Dash Camera Analysis - Frame By Frame Midwest City Oklahoma Police - Shooting of Charles A. Pettit Jr. on October 5, 2015 ANALYSIS OF DASHCAM VIDEO GENERAL POINTS VIDEO SPEED: 30 FPS BEGINNING: TC 22:00 = FRAME 001 ANALYSIS: FRAMES 011 - 111 ANALYZED BY: GLORIA LEVARIO / INDEPENDENT VIDEO CONSULTANT PROCESS: 1. STILL FRAME EXTRACTION FROM VIDEO 2. INCREASED TO MAX RESOLUTION FOR PRINT PURPOSES (300 DPI) 3. ENLARGE DETAIL AREA 4. NO EDITS / ALTERING MADE TO EXTRACTED IMAGES TERMS: 1. PO = Police Officer Hill 2. CJ = Charles A. Pettit, Jr. 3. LH / RH = Left Hand / Right Hand 4. LA/ RA = Left Arm/ Right Arm 5. LL / RL = Left Leg / Right Leg DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 11 -INITIAL CONTACT -PO CONFRONTS CJ AT DUMPSTER DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 12 - CJ IS FACING AWAY FROM PO - BEGINS TO RUN AWAY DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 13 - CJ IS RUNNING AWAY - CJ LL BENT IN RUNNING MOTION - CJ LH UP IN DEFENSIVE POSITION SHIELDING HIS FACE / HEAD - PO'S LEGS SPREAD, BRACED IN SHOOTING STANCE, RA EXTENDED, POINTING GUN AT CJ'S BACK DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 14 - CJ CONTINUES TO RUN AWAY - PO STILL IN SHOOTING STANCE / LEGS SPREAD, GUN EXTENDED DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 15 - CJ CONTINUES TO RUN AWAY - CJ LH STILL UP OVER HIS HEAD / STILL IN DEFENSIVE MODE DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 16 - CJ BOTH FEET STILL IN FORWARD RUNNING MOTION, AWAY FROM PO - CJ LH STILL COVERING HEAD - CJ RH STILL HOLDING PANTS UP DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 17 - CJ CONTINUES RUNNING AWAY - OBJECT THAT LOOKS LIKE A GUN BECOMES VISIBLE IN BACK OF CJ WAISTBAND - PO'S ARM / GUN OUTSTRETCHED POINTING AT CJ'S BACK DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 18 - CJ STILL IN FORWARD MOTION, RETREATING FROM PO, BOTH FEET STILL FACING FORWARD - GUN APPARENT IN BACK OF CJ'S WAISTBAND (NOT DRAWN) - PO IN SHOOTING STANCE / WEAPON POINTED AT CJ - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST FROM PO'S WEAPON INTO CJ'S BACK (SHOT #1) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 19 - CJ IS PROPELLED FORWARD - POSITION CHANGES FROM STANDING UPRIGHT / STARTS TO FALL - LH STILL UP / RH STILL CLUTCHING FRONT OF WAISTBAND - GUN STILL PROTRUDING CLEARLY FROM BACK OF WAISTBAND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 20 - CJ'S BODY BEGINS TO FOLD FORWARD / MAINTAINS FORWARD MOMENTUM - BEGINS TO STUMBLE / DOWNWARD DESCENT - CJ LH REMAINS RAISED PROTECTING HIS HEAD - CJ RH REMAINS CLUTCHING FRONT OF WAISTBAND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 21 - CJ'S BODY CONTINUES TO STUMBLE FORWARD - PO STILL IN SHOOTING STANCE DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 22 - PO FIRES GUN AS CJ STUMBLES AWAY (SHOT - F22 - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (SMALL) - F23 - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (LARGE) #2) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 23 - PO FIRES GUN AS CJ STUMBLES AWAY (SHOT - F22 - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (SMALL) - F23 - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (LARGE) #2) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 24 - CJ LOSES CONTROL OF FOOTING / CONTINUES TO FALL AWAY FROM THE OFFICER - GUN PROTRUDING FROM BACK OF WAITSTBAND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 25 - CJ HAS LOST CONTROL OF HIS FOOTING / KNEES BUCKLED - CJ BODY GOES LIMP - GUN STILL PROTRUDING FROM REAR WAISTBAND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 26 - CJ RELEASES WAISTBAND - CJ RH & LH BOTH VISIBLE, LIMP IN FRONT OF FALLING BODY - GUN STILL PROTRUDING FROM REAR WAISTBAND - PO OUT OF SHOOTING STANCE, BEGINS TO STEP BACKWARD DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 27 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION, - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 28 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 29 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 30 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 31 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 32 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 33 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 34 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 35 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 36 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 37 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION, - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 38 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 39 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 40 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 41 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 42 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 43 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 44 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 45 F 27 - F 45 (APPROX ⅓ SECOND) - CJ FALLS, ROLLS INTO SITTING POSITION - GUN SLIPS FROM CJ'S WAISTBAND ONTO THE GROUND - PO STEPS BACK, AWAY FROM CJ DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 46 F 46 - 49 - CJ IS ON THE GROUND - PO SHOOTS AGAIN (SHOT #3) / F 46-49 VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 47 F 46 - 49 - CJ IS ON THE GROUND - PO SHOOTS AGAIN (SHOT #3) / F 46-49 VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST - F 47 GUN SLIPPED FROM REAR WAISTBAND / FIRST BECOMES VISIBLE ON GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 48 F 46 - 49 - CJ IS ON THE GROUND - PO SHOOTS AGAIN (SHOT #3) / F 46-49 VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 49 F 46 - 49 - CJ IS ON THE GROUND - PO SHOOTS AGAIN (SHOT #3) / - 46-49 VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 50 - CJ REMAINS ON THE GROUND IN SITTING POSITION, NO MOVEMENT (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 51 - CJ REMAINS ON THE GROUND IN SITTING POSITION, NO MOVEMENT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 52 - CJ REMAINS ON THE GROUND IN SITTING POSITION, NO MOVEMENT - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #4) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 53 - CJ REMAINS ON THE GROUND IN SITTING POSITION, NO MOVEMENT - VISIBLE GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #4) (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 54 - CJ STARTS TO ROLL BACKWARD ONTO HIS BACK (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 55 - CJ CONTINUES TO ROLL BACKWARD ONTO HIS BACK (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 56 - CJ CONTINUES TO ROLL BACKWARD ONTO HIS BACK (BI LAW FIRM. DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 57 - CJ CONTINUES TO ROLL BACKWARD ONTO HIS BACK DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 58 (BI LAW FIRMLYING ON HIS BACK - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS LYING ON HIS BACK - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 60 (BI LAW FIRMLYING ON HIS BACK - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS (BI LAW FIRMLYING ON HIS BACK - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 62 (BI LAW FIRMLYING ON HIS BACK - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 63 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 64 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 65 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 66 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 67 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 68 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 69 F 63 - 69 - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND / NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTIVITY FROM PO DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 70 F 70 - 74 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #6) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 71 F 70 - 74 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #6) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 72 F 70 - 74 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #6) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 73 F 70 - 74 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #6) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 74 F 70 - 74 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #6) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 75 (BI LAW FIRM. - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND NO MOVEMENT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 76 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #7) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 77 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #7) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 78 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #7) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 79 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #7) - L OF FRAME / SAME BURST + SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME DURATION) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 80 (BI LAW FIRM. - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND NO MOVEMENT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 81 F 81 - 85 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #8) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 82 F 81 - 85 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #8) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 83 F 81 - 85 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #8) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 84 F 81 - 85 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #8) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 85 F 81 - 85 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #8) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR 86 (BI LAW FIRM. - CJ IS LYING ON THE GROUND NO MOVEMENT DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 87 F 87 - 91 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #9) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 88 F 87 - 91 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #9) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 89 F 87 - 91 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #9) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 90 F 87 - 91 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #9) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS FR # 91 F 87 - 91 - GUNFIRE BURST (SHOT #9) (OUT OF FRAME BUT SAME BURST / SMOKE PATTERN + FRAME RATE LENGTH) DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 92 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS nl? ?st-12(BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS I I nc- mum 94 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 95 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 96 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 97 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS lam :r 98 ca MEI .Il? (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 99 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 100 (BI LAW FIRM. 92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 101 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 102 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 103 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS I 332?;? MEI in man I In: 104 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 105 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS .. ?Ii,ll .r?jrza-g FR 106 (BI LAW FIRM. 92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND 107 DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS I mwt? "Irra 11- mm I I I (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 108 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 109 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 553.; 33$ FR 111 (BI LAW FIRM. 92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND DASH CAMERA ANALYSIS 110 (BI LAW FIRM. F92 - 111 - CJ CONTINUES TO LIE ON THE GROUND CONCLUSIONS: 1. Official Account provided does not match the video evidence 2. CJ never pointed a gun at Officer Hill 3. CJ put his hands up immediately upon being confronted by Officer Hill 4. Officer Hill’s first shot was to CJ’s back 5. Officer Hill continued to fire several shots at CJ after he was already on the ground