:CQUl1tYOf $a.nOiego, C.alif.Qrnia Sample BaUQt & Voter InforrTl~tion . p~mphl~t . PRIMARYI:LECTION .. POLLS ,' ,. . .' .. , . . - ........ ,,, ... "... {,,._-- ", .... " . QP,~NAT;Z·A.M~.AN,P,'gJ.icl$eAJ .8i· p ·M· l!·U; LO¢AflON OF Y9~F.t:.\B
e redistricted by ordinanoo- for tho purposo of maintaining apprmdmate
aquality of population pursuant to Section 5.1 of this Charter at least once in
;very ten (10) years, but no later than nine months following the receipt of the
'inal Federal Decennial Census information. Tho City shall not bo rodistrioted
Nithin four yoars aftor any rodistrioting, oxoept that thoro shall be a ene timo
(.'aiver ef the four yoar minimum to pormit rodistrioting prior to tho 100a
iAunioipal olootion should final Foderal Deoennial Consus figuros 60 roquiro.
)f
•
Any territory hereafter annexed to or consolidated with The City of San Diego
ihall at the time of such annexation or consolidation be added to an adjacent
Jistrict or Districts by an ordinance of the CounCil.:.. pro\'ided, that if any torritory
~nnexed or oonsolidated at anyone time shall eontain a population suffieiont
:0 upsot tho approximato oquality of tho ostablishod distriots, tho Ceuneil shall
1t least sixty days before an eleetion aftor sl::loh annexation OF oonsolidation
'odistriot tho Cit)' regardloss of tho timo limitation of four years Reretofore
110ntioned. However. if any territory annexed, deannexed or consolidated
Jpsets the approximate equality of the populations of the established districts,
i redistricting shall be conducted pursuant to Section 5.1 of this Charter,
;xcept that the nomination period for appointment to the Redistricting
::;ommission shall commence on the July 1 immediately succeeding the
mnexation, deannexation or consolidation and the Redistricting Commission
shall be constituted no later than the next November 1.
In any redistricting. the districts shall be comprised of contiguous territory
!nd made as equal in population as shown by the census reports, and as
~eographically compact as possible, and the districts so formed shall, as far as
::>ossible, be bounded by natural boundaries, by street lines and/or by City
::>oundary lines.
SECTION 5.1
The members of the City Council shall be elected by districts, as follOWS:
Subject to the provisions of the City Charter relating to referendum and
nitiative powers of the people. the sole and exclusive authority to adopt plans
Nhich specify the boundaries of districts for the City Council is vested in the
~edistricting Commission, to be established by this Section.
Commencing in the year following the year in which the national decennial
is taken under the direction of the United States Congress at the
:>eginning of each decade. the Redistricting Commission shall adoptplans that
'edistrict the City into eight (8) Council districts designated by numbers 1 to 8
nclusive. Those districts shall be used for all elections of Council members,
neluding their recall, and for filling any vacancy in the office of member of the
::ouncil, SUbsequent to the effective date of this Section (and until new districts
ire established).
~ensus
'R-1690-12
P
so 104-43
No change in the boundary or location of any district by redistricting a:
herein provided shall operate to abolish or terminate the term of office of an'
member of the Council prior to the expiration of the term of office for which suet
member was elected.
Districts formed by the Redistricting Commission shall each contain, a~
nearly as practicable, one-eighth of the total population of the City as shown b)
the Federal census immediately proceeding such formation of districts.
Each redistricting plan shall provide fair and effective representation for al
citizens of the City, including racial, ethnic, and language minorities, and be ir
conformance with the requirements of the United States Constitution an~
Federal statutes.
To the extent it is practical to do so, districts shall: preserve identifiable
communities of interest; be geographically compact - populous contiguous
territory shall not be bypassed to reach distant populous areas; be composed
of whole census units as developed by the United States Bureau of the
Census; be composed of contiguous territory with reasonable access between
population centers in the district, and not be drawn for the purpose of
advantaging or protecting incumbents.
The Redistricting Commission shall be composed of seven (7) members
ointed b the Presidin Jud e of the Munici al Court, San
who shall b
Diego Ju
trict. In the event that the Presiding Judge declines to make
the appointments, they shall be made by a Municipal Court Judge selected by
vote of the Judges of the Municipal Court, San Diego Judicial District. Should
the Judges of the Municipal Court decline to so act, then the Redistricting
Commission shall be appOinted by a panel of three retired Superior Court
Judges drawn at random by the City Manager in the fashion described in Penal
Code sections 900(a) and 902. In the event that all of the preceding individuals
decline to act, then the Redistricting Commission shall be appOinted by a
majority vote of the City Council in the fashion set forth below. The term
"Presiding Judge," as used herein below, shall include any person or any body
acting to appoint the Redistricting Commission pursuant to the provisions in
this paragraph.
The City Clerk shall solicit nominations for appointment to the Redistricting
Commission in accordance with this Section and shall distribute to the news
media the announcement of a thirty (30) day nomination period (which shall
commence on July 1, 2000, and on July 1 of every year in which a national
decennial census is taken) and the guidelines for selection of Commission
members.
Individuals or organizations desiring to nominate persons for appointment to
the Commission shall do so in writing to the City Clerk within the nomination
period. The City Clerk shalf transmit the names and information regarding all
nominees with the names of nominating individuals and organizations to the
Presiding Judge immediately upon the close of nominations. The PreSiding
Judge shall appOint the members constituting the Commission no later than
November 1! 2000, and on November 1 of every year in which a national
decennial census is taken. The Presiding Judge shall appoint women and men
who will give the Redistricting Commission geographiC. social and ethnic
PR·1690·13
P so 104-44
diversity, and who, in his or her 'udgment, have a high degree of competency
to carry out the responsibilities of the Commission. The appointees shall
include individuals with a demonstrated capacity to serve with impartiality in a
nonpartisan role.
Each member of the Commission shall be registered to vote in The City of
San Diego.
Persons who accept appointment to the Commission, at the time of their
appointment, shall file a written declaration with the City Clerk stating that
within five (5) years of the Commission's adoption of a final redistricting plan,
they will not seek election to a San Diego City public office. The members of
the Redistricting Commission shall serve until the redistricting plan adopted by
the Commission becomes effective and any and all legal and referendum
challenges have been resolved.
Any vacancy in the Redistricting Commission which occurs after the
Commission is constituted shall be filled within seven (7) calendar days by the
Presiding Judge of the San Diego County Superior Court, following the same
procedure and using the same criteria established with this Section and
making the selection from the same pool of individuals given consideration for
appointment when the Commission was constituted.
Within twenty (20) days after the membership
hold its first meetin at a time and
All Commission meetings shall be open to the public and Commission
records, data and plans shall be available, at no charge, for public inspection
during normal business hours in the office of the City Clerk. Copies of records
and plans shall be provided, for a reasonable fee, to any interested person.
The Commission shall elect a chair and a vice chair and shall employ a chief
of staff, who shall serve at the Commission's pleasure, exempt from Civil
Service, and shall contract for needed staff, technical conSUltants and services,
using existing City staff to the extent possible.
Aye votes by 5 members of the Commission shall be required for the
appointment of its chief of staff, the election of its chair, and the adoption of the
final redistricting plan and a majority vote of the Commission shall be reqUired
for all other actions. A majority of the entire Commission shall constitute a
quorum for the transaction of business or exercise of any power of the
Commission.
The Commission shall make every reasonable effort to afford maximum
public access to its proceedings. It shall solicit public comment and shall hold
at least four (4) public hearings in various geographic areas of the City before
the preparation of a preliminary redistricting plan.
At least thirty (30) days prior to the adoption of a final plan, the Commission
shall file a preliminary plan with the City Clerk. along with a written statement
::>f findi
reasons for ado tion which includes notation of all criteria
~mploy
In the process and a full analysis and explanation of decisions made
::>y the Commission.
'R·1690·14
p so 104-45
Durinq the thirty (30) day period after such filing, the Commission shall hold
at least three (3) public hearings in various geographic areas of the City before
it adopts a final plan. Upon approval of the final plan, the Commission shall
adjust the boundaries of anv or all of the Council districts of the City pursuant
to the final Dian. Said final redistricting plan shall be effective thirty (30) days
after adoption and shall be subiect to the right of referendum in the same
manner as are ordinances of the City Council. If rejected by referendum, the
same Commission shall create a new plan pursuant to the criteria set forth in
Sections 5 and 5.1.
Within sixty (60) days after the members of the Commission are appointed,
the Commission shall adopt a budQet and submit it to the Presiding Judge. if
he or she aoproves it, it shall be forwarded to the City Council for its
consideration. The City Council sh,all appropriate funds to the Commission and
to the City Clerk adequate to .:.. ,{ out their duties under this Section.
If any part of these amendments to Sections 4 or 5 of the Charter or the
addition of Section 5.1 to the Charter or their application to any person or
circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect other provisions or
applications which reasonably can be given effect without the invalid provision
or application.
PR-1690-15
P
so 104-46
ARGUMENT IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION C
Taxpayer dollars down the drain, bitterness, lawsuits and government paralysis. That's what
happened last year when the City Council drew new council district lines for the City. The lawyers
loved it, but we had to pay for it. The process has to be changed to restore fairness and
accountability.
The present City Charter calls for the City Council to redraw district lines every ten years in order
to equalize population among the eight council districts. Allowing council members to draw their
own district Jines is the ultimate conflict of interest. In the past, council members have labored to
draw boundaries that keep as many of their supporters as possible within their districts, while
excluding communities and voters that do not support them. It is an incumbent protection policy
that is fundamentally undemocratic.
Written by the government watchdog group Common Cause, this measure would create an
independent redistricting commission. The commission would take the power to draw City Council
district lines away from incumbent council members and give it to citizen commissioners selected
by the Municipal Court. It would require that the court apPOinted panel of citizens draw the districts
based on strict criteria of fairness and with full public participation and scrutiny. It would also
require the independent commission be set up and lines drawn after each ten year census, not just
before, as has happened in the past.
This law will compel the Council to work for you. Allowing incumbents to redistrict deprives voters
of the fundamentally democratic right to choose between competing candidates and views. An
independent commission will ensure that lines won't be drawn to lock incumbents in power and
that the City Council will be truly representative of the people of San Diego.
Create better government through fair representation. Vote ·yes· for fair redistricting.
STANLEY F. ZUBEL
Common Cause San Diego
LOUISE C. ARNOLD
President, League of Women Voters
RON ROBERTS
Deputy Mayor
MARK D. ZERBE
Citizens for Independent Redistricting
ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION C
No argument against the proposition was filed in the Office of the City Clerk.
PR·1690·16
P SO 104-47
CITY OF SAN DIEGO
Proposition D
(This proposition will appear on the ballot In the following form.)
D
AMENDS THE CHARTER OF THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO BY
ADDING SECTION 32.1.
Adds section 32.1 to the City Charter to require the City Manager and
all non-managerial officers of the City to inform the Council of all material
facts or significant developments relating to all matters under the jurisdiction of the Council as provided under this Charter except as may be otherwise controlled by the laws and regulations olthe United States or the State
of California. Further requires the Manager and all non-managerial officers
to also comply promptly with all lawful requests for information by the
Council.
PROPOSED CHARTER AMENDMENT
The portions of the charter to be deleted are printed in strike aut type and the portions to be added
are underlined.
SECTION 32.1.
RESPONSIBILITY OF MANAGER AND
NON-MANAGERIAL OFFICERS'
TO REPORT TO COUNCIL
The City Manager and all non-managerial officers' of the City shall inform the
Council of all material facts or significant developments relating to all matters
under the jurisdiction of the Council as provided under this Charter except as
may be otherwise controlled by the laws and regulations of the United States
or the State of California. The Manager and all non-managerial officers' shall
also comply promptly with all lawful requests for information by the Council.
ARGUMENT IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION 0
This Charter amendment is necessary to assure the citizens and taxpayers of this City that its
elected offiCials are fully and completely informed by the City staff concerning all material and
significant developments under the City Council's jurisdiction. Although we continue to operate
this City through a strong City Manager form of government, the elected Mayor and City Council
members are the ones who must answer to the electorate and who, in the end, must make the hard
decisions about resource allocation and policy.
Last year's decfsion by a former City Manager and other senior City officials to withhold
information from the City Council about allegations of sexual harassment in the Planning
Department would not have occurred if this Charter provision had been Jaw at that time.
Unless the Mayor and Council members are fully informed about all material Circumstances,
how can they be expected to diligently and intelligently make those hard decisions? A 'yes' vote
on this proposition will go a long way in assuring those goals.
MAUREE:N O'CONNOR
Mayor
TOM BEHR
Councilmember, District 5
VALERIE STALLINGS
Councilmember, District 6
ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION D
No argument against the proposition was filed in the Office of the City Clerk.
PR·1690-17
P SO 104-48
CITY OF SAN DIEGO
Proposition E
(This proposition will appear on the ballot In the following form.)
E
AMENDS THE CHARTER OF THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO BY
ADDING SECTION 225.
Adds Section 225 to the City Charter to require that all persons proposing to do business with the City fully disclose the name and Identity of all
persons Involved in the proposed transaction and the nature of their interest therein, if that proposed transaction could result in a contract, lease,
or franchise. Provides for potential forfeiture of rights for failure to fully disclose. Defines ·person" broadly for purposes of this Section.
PROPOSED CHARTER AMENDMENT
The portions of the charter to be deleted are printed in stril