on (?ssion checked the manually and found those infected entries were there and removed them?o Spyiiunter was ?wrest, alterzdii The problem I have now is that for some reason the HOS loader in and this prevents the Sl?YHunter Fix to he applied .1 never had this problem before and didn?t even know about this Dos loader. The spyware has always been removed by at booting without this loader . I'd like to know how can revert. to the normal cleaning process, but i cannot ?nd a way to disable this darn mmpact loader. Any suggestions? Thanks a: .. 190'sth tlovsudzer 2:354 -V 04:02 PM quietrnair} 2/4 1/5/2016 SpyHunter cannot remove infections - Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, and Privacy Software Since we do not recommend this program, I doubt any of our members use your question requires a more specific answer than we can provide. I suggest you Contact use 'ljechnical Sunnort Team mm; 1" wwvenignmsofm 3 and submit a ticket. Submitting support tickets is only for customers who purchased ESG products. if you are not a paid customer or not able to logon to their member's section, you can try contacting ESG through the Lnguiries 5; h?gedizgek {113; - i 3g; irg?gsf 3 page. wow. 0 4 Postal 29 November 2014 -- 06:37 PM mom, on Nov 2014 ~32:me r- omnivorous; mm 929 20:3 1130;: (on, said: Newer versions of Spyliunter apparently installs it's own ?Compact and uses GmbaDos loader to execute on boot up. The user no longer sees the normal Windows boot menu but instead sees the GRUB menu. For some fonts this has resulted in SpyHunter musing a continuous loop when attempting to boot. If you have downloaded and scanned with SpyHunter, any detection results should be viewed with suspicion. My personal rewmmendation would be to remove the progrm and replace it with a trustworthy altemative. Trustworthy alternatives. i do have Mahmrebyres but I haven't lost ALL my hopes with Spyi?innter and I?d iike to give myself me more time to use it because it has picked up infected Registry entries which no other apps had previously found.Actually, have on occasion checked the Registry manually and found those infected entries were there and removed them.So SpyI-iun?rer was correct, afterail! The problem I ha ve now is that for some reason the R8134 DOS loader kicks in and this prevents the SPYI-Iimter l-?ix to be applied .1 never had. this moi/112m before and I didn't even know about this FRUB4 Dos loader. The spyware has always been reomved by Spyilunter at booting without this louder . I'd like to know how can I revert to the normal cleaning primes, but} cannot ?nd a way to disable this darn compact ioader. Any suggestions? Thanks '3 Ittiandm Here's a little food for thought. Maybe Spy Hunter is finding false positives to fool you into thinking that it?s effective. Considering their rogue past, it would not surprise me. We see this sometimes here at BC. Ports-i harmonise-r 120:; 013:2: 2?34. As i noted above, SpyHunter is a dubious program and it is prone to a high rate of fix-Xv .1 and: runabout 43'sz wart-f:rlossarvf 311502113 Software. A hivstertv? it" Sortinnter - Fake security Fluted nose-rm? Software Group Spyhuntergornplaints Read some of the user comments posted on the Comgiaints Board: Eni 'n inter?ch '23; thml} . .1 :mvw comiian. liar amino? Revi .ws hr 3: hunts! NuilPointerEKeeption i?osterl or Thrasher 2.014 I reoommend llm?xegky i hit-pi to totally forget unchecking while installing bundled software. It's a totally automatic, trustworthy free tool. eepi ngcom puler.comfforum sit/51 7033/spyhunter-cannot-rem ove-i nfectionsl 314 1/5/2016 unter cannot remove infections - Anti-Virus, Anti?Malware, and Privacy Software ?5 Edited by newbie? 20.14 - ize :04 79M. I - . Poets-J 01 December 226?"; ~r o? :10 FM ?qmeonam 3 . on RaMMicI-iaeL?s Blog, indicates it is more for average users who are not careful about reading everything and accept all defaults when installing programs. The blog posting also indicates Unchecky is stitl a beta version, I seldom recommend using pro-release beta winition {beta so a ?3 versions of most programs since you never know what bugs or quirks might turn then you have to waste time researching and getting things straightened out. The goal of a beta program is to collect information regarding the performance, quality, stability, and functionality of new products in order to iron out the bugs before they are released to the general public as a stable final product. Beta software is not intended for inexperienced users since it may contain bugs ranging in severity from minor features not working properly to problems that may potentially damage your system. If you choose to use a beta program, you use it at your own risk. mean; 1 - What is beta software? {tittnz/ Ikbiu?edu/deta - Softwarereleaseiife "ole 'enwiki ediaow wiki Software Rock to Anti-Vireo, Anti"Etiolwere? an i. l?rivaey Software Remove Malware - Free Quick Malware Removal in 2 minutes. Free Download (Highly Recommended) ?lae?ngfompothmr ms Semirity m+ Aerie/inmate, aw? i?rimry?o?ftwarc bl eepi ngcom puter.com lforum ove-i rrfecti ons/ 4/4 Exhibit 7 1/5/2016 ZeroAccessJP help - Am I infected? What do I do? "a Security Am {immuth - . Welcome to BleepmgComputer, a tree commu mty where people 11kt: yourself come together to and learn how to use they: computers. Usmg, I swthe site is easy and fun. As a guest, you can browse and thcvarious discussions in the forums, but cert not create a new topic or mply to an existing - oneunless you are logge?l in. Other benefits of registering an accountoro subscribing to topics and forums, creating a biog, am; having no ads shown . I ahywhem on the site. Click here to'?egister a free account nowlror our Welcome Guide to loam how to use this site: 1 ZeroAccessJP help Surrirt?; Eiraoi?mir {rec 2074. 03:44 53M :BrattDuir o4 Bmember 2014 03:44 PM. I seem to have picked up this nasty little bugger and nothing seems to get rid of it. SpyHunter found it but I'm pennyless so can't pay for it to remove it. l'm at a loss so any help would be greatly appreciated. Bi} millet {Ldg?n to Rommel Remove Malware - Free Quick Malware Removal in 2 minutes. Free Download (Highly Recommended) .. - 3/ Guest?Ligh?rousei?artyj E?oste?: 0.1 2014 03.48 Hello there l'm LighthouseParty and HI be assisting you with your concern today? Let?s run a couple of scans to see what could be causing this. 6) Download MiniToolBox 1. Click here to download ?4tmiflox {tittozf mimiixmlbox? to your desktop. . Double click MiniToolBox. . Select the following and then press go. 03 . Post the log in your next reply. A Flush DNS Reset IE Proxy Settings Reset FF Proxy Settings List Installed Programs List Restore Points Install and run a scan with Malwarebytes Anti-Malware . Click here shims," iwmw. malwarebvtesor? to dowr?oad Malwarebytes to your desktop. . Double click and follow the arr-screen instructions. . 011 the dashboard, click update now. . After that, click scan now - the scan will nowbegin. 1/4 11512016 ZeroAccessJP help - Am I infected? What do i do? 5. When the scan?s completed, select apply actions - make sure the action is quarantine. 6. Restart your computer. How to get the tag. 1. 0n the dashboard, select the history tab and click application logs. 2. Select the log which has the time and date of when you did the scan. 3. Click copy to clipboard and paste it into your reply. (9 Download Security Check 4 1. to download Security Checkto your 5 :7 desktop. 2. Double click SecurityCheck and follow the on-screen instructions. 3. Alog should open, called checkuptxt. 4. Please post the contents of it in your next reply. Thanks and good luck! quictxnanas Posted o4 theorems: so}; 04:57 22329} SpyHunter by Enigma Software Group (ESQ) is a program that was previously listed as a rogue product on the because of the company's history of employing aggressive and deceptive advertising. It has since been delisted but Enigma still engages in deceptive advertising which violates several consumer protection laws in many states. In my opinion it is a dubious program which is not very effective compared to others with a proven track record and I would not trust all the detections provided by its scanning engine. AV~Test t? est-rs "ts has not beem able to include SpyI-Iunter in their comprehensive testing analysis which would reveal h0w SpyI-lunter compares to anti -spyware competitors in terms of protection, detection, repair and usability. The reason for this is that the publisher, Enigma Software, has not been cooperative in submitting SpyHunter for testing at likely due to the program?s ineffectiveness and high rate of ihttozl While there are mixed reviews for Spyl-lunter, many customers have reported deceptive pricing, continued demands for payment after requesting a refund, lack of adequate customer support, removal (uninstall) problems and various other issues with their computer as a result of using this product. Newer versions of SpyHunter apparently install it's own "Compact and uses Grub4Dos loader to execute on boot up. The user no longer sees the normal Windows boot menu but instead sees the GRUB menu. For some folks this has resulted in SpyHunter causing a continuous loop when attempting to boot and other issues. You may want to read some of the user comments posted on the ?Complaints Bomd: Enigma Somme Group Spyhunter Complaints 8: Ram; (into: i com} . Further, when searching for new malware or malware removal assistance (and removal guides) on the Internet, it is not unusual to ?nd numerous hits from. untrustworthy and scam sites which misclassify detections or provide misleading information. This is deliberately done more as a scam to entice folks into buying an advertised fix or using a free removal tool. SpyHunter (SpyHunter-Installer.exe) is one of the most common "50- called" removal tools pushed by these sites. - Sov?umer Fake securitv hinge lfyou have downloaded and scanned with SpyHunter, any detection results should be viewed with suspicion. My personal recommendation would he to remove the program and replace it with a trustworthy alternative such as Antid?aiware r'ht'tos' 1' ?-on3m:rigorousorrf :mtimalwarcx?} or ?gsisg?tu?p?ghtalwam up?, {Ewart-75%. - i-iow to Uninstail Spyi-lunter tint! '3 Note: Some users have reported that you may need to open Windows Explorer, navigate to thefoilowing location, Iookfor and delete a SpyHunter related file named SHSetup.exc before uninstalling from Programs and Features (Add/Remove Programs) in Control Panel. XP: C:\Documents and Settingsl \Local Settingsl Temp -- Vista, Windows 7/8: C: Useisl \AppDatalLocal Temp quictman7 routed 04 Decemhes' 1mm -- 04:59 PM 2/4 1/5/2016 ZeroAccessJP help - Am I infected? What serious malwm infection. If that is what you actually have, then disinfection will probably require the use of more powerful tools than we can recommend in this forum. Ze Ac okit ti" voice oh mm 1 Hold off on following LighthouseParty's instructions. Please download WREQII rkillg by Grinler and save it to your desktop. I Double-click on the Rkill desktop icon to run the tool. Vista/ Windows 7/ 8 users right~clial1 and select Wiggr :2 ms. rg? 178tog?mm ?(9391211. Ablack DOS box will brie?y flash and then disappear. This is normal and indicates the tool ran successfully. - Alog file will be created and saved to the root directory, Copy and paste the contents of RKillJog in your next reply. . i?osted 05 Becumlm 2014 o'rtgo AM Bran?mr For quietman'y' As requested the contents of the RKill.log: 2.6.8 by Lawrence Abrams (Grinler) hittermi) Copyright 2008?2014 BloepingComputer.com More Information about Rkill can be found at this link: 08:3 05th! Program started at: 12/05/2014 12:34:19 PM in x64 mode. Windows Version: Windows 7 Home Premium Service Pack 1 Checking for Windows services to stop: No malware services found to stop. Checking for processes to terminate: No malware processes found to kill. Checking Registry for malware related settings: No issues found in the Registry. Resetting .EXE, .COM, 8: .BAT associations in the Windows Registry. Performing miscellaneous checks: Windows Firewall Disabled "EnableFirewall" dwordzoo 000000 ALERT: ZEROACCESS rootlot found! C:\Program Files Dir} C:\Program Files Dir] C:\Program Files Dir] C:\Program Files Dir] C:\Program Files [2251 Dir] Checking Windows Service Integrity: 3/4 1/512016 ZeroAccessJP help - Am I infected? What do I do? PcaSvc [Missing Service] PolicyAgent [Missing Service] RemoteAceess [Missing Service] Searching for Missing Digital Signatures: No issues found. Checking HOSTS File: No issues found. Program finished at: 12/05/2014 12:35:59 PM Execution time: hours(s), 1 minute(s), and 40 seconds(s) Thank you for your help on this matter. Pasta-ti {moniker 201:; a 03:33 AM (mietman'y' owe: 7 ?i ZEROACCESS motkit found! You will need to create and post a DDS log for further investigation. Please follow the instructions in the Malwzu'e Removal and Log Section Preparation Guide hit 1 - If you cannot complete a step, then skip it and continue with the next. - In Step 6 there are instructions for downloading and running DDS which will create two logs. (Note: Windows 8.1 Users will not be able run DDS and create a log) When you have done that, post your logs in the Virus, ?1 andj?aiwam {atng 1? vi ms?: . NOT here, for assistance by the Malware Response Team. Start a new topic, give it a relevant title and post your 103(3) along with a brief description of your problem, a summary of any anti-malware tools you have used and a summary of any steps that you have performed on your own. Ifyou cannot produce any of the required logs or you're using Windows 8.1, then still start the new topic and explain that you followed the Prep. Guide, were unable to create the logs, and describe what happened when you tried to create them. A member of the Malware Removal Team will walk you through, step by step, on how to clean your computer. After doing this, please reply back in this thread with a link to the new topic so we can close this one. Rail; to Am 3. misstated? When. do? do? ?ltepingt?omoutcry/um n? Semen); Am linfet'ted? who: do i do? ngcom puter.com/forum slt/558678/zeroaccessjp?help/ 4/4