CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA Case CCT 121/16 In the matter between: THE MINISTER OF ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS Applicant and OHAN KRUGER First Re5pondent JOHN HUME Second Respondent WILDLIFE RANCHING SOUTH AFRICA Third Respondent THE PRIVATE RHINO OWNERS ASSOCIATION Fourth Respondent ORDER DATED 30 MARCH 2017 CORAM: Nkabinde ADCJ, Cameron J, Froneman J, afta Khampepe Madlanga J, Mhlantla J, Mojapelo AJ, Protorius AJ and Zondo J. This Court has considered the application for leave to appeal. It has concluded that the application should be dismissed with costs as it lacks reasonable prospects of SUCCESS. Order: . The application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs. @camaa KGWADI MAKGAKGA REGISTRAR THE COURT BAG FULL 29 MAR 2017 2017 GRIFFIEH VizH Mina.? ?or 2/ 3 CONSTITUTIONAL COURT TO: THE STATE ATTORNEY, PRETORIA Attorney for the Applicant 316 Salu Building Comer Thabo Sehurne and Francis-Bean Streets PRETORIA Email: Watubatuba@justice.gov.za Ref: 8286/2012/279 c/o MOTHLE JOOMA SABDIA INC 50 Saint David Road Houghton JOHANNESBURG Tel: 012 362 3137 Fax: 086 564 7375 Email: Ref.: Jooma /nl THE12.0010 AND TO: ERWEE ATTORNEYS Attorneys for the First Respondent Ref: c/o DYASON INCORPORATED 134 Muckleneuk Street Nieuw Muckleneuk PRETORIA Tel: 012 452 3500 Fax: 012 452 3699/7 Email: gous@dyason.co.za Ref: Gous Lowe MAT83334 c/o KERN ATTORNEYS Albury Of?ce Park Albury road Hyde Park OHANNEBURG Email: litigation@kernattomeys.co.za Ref: AND TO: SEYMORE DU TOIT AND BASSON ATTORNEYS Attorneys fer the Second Respondent Tel: 013 752 4456 05-04-17;Oli44 i 3/ 3 Fax: 086 653 5584 Email: idutoit@sdblaw.co.za Ref: I DU TOIT GAR8 0077 c/o BROOKS AND BRAATVEDT ATTORNEYS 203 Jan Smuts Avenue Parktown North JOHANNESBURG Tel: 011 788 7707 Email: trish@bandbinc.co.za Ref: Mr. Alec Brooks AND TO: MUNRO, FLOWERS VERMAAK ATTORNEYS Attorneys ?x the Third and Fourth Respondents c/o VAN DER LINDE ATTORNEYS Floor 457 Rodericks Road PRETORIA Email: kv@rnfv.co.za Ref: C.J. Prinsloo vn cler Linde/ji/MAT24186