PAUL J. HETZNECKER, ESQUIRE
Attorney I.D. No. 49990
1420 Walnut Street, Suite 911
Philadelphia, PA 19102
(215) 893-9640

Attorney for Plaintiff

Filed and Attested by the
Office of Judicial Records
22 AUG 2016 04:55 pm
Nafis PinkneyN. SWEENEY

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY
NAFIS PINKNEY
Plaintiff
vs.
DETECTIVE JAMES PITTS, ET AL
Defendants

:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:

COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY
FEBRUARY TERM, 2015
NO. 655

PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
REGARDING PRIOR MISCONDUCT OF
DEFENDANT DETECTIVE PITTS AND DEFENDANT DETECTIVE JENKINS
Plaintiff, Nafis Pinkney, hereby files this Motion to Compel Discovery Regarding Prior
Misconduct of Defendant, Detective James Pitts and Defendant Detective Jenkins, pursuant to Pa.
R.C.P. 4019(a)(1)(vii) and (viii), and submits the following in support thereof:
1.

On October 13, 2015, Plaintiff Nafis Pinkney served Interrogatories and Request

for Production of Documents upon Defendants. Following the request, counsel for the defendant
supplied some, but not all of the discovery requested.
2.

On May 28, 2016, Plaintiff submitted a Second Request for Production of

Documents attached as Plaintiff’s Exhibit “A.” On the second request the Plaintiff reiterates
many of the requests made in the first request as the Defendants failed to comply and failed to
1

Case ID: 150200655

 respond to those specific requests. In that request the Plaintiff specifically asked for but did not
receive the following documents:
“4.

The complete personnel files maintained by the
Philadelphia Police Department for all of the defendant
police officers.
NOT RECEIVED

5.

The complete Internal Affairs Division's investigation
file regarding the incident which is the subject of Nafis
Pinkney's complaint.
NOT RECEIVED

6.

All documents concerning every civil and criminal
complaint made against all of the defendant officers.
NOT RECEIVED

7.

All civilian complaints, grievances and charges made
against the entire defendant officers involved in the
investigation involving the defendant officers.
NOT RECEIVED

8.

All documents which concern or relate to any
psychological and/or psychiatric referral, evaluation or
treatment pertaining to all of the defendant officers.
NOT RECEIVED

9.

All training materials and directives including
manuals, handouts, outlines, films, etc. used by the
Philadelphia Police Department and the City of
Philadelphia in training their employees regarding an
individual's constitutional rights, including the
treatment of suspects and witnesses during
interrogation.
NOT RECEIVED
2

 10.

All documents, records/reports concerning all
reprimands discipline and terminations made by the
Philadelphia Police Department and/or City of
Philadelphia against the Defendants, as well as any
policy directives involving interrogations of suspects.
NOT RECEIVED
(a)

All cases and documents related to cases in
which the defendants have been accused of
misconduct. This includes all cases in which the
defendants have been accused of forcing
confessions;

NOT RECEIVED
(b)

All cases and documents related to cases in
which the defendants have been accused of
holding witnesses, as well as suspects, in custody
for lengthy periods.

NOT RECEIVED
11.

Please supply all W-2's, 1099's and Federal and State
tax returns of the Defendants.
NOT RECEIVED

12.

Please provide the names, addresses, telephone
numbers and a brief statement of regarding the
testimony of all lay witnesses that you intend to
produce at trial.
NOT RECEIVED

14.

All Police Department policies and directives involving
the treatment of individuals encountered and/or placed
in custody by the police who are witnesses as well as
suspects.
NOT RECEIVED
3

 15.

RECEIVED.

16.

Please provide all of the investigative files regarding
related homicide investigations. Any investigation in
which the defendants, as well as other homicide
investigators considered relevant, and/or related to this
investigations. (A more specific request with respect to
these documents is set forth in Paragraph 1)
NOT RECEIVED

17.

RECEIVED

4.
In addition, we are requesting the previously requested items ,
specifically referenced based on the limited discovery that has been
provided to date. While the City has provided the Concise Officer
Histories for both Ohmarr Jenkins and James Pitts, the disclosures are
incomplete. Specifically, we are requesting the Internal Affairs
Investigation Report for each of the following investigations: NOT
RECEIVED IN DISCOVERY
Officer Ohmarr Jenkins
IA No.
98-1171
01-9045
02-9006
02-0338
03-0246
05-0211
05-6134
08-6034
13-0014
15-0183

Date
7/16/1998
7/21/2001
1/30/2002
7/22/2002
5/28/2003
5/3/2005
9/7/2005
3/7/2008
1/10/2013
4/20/2015

Complainant
Denise McCray-Scott
Kareem Coleman
Harold Daniel Tibers
Harold Cornelli
Mike Bass and Jermaine Sutton
Donna Madison
Anthony Byrd
Confidential
Raffinee Taylor
Antonio Brown

NOT RECEIVED IN DISCOVERY
Officer James Pitts
IA No.
97-9078
99-1169
00-6075

Date
11/7/1997
8/5/1999
4/26/2000

Complainant
Robert Satchel
James Godfrey
David Willis
4

 01-0046
01-1053
01-1101
02-1009
03-0336
04-0198
05-0367
06-1040
06-0404
12-0041
13-0014
13-0592
15-0136
15-0311

2/5/2001
3/27/2001
5/5/2001
1/21/2002
7/9/2003
4/4/2004
7/13/2005
4/5/2006
8/4/2006
1/25/2012
1/10/2013
10/7/2013
3/24/2015
6/16/2015

Kathleen Douglass
N/A
Tyree West
IAD
Rosalind D. McLaughlin
Peggy Dugan
Luis H. Valentin
Sandra Fuller
Lucille West
Leroy Cook
Raffinee Taylor
Zshani Al-Rasul
Keith Tolbert
Diane Marble

NOT RECEIVED IN DISCOVERY
3.

On June 1, 2016, Assistant City Solicitor, Brock Atkins, Esquire entered his

appearance on behalf of the Defendants. Sometime in early June, counsel for the Plaintiff had a
phone conversation in which counsel for the Defendants, Brock Atkins, indicated that he would
not disclose the items that were the subject of the Plaintiff’s First and Second Request for
Production of Documents. Plaintiff asserts that the requested information is disclosable and asks
that this Honorable Court order the Defendants to produce the documents requested based upon
the following:
4.

In October, 2013, Nafis Pinkney was found not guilty of two counts of first degree

murder. Mr. Pinkney was charged based exclusively on the false confession extracted from him
by Detectives Pitts and Jenkins. This false confession was the product of psychological coercion.
After twenty four hours of continuous threats, intimidation, and sleep deprivation, Mr. Pinkney
agreed to implicate himself in a crime he did not commit. During the almost four years of
pre-trial incarceration, Mr. Pinkney anguished over the real prospect of either being put to death,
5

 or spending the rest of his life in prison for a crime he did not commit. Following his acquittal,
Mr. Pinkney continues to struggle with the aftermath. Mr. Pinkney lost his job, personal
security and psychological well being.
5.

As shocking as this case is, this is not the first time Detective Pitts and Detective

Jenkins have been accused of fabricating evidence. The evidence uncovered to date reveals that
both Pitts and Jenkins have engaged in a frightening pattern and practice of fabricating evidence,
including coercing false confessions. Based upon the information developed to date, Mr.
Pinkney’s case is the fourth homicide case in which Pitts and Jenkins have manipulated witnesses
and suspects into providing false statements. A review of these prior “bad acts” evidence
involving Defendants Pitts and Jenkins demonstrates that the City of Philadelphia has information
that has been withheld that directly relates to the claims in this case. In addition to the specific
claims set forth in the Second Request for Production of Documents, the City of Philadelphia is
respectfully requesting the court grant this Motion to Compel and order the ?City to disclose any
all information related to the cases set forth below:1
6.

On October 7, 2009, Amin Speaks was charged with first degree murder. The

same two homicide detectives, Ohmar Jenkins and James Pitts were assigned to investigate the
murder. Prior to trial, counsel for the defendant provided two surveillance tapes establishing that
Mr. Speaks was at another location when the murder occurred. Despite unequivocal evidence of
innocence, it was discovered that Pitts and Jenkins had intimidated a witness into providing a

1

Two of these alleged “Bad acts” are set forth in Paragraphs 6 and 7 reflected in the Daily News story dated
November 6, 2013 about the Plaintiff and these two other cases. Attached as Exhibit “B”

6

 fabricated statement that Mr. Speaks was responsible for the murder. More specifically,
Detective Pitts coerced a false statement from Shaquille Rainey, the learning disabled cousin of
the defendant, Speaks. During the interrogation which lasted five hours, Rainey was physically
assaulted and threatened by Pitts. A jury acquitted Amin Speaks of all the charges.
7.

In January, 2011, murder charges were dropped against Unique Drayton, a young

woman charged with fatally stabbing her roommate in August of 2009. The prosecution
disintegrated after the judge ruled that Detective Pitts coerced a false confession from the
defendant. In that case, Ms. Drayton was interrogated for almost 48 hours, repeatedly threatened
and twice physically assaulted while being handcuffed to a chair in an interrogation room.
Eventually, Ms. Drayton gave into the threats and provided the fabricated confession to the fatal
stabbing of her roommate. In granting the motion to suppress Judge Sarmina stated “This Court
found many things that Detective Pitts had to say incredible….” Judge Sarmina summed up her
decision by stating that “This[the defendant’s] statement that she made was not voluntarily made,
but was the product of psychological coercion.”
8.

On December 22, 2009, Dwayne Thorpe was convicted of first degree murder and

eventually sentenced to life in prison. One of the witnesses against Mr. Thorpe was a man named
Allan Chamberlain. Pursuant to a Post Conviction Relief Act filing on May 8, 2015, upon
information and belief, Chamberlain was brought into police headquarters to provide a statement.
Detective Pitts interrogated Chamberlain and threatened to take away his son and charge him with
murder. Detective Pitts physically assaulted him in order to force him to falsely implicate
Defendant Dwayne Thorpe. Eventually Detective Pitts fabricated a statement from Chamberlain
7

 and Chamberlain signed the statement. In that statement Chamberlain implicated the defendant
Thorpe in statements that he made indicating that he was angry with someone on the block and that
he implied that he was going to use guns to protect his drug business. Upon information and
belief during trial, Allan Chamberlain completely denied making the statement and explained that
Detective Pitts had physically abused him and threatened that he would prosecute Chamberlain for
the murder and take away his son.
9.

In Commonwealth v. Kyle Reed, CP-51-CR-0015615-2010, witness Rafinee

Taylor was called by the Commonwealth to establish the motive for the defendant Kyle Reed to
have engaged in a robbery homicide. Detective Pitts presented her with several statements for
her to sign. At trial, Ms. Taylor insisted that Detective Pitts fabricated those statements, held her
in custody for four days, most of the time spent secured in handcuffs and threatened to charge her
with homicide and that she would never see her children again. Additionally, he refused her any
food and kept her incommunicado from her family and the lawyer. She testified that she
eventually was overcome by his coercive techniques and signed the statements that he had typed
as she thought it was the only way that she could ever be released. (Exhibit “C“, N.T.,
11/26/2012, pp. 244-256)
10.

In the case of Commonwealth v. John McLaughlin, CP-5l-CR0010456-2008, the

Commonwealth called Raymond Mooney as a witness. Mr. Mooney testified that Detective Pitts
threatened to arrest and lock up his seventy-five year old if Mooney did not provide the statement
that he wanted. Mr. Mooney testified that he was coerced into signing the statement. See, N.T.
2/22/12 at 55-56, attached hereto as Exhibit “D”
8

 11.

In 2013 Internal Affairs received a complaint of Zshani Al-Rasul, IAD# 13-592

asserting that Detective Pitts held her incommunicado for two days, denied her access to her
eleven year old son who was home alone and denied her foot and water, all in an effort to coerce
a statement. Internal Affairs sustained the complaints, and held that Detective Pitts abused his
authority, engaged in an improper detention, and engaged in improper procedure. Detective Pitts
was eventually sued and the case was settled for $110,000.00. Attached as Exhibit “E”.
12.

In 2012, Leroy Cook, an eighty four old man,, had his door kicked in by Detective

Pitts, was screamed and cursed at by Detective Pitts, and was repeatedly threatened by Detective
Pitts. See IAD# 12-041. Detective Pitts specifically threatened to arrest everyone in Mr. Cook's
home for conspiracy. Detective Pitts placed Mr. Cook in custody and held and questioned this
eighty four year old man for over six hours without any legal basis to do so. Internal Affairs held
that allegations against Detective Pitts were sustained and that Detective Pitts abused his authority
and damaged private property. Attached as Exhibit “F”.
13.

In 2015, Keith Tolbert asserted that Detective Pitts assaulted him by striking him

in the face and the groin in order to coerce Tolbert into giving a statement. Internal Affairs
concluded that he could not be either proved or disproved as it was Mr. Tolbert’s word against
Mr. Pitts. Attached as Exhibit “G”.
14.

In 2013 in the case of Commonwealth v. Erica Hovington, Rosalind Woods was

taken into custody by Detective Pitts from her home in her night clothes. She was locked in an
interrogation room in the Homicide Unit for a lengthy period of time even though she had told
Detective Pitts that she had not seen the shooting which was the subject of his interrogation. She
9

 was threatened with arrest and prosecution if she did not tell Detective Pitts what he wanted to
hear. This information was provided by Attorney Trevan Borum. Eventually, Hovington was
acquitted.
15.

In 2008 Tonya Thornton, a correctional officer, sued Pitts after she was held for

ten (10) hours in an interrogation room and falsely accused of participating in a homicide. A
lawsuit was filed.
16.

On November 10, 2008, Terrell Johns sued Detective Pitts Badge No. 9040 and

two other police officers after he was assaulted by them. He was charged with aggravated assault
and resisting arrest. Eventually, those charges were dropped after he spent eight months in jail.
Mr. Johns filed a malicious prosecution claim, which upon information and belief was settled.
17.

Upon information and belief, on April 23, 2012, Recco Ford filed a lawsuit

Defendant, Ohmar Jenkins alleging that Jenkins coerced two juveniles into identifying Mr. Ford
as the shooter in a homicide case. Specifically in the Compliant, Detective Jenkins held the
juveniles for a period of time threatening the juveniles with prosecution for conspiracy to
commit murder if they did not identify Mr. Ford as the person involved in the shooting. Both
juvenile witnesses signed fabricated statements identifying Mr. Ford as the shooter. According
to the Complaint, both juvenile witnesses testified that Mr. Ford was not the person involved in
the shooting. According to the Complaint, each of the witnesses testified that they were coerced
into providing false statements indicating Recco Ford as the shooter. Eventually, Recco Ford
was acquitted of all charges.
18.

As asserted in a pending Motion to Compel, upon information and belief, James
10

 Barrow has provided a confession to the double homicide in which the plaintiff Nafis Pinkney was
charged and eventually acquitted by a jury. Recently, Mr. Barrow confessed to the crime of the
Shield Street murder and upon information and belief has also confessed to the crime involving the
double murder in which the plaintiff was originally charged. The confession in the possession of
the Commonwealth is the subject of that Motion to Compel.
19,.

Defendants, through their counsel have taken the position that this evidence is not

relevant to the malicious prosecution claim asserted by the plaintiff in this case, and therefore not
discoverable. Defense counsel’s position is contrary to the law in Pennsylvania this evidence is
not discoverable.2
LEGAL ARGUMENT
Rule 4003.1, Scope of Discovery Generally, Opinions and Contentions (a) subject to the
provisions of Rule 4003.2 (related to a party’s insurance) and 4003.5 (related to the identification
of experts and disclosure of actual reports) inclusive and for Rule 411 (related to limitation on
scope of discovery and deposition), a party may obtain discovery regarding any matter not
privileged which is relevant to the subject matter involved in the pending action, whether it relates
to the claim or defense of the party seeking discovery or the claim or defense of any other party,
including the existence, description, nature, content, custody, condition and location of any
books, documents, or other tangible things and the identity and location of persons having
knowledge of any discoverable matter. (b) It is not ground for objection that the information
2 Under Pa.R.Evid. 404(b) evidence of prior bad acts may be admissible to show common plan and scheme.
Furthermore, it may tend to show a motive for the claim against the defendants. Likewise, under Pa.R.Evid. 406,
the evidence may be admissible as evidence of custom or habit by the defendants in conducting interrogations.
Under either 404(b) or 406, the requested evidence may be admissible to support the plaintiff’s claim at trial.
However, whether evidence is discoverable is the question before the Court in this motion.

11

 being sought will be inadmissible at trial if the information sought appears reasonably calculated
to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. (c) Except as otherwise provided by these rules,
it is not ground for objection that the information sought involves an opinion or contention that
relates to a fact or the application of law to fact. Pa.R.Civ.P. 4003.1
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has interpreted Rule 4003.1(a) to permit a party to
obtain discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, which is relevant to the subject matter
involving any pending action. Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital of Sisters of Christian Charity, 91
A.3d 680 (Pa. 2014) Furthermore, the Supreme Court has generally ruled that a party generally
is entitled to discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the litigation
subject matter and will substantially aid in advancing claims or defenses. Pa.R.Civ.P. 4003.1
Cooper v. Schoffstall, 905 A.2d 482 (Pa. 2006)
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant this Motion
to Compel Discovery and order Defendants Pitts, Jenkins and their counsel, to provide all of the
documents the Plaintiff has requested within five (5) days hereof or risk sanctions upon further
application to the Court.
Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff

Date: August 22, 2016
12

_

 VERIFICATION
Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire, states that he is the attorney for Plaintiff, Nafis Pinkney and
is authorized as attorney to make this verification on her behalf. The averments of the foregoing
Motion to Compel Discovery are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and
belief. This verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904 relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.

Date: August 22, 2016____

/s/ Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire

13

 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on August 22, 2016, the document described below
has been served upon the following counsel and in the manner indicated:
DOCUMENT:
Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Discovery
SERVICE BY ELECTRONIC COURT FILING (ECF) AND FIRST CLASS MAIL
Brock Atkins, Esquire
City of Philadelphia – Law Department
One Parkway
1515 Arch Street
Philadelphia, PA 19102-1595

/s/ Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff

14

 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY

NAFIS PINKNEY
Plaintiff
vs.
DETECTIVE JAMES PITTS, ET AL
Defendants

:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:

COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY
FEBRUARY TERM, 2015
NO. 655

ORDER
AND NOW, this _________________________ day of ________________, 2016, upon
consideration of Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Discovery and any response thereto, it is hereby
ORDERED and DECREED THAT SAID Motion is GRANTED.
Defendants, through counsel, Detective James Pitts and Detective Jenkins hereby
ORDERED to serve all of the requested documents set forth in the Second Request for
Production of Documents within ten (10) days hereof or risk sanctions upon further application to
this Court.

BY THE COURT:

________________________________________
J.

15

 PAUL J. HETZNECKER, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY I.D. NO. 49990
1420 WALNUT STREET, SUITE 911
PHILADELPHIA, PA 19102
(215) 893-9640

Attorney for Nafis Pinkney

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY

NAFIS PINKNEY
Plaintiff
vs.
DETECTIVE JAMES PITTS, ET AL
Defendants

:
:
:
:
:
:

COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY
FEBRUARY TERM, 2015
NO. 655

ATTORNEY CERTIFICATION OF GOOD FAITH PURSUANT TO
PHILADELPHIA RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 208.2(e)
The undersigned counsel for movant hereby certifies and attests that:
[X ] A.

Counsel for Plaintiff, Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire has had the contacts

described below with opposing counsel regarding discovery matter contained in the foregoing
discovery motion in an effort to resolve the specific discovery dispute at issue and, further, that
despite all counsel’s good faith attempts to resolve the dispute(s), counsel have been unable to do
so.
[X ] B.

Counsel for the Plaintiff, Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire has made good faith

but unsuccessful ,efforts described below to contact opposing counsel in an effort to resolve the
discovery dispute.
CERTIFIED TO THE COURT BY:
Date: August 22, 2016 _______

/s/ Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire _______
Paul J. Hetznecker, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff

16

 Filed and Attested by the
Office of Judicial Records
22 AUG 2016 04:55 pm
N. SWEENEY

Case ID: 150200655

mm EEQEERE
&i?am?2?r LEE Na, 

gm Waimi $ng ?g
E?giiweig?xia? Pz? WHEE-

{3 

 

Em? E?iaimi?? Wm Pim?mey

EN  


 

mm FENKNE-Y mm? mmam 
2 m?ww
mag-mm 

 

 

 mg
.MMSES 

?efm?ams mm 

 

 

mg mamwm
Ti} TEE 

Piaimiff, 1323:: Egmm mm Mama-3, by m. mmugh his; magma mm 3,
ESQEJEW-, mm}; mq?tfg?m 2m aim m?fm?mm  {3f E?hiiadalgjh?a? 
madam: the failgwirxg dwamgzm 1hr: Plaim?ff?? impam?m ami mpyi-zig mm; ?lmy ?ayg
in. with the F?d?zm'E. Rules Civil Proea?rciura? Rum Nm $4.1 Sag}: Wigwam 3m.
Q?l?i??i?g up :53; {Egg {mm (3f {rigiL



A. PM :im: puma-gas mix Rmm?a ma wam {he m?g?mi, 33;}

{Em?is {Eiseme am}. am. mpi?g {Bf w??m primadx gamma! mpmi grapifzia a? magma;

ma?a {ii'mhi?'?i?g but mi; Eim?imd {a maiiempagz, ?iapass mid {was}? hamwer

pm?mmg mpmdiuaad m: pmpamda

 

 

 

 

EB, 17% aim-Em {iamm??ig Ema? gagmg?im mgmaiy an: W?i?l?i 
1132 {im- gmxm?mm m?a'zmiy $433sz pama-m gum-g: m" gummimg??s am: 53:33 Wu: whaif
E223: i?mmim yam am {mam- ag-amg3 imas-sigams? in?ammang
Maw-3g amgai?amg amt: gamiimt 

{is Mama idmtifg that Emma}? ?31m; priwiciea: mar: dagumm? ?g mm 

mama-n

 

?mg?g? gag. 
2. 22:: ?gs: E?ia?mifm ?ms??qw?gt far Eam?amimz 3:3? ?wm?m? m:

?aw-536:2? 3.13} 2:53 ?539 E. Swazi?miiy {maggmi? in 215$:

ma?a ai?? ?ght? immigg?w

 
  

ma has; m3: my dam is:- ma: az?-gmi mama
Em: {Era-,1. m??mi?g spa?aif??i 'feqmmis?? way mgr-1371i 
imaging ma: gamma-m h??mmi?a fax-2* m? Emmi 
_This imim?as $3335; S'E?m?ar .E??m?m?eg asi-E? wmfm?m ii} {Ew-
ham?aiti? gig-whim  was: Wig??m?;  

3.. ?32 i?m maimi??i?? ?imt ?mmg: ?am?m 33,



mm; wt: Fia?mi?" ragga-gig:ng gm 313$: set fa?h missus:

   
 

 



  
*El? a? ?m 

6.14. a      

 

5.. ?E?im mmg?am Emwmi ??vi?mk 
:W?im LES EM gaggm Nam

   

 

at m?-amgar?img ?v?ry a??i im?' gr?mim?
mmg?g??:?ia??geggw 

 

ME 
agaigwgi gm: gamma ?g 
sz-ng?fga?m ?afm?mmi??mm 

 

3&2

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

E533

w??g?ah magem er m?mg :3 a3?
m?iw gg?ya?g?a??rig- m??gm?g wasgmim 
?rw-?ilmm? :g?wig?i?i?g- m3 

Mi ?mizaigag ma??ria??g mm gagm?i?g
gigs; my? ih?
. mtg; 
Ewkimg?agig??a?g}: im?'iai?gg?i?z?ir- m;
?g??gg i?-?m?iE?g gm
smgw? ams?i Wi'mm?w gig-rim i
iai?grmga?m. 

   

 

  

ME mmrg?gx?mgt?s sag-E;

 

  

mg?m?? 
mi?m?ie .  
gi-
Wiw ?im??mg-ligamv 

E?hm mi 

  
   
  
  
 

 
 
 

my
i?ww?g??i?i?gi E3 .,

 

ME gm aim-gamig miam?izm m?w 

-.  
. . 5

gas-m. magi amejg 


Wag? samw?y
f?i?r-ia?g?i?  5

 

   

mm Fmg?wai ami Siam-
max at}? {ha -  
gmv?g?e a??amsmg 
mm?mm: aa? ?ri?i? siamxmm at?? wig-gig ?w
m?sfm?y a? $5 33%? 'ngmm?' m: mg: 2m
W?i??aa at ?rm? 5 

 

    

?i?mm? igmm?g
?ns: {.?atmmzi ixgi?v?mgg 
?33 mgm?y the; W?m ma am w?m?g?a?  gm




 

 

 

 

 

mu a? my kiwi mg?im? i?ii?-W??wg 
Eamma? Mfam- mmg?a?m me.


?g ahmmiag?w gm-Ipami 3:32 wwm?mmivm 2?23
2mg: mam 

33? imi?mi mamming aimsaimgagx

?93 Wegam wwia?? am? "gf?w ?gms?z?gmfiy? ?ggx 
?zi i? -
.. giggly . 

  
gig m: ?g m-   

 

31?? Mi. imag?ijgmim gm gamma 

. . .. 2mm ?g?ifixifgs?a . .
  

  

4: .. En micg?g?s?t?gig Jam: gwmi?miiy
mien-mm ham: 3m magi'?iz?i?m? 
Havi??a?i?ia magma z? {giggzizgm ighfsim,? mg. --  -  
d?'gk?m?zimis am I Symi?m?yg i?gim rim?gi?mi?g  ifiif?fmx?333m .
3? wimywm

 
- .  
i .. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

    

 
 ?gw?fmii 

Wmaw.232mm- 1-:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   
  
 

I'm-1Wqu ..

gm ML . WW 3 

ummni?ia?w??m?13:33.?



g% 

mgrma g3Mug-  \Va??m?im  

- TWWEW   


4:1- 'w

        
 
 
   

I

WNW. .mm?s?y 
m. 



 
 

    .       
f- .- -- 
{$311235} I

f- .. .w 
izmm 

   
 
 

 

 

zwi?ggzj   



 

mm; m, - - 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 m? gamma

Pam j. ?a-iz-zz?ak?zx E3

gam gar-gm ma 3 mw mf @Egimiff?g Firs: Raqu?aa
im- Pm?m?im M:

3:23 Firm mags Mai} the: ??i?awiz3g imiiyiaims:

g?ymamm Brigama Emiaaim I
{Kw 53f Eaaw 
E?i??mh ?zmm,  
Wiia?aip?i?, 3% ma?a-

?Wag-I}

   

  

ff? ?a?s mam-a3;

 

m; Mama? mm.

 

 

 

 

 

1&2132014 Same 2 caps buiit 3 mums: cases that fat! man W?ygm

sumr?mr i 

Harm News Sports 1 Entertainment 1 Business 1 F906: 1 Lifestyle 1 Health 1 Markatplace

   

 

Coliect?ons aw Gap

Same 2 amps built 3 murder sagas
at ?633 apart

 
   
             

. a'ms?'mm MAW may. mt; awmm. gm'?m 
trim. 05151 to ha 359? ?rm by a jury ?35! mm.

a? M. 53835? 5W W?mf
d?n?i?thWW?m, 3?1 
POSYED: Number 33, 2913

ZN THE ANNALS a? 'Fhiladeiphia crime, tha name Mafia Finkney ?nga
m3 ba?s amid'ihe murderers. my: caps and
- 

But En 3203? with a high?chcal aipiama. a steady icy}: as a baggaga
handset ai ?hiiadetphia imamiionai Aimm and no a?minai
vaic?ms, Fin-mm, mm 20, fm?d himswf hamath the bright. fight a?
a ext-mime! intemga?m.

in a 34419:}? span, 5% went neighbammd witness in prime
susme accused {if murdering; his wand 55mm daycare days,
Jonathan Wm, 31. Pitta? gi??dand. Nakaish?a Pinks, 20.



Siaadfastiy maintai?a?ng his inmance. Pinkney span? me next few
yams in city'jaila awmfting triai, and for i 132 at {We mam, it was
iis?ed as a death-533mm cage,-

Fina?y. last ma?th, i?n?jusi three hams af'de?bemtiun, a Philadalphia
jury datminad that W35 {ha man, famed him m: guiisy 0? a1:
charges and 33! mm frag.

By weir Get. 11 decisien. jam affaciimiy canctudad that Mafia
P??nkmy had amaihing in with mm Smahas and Unique-
Drayim, him tamer murdet defamaan who went-frag: They alt had
bean charged with martial? basal an km: ma same 
F?f?ia?elpma hemicide detectives, thaw Jankins and James Pitts
{m raiatim in Jmthan}

 

?Smd cop, bad mg!

Just a?-er 1'1 am. ?gug. 2Q, 2939, pdice: Emmi Jammie": Pitts and
Nakeism Pink's ?edfup and wmmtaea w?th duct 1393, had been
shat 5n the back {if that haads in Pitts? ransacked homa an [39!ch
Suva! in Qantas Wk.

Pitta desciibed by Nine as a low?Eavel (3mg (Seeder, a!st had {men
Waters. according it: the Medina! Examiner?s (Mice.

Finkney. new 2:1, says the hem homicide dazectivas an the came,
Jenkim and Wits. {?ayed ?gem cop, bar! mp? bame gmking and
 faiae cmf'assm an: of him

 

"Gm ef?car mini mum saunas a3 aaim am} me}. am: the 912191? ma
mull: ha avamggmaive." Pimkney {aid rm Daily News-391$ his
acquittal. ?The cinema: W6 lay hands {m Wu was. [Damn-?ve Pitts:
and Jenkiz?zs maid his Wing it} caim him dawn. But at {he and of tha
day, 3133! 69th began Za'iay hands on ma, hit me, punch me; mug me

aM?nks~ha6~m

 

5 as

1012112014

Same 2 cogs mm 3 murer cases that fa? apart Wiiygorn
around 32mg with M131 may ware {?ing ma?

Pinkrzey said he} signed ma cmfassian ?banaan i thcugm aha: was;
my My way wt ?ue dear. ?may said. ?if you sig? W32 was gm? mi
826 onty (ma mam been mmugh what We been Waugh fame}
canfessions and wings a! 2m: mum. was a mistake an my term?.
but ?t?s net my main"

A: Rial. detec?ves Jankins and Pitts and Ehe Gistrict- Mmmay?s Offica
warn: fun?bare :0 gm the jury in: camict Pi-nkney of two mums 0f ?mb
degree muzdar? wh?ch maid may a sentence of ?fe in ??san wi?hmt
93:21:32.

in an? Pinknay?s fam?y spent aimaat $59.60!} an threw defense
Mars; accer?i?g it: his father, Themas ?inkney, 52..

New Pinkney. his-{amay and {he iawyar whe repmsante? him it: came
J. Pagam, am asking: Haw amid such a miscm?age a?
jusikza happen?

Thair queatiuns start w?th the waged acticns of daieciima Pitts and Jenkins? what: may chain: gava Pi?knay atom the
mur?em and max-ed mm {a make up ngausibia ?ies implicating himgeifand aha? men during 3 :2er intarmgatian.



"Tm detectives mum hays. fad him juat enough Each to put mm statemem t?g?iher. don?i think mama?s any tamer camiusinn.
Pageant: said,

"Somaiimw this Wm 43?? daientim m?ght wow. Sama?mas yam can cwm? a siaeaman: an: at a gnaw gamma. and 3% 2m
mama {he tha mm anti Singamzinis; might ?t ink: 513w. ant. sameiimes when you mm a wida net ?ka that, you
5:00;: 15;: a ?sh that?s ?nmca?t? Than #2 down} work. ?men it fags in games.?

the m: {Ema
Pi?knay is ihe {him ?Marxian: in three yaars ta be weaned after Mag charged with murdar based on {ha wu?c at the same hm

datectivaa:

Last year, a?ar 35%an {new than {we gleam in gait awaiting zn?ai far a murder En North Ph?ademhia. 9min Speakas. 25? was
acquitted by a sury mat 33w aume?iama widm pmving ha was eisawmm? at {ha tima 6f the crime.

As the my W3 mpmad ifi a cover Fab. 8,201.2, tam timwtampa? finaakm mam my {mm 2% {kit 
mag. ahm?ag c3? Timmy *?wgar? Ross for which he was charged with ?rst-6W murdar. ?m mass affica had viewed the
video am {seemed in wt swam an via! anyway? -

?Had we. daieci?vw and the palica can?nued to do ?ama i?vesi?ga?ng in ma naighbomaod fur the test of ?213 day and ?ght? they
may hava caught we 831m,? Yam?! Rainay, Spam?? said Mr this jury fauna him r16: witty? ?But they WIS
the; ha? in my iivmg?mimn cam and 2&9: it them."

in January 20%; maxim anti mamas shm?gas mm fast-raw}! {3:52pm againsf m?qua Emma. WM was chargad wi?h fam?y
stabbing her male on Streak near 52:14:: in mart:er in Augaa: 533$ fail am when (22:11am 91m
Judge M. Teresa Smina, mii?g that wayth had bean new Wuhan: pmhabie mum! auppressed the canfeasim siazaman: she
gave mtmtive pitta afier being; in custady for 4?1 Mum? - .

"Tim siaiamam that she maria was neat mummy made, Em: was {he pmttuct Wyomingij coercion.? Sarmina said in her
Novamber 2am raging, assuming a mm transc??pt. Tm} gadge she fauna many wings that Pats Said during the
sugaramim hearing ?mmwm.? whiia she hand must 5% what {Wynn mix: {0133 ?c-radmie."

think ?atecliva {Pitts is far 5&3: aggrerssm: in "his: im'ermgatien' saw mimic Manda! Andwa KW. who mpramnted
?rayicm with feiim mimic ?efendefr Mari! grammar}. "He?s a big-guy. 1 think be gets in there arid unifies smegma, and ha causas
Ma?a my ?15th that may mt ha mm" 

As in Pinknay'sz amass? an arm elm: has biases? rammed far this murdam fm Wish Smmkes and Drayh?m {mask wem ?charged.

?Tha sca?wt thing here: is man: mom than me: coid~b?oadad i? waik?ng the gamma Pmiadaiphia,? said Pawnee, Pink?ay?s
defansa lawyer?

Nawha?a homeiess
P?rxknay. whet hasmovac: mm the F?hiiadwphia arses, said the: Mesa! has lefi him heme-teas, unampiayad and disgusmd by me
car:de a? the {?aaeciims Wm: amused him a? murdexing hia Mantis.

*ii?g sad because we mm thew af?cm arid aatectiws :c a higher smndam DQCEUSQ uf aw safety," F?inknay said.

"Psopie rm to and dan wages: ma Phiiadaiphia malice erartment or caps, patina} becaum things 1533 this 213993;}, We have
peop?a incarcerated am! 1315}; 295d the m. Bui- ycu 23%.an was? {a haliwe them inst ibecausa was haw 3 making. a Wrath, Their
{was am taken; from them" 

aezeczive Pitts. <33. game: paiica {ma if: 298%; Jenkim? 42. came an 2mm in 2995. Homicide Cap!? James Siam aid not 
mam? Bo Qaiiy News requests far eminent cm the a?egatims made by Pagam and ginkmy aga?mt the Mo dazaeiivas.

But ?ssistan?i Dist-fiat R?omay Maris Lwanbarg. pmsacuted Pinknay, said Pinkneiy ?farch it} meminn,? du?ng mam than an
ham an tha-witnwis 3mm: whim twang. quas?med by Paganm. that the detamivas as'san?iad. him. Hamid Pinkmy had at: injwias
mm m: m5? mm hit 

ma Fihkmy?s anyam am It: mam for his mu?symr wax ha tried haca?m they kegs! ?aking fur pasiacnemenis.

disagma with the verdict. I?m mt gning it: angaga a guessing game abut}: why the jury did as it 65:11.. Yha guidance; was gammy
dear,? said Lavenbwg. fauna my raw; mm the wamigr 0f Pins and Ja?kins,

?i think Ewing a mm?cida damalive is a dif?au?z job. think that im aviaencg: all speaks; far imam i dam {mime rim: that
slamnerzt wag ca?amaa. i shim: the: ?afandam fiat: awn: wme lhi?gs, rm the grand.?



 

 

 

mmg'zuw Same 2 com mm murder gases that fan aparz- W?ysm
931% was my 

Nam Pinknay :1in WE Jemima Pitts and Nakaisha Firsks, than whe did?

in the azaiement taker: by da?ecziva$ Pitts aria Janxina 2mm day after the amyinga, Fir-1km identi?ad :ha gunman 323 Lea/my
Waikar 3an Miiteni?une? Mamn, two man who: he said agraed tat mb may harm of drug maney.

*1 mid Lenny haw to get into Jan?s Mum and where i zhnught the manager was at Ensi?ie ma Muse," ??inknay is qumad 33. saying in
{he cmiessicn stazammi. .

Eat Mica ihamughiy immstigatw Wakker- am} Mama whu ?3 Pinkne?y?s (mush am! no evidence linking them to {he
murdem. They wara quastionad and mSeaaed?

Pageant: be?ievss- inst may toe: street-savvy to be ba?ed ink: giving faise mnf?saien?s?

The manly phygical ewidemm gages: had to link Pinxnay in the crime seem wag a Waist? bimdslain cm a ammtairs Wan.
nawhem mat the swm?mr?m mar-ties: scam:

Pinknw claims that the sta?u was zm me wail fang befm this mm! the: ram)? cf mughhw?ing he: and uthar friends when did at
Jenathars Pitta? hams? 

Pagans: saw {ha detectivw Seamed cf Waiker and Martin a?atr quegiioning Whitney abmzt the mantis with whom he and lawman
was hung out.

may 159$: that and ran with it,? ?inkmy suggeared.

Ha baiieves mat mime 3130 ran with {mm same at? the v?ctims? $913th We 93mm at aims scene. that Pinxney
had same??hg 39. 6% sum: the s?ayings given hi5 dame with Jemima Wits.

With 2% miners ?aming and ms desim in. new catch the Ri?e! max, Mame? he readin 3W t9 he inimimd by
mike; '1

amid have aas?y mead up being madam, duct?{?59m and bat-mu. at: i put my has: met 19mm 33. a {dam it: 2233p {ha has:
way msibiy that! maid," he said. ?And Was 23km: 'mamaga It?s mt'rigmf

Tha {am-page pc?i?e Statement a edgy a? wh?ah was gamma by Nam ?aniaimd things that ?inkney mm the
datactivea that ha says may wath in hear am? w?ta dqu -

The steam-mam than at 1:45 pm Aug. 23353 322913: 24 hours after ha had been:me mm 

But in the can?rau?, the mammary: that 3enkins and Pitts had usm? to am: Pinm?y the key to his 1mm, Pagans:
balievgs, .

in Pink-nay man-sing tha rehberydummamm an man wha were ?amed 0f the slay-Ema ha aim 335:: in that
stakmam that me im mar: $4.221 mm the by ciimbing; a gmer'ms amazing thmugh a mar windm,

Pagam mid m3 that ?mm was no evi?anm that the k?iem gamma {ha #191333 mm mm and mat mast hamaoimasion
perpetrators go {mung}? the from dear. -

??rm can you heii??e? his statemem?? That was my arimary migrant the ?133. if Lanny and Jung we run invafveda, if {ha
nai'ga its thmugh the back wi?daw, than yen mum? beiiava his mammam ?rst} if yam nan? beware his maternal-at.
than it must ham wen waited." . - 5

Pagam shared Withthe 33:31.39va Emma an momma ham-Riga? mac-mum,

Jma?h'an Pitts ma?aged that (3331:3331, a ham: {58:31 and 3mm smarts mat his mt?er'owned ants maiwas within a a! his
ma Surname May 213% mm. him ho'mfa'a?er'ha aimed ma bar 133: Saar :2 am? Pagan} said.

Or the. k'iiter maid {Stave {legalize sama mm: wha family shat Kamam Joseph arm ?hiaid? Sheet near Eimmod Avema. five
daya harm than. mum mania and a mag mum than i 122 miie? my- 3

Law .mnarhan pitta Mica dastxibad 30, as a imam! dang dealer; and hangs mama wizh duck taps and she? in the
bask 3f me new. as mus am: ?rms, Fagam armed.

 

Probing waging. miica mquestad Fi?kmy's magmas: mama %n Warm}! is: link him ?9 the slayirsg! acam?ng {a a
Police ?apa?mantiattar cmaimd by {ha 53mg; News: We ?nk wag fwnd, am? Jesesm?a' massing remaim unsolva?

Aiihaugh is fraa; siinknay said. his iifa wit! mum ?929 sama {3:3 P'agam?s acivia?a. ha mavens tram ma West Phiiadaiphia
neighmm Mafia he wm ham and misw. and where im- amj F?Etta atta?ded day cane: tagether.

He saw ha watts Fiitts? and Fwy fam?ies to Maw that ha bad Wing ta dz: with we}: mur?er?s?

ins: want {a gas  with my {Ha and "?32 331ng knew that things must changa, bam?se were are a. lot 01' mama stamped am;
thay?ra in prism Mame 9f mm 3333: tiara er where ihey?ra fer 03"ch33 cf Said Finkmm mo hepas 2c
earn a baa-Mesa degrae in mm rut?: his fathair?a ?werwice businaas? . -,
?39 detectivas Pitts-fawn? Jenkins, he sai?: 'mazty da'think they wed in} . . ham 3: heart? Wy?m very caramss and unmanade
about maia?s ?ves. Twat 9min; l-ika yam; want in ha {mated} 

32m? mm Qw?d?amhmma- my:szth in this; re:an

 

 

 

Firm Bis?s?m a3? I

5mm i
Waz?iagm -

 

 

ma; mm mm 3 
Navami?gr 2&2 

 

 

?rst Ja?iaiaf ??Samzz af?mwivmizz -

ma Sam}; mam? mm, 
mgiaaemia, mm

{235) 533mm .. (2E5) 

 

   Fife PW
ms mwag .33: 33mm:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

gimmismzm mg; (gm-y} Mama 1
I Newmiwz? 3% 2m
?aga ?i F?aga 3
3% {?33
g; 3mm. amsm 
{21 .
. mama 
ma?aumm?s?aamma (Maxim! ft)? ma-Cammamweaiih
a . gag}
?73 ?35 wwagm 35m Emmaa
:51 Gaunwi fez? raga W3?ima
. i8}
W1 Mm {may mavam Kamuzag
Swami far Mr, Reacts
E81


{is} mem ?2 ma, Grin-?rm Jus?m Genie:
??h?a?aiphia, 
m} 
Nwembarz?, 2312
?18} Vaim?
am}
{2333

{3 E: WE TENN, 

?nd a my
222}


{25! 
Rim, WE. {mm

     
 

 

 
  
   
 
 



 

     Page 

lo  a mat? :iiscussiw tam}: ghee
mm as falinm:

 -   {Simei warming. Wka askazi far

?le mfmm?? 
MR. 3 think Mr, Sway 313:1 i heath
haw a magpie: ?55333.
314$ All fight.
G?na mumingy Yew Ewan
Yaw ?31232; 1 believa ?xavaa whammcr wimcss far
my ciimt. mg swear; she: haw?: aWd 
mum"; '1 am 59:23:, Yam Exam 3: what?
m. mac? wimrzs$ far my
c?mi, Rama? E?waz?s. Ska hasn?t aggeareti say I
e??n?z give; hm mimic; bar: 1 am being ma. that
sha?s gaing in amt, ginsi want its whiz-ass the
jury maka Sm m3 mm weald mmgnize: he: mama,
Wha? ix Em? 2133mm?
Rama-i Edwmas,

Anything aim?
SEAY: Nat me, Yam Karim.
Yaw gamer, a. witness 1:3? the:
mama af?a??imt- ??E?ay?iar is gaing it! ?astify prababiy
this ramming. Ms; Tayiw'is? a gamma" anyia?: 3%

Anti when was quasiiam? swam} ?mm by 113:

?hawxz'm?cai{??wmms Kama? mass: Emma?? RacmsE   
am mmas $5 
mm. mm 553
?3'3 ?63
{33 {73
mm mama ?12} 1}
3mg. 55mm ?23? .E
21
i TAYLGR 152 2% m}
:35; 
?m 24$ ?151
{:32 av mm?: 263
gig: 
{is} 
5233?: {$33
:21; aamwaawm

gymma . nmsm? {2:225:53 mamas Kim:
1 5?2:  
II 12% s: gm}
E252 i231
?hamn Rim, am cm ?ng

$2953
$252
. 1
Shawn: Ricci, 

Qau? Ragw?irzg 53mm:

 

 

?2 ma?a ?i ?mg-j

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

gamma 

?i?riai {Jury} Valume 

 

Vincmi W'er Navemher 26, 213:2
gage 2492 i me 242

ER, ?zaz ?was it, ?me my ymi?m warding i2 

ad Ques?an: 5:33 yaw mama Emma item ibis Ms. ?fayiar gin-ism.?

13} aa?itian, an in spmk. you: have: a cma?m with Kyia A. I: mm?: ?lm that.

{41 bmicaiiy tailing him 37ml wm that aay?? Q. Are ya}: ?nishad?

{53 Yum a?awar: Yam. A. ?36%

i6} ?aegi?mm 31:: that mma?an yam imitate him {53 a, Mgaz?ayim, eii? maxi yam? wards 

3531: met this Eud?a; m? 3:31: km SW ?mir am?
Yes.
?91 Quea?im: yaw $315, Ky?a 3m: ha? Emit

 

 

again, dam Kyie get 123m: 33*   

m} Mawaz?: Ne,

{12} macs he gm mad?

{1 a; Anmr: 

E1 sag he say anything reganiing Emir,     we
{18} ?31th as a threat?

gm; Mama: 

Questian: He: mmiy gays, if} am am: mmakm, that.

{2 33 ha mamhm Eimir as the guy wha teak yaw pinata?

 
 
   

 

?193 YES.

{23; gm: ha mambmti whu he: was?

{22} giveaway: Yas.

?22} {39 yak: maran thaw quastiens am?

?23m? Gym" yam: Magimm 

{241 It was 331m brief anti that was it, It wasn?t   I  
{253 ?a it a it "was ?wiait 1  am? 

.:

  

 
 
 
 
 
  
  
   

Van it right, Yen mad i? rigm, but 221:: my

yawn: mn?ing 2% ?lm it was a big cmvmat? em 333mcared $136212 him.

{1 $1 a. Ma?m in fact, came ham ?rm: ?zz: phata shunt

{111 {mi yam have a mm?m. ei?? have a mm?m with Km
{3'23 af?rm: 3min 

{i 3} Bricfa?mrz Wham-E was at.

?143 mmv: May 5% ms} at sidebar,
{is} please? -
$1 a 

a ??smssian was hem at
gamma? as 

WEE Haw much mm. a? this d9 you
?31th a: gm an? Yau'w a?imady yau?m 
Vacating  Exam: hm, Mr, (Sway. Yau?m? gaing
mm  ?m saw: ?xing? Th: jaw is fa?i?g

3!  

  
  

 ?mmv; am E, Eu?ga. iapaiogize.
m?g?w'm: W223 knew that WI

 

Sham macsF?aga- 244

gems: thatqu mim?k?i?g .l  umi?c?g?sim maiudcd)

:21 mm .-

{31 me pim that yet: 3311: am aim Yam Haunt, 3 have no 9mm

:43 they wm mm?h?e?ze& ?Yea: ?21me an say magma. m? quas??m 

Bang that 3m: mum haw: ham  Efyon i5} Vary wen

E83 waui? have: 38393  it wm?d imam cause?' a {63 Mr. Sm??

{3?3 mistrial}. am; SERVEW Wym. May ?,Yaw

1'35 120% mm: an ?at: fans-?213 gimme? E8 8mm? 

{93 Exam the 22km a?
{1m QER. my} 
[1?21 mum: dam with this? i m} v- 

{12} mam, yam aimdy asktd hm aims: as??an that she {12} m. mama:

3} Saki 33mg?? I g? 33 Q, Yam 3.3m by m, Cams? 2c: cxylain :dune, Ensign, gm; may have {vial ?ags that Mr: Rae?ipa? a: ta
{15} TEE mum": Am yam may tn. begin m? {15} Must; I33 mm?m? aim: 

{153 mm. SERVER: YES, Your ?nnm 3 rim?: ?16} Yes, 

?c?m 135 that ?w En ?lm the mima?m is, is hame 231% ?cmctiws

{13} ma mum: yam think: yum mum finish? {23; gwe that :3ch is 32311; $633?: ?aw?

MR. ihink mum six; it in EEG {is} A. Yes, 

{2:33 minutes,? in fact, yam mm maiga Mum: that, $622? yaw?

i213 Em 3m: haw mass afher? {21} 

{223 mm SERVER: Lime-a. {223 MR i mi am: yum

1233 THE $333353": 53% right. Waii, ici?s try ?231 am?m the' mag aftes?mmy aim 

?24} fm?sh. 3rd, 281%,,

{253. - Yam?mm, this ?3 33:23:: 2% amii?l? star:

Sham Kiwi, mm 31mm ch?i, am, am: 
?hamz Rim, {ma Smart- Regms?wg Sgysiem 8% {gaga a 2m

 

 

 

 

 

sxmamwazazag 

(3mg Vagame 

 

Wm: Wa?am Navem?wrg?? am
Paga 245 . Fage 2&8
{23 at ?rst 2% Hwy giicked 
g2} mg mam: am right$421631 they Waugh: in 
{43 SEERVER: E?m, Yum Hanan". gas} Yea. 
:53 Wk" MR. maxim: $53 $3 Amati yam di?rs?: mm is: me: :0 mm ?lm ai?m?
{33 Q4, Qum?am W612 get :9 yaw zhis is, a :63 Nae 
I qam?an that Way is mating in yam a. Mei. ?m ?cim??m; mm wt in ?m M3 what: yet: had

{33 Q?ea?am W613 gag ta yam statement. Came} has

a my eff: am? WEE get $0 it Eat is: yam 3am 
gm} in?icate: abau? 5463) ?31? 1%:me mm the: sizim?vcm -
?gain, wm?d that $32: aha?: a ?a?pa?c fing afhaw

 

 

 
 

?93 ?h
{11:23 m.



{131 much mam? Kim gai? t6 far skis pix?m ciub? ma?a-
{331 ?naww: 1 than?: 332mm, ?azm?wa 25.31:: mm 2&3: 
{$41  
{151 mayor: mag quastizm amiamar? 
{35] Ya, {16} 
Mei that?s What hamma?. the ?ctm?vaa gut m: ?ame a?
{13] in yaw mind? ?i?n?i they? I {13} 
{19] 4k Ym.  {193 a.
{2&1 Q. Sg?ak a ?rth 3:311:25? mm.   
:21} yes. - - v:   

Em Qt ?kay, Nam, when ya: had in Gama  -
an Fahmy am, 126%,? 
(2&3 mm 223- gm yam? 3 
:35} a% ?Yes. 

 

Sham Rims, REQ-   

 

 

 

E83 is.) same: ihm mam, 323$    

Y?s?
Ami Befamyau came in an testify, 2m ?atectiws WW

[1 a;  aha me man: with  thaw

Yes? . 

Haw 35mg Wm ?lmy in 233:: mm with wax? 
?E?Emym in ?m 232m Wh??a ?zzle,

3% Eight. Nat in {?33 mmnm?



E3112 Wi?a ?fths   

Yak. - 

{Ray} An? imiay aid 2kg}? hiring gem: is; again?

   
 
 

     swam

 

 

 

 

 I II I II - I is:  
Wc? mum an: gs: yum, right? a gig Ng?i?-Ias; ign?meiwha?ght, Haw, mi :3 bank up a 3512M  

  
 



my mm 
Im?z?iiygaasg?igg': gm 

 

 

 

$911 mid 12$ that yam afar 2:3 my client as Meg-am; Yak, 
[53 isn?t that right?? right. 3233:: 1m: at Rama? -
4% ?gm; {53 VWS - I
Y'w ?ank cal} him K95, ?33 gm? 5% Ami  wast; mkisgg cam- chiEM?
9% Nag - A, -  
313. ail 211% times it: 22m. mm Ami the ?atme  yam have it: mum with m, ciisin?:
{1133 2:523:- amm 1% mini Km ?zz-tam, itha??s mi Ema: yam mfezmei {1 a} ?ay? 5 
{1'33 3012:? Egaby?a father, is it? I {1 ?32- 
{333 3% Na, {32} Q. Yam $93113?; Exam a ?nite?
{13} Yet: WEE him Mm all the time $33 A. N5.
114:} A. Wm. a? Yam it: say 
{1&1 a. ma Wham 3mm   abaut him an ?11th Wm yam mii ?153 Nay 
him mama, yam? {?53 a Mei mm 33mg 33:  am: :3 the Emma Bivisian yen 
'Ym. {m W?t ?rm Emmy-wart: yam?
{1&3 Q.) ?ght? Nam when :his haggmm?i in 2mm and Mighml 5?53} ?gs. -
aiimi 332:3. Emmi ?ia? 311$ tha- xietwiiws mm an& {Easy .gnit'ym {131 Q. - An? wm yam We? aimui yew" chii?rm?
inmiaw W2, haw ai?  3:36:13? gag; Yaw. - - 
my I was 3:3. {213 a? Ami W319 33% taking: cam 3f than?
E223 Q,  1AM, him? many ki?s {Kai ?rms. have? $252} - Emma  my family,
?233 A. - {23} a. -  fmiiy; xakayg 
{2&3 m. ?md Bat}: nf'thc chil?m: iivac? with yam? ms; 3a may get: 3m mm :2me gaming: mm a:
?25} Yas. {253' the Ramici?m Eivisfim: is gm: ?ght?
Siam mania? mm, San .Riccig-WK 
S?m? Rit?ia ?msri Ram?istg Syg?am $3 .ii??ga 3&5 3&8}

 

 

 

53 mamm?zm Q, 5? mama mm ?E?riai {Sm-y) Valame 3

 

 

 

Vmamt ?avmhar 3m
. ?aga Waga 353

an ?Yam A, th.

{a is it a swamm 2mm ?aw with a aimm? mar? $33 a, Nam acwra?ng ta the (laments that we haw, ?mc?vc
?e Yeah. g3: {tumm?ngs 3.23.63 W5 ?lm cam: in ta intmi?aw 3:31: a: 31:55

Q. Is them anyhady else 133 $325 mam wi?x 30:3? {43 in {Em maming, ?aws-?at. Swazi right?

3125: mm? . Yam

Q, AR glam? i a, mm game  Eggs and Ekatmm mam, they mm

Yak hasiaa?y mica ta yam, ihay were games warm": may?

Wm yum: hm?m??a? at 333? gag A. Ym.

Yas. Q. Ami tiny were asking yam qwstiam 3mm: (is 33m: him:
a. Yam ?mm :1 e} am?is; 32m: mwmim ?2153 game;

:11; mg mam?: in?ina?ng 3m E1132}:th like: that, right? 

ma?cating ym ?fan: Emma [1121 Yeah, may 

{33} a? MR. . {13} Q, Ami ?zat?s in the fin: smiammt. 3.13m ymi have yam:

m; ?22. me: han?mifym a chair, a tam, haw am ?rst statmmt in af m? I that?s 

{151- that {153 TEE 

{163 may gust ha? am in 11mm. Likeg {My ha? me mar a gm Exhihi? 
chair am: ?aw mmstimes they hm}; mm in han?m??ii: 1m?; MR 

{$83 an 1132?}: yam think we- {13} yin: ham thai?

am far my arms. {13} Yum ihave it.

   

 

{263 i am my? 3 ?i?nk mm ix: Emmi: yam,?

  451.1151 Sf} may askedyeu thinga like, 3m: knew, ?e 3m:
{21; ma ym make: any :2?th mm m?tw??igmy? 

Kyiei, magaz?e Vincena dc; 3311 1mm Mm: kiwi

  
  
   
  

   
   
 

    

{2&3 ?gs Na, 3 42 mica? 1329:: S??-nfihing, right?

{231%. 3.3% yam Mam 221m in any way? 3 

{2&1 A. Na, a  Merging in Emir term, it. 
{251 a. am; my han?m??a?ym? A ..  

 

 

 

Sham RimigRPRa  

 .,  fgp?l"  I Page 352
 yggarma?ei?m 3m mm the swemymmi? yam muiei

Na, they Wm. mt mamiug, m. 
{23 We as  taikmi it} them mi said mmamy is. aways

Tim:wa take: is: yam? . 
{33.1% Yak, . 

  
  

 

 

  

 

{41 ?22? New, haw Rang dz: wt: think that ?rst stateth teak? in 

A, Abwi fives mm. {53 Q, A12 right. Nam 39 yaw 3mm anti

Raw ?5223 :33 yet": think: mm at ?lm ?m?aic?a mivisien is: gen ifihi? hams yam it: I: Wait: Ea 
if} bafmri: 3mm Warnings: anti mm ma ii} sea: yam? mm: 3

{33 As A mugiehm Ea} Amm?iagm any pig :5      an $23: sam? my con

33% may $3.?an 52m: in gas: anything eat? memkw inmviw?bcgi?m at. ?zS? p33,,
Na. gm;- ?m that Swami ?ght? 

Raw a?)an samc?hing zi?nk, my mm? 32%} ?g 3?53. 

{12} Na. a. 31mm ?w imam 33 by Eastwm this: fast is:th
{233 at ?aw $012?: :3 ga is: the ha?zmom? {is} with the nice ?atmtiws ?in 
I?m} A. Evmtuaily. But, m, am: far a hung titan, 13mm

a, mini haw 37mm: ta mm a ?33.31 yam" family :3 ?st :1 51 a maxi the: samurai it:th with ?lms new ?m?vm,
than: that yam ma right? g1 61 ?atm?m $323935 anti-J isn?: that. right?
11?} ?g mm?n?t maka a ?aw: mi}. km 
?283 if}: hawabtmi yam swam? ?133 a. gag?-
Nma?m {-291     
Q. Haw {32:3 wm yamki?sai ?xis Him}   Egg}

m} a, ?We: am ?right. Em}  Hi5;  - -

?22} a. Eight? :22} a, mwmam rag?

m3 swam . Ti??22?; at Sam? ?24} a.  mey'zatxm make-W??m ?333.32?

Sham Riser; Rm Sham: m'ccigmm am

 

Shawn Rim, I imam R?gm?ing Syg?am $3 {gage 3% 333}

 

 

 

 

 

 

gamma gamma, mm
V?mcmt Wa?max-



{133 A.

5Q, 
Em} AB 
Ez?iimfm'??'  
{221 ?344"  . . .
?233  
.. Wi?giz??f 
{ma- 

Na.
?fe?   we: is}: yam: yam haw a right remain
?133 Siie?f?? 
m; a; :Nm -
{12} $34;  -Wc??,?33aim?w mm .?Emkins; Ziggy ma Eh ih?
[133 am:  {a iatar?sw gram 3: mia; ?agz?mhay?

"Na
- Wm yam given an   
Na,

?aga 2&3
{3m ?zzy in: yum 2:333: in 3mm mhiidz?mi?

 

 in ham 3 lama?

3m: 53m? ask far a iawyar?
"Vea-

 a?rm? mag yam yam-rights?

 

2mm

V3311.
 ?ank at?msia is 3. mm En?i it?
Yes; -- 
mmagym mu?: my? 

2--

 

   
   

     

 
 
  

  
a . mega a?ka   :33

  
 
     
  
  
  

?ma? Va?ma 
3333mm53:31am
interview is! mm: - 

    

 Hm anti Imkias in'?ta{amn-  ?X?m  

$4 thsiy'in?iwii?g is; 3m: that. shay
{my mything :th ?rst 
gmk. Yam. 

ma. m3 mm my gaziing-ym 153335323123; they mm: yam .
Wigwam-haw gait: mam 

[14} Yes.- - - -

WM: k?n?s afi?xiszgs?n?? 
{353 . . 33mg msrigilingsma? that: knew Ska: my aazz?s fa?hgx
{1?3?3 mb?imi ngia. gaing ta kw typ?sggv? the
523mm  'm'gig?sit

diam?: b?ia?m

 . 13;}  
I   

 a  
  ?z?ze?y @392 352 yam?
 -
  5am - cw?  egg? -

  

 

E23 mil ?atwtiva $3233 ms? 3%
mythimg in at?

?33 ?k

I ram.
W33 

{11] Yak. - - - -

{12} 321 Zh? ?rm {mm 13:8(2 in the :21an WW: $353? 
1?33: bring 3m: in tutti}. macs at nigh?w yam ticm?t ts: 33m

?es}  - I

Yes. - -

1% {3:76; ?aw Eat gm; $3.31 3922213? famiiy in mi}; 321m yen
{m wan? 

{183 

as?


   2mm; 53':  

5&an magi, 

Speak yam ci?idxm?? 

I  

a 1 ski" i5. -.
gr??   

#157 3. I

T"-o ..A. H, I . I

am?; wsf?ia-iyrm 

.9 Iw. 9. W9 ?2w,

v?   

 ame?

Na? -

332:3 ?lmy give: 3mm a chanm gas: a

we; 

Haw 312w: ta gm in the hathmum?

Evenma?i?iy I want it; {he bathmem,

{may mm was that?

an a: night mm m? graham? Rik: 32-:an
1mm un?nigi??

Na.



Taik a; iawm?? 

Nan

kaifam

 

  
 
 
   
 

3
?mi- . 



{2&3 yam hum 223%  Ware $921533 that ?ma    

  mam
Weii? 33% ?gs} mm in; the ??rai gamma 
 93a? ?m yam with. the ham?gide I






 



    

Wa?m
.
33.3% 33% ?ights is: $3.2m 2mm? 

Yaw, -

I  .

mama-mm?w 

  I    

ii 23 stamwg gaw?wx??sm   

$23-$35; 

Yes,  . -

i? ?g 3a yam?re in mady nfzim aiztec?m in the
?am?ici?c ?i?siim ?fth: E?aiica ??a?aism?m Bxx?dmg {mm
m3 m2: 3mm mass-m9?

gig} ?am'?zmg

?363 a? Ym?z'a  mien haw, arm?; was? Ram-mm they

?xing ah?utjciays'an? nights: m?t we?

 

. {2?23 gawk-m ymga 3mm  may?

gamma  .

5233 a; - mm 3mm my, andanti 3mm 

 

  

$9321 ?egmr?ng Syst?m

mama: magmaw am
5?3; (gage. 3&3 ?a 355}

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Emma  mwmma


Jagm Maiaugk?yz

 

fri?ai (Jaw) Vaime 2
Faf?mm?y 22, 2W2

 

 

 

 

Fims? Jydizsiai' @memyfma??a

Sam?h Emmi ngm?d Fim?r
Piz?adga?zahz??z, Psi EM 2 

583w8?3?? (i215) 683w8??5

?rigmg F336 mm VI, Faga?
Wafag ii}: 328385353

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
   
  

 

 

  
 

 
  
 

   

51 ?t?ttat (Jury) 
mt;
- Qag? $3 1 Paga 54
it} Ma?tt?t?y -- mass

:22 At. That?s; Asst that get FAAE its

{33 gm that it tt?? 1 year tit. 

A. Yeswith I {at 

{61 i {at B?t? 

A. YAA, I {it} t?t. Mt. Mamey, At I'Ctt?tk at

{at Att tight. Leta gt: 39-8. {at Q93, A Etta that 

{9t tt that Ag; 1 gave dAtActAtAA A Ahaet,
0A Airmen? its} tight? item?s t'm mtertittg
{111 NA, mt, Judge. tit 11 Tttey bath have A cams? they?
:12} 89%. t?m gttEAg tit ASA A. ?t?eA. they tics.

:13} t0 Attw at a Same 

CA8. A. VAS.

{t5} tart-y. it At; A 

What ttiA Aty?? Six AtnA? $93. Etta. Ett?} A. YAA.

{t2} A. tt the the

mtant A - gttat this treaty. tit-art?s A
ttattattAttLA: Fargivt mt. art-the; the 
CAQA. that?t At
{at} THE {3:2 have {3&3 EA Ema. ttftArA. things

{22; twat at st?? g, at: that's; ttittAtAAt it it; that it rAAttA 

[231 thtt?$$2 Ya$.   3g} at." thAtA?A ?ew

THE Vary WAR. ?tam A g} ?tsgtAtAatEVA-A this

tack At it. it   want b8. 

(East t3. g"  ?a??if??k?t?kt
(taut: 
683~83??3 ttiggt?t'?tiggttasm?
yet-git  - 
et?tt??fM_ 

 

 

 
   
 
  
  
 

  
      

 

 

53

gt} - crass *5 $.53 -- gt'tRA. - crass
t2} trying it} be my. AtA?tA-mertt tt?A   A .statA'mAAt Wham far the
metastim far this
{At at ?it . A-Att QummtA-QA.
t5} tit-Atacttve Pitts. fit} 
is} A. it; that at an new? 5 {63 A. 
Q. Rtgt?tt t3. Amt ttittA, tight? was
{at and metecttve Pitt. thAtA. -
A. may. Yet. it} A. Pitts 
Eta} Right?? {mt At. HA thaw.
A. YAA. m; A. t?ta {me said put the
:32: t2. Eamusa matte AA Aim Amt tam twat tart 
{tit} that the first timA 
{At} the tth, right?? At} t3. {tat 
{151 A. Vast. {t5} A. Qt 
{t6} (A. ?15 tartar. Q. And tEtA that threateAAtt
mitt ma eartiet that Wit-$31 asked tt 3AA: Atstet.
{t8} wAtA mtAttAAtett. yaw mitt yaw At; A. Yes. 
{19} by Pitts, tight?? Ct. ttitt. Stem 
{At} A. Yes. it;th Watt: Aim 
{2t} Ct. And hast tat} Hamit?tt? A timtt, tit
{22} tit with the whtte yam tied, {223 tack utt S?ttat?tty??tt? zyAAt 
{233 did he? that testament?
A. ttA. A. YAA.
{25} Q. Right. ?etacttva ttitts ts tit. they did the

Start 53?. S?k?t?ki i 8AA G. Sakai-ARE

Qt?ai?at I RfettmtAt
{2t 5-5} (2t ti) 
I
5

Atari (Atltet (mutt Regattittg ?34 (t?tAgA f5$ S?t

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TC)

FRQM


 

   


SEW 

mm @2?2?~15
:Palice Camm?ssi0mr
:Cammarzdi?ng Qf?cer, Entemai Affairs 13ivision
ESRANE @359;

. 3?3;  .

   

(3n Wedmsdayg Sgt. Fraziaz? #5433 Internal Affairs; Bivisim, was
mti?a? Gfa C?mggiaim Against mike via, Chiefhwpect?r Rama? Emma} Affairs
Divisianm (Emmi @3692 was Emma,

Tim camplainam, Emit? Rudmaky, Esquim, an Eaehaif this ciicn: 3531211111 455.1?
Rasml;a Egr?BiF, 5424 Wiilow3 gave? Phiiadelphia, PA $9343: 333% 21.5%244496,
reparted that unimawn Fh?ae?aighia Paige ?eiac?ims diei mt faiiaw- pram? poiice
praccdmes Whea. inteswiewing 114:1? in mferenw a Hamieis?a i?vestigaticn.

A af?ne Paliee Pemenml Eatabasa imdiaatcd:

?at. 33mm Wits #99433 #Z?l?lg? was aggai?zeg? em and assigned
the ?am?cide {31:33: am 12-26436,

?at. Rauai? ?aw ?sgaggm? 3258659; @as'agxgmimee? {m @6w23w9?? and:
assigne? the ?m?z?cide {Emit an  Eat. {El?wa Was ?isn?sse? fram

the 'xiegartm'mt gm 1%?9w33; v- 

Lieutenant Nichoias ?e?lagis .Ememai Affairs Divisian, was assigmd the
investigatien ?331 3638-33? 3313 inveszigatian was rewass-igneai t0 Sgt. Xamas
Eulagnmm #31 3, Intemai Affairs ?ivisim, am ??w?3f?4 -



This investigaticn axceecied the: "554%! tim? limit as man?am? by the Mayar?s
exacutiw Qr?er due: schedaiing ma?iais heiwa'm ?lm invastig?amrzs ami
aim izwaived Qf?aer 

43mm Ale-Rama, 54M Wi?aws ?vaw Phi?a?eiphiag 3% 19143, was
intawiawa?i 31-43543; at 3:3 0 PM, Li. ?e?las? at {mama} Affairs:
am? related ?it: failewing in gammy:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

hte. etetett thet while she we at teethee 1st 2913, she
received eetl Rideteh, whe etetee that he te te?lh te
her tie te She eehett it?ehe meet him ether teeth end
he stated he.? He eetee eett pteheti her he ttettseettett he he the 
his. etetett that whee the etehett her they etde?t
shew her e-hettge et ht). het they were She they teete
tee metee eett theet as he thee, ehe tees tett eett
steehy emit the mete", whe wee tett eett The eeteetivee ttenepettett
her te hetiee Heedtteettete tie htee here Theme

Met tees tete an interview teem with ehett eteeh; te the fleet.
?the detectives teeh her eett geese eett tett. hheet eh heet tetera the heme
tee returned eett her eh thet she wee
invelvett thee the .3 5th} hteeh et" hieggeht Sheet, hitter te' the hamster ef Cert
ett h?whhutit. he et? hate, him
eehi?ete, Aehtey wee ettegett te eheet
te htieg gee te eet?tte they wet-e theetvett tie. they
etee 'het gheetett Cert Betgeeget eth'e ehe he with;
met that he wee ehet zeett hittee eethe eetee: hie-eh Zthet? eight; hits eehee
te make eett het wee tteetett he the She stated thet the
tett- eett kept her hit the-teeth tetheete - 

At eepteetteetety see PM, the hteeh mete tteteethte__teteteett. t?te 
te het eheet the eeme teehteet end ehe ghee htte the same She
asked teeve and the tteteettee teh?t her net he get her 
hehtey eewh there-t jhtet eteeittett the tteteettee Wit-h 
She eehett "it"ehe Citittk; The tteteettve
yes end; ?tett. hte. the the next ttey.

{Lite 1.3, at ezee hhtt, the seete tere thet
etchett he hates Khey rte eheet the
incident ee Sheet. *t?he'h'teeh mete deteetive? that ehe
wee eet teeth? She tete them that ehe-tteettett te gge te week end the
Meek-mete tetiittg he? that it wee her thet'ehe-Wee te her jeht
hte. eehett if she etehe eett te melee the het
It yeet ette$ Whe hett heme PM he. She wee
eet te etehe any eette, {ht her eettett the Ueit
eett hung he he him? "the hieeh: mete eeteettee teet het jewelry eett het
teeth identi?eettee eett te-ht her thet ehe thee geteg te jett. {He teteih'et thet ehe
wee eet tetti'hg, the teeth .eett .thet ehe 1th the her ightt?tieett. hits? Ah
Reset. egeie ethett feteeteethteg .te eet..- The heteettee eetet-fyee. hut-thee tett fer
heete Witt-met her eeythh?tg; 

 

ht eppte xheetety the Phi; the hteeh mete heteettve te with her
eheet the eetee thing eett she gave him the same {the wee teht 'thet'ehe
tees net gee-tee heme teeth she eew the jeege hit the metetegt Me; eehett

 

 

 

 

   

again fat ta aat amt drink. At 329G titM, that attack mala
dataattva tataatact with a hard atataat a. af'Papai. "Etta aatatztiva askad fat

hat tall Sha it ta him, and aida.?t him again tilt tha next
days

Ga Maattay $643343, at attptaatmataty Stat} AM, the: Ettaat: mata dataativa
tattafaatt and hat that aha waa gating Emma Ha attitt tta thmagh hat taat
massages: and that it titta atta was; tattiag the truth Ha asttatt it?stta waatatt
a ride back hama at if aha was gating ta taka tha 821a said aha waatd taka
train, "t?tta {tataativa gava Ma. Atw?aaut a bit} far train at cat: fair ta
gat ta aatt Tha dataattva tats, his amt 
hat ta tatt hat attaatvisat ta aatt him if thay matted ta tatk ta him,

Etaa ?abta Rato W126, ttaattaitta ?that? 3 was
aa taatntatatawatt tat by Sgt, 
at} It, at tatataa]; aatt tatatatt tha tattawtag ta 

titat. it the: an, Haatiaitta Catattimwmt ?32. She was tat
an $541143 wttaa Mat ttamiaitta Unitas
Hat daya aft that weak watt: Saattay ?35?82~33 'Mattaayf S?w?i?twt?.

?at. Rainy stated that aha was aat at watt. Whita Ma. was dataiaatt amt
knaw Why Ma. was aataittad fat that the was.

?at; Rainy ataa atatact that a shart tiraa attar Data. aim-Raga} had tram
tha Hamtaiaaf wait", ratta-aaltad hat ta aahadata att tataatrtatal?aatt that'tsta'. 
gat vary apaat' and bagatt ta yam .. Ma- taitt'tftatt ta Catt hat
attataay,  

Bat. Railiy atasatibatt aa Activity Shaat as a summary at? Significant
that was datta ta ta intraattgatiaa Ska atatatt that at: aattatty'Sttaat waaltt Eta
aamplatatt if 'faa .iatartriaw at a at aava?tattatt 
Art Aattvity ghaat alga Etna if an itia-att?aattaa was at a Ray 
avittattaa Was fauna. activity Shaata ara mmptatati by Whaavaa zines tha wart;
amt ata atatatt with tha Sitta dida*t teal that it was fat the:
detective an that ta aat hava att Activity Sttaat. ?at.
Ritay stated that aha txad aat baa any at ta the
tt-ava anatativity Shafatt 

(hay atta activity attaat ttaa aamptatad fat #Mt 3&1 {32, ?at?
Rttay aid aatft?aat that was art 
mata athatat- Sha?tt?that-atatatt that at: Sttaat aat
hava been Gammlatatt ?at? Etitta Whaaha atakatt atawatat Ma. ttaa ta tta Mitt tha 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Etet, Reilly, whee ehewe eepy efe mete, that hee hits. heme en it and
the weeds thete fee 3 set? end ?he eette??, that wee theme te Case with
182, etetett that the em eet knew wettieg wee test the mete. She 
stetett thet the mete wee preheth tn the deer ef the teeth that hie. elm
Reset was he The eete wee te ensure that Met teteesett 
Semeette there 3 Sqeed epehe with hee,

Eet. Reitiy eteted thet te ehtete hem the hettee {Eeteettee Unit all she
weeltt te tie is eett eewe te the eett teem 'tt?thete ere there She
can tiewe emit get them. tt?thete etett?t any evettehte the eel}. teeth wettht
piece ee etetet'te get them. 

See. gheetee ttit?e, ewe Seth} wee
tetetvtewett ee {teeth Sgt. Beth geehe #3 t't, .et A?ei?re', end tetetett
the feilewhtg in 

(ht Sgt. wee wethieg the h?t} AM te e215 PM He
net wethteg this eteyt _.t-te net knew whe hteeght
Arte, te the Hemietee Ueitt He tee etete thht-itwhettgetete were required
te eetify either the (test: men et whee they eet er 
trite. ext interview teeth. Sgt, hed he et
the Ueh 

Sgt. Seen _;etetett thetet the thee that hit. Aha-Reset wee et the Hee?etee Uett there
were he legs kept et? eete et _.ee er eete?ttett 'te we the
test teem-i .tt'e elee etetett'thet'thete wee he eteettee ee'hew'et when 
wee? with thee, trey-the eett weele
have eelhtte Al?em?t?e "-hehett? te-ttetifyffeetity e'ti? her it.?
the hett it. tie whegfit?eeyette, matte-e eeth
Sgt. eteteet that the ee'etgeett te the tetr?ee'ttge?eeheettlee their
witnesses; et est leeg eethey ere wethiega

 

 

Sgt. Reheat thhtee PM theme. 5 hqeett, wee
tetetetewed ee {35% Ew'tithtt? Stet Attette, .eett tetetect
the fettewgieg ht eetemety:

{Be Sgt, thkiee wee wethteg there FM te. twee AM.
He tt'et eta-eel}; this. eteyt- tte .eettmew whe hteeght
Me, te the --tteteteitte {Seth hut etetetst .thet'ieVeettgetere' wete'rettetteet te
e. whee they pet et tete et?t? interview t?tt-ti?tt?t?t. tie
eet knew whet his. teteve?ttee he the was ex? whe, it?
here Sgt, die eet hetre with Me. At?


 

Sgt. Wtihthe the etete that it is the end the deteettvee thet 
et? it is} .te eheeh ett the well efthe 



 

 

 

 

 

   

Sgt? Mathew #3235 t?Rtt t?t {hath 2 Sigma, ?3&5
an {that halt by #3133 at: Affairs, amt related
in summary: -

Qt: ?ht?dh, Ryan} warhed ham with PM ta 12%}0 hit: (that
hat spwi?tzalty recall waking thit day. Ht that he dates know with
hrttught Ms. Alattasut th Hamici?h Unit and has ether heing
there, He: did state: that the usually tmtify a a
ht" is 131mm}. an intervth 

Sgt. Byard stattd that he; had It} at this amt not
?ght}? why Ms. was detaihe? tune Est-t9 31mg
3 -

Sgt. Eyatd statett that at the time that twist was at the 
Unit, theta Was he pantie}; tan what: a Sushth ht was he given hr
?fatten tie did say that ifthe suspect ht witness hatchet that that
Whultt hath heat} 

Sgt. that theta its a. system at the ham. dash that is there ta
wail hath-g and 

Frank Hayes #h?hhs t?Rh?? $3823, was
intetvihwmt {an Affairs, 3215:! telattsd
the ht summary: 

Sgt, tthyas was Shawn a catty ?fth? Ethmichte ?nit?s titain Repatt
fat that days is: and $29138 it thaws that hh 
FM Sim W, that": @4333?: 3:053 AM 6:96 mt. It
the he thrk?t'l G?w?twtt .1 12% that th 582% AM. Ht (that not
recall {lays that that Daily Atthh?ame it
accurath, 1 

Sgt. Hams {that whit tit-taught hats. Atwtitasut ta 'Httmittitte Unit at
why the was: tittahtett hath (35th wt 3 ht 054334 3 31th"- lith it? at 
was taken at hy what,

Sgt? {that mt remit at Uttit mt? ifshe
was hravidett with that hr water his swift. tit tftha had.
what it} eat at think that it have hath

When attest} .it?ht: rhmemhemd 021 Mt, Ath?ttut during his that's at? (tuty
mt 0&6243 tm? 654334 3, tit-Wt wit that he hast tit} Sphhi?h hut
it? she WitS them white: ht was tht?kit?ig that he haw hart He
statect that his the th (thank ht withessezs
that are hating; {Esta-Ema matches checht.? 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

gga Tlmaal?ly #8541, ?amlalala Sail, 5 Sqaaclg was
lnlarvlawacl an lay Sgt. Jamaal at laiamal Affalras anal
aha fallawlag in summary:

Ga Sgt, {loamy warlcad lha 6:611} AM la 2:09 PM laar afelaty, Elma
avalailaa ?am in am Ha am. apaai?aally recall
warlclag day,

Sgt. stated that at thla time: ha was assigned la aha 8:;an and that
lla hall aa in new cases that aama in, apaal?aally Casaa
Ml3? 3632. Ela thriller atalacl llaal- aa a aaparvlaar asalgaatl la aha Fagitl?va Squad;
ha hail aa far aha ??aat alaak ar far aa that wara
placed. lata iataaviaw mama lay aalalcla af his squad?

Sgt. Gamay had at) cantaat with Ms. anal had aatlalag ?ml?laa la aalal ta
alaa awaailgatlaa.

Sgt. llama Williama #262, Uallr, 3 was
latawiawail?aa $943844 by Sgt. a3 l, at latamal Alfalfa, and
ralalad Ella fallaailag? la summary:

(3a Q?~?32~l3, Sgt. Williams warlcaal fram am AM la $325. ?311 ??aQ3~13a he
warkac?l it; 4:15 FM anal than warliad ava?izaa {mm a: 5 FM mill
$2?l?l Ha amt spaci?aally racall warlclaa daya

Sgt. Williams atala? that ha ?lala?t linear aha amaghl Ma, ta tha
Hamlaicla {Jail aria elaasa?l; lama: wha llar law aa iatarvlaw mam. Ha alsa
didn?t kaaw whag if apalca la liar. statad that ha
speci?cally recall if Ma Alwllasal was pravldacl with faa?l ar waiar bat
Ella? ?she allaalel aacl azaulcl llava beam? Sgt, Williama alatfacl "that it was: aat him
who pravlil?dtlla praiaal axial aada la Ma. 

Williams alaa aldalt kaaw ll?Ma alean was parmlil?atl la maka any alwaa
calls car if" any ialwaa calla ware ma?a ma lam? ballalf; Elia alas; stated. am: at that time
Ms. was at aha Hamialcla Halt, max-a was 21a aallay la daalgaatlag
raspaaslallity it waa ta check an llaa ar wall laaiagl
tha clalaa?llva that lamaghl: than: lam lha unit wauld shack an them.

Lt. E?alliga 333ll7l, llait, a was iatarvlawacl
aa ma lay Sgt. Jamaa #3l 1, at lataraal affaira, aazl ralalaal {ha
fallawlag la summary:

{Ila ha warkazl tha AM a} PM Mar afdaty. Qa Gaga-.23 ha
was an Clea 06~?l3m13, ha warlcaa la 3:15 may afdaty than
warlaacl avarilma-?amB?? ta 3":le PM. Ha mat these
clays, --

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

ht. Etiehi stated that he knew eeythiag Me. Atwhaeei er Hermeitte
eet he have any ei? her being there, He 
eheehieg ee her but said that it was the et? Whtkitig
te eheett en the weihheiag er that were at the teeth

He stated that there was. he peiiey in hiaee eh Wheat priseaete er Witnessea
were te he feet at the time that hate? wee them. Bet that ifahe had asked
the semethihg te eat ?31? think, that thee er teeter wetthi have been ptevitieti.

Waiter Re?t #219, Phi? @4353; Hemieitie Kieth 3 was httervieweti
eh by Sgt, Beieghehe ?t it at ieteteei Attihite, aed teieteti the
feliewihg itt summary:

Lt. Bell deactihed an Activity Sheet aa a, summary ef circumstances pertaining to
a ineeatigatiea. He eteteti they generally Statements,
attempta te leeate aespeets and witnesses and anything 
pettehtihg he the inveatigatiett.

Amivhy Sheets are eemeleteti by the aasigeeti deteetive but there ta ee
herd arid fast-rate aa ta whe can prepare me. The}; are 'gtteet?reae by a eepetviser
anti thee added te the ease ?le. They are etee t?tiahiheteti in a .peeket te the
administrative ateft?whe Witt thee disttihete them te the and
?isttiet httemey?e Qf?ee.

A Aetivity Sheet is eempietett fer eaeh iaeitieat and it
atetect in the ease file. aetivity- Sheets ere weathered deeumeeta fer
the extremes eta Crimiaal Trial aed ere kept ihthe Case 

Lt Belt theeght that it attendee unusual that a Hemieide tavest'igatiea Case File
weeld .eety eeataie ehe hetieity Sheet hat net heieg with the
ineeatigetiee he eet tea the amaaht,

When asheti hew hang. the Hemieide tittit has heeh required. te tilt Activity
Sheets Lt. Beii stated that they?ve been tieittg them since tie-wee trenefetreti there
in. 2605. He stated that he has never seen any memetahtieme pertaining te when
an activity Sheet is required te he but that it?s etetty teach eemmee 

Lt. stetet?t that the detemihatiett eh hew hang a witness wettitt he heht at the
Unit hefete they were ehatgeti er was tteeicied eat an iatihrieeal
basis. Each heteatial witness a seapeet er 
timing the meme efthe ineestigatiee, White heiag hehi at the itemieide Unit.
These peteatiel er he hehi fiat ah eateetied heated et? time
emit eh invee'tigetiee reveaie "their te he tree end eetteet. It" 
theta were identifiee that teet?ti a gamma wit-e etatteti emf as a witness te
heaeme seepeet, the tieteetita?e weuie emit}; a eehewie'et? Whe weuht in turn

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

the haltiittg at? the usually attat with tha Eiatt?iat
Attataays {Ett?taa fat paastala ahatgaat

Matvta t93?32? that, 2 gqaatt, waa
iatatviataatt an t36~?3??1?t anti tamtatatvtawatt an atuaawta by Sgt? 
#3 t, at tataraal ,t?ttfat?itai amt ratatatt tha in Summary:

Cm 05-61433 Lt. Williams. watkatt 18:43 PM ta and than 
avattima ta ta Hattaaitta i7it?tt} AM ta 3:60 PM.
tta that iavastigattaa that day hat {tat aat madam tatatvtews at
participata'ta that taveatigattaa.

Lt? ataa workaa 0a {t?w?zutE ?ttm PM ta Skim AM than marked
avattiata AM ta PM. {ta aa-?aawta ha watkatt ?am, 1-9243 FM ta
??:titt3 AM that warkatt ma AM ta 32:68 PM.

Lt. thttaata atatad that ha. data aat knata wtty Ma. Atwttatat was aatataatt far
ttaya at What tier ia the Hamtatda tava'attgattaa was; Ha aid

aat Witt: tats, and data mat What did: may if
a famtal was taken. ?tntt hat: 

Ha farther atatatt that at that: tam; that Ms. was. that 
that aid aat haw a aaiicy haw attaa a pttaattat at was ta ta fad but
that and avatar is 3

Lt. Williams ttat knew if a cat? was ataxia att Etta, behalf
hat atatatt that atta haw ma?a if aha reattaata? it; Ha-atsa stated that it
it the at.? all watt hazing at?
amt  

Wham tawiatatviawatt, Lt, atatatt that aativtty Sttaata art: at} tatamal
pattayg hat that Unit tiaafa-ttat ittatra a writtatt aat at? Standard
Qpatatiag t?tacadatast Ha atataa that ta tta patiay that haw
and when att activity Sham-ta ta taa aamptatact 3

Ha daacttbatt tha Shaat as an aadata tata?ag aftha tavaattgatian
that ta 'ttatagt It ta ?llatt by the diataattvaa that ta tha
iataattgati?agat ft?ha Activity Skaata are apamvatt by sergeant at 
pttat ta aa-ittg ta the. la ta taaittg- actdatt ta. 
case away is ataa aabmittatt ta ttaa ?f?aat t?tatataitta
Unit as watt aa th?a Attratatattattva Qtt?taa. Shaatfs? ata-tatataatt ta. tha aasa
fits; .tatta?nita?ty as they ata tag a Lt; that it
was far a Hamiaitta tavaattgattatt is atta. yaatffaatt swat: aid ta
aaty hatta atta Shaat, Eta-atatatt that wank}; mat tta required ta
eta at; Aattatty Sttaat jaat far a ta ?at 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

he, Wilheme {here he did he: giving Pitts eeti ?eve ee
whee he hieh he Mew er eh ether he hem her at the Hemieihe Uhih He
harther the: he the heet ef his he didn?t knew Thee wee
at the Ueh. 

he Willem wee Shawn e. eepy ef eete thee eteteei he hes-hi Me. Al??
fee 3' heeled and net he permit phehe eehethat eete hheehie weeie have 
en the intereegetiee mere he deese?i knew the: wee, hut if weehh
was met here hy him.

he the thee ef Me Alwheeui?e 14h Wihieme weuhi have heeh the everell
fe'f ehie ehe fer heyehe h'eihigi'c?ieteihed et the
feetee hweetigetienehet he were he.

he ?ees nee .heheve the: he wee hep: .ihfeemee efh?ie. Ahheeui?e Stems
by the that were ehe ieveetigeheh he he ese?e
the 

Lt. William wee eeheei if ?eteetive Phie Whale have heeh required he prepare any
pepemeehg that he hed piehed he hie He etete? the Eee.
Fitteeheehi heve he's; heme'ihehe Hemiei?e Witness Leg 
heeh at he ?eet desk" e?fhehee we}!  Write her heme en the
Ieteeview heme-Leg efthe them he he "he meme-eh sheen 
efthe leteeviewheem Leg: fee interview Rhee: ?3 .het dieeh the
eh h; 3'

he. me heiee Squeeh wee interviewee
eh hem-ewe 71 heme heiegnehe #32 3 e1
inteme? A?eire, .eed the fehewheg he eemmery: 

?e v.3 3, he werhes? here. ,2 ees PM he AM, thee werked everihee here
?hail  ee 32% PM. ah he weehee here 13:45 em ?e 8:88 AM, there
werheei evfe?ime hem 8:133  he 65:36 Ehhai; {35h ??e?hn?iB, he wee?heci 1.12.4215 
te weehee eveeahhe hem h?h'hh?i he 3 :hh de es 3263-?
epeei?eehy Weehieg days .ihei- theiDeily 
ie i 3'

he; hitte stated the: en h?uhhi 3, he weehed he ?emieide
M3 Nee He hie-22g with mete Rehhld #8633, whe wee hemihete?
hem the eh hiehee 1133 hem her 
ef emhiemeht .ehd hempeheti her he theT-Heh?eiee Ueih

met him, ieher reviewihsg the Heheei?de Interview heme Legs ehee Me. AL
Resei end h'eid he interview Rhee: Cf hem 13 until



 

 

 

   

35 hut that ht: was hut hair there. T0 the hast hfhis
rmltectimy hats? Ahttasut was sitting dd 3. ht ?dmicidd {Edit when
he saw hen

?at, Pitts did hat take a statement ?dm Ms, hedaum she had exptdindd
td him ht: tide td Hemididt: Uttit what knew the inwstigatihd.
Bet. Pitts that hd dithdt? the ddhigndd ddtd??tin at the 
What had said and that: was his last with her.

Bat. ditts denied pthviding Md Atwttasut with a hmde and and dads not
lmaw W'th prdvided with, fde dt drirdh Ha aim dads mt remit
givhzg he: $2.8 t?dr dah (32" hits fare? that. Pitts stated that he may have given her 
card at any time durhtg pracde hut ddeszt?t itan h, 
he it td hear. Ht: stated that, if that? 
madam, ht: gave it. th hat? Sh had a hhdhe dumhdr thy her the cat} strum ht:
her tip W?t?k. 

?at the time at this hugged them was: mat a Edirddtitrd gdwming
have; and a witness was td he dz" i?id??gamdt Since
this the draated Fditdd 'dt 
And Rights Add Eddtids QfLaw 
whihh a dd and wilt he
candudtdd. 

The {attire hash his fat ?3de was and {hand th
adhthih dtdy dht?: aetitdty sheet, Widtzh id dated muddvd 3. I

It; df?dld, the City Sdhhithrs Gifted haid his. dh?asdt $1 it} settld
tht: law suit that dht: had ?led. for fat d? ht)th

tit-eh titdve was tight dud ted the that "he wasdihmimd 
data-det and is ahftedtty'uhddt  

it}

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

11

 

Submitted by:

   
 

 

Enigma}

Raviawad anti by:

QM g; a
Michaf?i Fa Ryan 
(23:22:33; #28
intemai ?ffaiz?s ?-ivisim

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   



This investigated did SEESTM the feet that Set, Jemee .Pitte FR
#331618 and Edet, #8883, FEW 228568, Hemieide Unit, deesed
?their detheetty,

Me. stated that she teed received ehede (ted drum 3. detective, who she
theeght wee named Bet, whe iefeemed her that he needed te speak with
liter in referenee te Hemieide investigated. Me. AtwReetd asked if she 
meet him etter she was time were but was teid ed, d. sheet time let-ex, Set. Fitts
eed eteked up M's, Maltese}.

Set, Wits eteted that he end Ret. {ewe bed eieked Me, 133; at her 
ef empieymeet eed deepeed her effet the Hemieide Unit at F?e?ee Heedqeetters
eety as witness.

The ailegetien by Eskeni ef Eteteettee against wet. James
Pitts #9040, PR #EGIdtd eed Eet. {Bette #8 ?333", 228.650, Hemieide
B?tdt, is - 

Me, Atwtteset stated that she wee eietted 13;: et tier ef emeteymeet by twe
eekeewe detectives, later identi?ed es ?et, Pitts end She was
teenagetted._te the Heedeide Unit, Where she wee pieced end keet it: eel-interview
teem freed AM end! 8:981dMi ddwt33~13g Me. 
ever the. meme efttee time at the Heedeide tied
with the eeme eteekmele deteetive that pieked her up, She else eteeided tee,
Fitte* besides-e card that wee given te tier t2}: tide, epee tier? eeleese.

Eet. Pitts denied having keewledge efwhe elected fete. in en
interview teem, He stated that dte test time he sew Me, eke was sitting
e21 beech in the Hemietde tie-it end that The bed rte {tether with tier,

This tnveetigetien Vietetiee et? Bireetiee #82,
?dethth Xe dedee Cestedy? against Dee. tamed .ttitte #9343, Mid
2816?; 8 and" Det, ?eve #8893, Fitted-?23558, Lt, Mdt?vin Wittiems #1 d3,
293d32 add Sgt. Freak Reyes #8595, Pitt? 193328, at! Hemieide Unit, 

Me. stated that white te eestedy at the Hemieide Unit fee heaters she
was met giver: anything te eet er drink except eretzet end eede,

?tteetive #82, Adett It: Peliee Ceetedy, stetee that ?e31 detainees in
eestedy fee 8 beers Witt tee and ed tear ef?
dety thereafter,? 

Ne be in the that ifer when the
eemgdeineet wee previded with feed er teeter,

12

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

at: aapmsata intawiawa? atatatt that a patsatt ta. castady amulet Eta given
something to eat at drink ifthay it?

That atlagattaa by Zahaat Atvttasat at? twat-ape? against Eat, Jamaa
Pitta #90413, E?t?tat amt ?at. Stave: #863033 Pitt? 2285563 Lt? Melvin
Wittiams #153,, PM 1935532 and Sgt. Frank ?ayaa #3595, Pitt? WBSZE, alt aftha
Hamicitia ?Unit, is SUSTAWEXX

Ma. atath that aha tagaastad ta maka a phatta Cal} savarat timaa to
maaga fat child Gaza fer ha: 11 yaar aid; start, What was Emma and ta call
warts: ta aati?l than; aftnar abaanaa anti was 

Baa Pitts daniad. having any mataat with Ms. white: aha was at the
Hamtaida Unit amt atata? that ha didn?t knew aha was thata far thraa aays. tic
farther statatt that ha aiaatt lama had amitta?d Mat tat?Kasai ta make
a Gait,

A hamdwrittart mate with Ms. mama at: it was fauna it: tha 
Casa Etta Milt-102 with the wards ?Haiti Fat 3 and: ?Na ?ags? written an
it. it. Mata?a Wtitiama #3 53 tits writiag aa af?a?t, Ema.

The attagattaa by zahaai at t?ttagat Saaratt agaiaat- ?at? Jamaa t?itta
9840, Pitt! 201618, Hamiaidia Uai?t, is NST 

MS. Stated that ?at, ith hat ta hat that}. mae- 
whiatt aha gava tam, Whita biting Eat. atatatt that ha Want thtaagh
her tax: massagaa and it appaataa that aha was truth

?at. Pitta ttattiatt having any Ma. atuaasat atlas: ha braught he: ink)
- -.-  - a

Na iattapaadaat maid ha ta sappatt at tatitta; this attagatiaa.

Th6 invastigatian tiiti SHSTAZN the {ant that it Wittiams #153, 
193632 .aatt Sgt, Hank Hayes #3595, FM 19332.83 bath aftha Homiaida Uatt,
Faitatt Ta 

Ms. statad that aha waa piakatt at: ftaat hat ataca at amptaymant at;
{ta-01 at 3 anti trans-parted ta and dataittatt at the Unit until 13.
Star: ataa stated that atta- was mat pmvictaa with {ma at water at pamtittatt t0
make: any ph?l?t? tails ta natify hat fatality at matayar ttfhat? wharaaboata, A
famai was aat taken tram Ma. aat?waa aha with a
Gama 

13?.

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Lt. Wilttam was an @6433 wt 3 in ta (Bath
#tvtt hut 02, which is; the case that Ms. was; and
{thth ht: which Shaw-ht hmught it} Unit. hit him mt
{thaw-?t 3 anti h??htit. ?t the time tnvesttgatimt, ht. was that
Tilt-ht: Squad which was squad that was: 
Catt: tit/t3 3~t ?32? Lt, William stated that ht: tht:
but dict mt participate in it it. saith that he had n0
hat ttitt ha h.th what: Ms. 
ht was ht the hates

it Wittiams was theatt ht ?iti mt any Sp?tzi?t} 
his, Agiwga?tti at why the: that -t 3 with 
Lt? "Williams diti state that it wag Supervimtts 
tth'tht whit and H6 man
if hit. was with hut that the have
hath if the it. ht. Whitth that hm?tr?w?
he ?f'Witt?t?ttSit 

Lt. thttams was Whthing a thtat hfh? hams set?? heath Ms. was


Sgt. {tit 0643243 and He was Three Squad,
which was" Emmet that was ?aw-Mattias Sgt.
Hayes that he tit? his, ht the:
{thin 'Hh ht Why-Shh was ham
h?wttlith {th-Gl?ta?h ht: h:th htty' that
that the sp?ttht at the Unit. 3

Sgt, Hayes stated that at paint? a. hatify- a. 
that a, (32? witness that hath platted :htth at: Eta: high stated
that it was the heihg? hf 
anti Witnessht hut ht garishth and
witmtsas ht: it?-

Sgt,? that a h't'hh 47hth M33 was
d?iaintidt -

A mp}; hfthis Witt ha ttit that 
Bttat? .th't ??i?fzt -

         

 

an -  t?



t4

 

 

 

 

 

PGLECE
my 

3mm: 

   

Faiim Qcmn?ssiunm?

13mm Camanding foima internal Affaim Bivisien
?334?  CQEGK, 1.3m}? mam

 

 



Q12 Mon?ay, mama, at 3123?m? ?wiman #i?ig intamal Affairs ?iv?sian,
was natifiad {2f 3. Cempiaim ?sgaingi 13(32ng by the; mmg?ainant, via ES. Mail. issued was
an Enigma} Affaim mvisim Tim mmg?ainam! W. Lamy {Ewa?cy SMBM, 31%
Mamae Si, Phiiadalighia, FA EQMR mama the ha was {mama mgmfassianaiiy mid wrba?i?y
a?usm 23y Emimtim E?i?s, who is asaigm? 31: {ha ?amicic??a Unit?

?smmding 2m mmgiaimamg {m whi?ia a: 3333 Mamas Straw, ?ezmiiva Pi?a
came: ?Kim cumplaimm?s m5idmm waking far- iai$ gram?isan, E53321 (leak, in mfmma a
hamicigie: that he: wimesg?d whim was. gmiaig m. Maia ML ?m?infamad E?taciiva ?rm
that hi3 ganmm ma: Eva 'Wi??i him. Ammr?img ?a?ks-Ee-was pimms?i against the;
MIR anti that: {mm ?ner What: meme famed ?lm. Emmi agar isms}; What: Mn {imk
requastad we: the; 333w}: mm 333:1! dm?tme?any faa?zag wmi:
he. i$ a wimegg mi hmmicidaf? ?atmziw magi 'Imifam?zd af?ne/rs amazed that
mm?a?nm?s residwm his Wanissiam-gamhing 1er his; mmism aa?'i?cking in
ma dmma- ?emctiva E?iits mm} 1313 campia?nam, yam 133, ii? we:
can?t fina Nam,?  ka was; hamim?fed; 3:183 {wasm?ad the-Hamicma Uai?t .afmr Em
and Datceiive: Hits ibagan ?hnuting at each. 6mm Wm fram the Hamicide Untii,
wimaw; {Eagle ma 131mm Eimgital, mam, far chess;
pains. Tim campiainam aim mam-:3 Batmtim Fitzg-gmfi?scawd his call gamma and variams
{mar "pimms in tha?lmsidmm and. he: am} has m: m?iaiva?'tham back

 

2% 65283}: af ?zz? mmr?s indimws 33w fgzx?iawing:

   

jamm Eris {mwms i wag :agagmmtagi gm Wama??. Curm?t
?ussignmmi, Hamici?a Unit {@383} an unmew. -

Gr: gins-2642, Sergeant Emmi Rangam #86885 was assigmd am this mm gaiimz.

 



121 ta Emcu?iiw (Maia: 333 pariias ham bean natifiad mat ibis
iawstiga?m has @x'ma?ad that mm?amry ff?wziay invag?gaiiw gima Emit .mg ??lay was
aim {as 'itifermatim $322: $33 mg?irmi ?m mmg?eie: this jixxivastigatim.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

A gawk afaha ?aparaaza?a: 

a ?n Jamaa Fats CPR i 984%} alaag with his 
Dataativa Rabara a18?8?2 a? ?3629) a: U213: (Big),
atzaazataa Ea aaraa a aa Naiza Caak E03 Emma FEE
aha at 31% Maaraa (Wm: by

iaaga Rasa ?a?aawNaataai (Saar: {Eaakat ma: Riahaxcl
Sax 

8* 0a mama at agaraaimataiy mama Patml Wagaa 
foiaar Waka?ala $232322 3 i639}? hat gamma: @ffiaar Frank J.
i 3824}, W. Way Caak {a ma Felice
{ma} a a:21 St. aa. Caak was takaa aa aa
wait far parading a? af Justiaa 1


9: Ga Tham?ay, a ax? (Wag) DC was
by Eamaa 31 (PR. #23??15i {$313. -- ta tha 
Paiica Bistrict}, 15.13 ta ?i?his WAS a?agaa that 
damagaci his; {ma fraat wh?a a: gain --aatry iata his
mamaa St}, assignaa {mama}. Affairs 
aa ailagaa damages} fraat dam. 

My? (Isaak mama 32a aa, Pa
3314?} FA Was an $33wi?2a12
at at Taa mt Iran Baiaa?ag, ?3?38 Ayah aa, Sai?a Waila?a?ip?z?ia9 
Ea aha af . Ba?aw is a
S?i?a'   g1 a? that 

 

Ga 83~3?w12, My. Lam Caak a Emaakiag' an his Ema: Wham ha aha
amt, {are} am am: aim-if Naim {Zaak (Emma
W, was hams}. Ma. {Eaak-aafannaai {ha
Hamiaida that ha aa inat- Sahara Naiaa was;  Aaa'aa?iiag ta Mr. 
may aama iata his Shaman? naa aka as 3mm Pitta) hit him
?a aha ahaat with hi5 album whiah him a: fail agaiast aha wail ?Thai thaa
a} aha and; third fiaara af the: a-raparay making in aha baaraam
dams iaakiag far Naiaa, Ema shad. Mr? Caak?a Aagag {22) aad:
Naaixfa aama and a: in ?aa ?viag mam araag Aacaraiag a) Mia, Caaks
Pizza aaifa. that ha {Ma Caak) aliawaa Naiaa- ta am aha af {ha

paaparty.

Tha a; an axaara: fram Mr. a: tha affairs-


?i 3 data?: icnaw aha yaa Ha said I can {Ea this. I said at?: what. ?aming in my
iavadiag my 3 ma: kaaw yam ara, Yaa hava aat Shawn ma any
papara aa maxing,? ?a aaici can (la ahia? Ha Wham  said ia aamaahiag 
aam?ag. Ha said. Fa: gaiag a} 5.1a. 'X-aaia why? What, aa; aa.

 

 

 

 

 

   

the said he: maid ah: Ethtd am suppasaet Shaw that $0m??li?gt Isaitt Shaw 
wmaht. He said I (thh?t meat with. Ht: thitt hit it} can waghh. They
handcut?thd that 31th guy, tit"t?a Eh: had, a hash? hf pht?tth tth. A tang Chat.
Ha ditt t?t?t avast hath hthet that that tight. Ithhught he has
whith. Ht: came heath? I want th anti Ram? them? saw his.
pmheh Wham {came it was twenty Qt? thirty stays that 

Mr. Chats; was hf Wham ht: was hathg transpm?thtt ht: was in?amed by the:

hf?hhrs that hh- was at that {Fatima Building 
Pm)?

?White, I was them 1. mt far hathth ha hamh 313% gm the. RE what mt: wheth is
Nathtt him 3 knew. Ettw Fm ht Etth Wham he is, ht: is a 
than. Sh mitt him i thm?t watt what art: talking. Ha said art: hat
ghihg it} talk tat ma, get up amt get that hf thy tmm. Sh 1 get up he pushed mt: the:
mam. I stagght?hd th the: hal?iwayt has hut ht .thh I helith it ta he
the mam; ?h?hg timh ha had the in that .hh] that my He stilt
has its thatacttve Pitts hailed Eamth C?th mt tht: titth httm. my cash
thhy first ?rm. This was hay ?thy 'hhtt the hem ?t?hhy mt:
?t?h mam ?that: than with thh'th was sitting with
ttat?ative.. Wham htnmihitth ?3:3t) that hight. My 
?mve the th hut-pithtt whitth the 

what; the: Dr?s the: that they Wht?h hat gaming th tat gt: hhmh. get hut
Thursday 3 

{ht 61-49th, them Wat?h hf?cht?s th thhk?ihg ft)? his Nhim (Shah.
th  Smith,- hh thtitatt tt't?t?thht?t his th 'er Natth.
Mr. (2th hhsmihhtt and as 

tit My. Cahh, hating attihhtt th his whithth far at. third timh. 
(Shah twat meat} the: dates, this whith? Mt: Catt}: watt hit-t but hit
ht Cathie Rt tte?Q?w?gh?tf?h) wast. hath-t th saitt the
petiw that tat (that: in that .Nhtm Shah. [Eating this Mr. 
{that was t3th was hat gymsesht
tithing hut hatihvet it mama t;th hr thteh- hays shattht?t i??id??it

?aughtet?t Ctth?t?h Rt Shah B?ht 318 Sh
Rh E??t (EELN Chihtthir was
at wan-that? ht The ts a summary at? that


Gr: his, Rt Chat: wag dishing; what; her fathar, Mn
Leto Shah? was tit thtitw

{ht Qt~t8?12, M3, ka whith far wart: ht aha
hazartt what she he mt fight dam? msidehhe {3 it}
Mahmh St.) Baring this with twitch the tram ?ttiht? wag which
hf a theh, amt it d??t?fmm?t

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Awarding it} Ms. kak what: that ?nally eptm? tram dam; mattctiw t?itts has it)
13$th mitt asked Wham her tart {Natm ka} was, When Pitts Mt.
Catt}; tit living Emit}; amt that up, him Pitts) that Em wax
very nasty; and mate, 3mm ?tts weiryme
it} ?tting mam amt. Swat; mitt;de af?etts 
appmximately five sweat after the W?m inside the: .msidtmceg {Ema
that: atting that" sttyatt in the vestibutt: ma. What: Eetective Fit?ts (tame:
he shuwatt Ms. Cottk Matt and saitt that Naim watts tt} came 
Gt?tt?t. Aftat it: Ms. amt? ht: Saiti that; wat?d canttnue Gaming
back: ta their mittmca tutti}: tha mutt east has Mt, ka attpratsed amt:th tit)
Pitts saying that tam way they tam tam tutr Emma is the 333m
way the suspactt at? amt same ta that}: ham. Pitts why
Naim Carat: was matted mutt; tat anti that they {mitts} have: ?th?t? 


?322 Ms? mcalittd. 99km coming back Mmmte. Titty wart
att- mat: a?ttzet't Witt} Wet: tacking. fast N?ime Ms. that: mitt than:
that was mt them St} they 16ft.

Qt} Q?wt?wm, Mt Cant; was sham: a patiw 33mm my {martial Affairs
at Katmai-Affairs ctmtett and Sigma tht: graham an
the t? raw 3 tenant} past?time She meatlatt that tnttivtdutat as baiting Fitts Wilt}
5mm tn hm? hams mt $14342. 

3&3: ma?a-8?? 31% St, t?h?a?ehthia, Wt
mm, ?et?t?at? was at Eat?t attit?wl?wtz at lEt??PMt
tattawittg is a summary 

{3n ?int??12, Ms. Nadita (?Emit was gatng aim {taming
tram dawnstaits, Stat: cattett ttat {let {Twist} amt tatd tact: it
mantis Etta pelt-tit watt. dawnttattse tit tats. Nadtta ?ank, it S??t?t?eti 
may {what} watt with samamtt at; wart: trying tectiget tap the steps? Whiltt
she: was putting an same the: wat mitt titre wake tam? ?lth}: and gt: 
White-her mama: was stilt an the." gamma: Mist that: was. axi?ai?ing ta
titt what was gating Tm, What} the: :tataattva at James Etitts} 
tha phtme tram her hands and tat: MS. amt: was Nam? As she:
prtma?tct dawnttatts as the: wasted hast  Emmy ka3, that
musitt and hat it} that mam? .Pitts? W33 
as. a that-tat whim matte. Wht?s was (?abby as ?etwtiwt Rattan 3, Hessm' 13R
I ?tteattva Pitts was, at and being mats? 
detactiva said that its maid attest in titta tat aunspiratzy amt tit: 
detaizt them far Nttim tums himself in, at that 'titft?t?i Wastth Pitts; grabbed hat"
twitct attitt??i. that? hm" and
ptacad him in Mt" Ms. tit gm (twat amt set: if
Sim (tsatmt (Exact: 38563. Mamas cats gat a, him Mt {Emit matted. the
twat mt Czactx?t Emma aftat atticem had 
titer 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Ewing Ms. Nadim ka?s Internal Affairs Eivisim intewiaw? 321a was Shawn a
Fhilacielphia Palica Qf?mrs 13th may, Mg? Na?im ka cimlad ami sigma ma pismm
it: raw mm (1), third yiamm {Em 1cst SE16 believed that Emma. K: 136 
James Fins;

(33:1 91~1??12, MS. Nadim Cm}: whiie: ska was slewing? ?312: whim came; inn) hex
bedrmm imkiug far 313: {31?9me Naim Ceak. Eatmtiva; was shaking {ha 9mm mam
Whiie ma anifmmd ?f?mr stayed with hare Tm nf?cer Stayed with hat anti}:
Beimtive Pitts Gama imc} ma mam anzi sai? ?gaz: 3:233 may?, Wham she gamma dawnsiaim, 33m
maimd {mm dam? was bmke.

Witzxeas: {sake} Smith 3&4 Mmma St, E?h?a?alg?hiag E331. $145}: wm imemgwmi {:23 94s
at a& 3M Manma Sig Rama? is a    a? that iatewiew:

 

Q11 a: iz??m?s Mrs, 133m ('32th want misida {ref her Emma (3M
Maxim: and mtin Em mighbm?, Mr. Lam}? ka; miag 331mm ink} an Emarganay
Pam? W3.an by a a?ifermaii miiaa af?car, and watched by that
af?can Mr. (333%: wa$ taken awayq Awarding ta Mrs. th,- :th af?wrs were nun?
du?zlg this incident.  {Izaak was 3153:} vary quiai an? 1mm
Ha jigs? be shakem

Mn ka?s grandda?ghim' (idemi?e? as Nadim ka 339.3 8&3} want it: Mm
szh?s hmsa mgaagting infermmim fur a Zawyar that she: behaves? bar grazztifamar Mr.
Lemy ka) wmuid mm A?er the Emargamy ?tmi Wagma {mic  Ceakaway, the:
{we} Hgmicizzia datea?iws ask?d Mrs. (322th if mam was a ba?ks-aliisyway. Mia, {Izaak
mguastad that ?rm dat?a?vas Shaw hear their hadgas beme aii?wing?wm in mm}: hear karma.
Sim ma}; them ta the weak yard and they i?akasi war ma yard wall.

Mrs. Cami: speaks with Mr. Cm}: a few days Mar and askad him what mmd? Ha
infam?? ha? ahat {my (datestives) ?mm ha?ging an his?; Mr am: when be marked. aha dam,
may him ms: af aha. way, mm upstaima and h?gan apening am} mamhing ska
mama, m. <3an furthar axpkimd {a m. Cm}: that ha ?skf?ii than} what ?lmy mam
making fat: The {iemctivas mid way {Maggi}: 31% M. Cumk?s grazi?smz a? Naim {jack} was
Ehm'e and that ha was; pratmting him. My, Cami: infan-md Mrs. mach that may had; him
sitting in a mam. at pa?ae staiixm far hams;

E?atml Sargemt: $9323} T. Wait (PR #216??4 i @384); Currant Paimi
Bureau ?ivi?im: mama limit: 33% msmitig 5C, maxi was mmim
am a: Rama? is a Summary af m: interview:

Q32 at appraximat?y Sargeant Eahn T. Venit #8384 mpmd?d ?0 31%
Manm St; in the: 3m Paiics 3:33am in refemnw a Hakiizig Fri?se?mr 
Q?ginaily, ?3?1iszsa Emit: (impade the: grim?y Mam}; mama's as: 318 Manmsa St?
Sargeant Vanit pm?wda? that Imaticm Manama St.) with ad?itiami Emmi
afficezss. N5: d?i??iVES wem an ima?az} at ?313.: Vania rcquasm?i that;
Radia gamma ?m datacfiwg far the: mama? Ematiana Faiim Radia infamad-him that
the: Gamma maiziian was 318 Memm St. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Re; gammadad that Ema?an anti :1me arrival, ha sbsarwd ma glancimhag datacaivase
Sargaant Kiwi: dasm?ibas these dataczi?ivas as, am Eaiaczk maia anti {ma whim mam? {?rm @f
121% dawc?ves infemmi {ha sargaani {km 33} may nessis? wag mwo?atim af a gimme.
Based an that .iafarmaiion gravi?mi by EM aimec?vas, Sargaant Venit mamasi 
unnecessary palms gamma}, Tim wagan was an imam}: and may the:
in?ividual ?umicicia Hea?Qumam. Sargeant Van?t ?id my: kn?w if Ema mi? {11% Wt:
hammde pawns was a suparvisar 01? mt? Sergaam Vani?: resumw 9mm} (mm ma 13mm}
wagam 33ft am Ema?m with the Wigwam

E?aimi ?f?eer: Tanya L. K?gmm mama N28), {3132mm 2:  Paimi
3mm {3ng ma Mica maxim was .interviewe? at
mast 32%: ii?a?g?mmcm?-SE?E Ne? i?haffin 3E3aii'c1a .A?lvisar
Cammissim Swing ?at-?an Man-Phiia?aigskia, mama Thefa?awi?g is
a Summary mi? 'ii?x??i?ii??grvi?m 1

 

GI: ?bl??i?g foimr was asgigned in; WC 3353mm? Tim affimr?s E?atm};
Lag 1&3) imiicaies a: Sim a g?n?ty backup, Eamicida-
d?mtiws at 468 animsa St {mtual leaa?ia?m w- Ei? Mame Sn) with 21 p?s?nar. Tim
affirm: mm?s that'thizs Radiu ?33313 Was ?ispa?izhad 'er a diffamm imatiazz, foiaar Engram
b?iievas a Silpm?im}? cama mm the mm and magma that damtivm pra'vidg the
mam: ima?mn? foi'ctzr  resummi yam?: prim? mgatzizzg :he: cal-ma: 1?c3?$m

 

Faimi Smear: Paw Emk- #232184 5" ?545}, ?amam Asgignmem: Faisal
Eamaa Bivisim:  1"miri?? ?nits' I263 Was 'iz?te?rvi?wmi at
3&3? $322 ?ag  
Cammissim Sg?ag - x31. is" a
Mary ?f??a?imimi??w: - 

 

Q31 at agpmximamiy izi?PM, (3mm? Emu} It was m?igmd tea 
32$ {333$} arid remanded is} a hmiding .irs?snner aggignm?nt a: Magma St, {Efficer Buck
aiming with wits wag a?gizzaiiy ?ispafahied 3w Nanmsa St. :33
23mm}; ?313 Hami??idia ?atm?wsg {Egan his arriVal it 'Zha?;
ma Ramada: dat?a?vas pm?dedf-E?aiica Radig Mammy .Ei?kiase; .Ra?iizs
mdimawd the; mimic: ESL Wh?? @Efimzf Emit-"mith at 31%" Mam Stew a
Han?aida {Macaw advise? him that he; jam nwda? a 'vahiala far {ra?spmtatiam This
affix: did nb?mg? at}, alder hi?ak?aiahan?cuff?? and hei?g 513:1 ma Emmgamy
?iatml Wagm. Afiar iha- y?sanm? was ma?a i331} ma wagan', 'Qifimzr?uck msume?i?paimi?
?fixer deimtive?s Sig: W?s 131$}, 

 

?gmiai inves?gamr jaw  ?lm Fame A?viwry ?ammisaian quastiazzm}
Ewing We fallaw?ng a; sammary?f Cs?ia?er {?ae?s is; time
quesiims:

Gf?am? 333k, wh?a ?331 lmatian at 31% Mamm St? m: wam any injurias thg.
prismmr (My, 1mg; Caak 3mm mm was mare; 3333* min 31:32? 
?ma gamma:- ?iai aygmar ta b3 zugasat'. ?f?cw 311$: baz?wim 3 4- uniia 31$}
Mam hut 'bmaus?: Rama Radia- digpamha? ma amig?mmim .3 1i}; Mmtm?a?t?hmsa
waits was mama: ii} imam'tha rietactivm,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

0.13% am addmsa was ziisgamhadv numamus unim raspand?g?i 311$. mmargad a: 31%
Mamm St, ?K?ha: 0233;}! mpervisar that in?imr Buck naticed an was; Sargeant Vania

Fa?mi Qf?wr mm Sr! {91% i {Emmi ?ssignmem: ?a?im?
3mm, 33mm: gm? mm: mat: am marks? 33 was inammwea at m3,
em at mawm in the gmema at? SN 37% Chaim: Fai?m Advimr
Cammigsim swing ?ar?an "Em E1. F?zi?a?ew?ag Pa $123). ?e?aw is a summary
{if #3333; inimiaw:

Cm ?1w1?~12, Qf?car Eaffy Sr; #4933 was warking with Gf?mr 3111?;ng #6148 and.
assignad ta Rm Whiia manimzing Faiiw Eadim ?f?aari?uffy Emmi a. datmzim
mugs: bagkzip a: 33} 32. When r-Ehay m?vagi at. that-Bamzim with a" fesw athar
msp?nding waits, aw datwtivgg W?m my: 3mm, umam af?mr 
Wuasmd Palms: Ra?ia tit: ma?'?ainihe came: .iacatim {Ema-mtg, Th5; da?w?ves
than statad?m may ware-a: Ma?ma-SL They rammed pmmi prim ta ar?ving' at ?lm
Imatian dam suffit?ient mimic unit's an imca?m. 

Paimi Wm? ?amis R. Eungn?a i Summit i?atwi
331mm Bi?sim: SW), i?isar?a? Emit: {353% F?aiiw?i?ric?, is?arviaweii at
mama an ??m??wizgat imam-M Balaw?g afme igter?aw:

(3.21 ?1~17~-12, Wimp: 323:3ng #5143, aimg with his gaming? Sffig?r Euffy @4833, mm
assigm? WC .131?2. (3mm ,ma?g a gsiasiazciiviae: 'j mamas raw: Rama
mqaas?ngi backup at 318.5 $52; YhayWanE was; gamma 
be the: mmag 3mati??& ??zmtive man emf: back?wx? may Wimhe: mam: lmatian,
which W33 31:) Mmma- St,  Myer ma?a it as f?t'h?t?ima??n 53:32:35: thaw ware:
suffieiam mm {mi-i3 an 
gm:- jasgapgh Q?Rei?iy _#24?33% a? mxfrient ?s??ignmeat: I?ami
gummy mvigimsz ?Wit: 3m E?i?ga -?Biis5??tr?a?,r2f? was misewiewe? gm
?3~14w~12 at ?elaw ?5 a   {if ?hat-?i?tarviam 

 

 

(13:1 at awraximawiy {Emmy Jamph ?gsa was assigned {a
ma: 334 with his ymm-?f?wr Mali-53a Tkay rammed-tat: Eli}
Manama fair .a-nglding gxismm wag ma warms: asf WC
3124, anti when my 'imivad ?3333 Emaitiem S3: Vmit mm (Effiger'?mmcha? graaeec?ad irate
the: grapezzy, wkizzif: apgm?amd ha aban?anw. P'Qiim Radiaredimawdtha wits {Em
cam: imatim 0f? 33% Mamm? St, Wham may art'in at -M??ma ESL, (3mm:
13mm 'Qf?cer Kramchmig wmt?: inSiti? itha mfsi?amg whim ha waitad
?uisi??. The: primmr, Wm was wag 933m}. in ma .jwai?ing Emargamy 33mg}
W3.an (3mg ma magma?: was swarm, may msme? paier

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

FMWE {Emmet mam Kramchad {?gment Amigammi: Fatwi
Burma: ?iv?aim: $333, ?323: 93% 3? yaiim: Eisiricigrz?g ami- was im?axwiewee?
an ??air~?~12 at ?smm. Baiaw ?g a gammy a?'i?s?aai ??mwigw:

Qt: ?b?wlzg Uf?g?r Kramcha? #61845 was assigmd RFC 324% wiih hm" pmer, foicar
iasaph (3?R?iliy am? a hai?zing primmr assignm?nt 3m Mamas St!
They a?gina?y mapw??d {a 31% St. as dispatchmi by Paiim Ra?ia.

Qf?mz? Kremchad and 55g: Vamit cicmc? that graymyi R?im Radiz} pmvidad them
with 121% mmat Iata?an at 31%} Mam St, Wham ?my axz?imii 3% 3w Mama 312., ?fficaer
was}: m5 mgi?ama mid a?iasawad an man mg was 
aighty yam ?f aga ham?szfmi A: thatpaint, the; detazitivas; the; male: was; gazing
20 Hamicide, foiimr Kramzhad asm?g? {11$ ma?a m3: mi hanaadhim {war m? mm:
Wakafiaici anti {if?wr Wigwam, WM mam asaigmzi at; Emmng 93m}! W23:ng 
3mg Tim; msum?? pairs} (mm ma 13ft: ?m-?ima? an.

i?a?mi Qf?mr Frank EJaanarm #2mm i Curtain?: gamigmna??: 
Barman mama: U?ii?; ?33636 3? Ragga ?ist??tg and was inimiawm? {m
?32~27~12 at Sawsabi?iga ataggmximatcly {Effie-er Frank 31. La?amam $3324 wm assigmd 
Emarganay imam? 'Wa-gi?m with and they
mspunded a Wilding Mama-z:- 313$} Max:336 Si, 

affix: Manama rem?mi ih?s agaig?mam bairig ?isyai?shm as. a mi.me back~up
fetter tha Hm?ai?? Unit. 3% $03323 'an?i? ?i-ggsat?hk?d wag St
Thea? Eater mcaivez?? tha'wmz?a??rass 035:" '3 if? Ma?m- Si; Wh??-ih?y' Ewati?m
they ymwadmi mm 3% Qf?cw-Wm?igma ?bmme??v??mh? be?eva? it: Em mi:
Hamicidg ?atemives am ..3acati?m; Q'f?aar mF??i'am ?as??b?d 131$ {Wis .H'm?nizfii?a
detemzives as EWQ malesg mm: $313? whim. fif?hey {Xi-?mar Wm:th
taka {Em g?mn?r (mg Lam}? {Emit} swighi?m msa?m? m3
pri Emmi!? ba?ng handcaffa? ail-Aim; 3 wig: it} gigging 
in their gatmE wag?n, Qf?cm W?'?mm marsh-ea tha-r?alafm Waawns 3126:} my 
Mag-was .u?m?ez?ib?c} ?3y ?f?a??k??ntmm as}: gammy- year {336. black
mam: did 'sz camg?ain?f any $333.3?: ?r "What: .m?wd at the:
E?eiim ?eim?m ?nk .Wantann backmi the: .wagan ima- smkiing grimmr
bays. They 5:339 2mm (31:12 the 13mm? .ia'taka Em gj?zim' {<13 zaking the: prisamr
mmugh Elm Wilding mil ma?. {if?mr gmpm?. :3 I?mpt?ta?? far
Hmmiaidt withmt'numbm. 

Mm: amaze ignnifm? Wake?ei? {m #232122 3? 3mm, Ms?gxamm: Mm: 
Bursa-u ?ivi?iam; 3m, ?is?i?e?i  .?i?z?im am was-'inmewe? ?m
imam Eemw ?x an: sag-2:2; at? that 5'

 

{3:1 at foimr Kamifm? Waikafiscl? #3529 was assigned 
39W 3m, with he}: mm: .1. Lam-mam game; Thay mgg?ndad ?9 a
Emkiing prisamr assigammi a: .3 Mamaei Si. Th?y {ng ?rst ?igpatchezi 
23$; w?ic? waS a yriarity Ramp far i313 H?n??ida {iatactivas wiih? a-primzmr.

 

   

(lace at 318 Mauls-95? St? {hay cm?d ms: imam Elm clat?mlivm, lloiicm Karim ammually
EPW 383. with Elm mums; lma?lm 9f 31% Manama St? lilfl?lcar Wake?eld mcallecl
Ella (Ml: Lara}: {330k}, being hamlcafl?ml prim galval. Prim- ta galaclng W.
(rock. in the pawl wagan, they mammal far mammal; anal Walsh ?lil
mt unsawr anything @fl?lcar Imallall ml Canals: Emil-lg llpS??l; algal ha: was Ewing
mangled; but lag was. very sampllam will: than: {{l?lmr Wakefialsl- am 
Sal?ng Valli: #384 almg will: palml mils; (m 
Walw?el? pmpamal a {Zamplalm Qr Replay: (7548} fer Elm
Ramada limit Mih?lli numlmm EPW Bill was instructad by ?amclivas tramme
Mn lea it: Hen?sl?lel {lazing {hair Cask did all}: cam}:le
all any gain ?ll? any type al? Altar taking My? (mills: lee licmialcla ?limit, EFW
Bill mumml pawl. 

Palml ?l?l?llzer llama Kelly #35?l?l3 Surreal; Elam] 321mm
Ekll?icl ?ls?lrlaxla 1C3 aml wag laiervlewe? am llil?
{walla-at Bell?lw is a summary 23? latervlew:

{3n {llama ?llies: Emma Kelly #2295 was assignall RFC 334 with folmr Kelly?s
Paired Lag Campuler lliclad Elspamla {Cm} and "$48 Inquiry 39mm
(EC indicates that all lill?lml? al he mmluctacl
as: Invastlgala Framlws at illil Manama; Si. This Wag basal; ?ll 'a-?lvlata?al
Wlmass Banal: fill? Nalm ?ank {Warm}: #Sll?wl?ll?ll??ll??ll?l. Kelly
was all?lWEd small ll?l?? pmparly by 'llm Lamy?mlk, Wm mswemd 
deter.

?fl?laelr: Rally m?l?d Ella ka mumling a, my}; {3f the; (302m
Wamnl far his  failum appeal: fa; in a (Elli-?36? Rally
alwwexl m, le?' Elm gl-agwmark. {liming marsh lar?l?l?aim mm Kally 
a calling mid will: Nalm ka?a Elm ?llillmd it Mr, Lamy Came: was mammal is; call
the: mime; if Nalm filmlc mamas Ema llamusa lint: (Nalm {Tank} is llil?d?lil _-f??lffic?r
Kelly mmemlrlem M2: Lamy leg and an Sill malc in ?lm. living
mam. Thaw was famala in liar he {Qf?cer Rally}
haliewcl la be  Lam}: Sarah?s granalelamgl?lm? Rally 35m Manama Sta
with a backup unit but he. ?aw amt :mcall ll?z'ie' :lrla?lmg' g?fl?lmr?g llama anal unit
nambar. Rally m-sumgll glaml and mum 335le in refamlma is: this animal. ML
Lara): Cams: wags cmmratlw (luring ?lls. il'?llilii??l Rally will: illa
in. ma William mammal the: 27548; 

Llaulmazll Elem i 443); (Surreal gamma,
Unit: ?ll?il mad? wag Via ll; ?323 {mm-ll at
Ella ill -1 Emil?: glarllas ?lm 
Elli:an 3.ng ill via
email? ll?lm falla?lzlg?; .ls-zl Salami? 

Rlahl Mama alarm al" at: {34} yam alcl 3mm glimmer
(ml {may (2mm biasing halal all the Hamill-lag lay 
?nding charges {Elf i becaml: aware; {lf Mr.
his ?all 'lmn .aflar FM.

 

 

 

 

 

   

Fitts was mitt it?s the at timtz. hast tht?kett 
taut anti 6 {twain-ta (tilt?) whim ?itting at Rietat magma this malt
an Warrant it? atth Emmi:in Pitts 9f
rattaSt-t titf W. Lato Via watt a?W?m that W,
witty Cattk tittettatt th? lmttittg a, 
that witness Ct?ttk}; tilt trial; mated it: a ?Net Smitty? verdict

Rt?mrt 3. ?atter {mt #135352; Eetmtiva
Emma, Uttitt ?aw Unit amt was interviewett at 
?t?ht is summary at that 

Gm Tatsday at kmm?, Hagar #626, tilting with his
patina." twig}? 31% Mamm Sta it an attain a Naim
{Emit Whit was wantt? an t: Wmnt? 
itsutti by tadge Rate: (Quart. Wk?t Am:
Rithm? Sax 

Hassar attmg with his gamma E?itts, Emackittg tilt 
at 31% Manama St and at; malts at Mr? .Ltmy "Emitting taut at?
the that The: W. that thtay wars tht: 
Mt. (Emit ttatmtitrtt that ht: waatd 7m tight. (tawtt Whilt 
fat. the: am: tat be opened,. What Eat: as tian
awning, stasittg, and {if at tilt 
Hatter, it awttilt: tar  ta) 23w ttmt?. Qtw? the timt was apcttatt, 
datactivas mqusstatt .tha tn? Naim ?ank. (Mr. {may (Matt?s; granttsett)? Naitm
Smelt was wattmd a Wmuti Mt? Cottk said Em tit: it: his
Basset mallet sat straight thmugtt the. amt the
baakytr? that thematin Hatter, with hits. pmattded ta baakyatti
atta ht natictd it wall but gate? mm tht: ittft backyard mm, W.
Geek the third fitth Wh?t?? Nttim that: ttaytt E'?ettctiva t?itts cheated the
ttsititmze far titmk with tat-suits, ?t?ht: at? this watt
sent ta that living mam trait taftty' Wham: Hester was waiting.
Awarding- tt: ?tm?tt was anti yattittg..  {Etta}: 
statatt that this wati?t?tts Baum? Mt: ka that dang
was in natm. {Isaak stattasd saying Emmy, w?wm lack: we ?ametin
Hatter warhth at: t?tmatt {Nadtm saying, ta get
bask hem, he it it: Basatt {m the phage 
that Naetiztt {limit was hat? Mather, Natm 

333% an {ha data}; in 933%ng the and. Etattgittg amt matting 317mm}.
Entitit the: Muse and {mat thegmpettyg dtmt- apart; the: date-mitts 
tiitmtad by Mr. Cattk tat the thirst Ham", tit wait as: the t?nmrsatitm, 
httitte that ML that: ?ttibtt'ttm (tp?ttit?lg Etta amt.
At that paint, tt wagtm was catta? Mt; Sm and}. Rate 
Emit} it? t1 titt? Justice Cihatgt" 

    

be a?mwmi by the:  

it??

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Eu?ug tha sawing 9f thc: ?Material Witness Waxmnt?g {Em mar if this pmpe?y was 3193.
cavared mar gamma by palica.? Awarding {a ?eteciivg Hassm?, it aha:- this
pmp??y (318 Mmma St.) did mi haw a. war exit. Wag thair $21171}? Ema; 31% M?maa Stu,
Eaiactiva Remix? tiid mi damagm kick, :32? farm his way 31:23 the hams. Mr. Lem}: Cm}:
mm Kim frat}: dear far that: damciiws. Ragga: did mi: 33in Mr. ka betwee?
the; am: ma 4% ha 82mm; Mr, way Cm}: in ma {311632 {311% ha cn?mmd
tin: msiaieme.

?aieciim ?ames Fitm #291518 2? Carma: $ssignmeni: ?emctiw Bar?ng
??strica ?rm .IE-Iamic?a?ia {Emit sm? was; imarv?awe? em ?6~22~1z at 322%ko in the
gramme SW Em {Emma}. Paiim A?visar   {We} Spring ?ard?m ?3?31 F2.
E?Eziia?e?gh?ag Fa. ?eiaw ?g af maxi iniewiaw;

 

{321 Tuesday magma at appraximat??y Eematim Pitts #9G4i}, 31mg with his
pa?na?r, Eetm?va Haggai? #5261. gracaadad Max:333 Si. in an effa? {a (imam Naim
wag wan'ta? as a ?Mate?ai Wim??s Warm? Wm?; 
issaeci by LFudga Rage HefimwNasmi (Cam mm: WA:
Richard. Sax awigned pragmatism

Datactiva E31125 macaedazd ?53313 Mi}an Si. is germ this wmant? The deiectiva meme-ct
an $16 dear; an gammy man {idm?fied as Mr. Lemy ka) Eaakad- am: {31? ?m gamma,
?mr windaw and mked whey it. wag. The datmtiws infamad W, ka 313212133: wart: the:
gmlice, Mr! Cm}: mm me detactivas that he 33% mz?z?ng (Ram, Prim 
E?tac?w Pitts had ham": 318 Mamm 3:5. in ?le: E3331 E3112 W?m unaware that {his
mai?mw has a rear axii, whiz}: wmui? aiiaw 2m indivi?uaj exit 1% alleyway via
breezeway, No paiim panama! cavemd 1313 max ?35 tin: pmpe?yg As may waitad far Mr.
C?an ta mm: 223% awn which was}: awhila, ?awa?w?m dams siamn?ng. Tim
?ewc?va mica agaiza knackad {m this ?rm? mad a 3mm 1am,  ka {waned {ha dam:
Aamreiing ta ?atesc?va Wm! When ha simgs'ped if: {Em {imam mked MI. Cw}: "when:
was Main?: .Caak (My, {may kafs gildSm?i). macaw was; diai 2w: faminy 9pm: the:
frat}: dam" m2: {ketea?va E?i?s yin Mr? ka batwa?n the my aim. the: wall ?33? albnw
him in the when. amazing imn thia- residmm Naim ?mk Was a witness in a hamicide
cam: and M?krmam wax giving a *Mmrial Wiims? ma mdga
gma?ding mm? ?iha ?23.38? 

  

?ithmugh My? (3091: dimmed the: ?ezactivas Naim.?s ba?mam, wi?ch is an aim third. ?aw?
?atmtiva Pitts the; backyar? dam: amen, {hag ma. (3:126 again, Mr..
Cm}: wasted the; ?ateazives 1:43 am third; ?aw Where mam was. magazine: Ti?itis
3%th {ha swam} 331523 thisz flaws 9f the pragmy. While {in am third {lemon 3 yaurzg
woman (Naaiim Geek) infamad mazmtiver: E?Ei?s {?athaim?s mam was? ta the: mar 12m
@1133. maiactiva PRES had all eccu?ams imam: an ma upper flaw; 3am ?awnsmirs the
iiving mam ma Wham ?atactivg Bessel? awaiiazi. Ea-aa?w P3535 me?la? My, Cm}: hazing
vary laud and mmimaiiy sayiz?ag that this was big ?3201353.. The: dazestiva $3353er Mt. Sign}:
Wham he allay? are run am am bag}; dam?? Eatemiw: Fim gxpiaimd Mr. {Zack that
what ha ciid was miminai in nature. Acmr?ing.m ?emciiw' Firm, the sima?m in 3:0
Mmma Si. mama vary misy with Mr. {kam??ma?y yelling arid rm?: calmiag- down?
ammugh his gran??aughters wm taking him, mlax.

1.1

 

 

 

 

   

A: same pains, metmiiva mas avarhaard Nadim taikizag en 1161* aa?z?ar gimme. She was
saying mm? gm: ?115 hem? Gmn?d?? is; aim}: in gay: in mama ?9'an raced 
handla this." 1? he mnwmatign wag bziaf. Aftm? {31% Wang wamazi hung up 1% mam;
Eatmtive Fii?s askad if he {Nam ka} was baak. Sim $331, ?3 am Emmy.?

Basmi an {ha mighty 9f aimumtmaags Elm daiay i3} awning {he Emmi; damn that siam?ng {if
(3mm, the 99:22} bmkyai?? dam, mad the. gham that the granddaughter hagl with
ailegedly Nam: Cask, 21% had a Emrgamy mm); Wagmn trampert Mr. C991: 22:)
the: Hamicida U?nit fer ma gamma amt-gag af ?E?m?a?zzg Apprehamim? m? a?
ius?c??. WM m3 ?am?cida ka?s gamma waS ringing, A: 5mm- paint, MI.
ka 333;} it was his: daughter, but met Naim?s grammar? ?ftar Mr: Cm}; gava ?cmtiva E?itts
{ha gimme: mmbar far Naim?s mother, aha wag caiie? and. indicaimi that ska diti mt want
my pm if axis 

Men Emm?ve Pitts m?m? at am Hamicis?a Unit, he: infamad mg: Mc?amm: af the
was: siams mf Nair}: Caak. Ha: aim infarmmi ?72m gm. ma?: ha wauhi maka a. a?cigiun ti:
charga Mr. ka with ?E?ndcxing :32: ?Qbsma?m 3f Eustica? ?atmtive
Pitts exgiaim?-m ma: Enigma? Affaimimastigamr that-awry aims: ma?a-13y Hm?side
Uzzit mast-?Em appmye? by a Hmiaida Suit  bafam aha assigzia? ?aw-mm c2321? mazng
famarci Wim any prawssing {sf that In mg ?emrs?m ?ivisi?n, an. assigzze?
{iawciiva can pm$s a. Freiizr?nary A?es: Repm: m: a gimme? grim: {a mistrim;
Amway Charging ?rms apgmving at: mast, if an  mt agpmve {ha
chargm, a {imiim?m Wm 33% isauasi

?amtiw Fi?ta 33ft .wgrk fear tha clay buz inmmiad mt: ramming that might md charging Mr,
ka with Rimming {Jr at" 313mm?? if Naim .Cmakdid mm
himgalf int-?3 Amarcii?gm :m?tineiy {@313 --his mum: phans 
silmxt whazz ha. gam in tha {Z?n?z?zal-Eugtice' {tam {gem mar: marm- ?nd as a-msali, 
cam-m 3313:3333 was imtz?-aff ihaiima ha: Ea? that-mi: that;  Ii?a?m?w Hit-s aim:
Hamicide .4FM whim ha ar?va? Mme, amismci m1: a amt
h?s iicaimmit {Lieutsmamswahim??ma?a?da Hair} ?mf?mnfgi {hat he: was gaing 
have  ?mk mtect?iva Pitta was ?at gzresam Wham My. {imk'was rammed

A ?M?ata?al Witrmsis Warmms? mam alga ?gsua? far mm awarmiuatam Wimasses t3 this
cam ?Mam?al Wimms Warrant?; as m?ainmi by Eewc?iw Rim, is issueci what: a
wimaw has signad an invastigamry intewiaw, hm? am :20: wam 3:13? invalvemmt in ma
criminal {23% if it man ha 13man that: in the pa?t the: perszm hw-bwah warranted <31? has
indiaamd that may. WEIR mat mine: mmun?ar any aimums?amas that: may can mum},
and is?: {imma? by $13 Sittiag; gadg??iat {Emir apg?arlaxzm in mutt is a ?Mamriai
Wima?s Wm? 'gwili Em $31555: .wamis: .giva aha wiim the arme the
in?ividm?. Tim wimess? is hem gin untii'me' mm is dismse?. :nfi m?a?ss the: jui?g?:
?mi?as diffammly; - - 

IQ

 

 

 

 

 

   

Q11 inigwm at agapmximazaly ?amm?ve Pit-m 33mg with his partner mmiim
H6333: mm. back is?; 316 Mamea St? iwking fer Naim ka?. {Eu?ag that inwstiga?gm?
Eatacziva Pitts; did mt ?amaga Mr: ka?s dam

    

Sergei  #3588
imam-a3 Affaim ?ivisim

 

 

33

 

 

 

   



This Mt, Leto ka?s at t?tt??l??ta ABESE whitzh
actanad mt thy twat Fitts i 9348}, datective
Mt. Cook?s hamt in at: apprehend Mt: ka?s grandam, Emit, is
NQT 

Mt. ?3an wages when Bettactiva his (319 Manttm St}, the:
hatwaan the wait. and the ?tter. Mitt ka. that
Immatin Pitts him it: the mast. This itmtiti {tattmtitte if thaw
was any physical batman. the patties tinting 

 

?I?ttis tnvastigatien Mt. {may Ceatt?s tt?tEE Qt?   which
at: 333mg i may, what this
datacttva entamti ML ?aak?s hnma att taffmt Wyatt-wit his grandam? Naim
is 

My, ka?t grandma? (Ettak, was a Witness ta a which mt 
?39 at 948 . t3? St. #?gmw?mt?g, mantra} #32122}. Euttng 
hamicitta Naim Cent: tt wants that
gamma-that __Etcattm Nam-Can Apptat? ta tilt mutt 
a ?Matat?ial Witmts {Warrant was .ttsuat?i by 
pttsittittg Judgt Assistant
Dismct ttit?tartt-Sax watt-assigned this triat; ?maiztt: at? 1:116 tack at?
all this was; -t?t??3a83ti {?u-ts
?Lack at 

Qt; ?tut?m, Batmtim Pitts want Sta Emit Cattk. 
Pittg ta mam the tear at am St, was swarm tty' 
prim tha ?ametin Pitts k?mk?ti;
hwy tamttett that t?tmt amt Eta tat- 
?ttmt?m .Stat?? has .tteat?? ?tters A fatal minutas
{Emit (Sank: Pitts-tit {Zack?s mam:
Naim ?3an was Emmett. a apatt,
E?m?it??t Pitts tat Marti Nadita katailkittg the ?Yttu
patica: it get it: mtg}, this? Wham
tty ?ttet?ttva Pitts tt? Nattm C??k-Wa? :30ng back, Si?t??t ?it titstt?t
imam?

 

Pitts swt?tit an at tzttitPM, he attesttd Mr,
(leak fat, Justictt?.? had Mt.
tht' Hamititts 'Etitts- it:um
eta}; but ta gal-tram against Mr, Emit What: he walk that





 

 

 

 

 

   

LL Rhiel stated Em Eamad {3f ka?$ ?ammim; a: agpmximataly 5mm and. magma},
that My. ka ha mlease?, ha {mated Bamtive mm; with thig infmma?am Naith?r Lt.
Rhiai my ?amtive Pittg imaw wha a? Wh?? C??k wag W. ka aiata? he:
was reimad a: apgmximwly 

Thia invastiga?an mmaia? mat Ms" {may Sank, aga 84-, was mcsmi, irampe?a? 
Hm?cida Unit, ques?ana? and {imaimd far aver xix mum bmc? (m Virtually m}
artica?abh fans that Weauid a ?E?n?c?ng ?pgmhemsian? a: m? Eastica?
charga 39 b6 campiemd at, the iima: 9f ti}: inci?am, My. ka came: dawn 3:16; waned the
dim}: afzesr ?maciim Pitts {mm m: apstairs windmw. {Batmtive Pitts Maid;
dams sim?ug. Emmy ka? Nadira Caak, and Angel Caekg a3} waits wam insi?a
the Emma. and may haw pm?uced thaw snmeis. Eazmtim Kits haii infarmatim that
Naim Cm}: was insida the Emma prim the: wan-an: macatim 323d ahsawe? :23 ?ats thai
wm?d iadiaata Naim Emir: ascapeii ?118 Mina dating the .m?cutjm 9f the warrant
?aiactivc Pizza 3mm: ha hdeadim masking m: a graham Sammzm, ail?geadly
Naim (fault, Easadr'zm ?gimiiva Fins maxim}? ?f ma {mwmmiam meme is ?t?a-ev?dmca
muc?iuda Naim m3}: had tiw Mme timing the: :axe?a?an {3f rim warrant,

It is mam ii??m?y that ?emciim Wits was irz?tata? at: the; eiusimmss (3f Naim (3901:: fram
baing fmm?e? and {ha {imam-inn {if Cw}: a3 a may} in wegaratian {mm
Mr. (369k a: Naim :ka smwmiar. Thix is supparmi ?y ?eta?tiva- Eigitts? aeimissinn that
he. iaft Mr. Law}: (3an da?gaimd at ?amicid?, Rafi wark, ami imamimi pursue charges.
agaimst  (Zka {hat night Wham ha wark, 

Emmch Pitts she-aid mt have: magma {may ?cmk. duzizng this imi?ante Any gamma
arms: 5113121451 have ham campi?tmi afier an investigatim and saiz?mmsim a1?? a M?davit 9f
Pznbabiat-?Caum it}? Ms: Warrant: ma aggrava} by ("?atiective??iifs ma?a m;
effart, wan aim Wsting  ka "at ?lm 53mm; .f?rmally against Mn (34ch
?lmugh ?uhmissizmaf an Affidavit far Mbahla {33%sz Magi. This?atemiam mast,
and quastianing gaf- Mr. 1:12:15: thaw ?irmumsma? was .?njusti?e?, 'impmpar, and
unpmfassimaL

Assam-(511g a; tile Aizied ?isgatah 3.13pm?: 13%: WW 331
transgoxte? Mr. C??k tea the Ramada {Emit at msuma?; yam} 3% 
Ida-mama: Riahl caliaii 3mm ?w U?it a; appraximamly gaming the:
Mame: af  gawk; Mn Cm}: was. miaamd shamy thm'a?m. i.  Cigars a?pmximaw
tam} mg in palm cuaia?y at the Ramada Unit was aggmximawly 3 3% hams.

An investigatim mm m. mm}; ka?s aliaga?mzz af TG 

PRGFERTY {'me dam} by l3etactiva Emma $3135.. (FR #233618 f" what: @113

?amiiw attemgawii farce. ants-y irate  Saw?y, karma: in at: affa? ammth Mr.
 dam, Naim ?aw? is  

   

?aring ?mk?g Enigma: ?ffaira interviawg 1m mum ma?l the date; that am {rant
dear big msidmm was damage?; Magma. ha wag mi imam: what: Eama?va Pitts
rammed :9 his msi?imca: waking far big aa?sazz, Naim (Emmi; 3M3. Sarah wha
is. ?rm {2f  hwy ka,~am? {ha mama: {if N?iim .kag magna?the {imaged
pmperty aim 

 

35

 

 

 

 

 

   

Camgziaim Encidmi; R?pm?i $548} was; prapmed far ?E?mg?m?y Eamaga? 
Cmie 318?}. Sargaam 33mm 3. B?iagmm @331 as?ignad ta the
3rd F3133 mistrim, this: mgmri an mama at ?z?wm. ?ats: ?f {smmences
was mated mama Cmm?a?nm? was refarmd 311:; City Sa?cit?r?s Qf?czar far
mimbm?sammi.

A. 439333 af this {wart mama faxwar? C?manding foiaar, Faiim Ram. 0f Inqaify
far twig?: anti actim.

 
 

?misefma Win of
Staff 1135mm:
Mama} mivisiezz

16

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

 

a

   

MEMORANDUM

PQLICE
CITY GE 
TO 2 Ealiae Cammissimnar iw?wl?
FRQM foicar. Internal Affaira mivision

KEIEK mmzagammz?n ?l?w136



an Manday. 3w23wl?g a Against Paiice was racaived at internai
Affairs. Keith Tmlbart. and IRE ?l?wi3? wa? iasuad.

Keith Talbaxt, 36. af?. Gamp ?ill. allagad that on
9w4m13. at am gn? Race Stzaats. Eat. yitts punc?ad him in tha fame and
ruhba? his knaa against @nlbart*$ penis. Tmlbart alga allegad met.
Petarman t&reatened :9 break his jaw if he didn*t give a statament.

met, Jamas Fitta 2&1538. wag ayyainted ta tke Fhiladelyhia
Emlima nepartmant an an? an i?wz?w??g ta tha Ramimida
Bait.

Eat. Reward ?ataxman was aypminta? ta tha
$h&la?alphia P?lica ?ayaxtmant an ?m3$w8?, au? a?gxgna? an 12w1?w$8, tn
tha Ramic$?a 

an Wadnasday. Lt. Eatar Sandasky Internal Affaixs
Divisian. was asgigna? tha invastigation.

:viswxaamzvm 

This investigatimn exmaeded the ?5mday limit man?ated in Exacutive
Qxder G?m11. Ail parties are awara af the dalay. which was due ta
wezbart?s anyar?s failurm ta ta lattezs and phena calls.
Talbar??s initial aamplaint instructed the asaigna?-investigatax t9
Cantact ?is iawyar, Mary Mara?.

Keith.?ol?ext, was interviawed by phena on llm25m15. Telbaxt
atata? ha was braught frem the ?etantian Centar ta 8? an? Race Straat?
on ?albazt was made ta taka m?f his swaataziwhiah had a head.
Talbarn wa? maid the sweatar an? hacd ware a saaurity risk. welhazt was
left in a ramm with cnly a tank tap aha shazts. ?baat twa hears 1&tez.
Eat. Fatarman antarad aha raum and began ta talk abaut a homiui?e that
hagpened. was adamant that he.knew Talbart?s rala in the
hamicida. Talbert told Bet. yetarman-he wanta? ta talk ta his iawyer
and invaka? his 53*Ememdment Right. mat ta say anything at that tima.
Tcibart amid ?at. $etexman his lawyar was Mary Maran. ?at. ?atezman
exylainad aha details af the aasa and tha cir?um3tancas. but Tcibert
di? mat reggand. Bat. Eetexman laft the ream.ana anathaz datechiva
entexed.

Talbert $tatad he ?aund Gut latex that tha second dataqtiva was Pitts.
?aring this quastianing. PittS tald Tmlbart abaat himself. an?
that if Talbext ?id nut taka this questianing Swrieusly ha wmuld aggret
it. Talbert tal? ?at. ?itts that ha wanted his lawyer pxasent during
his quasti&ning. Talbert alga tal? ?at. yitts that.the law said all

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

witnesaas waza t9 b8 zacazdad in some way. met. Eiat? di? mat Like that
rasganse an? teld Talbert that this was met a mavie. that smmeba?y was
dameasm?, Talbert wax in tha middle of it. and if ha did mat taka thig
?eximusly ha wauld be in a lot af tremble. Tal?ext statad ha iaoked at
Bet. Pitts and Said ha had cammunicated what his pasitiam was. and he
ha? invmkad his ?m Amen?mant Rights with Eat. ?atarmam and him.

Talbext statad ?at. ?itts haeame visibly agitate?. yulled up a chair.
and gat up fa?a t? face with him. Eat. Eitts 5&id it wa$ in $thert?s
beat intarest ta tail him abaut thi? hamicida and wh?re the bady wag.
Talbazt stared at Sat. Fitt? and did mat say anything. Eat. Eitts teid
Talbert ha needa& ta tall him.samething. ta spaak. Talbert smiled at
Eat. Eitt$ briefly ta give him a hint that ha was net scarad and wag
firm in big stance..?at. Pitts tal? Talb?xt ta stag smiling. thi? is
?at a gama. Eat. ?itts than taak his fist and struak Talkert in the
Ease with his right hand. nab. Pitta cantinued ta raisa hi3 V0158. but
Tolbart ?id ?at physically :ataliata. Tmibart stayed calm even thaugh
Bet. Eitta was tarrarizing him and had xaga in his vaice. Talbert askad
if this was the way tha ?hiiadelphia Felice canducted intarreg&timn$.
and Eat. 9itts tol? him t9. ?$hut tha fuck up.?

Talbezt bgcamm fearfui tha? De?. Pitts wauld strika him. 3% in an
affaxt ta div&xt him gram his rage and aggzessien. Talbart a?kad Bat.
9itt5 t9 tall him abaut what was gaing an with tha ma?a. Bat. Pitts aat
dawn in a chaiz and pullad tha chair mlcsa ha Talbext. ?at. Fitts than
began to pu?h his knaa intb $al?ert?s cra?ch area. and use ?is knee ta
pugh and massage next ta hia penis axaa. Talbert.did mat knew how to
take this. an? ha was axtxam?ly smarad. angny a?d hurt. Talbatt statad
ha was almaat in shank. This wan? an f0: a%aut tan to fiftean minutas
as they taike? abaut tha cage. Talbert asked ?at. Fitts if ?e caul?
have same tima to t?ink about what thay disauasa?. Talbert did this ta
get sama ralief Exam what ?at. Pitta was daing. ?at. $itt3 gat up and
1&5? tha raom, an? did mat ratuzn fax ahaut twa t9 thraa haurs. ?at.
Pitts raturned.and cantinuad ta leatuxa Talbert abaut haw it was in his
best int?r??t ta di?cuss hi5 tale in tha hamiaide. Talbart again tai?
Bet. ?itts that he wantad ta ?paak ta his lawyaz. D?t. Eitts went back
ta an aggressive ma?a. Talbert ?aa?de? ta stand up ta get. $itt3-and
taid him ha thaught ?at. ?itt5 was dirty an? ha was gaing ta taik
to a ?ixty cup. and he baa nathing ta say. Bet. fit?s ?eld Talbart ha
was gaing to talk, and he wmuld ha theta all night until ha talka?.

Abeut three hmurs lataz. Bat. Petazman same in with ?at. McNamee. Eat.
?eterman tald Talbert tha twa girlg were in tha athax Kaom. bath had
aaid similar things about TolEErt?s invalvament in the allegad
homicide. and.Tleart naa??d ta tall tham w?at ha?pane?. They centinued
ta badger Tolbaxt he give a statament. which Tclbart refusad ta do.
Bat. $aterman Enid Talbett that ii ha nah ?ake sarioualy ha
wauld break his jaw. Tolbart stated ha was ?iaying games by mat giving
a statament. and thig waa aftex ha invaked hi3 5w Rmandment Rights.
Seth detea?ive? left and ancthex ?ataative Gama xn an ham: latax. This
datactive had sama ma?as and Tha natag ware fram
tha gixis. Taibart assumed it was a giay ta tall him the girl? wera in
austady. Tha detectiva shawed Talba?z tha statements. Talbart said ha
still aid net halieve what he was aaying.

Set. 9eterman raturnad and held Talbert they had gntten sta?ama?ts fram
bath girls and it was met as ba? a3 Twibart thaught. and thay triea ta
switch their tnne with him. Talhart agapanded that tha interraganian

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

was mat being zacor?ad an? he stili wantad that ta hagpen, and he did
mat why thay mantin?ad ta try to gat a statameat ?xmm him. beta
geterman left the ramm and ?at. McNamea ratatnad ta the ream. ?at.
Ma?am?a eX?lained tha chaxgas Taibext was faginga Talbart tai? Eek.
McNamaa that if ha cauld gat hi3 lawyarg Talbert waala give Data
McNameag and aniy met. MgNamea, a Statamant. Abaut thraa hours later;
?at. Mc?amee Tolbart?$ lawyer an the phame, aha @ulbert spaka ta
hez? Ms. Mazan ?eld Eat? MSNamea :0 stag quastianing Talbert; and it
was over &t that point.

In reS?onse ta sgeaific questiensg Talbert stated his complaint is
against Eat? ?itt3 far asaault and sexual assault, and.agaimst Data
9etexman viglatimn Qf hi? Mixan?a Rights; and the law that all
witnassaa ghmuld ha r?carded, $albart state? his aniy injuxies from
this incidant were gain and sarenass, ha did mat have amy bleeding 9r a
busta? li? 9r anything, and damaga ?rmm the saxual
assault. Yalhazt stated n0 Qne alsa was pregent when ?at, $itts s?ruck
him in the faca and rubbed his knea against his genitai araa. Tolbart
state? mat. ?etarman di? mat hit him; and ha ?id Ra? giva ?at? Qeterman
a statement:w

Tal?ert alga ma?a statemanta abaut Maxy Maran and tha famt ha did mat
feai she ptmvided him with prapax rapr?santatimmw Tha assignad

inwastigatmr bald Talbart he wauld hava ta address thnsa aam?iaints in
ano?hax venua? I

met? Jehn Ma?amaa $835, Ramici?a Quit was intaxviewad an l?m?iwi?, at
intarmal Af?aira by Lt. Sandusky $389, Eat. Ma?amag stated he was
aasigned tn intazviam Talbart i? referance ta tha Hamimide mi Mr.
zarzyaki. Dat?_McNamea advised $91bert oi hi3 Miran?a Rights and told
Talbert he was a suspeat in the killings ?at. Ma?am?a statad thay spake
abaut tha inc$?ent fa: ahaut an hauz ta an hon; an? a_half? At some
paint ?uri?g tha intarviaw Talbert wanted ta spaak ta hi5 attarneyg
Hazy-Mayan; ?at? Ma?amaa ?aak $01be?t ant mi tha zaem, calle? hi3
attarnayg an? tal? Maran ?hat-?mlbezt was 13 austa?y ana ta Speak
ta.hara ?at; McNamee gut Taibazt on 
dmas mat what Talbett and Naran.?iscussa?. Ma?amee an?
Tolb&rt retux?ed ta ream Cr For a geriod'?albart did nut want ta Sp?ak
anymare? Qat.-MaNamae left the ream, an? samatima latex Talbert askad
him ta mama back in, Thay'?gake abaut tha'imdidantgaame mare but
Tmlbazt nut want ta giva a statmmant- Bat, gatarman was tmi? 0f the
d?scussiun Bet? Mc?amaa ha? with Talbert; and that was tha en? a? Data
McNamaa?s invalvamant.

in xa?pansa ta specific quastimns, ?etw Me?amee atated.?mlhert nave:
tald him what ha??anad batwaan Talbert and Mr? ?at? mamamaa
stated he hxiafly.5poka ta Maxang about whethex Taibext waul? spaak ta
thaw ahmut tha incatian Qf tha demeasad?s ?aad. Tcl?azt wanted tn sga&k
ta his attaxney bafmxe syeaking ta gets Md?am?e. maran state? aha wa$
net gaing t5 allew ?clba?t ta t?ll them aha laeatign'mf tha h&a&s Bat.
Mm?amaa daes nab re?all tima'that he; Talkertp and Data
$aterman weraiin the zaam tmgathar?-?at, McNamaa mat ha?x 
Eatarman thraat?n ta break Talbert?s jawa Talhart did not tell Dat?
McNamea abaut33at. Pitts hitting him? Bet. Ma?ameaz?aas mat reaall Eat.
having any imt?xacticn with Talbert? ?ata McNamee did mat sea any
injuries an Talbert? ?at, Mc?amea atate? ha did mat speak ta wal?ert an
a latar date abaut his lawyez, 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

?at. Buwaxd ?etexman #3114; Ramiai?a ?nit was intaxviewed an 12w03~1?r
at Entexnal Affaizs by Li, Sandusky ?at. ?eterman s?ate? ha was
assigned a missing per$cn ma?a that was handia? by'Nertheaat
mateativas* Hemicide beaama invalved when tha missing yersan a
hamicide? Qatg Feterman had a hriaf aanvarsatimn with Tmlhart at the
Homicide ?nit? Talbert was eventually arreatad and chaxga? with muzdar;
and plaa? guilty to the same charge.

in xespanse ta spacifia quegtiansg Date Paterman statad ha sgoka t0
Talbert but di? net do any type o? intarview ex interragatian. ?at.
?eterman stata? ha did net xecail telling Talbert ta taka off his
sweatex with a hacdi but he may have dana that, ?at. Qet?xman stated he
wauld hava dane that if Talbext had a drawstring 1% th& swaatar that he
did hat want cut an: of tha sweater. Thay woula d5 this 3Q Talbazt
maul? net hurt himsalf? ?at? gatarman statad Talbart did tall tham
anything abaut Zazzyaki, net? Pataxman state? Talbert di? nah ask
him to centact his lawyar; Mary Maxan? Eat? Satarman stated'ha aid net
tail Talbazt that if ha did not take this saricuslyg that he wauld
bxeak his ?aw, Talbert did not tel: ?at. ?eterman that ?at, ?itts had
hit him.in the face.

Eat. aamaa ?itts Hem$mida wait wag intazviewaa an at
internal ?ffaixa by Lt? Sanduaky Eat. Eitts stated ha reaalled
the hwmicide invelving falbeztg that thara Hera bmdy paxts fauna in the
river, and twa femalas lured the viatim.t0 the apa?tmant far aax. At
sema paint, Talbart an? the female? kiilad tha viatim, and parts mf his
ba?y were amt eff and mi in the rivaz. Bat. ?itt$ statad he
may ha?e spaken ta nae 9r twa cf tha defendants but he aaes not 
anything signifiaant baing said ta him;

En ragganse ta spacifia queationsg ?et* Pitts statad he did mat recall
intarviawing Talhaxt but he may have spaken ta him; Bat. Qitts stated
he ?id mat take Tolbart?3 swaatar him, did mat punch-Talbert in
tha fang, and.?i? mat rub kig knea into Talbert?s armtah araaq ?at,
gitts alsc stated he'did mat tell Taibert ta, ?Shut'the fack up.? ?at.
?i?t5 stated Talbart dia net ask ta he plama? im a xnam with a aamera,
and gang Eitts?di? mat tall Talhart thaxa was a farm ha neaded to sign,
and than rafua?d to ailmw Talb?rt t0 sign the faxm until ha gava-a
Stat?meRt-a -

At the time $?kbaxt was in custadyg 9m4w13, it was mat tha paliay of
the ?hila?elphia $alice Dagartmant ta all custadial
interragatiens @f persoas suspentad 9f Cammitting criminal homicida,
manslaughtar, and ather hamicide r?lated ahaxgasu Fhiladalyhia $mlice
Eeg&rtm&at ?ixaative 151, Interviews and Intarxagatimnsw?ights 8f
individuals and Dutias 0f ?aw En?areemamtg was iaame? an lw?lml?, and
up?a?e? an Qw??ml?g ??aarding t0 Lt, Narman Daveupart #315, ?omimide
Un$t? g?icr ta EQl?f tha aleatranic zacmrdimg mf intarragatimna was
anly dang with-tha written 9f tha suspaatw Thaxa wara only twa
such recardings cm??ucted in tha,?cmicide Emit hetw?a? 2011 and BORE,
an? thexa werewna sacardings ?aua in 2013,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

Telbazt did men give anycne the ?mmicide Gait a statement in
rafaranaa ta tha ?aath a? Frank Zarmyaki. Toihart ?i?ad guilty ta
muxder 9f tha third degzeea annspiracywrahbarywinfliat sariaus hedily
injuryf an? abuse af a corysag an ?wa?w15,

Submittad by;


Fatar San?usky ?38?
Lieutenant

Enteznal ?ffair3 ?ivisian

Raviewed and a?gxmved by:
If 

Car?i Abr?m$j? 

Cagtain

Internal Affairs Eivigimm

 

 

 

 

 

   



@ha allegatimn that ?at; Jamas yitt? 261$18; Hamicide Unit;
yhysiaally an? vmxhally ahuged Kaith yozbart is mm? 

Talbert allegad he was punched in the faca by Eat. ?ittsg and alsc had
his grain araa.massaged by Bat. Pitts knee, Talbart aism alleged Dat?
Pitts cursed at him: Telbezt Siated ha and Eat. ?itts waze tha oaly twa
paeple in the ?60m whan this Bet. Pitta daniad the
allegatimns against him? arrest photeg a? Taibart dm mat Show any
injuzy and ha did nut $eak any madical attentien. This investigatian
Can naithax @tha mar ?isgrave thase aliagatians.

allagatiwn that ?at. ?awax? Fatarman ??124? 33% 180%39, 
wait, thxaatana? ta bxaak ?albaxt?a jaw is 

Taibart state? ?at. Petarman.m??e thia thraat while mat, Mc?amea wag
also in tha ream. Set. gataxman stated ha did mat threaten ta break
Tolbext?s jaw, aa? Eat* Ma?amaa stated ha di? mat haax Bat. Petermam
threaten ta bxaak $leaxt?5 jaw.

A capy cf thia invg$tigaticn will ha farmaxdad ta tha Cammanding
af?icar, Homicide Bait, far zeviewu

       

  

 

Eaurenaa Radi?f
Staff lnspemtar
I?ter?al A?faixs ?ivisiqn