Nov.15. 2012 No.1495 P. 1 BEFORE THE WEST VIRGINIA BOARD OF NIEDICINE WEST VIRGINIA BOARD OF MEDICINE, Petitioner, v. Complaint No. ll?lZS-W KENNETH JAMES SEEN, Md). Respondent. ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE On November 13, 2012, the Respondent, Kenneth James Seen, M.D., by counsel, David K. Moore, ?led a Motion for Continuance ol?the hearing in the abovevcaptioncd matter. Whereupon, upon review of the motion, it is hereby found as Follows: 1. The hearing in this matter is scheduled to begin on Not/ember 19, 2012, at the of?ces of the Petitioner, West Virginia Board of Medicine [?Board?], in Charleston, West Virginia, pursuant to the Board?s Order of Summary Suspension of License to Practice Medicine and Surgery and Notice of Hearing dated November 5, 2012. 2. On November 13, 2012, Respondent Kenneth James Seen, M.D., ?led Respondent?s Motion to Continue the hearing seeking a continuance of the hearing until mid to late January 2013 in order to permit his counsel to conduct further investigation of the allegations against him. 3. Petitioner indicates, through counsel, that it has no objection to the continuance of hearing to a mutually convenient date as long as the continuance is not construed as a failure t? the Board to adhere to and follow the provisions of West Virginia Code 30?3?l4(k) and 11 CSR 3 l0.16, and as long as Dr. Seen understands that his license to practice medicine and surgery in the State of West Virginia will remain on a ?suspended? status until the Board enters a ?nal Order following the conclusion of the hearing in this matter. Nov.15. N0.i495 P. 2 4. It is found that good cause has been shown for the continuance of the hearing in this matter ?om November 19, 2012, to a date which is: subsequent to January 15, 2013, and which is mutually cmwenient to the parties. WIHEREFORH, the Respondent?s; Motion for Continuance is Dated this ?n day ol?Novembcr, 2012. Hei'sehe] I-I. Rose, 111, Esquire Hearing Examiner EEQAREE Peti??nen Va {iikigzyia'ini N?o 3.3423412? JAEWES Ml}. GREEK ii}? SEMIVEARY SEISPENSEUR OF LECENSE PRA CECE- SURGE-RY SF ?E?he Wes? Virginia Hoax-d cf Ma?icim Bea-16?} hereby SUMMAFJLY the listings: of Kenna-t1": Emacs $5621? "$363132: N20. 15316, :0 pig-mm mediai?e and. Surgery in the 3813136 of Wes: Virgiaia purgutmzi; ta W?t Virginia. 'Cade- 5% Wag? Virginia (Sade: West Virginia Coda and 11 CSR 3' 71.0.3 6. div: to an immediate danger to that pablic- safetyalmalth welfare as: rag-3111? of his arms-i 02:1 a felony charge of al?ld :abx?t's'e mm??g risk Qf injm?y and on misdcmeanm? c-11arga30fbaimxy and 34523313112. FENBENQS 1; K633116131 Jameg Seen} MD. S6431in lmlcis a it) pt?aatice medicine and Burg-awry in the Siata- {1f W?sx Virginia; No. .153 ?6 which WES initially in 198?. Dr. Sea-31?s addresi? {of recorci with {he 80am is in. Spencer, ??ar?agi' Virginia. Egg Public Carma? R-e-pm?t {3f ?Limnsae: .attach?cdherem as Exhibit A. O'n air :abeuiNevambar '1 2012., Bmard 1633111626 ihat Sean had been 0-11 minimal chargss on 20]. 3, The Bamd subseaqusu?y {111:3 Mag?gigsirz?e {301m of Rama Camus? WMCE pic-vided the Rik-aid with capias of reia??g ix: ms; feloay 93133346 and thee. aha-1:93:35; \arhich Weir-e 1:537:3?13ght agai?gt Dr. 353-61101: Ocigf?m 3'1, 201 \3 4. Om Crimiijsal Campia?ni: 131513.351 againsi. 193?. 8.6311011 Sacha: 1, 2813-? in {fa-3Q. N930 125E376, and 12me993 ii??acts that p?ifcsbahla $31,136: was ?mn? to anti Wzsman?izs iss?ti'ed for 01:13:63? Virginia. Code. 533 131).: shim-3,1311% GTE-mug; risk {if injury? W's-St. Virginia Coda for hal?imy and. Mfg-Ema Code asmult (Ir-2111mm. ?omp?aim in 12??F?2??5s and attacha? Ina-mm as Exhibit 'E?he Criminal attach-d EXEibii EndiC-ates; That 373: mm bagged an informa?anfrom. the Complainam, who was identi?ed as Virginia Siam Police] Tmopar 13?. :IE-Iarmzack of Spence-r. The Criminal szazrz'zpiaini. m?cds that it was based 1333031 {allowing facts: 1 WELS faquested by (Lit?dwe? Qf-the 817611213617 Ciiy 1301196 inVes?fga??: a child 351186 invoking a ma?awc?d male and NR Kamath 88,6111, ?38310? Se-cziiety af'RQane Sammy: fiacsaiicd in Emma. Sgt, Caldweil Staiiad that the: an empEOyee of the City and Wm?d be. mars with. an Quis'ide- agency in?xire?tigating the: madam, .031: 1:116 38:11.6 dam at approxinla?mly 133 {1 ham-:3 I ba-gzm inismiewing the aims}. and- thrae othar' ?liamagers that wen prawn: The Victim fold 13213 $1713? ML picksd him an MS bmther up to takf: tha'm 1:6 Chumh .031 2012 in 111:3. Vi??m stamd that 116 W328. Sitting {m a ledge maths enimnm and had his lmi'fe am} {36:11 91101166 "E?hes'vimixn INJ- Mt Seen instruatad him to gat don-2'1 and he dizi, Th6: victim want 011:0 3L that ht: wemf gm'ljaack up and get his 19110116 and knife and Mn $16311 grabbed him about ?jewaisi and ?thaw-111mm gmmd. The: yin-Kim want an say frhat My, $66.31 get on his back and punchinghim Wi?z Clesmi ?st-s irepea?tadly? 'I?hf: Vimintl. matedfhat Mr. See-:1 ?ak him ?3110. the; mas." thhe buildi?g- axial into the: mfrigsraim. The. 'addim Eta?if?d he used pmfam-ty and ML 8561161311 slapped him. across-the. 13:653.. 1 Speka with 111mg 0:11.61? temags: bays present and [size] S'tipai?aiir: ii 1.1168. 2-5113 bf "than timincidem 2L3 the victim did. N0 gather malts WW: page?mt at itle: time of 3:13.23 Criminal Calnplaim in. Case Nils. and Eluh?bggfi? attache-d. hereto as Exhibit B. 6. TheC?mina}. 8631133313311? a?thG?. a?s- indicaiss; {hat- Wesf Visfginia Cede provides that ?chili a'bw?a creating risk is da?nad 38: ?Any perm-11. who 3131-1333 a child 331d. by @335: 21131136: armies a. substamial risk Sta-mus bodily injury 1:32" dif??h? 5% Criminal Campiamtin (L333 N03. 1232? 3 Rik/$997 and. attached harem as? E?zhijivit 7. Tim Criminal Complain? attaohcdas Exhibit imiica?es that West Virginia {Di-3&6: p'fDVi??ts that batter}? is defined. as: ?Any pagan 'Wht} {wavy-?fully 21nd imamioaa?y physical of an. insulting {31' jp'rmroking 113111113 with the-pefson 0f or m?a'wfull?y an [gig-ta] intentiomlly Gauges physical: ham} t0 anther pal-son.? {fairim'jinal in. Cage 12$?276, and aim-chat? harem Exhibit B. 8. The Criminal (IQ-mplai?i attachad as Exhibit indicaies that Wag: Virginia {lads 61?2?9(b) pmvides i113}; asaaul-t defined as: ?Amy fps-man mm unlawfuliy 5111:3333 gigs 11:) 0037131133113 vialeni injm?y t0 tha permit: of azm?thm? 0r uniagw?zily {zommits an ain't 'z?hat places' mama: in of .izmrnediately receiving biliary? Criminal Carn?ainf in. (32133 1.2%1276, 12?34-997" attached harem Exhibit? 9. A second. C?mima] issued againgi Dr, Sam on Quiche? 1; 231.2, i321 C1336 ilk-@995 re?ecis the-.1 prcibablc muse was found. in am? aux-"2113221231: igg?uw? for 21 vii?laiim {3f ?Wast Virginia Cf?d? 61-2-91?6) for battery Criminal Compiaim in?a?e Na. a?acha?hamta 215- EXhibit JG. T3161 Criminal Camplaint mad-rad- as Exhibit (3 indicatas. ?11211; it was bamd 0'11 inferma?en from "the 'Cempla?nang who was. iri'azlti?ad [West Virginia; Siam Pd?ce] 7:00pm F. e- L, I?Eammaek {72f Spence}: The Crin?ml that was bagcd upml ir?bmmticm fmm- a, Ms? Ym edacmdL 6313153. YET-est Virgim Sta-e ?lms in Spfintaf ?le a wmplaini: r?gardimgg an 2133-3111?: mummi?ed again-5f 13.617 father? SMM :[ramcied]. 111:3 Cemplaintindicgt?s that?vifs? repo?-ed Ho Spiral rapo?sd. it: Eartha: Mi?, Sum? ., who suffamd dementia am} ?aykimmifs Diseas-e; haci bii'ten {11:3- mnguzss 0f Br. It indieate?s fhai Troopm lfiammack obtain ML 5-3; medical. {maids had Spoken with Dr; 83611, wha- alletrad ?1121? Mr, 3 had ?gralb'bsd hi5 and mailed Dz: dust: t0 him E9 .L and: {hen EFT. Sean?s fa; His; (3:1 aimed ?lm he jusi ren?mnhamd pain and 'b'l?bdf? 'Crin?nai Complaint- iu: Casa N0. Masha-? b.6133) as Exhibit 11. T116 C?m?mi Complaint attached as Exhibit {3 ?mhmf indicates that Tm?per Hammack Sintewiawed an Emergency d??tisf who. had treartetaii Dr, ken a?ar the incident. i'r?fla't agate?: indigaml that Dr. Sam could. mi have caugad {he injury to lama-elf ?they: Dr. 3636?;le of?vmts 0011M. net: be true, The ER doc-w}? and the, nursing Staff at Rama Gem-221 Hosp-ital. aim indicam? ih?i Was not. physically 3301.5 132.3% ?81371 ed. @111: the ac?ens 'das-Gribe? by Br. See-11. awarding to the: Complaint. Crimi?ij?al Complain]: in Case No. attached here-{0 Elxl'zibii 12. The B'Qaz?d. ?1130 Obtaimd from the Magistraie Cami of?mne copies 0f documents ?Warrmi for; Armed,? which. that: was igsufsd in 635311 5f the :fbur? Criminal {301111313i11t3 againgt Dr. 86:33.1 an October 313 201:2, gas;ng :Emm: "Warrants; for Arragt. calleazitivaly attachad harm: as 13.. The: Beard obtains-d ?aha Eviagisizratc: {30132:?1; of Rama: Count}? indieating that Dr, Seen had ?nds. 31.3 appaaran cc and had been rehaasad. jail. after paging hand or; Navamber- 1201 2., inCagz-z N9 IZM-QQS and '1 24%?9985 5.1.?th 2113.}; four Charges against Sean are {2:521:66 in the; liOcummts. ?initial Appearanm: Rights Siafemem? and ?Criminal Bail. A;ng 2.111311%: Cash 01" Recognit,am:ej? attached hare-t0 as. Exhibit 14. 01-1 01' 3.130131 Ocmber 9. the Hamil .1?eceivad an Admrse Aaz'tioni the: Na?oaa] Pmciitio?ey Data Bank. indicating, that: Rome ?maral Hag-pita} hat} mpo?c? 2; Similar?- or emergenay31151362131011 efclinical pmrilages 011' Dr. 363613.911. September 75- 7-261. as a I?suit aft". 2131 imiden?t which osmircd; on Augugt 1., 20.12. ?ction 78.13pm: {iate? Q'cmhe; 8., 2012,, mashed Estate 213- E?'?bit F. 1'3. The: initial Adversa Aci'ian Repari indict-mas that the? M?dical. Emwiive ofRearae: (Erma?ml Hospital mmlu?ed, the 11m:st gaziion 2.111 inc-idem betwm? Dr. 836:1. and a patient, that Dr. Scenb'ad sustaim? an injuxy Gama-d by the patient bi?ag his; magma. The M?adiaal Execuiim ?enm?ttea cauld- n-in determine 3. Valid. madman} pma?d?r?- which 'Wizuld. allaw 1&3? Such an injury is have mammal and D1: 83:31.1 did not. offal? a. mragmzzi-ibla ei??plzmaiia? to mam ?ies injm?g, 316.com ing 10 the Adverse Amiga Repart. Medical. EXEC {?ve Commiitee ?-O??lud?d that Dr. Seen axplamtim W33 not creciible and ?171.21: the iigiul'y?izilqely had Waived Sean?s mniact wi?} ?the. patient. according to the. initi-a?i ?gs-Tame Action Remit. Advamic A'C??ll Report dei?ed Samba 2.01 ai?tachad Emmet-o as; Exhibit .. 16. (3911 24. 31731.2. the. Board maeived ?revigimf? .Ad'verga {m R?po? @0111: the. National Da??ga Rama intiicaiing that Rome ?emml 11:54:? rap-Grim that an. Omaha: 20122;, ifs Emmi {if Twat-369113;! 'mtad 1111mm 011513? to af?rm the: R.300mm?mda?onBf thra? Medital Exe-czxitive Committee. The. res:me Sta-1m. i?ha?i: ?afi?mivxf: (Ila-3:31:16: 19. 33812.. Dr. Kanmth Sean?s; clinical primitives and. medical Staff mama-whip a??io R03116 {331mm} HOSpim} . rem and. tamlinafed.? Th?i remit 21.330 ?lm-Gama that; that imam pmimamaui?. Adm-rat: Azrticm R?po?; de?ed Dumber 24. 33121. 3113633641 1133:1219 as Exhibit 1.7.. I The caniimwd iimnsimg Dr. Sci-<3sz t0 mac-?196: medicine and surgery in the Siam 91" West Virgii?a gprasmts a patentiai immediate dang-5:2? tr}: i133 191119330 ii?ia?znmc?n as ha heal}. charged Wifh a. falcan inmlving child 3.3313313 ml-a?ng ta ch??i and. ta patiam. EUPECLESEGNS LAW 1. The. Waat Virginia Board. Medicina has a. mandate pursuant i9.- West "Virg?i?a Mama} Ragtime: A91- 10 pretax-?t the public intaraat. Waist Vigimia Cede {339% a. seq, .2. Pmbable to. substm?ata chargers of'disque?i?ca?m See-33 'fmm the pt?a?ica 0f medicine. mid. surgeiy in that State usts?: irgi 1312;: bagad 13.13am Wm": Ez'irgmia. Cede 311d 1' E: 1A 1.13.} relating 1'9 madam ?rm-wing a (1613me from the stall?arda afacceptahla 211153; piazza-?ing mica} praciice, 3-. Kai?as?fi1gimiaCoda ?3 and 1} (38R. 33 10.16 provide; that ?at: "33:33.16 datermines the Evidence in ?33 indicaiag that a physician?; mmiinuatiau in pyactic?e- or umastricm? practice mngt?u?ies 3.11 immediata danger to ?116 public; {33:313on mg}; take; my (film actiem pmvided for ii} 6} 0f this section. 0.11 a. temp?rm?y basis; and Without a. hearing, of pmmdurm far a. Ema-mg befare: thf: b?ard are initiated. simrd?amaugly with that ic-zenlpm-rm?jg action 2:316; bagin Withi? ??a?en days the aciien, Thai: ?00de 133m}! {?nder its; five. days Df?l? comm-Siam of hag-?ag 113.1%? this At: its; mg?ax 51 203.2? Wi??ii a quorum of TE-Breard mes-6am and. 'm?ng ?gs. Beard fermdj wiih 110' dissemimg mags: that made: {ac?{S and 'C?iijmQS-t??c?s; "fa-1" "Dr. Sam to cg?iirsma ?Lo-hold active Haema- "ta practice m?iis?iie 21m? surgm'y in the: State GNU-"est V?Eg-imia constitutes an immediate; danger t9 the: health, Wczifamg safes?t3! of ?the whim. The Baard' mmcluded, as a mafia? of mm {Jim Sud}. dagger-1.? {a aha public dam-ands; sx?ira?rdinary maasumgv Thareibm tha Baal?d, wifh guamm pragem: 311:1 g; {mum-i with. no digsm?ng 'v'rt??igg Eat in awmzdance with itg Mammy mandate t0 gamma: the. public imarest the Ei-Gense ?i0 pragtice medicine 213d surgery of Kamcth 333.11% See-11: Mil, License Na. 15316, mus-f be gamma-rib? in with West Karginia. Cede and 13. 03R. 3 10,16, In all (ta-ff the fem-going mam-ms: Br. Farrebeea DI: Weak? Dr. and Ms. Hm?axsm abgtainad from ve?ng due 1'0 {heir in ?it? finding of pmbabie; gauge ta Substail?afte chargeg agai'ngi'Dlz 33611 as mmnbars gf'the Batmd?s Camp}: int Cgmnit?zaa. WHEREFQREA ills Buard $113.? the. 33031"; 3.6: to practictt zinezdicima and mge?mdd by Emmi}; 3 33163. Saran MI), License: Na. 15531.61, is effac'tiva-Nwember 2013.2, .3: 11:59 NGTECE EEFIEARENG Fara-um: Wag-?E Virginia {30616. and 11 CSR 153.1%; if thsre?cu is ?ak-.613; by the Home: imi?u?m pwmwiugs for a. hearing "be-f0 the Bamd 13:11:81: bat initi-atssd sim?a?tamausly Will the ?tempozrazy aetim and. 1111:1543. begizm?hifl 1:37 days of Elflifih aci-im. {kw??m??iiJ-Di?, 36611154 mmby-mtl?ad {hat g; g. day 3301232341 that: Wiest Virginia 'Zl?eard ca? Madicime will. commas. in i?t? Gf?ceg 237i 10] Dee Brim: (Shariasg'izml, 'Wesi Virginia, with. Herschel {Ned} patzsiding as the hearing gaming-far ih?z-purposg 43f h?al?i?g avidmce with mgard 1:0 the: mailems; of ibis BREE-R. such hearing: Dr. Sam 11313.3: ?33 present perm]; and may be by {1011133811 if in: :30 desimgu H6 :112ij prasant any 3236101?. evidence Show came, 'Why his; Sesame. t0 pms?ce m?diizim- and Surge.ng the: State Vifgil?a Shm?d not be Subjfeci: to further res?fi?tion, The {wagging UE EECEZNSE AW SURGERY ?wag ENTERED and the faregoimg WEARWG wasissued this 5th. dag; 201.2. EQKARD 33 Rev. Rig}: 31:6: Pmsidm? w? i if?" IVE-23137311 Swix?mr, Evil}, ME 8 Imiiviciual Licensca Public: Emmi ?P'a-ge '1 {1f '2 WEST WRQENEA FEJEEMQ Saiurdayi Navemb?az? ?33, 2012 Erin? Egenel'fg' J??m NEW-CAL Narnia-eff: Liaamma $050.55 Time 9% Edema !aaUe-a? Lasi Renewai Laid: Expiration PMS 53?? 6 ?f ?125.3% 1 '93? 1328? 3 Other States Where Lisensea? Nurtahex'}: Pars-ma 'Bi?h'D'aie' Birth Piace: PHIUPPL WV . ?dma??m Traini?? anti ?xamfna?tSm-?zs Iype. Ssh?al Qi' H'Gspi?i?ai Gamma-ted Haifa oa-m?owmc 9F arzmgaa WHEEJNG BIS-1321 98? Exam W96: Na?or?ia?i Beards Foreign Graduate: Ni?; License Named: Cfarreni ?t?dmase? CGnta?'Type' Address Cam-hr . . i GENEFAL 2.130 . Work Lasa?on DRIVE WV 252% R-QAME Pf?fErr-Sd RQANE GENEFML 200 NN-E Ma?ng Adidreas BRWE WV 25236 i?urren?' 6::me Af?iiatmng n- Na Curran?t-Sam-pany on Rama? Summit WV Ha?g?a? Hogpf?a! Name: my {County} Filed Date RDA-ME GENERAL HOSPITAL SPENCER amen-i amniai?es {Se-f??esignat?c?) Rank Sim-c?aiiy E5962 Specie-35y Name FP FFXMELY ?mm-n-E?upemiksim ?Na Supervisier infarrnaiiom can R?coz'd ?iga?g?na Sa?sag -- No Di?gcip'iime Cases an Recsrd f?aipjrac'zim -- we Maiprac?aa- Ramrcis Fauna? ER Samar-net?s .shau?d {aka ting fa?iawing faciora iniu amnesideraiim Wham evaluating a physician?s mmpetenae 'fmm maiprac??ce- data. a A numbe?r-of studies have been mnducied is idsnii?iy-in-dicamrs of gamma-dam mare amazing phys?cians. Thaiais rm comigsiv? eevitience ?ne: malpractice data csweiates with pmfessiana} comps-313mg. a Therea- agazais'ai?iety a? factors unrelated is prai'essionai competence Or-canduciwhich affect ?the iikaiihood ?that a physician-Mi} fhe sut?g?ec: eff-3 malprac?ca ciaim, such as, the physician?s fin-:53 in prarrtice? the na?um affhe spa-many, the types cf m?en?is' free-tam geagrap his Eacat'ion; eta. Fm example: {semis-z medicai spam-3mg have a higher rate cf'rnsipra'stice cia?z-na because 0 WW3 {33-1 In?ividuai Licengee P'abiigs Rmm?d 'Sefdame'nS of maipr' 9503 cases Fay- insurer? ?min-Gr. 053mg", it Is teas for the ins highar inherent to th :2 ?e?d of pm af?ne. ca companies; are sometimes .l?xandied a3 imam-395 deaiS?io'ns. in ?{he case of 50is man-ca company to 5:339: a monatar?y :satl'iemeni than ii is fof'i'heam it: take the vase Er: u? or admissicm cf gu?t an ?ha part ihe physician? Spraciice aefima orc?aim ahoum not he canstrued as seeming a prasump?aiam that Medina! COM Many?rimessucih cases are. sei?ed without a ?nding 01? fa A p-ayn'mnt in sei?emem 0f 23' medioa? malpractice, has o'ccurred. . .. . End of Rap-m muww. .. . . . WMmem. .4 n? 0:45; 5-. 1 33mm WEST magma. 35w. (ZGURT Ra 3.116 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA. f? 3 My Case Na: {?amed}. Seen Market SireeLApf; ?7 Spenczm WV Misda'zzmamr 236-3031}? Sou" 123:7":sz Li??xm? E?tu?g??rzm AL i, i?iht: undersigncd campiainant, upon. my aa?h. af?rmaiiam Bram this {Callaaving is. ter and mum; the. has: of my ISIS ?71} 2 Rag?me I {65113} Virginia, if; ?i?d??ggsz 117-373.. Gait": (?aim Spaciffc secffan, g?-?xectfwa knowisd-gaand Bake]? 0:21 a; ab?ui in . Sammy; 'Wega? mdk?br subdhrisfa?. as app?m?iggammy afaff?zzmj {3m .Abusa mam-mg. 1:23;: amqu (imam) Emmy sham? Asaauix?lw?? I Eartha-Siam that this-wmplaint is based {m thz: f??owing facts: Sac arms-bed C'eniimuadeh aita?hed Shaet?? yes Ems Cm this complaini, sworn. m: af?rmd bafom and Sigma this dais, by complainan?t if} my gamma-e; ghe- 1?5mis) checked balm? apply: :Qamp-[ainar? (who 5119;362:131 bafwre Hammaaig Name- .xW?Pz~obah1? cauggfoii-n? Adm-E35? Summons issmd 39%ch ?HWazfrant {j WEE'rantleg? arm: Tramps?: {pi-?Ob 11:36 fa?'?d - Q-ffi- Mia, iflany KMMg?ff . @hgi??imia Signa?fu-rh ?53? 3,?wa Cm?F-?mem Sigmth wag, Ci, Crkm. Ruiea m5 201.3 11:58N?i? Ne. fif?w .5 :74; I {Grimm} Compiaiur Canaan-M} If}! 12 I was re'quegteati Said-welt of the, Spar; car City Paiice arimmt to invests a 3% {i ahugs compiaiat inva-"iving a it? i?ar swim-Bic- andk?r, Katmai}; Sam; am: an? Chrigiian. Semis v- o?lmma Coum 3 baited in 32105:", Cai?waii mates-d rim 11h: -- w- Km 5 an iemplgayac 5f the City an? maid bf; mum ?_?m1fe?ahi; wit?ri agency the i110i-dem._ an?m'sme {13:6, a?h?ppmazima {5137 133:0 hangs Ibegzm Enhamewing i?he trimih? mm mm: Su?-Lam? igx?garg- The Vii?ifim MM m5 {11311139171 piak?a? himarzd his up take them :0 ohms}; an 0.133321%: 0'73 391?, in ihswming. 371:; viciiuxs?i?ted :1th hi: was aitting can sled igas?vaz? the entrance. and had 115:3 knife: and can phmm. The victim-L siaicd aha? Mn. Sam ins-me?ed. him is gatdowan and ha'di?; The victim W?ni {m as say that ha was: it: g0 13an up and garhjs phone and? knif? and Mn Seen gmb?sed him absutt?mweigc and gm gmun?? Thg-vic?ng wanton by that Sega get 611; mg hack and mm punching him wizh 0103a; fists yep gated-Ega- ?m Victim grated :hatMr. mole him inio {he war of the; WEE-ding and; pus?lmci him ma?a ?it: r8331? gamma T75: vig?m Qatari that I13 :1ng 34133611 man slappad him-amss ?16 face; 3' spake. wiih ?rms other Emma ga My?: anti. 3mm tim?s. Ail. of them remix-mad {ha inoi'zimt di?. Ni} csihcr a?uiig Wm pragem-af rim: {Ems-?13m Ensi?mt, WEIR: - whim daiemzifmi; m3. WW ms Fink-m campin?nmt Ggi?mm? 33:19, @5552 . /Zf? 4-7 F5 a: (Skim-inn? Cam-piai'nt. 'Cl-i??d abusecwatmg aha risk (if injury Any pagan was; amistag a 511:3 hjr-?m abusc cream Muhmmia? six}: of gamma bad-?g? :?njury a: {it-am BMW 11m imvfuiE-Y and imam nix-313? makes rm?- tfact of an ilas?l?ng m? pmwm?ig mm? 3mm 9f gummy a: unl?wf?i an Emcmionaii 'causass harm K3 maths-r gargm .3 maul; ?zzy puma W110 mxiaw?i?y- attempts $0 commie: a Vi?l?nt injury in aim of 31-10mm? or unlawfmiy ct?nm?sii? am am; ?mp?aceg work-Tsar fof- inmmr?a ?515; raceiviug 3. 913026sz injury mm $123311 swam-31exam-143:3- ?it? Hm: a ming?iaimm abiding-Q's ~pmagwiar TELEWXM was MMISTMTE CGURT a? Rama {3 TEST ERG-EN 1a.. STATE WEST VIRGINIA Kenn?lth Ema. 23%? @w ?322.32: 1:1 Ma?wt Shea: Apr, 7 3333mm Address: Mil-3:; $3138.23}; gmial- Driver?s Marin?3a Ni}. Eats O'fi?ifth E1 CRIMINAL COMPLAENT 13 the midsrsigmd mmplainani, 12pm mafih m: af?nina?m, state; the; fallowing Emma 3:35 can:th to the best 91" my .knawiiedg? and hc?iaf, On about ?En. . Roan-e: Male) Country, Was? ?igligfginiia; ?in x?iola?dn of 333.1%. Ends (aff-e maxim, and/hrszibdfvisfm (ZS Emery 61-39%) the; ?id (hare smirzzozy Mammy afg??Tcei-zsg} I further Siam {hat this aomPIaim: is 132L366 on the fe?owing facts; Sas-afi'achcd {20:111de O'?att?ChEd sheet? Eyes Elm) Complainant (who appeam be.me magistrate); Eam?z??; EL. Nam@ Roadigpencar, - Add :36 as Spam: 'F?iaphome Emogar SIRE ear-tibiae, 152m}! Sggmamra Mac- ?311, Srim mags 3, (H 1 1-9-3- Ora Skis. mmplaimi-a swam a; af?rmed ms: and I signed [his date by campia?mni in my pram {:65 i ?aws} abmka?. f?mwB-Pmbabi? caus?e "fmm? "Er Warrant; igmcd "Wmm?ms prQb-abl? .na. :36 Emma f?mf/wz Wight: {ct-1:11: Gram Ya;an ma Fink .w campkinaht Gei?anmd New. 1. - ?0,955.52 .{Criminai 'Caingla-im Cnn?mm?} 8-312- - can}; to 39523631? to {11? a in :13: an 5333.111: wimuzi?md can has: Esther, Mr, mad wag-mi}! byskenzhia. Th2: victim .isqa x?asidem- a? (imam: Hospitai aims at: ??mnsia and va?mumcd R3 F?auc??ncml {m the dais cf ino?danis my mama utms-farmd to Cabai Haggis/1?; far imam-1mm My. mad that 31w was iufm'nrmd Mg, and was G?n?n?d to his Bic-d, Mg, Roam 63:16:33 that hair fathar 3m: mam-?11?? @011 gm: of his gnawing phi?icim, Dr. Sat M3. . {Hat rim: amnding mum-g did {11:29:21 bicmd from he: fa?imr?s fact 5%"meth an itch- {mm his mum. fai?ad 33113 was in?amed that Dr, Saga Eravaieri f0: Lat-fishes: "faugh?i' ma autimistation f0 use and di?closs pratasted- Mam; The ?On. Co?ay?s date: and Lime Ms. EHQWS ?icWaat Virginia Stats 13950:: t9 808655 MI. xmdieai rec-arm. 93:1 ThursdiaygS'agten-lber 3E9, 20:12- at approxima 1:635! ham-35 I refxieved racocdg from-Ream: Gena-mi Hogpital in ma?a it} ?11.23- Ammag the: i2'3f91'111a?c3n in {km 3 E3315 for}! an mam?azai?nn c-onduamd insidean s?aye?ad by Mm, 115.1: of a parsim; of Dr; Stan?s- {0113113. Th3 of Mr In thempo?, Di: mom; that an ?115 prevfmm awning, Mr. regi?? aim was. char 1735i. Sac-2n sa??ght medical 'trcatmm?it, Tim raped" miss that hare was no injury to Mr, A arid that-ha: (Sid not wish tin?; mien-ts of .6116- pravigms waning. I. obtaimd 33am}: for Dr. Sam?s; mcdicai momds gcm?mmd ?rm-x. Ch: 1:1ig11f of [116 gray ?nvasi-iga Liana sawdust/m by the hmspiiai? CM 13133323 obEaiacii said mfmhatiab; and c?bztaintzsi-amwg other it'smg's, Dr. Sam?s Dz: 3x331: claimed thatMn m?cmd {m him it) carpe- 131*. Sean. oomp??zagi andin {hat momma} Ear. . wished his: Magma and mum 33st, Siam him and 121:1: Dr. Sm?s? Incmory fag-16.5.: Hm grammar (Liaigrsad that. 11:: pain and Erioedx I aim abrained the; mamas {ref thannrseg and mat landed to Dr. Sam 13m: 01min 20:} WEEK i Z, I thainecl a Dr Wile was the: ER. ?esta: s: Roam: {E'ancrai and {em?eci 332;. Sean! Dr, azamd had a. significant particm this. tanlguc- bit sand the injurywa'ssa that Dan Stan couid dona?t to pramnted with Dr. 3&6:ng gamma at" how it wippched; mad that it amid nor, be; true.? if}; ?xpiama? ma: in arda?r form, Sam?s giafmmi it: in: Mr. 150' "hit: his. own ?ags hi addition, 33:; fouls? moths able: {a pick 11;; any ?16331? 1:31; alone 33:; Saon?g Raid an is: 5:1 {311 1.911 63512.; I obtaiinad amtemema {mm 3:516 nursing sniff th at tar:de [a bat}: Dr? Saar: and My Ii. {33/3 1.112. nursing mid an: that Ma was, mm: taxi/3mg any of {ham bcfma or af?x ?le: incident with Dr, 36$3f1<_ Thay?aii $130 agr?ed that Mr. 333's. able to cmyauz' tha aciimxm degmiba?'by Sean, Sax-Fara! of aha n'gaciicai gaff giaimezd. mama Seen was? an 139mg sampummhai'hit hit eff hi5 tang; a 0n 13,1 a?miaed mdicai records fen ham?a', Sta?x: Wag-mfcm? Em?. mainme Smm?3 amounts ;_Eff?z?ni ?an: mast-2; he: pmvi?ed to 3?33. Wi?i?v ran-am (Ema-n d?fm?anr - . . Piu??. - a} dim? {Crian .Cma'spl-aint {fora?naed} Emmy 51w2~9? H. Ii 323-?: ??gu4gi 8&3?fo who unlawfuily and imam-Emmy makes physisai mat; a: of an insulting; or garmrokalg with she person cfamt?cr er amm?i??y an inmnziamliy causes physisai harm re gnome; pi?man Whig: mum Gist-m defendant. . _9 3 In: saga-$21; ?w Fink Bai?mmi 443mm:sz New, ?in 2'81? 153% 95G: @453 JEN THE CQERT mm ARREST Scam af Was: Virginia - Case Nags). a: I (.2me ABUSE cma?m KENNETH saw 1mm? bei?h?d??t STREET A?dma? Emma WV 225275 Law En??armmn?t Of?cz?zr: iihES com 1133 fom?hd pz?e'babia 831253 {a Emiiave that ricfamdam; RENEETH SEEN in: c: an. affanse. ox?uffa?sas in this County on the; 3'7} day GCTOBER 3 ?f?xricms- ta ?at: Banana-a aft-I133 Warrant: uniawfuii?? [3mm Margmge- ?fof?i?m 1th abuses 3 (him ?fid by the; abuse cream a. Substantial} risk of scriaus injury {Ii-l" 531?? ?ea?th to the ?hiic?i is feign}; arid; Upon wuViCr?on thama? shaii be fined 11m: mom {ham :hziea thaw-and daiia?i?g anti cen?'ued ta this: mgm?y af?x: ?-EVIgi-cm of carmgtiam far not has-.3 than. one m: mare than five wag. 5 agaigxstiha grams and cf the Sta-m Timrafam 3?01: am imhg name {if the 3631?: {if WastV-irgini?a to appz?ta?zezzd {1:26 abmfmaapm? dafm?ani and: gamma before, my magimata in. this County; as be: c153}; mm 121 Lieia?on the: simgeis) ascmdinfg'?a lam Thia ES E9 be. Executed if; thf; foilmwing 1133mm: (chick 0325}: Eartlmim [3 Batman the; ham-*3. 0f 9 am and 4 pm?, Mnn?ay fin?WEE} grid?y 1:1 Grim}: (gm. Sp865?feg33 warm this :31 day 01" OCTQBER 5 291.2 M5?ng Ni? Emcu?ea? by; . 3:31 Saw?y, WEag-j an; {Bate} tic-36w 5643?3; Mag. aim. Essie 36:52an {@195 1391: BN2 WEQAE "3c 9535; Hg QGUHTE 03F WEST Fm: wwg?f Emit} {sf West Viygin Ea V, Cassi: 131311-996 - Bame bait-mam 21 .Add?tess T20 Any Law Eiifarmemcnt Qf?gm?: WHEREAS this court has found probabis mum 1:0 beiieva {113% the tiafandant, SEEN {did an ngsz15& or af?anses ibis issuance, this erant, by tz-nlawfuiiy [Ef?e smmz?ary Ri?gi?fg?i of'qfeizxgajj If any per-sen uniawfu?y and.E?J?amicnailiy physio?i maniac: of of}: pziovnkjing'ng?ium with i225 gamer; =2ag-0E?cm: u'niawfu?y physical harm. to 3mm? pagan he si?gali b-?-g?ihy aria I'ni-sciizmcamr ail-*3? upon canvictim, .ghaii 33$ j?i? far not mam than (wake; mag-Lib 3! Dr ?nde QO than {in drag dag-Hal?s! Gr bath ?nch-fun? and agaii?zsf the peace-and igglity of ma Stats?, - ?lm name. as? mag-tam afth Virginia appmhend' the ab-wananwi ?-cfen?am 54w magigf?r-?att: in thig?ounty; i0 with in rela?im t9 i116: charge?s} awarding to law. TEE-arms: ism be macaw? in ?lm f??m If;ng laminar {cfzecic 02w Baby-ecu ?rm-hour? 0f 9 and 4. 13311?- Mmday fhm?g?h Friday 061-621" (ks spas-Wed}: Givm ?nder my Emmi this mug} day 0f RETOBER 3 3f} . xw??yfi?, - i Magi?rzsic Exegu tad. by: .. En .Coun?tj?a {m {33m} '50 xii-3; Magi. GE, Grim, 4 R6 mm. . .. B?cm?am? swam 3.25 Fiig 2012 gm P. 9 EN TEE 015? - RQAEE Ef?gy V?i?l?f?g ESE. img'r Sfatc- Elf Was: Virginia Case gsyawgg SEEN Defm?ani. 1 2'1 STREET ?ndings- WV 25225 2% Anj Law Ei?hfaz?tament ?f?mr; WHEREAS thi?; Cami hag. prehabia Gati?? ??70 b?fiave {hat'if?ia {Iafem?aiag did Gaza-unit. an affenge-m- in ?i'hig County (2211 {ha day of GETS-BER. mm praxximmfo ?113 of "Wauer by m?awfu Ely [Same graham}? {bog Emmy. m- {$31131 parscn [?liawfully-and inmrimm?y makes p?ysica?a miact afan inguiting or wanking nature with the. parser; as? summer or" :uul'msrfuiiy and intan?cn?ally 03:18:23; physical harm to anoi?nar 33613011., 1163 3112511 135 gnaw {3ng awn miwmi?m shal'i Em con?ned injafi for mat mom that; Mews: mamhg.? ?nad not more than five hundrad doi'l'argd as? bath such fine mt} imp?wnmxiz. again-3fth paws and diguiiy {?fths $51135, Thm?fmm are? cm?mm?a?i in ?it? Ram?? 0f {hf-3 Sm (31?11? 63:: Virginia to amalgam-11m abovawnamed defaude and mag-mag magi?i?a?m 1:2. This- Cmmt? in Eng daai?: with. in rsiation E5 @513 chazrgafgs} awarding :0 law, This is to be $X$Ci?f?d in; {he fciiowing imam? (aback Forthwi?l Eamw? {ha-hams 0f 9' a,in._ am 4 mix, Mmday thraugh Fri?ay Other (:23 swayed}:- ?nch? my {land this?. day 0f 3 232:; x? ff 5 g?wafx? um WA Ema-13m by: in. 9.931113, QR. ME. {395% 50%?3; Mag; Ct: "Grim R1116 'Rmm'm I [j 'b??fandmr Ci F515 EN THE mm? 042:? QWTE MES 11? Vm?m? 53% {3f W?st Virginia y: - Saga. lzemm?gg KBR-NETH - A333UL3W w. Befcnd?nt .E II A??m-s-s swam. WV 352%- Ta my Law ?rm-mama; am": WHEREAS th?g courtham-f?umi pmbabla cans-c": 1:0 beiiam that the: d'?fendanf; KEIWETE SEEN din" cmnm-it'an c?f?emse Cir a?e?se: in. dais County on the_ ciay of OCTOBER 2012 p-rmri-ms t0 the i58U? ca {31? {big Warrng by unlawfully [Sm-?2 ofq?isseg?s? If all}; p?ai?m? HI?awfnliy attempt-s m. 6611;1er a. violeni; injury :0 pamen cf ana?har cagmn?g an which in apprehmsion of immadia?e?y metamng 9. 39353536 injury, he shall be gu-i'lty'of amigdemeazmr and?pgn Cam-ic?m Sh?li b?-icmk?n?d in jaii for mi mam {hem sh: maniihs} ms mares: (Mia?s, a: ham and; ?ne and 6-1 agaimt-tha paw-3:6 Eli-1d dignity 0f {ha 'Stata. $013 P1176 in 316 mains afiha State: sf Was: Virginia in app-mheud the abovczanamed defen?ani 331d ?l?i'zig tha?p?rscm ib?fom any magis?g?aig E11 thia Gaunt be dealt with in relation it} {?16 chaz?ge?s) awarding 13:0 324w. Thig armst Wazmm: i383 be executaa?i ?in. {his-3 f0 ?ow ingmaa'z r1631: (?23313223633391 me-hwith gamma. {31$ {19.241.13.053 am. and: 4 {3'me Monday thmu g1: Fi??day' ?fi?ar {225 spam ?iwn 1:115:31? my hand [his 31 day Of pm 5 2612;- A. 7?1? JW Magi-?g; mammal by: . if; {imam cm (Date) Cadm? Mag. Ci; Grim. Rule: 4 133mm a Q?'g?gmm mm 1? 2:31:21 Maia. ?31? Frmn.-um.mm NEBIUNHL JAN- 304 3785 250-3 335.29? gm 2m . I Ha. 1193 IN THEMAGETEWE mum ?25? mumm {273% a? Eris ?fginiu a . 1 Ca??minai ?25135 Numba?a?z . Harm #723 - a Def?z??m? {Fuli Mama) z: - a- L-Etzaaw- Nag, Campiui??f?c?a: WT A I 15? 51?5- ff I. I a {3:11:35 Hf BM 1 A. QR 50m The; m-czgi?mla has anar?i'nacihm ?xafi am shurged w?h the .off?mefej Of and if am [afar ?ounr? 4:51:21 p?sfa'?ihl?a ?gmiwl?as Gigi-{3mm m?n?af?wy and muxfmum ?x . . ?19in 7?22 E?z?w ?33mKama? as? 4 . "Mp 252? $ng "Th5 {.?aglsimfe Has ihf?tmezi ma :th ff'ika Cadga pz?mwidas: :er jail i ham-gm righi? 'Erai rap-magnian hwy-cm gammy mi" awry fu?fiar pra?am?ng and-?1731; if quz?i?g as Easing um 521-5. {9 1m 'hfr'a an weir/may; b3 appoinfe? {a rapmmni' me, Uh?dea?smnf? Eff ciew'?e Ea raps-"63m? mime-1'5; 5 Emma? Wm" ci'gI-m thc?x? wag: daniad my {Igh?i his: by an a?amay. MUST INITIAL Qiji?? GFTHE FENALTY IS- Fag-51M; i giva tip: my rigid? ?ftr ham an warm? r'?apmaani m3", 53-? - 1:3} 1mm 31% (if? u?amey E11: ram-33m? mm a i want an ?HQmay cz-pgminieci it; :?epragani' me.? i fha?L if Ham ?mi-133:5 gu?-M 5.. might? 133$ required m?ra?nbmga SiciEa {Ur a?mmay E6 93 @395: ?le Gig-Um gzgpaihfi?aci aliasing}? appmvat? 2?33 ram-a am? m? "mm: 20121250P-M Framiumrrm ?E?iiU?mL JML 8.0053(1ng FF. 3 #20? 3 $93! 685 We, 304 ?65 2399 11:2? Hays. 3332 i?i?r? Appa?mma: ?ighi? 93138 2 of 2 I 3w 9 "Th-a mczg'isfm a. has infarmad ma ihm?; {52:89: fgr"ar?yf??aay offal-25:3 Furwhicfz 3w p?en?if?? HES fmprigon?wn?ig at. 'mag?isirmx may mimiya ma 15mm cw?adyswala am ngi??g far {MM-rpreca?z?ags {an $55: .gmgati-aimm- f? (gm abie 3'3 maich hdi?l genera?): as" ngEmwg$5125 mm?f?r?ag??ea masomkigv?ma gm gmjg?mgiy f9 gag: Wm} Cm magma? mm ma?a or whiz? pea-man far ?she-gaumom r35: ?biai??ng mum-6P9? {if arming:an ija?fiu Ike: magi-s mE-a hag-3 laf?fmaci ma?a? da mi have: i?naisfif: any f0 ?azyuf-ga mike-r 333% m. Staf?mgnf?- in-ihfs-?awrnenf and 3?th any sfai'?m?ianf {it} ma?qr?; may be: 35*? 6:58-3:13? me. Hg mamas; QM. "$136" mcagi'ai?q?a hm! infarm?'ci ma?a}! ham" a. rig} mf-?u?tify; {half Mm a" rigm? rg. frail by afar}; 5r by-q m?g?imfawih?mgd fury; mm. mm if {pig-z?giwm Erir?, magi?fub km {Mama} mg Elm? I ham-Jen ma ?ght: is dsm?mi :3 Emmy ?me and fhai?, if} Wan? a-ib-WfirEGH mam? 1-33 couri? kmw'ih viri?ng? he fhutn 33!} ddy? {mm dam QF ?En?i?ai' appear-nnw or, {waive ?sjf?gwippmini?ai {5&235?33; 23 days {mm iha dais ihai? an meme}: it: uppein?md- Thai. ?gs furihar ini?onnad ma kiwi I CEF?m?-hr?i :5 Eu irir?, 315mg} may no? wi??dfdw my darian {01? :1 My fri?i Ef?m 12mm tri?ing aimm?y 2033331113 in? {he w?ih?rm?ai, {f I 333, w; fary?i'a'Lw?Mn ?-ha 2&de paid-:5; 2 huge dim E's-sash infamm?? {ha-s? g?'va up my right it; c: 3mg; Matt: ma?g??rqf? Mm}: tr; o. '5 a a; 'azziih-cs?r?a 1 335:3 thaui?gh?}! weigh appmi of a nj?atxgkimia Cami canvia?m MB m?r mm 0: gm; Eriui zip-wk mud. 3. UMaaian? er; wa?ihmxi? haw in, ma fury fee WEE Em ?laxm?i??ed amine} ma ?sf-i rm mmr?cfadi L- may Th?w'mczgisifc?a hm; Enf?rmgd we {may draw ham gihmgead MEET a fanny, hov??ia- H15. rigf?ai'a- Cy?? a whe?w 3%de i333 bw?d pregazgfa?nn ?n is grainswar-mm pra?mi?mr?y 319M373: - .. 3 {Ex} a a 1 - I. [lg-g? 21-01? in}; aiffnm'a?v?f Enfmranriha ce??wh?lhaz? Waf? a2: pre?mimw ?aming: 11; un?arsfara? ?553.? E?i??g??am is: in?rm H123 muz?i E?odaya ?ni'??aa "as: half an? {inges- Ei" bum ?as- {izrbc?l w: a. {mm amt-Mo a: ihczf 321a 5:35am}; gharga??g?mb ma aver far. poasib?g grazar?a?m a grand gar-y, x534? . f? D?giamj?mfa ?gm?i?zre.?5g?u a. a 613E ?aw; Wit-mi 111:1?d?iy?hf??ti?n??i??f?? 9- ?f?fmg?d ?313.55 daf?n?c?m giam'gria?ly ?gg?mi?a h?e?g?ai??i? knawiz?zgi}: .. .m i. .f?zg?a??mf mogm?a?'gm ti??r?mwmmi d?hg glme?aMagE?jg?f-. 1? 2311? 1- p: Flu-mmum.nm, r?f?uzwwu ML 334 23133 ?53152in in, N61. ?133m. MEI-193 f3} a THE Mmzez?m?m ?10113? j. ,f 3% .32 .54? 63% f, csEWaat Wrgiraf? 'g?y?A/T :23? @rivm?a Limarisa him-1mg: Big-1h Dam gg?g?i?} J: ?2 Taiaphone mi'fihe??) {Bali gammy-st per Gimme: mm Sbai?i SamrEL-y- E?timher ?TE-gamma. BAIL AGREEMENT: we: mmwsi?gfmm Em, 'Thg-das?el?ant {ha [i?iffafa?aj df??r?ademag??: {If e?anggi'slgf . $122and'tmvEng? . W. y. 15m fem: af??iffefang) cash m- k313th this; cam-t hem?! SEES 994 1W ?53 65' - $132!; cash andpargonal remn'izatm will Wei-3i 31931;?wa 3194 ?39d 333653533; 3; iag?i?cngm-mf mummi?ed? RELEASE 33.31? ifsdm?tmi in MEL neiar??ma . (ilaf??n?f?tWiEfg?gg agreaa: . J. - r3? Ti; i?a thi? cam a-i fh?} a if 3.53? mi $136315 EB .ap?sE-?fed Inca Quilt?Ea nf-h?a?ng iha?? E11 55: 11283355 at 22139113 adi?fr?s?'ff?r Bifhar'?giffgf ?12593} n?ii?daramg?uaj-plea pmmemng or met er - - (my pmlimwhaa?w; 3-, ha yawn: para: ?191.11}? many {has 1&th char ?45} and-it; shay an grammar oz?arilsauedby- :1th tinge mmut? mug un?l this: my [ha c?muu may: hag (Hap-med 9me ma?m wan mizlc-? a 1:232 1352mm herein may $3?)in ?m ?ajgin sewing jau Gr'p?m?i ?me as: ard?rad by {bit dEapmamg {2mm Ef Eil?fmuz?i a fudgmam m" gum {he offcmaigi} t?arged andimpcaae a pawl-{y oftmmem?on; mum ma Many change af mm a; 91:15:33.3: or (dammit; numijer; *fin afWeam-Iginia mm Wr?ten We?: 53s.. "Fa hat-Vioan any-3mm .br'fad?r?fii?wif?s Tag-{awe 1m dim; orfaci??rs?i :cmm'ac?i' vs?h ?omi?if fa E5113 ma?x?m T2: wim- mafa??wrmg axial-aim? can?i?om?e?) of mama: Th5? dafa?dan?imo V?dm?uda 31?? a?mgmhaa if he m? aha Es admi?e? i9 hail am {10.33 mi MEI ma Exams am? 55mg? {ha tux-Emil amaznni Ea sumaci to {Mama mg 233 iacmamd; ?m?i Lamar vizi?iim argue-h {arms and mm?f?mm 332;}; {mg-wad: anti than if darmudani Emma Eijigwigmm {Fm may WEE ha axaumi?d 5:15: ma- mah mans-432.: mum-d 3% 33a ?r-agx?a?gg er. {Ext-3 wm?mimca' mifii?ai - 1' 9?5" gala Magisir?ta magma I ?Sam a - Mia . batsman: W. 955%?! 4 Him. 1 20m 2:02w- .4 ?ftiz?mvrm Emma 39-4? 765 2:31:22: ?mam-{3 11:35 gig-j 11 2-1312 mam . {39-3 #3 - Pg; ?7 - 525' . Casai?f?a mg BE {Magiamfa {aid sz?afam" campfm mfg: am 01? 259 :?ffowfm?) SASHA Tim dam?ammgamm dsfendanf?eaehamw - ?mg I {magma $955173} @kkW? if 233% fh?V?} 535-35} 533% War mum's} ?maumhafzg wk a?ibf??' Ere i?zm? ?Sm? Ei?f [111$ "Hy-vim.- 2? gags-QHRL The; und'srgigmeii dafandan'fan his {w Em awn r?'z?ggnizanm {ti-?es {mm-{a {a {Weft a of? -- {a {m ?aked 3mm: if ha DIE-fit} faffa Eo- dummy mi: ma apac??c? mime; am? mm?i?ma 53% mm 3mm 31 Ram (38 NEANCE. Th9 Un-d?r?fg?ad hwy,? "mfg - {?zf?f?-wn?ffag afr??lpf?c?eei?i??f by. {rammigmma mm gig-15:; agfan-dmifg h?haf? ?5933 era?s Lindaz?akg in a 334m msnayjaqu?m {Isa amwaiiar b-e?ridiff {Ema??fandam fail; in asm?fywli?a aha spas-Eric: {is-mm was? acacia-ans ?at 911.? abnm ?fu?if?aa?m ?531?in (infizzaf 631a} ?gm; is 112.2% {mam-{L am 1mm 13% Inamrgxomm hawk: Wm {amass-sq man Am (ML QEGQ WW "3 GEE, E?ha defendang on the ma?a ndt?'si'a Mimi?! {:18 n33 yaw} {mfg} :fapns?ied Main 952%: the tori-*3? 1:1 {31$ anmm-M? oxw?hfch .., 5m 3 33 35mg; 1 a bag, a; amid} 12:: 'fmfaiied If {he daf?adzm?de SE mimmgiy Wi'fh tha?i?ugms and. wtagam Adai??bnaify, {he andmi?gaa? darem?nmn his miner min mmg?nizanm .doag mama?ze-ms-fdrf?im gum afr?m?i?? m. 9:3 ?ame?it?fi?? mm: ha dram faila can:va z?ak'agad?a {term}- armf a??di?an? mt ma?a-Exam, i a, ?2315?: defendanth 0:1 ih-Q?dafan?anfn ?ahaii?i {mam (if cm? d?p?SEEQQ-izj? any) .ha?'i'?ng ;.dapa.aii.ad cam; ?11 [?33 mama f$ Mm. Mhia? rapmaanirs i9 {imam @316 ball Brit? Which ha fsrfafmdm?a ?ai?an?a?nfdu as; hag-amiy wi-Ei'? Kim? tame. E?'d'?oni?iiana m?mt 32m, gd?i?manyq ma . 3 i1}! mist]; EH9 farm if}? - _9 my Mg )1 fn'?amfbg 311mm 3.2g; {5 5i {Amp Eff}: Sf??kffl?? 33,3 ah. {ha diamante ?sh'ai?. {?9543 mic u?da?ehe is roifafra aim: of mqnay?quag percent af-iiw ba?'ift?a ?sfamfan?fa?s gm; gpg?f?l} {arms- and a mi mum. A. guzli?mimn Mammy {5:13sz am 52 1mm :53 a gum?$5] Is a? "fa notrsquig?g d; Emma, is J?ma'rparatad harm by raf?ranw. mg 11931:; BEE-1.35111 Ag mg ?ha hair, I {ma} .dn- a: "NH-dc: mi asa?a?n?fa 313 3g g?i?sa?un 2:1; isman ma?' ?ag?a?ielkw? {533' 94?ij dispoafng 5mm Tar; ?ery; ?fuiigmani of grjlif: again?t {its .d?afartdmi, x7. - #1452; ., ?35216: ham: 5' 5125;531:35de that! ham Wad sand agm the 521m tam and tam-?ame 5351233! Ear mama: stigma fag-eat? fa-bsrEWd?umga-ignammox any ma?a mid {We Other Dpp?s?df 333? Email; ngzf?i 533 613:5 {31' Bap 051:9? m?amiy??i?mm mm?) :nga-ggag'wmm A?cm?i?g?k? m3 samthareby appra'vea bent! {urine ?efmdm and ems-Ra ?at; wn?mmd?w?m er: zsaifrarr: gm?n?y? ,x-?zz mM-jgy :awie??geqfhei?ara me am: {his ff?. . . I - $2.1 Mfg?22; my. {531: {af?x am {m 23. Tm: 31.6% . . EH5 C3 Emmaer u: 3' 77min- Exhibit Redacted Exhibit Redacted BEFQREJ THE 33%? MEIEFECINE WEST Magma 5931f? F?s??igmen V, {l?mg?aim SEEN, (Ema GEL L, Rebama. L. Stepm Diaciplinm?y Chm-31361 fer the 'Pa?iiomr 335.633? Virginia Beard Medians: {10 118er certify that on :Nmember?p $312, I cam-mi the. foraging ?Order of Summry Empean of Licema?o- P172101qu.i?fviiadimine and Surgery .zmd Ngiim (3f Ewing? ix: 133 save-5:1 upon Kenneth 32111183 Sean: M. at: Keansth 313.155 Seam M..D-. (via Hay-azi?efivery and '1 1 Maszet Sims: WV 25276- Kenneth Jazz-163 Seen, MD. (via Cerig?edg?vfa?i) R0 51.1163 (363116181. f?iimspiml 52.00. Drive: Simmer, KW 252?-