Court Fi1e No. ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE N: HELENA GUERGIS Plaintiff - and - V. RAYMOND OVAK, ARTHUR HAMILTON, CASSELS BROCK BLACKVVELL LLP, THE RIGHT HONOURABLE STEPHEN HARPER, GUY GIORNO, SHELLY GLOVER, THE HONOURABLE LISA RAITT, AXELLE PELLERIN, CONSERVATIVE PARTY OF CANADA and DERRICK SN OWDY Defendants NOTICE OF MOTION OF THE DEFENDANT GUY GIORNO (Motion to Strike) asv, aa The Defendant Guy Giorno ["Gi0rno"] will make a Motion to the Court, on a-d-ate-m 7/ at the Courthouse, 161 Elgin Street, Ottawa, Ontario, KZP ZK1. PROPOSED MQETHOD OF HEARING: The Motion is to be heard: in Writing under subnne 37. 12.1( 1) because it is on consent; in Writing as an opposed motion under subrule ora11y. ."cz1---fG.) .-D brought This action ES vi O. H1 G10 ding others inclu and 4% cd UD Chief nof ctio dire CD ~w fi; he was Working nh pled by the Canada. A of inister 6 7 sub ect to been has <13 w\ bl) other ong 3111 alleges, .2 ii? 3 QD cd v--4 C) >>-511 3 od allegations *cn "Ei U.) i>w made her ns against alle gatio OHS vari Q53 .51 and fraud. HG cai CO of S6 her tentional -5-1 BLS tal suffering SH ed With in ict infl and conduct. acted Giorno, .E "ca inclu his advisorsand the Office of the RC he I1 tio alle ga S6 `gthe di (D sa .-D if--I CD CL EL .Q She O11 missi ["Etl1ics Co Sl' ission Co Ethics 3,11 st tere 3.11 Cf 3.8 du iniste1"s con Prime he dt 311 describes Giorno's STOUS I1 and asserts makes Claim di LD causes of action. OHSPIYZCY 10 3 U5 4? 'gg CES 1+--C5 -"x-in ti ,sri ll-1 -2 oi vi v--5--4 s:I` .S G) ng onspiracy to ofa O11 allegati An 3 cu CJ fl) -fadvanced as a separate othing. claims, adds oh ~r-4 'Tj OCS (D C-L4 ended SIT C.) cg; .521 sri 3 3 8 33 fr.-Cl 3 CD ui <15 WH 4-1 sues of a poli IS iable -rs FA :s .ci U) G.) (JJ 'za L4-4 can Moreover, the exatiousacy must conspir +Accordin ture. Ct! Cl leave to amend. Defamation icipated in he part because bl) G.) all Claim cu .Ili Ev--1 cd L4--ff-C1ission Il'lI'1'1 Ce CM issioner that the Prime Minister's ofice had Co The letter advised the RC l6_ lo-c cerning the conduct C011 vity CU al crirnirr 621W .-been advised had -r-4 4% CCS uf S1 of the allegatio lmovvledge .J-'ll l-Fi sri .If-"1 co 12 <11 and OPP. cated to the RC that the allegations had already been eo acting on 3.S IT1 io lute privilegeation unic CO This l7highest officer of sta he ister, in alf of the Prime eh ssioner. Co other officer of state, the 251 KD ,Ci nj 4-A ere themselves officers of sta Novak and H1 Gio Furthermore, od Sl' aft subject cn r-C21 EM ui fu se of their official duti CO in the "3 l'/J G3 $22 .2 ce .2 mal .-C3 4-7 of sta IS matte volved in I1 CO cu 'fi' LH ca 6_3 G.) la* _no .FSI -iz: 0.) H--1 .-C3 -f-4 CD cn CL sofa gation alle rn 2 cd 3 TS -1privilege can only CD L13 -f-1 C6 I3 "5 ?3 UD ege. il priv led 3-6-4 cd 13 PN U.) (D 5-G C1-1 U) 'r-4 C) cu ii Guergis S. alic IH HS O11 tmicati Q) LH CU 2111 dorriih he deift be set asi ia" narit ose 1--4 v-~malicethe Claim related to malice, with the exception of the liideed, any statements void below, are de paragraph (D #53 ent described 3 CG bald assertions. of nsist solely "Cf -vshown C6 mali '.-constitu issiorier. This does no $351 Iii? QD -3 Q) T3 3 L-4 ?3-i 4-J fl) rg ll--.-CYS .-Cl _rn Eb Guer malice. o's H1 Gio that "cs DI) C15 faili malicious, or that by be would (D 's <4-4 U3 v-1?-lice. 3. IH 21S HW `catio C.) of the SS iriarit IH do that was 61' a lett ith Sl' ovide on to pr ti a posi -v-4 (H cd 3 v--4 Cland sign vered eli 'cation to the RC CO the din form ts vilege, the statemen C14 +4 sa an cd ei ou (1) C.) -r-4 mi (1) a report stitute C011 They defamatory. Il() BIG 'ssi Co CD ,ef sn CG nform 1 13 .3 .E E- #1 'v-1 activ mal rim ofc ClSH. seriou this conveys (specifically lett "Sill CD $3 cd C10 lle SSBoiir $611 office has rn Q) rn 2 nm5O?U?Om gm OM S0333 MEMWEDHEW ME 8 QOENEH QOEQN MO 358 QEQOQE Am 206% OH Emdmw EB _gag Ent mmOWwm5Ow% 203 5% wig Op QOEWE EH MOSES mmOEmDQm% OW OO gg wg E5 P05200 MO QE Emw5Om@ 5% mga QOEWENHDQ wg Hwang gp "Em MOM QOQE CHO WEE 05 EBM Egg mg 63500 MO ?1300 UHMEQOMQQN Ep mg, Smawg OU gum 05 8 GOQECOWE 25 _mO?wU`mg? gm nga #03500 MSOZ wg M3232 "wang 0% AOEOWG HOW EQOHQEW 53 MSE E503 HW EDDUGM OM Um Mug MO NQOQHS E5 556 gp mg! QOENEQPE gm mum VMDOMMH MO HE QEM 03620 HN EOM 83002 5% WO DS "Wg DQEGBDQ OH Q50 M63 H5 VELHM Op gg HN EHS 295 MQOZ "Om Danni" EW H223 6030 Dgum 23 QOEQDE 0% OP EMWSOE H53 QOMEDEV EP OH EKVOEH nun# MO DQUUEOGM BM OM gg GOQB OO gm MO SEE E033 mg _Ugg 0% OH EQOEQ OO 53 wg QHEO Aw WHOEMMSAW MEM E5 H52 mg VEPOZ ESE QOUROED OO MEM ?30302 of a political issue cover, the Plaintiff raises non-justiciable exatious. Mor andv OU ith ck be stru St O11 defainati relates it 3.8 G11 ture. Accordingly, the acti Cd $31 leave to amend. 3 r-1 C) Misfeasance in Pu --4 in pub IIC SB. misfea '53 intiff alleges la The 27. ve noted of the abo r--'33 D-1 'r-4 .2 Q4 se he 3.ll office bec ISSIOZISII Co letter to the RC er letter was sen anoth 3 cd 3 3 Ei -o-1 -2 cd .-Cl alleges Sh 28. issioner. to the Ethics 'ill4-4 453'33 53v--3,5 that she CU ific spec 4.2 (D and Cabin onservative"] fd cd arty of provided. cn Conservativ articulars are -1--4 (1) 5-4 removal or her in $3 ce culrnin VS the abo "Ei .iff 33 cd U3 rgis UC 31 Conservative caucus and Cabinet. (1) LE (4--4 CJ Y-conduct 'rL.-4 lg' 5 3 3 Q4 1- NUC Z9 _gwmm N: QOESOW m@U< 0306 MQSUQUMQQ Ep _gg QR Am; Am; UDWH UDWH h'M8uw> UDQM _muwom QE Zo "gmac "gg Egm AMQA DJNEZEL i NH NSN 6 bw; GOVVLING LAFLEUR HENDERSON LLP AND TO: no 1.1 Street K1P 1C3 gin 160 E1 a, ON NO C3 Q2 00214: 93 'Him 1.1 Wagner, LSUC cl G. Dearden, ee up 613 786 0213 '1`e1: 613 788 3642 Pax: Pe11erin 2 4-5 3 8 8 +4 yers for Law OODS LLP STOC AND TO: 8 8 58 ab ei; *aa-9358 E824 *gd EOQQE 8 2 Toronto, ON DD vm EE mm mn-4 416 593 2491 Te1: 416 593 9345 Fax: O21 Arthur Hamih: ce F3-4 1-I cd '55 <58 Cassels Brook ants Q) <15 Lawyers fo PERLEY-ROBERTSON, HILL MCDOUGALL LLP AND TO: 40 Albert St. 2 (DFG Bo S3 Ottawa, ON K1R 0A5 613 238 2808 Tel: 613 238 8775 Fax: ce rd LH Conservative Party 6 8 8 CH <13 Lawyers for the <1 HELENA GUERGIS - and - V. NOVAK, et al. Plaintiff Defendants Court File No. l1>>~532l0 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE Proceeding commenced at Ottawa NOTICE OF MOTION FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN LLP Lawyers Suite 1300, 55 Metcalfe Street Ottawa ON KIP 6L5 Peter N. Mantas, LSUC #35269 Marisa E. Victor, LSUC #5206?Be-fi" 5 Alexandra Logvin, LSUC #580 2V twat _ara Tel: 613 236 3882 Fax; 613 230 6423 Lawyers forthe defendant Guy Glomo