Chandler, Matthew From: Cline, Richard (6) Sent: Wednesday, November 16. 2011 3:15 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Davis, Robert lvl; Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, rent; oogaar eter; ess, avid Subject: CBS NEWS llvlEDlA REQUEST Yes ma'am, on Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at approximately 4:30 a.m. FPS and Portland Police Bureau officers moved into Terry Shrunk Park in downtown Portland to evict a number of "Occupy Portland" protesters who had set up tents in the federal park. Approximately 12 tents hd been set up and about 20 protesters were present. FPS personnel ordered the protesters to depart since overnight camping is not allowed in the park and about half of the people present complied and departed. 10 protesters refused to leave and were arrested for failure to comply with the lawful order of a Federal police officer. Kris Cline Deputy Director for Operations Federal Protective Service Fr??1= Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:08 PM To: Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Colburn, Brent; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDLG. REQUEST With regard to FPS arrests in Portland, weren't there some arrests the week before the eviction? From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:04 PM To: Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'lnquiry, Media' Colburn, Brent; Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Matt, Since these protests are lawfully protected First Amendment activities, we are treating all "Occupy" demonstrations as peaceful. We are working with GSA and each city government to ensure that all parties concerned are safe and secure. When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, we work with those officials to develop a plan to evacuate the participants in a safe manner. We have held standard coordination calls and face-to-face meetings with our partners to ensure that the proper resources are available for operations such as street closures, etc, The only eviction FPS has been involved with was assisting the Portland Police Bureau at the federally-owned Terry Schrunic Plaza where FPS arrested two people. Bob 1 *I-I-Tal A lvl. 2 xi l? .-., . tm'sijITIL_l.q .1..1. . 1- il Ts-`o?-yu.? (L o-via --ucla iiI?o5lvm? I o? 4 . *1 . ft as ia- o$?o wilip-.ig`iji . wig ia+2-3 . . `{uyynlu?l_T ,}-gi `sl.--. . lv A ky? - TH I `?ipa; I- "o`.Q-. `flra'lqfir: pl'; J) . U-nn . J. 6 sig} Ti l` 'ini jira I I .-JilIr?. -1- - {ii`oro-? {hp**13 I Mu '-`i$Bg.F . Lux -: kl\i"Y ,o . irq;. L, A l-'V S. ??roq ?ni. 1 auul ?4rii.4.f 4. _o - . . weYo??%o Gin.-oh. |r1,v_ - fr I~.4ov .. rj . NEXT: Hi, I . . wifV1-\..-.. -. . . . -T-. ..-. . -..-. -- db') . ,4 yq, I all ..1, . Bl 4? L. .-mf!. ?i I - ZM. vice_44_ - . . . - I . . V?:Jiix L-A lh, lh, MET, lk . ri Ah-. arr Hug, V. ifwo'?o - I lr- .35LALAJL.2g?fq .. 4, - rh;] 2 L, ., . 4' ..--5-{nm. v` r_ .,21 xdhfi 9% 2, A 44 .i :4 `o:_-fgy ?lo* -- I -oloan-an- ?-riu .-gf A CII4.,Lv-rpil .5 A . IV vt', o? 1 fx Igglf QIQ-'il:1?rx?P--1 {ni . fg I vmxz{{35 f. (U) (6) R, ?o . l* I .. 5 ki_i.o I - 0 ,;yg all-h-1 Antrim qa{fbio~oim-.T- .r mx 41152'Nfr. A a Elf.2-.i-inrxhif . . ini: I 1- 5 1-- V, .4oo?o` I `t ij-.. T3-Fil v--V vpQ;-..-- .- JQ;-wai i` .1. it i' jg *4-(IDala'll th 3 Ti' . R. -o;ro;-(reg: . a` 0 -J..4IIIAI `?7{`kqvw.-K! -7 'o *7fic:} 4 4.. 'o lllaw rqg?} - A h` Jiif"ii, I Xi, Tit`! ., _follThkgi if` rr {ng-'oo..2. -- hgLi{illzi,} 4, rb - . ?f_lvv'v~ {Ia! - ir . 1 I--1fi.- cj hits}; A - looL ai~f.4*1 i . - .- - 'erv. fftip" I. 53** di it 1- .. . EffZo_?i?d1.Aoo'pg- --.. ., o(?o . K.-ivQ4jailooj.>> Ir}, .-Fi?. - Quin nrIiiII-FRI . - .s.1..--Iopo?IgI}-`lci . nl . I h.-o-ir-? -- Q-., i? 1. Ll VQ I IQIQII --2. iy - cxlh. oH_i[Ira" 1- (2 3- - - ii`rfl I- i "Jig .?prA_81_ . feMtg1., --.. "f?r7?,Lln 1- I wi', ?oEUR-?hol??- . 1-pnql ,[iQ Av--.-- .-.. itiloJo~-- .. - . . -- A jah _'4fI_ .wvy-j-1l-1-- . oo>>?--suxFg-. in T, Ioo"si..- --.. - .-.. - ..- - FFQ4 I . - I I - 1-e-seo-ya.533 'or*i` -. - **'thk" lr gs; dh i rr.--Lnvii? - {.7*34 . - 4 I {Ai- Q- ably). griro,-i I - . - .2) 1..: ryjr" `t'of'a?L `rnuy: Av" ?o-j`io.oo~'-Jar ..I-. axle .-44its- o? -1 {Aug I.-I -7 - g_ ..I.-, . .4 I.v.;v rL*Qouni.EUR 1??rb? --I.. IISII II II `rjn LII Jog` 4 ,o IgocU?x?I VixMlars. YA, - II QQSIIT I-I.): Pp -1 -4 -?o1onl. o`;ou.-- {Za. -2to_v?o1-3; Jilld?g._.iQ A l. ngT.-, fifj A . 1* I Ajyn . ?wxDat-o_ . rv! . I ..2. 5 Ext" :1 . 1.. L7iujhrlh} qhqiv,jYzip., - -, 1; - -Af.3-. foq>> fw .. I ANALoo-~ ~so[Yi ..(I0) (6) -- I H- - Ig I I I -?1?oMll|?M.-, - - 3ixIIQIIF II44--. .g,_Iz Mo?qjumn, it ahnf} wi'.il. -.-.. - - .. o?.--. . . ., -- ffi I0. 1.. - A 4_ J. yer:-4.., . ffip h} ??-Iii qu'. i 1 - "i o. elim ot- ra?:io-oloIlfn Tia ?-rr 01:*ooi.?Yoo tl, fn". hwlillv - 4 oo gh l--it j- UN h' nn" .6Mg.- . 5 .-., . . . lf 1/l Sr'occupy-wall--street- crackdowns I Occupy Wall Street Crackdowns: Was The Federal Government Involved? ln the wake of raids on Occupy Wall Street encarnpments in multiple cities, some, like AlterNet, have wondered whether federal law enforcement spent time and resources coordinating with local authorities to crackdown on the protests. On Tuesday, The Examiner published a stog quoting an anonymous Justice Department official who said local police agencies "had received tactical and planning advice {rom national agencies" including the FBI and Homeland Security. That assertion was denied by the FBI in an official response sent to The Huffington Post. "Recent published blogs and news stories have reported the FBI has coordinated with local police departments on strategy and tactics to be employed in addressing Occupy Wall Street protestors," the response said. "These reports are t`alse. At no time has the FBI engaged with local police in this capacity." The Examiner's source, who still reportedly stands by his story insists that the Bl advised local law gforcement ortpress rela gilo.ne thatany-moves4o evict protesters be coordinated for a time when the press was the least likely to be present." The Department ot`Homeland Security (DHS) did not respond to request for comment from Huft`Post by deadline. But on background, department officials did tell The Examiner that the department played a "limited" role in breaking up the encarnpments. Homeland Security's involvement included making several arrests at a federally owned plaza in Portland. Nevertheless, DHS officials told The Examiner the department is "not actively coordinating with local governments or police agencies on the 'Occ upy' evictions," a statement that "leaves a lot of room for advice, both tactical and otherwise," according to journalist Rick Ellis. ln New York City, NYPD spokesperson Paul Browne told [-lul`lPost that his department did not work with any federal authorities before or after the raid on Zuccotti Park. enforcement action re: OWS was accomplished with no involvement by federal authorities (no coordination with them either)," Browne said in an email. Occupy protester Max Berger, who is a member of the OWS direct action working group, said he's not sure the feds are being honest about their involvement in the raids. Berger told Hul`lPost he was arrested during the Zuccotti raid and held for 24 hours before being let go without any charges. WNW . 'o 5- . IfVoo;(IxfcyAIAish- I -.4 1 -- [x1E'-tv- II IW .. A4. 4_ii1..- al -- I gikhpig rxr. Ik}, lg.f'ha1.2.-.7..11j A . - A 4 I-jilluint`--I`twaew xxi?mc,.ft". IL. - - Y. . "tztw Ahn U. . I . _yJ,;_o*Nlvi" 3 1* ThyILrilg ali-?o . 9 I K. Is" 4..- - - oo;o,. *1 I xx A I Ji35jiJ2gg-ri`. I .o k, gnxl`. JiJlnu . M1 . ly Jn; I 'ol' ..-. . 7y`gLat-oos24Li>>--g; - v?F\ I qv ~ro'v~ if 'oq .. leg..{sy vera . lamo;~;ola.I..i LZJrLei jj--., . -- fbfp..xy', UWB I 4 -- -- --.-.- . . lc*.4.ol4`-IVolsTf;"5} - xs v9.! ni I I I .41Q-.1 1 i 'n `o 111.at-IJ %Qh ?i I?w' . rib I ~soG??>>iZ4 . .-lg}; niet Fjvfufujvi - I - I- -- nv es_`ii?i`bo `irfriif riI'ooH`?}iYm .. .- o?i"io' I v.-lr ilUn" .2`??ioi rr . o~ I- I 1 v'-wi.6.. -;et"' -- ,4 -as-tru-. . I 1 . . .V.. . A T: sk . {tal-9..twuae.o?r . A -. . ,1 lling 4 I Ab. Ur - rl. 'lxp (IO,14 . ap,-rsvb'fo Hggs-'? ?y ap ??vnro I air .os.-7lg.-uh71.5 ii`. arf;-v_ 7 ,o *4 v~ A 'ljh A - ?`2.nJ unw-M. em . z- . JF my-6*- .-.. .f . .5waispu" ;Ioy?"ef J--i -ToI$"iL 'F'j 1 - -n-lh ll 3 A T. lmxr. #443--lEf_??7*1i_:ii" Aftmaisgik? il. - I `lsly 1) wgrgQuay . 'ij;. rlThat assertion was denied by the FBI in an official response sent to The Huffington Post. "Recent published blogs and news stories have reported the FBI has coordinated with local police departments on strategy and tactics to be employed in addressing Occupy Wall Street protestors," the response said. "These reports are false. At no time has the FBI engaged with local police in this capacity." The Examiner's source, who still reportedly stands by his story insists that the FBI advised local law enforcement on press relations, including "one presentation suggesting that any moves to evict protesters be coordinated for a time when the press was the least likely to be present." The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) did not respond to request for comment from HuffPost by deadline- But on background, department officials did tell The Examiner that the department played a "limited" role in breaking up the encampments. I-[omeland Security's involvement included making several arrests at a federally owned plaza in Portland. Nevertheless, DHS officials told The Examiner the department is "not actively coordinating with local governments or police agencies on the 'Occupy' evictions," a statement that "leaves a lot of room for advice, both tactical and otherwise," according to journalist Rick Ellis. In New York City, NYPD spokesperson Paul Browne told HuffPost that his department did not work with any federal authorities before or after the raid on Zuccotti Park. enforcement action re: OWS was accomplished with no involvement by tiederal authorities (no coordination with them either)," Browne said in an email. Occupy protester Max Berger, who is a member of the OWS direct action working group, said he's not sure the feds are being honest about their involvement in the raids. Berger told HuftPost he was arrested during the Zuccotti raid and held for 24 hours before being let go without any charges. would be surprised if there was not some federal level of planning involved, in spite of what they say." Berger said. "They don't want that story out there. We're coordinating nationally. so why wouldn't they'?" Two civil rights groups seem to share Berger's skepticism. The Partnership for Civil Justice Fund and the National Lawyers Guild Mass Defense Committee have filed a Freedom of Information reg uest for any cornmunications between federal law etdorcement agencies and local police related to the protests, according to The Examiner report. On Tuesday, the Associated Press reported that mayors and police chiefs in cities around the country strategized with each other about how to deal with the Occupy protests. From the AP: As concerns over safety and sanitation grew at the encampments over the last month, officials from nearly 40 cities turned to each other on conference calls, sharing what worked and what hasn't as they grappled with the leaderless movement. 2 Ilits -..- :`tn cl I ld, jfbQi'. _-gl ELL it i` . . ih-:7 I ?*o-pin I-al . - t5-vi_ool - ll.,`y1o IT o= aft .. _jo-.-., JQII- I I I und! ll I io.{.on - 'y?lJ`srYKI-- -- 1* agi N4. t'.J q?r Natl *8 ?o-in`ffyjqtvu"- 4* QQ-. La?i?,yi ?1 ye '7 l` i- ri`; lj A .- pl` A ?-.1hairAir`-`-14Y .4. ?4Vols" JT Je- i . rp, The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) did not respond to request for comment from HuftPost by deadline. But on background, department officials did tell The Examiner that the department played a "|imited" role in breaking up the encampments. Homeland Sectu'ity's involvement included making several arrests at a federally owned plaza in Portland. Nevertheless, DHS officials told The Examiner the department is "not actively coordinating with local governments or police agencies on the *()ccupy' evictions," a statement that "leaves a lot of room for advice, both tactical and otherwise," according tojournalist Rick Ellis. In New York City, NYPD spokesperson Paul Browne told HuffPost that his department did not work with any federal authorities before or after the raid on Zuccotti Park. enforcement action re: OWS was accomplished with no involvement by federal authorities (no coordination with them either)," Browne said in an email. Clccupy protester Max Berger, who is a member of the OWS direct action working group, said he's not sine the feds are being honest about their involvement in the raids. Berger told I?IuffPost he was arrested during the Zuccotti raid and held for 24 hours before being let go without any charges. would be surprised if there was not some federal level of planning involved, in spite of what they say," Berger said. "They don't want that story out there. We're coordinating nationally, so why--wouldr1it42l1ey?" Two civil rights groups seem to share Berger's skepticism. The Partnership for Civil Justice Fund and the National Lawyers Guild Mass Defense Committee have filed a Freedom of Information reguest for any communications between federal law enforcement agencies and local police related to the protests, according to The Examiner report. On Tuesday, the Associated Press repgrted that mayors and police chiefs in cities around the country strategized with each other about how to deal with the Occupy protests. From the AP: As concems over safety and sanitation grew at the encampments over the last month, officials from nearly 40 cities turned to each other on conference calls, sharing what worked and what hasn't as they grappled with the leaderless movement. Berger said he believed all of the effort spent arresting and charging protestors would gave been better spent investigating and prosecuting those responsible for the economic crisis -- a common complaint in the Occupy Wall Street movement. "lt speaks to how this country works right now that we saw such a giant investment in resources and huge amount of concern directed at the occupation while Wall Street gets off scot-free," Berger said. "lf they spent half the time worrying about how to go after those criminals as they did going after LIS, we wouldn't even need to be out there." 2 Chandler, Matthew From: Davis, Robert Sent: Thursday, November 17, 2011 7t29 AM To: Chandler. Matthew Cc: Ortman, Chris Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Did you ever find out if somebody from DHS was on the conference of rnayor's call discussing "occupy?" From: Colburn, Brent Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 6:42 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Spaulding, Suzanne; Ortman, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Triple checking on this--there hasn't been any connection except for Portland? From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:57 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Drtman, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "We are treating all of these protests nationwide as peaceful demonstrations. If a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. DHS is not actively coordinating with local law enforcement agencies andfor city governments concerning the evictions ot`Occupy encarnpments writ large. From: Spaulding, Suzanne Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:47 PM To: Ortman, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Good point, Chris. Let's say Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." 1 ..5i I Mr .2 twig-j`i7f5*ifirw-f"? Lfkg?It' -- MK jh.; v_ F5 1; .. LDL.: A 7?y?gAgl.; ., Ji"-Tr -.L..-.. . {dg --.. --.. ?1Hl I ?~iv"? a ly'. Qi I . `lli --. . . .5Irl I- bn ff rl, In Almiww - -1kx-` {hy . (tj} #9 QI . . A-o '?oo 1: IF Iflro;?o*?oo?4o --Y1 `zgy-- 1 - Tryvi, 2.-- '5 I, `Yf Lrg)? hhrj.-Eva uri-.? . 45nA;. A-TNT MEA '`Pw. if (vsnl 4 ?rrSI1. l` I- i - I1xiii-`A1. o-o - `r . npiq- }noT iixiiu lmfvj. ..-- - - .- . .. 4. \i rl - . j1. Lg; ?-Qt -v . 2 I `vlw rv. at me I .--[is*:Alf *-fbind?-+4t; a .?-rx- Chandler, Matthew From: Shlossman, Amy Sant: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 6:49 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Colburn, Brent; Kroloif. Noah Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Has WH comms seen this? From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 6:41 PM To: Colburn, Brent; Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter; (6) Drtman, Chris Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Dk, will go with this shortly. From: Colburn, Brent Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 4: 16 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter; (6) Cirtman, Chris Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST We need to really stress the third background bullet--make it clear how rare the federal involvement is Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 04:07 PM To: Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter; Colburn, Brent -- (6) Ortman, Chris Subject: FW: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST were getting inquiries from CBS, AP, Daily Caller, Salon and others on an un-sourced Examinencom piece that says DHS and are collaborating with cities by providing tactics and information on removing Dccupy protestors. A check of l&A and FPS shows that this type ofoutreach is not occurring in any wholesale manner. Please see below clarifying role in law enforcement around protest sites: "We are treating all of these protests nationwide as peaceful demonstrations. lf a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitany or unsafe by the General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND I FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. DHS is not actively coordinating with local law enforcement agencies andfor city governments concerning the evictions of Occupy writ large. 1 xI_vrgy11* -1-dubk4l-`ggi . wv.2IpChandler, Matthew From: Shlossman, Amy Sent: Wednesday, November 15, 2011 6:49 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Colburn, Brent; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagan; Kroloff, Noah Cc: Boogaard, Peter Orlman, Chris Subject: RE: CBS NEWS Please hold- +Noah From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 6:41 PM To: Colburn, Brent; Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter; (6) Drtman, Chris Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Ok, will go with this shortly. From: Colburn, Brent Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 4:16 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter (6) Ortman, Chris Subject: Re: We need to really stress the third background bullet--make it clear how rare the federal involvement is Fr?m? Chandler. Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 04:07 PM To: Shlossman, Amy; Sandweg, John; Grant, Daniel; Grossman, Seth; Manning, Meagen Cc: Boogaard, Peter; Colburn, Brent (6) Ortman, Chris Subject: FW: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST We're getting inquiries from CBS, AP, Daily Caller, Salon and others on an un--sourcecl Examinercom piece that says DHS and FBI are collaborating with cities by providing tactics and information on removing Occupy protestors. A check of and FPS shows that this type of outreach is not occurring in any wholesale manner. Please see below clarifying role in law enforcement around protest sites: "We are treating all of these protests nationwide as peaceful demonstrations. If a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration (GSA) or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND I FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. 1 _yT" tif", Alf *25.katv., I 1 - ijLn-fr[Kyi .. . wl i3 yl. ..3 .. ulleqqknzu`, Hcic ?g--jq v??xiiChandler, Matthew From: Colburn, Brent Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 6:42 PM To: Chandler, Matthew; Spauldin Suzanne; Ortman. Chris` Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Cc: Winchester, Robert Lluberes. Andrew; Media inquiry; Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re; CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Triple checking on this--there hasn't been any connection except for Portland? From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:57 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Ortrnan, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Cc: winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "We are treating all of these protests nationwide as peaceful demonstrations. lf a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some CHSES, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. DHS is not actively coordinating with local law enibrcement agencies and./or city governments concerning the evictions of Occupy writ large. From: Spaulding, Suzanne Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:47* PM To: Drtman, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Good point, Chris. Let's say Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." . From: Ortrnan, Chris Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:35 PM To: Cline, Richard Spaulding, Suzanne; Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "lfa protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe bythe General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service works with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only hasjurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. From: Cline, Richard [mailto: (6) Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:24 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Dttman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Yes ma'am, this is an accurate statement. Kris Cline Deputy Director for Operations aaragrgijn tar ts}; l;?m?Spaulding, Suzanne [mahto -- A Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:12 PM To: Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Medialnquiry@dhs.gov; Colburn, Brent; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST I would alter the last sentence of the first para "When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, we work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved? Kris-- is that accurate? From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:04 PM To: Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media' Colburn, Brent; Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Matt. Since these protests are lawfully protected First Amendment activities, we are treating all "'Oocupy' demonstrations as peaceful. We are working with GSA and each city government to ensure that all parties concerned are safe and secure. 2 When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, we work with those officials to develop a plan to evacuate the participants in a safe manner. We have held standard coordination calls and face-to--face meetings with our partners to ensure that the proper resources are available for operations such as street closures, etc. The only eviction FPS has been involved with was assisting the Portland Police Bureau at the federally-owned Terry Schrunk Plaza where FPS arrested two people. Bob From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:42 PM To: Davis, Robert Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortrnan, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media'; Colburn, Brent Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST And now Salon. This is getting legs. Any info would be greatly appreciated ASAP. From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:32 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortrnan, Chris; Chandler, Matthew; Lluberes, Andrew; Inquiry, Media Subject: FW: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST AP_at?igjBS are asking about ourtelationship with cities de_al_i_ng with "occupy protestors" how would we describe our activities? From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:01 PM To: Lluberes, Andrew; Davis, Robert Cc: Colburn, Brent Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Eileen asked about this as well, adding Andrew and Bob. ls or the fusion centers holding conf calls on this topic? ls From: Shaban, Bigad [mailt (6) Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 01:58 PM To: 'MediaInquiry@DHS.gov' Subject: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Hi there. My name is Bigad Shaban and I am a correspondent with CBS News (national). We'd like to request comment from the Department of Homeland Security concerning whether it. or any other federal agencies, offered any kind of assistance or advice to municipalities looking to dismantle their own "Occupy" protests. Published reports note a relationship between the federal government and cities orchestrating the removal of "Occupy protestors" from makeshift camp sites. 3 4Ufsl-o?vo_fi?. - 7 - -- f-`tr-Chandler, Matthew From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:57 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Orlman, Chris Cline Richard Davis, Ruben Cc: Winchester, Robert Lluberes, Andrew; Media inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaa eter Subject: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "We are treating all of these protests nationwide as peaceful demonstrations. lf a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. DHS is not actively coordinating with local law enforcement agencies andfor city governments concerning the evictions of Occupy encamprnents writ large. From: Spaulding, Suzanne Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:47 PM To: Ortman, Chris; Cline, Richard Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Good point, Chris. l.et's say Federal Protective Service will work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved," . From: Ortman, Chris Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:35 PM To: Cline, Richard Spaulding, Suzanne; Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "Il a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration (GSA) or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service works with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with 1 ,iriww GLEN kt" I We~-rt .fIy?o?i UI 'l . - jl?rtoL-- 1; 44-l-I I `fnr as 4 ,4r . allim -- -- `alln nity 7 F. I 4 A 2 4..?iLgt} `fkJl-Mll;4oglr{rf,o.o y"N ,oT" JT I. - . Tagityi`Xa:.7.gi . 4* 4 AlUH, Plr 3141 ,4.1 Ve.-Llirs" A ive- o..o?13.* Hg-, oat.1.4.. 'Il. i . 4 Ax_4l,Per?sgl'. . qtug 'hk EV *`in? o?i"s?oo *vz--tl fi I .. lj `t`Ir' 18,64 - - fi d`-2 ?l"J`l LClu-,ol_ mlxir`; .v . ,5 Iifivg`Uja TipPilar{Law}- o` ., . '1g_ . . . lrpaltwFrom; Suzanne_[mailt (6) -- Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:17 PM To: Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; MediaInquiry@dhs.gov; Colburn, Brent; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST I would alter the last sentence ofthe first para "When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, we worlt with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." Kris-- is that accurate? From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:04 PM To: Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media' Colburn, Brent; Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Matt, Since these protests are lawfully protected First Amendment activities, we are treating all "'Occupy" demonstrations as peaceful. We are working with GSA and each city government to ensure that all parties concerned are safe and secure. When a protest a city, weworlcwith .those.olticialsl.0 develop a plan to evacuate the participants in a safe manner. We have held standard coordination calls and face-to--face meetings with our partners to ensure that the proper resources are available for operations such as street closures, etc. The only eviction FPS has been involved with was assisting the Portland Police Bureau at the federally-owned Terry Schrunk Plaza where FPS arrested two people Bob From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:42 PM To: Davis, Robert Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media'; Colburn, Brent Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST And now Salon. This is getting legs. Any info would be greatly appreciated ASAP. From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 15, 2011 2:32 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard lt Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortrnan, Chris; Chandler, Matthew; Lluberes, Andrew; Inquiry, Media Subject: FW: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST AP and CBS are asking about our relationship with cities dealing with "occupy protestors" how would we describe our activities? 2 {ij- yl,. t. .o~_s,wqf r. vw A 1 AJAI .L 5 I- i I _Hf+\rQ--.A Je; {Qi; 5 if ikV-rl%H` gr`: . .. . f- oo warn-?ask -n-sx-4 ist`, Li"' iw1- at 1 1 - Qt- ag-..;4444?*o-4E' I ??4`n? ,1 I 4 di.-tv4444444*4 xg{mbi-o\ -, ag, I 4 Wt 444i'?4 A. 4; .. .c ..0. .'4--444 444`ilrl VUVQVF A I - . 44;- 444?Y_o' 4 I 4-s i Y--. .414 S14 Mme .. - - -40. 44_? ir N. . 4o>> 4 4 444Jay'44` P3: '4 444t4"fC4uV??--4444 gtiff.; AK gl _o4 li"- y. . .44 44444r ~444 2.43.4.:4 . 4 4444Lx?p we vi 4 44 4444 `44445 {ri. I-- . 1 .. `4 ufYY1IJ}-gf} Avi, -4#4-.1*4 4* 4 4 `\ -- 0 15 . 1. innp-20 vnsirau` gun} I anixix ..4 Is`ij- av . I I"l? 4 .. nl Lv; v_ AxCivtus-; -1 tr Q1 .-p17 pn..--. . I 1* giUroo?o A . ?r - lgChandler, Matthew From: Ortrnan, Chris Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3135 PM To: Cline, Richard Spauldin Suzanne; Davis Robert Chandler, Matthew Wi??hsS?sr>> Reese L: il5X(?1 HBXEK Media Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST "lf a protest area is located on Federal property and has been deemed unsanitary or unsafe by the General Services Administration or city officials, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, the Federal Protective Service works with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." ON BACKGROUND FPS only has jurisdiction when a protest takes place on federal property, and in some cases, shares that jurisdiction with local authorities. The GSA is the permitting authority for protests on federal property. From; Cline, Richard [mailto (6) I Sentawednesdayr November to, 2B.1L 03;.24 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Media Inquiry; Colburn, Brent; Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Yes ma'am, this is an accurate statement. Kris Cline Deputy Director for Operations Federal Protective Service From: Spaulding, Suzanne [mailto: (6) I 1 Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 3:17 PM To: Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; MediaInquiry@dhs.gov; Colburn, Brent; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUESI I would alter the last sentence of the first para "When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, and they make a decision to evacuate participants, we work with those officials to develop a plan to ensure the security and safety of everyone involved." Kris-- is that accurate? 1 From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:04 PM To: Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media' Colburn, Brent; Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Matt, Since these protests are lawfully protected First Amendment activities, we are treating all "Occupy" demonstrations as peaceful. We are working with GSA and each city government to ensure that all parties concerned are safe and secure. When a protest area on Federal property is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, we work with those officials to develop a plan to evacuate the participants in a safe manner. We have held standard coordination calls and face-to-face meetings with our partners to ensure that the proper resources are available for operations such as street closures, etc. The only eviction FPS has been involved with was assisting the Portland Police Bureau at the federally-owned Terry Schrunk Plaza where FPS arrested two people. Bob From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:42 PM To: Davis, Robert Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard l< Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media'; Colburn, Brent Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST And now Salon. This is getting legs. Any info would be greatly appreciated ASAP. From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:32 PM To: Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline Richard Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) Drtman, Chris; Chandler, Matthew; Lluberes, Andrew; Inquiry, Media Subject: FW: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST AP and CBS are asking about our relationship with cities dealing with "occupy protestors" how would we describe our activities? From: Chandler, Matthew Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 2:01 PM To: Lluberes, Andrew; Davis, Robert Cc: Colburn, Brent Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Eileen asked about this as well, adding Andrew and Bob. ls or the fusion centers holding conf calls on this topic? ls From: Shaban, Bigad [maiit (6) Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 01:58 PM To: 'MediaInqulnr@DHS.gov' 2 - *4oii?' #1 - -- . - Nb} ll l.-l .. ig Ni agi. 4 if . I I ?fQ"`1 Maya Ik;] - -I?vooll'. 3- `asli 1" wri?.-.. . rl;-I . lk- 4.. 1 ??1IwI`ic-FC"llb - (ooI_I *?o??'j4IIVIIW Ig x__I A II JIP -- fit. I Irl Q-yy A - I 5 ig_?II.IZ.. I iff? ik I -- Q. .. 1f?P I-- I - . AI {tl" TI 1 "*lr . gw..V. ---I-I, -- ?x -IJ--. .-..- IIAI .I..VVjk? I . o? Lil.1n.1n17. ui - ET {Vx: Vw- ff"; - ViewIxytf`qvw . . "f?Ef-I-I . l-I1:rI;-tVVl_ `gff iiuv 1 . . ?o In- - mr- #*geVJOI Ilf11-U-v-oo??ooj?o?'?qginhlg$vf75Lo5 ig`Vot_ *P5.. 2..- . . *7**1 `oI?Ao35iiAyL.-, `lsufSy? ltln1-71 J. I . I 2.31-1: .1.5.). 3. -4 Ly. ..1--. . ;(U) (6) il- Xv . and oIj>>, I-xsfvyxl`.`, . FJ l` I I (6 1-.-- .. - 1* A I- mi.o4kio' Ai oLh" . ..-- 3 gl"ll34j-I-L LFLI -- ?liar - -- 1, .6 fw 4.\oo*aIA ooX-. ry.; 'jf - V.: 1 Qj fwChandler, Matthew From: Cline, Richard Sent: Wednesday, Novem er 0 PM To: Spaulding. Suzanne; Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Ce; Winchester, Robert (6) Ortman, Chris, Lluberes, Andrew, Media Inquiry; Colburn, rent; oogaard, Peter; Hess, David Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Yes ma'am, on Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at approximately 4:30 a.m. FPS and Portland Police Bureau officers moved into Terry Shrunk Park in downtown Portland to evict a number of "Occupy Portland" protesters who had set up tents in the federal park. Approximately 12 tents had been set up and about 20 protesters were present. FPS personnel ordered the protesters to depart since overnight camping is not allowed in the park and about half of the people present complied and departed. 10 protesters refused to leave and were arrested for failure to comply with the lawful order of a Federal police officer. Kris Cline Deputy Director for Operations Federal Protective Service Suzanne A Sent: -Wednesday,-Nevember--167 201-1-3:02} PM To: Davis, Robert Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; Colburn, Brent; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: Re: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST With regard to FPS arrests in Portland, weren't there some arrests the week before the eviction? From: Davis, Robert Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2011 03:04 PM To: Chandler, Matthew Cc: Winchester, Robert (6) (6) Ortman, Chris; Lluberes, Andrew; 'Inquiry, Media' Colburn, Brent; Spaulding, Suzanne; Cline, Richard Boogaard, Peter Subject: RE: CBS NEWS MEDIA REQUEST Matt, Since these protests are lawfully protected First Amendment activities, we are treating all "0ccupy" demonstrations as peaceful. We are working with GSA and each city government to ensure that all parties ooncemed are sate and secure. When a protest area on Federal properly is deemed unsanitary or unsafe by GSA or a city, we work with those oflicials to develop a plan to evacuate the participants in a safe manner. We have held standard coordination calls and face?tc--face meetings with our partners to ensure that the proper resources are available for operations such as street closures, etc. The only eviction FPS has been involved with was assisting the Portland Police Bureau at the federally-owned Terry Schrunlc Plaza where FPS arrested two people. Bob 1 i I - i- . p. r4~_ 44 .. .. I 444Z4r,.! .4: 4` 44 44 44yL? (ki IAQ "o1? Nr Tg hrlo114441 glUQ"'wl4**T-iv14k" Intl . . 3 - 21 1 - i yq,1wsj; r?..oj,` wil`, . I *3 qi. -1-hse . unii . . - . `ava i 1- ., -- ill`? "2 TYLI- i`f -. it- w-I.- -1.-: I lf.} .3. . j_I_ Jl; . --. . . - ._rv V-), il -- TC II): II . . $1 I ??.*524 A v' ."Mv 3 .f 3 I "1 Jiy.o? ro?o. - I Cr'.ntl',riftx: -.i`uh: 5I.f . pry`, . 2i?'fsljj; Il II14Mpo"o"o? l- vi-- - . -o?lv"Jr- .- `i?f qt:. nt; I. 'o1o {nf- Ib` ?o'oJ . . I y. 4., -.. qi`. . I - nn 'L in n* .. I 4-.-`psi spofY`7uAyvirxavi; .vIr?` v` 4 . n-jg.5.. up !2izs4>> V. JJ 1 . -o'Toebwb; 3 qua- -1 1 25 4,iu I l"`VV: IIJI . .`gjkl I!-Qvrei ?vIrif". I - F-- . 4a3:5 pwoi?;EURf I I.- J. I . ,"4- iu}- ter . 1 izrfifra- . .-- Jer- JiT1-Rv-1-.. . - A - *13 g-jug.4J1?,r I ?i wt yazjw 4 I XL .. J. ..-.., - pyay". o,o w, .4 - Qs -2.5 {by {(51 vT%`J4`j . 'In I 5i" ?fr?i?j7fs'?gay..or_o< A VJJW P. -3- - - . . XT. nj' TungxgdifW7ITEK o*'Kr}; as 3 QM II IJ nl?f7.?oHguy Ib an I Fir- -- 4 - o* ?t stuq-wl-? . MN . . livKp- .1avat5,rwgergHP- fg~r_n ._Lv i . . ?Ji i__l `vtn -*ii-,?`ijqi?1 (tnTXKA - - 4 4.. . 4 I ?*vw\jv' 3 - xqlfaq Q- AI -3 9 "kxfir .4glpl, zy"4-A A "rn lf!. . o. . - - igx?{ini-. 4 I . A- I- "`lnumy Ii'*'oxq . 'I-in an "igz"? --: Driv:. I ur I WTP- puff i - - -4'ls .44.:pj-?"oEURo?f I-`ifg - A v?.-As ooto`l'.-4Akai4..-- - ?Lixtyl nl'. lib@17`agqgf - xx`} 4 .-. . . A z.vIn?o-1 .-Il"` 1 . E. I 'Vf?roray):. . . . . ryxlfunik- L??`in--gi"qhl . wirK.-, - tinTXQlat"!. lb V. Rl - . gl- in-ll gffat?'asvfi} at-- 1 ifsAffoz? gf-, jk`filg . . . ix': I `Dl . ovx3' d-1, 1 - -l-lo j` Il 5 tJooq rshrv.; t; -uuww'ins -- 1? Wl- av 0 wi.? I. {jig, Aulh, YETo_[Nbr 1ii..-4 1 . i . 3-Iv. lla';. vw,*67 . . A 1 - nov ?fo on_ ww - .- -- .V It* my?. wx"? AA A uh 1-- JionA_ lt, -.-rl. LIIwik?og_ :Yq inf"'-9fi". In - . 4.:(rnsqi`*fTya .. {AjPVT..-v:'in?-ll,. ih. >o ll rwa" Y- W- an- @0 PNNL . . Yi..-. - - -- ir"'-ill 1 cf` 'x 61{fat - Q. ty.4t_ 5 'irif vgK-QQ --. - ?g-N L. - ?r?-rtql ',.fx 1- 1. jr-. fa. Y. JY- 1 . -- Qvrr'.Toi_ . - (iq- r?r_"I4xmlk! F-.-*oJ_ (Ba I - OQ ll7,li:. . MJ qt "54AtiauthLian" YI - - {rhqlti A I- oo` g` ?f - txMi`. _j`Z W- A -15-Lfiglx rl *r . Y. -- It PitZ2. ri:-`Jaf o-ny I I - int ll*?oYogy{IrPBEQ.QVwkIg?} I ig"llx tl if - 1**llt-t VI mh - I., - -.--JL'44-.. 1 qs, fw i J: rl`{jr nl ar l, 3. Eatml`L-H-iw-`lfl "I~vo; - Tb