Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:16:39 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: FW: You're invited to Future Leaders Event: Seismic Shifts - (Mar 10, 2016) Date: Thursday, August 24, 2017 at 3:13:11 PM Central Daylight Time From: Liz Caldwell To: Mindy Stitt From: Liz Caldwell Sent: Wednesday, March 09, 2016 11:51 AM To: Terra Argo Subject: FW: You're invited to Future Leaders Event: Seismic Shifts - (Mar 10,2016) Liz Caldwell OERB Environmental Coordinator 405-601-2630 From: Natalie Kinmonth [maiItozinvite@eventbrite.com] Sent: Wednesday, February 17, 2016 11:32 AM To: Liz Caldwell Subject: You're invited to Future Leaders Event: Seismic Shifts - (Mar 10, 2016) Hello, You are invited to the following event: FUTURE LEADERS EVENT: SEISMIC SHIFTS - THE EARTHQUAKE DEBATE PANEL Event to be held at the following time, date, andloca?on: . Thursday, March 10, 2016 from 5:00 PM to at"; msren-tepmv. (Manna; 2mm we.? 7 30 CST) . OIPA - Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 Northeast 4th Street 3rd Floor Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Page 1 of 3 View Map . Fumes .. P. ?Ma #71113] ?12: Seismic Shifts Combating misconceptions in Oklahoma '5 earthquake debate Join the ()liRB and industry leaders for an exclusive event on March 10th at Legacy Hall. In partnership with the the free event features a conversation with industry experts about seismicity. l?rom social media to community outreach and media relations. there are plenty of opportunities for the industry?s future leaders to join the effort to combat misperceptions that exist within our own networks. Bring a colleague and enjoy free cocktails and hors d?oeuvres as we reveal the latest on seismicity, plus receive free resources to join the grassroots movement to promote the essential role that industry plays in all of our lives. Seating is limited. Reservations required for all attendees. PANEL INCLUDES: Kim Hatfield; President of Crawley Petroleum serves as Chairman of the OIPA Induced Seismicity Committee Page 2 of 3 Paul Brothers; President Executive Creative Director of Brothers Company the ad agency of record for OERB Kristin Hincke; Stakeholder Relations Supervisor at Devon Energy serves on the OERB Public Education Committee Sponsored by: Light Snacks and cocktails provided We hope you can make it! Cheers, Natalie Kinmonth Ev-rrit in: ?l his invitation was sen? to loaldwellfifCoet?l.) com by Natalie the, organmzr w, by To stop receiving invitations this orgasmizer you can I o~ I Evenimmte Eventbnie lnc. i 155 5th 31. 7th Floor Dan Francisco. (A 94103 Page 3 of 3 From: Liz Caldwell Sent: Monday, November 23, 2015 3:56 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject:RE: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Iill help! Liz Caldwell OERB Environmental Coordinator 405?601?2630 From: Mindy Stitt Sent: Monday, November 23, 2015 3:41 PM To: Natalie Kinmonth Lauren Burnett Cheryl Standage Hayley Kennon Liz Caldwell Steve Sowers Brandi Biggs Marcy Davis Carla Schaeperkoetter Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Terra Argo Subject: Fw: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition We need volunteers to read (in front of a camera) mean tweets about the oil and gas industry from 2:00 4:00 on Wednesday, December 2. Please let me know if you are available. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601?2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Holly Gray Date: Monday, November 23, 2015 at 3:28 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Can we video people reading mean tweets on 12/2 from 2?4? H0 LL GR AY Accou nt Super visor 405.60 0.7855 i broc o.com The information in this email and any attachments may contain proprietary and confidential information that is intended only for the addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, distribution or copying of this information is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately contact the sender and delete the e?mail (and any attachments). On Nov 19, 2015, at 3:17 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: I will be out a big part of both days, but we should have quite a few people here. If you can give me a definitive time, I will email the staff to see who would be willing to be video taped. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405?601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Holly Gray Date: Thursday, November 19, 2015 at 2:16 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Great! Do you think we could video on 12/1 or 12/2? It wouldnit be too intrusive. We could set up on the 3rd floor or in one of the empty office spaces and pull people in one at a time. It wouldnit take any more than 5?10 minutes a person. I can see this being very entertaining! HO LL GR AY Accou nt Super visor 405.60 0.7855 1 broc o.com The information in this email and any attachments may contain proprietary and confidential information that is intended only for the addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, distribution or copying of this information is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately contact the sender and delete the e?mail (and any attachments). On Nov 19, 2015, at 1:55 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: Letis do this deal! It will be fun. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405?601?2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Holly Gray Date: Thursday, November 19, 2015 at 11:00 AM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Mindy, Per our phone conversation, I am proposing that we produce a iMean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Editioni for use in the December public education committee meeting. The video has two primary objectives: ?Showcase the reality of public sentiment via social media -Illustrate the type of content that resonates with millennials Jimmy Kimmel produces a series of iMean Tweeti videos in which celebrities read aloud mean things that have been said about them via twitter. It showcases just how utterly insane and outspoken the public can be behind a computer screen, but the reaction of the celebrities is very entertaining. Here is a link to Jimmy Kimmelis iMean Tweeti (I think the Country Stars and NBA, NFL versions are the best). The idea is to have staff to read imean tweetsi about the oil and gas industry. Below is just a small sample of some of those tweets. This would not be published publicly - internal use only! Sample Tweets Donit ever live in Oklahoma. Fracking cause earthquakes and contaminated water. Ainit ever gonna stop. Might as well change @OKCThunder 2 OKC earthquakes. Another earthquake in Oklahoma this morning. Pretty sure fracking sucks. #fracking Just disgusted that Oklahoma and Texas keeps electing dirty energy lovers, pollution lovers, pollution lovers climate denial idiots! Sweet lord I am ready for younger minds to hit critical mass and be the thought leaders. This shit is embarrassing! #frackingsucks Please let me know your thoughts and weill proceed accordingly. Thank you, Holly H0 LL GR AY Accou nt Super visor 405.60 0.7855 1 broc o.com The information in this email and any attachments may contain proprietary and confidential information that is intended only for the addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, distribution or copying of this information is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately contact the sender and delete the e?mail (and any attachments). From: Liz Caldwell Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2016 10:49 AM To: Holly Gray; Steve Sowers Cc: Ashley Barcum; Dara McBee Subject: RE: Restoration Submissions From March 16th, 2015 June 7th, 2015 Hi Holly, From my records it looks like 119. If you need it the breakdown is below March 7 on?24 April?49 May-36 Until June 7?10 Let me know if you need anything else! Liz Caldwell OERB Environmental Coordinator 405?601?2630 From: Holly Gray Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2016 9:18 AM To: Steve Sowers Liz Caldwell Subject: Restoration Submissions From March 16th, 2015 - June 7th, 2015 Hi Steve and Liz, Iim planning for the 2016 restoration campaign launch and am in the process of setting some goals. Is there any way you can tell me how many landowner submissions the OERB received between March 16, 2015 to June 7th, 2015? It looks like there were 85 online submissions through Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, Holly H0 LL GR AY Accou nt Super visor 405.60 0.7855 1 broc o.com The information in this email and any attachments may contain proprietary and confidential information that is intended only for the addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, distribution or copying of this information is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately contact the sender and delete the e?mail (and any attachments). Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:00:13 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Allison on earthquakes Date: Thursday, February 25, 2016 at 2:56:00 PM Central Standard Time From: Mindy Stitt To: Mike Terry CC: JEREMY FITZPATRICK, Carla Schaeperkoetter, Terra Argo We are adding the discussion to the agenda. We'll look at the issue from a broader perspective. Mindy Stitt Sent from my iPhone On Feb 25, 2016, at 2:47 PM, Mike Terry wrote: Guys, My thoughts are a little more broad in scope. The problem is not the students, it's the parents and the teachers. We also need something for teachers so they won't just regurgitate what they read and see in the media. I haven't ?gured out what that is but I would hope the committee would look at the problem from a broader perspective. MET Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 On 2/25/16 12:55 PM, ?Mindy Stitt" wrote: Hi Jeremy, Thank you for sharing this information. We have a scholastic outreach committee meeting coming up soon. I will bring this up and see if we can?t revamp/add to our Petro Pro presentation to include some factual information about seismicity. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com On 2/25/16, 8:55 AM, wrote: My six year old daughter came home from school yesterday and told me about earthquakes. I know we've discussed strategies in several meetings, but I wonder if we could send PetroPros to schools and incorporate a discussion about natural phenomena and possibility (or speci?c occasions) where injection wells might contribute to or be a factor in causing "tremors" (not earthquakes). I couldn't believe this, but it became very real to me when I heard MY daughter tell me about this - as a matter of fact! I presume lots of kids are talking about earthquakes at school (felt them the night before), and we need to get in there and help educate or the next generation is going to conclude that our industry is the cause of every seismic event that they feel. In my opinion, that fear and uncertainty (especially for school children) will turn into negative public opinion about our industry. By the way, I volunteer to do this but I need to get some PetroPro training. I haven?t heard as much about that program lately, but perhaps I'm just not paying attention. We need to deploy the troops. Page 1 of Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:00:44 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Date: Tuesday, November 24, 2015 at 8:27:35 AM Central Standard Time From: Mindy Stitt To: Carla Schaeperkoetter Thanks. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Carla Schaeperkoetter Date: Monday, November 23, 2015 at 3:42 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Even though I hate being on camera..l think this will be really funny, so I?m in! Carla Schaeperkoetter Education Director OERB 500 NE 4th St., Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 P: 405.601.2715 E: cschae@oerb.c0iu From: Mindy Stitt Date: Monday, November 23, 2015 at 3:40 PM To: Natalie Kinmonth Lauren Burnett Cheryl Standage Hayley Kennon Liz Caldwell Steve Sowers Brandi Biggs Marcy Davis Carla Schaeperkoetter Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Terra Argo Subject: FW: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition We need volunteers to read (in front of a camera) mean tweets about the oil and gas industry from 2:00 4:00 on Wednesday, December 2. Please let me know if you are available. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com Page 1 of 4 From: Holly Gray Date: Monday, November 23, 2015 at 3:28 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Can we video people reading mean tweets on 12/2 from 2-4? rwc?ounl supervisor J) 405 600 7855. On Nov 19, 2015, at 3:17 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: I will be out a big part of both days, but we should have quite a few people here. Ifyou can give me a de?nitive time, I will email the staff to see who would be willing to be video taped. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Holly Gray Date: Thursday, November 19, 2015 at 2:16 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Great! Do you think we could video on 12/1 or 12/2? It wouldn't be too intrusive. We could set up on the 3rd ?oor or in one of the empty of?ce spaces and pull people in one at a time. It wouldn?t take any more than 5-10 minutes a person. Page 2 of 4 I can see this being very entertaining! - biococom On Nov 19, 2015, at 1:55 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: Let?s do this deal! It will be fun. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Holly Gray Date: Thursday, November 19, 2015 at 11:00 AM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Mean Tweets Oil and Natural Gas Edition Mindy, Per our phone conversation, I am proposing that we produce a ?Mean Tweets - Oil and Natural Gas Edition? for use?in the December public education committee meeting. The video has two primary objectives: -Showcase the reality of public sentiment via social media -l ustrate the type of content that resonates with millennials Jimmy Kimmel produces a series of ?Mean Tweet? videos in which celebrities read aloud mean things that have been said about them via twitter. It showcases just how utterly insane and outspoken the public can be behind a Page 3 of 4 computer screen, but the reaction of the celebrities is very entertaining. Here is a link to Jimmy Kimmel?s ?Mean Tweet? (i think the Country Stars and NBA, NFL versions are the best). The idea is to have staff to read ?mean tweets? about the oil and gas industry. Below is just a small sample of some of those tweets. This would not be published publicly internal use only! Sample Tweets Don?t ever live in Oklahoma. Fracking cause earthquakes and contaminated water. Ain?t ever gonna stop. Might as well change @OKCThunder 2 OKC earthquakes. Another earthquake in Oklahoma this morning. Pretty sure fracking sucks. #fracking Just disgusted that Oklahoma and Texas keeps electing dirty energy lovers, pollution lovers, pollution lovers climate denial idiots! Sweet lord I am ready for younger minds to hit critical mass and be the thought leaders. This shit is embarrassing! #frackingsucks Please let me know your thoughts and we?ll proceed accordingly. Thank you, Holly supervisor z) broco {tom Page 4 of 4 Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:01:30 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Ellis?brace yourself Date: Monday, August 25, 2014 at 9:33:01 AM Central Daylight Time From: Avery Smith To: Ellis Stromberg, Regina Mullennix, Cody Bannister, Lauren Burnett, Natalie Kinmonth, Carla Schaeperkoetter, Mindy Stitt Attachments: Wine_3.jpg, Wine_2.jpg, wine_1.jpg, Wine_4.jpg These pics might send you into convulsions. So much lost opportunity! Damn you, Napa earthquake! Avery Smith Vice-President of Business Development Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 NE. 4th St. Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: 405-601-2828 Cell: 405-436-0547 Fax: 405-942-4636 '4 Page 1 of 1 Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:01:40 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: fracking Date: Thursday, July 31, 2014 at 2:08:30 PM Central Daylight Time From: Mike Terry To: Carla Schaeperkoetter Attachments: Thanks From: Carla Schaeperkoetter Date: Thursday, July 31, 2014 12:49 PM To: Mike Terry Subject: Re: fracking Mike, I heard back from E-Tech about blocking this email address. They said that you will need to block it from your Outlook account. They sent these directions on how to do it. If you have any trouble, let me know and I can come up and give it a try. lt you want to stop receiving e-mail trom someone, you can add his or her e-mail address to your blocked senders list. Outlook automatically mover-5 any new mail that you receive trom this person to the Junk E-mail folder. When you want to receive mail from this person again. you can remove his or her email address or domain from your blocked senders list. Do any of the tollowing' In the message list. select a message {rum the sender whom vou want to block. On the Home tab. click Junk and then click Block Sender RUles time Move .- swat.? a" 133mm: v- Outlook adds the sender?s e-mail address to the blocked senders list. You can restore any of the mail that IS in the Junk E-mail folder. Click the message that you want to move to the int-ox folder and then on the Home tab, click Junk, and then click Mark as Not Junk. Carla Schaeperkoetter Education Director OERB P: 405.601.2715 E: From: Mike Terry Date: Wednesday, July 30, 2014 at 1:01 PM To: Carla Schaeperkoetter Cc: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: fracking Thanks! Sent from my iPhone On Jul 30, 2014, at 12:48 PM, "Carla Schaeperkoetter" wrote: we can block him. I will send an email to E-Tech and have them add him to our block list. Page 1 of 2 Carla Schacperkaener Educanon nueuor OERB P. 405.601 2715 E: udmcfi curb tom From: Mlke Terry com> Date: Wednesday, My 30, 2014 at 1239 PM Tn: Carla Schaeperkoetter Cc: Mmdy sun Subject: FW: {racking Carla, This week I've been recewmg multiple emays nom < Subject: frackmg here's some more data eanhquake-connectionece Page 2 of 1 Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:01:55 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Thanks for your time today Date: Wednesday, July 9, 2014 at 7:29:23 PM Central Daylight Time From: Mike Harris To: Mike Terry CC: Carla Schaeperkoetter, John Brett, Chelsey Jones Attachments: image003.png, 7.23.14 TECHNICAL LUNCHEON Dear Mike, We got much more than we had hoped for in our trip to see your facility this afternoon. We so appreciated your spending time with us and look forward to establishing a solid working relationship between the and the OCGS. We will dedicate another meeting to determine our path forward with regard to the earthquake response situation. This can be a topic of discussion at our July 31St board meeting. Attached is the announcement about our July 23rd luncheon featuring Glen Brown's earthquake presentation. You will be our guest for lunch that day I just need your con?rmation that you will be attending. And as we discussed, please invite Todd Hiett who will be our guest as well. John is reaching out to Dana Murphy. Thanks again, and we?ll see you in a few weeks. Mike Harris, CEO Oklahoma City Geological Society 120 N. Robinson, Suite 900 Center Oklahoma City, OK 73102 (405) 235?3648 ext. 19 (405) 206-9771 (mobile) ?it HW- i3 mags? OKLAHOMA CITY OOIGAL 800117? ?Connecting, educating and equipping today?s geoscientists? Page 1 of 1 Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:03:37 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: You're invited to Future Leaders Speaker Event: (Mar 10, 2016) Date: From: To: Tuesday, February 23, 2016 at 12:10:09 PM Central Standard Time Natalie Kinmonth Carla Schaeperkoetter Hello Carla, You are invited to the following event: l? if.- Event to be held at the following time, a. 2' date and location- a . .4 - I 51104:!? Thursday, March 10, 2016 from in?; . . . . 2? 5.00 PM to 7.30 PM (CST) - ?new". .5 . . i OIPA Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 Northeast 4th Street 3rd Floor Oklahoma City, OK 73104 2 . 0 Event registration is by invitation only. Register with your email address to attend this event. Page 1 of 3 i 9393?; . - Ar: e. do: 31mm? m5: n: . L;rrm3- mutton; lxostedpyi?? FUTURE Ht 1! 'rm . i, iT?fix' 2 .hr'l Future Leaders Event. Energy Engagement Join the OERB, OIPA and industry leaders for an exclusive event on March 10th at Legacy Hall from 5:30 to 7:30 pm. In partnership with the OERB, the free event features industry and communications experts discussing how we engage in conversations about the issues that impact the oil and natural gas industry. Bring a colleague and enjoy free cocktails and hors d?oeuvres, network with other industry advocates - plus receive free resources to join the grassroots movement to promote the essential role that industry plays in all of our lives. Seating is limited. Reservations required for all attendees. FEATURED SPEAKERS: Kim Hatfield; President of Crawley Petroleum serves as Chairman of the OIPA Induced Seismicity Committee Paul Brothers; President Executive Creative Director of Brothers Company the ad agency of record for OERB Sponsored by: Page 2 of 3 We hope you can make it! Cheers, Natalie Kinmonth umtatirm was sent to by the (:u'gamrer Event on: mJ urn! mum; r: I Fa: mm :3 ?ven?b?ta To 5:10;) rewavmg :nvutations from this ovgamzer. yen can Ugey?griige. Inc 9 155 5th 81, 71h Floor San CA 94103 Page 3 of 3 Tuesday, August 29, 2017 at 8:04:13 AM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Future Leaders Event Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2016 at 9:14:08 AM Central Standard Time From: Lauren Burnett To: Carla Schaeperkoetter, Dara McBee, Ashley Barcum, Natalie Kinmonth Attachments: C2746BS7-FOD4-4AD3-ACAE- Good idea! The more the merrier! Kindest Regards, Lauren Burnett Events Director OIPA 500 NE 4th, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Officez405-942-2334 Direct2405-601?2770 Cellz405-570-1684 Iburnett@oipa.com I a l? '1 ?294.! Wk? . 3 ml ION From: Carla Schaeperkoetter Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2016 at 9:12 AM To: Lauren Burnett Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Natalie Kinmonth Subject: Re: Future Leaders Event Perfect! I will tell them to contact me if they are interested, and I will send you all that list. There probably won?t be very many, since they would be coming from Norman, Stillwater and Tulsa, but I just thought I would throw it out there. Thanks! Carla Schaeperkoetter Education Director OERB 500 NE 4th St., Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 P: 405.601.2715 E: cschae@oerb.com From: Lauren Burnett Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2016 at 9:10 AM To: Dara Jones Carla Schaeperkoetter Ashley Barcum Natalie Kinmonth Page 1 of 3 Subject: Re: Future Leaders Event Hey! I don?t think that will be an issue. But we don have any thing ready yet as far as registration goes. Just give Nat their emails and we will put them on our invite list. I think that will go out around Feb 18th. We have Paul Brothers and Kim Hatfield confirmed on our induced seismicity panel so far. With potential welcome remarks from chairman McDougall. Its a cocktail reception with light appetizers 5:30-7:30 (isn?t that what we said?) Kindest Regards, Lauren Burnett Events Director OIPA 500 NE 4th, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Direct2405-601-2770 Cell:405-570-1684 burnett@oipa.com a ll '1 [Mil 2?4. i Ff- 315501le From: Dara Jones Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2016 at 9:08 AM To: Carla Schaeperkoetter Ashley Barcum Natalie Kinmonth Lauren Burnett Subject: Re: Future Leaders Event I would say we can inde?nitely invite them! Lauren and Natalie just need a Excel spreadsheet with the email addresses of those you want to invite. Then they will RSVP if they want to go. It's going to be a panel discussion about how to talk about induced seismicity. Dara Jones OERB Website Administrator/ Communications Coordinator 500 NE 4th St, Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 gjonesg'cboerbcom 405-601-2756 From: Carla Schaeperkoetter Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2016 8:03 AM To: Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Natalie Kinmonth Page 2 of 3 Lauren Burnett .com> Subject: Future Leaders Event Hey ladies, Can I invite our scholarship recipients to the future leaders event on March 10? lam sending them an email today about a bunch of upcoming events so I thought it would be good to include. What information can I provide to them? How do they register? Anything else upcoming that would be good for them to be aware of? Thanks! Carla Carla Schaeperkoetter Education Director OERB 500 NE 4th St., Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 P: 405.601.2715 I E: cschae@oerb.com Page 3 of 3 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:14:36 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Environmental Stewardship Campaign - Seismicity Video Date: Friday, May 29, 2015 at 1:52:52 PM Central Daylight Time From: Mike Terry To: Ronnie lrani, Mindy Stitt Attachments: Ronnie, Paul Brothers and Dave will be presenting this info at our Annual Meeting so most of the BOD will see it then. After the meeting I will send it to those that were not there and am thinking about sending it to the entire membership and asking their employees to send it our through social media. Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 ?4 From: Ronnie Date: Friday, May 29,2015 1:23 PM To: ?Mindy Stitt' Mike Terry Subject: Re: Environmental Stewardship Campaign - Seismicity Video Hi Mindy, Mike, How about sending to OIPA Board members and also SOER Committee and Advisory Comm members? Best, Ronnie Sent from my iPhone On May 22, 2015, at 12:05 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: Dear OERB Board and Public Education Committee Members, The newest video in our Environmental Stewardship Campaign is now available online. The video, titled ?Seismic Monitoring and Mitigation,? focuses on the history of seismic activity in Oklahoma, the recent increase in activity and the role the oil and natural gas industry is playing in ?nding solutions. The video had overwhelmingly positive feedback from focus groups and helped changed their perception of the oil and natural gas industry and earthquakes. The video is available on our website and on Youtube After watching it, we hope you will share this video with your colleagues, employees, friends and family. Because we Page 1 of 2 received such positive feedback, we would like as many people as possible to see it and will be working with Brothers on distribution ideas. Also, the ?rst video in the series ?Water: Produce, Protect, Conserve? is also available on our website and Youtube Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. Best Regards, Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601 -22 77 mstitt@oerb.com This email is Confidential. if you believe it has been sent to you in error, then do not read it, do notify the sender you have received it, and delete it. Email transmissions cannot be warranted to be secure or error?free as information could be intercepted, misdirected, corrupted, lost, incomplete, destroyed or containing viruses. The sender therefore cannot guarantee the integrity or seem in: at i" ., email or any fiie(s) inciuded herewith. RM and the sender hereby disciaim any and all liability for injury or damages that may nit from the recipient(s) receipt or transmission of this email and any ?leis) included herewith or reliance on the contents thereof. Any oil?eid equipment, materials or services ordered by or provided to or its af?liates in connection with this message shall be governed by RKi's Terms and Conditions of Purchase a copy of which may be found at and such Terms and Conditions of Purchase are hereby incorporated and expressiy made a part hereof. A paper copy of RKi?s Terms and Condition c: Purchase will be provided upon your written request. Page 2 of 2 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:15:17 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: FW: Invite Date: Friday, August 25, 2017 at 2:44:22 PM Central Daylight Time From: Dara McBee To: Mindy Stitt Attachments: image001.png, image002.png Mindy, Below is all I have with regarding earthquakes. From: Dara McBee Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2016 at 7:59 AM To: Cody Bannister Ashley Barcum Lauren Burnett Mindy Stitt Natalie Kinmonth Cc: Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite Ashley and were discussing this same thing last night. I agree and like your changes! Dara Jones OERB Website Administrator/ Communications Coordinator 500 NE 4th St, Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 dim 405-601-2756 From: Cody Bannister Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2016 7:56 AM Cc: Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite All, After thinking about this overnight, I think Seismic Struggle is not the right choice. If for some reason this invitation was seen by someone from outside of the industry, it has the potential to appear insincere i.e. If I?m a homeowner facing thousands of dollars in damages to my home because of earthquakes I am certain are caused by the oil and gas industry, I might tend to scoff at the thought of the "struggles? the industry faces in communicating. I realize the chance of that happening are slim, and perhaps I'm reading way to far into it, but I would encourage us to err far on the side of caution. I would suggest changing struggle to shift (Seismic Shift: Combating misconceptions in Oklahoma?s earthquake debate). CTB Page 1 of 8 From: Ashley Barcum Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 5:29 PM To: Lauren Burnett Dara Jones Mindy Stitt Natalie Kinmonth Cody Bannister Cc: Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite Actually I like the use of seismic struggle here changing my vote Ashley Barcum OERB Communications Director abarcum@oerb.com O: 405.601.2757 M: 405.630.9257 OERB on Facebook The Great Quake Debate The seismic struggle is real Kindest Regards, Lauren Burnett Events Director OIPA 500 NE 4th, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Officez405-942-2334 Directz405-601-2770 Cellz405?570-1684 lburnet?gimm 741 #4381131} 3M KIN From: Dara Jones Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 4:51 PM Page 2 of 8 To: Ashley Barcum Lauren Burnett Mindy Stitt Natalie Kinmonth Cody Bannister Cc: Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite Great. Me too! Dara Jones OERB Website Administrator/ Communications Coordinator 500 NE 4th St, Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2756 From: Ashley Barcum Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 4:50 PM To: Lauren Burnett Mindy Stitt Natalie Kinmonth Cody Bannister Cc: Dara Jones Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite That gets my vote Ashley Barcum OERB Communications Director abarcum@oerb.com O: 405.601.2757 M: 405.630.9257 OERB on Facebook im actually digging the Seismic Struggle! Seismic Struggle: How to combat common misconceptions in our networks Kindest Regards, Lauren Burnett Events Director OIPA 500 NE 4th, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Officez405-942-2334 Directz405-601-2770 Cell:405-570-1684 Page 3 of 8 a '5 ,k?xSSlii'fjir'kl KIN From: Natalie Kinmonth Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 3:54 PM To: Cody Bannister Cc: Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Mindy Huffman Subject: Re: Invite Idon?t know that it is my call on the I think it needs to be the most politically correct while still sounding fun and not super boring. Feel me? Please feel free to throw out ideas Natalie Kinmonth Director of Business Development Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 NE 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 942-2334 Direct: (405) 601-2488 Cell: (405) 206-9144 nkinmonth@oiba.com a '1 ix: i. i ill-1M1} lil? From: Cody Bannister Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 2:27 PM To: Natalie Kinmonth Cc: Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Mindy Huffman Lauren Burnett Subject: Re: Invite Text is ?ne for me. just need to know what you?re calling it if you want a banner. CTB From: Natalie Kinmonth Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 2:21 PM Page 4 of 8 To: Cody Bannister Cc: Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Mindy Huffman Lauren Burnett Subject: FW: Invite Cody- Any feedback? Really hoping to get this out tomorrow. Natalie Kinmonth Director of Business Development Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 NE 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 942-2334 Direct: (405) 601?2488 Cell: (405) 206-9144 nkinmonth@oipa.com I '5 '4 -.. 21? F'i. miliiv'ili'iliu?kl if.) 5:1 From: Dara Jones Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 9:26 AM To: Lauren Burnett Natalie Kinmonth Cody Bannister Ashley Barcum Cc: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Invite Paul Brothers is con?rmed. Ashley has been in touch with Kristin. At last check she is still not sure about herjob, but she put the event on her bosses' calendar to ensure that one of them will be there. I think we can be pretty sure we will have a representative- name unknown at this point. Here is the text Ashley and I came up with: Join industry leaders for an exclusive reception on March 10th at Legacy Hall. In partnership with the OERB, the free event features a conversation with industry experts about seismicity. From social media to community outreach and media relations, there are plenty of opportunities for the industry?s future leaders to join the effort to combat misperceptions that exist within our own networks. Bring a colleague and enjoy free cocktails and hors d?oeuvres as we reveal the latest on seismicity, plus receive free resources to join the grassroots movement to promote the essential role that industry plays in all of our lives. Seating is limited. Reservations required. Please RSVP by Page 5 of 8 Dara Jones OERB Website Administrator/ Communications Coordinator 500 NE 4th St, Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 dionesgmoerbtom 405-601-2756 From: Lauren Burnett Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 9:17 AM To: Natalie Kinmonth Dara Jones Cody Bannister Ashley Barcum Subject: Re: Invite Have we confirmed all the speaker at this point? Kindest Regards, Lauren Burnett Events Director OIPA 500 NE 4th, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Directz405?601-2770 . ?a I. [we] a KIN From: Natalie Kinmonth Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 8:44 AM To: Dara Jones Cody Bannister Lauren Burnett Ashley Barcum Cc: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Invite Yes that is my main question. What exactly are we calling this? Natalie Kinmonth Director of Business Development Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association Page 6 of 8 500 NE 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 942-2334 Direct: (405) 601-2488 Cell: (405) 206-9144 nkinmonth@oipa.com a '4 a '1 313$ . FULL-L KJN From: Dara Jones Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 at 8:29 AM To: Natalie Kinmonth Cody Bannister Lauren Burnett Ashley Barcum Subject: Re: Invite Just a few questions: 1. How are we of?cially branding this event? What are we calling it? 2. We will send you our invite list but in case we miss any, can we just forward the invite? 3. i sent a draft for the description to Ashley. She will perfect it (with the correct event name) and send it on to you all. Dara Jones OERB Website Administrator/ Communications Coordinator 500 NE 4th St, Suite 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-6012756 From: Natalie Kinmonth Date: Monday, February 15, 2016 8:02 AM To: Cody Bannister Lauren Burnett Dara Jones Ashley Barcum Subject: Invite Hi guys! Was hoping to get event brite up and running today or tomorrow. 50 - questions: 1. Cody - can we get an image/banner made up for this thing? Page 7 of 8 How is the language of the description of the event coming along? I will have my people to invite but, OERB- please send your list over to me. lam planning on inviting our BOD, as well. Anything else I am missing? Natalie Kinmonth Director of Business Development Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 NE 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 942-2334 Direct: (405) 601-2488 Cell: (405) 206-9144 nkinmonth@oipa.com '4 '1 {fl-411 - Zuni-A (?SS-Didi? Page 8 of 8 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:15:35 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: website for distribution - OK Jobs Date: Monday, March 9, 2015 at 10:31:24 AM Central Daylight Time From: James Roller To: Mindy Stitt, Jill Harrison, Dara McBee Oklahoma Works I don?t believe the seismic council website is live yet. Page 1 of 1 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:16:12 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: FW: Article from Bartlesville Examiner regarding earthquakes Date: Monday, December 8, 2014 at 12:05:38 PM Central Standard Time From: Mike Terry To: Mindy Stitt Attachments: FYI Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 I ?1 a From: Bubba Date: Monday, December 8, 2014 11:57 AM To: Mark Schell "Don Smith Drew Harding "ehillerman(03newfield.c0m" "Eric Grimshaw Jeff Wilson "Jeremy Webb Jeremy Fitzpatrick "John Randolph "Kent J. Harrell" ?Kevin Layton ?Linda Cook "Lucas J. Munson "McCutcheon Bob Mike McDonald Mike Terry "Rand Phipps Randall Vaughan "Robert Sullivan Jr. (Mjm?sullcocomr' Subject: Re: Article from Bartlesville Examiner regarding earthquakes That is a very informative piece thank you for sharing. In my view we are always better off to face public concerns and to participate in the dialogue. OERB should be an honest broker of the issue ;replacing fear with open discussion and sound and honest science. I hope they're doing just that Merry Christmas Mike Sent from my iPhone On Dec 8, 2014, at 11:46 AM, Mark Schell wrote: Page 1 of 3 Expert explains link between seisimic activity and fracking, wastewater injection By Sarah Kirby The Norman Transcript (TNS) Oklahoma is now more seismically active than the state of California, according to a hydrophysics expert who spoke in Norman recently. Dr. Todd Halihan, OSU Professor of Hydrogeology of Fractured Aquifers and Hydrophysics talked about fracking, wastewater injection and earthquakes at a public forum on Dec. 1. It was the third educational public forum in Norman dealing with the controversial topic. Halihan offered scienti?c insight based on his signi?cant experience in both public and private sectors, which has been highly valued in the ongoing dialogue on the impacts of oil and gas drilling in Oklahoma. One of state?s leading experts on the recent earthquake outbreaks, Halihan is a member of the Governor's Coordinating Council on seismic activity, which advises policymakers at the state level. He is also the associated Editr for "Ground Water,? a scienti?c journal, as well as the chair of the Geological Society of America. He prefaced his presentation with comments others have made about his biases. "I?ve actually been accused of being overly neutral,? Halihan said. "But l?m going to talk about technical reality relative to seismic activity in Oklahoma." Halihan likened seismic risk to the odds at winning at a casino, which have been steadily increasing in Oklahoma for the past ?ve years by a more than a factor of a tenth. "If you look at the things since then that are weird at least from 2009 to 2012 timeframe this would be the guy watching the casino ?oor. You got all your machines running. Which machine is paying out for being too normal or which table is paying out too much? You?ve got your cameras watching everything. "In Oklahoma, we're really, really statistically unlikely. We?re playing Blackjack and winning lots of hands way more than we statistically should,? Halihan said. During that time, Halihan said, more wastewater injection occurred in the state. Because Oklahoma has yet to invest in a $2 million ?blackbox" technology to monitor quake activity from wells injections wells, Halihan said there is no conclusive data to prove what has been causing the frequent number of quakes in the state. ?Statistically, it's weird that a lot of them happen at the same time and there was a lot of injection going on, but you don't have a tie that says feel that pressure right by where that happened and it went way up.? When we say ?way up' relative to an earthquake being generated by injection, we?re talking about the same amount of pressure you need to in?ate your tires.? From January to May of 2014, seismic risk went up another factor in Oklahoma. ?It?s not a slight statistic change,? Halihan said. ?We haven?t gotten more shaky. We?ve gotten way, way Page 2 of 3 more shaky. Statistically, it?s really bizarre.? Halihan referenced an updated report released by the US. Geological Survey which indicated that Oklahoma was likely to have a larger magnitude earthquake than it has experienced before, without indicating clause although there is natural phenomena to explain why. ?It?s very hard to be working in energy and ?guring out a problem," Halihan said, ?because you?re supposed to directly talk to the public and tell them they will be ?ne. And the public will say it doesn?t believe you. It?s very hard to be that person in the energy company. "Relative to those issues, if you have public opposition to something that?s happened, you have a breakdown of trust. And you can quickly lose it and it?s slow to be regained. I mention that so that people on any side of the issue it?s something you have to keep track of. People aren't stupid." See more at: 1311mm put Mark E. Schell Senior Vice President, General Counsel, and Secretary Unit Corporation 7130 South Lewis, Suite 1000 Tulsa, Oklahoma 74136 918-493-7700 (work) 918-691-5222 (cell) n1ark.schell@unitcorucom Disclaimer - This e-mail communication is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to nor does it constitute a commitment or agreement binding on Unit Corporation or any of its affiliated companies (collectively "Unit") regarding the subject matter ofthis communication unless it expressly states that it is intended as a binding commitment or agreement and (ii) is sent and signed by a person authorized by Unit to enter into such a commitment or agreement. Page 3 of 3 Date: Tuesday, January 17, 2017 at 8:05:07 AM Central Standard Time Subject: Re: OERB Refunds From: Mindy Stitt To: Mike Terry Attachments: image001.png, image002.jpg, image003.png Ok. Will do. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE St, Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Mike Terry Date: Tuesday, January 17, 2017 at 8:01 AM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: OERB Refunds Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:17:38 PM Central Daylight Time Ok He is a reasonable guy. Be sure to inform him about your earthquake education activities. Let me know how things go and if I need to follow up. Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 . '1 From: 'Mindy Stitt' Date: Monday, January 16, 2017 at 4:57 PM To: Mike Terry Subject: FW: OERB Refunds FYI I will contact Joe. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE St, Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com Page 1 of 3 From: Fonda Manwell Date: Monday, January 16, 2017 at 4:53 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: RE: OERB Refunds Thank you. We actually haven?t got that far to find out. We have a new person in place that just received the paperwork and she had some questions about the paperwork, itself. I told her after she got her questions answered I would like to present it to management before we just jumped out and ?led anything. I think it will be a combination ofJoe C, our General Council Jeff Zanotti and our CEO Elliot Chambers. Since you have already met Joe you are welcome to give him a call anytime and discuss. 252-5879. Best time to catch him is early like 8am. He?s on a conf call 730-745ish fm Fonda Manwell Director Government Affairs - (0) PO. Box 13360, Oklahoma City, OK 73113 301 NW 63rd, Suite 600, Oklahoma City, OK 73116 WHITE STAR PETROLEUM From: Mindy Stitt Sent: Monday, January 16,2017 4:45 PM To: Fonda Manwell Subject: Re: OERB Refunds CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Page 2 of 3 Hi Fonda, It was great seeing you as well. Hope all is well in your world. Viji Ayyaru will be the person processing refund requests. She is our controller. Her email address is nyaru@oerb.com. If White Star is considering getting a refund, I would like to visit with whomever is making that decision. Would that be Joe Craig? Best Regards, Mindy Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405?601?2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Fonda Manwell Date: Monday, January 16, 2017 at 4:37 PM To: Mindy Stitt Cc: Jana Meece Subject: OERB Refunds Good Afternoon Mindy, We have a few questions for your department that handles the GPT refund. Can you send me the name of the person that handles this, please? Hope all is going well your way. It was great seeing you at the legislative reception the other night, also. Thanks fm WHITE STAR lit.) Ll? Fonda Manwell Director Government Affairs 252-5870 (405) 388-6403 1 (855) 862-4265 PO. Box 13360, Oklahoma City, OK 73113 301 NW 63rd, Suite 600, Oklahoma City, OK 73116 Fonda.Manwell@wstr.com Page 3 of 3 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:17:57 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: FW: This is about fracking Date: Wednesday, November 6, 2013 at 8:36:38 AM Central Standard Time From: Mike Terry To: Mindy Stitt, Jill Harrison Attachments: image001.jpg FYI From: Brian Woodard Date: Wednesday, November 6, 2013 7:52 AM To: Mike Terry Cody Bannister Cc: Jeff Wilson Drew Harmon Subject: FW: This is about fracking Here we go. very own local chapter of the Sierra Club ready to jump into the rulemaking fray at the OCC concerning IS. Regards, Brian Woodard Vice President - Regulatory Affairs Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 601-2332 Mobile: (405) 543-8685 E-mail: bwoodard@gipa.com From: Kim Hat?eld Sent: Wednesday, November 06, 2013 7:49 AM To: Brian Woodard Subject: Fwd: This is about fracking FYI Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: SBH Date: November 6, 2013, 7:34:10 AM CST To: Kim Hat?eld Subject: This is about fracking Begin forwarded message: Page 1 of 3 From: Oklahoma Chapter of the Sierra Club Date: November 6, 2013 7:00:21 AM CST To: suzhat@mac.com Subject: Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Recommends Purchasing Earthquake Insurance Reply-To: Oklahoma Chapter of the Sierra Club View as web nail; 1 Tell a friend Sent to suzhat/Q?Imaccom. Not you? Sigup licrc. Oklahoma Sierra Club Explore, enjoy and protect the planet! {db-23616 {3793' Dear Suzette, Two weeks ago, I was interviewed by OETA's Oklahoma News Report concerning the recent rise in earthquakes occurring in Oklahoma. As I pointed out, these increases in earthquakes are occurring nationwide and the overwhelming consensus of scientists is that they directly correlate to increased use of injection wells for oil and gas fracking fluids. If you didn't get a chance to see the segment, you can watch it here. cm- [imam wusswmums Just last week, the Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner issued a statement recommending all Oklahomans add earthquake insurance to their policies. Personally, I did add earthquake insurance (at a cost of approximately $60 a year) 1 I and would also recommend everyone else do the same. However, how is it fair that all Oklahoma property owners are now paying an additional yearly fee because of the actions of oil and gas companies? Even m0i importantly, should Oklahoman's property and safety be put at risk by an activity we absolutely know directly correlates to earthquakes? Currently, the Oklahoma Corporation Commission has no rules requiring seismic studies pi to an injection well going into operation. Several other states have adopted rules and law: addressing induced seismicity related to injection wells as a first step to addressing this extren dangerous problem. Page 2 of 3 Today, I am asking you to sign a petition that I will present to the Corporation Commiss asking them to address this threat in a formal rulemaking. The Oklahoma Chapter of the Sierra Club knows the difficulties it will face in taking on the state's most powerful interest, the and gas lobby, but we believe this cause is simply too important to ignore. The only way we ca compete with their money and influence is with the help of our grassroots members and supporters. So please, as a first step, siqn on to this petition today. Thank you for your efforts to protect Oklahoma's environment. Yours in Solidarity, David Ocamb Oklahoma Chapter Director PS. Please share this alert with your social networks: Oklahoma Chapter Sierra Club 4900 Richmond Sq, Suite 203, Oklahoma City, 73118 405.286.2277 ii f'is': LZJE update My Profile Manaae My Email Preferences unsubscribe Page 3 of 3 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:18:21 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: News Article - OK Disposal Well Shut Down due to Date: Wednesday, October 2, 2013 at 8:34:38 AM Central Daylight Time From: Mike Terry To: Brian Woodard, Cody Bannister, Jeff Wilson, Cody Bannister CC: Mindy Attachments: image001.jpg, image002.jpg Tom is a long-time member, building donor, and former chairman of the Marginal Well Commission before the OERB took over. lf anyone has any ideas on how we can help him, I'm sure he would welcome some support. MET From: Brian Woodard Date: Wednesday, October 2, 2013 8:31 AM To: Mike Terry Cody Bannister Jeff Wilson Subject: News Article - OK Disposal Well Shut Down due to EARTHQUAKES: Okla. disposal well shut down after tremors Mike Soraghan, reporter Published: Wednesday, October 2, 2013 The operator of a new drilling wastewater disposal well in southern Oklahoma has shut it down as state officials investigate whether it triggered a series of damaging earthquakes nearby. Injection at the Love County Disposal Well began two weeks before the earthquakes started near Marietta, Okla. "The number of earthquakes increased as injection peaked," Oklahoma Geological Survey seismologist Austin Holland wrote in a report. "However, we cannot rule out that this observation could be simply a coincidencetug-State ottscials are trying to determine whether 3 di'siling waste. disposal wait triggered earthquakes that began Sept. 1.7 near Mm'sezza Okla. Cllz?K the? may, for a target: vers?nn. Ma:- v:ourtesv of the Oklahoma Geological Survey. Well operator Tom Dunlap did not cite the earthquakes in his message to state officials that he would be "shutting in" the well until further notice. "Our business is uneconomic at this point," he wrote in an email. An attempt by EnergyWire to reach him by phone was unsuccessful. Injection began Sept. 3 and the earthquakes started Sept. 17 in the area near the Texas border about 100 miles north of Dallas. The strongest was magnitude 3.4, and they have damaged chimneys, broken windows. and caused objects to fall in homes and businesses. The Geological Survey has moved four seismic stations into the area to determine more precise locations for the quakes. Before Dunlap voluntarily closed the well, the Oklahoma Corporation Commission (OCC) had sharply curtailed its operations. The agency limited the well to 1,000 barrels a day (42,000 gallons) at a maximum pressure of 375 pounds per square inch, OCC spokesman Matt Skinner said. The well was designed to take as much as 19,000 barrels per day (798,000 gallons) at a pressure of up to 2,200 psi. Skinner said the OCC was employing a "red light, yellow light, green light" approach. The limits on injection were a yellow light. The National Academy of Sciences recommended such a traffic light protocol in a 2012 report. The well had never accepted its full daily capacity of wastewater, though. State records show injections got up to 9,500 barrels Sept. 21 before declining. The well was not hydraulically fractured. But Holland's report said it was treated with 10,000 gallons of hydrochloric acid. The OCC, which regulates drilling and other industries, has also ordered that a digital pressure reader be put on the well that gives seismologists and oil and gas of?cials precise, up-to-the minute readings. Page 1 of 2 Local news reports have indicated that some residents are blaming the disposal well. Geologists have known for decades that deep injection of industrial waste can lubricate faults and unleash earthquakes. Some earthquake researchers now say the nation's drilling boom. fueled by advances in high-volume hydraulic fracturing, could be spurring a rash of such man-made quakes. Most seismologists agree that the speci?c process of hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, presents little or no risk of triggering earthquakes that damage preperty or injure people. Instead they point to injection wells. Fracking and production of shale gas produce millions of gallons of wastewater. Some can be reused. but eventually, what comes to the surface must be disposed of. Usually, that's into injection wells. Causing an earthquake is not illegal under the federal environmental laws that cover deep injection of oil and gas waste. But it could be illegal to allow injection to damage drinking water supplies (Q?gyWire, June 18, 2012). And lawyers have sued injection well operators under general nuisance provisions after earthquakes. Very few of the 40,000 brine disposal wells in the country have been linked to seismic ruptures. But in the shale drilling boom of the last few years, earthquakes have been linked to injection wells in Arkansas, Colorado, Ohio. West Virginia and Texas. In 2012, U.S. Geological Survey scientists said they were observing a "remarkable increase" in earthquakes in the middle of the country likely tied to injection. An increase in earthquakes in Oklahoma was central to that ?nding. Since then, seismologists have linked a more damaging 2011 quake outside Oklahoma City to nearby injection wells (EnergyWire, March 27). Brian Woodard Vice President - Regulatory Affairs Oklahoma independent Petroleum Association 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Of?ce: (405) 601-2332 Mobile: (405) 543?8685 E-mail: Page 2 of 2 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:18:39 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Earthquake Talking Points Date: Thursday, April 12, 2012 at 2:14:05 PM Central Daylight Time From: Cody Bannister To: Mindy Stitt Attachments: Induced seismic activity talking points.doc, Seismic activity talking points.doc I have two. One I put together after Austin Holland?s report from Grady County and one from last week from the USGS abstract. They're both attached. I?ve also got a printed copy of ANGA's talking points. walk a copy over to you. CTB From: Mindy Stitt Date: Thu, 12 Apr 2012 13:44:29 -0500 To: Cody Bannister Conversation: Earthquake Talking Points Subject: Earthquake Talking Points Hey Cody, Mike tells me that you have some talking points regarding hydraulic fracturing and earthquakes. Could you send those to me? Mindy Stitt OERB 3555 NW 58th, Suite 430 Oklahoma City, OK 73112 405-942-5323 ext. 230 mstitt@oerb.com Page 1 of 1 Seismic activity talking points Use the term ?seismic activity? sted earthquake. The report focuses on central and southern Oklahoma, areas of the state that have historic oil and natural gas production. Crude oil and natural gas are produced in 70 ofOkIahoma's 77 counties. Any seismic activity is likely to occur near oil and natural gas activity. Northwest Oklahoma is home to today's most intense oil and gas exploration and production. There have been no media reports and the report does not indicate that there has been an increase in seismic activity there. In Oklahoma, there are 10,500 injection wells found throughout the state. Injection wells have been used for decades in Oklahoma to dispose ofproduced saltwater with no documented cases ofinduced seismicity. The OIPA supports the continued study ofseismic activity and its relationship to the oil and natural gas industry. We must take a common sense approach. Any regulations that deter oil and natural gas exploration based on untested and unfounded theories of induced seismicity will only slow the state's ability to grow its workforce. Industry notes for Oklahoma The use of horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing has opened new areas of exploration for Oklahoma producers and has renewed exploration and production in the state's historic oil and natural gas fields. Increased drilling in these formations results in an increase in jobs in the oil and natural gas industry and occupations that support it. One out of every three dollars spent in Oklahoma is directly or indirectly tied to the oil and natural gas industry. The industry accounts for approximately 22 percent ofall taxes paid in the state. In January, the most recent data available, employment in the oil and natural gas industry was up 17 percent from the previous year Seismic activity talking points Use the term ?seismic activity sled earthquake. The area where the seismic activity was recorded has a history of seismic activity and has been one of the most active areas in the state. Garvin County is also an area where oil and natural gas exploration occurs, with 41 oil and natural gas wells completed in 2009 (the most recent data available from the Corporation Commission). The majority of new wells are completed using hydraulic fracturing, and similar seismic activity was not reported during the hydraulic fracturing process at other oil and natural gas production sites. From the Report The number of historical earthquakes in the area and uncertainties in hypocenter locations makes it impossible to determine with high degree of certainty whether or not hydraulic-fracturing induced these earthquakes. From News The fracturing continued at the Picket well after the earthquakes, and the survey detected no additional seismic activity during that time, Holland said. The well was located in a geologically complex region riven by thrust rocks, he added, and a quake would likely have occurred at some point with or without the drilling -- the rocks were primed for it. As Holland noted, firms have drilled more than 100,000 fracturing wells in Oklahoma, with only three minor seismic events reported. Industry notes for Oklahoma The use ofhorizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing has opened new areas of exploration for Oklahoma producers and has renewed exploration and production in the state?s historic oil and natural gas fields. Increased drilling in these formations results in an increase in jobs in the oil and natural gas industry and occupations that support it. One out ofevery three dollars spent in Oklahoma is directly or indirectly tied to the oil and natural gas industry. The industry accounts for approximately 22 percent ofall taxes paid in the state. Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:19:47 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Public Education Committee Conference Call Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2016 at 12:33:11 PM Central Standard Time From: Mike Terry To: Mindy Stitt Attachments: I will join you in the conference room. MET Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405?601-2244 From: 'Mindy Stitt' Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2016 12:05 PM To: Mike McDonald David House Ronnie Irani Tim Munson Julie Kruger-Musselman John Pilkington Pete Brown Kristin Hincke Kristin Thomas Mike Terry Cc: Ashley Barcum Dara Jones Dave Thomas Holly Gray Subject: Public Education Committee Conference Call Dear Public Education Committee Members, The OERB board met yesterday and voted to fund a proposal from the Ground Water Protection Council to update the Oklahoma Corporation Commission?s data collection software. This update will allow the OCC staff to more accurately and ef?ciently analyze spatial relationships between saltwater disposal wells and earthquakes. The consensus of the Board was that this is a great opportunity for the OERB to talk about how the industry, through the OERB, is helping with research efforts regarding earthquakes. However, the Board agreed that is was important to consult our advertising ?rm regarding a detailed messaging plan. Therefore, Chairman Mike McDonald has called a meeting of the public education committee for 3:00 (tomorrow) Thursday, February 11. This meeting will be conducted via conference call. If you are in OKC, you are welcome to attend the meeting in person, at our of?ces. To join the conference call, you will need to call 405-601-2420 and use the passcode 230. Page 1 of 2 For those of you who are available to join the meeting, either in person or via conference call, more details will be provided tomorrow morning. So that I can get additional information to you, please let me know you will be participating by replying to this email. Thank you, Mindy Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com Page 2 of 2 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:20:00 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: OERB Shines Date: Thursday, July 28, 2011 at 3:44:55 PM Central Daylight Time From: Mike Terry To: David House, Ronnie Irani, Tim Munson, Steve Slawson, Bob Sullivan, Mike Cantrell, Pete Brown, Thompson, Randy Foutch, Mike McDonald, John Pilkington, Patrick Cobb, Dewey Bartlett, Harold Hamm, Mike Cross CC: Mindy St?itt Gents, It?s not often that I have witnessed an event more inspiring and rewarding than what I saw this morning. I received a call from Mindy this morning about 10:00 asking me to drive to Santa Fe High School in Edmond to an OERB workshop. Mindy doesn?t generally call me unless it is something very good or very bad. I was sure this would be good! I drove to the school and arrived about 11:30. I walked into the cafeteria and couldn?t believe what I saw. The room was beaming with more than 200 teachers eating box lunches provided by the OERB. They represented all grade levels, from 1-12th grade, and had just come from 14 individual class rooms where workshops about oil and natural gas were being taught. Every single curriculum offered by the OERB was being taught by master teachers from all over the state. While eating their lunch, they were being exposed to a Petro Pro presentation conducted by Steve Slawson (doing an excellent job I might add). I couldn?t keep from being reminded of the old days when John from Colt Energy (Randy Foutch?s ?rst company) designed and taught the ?rst Petro Pro presentations. Randy, we?ve come a long way my friend!! After lunch, Mindy and I toured all the different workshops underway. I saw oil?eld safety activities. derricks being built, seismic lines being colored in, geological terms being explained, drill sites being drawn out on township maps, scienti?c calculators being used, etc., etc. In short, it was incredible!! After leaving the class rooms, I drove around to the back of the school to see hundreds of shiny new workshop kits being unloaded and sorted from a 24 foot trailer. The OERB staff had developed a drive by system where the teachers could drive their car by the trailer and receive their kit without leaving their air conditioned car. Guys, I?m telling you, this student ed program is a well oiled machine. If you do the math, this one workshop has the potential of providing oil and gas curricula to 20,000 students, and that?s if it is only taught one time per year. Some of you have always believed this is the most important work the OERB does. I?m beginning to be a believer! We are slowly but surely winning the war; at least in Oklahoma! MET Page 1 of 1 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:20:15 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: What Siesmic Shift should or something like this. Date: Thursday, February 18, 2016 at 5:29:42 PM Central Standard Time From: James Roller To: Natalie Kinmonth, Cody Bannister, Ashley Barcum, Dara McBee, Lauren Burnett CC: Mike Terry, Mindy Stitt Team - Below please see a quick edit that I believe we should send out in replace of our last email regarding the March 10th Future Leaders Event. I believe we may not have communicated collaboratively or fully what the intention of the event should be. In my opinion, the previous announcement we made looks as if our efforts for this event are to prepare our young leaders to shift blame and combat others. This is about educating members on how to have conversations about energy in their circles of in?uence. It?s not that I don?t think seismicity won?t be discussed, but seismicity is not the only topic we should discuss. This about a broader effort to have communication on energy issues. What are the thought processes we work through in processing statement? How to we engage in a more meaningful way? I would have mentioned these items prior to publishing had I been involved. And I?m not saying my opinion matters any more than anyone else. Please Consider. Energy Conversations Join the OIPA, OERB and industry leaders for an exclusive event on March 10th at Legacy Hall. In partnership with the OERB, the free event features a panel with industry and communications experts about how we engage in conversations about energy development within our communities. From social media to community outreach and media relations, there are plenty of opportunities for the industry?s future leaders to engage with Oklahoma?s public in order to promote and educate others about our longstanding industry and its benefits to society. Bring a colleague, network with other industry advocates, and enjoy free cocktails and hors d?oeuvres as we learn how we can have more conversations in our community about our industry. Seating is limited. Reservations required for all attendees. PANEL INCLUDES: PR Company A Industry Communications Professional Page 1 of 2 Paul Brothers; President Executive Creative Director of Brothers Company, the ad agency of record for OERB James Roller VP of Legislative Affairs Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association 580-309-0551 Page 2 of 2 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:20:30 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: FW: Monday Conference Call or Meeting Date: Monday, January 18, 2016 at 9:07:43 AM Central Standard Time From: Mindy Stitt To: Mike Terry MET, Danny will be here at 10:00am. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Danny Morgan Date: Monday, January 18, 2016 at 8:59 AM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Monday Conference Call or Meeting I'll be in the area and will just stop by at 10:00. Danny Morgan On Jan 18, 2016, at 8:30 AM, Mindy Stitt wrote: Good Morning Danny, Mike Terry and are available for a conference call today at 10:OOam, or 3:30pm or later. What time would be best for you? Attached is the proposal we will be discussing. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Danny Morgan Date: Friday, January 15, 2016 at 5:13 PM Page 1 of 3 To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Monday Conference Call or Meeting Ok Danny Morgan On Jan 15, 2016, at 5:11 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: I will check with Mike Terry to see what works for him and will get back with you. Thank you and have a good weekend. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 mstitt@oerb.com From: Danny Morgan Date: Friday, January 15, 2016 at 5:09 PM To: Mindy Stitt Subject: Re: Monday Conference Call or Meeting I'm very ?exible on Mon for a conference call. Call me at 205-0654 and we can set up a time Danny Morgan On Jan 15, 2016, at 3:53 PM, Mindy Stitt wrote: HiDanny Would you have some time on Monday for either a conference call or short meeting with Mike Terry and me? I would like to discuss a proposal I received regarding gathering data on earthquakes/injection wells. Mindy Stitt OERB Executive Director 500 NE 4th St., Ste 100 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2277 Page 2 of 3 mstitt@oerb.com Ground Water Protection Council.pdf> Page 3 of 3 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:20:44 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All U.S. Injection Wells Date: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 at 3:37:58 PM Central Standard Time From: Mike Terry To: Kim Hatfield, AJ Ferate, Mindy Stitt, Ashley Barcum, Dara McBee CC: Cody Bannister, Natalie Kinmonth, Lauren Burnett, James Roller Attachments: image001.png Kim, Thanks for your input. My intent was to make a point to our staff about using our future leaders as a pipeline via social media on news items. It was not my intent to use the news piece as a factoid or official position of the OIPA on this issue. I respect your opinion and don't disagree. Thanks Mike Mike Terry OIPA President 500 N.E. 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 I ?4 ?1 From: Kim Hatfield Date: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 4:07 PM To: AJ Ferate Mike Terry ?Mindy Stitt' Ashley Barcum Dara Jones Cc: Cody Bannister Natalie Kinmonth Lauren Burnett James Roller Subject: RE: Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All U.S. Injection Wells This paper is pseudo-science that gives a misleading view of our understanding of this issue. While the statements on the face of them sound good they immediately lead to the question ?If so few of these wells are the problems then why not do away with those and solve the problem?? This sounds great, but the fact of the matter is that while we think that the number of problem wells is probably small we can?t pinpoint which ones they are. More importantly, we do not know the mechanism by which these events are triggered and the top researchers don?t even agree among themselves on this point. We have to be very careful about how we discuss this issue to make sure we don?t get beat to death with our own words. From: A) Ferate [mailto:ajferatega?gpacom] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 2:44 PM To: Mike Terry; Mindy Stitt; Ashley Barcum; Dara Jones; Kim Hat?eld Cc: Cody Bannister; Natalie Kinmonth; Lauren Burnett; James Roller Subject: RE: Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All U.S. Injection Wells Page 1 of 4 think on this one Kim (cc?d) would prefer we not use this as a talking point. From: Mike Terry Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 1:43 PM To: Mindy Stitt; Ashley Barcum; Dara Jones Cc: Cody Bannister; Natalie Kinmonth; Lauren Burnett; AJ Ferate; James Roller Subject: FW: Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All US. Injection Wells Guys, Below is exactly the type of information we should be forwarding to our future leaders on a regular basis so they can use social media as a vehicle to spread the information to friends, relatives, etc. Mike Terry OIPA President 500 NE 4th Street, Suite 200 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 405-601-2244 I '4 From: Energy in Depth on behalf of Energy In Depth Reply-To: Energy In Depth Date: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 2:35 PM To: Mike Terry Subject: Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All US. Injection Wells Issue Alert: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All US. injection Is this email not displaying correctly? Wells View it in your browser. . an}: . Dr! "37.3.ENERGYIN projectof tho DETROLEUM Assocmnou OF . . You MISSED IT Report: Earthquakes Linked to Less than One Percent of All US. Injection Wells A Posted by: Katie Brown, Page 2 of 4 f? Team Lead ll Washington, DC. Nov. 17, 2015 Fewer than one percent of wastewater injection wells across the United States have been potentially linked to induced seismicity, according to a new rem by Energy In Depth. The report, entitled ?Injection Wells and Earthquakes: Quantifyj?g the Risk," consults data from the US. Geological Survey (USGS) and several peer-reviewed studies to examine the number of injection wells that have been suspected as causing earthquakes, compared against the total number of operating injection wells. The report includes breakout statistics for several states as well, including Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado, New Mexico, Ohio, Kansas, and Arkansas. Below are the key findings, by the numbers: Total number of US. disposal wells 40,000 (approx.) Number of US. disposal wells potentially linked to seismicity 218 Percentage of US. disposal wells potentially linked to seismicity 0.55% Percentage of disposal wells operating without seismicity 99.45% Total number of Class II injection wells in the United States 150,000 (approx.) Percentage of Class II injection wells potentially linked to seismicity 0.15% Percentage of Class II injection wells operating without seismicity 99.85% The report helps to quantify the risk of induced seismicity from underground wastewater disposal, demonstrating that despite prevalent media coverage of each seismic event, the number of wells even potentially linked to earthquakes is comparatively small across the United States. Even in the individual states where most of the attention on induced seismicity has been focused, the vast majority of injection wells are operating aseismically. In recent years, scientists, regulators, and industry have come together to implement a number of measures to mitigate the risk of induced seismicity, including resource and data sharing to empower states to adopt best practices. Many states have also updated their rules and guidelines for injection well permitting, and companies have spent tens of millions of dollars in mitigation procedures many of which were voluntary in order to further reduce risks. To access the full report, and the state specific-fact sheets, click the links below. 0 Full Report: injection Wells and Earthduakes: Quantityj?g the Risk Oklahoma Fact Sheet Texas Fact Sheet Colorado Fact Sheet New Mexico Fact Sheet Ohio Fact Sheet Kansas Fact Sheet Arkansas Fact Sheet Complete post: Page 3 of 4 follow on Twitter 1 friend on Facebook i fon/vard to a friend Copyright 2015 Energy In Depth. Ali rights reserved. You have selected to receive Energy in Depth morning news clips Our mailing address is: Energy In Depth 1101 Street. NW Suite 8100 Washington, DC 20005 unsubscribe from this list i update subscription preferences Page 4 of 4 Monday, September 4, 2017 at 1:20:59 PM Central Daylight Time Subject: Re: KOCO report on Monday titled Pipeline Panic Date: Monday, November 9, 2015 at 9:44:27 AM Central Standard Time From: Mike Terry To: Linda Whittington CC: Mindy Stitt Thanks Linda. It's sad that the Oklahoma media feels the need to push the anti-industry agenda! Sent from my iPhone On Nov 6, 2015, at 10:21 PM, Linda Whittington wrote: Hi Mike, Just saw a teaser on KOCO about a Monday story called Pipeline Panic. Focused on Keystone, Earthquakes, Cushing and Catastrophic Panic. FYI Linda Whittington Sent from my iPad Page 1 of 1