On Tue, May 19, 2015 at 6:34 PM, Ofc. Alejandro Murguido wrote: Dr. E. McDonough This E-Mail is to confirm that per our conversation, tomorrows hearing is cancelled and that I will responded with in ten days. Respectfully Ofc A. Murguido *~CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE~* The information and any attachments in this Email are proprietary and strictly confidential. It is intended solely for the use of the individual or entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or agent, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distributing, or taking of any action based on the contents is strictly prohibited and protected by the law governing records confidentiality. If you received this communication in error, please notify the sender and delete this communication. ~Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public-records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing.~ From: Eric McDonough [mailto:phd2b05@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2015 10:15 PM To: Ofc. Alejandro Murguido Subject: Re: Dear Officer A. Murguido I confirm the grant of ten days to respond, as per our conversation. Sorry I did not respond back earlier as I had a school play to attend. In the effort of moving things forward could you please provide me with a phone number and/or address for your son, so I can provide it to my process server? Thanks. You may also want to let him know that he needs to update his drivers license if he has moved so he is not in violation of Florida law. Respectfully, Dr. James Eric McDonough On Wed, May 20, 2015 at 8:40 AM, Ofc. Alejandro Murguido wrote: Dr E. McDonough Thank you for the ten days. As for my son, we have been estranged for several months now and I do not know his whereabouts, however I will make an effort to find out where he is living. P.S. It would be nice of you if you left my family out of our misunderstanding. Ofc A. Murguido. From: Eric McDonough [mailto:phd2b05@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, May 20, 2015 11:08 AM To: Ofc. Alejandro Murguido Subject: Re: Re: Thank you for the effort to locate your sons whereabouts. I would happily remove your son from this lawsuit, if you would simply admit your false statements against me notarized in writing. I did not wish to bring family into this. That is something you and/or your son did when you both decided to give false statements to the police leading to me being falsely arrested from in front of my family. For your convenience I am attaching a copy of the recording of our conversation on 10/29/2012, and your sworn false statement from 2/28/2012. Respectfully, Dr. James Eric McDonough On Wed, May 20, 2015 at 1:01 PM, Ofc. Alejandro Murguido wrote: Doctor You and me would have no issues today if you had responded to the police station with any issues which you felt you had like I advised you when you went to my home the fist time. Unfortunately we have different views of the events. Please know that I forgive you for any trespass which you have committed against me and my family. God Bless. From: "Eric McDonough" Date: May 20, 2015 2:20 PM Subject: Re: Re: To: "Ofc. Alejandro Murguido" Cc: Officer Murguido, You and me would have no issues today if you had not decided chase me down and falsely imprison me (FS. 787.02), then lie about our conversation leading me to be falsely arrested/kidnapped (FS. 787.01) and retaliating against my First Amendment rights no less than 6 times to date. It is time that you begin to take responsibility for your actions. No action I have committed against you was against the law in any way. However, many of your actions against me are patently illegal. I was concerned for the safety of the children in the neighborhood, you then had me arrested basically for contempt-of-cop for making speech of public concern then for trying to file a complaint. You even went so far as to file another false stalking injunction against me because the media published my story and I filed a complaint. You then reopened it when I wrote online that you were a coward for not showing up. Obviously you are aware that such is first amendment protected activity. You also failed to appear for all three of your injunctions against me and failed to appear for three depositions. Maybe you think filing false documents and wasting my time and families money is funny, I do NOT. When we spoke in front of your house the first time you approached me as I was writing down your license to file a complaint. It appears you have forgotten that you had begged me not to file a complaint against you, and requested that if I had a problem with you to bring it to you as a neighbor and gentleman. It is also noted that this occurred on or about 5/7/2009 at 10:34 am, not on 7/27/2012 at 8:00 pm as you have falsely alleged in your sworn statements to police. I also have an alibi and witness for this false date/time you have alleged. Also I never pulled into your driveway or entered your property. I had to request you to get off my car so I could leave at least four times. Also despite your statements to the contrary, there is no record of you bringing this matter to anyone's attention, as the SOPs would require of you and your supervisor. Your personnel record documents you making no less than 6 false statements to supervisors, a false statement to the State Attorney's Office, three tickets written in retaliation, and lies about drug use on your polygraph for employment with Homestead. Let us not falsely pretend that you do not have a propensity for lying to protect yourself. Under the dictates of law you should not possess a law enforcement certification see FS. 943.13 (4 and 7), this goes for Deputy Gomez as well, as your statements made under oath to the police are a form of perjury. I also have records of other victims who you have made false statements about leading to their false arrest as well. It's not nice to abuse senior citizens and their disabled family members, and I would strongly advise against any further retaliation of them. I'd also point out that falsification of the record with corrupt intent is a felony (FS. 838.022(1)(a)), and you have a history of doing such in a sustained IA complaint. The preponderance of the evidence is against you. Also I note that to my knowledge none of the people you have arrested have ever been made aware of your past history of false statements. This is a violation of their rights to due process under Brady v. Maryland. Also your record shows at least 8 accidents in police vehicles, generating six injury reports. The reason I had contacted you is that you were driving with reckless abandon creating a danger to my community. You were not on duty, your lights and sirens were off, and you were not responding to any calls. I have already pulled the records to confirm such. Again it is time for you to take responsibility for your actions, and stop falsely blaming me for your incompetent actions. Also Sgt. Surman was incorrect when he said you did not violate any policy, as the HPD SOP manual clearly states that for any official action outside of your jurisdiction you must immediately report such to the agency whose jurisdiction you were in, which you failed to do. This is not the first time Sgt. Surman has covered for you against me. However, we both know there was no ATV you were chasing. Others at HPD have also acted in a criminal manner to help you cover up your crimes such as Det. Aquino. Fortunately you did not have the good sense exclude this information from your statement in you first false stalking injunction. We may have different views of the event, but fortunately digital evidence shows that you made false statements under oath, not me. Please know that I forgive you for your trespass and sins, and pray that you repent and find Jesus Christ as your Savior. If more could come to Jesus this whole travesty of justice will be worthwhile. Do note that forgiveness is not synonymous with no repercussions for wrongful acts. Your victims should be made whole. It is noted that to walk with the Lord is to walk in the light of truth. I will drop this law suit if you pay my cost of suit, and admit clearly on the record that you and Gomez conspired to make up lies against me. Swear to it, sign it and notarize it, and we are done here. I have tried to handle this amicably from the beginning, unfortunately you and your department have NOT. Respectfully, Dr. James Eric McDonough ps. the crimes of Chief Rolle and Det. Aquino have already been publicly exposed, and they can no longer act to protect you.