tti?i??ett't?etii?'t? Elie" eete?t ?teeter etii e?Te mete tie, Eifft'i?i?eit ee rt't. ee sitieihh?i??i-ti?ili? ii?ei it e-tieteete .333 i Hi?? %i Fieeitie en time 130bit'd}; 260m i{ I e?ee t?tii te te iehetitet?: Cent}: Deita Sf}? wee "feilewed it}: Jeiet itetentien Greet} 13ij pert-tunnel during the Ite'te'e reign-ii} .2086; tied= wee tiet whether thie ?eiiete eetitifihtiteti te the ef the te eeiemit en thet eight. 3. it eetepieteti e11 review efthe iitete end the exetiette ef the geerti fire-ee end ethet' JDG during the ?if?t?t?tigit?f ef 1 i} Jette- 2385, I 1e that geerti fetee and ether KEG eeteetteei ti efthe {Seine Beite St}? titeng the ever-?eight heete ef "I'ite ieliewittg petteiee: luau?h I hie the": efSC?t'i? See-iiett te tee e'eility ef the te eentetit . . . - . . it i rejeet lee eetteieeten thet etefettee ef etw ?eetien ibiiZ} tiethittg te the the te The findings effeet in the repert ei eleetijt te?eei that the three time ie prepare [he instruments with whieh they eetemitted (bit?) {biiZ} The that the thie Letititetteeted gee itt geetd en the tier te ire eet inZ} i tittet ei? $9.13 Seetiee i eettiieeteti ili?hi?g te the ebiliije the te eeteteit i__ie__tefe_t{e_tii_i hie; ie ieeigei?eeset i tiiteeteti thei the tii'fit'i ieetitete ark! In F1 - nag-1.? I 1- ;r it} te. titte gem-tee: the iieete. i teieet hie titet ei? Si}? See-?ee (bit?) in: a. a. .- '31elm: I-.- - ?an e. Hugs" a -r e42. rat-21% .e .e emu.- -.-.-. Ti ema- .- 114:; tee itin in tee tit tee?. itei te i ten. tteteetee . .. H1c ai-?V ?trim-'- 1-.--: --. - . . I. Week Hi mi Haiti eta. :tE fjitqieet?ii?tittif tintjti it: tent; tithe - -.- .5 ,1 a- -.-i?hw 1.I'w'i't'?a I: 'h i? I: .1 7n!- . . 'Ii. a 1 ?eet tie:- ?ee tie ?itet?t e. tit tit the Le. Heme tittet? it?: e. tiete ei tt?teii a iaLifE-ei?i-t Ir. ., ..I In": "'21 E4 in if? 'i?Ti et. ?e ?Pg-i *2 ?it-"J eat-??21?: i"H ?1 LWT- PHTE 1-1 r: ?i'iw-u 1.. 1";5 gig-31.1.5.5 Le! EHJLEvile-5.1. a . II 5e. 13.5: ..-. a .I 1. clip.II. I I. Pull. Jul: l. a: at} l' I Lin-Ii; Left EILEJJELL igz-E?v?a: Elia-L153 Ei??ulii?e Li- ?it?Eighteen: 11.- 2- 51:5. ?Zr LEE-vii:- ii}: It} 2 GTMO SJA 1 "tj'taa hat-ta tat-a ttatt?ttaata aatata tha "t'"tta titat tta: tata? 'a?at?a Ettat attaa at ataa aa t3? Etata ?Ett??a tta tatatt aat ataiattaa at St}? ta at'tt'tit?jtr tit-fitti- ta aatataa f. itta that had a'aatti atatt EEG tall? a . tha titti tt ta t'tta tta'a'a J.- 3. ?vlr'aia??f? ft. ta ta fatagatag tha tattaatigattaaf {Ef?aat that tha J?t?f?tta pattay at taattiattaa ar aitatattaa af {ta taattataat tialattatt at? SGF Eaattaa Et- Eita) ta tha at?tita ta iaataa wttit tha t-attaatigatiag ?t??aat?ta tt?t thia tagard. in a?dittata att?tat that an: wait hta ra'aart tikat}: ta tita aa watt. tha Riga fat ta haag ahaata? btaattata? aatt athat' ttama aatia and dimming af lighta aa tha {tat ta the Tia: WETE a'ttla ta that]: btaakata aatt attaata ta- ataa frata lha attarda tahtia thaja hang ??am thait and tank. at tha ?ghting tattaa ataatiag a ma a with attaata ta-atartala ta taaita it iaatc; ttka "atata ta their calla Si??pt?gt a. hatta that a it}? that guard Elli} ataff {it"ET many at tha taint-a that apptiad ta tha guard fataa?a haatdltag at tha ta tha ability ta aatamit aaiatda, tart t3}: tha Of?aar it?t his; rapart thara abaat what {ha wata ta ha 113 ta thait aatta aatt aha-ta ta'ata a'athattaati ta da aa The: gttatda warn: alaa aha-at haw fat" [hay tafata ta gt} ta ?ghting afaitt at ataa-?aataat at at atght aatt tattat that: wata aathattaatt [a taka if that: at ghtad aaitltaa Fiaalt}: ttwaatigattaa Eti'p?? daaumanta that the: $136 taadatahip lat-"ET a. tang pattad aftiata - apatatad in aa af aagattatiaat and with tha in Camp Dalia ptiat ta the Tha datainaa' taak af gtaatad by tha ta on 9.51% Jtata Aa in that tapart afiavaatigattaa, ataay guards: had tataad about ma?a ta 111a and had that]: aanfaataa appltaahtitty 0f aftha EUR tt aat appaar that "ate-ta- priat ta tha ti. an that tiaata aaci in tha apart at" tI?It-?E?igftit??g tha aatatiaataa that paratatatt tita t'tftt?t pttat ta tha and tha taattatattitfa fatlat?t: ta tia aattatt ta aat thta 1.1 a? .- T-rrnw: l??pri _r u: rib: 1.. I In. attititt that: that?. atfa {ti "that at? tat that-at. . 'i -: . slit-alga; ji; Eli, ?ittfaat? ata ta a: at: artta GTMO SJA 2 - . . - . . . i. i? 1. -. - 31:} "r LGEHE rm Ema: mm mmam gagg??n: am my; data 162% .11 i?LhS {:31 Lhk- gm: .mmi risin: ?f a?iuidcg and ilmi'iar a?ivit?aa. That g??f?i rati?rva ff?i?i?g m: ini:lla' 12:. mi imi lLifi?ifii ??g-agtm?kal a This D?im its aisz?m??y "Limitrg?i'?g a 33mm and :?ew?m Eu wri?iicn pmmciums it: pm?i?? and it} Katmai? ?15313}? in?rm {:himg? {hm b?e? pmmulgm?d in 335mm Th? EEG it; puhii?hing ?a?y {ha EEG Grains}.- whi?h wmaim gu?d?na: am ?aws a?az??i?m d. with Eh: ?ami??m .1..- E. in?r?a?a? guard mam??g that suicidu?? Elia [3131111ng Each ?ag-EL wag incraasad it} indude bHZgu-ar?s wiih aha: Sale {31" walking up 3.11;} {iitpml bi?uka 1:13 ?111(2) t0 n~ Lamar gum?ds pt]: blag-K deviate-d in: Shawar?, ream-alien tima maai?} mm?amentsg m. Thi? aiiuws ail bu: ulwck?d within {hm} r41. Lighti?g - Light? cm the: ma i?ngcr dmmed 3.1. {Light f. Reduced Gamma: Items - wan: num?ruug mm?nrt {{wca blankcta, hm sheaths, mm) prim ihu Thi? practica war; m-cva?uated anti extra item?, Such as $3.1m Eil??ts and hiankala were. eliminamd, A?di??na?yg Shams are new ?amed cash night at 3201;} and animated aach morning at 050121. TEE: number ai?iiumi d?t?i??E-S an: ED keap if: their has bait}: grea?y 3, This. EsT?-g?gaiing mucu?mi?g purmnn?i d?'m?i?pm?ni ju?imr Ewi?d?ra and Qataim? ?n??rmati?? ?sf?nag?mcm fiyat??'l mix-??51131: are: h?i'?g {St ?313; g?i?i'?i r31? ma?a? fa}? ?Ehi?r: ma?? i5"; Hi3 50$ amiacia? 531?:me mm:- ram-2%? any? trau?a?ii??a. 'r 933;; if; if? xii? figs-:71. x" i: I f-eyl Email-{gr - fir Ia?r?gj Eff-"flag: Twi .51 ?g EM 1? Iris-Era a: ?a i 1' .aimh 13.42Hidi?ir?g? :5 GTMO SJA 3 3% ?-?aege? Here}! :14 fire?: Rat-pee; effe? 3343 {if} if: eeieh ie?ee ?E?ee Ami}, ee investigetiee iete Whether {?e??tei?e ee the eige?s 2.9336: if whether be the dee?ze me} $93, ESE eed ?93 I meet eyelegiee fer the deiey in predeeieg this repere hut the iete? iereekieg efe eritieei medi?eetien Ie the SGP diempted e1}; erigiee? timetable. Beth the Jeim Beteneiee fit?er end the C-rie?ieel Inveeiigetive Sereiee hed- ee efehe treble I ?etiei?ee.? The revieien eiieweei he end wee ie efiee-l ei the ef the This; made it me te er revise enlisten?el pertiee ef week: ahead}; eempleted: and {e receneidee 1e}; Ee {he eere With regard te ehe ?eet the Ephe. Hiee?egeer?. ieem *eieletes? peiee?elly eigei?e? ee efehe {keep Due-lie ESP: is?:egaiee'?eeh ex5:33.13? Lee ?ee-emer- egr'I'l-l . -. 3 Lee i??i?i weeie re 5: .T- -T Ml;- - Ir I- 115.q-E In 5:55 .-L 33 is H3- ??'rejef. Eemfe in: 3.1 E?ei??l? ELI F: GTMO SJA 4 -.-. - 75:? urn} Lulu u'ui uu . .1 Pu: -. uu?uu?y Eu usu a mi}? uumugu u; {?if uud uiruuiiy Eu mu 'E?hu ugwuu usuiuh hung ?31qu uu?uJuu uqu gruu?y uurupH-uutu? the uu~gu?ug fur Tau uiulu?uu uruu by ufihu Juiui ?ruup? uua; by Emu}: 1 guurduminduui the f?uruu diuuppz'uued. uf the viufutiuu. Thu HUGEUE: with whiuh mu wui?u thut was u} the uui-uiduu? which that pruduuiug uua'i ugng a wuru ?u wurk mu uurdu jut it uupuuiu thui JBGE puliuj; with :?ugusru tu the fur Thu hurt: withiu runjeu just. what the- utu?tuci. Flu}: qukuu uui?uci undursiuudiug uf impuriulli rqu-u uS thuqu purtuiluug ?Eu huugiug uu cull 1*qu 13 uud uhuukiu g1 whiliu {hey ulupt- The dutuinuus generated u: uuh ufth-iu uitumutuiy u?uudiiug fur uumprumiuu uud rugiug uguiuut uil '[hu wh?u duugiiug auirugu uf just huyuuci tuu much uf uhiufputty uf?uuru auid juuiur uf?uuru. Thu bust ihu Strategy uf subversiuu wuulu hum: utuu?y gumuut tu Camp Gnu-*5 uupurui uiug CPOS uud juuiur u??uul?u tu uufuruu camp rule-5 ?rmly; huhuuiur. t?hu Juiul {Eruup Ehu uumu u'uumiuui GTMO SJA 5 ii, Hi FL XI, KER EIH. XIV. EV: HEEL Ei??i??a {if Fr?smw uf Required ?aard PE {3f {fimm?i? 1. Hm?aga ?'?ai?ri?i {ham-Jim? Bi?t?ii?i {Li?:3 Hai?am {if 12in: Camp- Bait? D?au?ea E'??frrmagi?? Safa'tam (E) Fi?di?g? Hf Fact: Mann-Er and Tim? ?f B??sth Mamie; 0F Uaatim ?rmed Magical Exa?nnars? ?giini?ns 1; I Mammal hem Regarde 311.11? gm gum {if} 'ifistimat?d Tima 5f Scam: Dismv?ry {If the H?iim?i?d Tim-t: ?i?D?ath: 01? Death E?tnnatcd me 173mm: M?di?ai le?xra?n?rs? Finai Pitamp? RETIDHS 3f" Camp i Duty Leadcmhipg Sung 3086 (U) PTESEHEE {if Aiphz: Black Guam T331115 9 Juan: that Gum-{in Left 1h: Black Una?un?ad? 9 $11111: $30365 Finding? uf FREE: Hf Guard ?versight :31] ?13th Black "Vigilance {1f Alpha Biij?k Guard '11:.am, 9 June 2006 (U) Randnm Hcadwu?ts, Jung: 2886 (U) Frequancy wiih Which Guards Sumi?e?s?: Ruiag far Guard Sightinga {3f 3i High: F?iim?u?: mm?} 3 him: {if} What Br} Wham ?-uafd? {Tania HUT: 55:3 IF 1 ?i ?g 5. 'hnEi??i??h ?33ii? if"? GTMO SJA 6 Elm-H'- 1 i' Mi lam. Hit-J: -: .HII. WI: :rI . if 'Lr Egg pr.- KEBK HER-FE. Evy?" i?fh'?i . IT. HERE. XXKIIL EDGUJ FEVER {if} {Emma Liam}, ?15: S?ii?ag 3g L5 iirwa??i??a ii}? mm: FEE a? fh? #312 {if} Fmp?fm??m 555% Summit-6;: EH 31 Semii?aee P?gsamj??a far ?uicide: :33 far Suicid?i {ii} Birmi??: P?mgami?c?a {at Emi?i??: :31? 11.14.:- . . - (if; 1L r. w! Ell-1 .- ?iljaiifmj?j; if; Ema: ?f??aih (IE) Findings {Tam?u??ge and {T?ncc?lmmt by ?atainma 3GP hai??i?c?i?n Panni?ad Hanging an Camp 1 Walla?? ?unmaim?m by This {:hain {Jf Cumm?nd C??aprehen?imn that 3GP Permittad Hanging; ?15 {miceaiment his Eatai?a?? m1 Paipha ?lmk, Emma 290:3 ?139 ?ammami quighL ?vaiiatb?ia Eur Night by {Earth-a, 9 lung 20% ?35712} Q?p?rt?iif?? {?rm Si}? Eli} ih?- Eia??i?? Ramp 0f SOP viaji?ti??s, 9513 June. 28% T4 ?uipab?ity simian Ragax?ing Juniur L?ad?f? C?n??nmi?n Gf Cammand Phiin??phy Ent?liig? new Analyai? Samurai: infant-mama Managemai? Ryatam Em??im gi. - H, 51.1} J?ikf??5'1. r- a 5 aim: ?rth: fut-7:1; i a at. ?him, Jim 3941?- GTMO SJA 7 EEHEE .3: Ham"? 3-: f?i??dai? ?gi??i 1g; .E?f?a?dnx?a 3.12% {Eg?ci?i .?qggmiuti?g Latina and Emm?ian 2. Camp Sarita. Standar? @g?ra?ng Fr?a?dm? di?t?? 3. {if} ?ataui {Sim Jun E?ih?j USC E. Mantis. Ei??a?j {Li} USC Emmi}. 15 ?ipha Black But}? F?r??nn?h Night ?f 9% 1:111 2.0% 1. (3am LEG Nigi?; Jun MAI rim-1 mum: St i?menia EL U56 J. . . Eritremantq 5 an h-J :isz??ums G. if MASH USS Statememg d?nh TREE C. Gthar {Ea-1111:: i DHW Guard E?m?w. High? {if 951% L111 3.866: i. 2 RUE gamma 3: St?tc?fci?? 4. f) Mg?i Statemth MAE .1 Ham CTMI 0n TR 1t 3. MAST Statement. 9. MAE .I Stareman?t LIZ "l 5mm? tama?t CWOZ .Ej?l??t {11333.35.11. T: USC 2:331:13}. .73. if? GTMO SJA 8 "Fi? {if} {Izmir Eh{if} kx?i?? le3li1DUSC 2, ?13?b~m3Hm~mhiWCF sit-31mm; 3. {ii} {as} ma: 3 a (U) {mm-i 3&5 {If} Emmi; ?ai?i? 115m? Paya??-i?i?h Juli-:5: E?fiI?'uf MN {in {If?-L?aa?ia?am? Bay Hawaii H??piml E?Ui?mn?uL 9 ?lms:- 230% E. {ii} {b}{3}11 U50 Stat?mem and Ewart 2. Mm Rea-nus Fina} Aut?ga?y R?p?f? E. $533, Tagir 31 liai??ani, mm? Sakai 2 August El. ESTE- Mani Shaman TUka Mumyhi, r?pn? da't?d 31 Mi}; 3 {119130) 693,. 311i Abdullah Ahmad, I??p?l?l dated I Augu? 2005 THE (if) Learned S?urces; 1 Linguist intarviaw nt?wiew 3 1 {Tum 111mmle u. 1.. GTMO SJA 9 r} Emmi. (Ewing? E'hmum??ii {CT-amp E?s-aim mag} ?32121 Ei??k diagmm I .r i?hi T31: I if {ii} 1hr E?gu iai? i?i if? ??fi?i E?u?i 5; Elam; 1% watch ?ili? mm 38-34} {Li} Ej??ajn?a Manag?man?t Sy??m ?iph? mm Bim??r ?35 {252866 ?aming: Ma??g?i?a?t By??m {limit Ewan; EHML magma} ?aming: i?ib??alm? M?ligif?i??i Haggai 13mm"; ii?ygrij 56% {Emmpi??} {If} Camp 1 Piam?n Pass 13mm Lang Feb E??i?wg Ma}! 9* Camp I Plat-nan Madam P5335 ?aws": Lang 3.9 May Aug 323%} Camp Serg?am Bf the. Quard- i?ag Dawn Lag {31 Mar Eur: 1J3. Emmi 5?3" ?mg 5913' K. 13331531 Criminal Inveg?ga?iive Exhibits NCIS Ram-?aw EJ'fCamp Delta 22 51mg 2806 2, {Li} inibrm?tim? rcgarding victi?m? timc af?m?rh Exhibit Ph?t?gr?phs ?f ?lpha, mack and Alpha Bligh Ti?r E?ijb?. 115: 535.55 83' 43. 331315 Ph??i? f?ph? {if {jail was Exhi?aii 12.53 ?193 {3.101, :11} in t: 13? 5. (U) HCIS Ph?mgraphs 0f Cali ?13 Exhibit Hi Emu-mamas ?3245 ?3255. ?331, 1142, D451 6+ {if} N613 ufij?? A12 Exhibit Emi??u?j? E1 E9: Em E1135 F2193. REL F1325 Eff-13E E382. GTMO SJA 1O 3. {31s the eight ef sues EEJUE: seas she essiy seeming es" Jesse sees ghsee Yesses Tees} 5?13 Eshssei ESE Mess Eeselse ?sieis?sbi {?ete?ese ?fe 533}, see AH ?bessilsh $1 Aiseeii {Detainee were iseisseel is 331.: Alpha Ei?'?k i3 3 f??m?g?l?f ?le-111M! iese 'ssee sews ef eeiis ee eppesiie sides ef Lesikw?y slimy? 33 the e??zss Es {Zens 020(2) ere es the Eeft side ef the tier ss sees E'sess {he geese siege?; 4. ere es}. ihe sight side of the ties as seen frees the guard sheets} 5. De Jun-=3 deiei?ee 1393 "sees heesed in cell {3:1 39.33 {3 Jesse 1591? 333 mass heesed is sell Es- i {3?11 Jesse detainee 15:55 593 was heused in cell Ani? E4. 99:18 .Euee sees? eel} s15 ess sepsseted feel-ass eel! EMS {33: ?ee empty ee?sf 9. 011 69,910 fies-1e 200a eeH sing ?sees sepssete? frees eell :1le is}! ene- empty eell sud twe eeiis? if}. Fm the night ef UWIU June 20%: Chief?s??ssesni D?iees CWGEHMBM sees the Assistant Of?cer in Charge (AOIC) ef Camp 11. {311 the night ef 39.2? 113 June 2006, Master st Asses Chief was the Plsseen I'sesdes fer Camp. '1 . 1-- . Infurmstien figstem Aisha Eases Biester 35'} T3 Hines Esme ?eiie seep (T518 51} 3 ?ip-es Blue?s: {Tee 1'53}? Mes'i Eise fee ?9 Ease Leessiess ?les}; iE'eEs see}. Eel-ii ?embess ?ees Else-Es Evie-e? Piss ?e Jesse ??sewieg ssessiees ef?iees i?is see . . esses {see likes ease-Pee": 5'5" 3? Hi?i?usc in. 33;.ij- Hie-es {see 3W1: erase; {Tes- es r- II- hiatus2-?l 5- I- - H. sees. meshes i 955s mg 33? . Lesa-I i .- as? GTMO SJA 11 5. axis: is; sign?: sf {?rm hiss: ?ss?s i U50 {has si?shs {has}? ?sr {73131131}; I I I - Flu-l .- Il-_ .l 41.. 1 - - 1 a gush} shift sisng mss?sd m1 Elissa: s- s45. if: A I. ia-InI ?Tim Uhs?su??g shaft Us sir Arms 3313?s? i E?u?iss'iss mm usc {mans uss 15- Th1?- Esm?l? if? alpha bissk sf 3:33:10.? ?16. Ess?ing mssis "isstsui fur hsiilhs-ur and si ?fths- Essie: about. ??ssn minutss? E3 The fsurth ss'E! is praysr st 19 5. '3 Emits?: s, ssn?sm st EGEHLH .1sf}. Yrs-.- hs-adssunt sun} twsnEy-slgill detainees piss-s11 ss-ssumsd tar} and ?ss- gusnjs began ts and than: at ?815." .rI-a -I- t- r- .. .12. Ens singing sud chanting was Issac-1' than usual.? 313- {5655?} This sf Guard ass! ssilsai a, transl?mr listsn is ti and chant:Camp( Duty Raster Night sf hm 2906 i} Cami-3L. RDSIEL Night Jim EMBE- Hi Nam uss W313 $316.3): Camp 3. {Mil}? R?st?r, Night Jun {El-?15 {'I?n?irr?u?r' Rwsijr. Night sf?i-?i? Inn inns "$113 H515 uss Eli?s-Huh u: I. Fals- if: ?lim dH I: :s was; ,{busms uss H: bait: I.- at H. rs rw-i-r' I 3' --.. "1 - "c dismiss; fi?ij?i?i?} .Hs-sai Emmi. :91 sissr?'. v.5. .. {Fi? .. .3: GTMO SJA 12 Tug-5.; Ir.- 1 in 1 HH1 rug-."fate ttenetetnt entt net et E?'eet ttetened end titen tit-E i" I-?the tent tee etnente entt ettenttne teen h. . . 7e an.- a "arethe ttenetetnt EnJ-et'ti the eitent tite wen; ?which he ennin net eteetptteten. teem USE the enent ennttet ee; In? - l?fteeneietnt enttee?nen?}? eeknnwiedged tit et he tint net whet the 9 IT. I. nth-e et 303% when he wee en the tier. 313+ A tet'en?ez? tn ee b18111 nee feet in etnt tetebtet the were that i eneii phenettee?y ee yes-henn?? nteene Jen-tieh? we ebeeteing ISM 0935. ISM 533, and 693 3t}. The einging entl fee the ?fth nett nteyet e' etgn~- Jun-'5. UI 31 prey-e1". {been swept the tier between e1 ee end 2: tut}1 31 The resented singing enet eintnting nftet the ?fth eeti tn .P r. . - 3 nee-3 {new WEE dwm?d ?lm when she swept the net e5 iete ee 2130,? 34, {116993 The detetneen enit etnging end chanting ernund $3130.34 35. Meet nf the were eeteep by 2145.35 -- ntt? men it mete tf USC tftee tie-e} - n26 Interview {Tab 5'1} nnte e: {tee Bite} 3? nee; . e-t te- nettet eft ?it t?tifti?t 'eette . ?"teetet USC GTMO SJA 13 Fa: I, . .5. .. -- I?lgfIn. 41.. gi??i hg?i?; wam and? {m 221$; 113i 5.1m"; mi": Sada {at - 1 a, - - Eim mt}: ma?a sis-in ?ags 213% 55:13 Hr? Sur?ng at 221%} guar?a walkad. Mpha bi?ch {Er i? haifph?ur watcha? awarding 1-1: 3.11 Saih??ui?f? ?1513 waich and the {11723.11 USC a ?13?b. 1 . i a qq in": ham. watc?": and walk?d {ha} 112:: imm EC: 233%" ii. a MEL: had watch and walk?d in: frer 23801;} 12338:? '3 33, II-I'ijl Mm 3? ?j we?; a: thaw at Ems? WAC arrived at alpha blue}; 311.232 f? CF .1. .I.. MASS: :aik?d Eh? ?at? 5231* ?rst: minuies with MAI 31D r-i. 44, MAE :??lpha hi??k at?f?' I i?aJ 3 anti waih?? "the tier E?me 143 1L1 M33 {b33351 {mm ?h?w at T334313 355 MAE i and MASH (b}{3}11 want if} $th at 48? .3 1e Dnemi?ee Centur a1 randnm headwunt 211: 131335.43 use MILES Mist; was 333.21} JEEHHE 43? .11.;22} wig?"ElFae-Lara Fl. 1 1. . High-E:- 11-. "u gal-Pg I. Err li?L?u 515. 15f I .5 Ju ."Emn hum-in! Jr?: main}? a $313111}: an _s Lia-5-52,. :13; ,1 if}: GTMO SJA 14 :39 2334?} 5%me REEL: madam ?E'a??dmum wiry "r vi?! i?'??iym?ighu if; . 4i} . ?.53 I in; . .. ?ci?mn?: agwu?i?i Ma ?1 u' 1? 33536.} guz??d mm?mb?r? p?l?i?l??ll?g "that: 233%} h?-?dmumwaike? tier, M1513 1: .- DUSC MAE {b}{3}21 . . 5% ad the? wamh and began the i151? 3i Jig-?g: -1n Swim-E1 ad Ehif?? Eh MES 3W wax-FEE}: 512583315- E. guardg a. ii. waikad the. ?air from 0305 until he d?t?ctmi a pmhimi iu at uei'i xii?3 [11.51. saw m: uutii?: 13f whai; app?arcd i? 1:31: and a Emma: *3 MAE 53. M513 . . . :3 pres-ant. {1n 3.1.1'251m1ma2k the guard ?h??kf muse mm asid?, and gut 11:2} magmas.? I-I {b}{3}21 ??-mpt?d in Wali? 093 and @131 m} Lia USC maimed {mm thrcaugh fhe. hear: incl-?e 0f can hug: pun the .- ?i'g D?i?i??c In ?g rmali?n mtagemum 3323mm Ham] {jaunt R?y?fh {193 UN 23% HEEL 15?} USE: 335.3) 53 ?3411} E. 14.3} 132-3; 5'1Hm51 .ajL 1* 93' HEEL $3 f; {3.15; Hiff? .I. :sl? m'nI-i . . 71-? .- . if.? 1. LE we" 33:? at; ya ET a. 51372. . 5' a $5 a? GTMO SJA 15 . 1 - ma am {113:1 Emit-1L5. mill: mail, ?Whe?: WEE H3112) mi, 131%:- ggu?z??a 33w aha ma?a? E3252: rim! MAEWHMH 2 1 13.23. 31:15:?; was 11:35:?; pr??emat mama; and h??f?iht?: 63: {Fi'i?ijjt Riff-k2 )3 upward an ?ute}: 531mm: (311 ualiKbX and lu?kud thm'ugh i?hn?; windnw? bH?m ?54. MAE Saw Mimi: ha?gi?g by ME. their 513%: bah-m EL: MW ?55. Damned: LEN 993?s were an i??h in- an inch and a half {Tiff thr: gr?unddm I USC {Tam}: i ?i?l?di?g M?l mum rhuwrx rim} I. i I MASWMH tri'iiu'?i? ?le: uc?, cut [his ijami?? l?wer?d 133%: i993. :1 Camp ?1 guards; rammed {laminae 18?} cell per 8'01}, secured him In a baukb?ard, and rapidly . ?vs-L1 hi H1 u: this Camp Bah-as - a? Eil?i?. 63. At {3345 medical 3? Camp Haifa medi?ai ?117 Cardiopulm?? R?au?citaii?n and Atmpi?c 3:2 in an attempt ta} r?'v?ive detainuc 133$ 1 - - 69: .i E16333 111 mamas; at With ?agatwe results,? USC 51? HCIE NETS mm if NEE 31:15.5 -1 is?; a} in - -: II-IEL-J :5 2313,33? *5 Hi ii?: ET at. :5 If; .- 1-1-3 'h GTMO SJA 16 ?Fit f" i} sir: 'i?ir?y?i??i EN @553; {mm {ha Gamay Ear-33:; uii?ia: it} as: 5' mg: f. ??t?iim? {393. wag prisu?uncud {an ii?) 311% (if; in}? {want} U35 China-f ij?im Flali?'lu TE, a aii't?p?y anagram? sea. ffii?i?i??i? mm ma: 33'er ?ih by Eui?d?i ha?gingi 333* Simr?y a?ttr tilt: dimmer}: emf {imam-:13 38793 0933 {lamp 1 guard? The oc?upiad. cans. in. Alpha Bimck. ?3 T4. B?aiims: ?31 ?ght wag .ib??d E31: U50 a?d mugging by hie: mm}; in {as-1:11 Au} 2 ?with 3 Sheet .- I a -. n. wrapde arm'u?d 1115 hqu and by a Shea-t Imaging an the at his ?it-ii, 7?5. Camp 1 guard??. in?iudi?g EMSN U59 MASH USC and l?w?red 533?? T6: Th?. guard; i?tannf?red ?333 Emmi azuli ?125 ?l??kih??kbuard, and :?pidly ?amed him it; the Camp ta ciim?. ?5 0050, ??tai?ee ISEXE 533 was; administerad Cardia? .iluimunary and use {if-11?: (TAB we :2 NCIS Inf?rmaEi?H mganling ?'v'ilili'im?lr rim: [?1dech ?3 Final Aummj: Rag:an Ear T'Erili??i? T5 5} Fi?rhr??i {131% am; :31? {ha Arnie-:5! Fora-:33 M'red'imi Examiimi; ?rmad Emma; in?timte {If Path?l?gyr dated 2 Angina: E.) USC GTMO SJA 17 . ?er 5mg: ma?aum: 111% mi; a. imagihf3}. ?u i5} hint?? {Fi? 535 1: ram-1 {Ir-mum} Medm?i Datammn i-Emsp?ah jgm?cru?u?d Rabi 333 EEK, "531% autmga?y feu?zzi {Emma-t: ESE 5333:: {hath wag aausa? . i. gs} hf; auicid? hangmg, I. 0} TEE Hf d??th f?l? 538 W215 a?imam? i? ?ag-t repurt ?in EE ?at Margit a mum-:3 {if hum-um prim if} we dimmer? sit-f hi5 Edy?? 32. Shur?y alim- ihf: di?mwrj: {if ??taj?ea ISM $335, Camp 1 guardz feund 13534 I593 ha?g??g by his; ?c?k ire hi3 call with 3 mb?mrad by twa blankets in 'Eht: [tar {31? his amu?? hi5 am including U50 Camp 1 Ell?l'd?a cut th? am I??wefgd ISN 6933.} 34. Camp guar?g ram-mad #15: SOP3::E3'Lni'mi mm a ha??i??fd, and 11111: aha: Lamp mug sham. 85. (my Datain?a 693 was. admim?ctc? Cardiac Puim?nary Rasuscita??n and Aimpim: x235 Hm} Amway Hanan in: Mam hhaman iurl? Mutaybr {135% 3.155]: at me Arman Wiu?lu?i Emmin?a Arum-j Fm?cea institutr} ?ff?aihui?g?: dated ?33 August Elm-??5 Final fantasia; Karim?: ?zr Mani Shaman 'i?nrki Malay-id 533}, ?l??ce Uf??l? ?rmed Far-953$ Mia-mm} Exami?m?. Al?m?d Farms Institut? data?: ?ugu? USC GTMO SJA 18 - new . - . i re ?re erer were {Wererr?ree HERE eree e* 3e err Er} Eerie Elle: USC e311, mite er-reereef? ampere. 33: {39$ 3} The ?eei elite-grey repe?. rher ESH ?eeih wee I- Ir .- by ereerr?rel heegerrgr {Elf-3'36} The time fer 2393 "were eerireeree ie Eire r'ieei - . . . . 5? 1* 551353 reperr re- be *er ei heere berere he wee LL {Li} Er The {jer?p 30F iiere the feEinering 'ijillere em"? rheir deriee in he intreriee-riee re the ilemp {Eerie eireie 33, {may The jeier ?elereierr Greer; .1337}: ie Fer e11 in Cemp ?elrer 3+ The Beyer}! Ceerererrder, Jeier Hereeriee {Billf??jh ie eirpoier'ed by re eerier ie ei?dutree, 4. {m The {)f?eer ($136 33} plerre end e1}. Deite Ciperetierre? with en the reefer end ef?eieru eperetiee ef Came Delta. end ether were [J's . ff The Fieid ?rede 1e Wire (FGIW) is weleheteedi?g ef?eer e.th pereerreily the CKBG in the camps, end keeps the infenned regarding eigei?eeru? elleeting eefety end 5. (W) The Camp 13er Of?eer e; weleh-eteedieg ef?eer in the Dereinee Center. Ere direered by the EEG the Ee reepeneihie fer a? eepeete ef the eperetierr 0f Cain}: Delta, te ineiude the rile)?? te-riey humane eere, eueteriy, dieeipiirre, refer}: end wel?ere efeil The CBS is fer eerer and dieeipiiee ef geerd reree. USC Cu": .E?reei er- .erE? re: e?ieir ?rmer? er? reef gimme-e E-?ereer ?re?ieei new; E313. ESE-SE Free} ?reegrey Rep-err fer rife: e-fiiriie? r} ??iee err-hr; A: mini Ear-rarer ?feri?eggf Armed Eeei??sere e? Ferhe?rr?g fi?i?ii?' GTMO SJA 19 {rag-a} are JFE a? earara at are: Catarr Betta a. errata vl'! I. 11? 'Ju. . tier aer {Fir}, a arrataataadtaa ea magma-r ef?eet rattan at 3. The W?t?h??t??dit?tg Hargreaat Gaard ia the aaperriaar trt?aata? {Steele Niff?a aati Eat if Partr?-ate {arrareta The reagenathi?ttea eare? earataea arat aafetjr af arrara three-r 11a: 50?} eatbreea eeatraa, aat?eaya tiara aad 'ararraae treatraeat at aetaraeea titre arra- erraarea that guara perfartrt etatiea aati taaka tr: ataariarrL aad eeat?arra ta (Sartre '[ltelta ESP: The $06 erraraiaatea legratreal aappert at gear-a faree and detaineea and extra area that raeala are law Sehedaie af Carla. The $013 be the pa}: grade at er abaae. 9. h?he Biee-k ia retrpanaihie far ea'ery aapeet af the aerated}?! eeatrah eare} alteitea feedr'aa? treatment at'aEl detainees; in the biaeku The Black. NC 131C ettaatea aeerrantaiaility rarer ali triaatie aarata ant! ereraeea'eteanap after ateaia. tilt. the LEGS aati ta?) eeatrat, repeat, and. traeie at} aapeeta at? aeterttiaa faeitita 1. m} The Eaeart Centre? arid ?aatataat are reapenaibie .?rr air aapeeta e-f {Tatar} Delta aaeart eperatietra. 32. "fire Deteatie-rr Haaprtat Seettritjr Fetee NCO i-a far at} ae-e'aritgr awarded at Deterrtiaa titre-tartar? for eaatedy aarj eaatrei at" all detaineea treated at. the heapitai? arrel fat eperatienai e-arttrai rrt?aH attatda arraigned [er the heapitai. Hi. {Ur R. a. The earttpiete Camp Delta 3013' is attaehed to this repeat at Tab A-i. 1 ?at here the relevant partiena afthe ware-t1 are adttreaaed in greater detail ta subsequent Thea-re iterrta are arranged. aeeardtag ta the arder irr ware-h I ?rat them; the relevant aeetrrzuaa are ta 1aaret.tt.ireaea. My atatatieaa at at}? are eeatatneti ia aeetiaa ul- a? Err-?ff? re a? arr-a? a a. apes-?63; a a} a Eta; fine? 5% irr??a i it: GTMO SJA 20 4. 3:31? iabi? {Pi} Nat lri??gi??t {as SGP 1g (mini; Hg vimim?d *1 we?. {inhi- b}{23 .- - n' Ha}- -I- - - - SQPia?mic 3013 IF 1' ll:? -2.-. my 11439658} m? hig?r?i :33 Mai {Eifl? 22- 3531M 2} q? {sz) 1: brii- F.- star-aGTMO SJA 21 13. SUP tight-it: {httZ} time; te, 1001(2) thZ'} {Kt} t? [?FFtt?F?t en {mg} I I ?31(2) I f" "if Jet-J" venue-enema. .t e. em? t. 1e. {meet Hem 1-: grit W193-.- (Rte t- see- Detainee 1. The Deteittee lethrteetien Management System GEMS) ie the prime?' SFSf?l?tl fer Camp Delte geerde te everything releted te ettei events that in the hieeke, as well es the primer}! eyetem etepleyed by the IDS in ef ete?" duties?fty-Eff: gettetette teed repette er ItE-EE-??rj?e te teeiede getter}, peliey eheegee, itepeeteet reetere 'te interim Steele: .. ?i I '1 'r Nt?e ebeet titteete thet teteete the 8ettett ee e'teet t'etteeth-tr the likeIf: ?Iii-i Fir ,3 :1 if?: F. I -H. 1.. li'lr . I. . teitit fifteenth eat-?Let my; t?g? Ethel; {it {3in! eett the eett?te: ete teetet-teti 33w r*u'r sir-?..-. hr 4 1 athlete? i . . wife}? ?it: EH1: TE acre 1 .I et- ma luv-:'ai "1'21. 3, 1 -- -- eE1.. ?51? ?aim EH55. a Hf? ?ee-eater: Hittite Best-Tr ?at tt??tt?t e: t} er. GTMO SJA 22 ??lg?izilaaiiy anai ?agramghj my gig-gum an}; 5-591. Egg: 51:; F- the: I: Fania. mm. ?it ?5 ltmaie 238%: W3 E. f?iiuwing {yp?ra if in this rmp??: :33- - Emah Bimt?{11% U1 Guard "F??asag?g?i 3.55:3 {11:21:51 Haunt anti FF: 3311643111 I 31*- 5,57% u' "r "a it? 3.: ?irty if?? 3r." HEW i i. ?5 :?ar tsr-vv. F- - 35.31 Ll??t? :E'A?h?li hi?n EMT E.) 1FE jit?t? 4i"; 3 5151?:- d-F_ 3: $15.7" 9343 I a} 153?? Emir?? a en.- I I: ii ti. 3&3- .3: ?a .. ?fr GTMO SJA 23 u' Fia?iags ef Faerie Time ef Beat-tie T-E..- .-I: -H-: - ii.- .2- er tiresei - referee eereea a} ??ijt?rk i i :3 The ihree eaeh eiied ei' asehjmiatiea ea: te hemeiem the et? fi??ii?t eras ie. eaeis ease- 2.. The Fieai meteess? i?er is}? {3933 states that ?This year? ei? iiaegieg,? Tire feather siates feat ?tritier arr eateesiee iaeestigatiea there is ae te suggest that eise aas ie. this deaths Easeri ea the ieferm atierr available? the ef death is s'eieiriet?EM Ii. The Finai humps}: Repert fer st'ates ihat ?This Sift ?rearm eta detainee dieel efhaeg The repert {tether states that ?Fiat-lee ea the available at this time, the maimer ef eieatii is Seieitie.? if; 4. The Fieai Aatepsy Reymrt fer 13M states ihat ?This years eid data eiirai et'isaagiag.? The reperi further states that ?Ba-see ea the i teestigatiee iafermatiee ei? this date: there is ae ef aajreae else heme with Lilia eieatia? The repeat that ?is mad ea iafermatiera tiie manner ei?eieatii is S. Merit-ea! eaaminers? estimated the time et?death ier EN 583 and Him {?531 medieal eaamiaer did eel estimate time ef death fer ass. ti. "Hie Ir?ieai ritetepsje Repeat fer EN 1393 dees net an estirttated time ei? death." The Fieai Aatepsy Repee fer EN 533 states that ?The deseriptiea ef the "bedy during the attempted resaseitatiea iadieates that the rte-ate ai? least a eeupie efheurs befere he 1eras 3. The Fieai Aetepsy Repeat fer 693 states that ?based err the medieai ef the remaias entries; attempted re seseitatiee, rlre . . . nu. . . ?eteesy Repere iier Eire-air T. Fatimei east {.3973}, tittiee ei?tiie farmed i?erees Esareiaer, rarmee "fame .I_?r ..- -. -- irieai .aeteesy itemert rer tease Ei-iamae eerie armies-is: {Eats sear, r_ir.iiee _i'isemieer, ,?armee eeree-s iestitete ei?iiatiseiela'se eiateei itseaasi, Eiitfei {?rae iesiitete ef Pil?it? 1e ?fe} ii A agest Zititie ti'?ii it ee armee rem emerge} i'er Jail: {ii?fa east ?Lair-ea {armee Leta-es meat-a: I. II 1.11Reamer-ash Aime} iasrmae e1 insight-?3? gage-j 551L153 Ebg?rsg? {Tessa are?; "la. . I- film-Er .- -.I d. H- .1. Emirates; res: asie i, giai'iraer {item Fit ea;- e?ierarea Fereas Petersera: ear. mar-HI- -.-I - - 'hl3:5: same-a irerees teatime e: eaeen .Eeir a, r. ii; i, .m-sr- :smas . ia?ai?ii in}? i?s-?Ei-i brie?mci f?i??ii at He?s i ?it-in? Li'ILI?ejt H5 'h . 1-[ill -- see-a .eiatiiee 3 1 seeGTMO SJA 24 1:5 ial: 3?1" iri' I 'abasal; L??g .51 rig-if}? tili- Elig??i?tvr?rgaain E?ii?y} v.1 - - in a -.- jigging] Raina-an. . {3n f??ug??t {bii?in? USC {Wig}: mimic? {aiiama use ia aanan in fan aani aapii fi Dapaninant nf Dafanaai Wiih ragaan in anangniatinai {Mimic} nifaiad {ha parfni?niad ia13pia-Eii jaii hnnaa nanging airanggniaiinn} the in aii'ainnal ia within inn ininaiaa and ?aad within inn: mininna. 3. The ainia iiaina ia if ?ia indi?aldnai aiaangiati hiniaaif in? iiaraalf lying (inn-n naing a liga?inia aaiappad {ha naak. 4i {Li} Mina: aai?in?iai?aii anangniatinna an: nni fnii~anananainn hangings; that 153 in aa 33 than: annia anniani brain-nan ?nna nr anniha'a nniani and the h?d?av. 5. {La} ?aatii naii naani? in a hanging= a. Aianpaiaa gnnaraily n1 Liaian?niniag ?aw inna; it tank an}; paiann in {iia iinin atrangniaiinn. Fni'aign airway" ni?iatniatinna in aha tinnai niay aanaa drath faa?tar than fnrnign matter in tha thrnat. i, Alpha Einak gnania tin: bud}; nfi?i?bi in nail ai? ahnni nn ii} Jana ii?iifii wit-Fair Rim-i?iF-i- rai? nag}, Sinai: n? ina nn?ii?aii ii in: ni? {aw Ii. C'f?i??ibiigi?? USC in aa {?filial l: It: -1-3- - II..I- I -F-.- E. I I: - 2:111 - k'g-F' "1 E'hII.- Flu-El II I. 1 JEHIE I a: I Ell-'th F: L4in?: Tab anaaibi?ii?l rI-l' 'i . . raga -x :enn - - -. .- ifs; E?a rij-?lgigrg 5.x i ?Jiain?hg Eiri?af? i GTMO SJA 25 {b}{3}21 ?a :?F?ff a. 3 . .T?i?g?13 aa Ea: a-?aa?a Ea a? aa?ii aaw q. I. - .: :yii?ii at ?y that 5. aiataci Thai Ea: Saw ?ipiaa Giana?Ta mailing: iraa aha had aaraiad ISN 13% Ea aha iaadiaal a?aia and a a-gagabaa Swim-Hf: Finite: if USC UUI a and ihai'; Ea: a ma?a-Egan aim MAE: that, appraaimataly 15 ha 35} laa?' apauaa {ha prabiara in aail Egan}:- 1:1 MA. 3 3133C a aiatad that ha ami?aa af Elaa aama?ma a?ar midnighh 1% use 1 Mai} ?13 atatad that Ma? {b}{3}11 a with. ?ail a3 whiia MAE {b}{3}21 afaa waiking iha Liar ?ea} ta 810$ a'a if} $3006. 3. afar?a? IVEAE . . fa? aha: 9. ma (?page :1 Ma an 1. I 'Ir 23.45:, a: a ?air aitli?' a5 fi'am b}{3}21? stain-Li that he ?want ta- ahaw a1 1a {Fa-tire} atatad that aha want ta thaw wiih HAHN and ram-mad frara a-haw abaat 2344f}; USC I I. {may} hiaB atata? that ha aaturaad from thaw ai abaa?i 23:35, and that ha ramamhai?a taking aa'ar MAE atiar ahi? at ahaa??: 003a 1 b}{3 12. (ma?a) aia? far 18H 8?93 at 1:3. am thaagiglhi aha: he heard tha alahaard tha LU tan 17a i?uI-aa ba?a?a mi?aig?i. 1* mama use . ?13?b. mm :31" a a an {Taa a} a} a; - ri??a a 5 an Hawa; {751% E35 Hia?; {Tia} {"27 a a ?35: 4 a} in: gist?Eh: a .L a; .I. GTMO SJA 26 Hm. ?rm-mi: an, appmfiinmi? ?int: fur {ha 1 at qu'i {hat mu: EEK: a ready marria? WEE tea-11:3: m??mai and mtum?i he: Emilie-22,1 up If: ?ipha ht: h?ai? Aipha 125. kirk 1? ?di?irj ha 9:22.151: ?ipha, guards; if: (W) Camp 1 guards; diamvcr?ai 1hr: bad}? EH ?393 in 31$ :11: abm? Gil-?4% an Emma 10%. V13. .U??rh 1. Findings; 01" fact ragtimng the: pranmunc?m?nt 0f death ?rst 133%? 0% {13:31] ?513} Inciud? rim fbfl?wi?g: E. (EEG- mam m::mb::rs ?EE-?li1p??i?? 13M ?393 the Hava? ?195;me {gunmanamu Bay ST?ii?d mat medic-a} {Ers??n?l at tin: Iauapitai deniamd 8% {a be dead 211: 111150 {311 10 June: 3i. {Wig} Eta-{i that 8?93 wag -l prm?munced. dead at 01310;: In via. MAE 511W ?aw that abnut a deem: at that I?ims'a} {Emapit?i ISN {.793 dead.? ?5 5, Findi?g? {If 121:1 ragardi?g the estimalud time (If death far 533 55112) include tbliuwing: I {11. Camp Delta. medical uiinir; my}va that the Era-"Trim" Manila-? {Jf?ma USC 23%? 53.3% {1335.1 21E 9} 5' GE 'gg} 3mm 3905 ?nial mum mu?er f} Efi??l 5:24:33 ME in {ha srigt: ?arfm mama-a} Eii?ia? a? GE ?1 ?3 Mid ham? Esj?g war: have: imam ERR. "13.2% (In. . . v.5. JJIF may; that ?"111: $35.1;er i5: J. I..- maul-55'1" - ?l?hEE i=3; :5 sat: I?ll: I i. . ta- . :Irl-I'. IIE-E I n. Milan?- t" U55 a a .FI. .l l'l'l I. - f} as "g air": a" i 3.32: 1% "f 3-. GTMO SJA 27 USC far ahaat Eaaif aa Ema: Tha $13Dbib?HEHb?h w? . -L ugh-mi a1 iaa; mm: is; g, 1 I..- {Ea-ad by 13a: ariaazi?aai G'i'?aar ma. rig .- . -r {?at ESN 533 {W331i} ai? ahaai 33- that {211. 5 aha acacia? {Eat -. 3 new- a. aha {Ia? *aai amiajil?i?m atatad that ?am-.21 nfiba 533 and ISM {3533] in tha ham mama wart: pra??ancad daad a] lara *5 1a. ma?a the: daciaian that iha detainee was daad. a?tata? that ?At U1 Dr. =51] if! 12.. Fiadiaga 0f fact ragaadia-g tha af daath far 6?93. {call iaalatia 111a 11.1119 wing: E3. Camp Dalia. aiinia Ba Jana 209113. Ewart mat aha Bani-sat 1593 daagf! at {3.1 2:35 aa USC 14. ma: aa that ha waa iha Elma a1" ?aaih. I laakad [may] watch and ii waa 15.? 131i i5. {118999) atatad that ?Hath af the: 583 and ISN 693: in ma iwa mama wan: dead abnut 0] ma 1:2: Ha. USC ?at-acted. aa aigna afl?a {in 6931 and {ha iima ai?daath al 8116.? Via aggra J. l. i: ..I it?! End 1..- .- .1 . 1L1: .--. .- I i' . Hit-'1'! I I?ll.? ul'" a! mama gamma: It {at-aa aa} {a?aa airJar", w. 1% :5 E55: if .--.. I. H. .1-1 In.- - E- h? .3: Esj?y?t?if 35*? Egg"? when IE. Iii-L- :5 clun?r- E. 3 i a GTMO SJA 28 tit Retirneren Eeerninereifftnetnrennet- Renn?g h. hark ?t 1: car-:55" t, t: . n. ate renter tan eh net rnenee eennteten nnte 3. titre ttnet entnpee repnrt fer E33 etetee thet ?The teeny [ref 1334* tne etternetett reeneeitetien ivnnteetee titet the et. tenet e. eenete eefere tire wee it Tine ?net entepey repert 181%? 6?93 etetee thet ??t'tre e1? titre we}: [er 693] during the ettentptett reetreeitetien thet the eleeth nee-erred et e; ennpie ef hnnre hefere he wee 4. The ntertteet eettrnete ef eeneie nt? trenre nerrnwe tire renee ef tinree the the deaths; ef 533 end {393. 5. If ennpte nf trenre entreled Ewe then ten entt ISM 693 died between 2330 end 13:31:1th ?eeing the tier weteh USC 5 USC 6? wee the genre wtrnee ettentten wee rirewn tn ee --ere we} {hiring hie tier weteh. :teted Lhet: ?When I erri?eett et $121 I eew hienltet en the fie-er. The blenleet te eentething er eenreene under it en I err. I interpreted the te the deteinee tying trnderneettr tt. I die. net wenettj; the eeli tn it er enyene wee trenging inetrte. I neet but I didn?t innit in en}? nt? the eelle I wee ebetrt the bienket en the ?eet in At?tf??q 1 :tlee eteten that ?1 feet thet the guerde end rnyeeif en Alpha, bieelt did en inertetgeete jet) rne-nitering the thet night tn rneke enre rhet they were fetiewtng tire rulee ee tn ehew?ng} enn?re kind e1" ekin white eteeping. feet thie happene with everyene en ever}? nine-k5. everyday. it? end rte the eerne etr'ery tinge? end it gete enrt bearing. I wien new: been ntere ettentwe entt eenid enntething tn eette the 1 teen"! knew if the died en wetele tern .t enrnehew feet reetrenernte ter their m_ 're't?ftfe {b}{3}II.- FE Hi negate Feat Few: i i' "i 1' J5 .-E GTMO SJA 29 ta" a; it a atata titaa tta'a ttataa ttat taatatt aa Etta-t atat LEE?tat atay tta'aa ta: tha tt?tt?ittw?Itit USC 9, tar-La} 1 that attatd aha . 1 . 1 =3 aattat ta. tat: aaf it. WHEN ta a taa; ?aa ata that ?at a - ?at? tag: Tha ta ttata tt EtE?trI-t . .- It}- 1 1+ {mi Latat at that: aataa ia ta at}; a ??aw aid ahaak far a haad aatatt?? }:1?aaid 11a ?Laaka at at a tiraa; laaka fat bat taita it aatit ?aa?akaa up. It 'takaa {iv?It} ta "aiaw aiaapiaa aataatiataa yaa hatra ta wataa 1.1'tit1t'ttaa [ta dataat' 11%} If a af haara waa mom that] ttaa and a itaifhaarat than tlta hangad thata tahtia tha tiat was; {all}! itiamiaatad. Man} {b}{3}11 atatati that am paattit?a that all Ehl'?t: taata aliaa What: 1 ata'aapiag. ?Pitta attattiy bafata a13an btt3tr1 14% W63) Ma 31:] USC atatati that aftaa tha ttat tarataht ha at: aat?aa a dailaa and. than raa'ttatiatt tha athat ta Er; it:th a trait 35a? i?w ?s?a?gt? $5513} t'tatt tat-t3? Etiat t-H'aw GTMO SJA 30 Eim??g? ?f Faith Waygim? {if ?mrd {Siam {hi-*3 3533 $333: gis?eeg?inm raruag?r?f 53*: gagr? 5:31:33 imdera??g} {Egg Ff. gag-:- {g?rga?m af?x {Emmz?f 1w? 5 prewar?! wi?lm fia?fr #5 Ski? ?m??is?y a? am am #:ka Hawk?! in? {may ?zgri?g Egg", I 2. Ne: ?uggasts that {:iiher tha {13111;} I :31: if this Guard CTMI {blwlim was ab?a??g hi5 pi?cc 3. {Few M?l? [31(3) was duty Flaunt: Lsad?r in Camp 1 tbs: nil-gm w?mh ?rm] abus? 17:45 01} 9 June it} ab?ut 0545 1:111 10 June Emmy} MIKE hHSW'z??dll?i?d. a ikm?amugh i?EpEE-fi?? mi?ipha Black; at??aut232?l31 m. appreximately MACWHM imam 31mm Elma}? an his; Edit: and ran Lu M12113 Walk?; - E71, wag duty Sargeam Guard in Camp 3 far 1.11: 1:11 watch ab?ut 1-345 an 5} him?: 3006 aimui: 0545 ?311 10 ?11115: 200a.? {mm-Em ?p?ke with ah: Alpha Rim}: NED amund 134 USC 3- visited ihe ?ipim Black guard sh??k b?lwl?-E? 2130 and 2200.155 (TM: visaii?d ma alpha Black guard shack Sh??fl?f after as: . i ii}; appraxjm?taiy Gil-?11K! M?i U517 31? aypamn? E?i?id? Ci'h? ran {35:1 EN wash mus. mm 5:51am; 2; was: {Wizziaa??asa? 23.73% ITE: :33; #1 Lu'. i334 USC 'tjlij??i! mag; 12-; ..-.. I 155% Til-i. $.35 '5 w-s; :11 5h . .1 GTMO SJA 31 i 2 . e. - 53-93 hie I?fi?iemere?eye X1. m. 1e. 2006 {$896} Ae eeted ebeve in V, ef Gee}? 1. Der}: Leederehip? the Cemp 1. end Sergeth ef? the Guard. ?lphe Week at feer en .9 mile 3. ere: epeke eehthe me me wee - .133 3033+ ?13ee.{e} {were} 4. eieited {he AEphe Bieek gueed eheek 213$ ed. 2296.139 3? {We Wee}- {he ?ee-e meek geerd ehe?ie e?'ee {i Him} e. *e'e?eehreegh inepeetiee e1" Aiphe meek etebeel??l?.H ?He DIME eiphe Bleek ee- 9 end 10 J1me eenteiee the {eliewing entry at time 2320: 3. The BIMS ?lp?e Sleek Bieiter fee: ?9 and Je?e 2.506 the fellee?ng entry e1 time 2323: GFE e. MAEMSW teed the: ?Durin '1 3- USE . my e300 e338 mete-h. Essie-Hi {bin} and did e-eik-I?reegh. I wee ie the middle ef the tier when they eerie-ed. ?Heel-4;r eeme in behind end me. The}: wefkee Le the end ef {he ?ee, turned. eed welked iee'erd the geerd eheek. .E de eet knew if hey ieekeei iete eeH end by {he they see. the; bed ee eed; eelie ?ij ?33 Eli-a i Hi .. era-ere he USC ?ee; {fee-e{WWI-1 use wee e. a e. ire .1?an GTMO SJA 32 VII .2 .F Ill-H. m. i h; Af?rm. Mimi-z ?aw mam 33mm}: 2113:3171 an mfarmai ?rai?i mice: l: H: a? :12mmhu?ugg?g c5, Egg. {gig-?g? 51.23 H1359 54.3 5-5111?; . i??'LaFg -- . -. HUS El th?} :1 "wash bi} hma? 1 H4 {b}{3}21 {ii-:21 {ha stat?d that ??i'htr: guard? "wan: wat?hcs 531' Bi] minim? mic-mam, This night [9 Inna [1mg w?mf: 34?! I4. 213$" 15+ liar" ?3181} MAE MAE ?306 M313: 1175i far the. p?fi?d usc, W?i?h atana??r it: indi?at?d in but ?iga?where in hi3? Eh? 531:5: that She mend the: Quit] $31 m" hersuifh?ra is an ermr, 35 in. ?lm 3 {b}{3}21 ?ll-Dr? i?us?rated in App?-Ildi? 1 0030-0100} 20. 21.5F6?f?? hi?? IRC a; i-i?a} 1 553: 31:5; ma 1% 3,3} USC ?-?E?iff?li? E5 ?3,535} ?13?b. is"? Ei?a? .Ir .. a 31%; a Eq??uu 0930? MAE Exchanged ta {actually use ,u . . 51min Mimi-1E ?Cums-lmmna? 321111911 anti MAE USC exchangcd USC ch?ngt? watches with MAE fu?her 51:21:qu that ?It is 1n 1130(3): j! undursta?ding that GTMO SJA 33 that Uttatteattett Ease: Ef?e . .. . ea stat esa at. thZ'} 3, Gee alpha. tateett statett titat as a eettseqaettee ef etetattag Etta} fit? thete "teas a patted at? tett after ?ared ta detainees eat-ass ?He teas wateitiag the a. stated that ?Aftet sets-?tag the feed te the {at ataaut ea 26061, the ait at atpha ?eieett et'e'a" atet ef the guard shaelt teta'attis the Sa?ys. We ate efthe eat-ta feet! that the detainees did eat teaat aetl had a shaft eett?ttets atieat mitten tastletl} appt'eaitgaateiy 1-3 minutes, Ne ene teas wateittag the at that at Tate algae Hteek ?estas same at the haste taets at ?at?t?t??h bat ?aetag eff the ttet aatt eff the . I C?f" tateelt, a. MAB teseeatletf la the questions ?He attat?tis step eat at the ?eet: tea: tef?teaet eheta'? Diet that hapeea eat t?aht at" 9-- 10 Jane?? by stating that ?t have seen guards eat at tale-eta; tattea the ?ame has heett tet?t eat. {in the eight ef 94.9 at? June ail Meek guards stayed ea the blue}; a?et? ehew was eat: We sat at the betteat ef the stairs in the treat at" the black and talked W?fk and pe-t'aeaal subjeets.? t4? MAE (W3) respeattett te the questieas ?De guards step eat efthe bteett fet- Eeftettet? Did that happen an night at 10 June?? by stating that eftett step at? the ti er, as 111}? ttet eff the hiee it, ta eat sttaeks at left eater ateats. it is a eetataea ameagst night shift petseattet beeaase tee teete eel}? aatitetiaett at eat break per 13 heat sat-ft: 3345 mi in the ta'tteteas ea. dates yea ate ttae breaks. Mast gttata's I title-ta? ea nights skip meals at Itetae te get mete steep the __tee tired theta GEL sits as it ttapeeataa eat the at a Jatte eetiette theta is a gated. gaesa'ttatitja that attatas ate the Eat it t?tet?t?t tithe?" ate at stat.? . . . ?eat; eat-"see: Lt east atas ?3 a: t-?aaea tta?a USC ?13?b~ s-?th?tta as at at . law-hr fant- t?a eaasa eat; a GTMO SJA 34 . ?t Etaii. {Wit iaitaiia Eta-cit i?witf-tjt atatati t?tat tita aat?piaa aitaa? titat attai?tia ata aai'aa tiara Camp 1 iaatait ME: Mail anti? 1. a: had aatt?a and attarati it ta tiia Evita} Eli}? t-aapaialati ta tha minit-fiat. aba at atitaiaa aiia?a"? Eta attatita aat aa?j; a it?? aa that tita af ahaia. tiia aaraiaa ia. ti a traah. taiag attata ta tha hiaak an tiia aatt. aagy' at} ia tita tiaait. Pia a. aatta attaa" aat ait tiia gaatiia aat tiaat?a ta? at ta hit: at. tiara Etta-ii at tit-a taiata attaitai?a ia Biaak}. Sa- aa titia aurplaa ia avaiiabla. aamatiataa t' . atataii tiiat ?Elia . LI- 3.4.1.3 i aaritiad that tha faar aqaairaa drawn ia Black b)(2)ia a: map at Tait .i?i ahattaiad tatiiaa. Tilt: ajapiated haada gaaida. ?taak a sat at (U) Findiags af Fact: Quality af Ga an} Oversight an Alpha Black 1. if} 35:111. Kiia'ilaitaa af ?i?i??u?ig?h?gg?if?m.. it 73.0% {bazi --..II it. Ora:- Aipha Black guard stated. that ha fait tha Aipiia Btaak guard did an inadequate jab t?t?t?t?tii?t?it?tg tita- an the: night at" 9310 June 2306. 3. 636%} MASNipjig?Vm atatad ?i Faal that tha gaatda and Iayaalf an Alpha intact: ata an inadaqaata jab aianitariag tha that night ta raaka star: that thatI ware taiiawiag the ralaa aa ta ahaw kiad alibiiZ while aiaapiag. tiara} this with an black. We and {it} tha aviary day. an it gata aid. and baring. i taiah i ta'aaiti itatra manta and aattid ita'aa aamathiaa ta aatra that i tiaift titan-a iftha {iiad (at at}; hat i faal tat titait? daatita.?1? Far ia tiaiata i diti - ttiia a at tita .ttitaita use ft?13aatba?tt i-vaFHC} 'ra?i'a ail-u h" -.-I I'm-aau. a Li GTMO SJA 35 y- a. ?at: Etta-ha Eta-tat: gaata atataa .?EDhtt Biatta attata taat-?a atat aza'y taata. 5 La, ?m ta t'tta attaattatt mat-Etta? tt taak tha Lipita Black: guards; aa iaag ta ftad tha with that t? thawing ?it ta at? pat?attaat atti-ataa that tt" tt hatt- baatt iataak an. alpha Elia-at: that aiaht? that it ia ttatj: that tt aat hat-ta ttatit that atatatagt and: that atata i. nil-"J ll 1. . h. will; Tn. .51 iguana}: tailgtti bait: KW. 91mm 31805 1 "Hm. tam-.1} aib'JtZ'} 5. 't't j: 131' t?r?d {ha mun: {115m hata'a apart, 6+ Alpha Biaak t'acaia'ed that: 9 Jam: 2906 calla [hfb?z? at. 2004 and 1335} and replica via at 211]]? and 2358.-1 fittig? Emilia-t1 333.5; at?: Lat} ta} GTMO SJA 36 A 15. Alpha Bl?tk guards Stated that 111:3; d0 11m knaw win} made the {:Iill?iti? far their black at 281'? and 2350 011 3mm 2006. 15- MAE Elm fated ?he: {lid m: mam: the. {rand-tum headmunt] entry and (11:21 mt kiln-w who did.? MINE aim Suited that ?anytim- L311 111% bincic I'Il'in can mm: rande beanie: Hunt Eiitriu?sf?? - .-. 9 33? . Evi?hn Stigma? Thai: ?1 153g in Hf]? ui aha: SOC mnde h??d than night.? ?'31 Haad Emmi 2} {if} Tifii?fi 4: my? ?air f} :3 JEEP: . iiph?. Email; Emir}; .E 1355;} L2: 23:: . a? Haimiuuzim. E??a?g ?63} Haa?muni Raga-{all-It hi" If} If?? 3L 1'1: Ea": . H. - . :l?'ii?jL' hi LI Hf:- Egh?? fh?i?g Flag-$232: Asia", PM .e Ha *4 i; Egan GTMO SJA 37 {We mg ere in en eeiniereiee? en ?e J'nne freer ere-re nee}: er Eenerea {the} he are net ee val-h"- re eerre er'e'. ere nee krre er diet? in ree enere rewirrenerreef: ?Mi? - eere ee nee en e-Eiee}; er neere; ?ne eenee nee free; ereend. 23E heere e?er eteeping re MAC e; 19. I Mr?? eeie. ?ii ne en reelien re ,n I I.- ee wee ?ee freer re Eerieeereel er ree ?ner enn . a ne rnerered. 1' en Keene stated the ?he ere net make the entry end den-e remere her enyene deing inn heedee net? end tent nee ene end erderee heed eennrn we; reer fer ?e?ee ene iheii eerr'ernred er the beginning ef . . -. e- the ehll-L 21, MASH 'm stated ?The e+?eleek teen} die! the heed nee we were by eieneiie in eetl e1: the beginning; ef the shift; bee-enee I wee rhe ene the? its. end the ether ene en en 1 wee n1 ihe end the ECG fete i rien?r e: re re tie it end rheje did the eenn??ms Cenrp 1 guard feree pereenner een?iering fer rendenl neerleernn ei nighr during rirner Eigete et "3208 end iignre reerereei er 23. {Zine Arnie: Bieefe. genre etetee {her rendem eerie. eennt reereree ir'nrnei?eie efdetninee in eeii. 24, meted the? when ?the Tandem heed ere. dene rightfi} Hew free eerfernl heed the inre rhe eeil end eisee?y ee per ?fee, ereik te erle eerie. tern end ee {he ether eerie Ei?i?- e?ee.? 115. ?i?inee geer?e ernteei ree. rendern heed 'e'ee fer geerde: ner GTMO SJA 38 .- - anutaaw a madam ataattj ta ta: aa attack aa Elata ,1 atat . tatAZtin3}i1 atatati area-{ta ta tha a-iffaat that 1% ?aadatataad thia r1 it? Mai} ??watatad that watt: ataaiatattatiaat fat blaat: aad it wank} have tha at aad aat ?Ea-t: tatatt?a a B?aak {E-aatz? aha ta ta {bltZ} .e b' . .. 231 tai??gn? aapaadad tn the attaattaa, "Watt: yaa awata at .aat attaitratiaa tha- via ?ghting af at ay ata tag that ?Eta ?aw?atataa aati aft-f? 't whaa wa a at htiaa afim?I-Z} and may watt: ?aw-Ettaa iata tha EEME Ejf?t?m aainz} at a Visual atghting a?sz} was ?at by an}: guards in {faatp Datta dtattng ainZ} Eta-a b'adttatt as. 'a-?ata taint it Ell-wax i tat aatataiatztatiaa t-"w ahatat :41} aa "am anuthZ} E- Wh?a ail tha Eighta wart: at; Alpha Black guards walked the can tiar at their man pace. 3. MAE Elam}: atatad that until lights. ant ?than: waa aa aat titaa aa ta haw tang ta Walk a tiat?H t{bj{2} Carat} ?aita at Eta}; fat wata ahaata-?ati at ??ag?a intama?a. attain-?Ema tat? Ft Pat ?5?1 {3 ataataat {'E'aEt ?ag} use atata ataat .15 at; ate-ha; . . . . . tat-t tt ta; I I GTMO SJA 39 9. [hiring the: were r?qllir?d by to ?ight 23.. a {b azimuit 31* the: E, r} 5% Emma??t azaf i?h? Egg; 3i}: that: u. rl Ti {32; p?4 Elia SEE i?g Entry i3 mnaimmi with Si)? {Emma-Eta; :3 3. Eu ?iphii mm: id??li?i?d as riak? in this: Pi?m?? L??der Ein? Sm?gmnt ?f th? Guard fungi. G11 5:1" H3119 U35 r??pu?d?d H3 1333 LiliE-Sii?? ?i-I?w l?ng it take ?53: 11131;: ti iightg 213-. ?nimws: ?Dagmnding 11ml; man}; ht Kiri. Rulasa far ?uard Eighth: 3 9f ??tain?es at Ni E. reapoucied It: the queati?m ?Were mu aware ?f guards rant vim??; mummng the h?adcmunt via [33(2) by Stating mm ?"1113 {in-(imming and fou??img Headwuma w; Wh?? we xri?uailj: E?ndu?i?d a (HQ) and may WERE writ?m Ema th? 3}?Si?ii?i :13 {hr-C?nai?g an? hm a $311211 ?ghting wait"; HUI by" any guard? 1:1 {lamp during 2:1 - -. r54 Rau??m i?mat?d H??d?mmt, H, if. 3L5: - :3 1 r-wr- '1 H: Lug; if?! use {ism} My 1:5: hi}; Hairy; 5m i i? i? 59:. 5E GTMO SJA 4O .. us?c". ass I a -1 I- 'IiaiLQijiEr; ssa?iaa isiaaiz. sas as; aa iaiasaiai {ail waiis. 'iias afia's hail-Is ass ?53 ass; Mai} iasaii dasiaa arias as: tiaa iiar, ha ?aid aat saisa af at? ia aaiis as as ass. isa isaaw a tharaagii ha samaasisasaii spaaifias abaaf M. is: gas; m- again. USE. ii, Eff-?s 3 ?5 Ham . M33 ELISE statari that whiia sha was waiisiag tiar watah fraia as :i3iiE iaakaii ia that aaiis as waikaci is}: i Star: as; [11a ia?; aid; sis-Emma ??aia hi9} aariaa bask aa iha sight sisia ?am mm) {Essa if am: bum (if this is: ans and wara as: aha aas-asaa with a shaai.? MAB {bii3ii1 farthai' staasd ?i iaakaii in aali and saw wiaati balias-?aci ta ha him siaani'ii?ria irati andai? a Masai-cat.? had sisa iias wataii aad {a ahaai: aaiis 3? HI his as. (W) {Fligisiatad that walkaa shift an the: tiar batwa-aa aithai' as i raaiijs ran'iamhas wi?ah.? [it was i: as ii'li?ih?i' Sia?i?d tiiai ?ii samaasbar ?that ih? datainaa in rail ass ha. aibiizi i??hi?g 1a asara as: Has ta taa sails is appaarad as I walkaci by {has ha was ia his i saw sasaa aasias a has aat saa his haaii iha a'iaw was biaakad, {bHZi i dan?i kaaw far saris if an}: af that ihsaa wara aiissa whaa I was waikiag that ?at at this baa-sass: if dida?iinZ} hat tiraa.? 9. in a sapasata stats-maria MAI said that ?Guards had ta saa {mm daring thair Islands, but sama wauid [pasi?iiaa] mm a way that it was very dif?at?t ta taii and this issua was bsaaght ta 1hr: af Has ahaia af aanam and. Wa w'asa said ?at ta waka it maid be as harassniaai. This Piss and SOGs said. this was taming fraai aha appas chain was waiisiag Ha: aas Iaain: asas Ii'as Haas shift G033 043i GET-133 :13: 3:1 :1 1 aasa as a fit} was 1 siataezi that sasa i u: d- I 1 ?IL-ll- r. iaraiara {if-RE 515.1,: a 21's ix'iI-a? Baa} "i ssaa ass} gas ai'iai Elia Ii. man?g 1217iisia isi it:- is; a} ELIE-fihwf i aisai-a-si sail a; s' a as ?s a ifs-i; a .ai GTMO SJA 41 a .i i -i i a, .{bii3}21. . ii. is ?ii Eissiisi?i s?ii sissn I Inf-1 is ss "is? iimii: i?i?i??ii 1' iisii fissii E?i?i its 'ssiisii is: is? 2%?31?3 i2: sums :isiisii i rsiiss?s? is?isii '3 i3} is sis-s sissin my iisiissis tins i i'iass?t sis Ei?im?ii sis ssiisii "s i ti'ssis issih is ssiis {isms sass sis and is swiisi?i - is: shifts,? 13. ji sis isms Hi?hm??ii sisisii sis- {Hiif i4. (WEI) siss??blif?lg?l that siisrsij; hi: switsiisi} ti . with MAE ?gs: ssiird this Ssi?gssi?ii si'tiis Gusts! is isik is him s?ss 80 sirisis. my shit. I is MAE and switshsii with him sin that shift in: fi?fi?i is has sisrisd his turn {in Liss' several midnighL} I stasisd st ssilisd amiss ass sf?is ties. My practiss is is gs (is-ssh ass sids tiles. 1?1ka 11 this iris: iisi iiks is: sis back and fin-sh i?hs tisr. i s1. ssii 2 is: had a shsiit miss his its:de Eigii?y as his 'Jssii iisis and asked him is tsizs his sn smilsi his bass, 'Hs sass-piisr i sis-s sE ssii Ei? hs was ijifii?ig as his i sitsysii 1.11st E: ii'stii i ii's sure: is: was missing? ?'33 - . . {bum ME: .i i Gu??isig gum: 35? Hi I. Psi 8039mm} 2. Per SUP F1 (his Aipiis Bliss}; gust-5i sistsd the night sf isms, did .il?f slissk sli ssiis during his $283?$236 sis ihs sis-r5 it?s-sis ssiis iis iisi si1ssk~- .i?sii siisi ?i?whsid suisisls. is . is . sistis-d tiisi dis-mg i113 iiss swish, *i hi i {i is?, (is: sighs hairs-ii sii?is 13?? ii'it.? iisi; giisi? sissi sisis sis-r ii?i?ii sis: si?isisiss? in. ssiisii i sizes-s i ssisi sisisii?iss's {b11121 533?s? 13;- Li?i? :3 rhn? .. iisii i st, Isis. i is. sis?ssi . . . . {b}{3}11 ?3 sis} USC is ?1 isf?a F-n- .- .- 5 i i: ?Fifi Ti via GTMO SJA 42 1: PIT-etc *r I '3 - 1 ir ett the ?eet, ettgetetet?: te er tt ee tee, thie te ?tee t?tte tying; it. ttet te b) the ee?tt tt? tat etteette teet?et Kb)(2) heat te 43-1 1- . I - - the eiettitet en the ?eet titty eff? the eette I wet; i te'eiit the eleeit estte .t tittitt't teett it?t eett time them.? 35? Tit-bet} ?tit?thtt Eg?? ?tt?tt?tt thet ?ne-th {ht-351;? tie-1' m2} e. {136%} MAE WW I 3?33!) were tree eete te etetittg ?Net I eemtet 351}? I eete te see H55 {but {fatter ?1 den?: fer eere it" e11}? ef the three te the qtteettett greet E?tt?eu- ee eEt detainee-e?? be e11 311 were alive when .1 wee walking the tier at this time [emu?"Meet, dttle?t ?30(2) mitt, .fethettet'te ?ee. et time. 1-. i313 i. The (blitz) 2t 1. directi?t? 3. twee? guards weuIL'l eheek fetinE} ee were sleeping, the the JDG Deputy eteted that ?If the enter fee a eetne during the time deteiee (W2) ?1 I?l 4: USC tree 3} 'testete t'tett tet . .H- He-u- -r x_ it ri? Etna: a? tee t3 33:3. GTMO SJA 43 .1.- .qh-I _Jw} HIE II. .u AI. r. "rue aerue Carae auar-u uraru aarrereraera arui uuarde berieaed rue: rue aer riu?eereri rinZ} guarua erruirii ue'r aeemHZ} 6. The Ceuaureuder Jeiet Be'teuriuu Greup er the urea ef ?re U59 ataied rhar er" rhe Red Creaa} hea- juar? rhe ef the eerarueea a rare the eight whee the arauuaru 1' rue: Eu u?rjr with ureru ier?fr ?re rere aayrua *ereu?e rrui abuz} errierra? by higher e?ieraiaf?SE I :1 Plateeu Leader iu Carup atared ?that when he . .1 . Ier~ reuree! Lamp 1 eeil bleeka er urgl'ur ire eluraya waited 'l'e If he euuldu? aef he uruuid quee'uua the guard(W83 I}qu atated te rue that uraer yea needed re make tire 3mg {51? Ma: alae altered that ?rfyeu Limit 5m? fb'HZ} wake up the a, era @911? aiaterueu'i. rue by a repurr that he rue arurd a1?: a Camp 1 ruequ uu'r re wake eerairreea; MAB atateraear heluer fer the full repert. mp 10. Mr?ibli?? arater} that en the eight u'f Qr?l Euue, ?i arupped ar ee'il he had a sheet ever hie head. i tapped Eigh?y en hie beau heie and aakee?. him Te Take deu?u hie aheel ae i eeuid. hie head. He eea1eliee with my request.? I I ME 11 :1 St?t?d ?3 ?i'rl 12. Either Camp peraerurel meager that they 1e-"ere prehibiteri freer waking a detainee at uigiur 13. A fer-ruler Prareeu Leuder i1 Cerup 3 reapeuded te- ?Did guards: have re eight wire the araterueui: ?Ne. Hue?? I use Hat55.13 feegwf?ge 1? :r if 3" he in? kg? $7511 in? EE GTMO SJA 44 a an bean stated a a an ea. ann- a1 ?ee-nee Fianna. arena {he net "alanine detaineea were awake in Ea {Tana}? anaeein - .5 i - annahand eeneeaged U31 ?ea Sanaeanenilaa I?ei?i {mm?atate? ?alien 15+ earn 1a. enn'anand .l he i?La and 50133 and ?ne was. earning Hem the upper chain ea? *a beiief?aai? the required 13. In a annaeqnent aiatetnenn ?The wee}: week belnre ihe aaienieag MR2. "d that rile?LE lrhwa'm H: enunaeiing saints; ?'ena Chief . it ee-nira?nand eat ei the: banana [Sara-eagle nf the Guard] She eentiaeed a; {in an and USC far takiW?mJr bean heiea elf eelia while the detainees: were aieeninge ween train at the neat guard meant he ?ll?tr? "'Dn nee he bothering the detaineea, den": give them a tn riet? {innit pane at them with atie-ka in the. an indie efthe night: annually meaning uni tn e:an 19. Hanna} MAE (b.1123? atated {ban ?31(2) in manna use: {a are a 3 GTMO SJA 45 i??ine?nein n? Feet E?eeninee Pregneeniiene fee ?nie?e?e Yen? ennege en nee nine: in inn-*eetignte eeneenee ie-iinee e32 it?ne gene Sf}? eenn?eineei in fee nitr?-Eejg ef ?ne :ie'i'nineen en eernenie enieine en nae night ef ?s?ii} I b' 2' emf E, Mn}- nineen tent ?We gnnede heree in enr ennin ef enn?an'innd thee Ehe neinineen ehenid ne'i be niinnren tn been henfning in their eeile but we were eel}? e?iewen te inetnlet then?: In itenln free}; n1" deer. in Mereh 2006, ENS {b}{3}31 Cninp 1 AGICF teld en in evening Genre Menn {net ?The SGF in ent}: guideline end in nee eenee end tn net nil-{e Hen] the the: ween: iike enn'n eheetee inner: nee? feed nnei in net - -- i nee-en them new ne net disturb ?le CELEB 1 leg entriee lenient nun-me: ebent giving eneele in ne-tnineen, even in eeEf-hnem eneen 3. tied nee-en en?: nf hie- eheet, threnienen in hnneeiL ?neetn Inken nanny.? l. 4.. H.an eheet 'n?itn intent tn "nee. if in knee nn?neeiil Talked hen nut ef it. Teek e-heeL {?iieen beet: en pee 5, in hn'neeif by EEUG if net ?ny lnenien?. "Feel: Ejetninee ete?ed tine: he nnig: rnnde ?'n'ent ?Ee n: by . . . zen medienl. Sheet green bnek en per ENS. 11 Peri-semen} we e. neewn {hen ?13nbim inn}; gene 3'71"} in: En; {?11-?13 en GTMO SJA 46 a. preparer} their apparatua fer auretae irt a aarrteat ai.? EDIE tateratraa t?ar detaraee a. the eraetree at taieratraa; tire attarattaa at e?etrrea tar aetar?rreaa pr?eriatett the at tile 31in a area trtaee afar: an? 1" ?a brief" tautu?e aa Laura Plateau Leader (air; tl~heur tataa an W. 13., 21, 17:2. and 24 aprii a. arm at?? atated that ?When 1 a eaarplete tiraraugtr eeit aearrttea a Eat at eeu?aeated. Guards: wauta erra?aeate aItereti eieth'rag arrel ether rte-rue that raereu'tthZ} [taut the} arr-re ta'auid tell the treat shift te give them Isaak. Erraatptea: tiara guarda fatter} with faurteea water eeuld he arr marry. eapeetatiy ifthe rule a'aa aue-iar?aue tra'a?rtartarr?i? 77* 't 'raa ea guaraa arerea?t attea-?ea ta take the aarraertt eff that detaia e; the}? were ?eld it weuia tea trauiale. Detarueea trauattrreti ta Camp 1 freru Caruprraught with them large prayer raga. but eel}: aural? raga were authariaed at {laurel i. i there rut autheriaatiurt far the-m ta hare Earge raga. {Bu the treat ahift, the 01C. er ADIC tuattrd hat-re the rage returned. Detainees; are authariaed prayer eap. rt detainee had a one made treat a trauaer leg. aaid ?Whieh Lie yea want? Detainee indicted be 111. guard teak the rare eff detainee?a head, ereatir; arr an the guard and arr uprear arr. the tier.? Tn bazi I'lliI'I I 7. Detainees trueaar?ea preaaure ea 1 guards: ta retaa ruiea abeut rue dr?ed e-ietitrua in late 3. {Tartar attire Cararri tratet?} rulea aha-at ruear?ett truer F3. 9'1 r?af?t April ".3686. The aratatatrarr irraraatea repeat tier .- Nil ?7 31 . It? I tatrr?t'ataitt'tr??i': eater: a r. t-t?Eula: .d 1- 1D attire-urea; treat 1 3 .E 1.--. a, .h 5a.. Er 5 3 :5 $53. as: {3 5- 513.:- 5H in. ch f5. 2 I Ilze E.- - GTMO SJA 47 .. .I . I 1' v.1- 3 {igtgig??i'j timii'ittii it?tiim git ii i H. 1 I. e' mam}: mit?ti't?fi itit?-i-i timtu?it 'li .w 1: w_ (W2) mesa-st itiit tutti .. I - 1 Etimm 3 tab: piimii ?i339 imt mitt: itimmci hittidm W2) lu- mitt-mil ptt?l?" ii Aimmd pants? i6, ?film-mt} pants.? ?m [Nu m: mini:th 17. in E?fiy May abmtt it tit-mith heftim tim atticidtm, a 1mm ptilittfj: {1me i Lit-radar MC bii3i31 Sit??d wards tti tim that ?inZi which, trimmed' 3GB ii'itmlijt?i dmpim gim?i aptmtiititit-titg minim-3i mitt. thangmi ti: it gaming, imii mm Ecstatiimhmig itt which t?lmainem were with mm pair {if t0 ham. {rim timti hittide timm ibiizi with mm langth m? titmtidt watchmi them Wiliit: they tit-3i] ?awed, mauvmmt mt: tie tilt: btiftim letting umt it}. The first Guard 'Mtiimt Message iimntimtitig S??ai'i?i?g is dittmi 3 Mint it in full that ?All Damimm platmti in it SE??l?g cell Will have :1 maximum time: limit Dfibnzi .ti SUW rimming. ?11m: the timt: limit ?finZ} Dmmime ht: returned It) 1113 t-mi." .. II. .. rtiti mg Night. ii?} tititfi is: mam-ii Wait 5 1 it Lit): i?tt-mititt gm. {TH-tit .0 ti mi; Night. til-tit i i It" Emit ;,iig i?m tfi'ititt ii i mi: mitt-ii i 1 3: 3.3453; it" ?t tilii'i itii?iifii?i?ri Whig-HE? ?Eli-E? i i a a .I-- r- -: 4 ii tit-tam- rm tit 5? 5 ?i-Ci' ifGTMO SJA 48 -n . 3' i Leif}? ?33111? i dig}? $333195: vii}. {an a, i ?aw: mi" .Ei'??ahfzwi?gg aaii?. war: ?aauma . w; Eg- {fEIn?nr Jig?Jill Lil'- -- a: I -: It; '31; 43,3 E311Guard "?aunt Ma?a-133a Si}? d??m?iun i?d?hg and. c-E?zhingg, pra?iaa {12f a?awi?g ?g-aa??em if: and That. 3f m?dimg am? by ta} mm: this a? $11 mm; ma?a wag. a 0f WEB 4. MAE d??i?-l?ib?fd his ma?a; in an ambu?ancq: with. EN {193, en route: to {in antaumu Ba}? Naval Haipimi MAE Stated that ?i that, tha mate-rial {mad Etazaa? that 33w 1:2 .13 - A Mum-rm Emmi Thai KEN 3% himg by rr' . - n?uhuWWuwvia; ,2 ?ue-4:125: i322. ma?a- data?? ire: ?ns: i {-5133 3:rs!? .9454: has; a; ru {1:3 I - I..E I: -.-..-I.. .- -- .-. -. if {531.3 55.5; a" '3 a 3? in?: I I I 2 I: nil} -. f; GTMO SJA 49 I -1 ru- '1 1. 1: ?lmed?a??mg ha: aim} mm Mm} twang-:33 #415: Email the waig by ?1551} A3 aim}. um} Kb) I {'33 3. {_th That cm? wag mapped aw}; amu?d: uracil; in. m" {bur 2111111451 mamas; . I: i_ G. I ELL MWE 22%, 2m, 35:13:: :11 ?at: _v H- 1? 2.7 . "1?11: nmdica?i examiner Hammad about 135% f. H. 1* U993 Kiwi__Twmm?E W, WW - a 1'2. W9) Ralevant in ?uii #13 by m1 Jam: 2306 are i?ciuded in this rupcrn as Exhibits DES and D32 in TAB K5. 13" W) {311 9 Ji?i? 533 hung himsalf in call 2 with a cart} name: 14. NCIS Elfi?l? mane indicah: ihe: curd mf ISM 538?3 Hgatumib?} 25 .15. "35.51? a. ELIE W151 ain't mrlI: E-t?i? 9. 1? t: Harm-?; w, . a. I. If". --.- ?in-L . - I I .1. FI?i?x 31. ll. f?HH-f?i?g 9133413."? Ei?hisii?-? UP, .5: ?LE?a?h?w .1 if} {is In I'd-f" - I-: I: Ill. In F- .1- I 1 l-l: II I . I rule - .I't I Emmi-EL 5125:513511 in is - 1?9} .. "i HLEH as.an rm 3 =1 GTMO SJA 5O .M iriririrri ri'irii inri ri?ir: i. r. W339i M?h? Similar} rii?rwri il?ir?: i9. MASH a! {war min. Erik; ii?? rrigrrirrari ribm'ii ISN 533 that ii drird abrasirin the. EEC-1L The; is regular with the width varying frijrri ii?: Vi il?ii?iifi. iilr: imprinted with 3.- iype 23. {311 9 June ISM ?1193 hung hiriircil'irr cell 3?15 with 3 nmrr. the 0f EN 693% Ef?gy up ifiri 69333 bird}: whiir anir?iirr guard 1hr. apparatiiri ii?idi'iig riir: handy iipi I heiprd ri'ii: guard Er: ?nd the righi place rim rr-ers?jr iri gi'?ii?ii .i {him .ti-L -. - {bii3i-1? irri'iri {,?Zirfi USC ii rjir a} it-? n. ii. ?5 Lila-r EEK E321 rzjri ifi inihi ?he 5'5 Fi? Cir; Fifi-ii i" Maili- i- iiri' ?i?iiriri "i Hi? gig-i i irii Eiiriariira {Iii}, 'i .. {Iii}. GTMO SJA 51 1W meeimm If? stated that ehe E?remevem} the eieth . 1: use ?13ebimneymnmejr E?g?g: ef eel? ?12 eiepieiing the U55 ?13?bin5L?bH??CIt ?etei?ee Prepgyeiie1_j_.e fer?uieide; ef the ?gg?ej E. W) {he three hung themselves full}? their eieeke. 3* {Wm Fee}: ef the Mae era the 'Ehet ESN wee Elli}? the deeie ef eeil A3. ?mem_l_p?hm 2312 N535 {fee-he e1: 3' NEE-ES use a: ?1 35ml ef?i?i.1. ?week-33% eke; GTMO SJA 52 Three, ii'fihi: Eli] mini: 3 {min i MM i 555i?i?fii .- - Ii619179;; icii-i i Mn The. {immiqu was; 511,33 --rimii-i:i nit-i 4.: . . i muse {hi?fg M53381 i: i r! aging bx "aha went: painting dawn ihi': dacig?z? {b}{3}21 ii. WMAE - . i ihmugii {hi} Liff thii H24: {111. fuiiy Fib?i?? {hi3 d??k Hf ELIE.ru? ., 1H. twig} -- fab?: If i zigijii ii4.5} I liltr". 3. (W i? MAI i333 383 further i'i?ti??gif?lii?id? Ei?ti USC . WEE: "?11 i sir-ii i. SEW ii??i?ii i Willi ?le-Eff: the Winn the ceii and back ihe Sii?t?i I came} am; that hi5 ijiidy was. Eu?pcn?td and I ii? that Wh?? he i??kud 251$ Sim iha: ?aming: hanging by his Heck." imher St?t?d that ?1 saw the: feet: and ii haif il'l?iltl?? wiih Hf} ?the f??i 10. W) in the Jibii3ii1? ?11510 aimed that grabbed the detainee ?i??il?d i116 35 hit; wni 31: wag ab?ut iil?- in]: cheat; and him Lip. Snmeb?dy have Eu! hirii dawn :31? the cimh 3.3 1 him up ihiir Lir??p?d in}: i i. ii 51.5 53-3} if?? ifii?: ii- El?- at 'E'Ilug: E: ihii Eili?ili?: his 63 GTMO SJA 53 3} far S?i?id?iwfbmm? 311mm}! _r_l 1! I If. - 51:33:: am 332 gimgni. ma?a I 7?7. ,5 'Eii?mr wa? ii. ..- $2113ij anci I rumii {hm Em was aib?uf 33m: $1 with ma Wh?? ?i waik?d i?i? [Eh-v.23} Casi}. EH "#35 ?at arid 21111 rhai hangi?g aa-Pith his: fame: ?ight}? {ha ??miw'4' . - I Ms??'w USC Ei?t?? 3:51:11, @1325 might E3. 14$: 153. ii?al 3.11m ray rupm?t HHS EN 5383:; . . . heaght 2:3 @532: mam-5; iaiif?i Um: gf th? initial Ems arm Th? stated {hail ISN 6-5-93 waa fuii}; S'L'i?p??d?d 3mm: that deals: A5. 17h MAI stated that appmachmi tht?: End? and Eifted it ta the Temim} am the ESN ?393?? wai?? wag Egg?2mm In}: .693 war; appmximat?y 31113;; i??h?s 33:1 {if hi3 h?dj? i? wi?fh mt: dear: b? ES. in 1h: same statement, mm. ?mm: i133 h?igl?. an; '32 ?rming: gave might as {113 i??hlj? 1. (F953) The: ?ame when mirlmitt?d Elli?id? 2411 had Eig?i?uaut 331 3 $93! Lilia ?and l. tug-5. i'gl 5- v?w. .- - .- - fair Kim ?an-ram. 5:3. mummy ma?a: salutag-m sj?m- 532:} diam-? .s?ajEw r: guars??: and {may anardicai ?erg??jzuh :?Emri??gg Lus- eight had '9 i Tut": a? EUSC 5. FL iE?ii I: Eig9-111! I: If: I I.- urn.1102?- - a Il-m'-I-. . i wry; it}? in ?gs?uiam gamma =2 1- g? :33GTMO SJA 54 $31.51 r3: r?ag?fmgra mhga?red ha? :55. {Iii-t3 i?i??w?i?um??fa? ??i?iihit 5-33. PM. a1: aa?ii'iy {by 2} El; 1" Mia :in31? .m Ei?te? {hat whii? KEN 0?93 was hanging: SEW hmka? iik? s: f??i'mp Hi} 5. ESN 993:5: h?ii?in?- Mm ?air: its: halyard ?3111?. dawn . ?Lh?umwmwed 3111:"; Thai f1 {may MM hi5: da?c?b?d 110% (fr-hacrwd USC {Mm-19 U59 [1?32" puli a hut they I?i?t able 3} 1.1 . I -.. m: MAE ELL aim Emmi that jam; at the EFi?i??-f? Ehl??a mid. $11-31} [Lain mar iu-a? Staff} ?my fiat:- 3.531% me:- had ?ii'??dg My?: 3?1 iwlkcath in?icaxa . ?Thar: wag inn - gin-h 15! 3. {129%} Mr?gb?fgy that when ha: winked A8 ihr . mm CL mug .113 mumde mnd?m! Isaw this. de?ant?: hanging by his neck. Hi5; {lice wag raw-3mg me wiih his head munching dawn I ?9111?551 mm mm whim abatry?? ESE bang?: Emma} a ram-airira mun $3 SC h?13?mbn6 15.: mE?-?in r! 5:515 1:151; ?gs-1.ait? ?n 2.31% ag?r??Erie? E- 'E'u 3* {Ir- Ir' w. - .- II: fig-'din-is I ?an-1f i 32: a: ..J GTMO SJA 55 mew ehee whee he walnerei 1: !hf't? 1 HA .t e. ghe?i?? lee: an fee ti?e?epere ee- tee mediee? ?.533 had eereethiee iinZ'} MASN ee? eemeihieg white er . ?iether Stated that l?wl'a' 1:5. MASH. ?n :thq Elgekr Her? meme use 13? nee ef the Wee; [Ieie' We the 1.11 'e'ee ?(beer medieei whe were etteleptelg Ee ESN {393 etteaepted but he eei.? . e5 he eerieeri MASH remeeing eek HELEN ?er?zher thee the eel-?e {hing he ?y a, Fiee medieel in the Camp Delie my:er KEN Gee eftheei wee a A eie?i?h eerpeme: ere-he eeneed Letee eewz} 14. HN ?11*?me that ?The detainee 093? Limelight weef?'] Li (W) elated that he a . - a, 37*? - . Jig; freel (hamlet; e1 ?ee when. 13%: 093 13': ?ne enei Lhet he ?eetieed glee? the deieinme her? a IRC 'i?eei e: e} EEUSC {Tie {ghee are} e} ee {er-H3: Eli-Li. ee 1 ?e ee GTMO SJA 56 2U. {hm ISN 533 rb?} Him-ii. stated that ?The d?tain?c Hamid that ?man: wag HHE in the tr?afm?? mum "With {.193 El?n-3r {b}{3}11 had cardia- and she Hated that did um absewa?: anything in Tim detaine?a 1mm} {116%} .111 the cell ?f?Eh? suicide? A12. {bur ?fihe ?r a 113nm}? fnurm ini?al aim saw 3mm: Ulh?l? L-SN 533?s 2i. MA3 Hin'Hd {Em rcmemher $33 ikhiwhrz??ai?? ?gr; 3mm}; :21 imm?ed $33 15:11:? {high aitih? E?i?ih ?his. 3 ?m3? 'i?ifii'??l??a'fi? th? FEE-GEE -l - -. .E {3 USC 23': :i {Fi? 313M . "inn" in?: Ma. ..I 1: 92:. j. IE. a. 3-1: if?! - JI- GTMO SJA 57 eteete, tinEJ tinZ} 1 - - i trethe -. r- e3; {we eeter eehhe he the eert ?he eetee eert et? [fl-aria?? 1:213? E4. Merit 1? b? $11.1 ht ISM 693 te the (Tenth {kite eterlieei etieter Jeet e?er hrtegieg 693%; heele- eterth the eheie e. heerd eett fer hele ie ee. eat-jeteiee She eteted thet there ehe erttiMAlmH3}31? ?helped whe wee perferzetieg CPR err e?tetietr JEN 3335* She further eteted that she in CPR ee ISM 533 by" ?braiding ee eeygee eteefr itt ee'er the Whiie I weer heldieg the eejrgen re fete-tree the heed eel ef the we}; re 1 rte hehlteg the eejrgee eteeh ie Hr? hew ?There wee prehiere the weete eet ee errwed ieetreeteet te try eed pry the eteeth She [the eeideeti?ed eerpeetee} emleeled, eed ehe wee eele te retiree the lipe, but the teeth were ehet. et thie peiee when the lipe were err-erred? thet there were ?rm-HZ} 1 eeute eet tett ter etere whet were. i wee ertebte te teil they "were: fer "g It ether 25. (W) teedieel re the Ceetp Deite medieel eitnie whe were tr te 13H 538 tee} I i titer see-e .t we eerpeetee etetee thet the 3' eheervecl whet eppeereri re he JetterthZ} err-Lt eeree etetert thet there wee eert efthZ} {blizl?i tees are r3 third eteted thet. he eetrer eew the {mat ee. HEW-WM etetert thet he tried te eteer EN 58335; (bee a {meme Use {?libh?f GTMO SJA 58 ..: I. fizz: 1.3.33.1. 2 mi 12% II. . 521:?! it - . .. v1.1 . _Lrel.? . I 1.1 -H-ll. 5312T.- IF-- .. ..L - {Flu-Inlan.13.. .. .. an T. L..Im..l H. .II .I. I . ul.ln .rk ..IJL ..I.. II.rrILGTMO SJA 59 U50 4f}. 1?s JDG geese whe ehsersed 6933 shestiy e?'er his beefy sees est see! Laid en the desk efeell A5 describes? seeing 41, seeied their he went es Alpha Bieek. s'fter the ?rst deleinee was tseesperied eet e'Fshe sleek ass-:def?'?de . sese see; 69.} issue en the Lieek 1sside eeli further sis. ed eetieed. qmnz} 33% 41 A eseeri and three medieei peesexmei in the {Temp eiene whe were trying {e resuscitste 13353 6931 described lereig?. meterssi 1e 6933s memh. 43- (W) the}. he assisted {3 min ESN UFSC I .I . I seer?. ?1 USC 44. geese; r? '3 USC :??ise sees 13?; sis ?1 39M {11's as es Ff gems. ?33} i sf 5 $43453; inf-Wull. GTMO SJA 6O - .IF . . J51, . i ?a Ira?5 abuzz} a ?ta an; 1- 1M '95 Maia-42E that ?"Whaa 1' ta that {aft 3] i aa' :a ?a?iaj the: EEG Madiaai alumna IJ-lr"! than 'Egra'iaa' {a aat. ?Ha: 4g? . stale-d that a?aa? ha {aa? 69:31am tha Camp Dalia madiaal aliaia} madiaal drama? {:11 1 3313*. [jaaSHigigia .Maaka 1, (W In aha aail aftha tha" aha SN {3932 had ainZ'} 3 3-513; initial I'alaa?ad? his-11' atatad lhat ?Thara waa what Iaakad liiaamHZ} -1n atatad that ,?Em Mr??i .aatad tha? {b}{3}21 I f??rm-531E I ma aIaLad {hat iha ?fpiaa guard {aai'a aataraa 5318: ha- ataad aLaai-Lia aha a?a *Wiaia USC ?13?bib EWING :f Hli?a - I 11:. Elf-- E- 2:?faa '6 F5 5- GTMO SJA 61 irrraw; nix Lia: {Eli 7113i. iil? {iif'i?ifa?? EEK ?33 h?i?inZ} ?i?t?ij [33} 21. Em A aim?I ?Minn?HM} 4.1.. .. {bum ?i ii} immi?i ibiizi i Lilli - Vii-I- 1.11%: i .{bii?m? - . 3- MAW use I-r'tr" ?E?i??'mhrl ihi? Hana-:2. irim?i mmuved Ib?iin??f? MAE ablif?i ih? ciri'?i iiziimveu ??il mm: 11: in the ccili" ?gi .b3:1? iagf?b?i M33 I Hi Siai?d that upmi suturing gall arid ramming ii. g. ihii'? Saw the {i?i?i?i?tj 53$] i3}? hi3 Traci-ii. "Hit: WEE: pain had game {ma} 1% One rcspuudiir myriad in the EU nf? guicicia? Fifi, this: .iiati i ii:- initial MAEWHSM ?tai??th?i?E?EFHibiiZi iirhir?'i ErCRii?EiE-na Fibim In. ESN 993333 E. Emir initial ii?i'ii {i935 1' i?i?ipw?iid that in i'ih': ceii ihiigi thin ?1083*? i?iE i?i? i ii IKE - {bii3ii1 ?3 afizi} U55 ii i ii; ?13?blbii5i rif?-..- -.. -- EH 3-1 .- Illa-99" Hi i -- ?ick GTMO SJA 62 3. frete eel} :38! and I _Il: Iee?eEC} "urp' a 1- 'feethee etee'eei 53"? 5- 1 ?i ieeked deem end. eele' h[ at. ?efeiei 6% Mia ?eet e. em: ?1315 ?34113 hie eekleef? stated ?iei ferthei? eteie I: seated the? he ee'eiei 'ihe ?in; e. em}: Stated that I'll .-.- - -. . . a" i i?ei?i 11:33? 11151:"? Eh: gum} as ?Peter mmei we ew?b?fl? deem 13H 093, (FQEEB Twe JDG ebeereed ISN {393 ehe?iy e?ee hie remevei '{Reneeatetee that eh?e Le. we: pee]: ee guerd in MB) Bleek, he eheewee? ether guard ieree ?teenepertiee iieteinee 693} en a Three Fteiher eteted ihet?Regereii11g ESN 093, I eely Ciinie.? MASN Eh the eelly iewerd the 10. MM. ateted that Shem}: after he arrived 31': {Same Belle, metfieel elinie end 53W 13% 893 ebeeweei Cememee the {busy-1e {Ree USC me Hie} WINNIE 5-1" 4' H: 1 1 333.15 ?fr?i . If . a: sen-1*: .n '53 I Iu-r-?I-?l-r {Tee :eiee'iee ?ee ee?eed "he"Lt-3 we egm We e32? ewe. ewe-15.5? FL Eda: .- {VuJ-l- u. GTMO SJA 63 has-qau?? usua?y i?ik? M?f? 2 I. A I?ll1.5ng Elihu?? h: an; 1535.53} 111m {$115 We; 11:31: gm Eh? alt-:3 .51 L12 1 d?d magi-Hm; wag Emnz} mm mm high Eu??gij? 7h.- -. 1. - ..-, . - . 12* that i??m?di?f 41"; IEN {$93 WEE hrnii?'?? mm the. ?ii'iig 'vesith what I balk HI. 1?1- IHJH I i1r'Hr51' Ef?t?d thai that E3154 $93 Ed 31 niece: ui? 15. stain-3d that. did. 1.1m {1133mm his HEN Manda iinZ} bl?l; HM that ?1 diL?i nut see the detaincu?t: 093:3} 1* HM: ??ivacl ?11?th [raatment mam with 093 a?er {mm-?3 had. started cardin-puim?nary mauscimtimm and Shm?ted that ESN the det?mcu amend: 111 1:31] All Ely: Hf mmal 1'55 panda}; var}? ?hmm 111:: datain?? 131*? 5583 hadw Emu} myUSC :E?rzi?? i WEE- 9?3} WEE i?13?bi r? I I mam Fa} I-H Hag-E; :f I: a .. =35; ll J: GTMO SJA 64 344%} A3136 AIS-1 2.5. {we} Me?tet teetett he tee eteett etetee? mm?) ?5?3 ?13?b whieh tee Matte jittjt?m *3 Stated. the 57 3t?; :21. {119%} MAP: hende . 5 :11 Melt-SN A 53355;} I {it} tilt}? think. 23. teat {tie hates?? ?9 etetett thet stated th? Stated that ard whe- eijeet'ttet'l EN W'H'wn that he went te ?ttehe meet: after the ?rst deteittee wee teeneperted ef the Week and that after he was inettueted te $123,113 waking and Uht?t?ki?g the tent ?itting Alth Blue-k then tetlxteesed. ISM 5334 A1 E, itetrt?g been placed en the beekbeetd end be?tg T??dt?d ?E't??t?t?t?u?trt in the ?etni?ee F?Hwiw i trim-r?! hr?h'l'h xvi:- +l1n Amwlw-Hm -. :15. A JDIHG eememen whe sew ISN at the etinte stated that 533?s (blitz) Camp ESH 2t. HM IJ-lil'i that we: itSth 53315:] kaZ} end. his. eff. 28. (W3) 1: 59315 Ilf?r? {wane use gamete} I t-ftte Site} rt tj't tteet :?ttel tit ?it} met .J estt?tte gets; 1* r'r- I: fill-tie? .3 a. ten he arrived. Twat ether JTF medical in the wlte were etlempt?tg te reeuteitete 533 stated that [he time they ?ew hint i??td? the elinie. them: eteteet that {lid eet etteett'e hit: 533:3] ttgit?tt the time at at}; if; ?aha badeidetmu I - I. I EE 5? Pin-c {ft-HI. A I ?g GTMO SJA 65 hr r" I EN bli3li1?.. 9 He? ?ee: detainee- e3 eerie-re.- ee the. eE .. .- enmef die? the ?emi?ee?e the: he wee. ere @9533: when 53$ eerie-?ea? LA he the ee? Li? ihe three esf the iHi?i?ei the? 65*} Eiee?b?zl? . ewe-1e eh? iimee eiet'ee eiei'ee ?ie.I- 131% m3 {mum nee-eel reependee aimed the: he {ii net remember 125W eerie 31. MAiiblH?}: 6939:; bed}? wee eel {he netie-ed. ISN $9.13? ?10412) 1 -. ?Mai-k2 untied the frem hie 693] week.?j stated the: immea?etely after ehe wee. eut and {lit-H2} Feehiened added that {b}{3}21 Ilil?r" 32. h?i?SN Sew IBM 693 3 . Icr? eme en i 15: He: Stated that ?When I eerieed {e11 Alpha BieekL I int-1MP ear-II A i MA em?hmm-m 33, MAI that while he was in eeil Ex I 25, heard 1:me ?513.}.th 5f te alpha 5 [but] enethee greep had eireedy made entry l?t? the eeii, The detainee [15$ 693] wee in eele-tieeije the (Emilia:me as the. detainee. in alpha '12. ?ll'iere wee ereemd hie neele . 34. {my} m3 ?lmed that mama dew-11,, he Saw that bed}: 693E wee relatively {buzz} 35. (W wee pulled the same set up as A3 seated thee i2e. did net remember seeing 3e. {ii-46%} {Zine ie the Cemp ?eiste mediate}. whe Lees enemmtiee te 133% $93 eteied peeitieei}? r1131: 15?; 693?eib?2} Eh?' H?iy?d b?dgid?. Titian?5' {t?rmmen 15Fqu FHi??I?igf??l I 3? *3 ewe. . I - - 9 eeseUSC em; e; 1m?13?bibl eemee?kibl?? :eEGee gee we; e??e . .. ir?ii?e {3.515 ?le; eerie: 32.3? {5 an} if if. ee GTMO SJA 66 I 33. me weir-.. ea' Ii. eme?e i Lie: ?ee ?ee fie?~"Leer: me, eerie ei Ref; ee?ee? re the; 5mg}- Jr: r: thee tryieg {e beanie this; USN 391 ?'??iihri? um fr". ?anql-u. i1.? Huh?. ?1 KKVI- 1 - ?n?if?i? when. he netieed Eh {b}{3}21 eat eemethine wee wrung in eel} AH me ?2 wee teking his mm weiki?g the ?iphe Blue-k tier ghee-1 +1131: Le} rI when MA In the een'le e:Eeear-J:men:w ?M?q {b}{3}21 Mime-d The? Jul-?Ly 4. MERE el'eieri rhe?r ?If renewed like the detainee. 093} 3313 . . eerieib?m? a" - I ma?a: a: fee; 1 gm use emwm 5. In the eeme etetemeet} ?13: Enid. the? {buff} r-i-1 {357; "ii-5T?ak: ll: 1} ewe-e?. ?e e; 5; ,1 he; gene GTMO SJA 67 w?mu has wa??i?g that {mm ?339 {Eli 53:3? war; in hi9Ei?i?i??i??i him i Eii? 8. F6136) MAE {Maj ?aw} that aim was ?b?ewing A3 when I Inrt 95 1E1 ?lli- ?fth? .E?lzi?idsMASNIWGEM it?t?d that Win-in ht raache? r1911 ?1 MA SN Sta'Lcd that Wh?? ha lnmkad in call All 533 fi'ifjj 111$ ?ame StatemenL MASN fhm? 5v? jng?g {'E?ffa? {3.555333} USC AH Hi3} ?1 15?. 1 .E. 1-1-1 . .2 . . . Hua FEE: GTMO SJA 68 Ea ehe ef the ai .?eaei {may ?54. M?i FEE ataiea that ?When I arrived i" ee ii a. {a the Mai. E. haw a aa?ee Linkeewa ee 1?1iee,r he: eiheea'iae ideaii?abie aa E?eia?? ?ealeeked the aeel partiali}? entered" the reeaa heaitaat te feiiy enter the witheat fl; . uni-teeter: member {hehiief'??f?m 1: Pee-earatieega ?eieide: Ceeleealiaar {he Bediea a. Guard feree atated that thee ?amed eaeh ef the a. in the ef the ea, the ?ea: eeapeedera were me} {anaem use a, {wee} adaa (haw age-EWZ} {hm} 4. {$19339} ateted that When he feline the heel empty in eeli A3, ?i iheaght he 093] might be waiting behind the blanket? hanging up ?ey the in the rear ef ?ee eeil. MM "left were en te state that ?We yanked ea the elaaket, whieh aid eel; immediately ae'eaa emei then I emailed ie aaicie aed ian'eediateiy up the detaineef?m fie maa?imm elated the {in eel! A83, eraa bee?ng ea a?eaepigieg a: harm feethee ataiea that ?(5)1133 ?ee a see ?1 . 11. 32?3- Erie} ee?a USC ?ea} ?13?b ea a} h?u? HI GTMO SJA 69 2 eteteti titet 1- - teen: the eeit eejeteteg weteit wee eert end i teeteeat ee the eeti ttieti te eet et?whete i313 wee -- [1 USC 23335 tint henging it}? hie tteeitf Il?tr? MAE the ettieed et A8 ee Mei ie. tittEieth . bii3}i1 USE IEHEETE St?t?? ii?i?i he eteeti ?ttii "ibiizi the the einiti i elee eew enethet? eheet et half ef the hieeket eetreting tie the wet} behind the tiiegene11}r hung etettitet. 'itt edditien: I elee eew ehent qeertet et? the shelter 1e the eeli eet'et'eti up, hat)! ?ett thenght wee thet the wee behind the hleeitet end wee ef whet he 1 31-33.; ee it! he tteieg. e. {bit3ii1 etei [tether eteteti thet ?When {en the alphe Bleek weteh teten] wee te the eetit i deeided te ge eeteide the hIeek end leek eetintete it teek tee te ieet'e the ?eet et? the eeil deer end attit?e et the enteitie (blitz) the deteinee henging i?ijf hie e. wet they; 1 geet?e deteetett that eetnethieg wet?; in eeil A3. MM wee in the Bieek NED eheeh when hieek :tetett thet when he went te eeli AS, eetereiing te the ?eet, end pettitiening the heck left eetner ef the eeit {term view item where I wee eteediegi At this time, 1 netieed twee enteide end hehied the tier leeking inte the melt. [1 USC eew the detainee henging frent inside the eeii.? #35 ttete?l thet he 10. Iii-16%} in the ef the enieide 55113:, feet i..eitiei eteteti thet the}: ?fteen the it?tijf efiSi?t 533 itengieg It MASH etetee titet ?i went te 12 enti netieed thet the detainee beet ethHIZ} ie te?ftee use at e.e.tete tit .e tit tie d: a I via-~i:ei tee teete- wan-$-5- 3-. . er iti: GTMO SJA 7O 1E. Me} 1E. in fee {2911?} ?eei when she en eei? e1 2 eneneei, eemen men neene new {new .et?EEd nee men 3 :1 .Te 1% REEL eteied ihet ?When I get neer the eeii, I heeni, Ii.- {b11721 inhe 12." I went tn- Alphe 1'2. ene new nf nennle render tn ge ineide the eelih When. get. in Aiphe lief-W2} eteted that eleneed et en? A12- end reelined 15. {Jeanne} 'nher nee- ?The three ee ee {mew emenib??m e12 endinE} a? eieted he went. tn- ee? A12 with a nd Feet enineked the eeli end we entered, After entee'ing the eeilg i ?31(2) 17* In the eeil ef the enieide. 1315.. the ?eet reenennere were MAE USC The}: Fennel the bed}: ei' ISN 593 {hen 1e. mere: I new [bet e?er the ef the nenging deieinee, eeneenne neede en the nine-e end I nee we in wee}: teweed. the end ef" the her when i heeni Ailehe i I ren linen: end eleenteei fine in dense, There were ?ee-re en 1 epened the ii??ii Semenne ehen?teel we need en 1 een tn Kenn Binnie end when i been ee nee nee been. en? ?ee-en en nee reed in be eenepenzeei in um- ?5 en'ne an en; 32:12?: Iran's-u inf-Er use weenie{nee e: j; 1-: 1.- liewllil- J-ira- cl?ln? E: .5- - . .l Jr!- I. "1 il- Hulk. r'ir 4-05.: ?343.55} {Ti "Fifi GTMO SJA 71 3e?. {been re ee ewe-ewe ?e wee?e {he-H El 1' I e- i'eei ee eeideeti?ee ye?ee wee-e we USC WEEK: {bl-Jig Sie?EEd the: ?i W??t?it ?te 5} end I SEE eny?ne; i?eide? Mggih?h? further etetee' 13h e1: 11 pee eeierieg the eel} with {we eeher Nee. ?We ree??Fe end leg hmgi?gle we M312 Lb??y thee he- returned te Mphe ?fe-e31 ?ee] . 693 he the medical e?nie, end 51mm ef?terwerde heere the eell Fee with A5 {w MAE. b11131: MM 1? km 31:1 Heeifh LEI-EH: he feer?e in eed picked {up} the ileegjeg by the weiet fer elee in we been 22, MAE eteted met ehe beek ie the melee Bieek tier euteiee e315: peepereteey ?e 693 the ate the Camp ?elte medieai elieie She ?eeher etetee ?eet leekiee inter ee?L?i ehe ee?w 234111966) meemeem die eel menlien am?) elee netieed, jest ee I entered the eel} eed befere we etertee tekieg the bed}! dewe, the: there wee biee in mine, eight He 693 ge heed we eteried ige take the bed}? dewe I eiem get new te whet the wee te; ee we: 4: we we etetee thee weiie he wee in ee? {e El ?ee: ee'eeaiFun". I: ei?eue i?e? {he ?ne EESH we?: wee [he ewe nwvp??ii?ii? 111??: ?ne - Inn-n? "I'm l?nu?h-uu-mu?rme-ee GTMO SJA 72 'Hw?m reie i-Zi?i ie {if} ef {Z?ee?iee?ege by 3&3 ?ii ii?? heme {Seemmiw?emi Weiie .i Fertile i 3. The 11.11? [his Guard Meme: and en updated ef the tei?iie e11 page ?8-4 ef the EH35 30R The revised tehie is dated 12 Mereh EG?fii JDG pi?i??id?d eepiee iinZ} wig-1L. i 4L {@9539} i eeleeted the $005 parameter ef em reiei? ie em'?z} ee than: date? end tile ?if eeien ef the EleJf nelere me Humid-es; was; published in i the eiher parameter, 18 June 2636., it ie the def; e?er the ii . (FBEEF) ?ndings; effeet regardng en eutherieed in the Camp Deite 30F that eermitted eempiient detainees Mimi-2} ii {3:115 May 2905, Eii?j??JE ChiefefDieeipiinei MACS tra?SmiW-?i?i 35 ?111 eiteeiitiiei?ii ii} at HEPR email 2.1 new {if if {rd-I'.I1344?fe" .H {3.13 GTMO SJA 73 -- "4 WEE-$11 mi}; 51,- WEE: 21% a: mg; 33%; ?ying. was: Qi?-m? am; am"? EEZIE a I'm U55 .- In?- . 15. (W) Th? aliwcaps emphasis is: in this rcviacd tabla; it is n01: my? additi r111 16. Rclate? ?nding? nf fact regarding pr?cmjagum fying the. Camp Balm in?u?Ana-ls up? th?a EEKEA 1.: .EEH, r. i-E ?33 - I.- GTMO SJA 74 13.31269%} P?l' the t?bhj A ?rhdn?up riln+uri 1ma?a? - iin?iih?r?i?? .5- E..- williF-E?g??a {13315;} i?iggj?ff? I. -- I I a 1rd- H- I ?ai?am L- Eizf: ?1155} ?t a. Em ?igm??g ?ing}:ng Kai Farmi?gd Ea Elam; If" in?r- Fl.- .gl-L i? ..JE .1 that. ESE: Mai - 'wvuTHd?hWHvuu?_h -.- 3:53:33.an m?fb'H'Em . '5 site-1x3 i-E-Li?n? 3; #651?" "ii-J hif?TF" t'H- 1m; . Lr'ur??srw f?q??fc??gki?i Ft 'Hi-ef 3 raj; GTMO SJA 75 ??ihing ?331 33:: hung SEEM :i?t?d Tim? 33,3113 Emma: m: aim- Ei?i?d ihai an": ?r?hrm E31 :35 ms: 1.111 at ?et?in?eg washed th?i?? bi??k?i? ihai day: and hung the-2m in their {3:11-51 dry. I . . I3 Addita?nmiy, Ea?t?d Khar?ua?rd m?SSE-l?i? {m (W64 Seven-1E fact?rs curtail the: lik?iihuuj? that. the Calnmander Inint Detc?ti?? {Emu}; unaware that that rm.? 1 II- ?nau??l-JSC .I in!? 3. Cm a? 3m mm lEr? -- 5 H3235 Haggis: .5 i331. 2w: Tastiimi?r 235$- 5&3} "1 ?v .ln. GTMO SJA 76 9?1 {31min 5} 3'57?? BEE-mnbur Si}? imma??aiy macadag Hag?- EeLsi .113. 13+ {?1999} D??pit? COL im?gkm U50 amnh mum {hat an mm: 2086 ?115: SCIP at?? With the exc?p??n USE *?I'lnh Haul-TL I Hana 0f miwa?t Ur}? duiy pit-manna} the {Rpm}: HEIG- Lu 1h: Alpha. Him-i: {in?rm he?eved that amid. Hui, itemg walla. 14L ?311 3.4 Aug?t {ha {Esp-11w {J?mma?il?r IL:th Deiamiim fime pmvi?ed a fivc-paragraph the queati??, ?What wan? the: W165 regarding 11am ging thing-3 can ?il? mil walls?? liar resapnnae inciudas the ?niimwing [we qmuiaam 3:1: GTMO SJA 77 EWW guards?; ?i?i had in ha $3123 in mm m: can. {his n63: hag-5:211:33? {magi WHEEL hush; 1-, b3:1r .3 1, a $21: REEL n: ma Emma: i?i?iacm? Hi {?ihmg? of Camp i wife-L3 was; an duty {:11 ting night Df the Emma 1E2. wag mi interviw?? ?EiEf?. in i?iE?-?i?w with ma?: at Liamp America an :23 July 2006:: {315:2 raip?ndcd {a 1271;: ?$3313.: HIE 53.13 [122633 an hanging ihi?g? in. with 20. ENS is {ha {73$th in {Sharga {3f Camp 1; she wag duty at the: ?rm {fifth? Suicides. Ski-a: wag iniewiewad by NEE-1. In Si?f?i??li dam-i} ?23 uh: She ra?p?ndaci thi: gut-Him ?What are the. rules {an hanging {hinua in calls?? :15: f?Hnu-Ta: the time: thy i-m-ahh-mr U50 ffjib??im USC an: :fl?a?a at: B?bib??} mt; - Ema; tin-13%: 2 2? - GTMO SJA 78 USC ee Lbf??i? eieip i eeigeem ei? {ieeri ieid ine in en the: ?anytime the Git? ei A?iij gen .ihimi? mini} be 9 June E??t?i E. An initiel reenender eiie-r the ef the. reperteei ihei {bH2:eninn ri?i: in: MAEE W311i} tee ee: e1 i 13%? ii en en ine nip-he ewe; iiei', ?i Lee telii The in iiewin eteienieine eei?er tn ef hanging ieienieein en nine ?1806 ?le?Iingg {he enieidee were Fer eegeniing henging hienkete that were by guerd fnree pereennef the dieeneerg' e1" the bediee, Appendix entitled "i?eetiineny' in Time ef Death.? in} 4? (mi-H3} MATE ih?t et eppreeimetely 1900mm, whiie ien'ieeing the tree}: ei?ter the evening meal, believe I sew e. bienket hanging in ihe reei' eei'ner ef ne ei thee e5 wee egeieting hie bieniiei eiewn with ieeter. "The eeneii}; weeh end wee}? their hienkete ihie neg? 5- 3133 eteied ihni; 2901f}, he eein" ?The i?i Avg Squirting hie i'il?i'ik?i with. ee if in: nee ?e?eehi?ei 5' ei? :1 gee: if: ere {i?e?i?i ee USC gig if ?1 SDILibii?ici i Lea?ee ?i?iei, eei?w dig Efe?iieHn eiei-Lie i-inzeneei enriernee enenz,? in; weenie ?er-e. 5 ii?Ht?: i i Hie: rem" i' 3:32" Li'Er H: . .I - ?nu. . -e gait-f "Hall I W: era-e Li. a. HTM- ham! ehem e. e: a; I GTMO SJA 79 mt . . b'311 . -. a {meat ta a atat?I 3' atataa ata tta a a i auac ?agaatt?taattja t?aatatattatatt ta aa W??t?tt?g Ettft at: tattatt Eta tat-ta .tztt-zagaata tat?t?t . 4. - - Ettaatb?m aata at aa that" ttatt tattaa tata tt? ttata at - t. {Wt atatthW attata atta aa ?tat; ta aait 3i tat atatatt that aha ta'aa ta'alittaa ttat watch ftaat 231139 ta ?2339. that aatati that tha ta aati 5&3 ti}. Mali whim Stated that white ha ttratkad tha ttat atattaat ha aattaad that ?tha dataima in ?ail. A-S ttad a btauttat hanging at) back by hta 1 a 1ft. "that aammittati autatt?ta can ?31. {193a ttaad ltta 1L Spaaktag with to that ta aa? Anti (13H tam it}? atatatl that ?Strata lattit'at! at 1 (baa 13. atatad that Wh?? ha dataatad in tha A8 (blitz) 1-4. MCI-S ph?tagtapita A5, 518,: and HE {taptat tl?t, {jut t't ?irt: :tt? at tat Matt E..- c. I Ila.fi. 'nhu'E-I'! (bx GTMO SJA 8O WW) for blight Ob?a?miunby?uania 9 Janna 3006 2-15 Findings; m? that reg?rdi mg the. i?muina??n in?ide ?ipha Him-k an the. night af 9518 full: 2996 inciudu: {magi} MAB E?m Med that ruatuiiat?iea HERE m: that E?li?l Ei?? if}? Mama. {@5ka ma Wide a {my Smt?dthat??0the Exhih?i 731.35 Elwin "7 Exhih?i Es'ws??gua'? {Iii 133% 3?33: 34* Eh ?Ex??tsi?i iliafis?iiza?e MEL if} 5 ?5 E5 53w. jf'" a {?ner ?War ?jif'w - E: m; s; GTMO SJA 81 rm! that. MAE Stat?d, that it grated than, {Egg?Q} 'l?h-B MW 75550,. ?30(3) U55 pm Said" siated that use 1m 1% 3- ?1 .I. -E saws; giE-c'liigi GEE: -f 1:33:15} - -- f1, Ff? if?: $.13be {in?ue- an. E. in?" {El-?23- .E- LEE-.53 i a a. . GTMO SJA 82 ii. #1 regeet?eg eat-er: ?le Emile .2306, en eff ?ee Lewes: eepe?esj ?ee eempietiee m? tandem The repert ie ?llee ee member e? the melee ee ?ee dime-?ve tea ekeikieg ?ee ?ee ever}! ee?, eigheiegib??er fer ever}; detainee. The eie-letien is by the time heedeeuet e1: 2335,. the medie e1 epinien is then the detainees efreeriy heel been hangieg fee ebeul e11 beer er mere. with SDI-J ??3~6f weuld eel? hex-e prevented Line eed? failure ?e eemplj; nee bee-"e fee?iteteei {he 13, {$369) The feiiewieg SUP but net demeneirebly eemrib'uted he the ee?e?ge ?f?reeg ?ag; emee: "Eee chi-ii:- ll-l?ee nee} 1e eh} ILqu ef?eerie if eke. mehe Tie ME we "1 GTMO SJA 83 '13? aim-4?5 ?g?ii..r . I awarding in $125: 12::{gjar? ?pinim ?f L32: g?i??gj?h 33:; b3}? aha? ?Wm; ja? h?m?a mngi?f imam}? W?hi? 35mg 51:15? t-?imu a El?i?i?? him-E53 hi3; aim-1:513; and him?aif i?iiy i a maize} {is-aim mam: :35, gum? ?ji?miaring Eli}? match;- it: 3% a d?t?i??e?ibl?i? and a guard mg as. cit-a: m: up an". 5.1m: m? ma mar 3111:: ?uw? ma ?fhf?f wm?d ht:- in Emmi ramme- give-1:1 mail Even an, iniurvai 9f (M112) {netweaz? m'ifag?v? 11.3115 appem: ma mag pram-inf a data-2: EH1 dataim: waiiad {51* 3-. guard {.23 p555; and than ?pc?iy hangad him: E?'if in the: ?an? ?f hi3 {.1131}: {ha detainaa Still maid aghieve death mm 111:: guard rammed anuugh ii} SEE: me Ext: 2131' ?rst the: 11mms,thu E-i?b?f?i? preparaiiu?g 0f the: detaineas in advanca of their death? 3;]an senr?cl Shrink the already? 3111311 manta that mm. reviva them. GTMO SJA 84 i . I an rnrninn Eii?i?ii}" ni?inr ?2331 {inring rirr: rinr nrninii nf 1' i Eikniy in prawn n: USC in inninrinn nf Il?tr" inn in: in nnr. ?ning gi?grhg?mm?'?? in n: rihnri irnnr nririin walking inn 09% I -- ul? rinr 223i} and man lair was drawn in nnii ninn {insnrii?ind iinw in: r'iid nni inrtiinr, rand riiri nniin A3 and nniin tn hniri n-?hn rninidni 3 in ni?hir NCIS Midi-Sr?? inrni ihn ?iphn Binnk. guard rerun; rnn-rnnr inriinnrn. i nininninnrn nn nrinrn pin in inn ?ninrnn winin denying irn had anything in {in with tin: rinnihn. 61 MASH ablif?y ninn in ngninnt nnri in inninrir rrnd?ing in the guard shrink: nnr'iriing man in guard. niinnir, nriLi failing in walk Erin in innininr: .i as in irnni ?Wi'l?ti'ii?i? lin niinnid have npn?nd t'nn dnininrnn n'hn nninidn 1F. I 3. in than mndinnl ii is that the rn nnii A ll iS?nE 585i} ni inn iinnrn tini'irrn hi3 13nd}? n1: nbnni {53035 nn ?0 Eifiifiti. 9i Mnsr?miim niini inn an n?r LEE inin?'i inn" rrn?rnii inn iirnrr nniin'rnin. if - 1 . . nit-E . at . i "rirn ii ir use Pic-'- l?l?ll II: E: I I mini; gift? r31, Err-n Emmi r. nifnii- - I Ina-- I .I: - - ii-f-a riai'rs? 5 i_,3 El?i?J?} GTMO SJA 85 bit? W. -: t} 'i?ha ahi?iia U50 .E q. 1? mam-1 {hay-h Ha:- Lia: baa ha aa aa?aa?; a ,a ma}. aha aa?inZ} E. Ii' it aa?aaia that bafara {ha {1-1 1- a. rl11a aha again-wait tarb?} 15? 15H 1393 in mada aiabarata that ha pradaa?y baa-?a ia iarighiar light. 16. in additiaa. in tha guard iaraa? H?m??y alalad ha waa an Aipha Biaak far tha 0f ?daring raaghla? [ha aima 1. I I u. Fl; 233-? aa llail'j'? 127?. it aa?kaly that aha aha aar walah afair?? USC II 1:71. waa aa brig MA with a Ilf?r? far balding ta aha mlaa. 193143 Ea) Ms? had a hiatary af with IBM 693, an it is unlikely that MAE mg?b?f waald ignara {3193?s. was [ha guard nae-11a ?ral that. aaxaaihina waa amiaa in ISM 093?s aaii. Na aaggaata that MAS {b}{3}21 waa a. watch aiaadar. 211. I it likal}: ?aai' aha a-Tara araitiaa liar 11a: at tha- atraag lika?haad that may had "aa?y him aa aa: mamhar at" aha Aipha ?13. Em; a: wag-ad gainmam-1 rhwam raw-mm a? -- fair aalaa: a: atafa aa; 4? yam-i . . a ., ?jg-a aa-a a ga?sa? '5 ?fths)?? aa: aa ai? wi aa 1 ?Fig.5., a HE 3: Eva a tax: GTMO SJA 86 ei i . ris- eeied ebee?er i thet the iree rlerieg {bli3li1? '{ier eeti rie eer thee be i eeriee Me?i?i Shin re geerde whe ie i -e eiehe Eieek eeilei i the Si}? eeiherieeri ee re if geerde were 3. i ere eepereiel}: ?te regerriiee i'eiee {Li} 1, Seine ef the feree pereeneei wile very well dieing the peried fellewieg ?le efrhe merit freer eirereiee. 2., in Alphe Eiee'e geerri teem, {he ?eiie'e'rieg yeer J. MAE Lise. reieed the erigieei elem ihe e-ee in A3. He retrieved the {big} eheere, eeiered the eellr eed 3391i? e?er whieh he eeri ether geerde iS?i?i 0'93 1e eerried hire re the er ree. When the geerrie retereeri ie ?iphe the eed were ere}: {him eelied fer entered eeli A5 with ether g?LierdeE end ilie lied}? 693; egeie he eet the in with SUP, elieekied (ii-?3 *e iege eed helped the 1e beeir Sebeeqeentiy he weiked the tier .ieekieg items free}; weiie eetii erdered eeteide te teke breether. MAE eieted the? tried. re heir} i1. regeiher eed be leader e'er lhe whele iike eightmere?im ef hie i kepr reek.ng eed tekng effeeriee 4. . A W. 'e'ee ie the When hm}- reieed the eIerie ehe the irii: {Liam the eheerej breeght ether ?ie ee - *?iiee erreegeci beeidieg 333$? fire eeiL Lei eeri eieeg :33 ie reei iE?ii?i e-r Wife we - in Elsi-EA Ha?z-?ing, hi? Hail? ei?iei?i?e I I- Ilia-1?? - Farageeree Leili: ieje 1311 Sui-55: eerie ii? is i Kei?iere {biizi {[31:37 I 3} ee e3 rii? - .- "hnn' ere i? ir'?ieae ere-e e: -- e. we.? 52'- e; ?if GTMO SJA 87 'ii?i?i aai'riad 1393 ii": at. a Siia waainE'} gaariia waiFEi?i?ii?i?ir'Eg aia?i iiwa aa ii raa aa aigiia i aa aa waia. gaaiag a 131:: aa aha ii'i?i aaii; wiiaa gaaida iha hacig af i335 hia i133 waa Iawai?aa ia- ig wii?jil?i?iim and 13%? 533% wi'aii baa}; iiai? ia aa Gih?i? haai?ii alarm. ai Siia ia a iaai'a whaa aha fiad Sil??i'ii: aha. ta ?m2? iia" gaii'. Lipaa that {393 i cat aawa and. giaparad far la Lil? clinic, aa aha raaitaiad walking ahaakiag aa aaila; wakiag up and araariag tham ta hanging ii'aai iha waiia. MAE- :ilblifiy kaat lia-aii ia aiid aapi up ai iha i'ighi am} right 5* 32?! a3 was walking an: Alpha Eilaak tiai whaa ha :31 can Ali. in la:- iaitiai Eff?i'i ta Il?raiaad what was iiappaaia MAE ibii3ii1 anilarad tha artifith aiijainiag aaii.I with M3513 {bii3ii1? f! ?ll-Dr? L. aaci was abia ta that $93 waa hangiag. MAE: aatara-ri aihai' aad 1gad cat iiawa agaa ihai iha {mania had i {baa gaff? ma ia the aiiatraatiaa the airway, A?ar iSi?i ?393 la:- a backward: MAE tha- athar aan'iaci tha ta .-. at a ran. A?ar aaliaariag iSi?ii {193r 34:13 haaid a ibiiz) alarm. and an aariiaLi a back fraia iha ia- at aha whara aipaa KEN figli iai? MM did raiaambar having aa, ha? ha ihaa haipaa carry; 6-93 ta iha aliaia. [ha E?i?i?g??EF} MAB kapt making and kaal Lip {ha damaading wara iiwalaad ia mating {iawai twa preparing [ham fai' ta [ha aad than carrying La iha at a ran. 6. Btiiar afiha Camp 1 guard 1aa1'a wha yaur USC Ham Fi?-m La iaipha ii}? iha?imi?i Biaa}: NCQ a?ai i?ia: waa ??ii?ii $93. Wiiaa Liiag awiaad, tlia iaipiia Biaak guards waia tha black; wiih ISPJ i193. Tiia ai?iha {iaai?d waa aiandiag {ha biti?ii: aa Willi USC w'aai a-a iiai- aiid ?aagaa 4 iaa?g a ?iaii 3% "aai ia ia 'i?ia 3i {bii3ii1iaaij}: aawag fl?i?iim Pg}. 5.-. mpgaai?i? ?ii-i 52:: i aai?airift-h - {it - I-H I .-.- Jld-1--. I.- ?Er-n. - Liia. Maia?? Iii-iiraiL- hail-Li Li. GTMO SJA 88 mp te r?l'iipha Bieeki reritere tee-3r ranged: rise ear! deem the tier ertieriaa rietaia - ea re taiee iteera it?iigittg ea araiia. 'iliejr at tiria tie-ta aetii ere-eerie Tiiefr are eetai- ie iier iiariair maria aria? tairea aetiea iri tiie e. leadership. S. USE ?13?bibiimibw?9 area a trieraber ef the teara ariie reiie i a tee taitiaa ii?i?i itgii te the tie the eerpareae CPR its}? iieiriiria rate ?393% i?i-Eitti ie etaee arid the air triaak ire tirae with the {a the eearae ei" tea}; a ?aieir eraage bieed-iike aahataaee apewed eat ef 093?s ateuth and ever MAE tb}{3}21? header Aa ibit3ii pet it, pulled beak, but the eerpatriart aaiti te iieefi geiag,? whim-J31? ea, er the remainder ef a i?ettgii title te the heaeitat. USC ?anti ?mm Hie-aim .eti ether te r-?iti ?a'iiere eaee?eered the hanging bed}; 691 MA :1?l13iti the treaty up while aaelher MA eat the eerd. arid ethera .ewere ISN 693 te the greener ahaekied hire te SUP, hire. te a liaekiieardi and earrieti him he the Camp Delta. iaedieai eliaie. ane the eliaie, heard ie a aitiliere treeia with U93 fer a eeraeat fer tie ia ae ire releeteereti te 1.1111 the airiee earaera fer ei?r tree aritii iaatraeted {bitmim te atee aideetapiag the errata. He then direeterl neejaaier MAS in and setting the aarieaa materiala that had ia with the detairreea, - - i 11}. MAI mm.? area a guard ea Set 133" Part 5L "When aite heard that a "Wat-t attempting te 1eaeg ahe aa erder te a?ethet aa?ier ea Salty Fert 3 te prepare the the arrival ef aredieal peraeneei.. Aetng e11 erdera frere ahe ran te the efiaie fer arietiier baa-kbeard, whieh ahe lireaglil Le eell A lint-Hie in preparing 693 fer traeapertatiee? arid thee helped carry him eat at the bleak and te the elieie. While rearing baaire-arda, aire hate 13H 693?a head te prevent ita trietiea. After detiverieg ISN 693 ta the ahe retareeti te tier peat at Sail?i?l Liinl mum {hummer area {31.1 iht?: eaeet?t tti'?l?t?l. 53in: raa if?i?t?i ?ih? eeatrei reeai te Aipha Bleei; ia reap-ease re a (bit?) brevity aeti tar-?ea ei' tire tirat peeple te eater eeil She ire-teed eat 693 deter-t. ear tie a-aa ea the fieer the Site aria. etiier geartia iEiN te a arid. earrieri hire. te the 1. 'ieritieri re a treat ia aa atiiei'iiea La--I-. II: --.. e-erjeefriae ee tare ea, treat 3 1- tutu.?- .-1 .- .i . I L, inere-r ire-*- -1 ttie?. aetitra?tet?tg i-?tri?tt?: Wee {at the raeie aerate irate age, eiittire-ti .r?teita tee eajig-theri ttr?taa err-err tae a itieetii, jitter :ng'a ri?e war; are I I. - r-lii: - rut-M'? - earn} ire-i {bii3i- - area trite tie-e eteer eaeerft =e tee 1n fer?'5': .-.- - its-LE: a GTMO SJA 89 feta-rat i-iesjeitai. tint feane that iti?' ass teas aise tie-art. Tire anarris teea intense-ti tn {it-tetra ?nite . tit. Itibiw?m USC teas {we} attare. teite teas tr-isttina tetra Btee?tt when gnartis there tirst were teas tereng in set} A3. White tire anards tatere assenteiing eet'aitie as in trreparatien te enter. etas 1; big? titetatht te epen rite shatter. anti elites-1t en ISM 093% states. 'ieiiten he ear that are eras ?te seentert in tire fest et'tite {at state te enter. anti then ran. arennri tn reieirt tire etiters. teir?t? {him}: trainee. .eenre re a basic beard and earrje i-?tit?t?t tn the eEinie. Linen. retreating te metre Bleak, eras fennet that tree atere sttieities had been he was ene ef the first guards 1e enter eel] r15. and he ptrliert aside the bianltet te retreat ti?ii. After training set desert ISM eras tessm retrierett restraints fer nae in ESP, and then went in Ail where he jeieeti the team that earrieri 13H 588 tn the eiinie. After titat, he returned te his ewn bleak and res turned his duties the-re. it" Resernrneadatiens ntent ef J'nrtier_Le_at1ers t. training fer staff N??s and jenier eftieers te trait} them resist tietainee teheediina. 'ntitnirtar?en. er ether rrtattietti'atitre- behaeier designed te eersnade earnp and tire lea-tiers te reiaa standards. it is irneettant that the ineerning members at the Naval Ea peaitieaars' Guard Battalien get. a. deetenstratien ef firnr enfereernenl tinting their training detainees eaeleited the last year. it. Ensure ii] at perferrnanee reviews are neither nesitieeiy ner tied tn the 'freqnenefr ef ciiseiplinary' aetiens. detainee eentpiaints. er attuned te this practice in his statement in NCIS. 3. Redirect the teens ef shift separatisers and jneier eftteers tehe battered fer reiatie-?e detainee at the eaeense ef gnarti erediiaitity. Ttee jenier ettieers in partiettlar? ENS {bii3ii1? USC ?13?bibii5iibii7iici are earned by an army at senrees as faitinst te bank tie saiiers in the ?rnt enfereement ef Carrie I rnles. Guard. rnerale tee}; a heating as a result. Gt?al] the perseanei in Center petty e'ftieers anti represent tire greatest prepertien ef preueat?ereentent sentiment. and the}: eapresseti strangle pesitiee tastings abent their-jet: setter]. they are teeritina i?er Sergeants at the Gerard anti t?iateen Leaders wire has}; their: at}. This eesitiee attitnrie trains there. sitter; eff detainee trait ttehatrier. w- ?Hts-Fr ate-T -. a. .. Er. ta. eiti. iLii Fitittise airs- I ?4 wee-t'? - "w "in-Pu alt-*4 - - r? tr a series} nan er .t beraeant er. rite train i erg; are es treat 2 -tertt ire Era-1- -.-I- i -II . In 'r?ehe'?a I ind-H. etraenetr "ts: tti ?titte- extent. "eeins tr Fitter rename-tree, net.-.1 - eetarnee tee-rt: _t teat ii b} 2} I I that?) tbse.1 a use an; an are seems mun-t fhth'th't ti? ?th w" re. re tirestart fife GTMO SJA 90 Tha ia a ia aa ?aat gaafta af? ahiaf patty aa aha haa faamaf? a?iaa "with mafia 32a aha aha?a ?za' at: "Ea Ea {la ?Eta Ear ta ?Thia ia a'iaat I ihia Ea aahaa pamaiaa: ?aa ia aahaa J. 4 Tha Jaiaa Graap?a Rama-h UT appraariaia HG {aam ifl?lu??f analyaa and rapa? an the aaraih?y campaign that culminated in aha {laminae "111a Laadar aad af the Guard Laga ?aali ha a aalaahEa far tha aha-ray: EL- Mama 1, I waa ta'td by 0p {?aataa that haa at: ahi?ty ta madam: af aali blacka aa a data. If thia ia i tha adailtiaa af this faatara: a tuna} ha aalaabla far apidamialagiaal aa wall 513 mac-arch. GTMO SJA 91 aa?? i aar?ar {asaa .a'saa'aasas Tiara a'f Garza}: aa I.J aha awe far-sf Ea aa? 25.3 {13% {5333} Ham a MAE J?s. a MA MA Fail?: 2 2,5 aisi USC MASH mas EASE arm 3. alpha Biaak ?aasa Psi-aha Eras-a; {Eaara Eaara Taa 79? af ara ("Esra-rd Raiiaf Aipha Biaak ECG Alpha Black Guasd ma?a Biaak Guard af Guara as Tab a-a 3:3 "raa '1 ab Cal-=1 ?Fab.?aa Fiaa mamhars at" the: Camp 1 draaggrr guard iaitia?y aa carat} saisitia in an (33% Tab Tab Burt?s Tab as Tab Cali Tah {3 Li'aara- Guard. High! aa-d 1a}: af taa Camp gaarrli faraa iai?aiia ta the disaavar?y af aha third saiaida in arr-1E 23.5 693}. I'm-r MAI USE: hia1?13?bimi?llm as use guards a aura? As a aarsib?m- 3'9? Esaart ?apartasaat .2 LPG, Esaar't Ekpartaraa! Squad. 1 'raa {33 Tab 05 was a guard an daty ia ibjpj Blaak aa {ha aighr at? .last bafara ?Ea-a afi'SE'? hadyr saraa ra Alpha Biaak ?as tall: arm Lhair a, as: was an hand far [ha aarargana}: saa? Per USC Jana Whaa aha raitiai alarm was raisaa: arasaiba?m Alia, aad saat MAEN was arr W2 llilaak guard an ara- raga: af black NCO aanl him In Aipha Black ta assist. Haas: HELE- EEH was haagiag, arasa Erma ISM 533. aatsida ta ?nals in aatariar ?a?ar I aria-?ad a1". Alpha, just as guaraa ?Nara aarriaa wirh {193 arr a baa}? haar'a. MAE-N aatarad Maha Biaak aad hagan a MESN that: waa arr-?ag in raparrarj aarar rnamaara afara sarara faraa aataraa call 14112 and aar- . . "Par .33 USC saraiag aa Tara raga: afiaraa?aar a: r. a Lama ?ax-Ta by $2953. I- araa'aa' farat-?h x: 'Ia?u-H, I Esra a; aaraias East-ass: alias-a Mat The: Tat-arr: wars r?a {iamr} Bahia a1; Baa; with raa ajpararasas Haasair {Eris?EC? 53a ?aai-aa; af?bHZ} aa raa ar- aatr a? East raa ass ESE: aa use "r _i a: .11..- - I . s? Laura} A aa aara araia as. as: 1- ltd-h. . 1" I I I T-Il'aha}? baa;- araita Tara-?a a as: Earan EaaI-a sa ?ag-a a; harm-mg sf};ng -.. -..I -3 1 . '1 'r .--, Hr- ?rmfal?a? ig?ici L-f?ian J: far air-a {Whig}: aa :aar-lEli"? HUEELUU ?732.:er ff?i'as?: Ear-3'3. . ahasaa- sass raa- sari a; as a? a a a; ra'saa- a as n. 95 Eva GTMO SJA 92 . I 1 [atria ?13?bq {mm ratprta Break {reare tab 33-h} Matt Betty ?ert ?-eaat "Fee $513? Met} aretta- Steele; 2 ?fat; Brat E11 31 ert Segeae. E: Tale {in tit araa art, Eaeert Eileeaztateat tee-eat} 3 Ta?) {Lt i Gerard Ta?e Mat} Serge eat at ?eard Streereeaterarae Tate re Etaak Earl".th Eaeert department ?ageae 3. "Eat: ?at? 4. Tara eaadat}? ef the ?ame duty guard aha partieipateti in the. etaergerae}r fallewiag diaeet'ery ef the detainee aeie'iriea ia Aipha Black previdetl atatementa relevant te that invea?gattea. U50 Eaeert, Eaeert Department Seeatl El Tab ea atae?gmmW? Eaeert meagre-tear iraa and thee ISM 693- Per EDP Thea, meeteera et'the eaeert team detainees te a'arieaa "teeatiena atteletlieg te a: reedieat etinie. ?"12 PEI U59 nae-a attending watett ea the night eraee June area at Satly Part 4. Site eeaerihed Siaer Part 4 ae ?the area that iadietdt-tale eteet ge te eet te {Lame 1. raetiag ea the ereera eithe ?eet}: Detta etedieai eiiete ter a beard. each site a - the raedieei area. 133 Per BEE-IS USE ?13?b~ib?m~?m??m was aer'eiea en the eight ef?rl? juae ea a member efrhe Camp ?elta Eaeert Team. He and his partner, {b}{3}11 reap-ended a rarlie ereeirv cede Eadieating a aerietla armatiee Ea Aleha art-ea- #4 Per U55 ?13?b~mHm~mH7er waa aert'ine en the night at Jeae ae a member e'fthe Camp Delta Team. Site and her partner? LII {b}{3}31 te a radie garnerein a eerie-ea mediea! aiatatiea in alpha Bteek. Deaeribed Deaeribed abetret Fer 551131 USC ?13?ble5LmH7Hm was aereteg in Caerp 1 ea the eight at" 59.31%} Jane :15 a reerneer at" the duty detainee team (lea?) When a guard {teat Care; 1 all the eae-erta te Eateha Hieek- eieed earre Fi?-t en a haeahearrl fh? magical; aging; ?m Per ECEEWHEHW ?13?b~m?m~m?7er was aereteg in Camp i ea the night at" 9.52% Jane aa a. member at [a mm Eaeert Team. haaeti ilt Came Betta. at Euridiaa ?eei err- with the {Seater {Eli-531C), MAE ea detiea tltia taay: ?Eta arr eaeert teaat rearreaarme fer tietetje eftieta?aeea re ateeteai and taterreaetieeaf" Ef?e: eireetee aa- t?eitea teaea raeeteer Ra? fbH3 ta rear-at te [area 3.. re a area-ear atria}: retreat eat. a a?aa tt'trea-teatee aerrteterea. Ere {Ta L. a aatty eert at: are2 tat-Ed eaeerta that the atteetee atreattyweaet traaeterree re the {fame {tetra ettater a: tie: ette?e Fee eaeerra ESE Ea the ea-re at" et'.ete treraee ee?i ?ee rte SE at ante the ?rearttaeaete Eli-at; Harare". eeibl?li araa we are-?era a eat-er :1 aa aa ae eetaetee eaeera Site are}. arr-at a'ere aeat re ea Caete Flietta Et-teatE-eagff'tiete age-are tat-'rung-fat?? a-eE-{at? ?are a: an eat-a via-?1' tray .1- Eater. hut-1:23: "It Baa: g'H'eFe?hjf?: II. ?1 a {Ti} ?t FE Era?H. nilfab GTMO SJA 93 5* 37m aga??i?a? pars?nwi faring; Ef?gy; Mm pariiamat?? {hm 'f?i??wmi ?air,- {if d?ai?ee EH- Eim? ?air; Em- mumwm? use LT E-IM Em HM HN HM Tab 31? Tab 112 Tail} E313 Tab F4 i an .1745 F435 ?Fah- Tab F-S 'l'ab Tats F-I GTMO SJA 94 1+ {a a a'i?aha seaside} A33 the. iaitiai the basis af ESE ease Ia as peas-rises; La assess the eat aEsa described ether relevant aspaass af the deta?ae?s bada. lg? :f'atr- EHH-Iaeil'i I. as: .Er?s as eeCEs l?I'h FIJI- a?'e't "If-1' Li'q. v} mm A stated ?eas ?this ayes were apes? he was said {a aha and his ?ngers and taes wees blae.? '1 ?3 3. staiad me: ?His ?age?ips were blue and he appeared ta ta lileiess,? A sashes slated that ?The Eaaisesi he was dead?? 4* Mayaawa use triad {a abtaia a pulse at there was His eyes were wide apea ?11113 his ?aae was aas him and he was 5. MAE Lb.) stated that ?The data-alas {193} had. aa himself and his eyes were and white.? seas further stated eel! xii-8 had same ?ght purpie an his ?ngertips. Based an. what} absaraad I WGUJCI think. the in :15: had beea daad at laast 39-40! asias?esia befasa I him?? s. {eases meagem stated the when he ?saw Isa hanging in his aali[, tjhe ?rst thing assessed was the disaaEaratiaa efaa lips, whieh appeared biua. His aye-s Were apes and blaadshat. I tell he wasn?t braaihiag.? T. {?939} aeshae stated that the guards had anered 533 {a the {Ea-as. ehee-aed far a pause: but as I did this I realised the heady was said ta {ha ESN 533 seams-a a lime stiff: As SE: 583 Ia}; these an the MAE ?eas. Tram the slashw?H {baa}: use ?1saa II. I as? Elie .e a E29 =13: a a I. 5 Film {Ll-3.113: A a, as Bea; i Iii-5 Ii?! LE safe-Asia I..- IIHH- GTMO SJA 95 {Hat-P5} Mit?txitbi?iim atateti titnt. ?innate anti tintija' 1,1,1- 1.1% r. ?3314::- at; ti tt?itn Egg-t? tn; it" tfti?t?gtU?} {inania anti tnenieai vane $593 attettiy attet hia tietn deaetibeti itia it}, taatt {bit3ii1? atateti that white an {int}: Part 4t ?taint eante an and ante tiaat titete area a tietainaa ttatntitta Tainta?f en- a?ttpna Binnie? ataat?fti?l? ttateti titat aitettit? therea?e't ?tine Minna} hieek gnatda were natty-tag eat the {teat detainee 993} an a haeknnant {internal}. Sail} il?t't' 4i. i nbaet?tr'ed that the detainee nine. The detaineeia feet we re puffy and nine anti it was: [nine ate-anti Itia 1? later learned that the detainee waa ftent eeti Alpha 83m?" ti, MAE stated that when he arrived at {Saint} ?etta ntedieai eiinie: ?The ?ne: thing I nntieeti the detainee 693] 1teaa hia blue feet. I aim natieed the detainee ataa titnpt? 12. {Fiat?i6) MAE an'i?teti at the Camp Belta tneelieai eiinie with hat Eaentt Teant partnen Par-1A3 1 She stated that enee inaitie tite etinie leaked at 15th? Q93. He iataa tight in ttent nf inn i enntd ne ntneentent and an aiajna nf tit-a in tit-"1H Ilia eyetitia teete enen, an itia aft-"ea ttiti net name, i eettld eat an cheat. diti net tentetnber hint wearing a ahirt. He had tan pantat He n?aa net nearing any annea. The skin an nia eheat n?aa the enter. itia hand-a and feet teete {tiniah in eaten the akin nndenteatit hia tnenaiia araa pnipte in enter. 1 eeniel teil at the eliniea when I innitetl at him} the HEN {tilt-i n-aa 13. MM stated that arriving at the Cantp Dena nieclieal elinie while eaeerting ISM 6935 ?Medieai. neraennel directed na tn take 693 ta eleven Ainng the way In teem I what I believe tn be 13131?393 in the trauma area with emergency C'F'Rf?S?b naa {the t?t .at "l ten-ta btt?itbt gilt.? .. .- GTMO SJA 96 in ni? rnieirin Eire iirni renneniiern the brie?y nf i?i?i in in iin. grain-nien ere inn: re npenn-err nine ether reieennr nepeein ei? tire deininee? her-15s?. naen?ibW-i? einieiirhni Miner nrinnieii en hire neif.? ri Eir-?i?i?i i'?i?iim etnreri ii in ?nii ienniri renrernber ie ri {er nnirrir: hire net inrn iris i?eei iirni . . in 1H ins ieer were nine ner}: erred," 3' i6. {3291319) pr'e'riried detailed descriptinn nf eienehedqinwei whieh i5 ineinded nhere in tire eeneerninn airway {ii?iSii?il?ti?ii??i end. wire nbrerreci 533 eiieri'i?y niier en enirneiien freni eeli AS nine his: eeneerenee. i3. i. einied filer entering ninhe Hieek new i 53% en the winie nF Sergenni ei? tire {freer-d and Aiphn Bleek. pereennei were pinning EN 533 enin i- kneeieri Linn-"n and felt in pniee enei deteeien ne eigne nf life: Hie egg-en were epen end irinnk. i?iis rnenih wee neen anti ennIn?. see his teegi. 1' netieed hie leenniir end tingeniniin ?nd nireeny ninried in turn nine?" ii}; L11 :m sinieri that ire brie?y entered Pripi?i? Binnie end then exited in get erretelier. ?linen? he ereied? ?i reinrneei in 533?s eeli end [3111 the eireieher halfway intn the eeli rieer. I then neeieteci picking up the detainee and putting him en the etre'teher by his; nnkien. When I grabbed hie nnkien the}: were. eeid. i nlen netieed his lee end finger nails; were purple and the pnirn?r] nfirie trends were very White."413 - .- - ?p a: - Fina-ii Earnsire-*3- ,n . -. nii.fin?13?b.ib tier-trier; i r?ni Len} e'rNtin {inn gin I GTMO SJA 97 tire e'f tire . A .3. H. Lariat-e atria-tee: Eta. tire retaerJ-aiiera the Eerie ei? ia ariditiert te- tite ia?attaatiaa areairieri aae're. tire irritiai reapeatiera tie-aeribeti ether reie?earrt at? the heel}: in} i. atateri titat aitertiy after arriaiajg ia eeit a5 artri ieweriarr iSi?a .iE?a tarraiaa array the areaari ?i eitee-iteei tier teapirati.eaa a ear. eeaid eat tiereet are; aiart at" are. i 1:393 was ta the teaeit. i aaw artti feit the ligatare 'atariea itia aeeirr the feit rettgh arai *aiaatie." tea: 6933a raeatit waa aiightia apart and i eeaid hie teeth. I dict aet aria-thing ia ltia nreatit. Hie were tar apart and ene was epea wirier thara the wharf??24 that ?eta a tear ear-a area. ti? ehaeraeri it at this; tiara? errata tel! that hie BEES were haii? ta three quarters epeaed. 'i'here was a large iadeatatiert areaari hie aeeir. and I was immediately atraelr with. haw deep the iadeatatiea waa. rerrte-at leer titia iadentatitrrt aa a ereaeerri ahaper trrward the aide at? hie aeek. 1 aatieed the after we lifted ltia ehia. Matti Emmet eheeiterl iiar a petite, fer a eheat riairta. but there waa rte aaetiea anti ae aiga ef iife, 6?93? fingers were ia'iae ireEtiati tile Hie teea were biue. "fire akirt ea hie faee arai arraa appeared te ire a tiara-1 a1 eel-at and hue.? waatba?m farther stated that ?fire earl}r itaei.t'waa piia?ele erieugh that we were able te raeae the eitirt tip.r at whieh paint we eaarrtiaeci the iarieatatiea ia the rteek. ?The bed}? was aet eeatpietely atif? like a heard; it waa atili eiiabief??i?: at. {#123439} MM ea, . aek beard te the tier eutaide and tea, .. At biwiimusc aari ether guard reilieahiar [tilt-i 693] elite the hae eart arr atrappe hire. dawn.? Mfr}. ibii3ii1 deaerieed ahaeat aethiag errata the badyia appearaaeej eaeeprt that. itelf?aattr that his 59ft} eyes were epea. ltheught he might be bat re. rv'iia?ibi?ii?l? .ite-ipea 181% 693 ta rite {lamp Deita Site atated that ??re we were earrjriag trier ta the Ilia?"i [Detairtee ijlirtie, Le?. Camp Deita medieai eiirtie} i rte-tieeri that hia ire-art '?epped amend a Jet. i titeagitt that peepie weal; atiiT are they were aeaa. i aari te iria head aa i rart waa what i aeratei at tie?err itt??t freer art}; irdiittaatai rate-it?. iire itaeitirea ra aet itaa'e a iaraee .i'er tire iteari. i it te rate. haeiawmria irr 3* areratbtt?m raa ea at aera? USC err-tie that rite ii GTMO SJA 98 USC ii??i-?i ugh-mg C, skLFi-E?x. BUR: 9 1 53-3575. 13.11 {m cm:- {#1111 1H5: 1'1'h I 11 51 murmu- mm {Tiff {it 1?5; EEK my. me 0:1: mm 1T Far-T 3 CE $53 $55 55:5 35- S?ii?? Sic: {35; +11? ?-IWJ-Wu-v-l-?-l {71:7 ?u in i {113:} mm ?it m1 4E "E'Tlimn 004:": mm {$13 was. +3135: i? 1: NEH-I. r-ll Wud?? -upth-I-??H?I -- WrI?Iwu r. . - .H-- Ir?~ r: 1r11'- --I "if r- - - '11ran (at! p: r" Irv-'-.- r..-.- gamma?: ii, n?i?i??fh Fa 31: ?ying, - 3 .51511if: r13 11-.- Ti . '13 till-I ?Fa I 'r-r an: a . I .IE Ail-Fl Ihl-{-If] If. v?I F1: I'll?- .. In HERE: 3: i3 mar-?r; f'nium? ESE. a; ?mm {ft-19;" 51151361}; {jug Ti?l' Watth I: Gama! at him GTMO SJA 99 via aata aa a'aa a aha? haa a3? war aa Erma j; ayaa.? 12:3, Guam-{Ea a1 aaraar?E ?a afar-a iraa aa'ii a? aha a ail-Haitian; a a?aa ?raa anal?; af tiara bias: aa? Whaai aariaai I 693 Eyiag Ga tha- daa'a aalfr, 3.5. i aa?aad aa - . . Eaagaa ihaa as if awai?iaa. II a PH. LET. In tha MAEN furthar aatad that 6931a aalaa appaarad La ha darkaa aa i?fraara than '23. Fiaaliy, MASH Mala that ha ISM 693 ?aliaa an the iaa?a day I waakad an Alpha i'?rrfaalaH Lb.) aiatad that whaa ha athaa team ara?aad at Atpiaa Bi.aak_., fig} had baa-a aa'appad aa a madiaal baakbaard. .ESN waa Hana. af 693:3 aanaa had fa?aa affaha Ii i '1 . aa arm aata taa and, 171011an haa araa a-aa aaf?ff g?ww?dMW-h?h??I - - mama USO {T'a?a {fa} a1 3am GTMO SJA 100 ii ieiter ef ee ei?iiee'e tiae ?iei?USC Cami; i iniee'i' ie. Ejei'ep i 1i3ie-eereei M?eiC} {Temp 1 ei?? file Kim ?ipiie Bieek .f'ii eipi?ie meek MAE ?iphe Bleek Hie} Mphe Bieek Geere MAE i-?iiphe Bieei: {ill?i?d ii. i interviewed the feilewieg Jeint Teek Be}; fee eed regee?eg Camp 1 end the ef 30135:: USC Deputy Cemeie?der, Jen-ire: Ce'eep Cerep 1 in Cherge if? Genie i Offieer ie {Sheree Hemp i Leederf?pe Chief 3? {Temp 1 i?ietee? Leader Ce'eip i Mir-i Camp i Sergeant ef the Geere EU ?eeip i Bieek Gee?i Mid Camp 1 Sal-i}: 'Pee?i Guard Me?- 3. The inleteiewe averaged ee hem and heif ?ed twe heme, preparing eepiee ef my netee ee ieeg ee the interviewee. 'peniens ef ietewiewe ere a?eehed ten {hie repert, end I ?led with yeer Staff Judge ill}? eempiete netee 1e: interview The eheve pereen?ei previeied ef?eiei etetemenle whiei?i ere attached 1e thie repert. ii: i reeievee the 111095 Camp Delta SEEP {Exhibit whiee wee eli?eei. en the eight, ei' 9f ?21396. i elee reviewed. time 21305., ?e Camp Delee?e ere te tii?ie i?eg'nei?t. The ?eiee i U55 ixiie ieg fee the Cami? .rl 'er'l'?d-InTeen-i: ei Lei-ieeiireiei-eei e._e ie ee?eei?e ee Ere; ee. 5 f?f?ei??i?e?i eii?i??e e3: eii- i .3 HL .321 . "wulFifi? .ih?E?-iEilg?imiifi? in Ee ?9 jei'ii: .et-?Li? ii} ii- gig-Hg: i} 5? 3 I 5' i355? ?e ?fe thigh, L'e 353' eijer. *3 :d 1:15.? GTMO SJA 101 . 1b; 1 .- II I I i-_I1 r? If l'u the ereerdee er. erret tee tiretetert- er trrerr rs", a; we beeree gr. US- Here-er Sereteer rte? triererer't 31f} errtt rte eeqeeL Sert'teer He}? Err-pert elf :15 Jet}? 33%. ?Ef?ire irreitre?ree NCIE E-rthi?eite ?+1143 end the igetter E?t?li? Erri?r??te trivia-?til irrettrde e. ef N?t? eeEri?erte ee te thie. repert, I etee ree'retred fer the free} etepejr reperte reenter try the ?ttlee e? the ?rmed Medte? firmed ef Pethe?te t?eryieed {Exhibite 1+1 end examined Exhibit 12?} MUS. Navel Crirrtirtre} Serriem ?Geerrterreree Bey Repert et? {ne?eetigetiee {:i?terireh? 13$ Jeiy 20%. NCLS Exhihit 12% ie ertt?r?er} {it} ?Review ef 30F "fer {Temp Delta, Thie exhibit preridee nie?rtitierrs rind eeplenetierte ef the eertterrte that te?i be erref?i re fer reede-re errfarn?ier ith (Temp Bette eperetierte. the intereet ef eerreiee I errtit beeie er-rpiiee?ene freer e1}? te free: but MCI-S Exhibit 1?29 15 etteehed herete {Exhibit Kr}; 3 I leeited the three te ebt?ie, review, and edditrerre?t materiel reteverrt te this. etteh ere ef? etek errteii. I dieerree these tee-truer: eeperateljr in the 9. the eve?ebie were srr?ieient te arrewer yettr queetierre. Predictably e, number ef differ ether in Herr-eutreterttret tr'rrye. Fer erternpie, meet ei? events agree with ether irr reietive eeqrrerree, but were? in the ereete? timing; email}; tire eeriatrerre ere irreigrri?eent. A5 e?e?rer ertemp'ie, the eletemeete e-f guard eer?r?ree identi?er-r ef pereerre during their initiet he the emergent: en the night of W18 5 urre. Where there are eignr? ee?t the}; are re letirely few-Hi ede sure te irrelude emeeg the ?ndirrge ef feel the fattest poee'ihie direet quetee, if ef the GTMO SJA 102