CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 1 of 53

'3

Ln



 

 

Jh TED 



[If] [Diva I 




F.- 1 ,1

wa :murr No. 


ka??l EldeiCL Hi. hHh;
_n?ividualLy and in he:
and Thurcaa Battim,
UfficiaJ 


Valeria Silva,
?npguizy;
Individualiy and in h?r

D?i?ndanLu.



The cur rattan}: 1:94:35.

t3 ?cticw 3E Taking qunsitign, at 8513 Eag?e Paint

1?th day wf



Ea amber, Etlh, Emily L. Brace, Uri 

guJ HuiafF FJu_i: in ?ounL? hnww?,

.nt EJ?pEQuUUnmixrlf 3.11.

rt? mm
.11.:





 

 

-: -i 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 2 of 53









can



 


.. 

aln?fume 

hi?

{3'5 i 

.
1.
I.--1

35-11: yam: prim' 

13'; LL . 

I
1.

Fall thin". "x?UJl r.I Cli-"i

3mm 

with iridegmtdan 

?faesa' .

inn-L; him-Vt? 511:1] .21; 

THE: [1 33115:] .


Htarr ?41- 51:. 1' .-: r. 

High ?ahoai.

a- - .


.- .. 

tun-:1 1:33:14 Lam 23m been a: 
:21. 

E. i rm: y-h-rl .-I.

r-i? i j?fl?fj :1 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 3 of 53



Fl

11]






I1. 

 

 

1711119.1. 

?33.12 'n'hiL'i'I .11 3'

13 1.32:. .1. r53: 1. a 11:1 unum J. 

f'

1 .. .- -.
1.1 1111:1111;

Arr-:1 I 11111191211 tam-l the?
311111
Fa Tens .
11111-2. re did 51am j. a 
"1 lL-Llli'fi [2'61 1 .

1551?" '1 I1 .

[Ti-:1 1'1 1'1

Cm.mra?3 En11nn:?

Ell:






1117-3101311

WHIP: .1-1 Hivi?icm I [relay-51it-.--

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page Hiqh

Jug cu*ie5 rm?rnnsi?ilLLiaH

153w. haf?: re

cur ircf?unt?
3T HR. 
incident.

lwfure 1n:iden-3

--J
ha.
..

2015.

F?r teachr 

r'1
-


day?Lamday nperatiuns, as far ma handli?g studanLn:



?1 welfare, Safely am?nq HUT Safety than: 1 an
respon?jblc i?L hainq a W?mb?r DE nu; 

13 a9513tdn?m ream: L'm c4::eutly the chji: mi guy ?ywji

l? Guamirnee; an? an? ELLE: dutiaa 33 aa??nwmu

i5 by my principaL.

(flit: 

Back in the Ehlb E213

:j'h
I.

make a? Lg p:ch;e: wii?in firm

3 

LLJ gun. Lrnwa: ?waiEVLanL 

 

 

 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page .T.-I I talk-Til 1'
- I-.- 

IIH-IllLIll. I l-I . 

 

rnIr - .-
I.n I ht.1Lnjl hfiLIIqii vb; Ina}: 

ES [ram staff '1v- - 
arid

.l I
I 1]er II I I r-I' - . I
l. HIT-LI

I - I -
DUIJIIH I'm: ElglLI-Ifl?lb 

.l
r-tht- Squufy' LL-EIIF. in: 

adminjatrntion151']; 

-.I I.. Ir?r I rrW?t ha;- km .

IEI Ell-I 
. In: at th: mek'inq, aru ThI..- I
I II
IILI 
LdExhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page say. altr'r has bur

as F: :TaEJni'Jc?zr but shrdam-smug rn? .31? "m9
. I..: .

v: f. .

.i'md Mr. was 

Em?









I


HI
ELI

Ira-i hi?Hum; gut] Emmi: ._aL what- 113:4

.1: 21.- ExslihiL EB, .qr-lrj [f

- .. .
3 turn-Hr. Mr. 

if. [-11 0305;;

3111Ila.L.1 1 -1 fin xl'l?llG??m
(L. 5 I- a .JII 
ll *H?erF 
I I l. I 

Exhlbit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page w'rn'a'

Hiryi-w fiche-:31 1n til-.2 2013?231

-.- -. .. 
.T- - 

paracn

1.: flu-r!"

Cir: ELI. 



LE Emit HITELL was 33mm

t'rml. Ive-rim} 0f Time?

I: I was; --

5 a fE! 1: clam r1111 

II
Jl


.

{5 

Na. we: carp--

"r



unwild

mm 7.5.: Iii-1:1: 

in li?nf? Salts-Ly

lepll. we

F: mm 9311.54 1? 1. c-

Wi? the palaun

the Emil I?m-j: that 

17110. .?rvr'

52:] 5 1121:1213 

i?l'







3'
1.

Hep-:3 lied as

?.33 i? f] 3 41-? re

wiLh a; wash paTifCuL?t ?marina.

rcr-LE- t??jn

Ham r?tzrniing
minute?.

far 



 

 

 

 

 

r' -.J- $44111-? w. I .3511.31 .- I 
'51: I r5-

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page EHhibiL







r.1[ 

'3 




Lyra?
l.

.
fir?.

Can you ch?? ta 3:

he]: Tn: what

Theae munln have DE

:ne meeting.

and that mania hmur

hh?

?ap,

Rama :hasc

anw?bor LT,

51'? ?1 r;n

-L'fni

maar.

r?n twpiCS LhaL Ha

?l1, Lu

been

Hi] 31

the tsp, in 2hr mindle

I run-

 

 

 

. . .
Hr -uJ 1-I -I1q Lt I- ..3.1-4- II I'i 


Exhihfl 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 9 of 53





 

r: i' ham-E EC- 

Eu'i Liar-55.53? High 
were airwmarns ijL-e 1731-31 
sLuda?Ls in building Hcfu nuL acting HE if thexe
were Jill-.633 {my Iain-7  31" T??r tun}; Lime:

they Haul-:1 brim]; Lin-:- ED was cane cance;n?

A aL Lhe tine were
and :sl'tsc'inhzn?E lunar-3 fee] Brig Like
dc) they want wiLidmi am: kind 

3:31.: FEET-1 .

Was there mar: uicimncw :?vnived at rhu.

rrw? 
.r'a c- pun-J :s .i a: . 1: [5195.- 



 

 

 

in i-i . I Fuj 17-23 I: 
H?alli? 4 II i d- -1- .Ilr'i?W" ptic_ Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17









 

 

Page 10 of 53

HhuL Juan Thar ?caLE
i" . .. . . 
J?s-l I: J. 

1:11] Hun-2 

ta xfn?unL sifuafimns.

What ?113,165 that [21:1 1-11 93171103].

High Schin??

A 1ft? maintain Saki}! Eur-wvbady,

we have ta make sure LhaL theta arm rules and Lhut the

11.1.11 f?niimwad 13:} that 13111113511113.1119 and 13::
a1. actuaa; 1vi 1w1u* ha1ring' ac- mrxru1_ vjtgiaw1t
inci 212:5 L:Li[1g 1115-11?12.

1.: :5 :1 211151 1.1 [12511111- in 

I {5'15 .

i?i'??xL 1.511%. 121;;- v-I 
3.1.- gar-tun 1_1
{.IJJlafz-J; 
km- :1 u: 1511;: -11- 1211511: an 
11-35.! SELFEJ 1.1 an 1 111- raj-:1:- 1
1. '1 1 tied-31Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page ?nd what have I?j?k Bil Hjh?gi

E?huvl ?nal Liwt.
that-

PCtLujii 




iucidentn whare EtudunLH were besemjn? incxeg?inqlv

mare angry.


i my
A



Wart 5LudhnL3 becoming Harm prunu to


a35aulting 3r 

THH.

r:

Ruierrinq tn Hataa 511, wmre it Say 

 

?'J'here arr-'1 11C: Fm: anijLiu-zj argunu



Pu 359:; .

(ii-7  Imam wharl Viz-I: I: 'j

Iii-5w.- I Lam-e a 

"1a.
-.-

1 Sauna.

ti d0 h;Lt HHTIHJHQ 

Ellie-:1 ham
4:1: 51H 

..Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17

l?I

5 

I31

--I



haw-:4.





3' Ir;



 ".Ii1

II: i d1;

It?ll. 5

Eu.-

BI 

1'1.

-



I Ia

anything In H-

Page 12 of 53

ITS-ILI-J-

IL): LII-run.-

391E. It

I: Elti? ch? a; :un:

that Mean "w

- .-.
.-I- 

 

[ii L- .
- 
=15; 
IE ?rm-I .

F5 I
r_ Lia-.3 
the

and 

eff wembcra, 





Fi?-Ci 1231C 

SIT i2".


I I
I .I '1 hill-H 

I 

-.. 

tee.




undersLuaJ

EijIZ?falil'.

GS



C?mmiztoe wag




arm-2: :ch 

VII, I: 

HT. 

wculd be Mmilt

it. wax313u'CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 13 of 53









 

 

r?qirnerWW-Tiia: fhfLivifiE?i, 

anJ_. zmur'heci Eu} [?ght finTf

trying it 3mmL In Fame 'E?jlwticn 

("Si?iiEEQEJHrlif?iiyaalhluu 31 Lb: huuk

that th?ru nu CDHSEquwnres Eur ?Luderta?

A TEE.
a And why did ihe ccmmittme Feel that may,
can Imm?mher?

HR . FEE): Obj an: L: 1 unr?a ..

neells fmT' 
cg? a5he;u1 E'id .qumn?r.
Wif?d??: W?uld FDH pi?a?c

ruqm?ali tin: 
JV HR. 

i; ?ft-m. L39 f?l I.
way. La?wd 3W vmur 

Ii" 

than. wLura Izatirug p 9um- ?l

LLHZ i?rm aha; mxn_L  5*51"' Fat huhugi:

l.uluvfuJi?h w?ujHn?'n. I can (t . 

 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page JULQ. u. ?un? Tsaum 1 :ng Fr?atfu

Cliff?f?nLLy [31' 
Ple.:c F??th.

. Kim: I T3 L1 




hack, plea?e.
iTi'l'i? .II'r-eaaij hawk if
the CGUEL Leyurrar.l
THE WITHESE: Ea.

HT . 

.at EH13

Ckuy. W33 IL J13mu45=~

time?

A 'Ph? cl' L?i?f rhAIincl mg:-

mu?iingh- Ear a2 its mp??ifiCiLy ;m 1ate3t

7-159-25th awake?! "Ia, I w-z-ulj .1151: 

13 ?Ht 32L m] wear, Him the

I
'i

i {If Ci?ii UF1 i 1 3:59 wj_Lh L1_p



cormiLL?a;

1 w?iiLEL it? mcvirua Lu AH 

?u A r??l NH 1 ijuct mniul :5 -hp
?erl llhill'r' 1 nglamCASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 15 of 53

 

HJVH,

i r"f {1r3r3 
2 THF.



fiEtS many Ur 



.,


33 bullet paint??








I-..

IU-




A pfuuiina]

far kida, and

9 HLnfi, nu



rue Lg n0 

the "Fights.





did the H??n by that?

MR. RECHEFEHH: Ubject: lackitq

Halls [m1 

:4 irl?id; Hi: illinn? H;;d 
luau" ?I'ie

F?if*?r1 nr1 ariaiJi, 

E?l. :hura. fLJu yim1 E?at

1.15.1 I: IF: ..

rend

5.1 

31 THE 'lfhh IL Mr a
IW Hr'w w%r{ 11 14 had
I ?mh?fg??Ih? Lu?
rnwmura: I II Ifl 

 

bark b'

"Bigg??t

what 

Whit

'i .
1'
a

 

 

 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 16 of 53

?11






.r-.Fu

 

 

risr I-r1fi3 doing rin-L' ?rH'lLl: 

. Mn"? 

as 1hr: bulie; unini",
LU EilLC-il 1, what 

p-maitiml :m

that 

Fa it New bulmdariL?HE m3

l-zxugtzr' 1:1: n-rhmn: an adul: had, knuw, 

the -1 .ild an Lhal: au't'rJIL'f rur-

- 
FBI-..LI-FL .



FE

LhaL 

'N-L'lf? IZFI-idi'r'e WEEK-3 

were an 

Lulinxl :1 f] r; rang." 

in?ichms "41.1.1134 place with 13L,

HAIL. that.

l' 


l?l-
I 1.

g; 1? mm r'da



all





rr, ..-, 
It?frlb:





ELIE 

 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 17 of 53

3]

 

 

If you L2H: wikauL g;nxuiinw a;
rm Fl riswm 1 
dmn't khan.

TFE I dcn'L k?nwHaw, ware Pa?aed by safazy

LL Huramhmr 2314 J: van knew ii Lhasa

Harv Lc any?rm in the aJmEn?at?atiGn bmajdea

y?u.jL any

p?i?L Ln ann that LESUDs LnaL wa?? raised it that

meetirg w3uid by ummehnm 

?7 thi?k those were 
Hrsr1129,

at: .a-E u:ue1:1, ?h2541 ijug?h 
i ll 5r 'h-w L1 rrlan CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 18 of 53



1 i 

f$un?ati?n, C?l_n IEIP SHE $113?, cal;? 
mubqun?nt ti??di?t mannre, avg Lt
D: ULI jLaE.

- . --
n-t_HhE :0 L3 1L ran

al??mEE, -gu LEHAJH.

the cmurt r?p?ItEr.f

?j?cu?sed at mn?tingi 3L safety tgam

 

gwwmara? tau: Ccrn.rat Iligh ih?wng]. Wt

??re that th?du p?t?t? net an.

k?war? .LL guru; [rtxr rhE?J_, T?n' 33L

1pm? dmuF ears and LLJI Lhere wa? r?r

:3 in Ip rurasariwa EL :u_?11

'ed fi?l??t iw-i?ent?.

hr*nq 

F52. 

 

up H?ihf? that In be addrwa?c?,



II: 

en wu

Suzem

It.:wn5 {19 Feeling at Lhu Ln?i it 

?i?q


I .

.c

THE Fnul? yum read

[th? requcaLed martian was read bank hv

The thatrWin . D;L;ul 't r1?
2 l'riff'iE'L-E "Ea 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 19 of 53






I


1

la.-

 




gar-.r lt"- -.
"malt rim:
huh?:54 Fi-I?lclf? :m :1 sir-3:11-? b91515. 
.



pasitian 



53 What. 1-555 211:}. 

Media namd?d ta we a H?titied 

That if the mudiu wpre aware DI Lhi?, 
acme ?f thiu Lniurmat?mn Hamid bu fmrward?

i'urB-liCI-l ?liq-:1: ill-1L." J. I 11g ?b?u ?hr-:1 Hg?- 

53 is in Fn?r Lu say LhaL by bringing

public: .LJlt'rr-nti-itrn 13:: Eur-72in: at flak, L'nat. 

Lit?:L- :mmrL-?r in?rm] 931:1"er 

359:5.
mt:- 5-1.6, Law 1131-5; gating-"u
7 .134! I. r11 '71:

55533.35. fem 'ff?iJ read arm-.1: 25513-15?
. i: 1' t? :35. 5: CL 351? r15; 

near 




- 


 

 

Ighjqu??

'l'l i 
,1 r1: I 1.
111Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 20 of 53



 

P. N19 !.hc =Uari3?  and' in
the rest; humid, cursing,

and d?flawnww i? HJL 

w; 11. in mg}: building-{5
Why wag iL hainq a1l?wed in Lhu buildingu?
A r?-nn?t knew.
again, ??t?l?ilim; Hates page i;
indicaLe3 wna anathe: maeL?nq called on
13, EEILIE, m. 
think Lhu "H?uLinq mnlJe? aL
p.11." the? CIJ. thl': 11,517?.

El rm. all right.
.

?jwi whaf.unmm3 lTh? IvjtaL;tuz .wr

hmvawber ED i, mean?
That H15 a t??ck?r?g Cum??rr? Tanard;n3

1min. 5511-5? We Jmci

IL: Il?lhiL 1r in:i11inq whgt? hwr'und ?kiE

escalating-1'1 a: -- with and il. ads-E?
Elm: :;Laf inn I1er tiiwg 

h%r -- it wuw 1uiL

5_ ;he L?mv.
TI "Hw? "31 3 1 I
Ihv hill?, ye1 'wwv 


. - .

i' Lil-r..- :2qu r5Exmb?D

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 21 of 53

f]



'1 

 

 

 





nauk :r if Eflf.
=ffaid Lu Mn.k 1L th? halla: afraid if

hipIJ-r?n Lr: halt: LI rE:

wi-ih El stuziergt.
?int: the air-aid in

karma 3? C??fr?if?li?n with Stud?nt??



A Ihm fnmuuliulAl . ff

3 staff member wmqu 53k, Why are ymu in h?iiw?yu?_ it
'ithG 63.: diSf?i?Iispem which 

3mm knuw, 

EVER Eran: 
?u Lea:her5 Slaqud :n pum?ure a 11;L_m

SJ 1 1: :11 f-rw i I. :15hr:- 56: ff: i be: LJ 
2fo~2f?5 Hahwvl wear, feel Lam nrnn?l 

re51m2niaJlg 



mf fLu keen.

LL15.rExhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 22 of 53

 



List



3- .

WHH HJLHESF: Okay.

the repuriur.}

7" 3213. 

.l

an cubjcw:tj;3:; _hg;k



in: apaculatiwn.

fh?hjeact LU Ity '?trferfticni, kiHJ Lain el?i?d?lT.

WITNESS: $95. in c?rLdin

Hh?: mnitar??

?1 icwc-IrierlLs.


L'l
r-J

Tuvalvi?g BLaff?
7? Tc?.

r1.
.-

-J ?krlii I: 'rtl u.irch :el a .

HF.- 

"h Hcfua- y, I'l! uh] v:

 

(Tum wag :xwui bECn Lu

RGSHEFURH: gust Icr Lhu record,

?f faunditimn, 33115

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 23 of 53



6



 

 



I a

tsall? icr?




iHhi9C: Luv nhiecticn, ch muv an?wer.

THE YES.

BE ME. VILLRUHE:

DU yum that puniki?n 0f Eh? :?hmul
dimLtiut, hack in 2?lb?2?1h ?fh??l yaar, ;ed to

rh: inwid?nt an chumh?: 4, E?lh, whmre Mr. Ekbiad was

a555n41Luni?

ER. EUEHEFGRD: Unject: ua11? fa:

lacxcing in Iihunitltity1. [ijen3t

:?mpIetE 

1c; :tn: 

?un?a?t t5 mm yin may JHEHET.





ENE. 151 
d? FGU LhiLk if In 

Eafrhad?

.-. -
UL ML.



rat {m?iy l3 T?xh Hih int

icllru~tuzi Wirq he

wouLH have

thalj r~ -Wh. 1 . 1? 
'1 IIJII I 
'13 I'll - I 

 

 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 24 of 53















 

 

il. 

LC: be: ale-:3: :LJerr" 

111:;- I. I .--: .i any i'rii [JAN-?tar. 1.: HI 
mule-J -.- Ci]: 

0n December EHLJ, a: well?

as}: you in turn 7:0 pal-g;- 

these yinur nukes; Iii-33' T?Dlh'??
Pa Thu.
Find :3

w:1_2

TFJEI.

111

Find ri-z-nrnn?i-?rtt, I- I1 pair-it uni-.11,

:11] 51;;31'1: . 

I read 

Arm why WEE: that :1 Jena-I 

iha ?15:?i:L hquw 

.I-?.-.-.ah; 

this; a safety meeting :15

i 

 

i I 
'l 

 

Exhibit 

CASE 

I-IH-

ID

.2.-

Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 25 of 53

 

 

maq?,

tqara

int



11 I.



F. 71735 

?3

ll:-



I .
guy.

15,


HE

In be



Htat hut 

1.45 EL 5

Fi?-Wt remember.

?nd I Hat yau t0 luxn Lu #39.

Thix jr161 Har?ty team meeting UH




. 
E..I 

?nd yum were present aL that

T95.

Why 1L Say, enz.i$3uu

rm: LHE d?cw. ELJEF i; jured.

r94h3tallmc??

yum




the frustra"'"

lE was Mu?c u-

-'the m%npl? Em THHC LL a; mu:

it any $ivcn Lima Jurinq

Tr vr?za :u;5;illq an: rn?r"? 3 1119
PW: ?ll, 15 ?iln'r huuw L.
LII PI W: 
-T?rwr'1 L: I - 'u 

 

Exmb?D

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 26 of 53

II

 

3.3.x? ?1:317:13; 

5 Lpasaifra !E.ya 14h at peas; ?uriflq ?lJ* c-f n?324

a ?ew: Lherh, Lhaf y?u nuudmd,

Lila; 



4 ye; knew. you: na?qa. y?u LG maer fr; peraun a:

a the ymu wuujd a sticke; Lu Mn Fr?m

Thu Dluvatnr cauld wnly L?k?

f3 LU the E-Ilcawa-f?r.
you ta the parLivular yum a?iu yam W?nk?d ta g0

ta; and then another ba?qw Lu get intm thaL

fimar.
1U s:ai? wu: Lrnatreted wiLL all of 
Inns-15'. {Icing an atl. ?irt-VG m:

I 1. I.-. . . .L 
. 12:51-4- yT-?l- ?Jr dm?rh a1:- {me-Had and x-rcg. we?:

T3 bee?minq may: vulnerable.
{3 fit Hid-=5, at L314 

if: 511$, it. reads, r57: main gain-Ly

TP and :mntruL??
MCI 





.



f5 
flaw can: Hm 5m_Ji an tr:r vH22



i FF- 2.11:3 l. i lih. 

 

'x Iii-1:13: E: .1 1. DUE-ILL. iLal ..a1' .1 I. . .--.I: - . .

 

JPN-J.

 

F. 1?53:



-2 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page .I: [It] I .111. I

.zha I.

E: [Jllj atlg' r'Ii Ha?ci EJL LJiraf

1'23, PINES, seiety :u'r-J-iat' {an: her-J;- um,-

LIL: Lin..- ii,



.W 
1:0le

9 and whit wag Lhe relatinnahip betwemn

Lhunw nnf?v a?d that incidD?L?

J?s. We) if the Lelt., EST. fhe timrc,
:hat therd L?dn'L been any 5*9p5 :akcn, in JJeu HT

that incidep:, that H??ld chanum behavigr a: allcw ua

mu-rs-z?r- HHFE rmr' ETIIiichingu.

LU

l.

Turning: Bate-5.: ?rh-E 

team Teeting Eur E5311 

th?m, Gft?n

Uh: qr?. 

wch? ?Ji?Lr Team ?cwmiztco mcuL?

. l?n.



m: :15; a

imnlh?f Fame urL

pm: ?maul 'I'Il'f r-F. 

 

 

2:161
Wig
gnu Ihwse awa ycur notciExhibrt 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 28 of 53

 

 

II

LII-DH I 



w' 

Lhi?

halis:icaiiy, a

huilding :31: 

Liza 

1r evidence.



I 



?nj

lil'ri' .

CELLS

l'

,r 

11-" L: . 

Her; 

rI-j 

.rrcl..I 3.1: :5 r1-



stud?an?

Whit r' s;

. 
ICE

Ill:-


Iw

THE HI 

wanld

Ire-If.



-- 
a. I .

LEE-.L 

.--I.

?15 3a.-

goiLg Lu he adGIC?ncd

mini-:16! I: I:

Lilt?
111:: we hair; qmtIzcz-II 1:3 

I: fa il'I hi? 1' .

Ezafi?

:rnn?th Lha: 

li-r] 

JIE-CE-TTIHII: EH:

I 
.. . TIT.

Lt

p315: 15, 

C: i-iJI: . w; 

hr:- .ll I 
I: I 1' 425Ir]: I I I :l 'I'l I I

 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 29 of 53





?'31 L. 

 

 

fl v.915; i arr: 

IJHHS

th: p?iLL i?
.Pu. 31.1:- just ma latte: l. tint-3.: HEEL

agwuttr Lhal- 3Th1 knew. an. Ilwa time, fr?H_rai. we




had acc? FULHLH ail Cve: place that we wean?t



HEIE t3 Cy?? Hn, which wculd lt?d Ln m?re

unsafe bni1ding.

and than tn ?ataa 521. next

pdgt: .

?gajr; 'tnESc are yin: :unmu;: i5 that

Enrrect?

-41





:ha lama i: has Ith-da?e Cf
fh:tcjn?1 is 'zhsuL?

3 I nc'.

1H akhlad Lh?39?

5. 

3:1 1 '9wi13d h? FH In rr?*nr 

.. 
..-I.I -: 

1? TVF 

 

 

 

5. 


E??htD

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 30 of 53

L-Lli i l-iJ 

II . 




a113u?

Lila-5 Huh-3:3] 

THE.

All rthr.

I?r

 

and if I may ul?n adj ta tk?L, iL was

:15

[he fanzt that the FEDIELF.H. ?ur building 

C?nLrn], wan 33L raking

been real, atLivm HVEEK.

?311 

And that Lia ta last sentczuu.

315

1?1: I. 

?TdthiFy Stud?hk? H'aff thaL are LJ

walks by b?caUEJ uf sele1y

f'

Mal-f- 

--
W??q U??m menu

:31afF unulfed L:

were erjit?wkm nr 

. . -


{Hi?TaFf1935. W?h'?4 
a -- Hm if .HJH Lhu dfiil? ?3 they Sh?uld hava

 

 

 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17



..

Page 31 of 53

 

MI I "inI?ll. .Ill':

EI .

.H-u

a:
bxhilgzi 

thiwhat haw

I'd km take

wauld.

Cr

this page?





[Hr re

Uri-2&1 



l'

warked

L: Tm;- ear-I TE: dccumum . It 

.31 {Lu "Jilin -3 
1-.- - - . .. - . . . . -
.. 1- ?d um; luau a RJ r:v_

14 Fax
1 132le :15 L11-

yaliuy an 

?uh1ic



hr: 1" ii: ?5 ?36. 1.1-: hm: J: 

f-f?al Saint. .1 i'?gll ham-'5; .3 .

 



we


Fake:

ID


El

and Tavaw

 

'51-7- -21 I I- 51-IL: I 
.3935. ..L. . 
2-1-1 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 32 of 53



Ix.-


 

 

Fat-.1 nfleain-?L- 

.

:rll?il-?iT' 31: Li: li-z'N?'?bet .-, r'e'znil?, 

t3? her-TSrL-H'l-Urit'. m: Mutt-nice dascritud by 

manic? by GE 

Dr memhar mf the ?uhnnl diatrigt



1.31:5 I PEER-1.1 Lh-?at; 

Want.
The page, Limit: Training, The

i? ha ha ?iSSEmi?ng? an and

Starlent?, and and sturjuzmi; 3

n.
.-- v.



Lut'nirtc; The [1133.1 ?an? 

"i QUE ?3 J, j_'t tau-Lug?' ?Flag; '1 111-

:i aggirwsz-Siazl 
Ir 7-: 11151-311
L11 il' I 1 it
1' . 111;; I 
.sl .1 rial-Lil. 11:91:. 
i. 

I i-i. . i ['31 . 

 

 

Ada-1r new?.


Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 33 of 53



C1

.I. Hl'r: :l r} 355: -i 
HEW t0 Lurn yuur L3

Dagambe: i, EJLE.

Ynu pre??nt at S?eral JHc?l Echami

mayJUaLle? fa: tam IDLMLU, 1f yam wwuld, as

In re?nhES to Mr. Ekhlad and ygura?li, what 

NH. ROCHEFHHU: 11.3. [flay

a- Lnu qwa?tt?n as mveriy and Udguwr and am

mnrh, it calls him tn anj npnnulace.

Caul?' yam- Jar?r 



RT HT- EILLEUHE:

3* athd and ii van unr.

WWma car tfie Lung' pmrri.n Fn tan Elle

I?l' th_nk Hh=t 1: ll- 1r 
I. quest;cu.

7?
I
'1




h"


I?u-

Etfle male prhmiue 1n mer

 

 

 

a 

EmetD

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 34 of 53







 

 

biFa. n?l'T'Ti?ii 2: [i5t1rl aiLLL: ?Ild .r 3-1114 

in]; Inna eqL

QUE thek wa ware DULH 1n.

1h
83' Uil 
Hun ycu what 
Plum ?he time LhaL berauu a p?fL ur the
inatdent. cam: nut n? GUY main attire and

Uilmuxlw fr] FT?nt GE UHF area huh]. 

. .- ..-I - -
Ln :qy Lrn% rrmn: 

..

caluLerim.

Fables, out,

when we

lhz-Ruir MIL, am? .3. 15.1135. ?rm-Er- l?dl-m.

I?dn? wag 1J5 a C?d: vgilmy in the ??Ftthia,

'hr?lL a fl?hL 

ijil 41L [wrvirlt. L?i :-u-3k 3175

F.-
_l

 

 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 35 of 53





. a 

 

m.

RQFL

 

Hil? H: a nan hmyiilq :h?bqj LHL Lru; cu'

Laulu.

THIEEC: in": Ell}! WE: u?u-L-z 

Hftu?errt?. JL?ln vna? tharl T?ak?ui amid ?r1t?

Lh? n? the table by game injlvidua], and

the: Dru-ice: Free and war: Lam-:4. 
right at the la?L mumwnt, J?h? slammed dawn gnLu

IF: fi?mr and waa being uhnked.



at LtaL paint, 1u35 r?n a5 iaar and

.-, - -.--. . J. 
4qu An I 3 knock thu mm the atudunr Ema: was

trying La :h?hu t: knack hi3 frmn, and

thankIully. iL did him and align him to JEE hia

hands Df ML. Ekblad.

Were injured in Lhu 

-., ,4

HH. Jun: irn' LHE 1?:lwnh

his I {hrn'r

{Juji?jgtzimdin.? I. .4 guns ?ml- 1'n1 gLLan

Zaw Lau! -?kv3LlL u;23 irleJV?ea; Eu: :JC2?urqeaH

HIEia?nchle WJUJ1 nreiudiuu him.

   

IHF WIIHLH 

-v to geL 

 

Exhjhit El

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 36 of 53

lilt?: it.

7 BE ME. TILLQUHEyum 

Hr. 

tli:l 523-1.-



rrmr'rn'mg, yam


r317: 

Lal

+3 Ell-1  l't?dr tht: student at? :?ALchizeer? :1;le

Hr. hikinl?d, hr?t r' dutit'u}: E'rl' Llu':

assault?



9 

13 What did yULl that? 5.33?, and 1-!th 

_C:J_r_l him if; gal].

?nkirm l'ni-mtiE: 311m ur: was [1.3413 hi5. 

5:

341.53 thaz, 2,1111 Feet: 31am that.

4 . Ha?

gnu 

Lari;



H.5- 

1% qivr; a what Ls; hiIr-E' 

fuck?? 1'7.

f; Fir: tl'liItJ: 
1le H: . was; 11: l- 2:1?

Quiz-2:351M13 :50 Iaz'.

Eff-1'1, 



-1 

 

"'53

ll: 3:41; 13-35. 

t5

 

 

-I - -- I
IIEkhjhit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page l1"Ir: Lin}! eff-3 :

Ema-r. Lu 

an:

I'l-
I

Wauld TD yum LLul ii wag
racially mativated?
MH. ?bjeuL; calla for
Speculatimn --

HY HR. 

HH. juert. 
f?rm of qn??linn; laak? Faun aticn.
EQL LHH nnwwer.
[17.5 1 .



m] ha: ?ux-EH 11.2; 
Number ugh win an m?nwnL muJ
LlisiL, titan-:2.

Fir-e l' . 



hill-1 . rn

[?r?arm 1' j: 2-Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 38 of 53







 

 

5i Fl. 

thi: HAG 'w Lhe ]hU:Hilc

I. --
hullm 

u: HE I?uz 'aJw

Why ?ld y?u wri;u it?



I was ??kun tn d? a: ?5 purL U. the

pruuaedinqn :hat Ecru 2m hawwm?.
?nd averyihinq cantained in he victim

impact {3 true?

Euu.

i The Hantent? read?, and qu?tcwag {13:33 pure-:14! maluu?ua; Lulu-mt. to
[10 inf:1ry.?

hat; 





.

11'

I_l

W'ni? hf 

In my awn T've -- brute?

up plunty n? in nv Ca-

thlE Leuul. awnr :h;5 uiujnlu. rereatediv

. 'llr-- -. . - 
u, ?19:1 jijfil.

'Ftun. and cum: LH

48

 

 

rt 1- ri=un
?dr- FL LHJH
?ill"fii' il?rl a 
f'3 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 39 of 53







r-u 


a) -


 

 

ML. Lkhle?

the p0rp0traLu:_ wag

Airi??n?Awericanf

A THE.

The HEEL EQRTEHCC reads, was the wunwt

and mn?L ui?l?nL atta?k seen Hr been mar

--
5.1 15 

cf it my I

Ann than the seccnd p?xagrap? ta1k5 abmu
Mic ccn?cqumn?a? that am?: a3 a
attack?

TEE.
And the? Lhird puxaqraph unwr gnu

i?ijt?, 'th: of rl1n Hung: dianerirmr things; ?thH- this
1711-51 wen; 

?Kali?"mi 'iI'l :g-ncl

J?1kar1 Htwh?? EIsn?miwi? er:;c many

i Fan l??I 



J. f. 01: rim

hath Lays wwr?

-Hey h?qnh lanhiag 

 

 

 

[1"1 . 
fig: H. 



CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 40 of 53

E3


an."




I



 

?d ti'EL'iJ 33611 Lu, "This

i lair-1. 

Did read that 

Ji 

And then yum wrnke, ?While head;nu GHL tn

lihc; Eryn-ad muleplri 

puliLlI-E. "i?cm thunk I give a fuck Laban whenl'.

haggaanec?f'"
Ii. Iii?? .

i LtFBeIi-i?i 

-
5  
I.



yum itl'er?u wrr?T-E; make-:9

i; u??31r :0 me Lian Lh? atJJum: was a HIE wj:h inngi.

i "'hiS in tz' Trivi :1 1-3 11:5 Ith L110

. .- Ell?1:51?) i In 



 

 

 


'r'I'1?1- i. if iti'ij': .l .41 
I I 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page purely

:i 
if?114:. lac}; HF

i?ra p?r??nul kr?wlejn?. m?dica?

.
1 {Nu-3 .

fits-ln'rsiu'n? thud-u, 1.1m. answer 



Ga gnu can answer itLhah aftack wag dune

n'iLI'; jnt-gn'. dc. 

Qua-1 L'rr: Jar-are Of the the

?it?JL- -- m: *h ere

I151 3:

:ii- ?17 

in 5mm rht'hlr. 

1? weer-u. sat-mun.
I 1

?3 1 .

01'; mark 



in 



a. 

511-: .

uwvwneL

'l -TI 1 I 431. 
1 
- 

 

 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 42 of 53

I1. 

1 



I 



 

 

Cumin- 

[12' MR. 
if Lhr: am Mr. :?Id
have? prevented?!
HF. MHz-if. of
calla Ln: 
farm.
{Sim ahead anti it.

5?1'1'I'Mtifjfj: "5:33 .

MIA. Fa". HE:

'1 Him been 



5 L535Eli-c: I. J. 

['visr. wrrI-? 1131: l'r'wm as


I I 



rm. 1'9 fC-L'm

jrt-II 

i'i 1'1- Lyn-6.1. I 

211 LL .

ill] 11'. .. act 1

l. - rn" 113.5. (02:11 
'1 .
17:: F: .

 

 

 




I 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 43 of 53

5" 1 3'5. 

if:

 

aim; waszs

l" if. F: . .


..

HLWHESS: EDthut.

HE
HE . I Lina. 

li'liill. riir?.? 

MR. ijeul-;

?51115 Gb'iEcL 

Lia: rm.



?nd anawcr, i: yum man.

(Tn-:9 ?35193 

1 L113 l.

THF13.5111}: Lulu-.9 H515 a 

I 

~22



El '3 my

Hit-?1 attack?
of

1? arm

what

F4. .

Hi}: 

i1 r.

 

hasac! r31. lint: 



:?rf 

Fm Ewe. I l'i-J Ll 

New

..Ilu- 

.

{:21 7.3 the 1.13"

tsiguz41%" 41 Lr rl - e2:
Val: I- 

 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 44 of 53

E1

3]



 

PH. E'Jtr'ii?erxL: r7711}? Lu:

[11.1 ttii: .Il' 5:11-1:15.

what Lhi': wj 1:119:23 11.13 maid 

55-1111, Ir'. F?l' Spc-Culal 5-:1r1, Hing 

Subject 1.111151%: 1.31311 

.

1.
JCS.

THE 511' 1' 1' Iii-i1 

HR . ?111.31 UHbi:

C111 thf.? 1325-1] heard

afzer 511E125, 1.11.1 will:

think. hi? 5151;1ou m1 EEJJLEIKE 1.21151 [3921111311121 111


.-

11331 1.11:: :1 I.

MP. . I'fl 

mil Fair? li? the ich'r'I

1'1- tha- -.1 31:15 ILL-C111.

.1

F1110: lL [.3141 31113151731; 

1::r {11'15111-3-151.







1

1'1.11.111 -.-F
I II Vii-T- L. - '1l'
A I.

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page Speculatingrruct: in?.

surna?r 14:1 m-

.f JIL. 



j? an?au and arswer.

THE {3021 .



Haw album-Eng 3m? 33,. 

1:51 IZL-?s?rnss :31 rift-ad than, if. 

(Review? durum-MU. .J (may.

y?cm 1-5-5] .21 Chane-.2 Ls). 17'5-

iE: Ell. 

T. 
.- I will? 

I i-[hrL- L: '.Jl .. 

I: 

. 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page Hr.. 1 :Eullj'lW??'t :Lunalnq

3 a upx:te as 



r. 1 Ir 
Halli] flu 

lie was lulunwinq and tunnqqi??

d&:ainc? it m.u. ?fFi?m,

I abaut haw KANE Limes he 'chki?g hiL that 

F4 teacher'?:

:1 E: .

f? Bit} I F95 i tliat 
Maw, He had made er?I?nrH; 1n Emu14? Ml+ ILL-314.151, LILEJ 

_x

1 3 :5 f. t. 

a_'r rat in Lhis i=?s Hit in

-J
:33




_Ju Arm? Thcul Ltu. unnu?rui p?lngq131hh 

II I

M4. lam-21?;

 

 

 


air?1 2'1"

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 47 of 53

5'3' 1" I T..

 

 

 



L15: LI Kw'tnhurk?qn L'm guul.  l? y?x

Cl 1 he"?


and than yuu ?ELudgnr wa?

:5 the

hrmner czuzf the? (that inciivirjus'l: is LEE-3L

thr?nh,

HHEHK

I'esafi tr; tk;L5 nthIIErrg, 1'ki TETQIJ tt;_

J.



:i?hL?

THE.
And then y?u WIDLD, "?fter he nade 

r" .
Lb bu??h Hi?dhlJu we FEPLdLedlf Ln Lhe upper

Hem 1:5. Iglm?r 

.

f] that Wh?n hujnred?



Baacj n: Lhe 

airi jnar1? c3: 11;

-mjjh?: :llJ_uv:iI1q -at Ezlul; L:u FM d,

til m] [:931 1r? . 

rr- rift} 

.-
.l


Fiwm fl Tue GMTELLGJ: t: f?t?dhi'?h,

I - . . .
3:53;:

 

 

Exmmt?

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 48 of 53

IE.

1.1?
r1-





f- 

 

 

 

TI WLLI'mlzl it];
.et-rw? ri-i- E13.

speculating, aim

May I have: ILl'it-i

read hacL leane?
was East-:21 bag-.1. In:
Lhc-t- mun": 
E1: win-J 
district?Spunbm:ad iniLiuLlun that all ??Lnl Paul
Pnhli? Schmaja wera 3nppoged Ln engrain  .21Ir=. Satan]. yt?rar, L?Ju-r-ua. ratat?

.15: (tantra? High 

In

:25 [in their mice-

P. Hm.
La: rutfnrir 

-wvw Hit: n;

ac! 

ULUJHHEH .H.f1u1hral ?til n: 
ii" 13'? -.-.-
Hm. I 1 3.1-3.1 I1 1, .. I. 1
Juinu I. L111.r ?lmy, I 
ts-z-i ml 1 ..11 . 1,211.. 

i In Eh that: .-II 

IL . -- -- .--..- . . -
a 

:1 





 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 49 of 53








HT

 

 

.L:
?rst: CJII LL.-

UC5H5LLU1 -e -x $iQLL:n_mwh:J_ 2; f? 

Hi?h 

TEE.

A Ther? ?inn'r Ream ta be any 1h

place Lh?t was going Lu dutwr b??zminq

veri:aJ.ly .anii :y iIfLu

the tritic?'mr?a.

nn y?ur 1&5: anuwnr, yum were mart

cf 

Eehtrm1's

l'm part :31 Emlr?. Paul

adn?inx4tratinrh

.-- .1 . .. . .
-: flnaj . Jam.w:. ?r that . cutd Lh;5i?i at] 

nk?u: th iF assaJltm an

Za3: bh?wgr

tearheis, dc you rhiih :chnn: HdPitiEftEtimn 3L

Hmn:rai fuwi rati?cd t?gat :unj in he (MTWE Tm

a?ruulin?
IKE. {jb?uici kc. ftp: chgn 
3f the qnw:-Ltn. I duH'l II . ynu've as"L-. 

?rn1?rhafirwn Fw?" LkuiEKWEHD

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page l?l



 

 

ruLlh rl-wf anj Hal:{ kg;
THE: it"; r? . 
WITFESE: THH.
Li?: . 1" L1 HST:
HhuL did a?miniEtLJiimn Lnuw that

:a'ln'mld have Jjg?n 51011.3?

HH. EUCHEFURD: Ubj?ct ta the 
[Lurks far

specuiaLimn.

CE Em Lh?ae Uh??nfimns, ;f ya; can



I 


Si]; 

TEE HITHEES: P3EESE rmpeat :39


:3ahlimnik t}

1

the unwrt 

WHL HLTHESE: af?ncg

3.. - -
1.11.335: 11,1341 qr: 

Hf?Ff. ?i?w try and pr?cgsi JHJ FigUTu
[)llL 11-52:. H: I r- Cult? 'l . 
Erew thg?viLq.
31' HR. J. 
hf:- F4 Haj-L- .J, u; 

. 

 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page Mnat JD mean th? y?u thatITIF 1' J. J. 

inlrr?u?? i;


mumuLPi?? H?r? tn pl?C?, Lhar yru b'

. - . l. Ir 
pxuximiLy E: maata H+?n 

#3 GfiDnL;meH an?g? our??muku unre tLat are pragectcd

'jr-j it par: UL 3mm: an?!
ya?pmnsihiliLius In ?g that?

I

it's a Chuiue gnu mak?f




r?es.

$?ldnta1y 

aL CuLLral 

deal wit]. vimlrJIZ-I-rl

1. I -

-tll Ir ,4 ml r-ku . l?ICASE Document 92 Filed 06/09/17 Page 11rah-1 n-Tt-?j

UL 3.1.11 Ir?rmj?e 



TI:


I

. -

I







-313.

 



Li 11:11: 1.1: [.1111 1:1J.il:y HEELS: 11.1.3.1 5511115131

E: H1 ke1mH mi and auL: mf vinl?nu? by Studunr?

7' L?'er??ELiLi in in {3f 1,11?;

Ewing iuvn?qu?

I I I - I
with SPELL

.51. 

11*- the 5111151. Lim?z that: Ln. deal

1" -.-- .
. [5 pun-1:. we

1' can 1a langu: unnta?n 31 help, wiJ: th?n' at thaL

I.

3 13.3. 1' I: af?p in 

.3

Li I
I12:

r? .11an 11-? an ramp-11.3 i1; .1. 11111

i;

15 WELT tilleu 

[hi-3' - j-f--.--.
I .1. I I

 

 

1:11 
1-. 

Exhibit 

CASE Document 92



PI-

9

Filed 06/09/17 Page LIL:

 

 

213-:- '33 

ifiLnP?E lacALng llnuw1aii3r and mnlLi?C 

Sp??ul?ti??.

rhwna Er. Klmig, iL

Subjch Ln

gnu can an?wwr, quasainq n1 mpequlating,

plea?e d0 5U.

THE L?f] Cit-I1 Hm: .

F1 . 

as [la-s mudguard prim-?ipaL 3.11.! a: warm-er

u] aha unrety team and an yumr earlier answer.
did Mr. have a Lu put himself aL

r1sk fiq?uf in d, 

!Jid he H?f a ru?pun;?iwiliry?

. .
.

WT. ?ha?k ycu. h?v?



nuLthq thhrar.

. 
l' HIT: EE 12' 1' Lil-1 ?Hrj I: kt;- I. 
.

TEN-I 

.


 

Exhlbit