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`$-@$94(&;'+#3'.9$.#9$3'#' 4$89$"'9$.(9"'"+#"'1#4'.-#,&-:'40$.",8#-'#&3'1(99,$3'#<(7"'"+$'=@$&8:N4' "9$#"%$&"'()'8#.",>$4G''J'1#4'#8P7#,&"$3'1,"+'`$-@$94(&'#&3'9$4.$8"$3' +,4'O73@%$&"T'J'#-4('-#"$9'"#-0$3'"('5J='()),8,#-4'1+('1(90$3'(&'"+,4' 4"73:G''=&',%.(9"#&"'89,",P7$;'"+$'JZ'9$.(9"'1#4'#-4('#&("+$9'9$%,&3$9' #<(7"'"+$'(7"4"#&3,&@'.9()$44,(&#-,4%'"+#"'8#&'#-1#:4'<$')(7&3',&'"+$' =@$&8:N4'9#&04G' '' J&'DEE_;'J'<$8#%$'5(7&4$-(9'()'"+$'I$.#9"%$&"'()'!"#"$G''H+,4'4+(7-3'&("' <$'8(&)74$3'1,"+'"+$'37",$4'()'"+$'!"#"$'I$.#9"%$&"N4'a$@#-'=3>,4$9G'' H+$'X5(7&4$-(9Y',4'#&'(-3'()),8$'#"'!"#"$;'#'.-#8$'1+$9$'"+$'!$89$"#9:' .7"4'4(%$(&$'1+('4$9>$4'#4'#'0,&3'()'3$.7":'(&'%,48$--#&$(74',447$4G'' =%(&@'%:'37",$4;'J'1#4'"('<$'"+$'47<8#<,&$"'X3$.7":Y')(9'"+$' I$.#9"%$&"'(&',447$4'()',&"$--,@$&8$'.(-,8:'(9'8(7&"$9"$99(9,4%G'' ' U:'67&$'DEE_;'*9$4,3$&"'U74+'1#&"$3'"('9$8(&4,3$9'"+$'8799$&"' #..9(#8+G''`$'#40$3'+,4'#3>,4$94'"('3$>$-(.'9$#-'(.",(&4')(9'"+$')7"79$'()' "+$'Z7#&"#&#%(')#8,-,":;')(9'"+$'$>$&"7#-'3,4.(4,",(&'()'3$"#,&$$4'+$-3' <:'5J=;'#&3'"('-((0'#"'"+$'4"#&3#934'@(>$9&,&@'"+$'"9$#"%$&"'()'$&$%:' 8#.",>$4G''' ' !$89$"#9:'()'!"#"$'5(&3(-$$LL#'^,8$'1#4',&')#>(9'()'8+#&@$G''=-4(' 47..(9",&@'8+#&@$'1#4'+$9'a$@#-'=3>,4$9;'6(+&'U$--,&@$9;'1+('+#3'+$-3' "+$'4#%$'O(<')(9'+$9'(&'"+$'b!5'4"#))G''U$--,&@$9'1#4'#-9$#3:'3$$.-:' ' C 8(&8$9&$3'#<(7"'3$"#,&$$'.(-,8,$4'#&3'8#99,$3'48#94')9(%'$#9-,$9' <79$#789#",8'<#""-$4'(&'"+$'"(.,8G''' ' !7<8#<,&$"'3$.7",$4'<$@#&'%$$",&@'9$@7-#9-:',&'+,@+-:'4$&4,",>$' %$$",&@4'"('8(&4,3$9'"+$4$',447$4G''J'9$.9$4$&"$3'"+$'I$.#9"%$&"'#"' "+$4$'%$$",&@4;'#-(&@'1,"+'A9G'U$--,&@$9G''J'1#4'"+74'[9$#3',&N'"('"+$' 3$"#,-4'()'"+,4'.#9",87-#9'5J='.9(@9#%')(9'"+$'),94"'",%$G' ' S+:'1#4'478+'#'.9(@9#%'#3(."$3c''J'3('&("':$"'#3$P7#"$-:'7&3$94"#&3' +(1'#&3'1+:'"+,4'+#..$&$3G''U7"')(79'.(,&"4'4"#&3'(7"Q' ' d,94";'"+$'#"%(4.+$9$'#)"$9'FVBBG''H+$'8(7&"9:'+#3'47))$9$3'"+$'%(4"' 3$>#4"#",&@'4,&@-$'#""#80',&',"4'+,4"(9:G''="","73$4'"(1#93'"+(4$'<$+,&3' "+,4'%#44'%793$9'1$9$'7&3$94"#&3#<-:'%$98,-$44G''H+$')$$-,&@'()'<$,&@' #"'1#9'1#4'9$#-;'#"'-$#4"',&'"+$'S+,"$'`(74$G''=-%(4"'$>$9:'%(9&,&@;' *9$4,3$&"'U74+'+,%4$-)'9$8$,>$3'&$9>$RO#&@-,&@'<9,$),&@4'O74"'(&'"+$' -#"$4"'"+9$#"4G''=-%(4"'$>$9:'#)"$9&((&;'747#--:'#"'_'.G%G;'Z$(9@$'H$&$"' 1(7-3'9$>,$1'"+$'-#"$4"'$&@#@$%$&"4'#4'#'3$')#8"('5(%<#"#&"' 5(%%#&3$9',&'#'@-(<#-'1#9G'''!(%$'()'"+$'"+9$#"'9$.(9"4'1$9$' #.(8#-:.",8;'4(%$'48#9$4'+#>$'&$>$9'<$8(%$'.7<-,8G''J'4#1'%#&:'478+' 9$.(9"4'1+$&'4$9>,&@'(&'"+$'*9$4,3$&"N4'd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e^e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`(74$'(9' ,&'"+$'?)),8$'()'"+$'f,8$'*9$4,3$&"'1+('1$9$'.74+,&@')(9'<$""$9' ,&"$--,@$&8$G''b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d(79"+;'=""(9&$:'Z$&$9#-'6(+&'=4+89()"'#&3'+,4'I$.#9"%$&"'()'674",8$;' #-(&@'1,"+'"+$'S+,"$'`(74$'5(7&4$-;'=-<$9"('Z(&L#-$4;'#4479$3'"+$' @(>$9&%$&"N4'-$#3$94'"+#"'"+$'.9(.(4$3'.9(@9#%'1#4'-#1)7-G''H+(4$' #4479#&8$4'1$9$'9$&$1$3'<:'=4+89()"N4'4788$44(9;'A9G'Z(&L#-$4;'#&3'<:' Z(&L#-$4N'4788$44(9'#4'S+,"$'`(74$'5(7&4$-;'`#99,$"'A,$94G' ' J'1,--'3,48744'"+$'-$@#-',447$4',&'%(9$'3$"#,-',&'#'%(%$&"G''d(9'&(1;'J' 1,4+'"('9$"79&'"('"+$',447$'()'7&,P7$'X$))$8",>$&$44Y'#&3'"+$'47..(4$3' #<4$&8$'()'#-"$9&#",>$4G''' ' H+$9$',4'P7,"$'#'<,"'()'$%.,9,8#-'#&3'+,4"(9,8#-',&)(9%#",(&'#>#,-#<-$' #<(7"',&"$99(@#",(&'$K.$9,$&8$',&'"+,4'8(7&"9:;',&',"4'.#4"'1#94;'#&3',&' ' _ "+$'$K.$9,$&8$4'()'("+$9'3$%(89#8,$4')#8,&@'"$99,):,&@'"+9$#"4G'''J'+#>$' 3(&$'4(%$'1(90'(&'"+$'U9,",4+;'d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dUJ'$K.$9"4;' (9@#&,L$3'<:'"+$'%,-,"#9:N4'6(,&"'!.$8,#-'?.$9#",(&4'5(%%#&3G''U:'DEE_;' ,)'&("'$#9-,$9;'"+,4'.9(@9#%'1#4'8(%.-:,&@'1,"+'<#4,8',&"$9&#",(&#-' 4"#&3#934',&',"4',&"$99(@#",(&'()'8#.",>$4G''H+$'.9(@9#%'1#4'+,@+R"$%.(' #&3'",%$R79@$&"G''H+$'()),8$94'97&&,&@'"+$',&"$99(@#",(&'.9(@9#%' 8(&4,3$9$3',"'$))$8",>$'#&3;'#"'-$#4"'<:'%,3RDEE_;'"+$'@(>$9&%$&"N4' -$#3$94'1$9$'#1#9$'()'"+$,9'.(4,",>$'#44$44%$&"G''' ' b(&$"+$-$44;'"+$',&"$--,@$&8$'8(%%7&,":N4'.(4,",(&',&'DEE_;'#&3'-#"$9;' 1#4'"+#"'#'47<4"#&",#-'.9(@9#%'()',&"$&4$'.+:4,8#-'8($98,(&'1#4' 7&,P7$-:'&$8$44#9:'"('.9("$8"'"+$'&#",(&G''H+$'#9@7%$&"4'"+#"'+#>$' #..$#9$3'9$8$&"-:',&'"+$'.9$44'#9$'"+$'4#%$'#9@7%$&"4;'$>$&'74,&@' 4(%$'()'"+$'4#%$'$K#%.-$4;'74$3'"('3$)$&3'"+$'.9(@9#%'#@#,&4"',"4' ,&"$9&#-'89,",84')(79':$#94'#@(G' ' eK#%.-$4'()'4788$44'8,"$'.-("4'"+1#9"$3'(9'"$99(9,4"4'8#."79$3G''!(%$'()' "+$4$'$K#%.-$4'%#:'&("'<$'#8879#"$G''?"+$94'%#:'<$'$K#@@$9#"$3;'(9' "+$:'%#:'%#40'%790:;',&"$9&#-'#9@7%$&"4'#%(&@'(.$9#",>$4'#&3' #&#-:4"4'#<(7"'1+(4$'4(798$'.9(>$3'(7";'(9'1+,8+'-$#3'1#4'0$:G''^,>#-' 8-#,%4'()'89$3,"'()"$&'#88(%.#&:'4788$44)7-'8#4$4G'''U7"'@$"",&@',&"('#' 3$<#"$'#<(7"'1+$"+$9'"+$'5J='.9(@9#%'.9(378$3'74$)7-',&"$--,@$&8$' %,44$4'"+$'.(,&"G' ' g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d$,&;'"('.7947$'#'.9()$44,(&#-' $K#%,&#",(&'()'"+$'$%.,9,8#-'3#"#;'48,$&8$;'#&3'.4$73(R48,$&8$'4799(7&3,&@'"+$' "(.,8'()',&"$99(@#",(&G''H+$'U(#93'7-",%#"$-:'.9(378$3'#'>#-7#<-$'9$.(9"'1,"+'.#.$94' )9(%'#'>#9,$":'()'$K.$9"4G''' ' ='9$.9$4$&"#",>$'8(&8-74,(&;')9(%'#'>$"$9#&',&"$99(@#"(9'#&3')(9%$9'3,9$8"(9' ()'"+$'=,9'd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h-$,&%#&;'Xh2U=^h'5(7&"$9R J&"$--,@$&8$'J&"$99(@#",(&'^$>,$1Q'?<4$9>#",(&4'()'#&'J&"$99(@#"(9']'a$44(&4' a$#9&$3'#&3'=>$&7$4')(9'd79"+$9'^$4$#98+;Y',&'J&"$--,@$&8$'!8,$&8$'U(#93;'Educing! Information!-!Interrogation:!Science!and!Art!-!Foundations!for!the!Future! iS#4+,&@"(&;'IG5GQ'b#",(&#-'I$)$&4$'J&"$--,@$&8$'5(--$@$'*9$44;'I$8$%<$9'DEEgj;'.G' BCE'#&3'&("$'FBG' ' \ RR' 8(&4"9#,&"4',&'@$"",&@'"+$'(.",%#-'"$#%'()',&"$99(@#"(94;'4,&8$'-#1' ' $&)(98$%$&"'#&3'%,-,"#9:'$K.$9"4'8(7-3'&("'"#0$'.#9"T' ' RR' 1+$"+$9'"+$'.9(@9#%'#8"7#--:'.9(378$4'%78+'()'"+$'",%$R ' 4$&4,",>$'8799$&"',&"$--,@$&8$'"+#"',4'(&$'()',"4'7&,P7$' ' O74",),8#",(&4T' '' RR' -(44'()',&"$--,@$&8$')9(%'#--,$4'1+(')$#9'<$8(%,&@'8(%.-,8,"',&'#' ' .9(@9#%'"+$:'#<+(9'#&3'#'1+(-$'4$"'()')9$4+'.9(<-$%4'1,"+' ' 8(#-,",(&'8((.$9#",(&'(&',&"$--,@$&8$'(.$9#",(&4T' ' RR' .((9$9'9$-,#<,-,":'()',&)(9%#",(&'(<"#,&$3'"+9(7@+'"(9%$&"T'' ' RR' .(44,<-$'-(44'()'(..(9"7&,",$4'"('"79&'4(%$'8#.",>$4',&"('%(9$' ' $))$8",>$'#&3'$>$&'8((.$9#",>$',&)(9%#&"4T'#&3' ' RR' .9(<-$%4',&'3$>,4,&@'#&'$&3R@#%$')(9'"+$'$>$&"7#-'"9,#-'(9'-(&@R ' "$9%'3,4.(4,",(&'()'"+$'8#.",>$4G' ' H+,4'40$.",8,4%'#<(7"'$))$8",>$&$44'-,&04'"('1,3$9'8(&8$9&4'#<(7"'+(1' "+$'2&,"$3'!"#"$4'4+(7-3'"9$#"'8#."79$3'"$99(9,4"4'(9'"$99(9,4"'474.$8"4G'' U:'DEE_;'"+$'9#@,&@'8(&"9(>$94:'(>$9'X=<7'Z+9#,$4;'1$'),94"' #""$%."$3'"('3$>$-(.'#'[<,@'<#&@N'#..9(#8+;'#'.9$4,3$&",#-',&,",#",>$'"+#"' %,@+"'"#0$'(&'"+$'1+(-$'8-74"$9'()',447$4',&'#'4,&@-$'#&&(7&8$%$&"G''' ' H('4+(1'1+#"'478+'#&',&,",#",>$'%,@+"'-((0'-,0$'#&3'+(1',"'8(7-3'<$' .9$4$&"$3;'#&3'1,"+'+$-.')9(%'A9G'U$--,&@$9;'J'1(90$3'1,"+'"+$'3$.7":' 4$89$"#9:'()'3$)$&4$;'Z(93(&'e&@-#&3;'(&'#'O(,&"'.#.$9;'#'&(",(&#-'39#)"' ()'"+$'<7,-3,&@'<-(804'()'478+'#&',&,",#",>$G''I$.7":'!$89$"#9:'e&@-#&3' 1#4'#,3$3'<:'I?IN4'I$.7":'=44,4"#&"'!$89$"#9:')(9'3$"#,&$$'#))#,94;'A#""' S#K%#&;'#&3'("+$9'4"#))G''?79'i7&8-#44,),$3j'O(,&"'.#.$9'(7"-,&,&@'"+$' ' k $-$%$&"4'()'#'.9$4,3$&",#-',&,",#",>$'1#4'3,4"9,<7"$3',&'67&$'DEE_G''i=4' #&'#,3'"('"+$'8(%%,""$$'#'8(.:'()',"',4'#""#8+$3'#"'=&&$K'=GCj''' ' `(1$>$9'"+$'!$89$"#9:'()'I$)$&4$;'I(&#-3'^7%4)$-3;',&3,8#"$3'"+#"'"+,4' .#.$9'3,3'&("'9$.9$4$&"'+,4'I$.#9"%$&"N4'>,$14G''`$'3$4,@&#"$3'#' 3,))$9$&"'()),8,#-'#4'+,4'3$.7":')(9'"+$4$',447$4G''H+$'b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a,&34$:'Z9#+#%;',&'"+$' ' XA85#,&'=%$&3%$&"GY''' ' RR' H+$'X5JIY'4"#&3#93;'#4'8(3,),$3',&'=9",8-$'C'()'"+$'Z$&$>#' ' 5(&>$&",(&4;',4'#-4('"+$'9$-$>#&"'4"#&3#93',&'"+$')$3$9#-'1#9' ' 89,%$4'-#1'iBk'2G!G5G'4$8",(&'DWWBj'1+,8+'"+$&'4"#"$3'i,"'1#4'-#"$9' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' C'='8(.:'1#4'.9(>,3$3'"('"+$'.9$44'%(9$'"+#&'#':$#9'-#"$9;'#..#9$&"-:'<:'#'I$)$&4$' I$.#9"%$&"'4(798$G''!$$'H,%'Z(-3$&;'XI$"#,&$$'A$%('59$#"$3'I,>,3$',&'S+,"$' `(74$;Y'New!York!Times;'?8"(<$9'B;'DEEgG''H+$'.#.$9'1#4'"+$9$#)"$9'%#3$'#>#,-#<-$' "('("+$9'9$.(9"$94G' ' F ' #%$&3$3j'"+#"'#&:'8(&378"'8(&4","7",&@'#'>,(-#",(&'()'=9",8-$'C' ' 1#4'#'1#9'89,%$;'#')$-(&:'.7&,4+#<-$'<:'7.'"('-,)$',%.9,4(&%$&"G' ' H+$'#3%,&,4"9#",(&'.(4,",(&'(&'#--'"+$4$'X5JIY'#9@7%$&"4'+#3'<$$&'"+,4Q'' S$'3('&("'+#>$'"('%$#479$'(79'8(&378"'#@#,&4"'"+,4'4"#&3#93'<$8#74$' &(&$'()'"+$4$'"9$#",$4'#..-:G''J)'"+$'4"#&3#93'3,3'#..-:;'"+$'5J='.9(@9#%' 3,3'&("'>,(-#"$',"G''H+$'(7"$9'3$)$&4$4;'#'4$9,$4'()'"$8+&,8#-;'O79,43,8",(&#-' #9@7%$&"4;'+#3'9$8$,>$3'"+$'%(4"'#""$&",(&G''!#%.-$4'8#&'<$'4$$&',&'"+$' ?a5'(.,&,(&'()'A#:'CE;'DEE_G''' ' =-4(;'?a5N4'>,$1'1#4'"+#"'Z$&$>#'5(%%(&'=9",8-$'C'3,3'&("'#..-:' <$8#74$',"'1#4'%$#&"')(9'8,>,-'8(&)-,8";'&("'#&',&"$9&#",(&#-'1#9'i=9",8-$' C'1#4'19,""$&'"+#"'1#:'<$8#74$',"4'39#)"$94'"+(7@+"',&"$9&#",(&#-'1#94' 1(7-3'<$'8(>$9$3'<:')7--$9'Z$&$>#'.9("$8",(&4T'"+$:'"+(7@+"'8,>,-'1#9' 1#4'"+$'-((.+(-$'"+$:'1$9$'8-(4,&@'1,"+'"+$'%,&,%7%'4"#&3#93'()' =9",8-$'CGj''=&3;'#-"+(7@+'"+$')$3$9#-'1#9'89,%$4'4"#"7"$N4'9$)$9$&8$'"(' X8(&378"'8(&4","7",&@Y'8(7-3'<$'8(&4"97$3'#4'4"#",&@'#'47<4"#&",>$' 8(%.-,#&8$'4"#&3#93;'"+$'?a5'3,3'&("'4+#9$'"+#"'>,$1G' ' J&'DEE_'!"#"$'1(90$3'"('.$947#3$'"+$'9$4"'()'"+$'@(>$9&%$&"'"('O(,&',&' 3$>$-(.,&@'#&'(.",(&'"+#"'1(7-3'#<#&3(&'"+$4$'"$8+&,8#-'3$)$&4$4'#&3' #88$."'"+$'X5JIY'4"#&3#93G''=&',--74"9#",(&'()'"+$4$'#9@7%$&"4;'#4'%#3$' #"'"+$'",%$;',4',&'#&'7&8-#44,),$3'.#.$9'.9$.#9$3'1,"+'A9G'U$--,&@$9N4' +$-.'#&3'8,987-#"$3',&'67-:'DEE_G''J"',4'#""#8+$3'#"'=&&$K'UG''' ' U("+'3$.7",$4'#&3'.9,&8,.#-4'<#""-$3'(>$9'"+$4$'"(.,84'(&',&"('"+$')#--'()' DEE_;',&8-73,&@'"+$',447$'()'+(1'"+$'#3%,&,4"9#",(&'4+(7-3'3$#-'1,"+' !$&#"(9'A85#,&N4'.9(.(4$3'#%$&3%$&"G''b$1'.9$44'9$.(9"4;'<:'I#&#' *9,$4"',&'"+$'S#4+,&@"(&'*(4";')7$-$3')79"+$9'8(&"9(>$94:']'$4.$8,#--:',&' e79(.$G' ' U:'"+$'$&3'()'DEE_'"+$4$'3$<#"$4',&'<("+'"+$'$K$87",>$'#&3'-$@,4-#",>$' <9#&8+$4'3,3'-$#3'"('9$#-'8+#&@$G'?&'I$8$%<$9'_;'#4'!$89$"#9:'^,8$'-$)"' (&'#'e79(.$#&'"9,.;'4+$')(9%#--:'#&&(7&8$3'(&'<$+#-)'()'"+$'*9$4,3$&"' "+#"'"+$'X5JIY'4"#&3#93'1(7-3'@(>$9&'2G!G'8(&378"'<:'#&:'#@$&8:;' #&:1+$9$',&'"+$'1(9-3GW''?&'I$8$%<$9'CE'"+$'A85#,&'#%$&3%$&"'i"('#' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' W'*$9+#.4'8(,&8,3$&"#--:;'5J='()),8,#-4'3$4"9(:$3'$K,4",&@'>,3$("#.$4'()',"4'8($98,>$' ,&"$99(@#",(&4',&'"+,4'4#%$'",%$'.$9,(3;',&'b(>$%<$9'DEE_G' ' BE 3$)$&4$'#..9(.9,#",(&4'<,--j'1#4'4,@&$3',&"('-#1'#4'1$--;'#4'"+$'I$"#,&$$' H9$#"%$&"'=8"'()'DEE_G'' ' H+74'<:'$#9-:'DEEg'"+$9$'1#4'&('1#:')(9'"+$'#3%,&,4"9#",(&'"('#>(,3'"+$' &$$3'"('9$$>#-7#"$'"+$'5J='.9(@9#%'#@#,&4"'#'X5JIY'4"#&3#93G''H+$'1(90' ()'"+$'b!5'3$.7",$4',&"$&4,),$3;'1(90,&@'"('3$>$-(.'#'8(%.9$+$&4,>$'4$"' ()'.9(.(4#-4')(9'.9$4,3$&",#-'3$8,4,(&'#<(7"'"+$')7"79$'()'"+$'5J=' .9(@9#%'#&3'"+$')7"79$'()'Z7#&"#&#%(G''' ' H+$'?a5'+#3'@7#93$3'#@#,&4"'"+$'8(&",&@$&8:'()'#'47<4"#&",>$'X5JIY' 9$>,$1',&',"4'A#:'CE;'DEE_'(.,&,(&G''?a5'+#3'+$-3'"+#";'$>$&',)'"+$' 4"#&3#93'3,3'#..-:;'"+$')7--'5J='.9(@9#%'RR',&8-73,&@'1#"$9<(#93,&@']' 8(%.-,$3'1,"+',"G''H+,4'?a5'>,$1'#-4('%$#&";',&'$))$8";'"+#"'"+$'A85#,&' #%$&3%$&"'1#4'#'&7--,":T',"'1(7-3'&("'.9(+,<,"'"+$'>$9:'.9(@9#%'#&3' .9(8$379$4'!$&#"(9'A85#,&'#&3'+,4'47..(9"$94'"+(7@+"'"+$:'+#3' "#9@$"$3G' ' !(;'1,"+'"+$'<#""-$'"('#..-:'"+$'4"#&3#93'+#>,&@'<$$&'1(&;'!"#"$'"+$&' +#3'"('),@+"'#&("+$9'<#""-$'(>$9'+(1'"('3$),&$',"4'%$#&,&@G''H+#"'%$#&"' 8(%,&@'"('@9,.4'1,"+'?a5N4'47<4"#&",>$'#&#-:4,4G' ' ?a5'8(&"$&3$3'"+#"'"+$4$'47$'"$9%4']'-,0$'X897$-Y'(9'X+7%#&$Y'RR' 4+(7-3'<$',&"$9.9$"$3',&'-,@+"'()'"+$'1$--'3$>$-(.$3'#&3'#&#-(@(74' 9$4"9,8",(&4')(7&3',&'=%$9,8#&'8(&4","7",(&#-'-#1;'4.$8,),8#--:'"+9(7@+' "+$',&"$9#8",(&'()'"+$'_"+;'k"+;'#&3'BW"+'#%$&3%$&"4'"('"+$'2G!G' 5(&4","7",(&G''=4'?a5'(<4$9>$3',&',"4'A#:'CE'(.,&,(&;'"+$'5(&@9$44'+#3' 8(&3,",(&$3',"4'9#",),8#",(&'()'(&$'()'"+$'X5JIYR":.$'4"#&3#934;'"+$'(&$' )(7&3',&'"+$'5(&>$&",(&'=@#,&4"'H(9"79$;'(&',"4'<$,&@',&"$9.9$"$3',&'O74"' "+,4'1#:G' ' H+$9$)(9$;'"('8+#--$&@$'?a5N4',&"$9.9$"#",(&;',"'1#4'&$8$44#9:'"(' 8+#--$&@$'"+$'674",8$'I$.#9"%$&"N4',&"$9.9$"#",(&'()'2G!G'8(&4","7",(&#-' -#1G''H+,4'1#4'&("'$#4:;'4,&8$'?a5',4'"+$'#7"+(9,"#",>$',&"$9.9$"$9'()' 478+'-#1')(9'"+$'$K$87",>$'<9#&8+'()'"+$'@(>$9&%$&"G''A#&:':$#94' $#9-,$9'J'+#3'1(90$3',&'"+,4'#9$#'()'=%$9,8#&'8(&4","7",(&#-'-#1G''H+$' ?a5',&"$9.9$"#",(&'()'2G!G'8(&4","7",(&#-'-#1',&'"+,4'#9$#'4$$%$3' 4"9#,&$3'#&3',&3$)$&4,<-$G''J"'9$-,$3'(&'#'X4+(804'"+$'8(&48,$&8$Y' 4"#&3#93',&'O73@,&@',&"$99(@#",(&4'<7"'3,3'&("'4$$%'"('.9$4$&"'#')#,9' 9$#3,&@'()'"+$'8#4$-#1'7&3$9'"+#"'4"#&3#93G''H+$'?a5'#&#-:4,4'#-4(' ' BB &$@-$8"$3'#&("+$9',%.(9"#&"'-,&$'()'8#4$-#1;'(&'8(&3,",(&4'()' 8(&),&$%$&"G''' ' S+,-$'?a5N4',&"$9.9$"#",(&4'()'("+$9'#9$#4'()'-#1'1$9$'1$--'0&(1&'"('<$' 8(&"9(>$94,#-;'J'3,3'&("'<$-,$>$'%:'8(--$#@7$4'+#3'+$#93'#9@7%$&"4' 8+#--$&@,&@'"+$'1#:'?a5'+#3'#&#-:L$3'"+$4$'8(&4","7",(&#-'9,@+"4G''S,"+' "+$',447$'()'X5JIY'3$),&,",(&'&(1'9#,4$3'4('4P7#9$-:;'#&3'4(',%.(9"#&"'"(' "+$'(.",(&4'<$,&@'3$>$-(.$3')(9'"+$'*9$4,3$&";',"'4$$%$3'&$8$44#9:'"(' .7"'"+#"'-$@#-'8+#--$&@$',&')9(&"'()'%:'@(>$9&%$&"'8(--$#@7$4;'8,",&@' 9$-$>#&"'8#4$-#1G' ' d79"+$9;'"+$'?a5'.(4,",(&'+#3',%.-,8#",(&4'<$:(&3'"+$',&"$9.9$"#",(&'()' ,&"$9&#",(&#-'"9$#",$4G''J)'"+$'5J='.9(@9#%'.#44$3'%74"$9'7&3$9'#&' =%$9,8#&'8(&4","7",(&#-'8(%.-,#&8$'#&#-:4,4;'"+$&']'#"'-$#4"',&'.9,&8,.-$' RR'#'.9(@9#%'()'"+,4'0,&3'1(7-3'.#44'=%$9,8#&'8(&4","7",(&#-'%74"$9' $>$&',)'$%.-(:$3'#&:1+$9$',&'"+$'2&,"$3'!"#"$4;'(&'=%$9,8#&'8,",L$&4G'' ^$)-$8"'(&'"+#"')(9'#'%(%$&"G' ' J'3,4"9,<7"$3'%:'%$%('#&#-:L,&@'"+$4$'-$@#-',447$4'"('("+$9'3$.7",$4'#"' (&$'()'(79'%$$",&@4;'.9(<#<-:',&'d$<97#9:'DEEgG''J'-#"$9'+$#93'"+$'%$%(' 1#4'&("'8(&4,3$9$3'#..9(.9,#"$')(9')79"+$9'3,48744,(&'#&3'"+#"'8(.,$4'()' %:'%$%('4+(7-3'<$'8(--$8"$3'#&3'3$4"9(:$3G''H+#"'.#9",87-#9'9$P7$4";' .#44$3'#-(&@',&)(9%#--:;'3,3'&("'4$$%'.9(.$9'#&3'J',@&(9$3',"G''H+,4' .#9",87-#9'-$@#-'%$%('+#4'$>,3$&"-:'<$$&'-(8#"$3',&'!"#"$N4'),-$4G''J"',4' 8799$&"-:'<$,&@'9$>,$1$3')(9'.(44,<-$'3$8-#44,),8#",(&G' ' H+$'<9(#3$9'#9@7%$&"4'(>$9'"+$')7"79$'()'"+$'5J='.9(@9#%'1$&"'(&')(9' %(&"+4;'$>$&'"+(7@+'"+$'(-3'.9(@9#%'+#3'$))$8",>$-:'<$$&'3,48(&",&7$3G'' H+$9$'1$9$'8(&",&7,&@',447$4'(>$9'1+$"+$9'(9'+(1'"('%#,&"#,&'#' 3,))$9$&"'0,&3'()'5J='.9(@9#%G''U("+'.9,&8,.#-4'#&3'3$.7",$4'$K#%,&$3' .9(.(4#-4'"('<9,&@'"+$'+,@+R>#-7$'3$"#,&$$4'(7"'()'"+$'[<-#80'4,"$4N'#&3'"(' Z7#&"#&#%('1+$9$'"+$:'8(7-3'<$'<9(7@+"'"('O74",8$'i#&3'1(7-3'@,>$' #88(7&"4'()'"+$,9'"9$#"%$&"'"('-#1:$94'#&3'"+$'^$3'59(44jT'4$$0' -$@,4-#",(&'"+#"'1(7-3'8-(4$'Z7#&"#&#%(T'#88$."')7--:'"+$'#..-,8#",(&'()' 5(%%(&'=9",8-$'CT'#&3'),&3'4(%$'1#:'()'%#,&"#,&,&@'#'4"#&3<:'5J=' .9(@9#%'"+#"'1(7-3'8(%.-:'1,"+'-$@#-'4"#&3#934G''='&$1'?a5'(.,&,(&' 1#4'#-4('<$,&@'3$>$-(.$3',&'"+$'4.9,&@'()'DEEg'"('3$#-'1,"+'"+$'3,))$9$&"' 8,987%4"#&8$4;',&8-73,&@'"+$'A85#,&'#%$&3%$&"G''S$'#"'!"#"$'1$9$' ' BD 8(&8$9&$3'#<(7"'"+,4'3$>$-(.%$&";'7&-$44'?a5'+#3'9$8(&4,3$9$3'+(1'"(' ,&"$9.9$"'"+$'X5JIY'4"#&3#93G' '' S$'&(&$"+$-$44'<$-,$>$3'"+$4$',447$4'1$9$'%(>,&@',&'#&'$&8(79#@,&@' 3,9$8",(&;'"+(7@+'"+$'#3%,&,4"9#",(&'8$9"#,&-:'9$%#,&$3'3,>,3$3G'' ?.",(&4')(9'#8",(&'(&'#--'"+$'%#O(9',447$4'+#3'<$$&'3$>$-(.$3')(9' .(44,<-$'.9$4,3$&",#-'3$8,4,(&'#&3'+#3'#-9$#3:'<$$&'3,48744$3' 9$.$#"$3-:'<:'"+$'.9,&8,.#-'()),8$94'()'"+$'@(>$9&%$&"G''' ' H+$&;'(&'67&$'DF;'"+$'2G!G'!7.9$%$'5(79"'3$8,3$3'Hamdan!v.!Rumsfeld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i1+,8+'<$8#%$'"+$'A,-,"#9:' 5(%%,44,(&4'=8"j'#&3'3$)$&3$3'"+$'&$$3')(9'4(%$'8(&",&7,&@'5J=' .9(@9#%'"+#"'1(7-3'8(%.-:'1,"+'9$-$>#&"'-#1G''*9$4,3$&"'U74+' #&&(7&8$3'"+$4$'3$8,4,(&4'(&'!$."$%<$9'gG' ' J'-$)"'"+$'@(>$9&%$&"'#"'"+$'$&3'()'DEEg'#&3'9$"79&$3'"('"+$'2&,>$94,":' ()'f,9@,&,#G'''U("+'!$89$"#9:'^,8$'#&3'A9G'U$--,&@$9'9$%#,&$3'3$$.-:' ,&>(->$3',&'"+$4$',447$4')(9'"+$')(--(1,&@'"1(':$#94;'1(90,&@')(9' 8(&4"978",>$'8+#&@$G''A9G'U$--,&@$9;',&'.#9",87-#9;'#-4('3$4$9>$4'89$3,"')(9' $K+#74",&@;'.#",$&"'3,.-(%#8:'"('8#99:')(91#93'"+$',3$#'()'1(90,&@'1,"+' (79'0$:'#--,$4'"('<7,-3'8(%%(&;'8(#-,",(&'#..9(#8+$4'(&'"+$4$'"(7@+' .9(<-$%4G''`$'+#4'8(&378"$3'4$>$9#-',&"$9&#",(&#-'8(&)$9$&8$4'"+#"' +#>$'4788$44)7--:'#3>#&8$3'"+,4'$))(9"G' ' H+$'2G!G'@(>$9&%$&"'#3(."$3'#&'7&.9$8$3$&"$3'.9(@9#%'()'8((--:' 8#-87-#"$3'3$+7%#&,L,&@'#<74$'#&3'.+:4,8#-'"(9%$&"'"('$K"9#8"' ,&)(9%#",(&G''H+,4'1#4'#'%,4"#0$;'.$9+#.4'#'3,4#4"9(74'(&$G''J"'1#4'#' 8(--$8",>$')#,-79$;',&'1+,8+'#'&7%<$9'()'()),8,#-4'#&3'%$%<$94'()' 5(&@9$44'i#&3'4"#))$94j'()'<("+'.#9",$4'.-#:$3'#'.#9";'$&3(94,&@'#'5J=' ' BC .9(@9#%'()'.+:4,8#-'8($98,(&'$>$&'#)"$9'"+$'A85#,&'#%$&3%$&"'1#4' .#44$3'#&3'#)"$9'"+$'`#%3#&'3$8,4,(&'G''*9$8,4$-:'<$8#74$'"+,4'1#4'#' 8(--$8",>$')#,-79$',"',4'#--'"+$'%(9$',%.(9"#&"'"('8(%.9$+$&3',";'#&3'-$#9&' )9(%',"G' ' d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e-$%$&"4'()'*(44,<-$'J&,",#",>$Y'i67&$'DEE_j' =&&$K'UQ''XI$"#,&$$4']'H+$'b$$3')(9'#'!"9(&@$9'a$@#-'d9#%$1(90Y'i67-:' ' DEE_j' =&&$K'5Q''/$-,0(1'8G>G' '' ' BW