Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 1 of 13Filed: PageID #:8:05 64AM Filed: 9/15/2017 Juli Luke Denton County, County, County Clerk Hagenbucher, Deputy By: By: Alexa Hagenbucher, CV-2017-02365 CAUSE NO. ____________________ JASON LEE VAN DYKE Plaintiff, v. V. MOCKINGBIRD PUBLISHING CO. and GERARD BELLO II Defendants. §§ §§ §§ §§ §§ §§ §§ §§ IN THE COUNTY COURT AT LAW NO. 22 DENTON COUNTY, TEXAS PLAINTIFF ’8 ORIGINAL PETITION PLAINTIFF’S I. 1.1 1.1 DISCOVERY CONTROL PLAN Discovery in this case 190 of the Texas case is intended to be conducted under level 2 of rule 190 Rules of Civil Procedure. Plaintiff seeks less seeks damages in the amount of $100,000.00 or less including damages of any fees. expenses, pre-judgment interest, and attorney fees. costs, expenses, any kind, costs, II. 2.1 2.1 PARTIES Plaintiff is Jason Lee Van Dyke Whose whose address is 108 108 Durango Drive, Crossroads, TX address is 76227. 2.2 (“Mockingbird”), an Defendant, Mockingbird Publishing Co. (“Mockingbird”), an Ohio Corporation may may be With process by served with by and through its registered agent, Robert Ebright, at 2346 Howey Road, 43211. Road, Columbus, OH 43211. 2.3 (“B6110”), an Defendant, Gerard Bello II (“Bello”), with process process at an individual, may at 675 may be served With Riverview Drive, Apt. B4, Columbus, OH 43202. 43202. 2.4 Subject matter jurisdiction is appropriate because because Plaintiff seeks seeks recovery of monetary Within the jurisdictional limits of this Court. damages within 2.5 Personal jurisdiction is is appropriate as as to the Defendants pursuant to the Texas Long Arm Statute because because Defendants have committed aa tort, in whole or in part, in this state. state. Tex. ORIGINAL PETITION Page of 13 13 Page 11 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 2 of 13 PageID #: 65 Civ. is one 17.042. Specifically, Bello claims to be aa journalist and is CiV. Prac. & Rem. Code § § 17.042. , of the principals of Mockingbird – an Internet website that can be be accessed throughout the United States. This lawsuit stems from aa situation in which Bello published false and defamatory statements about members of the Houston chapter of aa men’s fraternal organization known as as “The Proud Boys”. See See infra ¶ 3.3. Plaintiff is an attorney that 11 wrote aa demand letter to Defendants on behalf of the members of this chapter and others. Rather than cease cease and desist in their publication of false and defamatory statements, Defendants published an article attacking Plaintiff specifically. se specifically. It is for the libel per se contained in that article that Plaintiff now sues. sues. 2.6 Venue is appropriate in this court pursuant to Tex. Civ. 15.017. CiV. Prac. & Rem. Code § § 15.017. III. 3.1 3.1 FACTS Plaintiff is an attorney licensed to practice law in this state as as well as as Colorado, Georgia, and the District of Columbia. Plaintiff’s practice includes the representation of fraternal organizations of which Plaintiff is is aa member. Plaintiff has, has, for example, represented the Delta Phi Chapter of Theta Chi Fraternity Alumni/Housing Corporation in the past. past. Plaintiff is also aa member of aa pro-western men’s fraternal organization known as as “The Proud Boys” and has has assisted individual members of this fraternity in a a variety of legal matters. 3.2 This lawsuit stems from aa demand letter that was was sent by by Plaintiff to Defendants on or around September 5, is attached copy of the demand letter is 5, 2017. A true and correct copy “A” and incorporated by hereto as by reference herein. as Exhibit “A” 3.3 On information and belief, Defendants are associated with aa domestic terrorist collective known as as “Antifa” that prides itself on harassing, defaming, and committing acts of ORIGINAL PETITION 2 of Page of 13 13 Page 2 Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 3 of 13 PageID #: 66 violence persons and groups that espouse Violence against persons espouse conservative groups. In this instance, Defendants wrongfully accused members of the Houston, Texas and Columbus, Ohio chapters of “The Proud Boys” of the following: (a) (a) being “neo-Nazis”; (b) (b) engaging in aa hate crime by mailboxes; (c) by placing hand-drawn swastikas into mailboxes; (c) engaging in “ethnic cleansing” during hurricane relief efforts in the Houston area; area; and (d) (d) roaming the nation in an effort to commit acts be noted in this acts of mass mass murder against minorities. It should be case was present with the Houston Proud Boys during Hurricane Harvey case that Plaintiff was relief efforts and assisted them in rescuing residents in need of evacuation and in the distribution of relief supplies such as as food, bottled water, cleaning supplies, and other items to residents of areas hurricane. areas affected by by the hurricane. 3.4 Plaintiff sent aa demand letter for Defendants to issue aa retraction of these statements (which clearly meet the criteria for defamation per per se) se) and Defendants responded by by “B” on their website. publishing the letter attached hereto as as Exhibit “B” (( Count One: Libel Per Se) Se ) 3.5 3.5 Defendant published the following defamatory statements of fact concerning Plaintiff: (a) (a) Plaintiff is aa white White nationalist, aa nazi, and/or aa neo-nazi; (b) (b) Plaintiff was convicted of weapons charges and domestic Violence; violence; (c) (0) Plaintiff is prohibited under federal law from possessing firearms firearms and is currently in Violation violation of federal law for possessing firearms; firearms; and (d) (d) Plaintiff has has committed professional misconduct through the unauthorized practice of law or through unlawful “forum shopping”. 3.6 The statements published by by Defendant are false. Specifically: Specifically: ORIGINAL PETITION Page of 13 13 Page 3 3 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 4 of 13 PageID #: 67 (a) (a) Plaintiff is white nationalist, aa nazi, aa neo-nazi, is not now, nor has has he ever been, been, aa White or aa member of any affiliated with “national socialism” in any way. any organization affiliated any way. These accusations by by Defendants clearly “injure aa living person’s reputation and thus expose the person to public hatred, contempt, or ridicule, or financial financial injury” and “impeach aa person’s honesty, integrity, Virtue, virtue, or reputation.” Tex. Civ. CiV. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 73.001. (b) (b) Plaintiff has violence. Plaintiff was convicted has never been convicted of domestic Violence. of aa misdemeanor firearm charge while While living in the State of Michigan in 2000. That conviction was legally set by aa court order on or around set aside and expunged by September 28, 28, 2006. Plaintiff has not since been convicted of any any crime other “C” misdemeanor traffic Defendants’ statements to the than Class “C” violations. Defendants’ traffic Violations. contrary falsely charge Plaintiff with the commission of aa crime and constitute libel per se. Assocs. v. se. Leyendecker & Assocs. v. Wechter, Wechter, 683 S.W.2d 369, 369, 374 (Tex. 1 984). 1984). (d) (d) Plaintiff is not prohibited under federal law from possessing firearms, firearms, and thus, his possession of firearms firearms is is not contrary to federal law. In fact, Plaintiff has has a a license to carry issued by is authorized by by the State of Texas and is by the Texas Department of Public Safety to teach the Texas license to carry class. Defendants’ statements impute the commission of aa federal felony to Plaintiff and Defendants’ constitute libel per se. 56. Id. (e) (6) Plaintiff is is not engaged in the unauthorized practice of law in Ohio or any any other state. state. He has has not engaged in forum shopping or committed any any other act with respect to Defendants which constitutes the unauthorized practice of law. ORIGINAL PETITION 4 of Page of 13 13 Page 4 Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 5 of 13 PageID #: 68 Plaintiff is is licensed to practice law in Texas, Texas, Colorado, Georgia, and the District of Columbia. He is is licensed to practice in numerous federal courts including the U.S. Ohio. Accordingly, Defendants’ US. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio. statements have caused injury to Plaintiff in his office, profession, or occupation as as an attorney and constitute libel per se. se. Hancock v. v. Variyam, Variyam, 400 S.W.3d 59, 59, 64 (Tex. 2013). 3.7 It should also be be noted that the published letter contains several other false and defamatory statements. statements. For example, it states that Plaintiff is aa member of the Council for Conservative Citizens. Plaintiff is not now, and has has never been, been, aa member of this organization. white organization. Furthermore, it states that Plaintiff has an account on aa popular White supremacist website known as is also false and as “Stormfront”. While this statement is defamatory, Plaintiff has se. These has chosen to limit this lawsuit to his claims for libel per se. two accusations do not meet the statutory definition definition of libel. They are, are, however, relevant to demonstrating that Defendants have acted with negligence at at the very least, least, if not actual malice. 3.8 This is is a a claim for defamation per se 56 against a a media defendant over a a matter of private Plaintiff’ s damages are concern. Accordingly, Plaintiff’s are presumed. IV. 4.1 4.1 PRAYER thati Plaintiff prays that— a. a. Defendants be be cited to appear and answer; b. b. Plaintiff be be granted judgment for nominal damages, damages, plus general damages in the amount of at least $60,000.00; c. 0. Plaintiff be be granted judgment for prejudgment and postjudgment interest at the highest legal or contractual rate allowed by by law; ORIGINAL PETITION Page of 13 13 Page 5 5 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 6 of 13 PageID #: 69 d. d. Plaintiff be be granted judgment for all costs of court; and e. 6. Plaintiff be be granted all further relief to which Plaintiff may may be entitled. Respectfully submitted, /s/ Jason Lee Van Dyke Jason L. Van Dyke State Bar No. 24057426 108 108 Durango Drive Crossroads, TX 76227 P7 P – (469) (469) 964-5346 F 7– (972) (972) 421-1830 Email: jason@vandykelawfirm.com ORIGINAL PETITION Page of 13 13 Page 6 6 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 7 of 13 PageID #: 70 “A” EXHIBIT “A” Page 7 Page 0f 13 13 7 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 8 of 13 PageID #: 71 Jason L. Van Dyke Atiorney & Counselor at Law Licensed in Texas, Colorado, Georgia and The Dislricl ol'Cqmhiu September 5, 2017 Mockingbird Publishing Co. and Gerard Belle 11 2346 Howey Road Columbus, OH 4321 via CMRRR N0. 7016 2710 0000 9323 9190 and First Class US. Mail 1 NOTICE OF INTENT TO FILE LAWSUIT Dear Mr. Bello: This firm represents the Dallas/Ft. Worth and Houston chapters of The Proud Boys and this correspondence constitutes notice of their intent to file a lawsuit against you for the false and defamatory article authored by you and published by Mockingbird Publishing Co. a/k/a The Mockingbird titled “Nee-Nazi Group Targets Residents in South Campus Area”. My firm will also be associating with lawyers from Ohio to obtain damages on behalfof Ohio chapters of The Proud Boys that were libeled by your article. Specifically, your article contains the following false and defamatory statements: (1) The article falsely states that The Proud Boys are a “Nee-Nazi Group”; (2) The article falsely states that members of the Houston chapter were flashing “white power” or “nazi” hand signs (the article contains a photograph of members of the Houston chapter carrying guns, but not flashing any hand signs reasonably associated with “white power” or national socialism); (3) The article falsely states that the Ohio Proud Boys placed hand-drawn swastikas into mailboxes and mail slots in an attempt at unlawful intimidation; (4) The article falsely states that the Ohio Proud Boys were in Houston, when in fact, the only chapters providing hum'cane relief in Houston were from the Houston, Dallas/Ft. Worth, San Antonio, Austin, and Miami chapters; (5) The article falsely states that the fraternity members who undertook an anti-looting patrol were performing “ethnic cleansing"; and I08 Durango Drive Crossroads, TX 76227 P — (469) 96-6-5346 F — (972) 421-1830 jnsonoflvandykela\\1‘ rm.com Page of 13 13 Page 8 8 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 9 of 13 PageID #: 72 (6) The article falsely states that The Proud Boys are roaming the nation trying to shoot people. While I would normally permit a publication such as yours the opportunity to make a correction and issue a retraction, it’s clear from the context of the article and your willful disregard for the facts that making such a demand will be fruitless. Accordingly, demand is for you and Mockingbird Publishing Co. to immediately and permanently remove the offending article. Second, demand is made for you and Mockingbird Publishing Co. to cease and desist all fiJture false and defamatory articles conceming any chapter ofThc Proud Boys. Finally, demand is also made to payment in the amount of$]0,000.00 in damages to “The Proud Boys” as full and final settlement of the damages to the reputations of those depicted by your article to the organization as a whole and its individual members. Please direct your payment to this office. You must either comply with all of the demands contained herein within founeen (14) of your receipt of this letter, or in the alternative, provide my office with a reasonably time frame by which you will comply. Should you fail to do so, I have been authorized to initiate a days lawsuit against you. ‘ I son L. Van Dyke Attorney & Counselor at Law 108 Durnugo Drive Crossroads, TX 7627.7 P — (469) 964—5346 F — (972) 421-1830 jasoa'nndykclnwfirmmum Page of 13 13 Page 9 9 of Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 10 of 13 PageID #: 73 “B” EXHIBIT “B” Page 10 Page 13 10 of 0f13 White Nationalist Lawyer Threatens the Mockingbird with Lawsuit. Lawsuit. Rea... Case Mockingbird Paper (/) Pager (I) 110f3 of 3 http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer-thre... http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer—thre... 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 11 of 13 PageID #: 74 MENU THE MOCKWGBIRD .ILL THE NEWS THAT'S FIT TU PROVE )1 HOME (/) WHITE NATIONALIST WITH LAWSUIT. NAT‘ONAL‘ST LAWYER THREATENS THE MOCKINGBIRD MOCK‘NGB‘RD W‘TH LAWSU‘T READ OUR RESPONSE RESPONSE (I) /I WH‘TE White Nationalist Lawyer Threatens the Mockingbird with Lawsuit. Read Our Response Author: Autho Gerry Icontentlgerm-bello) Germ Bello (/content/gerry-bello) F pram-am ,Tweel ‘ I (http://www.heise.de (http://www.heise.de IcUarlikeIIZ-Klicks/ct/artikel/2-Klicksinvestigative effectiveness sh back and spin. There is no better push push back the threat of a effective fuer-mehrconfirmsjournalistic Nothing confirms journalistic integrity and investigative like push Ema”; frivolous lawsuit. A frivolous lawsuit has no purpose intimidate,,'and t Datenschutznd to drain resources when itit is used in in an attempt to purpose other than to 1333879.html) a prospect head head on, urglass sand and treasure, silence the press. Facing such a thing for aa new properthing treasure, is the proper o the cost in hourglass on, regardless of source to do. do. It is what is expected of if we are to defend the public trust that is placed in us to find and report the truth. source (http://www.mockinqbirdpaper.com/contentlneo-nazi-qroup-tarqetsA recent article about neo-nazi activity in in the OSU campus camgus area (http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/neo-nazi-group-targetsresidents-south-camgus-area1 has given the Mockingbird, trust. The article, chance to earn to that public trust. residents-south-campus-area) Mockingbird, and myself personally, personally, a chance “Proud Boys”, Boys", elicited our first actual cease and desist letter, which is concerning the not proud enough to sign their swaztika fliers “Proud is in short, are (1) included for reader download at the bottom of this article. Their demands, in ofthis (1) Make the article go away (2) (2) Don't write about No. No. No. And No. us again (3) (3) Gimme $10,000. The answer is going to be No. Later today, or tomorrow, September 15th, following letter will be sent officially as a iflI feel like it, a response. Our dedicated readers ortomorrow, 151h, if it, the following in Texas officially. L. Van Dyke wish to evade service of chance to enjoy it long before it arrives in ofaa should have a chance officially. Should Mr. Jason L. registered letter, from his actions that Mr. a newspaper for him to enjoy. It is clear constitutes the publishing of an open letter in a clearfrom letter, this article constitutes in a a letter. Van Dyke monitors this publication publication as well as any internet address associated with this author, as will also be outlined in Forthe Proud Boys, the letter begins now: For the Enjoyment of the reader and the edification of the Proud L. Van Dyke esquire, Dear Mr. Jason L. letter dated the 5th Through our statutory agent we received your letter 51h of September 2017. 201 7. We have read your objections to our work, and your demands to cease and desist. After that we had a a long hardy belly laugh. The letter has been shown to attorneys with which we have an ongoing relationship in free speech suggested that II not pay relationship and specialize in speech law. They suggested you actually bring suit as they pay them until you batting average when are fully confident II can handle you 100% batting you and this action without much help from them. Just so you you know, II have a 100% appearing Pro-Se in federal labor court, State Court in in Ohio and State Court in Texas as both plaintiff and defendant, defendant, both civil and criminal. Since you alleging Libel, please do realize that we are familiar with the relevant case law. That would be New York V Sullivan Times V. York Times you are alleging Ohio" II can assume that you “associating with attorneys in and derivative cases under federal, Texas and Ohio law. Since you in Ohio” you claim to be “associating you in the Northern District of Texas, the are still confused about venue, venue, and can not decide if you you are going to bring your so-called action in Southern District of Ohio, or the State Courts of either Texas or Ohio. Are you based on judges? you shopping based on case law or based is to sue Mockingbird Publishing Publishing and myself in State Court in in Texas. It is is not clear what exactly you Perhaps your threat is twice, once in myselftwice, you intend to do other than silence the free press and collect a a hefty payday. happen. payday. Neither of those things will ever happen. “Proud Nee-Nazis. What you One of the your core allegations is that the so-called Proud Boys are not Neo-Nazis. is that you a “Proud you failed to disclose is you are a Boy" yourself, is included profile. A screenshot of said profile profile is Boy” yourself, of the third degree, or at least that you you claim to be so on your Facebook profile. below. Are you under contract with the Proud Boys? Are you in house counsel? you under you acting as their in 1 1 of Page of 13 13 Page 11 9/15/2017, 7:58 AM White Nationalist Lawyer Threatens the Mockingbird with Lawsuit. Lawsuit. Rea... 220f3 of 3 http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer-thre... http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer-thre. .. Case o 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 12 of 13 PageID #: 75 Inigo mumu anu shuclw Siudcmu! man Tram Cm Lam-u. Wawr‘ B a. an cmu l9 Buy- You claim to be representing or finding finding representation for Proud Boys in Ohio. Proud Boys, as a a legal entity, as opposed opposed to an informal informal Boys in in Ohio. Persons claiming claiming membership have committed various acts of low low grade intimidation here, but they association, do not exist in have have not filed any threatening a a lawsuit in in one, possibly two venues for a a client any paperwork with the Secretary of State's office. You are threatening “association with" in “association that has no corporate existence in with” lawyers lawyers you do not care to name. Sir, you are a lawyer demanding monetary damages for articles written in in another state where you not admitted admitted to the bar on behalf of a a group of anonymous clients that have you are not no no way of retaining retaining you. For that, you nothing but a a copy of this letter sent to the Texas bar association. association. you get nothing Fort Worth Chapter (assuming II can only assume that your basis for any action would be your own personal affiliation with The Dallas Fort neo-nazis. You you affiliation of yours is an element of proof that the Proud Proud Boys are in in fact neo-nazis. you joined the closest one to you). you). This personal affiliation sir, are a nazi. This makes your clients, when they are your close political affiliates, nazis as well. Basic time your were in Basic research noted your 2000 arrest and conviction on weapons charges and domestic violence. violence. At that time in possession semi-fictional terrorist manual. You also had a aa of the Turner Zion, a Turner Diaries, a a neo-nazi semi-fictional a copy of the Protocols of of the Elders of a classic of oion, anti-Semitic forgery. The former book was written by by the late William Pierce, the former head of the National Alliance. That man was an self-described Hitlerian. There is unapologetic unapologetic and self-described is a a direct line from you him to George Lincoln Rockwell, Rockwell, who actually wore you through him swastika armbands. You is a known white supremacist organization, Conservative Citizens, which is swastika You were also a member of the Council of Conservative organization, albeit one lacking the more jackboots uniforms. more traditional robes and / or orjackboots How How you came to pass the bar fitness fitness exam with a a domestic violence conviction and a a weapons conviction is is a a mystery is mystery to me. What is in possession of firearms, much less claim to be an instructor with said convictions. Is Is the ATF aware also a mystery is how you can be in firearms, much of your apparent violations of federal firearms firearms while under disability. firearms law? You appear, on social media, in possession of offirearms media, to be in regarding the repeal repeal of certain certain firearms laws, on the neo-nazi website Stormfront, II also noted a post regarding WNLaw. II Stormfront, by by a profile called WNLaw. assume the WN WN stands forWhite for White Nationalist as opposed to What Now. This appears to be you. Is Is this you? Are you you rambling on about neo-nazi website some ill-conceived petition website while claiming that you and your friends are not petition drive so you can legally have guns on a a neo-nazi I'm just doing my neo-nazis? Did Did II get that right? I'm diligence here... since you seem to insist. neo-nazis? my due diligence Your claims in short are without merit. Since this letter letter may colorful may well be evidence some day II will spare the judge and the jury more colorful language describing the deficit deficit of merit your claims, and you language you as a human being, seem to lack. Ilam am going to assume that the letter should be delivered to 108 108 Durrango Drive as it is is on your letterhead as your office. That is a a lovely home home that doubles as your office. office. I see that you you and your father teamed up to buy that nice little foreclosure and benefit somehow from 2011. II guess bottom feeding runs in your family. the sub-prime mortgage crisis in 2011. I welcome am prepared, welcome your suit should you it. Ilam a number of firms who would be be pleased to prepared, and so are a you be foolish enough to file it. motivated their requests for participation. II personally do not represent me against you. Both my buffoonery, have motivated my friendship, and your buffoonery, take well to threats. Threatening Threatening me is is like attempting attempting coitus with a a garbage garbage disposal. disposal. It is is pointless, painful and makes you you look more ridiculous on the internet than you already were. were. Should you bring your suit it will be noted that II do have a cause of action against you as well, along with your anonymous anonymous clients. Your post to my fundraiser was proximate to so-called “shitposting” by my recent gofundme fundraiserwas by people II can only assume are also Proud Boys in house" then purchase my standing. The one who said he would sooner “slam his dick in a car door while leaving the keys in in the house” good standing. my latest book was a a real winner. winner. You, and your neo-nazi associates directly interfered with my the guise of political opposition. Since your goal was the underthe my business under speech." press organization organization we will not not dignify your conduct with the term “free speech.” shutdown of a press The threats and the harassment harassment will cease now. There will be no further contact from you. Good Day Sir, Sir, Gerry Bello Publisher and Editor in Chief Publishing Mockingbird Publishing BarAssociation Association, Colorado State Bar Association, Association, Georgia State Bar CC: Texas State Bar Association, Association Associated Documents: Documents: etler.pdf (http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/sites/default/files/van%20dyke%20letter.pdf) (http://www.mockinqbirdpgper.com/sites/defauIUfiles/van%20dvke%20letter.Qdfl dvke letter.pdf .4 van dyke Tags: Tags: - white supremacists sugremacists (/tags/white-supremacists) ltags/white—sugremacists) 12 of Page of 13 13 Page 12 9/15/2017, 7:58 AM White Nationalist Lawyer Threatens the Mockingbird with Lawsuit. Lawsuit. Rea... 33 of of33 http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer-thre... http://www.mockingbirdpaper.com/content/white-nationalist-lawyer—thre... Proud Boys (/tags/proud-boys) ltags/Qroud-boys) o Censorship Censorshig (/tags/censorship) ltags/censorshig) - Fail (/tags/fail) flags/fail Case 2:17-cv-00745-JRG Document 2 Filed 11/16/17 Page 13 of 13 PageID #: 76 o reserved. © 2017 Mockingbird Paper All rights reserved. Page 13 13 of 0f13 Page 13 9/15/2017, 7:58 AM