! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!! ! ! Millennial!Entertainment! Preferences!Study! Final!Report!8!July!2016!! Jane!Bokunewicz,!PhD!! Assistant!Professor!! ! ! Supported!by!! Rummy!Pandit,!MBA,!LPD,!CHA! Executive!Director!!!!!! ! ! 1.! ! 2.!!!! ! 3.!!!! ! 4.!!!! ! 5.!!!! !! 6.!!!! ! 7.!!!! ! 8.!!!! ! 9.!!! ! 10.!!! ! 11.!! ! 12.!! ! 13.!! ! 14.!!! Contents! ' Executive!Summary!……………………………………………………………………! Page!3!! Introduction!………………………………………………………………………………!! Page!4! Methodology!…………………………………………………..…………………………! Page!6! Demographics!!..…………………………………….………….………………………..! Page!8! Activities!………………………………...…...…………………………….………………!! Page!11! Percentage!of!Budget!………………………………………………………..………..! Page!14! Accommodations!…….………………….………………………………………..…....!! Page!17! Length!of!Stay!and!Planning!Horizon!…..……………...……………….….….! Page!19! Gambling!Behavior!and!Perceptions!8!Slots!……………....………..….…...! Page!20! Gambling!Behavior!8!Table!Games!……………….……………………….……! Page!24! Video!Gamers!and!Gambling!Perceptions!and!Behavior!………….….! Page!26! Atlantic!City!as!a!Destination!………………………………………….…………! Page!29! Appendix!A!–!Focus!Group!Questions!! Appendix!B!–!Survey!Instrument! ! ! ! ! ! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ! 2! Executive'Summary' ' This!study!focused!on!identifying!the!entertainment,!accommodation!and!amenity! preferences!of!the!millennial!generation!as!well!as!video!game!and!casino!gambling! behavior.!!It!included!two!focus!groups!and!a!quantitative!survey.!! • Activities!! o 667!surveys!were!collected!with!503!completing!the!entire!survey!! o Respondents!were!from!22!states!with!most!from!NJ,!NY!and!PA! o Millennials!view!drinking!activities!as!more!important!than!non8millennials!! o Public!Transportation!is!important!to!millenials!! o Gambling!was!more!important!to!non8millenials!(42%!to!21%)! o Casual!restaurants!were!important!to!both!groups!(80%)! o Millennials!reported!spending!only!8.5%!of!their!total!budget!on!gambling! compared!to!23.5%!of!non8millennials! o If!money!was!not!a!concern!50%!of!millennials!would!increase!spending!on! bars!and!nightclubs!compared!to!17%!non8millennials!! o 35%!of!millennials!would!increase!spending!on!gambling!compared!to!50%! non8millennials!! • Accommodations! o Free!Wi8Fi!and!Midscale!hotels!were!the!most!important!considerations!in!both! groups! o Millennials!cited!Economy!hotels!as!important!and!non8millennials!cited!Luxury! hotels!! o Millennials!are!more!open!to!the!sharing!economy.!!28%!of!millennials!cited! Airbnb!as!important!compared!to!6%!of!non8millennials!! o 33%!of!both!groups!listed!“all!inclusive”!pricing!as!important!! • Gambling!Behavior!! o 44%!of!millennials!play!slot!machines!compared!to!72%!of!non8millennials!! o More!Millennials!prefer!to!play!with!family!and!friends,!more!non8millennials! prefer!to!play!alone! o All!groups!expressed!an!interest!in!adding!an!element!of!skill!to!slots! o 40%!of!respondents!who!do!not!currently!play!slots!would!play!if!there!was!an! element!of!skill,!38!%!if!they!could!play!in!a!group! o 57%!of!millennials!play!table!games!compared!to!58%!of!non8millennials! • Video!Games!! o 38%!of!millenials!play!video!games!compared!to!29%!of!non8millennials!! o Millennials!prefer!shooter!games!and!non8millenials!puzzle!and!casual!games!! o Those!who!play!video!games!are!slightly!more!interested!in!slots!with!an! element!of!skill!! • Atlantic!City!as!a!Destination! o 84%!of!millennials!view!AC!positively!or!neutral!vs.!89%!non8millennials!! o 91%!of!those!who!have!visited!AC!view!it!positively!or!neutral!compared!to!74%! of!those!who!haven’t!visited!! o AC!was!too!far!from!home!for!many!respondents!followed!by!too!expensive,!lack! of!diversity!in!activities!and!negative!reputation! ! 3! Introduction! ' According!to!the!Pew!Research!Center,!the!millennial!generation!(born!roughly! between!1980!and!2000)!has!now!surpassed!the!baby!boomers!(born!1946!–!1964)!in! size1!(see!below).!!The!gap!is!projected!to!widen!at!a!sharp!pace!each!year!into!the! future.!This!is!of!importance!to!the!casino!industry!because!millennial’s!entertainment! preferences!are!different!than!the!baby!boomers,!which!have!been!the!primary!target! market!of!the!industry.!! ! ! The!millennial!generation!is!demonstrating!different!behavior!regarding! casino!gambling!than!Baby!Boomers!and!the!Silent!Generation!(born!1928!–!1945).!! For!example,!a!recent!Las!Vegas!Convention!and!Visitor!Bureau!survey2!revealed!the! following! • Only!63%!of!millennials!that!Visited!Las!Vegas!in!2014!gambled! • 78%!Baby!Boomers!! • 87%!Silent!Generation!! • 42%!of!millennials!used!Social!Media!to!Plan!trip!! • 18%!Baby!Boomers!! • 51%!Planned!their!trip!1!month!in!advance!! • 39%!of!Baby!Boomers!! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1!http://www.pewresearch.org/fact8tank/2016/04/25/millennials8overtake8baby8 boomers/! 2!http://www.hotelnewsresource.com/pdf15/HVS1103151.pdf! ! 4! ! ! The!Levenson!Institute!of!Gaming,!Hospitality!and!Tourism!(LIGHT)!has! received!funding!from!four!casinos,!including!Borgata!Hotel!Casino!and!Spa,! Tropicana!Casino!and!Resort,!Resorts!Casino!Hotel,!Harrah’s!Resort!and!the!Casino! Reinvestment!Development!Authority!(CRDA)!to!research!the!entertainment! preferences!of!the!millennial!generation.!The!study!consisted!of!two!focus!groups!and! an!on8line!survey!distributed!through!social!media.!!The!goal!of!the!study!was!to!help! understand!the!changing!preferences!and!behavior!of!this!important!cohort.!! Specifically,!the!study!focused!on!identifying!the!entertainment,!accommodation,!and! amenity!preferences!of!the!millennial!generation!as!well!as!video!game!and!casino! gambling!behavior.!!The!study!sought!to!not!only!understand!current!preferences!and! behavior!of!millennials!but!also!to!understand!how!their!behavior!may!change!with! technology!enhancements!and!increases!in!disposable!income.!!! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ! 5! Methodology' ' The!methodology!for!the!study!was!developed!using!feedback!from! participating!casino!executives!and!focus!groups!of!men!and!women!in!the!age!group! of!the!millennial!generation.!!! ' Two!focus!groups!were!conducted!to!gain!an!understanding!of!the!thought! processes!of!millennials!in!deciding!on!single!day!entertainment!experiences!and! overnight!or!multi8night!travel.!!One!group!was!comprised!of!participants!in!their! early!20’s!and!the!other!late!20’s!and!early!30’s.!!!The!groups!were!asked!a!series!of! open8ended!questions!designed!to!generate!spontaneous!comments!about!choosing! entertainment!options.!!(See!appendix!A).!!The!information!gathered!in!the!focus! group!meetings!was!used!to!develop!the!questions!for!the!on8line!survey.!!! ' Some!key!discoveries!revealed!in!the!focus!groups!were!as!follows:! • • • • • • • • • • • Dinner!and!drinks!seemed!to!be!a!very!popular!choice!for!entertainment! among!the!late!20’s!early!30’s!group! Dancing!and!nightclub!was!a!popular!choice!among!early!20’s! Gambling!was!not!mentioned!by!participants!until!they!were!specifically!asked!! Availability!of!public!transportation!was!very!important!in!arranging!a!night! out!because!of!concerns!about!drinking!and!driving! Respondents!wanted!to!spend!the!least!amount!on!hotel!accommodations!and! more!on!entertainment!experiences!! “All!inclusive”!was!raised!as!a!consideration!in!travel!arrangements! Looking!for!destinations!with!multiple!entertainment!options! Video!gamers!thought!slot!machines!were!boring!and!simplistic!compared!to! what!they!experience! Video!games!can!be!classified!into!different!types!of!games!and!gamers!often! have!a!preference!of!one!type!of!game!! An!element!of!skill!would!make!slot!machines!more!attractive! Because!of!information!overload!on!social!media!sites,!a!very!attractive! incentive!and!advertisement!must!be!used!to!get!people!to!complete!the!survey! ! An!on8line!survey!was!created!based!on!the!information!obtained!in!the!focus! groups!using!the!on8line!survey!tool!Survey!Monkey.!!(See!appendix!B).!!!It!consisted! of!27!questions!with!logic!to!skip!irrelevant!questions!depending!on!respondent’s! answers.!! ! ! ! ! ! 6! ! The!survey!link!was!distributed!on!Social!Media!offering!an!incentive!of!one! entry!into!a!sweepstakes!for!an!Apple!Watch.!!An!additional!entry!was!offered!for! those!who!shared!the!survey.!!The!post!was!initiated!on!the!Stockton!University! Facebook!Page!in!the!visitors!post!section.!!It!was!shared!on!the!Facebook!pages!of! LIGHT,!the!Stockton!Career!Center,!the!participating!casinos!and!various!friends!and! family!of!people!involved!in!the!research!project.!!It!was!also!posted!on!Twitter.!! Facebook!and!Twitter!ads!were!purchased!to!promote!the!post.!! ! Because!this!analysis!studied!preferences!of!many!activities!only!available!to! persons!older!than!21,!for!purposes!of!this!study,!millennials!are!classified!as!those! persons!between!the!ages!of!21!and!35!as!of!2016.!!Non8millenials!are!those!persons! over!the!age!of!35!as!of!2016.!! ' ' ' ! 7! Demographics' ! 667!surveys!were!collected!between!May!9!and!June!27,!2016.!!503! participants!completed!the!entire!survey!including!demographic!data,!which!was!at! the!end!of!the!survey.!!!Survey!respondents!were!from!22!states!with!the!largest! number!of!responses!from!New!Jersey,!followed!by!New!York!and!Pennsylvania.!!169! surveys!did!not!include!a!valid!zip!code!or!zip!code!was!not!entered.!The!following! charts!show!number!of!respondents!by!state,!gender,!age,!education,!relationship! status,!personal!income!and!race.!! Number!of! State!! Respondents!! New!Jersey! 256! Blank!or!invalid! 169! New!York!! 92! Pennsylvania!! 56! Massachusetts!! 26! Florida!! 15! DC!! 6! Maryland! 6! California! 6! Washington! 5! Delaware!! 4! Connecticut!! 4! North!Carolina! 4! Illinois! 4! Michigan!! 3! Texas!! 3! Arizona! 2! Iowa! 1! Missouri! 1! Louisiana! 1! New!Hampshire! 1! Maine! 1! Wisconsin! 1! Total!! 667! ' ' ' ' ' ! 8! Gender'' 510'respondents' Male!! 34%! Female!! 66%! ' Age'' Millennials'shown'in'Blue'' 200! 150! 100! 50! 0! Number!of!People! Not! Under!21! Reported!! 160! 29! 21825! 26830! 31835! Over!35! 181! 87! 49! 161! ' Education'' 503'respondents'' 300! 250! 200! 150! 100! 50! 0! Number!of!People!! ! High! School! 77! Associate! Bachelors! Masters!! Doctorate!! Degree!! Degree! 61! 257! 74! 23! Other!! 11! ' 9! Relationship'Status' 503'Respondents'' ' 200! 150! 100! 50! 0! Number!of!People!! Single!! Married!! Engaged!! 172! 168! 19! In!a! Its! Relationship!! Complicated!! 134! 10! ' Personal'Income'' 493'Respondents' $150,000!or!more!! $100,000!8!$149,999! $90,000!8!$99,999! $80,000!8!$89,999! $70,000!8!$79,999! $60,000!8!$69,999! $50,000!8!$59,999! $40,000!8!$49,999! $30,000!8!$39,999! $20,000!8!$29,999! Less!than!$20,000! Number!of!People!! 0! 20! 40! 60! 80! 100! 120! 140! 160! ' Race'' 505'Respondents' 500! 400! 300! 200! 100! 0! White!! Number!of!People!! 412! ! African! Hispanic!! American!! 24! 15! Asian!! Pacilic! Islander! Other!! 43! 1! 10! ' ' ! 10! Activities' ! ! Questions!about!the!importance!of!activities!in!planning!entertainment! experiences!revealed!some!interesting!differences!between!millennials!and!non8 millennials.!! ! ! Millennials!in!the!study!clearly!felt!that!drinking!activities!including!bars,! lounges,!nightclubs,!and!happy!hours!were!more!important!than!did!their!non8 millennial!counterparts!(See!Table!1).!!!Because!of!the!importance!of!drinking! activities,!it!is!not!surprising!that!more!millennials!rated!public!transportation!as! important!(33%)!vs.!non8millennials(11%).!This!supports!comments!made!by! millennial!focus!group!participants!who!felt!that!public!transportation!was!important! because!of!concerns!about!not!drinking!and!driving.!!!! ! ! Conversely,!gambling!was!more!important!to!non8millennials.!42%!of!non8 millennials!rated!gambling!as!an!important!activity!compared!to!only!21%!of! millennials.!!Out!of!the!list!of!28!activities!in!the!survey,!gambling!ranked!21st!!in! importance!for!millennials!and!7th!in!importance!for!non8millennials.!! ! ! Casual!restaurants!were!the!activity!most!often!cited!as!important!by!both! groups!(approximately!80%!of!respondents).!!This!ranked!first!in!the!list!of!28! activities.!Beaches!also!ranked!high!in!importance!to!both!groups!with!57%!of! millennials!and!65%!of!non8millennials!listing!it!as!important.!!Beaches!ranked!4th!in! importance!for!millennials!and!2nd!in!importance!for!non8millennials.!!! ! ! Results!were!similar!for!the!importance!of!activities!for!overnight!or!multi8 night!entertainment!experiences!(See!Table!2).!!! ! ! The!overwhelming!importance!of!casual!restaurants!by!both!groups!is! important!to!note!for!casinos!and!support!businesses!when!selecting!restaurant! tenants!or!when!designing!their!own!restaurant!concepts.!!Casinos!who!provide! complimentary!food!and!beverage!to!regular!customers!often!favor!fine!dining!but!it! is!important!to!keep!in!mind!the!popularity!of!casual!restaurants!in!order!to!attract! new!customers.!! ! ! Atlantic!City’s!Jitney!system!is!a!unique!form!of!affordable,!reliable!public! transportation!that!could!potentially!be!promoted!to!attract!millenials.!!!Additionally! it!is!important!for!the!city!to!recognize!the!popular!ride!sharing!service!Uber!as!a! legitimate!public!transportation!system!that!is!important!in!order!to!attract! millennials.!!City!officials!should!be!conscious!of!this!importance!and!work!with!Uber! to!allow!them!to!operate!efficiently!in!the!city!without!creating!barriers!to!entry.!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 11! Table!1.!! What'activities'are'important'to'you' when'planning'a'day'or'night'out'for' entertainment?'' 317'millenials'K'161'over'35' ' Casual!Restaurants! Bars!and!Lounges! Happy!Hours!! Beaches!! Concerts!! Fine!Dining!! Shopping!! Night!Clubs! Beach/Pool!Bars!! Sports!Bars!! Public!Transportation!! Museums!! Live!Theater! Sporting!Events! Hiking!! Cultural!Events!! Over!35!! Millennials!! Amusement!Parks!! Comedy!Club!! Wine!Bars!! Quick!Service!Restaurants! Gambling!! Camping!! Art!Galleries!! Day!Spas! LGBTQ!Clubs! Video!Gaming!Events! LGBTQ!Events! Hunting!! 0%! 10%!20%!30%!40%!50%!60%!70%!80%!90%! ! ! 12! Table!2.!! What'activities'are'important'to'you' when'planning'an'overnight/multiKnight' entertainment'experience?' 317'millennials'K'161'over'35' ' Casual!Restaurants! Bars!and!Lounges! Beaches!! Fine!Dining!! Happy!Hours!! Shopping!! Concerts!! Beach/Pool!Bars!! Night!Clubs! Museums!! Quick!Service!Restaurants! Sports!Bars!! Cultural!Events!! Public!Transportation!! Sporting!Events! Amusement!Parks!! Over!35! Millennials!! Live!Theater! Wine!Bars!! Comedy!Club!! Hiking!! Day!Spas! Gambling!! Camping!! Art!Galleries!! Golf! LGBTQ!Clubs! Video!Gaming!Events! LGBTQ!Events! Hunting!! 0%! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! 60%! 70%! 80%! 90%! ! ! 13! Percent'of'Budget' ' ' Feedback!received!from!casino!executives!indicated!a!desire!to!understand! whether!or!not!any!generational!differences!in!spending!patterns!may!be!the!result!of! having!more!disposable!income!in!later!years.!!To!try!to!better!understand!the! differences,!survey!respondents!were!asked!to!describe!the!current!percent!of!their! entertainment!budget!that!they!spend!on!transportation,!hotel,!dining,!bars,!shopping! and!gambling.!!They!were!subsequently!asked!“if!money!were!not!a!concern,!on!which! activities!would!you!increase!spending?”! ! ! On!average,!the!highest!percentage!of!current!budget!was!spent!on!hotel! expenses!followed!by!dining!for!both!groups!(See!Table!3).!Millennials!reported! spending!the!lowest!percentage!of!their!budget!on!gambling!(8.5%)!compared!to! 23.5%!for!non8millennials.!!! ! Table!3.! When'you'visit'a'destination'what'percent'of' your'budget'is'spent'on'each'of'the' following?' Average'is'shown' 317'Millennials'K'161'Over'35' 40.0%! 35.0%! 30.0%! 25.0%! 20.0%! 15.0%! 10.0%! 5.0%! 0.0%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Transportati on!! Hotel!! Dining!! Bars/Night! Clubs! Shopping!! Gambling!! Millennials! 15.2%! 35.9%! 23.3%! 12.9%! 9.2%! 8.5%! Over!35!! 14.5%! 32.0%! 24.3%! 12.5%! 12.9%! 23.5%! ! ' 14! ' ! Generational!differences!were!also!found!regarding!where!respondents!said! they!would!increase!spending!if!money!was!not!a!concern!(See!Table!4).!!50%!of! millennials!said!they!would!increase!spending!on!Bars!and!Nightclubs!compared!to! only!17%!of!non8millennials.!!One!encouraging!finding!for!the!gaming!industry!is!that! 35%!of!millennials!reported!that!they!would!increase!their!spending!on!gambling.!! Although!this!is!still!less!then!the!50%!of!non8millennials!who!said!they!would!spend! more!on!gambling,!it!suggests!that!this!generation!has!the!potential!to!increase!their! gambling!spending!as!their!earnings!increase!as!they!mature.!! ! Table!4.!! If'money'was'not'a'concern'on'which' activities'would'you'increase'spending?'' 317'Millennials'K'161'Over'35' 90%! 80%! 70%! 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Transportati on!! Gambling!! Bars!and! Nightclubs!! Shopping!! Hotel!! Dining! Millennials!! 26%! 35%! 50%! 63%! 69%! 77%! Over!35! 16%! 50%! 17%! 54%! 57%! 65%! ! 15! ' ! When!responses!to!this!question!are!further!broken!down!into!narrower!age! ranges!it!seems!that!the!percentage!indicating!they!would!spend!more!on!gambling! increases!in!the!higher!age!groups!(See!Table!5).!!!55%!of!respondents!between!31!–! 35!years!of!age!indicated!they!would!increase!spending!on!gambling!if!money!was!not! a!concern!compared!to!33%!for!those!between!26!and!30!and!30%!for!those!between! 21!and!25.!! ' Table!5.!! Would'spend'more'on'gambling'if' money'was'not'a'concern' ' ' 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! Would!spend!more!on! gambling!! 21!8!25! 26!8!30! 31!8!35! over!35! 30%! 33%! 55%! 50%! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ! ' 16! Accommodations' ' ' Both!groups!responded!similarly!in!that!free!WIFI!was!the!number!one! accommodation/amenity!most!cited!as!important!when!planning!an!overnight/multi8 night!experience,!followed!by!midscale!hotels!(See!Table!6).!!Generational!differences! were!found!however!in!the!number!of!respondents!citing!luxury!and!economy!hotels! as!important.!!Economy!hotels!are!more!important!to!millennials!and!luxury!hotels! are!more!important!to!non8millennials!over!35.!! ! ! Millennials!seem!more!open!to!the!sharing!economy!than!their!non8millennial! counterparts!over!age!35.!!28%!of!millennials!cited!Airbnb,!the!apartment!sharing! app,!as!important!compared!to!only!6%!of!non8millennials.!!Public!transportation!was! also!viewed!as!more!important!by!millennials.!!35%!of!millennials!cited!it!as!an! important!consideration!when!planning!an!overnight!experience!compared!to!only! 7%!of!non8millennials.!!!! ! ! One!interesting!finding!regarding!accommodations!was!the!percentage!of! respondents!in!both!groups!(33%)!that!listed!“all!inclusive!resort”!as!important!when! selecting!a!destination.!!The!“all!inclusive”!concept!was!discussed!in!the!focus!groups! with!several!participants!saying!they!would!be!more!likely!to!gamble!if!they!were!at!a! location!with!all!inclusive!pricing!because!they!wouldn’t!have!to!worry!about!having! enough!money!for!other!activities.!This!is!a!pricing!strategy!that!is!not!typically! utilized!in!US!casino!resorts.!!All8inclusive!pricing!could!be!a!potential!opportunity!for! the!industry!to!explore!to!attract!new!customers.!! ! ! There!is!an!opportunity!for!the!popularity!of!Airbnb!to!encourage!development! in!Atlantic!City.!!!In!other!cities!like!Boston,!San!Francisco!and!others,!investors!buy! condos!and!apartments!and!renovate!them!with!the!specific!purpose!of!renting!them! on!Airbnb.!!Additionally!private!home!8owners!may!renovate!a!room!in!their!home!for! the!same!purpose.!!The!investment!and!renovation!of!older!buildings!would!be!a! benefit!to!Atlantic!City,!as!well!as!making!additional!rooms!available!for!visitors! during!peak!days!when!the!city!is!at!capacity.!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 17! Table!6.!! What'accommodations/amenities'are'important'to' you'when'selecting'a'location'for'an'overnight/ multiple'night'entertainment'experience?'' 317'millennials'K'161'over'35' Free!WiFi! Midscale!Hotels!! Parking!! Economy!Hotels!! Public!Transportation! All!Inclusive!Resort! Over!35!! Outdoor!Pools!! Millennials!! Indoor!Pools!! Luxury!Hotels!! AirBnB! Short!Driving!Distance! Bed!and!Breakfast! WiFi! 0%! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! 60%! 70%! 80%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ' ! 18! Length'of'Stay' ' ! The!most!often!cited!typical!length!of!stay!for!a!multi8night!trip!by!both!groups! (61%)!is!two!nights!(See!Table!7).!!Slightly!more!millennials!reported!a!one8night!stay! as!typical,!(i.e.!44%!compared!to!32%!of!non8millennials).!'' ' !!Table!7.!! Typical'length'of'Stay'' 317'Millennials'K'161'over'35' 70%! 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! One!Night!! Two! Nights!! Three! Nights!! Four! Nights!! One!Week! More!than! One!Week! Millennials! 44%! 61%! 23%! 6%! 8%! 3%! Over!35! 32%! 61%! 16%! 6%! 10%! 1%! ! ! ! The!two!groups!responded!similarly!with!regard!to!how!far!in!advance!they! make!arrangements!for!an!overnight/multi8night!trip!(See!Table!8).!!!Most! respondents!in!each!group!make!arrangements!one!month!or!more!in!advance.!! ! Table!8.!! How'far'in'advance'do'you'typically' make'arrangements'for'an'overnight/ multiKnight'trip?'' 317'Millennials'K'161'over'35' 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! ! Less!than!1! week!! 182!Weeks!! 283!Weeks!! 1!month!! >!1!month!! Millennials!! 4%! 16%! 22%! 25%! 33%! Over!35!! 7%! 13%! 19%! 21%! 39%! 19! Gambling'Behavior'and'Perceptions'K'Slots! ' ! Although!gambling!may!be!considered!low!in!importance!and!a!small! percentage!of!budget!for!millennials,!it!is!encouraging!to!note!that!44%!of!them!still! report!playing!slot!machines!(See!Table!9).!Of!some!concern!is!that!while!this!is!a! fairly!high!percentage,!it!is!substantially!lower!then!the!72%!of!non8millennials!over! age!35!in!the!study!who!report!playing!slots.!! ! !!!!!!!Table!9.!! Plays'Slot'Machines' 126'unspeciUied'K'29'under'21'K'317'millennials'K'161'over'35'' 80%! 70%! 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! Percent! Unspecilied! Under!21! Millennials! Over!35! 50%! 10%! 45%! 72%! ' ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ' ! 20! ! Little!variation!was!found!in!the!types!of!slot!machines!preferred!by!the! different!generations!(See!Table!10).!Of!those!respondents!who!report!playing!slot! machines,!the!most!popular!type!of!slot!machine!in!both!groups!is!penny!slots.!!86%! of!millennials!report!playing!pennies!and!70%!of!non8millennials.!!!Quarters!were!also! popular!with!both!groups!but!slightly!more!popular!with!non8millennials.!63%!of! millennials!and!72%!of!non8millennials!reported!that!they!play!quarters.!!Millennials! seem!slightly!more!interested!in!TV!or!movie!themed!slots:!50%!of!millennials!play! TV!or!movie!themed!slots!compared!to!39%!of!non8millennials.!! ' Table!10.!! What'types'of'slot'machines'do'you' play?'' 144'Millennials'K'116'Over'35''' Penny! Quarter!! TV!or!Movie!Theme! Video!! Bonus!Round!! Over!35!! Dollar!! Millennials! Reel!! Poker!! High!Denom! Community!! 0%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 20%! 40%! 60%! ' 80%! 100%! ' 21! ! There!is!a!notable!difference!in!the!way!that!each!generation!prefers!to!play! slot!machines!(See!Table!11).!!Of!those!who!report!playing!slots,!more!millennials! prefer!to!play!with!friends!and!family!while!more!non8millennials!prefer!to!play!alone.!! This!suggests!that!a!social!aspect!to!gaming!is!desirable.!!This!is!further!supported!in! the!response!to!the!question!about!emerging!slot!machine!design!changes.!! ! Table!11.!! How'do'you'prefer'to'play'slot' machines?' 144'Millennials'K'116'Over'35''' 100%! 80%! 60%! 40%! 20%! 0%! Alone!! Friends!or! Family! Tournaments!! Community! Games!! Millennials!! 48%! 83%! 4%! 1%! Over!35! 70%! 62%! 11%! 0%! ! ! ! All!groups!expressed!an!interest!in!slot!machines!with!an!element!of!skill! and/or!a!social!dimension!(See!Table!12).!Millennials!had!the!highest!percentage!of! respondents!expressing!this!interest.!!!Lesser!interest!was!expressed!in!interacting! with!a!game!using!a!joystick!and!a!simpler!design.!! ! Table!12.!! Would'you'play'slot'machines'if'they' had'any'of'the'following'features?' 160'unspeciUied'K'317'millennials'K'161'over'35' Element!of!skill! Play!with!group!! Unspecilied!! Play!against!others! Over!35!! Joystick!! Millennials!! Simpler!Design! 0%! ! ! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! Perhaps!one!of!the!most!interesting!and!encouraging!findings!of!the!study!is! 22! that!of!those!who!currently!do!not!play!slot!machines,!a!high!percentage!would!play! slots!if!they!had!these!new!design!features.!!40%!of!respondents!who!do!not!currently! play!slot!machines!reported!that!they!would!play!if!the!games!had!an!element!of!skill.! 33%!would!play!if!they!could!play!in!a!group!and!28%!would!play!if!they!could!play! against!others.!!! ! Table!13.! 307'respondents'who'do'not'currently' play'slots,'would'play'if'the'slot' included:''' Element!of!skill! Play!with!group!! Play!against!others! Joystick!! Simpler!Design! 0%! ! ! ! 5%! 10%! 15%! 20%! 25%! 30%! 35%! 40%! 45%! ! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 23! Gambling'Perceptions'and'Behavior'–'Table'Games' ! ! More!millennials!reported!playing!table!games!than!playing!slot!machines!(See! Table!14).!!!57%!of!millennials!in!the!study!reported!playing!tables!compared!to!44%! of!millennials!who!reported!playing!slots.!!Although!there!was!a!large!difference! between!millennials!and!non8millennials!in!their!slot!play!behavior!they!responded! similarly!in!regards!to!playing!tables.!58%!of!non8millennials!over!35!in!the!study! report!playing!tables!compared!to!57%!of!millennials.!!! ' !!!!!!!Table!14.! Plays'Casino'Games' 160'unspeciUied'K'29'under'21'K'317'millennials'K'161'Over'35'' 70%! 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! Percent!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Unspecilied! Under!21!! Millennials!! Over!35!! 36%! 31%! 57%! 58%! ' ! 24! ! The!most!popular!table!games!among!both!groups!are!Black!Jack!and!Roulette! followed!by!Poker!(See!Table!15).!!!Millennials!seem!more!open!to!playing!electronic! style!table!games.!28%!of!millennials!who!play!table!games!report!playing!electronic! table!games!compared!to!only!14%!of!non8millennials.!There!also!is!a!notable! difference!in!the!generations!regarding!fantasy!sports!with!25%!of!millennials! reporting!they!play!vs.!only!14%!of!non8millennials.!! ! Table!15.!! Of'Those'Who'Play'Tables'' 182'millennials'K'94'over'35' Black!Jack!! Roulette! Poker!! Electronic!Table!Games!! Fantasy!Sports!! Over!35!! Craps!! Millennnials!! Sports!Betting!! Big!Wheel!! Internet!Gaming!! Baccarat! 0%! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! 60%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 25! Video'Gamers'Behavior'and'Perceptions' ' ! !There!is!a!slight!variation!between!the!age!groups!concerning!whether!or!not! they!play!video!games!(See!Table!16).!!38%!of!millennials!in!the!study!report!playing! video!games,!compared!to!29%!of!non8millennials!over!35,!and!35%!for!those!under! 21.! ! Table'16.'' Do'you'play'multiKplayer'video' games?' 160'unspeciUied'K'29'under'21'K'316'millennials'K'160'over'35' ! 45%! 40%! 35%! 30%! 25%! 20%! 15%! 10%! 5%! 0%! Percent!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Unspecilied!! Under!21! Millennials!! Over!35!! 41%! 35%! 38%! 29%! ' 26! ! Although!there!is!only!a!slight!variation!among!the!generations!regarding! whether!or!not!they!play!video!games!there!is!a!notable!difference!in!the!types!of! video!games!that!they!play(See!Table!17).!!The!most!popular!style!of!game!for! millennials!is!first!person!shooter!with!65%!of!millennials!who!play!video!games! reporting!that!they!play!this!style!of!!game!compared!to!only!23%!of!non8millennials! over!age!35.!!The!most!popular!game!styles!among!non8millenials!are!puzzle!games! and!casual!games.!!This!variation!is!relevant!to!game!designers!in!considering!slot! design!of!future!skill!based!and!social!slot!machines.!!! ' !!!!Table!17.!! What'types'of'video'games'do'you' play?' 120'Milennials'K'48'Over'35'' First!Person!Shooter!! Role!Playing!! Casual!Games!! Puzzle!Games!! Third!Person!Shooter! Multiplayer!Online!Battle!! Over!35!! Millennials! Simulation!! Real!Time!Strategy! MMO! Sandbox!!! 0%! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! 60%! 70%! 80%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ' ! 27! ! It!is!interesting!to!note!that!those!respondents!who!reported!playing!video! games!seemed!slightly!more!interested!in!games!of!skill!and!social!style!games!then! those!who!do!not!play!video!games!(See!Table!18).!! ! ' Table!18.! Would'you'play'slots'if'they'had' any'of'the'following'features?' 244'play'video'games'K'421'do'not'' ! Element!of!Skill!! Play!against!others!! Doesn't!Play!Video! Games!! Play!with!a!Group!! Plays!Video!Games!! Interact!with!Joystick!! Simpler!Design! 0%! 10%! 20%! 30%! 40%! 50%! ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ! ' 28! ' Atlantic'City'as'a'Destination'' ' ' A!majority!of!respondents!in!the!study!have!visited!Atlantic!City!in!the!past! year!with!the!highest!percentage!(81%)!in!the!non8millennial!over!35!group!(See! Table!19).!! ! ! Table!19.!! Have'you'visited'Atlantic'City'in' the'past'year?'' 29!under!21!*!316!millennials!*!161!over!35! 100%! 80%! 60%! 40%! 20%! 0%! Under!21!! Millennials!! Over!35! 48%! 63%! 81%! Yes! ' ' ! A!very!high!percentage!of!respondents!in!both!groups!view!Atlantic!City! positively!as!a!destination(See!Table!20).!!84%%!of!millennials!and!89%!of!non8 millennials!over!35!have!a!positive,!very!positive!or!neutral!view!of!Atlantic!City.!!!! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!Table!20.!! How'do'you'view'Atlantic'City'as' an'entertainment'destination?' 316'Millennials'K'161'Over'35'' 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! ! Very! Positive!! Positive!! Neutral!! Negative!! Very! Negative!! Millennials!! 12%! 33%! 39%! 13%! 3%! Over!35!! 20%! 43%! 26%! 9%! 3%! ' 29! ' ! Respondents!who!have!visited!Atlantic!City!in!the!last!year!view!the!city!most! positively!by!a!wide!margin!compared!to!those!who!have!not!visited!(See!Table!21).!! 91%!of!those!who!have!visited!the!city!in!the!last!year!view!the!city!as!positive,!very! positive,!or!neutral!as!a!destination!compared!to!74%!of!those!who!have!not!visited.!! ! ! Table!21.! How'do'you'view'Atlantic'City'as'an' entertainment'destination?' 352'Visited'K'164'Have'Not'Visited'' 60%! 50%! 40%! 30%! 20%! 10%! 0%! Very! Positive!! Positive!! Neutral!! Negative!! Very! Negative!! Visited!! 20%! 43%! 28%! 8%! 2%! Have!not!Visited!! 2%! 22%! 50%! 20%! 6%! ' ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ' ! 30! ! Of!those!who!have!not!visited!Atlantic!City!the!most!common!reason!cited!was! that!it!was!too!far!from!home!(See!Table!22).!!This!is!most!likely!because!of!the! responses!that!were!received!from!outlying!states.!!Other!popular!reasons!were!that!it! is!expensive!(17%),!does!not!have!enough!diversity!of!activities!(12%)!and!due!to!its! negative!reputation!(12%).!!Less!than!5%!cited!lack!of!family!attractions,!quality,! safety,!cleanliness!and!disapproval!of!gambling!as!an!activity.!!! ! ! Table!22.!! Why!have!you!not!chosen!AC?!! 164!who!did!not!visit!! Far!from!home!! Expensive!! Not!enough!diversity!of!activities!! Negative!reputation!! Not!enough!Family!Attractions!! Quality!of!Accommodations!! Do!not!approve!of!Gambling!! Concern!about!safety!! Quality!of!Amenities!! Concern!about!cleanliness! 0%! 5%! 10%! 15%! 20%! 25%! 30%! 35%! ' ' ! The!high!rank!of!“expensive”!as!a!reason!for!not!visiting!AC!further!supports! the!other!findings!that!casual!restaurants!and!mid8priced!hotels!are!very!important!to! both!millennials!and!non8millennials.!!Casinos,!city!planners!and!supporting! businesses!should!focus!on!providing!midscale!accommodations!and!casual!dining! options!to!attract!new!visitors!to!the!city.!' ' ! 31! Appendix'A' ! Focus'Group'Questions'' • What!is!one!of!your!favorite!things!to!do!for!entertainment!on!a!night!out?!! • Describe!your!planning!process!for!a!night!out!for!entertainment?! • How!far!in!advance!do!you!plan!your!night?!! • What!do!you!look!for!in!a!single!day/night!entertainment!experience?!! • What!type!of!transportation!do!you!use!to!get!to!a!single!day!entertainment! experience?! • What!percent!of!your!budget!do!you!spend!on!each!item?!! • What!is!one!of!your!favorite!places!to!visit!for!an!overnight!trip?!!What!do!you! like!about!it?!! • What!do!you!look!for!when!planning!an!overnight!entertainment!experience?!! What!activities!are!important!to!you?!! • How!far!in!advance!do!you!plan!your!trip?!! • What!do!you!look!for!in!the!room!accommodations?!! • Do!you!share!the!room!with!others?!!How!many?!! • Who!do!you!travel!with?!! • Do!you!play!video!games!for!entertainment?! o What!type!of!games?!! o How!often!! • How!do!you!feel!about!Casino!Gambling!as!an!activity?!! • What!is!your!favorite!Casino!Game?!! • What!do!you!like!about!it?!! • Do!you!play!with!friends!or!alone?!! • How!do!you!feel!about!slot!machine!games?!! • How!could!the!casino!experience!be!more!enjoyable?!!! • What!do!you!think!about!Atlantic!City!for!an!overnight!entertainment! experience?!! • What!about!for!a!single!day/night!entertainment!experience?!! ! For'those'who'do'not'visit'Atlantic'City'' • Why!not! • Do!you!visit!other!gambling!destinations?!! • Is!there!anything!that!would!make!you!want!to!visit!AC?!! ! For'those'who'visit'AC.'' • Describe!a!typical!visit!to!Atlantic!City!! • What!activities!are!important!to!you!! • Of!the!activities!listed!what!percent!of!your!total!budget!do!you!spend!on!each! activity! • How!do!you!see!your!entertainment!preferences!changing!in!10!years?!! • How!would!they!change!if!you!had!more!discretionary!income!to!spend?!! ! 32! Appendix B Millennial Entertainment Preferences You are invited to participate in a research study about the entertainment preferences of the millennial generation. Jane Bokunewicz, an Assistant Professor of Hospitality at Stockton University and the Levenson Institute of Gaming Hospitality and Tourism (LIGHT) Fellow for 20152016, is conducting the study. If you choose to participate you will be asked to complete an online survey with 18 – 25 questions. The survey will take approximately 5 minutes to complete. The survey is completely anonymous. No identifying information will be collected and results will only be presented in aggregate form. By completing the survey you are voluntarily agreeing to participate. You are free to decline to answer any particular question you do not wish to answer for any reason. You can terminate the survey at any time. Upon completion of the survey you will be directed to a new, completely separate survey where you will enter your e-mail address for one entry into a drawing for an Apple Watch. The winner will be selected via random number generation at the close of the survey period. If you have questions about the survey, please contact Jane Bokunewicz at jane.bokunewicz@stockton.edu or 609 703-1946. Your participation in this important survey will be very much appreciated. 1. Do you play multiplayer video games? Yes No 1 Millennial Entertainment Preferences 2. What types of video games do you play? Check all that apply. First Person Shooter Sandbox Games Puzzle Games Third Person Shooters Real Time Strategy Games Multiplayer Online Battle Arena Role-Playing Games Massively Multiplayer Online RolePlaying Simulation Games Casual Games Other (please specify) 3. What is the average number of hours you spend on the above video games each day? Millennial Entertainment Preferences 4. Do you play casino slot machines? Yes No 2 Millennial Entertainment Preferences 5. Which types of slot machines do you play? Check all that apply. Penny Video Quarter Bonus Round Games Dollar TV or Movie Themed High Denomination Poker Reel Community Games Other (please specify) 6. How do you prefer to play the slot machines? Check all that apply. Alone With friends or family Tournaments Community Games Other (please specify) Millennial Entertainment Preferences 3 7. Would you play slot machines if they had any of the following features? Check all that apply. Ability to play against other players Ability to play with a group Ability to interact with the game using a joystick An element of skill Simpler design No Other (please specify) 8. Do you play any of the following casino games? Check all that apply. None Blackjack Big Wheel Electronic Table Games Craps Poker Sports Betting Roulette Internet Gaming Fantasy Sports Baccarat Other (please specify) Millennial Entertainment Preferences 4 9. How do you prefer to play the above casino games? Check all that apply. Alone With Friends or family Tournaments Community Games Other (please specify) Millennial Entertainment Preferences 10. What activities are important to you when planning a day or night out for entertainment? Check all that apply. Fine dining restaurants Comedy Club Video Gaming Events Casual restaurants Public Transportation Gambling Quick service restaurants Day Spas Cultural Events Bars and Lounges Golf Camping Happy Hours Shopping Hiking Sports Bars Amusement Parks Hunting Wine Bars Museums Art Galleries Night Clubs Concerts Live Theater LGBTQ Clubs Sporting Events Beaches Beach/Pool bars LGBTQ Events Other (please specify) 5 11. When traveling for an entertainment experience that involves at least one overnight stay what is your typical length of stay. Check all that apply One night Four nights Two nights One week Three nights More than 1 week 12. How far in advance do you typically make arrangements for an overnight/multiple night trip? Less than one week 1 – 2 weeks 2 – 3 weeks 1 month More than 1 month 13. What accommodations/amenities are important to you when selecting a location for an overnight/multiple night entertainment experience? Check all that apply. Luxury Hotels Hostels Public Transportation Midscale Hotels All Inclusive Resort Parking Economy Hotels Outdoor pools Wifi Bed and Breakfast Indoor pools Free Wifi AirBnB Short driving distance Other (please specify) 6 14. What activities are important to you when planning an overnight/multiple night entertainment experience? Check all that apply. Fine dining restaurants Comedy Club Video Gaming Events Casual restaurants Public Transportation Gambling Quick service restaurants Spas Cultural Events Bars/Lounges Golf Camping Happy Hours Shopping Hiking Sports Bars Amusement Parks Hunting Wine Bars Museums Art Galleries Night Clubs Concerts Live Theater LGBTQ Clubs Sporting Events Beaches Beach/Pool bars LGBTQ Events Other (please specify) 15. When you visit a destination for an overnight/multiple night entertainment experience what percentage of your budget is spent on the following activities? (must add up to 100%) Transportation Hotel Dining Bars/Night Clubs Shopping Gambling Other 7 16. If money was not a concern, on which activities would you increase your spending? Check all that apply. Transportation Hotel Dining Bars/Night Clubs Shopping Gambling None Other (please specify) 17. How do you view Atlantic City as an entertainment destination? Very Positive Positive Neutral Negative Very Negative 18. Have you visited Atlantic City in the past year? Yes No Millennial Entertainment Preferences 8 19. Why have you not chosen Atlantic City as an overnight entertainment experience? Check all that apply. Far from home Not enough family attractions Lack of public transportation Expensive Quality of Acommodations Negative reputation Concern about safety Quality of Amenities Do not approve of gambling Concern about cleanliness Not enough diversity of activities Other: Please specify Millennial Entertainment Preferences 20. How many times have you visited Atlantic City in the past year? Millennial Entertainment Preferences 21. What is your age? 9 22. What is your gender? Male Female Other (please specify) 23. What is your primary Racial/Ethnic Identity? Hispanic White African American Native American Asian Pacific Islander Other (please specify) 24. What is your highest education level? High school diploma Associate Degree Bachelors Degree Masters Degree Doctorate Degree Other: Please specify 25. What is your relationship status? Single Married Engaged In a relationship It’s complicated Other (please specify) 10 26. What is your personal income? Less than $20,000 $50,000 to $59,999 $90,000 to $99,999 $20,000 to $29,999 $60,000 to $69,999 $100,000 to $149,999 $30,000 to $39,999 $70,000 to $79,999 $150,000 or more $40,000 to $49,999 $80,000 to $89,999 27. What is your zip Code? 11