Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Case Master Report 2015-648 Date Initiated 11/15/2015 Warning .. Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information - i . 5.: Agency: MINNESOTA BUREAU CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Division: Investigations Section: Metro Regional Office Unit: MRO - Homicide Lead LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Type Of Case: Officer Involved Shooting Case Sub Type: Fatal Case Description: Officer Involved Shooting- Jamar Oneal Clark - Minneapolis Authorized Operators Name Svmson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Evans, Drew (1302 I Superintendent's Office] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Woodford, Derek (1317 - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Case Status 7 1 Case Status: Open Case Status Date: 11/15/2015 Dissemination: Hidden MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Initial Report 2015?648 Report Date: 11/15/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Informatien . . . . - Description: Request by PD to investigate an Officer Involved Shooting Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Olson, Christopher (Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency - Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Dept 15-423384 Synopsis-n On Sunday, November 15th 2015, SA Phill was called to respond to an Officer Involved Shooting in Minneapolis. SAs Phill, Olson Swanson and Mueller responded to PD Homicide to be briefed on the shooting. No evidence acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name ED B_i0 Subjec_t#1 -,Rin?ggenber?g, Mark Douglas._ - - Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 12.3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Chartes (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Initial Report 2015-648 Report Date: 11/15/2015 Subject Dustin Timothy - I I . State ID Minnesota NO Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_i_0_ M3. EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 SUBJECT #3 - Clark, (Jamar Oneai Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: 11l15I2015 20:19 Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 2 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Initial Report 2015-648 Report Date: 11/15/2015 Record Status Information - Continued Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 12:47 Reporting (LEO 7 - Date . Supervisor - - Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on?the followingpage. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 3 of4 On Sunday morning at about 9am on November 15th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received a phone call from Special Agent in Charge Mueller regarding an Officer Involved Shooting in Minneapolis. SA Phill was advised that during the early morning hours of 15, 2015, the Minneapolis Police (MPD) had responded to a call for assistance from Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Medics at the scene of an assault at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. in Minneapolis. While HCMC Medics were treating the assault victim, a black male came out of the apartment and was pounding on the rear of the ambulance. When MPD officers arrived at the scene, an altercation ensued between the two MPD of?cers and this black male. During the altercation the black male was shot by police. This black male was later identi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark, DOB 05/03/1991. He was treated at the scene and transported by ambulance to HCMC. Early reports from the hospital are that and he was not expected to survive. The Minneapolis Police Department was requesting that the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension conduct a criminal investigation into this officer involved shooting. MN BCA SAIC Scott Mueller met with MPD Chief Harteau and her command staff and agreed to provide all assistance necessary in the furtherance of this investigation. A meeting was planned at the MPD Homicide Unit in downtown Minneapolis for 10am. SA Phill, SA Olson, SSA Swanson and SAIC Mueller arrived at 10am and met with MPD Detectives (Det) Thomsen, Moore and Green; also present was Commander Granger. SA Phill learned that Det Villella was the ?rst investigator to respond to the incident. She was able to obtain recorded statements from 5 Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Paramedics as well as one from Rayann Hayes, the woman being treated in an ambulance when Clark tried to interfere and was later approached by Police. SAs Phill, Mueller, Swanson and Olson learned that there were very little facts known about the shooting other than MPD Officers Schwarze and Ringgenberg shot Jamar Oneal Clark and he was on life support at HCMC. SA Phill was told there were some items of evidence to be transferred to the BCA. Please see SA Phill?s later supplement regarding items received from MPD on November 15th and 16th. During the afternoon of November 15th, SAs Phill, Swanson, Olson and Mueller visited the crime scene after it had been released by MPD. Efforts were made to talk to neighbors and witnesses with no success. SA Phill handed out business cards and spoke to various members of the local community encouraging witnesses to come forward and give statements. Case Report with Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplements Report Details Reporting Of?cer: 006422: Dustin Schwarze Approval Status: Approved Assisting Officer: 006030: Mark Ringgenberg Approve! Date: Nov 15. 2015 Supervising Officer: Date Returned: Approving Supervisor: 007201: Christopher Thomson Return Count: 0 CaiiISqd: 424 Date Printed: Nov 15. 2015 Precinct: 04 Last Uploaded: Nov 15. 2015 Reiated CON 1 Scivability: Reported Date: Nov 15. 2015 04:01 Primary Routed Unit: Entered By: 005183 incident Details Offense1: ASLTZ Desc: Weapon Statute: 609.222 Attempted: Address: 1511 Ptymouth AV Apt. 204 Minneapolis, MN 55411 Occurred From: 1111512015 00:40 Dispatched: 00:40:00 Occurred To: 1111512015 00:40 Arrived: 00:48:00 Location: KNOX AV NIJAMES AV Cleared; 05:00:00 Minor involved: No Pubiic Data not ://caprsweb.ci .. 1 '1 1 5/2015 Witness Role I Role rt: W001 Name: Thompson, Wesley William Residence: Telephone: Lie Date of Birth: Event Age: Est Age:- Race: White Medical Treatment: No Sex: Male Prior injury: No Height: 508 Build: ME Emglogment information Address Teleghone Occugation Home Paramedic Availability: Personal Description Category Description Related Offense comments Employment Status Employed Force Used No Witness Role I Role #1 W002 Name: Haskell. Tyler Jordan Residence: Telephone: Lie #2 Date of Birth: Event Age Est. Age: Race: White Medical Treatment: No Sex: Male Prior injury: No Height: 508 Build: ME EmployerISchool Address Teieghone _O_cgg_oe_ti_o_r1 Homo Paramedic Availability: Persona! Descrigtr'on Category Description Related Offense Comments Employment Status Employed Force Used No Relationships None De?ned Cap1?sReport.aspx?GUID. .. 1 1/ 1 5/20 15 Case Supplements 62 supplements begin on the following page. 1 1/1 5/20 15 Supplement number: 1 COM: NIP-15423384 Author: 004994 - Nicole Murray Supplement of Off N.Murray #004904 on 11/15/2015 04:02 On 11115/2015 was working squad #8220 with OFFICER DERHAAG when responded to a help call at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrive], I assisted with crowd control, taping off the scene and directing bystanders out of the area. END of Supptement 1 .. 1 1/15/20 15 Supplement number: 2 CON: MP-15-423384 Author: 0028-80 - David Hansen Supplement of D.Hense?n #002680 on 11/15/2015 04:03 On 11-15-2015 I was assigned to marked squad 506 as the 5th Middlewetch supervisor? At approx. 0040 hrs. there as a citywide toned help call on the northside with the remarks that shots were ?red and that officers need help. Myself and my partner Sgt. Brown responded to the scene at 1611 Plymouth Av N. We assisted in helping secure an outer perimeter, using the responding citywide of?cers. Once the outer perimeter was secure, we assigned Ofc. Hedberg to start a crime scene log. At that point we were instructed to monitor the responding personnel and monitor the precincts cat! load . We cleared from the scene and helped reassign of?cers not needed on scene to help handle 911 calls in the 4th pct. END of Supplement 2 1 1/ 15/20 15 Supplement number: 3 CON: NIP-15423384 Author: 005759 - Jonathon Pobuda Supplement of Off J.Pobuda #005759 on 11/15l2015 04:04 On 11/152015, I was working uniformed patrol as assigned squad 1322. (marked squad 184) with my partner Of?cer Moen. At 0057 hours, we self-assigned to respond to an OFFICER NEEDS HELP cell, located et1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrival we assisted of?cers already on scene with crowd controi. Once the crowd disbursed we assisted with setting up poiice tape on the northwest side of the ELKS CLUB parking tot. My partner and i remained on scene until 0014 hours. END of Suppiement '3 .. 1 1/1 5/2015 Suppiement number: 4 COM: Author: 005183 - Michael Nor-din Supplement of Off M.Nordin #005183 on 11/15/2015 04:05 On 11/15/2015 I was working marked squad 430 with my partner Of?cer Rodin #6075. Al: the above time, we responded to the above area to assist Of?cers with this incident. Upon arrival, assisted by helping Of?cers clear a large crowd around the Etk's Lodge so crime scene tape could be put up? twee then assigned to the southwest parameter near Plymouth Ave and Knox Ave and was there until released by supervisors. Nothing further from this Of?cer. END of Suppiement 4 UID. .. 1 1/ 1 5/20 1 5 Supplement number: 5 COM: Author: 003682~2akari Ketchmark Supplement of Off Z. Ketchmark #003682 on 11/15/2015 04:06 Officer Ketchmark 3682 On 11/15/2015 at 0050 hours was working marked squad 120 with Of?cer Bishop badge #0563 when we responded to an of?cer needs help call at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrival we placed our squad in a position to maintain a perimeter at the intersection of Plymouth Ave and Knox Ave. 1 maintained the perimeter until relieved from the call. END of Suppiement 5 1 1/1 5/20 1 5 Supplement number: 6 CCN: NIP-15423384 Author: 001573 -Josi1ua Domek Supplement of Off J.Domel< #001573 on 11/15/2015 04:08 On 11/15/2015 at approximately 0055 hours. while working marked squad 311 in full MPD uniform with my partner OFFICER BERGERSEN, we reSponded to 1611 Plymouth Avenue for an officer needs help call. Upon arrival to the aforementioned location. i observed a chaotic scene with bystanders yelling Obscenities and threatening of?cers on scene. i assisted in clearing the parking lot of the Elks Club of these individuals in order for crime scene tape to be put up. i stayed on scene for a brief time period after the perimeter had been established to assist with scene security. END of Supplement 6 .. 1. 1/1 5/2015 Supplement number: 7 CON: NIP-15423384 Author: 004832 Adam Moan Suppiement of Off A.Moen #004832 on 11/15/2015 04:12 On 11/1 5/15 at 0151 hours, while working squad 132 with Of?cer Pobuda, we were advised that Of?cers needed help at the address of 1611 Plymouth Ave regarding a shots fired call and there was a large unruly crowd. Upon arriving, we responded to the building across the street from the address and assisted in crowd controi where a large group was gathering and yelling and swearing at Of?cers. They were becoming larger and larger and were pushing against the crime scene tape that had been put up. We assisted in moving the crowd back and to their cars that were in the parking tot untii the iot was cleared out and we were able to regain control of the area. Additionai crime scene tape was put up and we were advised by Tucker that we could clear from this call and head back downtown. END of Supplement? 1 1/15/20 15 Supplement number: 8 CON: Author: Supplement of Off CBishop #000563 on 11/15/2015 04:12 On 11/15l15 was on duty working uniform petrol while assigned to squad 120 with my partner Of?cer Ketchmark. At approximately 0050 hours on this date dispatched aired 3 HELP cat! for 1611 Plymouth Ave North. 1 drove to that location with lights and sirens activated. Upon arrivei We were directed to the intersection of Plymouth Ave North at Knox Ave N. There we helped establish and maintain a perimeter of the scene until released. Signed crime scene tog. END of Supplement 8 .. 1 1/ .1 5/20] 5 Supplement number: 9 CON: MIDAS-423384 Author; 006075 - Anthony Rodin Supplement of Off A.Rodin #006075 on 11/15l2015 04:18 On 11/15/15 at 0058 while working squad 430 with my partner Of?cer Nordic we self-assigned to an of?cer needs heip cail at 1611 Plymouth AV N. When we arrived I saw a large crowd gathering assisted other of?cers in moving the crown back. I was approached by Sgt. Brown, #0824, and was instructed to keep a crime scene tog of the of?cers that were on the scene. I waiked the perimeter of the crime scene and approached all the of?cers I saw and added their names to the crime scene log. I provided scene security at Plymouth AV and James AV N. I was able to log personnel walking into the crime scene. Due to the minimum number of people that were providing security I was unable to track the time that people cleared the scene. Lt. Wheeler, #0711, instructed me to ?ll out a separate crime scene log for EMS that responded. I property inven?toried the 3 Crime Scene log pages and '1 crime scene log page for EMS in locker 48 at Property Inventory in MPLS City Hall. END of Supplement 9 LI '1 5/2015 Suppfementnumber: 1O CCN: NIP-15423384 Author: 000750?Peter Brazeau Suppiement of Off P.Brazeeu #000750 on 11115/2015 04:23 On 1111512015 at approximately 0056 hours i was working marked Squad 131 with my partner Of?cer REED. We responded to 1611 Plymouth Ave on an Of?cer Needs Help call Dispatch aired that an officer needed help and shots were ?red. My partner and I responded to the scene. i helped escort people out of the crime scene, put crime scene tape up, and stayed on scene at the intersection of Plymouth Ave and Knox Ave for scene security until Sgt. Tucker released me. END of Supplement 10 1 1/15/20 I 5 000251 - Benjamin Supplement number: 11 CCN: Mia-15423384 Author: Badowich Supplement of Off BBadowich #000251 on 11/15/2015 04:24 On 1111512015 1 Of?cer Badowich was assigned to squad 411 aiong with my partner Of?cer Shanidin. At approximateiy 0050 hours. Of?cer Shankiin and i were at the station on our lunch break I heard over the radio, Squad 424 reported shots ?red and need heip. Upon our arrival, assisted other Of?cers on scene with setting up a crime scene perimeter. i put up crime scene tape from James Ave along the south side of Plymouth Ave N. then handed the crime scene tape to a Metro Transit Police Of?cer who ?nished putting up the rest of the block. I saw the person that was shot (JAMAR ONEAL CLARK) was being put into the ambulance. I then got into the ambulance with HCMC paramedics. Due to the scene being very chaotic. the ambulance drove two blocks away so they could work on CLARK outside of the scene in a safe area. A short time later, they transported CLARK to HCMC hospital. i remained with CLARK white he was at the hospital. One of the hospital staff gathered property and packaged it up. She then handed me property and I signed a property receipt. CLARK was moved from the ER to a room on the 7th floor. 1 remained with CLARK and made sure no one touched him besides medical personai. i was advised by Deputy Chief Foikens that we could clear HCMC. Officer Shankiin and i then drove to MP0 headquarters and property inventoried CLARK's clothing in the biood room. i kept custody of clothing the whole time until it was property inventoired. END of Supplement 11 us/CaprsApp/CaprsRep ort.aspx??GUID. .. 1 1/1 5/20] 5 Supplement number: 12 CCN: NIP-154123384 Author: 000824 - Kristopher Brown Supplement of K.Brown #000824 on 11/15/2015 04:24 On 11-15-15, Sgt. Hansen and i were working Squad 506. 5th Preoinot Patrol Supervisor. when a help call was toned over Channel 3. The aired remarks were that ?shots were ?red". We responded and as we arrived of?cers were puting up the cutter perimeter police tape. We then assisted with securing the cutter perimeter and assigned Of?cer Rodin to complete the Crime Scene Log. After the scene was Code 4, we assisted in allocating squads to assist with the heavy call load in the 4th Pot and returned to the 5th Pot as the only supervisors available to monitor bar close and calls. END of Supplement 12 .. 1 1/ 1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 13 CCN: 5423384 Author: 004897 - Chou Mona Suppiement of Off CMoua #004897 on 11/15/2015 04:25 On 11/15/2015 i was working Squad 149 (Pir76721). At approximately 0057 hours responded to an Of?cer Needs Help call at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrival assisted with crowd control in an open lot across the street from the address. There was a large crowd that had gathered and was becoming unruly. Once the crowd dispersed and left the scene. I assisted with securing the perimeter at irving Ave and Plymouth Ave until crime scene tape was put up. i then left the scene and returned to my patrol downtown. END of Supplement 13 .. 1 1/1 5/201 5 Suppiement number: 14 CON: NIP-15423384 Author: 006488-Nicholas Shanklin Supplement of Off N.Shanklin #006488 on 11/15/2015 04:26 On 11/15/15 at approximately 0050 hours while working marked Squad 411 76727) with my partner Of?cer Badowich I heard Squad 424 say over the radio, "shots ?red, one down". My partner and responded from the 4th Precinct to Squad 424 location at 1611 Plymouth Av N. When i arrived on scene i saw a large group of people (50-60ppl) on the North side of the street. I also saw a person, who was later iD?d as JAMAR CLARK, lying on the South side of the street on the ground in the grass between the sidewalk and the street. ithen saw a couple of people coming out from the 1811 Plymouth Av apartment building and start running towards CLARK tying on the ground. 80 to secure the scene I had the people stay back toward the entry way of the building until we could get the crime scene tape up. My partner Of?cer Badowich then informed me that he was going to ride with CLARK to the hospital in the ambulance. I followed the ambulance in my squad car to Hennepin County Medical Center. After arriving at the hospital was advised to transport one of the HCMC paramedics to Rm 108 in City Hall to be interviewed by investigators. After both HCMC paramedics were done being interviewed transported them back to HCMC. My partner and i then transported olothing's to City Hall and property inventoried them into the blood room. END of Supplement 14 ://caprsweb.ci 1 1/15/20 15 004987 Guisiain Supplement number: 15 Author: Muvundamgna Supplement of Off GMuvundemina #004907 on 11/15/2015 04:27 On 1111512015 at approximately 0140 hours while working Squad 510 with my partner, Of?cer Saint Jean. 1 was dispatched to assist on an Of?cer Needs Help call. I responded to NMMC and was instructed by Sgt. Campbell to guard HOMO ambulance rig 419. was later told by Sgt. Campbell that the Ambulance would need to be towed to the forensics garage. I completed a tow sheet and spoke with the driver from the Miller Towing company informing him that the Ambulance was to be taken to the forensics garage. As we were about to heed to the forensics garage with the tow, and of?cer invotved Squad accident with injury came out at 26th Ave and Freemont Ave N. Due to the lack of resources from the Of?cer Needs Hetp call. we diverted to assist on the physical injury squad accident scene. END of Supplement '15 1 1/15/2015 Supplement number: 16 CON: Author: 001425-Bach Dang Supplement of Off B.Deng #001425 on 11/1512015 64:34 On 11/15/2015 at about 0052 hours while working squad 113, my partner Of?cer Krautkramer and I responded to an Officer needs help call. We arrived on scene and I put up police tape around the scene. I provided scene security until relieved by a supervisor to return to 1st precinct. END of Supplement '16 1 I 1 5/2015 Supplement number: 1? SEN: MP-15-423384 Author: 003854 Cory Krautkramer Supplement of Of? C.Krautkramer #003854 on 11/1512015 04:40 On 11-15-15 I was working marked squad 113 with my partner Of?cer Dang. At approximately 0052 hours we responded to 1611 Plymouth AV for an Of?cer Needs Help call. Upon Arrival assisted with securing the scene and stood by until I was released. END of Supplement 17 .. .1 1/ 1 5/2015 Suppiement number: 18 Author: 003198-Paui Huynh Supplement of Off PHuynh #003198 on 11/15/2015 04:45 On 11/15/15 at approximater 0052hrs, was working squad 121 with my partner Of?cer BEMAN when we were dispatched to an HELP call at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North. Upon errivet, 1 provided perimeter security on Plymouth Avenue North outside of the crime scene tape. There was a moderate size crowd of about 15-20 individuals standing around the squads on the sidewalk area. A few of these individuals were saying "fuck the potioe? and "you guys are dirty" over and over again. We cleared the scene at approximately O120hrs per Sgt. 105 to be downtown for bar close. END of Supplement 18 . 1ninneapolis.mn.us/ .. 1 1/ 1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 19 CON: MP-15-423384 Author: 006179 - Nichoias Rowe Supplement of N.Rowe #006179 on 11/15/2015 04:47 Supplement of N.Rowe #006179 on 11/15/2015 04:45 Supplement typed by SGT Rowe, badge 6179 on 1015115 at 0437 hours. On 11/15/15 at 0050 hours i responded to an Of?cer Needs Help call in the Fourth Precinct at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Remarks indicated that shots were fired. i arrived at the incident location. Squad 407 requested that monitor 911 calls for service on the street in the Fourth Precinct. noti?ed dispatch on channel ?ve. Squad 408 arrived and took over the role as the street supervisor. I then cleared the scene. END of Supplement 19 1 1/15/2015 Supplement number: 20 Author: 001263-Chad Conner Supplement of Off C.Conner#001263 on 11/15/2015 04:49 On 11/15/2015 at 0050 hours, while driving squad 425 with Officer Sworski. i heard an officer air that shots were fired and they needed help at the location of1611 Plymouth Ave N. We responded to their location and assisted. Upon arrival. 1 observed squad 424 in front of1611 Plymouth Ave N. I observed two Of?cers near a male who was down on the sidewalk. Paramedics were also on the sidewalk andappeared they were providing medical attention to the male who was down. There was a large unruly crowd that was gathering in front of the Elks Club on the North side of the street. i noticed there were two security gaurds who were standing on the sidewalk in front of the Elks Club. 1 also saw a group of people in the of1611 Plymouth who were screaming at of?cers. i heard that this was a officer involved shooting from the twu of?cers involved. i got crime scene tape from my squad and assisted in setting up a perimeter and crowd control. i also assisted in casing 1611 Plymouth Ave N. i did not speak with anyone who witnessed the incident inside the building. I did speak with two individuals in front of the apartment building who claimed they witnessed the incident but refused to provide a statement. They were upset and were uncooperative. They refused to provide me with their names. 1 reminded them several times that if they wanted to give a statement that homicide investigator would be here and they may speak with them. i also provided them with the opportunity to go to room 108 to give a statement but they refused. i did not detain them due to their egressive behavior towards the police and it would have likely turned into a physical alteration. I specifically remember upon arrival at older female approximately 50-60 years old. She was attempting to run to the male who was down on the sidewalk but someone was holding her back. i also assisted in dealing with the Elks Club management to provide surveillance video. I stayed on scene for scene security until the scene investigation was ?nished. END of Supplement 20 caprswebci .minneapolis.mn.us/ aprsApp/ CaprsReport.a5px?GUID. .. 1 t/ 1. 5/20 1 5 Supplement number: 21 CCN: Nip?15423384 Author: 006046 - David Robins Supplement of Off D.Robins #006046 on 11/15/2015 04:50 On 1111512015 1 was working marked squad 352 with my partner Officer Boelk. We heard a help call get toned over the radio and responded to the scene. Upon arrival, we took a perimeter on the corner of Knox and until we were relieved by the incident command. END of Supplement 21 .. 1 1/1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 22 CCN: Author: 000383 - Cameron Beman . - Suppiement of Off C.Beman #000383 on 1111512015 04:50 I responded to this call because i heard a request made over the air for all avaiiabie squads. Once on scene 1 provided security for the scene from putside the crime scene tape. i then cleared t6 f?tUi'i?i Der 105- END of Supplement 22 1 1/1 5/20 15 Supplement number: 23 CCN: Author: 000958 Thomas Campbell Supplement of T.Campbeli #000958 on 1111512015 04:52 On 11/15/2015 i was working squad 105 as the ist Precinct Dogwatoh supervisor. At approx. 0050 hours dispatch aired an Of?cer needs help call at 1811 Plymouth Ave. Additional remarks from dispatch were that shots had been ?red. 1 immediately headed to this location to assist. As i arrived on scene at approx. 0054 hours i noticed extremely large crowds on both the north and south sidewalks of Plymouth Ave. noted that the crowd was very agitated by their screaming, and their hand and arm gestures that were being thrown into the air. At this time i asked dispatch who the incident commander was, and was informed that squad 407 had command. 1 located 407 and discussed my responsibilities for the incident. First, assisted Of?cers with moving a targe hostile group of on-lookers from the north side sidewalk area. Once this was completed i instructed several Of?cers to tape off the area. and to maintain a secure perimeter. These Of?cers were instructed to hold this perimeter until instructed otherwise. Secondly. along with several other Of?cers went to NMMC to secure the originai 911 sailor/assault victim (Rayanne). and the two witness paramedics. Once there, i had one Of?cer stay with Rayanne the entire time. until relieved by an investigator. Next, i had two separate squads transport the Hennepin County paramedics to room 108 for interviews. Lastly. i had squad 510 tow the HCMC ambulance to the MPLS impound lot forensic garage for processing. After clearing the hospital i returned to the scene on Plymouth Ave and was released soon after by to Sgt. McBride. END of Supplement 23 1 1/15/20 15 Supplement number: 24 CCN: NIP-1 54123384 Author: 002997 - Conan Hickey Supplement of Off C.chkey #002997 on 11/15/2015 04:56 On 11-15?2015 I was assigned to squad 530 with Of?cer Deoheuang. At approximately 0048 hours we were dispatched to 1611 Plymouth AV to assist other Of?cers in a possible shooting. We arrived on scene and assisted in securing the perimeter. We remained on the perimeter until approximately 0430 hours. At 0430 hours we were instructed to break down the perimeter and leave the scene. END of Supplement 24 .. 1 1/ 1 5/20 1.5 001424 - Souphaphone Supplement number: 25 Author: Daoheuang Supplement of Off SDeoheuang #001424 on 1111512015 04:57 On 1145-2015 i was assigned to squad 530 with Of?cer Hickey and at approximately 0048 hours we were dispatched to 1611 Plymouth AV to assist other Of?cers in a possible shooting. We arrived on scene and assisted in securing the perimeter. We remained on the perimeter until approximately 0430 hours. At 0430 hours we were instructed to break down the perimeter and leave the scene. END of Supplement 25 .. 1. 1/ 1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 28 Author: assess-meme! Nelson Supplement of Off MNelscn #005033 on 1111512015 04:57 On 11/15/2015, was working SOD 420 with my partner Of?cer Robert Lewis #4101. We were in marked vehicle #420 I was the passenger of?cers and Lewis was driving. At about 0051 Hrs, we responded to the area 011511 Plymouth Av to assist other officers at the location who were requesting help. The call comments included: 1111512015 00:19:42 SYS Response Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] 11/15/2015 00:19:59 SYS Response Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] 1111512015 00:20:24 SYS Response Possible E911 \Mreless Phase 2 update[Shared] 1111512015 00:20:32 CT123096 Response 1 HOUR AGO CLR BROKE UP A IN LOBBY, CLRS ANKLE NOW HURTING A LOT [Shared] 1111512015 00:20:45 SYS Response Possible E911 \Mreiess Phase 2 update[8harecl] 11/15/2015 00:20:52 CT123096 Response ALL PERSON THAT WERE ARE NOT LONGER ON SiTE[Shared] 1111512015 00:21 :51 CT123096 Response CLR NOT ABLE TO WALK ON SEND SON OTS TO LOOK FOR 1111 512015 00:40:07 000033598 Response Mum-Agency EMS incident #2 15076385 11/15/2015 00:40:07 000033598 Response [51] [Appended 00:55:21] Multi-Agency Incident 15-423384[Shared] 11/15/2015 00:40:13 000033598 Reaponse EMS REQ SQUAOS CODE 3 [Shared] 1111512015 00:40:23 000033598 Response [10] ASSAILANT IS 30 FT IN FRONT OF AMBULANCE [Shared] 11/15/2015 00:42:18 000033508 Response [11] EMS IS CODE 4, STILL REQ SQUADS CODE 3 [Shared] 11/15/2015 00:48:00 000014497 Response [12] ASSAILANT IS NOW AT AMB DOOR [Shared] 11/15/2015 00:48:05 000014497 Response [13] EMS CODE 4 INFO FOR POLICE ONLY [Shared] 11/15/2015 00:50:20 000033598 Response [14] Duplicate call of Incident number 15075391 [Shared] 1111512015 00:50:20 000033598 Response [52] [Appended 00:55:21] [14] [14] Dupticate call of incident number 15075386[Shared] 11/15/2015 00:50:29 000014497 Response [15] EMS REPORTING SHOTS FIRED [Shared] it should be noted in the background of the radio transmissions from SOD 424, there was a lot of commotion in the background. My partner and responded to the location in an expeditious manner. Upon arrival I observed that there were around 100 people on the sidewalk on the north side of Plymouth Av, in front of the Elks Club (1514 Plymouth Av N). i also observed that Of?cer Schwarze and Ringgenberg were on the south side of the street. There were other of?cers that had arrived before us assisting with that scene. At that time, I began to keep the crowd back from where the of?cers were dealing with the gun shot victim. The crowd kept trying to advance into the street towards the officers. I called out on the radio that we needed more officers for crowd control, and also that we needed to close traf?c on Plymouth Av. Of?cers were eventually able to make a line of of?cers and contain the crowd to the sidewalk. Crime scene tape was then put up. Of?cers then directed everyone from in front of the Elks club to leave the area. it should be noted that there were several uncooperative people in the crowd. Also several people in the crowd were video taping the situation. Once the area on the north side of scene was secure. went to the south side which had fewer of?cers to secure the area. There were numerous people in the doorways and balconies of the apartment building on the south side of the street that were yelling at officers and very upset. Crime scene tape was put up at this location also. I stood by near Plymouth and Knox and secured the perimeter at this location for the remainder of the time on scene. 1 1/ 1 5/20 '1 5 When told to secure by SGT McBride, i took down crime scene tape and Ieft the area. END cf Suppiement 28 1 1/1 5/2015 Suppiement number: 2? Author: 006709-M1chaelSonday Supplement of Off MSonday #006709 on 11/15/2015 04:58 On 11/15/2015 1 was working squad 550 and responded to an OFFICER NEEDS HELP call at Knox AV and Plymouth AVE N. Upon arrival, I helped secure the scene and took perimeter at the Northeast comer of Knox and Plymouth until I was relieved by the incident command. END of Supplement 27 1 1/1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 28 CCN: Author: 004891 - Roger Moua Supplement of Off RMoua #004891 on 11l1512015 04:58 On 11/15/2016 while working squad #460, I responded to assist squad #424 on an assist EMS call at 1811 Plymouth Ave N. Squad #424 had just aired that shots had been ?red. Immediately after this. I got into the squad car with squad #410 and we responded to squad #424?s location at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrival. observed that there was a large crowd of people on the north side of the street on Plymouth Ave N. Aftemrards, exited from the vehicle and assisted in helping control the iarge crowd of people and setting up yellow crime scene tape. After a perimeter was setup, 1 heaped maintain the east side of the perimeter until I was ailowed to clear from the scene per Squad 407. END of Supplement 28 i 1/ 1 5/201 5 Supplement number: 29 CON: Author: 000605 - Miehaei Boeik Supplement of Off MBoelk #000805 on 1111512015 05:00 On 1111522015. I was on patrol as the passenger of marked squad 1360. assigned as squad 362, with my partner Of?cer ROBINS. At approximatety 0050 hourst we self-assigned to respond to an Of?cer Needs Help call at 1611 Plymouth in North Minneapolis. When we arrived. 1 was directed to assist with crowd control. After directing several pedestrians away from the crime scene area, i assumed a position on the perimeter of the crime scene. My position was on the NE corner of the intersection of Plymouth Av and Knox N. At approximately 0435, assisted in taking down the crime scene tape and departed the scene. END of Supplement 29 . minneapolismn.us/CaprsApp/ 1 1/ 15/2015 Supplement number: 30 CON: BAP-15423384 Author: 005756 - Graham Supplement of Off G.Plys #005756 on 1111512015 05:01 On 11/15/2015 i was working squad 310 as the passenger along with my partner Officer Cummings. Amend 0050 hours we responded to of?cer needs help call at1611 Plymouth Av N. Upon arrival i could see crime scene tape was already setup. went area of the tape that was on south side by an apartment and maintain scene security until retieved. END of Supplement 30 1 1/ 1 5/2015 Supplement number: 31 CCN: RAP-15423384 Author: 004101 - Robert Lewis Supplement of Off RLewis #004101 on 11/15/2015 05:08 On 11/15/15 I was working squad 420 (Pa/#76699) with my partner Of?cer Nelson when i heard over the radio that there were shots being ?red at 1611 Piymouth Ave n. Squad 424 was on a call with EMS at this address. My partner and i went to assist squad 424. Upon arrival at the scene there were about two hundred peep/e across the street at the ELKS club yelting at of?cers. The crowd was very hostile towards of?cers. The crowd was in the street and moving toward officers. There was another crowd coming out of the apartment building and this crowd was about forty peopie and they atso were hostile towards of?cers. I helped other of?cers move the crowd that was in front of the ELKS ciub to the back of the club and told the people to tears the area. I then stayed at the scene for scene security. i stayed there till 1 was totcl to drive squad 424 back to the PCT. END of Supplement 31 .. 1 1/ .1 5/2015 Supplement number: 32 CON: Author: 001521 Steven Derhaag Supplement of Off SDerhaag #001521 on 1 1/15/1201 5 03:41 On 1145-15 at approx. 0051 hours responded to 1611 Plymouth AV on 3 HELP call. Upon arrival assisted three vehicles in backing up and exiting the lot of the Elk?s club. 1 then maintained crowed control on the North side of the scene next to Eik's club until released by 2202. END of Supplement 32 .. 1 1/15/2015 Supplement number: 33 MP-15-423334 Author; 001126 Thomas Choriton Supplement of Off T.Chorlton #001126 on 11/15/2015 03:43 On 11/15/2015. i was working squad 8212 with my partner Of?cer Payne Along with all available cars, we self assigned to the help call at 1611 Plymouth Av N. After most of?cers had cleared, Of?cer Payne and were asked to stay and keep the crime scene secure, as there were many onlookers who were very agitated. When the scene was secure. i provided cover security for of?cer Martin and his recruit while they canvassed the apartment building looking for witnesses and taking statements. Due to the amount of people outside iooking at the scene, as well as those on the balconies, was asked to accompany Of?cer Martin and his recruit to just provide cover while they coliected statements. After a couple hours on scene securing, officers were then dismissed after many of the bystanders left the area and were no longer perceived as a possible threat to of?cer and scene safety. END of Supplement 33 1 1/15/20 1 5 Supplement number: 34 CON: Author; -Thomas Wheeler Supplement of Lt T.Wheeler #007710 on 11/1512015 05:19 I was off-duty when Car 9, LL. Novak called me via cell phone to report that there was an officer invoived shooting near the Elks Club (1511 Plymouth Av N.) I received the call at 01:04 hours. i arrived at the scene at 02:12 hours and checked in with the Incident Commander (Sgt. McBride.) I met with Of?cer Rodin to check-in on a crime scene log. The scene was Code 4 prior to my arrival. While on scene, An EMS Deputy Chief approached me and stated he was a witness to the event. The EMS Deputy was identi?ed as Mark Trullinger. i made a request for Officer Rodin to complete a separate crime scene log for EMS staff. I asked Truilinger to log into the scene with Of?cer Rodin. Trullinger was later transported to room 108 on request of Sgt. Green. Evidence from the scene was secured in a separate taped off area. This evidence was taped off prior to my arrival. i stayed out of the area where evidence was located and i was not close enough to the evidence to view it. I continued to assist in monitoring the crime scene until MPD and Car 21 arrived at the scene. I remained on scene until it was secured at 04:32 hours. - CASE OPEN (or) LT. THOMAS WHEELER MINNEAPOLIS PD END of Supplement 34 1 1/ 3 5/20 1 5 Suppiement number: 35 CON: NIP-154123384 Author: 002999 - Griffin Hittbo Supplement of Off G.Hilibo #002999 on 1111512015 05:20 On 11115115 twas working squad t62A. i was in full MPD uniform and driving a City of Minneapolis marked squad car. At approximately 0051 hours, I responded to an Of?cers needed help salt at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Further info was given that shots were ?red cali and there was a large unruly crowd. Upon arriving, provided security for the Paramedics as they treated the suspect. i couid see Of?cers already dealing with large groups that were yelling and screaming. Many of them were yelling racially charged slurs at the officers on scene. The suspect was transported a short time later and began providing scene security at Knox Av and Plymouth Av N. Campbell requested several squads to assist at North Memorial Hospital and I responded. When i arrived at North, I obtained info from the original Paramedics (Wit and that had arrived on an Assault call at 1611 Plymouth Av N. They said that their run number is 15076386 and responded to apartment #204. I then transported one of the witnesses to room 108. After these paramedics were done giving their statements, 1 transported them to HOME. END of Supplement 35 .. 1 1/1 5/20 15 Supplement number: 36 CON: MP-15-423384 Author: 004062 - Daniel Ledman Supplement of Off D.Ledman #004062 on 11/15/2015 05:20 Oh 11/15f2015 at approximately 0050 hours while working squad 421 (Marked Squad 423 with my partner Of?cer T. Yang, we self-assigned to assist as Squad 424 aired that shots were ?red at 1611 Plymouth Ave. N. We assigned to the help cat: as we were coming from downtown. was driving and my partner was passenger. As we arrived on scene i observed large crowds of people on both sides of Plymouth Ave. N. The crowds Were yelling and screaming at Officers. Shortly thereafter I was informed that it was an Of?cer involved shooting. assisted in providing scene security on the south side of Plymouth Ave. N. from James to Knox Ave. N. I also assisted in stringing crime scene tape and covering for other Of?cers as they attempted to speak with residents inside 01?1611 Plymouth Ave. N. After the scene was processed by Car 21. assisted in taking the crime scene tape down per the instruction of Sgt. McBride and then cleared from the scene. END of Supplement 36 .mi nneapolism 1/ 15/2015 Suppiement number: 37 CCN: Author: 002927 ~Anna Hedberg Supplement of Off A.Hedberg #002927 on 1 11151201 5 05:21 On 11/15/2015 at approximately 0040 hours, while working Squad 431 in marked Squad 431 responded to 1611 Plymouth Ave in regards to an Of?cer Needs Help call. i heard via the radio there were shots ?red. Upon arrival 1 observed a male lying on the ground directly in front of the incident iocation. I observed a large crowd gathered in front of the address and across the street at the nearby Elks Grub. assisted with crowd control as the crowd was very hostile towards police. As the crowd grew in size and hostility parked my car in front of the incident location to block the crowd from the crime scene. i activated my MVR and pointed it towards the entrance of1811 Plymouth Ave N. i then stayed on scene and assisted with scene security and putting up crime scene tape. 1 also assisted with canvassing the apartment building for witnesses, however none were identi?ed during our initial canvaSs. Once Squad 40? aired the crime scene tape could be removed I assisted with taking down the crime scene tape and i then cleared the call. END of Supplement 37 1 1/15/20 15 Supplement number: 38 CCN: NAP-15423384 Author: 007892 - Toua Yang Supplement of (lift T.Yang #007892 on 1111 5/2015 05:22 On the listed date and time. While working merited squad 421 with my partner Officer Ledman. we responded to a help call at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Upon arrival assisted in securing the scene. Once the scene was secured. per Sgt. Brown. entered the mentioned building with other of?cers to interview any possibie witnesses. knocked on units 301, 302. 303. and 304. made contact with tenants in 302 and 304 and asked them if they saw or heard anything. Neither of the tenants in 302 and 304 saw or heard anything. I then returned to the perimeter of the scene. While outside a large crowd formed on the southwest corner of Plymouth Ave and James Ave N. The crowd was shouting and becoming verbally aggressive. The crowd proceeded to breach the crime scene perimeter. Per Sgt. Brown, i positioned my squad facing the crowd with all lights on and squad MVR activated i then assisted other of?cers resecure the scene. perimeter. After Car 21 processed the scene. per Sgt. Mcbride, i moved and parked the HCMC car back in the 4th precinct lot. . I was then released from the scene. End of Report. END of Supplement 38 .. 1 .1 1 5/2015 Supplement number: 39 CON: Author: 007113 - Jeffrey Sworski Supplement of Off J.Sworsl8 65% 0? ?e?az?ch Meisha He was not the victim. He was preventing HIS victim from getting help from paramedics. He attacked the police and got shot. Oh One less criminal running the streets hurting people. He was handcuffed after he was shot which is STANDARD PROCEDURE. have a degree in CRIMINAL JUSTICE. I know what I am talking about. Plus was there leaving the ELKS and aeen the whole thing. The POLICE did nothing wrong. Now I am for standing up for what is right, but JAMAR was in the wrong a almmusagu a Liz Oppenheimer - Depends on if you believe cops who say there was a scuffle, or witnesses who say there wasn't; the media or the people {a Ir?r?? (a .lf3Lll :3 gig: I Meisha A was a witness .2 nous-*3 ago I Colleen DeeTee You should contact the BCA then Meisha. hours Reques inessenger Nk?incahons MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-18-2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Tameisha Louise (TB) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (CO) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO The date is November 2015. The time right now is 12:20 in the afternoon. I?m currently at the home of Tameisha Sherell Louise Byrd. Uh, spelling on that is uh, Sherrill Louise and is B-Y-R-D, with a date of birth of . and h, Tameisha did I actually, uh, articulate your name and birth date correctly? TB Yes. CO Okay. And you're currently residing at 329 30th Avenue North. TB Yup. CO Minneapolis, 55411. TB Um-hm. CO And your cell phone number?s? TB Yes. CO Okay. And uh, you are aware why we wanna talk to you today, is that right? TB Yup, the shooting. CO Okay. This is for the record. This is BCA Case 2015-648. And so I haven?t really asked you any questions specific to the shooting prior to turning this tape recorder on is that right? TB Correct. CO Okay. Just in your own words, uh, articulate to me what it is you observed um, what day of the week it was. Urn. TB I was going to the Elk?s to pick up my aunt and her very intoxicated people friends, boyfriend and another friend. Uh, I pulled up outside. I was waiting on them to come out. I noticed there was a commotion but I wasn?t paying too much attention to it. CO And by commotion, what did you see? TB Um, fighting. CO Okay. TB Um, there was you know, ambulance, police, but to me I?ve kinda gotten used to it, it?s north side. I'm from south Minneapolis. CO Okay. Page 1 of 14 80, I?ve kinda gotten used, kinda gotten used to it. Um, since I?ve been livin? over here. Um, it wasn?t until my aunt said somethin? to me and I happened to start paying attention, thing, the you wanna call him, the victim. Um. wrestling and tussling with the police. Do you know this person?s name? That, that got shot? learned it from the news. Okay. But it isn?t someone that was known to you before that? No. Okay. Um, and then the gun went off. And then everything was getting cleaned out, pushed away, police were tryin? to clear the scene. I left. Okay, so I?m gonna get But no, I did not see as everybody?s saying, the handcuffs. I didn?t see any handcuffs on him. Okay. Um, from where was angled at, that?s not to say there wasn?t, but I didn?t see any. Okay. So lemme uh, back up a little bit. Do you remember what time this was? That you showed up at Elk?s? Um. And if you don?t know the exact I don?t remember the time real clear. ljust know my aunt called me. I was at home in the bed. She?s like, please come get me. Okay, what?s your aunt?s name? Oof, she?s gonna kill me if I tell you her name. Uh, you understand the importance of this right? Yes. Okay. I mean this Her name is Shawna. I?m sorry, what was that? Shauna. Shauna? And last name? Uh, what is she now? She?s done married so many people give me a second. Okay. (laughs) She?s love bein? married. Oh my God. How you spell it? (inaudible) L-O-U or somethin' like that? French? Lungula? No. Page 2 of 14 Lungelou. Lungelou? lt?s somethin' like that. She (inaudible) too many letters in that name. So this is like your mother?s sister? My mom?s (inaudible) yeah. Okay. And uh, how old is she? Roughly. In her 50?s. Okay. Does she live on the north side? I mean you were gonna drive her home. Uh-hm. She lives on the north side. Where does she live? She lives off of Penn. Penn? Yeah. She lives right on Penn? What intersection of. What?s that, Golden Valley? Golden Valley Road? Um?hm. Okay. Do you know the address? No. ljust know how to get there (laug Okay. he). I don?t write my aunt letters or anything. Alright. You got a cell phone number for Shauna? Um, not off-hand. Okay. So she didn?t see anything though? Was she in the Elk?s Club when this happened? She was coming out. Okay. But I don?t think she seen anything. She was just talking and she was just entirely intoxicated. Okay. And then she said somethin?. ljust happened to look up and over and that?s when i seen all of it. Oh damn, okay. Then I heard POW. Was, was she standing next to you when this happened? Well her back was. Okay so she wasn?t facing. Yeah, she wasn?t facing. But after the POW she was probably looking right? She got scared, she?s like what?s up? Page 3 of 14 Okay. She didin?t, she wasn?t, like I said she wasn?t payin? attention. She didn?t knowlwhat it was, and it wasn?t ?til later I told her it was the police and a guy. She thought it was Just some random people shootin? at each othere. Alright so when you arrived, did you go in to the Elk's Club? Oh no. Okay. I was not gonna (inaudible) in there. How did you contact her to let her know that you were there? Um, I tipped her a text. Okay. What time. And told her I was outside. Okay. And she said okay, here we come. And where did you park? I went around and then I ended upjust stoppin? in front of the building. Okay, so you were facing west or east? If you were parked on the same side of the street as the Elk?s. Um-hm. So you would?ve headed west towards like Golden Valley or towards you know. Penn. Okay. Towards Penn. Yes. Okay. I?m tryin' to think I see look I?m directionally challenged. Well you weren't facing 94. You were facing uh, the other way. Yeah. Okay. I?m, I?m directionally challenged, and I?m still tryin? to understand why 94 east and west. ls going north and south? Yeah (laughs). You?re not the only person that have wondered that. So uh, you?re, you?re on literally parked right in front of the Elk?s. Yes right in front, ?cuz I just was pullin? up, want them to hop in. What kind of car were you driving? Uh, the Jeep outside. Okay. What year is that? Page4of14 2000? Somethin?? Older Jeep? 2002? I think somethin? like that. What color is it? I think it's blue. Yeah it's blue. Okay. (inaudible) So you showed up alone, and you were there to pick up Shauna. And anyone else? Her boyfriend and herfriend. I don?t know her friend?s name. Okay. What?s her boyfriend?s name. Or now I thought Shauna just got re-married. (inaudible) She?s been married, they?re separated. Okay. Alright. So the (inaudible) Who?s the boyfriend? His name is Curtis. Curtis with a Um-hm. I don?t know his last name ?cuz I don?t know too much about him, and I don?t too much care for him. So was, were both Curtis and And then her friend. Plus friend. Okay. And a female friend? Um-hm. Who?s name you don't know? I don?t know her. Did they all get delivered then to Shauna?s house? Um-hm. Dropped ?em off and then kept goin?. I Okay. So were they all standing there uh, when this gunshot went off? Just my aunt. Okay. They were takin? their time comin? up the steps. Okay. ?Cuz I guess there was lady that was urn, in a walker tryin? to get up the steps and it was takin? her a little bit of time. Okay. I understand. And so let?s, as soon as you heard uh, what you know to be gun fire right? Um?hm. Page 5 of 14 Um, did you have a, a, and you were standing at relative to the front door of the Elk?s, were you standing right at the front door? Or were you on the street? I was on the street. i stayed in the car. Okay. So you were in the car seated. Yes. I was in the car. I didn?t wanna get out because i didn?t want the police pull, like you know give me a ticket or anything. So is this happening as you look out your window to your left, or was it behind you? was just lookin? out the window. I was (inaudible) just look. How many feet away do you suspect the ambulance was from you? i don?t know. Well let?s uh, maybe kinda from like this wall of your house to that white door there, do you suspect that it was that distance, closer? Mm, a little closer. Little closer? Yeah. I don?t know how many feet, inches, (inaudible). So I?m 6 feet tall, 6 feet and change. Uaughs) So if you were to stack a bunch of me uh, in between the ambulance and you. I?d 4 or 5? Yeah. ?Bout4. So. 4 and some change. Like you like to say. Okay 4. Okay so you think maybe between 20 and 30 feet? Yeah. And how, do you remember the lighting? Uh, wa-, was there a street light, was there, was it dark? It was, medium light ?cuz I mean the Elk?s is pretty bright in front of the Elk?s. Okay. But across the street it's always been like kinda darkish, Okay. there. Right. Um. Okay. And so uh, when (inaudible) did you see the officers arrive, or when you got there was there a marked squad and, and officers present? There was already I think an officer there. But like I said, when I pulled up, I text her, let her know I was outside, and was dinking around on my phone on Facebook. Page 6 of 14 Okay. And then I happened to look up, and (inaudible) oh okay and i looked back down. And when you looked up what did you see. Um, them tryin? to get him away from the, the ambulance. Okay, so them meaning the police were tryin' to Yeah. So ljust thought maybe, in my head I was like oh, he?s worried about whoever was in there. So then ljust started messin? with my phone again. And that?s when my aunt came out. She came around, she was talkin' to me, and (noises) I?m like okay, and I looked at her and was lookin? past her ?cuz I was hopin? she?d shut up and get in the car. She was standing outside your car. Yeah. And I was hopin' she. With her back to the ambulance. Yeah. Okay. So l?m talkin? to her and I'm lookin? past her like please shut up and just get in the car. And then that?s when I seen the struggle. Then I heard (noise) and was like OH. (laughs). Okay. (inaudible laughing). Alright. don?t like gun shot, like I don?t even know howl got in, got into, wanted to get into this buildin?. I can?t handle a gun shot (laughs). So you, did you hear, uh, the, the person that got shot, his name uh, did you hear any dialogue, any conversations goin? on? Stop Arthur. Come here. Um, no. Did you hear any yelling, (inaudible) hey. No. No. Like I said I wasn?t too much paying attention, tryin? not to pay too much attention to it. was just on my phone on Facebook. Hey baby. I was, go sit down and watch your cartoon. And do not make a mess with them chips. Um, I was watchin? on my Face, was messin around with Facebook. Just checkin' out everything. Like I said I occasionally would look up, but oh okay. And then when my aunt came to the car, she was just drunk talkin?. was just like, please shut up and get in the car. Okay. And I was just lookin? past her and then I saw the (inaudible) strugglin?. was like oh (inaudible). Uh, when you said you see ?em strugglin?, were they standing or were they on the ground or what wou-, what did that struggle look like? Page 7 of 14 They started like they were up. Like standin? up. And then they end up on the ground. And then that?s when I heard the gun shot. She kinda like shifted her body a little bit. ?Cuz i seen the struggling, they were tussling or whatever and then boom. Okay. (inaudible) gonna try to get into the most details I can about the tussle. Could you tell uh, if, if, who was hanging onto whom? Could you tell if the officers had a hold of this uh, person? Um. They had a hold on him, and he was fighting back tryin? to get away. Alright. And what, what part of the, his body were they holding onto? And if you don?t recall, that?s okay, (inaudible, small child talking over). Sittin' here tryin? to think, i, that I don?t. Okay. But initially the struggle involved all three people standing. There?s 2 uniformed police officers. And then him. And do you remember what he was wearing? No. l, I occasionally, like I said I was occasionally glancin? overthere, and didn?t really like take (inaudible). I didn?t it was gonna get this serious. Okay. I didn?t think people were gonna start blockin? 94 and. Okay. Forgettin? about his victim and. Okay. So uh, did the, uh, uniformed officers, did they (child screaming). Shh. Sorry. He?s feelin? better (laughs). Did the uniformed officers uh, did they uh, were they wearing uniforms, police uniforms? Um-hm. Both of ?em? Um-hm. And that squad, do you, presume that they were in uh, was that a marked squad? Did it have lights? Was it unmarked? Was it uh/ It had lights. Okay. And were the lights on or off. The overhead uh, emergency lights. That I don?t remember. Okay. And was there uh, was there any more vehicles? 80 you got an ambulance, and you?ve got a police car, and were there any other vehicles? There was just like a bunch of cars, like people comin? and goin?. Okay. You know, pickin? up people. But I?m talking like uh, first aid vehicles and/or emergency vehicles. Was there one police car? Page 8 of14 first I, l, oh my God, at first I think it was just one. But afterthe gun shot theyjust came out of nowhere. Okay. And then that?s when we were, they were like tryin? to get everybody out, ?cuz like I said once the gun shot hit, everybody started scramblin?, movin? around and. Did a lot 0 fpeople come out of the Elk's when that happened? Uh, whoever was, I guess who was ever, when was told from, ?cuz I know one of the bouncers there, whoever was already in the hallway got pushed out, whoever was in there had to, you know stay and then they put the rest of ?em out the back door. Okay. 80. And then, I think I already asked you this, but when you arrived, were the uniformed police officers already uh talkin? to this person? Or did they show up after you arrived? Mm. If you don?t remember that?s okay. When you first pulled up there did you notice that, the presence of uh, police? Yes. You did. Okay. And they seemed more like they were tryin? to like calm him down at first, like come on let?s go. I couldn?t hear nothin?. I had my old music up. Okay. And (inaudible) probably one of them angry people that you hear comin? down the street, boom, boom, boom, (laughs). Okay. But at some point you turn the music Yeah. you had to talk to your aunt. Yeah. Okay. But I still, like 1 said, she was loud, and she was that loud drunk talk or whatever so I couldn?t hear anything like what was, like goin? on over there. Did you, at any point, see uh, uh, anyone with their uh, did you see any firearms. Did you see any uh weapons of any kind. Um?um. No weapons. Did you see any handcuffs at any, of any. No. Okay. And when I talked to you briefly on the phone yesterday as we were setting up this appointment, you told me, in your estimation, he didn?t have handcuffs on and you?re basing that on what? Could you see his hands? The I seen his hands moving, that?s why I said I don?t Okay, so. Page 9 of 14 had cuffs on ?cuz I seen his hands moving. Okay. Shh. And by his hands you mean the, the person that was shot. Yes. Okay. (inaudible) the victim. Okay. Jamar whatever. And how soon after you saw his hands moving did the officers try to take him to the ground? Was that kind It was kind of instantly. (inaudible) the struggle, his hands were moving. Did, were they saying anything to him that you recall? Not that I recall. Okay. Um, and dur?, there, there was some kind of fight that happened, is that an accurate uh, description or a struggle? Between the vicim and the police officers? Yeah. Yes. And do you know how long (inaudible, child talking over agent). Do you know how long that might've, that struggle would?ve lasted? You?re, you?re best guess was it 5 minutes, was it one minute, was it 10 seconds? It was a very short struggle. Like it was, l?d say, lwouldn?t say 5 minutes. Do you want some candy? Do you want some candy? Want some chocolate? If you want some chocolate you gotta go watch cartoons. (inaudible). I?m sorry. That?s alright. if you need to take a break you can go ahead. (child speaking) okay, you gotta be quiet. 30 uh, what you?re describing is a short struggle. Uh?hm. And uh, do you think um, were you watching it because you were interested or did you intentionally turn away or what was your? There was, like, like I said, initially I kinda like glanced over there and was like, hm, and then I looked away and it wasn?t ?til I started really turn and Iookin? past my aunt, seein? they were strugglin? and fightin?, was like oh this might be gettin? a little serious. Um?hm. And then I heard the, the gun shot. Okay. Page 10 of14 Um, but like I said, I seen his hands moving. So. I didn't see any handcuffs, Okay. hands were moving. (inaudible) he can?t have handcuffs on. Okay. I?m just sayin?. Okay. Alright. I mean it?s kinda. You saw his hands Yeah. front of his body. Yeah. Okay. And then people are like, well he had handcuffs on him at the end. And I?m just like well if he did, from what I learned in school, that?s kinda like standard procedure. You still gotta cuff the suspect. Okay. Even after they've been shot, I mean, that?s what they taught me in school. (inaudible) be alive but. But you didn?t see anyone putting handcuffs on him. No. Alright. And you didn?t see any handcuffs at the scene. Um-hm. Nor did you see any firearms. Just, didin?t see anything. Okay. I just heard it. Alright. Um, how long did it take you to leave then after that, because then you were waiting for two more people. Did Shauna get in right away? Um?hm. She staggered her butt into the front and then I?d say about less than a minute later, her boyfriend and her friend got in and then ljust took off. Okay. And did you see any kind of, of first aid efforts being uh, uh, did you occasion to look at the (inaudible). I didn?t, after that I did not look overthere. Okay. I?m not gonna lie, after that I did not look. Okay. So we didn?t uh, you didn?t look because you didn?t want to or? Page 11 of 14 didn?t want to. I didn?t wanna see. I, l, Was, so, Shauna (inaudible) or were there discussions in the car about what happened? Oh no. It got quiet after the gun shot, it got quiet. Okay. And to this day we still haven?t about, we just talked about what we see on the news. Okay. But other than that, that night uh?uh. We have not discussed it (inaudible child talking). Were you afraid? Yes. Okay. Um, what was happening to the crowd? They were, they were goin? crazy for awhile then it seemed like they were tryin? to start like a little mini riot. Oh fuck the police, ya'll shot that boy in the head, and, immediately the (inaudible) started like immediately. (inaudible) why don?t you get outta there. ?Cuz I didn?t know what was gonna happen. And I feel like people have been, like, low key waiting to start like another Ferguson, part 2. You know, and that's not necessary. Okay. Um. Have you talked, I notice you posted somethin? on social media. Yeah. Uh, have you talked to anyone uh, about this event. I mean you made those postings. Have you talked to Shauna about this since. Um-hm. Oh, okay. Alright. Yeah I made a post on (inaudible) itjust seems like everybody?s just like, you know, the police were in the wrong, like but ya?ll don?t know what happened. You know like ya?ll don?t know, nobody knows except for the police officers what happened during that struggle. Um-hm. You know, (inaudible) the man reached for his gun, and he, you know, reached for the officer?s gun and the other officer was protecting his partner. We, we don?t nobody know except for these officers, what happened during that struggle. In your estimation is it possible that a scenario like that coulda happened? Yeah. Okay. Did it look to you like maybe that was happening? I couldn?t see. Okay. But you know, you ne-, But you saw a struggle. Yeah. But you never know what somebody is thinking during a struggle with a police officer. Okay. Page 12 of14 You know, so. Especially ones who don?t have a care in the world for the police. Okay. Think of anything else? He?s just over there listening, doodling (laughs). I?m the catch-all, I catch all the things we forget to ask. (laughing) So you didn?t hear any conversation whatsoever? Was your radio too loud or were you too far away. I think i was a little too far away and then I had (inaudible). And I had my music on and you know I really, like I said I really wasn?t paying attention. Until I happened to glance over there and look and then I started looking when my aunt came and got in my face and was tryin? to get her to just get in the car. The officers, were they dressed the same or were they dressed differently. i don?t remember that. Okay. I don?t remember that. But you do rememberthey were, appeared to be in uniform. Yes. Okay. Were there any other, uh besides the, the two officers, were there any other people in uniform, uh, out at that scene that you remember? No. Okay. Not thatl recall. Alright. You didn?t see any paramedics outside of the paramedic rig? Not that I recall. Okay. Alright. ls there anything about this event that you think, or that I've neglect, orl haven?t asked you about that?s important that we should know? Um-um. Do you have any other people that have come to you and said they also saw it? Are there any other people that have said yeah I saw it happen? Yeah but they?re, they?re, they?re, but they?re the FTP crew. Okay. You know what that means. Um-hm. (Several talking) Yeah let's not indoctrinate him. Um, so who are those people that said they saw it and, and, are, are they? It?s just on Facebook. Page 13 of 14 Okay. You know like the argument back and forth on Facebook. Okay. Social media (inaudible) Yes. Alright. So you didn?t notice anybody that you knew there that night? Um-hm. Okay. Alright. I mean, and it?s like, I mean I know a lotta people that are in the Elk?s but that?s my spot. Like I go there and l, ljust like to think it?s low key that there?s no violence, so, but this to happen across the street is totally new, you know. So, you?re makin' a mess son. 80 Tameisha, are you, are you workin? right now? Not at the moment. Okay. I'm a, 1 don't work because of my back. Okay. Um, and I talked to your sister briefly and she had nothin? to do with this right? She wasn?t even there. Okay. She called me, she?s like oh my God ?meisha. Alright. And was nervous. (inaudible) why are they looking for me? What did i do. I?m good. Uh, alright, I think I?m gonna end the statement, (inaudible). The time is uh 12:42. END OF RECORDING Page 14 of14 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/9 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Primary Information Description: Lavell Bible statement Occurrence From: 1111812015 13:51 Occurrence To: 11l18/2015 14:31 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11l23/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis I On Wednesday, November 18, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane interviewed Lavell Rossell Bible. Item 9.1 (audio CD of statement) obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 6125 SHINGLE Primary Information Address: 6125 SHINGLE CREEK PKWY, Brooklyn Center, Minnesota 55430 United States Description: Hennepin County Government Building. Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Bible, Primary Information Subject Name: Bibte, Lavell Rossell Record Type: Person Bio: . lack, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 922 VINCENT AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address PHONE Property #1 - Audio CD - Bible statement Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD - Bible statement Property Status: HQ Status Date: 11l18l2015 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 013 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/9 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #1 - Audio CD - Bible statement Continued Primary Information - Continued Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Property #2 - 5 digital photographs of Bible Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: 5 digital photographs from the telephone of Bible Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 1111812015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Property/#3 4 Diagram by Bible'of scene Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Correspondence Description: Diagram by Bible of scene Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: in 11118172015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Record Status Information OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/18/2015 21 :44 Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Apprehension) Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 13:21 Reporting LEO Date SUpervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Narrative-begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 2 of 3 On Wednesday, November 18, 2015, at about 1345 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane met with Lavell Bible at the Hennepin County Library located in Brooklyn Center, MN. SA Olson previously learned Bible contacted the MN BCA Communications Center indicating he witnessed the shooting of Jamar Clark. SA Kane made arrangements with Bible to meet at the library. Bible was interviewed in a private meeting room. The taped interview with Bible began at about 1351 hours and concluded at about 1431 hours. This audio file was later transferred to CD by SA Olson and will be preserved as item 9.1. During this interview Bible indicated he took ?ve cellular telephone photographs at the scene. During the interview Bible sent those photographs to SA Kane, who in turn later forwarded them to SA Olson. SA Olson has preserved the ?ve digital photographs as item 9.2. Also during the interview, and at the request of SA Olson, Bible generated a diagram of the scene noting where he was standing in relation to the ambulance, squad car (424), and the of?cers Jamar Clark. This diagram will be preserved by SA Olson as item 9.3. Bible indicated that he was standing near the front door of the Elks Lodge when observed the shorter of the two of?cer?s handcuff Clark before the uniformed of?cers brought Clark to the ground. He reported he observed what he believed to be about a 5 10 second struggle between of?cers and Clark before Clark was shot. He indicated he could not tell which officer discharged his firearm. (See attached transcript for complete details). Bible was encouraged to re?contact SA Olson if he knew of any other persons that may have witnessed this incident. End report. . . . .. mu?- w-w .i . m- Wm (045 (kw mmo?S MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 18, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Laveil Bible (LB) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Chris Olson (CO) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO Todays' date is November 18, 2015, Wednesday. Uh we?re currently at the Hennepin County Library in Brooklyn Center. Present in a private meeting room is Lavell, uh is it Ro?, LB Rossell, yeah. CO Rossell Bible, spelling of Lavell is uh middle name Bible, common spelling, date of hint-and um this regarding BCA Case Number 2015- 648. Lavell uh we just had a couple uh conversations with you on the phone setting up this meeting. LB Yes sir. CO Is that right? LB Yes sir. CO We haven't talked about the details why you?re here or what it is um that you observed on uh was that Sunday morning? LB Uh yeah early Sunday morning. CO Okay and specific, or let me go through your addresses here. You?re uh getting mail at 3655 West Broadway in Minneapolis, 55422. is that right? LB Uh, yes sir. CO And your uh actual uh address that you reside at is 922 Vincent Avenue North, Minneapolis, 55411. LB Yes sir. co And you cell phone is- LB Uh, yes sir. CO Okay and the time right now is approximately 1351 hours. So Lavell we understand, we?ve learned that you uh observed this event occur out on Plymouth Avenue. LB Yeah, yes I did. CO On the 15th in the early morning hours, what uh in your own words describe what you, how you got there, why you were there, what you saw. LB Um, I drove there. There?s uh, there's a bar there called the Elks, Elks Lodge. CO Yep. Olson Page 1 of 18 Olson Um, the Elk closes like 2:30-2:45 so we were exiting the bar um i was walking with a couple of people. was by myself though and when we came out we seen a ambulance and a squad car pulling up and i didn?t really pay attention to it. l?m not quite sure if the squad car was pulling up but the officers walkin? up then wal-, I observed the officers walk up and there was a young man with dreads. I don?t know if there was dreads or braids and they walked up to him. They were sittin? maybe, they stopped ?em and they was like, kind a like reversing kind a like me and you sittin? right here and he was sittin? right here and they were having conversation talking like this and like this and by his body language he was just like whatever it wasn?t aggressive or noth-, they had a conversation. The officers were on either side of ?em? Either side of ?em he We?re tape recording it so we have ta kind a discribe (inaudible). Yep, yep, he was, his back was to the building behind ?em, and the officer?s back was to the street, to the Elks where we was coming out of and he was like between ?em and so they were conversatin? and talking or whatever then the officer on the right moved to ?em and turned him around so he was facing like he facing like this and turned ?em around like this and cuffed ?em and then we just like this and then we was because this like, like a normal takeover here so we?re watching but we?re kind a, kind a was odd that after, afterthe officer cuffed ?em the officer kind a stood up, one officer on the left kind a stepped back and the other officer on the right went in more and grabbed ?em in a choke hold and they were kind a was more thing, he wasn?t like when you grab 'em in a choke hold he wasn?t, he had ?em in a choke hold but he kind a went from position to get a better grip and he picked ?em up and slammed ?em on the ground and when he slammed ?em on the ground both of the officers fell on top of ?em and so then they like a little struggle was going on, not on his part because he was already cuffed but I remember seeing the officer?s back to ?em like he was wrestling he was getting leverage on his toes, picking up his, picking up his arms like picking up his arms doing somethin? and then by the time we had got, we had gotten a wall by this time and we was like, man what?s going on, I?m like they?re just doing this trying to make an example for us, you know what l?m saying. 80 then a couple people kind a (inaudible) we started voicing ourselves like hold on what?s going on we just heard a shot ?bow? and then peop?, then it was just kind a like and people looked and then the officer stood up and just left ?em and the officer stood up and he just was just lay there and then we were just kind a like bit the two girl, the two girls ran across the street to try ta see what was going on and all of a sudden a weap-, up (inaudible) weapon and told them to back up and then it was just So he pointed his gun at them? Yeah, he pointed his gun at the girls running across the street told ?em to back up. Okay. And then by that time I kind a was gettin? just so what had just happened and I started takin? pi-, I took a few pictures. How close were you to this when it all went down? Um, maybe 40, maybe 40 feet away, 30 feet, 30 feet away Could you hear any conversation between the person with the dread looks or the police officers? Did you hear what anybody was saying if anything? Nah, I couldn?t hear what was saying. I can just go by body language and when, when duing during no time did a confrontation of where what was happenin? was he aggressive like, like leave me alone and nothin? like that hejust kind a had like a lack-se?daisy attitude like, here we go again and even when they, even when they spun ?em around and cuffed him it was Page 2 of 18 Olson 2015-648-A02 just like and then when they slammed, when they slammed ?em to, when he, when he picked ?em up and slammed ?em to the ground and rolled ?em and doin? to the, rolled ?em over on the thing, cuz I?ve been in altercations before like how you sometime you don?t wanna be arrested and your body?s tight and your fightin? being handcuffed. It was none of that. He would just, like that man wouldn?t and thing like, the thing is like right here the picture you see, he pretty, he when be right here that?s him on the ground right here, that?s the whole position he was in the whole time so when it got, when they got up and when they got up and left ?em, they didn?t? move ?em and the whole time you could see if the things his He?s up in the grass right? Yeah, he?s right there, right like that?s like the sidewalk right there and he?s like right on the edge of the sidewalk to the grass you could clearly see his hands are handcuffed behind his back. Okay I see I was gonna clarify that you keep every time you say he was handcuffed you keep showing me the by putting your hands behind your back. Yeah. He was handcuffed behind his back. Yeah he was handcuffed behind his, his head Both, both hands were handcuffed? Yeah, cuz when they, when they, when they walked toward ?em the spun ?em like turn ?em towards you know how they turn to ya (inaudible) cops, the police officer step in and they handcuff you. That?s how he was handcuffed and they make him turn back around and then he, the office stepped back in and grabbed ?em around his neck and it wasn?tjust like a grab around your neck, he grabbed 'em and he kind a positioned himself to get a better like get his chin up under over his elbow and then picked ?em up and slammed ?em on the ground and that, then they all went to the ground and you kind a seen by the action of the officer cuz the officer by that time he was kind a the officer was kinda why this dude just like a skinny dude but you could see the officer like broken up to spin 'em and all of that and I kind a took it like the officer was getting leverage to bend his arms back ta do tall that and then we just had the one I don?t know what the officer was, was doing on the other side and by my thing that's where the shot had to come from because the officer that was with his back to us his arm was kind a occupied was gonna ask you a question. Did you notice if the officers, there?s two of ?em, right? Yeah. Were they wearing the same clothing or were they wearing different clothing? No they were both in, they were both in blue. Okay was it the same color like same shade? Was one in light, one in dark or were they both in dark or both in light? I didn?t, I didn?t (inaudible). I didn?t really cuz you knowjust see the, just see the blue and okay that?s Minneapolis Police and like that so we Did they look similar? Yeah they looked, they looked, (inaudible) Page 3 of 18 Olson 2015-648-A02 They looked similar. 1, I seen when, when after the call was made it seemed like a commander or somethin? like that came on and then his shirt, was like a little bit different, a little bit darker. Okay. ltwasn't white? No, I don?t remember being white. Okay. i don?t remember it being white at all. Butjust for the record since I didn?t do, so also present is Kevin Kane from the FBI. Um, a little house keeping item thereunderstand that officer had, one officer on each arm. is that accurate? Um no when, when, when no when they, when they first handcuffed ?em like the officer on the left kind of like had his back or whatever. So the officer?s backs were to the Elks Lodge. Yeah the officer?s backs were to the Elks Lodge. At some point, they uh the decedent, do you know this person? Nah-uh. Okay so uh that person was turned with his back facing to the Elks Lodge too during the handcuffing process. Is that Not, they didn?t turn his, they not, they didn?t turn ?em to the, back to the lodge they kind a Spun him facing up toward, alright were ls this south? We?re facing towards Penn Avenue. Oh, okay. So like so the squad you see. So that's west. Yeah so they were in to the, they face 'em into cuz you see the, the car right here so the car?s facing this so when they spun ?em they spun ?em into the car so he?s facing this way. When they hu- when they cuffed ?em. Okay. And i don?t really know how if they spun ?em back around and he turned around but eventually he was facing back that way, no matter of fact no he wasn?t, no he wasn?t because he was facing like, he was facing like that and i think like, I don?t, I don?t know how he got there but he was like face that way that?s when the officer got the thing upon his neck. Okay. And picked him up and. There was two officers there. Yeah. Can you discern which officer did that? Can you (inaudible) Um, by memory I think it Were they both, what were the officers, white, black? Page 4 of 18 Olson 2015-648-AO2 UH white I know they were white I?m trying Were they the same size? Was one bigger than the other? The, the one, the one that was doing the slamming was shorter than the other one. Okay. I do remember that. Okay. So just one picture you took? Or are there No, there?s multiple but that right there?s, alright that I think I'm almost Could you text me these pictures? Yep, I?m almost positive that?s the officer right there that was, that had ?em that was lookin? for leverage and, and, and um doin? whatever and that?s the officer that was behind ?much is goin? on it?s kind a minute, cuz see that I wasn't really paying attention I was more watchin' what was happening but i notice the shorter officer that, that was with the leverage on that I remember seeing the blue of his back. Um-hm. His, his blue shirt and l?m thinking, I?m wondering if that officer was involved being the second officer but he was like cuz you know how you got one person that's doin? more and kind a getting more of your attention, so he kind a had more of my attention. Let me go back cuz you?re lookin? at those photographs. When you first arrived did you actually see the uh squad car 424? I noticed you photographed the squad car 424. Did you see that car arrive or was that there when you first? I think and that?s, that?s kind a where I'm sketchy on because I don't know if they had pulled up and they were walkin? up to ?em as we were walkin? up because they was an ambulance there too and there was somethin? else goin? on (inaudible) The ambulance was already there. Yeah, there was an ambulance already there, after the shot the ambulance pulled off. Okay, did, don't I?ll get to that point. Alright. So when you uh arrived uh you thought it was what 2:00-2:30 in the morning or somethin?? No, it was like, like 12:45 - 1 o?clock. Okay, alright so um who were you with? Uh was by myself at the time. Okay, alright and you can?t recall specifically if that car was, that squad car was just arriving or if it was already there. Were there any other emergency vehicles? 80 you have an ambulance, you have a squad car, were there any other emergency No (inaudible) or anything like that? Nah?uh. Okay, so just those two vehicles? Yep. Page 5 of 18 Olson 2015-648-A02 And then as those officers were talking to this person you described as maybe having dread looks or somethin? was there a third person there either uniform or civilian clothing that you can recall? I don?t, 1, I can?t recall cuz I wasn?t really lookin? at the scene, ljust. Okay. ljust. I remember, I remember there was somethin? happenin?. There was like a I conversation. I don?t know if it was like a paramedic or somethin? there was somethln? gonn? on. Okay. But I didn?t really, my mind wasn?t on focus and all like what?s happenin? because it, you never guess you?re about to witness something like this. So like okay this is north Minneapolis. There?s another arrest that?s happening. Okay well just sit back and see the spectacle right quick and then it just went downhill then you don?t register like you?re not lookin? for details and, and then when he, when he, when, like I said when he, when he when he choke slammed him that?s what made me and a few other people across the street try to get involved and made a couple comments like, man therejust doin? it to make an example cuz we?re all coming out to show us that we don?t really mean nothin?. And so then we?re like this and people was like come on and people were yelling, come on, that's uncalled for, that?s uncalled for you don?t have to do all that, what?s goin? on and then like I said out of nowhere it was just like. And how long was that struggle in your estimation cuz you saw all three of ?em on the ground for a while, right? Ten, fifteen, ten seconds, five?ten seconds. Okay. Five-Ten seconds, okay. You didn?t take a movie of this at all? No I wish, I wish I would a. (laugh). I wish, because you don?t think nothin? like this is gonna happen. That?s a hard part of being a Yeah. You don?t know you?re a witness until after something happens. (inaudible) after the fact. (inaudible) consciously thinking i need to remember this stuff. And was trying ta, was trying ta get even better pictures and kind a creep across the street but he's like (laugh) the, the, the vibe was like get away from here. Do you remember specifically which officer might have placed handcuffs on him? Um, it was the shorter one. Okay. And now that I think about it it?s like I think when they, when they turned him around, (inaudible) they did turn ?em around I kind a like remember the other officer being involved so maybe like one officer grabbed this arm and the other officer kind a helped bring the arm together while the one officer cuffed him. Okay. Page 6 of18 Olson Cuz I remember they was both on his back but I remember one, the little shorter officer doin? the majority of the work and after they had ?em cuffed and whatever I don?t know somethin? was said but Ijust remember himkind a stepping back and kind a kind a measuring ?em steppin? in and getting him around his neck and making So the shorter officer in your estimation would a been the person to handcuff ?em and also the person to take him to the ground. Yeah, take ?em to the ground. Did you call it a choke slam? Yep. Okay. Um, and do you think that they, once they were on the ground um you said there was some conversation that, that occurred. Yeah, I, I?m not, I?m not sure Who was doin? the talking? I don?t, I?m not, I?m not knowing, I didn't see no one do no talkin?. Then again Ijust seen the, I?m just okay some one thing that does, I?m did, oh look come on I?m trying ta think cuz I just, I don?t know if it?s just like police shows or I seen somethin? was sayin? quit resisting and I kind a remember that. I kind a rememba?, he?s not resisting. Okay, but you heard someone say quit resisting. I?m not, I?m not positive. I think I might of, I might of but I?m not, I?m not sure sure. I?m not, cuz I, I do remember, I do remember people comment like we said, he?s not resisting. What ya mean he?s not resisting. So I kind a think it might?ve came up you know what I?m sayin? but I know we was sayin? he?s not resisting what you mean he?s not resisting. So were the police saying stop resisting or were the people standing around (inaudible). I think, I think one of the cops, officer might have said stop resisting. Okay. Do you remember the sub?, the victim saying anything? No, he was whole attitude, his whole attitude the whole time was like he ain?t, it was just like here we go again Okay. I don?t remember him saying nothing, even, even when he, when they picked him up and slammed him on the ground I don?t remember him like no grunt or ?ugh? or nothing it was just like he was waiting to be arrested like get it over with even when he, they cuffed ?em he was never aggressive or. Okay now what makes you think there was a struggle on the ground. What, what were you seeing that led you to believe there it was a struggle? I?m not, not saying it was like to me it wasn?t no struggle to me. It was abuse to me. It was like once they slam ?em, once they slam ?em on the ground. Was he on his stomach or his back at that point? (inaudible) when, when, when he picked ?em up to slam him on the ground they slammed on his back. Okay. But then the officerthat got choke slammed him dropped down with him and kind a remembered me of a wrestling match. Okay. Page 7 of 18 Olson And I remember him gettin? position and getting leverage and then you could see by the force pushing his body fonlvard and rollin? him, him rollin? him over or whatever. Then I just remember it?s So they rolled him over on his stomach? Yeah. Okay. The way, the way he is in that picture, he didn?t move after, after the shot was they got up and just left him, my thing, When they left him, how was he laying, on his stomach or on his back? On his stomach, the right, the way it went in, right the way he is right there and they just stood and then, and then they just stood up and I don?t? know what was said or (inaudible) come and see and then the ambulance pulled away and nobody, everybody was like, they just shot, they just shot 'em and my concern was like they didn?t check to see if had a pulse. They didn?t check, they just like left him there like a dog, like it was just like they So let me ask ya when he was shot when the gun fired, when you heard the gunfire, was he uh on his stomach or his back? No, he was, he was on his stomach just the way, the waythis picturelaying in this picture right here was Okay. A minute or two after the gunshot and that?s, they didn't move ?em. Would you send me that picture right now? Yeah. Just text it ta. Let me know when you?re ready. (inaudible) Maybe send all of ?em here. Yeah, I?m gonna send all of ?em. Okay. (inaudible) look at it on this phone while we?re talking about it. Okay. (inaudible) right now. So Lavell and l, I, I appreciate you meetin' with me and doing this but ljust wanna go through every detail that I can. So you arrived. You saw the shorter officer choke slam him and he initially went on his back and then as he was on his back, l?m trying to get the positon of both officershis back or one was? Alright, the one, alright cuz like, so this was, this would a been the officer to me so when he choke slammed ?em, when he choked slammed ?em he choked slammed ?em like this so as he choke slammed ?em he went down with him so then he got like in weapon position like, like this and I?m guessing what he did by then is turn him over but ljust remember his, he, he like arched his back and got up on his toes like he was get?, doin? somethin? or gettin? leverage. Okay and this is the officer that choked slammed him? Yeah. Page 8 of18 Olson Alright the other officer how was he positioned? Um, um, I?m, I?m not sure. Okay. Because the officer, cuz like the officer that chokes him he was kind a wide. He?s kind a buny. He was uh someone described him as buff. Yeah he was, yeah he was burly. Okay. And so like and the way he was positioned when he had them on the ground is like when you're wrestling like when you?re like pinning someone, like when you're pinning someone and you?re up on your toes and you?re getting leverage to force all your weight down and his back was kind a expanded so you couldn't really see what the officer, other of?cer other side was doin'. So block was, your View was blocked maybe by the girth or the Yeah what he was doin?, i don?t know if he was laying down next to him or whatever and most, most of my attention was focused on the one officer doin? all the arm bending, the you know what I?m saying then in. So the, the position that you were again, just ta uh so l'm clear on this, where were you standing? Alright I You wanna draw a map. Yeah. (inaudible) piece of paper here. Like i say this Draw Plymouth Avenue. This is Plymouth Avenue. And just for fun make a north arrow. Alright, Just put an arrow north. Alright. Okay, there ya go. This is apartment, this is the apartment complex. The apartment complex is on the north side. Yep. Okay. So I?ll Well actually yeah, okay. No there on the south side. The apartments are on the south side. The Elks Club is on the north side. Alright so I?d say, I would Page 9 of 18 Olson Just change the arrow, just change the arrow. I would say this way is Penn Avenue. Alright, alright, so cross out that and make an 8 there. Alright. Turn that into an 8. There ya? go. Perfect. Yep it would be on the south side, yep south side cuz it?s facing the south side. Alright here goes like the like I say the little grass area. Yep. Here?s the sidewalk. Okay. Whatever, I did the, he may, the Elks? like say right, it?s pretty much right in the middle of the block. And there?s a little driveway, there?s a little driveway right here. Yeah, i think Knox is right here, right? Yeah. Okay. And Make an where you?re standing or (inaudible). Okay so this is I should a made like a sidewalk. . You?re not gonna be, you?re not gonna be graded on this so don?t worry about it. Yep, so I?m right, l?m like right here. Right by the front door. Right by the front door, the front door is right here. And were you going there just to visit or were you going to pick someone up? Nah, I was coming out. Oh, okay so you were in the club. Yeah i was inside. I was coming out and all this is takin? place right here. Okay, so draw the squad car. Squad car?s about right here. Alright, just put 424 right in that box there. And then uh the ambulance was positioned where? That?s somethin? i don?t remember. I don?t remember. Was the ambulance in front of or behind the squad car? l?m thinkin?, i think the ambulance was in front ofthe squad car. Okay. I?m not, I?m 100 percent sure. Not 100 percent. Page?lO of18 Olson Just put an, just put an A in there. I'm not 100 percent sure but I think the ambulance was in front of the squad car. Were there any other vehicles that you can recall besides the No. and the ambulance? No. Okay and did you have any information to lead you to believe if anyone was in the ambulance? No. I didn't, not at all. The paramedics that normally are with an ambulance, did you happen to see any of them? Or do you might a cuz when I, when I first came, when I, when I first came out we noticed somethin? going on I remember seeing the officers walkin? up. I remember them Okay. Do you think at thatjuncture there may have been a paramedic? There might have been. There cuz, itjust my, I remember like some peoples, somebody standing over here like squad cars right here, right there and then like, like, like this is Like a citizen or you?re thinking an emergency responder? It might be um like the ambulance driver or somethin? like Okay. remember like in a uniform? Yeah, I remember seeing some cuz you know how kind a think back and you Yep. this like I said when we came out somethin? was goin? on and I remember, I remember the two officers. I remember seeing the suspect cuz I seen, cuz when they walked they cuz they walked up and they kind a met the suspect right here and then when during the course of things happening kind a moved a couple feet to the left. Okay so and, and so you, you?re standing right there and you?re on the sidewalk in front the Elks Lodge. Yep. Okay and you?re kind a positioned right in, right in between the squad car is and the ambulance is parked. Yep. Okay and this all took place on the pavement or actually on the grass? On the grass right, right on the edge of the pavement. Okay, alright and were there any people across the street that you No. Page11 of?lS Olson were watching? Nah, nah. Okay and were there any other people standing next to you? Yeah there was, there was like out at out here at the time there was anywhere from 7 to 13- 14 people and plus, and I didn?t know that was like i know exactly there?s like a guy standing next, 2 or 3 guys standing next to me, a couple girls right here. I know there was some more people in the parking lot right here. Do you know their names? No, i don?t. Okay, do you remember any vehicles, either parked or driving by during this? Um, I know there was a few, there, there was a few vehicles exiting, exiting right here. Okay. And then there?s a parking lot, there?s a parking lot right, there?s a parking lot right here. Okay. And I know there was stuff going on so. Okay. Matter of fact I?m almost sure there?s vehicles leavin? cuz I remember matter of fact I remember one vehicle pulling out and going by and then it just kind a got chaotic. Okay, alright um you don?t remember a vehicle parked literally on the sidewalk um right, right in front of or close to you, either a little bit east or a little bit west or right in front of you? You don?t Nah, no, nah, no passenger car? Nah. Okay would you be so kind as to put you initial?s and today's date on there, on that, anywhere on that paper?s fine. Uh today?s the 'l 8?h of November. Alright thank you. Uh and we?re gonna go back to the handcuffs here so you saw uh this guy being handcuffed. Did you actually see the handcuffs? Could you tell what color they were? Were they No, ljust, just by the motion ofthe the clinking You heard the clinking? No, just the motion of having them put on Okay. and ljust, his, his, his arms are closed behind his back like that and then turned ?em around and you, okay he?s handcuffed. Okay, alright and then how long did that process take to handcuff ?em? Was it quick or was it? It was quick, like 5 or 10 seconds. Okay, really quick. Yeah it wasn?t cuz there wasn?t no struggle. Do you remember what this guy was wearing? Pagelz of18 Olson Um, black I remember he?s like black like some black like jeans and like a dark, dark colors. But I do remember his dress more than you know what I?m sayin? I know he had on dark color and I think he had like on, on a go, a lighter color shirt like he had on like a hoody or somethin? and some black jeans and maybe like a white polo shirt or somethin? like that underneath it. So initially he goes down, down on his back. You saw the bigger, the more buff of the two officers flip him over. Yeah, not, not like flip ?em like, like this but like kinda wrestle ?em flip him over like force ?em over like. So you think he was hard to roll over, right? He must?ve Not cuz, cuz my impression was that he was already rolled over cuz like no like when you seen it, cuz like when he first went down and the officer did like this and it seemed like he?s all there but he seemed like he was getting leverage to push his face into the concrete or somethin? like with a, with a shoulder or with a forearm. Okay. Like he's already cuz the dude, the dude wasn?t nothin?, maybe 130 pounds or nothin?, somethin? like that and so that?s why I kind a get involved because the, the force because when the officer got up on his toes and was like arching his back, my impression was he, he was directing weight some place like he was, and his, and my thing was like he was forcing his head in the ground like So when that was happening this, this person was on his back? No, by this time he was on his stomach. Okay, okay so they?re putting weight on him. He?s on his stomach. Um, and then what happened? The shot was fired. Okay, did you see the firearm? Did you see a firearm? No, not at, no time that?s why we was all stuck like and for a minute we didn't, Do you think then that that shot was fired while he was on his stomach? Yeah, that shot was fired while he was on his stomach. Okay. It was it (inaudible) and it was kind a thing cuz it was like where'd the shot come from. And which part of his body was, was fired upon? Do you know? We, we i don?t even know because right after like, like seconds after the shot the officer stood up and then we just seen his prone body. We just seen his prone body laying on the ground. Face down. Face down, face down on his stomach and then our minds are like cuz you know it kind a like takes a second like hold it we just didn?t see what we see I then had the realization like no he?s not shot, he?s not shot, then hejust was laying and this was a matter of seconds then the two girls ran up, then the two girls ran across the street and the one girl, she was I remember she?s bigger girl she wearing like cream colored or white and she almost and she almost got to where he was laying and when the office drew his weapon on ?em and told ?em to back up, back up. Okay. You don?t know those girls. Page 130f18 Olson 2015-648-A02 Nah. Which officer, the, the buff one or the other one? I?m not even sure. Okay. I?m, I?m, I?m my mind was, my mind at this time with a scene that was war like you?re kind a looking like move man, move, like ljust didn?t see you got shot, move somethin?. Okay. Say somethin? you know what l'm sayin?. And then uh so you, you arrived at the Elks Lodge at what time? Um, I wanna say 11:30. Okay, so you?re there for an hour? Like about an hour, yep. Okay and how much have you had to drink at this point? I had a beer. One beer? Yep, I had a beer. Okay so you were not what you would consider to be intoxicated? No, not at all. Under the influence of any controlled substance, anything like that? No, not at all. Okay, alright were you did you arrive with someone or by yourself? By myself. Okay um and this is a regular watering hole for you? No, no ljust some place that a friend had told me to stop down. It?s a old north side hangout and I haven?t been down in about a year, year and a half so I popped up to show my face. Okay, alright. Have you, did you have occasion to talk to people uh on scene there uh after the event to compare what you saw? No, cuz at, we kind a went into a moment of police challenging mode like everybody just started moving together like hold on, you know what I?m sayin? and within minutes like within like 3 or 4 minutes after, after I say maybe 3 minutes after the, after the shooting police just was like started showing up and keepin? everybody away and we just, we just, them people was arguing the frustration of the community, what we just saw and talkin' to people then there?s like a brother advocate that was like, you all come on let?s get out of here just listen, just listen because they?re gonna end up hurting somebody else. Okay so somebody encouraged people to leave, sounds who was that person? Do you know? Um, no I don?t ljust no he?s a dark skinned brother with short hair and. You refer to him as an advocate. Uh, cuz (inaudible) the way he took command of the, the, the pe0ple there, the situation of you all just back up, let?s not and let?s and keep the people cuz people started tempers and Page 14 of18 Olson attitudes started riling up and get closer and closer to challenge the police and he tried ta get everybody together and backin? people up and trying to get people back to the parking lots to cars, cars and. Okay. You know I saw a video there was a guy that was saying brothers, brothers, you know he was trying to get peOpIe to go and I couldn?t tell if it was a police officer or not. Do you think that?s Yeah I think, yeah, yeah I think that might've been. Did, have you seen the video that I?m talking about where the guy is whoever?s taking the video says dirty mother fucker, dirty mother fuckers, over again? I Have you I think he was standing, I think he was That?s not you.You didn?t (inaudible). No, no that?s not me, but I think he was standing to the left of me right out, right outside the door because I kind of Saying that. that. Okay, yeah we?re trying ta, we?re just trying to track down Yeah, yeah. that has video footage ouz that?s very important to us. (inaudible) and you I don?t (inaudible) dude tell me be (inaudible) my mind is like I'm not you know you?d think (inaudible) (inaudible) picture Yeah. And I think, and I think the main reason why I took the pictures because I didn?t want no one to come and try ta move his body or try a thing and it?s not a good but cuz I know it when you?re doing things and when you, when, when you?re like this your arms are like this up like this. (inaudible) hand behind your back. Back like this so and if somethin?s happening and you?re conscious your hands are gonna fall cuz that?s not a regular position. They?re gonna fall to your sides. His hands stayed up on his back like this. When he was down on the ground. When he was, after he had been shot sittin' like this. You can I tell ya because you all got the digital stuff and all that. Yeah. Was see his hands are up and just down just like you know what I?m saying and making sure no one try and take the handcuffs off him or. Page 15 of?l8 Olson Okay. I hate to harp on this stuff but it?s, it?s super important I know we talked about the handcuffs before when they put his arms behind his back. You said that his body language demonstrated to you that he was handcuffed, right? Yeah. And then you said you didn?t actually see the handcuffs right? Nah. You just assumed he was cuz he had his hands the way that they motioned his Kind a behind his back and then when they got done they stayed there. Okay and then and then when he was laying on the ground after the shot went off and they left him there his hands, you, were up on his back as if he was handcuffed. Yeah, they were still up on his back. Did you see the handcuffs on his hands or did you just see the hands up on his back? No, I can just see his But I know it's hard to yeah cuz of nighttime but I just assume I guess an assumption butjust the way his, his hands weren?t, they were like they stayed together, they Yeah, they didn?t fall off. They didn?t fall off of fall on his side they, they stayed together. Okay. Hang on here I?m multitasking. Uh would you be willing to uh share those photos um with me? Uh, yes sir. Okay, Uh he can text ?em to you. Did you send ?em all? Yeah, I sent ?em all (inaudible) Yeah I got em. Yeah I got all of 'em I think here. Can wejust count on there to make sure we have the right amount? I have and I?ll send ?em to you right now to make sure you get ?em. Alright. I've got 5. Yep. Okay. Alright. So and specifically and just ta go over this again you didn't see anyone across the street um in terms of civilians um uh that you can recall? Nah. Alright, okay. When did, when, when, when, when the, the, whatever first happened I?m seeing a couple people walk by like behind me but didn?t know not that I recall sittin? there watching it. Page16 of18 Olson Okay, uh Kevin you got anything else? Is there anybody else that we should talk to that you knew or something? Man, wish, I, I wish I knew them two girls and I heard there?s another video going around facebook but I haven?t been able to see it that that?s like a 5 minute video. So that choke slam uh so you may have motioned uh, um turn your arm into a V. Did they uh was that, did that occur on the uh front side, or the face side of this person or the back side? The, the face side. Okay. Like, like he said when he got his Down by the adam?s apple? Yep, when he got 'em that?s why he kind a adjusted himself to get up under his chin to get a good thing to pick him up and slam him. And so you saw uh the motion of handcuffing, you didn?t actually see the uh handcuffs you didn't actually see any weapon. Is that (inaudible) No, I didn?t see no weapon. Okay, and you don?t know where this person would?ve been shot? Nah. Okay, and the reason you didn?t see because there?s your view was obscured by the officer? Yeah the burly officer that was restrained, restraining ?em or whatever you, what he wants to call it. Okay, alright and you didn?t hear any dialogue uh that, that you can remember? Nah cuz there was no, there was no screaming and yelling. There was no screaming and yelling. He might a had a smart mouth or somethin? on the low down it was across the street but You?re not, you?re basing it on not what you heard but what you think? Yeah the thing about the (inaudible) not only that but cuz you know sometimes when you interaction is some you yell at the police like, man leave me the fuck alone, fuck you all, what the fuck is you all fucking with me for and l?m only across the street so if there?s anything have any value to it 1 would a heard it but there was, it was, they were talking. Okay, alright. It was to me seemed like a civil, a civil interaction. And did any point did you see this guy before the police uh went hands on with ?em? Did you see him uh interacting at all with the ambulance or the paramedics or? I?m, I might of but I didn?t really pay attention. Okay. Cuz we walked out on the scene. Cuz we walked right out to the alley noticing a police squad being there pulling up and we seen somethin? was going on. You know kind a look at it half there but okay you know what I?m sayin? and then it didn?t really it really wasn't nothin' you know got your eyes open looking for a girl you might holler at or you know what I?m sayin' somebody you might know and it didn?t really cause to take attention until they started Page 17of18 with the handcuff the, they started putting him under arrest then my mind kind a focused in okay what?s happening here. The brother might go to jail. CO Okay, alright. KK Did we talk about which officer shot? Did you see which one shot the (inaudible) LB Nah because they, KK You heard the LB We heard the gunshot but nah from my angle from where I?m standing. KK Couldn?t, you couldn't tell (inaudible) LB (lnaudible) uh?uh. (inaudible) I think if it was the officer too me but I don't know cuz, cuz with his movements he was, he was doing a lot like with the leverage and his arms moving so but I think I?d a seen em reach back for a gun but you never know, I don?t. CO Okay, alright. KK Did any officer try to take your phone from you at all? LB No, no i was kinda that?s why I wouldn?t, that?s why when was like this and then when (inaudible) started gettin? blurry because I?m trying to be quick and (laugh). KK Yeah, did you get sprayed with pepper spray at all? LB Um, no I kind a seen that coming when (inaudible) like 15 squad cars came up (inaudible) kind a made that turn towards the Elks with that little aggressive like l?m like okay maybe I should back up here. KK (laugh) CO It?s a smart man there, eh? Well I?m uh I don't think I have any more questions for you at this time. If I do have a question uh that should come up later can I re-contact you? LB Uh, yes you can. 00 Okay. KK And if you talk to somebody in the meantime that you think we should talk LB Alright, alright. KK give us a call and let us know and I?ll call ya back. LB Yeah. CO Alright, I?m gonna end this statement now at 1430 hours. END OF TAPE. Olson 2015-648-A02 Page180f18 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/10 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Primary Information Description: Jerome Copeland statement Occurrence From: 11/18/2015 16:38 Occurrence To: 11/18/2015 17:03 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Wednesday, November 18, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane interview Jerome C. Copeland. Item 10.1 (audio CD of interview) was obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1101 BROADWAY ST Primary Information Address: 1101 BROADWAY ST, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Description: Employment and housing help center Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 a COpeI?and, JeromeC . Primary information Subject Name: Copeland, Jerome Record Type: Person Bio: -Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3651 4TH ST N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Nu mber/E-Add ress PHONE subject #2 - MENTION IN REPORT #1 Alfred Primary Information Subject Name: Edwards, Ronald Alfred Record Type: Person Bio: ?Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/10 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Subject #2 - MENTION IN REPORT #1 Edward?s,lRon?aId Alfred - Continued Addresses Relationship HOME ADDRESS Address 6048 W. Broadway, New Hope, Minnesota 55427 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship PHONE Number/E-Address Property #1 - Audio CD - Jeromecopelandinterview Primary information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD - Jerome Copeland interview Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11/18/2015 22:22 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 13:24 ReportingLEO . . Date - . . Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 lidarrative begins on the follow/Eng. page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 2 of 3 On Wednesday, November 18, 2015, at about 1630 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane met with Jerome C. Copeland. SA Olson made two previous attempts to meet Copeland; however on both previous occasions Copeland failed to arrive (1 St attempt Hennepin County Courthouse on November 17 2nd attempt at US. Bank parking lot at Broadway Fremont Ave). Copeland arrived with someone he described as his ?advocate?. SA Olson identi?ed the advocate as Ronald Edwards. Copeland indicated he wanted to speak with the police to provide a witness statement, and insisted Edwards was present during the statement and that the statement occur inside the coffee shop Avenue Eatery, 1101 W. Broadway. The statement began at about 1638 hours and concluded at about 1703 hours. The environment provided limited privacy and had considerable background noise. Copeland refused SA Olson?s suggestion to speak privately in a quiet area near the rear exit of the coffee shop. The statement was later transferred by SA Olson to CD and identi?ed as evidence item 10.1. COpeland reported that on Sunday morning, November 15, 2015, he was leaving the bar and noted Clark was not in handcuffs at the time of his death, but added that one of the of?cers choked Clark unconscious and was shot by one of the of?cers after he was incapacitated. (See attached transcript for complete details). Copeland also indicated that two bouncers from the Elks Lodge were standing with him near the front door of the bar when Clark was shot. Copeland told SA Olson one of the bouncers was known to him as Doug, but he could not recall the name of the other bouncer. He reported several other people were outside and observed the incident, but did not know any of the names of those persons. It should be noted that during the interview SA Olson requested Copeland draw a diagram of the scene. Copeland left the interview with that diagram. As of the date and time of this writing SA Olson has left multiple messages with Copeland if an effort to recover the diagram. SA Olson will continue efforts to contact Copeland to retrieve the diagram. Upon receipt the diagram will be attached to this report. Copeland agreed to re-contact SA Olson if he determines there are additional witnesses to this incident. SA Olson will continue efforts to contact Doug and the other unidenti?ed security person. End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-18-2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Jerome Copeland (JC) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Chris Olson (CO) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO Today?s date is 11?18?2015. This is regards to BCA case number 2015?648. The time now 4:38 PM, 18:38 hours. We are currently at the Avenue Eatery for the 1101 Broadway in Minneapolis. (Music in background) I?m conducting a taped statement now for with Jerome C. Copeland, date of birth- Jerome is Copeland. Uh address 3651 4th Street North, Minneapolis 55412. Also is present is uh Kevin Kane of the FBI and Fion Edwards uh, a friend advisor for Mr. Copeland. Jerome do you go by Jerome or? Yes. Okay. Jerome, Rome (inaudible). Alright so go at?thank you sir. No problem. And you?re okay with (inaudible) would you like me to address as Jerome? Yeah. (inaudible) to start (inaudible) that's okay. Um so yeah Ron just for the record can I get your address? For mine? Yeah. 8048 Broadway, city New Hope. 8048 Broadway? Um-hm. New Hope? Page 1 of 28 JC New Hope, Minnesota 55428, 55 (inaudible). CO 55420alright. JC (inaudible, constant talking in background, sound of someone laughing) CO And your cell phone number Ron? J0 co -what? JC . CO Alright. JC Um-hm-hm. CO And you?re here in a uh, at the request of uh Jerome, is that right? RE That?s right. CO Alright. So let's talk about November Um, um were you at (inaudible) CO Lodge? JC Yes I was? CO At what time? JC Well I pulled up in front of the Elk?s at a quarter to 1:00. CO Alright so 12:45 you arrived in your JC (sniff) CO . . . correct? JC Yeah. CO Alright and who were you with? JC was with myself. CO Okay. And at 12:45 when you arrived what did you observe? JC Well when I drove up 1 always talk to the security cuz, at the Page 2 of 26 the Elk?s? Uh?huh. Do you know the name of that person? Uh two of ?em, well one of ?em is a Douglas for sure, that?s who I know and forgot the other guy?s name. Alright. And they, but at the same time a? as I was out talkin? to ?em is at night, the Elk?s light not on. Okay. So and there was an ambulance across the street. . So when you arrived that ambulance was there? Yes. Okay. Did you arrive from the east or the west? I arrived off Knox? No off uh uh Mickey?s comin? up, comin? up, so I was going east correct? Headed I St. Paul? Headed towards the freeway? No, no uh no I was coming west. Okay. Coming west. Going towards the uh uh the Penn Avenue? Going towards Penn Avenue? Right, right going towards (inaudible, sniff). Okay. And uh so when you arrived did you actually park? Yeah I wasn?t in my car. I walked. Okay so I?m, I'm actually I?m parked way down on, on, on James (inaudible, talking in background). Page 3 of 26 Okay so you walked from James here on foot. Are you on the north or the south side of Plymouth Avenue? Were you on the side of the Elk?s or you I was at the front door up the, up in that area between, between the parking lot and the front door so I'm th? right there on that wall up in that area. Okay. Yes. But as you approached this th' the Elk?s Lodge you were on foot? You were on that side walking that side of Plymouth Avenue? Yes. Okay. And so you saw the ambulance. Did you speak to Douglas? Yeah we was just talking. I was over there just talking and looking across the street. Okay. How many people are out on the sidewalk at that time? Uh oh, oh with me at that time? Yeah just generally in the of the bar? have to say about 30 almost 40 people. In there? Because it was like now. Okay. Yes. Alright. And um tell me in your words what happened next. Well in my words I is like I?m talkin? so I remember the young man that?s deceased. You know this person? I know him but I don't. Okay. He?s a (inaudible). I know his family. Okay. Page 4 of 26 Everyone does. But anyway I altercations happened because he said, he said uh only heard him say was mutha fuck you to the paramedic. (sneeze) Excuse me. So he?s mad at the paramedics? Yeah so um he see' he says mutha fuck you to the ?Kay. Beats around or somethin? and after that the officer (inaudible) said, the bigger officer came behind him put him a choke hold slammed him down. Okay so let?s go back a little bit. Uh as you?re, 0' was he marked, officer in the marked unit there? Was a uniform officer. Okay one or two? There was two of ?em. Okay so when you arrived on foot, uh there?s one Yes and the two officers. And the two officers? Yeah. Were there two separate vehicles or man than two as there One, one (inaudible) No 1, how many vehicles? Uh how many emergency vehicles including the ambulance? ljust seen, all this of the little jeep they be drivin?. SUV yeah. Yeah SUV and ambulance. Okay. And how many, so you saw two uniform police officers? Yes. And did you see, how many paramedics did you see? And if you don?t know the answer to somein? that?s okay. (inaudible) think the paramedic got on the, got out of the vehicle. Okay but he had to be out at some point for the guy to, to use those (inaudible). Page 5 of 26 (exhaled) You know? I, I ain?t got him gettin? out. Okay. But at some point the paramedic was talking to the person Yeah well then, then the paramedic was in the vehicle when I came (inaudible). But ljust remember him yelling at the man mutha fucker I beat your ass to (inaudible). Okay he was saying that to the Um-hm. to police? No. (inaudible) Okay so what happened uh, how did the police get involved? Well l-l-l guess was there. i don?t know they got involved but I just know he grabbed him and choked him up. He meaning the police officer? Yes the police. Okay. And the you said the Ya the bigger one. There was a slimmer one and was a big one. Okay and was there a taller one and a shorter one? There was a slim one and a bigger one The bigger one shorter? Ron's size. Was the bigger one shorter? He?s he I, I know who it is but I just don?t know his name. Okay so 1 just he white? big. Page 6 of 26 he, how clo?, are they both white? I don?t I-I don?t, I?d (sigh) It?s okay. ?Kay. if I?m, if I?m not mistaken (inaudible) and the other is a Asian. Asian guy? Okay. So, so I don?t know because the guy had black hair. The slim one had black hair. I remember that. Okay. And so one, one of these officers, you think the large ain?t no question. put a choke hold on him? Right, right. Alright. So if (inaudible) doin? that were they interacting with this guy? Or did they just come up and put him in a choke hold? I didn?t see ?em talkin? to him. I know when the guy said mutha you to the paramed, but the bigger officer put him in the choke hold, choked him down. So that was in response to saying Yes. paramedic? Yes. And was the response immediate or was several? [t was immediate. There was no hesitation? There was no hesitation. Okay. And prior to that had this person been handcuffed or restrained or detained? He was not cuffed at that time no. He was not cuffed? Page 7 of 26 sir. Okay. Then you were standing literally on the, near the front door of the Elk? I?m, I was standin? like, almost right here and you could look right across the street and see everything. 80 if I give you a piece of paper would you mind uh kinda given me a Where that tree at, where that tree marked Yeah. That?s where wa? was straight across the street. You couldn?t miss. ?Kay. 80 this is the Elk?s. Right? Draw Plymouth Avenue, we?ll start with that so I get a little perspective. Oh then this Henry, cuz that is Henry right? Yep, yep. These are the townhouses over here. So then Knox in there so I got a little Knox (inaudible). Yeah but it wasn?t exactly on Knox. You No I understand that. I?m saying. No it wasn?t on the corner. It?s between Yep. it was (inaudible) James correct? Yep James yeah. So it was in the middle. So the town houses is right here. Okay correct yep. The Elk?s is right here. Yep. Page 8 of 26 JC And it is CO Just write the word Elk?s in there so ifl look at that later I know what it means. JC Yeah. (talking in the background) .10 This is the Elks. CO Okay perfect. JC Oh and this is the front door. CO Yep. JC Of the Elks. CO Yep. JC This is the parking lot. CO Yes. JC Of the Elks. So is a wall before you go around there. So we like right up in here. You understand what l?m saying? CO Yes. JC Put somein? right there in the front, you know where am, I'm in the front door here. Okay? CO So you?re on a sidewalk? JC Yes we?re on the sidewalk talk. CO Um-hm. JC Okay CO And Douglas is right next to ya? JC Yes uh it?s Douglas and the other security guard. CO Okay so his is, his name escapes us at the moment? JC Right yeah. CO Okay alright. .10 So I?m looking at the commotion, the ambulance say up in this area. CO ?Kay. Page 9 of 26 Lookin? at the commotion. The young man was right here. The two police was right next to him. And draw their car in there too, the police car. The car?was the car on the side of that? Let me think (inaudible). - Well if you don?t know where it is Okay know I looked there?s a, there?s a (inaudible) SUV there. Okay. Okay so what happened was when the man said, said what I told you he Yep. The bigger officer came behind like this, like a (inaudible) and, and choked him out. 'Kay. 80 he got all his weight on the guy like this. (inaudible) ?Kay. His partner had his knew hon his chest. Okay. So this guy that fell is on his back now? Yeah he?s on his back. Okay so he fell on his back, the No he was (inaudible) he choked him off. You understand what I?m saying? He choked him. He, he never let go of him. Okay. He?s chokin? him like this backwards. Okay. So he brings his weight down with (inaudible) and that one choked down. Okay. The boy was choked down. Is there, like a better way to buy you love? Did he lose consciousness? He had, had too cuze he was not responding. You understand what I?m saying. He wasn?t like trying to fight or nothin?. But he wa?, he wasn?t physical with ?em. He didn't (inaudible) Page 10 of 26 with ?em or nothin?. All I said women?s, when uh when the man said that word to the paramed that?s when the police grabbed and choked him up. Okay. And so now you?ve got an officer on the ground continuing to apply uh The choke hold yeah. Exactly. then the officer was doing what during this? The uh-uh officer I don?t know was he tryin? to put the cuffs on him or what, but I knew he had his knee in his chest area. ?Kay. And then the next thing we know we hear the gun shot. Okay. And do you think that uh, would you describe this as a struggle on the ground or? No there no struggle. How long did it last? The whole la? ?eh that whole thing (inaudible)? From the time they went to the ground until you heard a gunshot, what period a time unlatched. No more than about 5 minutes. Okay. Yeah. And been on the ground, from the time they fell to the ground, do you think it coulda been no more than 5 (inaudible) when you heard gun shot? Page 11 of 26 They, that?s right. And during that time frame uh what happened when they were on the ground? ?Eh I like I said the man?s chokin' him Yeah. other guy, his partner had his knee on his thing, I'm, I mean on his Yeah. don?t know if he was tryin? to cuff him or what but all we heard was the gun shot?bang. So when we looked we seen the gun and he was tryin? ta holster it. Okay. You understand what I?m sayin?? (inaudible) Was he right or left handed? lt was the right hand. Okay To be exact. Okay. Which officer was that? That was the slimmer one. Was it the, the smaller of the two? Yes. Okay. His partner did. Okay. 80 through that entire period of time on the ground, were you watching, did you, were you watching that entire time? Oh of course. Okay. Alrighthandcuffs come out? What, did you see handcuffs, did you ever see any handcuffs? To my (inaudible) no I (inaudible - not sure if he said did or didn't) Page 12 of 26 Okay. Do you know if Doug happened to see any handcuffs. To my knowledge I don?t know. Okay. I (did or didin?t?) Alright i (did or didn?t?) you said you think he may have been trying to handcuff uh your basin that on what observation? What were you seeing? Because of the way he was fumbling. Okay What I observed. he?s tryin' to get at his hands? He, that's what it looked like yeah. Okay were his hand, where were the guy, or where were the guys hands To me (inaudible) layin? like this. On his side? Yeah. Okay, okay. And there was an officer hate when I didn?t (inaudible) Was there an officer laying on top a him. There had to have been because he had a choke. No he wasn?t on top of him. He he hit the side. had him like this. Okay. And the gun was right here. He had all of his weight like this (inaudible). I understand now. Page 13 of 26 you?re using your right uh arm to describe or illustrate that he had uh his arm around the, the neck of this Um?hm. the other, while he was doing (inaudible) other officer looked to you like he may have been to apply handcuffs? He might have, i don?t know. Alright you?re not sure. Did you hear any dialogue or any uh conversation between uh anyone at that times between this person on the ground or the officers? Was there anything being said? Of course you know the very words, stop resisting. But he wasn?t resisting. Okay so you heard the words stOp resisting? Um-hm but he wasn?t. He says how, how's, how?s he resisting when you chokin? him out. You be chokin? him out. How many times did you hear stop resisting? Just about two or three times. Two or three times? Uh-huh. Okay and was it uh, it had to been loud enough for you to hear across the street. It was. It was. Of course and when we heard the gunshot we was like wow! Did we just see what just really happened. Okay. So I thought he shot him in the chest. Okay. But I know we heard the one gunshot and like i said I seen him tryin? ta holster the gun back in his holster. Page 14 of 26 Okay. So I guess when he realized what he did he was like whoa. Okay. Alright. Well when he did they got (inaudible). Okay. (inaudible) Again that?s when all the (inaudible) said and all the other group there. And how long did you stay on scene there? Oh I stayed there until like almost 3:00 in the mornin?. Alright. When all the officers came from downtown. Did anyone come up to ya and then try to take a statement from ya? No. Okay. You take any pictures or video? No. Did you observe anyone taking pictures or video. Just (inaudible). Alright did (inaudible), do you happen to know of anyone has pictures or video? I could, i could find out. Uh That?s, that?s (inaudible) Okay. l?m, and then don?t (inaudible) have a video? (inaudible) I can?t talk, I can?t talk about the investigation. Okay. I?ll (inaudible) okay no problem. 80. Page ?15 of 26 problem but no I didn?t, I didn?t at that time no. Okay, alright. I didn?t but I?m (inaudible). That?s what I learned. That?s what I seen. Of who have you spoken to about this? Have you been interviewed by anyone besides us you?ve talked with? Only you. Okay. So you?s all the only one that I got interview to. Okay. Alright. Other people been tryin? to call me; ANW ACP and all them, all them been tryin? to call. Black Lives Matter been tryin? to call me, i don?t like Black Lives. Okay. The woman from the NW 3? I don?t know what her name is but she called me one time. How did she get your name do you know? They musta seen me on Face. On Facebook? Um?hm. Did you make any comments on Facebook uh about this? Of course. Okay. And just summarize those comments from you. What did you say? You don?t have to know exactly what they are. ljust said it was sad, I just seen a sad thing. Okay. Did you, did you try to let the details of this on, No not exactly. Alright. But I telled he was executed. That was an execution. And that was an over (inaudible, loud music playing) Okay. Page 16 of 26 And (inaudible) because I?m thinkin? if he was drunk or whatever you can still calm him down. Okay. It?s hard to but there's ways of calmin?, man cuz I deal with bad kids every day. So when they?re on the ground did, did it, did it at all look like a struggle to you? Did it No the man was choked out. Okay. Listen the man was choked out. So when the shot came he was (inaudible), he didn't move, there was no movement or nothin?. Did you see any movement by the officers fired the shot? (inaudible) Were theyjust laying on him? Or he, was there any contact between the officers and this man uh at when he got shot? Was there any physical contact? Oh no, yeah, the only physical was the officer chokin? up. And so the other And the other got his knee on his chest. Okay, alright. His left knee was on the man's chestthe right side. I mean you know with his right hand because he was holstering, trying to holster his gun after he realized, because we heard the gun shot. It was like?boom! And blood all over his (inaudible). Alright. So what, what did the two officers do after? Did anybody have gun out (inaudible)? (coughing) (inaudible) Then they left. They got the gun and left and the all the rest of ?em came with they guns out, maceing people and acting crazy. 80 this two that were involved, they got in the car and left? Yeah I um, yeah they get, they went somewhere. Page 17 of 26 Okay. Yeah. Not in their car, they got in someone else's car and left? Exact and I was stunned yeah. Okay. So you?re estimation how many people observed uh you don?t have to be exact but in your estimation how many people observed this? Around me? Yeah. At that time? Yeah. Uh probably, probably about 20 to 30 people because people were movin? out, cuz they made us leave. Okay. Leave. No l, and I'm not talking about afterwards. I?m talking about when the moment that the gun went off, how many people were standing on the sidewalk? I?d say about, would say about 20 to 30 people Okay. And that's Because the Elks was (inaudible). Okay. They was at (inaudible). So most of that group were coming from the Elks Lodge? They was coming out the Lodge (inaudible). Coulda saw it. And as you come out the Elks you can see right there with, where, wa? what, what, what whole confrontation took place there. (coughing) And do Page 18 of 26 Excuse me. you get Doug?s uh name for me? Sure. Okay and Doug?s uh Sure. a partner there? And you, you got my number right? Yes sir. Okay. Course I got your number. Alright. (pause, talking and music in backgroundDid you, uh uh I don?t remember if asked you this in, in some of the interviews but, but you never saw handcuffs come on? You never saw anything shiny? You never saw anything like that? No. Okay. Alright. No. Um after the scene was uh a little more controlled, had you happen to see any handcuffs anywhere at the scene? No. Okay. Alright. No because you couldn't go over there. When they were, mean when all the, all, all the officers came cuz they had from all the way to Mickey, all the way to Knox blocked off. Okay. And that first ambulance, do you know anything about the details ofthe why that ambulance was there? I don?t, oh what i heard there was a altercation with him, but with, with him and his girl. Okay. Alright. Page ?19 of 26 That girl is so angry. That ambulance left and they called ?em back and that's when they grabbed the body and threw it the ambulance, took off with (inaudibleThis, the second Who I don?t know if it was the same ambulance but none of the ambulance came and got the Okay. Alright. Alright. In terms of uh uh the uniformed officers were saying, the only thing you can recall hearing is quit resisting? Yeah. Alright. That?s all. Any other verbal commands that you remember? No. Any other communications between those two of?cers? And, and the individual? No uh any, any No. No. No i didn?t. officers? (inaudible) Okay. No. Nojust like said I was across the street. Okay. Street so you can't really move, stand, because we couldn?t get back over there anywhere. Okay. Because they (inaudible) already came and (inaudible). Page 20 of 26 CO Okay. JC Same thing uh secure the scene. Or may get pulled over and we know how to do it. (pause) CO How many people do you know? How many name of people do you know that saw this and reluctant to come to the police? Or it maybe it could be known, I don't wanna put words in your mouth, but are, are there people that saw, do not JC I don?t know yet because I haven?t been back to the Elks yet. CO Okay. Alright. JC But, but I could find out maybe ?kay, i know (inaudible). CO And if you should uh come across people JC Yes sir. CO video uh and are still JC No problem. CO you reach out to me? JC (inaudible) CO Alright. JC I aint got no problem with it. CO Alright. JC I?ll be more than willing. CO And uh I need to ask you this and uh were you drinking uh alcohol Okay. JC 1 was sober because I didn't go in there. i came when it was closing. CO Okay. But where were you coming from? JC Coming from my niece?s house. Page 21 of 26 Okay. You were going down to the Elks for what purpose? No was going there to talk to some of my partners in there and, and brothers to, have a lot at there. The matter of fact l'm almost about to be member of the Elks. Okay. I?m just waitin? on my confirmation that?s all. I, l?m.years old. Yeah I know how that feels. Yeah. (laughs) Yeah. (laughing, inaudible) (laughing) (inaudible my way) (laughing) Hey I?m. l?m Do you remember any vehicles parked uh at or near the scene, civilian vehicles; non Because you can?t park on (inaudible). Okay. You know what I?m sayin?? You can?t park on (inaudible). Okay. No. It, the bike route, ?eh you know the bike trail? You rode your bike is on and no ain?t no bar right on Penn. Remember were the officer wearing the same type of uniform (inaudible)? i didn?t, Minneapolis uniform (inaudible). Okay. And, and, and these the same two officers i know who they are. Okay. Have you had previous jails with these two officers? I might have. Page 22 of 26 Okay. Negative, favorable, just, just in passing? It mighta been the big guy that did ?eh 'eh if this is the same big guy. He, he, he kind of a? hole. Okay. But (inaudible) bad. And the big guy is the Asian guy the white guy. Okay. And do you remember seeing any guns uh, uh firearms on holsters? Uh, uh you saw the one going back in the Um-hm. you see it coming out ofthe holster? Or not? If you don?t remember that?s (inaudible). I seen the gun. When he, look then when the shot went Um?hm. You saw it being holstered. seen the gun like this. He had it like this. Okay. Cuz then he holst. Okay. You see what I?m sayin?? Cuz he missed the holster trying to put it back in there. Okay. That?s what I?m sayin?. Alright. And that was the big guy or the small guy? That?s the skinny guy. The shooter. The big guy didn?t do the shootin?. Is the (inaudible)? The skinny guy did the shootin?. we?re on tape I gotta make this clear. Uh when he got shot he was on his back? Yes. Page 23 of 26 Okay. Alright. Like I said I thought he shot him in his chest. Okay. Alright. So they, they, then I found out it was the head shot. And the other guy had his arm around his neck ?eh uh uh during this for what seemed like a long period of time? He chokin? up, I know the boy chokin?. Do you think that was about five minutes? Yeah. Okay. (inaudible) yeah the boy was choked out. The boy wasn't respond respondin' to nothin?. Okay. You know what sayin?? He was choked out. Alright. I know when you choked out. So that officerthat then uh when he had arms around that guy, that was officer moving? Was his body or torso moving in any capacity? Who, who, who? The officer that had the hold on Right. I his legs or arms or moving Oh the kid? I No I?m talking about the police officer. Was, was the police officer moving? Yeah he was, he was puttin? arms and he (inaudible) he had the guy like this? And was he moving or was he stiff? Was who movin'? The police officer? Page 24 of 26 Yeah the arms were (inaudible) over like this. You know puttin? his weight on him. Chokin? him up. So he was (inaudible). He was moving a lot or what? Yeah he was chokin? the man out. You know when you chokin? somebody like you?re rastlin?? Yeah. That?s the way it was. So he was moving but the guy wasn?t moving? No. The guy was choked out. (inaudible) The guy wasn?t uh you know he wasn?t kicking? or nothin'. Okay. Alright. Uh were you to say uh let's take the legs of the officer, those legs were moving a lot? The officer had the leg choked out so (inaudible) you, me I mean using all his weight. Yeah I?m just asking if his legs were movin?; the officer's? Not really. It?s a hard thing to remember. Right. Right. ljust know he had him like Okay. was, you, you?ll, you know puttin? the choke hold on him. Alright. I think i understand. Kevin you got anything else? No. Jerome you got my number. (inaudible) I mean I think you have been talking about this to some people. Not really. Okay. Not really. Can I ask you something (inaudible). Uh yeah (inaudible) Page 25 of 26 KK (inaudible) like to reach out to us (inaudible) JC I gotcha. No problem. 00 Uh we?re gonna end this tape and now the time is 7: (inaudible) 3 hours. Page 26 of 26 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/11 Report Date: 1111712015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Interview of Minneapolis Police Officer Dustin Schwarze Occurrence From: 1111712015 00:00 Occurrence To: 1111712015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Phill, Charles (13851MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1112512015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 1 Metro Regional Office 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 17th, 2015, SA Phil] and SAIC Mueller conducted a recorded interview of Minneapolis Police Officer Dustin Schwarze. Acquisition of item 2015-648I11.1. Address #1 - Occurred #1 5500 WYZATA BLVD Primary Information Address: 5500 WYZATA BLVD #1000, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416 United States Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 53 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (13851 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 of 8 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/11 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy - Continued Primary Information - Continued Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_io EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oheal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications . Elem Mate FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO subject #4 - BRUNO, .Frede?ric Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Juvenile: Addresses Relationship Primary Information BRUNO, Frederic Person White, Male NO Address .- IVIINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 2 of8 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/1 1 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #4 - ATTORNEY #1 - BRUNO, Frederic - Continued Addresses - Continued Relationship Address BUSINESS LOCATION 1450 THE COLONNADE 5500 WAYZATA BLVD, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416 United States Property #1 - CD Centainin?g' Digital Audio of Interview with MPD Officer Schwarze Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/17/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Datefl'ime: 11/17/2015 00:00 CD Containing Digital Audio of Interview with MPD Officer Schwarze Property #2 Hand Drawn Diagram by MPD Officer Schwarze Primary information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Property Status: HQ Status Date: 11/17/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 11/1 712015 00:00 Hand Drawn Diagram by MPD Of?cer Schwarze Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11/19/2015 08:17 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11125/2015 12:00 Mueller, Scott (1305 Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Mueller, Scott (1305 Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO . Date" SuperVisor 7 . - - Date - Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Mueller, Scott (1305/ Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 3 of 8 On November 17th, 2015, SA Phill and SAIC Mueller conducted a recorded interview with Minneapolis Police Of?cer Dustin Schwarze. The interview was conducted in the presence of Fred Bruno and Stephen and occurred at Bruno Law Of?ce 5500 Wyzata Blvd. Suite #1000 Minneapolis, MN. 55416. This digital recording was later downloaded and transferred to CD. The CD was packaged and labeled as evidence, item #2015?648/1 1.1. The recording was also transcribed; the transcription is also attached to this report. Of?cer Schwarze was advised of, and given a c0py of the BCA Criminal Investigative Warning. Of?cer Schwarze and his attorney Fred Bruno reviewed the document, and both signed the document consenting to a voluntary interview. Of?cer Schwarze was then given a COpy of the BCA Consent to Provide Chemical Test of Blood. Of?cer Schwarze had previously given a blood sample on November 15 2015 following being involved in a shooting while on duty in Minneapolis. SAIC Mueller explained to Of?cer Schwarze that the MN BCA would like to take possession of the blood sample given and have that sample tested in the BCA Laboratory. Of?cer Schwarze and Mr. Bruno reviewed and signed the document consenting to the request. The last form that SAIC Mueller explained and gave a copy of, was the BCA Consent to Search. SAIC Mueller requested that Of?cer Schwarze give a voluntary DNA Buccal Swab. Of?cer Schwarze and Mr. Bruno signed the form consenting to providing a DNA sample. All three forms are attached to this report. The DNA sample from Of?cer Schwarze was collected by SA Phill. (See SA Phill?s report for further details regarding the DNA) Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he has been a police of?cer for approximately seven years, working for the City of Rich?eld for six years, and for the City of Minneapolis for just over one year. Of?cer Schwarze?s POST number is 20146, and his Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) badge number is 6422. Of?cer Schwarze stated he has completed training in use of force and ?rearms within the last six months. Officer Schwarze is assigned as a uniformed street patrol of?cer in the 4th precinct of Minneapolis. On November 14-15th, 2015, Officer Schwarze was working his normal patrol shift from 4:00pm 2:00am. Of?cer Schwarze normally works as a two person patrol team. On this shift, MPD Of?cer Ringgenberg was his partner. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he normally wears a typical Minneapolis Police patrol uniform consisting of a light blue shirt and dark pants. On the uniform there are two department patches on the sleeve, a name plate and badge on the breast area and a duty belt. On Of?cer Schwarze?s duty belt is a double magazine pouch containing two extra magazines each with 17 cartridges, radio, ?ashlight, handcuffs and a holster with a handgun. Of?cer Schwarze carries a Smith Wesson 9mm handgun. The handgun is loaded with a magazine containing 17 cartridges and one cartridge is carried in the chamber of the handgun. Of?cer Schwarze was also wearing an outer dark blue fleece type jacket. This jacket also had MPD patches on the shoulders and a badge on the breast area. Of?cer Schwarze was asked to walk agents through how he and his partner, Of?cer Ringgenberg became involved in the critical incident that occurred in the early morning hours of November 15, 2015. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he and Of?cer Ringgenberg were assigned as Squad 424. They were noti?ed by dispatch to respond to assist EMS personnel on Plymouth Avenue, approximately three blocks away from the MPD 4th Precinct, where they had been having dinner. Of?cer Schwarze stated that EMS on scene were requesting assistance because a there was a possible assault suspect that was interfering with them. Of?cer Schwarze stated they also noticed in the notes on their computer stated that they were requested ?Code which means a fast, emergency type response. Of?cer Schwarze stated that they reSponded quickly to the location, but did not activate their squad?s emergency lights since the location was only three blocks away. Of?cer Schwarze stated that they have a Ford Explorer type squad car that is a ?illy marked Minneapolis Police Vehicle. Of?cer Schwarze stated their squad car is equipped with a dashboard camera type video system with an auxiliary microphone that can be attached to their uniform. Of?cer Schwarze stated that neither he nor Of?cer Ringgenberg were wearing the auxiliary microphone, and did not activate the squad?s emergency lights, (which activate the squad?s dashboard camera). Of?cer Schwarze was driving the squad, with Of?cer Ringgenberg in the front passenger seat. The of?cers exited the MPD 4th Precinct parking lot, turning north on Morgan Avenue and then east on Plymouth Avenue approximately three blocks. Of?cer Schwarze stated that when they arrived, there was an ambulance parked on the south side of Plymouth Avenue, facing east. There was also a (medical) SUV parked on the south side of Plymouth Avenue, facing west. Both the ambulance and SUV were within several car of each other, and both had their emergency lights activated. Of?cer Schwarze parked behind the SUV on the south side of Plymouth Avenue, facing east. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he and Ringgenberg exited their squad and approached a paramedic who was standing between the ambulance and the SUV. The paramedic (later identi?ed as Deputy Chief Trullinger, told the of?cers, pointing to a male who was standing near the ambulance, but on the boulevard. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Trullinger told them that there was medical personnel in the back of the ambulance working, and that the male had been interfering with them, but he did not have a lot of information at the time, and was still trying to ?gure out what' was going on. Of?cer Schwarze stated that the male (later identi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark was wearing a large dark colored winter coat, had both of his hands in the pockets of the coat, had his head tilted down with his hair partially coving his face. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Clark had a ?thousand yard stare.? Of?cer Schwarze described Clark as not looking at anything in particular, but was looking in their direction, and that it was ?an uncomforting look.? Of?cer Schwarze stated that he and Ringgenberg then approached Clark, noticing that he still had his hands in his pockets. While approaching Clark both of?cers were asking Clark to take his hands out of his pockets several times, and Clark did not move, still with the same look on his face. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he saw his partner take his handgun out of his holster. At this time Of?cer Schwarze stated that Clark looked at Ringgenberg handgun and began asking, ?what?s the pistol for, what?s the pistol for?? Of?cer Schwarze stated that once close enough, he took hold of Clark?s left arm, and his partner Officer Ringgenberg put his handgun in his holster and took hold of Clark?s right arm. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he pulled Clark?s hand out of his pocket while telling Clark to take his hands out of his pockets. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that Clark?s arm was tensed up and he had to struggle to remove his hand/arm from his pocket and to try and move it to Clark?s back. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he then struggled with Clark, who was trying to remove his arm from behind his back, while Of?cer Schwarze stated he was telling Clark to leave his hand there. Of?cer Schwarze then removed his hinged handcuffs from their holster and was going to attempt to handcuff Clark when both of his hands were behind his back. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Clark?s jacket was covering his wrist, so there was no room to handcuff Clark. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Officer Ringgenberg was also struggling with Clark, and was not able to bring his other hand to his back in order for Of?cer Schwarze to handcuff Clark. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Of?cer Ringgenberg then used a ?take down maneuver?, pulling Clark backwards onto the ground. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he maintained control of Clark?s left hand, and after Clark was on the ground he went down to his knees, still holding Clark?s left hand. Of?cer Schwarze stated he 'noticed that Of?cer Ringgenberg was now lying on his back at a weird angle, on top of Clark. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he could see his partner was trying to roll off of Clark, squirming around, but was not able to do so. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he believed the intention was for his partner to roll Clark over in order to handcuff him. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Of?cer Ringgenberg then said to him in a very ?stern, but excited and serious? voice, ?he?s got my gun!? Of?cer Schwarze stated he could still see Of?cer Ringgenberg struggling. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he then put his handcuffs still in his hand, back towards his handcuff pouch, but was unable to fold them back into his pouch, so he just dropped them on the ground and drew his handgun. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he then pointed his handgun at Clark?s head, making contact with the tip of the barrel to the left corner of Clark?s mouth and told Clark, ?Let it go, or I am going to shoot you!?, while still watching Of?cer Ringgenberg struggle. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Clark then looked at him in the and stated, ?I?m ready to die.? Of?cer Schwarze stated that Of?cer Ringgenberg then said, ?dude, he?s got my gun!? Of?cer Schwarze stated that this time, Of?cer Ringgenberg screamed in a scared and frightened voice. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Of?cer Ringgenberg was screaming this to him, ?like I have never heard Mark scream like this before, it was one of the most frightening things I think I?ve ever heard.? Of?cer Schwarze stated that he could see that Of?cer Ringgenberg?s body was arched and it appeared that he was trying to use his body weight to pin Clark to the ground. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he was ?so scared,? believing that Clark had Of?cer Ringgenberg?s gun. Of?cer Schwarze then put his handgun to the left side of Clark?s head, believing that he was going to hear shots ring out from Of?cer Ringgenberg?s gun that he believed Clark had ahold of. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he then several times told Of?cer Ringgenberg that he was going to shoot Clark. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he then heard Of?cer Ringgenberg say, in the most panicked, sincere voice he has ever heard, ?shoot him!? Of?cer Schwarze stated that he thought if he did not do something that his partner, himself, paramedics or a bystander were going to be shot. Of?cer Schwarze stated he then pulled the triggeroff. Of?cer Schwarze stated he could see that the slide of his gun was depressed making his handgun unable to ?re. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he then pulled his handgun away from Clark?s head and pulled the trigger again, shooting Clark in the head. Officer Schwarze stated that he then ilrnnediately got to his feet, and Of?cer Ringgenberg was able to roll away from Clark and move to his feet. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he could see that Of?cer Ringgenberg was ?disheveled? and shifting around. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he could see a large crowd gathering in front of the of?cers and behind them. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he remembers the paramedic telling the ambulance to leave and retrieving rescue gear from his SUV. Of?cer Schwarze told agents that he faced north and Of?cer Ringgenberg faced south, keeping security 360 degrees around the scene. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he got on the radio and called out that shots had been ?red and requested another ambulance to respond ?code and requested more of?cers. Of?cer Schwarze stated that shortly after other of?cers arrived, MPD Of?cer Sworski took both he and Of?cer Ringgenberg back to the precinct, where their handguns were secured as evidence. Of?cer Schwarze stated that Of?cer Sworski initially took possession of his handgun, but gave it back at the precinct until he turned it over to a sergeant as evidence. Officer Schwarze stated that he did not pick up his handcuffs again after dropping them, and should have been left at the scene. Of?cer Schwarze stated that he had not had any previous contact with Clark. Of?cer Schwarze was then asked to make a rough drawing of the scene. This drawing was scanned to this report, as well as packaged and labeled as an item of evidence, item MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension 1246 University Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55104-4197 Phone: 651.642.0610 FAX: 651.642.0618 TTY: 651.282.6555 macadamia? CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION WARNING You are hereby advised that you are being interviewed by a Special Agent of the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension as part of an of?cial criminal investigation. This investigation is separate from any internal investigation that may have been conducted by your employer. You may already have been interviewed pursuant to an internal investigation. If so, you may have been told that your statements could not be used against you in any criminal proceeding. It should therefore be clari?ed that any statements you give to BCA agents as part of this criminal investigation can be used against you in a subsequent criminal proceeding. If any representation has been made to you that you must or should answer to questioning by BCA agents as part of an internal investigation, you should disregard that representation. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This statement is given by me voluntarily. I am not making this statement because of threats made or pressure exerted on me by my employer, anyone associated with my employer, or any other individual. No consideration or reward has been promised to me in exchange for my agreement to make a statement. I HAVE READ THIS DOCUMENT AND FULLY UNDERSTAND ITS CONTENTS. Eggs/Q..ch (SIGNED) (DATE) HA km 5/ 5) (DATE) MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension 1430 Maryland Avenue East, St. Paul. Minnesota 55106-2802 Phone: 651-282-6555 Internet: Bureau of Criminal Aporehension CONSENT TO PROVIDE CHEMICAL TEST 0 BLOO URINE I, hereby authorize 5/4 ?zz/lull, err/wipe a Special Agent with the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, and/or any other duly appointed law enforcement officer to administer a test of my (blood) (urine). This written permission is given by me voluntarily. I am not taking this test because of threats made or pressure exerted on me by my employer, anyone associated with my employer, or any other individual. No consideration or reward has been promised to me in exchange for my agreement to take the test. I HAVE READ THIS DOCUMENT AND FULLY UNDERSTAND ITS CONTENTS 7g \?Ii7Ii? Signature Date I UV. I la Witness Date (sum) (OENSIS) i (awn) (635121?33- g? a? Mm 7< 3SESSENJJM 1 (awn) (uaNals) 7* Sil 2mm; CINV SIHJ. CIVBH HAVH 01 ECIVIN N338 GHVMEIH HO NOILVHEGISNOO :10 ANV SAVH HON GENELVEHHL N338 .LON SAVH 1 3W A8 NHAIE) SI NSLLIHM SEHJ. ANV .LV 38 NVO .LVHJ. I (M9 3v 038180830 1030100 MN aacmn Emu?{3A 30 33 Iwaad BHJ. :10 H0 V38 100mm 01 3301330 A100 aaHm ANV 2:10 0w errand :10 mamawaa :10 nvaana VLOSEINNIW 3HJ. :10 a I ?a?jn/lf?s 177% (rm/b azuaOHmv ?Hoavas Hons 0.1. masnoo 0.1. 01. man: AW :10 GNV mvaavm Hoavas inOHilM 03030330 ao saslwaad BHJ. :10 aavw Hoavas EAVH 01 mam AW N330 SNIAVH 92mm ??15 ?1 i )vp7n? 5 HCHVES Oi LNESNCC Hm?ddmmopmm 5 999928?ng 3A 335011101 Wed '18 9172:, neemg Ol'l?nd :10 VLOSBNNIW Um rt. vim, Z. 5'1: 2. . ll Z04 210 I. all-I'll If . MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 17, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Officer Dustin Schwarze (DS) INTERVIEWED BY: SAIC Scott Mueller (SM) Attorney Fred Bruno (FB) SA Michael Phill (M P) Stephen (SF) REVIEWED BY: On November 17th 2015, SAIC Scott Mueller and SA Michael Phill interviewed PD Officer Dustin Schwarze. Also present was his attorney, Fred Bruno and his assistant Stephen This occurred at Fred Bruno?s office in MinneapolisTime is 20:30 hours. 11/17/2015. Special Agent in Charge Scott Mueller, Special Agent Mike Phill at 5500 Wayzata Boulevard, Suite 1000, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416. This is in reference to case number 2015-648. We are here with Dustin, Dustin how do you spell your last name? And that?s Schwarzee? Correct. Okay. And representing Dustin is Mr. Fred Bruno? Correct. And also present in the room is? Stephen Thank you. Um Dustin before we turned the tape recorder on I let you and ah your representative look at what?s called a criminal investigative warning that the BCA put together and I?m showing it to you right now. This criminal investigative warning basically says in short that the BCA conducts a criminal investigation, that?s what this is. Ah this is not an internal affairs investigation. We are not compelling you to talk. Ah this is a consensual interview. Ah and you have signed the bottom of that indicating you're okay talking with us. If at any point during this conversation that we have that you want to stop talking please just let me know and, and we'll stop the tape. Okay? Okay. Um the second thing that I showed you was what we call the BCA consent to provide a chemical test of blood. Um my understanding is, is that blood was taken from you um on the well I guess it would be the morning of this incident, this instance um at the Minneapolis Police Department. What I?m asking for is your consent for us to take, the BCA to take possession of that blood and to have that blood ah brought into our toxicology laboratory. Are you okay with that? 1 am. Okay and ah you and ah Mr. Bruno have also signed that one as well. The last form that have that ah we looked at before we turned the tape recorder on was a consent to search Page 1 of 10 Phill-20'15-648-A07 form. Um what we are asking for at the BCA is consent to take a buccal swab sample from you. Um a consent to search of your person for that buccal swab sample. You?re okay giving us a sample at the conclusion of this interview? I am. Okay and ah you?ve signed that as well as Mr. Bruno. Um, your address um the 4th precinct address is 1925 Plymouth Avenue, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 and the telephone numberfor you is 612-673?5704. Dustin what?s your POST number? 20146. And what is your badge number? 6422. And you are a Minneapolis Police Officer? Correct. How long have you been a police officer? Ah approximately 7 years. Okay. Have you worked the entire time as a police officer for Minneapolis? No. Okay. Where did you start your law enforcement career? Richfield. And how long were you at Richfield? Approximately 6 years. So you would have been at, at Minneapolis for about a year? Yeah. Little over a year, okay. And what do you do for the City of Minneapolis? You?re a police officer but in what capacity? work in the patrol division. And what shift do you work? Middle watch. Middle watch? What time is that? 4:00 PM. to 2:00 AM. What precinct do you work out of? The 4th precinct. Okay. Dustin when was the last time you had ah use of force and firearms training? Both within the last six months. Within the last six months? Okay. Do you have any specialty assignments with the, with the police department at all? No. Okay, handler anything like that? No. Page2 of10 Phill?2015-648?A07 On, you were working on the evening of Saturday the 14th of November into Sunday the was. Okay. Um do you normally have a partner when you work or do you work a single squad? I usually have a partner. Okay um do you have the same partner or is that rotate all the time? It rotates. Okay. Who, who were you working with on, on Saturday the 14th into Sunday the Mark Ringgenberg. Mark Ringgenberg? Okay. Have you guys worked together before? Yeah. How long have you known Officer Ringgenberg? Approximately one year. About a year? You guys work together quite a'bit in the past? We do. Okay. Can you tell me um when you go to work in, in patrol in the 4th precinct ah specifically last Saturday how were you dressed? was wearing a full Minneapolis Police uniform. Okay. What does the shirt look like? The shirt is a button down light blue shirt. Uniform shirt, it has Minneapolis Police patches on each shoulder. It has, I have my metal badge pinned to the front ah breast and my nametag on the as well on the other side on the front breast. What color pants do you wear? Navy blue. Okay. Do you wear shoes or boots or? Black boots. Black boots? Okay. You ah on Saturday into Sunday were you wearing a any kind of external vest or jacket or? I was. Okay. I was wearing a police type jacket that also has a ah Minneapolis Police badge pinned to the front of it with Minneapolis Police patches sewn on each shoulder. Okay. How about ah stocking cap, gloves anything like that? No stocking cap. I was not wearing one that night and was not wearing gloves. Still relatively warm out, right? Correct. Do you remember how warm it was that night? I don?t. Page 3 oin Phill-2015?B48?A07 Warm enough to wear part of a jacket? Yeah warm enough to wear part of a jacket if I was standing out there I?d had it on for the majority of the night. Okay. Um, what about your duty belt, what does that consist of? have a leather basket weave duty belt. It?s a buckle style so it has a silver buckle in the front. Um starting from my left side I have a dual mag pouch that holds the magazine, the extra magazines for my sidearm. Each of those ah contains ?17 extra rounds of ammunition. Then I have a belt keeper. Then I have a radio. And then it?s a flashlight. And then it?s another belt keeper. Then continuing along my back towards my right hip there?s a belt keeper, a set of handcuffs another belt keeper, my firearm. What kind of firearm is that? It?s a Smith and Wesson 9 mm. Do you know how many rounds you carry in that when you?re working? Eighteen, seventeen are in the magazine and one is in the chamber. Okay. Go ahead. The next thing on my belt is a belt keeper and then the next thing after that is a ah closed handcuff case. And that?s it. Okay. Can you I?m gonna open it up to you can you tell us just kind of from start to finish ah you became involved in a, a critical incident on the early morning hours of Sunday the 15th of November. Can you tell us just from start to finish how you became involved with that. Ah when you first heard of ah the call or a call that you reSponded to. How you became involved. Who was with you and what transpired during that call. was working that night with Mark Ringgenberg. We were dispatched to the call location as squad 424. When the call came out the dispatcher aired information that this was an assist EMS call, and that they were requesting a police assistance because there was a possible assailant from an earlier assault that was on scene and was hindering um the process. We were at the 4th precinct when this call came out. We got into our patrol vehicle, which was parked in the back parking lot. I was the driver. Mark was the passenger. When we got in the vehicle we looked at the computer screen that?s in our car and there was call notes in the call that said request police respond code 3. Which means, it's urgent. We exited the parking lot. Which exits onto Morgan Avenue. Ah we drove north on Morgan Avenue and then east on Plymouth Avenue. When you exit ah when you take the turn from Morgan to Plymouth, the call location is approximately three blocks from the station. I could already see the emergency lights down the street which is where we were going. So the fastest way that we could get there was just to drive we were very close, we got there as soon as we could. We didn?t have to, there was no need to turn our lights and sirens on or anything like that we got there very quick. We get there, there?s a ambulance parked on Plymouth Avenue. The ambulance is parked on the south side of Plymouth Avenue it's facing east. There's a SUV that is also parked on Plymouth Avenue on the south side and that's facing west. Both of those vehicles had their emergency lights on. When I pulled up I pulled to the right curb into a stop. My partner and I both exited the car and we approached a paramedic who was standing between the ambulance and the SUV. He said that, they had called us because ah this male and he pointed to a, gentleman that was standing nearby. Not on the street he was up on the boulevard, the boulevard area within close proximity to both the ambulance and us. The paramedic told us that there was somebody in the back of the ambulance along with paramedics and I could see that there was people in the back of the ambulance but I couldn't, it wasn?t a clear sight I just knew that there was people in the back. Ah he said that this male, pointing to this gentleman standing there ah was hindering Page4of10 the process of these paramedics rendering aid to whoever was in the ambulance. He said that he didn?t have a lotta information and that he needed our help figuring everything out. i then drew my attention to the male who was standing on the boulevard area. I remember he was wearing a, larger a dark colored winter type coat. He had both of his hands in the pockets of the coat the hand pockets of the coat. Um his head was, tilted down. And this area was lit pretty well just with street lights and the emergency lights of the vehicles. But it was still nighttime. His head was tilted down and I remember seeing a lot of hair kind of, covering ah the front of his face but I could still see his eyes and, he had this thousand yard stare. It didn?t appear that he was looking specifically at anything he was just looking in our direction. And it was a very, weird uncomforting look. My partner and approached him, still noticing that he had his hands in his pockets. I said take your hands out of your pockets. Ah at the same time was saying that my partner was also saying take your hands outta your pockets. walked closer to this person I said take your hands outta your pockets again. I could also hear my partner saying take your hands outta your pockets. He didn?t move he just, stood there. The same look on his face, both of his hands were still in his pockets. My par, i saw my partner ah take his gun out of his holster and now the, this male was saying what?s the pistol for, what?s the pistol for. And now he?s looking at my partner and my partner?s gun. His head was still tilted down. At this time I?m now within arm?s reach of this male. Ah simultaneously I grabbed his left arm my partner holstered his gun and grabbed ah the males right arm. 1 had to physically pull his hand out of his pocket. i had said again take your hands outta your pockets. So I physically pulled his arm and his hand out of his pocket and was able to hold onto his arm with my right hand and then I went to grab his, left hand and I ended up grabbing it in like a handshake position so I could feel his fingers I knew he didn?t have anything in that hand. Um he?s very tensed at this point. Ah he wasn?t saying anything else. Ah there was a, struggle over me trying to get his hand behind his back. I was able to get his hand behind his back quickly but now l?m, just trying to keep it there. He?s trying to pull it away from me but I?m just trying to keep it there. So i, I let go with my right hand and i take my handcuffs out of ah the pouch that?s in the small of my back. Those are hinged handcuffs so get them ready into a handcuffing position and I?m, my intention is to handcuff him. But the jacket on his left arm was down so there was no area on his wrist to handcuff. Um and my partner was having troubles getting his right hand behind his back. So we?re both in a standing position and we can?t get his hands close enough to where we can effectively put the handcuffs on. At that point ah my partner used a takedown maneuver ah grabbing the, this person and pulling him backwards on the ground. I maintained control of his left hand. So still had his left hand, was holding his left hand with my left hand. I still had my handcuffs in my right hand and now i went down to both of my knees. 1 immediately noticed that my partner was now lying on his back and almost kind of his side in a very awkward angled position and he?s laying on this person that we had just taken to the ground. Um, I could see that my partner was trying to roll off of this person and he wasn?t able to do so he?s, squirming and just trying to turn back around. Ah again with the intention that we can just and I?m just waiting for this I?m just waiting for my partner to turn back around so that we can ah roll this other you know roll this person over and handcuff him. My partner then says hevery, stern ah excited like very serious tone in his voice when he said it. I still see my partner struggling. 1 immediately ah put my handcuffs back behind my back. i almost thought for a second that was just gonna put them back in their pouch but i wasn?t able to fold ?em quick enough so ljust dropped ?em on the ground so my handcuffs are now behind me. I then grabbed my gun and unholstered it. I pointed it at this persons head and I made contact with the tip of my gun the barrel the end of the slide and was touching the left corner of this person?s mouth. And I said let it go or I?m gonna shoot you. My partner, was still struggling at this time. i could still see him trying to, roll or move off there?s still a brief struggle going. Um, the person that?s laying on the ground is now looking directly at me and he says I?m ready to die. My partner then says dude he?s got my gun. And it wasmuch more ah, ah scared, frightened scream than the first time he said it. And he says it again this is the third time he said it now PhilI-2015-648-A07 Page 5 of 10 SM Phill?2015-648?AOT and he just he says he?s got my gun and it was just a screaming I've never heard Mark ever scream like this before. It was one of the most frightening things I think I?ve ever heard. Just the tone of his voice, I?m also ah noticing his body position and his body position has, his back is arched and it appears to me that he is just trying to, use all of his weight to pin himself on the ground. I, I noticed that he?s now not trying to get up now he?s trying to stay .on the ground like with all of his might. And, I end up pushing this male?s ah chin to the side with the side of his head. It was the left side of his head. And I was so, scared and just thought he had the gun. I thought, I thought that shots were gonna ring out. I thought that somebody was gonna get shot. I thought my partner was gonna get shot. I thought I was gonna get shot. There were so many things that were running through my head. The only thing I could think of to do was to save our lives and anybody else that was in that immediate area of any danger so I pulled the trigger. And, my gun didn't go off. Excuse me. I told Mark was gonna shoot him. I said I?m gonna shoot him. This is when had my gun pressed on the side of his face. I said I'm going to shoot him. Mark said shoot him and again when he said shoot him that was again in thisjust panicked, most sincere panicked voice I?ve ever heard. The person that was lying on the ground said again I?m ready to die. I knew at that second that i had to, pull the trigger. So I pulled the trigger. My gun didn't go off and I remember looking at my gun during this and was, trying to, I was making sure that the, trying to make sure that my gun was in like a up/down position so that it would only go down and that it wouldn?t shoot I was, making sure that it wouldn?t go anywhere else but where was intending for it to go. So I lifted my gun back up and I had cuz I had realized that the slide was back a little bit and that?s why it didn?t go off. I knew that it wasn?t a malfunction it was just that was the reason ah the round did not, go off. So I pulled the trigger again. My gun goes off. I knew that I had a hit the suspect. immediately ah got back onto my feet. Mark rolled away from the, person. We both stood up. I could ah hear and see that there was a large crowd of people on both sides of the street so we just put our backs towards this person. There was a EMS the EMS person that was standing there went and made contact with the, the paramedics that were in the ambulance. I remember him saying go?go-go. The ambulance then drove off. Mark and I stayed near this person as that paramedic had went to his vehicle to retrieve some medical supplies and render aid to the person that was lying on the ground. Mark and were facing away from each other. I was facing the north and Mark was facing the south and we were just trying to, maintain like a three?sixty security. At that point I, or immediately when I stood up and that as this was going on I said, or I got on my portable radio and I said squad 424 shots fired. I wasn?t able to hear what the transmission was coming back into my radio. I then aired additional information. I said squad 424 we have a large agitated crowd. One down. Again I wasn?t able to hear what was coming in on my radio. Immediately after that aired the third transmission and I said 424 start EMS code 3 which means a fast rapid response. And I did that because I, knew that the ambulance that was there had left and I knew that there was, medical personnel that was there already rendering aid but that we needed an additional ambulance to come and assist. Moments later several squad cars arrived to assist. I could see officers all around. Um, another officer approached me. I still had hand. He, told us to come with him. He was gonna take care of us. Ah he just said come with us, get in the car, we?re gonna go back to the or he said hop in the car, he had me sit in the front driver's seat or excuse me the front passenger seat of the vehicle. He asked Mark if Mark felt that it was okay to sit in the back seat. Mark sat in the back seat. And then he drove us westbound on Plymouth Avenue towards the precinct and he said since we?re so close to the precinct we?ll just go back to the precinct. And then when I got to the precinct ah he was able to help me get in contact with the Sergeant and advise them, that we were the officers involved in a critical incident. Okay. Thank youfollow up questions if you don?t mind. One is ah when you were going to this call and you were in your squad can you tell me what kind of squad that is? Page 6 ofIO Phill-2015-648-A07 It's a Ford Explorer. It?s a marked police vehicle. It has a light bar. It has spotlights. It's a fully equipped, functioning squad car and it was markings on both sides and the back that say Minneapolis Police. Does it have a squad camera in it? It does. Okay. Was ah when you were in route to this call did ah was that squad camera activated? No. Why is that? In order to activate the squad camera you have to turn your lights on all the way and we didn?t turn our lights on to get to this call. Can you tell me why? We were so close to the call, when we exited the parking lot that, there was no faster way to get there than the way get there. Turning our lights and sirens on would not have expedited the process of us arriving at this call any sooner. This was towards the middle of the night that this happened so there was very little if any traffic on the road. Um there was no stop signs or red lights or anything this was a very quick within three blocks a range of our police department. Um when ah going to ah the struggle um that you ah talked about. The handcuffs that you took out were you ever able to put those on even one hand of this person? No. Okay. And when you said you dropped them at one point you were gonna put ?em you, your words were you were gonna put ?em back in your pouch but it was gonna take too much time to fold ?em up and put it away and so you dropped ?em on the ground. Correct. Did you ever pick those handcuffs back up again? I did not. Okay so they would have been left there? Correct. Okay. You ever had contact with this person before, that you saw? Not to my knowledge. Okay he didn?t look familiar to you or anything like that? No. Okay. (inaudible) you mentioned that ah the phrase thousand yard stare. Can you describe what that looks like? It looks, as if looked as if he was looking at something like a direct look in his however it doesn?t look, you just can't tell what he's looking at it's a very ah uncertain stare. It?s just this kind a glazed look. Almost like you?re you know like someone would be thinking about something you're just you?re so focused on something else but you?re, you just have a blank look on your face. Okay. In your seven years of police work is that ah the stare of a complaint person? No. Page 7 of 10 PhilI-20?l 5-648-A07 And usually you know when you see that, that there?s, there?s gonna be an issue it's non- compliant? Very much so. And so the same with when you, on your seven years as a cop when you tell people to get their hands out of their pockets what do they normally do? They take their hands out of their pockets. So you knew when this guy would not, you were thinking this is gonna somewhere right? Immediately. Okay. Um when you, after the shot was fired, Mark gets up do you remember seeing Mark's belt at all? Do you see his duty belt? I remember him being disheveled. Ijust remember him kinda of shifting around. Like when he stood up I think he was, he was trying to, he was trying to get up so fast and when he got up I, I don?t remember exactly like looking at his uniform or his belt but Ijust remember him trying to, trying to get his bearings back. Um-hm. Um, and then I remember seeing the gun in his hand when, that was the next thing I had remembered the, now the gun was in Mark's hand and its, its out cuz we?re trying to provide the security. Okay. Um I know that Minneapolis has (inaudible) for body cameras, um did the body cameras come through eh the 4th precinct? They did. And so some officers wore them for a period. Correct. Did you ever wear one? No. Okay. And currently now is anybody in your squad, your shift, your watch wear the body camera? No. Okay so there were no body cameras in at this scene as far as you know? Correct. And the camera that?s in your squad what is your understanding of what it?s there for? The squad camera what do you guys have it in your car for? (pause) What?s your understanding? It?s to capture, video footage from the front of the squad and then the rear seat. Um it?s to capture incidents such as vehicle pursuits and traffic stops. Ah it?s also, there in a emergency driving situations. Pursuit (inaudible) Yeah all sorts of vehicle related incidents. Okay. So you have a mic that goes with that it's on your person? Correct. The, there is a portable microphone that picks up just audio. Um-hm. Page 8 of 10 DS And that?s synced to the camera. My understanding is that that?s only to be worn it you know that the camera is running as well. MP Um-hm. DS They go hand in hand with another. MP So they're not permanently attached to you, you have to grab it out of a dock or something? DS Correct. MP Alright DS We're issued mics at the beginning of each shift and then theyjust stay in the vehicle unless we are gonna get out knowing that the, the whole system has been activated. MP Like on a traffic stop you?re up there talking to the person you?ve got the mic on? DS Correct. MP Okay. So as far as you know that?s what the cameras are for. You haven?t been directed to wear those with every police person contact (inaudible) DS Correct. MP Okay. My last question for you Dustin is what do you think would have happened if this person had gotten that, gotten Mark?s gun out of the holster? DS I thought we were gonna get shot. I, at first I thought Mark was gonna get shot. Just based on the body positioning and the, the things he was saying to me. Eh that was the first thing that was going through my mind. And then that just kinda turned into a thought of, maybe more people are gonna get shot there was just, there was innocent bystanders there was all these people around. There was paramedics. was there, I was so close to him. Ah the fear of him having control over my partner's gun having just full physical control and the belief that he has this gun and now my gun is out, there was just (sigh) there was a lotta I mean just having multiple firearms, semi-automatic weapons that are in this close proximity of this suspect who is, this person was you know actively, a resisting and making statements that ah he's ready to die. He just has this, you know he's, he?s made it clear. There was opportunities where you know we tried to, you know end the fight without violent results. We wanted to just you know, get a get him under control. MP Is there any doubt in your mind that if you didn?t act the way you acted that you or your partner might have been hurt badly or killed? Any doubt in your mind? DS Not one at all. MP Okay. SM Dustin the last thing that I?d like you to do if you?re okay with it is just draw a rough diagram of what the area looked like. Probably when you pulled up where ah the subject you came in contact with was standing. Where the medic supervisor was standing. Ambulance, medic supervisor rig and where you park. Doesn?t have to be a Picasso. And then l?m gonna specifically have you write on the bottom here that this is a not to scale. DS Okay. SM And ah and then I?ll have you sign it. DS Okay. (pause) SM Do you want to put like a, a direction that?s north and then like I said it doesn?t have to be a Phill-2015-648-AO7 Picasso but if Page 9 of 10 (pausefor ambulance, for medic and then for police car. (pause) DS The arrows are the directions that they?re facing. SM Perfect. And if you could just put an where ah the subject you came in contact with was. DS Yeah. SM And also the medic where he was when you first got out of the car. (pause) DS So the is him. And I?m sorry what?s for the medic? SM You can just put another and just right medic next to that one. (pause) SM Okay. Can you ah can you write not to scale and, wherever you want one of the corners or something like that. (pause) SM And then if you could sign it. Put a date next to it too that?d be great. (pause) SM Okay is there anything that we didn't bring up that you feel is important to, to let us know? Anything that we didn't cover? Anything that we didn?t ask DS Not at this time. SM Okay. Time is 9:09 we?ll be stopping the interview. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648-A07 Page 10 of ?10 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/12 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Primary Information Description: Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: Acquisition of Known DNA from MPD Officer Sworski and Conner 11/19/2015 00:00 11/19/2015 00:00 Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 12/08/2015 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On 11-19-2015 SA Henning obtained known DNA samples from Minneapolis Officers Sworski and Conner. Acquisition of exhibit 201 and 201 5-648? 2.2 Property #1 - Known DNA from Officer Jeffrey Sworski Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Submitted To PES: Collected Datefl'ime: Evidence DNA Sample Collection Kit Known DNA from Officer Jeffrey Sworski Pending Lab 11/19/2015 1 YES 11/19/2015 09:35 Property #2 - Known DNA from Officer Chad Michael Conner Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Submitted To PES: Collected Date/Time: Evidence DNA Sample Collection Kit Known DNA from Officer Chad Michael Conner Pending Lab 11/19/2015 1 YES Officers LEO Sworski, Jeffrey (Officer/ Minneapolis Police Department) Conner, Chad (Of?cer! Minneapolis Police Department) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/12 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/19/2015 12:38 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/08/2015 13:40 Reporting LEO a 7 7 Date-- . HSUperVi'sor' . Date - Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins onthe-following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:35 Page 2 of 3 On 11/19/2015 SA Henning met with Minneapolis Police Of?cers Sworski and Conner. SA Henning obtained known DNA samples from both of?cers, acquisition of exhibits 20 15?648/ 12.1 and .2. SA Henning submitted both samples to the BCA lab to be used during forensic processing of evidence in this case. Attached to this report are the receipts for this evidence. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East 315-14003 Agency Case Null-11,31- St. Paul, MN Laboratory Number TEL: 65 {-793?2900 20: 5-648 TTY: 651-442-6555 FAX: 65 L793 ~2901 LABORATORY ANALYSIS REQUEST BCA St Paul . . . 1430 Maryland Avenue East COUNTY- ennepm St. Paul, MN 55106 TELEPHONE: 651-7934 100 TYPE OF CASE: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death Attn: SA Mike Phill Report Distribution: BCA St. Paul 1 Section Involved Estimated Due Date Nuclear DNA 3/18/2016 CIRCUMSTANCES AND PURPOSE OF ANALYSIS: PRINCWALS: Date Of Birth $335 Race Comments Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Clark, Jamar Oneal 5/3/1991 SID a? Sworski, Jeffrey Steven Conner, Chad Michael ITEM DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE: Item In Container Packaging and Type Source Descrigtion 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a known Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Agency Item DNA sample collection kit #201 5648/12.! 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a known - Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item DNA sample collection kit #2015-648/122 Page I of 2 Submission Receipt for 315-14003 Submission 7 Lab Case Submitted By Received Bv 7 11/19/2015 13:29:17 Doug Julie Dornseif Submission Date and Time Page 2 01?12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension . i . offense Number: 2015548112 Case Agent: (1361 I MRO Homioide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Item Quantity Description 1 1 Known DNA from Of?cer Jeffrey Sworski 2 1 Known DNA from Of?cer Chad Michael Conner State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATEON I nearby certify that I have received the above Fsted property Signature Date Received 11/19/2015 Name Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - aul OwnerlFor Owner Address CityiState Released By Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Telephone Veri?ed By Eigegming 11/19/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 A Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/13 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Primary InformatiOn Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved ApprOVed Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: LR1: Positive ID of Jamar Clark through LP Analysis at BCA Lab Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11l19/201513:50 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/23/2015 17:54 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO 5 Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: 793-2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-International ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul Lab No. SIS-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Report No. 1 St. Paul, MN 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Latent Prints 1 1/18/2015 Laboratory Number: 815-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Latent Prints Agency Case Number: 2015-648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Principals: Jamar Oneal Clark Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packaging Description/Sauce 1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as MCP's Jamar Clark known major case prints 2 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a Images of questioned ink prints ?'om Item 1. disk with images Created by Scientist. Results of Laboratory Examination: KNOWN EXEMZPLARS (Said to be from) Name (DOB) Source of Exemplar Jamar Oneal Clark (5-3-91) BCA Files SID A request was received from the Hennepin County Medical Examiner?s Of?ce to compare ?ngerprints obtained from a deceased individual, tentatively identi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark, to known prints (from BCA ?les) said to be ?om Jamar Oneal Clark. Item 1: 0 Major Case Prints right thumb from deceased tentatively identi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark Questioned Inked Print! 51 0 Item 1, right thumb: identi?ed to the known right thumb from Jamar Oneal Clark Item 2 was created with images of prints from Item 1. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. ?at/aw Dennis P. Randall Forensic Scientist Disposition of Evidence: Item 1 will be held until all exams have been completed. Item 2 will be retained at the BCA Laboratory. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/14 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Statement of Officer Mark Ringgenberg, PD Occurrence From: 11/17/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Mueller, Scott (1305 Metro Regional Office! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference NUmbers Agency Case/File Number Hennepin County Medical Examiner 2015-6355 MN BCA Lab 315-14003 Minneapolis Police Dept 15?423384 Synopsis On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, SA Phill and SAIC Mueller interviewed PD Officer Mark Ringgenberg at the law offices of Fred Bruno. The statement was recorded and preserved on a disc labeled evidence item A hand drawn sketch made by Ringgenberg was also entered as item Address Occurred #1 3 seem AVE Primary Information Address: 906 5TH AVE, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55405 United States Subject #1 SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES . Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: I Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Nam 12?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/14 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 .- SchwarZe,- Dustin Tim'othy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name ?g EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications State (RD?unity. 9.03m FBI ID NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota N0 Property #1 - Audio CD of Mark Ringgenberg-Statement Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - PhilI. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 201 5-648/14 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Property #1 - Audio CD 0f Mark R?in?ggenbfer'g Statement -..C.ontinued Primary Information - Continued Description: Audio CD of Mark Ringgenberg Statement Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/17/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Prbpelrty-?itz - Hand drawn sketch..Ofc Ringenberg Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Hand drawn sketch by Ofc Ringgenberg Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/17/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/19/201514:17 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/30/201518:40 Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEOI Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 [Erratum begins onuthe foltowing page. . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, Special Agents (SA) Phill and Mueller interviewed Minneapolis Police (Mp1s PD) Officer (Ofc) Mark Ringgenberg regarding the November 15'Eh Of?cer Involved Shooting of Jamar Clark. The interview took place in the of?ces of his attorney, Fred Bruno, who was present for the interview. Ofc Ringgenberg and his partner, Ofc Schwarze tried to arrest Clark, scuf?e ensued and Ofc Schwarze ended up shooting Clark who later died ?om his wound. The following is only a smnmary of Ofc Ringgenberg?s statement. Please refer to the attached transcript of the entire interview or to the digital audio recording of the interview. The audio was burned to a CD and labeled evidence item 2015-648/ 14.1 along with a hand drawn sketch of the crime scene by Ringgenberg labeled item 14.2. Ringgenberg said he and Schwarze were at the 4th Precinct when they received a call of paramedics needing assistance. The call was at 1600 Plymouth Av which was only a few blocks east of the 4th Precinct on Plymouth. They did not activate their lights and sirens because the location was so close and there was no traf?c to navigate through. Ringgenberg said that upon arrival, they were met by a paramedic supervisor who advised that a black male standing nearby was interfering with the treatment his EMTs were trying to give an assault victim. Further, they were told that the black male was possibly the suspect in their patient?s assault. Ringgenberg said they approached the male and told him to get his hands out of his pockets. He noted the male had a strange look in his eyes and a weird stare. Ringgenberg drew his weapon and held it in front of him, not pointing it at the male but asking again to get his hands out of his jacket pockets. The male still refused so Ringgenberg holstered his weapon and went to grab the subjects right hand and pull it out of his jacket pockets. He had to forcefully pull his hands out of his pockets but he could not get his hands behinds his back to safely handcuff him. The male was resisting their efforts to get him handcuffed. Ringgenberg said he decided to take the male to the ground to more quickly overcome his resistance and get him cuffed. When they took him down however, Ringgenberg said he ended up partially on tOp of the male with his back to the male and partially with his front to the sky and to the side. Ringgenberg said he tried to roll away from the male and he felt his gun, holstered to his right side, pull towards his back. He felt back there and felt the male?s hand wrapped around the grip of the pistol as he tried to get it out. Ringgenberg tried hard with the back of his right hand to keep the male from pulling it out but he did not have a good angle to properly use weapon retention techniques he was taught in classes. He yelled at his partner, Ofc Schwarze ?He?s got my gun, he?s got my gun? more than a couple times. All Ringgenberg felt he could do was try to roll away but keep pressure on the gun at the same time while also trying push the gun down. After telling Schwarze again ?He?s got my gun,? he heard Schwarze say something like ?Let go, or I?ll shoot you? but the male then said ?I?m ready to die? which instantly ?lled him with the fear that he was going to die. After telling Schwarze a couple more times that he had his gun, he told him to shoot the male. He then heard on shot and he was then free to get up from the male. Ringgenberg then drew his weapon and began watching the crowd on the north side of the street. Ringgenberg did not remember if his Level 3 holster had the hood over the gun when he holstered before going hands?on with the male. Ringgenberg said he kept watch to the north side of Plymouth because people were gathering and causing a commotion across the street and he saw that Schwarze was watching to the south towards the townhomes and apartments on Plymouth Av. Ringgenberg said that he saw the EMT supervisor get out of the ambulance and hit it yelling ?Go, Go Go? and it left the scene. The supervisor then went to his own truck and pulled out medical bags to give the male medical treatment. Ringgenberg said he and Schwarze acted as scene security for each other, the injured male, the EMT supervisor and themselves as they waited for backup. Ringgenberg said he and his partner never got the male handcuffed nor did they identify him. He also said he did not recognize the male from any previous police calls. Finally, Ringgenberg said that he believed that if Schwarze did not shoot the male, then he likely would have killed himself, Schwarze or somebody else in the area. STATE OF MINNESOTA F?s-50030 (REV- 12102) Minnesata DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bu'eau of {Emma Apprehension BET-saints. 5: Brawl?? 7 EVIDENCE RECEIPT .JO/S-wkft 470.95 ?em S.W. Lab Guam 'Name of Person From Propeny iEbbtained Purpose For Which thained Mm No Item Item we. No. my ?Saw Civil/Er {/w/rW/?fpf 9/5 DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES Evidence Nu 54/065 Fm' macaw->546 A pix/55 (my 1) MW EST/more; '1 CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVES AND HOLD FOR azerTirne Signamrsv a I /7 :5 ??jylf I CHAIN OF CUSTODY 1 MM Item 3 . . Na Date Rehnqurshed By Received 83; Signature STATE OF MINNESOTA :4 Minnesata Bureau of Criminal Apprehension EVIDENCE RECEIPT PS-G-OOSU (Rev. 124'02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Laboratory Na. N0 ?em SW. Lab Guam 'Name of Person From Pmpeny is?Obtafned Purpose For Which Chained ltem it A No- No. If? my ?rm/we 4d 1534/ ?rm/c (7/5 I DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES my?; 52mgx55 {?97 .7 ,5 {Mk/fr? a; r/ wen-4 f/ sf I WV I CERTIFY THAT RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE atemma Signature MW p; - WT Starage SiTe H7715 [Kc-am 7? CHAIN OF CUSTODY 1 a ME if: Date Fleiinquished By Received By 2% STgnam re /7 Bureau of Criminal Apprehension 1430 Maryland Avenue East, St. Paul. Minnesota 55106-2802 Phone: 651?282?6555 Internet: BJeeu of Criminal Apcreizersicn CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION WARNING You are hereby advised that you are being interviewed by a Special Agent of the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension as part of an official criminal investigation. This investigation is separate from any internal investigation that may have been conducted by your employer. You may already have been interviewed pursuant to an internal investigation. If so, you may have been told that your statements could not be used against you in any criminal proceeding. It should therefore be clari?ed that any statements you give to BCA agents as part of this criminal investigation can be used against you in a subsequent criminal proceeding. If any representation has been made to you that you must or should answer to questioning by BCA agents as part of an internal investigation, you should disregard that representation. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This statement is given by me voluntarily. I am not making this statement because of threats made or pressure exerted on me by my employer, anyone associated with my employer, or any other individual. No consideration or reward has been promised to me in exchange for my agreement to make a statement. I HAVE READ THIS DOCUMENT AND FULLY UNDERSTAND ITS CONTENTS. gym/Jig? Sigh?a ure 4 14/ Date .- . - Witness - (awe) A (GENSISfame) - (GENSIS) A K. f) 21/" .l 1 97-" ?if; 3SESS3N.LIM I {Epic} if ~r (sagas) 37/ $317A'l'l?d GNV SIHL EAVH I 0.1. 31va N338 GHVM38 HO ANV 3AVH HON N338 .LON 3AVH I 3W A8 NBAIE) SI SIHJ. ANV .LV 38 NVO J.N3SNOO A 4V 797-349 3v oaalaosao MN aaGNn mama/x HO SHJ. :10 Hoavas .LOFIGNOO 01 3331330 831-110 ANV HO GNV ?uadvs amend :10 50 means EHJ. :10 (SMONSILSBANI 7 .7 a 94;; 7?7 2: CINV ?3:4 Jag; azmomnv ASEHEH ?Hoavas Hons o_L 01 380338 OJ. mam AW :10 CINV .LNVHEIVM HOHVES GEEIHOSSO HO 3H1. so aavw Heavens EAVH 01m mam AW :10 N338 SNIAVH :63; f) ?1 LIJ HOHV3S Oi .LN3SNOO nemem 9999382199 01.902179 L99 ?InE?d '18 ?enUEWv? 91721. uogsuequddv leugLugJQ 4o neeJna Ghana :10 VLOSEINNIIN (N.O. 239 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 17, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Mark Ringgenberg (OR) INTERVIEWED BY: SAIC Scott Mueller (SM) Attorney Robert Sicoli (RS) SA Michael Phill (MP) REVIEWED BY: On November 17th 2015, SA Michael Phill and SAIC Scott Mueller interviewed PD Officer Mark Ringgenberg at the law office of Fred Bruno. Also in the room was Robert Sicolipresently 1853 hours on November 2015. Special Agent Michael Phill along with Special Agent in Charge Scott Mueller, currently at ah Bruno Law Firm in Minneapolis, Minnesota to interview Officer Mark Ringgenberg of the Minneapolis Police Department. This is ah for BCA case number 2015-648. Also present in the room is Officer Ringgenberg?s attorney Robert Sicoli of the Sicoli Law Firm. Mark I want to go ahead and get some basic info down here that we want to get ironed out for the report. Your first is Spelled and Ringgenberg is spelled correct? Yes. And address for contact is 1925 Plymouth Avenue North, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412. Contact phone number 612?673?5704. Mark you told me your Minneapolis badge number was 6030. Correct? Yes. Alright. Mark 3 little bit of background on your ah police career and education urn you said that you after getting your high school diploma you went to college. Correct? Yes. What did you get there? Ah I got a Bachelors degree in criminal justice from St. Mary?s University in Minnesota. Okay and you remember what year that was? Year of completion? Ah 2008. Alright. And after that did you immediately seek a police employment? Ah, yes right after that was employed by the San Diego Police Department. Okay. And you were certified as a police officer in San Diego, correct? Yes. Um I didn?t ask you your did you have a POST or a, a skills number for California? Not that I know of no. You were just certified for the city to work after that? Yes. Okay. And you worked there for how many years? Page 1 of 14 Phill-20?l Ah approximately four, just under four years. Alright and ah after four years you left of your own volition and lateralled to the State of Minnesota? Yes. And where did you go work then? Ah Maple Grove Police Department. Alright. And same thing you passed probation there and ah were given a full timejob and worked for how long? Ah approximately two and a half years. Did you hold any specialty duties there? Anything different beyond patrol? Ah my last assignment was a with the Maple Grove City Streets Unit. Okay is that a plain clothes unit? Ah sometimes yes. ls it for targeting certain crime specific areas or hotspots or issues in the city? Yes. Okay. And from there ah you ah took the opportunity to lateral to the Minneapolis Police Department? Yes. Ah and for them you had to go through another academy? Yes I went through the Minneapolis ah Police Academy. It was a lateral academy it was approximately ten to twelve weeks. Okay. And you started what month and year? Ah September of 2014. Okay. Which puts you um off probation in approximately September of this year? Yes. Okay. Um I didn?t ask you earlier what is your Minnesota ah skills number? Ah 21349. Okay. Now in working for Minneapolis it?s been a little over a year you haven?t had any other specialty assignments or details like that safe streets correct? No I?ve worked only patrol. Okay. And can you tell me what precincts you?ve worked at besides the 4?h where you?re currently assigned? Ah the 3rd precinct as well. Okay. And ah you are currently assigned to what you call um 4 precinct middle watch? Yes. And what are the hours for that? Ah it?s 1600 or 4:00 PM. to 0200 or 2:00 AM. Okay. And ah the time you?ve been there is it generally a two person car for the most of the time you?ve been at 4? Page 2 of 14 Phill?2015?648-A08 Yes. And ah you, current partner now um you picked him and picked him up as a partner when? Ah approximately June when I came to the 4th precinct. Okay. So you?ve been together pretty much ever since except for vacation days or different things? Sometimes we ride with some different people um because, on our car, but for the most part we, we ride together quite a bit. Okay. And his name is? Ah Dustin Schwarze. Okay. Ah you and Dustin both where you work that middle watch 4:00 PM. to 2:00 AM. generally unless there?s overtime or something else going on and you wear your ah a uniform correct? Yes. Can you describe that uniform for me from head to toe. Um my I have a from a about the second I think it?s the second week in November maybe the first week we have to wear long sleeves so I had a long sleeve ah light blue shirt on. Um the shirt has a patch on each shoulder. It?s a darker blue patch. it says Minneapolis Police and it has a, a sailboat and a lake in the middle of it. Urn on my chest on my left side I have the Minneapolis Police badge um it?s silver and gold in the middle, it has my badge number on it and it says Minneapolis Police and it says Police Officer on there. Um on my right breast wear a, a nameplate that has my first initial and my last name and it?s a, a golden color. Okayduty belt which is black in color. And it?s Leather or nylon? it?s a leather it?s a basket weave leather. Um.. And your pants? Ah I have a dark blue a cargo pants on. And then a, a black um they?re kinda like boots, boots kind of tennis shoes. Okay something good you can run in? Yes. Okay. And then back up to your ah leather duty belt. Can you describe for me what?s on that belt going around it from left to right? Ah I have a, a plastic buckle in the middle. Um and then there is a ah magazine pouch which has two magazines in it just to the left of that. Um?hm. Ah right next to that I put a, a keeper and then I have my radio and my flashlight. And then right behind that have another keeper. And then in the small of my back I have another keeper. And then I have a set a handcuffs right behind my gun which is on my right side. On either side of my gun directly next to it I have a keeper and then in front of my gun I have a um ah OC spray and then a set of handcuffs. Okay. Page 3 of 14 Phill-2015-648?A08 And then it?s the belt buckle again. Alright so there?s a total of three mags, two in the front and you?ve got one in the pistol itself. Yes. How many ah rounds are in each magazine? Um there?s twenty rounds in each magazine. And those are 9 mm? Yes. And what type of pistol do you have there? Ah it?s a Sig Sauer ah P226. Okay. Is that ah owned by the police department or do you have to purchase it yourself? Ah I had to purchase that myself. So you?re the actual owner of that? Yes. Okay. And when you say keepers, what is a keeper? Ah it holds your, your duty belt to your inner belt. 80 it holds it in place so it won?t move around. Okay. Is yours snap or Velcro? Ah mine?s snap they there's ah two buttons or two snaps on each keeper. Okay two snaps on each keeper. You?ve got four of them total. Ah five total. Five total and that?s designed to keep your belt stable when you have to move, run, jump do any of that stuff keep your belt stable on you?re the belt around your pants? Yes. Okay. Mark do you carry a taser at all? Ah I do not I?m not issued one. Okay some people are on the shift but, or is it a sergeants? Some people are but I?m not issued Okay. Do you carry a backup weapon? Backup pistol? I, I do not. Okay. Um the issue of body cameras we know Minneapolis PD is looking at that and some people were um getting those assigned to them. Did you have a body camera on that night? No I did not. Do you know if anybody currently does on your shift? Um, no I don?t believe anybody does. Page 4 of 14 Phill-2015-648-A08 Okay. Okay um one question ah before I get into what happened on the 14th was just to ask you about your training records. Do you remember the last time that you were ah certified and ah got your you know use of force for firearms and handcuffing that sort of thing? Ah I believe my use of force was the beginning part of 2015 and firearms was around the same. Um?hm. And I?m guessing because it?s only been a little over a year that it?s pretty recent. Yes. Okay. As far, you qualified, passed everything?s good to go as far as you know? Yes. Okay. Alright so Mark on the night of ah November 14th um you were working with Dustin. Um and you started your shift at 4:00 can you tell us what happened for this particular call. Um you don?t have to be specific on time but um what happened, what did you hear and how did you guys react? Um well it, I remember it came out as a ah um paramedics need assistance. Ah I believe they said they were trying to treat a patient and there was somebody who was interfering with that and they believed he was possibly the suspect. Okay. And, at the time that that gets called you were at the 4th precinct? Yes. Okay you?re at the 4?h precinct which means you had to drive there? Yes. And can you tell me what, about your squad? Um it?s ah ah it?s a newer ah Ford Explorer. Um it?s a it has a, a black front end and rear end and the, the all the doors are white. Okay. Um there's a Minneapolis badge on the front doors. And it says ah Minneapolis Police on the back. And I believe it says um to protect with courage to serve with pride on the doors. Okay. Um and then there is a, a red and blue light bar on top of the car. Okay. And ah this is the car you and Dustin usually use? Try to check out the same one or does it vary per shift? Ah generally your, car matches your area the number Oh okay So we usually take um 424. Okay. And you had 424 that night? Yes. And then you jump in the car to respond to the scene. Is that vehio, vehicle have a, squad camera? Yes it does there?s a, a camera ah mounted to the um just next to the ah the rear View mirror. Okay. And ah how is that camera activated? Page 5 of 14 Phill-2015-648?A08 Ah when you turn your lights on all the way over to um the number 3, the code, code 3 ah the camera automatically activates. Okay. So without that it?s not gonna come on, is there a way to manually just turn it on? There is um there?s a kind of a control box um in the, in the car and you can hit record and manually turn it on. Okay. But for this call you were headed just a few blocks from the precinct to this address 1600 Plymouth. And um you guys did not activate your lights and sirens. Can you tell me why Ah it was just around the corner. Um the call just ah it, it paramedics just kinda needed assistance they were just trying to figure out um what was going on Um?hm and this time of night the call was roughly, what time? Um I believe about 12:30 around there. Okay so there was no traffic issues between the precinct and the call. Right? No. There you can just get right there, that time of night. Yeah Okay than I mean it?s really quick. Okay so your lights and sirens weren?t activated cuz you can get there really fast? Yes. Okay so you and Dustin arrived on scene. Can you tell me what happened? Um as we arrive on scene um I remember there was an ambulance parked on ah south curb line in front of a of um a townhome complex. Um they were facing ah east. Directly behind was a SUV which a usually I know the paramedic supervisor?s usually got it. Hm And that had its overhead emergency lights activated. And that was facing west directly behind the ambulance on the south curb line. Um we parked behind the SUV. I can?t remember if we pulled up on the sidewalk to kinda get outta traffic or if we parked directly behind the, the SUV but we parked just to the west of that SUV. Okay. And then you got out of the car who did you interact with first? Um as we exited I saw there was a, a the paramedic supervisor um was standing between the ambulance and another male party who was over in that sidewalk area. Urn the paramedic supervisor saw us and immediately walked towards us and he said they had somebody who had been assaulted in the ambulance and the individual standing on the sidewalk had a been interfering with them trying to treat that person. And ah he believed that that person had possibly assaulted, so he believed he was possibly a suspect in the assault. Okay. So you knew that right off the bat that he was possibly the suspect and he was interfering with them giving her treatment? Yes. Ah what did that male look like? Urn he was a black male. Urn and he was standing on the, the sidewalk and he was wearing a, a blackjacket and he had his hands stuffed in his pockets. And he had hair I can?t Page 6 of 14 Phill-2015-648-A08 remember if they were dreadlocks but he had hair hanging all around his face it was kinda hard to see his face. And i, I could just I remember he was just he had this really weird, um stare about him. He just there was just this look in his it ah it was really weird look. Um and it kinda it, it was just something ah it made me a little nervous just the look so I walked towards him and I told him to take his hands out of his pockets. And he refused. And so as was doing that l, I pulled my gun from my holster and I held it right in front of me. I never pointed it at him but I just walked towards him and told him several more times take your hands out of your pockets. And he still refused. And all he would do is he would just yell what's the pistol for. He just kept yelling that over and over again. So as I walked towards him I put my handgun in my holster and I grabbed his right hand cuz he was still refusing our orders to take his hands out of his pockets. And I held his right hand and I think his coat briefly and I tried to feel to make sure there was no weapons in his coat pocket. I remember it was a bigger bulkier coat. And ah so at that point I ordered him i said put your hands behind your back. Um i wanted to make sure he didn?t have any weapons and, and he kept um he would, he wouldn?t I had to forcibly pull his hand his right hand out of his pocket. Dustin had grabbed ah the left side. Um?hm. And so I pull his hand and I?m telling him I told him several times put your hands behind your back. Um, he ah he, he kept refusing and he was pulling away and l, I couldn't get his hands behind his back so we could safely handcuff him. Um so at that point um i ah I grabbed him around I went to grab around the upper chest area and tried to take him to the ground. I took him to the ground ah so we could safely um get him handcuffed. Um ljust, l, ljust remember ah there were so many people I, I remember there were a lotta people in the townhouses on the balconies and I remember across the street it was really busy. And I know I just i wanted to, to try and, and get him handcuffed as quickly and safely as possible. So ah that?s, that?s why I took him to the ground so we could try and get him handcuffed and, and overcome his resistance. Um-hm. Um, as a as we went to the ground was in front of him and I grabbed him and I took him down and he went on his back. And I landed kind of on my side on top of him. And I don?t remember where Dustin was at that point. Okay. And when we go to the ground I?m kind of on my side and I?m in a weird position. And I remember thinking we?re just kinda tangled up and I?m gonna roll away so they can grab him and we can get him rolled over and get him handcuffed. So i, I try and roll away. As i do this my gun, goes from my right hip to the small of my back. And I, ljust get pulled um right in. And I?m, I?m pretty much on my back at this point. And I tell Dustin ?He's got my gun." And so I?m on my back and l?m trying to reach around but I?m in such a weird angle with him underneath me and my gun in the small of my back I?m trying to hold my gun down. All I can do is get the back of my hand on top of my gun. And so i, I feel his, his whole hand he?s got the, whole gun. can feel his, his hand he?s got my whole grip. His hands wrapped around the grip of your pistol? Yes. And he was pulling on it. And I?m trying to, to keep it down with the back of my hand. And ah I?m trying to, to roll away all at the same time. And I?m at such an angle that I can hardly hold my gun and, and i keep telling Dustin "He?s got my gun, he's got my gun." And there, there was nothing I could, I could do to, to keep it down there. i could, I all I could really do was, I was trying to roll away and put pressure on it all at the same time and hold it in with my hand but, my hand was at it was just such a weird angle l, I could, I had no strength or, or anything to push down on his hand. And so ah, I?m telling Dustin ?He?s got my gun.? And I remember Dustin telling him to, I can't remember exactly, it was something like Page 7 of 14 Phill-2015?648-A08 ?Llet go or I?m gonna shoot you.? And then ah the guy said ah ?I'm ready to die." And um that was the, the worst feeling ever because ah eh it was eh it just my heart just sank right there. And What did that mean to you when he says I?m ready to die? I, I thought I was gonna die at that point. Um I, I had no control over my gun. This guy didn't seem to, to care what happened to him or us or anybody elsetell Dustin a couple more times, I keep telling him ?He?s got my gun.? When you say you tell him are you talking in a normal voice or are you yelling that? No I?m, I?m yelling. So you?re screaming this, yelling this, what are Yes I?m, I?m, l?m yelling I?m, I?m yelling. (inaudible) "He?s got my gun.? Okay. "He?s got my gun." How did you scream that how would you yell that? How loud would you do you remember being? Pre, (sigh) pretty loud I mean loud enough where, you know (inaudible) my main concern was that Dustin could hear me. Um I, ljust remember thinking that, that I couldn?t let my partner get killed with my gun. So, so ah, ah (clears throat) excuse me Okay. So, I think Dustin says again ?I?m gonna shoot him.? And that, l, I ah I keep telling Dus l, I told Dustin I said ?shoot him." And then ah I remember the round going off. And then I ah I was able to roll away. And then I, I stood up and it was just people everywhere. Um and then everybody was yelling. And ah I, I didn?t know what was gonna happen at that point. So I remember the paramedic supervisor tell the, tells the ambulance to go. I remember him banging on the side of the door and telling ?em to go get outta there. And then ah, I ah I grabbed my gun and I tried to watch the north side of the street. And I stood on, the one side of ah of the suspect and Dustin was on the, the townhome side. And the supervisor was in between us I remember was trying to treat him. And so we got on the radio I know Dustin put out shots fired, I remember thatthe radio and I called for help cuz there were so many people. Um?hm.? And ah I just kept looking over my shoulder at Dustin making sure he was alright. And then ah just waited for all the other cars to get there. And so when the other ah the other cars got there and then ah were helping keep the crowd back and ah another officer told us ah to get in his car. He wanted to get us away from the scene cuz it was, such a, a crazy scene. He ah, Dustin jumped in the front and I jumped in the back seat and then we drove, drove to the precinct. Okay. And going back to your, getting your gun out when you got up do you remember where your gun was on your body? Don?t um, I remember when was on the ground I know it was in the small of my back cuz I couldn?t reach it. But when I got up um it's stupid I remember I originally ah it went through my mind for whatever reason, I to grab it, because I knew what had just happened and l, Page 8 of 14 Phill-2015-648-A08 So you were thinking in terms of evidence It crossed my mind like briefly but I knew I had to get my gun out and just, (inaudible) it went through my mind just probably a second but i knew what i had to do so I, ljust grabbed my gun and tried to watch the other side of the street. Okay. And so you holstered a in the car you were being taken back to the precinct and your weapon stayed in your holster? Yes. Until what time? Um until ah, ah our 21 or our, our ah that?s their, their call sign or unit designator Um-hm it?s our ah bureau of investigations they?d come out and they, they took my, my gun from me. Okay. Ah did your holster have a, a level two, a level three a hood anything like that to keep it retained? Yes it has a, a hood. Um and then there?s a, another like button you push so i guess it would be a level three. Okay. Um, when I walked up to him I remember putting my gun away but I don?t remember if I, snapped my, my hood or not, hm before I grabbed him. Okay. But you did have it out when you approached him and then you hol, re-holstered but you don?t remember if you snapped that hood back? No. Okay. I don?t. Okay. I want to back up a little bit. Um to first getting on scene. When you see somebody with their hands in their pockets and you tell 'em to get their hands out of their pockets why are you doing that? For, my safety Dustin?s safety, everybody?s safety um people commonly conceal weapons in their pockets. Um so my concern is I want to be able to see his hands so I know he doesn?t have any weapons. And most people you tell that to, in all the days you?ve worked when you tell 'em show me your hands, get your hands out of pockets what do they do? They get their hands out of their pockets. They show you there?s no weapon? Yes. And did this individual ever do that? No. He, he never complied with anything we told him to do. He never put his hands behind his back. He never ah um never took his hands out of his pockets. He never did anything we told him to do. Okay. And you said it was actually you and Dustin who had to get his hands pulled and yank ?em out of the pockets? Yes. Page 9 of 14 PhilI-2015?648?A08 Okay. And you also said as you approached him you, you saw a cray ah not a crazy look but a very concerning look in this guys eyes. Um did you lock eyes with him? (no audible response) Or was it his entire face that was very off to you? I was watching, his eyes as I walked towards him and l'm watching his, kinda just watching his whole his Um?hm was really worried about his hands. i remember his face he was just kinda he was looking at us but kind of at an angle and his hair was just hanging all around his face and he was just staring at us. its just, it about, his stare it, it was just it was a, a weird stare. Was it a look of fear? No. No it wasn?t, it wasn?t fear. Um it, itjust, it?s hard to describe. But you said that look made you uneasy? Yes. Okay. And you?ve been an officer for, for approximately seven years? Yes. And that type of a look gave you concern? Yes. Okay. Um with respect to his hands in his pockets how cold was it that night? Urn, maybe in the fifties. I don't remember it being, that cold wasn?t wearing ajacket. Okay. And was it raining? Not that I remember no. Was there snow on the ground? No. Were you wearing a jacket or gloves? um i might have had gloves on, 1 might have black gloves um but other than that no I wasn?t wearing anything else. Okay. Are those gloves for police use or for cold use? Ah police use. Okay. Police use for cutting, grabbing, moving things? Yes. Okay so you don?t recall it being cold enough for someone to not comply saying it was too cold to get my hands out? i No. Okay. Now, so you guys you and Dustin have each arm. He?s not complying. You?re trying to get his hands behind his back. And you said that you then made a move to take him to the ground. What have you been taught? Why did you take him to the ground to try to cuff him as opposed to doing it up, standing up with a person who isn?t seeming to be compliant? Page 10 of14 Phill-2015?648-A08 When I went through the academy in San Diego was taught anybody who resists you take them to the ground. lt?s safer for everybody. It?s easier to, to gain control and place them in handcuffs. Um, it ah it?s just safest way to do things rather than to try and stand up it?s harder to get leverage when people are standing Um?hm. easier and it?s easier for them to assault you Have you and Dustin done this before? Yes. Take people to the ground to arrest them? Yes. Okay so you?re a team you guys work together you know what to do? Yes. Alright so you, with your training and experience taking him to the ground makes it safer for everybody and easier to get him cuffed? Yes. However it didn?t work out that way right? No. Okay. He went after your pistol. So when he does grab for your pistol, what were you taught about weapon retention? What kind of things can you do to try to keep that from coming out of the holster? was ah, a lot of the weapon retention I?ve been taught is mainly when standing up. Um-hm was taught to (inaudible) lock your weapon down. Um add a spin into the elbow, the opposite way that they?re, they?re hand goes. Um-hm. Or ah you know depending on the circumstances the other way but ah just try and, remove yourself from that situation while maintaining your handgun as quickly as possible. But that?s been mainly standing up what you?ve been taught? Mainly yes. And in this situation you?re lying on your back and side and you feel the weapon is actually pulled to the small of your back which means those keepers came loose? I don?t remember ifthey came loose or not but I (sigh) it?s never happened to be me before that somehow the whole, the whole gun the whole thi .. Holster and everything? Everything went to the small of my back. Okay. So, So now the things you were taught with retention, grabbing it, pushing it down, clamping it down you couldn?t do it because it was in the small of your back? And you made a motion that you used the back of your hand to try to hold it? Page 11 of14 Phill-2015?648-A08 was trying, I was at such a weird angle and with him under me I was trying to get my hand back there so I could look my gun into my holster and I would know where it, where it is. But all I could really do was get the back of my hand on top of it. With the angle I was at I couldn?t, I couldn?t move my hand I couldn?t reach it. And all I could feel was his hand just he just had this grip on my gun and he was just pulling. And ah, that, that?s all I could I couldn?t, I, was trying to, to pull away and I couldn?t pull away. And I was trying to push down, and was trying to do all this at the same time and, and nothing was working. Um?hm. Nothing I would do would work. You say he was pulling at it could you feel him trying to pull it out of the holster? Yes. Yes ah he was, he was pulling so hard on my gun I was trying to roll away as hard as I could and pull away and I, I couldn?t move. I, I was just I wasjust stuck on my back. Okay. Um going back to when you first walked up to the subject. You said his hands were in his pockets. Which pockets were they, were they pants pockets, jacket pockets? Do you remember which pockets his hands were in? Yes they were in his, his jacket pockets I remember he had a, a bulkier black jacket on and they were shoved in his jacket pockets. Okay. Um and then going to, immediately after the ah the shot was fired you referenced the ah medic supervisor was outside. Was he outside during this, this confrontation ah of dealing with the subject or was he somewhere else? I don?t remember because just as, as soon as he told us what, what they had he said they were trying to figure everything out and my attention was, immediately drawn to the guy he pointed at, at on the sidewalk. Urn at that point I, I don?t know where he went or what he did. And the next thing I remember from him is when I?m standing up I, I see the side door of the ambulance open and I see him banging on the, the side of the ambulance and he was just saying go-go-go. Okay. Um at any time did you and your partner ever handcuff the subject that you were dealing with? No that was our intention when we were standing up. But we, we were never able to, to get handcuffs on him. Okay. How about afterwards? No um the paramedic supervisor grabbed his thing he came running over and ah it didn?t even ah I just remember looking at the, the scene across the street but um we never, we never put him in handcuffs. Do you ever remember taking your handcuffs out or anything or having them out in your hands? No cuz I remember ah I think Dustin had his out and he had his left hand. And I was trying to get his other hand in there so we could get him in handcuffs and itjust wasn't, wasn?t working. Okay. He ah the subject that ah I think you described that you dealt with, you ever seen him before? You ever dealt with him before or been on calls with that person before? Not, not that I can remember no. Okay. Um the only other thing Ijust want to clarify and kinda go back to the beginning is ah prior to turning the tape recorder on we ah sat and explained to you the criminal Page 12 of14 investigative warning, that we don?t do internal affairs investigations. That this is a criminal investigation. We explained to you that this is a consensual interview. And you don?t have to talk to with us if you don?t to talk with us. Um and we showed you a criminal investigative form that basically says that in short. Um that you agreed to sign and, and have an interview with us and speak with us. Um you?re okay talking with us, you?re okay giving us a statement. Yes. Um and then the other form that we showed you is a ah consent to get his DNA form um if you're okay with ah us taking a mouth swab? Yes. Okay. Um I, I think that?s about it just have two, two quick points. You said that you stood when after the shooting you stood there facing the crowd that was coming out of that club. Um and then Dustin was back facing the other side or the other side and you had the guy on the ground between you and at the EMT supervisor between you. Um what, what role were you two fulfilling at that point? We were just trying to, keep everybody that was there safe. We were trying to keep, the paramedic supervisor safe. We were trying to keep the suspect safe. And we were trying to keep each other safe. Okay. Cuz that was, that was our scene at that point. That was your scene, you knew it was now a crime scene and you knew that ah you had help coming? Um?hm. Now as far as giving medical aid um did you do that or were you guys relying on the EMT for that? We were relying on the EMT for that. You remember if any words were spoken hey you know is he alive, are you gonna help him, anything did you say to the EMT guy? He, hejust, did it all on his own. Okay. he told the ambulance to go and then [just I, I remember Dustin and I kinda took a, a position on either side so we were you know kinda back to back with a little space in between us. Okay. And he just ran to his SUV and he grabbed a couple bags Okay. came running to, to the guy. 80 you let the role of giving aid to him to the EMT supervisor? Yes. And you and Dustin performed pretty much security and waited for backup? Yes. Page 13 of?l4 MP My last question for you Mark is, what do you think would have happened if this guy had gotten your gun out and Dustin did not fire? OR 1 would have died. And Dustin might have died. Maybe the other people there I don?t know urn MP is there any doubt in your mind about that? OR None. When, when he said "l'm ready to die? that was, that?s the worst feeling I?ve ever felt, so um (inaudible) Dustin saved my life there?s no doubt about it. MP Okay. SM If you could ah and it doesn?t have to be a Picasso if you?re okay with it can you draw us a not to scale just kind of a rough diagram of kinda the, the layout of where the medic supervisor was when you guys pulled up in relationship to the ambulance and then maybe just a couple X?s of where you were, where the subject was, where Dustin was when you first walked up. OR So, (pause) this is Plymouth. Runs ah east and west. SM Um?hm. OR Um (pause) the ambulance was here, facing east. The, the SUV was here, facing that way. And then we parked our car somewhere in here. And like I said I can?t remember if we were on the, sidewalk or on the street. And then paramedic supervisor would have been here. And, the suspect was about, here. So he kinda had positioned himself between the ambulance and the suspect. And Dustin was driving and I was ridingwalked towards him so we walked up here. SM Okay. Can you, can you I don't know write subject for this, this one and write medic for this one for lack of a better term. And I know you guys were fluid l?m not gonna have you place yourself um because that was, from what you said kind of moving all over the place there?s no need for that. If, if you could for me ah just write not to scale just so anybody that sees this knows that this is not to scale. Um and then sign it under that. (pause) SM Thanks. Is there anything else that we haven?t asked that we either skipped or omitted or, or neglected to ask that you think ah is important that we should know about? OR Hm nothing that i can think of. RS No. MP Okay. We?re gonna go ahead and stop the interview. It is presently 1932 hours. END OF RECORDING. Page 14 of 14 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 201 5-648/15 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Primary Information - Description: Evidence pick up I HCME (DNA - FA) Occurrence From: 1111912015 13:33 Occurrence To: 1111912015 14:29 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1112312015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (13261 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers 8.9.892! ass/rm Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - St. Paul 315-14003 Hennepin County Medical Examiners Office 2015-6355 Synopsis . On Thursday, November 19, 2015, SA Olson picked up known DNA and other biological samples from the Hennepin County Medical Examiner's office and delivered the items to the BCA lab for analysis. Six items of evidence obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - - Hennepin Examiners-Of?ce Primary Information Address: Hennepin County Medical Examiners Office, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #1 MENTION IN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 0510311991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks - - - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/15 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Subject #1 - MENTION IN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued Identifications ID Type Number ?g FBI 717111FD1 232941 Minnesota State 10 - Minnesota PM: NO NO NO 99mm Property. #1 - Bulleth 'P'rojectite: Metal fragment, (left-:temporalis (HOME Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Ammunition Description: Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Bullet! Projectile: Metal fragment, left temporalis (HOME 3) Property #2 - Bullet Projectile: Bullet from right occipital (HOME 9) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Ammunition Description: Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11l19/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Bullet Projectile: Bullet from GSW I right occipital (HOME 9) Property #3 - Btood prep (HOME 2) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Known Blood Sample Description: Blood prep (HOME 2) Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11I1912015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Property #4 - Right hand nail clipping (HOME 8) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau ofCriminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/15 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Property #4 - Right hand nail clipping (HCME 8) - Continued Primary Information - Continued Property Type: Biological Sample Description: Right hand nail clipping (HCME 8) Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11l19l2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES PrOperty #5 - Pulled head hair (HCME 7) Primary Information PrOperty Class: Evidence Property Type: Biological Sample Description: Pulled head hair (HCME 7) Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11l19l2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Property #6 - Left hand nail clipping (HCME 5) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Biological Sample Description: Left hand nail clipping (HCME 5) Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 1111912015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 1111912015 14:40 Last Update Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11l23l2015 13:26 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor . Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26l2016 Apprehension) Earrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of4 On Thursday, November 19, 2015, SA Olson arrived at the Hennepin County Medical Examiner?s Of?ce and picked up six items of evidence described below. 1. Bullet Projectile metal fragment from left temporalis 2. Bullet Projectile from GSW right occipital 3. Blood Prep known DNA 4. Right hand nail clipping 5. Pulled head hair 6. hand nail clipping SA Olson delivered the aforementioned items to the MN BCA lab intake for further analysis (see attached lab analysis request and Hennepin County Medical Examiner evidence receipt). End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Laboratory Number SI 5? 14003 Agency caseNumb? TEL: 651-793-2900 2015?648 TTY: 651-242-6555 FAX: 651-793-2901 LABORATORY ANALYSIS REQUEST BCA St. Paul - . Henne In 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TELEPHONE: 651-793-1100 TYPE OF CASE: Attn: SA Mike Phill Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death Report Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Section Involved Firearms Nuclear DNA CIRCUMSTANCES AND PURPOSE OF ANALYSIS: DNA and FA PRINCIPALS: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Clark, Jamar Oneal Sworski, Jeffrey Steven Conner, Chad Michael ITEM DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE: Item Container Estimated Due Date 3/1 8/2016 3/18/2016 Comments Date Of Birth U) .4 5/3/1991 intact/3mg 00 00 Source Description Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #1 Packaging and Type One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as projectile(s) One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as projectile(s) Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #2 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a bloodstain blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 One manila enveIOpe containing evidence classified as known Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #5 head hair(s) One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 Page 1 of 2 Submission Receipt for SIS-14003 Submission 8 Lab Case Submitted By Received Bv g: A 11/19/2015 14:29:18 Olson Julie Domseif Submission Date and Time Page 2 of2 Hennepin County Medical Examiner 53!] enhances-anus, l-.-11nneapolis.Iu-Iinnesota 55415 i i Decedent: Clark, Jamar O'Neal ME Case 2015?6355 Investigating Life Source Agency: Comments: Reason: Release to Investigating Agency Description (3 Blood Prep for Investigating Agency Bullet/Proj ectileDescript1011:Metal fragment, left temporalis q; Left Hand Nail Clipping 5/ 9 Pulled Head Hair 7f g) Right Hand Nail Clipping Bullet/ProjectileDescription: Bullet from gunshot wound of head, right occipital Released To Name: Olson, Chris Release To (Agency): BCA Clmh?J?"?h?W 1. e?x" Signature Released By Name: Schuman, Amanda HCME Release Date/Time: 11/19/2015 01:33 PM 1/1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/16 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Primary Information Acquisition of Video from Minneapolis Public Housing 11/18/2015 00:00 11I18I2015 00:00 Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Description: Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved 12/01/2015 Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approvsd Date: Approved By: Synopsis - . On 11/18/2015 SA Henning met with Minneapolis Public Housing and obtained video footage. SA Henning acquired exhibit three containing video footage. Address #11- Occurred #1 - 1001 WASHINGTON AVE Primary Information Address: 1001 WASHINGTON AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Description: Minneapolis Public Housing Subject #1 - OTHER #1 - BUEGLER, HEIDI Primary Information Subject Name: BUEGLER, HEIDI Record Type: Person Bio: White, Female Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address BUSINESS LOCATION 1001 WASHINGTON AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Property #1 - three CDIDVD containing video provided by Minneapolis public housing I Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: three CDIDVD containing video provided by Minneapolis public housing Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 00:00 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/16 Report Date: 11/19/2015 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/19/2015 16:10 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12I0112015 14:29 ReportingiLEO I - 1 Date f, Supervisor - Date Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on (the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 On 11/18/2015 SA Henning met with Heidi Buegler with Minneapolis Public Housing at her of?ce. The of?ce is located at 1001 Washington Ave N. in Minneapolis, MN. Buegler provided SA Henning with three (acquisition of exhibit 2015-648/16. 1) said to contain video footage from a property located at 1710 Plymouth in the city of Minneapolis. Those discs were turned over to SA Phill at a later time. The change of custody form is attached to this report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension r" Erin?. .3, offense Number: 2015648116 Case Agent: Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) item Quantity Description 1 1 three CDIDVD containing video provided by Minneapolis public housing State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION [nearby certify that i have rec ived the above iisted property signature Date Received 1112012015 PhillfC?herles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of name Criminal Apprehension) owne?For owner Address 0- Henning, Doug (1361 I ItyIState Released By MR0 Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Telephone Veri?ed 8y dhenning 11/20/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminai Apprehension Page 1 of 1 Rik? Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 201 5-648/17 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Voluntary statement of Joseph Gipson at 1315 Lowry Ave. N. - on 11-19-15 . Reporting LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis - . . On 11-19-15 SA Homer and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with Joseph Pierre Gipson tthe North Regional Library of Hennepin County. Agents spoke with Gipson in a conference room where he provided a voluntary statement. The interview was audio recorded. By virtue of this report, exhibits and 17.2 were acquired. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1315 LOWRY AVE Primary Information Address: 1315 LOWRY AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Description: Hennepin County Library Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - GIPSON, Joseph Pierre Primary Information Subject Name: GIPSON, Joseph Pierre Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Photo: YES Addresses merits; Adm HOME ADDRESS 3243 LYNDALE AVE Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States HOME ADDRESS 6528 Carpenter, Chicago, Illinois 60621 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address CELLULAR PHONE Subjects Relationship Name B_i0 DOB GIRLFRIEND Steele, Kiesha Mona (Person) 28 yr. old, Black, Female Identifications mile Number State Countm As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Illinois NO LICENSE DRIVERS Minnesota 11/19/2015 NO LICENSE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 201 5-648/17 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications Ilium?her ?t_ate mtg. mm FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota N0 State ID Minnesota N0 Subject #3 - MENTION IN REPORT #1 - Gross, Darrell Lashorn Primary Information Subject Name: Gross, Darrell Lashorn Record Type: Person Bio: 48 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship ?Address :1 HOME ADDRESS 1615 PLYMOUTH AVE N., Minnespolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address . CELLULAR PHONE Identifications mm -.. ?Lat_e $.0me A?iDa?te mm C_0.nm1s.n_t DRIVERS - Minnesota 1111912015 NO LICENSE z, 4 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/17 Report Date: 11l20/2015 Subject #4 - MENTION IN REPORT #2 - Steele, Ki?esha Mona Primary Information Subject Name: Steele, Kiesha Mona Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3243 LYNDALE AVE Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States Telephones ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address? ?7 SUBSCRIBER Subjects Relationship Name ?ip BOYFRIEND GIPSON, Joseph Pierre (Person) 28 yr. old, Black, Male 03 Property #1 4,00 With) audio recorded ofgloseph Gipson Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Joseph Gipson Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11l19/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 11l19l201510:20 Preperty #2 - Map dravm by. Gipson (Not to scale) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Map drawn by Gipson (Not to scale) Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11l1 9/201 5 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 11l19/2015 10:20 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/17 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Officers LEO Vogel, Matt (Special Agent FBI) Record Status Infermatio'n Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: I-IORNER, Cody (1395 1 Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/20/2015 07:50 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/30/2015 17:03 Reporting LEO . - Date Supervisor - . - - Date HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of 2/26/2016 Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On 11-19?15 at approximately 1020 hours SA Homer and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with Joseph Pierre GipsoMat the North Regional Library of Hennepin County. SA Vogel previously spoke with Kiesha Mona Steele who made arrangements to bring Gipson to the library. Agents met with Gipson in a conference room where he agreed to provide a voluntary statement which was audio recorded. Gipson stated that he observed the shooting of Jamar Clark. Gipson said that he observed an of?cer put a handcuff on Clark?s left wrist and then take him down to the ground. After he was on the ground, Gipson described that the paramedic and two MPD of?cers (talk dark haired of?cer and Chinese of?cer) were around Clark. Gipson then heard a gunshot and observed that the tall dark haired of?cer had his gun out. Gipson stated that right after the gunshot he observed smoke from the gun and that blood ?went in the mist.? He explained that he was standing on his uncle?s (Darrell Lashorn Gross/q porch at the time of the incident, which he said was three to ?ve feet away. They were at his uncles residence for a gathering in which people was consuming alcohol. Gipson said that after the shooting and the second ambulance arrived, one of the handcuffs was removed. They remained on one wrist as he was put inside. He continued to state that the of?cer who ?red his weapon rode with Clark inside of the paramedic vehicle as it drove off. Gipson drew a map of the area for the night of the shooting which is attached to this report. During the interview the odor of alcohol was emanating off Gipson?s breath and person. Gross informed agents, after the interview, that Gipson had consumed alcohol and that he (Gipson) has a problem. See statement for further details. By virtue of this report, exhibits 2015-648/ 17.1 and 17.2 were acquired. 'u i . "uh?h. A - Ivth- . ?r ?h bydiff 5..l1n I : tuit- I 0.: .1 Clulvllu n: .. I?ll. e, 1.. illit. Eilli. 12:31: i; .la: .. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-19-2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Joseph Pierre Gipson (JG) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Cody Homer (CH) SA Matt Vogel FBI (MV) REVIEWED BY: CH BCA Case number 2015-648. Time is 10:20 hours on November 2015 at the Library in North Minneapolis. Ah, present is, is it Joe? JG Joseph. CH Okay Joseph. What?s your full name Joseph? JG Joseph Gipson. CH What?s your middle name Joe? JG Pierre. CH Is it JG Yep. CH Okay. And is the last name JG P. CH How do you spell your last name? JG Gipson. CH Oh, okay. Gipson. Okay. I?m sorry. And what?s your birthdate? Je? CH Yep. JG CH JG Um-hmm. CH ?Kay. And where do you currently live at? JG 3243 Lyndale Avenue North. CH ?Kay. And that's here in Minneapolis. JG Um-hmm. CH Okay. What?s the zipoode here? JG 5-5-4?1 -2. CH ?Kay. And is there a home phone or a cell phone. Pagel of 16 kay. Alright. Um, like Matt explained earlier just, just paint a picture of everything that you saw. Ah we weren?t there. Um, i don?t know anything about what really happened so What happened was this? And the other thing I, I forgot to mention earlier ah make sure that what you tell us is exactly what you saw, not what ya talk about afterword or what you saw on the news. I was just what, let you know everything that happened. ?Kay. (background noiseFirst off, we was in Kiki?s house. Her and her husband got into it. Okay. Wha-whats her husband's name? Al. Okay. They got into it, amongst each other. The female companion that he was with? Who, No. Jamar. Okay. Was trying ta break up the situation she ended up spraining her ankle. Who did? Came outside. Jamar. Okay. Girlfriend, the one that initially was the call was for. okay. Do you She sprung her ankle. Do you know her name? Ah, Pam something like that. Er, what do you call her? 1 the, this my first time meeting her. Okay. So what happened was she was trying ta break up a altercation between those two and sprained her ankle. He goes outside when they came ta get her in the ambulance. He walk up to the ambulance door looked in, ambulance man got out. Get the fuck away from the door. He move back with his hands up. PageZof 16 When you saw who, who are you (inaudible) too. Jamar, Jamar. Okay. He moved back with his hand up. They got out and they put their black gloves on. The first off, officer put the cuff around his hand and the other officer grabbed the other arm, they took him down. Okay. i think we, we need to go back and just lay some, some background here. So, the you said someone called for an ambulance. Let?s start with, start back there. I don?t know who call. Okay. But they came and she got in the ?Kay. was just going to check on her. And where, where was the ambulance. Right in the front of the building. Okay. Which Jamar?s sister stay at and Kiki they, and him and his sister they they right across the hall from each other. Okay. We all was just in there playing cards, eating. Chillin'. 80. Let, lets back up even before that. Where exactly is this? And where did this happen? Next door to my uncle at 1615 (inaudible). Okay. He (inaudible) town with the first townhome. Right there. ?Kay. The apartment building is right next door to him. That?s where we were. 80 we came outside, I was on my uncle porch. Um?hmm. He come out ta get some air, he went over there to the ambulance. it just, eh. How far is the ambulance from the porch? Like right there where them balloons was at. A few feet from where the balloons at from the tree. There's balloons by a tree? Yeah. Okay. it was, right there like a couple Okay. the tree. 80 in your estimation, how many feet is that from the porch where you were standing? Pag'e3 offs Three, two. Oh, so it's really close. Yeah, really close. That?s from like me to you Three feet. 80 even closer yet. Cause you and are probably about five feet. It's not five feet. Okay. It was three feet at three, three ta five. Okay. we?re not three ta five right now. Okay, okay. So, as he went ta the car. He looked in, the ambulance man jumped out told him to move back away from the car. They slapped the first cuff on him. His hands were behind his back. (inaudible) you, you skipped the officers showing up. No, when they showed up first okay right. So when he moved back, th-the ambulance was right there. The police pulled up. Okay. They put they black gloves on. They didn?t ask no questions, who he was, what did you do there. They ask for no lD. Nothing. They slapped the cuffs right on him, took him down. Which, wrist did they put the cuff on? His left wrist. His left wrist? Did ah, did you see handcuffs? Yes. Or, or did you see them like the normal like holding the hands? No. And He took the cuffs out. Was it in front or in back? I The first cuff went on, he was when they, when they swept him and took him down he was on his back. Okay. With the cuffs on him. They already had ?em on him. Okay. They was on his chest. Page4of16 Let, lets start with deta, detail by detail. The officers show up, get outta the car. Tell me I everything you can about where they are, what they look like, ah what they say, what they re doing. They didn?t say anything. They came straight out they car, put they gloves on. He went and talked to they to the ambulance. He said something to him and soon as they walk from him they straight took him down. Where, you said that they talked to the guy in the ambulance. Where did they talk to him? After they told him to move back away from the, the vehicle he moved back and when they pulled up. Jamar did? Yes. Okay. He moved back, the police man went and talked to the ambulance man. In, in a door or where was he talking to him. He was outside the car. Oh (inaudible). He got out, he told Jamar to get the fuck away from the ambulance. Okay. So he was already out the, at the ambulance. Okay. So, at that point. They talked and they went straight to take Jamar down. They put the first cuff on him and the ambulance man helped him take him down. He thought he was shot. Okay. So, ah eh describe when you?re calling the takedown, what what happened? They put the first cuff on him. As his hands was up, they took the first cuff and slapped it around his wrist. This hand was behind his back. They took the other one and he was like ya?ll. Cause they never asked him anything for no identification or anything. They swept him down, they hovered him. (inaudible). And that's when the shot went off. What do you mean they hovered him? They was on his chest. They took him down. So now they and they trying ta make it seem like it was a resist when he was already in the cuffs and swept him off his feet and ya'll had total control. Did, what color were the handcuffs? What, cause they?re different colors of handcuffs that?s why I?m asking, i mean you said you saw the handcuffs. Silver. They were silver. 80, they take him down to the ground. Describe how, how the situation is where people are posMoned? The (inaudible) was just coming he was over there chillin?. PageS of 16 Um-hmm. Everybody was outside. Okay. Yeah, but ah but what I mean, I mean Jamar and the officer how they're, how they?re positioned. You know is, is Jamar was laying. l, I (inaudible) I don't wanna put any words in your mouth (inaudible). Jamar had the cuffs on him laying on his back when he was shot. He was like this on his back with the cuffs. Okay. Cause they will, they all was hovering around him while he was on his back. Okay. And The shot went off. were the officers positioned while Jamar was on his back? One was on the right side, one was on the left. The EMS man was helping them in the front, it was like ah, a three cover. They cov, they they hovered over. And the one that was on the right side from where my uncle porch was, that's the one who shot him. Did you see the, did you see the officer shoot him? Yeah. Okay. Not initially, cause they had, they was hovered around. But i know the one on the right. But you didn?t see it, you heard it. No, I was looking but if, just say for Yep. lf um, if us three guys are hovering somebody you wouldn?t be able to initially see it. Um?hmm. But I know it was you. How did you know it was him? What? Well l'm (inaudible). He the only one that had his gun out. Okay. That?s what i was getting at. First when, when the shot went off we ran everybody ran up like you just shot him with the cuffs on his back. He upped his gun, move back eh, even the crowd across the street, the other one took this side and the other one took the other side. Move back. I saw the smoke from his gun and I saw the blood and the blood went in the mist. The one on the right shot him. Okay. The ambulance man even, weh he thought he was shot. When he got up he started checking himself. Oh, shit what was that, what was that. Exactly. Pages of 16 That's what the ambulance drivers or the Yeah. said. So they pulled off with her and left him right there. And another came and they picked him up and they threw him in the ambulance. And they pulled off with him too. Okay. Well you?ve described, you?ve described one medic. Right? is, is was that one of the people that left in the first ambulance, with the female? They, yeah they left. They left. Okay. So how many, how many people were associated with the ambulance? Two. Okay. One was in there attending her sprained ankle and the other one jumped 5Kay. talk to the police when they pulled up. Okay. But initially when he got out, he got belligerent with Jamar. Get the fuck away from this door. Okay. He was like okay, fine. Move back, when they pulled up they put they gloves on, they walked up on him. Talk, they talk to them first. Then they act like they was going to the ambulance and they straight grabbed him and took him down. So when you, you describe that you, you heard the shot you saw the one officer with the gun. Um, did you see and l?m just trying ta really paint a picture here and be descriptive as possible so. Um, I'm not trying ta you know belittle anything here um, but did you see him point, or ah, let me back the train up. As you heard the gun shot go off is that when you saw the gun after the fact as he was getting up or did you see the Yes when he was getting up. When he?s getting up. So I know the one, the one on the right shot him. Okay. (inaudible). His gun was out first. When you saw on the right, you're talking about as you're look out towards the street, right? So you?re right. Yeah, we was just talking. He just walked off from me, talking to me. And went to the ambulance. i saw, the the one on the right shot him. Okay. Ah, can you describe the officers, how they were dressed, what they look like you know not, not all the officers wear the same, they wear a uniform but it doesn?t always look the same. It's all the same. Were they, they were both dressed the same. Page70f 16 Yeah. Okay. White uniform. Kinda chilly out. Blackjackets. Okay. So they both had a, a white uniform and blackjackets. Yeah. Okay. Can you do me a favor as your, just wanna really make sure i know what you're talking about can you draw a picture of where the porch was, where the paramedic rig was, the squad car, and then where the officers, and where Jamar was. (background noiseOkay. This is my uncles porch over here. Okay. You can, you can literally like draw it out if you want if you want. You can put like a square or something like that. Okay. I say it like that. Okay. Jamar was over here by the ambulance. Okay. Now, this is Is this the ambulance right there? Yeah. Okay. So the building is right here. ?Kay. My uncle house is here. ?Kay. 80 it was directly in front of the building. Okay. When they pulled up Jamar was right here on the side walk. Okay. Where was, can you draw on there where he was standing at? Make it precisely. That's fine just. Little bit. Okay. Right there. And where is the front of the ambulance on that square? Which, which side is the front and which side is the back? This is the back, this directly in front of the building. PageB of 16 Okay. This is my uncle porch. This is the building. Okay. This where the ambulance was and this is where they took him down there. Okay. So the back of the ambulance is right there? Yeah. Okay. Can you just put a little right there on that print there so that was I know it's the back. Okay. So, when they got out Jamar back, back off the car. Um-hmm. Right here, way (inaudible) at it. He, he back back, the police car pulled up. Right in the back. Flight here. Okay. They got out talked to the EMS man, they walked straight over to Jamar and took him down. Okay. The first cop when they initially you know when they arrest you, they slap the first cuff on they wrap it around your wrist like a bracelet. That one was on already. The other man, the other police officer grabbed it, the other arm and put the other one on. So when he starts saying fuck you, they swept him off his feet from the back that's what made him fall on his back with the cuffs. Um-hmm. They hurled around him, like he was like no he?s not doing nothing, hejust saying fuck you. Cause initially you didn't ask for no identification. That could have been her brother, her uncle, you didn't know who this was. And initially he never touch the girl. We was right there when she sprung her ankle. Ah, who so whe~where did she sprain her ankle, where, where was she. We was at Kiki's house. At Kiki?s house? Yes. Um. In the hallway. Who else was there? My wife was there. Uh-huh. My uncle had would a made a run, he wasn?t there yet. Okay. Until after the fact when we came out when the situation was diffused. Okay. So, she went upstairs with her daughter. He daughter stays on the second floor. Um-hmm. Page 9 of 16 came outside. He meaning? Jamar. Jamar came outside. As we?re just, taking a cigarette break, you know. Getting some air, the ambulance pulled up and now they coming to get her. So he was like what?s wrong. Um-hmm. He just walked to the car. Okay. Um, had it it, its been described as a party or gathering or get together. Yeah. Ah, had and ya know, don?t read any anything into this question. It?s a question that has to be asked. Um-hmm. Ah, had people been drinking? Not yet. Everybody just arrived. It was, it just started. We was eating at the time. Okay. When she sprained her ankle. Yeah. And then so after a little, after a little while people had a couple drinks or ah, one drink or ho- how much, how much did you have during, I just got there. you got there, between when you got there and when ah Jamar gets shot? My wife get off at eleven. She had make it round to the area to pick me up around twelve. Forty-five minutes we just got there. Okay. Did you right, so between when you got there and when the shooting happened ah how much, how much did you have? i had ah, like two beers. Okay. Beers? Yeah, two beers. Um, do you know if Jamar had been drinking? Yeah. Do you know what, what he was drinking or how much? Beers. Jamarjust got threw eating his plate. Okay. Before we came outside. He had a big plate, he ate. He came outside and if this is your girl like why eh, if they companions, what wrong with him being the, come ta the door and check on his, his girl. Right. If they?re companions. Right. PagetO of16 What was wrong with that? We?re not saying that there was something wrong with that. We're just asking questions. That?s all theres (inaudible). I know but l?m saying like the way he jumped out like get the fuck away from the door. This is his companion. He don?t have that right. Yeah. Yeah, i get it. Was there and once again don?t read into the question, we just have to ask to have all the factsany drugs prior to this? No. Did Jamar do any drugs prior to this? No. Were, did anybody do any drugs prior to this? No. No. Okay. So it was just alcohol. You're nodding your head yes. Yeah. Okay. - Yes. Okay. When, when you described that the handcuffs going on ta the officers and I?m just I?m really trying to pin this down. Um, you said you say the one, you called it a bracelet go round the left wrist. Yeah, once they hit it around it. Gone slap around like a bracelet. Yep. Did you see, did you just see the motion of the arms going behind his back or did you actually see the handcuffs going (inaudible). I saw the first handcuff go on. The other one grabbed him and that one went on too. You sa, you physically Yes. your own Yes. handcuff go on. Yes. Okay. Alright. I, wanna go back to ah the words that were spoken um, by Jamar and the medic and police officers but i, can you recall exec, I, i know it tough. it?s been a few days and there, there a (inaudible). All he was saying was fuck ya'll. Did you hear the officers say anything? No. Okay. Um, did they ah, did they give any any orders or commands? They just walked Page11of16 They, saying. the orders that that was given was when the ambulance told him to get the fuck away from the car and he did exactly that. Ok, so you heard the medic say something to him. Yeah, he got out the car, get the fuck away from the ambulance. Move away from the window. And he did exactly that. So he stood on the sidewalk while they were conducting they business. Then the police came. They put the gloves on went and talked to the ambulance man and they went straight took Jamar down. Okay. Ah, did the officers get when they got outta the car did they have anything in their hands or just the gloves that they put on? That's it. Okay. That's it. Did you hear anything ah being said after the fact, after the shot happened by the officers? No. Uh, besides them calling for backup. Okay, you said they ah, the medic kinda checked himself, di-did any, what was there any shouting that you could hear? Yeah, the he thought he said what the fuck was that? Okay. While he checking himself. What the fuck was that. Cause he didn't even expect that neither. Um-hmm. Nobody did. What did, what did the other ah officer do after the sh, ah the shot was fired? He pointed his gun towards the (inaudible) which was across the street. Okay. So Because everybody was trying You side. I?m sorry. I'm, I'm not trying ta cut you off but you had described that Jamar was on the ground. Um-hmm. And that the officers were down on the ground above him. Right? Um?hmm. From, so the shot is fired. How did, how did the officers get up? Can you describe that movement? After the shot went off. He started looking but he saw the crowd getting a little bit closer. Like because it was unexpected. Page120f16 Okay. Were the officers on their fee the whole time? No. Were they on a knee, where they on the ground? They were on the, they was on they knee. When the shot went off they got up. One officer took one side and the other took the other. Right, that's what i was getting at. The side that we was on, the one who shot him pointed his towards my uncle house. Move back. Theyjust straight up their guns. Everybody from that, the (inaudible) getting out. Like 12:45. Something like that, they came outside. They pushed all of them back. Um?hmm. After they got off the ground and they left him right there. He told the ambulance to leave, they left with her in the ambulance and another one pulled but they shut her down. So-soon as they shot him, he told him to leave. He skeeted off then another ambulance pulled up. They had both of they coff him back up and they both had a side a piece. With they guns out. Then another ambulance pulled up. Then they turned Jamar over uncuffed him, picked him up and put him in the ambulance and took right off. When is somebody shot that?s inresponsive and the just pick him up and move him. What they do with the handcuffs? When they took them off. One, one was on his wrist. They left it, the one on his wrist. Yeah. And then and that?s when the ambulance took him off or I?m sorry drove off. Yeah. Okay. And one of the officers road with him. Okay. (background noisetheyjust, so theyjust took off the one handcuff put him the back of the ambulance and drove off. No, they they released the handcuffs. Yep. One of ?em and laid him out. Okay. Like, you didn?t have both of ?em on it was like we was trying ta get the other one on. No you just turn him over and took that cuff off and laid him back flat. When they turn, they turned him sideways. When they released the cuff his body just lay flatthe ambulance too? Yeah. Page13 of16 Okay. They put him in ambulance. And one of the officers were with him. And he still had the one handcuff on him? Yeah. Okay. Alright. I, I can?t say what happened when they got in there. Yep. But he still had a cuff on him. Okay. As they're putting him in the ambulance. And one of the, you said one of the officers rode in the ambulance. Um?hmm. D, can could you tell which, which one? The one who shot him. (inaudible) okay to leave and he got in with them. One officer stayed because backup was coming. When backup got there, he was immediate ready. He got in the car, they pulled off with Jamar. Okay. Are you, are you sure or eh ya know it, be eh, I just wanna be clear. If you?re, if you're sure or it probably was or might have been which officer. Are you a hundred percent? Are you a hundred percent sure it was the officer that shot him? Yeah, it was him. Okay. Can you describe him? What does he look like? He was just tall they, 1 mean they all the same. I mean i can't cause I'm not, i don't physically know him or like one face like I Um-hmm. Well I mean was he fall, He was tall. skinny. Tall. Tall? Okay. Yeah. Dark hair, light hair. Dark hair. Okay. And there was a Chinese officer with him. That was his (inaudible) the Chinese officer. So the only two officers that you saw was the tall dark haired and then the Asian guy. That?s the one i was watching. Page?l4 of16 Yep. When it all happened, my eyes was on him. Cause he did it. Whi-which one. The tall one. one. On the right side. And the Asian He wasn?t that physical. He was physical as he was. Okay. He was physical. Which officer was the one that put the handcuffs on initially? The tall one or the Asian one. Yeah. He, he, he put the, the handcuff of. The Asian dude was the right. Then it was like at the (inaudible) went down and they got extra help from the ambulance, it was like they switched sides. And they went down they both was hovering him. They already had the knee on him. The cuffs was on him. it was just all about what he was saying. He never did nothing and they shot him, (inaudible) in my face. Its, it?s fucking me up right now. Excuse my French. That?s okay. So when you, when you saw the shot, how far were you from that? Is that the three feet that you were describing earlier? Yeah, I was on my uncle porch. Okay. And it happened right there. Can you do me a favor, on this things that you wrote, can you write down uncles Right. or uncles porch, police car, and then ambulance where ya, where you wrote down. (background noiseAnd you, you said that was a police car, right? Um-hmm. Can you write police car? And then just so I don?t forget who, who drew this can you just put your na, can you put your name somewhere on there? And todays date which it's the November Um I, I, I think that?s all the questions we have for you right now as things move forward and as we've learned more information, there might be other things that we need to come back and clarify with Um-hmm. see if you know anything else. That you just didn?t think to tell us. Ah, is there anything that we haven?t asked Page15of16 Um?um. you think we should know? Anything we missed. Anything we forgot to ask. Yeah, like I don?t understand like what was the call for the thing my thing is this, it had nothing to do with them. It was a domestic call it was about there, Kiki and her husband?s argument. Had nothing to do with Jamar or his girl. She end up hurting herself, trying ta break up a confrontation between them. So I don?t see why they even came at him like that, like he did something wrong. Okay. Was there any facts that we missed? Anything that we forgot to ask you as your painting a picture for us? Um-um. Well I would like to say if if you know anybody else that um, ya know saw it or has video or anything like that, we really encourage you to talk to them and have them come forward to us. Um-hmm. Cause we wanna be able to talk to them and, and ah you know talk to everybody that saw er, saw it. Everybody that has video. So that you know we have all the facts and we?re not missing anything. Yeah. 80. I got some more people that, that?s saying it but I have to talk to them. Okay. And see because like um, like I'm tore up about that. I understand. (inaudible) down. Do you all have my business cards? Um?hmm. I take one. Okay. There you go. You can talk to my wife (inaudible). Okay. Okay. This concludes the statement taken, time is 10:47 hours on November 2015. END OF RECORDING Horner/2015-648-A01 Page160f16 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/18 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary?lnformatiOH Description: Voluntary statement of Darrell Gross at 1315 Lowry Ave. N. - on 11-19-15 Reporting LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1113012015 Approved By: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1315 LOWRY AVE Primary Information Address: 1315 LOWRY AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Description: Hennepin County Library SubjeCt?tt-?I - WITNESS-M31 Gross; Darrell Lashorn Primary Information Subject Name: Gross, Darrell Lashorn Record Type: Person Bio: 48 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1615 PLYMOUTH AVE N., Minnespolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications @1199 Number As_Of_Date 991m DRIVERS Minnesota 1111912015 NO LICENSE Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 (Clark, Jamar Oneal .1 Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 0510311 991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (13851MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/18 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued GIPSON, Joseph Pierre (Person) 28 yr. old, Black, Male Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number State Country As Of Date Fictitious FBI 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Subject VIN REPORT #1 Steele, Kiesha Mona Primary Information Subject Name: Steele, Kiesha Mona Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3243 LYNDALE AVE Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship NumberlE?Address SUBSCRIBER Subjects Relationship N_an_? B_io DOB BOYFRIEND Prbperty #1 with audio recorded veluntary statement of Darrell Gross - Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Darrell Gross Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/23/2015 Quantity: 1 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/18 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Property #1 - CD with addio'rec'orded voluntarystatem'ent of'Darrell Gross - Continued Primary Information - Continued Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 1111912015 10:53 Property #2 -. Map drawn by Gross (Net to scaie) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Map drawn by Gross (Not to scale) Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 1111912015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 1111912015 10:53 Officers LEO Vogel, Matt (Special Agent! FBI) Record Status Information; fC ?nal Record Origination Operator: HORNER, Cody (1395/Fmanc1al Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau 0 nm Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/2012015 07:51 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Last Update Operator. Apprehension) Last Update Date: 1113012015 17:05 Repbrting LEO . x- Date? . 7 Supervisor . 7 . - Date . HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 1 Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Investigation Minnesota Bureau of 2126/2016 Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On 11-19-15 at approximately 1053 hours SA Homer and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with Darrell Lashorn Grossl? at the North Regional Library of Hennepin County. SA Vo gel previously spoke with Kiesha Mona Steele- who made arrangements to bring Gross to the library. Agents met with Gross in a conference room where he agreed to provide a voluntary statement which was audio recorded. Gross stated that he observed the shooting incident of Jamar Clark and estimated that he was approximately 30-40 feet away. He described that an ambulance arrived and he (Gross) thought it was for Clark because his face was ?messed up.? Shortly after a female got into the ambulance and Clark remained outside. Clark went to the back of the ambulance and was looking through the Window. A paramedic told him to get back. Clark walked over to the curb and stood there. Shortly after, MPD arrived on scene. Upon MPD arriving, the white of?cer approached Clark and put his hands behind his back. The of?cer then took Clark to the ground. Gross never observed handcuffs. Clark started using profanity at the officers. Gross then heard a gunshot and said that he observed ?blood and smoke.? Gross was not able to see which of?cer ?red the shot. Gross saw something hanging off Clark?s arm as he was being placed into the ambulance, but could not tell what it was. He also stated that no of?cers got into vehicle, only paramedics. Gross drew a map of the area for the night of the shooting which is attached to this report. See statement for further details. By virtue of this report, exhibits 2015-648/ 18.1 and 18.2 were acquired. o4"! 9 ?/xcz KM [m MW . . .. 19k. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-19-2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Derrel Lashorn Gross (DG) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Cody Homer (CH) SA Matt Vogel FBI (MV) REVIEWED BY: CH BCA case number 2015-648. Time is 10:53 hours on November 2015. Present at the library in North Minneapolis is Cody Homer of the BOA and Matt Vogel of FBI along with Derrel. Derrel can you state your full name for the record. DC My full name is CH Or Derrel I'm sorry. DG Derrel Gross. CH What's your middle name D?Derrel? DG Lashorn. CH How do you spell that? DO . CH ?Kay. And how do you spell your last name? DG Gross. CH Okay. And what?s your birthdate? De? CH Yep. De- CH Okay. And where do you currently live at? DG I live at CH Yep. DG Avenue North. Minneapolis, Minnesota CH 5?5-4?1-1 DG Um?hmm. CH Okay. And do you have a cell phone? DG Yes. CH What's your cell phone? we CH Yep. Pagel of 19 Yeah. Like l'd explained before um, we just want to get a recollection of, of everything that you saw, we don?t want any speculation. We just want you to paint a picture of exactly what you saw, what you heard, you know what you felt, things like that. Just, like for instance we weren't there. 80. And start from the very beginning and kinda work your way through and what we'll do is what well, we?ll have you explain what you saw and we'll go back and ask some questions along the way to try to clarify some things. Okay. Okay. And, and try ta, try to use names instead of saying he or she. Okay. Alright. Well the night started off like ?cuz I wind up cookin' some chicken for Nikila Landers. And it was for her party that her husband was givin?. So I went to the, i had cooked the chicken. Took the chicken over there to her house for the party. Okay. That?s where I met Jamary Clark. Okay. And he was there at the party. They all was playin? cards when I came. Okay. Um, when I got there I couldn't stay long because I had to take my daughter to (inaudible) with her boyfriend. So I had left for a couple hours. Well i left for about an hour and a half. Then when I came back, you know, I came back to my house. Everybody was outside. 80 i met up with 'em on my front porch at 1615 Plymouth Avenue. Um, 1615 Plymouth Avenue North and then i met up with my nephew Rock um, Joseph Gibson, Nik urn, Nikila Landers, Kiesha Steele, um, who else? And um, my cousin John um, John (inaudible) Townsend. We set up in there, we was just messin? around, you know, just standin' out there talkin' and everything. And Jamary he comes outside cryin'. And they was tellin? me the story what was goin' on with that but uh, urn, I'm, that?s just what they was sayin?. So i leave that one out. But he was out there cryin?, and I told Nakila Landers to go up there and talk to ?lm. Because he?s out there crying. And the next thing we know they bring the, the ambulance ca?, showed up, and we were wonderin? was it for him because his face was messed up from where his girlfriend, her name is RaeAnn, I don?t know her last name. And she had pushed his, supposed to pushed his face up against the urn, door, the door thing right here and it swolled up. it was, his (inaudible) his face was already messed up. When you say he, who?re you referring to. Um, Jamary, Clark. Okay. His face, she had pushed his face into the, the (inaudible) swolled his face up. But he was out there cryin? because, Jamary was out there crying because his sister put him out. And he was upset about RaeAnn. So when he set up in there and the ambulance came up bringin? RaeAnn out, he went up there and was tryin? to talk to her while they was puttin' her, while the the paramedics was puttin? her into the ambulance. So then, Jamary was like, ljust tryin? to talk to you, he was saying, um, I'm just tryin' to talk to you and the paramedics was like well we?re tryin? to get her outta here. He was like, fuck ya all, and then the next thing you know they put her in, they got in the ambulance with her. That was it. So he went to the back of the, Jamary went Clark went to the back of the ambulance. He stood Page 2 of 19 the back of the ambulance and looked, was starin' in the window. The EMS guy in the truck pulled up, said step back. Then, can I stand up? Oh yeah, absolutely. He told him to step back. Jamary Clark stepped back, got on the curb. When he got on the curb nothin? else was said. Next thing I know, Minneapolis Police showed up. So when Minneapolis Police shows up, they talk to the EMS. He said somethin? to ?em real quick. The two officers put their gloves on, after they talked to him, or whatever he said to ?em walked towards him, Jamary Clark put his hands up. One officer went behind 'im, put a hand here, hand here, he was, he was, he wasn?t fightin?, he, he, he was not resistin? at all. And the next thing I seen was one of the officers, think it was the white officer, set up and then pushed him, slipped him down, or pushed him down on the ground. He was on the ground. Okay? ?Cuz everything went so fast and, so he was, he was on the ground. He was restrained to me. ?Cuz i never know no one not to be restrained if you got two people on 'im. 80 then the next thing I know, i have one person on top of him, I don?t know which one it was. One person on top of 'im, and then I see, I hear, pow, blood and smoke. And that?s the only thing I?m seein?. I, I constantly all day all night from Jamary Clark?s head. It?s, it?s, it?s the blood and smoke constantly poppin? up. ?Cuz it's right in front of my doorstep. Because we were standin' on my porch um, I was right here, my nephew Joseph Gibson was right here on the side of me, on my left, left side. And we look. I couldn?t believe it. See the gun and smoke, pow. Pow. The blood, smoke, that was it for me. The people was comin' out of the club across the street, and um, some of ?em was watchin? it and then when they heard the same thing, seen the same thing, they was about to rush. One officer pointed towards them, and we (inaudible) my nephew Joseph Gibson was, was like for real and we stepped that way, the other officer pointed the gun our way, so you know, they had to protect theirself. I understood that part. Because there was just them and the EMT, I mean the EMS out there. So and there?s a lotta crowd, it was a whole crowd. And they held ?em off there and they held them off my way. So after that, it was like Jamary?s just layin? there, no movement, nothing, body still. And it was, it was just so messed up because you knew he was gone. And they tryin? to say he was alive (inaudible) but he wasn?t. Because I know when they take a body. ?Cuz they came to get the body real quick. The two officers, they disappeared, like that, nobody even seen them leave. And when they came and got Jamary Clark?s body, it was they hurried up, they had one guy come to check him out. And he still wasn?t movin?. And this is all I'm lookin? at. The body?s not movin?. He?s not movin?. No movement from nothin?. And they picked him up. see somethin? dangling from his arm. I don?t know if it's handcuffs or what. Um, and they put him in the ambulance and normally when, if a person?s still alive, the ambulance leaves with the sirens goin?. No. They just drove off. No sirens, no nothin?. And when the other officers showed up, um, when the other Minneapolis Police Officer showed up, um, they walkin? around. I thought when you have a crime scene, you wasn?t supposed to walk around on the crime scene, or by the crime scene, or nothin?. So the, the investigator's came. They all over in that area. So it?s, in, it, it, it was just messed up to me. I, I, ljust couldn?t understand what (inaudible) goin? on. Okay. Well (inaudible) gonna go back to the beginning. And we?re gonna kinda walk our way through it. Um-hm. And kind of uh, you know, we?ll ask some questions along the way, things of that nature. Yessir. So, okay. Starting at the very beginning, you said that you were cookin? some chicken for this party. Um-hm. Page3 of19 Okay. Um, were you, when you were cookin? for the, the chicken for your party, was that in your house, or your (inaudible). My house. Okay. And what?s your residence again? 1615 Plymouth Avenue North. Okay. And then who?s party was it that you were cookln? it for? Nikila Landers. ls that, is she also known by Kiki? Yeah, that?s Kiki. That's Kiki. That's Kiki. Okay. Okay. Sounds good. So at what time did you go over to Kiki?s house initially? Um, maybe 10:30 or 11. Around 10, about 10, had to be about 10, 10:15. And was gone. 1 had left. Take my kids to Brunswick. It had to be around ?bout that time. And you came back from Brunswick around 10, 10:15 right around there. came back from Brunswick, about 11, 11, 11:20, 11:30. Okay. So you originally went there about 10 o?clock, left, came back around 11. Um-hm. I Right around there, okay. And the (inaudible) about it is now this is how I know. Estimate around the time that the incident Um?hm. because at the, the, the club across the street, it closes at um, they push people out at 12:45. Okay. That?s why I know it was a big crowd. Okay. At 12:45 they, they push people out. I been livin? there long enough, every, I know their routine. 12:45, I sit out there sometimes just to sit up in here. Wicked, trust me. (laughing) (inaudible) I?m a single dad. So yeah I know. But um. I hear ya. (laughs) 12:45?s when they start pushin? people out. So that?s when everything, everybody was comin? out. That?s how I know exactly around the estimate Okay. what was goin?, what time it happened. 80 it?s safe to say you were at this party for about an hour, hour and a half before this happened? Somewhere right in there? Page4of19 wasn?t even at the party. I, l, (inaudible). Yeah. I didn't stay that long, I stayed for about 10 or 15 minutes. Oh, that?s it, okay. Alright um. You know I brought the chicken, showed up in there, wish a happy birthday, took a couple pictures. Okay. But then I had to take my daughter. Okay. You know I never disappoint my daughter. No, i understand. And then when you came back you didn't go back to the party, you went, you were at your house? ?lt was at my house. Oh. Okay. I'm with ya, that?s where I was misunderstood ya. Okay. So you?re at your house, um, were you guys drinking at your house at all? No. No? No drinking (inaudible). I wasn't drinking. Okay. Wa?, how many people were at your house? Um. Or who was at your house? Okay um, Nikila was at my house, Kiki, she was at my house. Jose Gibson was at my house. Um Kie eele was at my house. Um, my daughter,bum, her friend? he was there. Those two was upstairs watchin? a movie. Um, my cousin John (inaudible) ownsend, he came later. A little bit later. (inaudible) just hangrn? outside by the door. Um?hm. Um, at my house, they did have a little alcohol. Okay. But it was like a shot. That's fine. And, 1 kn-, I know. But you know, it was like a shot. Yeah. But see don?t, I don?t drink like that. I?m not a, because like I said, I?m a single dad. Yeah. I have to take care of my daughter. Um?hm. And I (inaudible) much you know, that?s just me and her. PageS of 19 Yup. So I?m always with her. And then, I don't drink and drive. I don?t do stuff like that. Um-hm. So that?s what happened. I?m not tryin? to paint a negative picture. I just have to get all the facts. Right, right, that?s no problem. Okay. Was anybody using any drugs? No. No? No. ?Cuz I have, my, my house is a drug free zone. Okay. I, have, like I said I have a 15 year old daughter, and anybody who?s doin? anything wasn?t doin' it around it around me or my daughter ?cuz they know that?s, I don?t do that. Okay. So then let?s, let?s walk into as the gathering at your house kinda progresses and we kinda get to where the ambulance was there. Um-hm. Um, who called the pol-, or who called the ambulance? That I do not know. And I don't have no idea what was, what they, what they came for. Until we seen them bring RaeAnn out. Okay. You say they. Who, who are they? Um, Nikila, um, Joseph, um, to my knowledge, Nikila, Joseph. Who did you see bring them out? Uh, who, bring, bring RaeAnn. RaeAnn out? Um-hm. The paramedics. Oh, so did they come to the house and bring her out? ?Cuz she wasn?t at my house. Okay. Okay. The way our, the way that um, (inaudible) is Um-hm. have a two bedroom townhome. Okay. to apartment building. Okay. Okay. 80 Ni-, um, Nikila Landers birthday party, Kiki, her birthday party was at her house. Page 6 of 19 Um-hm. On the first floor. Um?hm. In um, the apartment building. Okay. The apartment part. When you come out their door, of the building, my townhome is connected directly at it. - Okay. Right, right, directly to it. Okay. So we just meet up on my porch. That's where we always meet and just sit and talk (inaudible). (inaudible) And wait ?til the Elk?s let out and see how drunk people (inaudible). Uaughs) That?s, just what we do you know. Yup. Just, I don?t have too much adult time. Um-hm. Because l?m always with my daughter so. Um-hm. That?s what, that?s happens. So when you came out to the patio then, was she, was the, she already in the paramedic rig or was she on her way walking to the paramedic rig? Who, uh FtaeAnn? Um-hm. RaeAnn was bein?, she, they brought her out of the, out of the building. Um-hm. In a, like a chair?like thing. Okay. And put her into the ambulance. Did you see that? Yes. Okay. And where were you when you saw that? Sittin? on my front porch. Okay. Right by the doorway. Page7of19 Okay. And what happened after that point, after they put her in the, in the paramedic rig? Okay, after that point, what had happened was that's when Ja-, Jamary Um?hm. I told you. Um-hm. He seen ?em comin' up, he tried to say somethin? to her. You know. Yup. He wanted to say somethin? to her. The paramedic says somethin? to him. He said fuck you. That?s all he said. He didn't, he wasn?t bein? rude with them or nothing. They put her in. He tried, kept tryin? to talk to her. At which side of the paramedic rig was he tryin' to talk to her? Um. Was it the side or the back? It was in the back, at the rear, the rear of the truck. Okay. When they was puttin? her in. Okay. And um, he was, if you was facin? the truck, it would be the right window where, once they put her in, is where he was standing looking in. Still tryin? to, yell at her, you know, i wanna talk. Um-hm. And um, but um, afterthat like i told you, the urn, EMS he came. He said somethin' to him, he stepped back and set up on the curb. Okay. Then that?s when the two officers came. When you say he, you?re referring to Jamar. Jamary Clark. Okay. And that's when the two officers show up, okay. Walk us through, i know you told us before, but walk us through Okay. you saw once the officers were there. Once the officers was there, they said somethin? to the EMS guy. Even, even more detailed than that. They get out of the car. They, okay they get, they got out the Um?hm. walk straight towards the EMS guy. Would it help to draw us a picture of like where everything's located? Yeah. Page8 of19 Okay. Draw like a square where the paramedic rig Okay (inaudible). square where the squad car was. l?m gonna do, just like this. Okay. This is the street. Okay. Where's your patio? Okay. My porch is (inaudible) um, side, that?s the grass, sidewalk, this way here, this is the arch to the building, here, then a little brick wall, mailboxes, stones, um, my porch is right here. Okay. Can you write it (inaudible) porch, right next to it or something? Um-hm. Okay. And let?s see. This is the grass. Okay. Uh, the tree is about right here in front of my porch. That's where the tree is. Urn, the ambulance is right here. Okay, and the EMS guy parked right here. Was it like a second EMS vehicle that pulled up? Uh?huh. Well no, the, the ambulance? Yup. Okay, that was the ambulance there (inaudible) there's an EMS guy, it was a white truck. Okay. The gentleman was in the white truck. Okay. Alright. Um. Where was the police car when that pulled up? Police car, pulled right here. Next to the EMS truck. Can you write police in there? Okay. And then what happened as they pulled up? Okay. The officers got out the car, they came here, the EMS guy was standin' 'bout right here. Okay. The officers walked to about right here. And Jamar Clark was Can you put an where he was? right here. Okay. And my doorway right here, I was right here with the on the (inaudible) circle. (laughs) (inaudible) Okay. Okay. My nephew, Joseph Gibson, was right here. Page 9 of 19 Okay. Alright. And he?s the one we just talked to? Yes. Okay. Alright? And everyone else was right here in the doorway right here. Okay. Urn, Nikila Lenders, and Kiesha Steele. My apoloiges for interrupting. How far distance-wise do you think it is from where you were standing at your patio, to where Jamar Clark and officers were? Or like in relation to this room. How, was it further than like from you to the wall or was it like from here over to the glass wall there. Okay. From this doorway to urn, ?bout where the (inaudible) is in that room. Which one? (inaudible) (inaudible) The urn, one in the doorway right there. Okay. The one that?s turned towards us? Yup. Yup. Right there in the doonNay. Okay. So what do you say that?s about 50 feet you?d say? Um. Maybe more than that, or less than that? You mean (inaudible) (inaudible) 1, 2, 3, 4. if you gentleman wanna come to my house, you can measure it from my door to there. Yeah. Well we?re, we?re just tryin? Yeah. on (inaudible). Tryin? to guesstimate, yeah, yeah. And so for the record, it appears that what you're showin? us is probably about 30 to 40 feet? Yeah. ?Bout that. Would you agree with that? 30, 40 feet yeah. Okay. That?s fair. So (inaudible) it?s not that far. Okay. PagetO of19 ?Cuz right here is just a little landing here. Sure. And then (inaudible) the sidewalk here. Okay. Sounds good. So okay continue on. So Jamary was there on the, grass. was right Yup. the grass. So what happened then? Then the next thing you know, the officers after they, the, the EMS guy said somethin? to the two officers. They come towards Jamary, and he puts his hands up. Okay. Alright? One went behind him, and one was in front of him. Now describe what the officers looked like. Um. The white guy was in front of ?em. Okay. And what is does he, is he tell, is he short? (inaudible) Skinny, fat? (inaudible) lighter. Both of ?em was, both of ?em was medium Okay. was, not that big of a build. Okay. You gotta remember l?m a fat guy so. (inaudible) (laughs) Okay. Um, he, they (inaudible) one of ?em 3 baldheaded. The one has big ears. Okay. That's (inaudible). Okay. You know. Um, with the big ears, he was a white guy. Now is the other guy a different ethnicity ?cuz you keep sayin? white guy. Yes. Okay. He, he, to me he look kinda Asian, or Chinese or somethin? like that. Okay. So there?s one Chinese guy and there?s one white guy. Page110f19 Right. 80 the white guy walks No. No? No. I don?t know which, it looked like the white guy, it looked to me like the white guy was the one (inaudible) down. Okay. Alright? 80. Well you said that he has hands up like this. He had his hands up like this. And then what happened? One officer (inaudible) behind. Okay. Do you remember which one it was? i wasn?t even payin? attention. I was just watchin? ?em, after I seen him put his hands ?Kay. watchin? what they gonna do with his hands Yup. they put his hands like this, and did his hands like ?Kay. wasn?t lookin? at the officer?s face, I was just lookin' at, okay, what're they gonna do to ?em and then the next thing I know they slam 'em. Did you, did you see ?em just put the hands behind the back or did you see ?em handouff ?em, like what did you 3-, what did you see? Truthfully if it were me No speculations, what?d you see? l?m not what i seen is just them puttin? his hands behind the back. I can?t say Okay. that, that's why you never heard me say anything about cuffs. Okay. So, my whole thing is that I know his hands were behind his back. Okay. Fair enough. And they did have 'em behind his back. Okay. I did know, I do know that for a fact. Okay. Alright, um, that's why you never heard me say anything about any cuffs. Yup. Page12of19 The only thing I, only time you heard me say somethin' about cuffs is when they was takin' the body away. And there was something hangin' from his arm. Um-hm. ?Cuz I know good darn well that wasn?t his jacket. Yup. Okay. So his hands were behind his back. Yup. You see them sweep him down. Right. What happens at that point? Uh, afterthey swept him down, he was like fuck you, you know fuck you. He did say that couple of times but who, who, who would say, who wouldn't say that you know. Did you hear the cops say anything to him? No I didn't hear the cops say anything. Okay. No. And was he shouting? (inaudible) Clark shouting? Mr. Clark? Mr. Clark he said fuck you a coupla times and yeah he did shout that out. Okay. But then after that, everything went so quick, was like pow, blood, smoke. Describe how, how people were positioned on the ground. You say they Okay. officer took him, took. It was one, okay I?m gonna tell you it was one officer that I don?t know if it was the officer or the EMS, one after you seen the blood and smoke, go pow, you seen, you heard the pow. Blood, smoke. Then you have one person that was on top of 'em, i don't know who, which one of 'em it was, because I'm watchin' the body. Okay. To see if he was moving. Alright? Let?s back up before then. Let?s, let?s, let?s go back to when they took him down to the ground. Right. Where was everyone positioned at that point. This, this is what I?m saying. Okay. Before the shot. You said that it looked like the white It, it looked to me like it was the white officer Jamar on the ground. Page13of19 him down to the ground. How was, how was he positioned? When he was Jamar. other person was behind him, the other person swept him down. And they took him down. So did he, when he, on the ground, was he uh, on his side, face up, face down? He, he was on his back to me. Okay. You know. At that time he was on his back. Okay. Alright. And then how were the officers positioned? it was one on front and then there was one like on, on him. On top of ?em. Okay. Alrightknee? On the knee like, yeah. Okay. Were they kneeling next to him, or kneeling on top of him? I think they had one on his chest. That's why I?m like, okay, there?s no way possible that he wasn?t restrained. And then another one, was on him, laying on em? or holdin' him down, holdin' his legs or somethin?. Because the next thing I know, (inaudible) this is where the pow, blood, smoke. The next thing I know I see one of the officers or EMS or whatever, whichever one, whoever it was, search his body like did he get shot? And then I look back up and then the crowds, that's where was. Um-hm. That?s where my own focus was. But i was still lookin? at the body to see was he movin?. Um-hm. Do which officer was the one that shot him? To be, I, I?m not gonna speculate on that ?ouz I don?t know Okay. one. I appreciate that. I, I Yeah. True. not speculating. Right. Because like I told you. I wasn't payin? attention no faces. Page14of19 Um?hm. After the, after the Um?hm. paid attention to the body wasn?t movin'. Okay. 'Cuz like, I, was a, was a medic in the army. Um-hm. So my first instinct was to look and watch the body and see what was goin' on. That's what was lookin? at. Okay. So what happened after the shot went off? So after the shot went And the crowd started comin? in. The crowd start comin' in, you got one officer, because the crowd (inaudible) like oh my God you killed that man. You said, they, they was gettin? ready to come across. One officer stood up, pointed the gun that way. And me and my nephew, Joseph Gibson, was like for real, for real. I was like for real, for real. And we was getting? ready to move that way. And we had one officer pointinstopped. 80 they had to protect themself. And I understood that. Um-hm. 80 but the body was still layin? there and that's what I'm lookin?, see any movement. Still no movement. Describe the body to us. What, what're you seeing, like where are the, where the legs, where the arms were, how's he laying on the ground? Okay. Like i said this is, this is the street right here right? Yup. Okay. When they first did it, so we gonna use this as the street. Okay. When they first did it, he was I don?t know, he was positioned with his feet street. Alright? Okay. Jamar Clark, his body was, his feet towards the street when they pushed him down. When they slid, when they moved him over I guess um, this, this is just a guess, I don?t know how this happened, but by the time, but after the shot, his feet was facing this way. You know, towards my way. You don't know how it happened, you just know that his feet swi-, switched. Right. Okay. Was he still on his back, was he on his stomach? Now that you me-, his feet was pointin? up. He was still on his back. Okay. Alright. Um where was his hands at that point? His hands, his hands were still behind him. Page150f19 Behind him? Okay. Then it was another guy, I don?t know who this guy was. He walked up. it was a officer and checked the body. Um-hm. And that?s when the two officers had disappeared, and then all of a sudden somebody came and they came and took the body. Okay. Describe how they took the body. You say they, are you talkin? about The, the urn, don?t know if they was the paramedics because basically after that I just went blank, but I don't know if it?s the paramedics but you seein' ?em pick, you see that they use the paramedics pick him up and they put him in head first. Because his arm, this arm was hanging. You say this arm. You talkin? about his left arm? (inaudible) was hangin? down. And that wasn't moving. Okay. I'm, I'm tellin' ya, I wasjust, my main focus was on (inaudible). That?s fine. And that?s fine. We're just, we?re, that?s why we?re asking questions to see if you remember any of this. Um, you, you mentioned earlier that there was something hanging off of his arm? Yeah I don't know what it was, it could've been a, you know, but it wasn?t, it wasn't no clothing. It looked like a cu?, a, a, a handcuff. Okay. But you know. And was that on the arm that you described was hanging? On the left arm. On Right. arm, okay. Um. Who got in the uh, ambulance with Jamar? No one, no one. I don?t think no one got in there with Jamary. No one got in the ambulance with Jamary. Okay. Not that I know. Okay. And you, you said the uh, officers who had been involved, uh, kinda disappeared. Yeah, they, you can do a better magic. act if you have to pay for one. (laughing) I?m gonna tell you the truth because they just disappeared. Okay. I mean Had other officers arrived on scene at that point or? Page160f19 Yeah. Once the other officers came. Okay. ?Cuz they and truthfully like i told you, the place across the street? Told you between 12:45 and 1 o?clock is when they clear that place out. They start pushin? ?em out at 12:45, so a large crowd started coming out. I've never seen ?em clear a parking lot that quick. They cleared this parking lot within 15, 20 minutes. So I have, I, I never seen that clear up a parking lot clear, cleared that quick. ?Ouz like I told you, (inaudible) and that?s the way it goes over there. Every weekend, so. Never seen that happen. 80, officers came from outta nowhere, (inaudible) cleared the parking lot, everything else. Once they came two officers was gone. Right after you saw the, the gun shot or I?m sorry the smoke and the blood and stuff that you're describing earlier, um, did you hear the officers say anything or did any, or the EMS guy say anything? No I didn't, I didn?t hear anything. Okay. I didn't hear nothin? after that seein? the blood and everything else. How about when they were loading him up into the ambulance. Did you hear 'em say anything? I didn?t hear no one say Okay. that because all I was focused on was watchin? that body. Okay. Because I, I know his sister. Um-hm. So i wanted to know was he alive or was he dead. I knew he was gone when Jamary (inaudible) when he, when they took him away. Um?hm. You know they just put him on the machine to make it last longer but (inaudible). Okay. Just so I remember who drew that out, can you write your name on there for me? Anywhere is fine. And can you date it? What?s 11-19. (inaudible) Alright. Is there anything that we missed or that we forgot to ask you that we should know? Anything that we didn't cover here that you wanna tell us? Uh, ljust have one question. Okay. Um, it's like I said, when it's a crime scene, officers they're not supposed to walk around that crime scene did they? Well I can?t speculate on, or uh, talk Page17of19 Right. exactly they do or they don?t do, 'cuz every, every agency does things differently. I don?t know how they handle it or anything like that. Urn, everyone?s got their own protocol and you know (inaudible) I, I?ll tell you this. I?ve been at um, I personally have been involved with uh, um, 4 different homicide investigations um, where "ve been a, a lead investigator and I can tell you that people do walk around there um, usually there?s a log or something like that, that?s, that?s been my experience but you know, like I said every agency does things differently. Okay. How they document things, so I ?Cuz I mean there I can't. too much Yup. he was shot and then they took the body away. There was just too much traffic right there. And that?s, that?s gonna be one of the things that we have to figure out. Yes. Right. Yup. Um, uh, the only other question I wanted to ask you was uh, how, how you know Jamar, when you said you know his sister. I know his sister. And for how long uh, had you known him? I just met him that night. That night? At, at, Nikila Lander's party. Okay. Just met him that night. Okay. Um, ljust wanna add one last thing. If you know of anybody that saw it, um, somebody that we haven?t talked to, or somebody that has video of it, we wanna strongly encourage you to try to talk to them to come and talk to us so we have all the facts. Um, ?cuz that?s all we're tryin? to do is gather all the Right. the investigation 50. There?s no problem. Yeah so I mean if you, if you?re talkin? to somebody I mean (inaudible) Page180f19 Yup. Nope but i mean outside when you leave here, if you ended up finding out there's somebody else that saw it or somebody else that has video, um, we encourage you to talk, tell ?em to talk to us, so we can get their side too. So, ?cuz we wanna make sure that we have all the facts. Alright. 80. And only wear glasses ?ouz I haven?t been gettin' no sleep. I haven?t been asleep since Okay. I do not (inaudible). 80. Okay. And I be havin? my glasses on that night. (laughs) Okay. This concludes the statement taken. Time is 11:30 hours on November END OF RECORDING Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/19 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Infermation Description: Voluntary statement of Nekelia Sharp at 1315 Lowry Ave. N. - Mp1s on 11?19-15 Reporting LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On 11-19-15 SA Homer and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with Nekelia Levette Sharp tthe North Regional Library of Hennepin County. Agents spoke with Sharp in a conference room where she provided a voluntary statement. The interview was audio recorded. By virtue of this report, exhibits 2015-648? 9.1 and 19.2 were acquired. Address #1 - ~1315 LOWRY AVE Primary Information Address: 1315 LOWRY AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Description: Hennepin County Library Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Sharp, Nekelia Levette Primary Information Subject Name: Sharp, Nekelia Levette Record Type: Person Bio: 39 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses We Egress. HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N. APARTMENT #103, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship NumberlE?Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS - Minnesota 1111912015 NO LICENSE Alias Information Alias Kiki Subject #2 SUBJECT Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal a - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/19 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Sobject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark,- Jamar Oneal - Continued Primary Information - Continued Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 JUVenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks identifications ID Type Number SE County FBI ID 717111FD1 OID 232941 Minnesota State ID Minnesota As Of Date Fictitious NO NO NO Comment Subject #3 MENTION IN REPORT #1 Steele, Kiesha Mona Primary Information Subject Name: Steele, Kiesha Mona Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address SUBSCRIBER Subjects Relationship Name BOYFRIEND GIPSON, Joseph Pierre (Person) 3243 LYNDALE AVE Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States ?g 28 yr. old, Black, Male DOB MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/19 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Property #1 - CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Kiesha Steele Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Kiesha Steele Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 1111912015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/time: 1111912015 11:36 Property #2 - Map drawn by Sharp (Not to scale) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Map drawn by Sharp (Not to scale) Property Status: HQ Status Date: 1111912015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 1111912015 11:36 Officers Vogel, Matt (Special Agent/ FBI) Record Status InformatiOn HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 1112012015 07:53 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Operator: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 12/01/2015 18:17 Reporting LEO Date Supervisbr I Date HORNER, Cody (1395 Financial Crimes Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Investigation 1 Minnesota Bureau of 2/26/2016 Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) lilarrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (13851 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On 11-19-15 at approximately 1136 hours SA Homer and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with Nekelia Levette Sharp?(AKA: Kiki) at the North Regional Library of Hennepin County. SA Vogel previously spoke with Kiesha Mona Steele-who made arrangements to bring Sharp to the library. Agents met with Sharp in a conference room where she agreed to provide a voluntary statement which was audio recorded. Sharp stated that she observed the shooting of Jamar Clark. She said that she will never forget it because she has had two brothers killed by the police. Sharp was standing on the on a patio when she saw Clark come out the side door of the apartment building. An ambulance arrived and Sharp thought it was for Clark because the side of his face was swollen. A female got inside of the paramedic vehicle and Clark approached it. He started looking through the back window. An EMS vehicle came on scene and a male wearing a white shirt exited. He approached Clark and told him to get away from the ambulance. Clark stepped away. Two squad cars came to the scene, one drove by and the other stepped. A white officer and Asian of?cer both got out of the vehicle. They approached Clark and handcuffed him behind his back. They took him down to the ground onto his back. The white of?cer placed his knee on Clark?s chest and the Asian of?cer knelt down on the other side. Clark stated yelling profanities and then a gunshot went off. Sharp said that she saw the gun in the Asian of?cer?s hand; the white officer did not have his gun out. Clark was then put into the ambulance and Sharp did not see where his hands were. Sharp drew a map of the area for the night of the shooting which is attached to this report. See statement for further details. By virtue of this report, exhibits 2015-648/ 19.1 and 19.2 were acquired. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-19?2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: elia evette Sharp (NS) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Cody Horner (CH) FBI SA Matt Vogel (MV) REVIEWED BY: CH BCA Case number 2015?648. Time is 11:36 hours on November 2015. Present at the library in north Minneapolis is Cody Homer of the BCA along with Matt Vogel of FBI and I apologize, what's your name? NS My name is Nelelia Sharp. CH How do you spell your first? NS Sharp S-H-A-R-P. CH Okay. What?s your middle name Nekelia? NS I didn?t hear you sorry. CH What's your middle name? NS It?s Levette. CH How do you spell that. NS CH Okay. And what?s your birth date? NS - CH Oh you just had a birthday. MV Happy Birthday. CH Yeah. What's your uh, where do you live at? NS I live 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, Apartment 103, North Minneapolis, 55411. OH I apologize, what apartment was it? NS 103. CH 103. Sorry I don't write that fast. And do you have a cell phone. NS My cell phone is CH Um?hm. NS CH - NS Yes. Page1 of 16 Okay. Good deal. Um, well like I said just paint us a picture. Try to be as descriptive as possible. Pretend like we know nothing and just kinda use all your senses about what you saw, heard, things like that and (inaudible). You know one thing I wanna say before we even get into this conversation. Sure. See that?s one thing you can never forget is what you see. Um-hm. Especially me. Um-hm. ?Cuz I lost 2 brothers, being killed from the police. 80 l, l, you know, it?s something that you can never forget. Um?hm. You know and the way that ha-, the way that this situation happened that night, (inaudible) it?s unacceptable. The party started at my house. There was a birthday party, given to me. Um, it was a surprise party. I didn?t know it. Um, bef?, we had fun, we (inaudible) we set around had a few drinks. I?m not a big drinker so therefore I wasn?t intoxicated at all. Like I said, we had fun. We enjoyed ourselves. One thing led to another, my husband and l, we had words. But we left. Maybe like 11:30, 12, maybe 11:15, 11:20. I said okay well, I have my children and my daughter and her friend I think it?s time for me to lay them down you know, it got pretty late. 80 I said it?s time for everybody to go. By this time, my husband got ready to leave. I felt like why are you leavin?? It?s my birthday party. Like you shouldn?t be leaving me. So I got to arguin? with him in the hallway. Before I knew it, me and my husband we arguin? back and forth, you know shovin? each other. By this time RaeAnn, she grabs me from the back. She?s holding me. But when you?re uh, when you?re strugglin? with a person you don?t grab nobody. So by this time, Jamar, Kiesha, um, Bock, Dee, everybody's grabbin?, grabbin' her tellin? her to let me go ?cuz i had nothin? to do with her. By this time, she?s really, RaeAnn was really drunk. But she tellin? them, man no that?s not right. They shouldn?t be arguin? and fightin? woo woo woo. But like I said, another day, this is me and my husband?s dispute. They got us apart, me and my husband, Kiesha, and Rock and everybody got my husband and apart. I went in my house. Now what happened in that hallway with RaeAnn and Jamar, I don?t, I don?t recall. I didn?t see that much, but I did hear all the commotion. By this time, my daughter and uh her friends were still in my house. Jamar's sister which is Cherese, she?s say, you know what Kiki, this your birthday weekend. You go hang out and finish havin? your fun. She said I'll keep your daughter overnight. She said this so much. She say I I?ll keep the baby so she took my daughter and her kids in her house. lock my door up. Me, Kiesha, Rock and my son, my son was there also, we left and we went outside and stood in the front. By this, maybe like 5 minutes later, I see Jamar come out the side, coming from around the building out the side door. I, I would assume that?s where he was comin' from out of the side door. He gets around in the front. He?s standing there with us all talking. And he says to me, he said I sure wish I had another drink. He say, ?ouz keep me warm. My sister put me out. can?t go there tonight. So I tell him, I said well you okay. I go back in the house, I pour him another drink. I bring it back outside, I give it to him. He sip, by this time, that I done come out with the drink, i see the paramedics pullin? up. I?m thinkin? that the paramedics was for him, ?ouz when I saw his face, I said, what the hell happened to you? The right side of his face was really big and swollen. So how that happened, I still don?t know. So he said, oh me and RaeAnn got into it. So he said the paramedics was for her. So when the paramedic got out, and they asked me to open the door, I opened the door. They come out with RaeAnn, we still standin? there. But Page2of16 this time he had done took a sip of drink out the cup, he throws the drink. I turned around and I looked at him. I said, I coulda drank my own damn drink you know. So he walks up to the paramedics after he throw the drink down. He walked up to the paramedic truck. You guys, he didn?t do nothing. He just stood and looked in the back of the truck. He didn?tjump on the truck. He didn't beat on the windows. He didn?t do anything. He was watchin? them whatever they were doin' to her inside. Maybe like 3, 4 seconds later, I see EMS pull up. When EMS pull up they pulled him from the paramedics. The white guy, well, the guy got outwith the white shirt, the EMS guy, he asked the gentleman to step back. Jamar stepped back. One thing Jamar did, when he asked him to step back, this is Jamar standin? at the paramedics lookin' in. EMS walked up on this side of Jamar. He asked him to step back. Jamar turns around like this and he stood back. He just stood there. He didn?t say nothin?. By this time, here's two squad cars pull up. One squad car rolled past, the other one stopped. White guy get out on the driver?s side, the Asian guy get out on this side. On the le- on the passenger side. They puttin? they gloves on by this time. As they proceeded towards the paramedics, I actually thought they were goin? to the paramedics, but they whipped around. One grabbed him this way, the other grabbed his arm. They cuff him. By this time only thing I notice his foot, 1 can?t recall who kicked him down, but he?s down by this time. (inaudible) laid on his back. This guy is handcuffed on his back. i saw the guy, Mar-, Mark the white police officer, well the police officer that got out on the driver?s side. i saw his knee on this guy. Okay. So which, which one is that, The, the white guy. The white officer. Has his knee on Jamar. Has Ja-, has his knee on Jamar's chest. Okay. He?s on this, he's on the left, he?s on the right side of Jamar, the Asian guy was on the left side of Jamar, as he was down. Only thing that guy did afterthey had that young man handcuffed was looked up at, he was on his back. Only thing you hear was fuck you, fuck you, pow. By this time i done ran in the building. To get his family. All the extra stuff, like I don?t see the handcuff hangin? off. I didn't see them with him in the ambulance. You know the handcuff, arm went up (inaudible) but i did see them when they put him in the ambulance. It wasn't, his body wasn?t there 3, 4 minutes before they moved his body. And it?s just like i said, it's like, it's wrong because everything that you?re hearing, if he put up a struggle, he went to grab for the gun. That?s why I don?t know who to really talk to. Because it's scarey. Because you don?t want nobody to twist what you say up. My story will never change because this is one time that We had a birthday party outta my 40 years, and l've never experienced nothin? like this. But what I did, what I do know, that that young man was handcuffedstruggle and that police officer shot him for nothin?. It?s not right. Let?s go back to the beginning and kinda work our way through it. Um, you me-, are you the one that they, that goes by Kiki? Yes. Okay. What do you prefer that we call you? Do you want us to call Nekelia. Nekelia, okay. Um, Nekelia you said there was a birthday party for you, and then um, there was a little bit of an, an argument between you and your husband out in the hallway. Yeah. Page3 of 16 Um, you said that you went outside at that point and that?s when you saw um, Jamar come out the come out from around the building? I saw Jamar come out the building. Okay. After the confrontation of me and my Yup. The confrontation was calmed down. Yup. I went in the house. (inaudible) what they were doin? in the hallway. I haven?t the slightest idea. I did hear the commotion, the arguin? and stuff. Yup. But I was in my apartment at this time. Kiesha, myself and her boyfriend, this gentleman standing out here. I call him Rock. Okay. We were all inside my apartment. By this time they had calmed me down. Like I said, what?s goin? on in my hallway with RaeAnn and Jamar I don't, I don't know. I didn't see that much. Okay. But I know when I left and went out my buildin? and locked up my house door, and went and stood outside, few minutes later, I see Jamar comin? from around the building. When Jamar came around that buildin? he came and stood where we were. He asked me for the Um?hm. said okay. I iwent in the house, poured him a drink. When I come back out, I see the paramedics pull up. By that time I let them in the building. Um-hm. They come back out, put her in the truck. He done throw my drink down by this time, and he walked up to the paramedics, lookin' in the paramedic?s window. Okay, I?m gonna hold you right there. Would it, would it be beneficial for you to kinda draw a picture of where everything?s laid out so we can talk and kinda get an idea of where you?re seeing things? That?s fine. Okay. ill give you a piece of paper here. I'll give you my pen. What I'd like you to draw is where the entrance to the building is. Um-hm. The paramedic vehicle, squad car. (inaudible) but we gonna figure it out. Yeah, just a sketch. Yeah it?s just a sketch, so. Okay. Let me see. Okay l?ll say this is my balcony. Okay. Page4of 16 I?ll say this is the walkway. Okay. Say this is the front door. Okay. Okay. This is our front door to the building. Okay. This i my balcony. Um-hm. Okay, well my balcony would be over here. Okay. Then I have my neighbor in between, you know. Yup. Then this is my neighbor so this is my balcony. Okay. Neighbor. ?Kay? Then this is our walkway. Um?hm. Now outside in front our buildin', there?s a little like a little flower bed, which this would be the little flower bed. ?Kay? Then these are our mailboxes here. So we're all standin? here. Okay. This is where we?re all standin'. Can you write downwere standing, or something Okay. signify that?s where you guys were at. We?re standing. Okay. This is my, okay, these are the mailboxes. Um?hm. Now a little bit over here, this is my neighbor?s house. Okay. This be house. Neighbor. ?Kay. Now a little bit on down the ways, here?s our walkway. This is our sidewalk. This is the grass. The paramedics was here. Okay. They were parked here. And (inaudible). Not good with this (inaudible). That?s okay you can write it facing you, you don?t have write it facing us. Okay. This is the paramedics. Um-hm. This truck here, EMS. This truck is here, squad car. PageEof 16 the squad car was behind the EMS vehicle? It was in front. Okay. 'Kay so, the paramedics pull up here. Um-hm. They're facin' this way. EMS pulls in front of them, which EMS is facin? that way. Um-hm. But the squad cars are facin? this way. But they?re in front of it. Right in front of. Okay. So, this is the squad car. And then police car here. And where was Jamar in relation to. Jamar? Um-hm. But like i said this is the paramedics. He was lookin? in the window. When EMS pulled up, they asked him to step back. So Jamar is standin' like little ways up the grass. Can you put an where he's at? He's standin? middleways up the grass. Okay. Still in between the paramedics and the EMS truck. So, all these cars are parked facin? the wrong way in traffic. is that? No. The paramedic is facin' 4?h Precinct Police station. EMS is facin' 4th Precinct Police station. The only squad car, the squad car that pulled up, was facin' toward the two car, toward the you know. Okay. Just so I get my bearings here. Is this? So, say (inaudible) this way. They?re facin? this way but this is the squad car. It?s facin? this way. You see? Okay, right but traffic, the traffic would be goin? this way. The traffic would be goin' this So the ambulance? car. The ambulance was facin? the wrong way? The ambulance was facin? the wrong way. Okay. And this Page60f16 facin? the wrong way. This is the medic truck. And this arrow you have is front? (inaudible) This is the front of the paramedic here. Okay. This is the front of the paramedic. Okay. That?s the front of their truck, this is the front of EMS. But this is the front of the squad car. Okay. Okay. Jamar?s standin' here. When they walked up, when they walked past, the police come past, they come past. We, like I said, we actually, I, Nekelia, thought that they were goin? ta the paramedic. But they whipped around, one cuffed him this arm. They grabbed him. The first arm they grabbed was his right arm. Round, round, back. Where were you standing at when that, when that happened? In that same, that same spot? Right here in my same spot. I didn?t move. How far, or distance wise, so if we're sitting here, let?s say that's the, let?s say we?re at the front of your Um-hm. or whatever you wanna call it. How far away in relation to here is where Jamar was at? 80 like, looking that way, how far, towards From my pa?, if I was standin' on my patio? Oh no, right where you were standing. (inaudible) I was standing. Yup. Yup. Looking that wayinto that room? Was it prior to that roomfrom here to the wall? think maybe if I stand maybe if the (inaudible). If I?m standin? at the Um?hm. The wall is Jamar and the crime scene. This is the crime scene here. Okay. it, it was no stretch. So like 15, 20 As far as that. something like that. Maybe so, may, Page7of?16 Yeah. you walk from where l?m standin? maybe 5 or 06 steps. Um-hm. That?s how Okay. were. Okay. Um?hm. So when you say that you saw ?em put the arms behind the back. Yeah. Did you 3-, now this is where l, I need you to be very, very descriptive okay? Okay. Did you just see the motions of them puttin' the hands behind the back, and it No. there was handcuffs? No. Or did you see handcuffs? When, when they grabbed Um-hm. the first officer grabbed him? Um?hm. Cuffs. They cuffed that arm. What color was the cuffs? Silver. Okay. So when the other, so when the other officer grabbed, he was cuffed, both hands were cu?ed. Now you said that when the first officer cuffed him, how did he, where did he cuff ?em. Did he cuff ?em out here? Did he cuff ?em back here? When the first officer grabbed him, his back went down, the cuffs was snapped on him. Okay. And So it was (inaudible). the cuff the air. When he cuffed 'em he (inaudible) it was here at this point. Okay. Enough tiem for the other officer to get his other arm. And the cuffs was clicked on this guy. Page8 of16 Jamar was there, you're here. Was uh, was his, like his front side facing you or was his back side facing you? No his side. His sidehis side? like this. Okay. So when they grabbed Yup. one officer clicked the Yup. 0-, when they grabbed the other arm the cuff was clicked. Like I say, I don?t, I can?t recall EMS at this point. Bringin? him down. Okay. I can?t remember who brought him down. Okay. But what I do remember is not the, the Asian officer, the white officer had is knee in his chest Okay. And Yes. he was kneeling down with his knee in his chest? Yes. What happened at that point? At that point, they were just, you know, um, the EMS and the other, the paramedics, the EMS and the police officers were talking. By this time only thing i could hear was fuck you, fuck you. Pow. The gun shot went off. Okay. Yup. What happened at that point? At that point, the paramedic that was still sitting there with RaeAnn, because the paramedic was still there. At this point, this paramedic (inaudible) and here comes another paramedic. By that time we all holler, 1 runs in the buildin?. And grab his sister. lt give me enough time 3, 4, within 2, 3 minutes, to run in, run in the buildin?, hurry up beat the door, your brother got shot. i came back out. By this time this paramedic was pickin' him up. Puttin' him in the, puttin? him in the paramedic. Let?s go back to the point where he was shot. Um, you said you heard the gun shot. Yes. Did you see the officer pull his gun out? Page90f16 The officer gun was already out. Was already out? It was already out. Okay. He didn?t pull his gun out. At what? I didn?t see him pull his gun out, but i saw the gun already out. I didn?t see him pull it Okay. the gun was already out. You saw it in his hand. Yes. it was in his hand. Okay. Which? Which officer was this? The Korean, well Asian, Korean, it wasn't the white officer. So it was in the, in the Asian guy?s hand? Yes. Do you remember if it was left hand or right hand? I can?t actually remember. Okay. I can?t actually remember. Okay. Um, so the white officer was kneeling on ?em, and then the Asian officer?s the one that had a gun out. Yes. Okay, and then you heard the pow. The pop. Yes. What happened at that point, as far as anybody saying anything? Did you hear anything? Everybody just got to hollerin? you just shot that man. You just killed that man. Why?d you have to shoot him so the crowd was really outraged. It was really a rage. By this time here, all these different police officers, they?re backin? people up, makin? us get back. They had done cleared the whole Elk?s Lodge out within 3 seconds. Like I?ve never seen that parkin? lot cleared that fast, ever. And I?ve been livin? there 9 years on that block. I've never seen nothin? like this in my life. Um-hm. it?s sad. So as they, the paramedics, um, picked Jamar up and put him into the ambulance, um, did you see where his hands were? Did you No. No. PageiOoftB l?m not gonna even lie to you. I don?t know. Okay. But you just saw him on the cot? Yeah, i seen them put him on the stretcher. And by this time they were pullin? off (inaudible). Okay. Alright. They didn?t even give the family, like l?said, by the time the family got out there, they were takin? his body then. They didn?t even give his sister time enough nothin?. Theyjust had all us backed up at gunpoint. You Um?hm. back up, everybody get the fuck back, don?t move. Um-hm. You know. Um-hm. 80. Wanted to ask you um, goin' back a couple things, when the police got out of the squad, urn, do you recall what they were wearing? The regular uniforms. Okay. The ?Cuz uniform. they differ sometimes you know. Um-hm. When it's warm, some people wear short sleeves. Sometimes No, these officers had long sleeve shirts on. sleeve. Ajacket on, or? They had long sleeve jackets on and they vests. These officers did not have jackets on. Not, neither one of ?em? I didn't see jackets on neither one of these officers. Okay. Um, and you described the white officer as having his knee on Jamar?s chest. The chest. Yes. How was the Asian officer positioned when they were on the ground. Kneeled down. He was kneeled down. He was on, he was on? Um?hm. (inaudible) okay. Uh, where in relation to Jamar's body were they? He was on the left side of Jamar?s body. They other officer was on the right side of his body. And when you say? PageifofiB remember. And when you say that, is that, is that Jamar?s, (inaudible) that as you?re lookin? at it? Uh, at Jamar's body. Okay. So Jamar's left side, which officer was on which? Jamar's left side of his body, the Asian officer was on. Okay. Jamar?s right side of his body, the white officer was on. Okay. Now how remember this, is because Jamar's face was swoll on his right side. You could never forget that. Yeah. Was there, is there anything that uh, we missed or that you wanna tell us, anything that we didn?t ask? Anything that we forgot to ask? Anything that you feel is important? You know the thing I feel that?s important is that this was a, this is a family that is grieving for a young man that will never be able to talk or see us again. You know. And I do understand how that family feel once again. Ijust feel that it's important that you know, they do get justice for him. Because all these lies are bein? told. Like literally. There was never a gun mentioned. Uh, him tryin? to reach for a gun if, the day that this happened you know. Now here it is 3 days later, now he's s'posed to have been reach for the gun. How can you reach for a gun if you're handcuffed? I mean, how can you let this guy get that close to you to reach for your gun, if he's already down in cuffs? Um-hm. I mean I?m not a bad person, and I?m not a perfect person. I haven?t had the best life. I?ve had flaws in my life. But one thing I?m never gonna do is get up here and laugh at nobody. ?Cuz it's not that important. What's important, is that we have a young man that?s dead. That we need justice for. And i wasn?t willin' to talk to nobody. it's not because I have nothin? to hide. it?s just because I?m askin? myself does our story, or our statements even matter. We have a young lady that came and talked to us, and we got in front of the cameras for her, and she?s not talked back to us since Sunday. 80 I ask myself, is anything that I?m sittin? here tellin? you guys, is any of this important. it is. And maybe it is. it is. And I know it is. Wit-, witnesses state, statements definitely are important. And I (inaudible). Especially in, in an incident like this where things happen, and happen quickly, and there were so many people present that, that saw what happened. Each person sees (inaudible) Paget2of16 Um-hm. details matter. Urn, you mention that you had made a statement in front of the camera. Do you recall who who you, who, who have you made that statement to about these, about this incident. I have made no um, statements to nobody but think it was NAACP did the press conference for. Um-hm. And that was Sunday morning at 11 o'clock. And I haven?t talked to nobody since. We had like 50 people come to my house and leave cards and you know I have people on my Facebook and then I have people followin? me. You know I have Channel 9 News and if they see me leavin? the house, and they see me getting' in my truck, how the hell can you possibly be seein? all this if you're not watchin? me and following me Um-hm. Total harassment. Um-hm. I don't have to talk to you all. Uh-hm. didn?t have to talk to you guys. But I didn?t want you to feel like I had anything to hide. l?m just as hurt as everybody else, because the day I give myself a birthday party, it?s not the best birthday in the world. Hmm. Because I lost this friend. Um-hmm. Uh, wanted to ask you um, how how you know or how you knew I for, and for how long. Um, Jamar's sister and I are friends. She?s my neighbor. I?ve been knowin? her for quite some years. Um living on Plymouth townhomes but Jamar I've been knowin? Jamar maybe five or six months. Just livin' with his sister. But we get up every day we sit and we chat and we talk and you know. He, he and I talked about alotta stuff. Some stuff that his family never even knew. Um?hmm. Can you do me a favor just so i know who drew this, can you write your name on there for us? Anywhere is fine. Okay. (inaudible). I guess like I say you guys are the second people that We made a statement too. And we appreciate that. Can you I don?t. you date it for us too? Okay. It's a, it?s the I don?t, I don?t associate with people and a Page130f16 Nineteen. another thing is don't even have company in my house. Um-hmm. That?s what was so crazy like, here go have a party and i don't even have company in my house announced, this guy gets killed. [just hope that the family didn't think that you know like how shehe goes to her party he gets killed but. Nothing ever took place in my apartment far Um-hmm. the fighting. Even with my husband arguing and (inaudible) pushin' and shovin'. It never took effect in my apartment. Your husband Albert Landers. Okay and ah, did he My happened? home. Nut, you know like I said he and confrontation resulted to him goin' Okay. and me staying home calming down. So he left. 80. Ah, you mentioned that your was there. My son name is (inaudible). He was there but my son he, he's the type of kid that you know he don?t do a lot of talkin' and ya knownineteen. Nineteen. So, we didn?t had a lot a losses in our family within these last few years. His dad, his grandma, his uncle. You know so my son when he come ta stuff like that my baby he shuts down. Okay. You know. But he did see what happened. Yeah, he seens a lot of it. Okay. But I haven't honestly I haven?t (inaudible) my son talk to nobody because I wanna him bring back up a lot of stuff that he?s already deald with in his life. You know he's not a nineteen year old adult man ya know, he?s a nineteen year old in child's mind, you know. So, l'm not gonna put my son (inaudible). l?m gonna be honest with you all, it?s not because my, like I said I have nothing to hide but my son, l'm not gonna put him through this. Page14 of16 Well this is a perfect ah, segway to talk about what I was gonna say is, if you know anybody?. Yeah (inaudible). that saw it, was an witness to it or has video of, of the incident. I mean l?ll talk to my son. Yeah. I have you all cards and stuff. Yep. Like I said I don?t wanna put my child back through a lot of trama his life that he?s already been through. Yep. You know he?s only been here in the State of Minnesota since July. brought him here to get him away from the Chicago lifestyle. He wasn't a bad kid there but I didn?t want the streets to kill my son. 80 I went and got him and brought him home. Um-hmm. And like 1 said, I?ll talk to him. if my baby is comfortable with talking l?ll let him. l?ll call you guys, i could meet you and I?ll let you talk to my son. And we appreciate that. But right Yep. give him the Yep. decide if he wants to talk to the police because he says now i don't wanna be in front of no cameras. Yep. None of that stuff. 80. And I wasn?t necessarily inferring him, I?m taking understand. So, yeah if there's You know and like I said there wasn?t too many people um?hmm, that really witnessed the actual what happened, what happened. Um?hmm Likewe, us guys, his and (inaudible) our child where really actually the main sources of this. Like the outsiders they saw bits and pieces. But when everything first started from this point to that point. Nobody actually (inaudible) saw nothing. Um-hmm. They just comin' forth with just saying what they know. Page15of16 Um-hmm. I wanna tell ya um, ask you about that-year old because ah that?s been brought up before. Um-hmm. Now who's child. His name, his name um his mom?s name is? Okay. And whats the boys name? His name is? MV okayUm?hmm. Okay. And ah, wa so was .also there with you? Nek,-was in the house. Okay. -didn't know what was goin' on until her son ran in there and told her. Okay. Um, ye ye and you, are you in touch with her? Do you She?s my Okay. (inaudible). I think um, and you know I, I don't know for but well we can, we can finish this interview and then 80 i talk to her, see everyday. Um-hmm. talk about that a little bit. Okay. This concludes the statement taken, time is 12:07 hours on November 2015. END OF RECORDING Horner/2015?648?A03 Page16 of16 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/20 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Digitally Recorded Interview of Michael Donnell Evans. Reporting LEO: PRITZLAFF, Mike (Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: BLACKMORE, Bob (FBI - MINNESOTA, MINNEAPOLIS) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) SynOpSis, I A canvass of the area was completed. Resulted in an interview of one individual and business cards left at another apartment. Address #1 - occurred 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name ?332 DOB Subject. MENTION lN REPORT #1 a Evans, Michael Donnell Primary Information Subject Name: Evans, Michael Donnell Record Type: Person Bio: 53 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #301, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address HOME Preperty #1 - Evans'audio interview . Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Evans' audio interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/20 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Property #1 - Evans' audio interview Continued Primary Information - Continued UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: PRITZLAFF, Mike (Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/20/2015 13:28 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11l30/201517:16 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date PRITZLAFF, Mike (Financial Crimes Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of 2/26/2016 Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins tonr?the5following page, MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 Investigative Supplemental 2015?648/20 By SA PRITZLAFF On November 20, 2015 at 10:54 Federal Bureau of Investigation Agent Robert Blackmore and Bureau of Criminal Apprehension SA spoke to Michael Evans during a canvass ofthe area (1611 Plymouth Ave N). The conversation was audio recorded, downloaded to a secure server, a copy placed on a and placed into evidence, and a transcription will be added to this report when completed. Michael said he spoke to law enforcement the night of the incident, but it was only to ask if he saw anything. Michael told law enforcement that night that he was sleeping and never saw anything. . Michael said his name was not taken at that time. Michael said he did happen to wake up that morning and looked out to see several officers out front of his apartment complex. Michael again said he never saw or heard anything prior to seeing all the police officers on the street. Michael said he stepped out on the deck and observed for a little bit, but went back in to go back to bed. Michael said his wife; Mary Lo Jackson was home at the same time. Michael said she never saw or heard anything herself. Michael said she did get up, looked outside and then told him she was going back to bed. Both agents provided their business cards upon leaving the interview. Agents attempted to make contact with apartment 303, but never received a response to knocking. Both left their business cards on the door requesting a call. STATUS: Report only MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 1 1-20?2015 10:54 AM BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: Death Investigation EXHIBIT A01 INTERVIEW OF: Michael Evans (ME) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Mike Pritzlaff (MP) SA Robert Blackmore (RB) REVIEWED BY: SA PRITZLAFF ME Sorry it was my day off I was sleeping. RB No problems. MP Have you talked to law enforcement at all concerning the incident that occurred outside? ME Well they stopped by that night and asked me if I saw anything and I told um Ijust happen to wake up and see all you guys out here on the streets. MP Okay. (knocking) ME Probably one of you guys. MP Yeah, hand on a second. ME Well anyway. MP We got this because the other one was, if you wanna try it you know. Okay. ME Anyways. MP Sorry about that. ME I start work at 5 o?clock in the morning so I was sleeping. So I didn?t see or hear anything. RB Okay. ME And like, sometime I get insomnia and I wake up in the middle of the night and Ijust happen to see everybody outside. I mean the law enforcement. MP Yep. ME And that?s it. MP Alright. Did you hear any shots? Did you see anything as far as what was going on or anything specific or you just looked out and saw a bunch of people? ME Ijust looked out and saw a bunch of police officers lined up down the street with their cars. MP Okay. RB Okay. ME I didn?t see or hear anything. My wife was here with me. MP And, would she say the same thing? ME She sleeps through a tornado man. RB I wish I could do that. Evans, Michael Transcript ~2015-648?A0?l Page 1 of3 Evans, Michael Transcript She looked out the window said l'm going back to bed. i stood out on the balcony you know for a few minutes and you know and I had no idea what happened. Okay. Actually I thought a police officer got shot cuz i never seen that many police of?cers you know out of one, out on one scene. Now when they talked to you there did they take your name or talk to No. in any detail just if you saw anything and? No theyjust asked me if I saw or heard anything. Okay. And I told ?em i told ?em the same thing I?m telling you guys now. Okay. Um, just so know l?m recording our conversation just so that we have it on record. Um?hm. Okay urn have you talked, do you know people in the building very well? Well enough that you could talk to ?em and find out if anybody might have seen something directly that night? We pretty much keep to ourselves. Okay. I?ll be, we been here a little over a year. We moved here in January, no, yeah around January, last year so we only been here a little over a year. We go to work, come home, that's it. That?s our life. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Okay. Urn can i get your name so that we know that we talked to you and can document that we talked to you? Sure. My name is Michael Evans. Do you have a middle name Michael? Donnell. Evans is the last name? Yes. And just for my records your birthdate was born in .as well. And this is um 1611 Plymouth Avenue, right? Yep, apartment 301. Do you have contact phone numbers? Uh, just the home phone. i don?t do cell phones. Page 2 of 3 MP I wish I was that lucky. (laugh) What?s the home number? ME (inaudible) I don?t call it, that?s it. I had a bad experience with cell phone so I don?t fool with ?em anymore. MP Alright um I?m gonna give you my card. ME Um?hm. MP Um RB I?ll give you mine as well. MP If you hear anything um what was your wife's name? ME Her name is Mary Lou Jackson. MP Mary Lou Jackson and you were with her that night? ME Yeah, we both here. MP And she didn't see anything other ME She was sleeping too. MP Sleeping too as well. Did she get up and look out and hear anything different do you think? ME Eloc,i she got out, looked out the same uh I did I woke her up and she said I?m going back to . MP Okay, alright. If you hear anything from other neighbors or just inklings that somebody saw something could you give me a call? ME Absolutely. MP And then we'll just kind a take it from there. Do you have any questions for our, I'm, l?m with the BCA, the state, l?m with the FBI. MP the FBI. Any questions for us? Any concerns or questions for us? ME No, not at this time but if I, if I find anything I think you guys should know about be more than glad to let you know. MP We appreciate it. RB ghe only thing we care about doing is getting to the truth of what actually happened out ere. ME Absolutely, I understand. Ifeel the same way. MP Alrighty. We'll let you get back to bed, right? ME Oh yeah. END OF TAPE Evans, Michael Transcript Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/21 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Digitally Recorded Interview of Chala lyssa Stroud Occurrence From: 11/20/2015 11:00 Occurrence To: 11/20/2015 11:10 Reporting LEO: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBI/Mpls I Federal Bureau of Investigation) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/07/2015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 20, 2015 at aprox 1100 hrs, MN BCA SSA Gary Swanson and FBI Special Agent Stephen Vitale interviewed Chala lyssa Stroud at the door to her apt at 1611 Plymouth Ave. Apt 203 in Minneapolis, MN. As a result exhibit 648/21.1 was acqurred. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE A Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #203, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subjects Relationship Name HOME ADDRESS Stroud, Chala lyssa (Person) 2? yr. old, White, Female . Subject #1 WITNESS #1 - Stroud, Chala lyssa Primary Information Subject Name: Stroud, Chala lyssa Record Type: Person Bio: 27 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #203, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #2 - SUBJECT Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION PhilI. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/21 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued Primary Information - Continued Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number ?ne Countm As Of Date Fictitious Went FBI ID 717111FD1 No OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Preperty #1 - CDcontaining file of the interview Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD containing file of the interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 11/20/2015 00:00 Officers Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBIIMpls I Federal Bureau of Investigation) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/20/2015 13:35 Last Update Operator: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/07/2015 14:34 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/21 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Reporting LEO - Date . SuperVisor 7 3 I - Date Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins- on the foilowing page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On November 20th, 2015, at approximately 1100 hours, MNBCA SSA Gary Swanson and FBI SA Stephen Vitale conducted a digitally recorded interview of Chala Stroud at the entry door to her apartment located at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, Apt. 203 in Minneapolis. Upon the door of the apartment being answered by Ms. Stroud, agents identified themselves to her as FBI and BCA agents and she was advised we were doing a neighborhood canvas in order to locate any witnesses that had seen the incident involving Jamar Clark on the early morning hours of November 15th, 2015. Ms. Stroud became visibly upset and stated that she was in fear for her life and her family's life and was very hesitant to speak with us. Stroud stated during the brief interview that she saw Clark lying on the ground and saw an officer on top of him. She stated there were two officers present and that she did not believe that the one officer knew that the other officer shot because according to her the second officer acted as if he had also been hit. Stroud stated that she witnessed this from both the window of her apartment and then on the balcony after she had put on a shirt and went outside. Stroud stated that when she heard the commotion outside she looked out of the window and saw the man standing by the ambulance as the police arrived. She then stated she heard the officers start yelling. She stated she went out on the balcony after she heard the shot and that?s when she saw the officers on the ground. SSA Swanson asked her if she could see if Clark had been handcuffed and she stated she did not see handcuffs physically on him but when they flipped him over she believed his hands were behind his back. She stated that the officers did not flip him over until after she had heard the shot being fired. At that point she saw EMS rendering medical aid doing CPR on him. Ms. Stroud was very hesitant to speak with agents but did give the limited interview and at the end of the interview she was asked if she knew of anyone else that may have witnessed this and she advised us that she stayed to herself and did not talk to other people in the area. Ms. Stroud was provided with business cards from both SSA Swanson and SA Vitale and requested to call if she should remember any other facts regarding this incident or if she obtained any information as to anyone else who might be a witness. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 20, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: Homicide OIS Fatal EXHIBIT 2015-6480131 INTERVIEW 0F: Chala Stroud (CS) INTERVIEWED BY: MN BCA SSA Gary Swanson FBI SA Stephen Vitaie REVIEWED BY: SSA Swanson CS My son is 8 years old wanted be in the SWAT. He wants to be a police officer after he, he came Swanson~201 5-648-A21 at 4 o?clock in the morning said mom I'm here to go to sleep, sleep. You never know what (inaudible) be killed. Uh-huh. So and, and I?m trying to keep my children (inaudible) safe. Uh?huh. Well And it's crazy when a police officer (inaudible) that my child?s looks up to finds out that he killed a guy. That's why we?re here. Yep, so Chala that?s why we?re not the only ones here. We have other agents that are doing interviews. I don?t know 'what?s goin' on. We?re trying to get the story. We, that?s why we wanna know what you saw. Now, you all gonna need to ?gure out what?s going on at that station because if (inaudible) (inaudible) we need to hear what you saw. I seen, I seen him laying on the ground. I seen him laying on the ground. Uh-huh. And I seen the officer on the top of him. Uh?huh. (inaudible) officer on top of him. There's two officers at the time. Uh?huh. The way we do this is um we record an interview so I understand that. I understand that. I don?t mind being interviewed because I don?t know what?s going on over there. I don't want my family (inaudible) We're not part of them. I hope not. We?re not. I hope not because this is crazy, this community. (inaudible) Page 1 of 5 Swanson-2015?648-A21 We don?t work for the Minneapolis Police. We have nothin' to do with ?em. We?re outside agencies. i understand that. No one talked to you yet? I, i don?t, I don't wanna talk to nobody. I?m saying you have not been interviewed yet? I don?t want to talk to nobody first. Do you understand me? Sure, I do. There, there is tons of people that done seen that. My (inaudible) best friend seen that. We?re sure it?s homicide. Do you understand that? Where did you see it from? I seen it from the window. Your window? The back window. You were outside on the balcony? No, i went outside on the balcony after shirt. I was putting my children to sleep. My son woke up to the gunshot. Um-hm. There was people yelling. This is traumatic around here. Shit doesn't happen like this around here. Um-hm, okay. The, these people aren't getting away with murder and it's not cool. Okay so you don?t wanna talk to us. I, i don?t wanna talk to nobody. I?m scared for my life. Do you all understand that? I, you know what you all (inaudible) every day. You all know how it is to be scared. Um?hm. A man and his child just got killed and he was giving this baby all yesterday. Do you live here alone with your child? With my children yes. Okay. Were there any other adults that saw what happened? My sister from out of town, she?s out of town, she?s from Kansas. Did you see She didn't see it. She heard the commotion and then we went out on the balcony after, you know what I?m sayin'. When you went out on the balcony were the, were they on the ground? (inaudible) Yeah. No. They weren?t. The one cop, the one cop that was on the ground, (inaudible), I don't even think that he knew that his partner was gonna shoot 'em cuz he got up (inaudible) cuz he thought he was hit. Uh?huh. He thought he was hit. Page 2 of 5 Swanson?2015?648-A2?l Uh-huh. After they shot that man they raised up their gun (inaudible). i don't know what else to say you know. My statement gonna mean shit but I?m tellin? you all what (inaudible). Your statement will mean a lot. I know that that man died unjustable, unjustifiable. Chala He was (inaudible) That?s why we?re trying to talk a little bit since cuz I mean so you said you went outside after your heard the shot. Yes. Okay. No, (inaudible) after i heard the shot but when was in the window I hear commotion and I heard commotion. l?m really nosey so I look out the window. i seen the man there i mean the EMS there a long time ago. Um-hm. Didn't know what the situation was. never seen that man banging on no window or nothin' like that. When I seen the police pull up, that?s when I started hearding the yelling of the cops. Uh-huh. Excuse me, (inaudible). (inaudible) So were doing this now (inaudible) (inaudible) Okay. Um is there a phone number or card maybe I'll feel more comfortable. (inaudible) come to our office, one of our of?ces so you?re not doing it here, later. We'll give you a card. (inaudible) more and more people (inaudible). That's why we're trying to keep (inaudible) That?s why (inaudible) (inaudible) Um. (inaudible) So do you have a, how do we get in touch with you? (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) phone number that you (inaudible) Could, could you see if Jamar was handcuffed? I didn?t, i didn?t see handcuffs physically on him. Okay. But when they flipped him over. Uh-huh. Page 3 of 5 Swanson-2015?648?A21 I believe his hands was handcuffed cuz he was, his hands were to the back of him. Uh-huh. His hands were to the back of him. A person that would be fightin' their hands would be on the side or (inaudible) by his side. Uh-huh. i didn?t see none of that. Okay. And, and I didn't hear (inaudible) cuz i know what I Uh-huh. He killed that man. If you So you say when they flipped him over that's after you heard the shot? No, no, no they shot him and then they flipped him over. The EMS, the EMS tried to do CPR on him. Um?hm. And looked up at the cop like what the fuck did you all do. I've witnessed plenty of murders, believe me living on the north side have mother fuckin' (inaudible) Um?hm. But we do our best over here. We keep our community tight. Um-hm. (inaudible) Um-hm. You all need to figure out what the fuck is going on That?s what were That?s what we're trying to do. They?re doin' too much to peOple over here and they?re treating everybody like, oh just because you're (inaudible) you decide to live like animals. This shit ain?t cool. That's what we?re trying to do. The media and everybody stories around, it?s crazy. You all need to get a handle on this shit before Minnesota starts looking over every fuckin? other state. I don?t know what to tell you all. I?m going into my house with my children and I?m going to calm myself down. i wish l?d (inaudible). Okay. Okay. I have been (inaudible). I can't deal with this right now. l?m sorry. i hope you all can figure it out. Chala do you have uh (inaudible) birthdate? Alright. Thanks for talking to us and we?ll, we?ll (inaudible) get back in touch with us. Cuz we would like to hear more of your st?, information since you saw what happened. That would be helpful. i didn't see the whole thing. ljust seen parts and pieces from (inaudible) to the next. Okay. Okay. So. Please, please give us a call. it'd be a big help. Page 4 of 5 Swanson-2015-648-A21 I know the little boy, he always be in the window in the neighborhoodknows everybody, everybody knows everybody. Um?hm. (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) Okay. Do you know anyone else? I don't know nobody around here. I keep to myself. So no one, you, you don't know anybody that may have also witnessed this? No, no. Okay. The, the, the ton of people that was outside that day. Yeah. There a ton of people outside. But no one you talked to. No. Okay. No. I don?t? talk to nobody around here. Okay. I don't. I keep to myself. Okay are you working currently? No. (inaudible) trying to figure out how we can (inaudible) (inaudible) Okay. (inaudible) there?s plenty of ways I can call you. I?ll ?gure out how. I just hope you all change (inaudible) down here. We're trying. Thank you. You're welcome. END OF TAPE. Page 5 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/22 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Digitally recorded statement of Teto Lamont Wilson Occurrence From: 11/18/2015 10:12 Occurrence To: 11/18/2015 10:12 Reporting LEO: Hanegraaf, Luke (1389/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vogel, Matt (Special Agent FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1 1/24/2015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 18 2015 SSA Hanegraaf along with SA Vogel (FBI) obtained a digitally recorded statement from TETO LAMONT WILSON, 0.0.3. at the FBI building located at 1501 Freeway Blvd. in Brooklyn Center MN. By virtue of this report, exhibit 2015?648l22.1 (CD Containing digital statement of Teto Wilson) was acquired. Address #1 - Occurred '15101 FRI-sewn BLVD Primary Information Address: 1501 FREEWAY BLVD, Brooklyn Center, Minnesota 55430 United States Subjects Relationship Name i BUSINESS LOCATION Brooklyn (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION FBI (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Burnham, Chuck (Law Enforcement Official) Male BUSINESS LOCATION Morrissey, Katie (Law Enforcement Of?cial) Female EMPLOYER Burnham, Chuck (Law Enforcement Official) Subject_#1 #1 Wilson, Teto Lamont . Primary Information Subject Name: Wilson, Teto Lamont Record Type: Person Bio: 42 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3926 VINCENT AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address SUBSCRIBER MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide lMinnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/22 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #2 a sClariondamarOnealg._ Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Stag County Male FBI ID 717111FD1 NO 232941 Minnesota NC State ID Minnesota NO gamut Property - CD containing digital audio statement-of Teto Lamont Wilson,,4l7l73 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD containing digital audio statement of Teto Lamont Wilson, 4/7/73 Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11l19l2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 22.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 11l18l2015 00:00 Record Status Information Record Origination OperatorMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Page 2 of 5 02/26/2016 13:36 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal .- Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/22 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Record Status information - Continued Record Origination Date: 11/20/2015 14:31 Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/24/2015 14:47 RepartingyLEO .- Date Supervisor Date Hanegraaf, Luke (1389 I Financial Crimes Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 On November 18, 2015 SSA Hanegraaf along with SA Vogel of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) obtained a digitally recorded statement from TETO LAMONT WILSON, D.O.B- at the FBI building located at 1501 Freeway Blvd. in Brooklyn Center, MN. The purpose of this statement was regarding the death investigation of JAMAR CLARK in the City of Minneapolis MN on Sunday November 13, 2015. The digital statement was later transferred to a Compact Disc (CD) and labeled as exhibit The transcribed statement is also attached to this case ?le report for full details of the statement given by WILSON. A synopsis of the statement is as follows: TBTO WILSON told SSA Hanegraaf that he along with four friends arrived at the ?Elk?s Clu in Minneapolis on Saturday November 12, 2015 at approximately 23:3 0hrs at which time he (WILSON) had one Heineken beer while at the ?Elk?s Club.? WILSON stated that he along with his friends exited the ?Elk?s Clu around closing time which was approximately 00:5 0hrs to 01 :OOhrs which was now Sunday November 13, 2015. WILSON advised that when he exited, he observed the incident transpiring between the Minneapolis Police Department Of?cer?s and an individual who he (WILSON) later learned to be JAMAR CLARK and will be for purposes of this report be hereinafter described as CLARK. WILSON said he observed the incident across the roadway (Plymouth Ave.) from the approximate distance of thirty feet. He described CLARK to be wearing light colored clothing, lying on his stomach with his (CLARK) head facing east paralleling Plymouth Ave. He could not observe ?om this position if CLARK was or was not in handcuffs or restraints and the position of hands at this time. He stated that from his position, CLARK appeared to be in ?total submission.? He stated that he observed two Minneapolis Police Of?cer?s during this time involved in the incident with CLARK. WILSON described one Of?cer with his knee in the back of CLARK and the other Of?cer in ?some really weird type maneuvers on his body? referring to the position on CLARK. He described this position of the Of?cer as in weight lifting terms of a ?dip.? He demonstrated this position for SSA Hanegraaf and SA Vogel which could also be explained as someone facing in an upward direction holding themselves off the ground with their hands. He (WILSON) described this Of?cer to be in this position on the upper torso region of CLARK. He further described this action or position by the Of?cer to be strange and that it ?didn?t look like normal police.? SSA Hanegraaf asked WILSON if he heard any verbal transactions from either the Of?cer?s or CLARK during this incident at which point he stated no. He stated that from the point at which he began observing the incident, it was approximately one minute before he heard one gunshot. He could not state for certain which Of?cer ?red their weapon at this time at which point he went back into the ?Elk?s Clu SSA Hanegraaf ?nally asked WILSON if he would be willing to provide the names of the other four friends that he was With during this incident, at which point he respectfully declined to provide their names. SSA Hanegraaf provided WILSON with a business card and requested that he pass SSA Hanegraai?s contact information to these individuals. For full details, see the transcribed statement attached to this case ?le report. By virtue of this report, exhibit (CD containing digital statement) was acquired. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 18, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Teto Lamont Wilson (TW) INTERVIEWED BY: SSA Lucas Hanegraaf (LH) FBI SA Matt Vogel (MV) REVIEWED BY: LH Okay this is Senior Special Agent Luke Hanegraat of the Minnesota BCA. The date is November 2015. Time is 10:12 hours. Ah along in the room ah with me is Special Agent Matt Vogel of the FBI. We are at 1501 Freeway Boulevard in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota. This?ll be regarding BCA case number 2015?648. Um Mr. Wilson is also in the room. Ah Mr. Wilson could I have your full name and date of birth sir? TW Teto Lamont Wilson. LH Could you spell that for me please? TW Lamont Wilson LH Thank you. And your date of birth sir? TW LH Okay and what?s a good address for you sir? TW 3926 Vincent Avenue North, Minneapolis LH Can you spell the street for me? TW Vincent, LH Okay, thank you. Avenue North? TVV Yes. LH Minneapolis. What zip are you in there? TVV 55411. LH Alright and what?s a good phone number for you sir? TW LH And is that a cell phone? TW Yes. LH Okay. MV (sneezes) excuse me LH Ah Mr. Wilson ah today we?d like to discuss ah with you the incident that occurred on this past Sunday in the early morning hours in Minneapolis. Um an individual was ah shot by the Minneapolis Police Department um you?ve come forward and basically told ah the BCA that you either had knowledge of it or see, saw what happened. Um today I would just like to ask Hanegraaf-2015-648-AO1 Page 1 of 11 E333 LH Hanegraaf?2015-648-A01 you what exactly did you see. Could you start from the beginning as far as before this incident happened and then all the way through and after. And tell, okay as if we didn?t email anything about it Okay a picture. Well, this is what happened. Ah myself and some friends decided to go out on a Saturday evening to the Elks I?m, l?m believing it?s Elks Lodge. Okay. Urn right ah right there on ah James and Plymouth Avenue. Um the night ended there about I would say roughly anywhere from about 12:50 to maybe 1:00, 1 o?clock somewhere, somewhere in that range. I know they turned the lights on meaning you know it?s over it was right, right around 12:50 or whatever. So we were, we were still in there for a few minutes. Um once, once it was ah over. And so myself and my friends we were you know headed towards the exit door. And we walked outside. Right outside the front, the front door of the Elks on ah Plymouth. Um immediately we saw two cops and Mr. Jamar Clark um Jamar Clark was laying on the ground, face down. Head, leaning, running parallel with Plymouth Avenue. His, his body was in the same direction. But head facing east I?m sorry um one cop had a, he was over him with his knee. I believe, I believe it probably was his left knee it appears it was definitely in his back, holding him down. And the other officer was making some really weird type maneuvers on his body. He had, he, he was out and this sort of position pressing down on ah his upper, maybe around his head or upper shoulders. Pressing on to hold him down. And he kept like you know moving himself around almost like you know that?s what made me really pay attention because it didn?t look like normal police, practices to me. So in my mind I was thinking I hope this kid doesn?t get shot. And so I you know I, I still you know was watching, watching this ah police press down. And you know it seemed like he was just kinda like moving, getting himself in some sort of a position. And next thing I know this, this probably went on for maybe, a minute or so. But we were standing there just watching it and the next thing I know the, the gun went off. I can?t say with certainty which cop shot him. If you know if I'm going off of my belief because I saw this other cop with his hands down I would say it was the cop that had his knee in his back. But I can?t, I can?t say with certainty if, if that was the cop, that shot him. Um and I can?t determine whether or not Mr. Clark was handcuffed. But I do know he was in total submission. He wasn't fighting. He wasn?t resisting. He wasn?t kicking. He was, completely laid out. Face down and ab Okay. Um l?m gonna back you up and the only thing I?m gonna do isjust kind of break up the sequences a little bit that I had questions on. Sure. Um Mr. Wilson, so when you describe him laying face down and his head facing parallel, his body is parallel with Plymouth Avenue. Yes. 80 his head would have been facing east? East yes. Okay. And when he?s lying face down um did you hear him say anything? I didn?t hear him say anything. Okay. Can you approximate how far you were away from them at this time when you walked outside the Elks Club? Page 2 of 11 gs Hanegraaf?2015-648-A0?l Oh what would that Plymouth, how wide would Plymouth Avenue be? Maybe, ah I don?t know how wide a street it was 50, 60 feet. You know um Lanes of traffic are 8 1/2 to 9 feet so each lane of traffic should be approximately so a roadway minus the sidewalks should be about 20 feet. Okay. So then if we add in the sidewalk so maybe we?re 30 feet away. Okay. Yeah. And they were, were they on Plymouth Avenue or were they on a sidewalk? No they were, they were I believe they were on the sidewalk. Okay. I believe they were on the side, it was dark outside you know so I was just paying attention to what I was seeing not necessarily you Sure. were they on the grass or you know on the sidewalk but I believe they were on the sidewalk because the next day we went back and um I don?t know if, if the police put a stick in the ground for where it happened at or if some of the protesters put a stick in the ground where it happened at. And it was, it was really close to the sidewalk and the grass. Okay. So, you know it probably, his body more than likely was probably on the sidewalk. Alright. Can you describe the lighting that it was that evening I mean was it just a street lights was there, was There was, there were street lights. Ah the police car I believe it had it's Emergency lights on? his, had his lights on. And then the ah the Elks Club think they had some, some lighting ah on the top of their building also. 80 I could see clear enough to see what was going on with the, with the, with the cops or whatever. Okay. You know I couldn?t see, who actually pulled the gun out and shot but like I said based on the cop that was facing us, the one that was had his hands in, in this position in his body you know in this position you know it didn?t appear to me that he did the shooting. Okay. Was there any, how many officers were there? Did you see. At that time there were only two. Two officers? Just the two officers involved. Okay. That I saw. Alright. Was there more than one squad car or was it just, I only saw one. I, if there was another one I didn?t see it. Okay. Was, was there an ambulance around that area? Again, you know because of the excitement was going Page 3 of11 gags 3535353 5 3E Hanegraaf-2015-648?A01 Sure. I didn?t, I didn?t notice 1 saw a police car. Okay. But I didn?t, you know I, I wanted to pay attention to what I was, what I was seeing so there may have been I, I don?t know. Okay. Alright and that?s okay I appreciate if you say I, you don?t recall that, that?s, that?s absolutely correct thank you. Um were you able to tell how Mr. Clark?s hands were? Were his hands out to the side? Were they underneath him? Did you notice anything? I couldn?t see that. Okay. I couldn?t see that. But you know I do know for certain he was in total submission. Wasn?t moving at all? Wasn?t moving. Okay. He was not moving. The cop that was doing this weird maneuvering he was moving. This kid was not resisting. Hewas not fighting. He was, totally submitted, body still. Um-hm. Body completely still. And I mean I, I could determine that because I can?t remember exactly what colors he had on but they were like lighter colors so I could see, I could see him just, still. Um-hm. And then like I said the, the cop had his knee in his back and the other cop doing his strange maneuvering and like I said it was probably a minute could haVe been less but it eh you know I was watching it for a good while. Ah so, then the shot went off. Okay. How many shots or shot did you hear? One shot. One shot? One shot. Okay. It?s hard to, with a tape recorder understand exactly what you?re, mentioning when, when you say the actions of the one officer with their hands. Yes. 80 if I can just kind of verbalize this if you can tell me if that?s correct so, Mr. Clark is laying on his stomach on the, a part, portion of the roadway, sidewalk, grass. Um at that point that?s irrelevant at this point but he?s on his stomach and one officer has his knee into his back. Do you see that of?cer have their service weapon pointed at him? I couldn?t, I couldn?t see that. Okay. I couldn?t see that. So the one officer has the knee in the back of Mr. Clark. The other officer as you?re kinda describing has his hands are his hands on his back? Yes ah, ah up around his upper body. Page 4 of11 l? g: 3 ?53 LH Hanegraaf?2015-648-AO1 Okay. It was either his head or his upper shoulders upper back area. Okay. I will say you know I go to the and we work out and we call this position kinda like a, a dip. Yep. Yeah we?re going dips. Okay. So his body was in a dip position. Alright so his, his lap area if you will would be facing up? Yes. Okay and then so his hands were on Mr. Clark? Yes. And up, his upper region at that point. Absolutely. Okay. Did you hear any type of verbal um commands from the officers? Did you hear anything verbal come out of Mr. Clark at that time? I didn?t hear Okay. from either one of ?em. They may have been talking but I ah again I think was just so shocked at what I was seeing. Um-hm You know I was just really trying to focus on seeing. I didn?t hear. I didn?t hear Mr. Clark say anything. He may have made comments I don?t know. Okay. I didn?t hear the police making comments. They may have made comments I don?t know. I was just really focusing because I my concern was I?m hoping this kid doesn?t get shot. Um-hm. 80, Okay and then you, had mentioned prior um about the handcuffs. And you, you reiterate that you weren?t sure if you saw handcuffs? I?m not sure Okay. I?m not, I don?t, I don?t know if handcuffs were used or not. But to me it doesn?t matter. Um?hm. It doesn?t matter you know and I think this whole whether he had on handcuffs or not deal is really, being overblown because this kid was totally submitted. It does, it doesn?t matter if he had on handcuffs he was not a threat. He wasn?t fighting. He wasn?t resisting. Okay. Page 5 of 11 LH 35% 3535 Hanegraaf-2015?648?AO?1 So it doesn't in, in my mind you know a lot of people have been asking me oh did he have on handcuffs and I say i don?t know but it doesn?t matter. Um-hm. Cuz he, he was totally, totally submitted. Okay. When you walked out of the Elks Club, Mr. Wilson that is at that point when you saw that transaction occurring Absolutely. Okay. What happened after that shot went off? What happened after that shot off was me and my friends we, we saw it and then we shuffled right back into the Elks. Okay. Because you know I didn?t know if more shot, shots were gonna ring out or whatever. I didn?t want to be caught in any crossfire so we went back into the Elks. Ah we stayed in for maybe, maybe two minutes or whatever and you know I grabbed my friends hand I said you know let?s, let?s leave let?s get outta here. And when we got back outside I mean there literally it was, instant the streets flooded with cops. Um?hm. They had already had up the yellow tape. 1 mean they worked very fast. They had, half the place cordoned off. Cops were standing there some had their guns in hand some had their hands on their gun. You know that was very quick and you know we got nervous so we went back in the Elks again. Stayed there for this maybe three, four minutes and you know I said we just gotta get outta here this is, this is crazy we gotta get outta here. So I grabbed my friends hand and we just, we left we just scattered down the sidewalk and just got in our cars and left. Okay. How many friends were you with or how big was the group that you were with? The friend I was, there was four. Fourofyou? That I was with yeah. Okay. Did they see about, everyone sees things especially when you talk about i, qualify this as a critical incident. This is something that gets your heart rate up. This is something that is not normal activity that a person sees in a day, every day occurrence. Did your friends that you were with or the group that you were with do you believe or think that they saw what happened as well? You know I, I can?t speak for them. Okay. Ah you know, I don?t want to, I don?t want to put them in any you know sort of position I can?t speak to what they saw. Sure. Or you know if they?re even willing to speak about what they saw or what they didn?t see. Okay. You know I?m here to give an account. Ijust l, I can?t, I can?t speak for them. Okay. I, I guess I probably miss phrased that question to you sir. Um they were in a spot where they could have seen what happened? If they were by you? Page6 of11 TW LH LH Hanegraaf?2015-648-A01 (sigh) (inaudible) if that?s an uncomfortable question you don?t have to answer it that?s fine. Um so you?re, just want to go through one more time you heard one shot. You went back into the Elks Club after that. You came back out. Minneapolis police department had arrived and you had gone back. After you left the Elks Club did you just proceed home at that point? Ah we got outta there, proceeded home um my friend she didn?t she had already gotten to her car that?s why she told you she didn?t see it she was there but she didn?t see, at all what happened. And so we got in her car, I had my vehicle parked ah on the next block I think (inaudible) must have been Irving Avenue whatever and went home. Okay. Yeah. Alright. Um have you talked to anybody else about what you told us today? I spoke to WCCO and there was a guy that worked with the Star Tribune we were there um on Sunday with the protesters. Okay. Um and he asked me for a story and that was it. Some guy walked in my shop yesterday for some British tabloid but I just, I wasn?t interested in talking to him so Okay. Um Mr. Wilson how long do you think you were in the Elks Club? From? From the time you got there until the time of closing when you walked out? Oh boy we probably got there, I don?t know maybe 11:30. Yeah. Okay. Yeah maybe 11:30 until it was closing like I said around 12:00 anywhere from like 12:50 to 1:00 or whatever. Alright. And did you um consume any alcoholic beverages while you were in the Elks Club that night? Yeah I had one Heineken. One Heineken? One Heineken. Okay. Alright. Mr. Wilson is there anything that I haven?t asked you or you haven?t told us today that you think would be helpful or pertinent to what happened that evening? Yeah. Um, you know I don?t, I don?t know police procedures and you know when it?s okay to shoot and you know not, but there was nothing that I saw if, if, if this kid if there had a been something going on prior to me getting out and seeing it Um-hm Prior you know before I started seeing what was going on, at the point at which I saw he, there was nothing going on. They had him restrained and ljust don't understand why there was a need to shoot this kid. Particularly in the head when you have him, totally submitted. He was restrained. And ljust, ljust you, you know it?s been bothering me since I, since I saw it you know me being there and knowing that this thing happened a lotta times you know we hear about these police shootings you know going on across the country and then you know you get a little bit skeptical and like you know I wonder you know the person that got shot was really doing something. You know was he submitting. Were, were the cops telling the Page 7 of11 LH 3333333333 TW MV TVV Hanegraaf-2015-648-A01 truth you know partial truth, the whole truth or whatever. You know and so witnessing this kid you know laying on the ground and not fighting and still getting shot, it?s just, it?s just amazing to me. You know and I just, there was nothing he did or was doing that he deserved to be shot in the head for. Okay. And Mr. Wilson ljust want to clarify one thing with you. When you say he's shot in the head did you see him shot, be shot in the head or is that something that you had learned afterwards? Well that?s something that I learned after. Okay. There was one shot. Okay. It was one shot that went off. And so you know he was shot in the head. Okay. Yeah. But like I said I didn?t see the which officer used his weapon to shoot Mr. Clark in the head. Okay. Whether he was even if he was shot in his foot there was no reason you Um-hm that to happen. Okay. Um going back to ask a, a couple questions and, and go back a little bit but I, I fully agree with what you?re saying if you?re gonna shoot someone it?s because, their, you?re authorized to use deadly force. And you don?t shoot someone in the foot like you said because even that could kill someone. Um and that?s why we?re looking into this because we need to, we need to determine whether or not they, did that properly or not. So and I understand from what you were telling me that you got out, he was already on the ground. Did you see, did you see any of what led up i did (inaudible) no. Did you know Jamal Clark? don?t know him at all. Okay. Never met him, never heard of him in my life. Um, you described him as wearing lighter colors? Yeah. I, I can?t remember what (inaudible) Sure. Ah do you remember what the, the officers were wearing? Were they in the same uniform? Were they dressed any differently? I?m assuming yeah (inaudible) the same uniforms. lt darker colors. Okay And so it probably was either blue or black. Page 8 of ?11 MV MV 333 3333333333333 3333333333333 Hanegraaf?2015-648-AO?I Okay. You know but it was, it was dark so I mean I could see their uniforms but I couldn?t you know, dark color uniforms. Okay. Um ljust I know um some of the departments around here they?ll you know the officers will where different stuff you know they?re, during summers some of ?em wear short sleeves some wear long sleeves, might wear a jacket might not wear a jacket. Do you, was there did you notice any difference? I didn?t notice any difference. Okay. I mean ah you know I wasn?t paying attention to what they were I was just paying attention to Sure. were doing. Sure. Um, the so there was an officer with his knee in Jamal Clark?s back. Um?hm. What, what part of the back would you say that was? Maybe his.. Like around, around the neck? Was it around the I would say it was maybe bottom of the back? It?s hard to determine exactly where but I would say probably mid, mid back Okay. And then His upper back. And then the other officer ah I wasn?t completely clear sounded like you described it a little bit but ah was kind of had his back, No he had his hands But his back facing, Okay this is Plymouth Avenue here. Okay. Okay east, west. Uh-huh Okay. Jamar Clark on the ground. Face down, right? I don?t know where his hands were. Sure. You know I don?t know. This cop here, I believe it was his, his left knee had it in his back. Okay. The other cop was facing us. So his body would have been positioned north. Page 9 of?l?l 33333323333535 3% MV TW MV Hanegraaf-2015-648?A01 Okay. (inaudible) on Jamar?s body. So kind of, with his butt on him orjust above him. Yeah, yeah. Okay. And but he had his hands, he had his hands on him pushing, pushing Okay He was pushing on him Uh-huh And he kept, he was like just moving. He kept, and that?s what made me really pay attention. Um-hm. Soto what was going on because itjust didn?t, it didn?t look normal. Cuz he's kind of facing away He's facing away from Jamar's (inaudible) body he?s facing us, directly facing us across the Okay Okay. And he just he, he kept doing it until the shot went off. Okay. Did it seem like um Mr. Wilson that was a when this officer was doing that and you said he was moving around was it, did it look like he was trying to gain position on Mr. Clark or? it?s just it?s a weird position, very weird Um?hm i couldn?t, I can?t determine what he, in my mind it appeared that maybe he was you know and maybe it was just me after a shot went off it appeared that maybe he was trying to provide cover. Um-hm. For the other cop or maybe himself. i don?t know. Okay. ltjust it didn?t We never seen anybody be apprehended like that or you know ah restrained like that. Um?hm. It was, it was totally different and like i said that?s what really caught my attention. You know the way that he was maneuvering. Okaydidn?t because once the shot, once the shot went off I mean it like it alarmed us all and we immediately went right back into ah into the Okay. Page 10 of?li LH MV LH Elks. Okay um and then when you came out Okay I maybe i didn't add this when we came out the first time (inaudible) I looked across the street and you could still see the kids body, laying there. The cops were up at this point. Um-hm. This was after the shot? This was after the shot. Okay. We, when we had went back in. Um-hm. And then we came out like i said it was maybe two minutes or whatever when we thought we were gonna be able to leave the first time. The cops were up. They were up off the ground the body was still just he was laying out and everybody was screaming oh you killed him, you killed him. But his body was laid out flat. The police were not no longer on him. And when we went back in, came out again I couldn?t determine then if the body was, was there or not. I know some people said they you know took him away really fast. I don't know. But I know when we came back out the first time his, he was just laying there. The police were up off the ground he was still laying there like I said everybody else was just screaming and hollering oh you killed him, you know why did, why did you shoot him so on and so forth. Um?hm. Okay. Okay. Alright thank you sir. I?m gonna stop the tape at 10:37 hours. END OF RECORDING. Hanegraaf?2015?648?A01 Page?ltoflt Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/23 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Digitally recorded statement of Kiesha Mona Steele Occurrence From: 11I18l2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/18/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Hanegraaf, Luke (1389 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vogel, Matt (Special Agent I FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11124/2015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Of?ce I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synapsis I On November 18, 2015 SSA Hanegraaf along with SA Vogel (FB )obtained a digitally recorded statement from KIESHA MONA STEELE, D.O.B. tthe intersection of Plymouth and James Ave in Minneapolis MN. By virtue of this report, exhibit 2015-648l23.1 (CD containing digital statement of Kiesha Steele) was acquired. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - Plymouth at?James Ave Primary information Address: Plymouth at James Ave N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412, United States 'suisject #1 Mena._ . Primary Information Subject Name: Steele, Kiesha Mona Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3243 LYNDALE AVE Minneapolis, Minnesota 55412 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address SUBSCRIBER #1 - Clark-,JamarOneaI Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/23 Report Date: 11/20/2015 subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued Primary Information - Continued Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number S_ta? FBI ID 717111FD1 OID 232941 Minnesota State ID Minnesota As Of Date Fictitious NO 0 9w Property #1 - CD Containing digital audio statement of Ki'esha Mona Steele Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11l19/201 5 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 23.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 11I18I2015 00:00 CD Containing digital audio statement of Kiesha Mona Steele Record Status Information. Record Origination Operator: Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/20/2015 14:45 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11I24I2015 15:01 Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO .. Date Supervisor Date Hanegraaf, Luke (1389 I Financial Crimes Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26I2016 Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 On November 18, 2015 SSA Hanegraaf along with SA Vogel of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) obtained a digitally recorded statement from KIESHA MONA STEELE, at the intersection of Plymouth and James Ave in Minneapolis MN. The purpose of this statement is regarding the death investigation of AMAR CLARK on November 15, 2015. The digital statement was later transferred to a Compact Disc (CD) and labeled as exhibit The transcribed statement of the statement is also attached to this case file report for full details. A synopsis of the interview is as follows: STEELE stated that she arrived at 1615 Plymouth Ave later in the evening of November 14, 2015. She stated a barbeque and gathering was occurring at this residence which consisted of herself, her uncle Derrel Gross, her husband Joseph Gipson, Jamar Clark, his girlfriend Rayann, a female named ?Kikki? with her husband ?Al? and a teenager approximately sixteen years old named -from Chaska MN. Steele advised that alcoholic beverages were being consumed and when she arrived; she described CLARK as ?so drunk? at the time she arrived. STEELE advised that ?Kikki? and her husband ?Al? became involved in a physical altercation during the evening at which time ?Al? left the area and the gathering dispersed and everyone went outside to the south side of the building. She indicated that approximately forty five minutes later, an ambulance arrived in front of the building or the north side of the building at which point she and others walked there to see what was transpiring. She stated at this point ambulance personnel exiting the building with Rayann girlfriend) on a stretcher. She said that she observed CLARK approach the ambulance and overheard ambulance staff tell CLARK to ?back off.? She further said she observed CLARK to back away at this time. STEELE indicated at this point the Emergency Medical Service (EMS) commander arrived on the scene and she also observed this person tell CLARK to ?back off.? STEELE told SSA Hanegraaf that when the Minneapolis Police Department arrived shortly after the EMS commander, she observed the two Officer?s place CLARK in handcuffs behind his back. She stated the handcuffs were silver in color at this time. STEELE continued that when Of?cer?s placed handcuffs on CLARK, the EMS cormnander ?swept him (CLARK) off his feet so he was lying on his back.? She next observed the EMS commander with his knee on the chest of CLARK and the two Officers? at the side of CLARK. She described one of the Of?cers as tall with ?big ears? which was on the right side of CLARK and the other as shorter being on the right side of CLARK. She described as the EMS commander have their knee on chest, this EMS commander appeared to be searching CLARK. She next describes hearing a gunshot going off and the EMS commander stand and say ?what the fuck was that?? She described she believed the Officer who ?red was on the left side of CLARK at this time. She indicated that another ambulance arrived at which point the handcuffs were released from the right arm of CLARK as he was being placed in the ambulance however she could still see the handcuffs attached to left arm. Prior to the ambulance leaving at which point she believes the handcuffs were taken off his left arm. SSA Hanegraaf asked STEELE if there was any physical altercation between CLARK and his girlfriend Rayann that evening at which point she stated she never saw CLARK assault Rayann, but that Rayann had ?slammed? face into a door causing his nose and face to bleed which is what the blood inside the hallway was from. SSA Hanegraaf further asked STEELE if she knew why Rayann was going to the hospital at which time she stated SSA Hanegraaf inquired to when the ?rst time CLARK approached the ambulance at which time STEELE stated when they (EMS) were brining Rayann out on the stretcher. SA Vogel asked STEELE to describe what the parties involved in this incident were wearing at which point she stated the EMS commander was wearing a Khaki Shirt with dark pants, The Police Of?cers were wearing blue jackets with dark pants and ?nally that CLARK was wearing a black ?hoodie? and dark blue jeans. SSA Hanegraaf ?nally asked STEELE if she heard any verbal communication between the Of?cer?s and CLARK at which point she stated only when the Of?cer?s arrived she heard them tell CLARK to ?back up sir.? She said she heard no further verbal communication after this point. SSA Hanegraaf relayed the information of other parties who were at this location to BCA Case Agent SA Phill at this time for further follow-up interviews. For full details, see the transcribed statement attached to this case ?le report. By virtue of this report, exhibit (CD containing digital statement) was acquired. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11/18/15 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Kiesha Steele (KS) INTERVIEWED BY: SSA Hanegraaf, Luke (LH) FBI SA Vogel, Matt (MV) REVIEWED BY: LH Okay this is Special Agent Luke Hanegraaf with the Minnesota BCA. This will be regarding case number 2015?648. The date is 11/18 of 2015. Were currently at the intersection of James Avenue and Plymouth Avenue in Minneapolis Minnesota. The time is approximately 1211 hours. Present in the vehicle with SA Hanegraaf is also SA Matt Vogel with the FBI and ah Kiesha. Can you spell your first name please? KS K-I-E. LH KS LH And you middle name mam? KS LH And you last name? KS Steele, LH Okay, and what?s your date of birth mam? Ks LH Okay, and what?s a good address for you? KS 3243 Lyndale Avenue North, Apartment 2. LH Okay and what's the zip in this part of Minneapolis? KS 55412. LH 55412, okay and what?s a good phone number for you mam? Ks LH -and is that a cell phone? KS Yes. LH Okay, all right, um Kiesha the reason were speaking with you today is we understand that you have information that you saw some of the events that occurred on Sunday, this past Sunday with Mr. Clark and the Minneapolis Police Department is that correct? Page 1 of 14 KS LH MV KS Yes. Okay, can you explain mam, what you were doing before this incident happened and just walk us through ah what you saw specifically to yourself on what happened? And start as if we didn't know anything about what had happened that day. Okay, so um before this incident happened, we were in this house right here with a barbeque grills and stuff there. We were in there for a get together for a mutual friend of ours. Um, Jamar was there, his girlfriend was there, me, my husband, and the lady of the house and her husband. We were drinking and hanging out. Um the lady of the house that we were at, her and her husband got into a altercation. And that altercation lead to outside. Her husband left. Everybody dispersed from the get-together. We came outside, we were outside for a good forty?five minutes. Next thing we know, the ambulance pulled up. Now when the ambulance pulled up we came from the back of the town house buildings to the front and we came to the front of the town house buildings. We were standing out there, Jamar was standing out here, and we were trying to see who was going in the ambulance. When the ambulance came, when the ambulance person came out, they brought out Layan and they took her and put her into the ambulance. When they put her in the ambulance, Jamar walked up to the back of the ambulance vehicle and he looked in to see if his girlfriend was okay. When he looked in, the amb?, the paramedics told him to back up. He backed up. By the time they told him to back up, EMS Commander pulled up behind the ambulance. When EMS pulled up, he told him to back off. He backed up. The police came from that way. Just split seconds after the EMS Commander pulled up. They told him to back up. He backed up with his hands up. One Police Officer took his arm, put it behind his back. The other one took his right arm put it behind his back. They put the cuffs on him. The EMS Commander swept him off his feet so he was laying on his back. The next thing you know we hear a gun shot. And we see smoke, and we see blood. And just went crazy, because I?m like, what happened. So the EMS Commanderjumped up and he starts checking his self to make sure he wasn?t wounded and he turned around and through his hands up and he axed the police what the fuck was that, what the fuck was that. When they ambulance, ?nother ambulance pulled up. They picked him up. They released his right arm out of the handcuffs. This arm was still hanging out the ambulance with the cuffs connected to his left arm. They put him in dare. They took the cuffs off and they, he, the ambulance drove away. As we were standing out here after the incident happened, it was a good almost hour before any police had even came up to us to axe the people that were standing out here what happened. All those other people, day don?t even know what happened. It was only five people standing on 1615 porch, that was me, my uncle, my husband, Kiki which the lady that stay right here, and my uncle's son in-law. It was the five of us standing on the porch. Nobody else saw this incident happen but the ?ve of us. Everybody else can say they heard a gunshot, but they not see what we saw. We were the only five witnesses to what happened. So everybody else that's saying that saw this or they heard this or they think this or they thought that, nobody knew what happened but the five of us. So once they took him away, the police blocked everything off. The crowd got belligerent cuz people started Page 2 of 14 coming out after they heard the gun shot. People were at the elks coming out so. The crowd got crazy after the police didn?t say anything they went and talked to everybody else but the, but the one porch that all the eyes that actually saw the incident. They talked to everybody else around us but they didn?t talk to us. So I was waiting for the police to give a statement but they never came to the porch. They told everybody to stand back. I went home. I left. Then I keep getting all these people saying that they saw this, what happened, they saw this, none of those people saw nothing. Were the only people that saw it. The man had on handcuffs, he was laying on his back, and man shot him in his face. I don?t know which officer it was, but one of those police officers shot him. Okay, l?m going to back you up a little bit Kiesha. When you described this uh, before all this occurred, and you were all in gathering in this one place and you said there was, if I remember right, a disturbance, or was somebody arguing? There was somebody arguing but it was not them, it was not the person that um, it was not the, it was not Jamar or Okay. itwas, itwas Rayan? Rayan is the girlfriend. Okay of, of Jamar? Of Jamar. Okay. It was not then that was arguing, it was Al and Kiki, l?m not sure her real name. ljust know here as Kiki. And they were arguing, it was her birthday and she was upset with him so Al right there. It was him and, and her arguing. When they had, they physical altercation, Al and his and his brother left. 80 when Jamar came out to the front, that was after the incident, it was a good forty-five minutes after those two got into it, so the call was not even for them two. The call was for Al and Kiki because they got into a physical altercation. Okay. Not them two. So i don't know why Rayan went to the hospital. And i guess he was just trying to see like where you going all of a sudden. We were just all hanging out and now you going to the hospital. Um-hm. He's trying to axe her what was wrong with her. that?s why he walked up to the back of the, to the ambulance. To axe her what was wrong with her. Okay. Page 3 of 14 make sure she was okay. So when the po?, when the police got called for that disturbance, they was for a whole 'nother altercation. It didn?t even anything to do with those two. Okay. Did Kiki get any um, injuries during that? Um Kiki cut her finger but that?s because she was throwing shit around in, in the apartment. Okay. That?s how she cut her finger. She bust Al mouth open, she didn?t even get no injuries from anything that her and Al got in to it for. Okay. So when Al and Kiki, well Al and his, and his brother? And his brother. And when they left, Jamar and Rayan were still inside? Jamar and Rayan were still inside and she slammed his face against the door. That?s where the blood came from, from him. In the hallway. That?s where the blood came from cuz she slammed his head into the steel door. His mouth and his nose was bleeding. He walked away from her. She went upstairs to the second floor, well I guess her daughter stays on the second floor in this building. She went upstairs to the second floor, we didn?t even see nobody else for like forty-five minutes. Jamar and the rest of us was standing on the deck drinking. Okay. So, when we see the reflection of the ambulance we all came through the house to the front porch to see who was going to the hospital. Um?hm. Cuz we thought at that point they called for Al and Kiki because they got into a altercation. So when it happened, it happened so fast, we couldn?t even believe that he got shot, because we like this altercation wade?, wasn?t even for him. The police call wasn?t even for him. Um-hm. was for them two. 80 when she tried to tell the police, like yawl? was calling because of me and my husband, he told her to step the fuck back. And so when she stepped back, nobody else wanted to get shot so we stood back. Um?hm. Okay, so when you see the ambulance in the back and then you go back out there, Jamar is at the ambulance? The ambulance was right here. Right here? Page 4 of 14 When we saw the ambulance Jamar was standing back, you can?t see from right here, but standing back over here. Its uh, like three stairs to go into, up into the apartment Okay. he was standing right there. He never walked up to the ambulance until they brought her out. And then when they brought her out he walked to the edge of the grass and then he got closer to the ambulance while the ambulance doors was still open, he was axing her baby are you okay. Um-hm. She didn?t say anything. The ambulance man told him to step back and when he stood, when he stepped back the EMS Commander pulled up, and the police pulled up. The EMS Commander told him to step back, he had his hands up, and two police officers came. They put one here one here, and they got him on the ground with the handcuffs on and they shot him. Okay. Did you ever see Jamar assault Rayan at all? At, not at all. Okay. Not at all. When they brought Rayan out was she on a stretcher? She was on a stretcher because she said she fell and hurt her ankle going up the stairs. That?s how she, that?s why she ended up calling the ambulance. Okay. Because she twisted her ankle going up the stairs. All right, so when she comes down and Jamar backs up, the EMS Commander come and then, and then the Minneapolis Police Department arrive, when you see the first point of Jamar and the Minneapolis Police Department um, interact, when they first come together, is what do you hear each other saying? Do you hear anything, any words being The Minneapolis Police said um, back up sir. He backed up. He put his hands up. And it was no other words after that. They put the handcuffs on him and when the got him to the ground, EMS was checking him I guess for weapons or whatever, and as EMS had his knee on his chest, that?s when the gun, the gun went off. And obviously the EMS man didn?t even think that was going to happen because the way he jumped up and searched around and axed them what the fuck was that. Um-hm. That?s why we were all shocked because he was shocked behind him, he thought he had got shot. Page 5 of 14 that person that, that EMS person was that the Commander that said that? That was the Commander, yeah. And he said he had his knee He had his knee on his chest. Okay. This is not like if they come and you got anything that, that could poke or stick Um-hm. he was basically checking him to see if he had on him. And as he was doing his search, that's when the Police Officer shot him. How many Police Officers were there mam? It was only two when that took him down. It was those two Police Officers and the EMS Commander. Okay. That was the only two Police?s When this happened. When this happened. Okay. The other Police came after the incident happened. Um?hm. Okay, did you did you see which officer handcuffed Mr. Clark? First, first let me ask you, where they, where the Police, what, what were the EMS Commander and the Police, what were they wearing? The EMS Commander had on the Kaki um shirt with the dark pants, the Police Officers had on the blue jackets with the dark pants. They were both dressed the samethe two Police Officers? The two Police Officers were dressed the same. One of them had on a hat, and the other one with the big ears, i know him because he came to my house when I got stabbed from somebody that, that was just trying to put out my house a couple weeks ago. I remember him because he call me back, i remember him he?s not the one who, shot the man. He was on the right side of him. This man got shot from his left side. I don?t know they say that the cop is a Asian but i don?t know if he a Asian or not. I don?t know that for a fact. That go the lady I?m talking about right there. The altercation with them and them. But anyway, I don?t know what this Police Officer look like but I know what the guy with the big ears look like because I?ve seen him before. Page 6 of 14 Okay and he?s the one that didn't shoot? He?s the one that didn?t shoot. Okay. It was the other one on the left side, which was the shorter guy, cuz this guy is tall with big ears. This other guy?s kinda' stubby. Did at any point, um mam, did you see Mr. Clark and the two Minneapolis Officers and the EMS Commander, um getting into like a scuffle or were they wrestling or anything like that? Not at all. I?m a tell you this, Jamar was so freaking drink, we were, we were they were drinking before I even came. I, l, I got here around eleven so I had only had one drink and one beer. They were already drinking, he was so drunk, ah he wouldn?t even put up a struggle. That?s how week his body was, cuz they had been drinking all day. Um?hm. So when he see the Police, he saw the ambulance but when see the blue and red lights he instant put his hands up, when he see the Police come from this way. So once he put his hands up, he went straight down, they put the handcuffs on him, the EMS and the Police got him to his back, the man was checking him, and the gun went off. Okay, so the, what your describing is when Mr. Clark is shot he?s on his back? On his back with his hands handcuffed behind his back. Behind his back, okay. They hadn?t already put the cuffs on him. They took him to the ground, just to check him out. Okay. So. I don?t know what else you want me to say They, they had or had not put the handcuffs on him? They put the handcuffs on him and they had him on the ground. Okay. When they took the, those cuffs off him, that?s when they put him in the ambulance, they released one hand, they pick him up with his, with they hands coming through him like thishisjeans. And they put him in the ambulance. And they released this arm and this arm was hanging out of the ambulance like this with the cuffs still attached to his arm. Okay, do you remember Mam, where those handcuffs, were they black or were they silver? They were silver. Page 7 of 14 Silver? Okay. Was there any, you described the EMS Commander basically saying what the fuck was that, was, did the Officer say anything that you heard? He just put his hands up and, it happened so fast he didn't say, when EMS Commander said that the Police didn?t say anything to him. They picked him up and they put him in the ambulance. Okay. There was no word exchanged between the EMS Commander and the two Police Officers. All right, and it?s hard when something like a big event that people are not use to seeing happens, um Kiesha what I?m wondering is this something that happened like within a minute or five minutes when it started? Barely a minute, like I would say thirty seconds. They came, they put the handcuffs on, got him to the ground, boom, the shot came. It was no more than forty seconds. All right. From them putting him in the ambulance, from the gun shot, from arresting him, shooting him, and putting him in the ambulance that was like two and a half minutes. Okay. For the whole incident. All right, and was there only one gun shot or was there more? It was just one gunshot. Just one gunshot. Okay, what was Mr. Clark wearing? He had on, I believe he had on a black hoodie, and some dark blue jeans. How big is Mr. Clark? He, he?s about no more than no more than like 190 pounds. Okay, all right and you said that five people, uh so five including Um?hm. saw this? Yup. Okay, do you know have, has anyone talked to those people? Nope my uncle right there, he wanted yawl to come to talk to everybody. He wanted yawl to come in and talk to the ones that was here, which is Kiki thatjust walked Um-hm. came from that way with that scarf on her Um-hmm. Page 8 of 14 husband thatjust came to this car, my uncle, his son in-law, and um the other guy I don't know his name he was standing in the doorway. Okay. Alright. Has it, have you talked to anyone else about this? Besides us? Just no, with us within our family and immediate friends right here. Okay. How long have you known Mr. Clark? I've known him for at least four years. I?ve been in Minnesota for six years and I've known him for four. Can you describe his character? Can you describe his personality? He's a nice young man, like ah when, when I met him we were in a shelter and he just offered ya know words of encouragement like he was, he was homeless at at one point too. He was tryin? ta get his life together. Last I heard he had just got a job. Working, he was just a nice young man. ljust, I couldn?t recently when ljust started back talkin? to him, I didn?t approve of his relationship with Rayan because she way older than him. Um?hmm. And I'm just was like bro you don't even talking to the, her she old as hell like. How I?m just saying, she was, she?s at least almost thirty years older than him. Okay. So, that's why I?m like that?s a fling or whatever you gonna do, well fuck her basically. Um-hmm. What I told him and he started laughing and we started taking shots like we were playing cards and everything I just was like i ain?t seech you in a mini, he was like well I?m glad yawl out the shelter. He was like yawl, you look happy now. I was like, yeah cause that was just a long stretch being in the shelter. And you know he wanted to see the kids or whatever. I said well we gonna bring ?em out here for a birthday party that?s this weekend and he was gonna go to the birthday party wit us so. Um-hmm. Can you describe, Keisha, the interactions you had with the officer you described with the big ears? Cause you said you had a previous contact with him? He was cool. I had no problems with him. Okay. I believed that other guy, I just can?t see his face. And I know officers don?t always stay with the same officers when they on the beat. Um-hmm. So, I'm not sure if this was the same, the other guy was the same man. But this guy you know well, (inaudible) words on the phone because when was trying ta get Kathy outta my house, I was telling him like this lady said she gonna kill me, she?s gonna stab me. i Page 9 of 14 said you think it?s a joke. I said just wait and you gonna see some drastic shit happen and he was talking about Miss Steele just calm down, he was like you seem like a cool person. He was like I don?t want you to have to go to jail for no bullshit, he was like just calm down we gonna try to figure it out, just give her week you know he was cool. He came to the house twice and then a third time he called me on the phone and the fourth time I seen him was when I walked to the fourth precinct after I got stabbed and made the report against Kathy. Okay. Then he was like I apologize for, for not listening to you when you were trying to tell me you know that this was gonna happen to you. Um-hmm. So, he was a real cool police officer. Not saying that he should be in trouble for what happened but he ain?t the one that pulled the trigger. Um-hmm. Okay. He, he was okay. Alright. Matt, do you have anything? Ah, yeah couple things ya know. One in, it?s not a question I like ta ask but somebodies gonna ask it at some point so we might as well get it out ofthe Um-hmm. on. You said ah, that you and de and everyone really had been, had been drinking and ah, Mr. Clark had been drinking from earlier on in the day. Wha?what was he drinking? I?m not sure, when I came he was drinking a red ox. Which is what? Been Okay. That's when I came. 80 I don?t know what be consumed before I came but like I same I ain't get off work until ten. And I came over here, I made it on this side at eleven o'clock from over south. So. You said you had, you had a drink and a beer. I had a drink and a, I had a shot and a beer. Okay. Um, and then moving forward to police arriving on the scene ah, initially it?s set, it?s if I understood what you were saying and and you know (inaudible) there's a lotto say. So maybe I didn?t understand it, but it sounds like maybe ah, initially he was, he was pretty, he was pretty calm, the police were pretty calm with him if, if not direct, right? Page 10 of14 Yes. So, what happened that, that that changed that calm situation? I?m not sure what happened with the police that changed the calm situation cause he always remained calm. He never resist or nothing. That?s why we were so shock and outraged that it happened the way that it happened? Um?hmm. Because, it was not even ah, a stressful situation. The (inaudible) had just let out. People were out over here because it, it was warm outside. Like it, it was nothing ta hype him up. He was calm. When you, He was just standing there. What did you see and, and then you can eitherjust go back over or or maybes add some detail about how he got from standing up to on the ground. When the police, one took his arm the other one took his arm, put the handcuffs on. The EMS Commander swep him off his feet. That?s how he got on his back. He like, like kick Like, kicked his legs from up under him. Okay. And when he went down, EMS Commander put his right knee on his chest Okay. And he proceeded to check his pockets. when he's on the ground how many, how many people are on top of him Just one. Just the EMS man. The other officer was on his left knee and the other officer was on his right knee. On the left side the officer that was on the left side was on his right knee and the officer on the right side was on his left knee. On Jamar?s, what knees? No. They were on They?re kneeling down. kneeling on the ground. Yeah kneeling on the ground. What are they doing? Page 11 of14 They had him by shirt at this point. By the top of his head he like this to make sure that he he didn?t move or anything while the EMS man was checking him. Okay. And then the gun went off. There was not even a struggle that?s what I?m saying like he ain?t got to pull his gun out. He coulda tased him. You got three options before you even get to your gun. You gotta tase him, you gotta billy club, and you got pepper spray. You coulda used either one of them. You don?t have to use your gun. So both of these police were on, were on their knee they On Mr. Clark? Yeah, they weren?t on top of him. The only question they (inaudible) none of, none of the officers went to the ground. They didn?t go to a ground in a struggle. They went to the ground at the EMS put him on his back. Uh-huh. That's how they got on the ground, they out they can?t stand over him to perform whatever they gonna do. Um-hmm. So they got to they knee with the EMS to check. 80, but so that l, I should ask the question a little more descriptively. Ah, they they were, they were over him, they weren't laying on the ground with him. No, they weren?t laying on the ground with him, they were hovering over him. Okay. And then you describe ya know its, at least first name some of the people that have, that that were with you. That saw all this. Um, and you said that you know they, they were hoping that we?d go in and and talk to everyone. Um, yeah. And I think you know hopefully you, you can see why we like to talk to people individually cause". Yeah. when you got a lot of people telling us these Everybody start get Um?hmm. why I said so. People Page 12 of 14 KS MV KS IVIV KS You know. People say he a lot and ya know Right. it?s easier to talk to people one on one um, can we get the names of all the people that were there that saw what happened? Yeah, Joseph Gipson, which is my husband. (background noiseit?s with a P. Oh, I?m sorry. And you got Kiki. But l?m not sure of h?r whole name, she?s standing right here. Um-hmm. Okay, that?s Kiki. Um, you got Derrell Gross. That's my uncle. I don?t know if I want to give you? because he?s a minor and he doesn?t even (inaudible) Minneapolis no more, he lives in Chaska. Okay. So. So that would round it out. Yeah and then you have the little baby that was standing in the door (inaudible) and his momma. She wasn?t in the door. He was in the doorway. Um-hmm. That?s, that?s ah, the fifth person. I don't know his whole name but he, he?s a baby obviously he (inaudible). Okay. So you got me, my uncle, my husband, Kiki, and then a little baby that was standing in the door and then the teenager. Which, he stays in Chaska. Okay. Um, Keisha, any point did you see when the officers came them draw their firearm? He put, when the police officer get out the car, he had on black gloves. Both of them put their black gloves and when he got out the car, he did not have his firearm out. He got out the car, he had the handcuffs out and they immediately handcuffed him. He not have the gun. i not see no gun. Okay. That?s what lmma saying. I heard a shot. Page 13of14 Um-hmm. i saw smoke and I saw blood. Okay. 80. But the, but where the smoke and blood jump from, that was on the left side of him. The officer with the big ears was on the right side of him. And the commander was on his chest. Okay. Alright. is there anything else ah, Keisha, that we haven?t asked you that you think would be helpful for this so we can put the, the puzzle together? No. Okay. Alright. l?m gonna out. Matt, are you good? Okay, I?m gonna go ahead and shut the tape off at 12:39 hour. END OF Hanegraaf/2015-648-A02 Page 14 of 14 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/24 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary information Description: Re~Canvass Plymouth Ave I Olivia Scott #201 Occurrence From: 11/20/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/20/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Morrissey, Katie (Special Agentl FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Friday, November 20, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Morrissey participated in a canvass of the apartment building located at 1611 Plym0uth Ave. The resident from apartment 201 was interviewed and reported she was sleeping during this event and did not witness anything until after the decedent had been transported from the scene. No items of evidence were obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1611, PLYMOUTH AVE I Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects I Relationship Name io Subject #1 - MENTION IN Scott, Olivia Jerre?Dine Primary Information Subject Name: Scott, Olivia Jerre'Dine Record Type: Person Bio: 21 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE #201, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota No LICENSE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/24 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Record Status information Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/20/2015 16:54 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 13:28 Reporting LEO I Date I - Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide/ Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrat'ive begins on the following-page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 On Friday, NOVember 20, 2015, at about 1100 hours, SA Olson and FBI Agent Morrissey spoke with Olivia Scott, 1611 Plymouth Ave N, apartment 201. This interview was occurring as a part of a re?canvass of scene of the incident. Scott?s second floor apartment has windows that face the scene. Scott told agents she was sleeping during this incident. She reported that she did wake up at some point when the crowd at the scene became loud and agitated, but added she did not see the injured Clark outside. Clark reported she does not know anyone else in the apartment complex as she just moved in, and added that she has not heard of any residents or other neighbors that may have witnessed the incident. SA Olson left a business card with Scott and encouraged her to call if she learned of any witnesses to the incident. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/25 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Re-canvass - 1619 Plymouth Ave I Shalamar Hardnett Occurrence From: 11l20/2015 11:15 Occurrence To: 11l20l201511:15 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Morrissey, Katie (Special Agent! FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23l2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) synopsis On Friday, November 20, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Morrissey interviewed Shalamar Hardnett at this residence located at 1619 Plymouth Ave. Hardnett reported he was not home during this incident and as such did not witness anything related to it. He reported no one else from his residence could provide and witness information. No items of evidence obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 -'1619 PLYMOUTH Primary Information Address: 1619 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshii Nime Telephones E-A ddresses DOB Relationship Number/E-Address INSTALLATION ADDRESS Subject #1 - MENTION IN, 4, Hardnett, ShalamarDimineon, I. Primary Information Subject Name: Hardnett, Shalamar Dimineon Record Type: Person Bio: 36 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1619 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address PHONE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/25 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #1 - MENTION lN REPORT #1 - Hardnett, Shalamar Dimineon - Continued Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO Suspended LICENSE Reoord Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11/20/2015 17:41 11/23/201513:31 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor 7 A Date. OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 22/26/2016 Narrative begins on the MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 On Friday, November 20, 2015, SA Olson and FBI Agent Morrissey spoke with Shalamar Hardnett at his residence. Hardnett told agents he was not home on November 15, 2015, and that no one from his home was a witness to the incident that occurred during the early morning hours. Hardnett said he is unaware of additional witnesses that may have information in a furtherance of this investigation. SA Olson provided Hardnett with a business card and encouraged him to call if he learns of anyone that may be a potential Witness. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/26 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Acquistion of MPD squad video I pole camera capture Occurrence From: 11/20/2015 15:00 Occurrence To: 11/20/2015 15:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: GRANGER, Christopher (Comm I Homicide I Minneapolis Police Department) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 ApprOVed By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Friday, November 20, 2015, SA Olson acquired three video discs containing responding squad data from the event. Additionally, SA Olson received video from a nearby police camera located on Knox Ave North. Items 26.1 (squad video) and 26.2 (pole camera capture) obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 so 5TH ST Primary Information Address: 350 SO 5TH ST #108 Minneapolis City Hall, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Description: Minneapolis Police Department subject MENTION IN REPORT #1 Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Country FBI ID 717111FD1 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/26 Report Date: 11/20/2015 subject PMENTION 1N -_Clark, Jamar Oneal Continued identifications - Continued m: Em County As or Date Fictitious Comment OID 232941 Minnesota NO .-- State ID Minnesota NO Subject #2 - MENTION IN - HAYES, RAYANN FRANCINE Primary Information Subject Name: HAYES, RAYANN FRANCINE Record Type: Person Bio: 41 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Prevent-#17 - 3- QBSf-sphtairiirig Squad 'videe event; ..: Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: 3 containing squad video from event Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Ave NI, pole?camerard'ata Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE I Description: CD video - Knox Ave I pole camera data Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker O?ffi0ers. Koenig, Mark (Sgt. I Minneapolis Police Department) Gerlicher, Scott (Commander! Minneapolis Police Department) Tuma, Jaclyn (Officer! Minneapolis Police Department) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/26 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Record Status information OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/20/2015 17:52 Swanson, Gary (1326 - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/2015 14:09 Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Reporting_;_LEO 7 7 - Date Supervisor Date - OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on' thefo?ilowing page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 On Friday, November 20, 2015, at about 1500 hours, in reSponse to a request from SA Mike Phill, SA Olson arrived at the Minneapolis Police Headquarters for the purpose of picking up all squad video from responding squads and footage from a City of Minneapolis pole camera located near the scene. SA Olson met with Commander Granger at about 1500 hours in his of?ce. SA Olson received three discs from Commander Granger. The discs were reportedly prepared by Sgt. Koenig at the request of Commander Granger and contained all squad footage from responding units. The three discs were later labeled with evidence number 26.1 and turned over to SA Phill (see attached evidence receipt). Additionally, SA Olson received from Commander Granger one single disc reportedly containing video footage from a pole camera near the scene (1600 block of Knox Ave facing north). SA Olson learned the disc was prepared by Jaclyn Tuma (Strategic Information Center) and later provided to Corrnnander Scott Gerlicher who delivered it to Commander Granger. It should be noted that Commander Granger provided SA Olson with a disc labeled ?investigative copy? in addition to a disc in a sealed manila envelope (see MPD supplemental report 15-423384-81). SA Olson labeled this disc as evidence item 26.2 and turned it over to SA Phill (see attached evidence receipt). SA Olson later reviewed the squad and pole camera video and did not note any coverage of the shooting. The pole camera coverage documented responding emergency vehicles ?om the west, but the scene was blocked by a group of residential townhomes on the southeast corner of Plymouth and Knox Ave. The time on the pole camera documents the arrival of emergency vehicles around 0050 hours. While reviewing the squad camera data SA Olson noted video from squad 425 (Of?cer Sworski see MPD supplemental 39). The video from 425 (P76703 disc 1) documented Of?cer Sworski enroute to the call, arriving at the scene, and transporting both of?cer Ringgenberg and Of?cer Schwarze to the 4th Pct. There was audio with the video and SA Olson did not note any dialog between of?cers beyond Of?cer Sworski asking them if they were alright. The time stamp on this video began at about 0050 hours and the video was turned off at about 0054 hours. SA Olson noted video from squad 411 (Of?cer?s Badowich and Shanklin) following the ambulance from the scene (see MPD supplemental ll Of?cer Badowich). The video (P76706 disc 1) starts at about 0050 hours and ends at about 0019 hours. The video depicts squad 411 responding to the scene, arriving on scene, and following the Hennepin County ambulance to Hennepin County Medical Center. SA Olson noted video from squad 410 (Officer Grout). The video from 410 (P76765 - disc 1) starts at about 005 0 and concludes at about 0051 hours. The video shows squad 410 arriving on scene just as the ?rst ambulance containing victim Hayes leaves the scene. The video captures what appears to be a white male paramedic standing just off the roadway (south of Plymouth Ave), but does not show the Clark. The video turns off as the squad pulls past the scene facing east. SA Olson noted a squad (P76733) video showing arrival on scene at about 0053 hours. This squad parked at the intersection of Plymouth Ave at Knox Ave and pointed the dash camera in a northeast direction facing the west parking lot of the Elks Lodge. The video runs continuously until about 0119 hours and captures several pedestrians leaving the lodge and the scene. SA Olson noted a squad (MP Park 0223 9) arriving on scene at about 0053 hours. The dash camera from this squad ran continuously until about 0104 hours and was positioned on the north side of Plymouth Avenue (facing east) near the front of the Elks Lodge. The camera captured many patrons leaving the lodge and persons from the crowd yelling toward responding law enforcement. SA Olson noted a squad (P76657) arriving on scene at about 0054 hours and positioned on the north side of Plymouth Ave facing west. The dash camera captured several patrons leaving the lodge and yelling toward responding law enforcement. The video ran continuously from 0050 until approximately 0115 hours. Additional video submissions were reviewed by SA Olson (42 total videos) that did not appear to include information that was directly relevant in a furtherance of this investigation. End report. Minnesota STATE OF MINNESOTA ureau CriminaI Apprhensio (Rev. 12/02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55195 Bureau No. ILaboratory No. Evidence No EVIDENCE RECEIPT 2,051? ZOI S.W. Lab Name of Person Fro Whom Pr rty is Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained em Quan- No Item Item t. 5 7* - No. No. (mew I I?ll-36A +4 DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES I Cb?; Pk I. Sawscl :29 I CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Datemme Signature Storage Site CHAIN 0F CUSTODY w: Date . Relinquished By Received By Signature I ., . Signature 1 I . (A IgcibI Hwy/35:5 STATE OF MINNESOTA Ps-e-ooao (Rev. 12/02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPFIEHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau 1? iinal Aprehensio Bureau No. I Laboratory No. Evidence No. EVIDENCE RECEIPT image-blag 7.91 Hem S.W. Lab Quan? Nam of Person From Whom Pro erty is Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained No Item "DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES I I . (cg-me mm} 04:55; 5W QWM a Q9 \l CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Date/Time Signature Storage Site CHAIN OF CUSTODY I Date Relinquished By Received By .- 5, Signaturf/?AK re?t? cg/ I ts/ao IMS 1%7?0 Ia?, I Angela Erichson Granger, Christopher From: Sent: Friday, November 20, 2015 3:56 PM To: Olson, Christopher (DPS) Cc: Phill, Charles (DPS) Subject: Data Practices Advisory 11?20?15 BCA Special Agent Chris Olson, These files and or videos are being provided to you un-redacted under MN State Statute Section 13.43, Subd. 15. Dissemination of data to law enforcement and or MN State Statute 13.82 Subd. 15 Public Benefit Data. These files and or videos do or may contain data that is protected under the MN Government Data Practices Act. These files and or videos must be reviewed for any necessary redaction under the MN Government Data Practices Act before any public release of their contents. Reference: The Internal Affairs Unit and Office of Police Conduct Review Files and the Personnel Records provided on today?s date (Training records will be provided later). Commander DeChristopher Granger Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes Investigation Division 350 South 5th Street Room 108 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Of?ce 612?673?2945 DEPARTMENT VALUES: 1 COMMITMENT INTEGRITY TRANSPARENCY Department Goals: Public Safety, Public Trust, Employee Engagement and Morale Confidentiality Notice: This email message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain government data and thereby subject to the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 13; may be subject to attorney-client or work product privilege; may be confidential, privileged, proprietary, or otherwise protected. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any unauthorized review, disclosure, copying, distribution, or use of the contents of this information is prohibited and punishable by law. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please immediately notify the sender by return email and then delete this message from your computer system. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Warning . Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information- Description: Acquisition of Evidence from PD Crime Lab Occurrence From: 11i18l2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/18/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1112312015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) AgencyReferenceNumbers Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab Synopsis On November 18th 2015, SA Phiil received severalitems of evidence and 2 documents from teh PD Crime Lab. Items 2015-6481211 thru 27.19 acquired as evidence. Address?? - Occurred-#1 359 ST. . Primary Information Address: 350 5TH ST, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Subjects Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION LOONSFOOT, Larry (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION PETERSON, Luke (Law Enforcement Of?cial) BUSINESS LOCATION PORRAS, Francisco (Law Enforcement Official) 0 CD BUSINESS LOCATION SAND, Brian (Law Enforcement Official) Male BUSINESS LOCATION SCHANY, Joe (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION Schmidt, Kristina (Law Enforcement Of?cial) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION SEIDL, Jeff (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION ZIMMERMAN, Richard (Law Enforcement Official) Male RELATED BASS, DENNIS NMN (Person) 38 yr. old, Black, Male EMPLOYER HOLTHUSEN, John (Analyst) Male RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB UNIT (BUSINESS) RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE DEPT BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) RELATED BROWN, FERNANDO NMN (Person) 50 yr. old, White, Male RELATED COOPER, RUDOLPH GORDON (Person) 48 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED COX, JOSHUA JOSEPH (Person) 34 yr. old, White, Male MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charies (1385 MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Address #1 -..Occ_urred_ #1 - 350 5TH - Continued Subjects - Continued Relationship Name B_io_ RELATED DODGE, CHARLES (Person) 63 yr. old RELATED FOSTER, ORVILLE REDALE (Person) 51 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED KOBERSTEIN, DAVID BRUCE (Person) 45 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MAXEY, SCOTT DOUGLAS (Person) 51 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MILLER, REGINALD ANTHONY (Person) 55 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED Rowen, P. MNU (Person) RELATED WILLIAMS, HAKIM JAMAL (Person) 42 yr. old, Black, Male Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS 0 EU I I Subject #1 SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg,?Mark Douglas Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvanile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 9?3. EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - . - . . . . . . . . . . . - . . . . - . - - a . .. .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION PhilI, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy - continued. Primary Information - Continued State ID Minnesota NO Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name Big EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subisact. Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications Mme 5.1% Ma?a Pic?Wow; ?gment FBI ID 717111FD1 N0 OID 232941 Minnesota N0 Property #1 - Envelope with?SWabs taken from ?ea-door of HCMC Ambulance #419 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Miscellaneous Swab Description: Envelope with Swabs taken from frea door of HCMC Ambulance #419 Property Status: Pending Lab MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 01?12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #1 - Envelope withfsiivabs'taken from?frea door of Ambulance #419 - Continued Primary Information - Continued Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Disposition: 1 2015-648I27.1 NO YES SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - Fingerprints lifted from rear clear of HCMC Ambulance #419 Primary Information PrOperty Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Disposition: Evidence Latent Prints Fingerprints lifted from rear door of HCMC Ambulance #419 Pending Lab 1 NO YES SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #3 - Smith 8; Wesson 9mm pistol Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Make: Model: Weapon Sub-Type: Firearm Caliber: Firearm Finish: Control Number: Owner: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Disposition: Evidence Weapon - Firearm Smith Wesson 9mm pistol Pending Lab 1 Smith Wesson PISTOL-SEMIAUTOMATIC 9mm Schwarze, Dustin Timothy NO YES SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Page 4 of 12 02/26/2016 13:36 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Pre'perty #4 Smith/8? Wesson 9mm Magazine, Loaded Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Firearm Accessory (CASE, MAGAZINE) Description: Smith Wesson 9mm Magazine, Loaded Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 2 Control Number: Owner: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #5 -?Sig Sauer 9mm Pistol Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Weapon - Firearm Description: Sig Sauer 9mm Pistol Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Weapon Sub-Type: Firearm Caliber: 9mm Firearm Finish: BLUEIBLACK Control Number: Owner: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #5 - Sig Sauer 9mm Magazine, Loaded Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Firearm Accessory (CASE, MAGAZINE) Description: Sig Sauer 9mm Magazine, Loaded Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 2 Control Number: .. . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 5 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #6 - Sig Saluer 9mm Magazine, Loaded - Continued Primary Information - Continued Owner: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Leather Police Duty-Belt Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: MISCELLANEOUS Description: Leather Police Duty Belt Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 201543481271 Owner: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #8 - 9mm Cartridge . Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: MISCELLANEOUS Description: 9mm Cartridge Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #9 - Peerless brand, Hinged silver handcuffs- Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: MISCELLANEOUS Description: Peerless brand, Hinged silver handcuffs Property Status: Pending Lab MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 6 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #9 - Peerlessbran?d, Hinged silver handcuffs - continued . Primary Information - Continued Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 201 5-648127.9 Owner: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Rr?berty #10 EMS MedicaiBa?QI-gr??h. Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Equipment Description: EMS Medical Bag, green Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #11 Ford Key Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Key Description: Ford Key Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 1111 81201 5 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #12 - Large bag containing numerous clothing items Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Clothing MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 7 of12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #12 - Large bag containing numerous clothing items - continued Primary Information - Continued Description: Large bag containing numerous clothing items Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: Owner: Clark, Jamar Oneal UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE #153 - Pink?CUp-a Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: MISCELLANEOUS Description: Pink Cup Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11118/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #14 - Swabs from Jamar Clark's hands Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Miscellaneous Swab Description: Swabs from Jamar Clark's hands Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 11118/2015 Quantity: 2 Control Number: UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 8 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #15 - Surveillance disc from MPD Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Surveillance disc from MPD PrOperty Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11I18I2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: Owner: Clark, Jamar Oneal UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY ANDEVIDENCE Property #16 - Wallet Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: WALLET Description: Wallet Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11I1 81201 5 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648i27.16 Owner: Clark, Jamar Oneal UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #17 - .95 cents in change Primary information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: US Currency Description: .95 cents in change Property Status: BCAI HQ Status Date: 11I18I2015 Quantity: 1 Currency Type: US. DOLLARS Control Number: 201 5-648I27.17 Owner: Clark, Jamar Oneal . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 9 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Property #17, - .95 centsin change Continued Primary Information - Continued Submitted To PES: NO Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #18 --Crime Scene Video; from Crime Lab-Unit Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Crime Scene Video from PD Crime Lab Unit Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/18/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE PD Crime Ita? Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Crime Scene Photos from PD Crime Lab Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information. Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/20/2015 18:03 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 13:33 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 10 of12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/27 Report Date: 11/18/2015 Apprehension) Reporting LEO . . - Date . supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) mafrrative begins on the followingpageja MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page11of12 On November 182h 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill retrieved numerous items of evidence from the Minneapolis Police (MPD) Crime Lab and Property Sections. All items were collected by the MPD Lab at the Of?cer Involved Shooting scene at 1611 Plymouth Av North. SA Phill coordinated with MPD Crime Lab Director, Shannon Johnson on November 16th and 17th to pick up the items on November 1831. Crime Lab Manager Randy Hanson provided the items to SA Phill and most of them were then driven to St Paul Where SA Phill submitted them to the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension?s (BCA) Lab for analysis and testing. SA Phill gave all the items an evidence number in ACISS from 27.1 to 27.19. All items except for 27.10, 27.11, 27.15, 27.16 and 27.19 were received by Carolle David in Lab Intake. Items 10, 11, 15, 16 and 19 were secured by SA Phill in Investigations. STATE OF MINNESOTA anzsota Eureau of Gimme! Apprehension Farm-[Won 7? I 1'9 EVIDENCE RECEIPT (Rev 12102) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST. ST. PAUL. MINNESOTA 55106 V?E?PgratoryNT (555: 5/ I N?me of Egg?an From Whom Prob?? is Obtained- ?em item Item Quan' ?1 No._ In A SL1 f" ?FTurpTase Fer Which Obtained {W/nz? 376? 7 1:73 5 DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES own gun?[35' ir' r514 m0 {jg-l. Iji'?r 3:7 6, IX, 1 14.7" Ix/rt': {57WIT raga-f3 91;: I L- . t: $.71 .7 V- I HA Date/Time Hem I QEETIWTEEI Date I Iva/t ?3 If: I I Ff? CENED I Sign ., v? . (nag. 1" ?7 Iv Li THE Storage Siie I: . . CHAIN OF cusToT? ?37m. N0. By HECDIVBG WWI STATE OF MINNESOTA PS-S-ooao IRev. 12/02; Minnesota DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau of C?iminaI Apprehension EVIDENCE RECEIPT i 0/3 75'1" I _r ?l L, Eurpr i ?am ENE-IL I Lat} I Quark ?Fri: DI Person From {Juli-{cm prope?i?is Obtained Spurp SE FQI, I?thECh [xtzainad m: wade/?i I 5 Inc-7? DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES I 51 In A '3 L. 22(fr?7? limb(will? #357474 Infix/IL?: Ir?, r'I' 1? I I 55:2: .a?vw 2. (I I I was; 57?? If}. .- 1 ?5 .rfh?l?i >Efivfix Grams"? 6 EM 9 k? 2/ TTCERTIFY HAVE RE swig?BEND HOLD MYSELF LISTED ABOVE Date/Erna v? Signazureu ISIoragc? 338 mm - . I CHAIN OF CUSTODY ?em I Date Bu Recawed Ely No. . {11? Signatur?e?? EEQWEIIWI I I I Agchy Case Number 20l5?643 BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55 106 Attn: SA Mike Phili MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Labomtory Number Si 5-14003 TEL: 551-793?2900 TTY: 651?242?6553 FAX: 651-793-2901 LABORATORY ANALYSIS REQUEST COUNTY: Hennepin TELEPHONE: 65l?793~1100 TYPE OF CASE: Officer Involved Shooting/with a Death Report Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Section involved Firearms Latent Prints Nuclear DNA Estimated Due Date 3! 7/20 6 12/163016 3/l 7/2016 CIRCUMSTANCES AND PURPOSE ANALYSIS: Check for DNA and compare Bloodspatter on clothing Check for latent prints and compare Firearm function and comparison Schwarza, Dustin Timothy Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Clark. Jamar Oneal Date OfBlt-th 119;.- 5/3/1991 Sloa- ITEM DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE: Item ft in Container 3 Packaaing and Tyne One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing from Item Source I Descrigtion ??om EMT truck One manila envciope containing evidence classi?ed as latent from EMT truck print iift(s) One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a ?rearm Smith Wesson and magazine One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a magazine ?'om Smith Wesson One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a Sig Sauer ?rearm One manila envelope containing evidence classified as a from Sig Sauer magazine One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as an Duty Belt from Mark Douglas Ringgenbelg item of evidence Fage 1 of2 Submission Receipt for Sl5~l4003 Submission 4 Lab Case 8 1 10 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as from boulevard north of 1611! Plymouth cartridge?) ll One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as an handcu??s item of evidence 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 13 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as an 211;: item of evidence 14 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a Jamar Oneal Clark left and right hand swabbing from Item Submitted By Received Bv 15:47:21 SA Mike Phil] Carolle David Submission Date and Time Page 2 of 2 .. --7 . HENNEPIN COUNTY MEDICAL QENTER CENTER 55415 men Picg?gmhz . PATIENT .7 - A ess:aas7agi;Tlint i an i ii I I Locker/probe: bquf?r Vauim Patient Room .H a: Home P: Poiice (Giro! that appiy) Lowers i3 . esis [socks J, List amounts License stay. I understand that HCMC i less they are pieced in the Vauit. Relationship to Patient: _Date: Patien?Authorized Signature REQUESTED TD MAINTAIN POSSESSION OF Harem? Date: Patient Signature I. - List items taken to Vault BY: . Date: List items received in Vauit by: Date: Items SENT HOME Were taken Date: Patient approval: Witness: Date: UNIT: I HAS mum Mam-930mm unm Date: HCAINURSE HCAINURSE NIT: I HAS mummy mum UNIT: _1 Date: HCNNURSE HCNNURSE NIT: I mm? PATIENT Hurt-Lb 1_ Date: HCAINURSE I HCAINURSE POLICE ITEMS TAKEN BY emce- SQUAD: . Date/ 5 5/ - - ALL. PROPERTYNALUABLES LISTED ABOVE Patient I authorized signature 595/ Relationship to patient: Date:/ 5? I . Staff signature ltitie: Date: Discharge Date: COPY i MEDICAL RECORD COPY MEDICAL RECORD MPD Crime Lab Unit - Chain of Custody CCN: Lg" . Obtained Examiners shall document evidence obfalned from MPO {hat Is not examined not examined next to the item. Date obtained 0 Items obtained from: MPD E. Scene. Other Item description or Property Inventory and line number. Ifdate obtained is different than above note the date next to the item desorption. Items obtained from Other: Items recleved from individuals outside This section shall be the lndivdual Printed Name 6 Arr or Crime Scene for examination. the items to the MPO CLU. afar/r Mltli?/zt, M'sz L- Rev.3 Page of 1? Approved: SHJ 10/06/2014 MPD Crime Lab Unit - Chain of Custody CCN: 15423384 Obtained by: NL Date obtained 1111 5/2015 Examiners shall document evidence obtained from MPD that Is not examined Items obtained from: MFD E, Scene, by maggot Examined next to the Item. Other (see beioW) item description or Property inventory and line number. If date obtained Is di?srent than above note the date next to the item desorption. items obtained from 1 Pistol magazine Ofc. Schwarze (#6422) 2 (2) magazines with live cartridges 3 Pistol with magazine Ofc. Ringgenberg (#6030) 4 (2) magazines with live cartridges i 5 Duty belt and accessories 6 EM A: D00 1611 Plymouth Av 7 EM 3: Handcuffs 'l 8 EM C: Green EMS bag with medioai supplies I 9 EM D: Possible squad key other: Items recieved from individuals outside or Crime Scene for examination. This section shall be completed by the indivdual transferring the Items to the MPD CLU. Printed Name AgencyIUnitlDivision Signature MM 101x12, Chg: Rev.3 Page 2 of Approved;SHJ 10/0812014 MPD Crime Lab Unit - Chain of Custody 3 3 3 Obtained by: ?55? Date obtained 1 1/15 Examiners she]! document evidence obfained from MP1: that is not examined "ems obtained from: MPD 5. Scene, by writing not examined next to the item. Other (see below) Item description or Property 'Enventory and line number. If data obtained is di?erent than above note the date next to the item desorption. Items obtained from 1 LI ?nucioga v/ 0N4 madOther: Items recleved from lndividual?s outside of MPO a or Crime Scene for examination. This section shall be compiatod by the indivdual transfer-fag the items to the MPO CLU. Printed Name Agency/Unitl?ivlsion Signature 7 Rev. 3 Page I of 2? Approved: SHJ 1010612014 ?ipy$4 . o, :rimm . M, z? y. E2 . mfg: ?irt; .1: . "calla . .3 Isi. . 3.1.3.151 urui2:111 . 4 3 1: Ana1:21 . 2 ?an..I. . .: 11.15:; A its. 3311?}. 2.1511. .3 rig-inffigJ. 3. .1. :?Iu ,3 . . . . 715,335.3113123;. v. i!..o.ivfl3.a.l.! #3213..- .6. (itt5i513?uu . Qua/m Egg .2 i. . w?aam .. .. . aqhot?v A - ?Mr? {Zn-w TC) C3 CU ?329 ?Wn ?g 21:: mg g; PJNUMBERI Original 1111612615 MPD PROPERTY INVENTORY 2915 .. 043741 BADGE NUMBER AND pm Pas DATE. we REASON HELD: can: 000251: Badowich. Benjamin o4 11I1612015 09:45 EVIDENCE "1945433334 NAME LAST, FIRST, MIDDLE PE EMPLOY I NUMBER: a) 111262 ROLE CIRCUMSTANCES - (a FM BLOOD JAMAR CLARK 3 :2 "3 ASLT2 BLACK ZIP UP QUELTED JACKET WI BLSI CUT BLACK ZIP UP HOODED SWEATSHIRT 81.3! CUT RED SHIRT WI CUT PAIR OF RED BOXER SHORTS WI BLS PAIR OF BLUE JEANS BELT WI BLS OF BLACK SOCKS WI BLS PAIR OF RED TENNIS SHOES WI BLS Estimated End Of Property Inventory HOLD FOR MAIL a II R: . . Original 1111612015 MPO PROPERTY INVENTORY 2915 . 043764 BADGE NUMBER AND NAME UNIT PCT DATE TIME REASON HELD CON: 000251: Badowich. Benjamin 04 111162015 09:45 EVIDENCE Nip-15423334 NAME (LAST, FIRST. MIDDLE): PE EMF NUMBER Le; '111262 ROLE NBR. CIRCUMSTANCES: FM BLOOD JAMAR CLARK $0332: worm: PINK CUP Estimated Value: End Of Property inventory Pl Original 1111612015 MPD PROPERTY ENVENTORY 2015 .. 943303 NUMBER AND NAME UNIT PCT Pas REASON 003636: Karakostas. Christopher 04 11I1612015 13:16 EVIDENCE ?amawen mom NAME (LAST. FIRST. MIDQLEI ?5 EMPLOYEE NUMBER: 3L5 055559 . a A A ROLE naa CIRCUMSTANCES OFFENSES): ASLTZ CRITEN ENV CNTG BAG W12 ENV CNTG PLASTIC BAG W12 Total Estimated Value: 2.00 End Of Property Inventory a 349399 PENSION 2 Original 1111612015 MPD PROPERTY ENVENTORY Pl 2015 - 043809 BADGE NUMBER AND NAME 004057: Lacy, Steven PCT 04 Fae DATE: 11/162015 TIME: 13:45 REASON HELD CCN: EVIDENCE Mia?15423384 ?qmnen?iom- NAME (LASTTFIRST. MIDDLE): JLE. PE EMPLOYEE NUMBER. 11 1262 ROLE NBR: cmcumsmuces. FM ASLTZ CRITIN VECTIM VIDEO SURVEILLANCE End Of Property inventory FOR ADJUDICATION '3 Original 111161201 5 MPD PROPERTY INVENTORY PE NUMBER: 2015 - 043758 BADGE NUMBER AND NAME UNIT PCT P35 DATE: REASON 000251: Badowlch, Benjamin 1111 512915 99335 EVIDENCE NIP-15423384 FROM: NAME (LAST. FIRST. mums)- PE EMPLOYEE UMBER. 15 g) 111262 ROLE NBR: CIRCUMSTANCES - FM BLOOD JAMAR CLARK "53 015%- VICTIM. ASLT2 QUANTITY OF ROLLING PAPERS WI POSSIBLE BLS End Of Property Inventory ADJUDIGATION MAIL or Identi?er BLACK WALLET CNTG PIECE OF PAPER 8: MN ID JAMAR CLARK WI POSSIBLE BLS Tota! Estima 2.00 PE NUMBER: Original 1111612015 PROPERTY 2015 - 043765 BADGE NUMBER AND NAME. um PCT RECB as were: TIME: REASON HELD 0W 000251: Badowich, Benjamin 1111612015 09:45 EVIDENCE FROM NAME (LAST, FIRST. MIDDLE). PE EMPLO NUMBER: LE 111262 ROLE NBR. CIRCUMSTANCES: FM BLOOD JAMAR CLARK ASLT2 Lina Quantity I #1 1 End Of Property Inventory .n :0 3 MAIL Total Estimated Value: Original 1111612015 MPD PROPERTY INVENTORY Pl NUMBER: 2015 - 043728 names NUMBER AND NAME: 006075: Rodin. Anthony UNIT per 04 856'!) 98.5 was: 1 1116201 5 TIME 09:12 REASON HELD- EVIDENCE CCN: NIP-1 5423384 FROM: NAME (LAST. FIRST. MIDDLE) PE . . NUMBER ROLE NBR: CIRCUMSTANCES. FM LOCKER 48 OFFENSHS): ASLTZ CRIME SCENE ENTRY LOGS CAN or 8: identi?er End Of Property Inventory HOLD ADJUDICATION MAIL s! Total Value: 1 .00 Pl NUMBER: Originai 1111612015 MPD PROPERTY 2015 - 043767 BADGE NUMBER AND NAME: UNIT PCT P85 DATE: REASON HELD. 000251: Badowich. Benjamin 04 09:45 EVIDENCE ?"w?mmeo FROM. NAME (LAST. FIRST, MIDDLE) PE 5MP NUMBER: . 111252 ROLE NBR . I . . FM BLOOD ROOMIJAMAR CLARK 15 VICRM. AS LTZ QUARTERS WI POSSIBLE BLS NICKELS WI POSSIBLE BLS Value: 0.95 End Of Property Inventory HOLD FOR MAIL c: Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/28 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information . Description: Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Backup LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: Acquire damaged MPD pole camera head 14:26 11/20/2015 14:26 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Jacobson, Robert (Sgt. I Minneapolis Police Department) Approved 11123I2015 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis SA Olson acquired a damaged pole camera from Minneapolis Police Department. Item 28.1 received by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 I- 25 37TH AVE NE Primary Information Address: 25 37TH AVE NE, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55421 United States #1 7- Mobil Pro Systems'ca?mera' head ET Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Submitted To PES: Collected Date/Time: Remarks Damaged Electronic equipment Mobil Pro Systems camera head - MP32800 ET HQ 11120/2015 1 YES 14:26 Axis camera head from 75741 (VIN: 5AJLS161XBBOOZS12 - trailer) Record-Status InformatiOn 7 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11/20/201519:03 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 13:35 OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) NarratiVe begins on the following page, MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 2 On Friday, November 20, 2015, at the request of SA Phill, SA Olson received a damage camera (previoust destroyed by protesters after scene investigation) from Minneapolis Sgt. Bob Jacobson (SIC Unit 25 37th Ave NE, Minneapolis, MN). Jacobson reported the camera head was badly damaged and not repairable, but the camera footage from this camera was intact (see BCA supplemental 26). SA Olson later delivered the camera head to SA Phill (see attached evidence receipt). End report. STATE OF MINNESOTA Minnesota Ps-a-ooso (Rev. 12/02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST, PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau of Criminaf Aprehension Bureau No. Laboratory No. Evidenca No. EVIDENCE RECEIPT ?em l[fab Guam Name of Person From Whom Property is Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained No. No. :in DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES Pry MM MUS-1800 AR M10 bk? I i CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELRRESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Mia Date/Time Signature Storage Site CHAIN 0F CUSTODY lofte 4? ?Helfnquished By A A. 4 Received 83/, s- .9 232$? SignKW I I, - C?m?w Hazy/5? IZCI VIZ-CG ?1 I I: I LI Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/29 Report Date: 11/20/2015 warning . Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information . Description: Examination of HCMC Ambulance #419 and Video Occurrence From: 11/20/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/20/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KATZOVITZ, Michael (SRO - Crime Scene] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/16/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference'Numbers Agency Case/File Number MN BCA Lab 815-14003 Synopsis On Friday, November 20th 2015, SAs Phill and Katzovitz examined HCMC Ambulance #419 for the purpose of documenting the reversal of left and right sides on the rear camera recording submitted as evidence in report Evidence items (Hard Drive) and 29.2 (CD documenting camera reversal) submitted as evidence with this report. Adaress #13? occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Address - RELATED #1 - 1611' PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects RelationshiE Name I Bio A Subject - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information 03 Exempt From Disclosure: YES MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/25/2016 13:36 Page 1 015 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/29 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark- Douglas - Continued Primary Information - Continued Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name w. EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #2 - sueaecr #2 DustinTimchy . Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/29 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 -?Clark, Jamar Oneal 4- Continued Personal Information - Continued Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications Malia t? State: County As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 No OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Property #1 - Panasonic SSD Hard Drive Cartridge- Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Computer Storage Media Device Description: Panasonic SSD Hard Drive Cartridge Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11l20l2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: Serial No: nbA00819 UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - DVD containing video and photos of HCMC Ambulance #419 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD containing video and photos of HCMC Ambulance #419 Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11l20l2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES DISposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE ReCord Status Information . Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11l20l2015 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/29 Report Date: 11/20/2015 R?pdrd Status Information - Continued Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/16/201513z30 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) i. Narrative begins. qr; the fouowingpag??. . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On Friday, November 20th 2015, Special Agents (SA) Phill and Katzovitz examined Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Ambulance #419. HCMC Paramedic (EMT) Sam Erickson drove the ambulance to the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension?s (BCA) Crime Scene Garage at about 10am. SA Katzovitz documented through Video and photography the manner in which the rear facing camera on the ambulance plays and records with left and right reversed. This is done for the purpose of backing up and rear view safety. In this manner, while looking at the camera while backing, the EMT driver will see the true direction a person or vehicle is moving behind them. SA Katzovitz produced a DVD containing all video and pictures he produced. In addition, SA Phill obtained the Panasonic hard drive containing the video from November 15th 2015 at 1611 Plymouth Av in Minneapolis. This was the scene of Jamar Clark?s arrest and fatal police shooting. The hard drive was imaged in the BCA Digital Forensics lab to preserve a copy of its contents. The actual Hard Drive was given ACISS evidence number 2015 ?648/29.1 and the DVD from SA Katzovitz was given item number The only camera from both ambulances that shows anything of value is from #419?s rear, backup camera. The time is not correct on the cameras but they can be used to log the activities of those recorded. 0 At 6:42.10, Jamar Clark approaches the rear ambulance doors and begins knocking on them and attempting to open them. 0 At 6:47.30, EMS Deputy Chief Trullinger arrives after receiving a help call from the crew of #419. He begins to talk to Clark and calls for police assistance. At 6:49.10, Of?cers Ringgenberg and Schwarze approach Clark. At 6:49.30, Clark is taken down by the of?cers. At 6:49.51, Ofc Ringgenberg can be seen struggling to get up from the ground. At 6:50.14, Ofc Ringgenberg gets up and his holster can be seen pulled to the rear of his back, he calls for backup. 0 At 6:50.53, Ambulance #419 leaves the scene to transport Hayes to North Memorial Hospital. Nothing could be observed on the recording regarding handcuffs or the shot ?red by Ofc. Schwarze. EMT Erickson signed a Consent to Search form and received a BCA Evidence receipt for the Hard Drive. EMT ambulance #419 was then released to EMT Erickson. STATE OF MINNESOTA (Rev 12/02) Mirna-ate DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1:330 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL. MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau ofCrImInalADDrahension I I {Labormw NO . EVidence ND. Wu EVIDENCE RECEIPT 19(7) "a L/g/ If. 9,3; "em SW 'Lab Guam Name of Ferscn From Property is Obtained 1:77:34 Far Obza'med I No. :ng my - y: gum-?745? f? f, ?5 r/V' {7.1 DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES IV. 2:32 IV. LU -- ?in, JV I Air("ilk-H I -21 if; I CERTIFY THAT RECEIVED AND RESPONSIBLE THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE ?a Signafrre I I. a ESIara?gxla CHAIN 0F CUSTODY i I WI :85 Date I Relinqus?sned Received By Signaturei Signature A - i a I MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension 1246 University Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55104-4197 Phone: 651.642.0610 FAX: 651.642.0618 TTY: 651.282.6555 Internet: CONSENT TO SEARCH I, $51" ?7 I A, (- HAVING BEEN INFORMED OF MY CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT NOT TO HAVE A SEARCH MADE OF THE PREMISES OR VEHICLE HEREIN DESCRIBED WITHOUT A SEARCH WARRANT AND OF MY RIGHT TO REFUSE TO CONSENT TO SUCH A SEARCH, HEREBY AUTHORIZE I-THE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY, AND I OR ANY OTHER DULY APPOINTED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CONDUCT A COMPLETE SEARCH OF THE PREMISES OR VEHICLE UNDER MY CONTROL DESCRIBED AS I (9. - ,v gnJ/V-n I .- 2 C- li eff.) I UNDERSTAND THAT CONSENT CAN BE WITHDRAWN AT ANY TIME. THIS WRITTEN PERMISSION IS GIVEN BY ME VOLUNTARILY. I HAVE NOT BEEN THREATENED NOR HAVE ANY PROMISES OF CONSIDERATION OR REWARD BEEN MADE TO ME. i HAVE READ THIS DOCUMENT AND FULLY UNDERSTAND CONTENTS. (SIGNEDVVITNESSESZ (SIGNED) (DATE) (SIGNED) (DATE) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/30 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information - - - .- Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/22/2015 Approved By: HCMC Property Sheet for Admit of Clark Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 14:49 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/22/201515:26 Apprehension) Raporting LEO - Date) Supervisor: Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Narrative begins on) the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 2 On Wednesday, November 18th SA Phill obtained several items of evidence from Minneapolis Police Crime Lab and Property Section. One of their pieces of evidence was a copy of the HCMC property log taken during Jamar Clark?s admission. That property sheet has been attached to the case ?le as a document via this report. It has not been labeled evidence in ACISS. a, . . wan-?mn-r-mgr?, unmw . COUNTY MEDICALC-ENTER I LEVEL 1 TRAUMA li??li: Iii-22138. i DOB: 11?151199?.? ?25 V's) . 't'd . a? . PATIENT VALQABLES 2715379435 cell: ammun??g?t l, Property/valeebles checkee in by: Lem Date: 1 . 35451-1: bin-VF Vault Patient Room Home Paiice (Circle all that apply) [3 Lowers . List amounts License 3 Relationship to Patient Date: - - Patientmuthorized Signature PATIENT REQUESTED To MAINTAIN POSSESSION OF PROFEWL Date: Patient Signature List items taken to Vault BY: Date: kw" List items received in Vault by: I Date: a Items SENT HOME were taken by. Relationship: Date: Patient approval: Witness: Date: RE. . UNIT: I HASTRANSFERRED PATIENT PROPERTYTO unm I Date: HCAINURSE HCAINURSE NIT: HASTRANSFERRED mum momw Hun-w Date: HCAINURSE HGAJNURSE NET: I answers WPROPERTYTO 1mm Date: MM HCNNURSE I HGAINURSE POLICE ITEMS TAKEN evomce Date/I 5 I mm; REC . ALL PROPERTYNALUABLES LISTED ABOVE .12: I (?Relationship to . Staff signature liitle: Date: Discharge Date: COPY MEDICAL RECORD COPY ll MEDICAL RECORD -J Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/31 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/22/2015 Approved By: PD Crime Scene Log Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information. Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/22/201516:32 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/22/2015 16:37 Apprehension) Reporting Date . Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Narrative begins on the folloviring page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of2 On November 18th 2015, SA Phill retrieved numerous items of evidence from the PD Crime Lab and Property Room. One of those items was the crime scene log from November 15th 2015 at 1611 Plymouth Av N. A copy of that log has been attached to the case ?le via this report. It is not an item of evidence in ACISS. 79% V. 43,24?pay? Ease?tS??R'Sg?i ILocation: (g1! In?ag/lr/?H so I are approximate and are acco ng to logging r's watch. COMPLETED BY: 607 NIP-9011 (1l05) - 'w ?Inna:ng ?34:1? i? '56ham. [Ease #:33?3 Lfk33ftf lLocation: {?le highmag ?L?MIDaiei/f/*Times are approximate and are recorded according to to o'ffiCer's watch. COMPLETED BY: Qw?m 60 7 NIP-901 1 (1105) E431 .. I I w?i?m 33:531. Lease {Locatiom?u WM mate: ?it/1h? I ('33 *Times are approximate and are recorded according to the iogging of?cer's watch. COMPLETED BY: 63d? Q07 f? (1105) ?mum?z? -- - LCase ($518361 ILocation: MW mate: 7 4 are approximate and are recorded according to the Jogging officer's watch. 0MPLETED BY: o?m ?90 Mil-9011 (1105) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/32 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Interview of Felisha Burns Occurrence From: 11/17/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/17/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agentl FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis, On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, SA Phill and FBI SA Kane interviewed Felisha Burns. Burns was leaving the Elks Club on November 15th and said she saw the arrest and shooting of Jamar Clark. Evidence item a CD of the audio from the interview was acquired with this report. Address #1 Occurred #1 - 6645 HUMBOLDT AVE Primary Information Address: 6645 HUMBOLDT AVE Brooklyn Center Police Department, Brooklyn Center, Minnesota 55430 United States Description: Brooklyn Center Police Department Subjects Relationship Name BIO BUSINESS LOCATION Brooklyn Center Police Department (ORGANIZATION) Telephones E-Addresses Relationship NumberlE?Address BILLING AND (763) 569-3333 (BUSINESS) INSTALLATION ADDRESS Address #2 RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshi? Name Bio subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Burns,,Felisha Rolshel Primary Information Subject Name: Burns, Felisha Rolshel . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/32 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Burns, Felisha Rolshel - Continued . i Primary information - Continued Record Type: Person Bio: 41 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 2219 MARSHALL ST NE, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55418 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Relationship Number/E-Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications Number State DRIVERS Minnesota United States 1111712015 NO LICENSE Sindee-#2. .-- . R'inieseribergiMark- Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name Big EMPLOYER Subject #3 SchWarZe, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer JuvenileMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 6 Minnesota BUreau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/32 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #3 - Sued #2 - Schwarze,DuetinQJIimethy - Continued 5; Subjects Relationship EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number State Country FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota N0 State ID Minnesota N0 Property #1 DVD Containing Audio of Felisha Burns lntervie Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD Containing Audio of Felisha Burns Interview Property Status: BCA 1 HQ Status Date: 11l24l2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648l32.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/32 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Property #1 - DVD Containing Audio of Felisha Burns Interview - Continued Primary Information - Continued Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record. Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11l22/201516z53 11l30l201518z43 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO 1 Date - Supervisor . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 6 On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill and FBI SA Kane interviewed Felisha Burns at the Brooklyn Center Police Department. Burns said that she witnessed some of the Officer Involved Shooting on November 15th in Minneapolis. Burns was at the Elks Club on Plymouth Av across the street from 1611 Plymouth. The interview was digitally recorded and burned to a CD for evidence. The CD was preserved as ACISS item The following is only a summary of Burns? interview. The complete interview was transcribed by Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) Communications staff. For a full account of what was said, please refer to the attached transcription. Burns said she was leaving the Elks early on the 15th and saw the police across the street on top of a man. She described the man as being restrained and said that one of the of?cers was maneuvering the man around for some unknown reason, but then suddenly, she heard a ?Boom? and realized that the of?cer shot the man. Burns was very astonished to realize the police shot the man who appeared not to be ?ghting. Burns said she did not hear the man or the of?cers say anything before or right after the gunshot. Burns said the man was not ?ghting or struggling with the of?cers as far as she could see. She acknowledged not seeing the incident that led up to the shooting; only once the of?cers had the man restrained on the ground. Then she heard a shot. Burns said the of?cer with the light blue shirt on shot the man as opposed to the other one with dark blue top and dark pants. Burns did not see the of?cer with the dark top with his gun out, but the one in light blue was acting very bold and showing people his gun in his hands. Burns said he did not point it at anyone but he seemed to want to show people so they did not bother him. Then when more police cars showed up, he became bolder. Burns said she saw the injured man wearing handcuffs after they shot him. Then someone took them off but she could not remember which of?cer removed the handcuffs. Burns said that the ambulance paramedics did not treat the man right away. She doesn?t know if a paramedic took off the cuffs but she does know that the man lay there after being shot for quite a while. Burns said that she was leaving the Elks with her friends, Danny and Shawn Braylock. Burns said that Danny recorded most of the incident on his cell phone video recorder. She saw that he posted it on his Facebook page and she copied it to her own page. Burns said the video accurately depicted what she saw on the 15th across from the Elks. Burns remembered that reSponding officers were acting very rudely and ordering patrols from the Elks to leave the area. One of them was spraying them all with a large pepper spray can. She also saw that of?cer trying to take a cell phone from someone recording the scene. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 17, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Felisha Burns (FB) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael Phill (MP) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: On November 17th 2015, SA Michael Phill and FBI Kevin Kane interviewed Felisha Burns at the Brooklyn Center Police Department. This was for BCA Case# 2015-648, regarding the November 15th PD OIS on Plymouth Av. MP It is presently 9:57 A.M., Tuesday, November 2015. Special Agent Michael Phiil with the Minnesota BCA along with Special Agent Kevin Kane with the FBI. We are working on BCA case number 2015-648. We are meeting with Felisha at the, what?s your last name Felisha? FB Burns. MP Felisha Burns at the Brooklyn Center Police Department in reference to a Minneapolis officer involved shooting. First Felisha can I get your full first name? FB Felisha. MP The spelling of it please. FB MP Do you have a middle? FB MP And Burns. FB Burns, B-U-R-N-S MP What is your date of birth? Fa MP What?s a good address for you? F8 2219 Marshal Street Northeast. MP Marsha? FB Marshal. MP Marshal, okay. Street Northeast. FB Yes, Unit 5, Minneapolis 55418. MP 55418, and a good contact number for you? FB MP Okay. Do you mind if I refer to you as Felisha in this interview? Phill-2015-648-A12 Page 1 of 15 Phill?ZO?l 5-648-A12 That?s fine. Okay. Now you were at the Elks Club in Minneapolis the night of Saturday, November 14th into Sunday, November Right. And it happened that you were outside when you saw, some an ambulance there and some police action correct? Correct. Can you go ahead and tell me what happened, what brought you outside the club and what you saw from there? We were leaving the club. Okay. And directly across, soon as you walk out the door there was these townhomes. I saw an ambulance and I saw a patrol car. Or I saw two police officers on top of this man. - Okay. They had him restrained. He was like face down on the ground. But at first you couldn?t see if he had on cuffs because how the officers were on top of him. So you couldn?t see that. So how would you describe that on top of him? Well (sigh) he?s laying flat on the ground. One officer on top of him the other officer on top of that one. Okay so And they?re like restraining him. But he was already restrained but you couldn?t hear he wasn?t yelling, he wasn?t screaming he was, he was just laying there. Ah flat on his front, side or back? would say more on his side. Okay. So he's laying on his side. And More on Clark Yes. we Correct. 80 Mr. Clark?s laying on his, side you think. Right side? I think it was the right side. Is it the right side orface down I can?t remember. Okay. I just, know he was down. He was down. And the officers were on top of him? And they?re on top of him. They had him restrained. Okay. Page 2 of 15 Phill-2015-648?A12 And um, but like I said at that time you could not see if he had on cuffs. I couldn?t see that because you have two people on top of this man. 80, but you could see the officer that's on top maneuvering him around. Okay. And everyone?s watching. Everyone?s saying why are they on him like that. And just pick him up and put him in the car. Next thing you know he?s like still maneuvering him around and then we heard this boom. And it got silent for like a second (inaudible) like a half a second. And everybody was just silent. And the next thing you know it was just, loud. What do you mean? Everybody started screaming, crying, yelling you just shot this man. And then when they got off of him you could tell that he was cuffed. You could see it. Um-hm. When they got off a him he was cuffed and then they un?cuffed him. Hm-hm And I?m sitting there and I?m watching this like but I?m more like you just shot this man. Um-hm. And I?m like yelling like, you just this guy why did you shoot him. And it was just I don?t know next thing it was just, it was just, it seemed like it was a riot. The police officer that shot him he came out, he had his gun like came they were like kinda at the curb. But then he comes out to the street and he um you know he had his gun but he never came close to us yet, til his backup came. Um-hm. When his backup came, the paramedic was in the ambulance from what I saw. He jumped out of the ambulance, I don?t know know is that theyjumped out the ambulance and ran around like what just happened. And then the other police officer stood on the sidewalk, the other one came out in the street. When the backup came that?s when he really got bold, with everybody. He had his gun out. Next thing you know they had the pepper spray and they started pepper spraying people and then they?re all coming over the police officers are all coming over to the side where the Elks Um-hm Telling people get the outta here and trying to snatch cell phones. And it was just it was just too much. Hm But everyone?s so angry because we?re just like you know in disbelief like you just shot this man. Why did you shoot him. Why did they, I don?t, I see now I?m gonna start crying again I?m just Yeah, I understand it?s an emotional (inaudible) It?s like why did you just shoot this man. Why. You restrained him, he was already restrained. So I don?t know what happened priorto I wasn?t there. ljust know what happened at the end. I don?t know. Um-hm. But it, it?s not, it wasn?t called for. Okay. Page 3 of 15 Phill?2015-648?A12 They shouldn?t a shot him. Alright so backing up a little bit. You said that one of the officers got wasn't, pointing at everybody was he? He just basicain like had it, it was still out but I think it was more like he had it out for his protection. Okay. So he had it visible for everybody to see? He, we saw it. Yeah and And I think it was more for like, (sigh) i don?t know if it was for his protection or if we would interpret it as okay you can get it too. Hm You know what I mean? (inaudible) So I don't know what (inaudible) But he didn?t say much until backup got there? Right. Then they started to say (inaudible) That?s when he got bold. disperse Right that?s when he got real bold when his backup came. Okay. Now backing up now to the struggle do you remember an ambulance being there? I did. What did the ambulance do once the struggle and the shot happened, what happened to the ambulance? The paramedic he jumped out. No one was attending to him. For a while he was just laying there. Like he was just a nobody. Okay. He was just laying there. But then, um I don?t remember as far as because I was so you know I was just crying and when I look at other videos online I see that the paramedics did come over. Um?hm. And they were bent over, it was one paramedic and he was bent over, he or she, you could see it on the video. Okay. But I did not see that myself because i wasjust out of it. So I can?t tell you yes I saw it I, I did not see that I saw it on the video. Okay. So,yeah. Alright. And you said that after you heard the boom and it was silence and as the officers got up you saw that Mr. Clark was handcuffed on the ground? Page 4 of 15 Phill?2015-648?A12 Yes. You could see that. You could see cuz and did you say handcuffed in front or back? His back. 80 hands behind his back? Yes you could see that. Do you remember if the handcuffs were shiny or black? Like silver or black? I don?t know. Okay. I just know he was handcuffed. Alright and then you said someone took ?em off? Somebody took ?em off. And did you They took them off. did that? Which I one who It up with the gun or? I don?t know. Don?t know? I just know they took ?em off. But he did have ?em on. They were on. Now when the paramedic came to help did they take ?em off at that point? I don?t (inaudible) by the video from what I?m looking at on the video I don?t, you really I don?t know. i don?t know but they did take, they took them handcuffs off. He had those handcuffs on. Okay. They were on. We could, anybody could see that. There?s so much lighting in that area you could see those handcuffs were on him. Okay. But I don?t know who, I don?t know if it was a paramedic I don't know who took ?em off. Okay. But they took those handcuffs off (inaudible) well he didn?t have handcuffs on, yes he did. Okay. And then ah as far as the struggle that was going on. You said Mr. Clark you never heard him say anything? No. Did you see him fighting? Page 5 of 15 Phill-2015?648?A12 No. (inaudible) before this shot. We Any fighting at all from his side? No. He was on the ground. When we came out the club he was on the ground. Okay. We don?t like I said I don?t know what happened before. They said he was arguing or whatever with the ambulance, I don?t know I wasn?t there I didn?t see that. just know what I saw when I came out and he was already on the ground. He was already restrained. There was two police officers on him. That?s what I saw. Okay. You saw them on him I saw them on him. And a struggle and then (inaudible) It was not a, it wasn't a struggle. Oh I thought you said it was they were struggling on top of him. No the police officer was maneuvering like he was trying to position him and then Okay. him. Alright so maneuvering, what do you mean by maneuvering? Like he was moving him around trying to I don?t know from what I saw it was like he was maneuvering him around and then I don?t know if he was trying to get a position of where to shoot him but then he shot him. But don?t know, but we didn?t know where he shot him we just heard, the shot. Okay. But he was like maneuvering him like moving him around. Okay. Like and then he shot him. Alright. So I don?t know, I to this day I still don?t know why that man got shot. I don?t know. Well that?s, that?s what I?m trying to find out. You hear it on the TV but you don?t know what?s true. Yeah (inaudible) One minute they say he?s gone the next minute they say he?s on life support. I don?t know. I just know what I saw. Yeah and that?s why we?re wanting to talk to you. Okay. To find out what you saw. We get enough pieces of what everybody Right. then we can get to the truth. Page 6 of 15 Phill-2015-648-A12 Right. Um now you said you, we were leaving the club. Um-hm. Um can you tell me who you were with and are they willing to talk? Well Danny Braylock is one and his wife Shawn cuz we all went out together for Okay. went out together and when we were leaving it was us three and we all came out at the same time and we all saw this. Danny started recording. And that was it and I had spoke to Danny I called Danny and I said I?m going to talk to the BCA, would you like to join me. And he told me he would but something with his daughter, I?ll call you by 9:00, let you know. 1 said ifl don?t answer the phone leave me a voicemail I?ll come get you. That's why I never text you because I never got a response back. Understand. Well hopefully he?ll get back to you today sometime. We?ll see. And then I?ll give him your number. Yeah. Yeah. Ah do you have that video presently you could show us? Yeah I can show you. And is it on a public web, Facebook page or? (inaudible) Facebook, yeah. Okay. Um, Do you remember the police saying anything when they were on top of him? No. Just kind of like a blur that was going on? You (inaudible) You didn?t hear anyone, you didn?t hear anyone say anything you just saw them on the ground. You didn't hear nothing. You heard the gunshot but you didn?t hear nothing from him. He wasn?t cursing he wasn't yelling he was nothing he was just on the ground. Were the police saying anything to the person on the ground? No. Were they talking to each other at all about what was going on? Not that I could hear I couldn?t hear that, no. (pause) hm okay so let?s see (playing video) Now this is (inaudible) he?s already been shot. Okay. Yeah he?s already been shot. (video playing) Danny started recording after the shot then? Well he thought he was recording when we came out when we saw him on the ground. Page Tof15 MP Yeah. FB But I don?t know what happened with the phone but (video still playing) as you can see there?s no paramedics right now. MP (inaudible) FB But then he?s, and its he was coming out he?s gonna come out. (video still playing) MP (inaudible) FB See that. (video still playing) (inaudible) the police backup MP And there?s a (inaudible) FB Right there that?s. .. MP (inaudible) FB paramedic yeah. MP Okay. (video still playing) FB You can see the paramedic right there attending, well he?s standing with him. (video still playing) MP And so that?s another (inaudible) tending to (inaudible) down there. (video still playing) MP (inaudible) FB Um-hm. (video still playing) MP Okay so a lot of police arrive, did you get, you can stop it did you get ah (inaudible) also you said of the police trying to take peoples cell phones? FB I wasn?t recording. MP No did you, did do you know if Danny (inaudible) FB No I don?t know if Dan, no I didn?t see it on his. MP Okay. FB 80 I don?t know but I know Danny recorded and then other people recorded. A lot of people were saying that they seen it on other peoples but they?re not friends of mine so I can?t see what they see. MP Okay. FB So MP But you personally do you, I know you were very upset I can hear it. Did you remember seeing the police trying to take cell phones? FB I saw, one police officer he had a can it was pepper spray I never seen this before in my life. It was like a, cuz I?m used to pepper spray you know a little small one. MP (inaudible) FB But this one that I saw was a can and then it had like a, a plastic shield around it. MP Okay so (inaudible) Phill~2015-648-A12 Page 8 of 15 Phill-2015-648-A12 A plastic, I don?t know like a covering around it. I?ve never seen it before. (inaudible) So like if you spray it out it don?t come back at them it hits everybody. Okay. And I guess that?s what they use and then when he was spraying it he tried to reach out and snatch a cell phone. It?s like he had it in one hand and then had the other hand open snatch, so like let me blind you and then take your phone. That?s what I saw. Okay. 80 Danny did not record that. Cuz I?m thinking like maybe we?re all like trying to get back. We see this pepper spray and they?re spraying people. Um?hm. They?re like really like get the outta here and they came and tapped on my car window to see if I was on the phone. But I had my blue tooth so my phone was actually in the compartment part. Um-hm. And I?m talking to my niece and l?m telling my niece what?s going on. And so he was like pounding on my window like get the outta here and, looking through the window like what is she doing and I?m like are, really. But at the same time I?m still crying like I can?t believe this just happened. Um-hm. How you people just killed, this or shot this man. Not killed cuz i don?t know if he?s dead. Um-hm. I just know he?s laying there but you would assume he?s dead because it?s It didn?t look good? Not at all. Now you were in your own car when you left and not with Danny and Shawn? No they rode with me. (inaudible) Um-hm. So you all drove together? Um?hm. Okay. Alright ah are you able to send me that video? If I give you my card can you send it to me. I don?t have Facebook and I?m sure somebody at the BCA does but it?d be nice ifl could get it just sent to me. You gotta have Facebook, no. I?ll yeah I think I mean, what do I need, do I need a link or some i don?t know maybe I can, l?ve never done that before so I think I can I?m gonna see ifl can do it now. Okay. So, tap link, okay so l?m gonna just tap it and then I?m going to, now if I sent it to your cell phone you think you can pull it up? I don?t have to send it to your email address If, if you send it by email it will go to my cell phone cuz my email goes there I should be able to pull it up that way. I?ll be able to look at it through my email. Page 9 of 15 FB (pause) MP You?re more savvy than I am (inaudible) KK I don?t have a Facebook account either. MP Oh okay. FB 80 have to send it to MP (inaudible) FB Alright you two, see um let me see. KK You can just send it to, to Michael. FB Okayhim. FB Do I have to send it now, cuz I can?t figure this out right now. I will send it to you MP No, no?no you can, you can just take our cards and if you can send it to me later that would be fine. FB I'll send it to you when get back to work when I can MP You know and if you have it on your Facebook page I can have somebody try and look it up. FB Well it?s (inaudible) MP Yeah FB What I did I, l, I copied the link to my clipboard and all I need to now is put your email address in my phone and that I don?t know how to do. MP Okay. FB And MP (inaudible) you want to send it to my phone? You want to just do that then? FB I can send it to your telephone? MP Let?s do that then cuz I, I don?t want you to worry about this when you get home. FB I?m not gonna worry about it anymore since I talked to you. MP Yeah and 1 can?t tell you how FB Now MP appreciate it. FB I can sleep because I haven?t been asleep since Saturday. MP I can only imagine (inaudible) FB And I?m really tired and was falling asleep in this meeting and MP That?s righttired. Yes. Okay. (inaudible) Okay so, (pause) Okay. (pause) you don?t have Facebook you said right? MP Um?hm. FB I just sent it. Phill-2015-648-A12 Okay. I told you I?ve never done this before. So, let?s see how can I do this. Page 10 of15 Phill?20?l 5-648-A12 Alright. But I don?t know, okay, did you get it? No not yet (inaudible), it?s gotta go to the tower and then back down to here. Okay well I sent it to you. Okay I (inaudible), good. So on the video that?s your friend Danny that took the video. Um-hm. And then he posted it on his Facebook page? Um?hm. And then you liked it so you ah this is where it gets out of my, my tech area right (inaudible) The thing is you share it he share it with you? Yeah. You can go onto his page. If you're friends with him Yeah You can go onto his page and then you can, you see the video here I?ll show you. When I, when I Okay so you put it on your page then? I put it on my page. Okay So it?s So the only one that took video that night was Danny? No. There was more people Between the three of you? Well Oh yeah the three of you guys. three of us right. So it] go (inaudible) okay so I?m on Danny?s page now. So I go to Danny?s page. This is his page. Um-hm. And then here's the video. Okay. So you go up here and then i could save the video, don?t like the video, copy to link but I don?t (inaudible) So you can save that video to your cell phone off of there? Um-hm. Could you save that video and then email it I can share it to Page 11 of15 us? See that all you gotta do is push share. Okay. And then ifl do share The thing is its, when you share it you?rejust sharing the link it?s actually uploaded to Facebook?. (inaudible) stays on their servers. Correct. But if you save the video then it saves it onto your phone so then you could email it as an attachment. Exactly. (laughs) so (inaudible) you?re right, you?re absolutely right so I saved it it?s saved on my phone. Okay. I don?t know why you didn?t get that yet. Yeah I don?t know. Your phone it's probably, I don?t, It?s probably a big file. Yeah. Okay. Maybe it's too big to get that way. Um, (pause) got it? Nope, that was an email but not from you. Nothing yet. Okay so I sent it to my phone but I don't know where I saved it at. I don?t know about phones I just know how to talk. It should be on, I know how to talk and text. What is that Samsung? Yeah. There should be a, my files Okay. Go to downloads. Download history. No downloads, that's not good Okay (inaudible) go back let?s see do you have video, videos check that one once Page 120f15 Phill-2015-648-A12 There?s nothing there. Huh So it?s under something I just don't know what. And this is Danny. Uh there?s Danny. Okay. (on phone) Hi. I?m already I?m still here I?m still talking. Uh-huh. I?m alre, no hang on I?m already here I?m talking to the BCA right now. No you were supposed to call me ?memberl said i was in a meeting. Yeah i was in a meeting so I couldn't call you. want to meet with Mike? Um is this the only place that they can meet you? Do you Ah no we can meet anywhere. Cuz him and his wife would like to meet you. Well we just need to be in a place that?s quiet, that?s all (inaudible) They have to meet in a place that?s quiet. Should they come to, can they come to your house? You want to do that? Michael is a Special Agent from the BCA. And then you have Kevin Kane and he?s from the FBI. They can come to your house? Um okay can I give them your phone number and have them call you? Okay. Okay I'll have them call you okay I?ll have Kevin call or Michael one, somebody will call you. Okay. Alright. Okay. Alright thank you (inaudible) So, of course um-this is Danny?s phone number. Okay. Um. Alright. Okay. Is there anything else you can think of you want to let us know we may have forgotten No. you? There?s nothing else (inaudible) (inaudible) I?m not gonna lie. No I told That video i told you what I saw. That video that you have on your phone Um-hm that we just watched together Um-hm Is that an accurate representation of what you recall that night? Yes. And when you see the officers there, the two officers on the video. Yes those are the two that had him down. Page 13 of15 PhilI-2015-648-A12 Okay so one has like a lighter colored shirt on. Yeah. And then one has a darker Yeah or shirt Yeah Which one of those two officers do you remember is the one that shot? The light one, was the one with the light he was the one that was the bold one. He was the one that had the gun still in his hand. That was him the one with the light shirt. Okay what was the other officer doing? Just standing there. Okay. He was just standing there watching his surroundings. And then like I Did he have his gun out? The other officer. No. Okay. No he did not. When you, when you first saw this happening how long do you think this whole thing took? As far as? Like the incident itself up to the gunshot. When we came outside it was, when we came outside I?m trying to think um (inaudible) maybe three to five minutes. Maybe not even that. It happened so, it?s like when you come out, you came out you see ?em on the ground. People are saying things like ah get him up, pick him up, put him in the car. And then you see the maneuvering and then you hear the shot. So I would say probably within maybe three minutes. it was like three long minutes. Um-hm. Yeah, about three minutes. And then the victim, who took him away? Took who? The, the person that was shot. They never took him. The paramedic, you didn?t see that happen like loading (inaudible) He laid there, no they never took him they, he laid, well you saw how he was just, that's how he laid. Okay. Like he was a nobody. He laid there for a long time they never moved him. So when you got in the car and left he was still there? No I don?t know cuz my car was parked behind the Elks. I just know what I saw. Page14of15 Um?hm. So I don?t know what happened cuz the police like i said they came charging at us. Um-hm. Get the outta here and they?re all in the parking lot and you know of the Elks. They?re pounding on cars, looking in cars and you know get outta here, get outta here so I don?t know what I just know what I saw I don?t know what happened when I went to my car. Okay. I don?t know if they picked him up. i don?t know. [just know he laid there for a while. He did lay there with all that commotion that was going on he was still laying there at the curb. Like a nobody. Okay. all I know. Alright. That?s what i saw. Thank you very much for that statement Felisha. We are gonna stop the tape. It is 10:25 AM. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648-A12 Page150f15 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/33 Report Date: 11/17/2015 warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Informatidn Description: Interview of Danny and Lee Braylock Occurrence From: 11/17/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/17/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent! FBI) Approval StatUS: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, SA Phill and FBI SA Kane interviewed Danny and Lee Braylock in their home regarding their witnessing Jamar Clark's arrest and shooting by PD on November 15th 2015. Evidence item (audio disc of interview) and 33.2 (CD containing copy of Danny's cell phone video) acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 906 5TH AVE Primary Information Address: 906 5TH AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55405 United States AddreSS RELATED 161 1? PLYMOUTH Ave Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects RelationshiE Name I Bio Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - BRAYLOCK, DANNY LEE 0 DJ Primary Information Subject Name: BRAYLOCK, DANNY LEE Record Type: Person Bio: 57 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: N0 Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 510 Weight: 170 .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2015 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/33 Report Date: 11/17/2015 SUbject #1 - WITNESS #1 - BRAYLOCK, DANNY LEE - Continued Personal Information Continued - Facial Characteristics: GOATEE Physical Build: THIN Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 906 5TH AVE, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55405 United States Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date DRIVERS Minnesota United States 11/1 712015 NO Suspended LICENSE Subject #2 - - Braylock, Lee Lashane,~- Primary Information Subject Name: Braylock, Lee Lashane Record Type: Person Bio: 51 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 504 Weight: 150 Color: Black Hair Color: Black Identifications ID Type Number St_ate County AM DRIVERS - Minnesota United States 1111712015 NO LICENSE Sabie?iti?? Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO 4. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/33 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #3 SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark_ Douglas - Continued Subjects Relationshig Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #4 SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject-#5 SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar-Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications um ?ats: am am FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/33 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Property #1 - CD Containing digitalaudig of Danny and Lee BrayIOck Inteniiew- Primary Information- Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing digital audio of Danny and Lee Braylock Interview BCA I HQ 11I17l2015 1 2015-648 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - CD Containing copy of Danny Brayiock's CellPhone Video- Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing cOpy of Danny Braylock's Cell Phone Video BCA I HQ 11I20I2015 1 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information Last Update Date: Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11l30/2015 18:45 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill and FBI SA Kane interviewed Danny and Lee Braylock at their home of 906 5th Avenue in Minneapolis. The Braylocks were leaving the Elks Club on November 15th 2015 at about 003 Ohm. They observed the attempted arrest and shooting of Jamar Clark by Minneapolis Police Of?cers Schwarze and Ringgenberg. Danny Braylock said he recorded some of the shooting and arrest on his cell phone and posted it to his Facebook account. He was later able to send the link and the video clip to SA Phill. SA Phill had a cepy of the video burned to disc and labeled in ACISS as evidence item 2015-6423832. The living room interview was digitally recorded and later preserved on CD. The disc was labeled In addition, the interview was transcribed and the full transcription was attached to this report. The following is only a summary of the interview. Please refer to the attached transcript for a full account of what was said. Danny said that after midnight on Sunday the 15th, he and Lee left the Elks and saw an ambulance and a police car across the street. He saw two of?cers holding a man down on the ground. Danny said the man on the ground was handcuffed. Then the policeman pulled out his gun and shot the guy executioner style. Then they faced the crowd and called for backup. One of them pulled out Mace and as other of?cers arrived, some of them were spraying Mace into the crowd and others were trying to grab cell phones from witnesses who were recording the scene. Danny said he saw handcuffs on the man after the police shot him and they stood up, that?s when he saw the cuffs on the man. He also said that the man who was shot didn?t say anything. Danny only heard a grunting sound once he was shot. He said the man was not ?ghting before or after the shot. Lee Braylock said she saw a man on the ground and the police were holding the man for about 4 or 5 minutes. She saw no movement but then she heard a Pop. Lee could not tell which of?cer shot the man. The Braylocks were concerned that the ambulance left the scene without helping the man. Finally, the Braylocks provided SA Phill with a copy of Danny Braylock?s cell phone video. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 17, 2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Danny Braylock DB) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael Phill (MP) Lee Braylock (LB) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: On November 17th 2015, SA Phill and FBI SA Kevin Kane interviewed Danny and Lee Braylock at their home in Minneapolis regarding the November 15th OIS on Plymouth Av in Mpls. MP It?s presently 10:55 AM. on Tuesday, November 2015 for BCA case number 2015-648. Special Agent Michael Phill with the BCA with Special Agent Kevin Kane of the FBI here to view, here to interview Danny and Lee Braylock at their residence of 906 North 5th Avenue in Minneapolis. Danny?s a full name is Lee L-E-E, Braylock, date of birth- Phone number for Danny?? DB Yeah. MP And a phone number for Lee is_ Lee?s full name is Lee, L-E-E, Lashawn is her middle -N same last of Braylock, LB- MP .okay ah all that information just read correct? DB Yes. MP Alright so Danny do you mind telling me you were at the Elk?s Club on Saturday the 14?h and they let out late at night into early morning of Sunday the DB Yeah. MP Can you tell me what you saw when you left the club? DB Well we came out the club we noticed there was a, ambulance and the police across the street with they had a guy on the ground handcuffed, one of the police officers was sitting on him the other one was kneeling down. As we?re sitting there talking to my daughter on the phone um we?re watching him and I?m explaining to her that I see some guy on the ground handcuffed. At that time the policeman pulled out his gun and shot the guy, right there in the front of us. It was a executional style to me. Um after he shot him he stepped over him and he looked at the crowd and he was watching everybody in the crowd and then I guess he was waiting on his backup to come. Because the crowd was kinda getting up rowdy, you know people crying and everybody's talking about well why did they do that why did they do that. And he stood there with his gun out the other one pulled out some Mace until the other squad cars came. And that?s what I seen. MP And then all the police cars started to show up and they, did crowd control tell everybody to get outta there DB Yes when all the squad cars came the most of ?em got out the cars some of ?em had their hands on their guns. Most of ?em had their hands on their, ah the spray and they was Page 1 of 7 Phill?2015?648-A?l '1 pumping up their spray and spraying the crowd. Walking towards the crowd telling everybody to get back while another police man was putting up the, the yellow tape. Okay. Now you were there with Felisha, the three of you? Yeah And you decided, and you just happened to be leaving the club at that time? Right. And as you were happen to leave the club what made you pull out your phone, what, what did you see first to make you start to record? When was coming out my daughter had called me while we was in the Elks so I was talking to her on the phone. Okay. I was just about to hang up with her when we came out the Elks and that?s when I noticed the squad car and the fire truck so and the ambulance. Well that?s why I had my phone out in the first place. Okay. When I seen this I was telling her I?m gonna get off the phone cuz I wanted to record this. At the time I was saying this to her and was watching them is when he did the shooting. Um-hm. I started recording immediately after that. Okay. So we didn?t get that part recorded but tell me what did you see. Ah did you see the, this man on the ground with the cops on top of him? Or, was he on top ofthe cops? What did you see? He was on the ground face down. Okay, face down. He was face down. There was one police man sitting on him facing us, facing towards the Elks. The other one was behind him but he was kneeling down facing us on the top of the guy too. He pulls out his gun and hejust puts his gun down and just shoots him, point blank. Okay and now the two officers, as I recall one had on the light blue Minneapolis shirt and the other had on a darker like a jacket, Minneapolis Police jacket. Right. Which one of those two is the one (inaudible) The one in the light shirt?s the one who was sitting on him. The one in the dark shirt is the one that pulled the gun out. Okay. 80 blue was sitting on him. Yeah. Dark shirt or the coat he's the one who pulled the gun out and He?s the one that took the gun out and shot him. Okay. And after he shot him what did he do? Ah after he shot him then the one that was sitting on him just stood up. He stood up and looked back at the guy and the other one kinda, he stepped over him and he still had his Page 2 of 7 Phill-2015-648-A?l ?l gun in his hand and he was looking at the crowd like he was waiting for somebody to say something like, he wanted to defend his Um-hm. the crowd came over there so he still had his gun waving in his hand. Now you said you also mentioned handcuffs. (inaudible) When did you see handcuffs? Orfor certain that you saw (inaudible) l, I seen the handcuffs when the policeman that was sitting on him stood up that?s when I noticed the handcuffs was on the guy. That was immediately after he shot him. Okayall take the handcuffs off? (inaudible) didn?t see him when they took the handcuffs off but my belief is as they was as the fire the excuse me the ambulance was pulling up Um?hm. The ambulance pulled up right away then another car pulled a police car pulls up and they blocked us. That?s when I seen the other policeman bend over but I can?t say that he took the handcuffs off him but I did notice that they were bending over the guy. Okay. They or the The policeman. Policeman were bending over him (inaudible) But you didn?t see it but you think that?s when the cuffs came off? I think that?s when the cuffs came off. Okay. And then, were you able to keep recording or did the police end up moving you out of the way? I recorded as much as I could but they was backing us up. But I was recording as was walking backwards recording as much as i could. Um?hm. And then we also heard that the police may have been trying to grab phones. Anybody try to grab your phone? Yes they tried, he was coming towards me but I was too far back in the crowd. But they was, a couple of ?em was on the side reaching for the phones. Reaching for, for a couple of people?s phones they was reaching for their phone. But they couldn?t get a hold of mine. Okay. Now I also saw the video and there was a lotta yelling and screaming in there it may have been difficult, do you remember hearing anything that officers said to the man? I didn?t hear nothing that he was saying to him. I didn't even see him moving his mouth talking to the guy that they shot and And do you remember hearing the man say anything? Cuz he didn?t die, do you remember him saying anything before the shot or after the shot? Ah, ljust heard a grunt. When he shot him ljust seen his body bounce. When the bullet hit him he kind of bounced. Um?hm. I didn?t hear him say nothing. Page 3 of 7 MP Okay. DB Just a grunt sound. MP And then, to describe kinda what was happening would you say that that man was fighting the police at all? DB No. No not at all. MP Okay DB He was handcuffed on the ground. He couldn't fight. MP No punches? No kicks? DB No fighting no, no, no he was, he was handcuffed face down on the ground. There was no fighting. No, resistance or nothing. MP Okay. Kevin do you have something? Anything? KK No just, did anyone else I know you went with Felisha there that night. DB Um?hm. KK Did anyone, did you recognize anybody else that was at that club that might have information for us? Or other names DB Well it was me KK around and you saw ?em standing wife um Felisha, goes to the Elks every now and then so I do know some people there. I might not know them all by names and stuff but yet there was a few other people that I?ve seen on the news um some of the guys that was in the Elks I seen a few of them there. That was on the news I think one of the guys who spoke to a news crew. KK Okay. MP Yeah we, we?ve heard that and that people are talking to the news and stuff and we need (coughing) MP talk to us. (inaudible) MP Um we?re gonna leave you our cards and if you talk to any more of your friends or you go back to the Elks, anybody who saw what happened, we?d like ?em to give us a statement. DB Okay. MP And so we can get the truth. Now Lee, as far as what you remember were you at Danny?s side as you left the club? LB (no audible response) MP So you weren?t on the phone? LB No. MP What did you see? LB This what I seen. Well we came out of the club. I looked across the street. And I see the police was there. And other people was on that side of, with on that side just watching. What I seen was I seen a body on the ground. I, I didn?t see him move at all. MP Okay. Phill?2015?648-A1 1 Page 4 of 7 The policeman, I say the policeman was on top of him for a good four minutes. I?d say about four minutes, four to five minutes I seen the policeman just on top of him. I couldn?t see no handcuffs. I couldn?t see nothing. didn?t see his body move. But after the four or five minutes all heard was a pop. And that?s all I seen. Okay. So you didn?t see any fighting, any struggling? (inaudible) he didn?t move, (inaudible) body wasn?t moving they was on top of him. Okay and did you hear the police say anything to him? I couldn?t hear, ah no cuz I was across the street I can?t hear what they?re saying. Okay. But I could just see that he?s not moving and, and you?re on him for far, five minutes and then you just heard a pop. Okay so you heard the pop. Could you tell if it was the officer with the blue shirt or the one with the dark (inaudible) I can?t tell you, (inaudible) Couldn?t tell? So after you heard the shot what did the officers do? They got up. They got when ah after they shot him people were starting to come in the street now after that, at the you know (inaudible) people started coming in the street. And then they got up and then they started coming towards us. Okay With their mace and What were they saying? Get back, get just ah'get back, get out of here and this and that but they were trying to take people?s phones you know. Um?hm. But no one was given you know giving that up but that?s all I seen. Did either one of you get pepper sprayed? No we were getting out of the way. You got out of the way, backing up? We didn?t Right we (inaudible) We smelt it but it (inaudible) Right. But it was lingering. It was ling, right. You could smell it. But we just got out of the way. Page 5 of? Phill-2015-648~A11 So when I seen them starting to spray it then that?s when I started coming back cuz I, been pepper sprayed before and I don?t like that. Okay. So I stepped back from there. I agree with you. So, do you remember as you were starting to leave and go to Felisha?s car do you remember seeing an ambulance come or anybody come give medical aid to that man? Yeah when, when we was, before we was leaving the ambulance came and the whole police force came. Everybody? Everybody, the whole Minneapolis police force seemed like they were there. Okay. And you got outta there before they took his body away? Right. Okay. Anything else you can think of that we forgot to ask you? have well I do have a question which I know you probably couldn?t answer but when he did shoot the policeman there was already a ambulance there. But when he shot the ambulance pulled off. Yeah. That?s because (inaudible) was there for somebody else. on. Somebody was already in there getting treated and they were taking that person to the hosp?ai Oh okay. And they never like to put two people in, if you've ever been in there it?s real (inaudible) Right. Yeah, my whole concern was I can understand that but my concern was if the ambulance was there to (inaudible) he?s supposed to try to aid the guy. Um-hm. Even though they had somebody in there they was a paramedic they shoulda, i mean ah at least looked at the guy cuz he was just pulling off. Or, But they pulled off like they was scared. That?s a question I have to ask them I Okay those paramedics. But i would have to ask ?em that too what did, did anybody help him. No, nobody helped him they jumped and they van, and they just took off. Left, okay. Anything else? No. Page 6 of 7 MP Okay. I?m gonna go LB Thank you. MP No thank KK Do you want to get the video from these guys? MP Yes. KK if he?s got it saved on his phone maybe he can email it. MP Yes I want to get your video data if you can email that to me I couldn?t get that from your Facebook page. I?m gonna go ahead and terminate the interview at 11:06 AM. END OF RECORDING. Phill?2015?648?A11 Page 7 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/34 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Interview of Tondalaya Thompson Occurrence From: 11l17l2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11l17/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent! FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency; Reference Numbers Ass-m1 Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab 515-14003 Syn?dpsis On November 17th 2015, SAs Phill and Kane interviewed Tondalaya Thompson at the BCPD about the November 15th 013 on_ Plymouth Av. Thompson said she was an eyewitness. Evidence item (Audio CD of Interview) acqurred report. Adfdress#1 - Occurred #1 - 6645 HUMBOLDT AVE Primary Information Address: 6645 HUMBOLDT AVE Brooklyn Center Police Department, Brooklyn Center, Minnesota 55430 United States Description: Brooklyn Center Police Department Subjects Relationship Name B_i0 LB BUSINESS LOCATION Brooklyn Center Police Department (ORGANIZATION) Telephones ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address BILLING AND (763) 569~3333 (BUSINESS) INSTALLATION ADDRESS Address #2 - RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name EOE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/34 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Thompson, Tondalaya Cantrell Primary Information Subject Name: Thompson, Tondalaya Cantrell Record Type: Person Bio: 43 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 502 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 4011 WELCOME AVE N, Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address CELLULAR PHONE Subject SUBJECT #1 - MarkiDeu?QIae Primary Informa tion Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name LB EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: .- .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/34 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Subject #3 - SUBJECT Schwarze, Dustin Timothy - Continued - Primary Information - Continued Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name Bi EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar Oneal - Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 7 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications 8 Stats M1 113.0% FBI ID 717111FD1 N0 OID 232941 Minnesota N0 State ID Minnesota N0 Property #1 - CD Containing digital audio otThompson's interview I Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Preperty Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing digital audio of Thompson's Interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/17/2015 Quantity: 1 Control NumberMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phil], Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide IMinnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/34 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Property #1 - CD Containing digital audio cf Thompson's Interview - Continued- Primary information - Continued UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11122i2015 17:37 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11I3OI2015 18:48 Apprehension) Reporting LEO I Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2i26/2016 Apprehension) [Narrative begins on the following-page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On Tuesday, November 17th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill and FBI SA Kane interviewed Tondalaya Thompson at the Brooklyn Center Police Department. Thompson said she was at the Elks on Plymouth Av in Minneapolis on November 15th when the Minneapolis Police shot Jamar Clark. The following is only a summary of Thompson?s statement. Please refer to the attached transcript for a full account of what was said. The interview was digitally recorded and burned to disc for evidence. The disc was given ACISS property number Thompson said she was at the Elk?s with a friend and they decided to leave to get some chicken. Once in the lot, she said she saw an ambulance police car across the street on Plymouth Av. She said she saw two of?cers, one with a blue shirt over dark pants and the other with a dark blue top and dark pants. They were leading a man from the townhomes to the street and they each had an arm of the man. Thompson said that she saw the man was giving them a little resistance so they slammed him to the ground. She said the man stopped resisting. The light blue shirted cop was laying on his side with his back to the man and to the other police of?cer who was kneeling with a knee on the man?s stomach or legs, pinning him to the ground. Thompson said the man was not saying anything and then she heard a ?pop.? She said the man?s dreads move and his head tilt back and his legs go limp. She said the 00p in light blue also ?inched when the ?pop? sound happened. Then she said the cop in light blue got up, grabbed his gun and stood facing her and others in front of the Elk?s club. Thompson said that she saw an EMT jump into the ambulance and drive off which surprised her. She then saw that another EMT was standing across the street and she wondered aloud where the ?rst ambulance was going when someone was clearly in need of medical help. Thompson said that the of?cer in dark clothing behind the man handcuffed him and he was handcuffed while he lay on his back, cuffs in front. Thompson did not remember hearing the police of?cers saying anything to the man, if they did, they were quiet. She saw the man eventually loaded into another ambulance and driven away. Then there was nothing but cops everywhere trying to move people away from the area. They were spraying pepper into some of the crowd and some were trying to grab some people?s cell phones. Thompson did not ?lm anything with her phone because it is defective. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: 11-17-2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Tonda Thompson (TT) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael Phill (MP) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: MP Alright today is November 17th, 2015. Current time is 12:39 PM. Special Agent Michael Phill of the Minnesota BCA, Special Agent Kevin Kane of the FBI at the Brooklyn Center Police Department on BCA case number 2015-648. We?re here to interview Tonda Thompson and her first name is spelled Lia, Laya, Tonda Laya L-A-Y-A, middle initial is C. Thompson is elled date of birth is- A contact number for Tonda is Address 4011 Welcome Avenue in Robbinsdale, 55422. All that information correct? TT Yes. MP And you don?t mind if I refer to you as Tonda here in the tape? TT No that?s fine. MP Okay. Now Tonda you?d to call and told me that you were at the Elk's Club in Minneapolis on Plymouth Avenue that night of the um Saturday the TT Yes. MP And it kinda let out in the early morning hours of the 15th? TT Right. MP Can you tell me why you left the club and what did you see when you left? TT Urn the Elk?s tends the, they close a little earlier; they set their clocks a little faster just cuz they can get everybody out. MP Um?hm. TT Um and we wanted to leave because we were hopin? to get chicken at the 200 (laugh) bar. We were hungry and so we wanted to get some chicken so we kinda left out right away. Um and when was leaving the Elk?s I noticed an ambulance police car and l, I noticed two cops and a man, they were running out of the building, out of the?the building?s kinda funny cuz on one side it has like townhouses and on the other side it has like apartment buildings. MP Okay. TT So they were bringing him out of the apartment building part. And I said whoo you know, what?s goin? on here? So I?m and everybody who knows me knows l'm, I watch all those shows and forensics MP Um?hm. TT I?m always like tunin? into stuff like that, so I stopped, I walked over by and at this point I'm by the, the driveway of the Elk?s where I?ve, I?m kinda in the street but not in the street. Phill-2015-648-A10 Page 1 01?21 I?ve got you. In the driveway of the Elk?s, and Ijust sat there and watched. My girlfriend?s over there talkin? some people that were out there and so as they were bringin? him out; they each had and arm and um they were, at that point I think they were just tryin? ta check him but he was still fussin' yeah. I could tell that he had had a couple drinks probably or somethin?. He was on somein? cuz he?s kinda staggery. Um-hm. Um and he was um l?m like oh okay he?d been drinkin?. You know this is just me kinda talkin? out loud. I?m like oh?oh he?s been drinkin? and then I said?~30 l?m watchin? him and he?s like kept lookin? back up at the buildin? like you guys know this?can cuss? Sure. I?m like you know he was like you guys know this is some bullshit. This ain?t fair. This well I know this this is bullshit. Um?hm. You know and I?m like oh-oh you know and then there was a couple other girls standin? there. I said oh-oh he musta got into it with his girlfriend or somein?. You know and at that time I didn?t know what had happened in that house or anything. I said, I said oh-oh. And then so l?m still watchin? and then to me they felt, I was feelin? like they were bein? a little rough cuz his body was kinda like doin? this. Um?hm. And I said he?s upset but he?s not resistin? and I kept saying he?s upset but he?s not resistin'. So l?m on if this is the street, I'm on that side of the street, he?s on this side of the street, so they proceeded cuff this hand here and then with this arm; with his right arm, he was like ?man this is bullshit? and he kinda stomped and he did his arm like that and when he did that they didn?t longer had a hold of his arm. Um-hm. So then that?s when they were like cha?, you know real fast. Yeah (inaudible). On the ground. Okay. (cleared throat) So at this point he?s, he?s on the ground and he?s like on his side this way. There was two cops?. Which side is that? Just got remember we?re recording it. Oh I?m sorry. (inaudible) recorder can see it. This would be his, (inaudible) would be his right side. Alright. So by this time he, they done slammed him Um-hm. Page 2 of 21 Phill-2015-648?A1 0 his (inaudible) side his head is this way and feet are this way. Um and I?m across the street so um, I'm like he?s not resistin? and after that you didn?t hear him say anything. i was like look he don?t want no trouble, you know. You could tell he didn?t want no?he wasn?t a big dude; kinda slender built look like wore baggy clothes so was hard to tell what weight they probably really are Um?hm. didn?t look like a really big dude to me. Didn?t look real super tall; um had a little height but not, I didn?t take it much like super tall. Um and there was a shorter cop and a taller cop and no, the shorter cop had a like a light blue, they were dressed different. One had a light blue with a darker pants and the other was in all dark. Okay. With uh, with uh walkie talkie on his, on his left side right here. And I remember because after all of it happened he went to it. You know? Um-hm. But um the shorter, the shorter one was more on his back at this point when they had him Yeah. rolled him on his back. At that point the one that was in the lighter blue was lay kinda on his back but his arm; his right arm, was kinda in the chest area in the, like up in Um-hm. the guy and So kind of, he was kinda laying on the chest area of the, the, the Of the guy. arrested. Right yeah. (inaudible) Cuz he?s laid a? I?m, I'm sorry. I don?t what way this would be but he was laid out and the one with the lighter blue shirt um, feet were towards the street. Okay. So he?s like, laying like this kinda over ta his right side with his arm kinda up here by his, his head area. Okay. Like up in his chest head area. Didn?t have him in a head lock? Noth? no. Just had his arm up chest area. by the chest area. I could So was the officer?s baCk to the man?s front? Page 3 of 21 Yep. To the, to the other officer?s front. Okay. And um the other officer was on this side of the body kinda like h? he, like knelt, knelt down into either his stomach area?cuz the guy in front was kinda blockin? exactly where his knee was. But seen them where they had?once they rolled him over ?eh his arms were like this, the back one, that one right here. In front of him? in front of him. So they went from back here to up here. Okay. And th? this is where I?m, l?m gonna start cryin? cuz he was over him, he was over him with his knee in his either stomach area or a? across his legs, again it was hard to tell The darkjacket guy? The dark jacket guy. Okay. It was hard to see exactly because the guy on this side (inaudible) Okay. of that so. (inaudible) light shirt was Laying on top of him. Yep and his fit were out and he was like over like this. Okay. Not headlock ways but like puttin? his weight on his area up in here. Okay. the hands got front, I know he has his hands in front. Now he has his hands in front. He didn?t, he didn?t like yell or cry or anything and you heard a brief, it was like a pause almost. You know and, and in my head I?m thinkin? okay they?re gonna lift him up. I?m like yeah get him up. You know I?m like he?s not resistin?. And you heard this pop. And I couldn?t move cuz I literally seen his dreads go back and his legs just went out in like straight. Um-hm. And, the and it, then after that pop and brief little quiet second or whatever it was, the ambulance; there was an ambulance that sat on this (tapping) side and now I?m talkin? on where I?m stand? from Um?hm. standing. The ambulance is on my left and the police car is on my Um-hm. Page 4 of 21 TT for in the middle of it on the sidewalk. MP Both of it?s on, all that and the other side of the street? TT Yeah I?m on the other side street. I don?t leave my area. MP Um-hm. TT And I?m kinda like oh my God. Oh, ya know by this time I?m like oh my God. But I remember the ambulance guyjumpin? in the ambulance and takin' off. MP Um?hm. TT And I started sayin? what the fuck is he doin?? Where is he goin?? MP Before he jumped where was it? TT He was like standin? on, he, the ambulance was here and he was on this side. MP Okay. TT Now I didn't know ?til later there was a second ambulance guy. Cuz ?eh I couldn?t see him. He?s on the other side of the truck. MP Okay. TT But this guy was in the street. MP Okay. TT And he seen that, he ducked a little like everybody did. We was all like (inhaled) ya know, and he jumped in that ambulance and took off. I said where the fuck is he goin?? MP Um?hm. TT I said why isn?t he tryin? to resuscitate him or do somethin?. And 1 pointed at them officers. I said you guys just killed that man. I just watched you kill that man. MP Um-hm. TT said you guys just killed that man. The light skinded guy orthe lightjacket shirt MP Um-hm. TT up and the first thing did was pull his gun. That what was odd is cuz he also did like that. Like everybody kinda did like that. MP You saw him TT Yeah. MP be TT seen him flinch. MP TT Yeah MP Okay. TT know. And he jumped up right away and, and when they both jumped up and went away from that man he was laying like this. He was layin? just like this. MP Laying on his back? TT No movement. MP Limp, no movement? Phill-201 5-648-A1 Page 5 of 21 PhilI-2015?648?A1 0 On his straight back, no movement, no limp, no nothin?. Now when you say, you?re saying like this. You had your hands in front like he was cuffed. Was he cuffed? He was cuffed. That?s very important you remember Yes seen cuffs? remember seein? cuffs. What color were they? Uh I couldn?t tell you the color. Okay. I couldn?t tell you the color of the cuffs. Okay. i couldn?t but and l, And you, you made mention of dreads earlier. You mean dread looks, so Dread locks. he was, he was black and he had some dread lock hairs? Right. it looked like his hair And you saw them move when Yep. back? It, it um and again they coulda been braids. was stayed across the street. 1 never did walk up on the man. ?Kay. But he, they could been like single braids. ca?, i said dread Um-hm. that?s what they look like from was ya know where was uh Yeah. they were kinda more down in his face, like they were loosely like he wore ?em all kinda like, I call it the (inaudible) they were all kinda down. Some people where (inaudible) know kinda tied back but his was like all down. Okay. Page 6 of 21 Phill-2015-648-A10 And um, and when he, when that gun shot went off I watch his head and his bodyjust like, it was like the same motion like straight back. Hm. And his, the few loose ones that were down went to the back. Okay. So when you saw the officer who fired the gun was the who was all (inaudible) all dark behind (inaudible)? Yes. Okay not the one in the blue shirt? Not the one in the blue shirt. And to be honest I did not see like Um?hm. you know? Never saw, you heard? I heard it. Never saw it? I never saw it. Okay. And I didn't l?b, in my heart 1 believe it was the darker guy cuz the front guy was face it, his body was facing. Um-hm. You know. In the other direction. Facing the other direction. And he flinched too you said? He flinched as well. So it was a surprise to him. So after that the man in the blue you said stood up? Um-hm. Ambulance drivers, said the ambulance people got in there, took Just one. (laughed) Just one you saw got in there? Got it (laughing). what happened? Then I noted that, when he drove off I noticed the other one was standin? on the stre?, on the sidewalk. Okay. On the other side of the ambulance. l-l noticed he was still there and I?m still screamin? someone help help him. The ambulance came from the other way, came from Penn Avenue way. Page 7 of21 Phil 5-648-A?l 0 Okay. That was the second ambulance who finally did just come, you know come and get in there pick him up. But after that, after that ambulance left the light shirt guyjumped up, he jumped up and the first thing he did was draw his gun. The, the one in the blue um jumped up and I didn?t, I remember wa? lookin? at him and he was kinda like doin? this with his walkie- talkie thing he, he had right here. Um-hm. And he was like sayin? whatever and police started comin? outta everywhere. Um-hm. And ?eh th? all they did was they, all of ?em started grabbin? their, grabbin? their um, pullin' their guns and their mace ya know and we?re like well w' whatya guys gonna do about him? You know? And what really started me to cry is because two girls, I?m, I'm assumin? that?l don?t know if they were friends or related, they come out of the buildin? and I heard one of ?em yell, what did you do? Wejust needed you to get him outta here. What did you do? You know? And Um-hm. I felt so bad because they just wanted ta probably, he probably needed to get rest. I don?t know but it just hurt Um-hm. they were like we just needed you ta get him outta here. Um-hm. Ya know and I kept sayin? you killed him. He, he wasn?t movin?. They didn?t try ta? put nothin? on him ta help him breath or, they didn?t do anything. Theyjust, the second ambulance just kinda picked him up, put him on there, flown off and he was cuffed and ya know that, that, that the thing is too, I don?t know what color the cuffs were but ?member thinkin? after I got home I, you woulda thought his, if everything else went limp his arms woulda went to the side or, or somethin? and they stayed in this motion right here. They were just like, you know like there was nothin? So you saw him leave in the ambulance? Yes. You saw them tend to him? Did they put him on a stretcher? Yep. And when they put him on there did they lay him down on his back? Yep he was on his back. So he was still in that He was holdin? that same position. (cleared throat) And when he went in and they shut the doors of the ambulance he had the handcuffs on his hands (inaudible)? When I seen them roll him in there, I don?t remember them shutting the door. Um?hm. I don?t remem?, I think that?s when and on, not but now cuz there had police all on this side of me and now I was kinda still stuck and they had the pull me back because Page 8 of 21 Phill-2015-648?A?1 0 they want, block that area off. Move back! Everybody move back. And I was closer to the street. Um?hm. was like, again it?s not uh, it wasn?t a sidewalk cuz it?s a driveway up into Next to the Elk?s? Yeah. It?s like, it's a driveway. So uh it was kinda flat right there. It?s not like a curb or anything right Um-hm. was standin' it?s flat because you gotta drive your car up in it. And they, I remember my girlfriend kinda like grabbin? me back cuz I was just like stuck like. Oh my, you know, screamin? and yellin?. How close were you to this entire incident that took place? Did it, just as, as wide as, as wide as the street. Okay. I 80 then don?t know how wide that is but as wide as Plymouth Avenue is how far I was away from it. Okay. So, there was a couple times I, you knowjust kinda, remember like duckin? and so my feet shifted a little you know, but I didn?t like leave my area there. Um-hm. Did you get any of the pepper spray on you? Look I did, but not as much because he kinda sprayed more this Um-hm. got some dudes that kinda started to proceed more into the Um-hm. yes I did call ?eh that he, that cop was just, he was too animated for me. Hm. He come right in. He?s back and forth and he had his hat and he, you Um-hm. the big old can with this little horn thing on it or whatever and wa?, he was you know and I?m like see you And you never walked in the street? I never And you stayed the street. other side. i stayed on right here on the other side and I?m like why are you way over here? Um-hm. Page 9 of 21 You know? Did you uh see the police try ta take anybody?s phones? Yes. Yep. Okay. Yeah. And do you want, were you filming at all? Nope. (inaudible) My phone is old and it doesn?t work right. Umhm. And like said for me watchin? it was kinda just, kinda glue. Yeah you were keyed in yourself. Yeah was keyed in and l, I couldn't like function with nothin? else. Like everybody else had their phones out. I remember seein? a girl cuz a officer was comin? up to her. She was like I?m taping you. I'm, l?m taping you. Uh?hm And um but yeah l?d, I didn?t tape anything. I didn?t even think ta grab Gotcha. Grab anything. I was just like, oh my God cannot'believe this is happenin? right now. You said that you heard the guy sayin? the bullshit Yep. right? Yep. Did the police say anything to him? No. They weren?t like, they weren?t being like loud. If they were saying somethin?, I didn?t hear them Hm. him out or saying anything mean to him. And he, they, he wasn't really talkin? ta them. I could tell like he was fussin? at whoever was in this buildin?. He kept look back like ya all know_this is this is bullshit ya know. Um-hm. He kept lookin? back like ya all know, you know? Um-hm. And by this time like I said they both had a arm. Um-hm. They, they didn't um, and you know the one officer at one point he did turn around, the lighter blue shirt, and faced him and I think at that point they were checkin? like pockets Um-hm. Page 10 of 21 Phill?2015-648?A?1 0 itjust kinda seemed like they were checkin? and then the one in the dark blue still had the um the left arm, his left arm. You know? Um-hm. And the right arm, the arm he finally said at, you know he had one already behind him and he went you know uh, they were tryin? ta get the other one. And then they couldn?t get it? And they couldn?t get it and that?s when they threw him down. Okay. I said he?s upset but he?s not resistin? and oh. When they had the left arm behind him, did that have a handcuff on it or did they just have his arm restrained behind him when (inaudible)? He, they, that one was cuffed already. So they had one handcuff on his left arm? Um-hm. And his right arm was still free? Free. Okay. And I think when they went to do that, that's when he finally?he?s like oh man, almost like a tantrum is what it looked like to me. Um?hm. man. Ya know And he was speaking loudly? Yes. He was yeah. And the police officers were talking they were speaking quiet? Quietly yes. 80 you didn?t hear them say anything? Um-um, I didn?t hear ?em like saying nothin? mean or calling him by a name or, or anything like that. Before the shot went off did you hear the police officers saying anything when they kinda went down to the ground? Nope ?eh ?eh they if they, if they were saying anything they were very quiet with it or you know normal tones or whatever because by this time too urn you uh y? there was people, more people out there now. Um-hm. And people are yellin?, ya know I?m, I'm yellin? like he?s not, he?s not resistin? ya know? He's not resistin?. He?s upset but he?s not resistin?. And um they the, the boy, the young man himself he was quiet. Hm. Like he was no more that, this is be. No more talking. Page 11 of 21 Phill-2015?648-A1 no more talkin?. He didn?t want no?and I kept sayin' l, I kinda, well go he don?t want no trouble. You know ouz ?eh I mean it, it You could tell it when they slammed him to the ground was the end of him talking? That was them talkin?. He don?t ?Kay. trouble. He di? he c? you could tell that he was doin? what they and they flipped him on his back. Um-hm. And got that other hand and you just, it it?s wer?, it?s weird how it, it was like quiet for a second, seemed like. And just heard this pop. Um-hm. And everybody was kinda stunned by it. Like what, you know you wasn?t quite sure what it was or it but I seen his head roll back and legs Like his body reacted (inaudible)? React to that shot. Okay. But you said we left early, who you with? with a girlfriend of mine. is she willing to, did she see or was she still in what I mean My girlf? (laughs) my girlfriend was watchin? and I don?t, I?d, she was recording some things I remember. Um?hm. Her recording some things but again I wasn?t focused on them so much. I know she was? when it first started she was talkin?. There was a couple people that came up with us. Okay And you know how you?re like, oh yeah there you know. Yep socializin?. She?s socializin? and I?m like ooh what, ya know, what?s goin? on? l?m, right away l?m over there and I?m not talkin? (inaudible) the lights? anybody. Yeah. Yeah. I don?t know if she?d be willing to. It?s not somethin? I asked Okay. all. Well you have Page 12 of 21 Phill-2015?648?A10 Yep. if you can, if anybody else that you come across said they were there and saw Um?hm. like uh talk to ?em. Not the people who saw or came after. Right. Anybody who saw the shot, that?s what we wanna know. And um so just get their information. I will. Um anything else we?re that we?re forgetting to ask you? I don?t know. No. I don't think so. I think you covered it pretty well. Yeah. I know I, I did, l-l feel bad just fortheir family and it?s, inside I don?t know. Okay. does, doesn?t seem right (exhale). And you?re, w? w? you understand what we?re tryin? do we?re gonna talk to everybody we Um?hm. then the police have their side of the story. Hm. We?ll see what they got to say and if there?s video from the Elk?s and all that stuff, we?ll try ta find all that stuff. Yeah. Get to the bottom of it. And figure out exactly what happened. You know that?s what our goal is. I really appreciate you coming forward. Yep. And l?m glad you did. You?re not alone. Some people are starting to come forward. Oh that?s good. Yep it is. l?m glad. I?m glad. Okay. Well please then talk to your friend. will. (inaudible) tell her any you recorded it let us know I will. do. Yeah I don?t, l-l just, I do remember her phone bein? on. ljust don?t know what time she pulled it out and decided to do that. Page 13 of 21 Phill-2015-648-A10 Okay. Um. I wasn?t uh, I wasn?t really focused on anybody else really. Um-hm. Just kind of stuck almost, I felt almost like you know? Um-hm. Just kinda stuck in my area. Yeah. Did you eventually uh drive off, I don?t if Kevin asked you this, when the ambulance took him, then you finally went home? No. How much longer did you hang out? Um I was there for a little while. They had preceded to tape off part ofthe Elk's and where I was standin? even, they had taped off Um?hm. area. Um they were giving the okay at that point to kind of..bum rush the Elk?s so to speak to get everybody even off that side, which I didn?t understand. I?m like it happened across the street. That?s where you should be. Okay. You would think you would wanna focus you know, your time but ya know they pretty much had the Elk?by time I park c? the Elk?s the packed that night ?er super packed and we had parked on; I think that?s Irv yeah, Irving, we parked on Irving. Cuz Knox is the closest one right there? Rig ht Knox is the closest. Knox is this way. Yep. But we parked on Irving. Okay Irving followed on the other direction. yeah. Yeah. King, J-K. Except you pretty much hung around until the police started moving everybody out? Yeah ?til they started movin? people out and then we went to our car and so we were gonna go around the block which brings us up comin? up Yeah. ta, ta Plymouth and you couldn?t even get there if you would?ve been the first one there you?da thought somein? happened at the Elk?s. Okay. They had all the cars put, cuz after we got to our car we didn?t drive off right away. I just kinda needed a minute and I Um?hm. Page 14 of 21 like I can?t believe I just that, ya know and I'm, l?m, I?m like oh my God. I, w? what are we gonna do? Ya know? Ya know and I?m, me and my girlfriend were just kinda just sittin? Um-hm. And then so she?s like come on let?s just ride around, ya know, this way. And when we did they had the Elk?s completely cleared off by then. Um?hm. I mean they were even standin? in the Elk?s parkin? lot. And you would?ve thought if you'd walked up somethin? happened at the Elk?s. Okay. So then we had a huge Oh. the tape and the (inaudible, two people talking) All the way around. (inaudible, two people talking) All the way around. Alright. Was there anybody else there that you knew that night? Oh yeah, there was a lotta people there that I knew. Mm. Okay. Did any of those people see it? Um, no like I said we kind of ran out kinda quick. We were tryin' to go get some food (laughs). Yeah. Before they stopped servin?. l, we didn?t know what time they stopped servin? food at the 200 Bar, calls it 200 but (inaudible) whatever it?s called. Yeahkinda dipped out you know quicker than most so. Okay. Um, there I wish I knew the two ladies that were standin? there with me because they were out there when was out there. They were actually out there before I was out there. But I came where part where they were walkin? ?em out of the building. Um?hm. Um, and they were standing there as well and I remember one of the girls havin? her camera out. I would say she, she had hers out kinda right away ?cuz I think uh with me yellin? and sayin? he?s not resistin?, he?s not resistin?, you know come on you guys be nice you know. Stuff like that. I think that got them more focused ?cuz they were just kinda talkin' to each other, but they were, I was on the other side of them. I actually walked around them. They were on the sidewalk closer by the door. And I walked more on the driveway part, walked around them two ladies and but I don?t know who they were. I wish I did. I don?t, I don?t know who they are. Page 15 of21 Phill-2015-648-A10 Yeah, ljust didn?t know if you and your girlfriend had seen some other friends (inaudible). Yeah she knew some people and she was, she was talkin? to some people but I didn?t engage in any, I don?t know what they were talkin? about, or, I went right to the watch. Okay. That?s what I did. The last question is when he had his hands in front, you think his hands were cuffed in front or they were not cuffed? Once he, once he did (inaudible) hands in front and than the officer laid on him. No they cuffed him Before or after he was shot. A-a?a, before he was shot. 80 you think he was cuffed in front. In front. He was cuffed in front. And that?s the part that?s hard for me to describe, it, it?s more like they started from the back and when he did this as they goin? down.'.. Um?hm. comes down on his, on his right shoulder. 80 now his body is face, is facing everything is facin? me. I?m over there. Um-hm. You know. And then they, they rolled him over and that?s when I, I watched his arm go from down here and they, when they rolled him over he was kinda like, kinda like this you know like this, his right Um?hm. still like out here. They rolled him over Which one. Which officer put the cuffs on him? The, believe it was the one in the dark blue. All dark blue. Behind him. Behind it. Okay. So the one behind him in the dark blue uniform. That was the one that was proceeding to put the cuffs on him anyway. He had the left arm. He had the left arm. The one in the blue lost the right arm. No. in the struggle. He lost the right arm, the one in the blue shirt, lost the right arm and that's when they go to the ground. In the light blue, in the light blue, yes. In the light blue. Because it, this is what happened. They were comin' down they each had an arm. They ea-, they?re comin? down. The light blue gu-, in the light blue shirt now has got his back to me ?cuz it?s like they?re checkin? pockets or whatever. Um-hm. Page 16 of 21 Phill?2015?648-A1 0 The dark, all dark blue officer is this way. He cuffs this one, but then, you know, and at the time he was getting' ready to like, look like he was gettin? ready Pull the right arm over. Pull the ri-, right one last: this is some bullshit, and, and he kinda (inaudible) man and you know he was like that and then that arm went so when that arm went that?s when behind, front (inaudible). So the blue guy, dark blue behind, light blue front. Front. And they took him down to the ground. (inaudible) like that. And the light blue guy was layin? on top of him. Light blue guy kinda was like now his back is on him. Um?hm. With his right am like this, his feet are towards the street. Um-hm. He?s got his head, his face is you know he's in front of this officer who?s behind him. Okay. And that officer you know and the dude when he fell on his side kinda fell like this, like this ha?, this hand and uh this was still kinda. Um-hm. Showin?, you know. Um-hm. So when they rolled him on his back this way, like goin' towards his left, like they kinda took him this way, flipped him this way. Now he?s on his back. Um-hm. They grabbed this hand, and again you can?t, I couldn?t like a hundred percent see when I watched him like, like he was doin? somethin? with his hands. Um-hm. ?Cuz again the other guy's kinda blockin? that?s why I couldn't really see where his knee was. (inaudible) But he kinda came The light blue guy?s blocking. Blockin?. ?Cuz he?s layin? on him. Layin? on him. Okay. But you could see like they took his arm So somethin?s goin? on with the arm. Page 17 of 21 Phill-2015-648?A1 0 With the arm. ?Cuz when I was like this I watched them roll him over take his arm and the cop kinda is in the way. Like if he was holding him down for him or somethin?. You know? Um-hm. Um?hm. And he?s got his knee either in his stomach area or across his leg you can tell he?s like kneeled. Um?hm. (inaudible) silence. Yeah, there was some silence and then you heard pop. Do you remember seein? the dark blue guy draw the weapon? That?s the one that you said shot him. (inaudible) I believe he shot ?im yeah. Do you, I know that that?s like a weird Right. the silence and everything. Do you remember seeing the gun be drawn, or do you remember seeing it after the fact? - I remember seein' it after the fact. Okay. So you didn?t see him draw any weapon And I didn?t hear him yell like you know I?m drawing my weapon Okay. still I?m gonna shoot you or any, you know 1 didn?t hear any of it. When the pop went Um?hm. was the blue of?cer? Was he still layin? on top of him? The light blue? Yeah. Yup. He was, he was still on top of him. He was still on top Hejumped. He, he. Okay. ?Cuz that would?ve gone off right by his (inaudible). Right. He, he was like you know and everybody was (inaudible) you know but I, was stuck because I, I watched his face, his head go, it?s like he lost his life, like right there in front of my face. His arm went Like limp. went limp. And when they got up off of him, his hands were still like this. Like those didn?t go to the side or. When you say like this you mean in front of his body. In front of his body, like he?s on his back and his hands are Page 18 of 21 PhilI-2015?648-A1 0 Together on his stomach on his stomach. Okay. And that, that?s when they finally both got up and walked you, you know moved away ?cuz the light blue shirt guy moved to the street, with his weapon now drawn. I seen him draw his weapon. Okay. And then when you looked at the guy layin? there, he, he was handcuffed. He was handcuffed. Okay. With his, you know, just kinda just no movement. No shufflin? no tryin? to get it right, you know like if, you know nothin?. No movement. And you just showed me the movement of the officer in the blue shirt, pulling his weapon out? Yes. With his left hand? Is that how you remember it (inaudible). Yes he had it in his left hand. So he left-handed it He had it in his left. So he was holding it here and he?s standin? in the street lookin? at all ya?ll. Yup. Okay. (inaudible) right?handed. i believe it was his left hand. Okay. 'Cuz he didn?t have no gun at all. He didn?t have a gun out at that time. Previous to that. No, he got to the street and then pulled his gun out. Okay. And you know what, I?m gonna take the left hand back. I am. I?m gonna take the left hand back. (inaudible) I don?t if you thinkin? when you're thinkin? about changin? what you?re thinkin?. I?m sayin? the light, the officer, when he was standin' in the street. Um-hm. l, I (inaudible) say, just say how you remember it you know, I don?t want you to overthink it. Right. And that?s what I think I?m doin?. (inaudible) yeah. It's however you remember it is how you remember it. Yeah. I only ask ?cuz I saw you do that movement (inaudible). Page 19 of 21 Phill?2015-648-A1 0 Right. And that?s why I was thinkin' it's his left hand but (inaudible). Are you left handed? l'm left-handed. Okay. Yeah. But the other officer um, yeah, um, now l?m not sure what hand he had it but I know he moved to the street, but, and watched him pull his gun out. The other officer was right, right hand? Which one? The 0-, the one that you said was carrying the gun around after the fact. (inaudible) Which guy, which guy was that? That was the light blue shirt guy. Oh. But not the shooter. That was the one that had, not the shooter. Okay. No he didn?t pull his gun out 'til he got to the street to kinda, (inaudible) 1 mean by that time To get people to back up. Yeah to get people to back up. 'Cuz if you think about the light shirt guy, was he carrying it like this? Or was he carrying it with his right hand. He had it down and out. I wanna say he was, in, it was in his left hand. Okay. The light officer. When threatening? He just had it out. Was he threatening people or he just have it out? He just had it out. Was he saying anything? Nope, l, and by that time, l?m yellin?, l?m like ljust watch you guys kill that man, you guys just killed that man. Why did you guys do that? You guys just killed that man and l?m (inaudible) and he wasn?t really sayin? anything. Just kinda and just kinda like kinda um, dark, like. (inaudible) waitin? for his back-up (inaudible). Yeah. And the other guy stood up over him and he, when he backed up he still stayed on that side of the street. And he you know, the body?s here and he?s now standin? like right here and he?s doin? this. Got on the radio. Yeah. Got on the radio. Okay. Alright l'm gonna stop the tape. (inaudible). Page 20 of 21 TT Um?hm. MP It is now 13:13 hours. Stopping tape. END OF RECORDING Phill-2015-648?A10 Page 21 of 21 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/35 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/22/2015 Approved By: Computer Aided Dispatch (CAD) Info and Visinet Data Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status) Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/22/2015 18:10 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/22/2015 18:14? Reporting LEO Date Supervisor . . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of1 VisiNet Browser Incident Information Incident Detail Report 5525.78.15 Reports - Incident Report Data Source: Data Warehouse Incident Status: Closed Incident number: 15423384 Incident Date: 1111 512015 00:40:07 Last Updated: 1111512015 09:51 :40 2 Of?cer Response Sergeant Alarm Level: Incident Type: Priority: 0 Determinant: Base Responsett: Confirmationii: Taken By: Scurry. Jena?CT Response Area: 410 Disposition: AST?Assist Cancel Reason: Incident Status: Closed Certi?cation: Longitude: 93300834 Incident Location Location Name: Address: 1611 Plymouth Av Apartment: 204 Building: City. State, Zip: MINNEAPOLIS MN 55411 Supplemental Information - Person PERSON 1 Name: clarkjamar oneal DOB: 05/03/1991 PERSON 2 PERSON 3 Supplemental Information - Vehicle VEHICLE 1 VIN: 1fdxe458fda2701 0 VEHICLE 2 VIN: 1 VEHICLE 3 License: 850pcv VEHICLE 4 License: 157HJH VEHICLE 5 License: VEHICLE 6 License: 974egg VEHICLE 7 License: 296LIVIH Cali Receipt Caller Name: RAYANNE Method Received: Caller Type: Time Stamps Description Date Time User Phone Pickup 11115/2015 00:40:07 Key Stroke 11/1 51201 5 00:40:07 In Waiting Queue 11/15/2015 00:40:07 Gall Taking Complete Problem: Agency: Jurisdiction: Division: Battalion: Response Plan: Command Ch: Primary TAG: Secondary TAG: Delay Reason (if any): Latitude: County: Location Type: Cross Street: Map Reference: OLS: OLS: OLS: Call Back Phone: Caller Location: Eiapsed Times Description Received to In Queue Call Taking Scurry, Jena?CT In Queue to 13?: Assign Page 1 of 16 Of?cer Needs Help (P) POLICE MPDIMFDIHCMC Precinct 4 P4 Sec 1X 2 Of?cer Sergeant 44991497 HENNEPIN KNOX AV NIJAMES AV 404F MN MN MN (612) 2826898 204 Time 00:00:00 00:00:32 http://170. 159. 1 1/ 1 5/20 15 VisiNet Browser 5.5.25.7 8.15 Reports - Incident Report Page 2 of 16 1st Unit Assigned 1171512015 00:40:39 Call Received to 1st Assign 00:00:32 1st Unit Enroute 11l1 572015 00:41:03 Assigned to 1st Enroute 00:00:24 131 Unit Arrived 1111512015 00:48:14 Enroute to 1st Arrived 00:07:11 Ctosed 1111512015 08:17:57 Bixby, Jenna Incident Duration 07:37:50 Resources Assigned Primary At Delay de. Odm. Unit Flag Assigned Disposition Enroute Staged Arrived Patient Avail Complete Enroute Arrived Cancel Reason 424 00:40:39 RPT?Report 00:41:03 00:48:14 01:05:13 04:33:48 4346.1 4346.1 352 00:50:54 HST-Assist 00:50:54 00:56:56 01:05:13 04:43:20 2777.4 2777.4 8222 00:51:05 AST-Assist 00:51:05 01:05:13 01:26:30 46251.3 330 00:51 :07 AST?Assist 00:51:07 01:05:13 01:26:11 2794.0 310 00:51:13 AST-Assist 00:51:13 00:55:44 01:05:13 01:19:39 4307.3 4307.3 420 00:51:22 AST~Assist 00:51:22 01:05:13 05:04:00 3773.5 162 00:51:25 RPT?Report 00:51:25 00:53:48 01:05:13 05:37:38 361.4 361.4 613 00:51:30 AST?Assist 00:51:30 00:56:42 01:05:13 01:16:32 110 00:51:41 00:51:41 00:54:03 01:05:13 01:17:08 107.8 107.8 120 00:51:41 AST?Assist 00:51:41 00:53:18 01:05:13 04:45:44 4214.3 4214.3 320 00:51:42 AST?Assist 00:51:42 01:05:13 01:18:59 387.0 111 00:52:03 RPT?Report 00:52:03 01:05:13 03:55:32 1388.0 8226 00:52:08 AST?Assist 00:52:08 01:05:14 01:16:16 3177.7 824 00:52:09 AST?Assist 00:52:09 00:53:46 01:05:14 01:31:29 875.5 875.5 850 00:52:14 AST?Assist 00:52:14 00:53:45 01:05:14 01:36:15 496.1 496.1 506 00:52:16 AST?Assist 00:52:16 00:59:45 01:05:14 02:00:32 6764.0 6764.0 321 00:52:25 AST-Assist 00:52:25 00:54:15 01:05:14 03:47:37 2666.5 2666.5 331 00:52:28 AST-Assist 00:52:28 00:55:36 01:05:14 01:17:49 2865.9 2865.9 560 00:52:29 AST?Assist 00:52:29 01 :05: 1 4 05:21:41 672.9 113 00:52:33 AST-Assist 00:52:33 01:05:14 01:23:29 1008.3 8212 00:52:36 AST?Assist 00:52:36 01:05:14 03:17:11 1217.6 160 00:52:41 ASST?Assist 00:52:41 01:05:14 01:32:12 606.5 121 00:52:51 AST-Assist 00:52:51 01:05:14 01:20:16 1616.9 09 00:52:56 00:56:04 01:05:14 03:42:28 EX?Unit Exchange 410 00:52:59 RPT?Report 00:52:59 00:56:15 01:05:14 04:14:51 369.1 369.1 530 00:53:00 00:53:00 00:58:46 01:05:14 03:42:45 3006.5 3006.5 608 00:53:08 AST-Assist 00:53:08 00:55:06 01:05:14 08:17:57 223 00:53:17 AST-Assist 00:5311 7 01:05:14 01:18:41 3271.2 T105 00:53:23 AST?Assist 00:53:23 01:05:14 01:10:57 211 00:53:36 AST?Assist 00:53:36 00:57:58 01:05:14 01:37:18 3104.8 3104.8 561 00:53:36 AST-Assist 00:53:36 01:05:15 02:29:31 863.3 8220 00:53:41 AST-Assist 00:53:41 00:56:15 01:31:47 5914.9 513 00:53:42 AST-Assist 00:53:42 01:02:11 01:05:15 01:25:16 8087.1 8087.1 HC 00:54:43 AST~Assist 00:54:43 01:05:15 05:17:34 407 00:54:45 AST-Assist 00:54:45 01:04:32 05:51 :17 6817.2 425 00:54:51 AST?Assist 00:54:51 01:05:15 05:57:34 678.6 105 00:54:54 00:54:54 01:05:15 02:52:27 470.9 311 00:55:11 AST-Assist 00:55:11 00:55:40 01:05:15 01:31:56 846.5 846.5 361 00:55:22 AST-Assist 00:55:22 00:55:38 01:05:15 06:10:20 1669.1 1669.1 341 00:55:31 AST?Assist 00:55:31 01:05:15 01 :31 :41 2684.0 521 00:55:32 AST-Assist 00:55:32 01:05:15 01:25:14 668.4 340 00:55:33 AST-Assist 00:55:33 01:05:15 01:32:13 4672.5 430 00:56:26 AST?Assist 00:56:26 00:59:37 01:05:15 05:14:32 903.3 903.3 531 00:56:27 AST-Assist 00:56:27 01:04:24 01:05:15 01:21:06 1191.2 1191.2 213 00:56:31 AST?Assist 00:56:31 01:05:1 5 01:28:36 102.9 207 00:56:41 AST?Assist 00:56:41 01:05:15 01:18:11 9636.3 149 00:57:03 AST?Assist 00:57:03 01:05:15 01:09:37 401.3 131 00:57:26 AST?Assist 00:57:26 01:05:15 01:19:40 7414.3 132 00:57:26 AST-Assist 00:57:26 00:59:14 01:05:15 01:18:53 71559.2 71559.2 221 00:57:26 AST?Assist 00:57:26 01:05:15 01:28:13 250.4 957 00:57:26 AST?Assist 00:57:26 00:59:19 01:05:15 02:25:05 511 00:57:26 AST-Assist 00:57:26 01:05:15 01:18:57 2223.1 6224 00:57:31 ASST-Assist 00:57:31 01:05:15 02:02:42 6280.3 953 00:58:11 AST?Assist 00:58:11 01:02:36 01:05:16 02:09:58 411 00:58:30 RPT?Report 00:58:30 00:58:57 01:05:16 06:14:42 1327.7 1327.7 421 01:03:47 AST?Assist 01:03:47 01:05:16 05:26:44 6678.9 06 01:04:23 RPT?Report 01:05:16 07:52:54 881 01:08:40 ADV~Advised 01:08:40 01:11:11 9448.7 505 01:11:23 RPT?Report 01:11:23 01:17:38 1 03:26:23 2585.4 6402 01:12:33 lNS-Inservice01z12:33 01:12:34 01:24:31 7405.5 7405.5 431 01:37:37 RPT?Report 01:37:37 01:37:48 05:31:44 3409.3 510 01:40:45 AST-Assist 03:23:01 401 01:46:28 AST?Assist 06:57:43 122 01:56:51 AST?Assist 02:44:48 1 1/15/2015 19 21 4402 530 407 21 Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports ~Inmde111: Report 02:16:30 RPT?Report 07:53:00 02:30:42 RPT?Report 02:30:42 03:44:29 03:51:56 06:34:50 02:33:54 lNS-lnservice 02:33:58 02:40:05 06:10:33 783.1 03:43:41 AST?Assist 03:43:41 03:43:51 05:02:32 3006.5 05:53:37 AST?Assist 05:53:37 05:53:39 08:17:47 6817.2 07:16:33 RPT?Report 07:16:33 07:51:54 Personnel Assigned Un? 424 362 8222 330 310 420 162 613 8226 824 850 506 321 331 560 561 8220 6224 953 41 1 421 881 505 6402 431 510 401 1 22 21 4402 530 Name .-Ringgenberg, Mark (006030); Schwarze, Dustin (006422) Boelk, Michael (000605): Robins, David (006046) Cragin, Russell (001327): Knoll, Ryan (003748) Allen, Andrew (000037); Parsons, Kevin (005455) Cummings, Brian (001360); Plys, Graham (005756) Lewis, Robert (004101); Neison, Michael (005033) Hillbo, Grif?n (093112) Grayton, Steven (004303) Schmidt. Corey (006369) Bishop, Christopher (000563); Ketchmark, Zakari A (003682) Costello Tim 001305 Osbeck, Angela (005378) - f?cer; Peterson, Cole A (005564) Grimstad, David 8 (116771); Pham, Caivin (121284) Of?cer Archer, John (119909); Hursh, Zebariah (123458) Brown, Kristopher (000824); Hansen, David (002680) Martin, William (004433); Womble, Aaron (007851) Stewart, Joshua (006824); Trebesch, Jesse (007277) Sonday, Michael (006709) Dang, Bach (001425): Krautkramer, Cory A (003854) Chorlton, Thomas (001126): Payne, Daniel (005497) Appiedorn. Sherry (030214) Beman, Cameron (000383); Huynh, Paui (003198) Novak, James (005219) Grout, Gabriel (111524) Daoheuang, Souphaphone (001424); Hickey. Conan (002997) Suker, Gene (007004) Crofion, Jesse (001341); Judkins, George (003596) Noble. Brandon (005153); Shafer, Lee (006329) May. Daniel (004513) Derhaag, Steven (001521); Murray, Nicole (004904) Bernardson. Thomas (000516); Hagen, Joel (002618) - Community Service Of?cer M0 Bride, Stephen A (004517) Conner, Chad (001263); Sworski, Jeffrey 8 (007113) Campbell. Thomas (097371) Domek, Joshua (001573); Johnson. Ashley (003302) Andreas, Corey (000168): Cushenbery, Christopher 0 (001375) Thunder, Robert A (007232) Dominguez, Mack (001575); Martinez-Gavina. Oscar (004436) Castle, Bryan (001027) Nordin, Michaet (005183); Rodin, Anthony (006075) Crabb, Brian (001326); Joseph, Kyle (003639) Carrero, Ryan (001003); Dittman, Joel (001552) Rowe, Nicholas (006178) Moua. Chou (004897) Brazeau, Peter (000750) - Community Service Of?cer; Reed, Andrew (005915) Moen, Adam (004832): Pobuda, Jonathon (005759) Osuji, Joseph (005387); Truong, Benjamin (007311) - Of?cer Lindquist, Matthew 3 (004169) Dziuk, Nathan (001649): Johnson, Benjamin (003294) Gregory, William (002450) Brandt, Shawn (000746) Badowich, Benjamin (000251); Shanklin, Nicholas (006488) Ledman, Daniel (004062); Yang, Toua (007892) Wood?li. Brian (101293) Pucely, Joel (108184) Rockiin Jr., Michael (006071) Hedberg, Anna (002927) Muvundamina, Guislain (004907); Saint Jean, Justin 0 (006247) Friestleben. Michael (002120) Ali, Abdiwahab A (000030) Christensen, Jenna (116645); Lenway, Nicole (119885) Wheeler, Thomas (007710) Daoheuang, Souphaphone (001424); Hickey, Conan 0 (002997) Page 3 of 16 http://170. 159. 13 isiNetBrowser/ earch/InciclentReport. - 1 1/ 1 5/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 Reports - Incident Report 407 21 Pro-Scheduled information No Pro-Scheduled Information Transports No Transports Information Transport Legs No Transports Information Comments Date 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 Time 00:19:42 00:19:59 00:20:24 00:20:32 00:20:45 00:20:52 00:21 :51 00:40:07 00:40:07 00:40:13 00:40:23 00:42:18 00:48:00 00:48:05 00:50:20 00:50:20 00:50:29 00:50:31 00:50:34 00:50:34 00:50:37 00:50:45 00:50:54 00:50:54 00:51:05 00:51:09 00:51:12 00:51:15 00:51:24 00:51:25 00:51 :31 00:51:41 00:51:51 00:51:51 00:51:52 00:52:03 00:52:16 Mo Bride, Stephen A1004517) Jensen, Steven (003287); Schultz. Michael (116525) User SYS SYS SYS CT123095 SYS CT123095 CT123096 000033598 000033598 000033598 000033598 000033598 000014497 000014497 000033598 000033598 000014497 000033598 000033598 000033598 00001449? 121521 121521 119080 119080 121621 109577 0T1 12741 121621 108992 000014497 103992 000033598 000033593 000014497 1 08992 108992 Type Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Page 4 of 16 Cont. Comments Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] 1 HOUR AGO CLR BROKE UP A FIGHT IN LOBBY, CLRS ANKLE NOW HURTING A LOT [Shared] Possible E911 Wireless Phase 2 update[Shared] ALL PERSON THAT WERE ARE NOT LONGER ON SITE[Shared] CLR NOT ABLE TO WALK ON SEND SON OTS TO LOOK FOR Mum-Agency EMS Incident#: 15076386 [61] [Appended, 00:56:21] Multi-Agenoy POLICE incident 11: 15-423384[Shared] EMS REQ SQUADS CODE 3 [Shared] [10] ASSAILANT iS 30 FT IN FRONT OF AMBULANCE [Shared] [11] EMS IS CODE 4. STILL REQ SQUADS CODE 3 [Shared] [12] IS NOW AT AMB DOOR [Shared] [13] EMS STILL CODE 4 INFO FOR POLICE ONLY [Shared] [14] Duplicate call of incident number 15076391 [Shared] [62] [Appended, 00:56:21] [14] [14] Duplicate salt of incident number 15076386IShared] [15] EMS REPORTING SHOTS FIRED [Shared] [53] [Appended, 00:56:21] [15] [15] [Notification] Problem changed from Medical Misc(E) to Emotional Disturb PersonEMS(E) by EMS[Shared] [64] [Appended 00:56:21] [16] Muiti?Agency EMS Incident 15076391 [65] [Appended, 00:56:21] [17] [Noti?cation] [EMS]?Problem changed from Emotional Disturb PersonEMS(E) to Paramedic Needs Help by EMS [Shared] [66] [Appended 00:56:21] [18] [Noti?cation] [EMS]-Probiem changed from Emotional Disturb PersonEMS(E) to Paramedic Needs Help by EMS [Shared] [16] 424 SHOTS FIRED [Shared] [17] [Page] Probtem changed from Assist EMS Personnet (P) to Of?cer Needs Help (P) [Shared] [18} Backed up 424 with 362 [Shared] [19] Backed up 424 with 8222 [Shared] [20] 424 LARGE CROWD WITH ONE DOWN [Shared] [21] 802 ACK - RING [Shared] [67] [Appended, 00:56:21] [19] DETECTED ONE AT 1600 PLYMOUTH. [Shared] [22] Backed up 424 with 420 [Shared] [23] Backed up 424 with 162 [Shared] [68] [Appended 00:56:21] [20] [Noti?cation] [EMS]-Problern changed from Paramedic Needs Help to Medical Misc(E) by EMS [Shared] [24] Backed up 424 with 110,120 [Shared] [69] [Appended, 00:56:21] [21] Multi?Agency FIRE ncident#: 15-0037585 [70] [Appended. 00:56:21] [22] [Noti?cation] changed from Medical Misc(E) to Shooting by EMS [Shared] {71] [Appended, 00:56:21] [23] [Noti?cation] [EMS]?Problem changed from Medical Misc(E) to Shooting by EMS [Shared] [25] Backed up 110 with 111 [Shared] [26] Backed up 110 with 506 [Shared] http://170. 159.13 0.7/VisiNetBr0wser/S . .. 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5.525.78. 15 - Repelts Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 00:52:25 00:52:25 00:52:29 00:52:34 00:52:41 00:52:52 00:52:56 00:52:59 00:52:59 00:53:00 00:53:01 00:53:05 00:53:24 00:53:24 00:53:36 00:53:41 00:53:45 00:54:22 00: 54:28 00:54:43 00:54:46 00:54:51 00:54:54 00:54:58 00:55:04 00:55:1 1 00:55:22 00:55:25 00:55:29 00:55:31 00:55:32 00:55:33 00:56:05 00:56:16 00:56:27 00:56:31 00:56:41 00:57:04 00:57:04 00:57:27 00:57:31 00:5821 1 00:58:17 00:58:30 00:58:36 00:58:53 00:59:21 01:02:13 01:02:44 01:03:47 01:04:23 01:04:27 01:04:32 01:09:30 01:11:23 01:11:59 01:12:59 01:15:50 01:21:06 01:22:11 112776 121621 108992 121621 108992 108992 109577 121621 112776 108992 109577 119080 121621 F106504 108992 119080 121621 121621 CT123096 119080 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 119080 119080 121621 E419 119080 108992 119080 F106504 INT 121621 119080 119080 108992 121621 121621 119080 121621 00001 4497 121621 121621 F106504 109577 E443 F106504 121521 109577 109577 121621 121621 108992 121621 121621 121621 121621 060897 Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Responsa Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Page 5 of 16 [27] 424 NEED EMS CODE 3 [Shared] [28] Backed up 424 with 321 [Shared] [29] Backed up 506 with 560 [Shared] [30] 424 NEEDING PLYMOUTH SHUT DOWN [Shared] [31] Backed up 110 with 160 [Shared] [32] Backed up 110 with 121 [Shared] [33] Backed up 424 with 09 [Shared] [34] Backed up 424 with 410 [Shared] [35] Multi?Agency FIRE Incident 150037586 [36] Backed up 506 with 530 [Shared] [37] 09 RESPONDING TO SCENE [Shared] [38] TRANSIT onp [Shared] [39] Backed up 424 with T105 [Shared] [40] LINK: [15423384] to [15-0037585] because [15- 0037586] appends to [15?0037585] [41] Backed up 506 with 561 [Shared] [42] Backed up 424 with 8220 [Shared] [43] NEED SQD AT [Shared] [44] NEED SQDS ON NORTH SIDE OF PLYMOUTH [Shared] [45] CO HAS 3 DEPUTIES ENROUTE TO 1.00 [Shared] [46] Backed up 424 with HC [Shared] [47] Backed up 424 with 407 [Shared] [48] Backed up 424 with 425 [Shared] [49] Backed up 424 with 105 [Shared] [50] 105 ON SCENE [Shared] [511407 6 BLOCKS OUT [Shared] [52] Backed up 424 with 311 [Shared] [53] Backed up 424 with 361 [Shared] [54] NEEDING CHEM SPRAY AT ELKS CLUB [Shared] [55] EMS Transporting to: NORTH [Shared] [56] Backed up 424 with 341 [Shared] [57] Backed up 506 with 521 [Shared] [58] Backed up 424 with 340 [Shared] {59] E4 STAGING AT C4 [Shared] [60] Unit 8220 in 04 Code 4 status. [Shared] [72] Backed up 424 with 430 [Shared] [73] Backed up 424 with 213 [Shared] [74] Backed up 424 with 207 [Shared] [75] Backed up 105 with 149 [Shared] [76] 425 ENOUGH RESPONDING CAN SLOW IF NOT ARRIVED [Shared] [77] Backed up 424 with 131,132.221,957.511 [Shared] [78] Backed up 424 with 6224 [Shared] [79] Backed up 424 with 953 [Shared] [80] EMS NEEDS FIRE AT AMB 2 BLOCKS WEST OF SCENE [Shared] [81] Backed up 424 with 411 [Shared] [821411 WITH EMS [Shared] [83] E4 EN ROUTE TO 2 BLOCKS [Shared] [84] PRELIM PIO PAGE SENT [Shared] [85] EMS Transporting to: HCMC [Shared] [86] Secondary Location for E4: HCMC. 701 PARK MN 55415. [Shared] [87] Backed up 424 with 421 [Shared] [88] Backed up 424 with 06 [Shared] [89] 06 RESPONDING TO SCENE [Shared] [901407 C4 ON THE HELP CALL [Shared] [911411 a ARRIVED AT HCMC [Shared] [92] Backed up 506 with 505 [Shared] [93] 111 WITH 4118 AT HCMC TO ASST WITH C4 [Shared] [94] PER HC 1123 WILL HAVE SQDS ENROUTE TO HCMC FOR NEXT FEW HOURS [Shared] [95] 111 Unit 111 current position updated to 701 PARK AV (HOMO). [Shared] [96] 105 FEMALE AT NMMC FROM PLYMOUTH LOCATION [Shared] [97] [PageJPaging Group Notified: MPD Command Staff Paging Group (803). Sent From: 801. Comment: P4 OFCR INVOLVED SHOOTING - 1611 http://170. 15 9.13 . .. 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5 525.7815 - Reports Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 01:23:51 01:24:06 01:24:57 01:29:58 01:31:24 01:37:49 01:38:20 01:38:46 01:38:58 01:40:17 01:40:45 01:40:53 01:41:24 01:42:07 01:46:28 01:46:31 01:56:10 01:56:51 01:56:59 01:57:08 02:12:19 02:13:10 02:16:13 02:16:30 02:25:58 060897 060897 060897 060 897 060897 INT 1 09577 109577 109577 006488 109577 109577 1 09577 060897 109577 000168 109577 109577 109577 109577 108992 109577 060897 060897 004907 Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Response Page 6 of 16 PLYMOUTH AV - SUSPECT IS TRANS TO HCMC - 010 407 MCBRID CAR OS LT NOVAK HE CCN Ig?aired] [98 CAR 06 P10 ELDER ACK [Shared] [99] CAR 7702 LT ZIMMERMAN ACK [Shared] {100} DC ARNESON ACK [Shared] [101] INVESTIGATORS GREEN AND VILLELA RESPONDING [Shared] [102] COMMANDER GRANGER ACK [Shared] [103] Unit 431 in C4 Code 4 status. [Shared] [104] Secondary Location for 162: NORTH. 3220 LOWRY AV MN 55422. [Shared] [105] Secondary Location for 361: NORTH. 3220 LOWRY AV MN 55422. [Shared] [106] Secondary Location for 105: NORTH, 3220 LOWRY AV MN 55422. [Shared] [107] TO: MPASZX-00180615 20151115 01:39:32 0668026187 FROM: A36MPQ42-16576018 20151115 01:39:32 OCBBOOD084 TXT DISSEMINATION BRYANT AVE N. DISABILITY CERTIFICATESN DONOR2N DESIGNATED #03/26/13 MN ID CS 17 INVALIDATED 06/17/15 NOTICE RE REQUIREMENTS SENT *05/18/15 REV - FAIL TO PROVIDE INS CONV 00030 06/17/15 03/09/14 *06/11/14 SUSP - FAIL TO APPEAR OR PAY FINES 27 03/09/14 DRIVING AFTER WITHDRAWAL - NO ACTION 227 20151 18 03/09/14 FAIL TO PROVIDE INSURANCE INFO - CONVICTION 227 2015118 03l09/14 FAIL TO AP PEAR 27 2014162 *01/23/14 SUSP FAIL TO APPEAR OR PAY FINES 27 10/17/13 INSTRUCTION LICENSE VIOLATION 127 2015118 10/17/13 FAIL TO APPEAR 27 2014023 END VIOLATIONS [Shared] [108] Backed up 424 with 510 [Shared] [109] Secondary Location for 510: NORTH, 3220 LOWRY AV MN 55422. [Shared] [110] 105 162 510 AND 361 ALL RESPONDING TO NORTH MEMORIAL [Shared] [111] HALVORSON ACK - EA RESPONDING [Shared] [112] Backed up 424 with 401 [Shared] [1131361 ENRT TO NMMC [Shared] [114] 111 REQ SQD TO WATCH EMS RIG 443 [Shared] [115] Backed up 111 with 122 [Shared] [116] Secondary Location for122: HOMC EMS, 601 PARK AVMINNEAPOLIS, MN 55415. [Shared] [117] 122 GUARDING EMS RIG 443 [Shared] [1181122 4 FAMILY MEMEBERS ARRIVED AT HCMC [Shared] [119] PER 122 - FAMILY MEMBERS STARTING TO SHOW UP AT HCMC [Shared] {120] CAR 19 HAGEL RESPONDING [Shared] [121] Backed up 407 with 19 [Shared] [122] TO: MPB176-00237629 20151115 02:25:37 08A303AOSD FROM: A36MPQ47-04703339 20151115 02:25:37 08A300F01 TXT CNTY CMED. SNIW1600 PRAIRIE DR. http://I 70. 159. 1 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports Incident Report Page 7 of 16 P155340-5421 . FDXE4 0. 5. D. ONLY NO PLATE ISSUED [Shared] 11/1 51201 5 02:31 :34 119885 Response [123] enrouie to 4th PCT ?rst [Shared] 1111512015 02:32:10 000168 Response [124] TRPT HCMC PARAMEDIC TO ROOM 108 [Shared] 1111512015 02:33:54 050897 Response [125] Backed up 407 with 4402 [Shared] . 1111512015 02:41:03 000030 Response gcigaggfg?fg 't was dete'm'?9d that 11/15/2015 02:42:25 000014497 Response [127] has closed their incident [15075385] [128] The keys of the rig was handed to another paramedic 11/1 512015 02:42:55 000030 Response (CARA BIGELOW, BADGE 4491), and she took custody of the rig [Shared] . . [129] guarding and will be towing HCMC rig 419 at NMMC to 1111512015 02.45.45 004907 Response the forensic garage [Shared] 1111512015 03:22:34 004907 Response [130] tow took rig to impound [Shared] 1111512015 03:43:41 121521 Response [131] Backed up HC with 530 [Shared] [132] FROM NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE - . . FROM 0050 HOURS. TEMP 48 W1 52015 03'45'12 ?1127?? Respmse DEGREES. HUMIDITY: 58%. CLEAR SKIES. WIND FROM THE AT 3 MPH. [Shared] 1111512015 04:19:59 F119080 Response [133] Mum-Agency FIRE Incident 15-0037509 1111512015 04:19:59 F119080 Response [134] 407 REQ MFD TO SCENE FOR WASHDOWN 1111512015 04:27:27 121521 Response [135] 407 WILL BE TAKING DOWN TAPE [Shared] 1111512015 04:31 :59 Response [135] has closed their incident [137] 407 THE 1111512015 04:32:47 121521 Response RESPONSE COMPLETE REPORTS [Shared] 1111512015 04:43:20 352 Response [138] WILL ADD SU PP LEM ENT [Shared] 1111512015 05:53:37 121521 Response [139] Backed up 425 with 407 [Shared] Address Changes No Address Changes Priority Changes Date Time Changed from Priority Reason User 1111512015 00:50:54 1 Default 1 Alarm Level Changes No Alarm Level Changes Activity Log Date Time Radio Activity Location Log Entry User 1111512015 00:40:07 Incident in Waiting Queue 11/15/2015 00:40:07 MultiAgencyResponse Originating Inc: EMS Inc#15075355 000033598 11/15/2015 00:40:14 11/15/2015 00:40:17 1111512015 00:40:39 424 1111512015 00:41 :03 424 1111512015 00:41 :41 1111512015 00:48:14 424 1111512015 00:50:54 362 1111512015 00:50:54 Read Incident Incident in Waiting Queue Timer Clear Dispatched EnRoute UserAction A Arrived Dispatched Problem Nature 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av Incident 401 was Marked as Read. 121521 121521 Responding From NEWTON AVE 121521 AVE User clicked Exit/Save CT123095 Unit speed at the time of status change 10.00 119080 ID 4508401 A Change in the 121621 Problem Nature change from Assist EMS Personnel (P) to Officer Needs 1111512015 00:50:54 352 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 111151201 5 1111512015 1111512015 http://l 70.1 59.] 3 .. 00:50:54 00:51:05 00:51 :05 00:51 :05 00:51:07 00:51:07 00:51:13 00:51:13 00:51:14 424 8222 8222 424 330 330 310 310 352 EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched Echute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Route Deviation 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av LAKE ST EH 8 AVE Help (P) Responding From LAKE ST 119080 AVE Backed up with 352 119050 119050 Responding From WASHINGTON 119080 AVE ST SE Backed up with 8222 119080 VISINET Responding From 34 AVE 8154 ST Responding From BLOOMINGTON AVE124 ST Unit 352 deviated from original M1 11/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 Reports - Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 111151201 5 00:51 :22 00:51:22 00:51 :22 00:51 :25 00:51:25 00:51:25 00:51:30 00:51:30 00:51:32 00:51:41 00:51:41 00:51:41 00:51:41 00:51:41 00:51:42 00:51:42 00:51:57 00:52:03 00:52:03 00:52:03 00:52:07 00:52:08 00:52:08 00:52:09 00:52:09 00:52:14 00:52:14 00:52:16 00:52:16 00:52:16 00:52:25 00:52:25 00:52:25 00:52:28 00:52:28 00:52:29 00:52:29 00:52:29 00:52:33 00:52:33 00:52:36 00:52:36 00:52:41 00:52:41 00:52:41 00:52:51 00:52:51 00:52:51 00:52:56 00:52:56 00:52:59 00:52:59 00:52:59 420 420 424 162 162 424 e13 613 110 110 120 120 424 320 320 111 111 110 8226 8226 824 824 850 850 506 505 110 321 321 424 331 331 560 560 506 113 113 8212 8212 160 160 110 121 121 110 424 410 410 Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute UserAction Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute UserAction Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up UserAction Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched Unit Backed up MultiAgencyResponse Dispatched EnRoute 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1011 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1511 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1511 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av driving directions route Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 420 Responding From GRANT ST AVE Backed up with 162 Responding From BLOOMINGTON ST User clicked Exit/Save Responding From 4 ST AVE Page 8 of 16 121621 121621 121621 108992 108992 108992 CT119779 108992 108992 108992 Responding From WASHINGTON 108992 AVE N13 AVE Backed up with 110120 108992 Responding From 3 AVE ST User clicked Exit/Save Responding From ROYALSTON AVE AVE Backed up with 111 User clicked Exit/Save Responding From RIVER PKY EIISEYMOUR AVE SE Responding From WEST RIVER RD RIVER PKY Responding From WEST RIVER RD RIVER PKY Responding From NICOLLET ST Backed up with 506 CT1 12777 108992 108992 108992 CT1 19779 VisiN ET \fisiN ET 108992 108992 108992 121621 Responding From WASHINGTON 121621 AVE N12 AVE Backed up with 321 121621 Responding From HIAWATHA TO WB AVE 108992 Responding From 18 ST AVE 108992 8 Backed up with 560 1 08992 ET Responding From 3 ST TO WB 1941\2 AVE WSTNET Responding From CENTRAL AVE NE 108992 Responding From 4 ST AVE 108992 8 Backed up with 160 108992 108992 Responding From 4 ST 5115 AVE 108992 8 Backed up with 121 Backed up with 09 Generated Inc: FIRE Inc/1515? 0037586 Responding From PLYMOUTH 1 08992 1 09577 1 09577 1 1 2776 121521 121621 http://170. 1 59. 13 isiNetBrowser/ earch/Incidentchort.as px?id=4608. . . 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports - Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 00:52:59 00:53:00 00:53:00 00:53:00 00:53:02 00253205 00:53:08 00:53:08 00:53:17 00:53:17 00:53:18 00:53:23 00:53:23 00:53:23 00:53:24 00:53:36 00:53:36 00:53:36 00:53:36 00:53:36 00:53:41 00:53:41 00:53:41 00:53:42 00:53:42 00:53:45 00:53:45 00:53:48 00:54:03 00:54:15 00:54:41 00:54:43 00:54:43 00:54:43 00:54:45 00:54:45 00:54:45 00:54:48 00:54:51 00:54:51 00:54:51 00:54:54 00:54:54 00:54:54 00:55:06 00:55:11 00:55:11 00:55:11 00:55:22 00:55:22 00:55:22 424 530 530 506 608 508 223 223 120 T105 T105 424 211 211 561 561 506 8220 8220 424 513 513 850 824 162 110 321 8212 425 425 424 105 105 424 608 311 311 424 361 361 424 Unit Backed up Dispatched En Route Unit Backed up UserAction UserAction Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute A Arrived Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Link incident Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived Route Deviation Dispatched EriRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Route Deviation Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up AArrived Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av BROADWAY ST AVE NE 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av BROADWAY ST AVE NE 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av AVE AVE Backed up with 410 Responding From 60 ST AVE Backed up with 530 User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Responding From FREMONT AVE Nl26 AVE Responding From 20 AVE ST NE Responding From 2312 6 ST Backed up with T105 LINK: [15423384] to [is-0037585] because [15-0037586] appends to [1 5-0037585] Page 9 of 16 121621 108992 108992 108992 1 12776 1 1 9080 ET ET 121621 121621 121621 106504 WsiN ET Responding From CENTRAL AVE \nsiNET NE Responding From NICOLLET ST Backed up with 561 Responding From UNIVERSITY AVE AVE NE Backed up with 8220 Responding From NICOLLET ST Unit speed at the time of status change: 16.00 Unit speed at the time of status change 55.00 Unit 8212 deviated from original driving directions route 108992 108992 108992 119080 119080 119080 \?siN ET ET M1 119080 Responding From 3623 Colfax Av 119080 Backed up with HC Responding From PENN AVE AVE Backed up with 407 Unit 211 deviated from original driving directions route 119080 121621 121621 121621 M1 121621 Responding From MORGAN AVE 121621 AVE Backed up with 425 Responding From 1 AVE ST Backed up with 105 Responding From 7 ST WHITE MEMORIAL BLVD Backed up with 311 Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 361 121621 121521 121621 121621 VisiN ET 119080 119080 119080 119080 119080 119080 http://l 70.159. 1 1/15/20 1.5 VisiNe?t Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports - Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015' 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 isiNetBrowser/ 1 1/15/2015 00:55:31 00:55:31 00:55:31 00:55:32 00:55:32 00:55:32 00:55:33 00:55:33 00:55:33 00:55:36 00:55:38 00:55:40 00:55:44 00:56:04 00:56:15 00:56:15 00:56:22 00:56:26 00:56:26 00:56:26 00:56:27 00:56:27 00:56:31 00:56:31 00:56:31 00:56:41 00:56:41 00:56:41 00:56:42 00:56:56 00:57:03 00:57:03 00:57:03 00:57:10 00:57:10 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:26 00:57:31 00:57:31 00:57:31 00:57:58 00:58:11 00:53:11 00:58:410 8220 430 430 424 531 531 213 213 424 207 207' 424 61 3 362 149 149 105 131 131 132 132 221 221 957 957 511 511 424 e224 6224 424 211 953 953 424 Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived C4 Code 4 Append Incident Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up A Arrived A Arrived Dispatched A Arrived Unit Backed up UserAction User/Action Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Dispatched A Arrived Unit Backed up A Arrived Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Piymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Piymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av Responding From WB l94 TO LYN DALE AVE AVE Backed up with 341 Responding From FRANCE AVE LAKE AVE Backed up with 521 Responding From OLSON MEMORIAL AVE Backed up with 340 Dispatcher Appended [15-423400] to this incident Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 430 Page 10 of 16 119080 119080 119080 105992 108992 108992 119080 119080 119080 121621 121621 121621 121621 Responding From SB l35W TO ST 35W 88 Responding From AVE AVE Backed up with 213 Responding From WEST AVE Backed up with 207 Unit speed at the time of status change 37.00 Unit speed at the time of status change 00.00 Backed up with 149 User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE 119080 119080 119080 119080 119080 119080 VisiN ET 108992 108992 108992 CT119779 CT121623 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 Responding From 10th ave se/4th 121621 street se 121621 Responding From 1611 Plymouth 121621 Av Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 131.132,221.957.511 Backed up with 6224 Unit speed at the time of status change 00.00 Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 953 121621 121621 121621 119080 119080 119080 121621 121621 121621 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports - Incident Report 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 111151201 5 1111512015 11115/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1015/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 http:/l 1 70. .159. 13 0.7fV isiNetBrowser/ 08. 00:58:19 00:58:30 00:58:30 00:58:30 00:58:46 00:58:46 00:58:46 00:58:49 00:58:57 00:59:04 00:59:14 00:59:16 00:59:19 00:59:37 00:59:45 01:00:07 01:00:29 01:00:37 01:00:39 01:00:40 01:00:45 01:01 :04 01:01 :15 01:01:42 01:01:57 01:02:04 01 :02:1 1 01 :02:27 01:02:36 01:02:58 01:03:46 01:03:47 01:03:47 01:03:47 01:03:57 01:04:14 01:04:20 01:04:23 01:04:23 01:04:24 01:04:32 01:04:37 01:04:46 01:05:424 531 407 430 506 424 Custom Timer Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up A Arrived Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer A Arrived Custom Timer A Arrived Custom Timer A Arrived A Arrived A Arrived Custom Timer UserAction Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer A Arrived UserAction A Arrived Custom Timer Custom Timer Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up Custom Timer Custom Timer Custom Timer Dispatched Unit Backed up AArrived C4 Code 4 Custom Timer Custom Timer C4 Code 4 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Piymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE Backed up with 411 Unit speed at the time of status change :47.00 At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. Unit speed at the time of status change: 11.00 At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. User clicked Exit/Save At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as iate. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. Unit speed at the time of status change: 00.00 User cticked Exit/Save At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unlt marked as late. Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE NUAMES AVE Backed up with 421 At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Probtem/Nat- Unit marked as late. Backed up with 06 Unit speed at the time of status change: 05.00 C4 ON THE HELP CALL At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as iate. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. Page 11 of 16 121621 121621 121621 \fisiNET \flsiNET D808 CT119779 121621 121621 121621 10057? 109577 121621 121621 11/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78. 15 Reports Incident Report 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111 512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 11/1512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 http://170. 159.13 isiNetBrowser/S earoh/ 1 1115/2015 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:13 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:14 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:15 01:05:16 01:05:16 01:05:16 01:05:16 01:07:25 01:08:13 01:08:40 01:08:40 01:09:12 01:09:37 01:10:57 01:11:11 01:11:23 01:11:23 01:11:23 01:12:14 01:12:33 01:12:33 01:12:34 362 8222 330 8225 824 850 506 321 331 560 1 13 8212 160 121 09 410 530 608 223 T105 211 561 513 6224 953 41 1 421 06 881 881 149 T105 881 505 505 506 6402 6402 6402 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 04 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 04 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 C4 Code 4 UserAction UserActlon Dispatched EnRoute Use rAction Available Available Available Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up UserAction Dispatched EnRoute A Arrived 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Piymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 161 1 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Ptymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Piymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE User clicked Exit/Save Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE NURVING AVE Backed up with 505 User clicked Exit/Save Responding From 18 AVE AVE Unit speed at the time of status change 00.00 Page 12 of 16 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 CT119779 CT112777 WNNET CT123096 \fisiNET 121621 \fisiNET 108992 108992 108992 060897 \?siN ET \flsiNET VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 01:16:16 01:16:32 01:17:08 01:17:38 01:17:49 01:18:11 01:18:41 01:18:53 01:18:57 01:18:59 01:19:09 01:19:39 01:19:40 01:20:16 01:20:27 01:21 :06 01:23:29 01:24:06 01:24:31 01:25:14 01:25:16 01:25:34 01:26:03 01:26:11 01:26:30 01:28:13 01:28:36 01:29:39 01:31:29 01 :31 :41 01:31 :47 01:31:56 01:32:04 01:32:12 01:32:13 01:34:08 01:36:15 01 :36:45 01:37:18 01:37:37 01:37:37 01:37:48 01:38:20 01:38:46 01:38:46 01:38:58 01:39:30 01:40:45 01:40:45 01:40:53 01:41:10 01:42:15 01:45:21 01:46:28 01 :46:28 01:52:41 01:56:51 01:56:51 01:56:59 8225 613 110 505 331 207 223 132 511 320 113 310 131 121 531 113 5402 521 513 330 8222 221 213 824 341 8220 311 424 510 401 424 351 122 111 122 Available Available Available 4 Code 4 Available Available Available Available Available Available Route Deviation Available Available Available UserAction Available Available UserAction Available Available Available UserAction UserAction Available Available Available Available UserAction Available Available Available Available UserAction Available Available Use rAction Available UserAction Available Dispatched EnRoute C4 Code 4 E2 EnRoute 2nd Loc E2 EnRoute 2nd Loo Supplemental Information E2 EnRoute 2nd Loc Supplemental Information Dispatched Unit Backed up E2 EnRoule 2nd Loc UserAction UserAction UserAction Dispatched Unit Backed up A2 Arrived 2nd Loc Dispatched Unit Backed up E2 EnRoute 2nd Loc 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth AV 1611 Plymouth Av PLYMOUTH AVE AVE 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 161 '1 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av NORTH NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av HCMC EMS Unit 113 deviated from original driving directions route User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE incident ID 4508401, 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038. incident iD 4608401, 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038, Page 13 of16 108992 121621 109577 M1 \?siN ET 1 1 2776 VisiN ET 060897 121621 \frsiNET 060897 D308 VisiN ET VisiN ET 12777 WsiN ET 1 19080 1 19080 060897 CT121 623 \flsiN ET 0T1 19779 VisiN ET \frsiNET 109577 1 09577 Supplemental Person record 14143 M9MPN138MSOS - was added for jamar ciark incident ID 4608401, 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038, 109577 Supplemental Person record 14144 was added for Backed up with 510 incident 10 4608401. 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038, User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Backed up with 401 incident iD 4608401, 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038. Backed up with 122 Incident ID 4608401, 601 PARK 109577 109577 109577 066104 050897 CT121623 109577 109577 109577 109577 109577 13 0.7/VisiNetBrowser/S earch/IncidentRep 11/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 - Reports Incident Report 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11l15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11115/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 1111512015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/15/2015 11/1 512015 11/15/2015 01:59:54 02:00:32 02:02:42 02:02:54 02:09:58 02:13:03 02:16:16 02:16:30 02:16:30 02:18:03 02:18:55 02:22:42 02:25:05 02:25:35 02:28:53 02:29:31 02:30:42 02:30:42 02:33:07 02:33:54 02:33:54 02:33:58 02:37:48 02:38:59 02:40:05 02:44:35 02:44:48 02:49:00 02:49:36 02:51 :36 02:52:27 02:56:36 02:57:48 02:59:03 03:10:33 03:14:53 03:15:23 03:17:11 03:23:01 03:24:22 03:26:23 03:36:14 03:39:28 03:42:28 03:42:28 03:42:45 03:42:49 03:43:41 03:43:41 506 6224 953 4402 407 4402 4402 4402 510 8212 510 505 09 530 21 530 530 UserAction Available Available UserAction Available UserAction UserAction Dispatched Unit Backed up UserAction A2 Arrived 2nd Loc Supplemental Information Available Supplemental information UserAction Available 0 Dispatched EnRoute UserAction Dispatched Unit Backed up A Arrived UserAction Custom Timer C4 Code 4 A Arrived Available UserAction Custom Timer A Arrived Available Custom Timer Reset Custom Timer UserAction UserAction UserAction A2 Arrived 2nd Loc Available Available Supplemental information Available UserAction Supplemental information ReAssign Vehicle ReAssign Response Available Custom Timer Dispatched EnRoute 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 601 PARK AV 1611 Plymouth Av 3220 LOWRY AV NORTH 1611 Plymouth Av 3220 LOWRY AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av AV 44973889, 93261944, User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Backed up with 19 Uss-r clicked Exit/Save incident ID 4608401. 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038, Page 14 of 16 060897 11 9080 CT1 19779 109577 CT1 19779 060897 060897 060897 CT1 12777 Supplemental Vehicle record 13825 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate Supplemental Vehicle record 13826 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate User clicked Exit/Save Responding From 4 AVE ST 8 User clicked Exit/Save Backed up with 4402 User clicked Exit/Save At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. Unit speed at the time of status change 08.52 User clicked Exit/Save At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. fl'imer] At Scene for Other Problem/Nat [Reset Reason] Status/Safety Check (N004) [Next Late Check Time] 1111512015 03:42:48 User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save incident t0 4608401, 3220 LOWRY AV 45013257, 93320038, CT121623 CT1 19779 060897 060897 060897 CT1 12741 121621 \flsiNET CT121623 121621 108992 121621 CT123188 121621 CT1231 88 Supplemental Vehicle record 13842 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate 850pcv User clicked Exit/Save 121621 CT112777 Supplemental Vehicle record 13844 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate 157HJH Reason: EX-Unit Ekchange Clearing Primary Vehicle Flag At Scene for Other Problem/Nat- Unit marked as late. Responding From PLYMOUTH AVE AVE 121621 121621 109575 121621 121621 13 .isiNetBrowser/ earch/IncidentReport. aspx?id=46 08. .. 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser 5525.78.15 Reports Incident Report 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 1111512015 Edit Log Date 03:43:41 03:43:51 03:44:29 03:46:15 03:47:37 03:49:30 03:50:45 03:51 :56 03:55:32 03:58:17 04:03:28 04:14:51 04:19:59 04:20:02 04:33:48 04:43:20 04:45:44 05:02:32 05:04:00 05:08:57 05:09:08 05:09:25 05:14:32 05:17:34 05:21:41 05:26:44 05:31 :44 05:37:38 05:43:52 05:51:17 05:53:37 05:53:37 05:53:37 05:53:39 05:57:34 06:08:44 06:10:20 06:10:33 06:14:42 06:34:50 06:49:59 06:57:43 07:00:02 07:08:58 07:12:54 07:15:09 07:16:33 07:16:33 07:51 :54 07:52:12 07:52:54 07:53:00 08:17:47 08:17:57 08:17:57 Time 11/15/2015 00:40:07 1111512015 00:40:07 Map__lnfo 407 407 407 425 407 425 361 4402 411 407 608 Field Unit Backed up C4 Code 4 A Arrived UserAction Available Custom Timer UserAction C4 Code 4 UserAction Supplemental Information Available MultiAgencyResponse UserAction Available Available Available Available Available Supplemental Information Supplemental Information UserAction Available Available _AVaitable Available Available Avaitable Supplemental Information _Available Dispatched EnRoute Unit Backed up C4 Code 4 Available UserAction Available Available Available Available UserAction Available UserAction UserAction Use rAction UserActton Dispatched EnRoute Available UserAction Available Available Available Available Response Closed 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 161 1 Plymouth Av 3220 LOWRY AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 3220 LOWRY AV 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1511 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av 1611 Plymouth Av Changed From Changed To Reason 404F 404F 404F Backed up with 530 User clicked Exitr'Save At Scene for Other Problem/Nat? Unit marked as late. User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save Page 15 of 16 121521 109575 121521 CT112741 121621 F123190 121821 F123190 Supplemental Person record 14216 M9MPN138MSOS - was added for Generated Inc: FIRE lnc#15? 0037609 User clicked ExitISave F119080 F119080 VisiN ET VisiN ET VisiN ET \?siN ET VisiN ET Supplemental Vehicle record 13860 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate Supplemental Vehicle record 13861 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate 974egg User clicked ExitlSave 000021771 121621 Visi NET Supplemental Vehicle record 13866 M9MPN138MSOS was added for license plate 296LMH 121621 121621 Responding From NEWTON AVE 121621 AVE Backed up with 407 User clicked Exit/Save User clicked ExitISave User clicked Exitl'Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save User clicked Exit/Save 121621 121621 \flsiNET CT121521 \?siN ET 12777 123098 CT002219 CT00221 9 CT002219 CT002219 Responding From COLFAX AVE \frsiNET User clicked EinSave Response Disposition: AST?Assist Table Response_Transports Response_Master_lhcidentE03 094131 123098 123098 123098 123098 123098 Workstation User 000033598 000033598 http:// 70. 159.13 0.7/VisiNetBrowser/ 1 1/15/2015 VisiNet Browser?: 5.525.78. 15 Reports - Incident Report 11/15/2015 00:40:14 Read Call 11/15/2015 00:50:54 Problem 11/15/2015 00:50:54 lncident_Type 11/15/2015 00:50:54 Priority_N umber False True Assist EMS Of?cer Personnel (P)Needs Help 2 Of?cer Response - Car 1 11/15/2015 00:50:54 Priority?Descriptiom 11/15/2015 00:50:54 Resp Recon?gState 0 11/15/2015 00:50:54 Response_Pian Custom Time Stamps No Custom Time Stamps Custom Data Fields No Custom Data Fields Attachments No Attachment P4 2 Of?cer 2 Officer Response 2 Of?cer (Recall Window) UP 424 HELP (POWERLINE UP 424 HELP Response (POWERLINE Sergeant 0 Sergeant WINDOWH UP 424 HELP (POWERLINE WINDOWH UP 424 HELP (POWERLINE Response recon?gure needed UP 424 HELP (POWERLINE ResponsewMaster_lncidentP02 Response_Master_lncidentP02 Response_Master_lncidentP02 Response_Master_lncidentP02 Response_Master_lncidentPOZ ResponseJl/laster_lncidentP02 Page 16 of16 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 121621 1 1/15/2015 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/36 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information Description: Voluntary statement of Zacariah Pam at 1611 Plymouth Ave., Apt. 101 - on 11-20-15 Reporting LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis . On 11-20-15 SA Homer and FBI SA Chuck Burnham met with Zacariah Pam nd Peggy Lucille Pam the 1611 PlymOuth Ave. N., Apt. 101 - Mpls. Agents spoke with both individuals in their apartment where they provided a voluntary statement. The interview was audio recorded. By virtue of this report, exhibits was acquired. Address #1 -- Occurred #1 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE-N Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #101, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Subjects Relationship Nat?me B_ig DOB FREQUENTS Pam, Zacariah (Person) 50 yr. old, Black, Male HOME ADDRESS Pam, Peggy Lucille (Person) 63 yr. old, Black, Female Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Pam, Zacariah Primary Information Subject Name: Paml Zacariah Record Type: Person Bio: 50 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses We Miss FREQUENTS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #101, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address USER-NON SUBSCRIBER Subjects Relationship Name SISTER p12 DOB Pam, Peggy Luciile (Person) 63 yr. old, Black, Female Identifications [Ange M1963 County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota 11/20/2015 N0 LICENSE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/36 Report Date: 11l23l2015 Subject #2 - MENTION IN - Pam, Peggy Lucille Primary Information Subject Name: Pam, Peggy Lucille Record Type: Person Bio: 63 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #101, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address CELLULAR PHONE Subjects Relationship Name BE DOB BROTHER Pam, Zacariah (Person) 50 yr. old, Black, Male i Identifications ID Type Number State Countp; As Of Date mp (mine?m DRIVERS Minnesota 11 [20/2015 NO LICENSE Preperty- #1 - CD with audio recorded of zacariah Pam Primary information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Zacariah Pam Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/20/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Collected Date/Time: 11l20l2015 11:00 Officers LE Burnham, Chuck (Agent! FBI - Minneapolis) Record Status Information . . . HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Record Origination Operator. Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11l23l2015 08:37 Last Update Operator: Hanegraaf, Luke (1329/ Fmancral Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Criminal ApprehensionMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/36 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Record Status Information - Continued Last Update Date: 12l01l201518:18 Reporting LEO Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) 7 7 . pate Supervisor . Date HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Hanegraaf, Luke (1329 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of 2/26/2016 Narrative begins on?the foIIOWing page. I MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of4 On 11-20-15 at approximately 1100 hours BCA and FBI Agents were canvassing the apartments and townhomes, located directly south of the shooting scene, for potential witnesses. SA Homer and FBI SA Chuck Burnham knocked on the door to 1611 Plymouth Ave., Apt. 101 Mpls. A male opened the door and invited agents inside. A female was sitting on a chair in the living room. Agents explained the purpose of their meeting and the male, who identi?ed himself as Zacariah NMN Pain/- stated that he observed the incident. The female did not. She identi?ed herself as Peggy Lucille Pam. Zacariah explained that he heard an altercation in the hallway of the apartment complex. Shortly after, an ambulance arrived in the street in front of his apartment. He looked outside through the bedroom blinds and observed a male (Now known as Jamal Clark) pacing all around the ambulance and talking to himself. He further described the male as going from the side to the back of the vehicle numerous times like ?a mad man? and thought ?he was on something.? Zacariah walked into the other room and then returned, where he again looked through the blinds. He observed two of?cers with the male on the ground and never saw any handcuffs. Zacariah stated that it was pretty dark so he could not tell if the of?cers were struggling. Zacariah again walked into the other room and then heard a shot. When he looked back out, he observed an of?cer being moved back to his squad car. Agents asked Zacariah about the amount of force that the of?cers used on Clark. He responded that they were not rough on him at any point. He went on to say, ?tell you with Gods love and um. . .and I?m being honest with you. I?m tell you like this ya?ll, I don?t think they used no force at all.? Zacariah said that people are lying to make the police look bad. Zachariah told Agents off recording that he did not come forward because he did not want to be retaliated against from the people around him. He stated there are gang members in his building. See statement for further details. By virtue of this report, exhibit was acquired. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 20, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Zacariah Pam (ZP) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Cody Horner (CH) Peggy Pam (PP) FBI SA Chuck Burnham (CB) REVIEWED BY: CH Alright, BCA case number 2015?648 ah time is 11:00 on November 20, 2015 uh present at what?s the address here? PP 1611 Plymouth. CH 1611 Plymouth Avenue, number 101 is Cody Homer at the BCA, Chuck Burnham of FBI and is it Zacariah? ZP Zacariah. CH Okay, okay, can you state, how do you spell Zacariah? ZP CH Okay and it?s Pam, ZP Pam, CH Yep, okay and what?s your birthdate? ZP CH Yeah, you don't have to look at that, that?s fine, it?ll just be you and I talking um, and a good phone number for you is? CH Okay um, well we appreciate you talking to us and taking time out of your, out of your day to sit down with us, um, we?re here investigating what happened to ZP Hm. CH that?s ourjob and with that being said ya know we, we understand that you were looking out the window? ZP Uh yes. CH Okay um, just be as descriptive as possible, tell us about what happened from very beginning to the very end and and ah, kind of paint us a picture it you will about what happened. ZP Okay, okay (inaudible) it escalated in the home, on the first floor home, by my sister (inaudible) okay they was there in the hall. There was arguing and uh so this, and his girlfriend or whatever had an altercation so what I heard that she slammed into the door or something and and and there was arguing you know and stuff so so that?s, so this guy there, he he told them get away from us, this is the door ?cuz ?cuz they hit her door too, fighting in the hall like ah, so all of a sudden going on in the hall so okay, so they told them, get out of the hall so it escalated so they went out the hall, went out the front door, went out the Page 1 of 14 Horner-2015-648-A04 doorway he went out the front so they went somewhere upstairs or downstairs or whatever but anyways when they (inaudible) out it was quieter here so I went in the in the bedroom to get into bed and I laid down for a little while so I got up and I look at the window and everyone was out there so i guess they were workin? on his girlfriend or somethin? ?cuz ?cuz it was like that for a minute then I kept looking out there then I saw a guy, I think that was the guy that got shot. I think he was by the ambulance he was just all alone at ambulance ya know and I told my sister 1 said hey, it?s a, it's a guy by the ambulance just peeking all in and doing everything in their (inaudible) and I told her about it. I said Peg, what?s this guy doin? by the ambulance here so so I tried to paint a picture so I came and told her about it so [just said there?s (inaudible) i got back into bed. 80 i got up and (inaudible) two cops had him on the ground. Okay, had him bound like this here right but i didn?t hear nothin? else, nothin' at all but that's what I saw so, so would I know anything yes, I?l came here, I told my sis- that, that the cops had him on the ground like I said I went back in the room just a little bit to get into bed and i heard like a boom, like a boom (inaudible) you hear that she goes yeah I heard that so I went back to look (inaudible) and she goes go look out the window (inaudible) and that?s all i saw but, but I can mention this much, that dude, no matter what nobody say that dude was (inaudible) was looking at him (inaudible) ya knowjust walking around there when he shouldn?t have been around there, l-l (inaudible) let him doing that so, that?s all I saw so I didn?t see nothin? about no, no, no handcuff, no uh, no shootin? or nothin' like that but I know they did had him down on the ground Okay. mostly what i saw but I'll tell you this (inaudible) and I did personally saw that boy (inaudible) ambulance and you know and I heard ya know (inaudible) I heard that havin' (inauidible) callin? him and stuff like that but he was (inaudible) they're not lying on that ?cuz I was looking out the window, (inaudible) told my sister, so (inaudible) like he wasn't, I tell him anybody lie, I saw with my own eyes. So yeah l?m just gonna go back a little bit through what you just said okay? Um-hm. So when you said you saw him at the ambulances? Yep. What was he doin' specifically? He was just walkin? from the ah, ah, walkin? to the passenger door to the back door peeking in, peeking in, stuff like that. And was he banging on the thing or not or? couldn?t, i couldn?t hear. You couldn?t tell? Hm-mm. Okay. (lnaudible) was lookin' at him for awhile then i came in and told my sister. I said Peggy, this guy out here was ambulance here just walking all around, pacing around. Did it look like he was trying to cause trouble, not cause trouble or was he trying to interfere? Well sir, to me, to me the girl at the end there, he had there, he must have been trying to interfere so. Why do you say that? Page 2 of 14 Horner-2015-S48?A04 ZP ?Guz he was walkin' all around like he was on somethin? ya know like he was (lnaudible background voicesNow describe that, describe that to us, you say that ah, it was like he was on something. Yeah. What are you, what are you seeing I mean describe it to us? Pacing back and forth around the, pacing back and forth, like he was out of, ?cuz we know he was kinda high or something then the, I mean they (inaudible) in the hall man ya know, ya know? Did you see them in the hall? No but we know they was in there ?ouz we heard arguing and fighting. You could hear arguing in the Yeah. inside the apartment? Yeah (inaudible). (lnaudible). (lnaudible). They hit your door right here? Yeah, boom. (lnaudible multiple voices talkingThey were fighting in the hall, they hit our door yeah. Boom hit it hard, (inaudible). It had to been them two right there ?cuz (inaudible) it had to be them two right there. The one that got shot and his girl. Okay, (inaudible) anywhere else in the hall that you know of? They was just ah, I this old man down the hall, this (lnaudible) guy, he was down the hall and I guess the the (inaudible) inside a (inaudible) here, 1 don?t know her name but she was in the hall too the woman she was in the hall but I seen, but she probably know what was goin? on (inaudible) ?cuz (inaudible) this lady right here and another girl came through that, came through that front front door coming in and and and and then all the sudden the the fight that broke out, (inaudible) came in with a girl and then before we knew it a fight just broke out wit? wit? the girl and her boyfriend, the one that got shot at and and At any point did either one of you go out into the hall? No, I didn?t wanna go in the hall, 1 said oh no, it might escalate to me ya know the boy might get mad at me. (lnaudible). She told me to go out in the hall, said nope, can?t do it.. (lnaudible). See me, I don?t want (inaudible) no trouble to my sister house, ya know what I (inaudible) I've been out there and that?s to me, they might try to pop me, I?m (inaudible) these brothers gonna pop me out there, they (inaudible) she handicapped. Yeah. And I didn't want no trouble Page 3 of 14 Horner-2015-648-A04 CB ZP CH Yeah. I saw, I?m telling the truth and my opinion (inaudible) in my opinion (inaudible) the boy tryin? to (inaudible) the police (inaudible). So (lnaudible multiple voiceshe?s walking Yeah. passenger side to the back passenger Um?hm. and forth. Um-hm. What happens next? Okay, the other thing that i can remember is that really the only thing I can remember, l?l came here, I told my sister, did I tell ya that Peggy? Um-hm. Then I came here, I sat for a little while then I went back in there. (lnaudible). And the only thing I saw, I saw the police guys (inaudible) I came out to Peg I said Peg, the police got the boy on the ground, didn?t I say that Peg? Hm. So I came in here, by the You were in the bedroom when you saw that? (lnaudible). Yep, I was peeking out the blinds (inaudible) I seen him on the ground. (lnaudible). (lnaudible multiple voicesblinds and you see them on the ground? Right yeah. So tell me, tell me what you're seeing, specifically. Can you turn the, the volume down a little bit? Is is, is Mr. Clark on the ground or are the two officers on the ground or is it something else? Oh, oh, Mr. Clark on the ground and and and the, and the two police were on top of him. (lnaudible). (lnaudible). Yep. When you say on top of him what'd you see? I'm talkin' about like, ya know hey man, tryin' to handcuff him so I don't know if they handcuff him or not ?cuz i couldn?t see all like that ?cuz it too dark out Page 4 of 14 Horner-2015-648-A04 Okay. I know, I know, I know the two police was on top and he was on the bottom. Okay. I know that, all of his face was down uh uh, I don?t know Mr. Clark?s face is down or you can?t tell? Right, hm-mm, hm-mm. What about the police officers, are they face down or face up? Yep, yep, face down, face down (inaudible). Are they on their knees, are they laying on the ground? They was on their knees with him yes. Okay. Um-hm, yep. And then was he struggling, not struggling, fighting, not fighting? Well it was too dark for that too, I didn?t see him struggling when they had him down so. Okay. l-l couldn't see that good like that but alls I got to say that he was (inaudible) ambulance I do know that like I say, (inaudible) and I?m not lying (inaudible). When you see out of it you?re saying you were talking earlier that you thought he might been like high or something like that? On something, on something yes. He was on something ?cuz it was like (inaudible) he was walking like (inaudible) walkin? like a mad man, l?m gonna put it like that (inaudible) (Phone ringing) ZP I could be wrong, I could be right but, he was walking around that ambulance just walkin? around, walkin? around, walkin? around. (Phone ringing). ZP (inaudible) Me, if I had (inaudible) my girlfriend lwould not be like that (inaudible). (Phone ringingUm?hm but something had to just like Hello? or somethin? I guess ya know i don?t know. Did he seem Hello? he was flailing his arms I mean i guess? Oh yeah he was doing (inaudible) he was doing other stuffjust walking around there it sound like he was talkin? to himself. And is the girl in the ambulance at this point? Yeah, yeah she is. Okay, were the doors open, shut, do you remember? Page 5 of 14 Ho rner?201 5-648-A04 the doors were shut. The doors were shut? Shut, yep, I was tryin' to hop when that I could see. 1 seen the ambulan- (inaudible) see the whole ambulance from the back (inaudible). Okay so you?re in the bedroom and you see the two officers on Yep. laying on the ground and can you tell if he?s on his front or back did you say? That?s where I couldn't, I couldn?t tell ya. He was on his (inaudible). It was too dark. I don't know if she might say (inaudible) but I couldn?t tell ?cuz didn?t tell that he was on his stomach all that I knew was that he was Um?hm. I don't know, maybe she might say he was on his stomach, maybe she might have heard from the TV that he was on his stomach on the TV (inaudible) but I don't know. I didn?t see that part but I knew he was down. I do know that. Okay so then what happened, you said you came out into the living room? Yep, yep I came out and I told her I said Peggy, the police got this boy on the ground here then all the sudden I was headed on my way back to the bedroom and I wasn?t (inaudible) on my way back to the bedroom so he must have scuffled with the police just as quick as I left out of the room or somethin? ?cuz I came back that's the only thing I went then I told her then I went (inaudible) and I heard boom, then I So you just came out to tell Yeah. like, give me an estimate how long were you out there? I think about a good 5-10 minutes (inaudible). (lnaudible). (lnaudible). (lnaudible) about a minute. About a minute? That you came out and you were in the living room? Yeah. Uh-huh. Yeah. And they Right. (lnaudible). Flight. (lnaudible) Yeah. Page 6 of 14 Horner~2015-648-A04 And (inaudible). What did you see when ah, when you went in there after you heard that? Oh. (Inaudible). (inaudible) laying there. Just was laying there? Um-hm. Where were the officers in relation?to that? Ah, like I told my sister, I saw the uh officer pushing, pushing one officer back to the truck, the truck was park right here. I saw him got his buddy. I guess they (Inaudible). him, I saw him pushing his brother back to the truck, (inaudible) ya know and the boy?s just laying there and pushed him back like, like they?re trying to get him away from him or somethin' ya know? Um-hm. That?s what I saw. Um?hm. So uh, after that I looked back (inaudible) and see I didn't even see all the po? I didn?t even see all them police cars, (inaudible) they just came up so fast and I?m tell ya how fast it got, how fast you can, (inaudible) of something. Yeah. They came so fast ?cuz I told my sister, I said Peg, two minutes ago there was one car out there then now it?s hundred cars out there. Hm. (Inaudible) anyways this um, this uh police got (inaudible) back to the police car and that was it (inaudible). So you saw one officer pull another officer back Right, right, yep, um-hm. car? Um-hm. Yeah going back when you said you saw that um he was on the ground and that the two cops were next to Um-hm. Were the, were the cops, did they look like they were kneeling next to him or Yeah, kneeling, kneeling, kneeling. Or were they laying down? Kneeling next to him on their knees yep. On their knees? Yep. Page 7 of 14 Horner-2015?B48?AO4 CH ZP CH ZP cs PP Okay and it was both of them? Yep, both of ?em. And do you remember what the cops looked like, can you describe ?em to me? Well i would tell (inaudible) one of ?em your color but one of ?em was darker than your color, can?t describe, one of ?em looked (inaudible) ya know he (inaudible). Would you describe them as Caucasian, Hispanic, Black, White? (lnaudible). (Multiple voices talkingyou can?t tell that?s fine too but were they Caucasian, Asian, White, Bl- ya know? (lnaudible). (inaudiblebetween black and Hispanic or something I don?t know, look, I don?t know, it?s it, I know he not you guys color, I know he the kinda darker than you guys. Okay. Yeah he was pushing, ya know pushing him back to the (inaudible) so. Did you see well, did you see any handcuffs at the time? (lnaudible) saw no handcuffs, (inaudible) i don?t know where the handcuff come in, I don?t know what it is, (inaudible) pushing and (inaudible) I would?ve thought they had handcuff on the guy (inaudible) you know. Why do you say that? ?Cuz, ?cuz they already had him down you know how that they were handcuffing everything you know but I?m tell you that i didn?t see no handcuff, i didn?t even see no nothing, I just saw him on the ground and I thought ya know everything?s gonna be cool we'll (inaudiblegone Um-hm. so that's all l?m sayin? but ya know, but like you said (inaudible) started from the Yep. started from in the hallway yeah, escalated wherever in the hall right there, they went through that door right here they Side door? uh huh, went in there then we didn?t hear for awhile, we didn't hear for awhile then when a bright light came up on the patio and I?m in bed, bright light and everyone was out there and and and (inaudible) for a pretty long time (inaudible). Hm. it was there for a a pretty long time. (lnaudible). Uh?huh. There's no siren. No, so okay. Page 8 of 14 Horner-2015-648-A04 siren? Nope. (Inaudible). No siren so I guess (lnaudible). But the lights were on on it? Yep, yep. (lnaudible) they went out there. Um?hm. And it (inaudible). Right so I guess they were working on the girl out there but the boy wouldn?t let it go. Um?hm. He wouldn't let it go like that so he had to, then again ya know ?cuz when was in the house, maybe he was (inaudible) even like insulting them, aggravating them and all this probably he was but I didn't hear that. But you couldn?t hear it if he was? Hm-mm, Hm?mmthe bedroom and then I had the fan on (inaudible) Um-hm. if I had not (inaudible) window I would not have saw that. Um-hm. ?Cuz i wonder what that bright light come from. Yeah. i got scared I said oh what?s going on here ?cuz I got scared (Laughs) but that boy was walking around there and I think that ya know, ya know, and ain't no sense of me being scared because i?l-l (inaudible) well I was trying to walk somewhere or go somewhere or somethin? like that I don?t need any of that (inaudible) I'm looking at the truth ya know like (inaudible) i ain't got nothin? to hide. And we appreciate that. But you what what if you had to say would you have said that they used enough force, not enough force or could you tell? Ya know to tell you truth, tell you the truth, tell you with Gods love and I?m being honest with you. I?m tell you like this ya?ll, i don?t think they used no force at all. And why do you say that? Ah, to be honest with you like I told my sister, th~th these people act like they were wild like (inaudible) Peg, Peg, these people looked like they were wild Peg? Yeah. Page 9 of 14 Homer?2015?648-A04 They acted like they were wild, I don?t believe they used no force (inaudible). (Inaudible). When they were, when they were out there with them could you tell were It, it, it, it, it didn't look like they were using no force. (Inaudible). (Inaudible) no force? Um?hm, just kneeling down that?s all, that?s all saw, that?s all. And it looked like they were kinda p- kneelin? trying to choke him or nothin' I?m sorry they were trying to choke him, they were trying to do what? They weren't trying to do nothin? to him but (inaudible) they kneeled down beside him that's all, like (inaudible) handcuff him or nothin?, theyjust kneeled down by him, that's all I saw. Did you see him moving at all, was he squirming? No. Did, did he look agitated? (Inaudible) I ain?t saw nothin?. Could you tell if he was trying to fight back or was he compliant or could ya tell? Nope, I couldn't tell ya. Matter of fact ya know, I admit (inaudible) to see all that, only thing I saw them kneel down by him and and ya know he wasn?t moving ya know, we didn't, we didn?t ya know uh, when I looked out the window, we didn't hear no gunshot or nothin? and ya know what I?m sayin? (inaudible) ya know? Um-hm. They (inaudible) and they kneel down (inaudible) and so that was it. Could you tell why he was taken to the ground or why he was on the ground at all? I really don?t 3, I really don't know but I'm thinking that, he (stutter) (inaudible) he was like, lookin? stupid and stuff, I don't know ya know maybe he was ya know not, I?m going by the TV but (inaudible) I did see him by that. I?m going by the (inaudible) he messed with the ambulance people but he was by it and I can imagine that he was irritatin? the ambulance people?s way to get the girl to help for whatever they was messin? with him so they found a way to got took ?em down ya know, l?l-l-I (inaudible) 1 really don?t know about that, I?m telling y?all the truth. it started from the building here. Um?hm. And then it escalates somewhere else and (inaudible). Did you see him get taken down or not see? No, no, no, no, I didn?t see him get taken down but I knew he was down. Okay. If had stayed in bed (inaudible) I wouldn?t have saw nothin'. (Inaudible) but I wouldn't know what it was Okay. So I?m giving you all the truth that I can give ya ?cuz I don?t know no more. And we appreciate that. Yep. Page100f14 Horner-2015-648?A04 there anything that we forgot to ask you or something that you haven?t told us or anything else that we need to know since we're here? (inaudible) there ain?t nothin? else to tell but Ijust know that ljust know that i didn't see all that rough stuff and all that crazy stuff that I told my sister and my sister agreed with me. i just tell her look, whatever people try and tell ya they try to, ya know, (inaudible) whatever they trying to rally it down now, down by the police office or whatever like that, that's all the one's that (inaudible) i did not see no rough stuff. i did not, (inaudible) whatev, whatever people try to say, I'm just tellin? you what i saw. It was no rough stuff (inaudible) they started at home (inaudible) trouble with your woman, doin? all that stuff, that?s all I saw and these people (inaudible) braggin? about it talking about but they didn?t saw nothin', i saw it myself right there. They was not rough on that boy. Do you know anyone else that said they saw it? Like not saw it later or heard about it but anybody else that actually saw it? i really don't know but they, (inaudible) but I don?t believe they have. (lnaudible). (inaudible) so I really don?t know. (lnaudible). Yeah but, (lnaudible). Hm?mm, i saw it close up right there. I?l-l was ya know I wasn't trying to be nosy but i saw it close up right there. Um?hm. I Anybody else in the apartment besides the two of you at the time? Nope, nobody but me and her. Oh. See, 1 don?t know (inaudible) they trying to make a story to make people look bad but people look like ah Peg, Peg you, you (inaudible) told you Peg or are you trying make police look bad. Yeah. You know how they said no well I think ya?ll did yourjob and you did the right (inaudible) l?m telling you, (inaudible) you know i don?t wanna say this but I don't care but, i don?t want nothin' happening? to me, ya know what I'm talking about but these guys around here trying to (inaudible). They?re trying to what? They kinda rowdy. Trying to rally? No, they kinda rowdy ya know I know rowdy. You like like the gang, the gang stuff (inaudible) but but (inaudible). think (inaudible) i think the police did a good (inaudible). (lnaudible). Page110f14 Horner-2015?648-A04 ZP Huh? (lnaudible multiple voices(Inaudible). I don?t know where he comes from. I don't know where he comes from. (Inaudible) know where he lives. I don?t know where he comes from (Inaudible) l'll say this, if there's anybody else that you know that, that saw it, or anybody else that ah has video or anything like that please have them come forward to us ?cuz we want to make sure that we talk to them and get all the Um?hm. talk to everyone that we can that saw it ?cuz um, that?s why we're knocking door to door is we're trying to find everybody that?s actually saw anything so. (inaudible) been trying to say to you sir is that look, I?m not lyin? to ya, my sister?s not lying to ya, you got some liars in this building, they gonna try to make it seem so (inaudible) but l?m telling you, I saw a big part of it, they didn't like what they talkin? about, they did not, they did not use no force is force and all the crazy stuff but boy was out of it. He (inaudible) his mind crazy and foolishness to get them to do that. Um-hm. So l?m just being honest with you so, somebody they can tell you whatever but oh they shot him they did thi- (inaudible) hey, l?m not saying it like that Yeah. you just be stupid you like (inaudible) ya know what I?m sayin' man? Yep. What I?m just trying to say (inaudible) he was either going to take the police life or the police were gonna take his so, vice Um-hm. Somebody had to go (inaudible) so I don't got nothin' to say but, there?s the pigs in here that?ll tell you a lie so. Okay. Now Peggy when he came out and he said, says the police are here, did you look out the window? She Did you stay sitting there? (inaudible). She can hardly get up (inaudible). (lnaudible multiple voices together). ca PP ca Were there, were the blinds here open or closed? Yeah, They were just like this or different? Page12of14 Horner?2015-648?A04 they were closed (inaudible). (lnaudible) the outer ones were closed too? Um-hm. Were hangin' (inaudible) Um-hm. (lnaudible). So they (inaudible) police tape to your railing here? Um?hm, yep. All across, all around. Okay. And But you're, but you left your, your curtains here you left them closed? Um I had (inaudible). Yeah okay so you opened ?em up after the police tape was on or? (lnaudible). Well (inaudible) when the thing was going on they were closed? Yeah. Okay and what about the blinds in bedroom were they open, you said you were peekin? through ?em were Yeah, I didn?t, didn't have ?em open like that, was peekin? through it like (inaudible) like a little (inaudible) what you lookin' at ya know l-l opened ?em like that, (inaudible) go oh no, oh no, see, not that (inaudible) scared of police (inaudible). Yep. You know what I mean? Yep. (lnaudible). Yep. (lnaudible). (lnaudible). Ya know what I?m sayin?? Is there anything else you guys can think to tell us? No. No. Here?s my business card. Okay. (lnaudible). it?s bgot my cell phone number on it. Um?hm. Page130f14 Horner?2015-648?A04 you, if you remember anything after we leave here or there's something that comes in your head that you?re like oh should have told 'em Um?hm. Call me, my phone number?s on there okay? Okay. Alright and ah, (inaudible) card too. Okay then, okay yeah man but oh man, that?s all l?m afraid of, l?m not afraid of tellin the truth but I know (inaudible) the guys around here man, ya know, don't really know them ?cuz I don't deal ?cuz l?m 50 years old I don?t deal with these knuckleheads but (inaudible) something else (inaudible) ?ouz like I say I know they gonna be lying to y'all guys in this building okay, anything they think y?all want to hear and I know ya (inaudible) you know what I?m talkin? about but they gonna lie (inaudible) oh no, oh no, I don?t mean he was good like they said he was ya know is like good he wouldn?t? have been like that. Like (lnaudible). Huh? (lnaudible). They wouldn't say that he sold drugs. Right, they?re right, yep, yep (inaudible). (lnaudible). We don?t care if he?s selling drugs. Right. We don't care what he?s up to, we're just investigating what happened Well, that?s what I'm saying. at the time. Right, right, right, okay then. Okay, alright, this concludes the statement, time is 11:26 hours. END OF RECORDING. Page14of14 Horner?2015-648-A04 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/37 Report Date: 11/21/2015 Warning 7 Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquisition of reports and squad audio and video from Clark's arrest on July 30, 2015 Occurrence From: 11/21/2015 10:30 Occurrence To: 11/21/2015 13:00 Reporting LEO: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1112412015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-283056 Synopsis Acquisition of DVD containing video and audio of a previous incident involving Jamar Oneal Clark and MPD officers from the 4th MPD Precinct that occurred on July 30, 2015. Clark was arrested after a high speed chase in a stolen vehicle with MPD. As a result, exhibit was acquired. Address Occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND Aver-:9 Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name E. BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Subject #1 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #1 - Folkens, Bruce Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Folkens, Bruce Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: White, Male Rank/Position: Deputy Chief of Police Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_io EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/37 Report Date: 11/21/2015 Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length:" Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Site County As Of Date Fictitious FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO QM Property #1 - one-ova containing Video-and Squadt?camiiaras Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: One DVD containing Video and Audio footage from squad cameras Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11l21I2015 Quantity: 1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Location Found: Collected Date/Time: Turned over to SSA Swanson at BCA HQ- 11l21I201511:00 Rectordstatus Information Record Origination Operator: 11/23/201510:32 .- Record Origination Date: -. Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Page 2 of 4 02/26/2016 13:36 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/37 Report Date: 11/21/2015 Record Status Information .- Continued Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11/24/2015 15:22 Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 2I2612016 Apprehension) Narrative MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of4 On Saturday November 21, 2015, MN BCA SSA Gary Swanson was made aware that a DVD containing squad car audio and video of a previous arrest of Jamar Clark was provided to WCCO TV and was going to be aired sometime on Saturday November 21, 2015. The DVD consisted of video and audio of a high speed chase that occurred in north Minneapolis on July 30, 2015. Minneapolis Police (MPD) Of?cers had located an occupied stolen vehicle and when of?cers tried to stop the vehicle it fled. The chase continued through portions of North Minneapolis and ended when the stolen vehicle crashed into a house at 1527 Logan Ave N. The driver was identi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark, DOB 05/03/1991. Also present in the vehicle were two juveniles. These people were taken into custody by MPD. SSA Swanson made arrangements with MPD Deputy Chief Bruce Folkens to meet at MN BCA HQ at 1100 Hrs. to take custody of a copy of the squad audio and video along with the written reports from this incident. After obtaining the reports and DVD of the audio/video, SSA Swanson met with MN BCA SSA Donnie Cheung so that copies of this DVD could be made. As a result of this activity, exhibit was acquired. This exhibit will remain in SSA Swanson?s custody until such time as it is signed over to SA Mike Phill. A copy of the written MPD reports are attached to this report. MPD CAPRS Case Report With Force - 5-283 056 Page 7 of 9 Crime Location Auto FLEE Crime Location . StreeUSidewalk AUTOTH Crime Location Street/Sidewalk DWI Crime Location Street/Sidewalk FLEE Crime Location StreetiSidewalk WT Type of Drugs Alcohol DWI Force Force Report 1 Involved Officer: 000996 Carlson, Troy Force Subject {Victim}: A001: Clark. Jamar Supervisor Notified: Subject UI drugslalcohol: Report Complete: Reason Not Complete: Electronic Signature: Last Changed Date: lnvoived Force Types: Bodily Force Details Bodily Force Type: Force Directed: Compliance: injury: Force Report 2 involved Officer: Supervisor Notified: Subject Ul drugslaicohol: Report Complete: Reason Not Complete: Electronic Signature: Last Changed Date: lnvoived Force Types: Bodily Force Details Bodily Force Type: "Force Directed: Compliance: Injury: Yes No Yes Resp. to Situation: Medical Treatment: No No Ambulance was called as precautionary measure. however A1 refused all medical service and therefore did not "Require" Medical treatment. Troy Carlson Jul 30. 2015 02:05 Bodily Force Body Weight to Pin Torso Yes No 000340 Bauer, Benjamin Yes No Yes Report Locked: Last Changed iD: Force Subject (Victim): Resp. to Situation: Medicai Treatment: Ambulance as precaution. A1 refused medical Benjamin Bauer Jul 30. 2015 02:05 Bodily Force Punches Headirieck Yes No Force Supervisor Review Responded To Scene: Evidence Coltected: Witnesses identified: Firearm Discharged: Spoke With Subject: Subject Transported Hosp: is there video nf for-3e: Supervisor review complete: Eiectronlo SignatureYes Yes Mercil Report Locked: Last Changed iD: Reason not responded: IAU Notified: Was Event Criticai: Subject Observed: Subject injury: Subj. Admitted Hosptial: ls video prop. lnventorled: Reason not complete: Yes 000998 A001: Clark. Jamar No No Yes 000998 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Force - MP-IS-283 056 Last Changed Date: Supervisor?s Narrative: Force Witnesses Page 8 of 9 Jul 30. 2015 23:14 Supervisor lD: 00473-2 Of?cers got into a FLEE with a stolen vehicle. The vehicle crashed at roughly 16th/lrving. The lead chase vehicle behind the stolen MV and had it?s MVR on. Of?cers Carlson (Passenger) and Bauer (driver) exited their vehicles. The driver exited the vehicle and was walking towards the rear of the MV and was taken to the ground by Of?cer Carlson by being tackled. In the video. You can see Of?cer Carlson on top of the Driver and then points his gun at one of the occupants as he is still on top of the driver. You can see one of Of?cer Carlson's hands on his gun and he is lying on top of the Driver. using his other arm to pin down the driver. Other of?cers arrive on :cene and control the passengers of the vehicle. Of?cer Carlson attempts to roll the Driver over and the driver appears to get back to his feet. Out of camera range, you can briefly see Of?cer Carlson and then the scene moves out of view. Of?cer Bauer stated that he observed the suspect/Driver get back up and Of?cer Carlson struggling with him. According to the of?cers. the Driver is taken to the ground a second time. Bauer then attempts to get the Driver in cuffs. but the driver pulls his hands away and refuses to give up. Of?cer Bauer stated that he struck the Driver once in the face. at which time. the Driver was cuffed without further incident. Once in custody, the driver appeared to be unconscious. I observed him, and he had blood trickling from his mouth and he looked dazed. with eyes open. I ordered an of?cer to monitor his breathing and requested Rescue/EMS code 3. At one point the driver suddenly was awake and OK and swearing at of?cers. spoke with the Driver, who verbally ld'd himself as JAMAR CLARK. CLARK stated that he was tackled and stru in the face "several times" He staid he was knocked out and was struck while he was unconscious, to which I asked him how he would know. He stated he woke up to being punched in the face I was on-scene when he "Woke up" and he was lying on his side, in the recovery position. being monitored by police. EMS arrived and cleared him, as he refused any treatment. i believe the use of force was within policy guidelines as the Driver actually jumped back to his feet and attempted to get away from officers. Even when he was being blocked from getting up a second time. he pulled his arms away and at this point had not been searched. Attempts to use body weight and pressure the other of?cers were tied up with the other two passengers and clearing vehicles. I photographed and only observed a small cut on his lip/right side. The SID card was lnventoried. No force witnesses identi?ed Non-lnventoried Property Vehicle Vehicle Number: 1 Owner Role: 0001 Owner Name: Mccarthy, BRIAN Make: Subaru Model: OUTBACK 2.5I LI Model Year: 14-14 Plate: MN EUBLUM Plate Year: 16 Original CCN: MP2015280552 Estimated Value: $1.00 Estimated Recovered $1.00 Value: Vehicle Recovery Address: 1527 Logan AV 1 1/20/20] 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Force - Page 9 of 9 Minneapolis. MN 554112Ep Code Recovery Date: Jul 29. 2015 Vehicle Status Category gate Description Vehicle Comments SUBA STN WAGON Vehicle Hold traf?c Vehicle Impounded Yes Vehicle Recovered Yes Vehicle Towed Yes Vehicle Used in Crime Yes Vehicle Descrip ion Category Description Comments Vehicle Color Inter Beige/Teri Vehicle Color Side Black Vehicle Col0r Top Black Vehicle MD. Key Vehicle Type 4 Door Vehicle Type Sedan Property and Evidence -ltem# Description Owner Qty Make/ModISeril Auth ID Dt 2015-29258 1 A001 1 006620 Hold For Inves?ga?ons 2015-29258 2 BLACK UNDERWEAR A001 1 006620 Hold For lnves?ga?ons arr-1:309:39. on or: RI HF A001 1 006620 Hoid For lnveshgahons 2015-29492 1 DIGITAL EVIDENCE 1 End of report for case NIP-15483056. Print ID: 3F98-. .. 1 1:20.. 20 1 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - 056 Case Report with Supplements Minneapolis Police Department Page 1 of 29 CCN: MP-15-283056 Report Details Reporting Officer: Assisting Officer: Supervising Officer: Approving Supervisor: Precinct: Related CON Reported Date: Entered By: 000998: Troy Carlson 000340: Benjamin Bauer 000293: John Grove 000293: John Grove 410 04 Jul 30. 2015 01:07 000998 Approval Status: Approval Date: Date Returned: Return Count: Date Printed: Last Uploaded: Primary Routed Unit: Assigned Investigators: Approved Jul 30, 2015 0 Nov 20. 2015 Jul 31 2015 100 4038 4. Investigators 006520: Sletta, Mark Incident Details Offense'i: FLEE Desc: Flee Police In Mv Statute: 609.487 Attempted: Offensez: ROBPAG Desc: Robbery Per Agg Statute: 609.245 Attempted: Offense3: AUTOTH Desc: Motor Vehicle Theft Statute: 609.52 Attempted: Offense4: DWI Desc: Driving While lntoxc Statute: 169A Attempted: Offenses: AOA Desc: Assist Other Agency Statute: REPORT ONLY Attempted: OffenSeE: WT Desc: Warrant Statute: Attempted: Address: 16 AV Minneapolis, MN 55411 Intersection: Girard AV Occurred From: 07/29/2015 22:10 Dispatched: 22:10:00 Occurred To: 07/30/2015 22:20 Arrived: 22:10:00 Location: 15 AV LOGAN AV Cleared: 03:00:00 Minor Involved: Yes Public Data Officer located a Minneapolis Stolen Vehicle and intiated a FLEE. was booked HCJ for PC Flee and PC AUTOTH. A2 was transferred custody to Metro Transit PD for a PC Pick?Up and booked JDC for the PC?Pick Up and 5 warrants. Further Investigation PROBABLE THE COMPLAINANT, BEING DULY SWORN, SWEARS THE BEI OW FACTS ARE TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF AND CONSTITUTE PROBABLE CAUSE TO BELIEVE THAT THE ARRESTEE COMMETTED THE OFFENSE (S) DESCRIBED HEREIN. Officers were on routine Patrol in the area of 16th Ave and Fremont Ave N, and noticed several people getting into a parked vehicle on the North side of the street. Officers ran the listed vehicle in NCIC and the vehicle came back as a Minneapolis Stolen Vehicle. Officers spun around on the vehicie that was now driving NE on Girard Ave from 15th Ave N, before officers could catch up to the vehicle the vehicle sped away from Of?cers at a high rate of speed. Of?cers activated Emergency Lights and sirens to stop vehicle, vehicle continued to try and evade of?cers by driving well above posted speed limits, in alleys and taking many turns. The vehicle made little or no attempt to obey traffic laws or have regard for public safety. The vehicle crashed into a house at 1527 Logan Ave N, and the driver as A1 was apprehended. A1 was driving a stolen vehicle, and evaded officers pursuing him with their emergency equipment on. A1 was booked HCJ for PC AUTOTH and PC FLEE. PC Authorized by Sgt. Liotta, badge 0401. 1 11?20/201 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MP-15-283056 SIGNATURE NOTARY SIGNATURE AND STAMP SUBMITTED UNDER OATH BY SIGNATURE OF NOTARY A.B.,Peace Of?cer License Number My license expires on June 30. . Hennepin County. Minnesota. Page 2 of 29 1 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - 5-283 056 Page 3 of 29 Arrestee Role I Role A001 0020100067 Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Nick Name: Pettyfolks Residence: 4007 Bryant AV Minneapolis. MN 55412 Telephone: 02612-695-7146 Lle MN 5279170360118 Date of Birth: 0510311991 Event Age: 24 Est. Age: 24 - 24 Race: Black Medical Treatment: Sex: Male Prior Injury: Yes Height: 508 City of Grigin: Minneapolis Build: ME St. of Origln: MN Arrest Information Arrest Address: 1527 Logan AV Precinct: 04 Minneapolis. MN Arrest Date: Jul 29. 2015 22:15 Arrest Location: Disposition: Booked County Arresting Officer: 000340: Bauer, Benjamin Michael Call/Sqd: 410 Arresting Officer: 000998: Carlson, Troy Allen 410 Qharges ?t_atu_s Type Charge Code Statute Citation Related CON PC Felony FLEE - Flee Police In Mv 609.487 PC Felony AUTOTH - Motor Vehicle Theft 609.52 1 69A A Personal Description Category Description Related Offense Comments Appearance Drunk Complexion Dark Desc. Comments Comments add: 2323 26th Av. N. #207. Mpls, Employment Status Employed Color Black Force Used Yes Hair Color Black Hair Length Medium Hair Style Dread Locks Injury Type None Type of Resistance Tensed Encountered Arrestee Role 1 Role A002 Name: Residence: Telephone: Date of Birth: Event Ag- Est. Age- Race: Black Medical Treatment: No Sex: Male Prior injury: No IDs-8204mm 11120/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - VIP-155283056 Page 4 of 29 Height: 510 Buiid: Li Arrest Information Arrest Address: i527 Logan AV Precinct: 04 Minneapolis. MN Arrest Date: Jul 29. 2015 22:15 Arrest Location: Disposition: Booked Juvenile Arresting Officer: 000340: Bauer, Beniamin Michael CallISqd: 410 Arresting Of?cer: 000998: Carlson. Troy Allen Caillchi: 410 Arresting Officer: 001263: Conner. Chad Michael CalliSqd: 425 @5315 gm 1'ng Charge Code Statute Citation ?ew PC Pickup Felony ROBPAG Robbery PerAgg 609.245 14-014574 Warrant Felony WT - Warrant Warrant Petty MSD Wi' - Warrant 27.011531 83 Warrant Felony WT - Warrant max/153692 Warrant Misdemeanor WT - Warrant 27JV152078 Warrant Misdemeanor WT Warrant 27jvi5254u Employer/Schooi Address Teleghone Occugation Availability: Personal Description I Cateoorv ?criotion Related Offense Comments Complexion Dark Employment Status Unknown Force Used No Hair Coior Black Hair Length Short Hair Style Dread Locks Victim Role 1' Role ii: V001 Name: Residence: Telephone: Date of Birth: Event A Est. A- Race: OtherIMixed Race Medical Treatment: No Sex: Male Prior Injury: No Height: 506 Build: ME Victim of: FLEE Employment Information Emgioyer/School Address Teleghone Occugation No Sohooi Availabitlty: 1 1.120/20 1 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - NIP-15283056 Page 5 of 29 Personal Description 9w Related Offense 92mg, Employment Status Unknown Force Used No Alias Role I Role AL001 Name: Residence: Telephone: Date of Birth: Est- Race: Black Medical Treatment: No Sex: Male Prior Injury: N0 Height: 510 Build: I Ll Arrest Information Personal Descrigtion Categorv Descrigtio? ?elated Offense 991% Employment Status Unknown Force Used No Owner Role I Role 0001 Name: Mccarthy, BRIAN WILLIAM Residence: 3315 Humboldt AV 8 MINNEAPOLIS. MN 55408 Telephone: muse Date of Birth: - Event Age: 3? Est. Age: 37 - Race: Sex: Male Height: 507 5507 Build: ME Parenthuardian Role I Role P6001 Name: White, Yvonne Residence: 1014 AV Minneapolis. MN Telephone: Em; Date of Birth: Event Age: 49 Est. Age: 49 - 49 Race: Black Medical Treatment: No Sex: Female Prior inlury: No Height: Build: Personal Description 1 1/ 20/20 1 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 6 of 29 Categog Description Related Offense Comments Employment Status Unknown Force Used No ParentiGuardian Role i Role PG002 Name: Patton. Tamara Joneile Residence: 4236 Penn AV Minneapolis, MN 55411 Telephone: Date of rL?iir?th: Event Age: 40 Est, Age: 40 - 40 Race: Other/Mixed Race Medical Treatment: No Sex: Female Prior Injury: No Height: 506 Build: ME Persona! Description Category Description Related Offense Comments Employment Status Unknown Force Used No Other Role I Role Name: THOMPSON. SHAKIRA LABELLE Residence: 1527 Logan AV Apt. 1 55411 Telephone: Lio Date of Birth: Event Age: 38 Est. Age: 38 - 38 RaCe: Black Sex: Female Height: 502 - 502 Build; ST Relationships Suhiect Relationsmg Tvge Qbiggt P6001 White. Yvonne Parent A002 P6002 Patton. Tamara Parent V001 A002 Alias AL001 Modus Operandi Category Description Related Offense Crime Elements Arres?s) Made AOA Crime'Elements Arrest(s) Made AUTOTH Crime Elements Arre5t(e) Made Crime Elements Arrestis) Made FLEE Crime Elements Arrest(s) Made ROBPAG Crime Elements Arrest(s) Made WT Crime Location Auto AUTOTH i 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements MP-15-283056 Crime Location Auto Crime Location Auto FLEE Crime Location Street/Sidewalk AUTOTH Crime Location Street/Sidewalk DWI Crime Location Street/Sidewalk FLEE Crime Location StreetlSidewaik WT Type of Drugs Ecohcl DWI Page 7 of 29 Non?inventoried Property Vehicle Vehicle Number: 1 Owner Role: 0001 Owner Name: Mccarthy. Make: Subaru Model: OUTBACK 2.5l Ll Model Year: 14-14 VIN A Plate: MN 309LUM Plate Year: 16 Original CCN: NIPZU15280552 Estimated Value: $1.00 - Estimated Recovered $1.00 Value: Vehicle Recovery Address: 1527 Logan AV Mlnneapolis. MN 55411Zip Code Recovery Date: Jul 29. 2015 Category Egg Descrigtion Vehicle Comments SU BA STN WAGON Vehicle Hold traffic Vehicle Impounded Yes Vehicle Recovered Yes Vehicle Towed Yes Vehicle Used in Crime Yes Vehicle Description . Categog Descrigtlon Comments Vehicle Coior Inter Beigefi' an Vehicle Color Side Black Vehicle Color Top Black Vehicle NLO. Key Vehlcie Type 4 Door Vehicle Type Sedan Property and Evidence Pl# item Description Owner Qty Makeli?odlSer Auth lD Di. 2015?29258 1 BLACK T-SHIRT A001 1 006620 Hold For Investigations 201 ?5?29258 2 BLACK UNDERWEAR A001 1 006620 Hold For investigations 2015-29258 3 PR OF BLUE JEANS A001 1 006620 Hold For Investigations c4f1-1 1 1/2 01201 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 8 of 29 2015-29492 1 DIGITAL EVIDENCE 1 Case Suppiements 17 supplements begin on the following page. O. .. 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - 056 Page 9 of 29 Supplement number: 1 CCN: MP-15-283056 Author: 007876 - Steve Wuorinen Supplement of Off S.Wuorinen #007876 on 07/30/2015 00:15 On 0712912015, was doing DWI Court visits when Schmidt called me and requested that! assist a Fourth Precinct Squad at the Chem Test Unit with a impaired driver. I responded to the Chem Test Unit. When the squad arrived they brought the AP into the unit. I was told that the AP had refused to do SFST's at the accident scene. i notice a strong odor coming from the AP that was unpteasant. i asked the AP for his ?rst name and he refused to give it to me. I then asked him for his date of birth and again he refused to give it to me. was given the name of the AP and saw that he was revoked in MN. I asked the AP if he had stepped into some dog dropping and he did not answer me. I read the Implied Consent Advisory to AP Clark who as what charge was refusing to take the test. i re read paragraph 2 to him and then he told me that he understood the Advisory. He told me that he wanted to talk to an attorney. The handcuffs were removed and he was given the phone and phone books. Ap Clark called his mother and then a friend. He did not get an attorney's phone number from them. When he hung up the phone he toid me that he was done with the phone and phone books. i asked. him if he would take the breath test and he said yes. AP Ciark was given the DMT test and he blew a .000. END of Supplement 1 .m1nneapolis.mn.us/Caprs 1 11'201'2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 10 of 29 Supplement number: 2 CCN: MP-15-283056 Author: 002139 - James Frost Supplement of Off J.Frost #002139 on 07/30/2015 00230 On 07/29/2015 at 2210 hours I was working marked squad 42-5 with my partner Of?cer Conner, when we responded to the area of 16th Av. N. and Girard Av. N. to assist a squad in pursuit of a stolen motor vehicle. Squad 4?10 aired they were involved in a flee with MN plate 309-LUN which came back as a stolen vehicle. As information was being aired by squad 410, I could hear the squads emergency siren was activated. Squad 410 aired the vehicle was W8 on 16th Av. N. from Fremont Av. N. We turned WB on 10th Av. N. and saw squad 410 several blocks ahead of us with their over head lights activated. They soon aired the suspect vehicle was SB on Logan Av. N. We turned SB on Logan Av. N. from 16th Av. N. and I saw that the vehicle had come to a stop in the front yard of 1527 Logan Av. N. and officers were taking the occupants into custody. One of the males taken into custody was later found to be wanted by Metro Transit Police. The male, later identified as as given to Metro Transit Police who arrived on scene to take custody of nim. We then cleared the scene. END of Supplement 2 1 1/2020] 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 11 of 29 Supplement number: 3 CCN: Author: 006371 - Kristina Schmidt Supplement of K.Schmidt#006371 on 07/30/2015 01:24 On July 29, 2015 was assigned to the Minneapolis Police Departments Traf?c investigations Unit. was assigned to Unit 9980 when was contacted by Sgt. W. Liotta regarding a vehicle pursuit, which ended in a collision in the area of Logan Avenue North and 16th Avenue North. Sgt. Llotta requested respond to the scene. i responded to the scene at approximately 2225 hours from the Traf?c Units office. Upon arrivai I observed MN 390LU in the yard of 1537 Logan Avenue facing in a South Westerly direction. The vehicle was at rest between the front porch of the address and a tree on the south side of the yard. i observed the vehicle to have damage to multiple areas. The damage included scrapes, cracking of the bumper, damage to the lights and the mirrors, as well as a ?at front right tire. I observed the front wooden rail of the porch of 1527 Logan Ave to be completely shattered and lying in the front yard of the address. I observed tire tracks in the Boulevard which showed the vehicle travelled through the yards of1527 and 1531 Logan Avenue North after attempting to makes a ieft turn to head south. I observed Logan Ave North to be a two iane north bound One Way with. multiple cars parked on either side of the street. The address was just south of 16th Avenue North and North Commons Park. The intersection is a intersection which is clearly marked with "Do Not Enter" signs from 18th Avenue or. to Logan Ave N. spoke to Of?cer Carlson who advised me he was the passenger of?cer in Squad 410 and his partner Officer Bauer was driving. Officer Carlson advised he observed the listed vehicle traveiling on the street and did a query of the license plate. Officer Carlson advised the vehicle was confirmed Minneapolis Stolen Vehicle. Squad 4'10 pulled in behind the vehicle at which time it accelerated. A pursuit ensued at which time the vehicle made several evasive maneuvers until it crashed. I then spoke to Sgt. Liotta who advised that two juvenile passengers were in the vehicle at the time of the pursuit and there were no apparent injuries to these passengers or the driver, I was advised was uncooperative but smelled of alcohol. I requested CLARK be transported to Minneapolis Police Chem Test to determine level of impairment. i was advised a 15 year old passenger was wanted for another offense and had been seen by ambulance and then detained by Metro Transit Police Department and was no longer on?scene. was advised a back seat passenger, 13 years old, was being treated by ambulance for a possible minor injury. This passenger was later reieased and had a bump to his head which was not deemed significant. photographed the scene and the surrounding area. Photos were taken of the interior of the vehicle. 1 did not observe any apparent blood in the vehicle. I observed the stolen vehicle to still be running with a single key in the ignition. I reviewed the Squad 410 video (Marked Squad 412 76678). The video captures Squad 410 directly behind the vehicle With the Emergency lights and sirens activated. The video shows the suspect vehicie making several evasive maneuvers including acceleration, failing to obey several traffic control devices including stop signs and stop lights. and travelling down alley ways. The video shows the squad to be travelling at approximately 45 miles per hour on 16th Ave when the suspect vehicle acceierates away and abruptly attempts to turn left onto Logan Avenue N. The squad can be seen circling around and then AilClark on the driver's side just prior to his apprehension. Photos were provided to Officer Grabowski for download for future use if needed. Of?cer Bauer advised while in pursuit of the vehicle he was not able to make the turn onto Logan Ave and corrected his steering and coliided with a tree in the yard of 1531 Logan Ave N. A separate CCN: 15-283246 1 i /20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - NIP-15283056 Page 12 of 29 was generated and labeled a Squad involved Property Damage Accident. SGT. SCHMIDT #6371 TRAFFIC INVESTIGATIONS END of Supplement 3 1?1th 1 - 11/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements MP-15-283056 . Page 13 of 29 Supplement number: 4 Author: 006385-Andrew56hroeder Supplement of Off A.Schroeder #006385 on 07/30/2015 01:42 lD OF A2 On 7-29-15 was working as Squad #411 with Of?cer Davis. Around 2215 hours, we responded to the area of ism/Logan. as Squad #410 had been in a motor vehicle ?ee. When we arrived all the parties in the stolen vehicle had been detained. Of?cer T. Carlson then instructed me to ID both passengers of the vehicle. I then spoke to Vi?yl stated that he was OK, and did not need medical attention- 1 then spoke to A2. who I immediately recognized as told me that he was not injured, and did not need medical attention. i was aware that A2 was wan ed the METRO TRANSIT DEPARTMENT (MTPD) for Robbery (MTPD i contacted MTPD investigator D. Lund, who asked me to have the juvenile male booked at JDC for AGGRAVATED ROBBERY. i then contacted the MTPD Dispatch, who arranged a squad to come to our location. i then spoke to MTPD Sgt. Wyatt. and briefed him of the incident. who authorized a PC MTPD Of?cers Lenders and Yang arrived and took-into custody. i then assisted in searching the vehicle that was involved in the chase. No items of contraband were found. i then cleared the scene. Later in the evening, MTPD Officer Yang contacted me and told me thatUctual last name Was - and he had multiple warrants. notified Of?cer T. Carlson of A28 last name. END of Supptement 4 1. MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MP-15-283056 Page 14 of 29 Supplement number: 5 CCN: Author: 000340 Benjamin Bauer Supplement of Off B.Bauer #000340 on 07/30/2015 02:47 On 07/29/2015 i was working marked squad 412(76678) as squad 410 along with my partner Of?cer Carlson. was the driver and my partner was the passenger during the following incident. At approximately 2206 hours i was driving westbound on 16th Ave from Fremonttowards Girard Ave on routine patrol. There was a vehicle MN- plate 309Lin facing westbound on 'iBth Ave in betwaen Fremont and Girard Ave parked with its lights on. As we passed the vehicle my partner ran the plate through NCIC. After running the plate my partner informed me that the vehioie was a stolen vehicle out of Minneapo?s. i turned the squad car around in attempt to stop the vehicle. As i turned the squad around I noticed the vehicle drive westbound towards Girard Ave and then turn Northbound on Girard Ave N. attempted to pull behind the vehioie when i noticed that the vehicle increased its speed towards 17th Ave trying to evade police. When the vehicle got to 17th Ave it went through the stop sign and then turned eastbound on 16th Ave N. At this point i activated my lights and sirens in attempt to conduct a Felony stop on the vehicle. The vehicle continued to go eastbound on 17th Ave going through the red light at 17th and Fremont Ave continuing eastbound. The vehicle then stopped at 17th Ave and Emerson Ave for a brief moment and then continued eastbound on 17th Ave N. The vehicle then turned southbound on Dupont Ave from 17th Ave N. When the vehicle got to 16th Ave it turned eastbound on 15th. The vehicle then drove to Bryant Ave and turned southbound on Bryant Ave speeding up as it came around the corner. At 15th Ave the vehicle turned westbound. The vehicle then turned Northbound in thealley in between Bryant Ave and Dupont Ave 1500 btockvaimost striking several trash cans on the west side of the alley. The vehicle drove to 16th Ave and turned westbound still refusing to stop. The vehicle continued westbound on 16th Ave again not stopping for of?cers an attempting to evade offiders. The vehicle then increased it speed to approximately 60 miles per hour going through stop signs and red light stop lights. The vehicle then got to Logan Ave and made an evasive maneuver and attempted to turn southbound on Logan Ave N. As the vehicle turned southbound on Logan was unable to make the turn because of the speed that we were going. I drove westbound through the yard of 1531 Logan Ave clipping a smalt tree with the front driver side of the squad causing minor damage. I was able to conduct a full U?turn and went southbound on Logan Ave N. As i went southbound on Logan Ave I noticed that the vehicle was crashed on the south east side of 1527 Logan Ave N. With the driver, who was later lD?d through lViN state lD was exiting the vehicle. A walked in front ofthe squad car to the passenger side, where my partner deait with him. i noticed that there was a front passenger in the vehicle. I ordered the front passenger: who was later lD'd as V1. out of the vehicle. Vi still had his seatbelt on. had to physically take the seatbelt off V1 and pull him out of the vehicle. V1 was placed in handcuffs pending our investigation. Another of?cer assisted with V1 and placed V1 in the back of our squad car. i noticed that my partner was stilt struggling to place A91 in custody. was on his feet and appeared to be trying to get away from my partner. i ran over to my partner and at this point he was down on the ground. AP's hands were under him and he still appeared to be resisting arrest. i ordered to put his hands behind his back several times. i tried to physically puli APi's right hand behind his back, however AP refused to follow my commands and tensed up pulling away from me. - At this point AM was not following my commands and he had not been searched yet so did not know if he had a weapon on him or not. i struck on the right side of his face one time with my right fist. immediately put his hand behind his back. was then handcuffed and pieced in the back of squad 421. .mirmeapolis - 1 0. 1 1 120.1201 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 15 of 29 The other OCCUpant, who was later lD'd as APE, was placed in custody by other of?cers. AP2 was found to have several warrants from Hennepin County and was wanted by Metro Transit for Robbery. The warrants were con?rmed over channel seven. I asked Vt if he was injured. V1 stated the back right side of his head hurt. V1 had a large bump on the right side of his head. EMS was called to the scene to check on all the occupants of the vehicle. EMS arrived and checked on all the parties. AP1 and AP2 both refused medical attention. V1 was transported to HCMC to be evaluated by a doctor. My partner rode down to the hospital with V1 because he was a Juvenile. My partner also called to inform her of the incident. It should be noted that before V1 left the scene, he stated the following. Vi met up with AP1 and AP2 in attempt to buy some marijuana. He stated. that he ?rst met them and they were on bikes. However. both of them told him to get into the listed stolen vehicle. and then they sped off when saw the police. Traf?c Investigator and Supervisor were called to the scene for the squad accident and for use of force. Squad 408(Sgt. Mercil) arrived on scene and performed my use of Force report. Squad 408 took pictures of and spoke with him about the incident. Squad 9980 (Sgt. Schmidtt) arrived on scene and took pictures of the crash. 9980 later wrote the state accident report. Squad 42'! transported to Chem Test, where the DWI procedures were performed on him. AP1 was then Booked HCJ for PC Auto Theft and PC Flee in a Motor Vehicle. PC, Authorized by Sgt. Lictta, badge 0491. AP2 was booked by Metro transit for his warrants. The vehicle was towed to the'Minneapolis Impound lot as a recovered stolen. END of Supplement 5 14/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements MP-I 5-283 056 Page 16 of 29 Supplement number: 6 CCN: NIP-15483056 Author: 000998 - Troy Carlson Supplement of Off T.Carlson #000998 on 07/30/2015 03:10 While working Squad 410 with my partner Of?cer B. Bauer, we were on routine patrol in the area of 16th Ave and Fremont to Girard Ave N, when I saw a vehicle parked mid-block on the north side of the street with several males near it, I observed a black male wearing a black shirt with short dread locks getting into the driver's seat. I used our squad MDC to run the license plate, MN 309LUM. The results showed us that this was a Stolen Vehicle. By the time, i saw that it was a stolen vehicle we already west of the stolen and i told my partner it was a stolen vehicle. while airing to dispatch that we were outwith a stolen vehicle. By the time, my partner was able to turn our squad around; the stolen vehicle was now traveling MB on Girard Ave N. from 16th Ave at a high rate of speed. My partner tried to catch up to the vehicle, as it turned E8 on 17th Ave N. The vehicle again drove away at a high rate of speed, my partner then activated our emergency lights and siren. The vehicle traveled EB on 17th Ave crossing Fremont and Emerson Ave while running red lights and having little regard for public safety. The vehicle turned SB on 17th and Dupont Ave and then EB at 16th and Dupont Ave N, the vehicle then went SE at 16th and Bryant Ave N, and back NB in the alley of the 1500 block of Bryant to Dupont Ave N, all at a high rate of speed and did not stop at the mouth of the alley. Once out of the alley at 16th Ave and Bryant to Dupont, the vehicle turned WB on 16th Ave N, and continued WB on 16th crossing several major intersections and running multiple stop signs without making any attempt to slow down. The driver, id'd as actually sped up and away from officers after 16th and Fremont Ave N. causing us to be almost a block and a half behind him. 1 believe the driver reached speeds of over 70 MPH while Fleeing from Officers. The vehicle tried to make several evasive maneuvers and pretend to turn SB from 16th while of?cers were pursuing him. The vehicle ultimately made a SB turn on Logan Ave N, and lost control of the vehicle due to his high rate of speed and went into the front yard of 1527 Logan Ave and struck the front stairs of the house, coming to a rest. Officers attempted to also turn SB and went into a front yard of the house on 161Logan Ave N, did a U-turn and continued SB on Logan, parking just behind the stolen vehicle, while we were traveling SB on Logan observed the same male i seen get into the driver?s seat of the vehicle, exit the driver's seat of the vehicle and attempt to walk away from the vehicle. My partner stopped the vehicle and I got out while telling the driver/A1 to get on the ground andvA'l continued to walk away from the vehicle. 1 then tackled A1 and held him on the ground, as i knew this was the driver and for of?cer safety A1 had to be controlled as at this point it was only my partner and on?site. I used my forearm to hold A1 down and i observed another male, lD'd as A2, crouched next to the car, attempting to hide, i then ordered him to the ground at gun point and he complied. Another Officer places handcuffslon this male, and attempt to roll A'i over on his stomach and place handcuffs on him. When he rolled over, he kept his left hand under his body and i tried to grab it out from underneath his body, and place a handcuff on him. it was at this point I felt Ai's body tense and he sprung to his feet while bucking my off his back, I hung on to him and possibly thought he was having a seizure or some injury from the crash, but he was resisting of?cers and refused to place his hands behind his back. At refused to place his hands behind his back and other Officers came in to assist me in handcuffing A1, while i yelled very loudly to ?Put your hands behind your back!" A1 was then taken into custody. Once Al was handcuffed i monitored him and watched as he again tensed up and appeared to have his eyes roll back in his head, fearing he was possibly injured from the crash, i called for an ambulance code 3 to the scene to check on A1. Later when the ambulance arrived on-scene. A1 appeared to be normal and refused all medical attention. I then waited at the scene to have a traffic car respond and lD the occupants of the vehicle. it was at this point, Officer Schroeder notified me that was wanted by Transit PD for an unrelated Aggravated Robbery. and they would be coming to take custody of him. Transit PD arrived on-scene and took custody of A2. Their CCN 1 1/20f2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MP- 15-283 056 Page 17 of 29 was 14-014574, which the PC Pick-up was for. It was later determined that A2 used a faise name, AM, and actually also had 5 outstanding warrants for his arrest. A2 was booked at JDC for the robbery and his warrants. While still o'n?scene, an ambulance was called for V1 to get him checked out due to his age and the fact he was involved in the crash. V1 was placed in the ambulance and prior to his departure to go to the hospital; was instructed to interview him brie?y on Camera by Sgt. K. Schmidt, as to who was driving and what happened. I then removed V1 from the ambulance and placed him in my squad and activated our MVR. i asked him who was driving and he stated the male in the black shirt with the dreadlocks. He stated the male told him, he was "Petty Folks" on the street. V1 stated he was on Broadway trying to buy "Weed" and ran into A2, who walked him to where A1 was with the vehicle and they got in the vehicle to go ?nd weed, and that is when Of?cers tried to stop the vehicle. V1 stated he did not know why A1 drove away from the police. i then put V1 back in the ambulance and was instructed by Sgt. Liotta to ride with V1 to the hospital, until PGZ could arrive at the hospital, due to the fact that he was a minor. I then left .the scene and rode in the ambulance with V1 to HCMC and waited with him till PG2 arrived. V1 stated his pain was a 1. on a scale of 1?10. He was taken to the hospital as a precautionary measure and did not appear to be injured. Once P82 arrived on?scene at the hospital, I released V1 to her custody, and gave her a blue card. V1 was transported via ambulance, run #15049668. My partner then picked me up from the hospital and we drove to shop to drop off our squad car that was damaged in a see CON 15?283246. lt should be noted that while in the FLEE, we were driving marked squad 412, We technically began to pursue the vehicle at 17/Girard Ave N. and I announced to dispatch per their question that it was indeed a FLEE at 16/Dupont Ave N. Sgt. Mercil was on-scene at the crash location and notified him of my use of force on A1, which was nothing more than a tackle to get A1 on the ground to prevent him from fleeing on foot. i then documented my use of force in a CAPRS. Use of Force report. I clicked that A1 did not require EMS, but an ambuiance was called in case, and that he refused all medical services and did not ciaim he was injured. END of Supplement 6 11/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 18 of 29 000251 - Benjamin Supplement number: 7 Author: Badowich Supplement of Off B.Badowich #000251 on 07/30/2015 04:18 On 07/29/2015 Of?cer Badowich was assigned to squad 421 along with my partner Of?cer Mays. We were driving marked squad 421 At approximately 2210 hours. I heard squad 410 air on the radio that they were in a pursuit with a storen motor vehicle. Officer Mays, who was driving our squad, drove to the area of 16th Ave and Logan Ave and observed that the vehicle had crashed. I exited my squad car and ran up to the suspect vehicle to assist other Of?cer on scene. i assisted Of?cers Bauer and Carlson with handcuf?ng After was handcuffed I saw that he was unconscious. i then rolled into the recovery position. A short time later, HOMO ambulance arrived on scene. was now awake. refused any and ail medical treatment. I then stood up and escorted him to our squad car. was then placed in the rear seat of our squad. The MDR camera was turned on Sergeant Liotta advised us to transport to the CHEM TEST unit. was given a breath test which he blew a .000 A1ICLARK was then transported and booked at HCJ for PC Flee police in motor vehicle and PC Auto theft. ciothing were property inventoried. END of Supplement 7 vi 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report ith Supplements MP-15-283056 Page 19 01529 Supplement number: 8 COM: MP-15-283056 Author: 004507 - Michael Mays Supplement of Off M.l\llays #004507 on 07/30/2015 05:16 15-283056 While working marked squad 421 (76681) with my partner, Of?cer B. Badowlch/passenger, we were conducting a traf?c stop at the intersection of Lyndale Ave and 26th Ave (CCN: 15-283048) when we heard squad 410 (Of?cer Bauer/ Of?cer Carlson) air via radio that they were following a STOLEN VEHICLE. i ran up to the vehicle, provided the driver with his drivers license and citation, went back to my squad and drove off to assist with the FLEE. At the intersection of 16th Ave Logan Ave N, observed the stolen vehicle parked on the 1527 Logan Ave front yard next to the house. i parked my squad car on 16th Ave (facing westbound) from Logan Ave and exited out of my squad car. i ran over to the stolen vehicle and cleared it (make sure no one else is inside). i then made contact with the renter from 1527 Logan Ave (lower unit) and advised her about what occurred and asked her if there were anyone hurt inside her residence. The female. who was later lD'd via MNDL as THOMPSON. Shaklra DOB: stated that everyone inside her home was okay, but were scared clue to tne ioud "banging" noise. THOMPSON was given a blue card and advised. My partner and later transported a male (CLARK) to the Minneapolis Chem Test and then to were he was later booked for PC AUTO THEFT and PC FLEE. END of Supplement 8 1 112012015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 20 of 29 Supplement number: 9 CCN: NIP-154283056 Author: 095704 - Christopher Hudok Stolen Auto END of Supplement 9 I 1/201?201 CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - 5?283 056 Page 21 0f 29 Supplement number: 10 CCN: Author: 006620 Mark Sletta Supplement of MSIetta #006620 on 07/30/2015 14:13 Statement of Sgt. Sletta CCN: 15?283056 On 7.80/15 1 was assigned to investigate this case. i reviewed the reports and learned the following; 1.0fficer Carlson observed A1/Clark getting into the driver's seat of a vehicle along with several other parties and ran the license plate of the vehicle. BOQLUM came back as a Minneapolis stolen taken between 7.127 at 1930 hours and 7/28 at 0845'hours. 2.0fficers Carlson Bauer attempted to turn around and stop the vehicle, however it began to Flee. Officers activated their lights EL sirens and the vehicle continued to flee. The vehicle was speeding and ignoring traf?c signs signals. 3.The vehicle eventually crashed driving into the yard at 1527 Logan Ave "striking the residence.- 4.0fficer Carlson Observed Clark exit the driver's seat and walk away from the vehicle. Officer Carlson the tackled Clark and held him to the ground with his forearm. Of?cer Carlson then Observed A2 rouching behind the vehicle on the passenger side and ordered him at gun point to get on the ground. 5.Due to the suspect vehicle crashing Officer had ambulance respond to the scene to cheek out the three occupants. 6.Sgt. Carlson interviewed so that old him he met and took him to Clark said Clark was the driver of the sto en car. the scene and could buy some weed. I then contacted the owner of the stolen vehicle VilBrian McCarthy. i read McCarthy the name, dob and description of each party that was in his vehicle when it was recovered and he said he did not know any of them and did not give anyone permission to use the vehicle. McCarthy told me that after reporting the vehicle stolen they check further and cannot ?nd the valet key for the vehicle and it is possible that it was inside the center counsel at the time the vehicle was stolen. i then went to HCJ and conducted a taped Scales Interview of Clark. i read Clark his Miranda Warning and he said he understood his rights and would speak to me. The following is a summary of the interview; 1.Clark said he never drove the vehicle. 2.Ciark said that permission. Clark said he told showed up. Clark did not know why had the vehicle and told him it was his mothers and he took it without the should bring it back and they were doing that when the police 3.Clark said he was the back seat passenger of the vehicle during the chase. 4.Ciark said after the crash he got out of the vehicle with his hands up and one of the officers tackled him for no reason. He then said he guessed he understood that he got tackled because they had just been in a car chance and the of?cer did not know what they were going to do. 5.0lark said the of?cers choked him until he had a seizure and then punched him repeatedly, "Like Eric Garner?. Clark said he has had seizures in the past and he does not take any medication for them. I asked aprsweb.ci.2ninneapolis.mn.us/ CaprsApp/ CaprsReport.aspx??GU ID=8204c4f1 -i 1.00/20} 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 22 of 29 Clark if they called an ambulance to treat him and he said they did but he didn't like the people who came so he did not get treated. After interviewing Clark I returned to the precinct and revieWed the MVR from 76678. Theyideo does not show the stolen vehicle crashing; however it does show Clark walking away from the open driver's his hands up. After watching the video Clark could not have been in the back seat and had to have been the dnven The video also shows Of?cer Carlson tacklin Clark (they are both on the ground at the front of the squad and not seen on the video). Carlson then orders to get on the ground on the passenger side of the vehicle while appearing to hold Clark to the ground. It does not show Officers repeatedly punching Clark nor can you hear Officers repeatedly punching Clark on the video. Clark is a convicted Felon showing he was convicted of Aggravated Robbery of Person in Hennepin County on {24:10. Based on the MVR video showing Clarkjust outside the driver?s door and Of?cer Carlson's observations of Clark driving the vehicle I will be submitting this case the HCAO for consideration of the charges of Fleeing in a motor vehicle and felony Receiving Conceaiing Stolen Property. Case Open END of Supplement 10 aprsApp/ CaprsRepprtaspx?EGU ID=8204c4fl i 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements MID-15983056 Page 23 of29 Supplement number: 11 CCN: Author: 000998 - Troy Carlson Supplement of Off T.Carlson #000998 on 07/30/2015 14:18 It should be noted the listed vehicle. had a single key in the ignition of the vehicle. END of Supplement 11 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 24 of 29 Supplement number: 12 Author: 000491 -Wendy Liotta Supplement of W.Liotta #000491 on 07/30/2015 20:14 CCN #15-283056 Typed by myself. On 7?29-2015, was assigned as a Middle Watch Patrol Sergeant at the 4th Precinct Station My call sign was Squad 404. was working in a fully marked MPD uniform capacity. At approximately 2210 hours. i heard Squad 410 air to dispatch they were behind a stolen vehicle. 1 than heard via the radio, Squad 410 was airing information of the direction of travel of the stolen vehicle with clear audible emergency siren activated in the background. con?rmed with Squad 410 via radio that they were in a pursuit with the stolen vehicle. Squad 410 confirmed they were in a pursuit. i asked for their speed and they repiied via radio they were going 28 miles per hour. They continued to air the direction of travel. It was then aired the stolen vehicle had crashed into a house at 152? Logan Av N. The driver. A1. was taken in to custody. (Squad 408, Sgt. Mercil handled the force report). The two passengers were also taken In to custody. I arrived on scene. I immediately contacted the Traffic Unit. The Traffic Unit arrived on scene. The Traf?c Unit took responsibility for the accident (house) and the Squad accident. Please see that supplement. No officers were hurt. Ambulance came to the scene for A1 who refused everything from EMS. The paramedics also looked at the juvenile, A2 but released him. MTC took custody of A2 since he had a PC pickup for Robbery through Metro Transit. The third juvenile was taken to the hospital via ambulance for a minor bump on his head. Of?cer Carlson, from Squad 410, rods with this juvenile and once the mother arrived at the hospital he gave over custody to the mother. Squad 410 was driving squad 412 and this squad is equipped with an MVR. reviewed the video of the pursuit. A pursuit summary was completed. END of Supplement 12 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 25 0f 29 Supplement number: 13 CCN: MP-15-283056 Author: 002366-ScottGrabowski Supplement of Off S.Grabowski #002366 on 07/31/2015 10:25 PURSUIT REVIEW COMPLETED ON THIS CASE. END of Supplement 13 caprsweb.ci .mi1meapolis.xm.us/ 1 - 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements .283056 Page 26 0f29 Supplement number: 14 CCN: NIP-15483056 Author: 006620 - Mark Sletta Supplement of MSletta #006620 on 07/31/2015 10:58 Statement of Sgt. Sletta 15-283056 Case Closure This case was presented to the Hennepin County Attomey?s Of?ce as a criminal complaint. This case was assigned to Assistant County Attorney Thad Tudor, who reviewed this case and authorized a criminal complaint against Jamar Oneal Clark. Dob: 7/29/91 for; FLEEING a PEACE OFFICER in a MOTOR VEHICLE (Felony) The Hennepin County Attorney's Office issued a complaint. which I reviewed and then signed via e?Charging. Case Closed by arrest/complaint. (50) Sgt. Mark Sletta 4 Pet Investigations END of Supplement 14 ?l 1 1/20/20 i5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 27 of 29 Supplement number: 15 Author: 003688-Sandra Kellogg Supplement of S.Kellogg #003688 on 07/31/2015 11:08 Owner of stolen/rechered vehicle, Brian McCarthy, called to provide his cellphone number and current address: 3315 Humboldt Ave S. MN 555408. Previous address listed was 2216 Irving Ave MN 55405. END of Supplement 15 .us/Caprs 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements 5?283 056 Page 28 of 29 Supplement number: 16 CCN: MP-15-283056 Author: . 004218 - Daniel Lee Supplement cf Off D.Loe #004218 on 08/04/2015 23:31 Crime Lab Unit, Digital Squad Video Report, 15-283056 On 08/03/2015 the Crime Lab Unit received a request from Julie Fling, Hennepin County Attorney's Of?ce. for a DVD copy of digital squad video pertaining to the incident. On 08/04/2015, I retrieved the following digital squad videos from the L3 Communications server: File# 581446: 76678 on 07/29/2015 at 2209hrs File# 581448: 76878 on 07/29/2015 at 2257hrs File# 581553: 76681 on 07/29/2015 at 2234hrs created and labeled one DVD copy of the recorded footage. The requester was notified via email that the DVD Was ready for pick-up at the Minneapolis Crime Lab Unit. The above videos are set to archive should a future copy be requested. END of Supplement 16 - 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MPH-283056 Page 29 of 29 Supplement number: 17 GCN: MP-15-283056 Author: 096069 - Mary Rye Supplement of M.Rye #096069 on 11/13/2015 11:03 15-280552 and 15283056 Claims Processing - Amica Scan Center PO Box 9690 . Providence, RI 02940?9690 AUTO HOME LIFE Toll Free: (1 E. Fax: 1?866?847-1603 October 28, 2015 Minneapolis Police Department 350 5th St, Room 31 Minneapolis, MN 55415 File Number: 60002208104 Date of Loss: 07/28/2015 Our insured: Brian W. McCarthy Report Number: 15-280552 Location of Loss: 3315 Humboldt Ave To Whom it May Concern: Please make this letter a permanent part of your file. We have paid our insured for a theft/vandalism loss. Your report number is noted above. if any arrests are made, we request that our interests be protected to the extent that restitution may be considered at time of trial or sentencing. Thank you for your cooperation. Sincerely, Leeann M. Dunn Claims Department 888-902-6422 X44308 END of Supplement 17 End of report for case MP-15-283056. Print lD: 0. .. 1 1/2 0120 1 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/38 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information . Description: Squad 425 video review - Of?cer Sworski I Ofr. Conner Occurrence From: 1112312015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/23/201 5 00:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis SA Olson located and identified the dash [squad camera video from Officer Jeff Sworski (squad 425). The video (previously taken as evidence item 26.1) appears to be consistent with Officer Sworski's supplemental report (MP-15423384139). Item 38.1 (copy of squad 425 squad video) obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1611 7N Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshi? Name (319 I Property #1 - Copy-of squad video?from' 425 -. P76703 (SWo?r'ski - Conner) DOB Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Copy of squad video from 425 P76703 (Sworski - Conner) Property Status: BCA 1 HQ Status Date: 11/23/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Officers g1 Sworski, Jeffrey (Officer! Minneapolis Police Department) Conner, Chad (Officer! Minneapolis Police Department) Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas (Officer I Minneapolis Police Dept) Schwarze, Dustin Timothy (Officer! Minneapolis Police Dept) Record Status Information A . Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 1112312015 14:MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 1 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/38 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Record/Status Information - continued . . - I 7 1 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 16:39 Reporting LEO . Date I Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) 5-. 4v MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 On Monday, November 23, 2015, SA Olson reviewed squad video from Of?cer Sworski and Of?cer Conner (squad 425). The camera system in this squad offers two views camera 1 facing forward on the front dash and camera 2 facing to the rear passenger compartment. Audio is captured on the video. The DVR identi?er in squad 425 is documented as MPD P76703. This video shows squad 425 enroute to the scene at 0050 hours. The squad arrives on scene at 0051 hours and is parked at an angle facing northwest (facing the Elks Lodge east of the scene) on the south side of Plymouth Avenue. Several bystanders are observed approaching the scene while yelling and screaming toward emergency responders. At 0053 hours the video shows Of?cer Sworski opening the rear cargo door to the squad and putting items inside the vehicle. Of?cer Ringgenberg arrived and is observed sitting in the back seat of the squad behind Of?cer Sworski. According to Of?cer Sworski?s report (supplemental 39) Of?cer Schwarze was seated in the front passenger seat (not video recorded). Squad 425 is then observed leaving the scene. The video recording stopped in the parking lot of the 4th Precinct at 0054 hours. While enroute to the 4th Precinct Officer Sworski inquired with Schwarze and Ringgenberg whether they were okay, but did not engage in further discussion with either of?cer while enroute to precinct. SA Olson will separate (video evidence is comingled with several other squad videos from evidence item 26.1 disc 1) and copy this video from squad 425 to a separate disc (evidence item 3 8. 1). End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/39 Report Date: 1 1123/2015 Primary Information . i I 5 .7 . . Description: Neighborhood Canvass of the 1600 Block of Plymouth Ave No. Occurrence From: 1112012015 10:30 Occurrence To: 1112012015 12:30 Reporting LEO: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1210112015 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 1 Metro Regional Office 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 20, 2015 at 1030 Hrs, five agents from the MN BCA and six agents from the FBI teamed up and re-canvassed the 1600, block of Plymouth Ave in an attempt to identify any witnesses and gain witness statements. Five people were identi?ed and interviewed during this canvass. Those interviews were documented on individual reports. 2015?648120,21,24,25,and 36. No evidence was obtained by virtue of this report. Adaress #1 #1 Primary Information Address: 1600 BLOCK OF PLYMOUTH AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/39 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Subject #2 - MENTION IN REPORT Evans, Michael Donnell - Primary Information Subject Name: Evans, Michael Donnell Record Type: Person Bio: 53 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #301, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address HOME Subject #3 - MENTION IN REPORT #2 - Hardnett, Shalamar Dimineon Primary Informa tion Subject Name: Hardnett, Shalamar Dimineon Record Type: Person Bio: 36 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1619 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Telephones E?Addresses Relationship NumberlE?Address PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO Suspended LICENSE Subject #4 - MENTION IN REPORT Pamj?Zacari-ah - Primary Information Subject Name: Pam, Zacariah Record Type: Person Bio: 50 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - JuvenileMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/39 Report Date: 11/23/2015 subject #4 - MENTION IN REPORT #3 - Pam, Zac?ariah Continued Addresses Relationship Address FREQUENTS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #101, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship 1 NumberlE?Address USER-NON SUBSCRIBER Subjects Relationship Name SISTER B_ig DOB Pam, Peggy Lucille (Person) 63 yr. old, Black, Female Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota 11/20/2015 NO LICENSE Subject #5 - MENTION 1N REPORT Olivia Jerrefoine Primary Information Subject Name: Scott, Olivia Jerre'Dine Record Type: Person Bio: 21 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE #201, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones ddresses Relationship NumberlE?Address PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota no LICENSE S?Ubiect - MENTION INA REPORT . Primary Information Subject Name: Stroud, Chala Iyssa Record Type: Person Bio: 27 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: JuvenileMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/39 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Subject #6 - MENTION IN Stroud, Chala Iysrsa- ContinUed Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #203, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Officers Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Olson, Christopher (Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) PRITZLAFF, Mike (Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBI/Mpls I Federal Bureau of Investigation) Morrissey, Katie (Special Agent/ Vogel, Matt (Special Agent] FBI) BLACKMORE, Bob (FBI - MINNESOTA, MINNEAPOLIS) . Holden, Jonathan (Special I FBI - MINNESOTA, MINNEAPOLIS) Burnham, Chuck (Agent/ FBI - MINNESOTA, MINNEAPOLIS) Record St?atus InformatIOn- Record Origination Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/23/2015 15:19 Last Update Operator: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: . 12/01/2015 20:05 Reporting LEO I Date Supervisor Date Swanson, Gary (13261 MRO - Homicide! Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) narrative begins can the renewing. page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On November 20, 2015 at 1030 Hrs, five agents from the MN BCA and six agents from the FBI teamed up and recanvased the 1600 block of Plymouth Ave in an attempt to identify any witnesses and gain witness statements. During the canvas, five people were identified and interviewed. Those interviews were documented on individual reports completed by the agents that did the interview. The reports are as follows: 2015-648I20 Conducted by SA Pritzlaff 2015-648I21 Conducted by SSA Swanson 2015-648I24 Conducted by SA Olson 2015-648I25 Conducted by SA Olson 2015-648/36 Conducted by SA Horner No evidence was obtained by virtue of this report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/40 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: MN BCA Property Release/Disposal and 37.1 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 11/23/2015 Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Recbrd Status Info-rmatic'n a Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 15:40 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/23/2015 15:48 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor . Date Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Chartes (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Offense Number: 2015?64813? case Agent: Apprehension) Phili, Charles (1385 MRO - Hon" 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal item Quantity Description 1 1 One DVD containing Video and Audio footag- squad cameras State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION I hearby certify that I have received the above listed property a we; 1 1/23/2015 Signature I 0 Date Received Name - HomICIde Minnesota Bureau of OwnerIFor Owner Address City/State Released By Telephone Verified By gswanson 1 1/23/2015 ?1 4-41? ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt offense Number: 201564815 Case Agent: Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehensmn) Item Quantity Description 1 1 CD containing audio zip ?le and PDF of ShotSpotter data State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION I nearby certify that I have received the above listed property . P) -- . WW TS Date Received 11/23/2015 Signature . Name [cgi?gsjelgiss?gm - HomICIde Minnesota Bureau of OwnerlFor Owner Address CityIState Released By Telephone Veri?ed By gswanson 11/23/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 14-41 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disp osal Receipt Offense Number: 2015-648/21 case Age" Apprehension) t, Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Item Quantity Description 1 1 CD containing file of the interview State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION hearby certify that i have received the above listed property Signature Name Address Phill??ha?es (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) City/State Telephone gswanson 11/23/2015 111-419. ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Date Received 11/23/2015 Owner/For Owner Swanson. Gary (1326 Released By MR0 Ho icicle] Minneso Bure of Crimi tank?,- Verified BY We? ex?/ Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015?648/41 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information) Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/23/2015 Approved By: Lab Report Firearms Analysis Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11/23/2015 17:23 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 17:27 R??girrting?L?ED I . - - Date, Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 TTK- (651) 282-6555 FAX: (651) 793-2901 AN ASCLDEAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To; BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. ReportNo. 2 Attention: SA Mike Phil] REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Firearms 11/20/2015 Laboratory Number: SIS-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Firearms Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/With a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packaging One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a ?rearm One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as test specimens One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a magazine One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a ?rearm One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as test specimens One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a magazine One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as cartridge case(s) One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as bullet fragment(s) One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as bulletCs) Results of Laboratory Examination: Description/Source Smith Wesson, magazine with ammunition, and one cartridge. test ?red bullets and cartridge cases from Item 5 (NJP - 11/19/15) from Smith Wesson - two magazines with ammunition SIG Sauer, magazine with ammunition, and one cartridge. test ?red bullets and cartridge cases from Item 7 (NJP -11/19/15) from SIG Sauer - two magazines with ammunition from boulevard north of 161 1 Plymouth Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #1 Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #2 Item 5 (a Smith and Wesson Model 9mm Luger caliber pistol bearing serial number ?red Item 10 (a 9mm Luger caliber cartridge case) and Item 20 (a bullet). Examinations and test ?ring of Item 5 showed the ?rearm and the safety mechanisms to be functional. The trigger pull was measured and found to be ?om 6% to 7 pounds. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory N0. SIS-14003 Report No. 2 Examinations and test ?ring of Item 7 (a SIG Sauer Model P226 9mm Luger caliber pistol bearing serial number UU763221) showed the ?rearm and safety mechanisms to be ?inctional. The trigger pull was measured and found to be ?'om 4 to 41/2 pounds (single action) and from 10 to 101/2 pounds (double action). Item 19 (an apparent bullet fragment) is unsuitible for comparative examinations. No comparative examinations were done with Item 8 (two SIG Saueer magazines, each containing 20 cartridges) or Item 6 (two Smith and Wesson magazines, each containing 17 cartridges). Two cartridges ?om Item 5 were used for the production of test specimens. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. am Nathaniel J. Pearlson Forensic Scientist 3 Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/42 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11I23I2015 Approved By: Lab Report DNA Initiation Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/23/2015 17:25 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 1 1123/2015 17:27 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor - . Date Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide/ Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26I2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793?2900 me (651) 282-6555 AN ASCLD/LAB?Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. 815-14003 ReportNo. 3 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMJNATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 11/20/2015 Laboratory Number: 15-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark Description of Submitted Evidence: gem Type and Packaging Description/Source 3 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a from EMT truck swabbing ?om Item 3A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a ?om rear drivers side door handle - EMT truck swabbing ?rom Item SB One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from rear passengers side door handle - from swabbing ?om Item EMT truck 3C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from side door on passengers side - ?om EMT swabbing ?om Item truck 3D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a ?'om front passenger side door handle - ?om swabbing ?om Item EMT truck 5 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a Smith Wesson, magazine with ammunition, ?rearm and one cartridge. 5A a ?rearm Smith Wesson 5B a magazine Smith Wesson 9mm magazine 5C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as silver FC 9mm+P cartridge(s) 7 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a SIG Sauer, magazine with ammunition, and one ?rearm cartridge. 7A a ?rearm SIG Sauer 9mm Model P226 7B a magazine SIG Sauer P226 9mm 7C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as silver FC 9mm+P cartridge(s) 9 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Duty Belt from Mark Douglas Ringgenberg an item of evidence 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an handcu??s with original packaging item of evidence 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded vest - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 1213 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t- Red t?shirt - Jamar Oneal Clark Page 1 of 3 12D 12E 12F 12F1 12F2 12G 12G1 12G2 shirt One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as underwear One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jeans One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as socks socks socks One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a pair of shoes a left shoe a right shoe One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as an item of evidence One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing ?om Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing from Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing from Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as lcnown head hair(s) One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings Results of Laboratory Examination: Items 3A through 3D, 14A and 14B were collected. Laboratory No. Report No. 3 Red plaid Hanes boxes - Jamar Oneal Clark Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark black socks - Jamar Oneal Clark black socks - Jamar Oneal Clark black socks - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark cup Jamar Oneal Clark left and right hand left hand Jamar Oneal Clark right hand Jamar Oneal Clark right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #5 left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 Five samples were collected from Item 5A as Items (grips), 5A-2 (trigger), (magazine, slide and safety releases), (sides of slide and back), and SA-S (muzzle and lens of ?ashlight). Blood was not detected on Item SA-S. One sample was collected from Item 5B as Item (bottom edges). Six samples were collected ?om Item 7A as Items (grips), (trigger), (back sides of slide), (back and hammer), 7A-5 (magazine, slide and safety releases) and 7A-6 (?ashlight). One sample was collected from Item 7B as Item 7B-1 (bottom edges). Five samples were collected from Item 9 as Items 9-1 (holster), 9-2 (mace holder), 9-3 (handcuff holder with cover), 9?4 (handcuff holder) and 9-5 (accessory holders). One sample was collected from Item 13 as Item 13-1. DNA analysis will be performed on selected items. If you have not received a report within 2 months of the date on this report, or if DNA analysis is not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratmy. One sample was collected from Item 11 as Item 11-1 (inside/outside edges). Blood was not detected on Item 11?1. Page 2 of 3 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 3 Additional DNA and Blood Pattern analysis will be performed on Item 11. If you have not received a report Within 2 months of the date on this report, or if DNA analysis is not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. Items 12A through 12E, 12F2, 12G1 and 12G2 were examined, but nothing was collected at this time. Items 5C, 7C, 22, 23 and 24 were not examined. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. 2am Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Portions of pertinent evidence items have been removed and are being stored at the BCA laboratory. The contents of Items 3A through 3D, 14A and 14B have been retained. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/43 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: PD Reports 65-83 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 11l23/2015 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11I23I2015 18:24 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/23/2015 18:26 Reporting LED 1 I - Date Supervisor. I Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of1 MPD CAPRS Supplement - MP-15-423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 65 Author: 001327 - Russell Gragin Date Printed: Nov 23. 2015 Supplement of Off R.Cragin #001327 on 11i15/2015 11:05 On 11/15/15 at 0051 hours, Of?cer Knoll and i, working as marked squad 8222, responded to an Of?cer Needs Help call at 1611 Plymouth Ave. N. Upon arrivai. we assisted with crowd control in the inner perimeter. We then assisted with crowd control along the perimeter on Piymouth Ave. N. While assigned on the north side of Plymouth. I observed several persons (approximately 30) in various small groups. 1 attempted to locate any witnesses by asking the individuals if they witnessed the incident. No subjects came forward as witnesses to the incident. and most were hostile towards of?cers presence at the scene. At approximately 0130 hours. we were relieved off the scene. End of Supplement report for case Print 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Page I of 2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Suppiement Number: 66 Author: 003287 - Steven Jensen Date Printed: Nov 23, 2015 Suppiement of Off S.Jensen #003287 on 11/15/2015 14:22 Crime Scene Report CCN: 15-423384 Offense: Critical incident Date/Time Noti?ed: 11/15/2015 6:00 Location: Forensic Garage, 51 Coifax Ave Briefed By: Sgt. Moore/Homicide Unit Scene Summary: Sgt. Moore requested processing of speci?c areas of a HCMC ambulance (Rig #419) for DNA and friction ridge impression evidence in regards to an of?cer invoived shooting. We processed the ambulance at the MPD Forensic Garage. - Crime Scene Documentation - Responded: Of?cer S. Jensen, FS M. Schuitz - Photographed By: FS M. Schultz Crime Scene Bioiogical Evidence Collection By: Of?cer S. Jensen - Biological Swabs: DNA Description item/Area and Location: HCMC ambulance rig #419 Rear door handle (driver side) - Rear door handle (passenger side) Side door handle (passenger side) Front door handle (passenger side) The foilowing items Were coiiected from the exterior of the HCMC ambulance rig #419 by Officer Jensen: 15-1023-CS.1 - DNA Swab(s) from rear door handle (driver side) 154023-032 - DNA Swab(s) from rear door handle (passenger side) 15-1023-CS.3 - DNA Swab(s) from side door handie (passenger side) DNA Swab(s) from front door handle (passenger side) Crime Scene Powder Processing - By: F8 M. Schultz - Description item/Area and Location: HCMC ambulance rig #419 - Exterior passenger side doors Exterior rear doors of HCMC ambulance rig #419 The following friction ridge impressions were collected by F8 Schultz: 154023-085 - Impression Lift from rear door of ambulance rig #419 (A) 154023-0815 - impression Lift from rear door of ambulance rig #419 (B) 15-1 023-08.? impression Lift from rear door of ambuiance rig #419 (C) impression Lift from passenger side rear door of ambulance rig #419 (D) The developed friction ridge impressions will be examined and the conclusions will be added in a separate supplement. The collected DNA Swabs will be inventoried at MPD Property and Evidence Unit. The photographs are retained in the Crime Lab Unit. Sgt. Moore released the ambulance to HCMC personnel. .1 1/23/1201 5 MPD CAPRS Supplement Page 2 of 2 We hereby certify that this is a report of the conclusions of an examination performed by us. Officer S. Jensen Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police Department F8 M. Schultz Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police Department . . ., . .. End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print ID: EASDDC) nan??. .. .. 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NAP-15423384 Page I of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CON: Nip-15423384 Supplement Number: 67 Author: 116525 Michael Schultz Date Printed: Nov 23, 2015 Supplement of FS M.Schultz #116525 on 15:08 Crime Scene Report CCN: 15-423384 Offense: Critical Incident Datel?l'lme Noti?ed: 11/15/2015 7:16:00 AM Location: 730 8th St Briefed By: Sgt. Moore Scene Summary: We were informed that an individual in this case had been taken to the Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) and was in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU). Sgt. Moore requested that we respond to the HCMC ICU to take photographs of the hands and arms of the individual. i took overall photographs, as well as close up photographs of the hands and arms of Jamar O'Neil Clark (DOB 5/3/1991). The photographs will be retained in the Crime Lab Unit. i hereby certify that this is a report of the conclusions of an examination performed by me. F8 M. Schultz Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police Department End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print ID://caprsweb.ci.minneapol 31385 I 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number; 68 Author: 005497 - Daniel Payne Date Printed: Nov 23, 2015 Supplement of Of? D.Payne #005497 on 1111512015 15:33 I was working in marked squad 212 using the call sign 8212 with my partner, Of?cer Choriton. We self?assigned to the heip call at 1611 Plymouth Av N. We arrived and I helped provide security for the perimeter of the incident. I assisted with canvassing 1611 Plymouth Av to collect any witness statements. 1 knocked on Apt 301 and the resident inside stated that he did not hear or see anything because he was sleeping. knocked on Apt 302 and no one answered. i knocked on Apt 303 and the resident stated that she had just got home and stated that she did not see anything. I knocked on Apt 304 and there was no answer. None of the residents wanted to give me any of their persona! information. End of Supplement report for case NIP-1 54123384. Print 10: . 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - MRS-423384 Page 1 Of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CON: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 69 Author: 006369 Corey Schmidt Date Printed; Nov 23, 2015 Supplement of Of!" on 11/15/2015 17:07 On 11-15-2015 at approx. 0051 hrs, while working squad 110 able, I responded to a HELP call at 1611 Plymouth Av where dispatch had aired that shots had been ?red. When I arrived 1 was directed to start moving the crowd of people that has started to gather on the north side of Plymouth Av because the police tape needed to be The group that was gather was very hostile; they were yelling things such as "fuck the police". "you are kitlers" and "You?re next". The group was also recording the police and pushing the yellow police tape. lined up with several of?cers and we started moving the group North stayed on scene until was directed by Sgt. Tucker to head back downtown to assist with bar close. i signed the crime scene log and cieared the call. END OF REPORT. . .. . H. report for case NIP-15423384. Print ID: C707F91 End of Supplement caprsweb.ci E3 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS - Mew-423334 Page 1 of1 Case Supplement Minneapotis Police Department CON: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 70 Author: 005806 - Aaron Prescott Date Printed: Nov 23, 2015 Supplement of A.Prescott #005806 on 11 ll 6/2015 08:13 On 11/15/2015 i was off duty as an investigator in the Internal Affairs Unit. At approximately 0136 hours 1 was noti?ed by phone of a critical incident involving MPD of?cers at 1611 Plymouth Av N. responded to the scene. Upon my arrive! I met with Together we received brie?ngs from the incident commander, squad 407 MCBRIDE, car 9 Lt NOVAK. and the investigator on scene. GREEN. walked us through the crime scene. After reviewing the scene we met with Lt HALVORSON and CASE at the 4th station. i then cleared the incident. End of Supplement report for case EMF-15423334. Print ID: 77.. .M . r. 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Page 1 0f1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: RAP-15423384 Supplement Number: 71 Author: 006357 - Thomas Schmid Date Printed: Nov 23, 2015 Supplement of T.Schm?d #006357 on 11/16/2015 14:59 On Sunday, November 15, 2015. at approximately 0030 hours, Lt. Halvorson contacted me and informed me that a Critical Incident had occurred regarding an of?cer involved shooting to have taken place at 1611 Plymouth Ave. N. in Minneapolis. responded to the scene with Sergeant Prescott. Sgt. Prescott and were debriefed on what had occured by Sgt. McBride and Lt. Novak. We then walked through the crime scene with Sgt. McBride and Lt. Wheeler, then cleared from the scene. End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print ED: -. . . 743A2C61 1 1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement? NIP-154123384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Poiice Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 72 Author: 007418 - Twila Villella Bate Printed: Nov 23. 2015 Supplement of T.Villella #007418 on 11118/2015 22:52 SCENE NOTIFICATION ON 11/15/15 AT15-423384 On 11/15/15 at approximately 0115 hours, Lt. Zimmerman contact me and advised me that there was an Of?cer Involved Shooting that had occurred at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North and the individual that was shot by Minneapolis Police was in critical condition and not expect to survive. I advised him that Sergeant C. Green would respond to the scene and the witnesses should be brought to room 108 to be interviewed by me. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Villelia Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes Investigation Division~Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case HEP-15423384. Print ID: . . ..-.. . .1/23/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement 84 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Supplement Number: 73 Author: 007418 - Twiia Viilella Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423334 Date Printed: Nov 17. 2015 Supplement of T.Villelia #007418 on 1111512015 22:55 INTERVIEW WITH TYLER LUPKES AT VCID ROOM AT APPROXEMATELY 0217' HRS ON 11/1511 5 On 11/15/15, at approximately 0217 hours, i met with Tyler J. Lupkes at interview room F. activated the audio/video equipment for the room. This is a summary of Lupkes interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: Lupkes totd he was on duty working for Hennepin County Medicat Center - EMS. Lupkes told he was working with Mari Hill. Lupkes told he overhead on his radio that an ambulance crew was requesting hetp to their location and were in ad of . po ice response. Lupkes told he heard ambulance crew state that the assailant was trying to gain entry ?red and they had aired this several times. Lupkes told the ambulance crew currently at that location had aired that they were leaving the area. Lupkes told that it is procedure for a 2nd ambulance to be dispatch when an ambulance crew is requesting assistance. Lupkes told they responded to 1600 block Plymouth Avenue North. Lupkes told while enroute to the location the call was upgraded to a shooting call. Lupkes told upon his arrival he observed a lot of squad cars and people out on the sidewalks. Lupkes told his supervisor was ?agging them down with his ?ashtight where he was at with the patient. Lupkes told they were on Lupkes described this male as a black mate, mid 20's, red t~shirt and black jacket. Lupkes told he observed blood on the males face and the injury was somewhere on the top of the males face. Lupkes told he and his partner loeded the male into ambutance and transported him to Hennepin County Medical Center. Lupkes told that the ambulance does video record the front outside and inside and the rear outside. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes investigation Division-Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case rue-15423384. Print it): emseAAzFeeo} 11/17/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - EMF-1.5423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 74 Author: 007418 - Twila Villella Date Printed: Nov 17, 2015 Supplement of #007418 on 1111652015 23:00 WITH HILL AT ROOM AT 0234 HRS ON 11/15115 On 1015/15. at approximateiy 0234 hours. i met with Mari Hill at VCID, interview room F. activated the audio/video equipment for the room. This is a summary of Hili's interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: - told she was on duty working for Hennepin County Medical Center - EMS. Hili told she was working with Lupkes. Hill told an ambulance crew requested a squad to their location because the assailant was there and approaching their truck. Hill told she heard the duty supervisor had responded to the scene. Hiil told she heard the supervrsor state that the assailant was outside the door of the ambulance. Shortly after the supervisor had responded to the scene she heard the supervisor state there was shots ?red. that EMS was code 4, but they needed to leave the area. Shortly after this was aired Hill told they got dispatched, originally coded as routine and then said they were told it was changed to a shooting and to respond code 3. Hill told ali they knew it was shots ?red, one down and they didn't know who was shot. Hill told this crew was out on the scene for a medical call and someone was having ankle pain. Hill told when they arrived there were squads everywhere and people were yelling and police of?cers were present. Hill told she heard yelling and heard a melee voice stating, "Black Lives Matter" over and over. Hiil told she observed the patient lying on the grass between the sidewalk and the street. Hill told the supervisor was providing the patient medical treatment. Hill toid the patient had a gunshot wound to the head. Hill described the patient as being a black male, a little bit tailer than 5?5, thin to lean built. wearing baggy clothing, red plaid boxsrs on baggy jeans, black zip-up sweatshirt, quilted jacket, possibly a red t-shirt on, but doesn't recall the color, and 24 years of age. Hiil told she did not see any weapons lying by the patient and her partner had asked of?cers if the patient had been search. Hiil told she felt on the patient for weapons and did not find a weapon on him. Hill described the scene as dark and not weil lit. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Villella Minneapolis Poiice Department Violent Crimes Investigation Division-Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case HEP-15423384. Print in: l. 1/ 1 7/2015 CAPRS Supplement - NIP-15423384 Page 1 of2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number: 75 Author: 007418 - ?l?wila Villella Date Printed: Nov 17, 2015 Supplement of #007418 on 11/15/2015 23:08 INTERVIEW WITH TYLER HASKELL AT INTERVIEW ROOM AT 0254 HRS ON 11/15/15 On 11/15/15, at approximately 0254 hours, met with Tyler Haskell at VCID, interview room M. activated the audio/video equipment for the room. This is a summary of Haskell?s interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: Haskell told he works for Hennepin County - EMS. Haskell told he was working with Wesley Thompson. Haskell told they received a call at 0020 hours for one with ankle pain and came out as a medical miscellaneous. Call stated the incident happened about an hour ago. They responded to 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, apartment 204. Haskell told when they arrived there was a few people standing outside and one of them had a key and let them into the apartment building. Haskell told they went to the apartment and there was a female sitting with her son. This female told she was not able to put weight on her ankle. Haskell describes this female as an African American. 5'6, 120 lbs, and described her as being intoxicated. Haskell told this female told she hurt her ankle because she had broken up an altercation about an hour prior to calling EMS. Haskell told at that time the female did not tell them who the ?ght was between. As they were leaving the building entrance with the female who was in a transport chair. they noticed a male crying and acting kind of odd. Haskell's partner asked this male if he was okay and they male didn't respond and looked away. As they continued walking towards the ambulance the female told them that was the male who had did this to her. Haskell describes this male as being African American, 5'8, long dreads, wearing black sweatshirt. black pants. Haskell told they continued to walk towards the ambulance with the female. Haskell told his partner got on the radio and requested police of?cers to respond with lights and sirens because the assailant was on scene. Haskell told as they were trying to get the female onto their stretcher the male he had previously described walked Lip to them and was asking where she was going, in case he wanted to come and see her. Haskell's partner told him to back off and to let her be at "this time. Haskell describes this male as being about 3 feet away from them and his partner kept telling this male to back up and stay away. Haskell told the female patient told this male to please stop and she didn't say anything else to him. Haskell told the female claimed that she didn't know him, but the male kept claiming he was her son. The female denied that this male was her son. Haskell told the female told them this male was not related to her. Haskell described the male as calling his partner pussy," Little Bitch.? Haskell told his partner got on the radio again and asked for police to respond Code 3, that the assailant is standing around them. Haskell told they got into the ambulance and white doing patient care and waiting for the police to arrive the male this whole time was knocking on the back window and was trying to open the door. Haskell told that his supervisor arrived and parked behind their ambulance. Haskell heard the supervisor talking to the male, telling the male to relax, that they were just checking things out and making sure everything is okay here. Haskell told he unlocked the doors so the supervisor could get into their ambulance. Haskell told the empervisor got into the ambulance and he asked the supervisor to re-lock the ambulance doors. 1 1/17/2015 CAPRS Supplement - Page 2 are Haskell told her never observed the police arrive. As they were talking to the supervisor and were getting ready to leave the scene that is when they heard the one shot being fired. Haskell described after hearing the gun shot he hit his emergency help button on. Haskell told the supervisor got on the radio and aired shots fired and they needed help over the radio and they alt got down on the floor of the ambulance. Haskell told the supervisor got out of the ambulance and his partner got out of the ambulance to get into the driver seat to drive out of the scene. Haskell told the supervisor stayed behind. Haskelt told he did not see anything outside between the police and the male outside. Told he did not hear them say anything and all he heard was a gun shot. Haskell told he heard talking outside, but did not hear what was being said and did not hear any screaming until after the gun shot and then heard a bunch of people screaming, but not any words. Haskell told he does not know who was shot outside besides his partner telling him it was the guy they originally had the altercation with. Haskell told the lighting in the area was dark, except for the ambulance lighting. Haskell told there were 5 to 6 people outside and across the street at the bar area had 10 to 12 people outside. Haskell told he never observed weapons on this mate, but told this male had his hands in his pockets a lot. Haskell told it appeared the female had been hit in the face a few times. Haskell told they transported this female to North Memorial Hospital and identi?ed the female as Rayann Hayes. Haskell told they had been parked facing eastbound on Plymouth and the ambulance side door was on the boulevard side. Haskell told he heard the shot coming from that area. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Villella Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes investigation Division-Homicide Unit End of report for case NIP-15423384. Print lD: .. 1 1/17/20 I 5 MPD CAPRS Supplement mess-423384 Page 1 of2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number: 76 Author: 007418 - Twila Villella Date Printed: Nov 17. 2015 Supplement of T.Villeita #007418 on 11/16/2015 23:15 INTERVIEW WITH WESLEY WILLIAM THOMPSON AT INTERVIEW ROOM AT APPROXIMATELY 0320 HRS ON 11/15/15 On 11 [15/15, at approximately 0320 hours. i met with Wesley Thompson at VCID. interview room M. activated the audiofvideo equipment for the room. This is a summary of Haskeil?s interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: Thompson told he works for Hennepin County Medics! Center - EMS. Thompson told he and his partnerlI-iaskell responded to 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, apartment 204, on a medical miscellaneous that the patient had been assautted when breaking up a ?ght that occurred one hour ago. Thompson told the call came in at 0020 hours on 11l15f15 and arrived at 0025 hours. Thompson toid the run number is 15076386. Thompson told upon arrivai they parked facing eastbound on the northside of the building. Thompson toid they went to the apartment 204 and located an African American female. 5'6. 100 lbs, in her 40's. last name Hayes. Thompson told the family was sleeping and there were kids in the house and a teenage son. Thompson told he observed the female had a hurt right ankle, had abrasions to her nose and a cut lip. Thompson told this femaie told him that her injuries occurred when she was in the hallway and while trying to break up a ?ght Thompson told they used a stair chair to get her down the stairs and down to the ambulance. Thompson told as they got outside of the door of the building. Thompson told a male was crying. Thompson described this male as being African American male. wearing all black clothing, having dreads and is crying. Thompson asked this male if he was okay. Thompson totd the female stated to them that is the guy that did this to me. Thompson told this mate iater told them that he was the femates son. Thompson told white they were getting the female onto a stretcher, the male was approaching them and because the female had told them that this was the person who had assaulted her Thompson got on the radio and requested a squad to respond Code 3. Thompson told as they were loading her up on the stretcher the male approached saying he was her son and the female was teliing them that the mate was not her son. Thompson told this male that he needed to back up. Thompson toid that this male started to salt him names, calling him a bitch and saying to him "fuck you pussy." Thompson told this male then told the female that he was going to come down to see her and the female wasn't responding back to him. Thompson told he was on the radio with dispatch telling them that they need police to arrive now. Thompson told he did not notice if the mate had any weapons in his hands. Thompson totd he was mainly focusing on getting the female into the ambuiance. Once inside they looked the ambulance doors. Thompson described the area around the ambulance as not well lit. Thompson told that his partner told him that the male had knocked on the back door. Thompson told they were staying inside the ambulance and waiting for help to arrive. Thompson told the supervisor arrives behind them and parks his vehicle facing westbound and they can see this through their rear door windows. Thompson observes the supervisor have a conversation with the mate outside. but he cannot hear what is being said. Thompson told he could hear over his radio that the supervisor had ordered the squads Code 3. I 1/ i 7/2015 o. - Supplement NIP-35423384 Page 2 of 2 Thompson told that the supervisor came into the ambulance and they have a brief conversation about who the male is outside and who is he to her. Thompson told he did not observe the police arrive, but believes they were there because he knows that the supervisor would not have come into the ambulance leaving a strange man outside the ambulance. At the time they are getting ready to go they heard a loud pop outside. Thompson told he knows its gun ?re in a close proximity. Thompson told he heard one shot. Thompson told he sailed on the main "shots ?red" and the supervisor hit his email button. Thompson did not hear any arguing outside the ambulance before he heard the shot being ?red. Thompson told he didn?t look to see if the male had any weapons. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Villella Vioient Crimes Investigation Division-Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case Nip-15423384. Print ID: 4~ SSDDAC 1 1/17/20] 5 EMPD CAPRS Supplement - Page 1 of2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: BAP-15423384 Supplement Number: 77 Author: 007418 - Twila Villella Bate Printed: Nov 2015 Supplement of #007418 on 11/182015 23:17 INTERVIEW WITH MICHAEL AT VCID INTERVIEW ROOM AT APPROXIMATELY 0349 HRS ON 1 5/15 On 11/115115, at approximately 0349 hours. I met with Michael Trullinger at VCID. interview room M. activated the audio/video equipment for the room. This is a summary of Trullinger?s interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: Trullinger told he works for Hennepin County - EMS and is the duty Deputy Chief of Operations. Trullinger told he was the supervisor on duty and told he heard ambulance truck 419 was asking for squads Code 3, but told they were Code 4 inside their truck. The personnel in truck 419 told that the suspect in the assault was trying to access into the ambulance and interfering with the care. Trullinger told this ambulance crew responded to 1611 Plymouth Avenue North. Trullinger toid that the female had an ankle injury and she had been hit in the face. Trullinger described this male as being black, short dreads. but not real short. darker outerjacket with possibly a dark red shirt. Trullinger told he approached this male and asked him what he wanted and the male told him that the female was his mother. Trullinger told that It appeared to him that the male was trying to forcibly make himself cry. Trullinger told the squad arrived and he walked up to one of the of?cers and told him this is the suspect in the assault and the person who is trying to gain access into the ambulance and he asked that they talk to this male as he wanted to talk to his crew. Trullinger told there were people coming out of the Elks approximately 6 to 10 and from the apartments there were quite a number of people out there. told he did not see the male with any weapons but he noticed that he would have his hands in his shirt or pockets. Trullinger told as he approached the side door of the ambulance he looked back and it appeared that one of the of?cers were trying to get control of him and observed one of the of?cers doing an escort hold on the male. Trullinger told he got into the ambulance and began asking the crew how everything was going and then asked the patient who the male was as he was claiming to be her son. Trullinger asked the female if this was the man 7E1 1 1/17/201 5 CAPRS Supplement a Page 2 of 2 from his head. Truilinger totd his ambulance crew to get out of there and they were going to transport the female to North. Trutiinger told he went up to the male on the ground and saw that he wasn't breathing, but had a pulse. Trullinger told he went to his truck to get medical equipment and started to provide life saving measures on this male. Truilinger told he called for a truck right away and requested ?re to respond. Trullinger toid the male had a gunshot wound to his left side of his head on the temple area. White the crew . arrived to assist they loaded the male into the ambulance and left the scene as a crowd was gathering. Truilinger told no weapons at that time was found on the mate. Truilinger told the male was transported to HCMC. told he only noticed one of?cer with their weapon out Trullinger told this of?cer was a white mate. possibly blonde hair or no hair. 5'11, medium to bigger buiit. Truilinger told that he did observed a pair of handcuffs lying next to the patient on the right side of him. Trullinger told the handcuffs were lying on the grass and were not on the male. End of Supplement Sergeant Twiia Vilteita Minneapotis Police Department Vioient Crimes investigation Division?Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case HEP-15423384. Print it): 02618905738} 68 7E 1. DAB. .. 1 1/17/2015 s. MPD CAPRS Supplement MP- 1.5-423384 Page 1 of 2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: BAP-15423384 Supplement Number: 78 Author: 007418 - Twila Date Printed: Nov 17. 2015 Supplement of T.Villella #007418 on 1111 6/2015 23:25 INTERVIEW WITH RAYANN HAYES AT NMMC ON 11/15/15 On 11/15!15. in the early morning hours, i went to North Memorial Medical Center, to conduct an in-person interview Rayann Francine Hayes. i took an audio recorded statement from her. This is a summary of Hayes interview and should not be considered verbatim without the use of quotation marks: i introduced myseh? to Rayann Hayes and told her i was there to take a statementfrorn her. Rayann Hayes she lives at 1223 Morgan Avenue North and was over at her daughters house at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, apartment 204. Rayann Hayes told that her daughter is Shamirra Finn and her daughter has a 2 year old. Rayann Hayes told she had been drinking and had two shots and a cosmopolitan drink and had smoked marijuana today. Hayes told she went to a birthday party at Alfred and Keylondra apartment 103. Hayes told others were aiso present and they had played cards Sharice Clark, Jamar Ciark who is Sharice brother and Ronnie Powell. Hayes told that Sharice Clark lives in apartment 104 with her husband Jerome Poweli. Hayes told she has known the people that live in 103 and 104 for approximately 1 year. Hayes told that something popped off and Aifrecl and Keytondra had got into an argument. Hayes wasn?t sure exactly what happened and while they were inside ptaying cards with Alfred and Key Key. Hayes was asked what happened to her face and leg and she told everything happened so fast. Hayes told when Alfred and Keylondra were fighting she got in between the two. i asked Hayes about sailing the paramedics for her injuries and when they were bringing her outside to the ambulance she pointed out the mate responsible for causing her injuries. Hayes acknowledges telling the paramedics this. I asked her who she told was responsible for causing her injuries and she stated she told them the guy standing in front of the building. Hayes ?rst responds that she doesn't know his name and really doesn?t know him like that. Hayes then describes the male throwing her to the ground and bagging her against the floor. I asked Hayes to describe the male and she told he is black and the one with the dread locks, short in height. dark complexion and then told it was Jamar Clark, age is middle 20's. told her that he is saying that he is her mother. Hayes told that is not true. Hayes told that the suspect is Sharice brother, who is Jamar Clark. Hayes told she doesn't know why Jamar did this to her. Hayes told that Jamar shoved her to the ground and said best, but then stopped describing this. Hayes told when she got up Jamar apologized and stated he thought she was someone else. Hayes told that when her ankle was injured it happened outside in the hallway of the building on the let floor. Hayes toid this happen approximately 830. Hayes denied calling the police and someone else called the police. Hayes told that when she was inside the ambulance that Jamar tried to get inside the ambutance. Hayes told that Jamar never gained access into the ambulance. i asked her what happened when she was in the ambulance and she told that the drove her to the hospital. i asked Hayes if she heard any shots outside of the ambulance and she told me no. Hayes was asked it she saw Jamar with a weapon and she told me no. I asked her if she ever saw Jamar with a weapon and she told me no. 1 1 1/1 7/201 5 w, MPD CAPRS Supplement 84 Page 2 of 2 Hayes told Jamar grabbed her and he did a leg swipe on her and she fell backwards to the ground. Hayes told Jamar was trying to get her attention in the wrong way. Hayes told that Jamar had head butted her and caused the out to the inside of her lip that needed stitches. Hayes then showed me the to the inside upper lip. Hayes told Jamar is a normally a calm person and has never seen him like this in the past. Hayes told that Sharice, Ronnie Powell, Alfred and Keyiondra and the kids would have witnessed Jamar do this to her. After turning off my audio recorder was told by Hayes that she suffered a fractured right ankle and she may need surgery. End of Supplement Sergeant Twila Viilella Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes investigation Division?Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print it): 1 1 1/1 7/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Suppiement Number: 79 Author: 007418 - Twila Villella Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Date Printed: Nov 20, 2015 Supplement of T.Villella #007418 on 11/17/2015 08:39 MECC CONTACTED TO CALLS TO 1611 PLYMOUTH AVENUE NORTH On 11/15/15. I contacted MECC to verify if Minneapolis Police had been dispatched to the address of1611 Plymouth Avenue North anytime on 11/14/15 to the time the paramedics had received a medical call on 11115115. I was told that no other calls were made for police or paramedics until the call on 11/15/15 at 0020 hours. End ofSupplement Sergeant Twila Vittella Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes investigation Division-Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case MP-15-423384. Print it): 1. 1/20/20] 5 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NIP-15423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supptement Number: 80 . 003636 . . Author. Christopher Karakostas Date Printed. Nov 20. 2015 Supplement of C.Karakostas #003636 on 11/17/2015 10:36 Statement of Sgt. Karakostas #3636 on 11/15/15- initial response On 11/15/15. LT Zimmerman calied me and asked thatl respond to the area cf1611 Plymouth Ave N. Lt Zimmerman told me that there was an of?cer involved shooting and of?cers were still on the scene. responded to the scene and arrived at approximately 0245 hrs. talked to Commander Grander at the scene. i was told of?cers were involved in a shooting and a person was at HCMC and was still alive however he was in serious condition and may not survive his injuries. White at the scene DC Fowlkes stated he was going to go to HCMC and meet with family members. i was asked to go to HCMC and attempt to swab the victim?s hands. i left the scene and arrived at HCMC at approximately 0315 hrs. While at HCMC I talked with HCMC nurse Val Rozenscn. I asked the nurse if it would be possible to swab Jamar Clark?s hands. I was told his hands had been cleaned with Chlorhexidine when he arrived at HCMC. Val Rozenson handed me sterile swabs and swabbed the victim's right hand and ?ngernaiis. Another nurse was attending Jamar Clark's left arm. Val Rozenson swabbed Jamar Clark's left hand. The swabs were put in the in plastic bags and labeled "right" and "Left." took the swabs from the ptastic bags and placed the swabs and in envetopes. The swabs were property inventoried. I cleared HCMC a short time later. Sgt. Karakostas Homicide Unit - -- our?. M. . . End of Supplement report for case Print ID: a - . 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NIP-15423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 81 Author: 003414 - Jaclyn Johnson Date Printed: Nov 20. 2015 Supplement of Off J.Johnson #003414 on 11/17/2015 12:27 On 11/17/2015, I was working in my normal position as an of?cer in the Strategic information Center, when I received a request regarding this case from Chris Olsen of the BOA. I exported Mitestone Surveillance footage from the Mobile Camera 1 on 11/15/2015 at 1230 to 0230 hrs. The camera was placed midblock on 1200 block of Knox Av and was facing NB towards Plymouth Av at the time of footage which was exports . The footage was burned to a which was labeled and sealed in an envelope that was then labeled and sealed for property inventory. A copy was made availabie for. the investigators. mun-adSupplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print ID: 1 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - MEN-423384 Page I of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MID-15423384 Supplement Number: 82 Author: 002429 - Charles Green Date Printed: Nov 20, 2015 Supplement of C.(3reen #002429 on 11/18/2015 20:22 ENCIDENT DETAIL REPORT 15422966 8: UNIT WI AVL FOR SQUAD 412 AND SQUAD 424 ON 11/14/2015 On 11/18/2015, I reviewed the incident Detait Report for MP0 CCN 15?422966, occurring on 11/14/2015, at 1902 hours. In the Incident Detail Report. data indicates that Of?cers in Squad 412 aired Shots Fired at 19:04:31 hours. Unit Activity data for Squad 412, inciuding Automatic Vehicle Location (AVL) Data. on 11/14/2015, from 18259052009153 hours. indicates that Squad 412 was located at Upton Ave N/Goiden Vaiiey RD at 19:03:54 hours and at 19:05:33 hours. located at Golden Valley RD/lrving Ave at 19:05:04 hours and heading west at 62 mph. According to the data, Squad 424 is ?rst iocated at Goiden Valtey RDlUpton Ave at 19:05:49 hours and heading west at 34 mph, located at Upton Ave NiGolden Valley RD at 19:06:41 hours and heading north at 7 mph. and located at Upton Ave NIGoiden Valley RD at 19:11 :02 hours and stationary. The above referenced Unit Activity for Squad 412 and Squad 424. and the Incident Detail Report for MPD CCN 15422966 were printed. retained. and will be property inventoried. END SUPPLEMENT SERGEANT CHARLES GREEN #2429 MP0 UNIT End of Supplement report for case MP4 5423384. Print ID: {02043605-AOD7-4ccs-8281- 1 1/20/20 1 5 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NIP-154123384 Page 1 of 2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 83 Author: 119885 - Nicole Lenway Date Printed: Nov 20. 2015 Supplement of FS N.Lenway #119885 on 11/20/2015 07:17 Crime Scene Report CCN: 15-423384 Offense: Critical incident Date/Time Notified: 11/15/2015 02:30:00 AM Location: 1611 Plymouth Av Briefed By: Sgt. C. Green Responded: FS J. Christensen, FS N. Lenway We were requested to ?rst respond to 1925 Plymouth Av (Minneapolis Police Department 4th Precinct) to take photographs of the involved of?cers. as well as collect their pistols. Of?cer Photographs Completed By: FS J. Christensen - Ofc. D. SchWarze (#6422) Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) The following items were collected by F8 N. Lenway: - Pistol with magazine from Ofc. D. (#6422) (2) magazines with live cartridges from Ofc. D. Schwarze (#6422) Pistoi with magazine from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) - (2) magazines with live cartridges from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) - Duty belt with holsters, handcuffs, mace and other accessories from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) We then responded to the scene located at 1611 Plymouth Av N. Upon arrival, Sgt. Green briefed us on the incident. Scene Summary: We were informed that HCMC ambulance #419 responded to the area of 1611 Plymouth Av to render aid to a female assault victim. While doing so, EMS personnel requested police presence, as a male was causrng a disturbance, hindering their medical intervention. Upon arrival of of?cers, a physical aitercation occurred with the male when trying to take him into custody. During the altercation. a shot was fired by a responding of?cer, striking the male. Both the female and the male were transported by EMS from the scene. On the boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av N, a discharged cartridge casing (DCC), set of handcuffs (both cuffs open). and a green EMS bag with medicai supplies was observed. An area of blood-like substance (BLS) was also observed on the above mentioned boulevard/sidewalk. HCMC EMS command vehicle #41035 was parked facing east along the south curb of Plymouth Av N, west of 1611 Plymouth Av N. Squad 424 (involved of?cers) was parked facing southeast in the eastbound lane of Plymouth Av N, just east of the above mentioned EMS command vehicle. - Surveillance cameras were observed on the east side of 1614 Plymouth Av (I.B.P.O. Elks of World). it is unknown if the footage from these cameras captured the incident. as we were not able to View the footage while on scene. Evidence markers (Ell/is) A43 were placed by F8 N. Lenway next to the DOC. handcuffs and EMS bag. 3. 1/20/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement IMP-15423334 Page 2 of 2 Crime Scene Documentation: Photographed By: F8 J. Christensen Sketch Completed By: FS .J. Christensen Video Completed By: F8 N. Lenway A secondary search for evidence was conducted and a possible squad key was located near the handcuffs on the boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av N. This was marked with EM: D. Additional photographs and measurements were taken. The following items were collected by F8 N. Lenway: DCC (EM: A) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av - Handcuffs (EM: B) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av Green EMS bag with medical supplies (EM: C) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av Possible squad key (EM: D) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av After collection, an additional search for evidence was conducted with negative results. After clearing the scene, we responded to the Forensic Garage, where we met a tow truck carrying HCMC ambulance #419. Ambulance #419 was placed inside the Forensic Garage. Sgt. J. Moore also responded. along with a supervisor from HCMC, to the Forensic Garage to view video footage captured on the cameras of the ambulance. The collected items were brought to the Crime Lab Unit; They were sealed and placed into secured storage for transfer to the BCA. The photographs, sketch. and video will be retained in the Crime Lab Unit. We hereby certify that this is a report of the conclusions of an examination performed by us. FS N. Lenway FS J. Christenson Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police Department End of Supplement report for case Print ID: 1 1/20/2015 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/44 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Infermation Description: Attendance of Jamar Clark Autopsy Occurrence From: 11/17/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/17/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) synapsis On Tuesday, November 15th 2015, SA Phill and FBI SA Kane attended the autopsy of Jamar Clark at the HCME. It was performed by Dr Baker. A bullet was retrieved from Clark's head. No evidence acquired with this report. Address #1 a Occurred #1 Hennepin County Medical?Examiners-Office Primary Information Address: Hennepin County Medical Examiners Office, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Address RELATED #1 -11"611 PLYMOUTH AVE-N Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Bio DOB Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 .- Ringge?berga? Mark ?dug-?5 Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/44 Report Date: 11/17/2015 S'quth #2 <4 SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze; Dustin Timethy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects . Relationship Name 9?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) suites? #3 ACIar'era'maroneai Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications Hm State Lem me?m FBI lD 717111FD1 NO 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Regard- status Infermation Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/24/2015 10:57 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal ApprehensionMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/44 Report Date: 11/17/2015 Record Status lnfOrmation Continued Last Update Date: 11I30I2015 18:50 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) l? Narrative begins on the follOWing page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of4 On Tuesday, November 17??1 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill and FBI SA Kane attended the autopsy of Jamar Clark at the Hennepin County Medical Examiner (HCME). The Chief Medical Examiner, Dr Baker, performed the autopsy. Dr Baker will issue a full autopsy report at a later date. SA Phill observed that Clark was brought over to the HCME after being pulled off of life support at the Hennepin County Medical Center. SA Phill did not see any evidence of assault or injury to Clark other than a gunshot wound to the left temple area of the head. Dr Baker ruled Clark?s death a Homicide due to a gunshot wound to the head. SA Phill observed Dr Baker retrieve a spent bullet from the head of Clark after it had passed through the brain and come to rest under the skull on the opposite side. Finally, SA Phill made arrangements to have the evidence retrieved from the autOpsy transferred to the lab at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. Clark, Jamar Press Release Decedent: Age: Race: Sex: Address: City: Date Time of Injury: Location of Injury: Date of Death: Time of Death: Location of Death: Comments: 11/17/2015 Hennepin County Medical Examiner 530 Chicago Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55415 Press Release Report Case No: 2015?6355 Clark, Jamar 24 years Black Male 4007 Bryant Ave North Minneapolis State: MN 11/15/2015 1611 Plymouth Ave North Minneapolis, MN 55412 11/16/2015 Hennepin County Medical Center 701 Park Avenue (Hennepin County Medical Center? In Patient) Minneapolis, MN 55415 This individual died of a gunshot wound of the head. Manner of death is Homicide. The MN Bureau of Criminal Apprehension and the FBI are the investigating agencies. Zip: 55412 Page: 1 of 1 4:25 PM Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/45 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12l08I2015 Approved By: Evidence Processing Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Syn?bpsis Digital Forensic Specialist Hughes imaged a hard drive received from SA. Phill in regards to an of?cer involved shooting. The resulting image file was provided to SA. Phil] on a hard drive. Property #1 Hitachi Hard Drive Containing .E01 Image File Acquired From Ambulance Hard Drive, SIN: PGG3AB3F . Submitted To PES: YES Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Computer Hard Drive Description: Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11I24I2015 Quantity: 1 Hitachi Hard Drive Containing .E01 Image File Acquired From Ambulance Hard Drive, SIN: P663AB3F Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/24/2015 16:20 Cheung, Donny (Investigations Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/08/2015 19:54 Apprehension) Reporting LEO I Date . Supervisor Date Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of2 Description of Evidence: Exhibit 29.1 Panasonic Cartridge", model no.: WJ-VR3002, SIN: NBA00819 Toshiba 256 GB SATA solid state drive, SIN: 5418103LTOSY Exhibit 45.1 - Hitachi 500 GB SATA hard drive containing .E01 image file acquired from ambulance hard drive, PGG3AB3F Imaging Process: The Toshiba solid state hard drive from the Exhibit 29.1 Panasonic Cartridge" was removed from the Cartridge" housing and connected to an analysis machine via a functioning and validated Tableau T35e hardware write blocker. An image file (.e01) was created of the solid state drive using FTK Imager v3.2. The image file was validated by hash values. The image file acquired of the Exhibit 29.1 Toshiba solid state drive was then copied to the Exhibit 45.1 Hitachi hard drive. The copied image file's hash values were verified after the c0py had completed. The Exhibit 45.1 hard drive containing the verified image file was then provided to SA. Phill. All examinations are concluded and no further examination is requested at this time. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/46 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/24/2015 Approved By: Lab Report DNA Testing Begun Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/24/2015 16:28 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/24/2015 16:Date Supervisor . . - - .. Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide/ Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of1 MINNESOTA DEPARTNLENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793?2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: 793?290] AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To; BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 11/23/2015 Laboratory Number: Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 4 Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: 3% Type and Packag?pg Description/Source 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection kit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a bloodstain Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on Items 15, 16, 17, 18 and 21. Additional DNA analysis will be performed on selected items. If you have not received a report within two months of the date on this report, or if DNA analysis is not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. Katherine Kingsland Forensic Scientist Page I of 2 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Repoxt No. 4 loci tested using PCR-STR includes some or all of the following: D881179, D2181 1, D7SSZO, D381358, D168539, D281338, D198433, VWA, TPOX, D1885 1, FGA, and Amelogenin. Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed. The contents of Items 15, 16, 17, 18 and 21 have been retained. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/47 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Primary Information Approved By: Description: Evidence Processing Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/08/2015 Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synapsis On November 23, 2015, Digital Forensic Specialist Hughes accompanied SA. Olson to meet with a subject in order to acquire information of interest from the subject's cell phone. Specialist Hughes acquired information from the cell phone and provrded investigation relevant information from the acquisition to SA. Olson. Property-#1 - Samsung cell phone. model no.: sM-cseo?rr, IMEI: 354335073153043 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CELLULAR PHONE Description: Samsung cell phone, model no.: SM-G360T1, IMEI: 354335073153043 Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/24/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Record-'Statufsilnforrn atien. Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Record Origination Operator: 11/24/2015 16:46 Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/08/2015 19:50 Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO - Date Supervisor . Date . Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Narrative begins out he following'page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of2 Description of Evidence: Exhibit 47.1 Samsung cell phone, model no.: SM-G360T1, lMEl: 354335073153043 Processing /Analysis: On November 23, 2015, Specialist Hughes accompanied SA. Olson to the Hennepin County Library parking lot. While there SA. Olson and Specialist Hughes met with a subject to acquire information from his cell phone detailed above as Exhibit 47.1 relevant to the on-going investigation. SA. Olson identified this person to Specialist Hughes as Lavell Bible and indicated Mr. Bible wanted to voluntarily provide three photographs to SA. Olson from his device. Specialist Hughes connected the Exhibit 47.1 cell phone to a CelleBrite Universal Forensic Extraction Device (UFED) Touch. A logical extraction of only picture files was performed on the cell phone using the CelleBrite UFED Touch. The CelleBrite UFED Touch generated a report containing picture files from the cell phone as a result of the extraction. A copy of three picture files relevant to the investigation from the CelleBrite UFED Touch generated report were provided to SA. Olson per his request. All examinations are concluded and no further examination is requested at this time. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/48 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Warning . Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information Description: Officer Anna Hedberg interview Occurrence From: 11/24/2015 13:00 Occurrence To: 11/24/2015 13:18 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBIIMpls I Federal Bureau of Investigation) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 24, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Steve Vitale conducted a recorded interview with Minneapolis Police Officer Anna Hedberg. Items 48.1 (audio CD from interview) and item 48.2 (diagram) acquired by virtue of this report. Address #11 1430-MARYLAND Ave: Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureua of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: Bureua of Criminal Apprenhension Subjects Relationship Name _Bi_o BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - St. Paul (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Joint Analysis Center (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION MN BCA Lab (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Sloan, Diane (Analyst) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION BANCE, Alyssa (Forensic Scientist) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION FLORELL, Josh (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION Rico, Susan (Law Enforcement Official) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION Blissenbach, Mark (Person) White, Male BUSINESS LOCATION Lind, Robert (Person) White, Male EMPLOYER GARFIELD, Lindsey (Crime Scene Tea'm) Female EMPLOYER SEURER, Lisa (Crime Scene Team) White, Female EMPLOYER David, Carolle (Forensic Scientist) Female EMPLOYER Julie, Dornseif (Forensic Scientist) White, Female EMPLOYER Lanoux, Debbie (Forensic Scientist) EMPLOYER GARFIELD, Lindsy (Law Enforcement Official) EMPLOYER LONG, Holly (Law Enforcement Of?cial) EMPLOYER Murray, Joseph (Law Enforcement Official) White, Male . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phiil, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 Of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/48 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Address #1 - Occurred - 1430-MARYLAND AVE. - Continued Subjects - Continued Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Relationship Name BE EMPLOYER Evans, Rachel (Person) White, Female EMPLOYER Jaspersen, Jennifer (Person) White, Female EMPLOYER Lackner, Julie Ann Letourneau (Person) 46 yr. oId, White, Female EMPLOYER LeTourneau-Lackner, Julie (Person) White, Female RELATED GAGNON, STEPHEN LOUIS (Person) 35 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MAAS, VICKY LYNN (Person) 48 yr. old, White, Female Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address BILLING AND INSTALLATION ADDRESS Vehicles Relationship Egg VehicleDescription REGISTERED ADDRESS 776AAD 2009 CHEVROLET - OTHER Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Hedberg, Anna Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Hedberg, Anna Record Type: Analyst Bio: 32 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO LEO ID: 2927 Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Juvenile: Place Of Birth City: Place Of Birth State: Clark, Jamar Oneal Person 24 yr. old, Black, Male 05/03/1991 NO Minneapolis Minnesota .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/48 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160_ Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Stai Country As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota N0 State ID - Minnesota no Property #1 - Audio CD Ofr. Anna Hedberg interview Primary information Property Class: Evidence 4 Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD - Ofr. Anna Hedberg interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/24/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Property #2 - Hand drawn diagram by Ofr. Anna Hedberg Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Correspondence Description: Hand drawn diagram by Ofr. Anna Hedberg Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/24/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Officers Hedberg, Anna (2927 I Officer! Minneapolis Police Department) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide [Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/48 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Re?ord Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/24/201517z43 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/30/2015 18:53 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor - Date OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of 5 On Tuesday, November 24, 2015, at about 1300 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Vitale conducted an audio taped interview with MPD Of?cer Anna Hedberg. The interview was at the request of SA Phill after reviewing Hedberg?s police report (supplemental 37). Speci?cally SA Phill was curious Whether Of?cer Hedberg observed handcuffs at the scene. Of?cer Hedberg requested and was allowed an opportunity to review her narrative report. Of?cer Hedberg reported it took her less than a minute to respond on scene from the 4th precinct. Of?cer Hedberg reported she parked her squad behind other squads that had already arrived and ran directly to the incident location. During the interview Of?cer Hedberg asked whether she could generate a diagram to help explain and provide further context. This diagram was later preserved by SA Olson as item 482. Of?cer Hedberg reported she was standing at the feet of the decedent shortly after arriving and observed he was not handcuffed (see attached transcription for complete details). SA Olson transferred the digital audio data to CD for preservation and safekeeping. This' CD is identi?ed as item 48.1. End report. BIH'eau: quF?MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Anna Hedberg (AH) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (CO) PD FBI Steve Vitale (SV) REVIEWED BY: CO The date ah today's date is 11-24-2015. Ah I?m at the ah BCA interview room with FBI agent Steve Vitale, and with Minnea olis PD Officer Anna, A-N-N-A, Catherine with a C, Hedberg date of birth Badge number 2927 and Anna did I state your name and ah, a birthdate correctly? AH Yes sir. CO Okra); And the address for you at your precinct is 1925 Plymouth Avenue, Minneapolis, rig t. AH Yes sir. CO And that's 55411? AH I believe so yeah. CO Okay. And specifically ah you came a to talk to us today cuz you learned urn that we had a couple questions after reading your supplemental report correct? AH Yes. CO Alright. And um I?m about to get into some of those questions but I?m showing you a report number of, cops (inaudible) what number is that? AH Um 37, supplement #37. CO Okay. That?s your report, you generated that report right? AH Yes sir. CO Okay and what was your squad number that night? AH 431. CO 431, and do you have any idea um how soon you arrived relative to the call? AH I would have to, suggest anywhere between 30 and 45 seconds. CO Okay so you were close? AH Yes sir. CO Where were you coming from? AH Ah the station. CO Okay. AH The precinct. Olson-2015-648?A04 Page 1 of 11 Olson-2015?648-A04 Alright. And this is just two blocks east of the precinct right? Correct. Um, in terms of, how many squads were there when you arrived? There Don't have to be exact. The ah the res the initial squad, the ambulance and So there. 424 was there (inaudible) the ambulance then two others and then myself so I was, right on ?em meaning right behind them. Okay. Third car in. Okay. And you parked in line behind those other two cars? Yes sir. Okay. And so you ah I don?t want to put words in your mouth but the ambulance was there? Yes sir. And was the supervisor there the paramedic supervisor? I don?t recall. Okay. But at some point um you, you came on scene and you approached ah well rather than me guess what you did what did you do nextthe front of the incident location. Okay. Which is um in the front of it to the left it was more of an apartment style complex and then to the right which is what I ran past is more like a townhome setup. So, each indivrdual housing section has doors. You know like entry doors. So we?re on the south side of Plymouth you?re describing Yes. the connected townhomes and then there?s a small gap between a three story apartment or Yeah it?s like a breezeway. Okay. So you could, I guess I?ve never been to the west in that building I guess I wouldn?t have to if um all those townhomes faced to the front or faced to the north. Okay. So there?s a ah larger sidewalk that leads to 1611 Plymouth, that goes to the ah main entrance I guess you could call it. Which is on the east side of the building? Or is that on the front side is it It?s on the north side. Page 2 of11 Olson-2015-648-A04 Okay faces north. Right. Okaythat area? Yes. Um and then what were your observations as you were doing this? I ah when was running up there was quite a few people that have already come out of the, townhome type style apartments or homes. And then a, ah quite a large group gathered in the front of the apartment section. Okay. Wish I could draw a picture. Well here I'll let you draw a picture. Urn and then at any point did you see the officers, did you see the decedent ah Mr. Clark? I did. Okay. And can you describe what you saw when you saw him? He was lying ah face up Okay His head was pointed towards the northeast at a diagonal towards the southwest. He was just to the north of the public sidewalk. Okay. If remember his feet, they were kind of on the public sidewalk. Do you remember what he was wearing? Anything about his clothing description? I just rememberjeans. Okay. Alright and do you remember specifically where his hands were? Urn they were down on his side. Okay so he was on his back and um he was laying with his arms at his side and did you, were you able to observe whether he had handcuffs on one or either wrist? He did not have handcuffs on either wrist. Okay. So in terms of distance when, how close were you in terms of distance when you made that observation? was standing by his feet. So you were on top of him essentially right? Correct. Okay. So you can say that you?re one hundred percent certain that there was no handcuffs on him? A hundred percent certain. Perfect. And who were the other officers um that were standing in close proximity as you were standing there at that moment? I only remember seeing Officer Schwarze. Page 3 of ?11 Olson-2015-648?A04 Okay. Alright. And do you remember at that juncture ah were weapons holstered? Were they un-holstered? Was there a mix? Schwarze?s was out. Okay. It was un-holstered. Okay. And ah describe the environment as you?re standing at his feet you, you started to already in terms of what was happening um, Ah it just ah seemed like pure chaos. Okay. When we, when first got there. Um I momentarily thought about rendering aid to Mr. Clark. Okay. But I looked to my right which would be to the south and there was just so many people that were screaming so many hateful things I, my first ah um thing that I knew I should do is more of a protect myself and my partners. Okay. Um So is it an accurate statement to say you were afraid? Yes. Okay. Alright um The, the thing is the history of this Um-hm. such that I wouldn?t want to go to a call there by myself. Eh even if the shooting never happened. You're talking about 1611? Correct. Okay. Um this whole bank of apartments along this corridor on Plymouth since I?ve been up there for nine years it?s always been, a pretty hard area to go to calls at so um me knowing that was being more hypervigilant for sure. Okay. So I like your idea about the diagram. With ah what I?m interested in is the position of your squad and maybe the decedent relative to the sidewalk and, and the housing. It doesn?t have to be to scale obviously, right so Do you have a ruler? No l?m just, I?m kidding (inaudible) can be the straight edge Sorry. Um just to give me a better feel for and do you remember if you were running squad video to the call? I mean that comes on automatically right? It does. Page4of1?l Olson-2015-648-AO4 (inaudible) Ah I did shut it off when I arrived. Okay. Alright. And as you?re drawing this, ah this is Agent Vitale speaking um what was the, the lighting like in the area when Street lights were on. Um, there were they're like the yellow street lights so it?s kind of a dimmer lit area. Ah there was a lot of not like a ton but there is some tree cover. Okay. You know that would block some of that. So you were able to, clearly see hand, his ah Clark?s hands at his side? Yes sir. l?m, I'm not gonna draw the back of the building cuz I can?t No that's (inaudible) what it looks like. Not necessary just throw a north arrow in there Oh, sure give us a little perspective Of course why don?t I make north up that?s a, a No problem. (inaudible) fun of that so, north up but north is down. Um, so these are more like townhomes. Yeah. Over here. Um?hm. And apartments. And this is like a, enclosed breezeway maybe. And there?s some stairs um it?s a side by side door and there is a um like a patio. Um?hm I can?t really say patio there's like a, a brick wall that kind of Enclosure? Yeah Some kind of But, but um it?s open Yeah Like a porch. I understand. And then ah so then this would (inaudible) (inaudible) Page 5 of11 CO Okay. And so if you, where did you, where did you ah car your squad end up getting parked? AH Initially it was right here. CO Okay. When you first arrived on scene. AH Yes CO And then where is ah the paramedic rig AH Paramedic, I?ll put a there CO And Ringgenberg?s ah rig is right there? AH (inaudible) I believe ah you know I, CO (inaudible) if you don?t know, you don?t know. AH I don?t, I don?t CO Okay AH CO So you were number 3 you think in a line AH I was right here. CO Okay. SV And your car is facing, that?s a one way street correct? CO No AH No it?s not it?s a two way CO a two way street. AH This CO So you?re facing east? AH East. SV Okay. CO 80 um and then you got out AH Cuz the precinct?s over here sir. SV Okay. CO You and ah, (inaudible) squad able AH Yes sir. CO Okay so you ah Went up by foot this direction? AH Right up here. CO Okay and the decedent is laying AH Like ah roughly right, right here. CO Okay. Alright. AH Cuz there?s, there?s grass right here CO Okay. AH Olson-201 Page 6 of 11 that?s put an 30 it's to scale but um it was kinda like this with a, more like that. alright. Ah with his lower ah torso or legs maybe on the sidewalk? Right. i think um if I remember correctly just like his ah left foot. Okay, alright. Leg. And the crowd you ah started articulating I know there was a crowd on this side. Right so the Elks Club is right over here. Um?hm. Whom they also do not appreciate police. So we knew, I knew how about that, I knew that we had a big hostile crowd here being that it was Saturday night. And this place they have parking lots on either side of the building and this place was, was packed. And, I?ve been to a couple calls there. Okay. And it?s, you don?t ever go in by yourself. Okay. Um so we had a large group of people already out here. We had people coming out of their townhomes. We had people up here in the ah vestibule I guess would be a, or the porch area. We had people over here off of the end of the apartment. Um so we I mean we were on all sides just kinda covered by people. So ah, what period of time did you stand over the decedent ah Mr. Clark um before you went and you helped with crowd control? Was it just a second? Were you there for thirty seconds? Was it a minute? Ah it was thirty seconds when I ran up. Okay. I saw Officer Schwarze just to the east. He was watching the crowd behind or to the south of us. - Okay. Ah I ah glanced over momentarily and then I was like ah there?s a ton of people over here, by the apartments and townhomes. So you self assigned yourself to go over there? I self assigned myself right here in the front. Okay. Alright. And then um I stood there. And I waited for the paramedics to come. Okay. And during the time that the paramedics arrived ah did, was that a load and go or did they work on him for a while at the scene or what was that like? Well in the midst of me standing here we have you know the, a bunch of squads from all over the city show up. And this crowd is getting bigger. And the body?s still laying there. And so ah myself and um I think I, I asked like hey what do you guys think if I move my squad Page 7 of 11 Olson-2015-648?A04 right here to try to block the view from these people you know of this guy laying out here. Um, Here, here for the tapes purpose is the for the Oh Yeah sorry where? Ah I parked my squad right on the main sidewalk entrance into the building. Okay. As to create a barrier between the people that were coming out of the apartment building and ah Mr. Clark?s body. Okay. Okay. Um (inaudible) So, I don?t know the exact amount of time between me arriving, moving my squad and the paramedics showing up. But I do remember seeing them cuz I was my head was on a swivel but I do remember seeing ah the paramedics arrive and they pulled out the ah cloth gurney. Um-hm. To get him up quick, and put him on and they were gone. So they weren?t rendering first aid for ah a long period of time it was more of a load and go? It was more of a load and go. Okay. And do you remember the first ambulance leaving with the, the victim of an assault or don't you have any recollection of that? I don?t, I don?t May be gone before that you got there. No there was a, there was an ambulance there. Okay, alright. And, you know amidst all the chaos I couldn?t tell you if it was the first one or the second one. Okay. that came and gone Okay But um I do know at one point an ambulance left. Okay. And I remember seeing fire arrive on scene. 80, Okay. Paramedics arrived, I mean when I got there, there was (pause) now I?m, cuz there was that ambulance Right . . . rig. Page 8 of 11 Olson-2015-648-A04 Yeah. So now l'm like walking through it in my head looking at the picture you know in my head l?m just wondering, if what I saw wasn?t the ambulance supervisor cuz that truck never moved, until later. Okay. Now ah, well the squad video will show but do you remember what way that was facing? Was that parked? That was facing west. Okay. That the north side (inaudible) it side of the road? You know I apologize either it was the paramedic rig itself or the supervisor rig. Okay, alright. So eh at any rate it was a, some type of ambulatory service. So at any point did you see ah handcuffs ah either at the scene, on the decedent or um did, did handcuffs play into this crime scene at allhandcuffs. You did not? I did. Oh okay where were those? They were ah right next to the body on the ground. Okay. So, Alright Maybe, In the grass or on the pavement or In the grass Okay, alright. Alright. And did you make note of that as the first time you saw ?em or later after he had been picked up and, and transported? When did you first note those handcuffs? Was that something you saw right away? Ah not right away. Okay But when was um you know doing the constant surveillance of the, of the Okay the, and the crowd and I glanced back and I saw the handcuffs. Okay. Alright So if you?re ah, which hand would you say on the Mr Clark?s they were closest to? Page 9 of?l?l Olson?2015?648?A04 The right side. Okay. Were you able to tell if the clasp of the cuffs They were open or closed? They were open. Both sides? Both sides. Alright I don?t have anything more. Do you? Ah do you have anything that might be beneficial for us to know or do you think we?ve covered it? Um, I, I guess there was a squad car not, not a guess know that there was a squad car key next to the handcuffs. Okay. Um, Like right next to ?em or a foot or two or Hm like a couple inches I guess. Okay (inaudible) didn?t take out a tape measure but No I know but really, (inaudible) I, I didn?t mean to be sarcastic there No No like i, l, I mean just a, in they were in close proximity to the handcuffs. Were there any discussions among officers about handcuffs or was this just a non-issue the rest of the shift? Ah, No we didn?t, we didn?t have any side conversations (inaudible) really I mean once I, once the ah scene, we put up crime scene tape Um?hm It was more (inaudible) We weren?t really talking about, what happened. We were more concerned about all the people that had come out. Um it was more of a concern of how are we gonna actually interview these people. Because, showing up we know there?s a lotta witnesses. Um-hm. Um and they?re very hostile. So our supervisors wanted us to get into these building, into this building and ask if you know anyone saw anything and most of the conversation that was a part of was I don?t know if it?s safe for us to go in there. Um just for the mere fact of whatjust happened and you know the previous, nine years in my experience with this location so Okay well that totally makes sense. Um, Page 10 of?l1 discussion with other officers about handcuffs and that kinda stuff i never had one. CO Did you hear people in the crowd ah yelling things about handcuffs or not at that time? AH Oh they were, they were yelling it right away. CO And (inaudible) AH CO What were they yelling? AH That you F-ing killed him. He was handcuffed. Why?d you have to kill him. CO Okay. AH You know all the, all those things. co So that started immediately? AH Yeah. CO Okay. Alright I have nothing more do you? SV No. 00 Alright. I?m gonna end this statement now. The time is 1318 hours. END OF RECORDING. Olson?2015?648-AO4 Page 11 of 11 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/49 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Of?cer Benjamin Badowich statement Occurrence From: 11/24/2015 13:27 Occurrence To: 11/24/2015 13:36 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBI/Mpls I Federal Bureau of Investigation) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synapsis On November 24, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Steve Vitale conducted a recorded interview with Minneapolis Police Officer Benjamin Badowich. Item 49.1 (audio CD from interview) was obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship 0?5 BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 .- Badowich, Benjamin, Jeffrey Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Badowich, Benjamin Jeffrey Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship [31.6% EIQ EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/49 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Property #1 - Audio CD - Badowich interview Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Audio CD - Badowich interview BCA I HQ 11/24/2015 1 YES Locker Record Status information - Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11/24/201519:01 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/01/2015 13:Dates. . 1- Supervisor '1 . . Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 3 On Tuesday, November 24, 2015, at about 1327 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Vitale interviewed Minneapolis Of?cer Benjamin Badowich. The interview was at the request of SA Phill after reviewing Badowich?s supplemental report (11). Speci?cally SA Phill was inquiring whether Of?cer Badowich observed handcuffs at the scene. Of?cer Badowich indicated he was one of the ?rst arriving units that followed squad 420 from the 4th Pct. when the call for help was aired. Badowich indicated he did not know whether his video was running on his squad (411), or whether he used emergency lights or siren. He indicated the squad video from this event (if it existed) would be associated to 76727. Badowich said he was initially a couple of feet from Clark?s head after arriving on scene. He did not observe any handcuffs on Clark or at the scene. Badowich further reported riding in the ambulance with Clark and he did not observe any handcuffs inside the rig (see attached transcript for complete details). SA Olson transferred the digital audio from this interview to CD. The CD will be identi?ed as item 49.1 and maintained by SA Olson for safekeeping and preservation. End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Benjamin Badowich (BB) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (CO) PD FBI SA Steve Vitale (SV) REVIEWED BY: CO Today's date 24, November 2015. Time is 1327 hours. I?m here with ah Steve Vitale ah FBI, SV It?s CO I was close SV Close enough CO Ah l?m Chris Olson with the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension and we?re seated with Officer Ben Badowich, it?s Benjamin middle name Jeffrey, common spelling. Badowich is date of birth- Ben did I state your name correctly? BB Yes you did. CO And we are currently at the BCA ah interview room right off the comm center. Ah Ben you?re here voluntarily today right? BB Correct. CO Alright and l, somebody explained to you that we read your police report we?re investigating this officer involved shooting in the 4th precinct from November 15th and I, we had a couple follow up questions relative to your report. BB Yes. CO And that?s your understanding on why you?re here? BB Correct. CO And um your squad number that night was what? BB Ah our call sign was squad 411 and I believe our number was 76727. 00 Okay. And a number is relative to the squad video? BB Correct. CO Okay. And, when you heard this call at 0050 hours or thereabouts where were you? BB Ah I was at the precinct station on lunch. CO Okay. And then you immediately ah of course went in route to the call for help is that right? BB Correct. CO And do you remember when you arrived ah who was on scene? BB Urn as we were approaching the area the original or the first ambulance that was on scene was just leaving. Urn we were right behind squad 420. OIson-2015-648?A05 Page 1 of 5 Olson-2015-648?A05 Okay. Um, ah we immediately pulled up behind them in front of ah in the 1600 block of Plymouth Avenue there. Okay so and at some point I might have you draw a diagram ifthat might be helpful but so 420 was parked initially behind the ambulance that left? Yeah the ambulance was leaving as we were, as we were basically turning onto Plymouth from the station from Morgan. Could see the ambulance I saw the ambulance go northbound on I believe it would be Irving there. Okay. So So and that ah you probably didn?t know a whole lot about ah who was in that ambulance at that time. Correct. Okay. And then when you arrived on scene you parked behind 420 and I?m assuming 420 was parked behind a marked squad? Ah i couldn?t tell you for sure. Okay. Do you know where squad 424 was parked? Ah, I knew it was, no I couldn?t tell you for sure where it was. Okay. So in terms of the order the sequence?that ah were you like the 4th or 5th or 6th or do you have no idea how many people were there when you got there? How Um we were since it was so clo, close to the scene and there was ah numerous other officers on scene we were one of the, one of the first units to actually arrive. Okay. Behind, the people that ah were requiring assistance 424. 420 got there first. Yeah. You probably got We, we pulled out of the station parking lot right behind 420. Were you the first one out of force or was there a trail of cops behind you? There, yes. Okay Correct Were you the number No we were the second squad, 420 was the first one out. Okay. Um who was in that squad? Ah I believe Officer Lewis and Officer, Officer Robert Lewis and Mike Nelson Nelson? Okay, alright. Um were you ah running ah video? Ah I do not know. Okay. Alright. That video were you running lights? I. Were you driving? Page 2 of5 Olson-2015?648-A05 was driving. Okay do you remember ifthe lights were on? Um I don't know for sure cuz I knew that it was Right down the road. down the road. Okay so, you have no recollection on whether your video was running? Correct. Okay. And ah what is the first thing you observed when you got there? When I got there I observed that there was a loud, large crowd on the north side of Plymouth Avenue. Um immediately saw Officer Ringgenberg and Officer Schwarze, they were on the south side right on the boulevard. Um standing over um ah Jamar Clark. Um and there was also a ah Deputy Chief with Hennepin County Paramedics that was also on scene. Okay. And where was that ah paramedic standing relative to those two of?cers? I, believe that he was walking back from his um, Suburban or Yeah his suburban, his vehicle with, with medical equipment. Okay. Alright. Um, and how close to Mr. Clark did you get? Ah I would say within a couple feet. Okay. Were you standing near his head? Near his feet? You?re off to one side? His right side? His left side? Ah believe that was, I was standing a right above his head. Okay. And his head was positioned ah (inaudible) describe how he was positioned, whether he was on his front, his back, He, he was, he was laying on his, on his back so face up. Okay. And was his head closer to the paved portion of the roadway or closer to the sidewalk or? i believe that it was right on the, on the boulevard between the on the, on the grass between the sidewalk and, and the boulevard. Okay. With his upper torso being closer to the street? Correct. And lower torso being closer to the sidewalk. Did you see ah any handcuffs at the scene? No i did not. Okay. At any point during this ah this protracted deal did you see any handcuffs at that scene? No I did not. Okay. What were your observations I mean did you look at Mr. Clark the decedent um ah did, you recall what he was wearing? Ah yes he was wearing a ah it was black, he had a blackjacket and then also a ah black hooded sweatshirt. Page 3 of 5 Olson-2015-648-A05 Okay. And then ah, bluejeans. Alright. Do you know Mr. Clark? Have you previously (inaudible) I?ve never, 1, I don?t recall him at all. Okay alright so you?ve never had to your knowledge personally dealt with him? Correct. It?s possible but you have no memory of it. Correct. And ah was there a discussion that took place ah between you and any of the officers at that time or what, what transpired in terms of dialogue? Um I asked Officer Ringgenberg if there was somebody that shot from the crowd. And he said no this was officer involved. Um at that time I immediately turned around um because there was residents coming out of the, the apartment or those townhomes on the south side. They were coming, towards us urn so we needed to push 'em back so that the ah the um Deputy Chief from HCMC could, could work on Mr. Clark in a safe manner. Okay. And as well as and to start setting up a crime scene. Okay. Um, getting back to Mr. Clark you saw him laying there on is back. Um could you see ah did you see notice his hands? Yes. And ah were there any handcuffs on his hands? No there were none. Okay. Alright. Did, could you see his injury? Ah I could see that he that there was um there was bleeding from the his left eye. Okay. Alright looked significant I?m assuming? Yes. Okay. Alright. Um I understand the scene from talking to officers and watching squad vid, video was ah tense to say the least. Correct. Alright. Did you ah, ah once you had that initial conversation um then you went into kinda crowd control mode is that correct? Correct. Alright. And how long did you stay in that ah role or you know how long did you try to keep that crowd back? Or did you return to the scene of the decedent? Yes what happened was is that um as soon as ah Officer Shinklin and were pushing people back more officers were arriving on scene assisting us. And then immediately ran to a squad car ah grabbed crime scene tape and I started putting up crime scene tape along the south end of, of Plymouth Avenue right in front of the apartment complex. Okay. Um and then I turned around, observed that ah um Mr. Clark was being loaded into the ambulance and observed that there was no other Minneapolis police officer with him and per Page 4 of 5 our procedures um when there is a, um somebody who?s been shot we, we ride with them in the ambulance to the hospital. Okay. And who was riding with him? It, it was me. Okay and then who, your partner followed in the squad? Correct. And that was Officer Nicholas Shinklen? Correct. Okay um and at no point during that transport were there any handcuffs inside that rig? Correct. Okay, alright. You have anything else Steve? Um you didn?t, did you have discussions with either of the officers about what had happened? No I did not. Have you had discussions, between today and the day of the event with the officers about what happened With, which officers? Ah the officers that are on admin ah Ah no Okay not spoken with them Okay. Alright ah are there, (coughs) excuse me I think that?s it. Alright ah do you have anything for me before I stop ah the tape here that is important for us to know No investigate this? Alright. (coughing) (inaudible) the statement 1336 hours. END OF RECORDING. Olson?2015-648?A05 Page 5 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/50 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information Description: Acquisition of PD Personnel Files and Sensitive Data Occurrence From: 11i20/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/09/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab 815-14003 On November 20th 2015, SA Phill received the PD Internal Affairs and Personnel Files on Ofcs Schwarze and Ringgenberg. SA Phill scanned the documents as attachements to this report. Evidence items 2015-648I50.1 (2 Squad Videos), 50.2 (Dispatch Audio), and 50.3 (Squad Video). Address #1 - RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE, Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name 1319 DOB Address #2 - 350 5TH ST Primary Information Address: 350 5TH ST, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Subjects Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION LOONSFOOT, Larry (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION PETERSON, Luke (Law Enforcement Of?cial) BUSINESS LOCATION PORRAS, Francisco (Law Enforcement Official) 0 I I BUSINESS LOCATION SAND, Brian (Law Enforcement Official) Male BUSINESS LOCATION SCHANY, Joe (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION Schmidt, Kristina (Law Enforcement Official) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION SEIDL, Jeff (Law Enforcement OfficialMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/50 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Address #2 - RELATED #2 - 350 5TH Continued Relationship EMPLOYER RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED RELATED Relationship INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS Subjects - Continued BUSINESS LOCATION Name ZIMMERMAN, Richard (Law Enforcement Official) HOLTHUSEN, John (Analyst) MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB UNIT (BUSINESS) MINNEAPOLIS POLICE DEPT BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) BASS, DENNIS NMN (Person) BROWN, FERNANDO NMN (Person) COOPER, RUDOLPH GORDON (Person) COX, JOSHUA JOSEPH (Person) DODGE, CHARLES (Person) FOSTER, ORVILLE REDALE (Person) KOBERSTEIN, DAVID BRUCE (Person) MAXEY, SCOTT DOUGLAS (Person) MILLER, REGINALD ANTHONY (Person) Rowen, P. MNU (Person) WILLIAMS, HAKIM JAMAL (Person) Telephones E-Addresses Number/E-Address Big Male Male 38yn 50yn 48yn 34yn 63yn 51yn 45yn 51yn 55yn 42 yr. old, Black, Male old, White, Male old, Black, Male old, White, Male old old, Black, Male old, White, Male old, White, Male old, Black, Male old, Black, Male ?1 Subject #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark'opygias Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Rank/Position: Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: .- YES Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Law Enforcement Official 30 yr. old, White, Male .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/50 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenlbergr, Mark Douglas 4 Continued Primary Information Continued Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 119 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #2 SUBJECT #2 SChwarz?e, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO I Subjects I Relationship Name ?g LE EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT Clark, Jam-ar- Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number State CountEy As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/50 Report Date: 11/20/2015 subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar Onea?l Continued Identifications - Continued ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Comment Property #1 DVD containingMP'o SquadVideofrom March 24,2015 Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE DVD Containing MPD Squad Video from March 24, 2015 BCAI HQ 12l22/2015 2 2015-64850.1 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - CD Containing MPD Dispatch Audio from March 11, 2015 Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing MPD Dispatch Audio from March 11, 2015 BCAI HQ 12122/2015 1 2015-648l50.2 NO YES SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #3 DVD Containing MPD Squad Video from March 11, 2015 Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE DVD Containing MPD Squad Video from March 11, 2015 BCAI HQ 12/22/2015 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 4 of6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/50 Report Date: 11/20/2015 Property #3 - DVD Containing MPD SquadUVi?d'eo from 2015_-. Continued Primary Information - Continued i Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phili, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/24/201519z32 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/09/2015 09:25 Rehearing. LEQI: I, 7 v. 7 ?7 Date-g -1 Supervisor 4 Date . Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) NarratiVe begins on the following?page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 5 of 6 On Friday, November 20th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received the Minneapolis Police Personnel ?les from Commander Gran er. Also resent were two Internal Affairs ?les from 2015 involving Of?cer Schwarze. SA Olson picked up the ?les and delivered them to SA Phill at the Minnesota ureau of Criminal Apprehension. All ?les were attached to this report and 3 items of evidence were acquired in ACISS. They were labeled items (2 squad videos), 50.2 (Dispatch Audio), and 50.3 (squad video). Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/51 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Priinary Information . Description: Interview of PD Officer? Occurrence From: 11/24/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/24/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers I Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab 815?14003 Synopsis On November 24th, 2015, SA Phill interviewed Ofc clarify what he saw on Nov 25th after an OIS on Plymouth Av in MPls. Evidence item (CD of interview audio) acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Address #2 - RELATED #1 1611 PLYMOUTH Primary information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name 0 03 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary information Exempt From DisclosureMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 014 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/51 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 gRinggenberg, Mark Douglas - Continued Primary Information - Continued Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects mm Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - SChwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal, I Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black "Hunullunlun . . . - . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/51 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued: . Personal Information - Continued Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks ldentifica tions ID Type Number ?ag Country FBI ID 717111FD1 OID 232941 Minnesota State ID - Minnesota As Of Data NO NO NO Comment Property #1 on COnta_ining audio of Ofc-interview Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing audio of Ofc-nterview Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/29/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Officers LEO ?u?ask Force Officerl Minneapolis Police Department) ReCord Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11/24/2015 20:34 11/30/2015 18:56 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date; Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 [Erratum begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On Tuesday, November 24th 2015, Special Agents (SA) Phill and Homer interviewed Minneapolis Police Department (Mpls PD) Officer (Ofc)- The interview occurred in a meeting room at the St Paul Headquarters of the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (B CA). Of_is a 23 year member of the PD and is presently assigned as a As such, their main focus is to work with the On November 14th thru the 15th, Ofc -Was working an overtime patrol shift as a solo car in the 4th precinct districts. The following is only a summary of the interview. For a full account of what was said, please refer to the attached transcription of the interview. In addition, the entire interview was digitally recorded and preserved for evidence as ACISS item Ofc ?said he responded to the of?cer involved shooting scene at 1600 Plymouth Av after a citywide tone that an of?cer needs help in that area. Ofc -arrived on scene and saw a large crowd of onlookers gathering on the north side of the road. On the south side he saw 2 Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) paramedics working on a black male with a gunshot wound to the head. The male was younger and had long dreads. Ofc -decided to provide security to the paramedics while they worked. Ofc- saw that the male was not handcuffed when the paramedics were working on him. He did not see cuffs on either wrist and he also observed when they loaded him onto the gurney for tranSport, that he was not handcuffed. Ofc- did see a pair of handcuffs in the grass once they loaded the victim up. Ofc- also remembered seeing Of?cer Reimer standing close to the victim also providing scene security. Ofc- escorted the HCMC ambulance from the scene to the hospital because of fears that some of the crowd Would follow it downtown. Ofc-then completed a supplemental report in the PD records system to document his participation on the call. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer? INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael Phill (MP) SA Cody Horner (CH) REVIEWED BY: On Tuesday, November 24th 2015, SAs Phill and Homer interviewed PD Officer? regarding the November 15th in Mpls. MP Alright it?s currently 11:27 AM. Tuesday, November Special Agents Michael Phill and Cody Horner at the Minnesota BCA in St. Paul ah here to interview Minneapolis Officer badge . MP name is spelledumiddle issue date of birth . Address is 3000 Minnehaha Avenue in Minneapolis 55416. Contact number for Officer is Urn do you mind if I refer to you as i or is that - -fine yes. MP okay. how long you been working for ah Minneapolis Twenty-three years. MP And what is your current assignment there? - I am currently assigned to MP Can you describe what that is? MP Okay is this i MP Okay. I want to call your attention to um the night of the 14th it was a Saturday into Sunday the Ah what time did your shift start on this, on Saturday the Ah it started at 8:30 PM. MP Okay. And do you generally work eight hour shift orjust work as far as what cases take you? i was actually working an overtime shift. MP Okay. Phill?2015?648?A1 1 Page 1 of 4 'they post a shifts throughout the city when people a call in sick, comp out, I picked this shift up and it was actually my first patrol shift in like four years Okay so you're a uniform patrol overtime? Yes. Okay. Alright so were you riding with somebody else? No was by myself. Alright by yourself. What was your call sign that night? Ah squad 111. Okay. So in the early morning hours of the 15th a call came out about um shots fired is that when you started to respond or did you respond prior to that? I responded once they ah they would a they did a citywide Okay. needs help. (inaudible) That?s when I responded to the scene. Okay. Ah did you have a squad camera running? Yes. Okay. Ah when you arrivedyon scene {can yousdescribe what you saw regarding officers Ringgenberg and Schwarze and the person that was shot? Ah I arrived on scenepulled up right ah kind of in front of the ambulance. Um-hm. Um there was a crowd on the north side of Plymouth Avenue that was becoming larger and larger and was you know yelling a lot and becoming unruly. Um it appeared they had enough cops over there dealing with that. Um-hm Um I looked over on the sidewalk on like the south side of Plymouth Avenue. Um I saw paramedics attending to somebody over there. Okay. Um there was one other Minneapolis officer over there, Jason Reimer. Um so I went over there and kinda just stood by and kinda provided them with a little security while they attended the, to the victim. Okay. So ah how many people were working on actually working on the vic, the victim then? Ah I rememberjust two HCMC paramedics. Okay so two paramedics. Um do you remember what that man looked like? His clothing? Um, I don?t remember the clothing. I remember black male, younger and had ah long dreads or braids. Um-hm. Did you see his gunshot wound at all? Yes. Where did it look like it was? Page 2 of 4 MP MP MP - Jul 13 PhilI-2015?648?A1 1 It looked like it was shot urn almost like exit wound out the left side of his ah eye. Okay. Ah and while they were working on him did you see him then loaded onto a gurney, eventually? Yes ah one ofthe HCMC paramedics _um stated let?s load this guy up and get him outta here. I think because of the crowd becoming ah more unruly. Um?hm. Um they picked him up put him on the stretcher um once they did that I saw a pair of ah black handcuffs laying in the grass. Um?hm. Um at that point the paramedics asked me to escort them out of the area. Um once the victim was loaded in the ambulance, the ambulance left. i followed ?em out and they stopped about two blocks away to continue to ah work on the victim. Okay. Um at any time did you see any officers handcuff the man, the victim, gunshot victim? No. And when you arrived did you see handcuffs on either one of his wrists? No. Okay. So, you saw cuffs on the ground. You didn?t see cuffs on him even when they got him on the gurney into the ambulance no cuffs were applied as far as you saw? Correct. And then you said you escorted the ambulance kind of a few blocks out of the area? Yes. But you did not accompany all the way to the hospital correct? I did. Oh you did, okay. Yes. 80 you followed all the way to the hospital? Yes. Um do you know if there were any officers in the ambulance? One officer in the ambulance. You know who that was? i don?t. Okay. And you mentioned Officer Yes. a present standing there close to the body? Yes. Was he also providing scene security or helping give aid? Scene security. Okay. Do you know Reimer? is he a, precinct patrol or? Page 3 of 4 Yeah we?re good friends we came on together. Okay. Um no he works ah downtown 1st precinct. Um he was working an off duty job at the time and same as me responded to the help call. Okay. What is his first name? Jason. I: .0 MP (inaudible), is there anything else you can think of about that scene that we oughta know about? Not that I can think of at this time. MP Okay. It is presently 11:34 and we are stopping tape. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648?A1 1 Page 4 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/52 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Warning . Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: Acquisition of 911 Call and Dispatch Audio and Transcript 11/23/2015 00:00 11/23/2015 00:00 Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 02/26/2016 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers - Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab 815-14003 Synopsis On November 23rd 2015, SA Phill obtained the dispatch audio and CAD notes from Hennepin County and Minneapolis regarding the Police and Ambulance responses to the November 15th shooting. Evidence item (CD) acquired with this report. Addressm - 1611 PLYMOUTH Ave-N Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Big - SUBJECT #1 Ringgenbje?rg; Marka'ouglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Rank/Position: Juvenile: Subjects Relationship EMPLOYER YES Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Law Enforcement Official 30 yr. old, White, Male Officer NO Name Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/52 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name Big EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT Clark, Jamar oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Country Em gm FBI lD 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Property #1 - CD Containing HCMC Dispatch Audio and Transcript Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/52 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Preperty' #1 -.- co: containing?emc Dispatch Radio, and Transcript -, Continued Primary Information - Continued Description: CD Containing HCMC Dispatch Audio and Transcript Property Status: BCA HQ Status Date: 11/23/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information .. . . - Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/24/2015 21:13 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 02/26/2016 10:23 Reporting LEO 17 1 Date - Supervisor '7 - a Date Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On Monday, November 23rd 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received a secure email from the city of Minneapolis Emergency Communications Administration. The email provided copies of 4 dispatch ?les and an Excel spreadsheet with CAD data from the November 15th Minneapolis Police of?cer involved shooting at 1611 Plymouth Avenue N. SA Phill burned the 4 audio ?les and one document to a CD and labeled it as evidence item in ACISS. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/53 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Warning . Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Ofr. Gabriel Grout - statement Occurrence From: 14:10 Occurrence To: 11/24/2015 14:21 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Vitale, Stephen (Special Agent/FBI/Mpls Federal Bureau of Investigation) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On November 24, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Steve Vitale conducted a recorded interview with Minneapolis Officer Gabriel Grout. Item 53.1 (audio CD - interview) acquired by virtue of this report. Address #1 Occurred #1 -'1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information I Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureua of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: Bureua of Criminal Apprenhension Subjects Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - St. Paul (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Joint Analysis Center (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION MN BCA Lab (Agency) BUSINESS LOCATION Sloan, Diane (Analyst) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION BANCE, Alyssa (Forensic Scientist) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION FLORELL, Josh (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION Rico, Susan (Law Enforcement Official) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION Blissenbach, Mark (Person) White, Male BUSINESS LOCATION Lind, Robert (Person) White, Male EMPLOYER GARFIELD, Lindsey (Crime Scene Team) Female EMPLOYER SEURER, Lisa (Crime Scene Team) White, Female EMPLOYER David, Carolle (Forensic Scientist) Female EMPLOYER Julie, Dornseif (Forensic Scientist) White, Female EMPLOYER Lanoux, Debbie (Forensic Scientist) EMPLOYER GARFIELD, Lindsy (Law Enforcement Official) EMPLOYER LONG, Holly (Law Enforcement Of?cial) EMPLOYER Murray, Joseph (Law Enforcement Official) White, Male .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 IVIRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 . Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/53 Report Date: 11/24/2015 Address #1 .- Occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND AVE - continued Subjects - Continued Relationship Name B_io EMPLOYER Evans, Rachel (Person) White, Female EMPLOYER Jaspersen, Jennifer (Person) White, Female EMPLOYER Lackner, Julie Ann Letourneau (Person) 46 yr. old, White, Female EMPLOYER LeTourneau-Lackner, Julie (Person) White, Female RELATED GAGNON, STEPHEN LOUIS (Person) 35 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MAAS, VICKY LYNN (Person) 48 yr. old, White, Female Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E?Address BILLING AND (651) 775?0803 INSTALLATION ADDRESS Vehicles Relationship Tag VIN VehicleDescription REGISTERED ADDRESS 776AAD 2009 CHEVROLET - OTHER subject. WITNESS #11- Grout. Gabriel Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Grout, Gabriel Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 13?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Property #21 - Audio CD Ofr. Gabriel-Grout. statement Primary Informa tion Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD - Ofr. Gabriel Grout statement Property Status: BCA 1 HQ Status Date: 11/24/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/53 Report Date: 11/24/2015 'Re?ord-Status Information . ., _7 ,1 - - Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/24/2015 21:13 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/01/2015 13:38 Reporting LEO a Date 7 1 Supervisor . I OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326/ MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Nari?fisi?f bgeiginsfoh the bage- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 3 of 4 On Tuesday, November 24, 2015, at about 1410 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Vitale conducted an audio taped interview with MPD Of?cer Gabriel Grout. The interview was occurring at the request of SA Phill after reviewing Grout?s report (supplemental 44). SA Phill was attempting to determine Whether Of?cer Grout saw handcuffs at the scene. Grout indicated he did not observe Clark in handcuffs upon his arrival, and said he did recall a set of handcuffs at the scene after Clark was transported by EMS. Grout said he was standing very close to Clark and reported he was the ?rst squad to respond after monitoring the of?cer?s called for help. SA Olson transferred the digital audio recording from Grout to CD for safekeeping and storage. This CD is labeled as item 53.1. See attached transcript for complete details. End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Gabriel Grout (GG) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (CO) PD FBI SA Steve Vitale (SV) REVIEWED BY: CO Today?s date is 24, November 2015. We?re at the BCA interview room with FBI Steve Vitale. Did I say that right? SV Yeah CO .. SV L-E CO ah Chris Olson, BCA and ah Benjamin Daniel Grout, date of birth- Did I state your name ah correctly Gabe? GG Ah Gabriel Daniel Grout. CO What did I say? GG You said Benjamin. CO Oh, yeah sorry about that. GG That?s alright. CO Gabriel Daniel ah Grout,?That?s correct right? GG Yes. CO Thank you. And the address at the 4th precinct 1925 Plymouth Avenue, 55411 right? GG Yes. CO Okay. Today?s date, I already did. Time is 1410 hours. Gabe I read through your ah supplemental I understand you were contacted because ah BCA had some questions ah um ah they wanted a little more detail than what was in your supplemental #44 is that right? GG Correct. CO Okay. Um and you came down here on your volition to, to provide more details is that right? GG Yes. CO Okay. And ah specifically what was your squad number that night? Squad number? GG 410. CO 410, do you remember ah where you left from at 0050 hours when the when you got the call for help where you were? GG was at the 4th precinct. Olson?2015-648-A06 Page 1 of 6 Olson-2015-648?A06 Okay. So there was a convoy of squads that basically left the 4th precinct. Were you like, first in line there or were you in the end of the tall or in the middle? Ah I, was the second carthat I saw. You were second car to the scene? Correct. So you?re the first guy to leave 4th precinct probably. Yes. Okay. And so ah the squad that you saw there is squad 424, is that right? Yes. Okay. And do you know who the officers were in 424? Yes. And who were those? Officer Schwarze and Officer Ringgenberg. Okay and when you first pulled up on scene where did you park 410 relative to 424? Ah I pulled ahead of their squad cuz they were standing just to the east of where their squad was parked and I pulled ahead to get closer to where they were at. Okay. Were you running ah red lights and siren or were you running ah just regular ah you were probably getting there quickly I?m assuming but do you Yes you toggled the red lights? I did have my red lights and siren on. Okay so there?s video that? show the trip down there ah did that video stay on? I don?t know if there was video. If the, If the squad was (inaudible) was rolling or not. Okay. Um, Alright. So you guys have those numbers ah Yes associate with the squad video. Do you know what number that would have been or you don?t know? Yes. What number was that? It?s ah 76765. Okay. Alright and then ah you were a ah single or a baker squad ah I was, single that night however when the call came out ah the guy that was working the deskjumped in the passenger seat in my squad. Okay who was that? Page 2 of6 Olson-2015-648?A06 Officer Moua, Roger Moua Moua, Moua Roger? Yes. Alright. And that was squad 410, I?m just making sure, ah okay. Do you know if Moua did a repon? l, I don't know. Okay. So what?s the first thing you observed ah when you got to the scene there? I saw ah Officer Schwarze and Officer Ringgenberg standing kinda up by the sidewalk in front of the townhomes there at 1611 Plymouth. Ah both, both of them had their guns out. Um there was a male down by them in the grass. The crowd that was there when I arrived was already starting to get pretty big. Ah pretty, hostile agitated ah screaming at them screaming at me and other officers that were ar'riving. Okay. Ah, screaming? Obscenities Okay. And the crowd that you first noticed was it on the south or the north side? Was it over on the Elks ah side or was it on the other side where the decedent was? i first noticed more people on the north Okay. the street and then people continued to come out of the building which was on the south side. Okay. Alright coming from both sides north and south? Um how close did you get, do you know the, Mr. Clark the decedent? No. Have you ah to your knowledge have you ever had a previous dealing with him? No. Okay. And, do you remember, how close did you get to him? Did you go right up to the officers and, and talk to those guys? initially I did. Okay. Um I don?t, I should take that back I didn?t speak with the officers but I was right by them. Okay. Um to make sure no one was getting closer and so I was within feet of both of 'em. Okay. In more of a cover capacity? Correct. That was kinda your ah self assigned role? Yes. Okay. Um did you have an occasion to look at this person on the ground, the decedent? Page 3 of 6 Olson-2015-648?A06 Yes. And ah can you just describe for me what you saw? Ah he was lying on his back. I would say it appeared he had a gunshot wound to the top or to his forehead. Okay. Ah maybe right above his eye. Okay. Um, What about clothing? Any, any recollection of that? I don?t have Okay. of what he was wearing. This is a, a black male right? Correct. Okay, eh ah did you see his arms and legs? Or did you take note of his arms or legs? Can you tell me the position that his arms were in relative to his laying on his back? Ah, I don?t Okay. specific about it. You don?t remember if they were folded on his front? Onto his sides? Maybe underneath him? And if you don?t remember that?s fine. Yeah I don?t remember. Okay. Did you have occasion or did you see any handcuffs at this scene ah at that point? At that point, no. Okay. Later on did you ah notice some handcuffs at the scene? Once he was loaded up in the ambulance and the scene was kinda calmed down I did see a pair a handcuffs lying in the grass right where he was. Okay. Um when I arrived. Okay. Do you have any information or knowledge ah indicating whether he was handcuffed ah at any point during that process? No. Okay. And, did you have occasion and I understand that you were probably focusing on the crowd ah did you see anyone rendering first aid to the decedent? I saw, the ah EMS Okay. which they wear the white shirts usually that?s how you can tell the Okay. Page 4 of 6 Olson-2015-648-A06 working on him. And ah do you know that persons name? Ah, look in my report here. Yeah. Mike Tullinger. And that?s the person you later transported to 108? Yes. Okay. And um so he, he obviously ah the first rig had left ah and did you understand ah when you arrived there what was happening? Did you know anything about it? I, I had heard the call come out an assist EMS type call. Okay. wasn?t aware of the circumstances until after the fact. When you arrived was there a paramedic rig on scene? It was pulling off as was arriving. Okay. Yeah. And did ah you probably didn't understand at the time but you probably do now I?m guessing that there was a victim in that rig? Correct. Okay. And um do you have any ah memory ofthe second rig showing up ah or were you othenivise ah busy? Ah I do remember, the only thing I can remember is they um when they loaded him up into the ambulance ah I don?t remember what happened when they arrived I was occupied with something else. Okay. And in your estimation ah to use a, street terms is this a load and go or did they work on him for a while trying to render first aid or don?t you know? I would say load and go. Okay. Alright. Um, and at no point ah at some point you were close enough to the victim ah probably standing, where were you standing ah when you first approached those officers? Were you standing right like next to him within a foot or two? Ah initially right when I got out of my squad was Okay. Close I mean Okay. And there was no dialogue with (inaudible) I don't remember speaking to ?em I think ljust, ah ljust remember looking at both of 'em and seeing the circumstances knowing we had to get this crowd back to you know secure the crime scene. Okay. And was it your impression from looking at them that they were ah, ah had the same concerns as you? Correct. Page 5 of 6 Just based upon what you were observing? And what they were airing Okay. before I arrived. Alright. Urn, think of anything else Steve? No. Did, have you had occasion to ah so normally ah Roger Moua doesn?t ride with you. No. Did you guys ride back together ah (inaudible) back somehow We actually had to bring the That?s right cuz you (inaudible) Squad down to the shop for a biohazard cleanup, unrelated call. Oh okay Um and then so I brought him to the precinct to get another squad and he picked me up at the shop when I dropped that one off Okay After this was all done Alright. Did he see in your estimation the same thing you did or he peeled off and went off in another direction or don?t you have any idea? I really don?t remember Okay. Alright. Ah Gabe so you indicated when you got there you didn?t speak with ah Officers Ringgenberg or Schwarze. How about after the ambulance left and you were at the scene did you talk to them about what happened? No ah they were, while I was still dealing with ah the crime scene and the crowd control they were put into another squad and driven out of the area. Okay. So at any time, since then have you spoken with them about what happened? I ah I?ve spoken to them but not about the incident. Okay. Alright I have nothing further. Gabe is there anything that ah either hasn?t been discussed now or is not in your report that might be important in your estimation relative to this investigation? Or is it accurate to say that ah you looked at the decedent, you don?t have any recollection of any handcuffs? You saw handcuffs later ah as an artifact at the scene but you never saw any handcuffs actually on the decedent at any time is that right? Correct. Alright. Think we?ll end the statement now. The time is 1421 hours. END OF RECORDING. Olson?2015-648?A06 Page 6 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/54 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12I14I2015 Approved By: Digital Forensic Imaging SOGARD, Mike (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) SynOpsis Specialist Sogard imaged the hard drive from Exhibit 7.1. Once the imaging was finished, all original evidence was given to SA Katzovitz. Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: SOGARD, Mike (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/25/2015 09:02 Last Update Operator: Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/14/2015 15:18 Reporting LEO I - Date . supervisOr Date SOGARD, Mike (Digital Forensics I Cheung, Donny (Investigations I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:36 Page 1 of 2 Description of Evidence: Exhibit 7.1 ?Watchbot DVR --Seagate ST2000VX002 2TB hard drive, 5XD684VR Imaging Process: The hard drive from Exhibit 7.1 was connected to the analysis computer via a validated and functioning Tableau T35es write blocker. An image (901) file was created from the hard drive using FTK Imager 3.2. FTK Imager noted multiple sectors that were unable to be imaged and is outlined below. The image was validated by hash values. The following sectors on Exhibit 7.1 could not be read and were replaced with zeros in the image: 238984 through 238990 238992 through 238999 355300480 through -1355300473 All original evidence was given to SA Katzovitz. All examinations are concluded and no further examinations are requested at this time. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/55 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Primary Information Description: Transfer of 17.1, 17.2, 18.1, 18.2, 19.1, 19.2, and 36.1 from SA Homer to SA Phill Reporting LEO: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information . . . HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Record Origination Operator. Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/25/2015 09:19 HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Last Update Operator. Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/01/2015 13:38 Reporting LEO Date A Supervisor Date HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes HORNER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of 2/26/2016 Criminal Apprehension) Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins On? the following page. . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page '1 Of 2 On 11?25?15 exhibits 17.1, 17.2, 18.1, 18.2, 19.1, 19.2, and 36.1 were transferred from SA Homer to SA Phil]. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt HORN ER, Cody (1395 I Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Off 01?) 648? 9 ase Agent Bureau of Criminal Apprehensmn) Item Quantity Description 1 1 CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Kiesha Steele 2 1 Map drawn by Steele (Not to scale) State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT .r I hearby certify that i have received the aWroperty Signature Name th. Charles (13/85 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Address City/State Telephone Date Received 1 1/25/201 5 OwnerlFor Owner HORNER, Cody (1395 Remased By Financial Crimes investigation 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Verified By _7 3?2 chorner 11/25/2015 (10-1/1 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt HORNER. Cody (1395 Financial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Offense Number: 2015?6481185 Case Agent: Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) item Quantity Description 1 1 CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Darrell Gross 2 1 Map drawn by Gross (Not to scale) State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION I nearby certify that I have received the above listed property Signature Date Received 11/25/2015 Name Phill,.Cha les 5/ Meiji Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Owne?For Owner Criminal A ehensson) Address City/State Released By Cdey (1395 Finanmal Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Telephone Verified By 2; chorner 11/25/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt HORNER, Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes investigation Minnesota I t: . . . Offense Number 2015 648/17 Case Agen Bureau of Cnmmal Apprehenswn) item Quantity Description 1 1 CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Joseph Gipson 2 1 Map drawn by Gipson (Not to scale) State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT I hearby certify that I have received the above listed property Mr Signature Date Received 11/25/2015 . . . Name Phill,? Charles - l-Je?icrde/ Minnesota Bureau of Owne?For Owner Criminal Apprehensron) Address City/State Released By (1395?, Finanoial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Telephone Verified By 5 chorner11/25/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 094:0 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Offense Number: 2015-648/36 Case Agent: HORNE-IR. Cody (1395/ Financial Crimes Investigation I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Item Quantity Description 1 ?i CD with audio recorded voluntary statement of Zacariah Pam State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION I nearby certify that I have received the above listed property Signature Date Received 11/25/2015 Name Pltili,_Charles Minnesota Bureau of Owne?For Owner Criminal Apprehensron) Address . HORNER. Cody (1395/ City/State Released By Financial Crimes Investigation Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 7 Telephone Verified By 1 r? chorner11/25/2015 ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015?648/56 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Primary Information - Description: Lab Report Blood on Handcuffs, Begin BPA Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) ,Ree?td Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/25/2015 12:30 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/14/2015 10:22 Reporting-LEO I 7 - Date . 7 Supervisor 1 . - a Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phili, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT or PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 NY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: 793?2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St- Paul Lab No. 815-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Report No. 5 St. Paul, NIN 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 11/25/2015 Laboratory Number: 5-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case umber: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packaomg' Description/Source 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an handcu??s with original packaging item of evidence Results of Laboratory Examination: Presumptive testing indicated the presence of blood on three areas of Item 11 and the samples were collected as Items 11-2, 11-3 and 11-4. DNA examinations will be performed on selected items and Blood Stain Pattern Analysis examinations will be performed on Item 11. If you have not received a report within two months of the date on this report, or if fLuther examination is not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. [gnxan?wm Jason A. Simser, Forensic Scientist 3 Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 5 Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Portions of pertinent evidence items have been removed and are being stored at the BCA laboratory. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/57 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: ?statement Occurrence From: 1112512015 11:52 Occurrence To: 1112512015 12:13 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent! FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1113012015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide [Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis CD of interview) obtained by virtue of this report. -. Item 57.1 (audio On November 25, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kane interviewed and took a taped statement from Address #1 - Occurred_#1 Primary Information Address: United States Description: Townhome Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 -u Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Record Type: Person Bio: 17 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: YES Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address A PHONE Property #1 - Audio CD - Primary Information Property Class: Evidence . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/57 Report Date: 11/25/2015 I. Property #1 Audio CD -. Primary Information - Continued Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD -~nterview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/25/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/25/2015 15:00 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/30/2015 19:01 . - ReportingLEO Date a . $upe'wisor . Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) a Narrative begins on the following page} to MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On Wednesday, November 25, 2015, at about 1150 hours, SA Olson and FBI SA Kane went to the home 0-. Olson and Kane learned from SA Phill that ?nay have been a witness to the shooting of Clark. It should be noted that rior to arriving at?residence SA Olson contacte_ mother, ,7 and explained the purpose of the LE Visit. Ms?put SA Olson on hold brie?y before returnin the telephone and telling SA Olson her son did not wish to speak with of?cers. Ms. was okay with SA Olson attempting contact with -at the residence was not home) in a furtherance of this investigation. ?answered the door and allowed Olson and Kane into the residence. Despite what-told his mother he told SA Olson he was agreeable to providing a witness statement detailing his observations from the incident. The taped portion of statement began at 1152 and concluded at 1213 hours. The interview transcript has been attached to this report. SA Olson transferred the digital audio date to CD for safekeeping and storage and identi?ed that as item 57.1. -indicated he was standing about 15 20 feet from Clark and observed the entire event including the events leading up to shooting. -reported he observed an of?cer place one handcuff on Clark?s right wrist, but added that the of?cer was not able to put the other handcuff on. _detai1ed his observations regarding the struggle with the uniformed of?cers while indicating he was unsure where on Clark?s body he was shot and by whom. Olson and Kane cleared from the residence at about 1215 hours. End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: INTERVIEWED BY: SA Chris Olson (CO) FBI Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO This is a taped statement between myself; Chris Olson BCA, Kevin Kane with the uh and date of birth_ we're currently atuwhere no one else is present and this is in regards to BCA case number 2015-648 and the time is 11:52 hours. ?did I s' uh say your name correctly? . Yes you did. CO Okay and uh your home address, I said that correctly? - Yes. CO Alright you, what i didn?t ask you before is do you have a cellphone number? Yes. CO What's that number? . I don?t know I have to go get it. CO Okay we?ll g' we?ll do that towards the end of the interview if that?s alright. Um and your mother is uh (inaudible)? . Yes. (clears throat) CO Uh does she go by the same or different last name? CO - Okay. And there?s no one else present in the house right now? - No. This is a private conversation? CO . Yes. Olson-201 5-648-A08 Page 1 of 19 specifically uh you?re aware of why we?re here to talk to you cuz we explained that to you right? Yes. Um and you were in North Minneapolis in the early morning hours of, of Sunday the November 15?? right? Yes. And in fact you were at uh some kind of celebration or gathering right? Or party or (inaudible) you at a friend?s house? Um?hm. Who?s house were you at? I Keke. Keke? Um?hm. How do you spell Kiki? Um I don?t know how it written in, just Okay. And how ?eh it was Keke?s house but it was right on Plymouth? Uh-huh. Was it one of those townhouses? Apartment. Okay so it was in the square apartment building? Uh-huh. What apartment number, do you know? Um (inaudible) look at that. Does she have uh a window that faces Plymouth or does she have a window that faces Nox or James or? Towards straight in Plymouth. Oh so she?s right on Plymouth? What floor? The first. Olson?2015-648-A08Page 2 of 19 CO first floor? Okay. So there?s uh?who else is at Keke?s that you can recall? . Urn (inaudible) uh Rocky, I don?t know their real names. CO Not, just so I?m clear I guess, little context here, did you use to live in the neighborhood there? . Yes. CO And I . CO how you know everybody? Yeah CO Okay how long have you lived in- -We just moved out here a month ago. CO Oh this is kind of a big deal for you right? . Uh-huh. CO Alright. So it?s good you get back in the ring, hood and hang outwith your friends. Um so Rocky, Keke, who else? Jamar. Jamar? His girl, I don?t know her name thought. Okay. Yeah. Did you meet or know Jamar prior to uh this evening of Sunday mom? ?0 0? 010 Yeah. CO Okay so you know him? Yes. CO Uh and you know him well like you?re a close friend? No I don?t know him well. CO Okay but you?ve met him ma? is more than a dozen times? Yes. Okay. Um and he knows you by name or he would?ve known you by name? 0 Yes. Olson?2015-648?A08Page 3 of '19 CO Okay. And buy you don?t know his girlfriend?s name? No. CO Is she a new girlfriend, an old girlfriend, they been uh together forever? What?s the story there? . Like kinda new, kinda old. You know (inaudible). CO You seen ?em around? . No. CO Oh okay alright. . I only seen her for one time. CO Okay. So uh ?eh I?m just trying a feel for the number of people at the apartment. Uh so start witha number, how many people were there? Cuz l?l don't know if ithave. no idea. Let me think. Uh Kekeen her boyfriend or whatever. Okay. Rocky girlfriend. Rocky plus girlfriend? Uh-huh. Yep. You?re there right? Uh-huh. CO Okay. Are you uh, you got your girlfriend there? I (No audible response) CO Okay. We left or we, we left cuz I took her bowling. CO Took her bowling, your girlfriend? Yes. CO And she didn?t come back? She did. We was at her house when it happened. CO Oh okay. Alright. So do you leave?what time did you leave the house? Olson?2015-648?A08Page 4 of 19 Left the house around like 10:00. Okay. 10:00 Yeah. Okay. Um and where she live? She live oh 1615 Plymouth. Oh she lives right, right next door? Yeah. Alright. Alright. So you left at 10:00 PM out of the apartment building into the townhouse? Um-hm. 1615. what?s her name? .3 What was that? How do spell that? .1 mean, yeah" Okay. Last name? ?sure. Did someone, somebody already talk to her from the police or the (inaudible). She wouldn?t talk. Okay. Alright. And she lives there with her mom though right Herdad. dad? Her dad? Someone talked to him what?s his name? Okay. Alright. Yeah somebody talked to him already. Olson-2015-648-A08Page 5 of 19 don?t know, l?l can?t so many people uh, can?t keep ?em straight but, She wasn?t at the party with us. Okay so you were at the party, you left at 10:00. You andiwent bowling at 10:00 Yes. And then were you home in time uh? Yes we was home at 11:00. Okay. Home at 11:00, then what happened? They told us (inaudible) and they say and the police that he was hitting girlfriend, he didn?t They say he?d never touched her. Okay so the people you know said he never touched her. Yeah. And by those people you mean Rocky, Jamar, KeKe, um the?you?ve spoken to Uh-huh. they say he never touched her? Uh-huh. This girlfriend?s name who escapes us um at the moment. Uh but she?s the who left in the ambulance? Yes. Alright do you know how she was injured? Did they happen to share that with you? He tell I guess Keke and her boyfriend was arguin? Okay. don?t know, and then like he was just tellin? her that?s not of her business to get into and guess she got mad at him and try ta fight him, but he never touched her. He sh? (inaudible), slammed his head into something metal, that why his face was swollen. So Jamar into somein? else? No she did. Oh okay. So she got mad at Jamar? Yeah. Olson?2015-648-A08Page 6 of 19 But not Jamar?s girlfriend? No. Someone else? No Jamar girlfriend did. Okay. Slammed his head into somethin? metal. That?s why his face was swollen. Okay. And he didn?t even hit her back. They said he left. Okay. And that?s when he went outside and we saw him. And that's when he, said they?re started talkin? to us. And what time was that? I don?t remember. I mean it was after you got back from bowling? Uh-huh. Okay so is after 11:00 and you guys were out on the sidewalk there in front of the apartment or? Uh?huh. Okay. in front. And what did he talk to you about? He was just talking ?bout what happened. About how she?s pissed at him? Yeah. Okay. And he was saying that he was, that is none a her business. Yeah. Um Okay do you know who left in an ambulance there? No I don't know her name. Olson?2015?648-A08Page 7 of '19 Okay. Alright. But it wasn?t his girlfriend? It was. I Okay. Alright. For she said, they said she twisted her ankle whatever. Okay. Did he talk about how that happened? No. Okay. And then how long did you talk to Jamar outside? I don?t know, for like 30 minutes. And was?with you during that? No she was upstair? in her room. Okay. Alright. And then after that 30 minutes or probably what 11:30 or midnight, somewhere in there? Uh?huh uh uh paramedics came, that?s when the paramedics came. Okay. Yeah and they got her and I guess and went bring back to the hospital. Okay so what happened? Were you outside or watching that from inside? No was outside watchin? that. Okay. So what happened after the paramedics show this up? Did she, how did she get into the paramedic rig? Did she walk? Did she take a gurney? Did They had a her inside little bed They, so carried her into the ambulance? Uh-huh. Okay. And uh you think it was a uh a gurney or was it like a chair or how of, do you remember what, you must a been pretty close right? It was a gurney I guess you would call. Okay flat? Olson-2015-648-A08Page 8 of?lQ Yeah. Okay so they rolled around on somethin? with wheels? Yeah. Okay. She went into the back of the ambulance and uh what was Jamar doing? And who else besides you and Jamar were sittin? there? Everybody. Everybody? Everybody. what 5, 10, 20, 30? Uh Keke, Rocky, his girlfriend and Jamar, Dee, Okay. Uh and that?s (inaudible). You Yeah. Believe I (inaudible) girl. What was the last name? on it?s, how he?s related to?? Yeah that?s her father. Okay. So uh and then assuming that, that ambulance door is shut?l don?t wanna words in mouth Yeah. Okay she was in there and she was being attended to by medical people? Yeah. He was at the (someone coughing) CO the back window trying to talk to here. Okay But they didn?t let him. did they look the door, did he try to open it or what was goin? on? Olson-2015-648?A08Page 9 of 19 didn?t try to open it. They locked it. Okay. Alright. I guess. And then it, then what happened? They set there for a minute he was just, talkin? to them. He was say they some bitch?s or stuff. They?re, oh he was swearin?? Uh-huh. Was he swearin?? Yeah he would just call ?em, call ?em a bitch. Okay. And that?s when paramedics police pulled up, whatever you wanna call 'em and that white They had a suburban? Yeah. 80 that person pulls up and then what happened? He told ?em to back up and that?s what he did. He backed up on the curve. Okay. And then he started talkin' to ?em. I don?t know what they was talkin? about. Okay. And then that?s when the police came. Okay. And then what happened? Police, as soon as they jumped out they car they put they black gloves. ?Kay. Both of 'em? Yes. Where did they park? Right in front of the white truck? Okay. So it was an ambulance, a white truck and then that first responding unit? Olson-2015-648?A08Page 10 of 19 Uh-huh. And they got on their black gloves and then describe to me what happened. They grab one arm. Which, which arm? The right or left? Left, the left. Okay and when you they you could you tell the difference between the two officers? No. Okay. So they?re, but were they both in uniform? Uh-huh. Okay and so the left arm and what happened? They put the cuff on this one and put it behind his (inaudible). I don't think they never got the cuff on this one, cuz they slammed him. Okay. Cuff left hand and, and then you said they slammed in? Yeah. Can you describe that? They?ve l, theyjust took him down. Okay. How close were you standing uh when this was going on Like they was on the grass and we was right there on the porch so I could?here?s the grass and here?s the porch. Up to, so the porch of 1615? Uh?huh. Okay. So in terms of feet, try ta shuffling) maybe even, so it can that wall to this wall or further? From like the table to the wall. Okay so what you?re describing is probably about 20 feet. (inaudible) For the benefit of the tape. Olson-2015-648-A08Page 11 of 19 .oIoI it?s probably like the begin of the couch to this walk most like Okay so Yeah. to 20 feet? There?s the grass growin? over the sidewalk and then the grass that he died on. Okay. So yeah. And uh and when you say ?eh you saw that the gloves come on, you saw a handcuff come out, you saw the you thought the left arm um was had one handcuff on? Uh-huh. Okay. And can say definitively where may (inaudible) may had on to the wrist or was it just an attempt or don?t you, can you Yeah. I believe they, they cuffed him on that one. Okay. They cuffed him on the left. Okay. They didn?t cuff him on the right i don?t think so. And then he went to the ground and Yes. hear anything? Was there any uh discussions goin? on He was just sayin? fuck them, fuck them, fuck it. And he was sayin? it to the officers or to (inaudible)? To the officers. Okay. Um and he wasn?t saying fuck them though because that would?ve been No he was sayin? fuck you all. Okay. And that was kind of re? uh repeated? Um?hm. Olson-2015-648?A08Page 12 of 19 IoloWhat were they sayin? to him? i didn?t hear what they was sayin? to him. Okay. Alright. Was he sayin? it in a conversation to ?em? Was he yelling it? He was yelling it. Okay. Um what were other people that were watching saying if anything? Well the Elks was just letting out, so everybody that was in there saw it. Okay. He was, they everybody was just yellin? he?s not resistin' and why is ya fightin? with him? Okay. And Did they start yelling that uh before uh the gun shot? Yes before. Okay and uh so we got out of order here. So they slam him to the ground and then what happened? Well before they slammed him to the ground everybody was already outside the Elks and stuff was outside. Okay. And they was just like they was like he?s not resistin? what is ya all doin? And some people i believe start recordin? cuz i saw the light on they phone. Um-hm. So yeah. From the north side of Plymouth on the, the Elk side? Yes. How ?bout from your side? On my side nobody was recordin?. Okay. And uh then to keep describing to me ?eh as well as you can um, after they brought him to the ground what happened? They were just fightin' him. I think they was trying to get that right arm. Olson-2015-B48?A08Page 13 of 19 .0 30 .0.o.o.olo CO 0 . Okay. So I don?t know. And uh so both officers appeared to be fighting with him, is that right? Yes. And you couldn?t hear any verbal commands um being uh spoken by the officers? No. Alright um but you could clearly hear during this, you could clearly hear Jamar right? Yes he was Okay. fuck ya all. Alright. And that was the same thing repeatedly? Uh?huh. Or did he uh utter anything else uh? Repeatedly fuck ya all. Alright. And at some point you?re, are you Iivided watchin? this or you watchin? across the street at the Elks? Where, where are your eyes? I?m right there on the porch watchin? it. They right in front of me. Okay so and I?m asking you, you notice some things across the street, but were you was, were your prominent attention uh directed at the Yeah. across the street? At the fight, but man that's not really a fight cuz he wasn?t resistin?. Okay. Didn?t appear as, as well you, is he resistin?? No he wasn?t. Okay. Then how are the police officers positioned during the fight? One had the knee on his back and one had if of the arm. And, and your describin? for the purpose of this tape you, you describin? like a head lock type uh, uh ya know you, you used your right arm ta. Olson-2015-648?A08Page 14 of 19 . 0 . 0.0.0.0.0 '0.0 . One wasn?t uh on like a head look but like, he had one arm behind his back and he had the, he had the right arm. Okay so one officer had ta? uh control of the right arm of Jamar? Uh-huh. And the other officer had the left arm? Uh?huh. Is that accurate? Uh-huh. Um and then was there, were they, were both officers on their knees or uh, I don?t wanna put words in your mouth, but how are they positioned? Were they on the ground? Were they laying flat? Were they standing? Well Jamar is laying flat, the one officer had his knee on his back, had his right arm like this was trying to get it cuffed. Okay. I don?t know. And where was the other officer? The oth? other officer was like next to Jamar. I believe he was sit on his but little leave, had his left arm. And was that officer kneeling, uh laying or standing? Think he was laying little bit. He was laying (inaudible). So both Jamar and one officer are laying down? Not like if all way laying down. Not sleeping laying but Sliding like he?s slanted yeah. Okay. So they appear to be horizontal to the surface of the, of you know the grass there right? And the other one is not horizontal, he?s got a knee in the back? Uh-huh. Olson-2015-648?A08Page 15 of 19 0 Upper back or lower back? Or butt or head or how low was that knee? Upper back. Upper back, okay. And did you ever ?eh did they succeed in handcuffing him? No. Okay what happened. I don?t think they did. The shot him before they could. Okay. And do you know which part of the body he got shot in? Where he got hit? Hm I wasn?t that close. Okay. So They sayin' the head. Okay you, you based that on what you heard, not on what you saw? Um-hm. Okay. And, and, and he was on his Um-hm. whole time? Uh-huh. Alright best you can remember he was on his stomach? Uh-huh. They never uh turn him on his back? No. Okay. They (inaudible) on his back when he got shot. 80 like he was on his back when he got shot Okay. So when the gun went off he was on his back? Yeah. During the struggle he was on his stomach? Uh?huh. Okay so tell me about that. How did he go from his back to his stomach? Olson-2015-648?A08Page 16 of 19 Olson?2015?648-A08Page 17 of 19 I don?t know. Okay. He's, hejust hanked up. Okay. Alright. Um (pause), so this is um, first of all l'm, I?m grateful that you?re talkin? ta me. I understand that you didn?t want to. Right. But I, and l, I know, ljust want you to be aware of this uh so ?eh agent came here with the FBI is been uh requested to assist that Federal Agency uh to come in and, and to make sure that every is crossed and every i is dotted and, but part of the thing for all the people we're talkin?, part of the, one of the elements or components that that brings to the table is that if someone were ta give a statement other than a truthful statement um, that there?s some criminal liability there and I don?t wanna see anyone get jammed up um by, by making false statements and uh and I?m just telling you that uh because i think you have the right to know that and I don?t want you to be surprised and ljust wanna make uh, I just I want to get assurance from you that I?m getting the truth both for my investigation uh and but as importantly for your, your sake. Okay? I don?t need a?how old are you, 17? I don?t need a 17 year old kid getting jammed up in somethin? uh that, that not necessary. is there anything uh has, is everything you?re telling me today truthful? Um-hm. Okay. Is there um anything that I haven't asked you specifically that uh is important for us to know f? uh as investigators? Can you show us, me why, uh why is it reluctance uh not only with you but for others ta come and talk to the police? Cuz we don?t talk to the police. Okay. And that's because of a trust issue? Mean we just don?t like them. Alright. Okay. All police orjust Minneapolis? All. Alright. Uh, Agent Kane are we missing anything on the details of this? No. Anybody know that you?re talking to us today? Nope. Your mom know you?re talking to us today? My mom and my girlfriend. KK KK CO CO Oh okay. Just those two? Um-hm. Nobody else? Anybody ask you to say anything to us specifically? So nobody coached you in anyway ?bout to tell us? Okay. Um say before i forget would you wanna grab that cell phone for me? Um?hm. Thanks. (pause, footsteps, sound of paper shuffling) CO You got two of ?em? Okay. And then uh, so if someone?s approached -and she?s said she didn?t wanna talk to the police? As far as you know? She wasn?t there. Okay. Alright. But did anyone approach her to talk to about the events that let up to the night? She wasn?t there. Okay. She was home in her Um?hm. but not outside right? Ummhm. Okay. As far as you know did see any of this? Um?um. (negative) Okay. Um I have one last question today I-l forgot to ask this. Was Jamar uh in your estimation under the influence of any drugs or alcohol? Olson-2015-648?A08Page 18 of 19 0.0. 7: I don?t know. Okay. Nothing obvious that you could see? He wasn't uh stumbling, slurring his speech? He wasn?t acting, was he acting in a manner that was consistent with how you know him to be all the time? Other than the anger, he probably wasn?t always that angry right? No. But the, in the, before he got angry was his, was his behavior consistent with how you know him? Um no. He had lotta, like I said, don?t know what happened at the party. I don?t it they was drinkin?. Okay. Cuz you I went bowling. go bowling. Yeah. Alright. Alright I uh again thank you for uh talking. (inaudible) to give you a card? No. Okay. Alright. I want you to reach out to me if you should run into additional people that saw anything and encourage them to be cooperative. I mean you may be tell ?em that I?m not a monster. Uh but you know, you uh, you understand what we?re trying to do don?t ya? Uh-huh. Okay. And we understand we need help right? Uh?huh. Okay. And uh, alright anything else? No sir. We?re gonna end this statement now. It?s uh 12:13 hours. Olson-2015-648-A08Page 19 of 19 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/58 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Primary information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Lab Report Trace Examination of Clark's Nails Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 11/25/201515:50 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/201510:25 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385! MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: (651) 793?2901 AN ASCLD/LAB?Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phil] REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Trace 12/10/2015 Laboratory Number: 815-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Trace Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Report No. AFETY 9 Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jef?ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item 22 22A 22A-1 22B 22B-1 22C 22C-1 22D 22D-1 22E 24 24A 24A-1 24B 24B-1 Page 1 of 2 Type and Packagjgg One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as fingernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngemail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings Description/Source right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?'om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark Agency Item #6 single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from fmgernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail 24C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings 24D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings 24D-1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings 24E One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings 24E-1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings Results of Laboratory Examination: Laboratory No. S15-14003 Report No. 9 single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (le? hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail The Item 22 and Item 24 ?ngernails were sub?itemized and examined under a stereomicroscope. Trace evidence was removed, ?irther sub?itemized and evaluated under a Polarizing Light Microscope. The trace evidence removed was categorized as follows: 27 Blue cotton ?bers 12 Grey cotton ?bers 12 Red cotton ?bers 9 Blue ?bers 7 Black cotton ?bers 2 human hair fragments that are not suitable for Nuclear DNA analysis 1 orange cotton ?ber 1 animal hair fragment Unknown silver material (largest piece was approximately 150 um long) Unknown black material (largest piece was approximately 250 um long) It should be noted that most of the above ?bers were very small fragments 1mm in length). It also should be noted that blue cotton ?bers are ubiquitous and may have limited forensic value. Additional ?ber fragments were found but were either damaged and/or too small to characterize. Additional trace examinations will be completed on the unknown black material. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. Susan T. Gross Forensic Science Supervisor Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Distribution: BCA St. Paul 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/59 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Primary Information - A a . 1 Description: Lab Report DNA Results: EMT Van, Duty Belt, Handcuffs Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/25/2015 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/25/2015 15:53 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/25/2015 15:57 Reporting LEO I .. Date . Supervisor I . Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: 793?290] AN ASCLD/LAB?Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 6 REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 11/25/2015 Laboratory Number: 1 5- 14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: 1m Type and Packag'pg Description/Source 3 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a ?nm EMT truck swabbing from Item 3A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from rear drivers side door handle - EMT truck swabbing from Item 3B One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from rear passengers side door handle - from swabbing ?om Item EMT truck BC One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from side door on passengers side - from EMT swabbing from Item truck 3D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a from front passenger side door handle - from swabbing from Item EMT truck 9 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Duty Belt ?om Mark Douglas Ringgenberg an item of evidence 9-1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a holster swabbing ?:om Item 9-2 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a mace holder swabbing from Item 9-3 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a front left handcu?? holder with cover swabbing from Item 9-4 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a back left handcu?? holder swabbing ?om Item 9-5 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a right side accessories/belt swabbing from Item 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an handcuffs with original packaging item of evidence 11-1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a inside/outside edges of handcuffs swabbing ?om Item 11-3 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a handcuffs swabbing from Item 14 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a Jamar Oneal Clark left and right hand swabbing ?om Item 14A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a left hand Jamar Oneal Clark Page 1 of 4 swabbing from Item Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 6 14B One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a right hand Jamar Oneal Clark swabbing from Item 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a lmown Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection kit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 bloodstain Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on Items 3A, 3C, 3D, 9-1, 9-2, 9-3, 9-4, 9-5, 11-1, 14A, 14B and on blood previously indicated on Item 11-3. DNA pro?ling was previously performed on Items 15, 16, 17, 18 and 21. The DNA results are as follows: Items 3A and 3C, Rear and side door handles, EMT truck 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made regarding the DNA types obtained Item 3D, Front passenger door handle, EMT truck 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, JefErey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded ?om being contributors Item 9-1, Holster on duty belt - Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded ?om being contributors 0 Mark Douglas Ringgenberg cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 Four of the nine loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 97.3% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 9-2, Mace holder on duty belt - Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population Page 2 of 4 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 6 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded ?om being contributors 0 Mark Douglas Ringgenberg cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 Five of the 11 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 98.1% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 9-3, ?Front left? handcuff holder, with cover, on duty belt - Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors - Mark Douglas Ringgenberg and Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being possible contributors - One of the six loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 71.8% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 9-4, ?Back left? handcuff holder on duty belt 0 Mixture of four or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded ?om being contributors 0 Mark Douglas Ringgenberg and Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded ?om being possible contributors 0 Six of the 13 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 94.9% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 9?5, ?Right? side accessories/belt - No DNA pro?le was obtained Item 11-1, Inside/outside handcuff edges 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made regarding the DNA types obtained Item 11-3, Blood indicated on handcuffs It Single source male DNA pro?le 0 Matches Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, ef?ey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner - Would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population Item 14A, Left hand of Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Page 3 of 4 Laboratory No. 815?14003 Report No. 6 Michael Conner are excluded ?om being contributors - Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor - It is estimated that 99.90% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 14B, Right hand of Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of two or more individuals I Major pro?le consistent with Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being possible contributors to the mixture Insuf?cient DNA was obtained from Item 3B to perform DNA pro?ling. Additional DNA analysis Will be performed on selected items. If you have not received a report within 2 months of the date on this report, or if DNA analysis is not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. 2mm Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist loci tested using includes some or all of the following: D881179, D21811, D78820, D381358, D13S317, D168539, D281338, D19S433, TPOX, D18851, D58818, FGA, and Amelogenin. DisPosition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 4 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015?648/60 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/25/2015 Approved By: Lab Report DNA Results on Handguns Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 11125I2015 15:57 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 11/25/2015 15:59 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO - Date Supervisor 5 Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793?2900 TTY: (651) 282?6555 FAX: (651) 793-290] AN ASCLD/LABJntemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 7 REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 11/25/2015 Laboratory Number: 315-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jef?'ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Itin Type and Packaging Description/Source 5 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a Smith Wesson, magazine with ammunition, ?rearm and one cartridge. 5A a ?rearm Smith Wesson SE a magazine Smith Wesson 9mm magazine 7 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a SIG Sauer, magazine with ammunition, and one ?rearm cartridge. 7A a ?rearm SIG Sauer 9mm Model P226 7B a magazine SIG Sauer P226 9mm 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection kit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 bloodstain 22 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 ?ngernail clippings 23 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #5 known head hair(s) 24 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 ?ngernail clippings Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on samples (SA-1 through 5A-5, 5B-1, 7A-1 through and 7B-1) collected from Items 5A, 5B, 7A and 7B and previously on Items 15, 16, 17, 18 and 21. The DNA results are as follows: Page 1 of5 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 7 Item 5A-1, Grips of Smith Wesson Mixture of ?ve or more individuals 0 Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded from being contributors 0 Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Dustin Timothy Schwarze cannot be excluded from being possible contributors I Seven of the 15 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 85.1% of the general population can be excluded ??om being contributors Item 5A-2, Triggei of Smith Wesson Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Dustin Timothy Schwarze, does not match Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Magazine, slide and safety releases of Smith Wesson Mixture of three or more individuals I Major male DNA pro?le matches e?rey Steven Sworski, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 5A-4, Sides of slide and back of Smith Wesson 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded ?om being contributors Dustin Timothy Schwarze cannot be excluded ?om being a possible contributor 0 Two of the ten loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 83.3% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 5A-5, Muzzle and lens of ?ashlight of Smith Wesson - Mixture of four or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded ?om being contributors to the minor types Page 2 of 5 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 7 Item Bottom of magazine from Smith Wesson Mixture of three or more individuals Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors Dustin Timothy Schwarze and Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded ?om being possible contributors Two of the ten loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 48.2% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 7A-1, Grips of SIG Sauer Mixture of four or more individuals Dustin Timothy Schwarze, efErey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors Mark Douglas Ringgenberg and Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being possible contributors Nine of the 14 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 87.5% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 7A-2, Trigger of SIG Sauer Mixture of two or more individuals Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jef??ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded from being contributors Mark Douglas Ringgenberg cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor Two of the eight loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 59.5% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 7A-3, Back sides of slide of SIG Sauer Mixture of three or more individuals Major male DNA pro?le matches Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among um'elated individuals in the world population Dustin Timothy Schwarze, ef??ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded ?'om being possible contributors to minor types Item Back top and hammer of SIG Sauer Mixture of three or more individuals Major male DNA pro?le matches Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among Page 3 of 5 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 7 unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded ?om being possible contributors to minor types Item 7A-5, Magazine, slide and safety releases of SIG Sauer 0 Single source male DNA pro?le 0 Matches Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, ef?'ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population Item Flashlight of SIG Sauer I Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded from being possible contributors to minor types Item 7B-1, Bottom of magazine from SIG Sauer Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner and Jamar Oneal Clark are excluded from being contributors Mark Douglas Ringgenberg cannot be excluded ?'om being a possible contributor Three of the nine loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 97.4% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Items 22, 23 and 24 were not examined. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. am Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist loci tested using PCR-STR includes some or all of the following: D881179, D2181 1, D78820, D138317, D16SS39, D281338, D19S433, VWA, TPOX, D18351, D53818, FGA, and Amelogenin. Page 4 of 5 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 7 Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - Page 5 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/61 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Interview of PD Officer Reimer Occurrence From: 11/25/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 7 11/25/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 11/30/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference? Numbers Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 MN BCA Lab 815-14003 Synopsis On November 25th 2015, SAs Phill and Vogel (FBI) interviewed PD Ofc Reimer regarding his work on the November 15th OIS at 1611 Plymouth Av in Minneapolis. The interview was burned to disc as ACISS evidence item Address #1 Occurred #1 -'1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects 5mm); Name M. BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Address RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshiig Name i'mo I DOB subject #1 a WITNESS #1 - Reimer, Jason Thomas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Reimer, Jason Thomas MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/61 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Reimer, Jason Thomas - Continued Primary Information - Continued Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 43 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses OTHER 19 4TH ST, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Subjects Relationship Name 9?151 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Subject #2 .- Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas - Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name L13. EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/61 Report Date: 11/25/2015 Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 - Primary Information Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Juvenile: Place Of Birth City: Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date FBI ID 717111FD1 OID 232941 - Minnesota State ID Minnesota Clark, Jamar Oneal Person 24 yr. old, Black, Male 05/03/1991 NO Minneapolis Fictitious NO NO NO mm Property #1300 Containing digitalaudio of Ofc R??i?mer's?lntewi?wt Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing digital audio of Ofc Reimer's Interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/25/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-6481611 UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Officers - LE Reimer, Jason Thomas (Minneapolis Police Department) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/61 Report Date: 11/25/2015 -. Record Status Information . Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/29/2015 14:48 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 11/30/2015 19:06 Reporting LEO 7_ .7 . Bat-?) ?4 Supervisor, -- Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 . Page 4 of 5 On Wednesday, November 25th 2015, Special Agents (SA) Phil] and Vogel (FBI) interviewed Minneapolis Police (Mpls PD) Of?cer (Ofc) Jason Reimer. The interview was conducted at the St Paul Headquarters of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA). The interview was digitally recorded and preserved on disc. The CD was given ACISS evidence item Ofc Reimer had already provided a supplemental report in the PD report system; the interview was to learn ?nther details regarding what Ofc Reimer saw. The following is only a summary of the interview, for a full account of what was said, please review the transcript attached to this report Ofc Reimer is normally a day shift patrol of?cer with over 22 years of experience. On the night of November 14th into the 15th, Ofc Reimer was working an off-duty security job at a business in downtown Minneapolis. He was in uniform and using an old PD marked patrol car. The squad car had the older paint scheme of all white with blue and white lettering on the side. Most PD squad cars are new Ford SUVs with a black and white paint scheme. Ofc Reimer said he heard the call to help an of?cer on a call with shots fired early on the 15th. He activated his emergency equipment and drove north to the scene on Plymouth. Upon arrival, Ofc Reimer heard a scene commander ask for responding of?cers to assist with keeping the gathering crowd of onlookers on the north side of Plymouth away from the scene. Ofc Reimer said he saw some paramedics working on a male on the south side of Plymouth and they looked uncomfortable. He then offered to be their security so they could work. As he was performing scene security, one of the paramedics asked if the gunshot victim had any guns on him. Ofc Reimer said he did not know, so while the male lay on his back, he patted him down and checked his coat for weapons. He did not find any weapons on the male. Ofc Reimer said that the male was not handcuffed when he saw the paramedics working on him, nor was he handcuffed when he searched him. Ofc Reimer said that he observed the paramedics work on the male and then load him onto a gumey and then into an ambulance. He saw another PD of?cer go in the back of the ambulance with the male. Ofc Reimer said that at no time did he see anyone handcuff or uncuff the male. The only handcuffs he saw were laying in the grass. He only saw those once the male was lifted up for transport, they had been under his body. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 25, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Jason Reimer (JR) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael (MP) PD FBI SA Matthew Vogel (SV) REVIEWED BY: On November 25th 2015, SA Phill and FBI SA Vogel interviewed PD Officer Jason Reimer. MP Today is Wednesday, November 2015. Presently 12:56 hours. Special Agent Michael Phill with the Minnesota BCA along with Special Agent Matthew Vogel with the FBI at the BCA Headquarters in St. Paul to interview Minneapolis Police Officer Jason Reimer. Ah first name is middle Thomas, common spelling, last is spelled Date of birth? Address for Jason will be 19 North 4th Street, Minneapolis 55401. Contact number will 12?673-5701. Jason is currently an officer with the Minneapolis PD. That?s the rank right, Officer? Badge number 5929. All that information I read correctyou mind if I refer to you as Jason? JR That?s totally fine. MP Okay. Ah Jason where do you currently work for Minneapolis? JR I work out of the precinct patrol division. MP Is that downtown? JR Yes. MP And what is your work shift normally? JR Ah day watch 0600 to ah 1600. MP How many on? How many off? Do you guys have the flexible work JR Yes. MP want? JR It?s different month. MP That?s a pretty good deal you guys got for contract. JR It?s fair I guess. MP Okay. So um calling, how many years have you been with Minneapolis? JR Ah twenty-two. MP Twenty?two, alright any specialty or can you tell me the assignments you?ve had over the years, throughout the years? JR I?ve been assigned to the 3rd precinct, the 4th precinct, the 1st precinct ah the city gang unit, SWAT team, patrol rifle team and that?s about it. Phill-201 5-648-A12 Page of 7 Alright so calling your attention to ah the night of the Saturday November 14t into the You were working an overtime shift? I was working a part time job. (inaudible) Part time job okay. And as, as such for Minneapolis you check out a marked squad, correct? If, if there?s one available. if one available cuz priority is to patrol. Yes. And then you also were in uniform? Full uniform yes. Okay full uniform and your what was the ah gig for what are the hours for that gig Saturday night? Ah mine was ah 7:00 pm to 3:00 am. Okay. And for doing overtime gigs like that there?s not reports you just set it up to do the contract and you do whatever they need to do and then you do a report on it if you have to take police action, arrest somebody or use force. That sort of thing correct? Yes. i Um but it?s not something that?s gonna show up on police logs cuz it?s an off duty gig. Um well I was signed on to a squad. Okay. So there is an assignment Okay showed me on duty. Alright. And working as off duty capacity. And ah I don?t have the (inaudible) with me but what was your call sign that night? Ah it was 6130. Okay. Alright so going back to that night which is the 14th heading into the 15?? can you tell me where you were when you heard the call and how you reacted what happened? I was down ah I was at Mayo Clinic Square at ah 600 Hennepin Avenue. was down in the loading dock area by the security um area. Ah I was in my squad car and i heard the alert tone come out officer needs help shots fired. Ah I proceeded up the ramp and um westbound on Okay. When you arrived then the address was generally 1600 Plymouth Ave? (inaudible) close to that yeah. Yep I don?t remember the exact address of the call but Can you tell me what you saw arriving on scene? Page 2 of 7 Phill-2015-648?A12 Ah when I arrived on scene there was already ah multiple marked squads. Um right as was getting there they asked for squads that were arriving to come to the north side of Plymouth Avenue. Um-hm Um there was a large crowd by the Elks Bar and they were trying to get those, that crowd um back away from the crime scene. Okay. Was there a scene commander giving any instructions at the time do you remember? That was a sergeant that gave that order as I was rolling in. I don?t know who was in charge at the time. Okaysupplemental report for MPD on that and having reviewed that I saw that you had occasion to actually the person who was shot and see what was going on. Can you tell me how you ended up up there by the shot person, and what you saw? As I was walk, I walked down the middle of Plymouth Avenue ah which was um there was a large crowd on the ah 'north side by the Elks. Um-hm. There was a lot of people on the south side as well by some apartment buildings. Um there was officers on each side trying to keep the people back. And as I walked up to the middle I saw the, the ambulance and I saw two paramedics ah working on the victim that was down. Okay. And I noticed there was no officers around them. So I went over, they were working really hard on him and they didn?t look very comfortable because of the crowd and everybody yelling. Yeah. Um so I walked over there to ?em and I said is there anything you need from me um other than physical security. I can give you security. And they said that would be great just keep us safe. 80 I stepped to the urn south side of where they were working on him. Um-hm. And um so my back was to them and, and my front was towards the crowd on ah the south side of Plymouth where the other officers were. And I said as long as you can see me I?m standing right here I was only you know two, three feet away from ?em I said as long as you can see me you?re safe. 80 you can have your head down and work. So that?s where I stood for several minutes. Okay. Did they um ask you to do anything as far as touch that body? Be with the person? At the time he?s still alive that?s why they?re working on him. Did you have any occasion to deal with the person there (inaudible)? Yes. What happened there? Ah one of the medics said to me um does he have a gun on him. And I said I don?t know I just got here. Um and the medic said to me something to the effect of will you pat him down for us cuz I don?t want to find a gun or touch a gun. I said yes I will. So I turned around and bent over and started going around his waist area and his jacket. Did a quick pat down, I said I don't see any gun, you?re good to go. And then they went, and they continued to work on him. Page 3 of 7 Phill-20?I 5-648-A1 2 Okay. So back, backing up to when you first approached the two EMT's working on him. Was that gunshot victim lying front, backside? What?d he look like? Where was he ly, how was he lying? He was laying ah on his back. His arms are to his side and his face was straight up. Okay. So he was basically lying on his back. Okay. Could you see what injury he had? Ah it looked like he had a gunshot wound ah near his or in the forehead area. Okay. And at that time did you see if he was handcuffed? He was not handcuffed. Okay. So now we come back to they say hey can you check him for weapons. You pat him down. Still on his back. Did you roll him at all to, to pat him down orjust did it, Nope I did not roll him. Ah they were, working on him I didn?t want (inaudible) at the same time? Yeah I didn?t want to get in their way [just kinda did a pat down around his waist area, his jacket and or clothes area and just tried to make sure that he didn?t have like a gun sticking in his waistband or something that would go off Okay they tried to move him. So then you stood back up and I'm guessing you went back to seeing security? Yes I, I stayed with the medics the whole time so they could be safe. Okay. So you didn?t handcuff him? No. Alright you turn back around and give security so did you see them then load him? Yes. At the time they were loading him did you see did he have handcuffs on him? He did not have handcuffs on him. Okay. Um was the ambulance parked close by? Yes it was. Alright so they rolled him over there ah I understand another officerjumped in the rig with them I guess a firefighter was also, at that time did you see anybody place handcuffs or take handcuffs off of him? He, he never had handcuffs on at all. When I was there. Okay. Um the officers who ended up ah being involved did you know either one of them? Ah Ringgenberg or Sohwarze? I know Schwarze. Okay did you see them at the scene? I did not see them at all. Page 4 of 7 Okay. Um after they got him loaded do you remember looking back at all at the scene and seeing anything there you know where they were working on him on the ground? Well when they lifted him up to put him on the stretcher there was a pair of handcuffs on the ground underneath his body. Okay. Did you touch those at all? No I didn?t. Do you remember at all what type of cuffs they were? Color? Did you happen to, I think they were just silver handcuffs. Okay. Incidentally does ah MPD you guys I know you have to buy your own weapons, do you have to buy your own cuffs? Yes. Alright so it?s your choice hinged, non, plated or not it?s all (inaudible) There is some limitations on them. Um?hm Um, but think they were if I remember correctly I think they were chain cuffs. Okay. So it pays to etch, you guys (inaudible) extra (inaudible) your cuffs so they?re yours or You should, I do. Yeah. Because there?s a lotta times where people get transported away or there?s a scene where you, I carry two cuffs lotta times you?re cuffing multiple people and they end up in different squads and if you don't have your name on 'em they might ah be lost or be left at the jail. So it?s a good idea to put your, you should put your name or badge number on there. Okay. So they get him in there. They wheel him off. Ah what role did you take then? Um after they got him up and another officer came by me and they said something to the effect that they were going in the ambulance. Yeah Or is any i, or something like is, is anybody riding with them and then that officer was getting in the ambulance. Um at that time the crowd was settled down somewhat as the ambulance left. Um there was still people yelling whatnot so at that time was just in the middle um of Plymouth walking back and forth just trying to keep my on the crowd and, and keep scene security. Okay. And at some time did, were you relieved by the scene commander or did you decide on your own okay it?s died down I gotta get back? Urn, there was one of the um bar close was coming and there was cops from all over the city there, obviously. Bar close was coming up um so the downtown officers got released to go back downtown. Um-hm. Um to deal with bar close cuz that?s one of our busiest areas of the city at that time. So at that time I went back downtown um went back to myjob. Okay. Approximately what time is that? Page 5 of 7 Phill?2015-648?A12 Um, I think it was around 12:30 I went back to the station. Ah went to the bathroom and then got in the car and drove back for bar close. What?s bar close, what time? Um 2:00 oh maybe it was 1:30. It might have been 1:30. I, I?m not sure exactly um (inaudible) a better question would be about how much time do you think you spent on scene? Um, Or did Half hour, forty-five minutes. Did An hour the call yourself? Well he the, the issue with my call is when was going to the call there was already, they were on the air multiple times saying we need more cops, we need more cops. It?s not your job to get on, I don?t think it?s a safe thing for clogging up the air when I?m in a different precinct saying 6130 assign me to that call. Ifl had a partner we woulda self?assigned on the computer but my priority was to get there as fast as I could in a safe manner and I wasn?t gonna be sitting there and touching the computer. If I had a partner they could have self?assigned and we went so I never got on the air and said that I went there. Um, but I was logged on to my um squad car so that?ll show the route so it?ll show me what time I got there and then what time I left if you want to check that out. Ah along with that um you had a marked squad. Was that one equipped with a camera? Um (sigh) I don't drive that car very often it?s kind of our worst squad. (inaudible) It?s kind of a left overjunk car it?s the oldest one um so it?s not an SUV it?s an old white car. Oh okay. So I don?t know if that one has a camera or not. Okay. To be honest with you um you?d have to look it?s, it?s it was it?s marked squad 164. Okay. But if the other, you?ll see me if you review the tapes because as I turned from onto Plymouth Um-hm There was a bunch of cops coming ah westbound on Plymouth behind me, Okay. So you?ll be able to, my car is gonna be identifiable cuz it?s different than the rest of ?em? Okay it?s the old style. Yeah. Alright. And also i?m asking this question of everybody I know that ah body cams were being tested for a while. You didn?t have a body cam that night? Page 6 of 7 body cam. Okay. Um could you go back to the moment when the medics decided that it was time to move the body ah describe exactly what you saw, how the movement was to the extent that you recall who did what to get him from where he lay into the rig. Um they had the gurney or whatever you call it wheeled over. Um I don?t know how, one or two of ?em picked, picked him up and put him on there. And when they lifted him up that?s the first time I saw the handcuffs that were like underneath him. Um so they picked him up and put him on there. And did what they had to do, strapped him down or whatever but I?m going back and forth of looking at them, looking at the crowd so I don?t know I can?t tell you specifically which medic, there was three medics there. I think one of ?em was a supervisor and two were the regular medics but I, I can?t tell you for sure. Um-hm. Ah I don?t, I couldn?t you could bring ?em in right now and I can?t tell you what their faces were I can?t remember I wasn?t paying attention to the, which med, they weren?t normal ones cuz they might work at night and I work I know some of the ones in the day by face so but I just remember them picking him up and when they walked over to put him on there that?s the first time I saw the handcuffs and they, they were underneath him. Did you notice the ah patient?s arms at all as they moved him? Um, I don?t remember I don?t remember if they put ?em on, sometimes they roll ?em onto a like a little soft cot and lift them up. Um which they might have done I?m, I?m not sure. Okay. I can?t remember. That?s probably what they did they probably put him on one of the little soft um, stretcher if, if you will and then they?d lift him up by that and put him onto the actual ah gurney. Okay. Do you recall if the patients arms were, sometimes they?ll place ?em over his chest. Were they down by his side do you call, recall how he was positioned? I don?t remember. Okay. I?m sorry. Ah is there anything else you can think of that was significant that we might want to know for the investigation? Saw or heard? Um, (pause) not really I mean I tried to put everything that I remembered in my supplement. Okay. Alright anything else? Alright we?re gonna be terminating the interview. lt?s 13:12 hours. END OF RECORDING. PhilI-2015-648-A12 Page 7 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/62 Report Date: 11 /23/2015 Primary Information Description: Acquisition of EMS radio traf?c from HCMC Occurrence From: 11/19/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/23/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/01/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On 11 [23/2015 SA Henning picked up a thumb drive containing audio from HCMC EMS relating to this investigation. Acquisition of exhibit Address #1 - Occurred #1 HCMC Primary Information Address: HCMC EMS, Minnesota United States subject #1 .- EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICE Primary Information Subject Name: WENDY Record Type: Person Bio: White, Female Juvenile: NO Subject MEDICAL SERVICE #2 - WARDALL, JORDAN Primary Information Subject Name: WARDALL, JORDAN Record Type: Person Bio: White, Male Juvenile: NO - Thumb drive-containing-EMS audio from HCMC from 11/15/2015 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Media storage device Description: Thumb drive containing EMS audio from HCMC from 11/15/2015 Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/62 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Property #1 containing EMS?audio from-HOMO from 11/15/2015 - Continued Primary Information - Continued Remote Bin: Locker Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 11/30/2015 13:00 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/01/2015 14:31 Rep?drting'LEO Date Supervisor Date Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 i MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On 1 1/19/2015 SA Henning met with Wendy Chief of Communications for Hennepin County EMS. SA Henning requested a cepy of HCMC EMS radio traf?c from 1 1/15/2015. advised SA Henning that she would put that information together and contact SA Henning when it was ready. contacted SA Henning on 1 1/23/2015 and said that the radio traf?c had been put on a thumb drive and was ready for pick up. told SA Henning to see her administrative assistant to get the thumb drive. SA Henning went to HCMC EMS of?ces located at 701 Park Ave S. Minneapolis, MN. SA Henning was directed to Deputy Chief Jordan Wardall. Wardall provided SA Henning with the thumb drive said to contain the EMS audio from 11/15/2015. SA Henning retumed to MN BCA and provided the EMS audio to SA Phill who is the case agent. SA Henning attached the change of custody receipt to this report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ri?eii?a?sremie?esarReceipt - A I. 1- I .. offense Number: 2015648/82 Case Agent: (1361 IMRO Hamletde I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Item Quantity Description 1 1 Thumb drive containing EMS audio from HCMC from 1111512015 State authority to release or menn er of disposition: AGENT I nearby certify that I have received the above listed property Signature Date Received 1113012015 th, MRo-?I?Homzcicse Minnesota Bureau of Mame Criminal Apprehension) owne?For owner Address - Henning, Doug (1361 CItyIState Re'eased 53? MRO Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminai Apprehension) Telephone Veri?ed By dhenning 11/30/2015 software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/63 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary Information Description: Evidence pick-up from MPD on 11/23/2015 from Commander Chris Granger Occurrence From: 11/23/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/23/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/02/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Syn?bpsis 2015-648I63.1, 63.2, 63.3. On 11/23/2015 SA Henning picked up evidence from Minneapolis Police Commander Chris Granger. Acquisition of exhibit Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 5TH ST Primary Information Address: 350 5TH ST #Rm 108, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Dale, Robert (Law Enforcement Official) PrQ'Pe?rty #1 {Unit #424 activity-iqu Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Unit #424 activity log Property Status: BCAI HQ Status Date: 11/30/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/lime: 11/23/2015 00:00 Property #2 Activity?a? a?tivity log Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Activity #412 activity log Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/30/2015 Quantity: 1 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/63 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Preperty #2 - Activity #412 activity log - Continued Primary Information - Continued Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 00:00 P?r??p?ny #3gr..g-.Minngapoiis- Pbificeji?gment-detail rag 154-22966 Primary Infermation Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Minneapolis Police Incident detail log 15-422966 Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 11/30/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Datefrime: 11/23/2015 00:00 . - LE9 GRANGER, Christopher (Comm Homicide I Minneapolis Police Department) Record Status InfOrmation Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 1113012015 15:37 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/02/2015 11:11 Rep-oning LEO . . - Date - Supervisor; Date Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 Of 3 On 11/23/2015 SA Henning met Commander Chris Granger with Minneapolis Police at his of?ce located at 350 South 5th St. Room 108, Minneapolis. Commander Granger walked SA Henning to evidence section where he was provided with an envelope containing three items: Activity log for squad #424 (exhibit 2015-648/63. 1), Activity log for squad #412 (exhibit and MPD Incident Detail Log (exhibit SA Henning was also provided with police reports by Commander Granger for SA Phill. The evidence items and reports were all turned over to SA Phill upon return to the BCA. SA Henning has attached the change of custody receipt for this evidence. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Releaseli?spos?ai Receipt is A . . 1 7 offense Number: 2015648,? Case Agent: (1361 I MRO Homioide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Item Quantity Description 1 1 Unit #424 activity 109 2 1 Activity #412 activity 109 3 1 Minneapoiis Police incident detail log 154122966 State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT I hearby certify that I have received the above listed property Signature Name Address W?w Phili, - ?Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Date Received 1113012015 OwneriFor Owner CityIState Henning, Doug (1361 Reieased 33? MRO - Homicide! Telephone Minnesota Bureau of Criminai Apprehension) Veri?ed By cihenning 1 1/30/1201 5 mm: ACISS software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/64 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Primary'lnformation Interview of HCMC Paramedic Mari Hill 11l23l2015 00:00 11l2312015 00:00 Description: Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/07/2015 Approved By: Henning, Doug (1361 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synapsis'. On 11/23/2015 FBI SA Matt Vogel and BCA SA Henning met with HCMC Paramedic Mari Hill for an interview. The interview was recorded (acquisition of exhibit Address #1 Occurred 701-PARK AVE 3 Primary Information Address: 701 PARK AVE 3 HCMC, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Description: HCMC HOSPITAL Subjects Relationship EMPLOYER Hallblade, Melissa (Person) White, Female EMPLOYER Jarvis, Kristi Jo (Person) 33 yr. old, White, Female OTHER Hilderbrand, Troy Allen (Person) 50 yr. old, White, Male RELATED BOOTH, JON GREGORY (Person) 59 yr. old, White, Male RELATED DEMARS, DENNIS DWAYNE (Person) 55 yr. old, White, Male RELATED PAYTON, JAMES CORNELIUS (Person) 58 yr. oid, Black, Male RELATED . RILEY, JAMES JOSEPH (Person) 62 yr. old, White, Male RELATED STILLDAY, DALLAS WAYNE (Person) 56 yr. old, Indian, Male RELATED THAGGARD, IRVING NMN (Person) 56 yr. old, Black, Male Telephones ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address INSTALLATION RESIDENTIAL) ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 Christine Primary Information HILL, MARI Christine Record Type: Person Subject Name: MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/64 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - HILL, MARI Christine- Continued Primary Information - Continued Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Employment Information Employed: YES Occupation: PARAMEDIC Addresses Relationship Address EMPLOYER 701 PARK AVE 8 HCMC, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Subjects Relationship Name B_io Ill?? CO-WORKER WORDALL, JORDAN (Person) White, Male Subject #2 - WITNESS #2 - Lupkes, Tyler John Primary Information Subject Name: Lupkes, Tyler John Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 509 Weight: 210 Color: Hazel Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationshi NumberlE?Address Identifications I I I Malia: _S_ta_te_ Countpg As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/64 Report Date: 11/23/2015 .Subject #3 EMPLOYER #1 Wardell, Jordan Alias Information WARDALL, JORDAN WORDALL, JORDAN Primary Information Subject Name: Wardell, Jordan Record Type: Rerson Bio: White, Male Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address EMPLOYER 701 PARK AVE 8 HCMC, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Subjects Relationship Name CO-WORKER HILL, MARI Christine (Person) 28 yr. old, White, Female . Property #1 - CD containing audio of interview with'Paramedic Mari Hill Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing audio of interview with Paramedic Mari Hill Property Status: BCAI HQ Status Date: 11/30/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 11/23/2015 00:00 Officers Vogel, Matt (Special Agept/ FBI) Record Status Information - Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 1 1/30/2015 16:49 12/07/2015 10:29 Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/64 Report Date: 11/23/2015 Reporting LEO Date) '1 Supervisor Date Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide/ Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrative begins on - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On 1 1/23/2015 SA Henning and FBI SA Matt Vogel met with HCMC Paramedic Mari Hill to conduct an interview in reference to an of?cer involved shooting in Minneapolis on 1 1/15/2015. The interview was conducted at HCMC EMS Administrative of?ces located at 701 Park Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55415. During this interview HCMC Deputy Chief of EMS Jordan Wardell was also present. The interview was recorded and a copy of the audio was placed on a (acquisition of exhibit 2015?648/64. I). The interview was started at about 4:53 PM. Hill told agents that she was employed as a paramedic with HCMC. Hill said that she was working on the evening of 11/15/2015 with her partner Tyler Lupkes. Hill said that she was assigned that night to station number 4, which is in the area of 94 and Lyndale Ave. Hill said that she and her partner were monitoring radio traf?c and were dispatched to a shooting on Plymouth Ave. Hill told agents as they arrived they didn?t immediately know where the patient was. Hill said that they were eventually directed to the patient and saw that their supervisor Mike was tending to the patient. Hill told agents that she immediately went to assist with the patient and her partner started to obtain equipment. Hill advised agents that the patient was lying face up with his arms at his sides. Hill said that she immediately noticed an injury to the patients left area. Hill said that when her partner arrived at the patient with the canvass stretcher she recalled hearing him kick what she thought was a pair of handcuffs as he put the canvas stretcher down next to the patient. Hill next recalled her partner asking if the patient had been searched yet. Hill recalled searching the patient from the waist down to his ankles. Agents asked Hill to describe what occurred next. Hill said that she put two IVs into the patient, one in each arm. Hill said that the patient was loaded into the ambulance. Once the patient was in the ambulance she cut off the patients clothing. Hill said that she had also asked via radio if the ?re department was responding to assist. Hill said that they did arrived on scene and assisted prior to leaving the scene. Hill believed that it took longer for MFD to arrive because of the crowds that Were forming. Hill said that the patient was transported to the HCMC ER. SA Vogel asked some follow up questions, he began by asking how long Hill had been a paramedic. Hill said that she has been a paramedic for 5 .5 years and employed by HCMC for just under ?ve years. Vogel asked how Hill and her partner reSponded to this call. Hill indicated that they responded code 3. Hill indicated that when they arrived on scene that there was a huge police presence. Hill told Vogel that there was a large crowd that had formed, she recalled someone yelling black lives matter. Vogel asked Hill if she recalled any police of?cers around the patient. Hill said that she did not recall seeing any of?cers around the patient but did recall bumping into an of?cer as they moved the patient. Vogel asked Hill if she knew the of?cers involved in this incident, Hill said that she did not. Vogel next asked about searching the patient and if that was policy. Hill indicated that it was and they check patient for weapons routinely. Vogel continued with questions asking if Hill knew where the medical bag on scene had come ?om, Hill thought that it was here supervisors that had been on scene. Vogel asked about identity of the patient, Hill said that the patient was transported to the ER and she was unaware of any biographical information until after the patient was already at the HCMC ER. Vogel asked several questions about the handcuffs. Hill indicated that she noticed that her partner had his handcuffs still in his duty belt while they were at the ER. Hill said that she knew that they were not her either because she was still in possession of hers. Vogel asked if HCMC paramedics routinely carry handcuffs, Hill said they did. Hill ?nished the interview by telling agents that she never observed handcuffs on the patient nor did she see anything on the patient which would indicate he had been handcuffed. The interview was completed at 5:19 PM. This report is only a summary of this interview, for mu detail please see the transcript which will be attached to this report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension agape ff;- iReleas efbisp'osaI-j ?Receipt Offense ?umber: 201564854 Case Agent: Henning, Doug (1361 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehenswn) Item Quantity Description 1 1 CD containing audio of interview with Paramedic Mari Hill State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION [nearby certify that I have received the above Iisted property Signature f? Date Received 11/30/2015 th, Hon'qi?i?de 1 Minnesota Bureau of name Criminal Apprehension) ownerlFor owner Address - - Henning, Doug (1361/ Re?eased By MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Telephone Veri?ed By dhenning 11/30/2015 software licensed by Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 23, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Mari Hill (MH) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Doug Henning (DH) FBI SA Matt Vogel (MV) REVIEWED BY: DH Okay, this is Doug Henning. I?m a BCA Agent um the date today is 11?23-2015. The time right now is 4:55. This will be reference BCA Case Number 2015-648. We're presently at uh Hennepin County Medical Center EMS Admin located at 701 Park, it's Park Street, right? MH Park Avenue. DH Avenue uh Minneapolis, Minnesota, 55415. Um, also present is Special Agent Matt Vogel, last name spelled, of the Federal Bureau of Investigation as well as HCMC EMS Deputy Chief Jordan Wardell, spend-, spelled, uh Um and before we get started I?m gonna read your full name and date of birth then. And it?s, yourfirst name is Mari, is that correct? MH Yes. DH Christine, MH Correct. DH Hill, MH Correct. DH Your date of birth_. MH Correct. DH And for the purposes of this report it?ll be the same address that I?ve already given. MH Yes. DH So I?m gonna put this up here. Um, I guess we?ll start with can you, can you tell me where your employed? MH Hennepin County Medical Center. DH Okay and what do you do for uh Hennepin County? MH I?m a paramedic. DH Okay. Um on November 15th were you working? MH Was I working? DH Yes. MH . Yes, I was working. DH Okay. Where were you assigned? MH Uh Eden, or we were at Station 4 in Minneapolis Fire Department, Station 4. HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Page 1 of 11 interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Okay, where?s that? in uh North Minneapolis off of like 94 and Lyndale area. (inaudible) Kind (inaudible) okay. Um so there was an incident that occurred just after midnight um which was a sho-, can you tell me about that? Um, how far back do you want me to start? We were assigned to Station 4, sitting there. Okay Um, there was another call going on in the area of this incident. Okay. Um, at a point something happened up there. Okay. I did not (inaudible) and as a result my partner and were called to a shooting. Okay. A (inaudible) that was down. Okay. So then who was your partner that day? Tyler Lupkes. Okay. So and Tyler responded to the uh the officer involved shooting. Correct. On Plymouth Avenue. Yes. Okay. Do you remember arriving at the scene? Yes. Okay. Can you tell me that you did once you got there? Um, well we pulled up and we didn?t' immediately see where they were at because of all the lights and so we pulled up kind a, to the side of where the incident was. We went over and um one of our other supervisor?s, Mike, was on scene tending to the patient who was shot. Okay. Um, when we got there I, my partner didn?t, I went immediately to the patient and to the supervisor and my partner went to the back of our truck to get our stretcher. Okay. So I went up and I checked for a pulse. Um, my partner, my supervisor said that he had just stopped breathing. I believe I didn?t feel a pulse buy my supervisor believed that he did so um my other partner brought over, we have like a canvas with holes in it. Um-hm. Urn so we used, put that on the ground um as my supervisor was bagging was now on the patient?s left side and my partner went to lay the canvas down and he kicked a pair of handcuffs out the way. Um, we got down, my partner asked if he had been searched um to which it sounded like he hadn?t so I went and i felt like down by his ankles and his legs. Page 2 of 11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Um?hm. And his pants and then we rolled the patient on his left side and kind a scooted him on. to. this canvas, picked him up on the canvas while the supervisor was still continued ventilation and put him in the truck. Once he was in the truck um my supervisor said that he no longer had a pulse and my supervisor started CPR. Okay. Um, and my partner at that time was assisting the supervisor in getting our Lucus Device, our CPR device on him while I was cutting off his clothes. Okay. Um, I asked if the fire department had been started to our location to assist us. Yep. Um, it took them a while to get there. It sounds like they had some difficulty getting through the crowds. So at that time 1 was between, I was cutting and bagging the patient between all the CPR. Um, fire arrived. They took over ventilation of the patient. Um by this time we had out Lucus Machine on the patient. Um I started IVs um in each arm on our patient and we transported emergently to Hennepin County. Okay. Medical Center. 80 let me take you back to when you arrived. Yes. Okay. You guys arrive. Yes. Your supervisor flags you down. Is that correct? Um, we asked over the radio where they were. Okay. And an officer, it was either an officer or somebody to our driver?s side that kind a flagged us down like we're over here. Somebody on scene pointed you in the direction (inaudible) Yes. was there and (inaudible). Correct. 80 you walk up or you get out you, you (inaudible) see. Um uh person laying on the ground. Face up? Face up, face up um his hands are at his side. Okay. He?s got kind of tennis shoes on, baggy pants that are essentially down around his mid thighs. Okay. He?s wearing a belt um kind of red plaid boxer's. Page 3 of 11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Um?hm. Um he?s got one of those kind a big baggy like (inaudible) jackets. Okay. And I believe it was a black zip up hoody. Okay. Um, I out both of those off eventually. Okay. And then he also had a shirt on which i believe also got cut off. Okay. And then I can see that he?s got an injury essentially on his left or like around his left eye. Okay. His left is not discernable. Okay. 80. And then you said at some point while you were sitting there working (inaudible) you noticed a pair of handcuffs. Um, yep my partner, when we went to roll him, actually didn?t see them at all I heard my partner, I shouldn?t say (inaudible), the first time I noticed ?em is because i heard my partner like kind a kick them out of the way. Okay. Um. Were they underneath him then? I don?t know. I think, I don't think they were underneath him because he, they were in the way of us laying down our canvas. Okay. (inaudible) along side of ?em? They right side of him. Okay. So (inaudible) My assumption was that my partner accidently dropped his cuffs. Okay. Kind of that?s kind where they like they weren't underneath him at all and they weren?t attached to him at all. Okay. And so I, my impression was that when my partner bent over to lay it Okay. may have fallen out or he dropped them or whatever and theyjust kind a got pushed out of the way. Page4of'l?l IVIH HCMC Interview of Paramedic Nlari Hill Okay but when you arrived, this person No. in handcuffs? Nope. You, you said his legs were on his side? His hands were on his side. (inaudible) Yep. And just lying there on his back. Correct. (inaudible) supervisor? Correct. Okay. Um, I don?t have any more questions. Okay. have a, a few questions and I?ll try to go in the most logical order (inaudible) but I Okay. ?em down as Yep. to mind. Um, how long have you been and an, a medic? I will have 5 years on, in February, February 11?? I believe is my 5 year mark. Okay. So not quite 5 years. Have you been with HEF, HCMC the whole time? Yes. Okay. I, excuse me February will be my 5 year mark working with Hennepin County. I?ve been certified as a medic for about 5 1/2 years. Okay. Um, you were dispatched code 3? Um, initially it was, it came across I think as like a medical and code 2. My partner asked I we code 2 and dispatch said no we?re gonna change it to code 3, respond code 3. Okay, um how, and, and I understand that this is I guess because it?s all documented and that would be the record but how long would you estimate it was between dispatch and arrival? Ew, 3 maybe 4 minutes. Okay. We were blocks away. Really quick. Yep. Okay. Um, upon arrival what kind of presence was there? Page5of11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill There?s a huge police presence. There?s a lot of cop cars there, lots of lights. Om, they, i noticed that they had the tape, the yellow tape up and there were crowds forming. um, I couldn?t hear all of them but there was one male voice that I heard screaming black lives matter. Okay. Um, amongst the officers there they, you work with these officers all the time. Um-hm. Um, were there, your supervisor was attending to the patient. Yep. Um, were there any officers that were in the immediate vicinity of the patient? On my arrival, not that I recall. I don?t, I don?t know. I don?t recall that. Okay. I, when we went to move ?em, I ran into an officer but he wasn?t there wasn?t another officer attending to the patient when I arrived. Uh, do you, did you know or have you since learned who the officers involved with the patient were? The ones that made, that were involved in the shooting? Right. know their names. I don?t know who they are by Okay. Or No, personally I do not know them. Okay. Um, and so you wouldn?t know if you had, if you, if you saw them there at the scene when you got there? No, not, there were officers that I recognized by face but i don?t know their names. Sure. Um, so if i saw this officer I wouldn?t? be able to put his name with his face but by name I do not know the officers. Okay, um you said that you uh searched the patient when you got there? Um, essentially his legs, i didn?t look in really and then his legs and his jeans. He had something like a cup or something in his pocket cuz I remember kind a pulling on it and it not coming out. It was (inaudible) Yeah, something hard and plastic, with like a round opening. 1 can?t think say for sure remember kind a seeing it, feeling it, kind a pulling it out and it wouldn't really come out of his pocket. Okay. Um, and then down by his ankles. I didn?t feel anything besides like baggy jeans. Okay, and so once you're in the rig you cut his clothes off. Yes. PageGof?li HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Were there any other items in his pockets? Um, I didn?t check pockets once they were cutoff and clothes just kind a fall to the floor. Um, and I didn't check the pockets after that. Okay. Um, is it your procedure and policy to conduct a search of the patient before putting him in the rig? Um, either ourselves or police officer, yes have police searches our patient before getting into the ambulance. Okay. Um and why did, why did you search the, the patient that night? Um, just for fear of weapons, we don?t want ?em showing up in our truck and we don?t want them showing up in the emergency Okay. the presence of anyone else. Were, so were you unaware whether the office?, the police officer had already searched ?em? We had no idea. Okay. MY partner actually yelled, did somebody search ?em cuz I don?t know if he actually got an answer so that?s when I started looking. Okay. Um, and then there?s uh at the scene once the scene has kind a cleared. They go through and document what was there, there?s a, there?s a medical bag of some sort. Um?hm. Uh, do you know who brought back the medical bag out? I believe it was my supervisor. Okay. I don?t, cuz I don?t recall my partner and I grabbing our medical bags out and my supervisor?s bags were out. Okay, and that would?ve been from? His vehicle. Okay. Uh, and had the patient?s uh name or identity or any other descriptors been broadcast? No. By dispatch or anywhere between? Not that I recall, um, it came out for us as an officer involved or like it didn?t come out clearly as whether or not, it didn?t come out clearly as to who shot who. Um, we didn't really find that out until we pulled up on scene or like on the way there. Um, I take that back, we didn?t find out until we got there, didn?t realize what was going on and I actually arrived to the emergency room without knowing this, anything about this patient. Um, our, on our radio report we estimated his age and we late-, um I believe the emergency room staff actually found his ID and that?s how I was able to put his name in the report. Okay. Um, can you describe to me how he was uh picked up from where he lay and placed in the, in the rig. Page70f1?l HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill Yep, um so he was laying on his back. We laid the canvas on his right side. Um, and then we essentially kind a rolled him towards us so that he?s kind a laying on his side on his left arm and then we scoot the canvas kind a underneath him and then we rolled him back and then just to adjust him on the canvas we kind a scooted him a little bit and then one person takes the two poles at the bottom and one person takes the two poles at the top and we moved him over to the stretcher. And where were you in this? I was carrying the head I believe of him. Okay. Or that kind of his head um and then we set him on the stretcher and then I can?t remember if we put a seat belt on him at that time cuz I know it was kind of a rush to get him in to the ambulance so from there he was on the stretcher so he went, you know we pressed our buttons to load our stretcher up and push the stretcher into the truck so that?s how he was loaded in the truck. Uh, can you, do you recall um how so he?s on this stretcher you said the canvas? Um-hm, without, yeah. As Canvas and poles. Is it, like is there support under it or is itjust the poles that the weight of the body? It, it?s kind of like the old army canvases that you see like in the movies where they carry the injured. - Sure. So it?s urn, it?s 1 mean they don?t sag hardly at all but it?s not like having a backboard under them. It?s kind a like being on a firm thick cloth with the two things on the side. Okay. Uh is it, would, would his arms have been entirely contained or were they, have been outside Um, I don?t remember exactly what his were. I believe his arms kind a fell to the side when we put him on the stretcher because he didn?t have kind of the cuff of the canvas. And cuz i remember cuz we always (inaudible) that?s always a concern when we put them in the ambulance we have to watch for their arms when the stretcher goes in. So they may have fallen off when they were put on the stretcher but once he was in the canvas his arms like can't say for sure what they actually were but typically they are in, like contained in the with the patient. Okay. Uh and correct me if, if I?m miss heard what you said earlier. Did, you didn?t start cutting his clothes off until after he was in the rig? Correct. Okay. That's when I started cutting off his clothes. Oh, what was the condition of his clothing when you arrived versus when you put it, when you put him in the rig? Page 8 of 11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill When we arrived, I believe all his clothes were intact. I mean like i said his pants were kind a down mid-thigh and around his knees and his clothes were baggy. i don?t believe they were, I can?t recall if they were ripped ortorn or anything. Urn, and then once we put him in this truck they were still intact until I started cutting them off and then the way that i cut them off is you kind a start at the collar and i cut down each sleeve um is what i did there and then you just kind a find a way to cut the rest off and I don?t?, can?t remember cuz think once I cut the sleeves theyjust that kind a fell off but I?m not sure how the shirt ended up getting cutoff of him. Was there anything um any, any item at all that hung off of him a, especially hung off anywhere on his loins? Um his jacket kind a would?ve hung off. Um, I?m not can?t remember if like you mean i guess you would?ve put him in the truck or? Cuz like I don?t From where he lay There. Well his clothes were really baggy. He wasn?t a very big guy so his jacket might?ve kind a spilled out over the side or anything but there was if anything was hanging from his arms it would?ve been his own clothes and it might?ve been the jacket that maybe kind of slipped off past his wrist but that was it. Um, you mentioned your partner's handcuffs? I don?t know if they were his or not. Do you do, i don?t believe they were. Do EM, do EM, Paramedics? Paramedics, okay um typically carry handcuffs here? Yes. Okay. Um, so when you, after you arrived uh at the hospital. Uh?hm. At some point you gave a statement to uh Minneapolis Police. Yes. Um, other than that officer, who else have you talked to about this incident? Um, my supervisor, Mike Cholander um I?m also dating a police officer who was on scene so he and have, not in depth, we?ve kind of kept that vary there but he was there. And it, it?s be natural Yeah, What, what?s his name? Griffin Hillbo. Hill, Hillbo? Yep, Okay. Um, and then my other supervisor Wade uh Johnson. Um, my partner Tyler, briefly though. i, I don?t think i really seen him much since the incident Page 9 of 11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill (inaudible) Lupkes, L-U-P-K-E-S, Lupkes I think. Okay. Um, and then there was the other two paramedics that were involved. We didn?t talk in detail. It was kind of more like holy crap thatjust happened but not really much detail about anything that I can really think of. Hopefully, not something you run Right. very often. Um, so you haven?t given any other statements regarding these incidents? No. Okay. Um. have you made any comments I?ve, not (inaudible) discussion events? This, because of the media and people everywhere that I work with, get really frustrated when like visually see that I?m frustrated but like the only comments that i made to them have been things like that you've already seen on TV so like a lot of times just say I don?t think I'm supposed to talk about it and they kind a leave it at that. Okay. So i know there?s a big issue about whether or not he was handcuffed and he was never handcuffed in my presence and I never saw anything to indicate he ever was but I get that question from people and again they can see that I?m frustrated but if (inaudible) answered the question with the exception of talking to the people that ljust mentioned, yeah like my boyfriend or the supervisor or whatever. Cuz I know it was a an original detail that I kind of freaked about cuz I know I didn?t mention it in my original one so more stressful for me cuz I didn?t know like who I was supposed to tell or how i was supposed to tell them so then that?s when I came to my supervisor to talk about that. Okay. So. I think that?s, I think that?s all I have. is there any other details that you think is important we should know about? Um, as far as my partner?s cuffs are concerned, when we got to the hospital my partner had his cuffs on him so the ones that were at scene I found out were not my partners. Okay. Um, and then just kind a the big deal that there was nothing hanging like off of his hands when we were there (inaudible) handcuffs. i still have my cuffs, yes. You still have your cuffs? Page10of11 HCMC Interview of Paramedic Mari Hill I do still have my cuffs. They?re on me right now. Um, I own more than one pair but I only ever use one pair. The other ones are in storage or in storage at home. Okay. Um, and I start, again i started both IVs on the station and I never came across anything that would indicate any trauma to his arms or anywhere else. Okay. So. I (inaudible) give you my business card. Okay. Um, (inaudible) It was very mind blowing. was actually like physically kind a shaken. If you think of anything else, would you give me a call? Okay. (inaudible) sit down again. Um-hm. So, okay? Sounds good. This will be the end of the interview. The time is 5:19 pm. END OF TAPE Page110f11 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/65 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Primary Information Description: Review of Transcript of Wesley Thompson Interview Reporting LEO: Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12l08/2015 Approved By: Woodford, Derek (1317 SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis ley?William Thompson related to the investigation into the Officer generated by virtue of this report. (Please see narrative report and SA Anderson reviewed the transcript of the interview with Wes Involved Shooting (OIS) of Jamar Clark. No Evidence was attached transcript for additional details). Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Thompson, Wesley William Primary Information Subject Name: Thompson, Wesley William Record Type: Person Bio: 36 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 220 Color: Blue Addresses Relationship Address Home ADDRESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address PHONE Identifications State County As or Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12l03l2015 13:11 Last Update Operator: Woodford, Derek (1317 ISRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12l08/2015 21 :53 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/65 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Reporting LEO . . - I Date) - . . Supervisor," Date Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Woodford, Derek (1317 I SRO - Homicide I Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I2612016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrative begins on thefollowing page.~ MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of4 On 11/19/15, SA Anderson was requested to review audio recordings and transcripts of interviews that were conducted by the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) related to the Officer involved Shooting (OIS) of Jamar Clark that had occurred on 11/15/2015. SA Anderson reviewed the audio recording and transcript of an interview with Wesley William Thompson that was conducted by Sergeant Twila Villella of the MPD. The interview was conducted on November 15m, 2015. In the interview, Wesley Thompson explained that he works as an Ambulance Paramedic for Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC). During the interview, Thompson explains that he and his partner, Tyler Haskell were working together and responded to a call at 1611 Plymouth, Apartment 204, where it was reported that the patient had been assaulted while trying to break up a fight. Thompson further explained that they responded and found the female patient who he described as an African American Female, who was in her 40?s. Thompson stated that the patient had a laceration on her upper lip, an abrasion on her nose, and pain in her right ankle. Thompson stated that when he and his partner carried the patient out of the building, he observed an African American Male nearby who appeared to be crying. Thompson further described the male as having dreadlocks and wearing a dark colored hoodie. Thompson stated that he asked the male if he was alright and the male muttered something that he couldn't understand. Thompson further explained that the female patient had told them that this male was the individual that was responsible for her injuries. Thompson stated that he asked for law enforcement to respond to their location because the assailant was in proximity to them. Thompson stated that they were in the back of the ambulance treating the patient when his supervisor, Mike Trullinger arrived on the scene. Thompson stated that Trullinger had some contact with the suspect and that they unlocked the back of the ambulance and Trullinger got inside and had a brief conversation with their patient. Thompson stated that at that point they hear what he recognizes as a single gunshot outside of the ambulance. Thompson could not see the of?cers orthe suspect when he heard the gunshot. Thompson stated that they decided to leave the area and that he and Trullinger exited the back of the ambulance. Thompson further explained that he then observed the suspect lying in the grass on his back. Thompson further stated that he observed two of?cers and that a large crowd was gathering. Thompson does not mention seeing any handcuffs orthe suspect being handcuffed. He does indicate that he suspect appears to be lying on his back in the grass. Thompson?s statement also indicates that their supervisor, Mike Trullinger was in the back of the ambulance with him and Tyler Haskell when the shot was fired. Thompson stated that he got into the driver's seat of the ambulance and drove them out of the area. Thompson was asked in the interview with Villella if he heard anything when he got out of the back of the ambulance and Thompson stated that he heard someone from the gathering crowd yelling at the police about the fact that they had just ?killed him". Thompson does not mention handcuffs or any weapons in his interview. It would appear from his statement that Thompson did not get close enough to the subject (Clark) after the shooting to observe whether or not he was handcuffed. No evidence was generated by virtue of this report. (Please see audio recording and attached transcript for additional details of interview). MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 15, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Wesley Thompson (WT) INTERVIEWED BY: Sgt. Twila Villella (TV) Mpls. PD REVIEWED BY: On November 15th 2015, Detective Sergeant Twila Villella interviewed HCMC Paramedic Wesley William Thompson at the PD Homicide Unit in downtown Mpls. TV Alright. (inaudible) Um, what is yourfull name? WT Wesley William Thompson. . TV Okay. (inaudible) and what is a phone number? (phone ringing) TV (on the phone) (long pause) On the yes ma?am. And who are you partners with? Tyler Haskell. And, tell me about this call that you received. Okay so we're on number 150 A number or, TV (inaudible) WT Phone number is-hat?s my cell. TV Okay and where do you work? WT Hennepin County Medical Center in the ambulance department. TV And how long have you worked for them? WT July 2012 puts me at three years this (inaudible) TV Okay and were you on duty today? WT I was. TV what time did you start? WT Ah 153076386 was for a medical miscellaneous which stated that patient had been assaulted while trying to break up a fight that occurred one hour ago. So we were going alone. And the patient was unable to walk very well and had a lot of ankle pain. Phill?2015-648?AO4 Page of 12 323232323232 32323232323232323232 32 Do you know what time you got that call at? Yeah right here ah our (inaudible) time is at 0020. Okay. We were in route at 0020. We arrived within 5 minutes and 25 Okay and what was the address that you (inaudible) And that is on the all this call starts on the Okay. And so we arrived the second floor apartment. Apartment 204. Okay. At 1611 Plymouth. We had parked on the north side of the address. Do you know who called? Ah the patient called. The patient. Yeah. Okay. And you?re parked where? We parked on the north side of Plymouth, ah 1611 Plymouth. Okay. On the north side of the building. On Plymouth facing eastbound. Okay. So we went up to her apartment with our equipment. Um found a woman who was unable to ambulate with (inaudible) person so What does she look like? She?s African American she is Probably a hundred pounds. Okay. Very tiny. And what was her name? Um, (inaudible) those details. That?s okay. I know her last name was Hayes. Mrs. Hayes. Okay. Does she live at that building? She lives at that building in apartment 204. Okay. And was anyone else present in that apartment when you went there? Yeah ah family were sleeping ah she had some kids in the back bedroom I did not count how many kids. We had a probably teenage son in the living room. Was he awake? He was. Okay. Phill-2015-648-A04 Page 2 of 12 ?2?2 ?2?2 2?2?2 Phill?2015?648-A04 (inaudible) come out and let us in. So was he, what was his demeanor like? Oh very pleasant. Um?hm. Do you know his name? i do not. Okay. Do you know what he was dressed like? (sigh) white shirt, jeans, non-descript, he was tall, tall guy. And that?s her son? Orjust (inaudible) (inaudible) seems kind of an odd domestic situation it?s like a son or a Okay Did she tell you what, what happened when She said that she was in the hallway trying to break up a fight. Did she say who it was between? She did not. Okay. Um and that she had hurt her ankle. She had also ah split lip on the upper lip. An abrasion to the nose. And a my partner stated she had a bruise I did not witness the bruise but I never um I did not get that far in my physical with her. So she had a cut lip, a hurt ankle. Which ankle? Right ankle. Okay. And um (inaudible) once so like in the way that you see on TV i had to get underneath her right arm and kind of (inaudible) a crutch so she How old was she would you say? Ah 40?s? 40?s, okay. Urn so you know I?m, I?m helping her (inaudible) we helped her to the bathroom. Helped her to the bathroom, she used the bathroom. Ah helped her get her pants back on. Helped her get out to our stair chair. (inaudible) it's like a wheel chair for getting people down apartment buildings that don?t have a elevators so put her on that. My partner and I got her down to the rig and I think we started, as we were coming out so we had to carry her down. She?s sitting on this chair and we?re physically carrying her down the stairs. Doing all of that and we got outside of the door and a gentleman, probably say not even ten feet away from me who was crying. And is he white? Black? Asian? Ah African American. Okay. Um, (inaudible) Page 3 of 12 he?s in all black clothes. Like a black kind of fuzzy hoodie and jeans. Ah he's got dreads and he?s crying. And I?m like, you know buddy are you okay, do you (inaudible) you alright and (inaudible) muttered something and I didn?t know. TV WT (inaudible) TV Anyone else outside? WT Um, not thatl immediately noticed. TV Okay. WT Um I know that there had been people outside in that area. So that would be to the west of the door exiting on the north edge of the build, the north end of the building. (inaudible) people that let us in, in that first apartment there. That?d be the west side of the north door. Those people in that apartment had to let us in ah on the first part of the call. TV Okay. WT Um but he?s on this side of the, of their stoop if you will. Um and I didn?t think anything of it I?m like okay well he, he didn?t say yes he doesn?t want help. Okay maybe you know (inaudible) whatever so TV (inaudible) one question how old was he? WT (sigh) um I didn?t get a good look at his face um but I do know that was the gentleman that ah later came up to us and was saying that he was the son of this woman (inaudible) the person that as we were walking down she said that?s him that?s the guy that did this to me. And I?m like, that?s the guy right there and she?s like yes. And so, and you know somebody (inaudible) ambulance with that stair chair. Had to get her you know and trying very carefully not to let (inaudible) getting her out to my stretcher. So we get her out there, (inaudible) get her ah from the chair to the stretcher out of the ambulance, setting it down and ah doing that I noticed he started to get closer and I?m like okay so if that?s the guy, I?ve asked for squads now it?s at that point that I call ?em I said I need squads code TV (inaudible) WT TV Cuz she, cuz she said (inaudible) WT She said he?s the guy TV (inaudible) WT Right and so at this point he?s still, he?s still on that stoop (inaudible) you know (inaudible) I need squads (inaudible) code 3. have (inaudible) they?re like do you want to start any help. And I said no but I need more personnel on the scene. TV Okay WT Cuz at this point it?s just us (inaudible) TV Are you asking for police assistance? WT Police TV Okay WT I?m asking for police assistance because we have an assailant for a victim and it?s not Phill-2015-648-A04 obvious that she wants to file any assault charges with us cuz she hasn?t mentioned that at all but we know that, we are now in close proximity to somebody who?s been involved in this we don?t want them therestart picking her up and move her to that stretcher he starts coming closer. And he starts saying I?m her son and she?s like he?s not Page 4 of 12 32 32 32 ?2?2?2?2?2 32:23: 2 Phill-2015-648-A04 my son. And I said okay sir you need to back up. And he?s like I?m her son. I?m like I don?t care who you are you need to back up right now. And she?s saying that?s not her kid? Yeah she said like this isn?t my son I don?t know this guy. And, he starts just kind of calling me names. And I just ignore you know I?m doing (inaudible) (inaudible) Oh he?s calling me a bitch ah fuck you pussy um and then you know he realizes he?s not gonna get a rise out of me and I'm just taking care of her. And um so he said something to her like you know I?ll come down and I?ll see you. You know I'll come down and l?ll, l?ll come down and, and see you. And she?s being really tight lipped about it but it?s to the point where (inaudible) up into the ambulance. And he is now, maybe offthe quarter panel of the back (inaudible), like we are loading right here into the back of the ambulance and he is now at about here so he?s not much closer. Okay. And I?m still trying to communicate with our dispatch like they?re like do you need squads. I?m like yes I still need squads I need them on the red. They?re asking me do you want a supervisor. I'm like no i don?t need a supervisor but I need these squads and I need ?em now. Because now he?s (inaudible) closer and he?s already kinda (inaudible) told him to back up and he?s kind of pacing but he?s not really (inaudible) Do you notice any weapons in his hands? I couldn't because I was mostly focusing on getting her in the ambulance. So he could have had weapons you just (inaudible) Yes he could have (inaudible) Okay. Right so um 80, this is the back. He's Yeah walking Yeah he?s over here kind of pacing back and forth now and I?m loading her up and, and this was supposed to be (inaudible) run so l?m supposed to be taking care of her. So I?m, I?m getting in back and my partner, (inaudible) I got in back closed the door my partner came around, came in (inaudible) and we?re like okay we are safe in here. And we locked up the ambulance. And started taking her blood pressure, talking and my partner ah said that while I was taking the blood pressure he knocked on the back door. And you didn?t hear him knocking (inaudible) Well no cuz i had the stethoscope Okay I?m, I'm listening to the ah (inaudible) So your partner, your partner told that he knocked at the back door? Yeah. And at this point we don?t hear any squads or see any squads on scene cuz we can only see out the back windows. And our supervisor hadn?t arrived ah until very briefly after that cuz I went to do an N. You can?t walk from the back of the ambulance to the front? Page 5 of 12 32323232 32325 52? ?2?2?2 2 ?2?2?2?2 Phill?2015-648-A04 No. You (inaudible) bulkhead so you can?t reach. Okay. And the windows like that big and it?s hidden by a seat so if I?m sitting here, if I?m sitting he?d be on the northern side of the ambulance like I?ve got the patient here I?ve got the back windows there. I got a big captains chair right here so I can?t see a thing outta there. Okay. And unfortunately because it?s dark I can?t even see out the side door so I (inaudible) So it?s pretty dark in that whole area (inaudible) Even when you come out of the apartment? Um when we came out of the apartment area (inaudible) kind of the orange security lighting. Okay. But it?s not, um it?s not it was certainly not easy and think our ambulance, um puts out a lot of light but as all the, just all of the um interior lights (inaudible) all the doors are closed all of our flood lighting turns off so you just have the, the (inaudible) ah the flashing reds and blues. Okay. So, So your partner says that he hears the guy knock on the back door? Um-hm. Okay. We?re just like, we?re just sitting tight now we?re just like we?re just waiting this out. Which is kind of our standard procedure is just you know lock everything down, stay inside the vehicle, wait for help to arrive. Okay. Um supervisor pulls in behind us facing ah that would be westbound but on you know ah on our side of the street so we?re facing correctly as he?s facing the wrong ways but he pulls in behind us (inaudible) Yeah. Okay. Um he came, comes up in conversation with this individual. And who's your supervisor? Mike Trullinger Okay. Do you see him arrive? Um, yes because his vehicle is lit up and ah we could see his lights through our ah rear door. And we can see him get out because the (inaudible) visible through that. Okay Page 6 of 12 WT ?2?2?2 3232? 32' ?2?2?2?2?2 TV WT Phill?2015-648-A04 Ah he has a conversation with the guy outside. Um we?re inside treating her for pain. So I gave her some (inaudible). Can you hear what they?re saying? No. Okay. Um he comes inside the ambulance. Do you have to unlock the doors for him? We, no i gotta back up. Um before he came into our ambulance yes we have to unlock the doors to let him in but ah before he came in we heard on our radio cuz I have a, an earpiece so I put that back in after um after doing her blood pressure and I could hear him order the squads, code 3 or request to them have them like you know where they are or whether they?re still in route code 3 we need the squads here code 3. And so um (inaudible) we ordered them Okay Yeah just to ensure that they had been ordered or I don?t you know at this point we have no way of knowing the call notes cuz they?re up front in the front (inaudible) Yeah um so I?m treating her for pain. We?re trying to adjust her ankle. And we?re still tending to her for the most part so um I know I did not hear what was going on with Mike outside. Um Mike comes inside and or Mike came up and was like you know he comes up, we good to go, wasn?t safe out there now it?s good to go and he comes inside and (inaudible) a very brief conversation (inaudible) ah Mike?s just asking her some questions about who that guy is outside to her. And this guy is saying he?s your son. Is he your son. No he?s not. Did he give you a name, who?s that guy out there to you (inaudible) ask those questions cuz he had (inaudible) interactions with her. Um and keep in mind that when Mike came in we unlocked the doors and then relocked them. Because now this is kind of the police are out there, we?re in here this is our (inaudible) I did not. Okay. Um the only reason I had an idea that they were there is that Mike was now inside. Okay. Whereas he would not have left a strange man outside when we Okay you know what I mean that, that somebody isn?t out there with him. Okay. And so he mentions that um you know like okay we should be good to go it?s at that time we hear a loud (inaudible) urn I?m a combat veteran from Iraq so 1 know that to be gunfire at close proximity. So you hear how many? I just heard one. Page 7 of 12 TV 32323 3 32 232323232 3232 32 Phill?2015-648-A04 One, one shot? One shot. Um Mike Trullinger hit his (inaudible) button I called on the main and I was (inaudible) um and we had all kind of tucked in between the um the most amount of equipment. 80 like between the stretcher and the urn the bench seating. And then I came (inaudible) Mike we need to get outta here. You know (inaudible) we need to get outta here so I took the keys because I worked at North Memorial for seven years so I know my way around that neighborhood pretty well. So I took the keys. Mike came out and out of the side door of the ambulance Mike goes this way, I can now see two officers outside which would be where our backboards are kept. I can see two officers, the assailant who had (inaudible) is now on the ground laying on his back. And I am coming around the front and I can now see a large crowd gathered outside here. And I get in the ambulance and take off code 3 and take a left and head north. And then scoot off to North Memorial where we took the patient. When you see him lying out on the grass is it the same person with the dreadlocks that you (inaudible)? Yeah. Okay and when you say he was crying was it like tears or sobbing Kinda sobbing. Okay. Like I couldn?t see his face (inaudible) because he was looking down, sobbing. So I never got a good look at his face until he was up calling me names. I just kinda, looked over. Did he seem like he was under the influence of narcotics or alcohol? I would guess alcohol. Um everybody there seemed ah like our patient had and (inaudible) um that I could kind of, catch a whiff of and he just kind of his demeanor his kind ofjust the way he was acting. He seemed inebriated and kinda agitated. Okay. You know the (inaudible) going between the, the mad at me and sad with her kinda dynamic itjust seemed kinda like okay this is, this is kind of an um (inaudible) So did you think she was under the influence as well? She?d admitted to having drinks. Okay. Um her decision making her speech, her mannerisms all seemed coherent. So I would call her clinically sober. Okay. Um So when you come out after you heard the shot Um-hm Do you hear before that, before you can hear that shot (inaudible) the police. I couldn't hear anything. Okay. Um but have hearing loss from my lraq so for me that?s not a shock. Urn, And you?re sure that Mike would not have come inside that ambulance Page 8 of 12 ?2?2?2?2?2?2 323 2?2?2?2?2?2?2?2?2?2 Phill-2015-648-AO4 Correct. the police had not been there? Right because he woulda left a strain, he would have left it very unsafe cuz we wouldn?t have been able to get out of the ambulance (inaudible) he was there. Okay. So kind of operating procedure wise it would be (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) cops are here we?re all good Yeah now he was just like I think we should be good to go. Okay. Um, So you hear the pop. One pop. One pop. Come out to see. (inaudible) we all tucked in and then we?re like well now what. Okay well we gotta get up and get outta here. So it was, it was probably a few seconds of us all ducked down in there as far as you know as far as (inaudible) down there but ah you know and then I came out (inaudible) I explained. 80 then when, when you?re coming out, this is your ambulance again. Yeah, um?hm. (inaudible) Um?hm. Side, you come out the side door? Correct. And the cops are over here? Right. (inaudible) and then the (inaudible) guy that you see is lying (inaudible) Yes. On the grass? (inaudible) Okay. Do you see any weapons, around that individual? I did not look long enough. Okay. 1 just looked long enough to realize that he was no longer a threat and I moved on. Okay. And did the officers said anything to you? Page 9 of 12 32 32 3? 32? Phill-ZO?l 5-648-A04 No at that point mean my, my immediate concern was that I mean as we were (inaudible) out here I realized there was a crowd here. We?ve got a patient to safe (inaudible) know that when Mike hits his (inaudible) button that another ambulance is coming for him. (inaudible) for the scene so at that point our standard operating procedure is like I need to now get us out of here. So I did not spend time there. That became Mike?s scene instead of my scene and I?m now in the front and I'm driving because Haskell doesn?t, Haskell?s got like four months here so I?m like (inaudible) I know where I?m going I?m getting us outta hereto North. Okay. Does the woman does she realize that this man had been shot? She never verbalized it. But I would have to assume that she understood that, what that was. You know what I mean? Um-hm Because we all heard it and I mean like the fact that all of us ducked down and then called shots fired there was, I?m saying it into my mic and Mike is saying it into his mic and because he hit help his radio switches over to business mine?s on the main so like there?s two different people calling shots fired. Okay. 80 Mike gets on at the same time as you though? Yeah because at that point we were doing no good in the, our position and then if anything ah (inaudible) we don?t know who shot who we don?t know what shot what but we know that sitting here if anybody does have a gun it makes us a bigger target, we?re a big bright flashing target Ah do you hear the crowd saying anything? Yeah as i came around um they?re yelling about like you just killed him like they?re yelling at police. Okay. Very agitated and I counted well I counted and put it out on our business channel at like as we?re leaving the scene there fifteen to twenty people outside yelling now (inaudible) Did they come from the bar? They The bar side (inaudible) Okay. So you think they came from the bar maybe and not the apartment? Yeah. Yeah no they, the, the crowd that I noticed was definitely coming from the bar side. Did she say that she was afraid of him? (sigh) no she was fairly tight lipped about it all just said like, (inaudible) Yeah she said that?s him and I think she maybe at one point said like cuz he was like saying like I?m gonna come down there and she said likejust stop you know like just and this is like as we?re getting in, closing the doors so like he?s, he?s out there we?re getting in and buttoning up, she?s just kind of (inaudible) determined that she was done with him. Okay. Pretty, do you believe that was her son (inaudible) No, no she told, she said she made it very clear that this was somebody who she didn?t want to be involved with. And that was continuing 1 think twice he said he was her son and she?s like that is not my son. 80, (inaudible) Page 10 of12 325232 :25 ?2?2?2?2 323232323 Okay this is just some guy who really wants to be next to us and will say anything to get next to us. Do you know what number called you, called in called it in? No unfortunately we get um, you know we get so many of our calls from the transit center I couldncouldn?t tell you how her Okay generated. Urn It should be in our call notes though when you pull up that run number you?ll get a full report. (inaudible) ambulance records right? It records video with no sound in the compartment in back. There?s no video recording in the patient compartment for ah patient privacy. There?s a rear camera that catches rear crashes. There are two cameras off the mirror to catch um crashes off the front. Which was their primary goal when they put them in. (inaudible) And then one to see what the driver and passenger are doing while they?re driving. Okay. And none of those record audio. They do record when we have Do you think (inaudible) have recorded the incident? I don?t because if he?s off the back here where I?d say is called the backboard cabinet cuz it?s where we keep our backboards. I mean this is one fish lens you know what I mean you?re get, you would have to catch off this angle I think you know even, even if they were right here you?re catching a pretty just a, a fisheye view of the back of the ambulance. Okay. But the, the good news is um I?ve seen the drives they?re, they?re (inaudible) or they?re disc drives in our ambulance (inaudible) all the supervisors are (inaudible) pull those. Okay. Our ambulance is still sitting at North Memorial we left the keys with Minneapolis PD. Okay. Alright is there anything else you want to add that I haven?t asked you? Um no I can?t think of anything. Um-hm Nothing I can think of. Alright well then we will conclude and they?ll call you if we need any Okay. cleared up, clarified or whatever. Okay? Alright. Right thank you. Phill-2015-648~A04 Page 11 of 12 WT Absolutely. END OF RECORDING. PhilI-2015?648-A04 Page 12 of 12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/66 Report Date: 12l03l2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Review of Transcript of Michael TruIIinger Interview. Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12l08l2015 Approved By: Woodford, Derek (1317 - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) S?hepsis SA Anderson reviewed the transcript of the interview with Michael John Trullinger related to the investigation into the Of?cer Involved Shooting (013) of Jamar Clark. No Evidence was generated by virtue of this report. (Please see narrative report and attached transcript for additional details). Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 Trullinger, Michael John Primary Information Subject Name: Trullinger, Michael John Record Type: Person Bio: A 50 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Informa tion Ethnicity: American Height: 511 Weight: 220 Color: Brown Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State Counth As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota no LICENSE Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Anderson, Micheal (1353 SRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12l03l2015 13:12 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Woodford, Derek (1317 - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12l08l2015 21 :55 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/66 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Rewriting LEO - or . .4 Paid. I, 1 Su?erxisor . . 1 a. I . Date Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Woodford, Derek (1317 I SRO - Homicide! Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrative begins on the folloWing'pa'ge. n5? MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 4 On 11/19/15, SA Anderson was requested to review audio recordings and transcripts of interviews that were conducted by the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) related to the Officer Involved Shooting of Jamar Clark that had occurred on 11/15/2015. SA Anderson reviewed the audio recording and transcript of an interview with Michael Trullinger that was conducted by Sergeant Twila Villella of the MPD. The interview was conducted on November 15th, 2015. In the interview, Trullinger stated that he was working as the Deputy Chief of Operations on 11/15/15 and that he responded to the scene on Plymouth Avenue. Trullinger stated that he responded because the primary crew had requested that the police respond to assist as a possible perpetrator was trying to get into the truck and interfering with their care for the patient. Trullinger stated that he thought officers from the 4?Eh Precinct would probably arrive on the scene before him. Trullinger stated that when he arrived on the scene, he observed a black male with dreadlocks tapping on the back door of the ambulance. Trullinger stated that he approached the subject and asked him what his business was. Trullinger stated that the male told him that it was his mom that was being treated in the rig and that he was upset. Trullinger stated that he told the male to relax and that they would let him know where they were going to take her. Trullinger stated that eventually a squad arrived and that two officers approached. Trullinger stated that he advised one of the officers that this male was the likely perpetrator and had assaulted the woman that the ambulance crew was treating. Trullinger stated that he did observe one of the officers remove his gun from his holster and keep it down by his leg. Trullinger stated that the officers approached the black male and began speaking with him. Trullinger stated that he did hear the male saying, ?why you have your gun out" and that the officer asked the subject if he had any weapons. Trullinger stated that he had not observed the subject with any weapons but that the male did have his hands in his pockets at times. Trullinger also stated that people were starting to come out of the bar and people were asking what was going on. Trullinger explained that he was then getting into the back of the ambulance and he observed one of the officers taking the subject in a type of escort hold. Trullinger stated that he then got into the back of the ambulance and spoke with the patient who verified that he male subject outside was not her son and that he had been the person who assaulted her. Trullinger stated that about that time they heard a single gunshot outside of the ambulance and that they all crouched down for a minute and waited to see if there were any additional shots. Trullinger stated that after a short time he exited the ambulance and he could see the suspect on the ground bleeding from the head and the two officers were facing the crowd. Trullinger stated that he told the ambulance crew to get out of there and he then approached the male subject and could see that he wasn?t breathing. Trullinger stated that he retrieved his medical bag from his car and that he began providing care to the male subject. Trullinger also stated that during all this time they had radioed for an additional ambulance and fire to respond to the scene. Truliinger stated that the second ambulance arrived and they loaded the subject and departed the area fairly quickly. Truliinger stated that a short distance away fire personnel met them and he then exited the rig and they took over assisting the crew with treatment of the subject who was ultimately transported to Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC). Truliinger stated in the interview that when he approached the male subject after the shooting, that the male was lying on his back and there were a pair of handcuffs on the ground on the males? right side. Truliinger stated that the handcuffs were lying in the grass and were not on the subjects wrists. Truliinger stated that he did not really hear the scuffled between the officers and the subject prior to the shot being fired. However, he stated that when exited the ambulance the officers were facing the crowd and that there were people in the crowd yelling, I can't believe you shot him? and ?that?s all you do is shoot black people and were sick of this". Truliinger stated that he heard a female voice say that they shot him and he was wearing handcuffs. However, Truliinger stated that he believes they were trying to handcuff the subject but the cuffs he saw were lying in the grass. No Evidence was generated by virtue of this report. (Please see audio recording and attached transcript for further details of interview). MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November ?I5th 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: HCMC Deputy Chief of INTERVIEWED BY: Minneapolis Police Detective EMS Michael Trullinger (MT) Sgt. Twila Villella (TV) REVIEWED BY: MT So how are you doing? TV Good, do you need anything to drink more than water? MT (inaudible) Ijust had one, if you have coffee that would be great. TV I don?t have any coffee, but water? MT I?m at the point where I?m hitting the wall TV No, I hear ya, do you want pop? MT No I?m good I?ll just have to use the bathroom then. TV That?s fine. All right, so I have to say your name?s Mike. MT Yup, hay I didn?t catch yours, I?m sorry. TV I?m Sargent Twila. MT Twila, nice to meet you. TV Nice meeting you. So its Michael? MT Yeah. een armed I mean. MT Okay, and you?re a Supervisor? And what?s your date of birth? MT TV MT down. TV MT - TV And home address? Page 1 of 17 Ah Deputy Chief, yeah we just changed titles. (radio tones) I?ll just turn that MT And a phone number? MT Ah, I'll give you my work cell number here, just a sec?, (inaudible) (sigh) let?s see here, cell TV Okay. MT That?s my cell and then my land line is? TV And um, do you work MT Hennepin County ah Hennepin EMS. is what were called. A part of H.C.M.C. TV Okay, and how long have you worked there? MT Um, just about nineteen years. TV Okay, and you were the Deputy Chief on MT Yeah on duty. TV on the MT Yes. TV And it?s called the Duty Deputy Chief? MT Yeah when you?re on duty. TV Oh okay. MT Othenlvise our title is Deputy Chief of Operations, so. All that is five dollars, will get you a beer in a bar somewhere. TV So you were on duty on the 14th or MT Overnights, so I started at 6:30 on the 14th and I?ll be done, hopefully at 6:30 this morning. TV So 1830 hours? MT Yeah, that?s when I started my shift. TV Okay, and what is your typical duties? MT Um, we supervise the operations for the entire shift, um, anywhere up to include almost 40 medics, you know cuz there?s 20 some trucks. Um, make the schedule, handle any personnel issues, and respond to certain calls like fire scenes, larger calls for squads. (inaudible) TV all those type of calls? MT Yup, yup. Phill?2015-648?A06 Page 2 of 17 PhilI-2015?648-A06 So tell me about earlier this morning then on the Well I was, pertaining to this particular call? Yes. Um, I was in my office and I overheard one of our trucks asking for a Do you know what truck? Ah, yes that would be 419. Asking for a squad. Code three, that they were code 4 inside their truck but that the suspect in an assault was trying to gain access to the ambulance and interfering, basically interfering with their care. Did she log they were (inaudible) They were at the back side of the truck. I Oh in the ambulance? Yaeh. Was in front of the residence, I believe it was 1611 Plymouth Avenue North, 1 can look at Yeah. but that?s, they were on a call, an assault call, I believe the squad had been there earlier cuz that and they always go on assaults but then cleared because they had, a gal had an ankle injury and had been hit in the face, um and they ah, had hauled her down to the ambulance with a stair chair and got her in the ambulance and he came out and was trying to get into, gain access, wanting to know where she was going and so they called. First squad code 3 but there code 4, they didn?t do an E-Help, what we call an E-Help for things like, hay we need all the squads we can right now. So i don?t know about that though because, you know they wanted a squad code 3, Where, where were you coming from? Down town. Okay. Right at our quarters at (:3th and Park there. Okay. Page 3 of 17 Phill-2015-648-A06 So, this thing and, and just the tone in her voice, and having these guys and then the ones a pretty brand new Paramedic, and then the other one?s newer. Yeah. Um, just the tone in their voice, so I kept going, I figured you know I'll probably get canceled cuz the squads will beat me there if there at precinct 4. Um, got up there, just the rig was there and I saw a gentleman at the back door (inaudible). They were facing east on Plymouth, was heading west I went around and parked facing away from them. I asked them on the radio, is this the guy you?re talking about? and there voice was very low and I?m like okay, they said Yes that?s the guy and he was the, a suspect in this assault. I said all rightthe back door? Yeah I saw him at the back door. Okay. He was looking in and kinda? tapping on the door or doing whatever and ah, and Describe what he looks like? Ah, he was a male, ah black male, with uh, I don?t know what they call it, like short dreads you Short dreads, okay. Not like really short but you know down to here, like kinda? natural or Yeah. I don?t know, I?m not a fashion kinda? guy I don?t know what you call that kind of hair style. Ah, he was wearing kind of a darker outerjacket with possibly a dark red shirt and the, the parts of him tapping on the window and looking in will be on the camera. Oh okay. Because he was right behind it. Um so i got his attention and just tried to distract him, and I said Sir what?s your business? and he goes Well that?s my mom in there. and I said Well what do you want? and he goes i want to know where she?s going? I said Well why don?t you stand over here, I kinda put myself between him and the truck and I just said Well if you need to know where she?s going we?ll let you knowjust relax. And then he, he stepped up on to the grass and kinda put his hands up, and I mean just forcefully making himself sound like he was crying. He goes That my mom man, (inaudible) and I?m upset. Page 4 of 17 (cell phone ringingPhill?2015?648?A06 I said Sorry about this. Not a problem. (on the phone) Detective Villella? Yes. Yup. She is. Oh. Okay? Yes. Can you tec?, can you text me her her name or what room she?s in? Can you do that? That would work and be helpful. Yeah, I?d probably would get there may be in the next 45 minutes or so. Okay? Okay. All right thank you. Bye, bye. 80 you think he?s trying to make himself like he?s crying? Yeah it did seem genuine to me. But anyways, so said it?ll be okay, I said just wait here and about that time, that?s when the squad, that was the first in squad, they responded and parked on the other side of my vehicle, so facing, (inaudible) my vehicle Okay. I don?t know how, I can?t quite tell how close they were, got out and the Officer started approaching and I walked up to one of the Officers, and l?m sorry I don?t know them, like their name, and just said, this, My crew believes this is the suspect in this assault and he?s trying to gain access, can you deal with him I gotta' check on my crew? And he said Yeah. So the three of us, you know the Officers and were kinda walking towards him and I did notice that the Officer I talked to, withdrew his weapon and held it down. Okay. Like low by a knee. Okay was it which Officer was that? (sigh) you know I wana' say he was maybe the taller one and either lighter hair or less hair or shaved or something, he looked like, I can?t remember. My focus again was on my crew. I?m trying to make sure What was he white, Asian, He was white. Okay. Pretty sure he was the white Officer. Where they both officers white? Cuz I, l, I don?t know. Well I, you Page 5 of 17 Phill?2015-648-A06 Okay. l, dealt primarily with the one. Okay. With him as he walked up I could hear the induvial, the suspect say Why you have your gun out? and he or first, I?m sorry, first the Officer said Do you have any weapons on you? and the guy said No man. Why do you have your gun out? Why do you have your gun out? and you could see him you know starting to get up, you know kina uppity or whatever. I said Do you got this? I?m going to go check on my crew. And they said Yup.. And as was walking I could tell that this guy was getting verbal and they were people yelling stuff, you know there was Do you know what people were yelling? I could, I you know, there was generally like What?s going on? What?s going on? Okay were they from the apartments? Yeah the apartments. Okay. There were people coming out of the Elks and lining that, were already out, out on the street and the Elks kinda just you know, shuffling around, they weren?t How many people were out there do you think? had to estimate, the Elks, there was probably 6 to 10 and the apartments there was quite a number of people out there. Okay. (inaudible) Did he seem like he?s under the influence of alcohol or anything? Not to me but I didn?t get close enough to smell his breath. My main thing was just to put him between me and the crew. Could you see any weaponssometimes had his hands in his shirt or hands in his pockets. Okay. Ahm, so while I was walking I went to the side door of my rig. The patients side entry door we call it, and as was getting in I could tell that they were tus?, I don?t Page 6 of 17 MT MT MT MT MT Phill-2015-648-A06 know what the proper word for it is, they were trying to get control of him and I thought I saw one of the officers like just come over here, like they were, you know, what we call an escort hold. Yup. Ah something that, again that was in my periphery. Ijumped in the truck, shut the door and said How are we doing in here guys? and they said Yup were getting ready to go. and I asked the patient, This man is claiming to be your son? and I knew it wasn?t cuz obviously to, they were both to young. (inaudible) Is this the man that hit you? Yes. I said Is this his name because he gave me some kind of name like Darrius or something like that and she said No, his name is blah?blah-blah. and I said And you?re sure that?s the man? Yeah. Do you remember what the name is? No you?d have to ask her, I, I, want to say it started with a like Tyrious or something like that. My main goal here was to assess, can we get this truck out of here. Okay. With all these people. It was at that, somewhere about that time we heard a single very loud gun shot. The medics and crouched down around the patient, kinda waiting to see if there is any more shots, there wasn?t. And we didn?t know pretty much voiced, we announced over the radio shots fired. And forgot to tell you this to, during when first pulled up, since there was no squad they said, re- order the squad code 3, I didn?t, I didn?t, well I mean it wasn?t an E?Help but keep them coming, we need them coming. Had you seen that he was there, by the ambulance? Yeah. Okay. So, so now were in the truck, we waited no shots, kinda checked ourselves, we gotta get out of here and were trying to get up off the floor and look out the door, kinda open the door slowly, I could see two officers facing the crowd and the ah suspect on the ground bleeding from his head. I said you guys get out of here. They said they were going to transport her to North. I said that?s fine go, go get out. Went up to the gentleman that was on the ground. I could see that he wasn?t breathing. I checked he had a pulse. A curated pulse. Ran to my truck got my ainrvay bag and my trauma bag. Came back, opened my kit. Started to breath for him. Bag valve him. And then I at some point put ah a large trauma dressing on his head. To kinda just cover his wound. Called for a truck right away during this is all concurrent. Called for a truck. Called for fire. Um we had Page 7 of 17 MT MT MT MT Phill?2015-648?A06 one with a GSW to the head, we had a pulse, but wasn?t breathing. And he but when did the shots fired we also yelled E-Help at that time (inaudible) look now we got others (inaudible) And you only heard the one shot? Yes the one shot, yup. And so the victim had looking up at me had a gunshot wound which appeared to me to be on the, i gotta think of his orientation here, the left side of his, of his head in the temple area, with a pressure, what we call an over pressure, he had a protruding eyeball on that side also on the left side for a protruding like flesh and eyeball, he was not breathing but he had a pulse. When the crew arrived we, I said were quickly get him out of here. We quickly kinda did a quick assessment. We didn?t find any weapon at that time, but we weren?t necessarily patting him down for weapons, we were getting him on the stretcher to get him in the ambulance cuz? the crowd at this point was quite significant. Ah realized that he no longer had a palpable pulse. Got him in the truck. Started CPR on and we moved a couple blocks down from the scene to get away from the scene. And fire couldn?t get to us there so were moving to a place where the fire engine can get there so they can help out. Put one of the mechanical CPR device. At that point the firejumped inknew that was going to be needed. Excuse me. Knew I was going to be needed with all the aftermath stuff. Ahm and they transported to Hennepin with at least one Police Officer and two Fire Fighters inside from Station 4. And that?s (inaudible) Hennepin County Medical Center? Yeah he went to HCMC. Fire responded. So when the police arrived and you told them that this (inaudible) who we believe is the (inaudible) assaulted her and you asked that they deal with him, and they said yeah we got this. You noticed one officer with their gun out or both officers? As they were walking, the one officer that i talked to, and told him, the other officer was kind of off in that periphery. And I was focused on this guy telling him the first officer, he just unsnapped or whatever they do with those holsters, I don't know if its swivel now a days, (inaudible) he set it Okay. And, and he just said do you have any weapons? and that?s when he was starting to address the suspect. And the guy's started like yelling something at him and why do you have a gun out (inaudible) I don?t really know what the argument was about, I was more focused on my crew. Page 8 of 17 Right but the, this, the guy that ended up getting shot, he noticed that the officer had his gun Yes. and he?s asking him why it?s out? Yes. Okay. And that officer, you said is a ca? ah white male? i believe he was white, i believe he had eitherthin blond or no (inaudible) he didn?t look like he had a lot of hair (inaudible) Tall or short? Ahm he stood at least my height. And how tall are you? I?m 5?11. Okay, and his build. Pretty, pretty well built i think. Like I wouldn?t call him big but not slender. Okay. i guess medium (inaudible) medium but bigger than me. Any facial hair? Not that I recall. But he was in Minneapolis uniform? Yeah he was a Minneapolis Police Officer. Okay. Then it was very obvious that they were Police? Yes (inaudible) Cuz they arrived in a marked squad? Yeah a marked, I believe that it was one of the, like the, Ford Explorer. Did they have their lights on and stuff? When they pulled up, yeah. Okay. i don?t know if they shut you know, a lot of times they activate, put it in park they shut down some of the lights. I had all of the lights on, on my rig. Okay, is your rig, um, videotaped? Page 9 of 17 MT MT MT MT MT MT Phili-2015?648-A06 Only when you put it in reverse. And it doesn?t record it?s just so you can back up. Do you think where he was found lying, do you think that would (inaudible) captured Our ambulance camera may have and I?ve already told the investigators? at the scene that (inaudible) Chief that handles our fleet that can download that. Okay. He?s working on that angle. It certainly caught him, cuz its always on, it?s notjust a thing that we turn on and off. Its always recording, so when he was at the back of the ambulance looking in and doing all that, he will be on that. Its where this incident happened it?s going to be right at the periphery of the coverage depending on where he was standing so. I think it?s you know a good idea that they pull that cuz it may have captured some of it. It certainly should have captured the Officer coming up to me and me talking to the Officer somewhat, it depends on how far down there angle is. We use to have them facing farther back and we angled them farther down now cuz they use them now for backing. But they do catch some of that periphery so. Okay. And so basically you know that the officers are having a conversation with him. They were having How long do you think you were inside that ambulance before the, you heard the shot? Some, I would, I would, use the mark about 30 seconds. Cuz it was quickly asking her who this guy was. 30 seconds to a minute I guess you could say. Because it was (inaudible) it was brief enough that all I got from her, or wanted to hear, cuz I wanted to get my crew out of there was is this the guy that assaulted you which she affirmed. Is he your son, no he?s not. And then she tried to tell me what his name was and it didn?t match the name he was giving me. And trying to do, just do the verbal judo thing when was out there with him i was like sir you should stand over here. If we need to talk to you, doing whatever to calm him down so that the police could just take over at that point. Was he listening to you? He listened to me in the sense that he Okay man but that?s my mom and that?s when he did the, the whole crying episode Okay. Page 10 off? was ag?, you, you could tell he was still agitated about something and, and this is very common when it, we go on calls like this all the time or (inaudible) show up and try and be concerned. Yeah. And you could tell right away by the reaction to the patients that they see them right away, that, that, that no that's not the case. (inaudible) in the ambulance, they had the ambulance locked so. Now did you notice any one that was outside that might even be family or friends of (inaudible) No. No one yelling out his name No. go away or? Not that I recall. Okay. The premise (inaudible) this call started again was an assault. And apparently there was a gathering. This gal either was assaulted or got caught up in an, in an assault that was happening or a fight and that she was assaulted. Had some sort of ankle injury, they actually had to use a stair chair to take her down all these stairs to get her down to the ambulance. And then she had bloody, I could see she had like a swollen nose and some blood around her nose. Okay. This gentleman?s shirt was a darker red but it appeared to me that it may or may not have had some, you know at least possibility that there?s blood over the design that was on the red shirt. It?s hard to tell in that kind of light cuz blood looks black when it starts to dry. lt?s, it?s kind of a, it doesn?t look like necessarily red so. (inaudible) that shot happened, did the woman say oh my god or what was that or anything? Ah, we were all kinda? yelling so I don?t know if she said something we (inaudible) hit the floor and kinda? trying to cover her to. And got on the radio right away and, and (inaudible) Yeah. Page110f17 MT MT 80 weird (inaudible) shots fired. And when said E~Help overthe radio. Were supposed to push our E?Help button but I was laying down on the floor so I couldn?t really reach it. Did you hear a scuffle or anything like that outside? Um mostly it was verbal. Um, what I did notice when I came back out to the patient was there was a pair of handcuffs near the patient on the ground that were (cell phone ringingPhil I-201 (on the phone) Yes. have no idea. (inaudible) and the woman is going to be admitted to the hospital, she will not be (inaudible) Okay. (inaudible) Bye. A lot of different peeple doing different things and everyone?s checking in so sorry about that. understand. Um so you noticed a pair of handcuffs. Yeah. And where were they? Ah they would have been to the patients right. Up in the grass near him. They weren?t on his wrists? No. Okay. So (inaudible) his right hand? They were kinda? lying about, yeah like where his hip ortorso would be in the grass. Okay, but you didn?t hear any fighting with the officers could hear yelling, but in a rig (inaudible) it?s more of a muffled sound. Okay. But as was getting in the rig, again that?s when they first approached him and was saying that whole exchange about the police asking if he had weapons and there like why do you got your gun out and then there was some sort of other exchange you know (inaudible) call it arguing I guess or is some kind of exchange where the patient was being loud. Then at, once I shut the door of the truck then it pretty much (inaudible) And then when you heard the shot, then you went out, back outside you didn?t see any one falling or anything? Page 12 MT MT MT MT MT MT Phill?2015?648?A06 No the, cuz we (inaudible) it was probably a good 5 or 10 seconds of us laying on the floor kinda? waiting to see if there was going to be more shots. Calling it in. then I kinda? made my way over to this little window that?s on our side door and tried to look out before would open the door and i saw the two officers, at least two officers, I don't know if they were the same ones, because by now I think more Police Officers were coming but. There was two officers facing the crowd up at the apartments on the ah south side of the Plymouth there. And then the individual lying in the grass. Okay. Were people yelling anything at the officers? Oh yes. All kind of, i can?t believe you shot him, I can believe you shot him. People were already, you know they were upset. (inaudible) he was a person of color so yelling that?s all you do is shoot black people and were sick of this and this, of course after our truck left then the crowd really amped up and someone in the crowd made it, made a statement like a female voice yelled out you shot him and he was wearing handcuffs. think what they probably saw was they were attempting to handcuff him but the handcuffs I saw were in the Okay. I don?t, i don?t know that the officer would have had time to take handcuffs off and why they would um so I don?t know if they were attempting to cuff him when this happened. Just based on my experiences with the police, there pretty fast about doing that so something happened because those handcuffs were laying in the grass, they were not on him. At least when I saw him he did not have them on his wrists, they were laying on the ground. And the crowd was yeah very well (inaudible) he after our ambulance left they were very (inaudible) they all just started coming of the apartments and the elks and they were all yelling, it was pretty chaotic. Okay, what was the run number? (sigh) ah, our run number was 15076386. And for him? ah I think, let?s see, l?d have to check and see if they attached to the same, the same one or not. Okay. Can I do that real quick, do you want me to? You know what maybe I should just call them. don?t want to tie up the radio here. I will just call our dispatch here real quick for ya if that?s okay. I (inaudible) maybe (inaudible) may not be because they got it as a shooting and where as ours was an assault so. Page 13 of 17 Phill?2015-648?A06 (on the phone) Hay Bobby this is Mike, hay on this call on Plymouth the call that 443 was assigned for the person with the GSW, did that have a separate run number? I think it did cuz there?s was listed as a shooting. Right. Got it. Thank you. Bye. Yeah they, they were given a different number once it became a shooting instead of part of the E-Help so (inaudible) have this right, so it would be there?s ah the second truck would have been 15076391 cuz the first one was 6386 right, that?s what i told you? Yes. Okay. Can you tell me his name? He the suspect? I want to say it was something like Darrius cuz i introduced myself as Mike, I?m Mike l?m the Deputy Chief I?m gonna' help ya but you got to stay back from the ambulance. It was Darrius or some form of that (inaudible) I really, he wasn?t real forthcoming he was kinda? like, what, what, what, what, what is your name again? Oh it?s this. That?s my mom man. l?m like ok well you know. i was just using what we call Verbal Judo Tactics to kind of Yeah. and to get him away from our rig. i won?t, I won?t lie to ya I?ll probably get lots of crap because I got out of the car, and this guy could have been armed I mean. don?t know but I just wanted to get him away from our crew. But you didn?t see anything on him though? I didn?t see anything but he had, he was wearing an outerjacket the baggy clothes. Pockets and stuff? Well yeah cuz he?s got them down here so he?s got to use one hand to hold them up. And he was yeah he was in and out of his under the coat a few times and then his hands would be up here, i was just kinda? hoping though. Yeah. Keeping an on him. Okay. Is there anything else that you wanted to tell me that I haven?t asked ya? I don?t know, let?s see. Uh, you know right now can?t think anything that?s pertinent. (inaudible) Page 14 of 17 was, I am told that they, your crime scene people were putting it on a flatbed and bringing it to where ever they process vehicles. Okay. And our Deputy Chief that handles the videos is aware that he was going to call (inaudible) Okay. And find out what he, where they needed him to download that (inaudible) Okay so you guys just can?t do it on a site, you actually need Yeah we have proprietary software that unless they could download it onto a laptop and bring it, I don?t know the old ones were easy. You pulled out a hard drive orjust hooked up a wire and they. these are Fire Tech. Okay. But they were really good (inaudible) Do you have his phone number? (inaudible) And he?s that video guy right? Yeah he?s the Deputy Chief also and, see we?ve got admin duties and we have focuses like I?ve actually the PIO. Okay And then I do education (inaudible) and anything related to the trucks so. He?s the Deputy Chief that?s the go to guy. Urn let me get you his information. There it is. So you can reach him on his mobile it ah__ Okay. And his name again? Chad Dotzler All right. Soto make sure I understand you, you think maybe you were in the ambulance with your crew and that patient for maybe 30 seconds? To a minute. 80 a minute. It wasn?t real long. Okay. Before that and then this whatever happened, happened pretty fast. Page 15 Phill-2015-648-A06 Okay. Did it appear that the guy when was outside (inaudible) when he?s saying why do you have your gun out? I would call that a level of agitation. Cuz if it?s you know again, I?ve been doing this a long time. If this was a legitimate concern for the patient, he would say I?m just waiting to, you know but. I don?t know what he, and I didn?t see whatever gesture he did to the officer and that?s pretty common practice (inaudible) Yeah. Were use to being around that. So any, and they explained to him, do you have any weapons, that was one of the first things they asked. And I don?t know did this because he put hand in, didn't see that part cuz at that point I was angling off to walk over to the ambulance so. How long do you think you had that conversation with him Myself? Yeah. Ah, from the time arrived, I don?t know what the printout says but I was with him a good minute or two before the first squad got there, (inaudible) at least a minute. All right. And you were explaining to him banging on Yeah I?m just basically trying to move him away from the ambulance and tell him its hay if you, if that?s your biggest concern, we?ll let you know, and I knew that well yeah I?m not going to tell him nothing. But if you tell him that he?s Yeah. Yup. Just to (inaudible) Yeah that?s when he stepped up on the curb to the boulevard there. Okay. The shoulder whatever. Cuz when you first seen him, he He was right at the back door of the ambulance. Okay. Looking in? Yup. Okay. Page 16 oft? Looking in and pacing or, and that?s when I say sir, and he kinda? turns around, I said what?s your business here, he says that?s my mom and I?m like why don?t you step and I went into that whole thing. was told, (inaudible) trying to see what he was doing, (inaudible) and always kept a distance probably between you and me, that far away from him, I never got really close to him. Okay. And then he hopped up on the boulevard. Yeah, and that?s when he was (inaudible) you know, after that I don?t know if that camera will catch what happened or not. Okay. Cuz don't know if they brought him back towards the street or not. Ah cuz he was laying on the strip of grass that?s the boulevard before the sidewalk when he Yeah. lfound him. (inaudible) All right. Well I will call you if] need clarification. Thank you for coming in appreciate it. Any time. I was glad to hear that the officers okay. The medics okay and the patients okay. Well yeah. Scary, scary situation. Thank you again. So what I will probably need is to get back up to the scene, I can call my, one of my guys and bring me up there if you don?t (end of recording) Phill-2015?648-A06 Page 17 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/67 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Primary Information Description: Review of Transcript of Tyler Lupkes Interview. Reporting LEO: Anderson, Micheal (1353 I SRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/08/2015 Approved By: Woodford, Derek (1317 ISRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) SynOpsis SA Anderson reviewed the transcript of the interview with Tyler John Lupkes related to the investigation into the Officer Involved Shooting (OIS) of Jamar Clark. No Evidence was generated by virtue of this report. (Please see narrative report and attached transcript for additional details). Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Lupkes, Tyler John Primary Informa tion Subject Name: Lupkes, Tyler John Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 509 Weight: 210 Color: Hazel Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Identifications Elm? Number aw game?m DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Anderson, Micheal (1353 SRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12/03/2015 13:12 Last Update Operator: Woodford, Derek (1317 SRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/08/2015 21 :53 Reporting EEO . . Date Supervisor - - Date Anderson, Micheal (1353 SRO - Woodford, Derek (1317 SRO - Homicide] Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) WMONWQHEWREHENSION - Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of2 On 11/19/15, SA Anderson was requested to review audio recordings and transcripts of interviews that were conducted by the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) related to the Officer involved Shooting (OIS) of Jamar Clark that had occurred on 11/15/2015. SA Anderson reviewed the audio recording and transcript of an interview with Tyler Lupkes that was conducted by Sergeant Twila Villella of the MPD. The interview was conducted on November 15th, 2015. in the interview, Lupke explained that works for HCMC and that he had responded to the shooting call. Lupkes explained that his partner on the crew at the time of the incident was Mari Hill. Lupkes stated that when he arrived, he found his supervisor (Michael Trullinger) providing aid to the male patient. Lupkes stated that the male (Clark) was lying in the grassy area between the street and the sidewalk. Lupkes stated that he asked an officer that was nearby if the subject had been searched and he was advised that he had been patted down and that no weapons had been found. Lupkes stated that he observed a pair of silver handcuffs lying on the ground next to the patient. Lupkes stated that at some point he picked the handcuffs up by the "hinged area" and moved them off to the side as they were going to put the patient on their stretcher. Lupkes stated that he and his partner ultimately transported the patient to the Hennepin County Medical Center for treatment of his injuries. No evidence was generated by virtue of this report. (Please see audio recording of interview and attached transcript for additional details). MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 15, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Paramedic Tyler Lupkes (TL) INTERVIEWED BY: Sgt. Twila Villelia (TV) PD REVIEWED BY: On November 15th 2015, PD Detective John Lupkes (static) TV So why don?t we just start for the record what is your full name? TL Ah (inaudible) TV TL TV (inaudible) (static) TL (inaudible) TV And your home address? TV Is that a house or apartment? TL Ah it?s a house. TV And a phone number? TL -inaudible). TV And where do you currently work? TL Ah Hennepin County Medical Center TV (inaudible) TL (inaudible) TV (inaudible)? TL Yes (inaudible) TV And what time did you start your shift? TL (inaudible) TV On the TL Correct. Page 1 of 8 gt Twila Villelia interviewed HCMC Paramedic Tyler at the PD Homicide Unit in downtown Mpls. Phill?2015-648-A09 And um did you have an opportunity or I shouldn?t ask (inaudible) did you have notification to go to the 4th precinct on a medical? (inaudible) Is there anything that you knew leading up to going up there on the medical did you hear (inaudible)? Um (inaudible) that I heard was we had a, a crew in that area already on a medical call. Okay and was it a Hennepin County crew or North Memorial? It was Hennepin County (inaudible) And what were what kinda medical (inaudible) l, I don?t know what type of (inaudible) So do, okay (inaudible) Sure um we were at ah Fire Station 4 I think it?s Fire Station 4 um just that?s where we were assigned. Okay. Overheard some radio traffic (inaudible) um because the assailant from the call that they were assigned (inaudible) the ambulance. Okay do you know what kinda call they were assigned? I?m going to assume it was an, something (inaudible) an assault or something. Okay. Um but I did not have the opportunity to read any of the, the call out information. And where did you hear it though on the radio? (inaudible) where, what was their location? Um I, I don?t think at the time I didn?t have the computer in front of me so I didn?t know their location when they were asking for, police. Okay. So they weren?t asking for, more assistance from EMS they were asking for police Correct. them because the suspect showed up on scene where they were providing medical treatment is Correct. Okay. And then what did you hear? Um at that time our supervisor um also responded and I heard him on the air. Um (inaudible) And who?s your supervisor? Ah Mike Trullinger. Can you spell his last name? And that?s your supervisor? Correct. Okay. And he said he was gonna (inaudible) okay and do you know what crew was out there? The names of those people? Page 2 of 8 Phiil-2015-648?A09 Um, Wes Thompson and Tyler Haskell. (inaudible) I think it?s Okay To the best of my knowledge. And then when the supervisor arrived on scene (inaudible) the crew (inaudible) the assailant was outside the truck evidently when he showed up um he could see the person outside (inaudible) urn so then he the supervisor (inaudible) over the radio um to verify that squads are responding emergently because he was, he was there by himself. Okay. And no police were there yet. Alright and do you, but you don?t know the exact location? Okay. Did he say if that individual had any weapons? Urn not that I heard over the radio. Okay. And who is your partner today? Mari Hill, Mari Hill? Correct. Okay. And what did you guys (inaudible) then? Um i believe our dispatch (inaudible) the nature of the call to a paramedic needs help, to get officers there faster. And they (inaudible)? Yes. Okay. Then that?s when we were dispatched as the second ambulance. Which is routine when we have a paramedic needs Okay. second ambulance gets dispatched. That's routine? Um-hm. So not necessarily that anyone was injured? No. Okay. So you were the second ambulance dispatched. (inaudible) Okay. Um and then we heard the crew that was inside the ambulance that was already there um they voiced over the radio ah two or three times that they heard shots fired. Did they say who the sh, who was doing the shooting? No. Page 3 of 8 Phill-2015-648-A09 And where were you at then were you already arriving (inaudible) Um no we were still responding. Okay. So what, did they say they?re leaving that location or do they say? Yeah they said that they were going to be leaving the scene. And did you guys still respond up there? Yes. Okay. And why did you continue responding when you knew they were leaving? Um because eh, as we were responding we were upgraded to a shooting call. Um once it was confirmed that there was a victim. And i believe that that was per our supervisor who, who remained on scene after the other crew left. And where is he at? i honestly don?t know where he?s at right now. Okay. So it?s up, upgraded to a shooting call. Um-hm. So then you guys are going in for that shooting. Correct. (inaudible) lights and siren. Correct. And where are you responding? Um we left Fire Station 4 which is at um Lyndale and Plymouth pretty much. Um so we went down Plymouth from Okay. the west and came to the scene (inaudible) Okay and the scene was at? i think 1600 Of Plymouth? Plymouth. Okay. And when you arrived there what did you see? Um lot of squad cars. A lot of people out on the sidewalks. Um our supervisor was flagging us down with his flashlight as to where he was at with the patient. Um on the south side of the road. Was he by himself? Yes. Okay. And he was with the patient? Yes. (inaudible) Was there any officers with him? Um there were several officers in the general area kind of forming a perimeter it looked like around (inaudible). Page 4 of 8 Phill?2015-648?A09 Alright and then when you get there what do you see? Um so um our supervisor was administering care to the patient. Um they were in the grassy area between the sidewalk and the street. Um he had his ah trauma bag out and a (inaudible) mask assisting ventilations. Um, and then yeah when we, when we got out our supervisor informed us that um he had a weak pulse and that he was sporadically trying to breath on his own. Um so at that time we just got ready to get him out of the scene. Okay. Do you notice any guns neat thethe officers that was there asked us if he could provide any assistance other than scene security and I told him that we didn?t need anything from him other than just keeping did ask the same officer if this gentleman had been searched. Um cuz as we were responding to the scene we were made aware by our dispatch that it was an you know officer involved shooting just to give us a heads up on the way in. Um and they had not searched him yet so a couple officers did do a quick pat down um and we didn?t find anything on him. Okay. There were, there were a pair of silver handcuffs laying in the grass next to him and I moved those off to the side as we were preparing to ah move him onto our stretcher. Did you notice any discharge casings in the area? No I didn?t. Okay. What did the individual look like? A, black male mid?twenties ah he was wearing a red t-shirt and a blackjacket. He had blood on his face. And where was his injury? Um the best I could tell was somewhere on the top of his face. I, didn?t get close enough to see exactly where the (inaudible) Somewhere on his face? (inaudible) When the first ambulance was out there dealing with the medical there you don?t know specifically what that medical was about? No I don?t. But they had, asked for assistance by um to have another squad or squads show up Correct. Because the suspect had, returned. Correct. And was (inaudible) on the ambulance. Um I didn?t hear if he was knocking on the doors Okay. all I, I recall them asking for police code 3 and that they were code 4 at the time meaning they were safe. Um but that the assailant had returned. Page 5 of 8 Phil l?201 5-648-A09 Is there anything else that I haven't asked you that you think might be important for this investigation? Not at this, not at this time (inaudible) Did you notice any alcohol, smell or anything like that? (inaudible), no. No? Um again was, my partner she was the attending paramedic. I was driving so I was just kind of assisting her with whatever she needed. Okay. So I didn?t have a lot of, really close patient contact. Alright. And this is a good number to reach you at then That?s my cell phone Okay. the only phone (inaudible) What is a work phone number? (inaudible), I think there?s a landline on there so but ah, that? number goes directly to the supervisor. Okay. Was it a (inaudible) area did you notice? (inaudible) Or was it (inaudible) Average, I would think and from my experiences I mean on the streets at that hour I, um I can?t say that was struggling to see anything that it was too dark or anything. Um i never had my flashlight out to see the scene or anything so. Okay and so where did you transport this male then? Ah I?m sorry what was that question again? Ah where was the male transported to? He was transported to Hennepin County Medical Center. Okay. And is, is this the male that you believe was injured by the police officer? To the best of my knowledge. (inaudible) I, I don?t know Okay. Who, who shot him. Okay. Um, do you remember what your run number was for this call? I, don?t it might be on my (inaudible) Okay, that?s alright (inaudible) (inaudible) Now, do you have video? Did, does your urn ambulance videotape? Page 6 of 8 TL Yeah the ambulance?s do video record ah front and rear. TV Inside or outside or? TL Um front outside and inside and rear outside. TV And would that be running on all the time? is there something that you (inaudible) to turn it on? TL No it, it should be constantly recording. TV So the other ambulance would have been recording as well? TL Correct. TV But not on the sides just front (inaudible) TL Um the front does have a hundred and sixty degree view or something so it?s pretty much everything out front but no nothing directly (inaudible) TV Okay. And behind is just behind TL Yeah it?s a it's a camera mounted above our rear doors. TV Okay. TL 80 it looks kind of down and out. it?s mostly used for backup camera um but it is on recording all the time. TV So that one side door is not recorded? TL Correct, no it?s not. TV And um do you know how we could go about obtaining the videos? TL Um contacting the duty supervisor at that number. TV Okay. TL I actually have their cell phone number if you?d like that. TV (inaudible) write it on there for me please. (pause) TV So how long do you think you were at this scene before you, from the time you arrived to the time you left? TL Um three to seven minutes. i don?t think we were there um too long. We did after we got the patient in the truck (inaudible) 424 at the end (inaudible) TV Yeah TL Okay um after we did load the patient into the truck we did move a few blocks down Plymouth so that we could do some treatments before we started transporting. Wejust wanted to get out of the immediate scene because of the (inaudible) TV Okay. So any more family members, friends show up of, ofthe, of this individual? TL Ah nobody that was contacted by. TV Okay. So you did notice a pair of handcuffs laying on the ground though? TL Yes. TV Okay. And you had kicked them to the side or did you pick 'em up and move ?em? TL Um I think I, grasped the hinge area and moved them. Phill-20?15?648?A09 Page 7 of 8 when you?re describing the individual lying on the ground was he in the street? On the, grassy (inaudible) He was in the grassy area but the (inaudible) area was in the street (inaudible) Okay. i guess ah I don?t have any further questions for you. Okay. Anything else you can think you could add? Not right now, l?m sure (inaudible) think of something. Okay. And do you know who um the other people were are on that other crew? Um I think was it Wes and (inaudible) Oh that?s right Wes and Tyler. (inaudible) . Yeah, okay yeah. They should be (inaudible) ah their truck number was 419 that i do know and last i knew they were up at North Memorial. Okay. Alright well thank you. Alright. END OF RECORDING. PhiIl-2015-648-A09 Page 8 of 8 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/68 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquire Squad 424 sqaud video (expanded) Occurrence From: 12/03/2015 12:15 Occurrence To: 12/03/2015 12:15 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/04/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis SA Olson picked up additional squad video for MPLS PD squad 424. Item 68.1 (DVD disc) acquired by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 $0 5TH ST Primary information Address: 350 50 5TH ST #108 Minneapolis City Hall, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Description: Minneapolis Police Department Subject #1 - MENTION IN REPOT #1?Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_i0 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 MENTION IN REPORT #2 - Schwarze,-Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/68 Report Date: 12/03/2015 SUbiect #2 - MENTIONIN REPORT #2 imothy - Continued Primary Information - Continued Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Property: #1 - DVD -,Squad 424 squad video Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD - Squad 424 squad video Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 12/03/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Officers: GRANGER, Christopher (Comm I Homicide I Minneapolis Police Department) Koenig, Mark (Sgt. I Minneapolis Police Department) Ration?! Status Information, Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12/03/2015 13:47 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/04/2015 13:03 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) bla?rrati?Ve begins on thefollowmg page._ .1 7 1 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On Thursday, December 3, 2015, at about 1215 hours, SA Olson picked up additional squad video for Minneapolis squad 424 from Commander Granger. SA Olson previously requested an expanded time frame to include the entire shift of Schwarze and Ringgenberg for November 14, 2015. SA Olson additionally requested last video from Squad 424 prior to the start of Schwarze and Ringgenberg?s shift as well as the ?rst video from 424 after squad 424 was put back into service. All video was assigned as 76679 from squad 424. Commander Granger reported to SA Olson that Sgt. Mark Koenig produced the DVD containing the video which was later provided to him. The disc provided to SA Olson included ?ve separate video excerpts from ?ve separate events. Three of the videos involved events from Schwarze and Ringgenberg?s shift starting the November 14, 2015. SA Olson reviewed the video on the disc and found them to be unremarkable relative to this investigation. The video reviewed were from November 14 and 15, 2015, and brie?y described as follows: 1. 14th/ 1406 1428 hours: Unknown uniformed of?cers responded to a motor vehicle accident. 14th/ 1619 hours: Equipment check Schwarze and Ringgenberg to start shift. 14th/ 1827 1831 hours: Traf?c stop by Schwarze and Ringgenberg. 4. 14th/ 1951 2007 hours: Two detained by Schwarze and Ringgenberg off city bus (19) on suspicion of weapon call. 5. 15th 0944 0948 hours: Unknown of?cer(s) responding Code 3 to unknown event. After reviewing the video SA Olson marked this DVD as item 68.1 to be maintained and preserved as evidence. End report. Angela Erichson From: Granger, Christopher Sent: Thursday, December 03, 2015 6:30 PM To: Olson, Christopher (DPS) Subject: Data Practices Advisory 12?03-15 BCA Special Agent Chris Olson, These files and or videos are being provided to you un-redacted under MN State Statute Section 13.43, Subd. 15. Dissemination of data to law enforcement and or MN State Statute 13.82 Subd. 15 Public Benefit Data. These files and or videos do or may contain data that is protected under the MN Government Data Practices Act. These files and or videos must be reviewed for any necessary redaction under the MN Government Data Practices Act before any public release of their contents. Reference: DVD Squad 424 with expanded times. Commander DeChristopher Granger Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes Investigation Division 350 South 5th Street Room 108 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Of?ce 612-673-2945 DEPARTMENT VALUES: COMMITMENT INTEGRITY TRANSPARENCY Department Goals: Public Safety, Public Trust, Employee Engagement and Morale Confidentiality Notice: This email message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain government data and thereby subject to the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 13; may be subject to attorney-client or work product privilege; may be confidential, privileged, proprietary, or otherwise protected. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any unauthorized review, disclosure, copying, distribution, or use of the contents of this information is prohibited and punishable by law. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please immediately notify the sender by return email and then delete this message from your computer system. STATE OF MINNESOTA M_in ne sota (Rev. 12(02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau Of ApprehenSIon Bureau No. Laboratory No. Evidence N0. ?Tl EVIDENCE RECEIPT a big, 1 Item 3W. Lab Name of Person From Whom Property is Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained Item item qan' N0. N0. No_ My DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Date/Time Signature Storage Site CHAIN OF CUSTODY Ikex Date Reiinquished By An Received By Signature Signatur - i Wm (M, (goat/? i/C G94 tars/WI . I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/69 Report Date: 12/02/2015 warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquisition of MPD Crime Lab Scene Sketches Occurrence From: 12/02/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 12/02/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/07/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) synopsis On December 2nd 2015, SA Phill obtained 3 items of evide 69.3 (CD and two paper sketches). nce from the PD Crime Lab. They were given ACISS item #5 69.1 thru Address #1 - Occurred" #1 - 350 ST Primary Information Address: 350 5TH ST #Rm 108, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Subjects Relationship Name Big EMPLOYER Dale, Robert (Law Enforcement Official) Address #22 ., RELATED #1 AVE Primary information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name 0 03 :Sybjectm Ringge?b?ira??EMilikt?ougi?S-Q Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO on MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/69 Report Date: 12/02/2015 subject #1 Rin'ggenb?er?x Mark Douglas Cd?nti?ri?uerd Subjects Relationship Name ?g EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 .. SUBJECT #2 eS'chwarz'e; D'ustin- Timbth'y I Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name BE EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject SUBJECT #3 ciark; Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: N0 Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications 1 ID Type Number _Stite County As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID 1 Minnesota NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/69 Report Date: 12/02/2015 Property #1 - CD Containing PD Crime Lab Scene Sketches Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing PD Crime Lab Scene Sketches BCAI HQ 12/02/2015 1 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - Computer Generated scene Sketch at 100 ft. scale Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence Documents Computer Generated Scene Sketch at 100 ft scale BCA I HQ 12/02/2015 1 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #3 - Computer Generated Scene Sketch at 40 ft Scale Primary Information Property Class: PrOperty Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Evidence Documents Computer Generated Scene Sketch at 40 ft Scale BCA I HQ 12/03/2015 1 NO YES LockerMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/69 Report Date: 12/02/2015 Property #3 - Computer Generated Scene Sketch at 40 ft Scale - Continued Primary Information - Continued Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Regard Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12/03/2015 14:24 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/07/2015 12:16 Reiporting?LEO . - 7 Date . i 5 Superyis'or . a Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) marrative begins on lthge'tollovvingxpage. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On December 2nd 2015 Special Agent (SA) Phill received the ?nished crime scene sketches from the Minneapolis Police Department (Mpls PD) Crime Lab. SA Phill picked up the sketches from Crime Lab Director Johnson. SA Phill labeled the items in ACISS at (CD of Sketches), 69.2 (Sketch on lOOft scale) and 69.3 (Sketch on 40ft scale); all were retained as evidence. AV xoux Plymouth Av CCN 15423384 1111512015 MPD CLU: JCINL Critical Incident 1611 Plymouth Av p. 1 of 1 SQUAD 42? ?as LEQEND A - DCC - Handcuffs 4 - EMS Bangupplies - Possible Squad Key Approximate Scale AV sewer Plymouth Av CCN 15423384 11I1512015 MPD CLU: JCINL SQUAD 424 EMS COMND 41035? Critical Incident 1611 Plymouth Av p. 1 OH 1611 f?q LEQEND A - DCC - Handcuffs 1 3 - EMS Bag/Supplies - Possible Squad Key 44 Feet 0 5 10 20 30 40 Approximate Scale Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab ResuItAttachment 2015-648/70 Report Date: 12/04/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12I0712015 Approved By: Lab Report Latent Print Analysis Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) PhilI, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date:' PhilI, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12I0712015 11:26 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 1210772015 11:33 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date - PhilI, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385] MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26I2016 Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 i MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793?2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: 793?290] AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab N0. SIS-14003 ReportNo. 8 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Latent Prints 12/04/2015 Laboratory Number: 815-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Latent Prints Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark Description of Submitted Evidence: 13g Type and Packaging Description/Source 2 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as 3 Images of questioned ink prints ?om Item 1 and disk with images latent prints from Items 4 and 9. Created by Scientist. 4 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as Four lifts ?om EMT truck latent print li?(s) 7 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a SIG Sauer, magazine with ammunition, and one ?rearm cartridge. 7A a ?rearm SIG Sauer 9mm Model P226 7B a magazine SIG Sauer P226 9mm 9 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Duty Belt ?om Mark Douglas Ringgenberg an item of evidence 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an Handcuffs with original packaging item of evidence 13 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as Cup an item of evidence Results of Laboratory Examination: term) Name (DOB) s?augaa?ftxgapm '7 Jamar Oneal Clark (5-3-91) BCA Files sm Analysis of the evidence submitted as Items 4, 7 (7A and 7B), 9, 11 and 13 revealed six latent ?ngerprints and two latent impressions (unable to determine if the latent print is ?om a ?nger or a palm) which are suitable for comparison. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 8 Item 4: a Lift 4A from the agency marked lift ?Impression Lift ?om rear door of ambulance rig# 419 and LP4A-2. - Lift 4B from the agency marked lift ?Impression Lift from rear door of ambulance rig# 419 LP4B-1, LP4B-2 and LP4B-3. - Lift 4C from the agency marked lift ?Impression Lift from rear door of ambulance rig# 419 Item 9: - Latent impressions ?om handcu?s: and LP9-3 (from handcuffs in case with portion of handcuffs exposed on the duty belt). Latent Print! s! LP4A-1: Clark excluded as the source. LP4A-2: Clark excluded as the source. Clark excluded as the source. LP4B-2: Clark excluded as the source. LP4B-3: Clark excluded as the source- LP4C-1: Clark excluded as the source. LP9-1: inconclusive for Clark due to a lack of information in the latent print. Clark excluded as the source. Images of latent prints ??om Items 4 and 9 were added to Item 2. Additional comparisons can be completed with the submission of additional known exemplars and with an additional request. Cartridges in the magazine (Item 7B) were not removed or analyzed for latent prints. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. wage; Dennis P. Randall Forensic Scientist Disposition of Evidence: Items 4, 7 (7A and 7B), 9, 11 and 13 will be held until all exams have been completed. Item 2 will be retained at the BCA Laboratory. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/71 Report Date: 12/07/2015 Primary Information Description: Case Report from Hennepin County Sheriff's Office Reporting LEO: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12l07/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminai Apprehension) Agency ReferencejNumlafers Agency Case/File Number Hennepin County Sheriff 15018354 Record Status? Infermation Record Origination Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12:07 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12:11 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor - I - - Date - Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 i MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 Of1 15018354 - MN0270000 1 HENNEPIN COUNTY SHERIFFS OFFICE In: 5'7? INCIDENT REPORT 15018354 AGENCY MN0270000 5 Reported: 11-15-2015 0052 First Assigned:0052 First Arrived:0052 Last Cleared:0238 Commited Start: Commited End: 5 Title: Assist Other Agency - LE How Received: Radio Short Description: Assisted Minneapolis Police Hennepin County Medical Center Security with crowd control at the Hospital after a shooting in Minneapolis. Summary: 0 ESD deputies responded to assist the Minneapolis Police Department with an officer needs help call shots fired call in the 1600 block of Plymouth Avenue North. 0 Upon arrival, scene was controlled and no additional resources were needed. 0 The victim was transported to HCMC for medical treatment of life threatening injuries. . ESD and CSU deputies responded to HCMC to supplement H-SEU and HCMC security personnel by providing extra visibility in front of the ER entrance. 0 Several distraught friends and family members of the victim arrived on scene and only a limited number of visitors were allowed into the hospital. 0 A group of approximately 10 people remained outside and were angry and upset. I The situation was de?escalated and the group remained on scene along the sidewalk. Location(s) Address: 1611 Plymouth Avenue City: Minneapolis State: MN Zip: Country: HCMC Address: 701 ParkAvenue City: Minneapolis State: MN Zip: 55415 Country: Custom Attributes Involvement - ESD Patrol Unit Involvement - - Sheriffs Enforcement Unit Involvement - Crime Scene Unit 3 Officer Assigned: Tait, Steven Badge No: 45 Primary: No u: Officer Assigned: Rehman, Richard Badge No: 556 Primary: No u. 0 Officer Assigned: Magelssen, Allen Badge No: 7'4 Primary: No Officer Assigned: Moore, Adam Badge No: 279 Primary: No Officer Assigned: Anderson, Eric Badge No: 123 Primary: No Officer Assigned: Ryan, Jason Badge No: 616 Primary: No Officer Assigned: Ballard, Nicole Badge No: 36 Primary: No Officer Assigned: Demarais, Joel Badge No: 582 Primary: No 8 MOC: HCQTOS Literal: Assist Other Agency - LE Statute: UCR: 15018354 - MN0270000 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/72 Report Date: 12/04/2015 Primary Information Description: PD Reports 84-88 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (13851MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12114l2015 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12l07/2015 12:54 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12I14I2015 10:42 Reporting LEO .. I Date Supervisor . I . . Date I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MPD CAPRS Supplement MP-15-4233 84 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 84 Author: 003287 - Steven Jensen Date Printed: Dec 10, 2015 Supplement of Off S.Jensen #003287 on 11/20/2015 11:32 This is a corrective supplement for supplement #66. During the course of the investigation, it was determined that the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BOA) would be conducting further examinations on the collected items. The collected DNA swabs and friction ridge impressions were transferred from the MPD Crime Lab Unit to the rather than inventoried in the MPD Property and Evidence Unit as stated in supplement #66. Results of the friction ridge impressions examinations will be reported by the BCA. Officer Jensen Minneapolis Police Department Crime Lab Unit End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print lD: CaprsApp12/10/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement 84 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 85 Author: 007113 Jeffrey Sworski Date Printed: Dec 10, 2015 Supplement 0f Off J.Sworski #007113 on 11/21/2015 23:15 On 11/18/2015 about 1000 hrs. I met with BOA Agent Doug Henning so he could obtain a DNA sample from me. This meeting occurred at the MPD 2nd Pct. A sample was taken and no interview or questioning occurred. This sample was obtained because i had brie?y touched the weapon of Of?cer Schwarze #6422. In addition to my original statement, I briefly held the weapon as I walked Of?cer Schwarze back to my squad. Once in the squad placed the handgun on the dash as drove both of?cers involved back to the 4th Pct. Once at the 4th Pct, I gave Officer Schwarze his ?rearm back and it was holstered. it should further be noted thatl infomed BCA Agent Doug Henning that my partner (Conner) had his hat on the dash and I believed that the ?rearm could of touched it. Prior to doing this supplement 1 informed Sgt. McBride of the DNA sample and that I would be completing an additional supplement. End of Supplement report for case Print lD: F9627809BD1 6} 12/10/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NIP-15423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-154123384 Supplement Number: 86 Author: 001263 Chad Conner Date Printed: Dec 10, 2015 Supplement of Off C.Conner #001263 on 11/23/2015 02:44 On 11/18/2015 at approximately 0900 I was contaced by BCA Agent Doug Henning to give DNA forthe process of elimination. I met with Agent Henning at the lifetime ?tness parking lot at approxiamtely 1000 hours where he swabbed my mouth for DNA. End of Supplement report for case Print lD: 12/10/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement - 5-4233 84 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 87' - Author: 002760 - Randy Hanson Date Printed: Dec 10, 2015 '7 Supplement of R.Hanson #002760 on 11/23/2015 15:59 BCA Evidence Transfer On 11/18/15 Special Agent Phill ll came to our Crime Lab for the transfer of evidence regarding this case. then signed over all items of evidence that had been collected by Crime Lab personnel that were related to this case. I took custody of items from the secure evidence storage and released the following items to Agent Phill: Collected by OFC Jensen FS Schultz (Supplements 66 84) - (4) Four DNA swabs from HCMC Ambulance #419 - (4) Four Impression lifts from HCMC Ambulance #419 Collected by F8 Lenway FS Christensen (Supplement #83) - Pistol with magazine from Ofc. D. Schwarze (#6422) - (2) magazines with live cartridges from Ofc. D. Schwaize (#6422) - Pistol with magazine from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) - (2) magazines with live cartridges from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) - Duty belt with holsters, handcuffs, mace and other accessories from Ofc. M. Ringgenberg (#6030) - DCC (EM: A) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av Handcuffs (EM: B) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av - Green EMS bag with medical supplies (EM: C) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av Possible squad key (EM: D) from boulevard in front of 1611 Plymouth Av Evidence receipts and chain-of?custody forms were signed and are retained in the case file. Randy Hanson Crime Lab Unit Manager End of Supplement report for case MP-15-423384. Print ID: .. 12/ '1 0/2015 MPD CAPRS Supplement Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 88 Author: 119885 Nicole Lenway Date Printed: Dec 10, 2015 Supplement of FS .Lenway #119885 on 12/07/2015 22:47 Crime Lab Unit Corrective Supplement CCN: 15?423384 It should be noted that within Supplement #83, the HCMC EMS command vehicle #41035 was incorrectly stated to be parked facing east. It should state that the HCMC EMS command vehicle #41035 was parked facing west along the south curb of Plymouth Av N, west of 1611 Plymouth Av N. FS N. Lenway Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police Department End of Supplement report for case MP-15-423384. Print ID: 102A3 12/10/2015 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/73 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Primary Information Description: Review audio of MPD interview with Mari Hill Occurrence From: 12/03/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 12/03/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/09/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On 12/03/2015 SA Henning reviewed Minneapolis Police interview with HCMC Paramedic Mari Hill. No evidence generated by nature of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 ~1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name B_io 9% BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (AGENCY) Subject #1 ?gs: Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05l03/1991 Juvenile: N0 Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks . . . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/73 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 Clark, Jamar Oneal Continued Identifications Elites N_UmLe_r ?Et? FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Subject #2 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL MARI Christine .- Primary Information Subject Name: HILL, MARI Christine Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Employment Information Employed: YES Occupation: PARAMEDIC Addresses mpg-Lilia Mesa EMPLOYER 701 PARK AVE HCMC, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 United States Subjects Relationship N_argg Wardell, Jordan (Person) White, Male Record Status, Information Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Record Origination Operator: 12I08l2015 11:55 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 1210912015 09:27 Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO - - Date Supervisor . Date Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2l26l2016 Narrative begins onthe followmg page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On 12/03/2015 SA Henning was asked by SA Phill to review the audio of an interview conducted by Minneapolis Police Department with HCMC Paramedic Mari Hill. The interview with Hill was conducted after she was involved treating a patient after an of?cer inVOIVed shooting in the city of Minneapolis. SA Henning reviewed the interview and found that an additional interview with Mari Hill should be conducted. SA Henning advised SA Phill of his ?ndings. SA Henning attached the transcript of the MPD interview to this report. Please see transcript of the interview for full detail of this interview. No evidence was generated by nature of this report. i. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 15, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Mari Hill (MH) INTERVIEWED BY: Sgt. Twila Villella (TV) Mpls. PD REVIEWED BY: On Sunday, November 15th 2015, Is PD Detective Sergeant Twila Villella interviewed HCMC Paramedic Mari Christine Hill?at the PD Homicide Unit in downtown Mpls. TV I?ll wait out here (inaudible) thank you. (inaudible) and get your basic information first. (inaudible) first name? MH Mari, TV And your last name? MH Hill, TV And your date of birth? MH MH Correct. TV And (inaudible) address? MH TV And a phone number? MH - TV Okay and where do yOu currently work? MH Hennepin County Medical Center, EMS. TV Okay and your contact number would be the same? (inaudible) main line MH yeah the, think it?s -Jr something (inaudible) it?s the-(inaudible) TV Ah who?s card do you have? MH (inaudible) card. EMS (inaudible) TV Oh yeah that?ll work, that'll work (inaudible) TV Yeah and how long have you been employed with them? MH Um, almost five years (inaudible) yeah about five (inaudible) TV Alright why don?t you tell me what (inaudible) MH TV response to the scene. Phill-2015?648-A05 Page 1 of 6 Phill?20?l 5-648-A05 What I heard today in my response? (inaudible) did, did you hear (inaudible) Hennepin County Medical Center paramedic being dispatched to the location over in North Minneapolis where they asked for assistance? Oh eh um I didn?t hear the actual call, but was sitting in the truck at (inaudible) four and I heard them request the squads. (inaudible) the call. In the notes I saw that they had (inaudible) or you know a person is shot. I heard our duty supervisor (inaudible) the radio or you know he went to the scene. And that?s Mike? Yes. Okay. Um and then I heard him get on the radio and say I don?t remember if he said that they were code 4 but I do recall him saying that the assailant was outside the door of the ambulance. And that he was on scene. I don?t recall if he said the police were on scene yet or not. Did he say if the assailants had anything in, in their hand? No he did not. Okay. Not that I recall. Did the crew inside say what was going on with the assailant showing up? Um, I don?t recall hearing them say anything. Dispatch was asking them questions about whether or not they were code 4, whether or not they needed police code 3 and the crew yvhat was hearing over the radio was a, was them just kinda saying yes and no. (inaudible) yes or no I never heard them Okay. more than that. Do you know why they were out there? What the original call was about? Um just through looking at the notes there was something about ankle pain. Um I think it ?actually came out as called it as a medical for them I don?t know (inaudible) (inaudible) were they at a house or were they just on the street? There was an (inaudible) There was an apartment number in the call but I think they were actually treating the patient in the ambulance when they called for a squad (inaudible) Do you think they went up to the house, inside the house to get the patient or do you think the patient met them outside? I?m going to assume just based on the notes from the call, (inaudible) the house just because the notes said that the patient had ankle pain and wasn?t able to walk on her ankle. So I don?t know if they had you know how her ankle pain, how that happened? I have no idea, no idea. Okay. It might say in the (inaudible) notes but I didn?t, I don?t recall seeing that. Page 2 of 6 PhilI-2015?648-A05 Okay. So how long do you think they were out there treating the patient before they asked for assistance? They asked for assistance, it was forty past the hour because I remember looking at the time. But I don?t remember, I?m guessing it would have been around midnight cuz that's when we have our calls but I don?t know howvlong they were on scene before they asked. Okay. And, when your supervisor shows up Um-hm. do you know what he observes? Um well in this instance he came over the radio and said that the assailant was outside the door of the ambulance. Did he describe the assailant? He did not. Okay. And I do not know which door he was outside of. We have the back door and side door and then the two truck, front doors so I don?t know which one he was outside of. Urn, what else I think and I think he said that they were in the I?m not I, I remember him saying that the assailant was by the door. And I cannot remember if he said that they were code 4 or not. Okay. But he didn?t give a description of this (inaudible) No. Okay. Not that I recall. So are you guys responding at that time too? No um ah shortly thereafter the supervisor came over the radio and said that shots had been fired. That EMS was code 4 but that they needed to leave the area. Um, and then shortly thereafter we got dispatched um I think it origin, 1 don?t know what originally came out but we originally got coded routine. And then they said we?re gonna change it to a shooting, go code 3 and that's when we got to, to (inaudible) Okay. Do you know what kinda shooting call it was? All we had is shots fired, one down. Okay. And we had no idea who shot, who or what or anything like that. So when you?re responding what do you guys see? Urn we pulled well we cuz we came up 7th Street and turned left on it was Plymouth right? Yeah. And so we actually waited at that stoplight because there was probably at least half a dozen squads going code 3. So we pulled up, there was squads everwvhere. There were people yelling. Urn there were officers out. We got on the radio and asked for their exact location cuz we weren?t quite sure where they were. They waved us down. We got in there and the patient was lying between, on the grass between the sidewalk and the street. On Plymouth? Yep. Page 3 of 6 PhilI-2015-648-A05 So he was lying on the grass though? Yep. And was he getting medical treatment at that time? Yes ourthe supervisor was giving him medical treatment. And do you notice a lot of people around? Yes. Okay. Are they saying anything? Um I, the only (inaudible) there was one it sounded like a male voice yelling black lives matter over and over again. Okay. And when you?re out there what do you notice about the patient? Um (sigh) the person (inaudible) they said gunshot wound to the head. So I looked immediately for that and if he, his left kind of the way I would describe it is you know how when people like flip their eyelid inside out and it?s like (inaudible). That?s like what his whole kinda looked like and it was really swollen. Um, (inaudible) the supervisor said that he had just stopped breathing so the supervisor was getting his the bag out to help assist him. And then we were looking for a pulse. And this guy?s pants were like mid-thigh (inaudible) and stuff but that was and I didn?t know if any other injuries (inaudible) Okay (inaudible), the injury is on the left eye? It was his, yeah I?m pretty sure it was his left eye. Okay. Above or right (inaudible) I couldn?t tell but I mean like it was the whole I couldn?t tell exactly where the entrance wound, was. Okay. But it was extremely swollen. Um and bleeding and kind of pink and fleshy and (inaudible) Did you notice any weapons that were lying around by that individual? Um I didn?t notice any lying by him my partner yelled to squads to ask if he had been searched yet. Don?t recall what they said but when that happened I started feeling on the patient for any weapons and I did not and I there was something in his pocket but I think it was felt like a (inaudible) I kind ofl couldnthink it was a cup. Okay. Or it seemed to have like a ring on it um but I didn?t feel anything that felt like a gun or a, weapon or anything. (inaudible) Okay and you didn?t see anything lay, laying around? Um it was dark. We didn?t (inaudible) (inaudible), was the lighting dark then? Yeah. Even though (inaudible) overcast and shadow especially the, (inaudible) our ambulance was like it was fairly bright (inaudible) all the emergency lights but once we actually got like to the patient the light was kind of behind, the supervisor so like l, I could see the patient fairly well but anything laying in the grass anything like that was kinda hard to see. Nothing obvious in his hands? No. Page 4 of 6 MH MH MH TV IVIH IVIH Phill?2015-648-A05 Okay. No I didn't, I don't (inaudible) his hands but no not that I recall. Okay. And what are, describe the patient. Um not very big. Maybe (inaudible) White? Black? Asian? Black, male. Um probably 5 I don?t know if I had to say probably comparable to my size, maybe. Okay. (inaudible) Ah I?m about 5?5" I?m thinking he was maybe a little bit taller than that. Okay. Um thin kinda lean build. Ah baggy clothes. I don?t recall much about his hair. I saw his license picture (inaudible) Do you know what his name is? something (inaudible) oh something Clark. l, (inaudible) Clark? Yeah, Clark is the last name and like O?neii might be his middle name. I don't remember his first name (inaudible) Do you know about how old? He ah for his license is 24 I think it said 24? Okay so you never had a conversation with, any of the people that had accrued there? No. Okay. Nope. And the lighting over in that area wasn't very, very (inaudible) No like I said I could see the, I mean like I could make out like what the patient was wearing fairly well but anything that was like laying in the grass (inaudible) urn he had red plaid boxers on. Jeans that were like arou, like big baggy jeans that were mid?thigh. I cut off a like a black zip up sweatshirt I think and a black like not a down jacket but like one of those that?s got like the squares sewn in it. Okay. Like the (inaudible) jacket (inaudible) like kinda like a quilted jacket almost. I don?t, I think he had a red t-shirt on don?t really recall the color. And you found no weapons on (inaudible) not in my time with him. And my understanding is that the ambulance um that (inaudible) Yes, I yeah I?m pretty sure. I had (inaudible) I don?t know about behind butl know in front it does. Okay. And this is a good number to reach someone Yep Page 5 of 6 . . . get that MH That (inaudible) I can, the other one that you might try is, the I can give you the duty chiefs cell. TV Okay MH (inaudible) or the EMS main number, is 612-873?5698 then it says pound 1 so I don?t know if that?s an extension or not but TV Do you know who was driving that other crew? I don't. . TV Okay or was part of that (inaudible)? Um, (inaudible) individual, Wes Thompson maybe but I can?t say for sure. TV Okay. And your supervisor is Mike Trullinger? MH Um?hm. (inaudible) yeah he's the one you (inaudible) TV Do you have anything else you want to tell me that i haven?t asked you? That you think would be relevant to this investigation? (pause) TV (inaudible) MH I don't recall (inaudible) already but no that?s about it I think. Went pretty fast. (inaudible) TV And you guys brought the patient down to Hennepin County? MH We did bring him to Hennepin yes. TV And that patient is still alive as far as you know? MH Ah he was alive when I left yes. TV Okay. Alright well ifl need anything else I?ll give ya, a call thank you. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648?A05 Page 6 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/74 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Primary Information I, . Description: Review of MPD interview audio with Tyler Haskell Occurrence From: 12/03/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 12/03/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved ApprOVed Date: 12l08/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis 3. On 12I0312015 SA Henning reviewed the audio from an interview of Tyler Haskell by Minneapolis Police Department. No evidence was obtained by virtue of this report. - Address-#1: - 14301MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name B_io BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Subject #1 - WITNESS, #1 Primary Information Subject Name: HASKELL, TYLER Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12/08/2015 12:00 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/08/2015 14:02 ReportingLEO 2 Date - I 7- a Supervisor. - . . Date Henning, Doug (1361 I MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 2 On 12/03/2015 SA Henning was asked by SA Phil] to review an interview of HCMC Paramedic Tyler Haskell conducted by Minneapolis Police Depaltment. This interview was conducted after an of?cer involved shooting in Minneapolis. SA Henning reviewed the audio of the interview to see if a follow-up interview would be needed. SA Henning felt that after the review of the audio that a follow up interview was not warranted in this case. SA Henning has attached the transcript of this interview to this report. No evidence was generated by nature of this report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November '15, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEWED BY: . INTERVIEW OF: Paramedic Tyler Haskell (TH) Sergeant Twila Villella Minneapolis PD REVIEWED BY: TV Can I get you anything? TH No. TV You're good? TH I've had enough today. (laugh) No, I?m fine, thanks though. TV Scary ordeal. TH Um?hm. TV (inaudible) TH Yeah. TV Alright, so I?m just gonna get some basic information from you first. What is your first name? TH Tyler. TV And your last name? TH Haskell, H-A-S-K-E-L-L. TV And your date of birth? TV And your home address? TH - TV TH With an L, yep. TV - Okay. TH Uh, TV TV And phone numberfor ya? TV And you?re currently employed with? TH Hennepin County EMS. TV And how long? Page 1 0f12 Phill-2015-648-A03 Since June 22nd of this year. June of this year. Yep (inaudible). You had no idea it?d be so crazy. Uh (inaudible) Is it? Yeah, they?re open (inaudible) 29 years so. Yeah, crazy deal today. Oh yeah (inaudible). No, no so let me know if you need to st0p or let me know. Will do. (inaudible) so why don?t you tell me about the call that you responded to. Okay. So we got called for one with ankle pain. It was a, came on as a medical miscellaneous. They had said, I think I believe the note said something about incident happened an hour ago and I remember what else the note said but (inaudible) going in What time did you get the call at? (inaudible) (inaUdible) (inaudible) (inaudible) came on at it was around 20 hours. (inaudible) 20 hours? Yep. Okay. And we On the 6 Yes. Okay and who were you working with? Uh Wes Thompson. Thompson. Yep. Okay, you guys rotate partners every once in a while or? (inaudible) different partners. Okay. ?0 we ran a almost different partner every day. Okay so you were the driver that day. Yep, yep. Okay. Page 2 of 12 Phill-2015-648-A03 (inaudible) (inaudible) okay so you get the call and you?re responding to what location. 1611, I can?t remember exactly the address, 1611 Plymouth Avenue North. Okay. Apartment 204. And who?s the caller? Do remember who the caller is? (inaudible) who called exactly um it was either our patient or her son. I don?t know which one did the call but So you?re going there. Yep. Because someone?s having ankle pain. Ankle pain is what we got, yep, yep um when we arrived there was a few people standing outside and looking at the apartment complex at the main door on Plymouth just to the right of that there?s a few people standing outside, asked us what we?re there for and we asked ?em how we get into the building and they told us they let us in uh somebody had the Okay. to let us in to the apartment building. So it?s an apartment building not a townhouse. So it?s a, yeah like an apartment building connected to i think they?re townhomes (inaudible) i don?t know if there apartments or townhomes either way but we were outside and they let us in apartment part of the building at least. Um we went up and found our apartment and there?s a female sitting inside with her son (inaudible) an ankle and that?s all we were told by herjust that the ankle pain and. What did she look like? Probably African American female, 120 pounds. Appear sober? She was intoxicated, admitted alcohol, she smelled of alcohol. Okay and did she say how she hurt her ankle? She said she was breaking up a fight, an altercation earlier that night about an hour prior to us being called. Did she say who the fight was between? Not at that time. Okay. So we, my partner helped her go to the bathroom. She had said she had to go to the bathroom (inaudible) do that and then we carried her out of the house on a (inaudible) apartment on a (inaudible) and as we were coming out the door the same party as we were walking out to the left, there was kind a like a stoop with a ledge there and there?s a male, (inaudible) crying acting kind of odd. My partner asked ?em if he was okay and he didn?t really say anything, just kind a locked away and as we continue walking out to ambulance down the sidewalk the female, our patient says that?s the guy that did this. He did this to me. Okay is that, was that the person with, was there anyone else in the apartment with her when you went up there? The son. Page 3 of 12 Sorry. He stayed in the apartment. The son stayed in the apartment. Yep. Was he an African American? Yes, yep. How old? Maybe mid to late twenties. Okay what was he wearing? Oh boy, good question. I think, I wanna say a grey shirt and sweatpants, I don?t remember what color. Okay. it was a T-shirt and sweatpants. Okay so then you?re coming outwith her. Yep. She says this is the person that she was breaking up the fight with? She said that?s the guy, he did this. What did he look like? African American male about uh he I think they?re called dreads in his hair, longer hair. Long? it was longer, shaggy you could call it. (inaudible) No, just a few inches long (inaudible) dread. Okay. Um he was wearing i believe it was a sweatshirt, black, black pants. I don?t recall if he had an actual jacket on or it was just a sweatshirt. Okay. And uh so we continued to walk her to the ambulance and when we got up to the truck I pulled the stretcher out and my partner asked for police officers one to respond with lights and sirens because the assailant is on scene. 80 you called even before he walked up to Yep, yep we called because we know that something wasn't right. Did he say anything? He didn?t say anything at that time. At that time he did not say a thing. (inaudible) don?t see any weapons on him? No he was sitting there leaning up against the stoop like with his hands at his face. Okay. Um. Did he appear intoxicated? Page 4 of 12 (inaudible) acting odd for a sober male of his age. What was he doing? He was sitting there crying. Oh, he was crying. He was crying up against the stoop. I don?t? know what floor he didn?t say a word to us at that time. Was her, was her son did he seem intoxicated? No, he did not he was looking up. He said that she woke him Okay. um when we were called. Okay. So yeah he I don't think he uh was intoxicated (inaudible) didn't seem to know anything about what had happened prior in the night. Okay so he?s crying and you think that?s odd so you like uh the assailants still around? Yep, yep he my partner calls in assailant is on-scene. Uh we just walked past him asking for a squad to respond uh just so that we have somebody therejust in case something happens. Okay. And then as we are getting her on the, the patient on the stretcher he kind a walks up to us and tried talk to her; our Okay. asking where she?s going case he wants to come see her and my partner told him he needs to back this time and he keeps. he keeps within maybe three feet away from us, my partner keeps telling him to back up, need to stay away. And the female patient told him just to please stop and she didn?t say anything else to him. Do you think that?s a boyfriend? She said she didn?t know him. He kept claiming that uh he was her son and she said no he's not. He?s not my son. He?s not? Yeah we asked her if we let you, you hide, is he (inaudible), what?s his relationship? She?s says there?s no relation to him. But he insisted that uh he was her son. (talking in TV TH TH TV Phill-2015-648-A03 Okay. So then if you?re inside the truck or? No we had, we were (inaudible) on a stretcher. He starts yelling things that my partner calling him a pussy and saying he?s a little bitch. Um guess my partner did get out of the rig on the radio and said we need squad?s (inaudible) if assailant is staying around us. Okay. And then uh we got out of the truck and l, we had ta auto load system in our (inaudible) pushed her in there and kinda left the door open while my partner was putting our stair chair back in the truck and partnerjumped in and he had asked me where we?re going and ljust didn?t respond, closedthe doors then looked ?em. Okay. So that, then one guy? Page 5 of 12 PhilI?2015-648?A03 The guy yep, yep (inaudible) are you goin? Hennepin, (inaudible) that?s what he said and I just didn?t answer, closed the doors and locked 'em. And so we were doing basic care, waiting for officers to arrive on scene, think my started an IV and I put an icepack on her ankle. And ah he, the whole time the male was knocking on the back window and trying to open the door to get in and ta, he wasn?t saying anything just trying to get in. So he?s at the back, door then. Yep. Not the side door? Correct the back The back? back double doors he's knocking on the one on the passenger side of the vehicle. We got double doors in the back. Okay. So he was on the passenger (inaudible) the, back doors. And is he Trying to get in, yeah. Okay. But he can?t cuz they?re locked? Correct. Yeah. Was he yelling? He didn?t say anything he was just trying to get in. i couldn?t hear him say anything. At least if he was it wasn't loud enough for us to hear. Um, (inaudible) we?re doing, we're taking care of her and our supervisor arrived and parked behind us. Okay. And he, I could hear him saying something to the guy outside, just relax it?s okay we?re just checking things out making sure everything is okay here. And i unlocked the door so he could get in the ambulance, my supervisorasked him to relock the doors cuz he was trying to get in so he did. And we?re sitting there talking to him about exactly what happened. We never saw when officers arrived so I?m not sure what exactly happened outside (inaudible) from there but we?re sitting in there talking to him and (inaudible) about ready to leave the scene when we hear a shot fired. One gunshot. And I hit my emergency help button and (inaudible) supervisor said shots fired we need your help over the radio. And we all got down on the floor of the ambulance and I laid the patient flat then after I don?t know how long fifteen, thirty seconds um Wes said we should just get outta here we need to leave now and l, I thought our supervisor was gonna get up and drive and i said I don?t have a vest on you have a vest and (inaudible) said it?s okay I?ll just get out and drive so (inaudible) my keys, Wes got out and drove us out of the scene and the supervisor got out as well. Okay. And we left with lights and sirens. Okay so when you say we left, who?s that? Page 6 of 12 Phill-2015-648-A03 So myself, the patient. Myself and the patient were in back, Wes got out and drove the supervisor stayed behind. Stayed behind? Yeah. 80 did you see any incidents involving the, the of?cers (inaudible) We didn?t see it. And the individual? I didn?t see a single thing outside. Did you hear them say anything? (inaudible) All I heard is a gunshot, that?s it. I could hear like people talking outside but not (inaudible) You don?t know what was being said? Don?t know what was being said, there was no, I couldn?t hear any screaming ah at all until after the gunshot then i just heard a bunch of people, screaming. Not any words per say but just screaming. And you don?t, and you don?t know when the officers arrived? I have no idea. (inaudible) So nobody arrived behind us that we could see. Um and if you look to the front of our ambulance we have a chair kind of blocking our one View going forward so I couldn?t see if anyone was there. The last I looked maybe thirty seconds after our supervisor got in the ambulance I did not see any officers, anyone out front. So, But the individual that you know was still at the back door trying to get in? He was somewhere around the ambulance I don?t Okay where our supervisor when he came in he said was still out to the side of the ambulance. Okay and (inaudible) ambulance records right? We (inaudible) know we came (inaudible) that record um (inaudible) I?m not sure about audio and then we have one in the back that I don?t know if it's always recording but we have a camera (inaudible) Okay how do you, how do, how does it record? I mean (inaudible) When we back up it turns on on our mirror. Okay That?s how I know are we going in reverse or (inaudible) Okay so is that not always running then? No Okay Just it can run if we turn our mirror on but ah as far as (inaudible) linked up to the mirror so I don?t know what it records necessarily have no idea. So you don?t, you don?t have any idea who got shot out there? I have no idea. Page 7 of 12 Phill-2015-648-A03 Okay. Not a clue. Ah besides my partner telling me it was the guy that we originally had the altercation with. Buthear (inaudible) who it was but my partner said it was the guy that ah we originally had the altercation with. When he's trying to get in is he yelling anything? (inaudible) anything? I didn?t hear him say anything at all. (inaudible) was crying and asking what hospital she was going to? No, no (inaudible) talk to her saying where are you going I want to come see you. Okay. He didn?t do that. And what was the lighting like around there? Dark. Dark (inaudible) The only light, so it was somewhat lit up because I had left our ambulance lights on because we were kinda halfway (inaudible) in the street so I turned the lights on so (inaudible) it was dark so (inaudible). How many people do you think were around there? Geez, (inaudible) when we got there, there were maybe (inaudible) that I could see outside the party at the little townhouse deal there were five, six people out there. Then across the street there is a (inaudible) say a bar I don?t know exactly what the place was called. When we got on scene there were maybe six or seven people out there and when we were loading the patient up there were probably ten, twelve people out there. Okay. Yeah. And that was the last that I saw, outside. So (inaudible) out of the ambulance and stayed on scene? Yeah. Okay and you heard one shot? One shot. Okay. And you never see any weapons on that, individual? No he had his hands in his pockets a lot he was kind of (inaudible) around I was watching him closely to see if I did see anything or if anything came out of his pockets. And we asked the female while we were in the back of the ambulance waiting for help to arrive if she had any idea if he did carry a weapon. She said she didn?t know him well enough to know one way or the other. Okay. And we asked her if we knew, if she knew anybody um there that may have a weapon she, she said she had no idea. Do you know what her name was? Yeah ah Ray, N-R-A-Y and then it's a second and then last name was Hayes, E-S. Page 8 of 12 PhilI-2015?648?A03 Okay was she being admitted to the hospital? I don?t know. She, so she had the ankle injury and I know it?s when we were taking her to North she had bruises on around her and an abrasion and she had a cut lip on the inside (inaudible) so it looked like she had been punched a few times and assaulted. Okay. So she, she stated that it was breaking up a fight but, she appeared to have been hit quite a few times in the face. And you brought to North? North Memorial, yeah. Did she hear the shots, (inaudible)? She heard it What did she say? She was just scared ah I think she said like oh Lord help me um and then I gave her my hand to hold onto as we kinda left and ah she was just crying not saying much on the way there and then 1, (inaudible) asking her like a (inaudible) where she lives to fill out a run report and kinda keep her mind off things. She said she was kind of visiting cousins and that this party she was at was her cousins and she didn?t say much else about anything else prior to that. Where does she live? Somewhere on Morgan Avenue North um I don?t remember the exact address but she said she?s, really she just came back here from ah Wichita, Kansas is what she said. That she?s from North Minneapolis. And she lives on Morgan (inaudible) Yeah somewhere on Morgan Avenue North I don?t recall the house number. And she was at a relatives house, that at that (inaudible) It was her daughters house I believe she said, it?s her daughters apartment I believe. Did you see the daughter? Nope. (inaudible) In fact when we were taking her out of the apartment her son said he was gonna call her and let her know that she was going to the hospital. Do you know the son?s name? No idea. No I don?t think we ever got it. Okay. Do you know Rayann?s phone number or anything (inaudible)? No ah we don?t, usually get a phone number. (inaudible) No. I know she was put in room 19 at North Memorial in the ER And you don?t know if she?s gonna be admitted? Yeah I don?t know. Um last l, (inaudible) officer to show him where (inaudible) to a show them what room she was in she was getting stitches in her lip. Okay what sergeant, is he plain clothes? Page 9 of 12 Phill-2015-648-A03 No he was in a uniform. Okay. I don?t, I don?t think we ever got his name actually. (inaudible) anything else you want to add that I haven?t asked you? Not that I can remember. Yeah, (inaudible) get into detail what happened then she (inaudible) She just said she, they were in the hallway outside the townhome or apartment I don?t know exactly it is she broke up an altercation. That?s all the details she gave. And that guy was involved Yeah. (inaudible), okay. Yeah. She was kind of, she?s pretty vague about what happened and kinda suspect it wasn?tjust breaking up an altercation. Okay Based off of And (inaudible) was crying? Yeah. (inaudible) (inaudible) Do you think she was on, high on drugs? Alcohol? (inaudible) his speech when he was yelling at us so I wouldn?t be surprised if alcohol Okay she said there was that?s where she had drank so I, I would assume there was 'alcohol at the party that she was at. But I, 1 don?t, I can?t say was close enough to get any smell (inaudible) alcohol or (inaudible) Um, was there like for me when you say crying was it like bawling He was bawling like sobbing and crying. It was notjust you know tears he was, audibly crying. Okay. Did he appear to have any injuries on him? No not that I could see. How about the son? No No? (inaudible) he was walking around just fine. And the apartment wasn?t in chaos and tipped over furniture or anything like that? No, not at all. Okay. But you believe she was assaulted? She appeared to (inaudible) more assaulted than or at least when she was breaking up the fight she was assaulted cuz she had, she had bruising on her left and abrasions there and then she had a cut lip that was already swollen. So she had to have been hit more than Page 10 of12 PhiIl-2015-648-A03 once plus her she couldn?t put any weight on her right ankle. So, it was like if she broke up a fight she got in the middle of a big fight I guess. (inaudible) yeah. And her ankle was pretty swollen? (inaudible) to see if it was swollen, I didn?t really get the chance. Okay But she couldn?t put any weight on it. Anytime we hit a bump even she was saying it hurt really bad so, (inaudible) gave her some pain medication that didn?t do much to help at all so Okay It was a decent amount Alright. Well when you heard the one shot Um-hm Where did you think you heard it coming from? Let me ah orient myself here. Our ambulance was facing eastbound on Plymouth. And so the shot was it sounded right outside our side door on the south side'of the ambulance. And it sounded like it was directly outside our door. Okay. It was loud. Not the back door but The side door so we have yeah (inaudible) it?s the front of our ambulance Yeah We have a ss, door right Yeah get in it sounded like it was somewhat right there, yeah. It was close. (inaudible) (inaudible) were you on the opposite, wrong side of the street then facing eastbound? Nope we were on the correct side. Correct side? Okay. Yeah we were on the right side, yeah and the home was basically right here. Okay. And the party was right there. Okay. Yeah. (inaudible) So (inaudible) Plymouth. Um-hm. And on the side door which would have been on the street side This would have been on, (inaudible) (inaudible) On the Page 11 of12 Boulevard? boulevard side yep. And that?s where you heard the shot? Yeah. And so and you never heard any arguing with the officer or anything? No I didn?t Okay thing I wasn?t, we were talking with our supervisor as well so I may not have, been paying attention to noised outside necessarily but not i don?t remember hearing any screaming, arguing all of a sudden there was just, (inaudible) people outside but ah all of a sudden there was just a shot. (inaudible) Yeah. Is there anything else you want to tell me that I haven?t asked you? Not that I can think of. Alright and um your ambulance was brought over to (inaudible) The last I saw of it, it was still sitting at North Memorial (inaudible) Yeah they were two officers with it, they have the keys What ambulance? Ah 419 419? Yeah and there are a couple officers sitting next to it and they have the keys to it. Okay. And who would be able to get us the tapes if, and stuff? Any supervisor, Mike Trelliger I?m sure could I That?s (inaudible) exactly Okay supervisor I know would be able to let the police (inaudible) Okay. I don?t know if (inaudible) Alright. you know Thank you. Absolutely. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648?A03 Page 12 of12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/75 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Primary Information Description: Charesse Douglas statement Occurrence From: 12/07/2015 14:49 Occurrence To: 12/07/2015 15:18 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On December 7, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane interviewed the Elks Lodge security officer Charesse Douglas. Item 76.1 (audio CD of interview) acquired by virtue of this report. Address #1 occurred #1 4251 233D a - Primary Information Address: 2511 23RD AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #1 #1 -'Doug as, Chares'se Primary Information Subject Name: Douglas, Charesse Record Type: Person Bio: 42 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses We Addre? HOME ADDRESS 4256 27TH AVE S, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55406 United States Telephones ddresses Relationship NumberlE-Address PHONE Subject #2 lN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar'OneaI Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis .. a MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/75 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject MENTION IN REPORT F'Ciark?, Jamar Oneal - Continued Primary Information - Continued Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications State 999m ism 9mm FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Property #1 - Audio CD .- Charessepouglas interview Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Audio CD - Charesse Douglas interview Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 12/08/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Record Status Information 7 .- . Record Origination Operator:? OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12/08/2015 12:58 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/14/2015 11:34 Reporting LEO Date: Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) (Narrative page.- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On Monday, December 7, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane met with Charesse Douglas. SA Olson learned during this investigation that Mr. Douglas was working security for the Elks Lodge during the evening of November 14, and during the early morning hours of the 15th. SA Olson previously made arrangements with Mr. Douglas to meet him at his girlfriend?s home (Octevia Pointdexter) located at 2511 23rd Ave N, Minneapolis, MN. SA Olson and SA Kane began the interview with Mr. Douglas at about 1449 hours. The interview concluded at about 1518 hours. Mr. Douglas indicated that he along with his supervisor Joseph Lane were both working the same shift at the Elks Lodge when this incident occurred. He reported they have both worked contract security for the Elks Lodge many times previously. Mr. Douglas told agents he did not know the decedent or the two initial of?cers responding to the scene. Mr. Douglas told SA Olson he observed the ambulance arrive ?rst and saw paramedics telling Clark to step back with what he described as an elevated voice. Douglas indicated he saw the Minneapolis marked squad arrive with what he believed were two white male of?cers. Douglas said he observed one of the of?cers take Clark to the ground, but could not hear any dialog between the of?cer?s and Clark due to the crowd that was gathering outside the lodge. Douglas reported the crowd was loud as they hollered toward the of?cers. Mr. Douglas reported seeing a muzzle ?ash and hearing a gunshot, but was unsure which officer ?red their weapon. He reported one of?cer was on the ground with Clark at the moment the weapon was ?red. Mr. Douglas reported he did not see any handcuffs before, during, or after the shot was ?red, and indicated that it looked like Clark may have been handcuffed because of the position of his arms just after he was shot. (See attached transcript for complete details) SA Olson later transferred the digital audio ?le from this interview to CD for preservation and storage. The CD is labeled as item 75.1. It should be noted that SA Olson received a security report generated by Mr. Douglas from this incident and attached it to his report. End report. lncident Report At approximately 12:50am Sunday morning date of November 15. 2015 on the 1600 block of Plymouth Avenue North in Minneapolis i observed Minneapolis police of?cers responding to an altercation between a Hennepin County Medical Center paramedic and an African-American male. Two police of?cers approached the African- American mate and they began exchanging words. i then observed the two police of?cers grab the male and proceeded to throw him on the ground at that time, the patrons of the Elks become irate with what they were observing. My co-worker and i started moving the patrons away from the scene of the incident. Things continued to escalate, so i then turned my attention back to the incident and at that time i heard a gunshot and saw a muzzle flash. observed the African?American male laying on the ground motionless and i saw one of the officers getting off the ground. 1 did not see which of?cer ?re the shot, but i did observe the muzzle ?ash. On November 15, 2015 was assigned to work the Elk?s Lodge located at 1614 Plymouth Ave. No. i was working with my partner Captain Joe Lane. Around 0040, I observed a Hennepin County ambulance arrive at the apartment complex across directly across the street and enter into the building. A short time later, i observed the paramedics getting into a verbal confrontation altercation with a black who came out from an unknown address which is one of the town homes which faces Plymouth. i heard the medics telling black male ?To get back.? The black male then asked "Why." Then the medics said, ?i don't know you and Phi sure she doesn?t know you either.? The black male than said, what the fuck do you mean. that's my woman." This was taken place on the boulevard near the tree towards the rear of the ambulance. The' female was already inside the ambulance. Around 0050 hours, i observed a Minneapolis Police car arrive. There was a vehicle parked behind the ambulance and the police had parked behind the other parked vehicle. i saw the two uniformed police of?cers exit their patrol vehicle and approach the black male. The police of?cers and the black male started to engage in a conversation. My partner and i went to perform our parking lot check on the west side of the building. We then proceeded back to the front of the business. i then proceeded to continue watching the incident across the street. 1 then saw one of the of?cer?s take the black male to the ground, by grabbing and throwing him to the ground. i then observed a struggle between the of?cer and the black mate. i then heard a few customers from the Eik's begin to yell and fuse at the of?cers because of the way the black was being treated. i then began to focus my attention on the Elks customers by tell the Elk?s customers to get in their cars and allow the police to do their job. i then walked towards the west side of the building again because there appeared to be some form of commotion because of the incident which was taken place across the street. 1 then walked back towards the front of the business. continued to tell the customers to ?nd their cars and go home. As i began to turn back towards the incident, I observed a muzzle ?ash and heard the gun ?re. i didn?t observe which of?cer ?red the shot. i then observed the of?cer getting up from the ground. i then saw the black laying on the boulevard not moving. The way the black was lying on his side it appeared that the male was handcuffed. However. didn't see any of?cer putting on any handcuffs nor did i see them removing any handcu?s. i then focused my attention back towards the Elk?s customers because they had begun to get even more upset because of what just happened. i was telling them to get in their cars and not go across the street. i heard the of?cer calling for back?up. A short time later many other police cars came and they began putting up yellow Glades?. tape. was attempting to tett the Elk?s customers not to cross the tape and go get in your cars but they were not listening. I attempted to contact you supervisor. My partner and I left the scene around 0135 hours. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: December 7, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Charesse Douglas (DG) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (SA) FBI SA Kevin Kane (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO The following is a taped statement ah between myself, Chris Olson, Charesse Douglas, Charesse is Douglas common spelling ah Charesse?s birthdate is Also present is ah FBI Agent Kevin Kane. The date is December 7, 2015. The time IS, 1449 hours. We are currently at 2511 23rd Avenue North, Minneapolis, Minnesota and Charesse's home address is 4256 27th Avenue South, Minneapolis, 55406. And Charesse ah you just ah and for the record no one else is present during this statement. This is in regards to BCA case number 2015-648. Charesse we are a currently at the home of your fianc? is that right? DG Yes. CO Okay and what?s that person?s name? DG Octeria Pointdexter. CO Can you spell Octeria? DG CO Okay. And the last name was? DG Pointdexter. CO Okay. Ah how do you spell that? DG CO Okay. And, your cell phone number, even though I have it if you could recite that for me. as - CO Okay DG CO Okay DG - CO And you ah monitored me a stating your name and your birthdate and your address. Was that all correct? DG Yes. CO Okay. So Charesse ah my partner and ljust briefly introduced ourselves to you and we under, you understand that l, read your report about the incident on ah the morning ofthe ah 15?? ah involving that officer involved shooting. DG Yes. Olson?2015-648?A10 Page 1 of 15 Olson-2015?648?A10 And I understand that you were working ah for what?s the security company name? Security Solutions Protective Agency. And ah you were working on a contract basis ah for them and on that particular night the of the morning of the 15th you were working at the Elks Lodge is that right? Yes. And specifically ah, this event happened. Were you outside ah when this started? Yes. First you know ah the decedent, Mr. Clark? Have you, is that someone that you?re familiar with? No. Okay. Have you ever met him before as far as you know? No. Okay. Um, just for some background and some context how many times had you worked security at Elks Lodge um prior to that night? Not exactly butjust approximately. Urn, every Friday and Saturday for like the past five or six months. Okay. So this was a regular gig for you on weekends? Yes. Okay. What time does your shift normally start and what time does it normally end? Ah my shift starts at 2300. 11:00 PM. and it ends? Um I?m sorry um I um not 23 ah 2130. Okay so 9:30 you come in. 9:30 PM. you come in and start your shift on Friday and Saturday nights? Yes. And then typically what, is there a typical time that you get outta there? Anywhere between 0100 and 0130. Depending on how busy it is and how many people are lingering? Yes. That sort of thing. And yourjob there is security is that right? Yes. And by security, keeping people from ah drinking ah bringing intoxicating beverages outside ah fights, um your Yeah. . . . bar stuff? Yeah. Alright. Just general security right? Yes. Um, and then on this particular shift you were working and who were you with? Page 2 of 15 OIson?2015-648-A1 0 was with my Captain, Joe Lane. Okay. And he?s worked, does he always work with you? You guys always paired up together? Um it switches. Um I work with him on Friday?s and or either some Saturday?s. Okay. And work with my Sergeant on some Friday?s and some Saturday?s. So it switches between the two. Okay. On this night you two are working. Were you, were you outside when you saw Mr. Clark ah initially ah being confronted by the uniformed police officers? Yes. Alright what did you see? What were your observations? Um, I saw the two officers approach him. Um, Did you see their squad car actually arrive? Yes. Okay. So you saw the two officers approach him. I?ll try not to interrupt you again. Go ahead. i saw the two officers arrive. Cuz I always speak to the officers when they?re passing by. it?s just that particular night when I spoke to the officers um they were going ah they were going westbound on Plymouth Avenue. Okay. And they did a turn. Um facing ah eastbound. Okay. Um I sat there for a minute. And I saw the two officers get out ofthe squad and approach ah Mr. Clark. And, how far, where were you standing in relation to that discussion that was happening? I was There?s a north and a south side of Plymouth were you on the ah Elks Lodge side, the north side? Yes. And the officers were confronting Mr. Clark on the south side? Yes. Okay. Did you have occasion to hear anything ah verbally that was being exchanged? i didn?t hear the urn the verbal altercation between the officers and Mr. Clark but I did hear the, the conversation between Mr. Clark and the paramedics upon the ah squad car arriving. Prior to the squads arriving you heard some arguing? Yes. Or, okay and what tell me what you heard. Page 3 of 15 Olson?2015-648?A10 Um, I observed the paramedics bringing a female um African American female out of that building. Okay. Um Mr. Clark walked out a, out of another entrance to the building. And he approached the urn the ambulance. Okay. And he asked the ah paramedic um what was wrong with the female. And the paramedics ah one of the paramedics told him they were standing be ah in the back of the ambulance. Um?hm And ah one of the paramedics told Mr. Clark that he needed to step back. And Mr. Clark was refusing. 80 And by refusing, you could tell verbally or I mean was he, what was, what was he saying specifically if you can remember. I heard him say um I don't have to go anywhere. Okay. Ah but he was swearing. Okay. So go ahead and quote him. I won't ah, punish you for swearing. What did he, if you can remember what he said specifically. Um he said I don't have to go no fucking where. Okay. Did he say that more than once orjust once? He said it more than once. Okay. And then he asked the ah paramedic why do I need to leave. Why do i have to um stand back or in, in those words. And the paramedic said because I don?t know you and you don?t know me and I?m quite sureshe doesn?t know you either. And then I heard Mr. Clark say you know quote, what the fuck you mean this is my woman. And the paramedic said i don?t care I need you to stand back. Okay. Um at that time Were the voices yelling or conversational or what were the They were, they were kinda, kinda (inaudible) Elevated? to, yeah Okay To the point where i can hear ?em from across the street. Alright. Um at that time that?s when a customers were began leaving out of the club. 80 i started ah tending to the customers that was coming out of the Elks Club. And that was a few minutes later that?s when I saw the urn the squad arriving. Okay. And so, getting the customers out ofthe Elks building is a normal thing that you do. Page 4 of 15 Olson?2015-648?A10 Yes. You?re normally outside during this hour? Yes. Ah and making sure they get to the parking lot, making sure they leave? Yes And did you continue observing then ah, what was happening across the street while doing your duties? Um at that time, I wasn?t watching what was going on across the street. was making sure that the urn customers at the Elks Club was leaving. Making sure that the parking lot was clearing out. At this time I was at the west end of the building by the parking lot. Okay. I was kinda walking back and forth. Okay. And there?s parking lots kinda all around that building but you were on the one that was furthest west? Yes. Okay. And, so did you ah let?s go back. Did you actually speak to these officers at all or you said normally I talk to the officers but on this night did you talk to the officers? Um no ljust wave. Okay. Anytime Okay pass by. Do you know these officers by name? No. Okay. Ah do you know them ah, by familiarity? Did either one of ?em look familiar to you or just ah just two Minneapolis cops that you didn't know? Just two Minneapolis cops that I don?t know. Okay. And where was Joe during all of this? When, now you?re hearing this stuff initially where was he standing? Was he close? Joe was a few feet behind me um he was checking the east end of the parking lot. Okay. And he was walking towards me to join me at the west end of the parking lot at that time. Okay. Um, at some point something happened that, that caught your attention. What was that? Um the customers at the Elks Club began yelling across the street at the officers. Okay. And that?s when I immediately turned around from the west end of the building and started walking back towards the ah front entrance of, of the Elks Club. was yelling at the customers telling them to mind their own business. Okay. Page 5 of 15 Olson-2015-648-A10 And to leave. Alright. And ah what was happening, what were the officers doing ah and what was Mr. Clark doing at that time, when the yelling started? Um when the yelling started um that?s when one of the officers um grabbed Mr. Clark and, and was throwing him to the ground, taking him to the ground. Okay. And that?s when the yelling started from the customers. Alright. And so did in your estimation what were you seeing ah one of the officers threw him to the ground. Describe what you saw. Um, I saw one of the officers grab Mr. Clark and began taking him to the ground and there was another officer standing right there. They were by the ah the ambulance. Okay. In between the ambulance and, and there was another car there if] can remember on the boulevard, right there. Okay. So and I?m gonna ask you some questions that really get into specific detail that um are, are gonna be important and, and I appreciate you trying to take the time to remember this. And if you don?t remember that?s okayjust say I don?t remember but um do you remember um anything verbally that may have been exchanged between the officer and Mr. Clarkjust prior to him being taken to the ground? I didn?t hear any, any conversation between the officer and Mr. Okay. the crowd at the Elks Club was being so loud so I didn't hear anything. And what were they yelling? Um, another black man or you guys are harassing another black man Okay. and those words. Okay and when, when you say they took him to the ground do you know ah can you describe to me how that happened. How they got him to the ground. Or weren?t you watching? I wasn't watching. Okay but at some point you, you saw that they were standing and some point you saw that was it the officer and Mr. Clark on the ground or was it two officers both on the ground and Mr. Clark or what did you, what?s the next thing that you saw? ?Um, it was Mr. Clark and the ah one of the officers on the ground. Okay. And there was one officer standing. Okay. And then did, did that, did your attention stay focused on that or, or did you? I started back focusing on the crowd at the Elks because they were beginning to get irate. Okay. So you turned your, your eyes away from that. Started doing yourjob. And then what happened? Page 6 of 15 Olson~2015~648-A10 Um after I was telling the customers at the Elks Club um to just leave, mind their own business, let the cops do theirjob. Um I was making sure that they, they wasn?t to get across the street to where the altercation was taking place. Okay. And at the time after I told them to leave um I walked back towards the west end of the building because there was a crowd standing down there as well. And they were beginning to get irate at um at that time as well. Okay. So I was telling them to mind their own business and leave the club is closed, leave. 80 at that time I turned back around and started walking back towards the entrance to the Elks Club. Okay. And at the time when was walking towards the entrance of the Elks Club um out of the corner of my I saw a flash from a muzzle. And um I heard a gunshot. Okay. And at that moment that obviously drew your attention then to look over there. Yes. Were, were the officers um, ah where were they, where was Mr. Clark? Was he on the ground? He was on the ground. And where were the officers? One officer was getting off the ground. Okay. Um he was rolling over ah getting up from the ground. Okay. And there was an officer standing there. Okay. And the one that was rolling ah was must have been the one that was down with Mr. Clark. Yes. And the one that was standing um ah you don?t have any feel for which, which officer discharged their firearm is what I?m trying to get at. I don?t. Okay. Can, was there any difference in these officers in terms of their appearance or look or anything? Were they white? Were they black? Were they They were um white. Okay. And, were you able to hear anything in the way of dialogue or conversation that took place after that from across the street? No l, I wasn?t able to hear anything cuz at the time the ah crowd at the Elks Club really began getting irate. Okay. Saying oh they shot him, they shot him and Okay. Page 7 of 15 Olson-201 5-648-A10 And they were trying to get across the street and was telling them to back up and you know and not to go over there. What, what was, and your best guess what was the period of time from, from when the officers arrived or let?s say when the struggle started so when Mr. Clark went to the ground how much time passed ah between that and the gunshot? Um I?ll say anywhere between, I?ll say six to probably six to eight Okay. between that time. Alright so a considerable amount of time. Yes. From the time they brought him to the ground, from the time that you heard the gunshot? Yes. Okay so do you, was there a struggle going on that entire time? i mean was there, was it a, a fight? How would you categorize it? Um I didn?t notice any, any um, any fight or anything between the officers and Mr. Clark. Okay. Did you at any point see Mr. Clark get handcuffed? No. Okay. And can you say definitively whether or not he was handcuffed? Do you know? Um, I can?t say if he was handcuffed or not. Okay. But there was a point and time I did look across the street after the gunshot. Uh-huh. And um I saw Mr. Clark laying there motionless on the ground and the way his arms was it appeared that he was handcuffedlaying and how did his arms appear? He was um laying on his side. Okay. And his arms were kinda like this behind his back. Okay. 80 but I didn?t see any handcuffs um I didn?t see him get handcuffed and I didn?t see any handcuffs come off. Okay. Um it?s just the way he was laying. Okay. Alright. Um, have you talked about what happened with Joe? I know you guys both did reports. Have you guys had a conversation about what happened? Um, I mean did he, did he have a better or worse vantage point? Did he see or hear things you didn't? Or don?t you know? No actually um I think myself and Joe Lane 1 think we saw about the same amount Page 8 of 15 Olson-2015-648-A10 Okay. was going on. Alright. Although at some point you were in different locations relative to the event. But Yes. um, I forgot what i was gonna ask. (pause) Did you actually see urn I?m assuming you saw the arrival of many officers shortly thereafter. Oh yeah. Yeah, do you see anyone attending to ah Mr. Clark? Ah his injuries or anything like that, did you see anyone working on him? No. Okay. After urn after the shooting um the, the crowd was yelling at the officers. The crowd from the Elks Club was yelling at the officers. Okay. Um I observed one of the officers get on his radio and call for backup. Um I didn?t see at the time no one attending to ah Mr. Clark at that time. Okay. But eventually a few minutes later they um well a couple minutes later finally after that they did call for another paramedic to arrive on the scene to come to the scene. Okay so the first paramedic that had the ah female victim in a, ah did that stay on scene for a while and then leave or did that leave right away or don?t you have any recollection of that? Um to my knowledge they were there for, for some time. How many paramedics ah total do you recall seeing at the scene? Two. Okay. And did, was there a, so there?s two paramedics and there?s two uniformed officers right and a marked squad? Yes. Do you remember if their lights were on, on their marked squad or if it was their parking lights or headlights or do you remember anything about the marked squad? Um I think their lights were on. Okay. Alright. Headlights were definitely on Yeah of the hour and you think the emergency lights were on as well? Ah, no. Okay so those were off? Yes. Okay. And when you saw them arrive um you think initially they were headed west and they hung a turn and then so that their squad was facing east as they confronted Mr. Clark? Yes. Page 9 of 15 Olson-201 5-648-A10 Okay. And I actually think they were um they were the responding officers to you know to the altercation. Okay. And I think they were coming um they were coming ah west to respond to the call and just did the turn (inaudible) Now when you say altercation do you mean the altercation between Mr. Clark and the ah the female victim or do you mean the altercation between the responding squads to assistance to provide assistance to the officers? The ah verbal altercation between the paramedic and Mr. Clark. Okay. Alright. Was that paramedic male or female? The verbal ah altercation. Male. Okay. They both were male. Alright. And were there any other vehicles parked, emergency vehicles ah parked besides the squad car and the urn ambulance? No. Okay. Alright. Did you eh visually at any point ah before, during the event or afterwards see any handcuffs? No. Okay. Alright. Have you had discussions with ah your, your work colleague, Joe about whether handcuffs were used? Um, we, we were asking each other back and forth like what you know like was he handcuffed. And Joe said i don?t know. It?s like I couldn?t tell if he was handcuffed either. Okay. Alright. But you never, just you?re basing ah people?s impression is maybe by the way he was laying that he may have been handcuffed is that an accurate, summary of what Yes today? Yes. Okay. Alright. l?m gonna just take a moment here and gloss over this one more time real quick. And did you ah this is dated 11-21-15 is that when you drafted this report or when you, wrote this report? Yes. Okay. That was actually when I, when I turned it in. Okay. Was this report written like at the end of the shift or the next day or sometime later in the week? Um, most of it was written a couple days after the incident Okay. just went through it and reconstructed everything. Page 10 of15 CO Okay. Alright. DG Trying to make it look more professional than it did the first time. CO You, you did a nice job there. DG Thank you. CO Um, (pause) Agent Kane do you got any questions? KK Yeah just a couple. So when the shot rang out and then you, you looked over at that right? DG Yes. KK Saw the officers standing there? DG Yes. KK Did you notice anything about their appearances in any way? DG Um no I didn?t um I just saw one of the officers um standing there and, and one of the officers were, was trying to get off the ground, that was (inaudible) KK Okay. If I said like what was the officers demeanor, do you know what l?m talking about? Like what, you know if you say what?s that guys demeanor and they?re like he?s super angry look at how angry he is and you could tell by looking at him. DG (inaudible) KK officers look any certain way? And I don?t want to offer anything first or second or third or anything like that. But did they look any way? Did they look like how did they act after the shot went off? DG Um, they didn't appear to have any type of demeanor, they were still like in like ah defense mode or you know KK Okay DG that makes any sense. CO Ah did they look afraid? Did they look, were they responding to the crowd at all? Could you tell? Were they calm? Were they ah DG Um after a while yeah they did kinda, kinda look afraid like you know cuz there was a lotta people out there. CO Okay. DG And when um I think they were allowing us to do ourjob as well. You know to keep the crowd back and everything but once people stopped responding to our, our commands you know stopped complying and the crowd was trying to get over there I, I think that?s when, the, the officers kinda panicked and called for backup. CO Okay. KK Did you happen to see when the gunshot went off did either of the officers look surprised in any way? You know like if somebody came up behind you and shot a gun, you?d probably go like what the, DG Ah KK Did anybody look like that like they didn?t know that was gonna happen? DG No. (pause) Olson?2015?648~A10 Page11of15 KK And then you said I think you said they were up did you say they were operational? That?s how they were, no demeanor they were just like continued to be operational and handle whatever they DG KK DO their situation that they had going on. KK Did you see what happened, the officer that shot I know you didn?t see which one it was. But did you see anybody, did you ss, what did they do with their guns after the shot rang out? Did you see that? DO I didn?t see that. KK Did they have their guns out? DG No. (pause) CO I?m gonnajump in real quick. KK Um?hm. CO So ah you said you ah you saw an officer getting up from the ground. DG Um?hm. CO Um was that person getting up like on all fours? Was he getting up from a, what kind of position was he getting up from? DG He was getting up on all fours. CO Okay but initially when he was down on the ground ah when you first saw him he was on ah hands and knees? DG Yes. CO Or was he on his, side? DC He was on hands and knees. CO Okay, alright. Okay. Did at any point you see ah when Mr. Clark was on the ground was he, you said ah the position that he came to his final resting spot and he was on his side right? DG Um?hm. CO But ah when he was first taken down to the ground was he on his, stomach, back, side? Don?t, if you don?t know that?s okay too. DG Um, when the officer grabbed him and they were going to the CO Uh-huh DG Mr. Clark was yeah he was on his side at that time. CO He was on his side? DG Yeah. CO Okay. And the officer on the ground with him was ah on his side, his back or his stomach or don?t you, don?t you recall? DG Um I don?t I can?t recall. CO Okay. Alright. Olson-2015-648?A1 0 Page 12 of?l5 (pauseOlson?2015-648-A10 As a bouncer there, working there do you know any of the people that, that go to the Elks Club? Um, I don?t know ?em really know ?em I, [just know their names by working there for the time I?ve been there. Okay so when, when you were outside managing the crowd did you look around and say hey there?s Fred over there he?s, seeing this too? No. Like do you remember seeing anybody that you knew that saw it? Um Just gonna follow up at the end where we ask you are there other people there that you feel may have been watching it you know full time like you?re obviously doing yourjob trying to keep everybody and get ?em to leave and stuff like that. Did you look around and see somebody that you knew there that might have a good view of what went on? Urn the only person that I know is ah Jerome. Um, I don?t know his last name. Eh if we said it would you know it? Probably, yeah. Copeland? Older guy. Yeah, African American, guy. Yeah Yeah. Um and he, and does he, what does he call how, how does he refer to you? What, what does he, he doesn?t call you Charesse? Ah ha no he calls me Charesse Oh he does? Yeah. Or um, Just we?re kinda like relatives a little bit So you guys are related? Huh, kind of. One of his relatives has a kid with one, one of my nephews. Does anyone refer to you as Doug? No. Alright. Alright um have you talked to Jerome about this after the event? Did you talk to him that night about it? Um, no he was actually Speaking to myself and Joe, Joe Okay. the incident um afterl contacted my supervisor l, I didn?t say anything about the case whatsoever. Okay. Alright. But he, he told you he saw the whole thing? Page ?13 of15 Olson~2015?648?A1 0 Yeah. Alright. And do you know what his opinion is ah whether or not ah, um this person, Mr. Clark was handcuffed? Urn he said he didn?t see any handcuffs. Okay. That's what he was saying. Alright. Was he, since he?s your friend he probably wasn?t one of the people causing problems. No. Okay. Alright. No. Was there anybody recording before that shot rang out? Um ah there were a numerous people with their ah with their cell phones out recording. I mean there was a lot of ?em. Yeah, do you remember who those people were by chance? Any of ?em. I don?t. Okay. See that?s, ah it?s been one weekend since that happened, the shooting and then a weekend was the Elks Club open last weekend? Yes. Did you work last weekend? Yes. Where, did you hear anybody talking about what went on the week before? Um, there ah numerous people talking about the case. What was the general consensus of what people thought happened? There were a lotta people saying that he was handcuffed, when he was shot. That?s basically what the whole neighborhood was saying. And everyone that was walking past the Elks Club that night as well. Did anyone specifically like say that they saw them, that they saw him handcuffed? And I know that there?s the overall talk but did, is there one person that you could point us to in general that said hey I was there I saw him handcuffed? (inaudible) not at this time I can?t. Or I recorded it. Did you hear of anybody that may have got this recorded or photos of it? I heard a few people saying they recorded it. Um, I can?t, can?t point anyone at this time. But ifl can I?ll, I?ll give you guys a call. That was my very next question, if something comes up yeah will you call us and let us know? I will. I?ll keep my eyes, my eyes and ears open. Page 14of15 with anything we don?t ever say that you pointed us to that person. Okay. We?d come in there with a different. Okay. know we say we got information or whatever we have to say we don?t We?re not gonna burn ya. We?re not gonna burn (inaudible), Alright. (inaudible) put you in a bad place right. Okay. Is there anything else that I haven?t asked you that ah if you were in my shoes is important to know? That ah, that you know that you think is important enough to share about this? Anything at all? Um, not at this time. You done? Yep. Alright ah we?re gonna end this statement now. The time is 1518 hours. END OF RECORDING. Page 15 of15 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/76 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Primary Information-- Description: Joseph Lane Jr. statement Occurrence From: 12l07l2015 16:02 Occurrence To: 12l07l2015 16:27 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: KANE, Kevin (Special Agentl FBI) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/1412015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On December 7, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane interviewed Elks Lodge security of?cer Joseph Lane Jr. Item 76.1 (audio CD interview) obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 vocc?rted a Primary Information Address: 2100 PLYMOUTH AVE Minneapolis Urban League, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Subject #1 .. #1 JR Primary Information Subject Name: Lane, Joseph JR Record Type: Person Bio: 60 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Bel?81mm; am HOME ADDRESS 2133 SOUTH AVE E, North St. Paul, Minnesota 55109 United States Telephones E-Addresses mm mm sumecrs PHONE subjeet - MENTION in REPORIM mammal Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05l03l1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/7 6 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Sul?iect? MENTION Glarkul?merg?sal continued Primary Information - Continued Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number ?ag FBI ID 717111FD1 OID 232941 Minnesota State ID Minnesota gum As Of Date Fictitious NO NO NO Comment Property #1 Audio CD - Joseph Lane Jr. statement Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Description: Property Status: BCAI HQ Status Date: 12/08/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Audio CD - Joseph Lane Jr. statement Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/08/2015 14:01 Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/2015 1 1 :36 Reporting . .. . - . - . Supervisor" . . Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2l26l2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following'page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13237 Page 2 of3 On Monday, December 7, 2015, SA Olson and FBI SA Kevin Kane interviewed Joseph Lane Jr. SA Olson learned during this investigation that Mr. Lane was working security for the Elks Lodge during the evening of November 14, and during theearly morning hours of the 15th. SA Olson previously made arrangements with Mr. Lane to meet at the Minneapolis Urban League located at the northeast corner of Broadway and Penn Ave N. The interview with Lane took place in a private meeting room near the main ?oor lobby of the building. The interview began at about 1602 hours and concluded at about 1627 hours. Lane reported he has previously worked at the Elks Lodge on numerous occasions along with Charesse Douglas (see Mr. Lane reported he observed a female victim being transported by paramedics to the back of an ambulance. He indicated he later observed two uniformed Minneapolis police of?cers Speaking with Clark and later saw a ?struggle? between of?cers? and Clark on the ground. Mr. Lane reported he did not hear any dialog between Clark and either of?cer. He reported the crowd of at least ten people was yelling in the direction of Clark and the of?cers. Mr. Lane said he heard the shot and immediately looked over and saw one of?cer standing over Clark and one of?cer struggle to get up from his back. Lane reported the crowd quickly became loud and dif?cult to manage after the gunshot. Mr. Lane said the portion of the struggle he observed lasted about 5 6 seconds, but added he did not see the entire event from the time Clark was taken to the ground. Mr. Lane reported at no time did he observe handcuffs on Clark. SA Olson transferred the audio data from this interview to a CD labeled as item 76.1. (See attached transcript for complete details). It should be noted that SA Olson received a written report generated by Mr. Lane on this incident from Security Solutions and has attached it to this report. End report. . 'Age; {ft/1 p} n'?mrw?. - -. enameeg?m?i??fme?swk? ?rsw?t?mm?ew? Well we Jr Print Name Shootino 11 I15 l2Q1? AM (AMIPM Nature of Incident Date Tim Where did incident take place: in front 9f t?jj Ave mom] Minneapolis Who was involved/ Personfs: We Witnesses: Agent Joseph Lane Agent Q??fg?g Douglas mm The facts Wm Description and all details. On November l5, 2015 Charess Dougias and I started our patrot to the west parking lot of the Elk?s Lodge I looked across the street and saw two Minneapolis Police of?cer standing and talking to a young man. We continue to the parking lot On our return from the parking lot! looked across the street and saw two Minneapolis Police Officer and the young man on the ground. People were not happy with the way police was handling the young man. i turn my attention back to the crowd to get them to leaved the area then I heard a gun shot I tumed around and saw one of?cer standing over the young man who was not moving and the other of?cer was stiil on the ground. Were police noti?ed? (x yes If so, by whom Paramedics (Name) What Time: MA which Department MPD I I . I, . Signature of Person completing-report: Date: I /9 11/75 x) 4:13.. Supervisor Signature: - Date: I I (-5 Use the back of this incident form if additional space is needed MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: December 7, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Joseph Lane Jr. (JL) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Olson, Chris (CO) SA Kane, Kevin (KK) REVIEWED BY: CO Today?s date is December 2015, we are currently at the um Urban League is that the name of this building? JL Yes. CO Located at Penn Avenue and Broadway in North Minneapolis. This statement is taking place at, with respect to BCA Case Number 2015-648. The time now is 16:01 hours. Present um for this statement is myself, um Joseph Lane Junior, date of birth FBI Special Agent Kevin Kane and were in a private meeting room on the main level of the building. Um your home address Joe is 2133 South Avenue East, is that right? JL Yes. CO And that?s in North St. Paul 55109? JL Correct. 00 All right, and I?ve got a cell phone number for you of?, JL Yes. CO And as ou heard me um, denoting your name, um and birth day, which I don?t know ifl did .. JL That?s correct. CO Okay. And your home address is correct? Um, I contacted you, initially I think this weekend didn't I, and asked you if you JL Um?hm. CO come in and give a voluntary statement, and you agreed? JL Yes. CO And it?s my understanding that you were a security um, your employed as a security person at the Elks Lodge on the evening of the 14th um this last 14th and into the morning of the is that right? JL Correct. Page 1 of 18 working that detail with? Charesse Douglas. All right. Someone um you?ve worked with many times in the past is that right? Yes. And you, I understand I talked to Charesse already, I (inaudible) as I understand you guys have been working or had this contract your company Security Solutions is that right? Right. You?ve had this contract for um months, several months? Several months, yes. Okay, and so you?ve probably worked in that environment dozens of times is that accurate? Oh yeah pretty close yeah. Okay, um so and I don?t want to put words into your mouth but um, I don?t, it was an ordinary night up until about what 12:40 in the morning, right? I mean was there anything remarkable about the evening? Somewhere around in there. Okay. Pretty um standard up till then. Okay, and then at some point um why don?t you just articulate for me in your own words what happened? Um what part are looking at? Well From the part when the Police arrived or? Yeah let?s start from when you first laid Okay on the decedent Mr. Clark. The urn Paramedics we heard them Okay. Sirens, lights, they pulled up across the Um-hm. Page 2 of 18 and they went in, stayed for a while then they came out and they brought a young lady out on a, in a what they call the urn stair chair. Okay. So they And I didn?t see him right away, and then um, a ?cores you know my attention went somewhere else, come back over then um he?s standing there and the Paramedics standing there, you know so they was having words talking. And how many Paramedics were there Two. Okay. There was two Paramedics. All right was the back door of the rig open or closed? Um eventually it was cuz they had to take the gurney out. Okay all right. So the doors open then and they put her on a stretcher. 80 um I left them doing that you know, doing that stuff around the building and um later um during the time when was folks starting to leave um turned around noticed the cops was there. Okay. So they was standing there talking to a young man. So we gonna do a patrol on the parking lot cuz when people starting leaving the building we start doing our rounds and stuff. 80 um when we went to um, to go up there, to the corner, they was standing there talking. So we turned around come back down again after we checked out the parking lot and um i looked over and noticed that they on the ground. You know so, And when you say The two Officers and the young man. Okay. Down on the ground, and the crowd is hollering well look what they doing to him, that?s not right and stuff like that. Though I turned my attention back to the crowd to try to get people to, to move on. And then that's when heard the gun shot. Okay. You know so i turned around and one cop was standing, the young man was down not moving, and the other cop was still on the ground. Okay. Um could you hear um, going back a little bit, can you hear any discussions or conversations occurring between the Paramedics, between Mr. Well what I heard from the Paramedics was that, I don?t know you, she don?t know you and I didn?t quite get what he said. Okay. Page 3 of18 But that's about all I got out of the conversation. But was (inaudible) oh go ahead. Was he responding to the Paramedics? Yeah he was talking but I couldn?t make out what he was saying. Oh okay. All right. Um, and then the squad car arrived um, did w, the first squad car to Well I didn?t see them arrive. Okay. You know I. was, wad'nt standing there watching the whole thing. Okay. Pan out, you know, I?m working so I?m doing my thing then I look over, doing my thing, then look over. 80 um doing taking care of business, I turn around and look and the squad was there and I say oh, the squad arrived. Okay. You know, and then that?s when we?z gonna go up and do a round and then come back. Okay. Um, was, did you have a feel for what was happening or why the Paramedics were talking to him? At the time no. Okay. And, and now, (inaudible) you?ve gleaned something from the media and the (inaudible) Well we know it was a Okay. a deal going on so. But that wasn?t apparent to you at the time? No. Okay, and Mr. Clark was he um normal was he agitated, was he Well he was just standing there, i mean it was, he was just standing there no motion you Okay. body wise, anything like that. Um he wasn?t screaming or anything like that. Okay. Um Dave, I heard com? Paramedic cuz he sounded a little upset. Page 4 of 18 The Paramedic sounded upset? Yeah his voice was raised a little bit, so that?s probably why i could hear him more than I could hear the other guy. Okay, all right. You know, so yeah. Then when the Officers got on scene, um can you tell me where they were standing in relation to where you were? Well they was right across the street, um you have the front door of the Elk?s here and I?m over here, we were over here. So your you?re a little bit east of the front door? Yeah. Okay. No west. Oh your west, closer to Penn? West pointing this way yeah. All right. So they kinda like at an angle right here across the street. Okay. So you got the two cops here, and the individual right here. All right. Facing one another. Okay, and how close were they standing to the ambulance for example? I say probably six feet or Pretty close. It wasn?t real, yeah it was close but they wad'nt that close. Okay, um and as far as you know it looks like a routine, at that point it looked like a routine encounter with a subject and two Police Officers, there?s nothing remarkable at that point? At that point no. Okay. You know I didn?t hear any voices from either one of them. Page 5 of 18 From um Mr. The or the Officers. Right. Okay, and what was happening to the crowd outside at that junction. Well the crowd it was um closing Okay so what? and people coming out as usual talking you know mulling around before they get ready to take off you know, talking to one another and stuff, it?s kinda like a slow process as people move on, you know then um I wasn?t looking but by the crowd you could tell like you know look what they doing to him and this kinda stuff you know so. And at that point something started to Yeah something started to happen then I wad?nt aware of at the time. So it, it developed when wad?nt looking. Okay, and then at some point though did you look over to see what was happening? Well yeah when wez um, wait a minute, when we um, no wait a minute, nope not at that time. Okay. Now when, when they was coming out and talking and stuff, as i said earlier, that?s when we went to do our rounds. Okay, and were you with Charesse? And that?s Basically within arm?s reach of him or did Yeah. Okay So that?s when I looked over and saw the Officers and the young man talking. Okay. Then we went up the street. 80 then 1 come back down, when I turn my attention to them, was trying to get them to move, that?s when the crowd came in, well look what they doing to him, you know that?s not right. You know then shots fired. Then you heard a shot fired. Yeah. 80 did you happen to see a muzzle flash or did you see anything like that? No. Page 6 of 18 Cuz you weren?t looking. I wasn?t looking. Okay. All, all i heard was the gun shot. And you didn?t hear any sort of um conversations except for the stuff you were hearing from the people on your side of the street? Right. Okay, you didn?t hear any dialogue from the south side of Plymouth Avenue? Um and what happened, I mean obviously gunshot probably drew your attention over Right. And so what happened right away, what did you observe? i turned around, like I say, when I turned around the um one Officers that was standing over him, guy wasn?t moving, and the other Officer was trying to get off the ground. Okay, let's try to describe that a little bit, let?s talk about the decedent Mr. Clark, was he, how was he positioned at that point? After your attention has been directed over there? You know I didn't get um I didn?t focus Okay. Yup so you don?t know how he was positioned. No Okay. All i know, he was down on the ground. Okay, so he?s either on his stomach or his back but you couldn?t tell? Or maybe his side it?s okay if you don?t No, no seriously you know, looked over and I looked at him and looked at him and looked at him. Okay. So it was more like a quick glance and then the crowd and then I went back to the crowd. Okay. You know so it?s, yeah. It?s just a matter of seconds that you looked over there? Yeah, so I didn?t look and then stand there and look. Page 7 of18 the Officer that was getting up was he getting up from a like a, off of his stomach or off of his back Well he was side or couldn?t you tell? He was roll, well I kinda focused on him cuz he was struggling to get up off the ground. Okay. You know, and stuff. And it was before or after the gunshot, after? It was after. Okay, so he?s struggled to get off Yeah he was trying to get up. And um can, try to articulate that struggle for me so I can try to visualize it? Um, well he was um I know he ended up on his back trying to um roll over and get up. Okay, so at some point he was on his back? Just moving around trying to get up. Okay, and what was the, in your estimation the period of time from um, from when the Officers arrived until you hear the gun shot, um what, what was that in terms of time Time wise would be um pure guess. Okay, I l, I you know um. You know it wasn?t a half of an hour right? No it wad?nt no half an hour. Okay was it um like a minute, was it five minutes? Couldn?t can?t say? You know um, guess'timation I probably say, Okay. somewhere around there, you know time to walk up to the parking lot and come back. I would guess'timate that. And did to be accurate time I don?t have. Was it the crowd um you were dealing with on your side of the Um?hm. were they objecting to what-was happening, when that was happening were all three of them standing up or were they already on the ground? Page 8 of18 The When the crowd started getting involved. When they was getting involved that?s when my attention went to them, turned around and the gunshot went off. So my question is, is the crowd gets No they, were they all standing up that's when they got into on the ground. Okay. They on the ground. So that was the crowds response. So um like I turned my attention to the crowd and then they started talking and stuff and then the gunshot went off. Okay. They was saying what they was saying and the gunshot went off and that's when turned around. So if, if there was a time when all three of them were standing there, the crowd at that point wasn?t getting to in to it? No pretty much watching. Okay all right. You know. It?s when, when he was brought to the ground that they started getting agitated? Well I think it, um, you know I can?t say. Okay. I really can?t say on that one cuz like I say, I?m, l?m facing the crowd at that time. Okay. You know wait a minute, no they was, yeah cuz when I came back they was on the ground. Um did you um from where you were standing, have occasion to notice if any handcuffs were urn part of this event, in any capacity? No didn?t um see that at all. So you didn?t observe any handcuffs at any point? Um-um. Page 9 of 18 Did you, was there anyone um providing first aid to Mr. Clark? Or attending to him after the gunshot? There was um I believe a Paramedic Supervisor was there. Okay. And that um I know one time I looked over um he had looked at him but I didn?t see anyone attending, attending to him. Okay, but so, at some point though there was two uniform Minneapolis Officers, there's someone that appears to be an emergency first aid person or a Um-hm. outside and there?s probably was there an additional one ortwo Paramedics in the rig? They, afterwards they finally took off. Okay, so I guess, what I?m trying to get at is how many Paramedics were at the scene? There was two per? Paramedics to start. Okay. And then, there was um a, what is that kinda like a Suburban? Oh okay a full size suburban? Yah. Okay. Cuz I know Paramedics they run around with a Supervisor in a Suburban. And did it have the name of the provider on it? Like if it was Hennepin County or North or don?t you remember? Paramedics I believe was Hennepin County, so I would assume that would probably be Hennepin County Supervisor. Okay all right, and was that the person that was um dealing with Mr. Clark um or was it the actual No it was actually one of the Paramedics. Okay, okay. Well I didn?t see this gentleman till later. Okay. You know I don?t know if he um arrived before the Police or after the Police. Okay. All right, but you do recall a suburban was parked there? Yeah he did, there was one there. Page to OHS All right, well the vehicles were positioned um then if you don?t remember that?s fine, but obviously Yeah. an ambulance out on the street, and there was, what was the next vehicle, was it Well de um, I know the police vehicle was there and I can?t get a real good call on the suburban. But I know it was there. Did um, were there emergency lights activated on that police vehicle, the first one that showed up to handle the call, or um I?m assuming the headlights were on cuz it Yeah headlights was on, didn?t notice the lights. You didn?t notice? Um-um. Okay, um what happened immediately, I know what happened to the crowd immediately after the gun went off, um could ya', did ya? have occasion to continue to observe the Officers or was all you attention then directed towards crowd control? Well after the shot round, and looked over there and saw that he was down in this crowd really started going. Okay. Really start um gettin? worked up. Okay. So Cherise and I tried to um get them to kinda settle down and move on and that was useless so we discontinued to do that. So by the time I started to focus back over there, more officers start to arrive. Okay. And they start taping off the Okay. shutting thig down. Did you, by virtue of working at the club, do you know any of the ones, any of the people standing on the sidewalk that may have observed the actual shooting event or the events that led up to that? Na? it was pretty, it was pretty, it was pretty Okay. you know and it wasjust like um to pick someone out of the crowd no. Okay, but so you don?t specifically know of one person, for example that was, that you know by name that was there and probably would have seen No. Page11of18 Okay, um in terms of, when the gunshot went off, how many people in your estimation were outside with the ability, not saying they saw anything, but with the by virtue of the timing, with the ability to It was definitely over ten. Okay. And of cores during the, the cores of that time people still coming out. I understand. You know so. And um were those ten were all on the north side of the street No just south, well there um everybody?s on the urn north side of the street that?s coming out of the club. Yeah, were there, did you observe other witnesses or people on the south side over by the apartments and/or Well that was um people urn across, you got the doorway here, you got the apartment side um side here, then you have the um lower single, double head up and down that people was there. Okay. How long they was there, I don?t know. Okay, so you can?t say whether they were there prior Prior to it, no. or after. No. Okay, cuz at some point they came from everywhere. Yeah eventually you got people everywhere. All right, and then do you remember the general affect or disposition of the Officers immediately after the gunshot um in terms of their behavior, was it um was there anything remarkable that you remember, were they calm, were they afraid, were Well da? the one Officer that was just standing there looking down. Okay. You know like I say the other one was trying Was trying to get up? Yup getting? up off da? ground so. Okay, and could you tell from your vantage point though if there was any sort of articulable emotion um, um being displayed and if you don?t know that fine? Page 12 of 18 Na? just standing there looking down. And so the distance, l'm guessing, um during most of your observations in terms of feet would have been, you know, across the street and over a little bit, right? Um-hm. Closer to the front door? Yeah. Okay, so I?m guessing what, thirty, forty feet, somewhere in there? Um yeah is probably somewhere around in there. Okay, do you know of anyone um since this happened on the fifteenth, it?s now um the seventh so it?s been three weeks, do, do, do you, have you encountered anyone that has observed this or been a potential witness that you've talked with this about that, that saw it? Um no. Okay, have I didn?t do a lot of dialogue with people about it. All right, you don?t engage people? Right. understand. Do you um don?t, you don?t know of any existing video, cell phone video or anything like that, that exists if someone?s reluctant Not that I am aware of. Okay. Agent Kane. What did the police do after the shot rang out? And The two Officers? you saw the guys struggling, yeah you saw one like standing there looking down then ya, one guy was like struggling to get up off his Yeah. Did you continue to watch um? No. Okay is that when you turned your Yeah. 80 you don?t, did you ever look back and see the Officers after that? Or is that the last thing that you saw? Um that's pretty much the last thing that I saw. You know, um like I say, then trying to work the crowd, get things going, you know it was um yeah, it was pretty, pretty wild. Page 13 of18 You did see people taping the event though didn?t ya? Well there was a cell phones out. Okay. Did you see cell But I didn?t, didn?t know, I didn?t know any of um, um personally. You know I couldn't pick them from, yeah go ahead. Did you recall weather a cell phone was out priorto the shot? Or there was No. Okay This was all after what I saw. I understand. Is there anything that would lead you to believe that, that, believe that they shot went off and surprised one of the Officers, or both of the Officers? Knowing something happens and somebody didn?t Right. it was going to happen and someone looks surprised, like there demeanor is supr', they looked surprised, or like whoo, did any, do you remember anything like Um?um. in any way? Okay. And just to reiterate, I think we?ve talked about this but, you didn't hear any sort of dialogue Between the Officer and between the Officer and Mr. Clark? No. All right, you?re, the only dialogue you heard um was from the Paramedics. Was from the Paramedics. Yeah. Paramedics with him. And the Paramedic was And what the um, the Officers and the young man that was more like look over see them standing there talking and then turn around and walk up the street. Was there a struggle on the ground that occurred between the Officer and the, and the Mr. Clark? You know, Page 14 of18 That you recall? know they was down on the ground, and well i assume they were. Okay, there?s a reasonable conclusion then in your mind anyways that they were probably struggling? Yeah, well if he's going down they struggling. Okay. You know. Right. But that was just look over and then back to, to the crowd. Okay, and I, just ta, I know it?s a guess on your part, but that struggle lasted, in your estimation? That would be turning five, six seconds? Okay. Its pretty quick. The struggle was quick? Well da' from when I looked over and turned Oh, okay. but from the beginning of when they started to the shot, I have no time on, timeline on that one. The only timeline have is when I looked over and they was on the ground and turned around to tend to the crowd and then the gun shot. And then the gun shot. And that was what period of time? That was short. Okay, seconds? Seconds. Yeah. 80 but its possible they could have been on the ground longer than that because you don?t know when they went to Right I don?t know when You didn?t see any (inaudible) take him to the ground. Okay. All right. We asked you if you saw any handcuffs? Um didn?t see any handcuffs. Did you ever think or perceive the guy to be handcuffed? Um no. Okay. Page 15 of 18 your impression that um perhaps um, I?m guessing but, I don?t want to put words in your mouth, was your impression that he was going to be arrested? (laughing) Was that your impression? When they take you down you going to jail. Normally when you go hands on, someone has to go, so. Somebody?s going down, right. So that was your impression. Well yeah. I mean once they take you down, it means your resisted arrest. So. Okay all right. Have you heard people talking about this at the Elks Club since this happened two weeks ago? Well people you know, wanna engage with the conversation, and i didn?t get into it, you know what I?m saying, it wad?nt right and stuff like that so. i didn?t engage in that. All right. What's the general thought at the Elks Club about this event? It was bad. I know, but I know that, I know that?s a heated, the topic is whether or not he was handcuffed let?s just focus on what?s general consensus is handcuffed or not handcuffed? I haven?t, I haven?t had any, hear any conversation on that. Just that, how bad it was. Okay. You know that he didn?t have to die, that kind of stuff, um handcuffs wad?nt mentioned. Okay. At least from the individuals that approached me. You been in the security business for yearsare you know? Yup. Okay. Um how long have you been with this current company? I think about five months? Okay. Page160f18 think. All right. I have nothing additional. But if um, as we ask anyone if something comes up, due to your position I mean your, are you going to work there still? Yeah. Okay, so if something would come up where someone, you?d hear that someone has video or photos or Oh sure. Or even an witness, you know? I saw And were not asking if you?d give us a call Yeah I can do that. And we would never point them you know we never, we never through ya out there. (laughing) won?t through me under the buss? No we don?t do that. (laughing) We be very successful if that?s how we worked, so. Yeah I wouldn?t have no problem. Is there anything I haven?t asked you that you think is maybe important for me to know? Um, no that?s, that?s pretty much it. Okay. Your kinda difficult to track down, did Who me? Yeah, I it took us the longest time through the (inaudible) to figure out who you guys were? Did you guys know we were looking for ya up until recently? Well I figured you?d be around sooner or later. (laughing) All right. Come to us, call us. Yeah next time um give ljust figured you?d be here sooner than later. I get that all the time. Yeah. Page 17 of18 GO All right I am actually end this statement now the time is 16:27 hours. (End of recording) Page 18 of18 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/77 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Primary-Information Description: Review audio recording of MPD interview with Rayann Hays Occurrence From: 12/03/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 12/03/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/09/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 i MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On 12/03/2015 SA Henning was requested by SA Phill to review the audio recorded interview of Rayann Hays by Minneapolis Police. No evidence was generated by nature of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 1439 MARYLAND AVE Primary information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects Relationship Name BE 11?3 BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Subject #1 VICTIM #1 - HAYS, RAYANN FRANCINE Primary information Subject Name: HAYS, RAYANN FRANCINE Record Type: Person Bio: 41 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Subject SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal; Primary information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/77 Report Date: 12/03/2015 Subject #2 SUBJECT #1 - Clark, JamarOneaI - Continued . Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications 19.11% We; ?ats 9m FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Record Status Information - Record Origination Operator: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/08/2015 14:06 Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/09/2015 09:28 Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: . Supervisor; I i - I Date Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO . Date- . Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Narrative begins =onrithegfollowing page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On 12/03/2015 SA Henning was requested by SA Phill to review the audio recording of an interview with Rayann Hays to determine if a follow-up interview needed to be completed. The interview was conducted by the Minneapolis Police Department. SA Henning reviewed the interview of Hays and determined that another interview of Hays did not need be conducted. SA Henning provided this information to SA Phill. SA Henning attached a copy of the transcribed statement to this report. Please see the transcript for complete detail of interview. No evidence was generated by nature of this report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 15, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEWED BY: . . INTERVIEW OF: Rayann Francine Hayes (RH) Sergeant Villella Minneapolis PD REVIEWED BY: Hi. Hi how are you doing, do you want a chair? TV Ah (inaudible) I?ll stand, thank you though. (Inaudible) sorry about and so it?s Rayann? RH Yes. TV Okay, remember l-l?m just wanna take a statement from you on what happened to you last RH Okay. TV night so I'll put my tape recorder over here so we can hear it well. (Inaudible background talking) TV It?s cold in here. (Inaudible) (Inaudible talking). TV Need something for your hands? You got something? (Inaudible) that one, alright, um, is it broken, your leg? RH (Inaudible). TV Do you want me to get the nurse first? RH (Inaudible) [just need to move it. (Inaudible). TV Set this over here. Okay I?m Sergeant Villella with Minneapolis Police Homicide. RH Hm. TV And I?m here to talk to you about what happened to you. RH Um?hm. TV So what is your first name? RH Rayann, capital TV And your last name? RH Hayes, TV Do you have a middle name Rayann? Page 1 of 12 RH TV Yes, Francine. Francine? (Phone ringingPhill-2015-648-A02 Sergeant Villella. Okay, hang on one second, I?m in this room doing this interview right now but (lnaudible) (laughs). Alright, (inaudible) you said it was Francine? Um?hm, E, okay. Hm. What?s your date of birth? And what is your home address? 1223 Morgan. Is that a house or apartment? (lnaudible). And what?s the phone number there? (lnaudible). There?s no phone? Cell phone number at all? (lnaudible). Okay. Do you work? Uh, part time as a (inaudible). Part time? Um?hm. Okay like where? Oh, my friend has a cleaning company (inaudible). Okay. (lnaudible) like um bars and schools and stuff (inaudible) department stores and stuff like that. Alright what were you doing over at 1611 Plymouth today? Uh my friends live across the hall. Well my daughter stays in this building? Oh your daughter lives in that building? Yeah, she lives upstairs. Okay. And um my friend stays under my daughter and the people across the hall from her, uh it was his wife?s birthday so he was having a little get?together for her birthday. Page 2 of 12 TV Okay so what apartment does your daughter live in? RH 204. TV 204? RH And they stay in 104 and the people across the hall are in room 106. TV Across the hall, so which one was having the party? RH Downstairs. TV 104. RH Yeah. TV 104? RH 103. TV 103 was having the party and what are their names? RH Um, Alfred, or something like that, I know her name is Keylandra(SP?) or something like that I?m not really sure. TV Okay and who stays with your daughter in 204? RH Uh no ope, TV Just your daughter? Does she have children? RH My granddaughter yeah. TV Okay how old is your daughter? RH She?s 24. TV Okay and what?s her name? RH Shamirra. TV Shamirra, spell it. RH TV Shamirra okay, what?s her last name? RH (lnaudible) TV Okay do you know, does she have a phone number? RH (inaudible). TV Okay, you don?t know if she has a phone? RH Um no, her phone just got turned off. TV Okay and how old is her child? RH She?s two. TV Two years old, okay. Okay and who was in apartment 104? RH The people that live (inaudible). TV Do you know their names? RH Yeah. TV Okay. RH TV Sharise? What is her last name? Phill-2015?648-A02 Page 3 of 12 Phill-2015?648-A02 Park. Park? Um-hm. Okay. (lnaudible). Her name, her husband?s name is Jerome Paul? Um-hm. Okay. (lnaudible). Well I just wanna know who all the people were out here. Okay and then um Jamar Clark, that?s (inaudible). Jamar Clark? Um?hm. Okay. (lnaudible) Ronnie, Ronnie Powell. Okay. And it was basically all the people that were there. At the party (inaudible) at 103? Yeah. For Alfred and Keylandra? Yeah. Right, do you know what their last names are? Hm. No? How long have you known these people? Urn, maybe about a year. Okay, that, even the ones in 104? See, Al and (inaudible) they don?t stay in 104. No, they live in 103? Yeah. Who lives (inaudible) how long have you known the people in 104? Um maybe about a year since I met. Okay so what time did you get at the place today? Hmm, we took the kids to the park, came back so maybe like 7:30-8, somethin? like that. Okay and then what?d you guys do? Nothin?, we just sat around for a minute and then Al came over and he was like um, it?s my wife?s birthday and we?re having a surprise get together for her you guys can come on over (inaudible) like okay. Okay so that was you and your daughter and the people from 104? No, my daughter was never there. Page4of12 Phill-2015-648?A02 Never there? Okay. i went downstairs with Sharise. With Sharise, okay. And that?s when we went over to their house. Okay, did you guys drink? Yeah. Okay how much did you drink? Um, well like, 2 shots, 2 and 1/2 shots (inaudible) i had 2 shots and then um (inaudible) cosmopolitan. Anything else? No. Any narcotics? No. No Marijuana. Marijuana? Okay, so while you?re out there, you guys get in argument or what, what goes on? No, l, i really, really don?t know actually what this made everything just pop off like that you know it?s just, everybody was hanging out, having a good time (inaudible). And then what happened, what happened here? Honestly I can?t even tell ya exactly what happened ?cuz I don?t know like, we, um, okay, we were sittin? down playin? In who?s apartment? In Al, 103? Al, yeah. Okay. We?re sitting there playin? cards and they got to arguing about Who?s they? Kiki and Al, I?m not really sure, (inaudible) they weren?t making it everybody?s business. They weren?t talking loud or anything. So, the people that live in 103 were arguing with each other okay? l-l wouldn?t even say arguing. Okay. They were just uh having a discussion with each other. Okay. ?Cuz they weren't being loud or anything like that. So I I mean I don?t know like everything went whack so fast. Well um what happened to your face and what happened to your legs? Page 5 of 12 PhilI-2015-648?A02 Um, Al was saying something, like everything happened so fast it was ridiculous. Okay. Ya know I can?t reallyjust pinpoint one thing that made everything happen. Okay, were you fighting with somebody? No, was breaking, my (inaudible) they were arguing (inaudible) separate them two. Okay, Kiki and Yes. And they were arguing? Yeah I was trying to separate them two and somehow I got caught in the crossfire (inaudible) and I know, I?m on the ground. I can?t move my leg. I?m like (inaudible) I thought it was broken (inaudible). Okay. (lnaudible) yeah that?s pretty much like I can (inaudible). Okay and so you called the police or you called paramedics to come out to your daughter?s house? Um?hm. And they come out there? Um-hm. And they help you ah down to the ambulance. Do you remember that? Yeah I remember that. Okay and as you?re coming outside you see someone? (lnaudible). Um, um?hm. Okay, when you come outside you tell the paramedics that you see someone that?s responsible for your Yes. you remember telling ?em that? Yes, yeah. And who did you tell ?em was responsible for your injuries? The guy that was standing in front of building. What was his name? (lnaudible whispering) I?m trying to think. I don?t know his name, I don?t really know him like that. But that?s the one like grabbed me (inaudible) so we?re on the ground and he?s banging me against the floor. Okay, so was that Alfred? No, that was, no, not Alfred. Was it one of the other people from 104 like Sharise or Jerome or Jamar or Ronnie? It, you know that what I can?t, I don?t wanna I know who it was. Well who was it? I don?t? know his name. Page 6 of 12 PhilI-2015-648?A02 Okay, what?d he look like? Urn, well the dreadlocks (inaudible) the short black guy with dreadlocks. How old is he? don?t know. 'Cuz he was saying that you're his mother. Yeah and told him I?m not his mom. I don?t even know him like that and I told the officer, I was like no I?m not his mom. He?s the one that (inaudible) did that to me. What, what apartment does he live in? That is um, Sharise, that?s her brother. Sharise's brother. (Inaudible). Um-hm. (Inaudible) okay. And how long have you known him? Well he doesn?t live there not that I know of. Okay. But he?s there frequently so (inaudible) pretty much the same time. I've been going (Inaudible) since we were kids. Okay. just met Sharise well like last year. Who?s, who?s her husband? Jerome. Jerome Paul? Yeah. Okay. I?ve known him since we were kids so ljust met her and him maybe middle last year. How old is Jamar? have no idea. Twenties, thirties, forties? Probably, probably his middle twenties. Was he drinking last night? I have no idea. Was he at the park party with you? He had just came in. Okay. So why didn't he throw you on the ground and start (inaudible) Like I told ?em I said i don?t know what happened. Like why, i weren?t, It wasn't even my (inaudible) argument at all. So I don?t know how I even got in the crossfire at all. But you did. Yeah (inaudible) (inaudible) you. Page 7 of 12 Phill-2015-648?A02 Yeah so And what does he do to you when he grabs on to you? He got me, oh this is what happened. They were arguing, i put, I, I grab em by the arm like this. I'm like just (inaudible) somebody else?s house calm down whatever. The next thing I know I?m being shoved to the ground and getting beat against the floor like, hey. And Jamar did that to you? Yeah and then when I got up, he?s like, oh I?m sorry I thought you were somebody else, what, you know like it?s just out of the blue. Okay. (inaudible) and then then that's when um he came (inaudible). Okay, (inaudible) Do you, do you talk to the officers on the first call? Cuz I understand it?s the paramedics that came up and, (inaudible) house cuz you had an injured ankle. Who told you, no that happened outside. My ankle, this happened outside or in the hallway rather. Okay and who did that? Uh the same person like Bradley like well i got brass I think when we tried to get up and like (inaudible) that?s when twisted my ankle, so. Were you, were you in the apartment when all three of you (lnaudible) the hallway. No (inaudible) we were in the hallway. Hallway of the first floor or the second floor? First floor. (lnaudible). Okay, what time did that happen about? Um I don t? remember. (inaudible) 8:30 maybe. 8:30. (lnaudible). And when did you call, did you call the police (inaudible) report. (inaudible) my own problems. Okay. Cuz when they came, I tell them what happened. Okay. Then everybody just disappeared. Okay and then did the police take a report for you or do you say everything?s (inaudible) Right there? Okay. Um?hm. And then they leave and then what happens? Then you call the paramedics. l, they were already there I never called the paramedics. Who, this officer was with me the whole time after that. Page 8 of 12 Phill?2015-648?A02 Okay, alright. Is it the, the one call comes in at like 20 after 12:00. I never called (lnaudible). I don?t even have a phone so. I don?t know who called in. Well it says Rayann on the 911 call. It says your name right here, that you?re the caller, Rayann. (inaudible) 282 number here. Yeah that?s, that?s Charise's number and I never used her phone. She called ?em (inaudible) cuz I never did (inaudible) Okay well I didn?t take that (inaudible) Yeah she must of called cuz I never called em at all. Okay. That was (inaudible) Okay so and then as the paramedics are bringing you out of the house you tell them and point out Jamar is the person that did this to you, right? Yeah okay they put me in back of the paramedics. The ambulance. Yeah this weirdo, runs up like that?s my mom. I?m like no I?m not well (inaudible) Okay. But no I?m not, he?s the one that did that to me. Okay so while your back there then what happens? He?s still trying to get I, I Does he try to come inside the ambulance with you? Yeah it was like really weird, like I don?t even know this guy like that like why would he go, I'm you mom, attacks me and so I didn?t really understand what, what his whole motive was. What he was doing. Did you see him with any weapons? No, no. Have you ever seen him with weapons? No. No. No. (inaudible) sick? No it was just like (inaudible) Oh. (inaudible) never seen him with any weapons. don?t know. I?ve never seen Okay while you're in the ambulance and the paramedics start giving you, you know the medical procedures that you need done. What, what happens next? He's, he?s trying to get in. Does he ever get in? No. Okay. Page 9 of 12 Phill-2015-648?A02 (inaudible) Okay and then what happens? Um, we came to the hospital and I got I don?t know (inaudible) Did you hear any shots outside? No. No? No. Okay. And he never gets inside? The ambulance? Yeah. No. Never? No. And you never seen him with any weapons? No. But you describe him as, is he an African American male? Um-hm. Okay and you said he short dreadlocks or? There not short. Oh, he?s just short. He?s short. Complexion Okay. Yeah ifl um meet him Is he dark complexion or what? Yeah, like my same color. And where does he live? Now that i don?t know. I don?t? know if he (Inaudible) with his sister. I really don?t know. You don't? know. (inaudible) Is there anything else you can tell me that I haven?t asked you? Um, I?m trying to think. It?s just like everything happened so fast you know. Is there video cameras in your building? I would like to think so but they don?t work so um like everything happened so fast. So you?re on the first floor in the hallway when he knocks you to the ground and banging on the floor? He didn?t knock me to the floor. He, I?m not gonna put that on there like that cuz he did not knock me to the floor. He grabbed me (inaudible) and then when we fell well he like you know (Inaudible) like when your wrestling. He (inaudible). Page 10 of12 Phill?2015-648?A02 Okay. (inaudible) Okay. (inaudible) he?s just kept on my shoulder (inaudible) just let me talk to you. Basicallyjust trying to get my attention in the wrong way. Why did he want your attention? I have no idea. What happened to your lip? He hit me. He punched you? He head butted me. He head butted you. Did you need stiches? Yeah. Alright he head butted you but then wanted your attention because why? I have no idea. i really don?t. I really, really don?t. What was I remember him saying, I remember saying get off of me. And then he was explaining to me what happened. I said, I don?t want to hear it. Get off of me. Explain about what happened about what? I don?t? even know. I, we were playing cards. i really don?t? understand why he?d have anything to say to me whatsoever for why, like for what? It was horrible for me. And you only had two shots and one was it cosmopolitan did you say? (inaudible) (inaudible) Was he mad at you cuz you?re trying to break up Alfred and Keith, their fight? No if he was that would a been a story because they don?t know him like that either. You know what I mean like. Why did he grab on you like that? (Inaudible) I?m thinking like did I say something wrong or and I?m like, no cuz we were all sittin? down playing cards so I didn?t say anything to ?em. I can?t, I don?t know. I don?t know. When the paramedics were bringing you outside did he try to grab you or anything at that time? Yeah. (inaudible) explain (inaudible) like no. What was he like? Was he, was he agitated? Was he happy? Was he screaming? Was he crying? - No he wasn?t, he wasn?t screaming and he wasn?t agitated. He?s um, from what I seen (inaudible) he?s a pretty calm person. So I don?t know what was going on tonight. You know it might a been something else that agitated (inaudible) (inaudible) drugs (Inaudible)? Has he ever beat you in the past? No, i don?t know ?em. How can he beat me when I don?t even know ?em. Well he just did so, right? Gave you that lip. Page 11 of12 didn?t beat me like. (inaudible) stitches. Yeah, well l?m just saying little, 1, I had my own words (inaudible) I'm telling you what happened, no one beat me. Okay. Just craziness, he didn?t beat me. Alright. Was there anything else you want to tell me about this incident that i haven't asked you? Um, no I, ljust can?t believe it happened. You know this was crazy. Just out of the blue. Was he drinking a lot maybe today or doing drugs? As far as i know he doesn?t even drink. He, like my daughter she stays upstairs. They stay underneath my daughter. 80 you know i go down stairs a lot. Our kids play together so and i see ?em you know but he just seemed like a mild tempered person. i never got into an argument with him, never got into a fight or noth-, none of that. So this stuff that happened tonight was like, (inaudible) maybe he was on some type of drug but I don?t know because this is not the same person I?m used to seeing. But you said you say know him maybe for like a year. Yeah, l?ve been around him. Just around (inaudible) different person We never seen him (inaudible). Who, who was all there when this was going on between you two? Everyone. Everyone? Um, me, his sister or my husband he was at a (inaudible). Me, him, his sister, her brother (inaudible) and um Al, kids were there and they had other company over there so it was a pretty (inaudible) a lot of people in there. Okay so Charise, Jerome wasn?t there cuz he was gone at work,Jamar, Ronny Paul and then Afred and Yalonda, Yelonda? Um-hm. Okay and then the kids? Alright, so that?s about all i have to ask you. Nothing else? Nope? Alright. These officers are gonna be able to leave, okay? (inaudible) Alright. END OF TAPE. Page 12 of12 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/78 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information Description: Acquisition of PD Assault Case interviews Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12l16l2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency,.ReferencelNumbers Agency Case/File Number Minneapolis Police Department 15-425874 Synopsis On December 8th 2015, SA Phill receiVed a case report from PD. The case is the assault of Rayann Hayes by Jamar Clark on November 15th 2015. The PD provided 4 CDs of interviews which were entered into ACISS as evidence items 2015-648l78.1 through 78.4. 'A?dferees #17 - Occurred yiisijh;_eLocK Primary Information Address: 1600 BLOCK OF PLYMOUTH AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #1 - FRANCIN Primary Information Subject Name: HAYS, RAYANN FRANCINE Record Type: Person Bio: 41 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Subject #2 WITNESS. #1 Burns, Sharice Lashea Primary Information Subject Name: Burns, Sharice Lashea Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American HeightMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 7? Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/78 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #2 Burns, S?anc'e Laenea Centin?ue'd Personal Information - Continued Weight: 170 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment "3 CAR-D Minnesota United States 1113012015 NO Alias information Alias Clark, Sharice slittith #3 WITNESS-SM - Grease-Darrell V.L:a.sh0rnf .- Primary Information Subject Name: Gross, Darrell Lashorn Record Type: Person Bio: 48 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1615 PLYMOUTH AVE N., Minnespolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/EfAddress CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State Countpl As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota 1111912015 NO LICENSE Subject #4 - WITNESS #3 - Sharp; Nek?eliaLe'vette Primary Information Subject Name: Sharp, Nekelia Levette Record Type: Person Bio: 39 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N. APARTMENT #103, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/78 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject_#4 Sharp, Nekeiia Layette?Continued Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address a CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS - Minnesota 11/19/2015 NO LICENSE Alias Information Alias Kiki S-l?ibiect #5 Stead, G?aila. lyssa Primary Information Subject Name: Stroud, Chala lyssa Record Type: Person Bio: 27 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APARTMENT #203, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States subject -, SUBJECT #1 unglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects mm _i_0 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #7 SUBJECT - SchWarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of? Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/78 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #7 SUBJECT Timothy -_Continu_ed Primary information - Continued Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name __iq EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subjedit?n NEIGHBOR #1 - Stanley, Antonio Primary Information Subject Name: Stanley, Antonio Record Type: Person Bio: Black, Male Juvenile: NO Property #1 stroud?a Stanley. Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of PD contacts with Stroud Stanley Property Status BCA I HQ Status Date: 12I08I2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I78.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - CD Gentaining?Au?di?o of PD Interview of Sharice Clark (Burns) Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of PD Interview of Sharice Clark (Burns) Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 1210812015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I78.2 -- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-1348/78 Report Date: 12/08/2015 PrOperty #2 - CD Containing Audio of PD Interview of Sharice Clark (Burns) - Continued Primary Information - Continued UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property/:3 {co PDI?rjtervieiv of?NekeltiaSharpj,2 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of PD Interview of Nekelia Sharp Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 12/08/2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I78.3 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Prdiaerty - CD Containing Audio of PD Interview'of Darren Gross Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of PD Interview of Darrell Gross Property Status: BCA I HQ Status Date: 12/08/2015 Quantity: 1 . Control Number: 2015-648I78.4 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/08/2015 14:46 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/16/201513:33 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 5 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Investigative Supplement 2015-648/7 8 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Reporting LEO Date Apprehension) Apprehension) . . . . . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Narrative begins on-the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 6 of 7 On December 8th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received a Minneapolis Police Department (Mpls PD) assault case ?le PD case number 15-425 874 detailed the PD Detectives attempts to investigate the assault of Rayann Hayes by Jamar Clark on November 15th 2015. The assault report and 4 discs of interviews were given to SA Olson by Commander Granger of the PD on December 7th 2015. SA Phill submitted the discs to ACISS as evidence items 78.1 thru 78.4 and the audio from the discs was transcribed into 3 interviews. One disc contained two apartment contacts that did not result in interviews. The three successful interviews were of Detective Sergeants McCarty and Osland speaking to Sharice Clark (Burns), Darrell Gross and Nekelia Sharp. The three transcripts have been attached to this report. MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 1 0f 11 Case Report with Minnea olis Police De artment CCN: NIP-15425874 Supplements Report Details Reporting Of?cer: 004523: Stephen McCarty Approval Status: Approved Assisting Of?cer: Approval Date: Nov 18. 2015 Supervising Of?cer: 002774: Donald Harris Date Returned: Approving Supervisor: 002774: Donald Harris Return Count: 0 CalIISqd: Date Printed: Dec 7. 2015 Precinct: 04 Last Uploaded: Nov 25. 2015 Related CON: - Reported Date: Nov 18. 2015 07:33 Primary Rooted Unit: 4116 -Assault Entered By: 004523 Assigned Investigators: 004523: McCarty. Stephen 0053?6: Osland. Mark Incident Details Offense'l: ASLT3 Address: Occurred From: Occurred To: Location: Minor Involved: Desc: Bdly Hm 1611 Plymouth AV Minneapolis. MN 55411 1111512015 00:10 10152015 04:00 Knox Av N?ames Av No Statute: 609.223 Dispatched: Arrlved: Cleared: Attempted: 00:00:00 00:00:00 00:00:00 Pubtic Data Assault Report. .. 12/7/20 I 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - NIP-15425874 Page 2 of 11 Victim Role I Role V001 Name: Hayes, Rayann Francine Residence: 1223 Morgan AV Minneapolis. MN 55411 Telephone: Date of Birth: Event Age: 41 Est. Age: 41 - 41 Race: Black Medical Treatment: Yes Sex: Female Height: Build: Victlm of: ASLTB Witness Role I Role W001 Name: Lenders, Albert Residence: 1611 Plymouth AV Apt. 103 Minneapolis, MN 55411 Telephone: Date of Birth: Event Age: 51 Est. Age: 51 - 51 Race: Black Sex: Male Helght: Build: Witness Role I Role W002 Name: Sharp. Nekelie Residence: 1611 Plymouth AV Apt. 103 Telephone: Date of Birth: Event Age: 38 Est. Age: 38 - 38 Race: Black Sex: Female Helght: Build: Witness Role I Role W003 Name: Powell, Ronnie Residence: Unknown Telephone: C:unknown Date of Birth: Event Age: 0 Est. Age: 0 Race: Black Sex: Male Helght: Build: I 2/ 7/20 1 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MP-15-425874 Page 3 ofll Witness Roie I Role W004 Marne: Clark, Sharlce Residence: 1611 Plymouth AV Apt. 104 Telephone: Czunknown Date of 53mm Event Age: 0 Est. Age: 0 Race: Black Sex: Female Height: Build: Witness Role I Role W005 Name: Gross. Darnell Residence: 1615 Plymouth AV Minneapolis. MN 55411 Telephone: Date of Birth: Event Age: 48 Eat. Age: 48 - 48 Race: Black Sex: Male Height: Build: Other Role I Role Name: Fine. Shamlrra Residence: 1611 Plymouth AV Apt. 204 Minneapolis, MN 55411 Teiephone: C:unknown Date of Birth: Event Age: 0 Est. Age: 0 Race: Black Sex: Female Height: Build: Other Role I Role 0T002 Name: Powell. Jerome Residence: 1611 Plymouth AV Apt. 104 Minneapolis. MN 55411 Telephone: Czunknown Date of Birth: Event Age: 0 Est. Age: 0 Race: Black Sex: Male Height: Build: Relationships 8-2 1 2/ 7/20 ?l 5 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 4 of 11 Subiect Relationshig '1?er meg V001 Hayes. Rayann Acquaintance W001 Lenders. Albert V001 Hayes. Rayann Acquaintance wooz Sharp. Nekefia V001 Hayes. Rayann Acquaintance W003 Powe?. Ronnie OT002 Poweli. Jerome BoyWGirlfriend W004 Clark. Sharice W001 Lenders. Albert Eoy_Gir friend W002 Sharp. Nekelia W004 Clark. Sharice Boy_Girlfriend 0T002 Powell. Jerome V001 Hayes. Rayann Parent OT001 Fine, Shamirra V001 Hayes. Rayann Friend OT002 Poweil. Jerome V001 Hayes, Rayann Friend W004 Clark. Sharice Modus Operandi Categorv Descrigtion Related Offense Comments Cn'me Location Apartment Halfway on the first ?oor Case Supplements 4 supplements begin on the foliowlng page. 12/7/2015 .MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 5 of ll Supplement number: 1 COM: MP-15-425874 Author: 004523 Stephen McCarty Supplement or S.McCarty #004523 on 11/25/2015 08:50 On November 18, was assigned this case. i received con?rmation to proceed with the investigation on November 23. On November 24, Sergeant Mark Osland and I drove to the Victim/Rayann Hayes's house at the listed address. There was no answer at the door. i observed several pieces of mail in the mail box. I left a business card. We then drove to 1611 Plymouth Avenue North to speak with the residents of apartment 103, 104 and 204. When I spoke to thessZ/Nekella Sharp of apartment 103. she clari?ed some of the names listed in this report. (It should be noted that her statement was recorded by Sergeant Osland, Job# 32418). Witness 2 told us that she and her husband. Witness thlbert Lenders were having a party. They invited several people that live in the building to the party, including Witness SIDarrell Gross (aka Dee), Victim/Rayann Hayes and Jamar Clark. At some point during the party Witness llLanders and Witness 2iSharp got into an argument. Witness 2/Sharp stated that she asked everybody to leave. As Witness 1/Landers was leaving the apartment building, the argument between Witness 1/Landers and Witness 2/Sharp that turned physical. This occurred in one of the common areas on the ?rst floor. Witness 2/Sharp stated that while arguing with Witness 1/Landers, Victimfl-iayes grabbed her from behind and put her in a bear hug. According to Witness ZlSharp, Jamar Clark became upset with the victim because she was intervening in their argument. Witness ZlSharp stated that she walked back to her apartment and left Victim/Hayes and Jamar Clark in the common area. Witness 2/Sharp stated that Witness 4lSharice Clark from apartment 104 offered to watch her (Witness 2?s) daughter so she could enjoy the rest of her night. Witness 2/Sharp stated that she was walked back to the common area of the apartment building and at some point Jamar Clark reappeared. She stated that his face was bruised. Clark disappeared after the paramedics arrived. Witness 21Landers stated that she let them inside the building. Moments later she stated that they were escorting VictimIHayes down from the second floor to the ambulance that was parked on Plymouth Avenue. According to the Witness 2/Sharp, the victim was walking. on her own. and was not being carried by paramedics. Vl?tness 2ISharp stated that she was standing in front of 1611 Plymouth when Jamar Clark walked up to the ambulance. Witness 2/Sharp stated that she saw all events that followed. After completing this interview. we walked up to apartment 204 to speak with OT1/Sharnirra Fine (daughter of Vlctimll-layes). As we were approaching the apartment on the second floor, two unidenti?ed males were leaving. i asked them if OT1/Fine was in the apartment was there. They stated no and left. i put a business card underthe door. We went back to the ?rst?oor to attempt to speak with to Ntness 4/Sharice Clark. We were unable to enter the ?rst floor because of the security door. 3 could see through a window several women talking in the hallway between apartments 103 and 104. \Mtness 2/Nekelia Sharp opened the security door for us. As we walked toward the women standing in the hall, Witness 2/Sharp identi?ed one of the women as Witness 4/Sharice Clark. As I walked closer to Witness 4IClark she retreated into apartment 104 and closed the door. Witness 21Landers'told me that she didn't wish to talk to police (based on Witness 4iClark's reaction as I approached her, i would say this was true). 12/7/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements Page 6 of 11 We then went to 1615 Plymouth Avenue North to speak with Dee, aka Witness 51Gross (Sergeant Osiand recorded the interview Job #32419). Witness 5/Gross stated that he was at apartment 103 for the party. He stated that he left prior to the argument. He stated that he didn't see any of the arguing between Witness 'ULandere and Witness 2lSharp. Nor did he see any confrontation between Victim! Hayes and Jamar Ciark. He stated that he did see Victim/Hayes being carried out of the apartment buiiding on a gurney and her put into the ambulance. Additionally, he saw the pcilce arrive at the scene and events that followed. CASE CONTINUED OPEN SERGEANT STEPHEN MCCARTY, BADGE 4523 VIOLENT ASSAULT UNIT END of Sapptement 1 a5 8?2 12/ 7/201 5 CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 7 of 11 Supplement number: 2 CCN: Author: 005376 - Mark Osiand Supplement of NLOsland #005376 on 11/25/2015 09:47 On 11/241115, and Sgt. McCarty went to 1223 Morgan Av in attempt to speak'with the victim. The victim was not home and we left business cards. Sgt. McCarty and I went to 1631 Plymouth AV to speak with witnesses. We attempted to speak with Sharice Clark in Apartment #104 but she refused to speak with us. Job 3241 We spoke with lMtness Nekelia Sharp in apartment#103. Here is a synopsis of the interview concerning the assault: Witness Sharp said for her birthday her husband through her a party with some of the people who live at the apartment building including Jarmar Clark and Victim Rayann Hayes. Vthess Sharp said she normally does not have parties. Witness Sharp said they were drinking and playing cards and as the night went on she decided to shut down the party because of her little daughter. Her husband was going to leave so she had altercation with her husband. Witnbess Sharp said it spiiled out in the lobby of the apartment building. Witness Sharp said she and her husband were pushing on each other and Victim Hayes grabbed a hoid of her to separate them. Witness Sharp said Jarmar Clark became upset with Victim Hayes about getting in the middle of \Mtness Sharp and Albert Lenders argument. Witness Sharp said Victim Rayann Hayes and Jarmar walked away and she went back to the apartment. \Mtness Sharice Clark from #104 offered to take her daughter. Witness Sharpe said she went out in front of the apartment building where she saw Jamar come walking around the side of the apartment building with his face swollen from a ?ght with Victim Rayann Hayes. Jarmar asked Witness Sharp said Jarmar asked for another drink because his sister Sharice kicked him out for the night. Witness Sharp said she went inside and got him another drink and came back outside and gave it to him.- Wltness Sharp was asked if the ?ght between Victim Hayes and Jamar was heated. thess Sharpe said it must have been because she could hear the attercatlon through the walls. Witness Sharp said an ambulance arrived and went upstairs. Witness Sharp said the paramedic came back down walking the Victim Rayann Hayes to the Ambulance. Witness Sharp said Victim Rayann was walking with a limp to the back of the ambulance. Witness Sharp continued describing the events of the incident of the night but did not pertain to our investigation so it was not included in this supplement. Jot) 32419 Sgt. McCarty and spoke with \Mtness Barrett Gross. Here is a synopsis of the interview concerning the assault: Witness Gross said he was at the party but left before the ?ght broke out. Witness Gross said tater he went outside to the front of the apartment buitding and observed Jarmar with a swollen face. Witness Gross said he was told the victim had stemmed Jamar's face into the door. Witness Gross said Jamar Clark was upset but was not angry. Witness Gross said the paramedic came by with Victim Rayann Hayes on a gurney but was in a seated position. Witness Gross went more into detail of the shooting incident but is not part of our investigation so it was not included. Sgt. Mark Osland Assault Unit END of Supplement 2 8?274. .. 12/7/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - NIP-15425874 Page 8 of 11 Supplement number: 3 CCN: MP4 54125874 Author: 005376 - Mark Osiand Supplement of M.Osland #005376 on 11/30/2015 14:2? On 1 1130115. i and Sgt. McCarty went to the apartment building at 1611 Plymouth to look for possible witnesses. Sgt. McCarthy and spoke with several residents including the sister to Jamal Clark. i turned See job 32564. 32565, 32566 and 32567. Job 32585 consists of two interviews. Job #3256? is the interview of Sharice Bums who is the sister to Jamal Clark. Sgt. McCarthy supplement for summaries of the interviews. Sgt. Mark Osiand Assault Unit END of Supplement 3 ://caprsweb.ci.minneapoi i.s.mn.us/C 8-2 1 2/ 7/20 1 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - BAP-15425874 Page 9 of 1 Suppiement number: 4 CCN: Nip-15425874 Author: 004523-Stephen McCarty Supplement of S.MoCarty #004523 on 11/30/2015 14:47 On November 25, I received a call from Robert Him?The following is a summary of his interview. Job it 32473 He stated that he is the property owner of 1223 Morgan Avenue North and that the victim, Rayann Hayes is his niece. He stated that she doesn't live at this house. He stated that she has been staying and'hiding (from police and Jamar Clark?s family) at her daughter's apartment at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North. apartment 204. Mr. Hiil said that Victim/Hayes has also been stating at "Grandma's" apartment. He stated that Grandma lives in the townhouses on Plymouth. one block west of 1611 Plymouth Avenue. He did not know Grandma's name or exact address. On November 30. Sergeant Osland and i drove back to 1611 Plymouth Avenue North to look for additional witnesses who may have further information related to the events prior to the ?rst ambulance arriving on November15, 2015. When we arrived at the iooation, there was a male standing outside the building, this male tater verbally identified himseif as Albert Lenders of apartment 103. Mr. Lenders talked briefly about his dissatisfaction with the protesters in front of the Fourth Precinct. Stating in part that they don't care about Jamar Ciark He also would not directly answer my questions about events earlier in the evening. He did however. talking about the get together at his apartment for his wife, Witness2/Nekelia Sharp and that he left the apartment building before the ?ght between Jamar Clark and Victim/Rayann Hayes began. I asked him if he would let us in the secure apartment building and he refused, stating that he would not help us talk to anybody inside the building. it should be noted this conversation with Mr. Lenders was not recorded. Sergeant Osiand and were able to gain entry in the secured building with the help of maintenance workers. it shouid be noted that all the follow interviews were recorded and download by Sergeant Osiand. We went to apartment 201; the following is a summary of my interview with Olive Scott. Job #32564 Olive Scott verbally identi?ed herseit as the resident. She stated that she was home the night of November 15. Ms. Scott told us that she did not see or hear anything that happened inside the apartment building. We went to apartment 203; the following is a summary of my interview with Chaia Stroud. Job #32565 Chala Stroud verbally identi?ed herself as the resident. She told us that she didn't hear or see anything in the apartment hallway unusual on November 15. Job #32565 We then went to apartment 2134 to look for Victim/Hayes. Upon knocking at the door a male answered the door. The maie verbally identi?ed himself as Antonio Staniey; the following is a summary of that interview. Job #32565 CaprsReport.aspx??GUi 7215 8-2 74. .. 1 2/7/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - Page 10 of 1 He stated that he is the boyfriend of OTi/Shamirra Fine. He stated OTt/Fine and Victim/Hayes were not home. It should be noted that this was the same male we encountered last week walking away from this apartment, at that time i left a business card with him. Mr. Staniey initially stated that he was not home when the VictimlHayes got hurt. Moments later he stated that he was upstairs in apartment 104 during the early morning hours of November 15, when he received a calied to come down stairs to help the victim. He stated that he saw the victim tying in the ist ?oor hallway; he helped her back upstairs to apartment 204 and sailed an ambuiance. He stated that was most likely when she hurt her leg in the 1st floor haiiway. We knocked at apartment 202, there was no answer. i left a business card. Several hours later, i received a cali on my cell phone. The number was blocked. An unidenti?ed woman stated that she didn't hear or see anything that happened in the hallway on November 15. We went to apartment 101. After knocking at the door for a few minutes, an unidenti?ed elderiy disabled woman came to the door. it was apparent that the woman was dealing with several medical issues. She stated that that she didn?t hear or see anything in the apartment hailway on November 15. The woman stated that her brother. who lives with her but was not home at the present time, may have information. i iett my business card. As we were getting ready to knock on at apartment 104 and man and woman opened the door and emerged from the apartment. woman that verbally identi?ed herself as Sharice Burns answered the door. She stated that she was the sister (Witness4l8harice Clark of Jamar Clark). The woman allowed us to talk to her. The following is a summary of that interview. Job #32567 She stated that she was at home at attending the gathering in apartment 103. She stated that when Witness 1/Landers and \Mtness 2/Sharp began to argue in the hallway Victim/Hayes grabbed Witness 2 in bear hug. Witness 4 stated that Jamar Clark told the victim to left her Motimlf-iayes) to leave her (WitnessZISharp) alone. According to Witness 4/Burns Victimll-iayes rammed Jamar Clark's face into the metal doorjamb in the hallway because he was trying to take her away from the situation. Witness 4 stated that Jamar Clark's face was bruised and bleeding as a result of this action. Witness stated that she tried to get Jamar Clark to come back to her apartment and offer him a towel for his face. Jamar was concerned about the Victim because she was intoxicated. Witness4i'Burns stated that the victim kicked at or toward Jamar Clark and that is probany how she hurt her leg. i asked what it anything did Jamar Ciark do after this happen. She stated that basically just stood there and tried to console the Victim. At some point the victim felt to the ?oor and appeared unable to get up. \MtnessIBurns went upstairs to apartment 204 and Antonio Stanley came downstairs and carried the victim to the stairwell located on the eastside of the building and most likely upstairs to apartment 204. After the victim was taken upstairs, she tried to convince Jamar Clark to come inside her apartment, 104. but he refused. CASE OPEN SERGEANT STEPHEN MCCARTY, BADGE 4523 F'h.ln.rn aprswebci 12/7/2015 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - NIP-15425874 Page 11 0f 11 End of report for case NIP-15425874. Print ID: 12/ 7/201 5 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015?648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Darrell Gross (DG) INTERVIEWED BY: Sergeant Mark Osland (MS) Sergeant Stephen McCarty (SM) REVIEWED BY: Can we come in and talk to you sir? DG (inaudible) Oh, no, no (inaudible). We?re investigating all this stuff. We?re kind a figuring out what happened, kind of before what happened in front of your place (inaudible). DG Okay. Did you hear or see any confrontation between people in, in the common hallway here? DG Over there? Yes. DG Um, no I had left. (inaudible) birthday party for um for (inaudible). Yes sir. DG That?s who the party was for. She was in the first floor apartment (inaudible. Yes we talked to her and she?s the one who told us about you so. DG Okay, that whole conversation and everything urn was between her and her husband. Yes sir. DG That's what it was when I was left. Okay. DG Other than that um I didn't know or see anything else abnormal then. . Okay. DG My um nephew and my niece was there. Cuz they know the rest of what happened. Okay, alright well we talked to the lady of the house and I mean she gave us a pretty good idea as to what happened with her and her husband. DG Right. You didn?t, so at when they basically, when they started fighting (inaudible) you left? DG Yeah, I was gone, I was gone a little bit before they started. Oh, okay so you didn?t see anything. So you didn?t see anything else that happened once you left over there? Okay. DG And then when I came back home you all was out here. Darrell Gross Mpis PD Interview Page 1 of 4 Darrell Gross PD Interview Right, you saw what happened out there right? (inaudible) Okay. And I gave my statement for that already. Do you know who you gave that statement to? (inaudible) (inaudible) FBI. (inaudible) FBI, okay (inaudible) and you didn't give (inaudible) (inaudible) the only thing I talked to ?em about (inaudible) cuz I didn't, I?m not gonna put nothin? on the news? Yes sir. (inaudible) Okay, thank you. (inaudible) you didn?t see the fight between Jamar and Rayann? Um, no, no I only seen his face after, cuz um Jamar face was swollen. He was standing out here crying. Because of what she did to him? Yeah. Did he tell youwhat she did to him? Yeah from what he said she threw, she hit his face up on the floor thing. Okay. You It?s my understanding she?s a real small women, right? Rayann? Yeah. Yeah she might be a small women but that don?t mean nothin?. Well, but was he really intoxicated that she was able ta push his face into the (inaudible) Rayann is, have ya all met Rayann? No, I have not. Nobody has seen Rayann since this happened so her daughter?s staying on the second ?oon Um?hm. But um his face was messed up because she slammed his face up into the door. He's out there, standing out there crying. That was the reason he was going towards the ambulance Page 2 of 4 Darrell Gross PD Interview cuz he wanted to talk to her. He, he really cared about the girl so the whole thing about it was he was just trying ta, you Um?hm. he was, he was a little intoxicated but he wasn?t that intoxicated to where he didn?t want nothin? else to drink cuz he threw the drink that he had down on the ground. He?s out there crying. His face was messed up already. (inaudible) Um-hm. (inaudible) when you look at it but he was, he just trying to communicate with her. Was he like pounding on the door then? No, he wasn?t pounding on the door. After they went and put her in an ambulance he was standing in the (inaudible) like this. The EMS guy came and told ?em to back up. He stand back up, stood up on the grass. When the EMS officer, police officers, the police officer (inaudible) said something to the police officer they came to him after (inaudible). One officer was behind ?em like this like that next thing I know I see ?em slam him to the ground. Next thing I know ?pow? (inaudible). Okay when were, did you see Rayann walk out with a uh ambulance crew? She didn?t walk out they brought her out in the, in the cart thing. Oh, so they went up to the room and got, put her in a cart? Yeah. 80 then they wheeled her out in a, in a gurney? (inaudible). (inaudible) She was just kind a sittin? up then? Okay so she wasn?t walking to the vehicle? No. Okay. Somethin? was wrong with her ankle or somethin?. it was my understanding, 1 was told that she twisted while she?s trying to break up (inaudible) goin? on. Uh was she yelling at Jamar when they, she went by? No, no. But they weren?t still fightin? at that point? No. She was standing there when, Jamar was standing there when they brought her out (inaudible)? Yeah he was standing, could take, well no right there (inaudible) He was standing right there (inaudible) brought her out? Out the door. Okay. Okay, she didn?t yell at him? He didn?t yell at her? No, no. There was no, there was no yellin?, there was no yellin? at all during that. Um-hm. Page 3 of 4 DG So when they brought her out the door he wasn?t yellin? at her. The man was actually standing there crying. Okay. DG 80 he was not yelling at her. Cuz I, matter of fact I told ?em to (inaudible) she needed to go out there and talk to him cuz he was out there crying. Okay, so he was upset. DG Yeah. He just wasn?t angry? DG Right. So that?s what he didn?t understand what hap-, everything happened. Alright, I think that?s all we need. Alright thank you (inaudible) Darrell Gross PD Interview Page 4 of 4 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 24, 2015 BCA CASE 2015~648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Nekelia Sharp (NS) INTERVIEWED BY: Mark Osland (PD) Stephen McCarty (PD) REVIEWED BY: On November 24th 2015, PD Detective Sergeants Mark Osland and Stephen McCarty interviewed Nekelia Sharp at 1600 Plymouth Av in reference to the Nov 15th Assault of Rayann Hayes by Jamar Clark. Clark was later shot by PD. NS that?s what I want to know. PD (inaudible) NS I want to hear her, her what she said so I can tell ya all what, really happened. PD Okay well NS (inaudible) PD (inaudible) NS puppy is in here PD Alright NS a very aggressive (inaudible) PD (inaudible) down a little bit cuz I don?t, you know I don?t want your neighbors to have to (inaudible) NS (inaudible) that?s fine I mean I have no problem (inaudible) and once again there's a whole bunch of stories being told. PD Um?hm. NS But nobody is actually telling the truth. PD Um-hm NS You know? PD Yes (inaudible) NS And feel like (inaudible) to be honest with you all I?ve lost two of my brothers. Two of my brothers were killed by (inaudible) and not here in the State of Minnesota but the thing is when you actually witness something with your eyes, this is something that you can never, ever get outta your, you know PD Um-hm (inaudible) NS And, and it?s, and it?s very traumatizing because I?m afraid (inaudible) my house. I don?t know who to trust. I don?t know who to talk to. Sometimes I don?t even know (inaudible) anymore. PhilI?2015-648-A19 Page of 16 PD Um-hm. NS You know. PD (inaudible) NS Cuz I feel like what 1 say and what the news people are saying is something totally different. PD Um-hm. NS And nobody actually knows. Not Mayor Hodges. Not the Chief. Not the huh nobody knows. What (inaudible) seeing that night and it was not right. (inaudible) a party. PD Um-hm. NS The party happened on a Saturday night the 14th of November. That was my birthday was the .was the following PD Um?hm. NS But my husband decided I?ll give my ha my wife a get together. I don?t (inaudible) people so I just invited some people (inaudible). Saturday night comes. We were in our house we were having fun, partying. (inaudible) drinking so I don?t, I wasn?t drinking but everybody else (inaudible) drinks, whatnot and (door Opens/closes) NS brother (inaudible) NS (inaudible) I?m okay. Hey I'm doing all right. (inaudible) (door opens/closes) NS Like I said the party started that night at my house. PD Um?hm. NS Um my husband and we had an altercation. The altercation, okay maybe about 11:15 he had turned (inaudible) my daughter, my neighbor?s kid they were in my back room. (inaudible) my daughter?s room there?s a (inaudible) eating, whatnot. So maybe about 11:15, 11:30 I said okay it?s time for the party to end because I have my daughter and you know (inaudible) so it?s time to wrap up everything. So before my husband decided to help wrap up everything he (inaudible) to me. I asked him to get upstairs because I say hey it?s my birthday I mean (inaudible) leave. So as he proceeded out I come out behind him one thing led to another. Out, behind this PD Um?hm. NS so we?re out like in the hallway (inaudible) PD Okay NS We were (inaudible), he and l. Rayann which is the female that gave a statement. She grabbed me from behind. And when you?re fighting you don?t grab nobody. So Jamar Clark and all the other residents were trying to make him, you know get him one way and Jamar?s trying to get Rayann cuz I gets that?s the girlfriend at this time. So they're trying to get Rayann (inaudible) PD So Jamar and Rayann are (inaudible)? NS They were going (inaudible) PD Oh, okay. Phill?2015?648-A?l 9 Page 2 of 16 Phill-20?l 5-648-A1 9 You know so he?s trying to tell her hey let that, let that go that?s not your business, (inaudible). So by this time my husband he?s gone, they had got him out the door. My other company think it?s me in the house so once I get inside the house what actually happened here in this hallway, Rayann and Jamar, I?m very clueless to it. Um~hm. Now when i went out, now my neighbor says (inaudible) her sister Sherise she said (inaudible) she said it?s your birthday (inaudible) you know go (inaudible) having fun l'll take your baby the rest of the night over here. That was a blessing for me so she had, she took my baby on, we all proceeded outside. It?s my son, I and my neighbors and the other people that were here at the party we all went outside and were standing by the (inaudible) right by the mailboxes. And few seconds later I see Jamar he?s coming around the building as if he exited at the, the side at the door. 80 when Jamar come around the building he?s standing outside with us and he says hey you know I sure wish I had another drink because it?s cold out here and have to be out all night cuz his sister told him that he couldn?t stay, that night after him and Rayann got to fighting, which is right here (inaudible) Was it a pretty heated fight? Well I?m not sure, the fight had to be pretty enough heated for his right side of his face to (inaudible) Oh he was? Jamar was Jamar Yeah up by? Him and I guess him and Rayann. Okay. (inaudible) after this must have been where they got my husband and apart i hear all the commotion with Rayann (inaudible) You didn?t see (inaudible) But you heard a commotion? But I heard the commotion. Okay. And then like I said as he proceeded and came out, Jamar he comes out he stands over there with us saying I wish I had another drink it's cold out and I need to stay outside. I said okay fine. I went in the house I pour him another drink. I bring it back outside. He sits at the curb. Few minutes later we see the paramedics pull up. So after saw his face I?m kinda shocked like what the fuck happened to you Um-hm He?s like Rayann did this. So when I see an ambulance pull up I asked him I said are the paramedics for you. He said no the paramedics are out there (inaudible) the building, I seen her open the door. I opened the door they came and they said I?m going to the second floor. When they came to the second floor they came out (inaudible) Rayann (inaudible) by this time we?re still all standing there. Few minutes later (inaudible) he walked up to the paramedics you know the paramedics is facing (inaudible) Page 3 of 16 Phill-2015-648-A19 (inaudible) 80 only thing that young man did (inaudible) he looked, he was just standing (inaudible). He didn?t fight he didn't argue he didn?t curse he didn?t say nothing he was just standing there. He was just standing there looking. By this time EMS pulled up. As EMS pull up they pull now this is what happened when was facing this way but when EMS pull up (inaudible) So it was, another ambulance pulling up? No the Was like a (inaudible) It was like a (inaudible) supervisor, supervisor okay (inaudible) paramedic Yep, yeah they?re like a ah a SUV or some type, yeah (inaudible) Yeah suburban Suburban exactly Okay So the EMS pull up, they get out, there was only one gentleman, white shirt he gets out, he walks up to the paramedics and he asks Jamar to step back. You heard this? Yes. Okay. I?m standing where (inaudible) literally standing (inaudible) Okay. So he askes Jamar he?s like (inaudible) step back. Jamar steps back two, three feet (inaudible) the grass. As Jamar steps back he?s by this time there was two police cars pulling up. One car went past none, neither one the lights were on, no sirens or on (inaudible). One car went past the other car (inaudible). Then one gentleman got out on the passen, on the driver?s side which was a white guy maybe (inaudible) shoulder (inaudible) inside of the car there was like maybe Asian or Korean or something (inaudible). And as these two guys got out Jamar is still standing in the same spot. He didn?t say nothing (inaudible). I?m actually thinking these guys (inaudible) to the paramedics. But by this time, one white guy he's on this right hand side now he doesn?t ask Jamar this way, the other (inaudible) this way and they cuff him. Their handcuffs were put on him. As the handcuffs were put on this guy (inaudible) I couldn?t see which (inaudible) him but he?s down now, backwards. The white police officer he had his (inaudible) the other (inaudible) on the right side (inaudible) the other guy which is the Asian guy he?s down (inaudible) on the left side of his body. The on, that guy (inaudible) he didn't (inaudible) fuck ya all is (inaudible) pow, have never in my life and the only thing (inaudible) you just shot that boy. We were all you just shot that boy, (inaudible). (inaudible) you know the paramedics pulling up the, the one Rayann is in then pulls off (inaudible) as another paramedics (inaudible) pulls up. But by this time, I?m thinking that they?re actually down on the ground trying to help him. Only thing (inaudible) any more (inaudible) and they drove off and they didn?t try to work on him or nothin right then and there, nothin' but I you know like I said I haven't talked to nobody Page 4 of 16 Phill-2015-648-A19 (inaudible) because my story (inaudible) was nervous (inaudible) and it was quite disturbing cuz like I said (inaudible) it?s not true. It?s not true (inaudible) how the whole family (inaudible) because it?s not true. it?s not right. (inaudible) so i know what people are going through right now. (inaudible) so when people give up on you and they start talking (inaudible) people need to be careful what they say especially when you don?t know. (inaudible) incriminate him. I knew it but (inaudible) not even his sister but I know how his family feels. lt?s wrong. I don?t care what kind of background a person has. Ain?t nobody deserve to die the way he did. i don?t care about that. (inaudible) deserve to die the way he did. This is my first time (inaudible) since that night cuz I don?t know who to talk to. I appreciate you telling us, right. (inaudible) (inaudible). We have another dead brother, right or wrong he?s gone and never coming back. So if (inaudible) one of my brothers once again I know what people are going through. 80 would, Albert (inaudible). My husband was not here. He was not here. He was not around and like I said after the confrontation happened with my husband and l, my husband went on his way, (inaudible) away from here (inaudible). (inaudible) My other friends brought me back cuz I was (inaudible). They brought me back inside and (inaudible) me and my friends, locked my door (inaudible) so much commotion going on out here. - Um?hm. I had no knowledge (inaudible) Okay. I didn?t see it. I don?t know what happened. (inaudible) one of my concerns cuz I was, it was (inaudible) I did witness him and her fightin? in the hallway (inaudible) Rayann (inaudible) and how he got swelled up on the right side of his face. Is she a big women? Oh she?s (inaudible) a little thing (inaudible). So just (inaudible) My son is 19 but the thing is I?m not letting my son talk to nobody. Um-hm. Not because we have anything to hide it?s just that my son is a 19 year old but he?s a 9 year old mind. Um-hm. You see what I?m saying and my son has lost (inaudible) couple years cuz my son is going through a lot at this time. Yeah. You know so I?m not puttin? my child through that, period. But he?s not the only one that witnessed this (inaudible) his face (inaudible) you know. But my baby he needs to (inaudible) how hurt she was afterwards? No, because actually like I said after all the commotion she wasn?t hurt to me. You know she was still whooping and hollering after (inaudible) my evening. But maybe it happened Page 5 of 16 Phill-2015-648-A19 After (inaudible) You know it might?ve happened (inaudible) because that?s where the paramedics got her from (inaudible) (inaudible) she has a sister or daughter. Her daughter was there (inaudible). After Jamar got his senses get (inaudible) (inaudible) went out there to talk to her. Who knows what happened (inaudible). I don?t know. I never leave the first floor. They put, was she walking or did they have to put her on a gurney to get her (inaudible)? She walked out. They didn?t have to take, bring no (inaudible) stretcher (inaudible) Didn?t they bring a stretcher? No. I thought they did bring a stretcher. No, they did not bring a stretcher in here. I opened the doorfor him. I let them in the building. No stretcher was brought in, no nothin?. But she was limping a little bit? She was limping a little bit. mean, I didn?t see nothin' actually wrong with her coming out to the paramedics (inaudible). (inaudible) see her face then or it looked fine or? I couldn?t really tell that was not my focus. She, was pissed with her because she just turned me loose. I could?ve handled my own situation. I mean I?ve been married 10 years to this man. Um-hm. I mean who doesn?t push and shove with their wife. But at the same time you have no business grabbing me and if you would just listen to everybody else cuz she was already kind of intoxicated before she got to my house. Right. 80 I think she needs to open up a few more bibles kind of you know (inaudible) raise her shit at little bit you know and i didn?t mean to do that you know (inaudible) have a few drinks you know not nothing big, no weed smoking and all that cuz I went through all that (inaudible). I really, don?t, I?ve been here 9 years, I?ve never had company inside of my house. People see me and they say you live around here cuz I don?t associate with people. 80 but Rayann did not look all that bad to me actually I have not seen her since the night they put her in the paramedics. Right. I haven?t heard anything from her. But she?s friends with people in 104? (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) Page 6 of 16 PD (inaudible) NS You know. PD (inaudible) NS He really, you know he really loved (inaudible). He (inaudible) her (inaudible). PD (inaudible) so it must of set ?am off a little bit going, well how hurt is she, is she (inaudible). NS Well, no I don?t know (inaudible) PD (inaudible) NS (door opening/closing) NS Good morning (inaudible) (inaubible) NS I?m all right. (inaudible) but I do (door closing) NS he really was. PD Okay. How long (inaudible) NS Maybe a couple a months PD (inaudible) NS He, he?s young. PD Yeah. NS (inaudible) PD (inaudible) she?s early forties right? PD Yeah, (inaudible) (inaudible) PD Did he ever, I thought that (inaudible) (inaudible/voices in background) NS But no, (doors banging/voices in background inaudible) NS I mean he (inaudible) (inaudible/voices in background) NS loved her. PD He must have been pretty upset (inaudible) (loud bang/background noise) PD (inaudible) NS (inaudible) you (bang/inaudible voices in background) NS coulda been (inaudible) standing outside (inaudible) PhilI?2015?648-A19 Page 7 of ?16 (inaudible/continued voices and banging in background) know. (inaudible) so I mean like after she was (inaudible) around here so Okay Ah she (inaudible) (inaudible) Yeah he (inaudible) Right yeah She was his, his (door opening/closingPhill-2015-648-A19 (inaudible) She was (inaudible) (inaudible) I mean he heard about it you know but when you?re twenty-four (inaudible) this older woman (inaudible) and made you feel (inaudible) Um-hm. You know that?s all he basically looked fonivard to on a daily basis (inaudible) seeing her? (inaudible) you know seeing her made his day. Seeing her made him laugh. You know and I can I can honestly say he loved her. From my, version of being in love with somebody you know. Um-hm. i felt in my heart he did. He talked to me a lot about her. Um?hm. You know. Yeah Yeah he did confide in me. Did he talk about you know she makes me feel, angry cuz she?s running around with other guys or? No because actually they were always kind of drinking and stuff you know so when you?re drinking and you?re hanging out, you?re happy I guess you know (inaudible) their feelings may be but no she didn?t never talked bad about anybody or he never talked bad about her. None of that. did he, what was their argument about? Their argument was about me. It was about (inaudible) Page 8 01?16 NS (inaudible) PD your competition? NS Yes. PD She tried to intervene between you and Albert? NS Yes. PD By grabbing youlike the fact that NS like the fact that she was PD (inaudible) NS else?s business. Right. 80 that?s where their confrontation (inaudible) PD Alright. NS Because had she not, I don?t care how her family feels I haven?t even talked to them but at some point I do know once we do face to face that they?ll be mad. But who gives a damn cuz bills. PD Um-hm. NS I don?t deal with nobody and I didn?t have to invite nobody to my home. I never have company in my home. Can?t nobody around here can tell you what my apartment looks like. Because I don?t, intervene with people. But I did have a party that night because like I said I?m gonna be thirty-nine years old hey I?m not in Chicago this year I?m gonna enjoy myself. And I only invited people in this building PD (inaudible) NS Yeah. PD Okay. Can I get your name please? NS My name is Nekelia, (inaudible) an PD One moment ma?am, as in Nancy. NS PD Okay. NS Sharp, PD And your ah date of birth? Ns PD Okay and you?re in apartment 103. NS Yes. PD And what's a phone number for you? NS PD Phill-2015-648-A19 Page 9 of 16 NS Yes. PD And that?s a cell phone then? NS Yes. PD Okay and you live there with Albert right? NS Yes Albert Landers is my husband. PD Lenders, NS PD And do you know Albert?s date of birth? NS Q. PD (inaudible) NS PD Okay (inaudible) with you. NS (inaudible) PD Does he have a phone? NS PD - NS Yes. PD Okay. NS (inaudible) PD (inaudible) NS (inaudible) my phone (inaudible) PD Yeah you know that?s okay and you two are the only two that live thereYour NS daughter and my son. PD Okay. NS I brought my son here from Chicago in July. PD Okay. NS (inaudible) PD Alright. NS (inaudible) PD He was here that night thenoutside with you and check on you? NS Everybody (inaudible) made everybody come out of the house. I mean like i said I (inaudible) locked my house up. After all of this locked my house up and we left because my neighbor (inaudible) she'll keep my daughter (inaudible) her kids Phill-2015-648?A19 Page 10 of 16 PhilI-2015-648?A19 Um-hm They made it cuz they were early, (inaudible) That?s the one (inaudible) That?s, that?s Sherise Burns that?s who (inaudible) She (inaudible) (inaudible) So she wasn?t over there with you? Yeah she was at the party. Yeah but after After the went on to her apartment she didn't even want to see (inaudible) And she took your, daughter And she took my baby and her two little (inaudible) (inaudible) her Okay (inaudible) doing it, she told Jamar get the fuck (inaudible) can?t stay here tonight you know Right. feel personally (inaudible) because she let him in that night Okay And now he?s (inaudible) cuz he (inaudible) out at night, he (inaudible) Where does he normally live? (inaudible) normally stays (inaudible) (inaudible) She didn?t come out front with you guys? No she didn't come out. She was in the house with her husband and the children so by (inaudible) she had not gotten (inaudible) those kids gonna make, with my Okay. But after all this (inaudible) know the kids didn?t get to witness nothing (inaudible) Um-hm You know. Um like I said, Sherlse?s kids (inaudible) they went in the house. I mean she?s (inaudible) the hallway with her brother and them trying to get this girl off and you know to let mego Um-hm. But like I said after they did get everything calmed down, after Albert Page 11 of16 PhilI?2015?648?A1 9 Um-hm. the scene (inaudible) (inaudible) don?t know What happened until (inaudible) Yeah and (inaudible) (inaudible) I didn't know nothing else Could you tell me who was all out front with you, who saw this? There was me. My neighbor (inaudible) next door. This neighbor right here or the one over there? No, no?no-no in the townhomes. So like and you walk out the door it's the next to the mailboxes, my neighbor is the first townhome (inaudible) Okay what?s her name? His name is (inaudible), I don?t know his last name. Can you spell (inaudible) We call him D, yeah. So I don?t um was out there with me. I had Tyesha, Kyehsa?s boyfriend Rob and my son Brandon. So there was basically like only five witnesses that actually saw, what happened. Um-hm. So all the outsiders that you got coming up talking about hey this is what happened, this is what we saw, no. Even from the people that were at the Elks Lodge coming out. Um-hm. Saw the incident but by this time the (inaudible) you know. (inaudible) the crowd it was so bad I?ve never seen the (inaudible) like that. (inaudible) I?ve never seen the likes (inaudible) Was anyone else, I mean not part of your party but hanging out on the street? You know how they do on a (inaudible) Yeah I know but I didn?t hm didn?t witness nobody else just you know like (inaudible) see the people I Um-hm cuz we were like all just sitting around (inaudible) you know. Right. I didn?t actually see none of the outside Sure no but (inaudible) like five of us that really witnessed the Um-hm. .ushoo?ng. Page 12 of16 PD Okay and he was definitely handcuffed huh? N8 (inaudible) you know (inaudible) PD Um-hm NS (inaudible) that young man was handcuffed (inaudible) PD Okay NS And that?s what hurted PD Um?hm NS of everything for the news to say he was not handcuffed. Because see, first of all, I can see if (inaudible) left him and if he?s angry enough the way he you PD (inaudible) NS No, he didn?t move. i mean how can you put up a fight when you have somebody down your chest, somebody?s knee down in your chest and you can?t move. i mean that?s impossible. PD Okay. N8 I mean how can they, (inaudible) had a taser, you have a billy club, you have pepper spray (inaudible) why was your first train of thought to kill, he didn?t fight. He didn?t fight, he didn?t. He didn?t. Now that?s not that I?m not gonna sit up here and say oh he didn?t put up a fight I mean he put up a fight I?m not gonna tell you guys that because that?s not, that was not the case. PD Um-hm. NS This young man was not fighting, (inaudible) he didn?t try to struggle, he didn?t try to reach for a gun, he didn?t have time. They snatched him and cuffed him so fast and once he?s down, you can?t do nothing you?re lying on your back. You can?t, (inaudible) (door opens/closes) PD (inaudible) any marks on his, wrist from (inaudible) (door opening/closing) NS And I don?t (inaudible) I don?t know PD Okay NS (inaudible) I don?t know (doors/voices in background) PD Okay NS I?m not, I?m (inaudible) PD (inaudible) NS (inaudible) PD Yeah NS But I?m hoping (inaudible) (multiple voices in background) NS saying (doors opening/closing) NS PhilI-2015-648-A19 the truth. Page130f16 (inaudible) (inaudible) it?s not because (multiple voices in background/banging noises) Yeah Everybody has (inaudible) in their lifetime. And (inaudible) (voices in background/banging) (inaudible) on him, there was no need for the (inaudible) took. Yeah. (inaudible), once he was handcuffed I thought that was that. Okay. Who do you know woulda saw ah Rayann ah upstairs getting into it with Jamar? On the second floor? Yeah (inaudible) I?m not sure, maybe (inaudible) Maybe. Okay. (inaudible), maybe I?m okay now. Yeah maybe l?m not sure. (inaudible/multiple voices, door opening/closing) I?m not actually sure. 80 (inaudible) get (door closes) PD Ns, PD NS into the, where the mailboxes on Plymouth (inaudible) can go to that (inaudible) (inaudible) you can exit either way front or back. Yeah right, okay. You can exit front or back. Good morning. (door opens) NS NS PD NS PD (inaudible) How you doing sweetheart? l?m alright. But yeah (inaudible) (inaudible) or back. (inaudible) valance of the entrance (inaudible) (door closes) NS Phill-2015?648-A1 9 Page 14 of 16 Phill-2015-648-A19 (inaudible) Well they told us the cameras work, I don?t know how sure it is. Um-hm. You know I have never known these cameras to work around here and we do have cameras for the building. So I don?t think they work though. I mean if they do they will clean up a lot of this bullshit that goes on around here now. Okay (inaudible) You know people hanging Yeah drugs you Yeah shit they do. Um?hm. You know for, where we can?t bring our kids outside. You know they catch all the (inaudible) I mean if we had cameras they would (inaudible) a lot of it. Yeah. You know. Um, But you know (inaudible) Yeah (inaudible) I mean (inaudible) (inaudible) Yeah Because I explained to the (inaudible) that was Sherise that was just standing there (inaudible) I talk to her (inaudible) red shirt. I talk to her everyday Okay (inaudible) you know, (inaudible) I try to console the family as much as I can but (inaudible) grieving from something like this you just (inaudible) because I know if it was my brother (inaudible) Um-hm. At this point they're probably concerned cuz it was (inaudible) Yeah know Yeah (inaudible) okay Page 15 of16 Have a lot of people come and talked to people? Yeah I (inaudible) I said I, I haven?t really talked to nobody. (inaudible) they?ve been in the Yeah to people? They?ve been in the building. I?ve been kind of harassed by channel 9 news. I?ve been actually (inaudible) time get in my transportation Um?hm (inaudible), i had this guy like me on my Facebook page you? know all these news I don?t want to talk to (inaudible) (inaudible) I mean cuz I know they?ll be giving the statements that they were given or they know you know but like I say once again Mayor Hodges, the Lieutenant and the Chief, yeah that?s you guysjob, yeah (inaudible) but at the end ofthe day (inaudible) Alright, alright. if we have more questions for you, we will unblock our, our number so you see it?s our number calling. Okay. Would you please answer? I will. I have no problem with you guys. Yeah. Or if you have any information feel free to give me a call l?m (inaudible) Okay. (inaudible) (inaudible) ones there. Okay (inaudible) (inaudible) ones, right Right. 80 you know feel free to give me a call anytime. And thank you so much (inaudible) (inaudible), i don?t really um, Yeah, I know it?s a terrible thing to see. (inaudible) it was, it was bad (inaudible) Alright, thank you very much. Thank you. END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648?A?l 9 Page 16 of16 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 30, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Sharice Clark (SC) INTERVIEWED BY: Mark Osland (PD) Stephen McCarty (PD) REVIEWED BY: On November 30th 2015, PD Detective Sergeants Mark Osland and Stephen McCarty interviewed Sharice Clark (actually Sharice Burns). Clark was a witness to the assault between Jamar Clark and Rayann Hayes that precipitated his attempted arrest by PD and subsequent shoo?ng. PD to ask who, who you are. SC I?m (inaudible) Burns. PD (inaudible) Burns, (inaudible) SC Um-hm. PD And what?s your first name? This is your apartment? SC Um-hm. PD What's your first name? SC Sharice. PD Okay. SC (inaudible) PD Right yeah [thought it was Clark. I'm, SC (inaudible) PD about your loss too (inaudible) SC (inaudible) PD My name is Stephen McCarty. This is Mark Osland. SC Um-hm. PD And we?re just trying to talk with you anybody who saw what happened prior to you know your brother, getting killed. SC (inaudible) PD So, and that there was (inaudible) party that was going on here. SC It wasn?t a party it was like a gathering (inaudible) PD (inaudible) that?s what they?d call it SC Um-hm. Page 1 of? family get together you know cards, etcetera. Um?hm. And just and it sounds like there was an argument that happened you know. Um-hm. So I mean did you happen to see anything that happened before this (inaudible) Yeah (inaudible) around like okay, how long are you guys gonna be around cuz l, have to go. You've gotta get going? I have to be somewhere else soon. Okay (inaudible) Well we?re gonna be around so I mean (inaudible) and stuff that you know (inaudible) (inaudible) give, give us a call (inaudible) (inaudible) how, how long (inaudible) is gonna take (inaudible) (inaudible) it shouldn?t take long, (inaudible) take long at all. (inaudible) we?re interested in you know (inaudible) So what, what do you want to know? Go ahead. Well do you want to do it out here in the hall? Um-hm (inaudible), okay alright um well like I said ma?am what kind of happened you know and maybe cuz (inaudible) domestic situation. Um?um (inaudible) don?t I think it was more of (inaudible) couples girlfriends (inaudible) Okay yeah and, okay Something just (inaudible) Yeah having an argument Um-hm you know like couples often do Um-hm Right (inaudible) (inaudible) just got done arguing Yeah (inaudible) argued with (inaudible) Um-hm. Page 2 of 7 PD over the weekend so we know that that?s happened SC Um-hm PD And it?s just something that goes on. SC Um-hm. PD So after that finished (inaudible) like urn it was another argument between Jamar and his friend? SC Um Jamar and his friend, the PD Um?hm. SC Jamar?s lady was trying to get (inaudible) into the PD Um-hm SC party PD Yes, yeah SC (coughing) SC Jamar from, Jamar was telling her this has nothing to do with (inaudible) and we can just leave the, the um (inaudible) PD Okay SC Um this has nothing to do with you. PD Um-hm. SC Let?s just get out of it, um the friend of Jamar?s her name is Rayann. She was still trying to grab (inaudible) the lady that stays here PD Yes, yeah SC And she was like (inaudible) PD Um-hm SC (inaudible) you know PD Yes SC (inaudible) we know how to (inaudible) and when Jamar seen that she kinda got shoved off, he grabbed her like come on baby let?s not be involved (inaudible) PD Um-hm SC and um she um was upset that Jamar was stopping her from being involved in their (inaudible) PD Um?hm SC 80 PD Your brother (inaudible)? SC Yes. PD Okay. SC So she took her hand and shoved him under the face (inaudible) Page 3 of? (inaudible) Yeah (inaudible) um and that?s how he got the bruising on his face then? Yeah. Okay do you know what happened after that? Yes um so I tried to grab a towel to get him to come in and said leave her be because she?s drunk Um-hm So let her be drunk and Jamar you come in and she?ll go home Um-hm And he left I just gonna wanna see what's going on, I want to talk to her Um?hm And Jamarjust really was concerned about her because she wasn?t welcome back up in her daughter?s home. Her and her daughter had something going on. Okay. And so sh, he was trying to figure out where was she gonna sleep. Um-hm. So he asked me if it?s okay if she sleeps here with, in my home with him. Okay. And l?m just like I don?t think that?s a good idea how about you just come in and get your face fixed up and, he still wanted to see how she was doing because she was sitting on the ground (inaudible) Okay so he isn?t (inaudible), he?s over with you? No their (inaudible) Oh they were both here, (inaudible) (inaudible) Okay. Alright (inaudible) (inaudible) told him (inaudible) help with a Um?hm stuff but he was concerned about her? Um-hm Was he bleeding that you went and got a towel for (inaudible) Oh of course, yes. Um, he didn?t want the towel he was just like leave it be don?t, you know wipe me um I?m okay so um shejust (inaudible) right there and just you know kicking and (inaudible) F-U and you?re no good and just saying things that she said to me before um she said it to him. Yeah. Page 4 of 7 she was just really being very rude. Um-hm And outta pocket (inaudible) You?ve known herfor a while haven?t you? (inaudible) Not a while 1 just met her this summer. Oh this, okay. Um?hm. (inaudible) guys are acquaintances? Urn we?ve talked we've um actually walked to the store before. Um she?s (inaudible) a couple of her um friends and the neighbor cuz I never really get out the house. Um?hm. So there was a time she?s just like well I know a lotta people around here you can come with me. Um-hm. And this is before her and my brother had met. Right, okay. But they were, they were dating Jamar and Rayann were (inaudible) (inaudible) to me, they said they were never dating they were considered friends. So can?t put a you know a dating thing on someone if they're not agreeing to it Um?hm You know. Okay so um what happened next then after you went, went back in the (inaudible) what happens next? 80 he was just like (inaudible) um I had um (inaudible) knock on the door. Um-hm. And I told him ah his son, son?in-law can he please come down and get her because she?s acting very wild down here so can someone carry her upstairs. So he finally gets here, the son?in-law. (inaudible) above with her daughter. Would that be Antonio (inaudible) Yes Okay. Okay. 7 He picked her up and took her upstairs. When he took her That way up (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) Um?hm So he walked her back into (inaudible) Um~hm this, Page 5 of 7 Um-hm Okay. Um he went, I think she was more like, they were more (inaudible) right here, I?m like right here Jamar is like right here Okay So (inaudible) And that?s (inaudible) Not that in the (inaudible) (inaudible) no one came back, okay. Alright so he takes her upstairs? Yeah he takes her upstairs and then l'm like well are you gonna come in ouz he was standing right there. (inaudible) And in the hallway um supposedly he was like (inaudible) [just really want to see how she?s doing and because I don?t, I don?t know what I did I?m just trying to make sure she?s not involved and no one else is (inaudible) so, l?m like okay, well I?m gonna go lay down you know. And then after that, That?s, okay so you don't know what happened how she hurt her ankle and all. I believe, myself (inaudible) She was trying to kick him (inaudible) Yeah (inaudible) (inaudible) okay, okay so you think maybe that?s where she hurt her ankle? Yeah but she always hurt herself when she?s drunk. (inaudible) hell of a time (inaudible) when she was drunk. Okay. (inaudible) She, she (inaudible) She drinks a lot. (inaudible) Yeah, okay. (inaudible) she's come back before with a bruise and my brother Jamar asked her what happened why (inaudible) (inaudible) alright well ah thanks (inaudible) The other thing (inaudible) (inaudible/multiple voices) She could have been, she was punching him Page 6 of 7 Okay. (inaudible) And that?s (inaudible) (inaudible) That?s (inaudible) at him um to come down and get her. Okay. (inaudible) she wasn?t, (inaudible) mad at so (inaudible) So as far as you know she didn?t, he didn?t fight upstairs at all? Oh no never And she stayed up there until the ambulance came? Yeah like this How do you, how do you know that though if you (inaudible) Um I was (inaudible) telling me you know um I didn?t come out to actually um Alright get in there Okay was like she?s upstairs (inaudible) I?m like well I?m gonna go in Right, okay did you, you watched (inaudible) from here? Did you (inaudible) point watch one of their children? Were you watching any children? Yeahhere for a little bit yeah. Okay. Okay So i didn?t really actually go outside but it was more like you know kids (inaudible) Right, yeah (inaudible) (inaudible) (inaudible) Cuz Jamar never went (inaudible) was right there. Okay And then hours later that?s, (inaudible) So it was a couple hours later after the fight down here that the, this all happened? The shooting? (inaudible) Um yeah she called the ambulance um supposedly (inaudible) and everything happened (inaudible) and supposedly she didn?t call the ambulance until twelve something. Yeah. Alright well thank you. Thank you very much RECORDING ENDS. Page 7 of? Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/79 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Primary Information Description: Transfer of digital evidence (Bible cell phone jpg's) Occurrence From: 11/25/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/25/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/09/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis SA Olson received a CD from Digital Forensic Specialist Shawn Hughes which contained 3 digital photographs from the cellular telephone of Lavell Bible. The disc (Item 79.1) will be maintained as evidence. Address #1 Occurred #1 - 15130 MARYLAND Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subjects . Relationship Name BUSINESS LOCATION Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (Agency) Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Bible, Lavell . - Primary Information Subject Name: Bible, Lavell Rosseil Record Type: Person Bio: 45 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 922 VINCENT AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E-Address Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phil], Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/79 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued. Primary Information - Continued Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number Countm As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID - Minnesota N0 Property #1 - 3 ,1ng digital Bible's cellular Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: 3 digital photographs from Bible's cellular Property Status: BCAI HQ Status Date: 11/25/2015 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: YES Remote Bin: Locker Office-rs Hughes, Shawn (Digital Forensics I Minnesota Bureau of-Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 12/08/2015 16:28 12/09/2015 09:31 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Investigative Supplement 2015-648/79 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Reporting LEO - Date I) - supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) INarrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of4 On November 25, 2015, SA Olson received a disc from Shawn Hughes, BCA Digital Forensics Specialist. This disc contained three scene photographs from Lavell Bible?s cellular telephone (see supplemental 47) that he reported showed Clark in handcuffs. It was SA Olson?s belief that the digital data taken directly from the telephone would provide more data and result in better quality images versus Bible?s previous delivery of those photographs to FBI SA Kevin Kane (see supplemental 9) via the intemet. SA Olson did later examine the disc provided by Hughes and was not able to ascertain evidence of handcuffs from the photographs. It should be noted that when asked what happened to the other two photographs previously delivered to SA Kane, Bible said he deleted them because they were too blurry and did not provide any useful information. The disc containing the three photographs has been labeled as item 79.1, and will be maintained and preserved as evidence. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Warning A Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: *Acquisition of FBI Supplemental Reports? Occurrence From: 12/07/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 12l08/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02l26l2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency I Case/File Number FBI Synopsis On December 8th 2015, SA Phill received? reports of interview from the FBI. The 7 reports and one transcript were attached to this report separately. In later weeks, SA Phill was giVen more reports detailing FBI interviews. Only one item of evidence was achIred, a CD with audio from an interview with Gabriel Garbowit. SA Phill gave it item 2015-6481801. Address #1 RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE - Primary information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Bio DOB gun?? Subject #1 - WITNESS Cherry, Dennis . Primary information Subject Name: Cherry, Dennis Record Type: Person Bio: 45 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal information Ethnicity: American Height: 601 Weight: 190 Color: Brown Hair Length: Bald . . . . . . . . . . - . . . . . . - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page '1 017 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 senate 7 Continued Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 3536 EMERSON AVE N, Hanover, Minnesota 55412 United States Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E?Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State Countm As Of Date Fictitious Comment ID CARD Minnesota United States 12I4l2015 NO Subject #2 #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas; Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name ?i_o EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Lia?mg EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 Clark, -- Continued Primary Information - Continued Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date Fictitious Comment FBI 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State 10 Minnesota NO Subject - LAW ENFORCEMENT Bauer, Benjamin Michael Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Bauer, Benjamin Michael Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 27 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship DQB, EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) subject #6 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #2 - Carlson, Troy Allen Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Carlson, Troy Allen Record TypeLaw Enforcement Official - - . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #6 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #2 - Carlson, Troy Allen - Continued Primary Information Continued Bio: 32 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship gig EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Jensen, Steven Paul Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 42 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Su?j?curs 0TH AGY - LAW ENFORC-E #1 - Schultz, Michael Neil Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schultz, Michael Neil Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Forensic Scientist Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name _Bi_0 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Subject #9 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICE #1 - Trullinger, Michael John Primary Information Subject Name: Trullinger, Michael John Record Type: Person .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #9 EMERGENCY MEDICAL: SERVICE #1 - Trulli'nger, Michael John Continued Primary Information - Continued Bio: 50 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Personal information Ethnicity: American Height: 511 Weight: 220 Color: Brown Addresses Relationship Address Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address SUBJECT-s PHONE Identifications Hum?bar .St? County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota No LICENSE Property #1 containing Garbowit audio-andvarious FBI reports Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD containing Garbowit audio and various FBI reports Quantity: 1 Control Number: Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 12/08/2015 00:00 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12l08l2015 17:23 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 02/26/2016 10:28 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil]. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 5 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/80 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Apprehension) Reporting LEO a Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26I2016 Apprehension) Wit-agave; begins the: MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 6 of 7 On Tuesday, December 8th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received 6 FBI reports of interview and one transcript of interview from SA Olson. The previous day (Dec 7), FBI SA Kane provided the reports to SA Olson. The interviews were of Hennepin County Medical Center Deputy EMS Chief Michael Trullinger, Minneapolis Police Crime Lab Forensic Scientist Schultz, Dennis Cherry, and Minneapolis Police Of?cers Bauer, Carlson, and Jensen. The interviews were not audio recorded and there were no items of evidence acquired with this report. In subsequent weeks, SA Phill has received copies of reports from the FBI detailing their interviews and evidence gathering. Those reports were then attached to this BCA report; 648/80. The only item of evidence acquired was a CD containing audio of an interview with Gabriel Garbowit. The CD was given ACISS item by SA Phill. On January 22nd 2016, SA Phill received 10 more reports from SA Kane. Those 10 reports were added to this report. No evidence items acquired with those 10 reports. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Investigative Supplement 2015-648/81 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquisition of Jerry Johnson's Interviews of Ofc Hillbo and FF Husnick Occurrence From: 11/23/2015 00:00 Occurrence To: 11/25/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On December 8th 2015, SA Phill enterered into evidence 2 CDs containing audio of interviews done by Fred Bruno's private investigator, Jerry Johnson. The CD5 were given evidence numbers 81.1 (Ofc Hillbo) and 81.2 (FF Capt Husnick). Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 5500 Primary Information Address: 5500 WAYZATA BLVD #1000, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416 United States Description: Law Of?ces of Frederic Bruno Addressing - 7 Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Bio DOB Ill- Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name [3?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/81 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #2 Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 Clark; Jamar on?al - Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications M292 N_Urme_r C_0U_ntjt 92m FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota N0 Subject #4 - LAW ENFORCEMENTOFFICER #1 -7Hillb_o_, Griffin Karl Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Hillbo, Griffin Karl . . . . . . . . - - . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/81 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Subject #4 - LAW ENFORCEMENT Griffin Karl - Continued . Primary Information - Continued Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Rank/Position: Juven?e: Subjects Relationship EMPLOYER Law Enforcement Of?cial 39 yr. old, White, Male Officer NO Name Minneapolis Police Department (Agency) Preperty #1 - CDCOntaining Interview of Ofc Hillbo byLJerry Johnson Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing Interview of Ofc Hillbo by Jerry Johnson BCA I HQ 12I08I2015 1 2015-648i81.1 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Propertyaz co containing _-Interview of FF captigigiusn'icx by Jerry Jonson . Primary Information Property Class: Property Type: Description: Property Status: Status Date: Quantity: Control Number: UCRDamaged: Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Disposition: Evidence CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE CD Containing Interview of FF Capt Husnick by Jerry Johson BCA I HQ 12/08/2015 1 2015-648I81.2 NO YES Locker SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/81 Report Date: 12/08/2015 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 1208/2015 20:36 Swanson, Gary (1326 i MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12I14i2015 12:50 RepOrting LEO Date? Apprehension) Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (13261MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2i26/2016 Apprehension) INafrative begins) on?the I a MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On December 8th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill entered two CDs of interviews conducted by attorney Fred Bruno?s private investigator, Jerry Johnson. On November 23rd: Jerry interviewed Minneapolis Police Of?cer (Mp1s PD) Grif?n Hillbo regarding his involvement at the November 15th 2015 of?cer involved shooting at 1611 Plymouth Av N. Hillbo?s interview was preserved on disc by SA Phill and given item number and a transcript of the interview has been attached to this report. On November 25th 2015, Jerry interviewed Minneapolis Fire Department Captain Chris Husnick. Husnick responded with 2 other ?re ?ghters to the of?cer involved shooting at 1611 Plymouth Av on November 15th 2015. The CD containing audio of the interview was given item number and the transcript of the conversation was attached to this report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 23, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Officer Grif?n Hillbo (GH) INTERVIEWED BY: lnv. Jerry Johnson (JJ) PD Bruno Law Firm REVIEWED BY: On November 23rd 2015, Civilian Investigator forthe Bruno Law Firm, Jerry Johnson, interviewed a PD Officer. Officer Griffin Hillbo gave a statement regarding responding to the Nov 15th 2015 PD OIS at about 1611 Plymouth Av N. JJ Okay this is a recorded statement being taken by Jerry Johnson on November 23rd, 2015 at 1938 hours ah over the phone with Officer Griffin Hillbo of the Minneapolis Police Department. Ah Griff do have your permission to record this statement? GH Yeah. JJ Okay. And can you hear me okay? GH Yes I can. JJ Okay. Ah how long have you been a police officer in Minneapolis? GH Ah I have been a police officer for approximately 17 years. JJ Okay. And on the night in question did you respond to a incident, what is it Plymouth and James correct? GH Yes it was. JJ Okay. About what time of the evening was that? GH Ah I want to say it?s about 1:00 in the morning. JJ Okay. GH Between 12:30 and 1:00, 1:00 in the morning I believe. JJ Alright and which squad were you working that night? GH Ah I was working a middle watch squad and I cannot remember which one it was. Ah l?m, I believe it was 162. JJ Okay. And so you?re normally assigned downtown is that correct? GH Yes l?m normally on the, on the power shifts but I was working overtime for middle watch that night. JJ Okay. And you responded to the north side for what purposehelp call. JJ Okay. Were you by yourself or with a partner? GH was by myself. Page 1 of5 Okay. And you went red lights and siren I assume? Yes I did. About how long from the time the call came out until the time you arrived elapsed? it would have been maybe a, a minute or two. Okay. When you arrived at the scene do you recall who was present besides yourself? i really don?t recall who else would have been there. i went pretty much straight to the scene where the paramedics were. Okay. Were there other officers there already? Yes there was already officers set up. Um on both sides of the street and already had a perimeter started up and were blocking the area. Okay. Did you observe Officer Schwarze or ah is it Ringgenberg, at the scene? No I did not. Okay. Did you observe ah the person who had been shot ah what Jamar Clark was he at the scene? Yes I did. Okay. Where was he when you arrived? Ah from what I recall he was laying I believe on the boulevard or close to a sidewalk on the south side of Plymouth. Okay and would it be on the east or west side of that intersection? Ah you know i don?t recall which, which side it was on. Okay. When, when he was ah lying there was he covered with anything orjust out in the open? i don't recall him ah covered by anything. Okay. Could you observe his hands? l, I did ob I did observe his hands. l?m sorry did you say you did or did not? Sorry, yeah I did observe his hands. Okay. And did you observe them from a distance or up close? I was, fairly close within a few feet of him. Okay. Where were his hands when you observed them? They were at his sides. Directly at his sides? Yes. So one hand on either side of him? Correct. Were they ah fastened in any way or did you see any type of restraining devices on his hands? No i did not. Page 2 of 5 there would have been restraining devices on his hands would you have been able to see them? Yes. And I?m, it, it?s one in the morning so it?s obviously dark, correct? Yes. Was the scene lit up by ah headlights of vehicles? Spotlights? Ah street lights that type of thing? Yes there was a multitude of lights going all at that time different emergency vehicle lights as well as ah um you know ambient lights from an ambulance which was right next to him. Okay. So was his body ah did it have lights shining directly on it to illuminate it? Ah you?re breaking up a little bit and i couldn?t hear you. Did, did his body have lights from vehicles of other sources directly illuminating his body? Were they shining on him? i, I really don?t recall. I don?t, i remember it being pretty dark but (inaudible) Okay. lights out there from what I recall. Okay and but you?re, you?re certain that there was no handcuffs? No restraining devices? Flex cuffs, anything like that on his hands? Correct. i didn?t see anything at all. Okay. Do you remember was he wearing a short sleeve or a long sleeve shirt? I believe he was wearing a long sleeve, shirt. Okay and was a do you know if it was a shirt or a hoodie or a jacket or anything specific? Urn, i really can?t remember Okay. kind of a jacket or a coat or, what kinda clothing it was. Okay. Do you remember what his injuries were at the time? Yes remember seeing a .what appeared to be a gunshot wound to the side of his head. Which side do you remember? (inaudible) entrance, yeah it was up ah next to his left eye. I remember seeing a, either entrance wound or an exit wound right there. Okay. And you?re a trained ah paramedic correct? Yes I?m a, currently a paramedic with the Minneapolis Police Department, the SWAT team as by Hennepin County Medical Center as an instructor. Okay. How long have you been doing that? Ah approximately five years now. Okay. Did anyone at the scene to your knowledge ever handcuff Mr. Clark? Not to my knowledge at all. Page 3 of 5 And how long were you at the scene? Were you still there when they transported him away or not? I was standing there as the paramedics placed him on the stretcher and moved him from ah the ground to a ah, to basically a movable cot and then placed him from that cot onto the stretcher and then moved him to the ambulance. Put him in the ambulance and then they, they drove away about a block or two. Okay and during the time that they loaded him into the ambulance did you see any restraints on him? I did not. Okay. If there would have been restraints would you have been able to see them? Yes. Okay. Do you remember specifically which paramedics were at the scene that loaded him into the ambulance? Yes it would have been their Deputy Chief which is Mark Trullinger ah the paramedic ah is Mari Hill and then ah a third would have been her partner and I?m drawing a blank on his name. Okay. i know that, I know that all three of those paramedics were interviewed at ah MPD as well as the, the two original paramedics that were there on Okay. the female that was, that was assaulted. Okay. Do you um do you recall what the weather conditions were like ah at that time? From what I recalldry, dry evening. Okay no precipitation, no snow anything like that? Yeah I, I don?t recall any. Okay. There was definitely no snow. Okay. Um did you yourself have any physical contact with Mr. Clark that night? I, I did not. Okay. And when you wrote your reports for this um incident did anyone indicate to you to um do a brief report and not a detailed report? was told just do a very brief report. Who told you that? That would have been Sergeant Campbell. Tom Campbell? Yes. Okay. Do you remember his specific words about that? Well because I had interviewed, I didn?t know if this was a, was a homicide or what this was and I had spoken to the two original paramedics that were on scene for the female that was assaulted and was their escort later on to MPD um 108, for the homicide unit and I had Page 4 of5 gotten their information as well as ah their story about what happened, not knowing that ah they would be interviewed by Sergeant Villella so, basically ah 1 did not include any of their information in my report because it was all taken by Sergeant Villella. Okay. So was it your understanding that you were not to include that information in your repon? Yes. And you feel that direction came from Sergeant Campbell? Correct. Okay. Is there anything else that you can think ofthat ah would be pertinent to this ah statement that we?re taking from you tonight? And I have informed you that I?m working as an investigator for the Fred Bruno Law Firm and we?re representing Officer Schwarze, correct? Correct. Is there any, anything else you can think of that ah you want to add? Nothing that comes to mind. Okay. And has anyone coerced you, encouraged you or done anything to make you give this statement other than giving it of your own free will? No. Okay. And ah I had your permission to record this statement is that correct? Yes. Um, alright I can?t think of anything else right now and if ah we think of anything else we?ll contact you and um, um we?ll end this statement then at 1950 hours. Okay. END OF RECORDING. Page 5 of5 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: November 25, 2015 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: Captain Chris Husnick (CH) INTERVIEWED BY: lnv. Jerry Johnson (JJ) Fire REVIEWED BY: On November 25th 2015, Civilian Investigator Jerry Johnson interviewed Fire Captain Chris Husnick via phone. This was regarding the Nov 15th 2015 Of?cer Involved Shooting of Jamar Clark, BCA Case 2015-648 JJ Alright the date today is ah 11?25 of 15. And this is a recorded statement being taken from Chris Husnick um a firefighter at ah 1558 hours this date. Chris can you hear me okay? OH I can hear you just fine. JJ Okay and ah can you just say your name for the recording? CH Ah Christopher James Husnick. JJ Okay and what?s your date of birth? CH - JJ Okay and you?re a Minneapolis Firefighter is that correct? CH That is correct. JJ Ah I unders, you?re a Captain is that right? CH Ah I actually just got promoted to Captain but at the day of the incident I actually was still a firefighter. JJ Oh okay. Alright and ah how many years have you worked for Minneapolis Fire? CH Ah it?ll be 17 years um this January 13?. JJ Okay did you have any prior experience before that? CH Um before that I spent 4 years in the Coast Guard um otherwise that?s, that?s about all the experience related to this job I guess. JJ Okay. And did you respond to an incident where a person was reported shot on Sunday, November 15?? CH I did. JJ About what time was that? CH Um roughly about 12:30 I think the call came in. JJ And at night? 12:30 in the morning? CH Yes. JJ Okay. Page 1 of 5 That is correct. And when you ah got the call were you at a fire station? I was at fire station #4 And where is that located? That is located at um I think it?s 1101 North 5th Street is the actual address. Okay so downtown? Downtown yes. Yeah okay. Um do you have a estimate of how long it took from the time you received the call ?til the time you arrived at the scene? Roughly two minutes. Probably less. Okay. It?s, it's very close, it?s very close to our station. Okay. Urn and when you arrived there was there already an ambulance at the scene? There was an ambulance at the scene. When we first arrived we ah we staged about a block away waiting for code 4 from the police cuz that?s usually how we work. Okay. Um so was there just one ambulance there when you got there then or was there two? There was one ambulance. Just one, okay. And when you ah arrived did you see a person who had been shot? Um no not when we first arrived. Okay. Who did you see there? Ah I saw numerous police officers. They had already kinda taped the scene up. Um they - had a pretty good crowd gathering across the street at the Elks, Elks ah whatever it?s called its the Elks Legion Center or something like that. And then you also had on the south end of the street you had a two story apartments where everybody, lot of people outside on their decks just lotta people in general. Okay. And this was at Plymouth and James correct? Correct. Okay. Um when you arrived at the scene and I?m talking about when you first got there you saw the crime scene tape and whatever Um-hm got outta your rig then I assume? Yeah so then we, we blocked, we parked at the, the east end of the block our rig and grabbed our gear cuz they said the (inaudible) said you know code, code 4 police to code 4 (inaudible). We started running towards the ambulance. Um when we first got there the ambulance was kind of right in the middle of everything. Right in the middle of the block and then it actually pulled out and just went like a half a block away out of the, out of the area and off to the side to, to the sidewalk area. So then we grabbed all of our medical gear. Ran down there. Um me and my well me and my firefighter my, my driver about halfway I said hey why don't you go back, get the rig and bring it around to ah to the west end of the block. And then when we got there the, the ah we got in the ambulance they had already started Page 2 of 5 working on the person. Um the person had the lucas machine which is like a, machine that delivers chest compressions. They already had one IV um i believe it was his left arm already started. And then we jumped in and quickly assisted in putting another IV in his right arm. And ah my partner actually started suctioning and, and bagging the person. Okay. And so when you (inaudible) there was lV?s in I guess that was ah gonna be like my next question. You saw his arms correct? Yes. I, physically was holding onto his arms, both hands because we immediately once we got in we took off pretty quick um to the hospital. And so my main thing was to kinda just ah stabilize his hands and arms so they wouldn?t ah wouldn?t move around at all. Okay. And ah did you see any type of restraint on his hands or arms at that point? No. He had no restraints on whatsoever. Did you at any time in the evening at during any contact with him see any restraints on him? No I did not. Okay. Were there police officers present on the ride to the hospital in the ambulance? Yes there was one officer that rode along with us also. Do you recall the name of the officer or not? I do not. Okay. Male or female officer? Ah he was a male. Okay. And did that officer have any physical contact with the ah patient during the ride to the hospital? Um, no he, he may have he kinda assisted me actually I think a little bit because it was kind of a bumpy ride and um we still were trying to get that second IV in on the way to the hospital and ah you know there?s just, ripping off pieces of tape and bandages and just kinda little things like that. Okay. (inaudible) the bag, you know but he was, he mighta assisted a little bit in that otherwise he was just, he was just there. Okay. And just to clarify so there?s no, no question the patient we?re talking about was Jamar Clark right? That is correct. And he, he had been shot in the head is that accurate? Yep looked like (inaudible) (inaudible) looked like he was shot directly in the left eye. Okay. Um, Or around the area. Page 3 of 5 Okay. Did ah when you were at the scene were there people trying to interfere with the ah crime scene at that point? Um no I mean there was a lotta agitated people. 1 mean we kinda ran right through the center of it and just you know you had officers kinda on both ends of the street trying to ah you know to secure the area and look for evidence at the same time. Um, (inaudible) numerous people with even with their cell phone out filming stuff. Ah you know, otherwise yeah that?s, that's about all we saw as we were running through, quick, quickly. Okay. And um to your knowledge then was he still um alive at the time that you transported him? Um we stopped the luoas at one time (inaudible) we had a (inaudible) pulse (inaudible) is what, is what I thought the ah I heard the paramedic say. Okay. Um, so Alright. Ah and he was not verbal I assume at that point? No. Okay. No he was, yeah. Okay. Alright. He was unresponsive. Um as far as the urn the conditions eh (inaudible) when let me back up forjust a minute. When you first saw him was he then in the ambulance or out ofthe ambulance? He was in the ambulance and they had already started working on him. Okay. And just generally at the scene when you arrived was the area well lit? Um yeah I would say it was, was fairly well lit. Did you, Um, you had I assume street lights and vehicle lights going? Yeah, yep and with all the off you know there was you know like I said I don?t even know I?ve never seen so many cop cars there were probably fifty cop cars there. Okay. And what were the weather conditions like? The weather conditions were clear I believe. Okay so no, no precipitation or visibility issues? No, none at all. Okay. Very good is there anything else ah pertinent that you can think of that you want to add? Um, all I would say is that probably somebody has a, a on their phone I would say somebody has a video of this because I, I did notice people on these decks and stuff and just people around all with their phone (inaudible) of course filming it I think so I would think there?d be actually some footage out there so it?s possible (inaudible) might have I don?t know for sure but Page 4 of 5 JJ Okay. Very good. Well thanks for yourtime and um I?m going to shut the recorder then off at 1608 hours. END OF RECORDNG. Page 5 of5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/82 Report Date: 12/10/2015 Primary Information Description: Re-interview of Tyler John Lupkes Occurrence From: 12/10/2015 13:15 Occurrence To: 12/10/2015 14:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01/04/2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Syh?bpsis - On Thursday, December 10, 2015, SA's Olson and Phil] attended a second interview of Tyler John Lupkes. At the request of the U.S. Department of Justice this interview was not audio recorded and no items of evidence were obtained by virtue of this report. Address-#1 300' Primary Information Address: 300 4TH ST Minneapolis Federal Building, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Description: United States Attorney's Office Subject #1 WITNESS #1 Primary Information Subject Name: Lupkes, Tyler John Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 509 Weight: 210 Color: Hazel Addresses mien?shit; Mirage HOME ADDRESS Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E-Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State Country As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page ?1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/82 Report Date: 12/10/2015 Subject #2 IN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal . Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 1 60 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications um $3 mm We! FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Officers Perzel, Tracy (Criminal Chief] US Attorney's Of?ce) KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Vogel, Matt (Special Agent] FBI) Berkower, Risa (Attorney I US. Department of Justice) Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/10/2015 17:05 Swanson) Gary (1326 Homicide Minnesota?Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/04/2016 14:50 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 3 On Thursday, December 10, 2015, at about 1315 hours, Olson and Phill attended a second interview with paramedic Tyler John Lupkes. The interviewed was arranged by FBI Vo gel and Kane who were also in attendance. Additionally, Assistant US. Attorney Criminal Chief Tracy Perzel and US. Department of Justice (Civil Rights Division) Risa Berkower were present. The interview took place at the of?ce of the US. Attorney, Minneapolis, MN. At the request of the DOJ and FBI the interview was not audio recorded. The interview concluded at about 1400 hours. FBI Matt Vogel indicated the he would complete a written report summarizing the interview and forward that to the BCA upon completion. The FBI report will be attached to this report upon receipt. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/83 Report Date: 12/13/2015 Primary information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Elk's Club DVR videos Reviewed KATZOVITZ, Michael (SRO - Crime Scene/ Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) O'Donnell, William (1328 I SRO Crime Scene Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) SynOpsis The video ?les from the DVR were viewed. The DIS incident does not appear to have been captured on this device. Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: KATZOVITZ, Michael (SRO - Crime Scene I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/2015 07:55 O'Donnell, William (1328 - Crime Scene I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/2015 09:33 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date . Supervisor Date KATZOVITZ, Michael (SRO - Crime Scene O'Donnell, William (1328 SRO - Crime Scene I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) I?irrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of2 On Friday December 11, 2015, SA Katzovitz received a hard drive from BCA Digital Forensic Specialist Michael Sogard. The drive contains the video files from the Elk?s Club DVR. On the drive are four directories named h, i, j, and k. Each directory contains 1,856 video files for a total of 7,424 video files. The video files are named hiv00000.mp4 - hiv01855.mp4, with the identical names repeated in each directory. All of the video files have a system date of 12/6/2011. However, when the files are viewed, there is a date and time of the recording superimposed on the video. There appear to be seven cameras on the Elk?s Club video system. Camera #5 is on the Northeast corner of the building and rotates approximately 225 degrees from the rear of the building (pointing northwest) to the front of the building (facing south). Camera #5 travels on its path for approximately 2 minutes and 22 seconds for each complete circuit. This camera does show parts of 1611 Plymouth Avenue North for about 30 seconds on each circuit. The videos on the drive reflect dates from July 2015 to October 2015. The last date recorded on the DVR videos appears to be October 28, 2015. Every video file was briefly viewed, with the exception of some files that could not be opened by a video player. The Officer Involved shooting at 1611 Plymouth Avenue North does not appear to have been captured by this DVR. The last dates of the recordings are in alignment with comments from James Frierson of the Elk?s Club, who stated that he has been unable to access the recordings for a period of time before this incident. By virtue of this report no exhibits were acquired. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/84 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Primary information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Lab Report #10, DNA Analysis of Clark's Fingernails Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/201510:35 Phili, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/201510:38 Reporting LEO I. Date supervisor I Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 TTY: (651)282-6555 FAX: 793-290] AN ASCLD/LABJntemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To; BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 10 REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 12/10/2015 Laboratory Number: 15-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; ef?ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Type and Packagipg Description/Source 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection kit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as 3 Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 bloodstain 22 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 ?ngernail clippings 22A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 22B One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 22C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngemail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 22D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 22E One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 24 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 ?ngernail clippings 24A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 24B One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 24C One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 24D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Page 1 of 3 ?ngernail clippings Agency Item Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 10 24E One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item Results of Laboratory Examination: Presumptive testing indicated the presence of blood on Items 22B, 22C, 24A, 24B and 24C. One sample each was collected from Items 22A through 22B and 24A through 24E as Items 22A-2 through and 24A-2 through 24E-2. DNA pro?ling* was performed on Items through 2213-2 and through 24E-2 and was previously performed on Items 15 through 18, and 21. The DNA results are as follows: Item 22A-2 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major male pro?le consistent with Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner The minor types in the DNA mixture are not suitable for comparisons because no loci meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations Items 22B-2, and 24B-2 - Mixtures of three or more individuals 0 Major male pro?les consistent with Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the minor types Items 22C-2, 22E-2 and 24E-2 - Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male pro?le consistent with Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major mixture of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, ef??ey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the major mixture - Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded ?om being a possible contributor to the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.9992% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 24C-2 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major mixture of two or more individuals Page 2 of 3 Laboratory No. Report No. 10 - Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the major mixture 0 Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.999995% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 24D-2 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor It is estimated that 99.995% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Further comparisons can be made to Items 223-2, 24A-2, 24B-2, 24C-2 and if known samples from pertinent individuals are submitted to the BCA Laboratory I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. 2mm Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist loci tested using includes some or all of the following: D881179, D21511, D78820, D138317, D168539, DZSI338, D19S433, TPOX, D18851, D53818, FGA, and Amelogenin. Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Portions of pertinent evidence items have been removed and are being stored at the BCA laboratory. The contents of Items 22A through 22B and 24A through 24E have been retained. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/85 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Primary Information- Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/14/2015 Approved By: Final Autopsy Report for Jamar Clark Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency Hennepin County Medical Examiner 2015-6355 Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/14/201510:38 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 10:40 Reporting LEO Date 1 Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide] Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/86 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information: Description: Review of Minneapolis Public Housing Video Occurrence From: 1111512015 00:00 Occurrence To: 1111512015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Henning, Doug (1361 IMRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 1211412015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (13261MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis SA Phill reviewed the Minneapolis Public Housing video from 11-15-15 on Plymouth Av to search for any footage of the DIS of Jamar Clark. Some blurry images are visible with the 1710 Plymouth SE Entrance camera. No new evidence acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 71710 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1710 PLYMOUTH AVE, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Address #2 - RELATED #1 - 1611 (PLYMOUTH AVE-N Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 -.- Ringgenberg, Mark Deuglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (13851MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 4 I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/86 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Subject #2 - susJe-cfr #2 Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer JUVenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name _i2 [3?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar-Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications LEEYJE NM iats Clo?unto: We mm FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID - Minnesota NO Record Status informatiOn Record Origination Operator: Phili, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 12l14/2015 13:15 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/86 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Record Status Information - Continued Last Update Date: 12l14l201514:10 Reporting LEO 7 Date . Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins onthe' following page.? MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of4 During the week of December 7th thru the 10th 2015, Special Agent Phill reviewed the video supplied by Minneapolis Public Housing (MPH) near the November 15th 2015 of?cer involved shooting at 1611 Plymouth Av N. MPH provided footage from 3 different cameras relative to the shooting address of 1611 Plymouth Av N. The three cameras are all from 1710 Plymouth Av n. Only the one at the South East entrance captured some of the actions in which Jamar Clark approached Hennepin County Medical Center ambulance 419 while they were treating Rayann Hayes. Presumably, Clark can be observed at the 1242 am mark, contacting the EMTs working on Hayes in the back of the ambulance. At the 1246 am mark, Deputy Chief Trullinger arrives to assist his paramedics. At 1248.32secs mark, Minneapolis Of?cers Schwarze and Ringgenberg arrive on scene. It appears from bystander reactions that a gunshot is heard at the 1250 am mark. From that point, ambulance 419 leaves the scene and backup of?cers being to arrive on scene. The picture is not in HD and could not be enhanced at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension to improve the viewing of the video. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/87 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquisition of citizen recording of? Occurrence From: 1211412015 00:00 1 Occurrence To: 12l14/2015 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/16l2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Thursday, December 11th 2015, SA Phill recieved an email file containing a cell phone video of a recording ofq tating what he saw on Nove 15th 2015 in front of his home. The video was burned to disc and labeled A SS evidence item Address #1 RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshi .3 Subject #1 . Primary Information Subject Name: Record Type: Person Bio: 31 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 503 Weight: 230 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS . . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/87 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Subject WITNESS Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address CELLULAR PHONE Subjects Relationship Name CHILD CHILD DB 10 yr. old, Black, Male Identifications ID Type Number State County As 01? Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota 1111 512015 NO LICENSE Subject a WITNESS #2 Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Record Type: Person Bio: 10 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: YES Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Subjects Relationship Name PARENT Subject #3 - OTHER #17 - Murphy, Phillip Ignatious Primary Information Subject Name: Murphy, Phillip Ignatious Record Type: Person Bio: 52 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO I93. 0 Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 511 Weight: 265 Color: Brown .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/87 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Subject #3 OTHER #1 - Murphy, Phillip Personal Information - Continued Hair Color: Brown Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1841 HAMPSHIRE AVE S, St Louis Park, Minnesota 55426 United States Telephones E-Addresses Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Relationship NumberlE-Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State Countgr As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota United States 10/24/2014 NO LICENSE S'ub'i??f #4 Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship 9?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #5 suBfJEcr #2 AS?chWarze, Dustin Timothy 7 .. Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship ?ame B_io_ EMPLOYER MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/87 Report Date: 12/14/2015 Property #1 -'Dvo CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE DVD Containing cell phone video of? Property Evidence Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Description: Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I87.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: Collected Date/1' ime: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE 12I1412015 00:00 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/16/201514:07 Reti??r?ng LE0 . Date. ?Supervisor: . . a . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On December 11th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received an email from Phillip Murphy containing a video ?le. Murphy relayed to SA Phill that he recordeC?telling people what he saw in front of his home on November 15th 2015. Murphy told SA Phill that he is working with the community in North Minneapolis to clean up the neighborhood and address societal problems. As such, he was out on the 1600 block of Plymouth Av at about 73 0am on November 15th after the Minneapolis Police of?cer involved shooting that occurred earlier in the morning. The shooting occurred in front of 1611 Plymouth Av N. Murphy said he heard a 10 year?old boy talking about what he saw so he listened and started recording it on his phone. Murphy said the boy recounted that he saw two Of?cers struggle with and then handcuff a man. They then shot him in the face and took off the handcuffs before everyone else arrived. Murphy asked the boy?s name and he said_ It should be noted that ad already been interviewed at CornerHouse for this case. The video was not transcribed because-it could not be determined who was speaking in the video other than? SA Phill burned the video to a DVD and labeled it ACISS item number 20 1 5?648/ 87.1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/88 Report Date: 12/15/2015 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Acquisition of Uniforms from Ringgenberg and Schwarze Occurrence From: 12/14/2015 14:00 Occurrence To: 12I14I2015 16:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12I23I2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On December 14th 2015, SA Phill retrieved the uniforms of Ofcs Ringgenberg and Schwarze from Fred Bruno for Trace analysis at the BCA Lab. The bags were given ACISS item numbers and 88.2 in this case. Address #1 - Occurred #1 5500 WAYZATA BLVD Primary Information Address: 5500 WAYZATA BLVD #1000, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416 United States Description: Law Offices of Frederic Bruno Subject #1 - Engle; Samantha Jeanine; I Primary Information Subject Name: Engle, Samantha Jeanne Record Type: Person Bio: - 27 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 507 Weight: 150 Color: Blue Hair Color: Blond Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Straight Complexion: Glasses Type: CLEAR GLASSES Addresses Siam Meg . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/88 Report Date: 12/15/2015 subject .- OTHER #1 - Engle, Samantha Jeanne? Continued . Addresses - Continued Relationship Address BUSINESS LOCATION 5500 WAYZATA BLVD #1000, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416 United States Identifications ID Type Number State Countm As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota United States 1 2/14/201 5 NO LICENSE Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark.-DotIglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_i0 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: a Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects DEE EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/88 Report Date: 12/15/2015 Subject SUBJECT #3 -.Clark, Jamar oneal - Continued Primary Information - Continued Birth Date: 0510311991 JUVenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications Mei ??at_e FBI ID 717111FD1 01D 232941 Minnesota State ID Minnesota 519% Fictitious NO NO NO Comment Property #1 ~?Bag Containing?gUniform PanhandFIQecePullover . Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Clothing Description: Bag Containing Uniform Pant and Fleece Pullover Property Status: Pending Lab Status Date: 12I15I2015 Quantity: 1 Control Number: Owner: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Property #2 - Bag Containing Uniform Pant andUniform Shirt Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Clothing Description: Bag Containing Uniform Pant and Uniform Shirt Property Status: Pending Lab .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13237 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/88 Report Date: 12/15/2015 Property #2 - Bag Containing?Uniform Paint and Uniform Shirt - Continued Primary Information - Continued Status Date: 1 2115/2015 Quantity: 1 Control umber: 2015-648I88.2 Owner: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Officers D59 TEGDesch, Jeff (Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - St. Paul) Record. status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/1512015 10:44 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12/23/2015 12:11 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative - begins on the folio/Wing; page. .1- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phil]. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On December l4"h 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill retrieved two bags of uniform clothing from Samantha Engle of the Fred Bruno Law Firm in Minneapolis. SA Phill made the request of Fred Bruno that Of?cers Schwarze and Ringgenberg provide their uniform pants and tops worn on November 15"h 2015 at their of?cer involved shooting in Minneapolis. Fred Bruno advised SA Phill that the uniforms were secured in their lockers on November 15th. On November 25th, the uniforms were put back on for 15 minutes prior to roll call. They were then then sent back home on admin leave. They then put their uniforms back in their respective lockers until December 14th when they were retrieved per Fred Bruno?s request. The uniforms were neVer washed and never handled by others. SA Phill labeled one bag as ACISS evidence number 88.1 and it contained Schwarze?s navy blue cargo pants and navy blue police ?eece top. Item 88.2 contained Ringgenberg?s navy blue cargo pants and light blue long sleeved shirt. On December 15th, SA Phill delivered both bags of clothing to the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) Lab. The items were received by lab technician Jeff Tegdesch for analysis. All relevant forms regarding the items of evidence have been attached to this report. STATE OF MINNESOTA PS-S-OUSO (Rev. 12/02) DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, ?95106 Bureau of Crimma! Amcrehension NE. Laboratory Nd"? ?mw Evidence ?em SW. Lab Guam Name In? Porscm From Pz'Iz-perty is purpose Fm Which Obtained It 2: . r" bf: :53 ?1?.mm DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES zinc an- van/vac, um?f"#955: HAVE REQEIVED AND EUR fut-{E ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE I Time . Siunaiure '1 rum gI?ra 9 Site CHAIN OF CUSTODY Dene Rehnquished By RECEIVE B?y? i Signature I I ?Ni Signature 6,133 Agency Case Number 2015648 BCA St. Paul I430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Aun: SA Mike Phiil MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55 106 Loot-mint: Number TEL: 65 2-7934900 TTY: 65 14424555 FAX: 651.793-2902 LABORATORY ANALYSIS REQUEST COUNTY: chnepin TELEPHONE: 551?7934 100 TYPE OF CASE: Of?cer Involved Shootingfwilh :1 Death Report Distribution: BCA St. Paul - Section Involved Trace Estimated Due Date (S CIRCUMSTANCES AND PURPOSE OFANALYSIS: Fiber comparison PRINCIPALS: Schwarze. Dustin Timothy Mark Douglas Clark, Jamar Oneal Sivorskl, Jeffrey Steven Conner, Chad Michael Date Of Hi?! 5:31199] .4 common-o}; f9 ?53 no 00% ITEM DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE: 11cm 26 In Container 27 Packagino and Time One brown paper bag containing evidence classified as C101]!ng Source 1 Description pants 8: llecce Dustin Timolhy Schwarze - item 89.! One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants shirt, Mark Douglas clothing item 89.2 Page on Lab Case Submitted By Received Bv 12/15/2015 {1:59:10 SA Mike Phi? Submission Date and Time Page 2 on. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/89 Report Date: 12/15/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: Approved By: Lab Report #11, Trace report on black item under nail Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Stast Iani'matEQW A Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12116/2015 14:07 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/16/2015 14:09 LE0 . I Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I PhiIl, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: (651) 793?2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Trace 12/15/2015 Laboratory Number: SIS-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Trace Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Report No. AFETY 515?14003 11 Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jef?ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: ltgn; Type and Packag?gg Description/Source 9 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Duty Belt ?om Mark Douglas Ringgenberg an item of evidence 22 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 ?ngernail clippings 24 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 ?ngernail clippings 24A One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as trace evidence from ?ngernail ?ngernail clippings 24A-1a One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as - unknown black material ?om ?ngernail unknown material Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 11 Results of Laboratory Examination: The black material from Item 24 (sub-itemized as Item 24A?1a) was analyzed by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy and compared to nine different areas on the Item 9 duty belt. The chemical composition was di?erent and therefore, the Item 9 can be eliminated as being the source of the unknown black material in Item 24A-la (Elimination). Item 22 did not contain any black material and there was some black material from Item 24 that was too small to fuither characterize. Elimination: Items exhibit dissimilarities in one or more of the following: physical properties, chemical composition or microscopic characteristics and, therefore, conclusively did not originate from the same source. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. Susan T. Gross Forensic Science Supervisor Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/90 Report Date: 12/17/2015 Primary information 7 Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/17/2015 Approved By: Evidence transfer - Olson to Phill OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Recdrd Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/17/201511:33 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12/17/2015 11:46 Reporting LEO Date: Supenrisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 2 On Thursday, December 17, 2015, SA Olson provided the following items of evidence to SA Phill. Item Number Item 6.1 DVD Video of?interview 6.2 Audio CD?interview 8.1 Audio CD Temeisha 9.1 Audio CD Lavell Bible 9.2 Data CD 5 photographs from Lavell Bible 9.3 Hand drawn diagram Lavell Bible 10.1 Audio CD Jerome Copeland 38.1 MPD Squad Video (425) 48.1 Audio CD Of?cer Anna Hedberg 48.2 Hand drawn diagram Of?cer Hedberg 49.1 Audio CD Of?cer Ben Badowich 53.1 Audio CD Of?cer Gabriel Grout 57.1 Audio CD 68.1 Squad video (424 expanded) 75.1 Audio CD Charesse Douglas 76.1 Audio CD Joseph Lane Jr. 79.1 CelleBrite photo extraction (Bible) The transfer of the aforementioned 17 items took place at the BCA headquarters (see attached evidence receipt). End report. STATE OF MINNESOTA PS-6-0030 (REV 12102) :Mjnnesota DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 . Bureau of Appr?hensIon Bureau No. Laboratory No. Evidence No. EVIDENCE RECEIPT 3_w_ Lab (If Person From Whom Property is Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained Item Quan- .. @421 Age: 5w. DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES Come/s L97, ALLAIO QB -- i 00" NATO Cb T?cH?thHi-I T??frci OM MAN c9 - 0m. Cb- Maggi?) ?iIJe 93 AHMI claim? mum @3in IN NAIL) c) - If}:wa 3?31 9435 Ari?[25? Aw?r?o QB - Au.? mg Nari- rim; Armi Amw? AM MIME, I CERTIFY HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Datemme Signature Storage Site CHAIN OF CUSTODY Item NO. Date Relinquished By Received By a. i Signature Signature I h] x? 921?7'7' r394 min STATE OF MINNESOTA (REV- 12/02) Minnesota DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION a 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau Of C?minaI ApprehenSIon Bureau N0. Laboratory No. Evidence No. EVIDENCE RECEIPT 2mg; (04% s_w_ Lab Na of Person From Whom Property is Obtained Purpo For Which Obtained Item Quan- .. No. for? may? tity I '3th Q: I DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES ?(all C) DTFIL Sicioujc?u-I g9} Adi-Aha QB O-FL. (Myth. gear 57?? MAID Qb - I 13M dIIcIio 933 ?x?fpr?cIicI, RAN: Cb RICA db 1m cgrkigr? ?Lm qIn-amu rs?L?e CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Date/Time Signature Storage Site CHAIN OF CUSTODY Item NO Date Reiinquished By Received By SIgnature Signature vi! A Ive 1?5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/91 Report Date: 12/17/2015 Warning I Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information . - 7 . . Description: Acquisition of photos from PD Det Karakostas Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/18/2015 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) On December 17th 2015, SA Phill received 9 photos taken of Jamar Clark while being treated in HCMC. The photos were taken by Det Karakostas on his cell phone on Nov 15th 2015. SA Phill burned the photos onto a disc and labeled them evidence item in ACISS. Address #1 - OccUrred #1 - Hennepin county Medical Center Primary Information Address: Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Address RELATED #1 - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name Bio DOB Subject #1 - - Ringgeznbergi, MarkDouglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 0?3. EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/91 Report Date: 12/17/2015 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 Schwa'rze, Dustin Timothy Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects mm Nine B_io EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) SU?lijectzita 4 SUBJECT Clark, Jam?arOneal Primary information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05l03l1 991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks identifications ID Type Number is}; County As Of Date Fictitious _Co_mn_j_e_11t_ FBI ID 717111FD1 NO 010 232941 Minnesota NO State ID - Minnesota NO Property #1 - DVD Cont-ainingS photos taken of Jamar Clark in HCMC Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/91 Report Date: 12/17/2015 Prob?rty - Clark in, Home continued, Primary Information - Continued Description: DVD Containing 9 photos taken of Jamar Clark in HCMC Quantity: 1 Control Number: 201 5-648191 .1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 12/17/2015 00:00 (Officers Karakostas, Chris (Sgt. I Minneapolis Police Department) Record Status Information I Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 19:55 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 12:14 Reporting LEO: - Eg Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) I?rrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 4 On Thursday, December 17th 2015, Special Agent (SA) Phill received 9 photos taken by Minneapolis Police Detective Sergeant (Det Sgt) Karakostas. Det Karakostas took the photos of Jamar Clark While he was laying on a hospital bed at Hennepin County Medical Center. SA Phill burned the 9 pictures of Clark onto a DVD and labeled item number in ACISS. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/92 Report Date: 12/28/2015 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 12/28/2015 Approved By: Lab Report #12, Trace Report on Nail Fibers Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12I28I2015 09:41 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12l28/2015 10:15 Reporting LEO . - Date I Supervisory Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTIVIENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: (651) 793?2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To; BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 12 Trace 12/22/2015 Laboratory Number: SIS-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Trace Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jef?ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item 22 22A 22A-1 22B 22B-1 22C 22C-1 22D 22D-1 22E 22E-1 24A 24B 24B-1 24C Page 1 of 3 Type and Packagng One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings Description/Source right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence from ?ngernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail single ?ngemail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item 24D 24D-1 24E 24E-1 26 26A 26B 27 27A 2713 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as clothing Results of Laboratory Examination: Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 12 trace evidence ?'om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?'om ?ngernail single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item trace evidence ?om ?ngernail pants ?eece - Dustin Timothy Schwarze - item 89.1 ?eece jacket - Dustin Timothy Schwarze - item 89.] pants - Dustin Timothy Schwarze - item 89.1 pants shirt, Mark Douglas Riggenberg - item 89.2 shirt, Mark Douglas Riggenberg - item 89.2 pants, Mark Douglas Riggenberg - item 89.2 All of the ?bers on Item 22 were different in type, color, microscopic characteristics and/ or visible spectra (MSP) to the known ?bers in Items 26A, 26B and 27B and therefore, can be eliminated as having a common source (Elimination). One light blue ?ber was found on Item 22B-l that could not be eliminated from Item 27A known ?bers based on color and delusterant, however, due to the damaged condition of the unknown ?ber, ?nther analysis was not possible and therefore, it is inconclusive if Item 27A could be the source of the unknown light blue ?ber in Item 22B-1 (Inconclusive). All other ?bers on Item 22 were different in type, color, microscopic characteristics and/or visible spectra (MSP) to the known ?bers in Item 27A, and therefore, can be eliminated as having a common source (Elimination). All of the ?bers on Item 24 were different in type, color, microscoPic characteristics and/or visible spectra (MSP) to the known ?bers in Items 26A, 26B and 27A and therefore, can be eliminated as having a common source (Elimination). One small blue cotton ?ber was found on Item 24B-1 that was similar in type, color and visible spectra (MSP) to the Item 27B known ?bers. Therefore, Item 27 cannot be eliminated as being the source of this unknown ?ber (Type 4 Association). All other ?bers on Item 24 were different in type, color, microscopic characteristics and/or visible spectra (MSP) to the known ?bers in Item 27B and therefore, can be eliminated as having a common source (Elimination). It should be noted that blue cotton ?bers are commonly encountered in the environment and may have limited forensic signi?cance. KEY for instrument acronyms: MSP Microspectrophotometry Page 2 of 3 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 12 Interpretation: The following descriptions are meant to provide context to the opinions reached in this report. Every type of conclusion may not be applicable in every case or for every material type. Type 1 Association: Identi?cation An association in which items share individual characteristics and/or physically ?t together that demonstrate the items were once ?om the same source- Type 2 Association: Highly liker An association in which items correspond in all measured physical preperties, chemical composition and/or microsc0pic characteristics and share distinctive characteristic(s) that would not be expected to be found in the population of this evidence type. The distinctive characteristics were not suf?cient for a Type 1 Association. Type 3 Association: Could have An association in which items correspond in all measured physical properties, chemical composition and/or microscopic characteristics and could have originated ?om the same source. Because it is possible for another sample to be indistinguishable from the submitted evidence, an individual source cannot be determined. Type 4 Association: Cannot eliminate An association in which items correspond in some but possibly not all measured physical properties, chemical composition and/or microscopic characteristics and cannot be eliminated as coming from the same source. This type of evidence may be commonly encountered in the environment, may have limited comparative value and/or there may be factor(s) limiting the comparison. Inconclusive: conclusion could be reached regarding an association between the items. Elimination: Items exhibit dissimilarities in one or more of the following: physical properties, chemical composition or microscoPic characteristics and, therefore, conclusively did not originate from the same source. Non?Association: Items exhibit dissimilarities but certain details or features are not suf?cient for an Elimination. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and inteipretations- Susan T. Gross Forensic Science Supervisor Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/93 Report Date: 01/04/2016 Primary information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: SPPD March 2015 Domestic Case against Clark Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 01/04/2016 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Op Record Origination Da Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: erator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) te: 01/04/201612:51 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/04/2016 13:30 Reporting LEO 7 7 - . Date Supervisor. I I Date . Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of2 On January 4th 2015, SA Phill attached a St Paul PD report from March 2015 regarding Clark. This report was obtained by the FBI and forwarded to SA Phill for the case ?le. No ?lrther actions taken or evidence acquired. CRIMINAL DOMESTIC ABUSE CONTACT Minn. Stat. 629.75 (?Probationary? Order) El Amended Order I 04 State of Minnesota District Court County: Ramsey . 'iet: SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT on umber: 15056543 Case Type: Criminal State of Minnesota vs. . Defendant Defendant Identi?ers l- Jamar'O'Neal Clark . lGender: Female Male DOB: 5/3/1991 I Firs"! Middle - Last . Protected Personf?s) Protected Ferson(s) Identi?ers Tiffany LeVette Truitt . Gender: Female Male DOB: 'First Middle Last I . Gender: Female [3 Male DOB: Gender: sealant] Male DOB: THE COURT FINDS: That it, has jurisdiction over theparties and subject matter, and the'Defendant has been or will be provided with reasonable notice and opportunity to be heard. THE COURT ORDERS: . Yqu are ordered to have no contact directly; indirectly or through Others, in person, by telephone, in writing, electronically or by any other means with the protected persdn(s) named above. You may not go to the folloWing location(s): or wherever the protected person resides. Except with a police escort to recover prescription medications, personal clothing and toiletries. Other; . You are also restrained from harassing, stalking, or threatening the protected person(s), or engaging in other conduct that would place the protected pers'on(s) in reasonable fearof bodily injury to that person; and You are prohibited from the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the'protected perscn(s) that wduid reasonably be expected to cause bodily injury. THIS onosn REMAIN IN sensor UNTEL: DATE: or Funnies ORDER on MODIFICATION WARNINGS TO DEFENDANT: This orderjis entitled to full faith and credit and shall be enforced anywhere in the U.S. including Tribal Lands (1 8 U.S.C. 2265). Crossing state, territorial, Or tribal boundaries to violate this order may result in federal imprisonment (18 U.S.C. 2262). Federal [at-w prohibits shipping, transporting, possessing or receiving ?reatms or ammunition while this order is in effect and upon conviction of a crime of domestic violence. 18 This order replaces any prior no contact order issued in this case. Compliance with this Order is a condition of your probation or stay and is in addition to any other conditions that may be imposed. Your probation (stay may be revoked if you violate any aspect of this Order. A violation of this order is a crime and may cause you to beam ed and subject ?irther criminal charges. . - . DATED: COURT on L9 . (date) By: (Initials) STAFF JAIL STAFF Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Matsen' Michael Name of location/business: Primary squad: 333 Location of incidentSecondary reporting officer: Hansenl Christopher ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver: Schmidt. Thomas District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Yes Secondary offense: LIFE Police Of?cerAsseu/ted or injured: Police Of?cerAssisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: Yes OFFENSE DETAILS TERRORISTIC THREATS) Attempt Only: Appears to be Gang Related: Crime Scene Method Point of Entry Type: Residential occup Force used: Hid Inside: Description: Single, Duplex, Townhome Pointofantry: Method: LIFE Attempt Only: Yes Appears to be Gang Related: Crime Scene Method Point of Entry Type: ResidentiaI prop, occup Force used: Hid Inside: Description: Single, Duplex, Townhome Point of entry: Method: SP7FA945C271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 0? ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) ARRESTS Booked Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Booking date: 03/20/2015 Date 8. time of arrest: 03/20/2015 10:30 Booking time: 10:59 Arrest made on View: Yes Booking Arrest made on warrant or previous CN: Warrant number: Originating agency: Warrant type: Charge/Citation/Bail Amount: Te rroristic Threats Attempted Arson of Occupied Dwelling NAMES Arrestee Clark, Jamar Oneal 4007 BRYANT AV KNOWN MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55412 Nicknames or Aliases Nick Name: Alias: AKA First Name: AKA Last Name: Details Sex: Ma e Race: Black DOB: 05/0311 991 Resident Status: Hispanic: Age: 23 from to Phones Home: Cell: Contact: Work: Fax: Pager: Employment Occupation: Employer: identi?cation SSN: License or lD#: License State: Physical Description US: Yes Metric: No Height: 508 to Build: Slender Hair Length: Hair Color: Weight: 150 to 160 Skin: Medium Brown Facial Hair: Hair Type: Teeth: Color: Brown Blood Type: SP7FA9450271 F63 Saint Paul Police Department Page 3 0? ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) istinguishing Marks red hooded jacket Clothing 8. Additional Description red hooded jacket blue jeans Offender information Arrested: Yes Pursuit engaged: Violeted Restraining Order: DUI: Resistance encountered: Condition: Taken to health care facility: Medical release obtained: Weapons Used by Police Weapans Used by Suspect at Time of Arrest Other Witness Johnson, Shawn Demar 713 JENKS AV Apt 2 ST PAUL, MN 55106 Nicknames or Aliases Nick Name: Alias: AKA First Name: AKA Last Name: Details Sex: Male Race: Black DOB: Resident Status: Hispanic: Age: 36 from to Phones Home: Cell:? Contact: Work: Fax: Pager: Employment Occupation: Employer: identi?cation SSN: License or lD#: License State: SP7FA945C271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 4 0?8 ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) ARSON INFORMATION Property insured: Who reported arson: Amount of loss: Who discovered arson: Estimated value: Who secured premises: insurance company: Insurance agent: Company address: Company phone: DOMESTIC ASSAULT . Violation of court order: Aciion: Arrest by officer SOLVABILITY FACTORS Suspect can be Identi?ed: Yes By: Victim Photos Taken: Yes Stolen Prepen?y Traceable: Evidence Turned in: Yes Property Tumed in: Related Incident: Lab Biological Analysis: Fingerprints Taken: - Narcotic Analysis: items Fingerprinted: Lab Comments: Participants: Person Type: Name: Address: Phone: Arrestee Clark, Jamar Oneal 4007 BRYANT AV MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55412 Witness Johnson, Shawn Demar 713 JENKS AV Apt 2 ST PAUL, MN 55106 NARRATIVE ICC squad 1369 Squad 333 (Matsen/Hansen) were sent to 713 Jenks Av upper unit, on 3/20/15 at 0940 for a property assist. We were initially called to assist a male in picking up property. Upon arrival the male We were sent to assist in picking up property was GOA. That male was later as, Jamar Oneal Clark. We spoke with a female at the address iD?d as, Tiffany Levette Truitt, Truitt and Clark had been dating in a short term relationship up until a week prior when she told him she wanted to stop seeing him. Clark and Truitt had an argument that led to him leaving her address at 713 Jenks upper SP7FA945CZT1 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 5 ?f8 ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) unit. Truitt told us she was awoken by her kids telling her Clark was at the front door asking for his wallet. He was there around 0900 hrs. When she came to the door he told her he needed is wallet. Truitt said she gave him the wallet and closed the door. Clark returned a very short time later and requested his clothing and "papers" (referring to his birth certificate). Truitt said she slipped the papers under the door. Clark became upset and told her he wanted the rest of his stuff. Truitt refused because she did not feel comfortable letting him inside the house. Truitt said Clark was outside in front yelling. He grabbed two bricks from the front yard walking path and threw them at her bedroom window breaking the window. Truitt said Clark then yelled out, "alright bitch, l'm gonna burn this bitch down". After Clark left Truitt opened the door and smelled a strong odor of lighter fluid. Truitt said she looked down at the staircase and observed a wet liquid on the staircase leading all the way down to the front porch. Truitt believed Clark poured the fluid on the staircase after he threatened to burn the house down but she did not see him. She said the lighter fluid bottle was initially on the back porch from a BBQ the previous week. When asked the blueprint lethality questions Truitt answered as follows. 1) Do you think he will seriously injure or kill you or your children? Yes, due to his past history of harming people and his heart being broken by me. 2) How frequently and seriously does he intimidate, threaten or assault you? She stated he hasn't and doesn't but she thinks he would not try. 3) When was the time you were the most frightened or injured by him? She didn't know, didn't recall previously being frightened by him and was never injured. - Stated he told her at the time of their break up that he couldn't leave her and will never be able to leave her. 4) Does the suspect mistreat animals? She replied no. Truitt had her four children who were sick at home with her at the time of the incident. They were lD'd as, and ruitt had her sister pick the kids up and take them to her house because of the lighter fluid on the floor and her fear of Clark's behavior. Truitt's friend (boyfriend of her girlfriend was inside the address. He was lD'd as, Shawn Roper (actually believed to be Shawn Demar Johnsonh Roper was not on scene when we arrived. He left before police arrival because he didn't not want to be involved. Roper was hesitant to be cooperative. Roper told me he was on parole but he refused to tell parole. Roper also refused to give me his contact phone number but I obtained the number from Truitt's phone that was speaking to him on. Over the phone he told me he was inside and heard the commotion at the front door between Truitt and Clark. After the window was broken Roper said he came out and smelled a strong odor of lighter fluid on the front stairwell leading down to the front porch. Clark was standing out front. Roper walked down and asked Clark what he was doing? Roper said Clark fled on foot w/b towards Payne Ave. Roper stated he didn't see Clark with the lighter fluid in his hands or a lighter but the fluid was still wet on the floor when he smelled it. We observed an open bottle of lighter fluid in the front yard just to the west of the front steps. The bottle was mostly empty with a small amount of fluid still inside. The front upstairs bedroom window was broken out. We located in the front yard off the walking patch where two bricks were removed from the ground. When we walked inside the front common porch we could smell a very strong odor of accelerant. We could clearly observe to the plain wet fluid on the floor rug leading all the way up the wooden staircase to the upstairs F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 5 0?8 ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and ?lime of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Pn'mary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) door. The accelerant odor smelled consistent with lighter fluid. We did not locate a lighter or other incendiary device related to the incident. At the scene we recovered the lighter fluid bottle and a floor rug from the front porch that was soaked in lighter fluid I accelerant. The lighterfluid (item was turned it into the gas locker. The rug (item was turned into pl #41. While we were at the scene officer C. Johnson located Clark at the intersection of Payne and Jenks. Clark had walked to the SPPD Eastern District office and requested officers to escort him to the property to obtain his belongings. When located he was walking back to the address. Clark was arrested without incident at that location. We transported him to the LEC. We contacted FSVU. We were advised to book Clark for felony terroristic threats and attempted arson. He was booked without incident. St. Paul intervention was contacted regarding the incident. We took the following photo's at the scene. List of Photosfor CN 15056543: . - OVERALL HOUSE . ADDRESS . - FRONT OF HOUSE . - OVERALL BOTTLE . - OVERALL BOTTLE . - CLOSE UP BOTTLE . 15056543-0319201 FRONT DOOR . ENTRY WAY . - ENTRY WAY FLOOR . ENTRY WAY . STEPS . - STEPS . STEPS . - STEPS . - STEPS . 1 - STEPS . - STEPS . 'l - STEPS . ?l STEPS . STEPS . - UPPER LANDING . - UPPER STEPS . - UPPER STEPS . - UPPER STEPS AND DOOR TO UPPER UNIT . - UPPER STEPS AND DOOR TO UPPER UNIT SP7FA9450271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 7 0? ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/20/2015 10:54:00 Pn'mary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) 26. - UPPER STEPS AND DOOR TO UPPER UNIT 27. - UPPER STEPS AND DOOR TO UPPER UNIT 28. - FRONT OF HOUSE 29. - AREA WHERE BRICK MAY HAVE BEEN TAKEN 30. - CORNER OF HOUSE 31. - CORNER OF HOUSE 32. - BROKEN WINDOW, CORNER UPPER LEVEL 33. - BRICK 34. - BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL 35. - BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL, INSIDE 36. - BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL, INSIDE 37. - BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL, INSIDE 38. - BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL, INSIDE 39. BROKEN WINDOW, CONRER UPPER LEVEL, INSIDE 40. BROKEN GLASS ON ROOF 41. - BROKEN GLASS ON ROOF 42. BRICK The labeled photos were TRANSFERRED to the Media Vault. End of report. PUBLIC NARRATIVE Squad 333 (Matsen/Hansen) were sent to 713 Jenks Av on 3/20/15 at 0940 for a property assist. We were initially called to assist a male in picking up property. At the scene we learned the suspect had thrown a brick at the upper bedroom window and poured lighter fluid on the staircase of the occupied dwelling in an attempt to intimidate and threaten the victim. Arrested nearby without incident was Jamar Oneal Clark, 23 yoa, NPA-4007 Bryant Av MN. Clark was transported to the LEC and booked for felony terroristic threats and attempted arson. SP7FA94SCZT1FBS Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/30/2015 15:43:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Sipesl Nichole Name of location/business: Primary squad: Location of incidentSecondary reporting officer: ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver: District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Officer Assaulted or injUred: I Police Officer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE (OFF. N. SIPES) am assigned to the Family Violence Unit. On this date SGT RANDALL requested that conduct a follow up interview with a witness, in this case. I spoke tent her residence (713 Jenks Ave E, Upper) with her mother. TIFFANY present. asked ~what she witnessed during this incident between her mother and the suspect, JAMAR CLARK. She said JAMAR "told us he was going to set the house on fire and kill us." She said he had lighter fluid and a red lighter. She said he was lighting the lighter and she could hear it (she made a noise attempting to imitate the sound of a lighter being flicked on). She said he was on the stairs at the front of the house but when he saw a neighbor he "flew off? the porch. asked-if she thought JAMAR was going to set the house on fire. She said "uh huh." I asked her if it was scary and she told me "very scary." I then spoke togwho told me that JAMAR "busted out the window in our mom's room.? He said that JAMAR "called his mother a bad word." He said that JAMAR broke the window with a brick. He said that his baby sister was "asleep right he heard JAMAR say "I'll set your house on fire." He said he "got scared" and told his mom. He said they all went across the street to his cousin's house. I spoke to?who told me that JAMAR "called my mom a slut." He said he heard JAMAR tell his mom "bitch, l'm gonna set your house on The interviews were all recorded and later downloaded to the SPPD secure Media Vault. TIFFANY told me she is moving out of state on 3/31/15. She said she will continue to cooperate and would return if needed for court. She said she will maintain the same cell number and will notify us if it changes. I left her my business card. SP7FA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/30/2015 15:43:00 Priman/ offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) PUBLIC NARRATIVE P7FA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/30/2015 08:28:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Officer: Ran-ideal]I David Name of location/business: Primary squad: Location of incidentSecondary reporting officer: ST PAU L1 55101 Approver: District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Of?cer Assaulted or injured: Police O?'icer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE l, Sergeant Randall - St. Paul Police Family Violence Unit, contacted the victim, Tiffany Truitt? by phone on 03/23/2015. I advised her of the charges against Jamar Clerk. I told Truitt that the Ramsey County Attorney wanted me to get a follow up interview with her oldest child and sister. Truitt did not want to give me her sister's contact information but said she would give her my number and ask if she would be willing to call. As of this date (03/30/2015) i have not heard from Tuitt's sister. Truitt agreed to an interview of her daughter. I told her an officer would be contacting her to set up a time when her daughter was not at school. Officer Monson attempted to arrange an interview with negativeresults. (see supplements). PUBLIC NARRATIVE SP7FA9450271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Repon? 15056543 03/29/2015 15:31:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Manson, Megan Name of location/business: primary squad; Location of incidentSecondary repom'ng of?cer: ST PAU L, MN 55101 Approve/1' District: Eastern Data time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09;00;00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Of?cer Assaulted or injured: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE Police Of?cer Assisted Suicide: On 03/27/2015 at 1330 hours I, Of?cer Monson, assigned to the SPPD Family Violence Unit did follow up on this case. I called the Victim. TIFFANY at ill?and left a voicemaii, asking her to call me back. As of 03/29/2015 at 1531 hours I had not heard back from TIFFANY. PUBLIC NARRATIVE SP7FA945C271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN 15056543 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Date and Time of Report 03/26/2015 16:23:00 Primary Reporting Of?cer. Monson1 Megan Name of location/business: Primary squad: Location of incident: 713 ENKS AV Apt Up Secondary reporting of?cer? ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver? District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Of?cer Assaulted or injured: Police Of?cer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE On 03/26/2015 at 1421 hours I, Officer Monson, assi gned to the SPPD Famin Violence Unit did follow up on this case. I called the Victim. TIFFANY at and left a voicemail, asking her to call me back. NARRATIVE SPTFA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 ?13 SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/23/2015 23:07:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Johnsonl Thor Name of location/business: Pn?mery squad: 956 Location of incident: 367 GROVE ST Secondary reporting of?cer: ST PAULI MN 55102 Approver: Gray, Shari District: Eastern Date 6. time of occurrence: 03/23/2015 23:07:00 to Site: 03/23/2015 23:07:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Officer Assaulted or injured: Police Officer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: OFFENSE DETAILS TERRORISTIC THREATS) Attempt Only: Appears to be Gang Related: NAMES Other 367 GROVE ST ST PAUL, MN 55102 Nicknames or Aliases Nick Name: Alias: AKA First Name: AKA Last Name: Details Sex: Race: DOB: Resident Status: Hispanic: Age: from to g: Phones Home: Cell: Contact: Work: Fax: Pager: Employment Occupation: Employer: SP7FA945C271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/23/2015 23:07:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Identi?cation SSN: License or License State: SOLVABILITY FACTORS Suspect can be Identi?ed: 31/5 Photos Taken: Stolen Property Traceable: Evidence Turned In: Property Turned In: Related Incident: Lab Biological Analysis: Fingerprints Taken: Narcotic Analysis: Items Fingerprinted: Lab Comments: PROPERTY ITEM #1 Type ofLoss: Recovered Dale of Loss: Location Lost: Owner: Date Recovered: 03/23/2015 Location Recovered: CCTV Lab Model Quantity: 1 Serial Article Type/Item: Other property I Miscellaneous items Totalvaluef Description: ICC disc; 153254.av Turned in at: Property room locker Locker ID CCTV1 Lab exams: Participants: Person Type: Name: Add ress: Phone: Other 367 GROVE ST ST PAUL, MN 55102 NARRATIVE I, Officer JOHNSON, am currently assigned to the Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) Unit, a division of the Technology Unit. i assist in monitoring the CCTV cameras throughout the city of St. Paul. I also assist investigators with locating. and exporting, CCTV and In Car Camera (ICC) video. I received a request from Wendy DeZelar of the Ramsey County Attorney's Office to recover ICC video from this incident. I reviewed the reports and located the following related video file: SP7FA9450271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 3 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/23/2015 23:07:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Officers MATSEN, HANSEN. vehicle number 1369. file 153254.av exported the file on to one (1) disc and turned the disc into CCTV locker today 03/23/2015. It should be known Officer Nicole ERICKSON was signed onto the ICC of squad 1369 but it was Officers HANSEN and MATSEN who were in the vehicle at the time of this video. PUBLIC NARRATIVE Supplement report. SP7FA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Comp/amt Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/23/2015 12:11:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Randall, David Name of/ocation/business: Primary squad: Location of incident: 713 JENKS AV Apt Up Secondary reporting of?cer: ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approx/er: District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:001?0 Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 An'est made: Secondary offense: Police Officer Assaulted or Injured: Police Of?cer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE This case was reviewed on 03/23/2015 by Assistant Ramsey County Attorney Elaine Ashbaugh. The suspect, Jamar Clark was charged with the following counts: 1? Terroristic Threats (F) 2- Criminal Damage to Property, ?ist Degree (F) 3- Criminal Damage to Property, 4th Degree (M) 4- Domestic Assault (M) CBA PUBLIC NARRATIVE Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 ?f2 SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/22/2015 13:57:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Manson, Megan Name of location/business: Primary Squad: Location of incidentSecondary reporting of?cer: ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver: District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Of?cerAssaulted or injured: Police Officer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE It should be noted that when an inmate is processed into the RCLEC they are assigned a PIN to use for making phone calls while in the facility. The inmate is required to enter the PIN when making a phone call. Inmates will often use another inmate's PIN when making calls. This is done to circumvent the inmate dialing a number for a party that may be protected in a DANCO or an OFP. The phone system is recorded and a recording announces that to both parties when the call is connected. On 03/22/2015 at 1357 hours I, Officer Monson, assigned to the SPPD Family Violence Unit did follow up on this case. When I spoke with the victim in this case, TIFFANY told me she was sure the suspect, JAMAR ONEAL CLARK (05/03/1991), had contacted his family from jail because she had started getting text messages and phone calls from people she didn't know about the incident. I searched for phone calls made under JAMAR's PIN 0308132 from 0311912015 at 0000 hours to 03/22/2015 at 0000 hours. There were 4 phone calls made with only 3 calls that were connected. The number he calls his mother at?is registered in the Securus system as: Irma Burns 4007 Bryant Ave N, Minneapolis, MN 55412. I found this same name and address connected to the phone number in Clear. There was no party registered in the Securus system to 312-214-0640 and in Clear the number was only connected to Minneapolis, MN. On 03/20/2015 at 1729 hours JAMAR called his mother at ?He tells her he doesn't understand what happened and why he was arrested because TIFFANY chased him around, pouring lighter fluid down his back and it was all over his clothes. Towards the end of the conversation JAMAR says, "l'm tryin to figure out how can they do this he said she said stuff when there's no evidence besides the evidence of lighter fluid down MY back and on HER stairs in HER hallway." On 03/20/2015 at 1738 hours JAMAR called his mother back at?and somebody named "Johnny" answers the phone. Johnny asks Jamar why he didn't leave as soon as he got his wallet and JAMAR replies, SP7FA9450271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 0?2 SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/22/2015 13:57:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) "Cause wanted all my stuff." Johnny says, "She said you bust her windows try to start her house on JAMAR says he didn't do that and Johnny asks him why he's in jail. JAMAR says it's because she called the police and Johnny says there must be some sort of evidence for him to be locked up. JAMAR says, "i was nowhere in the vicinity. The evidence is lighter fluid. That's it! The evidence is lighter fluid all done my fucking back. Ain't no lighter fluid on her! There's lighter fluid down the stairs. Lighter fluid all in my hair, all on my back." Johnny says that if there's lighter fluid on the stairs and he smells like it, then that's why he was arrested. JAMAR says, "That says that l'm arson'n?" Johnny tells JAMAR again that he should have got his wallet and walked away. JAMAR's mother is heard in the background, talking about a brick and a wallet. JAMAR says it doesn't make any sense, then says, ain't bust no windows. I ain't do none of that." JAMAR's mother gets back on the phone and asks JAMAR what he needs her to do. JAMAR asks his mom about talking to "her" and his mom replies that "she" left a message on the phone, saying JAMAR busted her window and tried to burn her house down. JAMAR's mother says, "When she threw you your wallet. you shoulda left. But what you need me to do?" JAMAR replies, need you to tell her to don't. to drop these charges because it's fake and it's faulty." JAMAR then says, "l should have put my hands on her if I was going to jail for something 1 didn't do." The phone says there's only a minute left and JAMAR tells his mom "Call that girl and tell her to stop B.S.ing." His mom says, "Alright, I'll try." On 03/20/2015 at 1749 hours JAMAR calls ?and a male answers the phone. JAMAR says "Man, this bitch just tried to set me on ?re, bro." The man asks who and JAMAR says, "This bitch over in St. Paul." The man says, "You goin back out there?" JAMAR says he went out there to get his ID, birth certificate and social security card. The man asks, "So what they do?" JAMAR says, "Man, Bro, i got lighter fluid all down my back, all down my coat Bro and I guess it's all up their steps. But she called them after I ran away and told them that I tried to set her house on fire. 80 when I get back, smell like lighter fluid and some more 000, i mean when comes to the corner and seen the police officers, I stopped them. I smell like lighter fluid. It's all down her steps and shit and i guess she try to say that i try to set her house on fire. But there ain't be no light or spark towards the flame towards or nuthin. It just lighter fluid sittn there and all on me. Now they try to get me with attempt arson and terroristic threats because she called police after she chased me away from her crib." The man says, "l'm bout to call Ki-Ki and shit, see what's going on. Prolly have to stop out there or sumthin. JAMAR says, "You don't even need to do all that bro because she on some police shit." JAMAR tells the man that TIFFANY's brother showed him a gun and told him to be respectful. The man replies, "Boy, l'm bout to go out there." JAMAR tells him that TIFFANY thinks he slept with her sister that lives with her. JAMAR then tells the man that his phone is at the store at Payne and Jenks? and says the man at the store will probably keep his phone for him. The man says, "Man, l'm bout to keep calln down there and check." JAMAR asks, "You want her number? Call Vonda. Get her number?Man, tell her to drop these charges man.? The male replies, "All right" and then the call is ended. I submitted a request for copies of the phone calls. PUBLIC NARRATIVE SP7FA94SC271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference ON Date and ?lime of Report 15056543 03/21/2015 10:33:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Monson, Megan Name ofiocation/business: Primary squad: Location of incidentSecondary reporting officer? ST MN 55101 Approver: District: Eastern Date 8. time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10255200 Arrest mac/e: Secondary offense: Police Of?cer Assaulted or injured: Police Of?cer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE Phone Interview with Victim TIFFANY LEVETTE TRUITT 713 Jenks Ave, upper, St. Paul, MN 55106 On 03/21/2015 at 1020 hours I, Officer Monson, assigned to the SPPD Family Violence Unit, made contact with the victim in this case, TIFFANY LEVETTE by phone at TIFFANY told me she had dated the suspect, JAMAR ONEAL CLARK (05/03/1991), for 2 1/2 months and had broken up with him 3-5 days before this incident, which was why he hadn't spent the night at her house on 03/19/2015. In the morning on 03/20/2015, JAMAR called and told TIFFANY he was coming to get his wallet, which she said he was ok with. She was asleep when he got there, but her children let him in and he started looking around. TIFFANY said JAMAR said to one of her children something about a man being in the house. He got his wallet and left. TIFFANY said a few minutes later he returned and was asking for other items. TIFFANY felt like he was making excuses to continue coming back to her house and she didn?t want let him back inside. She found some of his papers and slid them under the door, which made JAMAR angry. He started "cussing her out? saying that she was "fucking up his shit." TIFFANY said while he was "cussing her out? he was also talking about "jealousy stuff," accusing her of having a man in her house. She sad as he continued to yell, hejust kept getting madder. TIFFANY said he picked up a brick, which failed to break her bedroom window, so he threw another brick that broke the window. TIFFANY was in the bedroom and looked out the window, saying, "Really? You gona bust my window?" As she did this, JAMAR yelled, "I'm gone burn this bitch down!" TIFFANY said she went downstairs to confront JAMAR about breaking the window and when she opened her door she saw a puddle of lighter fluid at the bottom of her door. She also smelled the lighter fluid. TIFFANY said her friend was there, so he came downstairs and went outside. Her friend told her that he found JAMAR with a lighter and lighter fluid, saying he was "gone burn this bitch down." TIFFANY said her friend "caught JAMAR in the act so he couldn't burn it down." TIFFANY said when JAMAR saw her friend come down, JAMAR "turned diagonal in front of the SP7FA9450271F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/21/2015 10:33:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) house, heading into the neighbor's yard." JAMAR was "cussing TIFFANY out," saying he wasnt afraid and wasn't going anywhere as he ran away. TIFFANY called the police. TIFFANY said since JAMAR tried to burn the house down and was arrested, she has been contacted by JAMAR's family, who she has never met. She said she feared for her life because of JAMAR's actions and his family contacting her. TIFFANY said she believed JAMAR was contacting his family from jail to harass her and she believed he told them she had put lighter fluid on him. TIFFANY said none of them had her number, so she was sure he had given it to them. She said people were contacting her, telling her they knew where she lived. TIFFANY said she looked all 4 doors at her house, including the outer doors because she was frightened somebody was going to harm her or her children. She said people showed up at her house overnight, "pounding and banging all night" on her door. She said she told her case worker about this, but didn't call police. I asked TIFFANY the Blue Print Questions. She said she thought JAMAR would seriously injure or kill her or her children "now that he got these people calling me." She said he had only started threatening and intimidating her since she broke up with him and that he had "changed" since that point. She said he hadn't ever physically assaulted her, but his behavior had gotten worse during the time she was with him and since she had broken up with him. She said at first she didn't pay attention to his ?crazy talk" that she wasn't going to be with anybody else and that he wasn't scared to punch her eyeball out because he had punched his previous girlfriend's eyeball out. She said the time she was most frightened by him was ?these last couple weeks" but she had 2 never been injured by him. She said he had threatened to "beat her ass" if she called the police. She had never seen him around animals. He didn't own a gun that she knew of and he hadn't threatened her with a weapon, but he hadonce shown her an "old Smith and Wesson that looked like a old cap gun." They had never lived together. He was working at Waste Management in North Minneapolis, possibly at 40th and Fremont. She said he also worked at the corner store at Payne and Case, where he ran to after trying to burn the house down. When she broke up with him, he told her that she wouldn't be with anybody else and she took that as a threat to kill her. He had also threatened to kill himself, saying ?I'll just kill myselfl ['11 just kill myself!" when she broke up with him. She didn't know if he had run from the police or fought with them to avoid arrest, but he did walk back towards her house after trying to burn it down. He had been sexually aggressive with her. She had no other children besides the four that he was not the father of. He hadn't assaulted her while she was pregnant. She hadn't been pregnant during their relationship. He hadn't tried to strangle her. SP7FA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 3 ?f3 SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Date and Time of Report 15056543 03/21/2015 10:33:00 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) He smoked weed, but she didn't know if he drank. He was jealous. He tried to control her relationships by going through her phone and texting people. He also contacted other people in her phone to argue with them and sent friend requests to people from her account. She thought he followed her because she would go somewhere and then he would show up, like when he was at McDonald's on West Broadway in North Minneapolis and he just sat in a booth, staring at her. She hadn't considered suicide because of the way he treated her. audio recorded the interview and downloaded it to the Media Vault. 44. - Phone interview with victim PUBLIC NARRATIVE SP7FA945C271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN Dale and Time of Report 15056543 03/21/2015 07:50:00 Primary offense: ASSAU LTS-F LO TERRORISTIC THREATS) Primary Reporting Of?cer: Randall, David Name of location/business: Primary squad: Location of incident: 713 JENKS AV Apt Up Secondary reporting of?cer: ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver: District: Eastern Date 8. time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondaqr offense: Police Of?cerAsseulted or Injured: Police Officer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE I, Sergeant Randall - St. Paul Police Family Violence Unit, interviewed the suspect, CLARK, JAMAR ONEAL dob: 05/03/1991 (npa, no phone), on 03/21/2015 at 0737 hours. I conducted the interview at the Ramsey County Law Enforcement Center. I recorded the interview and later transferred the recording to the SPPD Media Vault. I completed the Miranda Rights Advisory form. The following is a synopsis of the interview: Clark did not want to speak to me so 1 ended the interview. PUBLIC NARRATIVE SP7FA9450271 F83 Saint Paul Police Department Page 1 0? SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT Complaint Number Reference CN 1 5056543 Primary offense: TERRORISTIC THREATS) Date and Time of Report 03/21/2015 07:19:00 Primary Reporting Of?cer: Macabe? David Name of location/business: Primary squad: Location of incidentSecondary reporting o?'r'cer: ST PAUL, MN 55101 Approver.? District: Eastern Date time of occurrence: 03/20/2015 09:00:00 to Site: 03/20/2015 10:55:00 Arrest made: Secondary offense: Police Officer Assaulted or Injured: Police Of?cer Assisted Suicide: Crime Scene Processed: NARRATIVE On 3/21/2015, at 0700 hrs., history of; CLARK, Jamar MNBCA (public CCH site). PUBLIC NARRATIVE (McCabe), assigned to the SPPD Family Violence Unit, reviewed the criminal 05/03/1991). His history shows no known QDVRO convictions in and SP7FA9450271F83 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/94 Report Date: 01/04/2016 Primary information . . Description: PD reports with Kiesha Steele as a Victim in 2015 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01/04/2016 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 01/04/2016 13:21 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 01/04/2016 13:29 Reporting LEO - Date__ . I Supervisor . - Date 7 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau ofCriminaI Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 2 On January 4th 2015, SA Phill received some PD reports involving Keisha Steele as a victim in two assaults. The reports were forwarded to SA Phil] from the FBI for inclusion into the case ?le. No ?nther actions taken or evidence acquired. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/95 Report Date: 01/05/2016 warning I - Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information - Description: Acquistion of Training Records from PD and Dennis Cherry Video Occurrence From: 01/04/2016 00:00 Occurrence To: 01/04/2016 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01/12/2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Agency Reference Numbers Agency Case/File Number Minnesota BCA Forensic Laboratory - St. Paul S15-14003 Minneapolis Police Department 15-423384 . On January 4th, 2015, SA Phill received 2 training discs and one CD of video from PD Commander Granger. The video was of Dennis Cherry speaking to a BLM event in and posted to Facebook. PD ripped a copy from Facebook. Evidence items 2015-648I95.1 adn 95.2 acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 STH STU Primary Information Address: 350 5TH ST, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Subjects Relationship ?lm BUSINESS LOCATION LOONSFOOT, Larry (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION PETERSON, Luke (Law Enforcement Of?cial) BUSINESS LOCATION PORRAS, Francisco (Law Enforcement Official) U3 BUSINESS LOCATION SAND, Brian (Law Enforcement Official) Male BUSINESS LOCATION SCHANY, Joe (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION Schmidt, Kristina (Law Enforcement Official) White, Female BUSINESS LOCATION SEIDL, Jeff (Law Enforcement Official) BUSINESS LOCATION ZIMMERMAN, Richard (Law Enforcement Official) Male EMPLOYER HOLTHUSEN, John (Analyst) Male RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE BOMB UNIT (BUSINESS) RELATED MINNEAPOLIS POLICE DEPT BOMB SQUAD (BUSINESS) RELATED BASS, DENNIS NMN (Person) 38 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED BROWN, FERNANDO NMN (Person) 50 yr. old, White, Male RELATED COOPER, RUDOLPH GORDON (Person) 48 yr. old, Black, Male u-u MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/95 Report Date: 01/05/2016 Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 5TH ST -._Continued Subjects - Continued Relationship ?lm ?ip RELATED COX, JOSHUA JOSEPH (Person) 34 yr. old, White, Male RELATED DODGE, CHARLES (Person) 63 yr. old RELATED FOSTER, ORVILLE REDALE (Person) 51 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED KOBERSTEIN, DAVID BRUCE (Person) 45 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MAXEY, SCOTT DOUGLAS (Person) 51 yr. old, White, Male RELATED MILLER, REGINALD ANTHONY (Person) 55 yr. old, Black, Male RELATED Rowen, P. MNU (Person) RELATED WILLIAMS, HAKIM JAMAL (Person) 42 yr. old, Black, Male Telephones E-Addresses Relationship Number/E?Address INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION - ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS INSTALLATION ADDRESS . I 0 0:1 #1 #1 - Ringgenb?erg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name ?g EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwafze, Dustin, Timothy Primary Information Exempt From DisclosureMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/95 Report Date: 01/05/2016 Subject #2 Schwarzepeustin- Timothy Continued Subject Name: Primary Information Continued Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: a Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name ?g 13?5 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject SUBJECT #3 .- Clark-,_ Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ELEM: plum?her My ism 9m FBI ID 717111FD1 N0 OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota N0 Property CD Containing the. Training?Records for-Ofcs Ringgenbergand? schwarze Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing the Training Records fo Ofcs Ringgenberg and Schwarze . . . . . - . . . . . . . . . MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/95 Report Date: 01/05/2016 Property #1 - CD Containing the Training Record?s?fo Ofcs Ringgenberg and Schwarze - Continued Primary Information - Continued Quantity: 2 Control Number: 2015-648I95.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ DISposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 01I05I2016 00:00 Property_#2v? CD containing 'Vidego?f Dennis Cherry Speech Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Video of Dennis Cherry Speech Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I95.2 UCRDamaged: N0 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 01/05/2016 00:00 Officers LEO Moore, Jane C. SGT (Minneapolis Police Dept) Villella, Twila (Sgt. I Minneapolis Police Department) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 10:31 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 01l12i2016 14:20 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO . I Date SuperviSor A Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on "thefollowi?ng page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 4 of 5 On Monday, January 4th 2016, Special Agent (SA) Phill received 3 discs of evidence from Minneapolis Police Commander Granger. The ?rst two CDs contained the complete training ?les pertaining to Of?cers Ringgenberg and Schwarze. Commander Granger also provided SA Phill with a CD containing a speech made by Dennis Cherry at a public Black Lives Matter event in Minneapolis in November. The speech was posted to the BLM Facebook page where Minneapolis Police Intelligence recorded it from the public site. SA Phill entered the training discs into ACISS as evidence item and the Cherry speech on CD was labeled item 95.2. Commander Granger also provided Minneapolis Police supplements 88-91 under their case number for the November 15th 2015 of?cer involved shooting of Jamar Clark. STATE OF MINNESOTA PS-G-OOSD (Rev. 12/02) :thnESOtd DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHEHSION 141.30 MARYLAND AVE. EAST. 33'1"= PAUL, MINNESOTA 55306 Bureau of Crirrina? Apprehansion . Bureau r50, LaboramF?TIB" Exil'de?cr?o' EVIDENCE RECEIPT I Lab Namewo" :erscn From Whom Property is Obtainedr Purpose For Winch Obzained tern Hem Item 09aLu: c442; 1/42/16 1.3) {2f 7? I DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES x. Mp 4?3; 05 7/09 mg I26 (/2255 are .2. . . . I 8 swam[1,64% 7 55??sz 14M .4 5? - r~ l-I/ 4/ - id - RECEIVED AND HOLD stir-OR 1.15512? Date/Time ?77 Siorage Site h?mu - CHAIN OF CUSTODY i Item I 7 E. Nu Date Rehnqulshed By Hecewed Signature 7 3 Signature M4 m" i u. raw" Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/96 Report Date: 01/05/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: PD Reports 89-91 Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 01/05/2016 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information. i Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 01/05/2016 12:36 Phili, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/05/2016 12:42 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO . a Date Supervisor. . . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/2612016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Mills-423384 Page 1 of 2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 89 Author: 000015 - Joseph Adams Date Printed: Jan 4. 2016 Suppiement of J.Adams #000015 on 12/17/2015 11:48 Technical Report of Appie iPhone (Lab#: 2015-351 Sergeant J. Adams 154123384 12-17?201 5 CASE SUMMARY: On December 14, 2015 the Minneapolis Digital Forensics Lab received a work request from Sergeant Twila Villella to examine a celi phone. The speci?c stipulation of the request was to retrieve or document specific text messages and contacts list information stored on the phone. The examiner began the examination process on Monday. December 14. 2015. LOCATION OF EXAMINATION: Minneapolis Police Crime Lab 350 5th Street South, Room 102 Minneapolis, MN 55415 EVIDENCE ASSESSMENT: 1. Documentation was retrieved from the Minneapolis Police Departments records management system and reviewed. Digital Forensic Lab employees took custody of the evidence item. Legal authority was established by owner consent Specifically for the examination of the evidence item[s] in a laboratory setting. The evidence media The resulting images were added to the case ?le. Upon completion of the examination the original evidence was rleturned to the owner. An evidence transfer form and a search authorization form was completed and added to 9 case ?le. GENERAL PROCEDURES: 1. The Minneapolis Police Digital Forensics Unit strives to provide service in a timely manner. Due to the complexity and the required attention to detail it may take up to 24 hours to complete a standard cell phone examination. Often the owner of the phone is unable to relinquish the evidence long enough for a full examination to be completed. in situations like this the Digital Forensics Lab will perform a limited examination referred to as a. "Technical Report". The case agent and owner will be advised of the differences between this methodology and a standard examination. 2. Details about the evidence media such as the make, model, and serial number were entered in the forensic laboratory management database. Each evidence item is given a unique number in the database software. The assigned media numbers and corresponding information are included in this report and can be viewed below: DIGITAL MEDIA Apple Cellular Phone 2. Mo 'iPhone 5s A1 33) b. 81% c. iMEl: 01 5 06084957 11?41?2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - EMF-15423384 Page Number: f. Lab#: 2015?351-1 TOOLS AND ANALYSIS: 1. The examiner used a laboratory computer to complete the analysis and report. Ail forensic software and equipment used during this examination is licensed to or authorized for use by the examiner and/or the Minneapolis Police Department. Various hardware and software solutibns were used to protect the integrity of the data contained on the original media. A search of the evidence itemIs] was completed with emphases placed on areas listed below: Analysis Software a. Fernico ZRTZ (version 2.0.93.0) Areas of Focus a. Contacts b. Text Message (SMS) CONCLUSIONS: Based on the information revealed by the forensic examination. as well as the examiners experience and training, the following ?ndings have been reported: 1. Due to the speci?city and time sensitive nature of the request the examiner had to use the Fernico ZRTZ software and a Canon Rebel T3 digital camera to catalog one contacts list entry and two text message entries stored on the evidence item (Lab# 201 5-351-1). The examiner also used the Fernico ZRTZ device to document the generai information about the phone. The examiner recorded the display screen of the evidence item while manually navigating the menu system of the phone to the desired location. The Fernico software was utilized to correlate the resulting images into a report. The report was added to the case examination DVD and can be found under the titie. "Fernico ZRT2 Report". It should be mentioned that Sargent requested the documentation of the contact information related to the contact. Green?. There were four phone numbers listed under that contact. Sergeant Vilielia requested that oniy two of the numbers be documented. There other two undocumented numbers were phone numbers belonging to personal phones. The examiners role is to extract or document the information contained on the evidence in a consistent reiiable manner. Question related to context and pertinence should be directed to the investigator that requested the examination. Any questions regarding the above procedures or additional information can be provided by the examiner upon request. One copy of the case examination DVD was created and given to Sergeant Villelia. A second copy of the case examination was created and given to Director Johnson. A third copy of the case examination DVD was created and preperty inventoried in the Minneapolis Police Property Room. Sergeant Joseph Adams Digital Forensic investigations Minneapoiis Crime Lab 612-673-2120 ~rSupplement report for case Print 10: oosccsesozae} .minneapolis.mn. 1/41/2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - EMF-15423384 Page 1 of2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number: 90 Author: 000015 - Joseph Adams Date Printed: Jan 4, 2016 Supplement of J.Adams #000015 on 12/17/2015 11:59 Technical Report oprple iPhone (Lab#: 201533512) Sergeant J. Adams 15-423384 124 7-2015 CASE SUMMARY: On December 14, 2015 the Minneapolis Digital Forensics Lab received a work request from Sergeant Jane Moore to examine a cell phone. The speci?c stipulation oi the request was to retrieve or document speci?c text messages stored on the phone. The examiner began the examination process on Monday. December 14, 2015. LOCATION OF EXAMINATION: Minneapolis Police Crime Lab 350 5th Street South. Room 102 Minneapolis, MN 55415 EVIDENCE ASSESSMENT: 1. Documentation was retrieved from the Minneapolis Police Departments records management system and reviewed. Digital Forensic Lab employees took custody of the evidence item. Legal authority was established by owner consent speci?cally for the examination of the evidence item[s] in a laboratory setting. The evidence media was-photographed and entered into the Forensic Computer Laboratory Case Management System The resulting images were added to the case file. Upon completion of the examination the original evidence was returned to the owner. An evidence transfer form and a search authorization form was completed and added to thecase ?le. GENERAL PROCEDURES: 1. The Minneapolis Police Digital Forensics Unit strives to provide service in a timely manner. Due to the complexity and the required attention to detail it may take up to 24 hours to complete a standard cell phone examination. Often the owner of the phone is unable to relinquish the evidence long enough for a full examination to be completed. in situations like this the Digital Forensics Lab will perform a limited examination referred to as a, ?Technical Report". The case agent and owner will be advised of the differences between this methodology and a standard examination. 2. Details about the evidence media such as the make. model, and seriai number were entered in the forensic laboratory management database. Each evidence item is given a unique number in the database software. The assigned media nUmbers and corresponding information are included in this report and can be viewed below: DIGITAL MEDIA EXAMINED: Apple - Cellular Phone a. Model: iPhone 5 (A1428) b. SIN c. IME. . d. FCC ID: 5.8 -?40'l 599A 87-A1 1/4/2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement Page 2 of 2 e. Number: f. Lab#: 2015-351-2 FORENSIC TOOLS AND ANALYSIS: 1. The examiner used a laboratory computer to complete the analysis and report. All forensic software and equipment used during this examination is licensed to or authorized for use by the examiner and/or the Minneapolis Poiice Department. Various hardware and software solutions were used to protect the integrity of the data contained on the originat media. A search of the evidence itemls] was compietad with emphases placed on areas listed below: Analysis Software a. Femico ZRTZ (version 2.0.93.0) Areas of Focus a. Contacts b. Text Message (8M8) CONCLUSIONS: Based on the information revealed by the forensic examination, as well as the examiners experience and training. the foilowing ?ndings have been reported: 1. Due to the specificity and time sensitive nature of the request the examiner had to use the Fernico ZRT2 software and a Canon Rebel T3 digital camera to cataiog onetext message entry stored on the evidence item (Lab# The examiner also used the Fernico ZRTZ device to document the general information about system of the phone to the desired location. The Fernico software was utilized to correlate the resulting images into a report. The report was added to the case examination DVD and can be found under the title. "Fernico ZRT2 Sergeant Joseph Adams Digitat Forensic investigations Minneapolis Crime Lab 612-67321 Supptement report for case Print it): 87~Al 11412016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - NIP-15423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CON: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 91 Author: 003636 Date Printed: Jan 4, 2015 Christopher Karakostas SUpplement of C.Karakostas #003636 on 12/17/2015 15:51 Statement of Sgt. Karakostas #3635 on 12/1711 5-RE photographs On 11115115. when 1 want to HCMC and swabed Jamar Clarke hands I also attemtped to take photographs of his hands. I used my department issued phone and took several photogrpahs. After returing to HQ 1 fall that Crime Lab should reposnd to HCMC and take better pictures of Clarke hands. Sgt. More later met the Crime Lab at HCMC. A DVD of the will be property inventoriecl. Sgt. Karakostas Homicide Unit End of Supplement report for case HAP-15423384. Print ID: 48-41110-8532- 73 114/201 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/97 Report Date: 01/21/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01l21/2016 Approved By: Lab Report #13, Trace Analysis Re. Clark's Clothing Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Rec'Ord Status Information . Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 01/21/2016 16:34 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 01/21/2016 16:36 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LED 1 . - Date Supervisor . . I . . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratmy St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 17?: (651)282-6555 FAX: 793-290] AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To; BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill Report No. AFETY SIS-14003 13 REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Trace 01/2 0/201 6 Laboratory Number: Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Trace Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packagigg Description/Source 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded vest - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t? Red t?shirt - Jamar Oneal Clark shirt 12D One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Red plaid Hanes boxes - Jamar Oneal Clark underwear 12E One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark jeans 12F One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as black socks - Jamar Oneal Clark socks 12G One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark pair of shoes 22 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 ?ngernail clippings 24 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 ?ngernail clippings 24B One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, ?ngernail clippings Agency Item 24B-1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as trace evidence from ?ngernail Page 1 of 3 ?ngernail clippings Laboratory No. 815?14003 Report No. 13 Results of Laboratory Examination: The known clothing in Items 12A (black jacket), 12B (black sweatshirt), 12C (red t-shirt) and 12B (jeans) from Jamar Oneal Clark were compared to a single blue cotton ?ber ?om previously examined Item 24B-1. The ?bers from the known clothing in Items 12A, 12B and 12C were different in color and/or type to the unknown blue cotton ?ber in Item 24B-1 and therefore can be eliminated as being a possible source of this ?ber The Item 12E jeans contained 6 denim patches. Fibers from all of these patches as well as the jeans were compared to the unknown blue cotton ?ber in Item 24B-l. The ?bers from the jeans and ?ve of the patches were different in color, type and/ or visible spectra (MSP) to the unknown ?ber in Item 24B- 1 and therefore can be eliminated as being a possible source of this ?ber (ELIMINATION). One patch contained an assortment of blue cotton ?bers among other ?bers. Most of these ?bers were different than the unknown ?ber however one ?ber was inconclusive in visible spectra (MSP). Due to the variability within the known sample and the inconclusive MSP results, no conclusion could be reached regarding an association or elimination between the Item 12E jean patch and the unknown blue cotton ?ber in Item 24B-1 (1N CONCLUSIVE). Items 12D, 12F and 12G were not analyzed. No other comparisons were completed on the unknown ?bers removed ?'om the Item 22 and Item 24 ?ngemail clippings from Jamar Oneal Clark to his own clothing in Item 12. Interpretation: The following descriptions are meant to provide context to the opinions reached in this report. Every type of conclusion may not be applicable in every case or for every material type. Type 1 Association: Identi?cation An association in which items share individual characteristics and/or physically ?t together that demonstrate the items were once from the same source. Type 2 Association: Highly likely An association in which items correspond in all measured physical properties, chemical composition and/or microsc0pic characteristics and share distinctive characteristic(s) that would not be expected to be found in the population of this evidence type. The distinctive characteristics were not suf?cient for a Type 1 Association. Type 3 Association: Could have An association in which items correspond in all measured physical properties, chemical composition and/or microscopic characteristics and could have originated from the same source. Because it is possible for another sample to be indistinguishable ?om the submitted evidence, an individual source cannot be determined. Type 4 Association: Cannot eliminate An association in which items correspond in some but possibly not all measured physical properties, chemical composition and/or microscopic characteristics and cannot be eliminated as coming from the same source. This type of evidence may be commonly encountered in the environment, may have limited comparative value and/or there may be factor(s) limiting the comparison. Page 2 of 3 Laboratory No. Report No. 13 Inconclusive: No conclusion could be reached regarding an association between the items. Elimination: Items exhibit dissimilarities in one or more of the following: physical properties, chemical composition or microscopic characteristics and, therefore, conclusively did not originate from the same source. Non-Association: Items exhibit dissimilarities but certain details or features are not suf?cient for an Elimination. KEY for instrument acronyms: MSP Microspectrophotomehy I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. MGM Susan T. Gross Forensic Science Supervisor Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/98 Report Date: 01/27/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01/28/2016 Approved By: Lab Report #14, Blood Tests to Follow Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information, Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/28/201617:13 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/28/2016 17:15 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO a Date 7 Supervisor . Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2I26I2016 Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of1 ll MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFET Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St- Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793?2900 (651)282?6555 FAX: (651) 793-290] AN ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 01/28/2016 Laboratory Number: SIS-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul SectiOn Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Report No. SIS-14003 14 Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packaging Description/Source 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded vest Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t? Red t-shirt - Jamar Oneal Clark shirt 12E One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark jeans 12G One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark pair of shoes 12G1 a left shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 12G2 a right shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Results of Laboratory Examination: Presumptive testing indicated the presence of blood on sixteen areas of Item 12A, twelve areas of Item 12B, three areas of Item 12C, ?ve areas of Item 12E, two areas of Item 12G1 and one area of Item 12G2 of which the following samples were collected as Items 12C-2, 12C-3, 12E-3, 12E-4, 12E-5, 12G1-2, and 12G2-l. One additional sample was collected from Item 12E as Item 1213?2. DNA examinations will be performed on selected items and Blood Stain Pattern Analysis examinations will be performed on Items 12A, 12B, 12C, 12E, 12G1 and 12G2- Ifyou have not received a report within a week of the date of this report, or if further examinations are not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory N0. Report No. 14 I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. [gnaw Jason A. Simser, Forensic Scientist 3 Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Portions of pertinent evidence items have been removed and are being stored at the BCA laboratory. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - I Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/99 Report Date: 01/29/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 01/30/2016 Approved By: Lab Report #15, DNA found on Clark's Clothing Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/30/201611:26 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 01/30/201612:14 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor. . a Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 TTY: (651)282-6555 FAX: 793?290] AN ASCLD/LAB?Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. Attention: SA Mike Phil] REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 01/28/2016 Laboratory Number: 815-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Report No. AFETY 15 Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Kin Type and Packagigg Description/Source 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an Handcuffs with original packaging item of evidence 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t? Red t-shirt - Jamar Oneal Clark shirt 12E One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark Jeans 12G One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark pair of shoes 12G1 a left shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 12G2 a right shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection kit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a e?irey Steven Sworski, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 bloodstain Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on blood previously indicated on samples (11-4, 12C-3, 1213-3, 12E-4, 12G1-1, 1261?2 and collected from Items 11, 12B, 12C, 12E, 12G1 and 12G2. DNA Page 1 of 4 Laboratory No. Report No. 15 pro?ling was also performed on an additional sample (Item 12E-2) collected from 12B and previously performed on Items 15, 16, 17, 18 and 21. The DNA results are as follows: Item 11-4, Blood indicated on handcuffs 0 Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski or Chad Michael Conner 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Blood indicated on black hood sweatshirt, inside right pocket 0 Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major mixture of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being connibutors to the major mixture Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.99997% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 12C-2, Blood indicated on red t-shirt, front middle 0 Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, ef?ey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the mixture Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded ?om being a possible contributor to the mixture It is estimated that 99.9999990% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 12C-3, Blood indicated on red t?shirt, front right shoulder Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Jeans, front left knee Item 12E-3, Blood indicated on jeans, front right knee Item 12G1-2, Blood indicated on left shoe, top right side 0 Single source DNA pro?les, indicated as female, matches the major DNA pro?le ??om Item 12C-3 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jef??ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark Item 12E-4, Blood indicated on jeans, front right pocket Item 12E-5, Blood indicated on jeans, front left pocket Page 2 of 4 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 15 0 Mixtures of three or more individuals 0 Major mixtures of two or more individuals 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the major mixture Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to the major mixture It is estimated that 99.999995% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors - Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 12G1-1, Blood indicated on left shoe, right side midsole 0 Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches the major DNA pro?le from Item 1203 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, ef??ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Blood indicated on right shoe, left side near laces Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches the major DNA pro?le from Item 12C-3 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Insufficient DNA was obtained ?om Item 11-2 to perform DNA pro?ling. Further comparisons can be made to these DNA pro?les if known samples from pertinent individuals are submitted to the BCA Laboratory. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. 72mm Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist loci tested using includes some or all of the following: D881179, D2181 1, D73820, D133317, D168539, D281338, D19S433, VWA, TPOX, 1318351, D53818, FGA, and Amelogenin- Disposition of Evidence: Lab will hold all evidence until exams completed- Page 3 of 4 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 15 Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 4 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/100 Report Date: 02/02/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information . Description: Release of Elks Club DVR and HD to FBI per HCAO Occurrence From: 0210212016 00:00 Occurrence To: 02/02/2016 00:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02/03/2016 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 1 Metro Regional Office 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On February 2nd 2016, SA Phill released the Elks Club DVR and removed hard drive to the FBI. This was per Mike Freeman, the Hennepin County Attorney. No new evidence acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred - 1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: BCA Subject #1 Ringge?hberg, mark Douglas j. Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name BE EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Of?cial Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Male -- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/100 Report Date: 02/02/2016 Subject #23 SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy - Continued Primary Information - Continued Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship 9?3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #3 ARRESTED. clark, Jamar Oneal . Primary information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications 9 ?lls (3?0003! FBI ID . 717111FD1 N0 OID 232941 7 Minnesota NO State ID Minnesota NO Officers KANE, Kevin (Special Agent] FBI) Record Status Informatian . . - Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 02/02/2016 17:18 ?Last Update Operato? ?305 Met? Regime? Of?ce .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/100 Report Date: 02/02/2016 Record Status Information Continued: Last Update Date: 02/03/2016 07:47 Reporting LEO 7 a ,y?ipate supervisor: 7- Date a Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) l?Nagirativebeginsz en the trailer/gingjpag?h .p - MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of4 Per a request to the Commissioner of Public Safety made by Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman, Special Agent (SA) Phill made arrangements on February to release the Elks Club DVR and hard drive (HD) to the FBI. On February 2nd 2016, SA Kane visited the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) to take possession of the DVR and the removed HD. SA Kane signed a BCA evidence sheet and also provided an FBI receipt. An exact image of the ID as received by the BCA Digital Forensics Unit will remain at the BCA in a secure server for further examination if needed. The BCA and FBI receipts have been attached to this report. The item numbers signed over to the FBI were 7.1 and 7.1A. Ps-e-coeo (Ram 1202) STAIE OF MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST. ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau of Criminal Apprehensmn Bl 1,93. MD ?Labomgm. My? rm EVIDENCE RECEIPT . I Item QEEW Name of Paris-33 From Whom Property is Oblaaned Fd'pose: For Which Obtained No. No. my - DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES CERTIFY HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED I I. - -- .1 CHAIN OF CUSTODY $39. I Date I Rehnquis?weu By necewzh Ely sis?05' 1 (Rev 3-11?94) Page of UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION Receipt for Property .. . fr(date) item(s) listed below were: f? 1 Received From [3 Returned To Released To El . :1 1 383w (Name) Lg . -. l/ Mi (45% 15.7% AL (StreetAddress) ,f?m/f ?L(Cityfry/47 1 lut? fax/U a; '7?5/55, 1 . g" c' "a ?ver ?72? 92/; Waa girl, 1? 47'" . if,? fez-3U? I i . Recawed BY: Received From: I) (Signature) (Signature) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/101 Report Date: 02/04/2016 Primary Information . Description: DNA obtained from Rayann Hayes Occurrence From: 0210412016 14:45 Occurrence To: 0210412016 14:45 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Phill, Charles (13851MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 0212612016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (13261 MRO Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis A On February 4, 2016, SA Olson and SA Phill obtained a DNA swab from Rayann Hayes. Items 101.1 - 101.3 (DNA kit and two audio files) obtained by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1830 PENN AVE Primary Information Address: 1830 PENN AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Subject #1 g. MENTIONIN REPORT -_Clark, Jamar oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 0510311991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date Fictitious mm FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State ID - Minnesota NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (13851MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 0212612016 13:37 Page 1 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/101 Report Date: 02/04/2016 Subjectiiz - MENTION IN REPORT #2 - HAYES, RAYANN FRANCINE Primary Information Subject Name: HAYES, RAYANN FRANCINE Record Type: Person Bio: 41' yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Belem Mm FREQUENTS 1830 PENN AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States subject #3 #3 Leonard Levon Primary Information Subject Name: Horn, Leonard Levon Record Type: Person Bio: 48 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 1830 PENN AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Property #1 - Rayann F. Hayes Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: DNA Sample Collection Kit Description: Rayann F. Hayes Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Disposition: Submitted to Lab Collected Date/Time: 02/04/2016 14:45 Property #2 - Digitai-audio recording ofRayann Hayes recorded voicemail. . Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: Digital audio recording of Rayann Hayes recorded voicemail Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: Locker .- 1- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/101 Report Date: 02/04/2016 Property #2 - Digital audio recording of Rayann Hayes recorded voicemail - Continued .. Primary Information - Continued Collected Datefiime: 02/04/2016 00:00 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, Description: Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: Remote Bin: Locker Collected Datefl'ime: Preparty DISC, TAPE Rayann Hayes audio interview (5:52) Property Evidence 00:00 Officers LEO - Castilleja, Adam (1323 I SRO - Crime Scene I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Cory, Christian (Det. Homicide I Wichita Police Department) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02I04I2016 17:12 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 10:25 Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supervisor'? . - Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Narrative begins on the followianEDa'QeQ MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 5 On Thursday, February 04, 2016, at about 1445 hours, Olson and Phill located Rayann Hayes at 1830 Penn Avenue N, Minneapolis, MN. Agents from the MN BCA and FBI were unsuccessful locating her in previous weeks. Agent Olson and Phill sought out Hayes for the purpose of re~interviewing her, and to obtain a DNA sample for comparative purpose against the unknown DNA sample(s) from clothing items worn by Clark (see MN BCA lab report 15). In an effort to locate Hayes SA Olson prepared and executed a Tracking Order (see attached) directed to T?Mobile for telephone locates on a cellular telephone believed to be utilized by Hayes. This Order was executed by SA Olson with the assistance of SA Adam Castilleja. At about 1000 hours T-Mobile began sending location information for the cellular telephone. The information received from T?Mobile showed the telephone at or near the residence located at 1830 Penn Ave N, Minneapolis, MN. This address is consistent information SA Olson previous learned from Shamirra Finn (Hayes biological daughter). Finn told SA Olson she believed her mother was staying with an African American or Hispanic male known only to her as ?Rat? near the intersection of Golden Valley Rd and Penn Ave N. When Olson and Phill approached the home of 1830 Penn Ave N, a person later identified as Leonard Levon Horn approached. When asked he acknowledged Hayes was in his residence and agreed to get her. Olson and Phill waited outside for several minutes before Hayes came outside. Hayes said she was not hiding from the police, but that she was attempting to maintain a low pro?le due to several previous efforts by the media to locate her. SA Olson recorded the conversation between agents and Hayes. This digital recording was later entered into evidence for safekeeping and storage as item 101.3. The duration of this discussion was just over ?ve minutes. Hayes said she did not hear or see anything on November 15, 2015, pertaining to the shooting death of Clark. She said Clark did not assault her that morning, and indicated she broke her ankle because she was intoxicated and the injury was the result of her falling. She said she did not know police had been called to the scene, and that if they were it must have been after she was transported to the hospital. SA Olson requested a consensual DNA buccal swab from Hayes. It should be noted that SA Olson previously drafted a search warrant to obtain the DNA in the event she did not consent (see attached). Hayes consented to the sample and said if there was blood on Clarks clothing it was probably hers. SA Phill obtained the DNA sample from Hayes (item 101.1). Hayes agreed to stay in touch with SA Olson should law enforcement need to re-contact her. Olson and Phill returned immediately to SA Olson?s squad where SA Phill completed the requisite paperwork before sealing the DNA Collection Kit. Olson and Phill cleared from the scene and drove the sample directly to the BCA lab intake where the sample was submitted (lab item 28 see attached lab analysis request). SA Olson later transferred two digital audio recordings to CD for preservation and safekeeping. The recordings were labeled as items 101.2 (audio from outgoing voicemail on Rayann Hayes telephone received by SA Olson on February 2, 2016), and 101.3 (interview of Rayann Hayes from February 4, 2015). A copy of the transcript from the brief interview with Hayes on February 4, 2016, will be attached to this report upon completion. It should be noted that during the search for Hayes SA Olson called the Wichita Police Department and obtained a recent booking photograph of Hayes and potential contact information for her from their records (attached). End report. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION INVESTIGATIVE INTERVIEW BCA Case Number: 2015-648 Person(s) Interviewed: Rayann F. Hayes Date/Time of Interview: 02?04-2016/ 1445 Inaudible Interviewed By: SA Mike Phil], SA Chris Olson Reviewed Bleate: SA Olson 02?06?2016 Rayann Hayes: Then when we got, when the police came there, I wasn't even there. SA Mike Phill: Yeah, they were, they were moving you out? Rayann Hayes: Yeah. SA Mike Phill: Okay, and I think you told the police officer that the, uh, Minneapolis person, that you didn?t' see the shooting? Rayann Hayes: No, I wasn't, they wasthe hospital SA Mike Phill: Did you hear it? Rayann Hayes: Did I hear it? No, I was, when I got in the ambulance they shot me with something 'cause my ankle was broke SA Mike Phill: Mm hmm. Rayann Hayes: and so I didn't hear anything. They closed the door and I didn't hear anything. I was just, just hearing the people talk to me inside the van. SA Mike Phill: Yeah, that's pretty much what you told Minneapolis, I think. Rayann Hayes: Yeah, and I'm like, that's why I don't understand why they keep wanting me to tell them. I didn't see anything, you know, and they tryin' to SA Mike Phill: How's the ankle comin'? Rayann Hayes: But the news people are trying to make it seem like, uh, he, he, he didn't, he never beat me up. There was never no fight. I don't know who said it was domestic. There was none of that. SA Chris Olson: Well, what happened to your ankle? How did you break it? Rayann Hayes: We were at a birthday party and I had on some heels like this high - SA Chris Olson: Okay. Rayann Hayes: and I'm pulling away and twisted my own ankle. He was on the ground trying to help me. I don't know what everybody was talking about he was beating me up and, it, I was drunk, but we all were really. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Rayann Hayes: And I fell, like, Ijust got mad because everybody was making a big deal about it. Everybody's lying making up all these stories. I was just like, I'm just gonna, I know what I seen and what happened, so, you know, I don't know exactly what happened when I left. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Did you, did you see, uh CaseNumber.Date.Name Page 1 of 6 Rayann Hayes: My daughter's, my daughter's baby's father was, he seen the whole thing. He was standing right in the doonNay. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Did you actually see, uh, any kind of a struggle with the police? Rayann Hayes: No. SA Chris Olson: Between Rayann Hayes: The police weren't even there. I SA Chris Olson: Okay. Rayann Hayes: I didn't even know the police were there. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Rayann Hayes: When I was in the ambulance, I didn't even know the police, 'cause when they took me in the ambulance the police weren't even out there. SA Chris Olson: Okay, so just two paramedics helping you out? Rayann Hayes: Yeah. SA Chris Olson: They brought you out in a chair and you were laying down in the ambulance, right Rayann Hayes: Yeah. SA Chris Olson: in a gurney? Rayann Hayes: Yeah. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Uh, so the last thing we need to do is take some DNA from you, uh, if you'd be willing to Rayann Hayes: For what? SA Chris Olson: Well, we're doing, uh, lab tests SA Mike Phill: Jamar had some blood on him. SA Chris Olson: of Jamar's clothes. Rayann Hayes: It was probably mine. SA Chris Olson: Well, that's what we're trying to figure out. SA Mike Phill: got shot though, so that's what we're trying to figure Rayann Hayes: Oh, okay. SA Mike Phill: maybe, so that's the only thing we've got to do. Rayann Hayes: Oh, that's fine. SA Mike Phill: Just SA Chris Olson: Can we do that in the vestibule as opposed to out here, or don't you want us in the house? Rayann Hayes: Well, that's his house. I don't know. He's, he's an idiot, so. SA Chris Olson: All right. Rayann Hayes: But that's fine. SA Mike Phill: I understand, it's his house and Rayann Hayes: Yeah he has it's was his blood and part of it was mine, 'cause he was, you understand me? SA Mike Phill: You gotta respect that. CaseNumber.Date.Name Page 2 of 6 SA Chris Olson: Did you, did something happen, did you get stitches or something to your face, or did you get an injury to your face that night? Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: No, my lip was bleeding. When I fell, when fell my legs Okay. My lip was bleeding Okay. but I didn't get no stitches or nothing like that. Okay, well was he, uh, what was your relationship to Jamar? We're friends. Okay. He lived, his sister lived downstairs from my daughter. All right. So, according to, were you romantically involved with him or? No. Not so much? No. Okay. And that's anotherthing, like, they're saying he's my boyfriend, l'm SA Mike Phill: if you just open wide, l'm just gonna rub the inside of your cheek. Rayann Hayes: Oh, okay. SA Mike Phill: Okay? Thank you. Right side, now left side. It's SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: You ever have this done before? No. All right. It's weird. Quick and painless, right? Yeah. So, will you do me a favor? I gave you my business card. Will you just kinda stay in touch with me periodically Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: CaseNumber.Date.Name Yes. 'cause you're really important to this. i know you don't feel like you are, but, uh it's crazy. - do you have, like, an email or something we can Um talk to each other, or i don't know what you're comfortable doing, or texting or No, I can, I have a phone but I have no minutes on the phone. Okay. So, but do you have an email that you check every once in awhile? No. Okay, sojust your phone? How long have you had that number? Page 3 of 6 Rayann Hayes: Um, a few months maybe. SA Chris Olson: Okay, um SA Mike Phill: If we got you a phone with minutes just so you could keep in contact with Agent Olson, is that okay? Rayann Hayes: I mean, yeah, I will talk to you guys, I'm just, I didn?t want to talk to the news and all the news people they want me to, I'm, I don't want to do all that. SA Mike Phill: Okay. Rayann Hayes: 'Cause, you know, they're like SA Chris Olson: Yeah, I don't blame ya. Rayann Hayes: they're looking for someone else to blame besides the police. I'm like, they can't, you can't blame me for the police shooting him. SA Mike Phill: No, absolutely not. SA Chris Olson: No. Rayann Hayes: You know? SA Mike Phill: No. Rayann Hayes: Like his family and stuff, I don't, that's why I said I don't want to be involved. SA Chris Olson: Well, no, like I said, I, I appreciate you keeping a low profile. Right? Rayann Hayes: Yeah. SA Chris Olson: So Rayann Hayes: Um SA Chris Olson: Just, I just want to make sure that you're not avoiding us. Rayann Hayes: No, was avoiding everyone else. SA Chris Olson: Okay, all right, well that's smart. Rayann Hayes: 'Cause I didn?t want to, you know? SA Chris Olson: Now are you gonna be here awhile? Rayann Hayes: All that stuff was crazy. SA Chris Olson: Do you think you're gonna be hanging your hat here for awhile? Rayann Hayes: No. I'll probably, ljust come over here once in awhile. SA Chris Olson: Okay. SA Mike Phill: If we brought you a phone could we bring it here? Rayann Hayes: Um SA Mike Phill: You could have a phone with minutes just so we, we can contact you? Rayann Hayes: I don't know? SA Mike Phill: your daughter's, here, where do you want it? Rayann Hayes: Um, I've really been out in Brooklyn Park with my cousin, so, I mean, but that's far, it's like Orchard, (SO?something and Orchard. I don't know the whole address. SA Chris Olson: Okay. SA Mike Phill: Okay. CaseNumber.Date.Name Page 4 of 6 Rayann Hayes: But, I mean, if you would, if you could drop it off at my daughter's I could get it from her. SA Chris Olson: Uh, is that, uh Rayann Hayes: And I know, i can't even, she can bring it to me because I don't even go down there. SA Mike Phill: You don't over there anymore Rayann Hayes: No. SA Mike Phill: that I SA Chris Olson: So you Rayann Hayes: They still, her family still lives downstairs and, like, they're harassing my daughter every single day. SA Chris Olson: And that's, what?s your daughter's name? Rayann Hayes: Shamira. SA Chris Olson: Sharmira Fein? Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Oh, Finn?? Rayann Hayes: Finn, yeah. SA Chris Olson: Okay. Do you stay in touch with her? Rayann Hayes: Well, I talked to her on the phone. She told me you guys were looking for me, but she didn't say you guys, she said the news people, and I'm, like, l'm not talking to no news people. SA Chris Olson: Okay. I just talked to her about a week ago and, uh, she said, uh, she doesn?t talk to you that much Rayann Hayes: No. I talked to her, like, two days ago. SA Chris Olson: Okay. SA Mike Phill: We're good. Rayann Hayes: Something like that. SA Chris Olson: All right? SA Mike Phill: We're good. SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: Yeah, i talked to her, like, two days ago. SA Chris Olson: Well, so hang onto my card and Rayann Hayes: Uh huh. SA Chris Olson: ?just kind of keep me, uh, let's turn into friends. Let's talk like once a week if that's cool? Rayann Hayes: Okay, yeah. SA Chris Olson: I'm not a bad guy. Rayann Hayes: Okay. SA Chris Olson: Um, and then if you need something, uh, you need to reach out to me. Rayann Hayes: Okay. SA Chris Olson: Okay? CaseNumber.Date.Name Page 5 of 6 Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: Okay. SA Mike Phill: Thank you very much. Rayann Hayes: Okay, that's fine. All right. It was a pleasure meeting you. You understand I don't want to talk to no news people. SA Mike Phill: How long you gonna have that boot? It should be healed up soon, right? Rayann Hayes: No, my ankle is, like SA Mike Phill: It's not healing right? Rayann Hayes: Right. SA Mike Phill: Oh. Rayann Hayes: SA Chris Olson: Rayann Hayes: Okay. So I gotta wear it until it gets straight. All right, well, you wear it well. It looks good on ya. SpeakWrite Job Number: 16036-001 Custom Filename: 2015-6481011 Date: 02/05/2016 Billed Words: 1831 CaseNumber.Date.Name Page 6 of 6 STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN In Re Search Warrant for Saliva buccal swab for the DNA of Rayann Francine Hayes,-DOB- DISTRICT COURT FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT REQUEST TO SEAL SEARCH WARRANT PURSUANT TO RULE 33.04 The undersigned requests the search warrant for Saliva buccal swab for the DNA of Rayann Francine Hayes, sealed until such time as directed by the Judge. Dated: February 9, 2016 Respect?illy submitted, MICHAEL O. FREEMAN Hennepin County Attorney I My E. sw SY Assistant County A omey C2100 Government enter Minneapolis, Mn 55 Telephone: (612) 348?6552 (26104X) STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN In Re Search Warrant for Saliva buccal swab for the DNA of Rayann Francine Hayes, DOB STATE OF MINNESOTA ss. COUNTY or HENNEPIN) DISTRICT COURT FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST TO SEAL SEARCH WARRANT AMY E. SWEASY, being ?rst duly sworn states and deposes: 1. The records requested are relevant to an on?going investigation involving a police shooting and the death of a known individual identi?ed here as 10. Because the investigation is on-going, it is important that information contained in the af?davit and not yet public not be released. 2. An order directing that this warrant be sealed until such time as the court directs is needed to allow the investigation to continue unhampered. WK AMY Assistant County Att Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of lain?- 2016STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT In re Search Warrant for Saliva FINDING AND ORDER 33:33.32" F1252: ?f Ra FINDINGS The Court ?nds that reasonable grounds exist to believe that ?ling the search warrant for could severely hamper an on?going investigation. MB IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. The search warrant for Saliva buccal swab for the DNA of Rayann Francine Hayes, DOB ~shall not be ?led at this time. 2. The above-described documents shall remain un?led until further Order'of a judge of this court. Until such ?ling, the documents and materials ordered withheld from ?ling shall be retained by the Court or the Court?s designee, the court administrator. rt? ?ag 111% Dist?ngEugPSEPl-i KLEIN \w Dated: 6 .: Application - 1 STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT AND SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT SPECIAL AGENT CHRIS OLSON, BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION, being duly sworn upon oath, hereby makes application to this Court for a warrant to search the Person, hereinafter described. for the property and things hereinafter described. Affiant knows the contents of this application and supporting af?davit. and the statements herein are true of his/her own knowledge, save as to such as are herein stated on information and belief. and as to those, he/she believes them to be true. At?ant has good reason to believe, and does believe, that the following described property and things, to wit: Saliva buccal swab - DNA will be on the person, described as: Rayann Francine Hayes, dob- Iocated in the City of Minneapolis, County of Hennepin, and State of Minnesota. This affiant applies for issuance of a search warrant upon the following grounds: COPIES TO: COURT I PROSATTY - PEACE OFFICER BURE4 OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Application 2 The facts tending to establish the foregoing grounds for issuance of a search warrant are as follows: Your affiant, Christopher Olson, is a Special Agent with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA), and is a license police of?cer in the State of Minnesota. Your affiant has been continuously licensed since 1987, and more specifically has been assigned to criminal investigations since 1992. Your af?ant is currently assigned to the BCA Metro Homicide Unit with primary responsibilities including murders, suspicious deaths, of?cer involved shootings, child abductions, and conflict cases. Your affiant has received extensive training in areas related to violent crimes, property crimes, and ?nancial crimes. Your affiant has drafted and executed hundreds of search warrants in a furtherance of those investigations. Your affiant has learned the following facts and information and believes them to be true and correct. On November 15, 2015, your affiant responded to a request from the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) to assist with an investigation involving an of?cer involved shooting which resulted in the death of Jamar Oneal Clark, dob/05/OSI1 991. Your affiant learned during the course of the investigation that patrol officers from the MPD were initially called to assist Hennepin County paramedics as they attended to an assault victim. The assault victim was identified by responding paramedics as Rayann Francine Hayes, dob? Hayes had injuries to her head and a broken ankle, and was later transported to the North Memorial Hospital for treatment. Paramedics reportedly called for assistance because Clark was identified by Hayes as her assailant, and he was repeatedly attempting to gain access to the ambulance while they were treating her injuries. MPD uniformed officers arrived along with a Hennepin County Paramedic supervisor. Jamar Clark struggled with MPD officer's and was fatally shot outside the ambulance. Your affiant learned that MPD Sgt. Twyla Villella interviewed Hayes at North Memorial Hospital shortly after this event. During that interview Hayes told Sgt. Villella her home address was 1223 Morgan Ave N, Minneapolis, MN. Your af?ant has since learned Hayes no longer resides at that address, and there does not appear to by any forwarding address for her. On January 28, 2016, your af?ant learned from a BCA laboratory report that the clothing worn by Clark was tested for DNA. The lab results from this testing indicated that human blood was detected on multiple clothing items worn by Clark (black hood sweatshirt, red t?shirt, jeans, and shoes). Additionally, there were multiple contributors of the DNA that did not match the DNA profile of Clark. Major DNA from the jeans, red t-shirt, right and left shoe indicated as a female contributor. COPIES T0: COURT 0 0 PEACE OFFICER BUREA OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Application - 3 Your affiant, in conjunction with the FBI, has been looking to re-interview Hayes for several weeks in a furtherance of this investigation. The MN BCA laboratory is requesting a DNA sample from Hayes in an effort to determine whether her blood is on any of the clothing items worn by Clark. On January 29, 2016, your affiant and SSA William O'Donnell spoke with Shamirra Chevell Finn, dob? Finn is the biological daughter of Hayes. Finn indicated she too has been looking to contact her mother, but said she was not sure about her specific location. Finn told your affiant her mother had recently been staying at or near a new housing development on the southwest corner of Penn Ave and Golden Valley Road. She further indicated she believed Hayes was spending time with a black or Hispanic male known only to her as ?Rat?, and stated that he owned a German Shepard. On February 1, 2016, your affiant met with Aashley Hase, the building manager located at 2205 Golden Vailey Road, Minneapolis, MN. Your affiant provided a photograph of Hayes. Hase was not familiar with Hayes, and indicated that pets were not allowed in the building. Hayes is a material and vital witness in this investigation. SA Olson has heard from a variety of sources that Hayes may be in ?protective custody", but that information is not consistent with any information your affiant has learned from other peripheral law enforcement investigative agencies (Le. DOJ, FBI, or MPD). Once located, your af?ant hopes to obtain consent from Ms. Hayes for a sample of her saliva via a buccal swab for the purpose of DNA comparative exams. Your affiant has received, and continues to receive information from a variety of sources that Ms. Hayes is currently residing somewhere nearby the intersection of Penn Ave and Golden Valley Rd. Your affiant believes Ms. Hayes will eventuain be located in that area, and is requesting permission from the Court to compel Ms. Hayes to provide a DNA sample if she refuses to provide a consensual sample in a furtherance of this investigation. COPIES T0: COURT 0 TTY 0 PEACE OFFICER BUREA OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Application - 4 WHEREF ORE, Affiant requests a search warrant be issued, commanding SA Chris Olson, SA C. Michael Phill, peace of the State of Minnesota, and all other personnel under hislher direction and control between the hours of 7:00 am. and 8:00 pm. only to search the hereinbefore described Person, for the described property and things and to seize said property and things and keep said property and things in custody until the same be dealt with according to iaw. . I. - Affiant: Special Agent Chris Olson Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Subscribed and sworn to before me this I - iday of . mm.? 1 Judge of District Court Judge L. Quaintance 4th Judiciai District Court COPIES 0: COURT 0 PROSA 77? 0 PEACE OFFICER BUREAU OF APPREHENSION Warrant - I SEARCH WARRANT STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT TO: SA CHRIS OLSON, SA C. MICHAEL PHILL, (A) PEACE OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA. WHEREAS, SPECIAL AGENT CHRIS OLSON has this day on oath, made application to the said Court applying for issuance of a search warrant to search the foliowing described Person, Rayann Francine Hayes, dob/- located in the City of Minneapolis, County of Hennepin, STATE OF MINNESOTA for the following described property and things: Saliva buccal swab - DNA WHEREAS, the application and supporting af?davit of Special Agent Chris Olson was/were duly presented and read by the Court, and being fully advised in the premises. NOW, THEREFORE, the Court ?nds that probable cause exists for the issuance of a search warrant upon the following grounds: The Court further finds that probable cause exists to believe that the above-described property and things will be on the person, NOW, THEREFORE, YOU SA Chris Olson, SA C. Michael Phill THE PEACE AFORESAID, AND ALL OTHER PERSONNEL UNDER YOUR DIRECTION AND CONTROL ARE HEREBY COMMANDED BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 7:00 A.M. AND 8:00 PM. ONLY TO SEARCH THE DESCRIBED PERSON, FOR THE ABOVE-DESCRIBED PROPERTY AND THINGS, AND TO SEIZE SAID PROPERTY AND THINGS AND TO RETAIN THEM IN CUSTODY SUBJECT TO COURT ORDER AND ACCORDING TO LAW. BYT COURT: Dated: OF DISTRICT COURT COPIES TO: COURT I PROSATTY PEACE OFFICER RECEIPT, INVENTORY AND RETURN 3-1 STATE OF MINNESOTA, COUNTY OF Ji?c M4 8?6 - S): swim- COURT RECEIPT, INVENTORY AND RETURN 1, Chris Chan received the attached search warrant issued by the Honorable 52 ct AN on "i and have executed it as follows: Pursuant to said warrant, on l?K at o'clock I searched the (premises) motor hiole) (person) described in said warrantr and left a true and correct copy of said warrant (with) (in) (at) 57? Cc: I took into custody the property and things listed below: (attach and identify additional sheet if necessary) I: 3 Cl? I left a receipt for the property and things listed above with a c0py of the warrant. (Strike when apprOpriatez) None of the items set forth in the search warrant were found. I shall (r tain) or (deliver) custody of said property as directed by Court order. $79k! being ?rst duly sworn, upon oath, deposes and says that he has read the foregoing receipt, inVentory and return and the matters stated are true and correct, except as to such matters stated therein on information and belief, and as to them, he believes them to be true. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 4'5 u/ day of Mt Mae-M as ?if? A - 37/: xx,? Notary Public, Signature . My commission expires . PUBLIC - ?aws: My Consulss?on Exp'ses Jan. 31. 2020 ?rt-?w an new! MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Laboratory Number Forensic Science Laboratory - St. Paul a l430 Maryland Avenue East 315-14003 .. St. Paul, MN 55106 Agent.) Lam. Number TEL: 651493?2900 2015648 TTY: 651-242-6555 FAX: 651?793-2901 LABORATORY ANALYSIS REQUEST BCA St. Paul . Henne in [430 Maryland Avenue East COUNTY- St. Paul. MN 55l06 TELEPHONE: 651-793?1100 TYPE OF CASE: Am]: SA Mike Pm? Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death Report Distribution: BCA St. Paul - I Section Involved Estimated Due Date Nuclear DNA 6/3/20 [6 CIRCUMSTANCES AND PURPOSE 0? ANALYSIS: Comparison LS: Date Of Birth Tvpe Race Com..m_.e_nls Schwarze. Dustin Timothy Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Hayes, Rayann Francine Clark. Jamar Oneal 5-3009] Sworski, Ie??rey Steven Conner. Chad Michael ITEM DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE: Item In Container Packaging and 'I?vne Emmy; 28 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known DNA Rayann Francine Hayes sample collection kit Submitted By Received 13v a; 02/04/20 l6 15:44:13 SA Mike P?hill Carolle David Submission Date and Time Page I ofl STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN Application? 1 DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT 4 JUDICIAL DISTRICT IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION FOR AN ORDER AUTHORIZING THE INSTALLATION AND USE OF A PEN REGISTER, TRAP AND TRACE DEVICE, ELECTRONIC TRACKING DEVICE, GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM (GPS) TECHNOLOGY, USE OF PRECISION LOCATION TECHNOLOGY, AND DISCLOSURE OF SUBSCRIBER AND CELL SITE INFORMATION AND TRACKING WARRANT APPLICATION AND AFFIDAVIT AGENT CHRISTOPHER OLSON hereby applies to the Court for an Order and Tracking Warrant authorizing the installation and use of: a pen register, trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, electronic tracking device, and/ or cellular tower location and service information, including services such as Global Positioning System (GPS) technology, precision location related technologies, and/or a tracking warrant on telephone number - In support of this application, the applicant states the following: 1. Identity of Applicant and Agency: Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. ?3122 and Minn. Stat. Subd. the applicant, CHRISTOPHER OLSON is a licensed peace of?cer with the MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION (MN BCA) with responsibility for an ongoing criminal investigation, and therefore pursuant to 18 U.S.C., 2703 2703(c)(1)(B), 2703 2711 3117, 3122(a)(2), and and Minn. Stat.??626A.36 to Minn. Stat. ?626A.42?may apply for an Order and Tracking Warrant authorizing the installation and use of: a pen register, trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, electronic tracking device, and/or cellular tower location and service information, including services such as Global Positioning System (GPS) technology and/or precision location related technologies. The law enforcement agency conducting this investigation is the MN BCA. Application- 2 10 Federal Certi?cation: Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. ?3122(b)(2), the applicant certi?es that his agency is conducting a criminal investigation of JAMAR ONEAL CLARK, dob/05-03- 1991, and others as yet unknown, in connection with possible violations of state and federal law relative to MN SS 609.066, Authorized Use of Deadly Force by Peace Of?cers; and that it is believed the subjects of the investigation are using telephone numberwin furtherance of the subject offenses; and that the information likely to be obtained from the pen register, trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, is relevant to an ongoing criminal investigation being conducted by the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. 3. Pursuant to Minn. Stat. Subd. 2, your af?ant applies for a tracking warrant to obtain location information for an electronic device including information concerning the location of an electronic device that, in whole or in part, is generated or derived from or obtained by the operation of an electronic device, including location information for an electronic tracking device, and/or cellular towar location and service information, including services such as Global Positioning System (GPS) technology andfor precision location related technologies. 4. Statement of Probable Cause: The facts and circumstances relied upon by the applicant show there is reason to believe that probable cause exists that the person who possesses an electronic device is committing, has committed, or is about to commit a crime. Af?davit of Probable Cause: Your af?ant, Christopher Olson, is a Special Agent with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA), and is a license police of?ce in the State of Minnesota. Your af?ant has been continuously licensed since 1987, and more speci?cally has been assigned to criminal investigations since 1992. Your af?ant is currently assigned to the BCA Metro Homicide Unit with primary responsibilities including murders, suspicious deaths, of?cer involved shootings, child abductions, and con?ict cases. Your af?ant has received extensive training in areas related to violent crimes, property crimes, and ?nancial crimes. Your af?ant has drafted and executed hundreds of search warrants in a Application? 3 furtherance of those investigations. Your af?ant has learned the following facts and information and believes them to be true and correct. On November 15, 2015, your af?ant responded to a request from the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) to assist with an investigation involving an of?cer involved shooting which resulted in the death of Jamar Oneal Clark, dob/05/03/l 991. Your af?ant learned during the course of the investigation that patrol of?cers from the MPD were initially called to assist Hennepin County paramedics as they attended to an assault victim. The assault victim was identi?ed by responding paramedics as RayAnn Francine Hayes, dob/- Hayes had injuries to her head and a broken ankle, and was later transported to the Hennepin County Medical Center for treatment. Paramedics reportedly called for assistance because Clark was identi?ed by Hayes as her assailant, and he was repeatedly attempting to gain access to the ambulance while they were treating her injuries. MPD uniformed of?cers arrived along with a Hennepin County Paramedic supervisor. Jamar Clark struggled with MPD of?cer?s and was fatally shot outside the ambulance. Your af?ant learned that MPD Sgt. Twyla Villella interviewed Hayes at North Memorial Hospital shortly after this event. During that interview Hayes told Sgt. Villella her home address was 1223 Morgan Ave N, Minneapolis, MN. Your af?ant has since learned Hayes no longer resides at that address, and there does not appear to by any forwarding address for her. On January 28, 2016, your af?ant learned from a BCA laboratory report that the clothing worn by Clark was tested for DNA. The lab results from this testing indicated that human blood was detected on multiple clothing items worn by Clark (black hood sweatshirt, red t-shirt, jeans, and shoes). Additionally, there were multiple contributors of the DNA that did not match the DNA pro?le of Clark. Major DNA from the jeans, red t-shirt, right and left shoe indicated as a female contributor. Your af?ant, in conjunction with the FBI, has been looking to re?interview Hayes for several weeks in a furtherance of this investigation. The MN BCA laboratory is requesting a DNA sample from Hayes in an effort to determine whether her blood is on any of the clothing items worn by Clark. On January 29, 2016, your af?ant and SSA William O?Donnell spoke with Shamirra Chevell Finn, dob- Finn is the biological daughter of Hayes. Finn indicated she too has been looking to contact her mother, but said she was not sure about her speci?c location. Finn told your af?ant her mother had recently been staying at or near a new housing development on the southwest corner of Penn Ave and Golden Valley Road. She further indicated she believed Hayes was spending time with a black male known only to her as ?Rat?, and stated that he owned a German Shepard. Application~ 4 On February 1, 2016, your af?ant met with Aashley Hase, the building manager located at 2205 Golden Valley Road, Minneapolis, MN. Your affiant provided a photograph of Hayes. Hase was not familiar with Hayes, and indicated that pets were not allowed in the building. On February 2, 2016, your affiant received a telephone call from a source wishing to remain anonymous. The caller told your af? ant the cellular telephone for Hayes is Your af?ant called that number and determined it appeared to be a working number. Your afflant has not succeeded in contacting Hayes, but feels con?dent the telephone likely belongs to Hayes because a female voice on the outgoing voicemail message identi?es the voicemail recipient as ?RayAim Hayes.? Your af?ant believes the voice on the outgoing voicemail to be consistent with the audio statement of Hayes previously obtained by MPD Sgt. Villella. Your af?ant is requesting the Courts permissions to electronically locate the cellular telephone belonging to Hayes in a furtherance of this investigation. Hayes is a material and vital witness in this investigation. SA Olson has heard from a variety of sources that Hayes may be in ?protective custody?, but that information is not consistent with any information your af?ant has learned from other peripheral law enforcement investigative agencies DOJ, FBI, or MPD). Application- 5 WHEREFORE, the applicant respectfully requests that the Court issue the following Order and Tracking Warrant: 5. Request for Pen Register and Trap and Trace Device and Tracking Warrant: Your Af?ant requests that this order direct T-Mobile to provide data on all communications originating ?om or directed tc_including the following infomiatio?n and assistance requested during the authorized period of inception: A. B. Cell site activations and locations; Outgoing numbers dialed or pulsed; including PTT (Push-To?Talk) communications, and, if identi?ed, any post cut?through digits; Incoming numbers, if identi?ed, and any post cut-through digits; Call duration and call detail records in electronic format; Call detail or toll records for the seven (7) day period immediately preceding the date of this order. Current subscriber and billing information for mobile telephone numb er- ?and the Electronic Serial Number (ESN), Mobile Equipment Identity (MEID), International Mobile Equipment Identity (IMEI), International Mobile Subscriber Identity (IMSI) and Mobile Subscriber Identity (MSID) speci?c to Current T?Mobile subscriber information and, if requested, historical subscriber information and other telephone(s) associated with this account including billing information and records speci?c to the subscriber Information relating to unlisted, non-published telephone numbers dialed ?cm telephone number _and telephone numbers appearing on the caller identi?cation (Caller ID) function for telephone number? List of control channels/radio channels and their corresponding cell sites; Spreadsheets in electronic format (upon request) listing pertinent T-Mobile cell site locations; An engineering map, showing all cell-site tower locations, addresses, sector and orientations: (upon request); The physical address/location of all cellular towers in the speci?ed market; 10. Application- 6 M. That the telecommunications providers for these include any assistance or access necessary to facilitate the installation of pen register and/or trap and trace device to include switch based solutions or system: (upon request); and, N. Records and assistance requested in this order shall be provided to any officer or agent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. Your Affiant requests that this order and tracking warrant pertain to any telephone for which data from?is redirected to another communication device, call forwarding). Your Affiant requests the Court speci?cally authorize the use of Global Positioning (GPS) pertaining to hm be used to track the position and/or movement of the mobile phone for a period of sixty (60) days from the installation/activation of the electronic tracking device (GP phone technology). Request for Technical Assistance: Applicant further requests that the Order direct that T?Mobile ?lrnish information including cell site, cellular tower location and service information, and call detail or toll records, as well as any and all facilities and technical assistance necessary to unobtrusively accomplish the installation of the pen register and trap and trace device by T-Mobile with reasonable compensation to be paid by the applicant for reasonable expenses incurred by providing such facilities and assistance. Pursuant to Minn. Stat. 626A.42, Subd. 4, it is requested that notice of the tracking warrant not be provided to the target of the investigation for a period of ninety (90) days or within a reasonable time not later than ninety (90) days after the tracking warrant is unsealed if the tracking warrant is sealed by the court. Pursuant to the statute, the issuing judge shall cause to be served on the persons named in warrant and application an inventory which shall include notice of: the fact of the issuance of the warrant or application, the date of the issuance and the period of authorized, approved, or disapproved collection of location information, or the denial of the application;; and the fact that during the period location information was or was not collected. Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. ?2705(b), the applicant requests the court order the applicable providers, their agents and employees not to notify any other persons of the existence of Application- 7 the requested court order because there is reason to believe that noti?cation existence of the requested court order will result ?mew (5) otherwise seriously jeopardizing an investigation or unduly delaying a trail based on the nature and scope of the investigation as outlined in section 8(a) described above. WHEREFORE, it is respectfully requested that the Court grant an Order and Tracking Warrant for a period of sixty (60) days, from the date of this Order (1) authorizing the installation and use of: a pen register, trap and trace device, including caller identi?cation, electronic tracking device, and/or cellular tower location and service infonnatioh, including services such as Global Positioning System (GPS) technology and/or precision location related technologies, (2) that probable cause exists for a tracking warrant to be issued, (3) directing T-Mobile to forthwith furnish of?cers and agents of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension with all information, facilities and technical assistance necessary to accomplish the installation and use of the device(s) unobtrusively and with minimum interference to the service presently accorded persons whose dialing or pulses are the subj ect of the pen register, (4) that notice to the person(s) named in the tracking warrant shall be delayed for a period of ninety (90) days or notice shall'be provided within a reasonable time period, but not more than ninety (90) days after the tracking warrant is unsealed. pursuant to Minn. Stat. Subd. 4. Christopher Bison Minnesota Bureau of Cri al Apprehension Subscribed and sworn to before me snag daydf-j (a Jud of District Court Jud L. Quaintance 4?31 Judicial Court Order?1 STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN DISTRICT 4 JUDICIAL DISTRICT IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE MINNESOTA BUREAU OF UNDER SEAL CRIMINAL APPREHENSION FOR AN ORDER AUTHORIZING THE FINDINGS, ORDER, AND INSTALLATION AND USE OF A PEN TRACKING WARRANT REGISTER, TRAP AND TRACE DEVICE, ELECTRONIC TRACKING DEVICE, GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM (GPS) TECHNOLOGY, USE OF PRECISION LOCATION TECHNOLOGY, AND DISCLOSURE OF SUBSCRIBER AND CELL SITE INFORMATION AND TRACKING WARRANT This matter having come before the Comt pursuant to an application by CHRISTOPHER OLSON under 18 U.S.C. 2703 3117, 3122, 3123 and and Minn. Stat. to 626A.42, authorizing the installation and use of a pen register and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, cellular tower location and service information, Global Positioning System (GPS) information (GPS), and tracking warrant for phone number(s) UPON REVIEW OF THE APPLICATION, THE COURT HEREBY FINDS THAT: 1. Federal Certi?cation: Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. 3122(b)(2), the Court ?nds that the applicant, SA CHRISTOPHER OLSON, MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL has certi?ed that his agency is conducting a criminal investigation of JAMAR CLARK, and others as yet unknown, in connection with possible violations of State and Federal laws relative to MN SS 609.066, Authorized Use of Deadly Force by Peace Of?cers; and that it is believed the subjects of the investigation are using telephone number in furtherance of the subject offenses; and that the information likely to be obtained from the pen register, electronic tracking, and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, cellular tower location and service Order?2 information and Global Positioning System (GP S) information is relevant to an ongoing criminal investigation being conducted by the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension and that probable cause exists that a crime has been, is being, or is about to be committed by the person in possession of the electronic device. Finding Supporting Issuance of Order: Pursuant to Minn. Stat. and Minn. Stat. Subd. 2, the Court ?nds based upon the information submitted by the applicant that there is reason to believe that the information likely to be obtained by the installation and use of the pen register, trap and trace device, including caller identi?cation and is relevant to an ongoing criminal investigation and probable cause exists that a crime has been, is or is about to be committed by a person in possession of an electronic device, and information related to an electronic tracking device, cellular tower location and service information, electronic device location information, and/or Global Positioning System Infonnation (GP S) is authorized pursuant to this tracking warrant. Finding of Delay in Notice: Pursuant to Minn. Stat. 626A.42, Subd. 4, the court ?nds that notice of the tracking warrant shall not be provided to the target of the investigation for a period of ninety (90) days or within a reasonable time, not later than ninety (90) days after the tracking warrant is unsealed if the tracking warrant is sealed by the court. WHEREFORE, based upon the forgoing, the Court issues the following: 1. ORDER AND TRACKING WARRANT Order Permitting Installation and Use: IT IS ORDERED, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. 2703 3122 (2), and 3123 and Minn. Stat. and 626A.37, that SA CHRISTOPHER OLSON, MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION may install and use a pen register to record numbers dialed or pulsed from telephone number-and a trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, be installed to register numbers dialed or pulsed to telephone number- ~and to record the date and time of such pulsing or records, and to record the length of time the telephone receiver in question is off hook for incoming or outgoing calls Order?3 for a period of sixty (60) days or the period necessary to achieve the objective of the authorization, whichever is less; and also that T?Mobile furnish any historical cell site, call detail and toll records still maintained by T?Mobile switches that were in use by the target number during the 48 hour period preceding T?Mobile activation of this order, and IT IS ORDERED, pursuant to Minn. Stat. that a tracking warrant is authorized to collect location information on an electronic device including, information concerning the location of an electronic device that in whole or in part, is generated or derived from or obtained by the Operation of an electronic device, including cellular tower location and service information, and an electronic tracking device and/or Global Positioning System (GP 8) information. Identity of Phone Listing: The person to whom telephone number?is listed is believed to be RayAnn Hayes; and Identity of Investigation Subject: The person(s) under investigation in this matter is RayAnn Hayes, and others as yet unknown; and Number and Physical Location: The phone number to which the pen register and trap and trace device is to be attached is? and based upon information submitted by the applicant the geographic limitation of the order is the Continental United States; and Statement of Offense: The offense(s) to which the information likely to be obtained by the pen register and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation and or cellular tower location and service information including Global Positioning System (GPS) information relates to violations of federal and state law relative to MN SS 609.066, Authorized Use of Deadly Force by Peace Of?cers; and Identity of Law Enforcement Of?cer: The law enforcement of?cer(s) responsible for installation and use of the pen register and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, cellular tower location and service information and Global Positioning 10. ll. Order-4 System (GPS) information is SA CHRISTOPHER OLSON of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension; and Time Period: The period during which the use of the pen register and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, cellular tower location and service information, and an electronic tracking device and/or Global Positioning System (GPS) information is authorized is sixty (60) days or the period necessary to achieve the objective of the authorization, whichever is less; and Furnishing Facilities: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. 2703 3122 (2), 3124 and Minn. Stat. Subd. 1, that T-Mobile shall forthwith furnish CHRISTOPHER OLSON an agent with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension with all information, facilities, and technical assistance necessary to accomplish the installation of a pen register and trap and trace device including caller identi?cation, cellular tower location and service information, electronic tracking device and/or Global Positioning System (GPS) information, unobtrusively with minimum interference to the services that are accorded person(s) whose telephone is to be the subject of the devices. This includes the existence of any and all custom calling, class, or ESS features including but not limited to Caller ID, voice mail, call forwarding and speed calling as well as automatic number identi?cation (ANI) that exist for telephone number Noti?cation of Changes In Service: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that as part of furnishing information, facilities and technical assistance, T?Mobile provide SA CHRISTOPHER OLSON an agent with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension forthwith all information regarding any changes in service relative to- during the authorized period of interception under this Order; and Order to Furnish Information: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that T?Mobile shall provide data on all communications originating from or directed to ?including the following information during the authorized period of interception: A. Cell site activations and locations; Order-5 B. Outgoing numbers dialed or pulsed, including PPT (Push-To?Talk) communications, and any post cut-through digits; C. Incoming numbers, if identi?ed, and any post cut-through digits; D. Call duration and call detail records in electronic format; E. Call detail or toll records for the seven (7) day period immediately preceding the date of this order; F. Current subscriber and billing information for mobile telephone number? ?nd the Electronic Serial Number (ESN), Mobile Equipment Identity (MEID), International Mobile Equipment Identity (IMEI), International Mobile Subscriber Identity (IMSI) and Mobile Subscriber Identity (MSID) speci?c to- G. Current T-Mobile subscriber information and, if requested, historical subscriber information and other telephone(s) associated with this account including billing information and records Speci?c to the subscriber of- H. Information relating to unlisted, non-published telephone numbers dialed from telephone number-and telephone numbers appearing on the caller identi?cation (Caller ID) function for telephone number? I. A list of control channels/radio channels and their corresponding cell sites; I. Spreadsheets in electronic format (upon request) listing pertinent T-Mobile cell site locations; K. An engineering map, showing all cell-site tower locations, addresses, sector and orientations (upon request); L. The physical address/location of all cellular towers in the speci?ed market; M, That the telecommunications providers for these include any assistance or access necessary to facilitate the installation of pen register and/or trap and trace device to include switch based solutions or system (upon request); N. Records and assistance requested in this order 'shall be provided to any officer of agent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension; and, 12. Request for Pen Register and Trap and Trace Device and Tracking Warrant: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that T-Mobile shall provide data on all communications originating from or directed taincluding the following information during the authorized period of interception: Order?6 A. Cell site activations and locations; PU Outgoing numbers dialed or pulsed, including PTT (Push?To?Talk) communications, and any post cut?through digits; C. Incoming numbers, if identi?ed, and any post cut-through digits; D. Call duration and call detail records in electronic format; E. Call detail or toll records for the seven (7) day period immediately preceding the date of this order; F. Current subscriber and billing information for mobile telephone numbe- ?and the Electronic Serial Number (ESN), Mobile Equipment Identity (MEID), International Mobile Equipment Identity (IMEI), International Mobile Subscriber Identity (IMSI) and Mobile Subscriber Identity (MSID) speci?c to G. Current T-Mobile subscriber information and, if requested, historical subscriber information and other telephone(s) associated with this account including billing information and records speci?c to the subscriber of H. Information relating to unlisted, non~published telephone numbers dialed from telephone numbewd telephone numbers appearing on the caller identi?cation (Caller ID) function for telephone number? 1. List of control channels/radio channels and their correSponding cell sites; I. Spreadsheets in electronic format (upon request) listing pertinent T-Mobile cell site locations; K. An engineering map, showing all cell-site tower locations, addresses, sector and orientations; (upon request); L. The physical address/location of all cellular towers in the speci?ed market; M. That the telecommunications providers for these include any assistance or access necessary to facilitate the installation of pen register and/or trap and trace device to include switch based solutions or system: (upon request); N. Records and assistance requested in this order shall be provided to any of?cer or agent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. 13. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this order pertain to any telephone for which data from _is redirected to another communication device, i.e. call forwarding, including any change in telephone number assigned to or associated with a telephone Order-7 bearing or containing the same Electronic Serial Number (ESN), Mobile Equipment Identity (MEID), International Mobile Subscriber Identi?cation (IMSI) and Subscriber Identity Module (SIM) card, listed to the same subscriber and/or telephone account associated with telephone number" 14. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED pursuant to 18 U.S.C. 2703, 3122, 3124 and Minn. Stat. and Minn. Stat. that T-Mobile shall furnish SA CHRISTOPHER OLSON or other Agents with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension forthwith all infonnation, facilities, and technical assistance necessary to accomplish the installation of a pen register trap trace, cell site locations, electronic tracking device and/or Global Positioning System (GPS) information unobtrusively and with minimum interference to the services presently accorded persons whose telephone dialing?s and pulses are the subject of the pen register; and 15. Compensation for Canier: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that T-Mobile be reasonably compensated by the applicant for reasonable expenses incurred in providing technical assistance; and 16. Delay in Notice: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED pursuant to Minn. Stat. 626A.42, Subd. 4, the court finds that notice of the tracking warrant shall not be provided to the target of the investigation for a period of 90 days or within a reasonable time, not later than ninety (90) days after the tracking warrant is unsealed if the tracking warrant is sealed by the court. 0 Date Hudge of District Court ?tanee L. Guam Ju?r?gh Judicial District Court Olson, Christopher (DPS) From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Begin forwarded message: O'Donnell, William (DPS) Wednesday, February 03, 2016 4:04 PM Phill, Charles Olson, Christopher (DPS) Fwd: Question image002.png From: "Rugel, Jeff" Date: February 3, 2016 at 1:49:07 PM CST To: "Kramer, Kristopher Cc: Subject: RE: Question on the hi0 below, we have figured out that the house or: Penn ust south of with the i sheeherd is 1830 Penn Ave ii. That looks like a duh'ex with the following residents: rug. Lower: Leonard Levon Horn- Upoer: Eugene Charles Snow-iden? Leonard Levon Horn has a shepherd registered to him. Not sure I can tie the merits Rat to him, but there cannot be that many guys at eon GVR with shepherds. he and the upstairs neighbor are suspected dope deaiers with a history of guns. From: Kramer, Kristopher J. Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2016 10:33 AM To: Rugel, Jeff Subject: RE: Question There is a house on the eastside of Perm about three houses south ofwaily?s that has shepherds. From: Rugel, Jeff Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2016 10:22 AM To: Kramer, Kristopher J. Cc: Subject: FW: Question Oops lthirl *hat the Di.? Si. lwoulc to see if there might be a From: Rugel, Jeff i bet the BCA aiready knows about her. i did not know her name uhti guy connected to her address that couid he yann Hayes mentioned below is the female victim that led to the November 1 i started checking A 2: Diet Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2016 10:13 AM To: Kramer, Kristopher J. Police - SICM Intel Subject: RE: Question CCN 14-430436 talks about "Rat" in the area of GVR Penn but does not iD him. It does identify a friend of "Rat" as Rayann Francine Hayes-/ 1223 Morgan Ave N. Maybe she knows his real name or where he lives. From: Kramer, Kristopher J. Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2016 9:58 AM To: Police - SICM Intel Subject: FW: Question Can you see if you can come up with anything for him? From: Keegel, Holly Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2016 9:54 AM To: Police - Bernardson, Thomas W. Subject: FW: Question Ring a bell for anyone? Sergeant Holly Keegel Violent Criminal Apprehension Team (VCAT) 350 South 5th Street, Room 108 Minneapolis, MN 55415 Desk - 612?673-3060 Cell 612-290-9109 From: O'Donnell, William (DPS) Sent: Monday, February 01, 2016 3:19 PM To: Keegel, Holly Subject: Question Sgt. Keegel, am looking for a black male who walks a German Shepherd dog around the area of Penn and Golden Valley Rd, friends call him ?Rat?, long shot, but wondering if you have any databases that might search on that name? Let me know if you have any questions. BILL SENIOR SPECIAL AGENT SOUTHERN REGIONAL OFFICE SERVICE UNIT El rear?s BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. E., ST. PAUL MN, 55106 OFFICE: 651-793-7087 I CELL: 651-334-1604 FAX: 651-793?7001 FOLLOW BCA Olson, Christopher (DPS) From: Sent: Thursday, February 04, 2016 1:56 PM To: Cc: Olson, Christopher Castilleja, Adam (DPS) Subject: Location Alert Location of_at 2/4/2016 11:55:49 AM Pacific Standard Time Result Lat: 44.998788 Lon: -93.308945 Uncertainty: 4m Google Maps 0? 469 aw saxJax a: 3 23rd Ave MCNair Ave 2'lst Ave l?th Ave anv uepuaqs 24th Ave QB we anv uaano Ave am "asan 14th Ave 2? r1, ?3 ?Ibo 43213:41, $3 .513 Minneapolis {j Schools 0 Golden Valley Rd Golden Valley 16th Ave N15th Ave North Community High School l4b1 Page 1 of 1 erg/1!. am; mo L: 2/4/2016 Driving Record Page 1 4 Driving Record for LEONARD LEVON HORN- Identi?cation Card Information Purpose for displaying photo Prosecute crime Reason (cad/case/incident physical ID, etc.) 201 5-648 02/23/2013 Name State ID Card Number LEONARD LEVON HORN Date of Birth Class 1 Gender Enhanced lD Male No Height . CDL 5'11" A Weight Issued Date 160 11/21/2014 Color Expires Brown 04/ 01 [201 7 Address Driving Status 1830 PENN AVE REVOKED MINNEAPOLIS 55411 Medical Alert No Corrective Lenses No Endorsements NONE :l/dvsquery.x. state .mn.us/DL/Detail/W03 326813 5406 2/4/201 6 Olson, Christopher (DPS) From: Cory, Christian Sent: Monday, February 01, 2016 3:43 PM To: Olson, Christopher (DPS) Subject: Hayes Attachments: Hayes, EJustice.pdf; Ge?mageCAYQUGTijg; GetImageCAX7MFUijg Olson, Here are the photos you requested, all taken 07/24/13 at Sedgwick County Jail. I also included a printout from our system that has all of the personal information we have on her. We have had a bunch of contact with her outside of her four arrests. If you need to look at those cases further or need a detailed list of associates just give me a ring. Good luck Christian, 316-651-7072 Detective Christian Cory Homicide Section Investigations Division Wichita Police Department 455 N. Main Wichita, KS 67202 (316) 268-4659 (316) 268-4206 fax Person Detail Report 3 Date of Info: Date: 02/01/2015 15:34 Page 1 0f 2 Person Id: 102237902 1 2 2 3 7 Last Name First Name mags SSN HAYES RAYANN Sex: Female Race: Black Alias(es) Date of Info: 07/25/2013 Date of Info: 03/31/2013 Physical Descriptions Hgt: 500, Wgt: 105, SMALL, BROWN Eyes, BROWN Hair, DARK Skin Date of Info: 07/24/2013 Hgt: 500, Wgt: 120, SMALL, BROWN Eyes, BLACK Hair, BLACK Skin Date of Info: 10/22/2012 Hgt: 501, Wgt: 115, SMALL, BROWN Eyes, BLACK Hair, BLACK Skin Date of Info: 02/07/2011 Hgt: 505, Wgt: 125, BROWN Eyes, BLACK Hair Date of Info: 11/ 13/2006 Address 1336 MINNESOTA WICHITA, KS 67214 Date of Info: 01/22/2014 Details Occupied: 09/27/2011 - Notify Date: Of?cial: History Date of Info Occupied Notify Date Of?cial 07/07/2013 09/27/2011 10/22/2012 09/27/2011 - 07/25/2011 09/27/2011 07/25/2011 09/27/2011 02/07/201 1 09/27/2011 - 02/07/201 1 09/27/2011 - 07/19/2010 09/27/2011 - 1514 CATALINA WICHITA, KS 67216 Date of Info: 07/13/2008 Details Occupied: No dates available- Notify Date: Official: History Date of Info Occupied Notify Date Of?cial 07/13/2008 No dates available. 07/27/2007 No dates available. 02/27/2007 No dates available. 01/25/2007 No dates available. 01/22/2007 No dates available. 602 MADISON WICHITA, KS 67214 Date of Info: 03/28/2007 Details Occupied: No dates available. Notify Date: Of?cial: History Date of Info Occugied Notify Date Of?cial 03/28/2007 No dates available. 09/29/2006 No dates available. Person Detail Report Date: 02/01/2016 15:34 Page 2 of 2 Address 1514 CATALINA ST WICHITA, KS 67216 11/13/2006 Details Occupied: No dates available. Notify Date: Of?cial: Source: History Date of Info Occupied Notify Date Of?cial Source 11/18/2006 No dates available. 11/13/2006 No dates available. Phone Numbers Residence: - Date of Info: 07/24/2013 Cellular: Date of Info: 07/07/2013 Residence: Date of Info: 03/31/2013 Cellular: Date of Info: 12/12/2012 Residence: - Date of Info: 10/22/2012 Residence: Date of Info: 09/27/2011 Residence: Date of Info: 03/04/2011 Residence: Date of Info: 04/02/2010 Residence: Date of Info: 07/13/2008 Residence: Date of Info: 07/28/2007 Residence: Date of Info: 03/28/2007 Residence: Date of Info: 01/24/2007 Residence: Date 01/22/2007 Residence: Date of Info: 1 1/ 13/2006 Residence: Date of Info: 09/29/2006 Employment UNEMPLOYED, Date of Info: 10/22/2012 KANSEL, 334 TOPEKA WICHITA, KS 67202 Business: (316) 263 9620 Date of Date of Info: 09/27/2011 info:02/28/2003 UNEMPLOYED, Date of Info: 02/07/201 1 UNEMPLOYED, Date of Info: 04/02/2010 INTERIM HOME HEALTH CARE, 333 BROADWAY KS 67202 Business: (316) 265 - Date of Info: 07/28/2007 4295 Date of inf0105/07/2006 UNEMPLOYED, Date of Info: 02/27/2007 S, 3361 ARKANSAS AVE WICHITA, KS 67204 Business: (316) 973 - 3200 Date of Date of Info: 01/24/2007 info:01/21/2005 Misc ID Federal ID Nlunber: 782551DB5 Date of Info: 07/29/2013 Mug Number: 206042 Date of Info: 09/28/2011 Scars, Marks, Tattoos Tattoo, Located: Neck, Description: ARIES Date of Info: 09/27/2011 Tattoo, Located: Chest, Description: Date of Info: 02/07/2011 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/102 Report Date: 02/05/2016 Primary Information Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approx/ed Date: 02/05/2016 Approved By: Description: Evidence transfer (It. 101.2 - 101.3) OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) RecOrd Status lnfOrmati'on Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 02/05/2016 12:55 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 02/05/2016 12:58 OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO . . a Date Supervisor 74.. . Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of2 On Friday, February 05, 2016, SA Olson transferred items 101.2 and 101.3 (audio to SA Phill. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Page 1 of 1 Offense Number: 2015-648/101 Case Agent: OLSON, Chris Item Quantity Description 2 1.00 Digital audio recording of Rayann Hayes recorded voicemail 1.00 Rayann Hayes audio interview (5:52) State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION I hearby certify that have received the above listed property 2? Signature m? Date Received :1 he 20/6 Name rles (l?innesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OwnerlFor Owner Address CityIState Released By Olspn, Christopher (Minnesot Telephone Veri?ed By lac; I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/103 Report Date: 02/08/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 0210812016 Approved By: Lab Report #16, Blood Spatter Analysis Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/08/2016 14:21 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02108I2016 14:27 Reporting-LEO I . Data supervisor . Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 TTY: (651) 282-6555 FAX: (651) 793?2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul Lab No. SIS-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Report No. 16 St. Paul, MN 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIJNATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Blood Stain Pattern Analysis 02/04/2016 Laboratory Number: 1 5- 14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Blood Stain Pattern Analysis Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Jamar Oneal Clark Description of Submitted Evidence: It_tm_1_ Type and Packagigg Description/Source 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an Handcuffs with original packaging item of evidence 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded vest - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark hooded sweatshirt 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t? Red t?shirt - Jamar Oneal Clark shirt 12E One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark Jeans 12G One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark pair of shoes 12Gl a left shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 12G2 a right shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 25 One plastic container with evidence classi?ed as an item MSP Video and Photos DVD 2015-648 BCA of evidence DNA results described in this report were previously detailed in Report 15, dated 1/28/2016. Results of Laboratory Examination: The following observations and conclusions are based upon the information provided to date. if more information becomes available, I reserve the right to amend this report. Reported bloodstains were either previously presumptively tested for the presence of blood (Report 5, dated 11/25/2015 and 14, dated 1/28/2016) or were visually consistent with blood. Orientations of ?left? and ?right for clothing descriptions are in reference to the clothes being worn. Page 1 of 5 Laboratory No. Report No. 16 Observations: Item 11 Handcuffs Bloodstains were located on the side of the handcuffs opposite the keyholes and on a portion of one of the hinges. 0 Ten spatter stains all less than 1 mm in diameter were located on the handcuffs. The only bloodstain not located on the side opposite of the keyholes was a spatter stain located on a recessing portion of one hinge. A number of indeterminate type bloodstains, where a particular bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) classi?cation could not be determined, were also located on the non-keyhole side of the handcuffs as well. 0 No bloodstains were observed on any other surfaces of the handcuffs. Item 12A Black hooded vest - Transfer stains and indeterminate type bloodstains were visually observed on various areas of the outside of the body portion and throughout the interior of this piece of clothing. 0 An approximately 0.2 cm diameter bloodstain mixed with apparent tissue and/ or ?uid was present on the inside back of the vest. Item 12B Black hooded sweatshirt Bloodstains were observed on various areas of both the inside and outside of the black hooded sweatshirt that were determined to be of indeterminate type. 0 Apparent tissue and/or ?uid mixed with blood was present on the inside back of the sweatshirt. 0 Complete BPA exams were not performed on the inside of this item. Item 12C Red t-shirt The majority of bloodstains on the t-shirt were located on the front and shoulders that included spatter stains, transfer stains and indeterminate type stains. 0 Approximately 20 spatter stains ranging in size from less than 1 up to 4 mm in diameter were located on the right shoulder. On the stomach area of the t?shirt was a mixture of transfer stains and indeterminate type bloodstains. 0 Located on the left shoulder were mixtures of transfer stains and indeterminate type stains on the exterior surface and transfer stains, spatter stains, and indeterminate type stains on the interior of the t-shirt. 0 The only bloodstains observed on the back of the t?shirt were two areas of transfer stains and one area of indeterminate type. Item 12E Jeans 0 The front of the jeans contained a mixture of predominately transfer stains and spatter stains. 0 Transfer stains were observed on the pocket, thigh, knee and shin areas of the right leg and the thigh and knee areas of the left leg. 0 The spatter stains all less than 1 mm in diameter were located on the thigh and knee areas of the left leg (28 stains) and the thigh, knee and shin areas of the right leg (9 stains). 0 Two indeterminate type bloodstain were located on the ?ont of the jeans, one on each leg. 0 Two areas of transfer stains were the only bloodstains observed on the back of the jeans. Page 2 of 5 Laboratory No. 315-14003 Report No. 16 Item 12Gl Left shoe 0 Approximately 55 spatter stains the majority of which were less than 1 mm with the largest being 1.5 4 mm in size were located on the right side of the ankle, tongue, laces, lace strap, and top front of the shoe. 0 A number of these spatter stains either had directionalities or placements on the shoe that supported their angles of impact as coming from above the shoe. 0 Two areas of indeterminate type bloodstains were located on the right side of this shoe. II No bloodstains were observed on the back or bottom sides of the left shoe. Item 12G2 Right shoe 0 A total of 7 spatter stains with the largest being 0.8 1.5 mm in size were observed on the front top and left sides as well as on the laces of the right shoe. 0 One of these stains had an angle of impact that was supported as coming from above the shoe. 0 No bloodstains were observed on the right, back and bottom sides of the right shoe. Item 25 - Minneapolis P.D. CST Video and Photos 1611 Plymouth Ave N. It should be noted that Bloodstain Pattern Analysis (BPA) interpretations from photographs are often limited compared to working with the actual crime scene and/0r evidence. 0 The handcuffs were observed on the boulevard, bloodstained side up, and surrounded by a number of other objects including apparent Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) items containing bloodstains. 0 Located partially covering the handcuffs were a leaf and an Avant Gauze sponge wrapper with spatter stains (10?s, less than or equal to 1 mm in size). 0 Blood pools and other indeterminate type bloodstains were located on the ground between the handcuffs and the sidewalk. - Transfer, saturation and additional indeterminate type bloodstains were located on gauze near the sidewalk. - Observed between the densest area of bloodstaining on the ground and the handcuffs was a plastic bag containing a number of bloodstains of indeterminate type primarily located on the side of the bag facing in the general direction of the blood pools on the ground. Conclusions: 1. The handcuffs were in proximity to a spatter producing event or events, one of which involved Jamar Oneal Clark?s blood (Item 11-4, Report #15) that was limited to one side of the handcuffs. Possible mechanisms producing the spatter include impact (including backspatter), expiration, cast-off, and satellite stains ?om dripped, projected or splashed blood. 2. The t-shirt, jeans, and both shoes were in proximity to a spatter producing event or events which involved the blood of an unidentified individual, indicated to be female (Items 12C-3, lZGl-l, and Report The source(s) of this unidenti?ed individual?s blood was located generally in front of and to the top of the shoes of Jamar Oneal Clark?s clothing when this event(s) took place. Possible mechanisms producing the spatter include but are not limited to impact, expiration, cast-off and satellite stains ?om dripped, projected or splashed blood. 3. The presence of a transfer stain containing the blood of the same unidenti?ed individual as mentioned above (Item 12E-3, report #15) is consistent with an object containing their blood coming in contact with the jeans. Page 3 of 5 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 16 4. The presence of bloodstains throughout both the black hooded vest and black hooded sweatshirt, some of which had apparent tissue and/or ?uid, is consistent with these items being on or located near to Jamar Oneal Clark while he was bleeding. However because the majority of the bloodstains on both of these items were either indeterminate or not readily visual (detected by chemical means only) the EPA interpretations and conclusions were limited. 5. The presence of medical equipment with bloodstains demonstrated that medical intervention could be responsible for some of the bloodstains observed on the handcuffs and Jamar Oneal Clark?s clothing. Terminology: Angle of Impact - The acute angle (alpha), relative to the plane of a target, at which a blood drop strikes the target. Backspatter Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting from blood drops that traveled in the opposite direction of the external force applied; associated with an entrance wound created by a projectile. Bloodstain - A deposit of blood on a surface. Cast-off Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting from blood drops released from an object due to its motion. Cessation Cast-off Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting ?om blood drops released from an object due to its rapid deceleration. Directionality - The characteristic of a bloodstain that indicates the direction blood was moving at the time of deposition. Drip Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting from a liquid that dripped into another liquid, at least one of which was blood. Expiration Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting ?om blood forced by air?ow out of the nose, mouth, or a wound. Impact Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting ?om an object striking liquid blood. Parent Stain - A bloodstain from which a satellite stain originated. Pool - A bloodstain resulting ?om an accumulation of liquid blood on a surface- Projected Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting from the ejection of a volume of blood under pressure. Satellite Stain - A smaller bloodstain that originated during the formation of the parent stain as a result of blood impacting a surface. Spatter Stain - A bloodstain resulting from a blood drop dispersed through the air due to an external force applied to a source of liquid blood. Splash Pattern - A bloodstain pattern resulting ?om a volume of liquid blood that falls or spills onto a. surface. Target - A surface onto which blood has been deposited. Transfer Stain A bloodstain resulting from contact between a blood-bearing surface and another surface. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations- gnaw Jason A. Sirnser, Forensic Scientist 3 Page 4 of 5 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 16 Disposition of Evidence: Please pick up your evidence. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 5 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab ResultAttachment 2015-648/104 Report Date: 02/08/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02/08/2016 Approved By: Lab Report #17, DNA match to Rayann Hayes Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Statuslnformation Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/08/2016 14:28 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/08/2016 14:34 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 1 3:37 Page 1 of ?l AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793?2900 TTY: (651) 282?6555 FAX: (651) 793?290] AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. 515-14003 ReportNo. 17 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 02/06/2016 Laboratory Number: 1 5?14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Rayann Francine Hayes; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Tme and Packaomg' Description/Source 3 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a ?rom EMT truck swabbing from Item 3D One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a ?om ?ont passenger side door handle ?om swabbing from Item EMT truck 5 One cardboard b0x containing evidence classi?ed as a Smith Wesson, magazine with ammunition, ?rearm and one cartridge. 5A a ?rearm Smith Wesson 5B a magazine Smith Wesson 9mm magazine 7 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as a SIG Sauer, magazine with ammunition, and one ?rearm cartridge. 7A a ?rearm SIG Sauer 9mm Model P226 7B a magazine SIG Sauer P226 9mm 9 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Duty Belt from Mark Douglas Ringgenberg an item of evidence 9?1 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a holster swabbing ?om Item 9-2 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a mace holder swabbing from Item 9-3 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a ?ont le? handcu?? holder with cover swabbing from Item 9-4 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a back left handcuff holder swabbing from Item 11 One cardboard box containing evidence classi?ed as an Handcuffs with original packaging item of evidence 11-3 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a handcuffs swabbing from Item 11-4 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a handcu??s swabbing from Item 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Black hooded sweatshirt - Jamar Oneal Clark Page 1 of 8 hooded sweatshirt 12C 12E 12G 12G1 12G2 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t- shirt One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jeans One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a pair of shoes 3 le? shoe a right shoe One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing from Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing ?'om Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a swabbing from Item One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a bloodstain One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as ?ngernail clippings One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known DNA sample collection kit Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on Item 28. Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 17 Red t-shiit - Jamar Oneal Clark Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark Jamar Oneal Clark left and right hand le? hand Jamar Oneal Clark right hand Jamar Oneal Clark blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #4 single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #6 single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item single ?ngernail (left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item Rayann Francine Hayes DNA pro?ling was previously performed on Items 3D, 9-1, 9?2, 9-3, 9-4, 14A, 14B and 21. DNA pro?ling was previously performed on samples through 5A-5, 5B-1, though and 7B-1) collected from Items 5A, 5B, 7A and 7B, a sample (12E-2) collected ??om 12E, samples 22D-2, 24D-2 and 24E-2) collected ?'om Items 22A, 22D, 22E, 24D and 24B. DNA pro?ling was also previously performed on blood indicated on samples (11-3 and 11-4) collected ??om Item 11, samples (1213-2, 12C-2, l2C-3, 12E-3, 12E-4, 12E-5, 12G1-1, 1261-2, 12G2-1) collected ?'om Items Page 2 of 8 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 17 12B, 12C, 12E, 12Gl and 12G2, samples (22B-2, 22C-2, 24B-2 and 24C-2) collected ??om Items ZZB, 22C, 24A, 24B and 24C. The DNA results are as follows: Item 3D, Front passenger door handle, EMT truck 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor Item 9-1, Holster on duty belt 0 Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 9-2, Mace holder on duty belt - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes - Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 9-3, ?Front left? handcu? holder, with cover, on duty belt 0 Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported - Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor Item 9-4, ?Back left? handcuff holder on duty belt 0 Mixture of four or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 11-3, Blood indicated on handcuffs 0 Single source male DNA pro?le, as previously reported 0 Does not match Rayann Francine Hayes Item 14A, Left hand of Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 14B, Right hand of Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 Five of the 12 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 96.2% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 5A-1, Grips of Smith Wesson 0 Mixture of ?ve or more individuals, as previously reported Page 3 of 8 Laboratory No. SIS-14003 Report No. 17 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor I Item 5A-2, Trigger of Smith Wesson Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Magazine, slide and safety releases of Smith Wesson Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 5A-4, Sides of slide and back of Smith Wesson Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item SA-S, Muzzle and lens of ?ashlight of Smith Wesson Mixture of four or more individuals, as previously reported Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor to minor types Item Bottom of magazine from Smith Wesson 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 7A-1, Grips of SIG Sauer Mixture of four or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item Trigger of SIG Sauer - Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported - Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item Back sides of slide of SIG Sauer - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes - Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor to minor types Item 7A-4, Back top and hammer of SIG Sauer Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor to minor types Item Magazine, slide and safety releases of SIG Sauer - Single source male DNA pro?le, as previously reported Page 4 of 8 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 17 I 0 Does not match Rayann Francine Hayes I Item Flashlight of SIG Sauer Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded ?om being a contributor to minor types Item 7B-1, Bottom of magazine from SIG Sauer Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported - Rayann Francine Hayes is excluded from being a contributor Item 22A-2, Fingernail, right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 The minor types in the DNA mixture are not suitable for comparisons because no loci meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations Item Fingernail, right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 It is estimated that 99.97% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 24A-2, Fingernail, left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 Seven of the 15 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 98.4% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 24B-2, Fingernail, left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Maj or male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types 0 Four of the 10 loci suitable for comparisons meet the BCA criteria for conducting statistical calculations; it is estimated that 94.6% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 22C-2, Fingernail, right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark Item 22E-2, Fingernail, right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark Item 24E-2, Fingernail, left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Page 5 of 8 Laboratory No. 515-14003 Report No. 17 Item 22D-2, Fingernail, right hand, Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major mixture of two or more individuals 0 A mixture of DNA from Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as the source of the DNA in the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.9992% of the general populations can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 24C-2, Fingernail, left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major mixture of two or more individuals 0 A mixture of DNA ?om Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as the source of the DNA in the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.999995% of the general populations can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 24D-2, Fingernail, left hand, Jamar Oneal Clark - Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported - Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as from being a possible contributor - It is estimated that 99.995% of the general populations can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 11-4, Blood indicated on handcuffs 0 Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major male DNA pro?le does not match Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Due to insufficient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Blood indicated on black hooded sweatshirt, inside right pocket 0 Mixture of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Maj or mixture of two or more individuals 0 A mixture of DNA ?om Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as the source of the DNA in the major mixture 0 It is estimated that 99.99997% of the general populations can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 12C-2, Blood indicated on red t-shirt, front middle - Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 A mixture of DNA from Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as the source of the DNA 0 It is estimated that 99.9999990% of the general population can be excluded from being contributors Item 12C-3, Blood indicated on red t-shirt, front right shoulder - Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported Page 6 of 8 Laboratory No. Report No. 17 - Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Major DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 12E-2, Jeans, front left knee 0 Single source DNA pro?le, indicated as female, as previously reported 0 Matches Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population Item Blood indicated on jeans, front right knee Item 12G1-2, Blood indicated on left shoe, top right side 0 Single source DNA pro?le, indicated as female, as previously reported 0 Matches Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population Item Blood indicated on jeans, front right pocket Item 12E-5, Blood indicated on jeans, front left pocket 0 Mixtures of three or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major mixtures of two or more individuals 0 A mixture of DNA from Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes cannot be excluded as the source of the DNA in both major mixtures It is estimated that 99.999995% of the general populations can be excluded from being contributors 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item Blood indicated on left shoe, right side midsole Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches Rayann Francine Hayes 0 The probability of selecting an unrelated individual at random ?om the general population having a DNA pro?le that would match this major DNA pro?le is approximately 1 in 1.9 billion 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 12G2-1, Blood indicated on right shoe, left side near laces Mixture of two or more individuals, as previously reported 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Major DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. Page 7 of 8 Laboratory N0. SIS-14003 Report No. 17 2mm Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist loci tested using PCR-STR includes some or all of the following: D881179, D2181 l, D78820, CSFIPO, D168539, D19S433, VWA, TPOX, FGA, and Amelogenjn. Disposition of Evidence: Please pick up your evidence. The contents of Item 28 have been retained. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 8 of 8 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/105 Report Date: 02/16/2016 Priimary lnformation Lab report 18 - Blood Stain Pattern Analysis OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02/16/2016 Approved By: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 02/16/2016 10:33 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 02/16/2016 10:38 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO I -_Dat'e 7 Supervisor . Date, OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I OLSON, Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 HT: (651) 282?6555 FAX: (651) 793-290] AN ASCLD/LAB-Intemational ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA 31- P3111 Lab N0. SIS-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Rep on; Na 13 St. Paul, MN 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAIVIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Blood Stain Pattern Analysis 02/12/20] 6 Laboratory Number: 315-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Blood Stain Pattern Analysis Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Rayann Francine Hayes; Jamar Oneal Clark; Je??i'ey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packag'gg Description/Source 12 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Jamar Oneal Clark clothing 12C One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as t- Red t-shirt Jamar Oneal Clark shirt 12E One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as Denim House jeans - Jamar Oneal Clark jeans 12G One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark pair of shoes 12G1 a left shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes - Jamar Oneal Clark 12G2 a right shoe Red Jordan Flight shoes Jamar Oneal Clark Results of Laboratory Examination: The following is an amendment to the Conclusions, section 2 of report No. 16, dated 2/4/2016, based on additional information available in DNA report No. 17, dated 2/6/2016. 2. The t?shirt, jeans, and both shoes were in proximity to a spatter producing event or events which involved the blood of Rayann Francine Hayes. The source(s) of Rayann Francine Hayes? blood was located generally in front of and to the top of the shoes of Jamar Oneal Clark?s clothing when this event(s) took place. Possible mechanisms producing the spatter include but are not limited to impact, expiration, cast-off and satellite stains form dripped, projected or splashed blood. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. Page 1 of 2 Jason A. Simser, Forensic Scientist 3 Disposition of Evidence: Please pick up your evidence. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Laboratory No. 51544003 Report No. 18 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/106 Report Date: 02/19/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information . Description: Acquisition of Ambulance #443 Squad Video Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02I19I2016 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On about November 20th 2016, SA Phill received two DVDs from Chad Dotzler. The DVDs were copies of HCMC ambulance videos from rig #419 (Hayes' ambulance) and #443 (Clark's ambulance). Each DVD contained views from 3 cameras mounted in each ambulance rig. DVD #419 was given ACISS evidence number 29.1 in a previous report. DVD #443 was given ACISS evidence number 106.1. Address #1 RELATED #1 9.1611 PLYMOUTH Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshir'; Name Big . Address #2 - RELATED #2 - Hennepin County-Medical Center- Primary Information Address: Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States SUbject #1 -_'Ringgenberg, Mark-Deugias. Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Of?cer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name Big EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 1 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/106 Report Date: 02/19/2016 subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 Schwarze; bus-tin: Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name _Ei_o EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subjectm 0TH - NON LAWENFORCE #?1Do?tzler,Chajd Robert Primary Information Subject Name: Dotzler, Chad Robert Record Type: Person Bio: 40 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 170 Employment Information Occupation: Paramedic Preperty.#1 - DVD Containing, the Video from HOME Ambulance #419 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD Containing the video from HCME Ambulance #419 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I106.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected DatelTime: 11i19i2015 00:00 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 2 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/106 Report Date: 02/19/2016 Property #2 - DVD Containing the Video from HCMC A-mbUlance #443 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD Containing the video from HCMC Ambulance #443 Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015L648I106.2 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 11l19/2015 00:00 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 02/19/2016 11:50 Last Update Operator: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 22:00 Reporting LED 7 . - Date Supervisor . 7 Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 2126/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 02/26/2016 13:37 Page 3 of 4 On Thursday, November 19th 2015 Special Agent (SA) Phill met with Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Paramedic and Deputy Chief of Operations, Chad Dotzler. Dotzler provided 2 sets of DVDs to SA Phill. One DVD had the ambulance videos from truck #419 and the other contained videos from truck #443. SA Phill and other agents at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) reviewed both sets of videos and saw that Rayann Hayes was transported in truck #419. The rear facing camera from that truck recorded Of?cers Schwarze and Riggenberg contact Jamar Clark at the request of HCMC paramedics who reported that Clark was banging on the truck?s rear doors. The videos from truck #443 showed Clark being loaded and transported to HCMC for treatment. Of note on both rear facing camera videos, it was discovered that the image was reversed from left to right. So action on the right side of the camera actually appeared on the left side; and gestures made by a person?s left hand, actually appeared on the right. A corrected disc was made to reverse the camera to show the true left and right actions depicted by the rear facing camera of truck #419. That disc was given evidence item 29.2 and the hard drive from truck #419 was given evidence item 29.2. The DVD from truck #419 was given ACISS evidence number 106.1 and DVD from truck #443 was given evidence number 106.2. Copies of both DVDs were then made for purpose of review and examination. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/107 Report Date: 02/29/2016 Description: Lab Report #19, DNA Begun on BPA Findings Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 02/29/2016 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 02/29/2016 12:32 Last Update Operator: Phili, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 02/29/2016 12:37 . . Date 1 {.?upzenriiszor . . . .. Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3111/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/11/201611:48 Page 1 of1 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: 793-2900 (651) 282-6555 (651) 793-290] AN ASCLD/LAB-International ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St Paul Lab No. S15-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Report No. 19 St. Paul, MN 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 02/26/2016 Laboratory Number: 815-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/With a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Rayann Francine Hayes; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Etc?m Type and Packaging Description/Source 26 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants ?eece - Dustin Timothy Schwarze - clothing item 89.1 26A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as ?eece jacket - Dustin Timothy Schwarze - item clothing 89.] 26B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants - Dustin Timothy Schwarze item 89.1 clothing 27 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants shirt, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg item clothing 89.2 27A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as shirt, Mark Douglas - item 89.2 clothing 27B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item 89.2 clothing Results of Laboratory Examination: This report contains an amendment for Report 12, dated 12/22/2016. The amendment is as follows: The Description/Source for Items 27, 27A, and 27B was incorrectly listed as ?om ?Riggenberg? and should have been ?Ringgenberg?. The remainder of this report concerns examinations of additional evidence. Presumptive testing indicated the presence of blood on eight areas of Item 27A, of which three samples were collected as Items 27A-1, 27A-2, and and on two areas of Item 27B, of which one sample was collected as Item 27B-1. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 19 DNA analysis will be performed on selected items and Bloodstain Pattern Analysis will be performed on Items 27A and 27B. Ifyou have not received a report within two weeks of the date on this report, or if these analyses are not needed, please contact the Biology Section of the BCA Laboratory. Blood was not detected on Items 26A and 26B. Amylase, a constituent of saliva, was not detected on selected tested areas of Item 27B. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. {gnaw Jason A. Simser, Forensic Scientist 3 Disposition of Evidence: Evidence will be held in the lab pending analysis. Portions of pertinent evidence items have been removed and are being stored at the BCA laboratory. Distribution: BCA St. Paul 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/108 Report Date: 02/24/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Transfer of EMT Bag and Pole Cam to HCAO Reporting LEO: Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03I03l2016 Approved By: Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On Feb 24th 2016, SA transferred some evidence items for Amy Sweasy at the HCAO. They were the busted pole cam (28.1), the IA files and discs (50.1-3) on Schwarze complaints, and an EMT bag (27.10) collected at the scene. Attorney Thad Tudor signed for the items. Nothing new acquired as evidence. Address #1 .. . Primary Information Address: 300 6TH ST Hennepin County Goverment Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55487 United States Description: Hennepin County Goverment Center Telephones E-A ddresses Relationship Number/E?Address BILLING AND INSTALLATION ADDRESS ADDRESS ADDRESS subject #1 suadsct #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects mm EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 21:36 Page of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/108 Report Date: 02/24/2016 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship _N_a_rr_1? B_io' EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Officers Sweasy, Amy (Assistant County Attorney HENNEPIN COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE) Tudor, Thad Nathan (Assistant County Attorney HENNEPIN COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE) Record Status information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 03l02l2016 09:17 Last Update Operator: Mueller, Scott (1305 Metro Regional Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 03l03l2016 09:03 Reporting'LEo. . A Supervisor 3 Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Mueller, Scott (1305 I Metro Regional Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Office I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/3/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the foilowingpage. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 21 :36 Page 2 of 3 On Wednesday, February 24th 2016, Special Agent (SA) Phill took some items of evidence to the Hennepin County Attorney?s Of?ce at the request of Assistant County Attorney Sweasy. The items were the broken Minneapolis Police pole camera from Plymouth and Knox (Item 28.1), an EMT bag collected from the scene (27.10), and the Internal Affairs files and discs from closed IA cases on Officer Schwarze Assistant County Attorney Tudor signed for the items and placed them in Sweasy?s of?ce for safekeeping. The evidence transfer receipt has been attached to this report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt . I I [Rage/1.1.9151 Offense Number: 2015648198 Case Agent: OLSON. Chris item Quaeti?r Description" 1 mo Mobil Pro systems camera head - meazsoo ET State authority to release or manner of disposition: COURT nearby certify that have received the above listed property Signage Date Received '2 Z?f? {6 Name I WAssistani County Attorney! HENNEPIN Owner?: rowner COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE) Address City/State Released By Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Telephone Veri?ed By Received From Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Court Case Number Defendants Name Deputy Clerk Signature Deputy Cierk Printed Name Date Received Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Preperty Release/Diaposal Receipt Offense Number: 2015-648/27 Page efi Case Agent: Phill. Charles [item Quantity lDescription lb 10 1.00 she'll/redraw Bag, green State authority to reiease or manner of disposition: COURT I nearby cedify that I have received the above listed property Name 1 swam (Assistant County Attorney I HENNEPIN Date Received 2-2?149 OwnerlFor Owner COUNTY ATTORNEY V.. - . . City/State Released By Phlil. Charles (1385 I MRO - Telephone Verified By Received From Coun: Case Number Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homioide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Aperehension) Defendants Name Deputy Clerk Signature Deputy Clerk Printed Name Date Reserved Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Freeway -- - Offense Number: 2015-648f50 Case Agent: Phill. Charles :Quantii; ll?bwgeg?i?b'tion ?f 1 ?oiEnvelope containing 2 MP0 Squad Videos from March 24 2015 1.00 MP0 CD Containing Dispatch Audio from March 11 2015 3 1.00 MP0 CD Containing Squad Video from March 11 2015 m- State authority to release or manner of disposition: COURT Ihearby certify that! have received the above listed property Signage 4% Date Received 2 . zit-f . a fkd?r?, 5 ame WSW (Aegistant County Attorney i I Tia?d COUNTY ATTORNEY owner For owner Address CityIState Released By Phi?, Charles (1385! Telephone Veri?ed By Received From Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Court Case Number Defendants Name Deputy Clerk Signature Deputy Clerk Printed Name Date Received Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/109 Report Date: 03/02/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Lab Report #20, DNA Results after BPA on Uniform Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved 03/02/2016 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1430 MARYLAND AVE Primary Information Address: 1430 MARYLAND AVE Bureua of Criminal Apprehension, St. Paul, Minnesota 55106 United States Description: Bureau of Criminal Apprenhension Address #2 - - 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subject #2 4SU3JECT #2 Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer JUVenile: NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/11/201611248 Page 1 of2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/109 Report Date: 03/02/2016 Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamaroneal - . Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 03/02/2016 11:57 Last Update Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 03I02l2016 12:03 ReportingLEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385] MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/11/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide [Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/1 1/20'16 11:48 Page 2 of 2 AFETY MINNESOTA DEPARTIVIENT OF PUBLIC Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793?2900 NY: 282-6555 FAX: 793-290] AN AS CLD/LAB?International ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 Lab No. 815-14003 ReportNo. 20 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXANIINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Nuclear DNA 03/01/2016 Laboratory Number: SIS-14003 Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Nuclear DNA Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Rayann Francine Hayes; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Egg Type and Packagm' Description/Source 15 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Dustin Timothy Schwarze DNA sample collection kit 16 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Mark Douglas Ringgenberg DNA sample collection lcit 17 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Jef?ey Steven Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.1 18 One plastic bag containing evidence classi?ed as a Chad Michael Conner, Agency Item #2015- known DNA sample collection kit 648/ 12.2 21 One manila envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a blood prep Jamar Oneal Clark, Agency Item #3 bloodstain 27 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants shirt, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item clothing 89.2 27A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as shirt, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item 89.2 clothing 27B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item 89.2 clothing 28 One envelope containing evidence classi?ed as a known Rayann Francine Hayes DNA sample collection kit Results of Laboratory Examination: DNA pro?ling* was performed on blood previously indicated on samples (Items 27A-1, 27 and 27B-l) previously collected from Items 27A and 27B. DNA pro?ling was also previously performed on Items 15, 16, 17, 18, 21 and 28. The DNA results are as follows: Item Front right arm of shirt Mixture of two or more individuals - Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark Page 1 of 3 Laboratory No. 815-14003 Report No. 20 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jef?ey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insufficient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 27A-2, Front right pocket of shirt - Mixture of three or more individuals 0 Major DNA pro?le, indicated as female, matches Rayann Francine Hayes, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Major DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, effrey Steven Sworski and Chad Michael Conner are excluded from being contributors to the minor types - Jamar Oneal Clark cannot be excluded from being a possible contributor to minor types It is estimated that 99.98% of the general population can be excluded ?om being contributors Item 27A-3, Back left side of shirt 0 Mixture of two or more individuals 0 Major male DNA pro?le matches Jamar Oneal Clark, does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Major male DNA pro?le would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population 0 Due to insuf?cient genetic information, no statement can be made on the minor types Item 27B-1, Front right leg pocket of pants 0 Single source male DNA pro?le 0 Matches Jamar Oneal Clark 0 Does not match Dustin Timothy Schwarze, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg, Jeffrey Steven Sworski, Chad Michael Conner or Rayann Francine Hayes 0 Would not be expected to occur more than once among unrelated individuals in the world population I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. 72mm Ross Thomas Forensic Scientist Page 2 of 3 Laboratory No. Report No. 20 loci tested using PCR-STR includes some or all of the following: D881179, D2131 1, D7SSZO, D331358, D133317, D16SS39, D19S433, VWA, FGA, and Amelogenin. Disposition of Evidence: Please pick up your evidence. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 3 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Lab Result Attachment 2015-648/110 Report Date: 03/03/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03/03/2016 Approved By: Lab Report #21, DNA on Final BPA Report Phiil, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 21:27 Phiil, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 21:31 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor 7 Date PhilI, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide! Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/11/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/11/201611:48 Page 1 of 1 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT or PUBLIC SAFETY Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Forensic Science Laboratory St. Paul 1430 Maryland Avenue East St. Paul, MN 55106 TEL: (651) 793-2900 (651) 282-6555 (651) 793-2901 AN ASCLD/LAB-International ACCREDITED TESTING LABORATORY SINCE 2009 To: BCA St. Paul Lab No. 815-14003 1430 Maryland Avenue East Report No, 21 St. 55106 Attention: SA Mike Phill REPORT ON THE EXAMINATION OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE Blood Stain Pattern Analysis 03/03/2016 Laboratory Number: Requesting Agency: BCA St. Paul Section Reporting: Blood Stain Pattern Analysis Agency Case Number: 2015648 Case Type: Of?cer Involved Shooting/with a Death County: Hennepin Principals: Dustin Timothy Schwarze; Mark Douglas Ringgenberg; Rayann Francine Hayes; Jamar Oneal Clark; Jeffrey Steven Sworski; Chad Michael Conner Description of Submitted Evidence: Item Type and Packag?pg Description/Source 27 One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants shirt, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item clothing 89.2 27A One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as shirt, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item 89.2 clothing 27B One brown paper bag containing evidence classi?ed as pants, Mark Douglas Ringgenberg - item 89.2 clothing DNA Report No. 20, dated 03/01/2016 was relied upon for conclusions in this report. Results of Laboratory Examination: The following observations and conclusions are based upon the information provided to date. If more information becomes available, I reserve the right to amend this report. Reported bloodstains were either presumptively tested for the presence of blood (Report No. 19, dated 02/26/2016) or were visually consistent with blood. Orientations such as ?left? or ?right? for clothing descriptions are in reference to the clothes being worn. Observations: Item 27A Shirt 0 The majority of bloodstains on the shirt were transfer stains. These were located on the ?oat right chest pocket and armpit, front upper right arm, back lower left, and back lower left arm. 0 One of the transfer stains on the upper right arm was mixed with apparent tissue. 0 One indeterminate type bloodstain, where a speci?c bloodstain pattern analysis classi?cation could not be determined, was located on the outside of the front right chest pocket ?ap. Page 1 of 2 Laboratory No. 815?14003 Report No. 21 Item 27B Pants 0 Transfer stains mixed with apparent tissue were the only bloodstains observed on the pants. Three areas in total were located on the outside of the right leg thigh pocket ?ap. Conclusions: 1. The presence of transfer stains on the shirt and pants is consistent with object(s) containing the blood of Jamar Oneal Clark and Rayann Francine Hayes coming in contact with these items. Terminology: Bloodstain: A deposit of blood on a surface. Bloodstain pattern: A grouping or distribution of bloodstains that indicates through regular or repetitive form, order, or arrangement the manner in which the pattern was deposited. Transfer Stain: A bloodstain resulting from contact between a blood-bearing surface and another surface. I hereby certify that the above report is true and accurate and represents my opinions and interpretations. ?aa?gw Jason A. Simser, Forensic Scientist 3 Disposition of Evidence: Please pick up your evidence. Distribution: BCA St. Paul - 1 Page 2 of 2 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/1 1 1 Report Date: 03/03/2016 Primary information I Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03/03/2016 Approved By: PD Reports 92-95 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) ReCord Status InfOrmation Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 22:07 Phili, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/03/2016 22:08 Reporting LEO 1 Date supervisor - - I Date Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Phil], Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/11/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/11/201611248 Page 1 of 1 MPD CAPRS Supplement - Page 1 of 2 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 92 Author: 004218 - Daniel Lee Date Printed: Mar 2, 2016 Supplement of Off D.Loe #004218 on 01/12/2016 22:09 Crime Lab Unit1 Digital Squad Video Report, 15-423384 On 0110712016 the Crime Lab Unit received a request from Conzi Bates, Minneapolis City Attorney's Of?ce. for a DVD copy of digital squad video pertaining to the incident. On 01112/2016. retrieved the following digital squad videos from the L3 Communications sewer: File# 630529: 76754 on 11/1 51201 5 at 0051 File# 629779: 76767 on 11/15/2015 at 0051 File# 630243: 76705 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629720: 76699 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629721: 76699 on 11l15/2015 at 0259hrs File# 632798: 76746 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629746: Pit 76706 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 630761: 76694 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629725: 76629 on 11/15/2015 at 01581105 File# 629723: 76629 on 11/15/2015 at 02481116 File# 629724: 76714 on 11/15/2015 at 0200hrs File# 629722: 76714 on 11/1 51201 5 at 0251 File# 629867: 76677 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 630113: 76734 on 11/15/2015 at 0051hrs File# 629754: 76676 on 1111 51201 5 at 0050hrs File# 629755: 76676 on 11/1 51201 5 at 0122hrs File# 629765: 76675 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 631113: 76698 on 11/15/2015 at 0047-hrs File# 630077: 76733 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629718: 76765 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629748: 76702 on 11/1 51201 5 at 0051 File# 631214: 76657 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629765: 76675 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 630406: 76696 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629657: 76717 on 11/15/2015 at 0052hrs 3/2/2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - 5-4233 84 Page 2 of 2 File# 629639: 76703 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs created and labeled one DVD copy (3 Discs: Disc 1 of 3, Disc 2 of 3, Disc 3 of 3) of the recorded footage. The above videos are set to archive should a future copy be requested. P#s 76679, 76764, 76718, 76682, 76759, 76741, 76745, 76571, 76708, 76691, 76684, 76758, 76752, 76637, 76744, 76729, 76758, 76724, 76702, 76735, 76329, 76666, 76678, 76692, 76709, 76737, 76372, 76732. 76727 on 11/15/2015 at approximately 0040hrs to 0600hrs. The requested search does not appear to have video pertaining to the incident with the requested search criteria. The requestor was noti?ed via email of the ?ndings, and that three DVDs were ready for pick-up at the Minneapolis Crime Lab Unit. End of Supplement report for case Print ID: {1 E367469-8003-481C-AD3D- 7F563981 3/2/2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - MP-15-4233 84 Page I of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: MP-15-423384 Supplement Number: 93 Author: 004218 Daniel Lee Date Printed: Mar 2. 2016 Supplement of Off D.Loe #004218 on 01/14/2016 22:57 Crime Lab Unit, Digital Squad Video Report, 15-423384 On 01/13/2016 the Crime Lab Unit received a request from Conzi Bates, Minneapolis City Attorney's Of?ce, for a DVD copy of digital squad video pertaining to the incident. On 01/14/2016. i retrieved the following digital squad videos from the L3 Communications server: File# 629794: 76764 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs File# 629827: 76718 on 11/15/2015 810055hrs Fi e# 629997: 76741 on 11/15/2015 at 0050hrs Flle# 629715: 76724 on 11/15/2015 at 0056hrs File# 629748: 76702 on 11/15/2015 at 0051 File# 629684: 76735 on 11/15/2015 at 0051 File# 629694: 76372 on 11/15/2015 at 0054hrs File# 630827: 76732 on 11/1 51201 5 at 0050hrs I created and labeled one DVD copy of the recorded footage. The requester was noti?ed via email that the DVD was ready for pick-up at the Minneapolis Crime Lab Unit. The above videos are set to archive should a future copy be requested. End of Supplement report for case MP-15-423384. Print ID: {1 F097BA3-53D6-4FZB-A073- 1F097BA3 ~53 . .. 3/2/2016 MPD CAPRS Supplement - MP-15-423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number: 94 Author: 004218 - Daniel Lee Date Printed: Mar 2, 2016 Supplement of Off D.Loe #004218 on 01/1412016 22:58 Crime Lab Unit, Digital Squad Video Reportl 15-423384 On 010412016 the Crime Lab Unit received a request from Conzi Bates, Minneapolis City Attorney's Of?ce, for a DVD copy of digital squad video pertaining to the incident. On 01/14/2016 I attempted to retrieve the following digital squad video for this incident from the L3 Communications server: 76605 on 1111522015 from approximately 0040hrs to 0600hrs. The requested search does not appear to have video pertaining to the incidentwith the requested search criteria. The requester was noti?ed of the ?ndings via email. End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print ID: 3/2/2016 .nvu - -.- MPD CAPRS Supplement Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: Supplement Number: 95 Author: 000243 - Christopher Granger Date Printed: Mar 2, 2016 Supplement of C.Granger #000243 on 03/02/2016 16:40 Public Information On 3-2-16, Deputy Chief Folkens contacted me with a request to add public informaiton to that section of this report as the information hadn't been added. Commander Granger Violent Crimes Investigations Division End of Supplement report for case NIP-15423384. Print in: 3/2/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/112 Report Date: 03/09/2016 Primary Information Description: Acquire 4231431 video Occurrence From: 0310812016 10:00 Occurrence To: 0310812016 11:00 Reporting LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 0310912016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis - On May 8, 2016, SA Olson received two squad videos (423 and 431), which were not previously received relative to this investigation. items 112.1 (squad 423 DVD) and 112.2 (squad 431 DVD) received by virtue of this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 350 5TH ST Primary Information Address: 350 5TH #Rm 108, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 . United States Subject #1 - MENTION lN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 0510311991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Persona! information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks identi?cations LILTttee m; State gantry M01339F131 NO 232941 Minnesota NO -- State lD Minnesota NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - OLSON. Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/09/2016 14:01 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/112 Report Date: 03/09/2016 Property #1 - 2 - DVD's squad video from 423 Primary information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: 2 - squad video from 423 Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 0310912016 00:00 Property #2 - DVD - 431 video Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD - 431 video Quantity: 1 Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: Locker Collected Date/Time: 0310912016 00:00 Of?cers LE9 GRANGER, Christopher (Comm! Homicide 1 Minneapolis Police Department) Record Status information Record Origination Operator: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 0310912016 10:58 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 i MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 0310912016 13:47 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 31912016 Apprehension) Apprehension) [Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION OLSON. Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 0310912016 14:01 Page 2 of 3 On Monday, March 7, 2016, SA Olson received a request from the Hennepin County Attorney?s Of?ce to obtain three squad videos that were previously mentioned in MPD reports. The requested squad videos were identi?ed as follows: 1. Squad 41 1 (P76727 Shanklin and Badowich) 2. Squad 423 (P76629 Ledman) 3. Squad 43l (P7671 4 Hedberg) SA Olson contacted Commander Granger in an effort to obtain these videos. On Tuesday, March 8, 2016, SA Olson received from Commander Granger the following (see attached evidence receipt). Evidence Item 112.1: Squad 423 (P76629 Ledman) Evidence Item 11.2.2: Squad 43] (P767l4 -?Hedberg) Commander Granger indicated there was no video of the event ?om squad 411 (P76727 Shanklin and Badowich). It should be noted that item 1 12.1 is-actually two while the video from item 112.2 is contained on a single DVD. SA Olson reviewed both squad videos which depicted angry and vocal crowds gathering outside the crime scene tape near 1611 Plymouth Ave N. SA Olson will maintain and preserve both of the aforementioned items pending transfer to SA Phil]. End report. Olson. Christopher (DPS) From: Loe, Daniel Sent: Monday, March 07, 2016 9:27 PM To: Granger, Christopher Subject: Squad Video Request CCN #15?423384 Commander Granger, The requested Pi: 76727 does not contain video near the time of the incident. Relevant video from 76629 has been requested online to be provided to you upon reactivation. Pit 76714 has been provided to you as requested. A supplement will be added to the case upon completion. Thank you, Ofc Loe Ofc Loe Video Forensics Crime Lab Unit Minneapolis Police STATE OF MINNESOTA P5-6-0030 (REV- 12/02) 7 DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION 1430 MARYLAND AVE. EAST, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 Bureau Criminal Appahension Bureau No. Laboratory No. Evidence No. EVIDENCE RECEIPT hem S.W. Lab 0 of Person Whom Prope Obtained Purpose For Which Obtained No Item Item stan- i No. No. or?? - i ?1 A DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLES m? Patti?(olqt ?x I CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED AND HOLD MYSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ARTICLES LISTED ABOVE Date Ime Signature Storage Site '5 3 [2.0 CHAIN OF CUSTODY if: Date Relinquished By K- Received By o; WNQEK A A a gar?i 1 6 Signature 53% (0-59 I - Olson, Christopher (DPS) From: Granger, Christopher Sent: Tuesday, March 08, 2016 11:06 AM To: Olson, Christopher (DPS) Subject: Data Practices Advisory 3-8-16 BCA Special Agent Chris Olson, These files and or videos are being provided to you un-redacted under MN State Statute Section 13.43, Subd. 15. Dissemination of data to law enforcement and or MN State Statute 13.82 Subd. 15 Public Benefit Data. These files and or videos do or may contain data that is protected under the MN Government Data Practices Act. These files and or videos must be reviewed for any necessary redaction under the MN Government Data Practices Act before any public release of their contents. Reference: DVD squad video for 76714 (2 copies), DVD squad video for 76629 part 1 (2- copies) and DVD squad video for 76629 part 2 (2 copies). Commander DeChIistopher Granger Minneapolis Police Department Violent Crimes Investigation Division 350 South 5?11 Street Room 108 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Of?ce 612-673-2945 DEPARTMENT VALUES: COMIVJITMENT INTEGRITY TRANSPARENCY 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/113 Report Date: 03/10/2016 Primary Information Description: PD Report #96 Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved 03l10l2016 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phil], Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau 'of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) (33/10/2016 11:52 Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03l10l201611:54 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide] Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3111/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Page 1 of1 MPD CAPRS Supplement NIP-15423384 Page 1 of 1 Case Supplement Minneapolis Police Department CCN: NIP-15423384 Supplement Number: 96 Author: 004218 - Daniel Loe Date Printed: Mar 8, 2016 Supplement of Off D.Loe #004218 on 03/08/2016 15:18 Crime Lab Unit, Digital Squad Video Report. 15-423384 On 03/07/2016 the Crime Lab Unit received a request from Commander GrangerI Violent Crimes Investigations Division, for a three DVD copies of digital squad video pertaining to the incident. On 08/07/2016, I retrieved the following digital squad video from the L3 Communications server: File# 629724: 76714 on 11/15/2015 at 0200hrs File# 629722: 76714 on 11/15/2015 at 0251hrs 1 created and labeled three DVD copies of the recorded footage. The above video is set to archive should a future copy be requested. On the same date, I also attempted to retrieve the following digital squad video for this incident from the L3 Communications server: 76727 on 11/15/2015 at approximately 0040hrs The requested search does not appear to have video pertaining to the incident with the requested search criteria. The requester was noti?ed via phone of the ?ndings, and that the three DVD copies were ready for pick up for 76714 at the Minneapolis Crime Lab Unit. On 03/08/2016, I retrieved the following digital squad video from the L3 Communications server: Fi e# 629725: 76629 on 11/15/2015 at 0158hrs Flle# 629723: 76629 on 11/15/2015 at 0248hrs created and labeled three DVD copies of the recorded footage. The above video is set to archive should a future copy be requested. On 03/08/2016 Commander Granger advised that he did not need the three DVD copies of 76629 from the Crime Lab. The three DVD copies were all placed in the secured shredding bin to be destroyed. End of Supplement report for case MP-15-423384. Print ID: 3/8/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/114 Report Date: 03/10/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Transfer of Evidence to HCAO Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03/15/2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis - On March 7th and March 10th 2016, SA Phill transferred the training records of Schwarze and Ringgenberg along with the Crime Lab Sketch CD and an expanded CD of Squad 424?s video (95.1, 68.1 and 69.1 respectively). No new evidence acqurred. Address #1 7 Occurred #1 - 300 6TH ST Primary Information Address: 300 6TH ST Hennepin County Goverment Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55487 United States Description: Hennepin County Goverment Center Address #2 - RELATED #1 --1611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Do'uglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: N0 Subject #2 . SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, .DUStin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/18/2016 13:05 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/114 Report Date: 03/10/2016 Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy - Continued Rank/Position: Juven?e: Primary Information - Continued Officer NO Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 - Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Record Status Information Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Record Origination Operator: 03? 01201 6 11:54 Phili, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03I151201 6 14:51 Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date Supenrisor Date Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicidel Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicidel Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3118/2016 marrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/18/2016 13:05 Page 2 of 3 On March 7th and March 10th 2016, Special Agent (SA) Phill transferred 3 items of evidence to Angela Erichson at the Hennepin County Attorney?s Of?ce (HCAO). There were items 68.1 CD of PD Crime Scene Sketches), 69.1 (Full Squad 424 video), and 95.1 (CDs of PD Training Records for Schwarze and Ringgenberg). Ms. Erichson signed for the items on the ACISS Transfer sheets and the sheets have been attached to this report. SA Phill will retrieve the items of evidence at a later date. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Pmperty Release/Disposal Receipt Offense Number; 2015-6348169 Page 1 of 1 Case Agent: Phill, Charles [Description mam JQuantity l? \ri ?ht 1.00joo Containing Mpls?iSEKCrime-Lab Scene Sketches .H ?jj State authority to release or manner of disposition: COURT lhearby certify that have received the above listed property i . Signature is? a CE Cit-K Date Received if) . I 91 Name Assistant HENNEPIN COUNTY Owne?por Owner Address CityIState Released By Pnill, Charies(1385/MR01 Telephone 7 Verified By Court Receipt Received From Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Court Case Number Defendants Name Deputy Clerk Signature Deputy Clerk Printed Name Date Received _u Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Page 1 of 1 Offense Number: 2015648168 Case Agent: OLSON, Chris HE. Quantity Descriptior ?l 1.60 DVD - Squad 424 squad video State authority to release or manner of disposition: COURT ihearby certify that i have received the above listed property [fl '1 L. I ?h - Klifzd-L? Signature 2 1- 37:51.11? Uj? a _7 Date Received - . Eriohson, Angela (Legal Assistantr' HENNEPIN COUNTY ame EORNEY OFFICE) I 1 Owner! or Owner Address 7 City/State Released By Charles (1385 I MRO - Telephone Verified By Court Receipt Received From Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Court Case Number Defendants Name 7 Deputy Clerk Signature I Deputy Clerk Printed Name a Date Received Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Page 1 of 1 Offense Number: 2015?6483/95 Case Agent: Phill, Charles item IDescription mm 1? Containing the Training Records fo Ofcs Ringgenberg and Schwarze State authority to release or manner of disposition: COURT I hearby certify that I have received the above listed property Signature Date Received Name E?iga?Egg?e?if?gal HENNEPIN COUNTY ownerlFor Owner ?u Address 7m City/State Released By Phill, Charles (Minnesota Bure Telephone Verified By Court Receipt Received From Phill, Charles (Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Court Case Number Defendants Name Deputy Clerk Signature Deputy Clerk Printed Name Date Received Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Attachment 2015-648/115 Report Date: 03/10/2016 Primary Information Description: Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Date: Approved By: Evidence transfer to SA Phill OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approved OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 03/10/2016 11:58 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/10/201612:00 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Reporting LEO Date . Supervisor .. - Date, OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/11/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrativeb'egins on the page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/11/201611248 Page 1 of 2 On March 10, 2016, SA Olson transferred items 112.1 and 112.2 to SA Phill for safekeeping and preservation. (See attached Property Release) End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Property Release/Disposal Receipt Offense Number: 2015-6481112 Page of 1 Case Agent: OLSON. Chris Item Quantity Description 1 1.00 2 DVD's squad video from 423 2 1.00 DVD - 431 video State authority to release or manner of disposition: AGENT INVESTIGATION hearby certify that I ha ceived the above ted property Signature PhiIITEhag?s (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of 0/4; Name OwnerlFor Owner Criminal Apprehensron) Address Released By Olson. Christopher (anesot Telephone Veri?ed By 5W Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/116 Report Date: 03/16/2016 Primaryulln?formatiOn Description: Search Warrants for HCMC Run Reports for Clark and Hayes Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03l25l2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On March 16th, 2016 SA Phill obtained 2 Search Warrants for the HCMC ambulance run sheets for Clark and Hayes on November 15th 2016. They were sealed on March 25th. Evidence items 116.1 (Clark's Report) and 116.2 (Hayes' Report) were acquired with this report. Both were also added as attachments. Address #1 RELATED AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Address;#2 - - Hennepin County Medical Center Primary Information Address: Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota United States Subject #1 - VICTIM Primary Information Subject Name: HAYES, RAYANN FRANCINE Record Type: Person Bio: 41 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO S?UbjeCt soonest-#1 Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05l03l1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American HeightMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 11:44 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/116 Report Date: 03/16/2016 subject #2 SUBJECT #1 'Clark;?damar Oneal Continued Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Personal information - Continued -- - Collected Date/Time: Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Clark's HCMC Ambulance Run Report Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2016454811161 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BOA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE 03i16l2016 00:00 'Ha'li??l Run. Report Collected Date/Time: Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: Documents Description: Hayes' HCMC Ambulance Run Report Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I116.2 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BOA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE 03? 61201 6 00:00 Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 12:49 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03I25i2016 11:26 MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phil]. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 11:44 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/116 Report Date: 03/16/2016 Reporting LEO . a j: Date - Supervisor - . Date Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide/ Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3125/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 11:44 Page 3 of 4 On Wednesday, March 16th 2016, Special Agent (SA) Phill obtained two search warrants in Hennepin County Court from Judge Bev Benson. The warrants were to obtain the Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Ambulance run reports for Jamar Clark and Rayann Hayes. On November 15th 2015, HCMC paramedics treated and transported both Hayes and then Clark from 1611 Plymouth to HCMC in downtown Minneapolis. The Run Reports document the treatment given by paramedics as well as any injuries observed or discussed in the ambulance. SA Phill gave Clark?s Report ACISS evidence number 116.1 and Hayes? Report was given evidence number 116.2. The search warrants as well as both ambulance reports were attached to the case ?le. On March 25th 2016, the search warrants were ordered sealed by Judge Daniel Mabley and ?led in Hennepin County court. STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT In Re Search Warrant for HCMC REQUEST Ambulance Run Report for the TO SEAL treatment and transport of Rayann SEARCH WARRANT Francine Hayes, - on PURSUANT TO RULE 33.04 November 15?h 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 The undersigned requests the search warrant for HCM Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Rayann Francine Hayes, ?on November 15th 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to I-ICMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. 8th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 be sealed until such time as directed by the Judge. Respect?diy submitted, MICHAEL O. FREEMAN Hennepin County Attorney By: 1 . 04X) Assistant County Attomey C2100 Government Center Minneapolis, Mn 55487 Telephone: (612) 348?6552 Dated: March 24, 2016 STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEHN In Re Search Warrant for HCMC Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Rayann Francine Hayes on November 15th 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to I-ICMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. 8th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 STATE OF MINNESOTA SS. COUNTY OF DISTRICT COURT FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST TO SEAL SEARCH AMY E. SWEASY, being ?rst duly sworn states and deposes: l. The records requested are relevant to an on-going investigation involving a police shooting and the death of Jamar O?Neal Clark. Because the investigation is on- going, it is important that information contained in the af?davit and not yet public not be released. it?) An order directing that this warrant be sealed until such time as the court directs is needed to allow the investigation to continue unhampered. y. SWBAS Assistant County Attorney Subscribed and swom to before me Notary Public 954 dayof mmc?; 20 . A 352 PATRICIA NOTARY pU . 6" UC- ANN ALGUIRE STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT In Re Search Warrant for HCMC FINDING AND ORDER Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and trans art of Rayann Francine Hayes? on November 15?h 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 FINDINGS The Court ?nds that reasonable grounds exist to believe that ?ling the search warrant for could severely hamper an on?going investigation. ORDER IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: I. The search warrant for HCMC Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Rayann Francine Hayesnon November 15?? 2015 from the .1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 shall not be ?led at this time. 2. The above-described documents shall remain un?led until further Order of a judge of this court. Until such. ?ling, the documents and materials ordered withheld from ?ling shall be retained by the Coun or the Court?s designee, the court administrator. Dated: Judge of District Court Incident Number 15 07'6386 EN NEPIN-EMS Patient RAY ANN HAYES tic-825, 701 Park Avenue Complaint Medical Miscf?) Minneapolis, MN 55435 Case Status CLOSED (EH-8736678 INCIDENT PATIENT DATES Case {7354A828-oese-4517? Name (FirsthI/Last) RAY ANN HAYES DISPATCHED 1111512015 00:20:45 Gender MOBILE unsizms 00:20:43 Incident 15076386 ooamge ?a yr AT LOCATION 1111512015 {10:25:43 Case Status CLOSED RacelLang. Black] African AT PATIENT 11115/2015 00:29 Incident Type MEDIC - Medical Misc(E) American DEPART LOCATION 15.115/2015 00:55:23 Urgency To EMERGENCY Weight 90 ii: ARRIVED DESTINATION 11/152015 00:53:04 Address 1611 Plymouth Av Address 1223 MORGAN CLEAR 11/1512015 00:17 City, St, Zip MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55411 City, St. Zip MINNEAPOLIS, MN Trip Distance (mi) 2.2 Loc. Type HOMEIRESIDENCE 55411 Loc. on Disp Downtown 55? HCMC I E419 Case TYPE ?~51 Shift/Van p13 1 Service Type 911 Request - Skiliset Paramedic priority 1 Way to Sm NONE Insur. Co. Rafe: Name (Quali?cation) Emp, Cert, Badge ATTENDANT: Wesley Thompson (Paramedic), 526058 DRIVER: Tyler Haskell (Paramedic), 976753 Hx PRESENT Subject Descriptionl?etails Cause FIGHTIBEATINGIBRAWL WEAPONS): BLU NT OBJECT (BAT, POLE, ETC) ALCOHOL USE - PT ADMITS INTENTIONAL INFLICTED BY OTHER Complaint (R) ANKLE: HURTS To MOVE 1 HR AGO STILL PRESENT PROVOKED BY: MOVEMENT PAIN LEVEL: 10 OF 10 QUALITY: THROBBING RADIATES: NONRADIATING BLEEDING MOUTH: PAIN I DISCOMFORT FACE: PAIN NECK: DENIES PAIN I DISCOMFORT BACK: DENIES BACK PAIN DENIES LOSS OF CONSCIOUSNESS DENIES BLURRED VISION Subject Allergies None Medications None Pro-existing PREGNANCY PRIOR 0 FINDINGS Subject Description/Detalis A Department of Hennepln County Medical Center: A Level I Aduit and Pediatric Trauma Center 03116/2016 01:59 pm Page 1 of 4 (printed by: HENNEPIN-EMS tic?825, 701 Park Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55415 612433-5673 Incident Number Patient Complaint Case Status 15076386 RAY ANN HAYES Medical Misc(E) CLOSED Initial Physical Impression Event PTFOUND LOC AIRWAY BREATH CIRCUL sec) SKIN GCS EYES NEURO ECG LOWER EXTREMITIES - EXAM LOWER EXTREMTFIES - EXAM LOWER EXPREMITIES EXAM HEAD EXAM HEAD - EXAM HEAD - EXAM NECK - EXAM UPPER EXTREMITIES - EXAM BACK EXAM LOWER EXTREMITIES EXAM ABDOMEN - EXAM ABDOMEN - EXAM CHEST EXAM GENERAL - EXAM GENERAL EXAM GENERAL - EXAM GENERAL - EXAM HEAD EXAM CARE EVENTS POSITION: SITTING ORIENTATION: ORIENTED 3 AVPU: ALERT 5731715: PATENT QUALITY: NON-LABORED (R) L5: CLEAR (L) (.5: CLEAR CHEST WALL EXPANSION: EQUAL EXPANSION STATUS: PRESENT SITE: RADIAL NORMAL REGUMRITY: REGULAR REFILL: NORMAL 2 G4P. REFILL: NORMAL 2 sec) TEMP. NORMAL COLOR: NORMAL MOISTURE. NORMAL SCORE: 15 EYES: 4-SPONTANEOUS VERBAL: 5-ORIENTED MOTOR: COMMANDS (R) REACUVITY: REACUVE (L) REACHVITY: REACTIVE (R) SIZE: NORMAL (1.) 5125: NORMAL FACIAL DROOP. NONE ARM NONE SPEECH: NORMAL GRIPS: STRONG - BILATERAL RESULTING NOT ASSESSED (R) ANKLE: GAIT DIFFICULTY (R) ANKLE: TENDERNESS (R) ANKLE: RANGE OF MOTION NOSE: ABRASION NOSE: NO SIGN OF BLEEDING MOUTH: BLEEDING NECK: UNREMARKABLE FOR. ACUTE ABNORMALITIES ARM: UNREMARKABLE FOR ACUTE ABNORMALITIES BACK: UNREMARKABLE FOR ACUTE ABNORMALITIES (L) LEG: UNREMARKABLE FOR ACUTE ABNORMALITIES ABDOMEN: N0 SIGN OF TENDERNESS ABDOMEN: NO SIGN OF DISTENDED CHEST: NO SIGN OF BREATHING DIFFICULTY NO SIGN OF SHARING NO SIGN OF SHIVERING N0 SIGN OF SLURRED SPEECH CRYINGITEARFUL NOSE: BRUISE TRAUMATIC INJURY OR MECHANISM DIVERTTO TRAUMA NO Details By 00:30 STAIR CHAIR. THOMPSON 00:44 COLD PACK HASKELLT 00:44 ACCESS Indication: KVO Device: IVCATHETER Gauge: 18 Attempts 1 Site: (R) AC Result: THOMPSON SUCCESSFUL Lock Used: SALINE Fluid: SALINE Rate: NOT APPLICABLE PtResponse: N0 CHANGE Complications NONE Volume Indeed: NOT APPLICABLE Tx Authorization: PROTOCOL 00:44 DILAUDID Indication: REQUIRING PAIN RELIEF Prepain Sever-inn 10 0F10 Dose: THOMPSONW 0.50MG Route: IV Pt Response: NO CHANGE Postpain Severim 10 0F 10 Complications: NONE TxAuthorizalion: PROTOCOL 00:55 PTPOS: LYING Pulse: 98 SP. 112W RR: 18 5p02%: 98 ROOM AIR 00:58 BLOODSUGAR Biood Sugar: 96 7 Transpert Form I Hennepin County Medical Center Emergency Medicai Services A Department of Hennepin County Medical Center: A Level I Adult and Pediatric Trauma Center 03/16l2016 01:59 pm Page 2 of4 (printed by: HM9091) Incident Number 15076386 HENNEPIN-EMS Patient any sun 5 HAYES PIC-825, 701 Park Avenue Complaint Medicai Minneapolis, MN 55415 Case status CLOSED 612-873-5673 Acknowledgment of Receipt of Notice of Privacy Practices Consent to Use or Disclosure of Protected Health Information Consent to Assignment of Insurance Payments for Services Provided In this form, the words ?us? and ?our? refer to Hennepin Healthcare System, Inc., doing business as Hennapin County Medical Center (HCMC). Notice of health information privacy rights under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) HIPAA requires health care providers, including HCMC, to notify patients of their privacy rights under federal law. Our Notice of Privacy Practices (NPP) informs patients of these rights, Including how their protected health information (PHI) is used and where they may ?le a complaint if they feel than rights have been violated. We have reviewed with you, an electronic version of the NPP. You may obtain a printed version of the NPP or this form upon request As described in the NPP, we may use or disclose your PHI for one or more of following purposes: For your treatment; To obtain payment for our services from your health plan or medical insurer, including Medicare; To support and improve our health care operations; In emergency When required or permitted by law; and For other purposes not listed above, but which may be required to enable us to carry out treatment, receive payment, and/or perform health care operations or legal functions. Other uses and disclosures not listed above or in the NPP will not be made without your consent. Acknowledgement and Consent By signing this form: 1. You acknowledge that we have reviewed with you an electronic version of the NPP. 2. You consent and authorize us to use or disclose your PHI for the purposes stated above and in the NPP. 3. You authorize us to share your health and account records with your health plan or medical insurer, Including Medicare, and to submit claims or bills to them directly for our services. 4. You assign to us, your right to receive payments for our services directly from your health plan or medical insurer, including Medicare, and request that those paymenm be made directly to us. 5. You agree to cooperate with us and our agents in processing claims for payment and resolving disputed claims. Hennepin EMS Receiving Facility Representative As a representative of the receiving facility, this signature af?rms that the above-named patient was transported on the date and time indicated on the patient care report. This signature does not obligate any reSponsibility for payment by any receiving facility or a facility's personnel. It is merely a con?rmation of transport of the above-named patient to this facility. A Department of Hennepin County Medical Center: A Level I Adult and Pediatric Trauma Center 03/16/2016 01:59 pm Page 3 of4 (printed by: HENNEPIN-EMS RIC-825, 701 Fart Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55415 Incident Number Patient Complaint Case Status 15076386 RAY ANN HAYES Medical Misc?i) CLOSED 512-873-5678 ix .. E5: Disposition: TX TRANS BY THIS UNIT Destination: NORTH MEMORIAL Best. Reason: FAMILY CHOICE Urgency from Sam: NON-EMERGENCY Delay from NONE Pt. Convey TO Vehicle: STAIR CHAIR Pt. Convey FROM Vehicie: STRETCHER Pt. Convey IN Vehicie: STRETCHER Med. Controi Name: mm eezzmrom smog SIQVB f? 5 215gHAYES, MYAHH W, PAMMEDIC 1111512013 u/isjzois 01:25 smack NURSE 3115/2015 01:03 A Department of Hennepin County Medics! Center: A Lave! 1 Adult and Pediatric Trauma Center 03/16/2016 01:59 pm Page 4 of 4 (printed by: HMBOQI) STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN In Re Search ?Warrant for HCMC DISTRICT COURT FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT REQUEST Ambulance Run Report for the T0 SEAL treatment and transport of Jamar SEARCH O?Neal Clark, 53/91 on November PURSUANT To RULE 33,04 15?? 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. 8th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 The undersigned requests the search warrant for HCMC Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Jamar O?Neal Clark, 5/3/91 on November 15?? 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 730 S. 8?h Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 be sealed until such time as directed by the Judge. Respectfully submitted, MICHAEL O. FREEMAN Hennepin County Attorney B};sz 3/ AMQE. SWEASY 6104K) Assistant County Attomey C2100 Government Center Mimieapolis, Mn 55487 Telephone: (612) 348?6552 Dated: March 24, 2016 STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT In Re Search Warrant for HCMC AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT Ambulance Run Report for the OF REQUEST treatment and transport of Jamar TO SEAL SEARCH WARRANT O?Neal Ciark, 5/32'91 on November 15'h 2915 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Henncpin County Medical Center, 730 S. Street, Minneapoiis,MN 55415 STATE OF MINNESOTA) ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN) AMY E. SWBASY, being ?rst duly sworn states and deposes: l. The records requested are relevant to an on-going investigation involving a poiice shooting and the death of Jamar O?Neal Clark. Because the investigation is On-gOlIlg, it is important that information contained in the af?davit and not yet public not be released. 2. An order directing that this warrant be sealed until such time as the court directs is needed to allow the investigation to continue unhampered. WK AMY Eu; WEASY Assistant County At ey Subscribed and sworn to befor this 025d day of We, 20 {7 a} Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN DISTRICT COURT FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT In Re Search Warrant for HCMC Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Jamar O?Neal Clark, 5/3/91 on November 153?h 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medicai FINDING AND ORDER Center, 730 S. 8th Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 FINDINGS The Court ?nds that reasonable grounds exist to believe that filing the search warrant for could severely hamper an on-going investigation. 9% IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: . The search warrant for HCMC Ambulance Run Report for the treatment and transport of Jamar O?Neal Clark, 5/3/91 on November 15?? 2015 from the 1600 Block of Plymouth Avenue North to HCMC located at Hennepin County Medical Center, 736 S. Street, Minneapolis, MN 55415 shall not be ?led at this time. The above?described documents shall remain un?led until further Order of a judge ofihis court. Until such ?ling, the documents and materials ordered withheld from ?ling shall be retained by the Court or the Court?s designee, the court administrator. Judge of Disu'ict Court 1_1/1_5/2015 2:06 Fa; r?o; 9,6139ue4392 21533;; on: or no: Inqidgnt Mgmh?ar Patient Cq'm'plaint Cae Status 1.5137533; 0 qua}; Ema?aml Disturb museum-'1 5) CLOSED DATESITIMES gems PIN-EMS 701 Park Mame Wampum, MN 55415 main-5523 meme?? PATIENT Case 1m 0 twin ans/29.15 {10:51:20 a Incidgnw 45026381 5111311921 213?" ATchmou 11I15i2015 09:54:29 WSW-113 @0550 Ratefiang. StackIA?jcan AT 13mm" 11115129153154 Incident?rvpe Elam-Emotionaleth Amman! 05mm- Locmd?: mil-1312015 91:02:13 Weight 1721.1} aesrmmon nus/ham 01:09:27 Addreias 4.60? 3mm W: cum 11115121215 02:91 We? 1.55.1 cm, at. 21p uzauwous, aux. 4.: mummusm 55m. 5541: Lac Type mumsan coo-co..on ch.tlesp Hmstatlon4 ow Marty/unit. .8614? ?443 511mm 914/ seam-Type Regina-- Sitillset Parmedic Prim; baggage?, may, Ins-mac. Tyler Lupkes (Paramedic), 973285 Marl :2 H71: 939's'?s magm- Descriptl?nlnga?s Cause mega-gamma wag/93% uumcwn swarm Mumc ?1550: Ha 1mm unmawn monoumuas: unmm Complaint undonsc?rous- astrima-?unnsu 035m 5 ma wmnom mu. PRESENT (L) EYE: BULGING c5551; EMS requested to scan: by EMS Duty Chief already on scene. Upan arrival, ms Duty Chief wais a'sse?ssinq lat-1d treating .1912. EMS Uuty? Chief stated that pt: had been shot in the face ahd had stopped. breatthg, but still had thready pulse, upon E33 ambulance arrival. 91: immediately mired to ambulance where other: tc?atments We~?e provided. Subject Description] Details Allergies MEFHCEUORS Pre-edsting Subject Initial Unknown {1an Descrip?onlbetaif PTFDUND LOC mm; my mac}: ugaans TO ASSESS AVPU: unaesmnm User: Kessler, Christine 3/16/2016 11/15/2015 22:06 FROM: Fax IO: P7033: 002 OF 003 Intident?umber Patient awn 0 CMRK ?c?SJB'ifqujgyegye Complaint Emu?tinal 0mm: Bhuapds, MN55415 55.95.50? 612mm H- .0. AIRWAY 5mm PATENT - - 8mm 00107:: 10.51009 mama man um 96904000: Equal Emma ?1/3 3 ugcm SITE: 0:13on 5725:1071: wax 350.105.9171: REGULAR 0:3 550333.: wax-nous vm: x?N?dnagm-ra?aman 5m with new amok: EYES (R) 5:25: u??asis mass (L) mum: 1th nauao FACIAL moon UNABLE-TO assess EGG RESUL we RWM: Pig-n - umgw canng phyacal HEAD - Bow - EYE: 315501143: new - 90w (1.) m: SWELLIHG HEAD mm (L) m: CHEST CHEST Em: C?e'sr: csnmonzsr Impression mumncmunv museums? water no mamas ARREST ans cam cuss unconscious and unresponsive upon ENS ambulance arrival on scene. CPR started. Pt has suspected gun shot: wound to left eye. Upon mayqu pt: to ambulance. unable to detect pulse. 3? 00154 ?29: 1. 39331.40 Ptme .IHPKOYED COmWib'mi KORE Nan-f:ch Tx HOT APRLICASLE 00: vmmnon - Imam mm W. Ven?k?bn Rate: 10mm 5 WW.- OR "0 1-9079 @Wb?w "95.3- ASSISTED nay/den 00:56 Shouldasmg?emt no Wa?taewxect was :1quth ?gs Lomrteg?e?tm LUPKEST no UnaHeTo HDTAPPLICABLE 00:50 Scum: amour-1 rams Memo: pHEgt 001122355510}! QNLY kamnsz {to ma: RESPONDER Comp?caddas: NOTAPPLI LE 00:56 CPR-mum. Source: Hakim-4pm;an Mm 6le07 commonw- PtRes?mrm Rama (5'mebe NONE NOTAPPLICABLE 00:59 CPR-LUCAS DEVICE Cpr? Ratio: 30:2 naming HO CW3: mp?qam NONE HILL 01.1.04 SUCTION E'wa Bide" REFERUAQBF- 54mm: YMMBEEWLETITIP Cam 14m HILL Volm 2966 PtResponsa: HO Canp?cam: WE 01:04 1v Indtadcm coume Bevin-a IVCATHETER 0am 1.4 1 HILLM 510:: (um: Rem: 3000555001. Lockweot sauna Haifa: aqua Razz; $900135}; HP. WEEK 0:004:09?sz RQHE Wm WW Tm? NOT APPIJWLE 01:04 0055mm ADMINISTER 01:04 ITD (POD) PLACED Ibdicatlom FIRE DEFT 01:00 VITALS Pulse01:06 IVACCESS mam:qu carinmou Devin: mum?s-Iran Gauge: 1.4 Am' 1 HILLM SIM was 8.0.82 34? 54.1.1131; ME- ?3050.958 Rm: NO CHARGE Com?fuations NONE Wilma 1mm. mom: 50mm Tr?abnent: 0.15.05 gaming 323mm: Fag-.wa Rate: 099mm Scam: Hans layman? LUPKEST 01:07 KING AIRWAY KIHgAimay?ze: 4 . 1 LurgSound: Assess E?gast?wm UNABLETOASSESS Remit: 8991-1.? User: Kessler, Christine 3/16/2016 p?uuw'l - 11/15/2015 2:96 AM races: Fax T0: 9,6129044242 PAGEIncident Number i HENNEPIN-EMS Patient ma a gamut . I Complaint mum-m am MlnneapolisMR 55415 (33.5.35th CLOSED . Emmi01:09 PM?wamww I i r. .r . RESU LT Qispml?on: TX. I Bauha?g'n': Best. Reagan: Em? CHQICE Urgency from Sm: numeracy Delay from NONE Pt. Convey To Vehicle: STRETCHER Pentiva Vehicla: Pt..me Vehicle: AUTHORIZATION j??zzni-q-uoug 1 . Himaapql? police officer rode in ambulance: witr} pt, agd EMS providpqg to SD. Traqsf red pt cage SD gtaf bout incident, Pt'a ob ed upon arrival to ED. tiger: I'essler, Christine Pam?2 Ti Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/117 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Primary Information Description: 12/10/2015 13:15 12/10/2015 14:00 Occurrence From: Occurrence To: Reporting LEO: Backup LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03/23/2016 Approved By: Tyler Lupkes - December 10, 2015 interview summary OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis . On December 10, 2015, SA Olson and SA Phil] participated in a witness interview of Tyler Lupkes. The interview took place at the U.S. Attorneys Office in Minneapolis. No items of evidence were acquired by virtue of this report. Addresenfii churr?d #4 -, 300. 41H Primary Information Address: 300 4TH ST Minneapolis Federal Building, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 United States Description: United States Attorney's Office Subject #1 WITNESS #1 - Lupkes, Tyler John Primary Information Subject Name: Lupkes, Tyler John Record Type: Person Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 509 Weight: 210 Color: Hazel Identifications Number Slate _Cbu_ntry_ DRIVERS Minnesota LICENSE We Fictitious NO Comment Subject #21 IN REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - OLSON. Chris (MRO Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/23/2016 13:31 Page 1 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/117 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Subject-#2- - MENTION IN, REPORT #1 - Clark, Jamar Oneal - Continued Primary information - Continued Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 0510311 991 Juvenile: N0 Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identi?cations lD Type Number SE Country FBI lD 717111FD1 -.. OID 232941 Minnesota Minnesota State ID 9 Fictitious N0 NO NO Comment Primary Information Subject Name: HILL, MARI Christine Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, White, Female Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Employment Information Employed: YES Occupation: REPORTQM - Thjomps?ns'WeSIey William - Primary Information Subject Name: Thompson, Wesley William Record Type: Person Bio: 36 yr. old White, Male Birth Juvenile: NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - OLSON. Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/23/2016 13:31 Page 2 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/117 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Subject?#4 - MENTION IN REPORT #3 Thompson, Wesley William 5 Continued Personal Information Ethnicity: American Perzel, Tracy (Criminal Chief I US Attorney's Of?ce) KANE, Kevin (Special Agent/ FBI) Vogel, Matt (Special Agentl FBI) Berkower, Risa (Attorney 1 U.S. Department of Justice) Height: 508 Weight: 220 Color: Blue Identifications ID Type Number County As Of Date Fictitious Comment DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE Subject #5 #4 - TrUllinger, Micha'eI'JOhn 7 Primary Information Subject Name: Trullinger, Michael John Record Type: Person Bio: 50 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 511 Weight: 220 Color: Brown Identifications __\ip_lD 9 Number .StLte mm we DRIVERS Minnesota NO LICENSE Officers . Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: 03/22/2016 17:16 Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 03/23/2016 13:19 OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - OLSON. Chris (MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/23/2016 13:31 Page 3 of 6 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/117 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) a Date Supervisor . Date" OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/23/2016 Narrative begins ?onthe follOwing page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - OLSON. Chris (MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/23/2016 13:31 Page 4 of 6 On Thursday, December 10, 2015, at about 1315 hours, Olson and Phil] attended a second interview with paramedic Tyler John Lupkes (see previous BCA supplemental 82). The interview was not audio recorded at the request of the FBI. The following is a more detailed summary of the interview. Present during the interview were FBI Vogel and Kane, Assistant US. Attorney Criminal Chief Tracy Perzel, and U.S. Department of Justice Attorney Risa Berkower. The interview concluded at about 1400 hours. Lupkes stated he started his normal work shift for Hennepin County Medical Center (HCMC) Ambulance at 1700 hours on November 14, 2015. This particular shift normally ended at 0300 hours. Lupkes reported the start of his shift was unremarkable and his assigned partner was Mari Hill. Lupkes indicated he monitored ambulance 419 (Paramedic Wes Thompson) calling for police assistance Code 3 (expedited response). He noted Thompson?s radio transmissions were unusual and described them as hushed and rapid. Lupkes reported he could tell Thompson was in distress. Lupkes indicated he monitored Deputy Chief Trullinger arrive to assist unit 419. He reported he and Hill were dispatched to the scene. Lupkes reported he monitored ?shots ?red? and he responded Code 3. He observed on his Computer Aided Dispatch (CAD) the call he was reSponding to was an of?cer involved shooting. At the time this was occurring he was unsure whether the patient was an of?cer or a civilian. He reported he arrived within minutes and had dif?culty locating the patient due to the large crowd (approximately 100 150 people), but eventually was directed to the scene with the assistance of Trullinger. The patient, later identi?ed as Jamar Clark, was on the ground with his arms at his side. Clark was not handcuffed. There was a significant amount of blood on Clark?s face. Lupkes was told Clark had a gunshot wound to his head. Trullinger told Lupkes and Hill that Clark had a weak pulse. Lupkes reported he retrieved the stretcher from the ambulance. Unit 419 left the scene with the ?rst patient. Due to the large and hostile crowd gathering Lupkes indicated that he and Hill planned to load Clark quickly and find a safe location for treatment and stabilization of Clark?s injury. After retrieving the stretcher Lupkes observed Trullinger and Hill providing treatment to Clark. One of the medics requested a police of?cer pat down Clark for weapons with none being found. Lupkes reported he and Trullinger rolled Clark onto his left side in order to place him onto a pole and canvass stretcher. Clark was later transferred to a wheeled stretcher. Lupkes reported he saw a set of hinged handcuffs in the grass. He recalled the handcuffs were closed and using his left hand he moved the handcuffs out of the way. After Clark was loaded into the ambulance he got into the driver seat while Hill and Trullinger stayed in back with Clark. There was a police of?cer in the rear of the ambulance, but this was not the same of?cer that patted down Clark for weapons. Lupkes indicated he drove a short distance away and stopped to set up an automated CPR device on Clark. After the CPR device was initiated he indicated he drove to HCMC. He reported he was not able to hear or monitor any discussions from the back of the ambulance while he was driving. Lupkes said after he pulled the ambulance into HCMC they delivered Clark to the Stabilization Room. Hill provided patient information to the ER doctors. Lupkes reported having no further contact with Clark after he was delivered to HCMC. He reported he later provided a statement to MPD investigators. He reported he and Hill were instructed not to clean up the ambulance by MPD. Lupkes stated he assumed Clark was the person interfering with Unit 419 which lead to the call to police, but said that no one speci?cally told him that. Lupkes said he was not acquainted with the of?cers involved in the shooting. He said he did not know Clark. Lupkes indicated he had not spoken with other of?cers about the shooting since his initial statement to MPD investigators. End report. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension A CISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/1 18 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Warning - Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary Information Description: Interview of PD Officer Conner Occurrence From: 03122i2016 20:00 Occurrence To: 03i2212016 21 :30 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: Donarski, Carolyn (1382 1 Internet Crimes Against Children I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03124i2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 i MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On March 22nd 2016, SAS Phili and Donarski interviewed Ofc Conner at 4th Pct. The interview was about Conner's observations on Nov 15th 2015 when Jamar Clark was shot. Evidence item (CD of Ofc Conner's interview) acquired with this report. Address #1 - Occurred #1 - 1925 PLYMOUTH AVE. Primary Information Address: 1925 PLYMOUTH AVE Minneapolis Police Department, 4th Precinct, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55411 United States Subjects Relationship Name Bi_o DOB BUSINESS LOCATION DELLWO, Paul Douglas (Law Enforcement Official) 44 yr. old, White, Male BUSINESS LOCATION Ledman, Daniel Peter (Law Enforcement Official) 35 yr. old, White, Male BUSINESS LOCATION SMITH, Chris John (Law Enforcement Official) 37 yr. old, White, Male Address #2 - RELATED #1 - 16111PLYMOUTH AVE Primary information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationship Name 0 03 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: .. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/118 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Continued Primary Information - Continued Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name 3 EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 - Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) Property #1 - CD Containing Audio of Ofc Conner's Interview Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of Ofc Conner's Interview Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I118.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 03I22I2016 21 :30 Officers Conner, Chad (Officer! Minneapolis Police Department) Sworski, Jeffrey (Officeri Minneapolis Police Department) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/118 Report Date: 03/22/2016 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/22/2016 21 :29 Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide/ Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/24/2016 20:41 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) Reporting LEO - Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/25/2016 Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 3 of 4 On Wednesday, March 22nd 2016, SAs Phil] and Donarski interviewed Minneapolis Police Of?cer (MPD) Chad Conner at NIPD Precinct 4. Of?cer (Ofc) Conner and his partner Ofc Sworski was the ?rst responding unit (#425) to assist Ofcs Schwarze and Ringgenberg after Jamar Clark was shot on November 2015. The interview was digitally recorded and burned onto CD. The CD was labeled evidence item 118.1. The interview audio was transcribed and that document has been attached to this report. The following is a brief summary of the interview. For a full account of the interview, please refer to the attached transcript. Ofc Conner said he and Sworski responded Code 3 from about Lyndale Av north of Plymouth AV. They arrived and saw one or two squad cars and a couple of?cers standing over a man lying on the sidewalk. 3 Ofc Conner said the man was lying still on his back and appeared to have a gunshot Wound to his head. The man was a younger black male. Ofc Conner said he did not see the male?s hands but that he did not look to have handcuffs on him. He believes he would have noticed if the man was cuffed. Ofc Conner knew that his partner left the scene with the two Of?cers involved in the shooting but he doesn?t know what was said or what happened between them. His partner later returned to the scene where they assisted with crowd control. They also tried to assist in retrieving video from the Elks Club. Later on, after the body was removed, the scene was pretty much done as far as he and his partner?s involvement. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: March 22, 2016 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW 0F: Officer Chad Conner (CC) INTERVIEWED BY: SA Michael Phill (MP) SA Carrie Donarski (CD) REVIEWED BY: MP It is presently 0836 hours on March 22nd, 2016. Special Agent Michael Phill along with Special Agent Carrie Donarski at the Minneapolis 4th Precinct to interview Officer, Minneapolis Police Officer Chad Conner. Conner is This is for BCA case number 2015-648. Chad can you go ahead and tell me your uh middle name please? CC Middle name is Michael. MP Alright and your date of birthOkay. Um you are a currently a night watch officer with the Minneapolis Police Department? CC Yes sir. MP How long have you been working? CC About nine years. MP Nine years. Uh your night watch shift goes from when to when? CC 8:15 pm to 6:15 am MP Okay. And the address of this precinct is what? CC It?s 1925 Plymouth Avenue North. MP You happen to know the zip? CC I do not. MP Oh don?t worry about it. Is there a desk phone number here? CC There is but I don?t know that. MP Do you have a voicemail? CC Uh, I don?t think so. MP Like a (inaudible) I can look up the Minneapolis number. CC Okay. MP Not a big deal. So you?ve been working night watch which for you starts at 8:00 um bringing you back to November 15?1 of last year you were partnered with Officer Sworski? CC Yes sir. Phill-2015-648-A20 Page 1 of 5 Phill-2015-648-A20 What?s his first name? Jeff. Jeff Sworski. And on that night he was driving? I don?t e, I don?t remember. Don?t remember? Okay. Uh cuz I remember there was squad video and I know he was driving at some portion but for the call l'm not sure. 80 on November 15?? you heard a uh officer needs help call? Yes sir. At a little bit after midnight. Can you tell me where you responded from and what did you see, what did you guys do when you got there? Um I can't remember exactly where we responded from but I think it was somewhere around Lyndale and north of Plymouth. Um?hm. And um we heard the help call and we went code 3 to location. Uh which was Plymouth and Knox area. Um when, when we got there um I saw uh this, a squad car with its lights on. I'm pretty sure it was just one maybe two squad cars. There was an ambulance and then there was a, um uh not an ambulance but it was like a supervisor rig. Um-hm. That was there as well. And then uh overhead lights were on so it was you know a lotta blinking lights. There was um, a couple officers standing around near the sidewalk just to the north ofthe ambulance. And then there was a, a man that was down on the sidewalk on the other sidewalk. Um and then uh there was people that were yelling across the street at the Elks and there was people that were yelling and screaming like closing in on us from the apartment buildings uh to the south of us. Um?hm. So the man on, on the ground can you describe him for me? Um, I thought he had a gunshot wound to the head. From what I could tell. Um he was on his back and um, he was black male, younger male. Okay. Do you remember as he was laying on his back did you see if his hands were cuffed at all? I didn?t, remember seeing his hands. But I did not see, see handcuffs, I didn't see him in handcuffs. Okay. Did you see if anybody was working on him medically? There was a paramedic for sure there was one paramedic that I saw that was near him. Um I couldn?t describe what they were doing but they were standing right next to him. Okay. So the paramedic was working on him. The officers who you we assume had dealt with him, who were they, where were they standing? Uh they, they were pretty much standing you know within a few feet of where uh where the body was. Um just they were it seemed like they were frozen. One of ?em had their gun out or both of ?em uh I don't know but I remember seeing one of ?em with their gun. Um?hm. And theyjust seemed kind of frozen like they were um not, not reacting. Um?hm. Well could you tell something had happened there, pretty serious? Page 2 of 5 Phill?2015-648?A20 Yes and then uh my partner actually asked ?em uh was this an officer involved. And I heard one of ?em say yes. Um, Okay. So at that point i, I went and got some tape. Some crime scene tape and I started taping off the northern uh side of Plymouth by the Elks. And dealing with crowd control. Okay that was my next question. So a crowd started to gather, when you saw a crowd was already there you said they were on the north side and also pretty close on the, apartments. And did you see that as kind of where you needed to put your attention? Yes. Okay. Yep. Um so you were dealing with the crowd. As far as you know Sworski, your partner was talking to the other officers? You know I, honestly I have no idea what he did at the time. Um-hm. Uh ljust kinda went and did my thing. Okay. Later on someone had told me that he took the guys, away from the scene back to (inaudible) Okay, you were dealing with the crowd so you didn?t see anything like that? Yeah You found that out laterall when the HCMC rig came to pick up, the guy on the ground, Clark? Yes. Uh what did you observe there? Um, I can?t remember if they like loaded him on a stretcher orthey put him in a, a bag. Uh but I, ljust remember them loading him up into the back of an ambulance. Okay. Um and then you did notjump into the uh rig. Did you see another officerjump in the rig? Not by name butjust somebody in uniform? I don?t remember. Don?t remember that? Okay. I want to back up to where you said you saw uh the man on the ground, Clark had a gunshot to the head. Kinda describe what you saw to make you think that. It, uh itjust, you know he had what looked like a, a hole on his forehead. Um?hm. Or near his forehead. Okay. And there was blood on his, on his head. Okay. Page 3 of 5 CC And he wasn?t moving. MP Alright. And when you saw the paramedic supervisor guy, whoever working on him was he working on that wound, or was he working on you know giving, chest compressions? Do you remember kind of what he was doing? CC At the point it?s, it?s almost like he was just kind of observing. Uh he wasn?t doing anything i, I don?t remember him doing any medical but I, ljust like I mean I didn?t stare at it you know i just kinda saw him and MP Yeah CC on to whatever else i was doing. MP What you had to do. Um okay so you had him laying on his back. Did you see anybody roll him over? CC No. MP Okay. Uh did you see any handcuffs at all? See anything shiny looked like handcuffs? CO No. MP Okay. Um, when you said also that when they loaded him up you couldn?t see at that point if he was cuffed, you couldn?t see a hand you just saw cuz he was a distance from you at that point? CC Right we were sitting on like the western perimeter basically on the, in a squad car and 1 saw him being loaded up so I, I couldn?t get a good look at him. MP Okay. Um did Sworski come back to the scene? CC Yes. MP Okay. At which time you guys could hook back up CC Yes. MP (inaudible) do what you?re gonna do and then you dealt with crowd control until relieved? Or did you stay out there the rest of the night? CC Yep um we did some well we did crowd control and the crowd kind of (inaudible) they slowly left but then we did um worked on helping secure the Elks Club to get the video from the Elks Club. MP Um-hm. CC I was down in there. And then yeah we, i can?t remember what time it was then but once, once the um the body was taken away the scene was pretty much uh, done. MP Okay. And then I think a couple days later you learned that you know your hat may have come in contact CC Yes. MP pistol so then we had to take a DNA swab from you. Uh but we didn?t take a statement from you, at that time. Is that correct? CC That?s correct. MP Okay. is there anything you can think of that may be relevant to this that we didn?t cover? CC No. MP Okay. (pause) Phill?2015-648?A20 Page 4 of 5 CD (inaudible) MP The position he was in was on his back. Right? CC Yes. MP And his hands were? CC Well I couldn?t see his hands. MP Couldn't see them? CC I don?t remember seeing 'em. I don?t, yeah ljust I don?t remember seeing handcuffs. I don?t remember seeing his hands. I think i would have recognized if I saw him in handcuffs I would have noticed it but I, I didn?t notice that. MP Okay. And you didn?t see any officers removing handcuffs either? CC No. MP Okay. Alright. l?m gonna terminate the interview, it is END OF RECORDING. Phill-2015-648?A20 Page 5 of 5 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/119 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information Description: interview wand Acquisition of Cell Phone Video Occurrence From: 03l23l2016 19:00 Occurrence To: 03l23l2016 20:00 Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Backup LEO: OLSON, Chris (MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03l2412016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (1326 MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis . . . 0 On March 23rd 2016, SAs Phill and Olson interview?t her apartment. Evidence items 119.1 (CD of Cell Phone Video) and 119.2 (CD OMCHO Statement) acquired as evidence. Address #1 - RELATED #1 - 1611. PLYMOUTH AVE Primary Information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subjects Relationshis Name B_io_ DOB Primary Information Subject Name: Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: - Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 505 Weight: 230 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Employment Information EmployedMINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page ?1 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/119 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Continued Employment Information - Continued Occupation: Date Employed: Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS Telephones E?Addresses Relationship NumberlE?Address CELLULAR PHONE Identifications ID Type Number State County As Of Date Em DRIVERS Minnesota United States 3l23l2016 NO LICENSE Subject #2 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name B_i0 LLE EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) subject #3 - SUBJECT a Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subjects Relationship Name _B_ig EMPLOYER Minneapolis Police Dept (Agency) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385 MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 2 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/119 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Subject #4 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03l1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Identifications ?lm Slate. Em its?WEE Elam gm FBI ID 717111FD1 NO OID 232941 Minnesota NO State 10 9 Minnesota NO subject #5 - PARENT #1 - ,BroyvngiAEnton Jermaine - Primary Information Subject Name: Brown, Anton Jermaine Record Type: Person Bio: 44 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 600 Weight: 175 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Addresses Relationship Address HOME ADDRESS 4901 SHERIDAN AVE N, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55430 United States MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 3 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/119 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Subject #5 - PARENT #1 - Brown, Anton Jermaine - Continued Telephones E?Addresses Relationship CELLULAR PHONE NumberIE?Address Identifications ID Type Number State Country DRIVERS Minnesota United States 3/23/2016 LICENSE Aim Fictitious NO Revoked Property #1 DVD one" Phone Video Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: DVD of~0ell Phone Video Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I119.1 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BCA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 0312312016 21:12 Primary Information Property Class: Evidence Property Type: CD, DVD, DISC, TAPE Description: CD Containing Audio of Interview witt-. Quantity: 1 Control Number: 2015-648I119.2 UCRDamaged: NO Submitted To PES: Property Evidence Remote Bin: BOA-HQ Disposition: SUBMITTED TO PROPERTY AND EVIDENCE Collected Date/Time: 03/23/2016 21 :12 Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: 03/231201 6 21 :12 03/24/2016 20:47 Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 4 of 7 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/119 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Reporting LEO Apprehension) Apprehension) Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide/ Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/25/2016 Narrative begins on MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill. Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 5 of 7 On Wednesday, March 23rd 2016, Special Agents (SA) Phill and Olson interviewed-in her apartment in told a canvassing Minneapolis Police Of?cer on Nov 15th 2015, that she saw Jamar Clark handcuffed before he was shot by Minneapolis Of?cers. She then said one of the of?cers took the cuffs off before more people arrived. SAs Phill and Olson interviewed-to get her recorded statement about the incident. The interview occurred in her?apartment it was burned onto a CD and labeled ACISS evidence item 119.2. also provided a video of the aftermath of the shooting in front of 1 Plymouth Av that shows some of the Police and medical response. llowed SAs Phill and Olson to view the video and attempt to retrieve 1t. Due to the video being over 3 minutes long, SA Phill had to copy it directly from phone the following day with permission at her workplace. A DVD of the video was labeled ACISS evidence item 119.1 in this case. The interview with was transcribed and that document has been attached to this case. The following is only a summary of the interview. For a complete account, please refer to the transcription. gsaid that on Nov 15th of last year, she was at her friend, Corrina?s house or a child?s birthday party. Late at night, saw police lights outside Corrina?s window which faces Plymouth Avenue and the Elks Club across the street. She said she saw a guy sitting on the curb handcuffed with his hands behind his back. His feet were on the street and he was facing away from her towards the Elks Club. said one of the of?cers was yelling at the handcuffed male and then she heard a ?pop? sound accompanied by a ?ash. Then she saw the male (later identi?ed as Jamar Clark) laying on the ground and an of?cer standing over him. -never saw the cuffs but assumed because of Clark?s position with his hands behind his back, that he was cuffed. After the popping sound, she saw an of?cer appear to take handcuffs off of Clark. said that believed that Clark?s girl got into a ?ght at someone in the Elks Club. She claimed that she heard the female in the ambulance that she thought was Clark?s girlfriend telling the police to let him go because he was trying to help her. She said the of?cers were telling Clark to shut up and be quiet and sit there. aid she heard Clark saying ?go help my girl, I?m trying to help my girl.? She also said that the ambulance had only one door shut, the other rear door was open and that was why she could see partially inside and why she could hear the woman inside yelling at the police. said that they shut the door after Clark was shot but she could hear the woman inside screaming. She said she would never forget hearing that screaming. also said the thought the entire police contact with Clark lasted 10?15 minutes before he was shot. larified that the shorter of?cer handcuffed Clark and the taller one shot him and later un?handcuffed him. She also said that she recorded much of the incident in Video on her cell phone. later showed the video to SAs Phill and Olson and gave permission to them to retrieve it. SA Phill noted that the file was too large to text as an attachment or to email. SA Phill made plans to meet-the following day to get the video off the phone with her permission. MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION TRANSCRIPT INTERVIEW DATE: March 23, 2016 BCA CASE 2015-648 OFFENSE: EXHIBIT INTERVIEW OF: INTERVIEWED BY: SA Christopher Olson (CO) Anton Germaine Brown (AB) SA Michael Phill (MP) REVIEWED BY: ALSO PRESENT Anton Brown (AB) CO Today?s date is 3-23-2016. This statement is in reference to BCA case number 2015-648. The time right now is 1825 hours. We are currently at? - inaudible) CO hawk the zip code here? . . CO ind you?re uh apartment number is.is that right? Um-hm. CO ~Present during this interview ismiddle name?right?~ CO ?uh last name~Your birthday is.of . Yep- co Okay.of -And your cell phone uh~s uhms that right? (no audible response) CO And also present uh in the room here today in apartment-s, is this yourfather is that right? . Um-hm. co Anton Germaine Brown, Brown uh date of birth.of Uh 4901 Sheridan Avenue North, Minneapolis 55428. Anton do you have a cell phone number? AB - CO Okay. AB .- CO Okay. CO . alright. Would you mind if I just set this here, is that alright? . Um-hm. CO Also present for this interview is Special Agent Mike Phill. So I apologize for the delay in getting to you-um you were uh we want to talk to you specifically about the event that Olson-2015?648-A11 Page 1 of 13 .0 o. . o.o.o.o.o.o 0 oCo.o?0.0IoIo .0 Olson-2015-648-A1?l occurred at 1600 block of Plymouth Avenue on uh the early morning hours of November Uh, you were at a friends house? Yep it was a birthday party. Okay. Who?s house was that? Corrina Harris. Okay. How do you spell Corrina? Hans? Um-hm. You don?t happen to know the address you were at do you? (no audible response) Okay. And uh was it her birthday or someone else?s? Her daughters. Okay. And, I don?t want to put words in your mouth so just tell me about that event or what happened that night and what you saw. All I know is we seen the police lights outside so we went and we looked. When we looked out the window there was a guy on the ground and there was two officers and the paramedics. And the officer was, one of the officers was yelling at the dude on the ground and he was handcuffed. And then next thing I know I hear a pop, we see the flash I'm standing by the fridgeratorl look the dude that was sitting on the ground handcuffed was now laying on the ground, still handcuffed and the officer was standing over him with his gun. And that?s all I saw. Okay. So, what side ofthe street is that on? I know where the Elks Club is. The Elks is on that side. She is directly in front of the Elks like if you look out her front door I see the front door of the Elks. Okay. Is she in that apartment building that three Townhouse. Oh she?s in one of the townhouses right next to the apartment? Um-hm. She lives two doors down from his dad or his mom. Okay. Two doors towards like uh the precinct or two doors towards the river? Two doors towards the precinct. Okay so to the west, two doors to the west. Um-hm. And, so were you at is Corrina, is that what you said? Um-hm. Were you at Corrina?s house most of the night? I was there for like three days. Okay. Um, and so did you happen to and I want to go back a little bit. When you first noticed the subject on the ground and do you know this person?s name now as talk to you? Um-hm. Page 2 of 13 CO CO CO 0 8?0.o?o?o ?o.o.o .0. {f '0 CO Olson-2015-648-A11 Uh Mr. Clark so we?ll refer to him in the rest of the statement as uh Jamar Clark. When you first saw Clark on the ground uh (inaudible) describe his position. He was sitting what it looked like to me on the curb where maybe his feet crossed I seen him from the back. All I seen was his hands like this. Okay. Folded like this behind his back sitting on the curb. And then it?d be like you standing up in front of me he has two officers standing directly in front of him. So were they on the pavement? Were they They were standing on the, on the street and he was sitting on the curb beside the street. Okay and so he was sitting on his butt you think his feet were on the pavement and his butt was maybe on the grass? Um-hm. So the (inaudible) He was sitting right beside the tree that they had his memorial service at. Okay. So he was sitting like if he reached his arm out he would touch it. Alright uh what distance were you away? Approximately. was in her house looking out herfront window. Okay. So out her front window I can see everything from the beginning ofthe block to the end of the block, picture perfectly. Was there anybody standing with you or were you by yourself? it was me and my sister. Your sister? Well I?m sorry Coco, I call her my sister she?s my best friend. Okay so Coco is her nickname Um-hm. Um-hm. And so she was standing there as well. She was interviewed that night by the police and didn't want to say anything is that right? No she was interviewed too. That's why I?m like I don?t understand why you guys came to me. And we did it to, like we told the same story to the detectives and they made us both give a, our name and numbers. Did they record it? No he just asked us questions. They?re a different branch of the police? Okay. Oh okay. Page 3 of 13 .000 to 1 CO 0 Olson?2015?648-A1 1 So and I?m gonna get into a few more details uh so he?s sitting on the ground did you see handcuffs on him or did it uh was his position such that it was it looked like he was in handcuffs? Or did you actually see handcuffs? He I know he was, when he fell over his arms were still like this. Uh-huh. And he was laying on his side and then when they rolled him over (inaudible) like his body went like that so it wasn?t like he could reach forward cuz any person would be like if they were arguing, doing hand gestures. Okay. And they were arguing and he wasn?t so I assumed he was handcuffed. So for the benefit ofthe listener here uh you're uh demonstrating to Agent Phill and your hands are behind your back. The specific question and if you don?t know the answer it?s, just important that you just be as truthful as you can but I don?t want you saying things that you didn?t see. Did you see handcuffs on him? No Did you see metal? assumed he was Okay. he was sitting on the curb like this. When he rolled over I seen the officer uncuff him. I seen that part for myself. Okay. Once the second paramedics came then they uncuffed him. But while he was sitting on that curb he was cuffed. When he got shot he was cuffed. Okay. That I know for a fact. Okay. And that was what the issue was when all of, north side precinct pulled up in front of her house like why do you shoot a innocent man. I mean maybe he wasn?t innocent I don?t know what happened. But he was handcuffed. So he couldn?t bring you in harm. Maybe he coulda spit at you but he couldn't have hit you or reached for your gun or reached for your taser. He was unarmed. So you?re describing uh through the window watching this event unfold. When you first saw him there was an ambulance or 1 sh, I shouldn't assume that. Was there an ambulance? There was a ambulance. Okay. There was a ambulance, two officers, him and then his girlfriend was in the ambulance. Okay. And did you see her get transported to the ambulance? seen, when it first, I seen it all but it was like broken down cuz one minute seen the police out there with just them and then they called the first paramedics and then they came for her. And then the police officer and Jamar had their incident. And then another like two minutes later or maybe three minutes later another paramedic pulled up. But then they pulled off. Page 4 of 13 0.0. etc Olson?2015-648?A11 So when, when we describe the incident was there uh did you see uh Jamar Clark get shot? Did you see that? You saw you No I saw the, the spark cuz we were in the kitchen cleaning up from the party. Okay. And her window was open so when the gunshot went off you could see the light of it. And then that?s when we looked out the window and I?m like oh my God he just shot him. Okay And then lfreaked out. you think you were seeing is what we normally refer to as a muzzle flashgun that?s what you thought that flash was. Hm. And then you heard it i heard it and i saw, Okay. So were you watching just before that happened? Were you watching uh, uh the event? Or you were in the kitchen? We were in the kitchen it was like back and forth. Okay. We could see the light so i mean we were just looking out And the kitchen in on, the kitchen is Facing, the Elks. Okay (inaudible) So out the front window you could see the curb and then you could see the Elks. Okay. And could you see Jamar Clark or the officers from the kitchen? Yes. Okay. Alright and the window was open so you could hear things fairly clearly? Um-hm. Alright. And who else besides you and Coco were at that time? It was, there was a lot of us actually cuz it was a birthday party that was still going on. Okay. The exact names, I don?t know like government names I know nicknames and stuff like that. Well start, well start with that. Um Drey maybe, Jessica. Kaz, Kaz with a Yeah. Um, most of these people are her family Okay Coco's family? don't really know all a her family like that. ljust, was there for the party. Do you got a cell phone for Coco? I can call her and ask her is it okay if I give it to you. Page 5 01?13 0.0.o'o.wowo Olson-2015?648?A?l 1 Yeah that would be fabulous. Uh don?t do it right now, we?ll do it at the conclusion ofthis so we?ll finish this up first. Um-hm. Um, and then l?m assuming, [just want to understand this as clearly as I can. So you initially saw him on the curb talking to police. And then did you go back to the kitchen? After that. Yeah i was just standing there looking being nosy out the window. And I?m like, Were the police talking to Jamar or was Jamar saying anything to the police? The police was talking like they weren?t talking they were yelling at him. And what I got from it was his girl had got into a fight with somebody in the club but they wasn?t trying to hear what he was saying they thought that he assaulted her. But that, they wasn?t hearing it but i was hearing what he was saying and I heard what his girl was saying. What was he saying? She was saying he?s, let him go he's innocent he?s trying to help me. And they?re like shut up, be quiet, sit there. And he was trying to explain to them what?s goin? on but the officers wasn?t listening. Who was she saying let him go to? The two officers that was standing outside the paramedics that was standing on the curb with him. Cuz the ambulance was pulled up right beside the curb like if you was to park off the curb. Damn how many times a day do you shit, boy? Damn. That?s like his like his fifth (inaudible) Alright just so you know, Anton this is gonna be on government, document it?s gonna be (inaudible) uh just trying to save us uh Hm to do. (laughs) Okay. 80 um so she, do you know her name right now as we speak to you the name of that The girls name? Yeah. No I don?t. Okay I don?t know them. Um so you heard her explicitly telling the, the uniformed police officers, he?s trying to help, leave him alone? Um?hm. And then what was he saying to the police officers? Page 6 of 13 8 .8.8.8 I CO CO 0 QOCOCO I I CO CO Olson-2015-648?A?l 1 He was just trying to say, go help my girl I?m trying to help my girl. That's all I kept hearing him say. Okay do you know uh which officer put him in handcuffs? I know it was the tall one. The tall one? Um?hm. And when you say you know that how do you know that? Because I seen him when he made him turn around and he forced him on the ground and handcuffed him. Okay. So they forced him on the ground. You saw them handcuff him. And how long did that process take? I don't know, maybe a minute or two. Okay. And was Mr. Clark struggling during that or did it look like to you that he just uh allowed that to happen or? It looked like to me that he was concerned about who was in the ambulance and was trying to get to them. And the officers wasn?t, allowing him to. So let me rephrase that. Uh did it look to you like he was resisting the handcuffs or that he uh just sort of acquiesced orjust kinda said okay? wouldn't say he was resisting I would say he was concerned about who was in the ambulance and he was trying to get to it. Okay and you could tell that by looking or by hearing? By looking and hearing. Okay. And what was the looking part? Describe to me, as well as you can what you were seeing. Just imagine someone trying to handcuff you and turn you this way when you?re trying to go this way. Okay so he was, it looked to you like he was trying to not be handcuffed? lguess. Okay. l?m just, just trying to be as accurate as I can I really I wouldn?t say resisting arrest. (inaudible) I wouldn?t use that. I would say, someone was blocking him to what he was concerned about and he was trying to get there versus listen to what they?re saying because they were wrong. Okay. I don?t know what exactly happened. 80 he continued, you think while they were on the ground he continued to try to get to the ambulance? Yeah. Okay. Alright. And you think that lasted approximately one minute? Page 7 of 13 0' .8I8. 0' o.o.o.o.o.Olson-2015-648-A1?l Or two, yeah. And did you watch that entire process or did you walk away at some point? It was bits and pieces cuz I really wasn't, involved with it but I could hear and see only because I was in the kitchen. Okay. And it was loud. I mean it wasn?t like they were talking. So uh when you were in the kitchen or at the window how many trips back and forth did you make? From the start of that event from, from the point they took him down. 1 think they was outside before he got shot for about ten or fifteen minutes. Okay. Alright. With the police? With the police yeah. Okay. Alright. Were there a lot of people outside? I wouldn't, I know his family was. There was people beside her house, outside watching. Be, before he was shot was there a lot of people out there? (inaudible) Yeah there was people from the Elks outside. There was people in the townhouses outside. Okay. There was people walking down the street. Okay. So yeah. And then after he was shot of course there was a lot of people. Right? The number of people increased right? The number of officers did too. Right. 80 at some point, at the moment he was shot do you remember who was standing outside? Or if anyone Like, there was people outside I Okay. don?t know who the people were. But there was people outside Where were they standing? There was some people standing right outside the Elks in front of the door. There was people standing in the driveway of the Elks. There was people outside. It was a club they was out there conversating I guess. And did Coco see the exact same thing you did? Um-hm. Okay. Alright. Uh who does she live there with? Her and her kids. Okay. Um, so and you don?t know the, the female person in that, the back of that ambulance right? You don?t know her, you've never met her? I don?t know either one of ?em. Okay. Page 8 of 13 .0 no .oIo'o. 0'0.0 .0. o. .0 Olson?201 5-648-A11 We never met or seen either one of them Okay. Alright. But you saw, did you see the ambulance arrive? Or, i saw no the ambulance was already there. Did you see how she got into the ambulance? They helped her in the ambulance. So you saw that? Um?hm. Okay. And was she on like a gurney or a chair or how did they help her in? They helped her like she was walking into it. I think she got, her head split or something by a bottle in the club. Or got into a fight with somebody in the club. And that?s why the paramedics was there. I don?t know that?sjust what I heard, after. Did you see an injury to her face or that?s what you heard or? i seen her as she was getting into the ambulance. i didn?t get to see her, her face. Okay. Any of that. So any injuries that you just talked about now probably would have been something you heard about as opposed to saw right? Right. Okay. And, they shut the ambulance door and did you see any kind They never shut it. The ambulance door stayed open? The ambulance door was open. 80 while Mr. Clark was outside the ambulance the door was open One door was closed and one of ?em was open. There?s two doors for the back. And I only remember that because you could see, straight into the ambulance. Alright. Do you remember that evening uh whether uh you were using uh, uh alcohol at all? (inaudible)? I don?t drink. Okay. And I?m assuming then by virtue that you don?t do controlled substances or things of that nature? No. Okay. And, have you reported this you said you reported this to the police? They, after it happened when everyone was outside, some officers I guess it was maybe deputy sheriff or somebody I don?t know from the precinct was knocking door to door and asking people for statements. Okay, alright. And see that at some point your name got written down. Yeah I was hoping that it didn?t but yeah. Page 9 of 13 CO CO a? . 03 Ef? Olson?2015?648-A1 1 Uh, and I see that it sounds to me like Coco wasn?t, didn?t want to give her name is that consistent with your memory? (no audible response) Yes? Um-hm. Okay. Since we?re on audio tape I need a yes or a no. Oh yes. Okay. And seeing as that she didn?t want to give you guys her name then whatever you do if you do contact her I don?t think that her name should be mentioned you know in that whole thing you know. We?re very uh cognizant of that issue and we?re, we?re we don't like to force people to do something they don?t want to do so, we?re aware of that and we appreciate that. You got anything else? When you said the doors were open on the ambulance let?s pretend like the TV is the ambulance. You?re talking about those two back doors? Um-hm. One of ?em was And one was closed. from your spot there you can kinda see inside a little bit of it? Um?hm. Okay. (inaudible) I want to say the one, further to the right. On the passenger side. Um-hm. Was open and the driver?s side was closed. Okay and that?s how you could hear Yeah. leave him alone that kinda stuff. Yeah but then once he got shot they closed the door. Okay. But you could still hear her scream like, I?ll never forget that, still in my head, yeah And then uh did, did the same officer that put in your estimation the same officer that put the handcuffs on is that the same officer that took the handcuffs off? No the shorter officer handcuffed him and the taller officer shot him. And he then he got little very quickly after he shot (inaudible), you sure because at first you said the tall guy turned him around. The tall guy did turn him around but the short guy was the one that put the cuffs on him. Okay. Yeah I wrote down earlier you said taller officer cuffed. Um-hm. Page 10 of13 0; go ?8 'o.o'oI.o .0 OE 0 Olson?2015-648-A1?l He was, the taller officer I know shot him. Okay. And if you?re not sure about something uh Yeah it No know months ago so Yeah I know the taller officer, was the one that shot him. The shorter one is the one And also the one that un?handcuffed him? Yeah. Okay. And then 1 don?t know what happened to them two officers. Cuz one minute they were there and then the next minute they were gone. Okay. What did happen immediately after this event what uh what, I know they drew their guns until other cars came and when other cars police cars came they left. You didn?t see them leave but you saw that they weren?t at the scene anymore? Right there was other, there was a once they called for backup, it was like fifty squad cars there in less than thirty seconds. 80 it was a lot of, police officers on foot and no I didn't see where they went after that but Do you remember (inaudible) have it on camera. You have what on camera? The incident. the actual shooting itself? have a, the ending part. I didn?t think he was gonna shoot him so I wasn?t recording it. But i have the after the, him laying on the ground. Okay After we?re done recording do you mind showing us that? Sure. Okay. So uh and then that you said the taller one took the handcuffs off. When the second ambulance came. And then do you remember what happened to those handcuffs? (no audible response) No? Okay do you remember ifthey were, what color they were? lfthey were silver I don?t but the only thing that bothered me the most was they didn?t even check him to see if he was dead or alive. They didn?t even try to help him. Okay. Page 11 of13 They were like oh well. And just drew their attention to the rest of the people outside pointing their guns. CO Okay. (pause) Thank you. CO CO CO 0 o'clol 0 Cole. loOol Olson?2015?648-A1 1 Have you uh the only police officer you?ve spoken to was the, the morning of this event? Um?hm Is that right? And that was a uniformed police officer or was that a plain clothes person? He was in, no actually he had on a suit. He had on a suit? Um-hm Okay. Uh, One had on a suit and one had a uniform it was two officers. Okay. And the one that had on the uniform was very rude. I don?t know who What did that person do that was rude? They just like with the situation and it happened he just, was like oh well just nonchalant about it. Okay. And do you remember the names of either one of those officers? And if you don?t, that?s fine. No I don?t. Okay did they uh leave a business card or anything? That you can recall. Not that I remember I don?t think so. Okay. And did they uh did you see them go uh which direction did they go? So if we?re standing in her door they went to the right so away from the precinct they were walking down Towards, okay away from the precinct. 'Uh and do you know if Coco had uh provided any information to any law enforcement? You?re pretty tight with her right? Yeah I asked her she said she didn?t. Okay. And asked her why they didn?t call you instead of me. And she didn?t know. She probably didn?t have, she didn?t have airesponse to that I?m guessing. She said that she don?t know why you guys didn?t call her. Yeah because uh tonight I think is the first time I?m getting her name so uh couple things we want to do is look at that video when we?re done here that you have. And then the second thing is we want to maybe reach out to Coco through you to see if she would have any interest in talking to us. Okay? Okay. PagelZ of13 CO Uh but in terms of, in terms of your memory of the events of that night is there anything else important that I haven't asked you? . (no audible response) CO Not that you can think of? Alright I?ll leave you a business card. AB (inaudible) CO You can feel free to re-oontaot me okay. . Okay. CO Alright we?re gonna end this statement now. The time is, 1848 hours. END OF RECORDING. Olson?2015?648-A?l 1 Page 13 of 13 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension A CISS Attachment 2015?648/120 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Primary Information Description: PD Report #63 Reporting LEO: Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03/24/2016 Approved By: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Record Origination Date: Last Update Operator: Last Update Date: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/24/2016 18:40 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/24/2016 18:41 Reporting LEO Date Supervisor Date Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO Homicide I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/25/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/25/2016 08:25 Page 1 of1 MPD CAPRS Case Report With Supplements - MP-15-4233 84 Page 72 of 117 Supplement number: 63 CCN: MP-15-423384 Author: 007851 -Aaron Womble Supplement of Off A.Womble #007851 on 11/15/2015 09:49 On 11/15/2015 1 was working squad 321 with my partner OFC MARTIN #4433. We were at city hall when an of?cer needs help call was aired at 1611 Plymouth Ave N. Remarks in the call stated there were shots ?red, one was down, and a large crowd was gathering. Upon arrival we posted near 1611 Plymouth Ave on the perimeter in order to help deal with the large crowds of people that were forming to secure the scene. While we were posted on the perimeter, Squad 505 directed us to knock on doors and see if anyone had seen the incident. . The resident of 1625 Plymouth Av N, approximately a 25 year old male who refused to give his name, stated he didn't see anything. The resident of 1623 Plymouth Av N, approximately a 20 year old female who refused to give her name refused to make a statement. The resident of 1621 Plymouth Av N, approximately a 25 year old female who refused to give her full name other than Lisa, stated she heard one shot. The resident of 1619 Plymouth Av approximately a 35 year old female refused to speak with officers._. I Phone-whom was also present at the address, stated she saw him sitting on the curb handcuffed with two of?cers, I Went back inside and about three minutes laterl heard one shot." The residents of 1617 Plymouth Av N, DOB?and" DOB: Phone: tated as outside when the incident occurred. i mother. old me, saw him with the ambulance, the of?cers came and handcuffed hlm, then started wrestling with him on the ground, then the of?cers shot not see anything but heard one shot. NAKAYLA SHARP, DOB: 1911 Plymouth AV Apt. #103, Phone: ho was also present at 1617 told me, "The guy who got shot was arguing with his girlfriend earlier in the day on the sidewalk. He was trying to talk to paramedics. It looked like the paramedics told him to walk away. He didn't move. The EMS showed up. After that the cops showed up and cuffed him, they threw him on the ground face ?rst and put a knee on his back. The police pulled their gun out and shot him in the back of the head." The residents of 1615 Plymouth AV N, multiple males in their 20's refused to give their names or any information. After we interviewed the residents we resumed our position on the perimeter until we were dismissed. END of Supplement 63 d?b7c.., 3/22/2016 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/121 Report Date: 03/23/2016 -Warning I Contains entities exempt from disclosure Description: Statement ofmo remain anonymous Reporting LEO: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03l26l2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (13261MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) .j'?Fstemly requested that her identity in this investigation not be released to the public. She also declined to be i volved in any court process. No evidence acquired with this report. Primary Information Address: 3500 THURSTON AVE, Anoka, Minnesota 55303 United States Primary Information Subject Name: Record Type: Person Bio: 28 yr. old, Black, Female Birth Date: _r Juvenile: NO Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 505 Weight: 230 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Employment Information Employed: YES Occupation: Date Employed: Addresses Relationship Address MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide 1 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/26/2016 15:52 Page 1 of4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/121 Report Date: 03/23/2016 Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Rank/Position: Juvenile: YES Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Law Enforcement Official 30 yr. old, White, Male - Officer 7 NO Dustin Timothy - . Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: Subject Name: Record Type: Bio: Birth Date: Rank/Position: Juvenile: YES Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Law Enforcement Official 29 yr. old, White, Male Officer NO #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05/03/1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) MINNESOTA BUREAU OF APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/26/2016 15:52 Page 2 of 4 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS In vestigative Supplement 2015-648/121 Report Date: 03/23/2016 ?EReco?igd-Staitus Information - Continued Record Origination Date: 03/26/2016 09:32 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide! Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 03/26/2016 14:55 Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide] Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicidel Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3/26/2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) page. .- MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/26/2016 15:52 Page 3 of 4 On Wednesday, March 231' 2016, Special Agents (SA) Phill and Olson interviewed~at her residence inp? was very reluctant to recount what she saw and eard in the early morning hours of Novemberl 5th 2015. SAs Phill and Olson were able to get permission fro to record her statement and to record the video she took after the shooting from her cell phone. Frepeatedly said that she did not trust the police or Black Lives atter and did not want to be involved in this case. Her father Anton Brown was present for the interview and did not express the same reservations. He said he believed tha should state what she saw and tell the truth. However, she maintained her desire not to be involved or identi?ed. 3 told SAs Phill and Olson that her friend CoCo also witnessed some of the shooting scene but did also did not want to be involved in the case. SA Phill made repeated attempts to interview CoCo unsuccessfully. Please refer to report #119 in this case documenting-statement. Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015?648/122 Report Date: 03/28/2016 Warning Contains entities exempt from disclosure Primary information Description: Acquisition of Metro Transit PD Report Reporting LEO: Phiil, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Approval Status: Approved Approved Date: 03129i2016 Approved By: Swanson, Gary (13261MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Synopsis On March 28th 2016, SA Phill received a report from Metro Transit PD from their response to the Jamar Clark OIS on Nov 15th of 2015. No video of their response is available as it is past their retention date. The report has been attached. No evidence acquired with this report. Address #1 - RELATED #1 _1 611 PLYMOUTH AVE Primary information Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE N, MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota 55411 Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Primary information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Ringgenberg, Mark Douglas Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 30 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: - Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO Subject #2 - SUBJECT #2 Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Primary Information Exempt From Disclosure: YES Subject Name: Schwarze, Dustin Timothy Record Type: Law Enforcement Official Bio: 29 yr. old, White, Male Birth Date: "i Rank/Position: Officer Juvenile: NO MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385i MRO - Homicide Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/29/2016 10:47 Page 1 of 3 Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension ACISS Investigative Supplement 2015-648/122 Report Date: 03/28/2016 Subject #3 - SUBJECT #3 - Clark, Jamar Oneal Primary Information Subject Name: Clark, Jamar Oneal Record Type: Person Bio: 24 yr. old, Black, Male Birth Date: 05I03I1991 Juvenile: NO Place Of Birth City: Minneapolis Place Of Birth State: Minnesota Personal Information Ethnicity: American Height: 508 Weight: 160 Color: Brown Hair Color: Black Hair Length: Long Hair Style: Dreadlocks Property #1 - - Primary Information Quantity: 1 Collected Date/Time: 00:00 Officers LEO SCHMITZ, TROY (LIEUTENAAN I METRO TRANSIT POLICE) Record Status Information Record Origination Operator: Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Record Origination Date: 03I29I2016 09:53 Last Update Operator: Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicide I Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) Last Update Date: 03129I2016 10:31 Reporting LEO I I Date gsuperVISOr - I: I "Date: 3 I Phill, Charles (1385 I MRO - Homicide I Swanson, Gary (1326 I MRO - Homicidel Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Minnesota Bureau of Criminal 3I29I2016 Apprehension) Apprehension) Narrative begins on the following page. MINNESOTA BUREAU OF CRIMINAL APPREHENSION - Phill, Charles (1385/ MRO - Homicide i Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension) 03/29/2016 10:47 Page 2 of 3 On Monday, March 28th 2016, Special Agent (SA) Phill contacted Lt Schmitz of Metro Transit Police (MTPD) Investigations. The contact was in reference to the November 15th 2015 of?cer involved shooting of Jamar Clark at 1611 Plymouth Av N. In reviewing a newly acquired video, a MTPD squad car was observed at the scene in the aftermath of the shooting. SA Phill requested Lt Schmitz check to see if any squads responding to 1611 Plymouth on an Of?cer needs Help call, had any video or reports for the case. Lt Schmitz provided a report showing that seven of?cers responded to the call that went out after of?cers Schwarze and Riggenberg called for help. However, no squad video was saved because it was now past their retention date. There had been no request to archive the video. SA Phill attached the MTPD report to this report. No evidence was acquired. Incident Report 15041531 - MN0274300 Page 1 of 4 ME TRO TRANSIT POLICE DEPARTMENT INCIDENT REPORT 15041531 IAGENCY MN0274300 IJUVENILE: '2 Reported: 11-15-2015 0050 First Assigned:0051 First Arrived:0055 Last Cleared:0111 Commited Start: 11-15-2015 0050 Commited End: 11-15-2015 0111 Title: Assist Other Agency How Received: Radio - Summary: Officers assisted MPD on a help/officer involved shoot. Location(s) Address: 1611 PLYMOUTH AVE APT City: MINNEAPOLIS State: MN Zip: 55411 Country: Custom Attributes Non Transit Property OTHER INCIDENT 3 Of?cer Assigned: Crosbie, Brandon Badge No: 72450 Primary: Yes .3 Of?cer Assigned: Wyatt, Geoffrey Badge No: 65055 Primary: No u. 0 Of?cer Assigned: Menter, James Badge No: 73245 Primary: No Of?cer Assigned: Erickson, Marcus Badge No: 6522 Primary: No Of?cer Assigned: DeGree, Chad Badge No: 73152 Primary: No Of?cer Assigned: Lawrence, Timothy Badge No: 72413 Primary: No Of?cer Assigned: Koller, Chad Badge No: 73398 Primary: No 8 MOC: 9903 Literal: Assist Other Agency - AOA Statute: UCR: 2 Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:50:50 AM User: Messer. Todd (Automated Entry) 0 Comment: Event Created by Todd Messer [messertw] Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:51:03 AM User: Messer, Todd (Automated Entry) Comment: Address Veri?ed in MSAG Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:51:50 AM User: System (Automated Entry) Comment: Agency Changed. CAD Event 006734 now 201541746 Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:51:50 AM User: Messer, Todd (Automated Entry) Comment: Status Status Changed From Pending To Assigned Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:51:50 AM User: Messer, Todd (Automated Entry) Comment: Unit 182 Is Now The Primary Unit Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:51:50 AM User: Bauman. Timothy Comment: Unit 182 Dispatch Date Time: 11-15?2015 12:51:54 AM User: Bauman. Timothy Comment: Unit 105 Dispatch Date Time: 11-1 5-2015 12:51:57 AM User: Bauman. Timothy Comment: Unit 116 Dispatch Date Time: 11-15-2015 12:52:19 AM User: Bauman, Timothy 3/29/2016 Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Incident Report 15041531 - MN0274300 Unit 182 En Route 11-15-2015 12:52:21 AM Unit 105 En Route 11-15?2015 12:52:23 AM Unit 116 En Route 11-1 5-2015 12:52:29 AM Unit 155 Dispatch 11-15-2015 12:52:37 AM User: Usen User: Usen Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy (Automated Entry) Event Type Set to ASSIST OTHER AGENCY 11?1 5-2015 12:52:37 AM Priority Set to 2 11-1 5-2015 12:52:42 AM Unit 115 Dispatch 11-15?2015 12:52:47 AM Unit 115 En Route 11-1 5-2015 12:52:49 AM Unit 155 En Route 11-1 5-2015 12:55:46 AM Auto alarm set for 115 Date Time: 11-15?2015 12:55:46 AM Comment: Unit 115 On Scene Date Time: 11-15?2015 12:56:05 AM Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Auto alarm set for 105 11-15?2015 12:56:05 AM Unit 105 On Scene 11-15?2015 12:56:08 AM Auto alarm set for 182 11-15?2015 12:56:08 AM Unit 182 On Scene 11-15-201512:57:54 AM 11-15-2015 12:59:34 AM Auto alarm set for 116 Unit 116 On Scene 11-15-20151:08:08 AM 11-1 5-2015 1:08:08 AM Unit 115 Cleared AM Unit 155 Cleared 11-15-2015 1:08:27 AM Date Time: 11-15-2015 1:08:27 AM Comment: Unit 116 Cleared 11?1 5-2015 12:59:34 AM User: User: User: User: User: User: Usen User: User: User: User: MPD Help call shots ?red 1 down User: Usen Usen Clearing unit alarm because of status change: 115 Usen Usen Usen Clearing unit alarm because of status change: 116 Usen Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy Messer, Todd System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy Bauman, Timothy System (Automated Entry) Bauman, Timothy Page 2 of 4 3/29/2016 Incident Report 15041531 - MN0274300 Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: Date Time: Comment: 11-15-2015 1:11:29 AM User: System (Automated Entry) Clearing unit alarm because of status change: 182 11-15-20151211229 AM Unit 182 Cleared 11-15-2015 1:1 1 :37 AM User: System (Automated Entry) Unit 105 is holding for event 201541746 11-15-2015 1:11:37 AM User: Bauman, Timothy (Automated Entry) Status Status Changed From Assigned To Hold for Unit 11-15-2015 1:11:37 AM User: System (Automated Entry) Clearing unit alarm because of status change: 105 11-15-20151:11:37 AM Unit 105 Cleared 11-15-20151:12:04 AM Disposition Set to Assist AM Event Closed. User: Bauman, Timothy User: Bauman, Timothy User: Bauman, Timothy (Automated Entry) User: Bauman, Timothy (Automated Entry) Page 3 of 4 MOBILE Dispatch (72450) Crosbie Brandon 11-15-2015 0052 Dispatch (65055) Wyatt, Geoffrey 11?15?2015 0052 Dispatch (73245) Menter James 11?15-2015 0052 Enroute (72450) Crosbie Brandon 11?15-2015 0052 Enroute (65055) Wyatt Geoffrey 11?1 5-2015 0052 Enroute (73245) Menter, James 11-15-2015 0052 Dispatch (6522) Erickson Marcus 11-15-2015 0052 Dispatch (73152) DeGree Chad 11?15-2015 0052 Dispatch (72413) Lawrence Timothy 11-15-2015 0052 Dispatch (73398) Koller, Chad 11-15-2015 0052 Enroute (72413) Lawrence, Timothy 11?15-2015 0052 Enroute (73398) Koller, Chad 11-15-2015 0052 Enroute (6522) Erickson Marcus 11-15-2015 0052 Enroute (73152) DeGree . Chad 11-15-2015 0052 OnEvent (72413) Lawrence . Timothy 11-15?2015 0055 Arrived (72413) Lawrence Timothy 11-15-2015 0055 OnEvent (73398) Koller Chad 11-15-2015 0055 Arrived (73398) Koller, Chad 11-15-2015 0055 OnEvent (65055) Wyatt, Geoffrey 11-15-2015 0056 Arrived (65055) Wyatt, Geoffrey 11-15-2015 0056 OnEvent (72450) Crosbie Brandon 11-15-2015 0056 Arrived (72450) Crosbie, Brandon 11-15-2015 0056 OnEvent (73245) Menter, James 11-15-2015 0059 Arrived (73245) Menter James 11-15-2015 0059 Ofvaent (72413) Lawrence Timothy 11-15-2015 0108 Cleared (72413) Lawrence Timothy 11-15?2015 0108 Ofvaent (73398) Koller, Chad 11-15-2015 0108 Cleared (73398) Koller, Chad 11-15-2015 0108 Ofvaent (6522) Erickson, Marcus 11-15-2015 0108 Cleared (6522) Erickson Marcus 11-15-2015 0108 Ofvaent (73152) DeGree Chad 11-15-2015 0108 3/29/2016 Incident Report 15041531 - MN0274300 Page 4 of 4 Cleared (73152) DeGree Chad 11-15-2015 0108 Ofvaent (73245) Menter, James 11-15-2015 0108 Cleared (73245) Menter . James 11-15-2015 0108 Ofvaent (72450) Crosbie Brandon 11-15-2015 0111 Cleared (72450) Crosbie Brandon 11-15-2015 0111 Ofvaent (65055) Wyatt Geoffrey 11-15-2015 01 11 Cleared (65055) Wyatt Geoffrey 11-15-2015 0111 Report: MTPD Report Cad Comments Sent Via: Sent To: Email Conzi Bates Paralegal MCAO Contact Info: Reason: Date: 12-29-2015 Notes: Conzi Bates Paralegal Minneapolis City Attorney's Of?ce (612) 673-2685 DISSEMINATION 3/29/20 16