IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF NOLEN SCOTT ELY, et 31., Civil No. Plaintiffs Magistrate Judge Carlson) v; . CABOT OIL GAS CORR, Defendant new: $3 I liminm Instruct-1011a In answering these questions, You are to follow the instructions I have given to you in the instructions that I read to you at the conclusion of the trial. Your answers to each question must be unanimous. As used herein, ?the Plainti??s? refers to Plaintiffs Nolen Scott Ely, Monica Marta-Ely, Jared Ely, Jessica Ely, Justin Ely, Raymond Hubert, Victoria Hubert, and Hope Hubert ?Cabot? refers to Defendant Cabot Oil 8; Gas Corporation. ?The Ely Property? refers to the approximately 8.28 acres of land, including the improvements and water wells thereon, owned by Nolen Scott Ely and Monica Marta-Ely that abuts Carter Road in Dimoek Township, Susquehanna County, Case 3:099va02284vMCC Document 745 Filed 0310115 Page 2 0f 6 ?The Gesford Wells? refers to Cabot?s Gesford 38 Well and Cabot's Gesford 3 Well (which was later renamed and completed as the Gesford 9DD well). Qngetian _1 Have the Plaintiffs proven by a preponderance of the evidence that Cabot was negligent in the drilling or completing of the Gesford Wells? Answer ?Yes? or Answeri 5 If you answered ?Yes? to Question 1, then answer the following question. Otherwise, do not answer any further questiens. Instead, the foreperson should sign the verdict form and return it to the Court. Have the Plainti?'s proven by a preponderance of the evidence that in the drilling or completion of the Wells Cabot negligently created a private nuisance which signi?cantly harmed any of the Plainti??s in their use and Enjoyment of the property by contaminating the water warms) on the Ely Property? Answer ?Yes? or ?No? as to each of the Plaintiffs below. a. Nolan Scott Ely Answer: Case Document 745 Filed 0.3110115 Page 3 016 b. Monica Marta'Ely Answer: 0. Jared Ely Answer: 5 (1. Jessica Ely yas Answer: 6. Justin Ely Answer: f. Raymond Hubert Answer: ES g. Victoria Hubert Answer: h. Hepe Hubert Answer: I. If you answered ?Yes? as to any of the Plaintiffs in Question 2, then answer the following question as to those Plainti?is) only. Otherwise, do not answer any further questions. Instead, the forepersan should sign the verdict form and return it to the Court. Case Document 745 Filed 0310/16 Page 4 of 5 Mega Only as to each Plaintiff for whom you answered ?Yes? in Question 2.have the Plaintif?s) proven by a preponderance of the evidence that the private nuisance created by Cabot was a legal cause of that Plaintiffs less of use and enjoyment of the Ely Property? Answer ?Yes? or ?No? as to each Plaintiff for whom you answered ?Yes? in Question 2. a. Nolen Scott Ely Answer: b, Monica Marta-Ely Answer: c- Jared Ely Answer: (1. Jessica Ely Answer: e. Justin Elyr Answer: '2 5 Raymond Hubert 55 Case Document 315 Filed U3110l15 Page 5 Of 5 g, Victoria Hubert Answer: 11. Hope Hubert YES If you answered ?Yes? with respect to any of the Plaintii?s) listed in this question, then as to those Plaintif?s) answer the following question. If you have answered ?No? as to all Plaintiffs do not answer the following question. Instead, the foreperson should sign the verdict form and return it to the Court, nestigg 4 Only as to those Plaintiffs for whom you answered ?Yes? in response to Question 2 and 3 what amount of money, if any, do you award as damages sustained by those Plainti?'s as a result of the private nuisance created by Cabot? Answer in dollars and cents, if any, only as to those Plainti??s for whom you answered ?Yes? in response to Question a. Inconvenienoe and discomfort to Nolan Scott Ely. Answeri$ 2001000 b. Inconveniencs and discomfort to Monica Marta-Ely. Answer: 5 i} 3 630', 000 Case Bowman! 745 Filed 03110116 Page 6 of 6 a. Inconvenienoe and discomfort to Jared Ely; Answer: 5.0; ()00 b. Inoonvenienco and discomfort to Jessica Ely. Answeri$ 000 o. Inconvenienoe and discomfort to Justin Ely. Answer-:3 d. Inconvenienco and discomfort to Raymond Hubert. Answer: 3 (370 e. Inconvenienco and discomfort to Victoria Hubert. Answer: 0:1 0 0 f. Inoonvenience and discomfort to Hope Hubert. Answeri$ Please have the foreperson date and sign below and advise the courtroom deputy that you have reached a verdict. Date: 3/0??6 . eperson