Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 1 of 9 PageID #:1

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

MEANITH HUON,
Plaintiff,
v.

ABOVETHELAW.COM,
DAVID LAT,
ELIE MYSTAL,
BREAKINGMEDIA.COM,
JOHN LERNER,
DAVID MINKIN,
BREAKING MEDIA.
JOHN DOES 1 to 100,

CIVIL ACTION NO.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

)
Defendants,

)
)

COMPLAINT
Plaintiff, Meanith Huon, complaining of the Defendants, states as follows:
CAUSE OF ACTION
1.
This a diversity action that is brought pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section 1332 for
defamation, defamation per se, false light invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of emotional
distress.
2.

The matter in controversy exceeds $75,000, exclusive of costs and interest.

JURISDICTION AND VENUE
3.
This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
Section 1332.
4.
Venue is proper pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1391 (b). A substantial part of the events
or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred within the district.
THE PARTIES
5.

Plaintiff, Meanith Huon (hereinafter referred to as "Mr. Huon"), was at all
1

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 2 of 9 PageID #:2

relevant times a citizen of the United States and a resident of Cook County, Illinois.
6.
On information and belief, Defendant, Breaking Media a/k/a Breakingmedia.com,
is a citizen of New York. Defendant Breaking Media owns and operates the website
Abovethelaw.com. On information and belief, Defendant, Abovethelaw.com, is a citizen ofNew
York.

7.
On information and belief, Defendant, David Lat, is a citizen of New York.
Defendant Lat is the managing editor of Abovethelaw.com website. On information and belief,
Defendant, John Lerner, is a citizen of New York and CEO of Abovethelaw.com and Breaking
Media. On information and belief, Defendant, David Minkin, is a citizen of New and publisher
of Abovethelaw.com website and Breaking Media.
8.
On information and belief, Defendant, Elie Mystal, is a citizen of New York.
Defendant Mystal is a write and editor for Abovethelaw.com.
9.
On information and belief, the John Does 1 to 100 are users and visitors of
Abovethelaw.com.
.
FACTS
10.

On May 6, 2010, Plaintiff, Meanith Huon, was acquitted of sexual assault charges

in Madison County, Illinois, after the jury deliberated for 2 hours.
11.

On May 6, 2010, after Mr. Huon was acquitted, Defendant Elie Mystal, posted the

following on Abovethelaw.com:
Rape Potpourri
We’ve got a couple of rape stories . . .
Our next story from the files of the wanton and depraved is a little more in our
wheelhouse. A St. Louis-area lawyer came up with an excellent little game to meet women.
Meanith Huon allegedly listed Craigslist ads where he claimed to be a talent scout for models.
...
But Huon’s potentially harmless lies allegedly turned dastardly, pretty quickly.
2

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 3 of 9 PageID #:3

The victim said she responded to a Craigslist ad posted by Huon in late June, seeking
promotional models , sending ger resume, her phone number, and two pictures of herself . . .
And this people, is why God invented Google. Had the victim Google Huon, she would
have found stories like this from the Madison County Record:
A Chicago attorney who was posing as a supervisor for a company that sets up
promotions for alcohol sales at area bars was charged in Madison County July 2, with
two counts of criminal sexual assault, two counts of criminal sexual abuse and one count
of unlawful restraint . . .
Meanith Huon, 38, of 3038 S Canal St. in Chicago, was arrested by the Chicago Police
Department on July 1, and was transferred to Madison County the next day.
Or she might have come across this link from, at Lawyer Gossip:
Lawyer, Meanith Huon, 39, who was originally charged with criminal sexual assault,
sexual abuse and unlawful restraint is now facing charges of harassment and cyber
stalking!
Of course, women shouldn’t have to assume that every guy they meet is a potential rapist.
But apparently there are a lot of depraved dude walking around that are potential rapist.
In any event:
Huon and the woman went to a couple of bars near Busch Stadium, then to a Laclede’s
Landing bar before Huon asked the victim if she wanted to go to Pop’s in Sauget to meet
the other models.
The woman agreed, but told Huon she didn’t have enough gas in her car, so she went
with him, she said.

3

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 4 of 9 PageID #:4

This is gonna end badly.
As Huon’s Honda Civic crossed the poplar Bridge, the victim said Huon drove past the
Sauget exit and continued north on Interstate 55. As the car was moving, Huon fondled
the woman, then forced her to perform oral sex on him, the victim, said.
Oh, come on. If somebody was driving and tried to “force” me to perform oral sex on
them, I’d just get out of the stupid car. Which is to say, I’d do exactly what the victim did in
this case.
...
Damn. If you can’t get a woman to consensually stay in a moving vehicle, can you
really get her to consensually agree to sex (insofar as lying to her about your job and your
intentions to get her into the car counts as consensual in the first place)?
Obviously, Huon sees things differently.
...
So we’re not denying that she hurled herself out of a moving vehicle, we’re contending
she jumped out of the car to make it look like she was raped? Right, sure. That sounds like the
definition of incredible.
It seems to me that there is entirely too much (alleged) raping going on in this country.
If this keeps up, men and women are going to have to start carrying around sexual consent forms
on their persons. . . .
A copy of the entire article is attached as Exhibit A and incorporated into this complaint.
12.

The aforesaid statement is false. Defendants omit that the same complainant is

involved in all 3 articles.

Had Defendants read the original source of the news, Defendants

4

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 5 of 9 PageID #:5

would have realized that the Madison County Record and Lawyer Gossip were all discussing the
same woman.
13.
On information and belief, the John Does 1 to 100 are users and visitors of
Abovethelaw.com and Breaking Media websites who posted defamatory comments about Mr.
Huon.

COUNT I (FALSE LIGHT)
1-13. Plaintiff hereby incorporates by reference the above paragraphs of this
Complaint as if the same were set forth fully herein.
14.

In recklessly stating and intimating that there were other women that Mr. Huon

allegedly rape and not explaining that the same woman is the subject of all 3 stories,
Defendants invaded Mr. Huon's privacy by portraying him in a false light.
15.

The false light in which Defendants portrayed Mr. Huon would be highly

offensive to a reasonable person, in that the suggestion of the article is that Mr. Huon got away
with rape.
16.

Defendants

had knowledge of or acted in reckless disregard as to the falsity of

the publicized matter and the false light in which Mr. Huon would be placed.
17.

As the result of so portraying Mr. Huon, Mr. Huon sustained severe personal

injuries including, but not limited to, emotional distress, irreparable damage to his reputation,
loss of standing in the community, and injury to his professional reputation.
18.

Defendants’ acts of so portraying Mr. Huon were reckless, outrageous, willful,

and malicious, warranting the imposition of punitive damages.
5

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 6 of 9 PageID #:6

COUNT II (INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS)
1-13. Plaintiff hereby incorporates by reference the above paragraphs of this
Complaint as if the same were set forth fully herein.
14.

Defendants’ acts of perpetuating false and inflammatory information concerning

Mr. Huon, specifically, that he was a serial rapist, constituted extreme and outrageous conduct.
15,

In making such false and inflammatory comments, Defendants intentionally and
recklessly caused severe emotional distress to Mr. Huon.

16.

As the result of Defendants’ false and inflammatory comments concerning Mr.

Huon, he sustained bodily harm, including, but not limited to emotional distress, irreparable
damage to his reputation, loss of standing in the community, and inability to obtain employment.
17.

Defendants’ acts of so portraying Mr. Huon were reckless, outrageous, willful,

and malicious, warranting the imposition of punitive damages.

COUNT III (DEFAMATION)
1-13. Plaintiff hereby incorporates by reference the above paragraphs of this
Complaint as if the same were set forth fully herein.
15.

The content of the article were defamatory in that it incorrectly and recklessly

portrayed Mr. Huon as a serial rapist by treating the same complaining witness as three different
women.
16.

The publication of the article constitutes publications by Defendants.

17.

The erroneous and inflammatory comments concerning Mr. Huon were applied to

Mr. Huon on the entire web page . Any and all viewers of the article understood the defamatory

6

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 7 of 9 PageID #:7

(i.e. criminal, loathsome, immoral) meaning of the erroneous inflammatory information
concerning Mr. Huon’s allegedly being a serial rapist.
18.

Mr. Huon sustained special harm as a result of the publication of the erroneous

and inflammatory communications by Defendants, including, but not limited to, the loss of his
professional reputation.
19.

Moreover, as the result of the defamatory publication referred to herein, Mr. Huon

has sustained irreparable harm to his reputation, emotional distress and loss of standing in the
community.
20.

Defendants are privileged to broadcast the defamatory article.

21.

Defendants acts described herein were reckless, outrageous, willful, and

malicious, warranting the imposition of punitive damages.
COUNT IV (DEFAMATION PER SE)
1-13. Plaintiff hereby incorporates by reference the above paragraphs of this
Complaint as if the same were set forth fully herein.
14.

The content of the article were defamatory in that it incorrectly and recklessly

portrayed Mr. Huon as a serial rapist by treating the same complaining witness as three different
women.
15.

The publication of the article constitutes publications by Defendants.

16.

The erroneous and inflammatory comments concerning Mr. Huon were applied to

Mr. Huon on the entire web page . Any and all viewers of the article understood the defamatory
(i.e. criminal, loathsome, immoral) meaning of the erroneous inflammatory information
concerning Mr. Huon’s allegedly being a serial rapist.

7

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 8 of 9 PageID #:8

17.

Mr. Huon sustained special harm as a result of the publication of the erroneous

and inflammatory communications by Defendants, including, but not limited to, the loss of his
professional reputation.
18.

Mr. Huon sustained special harm as a result of the publication of the erroneous

and inflammatory communications by Defendants, including, but not limited to, the loss of his
professional reputation.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Meanith Huon, requests the following relief:
1.

An award of economic and compensatory damages to Plaintiff and against Defendants,

jointly and severally, in an amount to be determined at trial;
2.

An award of punitive damages to Plaintiff and against Defendants, jointly and

severally, in the amount of 50,000,000 (Fifty Million Dollars) or in an in an amount to be
determined at trial.
3.

An order for injunctive relief against Defendants and their employees from retaliating

against Plaintiff;
4.

The transfer of the domain abovethelaw.com to Plaintiff.

5.

An award of costs;

6.

As well as any other relief this Court deems just and appropriate

.
DEMAND FOR TRIAL BY JURY

Pursuant to Rule 38(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, plaintiff, Meanith Huon,

8

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 9 of 9 PageID #:9

demands a jury trial on all issues triable.

May 6, 2011
___/s/Meanith Huon_____________
Meanith Huon

Meanith Huon
The Huon Law Firm
PO Box 441
Chicago, Illinois 60690
1-312-405-2789
FAX No.: 312-268-7276
ARDC NO. 6230996

9

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 1 of 8 PageID #:10

[u^

-tslut

srrdNs'rd

ludlu!J

I dqt

4.torql

r]dq

5.wrg

" JlasrarlJ0 ra.nrlJld o.\l

JnoI to ror\cd usroJd aqt Ssaujeq noi slal abelue^W
qxJeas ssal

pue iiqrrilu

{uuor}otrrord BrnIa.ts
autrl atcl ul uonH .iq pdlsod pr tsF8lu].) p ot pnlxrodssl Jt{J ples u&})t.r i}tll

uolnlos qlreas apra LururuloAoov

.c6qut^w

qcfes

Blxal ro!fttsq

erloqd rar{ 'arurs.ii rnq Srupus '{apo(r

ll putJ

saqllees Qals,{s luourao€ueLuluaunf,cp
palurod lsoN rrrc,i o] a Fuodsalun*sretuas

6unl

l€j ro sa^Dp palSauuoxsrpuo lsol ajaqaaNos oreql
ulo s,l

aru{ 6ur}Jerpro qljeasar Jo snoq plo}un a^es

plnor leql lrnpord \ro&! ua old aql
luroo-uo asj?aro leql

,{tllrnb /,Iard AIPre}sPPPauJnl
s uanH ]n6
ftg p te sgssa3oud utn6 anqnq sseldul o] 6ul&l
^l,€tualod
^ped
spn l asnelaq errJv Upreqps"qns uoJl Fqtupr tlJllso ue aq ol papu3Frd atlo l poon os reJ oS

Ilflaoalls sal ssa}ru€q

uorshcrd F?Jluol

srap0d roJuo)s rualPte aq or paLurPl)aq araqA spe ls4s6re.3

uorlou palsat'uno) teql

patsl ilpJh.lip uonH ttluEalil €uoa
'snol

.64u.Apy

qclr.S

@ilx.'l*6urlurill

laau ol aup6 a${ }ualla3xe ue qlh\ dn auetr r3^del eaJe

lS V asnoqlaaq{,.rno $ arow alpl e s pa^grdap pue uo}ueM aql lo sal't eqt uorJ ,itols txil rno

)saq 5 urj

.rnoi ,o rarMd uanord aql olut dEt ol iea Ja8aq P lsPI lV

nol Jeau sFidsr Aaurouepada[P lu€ se llas se snooe] pue qlu
aqllosuorlefiallesderaqlra^of,aM a6ere^oraderOuqeajqloJdoqsdols-augJno'iaja^l llvlParaH

'cnai'irvi ix.r.

{rE4uairued3$ ul }uero
atut e lc pua ssaursoq

saf,ueuadxs ll

leql adoq .4uo ue! auo arJl are sugrcBalle aql I 4!16 ploJea^

"ql
-g! V tuooJqleq aql ur ]no slno srq 8utlnd /illuailnl sr ljnpe reuorlere sr lsql eu Jo ued aql asief,aq tdcu
Uou seuo$au pcoqpllllr iu ollr palrol u   -p6 al$ e adgr plnol uorlrsod$lreqautt aql paluoqnlc^aj
oq^r ueu aL{}leq} a^a{aq }.uel ({l Juq ,tu tou ptfl]f,]ouui ,{ru 0l 6ula}or u,l) eu Jo aprsur

tr!t3 3No
$$,\pnpoJd{ro Aua^ord
JnoAolulde1:qxaps;xr1
,.6rd

.tJ

alprl aq1
^oq

/"{v'l 3H-t fAogv

6u{lus
sr uusus€ql

aol si€qrneuos. :lsaq I pres raueal3 lefl rolpa arJ$raxg erFafl 6$ earg lurllt I

-9raou€oargr-ilory

lll

uonHqlurrn I looqrrPj fil

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 2 of 8 PageID #:11

4papUa
-lso3 p{lBl$uapuuos ,,!}pnb_alruas
_
lgoal
,(lqanbFal6q s.ulri nodlo ,!a^{ap oq} ansul
l.lal. o) lal laqp pue qu{ aq asE3
'alwas suollellc
€s,plBd3qs pateloou!qla
pooo uo paspqilasare guaun:op,{e1 arnsa1ey1
^tBt
uoltPzuadJoino,{
ul af,?ld ut ,(psa{B sa 6opuqla} uloJj lsoul a {
l€g

'lrqP4$3J FllseFrn J0 unN *o
![F mqe lenxes
Frllu.u)Jo sluns o.rg ,$resse lEnxaslsqnuurjo s4mo' o.ul
,a JFf
{tBr
$mo:t uoqpBlt u! pagJprpss ilaq sm lp saPs
loqorp to; mooouord dn
tlil l€ql "twdurs E to] Jos,LuadnsE s ftnsd $.r! orl.$ j{ro$p
ogemn y

Pro€U
pmoJ e^gq gnoff aqs lsH

pegoog ullJ^

uo$r9€y{ a {l uo{
pog

st

.stql
an silo}s
,qdoad
sqt pW

^qa

eJou,puE
suo[or! 'slauq aluuy.r-pnpojd UOil JoUodns
qf,leosaj
0uuu 6€g ,(q,{auouj pu8 euil a^ps
\qnA
:no,{sdiaqe6quE^w qijeas
sxereuu@g
pe luMlnv'@WwtW
M4
qaBas erd/alur @/SVJ ,@M^tA ouFryruF{flloue
q3lesssud$llr p€rq-rrlssg r#il ,tlssi Eqlg$elul

dllfiog

ar$ peH a6ooo p€luilu!

'Pes
aqi :aq -{aualn ol tuqB s$ aq os pilp ,{q qapeu
tw{B}ruwd
rs{to rg req plor aq .etaql }o8 ff{s usq$
lnq teq ra$fip lp ulq taru
o}Jaq plot aE uonH pe["c pm Jrq ?mcru *_\ up1lr
arg ,.{pp}xa qfi lng
uF{r

.paq{tsal
'psds pse ase paqslruun qllA--qs

wo al{} reE
-]ffi  noI u€lucl suapsual aq1'6uqurutsaq quq
noI Jolilod Hod aqt ssarEq nol slale!tslue^pv
qases sxal uoqntG qrffi eph-ug
fussod y
.r6euapv

qqws rtnl

l8lfr $9 l, pulJ

sLlxrss ulsAs lusu36€ueu ljMsp
palulodlsm so,{ ot a lsuodsiu HFffi
&jns

.

urqili aP a.O,{pped sq srl

-tS &no}urop a1g}s 13er ol pae;B?osl d{l

..-n*lt{{Jo
sfi$ld o,ul
pup raqmu eu{d 14 .!ms
raq 8 4pus ,qap0u lemFoEtrd guFles
'amf ilPi q trfilH .iq pat$d pe
tqFAreJ) p ot p+uod$r Er{sFps ugrr 4[f

:/ip{ffib Ji$ejd.,{lFeFgp peutr4

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 3 of 8 PageID #:12

'ISNOAS:sqeluoltlc Bw eqt
iSr[1tPlsJaq.bpugrrumJEq
JosetusqrtupqrN qlup.Osrr+u[m pw e*qe Fnx33lprss*
Fn*asFqil:r!:J$rrr p€&eqr.{ilgqgjo sa{ oq"s,6t trmg q]$rar{ ,ra(sFl
m{ lF uoJ

ne ilFuesardal

sfraNsH€'l I gle mPuolut

oou

ISanbaU
F

ejoq Jl01 3f[ffia
sl€[]

.!aql rol file

ls3q J€u m 6uz4elder
4roa u*old

s4u

rap€r6 iiltFp
Fqu€u

6uliJl$
lrp0ld

,i&apula
-lsoJ sle &uop4uo3 .&ptnFajluas
1860!
,{Uenb
lssqoru s,uxg norilo drail ap a+ sr suS
}Ja$o:,{a{ra(p pls $lu'   fiq ssel
'aJWASclo[arc
@slojBdaqspqaoaur qu,r aE
pooD tlo posBq [m ale sluarrrJop,{o)t afls
alBll

^pee4€

 s ')turlsuj! gsoJx auof e eq ul8u eqs Jo

p3]gd l5?, B e'l8l

sl sfgJa q Faq ua3 u-!l mo^ aoq
tno rurl

ur afBid ut

(lsog aAel

rclrauDo$ Jnod
saroopufcat uorJ ]sou a[ Bg

uoq?€H
orpilJqsrur
*,n,pB.rd'ruo*J?ffif

;ffi

eO.lQ parsa:.r eu r06ery'D ls
ry
FupS S Bgof Jo ,8t lMtH {rru€€r[
.rtryulsrJ
lr+uBFmJo lmoJ ilo prE ffiqs Fnxs
FtlwcJoqmoosrl
lFwlenx6leqrEmJoqrmooqr{{.r.a,tnt
_
,t]moo uoqpPlt rr poAeEJ s"r $sq effi
ts sFs toq€p rol soqruold &r
qd let8 .{$!aks0o E jn$ twuadrs p
ff ft[sd s.R e+{ .{ruoue ogB4r{, y

rpssu Alnog uespefi a{t so4 .sl.$${l sailc}s
puol a Eqfinoil .rls 'uooli pslooog u/0ln
aql pE l aFoo$ p:l/il4 pog A{ s .aFoad ,snngjv

alou, p0B
x "1tJ{q!sm9l{dr&

ln i

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 4 of 8 PageID #:13

&pPq t)ua euuo6 sr sll1

'ptc Jrlj ltilll rlrL!\ ludtr..qs
oi .IuJ larl ut *rB r{fttoua a.1!q t.Rplp d(ls tronH pl}t trq .poilip $r,ruo.[ u{I
.sldpor{ t+Ll}o iqt
iiiur
or oB ol patrwr{ arl!-I utl]r.\

01 la5nEs ul s dod

aqt pi,Isp uortll i.iojaq .rEq ftrpue,]

r apal}E.I

E oi loql'ru.rrpeis qJs[g Jpau s]eqJo aldrcJ u oI ttrn_sllE{lroJi illl pup uouH

9Nt lt nuf , 3uA3NNt X
lua.\a ruE ul

9Ht.!lnucSuAf ililtr

seNN3do

3lvtcossv
's'nv svoNvvt'rvutsnv

si90er lerlualoclaie ieql aJaqt no puocte buDiteAisapnp pa^erdap iol e ale alaql /i,tu3ledde
J0
!18 )sroer lerlueiod e si laau Iaql ln6 ..Ja^aleql ounssE ol a^Erl lupjnolls uaeori

aslnol lO

'^3NQAS :sal3luojrlS elsv aql

Srryl-clJJaq.iJ p@ trrarus;rtJtq
,lltesr€
F+{EFm pu€ amqB l€nr-as
rllbr p+E,rerp -ilFilGtro *.s ot1-1!,61 f,rong qtruEal{ .Jai-{e,t

Jo sa8€qJ BnJp].!!ou r irflultsal
J€nras pwruul
nrn ltpltc I lt/f . 3.!ielrjatejdal
ssallsr!41 e pre uolE(rjcJul ajru

$art)sg
drss..C lanf.E-j le lul sllji ssotle augl e^eq lqoiu aqs JO

m -.!-'.

-9Jaou:0€19r-erows

M

ur^H qluEn

liooe)el

g

.

i:

wo^

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 5 of 8 PageID #:14

JOpuolaaasql 6e6aAsp'l uraq ol uaddeqno^jl d snf
u0 Sllt uragpl€^e
ol 0e leyl cIN uraq ilrnI pueI I
^e!i,l
aq lfa I pup(erssnuu p"seq sr oL,n)ealnl raqynj
yH urp?s€qasrnof,jo sr 3qspue lSas
allu€ue0-r3d
uau alodeoursursr srxaM{efl }o lteqpuzaql eurq3,')tH

alll,lo ,irn{ ar{l ot smtqd

p.r.trorls llsH

illf

.iaurollY s.aletS }lstslst

'Pagllsal u[lJL\ Aqt ..'rPJ }Etll,lo lno la8 or pFoJ I A$ll-iuE oP
aq1 ot l)sq aru i{etr 01 ?8o3 t,u*-s itlJI,,

ol uorflJap p apEu peq I 'ierraa{

'le) if([ ul uolIPJII]sapt

uraq ilh\ I pu€uaqou r.lluousrqlou ro silqv usqoH
puegHS lo f€ yH u aE noi Jl
ql/d laau ol a$ plno^1

prF $aoqs 'aimd ;iloqd

[a] raq Sn.rsal 'uonH adelsi ol pas als

'r€J 8[r.\o{u aqt uro-$ psdpai unt)lr

(vHpuEeHs f€
rlseaI puse^qn^
aJode8uls)
asv urstuauaf,edbuDiPU
suaMqt'a .)parnpoo0,{pen}uedp uoeqseLllsa

arlJ Jar{ qtgr lno a{Eu o] aJPld PapnlJs
p rcj prus ultJr.\ .Lil'&r,n4oo1 'sli?no6 $aN $au Sg atetalilsl patlxa uonH

slql Inuar€rsls€q,$paa s uo sluaualPd aldunur
ou!)lEuuffiq a^€qaa araqa ?uil.19
/ )lH u trlter)edsa
(4ua?atiija^ azaaJl6uuiqgo Suruol sull Sfl
0l dolo^! lP 6upnl?u0llleluelsqnsasearJurol €nulluol
ersvursourusdo
sn Joraqwnuaq1 ajaque^3
"l9r3o6se
I u0J pp ourlnJxaj^auuDl
uer nol srea^ofil lsPd
le e6e :lpua iq saqt Ltf,ear
aul ul rrrll laqp iu€ ueqlelsv u!sjauuPdpuesau!3osss
s n JosuauarEd arou apeu s€qnauurysalluorqS
eFV aqlJoiosuods fu!rulaE 4auuylo
uaqou
^aullx
puesJaeofueAf dq paroqFesrlsod sql rtpl-l

asel sql ur plp urlf r^ a$ teq/d,{t cPXa op p,l,{es ol sl tl 3lllJl^ Jel prdnF alli }0
t,1ole6 tsnl p I uaql uo xas lao uofad

ol au .aroj, ol paul puP Auhup sea ipoqeuos l uo auol qO

'pPs uqllt
uo]lad
st"sq

o] rJq pailo]
a1ttsrilrrl

uaql 'wruo.lr

aql 'ulfi{ uo xas pf,o

arit paFuo] uonH 'Btryaos tr,tr f,p) aril

uo quou panuquoJ pE $Ja laRnes 3ql l*d

PI€s urtrq.\ aq+ 'a3pljg

lee&S sldod

J.1dp uonH

aqi PessoJi JI.IIJ Bpuoi{ s-nonH sH

,{lpPqpua euuob sr srt{t

L--.
a -'9Tre*0g19I-aEUr

El

uo4{ r#w:n

l+dqrr?l

A

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 6 of 8 PageID #:15

oulouoJdp pJou l]EJl E 6equl sq] pupFl]!6lod
Naua)ue^p?Hrer sr areql)iaupls urIIu4?uFd
uaop eill3sol,$unuoddo!e s! u ?{ejFnvu ls6q
eql aq ol perapFuo?
s!
uts)rllerd staveu
^lepld ^eup,(s
del sn sql (su[ ilos ]e sialrEu seasrao raq o
pueyH u uaddequ9) q)rqa a{lun)APllPlol qla lle
p leaploupuEael $$rnras sn 4eJlls aq lla qor alll
laljeu sn roleu Jaqlo@JolJo mN urull sn oz dol
e uorj 6uuol 43ltl lsru salerssse Ee$su def,EeI
109ol pJ[ Agpsfi, aq ilm suqllsod 04 3ql laup.4sol
SuueroFrur palsajau sa]eoossp sarujnls Sn osl puu
sqr dFq ol sn pelsP selt suell) ul Sn dol lno lo ilO
egelraeJFs,iu
atpu ue3 pue ool sr3ql aq   la l lpa l@e uau ruert^l
ro pualeaasrqlseoa^spl u 3q ol uaddeqnoi ,t z anf
uo 9lN ur enPt€^e
ot 0e /iefl CiN q aq fi$ I pue I I
^eft
aq iln I pue(e6snHu paseqsr oqm)e,{rlnl raqunJ
',{ l!au€urad yH urpaseqasrnoap sr ar{spue IaoM
usu arodeou€ ur sr sflaM 'IeH Jo{eq puz a* euq3 I )iH
ui eq [h I puepaqoH q]uru sql ru ro sFlv uaqou
r+n lru ol alll F{noMpw gHS ro fB yH urilE no{ $
{vH puegHs 'ts
'#ode6us) asv u slu€waoEd6uUeuq3e3I pueeI{nA
srxslvrl}fi 'l#e p@6 ,{leFrlued p usq seqI*m
. r6rd

.i3uo$e aqt .'adEJ .i$" pFo-\r ar{s 'raq .ied },uprp uonH rr pnalpirq}
p@ oo9$ roJ pe{s wl+! ;qt tng 'f,s pnsasoJ ppq uaql Jo o.iq an pw
lr 'ftmare il{l rq lqod auos le }nq iau rilpc,r"l{F pup ronH
FIFS msq
lH$ uue]gts

Stmedo s-q Amp

pH '.ra"t-rre1
ama;ap s,uonH 'sllal\

ri0uaF.]r,ps6uql sss

aTtt

uonH ,{lsnonqo

z(al€F Fitl or.llur Fnsuasuol sP sluno! lef
arl olur ieq la6 ol suotua lt ]rcI pu€ qolrno,( lnoqe Jaq ol 6w(t se JepsuD xas ol aaj6e
ol raq la6

^llensffiuof,
ol ueaoM e la6 Lu€r no^ I u@O

no{ uer alfqal 0u6ou e u ,{e}s
^ileaj

^lensuasugl

'saol $J Puelaal patrrlqs 'saq pffiq
siwuo.{
pa^ror{slefl sJr{f, dauro]1v s.atsls lustssst'

ar&j0 .int aql 0t sml]ld

'pa1Ftstrtup)-!r et{} ,,'n) :!EqlJo$o rat or pF6 I 8q{rrtw op
ol uolslcape apeu per{ l .ie-\taaq ilp ol )lJeq su ats} o} 3I4oBt.os-n eq }r,,
'FJ +{ rq uoqeJgltuapr
pw saoqs'asd buor{d Us rill gereal 'uonH adeJsa01'plw aqs
'eJ Surou aql udJ pideq um[\ d{I 'raq q+u tno e{nu ot a}qd papRlJs
p JoJ'pH !uq.[i er{l 'Ssppol '*Fnoq lleN nil 99 a]e]sJatul pBlra rmH

r

-'g1{MdETgl-ilour

M

uohH t{xu.t}t

ll@Pnl

ll

- ;!

et

il

 Case: 1:11-cv-03054 Document #: 1-1 Filed: 05/06/11 Page 8 of 8 PageID #:17

.(asq
'$ilrllJuq

lsq il leqs ueql arru iuru ile elaql) eFV ul souruado
pa6in arou rno p auos p lsl a^0Euasajdere st aaH
esv ur sa/q sleDossesn qua
^firyrb
tua 6tru lo pjosJ )trel e seq uU Sn dol JeFrued

tauq q$ JoJa*re{pna ltr '-

:o '-

illoJfJ .&u 14uq$ruiaru
amlry ot su8r d UIEIJ I

'-

'pa.rlo:ru * (tiluano
Jo pe.iueq) qruw d s 8uq o$ per4r$o aq
.or
[Lh slsedord [e pw
P3]$!!l 1@ a& nq 'apoF4
sotlqnPm norotl't8 $ns 's,-ilpd ra$o aqt ol .tul 8o!xg3
ol luNo
.iqilaq op '.ipoq 1oqpue Eru Ems Jo Euaq 'pq&sapm rEt 'I

slll 'Jaqunj ssaloJd no uaeJpe aq pu lh y os
sapprpuetrodl u&J el0 roJgaJo qIff dl{Jnb Itr am
ot peJedaJd
a[,(all pl€s tH ssusnq uo Sn aql u s?a
3tl se depFlsai aJlJoiilpAS s,uI srill M{ Fu!€d
6wrq *ll gld lau I p€lsaaur eJenqdJ Fpua I iloqd
/tq noi qIfl irElepu firururoddoaql ra^o o0 ol ,(ddgrl
aP s '#nor l1o uorlsodgql $l ,!dde ol pap&u te
e{e.qsnyol uqlsuuor 6uuls $ a@adta Fgd clil u!
eeloe u ouliJofi wqt ?$ JoA! eobJe*eqe s { lEq}epsu
aq us3}]eun6ie &.$4s€ 'soq 6sl o lsrss3 6rnol
lo pue fuFlalEq) aq tit$ rc8sod sql elqtt Sn ol lrsq

suG€d

tFql uo sMl

'dn sdaql slq,

llsuo,

lgtxs

uor}ulap aql afl sp6os

anpalaqo
padMleqs

pume

6us(wr

ol aeq ol 6!€6 ep uauoa

lpF

A$rnol srrll ur uo &mO 6ud€r (pa6ell") qru

]eql 6sp@t!oa

lBql

eJ,as qlqil

.aJns 'Sl6tU
&soo

pug ru

@l Aarq€ s ajaql teql eu ol ssoas U

apoda *a

q.as ail )t@t I oleu

ol ts3 eql jo Uo

e ]o  no XesJal pgnq a s  eqt 6u,{€p

lou ar.aa oS

peaq@ql puear@Edxa oulsereu Alllbo sJea,(aa}
€ p@ds ro (se:so ssse o i{snqu uqlfi uo4 sJauued
oumuord JoproH l&q e seq uU sl]l pue Plllalod
pe JsPl s! ajaql} IaUMS ui,$uaueu}sd
luMfw
ueop anFs ot Alrtlsddo ue 6! I -elaFnv u €eq
alt €q ol peFpsual 4ep!a $ /bup,is u al[f,eJd s]al€u
dn Sn slqI {sur$ ilos le stailpu spes o Ja.flo
p@ yH u ued*rl !e3 qrqn awn) net F)q qte  l€
P pap l6u pu?ilel slinFs
iolru Jeultueto

so

^lartlla

'Peft?
.irt, plno-r eqs ,:ei -tsd l,Eplp umH g peFlpaJql
"'adEJ
pre oo99 roJ prls uq$ org $8 1s Fnsfl@
F{ wq[  }o oru 4F prE
.{molle aq}

FDos aumaq I €uE3.ra r{l q I4od ar{tr le tnq 'lu unlil rp Frp umH
fftrurdo su Swnp pffi 'ra.inq asiJip s,qonH sfl3K aill{

IHfl lEn3tels

aq [6 elo] eql

jlue€g p s6rqSs*s uorg -,(pnoSqo

x -edad*88tr{iou*M r,11:'i+,{$'iryf.i".eJilf;:ffi
xllr lE

m9I-tuour.LFellS

:d?J (A tk_j lD

ryqe,

3u

-

;;