w

pennsytvania

INVESTIGATION REPORT

DEPAFN,'B{T 05 ENVIFONMEiTIAL

9/15/20163:5129PM

TNOIECIIIr{

Comolalnt

lnfolrHton

CompLln rn H(.):
Relat d comphint ld:

8220 - EP DOGO SWOO DBtr Off
Cornplaht ld: 25,0516

unlclpality: GrEen Township

county: lndians
Enrerod By: PAIRICIA A

MEMUK

Att r Hoor! (YIN):
ER R.l.tod (Yr{):

sourco:
D.b Recolved: 10/312007
Abb.wi.i.d D..cripion:

153{Y04

auahiy problems $,1t!

D.t
ratetupdy

N
N

Ack Dwlodgod:

anBr gas dlilling

V.
1.
1

Long Doacripdon:

Re.pondble Pe{v lnfom.tion

Homo Phom:

l{rme:

Pemlll:
Count:
Addr!.s:

IoblL

Phone:

unlcip.llty:

lndiane
523 AIRPORT

INDIANA PA 15701

Re.pon!. lnfoirnadon

Green TovmshiP

DaLRofetald:'

Prioitly: 3

Relared To:
o.rE R6ohred: 03052008

Progr.m: Oil& Gas
Comphlnt TyPe: Vvtrr

Ert

wor* Phone:

Cotnprny N.msr PHOENX ENERGY

SUPPIY

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

D.te R.spoGe A.sigtBd: 1061f2007

Oat Repons€ Due: 1212007
Date Flrst R.spo6e: 111062007
llBp.ctot: FREDRICK

SupedLon

G SRANDT

EDWARD L RENWCK

CommanE:

lnvo.0oaton lnfonnrfi on

Date

A$lgned:

1oBlf2oo7

ln3pactoi:

FREDRICKGBRANOT

t).b lnv..iigaEd:

eFACTS lnsg.ctlon ld:

lnv6dgadon OetcrlPtlon:

11/o6Doo7

Typo: sit6 Vrsit

Vlolatlon(YlN):N
lnv6fgatjon ld: 245502

#.*r##$*'*i###ffi ffi fihdiffi#l#"ffi m''xE#it-"
collected a samole on U1zU07.
.-ijEfiil lJaii'di,iiiii'i eo Renwict tod( another
pnor'
Enardv installed a trBa[nent svsism approximatsly 1 month

samplo

rat6' supplv Found that Pho€nix

Hoolts/of Phoeni Eneryv and rndiana c'urrtv commBsioll€r Rodnev
ii 6i:H;i;; H;;&-ffi-*tt''jim
lhe comnl'inr
di3cuss
to
house
Ruddod< atlll
j"miir"o
or a ssmpl€s taken to I
* t"
resurs rrom ure rao

27iro8 - Rsceiwd srmpl€

a

-plo
'or rs
!o te{ r$'at t," Departneflt could not-issu€ an order lor
presumpton

mst illtatlhoure
lmHil*
on tp evroence *e naw' a' ,"err as th€ ross or
;":ilE;li;; ffi.JJ-fu-iiii'ua#
was rir'aie. complaint dosed afrer hts noUrc€ton

l"ij"ii".itiE,tirni-fr. i..ot"ir't

 tuv

TL

1CY1,2007

ComplaintlO#: ztoil

Com, laint I nformation Fo rm

t

Condct
Date Received:

10t3112007

Source:

Etr Phone

R6calv3d By

Call E Lefier D

Legislative

Contad E

Eichler
Other

Name:

Hom6 Ph:

V.
1.
1

Mobile Ph

lndMdual's

Home Ph:

Company

72+5434793

Phoenix Energy Produclions, lnc.

Mobilo Ph:

Address:

109 Jefferson Street

Kittanning, PA 16201

County:

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

I

t Debils

Description: Ouality problems with water supply after gas drilling

APR 2

r__i,

3

2008

il[zsrREGiot\]
' I c.,a

Location

county:

Municlpality: GreenTr,[p

lndiana

Program:

Oil and Gas

Program
Complaint Typ6

Water Quality

lnspector:

Brandt / Small

Sup6lvisor:

Ed Renwick

PnofiyCode:

fllod

Date Assign€d:

1013'l t2007

DL

ll-

E30

I

Z4-

r

t,-

 1CY1 20O7

Com laint R
Complaint

lO*:

tt

onse

250516

Firsl Response (date):

11 l6to7

Date Resolv€d

3/5/08

Dals lnspeded

11 t6l07

lnsp€dion Type:

X
E

!

V.
1.
1

tuY

site Msit
Phone call

oher

eFACTS lnspection ld:

(ifepplicabie)

(Check if applicable)

Brandt. Water sample taken. lnspected gas well
contacted
site, Fulmer#1, 06335164. lnvestigation revealed
brown in
was
reddish
supply
thatlwaler
to
report
mid
August
in
Phoenix Energy
color and that it contained a particulate that would settle out ofthe water over tlme'
'1116/07 - Site visit made by Fred

thde

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

lnspection

oescription

Phoenix collec{ed a sample on 8l'14107.

ofJwater

1l2gl08 - curtis small and Ed Renwick took another sample
supply. Found that Phoenix Energy installed a treatmenl system approximately
month prior.

1

211108 - Small and Renwick met with Jim Hoover of Phoenix Energy and lndiana
to discuss the
County Commissioner Rodney Ruddock at
complaint.
z27lOB - Re@ived sample results from the lab and mailed copies of the results of all
request.
samples taken

to-,pere

llrat

-house
D

telll,

that the
house to
3/5/08 - Small and Renwick met
water supply
her
Energy
to
replace
for
Phoenix
order
issue
an
could
nol
Department
presumption
of the
because
the
loss
of
as
well
as
we
have,
based on the evidence
after
this
notification.
closed
time the complaint was made. Complaint

APR 2

3

2008

(':, :::-s
---- ':Otrir-lYr?srBEcl0il

.

 Bureau of Oil and Gas
Water Supply Complaint Investigation
cTs

#

250516

T1,pe X auahy nauaodty trGas
Presumption ofResponsibility: n Yes XNo
Pre-Drilling Survey:

Gas

I Yes

f]No

Well lpformatiotr:

P€rnit/Resistatiou # 063-3
Drill Dat€s:   123-30101

5 I

63

FarmNme: Fulmer #l
Well Record Rec'd:

WirtEr Well lpforEstion:

Well Dep&: unknown
SUDDIY Ase: 37+YB.
TiEe in Residenc€: 37 yrs
Topo. Rel,atiooship: gas well upgradieot

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

SuDDIY TYDe: shallow well
Trcalment TYD€: lorc
Household Size: I
Distance to O/G Well:

V.
1.
1

Coqlaint

Date Problem Started aod Effect on Water Stpply:
water supply was redish brown in
contacted Phoenix Energr in mid Aug.'07 to report
color & contained particulati matter that settlcd out over time. Phoenix collected a sample on 8ll4l07.
+Phoenix installed treatment system apprcx. 1mon. prior to our 1/29108 visit.

I

II

,

,-

APRz3

.dTrr JZSTREI1lCN

LJ ,v-;,.

FilG:

wc

2'OOE

_.

.

r

<

sr4dy CoEpbid lnli!'tlt 907 My DooDaa rd

&-

( t-/'(

 2n7DNg
To:

Crrtis C. Small

WG Qusfity Spociati$
DEP - Buean of Oil od Gas f,farg€@ed
286 lDdutsial Pa* Rood
Ebcoshrg; PA 159314119

D"*II

V.
1.
1

Frm:

Enclosed pu will find copies of all of the vmer saryle rcsults thc Depstuert
bas for your rvdcr srpply. Ilere ze 5 total includiag 6c most tec€Et lhat Ed Rmwi*
,rnd I collected ou ll29l2008-

.

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

Inthe DEP'Srtsults youwill sec tbd soe of tberesults ca givco inUG/L rdh€r
rrrm MG/L. To oonvErt UG/L to MG/L simply move tb decimal poiut 3 places to 6e
l€ft. For €xanple on 129108 the @omt of Lon reported h your qample was
1073.000 UC}/L. ConvErtcd to MG/L this would be 1.073000 MG/L.

maimum cmoinant levels €stsblished und€r
the Pmsylvania Sa& DriDLitrg wdEr Ac.l You ce use lhb to coq)arc lour Esults
withI have also coclorcda copy of the

Sincecely,

cttir

APB!3

too6

[:f,f,ttE?sEcroN

c. sEdl

 Bureau of LabolatorLes
Anallrtical Report EOR

01/03/2008 09:41:13

DEP

Oil

sarple

State:

Water

xlrO

h2o

Reasoni Routl,ne samplirlg
12OO104241-S

COMPI,ETED

942

- Description

01045A rRON T
00{10 ]\LKAIINTTY
*{ Coment rr
Alkalinity

Measured

to

Reported Results

CoEpIeted

3258.000 uc/L

t1-/73/200'l
tt /13 /2001

5.0 tlc/l.

EDdpoint 4.5

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

CAJ,CII'M T
00095 SPC G 25.0 C
oo929A soDrrrM T
00403 pH
** Comment **
TiEe l,jlnit

00916A

CI{LORIDE

00 94 0A

rDs

0051s
00 937A
01007A

00921A
00900
01055A

MAGNESIOI.' T

llalalness

I

MAI{GANESE

$

2oo8

onr.rft&-r. IREOI0N

-9-.--c:,-a.e\S

1{.300 MG/L
151.00 utrfios/m
2.314 MG/L
5,9 pll unj.ts

tt
rt

23.6 tlc/L

7! / 20 /20A1
tt / 15 /2001
7L / L3 /2001

For Test Exceeded

!28.

C

POTASSIW T
BARII'M T
STRONTI(I{ T

0108 2A

APR ?

G105

1:

PA

V.
1.
1

Saflple Medlum: Watei

Test/CASi

CoMPIJETED

PM

Countyr lndiana

La-boratory Saeple ID:
Standald Analysis:

Status:

!7/0612001

ltunicipality: cleen Tflp

Locatioa: well

1

,lnd Gas Mqnt

ID: 0531 463

CoLlectori Fre&ick Brandt
collected: rl/06/2007 02:45:00

PAGE

t{G/L

1.565 MG/L
55.000 uclr
61.000 oclL
4,860 MClr,
56 MG/r
31,000 oclr

/73 /200'1

/ 08 /2001
 L/13/200'1
7L/13/20a7

lL/

/2001
/2001
tl/73 /2001
ta/L3/2007
13

tt/!3

l1/L3/

2001

 JAI.I-23-2OO? TI,]E

04I21

PI1 VAPCO ENGINEERINI]

IIIUU
IAX NU. EI4 9J!

P.O,U'3U

Comso/fdated

L

CLIENT:
WELL NAME:
SOURCE:

1t1512007

DATE SAMPLED:
sAtIPLED BY:

168814

lnc
Pheonlx En€rgy Productions'
Connle D. Fulm er#1
#3 Betty ONsill

-wlahil

ANALYEIS

TV

V.
1.
1

No.:

OEP

Nov

2oo?

HEEN SEU RelcF
olsTRICf OFF

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

ALKALINITY (to PH 4'5)
AclDlTY (to PH E,3) ' ' '

cALCluu.,,,...'..,

iiANGANESE.'."""'

.13.38

."""'

'

,..

soDlulll
POTASS uM....,.'

msll

.9.92 nOlL
<0.'lO

mgll

3.n

L
mslL

ALUMINUM,..."....

BARlUlr,.."..."

g

5.72 s.u.
1,13 umhos/cm
1.1 nglL
to.t ms/L

LABDH@20.5"c.'"'
spe6trtc coHouctAt't

UAGNEslUlil

119 & 210

Pr xrnwts.{,l^ 15767
rtdl! (tl+) ,3lj95o
r,I €l+) s*7@

Penn
LAB

rlt'

R

fi

o,w

6\

2s-66 mgt-l:)
1.b3 nwL
o.23 mgL

'
'...,..,
cHLoRlDE...,'

rRoN

SULFATES '

olL & GREASE...."

D8
TOTAL EUgP ENDED SOLI
souDs
TOTAL DlssoLvEo
HARDNESS

os' @L
29.9

<1

n

L

rg/L

<2 mg/L
a mglL
48,88 mgll.

:
" '" " " " " '
iffiiil';il;'rffi'count '' ' ' ' ''.'.'.','- '. .'.'. . . , .'. .'.'. .'."'..''.'.'. rNrc
Baokground Non4oliform " '

T6trl Collfom Count.

APRI32008
t-'

i€s:rFEGlilN

#-M

,

P,i

ie, ?4101{8'litlglw

,ffi
Its

 r.u.

Consolidated
Penn

=tw

iffit
-:#

Frx

CLIENT:

Phocdt EnerEr Productiou' Itrc.
WELL NA.UIE: Connie D. f,uLmcr #1 ' Post

DATE SAMPLED:
SAMPLED BY:

soURcE:JA)

FIEI,D TEMP:
FLOW:
FIEI,D PE:

8n4no07
TV

zt.so
5.5

191191

ALUMTNUM.,,.,.,,,,..

<$,10

ngn

BABTUM

<O.OI

mg/L

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E
5.91S. U.
L80 ut

rhos/crfl

4.Eng/L

..... , .,,

SULFATES

SOUIN ..
TOTAT DISSOLWD SOI'DS . ' .

TOTAL SASPENDED

TATOLIECAL COUflOIM

....

TotALcolf,FoRM

....,....,...,.
CALCIUM ...,.,.......,

......,...'.......

l9.lWlL

rf,oN

25J ng/L

MAGNESIAM

POTASSIUTT . . .7

nc/L

4nMnl
/looml

4439ntg/L

CaLONDS............

29.19

,., .........

,

oIl"/GREAsE

BACKG ROIIND NONCOU F ORM TNTC /1 00ntl

L

3

2006

,-

At

cor-rit{l€STREGION
-" --(,:-a C.rS

IEIWSYLYANIA OEIAA TMEMI

CEXnEED

4.l ng/L

< "'g/L

METUANS,.,.,,,,.,,,, 146.21
ETIIANE .. .... ... " . ,. . O,l ns/L

COMMWTS

APR 3

t.91nq1l
Lwb ne/L
534 ne/L
0.05 ng/L
l.51t.g/L

,.
TOTAL HARDNESS ....,

SODIIIM

t7

,.,.,., ..,

MlNCANESE

20ng/L

l*

c

nEs ULTS

ANAL

ALKAIJMTA

93t-4700

V.
1.
1

Prim!ry - Post StEple

AClDlN

(tlt)

LAB NO:

Dug Well.'

..

)t/

Roua l19 110
Pt n$utavne!, Pll I s767
Ph\ne (814) Blt-39s0

I-aboralories

UApH@24.0oC..
SPEAFIC CONDACfiWTI ,.

nox

hotizzd Sbnature

08 iENwtoNNEl rAL PAglECftoN

lAtOMIont

Na 334353

/f)

 'l14126qg

LAi27

PIGNIX

7245434796

Plrocnix Encrgy Productiols, lnc
Phoenix Enetgy Resources, lnc.

109

S ferfcrlor SL

Kifirr

PA@

E}ERGY

itrg PA 16201

A1/03

Pho$.t 721-543'4113

[rr::.72*5414796

FaxTransm ittal Form

Date 2

t

From

Qra u,tr a rt

Fax

ComoanY

Fax

7

^4

-

czf'

S-f

7

Num5cr ol-pages includiot cover Pate:

lD

Po'T )..//,

Ao* /y<,

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

MesiaSer

721-5131796

V.
1.
1

To

d

APR Z

3

2008

c;r,3o$ffiiluEcror,/

c.

 El,
2

-!c=a

R>

E9lS
63
EE

E

rQr'eEsigul,ri]ros'.,'r

ii
-d

;a

EE63

oo

x
i:!<

.9a
9E

oE
u.l F
E:

--

EI'

a

E EBE
'i;

o
E

i *6 3E
E

)

Es
<z
d<

cP

iE

3H6

I
>e

!g

E

llldtI o
=6ea
IL . -5
E3E 5
k3
o{

IC

z uav

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

9z

ai
o=
od

>J

o
!lll

I

V.
1.
1

8002

<3

jt

aLE
lll

*l
I zl

F
rt

-t

I

EE 91

=

I

I

I

d
E

ii-

i3

,8.
S!u

t!E!

ia

.95:

t

!6

P*
o.5

EE

E

d
6

:E

g

!ci
'e .9

g

?5
tLo

ta

-!!

t

!

E

i=
EE
63

.E

;[

I

 6gg

R>
>F
:

E

=E3,
I

E9

ii
E
Er.
qa!

a"

;r,
ta

ou,

.9
U'

ts3t
fEE
E

!

oriE

ll,l

E E

I

t-

Eg
9<
4Z

d.<

9=

KB
o<
fE

ai
o=
odl

E

z
E

c
>a

800e

E

I

:

g

J.l
(o

qj

G

og,

.!t E

.l

c

clll

I

B

E

t

I
I

E

a

iE I
I

s
di

E

E^o

E
E

E

!6

P*
o.b
hE

!ci

PT
E()

E

!z
6-

5

a

9

6

,
;

a

!
?
!
I

E

!

it

.6

r:

j

6 Bdy

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

3Bi a
z6ea
sor 1
E3E

!

lt
o
E
!t

r,iors;u:a:,':r.l?'lo3,

V.
1.
1

o
1
tn
e

 Bureau of laboletories
Ana.Lt'ttcaL Repolt EOR
Otl And Gas MqEt

O2/27/20OA OO:3a tO2

PAGE

DEP

sample

Collecto!: Curtii.s

ID: 0460 002

Status:

0L/29/2008

1

COMPIETED

C Soal1

Coflected: A7/29/2008 10:00:00 IM

State:

County: Indiana

PA

Green Twp

V.
1.
1

Municipality:

Sarple Medium: water
Water
WATER

IIXI,L

conplaint

PRT-TREATMENT

IN

OPSTAIRS IAI'NDRY ROOM

35 DEGREES, RATNING WITH SNOW COVER. SAMPIE I\PPEARED
BND
CLEAR
ODORLESS.

E..

J,aboratoly Sample ID:
standard Analysis:

COMPLETED

12 0 08 0034 34

942

- Description
01045A rRON T
OO41O ATKALINITY
** CoErtent **
ALkafinity

Reported Results

completed

1073.000 UG/l

01/3r/2008

OP
EN
_S
OU
RC
E

Test/CAS*

00915A

00095

00929A

CArCrUu T
SPc I 25.0
SODToM

00403 pE
** coEment **

T

Measured

C

MG/L

EndPoint 4.5

CIILORfDE

00515
00937A
0100?A
01082A
00921A
00 900
01055A

TDS 0105 C
POTASSIW T
BARIUM T
STRONIII]M T
T

t2.3

02 / 19
02 /o4

tlG/L

105.000 uc/r

MANGANESE T

APR 2

3

2008

r-i,t0ty*:-sBEcl0lv

/0a/ 2008

ol/ 3r / 2008
ot/31/ 2008
ot/3!/2008

102. t.!G/L
1,285 MG/r,
40.000 ucll51.000 uc/r
4.230 W;/L
47 t4G/L

MAGNESII]M T

02

11.700 MG/L
135.60 umhos/qn
3.424 lrG/L

5.8 pH units
Tlne limit For Test Exceeded

00 9{ 0A

Eardness

to

3.6

02/04/2008

/2008
/2008
01- / 37 /2008
ot /3!/ 2a08
01/3L/2AA8

ot/3L/20a8
o t- /3L/2008
0L/3r/2008

"'