New Orleans Historic District Landmarks Commission Nomination Report General Laundry, Cleaners, and Dyers Building Figure 1. General Laundry, 2017 Meeting Date: July 20, 2017 Property Address: 2525 Lafitte Avenue, 2532-36 St. Peters Street Owner: David Farnsworth Southern Recycling, LLC 902 Julia St. New Orleans, La 70113 Architect: Jones, Roessle, Olschner, and Weiner Construction Date: 1930 Significance: Architectural '4 . a. Figure 2. General Laundry, Le? Pavillion, 1930 Figure 3. Opening Announcement, 1930 General History In 1929, Robert Chapoit commissioned the architectural firm of Jones, Roessle, Olschner, and Weiner to design a new building to replace his laundry business’s older facility which had burned down; Chapoit wanted this new building to be modern, utilitarian, state of the art, and beautiful. Jones, Roessle, Olschner, and Weiner had just completed the Municipal Auditorium in Shreveport.1 Samuel G. Weiner had spearheaded the project, even though he had only recently graduated from the University of Michigan, and the Atelier Gromort, where he studied under Georges Gromort, at L’École Nationale Supérieure Des Beaux-Arts de Paris.2 Weiner had a “fascination in the late 1920s with abstract massing and the decorative potential of brick, terra-cotta, and stone.”3 The Municipal Auditorium is now considered to be one of the best examples of art deco architecture in Louisiana; it was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1991, and was designated as a National Historic (Veneziano 2013), (Bonner 2013), (Anderson 1979) Ibid, Ibid, Ibid. 3 (Historic American Building Survey 2012), (Kingsley 2003) 1 2 3 Figure 4. Door Detail, 2015 Landmark in 2008.4 O.M. Gwin Construction Company were brought on as contractors for the new building; the construction cost was $130,000 and the total cost of the building was $250,000.5 The new General Laundry Cleaners and Dyers building was different than anything else in New Orleans in 1930 and was shocking in its opulence and irreverence. Vibrantly colored and highly ornate, the General Laundry was high style late Art Deco; its ornamentation closely related to the Mayan Revival style popular in the Southwest and West Coast at the time. Through design and presentation, Robert Chapoit capitalized on the depression era taste for grandeur and escapism.6 General Laundry opened May 30, 1930 to great fanfare; five thousand people attended the grand opening, along with state and city officials.7 The visitors toured the business, danced to a live orchestra, ate sandwiches, and “souvenirs were given to the women and children.”8 Robert Chapoit spoke of the “modern laundry and its relationship to the home.”9 In the upcoming years, he threw “style shows,” monthly parties where customers could tour the plant, and mingle with models who were dressed in fabrics laundered at the facility.10 Chapoit wanted to Figure 5. Photo Accompanying National Landmark Nomination, 1974 “show the people of New Orleans what beauty, grace, and attractiveness present-day laundering and proper wearing can be had from home-spun cotton garments of this city.”11 (Venziano 2015, 34) (General Laundry Now Ready! 1930), (Newest Laundry to Open Monday 1930) 6 (Veneziano 2013) 7 (New Laundry Plant Inspected by 5000 1930) 8 Ibid. 9 (Veneziano 2013) 10 Ibid. 11 Ibid. 4 55 4 However, by the 1940’s, sending laundry out to be cleaned was becoming obsolete, with the rise of the in-home washing machine.12 That, coupled with numerous labor disputes, caused Chapoit to sell the business and the building; in December of 1945, a diaper company from New York bought ten plants in New Orleans, including the General Laundry.13 In 1952, that company sold the building to Royal Crown Cola, to be used a bottling plant.14 In September of 1973, RC Cola sold the building to the US Postal Service for $430,000; the post office planned to demolish it to build a parking lot.15 Figure 6. HABS Documentation, Library of Those plans for demolition spurred the community into Congress, 1976 action. Jack Davis, of The States Item newspaper, wrote in 1974, “Would the U.S. Postal Service tear down a beautiful building, a solid building of architectural distinction and fun, just to have a parking lot?”16 Leroy Green, a representative for the Post Office promised, “we would never destroy a building of genuine recognized historic value;” Robert Drew, a project manager at Curtis and Davis, the architectural firm working for the Post Office, assured Mr. Davis that, although he had never seen the building, the laundry was “interesting” but not a landmark.17 The Postal Service insisted that “it is not the policy of the Postal Service to destroy our architectural heritage….(but the General Laundry) was a wretched example of an art form no longer in existence.”18 Arthur Scully, Jr., an architectural historian with the Louisiana Figure 7 Parapet detail, undated. Ibid. Ibid. 14 (Veneziano 2013), (Davis, An Art Deco Marvel Faces Demolition Peril 1974) 15 (Veneziano 2013) 16 (Davis, An Art Deco Marvel Faces Demolition Peril 1974) 17 Ibid. 18 (Davis, Despite Protests, Unique Laundry Coming Down 1974) 12 13 5 Landmarks Society, wrote to warn him that “postal officials (should) not presume to judge what later generations will find valuable.”19 Professor Bernard Lemann, an architectural historian at Tulane, argued that demolition of the building for the sake of “car storage” would be “detrimental.” While Professor Donald Robertson, an art historian, also at Tulane, called the demolition “willful vandalism.”20 The Louisiana Landmarks Society nominated the building for placement on the National Register of Historic Places in 1974. As a compromise with the Postal Service, only the façade was placed on the Register.21 The National Register report is very spare, but states, “The building appears intact with all the Art Deco motifs in their original unfaded color as it was when erected in 1939 (sic). The effect of colors, zigzags, undulations, Aztec-temple motifs, diamonds, sun rises and rhythmic effect of the pilasters has an arresting appearance. lt epitomizes, as does no other Art Deco building in New Orleans…the Art Deco approach of geometric patterns, rich colors and reliance on lndian motifs.”22 The listing Figure 9. Window Detail, 2010 spurred the building’s inclusion into the travelling 1974-1975 American Art Deco Architecture exhibition put together by Finch College in New York.23 The only other building in New Orleans to be included in the exhibition was the National American Bank Building.24 Nonetheless, the Postal Service wanted to see the building demolished; on March 20, 1975, they, and the Advisory Council for Historic Preservation held a public meeting on the matter.25 The States-Item newspaper reported that, “Nearly all those attending the meeting endorsed the preservation of the art deco style façade.”26At that meeting, the Figure 8. Detail, undated Ibid. (Davis, Despite Protests, Unique Laundry Coming Down 1974) (Davis, Save Laundry Facade, Area Residents Ask 1975) 21 (Veneziano 2013) 22 (Louisiana Office of Cultural Development 1974) 23 (Varian 1975) 24 Ibid. 25 (Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Public Information Meeting 1975) 26 (Davis, Save Laundry Facade, Area Residents Ask 1975) 19 20 6 State Historic Preservation Office in Baton Rouge suggested four options, in descending order of desirability: 1) 2) 3) 4) Use of the building by the post office Letting it stand vacant Donating the façade portion (about 20’ deep) to a worthy owner Demolition as a last resort27 The Postal Service voted to defer demolition for another six months after their meeting with the Advisory Council.28 In 1980, the Postal Service sold the building to Richard and Jules Cahn, the owners of the Dixie Mill Supply Company, for $241,300. Southern Scrap Material Co. bought the building in 1986, with the title restriction in place that the “new owners could do nothing to its exterior without first clearing the plans with the State Historic Preservation Office.”29 In 2009, Southern Scrap Material transferred the property to its subsidiary, Southern Recycling, L.L.C.30 In 2010, the building was added to the Louisiana Landmarks Society’s New Orleans’ Nine Most Endangered list in 2010.31 In August of 2014, Southern Recycling, L.L.C. applied to the City of New Orleans for demolition of the building in order to build a new metal warehouse. The application Figure 10. General Laundry, undated for demolition was withdrawn on December 4, 2014. (Arthur Scully 1976) (Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Public Information Meeting 1975) Ibid. 29 (Rainey 2014) 30 (NEW ORLEANS REAL ESTATE TRANSFERS 2009) 31 (Louisiana Landmarks Society 2010) 27 28 7 Figure 11. Detail, 2009 Building Description The General Laundry Cleaners and Dyers building is a two-story, rectangular, stucco over steel-reinforced concrete structure, with two projecting pavilions at either end; the roofline at the façade features an undulating decorative coping made of blue pyramids and stylized flowers. Heavily stylized papapets at the pavillions are festooned with blue, green, and yellow zigzags, topped with green leaves, yellow daisies, jadecolored stylized floral sunbursts, an interlocking basket weave of jade, cornflower blue, and vivid fuschia head casings adorned with “palmettes and anthemiontype motifs.”32 Blue triangles backed by yellow and orange sunbursts crown the windows. A coral and cornflower blue Mesoamerican influenced serpentine figure rests atop and behind the sunbursts. Each pavilion features an entrance to the building, simple sans serif lettering spells out “OFFICE” above one doorway and Figure 12. General Laundry, 2017 “EMPLOYEES” above the other. The original doors and transoms had decorative triangular glass panels in starburst patterns. The doorways are trimmed with fluted yellow tiles which are themselves surrounded by coral blocks; long vertical windows sit atop these entrances, hemmed in 32 (Toledano and Christovich 1980, 188) 8 by slender banded coral fluted tiles. The rectangular structure between the pavilions features two bands of multi-casement windows – the sills of which are adorned with red diamond shaped tiles - separated by pilasters which are topped with jade green tiles in a highly stylized palmette and corn theme.33 Red tiled scuppers boasting an egg-anddart motif dot the roofline under the blue pyramidal coping.34 A course of blue, coral, white, and black tiles in a chevron pattern runs along the bottom of the whole structure. Statement of Significance The Historic District Landmarks Commission evaluates the significance of a structure based on four criteria as established by Section 84.22 of the City Code, any one of which can make a building eligible for nomination. The staff finds that the General Laundry building overwhelmingly meets the criteria for architectural significance, which is defined as any building that embodies “distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or specimen, inherently valuable for a study of period, style, method of construction, or of indigenous materials or craftsmanship.” Figure 13 Window and tile detail, 2017 of those have been either demolished or altered beyond recognition.35 In that inventory, the General Laundry was named “the most outstanding Art Deco building in New Orleans…the detailing is of such high caliber...”36 Indeed, the most striking elements of the building are its brightly colored, polychrome, terra cotta ornamental motifs. The building is adorned with sunbursts, diamonds, 33 34 35 36 A 1980 inventory of Art Deco buildings in New Orleans listed twenty-five notable examples in the city; as of 2017, over half Figure 14. General Laundry Building, wide view, 2008 (Toledano and Christovich 1980, 188) Ibid. (Cangelosi 1980) (Cangelosi 1980, 9) 9 zigzags, waves, pyramids, triangles, arrows, flowers, chevrons, and various other geometric decorative elements.37 The effect is whimsical, startling, bright, and irreverent. This sort of highly detailed art deco architecture, while found in other parts of the country, is exceptionally rare in Louisiana, and is completely unique in New Orleans. While the building has been very poorly maintained, the terracotta is still amazingly vibrant and mostly intact. This building is wholly singular in New Orleans, and is an extremely exciting example of the heights that industrial architecture can achieve. Staff Recommendation Based on the architectural Figure 16. General Laundry, 1930’s Figure 15 General Laundry, 1930's merits of this building, the staff recommends nomination of the General Laundry Cleaners and Dyers building for study as a landmark. Works Cited The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica. "Art Deco." Encyclopædia Britannica. February 2, 2017. https://www.britannica.com/art/Art-Deco (accessed June 12, 2017). Anderson, Lawrence B. "Rereading Gromort." JAE (Taylor & Francis, Ltd.) 33, no. 2 (November 1979): 18-21. Arthur Scully, Jr. "The Latest on the Laundry." Preservation Press, February 1976: 1. Bonner, Judith. "Jones, Roessle, Olschner, and Weiner Firm Years." In The New Encyclopedia of Southern Culture, Art and Architecture ed., by Judith Bonner, edited by Center for the Study of Souther Culture at the University of Mississippi. The University of North Carolina Press, 2013. Cangelosi, Robert J. "Art Deco, part II: the output." Presevation Press of New Orleans, April 20, 1980: 8-9. 37 (Capace 1999, 299) 10 Capace, Nancy. "General Laundry Building." Encyclopedia of Louisiana, January 1, 1999: 569. Davis, Jack. "An Art Deco Marvel Faces Demolition Peril." The States-Item, August 7, 1974: A-15. —. "Despite Protests, Unique Laundry Coming Down." The States-Item, September 11, 1974: A-15. —. "Save Laundry Facade, Area Residents Ask." The States-Item, March 21, 1975: 2. Historic American Building Survey. Municipal Memorial Auditorium. WRITTEN HISTORICAL AND DESCRIPTIVE DATA, Washington, DC: National Park Service, 2012. Jewish Endowment Foundation of Louisiana Annual Report 2013. "Tzedakah Award The Cahn Family." 2013: 4. Kingsley, Karen. Buildings of Louisiana. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003. Louisiana Landmarks Society. "New Orleans 9 Most Endangered Sites 2010." New Orleans: Louisiana Landmarks Society, 2010. Louisiana Office of Cultural Development. General Laundry Building. CRT National Historic Landmark Nomination, Baton Rouge: Louisiana Office of Cultural Development, 1974. New Orleans States. "Newest Laundry to Open Monday." May 23, 1930: 4. Preservation Press of New Orleans. "General Laundry." November 1978: 12. Rainey, Richard. "A New Orleans Historic Art Deco Facade Faces Demolition." The TimesPicayune, November 26, 2014. The Item Tribune. "General Laundry Now Ready!" May 25, 1930: 30-32. The States-Item. "Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Public Information Meeting." March 5, 1975: 47. The Times-Picayune. "New Laundry Plant Inspected by 5000." May 31, 1930: 2. Times-Picayune. "NEW ORLEANS REAL ESTATE TRANSFERS." February 21, 2009: 36. Toledano, Roulhac, and Mary Louise Christovich. New Orleans Architecture. Vol. 4. Gretna, La: Pelican Publishing Company, 1980. Varian, Elayne H. American Art Deco Architecture. New York: Finch College, 1975. 11 Veneziano, Heather. The General Laundry Building of New Orleans. New Orleans: Tulane School of Architecture, 2013. Venziano, Heather. "Art Deco Wonder." Preservation in Print, March 2015: 33-35. Figure Attribution Figure 1. General Laundry, 2017, Author’s Own. Figure 2. Left pavilion, 1930. Venziano, Heather. "Art Deco Wonder." Preservation in Print, March 2015: 33-35. Figure 3. Opening Announcement, 2013, New Orleans Item (Published as The Item Tribune), May 25, 1930. Figure 4. Door Detail, 2015. Venziano, Heather. "Art Deco Wonder." Preservation in Print, March 2015: 33-35. Figure 5. Photo from National Landmark Listing, 1974. HABS photo, Library of Congress, 1976. Figure 6. HABS Documentation, Library of Congress, 1976. http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/la0532/ (assessed June 7, 2017). Figure 7. Cornice Detail, undated. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:General_Laundry_Building,_New_Orlean s#/media/File:General_Laundry_New_Orleans_Corner.jpg (assessed June 29, 2017). Figure 8. Window Detail, 2010. Jennie Peach. http://punkinmonk.blogspot.com/ (assessed June 25, 2017). Figure 9. Detail, undated. Clio and Associates. http://clioassociates.tumblr.com/page/2 (assessed June 29, 2017). Figure 10. Untitled Image, undated. Clio and Associates. http://clioassociates.tumblr.com/page/2 (assessed June 29, 2017). Figure 11. Detail, 2009. Kevin O’Mara. http://www.flickriver.com/places/United+States/Louisiana/New+Orleans/Treme+Lafitte/ search/ (assessed June 28, 2017). Figure 12. General Laundry, 2017, Author’s Own. Figure 13. Window and tile detail, 2017, Author’s Own. 12 Figure 14. General Laundry Building, wide view, 2008. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:General_Laundry_Building,_New_Orlean s#/media/File:MidCityGeneralLaundry18Sept08FromOrleans.jpg (assessed June 29, 2017). Figure 15. Untitled, 1930. Venziano, Heather. "Art Deco Wonder." Preservation in Print, March 2015: 33-35. 13