CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page UNITED ECURT ?ll-"1 .1. .- Jul;r1 E. mi, ELaintiIL. . Emuri File Him I DESEIH Ill] Jrun nelchenl_ IJis?tszt Pk). $35; ?aietiu ELiium, un? in he: Capituit?r 5 Hart ., TrlLilalJL-l?ll in :19: [dF?E?j-EEz-r SciendunL?. h. HEHNER. taken I-I .. pur?ja?t Lu Taking at H.512 Eagle [Cl-?115?. my] Di Ducumtcr, EDIE. belong Fully L. Hf?d?, cmqr: Hz!? the {Azuunt'y Pf and Hur??y PLblic in and Parnrr'enrj "my .51 I. ?a WY _l Exhihi1 CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 2 of 57 9 3] 1L Uh-?gg. in the: right Hate:- ['quuIJL-s 111.3 i 5; 173:1? rat: E. . Why did yuu prnvi?c the G-m?il? ED My Firm in JIIEprteri-i': 1.11 a I pr?uidmd the e?maLls I've been aninq dilfigufcy with my numpnter. I have Lulders With all my prevf?us 1:1 ran-d my awn pr?bl?ma. JUS: i? my CQEPULEF waEn'L marking am if artide:tuiiy dv'?T?d anythi?uaztgd Lu have 311 I :911?1't Hake hwrc, w?nra? FLJ *0 have all 2.1 e1 . . . a] nv'I: TIT. I. Sithim. rm! I: H71"?r Isun;m:; raid THIL I I I 'j .- 1'13Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 3 of 57 ILTI 13-. funny"? "3355 .1 5 .1 Ir -. :L'Jlnl, :1 {1:11.35 "5'41 'fJ? '95 .'.hI'rI'Jgi'I 'iiv?fl, um? Eng"; and wk?r? are yum nurrently ampluv?dy 7 3?1 Hall High Am] is you .1 l. 9 ?nlf? Gf 1 My tuannh pasitiuu is ninth grade damn . .- 13 i'm Earryu graj: PI. gas?Jr] {If 1. is: ?nd hm: 3.er hatl'I :1 I: :71 Lin? 1 E. H. :3 find l' ft: ill-:SITE-.31: J. 1 3 --.Lil-J--. Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 4 of 57 5:1. LE If) A . F'lel Stilt: ., :3 . were I .. r?azhing r? win left. SainL Paul ?15 in trying hr 1 II 3:31.! 1. 13LES-LN. .-1.. rayzig?thn: my Pur?j?nul were ions. The las; Lima? 3 think. ma; {green u;r. . kilieu:h In; mi tima Lney Hr?? [i'fJ'iJ'i-IJ t? 1 - Ei'l?L' ul . .H 3? I1 5:51Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 5 of 57 LaIIJ"vrquL'l?TI?l .IL I THE 5;a. and whaL 15 :?ucaL'unal rhuroundJ Ha pin: fur educaLimn a BA [Timinal and haLf a More than hw?f. I dan'L know master'a in eduuaLinn. when. I?lun'abeLuLJam: wt]: b-ili?l. Paul Publ d?h??l?r d3? regardLnu uh; safety a: EaihL Pan} Schoolu? ESCHEWIIRD: l'n' tc- THE guc?tlmn a5 JTar;y urn?d. Thii'Jt 3:31 LC a. 1 if 3km; mm ?llS?r-?JL .i Ely-CurLzla Iii]; [gm val-IE. Ii: Yea, d;d. HE . "fl - ExhibiLA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 6 of 57 . . .l f;ght: L: hrmken the atud WL '13! th&L Jana-31LLLHI. I Icag c:?2uur::mr:. I Hamid an: vLci?uE thz?? h?ihq ghI wnwl? bx Fights uni :hq . . hAJnnIn u. hay?, .11.: their J. 5533-4] I'e-tlrf in {at - an: wh? assauiLHd ma hd?k -- bash in my thi? tan mindt??. Hare injured? Hg, waan?L injured. 53y gnu had wu?uIy FGHCEIHS, WHEN yam NEH, leate ta Elementary scha?l. midd;e 5 m: I Juat ?ltm??LHF? --I.- .3. - - .nu Hm; b_cLLmI?1a Lty; TEH hJ my waa happnn wr19?1 er 1 EII lrnf?rsfii?ulJ an 1 - . CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 7 of 57 I'mLia-f: arm has: Hm! wrrwi-r- 5 isriri' iL? Lu 1h,- . "=:irj h? t;nku Lih? absolutcig';xihnin$ anile??n the -i -r riqht back L0 my nians. Was Caucasian 0r wa: I?ll; i [:91 I1 I .H. n3 5 If? .?frican can? I'iil?y' . {Ii-Ci FEE-.1 Lililrl; strike Hi? yam ever dincusa ymur ?ai?gy with farmer Supra-i1: Silvia? J. .i -tI' . Mhuu did ymu hauu Lhnsa diduu?aiwna? Ram-Tit?) {111154, fii'l'fi the [5.1 :1 hand? Day wn? Laid, iro?i?qliv, at Benjami? E. M331. nay to Jun? w?af G;d yum ilt'L?J 5-33- L.-.: HilvEli-J .?ihlj idrau?q a_t?L DELLExhibit f-?i CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 8 of 57 I. LR.- 1. I .- -. .-- ITI I'll: :7er .- rr -. ..I -. . Ir'e JJ- I i?Ji--un-v :.gr.n -Ina II I T?l? -- the p??l - .. - JI . Sh? liaLcueH. Fi?h ch:anwF9:l:JIp BIND I hu?i aIIj I tculnl kl 51' HEW racial equity galjnies were playing rmlu IHLU Lha l?vej 3f but i t?ld her abauL .. he my ?n?unfl, and she :3 hair, and I t?$d -. 1a? . 1- I Couldn?t belimru she HHS dat'L I hEr I [3-551 hair, bicause :hL In?lmw?pal, a; Lhu Ifm?, was a mi ice-Hrif; I.r1 fmu any yam . ah?ut ?In: 5 r, H. "gull. w.5 I In LIExhibit? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 9 of 57 5-.- I .3 Ii: .Il. --ILinn? i I waa a mmati?? my] 3.II. I.I Lhze 1.11339 war-?Ir: cumin: Ell?11.515) E. 1 rm idea what gming an anther LI [Incl Lhe Pacific (lir?up, it; that Lh? y?u had with? a Thail'rr I lr'I'L 1 CI Ir" LEI. t: I'f'r II..I I. .- 5.311Er"- In -. .P . I it) r-rI'I-gnt fh?i: ?LaLl:Ir Inc; I?l'i I. 'Illv'JEWWHA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page que Evy Dill-lr_ Superb: rhe level w: {If the reporkeI.} HH . .I.- he: 1 .. diELliun jnwi hirea Lhe :1 Ful?ll i fit-r I.I-Ir.? r. I. it 5-3 1' reapuIIij-Cl 5.1 . f?ld Her . II :Jifhi?t Ip In I .Id-Iul -l .: L-r ..Illn 1.: and r7113. 3 new cananlLing ..?Iiri Lil .5 :i "3611 .i 711-?- .E-i'l-i-E and I -r .- ..-.- 17" .- II -'nrnf rjmc? a! fix-1 . I {hi pie? II Ilr. E: - I IIExhibit f-?I CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 11 of 57 i SCWIS in iriiwnlf, :?ilih? ?artrr.r a rrHirfrE- raj r1r r:i LH1 a; Echg' =13h 1' I and High futzi' 4 hlsming white teachc;: :wr rhe Igra LE 5 en cetana- HTECE a Jisaqreeing with ihau. That Jezta? wax published and naiieved a -- :uruived a attentimn. felt bad a lot 3f 3 int 3 agreeing wiLh mu, an wanted Lu iE Cleax Lhu aiL. h? my?all, addreasad th: achuui hmard Hec&mb&: DF 2611 by mya?if, and I _l Tfen I Said IL: Cf i5 _ncree?inf-Iiz'J' [La :1th lb blgiq ljl?ih Igl?fh ulid? FEST LU thvuarv Edig. L7 '3 kt=1 -. E. atgw* 1 "I'll? 1' I Tin?. 1 ::ch 3 rra: u? 1-. I I II I'l' I 1-Exhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 12 of 57 h1g ?rLiu_d wrote, i: HJF '2'1'12 El?pfiujll. in 113.5;le 17:117. gzjriug, [in 1191.33.35: [5.35 1n the Etc-gr T'Jzil'} the Press Faciliu Enuratianal and I had letter Lha; in the Piuuw?r Press called Thy LI: r?ie IECwmn. A tleumr:ljt f:?n:li19 I?srneet? L?rnru ab?ut my Ln the editor. The Pimnewr FFTEH trim ThlEi Lt"- first lrJI: ft} .wn uhnut it. "he 4.- an] it} FLUJCJI my ihktar t3 the in Lh?ir - Exmb?? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page n-uw, I U4H1L [all ugJ -- ILLJ 1C.3:l. [I-Wcth .dl?1c1. 11335;: WEEH -- --.- . . tL' ran-1: one, I Lalken abuu: my Star? H?inr Paul VugLic the vimlwn?e, haw 1L Hm? I. inireasinq, Hn? 5m Earth. BE ME. VILLEHME: a; NuuL wua gnu: FUIPUJU nf talking wiLh the 1H mndim in all thc?e iHL?rviaws and 1- LG EMEGEJAE LIHMI hf?d I 2+.5 Lryin: La a LR LargeLEJ. MAR i'i W'ua Ia; IwarI, in 1d 1 hm; than I r?elixej ??ljfi?? w&r? Ihat I :txhc beer (If 15 were inpiamantgd, a I :eeJli FECJ tlau? taqur.! inW WEE -- kn%w tagg'uw re (Vil?q -IrqL,L_ug - wl' II . i n" I l'IIrrw . I II :1 I Exhibit? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 14 of 57 Ir "Hf; I -r rhea-3191:: 3? wafer Em?; wI't-T-n I-n mm" 7.- J. in?: ?f I: -l Pan. in tum-r wanld liffht? at E5 Mayan Fin-ii ilk-5': :?iaJ'd, wa-Lll?' happen. Tht?r rum-lent i grifll. attrititkeri and nothing *3 tapperz?ci, i' realizing I hat: 1M Lia: If] never -- n'm-n't 3-31: hiL, ll :m when I113: arm we 173135315 gbcul; this. .Li; I En'rr- 1 wag-.1 in him ?ff'lC-L. IE: hlf?fl i'iJ'J-Ili'w'. EACH-3 1i "T?lj 7 Emmi you haw-rs.- yam cat?L'L i. El ?nal-Ed EIL- and EH'l'i lea. {Thur Lalxcul isfig--I I- i aw-?L'-.-. 'Exhibit .5. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 15 of 57 - .EI.. [Lln1.. t.fplg nudguL LJHJ r? EC My supetniuur my IFLELLZ, Fj?Lf 1 351$. ?mbfil, I 'n a m?km :h a raga black Student g3: Etta ted by a blank man. thj?ltg .1 }m3] H?thiJ Lo dm PH th ??Wld he hHEh-hushad n: wauld try 2m quic: me aL my meat ng?, an :hat'a the Leagnn way I 1. talked uanL 1L. I'm going ta refer yen ED EaLeu ?38, whjuh J'fi 1. I'd 515:}; "311? tn TDDK 51L Burg-3:3 WhaL dra Ratea ?53, #59? 433, and Lmli me: I'll- il . Iii-'3' '15 CH. 1153 E?n 1&3: 3 HT 5: 115-] i in: with out Read; Day me?Lan and being ?hlw ta I HES manning. Ln}; .I . tn fa;L Lu her, meanI ;ikq . . - .I .r .. -- erE! . Pi .. II - -JLLIH l" I [1 '1 I LLka ExmbHA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 16 of 57 (Ir: .1 .il lii'l?'IL - a H-HTH attic-"i. {Iii-1?? tlu'c- iiI'::I' 1'1-4'0. r'.f furl-ii an Hiat Dali-.25 cll?i?JIl' twin-:1 Lira-?51-92 mi ivy til-m2. which mno is Lkah? :1 =3 111; gm L. Pleaeu. la:- If[ll-:i lam 13m:- 15 EH rzlr' . Eilif?irv '75 I-n.l "i i" 641' LI. I Uni-3hrfruitdr: {Hm I-milr: PIC: Luz: if: 1:0 yam? ran??J. II likeExhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 17 of 57 It ".114 5111'." Ft") air-31H I I. LHJL- el-L.? 11? Z. . rem-awed ?Hr-1'1: antl ?un'k un?er?tanu =1 Student in DE 'Hnrhentic se_1.' In reqarda t9 nlajk hays, havu TEL km find aiywne In give me an accurate definiticn 91 term. Lhi? mean sh?uting an?wars 11:71:11.1: haH-?w :hei: EiELiflq in :hui: Laud talking? What 13.3.95:- haw alum-1:1 Ihi?'a [5-1r2111f2r' in Lul. {Elf war]: _sz maerjrgE, ?1:11: will 3:11:41] nan-~51; 1.11 I113 have rag?.51.; :31. .7111-rn.-_ 15:1: 311:4 palicics. ?in Ii_Lu Ltul 3 IE ELM. 'Mln 1--_.?gLiL Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 18 of 57 in If LLHJ may wf Saying EJHL 1L an ma?Linn? rp45 aunxu; F- ., .--.. . . LI d. and Hum-:4: rinse Because wm're I was invitej by th to aha HES inviting m: 1% Lhe tableF 1.-. EDI t3 nulp with GENE SaluLimna with believ?, Lha racial equity pilicy and vinlen?e, and it wag a waste mf my time; ?nd wanted LG knuw, HUS a R: yy Li1?_ tdELCHliy, iL Ill. ctr-f 1TH: Jinan-Jr. mun H11 ytu?re nur qainq t3 i?rire me I.-. .. --. . mm In 1:51: 1.11: - :4 I huh Lunr HiLh a?thL_ng LkuL wea ;rnait:, but. I may: Hlfur 1GTCleg Linn? :?iaL gin: hn'r: tin-?ishwii Lfnu;e I ;H_ilJ thava, Turnitmilx- Eutas 433. fiw-ri?nsil ue?md at F.W. in ?hzulii'ondan .. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page wrat did y?I MEHI HV Thur? .. - - Iha? ?'in a what .Ikge wnuh wu mat at H?hjarin 3. H?y5 3L Huwdn U?y?r IE her when aha -- we IaJIing me how She wanred :a talkad, she wan i?ie di?yiHTiliP? Faint EtuIl Publi: El?1umls+ I I?id her, all do.? There are ?i?ywlrifi?s 1J1 Eh? ratemr i Ilnld IIEI, "Nana: I held her trying :0 dc in H5355: wan; Elm?ld?? Huzrng 1L was arm: I ua$4ImIJiy was Mid? w5 talitd abun! 4h cur ase-qL~unm rIr:_I i IL I I If LtIu ru:hcmm;:I? I T--, wrn+ defi?iLulvIE?rrl I-- I L-Ill E??mi? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 20 of 57 LD- I..-..-. . .- . . 4Tqu; uh: nLuvm uh: m?J I had Hun Thu TWP viulwn~w Ink.- L;rr: running. h; StleJlain and E1: 7-H ..- f's l. I 131-513;. ther. 011;} r. What ?b?uL the at b? 2:31.431 rsc'ir: Staff? 'Eswult:u. with 3.5.: Thf?Z i?fjli-i-J ha -- ir. th-i?T: Uni: ?1 3G ?n ily wnuln . L2 I 3 F1 . with againut 5.53.3]. Ami .1. I- ii?'ly 5..4?Lgl . - I . i 5- 1-, . Exhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 21 of 57 :1 'll 3T Wha: T'm dmcum?hL.T Oh, f?iSHd I E: Hi funny aha 3 "rl mid gming t0 read I F. I. II.- r} 5m Ch, she mot mentj?ned that ftu MEAL I Trina] Lhat? quink. LI 1% reascn, iik ILi?ned thi 5.1' aha did {Rumimws said, 5 NH: king an we and she k?ew my wax a feagh?r! wax: 11kg, fiIIJiuaH_ian" ?Th?r??s scha 5h; - f?p. a ml If" wa? [uri?m Lhmru -5 HH wai Lailing he acr?as Lhe jUHt painted behind m9. mr knaw my are aiJ 'huxv iF buL 3hr Em -- EaLd, . 1 htL.? ndmoLhnr 99371 Sll': In" .P we Ind- ?du?niiun can hle '51 I .I II IF ?Lac It 'jmpi?_ul- 'r'11. m_ I I In =I'1ic II t-f 'i I'Ilfi?. [li?Exmb?? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 22 of 57 Lu": 171.1 ITE . h;sical_; I H. . r" ll mum-a", . fan Jml- Tizlzj };11_Iw LJe-zle-H amm- E'J?'c'll' men. Nil-ha. I- 5hrUni. IE: "la-4; 3h? Lhunqh: I di??'t hw1ique i . fr: In like ?iif'LE?Ji'Jlfj. ?ght. if??h. What d1d ?yang he; that is SURE: -- in LJJI: wintleu LL all, I haE 35 happy that aha meL Ya: know? Here i an h34r, nnmunn?an?. I'm Lnisa [Ila-ELi-ar; 11:, going int-1E: c-xt-t-?rIL-Jifhgj .z-tur'. .l i Lh uh have ?ne a! Lhe e?w?flz. She - Exl?libith CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 23 of 57 r] Rid 5he write ?char 01' hit-2.1.: 2.1L: LEL'rll-t :4 Tea-fret; Paul Salsa-3 Tinarnti, L: 3.4L: I me -:ali me a: mm was Eike, "?lmy. I that." gamut- cg?nta?ts with the mum.? writing and than any interviaw? that yam din, i3 Lhuh because y?u felt yam qua a public figure; yam had it) do .hi55? -- th?nghL 1? 54:: J-LJ . I many 5m urn-111v HUME: him wart-q {.11 -- 5-1 in H.311 11-31?: was: junta-I nut, blahwa:2tgsi E: .3 I J, I ml rare-.4541}; JCL - I . r11 Pern?im; :5 i.-i I'mi quL - a: le?lih I . I ll. . . Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 24 of 57 .- If. . ELLE an mnslaught than :n iiki, ?Ukny. She gave me ?Er was in Hummer, HUld. I EDRL ung e?ma1l, h?f I diaaqra; with PEG, E?k?ej :iept?-mber GE 2019. I have an ?nd I caLl he: nn? She ruLurn my call. I 41 RFC ?qr e?nuaila, .Arni Enlc IHULL: Iirwm. Almj uwsn PM, ?C-Icgy. 1 adrni?.? -- :26: I just: ?dhh m6 t0 :?ii hum, Haw gm mm;nc L: l?ErL?llfl. i'r' I "ran- . u_d yum y?u ware bian rernltated ax?wtlv. II: Li', I nu: Exhibit!?- CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page halteLih1 :tt!e whar?u {Jul gnu HHTE Ly the yuur rn1af1u: Lu LHP whaL were yum? CDHCEIHHU what my Hl?d?nf? feJt nbaul mE. have a very H?r? envi?3nmELL. I H?rk?d at very ui?lenf Hwhoel, but my studean were m? had grunL aluuents. Even Lha student whu me was a $901.1 kid. 1 Lc; my :TEditilLLy was put in quesziu?. see 113: fth?i an Wham 511?s I tan a egacw: tagl?y s2135w5r??nn tfuuy 9:1] immkid at C?tt uLhar Iii-3I "Etna. Ujl id.hjriuw1, anal thuL ?rm 3 Story -- Hh3+ I uh?nf this :u LWHTIGI liv? aLLuc?mnA I19 Er :Hjhf?c??wl av ch.lirvq fll? -. I I Ha} 135Manndu_lk. I .5. 1 E??mt? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page min. . run): anim- LJILE'J?l?laLLuulun J.ULHLJ ?dll; uni 1t wan Emil EFL was why trey IELJZILLI Imid Tn15 the HuthHT? The Gr}. the. [.1013 1m, HUI-I, Iii'I?r: FISSEILILL yen and ?he assault HIT. 1.11:: an? are: L. yum: c-L calla?3:" rachch (2-: Ch: FE-JLTI Put-lit; Erhard? have: LIESIIHJ. 83' "1 ?5:31: lI-jaL' you HQULJ hrn: VJH would meII. l?frfI'Exhibit CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 27 of 57 LFI Ia- 1.1? :r?l CI . I:s-n:i r-F F_i 5 erl hit-1", Thor,- qrnund; ihat they'r: hea say. n3; ruiidbla HGT r?i?unuhLy ;3 l??d to dlEcuuer; w? adm1551?l? wuidance, an? erike 'in thig Lg?; ?3 ahead. ET HP. Bridging. 31.5.;3? Thia appearm he be an v?nai] yin and a numbmr GI ether individual: ?uparfn?anjent Silva; 15 that right? ?ha:'5 uuxru?L. Can FEW tell he what L?i? a 5D L515 m?mai? :5 Ln nyFelf IHLI quev Th?m 5?m311 j? -n HI mi U5 ?dih??35iJlg 3; :Juu;a TE, fllf+ay iEh LULJ, ace a?fh??iJHTiZJr? - T'f E?lilil 7:5i" r?lrt' . e?m- I J. t? uluUIEt'? t? $014. E??mt? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page lli??l fij.{1 L. .2 Lin lupin: I. Ssh??is? Ind. 03p32iaiiy at Gf aeli on tha Saf?ty Well, during my years in Sain: Paul TEE-J. aL LHP Saint Paul Puhli: Public I f5; Henjamln E. Ma we 9 Schamls, ?5 and my principal and vice .. weekly Staff prioupa', Farilltat?rs, wuuld always Laik abmut heeuh?r?, primatily taacher?, 5-: l'l'f'm' where. 13-1 . talkej :hwuL-?? l: 5? wh&h*wwr qe ll. Ian' anres ?r ?l?iurmmn it M35 bCHaLUTlrh? the :hiLd Lu? 3H Iii-l- lDGkan 3: lb HJH -- Lh?l phraq? 3&5 uiwuy: *hrgwu_l_ LIL-I. I fr?; 'r an.'w. a. lum' miraacJ-- d?_uL I .ll .132 lbExmb?? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 29 of 57 If: I JL- inn-K, :rrl an 3: g-uL. lm?r Ell-.33 ELI tie we?: :0 3113C- ng L'r run :hE Hahnm] h?ard? Eiiq??t. l'l'iTI the. ream-and appr?ptiaLaly? Hitjl??. .. 55-. Pm, t'z-uL all]. :2 nah-g? HI v11:- :c:nt.im:ec? in Saint. Paul -- and Ptuhlmm? that 1 addra?seyum I..J IL.- I q. ..-- . -EI Tr'lucari-Ln'. Eng-Arm i- 1-1313?. or m; #?InExhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page r?SEuJunas. {sub-3:3; ?ea-c: heard 5:113, hear-Tl crl'le': Ian Lluukfwhitc, HG wauid uhnllenqa my administratars. Tit-?y ha Irtnn?raze?. it. Here an: 51 EJ 1H, 19-year uuteran, and I have paupim stuiLuring anj blub?wrinq. l'm like, jlnat TFthi?g a :urrip+. Emu Lkn}'r ever: kh?h what you?re Laikihq abaut. Okay? if yum really Haul t9 helL .url. I u-mnt Lei: mare than black and whifr d5:a. want tn Scu what ?y gighz? ?ainL Equl Ilu helluva the gnum: min?ritic? a:u Stu-3- never than". Eua-;i i r:?1 a] irlsta15=s[1r1 I re?t-3' fur and wuuLdn'r 5cm It waa hl?in. The." r11uh, 'l-TfExmb?A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page Speculatian. PIE-1.. 11. "In .I I II Il' 'Tw' um- - ir'I' - nihl II II 1' I Ir_ ru-r'. I .. 1. I'i' Eff-.3 i 11;" - - THII Fir?*1. -- HF kn Lin-I . r: f5 y?u knmw. gm aheai. I. hr-rf 5- eve Lila-y tili Paul hire-Li Ff LT t'llEJiEi. Elm-tar: the? F341 1.1 LJrnuyH lei-11' 1mm: I. i r: 1.1; rec. EKhibitA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 32 of 57 J35. '15-:er nan-:5 Ihn FHIHIEHWE -- the 14n? HJVF, irI ?rm-Jp- 1Fv1t5tl?? -h vHah+ Th1: Ln iUFt EMS is EH1 -- 'nhiiLLi {'Jf the 5:3- Lhi? WT. - -. -. :5 JLJ- _.Lm 1UJL UN 0; Lhat 2.9 wnuld at: Lhasa-2 1th:? Int-erel'ilT? an July W. Haw; l?uhing at both ?ut91 a53 and dhd, yaw 1.13"] [13 new pages; r1565 3"qu say 4.31.3: 315.3: arm 45:5. GEL it: -- Ulla. has HathiL-g t1: ti". with $1.114. T'nt'? is T'rr' Jrr'wr-u-arm . Fr?31135; .-I r: I113: _ljr; TIE-S I th'- LT 71-15! E. 1 II I .t-Jm'l linr.I-J x' l'l I In. l'I: 1 I '1 Exhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 I: Page 33 of 57 ic. rh? and t-ErliiJ-L: thrmugh severai 50 Min first wax an assi?t?n: beiinve y?u'rw gaing rm havw tn chi?Hm. vez'iI-y'. 1 5m :?sur?t?I. I think his vice ir?L Litia mun av Intern i i .I. Thard wd? EEK: HUFI 0? Thain: F141 1:515:13: n. ['51 17c; 11-1751:.3 Ink--31: Hik}, E. hat '5 MIN: wet: :?L'tl 'ar: ?If-xiiy-t-s T'Lliniilif?j him alifl I?l'l 2! I -. _1 ExhibiIA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 34 of 57 l' r. I. Jir-J? P. J: II . J.5.. that 71;; fi'li'i- I I I. l- Sum. aha-I :59 i'rr to react 1-1.. an Oh, 1L HIE-39H 3-3. I agent em 1.3 mm; . .--.. 5m war: {Lilli-.1, Pfur'?ar: and She 1:3ch b.2313 gain-r; ED happen, m: .?eT'Tal, I 55.11:: a threatet? Emmi, blah, LIL-fit. 1?53le 11an: .1. ll-f 1I '1355 . .-ILL. I I Exhibit? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 35 of 57 Ur Falki?g Lu 1? id: HII ra?'t C??iif? lnni. What ware with r?e Saint Paul Public . . .Ll- y?u ?ve: a EitU?ti?i mhmre a I Sshaal - -. aid Laid ta it Lu the Pi i Turni?g to EmLmwh?L Lh?xe e-maila are? requaat?d. I wanted h. 1? my 50 35 a Lmacher, we have snanLinq :alled PETE, I If. CIT: N4 Evewy tiTh yum write a behaviurui reiurn -- '4 51"3 f-0 5a; :1 pil?k .arrij u_ you Hr;tc up, yum han? it ih as in QC iito a adwtnistrat?r. and thaL'a any}. 4=ten536 -d nr1;Hcl r?ei Hf: I Ena:i'3? rnnray Will. i aij i Ltiukiuq, need a .l Lit; we . Elli-1rEthim CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page I?r I'll. . I . .I In.I-I LH . ..-I 1 I. {ji?rllL WHITE IiES?i-lrj arid {Ii 755 if; -.. LHFETWTELE. The IIr-cithL? ave-:5 -I Her-v. flu-:5! the Ijrl?irml. raguasted my d&ta for monLhn, and was juaL given Ira w?'re wmrking an 1L. We?re working HL and h?ra?aing rhia man. didn't- -- hsIc.? idea. 3L1 and ?n11 ?h?ur?FalaaT wca in Hp w?qld qum m: SC: .I we}: . . re. . I :wl.lI. wasfjr?Sit; I II - . Exhibii?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 37 of 57 11. C4 a?I. I . Ia' my Ell: 51w, zinc- I ..- - - - C?Lun l- I. .1 I 'i . She d33umuutud itFHITI II $1,151? EIL Hart [Fuhlic [I?m behay?igr enLur?d ian a Etudwna'? cum?iazive b?h?vi?f Elie? PI ED, Ira-311'. Fan-{J are then: Lhev I'jmn'l: .5. 1' may. 1.:zi tJImIq .3 (71:13:; LI I, m' :5 75ml :15. 1':IJI-rz-w I 'Ir'l uu?rensiLH luL? hr ..LJI . "l -- I .. . ?duh HLLJ J?i: I 1I II . LI -L-J'Lll u? .I TIEITH . - Exhibit Pu. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page iIILuznun-inn Enhnrickwi La I_hanIIn: :sLudEn:?I' F:Tesl?llu'? 1: 'I'HlL'i' Libil'f: Emu huv& Ln =3rant .- .. 3- 7' hid J. Ln'y?u have any pariah-:11 1.211;: Seajrer, Fan]. Rubin; Sch-male: mmpimyEEH arm williuliy dgazrcying reami?mn in hm TEE. h?liaua I?ll-L: El?n;- E. ?Tncn:l 1r,l - ..-I. [31:513'. rl?jrl?? :I'Iri in .ruidant HIRLC I r- Exmbn? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 39 of 57 LHL::uirwnn my thm. What as was n-L? 6.15519. ME. that? THE Elamanmly. NH. wag? ..: I - - i?vw :n Grudnn;n di. wy Esktu Nib .- [hwh antes. there Hid Inf HES my wag Lk?nw A. Jahn331 EGCHEFDHH: ?nd the pxiw?in?l .. . . - flu?Hr]: ELI-lull ?intlfu 1L wwni? hag: I ?l I her Ti' {93- HI. - Inrr I239 Pt-Lw UHL WTTHEEFJ fu?. L: 1 . I - WIIPJH EbeH? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 THE w:rnu53: ah: 'r Page 40 of 57 W2. Okay. THE n21 the :jty EquH 1 or Marsh Edi; Zh?f inane. '55 ME. . . T. ?ll right. DE: {9:311 think, m: with SainL Paul thlic Ssh?ulu, than th?v'x 1U jab in; lumping IL. P-il-l. 5.3 if EH-UL. 34.31mtg-3r": hack DJ. Exhibit?. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 . -.- I Page I'c" [2151 If] lr .r ?1-5 knit-:31" HIV. Fania-m". to the lam: CI- ?Jl?hL Catlin spam-.1 and 110E 12c) .1 mac; the diESnvury Gf ?d?iiuihla evidunca. PM. Emu can g? ahaad and a; Mr] '5 3' ME. HUCEEFQRD: Emma uhjw?ti??u. Tl"? I saw: r'J :3:an if. in EUII my had 11L. 51:11:: Etl- alum-er I [Hr- ju'finij. 1435 _:L1i_ I :hfl..1 Mr. a. My If ?in: i Ini 5-3.2. IL- .71ExhibitA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page main '1L'4l2'l' til?.3? Ir- - . .. tun AJL1.J L=JaLJurnh1p:. 134 nmed Lu r2115 -, E.- -- . - be Jana wiLh fidelity." the Hf?? Hard Lh?y but as they're Lalkiuq abuut th?ae :1tL1135, HHS git was m? was getting wmrae and woruw. 9 DD yum think it maLL?ra, in refaLinn LU Fran whather the in?ividuais ?uted H:u k?arhers CL emu nvaes a? viEirmrs? Repeat :11 --. I - - 1:;Il ?w yvu Lhi?i i: HE: the; ?rin?w'ts HFF nLrancE? are ngzutrs, 1 L?uz-w I .. to the 1mm,- i r" I :57. arL! Entwh'f, i I Vrd: '?rq "ff-'3 ir'a!' 5: r' o- Exhibit F. CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page adult?, I: a attacking . . m?ans LugLiLutt; . . .. Wt. EHlen, :3 HELP haa yum Lhinb . --.- I-.-- r' Jl:uL. .1 LJ1LJ Ilmri*uvr 2 .1 I . . JG- uLudL, pLuuy. 3 F. Una? yr} tells me rhere ar& dmup:r (J H: Uaeper wiLh tha SLudnur Ls teacher. HhEn ycu ?ay ?ducpw: what dw you Viulencw rimlenca :uwmn Naturallyin] mg?5H Shun be a manred :??lcul, gawklic leJJ'i?n, -?jd yin: I Li'lirH' _h.er ?95. uLLauk a atudrxL tr Hf :I:5':i:grl LhuL aura am 15 CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 44 of 57 I l?I 5.1" r? ME. HDCHEFDRH: lask BE g. -- . LIL-LL: qlliZF?r? Hirn?ss as an Expert. GD ahead and anawer. ?ctualiy, can 1 RHEHOE :het? MR . ELLE. GU ahumd. Lita-r} J. Lu"; iilr . in I: F'e'Jil'i finurant: Ix; the I erwj rl;_ humbcr EL airiruw?AmeriggLu hut 51:11:11. ir: Emma-.1 . _l - I I?ll:If'la- .51 1 I II II '91Exhibit? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 45 of 57 3'4 Based en ynur intacngLiwu wi?h administraknrs -- L'm Lulkihq abauL aL BEG dn yam think ymur inpuL and fee?back LhaL yum nave LHH H?mzn1?trat?rs, wh9ther Lna: EH was Later and . in arr: lav?Bra? 1: . [Shy 54:1? Lin-:1:- =av7ec ?gd1h?t we ?fLm: I Hp?i? TC I-FI .Lwl 1r: 3-1121] 51. IM- "'11 -.- . J5. .r lat'_Il him I '11- rhathnJ him 'md?..-. --I. I L. I I I EII I"-.-. Exhibit A CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 5-.I . 51 ?13! CC-Erlmi a; I. E. r. l-?i?1 a r1rFT fLm: nuuLGq him pericnally. .- .- H15 d_d4:? Lil, lawn clju~3-u1r' r1 fir-33; CI ?Ja 5; 5.1. I. ?Sud-El I, El. - 0 All right. Um yam knuw ah?ut the Safery the Saint FauL Enhiir Scha?i Ri?trivt? Ii"; I I"}1d the: 1yam; were in have a SaluLy team meetjan . a? Na. Mane wh?L?mvar. Thc?w did?'i 6" E?ruer in saint Paul imar?=inj Wh;n' I: -. I 51L uuwy Exhibilh CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page incri unr- LI .- intruwrw?n'r1r a? 1 ELQLLth.? H1125 . I 1.121 ti. . I . t3 rrIi-gzjh: haw-a ital-5522'] ._ranhn Jujrum?rh Shawing yen Exhibit 44. l'd d?h yum [u IFII-IF-I law; at: this I'm: a mum-311., y?u Haul-(J. {Rev1ew5 d?auman.} unn? fa hav: Lhia hanging; up in the al?. d?l'tt: E?s. JGhI'lsi-Jra, we wztuulrfl hang: 5-415- if. H.175 HI: :31 Huh :3 :111' I I 1 an]? '5?le i'1 if 5-311 (if??i? P?lity um I 1. Put--mt31 a 13 IT Exhibits? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page I?in??ct' UJ. Fil? rifni.ritrk Did I read tbs; Tua, ycu did. And tha?, an p?ga A, paragraph 4, maptiun: 'al and REJiquum Vlclenca, it reads, ?RaulmI and religious viaienne i? physical act mf aggression Or a??ault u: the thr?at Hf aggre?niwn ?y asaault upnn In manner rea?nnably E?laie? anathar be?aun? HI km race GT I?iigiUL. Tnis at: may alga 4 rl?n?lnu! rC?d th! F?ked 504 your kn?wiedgu 3.1 Tal wiLL kh? li?igl anu rhlinimua 1 InIrHUI, 39L4J IIH . ?1 IWI Hhuum . al-_ nggT?yr . . CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page hichI. ate wag HuiliJ'll. I becaiq: Eh? Md? Wu?llm, and ddTI?thT?Zj?H wag nmtIlJtd, Eurhin? may H?ra. 5 dl?ciplincmnkhar diacipiinn him, I E?H?il Ihe but my udminjquatjan wude d9 n?thinn w? I1 Why" -- ancl.l "n hmrwunse he Inns hl?r?i. ITu?z'? 1' h?iat I ?aw min& was the pniiuy ,Il' Lin-2 Ljii-IJ-?gra; if ELJETHHWII tnuliuy. 'Th;5 jfi wha: IE regenclu - have m~ we n5: in on: CJ arLgn . Fr II 1? thai we ??he EJHHU. p;h 1 3. vl"~ Th ?uli?: Jr C: I- Ind? a ?:letl; ?14__l [Pr?i?n=l, a - IF ti: :rhm I"1'3t IIHWITI 3 2 I II r-.T ILII . . l ?5 - I . "Lcl - CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 50 of 57 E. a: lit-mu} Jaw-1s11111 if. I I: . 1 .LJ LEM: 1.3.33 Fin-I'I-i-v' .3- Lulu. tug in J. saith 3:011: bull}! LH Ez??lzgk, he Sh?U d he dw?lr with, but buuausc the bully is black, T?"Fii? is; in": want .1: run-glam Lg Lug m5 . I Laid LhuL an the superintendent. 5mg agrcw au'f'l'h mil. L-raLr? her Elf all the tau1].ie3? Einswv ir. mg' lJ.uL. Inr?t. "If. in if?; I a. -I ?ll-it: TE per-LEI] 21:: . as: have ii I iu'i-J? I - - Film"- IUJLL :4 With irrH 1:541:13 an was a prehicn er E. HIM :1 HJ -- hn'?1?7 was I m_ w, H'I'll I ll" .'sl'i I .IIJI., -- I. - flux-r?. r: Maybe naL H: black, bu: ExhibitA CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page 51 of 57 I I S?nnvl dlaL:_u 153-113 I - . N: ?ll - ?f?hibLL? J?r?hm "ilL'zi-r "warri- h??a HDHLU nu :l?sarm1m. ?ftar SLmeudyf ?h:y yam? Iii-E t'igilt' in y?ur :lal?tgy::n:n, T: rhqy weren't disciplined? Herwn'r diacipiine? at all. hH1? acceunLahlp? A Hmpe. [n2 prlluy or Lha EnfaICEmenL any Dt??l ways? under R, ?Rour?n?ibijty L3 repnrt and 11.: 1:5: .?ppt' my: r31 a: . Thr-g J. Linn: i . - -.-. ..- -. -- - ?1o_r_hL puzhj?n:1: 113tr;cL L?fhw?n?- WHFI [aka and qun they 'r ?.17 ?Jl'i-D C11: :ju' . .. . - Lfl: 1-. Ty, ELEM-F. 1: .nnVeInii ?1 . I 313C Al - :qWL'r LC f1. U-Iln' -, Iiuuk'?: ., 1-1' .r . u-['T?r CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 JZ 7' .. arh?313 I ?rhn diu:r;:t w;l_ prnn?ti: Ln 1 :3mpLaLnlu, aizh:l Forn?i u: ianrmal, 01 y1ra:uar&nl: nl' 4 EG diaciplinu a: Late any student." ?sh amng, w??n'h if 3L kEHi it was ka:ry intermittently. The wk?le thing iH Thi? is CHLE is imke. The pcliuy? i 11?? s: jrnke. EH. Benn-:3. I have? . 3? HR. Page 52 of 57 [135-1 111' 1n33nsistan, a jmkm, Thank yam, Iw? 1 Fennat, my 13 If ll dx?enci 1* th; Lnuh I have Li- "hat Fifi - . -l . E??mt? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page Jon. Lia] EIJIU I Maya Husaum MaquuL, Capirgl Hill. sc?mnmi iH .3umnusr I :31uqrn; wanted ma 1:1] hr; a in teacher again, ;Mh? man; like, he?vher LILJM: . wag ?fftred C?hl? mak&. it wa? muuh Fri-5' and Paul. LLHL h,huol th JEN 'tu siLw at the Benjamin fl. I.-.1 :3 aurmer ?uh-H -- Ecnjamin 5+ taught summwr the ey? ?f Hume th??l Paul I've already and Haw Eht limil? I h?ck EU Saint ?.Ti Hm? yea: HtILj??1l? Iiuy?a? Ha Ihak _u EJLL: "a;l nr - 1 I ncLCASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page .IL..--..we: during I . I..-1 F. -.I [5-1 PEI-I, Inf-E" i'J?leLJ -r .5 .- LJL ?h m- Opl?ay Ln I 'auh and I arguing with my principar. Luiujmq my huhd. I We? GUI than would have and was tired {If hearinu SQ I t: I didn?t gm aimmgc ttn:a stLHEf, hirr and 5.13.1: 71.3-ng .HIP t0 yam.? He my far about l? Hurt-this. . - I FHJL Lac-:11- that In?, . Le]! her, i. l'_i ha m? qung If); rr was . .- rwrays IL wmnkExhibit? CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 05.! 10 Page 55 of 57 lthn?te? in a?kihq Ham; 3 Tun HHESLLUHH Kn HT. Vlliaumu, Lhaf ymu wnre a gut - y?ur teaching j3b5 Paul HPI int 133-111"; EEC-11 I waa farceu gut b?nause after my -- I?m tenurcd, teaching far EaJl. PunFJe 510 the Lh?t yen .33. r- I . .-. - tire a teacher. That ;3 Lh: and Wisccnumption arauni Emerica, 3L La Hi :5 gun ?f?ft ?u l-I. ??ll yon thc, QLUL, y?d jLIik? h1?w.? mug th+ ferL 'i . if . . f9}! mil ii rsf' w;n5 .Igw ILJJI Lhe Haw I.1H JH, bu I I - In?. 1 . J. St a mLIIar ?r t1wII-:drr [:Tl I ll:? EHNMIH CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 llJ' 1 ?1 In. Page ..5. .l I. waic?? an uiuuLll, n" r4artdLILyLn'kly. ha?u. I Can': f?ri?k UL'iHhi :uaf5er [ju?L rnar:hc: a kid has: :he nun nf kid. l've never seen tnaL befmrc. HR. are questi?ns I have fa: yum. ME. VILLAUHE: Hr. Benner, jusL hilve HIHJ r- 1 . a - I rhanhP LEEHTLETIEH 1 In $?u1 opiuin?, bagg? a; testiany I-. I. - -. c?ddl. EChC?FhiLn Lh;nL Lb: mwjig I I i I r- 'u'l'hI I -. 51xn_t I 1h 11 I . CASE Document 89 Filed 06/09/17 Page $11. ELI. J. HP: 111JJEWFLE nnihing further. Ill .7: HUGE 3'15: P- . fj'il?r 2111.! 1.111111 01:13:; Lil-:2 Eh: {1 Efrain mi {1111131 1 :1 ?t .EL 17:11:: I: '13: EJIJJL 111111.111 21' thE. anrl thy: P. 1' 1: 1-1. lg} F'Fhis- 13 dilatminqr righl. I I I II I U1: l-V Champlu 2' m: (1:11-11:15 1; with Lht': I . I rig." l''jni?hihj Jp n3 . 1r 1-H'ar L19 iI: - In 111:; 1 1. I - 1:131: 1:11' I :er u?r II '11? :111 1 6-1112?: -?h113 r: 11. 1.1--I -- I n, I I. Lac --hn I - *if 1 . w?Exhibil?.