Atik, David (DOF) Subject: Attachments: FW:CEZARY PODKUL - (ProPublica) (1) (061716) 20760622LL0135.pdf; 20L60622L70056.pdf From : Cezary Pod kul [ma ilto Cezary, podkul@propublica,oro] Sent: Friday, June 17, 2016 L0:42 AM To: Koszer, Gerald (DOF) Subject: CEZARY PODKUL - (propubtica) (1) (061716) : Dear Records Access Officer: Pursuant to the New York State Freedom of lnformation Law, please provide me certified copies of JS1 benefits for the two BBLs listed below: BBL 100972000L (Stuyvesant Town) BBL 100978000L (peter Cooper) Attached is a sample of the record I am seeking. lt is a DOF-certified copy of J51 benefits for another property. I am seeking this record for the two BBLs listed above. Request for fee waiver a' co J'",i:",'j¿iiffi'l'jH:i:ii: or la understanding of operation ad il:3i,i:T,',iaiver ce and it-s Request for electronic delivery provide address: ex Please email email me an PDF, if it is available in that format, and email it to me at my delivery is not possible for the responsive documents, please umenté to my åttention at the below mailing "dár"rr, Cezary Podkul ProPublica 155 Avenue of the Americas, 13th Floor NewYork, NY 10013 Request for prompt response lnformation am ea The New York Freedom of requesting will take longer than this any-or all of this request, please cite notify me of the appeal procedures ava of five business days. lf access to the records I am e when I might expêct this information. lf you deny justifies thirefusal to release the information and Please kindly confirm receipt of this request at your earliest convenience; I can be reached atg17 512 O2lgwith any questions about this request. Respectfully su bmitted, Cezary 1 or Department of Finance Lcgal Division 345 Arlams Street 3'd Floor Brooklyn, NY I l20l-3719 Tc1.718.488.2498 Fnx 718.403.3650 David C. Atik Attorney The undersigned, being an attomey duly admitted to practice in the State of New York, hereby affrrms the following under the penalties of perjury: L I am an attorney of the New York City Department of Finance ("Finance") 2. I have directed Finance employees to locate the records requested by the attached request dated June 17, 2016. 3. The attached nine (9) pages are a true and correct copy of original records in Finance's custody. 4. Records filed with Finance, or prepared by Finance, are entered at the time of the events they record or within a reasonable time thereafter. Entries into Finance records are made and kept in the regular course of business of Finance, and it is the regular course of business of Finance to make and keep such records at the time of the events they record or within a reasonable time thereafter. 5. I am duly designated to make this affirmation. Dated: Brooklyn, New York June22,2016 David C. Atik lt(/ Signature XIftIITf*TIIIì(*IXX}I*X*II}*¡XIIITXTXXI'IIXTXI*XTì}IIII**fTTfXIXX'XIXXTI'II'IIT*I*I*IT**IXT*TIX}iTI**II**II¡**XT*IIIXIIXI*}Ir*fTTT ABHS BORO ITANHATTÂN LOT 978 I BLOCK J-sl ABATEIIENT./EXE} PrroN TAX INIT Q YR T/F AB YR TAXÄBLE JsI EXHPT YEAR, AE,/YR EX PCT AB + J5I EX A}IOUNT ,92/93 92/93 L? 90 2B 42,000,000 *93/94 92./93 14 F 90 20 93./94 93/94 3 t4 F 90 20 I TOTAL qI,500,000 94/9 59 2/93 L4 F 9020 94/9 59 3/9 43 I4 F 9028 * ToTAL 42,250,009 95/96 9?,/93 L4 F 9020 t5/96 93/94 3 t4 F 9020 ì TOTAL 4t ,950 ,000 96/9 79 2,/93 l4 F 9020 96/9 79 3,/94 314 F 9020 * ToTAL 43,150,000 97/9E 92./93 97/96 93./94 97/96 97/9A L4 3 L4 la. F F F I 9A/99 92./93 98/99 93./9ct * 98,/99 97/9A 99,/00 92/93 99/00 93,/94 99/OO 97./98 99/OO 99/OO I Eo.loL F t4 F T4 F L4 3 L4 3 t4 l4 3 T4 F F F F 92/93 t4 r 14 F oo/oL 93,/94 3 Í 00/st 97./9E L4 oo/ot 99/OO 3 t4 F F or/o2 92,/93 14 OL,IOZ 93,/94 3 14 F ot/oz 97./9a L4 F gl/o2 * 99,/oo 3 tq o2/o3 92,/93 t4 o2/o3 93/94 314 02/03 93/94 5t4 F F F F 90 20 90 20 90 20 ToTAL 9020 9020 9020 ToTAL 90 90 90 90 44,E30,000 TAXADLE ABATETIENT GRANTEI' TÛTAL lAX TAX DUE l,?97 ,roo 2,421 ,5OO 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL 55,300,000 AIIOUNT I{TZ E4S, I 15. 0A t,E76,662-54 108,09I.64 735,023.44 Y y Y 42,250,000 3,71E,600 309,883.28 4,458,2t9 -98 4,I4E,336-70 2,7L9,777 -62 ,297 ,lOO 2,42L,500 41,950r000 3,7IE,600 ?Ol'79I .64 L,674,87O.9O y 509,865 .2E 4,533,536.4E 4,223,653.20 2,409,894.34 lr2g7,l0o lo8,09l .64 2,42L,500 201,?9t.64 6?6,93L.8O 1,473,079.26 43,150,000 3,7I8,600 309rEE5.26 4,77O,663.96 4,460,7EO.68 2,100,01I.06 l,?97 ,loo 108,0tt.64 51E,840.16 2,42L r500 20L,79t.64 1,27t,287.62 36,000 5,000.00 29,400.00 44,E30,000 3,754,600 3L2,8E3.26 4,951 ,921 .EO 4,639,OsE.52 1,E19,527.7E 108,091.64 20L,79t.64 36,000 3,000.00 47,150,000 a,754,600 312,E83. 28 5,463,43E -5O 2g 20 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL 52,700,000 I REHAININ6 /C 108,0tl .64 20t,79L.64 41o,74A.5? 1,069,495.98 1,297 ,LOO 47,I50,OOO PACE 42,000,000 I,297,10o 10E,091.64 4,L62,2OO.00 4,054,106.56 l,g5g,29E.36 L,297 ,l0o I 06 ¡ 091 ;64 951 ,206 .72 2,421 ,5OO 100,E95"82 2,O78,q54.I8 q,O94,147.54 41,500,000 5,71E,600 206,987,46 4,303,135- OO 3,929,660.9O 20 20 20 20 COST OF VALUE ALTERATION DATE 66,/2?./20t6 2,421 ,500 TOTAL 49,700,000 90 90 99 HrsroRy LrsrrNc 19,700,000 L,297 ,lOO 2,421 ,500 56,000 4E,90l¡ 3,805 ,500 1,297 ,lOO 2,421 ,500 36,000 52,700 ,0 00 4E,90 0 26,400 4,75O,5.85 108,091.64 302,656.88 -64 867 ,70q 34 3,000.00 23,400 - 00 2,037.50 41 ,972-59 3L4 ,921! .78 5,592,9q7 .OO 5,O7E,026 .22 I ,?35,753 .72 201 ,791 108,09I .64 201,79L.64 5,000 . 00 4,075.OO 194,565.2(r 665,912.70 108,091 .64 20t,79t.64 5 000 .00 ' 4,075.00 E6,473.60 464,121.06 l,?97 ,LOA 2,42L,500 2,42L,500 3I6,958.2E 5,967,976.0î 5,651,O17.72 Y Y Y Y Y Y 17,400 .00 33,E22.50 601,817.16 86,473.60 zot,79t.64 20t,79t -64 Y 20,4011 .00 l,2g? ,loo 2,42r,500 55,500,000 3,E03,500 Y 57,E97.50 9t8,775.q4 0 Y Y -22 1,596,644.5O 316,95E.2E 5,7L6,369 .Og 5 1399 ,410.72 48,90 Y Y .OO 5, E05 ,500 36,000 Y Y ?6?,329.42 262,329.42 Y Y jt*lf*lf;txxrx***r**xl1*xl*rx**rrx*frfrxrrxxxtx*rtrrr,(¡tl**r*xr*xt*xrxirrtxrxxxf*axxl*t*tlrfrttxr*tt*rrrtr*trtrtfx*t*fr*rr*\****\** J-5T ABATEIIENT/EXEI{PTION HISTORY LISTING ABHS 30Ro BLOCK I{ANHATTAN 97E TAX INIT LOT YEÀR AB,1YR f,/F AB YR EX PCT AB t2/o3 97/9A L4 A YR o2./o3 99/00 3 L4 o2/o3 g2/93 t4 90 90 90 F F F 3 3 l4 t4 t4 L4 t0 F F F F I F F F 14 F 04/85 02/03 * 06,/07 99/OO F t4 F t4 F r4 F 06/97 * 3 l4 t4 t4 02./93 07,/oa 97./9A o?/oE 99/OO 07/oE 02/03 o7/o8 86./07 08/o 9 99/oo oa/o 9 02,/03 oa/o 9 o6/07 oa/o I 08/09 0B/o 9 o8,t09 t4 514 l4 t4 l4 314 F F F F F F F F F 09/to 99/OO 3 l4 F 09/to 02/03 lq F 09,/IO o6/07 ltt F 09/IO E8/09 l4 F 09/LO 0E./09 3 t4 F COST ÛF VALUE ALTERATION 46,9f¡0 232,30ø 57,260,000 4,055,E00 2,421 ,5OO 36,000 48 900 59,460,000 ' 232,300 59,460,000 2,73E,700 2,4?L,5¡g 90 ?o 3,000.00 4,075.00 19 ,358.32 3L4,698.56 6,670,398.40 6,295, 699.84 201,79r.64 3,000.00 4,075.00 19,35E.32 22E,224 -96 7,503,E52. 36,000 48,900 23?,300 317,200 3,000.00 4,075.00 19 ,358.32 26,433.32 36,000 3,000 . 00 36,0t¡0 46,900 2,400.o0 ÍoTAL 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 7t,?40,OOO 7,275, 627 .04 3,000 - 00 4,075.00 19,35E.32 E6,97t. 0E 7, L46,360. 00 7,059,3E8.92 14,400.00 29,747 .50 1a9,711.68 496,t88.64 Y 170 ,353 .36 267,963.64 8,400.00 Y 2L,597 .50 150 ,995. 04 L80,992.54 5,400 -00 ,522.50 L3L,636.72 lSc.'559.22 17 7 ,E29,3L3 -60 232,30t 2,EO6,ZOo 71,240,OOt 3,123,400 4,O75.AO lt,358.52 255,E50.00 7 ,AO2,AE0 -28 2,400 . 00 78,330,000 4,075.00 .32 2,EO6,?O0 235,850.00 605,632 50,486.00 947,305 39,47r.O4 9020 9g?o 4,640,537 4E,900 232,300 2,806,200 9¡zo 9020 9020 85,630 ,0 00 605,832 947,305 4,640,537 9 ,37?.50 92,920.08 2,057,E80.00 259,683.32 8,497,507.20 E,237,823.EE 2,t60,172.58 4E,900 ToTAL 85,630,000 AHOUNT REI{AINING '{TZ /C 11,400.00 25,672.50 OO 2 4,075.00 13,447 .50 19r358¡32 ttz,27E.40 233,850.00 2,291 ,730.OO 66,560,000 3,123,4¡O 260,283.a2 8,477,747.20 8,21?,46A.a8 2,419,855.90 48,900 232,300 2,896,200 232,300 78,330,000 PAGE 60,537.7E 60,537 .76 9020 9l¡20 9920 TOTAL 65,160,000 9020 9020 9020 9020 TOTAL 66,560,000 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 2g DUE GRANTEI¡ 56,500,000 63,160,0 00 TÂX TOTAL TAX ABATE}IENT 36,000 48,900 232,300 5E,500,000 2,73E,79O 90 20 90 ?o 90 20 TOTAL * TAXABLE 20 20 90 20 T4 o6,to7 05./07 EXIIPI AIIOUNT 36, 0 00 t0 F F F 3 06/07 97./9a J5I 9A 20 TOTAL 05/06 97/98 L4 a5/06 99/OO 3 L4 a5/06 ¡2/O3 14 TAXABLE + J5I EX 57 ,280 ,000 TOTAL 04./05 93/94 3 t4 o4./o5 97/98 14 04/t5 99/OO 3 t4 06./22/20t6 20 ?o 20 TOTAL g3/o4 93/94 03/94 97/9A 03,/o4 99/OO n3,/o4 02/03 DATE I 19,35E 5,297.50 73 ,56L .76 I,824,030.00 494,762.80 815,103.46 347,240.36 9,E66,446.79 9,5L9,206.43 3,21t,75E.52 (,,O75.OO 19,358.32 253, E50 , 00 50,4E6.00 78,942 -38 3E6,711.40 I,338,268.26 Y ,2?2.50 54,203.44 I ,590 ,1t0.00 444,276.EO 734, 161 .3E 951,556.E6 2, E24,O44. L? Y tl*r*rrxIf*xtxr*x*xrl*rtI**xr*r**rr**r*r**rlxrxr*,(t*l*f**t*rlF*IxÍ*IxxrrrxlIlrxIxI*txrt*Itxrrrrxxxrtxllxrx**f¡*Ifxr*xrxrtrrrlrrr J-5T ABHS BORO BLOCK t{ANHATTAN 978 TAX INIT Q YR YEAR AB./YR EX LO/IL 99/OO 3 L4 LO/rl 02/03 t4 ¡.0./l t 06/07 L4 LO/IT o8/o9 14 to/tr 08./09 3 14 T/F F F F F F I tt/tz 02./03 t4 F lL/12 06./07 LCt F Lt/tz 08/09 14 F tt/r2 04./09 3 L4 F AB O2/OS 06/07 L2/t3 08/09 L2/t3 oE/09 3 L.+ t4 14 t4 .*. I 13/14 06./07 t4 13/14 0a,/o9 t4 t3/L4 0A/O9 3 t4 L4/L5 96./97 L4 L4/L5 08./09 t4 L4/L5 08./09 3 t4 T t5/r 60 6/07 t4 t5/t 60 8/O9 14 t5/L 60 8/O9 3 t4 I F F F F o6/22/20L6 TAXABLE EX YR + J5t PCT AB J5I TAXABLE EXI{PT A}IOUNT 46,900 232,500 2,806,2OO '020 9020 t020 T0TAL 90,450,000 90 ,450 ,0 0 0 90 20 90 20 97,250,0f10 97 ,?5O,OOO 20 90 ?a 90 2f¡ 90 20 TOTAL 4,9E0,000 99 ,718,197 ,371 1,222.48 15,486.80 ,L2?,48O.00 4,591 ,637 - 395,790.E0 343,304-60 15,486.80 37E,764.88 3,E37,4L3.E0 3,45E,64A.92 1,678,783.94 2,806,200 605,932 235,850.00 50,4E6.00 7E,942.O8 654,780.00 253,850.00 50,486.00 78,942.OE 420,930.00 '3a7 6f¡5,E32 947,305 34,683,067 4,359,337 947,305 49,480,0E4 4,359,337 IS IS LISTED BELOI{ LISTED BELO}I Y 3E2,636-40 3,063,592.46 2,680,956.06 2,O57,548.82 4,59r,637 ct,359 Y 576,?77 -22 8EE,650.00 605,832 947,305 ,/C 655,2L9 .30 233,E50.00 50,486.00 947,305 78,942.OE 947,305 4,359 ,337 3 A}IOUNT I{TZ 19,358.32 233,E50.00 50,486.00 78,942.OA ,35E 233,850 PAEE REHAII{ING ?32,300 2,806,200 605,832 947,305 1.9 292,81E.E0 497,335.14 242,33?-E0 418,3t3-O6 Y Y 363,278.0E 3,107,956 -9E 2,744,67A.9¡ 1,315,505.86 363,278.OE 5,664,656.50 19r,846.80 5,501,358.42 2,806,200 233,850.00 ,480,08.1 TO LEFT OF TAX YEAR II{DICATE SA CO}IIIEHT TO LEFT OF TAX YEAR INDICATE SA COII}IENT DUE 3E3,858.E6 2,977,7EE.46 I,693,9?9.58 2,440,rE5.22 2,EO6,200 605,E32 49 TAX 4,64î ,537 2,EO6,200 2I ,856 TOTAL TAX 34,E45.L2 1,556,330 - 00 252,300 2,EO6,200 605,E32 20 20 20 ABATE}IENT GRANTEI) 52 -00 50,486.00 7E,942.O8 60s,832 947,305 90 20 90 zo 90 90 90 90 COST OF VALUE ALTERATION 9020 9020 TOTAL 4,9Efl, OOfl F 9020 F 9020 F 9020 ToTAL 99,7t8,L97 F 9020 F 9020 F 9020 TOTAL 2L,856,37L F 90 20 F 90 20 F 90 2g ToTAL 34,683,967 t6/L? 06/07 rq F l6/t7 0E/o9 t4 F r6/t7 8E/O9 3 tq F r r DÀTE I TOTAL 12/13 L2/13 ABATE}IENT./EXEI{PTION IIISTORY LISTING LOT 50,4E6.00 76,942-08 16a,27E.08 7,351 ,219.4E 6,987,941 .40 187,0E0 . 00 50 ,4E6 . 00 78,94?.OE 316,50E. 08 9,257,819.20 A,941,011. 12 Y 539,450.98 952,227.78 187,0E0.00 141,360.E0 Y 260,50E.90 5A8,949.70 90,874.80 L81,566.62 27?,44L.62 Y IXXXIIIX¡XIrXrr*r(X*fIlXl*tXf*XItf**¡Ì11**xrx**i*¡rxrr*Ixrlxxrtxxl:txtxtlrlxÉI)Êtxrr*Ixrr*¡r¡trxtxf*)r*xxxxtxtxlfrrr*xttt*rtxxtxtfx ABHS BORO IIANHATTAN TAX INIT Q YR f/F YEAR AB,/YR EX TAX YEAR 92/93 94./94 93/94 94/95 95,/96 96,/97 97./94 98,t99 99./OO 0 0./01 0t./02 o2/03 g3/04 o4/o5 o5,/96 06/07 08./09 09/to t Lt/t2 T2/L3 l3/t4 I(1,/15 tílt6 10./l L5/t6 J-5I A3ÄTEIIENT,/EXEIIPTION HISTORY LISTINC BLOCK LOT 97a I AB YR PCT AB INIT Q YR T,/F AB YR ABIYR EX PCT AB 92/93 t2 90 20 92/93 t4 F 90 20 TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL g TAXABLE + Jsl EX J5I EX}IPT AIIOUNT CHG DATE 7 /23/99 12./20,/93 7/23/99 1/23/99 7 7 7 /23,/99 /23/99 /23/99 7,/23/99 12/L5/99 lt/o4./Do tL,/03/ot 6/2a/03 tL/26./03 tL,/25/O4 tt./t6/o5 tt/tE/o6 t2/ta/oa 12/23/09 Il/20/to tt/t9/tt t2/ot/t2 tL/23/L3 tr/22/L4 IL/2t/t5 ll/2t/t5 TAXABLE COST OF AEATEIIENT VALUE ALTERATION GRAI{TED cot{HENTS AUTOI{ATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY TOTAL RECORD CREATED-TOTALS REI{OVET) AUTO]IATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY AUTOIIATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY AUTO}IATIC UPDATE CAUSED EY IIET LIAIILITY CHANGE CHANÊE CHANGE CHANGE CHANGE CHANCE CHANGE AUTOITATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY ÂUTOIIATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY AUTOI{ATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY AUTOIIATIC UPDATE FOR ì{EI' QUARTERLY ABATEIIENT AUTOTIATIC AI}JUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHANGE AUTOIIATIC ADJUSTIIET{T DUE TO TAX RATE CHAI{6E AUTO}IATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY CHANCE AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOI{ATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOI{ATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOI{ATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOIIATIC TO TAX RÁTE CHAilEE TO TAX RATE CI{AN6E TO TAX RATE CHANCE TO TAX RATE CHANGE TO TAX RATE CHANCE UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY CHANGE ADJUSTI{ENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHANGE AI¡JUSTI4ENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHANCE AIIJUSTI{ENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHAI{ÊE ADJUSTI{ENT ÐUE TO TAX RATE CHANEE AI}JUSTI{ENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHAI{CE AIIJUSTI{ET{T DUE TO TAX RATE CHANGE ADJUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHANCE AIIJUST]IENT DUE ADJUSTIIENT DUE AIIJUSTIIE}IT DUE AI¡JUST}IENT I'UE ADJUSTIIENT DUE TOTAL TAX TAX DATE 6/22/2016 DUE PAGE AI{OUNT IITZ REIIAINING /C 4 fIIIIII*IXItIIXIXIITXTX*IXItXIIIt.IIÍ*IXIXIfI*ÍIIiXItXI*If:tXt*ffrt*XI**IIIIItftÌ**I**fIXIiXtXIt*t).I*Xr*IfIx*I**IIXfXfX*XI*rtI*IX J-51 ÂBHS ABATE}IENT,/EXE}IPTION HISTORY LISTINC BORO BLOCK LOT DATE PAEE IIANHATTAN 972 I o6/22/20L6 1 TAX INIT Q YR T/F AB YR TAXABLE JsT EXTPT TAXAELE COST OF ABATEITEI{T TOTAL TAX TAX I'UE AIIOUNT IITZ YEAR AB/YR EX PCT AB + J5T EX AIIOUIIT VALUE ÀLTERATION çRANTEI) REI{AI}¡IT{G ./C 92/93 92/93 12 90 20 85,028,500 E5,02E'500 5,066,5OO 422,2OE.52 8,536,324.32 7 'gLC.,lL6.OO 4'L37 '641 .6E *93/94 92./93 L4 F 90 20 3,715,433.36 5,066,500 422,208.32 93,/94 93,/94 3 t4 F 90 20 8,525,E00 355,2q1 .66 7,317,97E.34 TOTAL 75,60 I,3E5 75,601,585 15,592,500 777,449.98 E,20E,107.60 7,430,657.62 r,035,41L.70 94/95 92./93 I4 F 9020 3,293,225.04 5,066,500 422,288.32 94/95 93/94 3 t4 F 9020 E,525,800 770,483.32 6,687,495.02 x ToTAL 59,000,000 59,000,000 15,592,3001,132,691 .64 6,777,680.OO 5,644,988.36 9,900,720.O6 95/96 92/93 14 F 90 20 5,066,5,00 422,20ð.32 2,871,016.72 95/96 93/94 3 14 F 90 20 8,525,800 7LO,4E3.32 5,897,01r.70 TOTAL 64,?5A,OOO 64,250,000 13,592,3001,132,69L.64 7,750,497.48 6,6t7,805.84,8,766,O28.42 96/97 92/93 14 F 90 2t) 2,44E,808.40 5,066,500 422,2f¡4.32 96/97 93/94 3 \q F 90 20 5,1E6,528.5E 6,525,E00 710,4E3.32 TOTAL 56,600,000 58,600,000 13,592,3001 ,132,691 .64 7,53q,El6.OO 6,402,12q.36 7,635,536.7E 97/94 92./93 14 F 9020 2,O26,600-OE 5,066,500 422,208.32 97/9E 93./94 3 t4 F 9020 4,416,045.06 E,525,800 7LO,4E3.32 97/98 97/94 14 F 9020 42,O5E -36 4,291 .64 51 ,500 97/98 97/98 3 L4 F 9020 rr7,534.rE L36,700 5,695.82 * TOTAL 61, l?0,000 6l ,L7O,000 13,7E0 ,5OOl ,L42,679.1O 7,802,E5A-20 6,660, r59.r0 6,662,03?.6E 98/99 92/93 l4 F 90 20 1,604,391 .76 5,066,500 422,208.32 9a/99 93/94 3 tq F 90 20 3,765,561.74 8,525,E00 710,483.32 98/99 97/9A t4 F 90 20 37,766.72 5t,500 4,291 .64 9Atl99 97./98 3 t4 F 90 ?o LO5,942.54 136,700 ll ,59l .64 9E/99 9E/99 t4 F 90 20 E,65E,7E1.6E 10,578,100 E81,50E.32 I ToTAL 63,950,000 63,930,000 24'358 7,604,442.7O 5,574,559.ct6 4,L52'444.44 '6002'O29,¿E3.24 99/OO 92/93 L4 99/OO 93/94 3 t4 99/OO 97/9A t4 99/00 97/98 99/OO 9E/99 3 l4 t4 t4 99/sO 99/OO F F F F F F I 00/gl 92/93 0,/01 93/94 0 oo/oL 97/9A t4 3 g0//Ol 97/98 3 00./01 9E/99 0 0./01 99/DO oo/ot 00,/01 I 3 l4 t4 r4 t4 tq t4 F F F F F F F 90 20 90 ?s 90 ?o 90 z0 90 20 90 21) ToTAL 90 90 9A ' 69, 150,000 2A 20 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL 75,680,000 5,066,500 422,?08-32 8,525,E00 710,483.32 51,500 4,29L.64 136,700 11,391.64 10,578,100 881,508.52 15E,700 13,?25.00 L,lE?,183.44 3,055,978.42 33,475-0ò 94,550-9fJ 7,757,273.36 129,605.00 69,130,000 2q,517,3002,A43,1O8.24 8,352,296.26 6,3A9,r88.02 2,252,166.20 5,066,500 q2?,20t-32 E , 525 , E0 0 7lO ,4E3 .32 51,500 4,29t.64 136,700 tl,59l.ó4 I0,57E,100 881,508.32 15E,700 L3,?25.9O 41,800 L,74L.66 75,6EO,OO0 24,559,1OO2,O4(.,E49.9O 759,975.12 2 ,344 ,595 .lO 29,1E3.44 83,159.26 6,E75,765.84 9,056,Otg.60 7,OLL,159.70 116,3E0.00 35,A7A.3q ?44,936.3O :IflxI*xIIIX*IJ(IìXI*lI*II**rX¡XfltIIìXf*X*XtIXtrlIII*NX**r{*xi(txrxrrxfxtlxr*If*I*Ir*1xx**r**rri*xfJéfr*}**rr*r*rlxftxr**r*rf**1x* J-5I ABHS BORO BLOCK IIANHATTAN 972 TAX INIT Q YR f./F YEAR AB/YR EX 0L/a2 92/93 t4 F oI/02 93/94 3 t4 F ot/t2 97/9A L4 F 0t/02 97/98 tL/92 94./99 3 oL/02 99/O¡ Í 0t/02 00,/01 tq t4 L4 3 l4 F F F F 02/03 93,/94 o?/03 97/98 0?/a3 97/98 3 3 02/A3 94,/99 02,/93 99/00 t4 t4 t4 t4 lq t4 a2/03 00,/01 3 Lat o2./03 o2/03 t4 02/03 o2/o3 3 t4 F F F F F F F F F x 03/04 03/o4 03/04 03/o4 o3/o4 03/04 03/o4 03/04 93/94 314 97/98 t4 97/98 3I4 9A/99 99,tOß L4 l4 t4 t4 314 00./01 3 02/A3 Ð2./03 o4./05 93,/94 3 L4 04/05 97,/9a t4 o4/05 97,/9A 3 04,/05 9E/99 o4/05 99,too oq/o5 00./01 t4 L4 14 3 t4 o2./03 L4 o4./05 o2/o3 3 t4 O.+,/05 I o5./o6 97/98 r4 F T4 F F a5/o6 00/0r o5/o6 02/03 05/o6 o2,/03 3t4 1t5,/O6 05./o6 l4 05,/o6 o5,/o6 F F t4 314 t4 3 F F F F F F F F F 05/o6 97/9A s5/o6 98/99 05/06 99/O0 F F F F F F F F YR PCT AB t4 I4 F F F DATE TAXABLE + J51 EX 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 2Ð E5,990,000 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL r,q10,000 90 90 20 20 10,410,000 90 21t 90 20 90 20 90 20 J51 EX}IPT AIIOUNT TAXABLE COST OF ABATEHENT VALUE ALTERATION 6RANTEI) 5,066,500 422,20E,32 E,525,E00 7LO,4E3.32 5l,500 4,291.64 136,700 LL,39L.64 10,576,100 88r,508.32 15E,700 13,2?5.O0 3,463.32 4t,800 E5,990 ,og'0 24,559 ,tOOz,046 ,59L .A6 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL 18,680,000 51,500 4,291 .64 136,700 1L391.64 I0 100 EE1,504.32 '578' 158,700 t3,225.OO 4r,800 3,483.32 30t,700 25,141.64 5E,800 3,233.52 8,525,E00 2L3,145.12 5r,500 4,291.64 136,700 11,391 .64 10,57E,100 8E1,508.52 l5t,7oo L3,225.OO 41,E00 3,4E3.3? 301,700 25,14L -64 38,800 3,233.3? DUE AI{OUHT }ITZ RE}IAININC /C 357,766.80 1,634,11r,78 2q,89L.84 7L,767.62 5,994,256.72 105,155.00 32,395.O2 72,O40.EO 8,O?5,449.24 8,tgE,344.74 Y 2t3,L45.14 16,30E.52 4'ð,9E4.34 4'231,2(tO.O8 76,705.90 25,42E.3E 221,?46.72 Y 12,016.88 ,592.70 3,349,731 .76 63,4Eo.oo 21,945.06 37 196,105.0E Y 26 ,E36 .70 18,680,000 19,933,1001,155,420.oo 6,7L3,948-89 5,558,528.80 3,707,708.r8 5l ,500 156,700 10,57E,100 20 20 20 20 301 ,700 90 90 90 TAX 30,070.02 10r410,000 19,833,L¡oL,652,75E.20 6,553,741 .96 4,900,983.76 4,E65,128,20 90 20 90 20 90 2¡ 90 2A 90 20 9t TOTAL TAX 5,066,500 337,766.80 8,525,E00 7tO,483-32 923,628,46 5l ,500 4,29t.64 20,60a.16 136,700 Lt,39l-64 60,375-9A 10,576,10{1 881,508.52 5,LL2,74A.40 15E,700 13,??5.OO 89,930.00 4l,800 3,483.32 2a,9tl .70 301,700 25,t4t.64 246,35A.36 5E,E00 t,616.66 33,303.34 l,410,ooo 24,899,6001,9EE,90E.34 3,?43,72L.04 r,254,8L2.7Íl 6,515,EE6.40 E,525,E00 710,4E3.32 20 20 9A 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 ToTAL PAGE 06/22,/20t6 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 90 HISTORY LISTING I TOTAL o2/03 92/93 t AB ABATEI{ENT,/EXEIIPTION LOT 15E,70 0 41,E00 38,800 594,000 594,000 4,291 .64 ll,39l.6l EEt ,506 .32 t3,225.00 3,483.3? 25;l4L -64 3,233.32 49,500.00 49,500 . û0 7 26 ,725 -24 ,20r.06 2,468,223 .44 50 ,255.00 t8,46L.74 L70,963.44 25,603.3E 485,100.00 4E5, 10-0 . 00 Y tlxxxlx¡rxlf¡rIxt***r*rr*rr**rttt¡x*tf*rllrtrlxrxxtxx¡xrrrrr*Ixt-ftftxtlxr*fxxt*rxxrr*I**fxt*xfxxtxxtrrllrlìfxf*r*rrxrt*r*fIt-rt J-5I ABATEIIENT./EXEIIPTION HISTORY LISTING ABHS BLOCK LOT EoRO PA6E DATE 972 1 ì{AN {ATTAN 0 6./22/20L6 3 TAX INIT Q YR T./F AB YR TAXABLE J5I EXIIPT TAXABLE COST OF ABATE}IE}IT TOTAL TAX TAX DUE AI{OUNT }ITZ PCT AB + J5I EX YEAR AB./YR EX AlloUNT VALUE ALTERATION GRANTED RE¡IAINII¡G /C x TOTAL 27,8E0,000 2-l,EEO, 000 rt,901,300 991,774.88 E,24E,gO4.EO 7,256,229.92 5, 250,533. 50 o6./07 97/94 L4 F 90 20 4,291.64 3 ,453 .60 5l ,500 o6./07 97/98 3 L4 F 90 20 t36,700 tL,39t.64 L4,809 -42 06/07 9E/99 t4 F 90 20 1,586,7L5.L2 E81,50E.52 1 0,578, 1 00 90 20 o6/07 99/00 L4 F t3,225.OA 37,030 . 00 ì.5E,700 90 20 o6/07 00./0t 3 t4 F 3,443 .32 14,978.4? 4l 'EOo 90 20 06/07 02/03 t4 F 145,821.80 Y 501,700 25,14I.64 o6./07 s2/o3 3 14 F 90 20 38, E00 3,233.32 20,370.06 90 20 o6/07 05/06 t4 F 594,000 49,500 . 00 435,60 0 . 00 I TOT AL 36r160,000 36,160,000 lI,901,300 99t,774.84 79,699.?O 9,087,924 -32 2,258,758.42 07,/oa 97 /98 l(t F 90 20 3 ,455.60 5l ,500 90 20 07/oE 97/94 3 14 F lI ,39L .64 3,4t7 .7E 156 r 700 07/oE 9Et/99 lq F 90 20 7O5,?O6.EO 10,57E,100 EE1,50E.52 07/oE 99/00 t4 F 90 20 t3,225.OO 23,E05.00 158,70 0 07/oa 00./01 314 F 90 20 3,4A3.32 ll,495. l0 41,E00 07/oa o2/o3 l4 F 90 20 t20,680.t6 Y 301,700 25,14t.64 90 20 07,/DE o2/o3 5 t4 F L7 ,L36 -74 3E,EOO 3,233 -32 07/oa 05/06 t4 F 90 20 386,100.00 49,500.00 594,000 ToTAL 39,850,000 39,E50,000 11,901,300 990,9t6.84 8,609,50E-00 7,618,39r.16 1,267,841.58 08/99 97/9E 3 4 F 9020 3,4t7 .76 136,700 oa/09 98/99 4 F 9020 1 0,57E, r00 705,206.60 oa/09 99/OO 4 F 9020 10,580'.00 13,225.OO 158,70 0 08/09 00./01 5 4 F 9020 E,oll.7E 3,483.32 4l '800 0a/09 02/03 4 F 9020 95,53E.52 Y 501,700 25,14t.64 oa/09 o2/û3 3 t4 F 9020 13,905.42 3,233.32 36, E00 0E./09 05/06 t4 F 9020 556,600.00 49,500.00 594' 000 08/02 0E/o9 3 t4 F 9020 36,5E0,90 749,446.90 873,142 * TOTAL é2,290,OOO 62,290,OOO 12,7221942 E39,5EE.74 3,03E,048 .39 2,19E,459.65 r,2L4,O8O.62 09/to 99/OO tq F 90 2ø 10,5E0.00 l5E,700 09/L0 00/0t 5 l4 F 90 20 4,528.46 3,483.52 4l , E00 09/r0 o2/o3 tq F 90 20 70,596.EE Y 501,700 25,L4t.64 09/L0 02/03 3 tq F 90 20 10,670.10 3E, EO0 3,233.32 09/LO 05/06 rq F 90 20 49,500.00 2E7,100.00 594,OOO 09/IO 08/09 3 L4 F 90 20 72,761 .EO 676 ,6E5.lO E73,142 x TOT AL 79,020,000 79 ,O?O,AO0 2,008,142 164,700.06 6,945,03E.20 6,780,338 .12 t,O49,38O.54 I 0./l I 00./01 516 F 9020 41,800 3,483,32 1,o45.14 to/tt o2/o3 t4 F 9020 501,700 25,L41 .64 45,255.24 Y 10./l I o2/o3 3 t4 F 9020 3E,EOO 3,233.32 7 ,q36.78 I 0,/l I 05/06 t4 F 9020 594,000 49,500.00 237 ,600.OO t0./Lt 08/09 3 t4 F 9020 873,142 72,761 -aO 603,9?3.30 I ToTAL eA,420,Ûto 98,420 ,000 r,Eqg,442 154,I20. 08 9,8qE,A22.60 9,693,90?.52 895,26¡ .46 Il./12 00./0 I 5 t4 F 90 20 4r ,800 ,o45.t2 I]-.ltz 00/oL 3 L4 F 90 20 4r,800 1,o45.t2 *fItIIIIIT'TIfII*TI**f*fI*IIXI*TIXTITI***X***TII*XIXT**IXTI*IÍT**fXf*T*X*TXI*ITTIfIItTIXIXIf*If*If*TITITI'**TT*rTtTIT*ITIf*I*I:I J-5I ABHS BORO BLOCK LOT I{ANHATTAN 972 I I TAX INIT Q YR T /F YEAR ABIYR EX lL,/L2 02/D3 t4 F tI/Lz 02/03 3 14 F rr/Lz 05/06 t4 F rL/Lz 08/09 3 t4 F YR F F F F I l3/t4 02,/03 3 t4 F l3/1.. 05/06 14 F 13/14 0a,/o9 3 t4 F T t4/t5 t4/t5 I L5/L6 t5/L6 t6/t7 I DATE PAGE o6/22,t2116 TAXABLE + J5I 9020 9020 9020 9020 TOTAL t?./t3 02/03 14 L2/r3 02/03 3 t4 L2/ts o5/s6 L4 12./15 gA/lOg 3 L4 I AB PCT AB ABATEIIENT/EXEIIPTION HISTORY LISTING TAXABLE J51 EX EXI{PT AI{OUNT COST OF VALUE ALTERATIOII 501,700 38,800 594,000 20, ll0 ,000 20, 90 20 90 20 90 20 90 20 TOTAL 44,OL5,2t9 301,700 3E, E00 594,000 873,142 44,O15,219 1,8O7,642 9020 9020 9020 3E, E00 594,AOO E73,L42 ToTAL 19,609,152 05/05 t4 F 9020 0a./o9 3 L4 F 9020 TOTAL 7t,452,138 05/06 14 F 90 20 08./09 3 14 F 90 20 TOTAL 16,gLL,966 06/09 3 14 F 90 20 7q,o25,6EA TO LEFT OF TAX YEAR II{DICATES A T TO LEFT OF TAX YEAR INDICATES A I10,000 473,142 ,a49 ,4q2 COIIIIENT COI{TIET{T 19,609,152 1,508,942 594, 000 ABATEI{ENT êRANTEI) ÎOTAL TAX TAX DUE 25,t4t .64 3,233.32 49,500.00 72,761 .EO t51,681.8E 3,000,376.26 2,84E,694.3E 3,233.32 72,761 .80 lrt5,6OE.7? 5,344,646.O2 5,199,037.30 970.1? 49,500.00 72,76t.80 123,251 .92 2,012,623.04 L¡E89,591.12 49,500.00 873,t42 72,761 .EO 71,452,138 1,4é7,142 122,25t.EO 7,75O,t72.34 7,627,gLO.54 594,000 18,91I. 966 74,O?5,680 IS IS LISTED BELOTI LISTED BELOH 873,Ll2 1,467 ,L42 ÂI{OUNT IITZ REI{AININC /C 20,113.60 4,203 -46 18E,100.00 551,161 .50 743,578.56 20,113.60 49 ,500 - 00 970.14 I 3E,60 0 .00 458,399.70 597,969.84 89, I 00 .00 3E5,657.90 q74,737.90 39,600 ,00 3t2,E76.1O 352,476.1O 39,600.00 72,76L -EO L12,36L.80 3,968,42.6.54 3 1856,066 -74 873,t42 72,76I.E0 1,068,7?E.32 995,966.52 4 240,LL4-30 ?40,tL4-30 t67,352.50 Y xrtrxrit*rrrr*x*rxrxrrtr*ixrrrrrr***:*xxr*t**rtrxfxrf*xr*rrf**rxtr**frxfxrir*frrr*rrrt**rrrrtx*r**x***r*r*xr**xrrifrfr:fr*xf,r**x* J.5I ABHS BORO BLOCK I{ANHATTAN 972 TAX INIT YEAR AB,/YR E YRT ,/F AB YR EX PCT AB LOT ABATEIIENT,/EXEIIPTION HISTORY LISTING DATE I o6,/22./20t6 TAXABLE + J51 EX INIT Q YR T,/F A3 YR CH6 DATE AB./YR EX PCT AB 93/9ct 92/93 t4 F 90 20 12/20/93 94/95 TOTAL tt/L5/94 J5I EX}IPT AI{OUNT TAX YEAR 96/97 97 /98 98/99 99/OO 00/0 I oL/02 02/03 o3,/D4 04/05 05/06 o6./07 oa./09 09/to LO/IL LI/12 12,/t3 ts/t4 L4/15 15,/t6 t5/t6 TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL TOTAL 5/t5,/97 t2,/09/97 tI./t9/98 LO,/30/99 l?/t7/oo It,/03/oL t2/t7,/o? ll/26,/03 tI/25./O4 Lt/t6/05 lL,/tE/O6 t2,rt8/oE t2,/23/09 Lt/20/t0 LL/t9,tLt t2/ot,/L2 lt/23,/t3 tt/14/t5 tt/2I/t5 tL/2t/t5 TAXABLE COST OF VALUE ALTERATION AEATEÌ{EÑT GRANTED CO}IHENTS TOTAL RECORD CREATED-TOTALS REIIOVEI) AUTOilATIC AIIJUSTI{ET{T DUE TO TAX RATE CHANÊE AUTO]IATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABILITY CHANÊE AUTOI{ATIC UPDATE FOR NEI{ QUARTERLY ABATETIENT AUTOI{ATIC ADJUSTIIEHT I¡UE IO TAX RATE CHANGE AUTOI{ATIC ADJUSTI{ENT I'UE TO TAX RATE C¡{AIICE AUTOI{ATIC UPDATE FOR HET{ QUARTERLY ABATEI{ENT AUTOI{ATIC ADJUST}IENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHA}IGE AUTO'IATIC UPDATE FOR NEW QUARTERLY ABATEIIENT AUTOIIATIC ADJUSTIIENT I¡UE TO TAX RATE CHANçE AUTOI{ATIC ADJUSTIIEIIT I¡UE TO T AX RATE CHANCE AUTOIIATIC ADJUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CIIANêE AUTO}IATIC ADJUSTI{ENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHÀN€E AUTOI{ATIC ADJUSIIIENT I'UE TO TAX RATE CHAN6E AUTOI.IATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOTATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTOI{ATIC AUTOIIATIC AUTO}IATIC AUTOIIATIC UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIABIL ITY CHANCE ADJUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHAN6E ADJUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CHANCE ADJUSTIIENT I'UE TO TAX RATE CHÂN6E AI'JUSTIIENT DUE TO TAX RATE CI{ANCE UPDATE CAUSED BY NET LIÀBIL ITY CHANÊE AIIJUSTIIENT I'UE TO TAX RATE CHANEE AI¡JUST¡IENT DUE TO TAX RATE CI{ANGE TOTAL TAX TAX DUE P€E A}IOUI{T }ITZ REI{AINING /C 5