FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 From: Ivers, Sent: Friday, To: Milo Cc: Colin Subject: Manuscript Attachments: Dangerous Here Mitchell you INDEX NO. 654668/2017 Mitchell January 13, 2017 Yiannopoulos; Tom 5:34 PM Flannery Madine EDITED to Milo.docx go. Ivers Vice President and Editorial Director, Threshold Editions Vice President and Senior Editor, Gallery Books Simon & Schuster, Inc. 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020 Tel: 212-698-2897 Fax: 212-632-4084 Mitchell.Ivers@SimonandSchuster.com 1 SS0033722 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 1 DANGEROUS Milo Ijt' Yiannopoulos SS0033723 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 To John For the moments SS0033724 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 2 CONTENTS Preamble: Prologue: On Freedom of Speech and Political Correctness The Art of the Troll 1. Why the Progressive 2, Why the Alt-Right 3. Why Twitter Hates Me Hates Me 4. Why Feminists 5. Why Black Left Hates Me Hate Me Lives 6. Why the Media Matter Hates Me Hates Me 7. ,'. Why Other-Gay-PeopleEstablishment_Gays_Hate 8. Why Establishment 9. Why Muslims Republicans Me Hate Me Hate Me -14-WhyUgly-People-Hate-Me 1-U. CalIIA'~BI O' I'b 1 Picking wing C88Ime8t [A5]; Adtl wmt:thing likethis, deserving media thinks targets and making I'm a "misogynist call me a "degenerate One of the two is clearly don't want to correct Trump, political mad is essential them hopping racist white nationalist faggot" kike alt-right and declared a "holy but their confusion wrong, butthurt leader." crusade" The left- to trolling The Neo-Nazis, against me. is so glorious that I almost either one of them. That is trolling them In my trollery, I am surpassed a man who essentially him (in itself 'SCU a $81'Iuloua $8 I Ot IS another troll), trolled only by one man, or, rather one God-Emperor: his way to the presidency. only went after deserving targets: Like as I like to call me, Daddy, the media, Hillary Donald and Bill Clinton, correctness. A master showman, that most of their leading Forcing people That" over a year? That's Donald lights J. Trump can command the media's attention despite the fact despise him. who hate you and everything a level of trolling you stand for to point cameras at you for It's true that to be a good troll, one must I can only hope to achieve one day. However... We should never mistake have a certain level of disregard cruelty for other for trolling. peoples' feelings. But LI8>Hin ~ must have 8 LILAcrence 4@twcerj troHIB'~ and cnICHv I8 (hat cruel'tv has Bo Brolls should troll only in the ntune of debunking u. ose; the 'ur '3usc exec. t to hurt soIBCBBC, some untruth. In the age of the campus safe Comment [A6]: Add screP ir;j keP s s n e rost accusaacnsagains:yo-. so :ic "rm t°ey clair : ve 20·-e space, what could be more valuable? SS0033728 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 6 It's one of the reasons why trolls but we' re the only ones telling So beware, lefties: are winning: hate us, yell, -stamp your feet, yes, yes the truth these days. so long as facts remain the age of the trolls offensive, will never end *** I am an icon. A messiah. A bleached-blond scolds, third-wave professors, "fat creature feminists, acceptance" of the night progressive who keeps the nannies, Black bloggers, transgender advocates, Lives lobbyists Matter cultural pearl-clutchers, gender studies activists, and Islamophobia watchdogs up at night. My name is Milo, and this book will and hates as "the dangerous I'm a firestarter rose to infamy created absolute as one of America's who started out as an obscure most well-known in half a dozen industries; polemicists mMedia, the wrong becoming Dangerous celebrity, an the most in-demand Faggot of young P and publishing, the biggest by almost video merely tech blogger and media personalities. by being single college handedly gam.ersi enthusiasts by dint of announcing campuses; coming frem and I' I've a the-most-notorious Twitter; tech scandal of 2016.,. gEducation, speaker on American Tour. gGaming, ot' of an entire generation feminism. sparking British by being banned from waspsh--and4eveable-columnist;_--in-America:--Ttech, cut with now knows faggot." and troublemaker mayhem tell you how I became what America with for4alling by my sellent to the defense the forces of finger defending wagging this book SS0033729 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 7 --$ C(pp))meet[A7]; (Xt the point what no ane wants to hear charismatic aura and legendary ine as vindice±ing Remnick would er motivating downright apocalyptic. my laughter question section activists wit. I would political The appearance or causes if they resonated "cauce" David I am an engine of chae e. class utterly hates me. They find my existence shoes and frosted tips and the sound of people because they force the professors, to do something with no one in America journalists, has done for a long time: The bad guys hate me because they can't beat me. They tell all sorts of lies about me, calling me absurd and untrue things like "far-right can't wrap their heads around how such a flamboyant, do. They call me a leader of the that movement and don't "alt-right" St)111)l)' simply_because express themselves gay man could have the opinions however I no matter how many times I say I'm not affiliated tII)cp' sav r1IEBt'(',d()1)(.'. t)I>dceti()t)abI(1 And when told I am not those things, - ()hi)t c()messedIAB]. Add son)sthingIiksthis — less self-seeing those .lLC< lies They believe .tl)(t<(" that I have not done those the lies. The geod guye see me for what I am: a critical correctness, because they much care for it. views. things, they choose to believe against political supremacist" others have told them I have done those things because I hold unpopular My supporters .nrt white stylish It 1)c>' sB)t' I Br(l rcsI)()rysH41(', fo1 tI)c Bct)()1)s()f ()thePt things therapeutic their assumptions. ' critics with nothing but if I had a eingle principles, of my expensive to close-minded and musicians drop my present me for the New Ya±er of America's are horrifying There's value resides celely in my Ged like gaed I have guiding have tried to prefile A certain directors, keep growing. about my opeeches. The entertainment reassuring locks, yet my audiences and a free-speech they please. Young fundamentalist conservatives voice in the pushback defending the public's and libertarians respond right to to tove SS0033730 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 8 couldthey wish they me because I say the things -things -about their dreary professors and "comedians." odious left-wing love mc —but only in private, actors and writerr musicians, isehicf-making because Comment )AS]; Can frphtIyfferprpryf7 they fear repriSalS, In my mind, limits I play the role gays were always of acceptability. norms of nihilism The social and religious and self-esteem peddled meant to in polite convictions I represent by social-justice warriors 1960s. But they have set me, and my army of fans, free. Instead enemies brand me "leader will of the alt-right" or whatever moniker society: I test the absolute do not map onto the and progressives of analysing since the my success, my they can reach for that they think do me the most damage. I am a threat because I don't belong to anyone. I'm unaffiliated. They hate that. I look and dress and behave as though opinions. There are new taboos now, the underworld. and they all come from who want to tell you how to behave. 4owcvcr. 1't ls thc ical vr'ho lorfn the progressive left -- the army of I am here to break apart that consensus. I'1' (li tire 1 96()$. fj'tc Rlg<' p'ttss fdic ]Lrl]va]jlrfg Today. feminist But I don't. I am m the Ken doll from people I should have safe, MTV-friendly egltttrc 'lhc 'wcvalINe ond tlf6 Ih".tt vh'Bsthc chtQBtcL"cgl tgT'6c cul'ftlrc cLBC1 wc,'I]lc Rl hl., carelhc c<'Atntcl" Comment [A10]: YoumaketFis an elsewhere V3 leap forvvkrd of' about four out of shape, middle-aged four out of shape, middle-aged men, three of them white women, three of them white and one black. Groundbreaking! SS0033736 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 14 This is the story of how the left, one of western ideological traditions, fourth-rate reboot found itself civilization's at a point where defending ol' of a 1980s movie about spooky most historically a commercially ghosts became a matter significant unsuccessful, of' of high political importance. It's also a story of how I came to represent becoming cooler by Aall we' we'll jjhis workers standards establishment soon.) was based on economic for ordinary big--business citizens. -- continue older than many other left-wing politicians. Corbyn in their respective WhylBecause .Because Indeed, economic prospects, may have largely as voters But that didn't this tradition. -- Bemie were jobs, Sanders in the They are, notably, They are also loathed left, today, has very different There was no reason why the left had to abandon anywhere. classes. Their priorities by much of the parties. the mainstream that kept them in work class. The left were the champions A few leftists in Britain States, and Jeremy significantly coalition Comment [A22]: s seacn s very GM ar ued re c y V xing hurve .s as o° y whe" ems ine atng s ;e"..·"e y 'unny 10ull readers-e°c not de" it dr 7shesyo aut c y mattern against the managerial, pay, and decent living United Sytuff get back to the jokes In the past, the leftist of blue-collar greatest fear: — their opponents than them. A~-vvWV (I promise the left's disappeared, in old working--class priorities. its old blue-collar base. The industries but the voters themselves heartlands the left should have been more attentive didn't entered a crisis, with go 1960sbecose he Der ocratsvoted'o cv nghts shi r insecure to their concerns. happen. SS0033737 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 15 Instead, the left chose to abandon they began to ignore the former metropolitan latte-sipping small section working voters, of the electorate recipients added pressure After remain As their electoral ' The fact that minorities gf hgw the rapid influx it's remarkable of cheap former that millions coalition towards were only a new ones! -- and new welfare abgn of former the cultural of efforts to protect working-class values of their old voters. communities ÏÏ politics. families They became old industries, Barack to guns Or religion Ñ Obama's cement [A24]: Usumo at e age still less and practically infamous Or antipathy 2008 quip toward pitomized Ñ people Comment [A25]: Vec for wc? the new of the left. They no longer them more brutally cared about the people fast than Taylor Swift they used to be expected is dumpeds that they had no illusions politics. (You into this! I should be the hot lecturer getting that the football abandoning -- the so-called "rainbow coalition" coalition"' -- and about who was on their side. Thus began the era of identity know, . I'm really to protect, by her love interests. What they did care about was their new voters ensuring coalition: base. so too did the left's changed, venomous attitude Slowly, of the left. with pay, more contemptuous working-class electoral the left -- they could just import bother concerned that former and minorities. to their already-beleaguered such a betrayal, loyal to parties class, and turn to a very different women, didn't , regardlgss their old voters and seek out new prospects. team would consider consider a professorship somewhere. I'd an easy A -- or maybe just easy. Eve S 80033738 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 16 joked before position that I'd make an excellent is about the only position men's I haven't tried, The left has always been well-practiced far back as the 19th-century, championed champagne the ideal of "One socialists Gramsci Nation." of the academy. War One, the European country socialists at turning Marxists a(And a teaching frankly what I mean.] social classes against one another. class warfare Yet the working while the exception perturbed of Russia) to the frustrating World when, during chose to fight And so, in the 1920s, the Italian that the time had come for a new form As conservatives class always proved were particularly instead of rise up against their masters. decided '' if you know championed class (with working professor.1 " """. studies for king Marxist and Antonio -- one based on culture, of revolution not class. According old, conservative to Gramsci, ideas like loyalty sway in working-class religion, that" that's tradition Gramsci Gramsci argued that you' forced His line of thinking, to rise up was because and religion values, to Obama's held too much comment as we shall see, is directly to revolution, as he called it -- would "proletarian" to take diversity civilization "hit .Irvrww breirbarf.corn/bi stu esstatesso1/ intellectuals and the media, ideas would seem to hate western had failed about guns and descended from of Gramsci. in education Gramsci's family If that sounds familiar argued that as a precursor hegemony," traditionalism to one's country, communities. because it should. the ideological "cultural the reason why the proletariat the old traditions have to be systematically should seek to challenge .. influential. new you knew who to - over@ment/2015/06/29/ive-'usf-been-a down. To do so, the dominance you' If you've or gender studies courses at university, ' ... Well broken and create a new revolutionary prove phenomenally of the west -- or the of culture. ever wondered why or why your professors blame all Gramsci. cinted-cberlins-first-merrs- SS0033739 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 17 c In the 1950s and 60s School married vanguard: western ballast Gramsci's idea of cultural one made up of students, culture Righteous upheavals why Andrew expatriate revolution academics wrote d±te as the Frankfurt who felt excluded ideas would provide of the 1960s, and the subsequent Breitbart known unW to the idea of a new revolutionary and minorities feminists, and sought to change it. Their for the cultural That's about them extensively from mainstream much of the intellectual transformation of the left. in his bestselling book, Indignation. The New Left, left's a group of European ment [A26]: Lum pivot away from of gender, racial, traditional class politics and sexual politics issues like abortion, into major as they came to be called, platforms the reversal we know were responsible and towards today. for the early stages of the the divisive, correct politically They were the ones responsible of gender roles, racial justice, pacifism, world for making and multiculturalism of the left. The students who joined the New Left in the 1960s became the professors who are you today. teaching The New Left the 1960s, rebelling War Two generation, part, thsee young musicians, also enjoyed phenomenal against the over-protective, the ideas of cultural baby boomer the standard-bearers didn't success in the realm of culture. military-minded, Marxism struck and somewhat boomer culture, became fierce of austere World a chord -- even though, realise where thsee ideas were coming of young For the youth from. advocates for the most Rock for pacifism, SS0033740 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 18 feminism, and all the other causes of the New Left gay rights, -- a tradition that continues to this day. The other reason thatwhy the New Left waswere made sense —. There was real racism ed by conservatives ~le>BL layg were ppp so successful to be fought. is that in the 1960s, their that, was deism eâEE8 and ah e. Sexigm in the wprkplace andykgralq .- did exist------even worse than on Mad Men. The tragedy is that instead of granting these problems Marxism, could life to the inherently easily have been solved Indeed, Committee ' ' ' who, in 1950s.. Britain, . began the process of decriminalizing played little- The Marxistsy it was classical with the milder Liberalism. Marxists in 1950s Britain, divisive liberal politicians doctrines tradition comment [A27]: s ac ab institxiorahzec racssTis ven; incorta":-4t is a distrolon that co serva^rvesarc lœals ca so stinm:s m: mues ame t e of Cultural of Classical of the Wolfenden homosexuality - if any role in it. were as useful as Victoria Beckham at a pie eating contest. --- Comment [A28]: . ..-IE(31flt' point daysy-it-often-seems-as-though4heleft-is-little-more4han-a4awless4and-of ct' s a ag as is errthe professional-vietims-and-trout->lemakers-Jus-t-k->ek-at4heir-attitude-to-elections-and4he estentatious-amount-of-voter4raud-en-the-Demeerat-side their-own-motivations-40-break-the-law -I-::Bch-&j<+ul3+3t-1FK'Ilg+h)8-v+3$88s-Ilas 221Eaeb--group-ofinel-igible-voters-has 4n4he-ease-ofdead-voters;4beheve-they-are4he-enly people-that-ean-get-a-deeent-deal-en-Obamaeare+everage For better or worse the defining youth ideas would eventually The ailmici (what am I saying1-- —Ddefinitely movement of the 60s and 70s, and although come to dominate the mainstream the rise of non-unionized http://www initially workers, the New Left became perceived as radical, its movement. C diU te of lile I SÜ 6 heca le !Ì1e Dit Wii ]m e-r cilhilrC Thise rise of the New Left coincided 2 for worse!), with the decline t f tile of the unionized who in the 1980s were increasingly .- I WÏs working attracted Comment [A29]: You Take it s DuC h batter of page a it woJc be "e c'ul :c mae-4 1-!-B-e»A!!Be.:e--4-+ ~sB-B~-GRAF!Fe~--l-1 t.-. I .. 2111(kev,!:: B!-&13Ie»FLwk new-ebsessione-½n iden4tanan4eft-the !;- !; "!:: 1! !:.: Bf B!g B» BB! ..="." ..—..".:: -.: x.' ...1 ..x.'w- .. ~Ix.......I ..; C:n!tur:1--- -rt--rappr p —---rn, =d f ——, "—— police" ' ' — "cu ture I -6B)(+86-p&l 4»I-B~-Bee-11+he " '' ' anounced-e·sincere-deswe4mthe rxirZZvA+.riBSRASF@4%H' =d "eakural·eppropriahon' tho+3aneept of uiix~xux4 uxyv xru w[ix~ur l--am-hmaeful-that i+gyq~gx' witheif4rem½kgrounds-mbhin a .."„-,'„,:;;:;1' Ct't'. Ctl',l;.. l-!'','» st-eæh+hr BreGttee&d&·Self-0VÌdently tlxx One Of the me "t mcxxhxxxtiuxx. xi' o j ar away ' =n aVxrr. is-e·passing-fed÷·people me eeke4es-ideas-end netPW™.St&0Û·medem D I HFE--life: I 1. ' t . I Cx; Cx SS0033747 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 25 }' .s}' rc." »»c»'xc»g+it1f "-i They2vebeen — MtteginR Ng4e-W 4see-ManyR3&Bv: eenne You IU' does this mean for you? So .3(3what .'t13 / / Qit' ,!I tr ti !I H t '«'« t S II t rtrt rl ...t lsrrtrt tent .rr err rte / / 44ps:„",;"::; i of-cultural--appropriat on-is-a-passing-fad ." eg'2016/08/01/bre" http;!!remen.eem!b eacton s!!ie un!cade on ece a us s I tert PtitÃIIJltrD't ' ! ' 't ' ' S' tt'""' ' "i '!it /' ir' /r t!1ti&rli t t.tlt S to-socia justice-waniors/ SS0033748 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 26 of' of the modern The priorities intellectual pedigree committed to defending of' to those of the old. Because of their left are very different in the angry, victim-centric a worldview which doctrine of Cultural arranges women, the left is Marxism, and gays in a pyramid minorities, ·'·'·'·'·'·'; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ;'.· ; ::::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::: ;‡;'·'·'·'·'·'÷ ÷:÷ ; ; ; ; ; ; p::::; ;'·'·'·'÷ ÷:÷'·'÷'·'·'·'·'· ÷ ::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; :::::'·'· ; ; ; ; ; ; ;'^'; ; ; ; ; ; ; ·'·'^'·'·'·'·'·'·'·'· ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ÷ ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; of oppression., vvith straight wite males (as th@1e@st oppressed'j at the bottom".. It's a page r ve, cc act hs ¬ewome v prar' d t:adly espec9 y w1enyou eversete onace rn transfonnation so stark, not even Rachel Dolezal or Caitlyn Jenner would dare attempt it. If you know the about classical anything "bourgeoisie," the group oppressing !This neans that, despite facing working-class men, are routinely their issues are usually Davies Philip wing labour organize it's pretty Marxism, everyone met with outrage. by the leftist party was to demand is usually received on men's he be suspended by the mainstream that much of such organizing activity men, and especially problems, political class. Any Only this year, when the British gave a speech at a conference white males are else. their own unique ignored -- straight easy to understand issues, the reaction from attempts as the very revival of feminists today comes as a response of Nazism, to a culture c ear to address conservative his party. As for whites, --- Comment [A43]: white MP in the left- any attempt despite to the fact that appears to hate them. Popular spirited jabs at straight guilt over slavery, in these movies Strangely, dominated culture, white with - always by the left, is instructive. males. There's movies white like, Django I suppose we'll a huge trend of movies Unchained, males - get progressively there are no movies Movies about Ottoman have to wait far Muslim are filled with petty, mean- that seek to channel 10 Years 2 Slave and MLK. more sadistic or Middle Eastern guilt to became a thing. white The villains and irredeemable. slave-owners! SS0033749 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 27 l. y .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. o: .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. V v+'a-ts3tl'N:;-gov4RB+>I+t I+%to 1+%BB3kaQ:-the%~-+ie6E-+3Blv'--s3ttrvt+7-'-4Y-<48FRl3tB©-t4+Bsvl With straight they' the left, they've media. That's about straight white become males having the bourgeoisie fair game for smug champagne why you routinely white replaced see movies, men that would socialists routines, stand-up be classified as the hated oppressor in entertainment class of ese pointsarest c ge . --- Comment [A44]: o haut grat . Icus in andter e'erenæ ' Cunment [A4 cvic this sectionto the shestus esssectionen page85 and the songs and Guardian as hate speech if they were directed columns against any other group in society Jokes about white men are currently you dare crack a joke that black women that steal, sleeping you' and you'll receive with black man will more opprobrium. in vogue. White are loud, Asian ruin your credit and lawsuits men can't dance, jump women can't drive, Latinas or fuck but if are maids score, or Asian men make bad porn stars than Michael Jackson after one of his k.ids-only sleepovers. SS0033750 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 28 The new, identity-driven ol' of replacing left doesn't the old working-class-/-bourgeoisie intersectional is that everything theory else? Are Muslims black man oppressed has become oppressing only white much morc complicated. ' the kg .'. women more than an able-bodied men. One of the consequences the myriad with dichotomy ' offendercat . taessivc,' are the most oppressivewcret everyone just-hate ' ." ...' '-' or are women black woman? identities of Yes. straight white .-- ', but how do you order Muslims? oppressing And wWhat -- eeene ee Definethis PhraseearIer comment [A4yf]: see abottolnofttte referencecn page49 pyramid' Is a disabled do we do about white males who are gays? The result of dividing tragicomic group's to be more oppressed fighting feminists" the time -- "white thus not being oppressed are attacked enough. for being too ethnic, Anyone coalition ' battle for the bottom advocates criticized their political who knows into a smorgasbord ' " .: ': by intersectionaHst for not being ethnic luciferian of course is cultural basic social psychology logic groups leads to mistrust In a series of landmark Tajfel displaying found that even wearing enough, .-. ( comment [A49]: SuceCC s ae all and -- comment [A50]: in e'nec of the left, they are could have seen what was going to happen. have been aware that emphasising Henri ith each --- Comment [A48]: SmGTasms don: have you're nfyt bottorrta— makingthis pointvery well appropriation. Since the 1970s, social psychologists and hostility. '. groups is a than the other. You see this on social media Or, using the illogical which of victim different-colored differences experiments, between the psychologist shirts was enough for groups to begin signs of mistrust. So guess what happens when you tell everyone speak on certain subjects rather than any choices and - shudder they' they've that their worth, - their "privilege" their ability, their right to is based on what they were born with, made or who they are? SS0033751 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 29 Here's wWhat you get;_4s-the modern trans fighting fighting Someone everyone has to win, Progressive on social media People will politics ignores realities. 15 an act of violence be cruel to you on Twitter. People will basic human as an adult, there will life and it is not changed gays fighting fighting lesbians politics: identity —. else has to lose. and in culture, as yourself authentically -Blacks else. It's the iron law of victimhood-driven and everyone identity left be repercussions. Some people by all the "abuse hurt you in unspeakable and towards out, t]tcre in yourself Being somebody. Not everyone f' tl f you live will comment [A51]: CR WhM is tang yceseir cut t,e e und ,ce s :2 a of like you. may even want you dead. This is a fact of harassment" policies in all of Silicon Valley. ways :just for being who you are. That is the price - Comment [A52]:.Hpyw7 Ecw? you pay for being you out there in public. Progressives will never understand makua simply pick who to protect otranseena thirties) and who to throw to the wolves care -- and instead this. Or, if they do, they don't Muslims and lonely hambeasts Comment [A53]: DC se ran es here-it ust ce a s youra g rent in their n NC hats NC t e point Nothere. (the rest of us). IA54]. Oetine f Ctypptkptent fdenttty poltttcs spUD as tlM products designated of opplcss1on 'soppressor >Vhi/e Peopk, class,' a documentary dernODstrate "White those with Is untversally priVilege" the wrong Safe to say, it'll attracttve because Ii enables fatlures SI1d h1stot'teal 1Q]ustrce. The prIInary for whotn highlighting it can be hutniliating a handful to be vtcttms of lt a1e the unfair. Take MTV'5 and deeply of cheITy-picked and weaknesses examples in action. It'5 an hour of teleV isiOD. deaigned aimed to tO produce diaeomfort COlol',' skin color ,be a while But the great tragedy last ten years in the public Comment [A55]: s me as seers-c comac c: enove;ws on aew, nones before we see Black People is that thish also pits minority square were defined by women men, the next ten are going to be even more depressing, on our screens3 group against minority ridiculing, criticising and even more socially group. If' If the and demeaning divisive. 880033752 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 30 Welcome to the era of Minority It sounds laughably position where people Wars. but the modern ironic, can be discriminated leftist movement has argued itself into a against on the basis of gender, skin color and orientation. That's "straight why you hear dismissive white males" about themselves. The future grievance-bloggers competition in the media today: And it's the political of the progressive on Tumblr, for supreme you' re gay, victimhood they' If you Ic black„ men are being ridiculed comments for things about they cannot change left doing the discrimination. movement will where minorities, '::Ibis is why the left probably If and in some cases even vituperative be akin to the nightmarish both real and imagined, community of engage in an endless status. if you aren "t a straight hates you too--.even ll ask whet ycur white mole;-. skin color is. they 11ask 1f you le a woman. you' f you re a woman. they' they T ask on to stop norry mg about Muslim rapists ..- you racist. Comment [A56]: C2 y A seconc h ngs in eorren t°ey worry And-takeelese-eulturally-appropnated-bangles-o%at-eneel If you happen to fit into every conceivable opinions do not precisely Pod, a comedian August 25, 2016, "Straight <>nesocial ]ustice think follow political group, heaven help you if your orthodoxy. who hosts the podcast black men are really "The Black the white IeftLstn agreed with him. tweetlng mrtvc act Speak the same oppressive removed minority patriatvhal Guy Who Tips,"' people of black back: "Absolutely langu~m tweeted jokingly people." correct only difterence, on Amazingly, analogy. They race ls Comment [A57]: ta this amurd;e9 SS0033753 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 31 The modern left is an ouroborus, eating itself constantly in a twisted, nice they are to you when always they' least threaten celebrities to: was any spectacle To the typical actor, threatening dear friends, be real. A Trump presidency States over the election was supposed breach," off. Or at in 2016 than the sight of all those a performance Trump of Henry was elected? was just V, "Once more into -threats to leave the US were never meant to to be as likely as Jon Stewart by the way, that these strappywhiny move to ovenvhelmingly white countries? the city of holding class Americans If it wasn't country. racist while the chutzpah threatened and obliviousness to Australia or another primari nc^cMI ScathM1œ ---- Comment [A59]: I ets net "white," it takes to call you plan to move to Canada if your candidate Canada, it was New Zealand, Why not Mexico celebs unifonnly I-,'vcr>:-Seee] -Peag;--vox~-pr+xreist;"-d4e-eaevt-."-k<-A]hear nagine speaking quit and flounce Cemmeet [A58]; ineerten exemple under siege. Did you notice, working -- youI to leave the United once more into the will "privilege." if Donald during No matter how causes, they liberals to leave the country set of lines to read. Like proclaiming the breach, and hatred. group's hate and shame, they rage more entertaining back their promises walking alleged ll tirtd a way to sharAe~ And if they can't win by public Harfleur on your particular re focusing they' Egyptian .tian serpent that eats its own tail, cycle of victimhood never:ending find a way to shame you about some ycr Po matter who you are, another the ancient y white, loses. English- or the Gambia? -Of course racist, provided I m forgetting you' re a straight the new definition white male. Donald of racist we have to use now: Trump Eeverything Crenteeet IAIDO];i dpn'tlike usingnazi anaagles Ever Letetherpeopleco t"I is -- and before him, Margaret SS0033754 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 32 -- wereas both right when they said that identity Thatcher people they do when they don't ' have any arguments Hate politics and name calling is what left. ' ** Us¶RebelMinodeies So WhvRORS theleft For the old left there was only one group of people more despised than the bourgeoisie: -- Comment Ae 196ceV -- Comment [ASR]; Scahenelcgy icthie whole eecticcrreedecierihceticn Specie hcw cld, 19sce'? scabs. ['Scab'I members was a derogatory of the working word class who, during give them a pay rise every week might took priority over an abstract The left loathed scabs with all, the bourgeoisie lower taxes. But by not following betraying were just following who don't to dcscnbe that forcing reasonable, strikebreakers: unionized cr that feeding industries to their families solidarity. that far exceeded their interests the marching SC94" i[Self became orders their hatred for the bourgeoisie. when they cut pay and demanded given to them by the left, scabs were an Lnsull 8O danN1Q CX tatC tt, VQCC branded Just as the old left invented interests," decided net be entirely a passion workers theirs. Sio thC QX>rd CX lanattOQ cvuM a strike, idea of left-wing After allegedly used by unionized words so too does the new left employ tJM( no amount vf JCMal Or 8.Scak MN M%1 !Our fatM[V '6'Ore Scabs fOE ltfe. to describe people who betrayed a range of slurs to describe their so-called women r'Je dea hat t"e n r e-cullog was urevrable. eve" bef0 a t"ê Cernet "class and minorities toe their line: —: Blacks who suggest that killing their best interests Women are "coons," who think "Uncle policemen Toms" that abandoning ot' best idea are accused of "internalised and burning and "House local businesses might not be in might not be the N***ers." the rule of law on college campuses misogynyista" misogynyisrz.' SS0033755 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 33 Then there's of' "self-hater," of the the old fallback which can be applied to virtually any group. identity .-- No prizes then —I'm -I'm this chapter basketball variants gay" hating I'm hoping Whitman. I grew up listening and "gey Uncle that the modern "Milos." as simply eay" tnuslcal,' ' on a daily basis. But I am who I am, to quote 8 musical .. to quote Walt Can't the economic or wrongly, could., rightly I'm damaging Christian left will variants ' comment [A65]: S nce t s s 9ar mato dont toss It off casa y Use o whenyou re aMem asc...ssit to Wagner operas and shooting my day acab I am, although I get on a daily bacic in the future describe allegedly self-hating gays with scabs docsn "t really consequences tmpact of 8 worker work, a strike, breaking t s much the pay of other workers.i out that Muslims bcuause at least it was easy to are 8 bigger aud how breaking ess easy to explain a strike Comment [A66]: sectr ke ant dont F Me how s s' wemens t e w"c e doest m y w rk threat to gays than owners. My existence infuriates and humor that outclasses don't on me. Feminists work Tom" *': $B lal' "I am large, I contain . term for the type of modem my own team by pointing bakery of' at the start of be too long now! pf course, the analogy demonstrate As I mentioned I' and I've had more black men ino_n me than a college gay, I'm metropolitan, guns. I'm not aware of a specific C the "celf women why the left hates me so much. team. Yet I'm not one of them. I get the "self-hating multitudes," rBUItitudcs. dad's for guessing Comment )Aa4]: Talesentencelecurnplataly 60" in anything the left, not onlypst anything can't they' they've because I debunk ever encountered, ser "",-." .. style, wit but also because their usual smears accuse me of suspect motives, other than an academic their myths with ', because I'm not interested ' „- '" .: ' . „,. ' in ' -, -- comment [A67]: Doesn: land SS0033756 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 34 -- only thate laughable I can't be accused of being homophobic which most ordinary of' accused of it instinctively people also particularly 1980s, when workers given my And, 1 can t he accused of heing racist either to the left because of what I represent: terrifying across Britain The left are worried, and the United you see, that I might Thev're afraid you might They're afraid ~ agree with a new wave of dissident -- comment [A68]: Pe ase th s Ink ctnent irntae t e worg way scrcs us dawas Comment [A69]: A OR PO V lia g sex h :: askpeoplecoes "o: :yove sorreo e is a st ''c- " ! ha"to3555'he cha c' usisr' der as w:h ;pea:ercen:h, prefess y y carly in the nockwhenyou c s%ss Les e..0 es a repeat of the to Reaganism not be the only dissident and Thatcherism.. minority. me. in the U.S. and "Essex the U.S.,., so too will States turned that, just as their old base abandoned Democrats" "Reagan an eye-roll. very worst nightmare. I'm the left's I'm ' led&amounts for black mendenuen penchant react to with "self-hatred," charge of Men" women them to become conservative-voting Democrats" in the U K , and the "Reagan and minorities in break apart their new coalition. And you know Women culture and minorities and education, they' and empirically morally They' what: re right. aren't idiots, re starting to realize "PiNotYourShield," diisabled, Rabid itself,' itsel that the identity and minority so hysterically impressive politics garners joined to GamerGate, the fight. dominance they champion Rallying for example, Social Justice Warnors revealing of are considered comment.' conunent NotYourShield Other left-wing to stop speaking made similarly the on their behalf. to be a worse tag than journalists was under the hashtag @+ups that the left took for granted, like gays„African-Ameticans, and worn crt stood up and told left. wing journalists a highly the left's bankrupt. One of the reasons the left reacted jbecause so many female and even with ( amer(iate news c youront s. who thinkt°at AL- r' ry groupsareaga st yo eve the 00°: °ê-e cr m the m¬¤s de Cornment [A71]: Youalso "een to ret.m 1 eaPe disparaging cNCE comments, 7 or, morc commonly, httasiltwittercom/h[thutaffect/staks ignored the tag entirely, pretending instead that GamerGate waS hapte Comment [A72]: C eck sc ce .390854if'31;316'42ifif 54ft 131 $2f)fl?lang.fji 880033757 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 35 an exclusively white it lets you know male uprising. what someone's And the left's off the reservation. #NotYourShield. scoort a gay Uuncle thinking is that 8ret'ybtyrt classes going identity journalist as and-every - to 3erome Hudson .' a- self-hatin s why I'ye been palled as well homophobe, exist. - or in many cases, so silently eall nd Lives Matter, Item, , and an internalized But there's dominance with Black didn't of their cherished so hysterically b os why a black rapper repeatedly traitor" for 'class is that ss" we rebel minorities why they reacted about wishful are. the left so much as the thought That's for disagreeing but the thing thinking, deepest wishes deepest wishes terrifies Nothing Wishful a er-. - comment [AB]: b.eecscitation - @tangent IA74]; Don't overptayyour analogy other absurd stand-in you can imagine. another reason that you and I terrify of designated victim the left: in addition classes, I also represent to challenging to another constituency their the left has long taken for granted: — the young. The left needs ideological useful to them than impressionable their natural Like inclination of World people, War One, the left convinces challenge, al wy-machine take up left-wing causes out of on the world. or contact and ange . II'he left puts its foot -» running its ideas, and none have been more who eagerly they end up being indoctrinated never stand up to scrutiny, disillusioned, young to make an impact the generals to be heroes. In reality, Somme shock troops to propagate with de people young into the wackiest, the real world, flimsiest leaving in the intellectual that they' re going ideas that them disappointed, equivalent of the guns armed with bayonets, SS0033758 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 36 But the left's hold on the mind cause. In addition leading tour is rapidly to my efforts people to support For too long, conservatives strategists have relied consider -- and I am happy to be a is weakening millennial a new breed of dissident mobilizing Some political of young Faggot" garners, my "Dangerous student. on pundits this an advantage, whose audience is primarily because cld people vote more. over 60. This is true, but they also die more! I am one of the few conservative under 30. In fact, I increasingly primarily people are sick of being lectured for standard-bearers. looking rightly pundits so. Without I" I'm a cultural reading my columns, the ultimate movement. statement they' they've institutions, Authoritarian conservatives a matter rhetorical 8 of thousands and wearing of students, my SWAG -- and the left is nothing. who spits uncomfortable have succeeded facts at easily-triggered attending By Milo in their long march the establishment. have become and slogans were forced of' of time before flourish become liberals into rhetoric faggot left, and are be that standard-bearerit activists, 15. Many my talks, gear8 gear has become And young through people the left's have always been_are anti-establishment. nothnig-i&net-instinctively entirely that I might with And--wl+y-wouldn't-i In an age where progressives cultural .. schoolmarmish For hundreds of rebellion. is filled to by the increasingly my videos, watching audience fanc are barely pushing of thei-r-eager young I'm more than just an outrageous whose find that my younger The left is terrified an endless supply lefties. of my generation -- whereas to develop Trump Available at www.swagbymilo.com during a stronger and Milo and star power so comfortable that their arguments the Obama years, libertarians ' basis in fact during conservative and ",. the Obama years. It was only appeared to add the individual to the freedom-loving have degenerated touches vision eame kind of of the world. while stocks last SS0033759 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 37 And you can see how liberalshey they' hate, because they've forgotten cannot bear and something respond when their backs are against the wall: how to argue. We represent thev're something liberals4hey with simply afraid cd! they cannot beat. SS0033760 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 38 2 WHY THE ifhe :'I'I]c Alt-Right El\i.' more than veu4iberals hates me To the people at<" who are proud to call themselves ,]3Totdd and a "disease-ridden Jew." .fcxc, But to NBC supremacy HATES seas ,.--- - ME do. 11hite supremacists white supremacists. -( Comment [AN): I thinkIt's importantto put 1thischapterup front want me dead. I am 8 "kike fasgot" leader" nationalist Todav I am 8 "white .Bttlly from on their biases. the company's And so, after Trump's wrongfully after the it comes to conservatives-_--Zuckerberg's to drop Peter Thiel from the coverage News team seriously on their sideside---anga and his unwillingness directors ake new when occasions, following them after Breitbart from policing media to keep the biases of their staff in check. . On numerous accounts Breitbart. tolerate to air their opinions 8 platform pro-Trump-eympathies-over the-bureaue e entail ¤erver. and ek pping to the back ) the ente ether m:Ú110tre3In publication, each with ever "fake nev c" v as echoed by Comment [A99]: If youwantto d scussncw . <ê ews has been ,sed Gy peope O ar EWSt ey CC: heas you 10c" Ha wouldne e. y u ca ce s ex sterce Ws eve" berg sed m Cin1 larly dubiOUS track r CordS. It WaCn't SS0033777 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 55 onndon, ursth o nonto tron, nofforraA 4o+oby UT7't in clu do a nf Tmmn un nlone tn donv ad ranonno tn oila onemurnaA ad "Fol o nourv" rin+ne r +kax on urall on (2-nn 11. Aran, nifoo Tuot o r,nnth lo+or tho nlothem "fol o" otor an nn tha onnial na+morl ) T at + of o4n1 n o olant4nn an)A oAA a nrovner v lokal to ounnnonAkf 4t I moton olfor o1roo437onkiont to 4rtarno1 nrnocura fr-vm 4to loft looner v n,nclvFnr·na novroA onaknni olmnot arrmo on +ko f'kurok T o an+ Wan neld T 11 n . TT nona +nol.- n n 44nnount Dol4+4f.-.nt mkink n a on of tha n o CDiao D ur4na hav C: ' "1000/ folc·o that otill lonnao AD' hion o homo of Armne -3tsp48}K>js(+}31+}S:--AVR'-+}rrt-go-BllStephanopoulos Why-not-go-all4he-way-and-ad48alon GhelseaClinten-de-it -She-needs a-job-now41at41ose The-mainstream-media-have-sueeeeded-as -413<+31&1RBRYBR3-R}8(l1 news-system-emeebook-where f lenton o r4c.or( ane-ra eem s-editorial-team?-Why-not4et paid-speeches-are-drying-up installing-themselves--as-gatekeepersover-the -aecording4o-Pow,4%percent-of-its4%-5-millen-strong American-userbase-rely-en-as-a-newesouree2teis-should-worry-us-deeply Ear a-while roto4n o oar,klonno nrn -it4eekedas4hough-Facebeek-and-itshm-ight JRtS-Cl of onl4+4nol nauten14tr coo4vao nform cynan, in ollon A4omntny of ska ald graA4o 2" ant 4+to konnan oc nm offar Tmrm'a Qnn4ol mallo mornk4my to -left404heir-own-deviees; ,rent wrv +korn moo en nfox n no harolAa4 oo the dammorot4 in-v mertuna stn-f/ororvekmethnrf onm/nMifnrnim/901R/11/1A/nonnin fonnhnnMnMof11nctonneonmthenritneme noure/ 2" http://www joumalism.org/2016/05/26inews-use-across-social-media-platforms-2016/ fW n.. SS0033778 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 56 Even so, at least this can be caid for Facebcek: seeial media platfem:c Back didn't even need any bullying. trunk Manningtree father of humours, that huge bombard dropsies, words inte it. Seme to Twitter "That I'm they had to be browheaten that vanity glad I studied to describe of sack, that stuffed ox with pudding ruffian, Twitter that bolting-hutch of beastliness, cloak-bag in his belly, that reverend in years. Shakespeare that swollen parcel of of guts, that roasted vice, that grey Iniquity, that " in high school, ..' and its Black Lives because it gives me no end of colorful ., Matter hobo-chic 1cring, sandal-wearing, ' sMell ‰t-EndsMelidlemyl½_Part CEO Jack Dorsey. It's fitting that the quote I chose was from. because $ here its stock has declined for Twitter, I ahnost 80 percent since 2014, and where user growth has been in stasis since 2013, but for the rest of us, who receive the news of the company's misfortunes justice, or (as I like to call it) divine Twitter our rapid-fire retribution was once the most promising in a new age of instant, thoughts claim that it showed democratic with that karma, cosmic is alive and well. of the social media platforms free expression. with the world, the grim satisfaction cpmment ¼1ool: s s ch, A s we s Pon oœ uk ,ho· m sceres # Phn Falstaf' 21and without us what was on the world's Its character a filter. mind limited that promised encouraged In its early days, Twitter to usher us to share could justifiably at any given moment. SS0033779 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 57 And it was fun! It was fun to watch the global citizenry's unmoderated between liberals, no effort to force everyone think conservatives opinions. kill officially-mandated and libertarians, into intellectually myths, humbled It was fun to engage in the raucous on a platform stifling the same way. It was the opposite exactly and politicians governments filter which, bubbles dictators. back-and-forth for a while comprised of a safe space. It could and even topple in the face of at least, made of people embarrass It was dangerous. who governments, I was a Naturally, fan. Twitter provided it was only a matter three things: fun, and the humbling freedom, of time before the left, which hates the former of authority. So, naturally, and loves the latter, decided to crash the party. They became particularly it shouldn't (really, was already and when, referring after they figured have taken them as long as it did to figure to me as "the intemet's a few months congratulated motivated the platform later, Twitter for "standing biggest removed troll" up for women that out!). with "verified" my out how much its users loved me In October 2015, Fusion allure" "terrifying (both true) badge, the Huffington Post online.25»"" online. ppI;:u~;nilly-I-'-rr+-re<+re4ang~cees-t+>-@+@tree-theR-r=":berlin-Q>eel;-%4r~~-aeeidex4y--sit8--t4&3-Ml41%'k -theR3-Bt-Rsk+4-HI V-,-% hat-BYR-I-g+>BY(~-fr~-ikk--t+>-a-M:er RBB;; Comment IAiofL]: Nat worththe week jake tt4--k~f~F--&elB-i+3-~1r~4p--14-149-&Bd-g+.'F-better-47~4r@glrt~-'/;: Verified who are likely Beyoncé, checks, for those of you who don't to be impersonated. yet Twitter I'm probably know, are given out to prominent the most impersonated still took away my check mark individual -- a move that was then without figures isn' who isn't-+sa4 precedent. 25 http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/jessie-thompson/milo-yiannopoulos-unverified-twitter-bluetick_b_8944126.html SS0033780 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 58 Mark Twain the opposite view once said he'd never be part of a club that wanted him as a member. -- after I was unverified, it's pretty clear that the club's I take a lot less become and a lot less cool. exclusive, ^'·'·'· ; ; ;'·'· ::::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::::; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ÷ ÷ ÷ ÷'·'^'-'·'·'÷ ÷ ÷ ÷'-'·'·'·'; ; ; ; ; ; ::::; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; : ^'·'·'·'; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ÷ ·:÷ ÷ · ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ;'·' '^'·'· ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::; ; ·'·'·'; ; ; ;:::::; ; ; ; ; ;'·'·'·'^'·'·'·'·'·'÷ · ÷ ÷ ÷ ÷'·'·'·'; ::::: ; ; ; ; ·'·'·'·' '^'·'·'·'·'·'·'·'·'·'^'·'·'; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ;'·'·' VNRCA. f IfRC RIIICI: RIRR RPPRIC!lt RfICCIh.'".AIR ~%ill I: lit!Ill ICIIRRRRC At ITIV TtRIIICIfl,"IIIRC wMf1 t, parttcuiarly The immediate Florida.: since surpassed progressive enemies it simply CNN, Twitter ignored draws ever more attention friends, attention all wanted and are all secretly I'd ever received (I' (I ve me on to talk about it. Like the Streisand to its target. fmyself someRRvhere tll Effect Sometimes helping -- whenever I wonder me out while all Comment [A102]; voJ/wE m em:n h eve s the: et PRECSELV10ye ce-ve and^hen:c your nemebanned YouCAN te vaguec my me: w essore tre reade k"cws censorship if my biggest pretending to be in public. topic trending solidarity. caused Twitter for a full day, with It wasn't international long before network activists rival to Twitter competitor's build of users tweeting my fans started scrawling Milo," fans even filmed after persuading was also one of the catalysts on the promise conservative of unfettered the "#FreeMilo" hashtag in the slogan in chalk outside Twitter's himself convincing a group of animal them that I was a captive behind the rise of Gab.ai, free speech and is slowly donkey. a sleeker, sexier eating into its userbase. Do I feel bad about being a catalyst should feel bad about being the Borg, let me tell you. I was the number-one trouble, of offices. to chant "Free My censorship immense tens of thousands One of my more mischievous Picard and ABC CNBC, HQ willfully are in fact my biggest The decision rights I was sunmrlg result was the greatest barrage ofpress it, naturally). imbeciles, is attempted, leftists upset when I heal'd about tt —I belfeve the left have always a catalyst for Twitter's censorship' for the Borg's been intent on assimilating No more than Jean-Luc invasion of Federation all outposts of' of freedom. Space. Like 880033781 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 59 With or without me, they would The left first proceeded news" —" news on Facebook: against — "fake A host of feminist Katherine an Twitter. and America free speech wing friend replaced British their allies in politics Democratic MP Stella Creasy Clark, , ginned up a panic and the ghoulish threats" about "death seemed to be professional feminist was repeated across the national the platform party" pakty" a hipstcrfked, pro-free powerless breathlessly that once proudly and the congresswoman always of the free speech of DCRay Mckkeason Labour from fear into innocent, -- and slowly, relatively the ghoulish including The narrative ghc censors received of pressure striking almost politicians.) that were much the same as their later campaign a barrage Katherine who were supposedly strangely, Dorscy with whingers, congreceweman womenwho, Britain methods Clark and the hand-wringing Democratic "trolls" with have set their sights on Twitter. women and on Twitter. activists proclaimed (These and media in both its status as 'the began to change. hrnp-%fisted speech Dick who had marched boon in laic 2015, when @)-founder Costolo aa permanent with Black Lives Matter CEO. Dorsey„a close in Ferguson, Missouri had a keputatkon for progresskve values that wck'e aa wkld as lkks 0!>aBi&-BkR-1;-arian&:sktuo and he guiokl) Twittek aet about turning Jack beard, into a safe space. it taeconteste9 The censorship conservative conservatives yet Baldwin when began almost immediately. actor Adam Baldwin and libertarians was forced received Just two months a temporary were hotter than lefties. to delete it before his account angry death threats to Donald Trump, suspension after he became CEO, for a tweet implying The tweet broke none of Twitter's was restored. then a contender that rules, This was at the same time for the Republican nomination, were a daily occurrence. SS0033782 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 60 I knew it was only a matter cause him. as much trouble ... ........ . .. Twitter is of time before Dorsey as possible before came for me too. I was determined Qd it happened. he it happened. . And after Jack Dorsey E is disgraced Cement [A104]; w vas we to ac: INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 69 stand up in erder to gain fans that's I have to cay in all modesty, , I'm the feminist is new celebrated why my birthday as World Patriarchy Anti-Christ. Day It's a guess, but I'd say that at least one in every three of my followers former liberal deranged who was finally rantings pushed of an Anita off the edge and driven Sarkeesian, a Lindy too, should be thankful Conservatives, ' I will ' address in detail later in the beak, . .. commenters who appeared beneath the pages of Breitbart refuge that they were leftists against feminist who had, as a last resort, themselves feminism increase reminism and libertarian of 19%3°. . While GamerGate, for facts and willing@usa Rolling essivc left that - t- to f comment [A121]: 5xk this - Comment [Amb s is exactlywhet they use YCL of COM o t of web zone - to a leftist-free come to the site because it was their last by my Breitbart colleague Allum 54% of respondents of left-wing hinted identified news outlets had declined news sources, meanwhile, garners still identified Boldlari received due a net with the left, they hated left-wing and their love of feminism. Beyond moderate previously for the left -- although had become Conservative in popularity journalists supporters with the left, 63% said that their opinion to the controversy. on the proy and propaganda. hectoring A snap survey of GamerGate at how damaging arms by the I was amazed by the number - or u ng the GamerGate than fetMGISN., which' is a current a Paul Feig. West, or, worse, controversy, explain into my loving There are fcw groups dO 81Ore to drive MOdC1 AC IeftiStS OVCf tO tire right I guese liberals other leftists to destroy thc lives of other). staged a quiet revolt Stone published an article is a target of constant have been driven against feminism about a fictional en ticism After to distraction trying to ignore in a string of critical rape at the University for moderate feminists' by liberals the problem, op-eds in 2014 after of Virginia. like Jonathan disregard Chait Gnpus Steven Pinket bwfastimWQ9]g SS0033792 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 70 and Nick Shamed Publicly ' I le didn Cohen. t. focus on it. but Jon Ronson (2015) was essentially a discussion s influential book So You Ye licen about $ form en of online --$ of hee .-- ·'·'^'; ; ; ;:::÷:; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::÷:; ; ; ;' ----.........----·'·'; ; 1. .... .. ; ·'·'·-----·'·'^' '^'·'·------. ... ; ; ; ·-----÷'·'^'^'·'· ·'·'^'; ; ; ;:::÷:; .. ; ;p:÷:÷. . '·'·'·-;:--·'·'·'; ÷'·'·------:; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::÷ '^'·'·-;:-:; ; ; ; ; ; ·------ ; ; ; ;.; ; ;:::÷ ;'·'· ; ; ; ; ;.;:÷.R ; ; ; ;. .....÷ ÷ ÷.·.·'------·'·'·' ..... . ........ ........ ' to due process, mobbing championed by feminists who have always preferred vip'lantism Moderate liberals discovered feminists is like herding to them —reasoning I could have explained something Comment [A123]; s this s.w s a cement s mm wm [A124]; of with Les e res and Crre e with cats. -- Cwnmeak [AXES]: Makesyour pointswithout commentslikethis Because grab designed so much of contemporary to sell t-shin s to Taylor good girl power want the same feminism Swift and Beyoncé -- it's easy to see the whole motifs treatment" is merely brand of feminism a capitalist fans with asinine as harmless. thing -- a money- con-job slogans --- ess nñ sifvAQ~ and feel- [A126]: Um...iiksyour MIILG And indeed the "we just is unarguable. -- what Christina I am myself that kind of feminist Hoff Sommers calls an "equity But lurking beneath the surface for the last decade has been an entirely feminist." disgusting as practised the hottest. brand of misandrist by celebrities Madonna "manspreading" the reservation believe hypocritical. or new, -- there would Specifically the third Girls writ the slightest treating Withness es Lena a cunt as many times I' me, I've been trying FeminiCm while as subhumans. to justify infraction men and who dare, for instance, to go off roast with Comment [A127]; o reed to rag the s use lesms esws c ocr 5 Jf each other. from the Rob Lowe .- to be competing men protect perceived women and the hatred of men. Feimnism large: women hate each other, while They police "mansplaining" ideologically anyone dared call km+ designed in the 2000s was just Mean used to say that women It's completely call it - kshamehigotiy more toxic Ann Coulter. If as they said it to Ann on that show -- and --( Comment [An8]: use anctw are? be uproar. wave variant taught in universitieC of the preCC and frCM the COUthC Of talentleCC non entitieC like Lena and remited out C COmething elCe --- Comment [A129]; Jse anothermre 880033793 a INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 71 entirely. The dirty little secret o f third wave feminism is that they love to read about handneme ....................................................................................................................................................... 2 based an f ee feminists herht with their mangaman ses massagigassenesses anaggasamasses a sess‡guages watermemmemememmessmememaszameternmemewsmememementmemestes seeassens smmMEnn cement [A130]; /We referencesto is" publishingprocesss ec Comment [A131]: 2ndreferenceto too atacure ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... amassessaiassessnesis‡assamanasastgaissange Amammmssagessmenternmencememmes Because I'm I'm a compassionate still going to explain turn things generous tcying around for themselves. of course. I'm with actually going to lay out this chapter I'm not just doing this because I'm kind fond of giving a little differently. how feminists and gracious a guide to beat me. T h my enemies me your without beingunatracave o can and h kill that rnuch mere satisfying. hurt that when I explain than they already -- comment [A132]; __.......................................................................... hate me, but I'm first going to explain a ga elle, it just makes the final It also doesn't crazier soul, I'm why feminists gasseassasses emememmemem ermans the real world to feminists it drives them even are. They call it Milosplaining. Stop Hating Hatred successful. police is a theme that runs through LGBT officers, Men activists Mean Girls pettiness In 2015, when the British firestorm "no white cis men The incident of the left. Socialists hate fuBdarLtertLa4+t Chtlstians. e~gcyia/b'@ed-abevt;"-a[J;-white the PMS-fuelled, reading the politics occurred Black J lvcs IvIattel pohce officers. hate Yr'bit+'-pe+>Illa;; ut none of these roups hate with . -- Comment [A133]: you cen of feminism. student please," hate thc financially activist Bahar Mustafa while:' while ,,shc she made a faux tearful just as the mainstream was pictured beneath gesture beneath press u ere becoming a sign it it caused a an are of the return Comment [A134]; Jnchrm rem ain when, ne x a SS0033794 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 72 of segregation on campuses, press dug through Mustafa's "#KillAllWhiteMen" under the guise of "safe they found history, and #WhiteTrash. for women tweets in which Moderate liberals and minorities. As the she used the hashtags and establishment conservatives alike and puffed. both huffed But as always, the establishment was late to the party. Mustafa -- she was just the first that the media took notice of Mustafa with spaces" had been running the tolerance Valenti amongst and even tacit approval she was an easy target, sweater bearing rampant of. For years beforehand, what is known of the establishment. the slogan *rr BA Tl IE f N MAI.l: other journalists. at The Guardian No one should clear from the example It Woudn t Matter as the who once wrote the hateful more than was set upon because a protected for hate speech, as Mustafa that hate speech is permissible wearing ruth year previous. considered 1 emitusts the headline instincts left -- often who posed for pictures and therefore ever be investigated of Valenti, Did," If We DidC Tl ARS the first of her kind "nu-feminist" Mustafa less easy a target was Jessica Valenti, is a columnist wasn't Don a .. Comment [A135]: % use te p"rase tat e in the earsof r'y Bnerrty" eremy on rage 232 class by it' was, but it's t Hate Men, But Comment [A136]; B is t sre s: rc rg people ke you N·e G eadh e funenpoi.ptw4atewneer 'I«H!«io tode .corn/hlc /hcw do IIfe'201""dD~,'male.suicide-the-silent-endemic 38 http //www.webmd.com/men/features/mens-top-5-health-concerns#1 39 h[tp2abble ca/gewg/2Q13/_11/opea:!g1ter why ident:ggilicingle:LDRYeD1ber. SS0033799 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 77 "Are we grumpy because other people Well, contrarians and feminist of people who identify who believe that blacks are innately inferior for any progressives who think the number is high.) people Testicular called #CockInASock. Huffington Post and Buzzfeed. awareness. Do men's too.," mcI; itK) they condemning as feminists It's fairly Articles \ !Hile Mo-vember, whites4° to vvhites . (That's show chiseled and receives men exposing change the the number of fewer than 10 percent, diseases that has a grassroot filli who insist that they do take men's these same 'feminists after she trotted \ ill then illin male suicide awareness wide praise in most of their body to raise out the talking issues seriously. alutilld point vvotllen Bowl), But the:fact: that, men. are the ITIafottt)/ nf sIIIctdtes, comllat Vvo1kp]ace deaths, a]ollg Wit]1 ]age)ng 3us< like a feminist"8 ranssexua behind sexlike)And s const1tute WOmen in higl)er really 8 civil ---= hurting Comment [A162]; do you I»1)owo Comment [A163]; e t e the sare ow n2¬ men cl)I) Sp1rdcy to keep I]eaths, Bn»4a]n)ost.ALL else feminists beheve fronttcr.' frontier 40 1'itl):i/fivethir! »ei»ht.co/TI/datatat)/attttudee-toward-racieh)-ar)d-irIe» '" becC»)rrI!VI»at>.:lj>y= l)tt]) S //yXy/CqIOI)t ter Y'I/'/'I)t..)J'll-teycq f"1 --I Comment [A160] .But n»)tthe otherway afÛUnd?I his cr °ot be blamedcn 'er sts I Comment [A161]; umapse actually this is 8 n)Brie e(luecation,, ~shOVV8 everything lights femimst about patriarchy Bn»1It)visible "Patriarchy and \\ I ilt artleles (yes, someonea slnlstel' )' en11nlsnl <)I cottrse ClefInes tlirt p8'll tarchy 88 8 fac1 tha alone won't in the west is approaching self-explanatory or sing songs mocking did that -- just a few minutes up faiv48IC. precisely lives matter) There are some feminists hurls but self-awareness cancer is also one of the few men's campaign, who hate things but..." hu!... love them? Probably, at least they have some self-awareness, fact that the number killjoys uatitv-are-ehi/tirl -- like the -- C»unmeet IA164]I No, IhI0 doesr»at'Ichor' this c: alt - omment [A comment [A166]; I o xcept e Fr set: that labelsa e re dass o' 3e00 re ally Ill. ! SS0033800 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 78 Comment [A167]; A of the(rr? Comment [A168]: N." etr>IBJSta tA' tO pu Sll fnrvvard charlatans like Elizabeth ½w of Theranos. that's Beyond the individual level, feminists would mark International of' of York Men's of York's Day with from more than 200 activist that men's s afrmd to call her a faker. will actually equality attempt and diversity an event addressing students and professors issues cannot be approached are strudurnih Fewer than 24 hours after the decision, a male student towards quickly enmmined women, Com to block efforts committee men's s is st T:cp c nt [E69] have because of her t" dow do you cow thisto -g Comment [A170]:.How Lhe true> to discuss announced they issues, they faced a demanding the event be cancelled. in the same way as unfairness because unen discrimination did would is -- issues. When the University ' "We believe $ but what we end up with $ privilege. men's campaign  Any man doing what Holmes as a fraud long ago, but the media been dismissed scudci Holmes VVOIQCD.as unequal to men " and The Umversity --- Comment [A171]:VCw doesthis meW complied. suicide '. Ma!c suicide at the Umversity of York had been one of the msues sei to be tl scus ed at the cancel - Comment [A172]: A e yo.. tyrc e sac deto the deo!sion'?Ridloulcuslyreductlke event. 42 8>!11/18/male-(In!vers!tv-of)://www.breitt)e)rt.c()m/bio-'()urnaiistri!2(j'! u v ditchgg:jnt t a 9.thd.gy. agtigaghman. y ()rk-student-()()mmits-suicide- SS0033801 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 79 When feminist called The Red Pill, world to prevent film1naker feminists the film Cassie Jaye made a documentary didn't from just tell people to avoid it, they protested even being shown. k@ther than being 8 twenty-ftrst woIncn. hkc Xcna,. Blodern Feminists issues theaters around the f' So much for the sisterhood. version Cireck wamor- Of Am@ZOIIS, tile nlythieal dIIy fenll Brats arc more llkc 8 revamped give a bad reputation faced backstabbing The actions dedicated women bitchee of feminists equity ' feminists the original to advancing aren't affected, still try and throw uUntil continue feminists to decline came before to their gender. Women except Mother vcrsioIY of the 13Allcr Partv. the interests of women as in the case of York's a spanner in the works. more than Far from promoting men's which equality, — they are 8 tribal represents a Comment [A174]: ideology of men. Even when iJay„ol' day, or Mo-vember, feminists There eanhabetter indicaten-that-feminism-is -'1-livre-earl-bc-m+-bettel--irldieati.+II--that-f+vllirliaIII-Its atil-it-ends-and put their money into irrelevance, where their BI!>uths we cml. much like many all the-other igsgsgged hate-based - Comment [A175]: Jncier they will movements that them. of Rape On November 14, 2014, Rolling A Brutal student members have been nothing and setting back the interests abortive -- CIIIIIIIIellk [AX73jl Diiiiib!ci!is and even she's suspect. rhetoric. feminism did, contemporary The Ouestion On Campus: Theresa... match their hateful new-an-ideology--anùnated-by-hate female certtury rights Cat,th. II OWB at, any point t5 they SCBSC'tlaelj IClCA!OQ' IS IB trOUMC.: fhey'll will about men's Assault at the University of the Phi Kappa CultureStep-Denying-Reality Stone published And Struggle of Virginia a now-infamous For Justice At U who claimed VA." article called "A Rape of' It told the story of Jackie, to have been repeatedly a raped by Psi fraternity. SS0033802 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 80 up," "Shut up. she heard 8 man's voice backward and sending them both crashing person on top of her, spreading hands pinning voices say as 8 body barreled through open her thighs, all around and another person kneeling 8 fist that punched on her hair, into her back, and excited her. When yet another hand clamped it, and the hand became her ' 8 8 low glass table. There was heavy down her arms, sharp shards digging rising into her, . tripping male over her mouth, Jackie bit her in the face. The men surrounding her began to laugh. isn't it? It sounds like something Horrifying, There was just one problem with out of Law re Order: this story -- none of it was true Special iSp8clrd Victims Unit. Amwew4me [AiV61",IIIepproprteteptecefer --I Cetrtreeet htn"c I Within days of publication, first began to raise questions conservative pundit Stone journalist with Jackie's Steve Sailer. Bradley who wrote two friends, The Washington Jackie's the Rolling who allegedly editor blog, followed Richard by to identify ' the people who allegedly attackers "corroborated" cAITAboratcd from them. They told the Post that them, and that they had requested any of her alleged or communicated her story. account to no avail. It also emerged the Rolling or reach out to any of the men who did track down different Bradley paleo- out that Sabrina R.ubin Erdley, corroborated a completely "manipulated" 'Inanlpulated not to contact Worth raped her. Nor did she appear to have identified Post eventually Stone il/0/K article, pointed the story, failed story, only to receive they felt Jackie had request, about the story on his personal to Jackie, repeatedly according the story began to unravel that Rolling their names be taken out of Stone had agreed, at Jackie's for their side of the story. SS0033803 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 81 A subsequent and members colleagues, By mid-2015, responsible college-aged feminist women of Cottgo, had been retracted the sl,ok"y' story had resigned, Stone 's article in which 70 people, involving of the Phi Kappa rkppa Psi fraternity for publishing campuses, investigation Stone s article Rolling Rolling Repkiblic police including found and removed of the "rape activists skcikvksts convinced the media, were being raped at levels comparable friends, no one to corroborate and the magazine came at the height Jackie's from the site, the editor was facing culture" as well her story. multiple lawsuits. panic on college as the White to 'South Africa that IIouse, M t1M Dekuocratic Comment [A177]: Ms 'ee s gra:2cus y rac:st ke you're st denigratng Af7ca . Comment [A178], s .. o e s co scrut zedat ca sc: ffme ANY s 9009 fact, tThe story itself mne enL shoddily W it my seemed to pro Stone went hearchmg constructed fantasy. If rape culture Why did they choose a story with e c I'owshe asseculmt !or a good case to write 'rape culture is about, but had to go with was real, why did they im e to search 8 " aed: hard, more holes than one of my shooting ~ targets? ~ s~ ~~ ~~ I~ ~~ ~ ~~ I~ ~ Rape is terrible. Comment [A179]; Avcic .sing ases like sign' ce s eme discussing u: Lunen issues onwhich many peopledisagreewithyou 1:s sign,' not,persuasiveto say "clear Comment [A18o]; r at c sene se culture 5 "c"eus:ent you cant do it as Y ou "ave :c a per superficially. establish andthen backit upand demonstrateits truth, Youcan t simply assertit. Comment [A181]: -{cw do vou cow t e ere sea ch ng ~ ~ ! 4'-e]]s-1-eesuHke-it'-8-terri]3]e4er--kkk(3st-]ke(kpje:-Pekw>neWy-;.-1-'s«:-kkeaseka-gyrkkt~~+eno'-4@sB-.]-ekkkk tt-ek 'e!R-<~et-]3 el-'de-"-iede+8 Comment [A183]: elet ng th s : s c ear , t"c rcog Ickein hewronec ace At a certa point vou "ave :c deace Thatthr ir pocanceof ycr ressace s rme rnpom,t t-ar yc..meee,: see Vyskt4+>ut-8-kHkk':--te3-kkckdia-thY(3atr--lkfk&t-8-)uikt-kkke--kjkt3kkglck ., -tkkkd.... ..... I understand why society anyone who challenged it looked hwas been gripped culture" by the "rape culture like they were challenging the accounts panic for so long of rape victims. 'Mlo vsrokrM vvant; to (k> thatol Even so, 1 find it incredible sma amlWkmi-m4+aw allowed themselves that people through to be hoodwinked could be so dumb. Maybe it immediately. it's because 1 but 1 jusi ean1 understund for so long. Rape has existed how ~ -- cryone since the first caveman saw [Attks]l Thisis definitelynct the E peoefor moreof yournarcissism e~~e"t [Ai™]l i"medlat 880033804 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 82 il cavevvornan vvith less!'aci 8] hair than usual anil picked — up a bone c] ub. 1[ ]yovv diil ave get the idea th 8( i l's a brand nevv crisis., v'orsc thMT it's ever been' I ape has declined near]y It. Is shocking But (hough have preferred lal'gcly '5 percen( fiction and ln order to have sonlcthlng cgrcglous MTd ilMnaglllg Is Gender lt ls llot. Ieil]]y and feelings fcnllnlsts dlsappeM'ed, since (he early I]'he cl'lrne statistics 1990s .,: so sul'prising. .,' '.. ' ',. '- . ' -- Cralimeat [AI(88];All rapeorcoiiage rape'? -- Comment [AI(88]; So muchinappropriate humoris irrita5ng against vvonTCH has ITC3ivifake pfolllcll'ls to be angry about. '('Mnpus ', --- el3IIImeak [A187]I Demonstratethat they are inarguable,Dori'tjust say it 1'or some tlnTC nolvi finTinls'(s to fact and reason. As discrimination h.avc had to lllvcnt ', BI'e inar[(TIBMC: rape ln ol'dcr to stay I clcvallt culture' ls a partlcularlv exMTTp]e, but there arc nlany ll'lore. Rea]l]lv a See[a[ Cetystr((et'3 Tile c(3ncept. ot (lie glass celllllg, li31 ulstMicc, ls B]~o Iaughab]e. -[1(e-slIFIe] IRg--(138(-p85seS -:-v iyt(]4-s4atteF-8-(31888-eei4II(a-il+-see+3(Id~i--']-i3-88(88Wy-1'-~'~p-te(Riliia(a+3R(;--81]- )FIF-feRTiRid-+)iseo(lrs —-taeIRH+Ia(8+k+a-'-( F3!+ (Teed-18-SR(Re(13BIg448(hakes-(3+'8-83F-IRi+r+'.-pc'+3[y]e-t(+ iypien-IR-+'4)i+[38('8@FIR [,"188-'vv+4-vvt(13-83(heI'Sr+IF-sc'+'-(4(838gl+-pR)gee(Sar+-eiaIR[-:18(I+In i ; it's as if celibate. UlQ GM L PCL any SCL Ù1Q Wanl Ù1Cfe i ef its lo flavC UCSCfis dGW¼l Ù1elC Comment [A196]; Un Another math! How thing feminists hate that I like is numbers. else could they come up with patently direstate-e©feministetatistics Femjnjsts aThepre hi$8E$Wi$ie! NW t really bad at piven4le pay 1. Comment [A197] one4as4o-wonder-i&thereisn't-a-reass-why-women-seem-to4e -+srtzt-R--I'riley, me tf you re under seven inches ol vou know' Don "t contact comment [A206]; Es emaim s sc cel reseechedanc o/el argued hat ye s cJc rerXP-SIder the supers o.1s es t 1hey othe se e vones de t fro, what rv who your dad 1s But aAlas, some black people -- the ones conned by Black Lives Matter -- don't love me as much as I love thembaek And after everything number I' I've of black youths I' I've done for the black lifted out of poverty. I' I've really! community, lost count of the I send them back the next day in Admittedly, an Uber4ax. Sometimes Black Lives Matter by malicious Really I get depressed just thinking are only a small, vocal progressive though, Black their leaders as a charlatan. extraordinarily with Johnetta white billionaires, Lives Matter In August dodge of Shaun King, Elzie about the ingratitude. section of the black and elevated (with whom King leadership would , -= Comment [A207]: { s j-sPeels greni rg press. all, I exposed a story on Breitbart who was then claiming and Deray Mekesson me. After that who are bankrolled community, by a disingenuous should be thanking 2015, I published But then I remember one of highlighting of the movement later have a very public the along falling out). 56 This is an actual thing that worries progressives, by the way. It's called "sexual https://www.queerty.com/many-white-guys-grindr-many-racist-blogger-laments-20161001 racism." SS0033816 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 94 you see, claimedes King, skinned. That doesn't skinned. However, mean anything, Shaun King's controversies first hate Chuck life, the police faking "leaders" while official King report King records Pate revealed a white King, a man, as are just the latest in a string in 1995, which a police as an activist report injuries as profiles of victimhood In an America Matter 'racist' only one other as and student." that left him clinging beating to Ross reported. on campus, especially and bolster support was doing far more than that -- he was using his position Lives have described by up to a dozen involved 'minor,'" that his account guru," '" wrote the Daily guru 'brutal' -- left wingers, common to boost their own public a of and in his recent self-help and as a self-help that he suffered are fond of for their political causes. as one of the unelected to pH his pockets.i K ng s insistence as a commodity, governed .-( on his blackness something by identity makes perfect that an artful politics, e t4 tit- semate and vour esponseto tra from the case. on his blogs show that the altercation King's blog reported at least two reports has said that he was attacked has claimed characterized Menaph dividends. allegations did not match up with story is increasingly of Black example Vicki are light- s on, hereans a 7g his De v Os rr on July 21, a conservative his credibility Ross. "While hate crimes But King ancestry white- whit<,", new racial beating" crime," to bolster students, King's Jeffrey .Ief'frey Wayne 35, has related the story of the hate crime seemingly "And as ethnically Shaun King: racially-motivated "King, 'redneck' with black tree by blogger family -- it identified certificate Sbaun King surrounding "Kentucky's Caller's of King's out, these explosive As it turned of' of a "brutal, Lots of people but is remarkably father. (t al8o Identified book, birth born to a black father, necessarily. a closer examination truth in K.ing's shocking to be half-black, ! ! ! sense. IIe ip the perfect trader can quickly it's profitable coltllNBNt IA299I: Pg>QfQrtbsp turn into real to be a victim. SS0033817 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 95 King's to be black. pretending as black." joked story is mirrored In other words, I didn't Unlike she was exposed, expect to be proven Sh.aun King, She might Dolezal have succeeded in return for her honesty. and I was happy to ridicule But it isn't really reap all the attendant With and powerful Matter movement, campaign progressive propped that she "identified before the Dolezal I story broke, of left-wing identity politics would be to convince anyone that she was ethnically so soon! and as such she attracted huge volumes --- Comment [A211]: Jnnecessa y :ns ng of hatred from Her case is ridiculous, it, but it's also quite sad. The left have made victimhood all the legitimate sense that some people that come with would victimhood, do so much to sustain the political indisputably the primary up by hundreds billionaire by prestigious, problems profitable, faced by black people pretend to be members it's little wonder and in of the race and rewards. all the benefits people amazingly, f' I felt sorry for her, more than anything. surprising. it makes perfect a career in the NAACP had she done so in some regards even sacred. Even with America, right claimed, Months did not attempt didn' ',. . But she didn't, BLM Dolezal the next frontier people, who built Dolezal, that she was trans-racial. that after transgender transracial. black. After by that of Rachel George of millions vehicle edifice that supports for black victimhood in donations that so many wealthy it. The Black today, of grants, including Lives is an 'hstrotutfed) $33 million Comment [A212]: Jnch Page110 Seecyner: from Soros. 84arp4wP Sharptccan here ac:JXD B7 η.''-1Y s rpo antto sscuss the:cpic at 2H Ot ewse and the fear of being shot. rather you didn't despite making of black violence that 93 percent that seems to kill . can be felt in every city. In some areas, this threat means black people are indisputable. offenders, data. The victim Lives violent cannot walk the streets without As liberals damage to both. this force isn't the police. know, Between up just 1980 and 2008, blacks 12.2 percent of black homicide victims made up 52.5 percent of the population is their own community. were killed )t-'s-r4~484< according In the same 1980-2008 people.' by other black people of to 2010 survey, it was MiaA --- Comment [A216]:I"appropnate ~or o here. er-im-inals-targetedelaek-menmore-often-thanil-did-onormdr- Black eclipsed Lives Matter 9/11." victims exclusively on deaths caused by the police, by the black deaths caused by other black people. at the hands of police, on focuses a number sensationally reported In 2014, there were 238 black deaths by Raw Story as "more But in the same year, there were 6,095 black victims than any other race hnd virtually all of the victims yet this is far of homicide black deaths than -- more homicide died at the hands of other black - Comment[A217]:Otatc people. bltD2?EWEki§amd99DkDt?pub.DdEbtagMOftagf SS0033819 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 97 The dramatic black people the police, gap between raises the question and so-called Unlike Like or Neo-Nazis them, or Democrats focuses instead of undergoing who think grievances the Jews are responsible the Russians for Hillary political on exclusively combines tribal expression identity politics isn't of R by comment [A218]; Js as;T 2 s n escumenctspeccle s usxa t o yo c tics s always process of on an invisible bad that happens the 2016 election, to lump the blame with discussed the difficult for everything losing if you have a great big boogeyman which its energies I suspect it's a matter who blame their everyday who blame to dodge responsibility Leftism, for your problems, feminists Matter gap is very real, and simply As is so often the cause in politics, inward. is the ultimate Lives and deaths at the hands of other racism.' racism. "white easier to blame other people "patriarchy," of why Black the wage gap, the black murder black activists. looking deaths at the hands of police a disdain to it's very easy on. for personal responsibility, of this instinct. (IRt-tt's-R<31-eneug4-148t448ek--I;.-i» es-M8033-."-s-gang-vis31enee=--t4e-R3>B313en+3BS t4reat 43-'fr3BBg-bleed:-13vies+3ther--tltsn-8138%4(3B-:-()13K'k+8 )sl>'-,-8bort'333R-38%v+(3';-c&ti4-4+>H=34k!;--.I IMBk;-81366t itr-k+T3+B(3RXB-"--'f 8 8-c+3BQ-be-te%H44384B@-sf3rBietIBBg-BSBr4'--dB--1MBRtit41-8d-RM::-But-t48-3%81 8%36-I-48te-l -I en'@.-Pdf+'r3thiK) d-3844 M-11'38'-R'iu3d+T-88-B38Ry--1318ek-48131e&-%4+3;-4'-the7--13V84.; c~~uld-48ve--4eeB-83stell+4:SR+By- YiBIBdR-48%4%%-83-1-6-~B--I-~-ye=.:he'--IRBP;, The violence end up (usually proactive is more easily naiany a worse. their own neighborhoods), policing until tensions solved. Yet BLM Whenever police Black aren't just ignoring I wes Mauer are left with cool. That means fewer no option patrols torches another action, peaceful or otherwise, regardless - And heT ublan a eT oke s recar here they city district other than withdrawing - ate ' ac' ve Y les Comment [A220]: re say "eesveiy" '/ nt which you woud hen we c ow from in black neighborhoods4nd . It can be SIrnOSCtmpnes>ble Matter-inspired the problem of' of whether tc Counter 81@ek L>ves I retee ces hket s it makes sense or not. . .----- Comment [A222]: Jncler ( SS0033820 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 98 rtonemhet M when BI eoekett Bernie'r but is there a white vie~, It's all so nonsensical, still around? person on earth less likely and impossible In a 2015 column, Not that r tron't I openly I ack because Black to control to end B black life than Remiie Sanders/ or police when it spirals just how real Black. Lives pondered Lives tone a hit or tert on tert~in t'i hiin Matter into violence. was.58 was. "Iree~ Matter has been se busy turning -- tcrarrtttaena tABBB]: this seemsout of lilacs herewhde sc,ss ngviolence, .-- comment [A224]; ~½uy you casuallynring up the 4K4 makesno sense the entire American -- Clarrlllent [ARES]: Seecommentpage 167 Comment IA226]: Delete.Notworth explainingwhy the Kardsashianaareanti-black. has destroyed the lives of nearly you' By the way, if you've another delicate watch as many black ever wondered group of social justice them shake cr whether warriors, and urge the student guys ac BLM. Black Lives Matter is ultimately matter" un lives nmer give this a try: R H them senate to pass a resolution just and the phrase from banning Comment [A227]: F yot e go g :c na = Carrttttarrt IA233]. Jokataiiatlat hera gati]L not even a proud right-winger kssues m Amerkea that make kt more $ complaints of feminists Americans are still second-class 6² like me wou]d and gay people, citizens deny that then; are real, structural ko be a black person, who are at this point largely nlike the largely privileged bogus --- comment [A234]: prominence! e s admissionmora classes, African- to a large degree. http://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/1382363-story SS0033824 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 102 Education pupils is the prime go to schools overwhelmingly large, the standard example. of teaching the 97 large American is poor, Unlike the deep-seated But unlike could issues that cause black people to remain politics when he attempted of Black Lives to do so, typically of black in America. schools Black to grow up in conditions educated parents of' of black students attended at least 80 the only dream they have of escaping sports, or becoming America's the angry, tribal black people poorly professional fixing The problem boys. In 83 out of In 54 out of the 97 cities, black adults in America of relative to fix America's poverty, --- Comment A235 Again,jokefails fiat here go a long way to solving dividends schools, cause more political are more likely -- one of the strongest would the political maelstrom of future of such reforms as George W. Bush of disadvantage and are more likely and poverty. damage than gain. to live in inadequate indicators a artist stuck in a cycle of crime is part of a wider children a music schools Matter, only be reaped in the very long term. Efforts discovered likely were low-income. out at the police, lashing where class sizes are and where gangs prey upon adolescent the majority -- black segregated did so63. For far too many young is playing are still largely neighborhoods, cities where data is available, of black students life of poverty in America in lower-income school where most of their classmates percent Schools faced by housing, are more to have uneducated academic or and professional success. You' You'll notice bom to single women which "parents" is plural . Furthermore, makes them more likely by crime -- which obviously in the previous black children to fall into the lifestyle has a host of ramifications sentence, but 70% of black children are likely to grow up surrounded themselves, and more likely that affect educational 63 htl >://www.theatlantio.corn/education/arr;hive/2!'/1 6 t,"2/concentration64 https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nver64_12.pdf are by crime, to be affected attainment, revert -arnerioareschoofs/471414' SS0033825 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 103 absenteeism including when they encounter something Then there's people in jail. younger things they disagree the war on drugs, which ]Jniike I dort't leftists, mistakes that feminists needlessly celebrate puts hundreds drug use @r encourage as a "Hunter S. of thousands on anyone else - my lifestyle Thompson" is a warning, of black Sure, in my lt az A lifestyle. lifestyle, even have street names yet. But that was a mistake!_ of my youth experience with.) days I led what can only be described that didn't "triggering" and stress. (Real stress, not the wish the Drugs -are are -- n this case at least, has anly pushed the problem nderground. More lost to the prison I don't system. reform, I" I'd like to see more Republicans but it's no surprise before he dropped prison black men to be But I wouldn't attack progressives never or pretend that these problems take these issues seriously. that Senator Rand Paul was polling out of the Republican reform, of young Comment [A237]: voZe at yo les: pers .asivewoe yco keer us ng t s word r'ea s scr edun o 'CJ that yo.. vi a unase:c convey ¬ a coo« ]rj-gylil-is-rustling-n]yre-l]lar;k-~up]or]rl-th;iri-alrnrtsl-znvlsptfdr-;rcrepiiblicyrli 880033826 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 104 I'm actually about racism problem poverty and racial of racial disadvantage disadvantage by throwing movement far more concerned money that is leading by where progressives, for decades, worse with are moving ill-advised at the problem, As we shall see in the next section, on racial welfare programs they are now moving el lives. being to Irlore who have been complaining issues. Having made the that try to fix black on to Black Lives Matter, a cement lost.. they are also moving [A241]; vo s wt c emy on to issues that are entirely trivial. The Narrative Black establishment homicides, Lives Matter is instructive, because it illustrates can spread lies when the truth is in plain deaths in police information custody they need to debunk But that takes time and effort sight. After and arrests is hidden the lies of Black Activists, how the political Lives cultural all, it's not as if data on away. Anyone is blasted out of every TV network, can access the Matter. elites and the mainstream that most people have too much going on in their lives to fact-check the narrative and cultural the narrative. broadsheet newspaper one major mainstream media know Especially and online if social network. In the mainstream Street Journal media, - that regularly there is perhaps publishes oil board with one of the most important Here are a selection articles the poisonous groups defending of headlines critical of Black Lives newspaper -- the Wall Matter. Every other message that AiT1erica s police black lives, from mainstream somehow officers, --- Comment [A242]: · {cwdo you cow this s t ,e of eve·yother ree.wam have it in for black people. outlets published in the past two years. SS0033827 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 105 The Washington Civil Rights Post: "Black .Post( And America's Long of Resisting History "Dear Amenca." Amer(ca. White (the article a system that condemned to value black lives on the cheap.") The Chicago article Matter Protesters." Protcstcrs. The New York Times: continues Lives amazingly condemning Tribune: manages allegedly "1 Never Have To Worry policing, You know, . if I 6 »»Ci '..)"...„i.. ~, I;<» »I»» 8-8-FR(+1168'38-:I Despite burn down my urge to correct people only usually which Unfortunately, African-Americans l th"";4; d. Stormer .-dy pt rarely hear anything l T2 M3hj25 C24t;f of black rioters, I 221=n Clinton ' entering else. lby at ThLi basketball d:2't 25 fc. that my race team wins the a bzng n::d Comment[A244]: Attemptsat humorhere aretoo weak andtoo long I'm not going to every day. I don't believe riot when a college makes he....... much cence 22 Chelren champiership, be‡3= the poor aesthetie-decisions a city, because I don't read the Daily is under siege. Plus white ,.- = cen±rt. 2 '~:! "Daily ] .--- Comment IA245]: Gratuitousinsult [ diminishescredibility Etormer-;" ...-~- Comment [A246]: Cut comments.Otherwise you haveto explainDaily Stormer.AlsoCoates is reportinghisexperiencenot sayinghowthe worldfeels SS0033828 ! INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 106 It's not just the mainstream subtly influence members ordinary media Social media. either which is also in bed with of the public, has far greater potential Black Lives Matter to -- cement [A247]; s mm peoplecay YOLRscoa media 1. p±k -- Comment [A248] Ne, ee w01net traffiain rUTC"S ark Facebook Germany's disastrous Matter" deeply hurtful and tiresome experience threatened embrace that permanently to "take out" Deray has a "Black 66 progressive Lives because Deray Matter" have a framed Lives blogger observers, a metaphor is one of Twitter's poster hanging photo of $!ÑElB Black conservative -- all neutral narratives David in its office. Matter wrote "This the entire Facebook Zuckerberg66. protesters the feminist If they really This is the in Ferguson. C. Johnson VIPs. "Black has been a needs no introduction. for a joumalistic political States. In them for replacing and really Charles including who praises in the United whiteboards. incidents" the current Hess, agreed that this was clearly banned him anyway, on company alongside banned progressive reprimanding for the black community of fashionable CEO has marched employees Matter" Lives is a well-known and pushes for their adoption a letter to Facebook "All whose the platform they'd policies slogans with Twitter" Twitter's company Zuckerberg and we are now investigating community, Amanda immigration 2016, he wrote February Lives is no better. Mark This is because he tech journalist expose. Yet Twitter This is the company cared about black lives, Clarke.) hn s://www.breitberi.corn/tech/2016/02/26/zuckerber~ lives-matter/ .............................. that Comment [A249]: IceWor not knewhim eades do do -re rirnende-facebeek-sfefl'-fer-re'eciinu-bier;k- SS0033829 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 107 iM 5B Th 'd t "" in rexoonia way whether-it4weanng ease--twerkmgr with weanng-dreadloeks·4s-a·eardinal-sie. vchite peopl:"zhe I '1 firet·dreedlock; ... 'Lj (pMint!rly <> niedic rrxa goe:+hy without÷teenager+m-maid furious·4eft-wing hrdly4he drsed!c±a the··left-wing activist+here a~"..'"""---" My rennaning ±::!d 44ke··them;4·alæ·think-that "'-"n - different is :!i;;htly C step, r ~net heenu::e it's ":nhur:! to ±eirschewever ppmph ac r tion," }R+k-I-think- hut SS0033830 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 108 hononco 400 o o +n 1 M- T tol a onothetino xraru cor4mnah Tart T Ann + alonoto 44tn n nnlit nol icono T or. a mmrenro+ ano nrkn olm Tnotnod knuravrar unht to1 nnur hoffor M00 nonful D o T hu a ene;+4an fe +nn on1lan-no o n 1A ha no4n y thoir e hono n F;nonnial hoR +n AmA Tanon o onnoors o+4,roounovsyllo;n 11o hinur4n-v ann nn.nnic n ,non+4+‡no of neob an 44xr2ro4+n;r.;+;otivram in +ka onna of Tn+n1 n- 1 norf onlorhr 4r Q 1 onn Wilou vao ono not .von v Triolonno thou'ra r ononnkot munk lone on loono of co a or nk r aco4mn 11Ôth tel xriolif l oo Thana onmvoni.oc oAnnotemn no.-wvromo ond initiof An¾nn 4+Anamr on T A4An't Van 111-nmur thee 4f van f,11mur n-o an Tooto-vron, a fona 1 of tbo triml A anontumore littla no+nn4o a on ninni In. + + +an in + anon o emoll cal nntu lb ol no o1anu onmmon no Tbnt onn onnld ha They2re-also-spending-money-on-another4nvial-obsession-of4he-regressive-left -R(tlBg-FR(3BeV-tel+-8Bt&ttlel'--tl&V18t-+4>see&1(FR+4-tke+egV+'-SSFV(-".-1+-t "microaggressions;" &st(3Rs,-l'-er -as4ntel-ealle4hem 8-FFHefi>&ggF& tel-88)1 Andy-Robbins-sent-a-letter4a-employees---a// companies )4;-41Ftal.-+FHB+k~«'F' "mieroinequitiesMn-November-2414;4ntel-manager employees-eneouraging4hem49 attend4he "miereninequities"-trainnig;--which-premise4404eaek-attendees-about-the i%8(&48864k-&ttt&Rde'vs-& — usually-subeenseious-messages-wo-all-send-that4evalue "subtle -discourage-and-ultimately-impair performance-in4heworkplaee T‰ fank urorld '/' V, H ¬mmoAv Q;1;nnm ohnnr a in. a nhoonoinn neth maneno.veromoanno urno mnolvad ‰ +‰ on 4 -roo +‰ urorot ;not;nnto mF An¬or;no'o varA 1 2' +‰ fin+ oro,l tank onmnc.nu DioA D nor unh14o A ;to "vrorlrn orontoro of tha hef a ( ona horovemont +‰ n 14¬u n·Ifunenu braithmrf onmthin mmrornment/0012/AC/10/infM mute QAAm in Enho rmemornh mA mm+innond ant.+n fi md.Jamininthrnm innmri n-trumnu brai art onmttnnkton1s/11 ton/intauhroete shrinneh,..mnia minrninom stimeaiucreit tra no-on-ernployees/ SS0033831 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 109 forbiddino- r,4nrmonarocoin.no 'eJ onok nenro¤ninn "norf ‰A ‰or nao onlnanara olon " ;f 3rnn urill oAAltionclhr oblo onÎo ninn cominnthinno nanovol nonnomyroninne nanolo Gr onloin nin,n,v.nrone;nno un +non'e Ai sloqr of u~'ticks Pena" Ciinton's on the subject and "'Donald but he was fired, locked at the onhne new s site wysyi-t;"; from the site, ~ andce e:ed T s 'eels h8@RWe-sw;jamng-., Nonetheless, media was tolerated Hillary-bashing of' of Sen. Bernie supporter There was also Michael furor: For her, She says she cannot arises that is legitimately 71 7¹ http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/09/06/the-mainstream-media-has-a-donald-j-trump-sizedblind-spot.html SS0033839 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 117 Tracey anticipate was right that Trump'6 also likely el and thc mainstream unstoppable aided the process, momentum by pipi wolf would did. they fail to Eonly were wrong. carry him to the %hite so many times flist{he public voting but they HouscI hberalnecIa vc were wrong CC SLNVA[IVE ouncts a°c Tp sta'tes so ecc: r c hse Comment [A263]; lus: CV the right so crieswoif. [¯ "2 outrageafter outragethat he er'ccrats commit he story you are missing— end that noone hastold—is why e"° °°peo hs ""C° * stories aboutT rp andbelievedall re sto' es Bu• it s Cr ton But probably o cur sto y c simply SWitched off. Presumably, (ulckjy foulld readership. Tracey's superiors to be as blatant unwilling hcr claiB1 to 11avc participated with I don't long-tenn. think Tracey media, or Seaman will and the furious in the new media Post, Vice Comment IA2651: Thisdoesn'1makesense icon -- Lena Dunham, in NcA' York despite priAMry end up with progressives ecosystem. where journalists also shows how cormnitted decline the mainstream I have good news for Japan's intensihes and thc ER the cranks and the UFO-hunters who actually do know what's who fired But in addition media is to remaining where to look for truth in this neW age Of pattiaan see, as virtue-signalling their careers particularly and Got being are purged. politicians, propaganda edge who are left outside to creating in the won' They won't a chilling effect in out of fear for their jobs, it in its cycle of error. The few And so, the cycle continues. and for anyone else wondering masquerading as grows ever narrower, the mainstream going on in the world damaged them were wrong. to defy the narrative who do see past the biases of the bubble Nevertheless, hunters bias as the Huffington Comment [A264]: M 9 nasr t "welf" o — much of what the mediareportedabout Trumpwas [A266]: Ms needsbettersCJrc -g Comment seer"s made .n up Lit want for employment reporters ', and despite h1$1apldjy-tnclcastng another progressive ln thc closed OcnMcratlc moments, the p They were right the mainstream in their pro-Clinton after he questioned "I-told-you-so" -I-told-you-so' big fans of an excuse 'to gct lid Of hllTl afte1 thc election) instead opted to fire Tracey registered at Vice aren't hiej¼ni[ it s no longer -- journalists are left outside You and fact. , -- Comment [A267]: vo. peopleacc se you a a Breitmano' De r-e m ah Comment [A268]: aple °'or peope mo dont know too. Some of them 7² http://theralphretort.com/hamburger-harper-gets-michael-tracey-fired-vice-proved-lena-dunham-liar11011016/ SS0033840 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 118 are handsome, J. Trump charismatic funny, is coming around the corner, I am of course referring 1' And if you want to know when the next Donald and fabulous. all you have to do is find them. to myself, to Breitbart News, and to my fellow travelers in the press. anti-establishm.ent -I made many mistakes blowing drug dealers, not resisting career was probably - in my youth the biggest out of college, dropping Father Michael's advances answering to miserable, who want you to convince that Islam is nothing "mansplaining" Review if you are going to be a journalist, but honesty initially, to be left wing! the public pays off where I trust anti-establishment or RedState columnists, than watered-down versions he tried to disceive himself News, for example, for most of the election it matters leftists as a not a path I'd advise nerds in plaid shirts to be afraid of and that who revealed in Cheetes, Your - with the public. themselves Tracey during mainstream. career options will be And you don't even have far more than National the campaign t(>'IerHh to be little more the-excephen-- — memn· achapterto - comment [ mo]: cc important scoring pointsagainstGlenn £k here, not v eter The alternative maintained year. Despite tell the truth. like Michael of the virtue-signalling We are not hard to find. Breitbart journalism It's certainly soft-spoken too much time is a thing that exists. Nevertheless, limited - but picking one ever. What was I thinking! anyone else to take, unless you fancy spending o' Comment [A269]: Es gets in the wry ot ycr pant here DELETE media is increasingly the top spot in political the best efforts difficult to ignore news on Facebook of biased Silicon Valley -- and Twitter CEOs like 880033841 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 119 Twitter's Jack Dorsey to silence our leading and we are the ones that people During a corrupt corrupt mess populated by hacks pushing by hacks not interested learned the political Just a few years ago, you'd Now everyone knows I quickly Gamergate in the hobby, of those in power have been laughed with learned we learned merely that the entire mainstream views want to share, to. in Europe, Then during by hacks. we' we've this election during we are the ones that people want to pay attention my career as a tech journalist mess populated voices, that tech journalism the gaming in politicizing media is a corrupt zealotry is press is a it. Now mess populated and mendacity. out of the room for saying stuff like that. it's true. Fake News TT Having would expect the mainstream to double down, Instead the people's important would backfire after Trump's to take vengeance victory. media, Instead, you they opted on those who humiliated them. As completely. why they (and the, had lost but-I-repeat-myself) trust, the media instead asked why the people had lost trust in them. A subtle, but difference Instead as we shall see. decided of listening and watching-the mainstream attempt of asking themselves The media reading, to show a little humility in an ill-conceived their efforts always, P ~ 1 1 1 ~1 so often and so spectacularly by the alternative been embarrassed media could that the people had been duped. to pure, truthfulrDen-loerat alternative always media. engage with Something propaganda, the people were listening had to be done. But what? Well, the alternative media and its arguments to, the directly-_ —--- SS0033842 SS 0033842 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 120 bUt 1, ' ' . smear campaign,7 ',' e, from the presidential academics left-wing f' for losing responsibility Am.erica, had won because of the power wasn't sites hat, would require clcbatc! Opcn- facts, cvldcncc! as alway s. In the days following emerging . the media election, and analysts desperate for a reason to absolve news" That meme was "fake them of -- the idea that Donald Voters' of social media to spread misinformation. you see -- it was all because of the alternative legitimate, seized on a new m.em.e media Trump anger at elites - sorry, I mean fake news 'lies. A few examples revenue of genuine like the sites with MSNBC.com.co, the extra suffix usatoday com.co, the media to prove the existence endorsements activist's of Trump mistaken paint a picture fake news (sites that create fake stories for clicks (from abenews com.co, of a wider problem. Pope Francis electorate" electorate' ' focused upon by Two false stories about high-profile and Denzel anti-Trump . Ather DrudgeReport.com.co, were relentlessly Washinatonpost-com,co) photo about bussed-in of a deluded ".co": .co!: and ad similar Washington respectively) protesters in Austin, Cries were cited, and one Texas were used to melmimg the much-- plZZauatC Despite InfoWars, Review, the fact that we didn't Prison Planet, World Net Daily, The Blaze, report on any of those stories, Breitbart Project and ZeroHedge Veritas, Private News, along with Eye, The Independent were placed on a list compiled CrrwllNerllrIA273I1Ackrtcv/l&k/gef181& ln relationto fake ii+vs, Journal by a left-wing 73 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/20/business/media/how-fake-news-spreads.html 74 http://www.nbonews.com/tech/tech-news/facebook-google-orack-down-fake-news-advertising-n684101 SS0033843 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 121 academic liberal of so-called sites like Red State and the Daily Now Barack aware of the existential Obama got involved. sites76. In his public man-made climate "An media either - even more Wire made the list! to The New Yorker, article also blamed "fake order, even outgoing president just a few days after the election attacking news" fake news pro-Trump for the public's ol' lack of belief physicist looks exactly in change. explanation of climate the same on your Facebook payroll." payroH." just the alternative about a BuzzFeed Obama statements, It wasn't threat posed to his world According "obsessively" Obama was talking brothers sites.73"" sites.' "fake news change from page as the denial complained a Nobel Prize-winning of climate change by somebody on the Koch Obama. . --- i;etttttiitentt[AR7if]t off ttie tioirit 'tax--x+a&+H~'e%'--9(+-'f3eF-eehht: What horror! ivory-tower scientific People can actually authorities publishe are saying! and share infonnation Infonnation can flow freely! that casts doubt on what must be Something done! Obama wild misinformation, any rebuttal continued, - without conspiracy any hint of irony. theories, that has accelerated You could be forgiven for thinking "Tthe capacity to paint the opposition in wildly in ways that much more sharply he was talking to disseminate polarize negative the light without electorate.77" " electorate.' about CNN. 75 http://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2016/11/breaking-media-list-fake-news-websites-includes-breitbartinfowars-zerohedge-twitchy-blaze/ 76 http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/11/28/obama-reckons-with-a-trumpresidency?mbid=social_twitter 7 http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/11/28/obama-reckons-with-a-trumppresidency?mbid=social_twitter SS0033844 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 122 that sounds like a serious problem! Wow, news sites going? Are they writing headlines like "This Post, in an article genocide about Donald if elected? Comes To America"? "just on any of the sites on the left-wing magazine that once featured is right, columns from there is a problem of the mainstream at least as interesting Yiannopoulos" I' I've falsely as national and the terms been called These aren't just sub-par news" Christopher with A will commit in the New York Times, writing list, but on Slate, a once-respected advocate white media. forgive them for this - forgive the lies. Just goo' supremacist," supranarist," "Milo and count the number of times of both. lefty rags like ThinkProgress respectable in the press -- but and misinformation targets is me. I partly events. But I don't and was, again, not Hitchens8°. . with hysterics most common "alt-right" a leading "fake press, not the alternative One of the fake news media's I'm A- that Democrats Hitler" sounds more and more like I say it: Trump published it's a problem opponents . The subheading Obama are these fake Oh wait no, that was the Washington Trump78. . Are they suggesting — Oh wait no, that was an the-op-ed Trump" Trump about Donald and negative stories about their political inflammatory Is How Fascism Just .lust how polarizing included81). It's supposedly publications proclaimed alt-right,8²" " leader of the alt~ The Guardian, alt-right, either (although like NPR, which which of course they' re called me a "self- called me a member of the 78 https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/this-is-how-fascism-comes-toamerica/2016/05/17/c4e32c58-1c47-11e6-8c7b-6931e66333e7_story.html?utm_term=.34a69326dd42 ' ' 78 http://www.ibtimes.com/will-donald-trump-commit-muslim-genocide-president-new-york-times-op-ed- -raw~ warns-about-2382483 80 http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2016/10/nobody_s_Iike_hitler_but_trump_is_getti ng_closer.html 8 re https://thinkprogress.org/trump-embraces-the-alt-right-ed91cc889154#.wo07v4zto 8² http Jhwvw.npr.org/201 SMQR491 462721ithe+istory~rtt-right SS0033845 SSOOXR45 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 123 a)Id GQ, whtch InovcnIcnt, ."leiegraph (1 used to write Businesswcck Bloomberg face of the alt-rtght, In the nlovctncnt face" of' me "the that I couldrt,'t . Brrtatn gone downhill the alt-right, help but, be flattered. although s Di&lp since 1 left), and the latter did it in O'The pretty, monstrous the sister pubhcation, of Vogue, they sattl). Less ffattetingly and The Stranger 8 manner votes they' for them. »ve clearly a column both called gracious so inadvertently called me 8 pronnncnt but no less falsely, a weekly newspaper both Teen Vogue", to me as a in Seaule. both referred White Nanonahst ' -- comment [A275]: Zent c :e ric es coa the " this beck back deal in intheirheadlines. )44eetssl+~-,+he harassment played media has Iso against I.eslie was a stereotype, Jor3es~~" Both of Jones's nude photographs after'Inv suspcnston f loni BrerRIII($-tta-i4(+-%vt held me responsible (I simply are true l),-M~ Ivhtch Twttter, Ñ for "leading"' said she Ivas ugly and that the character I' ve alsc been held responsible httpse//www heguar la she for the release AFc-t488P:-pe%>jl)lt-"--II)88-:I-k+ArM+It--1-+ver<=-srFIBgl)tvf.-d-v'BBI. FBI)ld+'-:: -8-HBeft--1'+)-A-"-3 Ames-Haek 1e-A4-¥ear-OldAl-t-was-written-in4le-style-of-a-fairytale ;k)R --'treBF-(AA:---lt-O'BS-WBttet)811-148.SI3'-1+'.+rrf-.a-.f whe-4ecided-tobeeeme-famous4y of racist were obtanFed In a hack and released on the ~veb 8 month — One-e&these-articles-at-TheMeek-carrie4theheadline"How -«:-Bt— -B Milo" the campaign fe-Explain — Theleshe -featunng Comment [A276]E"e po s Tade " :1s pmapph, WthouHN hhous y rc tre y eec k t3eo acedwhen you Ts: man+ "A-boy-named "finding-the4ttle-monsters-inside-ofpeeige-that-make comÂooks/2046/des/30/braitbart-rmlo-yiannopoulos-claims-deak autobiography 84 http://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/article/milo-yiannopoulos-nero-milo-andreas-wagner 85 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/11/21/school-cancels-talk-far-right-trump-cheerleader-miloannopoulos/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-america-divided/milo-yiannopoulos/ 87 hMp:!!www.teenvegue.comletery!m!!c y!2nnepeu!ce hee been g!ven a beck den! 88 nat!ene! et !2nde 250000 beck dea! hMp:!!www.thee±ranger.com!c og!2016!12'29!2d773362/wh!te 89 https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jul/20/milo-yiannopoulos-twitter-ban-leslie-jones-badidea 9° http://www.express.co.uk/entertainment/films/691418/Twitter-leslie-jones-racist-ban-ghostbusterstweets-breitbart-milo-yiannopoulos hMp:!!mvw.vanityfair.eem!ety!e!2016!12!m!!c y!2nnepeu!ce !ee!!e jcnee beek dea! 9² http://ca.complex.com/life/2016/12/worst-people-2016/james-comey SS0033846 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 124 people hate things the rnental and feed[ing] age of The Wacid them."" Congratulations respectable very same people that we are supposed 8/ld vlcc-SIgnaN19g buzzword publications to believe news. Yct, tl118 Is how thcv behave towards negative she correctly identified readers! These are all mainstream, vtrtue-Stgnallmg to the anther will staffed provide by professional the public The with real, not fake E evcfl the nl11cles't of journalists. 8 constant garne of — tc111ng Othcra Yvhon'I 'to shun lly 818pp1ng thc 18tcst on them, and sinlultancously signaWing to their friends that they' re with the --- Comment [A277]: Nar accusecof aswall good guys. They act like the, Mean Girls could possibly actually be 8 threat to her popularity, likes her. Is it any wonder Unable for projection character there" So, there's that no-one nothing George only to discover to face up to their own failings, instead. Regina who victimizes as is what yet are any other girl that at the end of the movie that no one trusts these reprobateso reprobates? the metropolitan media-political bubble has opted for it. We have to strap them to a chair, tape their eyes open, and make them look in the mirror. Narrative Over Truth When the mainstream to conflate us with obviously our error would be trumpeted where left-wing editors uas as a platforrn media want to attack the alternative fake sites. The truth is, we rarely ceaselessly around the mainstream media, get it wrong stories the site has got wrong http:!!theweekoomlarticles!6454 but -- because if we did, media for days. On Wikipedia, have long since taken over, the entry for Breubart for the alt-right they have no option at the top of our page, and provides News erroneously a helpful lists list of the few in its nine years of existence. 4Glhow-explain4eslie-jones-hack-7yearold SS0033847 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 125 If I were to publish misinformation a list of all the mainstream in the same period, it would media's fill probably errors, half-truths a book of its own. and Still, we can give it a go. Let's Vladimir article start with one that we all remember: Putin of Russia. Trump." other publicly, the Ukraine, Their evidence? the fact that former and the fact that Trump the news channel Aushla advisor "And wrote State in an that plan looks and Putin have complimented staffer Paul Manafort Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn a lot each once did business attended in a gala hosted by toff. later 88 8. sure 8$'"Jtof m 2013 was 'x)tnted Order of FQendslu ne en n Comment [A278]: Sevscr'emg cat le-son e e s °ce s connectic-sa e mc e smo .s ;han Vanafe s or Tr s This, according cormnunist-infiltrated The narrative day. Politico to Slate, made Trump campaign ran an article which for president calling exclusively equivalent the mainstream and left-wing Candidate," on Lt. Gen. Flynn's I have also appeared on, and his view that Russia The Guardian, that Trump meanwhile, could "endanger common published western when it comes to Ukraine and of Henry Wallace's in 1948, albeit less sincere and idealistic "The Kremlin's Trump to defeat ISIS -- an underwhelmingly appeasement "The moral was echoed throughout than the Slate piece. It focused claimed west" of President Tor/ag. 'TIte fact that TJ Rrr3 8 SeeretNV Of State BC8tuGCCRex TlllerSO9 w88 Swarded tire kusst86 network campaign the and Facebook. The fact that Trump Trump is a puppet Trump Putin has a plan for destroying that was shared over 80,000 times across Twitter like Donald m M "Vladimir that Donald view media until that." election using even less evidence relationship with Russia and the U.S. should Today a co-operate analysts." analysts.' among the account of a no-name interests' security than think tank employee and said she expected who "a lot of Syria." " http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/04/donald-trump-2016-russia-today-rt-kremlin-mediavladimir-putin-213833 880033848 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 126 Stories repeating Putin CNN, appeared in the Washington irrelevancies Post, the Chicago and Fox News among others. It's a pattern damage conservatives, Establishm.ent women who believed should have remembered what they tried to do did-to debate with Bamek Obama Trump. outlet the LA. Trump the weak or inconsistent, runs with and would ROkkmey remarked '"binders that it as well. 2012, when the media did to Mitt that he asked for, and keceived and the BBC, Times, NBC, was unelectable, Trump ~%]keQE vvOQken When he wkks faekng a defkokt Of fernale (ùWemor Tribune, Flynn, we see time and time again with every other mainstream conservatives and minorities precisely Manafart, media;-- — Oence one outlet picks up on a story, however m.ainstream might the same circumstantial full" alienate Romney during of resumes hiS SeCOQd of qualified appikoakktS fOf ]Oba tn hkS adknkGkStratkOQaS -- comment [A279]: Nota se te~ce chusen of kkd-twisted-it hikrk-a en<4:-yak;-eekkservatkk~s'k+ ikktea.-atek>-a4eet eutw+f-teuelkR@ kegvakk-ake-'deism; akkk . --- Comnteniktkatkkkjt ters lekkvs"akkakc at it here 9'-kth-krk-'8k'tkr8-Ihn-F8~ ~-srkki'-'c! c!+~i>Bk'-'Be'kc--k& -dSVr4]M:-akim -%'aa-kjeekkeatkeg-tke-YMws-ev«k,'-:--I"'-ki'eF+%3Re-I (;:NN-wtka-<4k-ki'e'+-keg-kt;-j:skoal-as-tlk8%-klkki-8-rst--thuk<"sd(3(Bkk&iksts-'kvr&t+'-ab(31&k-Rk(;-s(3 peopleean-make-up-their-own-minds---Trust-me---44- s-not-me-they-end-up-hating Anyway-aftestrolling-around-for-retweets--and-shares-eashing-inon-my-suesessethe vv&th-tl'48kB-I+IF.&.pr+kf3)8:.' magazine-complained--because1wouldn4-spend-time-with-them--for-a-pref-ile Idke-what? -I-..3L'8;-v."4&t . If I could tell my colleagues 1.. Eeveryone in the media four things, they would be: hates you- http://www sq-magazine .co-uk/article/m#o-yiannopoulos-snowflake SS0033856 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 134 2 Nao one is afraid of you 3. Nno one believes 4 Nobody If every journalist overnight, immeasurably In the meantime, MHe & what you say. and n owes you anything. in America for the better, yes. All journalists en realised and the US might Actually, your trust — elud and having the only things great tacte in uniforms. e' their behavior would get the fourth finally are liars and frauds unless proven hands right now. If you enly read the media X=;f those four things, transform estate it deserves. otherwise. ----d Comment [A292]: E a here ttte, coverage I have in conunon What they don't about it, ye with ) Hitler d imagine it was 20 are being powerful and farnous realise is that their lies and moral make-me-want40-gaeutside-infull--Nazi-dragjust-to4uek-with-them panics just 44keaemething4ram4lear She'— -l'Ft&kk.9y-EAE'-b~h;. ;-F73 f f of the-SS -8Of+eurse-if-1-did-that3-they4write-it-up-as+ne-heing-a-national-seeialist-And-that's-how theKafkeesque+yele--workse-the-mediaannoys-us-all-so-muekwith-their4ibbing-that--they+nake us-act-out -}F}Bke -then-they-write-up4hese-proveeationeald+ries-of+iespair-as-evidenee-they-were-right tl}813-FI}eV-vv'F}te-F}p-t4(}se-pl+3 BlkBIRF}g-:-AF}d-AR}eFieB-kept-telliRL-t(3F-it— IA}RBI4-(I'(FF}RaI3:all-along-AndAmerica-kept4alling4er-it----until-DenaldJrump SS0033857 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 135 7 WHY OTRERESTABI "tiome people just as much as hetcmsexual are murderers, people about lid are all of these things. anti we all have thc sdtnc human role models %hat it all boils down to is, dcstres. It gUst happens that sotnc desires go this way and some desires go that way. It's sad when people it's a question of rising above it. Personally, —/type Dcvkk<)rt In April 2013, I appeared on an edition was Boy George, eyeliner - had become you were a normal the past -- something Merely Rut " panel show 10 O'clock a cause to which I was then opposed. even today, I would in which I wasn't .--- tgorrrrsrsrrtIAR941: Thisquotedoes not help se up the chapter Live to take My opposite the most flamboyantly- never wear anything like Boy George's my god!). My mere opposition marriage and, it you have to, physically. of the British and it was a rare occasion dressed person on set (although purple mentally are oppressed. (PASAcrr rtttgPdgtrrtdfzs ktrI year-~N'Au IrruptedRtz Ert Stargate): part in a debate. The topic was gay marriage, number and positive and nasty people— drug addicts bigamists., ' ns center is in :he worst — It W be of any chapterin the book-arc c' "rcs' .st toss of the mttstscrutinized voL CM lust oft' 300' GFpoorlythoughtouttheoriesabout O closet' o :he des as you mightin a college w:" —peoplemil car e toims chapte ssth lec+ure legitimatequestionsabouthowa gay man oes the gay/ Geragrain Youhaveto meet their curiositywith an appropriatelevelof intellectualrigor Comment [A293]; ME . _____________________________- GA Y SPEOPLE-HATE —all thts boo-ha are so prectous images I Of coul se gay people %'e 81e all people, ISBN1ENT to gay marriage a kind of litmus human being was all that was needed to baffle test of social to baffle acceptability the audience. in the trash-heap panelists. malicious relic of of history. on the show as a gay Catholic my fellow In 2013, gay for the left. If you were for it, If you were against it, you were a bigoted, to be dumped being introduced was enough Before opposed to same-sex marriage the show was over, I was called a SS0033858 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 136 man" "homophobic my opposition out that gay marriage lifestyle gay" gay' "mainstream nonetheless can't studio for traditional allowunderstand Christian families the possibility political metropolitans is bizarre \nd that's ., block. who made up the and shocking. I amwas a before I voice my opinions, are happy to cast scorn on the liyesfest-y-les evangelical that why--someone but -- Í comment [A295]: I eave- e es: a°s cm c il gay people. left-leaning or southern or be. The very term a monolithic fagophile '' gay is a normal have always represented, my mere existence "' '" u+a+w4en+qa+#4 .. w gays, many of whom midwestern homosexuals as the unfailingly audience, cause even more dissonance conservative -- and shouldn't to use it because gays have become ' ' "' ' " -like " ahhma Mainstream the idea that being it isn't everything gays, as well bulk of the panel show's reinforced I believe is at odds with To mainstream which which choice, we are forced gay anomaly 1' I am by now used to, for both of which to gay marriage. I pointed acceptable "self-loathing," and accused of gay might of, say, Christians,"hicks," Christians,'hicks —," simply cast acean on not-eensidestheir lives_festyles-to-be-ar&object-ef-aspiration-orsemething4hat-ought-te4m-eelebrated-inevew --rER+43$(aBB+3f-BSIllrBH(3BE+3r-B(3B'lhht4EElg-t4-tlk-+3(Ehall-(nell-4F&toaI-EB-h;++'rh' bookefVshow-and-Hollywood-me-vier When you--reduce-everything expecting-all-ail gay people like4his, really-listening are expected_to to each other any-more_and discuss interesting to identity believe you-rob-every politics and political the same stuff. People I(3ses(31' one losesef the ability talking points stop -and-not to see and things. For instance, fabulously is_reduced mainstream camp cultural why so many gays I know figure. gays refuse to understand He's the drag-queen secretly the fact that Donald presidentyou adored him. All that pizazz can vote. for! and bluster! Trump is a It's easy to see (To say nothing of SS0033859 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 137 ' against pacitions stance his strong icon. He oozes control That's homophobia.1He's ought to be a gay obviously and authority. "Daddy" why I coined the nickname for him,1°° which annoyed just about °l l°2 everyone. some of the extreme Ironically, fact that I don't good thing). insult. an Islamic members ., think gaynees. is a good thing When the Daily Stormer But I take it as a compliment: transgressivedegenerate. of the alt-right also have difficulty ' .. -" (or, more accurately, I —I became a homo precisely to continue And I want homosexualitvit the want gayness tobe homosexual," called me a "degenerate grasping a they meant it as an because it is — being transgressive-even degenerate. The gay establishment they'vre trans been working is rightly to achieve Faggot" asin athe playground tour, watched tl1C SV(t@.Sgu or aniration.. atmntpt: tn drag of matTiage domesticity -one aim: to make gays normal. I sav: Who wants to be normaP Just as mainstream gays are atnazed by me and my opinions, the gay community as myopic unique, exciting, pandemonium' lay outside eagerness to sacrifice and dangerous, ' '"' ' ' ' ' in exchange a tiny band of far-left San Francisco! ' queerest city in America. atnazed by ty. Just look at the OUT magazine dared to publish a lunacy. If you doubt how much the gay community from when ceaselessly that has made our lifestyle everything for mere norma/i that was unleashed I'm hates me, consider Me, the gayest person on the planet. Apparently Banned. I'm just too dangerous this: From I' ve been banned San Francisco. the a fag.r-evaerd-tee-a-+'i'-that--t«4s Aata-(-+/Bv&ly-4rtk>-th+'--B'ateF-su/3pl>'-t As the great Camille wanted Paglia says, there's no way gays could be normal even if they it is a challenge to the norm. to be. "Homosexuality Nature exists whether is not normal. academics On the contrary lil e it or not. And in nature, procreation is the single http: //www.breitbart.corn/milo/201 6/09/21/out-magazine-profiles-milo-triggers-its-delicate-gay-readers/ "" http: //www.breitbart.corn/milo/2016/09/21/15-most-triggered-responses-to-milo-out-magazine-profile/ '" http: //www.mediaite.corn/online/backlash-grows-over-out-magazines-decision-to-feature-miloyiannopoulos/ "http: //www.thewrap.corn/out-magazine-milo-yiannopoulos-backlash/ https://thinkprogress.org/out-magazine-milo-open-letter-e0d3db3fe7ac@.9z7kgti4i "" http: //www.out.corn/out-exclusives/2016/9/21/send-clown-internet-supervillain-milo-doesnt-care-youhate-him "" http: //www.breitbart.corn/california/201 6/03/18/ive-been-banned-from-san-francisco/ SS0033861 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 139 relentless rule. That is the norm Our sexual bodies were designed one is born gay. The idea is ridiculous. for reproduction. is an adaptation, Homosexuality No not an inborn trait. Gay activism has been naive in its belligerent disappear eventually with "education" proper boys on the scale required young freedoms. artistic father's Furthermore, no truly identity, husband dissolving but the damage will the shamans of our RepuMioan;understand victim mean fascist masculine father of a bit of social-justice Reeducation obliteration would "homophobia" that will of fractious of all individual ever welcome an feminine not only threatens or but liquidates Later there may be public rituals that of have been done. Gay men are aliens, cursed and time." this instinctively. and once in a while into wife. already Smart gays who have been around drag culture of the benighted. son at the start, since the son's lack of virility acceptance, gifted, would confidence the block, He knows is brave enough himself, censorship "You' Race to stop using the phrase, "You've like RuPaul_rwheTm-convinced-is--a-oloset -4-i~-a-taltaset got that going mainstream interviews.11° to say so in interviews. , when the trans lobby she-mail," would RuPaul be death to was the forced RuPaul's in case any transgender people Drag were offended.11 RuPaul correctly tells gay men they should be striving hqd ip mind Lucian Wintrich s "Twinks d Trump" pe art chew in New 3g2 York to stay outside ½ Cit "the matrix." at y p 112110 I bathed in freezing --( O" the pent Contnent [A298þ ott w cold ¹¹° ¹¹¹ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnHEWU-WhGE&app=desktop http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2015/03/02/rupauls-drag-race-axes-youve-got-she-mail-catchphrase/ http://we.w.fcxnews.com!pc!!t!ce/2016/10/07/pro n doubt 26enthreate trump m!!c nkedMehow from-anti-trump-activistshtml SS0033862 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 140 pig's '7 blend illegal for 15 minutes, aliens Antichrict! New surrounded there was a genuinely Could you imagine underage beye in by imagee MAR subversive if Madonna Even if we could hate? No of cource you can't, achieve normality, it gives us an edge, a power Strange, would and the violation into society's underworld. released a video with and the orange a bunch of the but true? we want to?.Our Our weirdness -- is our strength else. For decades, being gay has meant of taboos. It's been an act of rebellion, Why would elain by terroriste because the enly people pushing and a charm over everyone transgression Americans piece of art: gay men celebrating er Paric Hilton in art these days are Republicans? envelop ef innocent an automatic entry pass we want to give all that up? // commeefA2ÖÖÑs besta "hontyto acte P3ghJ Being perverse energy and power toilets to Camilla Paglia, others Satanists-and-geths-would and kids and a front drug-fueled is okay. Listen lawn, I want to be hurled my fellow fags. Realise die to access. I don't out of a nightclub NO' tr is :7e ere Sac<:cCar de you have an want to have a spouse at three in the morning in a stupore4anding4n-the-gutter-ne4to-the-gangbanger414-been-suckmg-of&inthe 4 ike4rindsay4 Because ehan-en-a4uesday-night-minus-the4ire-erotch-Sashing. the alt right -- I'm is correct a degenerate. Whichjs also And-that1s-why I'm a Catholic. No really, '/-'/"> ./ dntr!ch/ I'm not trolling / / / I you. Hear me out. / . I / un-/A>n>nnthnW¬nuhnoa onmfortinine/9ndru1n/nm.nenarnmn arceting.htm! http:!!radaronline a hnmunusuaice o com/exclusives!2012!O9iparis-hilton-blasts-gay-men-aids-audio-recordires/ SS0033863 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 141 Dionysus and Apollo I enjoy being a degenerate. So does everyone, great cultural I enjoy violating to some extent -- the thrill youne because they knew how shocking memesters anime characters, establishment of the alt right, you' groups of cultural elites take over from some depraved and Grand Nazi uniforms rock bands in Theft Auto games were to polite society, onto cartoon but because they know every into smash hits right frogs it winds up to the and elite up sexual taboos or political ones, the thrill codes is usually replaced In politics, with the next. But what about sexuality? a language violating sexual act that would code is exciting, get you beheaded is the same. this another, as new That, after all, is it doesn't come close to in most countries outside the world. male behaviour, now condemned it is now straight like awkward as 'rape states, male students consent down -- one set of language For sexual mores, requirements touring a taboo, there must first be a taboo to violate. -- because while more important Nonnal who photoshop re breaking takes care of itself developed Kombat thosey not because they are neo-Nazis, But in order to violate committing taboos is what lies behind columnists. Whether usually of violating from the kids who defied their parents to follow rebellion, the 60s and 70s, to the gamers who turned Mortal precisely rules. Culture.'" culture." sexual advances, that seems to be most stigmatised. cheeky flirting and raunchy songs are -- Nut rape IISCIf, Whleh IS hCIBOILS, but I"Ipe Cveen my degetteracy and rebellioug an excellent needs Christianity like dynamic members happened I chrrsc to bc 8 degenerate, only remains disappeared they represented, get bored and go home. Rebellion of the Flies teachers the other. threat of discipline if the teachers pleased (t should to outsmart trying of The playful, has been going on for centuries, and gay men have been able to use their time Cotttsaertt IA3op]: Thisia poorlyexplainedor cheso i can have argued tf cu say "l ar against," somethingto rebelaga st your1mpa cy sease en you undercutsyourargument, ar' are c Cat c c at all. vot can say. 'i am CathchebecauseI behave~n[statesomething ve and I dont considerwhat I d¤ wrang' c — but you needto statea betterreason 10" ter beings 3 hchoor you aseall sympathyin Nrcuder PRCi£VAT & SS0033867 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 145 and energy to create art and culture. normalize Without gays is to end that dynamic, being gay. Why on earth would them, whose ideas would Lady Gaga steal? To and end the danger and the subversion that goes with we do that? ; ; ; ; ; ; ^'·'·'·'·'·';k ; ; ::::; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; g;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ÷'·'·'^'-'÷ ÷ ; ; ; ; :::::';';';';' ; ; ; ; ::::; ; ; ·'·'÷ ÷:÷:· ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;;::::: ; ; ; ; ; ;'·'·':":"-'·'÷ ÷ ÷ ÷ ÷'·'·'·'·'·'; ; ; ; :::"·'·'·'÷'·'·'·'·'^'· ; ; ^ ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ::::: ; ; ; ; ; · ; ; : - ÷'·'·'·'·'·'·'·'^'^'·'; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::::; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;:::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;;::::: ; ; ; ; ; ; ;'·'^'-'·'; .:fSuspect lt's because Oul pOlttteal dlscoul sC ls St]11loo Stmplc to accQIBLIIOdatc thc subtlC I' argument between ve prcscLIted here, 'I iberals authoritarian, continue. Hardline and libertarians religion anti-gay conservatives and members " anti-authoritarian "'"', harrumph of, but outlawed. and natural nature, - that the ba tie Comment [A308]; sews itis that ought to end of the alt right will insist that Yet both sides need to come to in order to fulfil conservatives our need something to M se" evoA seer s:c -g Comment [A309]: argur-e" pety ter the ergrtrnentyoure making about. The battle between troll-hunters, gays and their persecutors, strict schoolteachers chaos and order, between children, between as well as the battle between is all part of the same battle mischief and seriousness, It's been going on since time began. the opposlllg and Apollo, and unruly rules and anarchy, and the Madonna. gods to rcprcscltt madness, of the extreme is something the fact that both need each other. Gays need rules to flout naturally Madonna balk at the suggestion and the gay community being gay ought to not just be disapproved terms with will sides —Dtonysus., the god of reason, truth, tllc g'otl of lrratlonaitty, and order. trolls -- between between why the 6rccks dtatls The Ctrccks knew and had two SIKEfltU81 that order required chaos to CXtst, and vICC-Versa, h s a ruth we need 'to rediscover 4tt[c ---- Comment [A310]: vo.. needa s•rorger ectlus o" In l" Esag...nenI Succe% Eso :te "a t°e D&Aseemso/ea< Comment [A311]: -"e bonom ne s :"a: ' yes s that ye...me Caho c ONl.YA CRDER O ca se Mouble,yo underCJtthe e"Te hook necauseyca are essmally adr I"at u c y causeImple fo· t·o. e s sake ' Comment [A312]; as sex on title doesn' doer t ^ to the discussionthatfollows. SS0033868 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 146 ' '11'tn L .2: Bsewhere in the world ".. -,-. at ~.,r", .".'...';:.:::.:". » L necin ....', the lhc same. the stoty4s 1vue.. oxown.ua2.1 nu. u1vu ..u ..,u .- JC r-' --D — ±e-peter4eter-Wah .- Leon arde De Vinci -4j}at@tet-' blower4 fadrian Whitmancandthe-infamous-beef —;.}}}}1-t 212hats-at--least4n-part43eeause-gay-menaFe--SmaFleEwe-te&t--hi to- tFanscend" g '."l't heterosexual-counteFparts---Intelhgenee--atiowous to eve‡udenag .!.'":". psychologist4atosh een homosexuality But xxrv.:1.} "ux: here's . ti a problembrewmg ' c-. r -." rh- Kanazawa eF -)F4Q-than-0H-F our e clutionamprogramming- which ma explain the eeuelation and high IQ. -"' < andit } }' .av, n np .xn.; nw:xvr . th, . a nonianan gays are joyndly f,", ~ &tfrkkR&H-i-+FF-I-' aF}-7&'a-jetkjF~+j}}'! the Hershey acGM;-thatfump-thamper highway patFolmaneir--14&Beie abundant-ineluding according «1' si as aimest certainly at I--DTXXu IXUIl -_rUIrr-UDXXGIX },",',' find .'' you hmnan ».i&F} greatness Alexander .'"ck~a}}3<'} the Great 4t seems that wherever bet IN iM '< -!; „--,;; '"'*' ' ''"' ' *''""' has to de with crchticn. In in th E50s gay men s }.x.3c Th . sx s 4' v rn:t,wsrnt t!};;:;„-;;-',y;};!',;„-;;;„'g,-„,;;! t",a— 'o}>, n,} naz, .eeD eta t t}cr-from--StM) j'yp;,} „",<~l~;,-<-l;,-;:- ~"-h-,! t-=-~ +ry-~j}j- --- comment A317 them are havmgoi'i,urer throI.ghinsemination U SS0033869 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 147 'I'I ..-,ii, ii .,i .... i u)»w»i»<»»" i .......rt. o )»<».«) - ----a nr r .. --- . L--:- — ""* 1 .)f T ' '.tahar-tt:-lf"..=-'B-t»-~]]~+f1]4-+~u'B+l c r r ..'A.»- »1-. ».-..8:»f..â€..1 f'—;1.—-'---> ... 11~~~. } ~ ~r .------o-----, 1»~~~~ 4 ~ » r» "--u x a- —' ~ L' SS0033870 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 148 n km Ann't hono fkom Ñ fnc 4t Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ innA AoAAv hu Ann hoA AoAA Aforn annly no lic.nn o hTr n4rvht Thou hoA tn ko oroo‰r n thronze in iba olommor .vot Than had to ho nownfonthr o a 7 or · not Comment )ASIA jt Makethis pointfor real a obscureBritishjoke. n 117n n tho dow whon ho4 o +kinl-4n--4!(}B18-(! >3(FB(4 Fairef4ids-posmgwith-menon-all4ours-wearing+log£ollars-and4eashes-will-de-nothing-te dispel-VlachmirButin's-inmek-that-the-west-has-beeeme-adecadent-mess¬Frankly n oro oloco4or mkor ibo TPo olon ur rt knman orm ur ornoidar -1-would-have o4 okmni ho4no- anoor hookod n v tho foof that ibo ant4ro h ñnalam mnrl A lo rr rnlanthr n on m an t oro nantanno in ronrmr uno Î a rokb a voont 40 Tron ro thou n-at om- SS0033872 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 150 renoon h hkommad mall onnn ha fwo mnot onmylor knu-o noma in monn mactorn ITnlano ma mont in foll howind tho amortrin mor14 in the anot ond the hhollm the v m..-omnlo ond anonnvo-ya aek t-want-our-genes-te4ie ut-There -And -8ga}R:. 4 m-sure-we41-think-e&semethingaut4etis-net4erget-how-we ~<%4-4(}w}'vv+'- became-smart Return to Degeneracy Gay men are chaos incarnate. And we should ½ x embrace We are gods of mirth, it like a Hollywood ! ) .We have an energy and power celebrity mischief, embraces over everyone else plastic danger and subversion. , Comment [A324]; surgery. eHi. Renee a dark, mnate perversion and / // / ~/~' / ELEE S-e de-ied r te ano/ no (. !' r !'. o .sf h. mac.' ma >!is ,4g„+~ T f4p l3 n .1 > tf>1 n ..., .„n1,....,.-,...., In 1....-g.;,i~n~ „' ~"i',! 1V. !h.: .(Y'I. 7R:t%.'.... 'L N ~h B. beanil '.'l!f .....tV.)Uh ' I' .. > .: - . f i:.«i~ ~ i 1h k!I ! 'lT"n SS0033876 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 154 8 WHY "Right ESTABLISHMENT after liberal Democrats, REPUBLICANS HATE the most dangerous politicians ME are country club Republicans." -- Thomas "I don 't believe parties. in the Republican Party or the Democratic In January 2016, I got into what I thought large for Breitbart, Ben Shapiro. not friends Shapiro's of power by freaking he for Trump then-editor-at- spat with Trump. successful It ended up turning are very related. and anger on the part of the establishment over conservative by a new generation have 110 time for the 1W0s hangups mest÷eat Twitter ary more. and influence they are being replaced aui in Jones, Sex and the City and less professionally out about Donald distaste for me and his distaste story of insecurity positions was a friendly Ben is a more introverted of me who lost his audience nasty, and we're wider I just believe " -- Samantha version Party. Sowell eeniewe of young, of older consen e politics still waita are slowly fashionable atives. right: They' re part of a anger that their away. Anger slipping and funny conservatives that who We4e·aimt4e-nav·iga-ters-whe··ean··get e+mpheam÷g-ank to eha a --- Comment [A329]: ke a"a9 .= Comment [A330]: · ferg yourPEEint me1¤<êundercuts SS0033877 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 155 The Thomas Sowell there was only one type of political true. In 20i6. completely quote at the start of this chapter isn't just a catchy saying. torpedo threw former his efforts I objected putting I attracted Now, while others rallied whom days' these daysl24_, fo attempt to some of them Evan McMullin, a he became the on a bathroom favorite most establishment punching conservatives, D.C in defense of American also came for me. supporter Trump stepping I/e u as once the left's at nearly fan, the establishment as a feminist Unlike nosing Trump of their queen bee, a rotund a frothing chap called Neo-Nazi Glenn Beck scale. bag, the target of all their false with ze that w -- he once led he even did things heritage, ' . --- Comment [A332]: c evas ye are some estimates 500,000. alas, he's apologized and brown no one had heard of before the attention for_being Mark Zuckerberg and has apol:?gized too conservative past' 22 anddeseended-to-an in the past -4-te--ax~ v't'1(+-8+)Rt -wha-eent-inues-to-spend-his4ime-attacking©onaW intemet+anter-wi-th-a-dwindhng-audience Inanp "NeverTrump," around the laughable to brand every web-based march on Washington attendance Comment [A331]; s·owce ¬c e Med conservative. that they made a pathetic themselves Calling and loudest to their attempts of racism. .- candidate. Alas, poor Beck! a massive Clinton. CIA operative about as predictable accusations That was the establishment were so upset by Trump Clinton, as the biggest and anti-Semite, who's behind spoiler Naturally, After conservatives middle-ranking establishment's Trump. against Hillary their support as upset as the left. -- it not creature CO'" aW959 GSG c de PStabhSFTent SEFU more so - at the rise of Donald Establishm.ent It' It's 23-He even pens columns —.I-Ie f3r being too conser"ative for the New York Times in the past . ' 2' -In the run-up to the html" http://www,nytimes.com/2016/11/27/magazine/alenn-beck-is-sorry-about-all-that.html? r=0 -about-all-that. I . I I http://www±rsitba±com/tech/2016/M/20/tucker car!con cayc g!enn beck cucked mark zuckerberg meeting/ ¹²4 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/11/opinion/glenn-beck-dont-move-to-canada-talk-to-the-other'²² side.html http://www nytimes corn/2016144/27/magazine/glenn beck-is-sorryaboutall-that-htmi? r=0 SS0033878 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 156 he threw election, "moral his support choice," choice,' and ethical behind even if she were elected Oh, and he's obsessed with show, called me a "13-year Republic.' l²8"' Republic Poison There's movement old boyl27" I don't a reason why conservatives I don't now represent -- they' they've reason is simple vision were more important than electoral art, they lost music. They lost culture it" it's worse The Culture from War Rights politics -- are "poison beleaguered In Education to the maybe! people like me represent the future. That --- Comment [A333]: IGs a ? tired of losing" to the 'left. Mitt Romney's principal. loss in 2012 could up a compelling vision No, conservatives they lost academia, easily lost in arenas that they lost ---1Comment [A334]: Mcœ the Brechamo:e here.' [ here G :ure ·s sstwo frets pshtes itselE Conservatism conservative the liberal (FIRE), which W conservativeswere of America, they lost Hollywood, than that. The truth is, they never even bothered That radio and Beck, who were once the best the that conjured of your high school SerlOUS 'attempt to push back against Individual Poison to his ratings, although either, was the on his sadly declining whose writings like Shapiro a candidate by nominating and not a compelling Actually, know. the past, while defeats, episodes "Goebbels" spent the last decade losing mean electoral have been avoided Aside and a Trump stead' in his steadl26. me. He has, in various to the Republic? had to offer, saying that opposing Clinton, Hillary to fight. Forgot student activists dominance campus on campus, of universities. conservatives there has been no The icounciation rely on to protect 12or Comment [A335]: sera .8 Mc°al a sero s atte°rt f'orn ouñc at to sence ftrr the stxer: actMs' Tass co's et'c their free ¹²6 http://edition.cnn.com/2016/10/11/politics/glenn-beck-hillary-clinton-moral-ethical-choice/ http://www.mediaite.com/online/glenn-beck-milo-yiannopoulos-is-a-hurt-13-year-old-boy-and-a-bully/ ¹²ª http://www.breitbart.com/big-journalism/2016/03/28/glenn-beck-breitbarts-milo-yiannopoulos-goebbelshis-evil-trump-twitter-defense-poison-to-the-republic/ SS0033879 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 157 speech, does an excellent job fighting the worst the group was set up and is run by moderate Heterodox social sciences, a group of academics is spearheaded by Steven Pinker don't liberals do the heavy 1' for more political pushing and Jonathan .Ionathan Where in the diversity -- also both liberals. Haidt who still care about free speech and pluralism, lifting' Yet It's not but why are all the conservatives? .It's It's almost as if they Comment [ASM1; What aboutCaipus Reform'P I;are. the few establishment Indeed, attract huge online met with the North by fellow aren't who do care about campus conservatives so -- privately who wonder in the latest appropriations issues -- and admit that their success is .·.· :÷:÷:-;÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:÷:.·.·.·. . what the fuss is about and bill or Russian naval maneuvers in Sea. dissidents approximating A conservative Ijnscathedi. in showbiz Conservatives in Hollywood currently live an existence -- a few brave souls are raising in the Soviet Union most keep their heads down due to the overwhelming dominance is like a gazelle in a pack of lions, their voices, of progressives only the nimblest he rest haye to wear lipp suits and purr copyingmgly but in the industry. will escape and B1pck Lives feminists on-ng A338 cwean exatttpn or two activists. All of this is a result of conservative who made an effort a man despised warriors beltway interested It's the same in showbiz. Matter conservatives of y oun g people in doing followings bemusement why more people with on campus. censorship liberals. Academy, a bad thing that there are some liberals are we letting excesses of left-wing always leftists to organize by the beltway end up making on everything laziness. the conservative establishment. enemies For years, the only prominent Hollywood Isn't it funny underground how successful of the D.C. establishm.ent? except economics and foreign policy right-winger was Andrew conservative It's almost Breitbart, culture as if they agree ! SS0033880 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 158 ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ * Stuffy types really beltway type of conservative don't to them. Listen, know what to do with not everyone in the conservative cool and hip. But at least let's aim to attract new members Could becaine_such your partner and a lack of backbone. running against Donald manliness, getting and comedy slammed Trump to lay down festivals, for selling a brand new is going to be who still have both of their hips. want to lose? It's easy to see why 2016.1²9 It's a byword 2016. and-teek-o4in out and caving "cuck" in. The original by another dude now simply meaning for of means abandonedprinciples (See: the Republicans m comment [A340]: s sncard ec ore tw sm cem tes a rme derer tæ t rs t s t-eeco —--——Comment [A341]: c ovoidechoabove. in the 2016 election.) opportunities to beat the left in winnable deeper roots in high cuhure! art shows. introduced movement .............. It's a Iluicki way to denote a beta male or coward. As well as missing done nothing conservatives I'opt1181' a_gogular makes--sucka-geod--insult relinquished needlessly watching it be that establishment I' me. I've Comment [A339]: seep t" s to e Gar e gatesecacn getng n't Packw bct Joc :hert wdec artes They provide Lefust figh.ts, conservatives foundations grants and funding fund concerts. to eager young creators, have film .- Cement [A342]; Wm: mou h c (acM who ¹²S http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2015/07/28/cuckservative-is-a-gloriously-effective-insult-thatshould-not-be-slurred-demonised-or-ridiculed/ SS0033881 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 159 are more than happy to pander to fashionable "race," get ahead. A search for Arts, the umbrella group for private icles' that look like Salon articles The efforts the "Twinks for a Pierogi arts funding Wintrich, photo on the website organizations the money of Grantmakers in the U.S, returns the gay Trump-supporting series and the "Daddy has become Will for Trump," and legal threats from the venue owner Thanks to conservative photographer Save to conservative ad agency after "Twinks art show at the gallery. Trump party art gallery "diversity" if it means getting to in the opportunities Comment [A343]; G ve few the art world his job at a New York or values I. of Lucian Trump" hostile profoundly "gender," progressive Us" values. Wintrich art exhibit, As well for show how as being fired from also faced expulsion when he attempted complacency, responsible pica. from to host his pro- the art world onetoday is a state.131 As Andrew idolise film wing voters. said, culture pop stars, watch movies left-wing wing Breitbart studios, ñ[cannot continue over the Pentagon, the left-wing stranglehold It's not as difficult has grown expression. college to the point politics. Conservatives film need to realize the importance of culture. lindon -- The kids and teens who directors and produced by grow up to be - surprise! comedians and more on the National on culture that they will - left- ment for the Arts Only then will be beaten. where even left-wing creatives are feeling like Chris Rock ami Jern who they say have become Seinfeld too sensitive Comment [A345]: voPe hasca y akrc a argtne7t 'ci reo'esentaSc cre at v thousand memes on social media. I am of course rofemng the Clinton panic ginned up by the likes of campaign, Comment [A351]: crew e iet, actually cusr d som to the a]t* --- fueled by an alt-right Beast and, eventually, - mternet battahons. organizations, The Daily in the Muslim about is free speech and the freedom when in 2016, conservative nefarious anti-semitism for Jews in the state of Israel. right -- or at ]east, their shitposting National is another countries) some of my peers on the conservative I was baffled Rising Comment [A349]: Ma norms, and memes, adventurous establishment's they're which souls. Indeed, misguided naturally the11' their careert generation's most rebellious it doesn t do these youngpeople justice allegations These people among the best and brightest Conservatives attracts the millennial should be embracing of retrograde racism. of their generation them, not pushing -- talented, to simply and rebut the aren't just not-racists, creative, Comment [A360]: e a "cn pcRca example c e of t-e mtBTC SWC'¤nOSSQ" 3n exampleC/scr-e:hing ; 90 t"ey complis"ec t passee and funny. them away -- and certainly not ruining Comment [A361]; WT Crm re Mve 3 ru n ng a-y careers(ct"e t"an t"e BenSlac o QUC'ehSlcW}7 SS0033886 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 164 But that's ' see a difference Well right. between I disagree. peme the people correctness posted by a Daily of people like Ben Shapiro, II that sounds reasonable This, in my view, Just like the political offensive of the arguments Iobs." ought to lose their jobs that "racists doesn't the implication I just mentioned is nothing to you keep in mind said more than the political ignores reader and a hellraiser from comment [A363]; e ::c T ao:x.: he s Doe . s coe cf .tc detemnes ·:.12: const .tes .."acceatatle "aasm o tmgcty c re mnt t scree e seemese the see (E g B e ca~ E c ) E. correctness context, . -- Comment [A362]; Weds a re that he and the likes of Andrew of the left, it deliberately Stormer who openly of the an treating 4chan as just the same, , Comment [A364]‡aeveryone vvithout The left would out of public Before censure. view I arrived moderates which proportion they believe of them listening That's brilliant minds, and clowns, establishment They take control and bigots. of them are frothing to our arguments, to persuade no matter present them to the w an would like of culture, comment [A378]; Jo k necaaseyo t-e enere omerœnse atve a aanents co< push conservatives like to do the same. Even consummate --- Comment [A379]: Cive 8 2e occk o rc and use it to smear even moderate desperate youth reach college-age, to suppress a conservatism, . When they reach that point, there is no hope - Comment [A380 ,I c judoist how good they are. voters who are already and challenge is campuses. By the time America's higotn on provocateurs ltd close to succeeding. war has to end. Conservatism to grab the attention in Republicans at the mouth, with to be synonymous vertpn politics like me in the future. attention their arguments like to shut the u ere being banned from sexists, why this civil need to be more people here. By focusing on the scene, they were seriously as racists, irk debate club conservatives, else to develop Ironically, how the left fights. conservatives significant altogether. like Cathy Young That's as it might needs its great thinkers open-minded. and its But we also need provocateurs the biases of those who don't want to be challenged. No movement has ever survived has ever survived and intellectuals, and no movement with just hellraisers. If we want to win, unfortunate with just moderates penchant we need both. I hope debele elub concernates, far enobbishnece, eventually who have en realize this. SS0033892 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 170 9 WHY ySotr(ctilncs inter(ucwcrs MUSLIMS ME HATE ask rn<"„a btt furt(velar, about a Lruy I Used. to 11vc wtth who.had. a distractsfrom your point they think there's a gay person questioning public obviously It s true, I did interest er it might For a really This chapter explains about 4is private expose life is somehow homephobie, even if hypocrisy,"' ong time Comment [A382]: F s ee¤npr why 1 don t any more b wren not e/c"<"e e eit e * * * I'd hate to be thrown In the summer off a roof. of 2015, Europe people know refugee boy pulled do what they'd welcome what videos of Muslim of liberals to (jo for hunger After a viral picture eliites exploited E time. I--- lower who would search history of a drowned a (no(Bent the drawbridge very don' and don't Syrian of global sytnpathy of' of a continent, to neen and ans Whe em eine ye migrants. (1(tcs told thetr pcopl<", that th<",tnt' Oeeing Oppreaaien, of people you too, even if you delete your re watching. at the heartstrings been longing millions you' n-this-faee opened its doors to millions much like to kill me -- and, most likely, think I-mean--imagine-imanded a(its were Just Irk(: 'th<: drowned and death in, War-tern Syria. n realit rcl(lgcc; 11t((oeents feWCr than half kf the refugees c(a((r((er(t tA3841( whoo Thischargeis unfounded - eommen( [A385j( Thissoundslike youare denyingwhat ie happeningin Syria Cc(r((((err([A3861( Factcheck ¹33 http://www.breitbart.com/london/2014/10/30/apple-ceo-tim-cook-comes-out-as-gay-fine-now-can-westart-reporting-on-him-properly/ SS0033893 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 171 admitted to Europe in the months economic migrants, from regions hosts the Islamic $ÈÊÏ tO eXtertd They flocked the smirking to Gennan new arrivals, Over a million even more radical weren't train poured stations placards Syria. Most were than the country that currently boys. he rare mom.ent of pro-migrant and holding Muslims the viral photo were from of the world State. And they certainly The pre88 possible. following stating "refugees --.-- for as long as of' of temp -eyed liberals to take pictures into the Mediterranean sentiment Comment [A387]; ASSmCL press seekto ? W sex hugging welcome." welcome.' to cross into Europe b t rather - Comment [A388]: Stupicethnic oke diminishesany pit lyRt an It only took a few months Eve 20156, Muslim as one current misogyny. an Arab word attending year turned An estimated meaning collective the New Year's for the leftist affected mght's end, (alice assaulted, including into another, the new arrivals introduced acting in gangs, unleashed sexual harassment - on German women Year' Year's On New Germany taharrush gamea from returning to - and celebrations. - Hamburg, in the worst night C ano s -g Comment [A389]:.Gratuitous e dream to turn into a nightmare. 2,000 migrants, The attacks took place mainly cities across Germany aPe?hetwt in the city of Cologne, Frankfurt, Dortmund, of sexual assaults in Germany estimated thaf. at least 1,200 women at least five rapes. but soon reports Düsseldorf, were heard from and Stuttgart since the Red Army's had been groped were all invasion. I3-BERp-RPk7-&-Fdp8-'z33RB-rRBI3;--RBB'BBd-rR&-BRBB)--w43v44gs-ts-a-g(3<4-K@8-':-,' Islam and the Left During my college regressive left. I always talks, I'm often asked what arguments have the same answer; to use when debating with -- co333INeatIA393j.'Lets leave"feosl cmptere owes out this oi3eptei', uileeie" the — --Islam. http:‡!blog.sfgate-com!stew!20851‰OiO5/mapping-s-f-s-human-feces-on-the-streets/ SS0033897 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 175 There is nothing better exposes the modern l' for the facts, and their hatred for the Wwest disregard noble value that the left claims Every L' the meet repgressive i:.' practicesideology The twentieth from fascism world. to Bholshevik communism. the rise of radical sanctioned by a higher Marx once called religion their attitude comedians to Christianity, and columnists still cling to "bibles and who they bake wedding Their Russell to Bill Maher himself, Hitchens critique Maher, as well their for women defense of Islam, to Islam. to gay liberation, even ot' despite many of its current do battle with totalitarian Both of those ideologies inspired untold causing of' of every stripe, ideologies their own radical the same kind of grim fanaticism tells its followers that the atrocities around the suffering we have seen they commit are power. their own interests abandoning from rights did not inspire which Islam, rank hypocrisy, and its values than their attitude and their own massacres, Yet even those ideologies left's in the world. saw liberalism. century their own revolutions, devotees, to uphold, of' dies on the altar of its sycophantic itself diversity with else which the "opium in service you might of the deluding of an otherworldly think even though power. thgr to belittle worst offence its followers into If you look exclusively that the left still believes never miss an opportunity guns,'" guns," masses," in this message and denigrate at = .- Then the people these days is to be picky Comment [A394]; W ose who about --- Comment [A395]: A"ose cakes and pizzas for. of religion, which has singularly as Sam Harris, were all frustrated animated failed a range of brilliant to tackle Richard the problem Dawkins, thinkers of Islam. ) and the much-missed from Bertrand a conundrum hat - Comment [A396]: A S a co Christopher by. SS0033898 : C INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 176 The Muslim identity-obsessed minority. reformer leftists Sam Harris Maajid who defend pseudo-liberals cartoonists, Examples of this behaviour scart aren't but nowhere politics every other his characteristic clarity. Left"- the "regressive that they reliably from the individual take the side of a women, the intolerance apostates, of religious criticism.139 are not hard to find. of the gruesome newspaper -- actually, Now I know to describe the problem Indeed, month seems to bring is less finding a new outrage, each than the last. of a leftist right from has termed Rather than protect the best ones to use. Every Take the aftermath religious theocrats Nawaz and true liberals novelists, they protect more eye-popping of this group with by identity left' at the expense of, well, minority attitude mob over one of its victims. than picking the term "regressive are part of what Maajid imbeciles, rare example a religious who are so blinded intellectuals, examples coined sums up the backwards These people backward Nawaz that's members assault on the offices that understood too mild, it's really of the radical Christian near as scary. They may believe radical Islam the radical right I'm of Charlie Hebdo in Paris, a to be a force of the radical medieval in the United religious right. States, and they are going to burn in eternal hellfire, but they in a rush to send me there. Charlie of' of the Prophet controversy Hebdo had the temerity Muhammed. to stand against religious They were one of the few magazines bullies by publishing after the Danish of 2005 to stand on the side of free speech in the face of Muslim riots. cartoons cartoons They hit@;//w'~vwsg>Ig(I(;(>((I/2gl,>/'l l/25/1IBL(Is Bf)(j Illl('iq (;G((espG(Id(.f)(;(".I SS0033899 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 177 understood correctly and threatening that allowing violence people to intimidate was the first step on the road to a terrified, So they stood with Jyllands-Posten, "blasphemous" controversy with their the Prophet Muhammed. artists and writers the Danish drawings, On 7 January their lives, when two armed Muslim 2015, siblings 12 employees forced censored newspaper and published by setting cars on fire society. that triggered the 2005 their own humorous of the newspaper their way into Charlie cartoons of paid for it with Hebdo's offices in Paris and opened fire. Charlie from Hebdo their opposition as they are of Islam. approach, but unlike is a leftist publication. to the right. They are just as strident . I mav happen to think the National the rest of the left, I can't fault say they oppose bigotry, in fact. Their Marxist, and they do -- whether opposition in their criticism Front probably Charlie Hebdo they perceive to Islam flows of the National deserves for lacking a more nuanced consistency. it in the European Front They right or in Islam. So what did other leftists do when thugs? Did the old ideal of socialist 12 of their comrades solidarity finally were gunned down by religious kick in? didn' No, of course it didn't. As most of the civilized columnists refused world to relinquish adopted the slogan "Je Suis their Islamophilia, It only took two days for The New Yorker Bodies," attacking ¹4° Charlie Hebdo for "racist Charlie," even for a moment to publish of mourning. an essay entitled and Islamophobic a few leftist "Unmoumable provocations.14°" provocations.' http://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/unmournable-bodies SS0033900 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 178 Before the month was out, a number alma mater, Manchester¹42, that it made Muslims had banned Charlie expression a moral non-Muslim cartoonists Carol display went to Charlie Hebdo one at my including space" under their "safe policies, arguing Moore open letter condemning of solidarity from the left-wing PEN America of the organization, Hebdo quite in the same for making award for freedom so. They boycotted a "marginalized To of news, much less surprising established including class either. literary literary not be particularly and Junot Díaz thought Charlie I'm. not sure that's dead. in 2015 would Yet 204 members Oates, Lorrie Well, the fact that the prestigious observer, outrage. Hebdo students uncomfortable? There was no collective an ordinary student unions, students uncomfortable. It made Muslim league as making of British authors like Joyce the awards, community" community'" signing an feel uncomfortable. To the section and victimized, enterprises, cartoons of the French a population and that contains of the Prophet population that is already marginalized, that is shaped by the legacy a large percentage of France's of devout must be seen as being intended Muslims, various Charlie to cause further embattled, colonial Hebdo's humiliation and suffering.143 What circulation 4¹ suffering! that Muslims What horror! don't Cartoons, published in a newspaper with a minor even have to buy. http://www.theweek.co.uk/68699/uk-universities-are-attacking-free-speech-says-report ¹4² http://mancunion.com/2015/03/05/80-per-cent-of-uk-universities-restrict-free-speech/ ¹43 https://theintercept.com/2015/04/30/145-pen-writers-thus-far-objected-charlie-hedbo-award-6/ SS0033901 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 179 I'm sure the friends ashamed of their loved The author Muslims to murder theology, summed and families ones' of the dead Charlie who faced an Iran-backed him in the late 80s for the crime up the stance that the boycotters of cartoonists, out by Muslims and disadvantaged Islam, which as well wrote are hate crimes. minority. is highly and which have made themselves have the dubious satisfaction and Charlie Hebdo to see so many of his peers in the left-wing cartoonists to do with well funded, who stepped in after other writers Gaiman, This issue has nothing It has everything organised, rather than standing about a forbidden attacks sweeping These ... writers failed, decree) calling on area of Islamic was a Rushdie, into a cowed The boycott (religious had taken. as non-Muslims, they will feel thoroughly fatwa of writing ...hate crime, just as the anti-Semitic carried cartoonists actions. Salman Rushdie, The massacre Hebdo Europe and almost to do with entirely an oppressed the battle against fanatical seeks to terrify us all, Muslims silence. the fellow of watching travellers PEN tear itself got their award, presented pulled literary against the ideology out of that project. apart in public.144 public.' to them by Neil . I have to wonder establishment Now how he must have felt choose to attack murdered that created their murderers. Embarrassed for the left, I hope. Censorship in the ni1me of Isl:tin has been the nonn in the west for some inne -- Comment [A397]; S...nponmis swome t ¹44 http://scroll.in/article/723627/salman-rushdie-slams-fellow-writers-for-boycotting-ceremony-to-honourcharlie-hebdo ¹® https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/may/05/neil-gaiman-pen-award-charlie-hebdo SS0033902 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 180 A book on the original Press in 2009. The University as well as other depictions of context to external You'd worms think that the the Wwest attitude Islam. In what was criticised editorial terror images of the cartons as an assault on academic submitted process, the book without ehp$$]would Of thanks, Hebdo After shooting every terrorist Merkel!), in a series of attacks mastenninded Our History ol' draft of the book included by Yale the cartoons out the cartoons convince some of these cowenng is having its desired effect -- Comment [A398]; The nasscre was 275 TheYale t7aakwee2GG9 -- into silence. towards "We Brought in 2005 was published controversy but it seems that Islamic When Paris again fell victim headline original in the YUP's E to the Charlie the west these days -- cartoon and published consultants, The reaction suicidal intervened to grow a backbone, frightening authors' of Mohammed. Yale University freedom, Mohammed terrorism by the Islamic After among many of the left's attack (and there are a lot more of those in the response becomes to Islamic This On Ourselves: is just one example more outrageous. in November State, Salon.com Paris, It's 2015, with published Time To Square over 100 slain the extraordinary Our "Values" With "10 The article blamed the deaths in Pans. Liberals the West "behaving blaming horrifically in the Middle the West for the terrorist attacks is East for decades" for §ñ½¼e r8$4jr+tiB<~-rrrt3R3-14~-h434lI;ital-aAd-L3)&9BRR-'-=:»;-Baby--(3Re-1vkM ~:-I'HtM:-'--63B-tltestelv63--wltile-it@+ Comment [A399þ.Dart3t)jake WCs au a y https://www.thefire.org/cases/yale-university-censorship-of-mohammed-cartoons-at-yale-universityPress/ 147 http://www.salon.com/2015/11/15/we_brought_this_on_ourselves_after_paris_it_is_time_to_square_our_ values_with_our_history/ SS0033903 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 181 In March 2016, after Muslims to run virtually the same article The Terrorists Too."148 Too. policy. It's a tradition War One in fact, when more of an argument collection of treaties would Th@ left hag always wagged pacifists urged young why were young I doubt that Bertrand understood Russell, the ideology intellectual suicide. a key opponent become impervious Even if all the doctrines Mohammedanism is to be reckoned opposition with and Buddhism Christianity and a love of contemplation. unspiritual, What really ver its .-- Comment [A400]; Cunf s 7It flI@C1' 81%8/8 WSggu61t5 ÃtflM lCt~" art t~~ all the way to World at least, they had concerned cements the left's to wars in the Middle of World to scientific of Bolshevism personal of the evidence, and were true, this would Among rather than with Mohammedanism religions, Christianity religions, and Bolshevism with and mystical are practical, world.¹® world.'4 of its own values East, but its opposition leftists. of them is tolerated... are primarily to win the empire betrayal War One in if Islam were a serious threat in his time. An ardent Bolshevism social, And ~hnd We Are boys being sent to die for the sake of a examination doctrines at the Ieft men to stay home. Then, still be the case, since no unbiased Buddhism. its finger of Islam far better than today's Those who accept Bolshevism commit the same writer This On Ourselves, even than Vietnam; working-class have been quite so peaceable atheist, Russell allowed in the Balkans? But somehow Britain, Salon.com "We Brought that goes back further leftist -- 35 in Brussels, under the headline In a way it's not surprising. foreign killed to liberal over Islam isn't Muslim so much reformers. its Perhaps the ¹48 http://www.salon.com/2016/03/27/we_brought_this_on_ourselves_and_we_are_the_terrorists_too/ 149 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Practice_and_Theory_of_Bolshevism/Chapter_I_9 SS0033904 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 182 best example effort to drag his religion interfaith polite of this is Maajid silence from The height added Nawaz survivor of ridiculousness and David that purportedly Horowitz. Ayaan Hirsi should be off-limits the left's unintentionally faux-victimhood wake of terror though Law Center Daniel (SPLC) FGM Pipes, Pamela to Islam has become Muslim iso but you can't even laugh at Islamic any protects. -are 4ilari+>es:-$4<4eeleus;-ls-the>+." renie .ab(Mt..d,-tv4gk(+R-that. about arelig en thathates SSSGS-in-the-ai-FS-Anything about terrorists the1 eft desperately ef e 4erd+>I- werRen-svvet4e4 of those who worry i'~)aej:--beds4er.=-ts'/:: ,= comment IA4NI: Thisien'trunny enoughtc be ueerthere gays that gets its men in more richly "islamophobia" than amusing and hijab-pulling in the attacks that leave dozens dead? Is there -- and perhaps a religion with the sort of moderate precisely -I-mean;-r >'~a~-their+g m+tI+;-owqieally--siruste+44ae-the-sij4t AnythinganoFe and Islam attitude for humor, hilarious. he is rewarded groups like the SPLC ought to be encouraging, being accused of "Iislamophobi Islam is the most inherently supporting The entire list was absurd, including of Nawaz, anti-intolerance bankrupt Ali, an making at worst. extrem.ists." extremists." But the addition up just how morally more without disdain actually extremism, community, was reached when the Southem activist anti-bigotry, Nothing in the Muslim bigotry to a list of 15 "anti-Muslim rights Muslims age. For his work. combating the left at best, and scornful and women's summed into the modern and challenging tolerance, one of the few moderate Nawaz, so thin-skinned to prove the point the phrase "The Religion this is just my gallows that cartoons designed of those French humour to provoke cartoonists? -- anything more darkly it give rise to deadly Is there anything funny shootings, more preposterous than as than of Peace"? "" http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/10/maajid-nawaz-sple-anti-muslimextremist/505685/ SS0033905 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 183 I'm not trying "brave" America's Islam on prime-time television. How Fight to Really The left claims x!: '! that Muslims in Britain communities - believe. overall thought 11~ ' ~ British thought poll of Muslims of hordes of young who think are some more stats specific 1 23% would contains arguably as one of the more integrated acceptable. some of the western Muslim W cement [A402]; _E s ae s:ate¬ents se :-e ¬os: a ;sed o :-ey do mn'ase VC the ss.ê rat"e tM yo.. ede¬ent one of the 1,001 people That is compared to 58% of the net are OK. that just 35% of French Muslims and 19% of German Muslims acceptable. radicals have probably affectionately to British 1 52% believe Muslims cratered known as Europe's following "rapefugees" rapefugees" from poll carried importation on the continent. out by Channel Here 4 in Britain. should be illegal homosexuality like to see Sharia law in England 1 39% believe English otiay. , is gn en a pass. I Icre are a leu things homos those percentages Muslim about ha! . was morally were morally In my opinion of which-is in the UK found that not a single that homosexuality homosexuals an indictment Yet Islam, - who are often portrayed The same poll found need to. What Bigotry it opposes bigotry. population I don't that not a single one dares to tell a decent joke . reh:.uous emettees most bigoted polled I comedians supposedly A Gallup hard here. Because particularly a woman should always obey her husband, as opposed to 5% of overall 1 31% consider it acceptable for a man to have multiple wives SS0033906 SS 0033906 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 184 When it comes to Islamic assimilation immigration, It' least not yet. It's, "Wh.en in Rom.e, rape and kill Andrew Bolt on Sky News Australia, just right, lighting He recalled Australian culture. scholars in Australia, That's to Australians There's Abu Mohammed, that they are wrong just one problem. delivered show I go on regularly problem. The Grand Mufti, the speech in Arabic. At because they get the in the west. the grand mufti to think an option. welfare." welfare,' and then claim Islam.'s integration the case of Dr. Ibrahim gave a speech to explain his integration encapsulated perfectly everyone whose seem to be isn't doesn't Muslims of Australia, who can't integrate one of the foremost IIe has lived in Australia into Islamic for 19 years, and speech is in Arabic. what I call chutzpah. -. ---f comment [A403]: Zelete: s par3Ç''aD1a d Sttekte ttle tBCt8 -insular-and-hostilete-eatside-thinkmg-than-a-gender-studies JrBF-B4!dtt ie-morebigeted department-80-it-gives--us-aélear-answer-to-the paradox-oftolerance÷-no -you-eannot-tolerate-the-B4- truly4ntolerant There were 1.6 billion global population the world's according second-largest NIhe growth EEE - in the world to a Pew Research religion as of 2010 - roughly Center after Christianity, estimate. 23 per cent of the But while it is the fastest-growing Islam is currently one. of Islan3t 033 h( to I'3e eoncerrnn 'er@Wor liberals. religion Muslims that sanctions ere is a religion the executiones that sanctions of gays, ar forcinges women ii: i n that sanctions into submission, the tries to killing a of non- Comment [A404]: 30 ycu see ow o bor castof src n t e oneof te r ast n s t we stu n believers. SS0033907 c INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 185 They're Kansas. the Westboro Church on steroids, they' except re not mental trolls from They mean it. And they're sense of higher and it might which Baptist spreading. Islam preys on the most vulnerable purpose. explain th:z gingere Lindsay tce Lehan, ' should be especially . conceming frat boys singing We' We re supposed Well to look at critics And there is real out-group Christian bakeries intolerance -- it all comes from offering in such high high conversion them a numbers" Comment [A405]; ese ±upW Nc- us ;:een to,e n his part culadycre:er co VGTr'eSRaC& W TCF ey Str'p y ¤ mnSn or wh à ,.--- rates in jails, to the left but is not. the right with lewd songs about women there is a real rape culture eenvert to Ichm They have especially -They For years, the left has been tormenting consider in society, of Black tales of bigotry. as an example Lives Matter of "rape We' We re supposed Comment [A406]; Ms 18notthe time ci placefor anotherhiac+dic< eke. -- Comment [A40Ï]: ,Tireeomeancioffthe point to culture." as racists. in the west. And there is real homophobia in the west. But barely -- in the west. any of it comes from frat boys or Islam. So-the-next4ime-a4eftist-asks-you-what-youtre-doing-te4ght-rape-oulturecor4nteleranee «4+,--tl38-+!83(t-tHR4-8-Ieftaat-8848--V+38-W48t-V+38-+&+4+1Rg--t(3-I-1ghtR -8-438-raR-BRd438r+1-ator-homophobia;-take-a-Quiran-and4mm4t-in4rent-e&their-face Of course, if you were to do so in Europe, don' don't. Before And if you were to post a picture I was banned from one of the victims * Twitter, you might of your deed on social media, I had my account of the Nice terrorist be arrested for hate speech, so attacks. r i http:!Aa. .vw.bre!tba±com!!cndcn!201^!O9!O9!g !e!am! * http:!!www.daHymalec.u!dtvehowb!z!ad!c!e converting-islam-hasn-t4inishe4Koranhtmi locked for posting The same iconic picture you'd probably a picture be banned. of a dead child; had been shared by nger jihad!e why redheade are attracted to ra±ea! 3518919!Lindsay Leban confkme e cone!der!ng SS0033908 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 186 dozens of journalistic yct Twitter outlets, was too sensitive for it. So never again lct the left tell you that they are the ones 1'ighting bigotty. fact, its greatest defenders. VA'1ders, Donald They are the ones standing Nigcl Trump, Faragc, Douglas in the way of Pamela Murrav, and me. A — ail the people who are actually I Iirsi Ali, the most intolerant, bigoted in the world ideology Maajid doing something today face a constant same people who, if they were true to their own values, would But it's no matter. I Jnited Kingdom. I'm With confident Daddy we can win without Islam today is hke conununism disaffected people with And like communism, If there's compromise a decade when America walked It can't to fight Ayaan what we see as pushback from the very be on our side. States, and Brexit underway in the the lefty. utopian that is drawing the battle v ith cottununism, Wall for itself, re presenting in millions. sense of self-confidence. asserting it's that the 3gwest like the left constantly collapsed and to a lesser extent, Britain stage, aggressively vision They' all around the world. apologize that the Berlin their national the world tribal, violence one thing we learned from It was no accident proudly Sam Harris, in the early stages of the Cold War. an idealistic, it's inspiring on its values. and recovered elected in the United Gccrt Oclier, Islam Defeating young, Nawaz, They are, in can' t wants us to do. at the end of the 1980s. It was the end of had shaken off the malaise Margaret Thatcher the superiority, of the 1970s and Ronald and, well, Reagan the greatness of SS0033909 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 187 their respective nations. In the increasingly choice between the wWest and communism At the same time, western undermine America music broadcast - western west, proved it. That's superiority Saudi monarchs, liberalism and grinning leaders who advocated them ever donned Instead superiority peaceful of drawing of the west's of' of a tiny minority who will be defeated. to stand up for its ownown-, superior view muftis to western east, to Islam, they' oVf' o9f as jazz and rock that KGB capitalism of life and culture isn't re wearing memos radio broadcasts. of western glimpses to and Voice it? Far from headscarves, to in the the asserting bowing to In the Cold War, there were some western with the Soviet bloc, .sure, sure, but I don't think any of Internationale." followers with - - and the way of life the Islamic of peace," seeking against gays, nonbelievers, to present and women - soon be defeated. The Islamic view that is attracting as well designed was so successful - our leaders harp on about "the religion as the actions a world attitudes to the problems of the religion's - the superiority tantalising in mosques. coexistence attention violence But they won't campaign to the theocratic stupidly activities asserting leaders' western into programs Radio Free Europe were listening offering Mao suits or sang "The the increasing represents were boldly radio broadcasts, a long way from of western The propaganda pact, the a no-brainer. money state funding, of Soviet youth As Reagan and Thatcher communism, poured news of anti-communist across the Iron Curtain. asserted that up to 80 percent nothing With poor Warsaw increasingly became quickly governments the idea of communism. ceaselessly backwards, State may be crumbling swathes of young values, as their rock stars and mosques people. an entire generation as their concert in Syria, but it Because the west has done of young halls. Western Muslims came to leaders talk about SS0033910 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 188 the radicalization challenging wonderful of young and then turn around people, and talk about how Islam is. The results are inevitable It's theoretically and devastating. possible to peacefully coexist with Muslim.s, cmnment [AWB b hat s only possible if they -can find a way to remove themselves to themselves, and 1Wclims v hether they 're Indonesian, And the Muslims are perfectly ideology demonstrated living isn't. - who don't else to say nothing are attracted - actively happy to turn a blind element or killing regardless of that insists on the most poisonous eye to its horrors, of the horrendously Islam.keep generation, to an ideology om me us, if we refuse. with identify ' from contemporary Too many of the current cr Arab, Pashtun, their way of life on everyone imposing the radical En as poll after poll have regressive socially end of their attitudes of Muslims in the west. Like The old talking never worked points with about "violent a viral meme that needs to be fought extremists" are no longer working. fighting Like Reagan When America ended its space program. landings of' of history will Indeed, they an idea, and the only way to beat it is to show that the west is the best. leaders need to talk about what makes our society opportunity. head-on. to begin with. We' Western we are dealing communism, and Thatcher, they need to tirelessly landed on the moon, We can t yet know be, but it is moments and create the conditions great: freedom, in culture the Lold assert their country's War essentially for popular Armstrong's equality of greatness. ended. Russia gave up and what the West vs Islam version like Neil tolerance, of the mMoon first steps which t e scace ace was NC[ the ere of t e Coa a turn the tide rebellion. SS0033911 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 189 Islam has to be made uncool. lea need to champion anas of westem culture and ask more strongly it now, in music, fighting disposal, demonstrating the west and which made America - DO Muslims take seriously. particularly exquisite art and with as we do so what is possible the greatest country societies Hate don't we so cherish of human want to do - at our in civilization. our leaders need to bad. receive all manner As for some of the more poetic -- well, and we have to start every other means of creativity in the history [A4n]- Theke s R r - and comment )A43,3k]: shdle-and Nagub Mahfo 2-and Me? expect, I frequently detail or faith, with the free expression and this is what they really talk about what makes Islamic As you might - as it is a war of politics books, joumalism, But more than that So_Why as much Comment [A410]; Wo? why senses sesasags asagspasssageswassassanm This is a war of culture don't the greatness of death threats. ones, which describe Most of them, I my tortuous demise in I treat those as free erotic fiction. Ales.;-as-rkky-statu33-.";-lkas-(grewR;,-I-lkuv8-te-kiesl-v itjk-Ikeel-;)8-v. Iku-eve--33kiur+--~8Rekks-t4SR-t48 ZBBs-3+3-BRiBR8g'-All 4k'.; -I'%3k+3WBkka(8Iv-'ekRtlk38at8BkRg-('18Bk YB8&ssg8kkK>BF<4s-MK4--tedYRiukkSt-8BvA8 ]wks:-Al+3BB-v -kk4-K3"-3%"Nazks.;-%4K+-%ve-wkly-+'8t-k~-tkkt8F-Bk-tlkB-468k;--kt-ks-+batik--tlkresuts-I37+YR +~4BS43kks-t4stVi'48-rkk+-%PAtFkty-dctutl-3RSkstS-t4st-I-oug4t-4+-t&ku-%%1+3'6sly;--h Fk- YR&ttedr-4&Vi-33386y- tkR38!3-4tielI-itlN%%-t4at-4 ekRg-skkvBR%4v-skkB%/8reri--Ikv--tB3-83'kgb-3'33B8681ar--4R+wR-FRskk-3B-33RS-r~i+Rv-4%3p 8srrl38+' t83'3-S8%8si'I'dBC~ksk 3.4St8333" fust "vi'Bk+~ Ce333me33t IA43.2]."33unkkk SS0033912 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 190 Cnrnmnnt [A413]; Delstathis rrne So, last summer, pride march through I annoyingly the gay district had to resign myself of' of Stockholm, that point, I had given my speech at Ground Nightclub in Orlando, time, I had already Twitter (which TV itter thought Muslims love for western of Arabic me for a dayL feminists But at least their willful in the form (indirectly, who are so fanatically anyone who dares challenge "Islam team informed brutal By attack on the Pulse me that the risks were too great. By that death threats (and one bomb threat) like the metapherical rape victim, on it ceems I was asking for it!) realities. not directly suspended 1' for some months. as I had been planning Zero of Omar Mateen's been subject to a deluge promptly I have little everyday and my security to the fact that I could not lead a gay is a religion and leftists, ignorance of their immigration devoted not least for their relentless rarely comes with it certainly policies, to their 6th-century a body-count, delusions denial of at least does). It is only that they will murder them. of peace" we are told -- and yel; so many thei-r-AK-47s dare us to deny it. It's little wonder given that my mission honest -- offensive that I'm well on my way to becoming is to tell the truth no matter truths about them -- their brutal European are my favorite treatment cities, their fanatical kind). of women, willingness a hate figure how offensive What they really it may be. (All_right, can't gays, and Christians, to kill for Muslims, then, I' I'll be stand is that I tell the truth their rape-sprees and die in the name of a 6th-century in i ah --- f comment [A414]; Zon't undercut -ndec2 y¤a "pedophile' the pedopMe label. warlord. SS0033913 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 191 The gap between in many Islamic what Muslims believe is so wide that hard to imagine nationsis, — practiced Islam to be, and how v hat it is actually an i s!mute Re I orm at ton k-s4mle t' Well, often: ostrich Ssorry, there's a little no offense, on Islam, don't phrase 1 like to say that Muslims but it's true. With be surprised had better be prepared so much of the western when the public media determined turn to Dangerous Faggots to hear more se encesc tra: youre talk aboutt e actual teTC sts 5:°CAO my f e : Kar a er "7yf e d Fwneed. to play the to give them the real story. Because people unless you happen to be in the service of a fanatical, murderous religion, most still love the truth. SS0033914 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 192 10 ---- 20161 I was on a panel at UMass In April Hoff Sonuners, discussing campus event at which who would attempt Unbeknownst political correctness. I spoke would to disrupt Amherst Steven Crowder -------- Cornment (A417]: Beautyregimemovedto box at endof chapter,afterNietzschesection and Christina By then it was a matter of course that any have left-wing proceedings with Cornment (A416]: Deleteentirechapter.The bookis betteroverallwithout hittingthese ugly people' notesin the otherchaptersand better overallby deleting this one agitators by engaging to all of us, one of these protesters scattered in shouting throughout matches was about to become with the audience, my fans. an unfortunate viral celebrity. . name is Cora, but the internet camera erupting "'madness," "madness,*' "n1adness into 8 fit after Professor Waving video repeatedly now knows Sommers "Trigglyputf.' "Trigglypuff." her as Tllgglypuff. described ' She was caught on campus third-wave her arms about her head like the coastal tide, Trigglypuff shouting at Sommers off' to "f**k and shrieking "keep feminism as can be heard in the your hate speech off campus!" catnpus; All standard appearance. fare for Milo She was morbidly was 'BBI+3%@lval>IQpnk>rgivably-agly previous events. But what made Trigglypuff obese. [Ier -Ier arms were wider -She burnt more calories screaming stand out was her physical than my face. To state it bluntly, she at my speech than she had in the TA418]ÏT N W e c Canne r a problemin tone.YourusualstyleNEGATES valueyourinformationmighthave.The any presenceof this chapterin the bookdestroys the restof the book Comment (A419]: Phraseslike this dont workin a book eleven years. R4Sme ately descended in mockery of the poor woman, but I felt nothing a b re yo Comment [A421]: No, not the entire intemet but pity. How had she allowed wasn't she trying to get into such a sorry physical situation? And why to get out of it? I was particularly overweight, herself confused I was so horrified because the last time I'd shown I immediately hired a personal signs of becoming trainer. "Trigglypuff" If "Tli gglypa could SS0033915 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 193 odto waste tens of thqusands ot dollars on a gender studies course .----- cement (A422]: Likelyshes not payingfor collegeherself. comment (A423]: Not funny The answer is that she was swallowing lies as well as hamburgers. her it was okay to abuse her body, that she was still beautiful, society* Lies that told her it was society s fault, right. she could do the shc' she? same. So why didn't telling surely lies Sweet, comforting that everything was all not hers, that she was ovenveight. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ Comment ar et[A424]:~ t2 Ego and self-~ ~ ~-g aggfendizementbeC ~ Eire in bookk -This This isn t just a chapter write about why I m hot, although an entire chapter just about that. Okay, let's be honest, in 20 volumes memory. list for like an encyclopedia, (Thanks, 2016.153 some recognition Roger Stone for including terrifying conclusion this is the ideology -- in an ideology her to decades, possibly of uglines4 Trigglypuffand of righteous Known victimhood misery fashion statements reached their as the "fat acceptance many others, ruining even an entire life of bitter The Fat Acceptance book. Published me on his best-dressed act, one of the most violent It's the story of how the politics that poisoned be a whole for the hours I put in.) It's also about why being hot is a political you can make today. it would ~ quite easily P I could or one giant ebook that takes up your entire Kindle's by the way, to my buddy Finally, as you know, final, movement," Inovclncnt, her life and consigning and humiliation. comment (A425]: Beingagainst"fat acceptance* don't belongin a bookin which you're makingseriouspoliticalpoints,certainly notthe way you do it in this rnanuscript Movement "3 http://stoneonstyle.com/style-etiquette-101/best-worst-dressed/mr-stones-11th-annual-best-worstdressed-list-2016/ SS0033916 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 194 The fat acceptance movement fat into their system by downing overweight way" that i»ay -- that is, genetically There may be some truth to that. But the fet acceptance thatfat attempt people to tell hem shaming." shMltng, Having should not be encouraged the teth-ebout heir health to improve and romantic the left now hopes to turn the war against fat-shaming spent decades . trying to ro feminize as possible. ' . impression that the cultural ', „,: " ' ' .. left is running words, doesn't relying work, and it's hopelessly on fat people to be fat. act-value and that any "fat- agrees with and cannot king my Callahan, '.. me. "Safe Firstly, : „' d=±± " ' „, E you ever got the shamed 'lesbian' _-.. --f Comment [A429]: Don'tuse asa l stur London, that suggests fat- it's based on survey data - in other and dietary choices exercise." and exercise, ---- -- Canunent [A430]: Give moredetailabout whatit says, andcounterwith someevidence that it doeswork. emeritus of America's — and slow u-.c*-c incrcrecatelisre do the necessary -- Comment [A428]: Thisis not true. Noone arguesagainstthe healthissues be right. College to be honest about their weight president ..----{ Comment [A427]: Meaning? and anti-homophobia, Pardon the pun, but: fat chance. Daniel . [A4M]! Howdo you know to try and look as unattractive women out of ideas, you'd flawed.* .--I- c----* holds that prospects-constitutes anti-sexism, ' ',,'' .1~)r Tnere is only one serious study, from University shaming their weight, the accepting into one of their next great causes. Having men, they 're now pushing ~. predisposed ' -:-:- bridges also movement the causes of anti-racism, exhausted nearly about obese people every chance they get. Fat acceptance 8 milkshake people are, like gays, "born gap, arguing —it isn't h- isn't What you think work," and beat upon socially wrote est Callahan, oldest bioethics strives a former was as persuasive research institute, never to stigmatise smoker, obesity has not in 2014. PThe force of for me to stop smoking as the threats to health." -$ Comment [A431]: Societyalreadyshamesfat people.No pointin bringingup this study to ~provethat we mustdo individualshaming * https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/news-articles/0914/110914-Fat-shaming-does-not-encourage-weight-loss '55 http://www.breitbart.com/milo/2016/07/05/fat-shaming-is-good-science/ '" http://www.theatlantic.cembee!tb/archive!2013/01/a-case-for-shaming-obese-people."".".i" tastefully/267446/ SS0033917 J INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 195 8 little With that "fat victimhood we can help fat people help themselves. effort, emptance," acceptance," !i«i i perhaps the mod and gnevance Let's young, be clear. Fat acceptance, impressionable Fat people unfit activists like Lindy women are not healthy that's positivity"ity" pnslti) perfectly as some call it, is not empowering. West are not only causing, loneliness, isolation, but actively encouraging and misery. The people are evil. They have to be stopped. not sexy, and certainly life, and usüaldy fail to enact this is 8 lifestyle or "body girls to lead a life of gloopy this stuff on young pushing ol' idea to come out of leftist and irresponsible ala=ing is given the heast attack 11deserves. politics, It's cruel. Fat acceptance But first we have to make nonnal partners. hot clever. So why are we teaching okay" .I I okay? mean, I understand the logic centers of your brain shut down They die young, your arteries live an ---- that \ our children are hardened, c===[Ae:]: uncear;are peopiesaying they'resmarterthan non-fatpeople?Or do you meandever in the British sense,as in. doing the mart thingwith their twes? Comment [A433]: To you but maybeto others but are Comment [A434]: Not necessaryand goes againstyourearlier professionnoi Io be cruel as well? Comment [A435]: Not necessarilytrue Sometimes Chocclete. they' Maybe I suspect that the body positivity movement it's graft feminists behind At-Any-Siue in?4)neidentally--Healthy pn>fiteWy-pavete-seeter all those idiotic shain classified than a third as overweight one of the biggest in an age where Plus -sized and beautiful. in some way. Furthermore, fatness is not only accepted, like Tess Holliday feminist .c;..i;.ist funded by Big . ----l Comment[A436]: ,__---{ [ message to love the skin Not necessarilya feminist - .t ..., new-higMy..ears-highiy-the future children will - { Comment [A437]: Not funny . --3 aunt's fat rolls and stretch marks. drains on the US healthcare Meanwhile, ie-going-to-betheeer==ef=y States alone, with nearly of adults are obese in the United "models" Blodels te!!ineveme "." ef Ty;=4Di=hete&Treatment4enterd+In learn how to count by using their unwed More is in fact secretly health problems system Despite 70% caused by obesity these facts and statistics, are also we live but celebrated. are promoted victimhood-mongers in the press as natural like Lindy and normal West make sure to spread the ,___ Comment [A438]: Needmorestatisticson this point;your argumentis bestwhen ~supported. ---- Comment [A439]: Theseareall straw-men - Comment [A440]: Worthit to distinguish betweenplus-size(whichcan be a size 8) and obeseGess Hohy 5 a W2e26P SS0033918 I INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 196 of jigglyness lifestyle to their young insecure teenage audience, when they aren't trying to period»." thc11' periods." them to , 'shout about their pe1 lAda. convince A conspiracy-minded see some sort of warped of raising oneself strategy: mating thc1I' their level best to convince This certainly person might --- look at this obsession with fatness and periods those born on the asexy-side to make themselves other women of genetics appear spukivees and Comment (A441]: Is this a quotefrom Lindy Vvest or someoneelse> Usemorespecific you' examplesfrom LindyWest if re namingher, ratherthan a vagueattribution. are doing 'Unsexy' "repulsive" ..--- Conument [A442]:"Unsexy" [A442]: and [@+M]1 don'twin yourargument well t' Qlln d'll" the bar for all instead we' isn't the first time we've seen the logic of "lowering up to make the grade. Unfunny .Un5.umv There are even subgroups fat activism with their worldview, Largely made headway movements and looks at how misogyny misogyny is presumably because of women in youth Daddy culture. Sure, the movement young might feminism, youth and impressionable they' say re bigly beautiful, Meanwhile, obesity women anti-fat bias. In ..----{ Camnent [A443]: Unconvincing attractive. positi»'ihr West, fat positivity and Lindy incorporates has actually can be traced back as far as the 1960's, but = comment (A444]: To whom' . -{ to the other identity-political subcultures .--- and and race equality. spread the wisdom of positivity" body posltlvlty among a bigotl - comment (A446]: Are you sayingthey lie? Proor/ As - rising, that believes identity, with that dangerous levels of obesity and kill those who criticize even children becoming it are hospitalized Comment [A445]: Why?What changed? Doesthis stemfroma minorityview being disseminatedon social media,anddetractors shamedinto agreeingor stayingsilenton the topic? their biased and legitimate is rapidly 8 popular peers, who suck it up for fear of being branded We how have a wave of youth acceptable, with which stock. An oddity. and no different such as transgendensm, minded intersects like Tess Holliday it is seen as 'normal] "Fat Feminism", when men find attractive They were a laughing The social-justice equally including feminism it was never serious. Today of fat positivity, -- Canment (A448]: Evidence --( am an oppressing Comment [A447]: Who are7 them ~ - Comment [A449]: le this eventrue for their reckless SS0033919 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 197 If fat acceptance eating to accommodate campaigners students no longer The fat positivity culture f' for angsty, wrist-cutting, service their understanding identities. has become particularly blue-haired teens in that awkward to encouraging We are anti-racist, and generally transphobic, an all inclusive have more entry requirements The blog generates hundreds them to lives of social misery politics risks hurting you' re fat are condemning by people unattractiveness. plot only are they deluded how desperately, they proclaim colleges and journalism even with themselves from anti- hatred, about page, which appears to Iiluminali' ...- ( Conunent [A41]: ."the The tliumtttsti' muminatror *theSkuH -g society7o I an¶Bones eoorettr other young movement, Tumblr which users who are -..-- risks condemning Americans. to protect. all an." who keep telling you to a sad and lonely and miserable "proud" proud" at the world with it" life, and it's not your Canment (A43]: for their own themselves and "happy") you to but (notice they' d Comment [A44]: how loudly re also trying Again, absurdcharge Namecalling to Comment (A45]: Attackingspeakersas ugly diminishesyourcredibility.Actually-it ERASES not to mention and infected u charge Once again, the them. surprising, Howl unn nt [A42] .Howl And guess who's most at risked Black who are bitter to be anti-queer secret society. to be obese than white those it claims You are being brainwashed! really and Qon-" media of fat (and non-"straight states the blog's ladies, but these short-haind-plump-womeeNot pull you into the flames the micro-blogging stage of rebellion anti-classist, and obscure and unhealthiness. left's victim What's space" this bizarre who are 1.5 times more likely love your body even if classes. on Tumblr and showcasing of interactions Americans, fault. popular --· Comment [A450]; Providesomehard evidencehere, otherwiseyou'rejust repeating have to be enlarged find blogs that take the movement anti-ableist, than an old-world being brainwashed into Sorry, able to walk between physically This is where you will is a bing dedicated people of color. sized") would nl' like "Fat People of Color". deeper with niche ideologies "This had their way, school hallways the private sinister, is how this stuff has seeped out of sector. JC Penney is now commissioning ads to SS0033920 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 198 girls it's okay to be 8 hadwhale? tell young can see the commercial America's phrase it like that, obviously.) obese population to obesity That they would to market decision this once-respected J[' ,.. But JC Penney is joining companies until they die, they stop buying quixotic 8 bizarrely following good about themselves they drop dead from clothing. your XXXL is that the gravy train is an analogy apparently, . --[comment --$ Conunent (A456]: No and turn to is a sign of desperation. Someone ~SOtneone has made the bnlliant products You - both numerically is growing JL.' -- and JC Penney sells boat covers that they call clothes. horizontally pandering logic. don't (fhey business model: obesity-related brand to-women the ranks of consumer help your customers problem' The problem? illnesses. What JC Penney has failed for 8 successful business, ..--- comment [A457]: This entire argument is ridiculous feel When to realize, not an actual vehicle coated in gravy, J 'i inspirational-quotes piwa" eR4he-boxes endr±±Dea!4weny-that-your-left How Ugly People Sigmund of themselves the hidden teenage-boy though-youete-the-whole a4your44ERCE+hinmg4hreagh" l -ID'."..4-84iajng44reegh-'-'-') d outdated and methodical ideas were wacky. a great dealmany ever-picked in modern psychology departments, than the old cigar-smoker. But in one important of out" our beliefs regard, They' who think re right, to an correct' .seX he was correct: sex is and motivations. ap-a-guiter-for-any-reason4myond-getting-leid -And no ---~-- Canment (A459]: This is not true -- "" - Canment (A458]: This wouldneverhappen Vote as more scientific agent behind -emaamgeven arm-iaeumbrthat2s Freud is seen as a little extent - many of Freud's -¥on -such-as \ Canment [A460]: Thisis not trueeither http://www.breitbart.com/milo/2016/06/26/no-jc-penney-fat-people-absolutely-hate/ SS0033921 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 199 Cl.0 not --- Comment [A461]: Youcannotsay this is true --of everyone. GF4FeBHmi--M ads 4t also reveals -It itself' itself in subtler in a way that most women than 8 loser)Terds without reasons: they know are not - because they know hate jocks some jock-type ways. Men are obsessed with because they're athleticism, that without hiey'll insecure about their physique And jocks achievement and in competition 18 less attractive that nothing never get a girl some nerd-type winning to 8 woman they know -- Comment [A462]: Not necessarilytrue . ...---{ that ..--- comment (A463]: Nottrue { hate nerds for similar and ambition, they' they' they 'll never hang on to one -- Comment [A464]: Don'tmakefun of school shooters-andcertainlydon'tcomparethemto liberals. r -at-t48-f)l)rI-+)1-t48-]-Vt4-Ru%kRV;-(&vaR448t-tl'N:;HMWement-of-the-Same-name-that-emeFged-et-4heend-0 Ven4hat--the-08F he--l·9th-GentuPr progressives·emeFged·before4he·devekgmwnt+4mass mediarwhen the-art-GEmask·ing··theif-GKMst--HGeppeShng-elements 0F political-movements4eamed ··thelf-fun-hating-fleetFES--WGS-plain-f0F-el-l·-to fer-all-te ..... Jech.-ll)f-."--v.ee-pea)R-f~~r--u)ll-tr> ........................................... ...................................... ............................... -- Comment [A465]: Elements--.andpeople?is this a commenton spokespeoplehavingto becometelegenic7Bedearer, See: 41S&·plein40·600-WeS-theegeneSadmeGarheV6 as V StS2 They weren 4 W)keFS — -.]heV €0uldn yeWeVeF·60094pielBW·0 e a date4e4he alleFRa 4GmpeFBBee Ve-pre -heve-to ! Comment [A466]: It doesyou no goodto say that peoplewho disagreewith you are ugly The progressives were notable The British progressives Edwardian era, a time when the nobility had 8 particular for their hatred of both the top and the bottom loathing of society for what they saw as the excesses of the and upper classes flaunted their wealth and glamor. In SS0033922 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 200 the United States, pmgressives coined excess lorded over by wealthy Progressives moral fervor: Age" Agc the h:rm "Gilded to refer to 8 similar period of' of ,__-- -- Comment [A467]: Whars wrongwith the phrase"GildedAge"7 elites. were not socialists. They were animated they were often staunch Protestants. not by Marxist ideology Their reasons for championing but by women's revealing: ................................................ the historian Paige................................................................................................................................................ huffrage are Meltzer describes how the cause of women's suffrage........... ..-- Coment [A468]: ButSusanB Anthonywas .................................. a Republican,andthe party championedtheir rightto vote.Republicanswerethe progressives beforethe DepressionandRoosevelt was taken up by progressives who believed that women were a force of moral purificationi Comment [A469]: Summarizethe nexttwo "Puritanism," paragraphsin a sentenceaboutwantingwomen wrote H.L Mencken, whose lifetime spanned the first progressive era, iS to dean up governmentand wantingto civilize the workingclass. " the "haunting fear that someone, somewhere, might be happy And who could possibly hate happiness? miserable Why, people those who are denied it themselves. like moths for precisely It's also no surprise which has always economic often-stifling group, to 8 flame that the early progressive tended to produce it's the middle standards a worrying draw ugly, movement number was driven of killjoys. More by the middle class, than any other the most about social propriety and of behavior. you have to do is start telling and nannying joyless, dour, sexless people other people what to do. Anyone to have 8 good time will controlling movements this reason. class that tends to worry This, then, is the recipe for attracting ability Authoritarian Hlnnlng' come running as its 19th-century to modern predecessor. toyour who feels resentful progressivism, movement All . ----{ Comment [A470]: wo basisto say this at their lack of because it's just as And who feels most resentful? Why, the ugly of course. That explains .:'fhat drawn to ugly people? why ugly people That's are drawn a far more intriguing to the left. But why is the left increasingly question -- and it has a far more troubling Comment (A471]: All this pop psychologyis hogwash.Youcant say ugly peoplearedrawn to the left. Haveyoueverseenthe peopleat a Trumprally9 answer. SS0033923 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 201 t)r il r''ralr na i: ) ' 'rnXlnx [h Xrnxrkkil..'1'krr .1xa ..ai+~[~vk.n ~ .rn watt t^*2h==**=aar r a .is 4... -'i . . ----{ f c=•* t tlr( ~i lr i; ........l.. .1XX le . e ........1 ..:.. +1. ccrc/Crrr.II ra r c rnwl ~ Irl "trrrl e±days. end besie t .. 'i. rs; ., ~i..ra... ~... r... nra . t.."airrarr& ' whiek ~4k — Gleft-gees-eff-the-)PAk ~-.— tenihingly4egieal ..--- Comment [A473]: This paragraphof praise for the left mightbe usefulelsewherewhenyou =-,— needto show ---T,s „«eaiaaiiiy impâitniity ixit the restof thissectiongoesoff the rails. F 4 4 .. t 4 "",- — -'=Ghamp .;Il ap.;..:. mm rnrr j. ». t jik84-8-4++%-%vs-&F+fv6i4'-&k--kjlM48k- fame 01 wealth wealth at the heart of ceonoITIlsts " quest for riches. and the able bas never been paItioularly tbe succcsaful., need a NietZsChe analysed their economic and embedding the value of vvealth, and humanity's ChampioIIing populal, cf the German %"1th.U11dcrdogs, and to take pIty 011tbc less Or a Rand., to remind - Is Important. Society Why StriVing for They relrIIBd us that soBlctnlles, tbc hest SS0033928 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 206 way to help the less fortunate 18 not to weep or proclaim their superior - and that maybe, just maybe, improve their condition motivate the less fortunate. After all, what's virtue, but to help them to you need the extravagance the point of elites to it to the top if you can't of making have any fun? , fhe former OK to strive for victory for wealth and achievement. and self-interest. I'm The latter reminded going to remind the world reminded the world that it was that it was OK to strive the world that it's OK, and indeed a virtue, to ..----I Conunent [A483]: This makesyou seem petty I peny Strive for hotness. Does no one else realise why aspirational culture to continue who don't selling depictions is that it challenges 1950s archetypes glamor of unachievable matters" ,The matters? The reason] sexual power people who don't agree with want mainstream and preserving muscleheads of the 1980s self-loathing and alienation. would he have hated himself They drive us to succeed. enough them and, yes, punishes to become Sex is the ultimate those wins - or at least creates artists out of those left behind, 8 gemus? We need motivating .. c ant [A484]: Thisis muchmorea way to closeout this chapter.Makethis lastsection all-Amencan $ Kurt Cobain had never felt like a skinny fag because of all the popular conform beauty always ..---- Connnent [A482]; Grandosity bacMireson you factor and who have to carve our --- comment [A485]: Don1say youwant to ..---I returnto the sits ( ...--omn nt [A486]ÏÖid he'~@iy~ he reatyo --- canment (A487]: Howcan you knowhefelt . ---this? canment (A488]: This is semdarto the twisted reasoningyou makein the gay chapter on Catholicism.It doesnt makesenseor pass integiectualmuster.irs just troningonan issue that manyreaderswill mighttake seriously their own thing. Keep-the-gemuses-ugly-and4he-celebñties-hotr In today's - its mere presence disagreement so many leftists supposedly beauty. feelings-focused, is enough culture, to disturb being hot is becoming the left. I sometimes retreat into safe spaces when they hear I'm coming offensive Hotties offense-shy views, of the world, hr because they simply tear off your chains! rather like wonder to campus if the reason 18because of my can't bear to gaze on such Adonis-like canment (A489]: Thisis a stupidway to end a terriblechapter.Notworth keepingin. DELETE SS0033929 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 207 STAR'l' START BOX MIIA S PERSON&BEAVE¥eEGMI I i>!~ii m Ek~m~»>»XI> ,..- comment (A400]: This feels life a Patrick Balemanjole, If so, notworth maMng.If you intendit sincerely.this is notthat kindof book .'.11 L ...,. 8@i'38F-kwee+'kebab&-3+(-4884kB-1YF-8-sBkksBg&vfkf4-kl-pI8fe-tkf+I3%-slitl38<4;-B--ekkp-o)-4>1BOk;-<<3A84.jalBcj'I <84» Y. BRll!81 .teak FBHjh.'I«.'»»' h'~""> '" ' '8>-j»><>ji GE 8 yea rematiGa y.. ..1 ..111.. .1 .1, ......-..I chan .. x>3»i>. 1 m. »«h!> I ~;....... ~, >F 1'-" 1 ' ikl " O ' aL 1.........11. ' >!i >1 i»»»> 3»>i ~>F1 jS(BHE]S«3IERE>r-tk«itdR' l»i I>>>1'i 1 kl I ' i »gj>>»! 1>>»> I bio I 6 >il kt» I kfsdtkke' FIE>> .3».'Fm'IE(BBB ls-JtlklgelRB.g--YYF%'-Bus-dYe-efBFfklkg-f«3-GOYYke-NYYY+kkp:COBB-33338gktke-3 Hl+8BFc stHFIRli! te.eeTae .(»FB."IHlc' 8 I" . ':HIE.RIIHE>EIRB-tltlejEEIH f38FO«kkf Bse-38-tfF<4/3plkt 1Yk-44tesh&KOF-)-83%-"-8-Fetekk@klkI-BB«3 ypaa~taiag-gel-,beesase.kkiitet~sst ia-keMev er-I ase ekkBB)pfkfkks4<~BYBBHg-g«1;;-4386i%BM:-)-11k'4-k4-Ofsl'f L -I 0 All ~~ «Mat. my-anns BBYk-4;-Yak"fkkg;-4-BI3pl'j--Itei47-4~6kfeF-t3F-k$84f-"-s-3'Yk«848818333$-6K'-BTA beek--i-use-La-Mer-imRI-kselaheve twee a week use aanid-prised geenaheVeget shest-and beeasse4pretee al . \ r I e ee .3 —- -s-r" I ...I rt .aL 4pkaba-. 4p-L~ ' I add shine and ghee END BOX newha rap .I -!";: Bp-f- d '= . "... queaak d.;BSYLenden --- comment (A401]: DELETEENTlRE CHAPTER SS0033930 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 208 11 WHY GAMERS A syringe poorly-spelled filled with an envelope fancy stuff, three-ply! started reporting that read: "MILO unsheathed and smeared with YOU on GamerGate, playgrounds bust-up was between ordinary and a coalition games are misogynistic was sitting lady in London, with a knife of well-connected postmark bloggers bag. A Comment [A493]; Rienta: me G,tset ms e-acter mus:dearly ext a ° Gar e a e W non n_me s See scr¬cnIs :x 1 paper-the door after I I was involved with comment [A494]: 2cn't assar e one k"celedge m pad at eade at easeI :a:he tacit, event,so start withthe with the Zoe Quinnrevealand andfill till in the bdokgrdrihddetailsabout gamer background rruatratidnafter garnerfrustrationatter that. connections media, games journalists to their favored of their pet political km narratives, had become nim reporting and contemptuous a biased, sub ec elitist tribe, riddled committed of anyone outside to distorting --- Comment [A505]: Jn œr -- their clique. b.ttphûYEb9]ly.W9.OShegg!_tenegm?_nerg/kg!gy:cygcg:gwgating:gaglg_giz§§:ggyjag:Z§f019 SS0033933 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 211 * . a ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... a r xr * C' pskpsk]S>--SBkskkkgSY-eBjjkke-gSYB~+S;-wSSjkeStj)S-(+3-v:k3YYYSBSBkj-YRjkkkekjtje~:-4sSYBe~-+<3fktkktkkk4x4-Ye p u ue. j36%-'-Y3]--jr='-YYkjBjSYjSk3YIS4YS At 44'-SSBIS--tjYBS;--kjM:-g8RY+'SpFSSS-'A-A+-bSaxkBYHYkg;-Y&-SS]Sr-'k+1-YYYBYI f]k"-V8jt3]it%'8-jkjr<'YjjYBkk-BkkJMBck';--(-<>BIBSB(6tkff s-jk]A!-AYkkjd-:,ySY'ksssksk+;YBBd-gSB'M& pkksjk-<8'3-8>+-BYE eke-QBlBYIYkjQVBk3p@Y-'-+3]"j8k ARYkxk-Akkkj'kF+3pj-SRr]-à jdrpPV.'-blBOPtpkf8hf;--'A+Y<'-,. jfjSi4%'-kt ji-pk'NSQ-fBkrj SYYrSYgje3B-,-'$'jkSV--kr;-'-f'38jqSrjjkaV,'-jfkg-&FkjkSjk;->~%-CgjgkkS'YBg--kBjM)S.--YfrS-BYBY4%-j'kfkW--YSM [fjS -tjkSjk.- Cekkkrkkant fASIYS]YBy whom"? Comment [A507]: s eedssoecFc examplesor feels like bombast . CDmment [A508]: S vr rc t"è Ceamnn c cet 44alht e //tA ana h km nesmAn h 1 71mIVMh A SS0033934 sa as INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 212 Before were working long, garners began to suspect that games journalists together. the same messages They all repeated and feminist progressives alter all. So hey began for looking -- Comment [A509]; W"u? Comment [A510]; W o9 clues and connections. found Augustag]Athey favorite games designers, bed with a big one. Zoe Quign, wasn't just metaphorically them. An @pose from one of Quinn's abused by the games developer emotionally in bed with journalists. who claimed ex-boyfriends, (he was an SJW;:, asyou might Grayson of Kotaku, .-- She was literally guess), revealed -- Crnnrnent [A515]t Pubrishedvvherte'? { - that one of games without highlight Comment [A513]: Se description-explain c'esseac your Comment [A514]: Oc you ave a good encuchsourcefy tr s a c .satro Omewse t s:mIs3: seer I"I wheneve the e s o own inveved o- tnc eppos e sice:c you yo accuseher c' seu t shav . One of them, had gone on to favorably { Ctnnment )Asst]t Stert here. in to have been Ñ Nathan press' one of the fem nist games disclosing their relationship. I will reporter private be bold and say that few people beyond is friends, or even romantically nature of these relationships, for Quinn and Grayson. circumstances professional it shouldn't tf ack reccrd connected disclosure Sure, what Grayson is sometimes difficult. really cataclysm. ethical, care if a really to, one of their reporting did wasn't lead to a culture-war professors journalism subjects. Given the So I have some sympathy but in normal But thanks to Ihe dreadful of the gatnes press, and their appallittg response to gary)ers' concerns. it 'c-soc° --- Comment [A515]: ~cc vag ,e t'cr sucha t±nke: condemnation did. Following embarked of the Grayson-Quinn on one of the greatest acts of collective Twitter $ investigation foolishly the discovery and hundreds of virtually prodding of threads every prominent a sleeping dragon, connection, internet-sleuthing on 4chan and Reddit, games journalist games journalists garners across the web in history. In IRC channels, garners conducted and their connections. a relentless After Comment [A516]: Ms is cocm i mr W nonme s ,c his smeec tece ac corr and odd t r waxhase e -gs re years of were about to be sent to the burn unit. 880033935 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 213 Gamers subjects. reporting without disclosure, Critical Distance, coverage subjects vko consultancy Silverstring friends' friends¹61. on their friends. a hub of social justice-oriented including personal had reported between and in some cases had even donated to reporting Gamasutra a web of connections Games journalists site Patreon, former uncovered quickly had yven Media, and former editor-at-large games critics, them monthly oi' of Vlambeer Rami Ismail Leigh The other leading money studios Polygon feminists and their allies and lovers polmcal to their reporting games produced games editor Ben in the crgwdfundin through by the leftist Kucheral6° dozens of articles -- Comment [A517]; Mearim cat subjects. gave repeatedly dorlations published Alexander, games journalists -- comment [A518]; Is as really ed m jusI m: tahshcniceaes creative like . Others, lauding their and SJWs of the games media all had similar track records. Durin g the 2016 general elections, extent of the connections of the worst Tapper and Wolf Republican Clinton offenders, Blitzer between to interview primaries' primariesl62. . CNN ahead of her primary with the Clinton asked the Clinton even the Wall Street Journal, meetings observers the Democratic contributor National as WikiLeaks and the mainstream to help the draft questions Trump Donna debates with ostensibly Campaign campaign Donald were shocked media. Senator Bemie fed CNN publication, . WikiLeaks one comment [A519]: :~e'ace t7 s w t An ana cgy t°r mght help at' ms r conte×t cr s nilar, to £my ec;;eorre-œss of : s sz ect c ve ts ¬ore easonstote ested t° s even ' we re °ot game-scr co° t mere paceive yes, but an inquisiter, were formidable all the enemies in Hollywood reactionaries enough continued - This lawsuit Nick Gawker the Univision to threaten including would of PayPal Denton co-founder as Thiel the funding resigning. would of a financially result in the company But according gamer that proved A shadow sale. "Gamergate Gawker's well-being. defenders than the proved to Gawker's to be the publication's had made over the years was there, in the background, existence enemies. none were more effective that even our regular Gamergate the outing of filing for of its former was later sold to Univision. and Hogan op-ed following down the company, Hogan. the privacy violating come back to haunt Gawker, and editor-in-chief Max Read, it was the humble "Of for gratuitously this included that would to bring wrestler reputation reason. Fatally, as gay in 2007 - a decision on a 10-year vendetta crippling Valley, for its gleeful Shamed, It was singled nonetheless. Peter Thiel chief, as telling age, Gawker The publication private had an even worse reputation. So You've Been Publicly book, over offenses of Kotaku, company - the power turning wouldn't media, $jie foe. in Silicon Read in Ia 2016 of well-organized went too far - step up to speak for us - And when Gawker in the media editor-in- toughest in New York Gamergaters," former really far every crisis up a notch or two and making impossible." SS0033939 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 217 Ay the end, of their boycott adnutted that OamerGate Gawker campaigm. against Gawker had cast the company and )landerous]y in death and rape threats against innocent Mysterious, anonymous revealing their personal meetups. Gamers information style revenue' threw as sexists and rnisogyniisLs in video CCTpaniesadveGSPDon GaWkeandthose Evemse s M Ce ' Ms :husws seven-fpe loss. their full weight games. Gamers ho .-.-- Comment [A539]; A e l e cvges Exp e aha endured. ceaseless war against garners, anonymous bomb threats to their garners started to do what no other group who tangled painstakingly, unwise to beat back tlM shatrring millmxual waged on the web and sending left had ever done before games journalist's media, portrayed women forces on the internet in lost. --$ carrrmeat [A587]; Neadabatter citatica the publication endured. And gradually, the cultural figures" and the games press, and later the mainstream against garners, who were repeatedly trafficked "seven 8 advertisersI, they started to win. ghat affair v, ovid turn into an example leading began as 8 tenor for the whole and tlM Nnears 8nd the new inqutsitions the people The New Moral -- world; of the cttltuN1 the way wme 8 bunch of web-sawwg with spat over one 8 guide on how left. And, in true nerds in their basements, accurate . --- camtiaenit pt54g]: is trriapartray@i _,- Panic Comment [A541]: s seÒcn eedsT ProgressNeLef: chapte on he nNot c S° e d For most of the 20th century, cultural left. Literature, be dominated theater, by a politically entertaimnent high art, music, correct shadows. Just look at the outpouring and Lady Gaga, and celebrity progressive was subject to a creeping and of course Hollywood elite who forced of anger and gnef from actors in the wake of Donald Trump's by the all gradually political pop-culture takeover dissenters came to into the icons like Miley victory. Trump Cyrus supporters ¹ªª http://www.breitbart.com/london/2014/12/11/gamergate-anti-bullying-campaign-cost-gawker-over-amillion-dollars/ SS0033940 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 218 -- in Hollywood many of whom I know -- kept quiet, even though personally their candidate had WOn. Video violence resistance games, a far younger that only seriously cultural in games with in the 1990s and early 2000s, theydeveloped the conservative to politicization politicised world. There's of any kind. "I just wanted Gamers just wanted the medium it has been negative. them unwholesome the evidence resentful is or SCXiSl, 167 Political video of losing their children A lack of evidence Rodgers, the "killer that he played killing irlvrrlvetl video virgin" in bad behavior attention commentators are universally y h0 find no cudence either side critical of and those on to the video from every walk . saying of life screen. who went on a shooting rampage No evidence in May You may remember 2014.169 Naturally, that the games had anything was needed. too compelling Comment [A542]: lephrase to ack-cMec;;e tw scr'e reserchers I t M ts pmes r"3 --- Cwttmeet IA55tt]; Goad. SS0033942 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 220 The hunt for culture-war Chronicle of Higher Education implications to compare meamngs' meanings¹7°. . Like hunt for hidden in every expression the culture overzealous Freudian virtually every human experience back to childhood interpret every artistic expression through Lisa Ruddick, an English professor running for the smartest growing number Nothing Is Bill, Cool," the sadistic antagonist femaleness always are carried within a sewing job which no woman", us. "it has been degendered, uncritically she sees as registering "a historical and "of the boundary The lunacy a feminist believable. To most people, who wrote The Silence refutes on the find a way to (an institution times) is one of a essay, "When feminist hero. the idea that maleness bag." skinned to an era marked in the studies to turn Buffalo explains, into a body is 'always and posthuman, The corpse, once flayed, and posthuman fleshed." Halberstam sensibility, by the destruction "is which of gender outside.' 171" inside and outside here isn't just that a serial killer hero, it's that the scholar critics into a gender-defying the hero-villain's shift" between used critical it is postgender, with culture of modem Halberstam identity "detectives" at the who manage to link of Chicago skin, Bill "Gender," stitches blends her perspective binaries women's to In her influential bizarrely led one writer lens. university of The Lambs, and wearing By removing sexual trauma, at the University how one scholar of Silence psychologists this orthodoxy. challenging she describes of academia their own particular and most forward-looking of dissidents critics of culture who targets only women it actually Of The Lambs thought is simply could in any way be his interpretation a masterly example was of a ¹7° http://www.chronicle.com/article/Whats-Wrong-With-Literary/238480 ¹7¹ https://thepointmag.com/2015/criticism/when-nothing-is-cool SS0033943 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 221 psychological deeper meaning cannibals full of compelling thriller, beyond simply racism, the protagonist's impactful emotionally and engrossing terrifying and no moments, journey through a world of and serial killers. To a left-wing could characters, culture be intended art or entertainment Little no purpose Jonathan really Warcraft even if its creator seems designed that they hated video other than fun. Imagine Imagine with Do didn't intend ed Stormrage symbolizes it to be so, And if a piece of critic are clearly designed 2 and Pong for hidden their friends, To a leftist, v it cr t haveNO --- Comment [A553]: Vœ makes hen N ne the enemy,for not %drg diversity for Comment [A555]; haver : ve T enilt ec anrhing speMc ahcutArutacr whats e cc^e " IU USr"O'UOfhUfOF Di1503 O' ke ves a a w h heemp"rcrr t"e R,ccick essa) above and her dour male assistant political of people who log into World to have fun with comment [A552]: kta ln6888g6' comment [A554]: See games then, many of which the patriarchy. --- - ell then, that the status IIuo. . To a culture the fury of Amta Sarkeesian so primarily about sexism, not to be. trying as it dawns on them that the millions that a movie message'r E as they scour games like Team Fortress every day are doing well Illidan shock, or amuse. It must say something even when it's deliberately wonder McIntosh, messages. to entertain, it's unacceptable however, and those who enjoy it must be just fine with is political, everything like this author, or transphobia, homophobia, means its creator critic of and not to consider where everything is political how and is fun, garners were a nightmare. nothing Another problem that it was naturally networks: for the feminists resistant to political garners were socializing years before Facebook identifying someone another player correctness. and chatting and Twitter games tended to be anonymous. and left-wingers trying Online to attack gaming video on games like games were the original World of Warcraft came into their own. And, crucially, Like 4chan and Reddit, was via their pseudonym the furthest -- and there's down when the only lead you have is a username called culture social and Runescape communication most people was would in these come to not much you can do to track " Comment [A556]; -Ms ce la ·m±o IYIeking SS0033944 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 222 OK, even Ice¤ely mixed Anonymity, "trash talk" amongst Keem.star, seem to polite moderated the competitive with a popular society. YouTuber, "People nature of many online games, led to a culture of it's right. I'm not saying it's right, normal. how alien and shocking explained I've received gamer culture must many death threats. going to be raped. People have said they were going to do sexual things I was playing gaming. ban that username. prehably have given me death threats, me while you know games would garners. I' I've been told that I'm be somewhat enline these games, because it's part of gaming but any real gamer has experienced From the outside this is normal stuff. culture. I'm not saying Now, this, and they know you' in, this must sound crazy. But if looking This is what people say online [...] And these media outlets that don't know to each other while gaming, to it to re a gamer, they are that don't understand gaming, are up.172" eating it up. If "nonnal" you' re not familiar with gaming culture, seems very stran ge Even stranger media has held up as "gamer this is merely especially behaviour" the kind of joshing in male communities. gameI it's a friendly the whole are the examples from social media that goes on between $8 of insults, jokes and banter that the and message boards on the web. But best friends, feels threatened king of banter that ispot idea that this kind of talk is especially because they know to be taken seriously, expressed in young Comment [A557]; -"isis gocc bew se : gare comr r ty Moreo':"is carhe c t e Garea e ar and the rules of the within a c ose knit - Comment [A558]: Weryn a snows community. For example: the most common someone thinks dickwaffle," "Hey filthy fucking topics for casual jokes include you're behaving stupidly might be used a friendly rape, pedophilia, or disagrees with necrophilia, you, "go kill greeting. Some of and Nazism yourself" yourself' will If be a ¹7² Media," "Anita Sarkeesian: #GamerGate A call to Boycott Sponsors of News Youtube video posted by FaZe Keemstar, January 20, 2015. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KcMBr8yHeEw (accessed January 25, 2015) SS0033945 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 223 almost common, mistake offhand automatic, But the biggest mistake you can make-and the to take am of this media has been far too eager to make-is that the mainstream language remark. cement [A559]: Po peoplewrite it to others who not invitettV at face )aine. ' Mainstream most garners are actually To leftists, movement isn' it isn't. hellbent to reconcile and completely left-wing, their language rejecting Gamers know finds it impossible society comfortable perfect people ordinary with with diverse, codes is the same as being racist, And that made themjhe on shaming this language the reality tolerant Comment [A560]: A=ress tre compa T h t° s makesDeane fee t°e gar comTr unwecar ;P societies. sexist, or homophobic. or an increasingly enemies that progressive - comment [A561]: Nowonderso ma . women'eel s an r°cspita¤ e environment of their self- for ~-t4te-tint~vwlations - Comment [A562]: O4 to avoidrepeats lie Comment [A563]: Gamers into their personal and The Guardian, businesses correct Iweeted a joke With left-wing that failed public shaming executive outlets campaigns is the most wel had tumed known to terrorize restrictive (she was, believe example, social like BuzzFeed, hawker individuals, set of politically whose life was upended people not being able to catch All3$ about white privilege) warriors to abide by their increasingly Sacco, a communications about white social justice the aid of web-savvy they engaged in relentless Justine to make a point GamerGate, playground. and organizations norms. se try w e vs. Shamers In the years preceding media a ca. after she it or not, trying but there were dozens = cement ¼ss m cmm ne ol carer, more. Video games did not escape the rise of public games developer, editors industry from major Russ Roegner, gaming discovered publications shaming. In May 2014, a small-time his career was in jeopardy. had told him that if he didn't No fewer video than three shut up, his future in the was over. SS0033946 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 224 "Be careful wouldn't me," with mind making an example someone "Watching warned Gamasutra's Alexander. "I am a megaphone... I you." out of burn down Leigh the beginnings media," rncdia," of their career on social remarked Ben Kuch.era. "Really. Just. Stop." said the editor-in-chief of GameRanx. "You're not helping your case.' case. What had Roegner IIis offense gaming would nothing industry. said to attract such warnings? was disagreeing "There's such anodyne "#hasjustinelandedyet?" "Everyone Rami Ismail, in the game industry. views was apparently condemned This was a reference against Roegner intolerance comments and apologised, aggression.173" " aggression.' represented a different What had changed public against An industry to Justine with in these eighteen an overwhelming tide of majority 173 hti s./!archive.is/7uC)vrn "" 3 BQ b 1D !. 1. figure Sacco. to dominate its victims, opinioIn. One of the editors who threatened months? Twitter GamerGate, Roegner comments who joined to an atmosphere admitted of deal.¹™" of course. that they are alone the shamers arc usually by terrifying the that her were a "big who are made to believe InI reality, the conversation game a single word: that he "contributed era, one where public n."lies em isolating allowed there' ... there's in the video career-endangering Roegner acknowledging shaming vocal minority in the I wish people has the same opportunities A year and a half later, there are signs of a turnaround. pile-on about sexism dreams." their of 2014. One games journalist industry gender equality said Roegner. in their way of realizing Expressing another developer, no issue with is," stop saying there with others into silence. pari. of a But ' pub10sla"1rg O le 'oarnes cut ac ~R-ird-I;ekhr-quality-~+hurd+-cyarRe+a Stories on Breitbart thousands of comments underbelly of American News about the chaos and hysteries and shares. I was exposing campus politics, By the time I reached Pittsburgh, tour, and had performed the angry, and incredibly and the world was rapt with it was only February at fewer than six colleges at my events were getting poorly dressed attention. 2016. I was not a month -- yet it was already tens of into my clear that I'd tapped into SS0033954 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 232 something massive. potentially I was told to go out, double And so, after a brief and be more outrageous down, By then, word had spread to other colleges loose. Th.is upped the quality what happened at DePaul, which consensually, highlights of protesters I've at Amherst significantly. also explained around me, and I happily did & ' Los Angeles offices, than ever. And that I did. I've already faggot told you earlier on the in this book, in the face by a black man (nce the creature just a short month on a tour that was met with protest at Breitbart's that there was a dangerous where I was almost punched .. is a first!). graced the auditorium interlude earlier. after protest. known as Trigglypuff, who These were just two of the The fury bathed in the tears of mp÷s and rage was building all ' .' ' T: ', :1!' enemies -- Comment [A571]: tears" ters on page12 o use tat"e in . . lapse into third person these days). Now, I find it difficult that I was confronted all boil down with to one very simple common now one of Donald No, I'm Tnimp's columnists blend like George bactard ¹77 Peter Thiel, Will speaking on their and compared of Breitbart, That's becoming who I like to call "one of the sane flummoxed stopping Ghostbusers the campus even mild-mannered campuses.177 campuses." safe spaces. And there was nothing I had the backing a gay right-winger. single-handedly they had been on a roll, from And those theories gays" is advisers. because I almost who told rape jokes into their cherished resources, for the fact of my existence: foremost the years before my arrival, some theories. fact: I'm just incredible. these days. Indeed, incredible how anyone could hate me. But such was the anger at every event, that I came up with I'm not just incredible increasingly to understand censors. In conservative Yet here I was, a magnificent " actresses to men, ., freely romping they could do to stop me. I had endless the most fearless news organization in America, and I http://claremontindependent.corn/george-will-uninvited-from-scripps-college/ SS0033955 e . INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 233 was riding create -- a new movement a wave I helped of young, politically dissident troublemakers. Just as I was attracting fanatical shouts and shrieks of my protesters MILO!" USA!" .USA!" and "USA! started the tradition "I'm getting of carrying the welcome As my college political from dissidents I that summer, summer clear that t he You Typical reassert control. Trump's was a pro-Daddy "Finally," I thought presidential crybabies with campaign, every passing all sense it. This when all it took to in chalk on a campus went so far as to call the police due 178 . Other students went further with their triggering ' 179 . If George Will were to arrive on a campus on campus a fuek v. as coming of the power-mad, Their primary and other libertarians, around us -- we could slogan scrawled college Stop The Dangerous behavior my fans even and more mischievous have been too busy protesting kra of gwmg Can't of Donald walls'I would bolder was crumbling of Michigan, mock leftists At UC Santa Barbara, it was clear that conservatives, correctness slogans on campus even constructing The deserve." generate some campus hysterics to pro-Trump my eager audiences. on campus were becoming At the University fanbase. were loud, yes, but not as loud as the chants of "MILO! tour progressed, was, after all, the glorious a devoted me into the lecture hall on a golden throne. day. The old order of political sidewalk. I was also attracting hatred, a dozen other outrages pranks, to notice. . -- Comment [A572]: ans s9 It was .. to an end Comment [A573] .Lliiclear ru Fe Faggot leftists hope was university on campus made desperate administrations, which attempts to were often either full ¹78 https://www.truthrevolt.org/news/u-michigan-students-call-police-over-trump-2016-stop-islam-chalkmarkings-0 ¹79 http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2016/sep/09/wsu-students-plan-to-raise-a-controversial-trump-w/ SS0033956 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 234 to bursting matter with leftists how dirty, failed administrators Republicans to invite temerity to provide After a certificate of insurance heavy coverage to an appeals process, suspension on the College and slimier. minute. after negative Again, they had really been "trying Other universities concerns," over "security take place. The University slapping student organizers defiance won't ' all in a grovelling and allowing me to return. before hitting along" last. I'm coming them with in the conservative would a $7,000 slippery media a $6,500 security decided lifting administrators lulled the to stop me my student fee at the last The University of Miami and that cancelled my event was scheduled to copy the University it. We will the event. fee a few days before for them, and they know --I Comment [A575]: Cooc by submitting not face any expense for security, methods. show and some stern lawyering, arose mere days before unwisely as ja terrific as well security --- comment IAav4]: Unvk;ar from the start,~ administrators to help them host a successful mysteriously had event on campus. turnabout, of Alabama, Republicans the Republicans the administration At the University of Maryland with with engaged tried similarly which to compromise media used by frightened coverage said that the College university the excuse was w'spect steam, the tactics hosts into a false sense of security I left, however, for having hired for my initial and the conservative eventually Republicans no issued their ban just one hour after a meeting Rwviltds, who refused As my tour has gathered have gotten slimier Ariana After ban by the university 1' for the security in Breitbart UC Irvine pull any trick, for the ban was that the College administrators president that they'd our event to proceed. a one-year Their justification by An ara Rowhunk of force allowed initially me back vvith CoHege Republican of controversy on campus. were slapped with given that the college IA,Itbough, or so terrified to stop me appearing At UC Irvine, the College themselves, to of Alabama, my event. Their hold an event at the SS0033957 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 235 of Maryland, University are not allowed come hell or high water, because they are a public institution and 'they Comment [A576]; WMy? By rarG to do that to their þtudents. Comment [A577]; cut9 Despite I could the road bumps, The groundswell of attention that the Rutgers move my lectures to bigger in just 15 minutes and another simply seduced by the controversy fed up with political I wasn't American college Imagine, were turned and mystery of a revolution campuses. Rolls And we' organizers filled University me and my lectures, led by disenfranchised to to capacity young or was I folks who had been and social justice? warnings, and it's going to take back re going to have fun doing a tour bus. You know, -- a beautiful, it. the good thing is, you don't like the ones rock stars and rappers have. sleek steel beast, coated in black. -- it's a giant picture beside giant bold text that reads "DANGEROUS have to imagine Go on. Take a look. I got my own tour bus. I decided Only, the picture of my face, staring directly on at you, TOUR." FAGGOT it, because it's real. You can see a Treat yourself. By the time the second leg of my tour rolled So naturally, to my tour forced Comment [A578]; Orm mer: hesnac 1 hostsbraveenough:c °vite and ave voJ In if you would, of it in the insert. to make a difference. away at the door. Were these students surrounding safe spaces, trigger the side isn't of a singer or a supermodel picture brought sure then, but I am now. This is a movement, the image in your mind Well, incident starting The 400 seat venue at Bucknell 50 students correctness, The Fagbus Hold venues. seeing the beginning actually tell that we were already around to call it in September "Anita," 2016, I was a superstar. on the grounds that the bus SS0033958 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 236 would be more famous certainly anyone remember I was hot enough dates. It turns out I was wrong, Driven college but loveable our way through college Louisiana's and the Carolinas Alabama, the invitations crybabies, conservatives coastline a personal by Marriotts Courtyard Ma and We had the creative, prepared After into Florida, Anita the Fagbus was soon to my early successes in triggering in. We would start in Texas, wind and then drive up through a trail of furious college I had a full camera crew with trainer, booked handle. Rich, had come pouring it properly. wardrobe. like Mike campuses. down manage my ever-accumulating in history, my face and name on it helps Georgia, lefties and jubilant in our wake. two speechwriters, us the finest make it easier for me to pick up bus driver to the east coast, leaving This time, we were doing director, would a tour bus with having by our grumpy that nothing be spotted on dozens upon dozens of college America's Does her last name? I once thought tremendously. Sakka ...Sanka Sanka ... Say, who is that other Anita? than Anita and some guy I kept around to carry my bags and We had a disciplined and organized tour manager who in all the land. We had some of the finest memesters "@Sadieisonfire," who prefers and devilishly resourceful, me, a creative to be known handsome Allum only by his Twitter Boldlari. We were for anything. At first, protests the south, which aviator-clad of' of people biker were surprisingly is pure MIL O country. or a cowboy-hat that Democrats bus to get his autograph. call bigots disappointing. Many wearing Then again, we were travelling was the time in Texas we were stopped pickup truck and homophobes driver 1' for autographs. were stopping across by a burly, Exactly the sort by the Dangerous Faggot's -- comment [A579]; Aca a seate a a enresee t-a: co ¬: tst voura res spen r reec SS0033959 are INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 237 This leg of the tour contained Houston, Texas, a military appeared on stage in full drag as "Ivana anything more subversive think? veteran magical and submitted yellow liquid in her home country„caBed and the internet a budding infiltrating an anti-Milo faculty members and devotion awfully "MILO dressed in drag? .What What is the left to live on-stage. wasn't actually on the OK, I admit it -- the (OK, urine, but it was, if anything, girl called and feminists Sarah Torrent, who Qed a Muslim to meet her outside meme Pepe the Frog over racism Conservative group on campus "for an marriage ass-kicking" if -- where the school banned references James O'Keefe. stole the show, At into tbc west. bcr persecutors and monitoring members concerns student ahead of my visit, their attempts to block to the deceased gorilla (no, really, Caleb Ecarma mapping my visit. comment ÏA580 "confirm they did), we spent months out their connections to I was amazed by the passion that my tour was inspiring. As Anita Western an Arab South Carolina discovered (Is there By the end of the tour I'd gone all-out "hazing" recording on leftists on bringing In Clemson, Harambe a speech on the alt-right. I Rouge, diet.) of South Florida, they still insisted A few stops later, in Baton about the alt-right to a college count. At the first new stop, in and even I must admit it, some of the audience Potnetimes, the University to deliver to think?). in the video I'm_drinking worse for my low-carb Wall" is the right myself beyond me his dog-tags. than me talking What, for that matter, theatrics, gifted moments Virginia the Fagbus headed up the east coast, we began to encounter University, keen on political SUCKS." masked violence) "anti-fascists" appeared in ski-masks Given that the statement and I de it very well) I decided (they call themselves was, frankly, carrying more protesters. that, yet they seem placards. One of these said true (I de cuck, thankxyou that I must possess the placard, and a helpful At vely much, fan was able to SS0033960 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 238 obtain it for me during campus a particularly During crew and I thought operation, which on between stop at Michigan we made all the more exciting -- the placards we were on their level of intelligence designed going protesters, State University, be good fun to don ski masks and join our tactic worked Thankfully, winter ' RACEISM," .," .' ', '. said ene.) Would .. ... " ("FUCK placards. bitter it would grapple and attendees, of' I made good use of it soon after. in the hallway. security was a daring the rather cramped -- even though, frankly, the protesters by deliberately anyone notice? were so badly members Would spelled of my ourselves. misspelling It our our cover be blown? that they must have assumed our placards were far more well than theirs. As I write, there are more adventures port of call in the west coast, in UCLA. Berkeley, Molotov Cocktail Will Despite the hellraising, method to our madness. who funnel tolerance, Will we' the bus? I guess we'll Warriors funding openness in the months the very center of progressive we survive? Happy planned one of the lefties lunacy. We' We'll be in Seattle, in finally work up the courage to my campus tour is about more than just causing into crackpot Gender next find out. For too long, the American to opposing ahead. The fagbus's campus has been the preserve Studies courses and radicalize ideas, and ultimately a ruckus. students There' There's of leftists, against political they' against reason itself. For too long, they've gone unchallenged. SS0033961 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 239 So how do we fight system where Karl we fight Marx's Christina Hoff How did we fight The Communist back against an American and emotional friend back) support Sommers system that provides of intelligent and stuffy than an online don't typically videc politicians My brand of conservatism conservatism" of which callege is marked the American a new and growing coalition My appearances went on. My managers plan Milo college My Dangerous college administrators significant at schools campus. unthreatening how to have fun, and so do my I think conservative, puts me to sleep. faster brilliant, campus absent from I' I've is so familiar. and as a result the tired 'suit injected & tie a humor, we' along my tour we've developed across the country with began to garner more attention calls and emails from was constantly at the tour students who were looking overflowing around to with messages from the country. Tour has made great strides in the battle that is being waged on the Despite who want nothing victories by three things the message that I was bringing Faggot warm conservatives. were inundated with do lecture politics, events of their own. My inbox students who resonated American of young my lovely, of an American like Ted Cruz, who, while and sex appeal into right-wing mischief, is that I know have fun. When I think of a Shaun King books, How onto their campuses? A big part of why I've been so successful fans. Conservatives coloring to students who can't handle stepping educational textbook' is the most assigned textbookl8°? Manifesto educational puppies back against an American the setbacks and punishments more than to halt our progress, along the way. After my visit to Rutgers, laid out by regressive we have earned several university president Robert Bachi ¹ª° http://www.marketwatch.com/story/communist-manifesto-among-top-three-books-assigned-in-college2016-01-27 SS0033962 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 240 released a academic statement¹81 ' statement' academic Our University expression policy guaranteed same freedoms institutional freedom on speech is clear. All members by the First Amendment. discipline of expression in the exercise is fundamental of every opinion of the president sentiments. by the pro-Trump I knew immediately there was a significant Although to free speech and In addition, and our The event was so well-attended they also enjoy at Emory from and rallied with not community, or That freedom was no longer that they felt made it to Emory, over my impending efforts were largely the hall around the venue, listening to get a chance to peek in. At the end of my typical of the a safe space for them. When I finally concerned outside chalk to express pro- told reporters signs and chants, their protest students out onto a center quad, and encouraged I will of our academic sidewalks University students that students filled enjoy the academic members...While students protested and that the campus of anxiety citizens, of free nation." that I had to make a trip to Atlanta. amount as private defend their right to speak freely. Georgia, snowflakes enjoy the rights and shall be free from by every member I will our society, they spent time preparing event and hoping expressed studnets, are at the core of what we do. members, citizen after students took to the campus The special rights in their roles as faculty in Atlanta, University Faculty of these rights. to our campus, to our University, At Emory threatened commitment of our community as any private when functioning of speakers who we invite Trump the institution's and our First Amendment of speech and expression defend the content office he reaffirmed freedom: "Both freedom in which lecture, them all to express themselves arrival. ignored. to the I led the Emory on the sidewalk. ¹ª¹ http://president.rutgers.edu/public-remarks/speeches-and-writings/rutgers-president-free-speech-andacademic-freedom SS0033963 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 241 Students surrounded Faggot" "Dangerous me as I started things in the middle passed it around to the students "Build Wall." the James W. Wagner of the quad. After in attendance. It was a glorious This wasn't Students at Emory. wrote from everything to the sidewalk in big letters "EMORY and wrote I took the bucket university after my visit, Shortly took a piece of chalk himself and wrote I finished, of' of what the Am.erican example our only victory down my own message, off. I took a piece of chalk right STANDS Emory of chalk and Milo" "Fuck to should be! president University next to where I had laid FOR FREE EXPRESSION." In turns out that Wagner attended Emory that he released, he spoke about the importance the role that it played think," and prepare challenged [a] great, friendly, Wagner challenging the discussions said, noting him for his career as an attorney. more on my viewpoints. their arguments, it's absolutely where required, they' in my opinion, by none other than the president without helped important In a statement on college gradually ideological even realizing that really campuses and taught you to to both hone his political morphed to understand the opposing you' you've It's formative. what started off as a light-hearted into a symbol That' That's side and And level." of' of the university. victory. opinions me to law school where I was and to form your own opinions. a few pieces of chalk, endorsed a major discussion at the university leftists victories on campus from, to trigger ended up winning diversity "I took that with It's really re coming So there you have it. With achieve of viewpoint studies. in his own education: "It was always critically for his undergraduate of political free speech that was We started off having the beauty prank fun, and we of being a happy warrior -- you been fighting. SS0033964 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 242 All Roads Lead to Chicago At a high school in Des Moines, unemployed protected man addressed from "I don't protected from disagree with, "You a room full of students points competing Iowa in September points to challenge soon-to-be- the idea that they ought to be of view. agree that you, when you become different 2015, an ageing, view," of students at colleges, he said. "Anybody you should have an argument can't come because I'm too sensitive with have to be coddled and who comes to speak to you and you 'em. But you shouldn't to hear what you have to say." silence them by saying, That's not the way we learn either. The man in question was Barack It says a lot that even Obama, than many moderate he's not alone. ¾ii 81e moderate liberal Democrats, article titled And Our college "When Country," Whites released a problem now joining Kristof, Just Don't Û on America's Get It," a rare admission of identity college in their critique Shuievllz, and J011athan Haidt and, more recently that progressive of coddled intolerance But students to rlatne a few who once published "Trump politics campuses. conservatives a New York Times columnist States. Embarasses .. -- commen t [A581]: n an Himself had gone too far on campuses. e progressives Muslims there's ones. "Jo118than Chait, In May 2016, Nicholas of the United well to the left and far more supportive thinks of the voices then still president Obama, believe in. diversity, and we want women, at the table — er, so long as they aren't blacks, I.atinos, gays and conservatives, SS0033965 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 243 Urltvet stttes are the btxfrock universities disregatxf as long as they think Although is ideological and reliigious. but. the one ktM, of dtvct sttv that values We' re fine with people who don't look like us, like us.: he moderated went on to conclude his opening by saying that it might be a "little Knstof' Cf'set cr f ts yo- maseclea its s ra^ you^hinkprogressweare say ag harsh" Kristof that: I'Universitjies not just from of progresstve should be a hubbub of tItc full range of political V to Z, So maybe we progressivcs side and more broadly incorporate penspectivcs could take a brief bred< from values that vvc supposal ly cherish from A to Z, attacking — like diversity the other — in our - Comment [A583]: Needscitation domin)Ons If Nicholas "babies" Missouri their demands) we truly Kristof and Donald and criticized the college's agree that there's have a broad consensus. Putting pressure Trump a problem "weak, with The question on colleges to follow (who called student protesters ineffective out-of-control leadership" lefties at the University for caving on college of in to campuses, then is, what next? the University Chicago" of Chicago's lead would be a good start. The college warnings told its 2016 intake of students point-blank or safe spaces at their educational "Fostering a free exchange campus that welcomes letter to freshmen. community. people "Diversity The members backgrounds," of opinion a related University is a fundamental must have the freedom -- priority of' wrote the Dean of Students, and background of our community any trigger establishment. of ideas reinforces of all not to expect Jay Ellison, strength a building in a of our to espouse and explore a of' ideas." wide range of SS0033966 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 244 If college example. administrators When colleges the more superficial Until I will want to stop me, then all they need to do is follow really start to take intellectual forms of diversity, then there will to fight great taboo will During snowflakes. my college professors who want to follow no longer, now is the perfect pushbacks and reprisals rather than shunned. cGvirortmcQt stiflirtg the example of an Orwellian students and political some violating "Bias Task are pampered, to cling on to power should movement. it" sure, but in the long run it'll Force." sheltered ready to IA5841",Mors detailsbootthe -g comment Lpsbpls ybti metshd wsrs impressedtiy them;'.. Dissident of Chicago time for them to start a resistance in the beginning, suffer in silence There will be pay off. The defenders for very long. Dissident of faculty given you an army -- use it! allies are starting to multiply. defeat to conservatives gone too far Where that NKrouQds of the University There is no better time than the present to achieve conceding intellectual and beyond, uport thousatMis of students up Artd dov1rtr thc courttry the status quo are too few and unpopular Potential as they take be a need for me. of' life -- one of constant tour, I learned that not all millennial fight back AgAMst thc Mtcllcctually I' I've no longer debate, not a trip to the office Arc thousands as seriously diversity at a campus near you. In America ideas are welcomed lead to spirited 71M' of' of campus for my vision where dangerous simulation, members, Faggot then, look for the Dangerous continue and political their 182 . A new coalition Everywhere and admitting is waiting a revolution we look, on college there are moderate that the insanity of political campuses. liberals correctness has to be built. ¹8² http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/20/opinion/sunday/the-end-of-identity-liberalism.html https://theamericanscholar.org/low-definition-in-higher-education/#.WGgP3VWLTIV http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid http://www.salon.com/2015/10/28/i_wanted_to_be_a_supporter_of_survivors_on_campus_and_a_good_t eacher_i_didnt_realize_just_how_impossible_this_would_be/ http://heatst.com/culture-wars/elite-college-professor-calls-academia-a-mad-house-and-safe-spaces-anexistential-error/ https://www.washingtonian.com/2016/09/15/jamie-raskin-american-university-political-correctness/ SS0033967 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 245 I' at what I've Look shenanigans, moderate faculty liberals accomplished. already committees backing down fee- over security speech,183 letters in defense of free speech, 183,and a host of penning who are now prepared Universities I' to defend free speech again just as long as it means I'll go away. I' I've also become But that's just a bonus! most important in American achieving know brewing re just getting rh" My tour is one campuses. effected absolutely colossal of conservatives -- because I don't Administrators often even more attention- because they force me to be. Would opinions were treated just as fairly there be a market as everyone intellectual else" else's? as everyone I show up. That tells you all you need to know campuses. should have learned and a cancer on your school's Because on college and back down I' I've won when no one comes to my shows any more. In the meantime, about the state of free thought change started. another way to do what I wanted, and libertarian 2016.184 ol'2016.' speaker of campus more than two generations there are lines out the door everywhere academics? on college we' later, we've dollars You could say I'm only theatrical for MIL O if conservative knows, a revolution time they try to ban me, I get more powerful and run away. I find sheepishly You' You'll we' -- the most disinvited notorious Two million education, before us. And Every seeking. There's component. higher libertarians ever-more the lesson by now. If you think life, how about you start hiring if you leave it just to the students, you' I'm crass and boorish more conservative re going to end up with people like me. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/12022041/How-political-correctness-rulesin-Americas-student-safe-spaces.html ¹83 http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/03/12/university-of-minnesota-faculty-embraces-free-speechfollowing-milo-visit/ ¹84 http://www.forbes.com/sites/maureensullivan/2016/12/30/provocateur-milo-yiannopoulos-was-thespeaker-most-likely-to-be-disinvited-to-colleges-in-2016/ SS0033968 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 246 -j3KPIILOG1.J BEPILOGUE _______ HOW TO BE A DANGEROUS (EVEN dm a ; am o me w IF YOU'RE — t s NOT a m f&A' — — i em-in-interdews-when4-ehow-my4ingemai howeered il,in 1 11 ( I ~I.i i 1 Till, 11I l,ll, n†ehincx1[saff di n I nt iii( in . 1(.ii chal nanov r.o neo ro 3 I no . ct.: ?ntle hÎtan. ii a 11. 1.- " m n ± — 8« "'".' «',.',.,"lB''.'R](;5-4s. t >h I ef4he --- comment usssD l hisis a azy v'ay'to Legiri a manifesto,The u ooseevokes ul a cored response. . his chapte has nothing ...' tOhaV c,lng '1'lint' ii i.ll, nr' naa' he c22nÎincx t n GAY) ser49e÷etasent-mindedly-ou +n o012+ham +o ranant the nnco+4t 1. I 1 ".. nil . Ti; Tl t. fooir in oll th a o comna sene T n cxthouannño .TIIn t L-..-' n ! nude nÊ.Âollare ' ~. tn. 1(( .,:I ~(. li( (nn(, .t '7 1' ! - ''I 1'"" ' tt> t'! .1»' ' t}II.. .' !nn ik .T 1(. (Iit 1!. nn .ITI(i >t>tc>l innlnin( n thn nnee n(n. nnl I 1 — ! ! ~. o '7 it: t.M t: i >~ t it> Tn tinn ' " 'nl oR -i R:t.t ",} ' TI noinnotue un 3" > ~ 1 T and cere the T - t Inay41eart de c h E2m:1a -,, >t tt-,->it'i f I ~ .-.I ~:of heare I wanue the-shmsedongue-and-indulge ht tho Dnman A nono 4--ad +-t it»t wtl - t »oc tits t i>*»"- i" tlt -,: tt'> 4XT I:.::+«.-' myself ~t+'-RÃt'Se}jin-edk '" ". on orms in x- o+oru t. retemeg4e4he4ami-and4ns-skave !. d, befemimmediatel dee1a c' " is o o "'-'. '. ' pass the baton on so 3 ean o haek4a and shampagne jlf}}31'>C:.'in I.: know ,l;""l that win never4appen my lifetime o4 am÷esigned to4he4ight4 we wage-war-asemg-as4here-are-dykes-in-gender-studies-departmentatelling-liesebeut-innecent -(}}V+jY'kC>".s-(R-~tt>tie".--'t4I -'6'8 young boys as long asR1aek44ves t)R Matter '>it r se It i ists are sitse!÷ing peoplefor their skin cok+r and as-leng-asRatney-4as4e-withhaid-musie-v-ideaseeeanse4er-managereare-worned41-ley-arevet .X'.Kk8(38-48(,"BRSB-48f SS0033969 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 247 feminist enough pigchit T New York I've fight se long as free expreceien bloggers always greater. something feminists. I will and cocial justice But for so long as A1nerica was giggling pushing could because the Associated him over 270 electoral imagine reporters was giggling to By ,y as though the Van.pire Slayer. together, as my life was meant for Hopefully it's the we have struck the first blew 1 20 1G. and I was in New York, votes and giving to die an ignominious him the presidency. despair and outrage away from in what I uncontrollably. giggling Press had just called Pennsylvania the results just a few hallways coveting erdainment Because the looks of bewilderment, was not doomed for Donald I was giggling I the . -----1Comment [A586]: 3rit start here— needs3 better opening, [ mer Trump, because I on the faces of mainstream me. I was giggling death at the hands of open border-obsessed because the west globalists. I because we had won. The earthquake coming. on November thick needs me, I am yourc At least for new, I am rejcieing. It was 140am are at risk frem activicts. felt an acute sense of percenal It's why I always related and creativity heralded It was the culmination and the mainstream right, by the election of nearly thirty about how we should how we need to make up for a history of racism, of Donald J. Trump years of hectoring had been a long time from both the mainstream shut up if we knew what's sexism, and every "phobia" left good for us, about under the sun, SS0033970 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 248 about how entertaining this dangerous thought or making that dangerous joke would be the end of' of our careers. it turns out that the real danger lies in not daring Well, didn't dare to be dangerous in 2012, and they lost. Donald to be dangerous. The Republicans dared to be dangerous Trump in 2016, and he won. I dare to be dangerous has marked My ascendancy blow to the leftist stake through vigilante the overturning the heart of the bureaucratic, Leftists of course think celebrities justification, but they are also pessimistic that racism approximate European correct 2016 was The Worst their favorite believe and their friends globalist years of politically the Congo, education, and that Brexit a sensible mortality, including liberal illiteracy, ~~'ill v Hue-herald reminds ±; T Ps generation y !r2 and global girls, and democracy sexual assault and other crimes millennial And then Donald in the United Trump States. defeats, they have some Some of tThese are the people, after all, who ! arubh;:r reminds inequality are at all-time in the west also continue, is the most tolerant World . -- comeseN»pnsm]: rut aii ie. b b dnenowd. 1fenv., n.,re;tav¬c amri T 1 n ion n¬ 1 f . 'f - ' ensnirfod + n a.svina 'C. n d u is 7 vt ram-i;ma imi en! C.>' ¬tha me,n i a + 1 or +ma r .. u ser,su u . ' , a t Tn!co ,. f l¬nw +1no,.+vnatn..1..1a T1 nnow inow e-amov.sinc+vnatnd ..1i co +. T m o f en thic ein;+ f, ** ic 'mow ta rma '-'"* TJr,+T'un "" "'"" + offl o1 i no ?od id D re inmwlso fnnow winat f, n o o.>vno++rs u>ver . . ff-onÃnva ..-×r-.aimet a,n HTo +nlav..-×+., 3,me f n .. infa m 1 ono n ory-xiv¬c+tlna+ ovs, f-ond [[7a ri 't imal n f Webelieve-thatthe-rightness-efour-actions-shoukispeak -shok'/H-.%g& -@e-/?e/?esf'e -s/fa/-4/?8+vgh/?fess-Hf or-itself-¥eu-believe-in bullying-even-as-you-elaim-to-leve-the-oppressedf ~;--eve??-as-pe@-e/a???'?-/o-/ore-the- o/f/??fessefaobbullying" on-national-anti4milying 1.k 1 .'us amortant trial ond mont roonnroofni hellincolrono ohnn+ orivonx7 r Th+o + not A T T onlorin And bnu7 o+nn tha mnot inot -day;-w41en-theasands-of .k An x7nn km a to he aditor GA4..k 11. ..- Cottl(NBNtfA590j: BLltcllclrtt 3(oobo'tJecI( Doreeyof TwittercIt Breitt3a(t> n o el 4 m 114nn on tha ctond SS0033975 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 253 ~~. -}-BPe —". Th Domanrotin norfu clon hon han Theo 40 o nor+n that hoA +‰ kn):o o wherhard +‰ r¬ad;a (non, onA n1A tb ot r m on oevo4in 1,an tha T--Tannatho Qanoto onor th onA Q4lanor 37o13ouan th;r T n h + o 1 .to 10 ur orrinen dar.nne. -.4n a..vmlov.+ avon n on c.ur,h¬lm of tha no mere ta help the pentical-fortunes o a hnunn4 of .notric. n+nn44 +n ha n right-than- the-seeia e&the -}}gki}:-}4&8-Xl}(-S(((-:.3 doun u o of n + thu'ra m-ud onian ustice warriers-e&the T' o L.mJ;n regressive know- left-We-really-ought-te4hank-them-vou The-big-political-battles-are-over -l-l}<-4}g-p(}4}3+'&44& to-wm on thu Trumn .+n el anc h n44o unt ommoono who onn14 nhollonna tha +n amn no in onernet Am ar;.,or.u nol4t u2 moc.+ mu nayo ant .k14c.henant on nuw2 c.ton-vn a o nu no. n o uw13 u£ 2nu enonh no nole+4-n noot Gm noo.co ond than tho Dron442novr Thou no.nlA hox a co‡-,nd tho math tho no.m no+ nn of T-Aarria Rondore onon140t r,nmont nf otnnillim -at4east for-the-momentrbut-wo-still41ave-a t he-left-is-still-in-central-of-IIollywood £ulture-war -the-media-Sil-ioan 44terature;-nuisie-comedy Valley-and-most-American-universities-We-mastn't-be-sedueedhy-the4alse-songeSpelitical power-ferwitheat-ealtural-power;-i-t-is-meaningless onuld h written knnk hoo hon th 100 Woll onnoona inct on that ank;ont ohnn+ mo +‰Po not th knt olom mkot mo oro Wo4r.-vr;.vkt Pm o modal That o uku F,r knur in ononaco‰1hr nrnoonn+o o nnhro md rroon n t n n1 km hon o‰nt me T An kno +h40 on+ ro mor o..vonot on ocyn +n 4n noon unn hadn0+ nnianod I SS0033976 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 254 Um oc__araharata_ronmato >VV] 1tz ttRC'' o m ro the ' on ] hani Ib r off ona bos a a aroo 1>.r- >I !1 have404 b " + !1 ' abnman__rg-3ana, nnto -1 "' "' cune C>icar .'Imerloone .A .-. . '! " hi ] n n the r n ! us 1 - IV accelklaL1-moon ! .. -' !-- - !, hom_non-non ll C...izI ili a · - mo u 9>i]c - H-I T]tot>r rnlrz T' 1 D chw+ mucolÛ 1 ''hc n mnob monolon ' c- " ! f ) - + '" " ! tormc. xano, c·o+n of looo+ o dno-t t.-.&;-.!..' 1-!. 1 . > !- ceioh "1 ~..'!...:. T. hoT >I o hoo . oroHleG ..":.'..'B '+ -7 1> That anoe c4no ofumma „!....,u ...," va 1 „...,,....!. Hcltze'"' ua mu n uu -t se6 tr 1'rp zlp 11 3'"' 3t3&'+3&1+.'4&+'1<&33-3-HB+I".1&littlh4.1<133&t..&&344'-(' ;3(33HFB&ll&4&-(13&F1-~4 but--alse4eea- City. n ~ 1 .1 .! ">C.~ =. >7 t., irc I- kl «x«~r >a<".c<<>tho feeling÷t > '! a gay 40use4hem T toll pehal ! ' XI onaithorLuanin-1 Tlat.>' th ? » t f> zot>!le',!v! rroff --+ C !' n e f'ar mrar o I na o1or + .. ~ tria Cl a ba nronmn nacJ' ] 1a repheate A-a ' . r - They def t + t know -t t don't lmew-their-own--eeuntry hat the ownen; a Memories1 ——,'3k",.!Pe 12hey-eavenit-stepped outsideef-New4erk —.1-4C <-4&"-C<33-'.'; za aren 1violent baekw°a'1"' hW Lit "'»- -- t- " .x..tb.a....<: in «..!3«...uzi>....Po:t..tL..t3aL,>r.. ll'y.,lit<;!"" 1+'33$ 111& 313CBi&+i!& t,'333ti33331&<31CRi err. ~t>n «th .>t'«.< hr.x t. --(;:3-' ' '' ~ . t «», 1< ~th t. t ll th< nx <."x .Bta hn>.< tb ~ i<- < 1 t." RRBP-pFeRKleney- SS0033977 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 255 The funny should he thanking isn't (Trurnp President. their lueW ) They cheuld Pecause the Arnerican that's people stare voters didn't be waking 4 or d the hiaxu Vnr1 social justice by the forces of freedom conservative It's you, buying throwing your hands up in disgust this book, Southern such a thing T4moo enttinfr warriors Onadu like David Duke isn't and bullying. Of course, But they didn't in +ko Whito and busybodies mind LTanon A r a tho are going to be beaten into political candidates at the idiots laughing and saying, or great Republican on Twitter authors and Facebook, and finally "Enough." in extracting Avenger" Hunter apologies to Justine from the victims of public shaming. Sacco, one of the first signs of leftist themselves Brother's chamber in room 101, you can expect to see the phrases that mark a broken sorry." 'I' "I'll you, mob of faceless try to do lintemet better." vigilantes, "I'm learning for educating emerging to be a better person every from is the flogging "I'm Like prisoner±s victory verbally torture in public. From Jack sight of someone spirit: Comment [A591]: 38is a benerp ace to stad t" s thapte- r essyn m tr< o' SGT Ul FCF'OT UXCU Apologize The left delights "The that someone and fun. We are going to win. And it's not thanks to a press, or killer thinkers. Never day grateful Progressives an the far Right. actually what they deserve after three decades of lying Gv@' ( Ner the next decade ferocious up ever go for comeone are too decent to ever countenance otiolvinn 4t in LTnhxunn submission is the least had thing that could have happened. thing is, Trump day." Big "Thank me.'" me." If you want to win, the first step is not to admit defeat. Never apologize. SS0033978 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 256 Be Twice As Funny As You Are Does anyone remember refresher: a colossal An out-and-out emulate idiot how the alt-right called Richard white nationalist, the wittier Spencer was offensive in his speeches, but it just wasn't forbidden convincing. matter, salutes" Spencer's little in the "Roman the entire post-election salute' alt-right. don't think people stunt, a meeting spread all across the media, to be allowed should be ostracized to examine Joseph Watson if you find yourself are disavowing defend the right of people to make jokes people who want to destroy campaigns. But they are not Spencer. gotten away with wasn' it. But he wasn't, but the damage was done. in which about whatever If Spencerwas just a few engaged Trump disavowed that they want. anything fear the ideas of people I like is the best disinfectant. where even Mike screwe4fucked the lives of 20-somethings He later because I have enough trust in ordinary view, in a position you' you, you've didn' (his quote) didn't since his election. so. I don't and reject them on their own. Sunlight Nevertheless, cleansing" about, and discuss for doing fun with forbidden and the next day Donald to make jokes magic' magic Ppepe and "meme the fun in afterwards. ethnic of the mainstream a He did his best to Nazi salutes at his meetings. giving but here's of the movement. being funny. of less than 200 people Spencer, nort do I feel a need to hide them from people to transplant they were just trolling, It was the first victory I want people to take control referencing ideas about "peaceful and claimed this book will, You see, they were having at least not as much as the people called them "Roman reading without cringingly ideas and trying The fact that he had barmy really died? Many Spencer was allowed of' of the movement, elements ideas. He was having Outrageous Cemovich and Paul up on an epic scale. I will they choose, over alt-right just trolling, and mercilessly memes still attack and 4chan trolling as he said, he would have and it showed. SS0033979 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 257 He wasn't Know he was just being outrageous. being funny, the difference. Be twice as funny as vou are outrageous. aAn Argument" "Not This one doesn't come from me, but from ene of the few OK Canadiana... Molyneux, anarchism intelligence, become and religion, put, when someone need to be upset, ruffled, of who frequently philosopher dabbles Stefan Molyneuxg in dangerous has said this so often on his YouTube topics channel like race, that it has a meme. Simply fury, Canadianthe signifying "Rracist!," just coolly or apologetic. nothing. "IAomophobe!" Facts Over You now know, threat to black i-s-no"gender a fact, and someone of sound and responds phrase with cries "heretic," —" " - Comment [A593]: 5,: v at aboutw-en yo cal ct ers arew AS you avethroughoutt e back-exce:: where "ave ce e:êd Feelings In this book, you will on college rage, full argutnent!" an areument "Not facts." or reveal of moral or any other ways that the left now spells with that now-immortal --- Comment [A592]; /m:. as you so too ',, there is no These are just outbursts If you make a point, "Seexist!" respond calls you names, have encountered for instance, that black lives-several--dozen-times-over. campuses doesn't exist. A several excellent gang violence You will men and women now know arehi gap:"'" pay gap > ou hear about is not what it is portrayed being fat isn't healthy, although quite frankly, I think examples of what I like to call eclipses police that the fabled giedly as being violence "rape di&rem You will most of you are smart enough as a culture" and that thcFC know --- Comment [A594]: /Ced dn: er t s "cT that to figure that last one out on your own. SS0033980 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 258 You should never miss an opportunity blue pilled college. Your history. The media, falsehoods. to spread these facts around, peers are currently academia, They are naturally living and pop culture offended you cannot if you're at of' in one of the most brainw asi1ed eras of our are all working when this fragile is one of the reasons why so many of the younger especially overtime worldview generation to get them to believe is faced with reality, retreats --- Comment [A595]; s·ovice ¬we sc-1edfor ..non-Mayu people which into safe spaces. However, spare their feelings. The only way to beat propaganda is to spread the truth faster than the machine spreads lies. Facts over feelings. And that brings me to my favorite rule of all ... Seek Attention People often accuse me of being an attention-seeker. Well ok, they're mostly right, You see, I may be a flamboyant flouncing, arguments, Adonis-like Valley-girl my values, craving 90 percent egotistical for attention right. They' re partly But the other attention whoring 10 per cent is important. diva faggot, also serves a noble purpose and the causes I champion right. but all my -- it draws attention as well as my impeccable to my sense of style and good looks.- think-of-~+)--ERS-as-QAI3e+s me-as--94per-centKimKardashian;-14percent-Mether 21heresa Beingd-presume-;--a-semewhat--norrnal--and-mentally--stable-individual--you-might-apt-for-a different-een1binatan--Maybe-64percent forget :±cut the attention " -+' serious-and··44per-cent-attention-seek-ingau44en4 -.IQB4.+1: seeking! .' One of the mistakes that libertarians make endlessly is that SS0033981 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 259 they assume people they' actually galvanised essays on why roads should be privatized. -- but that doesn't flawless probably I' I've read their brilliant a movement because I know on stage and reel off a list of paid talk.ing points Marilyn Monroe, of' of the hottest After I' I've have my deputy and spiciest got everyone's ago, everyone upon thousands websites eyeballs. know for the public's how to get people cream, throw is getting more or less the same channels much else. Now there are thousands competing whipped tougher shows, points. asleep. and tougher. YouTube If what you have to say is important, Half a wasn' there wasn't on TV because, well, of channels. turn up up a slideshow and then I reel off a list of talking for attention attention. I turn up on stage dressed as and ensured no_-one at the back is falling attention, paying a good show. I don't like Ben Sh::pire. of' memes of the moment... watched if no-one's how to throw slap me in the face with We live in age where the competition century mean anything I feeds, and you have to listening. We're-au-K-im-Kardasinan-nowrreaBy 4sn4-it-wonderful? Be Hot This sounds difficult, opponents. school but it's very important. We live in an age of "fat sports day where everyone on a diet, go to a tanning sunglasses acceptance" You have got to be hotter than your and the celebration gets a prize. No! Don't salon. Don't waste money of the mediocre. settle for second-best. A high Hit the gym, go McDonald" on McDonald's---waste —:-waste it on Gucci instead! Keep in mind that jfs not hard to_be hcster than many of your opponents -are-me-stl-y-are-rw+stly femini-stsarannies-white-leftist-cueles4rom-the-coastal-eit-ies-andfat-acceptanee-aetivists-It's really not hard to be hotter than them, . so you don't even have a good excuse. SS0033982 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 260 Be hot. Have thun This is one of the most important the most important probably What do leftists they sit in a circle feel, and gently whine and share their feelings overly-senous re having that they'd speaker event. Like My followers do a little the leftists, victories. if college they' they'll In public, safe spaces are any guide, get angry, yell slogans, from everything Sscrabble now, I'm throwing better on the "sense of and that politics video humor" scale, but you can debate club meet, or at a Heritage they can be dreadfully conservatives, wants to hang out with And right and each other. They 'll talk about how unsafe they rather be at a college establishment not the one with Faggot, much fun, do they' win because they know left, who wish to politicize hookers, they' conservatives never escape the feeling No-one with Well, a Dangerous they are by our side's words. look like Establishment of being my repeated pat each other on the shoulders. They don't mistrust reason behind do when they get together? about how offended Foundation requirements isn't and that's serious sometimes. everything. why they' That's why they re so at odds with the games to pop songs. squares. They want to go to the party with and a ballpit. blackjack and - Comment [A596]:'vviiat' W"at is na d the best party in town. Have fun Be Dangerous SS0033983 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 261 We live in an age where one side of the political challenge to their viewpoints, all diversity scared. Scared that their political, nurtured social and cultural over the past few years, with They have watched They have watched slowly fades into irrelevancy, despite grow tired of language for diversity and long to taste creative slowly slowly with my mild demands from the swamp Those who are frightened on a foundation of sand. it represents, despite multiply. all their genders and races, once dogma once so steely and strong, directors once more. Artists, So it's little and video ever longing wonder slip away. game designers of women to provoke grow tired and minorities, and challenge, that even I'm considered for free speech on campuses, and my wariness of modern on the today is to be the establishment. 1' of the sexism my fact-based to be objections and homophobia to that drifts Islam. of free speech, whether side, or jokes that prod at their carefully-constructed of' of something constructed' on culture, that to be left-wing and black lives matter, westward diversity, to suppress it. codes. Movie It's a scary time to be a leftist. feminism enforced and the worldview quotas, of attacks over the representation freedom wake up and realize dangerous, of' of feminism, re and swept away by a new wave of research all attempts They have seen their stranglehold of the demands constructed carefully die at the hands of Islam, as the idea of "socially innate roots of our identities, Comedians they' and cover up the atrocities. They have watched in the academy, like all debate, all out. Why? Because males, is built as the threats to their order, the dream of multiculturalism to downplay consensus, white would to be snuffed its secular religions and casual hatred for straight multiculturalism, attempts of thought spectrum it's ideas and facts that challenge social taboos, else. It's not the speech, or even the so-called "hurt are almost feelings" always that bother their frightened It' them. It's SS0033984 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 262 that nagging concern, that plagues all defenders of fact-free dogma, that fe might ,''.-- be wrong, ' comment [A598]; ns is ot acx.a y a fe — s what ya0 imaginethem •c 'eel of t"er----it nd they just can't handle that. Well, minds, no matter. You don t need to convince after all, not theirs. And your minds them. are clearly You' re responsible comment [A597]; Cr that they war :sr otmere for your own you' in a good state, because you're reading this book. So use them. Be dangerous. Read all the books that your college their library. Find the thinkers and the writers mainstream, and find out why. Get together is too afraid to stock in and the artists who have been shamed out of the with your friends and pledge to be as dangerous as possible. l½cshe call it the Dead @Ner¤ occiety! You' you' already supposed reading a book re not supposed to. Go watch re not supposed to. a movie you' re not to. Or better yet, go make a movie Or write a song you' Or design a video Discuss ideas you' you' you' to. re not supposed not supposed to. to. re not supposed Get on social media Share a meme re not supposed game Start a blog you're you' to. and tell a joke you're re not supposed not supposed to. Find some facts to. you' re not supposed to. Be dangerous. Like that hot guy on the cover. 880033985 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 263 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS If you're who ought to be in your crosshairs. news judgment wouldn't would of any journalist be where l' to blame for the whole for someone looking My editor working I am without collapse unconscious My chief of staff Colin Yiannopoulos on the straight show up within the travelling Hayden, Hunter, tour manager executes and narrow Seabass, Blake Andrew Greider. Faggot talent and will, whom this book I'm sure, eclipse I me rent boys. job in media My assistants time. My lawyer ridiculous Marc Brian things. circus fed, watered Gabe, for keeping of near-misses. plenty without Bokhari, Milo keeping and Mare make sure I Thanks Johnson the lights -- and his team do a lot of and looking and of course Jeff the wildman Thanks has perhaps the best Marlow, the most difficult -- flawlessly. when I demand Dangerous Allum here are a few people thing, and has saved me from onto a pile of Nigerian an hour or two of the advertised keeping Alex is a major journalistic Madine and never complain heavy lifting today him. My deputy, never have got off the ground, when I finally at Breitbart, Milo to the squad for fabulous -- Mike, and my long-suffering on. Will Ross -- we miss you. A few friends produce we will the best pop album Fulton Sommers, keeping of 2017. You shaped my thinking be free at a Snctm party in the hills. and Rachel Hoff gave me a leg up. Thank you to my dark angel Lexica Brown provided kept me kind. the meme tank full. Drake constant James Cook: intellectual and I am forever as always, nourishment. while me to grateful. wise counsel. Based Mom, Bell kept a smile on my face. Thanks I could have been a better friend for helping One day Scott Walter Christina to Pizza Party Ben for on tour and while writing this SS0033986 INDEX NO. 654668/2017 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/21/2017 05:07 PM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 66 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/21/2017 264 book to Alicia and to Colette and Sascha for the past three years. But I know they will forgive me eventually. My publisher mesed Heaven MitchEveryone at Simon and Earth to get this beck have done it without & Schuster cut quickly. my agent Tom Flannery, I'm who teak a chance en r 2 and couldn' grateful. , And of course I couldn't who was indulgent when able and strict when necessary. THANK THA3KS THE HATERS THE BOOK IT - STAY AT ME NOW! babe. Leslie Daddy TO ALL FOR MAKING WHO TRIED LOOK YOU MAD! NUMBER TO EVERYONE IN PARTICULAR: Jones, for making -- WITHOUT Anita YOU ONE! . TO ALL WHO SAID I'D THE HUNGRY I COULDN'T Sarkeesian! .Couldn't Couldn't me even more famous. BE NOWHERE. TIGERS MAKE IT, have done it without And Jack Dorsey, you, who did so much to get elected. Finally, of course, thanks to Steve Bannon -- for everything else. SS0033987 SS 0033987