Filed 08/04/16 Page 2 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1037 OFFICE OF THE OFX'TCE OF THE COUNTY PROSECUTOR COUNTY PROSECUTOR MONMOUTH COUNTY OF COTIhITY OF MONMOUTTT 132 I32 JERSEYVILLEAVENUE JERSEYVILLE AVENUE 07728-2374 FREEHOLD, 7 28-237 4 FR-EEHOLD, NJ Nt A1 (732)431_-7159 (732\ 43t-1rc4 MARC MARC C_ C. LEMIEUX LEMIEUX ASSISTANT PROSECUTOR FIRST FIRST ASS¡STANT PROSBCUTOR LORI LORT LINSKEY LINSKEY DEPUTY ASSISTANT PROSECUTOR ÞEPUTY FIRST F¡RST ASSISTANT PROSECUTOR MICHAEL MICHAEL J.J. WOJCIECHOWSKI V/OJCIECHOWSKI CHRISTOPHER]. GRAMICCIONI CHRISTOPHER J, GRAMICCIONI ACTING ACTING MONMOUTH MONMOU'TH COUNTY COT'NTY PROSECUTOR PROSECUTOR FIRST ASSISTANT DEPUTY Á.SSISTANT PROSECUTOR DEPUTY FIR.Sî PROSECUTOR MICHAEL PASTERCHICK JR MICHAËL PASTERCHICK JR. CHIEF OF DETECTIVES DETECTiVES CHIEF or 2016 March March 10, 10,2016 HAND HAND DELIVERED DELIYERED Thomas J. Thomas J. Mallon, Mallon, Esq. Esq. Mallon & Mallon & Tranger Tranger 86 86 Court Court Street Street Freehold, Freehold, New New Jersey Jersey 0772 07728 ' Re: 5-00177 Re: MCPO MCPO Investigation Investigation No.2 No.: HMI HMl5-00177 Your Timothy Harden Your client: client: The Harden The Estate Estate of of Timothy CIVIL CryIL DISCOVERY DISCOVERY Dear Dear Mr. Mr. Mallon: Mallon: As an enclosed is As you requested, requested, enclosed please find fìle. Also Also enclosed is an enclosed please find materials materials from from this this Office’s Office's file. the to invoice the of Please make Monmouth this cost representing payment reproducing discovery. invoice representing the cost of reproducing this discovery. Please make payment to the Monmouth County letterhead. County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office on the the letterhead. Offioe and mail to to the the attention attention of of Administration Administration at at the the address address on and mail You certain areas of this redactions concern You will will see redacted. These These redactions concem see that that certain this report report may have have been been redacted. areas of such items similar information. social numbers and driver's license as numbers, items such as social security The redactions redactions security numbers, driver's license numbers and similar informatíon. The have private information have been been made private. Unredacted be maintained maintained by made to information private. Unredacted versions versions will will be by this this to keep keep private Office. Office. Very Very truly truly yours, CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPTMR J. J. GRAMICCIONI GRAMICCIONI ACTING ACTING MONMOUTH MONMOUTH COUNTY COIJNTY PROSECUTOR PROSECUTOR By: J. Decker Decker By: CllI'lSl0]1l‘ -r J. Special Deputy Attorney General General Special Deputy Attorney Assistant Acting Acting Assístant Prosecutor Prosecutor Director, Major Crimes Crimes Bureau Bureau Director, Major CJD/dc CJD/dc Enclosures Enclosures http://www.prosecutor.co.monmouth.nj.us http://www.prosecutor. co.monmouth.nj.us Prosecutor's Prosecüto/s File File 0001 0001 Filed 08/04/16 Page 3 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1038 INVESTIGATION HM15.OOI77 NO. HMIS-00177 INVESTIGATION NO. CIVIL CIVIL DISCOVERY DISCOVERY (Thomas (Thomas J. Esquire) J. Mallon, Mallon, Esquire) 1. 1. 2016, 1 page MCPO Jr., January 15,2A16,1 January 15, BozzaJr., Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. 2. ) Bozza Jr., MCPO 2A15,11 page 10, 2015, December 10, Jr., December DanielBozza MCPO Supplemental Report, Det. Det. Daniel Supplemental Report, 3. 3, 4. 4. MCPO 23, 2015, 201 5, 11 page Jr., October October 23, Bozza Jr., Report, Det. Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, (Christine (Christine Brown Brown Statement) Statement) MCPO 2015, 1 page Jr., October page 23,2015,1 October 23, Daniel Bozza BozzaJr., Report, Det. Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, 5. October 21, MCPO 2015, 1 page 21,2015,1 Det. Brian Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot,, October MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. 6. 6. Bozza Jr., October MCPO 2015, 1 page 9,2015,1 October 9, DanielBozzaJr., MCPO Supplemental Report, Det. Det. Daniel Supplemeutal Report, 7. 7. MCPO Jr., October 23, 2015, 2015, 1I page October 23, Bozzalr., Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. (Tina (Tina Pinelli Pinelli Statement) Statement) MCPO 23, 2015, 207 5, 1I page Supplemental September 23, Bozza Jr., Jr., September Report, Det. DeL Daniel Daniel Bozza MCPO Supplemental Report, (Mary (Mary Green/Masks) Green/Masks) Bozza Jr., September 2015, 1 page MCPO 23,2075,I September 23, DanielBozzaJr., MCPO Supplemental Report, Det. Det. Daniel Supplemental Report, (Jeremy (Jeremy Hoffman Hoffman Statement) Statement) Bozza Jr., September 2015, 1 page MCPO 23,2015,1 September 23, Det. Daniel DanielBozzaJr,, MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. 8. 8. 9. 9. 10. 10. 11. 11. 12. 12. 13. 13. 14. 14, 15. 15. 16. 16. 17. 17. (Christy (Christy Meyer Meyer Statement) Statement) (Ryan (Ryan Edgar Edgar Statement) Statement) Bozza Jr., 2015, 1 page MCPO 23,2015,1 September 23, Jr., September Report, Det. Det. Daniel Daniel&ozza MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, (Benjamin (Benjamin Bleefeld Statement) Bleefeld Statement) Bozza Jr., 2015, 1 page MCPO Supplemental 23,2015,1 DanielBozza Jr., September September 23, Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Report, Report, Det. ohnstone Statement) (Michael Statement) (Michael JJohnstone MCPO 23, 2015, 2Al 5, 1I page September 23, Bozza Jr., Jr., September Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. (Joseph (Joseph Zimmerman Statement) Zimmerman Statement) MCPO 201 5, 1I page 23, 2015, Daniel Bozza Bozza Jr., Jr., September Septembet 23, Report, Det. Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, (Joseph (Joseph Wocio Statement) Wocio Statement) Bozza Jr., September 2015, 1 page MCPO 21,2015,I Supplemental September 21, DanielBozzaJr., Report, Det. Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Report, Bozza Jr., September 2015, 1 page MCPO 21,'2015,1 September 2T,‘ DanielBozzalr., MCPO Supplemental Report, Det. Det. Daniel Supplemental Report, Emilius (Casey (Casey Emilius Statement) Statement) Bozza Jr., September 2015, 1 page MCPO 2t,2015,1 September 21, Det, Daniel DanielBozzalr., MCPO Supplemental Report, Det. Supplemental Report, (Jeffrey (Jeffrey Mahajan Mahaj an Statement) Statement) 19. t9. Bozza Jr., 2015, 1 page MCPO 21,2015,1 DanielBozza Jr., September September 21, Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. (John (John Bree Bree Statement) Statement) 2015, 1 page MCPO ll',2015,1 Septernber 11, Rocco Santorsola, Santorsola, September Report, Sgt. Sgt. Rocco MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, 20. 20. Bozza Jr., September MCPO pages 2A1,5,22 pages 10, 2015, September 10, DanielBozzaJr., Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, Report, Det. 21. 21. MCPO Jr., September 201 5, 11 page 23, 2015, Septembet 23, Bozzalr., Daniel Bozza Report, Det. Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, 18. 18. 22. 22. (Audio/Video (Audio/Video footage) footage) 2015, 2 pages MCPO Supplemental 8,2015,2 October 8, Daniel Newman, Newman, October Report, Det. Det. Daniel MCPO Supplemental Report, Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0002 0002 Filed 08/04/16 Page 4 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1039 INVESTIGATION HMls-OAfi 7 NO. HM15-00177 INVESTIGATION NO. CIVIL DISCOVERY CIVIL DISCOVERY (Thomas (Thomas J. Esquire) J. Mallon, Mallon, Esquire) 23. 23. 2015, 3 pages MCPO Jr., September 17,2015,3 September 17, BozzaJr., Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza Report, Det. MCPO Investigation Investigation Report, 24. 24, 24, 2015, 4 pages MCPO November24,2015,4 Ricciardi, November Parnela Ricciardi, Report, Det. Det. Pamela Investigation Report, MCPO Investigation 25. 25. 2016, 1 page MCPO 23,2016,1 Ricciardi, January 23, Det. Pamela Pamela Ricciardi,January Report, Det. MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, 26. 26. 2015, 2 pages MCPO 28,2015,2pages September 28, ÏVeisbrot, September Det. Brian Brian Weisbrot, Report, Det. MCPO Supplemental Supplemental Report, 27. 27. 2015, 4 pages MCPO 15,2015,4 October 15, Lou Zuppa, Zuppa, October Det. Lou MCPO Technical Report, Det. Technical Report, 28. 28. 2015, 1 page MCPO 15,2015,1 October 15 Zuppa, October Lou Zuppa, Autopsy, Det. Det. Lou Photo Report Report Autopsy, MCPO Uniform Uniform Photo 29. 29. 2015, 1 page MCPO Zuppa, October 15,2015,1 October 15, Lou Zuppa, PD, Det. Det. Lou Howell PD, Report Howell MCPO Uniform Uniform Photo Photo Report 30. 30. 2015, 1 page MCPO 15,20t5,1 October 15, Zuppa, October Lou Zuppa, Det. Lou Report Scene, Scene, Det. Uniform Photo Photo Report MCPO Uniform 31. 31, 2015, 1 page MCPO SUMC, Det. 15,2015,1 October 15, Zuppa, October Lou Zuppa, Det. Lou Photo Report Report JJSUMC, MCPO Uniform Uniform Photo 32. 32. 33. 2015, 1 MCPO 6, Det. 3A,2015,1' September 30, Zuppa, September Lou Zuppa, Det. Lou thru 6, Itemsl 5-0577-5-l thru Log Items15-0577-5-1 MCPO Evidence Evidence Log page Page 2015, 6, Det. MCPO 15,2A15, October 15, Zuppa, October Lou Zuppa, Det. Lou thru 6, ltems 15-0577-5-1 15-0577-5-L thru Receipt Items Evidence Receipt MCPO Evidence 34. 34. September MCPO Jr., September Bozzq Jr., Daniel Bozza, Det. Daniel 8, Det. thru 8, ß-A577-l-1 thru Evidence Receipt Receipt Items Items 15-0577-1-1 MCPO Evidence 35. 35. J r., September MCPO 22, Septembet 22, Bozza, Jr., Det. Daniel Daniel Bozza, 15-0577-2-1, Det. Items 15-0577-2-1, Receipt Items MCPO Evidence Evidence Receipt 36. 36. 37. 37. , lpage lpage 17, 2015, Ipage lpage 17,2015, 2015, 2415, lpage lpage Jr., September Bozza, Jr., September MCPO DanieIBozza, Det. Daniel 3, Det. thru 3, Itemsl5-0577-3-l thru Receipt Items15-0577-3-1 MCPO Evidence Evidense Receipt 23, 2015, Ipage lpage 23,2075, September 25, MCPO 25, Newman, September Daniel Newman, Det. Daniel Itemsl5-0577-4-1, Det. MCPO Evidence Evidence Receipt Receipt Items15-0577-4-1 , 2015, lpage 2A15,1page 43. 43. MCPO Gaughran, John Gaughran, 15-0577'4'1, John and 15-0577-4-1, thru 33 and Receipt Items15-0577-3-1 ltemsl5-0577-3-L thru Evidence Receipt MCPO Evidence 1 November 2015, page 5,2015,lpage November 5, MCPO Daniel f)et. Daniel 15-0577-4-1, Det. and 15-0577-4-1, thru 33 and Itemsl5-0577-3-l thru MCPO Evidence E.¿idence Receipt Receipt Items15~0577-3-1 1 November 2015, Jr., 5, Bozza, page Bozz4 Jr., November 5, 2015,1page 77-3-1 thru MCPO Bamer, Jeffrey Bamer, 15-0577'4-1, Jeffrey and 15-0577-4-1, thru 33 and S-0577-3-l Receipt Items] ltemsl 5-05 MCPO Evidence Evidence Receipt December 2015, Ipage December 8, 8,2015,lpage Evidence MCPO Daniel Det. Daniel 15-0577-4'1, Det. and 15-0577-4-1, thru 33 and ltemsl5-0577-3-l thru Receipt Items15-0577-3-1 MCPO Evidence Receipt 1 December Bozza, page 2015, lpage Jr., December 8, 8, 2015, Bozza, Jr., 2015, Bozza, Jr., Items15—05 MCPO 77-6-1, Det. 6,2015, Jr., October Octobet 6, Receipt Det. Daniel DanieIBozza, Itemsl5-0577-6-1, MCPO Evidence Receipt Evidence 1lpage page Middlesex Zuppa, Lou Zuppa, Det. Lou Receipt, Det. Inventory Receipt, OfÍice Inventory Examiner's Office County Medical Medical Examiner’s Middlesex County 44. 44. 2015, 1 page Consent Search, Priscilla 15,2A15,1 Septernber 15, Priscilla Baker, Baker, September Consent To To Search, 38. 38. 39. 39. 40. 44. 41. 42. 42. September 16, 2015, 2015, Ipage lpage September 16, Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0003 0003 Filed 08/04/16 Page 5 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1040 INVESTIGATION NO, HM15-00177 IIM15.OOI77 INVESTIGATION NO. CIVIL DISCOVERY CWIL DISCOVERY (Thomas Esquire) (Thomas J. Mallono Esquire) J. Mallon, 46. 46. Bozza, Jr., MCPO October Jr., October DanielBazza, phone, Det. Det. Daniel Cell phone, Kyocera Cell Receipt Kyocera Evidence Property Property Receipt MCPO Evidence 1 2015, I page 5, 5,2075, 2015, 7 pages NMS 14,2015,7 December 14, Harden, December Timothy Harden, Toxicology Report, Report, Timothy Labs Toxicology NMS Labs 47. 47. 2015, 1 page September 11, Howell 11,2015,1 L,t. Martin, Martin, September Report, Lt. Review Report, Howell Twp Twp PD PD Meaningful Meaningful Review 48. 48. 2015, 1 page Howell 8,2015,1 September 8, Daniel Murphy, Murphy, September Ptl. Daniel Report, Ptl. Force Report, Twp PD PD Use Use of of Force Howell Twp 49. 49. 2015, 1 page Howell 8,2AL5,1 September 8, Conaty, September Twp PD Ptl. James James Conaty, of Force Force Report, Report, Ptl. Howell Twp PD Use Use of 50. 50. 2015, 1 page Howell 8,2015,1 September 8, Austin, September Nicholas Austin, Ptl. Nicholas Force Report, Report, Ptl. Twp PD PD Use Use of of Force Howell Twp 51. 51. 2015, 1 page of Force Howell 8,2015,1 September 8, Migdon, September Michael Migdon, Ptl. Michael Report, Ptl. Force Report, Howell Twp Twp PD PD Use Use of 52. 52. Howell 2015, 11 page 8, 2015, September 8, Bonner, September Vincent Bonner, Pti. Vincent Report, Ptl. Twp PD of Force Force Report, Howell Twp PD Use Use of 53. 53. 2015, 2 pages Call Number Howell 5,2AL5,2 September 5, 15-39715, September Report Call Number 15-39715, PD CAD CAD Report Howell Twp Twp PD 54. 54, 2015, 4 pages Statement of 30,2015,4 November 30, Austin, November of Ptl. Ptl. Nicholas Nicholas Austin, Statement 55. 55. 2015, 5 pages Statement 20,201.5,5 Bonner, November November 20, Ptl. Vincent Vincent Bonner, Statement of of Ptl. 56. 56. 2015, 4 pages Statement 20,2015,4 Conaty, November November 20, Ptl. James James Conaty, Statement of of Ptl. 57. 57. 2015, 4 pages Statement 20,2015,4 November 20, Murphy, November of Ptl. Ptl. Daniel Daniel Murphy, Statement of 58. 58. 2105, 7 pages Statement pages 5,2105,7 White, November November 5, Patricia White, Statement of of Patricia 59. 59. of David Statement 2015, 7 pages pages 26,2015,7 David Mahajan, October 26, Mahajan, October Statement of 60. 60. of Christine Christine Brown, Statement 2015, 4 pages 76,2015,4 October 16, Brown, October Statement of 61. 61, 2015, 4 pages Statement 75,2015,4 Meyer, October October 15, Statement of of Christy Christy Meyer, 62. 62. 2015, 6 pages Statement 5,2015,6 Tina Pinelli, Pinelli. October October 5, of Tina Statement of 63. 63. 2015, 6 pages Statement 23,2015,6 Hoffinan ,, September September 23, of Jeremy Statement of Jeremy Hoffman 64. 64. 2015, 8 pages Statement 23,2075,8 Ryan Edgar, Edgar, September September 23, of Ryan Statemenf of 65. 65. 2015, 6 pages Statement 22,2015,6 Bleefeld, September September 22, of Benjamin Beqjamin Bleefeld, Statement of 66. 66. 2015, 7 pages Statement pages 22,2015,7 September 22, Michael Johnstone, Johnstone, September of Michael Statement of 67. 67. 2015, 6 pages of Joseph Statement 22,2A15,6 Septembet 22, Zimmerman, September Joseph Zimmerman, Statement of 45. 45. Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0004 0004 Filed 08/04/16 Page 6 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1041 INVESTIGATION HM15-TOI71 NO. HM15-00177 INVESTIGATION NO. CIVIL DISCOYERY CIVIL DISCOVERY (Thomas EsquÍre) (Thomas J. Mallon, Esquire) J. Mallon, 68. 68. 2015, 7 pages of Joseph Statement pages 2I,2015,7 September 21, Wocio, September Joseph Wocio, Statement of 69. 69. 2015, 5 pages Statement 21,2015,5 September 21, Ladue, September Philip Ladue, Statement of of Philip 70. 70. 2015, 6 pages Statement 17,2015,6 September 17, Emilius, September of Casey Casey Emilius, Statement of 71. 2015, 6 pages Statement 17,2015,6 September 17, Mahajan, September Jeffrey Mahajan, of Jeffrey Statement of 72. 72. Statement pages 2A15,77 pages 17, 2015, September 17, Bree, September of John John Bree, Statement of 73. 73. of Andrew Statement of i 1 pages 2015, 11 8, 2015, September 8, Neri, September Andrew Neri, Statement 74. 74. 5, 2015, Statement 2A15,77 pages Toth, September September 5, Brian Toth, of Brian Statement of 75. 75. 2015, 8 pages Statement 5,2015,8 Baker, September September 5, of Priscilla Priscilla Baker, Statement of 76. 76. 2015, 5 pages John Smith Statement 5,2015,5 Jr., September Septembet 5, of John Smith Jr., Statement of 77. 77. 2015, 5 pages Statement 5,2015,5 September 5, Castillo, September Daniel Castillo, of Daniel Statement of 78. 78. of Patrick Statement 2A15,66 pages 5, 2015, Troy, September September 5, Patrick Troy, Statement of 79. 79. Statement 2AI5,66 pages 5, 2015, September 5, Cruz, September of Brandon Brandon Cruz, Statement of 80. 80. Calls and CD (Redacted) Transmissions (Redacted) Radio Transmissions and Radio CD 911 911 Calls 81. 81. DVD Yehtcle2? Ptl. Austin Austin Vehicle22 MVR Ptl. DVD MVR 82. 82. Ptl. Bonne DVD Bonne Vehicle Vehicle 99 MVRPtl. DVD MVR 83. DVD 10 Vehicle 10 Ptl. Migdon Migdon Vehicle MVR Ptl. DVD MVR 84. 84. DVD 28 Vehicle 28 Ptl. Conaty Conaty Vehicle DVD MVR MVR Ptl. 85. DVD Vehicle 77 MVR Vehicle DVD MVR 86. 86. DVD Vehicle 55 Sgt, Weg Weg Vehicle MVR Sgt. DVD MVR 87. 87. DVD Vehicle 51 51 Ptl. Murphy Murphy Vehicle DVD MVR MVR Ptl. 88. 88. DVD (Scene) Zuppa (Scene) Det. Zuppa FN15-00197 Det. Photos FNl5-00197 Forensic Photos DVD Forensic 89. 89. DVD (Photos of officers) of Officers) Zuppa (Photos Det. Zuppa FN15-00197 Det. Photos FN15-00197 DVD Forensic Forensic Photos 90. 90. CD (Redacted) Dispatch (Redacted) PD Dispatch & Howell Howell PD Mary Green Green & Calls Mary CD Phone Phone Calls Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0005 0005 Filed 08/04/16 Page 7 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1042 INVESTIGATION HM15-OOI777 NO. HM15-0017 INVESTIGATION NO. CIVIL DISCOVERY CIVIL DISCOVERY (Thomas (Thomas J. Esquire) Mallon, Esquire) J. Mallon, 91. 2015, 5' 2015 September 5, Weg, September Thomas Weg, Sgt. Thomas Nanative, Sgt. Twp PD PD Supplemental Supplemental Narrative, Howell Twp 91. Howell I3-Igiil l 93. :15:/geellTwp 94. flggxrgell Twp , 3 pages 2015, 92. 5,2015, September 5, Conaty, September wp PD James Conaty, Narrative, Ptl. Ptl. James & Narrative, PD Incident Incident Report Report & 92. Howell TTwp 93. 94. 5 pages 2015, Ortenzi, September 6,2015, September 6, RobertOúenzi, Det. Robert Narrative, Det. PD Supplemental Supplemental Narrative, Howell Twp PD 2pages 2015, 44 7,2015, September 7, Supplemental Narrative, Murphy, September Ptl. Daniel Daniel Murphy, Narrative, Ptl. PD Supplemental Howell Twp PD lr)IE:)g\:r:l1 pages 2015, 95. 7,2A15, September 7, Heather Scherbinski, Scherbinski, September Ptl. Heather Nanative, Ptl. PD Supplemental Trap PD Supplemental Narrative, 95. Howell Twp I1-Igzvgell 97. I515:/g: ‘l Twp 98. figsvillTwp 99, I1-lg:/ge(l Twp 1 page 2015, September 7, 96. 7,2015, Migdon, September Ptl. Michael Michael Migdon, Narrative, Ptl. Twp PD PD Supplemental Supplemental Narrative, 96. Howell Twp 97. 98. 99. 100. 100. 3 pages 2015, 7,2015, September 7, Austin, September Ptl. Nicholas Nicholas Austin, Narrative, Ptl. PD Supplemental Howell Twp PD Supplemental Narrative, 2pages 2015, 7,2015, September 7, MacDonald, September Ptl. Sean Sean MacDonald, Narrative, Ptl. Howell Twp PD PD Supplemental Supplemental Narrative, 1 page 2015, 7,2015, September 7, Bonner, September Ptl. Vincent Vincent Bonner, Narrative, Ptl. PD Supplemental Supplemental Narrative, Howell Twp PD 22pages pages 2015, 66 pages Medical 31,2015, December 31, Karluk, December Diane Karluk, Report, Dr. Dr. Diane Autopsy Report, Medical Examiner Examiner Autopsy Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0006 0006 Filed 08/04/16 Page 8 of 100 PageID: 8043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1043 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed ()l"l"l( I ( ()l \'f'\ ’R().\‘l{('l"l‘()R‘.\' \l()\\l()l l)ll()s¡.( t 'l ()ll'.\ (H-‘I" ('l". \t( )t ' ' ('()l‘\T\' \lo\ @ ilt .' I /1.. ì/i 1., \’ ,t .‘ V)-‘V’,/-ix" .:)!,Jt)¡ "; I-1.—Uni l. Unitt of I "J. Promis Gavel Gavel it# 2. 2. Unit File 1! GI cl I5-00172 r5-00172 GENERAL INVESTIGATION GENERAL INVESTIGATION 4. Case Agency(s) Poge I 7. 7 6. 5. ó. N.J.S. N.J.S. 5, Crime REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW 9. 9. Location I¡cation of CrimT Crime STATE HIGHWAY 1017 NT 0773]; 07131; NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ IOIT STATE HIGHWAY #33, #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ Reported Date Dale & & Time Tinrc 09/05/2015 l6:19 09/05/2015 16:19 I .8.Incident & Time Llncidcnt Date Date & Time ' 10. 10. Person Person Reporting Rcporting Incident Incidcnt // Crime: Crimc: 11. I l. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. 12. Person Person Info(s): Info(s): 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. 15. Person P*son Info(s): Info(s): 13. 13. Address(s): Address(s); 16. 16. Address(s): Addrcss(s)¡ 7 17. Pmpcrty 17. Stolenl Stolcn / Missing Missing Property: \ \t{lì \ I t\ 18. Weapon Usfidi 18. WeaP°" I of the Office of On County Offìce 2015, I received the Medical Medical from the the Middlesex Middlesex County Autopsy from January 14, 14,2015,1 the Report Report of of Autopsy On January ¡rccived the excited delirium induced of death be the to identifies The Harden. cause Examiner, drug induced excited delirium Examiner, on on Timothy Timothy Harden. The report identifles the cause of death to be drug was ruled with accidental. ruled accidental. the manner of death death was and the manner of with sudden sudden death death occurring occurring during during forcible forcible restraint restraint and of this Based included, which included, this investigation investigatíon which during the the course course of Based on obtained during on aa review review of the information information obtained of all all the involved, multiple multiple video video police witnesses and and ofiicers reports, Use police reports, from witnesses ofücers involved, of Force Force Reports, Reports, statements statements from Use of and it¡t radio call and scene MVR 911 transmissions, photographs, autopsy report; photographs, and recordings autopsy report; scene systems, call radio transmissions, recordings from MVR and from systems, 911 the within General’s Use acted Police the the Howell that members of Attorney Township Department within the Attorney General's acted Use appears that the m€mbers of the Howell Township Police Department of Force of Force Uniform Use Use of Force policy. Force Guidelines the Monmouth County Unifonn of Cuidclines and and the Monmouth County Policy. This This investigation is complete. investigation is complete. Based review and attomey review for attorney and closure closure submitt€d for Based on facts this this case case is is being being submitted on the the aforementioned aforementioned facts consideration. consideration. EXHIBIT (rycØ /«am i mm Þå6 Reporting Rcporling Dclcclive f)ctcctive DAM!-.'L nozzn JR. D.{'¡itI,iL .1,t 80zz^Jk Reporting Detective Signature Signailro Reporting Detective D ; 't' of7R7epo? Date Date of Report V-— 01/15/2016 0vl5n0ß fisupervisor Signature Supervisor Signature ‘- /7¢cQ£¢_5¢‘a¢_ 4Æ/LÈ. rå¿ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0007 0007 Filed 08/04/16 Page 9 of 100 PageID: BRM-TJB Page D: 1044 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed ()lì's () " “ ('lC ol;l'l( I ('()t \'¡ \ ’R().\ ’.('l"l M()\;\ ()l l'l{osl.('l 'l ()R'.\ N,t()\\l()t ’I'l llll ('()l.'\”l‘\ @ t /r \\ / 3. ¡,,i '., :)t i Jr U-‘ lll i't M/ ,' /.'/'.'‘< 1 P 'n1uis—”il 3. 3. 2. 2. 1 :1 G115-00172 crr5-00r72 7.l. Unit Unit G1-ZN]-2l{2‘\l_ INVESTIGATION TION 4. Case Àgency(s) Case Agency(s) % _ 09/05/2o1s1e:19 091051201516t19 __ I of I “ 7. Reported & Time me Date & Reported Date _ 6. 5. 6. N.I.S. N.t.S. 5. Crime Crirne REVIEW POLICY POLICY 9. Location of Crime 9. 07731; HOWELL, NJ [017 NJ HOWELL, NJ 07731; #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ STATE I{IGHWAY #33, IO17 STATEHIGHWAY Page 8.lncident S.lncident Date Date KL & Tinie‘ Tíme _ 10. / Crime: Incidenl /Crime: Person Reporting Reporting Incident 10, Person -11. ll. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. 12. Person Person lnf‘o(s): Info(s): 13. 13. Address(s): Address(s): I4. Viclim(s): I4. Victim(s): 15. Person lnfo(s)l t5. Person lnfotsi): -16. ló. Address(s): Address(s): I8. Weapon lE. Weapon Used: 17. Missing Property: Property: t7. Stolen Stolen // Missing \\ il{\ll\l .Iohnstone‘s of both they mention mention an an statements, they Johnstone s statements, M and Michael During B leefeld and Benjamin Bleefeld course of both Benjamin Duri ng the the course from the festival. Itt t, that ran he when Route initially from Harden Mr. 33, ran from festiva named “Chris” ly the nitial individual picked up Mr Harden from Route 33, when he indi vidual named "Chris that picked Howell or the witness to Township “Chris” guards security that is indication guards p was there or Howell ownsh be that noted T should no indication that "Chris" was witness to the security should be notsd that there is no Harden. withMr. Police interactions with Mr. Harden. Officers, interactions Police Officers, 2015, multiple 2015 to attempts multiple attempts From 7,2015, Decembet 7, of December to the the week week of 9,2015 the week week of of November November 9, From approximately approximately the did she know not that stated and contacted personally Baker personally Priscilla “Chris”. was made did not been to she know have that stated and identify contacted was Priscilla Baker made to identí$' have been "Chris". Baker failed Priscilla call this to him. for number able of be and failed knew him to but Baker to a Priscilla oall this telephone him. for might number get Chris, get telephone a Chris, but knew of him and might be abte to returned. been not have Baker Ms. reach to information. returnedwith back been not Detective have Multiple Baker attempts Ms. reach to Detective back with any information. Multiple attempts Investigation to continue. continue. Investigation to J i Reporting Detaotive Reporting Detective JR. DANIEL JBOZT'AJN. DA¡IIEL JBOZZA »_ 7 Reporting Dctcctive Signature Signaturc Reporling Detective S ,6 @fui"e Date of Report Report Date of 12/10/2015 tunn0l5 §uperviso_r _Signature ' Supervisor Signature .dÆF /{Egg Z fiflqaé râ¿ Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0008 0008 RM-TJB Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 10 of 100 PageID: Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1045 ( )l"l"l( 'l' \l()'\'.\l()l"l’ ('()l'V'l \’ l’ {().\' C('l“ '()R'.\‘ l)lt( )s1..( 'l I ( )l,l'\ ()l“ “l(‘ C \t()\\tot lll('ol \‘l @ _ l.it L Unit H", ‘'II ,''_i.'/‘, J'.'_'/ Page loll Promis (imrcl # 3. Prornis 2. Unit Unit File ti GI r 5-00¡ 72 Gr I5-00172 (EIENERAL iN\"l.!~i’l'l(if_\TION 4. Agency(s) 4. Case Case Agency(s) g * Reponefi)ate & Time Time Dste & 7. ?. Reporied — 6. 5. 6. N..l.S. Crime 5. Crime REVIEW POLICY POLICY REVIEW 9. L Location of Crime #33, HOWELL, 1017 NJ 07731; 07731: NJ HOWELL, HOWI]LL, NJ HOWELL, NJ HIGHWAY#33, IOIT STATE SÎATE HIGHWAY 09/05/2015 l6:19 û9/05/2015 l6:l9 _ 8.lncident Date Date & & Time Time _ _>>__ W i Crime: 10. lncidenl //Crime: Reporting Incident t0. Person Person Reporting 1]. I l. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) lnfo(s):. 13. Address(s): 13. Address(s): 12. Person lnfo(s): 12. Person - 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. lnfo(s): Person lnfo(s): 15. Person I8. 8. 17. Property: Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen // Missing I6. Address(s): 16. Address(s): Weapon Used: Used: \\l{l{\ll\l B rown, with Christine Christine Brown, met with and I met On w e sbrot and Brian Weisbrot Detective Brian :00pm, Detective 2 0 5, at Lt approximately approximately 1:00pm, October l6, 2015, On October of The New in Office Freehold, Jersey. Prosecutor's of this this purpose Monmouth The the Je rsey at New _, DOB old, County Freeh at the Mon mouth County Prosecutoy's Office tn DOB occurred that at Priediane, incident the Brown Christine ôccuffed at Pri from ediane, that take regarding statement ncident the :1 to meeting typed statement from ch n stine Brown regard ng was to take typed meet¡ ng was 5 2015. 2A 5. located Septem ber 5. on September H arde n, on Ti m othy Harden, N J involving tnvo tng Timothy Freehold NJ, Route 33, 3 3 Freehold, at 1017 I 0 7 Route located at 1:34pm and and concluded concluded at at The at approximately approx¡mately 1:34pm began at Brown began (4) page typed statement of of Christine Christine Brown typed statement four (4) The four dated Christine of Brown, the statement refer to details For incident. dated without Brown, Christine of statement the to 2:07pm, refer For details approximately incident. approx¡mat€þ'i:07prn,'without 2015 at October at 1:34pm. l.3{pm. 16, 2015 October 16, continue. Investigation to continue. Investigation to Reporting Detective Reporting Detective BOZZA JR. DANIEL JR. J BO7,ZA DANTEL J Reporting Signature Detective Signature Reporting Detective ,6 Tàæe ç6 “Date-of Rcport Date of Report 10/23/2015 tot23t20l5 ' Supervisor Signature Supervisor Signature ‘£6 4Æ/# råó Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0009 0009 3:15-cv-08043-BF_§_M-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 11 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1046 .\ ()\\ ()l'I ll ('()l‘\' '\ ’R(')H[-'.(’l 'l‘()R'\ ()I-l“l(_ IC @ unit GH5-00172 GENERAL lroN CENERAL lNVl;'$'ll(i/“TON 4. Case Case Agency(s) Agency(s) 4. Gl l5'00172 5. 5. Crirne C¡ime REVIEW POLICY FOLICYREVIEW 6. 6. N.J.S. N.J.S. __. of I 3. # is Gavel Gavel # 3. Pruiuis 2. Unit File Hfl 1 1. L Unit Page l _ __ 7. Ru 1¢rr1u:-it-I:)_tate Date 15:19 09/05/2015 09/05/2015 l6:19 Time Time 8.lncident Date & Tirne lime 7 9. Crl¡ne of Crime Loc¡tion of 9. Location STATE HIGHWAY NJ 07731; 0773I; 7 STATE HOWELL, NJ 10 NJ HOWELL, #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ HiGHWAY #33, IO IIT 10. Crime: Incident I/ Crime: 10. Person Reporting Incident Person Reporting Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Info(s): Person Info(s): 12. Person 14. Victim(s): 14, Victim(s): 15. Info(s): Person Info(s): I 5, Person 11. I l. Add.rese(s): - 13. 13, Address(s); 16. Addrcss(s): ló, Address(s): — I 17. Property: / Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen /Missing _ I8. Weapon Weapon Used: \\lìii\ll\l Meyer Christy Meyer, with Christy môt with and II met weisbrot and Brian Weisbrot On October ç 2015, Detective Brian :00pm, Detective at aPproximately 55:00pm, z0 5 at On October I5, of The New of this in Jersey. purpose The puqpose this Office Freehold, Prosecutor's ew Jersey N Monmouth the at DOB County Prosecutor's OfIice tn Freehold, at the Monm outh County DOB at occurred that Priediane, incident the Priediane, at occurred that from regarding Meyer regarding the incident Christy Meyer st¿tEment from Christy meeting typed statement to take take aa typed tvâs to meeting was 20 5 5 2015. September 5, on September Harden, on located Timothy Harden, n vol ng Timothy NJ involving Freehold, NJ, 33, Freehold, Route 33, located at at 1017 I 0 I 7 Route I — approximately and concluded 5:19 pm at pm- and concluded at at upproxiruatcly spproximately-.s:J9 The began at Meyer began typed statement of Christy Christy Meyer statement of pagetyped four (4) page The four dated of Mcycr, Christy statement the to the statement of Christy Mcyer, datcd refeito áetails refer For details 5:45pm, without incident. incident. For approximately approximâtel'V'Sr¿lp*,'*ithout 2015 at October 5:19pm. 15, October 15, 2015 at 5:l9pm. Investigation to continue. continue. Investigation to Reponing Detective Reporling Detective DANIEL JR. BOZZA JR. DANIELJJ BOZZA Reporting Dctcctive Signature Signature Reporting Detective Brute ltr'porl ol {:‘p(>rl_ I)ate oI' ,6 &&a"a 10/23/2015 r 0/2Jl20 I 5 Supervisor Signature Signarure r@¡lÉwa /xgetefl 5,, Em ,., Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0010 0010 Filed 08/04/16 Page 12 of 100 PageID: M-TJB Page D: 1047 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed )l'\"l'\' .\ ()\\l() \'l'\ l’R().\' -‘.( l'}ll( )sl' ( '1‘ l'UR'.\ (IH-‘l( ' ". I Il ( Ot \t( )\ \lol 'l'll('( @ \,i '/j'jr, il' , \, tr .~l, Unit 2. Unit File /1 L Unít CENERAL l'l ì'(ti\'' Page Page Ion I of I 3. 6avel ## 3. Promis Promis Gavel I G115-00172 Gil5-00r72 4. 4. Case Case Agency(s) Agency(s) ' 5. 5. Crime Crime ’" T N..l.S. 6. 6,N " POLICY REVIEW REVIEW ' ' 't_ed Date & Time Date & Reported 7. Repoi 09/05/2015 t6 19 0910s12015 16:19 ‘ Date & 8.1ncident & Time Time 8.Incídent Datc g 9. Location of Cri¡ne of Crime 1017 NJ 07731; 07731; HOTilELL, NJ NJ HOWELL, #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ STATE HIGHWAY HIGHWAY #33, 101? STATE 10. Crime: Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident I 0, Person Person Reporting Info(s): ‘ . 1l.Suspect(s) I l. Suspect(s) 12. 12. Person Person Info(s): 13.Address(s): 13. Address(s) 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Person Info(s): Info(s): 15. Person 16. Addrcss(s)r 16, Address(s): U I I _ I8. Weapon Weapon Used: Uscd: 17. Property: Missing Property: I7. Stolen Stolen // Missing \ \t,lR \ I l\ I w¡th Tina Tina Pinelli, Pinelli, DOB DOB met with October and II met On w e sbrot and Brian Weisbrot 5, 2015. Detecti ve Brian approximately 3:30pm, 3 :3Opm, Detective 20 5 at at approximatelY On Octo ber 5 of this The New in Office purpose Freehold, The purpose of this Jersey. Prosecutor’s Monmouth ersey _ at the New J ln Freehold, County Prosec utor's Office at the Monmouth County occurred at at Priediane, Priediane, that occurred the incident tncl dent that Pine ili regarding regard¡ ng the meeting from Tina Tina Pinelli take aa typed ststement from typed statement meeting was lvas to to take 2015. 5, on 5 5 Harden, September 20 I Route Timothy ber I017 located involv ng Timothy Harden, on Septem NJ involving at 0 I 7 Route 33, Freehold, NJ, 3 J, Freehold, located at concluded at at pm and The a,09.pt approximate$ 4:09 at approximately began at Pinetti began Tina Pinelli (6) page typed of Tina typed statement statement of The six six (6) lnq..oncluded dated Tina of Pinelli, the refer statement to details For 1 pm, without approximately +:5tpm, incident. For details refer to the statement of Tina Pinelli, dated without incident. approximadty 4:5 2015 at October 5, 4:09pm. at 4:09pm. 5,2015 October Investigation to continue. continue. fnvestigation to ‘ Reporting Detective Reporting Detective JR. DANIEL BOZZ.ATR. DANIELJJ BOZZA I 'Repor1ing Signaturc Dcteotive Signature Reporting Detective .é Date Report Date of of Report 1o/23/2015 t0l23l20ts I Supcn Signature Supcn isnr isor Signature Ivésee Z #34 tN- Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0011 0011 - - - RM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 13 of 100 PagelD: 1048 Utut Ftieit .l it LUnil EENERALINVESTIGAQQNV fills-00171 fl fl 4 case 7 Reported oiehl'ime I Tune 513nm: POLICY REVIEW location to I 7 STATE HIGHWAY m, HOWELL Nl HOWELL, amt. lo Pet-run Rep-min; Incident lCrune~ ii.sitepeetli) |1 Person Inla[1)27 lti Amazssar viaimia): 7 ineraunlntatr): '13 Weapnn Used: I Missing Huge"; On Monday, October 5. 20l5 at approximately am PM, Detective Daniel Bow onlte Monmouth County Prosecutor's omoe Professional Responsibility and Bias Crime Bureau and i immicwcd und obtained a six (6) page typewritten statem >>nt Tina Pinelli. 43 Webb Avenue Apt. 3. Ocean Grove. NJ 077% Don: -- telephone number in to this inveslig . The statement was obtained at the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office ioeated in Freehold. NJ. Tina was a volunte=r participant at the music fcskiul held at the Priedaine on the date oflh: incidenl. For additional information, please refer to the statement. On Thursday, October is, 2015 at apvroximalely 5119 PM. Detective Daniel noun at the Monmouth County Prosecutor's omoe Prolessional Responsih ly and Bias Crime Bureau and interviewed and obtained a four (4) page typewritten mlemem {mm Chriery Meyer, 43 Neil Avenue, Brick, NJ 08724, DOB: - telephone number --in reference to this investigation. The statement was obtained at the Monmouth Counly Prosecutor's omoe located in Freehold. NJ. Christy was working as the anl Gate Managu at the music lestival held at the Pliedsin: on the date of the incident. For additional information, please refer to the statement. On Friday, @2le 16. ZOIS at npproximaldy 1:34 Detective Daniel Bola uflhe Munmoulh Prosecutor's Office - meossionll Responsihilily and Bias Bum" Ind I inter 'ewed Md obtained A four (4) page from Chrislillc Brown -- NJ 07753. Don. -telephonc number--in reference in! 'i he statement was obtained at the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office located in Freehold. NJ. Christine was an attendee at the music festival held at the Priedaine on the date at the incident For additional information. please reler lo the shtment. For detailed information pertaining to this investigation, please refer to the reports prepared by the Monmouth Cnunly Prosecumr's omce -- Professional Responsibility and Bias Crime Bureau, case t1 Glts. 00172. Wing further to inf-is lime. ,i 7 7A fie iterating Dewitt: Deledive Sign-um Tuariernepou supervisor Signal": unranwarseatrr a, w/r'dg'ac Prosecutor's File 0012 RM-TJB Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 14 of 100 PageID: Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1049 )I-'l“l(' ". II ('()l'\'l .\l()\\l()l Yl \\ l’R().H'l-‘.(‘l"l‘()R'.\' I'llosl.( t'l ()l{'s (ol;l;l('l \t()\\l()t ‘Illl('ot @ .,, ;,,'i ¡'t l,t);il ,I .__,. \r r., ,-...v,-,,,-,-, \/,r -\_, .. is Cave Promis oaivetv 2. 2. UnitFile# Unit File cns-00172 Gl t5-00r 72 1.Unit l. Unit GENERAL INVI-2S'l‘I(iATlON Page Page [of] I of I _ 4. Case Agency(s) Agcncy(s) 4. Case Reported 7. Tirne Date & & Time 7. Reported Date T 6. N.J.s. 5. 5, Crime CrÍme REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW 9. of 9. Loctlliun ol'l..'rime 1017 NJ 07731; 0773I; NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ HICHWAY #33, 1017 STATE STATE HIGHWAY 8.lncidcnt Date & & Time Time 09/05/2015 16:19 09105120ti 15:19 10. Crime: Incident / Crime: Reporting Incident/ Person Reporting 10. Person Info(sl:_‘ Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Person Info(s): I 2. Person 13. 13. Address(s): Address(s): 14. 14. Victim(s): Victim(s): l5. Person Info(s): Info(s): 15, Person I6. Address(s): I 6. Address(s): 11. ll. 18. 18. Weapon Weapon Used: 17. PropertY: Missing Property: Stolen // Missing 17. Stolen \ \lti,l \ ll\ I On October 5, 20l 5, at approximately 10:00am, I received a phone call from Priscilla Baker, from Harden’s cell phone. telephone numbcr— Ms. Baker informed me that she had located Timothy the bin from found Souper Groove event. Ms. Baker stated that she had found the cell phone in the lost and Theresa Taylor. Ms. sister l-larden's Ms. Baker added that when she was trying to return other items to Mr. that was in the bin. Ms. Taylor had inquired about a cell phone that matched the description of the cell phone office might need the Baker stated that she returned the other belongings to Ms. Taylor, but thought that our her of possession and it cellphone. Ms. Baker indicated that the cell phone has remained off during the timeBaker informed me that Ms. was placed in a small plastic bag. When asked to come retrieve the cell phone, until home be 6:30pm. would not she and that her house the cell phone was located at Baker's to Ms. Ms. Baker’s responded to and II responded On Newman and Daniel Newman approximately 6:20pm, Detective Daniel 6:20pm, Detective at approximately date, at On the the same same date, the home in invited by were the we at Ms. Street, Tinton door, we were invited in the home by Ms. NJ, Once Once at the door, home, Falls, NJ. Tinton Falls, Peach-Street, located at at 77 77 Peach home, located small in a cell plastic with wrapped a plastic small me Baker in a phone wrapped Ms. phone husband a cell her and with provided me Baker Mahajan. provided Jeffery Baker Mahajan. Ms. Jeffery Baker and her husband -BlueiMetallic IMEI# with an C650N # Model IMEI# Blue/Metallic with an # C650N cell was a Kyocera, The Model Kyocera, provided phone was a bag. bag. The cell phone provided 011, nor he noted powered on, nor not powered was not phone was cell phone that the the cell 0l40l600268l‘)48 noted that It should should be case. It btue case. rubber blue *¡Ur au rubber 0l¡0160026tíg+g with removed to all and were battery removed to backing The all were made. battery and cover, the cellphone on backing to cellphone phone were power the phone on made. The attempts to power were any attempts fill out was evidence receipt An reinstalled. out then properly receipt was fill and prûperty numbers and IMEI Model the evidence to An gain gain access access to tñe Moäel and IhriEI numbers and then reilrstalled. phone was cell phone was The cell receipt. The the receipt. of the provided aa copy of and was provided Baker was Bakcr, Ms. Ms. Baker and Ms. Ms. Baker, both myself myself and signed by by both ãnd signed the with secured property receipt. receipt. in an an envelope envelope with the property secured in property receipt, receþt, phone and property cell phone the cell envelope containing On contain¡ng the the envelupe 6:30pm, the at approximately approximately 6:30pm, the same same date, dat€, at On the inside of the located1nd container, marked #4, located inside of PRU #4, in msrked PRU storage contiãiner, môunted storage wall mounted loôked wall in aa locked in Office Prosecutor’s NJ' Monmouth Freehold, NJ. the in Freehold, of Unit Office County Professional Prosecutoros County the Responsibility of Monmouth Unit Professional Responsibility were both secured secured were both the the cell receipt phone and property receipt and property cell Ph9n9 containing the On :26pm, the envelope 2015, at approximately envelope containing approximately II :26pm,the 6,2015,at Ocrober 6, On ()cluber l’rosccutor’s Monmouth County P¡osecufor's and placed marked PRU the Monmouth county placed in in the #4 and PRU #4 storage container, was containei marlied the storaþ from the removed from was removed 15-0577-6-1. # item with marked and vault evidence main Office Office main evidence vault and marked with item # 15-A577-6-1. continue. Invest igation to to continue. J Reporting"Dete*cEyo Reporling Detectivo DANIEL BOZZA JR. JR. DANIELJJ BOZZA > Reporting Signature Reporting Detective Signature @fut"a vs ofRepor1 Date Date of Repol I0/09/2015 I0/09/2015 Supervisor Signaturt Supervisor Signature '- * ''v $ filfilf \&-D 4þþ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0013 0013 Filed 08/04/16 Page 15 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:1 -cv-0 043-BR_M-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1050 \l()\\l()l' 'l ('()l'\"l‘\ ’R().\I-.('I ' ‘()R‘\ (ll-‘I-’ ('l". @ l- Va‘ Ha: \ Page I o{l I 2. File 2. Unit Unit Filefl Gll5-00172 clt5-00172 1. I. Unit Unit _GENl3_.RAL INVESTIGATION 4. Agency(s) 4, Case Agency(s) rs __ 6. 6. N.1."s. 5. 5. Crime # _ 7. Time & Time Date & 7. Reported Reported Date Q POLICY REVIEW REVIEW 9. Location Looation of Crime 9. 0773 1017 NJ HOWELL, NJ 07731; HOWELL, NJ HOWELL, NJ #33 HOWELL, HIGHWA Y #33. STATE HIGHWAY 01 7 STATE _ 09/O5/201516219 091051201516:19 _V 8.Incident Date Time Date & & Time . ”_ _ Reporting Crime: Incident // Crime: Person Reporting Incident 10, Person 11. I I. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Info(s) Person Inf‘o(s): 12. Person 13. 13, Address(s): Address(s) 14. 14. Victim(s): Viotim(s)l 15. Info(s): Person Info(s): 15. Person 16. Address(s): 16, Address(s): I8. Weapon Weapon Used: 17. Properly: Missing Property: I ?. Stolen Stolcn // Missing \\lili\il\ì provide D..epartment provide Police Department about September Township Police 2015, I requested On Howell Township that the the Howell requested that 16,2015,I September 16, or abour On or or attempted scene utilized on either that were masks CIr attempted of scene on different utilized the show either which were of the that types of masks examples mäsks, which show the different types examples of the masks, of made be disc telephone audio that any telephone an of made It disc be utilized on scene. It was on scene. to requested that an audio additionally requested was additionally be utilized to be Harden' of Timothy Timothy Harden. grandrnother of the grandmother Dispatch and conversations Green, the and Mary Mary Green, Townshipbispatch Howell Township between Howell conversat¡ons between of conversations audio files conversations files of (3).audio three (3) 2015, 1 received containing three On or disc containing an audio audiCI disc received an 2!,2015,1 September 21, about September On or about of the four received also examples I masks that (4) of that Green. the masks between the Mary Green. I also received four (4) examples and Mary Dispatch and Howell Township Township Dispatch the Howell between Two blood. from (2) Harden (2) spitting Two and stop F.M'l‘s provided on Howell Township Timothy Flarden from spitting blood. the Howell stop Timothy ro try and scene to on scene Township EMTsiroviåed rhe ofthe masks masks are example 'Iúese two two (2) Particulate Respiiators. N95 Particulate (2) rnasks are example masks of the.Respirators. These oftlte as NgS are identified identifie¿ as masks are of the masks on any Police him spitting blood to Police in Harden blood on an stop from.spitting him from attempt that on mask stop to was Timothy an attempt placed Hardenin original original mask that was plac€d on Timotþ was one Police Howell Department the was one from Township received Department that Police mask third was The Township Oflicer Howell the from or bystander. fn" *,¡ø mask thai was received Ofñcer or bystander. used be on to Timothy mask was Timothy rubber used on clear This to be with mask attempted mask was rubber oxygen clear tubing. oxygen mask with tubing. This clear rubber clear n¡bbeioxygen is aa hospital Howell mask. The The Howell him. The surgical mask. style surgical on him. hospital style musk is last mask placed on actually placeã The last Harden, was never never aotually but was Harden, but utilized. be to nor attempted utilized on not to be utilizEd. it but scene, attempted this was nor on mask, provided this mask, but it was not utilized Department þrovided Township Police Department Township Police attempted into the the main main placed into and four were then then placed (4) example masks were On example masks 2015, the audio four (4) disc and audio disc September er 23, Z3,20l5,the On Septemb Office. evidence County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office. the Monmouth Monmouth County vault at at the evidence vault Investigation continue. to continue. Investigation to Reporting Delective Reporting Detective JR. DANIEL BO7.ZATR, DANIELJ.1 BOZZA Signature Reporting Detective Oetective Signature Tepòrting .5 @fu"a Date Repoú Date of of Report 09/23/2015 09t2312015 Signature Supervisor Supcrvisor Signature rlÆ4.È Brå¿6 /x£e£fl'_;_.,,; Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0014 0014 Filed 08/04/16 Page 16 of 100 PageID: M TJB Document 62-1 62 1 Filed Page D. 1051 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB ()l{'s ()l" “l('l7. ’Rl).\ 7('l"l ol;l"l( l. H (‘()l \‘l'\\ Il'll( )sli( t 'l ()l{'S .\l()\'\l()l \to\\lot SIlll(ot\l @ .l. nit Unit 2. GENERAL INVI-.'STl('i/tTl0N TION 4. Agency(s) 4. Case Agency(s) ‘ Uut rm ## Gl15-00I72 GI t5-00172 Page loJl ~.():-. l‘ .\.. J Promis# # 3. 3, Promis _ __ 7. 7 6. 5. Crime 6. N.J.S. N.LS. Crime POLICY REVIEW POLTCY REVIEW 9. Crime of Crime Localion of 9. Location NJ 0773]; 1017 HOWELL'NJ 0773I; NJ HOWELL, HOWEI,T,, NJ #33, HOWELL, STATE HICHWAY #33, 1OI7 STATEHIGHWAY &. Time Reported Date Date & l6:19 _09/05/Q15 09/05/2015 16:19 —8.Incidcnt Dâte & Tirnc LIilcidcnt Date ' Crime: 10. Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident 10. Person Pcrson Reporting 11. Suspect(s) I t. Suspect(s) ‘12. Info(s): Person Info(s): 12. Person I4. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): I 5. Person Person Info(s): -l:«ddVl'9SS(5)§ I 13. 13, Address(s): 16. 16. Address(s): Address(s): 18. Usr:d: 18. Weapon Wcapon Used: I7. Missing Property: Propertyt 17. Stolen Stolcn // Missing \\lì¡ì\ll\l met with with Jeremy Jeremy and 1I met Newman and Ðaniel Newman On 2015, at approximately Detective Daniel :00pm, Detective approximately Il:00pm. 73,2015,at Septemb eî 23, On September The New in Freehold, Jersey. Office Prosecutor’s Jerscy. The New Monmouth Freehold, the in at Ofiìce Couttty DOB_ Proseculor's Hoffman, at ihe Monmouih Coúnty Hoffman, DOB- that incident the Hoffman tlrat regarding from incidenl the statement take Jeremy regard¡ng a this of to was l{offman Jeremy typed r*tltlg ** to take a typed statemeni from purpose of this meeting Harden. on 5, September 5, on September Route 33, Freehold, NJ, at [017 Tímothy Harden, involving Timothy occurred at NJ, involving 33, Freehold, I 0l 7 Route located at Priediane, located at Priedianc, äccincd 2015. 2A15. concluded at and concluded at of Jeremy l:39 pm and six (6) at approximately approximaæly 1:39 The began at HofTnran began Jeremy Hoffman (6) page typed st¿tement of typed statement The six dated Hoffman, of the statement Jeremy refer to datcd details l{offman' 2:27pm, without incident. incident. For Foi details refer tCI the statement of Jeremy approximately approximately'Z:ilpm,without 2015 at September at 1:39pm. I:39pm. 23,2015 September 23, Investigation oontinue. to continue. Investigation to Repo_r_t-i ng Detective Detectivc Reponing D.-XNIEL JJ BOZZA JR DÂI\IEL BOZZA JR. Reporting Signarure Delective Signature Reporting Detective @frq"6 "6 Date of Report RePort Date of 09/23/2015 09n3n0ß Supervisor Signature Supervisor Signature 1ã¿. B6 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0015 0015 Filed 08/04/16 Page 17 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1052 \l()\\l()l‘I'll ('()l \‘I'\ @ '1} ‘.!j_ ' 2.l nitFilc# # G115-00172 c¡ 15.00172 V l.Unit t. Unit (iliNiS!U\L INVESTIGATION ÕN INV ’R()Sl-‘('l"l'()R'.\()1-'1-l('F .' {'7' /'I Page Page I otl .? rmis Gavel Gavel if __ Case Agency(s) 4. Agency(s) 4. Casc 7. Reported Time Date at Time Reported Date ?. 16:19 09/05/2015 16:19 09/05/2015 ’ ' 5, 5, 6. N_J.S. N.J.S. 5. Crime REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW of Crime 9. Crime L Location of Nl 07731 A1731;; 1017 HOWELL' NJ NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, STATE IÛGIIWAY #33, 10r? STATEHIGHWAY 8.1ncident Date Time Dale & & Time _ _ 10. Incidcnt // Crime: Crime: ReportÍng Incident Person Reporting 10. Person 11. Suspect(s) I l. Suspeot(s) 12. Info(s): 12. Person Person Info(s): 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): 15. Person Person 1nfo(s): 137. Address(s): 13. I‘-ddfl‘-55(5): 16. Addres(s): 16. Address(s): - 18. Weapon Used: Uscd: 17. PropertY: / Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen /Missing \ \l{ll \ I l\ I I County ôf the Monmouth County the Monmouth Newman of Dani EI Newman Detective Daniel On 9 :00am, Detective September 23, at approximately approximstely 9:00am, 2A I 5 at 23, 2015, 0n September Prosecutor’s Monmouth the County s at Prosecutor' County DOB-—. with the Monmouth and I at met Prosecutor’ss Office, Edgar Ryan Edgar, Office, and I met with Ryan Prosçcutor' from statement Edgar Ryan take a Edgar to Ryan typed was from this statement of The meeting tâke typed Office p urpose of this meeti ng was to Jersey The purpose Freehold, New New Jersey. Offïce inn Freehold, Timothy involv tng Timothy at 1017 N J, involving J 3, Freehold, Freehold, NJ, Route 33, incident I 0 I 7 Route located at at Priediane, Pried lâne, located regarding that occurred occurred at ident that the tnc regarding the 2015. Harden, 5,2015. September 5, on September Harden, on DOB-N at concluded at and concluded of Ryan 9:45am and statement of approximately 9:45am at approximately The began at Edgar began Ryan Edgar (8) page typed typed statement eight (8) The eight dated of September Edgar, the statement Ryan dated September to refer details refer to the statement of Ryan Edgar, For details incident. For without incident. approximately ií:Ota., without åpproximãtefy 11:08am, 9:45am. 2015 at 23, 23,2015 at 9l45am. Investigation to continue. oontinue. lnvestigation to Reporting Delectirc Reporting Delecrixc JR. DANIELJ BOLL.\,'R, DANIEI,.I my/.'/...s. ' Reporting Signature Dcfective Signature Rcporting Detective ' .6 @fts¡"6, Date Report Date of ofReport 09/23/2015 09123120ls ‘Supervisor Sígnature Supcrvisor Signature rdÆúþea /’¢:9;Q¢__p¢,aé Prosecutor's 0016 Prosecutor's File File 0016 Filed 08/04/16 Page 18 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BR&TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1053 ol'l;l( l' ('( )t \ I’I \' \l()\\I()lIII l'lì( )sl'.( t 'l olì's ()l<'l"l(‘ -' \ l’R()sI~'.(.'l”l'()R‘.\‘ \lo\ \lot l ll ('(II“\' @ \. .,.,i,ri,i;'.i it File ## G115-00172 I 5.00 t72 1. l. Unit Unit GENERAL lNVl-LS' 'l(i/\'l'lt’)N , J_«‘._' J,’ /‘I' t'tlìii l,' i i /‘1 Page t of I 35 Gavel Gavel ii# __ _ 4. Agency(s) Crse Agency(s) 4. Case 3."cR?e 5. 7. Date & & Time 7 Reported Date 09/05/2015 16:'19 0910512015 15:19 6. 6. N.J.S. N.LS. REVIEW POLICY POLICYRF,VIEW 9. Location Crime Location of of Crime O?73I; 1017 NT 07731; HOWELL, NJ NJ HOWELL, #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ 1OI7 STATEHIGHWAY STATE HIGHIfTAY #33, 8.Incident Date & & Time S.Incident Date IO. Crimc: Incidcnt // Crime: Reporting Incident Person Reporting 10. Person 11. I t. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Info(s): Person Info(s): 12. Person "13. Addrcss(s)l I3. Addres:-1(5): 14. Victim(s): 14, Victim(s): 15. l‘o(s): 15. Person Person In Info(s): 16. 16. Addre-ss(s): Addrcss(s): 18. Weapon Used: Used: 17. PropertY: Missing Property: Stolen // Missing 17. Stolen \\l{ll\ll\r met with Benjamin with Benjamin and II met Perez and Rosendo Perez Detective Rosendo I :2Opm, Detective September ât approximately approx imately 8:20pm, 2A I 5, at 22, 2015, September 22, The New in Office Freehold, Jersey. Prosecutor’s Jersey The New the Monmouth Freehold, at Bleefeld, County Prosecutor' Offrce tn at the Monmouth County DOB T, Bleefeld, DOB E that incident the Bleefeld from regarding ident that tnc the statement Benjamin to take take aa typed typed statement from Benjamin B eefe ld regarding was to of this th ts meeting meet ing was purpose purpose of on 5, Harden, September ptember Timothy on Se NJ, occurred involving Timothy Harden, Freeho ld, NJ involving 33 , Freehold, Route 33, located at ât 1017 1 0 I 7 Route at Priediane, Priedi ane, located occu rred at On On S 2015. 2015. at approxim-ately.8:25pm concluded at at Bleefcld began and concluded approximately 8:25pm and The began at (6) page typed Benjamin Bleefeld of Benjamin statement of typed statement The six six (6) dated of Blccfeld, the statement refer Benjamin to dated details Bleefeld, For incident. Benjamin without g:îSprn, of to the søtement refer details 9:15pm, For without incident. approximately approximatàli 2015 at at 8:25pm. 8:25pm. September 22,2ALS September 22, Investigation to continue. continue. Investigation to Reporting Detective Dctcctive Reporting JR. DANIEL J BOZZA BOZZ,A¡R. DANTELJ l)etecli\Ie Signature Reporting. Signature Reponin g l)ctqctive r3i °5 Q,&"t ' of Report Date Date oFReport 09/23/2015 09n3n0rs Supervisor Signature Supcrvisor Signature ,(Æfi**aa /;(.ee;t2¢,.-—' =t=£36 Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0017 0017 Filed 08/04/16 Page 19 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1054 'l I I (‘()lI\"li\ ol"l;l('l ('ot sl I l’R()S -‘,(‘ll'l‘()R‘.\ \l()\:\‘l()l l'l{osl.( ti'l()l{'\ ()I" ‘ (' ’. \t( )\,1'l( )t 'l' @ \_ ;,..;i ' _GIiNF.RALlNVESTlGA'l' ON t 11/ .t! -.'. - ‘.', 1/3; /I ,-A, ili l't)l;,' Ì, ,~,/_/T, mllnitilefl Filc # ons-00172 6r I 5-001 72 Page Page Iofl lofl ts _ __ Z _ T Case Agency(s) 4. Agcncy(s) 4, Case 7. 6. 6. N.J.S. N.J.S. 5. Crime Crime 5. POLICY REV¡EW POLICY REVIEW 9. 9. Location of Crime NJ HOWELL, NJ 07731; 0773I; HOWELL, NJ 1017 #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ STATE HICHWÁY #33, t0 I7 STATEHIGHWAY . _ 8.lncident Date & & Time ll.lncidenl Date Time Reported Date Date & & Time 09/05/20l5 16:19 A9ß512015 l6:l9 _. _ I 10. Crimc: lncídent // Crime: Reporting Incident 10, Person Person Reporting ll. I l. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. lnfo(s)l Person lnfo(s): 12. Person 14. Victim(s): 14, Victim(s): I5. Person lnfo(s)l 15. Person lnfo(s).T- 13. 13. Address(s): Addrcss(s): I6. ló. Address(s): Address(s): I8. Weapon Used: lE, Weapon 17. PropertYl Missing Property: 17, Stolen Stolen I/ Missing \\l.il(\ll\l with Michael Michae met with and I met Rosendo Perez Perez and pm Detective Detecti ve Rosendo September 22, 2015. at approximately 6:155 pm, The New in Freehold, Jersey. Office T he Jersey Prosecutor’s New County Prosecutor' $ offi ce n Freehold, Johnstonc. DOB _at the Monmouth County that the incident Johnstone Michael th regarding the ncident at from M ichae J o hnstone regard ng statement from typed statement to take take aå typed vvas to this meeting meet¡ng was purpos e of of this purpose on 5, Harden, September ptem ber 5, Timothy Harden on Se rlvo v lng Timothy N J involving at Priediane, J 3 Freehold, Freehold, NJ, occurred Route 33, I 0 I 7 Route at 1017 located at Pried IAn e, located occurred at On 2015. 2015. pm and concluded at at and concluded approximately 6:40 Michael Johnstone at approximately began at The Johnstone began typed statement of Michael pagetyped statement of The seven seven (7) page ÍÍ0 dated Michael Johnstone, of statement the dated fer to Johnstone, details For re Michael incident. of without approximately :ôOpm,ïithout incident. For detaits refer to the statement approximatety'f8:00pm, 2015 at 6:40pm. 22, at 6l40Pm. September 22,2015 September Investigation to continue. continue. Investigation to Reporting Detcctive Reporting Detective DANIEL JR. BOZZA JR. DANIEL JJ BOZZA Reporting Signahrre Detective Signature neporting Detective ,& @72*"t Date of Repon Report Dâte of o9/23/2015 091ßl2aß Supervisor Sígnature Supervisor Signature rå¿ /76__'e:Q¢F,,‘aé_ 4Æh-* Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0018 0018 Filed 08/04/16 Page 20 of 100 PageID: Page D: 1055 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed JJB \t()\\lot l ll ( otì.i\ I \lii I'lì()sl (t t'()lt'\ ()l;l' l('l: @ _ I li, ' i't!!;; .nilFile # File it __g1_1§-00172 crr 5-001 72 Unit‘ 1. L Unit __{_il-2Nl:‘.RAl. INVI-lSTlGATlON 4. Àgcncy(s) Casc Agency(s) 4. Case Page I of I 3. # Promis Gavel *4 3. Promis 7. &. Time Time Date & 7 Reported Rcported Date J a 6. 6. N..l.S. N,J,S 5. C¡i¡ne 5. Crime REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW 9. Location of Crime Crime Location of 9. NJ 07731: 07731i NJ HOWELL, HOWELL' NJ 1017 HOWELI,, NJ #33, HOWELL, HIGHWAY #33, STATE HIGHWAY l0l7 STATE J-Blncident Date Time Ðate & & Time 09/05/2015 6:1 9 a9t05n0 5 16:19 _ __ _ ’ M 10. Crimc: Inoident // Crime: Reporting Incident Person Reporting 10. Person 11. Suspect(s) I 1. Suspect(s) 12. lnfo(s); Person lnfo(s): 12. Person l3._Address(s): 13, Addrcss(s)l 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): 15. Person Person Info(s): 16. t6. Address(s‘): Address(s): l8. Wcapon llscd’ 18, Weapon 17. ProPertY: / Missing Property: Stolsn /Missing 17. Stolen \ \lil( \ l\ I and II met with Joseph Joseph met with Wei sbrot and Brian Weisbrot Detective Brian 9:00am, Detective approximâtely 9:00am, at approximately September 20 5, at 22, 20l5, September 22, New in Freehold, Jersey. Office New J ersey The The Prosecutor's Freehold, Monmouth tn the Office at —, at the Monmouth County County Prosecutor' Zimmennan, DOBT, Zimmerman DOB that incident the Zimmerman that regarding ident from the lnc ing regard statement Joseph take typed statement from Joseph Zimmerman to take aa typed was to meet¡ng was this meeting of this purpose of 5, September 5 Harden. on on September Route Timothy Harden. 1017 at lnvo lving Timothy located NJ involving occurred at Priediane, Freehold, NJ, 3 Freehold, Ro ute 333. 0 I 7 at located umed al Priediane, occ On On 2015. 201 5. concluded at at at approximately and concluded 9.:29arn and approxinrately 9:29am began at The Zimmerman began of Joseph Joseph Zimmerman statement of (6) page typed typed statement six (6) The six dated Zimmcnnan. of dated stalemcnl Joseph the statement of Joseph Zirnmerman' 10:1 lam, toihe refer to det¿ils refer Êor details incident. For without incident. approximately lâm, without approximatàfylO'l 9:29am. 2015 at September 22, 201 5 at 9 29am. September 22, Investigation continue. to continue. Investigation to Reporting Delective Reporling Detective J BOZZA JR. DANIEL DANIELJBOZZAJR. Reporting Signature Dctective Signature neponñg Detective ' ,£ q6 oi‘§e—pori D2116 Datc'ol'RePort 09/23/2015 09l23lzltl5 Supervisor Signature Supervisor Signature‘ /£&£¢_F_:#‘ 4æ/l*t;l.r-S : Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0019 0019 Filed 08/04/16 Page 21 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BBM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1056 'tol{'s ()H“I(' ". olìl''l( ( ( )t \ \l()\'\l()l” l'll()\l ('t‘l ' ‘()R‘.\’ t\ ’R().\lf( \ ‘\' \to\ \lot "l llH (’()l @ .v.-.///',i; \¡ ""i \, -1.l. Unit Un¡t \-, , ,3' i!! H i'tt,.\._, "' Gl15-00172 GI15-00172 (JP-.N illAl. l'NVESTlGA1'l0N 4. Agency(s) Casc Agency(s) 4. Case __ ’ _fl _ 7. & Time Date & 7. Reported Date 6. ó. N.J.S. N.I.S. 5. 5. Crime [of] I of I Props iv 3. ls 3. 2. Unit Filc #I ‘ Page Page POLICY REVIEW POLICY REVIEW 9. Location of of Crime Crime 07731; NJ 07731; 1017 HOWELI,' NJ NT HOWELL, #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ HIGHWAY #33, STATE HIGHWAY TOI? STATE _ 09/05/2015 L619 0910512015 16:19_ __ Bjncident Date & & Time Time 10. Crime: Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident Person Reporting 10. Person Address(_s_): Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Info(s): 12. Person Percon Info(s): l3. I3. Addrcss(s): 14. 14. Victim(s): Victim(s): 15. Info(s): 15. Person Person Info(s)'. I6. Addrcss(s) 16, Address(s): k 11. I l. 18. l7. PropertY: Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen // Missing Weapon Used: Used: \\l{ll\ll\l wirh Joseph J oseph met with and II met Newman and Daniel Newman On Detective Daniel 21, 2015, 5 :45pm Detective åt approximately approximate ly 5:45pm, I 5, at On September SentemberZl.20 The purpose New in Jersey. Freehold, Office The Prosecutor’s Jersey New the Monmouth at Wocio. County Prosecutor' s Ofïice tn Freehold, wocro. DOB at the Monmouth County uuÞ _. r. occurred at at that occurred nc ident that the incident regarding the w octo regarding of from Joseph Joseph Wocio meeting was statement from typed statement take aa typed to take was to of this this meeting 2015. 5, on September 20 1 5 Harden, 5 Timothy NJ , involving involving Timotþ Harden, on September Priediane, Route 33, F reehold, NJ, 33 t Freehold, at 1017 i 0 I 7 Route located at Priediane, located and concluded at rJ/ocio hogan concluded at 6:06pm and at approximately approximately 6:06pm bcgan at The Joseph Wocio (7) page typed statement of Joseph statement of seven (7)pagetyped The seven dated of Wocio, September the Joseph refer to details rcfur to the statement without incident. stâtement of Joseph Wocio, dated September For àetails incident. For approximately O:f*,ïithout approximatety'i7:03pm, 2015 at 21, 6:06pm. 21,2015 at 6:06pm. to continue. Investigation continue. Investigation to Reporting Deteotivc Rep,orting Detective JR. DANIEL BOZ;ZAJRDANIELJJ nozz». Reporting Signature Detcctive Signature Re¡nrting Detective ,6 Date Report of Report Þate of 09/23/2015 a9n3noß Sup—cr\isur Signature Supcn isor Signature /(‘£2z â6 4,, ad, Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0020 0020 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB MJJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 22 of 100 PageID: Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1057 ‘If ()f"lrl(.1' ( ()t .\"l'\' l'()ll's ()l“ ~'l( )sl'( t ' ‘()R'.\ \l()\\l()l' l'lì( ).\‘lC(‘l \ I \ ’R( \t( )\ \l( )t Ill ("'01 @ Unle File ## G115-00172 Gt t5-00172 3. I Prom Gave! It 3, Promis 2. Unit 1. l.Unit GENERALL INVESTIGATION TION 4. Agency(s) 4. Case Agency(s) ___t_ __ __7 I 75.5. Crime 6. 6. N.J.S. N.J.S. 7. 1 Time Reported Date & & Time 8.[ncident & Time Timc S.Incident Date & NJ 0773Ii 07731; HOWELL, HOWÞLL'N' 10. Crime: Incidcnt / Crime: Reporting Incidentl I0. Person Person Reporting Address(s): T Suspect(s) 12. Info(s): Person Info(s): 12, Person 13. 13. Address(s) 14. 14. Victim(s): Victim(s); 15. Info(s)l 15. Person Person Info(s): 16. 16. Address(s): Address(s): Suspect(s) ’ ' 9. Location C¡ime of Crime Location of 9, 1017 N' HOWELI,, NJ #33, HOWELL, HIOHWAY #33, STATE HIGHWAY IOl? STATE 11. ll. V 09/05/2015 16:19 0910512015 16:19 POLICY REVIEW POLICY REVIEW I Page [of] I of I ::ìl'tit .,__.,. .., ., it! t;..': _— I 17. Missing Property: Property: 17. Stolen Stolcn I/ Mising I8. Weapon Used: 18. Weapon \\l{l{\ll\l Ladue, with Philip Phil rp Ladue, met with and II met Perez and Rosendo Perez tembcr 22 I , 2015, 5am Detective Detective Rosendo On Sc 0: I Sam, at approximately approximately 10:1 20 5, at On Scptember this of The New th s Jersey. of purpose in Freehold, The Office Prosecutor’s New Jersey Monmouth Freehold, ¡n at the County Prosecutor' s Ofüce the Monmouth County occurred at Priediane, that incident the ianeo Pried occurred at Ladue that from regarding incident the statement tng take Philip meeting typed statement from Phi ip Ladue regard was to to take aa typed meeting was { 2015. 20 5 Septembe r 5. on September Harden, on Freehold, NJ, located Timothy Harden, nvolving Timothy NJ involving Route 33, 33 Freehold, 0 I 7 Route at 1017 located at DOBh ooelat concluded at approximately 10:31am a¡d concluded l0:31 am and The five began-at Ladue began Philip Ladue of Philip (5) page typed typed statement statement of The five (5) dated of Ladue, the statement Philip refer to details For PhilipLadue,dated without incident. Fordetailirefertoihestatementof at 11:15am, f f :fSam,withoutincident. approximateiyát 2015 at September at 10:31am. 10:3lam' 21,2015 September 21, approximately approximately to continue. Investigation continue. Investigation to Reporting Dctectivc Reporting Detective BOZZA JR. DANIEL DANIEL JJBOT'ZAJR. Reporting S¡gnatute Detective Signature Reporting Detective °6 @14"" Date Report of Report Date of 09/21/2015 09l2lnaß 1 Supervisor Signature Signarure -SupeÑisor /zccei raê Z #3 hag, rlL#/i-# Prosecutor's File Prosecutor's File 0021 0021 Filed 08/04/16 Page 23 of 100 PageID: -TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1058 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB - - - ()R'.\ ()l“l"l( ‘R()S 7.(‘l" ol"l"l( IfI ('()t \ \ ()\\l()l ¡'lìosl ( t t()lì's \lo\\tol lill l'll ('()l'\'l“\ t\ ' @ .1 1,; ' _- j'r ;'11:," i 1'1 me Oavel # 3. ‘'~”*”‘ “1.u....— l. Unit 2. # 2. 11:11 0115-00172 cil5-00I72 GENERAL INVI-‘.S'l' (jA‘ 'l0t\'__ IN V4. Agency(s) d. Case Casc Agency(s) 6. N,J.S. 6. N.J.S. _’ Page Page 1°./1 I of ) “m “i _ 7. 7 " 5. 5, Crime Crime POLICY POLICY REVIEW REVIEW of Crime 9. Crime I¡cation of 9. Location 0773Ii NJ 07731; [017 HOWELL, NJ NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, IOIT STATEHIGHWAY STÀTE HiGHWAY #33, Reported Date & Time Time Date & " 8.Incident & Time Tirnc Date & S.Incident Date ' 09/05/2015 l6tl9 09/0512015 16:19 _ _ _ Crime: l0. Reporting Incident Incident // Crimel 10. Person Person Rcporting - Suspcct(s) Suspcct(s) I2. lnfo(s): Person Info(s): 12, Person 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): 15. Person Person Info(s): 11. ll. I 18. t8. 17. PruPertY: Stolen // Missing Missing Property: 17. Stolen \ \ .il{ \ Il\ _ 13. Address(s): 13. Address(s): I6. Address(s): 16. Address(s): Weapon Used: Used: I Casey Emilius, Em l USt Detective wt th Casey met with and II met Percz and ve Rosendo Rosendo Perez On 5 :20pm, Detecti at approximately approximate ly 5:20pm, September I7, 20 I 5, at I 7 2015, On September of The New this Jersey. The purpose of this Ofäce in ln Freehold, Freehold, New Jersey DOB — at the Prosecutor' s Office County Prosecutor’s the Monmouth Monmouth County at Priediane, occurred that incident the at o Priediane, Emilius occurred that from regarding nc ident the statement take Casey a regardin to lius ¿t meeting typed state ment from Casey Em was to take typed meeting was 5, 2015. 20 l 5. Septem ber 5. on September Route 33, NJ,t involving Harden, on located Timothy Harden, tnvo lving Timothy Freehold, NJ 33, Freehold, at 1017 I 0 I 7 Route located at noglat concluded at at and concluded approximately 5:22pm 5:22pm and at âpproximately The began at Emilius begun of Casey Casey Emilius (6) page typed statement of typed statement six (6) The six dated of Emilius, September state.-ntent Casey the dated September refer to details Emilius, For of Casey incident. 6:20pm, without incident. Fór details refer to thc statcmcrrt approximately approximatà ry^A:ãApm,w¡thout 2015 at 17, 5:22pm. at5:22pm. 17,2015 Investigation continue. to continue. fnvestigation to Reporting Detective Reporting Detective N JR. DANIELJBOZZA DANIEI,J TOZZAIR, Reporting Signature l.rctecllve Signature Reporting Detective S ,5 @fu"e of Report Date Report Date of 09/21/2015 09ntn0ß ‘ Supervisor Sign¡ture Supervisor Signature 4,e./iÈ /‘flea Z dflaé rÉ¡¿ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0022 0022 Filed 08/04/16 Page 24 of 100 PageID: 0359 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3I15-CV-08043-BRM-I.J_B Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1059 Case UH-' ('l" I ('()l'.\" i\' lol{'s()l;l;l( \I().\\ (ll l)lìosl.( t l'() {'S \l\ ’R().\'lC(‘l lll('ol \t()\)l()t lll @ \ r ,',lrl j 'l,li , :i ,"t I'i.t:,': \ Un 1. 1. Unit *0 GENERAL lNVE.S'l'lGAT1ON TION ram isis Gav] Cavel ## it 2. Unit File 4: G115-00172 GI15"00172 H _ A 4. Agency(s) Case Agency(s) 4. Case ' 7. ‘ 6. 6. N.J.S. 5. 5 Crime Page ) of I Rt:[)cIrIt:(l Date && Time Time 09/05/2015 1ó:19 091051201 5 16:19 POLICY REVIDW POLICY REVIEW ofCrime 9. Crime 9. Location of 0773 l; NJ 07731; NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ 1017 HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, STATE HIGHW AY #33, t0l 7 STATEHIGHWAY _ _ 8.Incident Time Date & Time S.Incidcnt Date _ _ — 10. Person Repoiting Crime: Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident 10, Person I ll. Suspcct(s) I 1. Suspccl(s) 12. Info(s): Person lnfo(s): 12. Person 13. Address(s): 13. Address(s): 14. Victim(s) 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): Pqson lnfo(s): 15. Person 16. Add¡ess(s): 16. Address(s): _ _ _ 18. Weapon Used: Used: 17. PropcrtYi Missing Property: Stolen / Missing I 7. Stolcnl \\l{lt\ll\l r County Monm outh County the Monmouth of the Perez of Rosend o Perez Detective Rosendo On 3 r40pm, Detective approx¡mately 3:40pm, at approximately 20 5" at 7 2015, On September September 17, Prosecutor’s Monmouth the County at Prosecutor' s DOB-— County Monmouth the at with Mahajan, l met and Prosecutor’s Jeffrey Mahajan, DOBo ffìce, and met with Jeffrey Prosecutor' Office, the statement regarding the conduct a regarding to typed was statement this of meeting The to conduct ryped Office purpose o f th ts meeting was Jersey The purpose N ew Jersey. Freehold, New OffTce inn Freehold, Harden. Timothy involving Freehold. Harden. NJ, 33. Route Timothy [0 7 I incident at 0 7 Route 3 3. F reeho ld NJ lnvo lving located at Priediane, located at Priediane, lnc ident at at conclucled at and concluded 3:46pm and begun at approximately 3:46pm statement of at approximately Jeffrey Muhajan The Mahajan began of Jeffrey (6) page typed typed statement six (6) The six 2015 dated 17, September 2015 17, of Mahajan, Septenrber dated the statement Jeffrey to tñe sratJment oiieffrey Mahajan, without incident. Re-fer to incident. Refer approximately 4:5lpm, without approximately 4:51pm, at details. for complete complete details. 3:46pm for at 3:46pm Investigation continue. to continue. lnvestigation to Reporting Detective Reporting Detective DANIEL JR. BOZZA JR. DANIEL JJ BOZZA Reporting Signature Detcctive Signature Reporting Detective Wr"o Report Date ofReport Date of 09/21/2015 û9ntn0L5 7 Supervisor Signarure Supervisor Signature‘. tat’. r{Æ/ -*øa nc=e.4.a¢_,=»*+- Prosecutor's File 0023 0023 Prosecuto/s File Filed 08/04/16 Page 25 of 100 PageID: M-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1060 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB - - - () “ “ ( "F. \l().\.\1()l \t( )\ \l( ) I "I411 ('01 \' '\ ’R().\i *.(’l ' ‘()R‘.\ @ 1. l. Unit Unit 2. 2. Unit: 0115-00172 cIt 5-00 172 ' INVESTIGATION (JEN!-.l{Al. INVESTIGA G 4. Case Agency(s) Page Page I oll Pros vel 3. Pmmis ‘ _ 1 _ ‘" Time 7. Rcported Date Date & Time 7. Reported ‘ 6. NJ.S. .s. 5. 5, Crime Crirne REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW 9. 9. Location of Crime NJ 07731; 07731; #33, HOWELL, [017 HOWELL' NJ NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ HIOHWAY#33, IOIT STATE S'I'ATE HIGHWAY Person 8.Incident Time S.Incident Date Date & & Time 09/05/2015 16:19 09/05/2015 16:19 — 10. Crime: Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident 10. Person Reporting Address(s-): ll. Suspect(s) I l. Suspect(s) 12. Info(s); 12, Person Person Info(s): 13. 13, Address(s): 14. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): -15. Person Info(s): Info(s): 15. Person 16. 16, Address(s): Address(s): 18. tE, Weapon Used: 17. PropertY: Missing Property: Stolen // Missing 17. Stolen \ \l{l{ \ I l\ ‘ I with John John A. Bree, A. Bree, and II met met wirh Weisbrot and Brian Weisbrot Detecti ve Brian On 9:45am, Detective at approximately approximately 9:45am, September 17, I 7 2015, 2 0 I 5, at On September of The New purPose of this this ersey The purpose Freehold, New JJersey. tn Freehold, Office in County Prosecutor’s DOB _ at Prosecutor' s Office Monmouth CounÇ the Monmouth aÎ the Route 1017 33, located at Route 33 at Priediane, incident I 01 7 at the looated riediane, statement at P conduct incident regarding to meeting typçd statement regarding the was to cond uct a& typed meeting was Freehold, Harden Timothy Harden. involving Timothy NJ, involving Freehold, NJ, DOBN concluded at at and concluded pruxilnalcly9:47am 9:47-ant and approximately at ap began at Bree began The A, Bree typed statement John A. of John statement of (7) page pagetyped seven (7) The seven 2015 dated 17, A. John September Bree, f 17,2015 Septembet statement 0 the dated to Refer Bree, without incident. incident. Refer to the statement oiJohn A. approximately irizl"*, ïithout approximatefi 11:29am, 9:47am for at complete details. details. for complete at9:47am Investigation continue. to continue. lnvestigation to Reporting Detcctirc Reportiog Deleclixc __H F JR. DANII-‘.l. llozz-\.lR. DANlIit, .1J no7.7..\ 7 Z Si gnature Reporting Detcctivc Signature Rcporting Detective S .6 @fu"a Date of Report Report Date of 09/21r2o1s 09Dtnali MSu_pervEor Signature Supcrvisor Signature 1€/lrÆ/F /’(£%_:._:g‘aé' Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0024 0024 Filed 08/04/16 Page 26 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1061 \l()\.\l()l Ill ('01 \' '\ I’ {().\'l-'.('l 'l'()R'H ()l" "l(‘l'i @ \ , F it GENERAL INVESTIGATION IN 4. Agency(s) 4. Case Case Agency(s) 6. 6. NJ.S. N.J.S. "' 5. 5. Crime Críme I oll 3. 3. Promis Pronris Gnvcl fl —_ ## 2. Unit Gt cl 1r 5.00172 5-00t 72 I. t. Unit Page I _ _ __ 7. & Time Tin¡e Date & 7. Reported Reported Date 09/05/2015 ß:19 09l05DAß 16:19 T POLICY REVIEW POL¡CY REVIEW 9. Location of Crime C¡imc l¡cation of NJ 07731; NJ HOWELL, 07731; IOI 7 STATE HOWELL'NJ HOWELL,NJ #33, HOWELL, HIOHWAY #33, srATE HIGHWAY l0t7 8.lncident Date & Time Time Date & >_' _ I0. Cri¡ne: Incidenl //Crime: Reporting Incident Pcrson Reporting I 0. Person ll. Suspect(s) I l. Suspect(s) I2. lnlo(s): Person lnfo(s): 12. Person I-3.3, Address(s): Addrcss(s): I4. Victim(s): 14. Victim(s): I5. Info(s): 15. Person Pcrson lnfo(s): I6. ló. Address(s): Address(s): I l7.TStolen Missing Property: ProPcrtY: 17. Stolen // Missing I8. 18. Weapon Used: Uæd: \\lÌli\ll\l of the Tom Connors Police Township Police Howell Township the Howell Connors of On Leonard Tom Captain Leonard with Captain met with 10, 2015, 2015, II met September 10, Thursday, September On Thursday, I that Connors advise to I Captain that was Connors this meeting was to advise Captain purpoie of of this.meeting The purpose function. The Department Internal Affairs function. Department'lnternalAffairs Tecum Duces with a Service Tecum Subpoena (EMS) with a Subpoena Duces needed to serve Meclical Service (EMS) Emeigency Medical Township Emergency l-lowell Township t¡e llowcll serve the needcd to this matter. regarding regârding this matter. met with w¡th subsequently met and subsequently Township Police Department, and Police Department, II then Howell Township of the the Howell Kudrick of with ChiefAndrew Chief Andrew Kudrick met with then met office. his in Coordinator EMS Doyle, oflice' Howell the Township EMS Coordinator Peggy Peggy Doyle, in his the HowellTownship of EMS records of EMS all records and all for any and matter for this matter regardirrg this Tecum regarding Duces Tecum Doyle with aa Subpoena prov¡ded with Subpoena Duces was provided Doyle was Howell in 20 5, 5, on September in Howell I-larden, of 5,2015, Timothy on Seplernber assistance/tretttnient mediialassistance/treatmeniof Timothy Harden, pËrtaining to to the the medical response resionse pertaining v5'7" Report - V5.7” Care Report titled “Prehospital over a (4) page document "Prehospital Care document titled four (4) a four Township, She turned tumed over Jersey. She New Jersey. Township, New 15166865. PCR#0I and 5—397l5 #201 Incident #2015-39715 and PCR#o115166865. Harden. Timothy, reference Timothy,Incident patient Harden, to patient refcrence to — review. for review. The file for the file in the included in were included documents were The aforementioned afiorementioned documents Rcporti _1tg Detective Detect¡ve Rcporting A K / .g-~ 141-! .\ ROCCO ROCCO SANTORSOI SANTORS()1.'l L ‘Date Report olRcport Date of -Reporting Signature Deteclive Signature Rc¡x'¡ ¡¡g Detective mots o9/1 09lltn0l5 Supervisor Signuture Supervisor Signature tâà 4Æ&# B4, /1€952, ; - . _ . ., _ , ,A___ . .. ._ . _. Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0025 0025 Filed 08/04/16 Page 27 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1062 ('()l’.'\'l’Y ’R().‘\li(‘l"l'()R‘S () 5l" ('l-I \l().\.\ ()l"l‘ l \t()\ll()llll('()tr\l\l'l{(}\¡.,(t'l'()l{'s()l;l"l('l @ ! ,1 VI," /i3 Vt‘ri V‘.,,i,j 1 _ 2.111111 Filc # 2, Unit Fllcfl t, Unit 4. 4. Case Case 3. 3 is1:l# l# GIVIS-00172 cl l5-00172 (iiENl~ItU\L INVl3S'l'lt_i/\Tl0N TION Page lof2 ,.tl ,1 r( )‘’''\l (7 1, J1 AI‘! H \\t‘/ ìi li,ti't)iit __ ’ __ _ 7 _ _ _ Agencyts) 7. & Time Date & ?. Reported Reported Date 6. 6. N.J.S. 5. 5 Crime 8.lncident t Date Date & & Timc 8. 09/05/2015 l6t9 09105t20t5 i6:l9 POLICY REVIEW POLICY REVIEW 9. of Crime 9. Location Location of 07731: HIGHWAY #33. N I 07731; NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ I017 #33. HOWELL, HOWELL' NJ I OI7 STATE STATP HICHWAY 10. Crimel lncident I/ Crime: Pcrson Reporting Reporting incident 10. Person Suspect(s) 12. lnlo(s): Person lnfo(s): 12. Person 13. 13. Addressts): Address(s): l4. Victlm(s): 14. Victim(s): l5. lnfo(s): Person lnfo(s): 15. Person l6. ló. Address(s)‘. Address(s)l ' 11. I l. Suspect(s) I8. 18. I7. PropertY: Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen // Missing \ \tit{ \ I l\ Weapon Used: Used I Ricciardi and Melissa with Melissa Detective Pamela met with and II met g, Z0l Pamela Ricciardi 2()l5. On 6:30pm, Detective i, at at approximately approximately 6:30pm, September 8. On September this of The meeting was Oflice. purpose DOB-—. at the Monmouth County Prosecutor’.-; Sievwright. si;;;iiDoB._'.uttl'.tulon'nouthbountyProsecutor'soffice.Thepurposeofthismeetingwas Harden' Tirnothy Harden. to obtain on Timothy information on background information obtain background to little over over aa dated for for aa little b.ut dated up, but broken up. currently broken she were were currently Ms. and she Harden and Timothy Harden that Timothy repofted that Sievwright reported Ms. Sievwright their for on the that the cause and cause for their on and Ms. Sievwright indicated.that ol'l'again. Ms. Sievwright indicated was always Their relaionship relationship was and-offagåin. on and ul*uyr on year-ir.'iir year. be would Harden Mr. healthy that be healthy She would Ha.rden reported t!a¡.Mr. Hardctfs drinking problem. .S.he reported offagain was Mr. Mr. Flarden's drinking-probtem, relationship was åf .g"in relationship would last money or or that would out of of moncy ran out alcohol binge he ran until he last until then o11 an alcohol weeks and four three binge that to for and go on;; ãnd then weeks good tó four three and óo¿ for for the would to he sober gym for Harden was go to the Mr. when would that he added happened. Ms. something Sievwrigtrt ãdded that when Mr. Harden was sober Ms. Sicvwright bad happened. somi¡hing bad and not not eat eat sleep and not sleep would not he would binge he an alcohol alcohol binge was in in an and eat healthy. hours he was when he three really However, when three hours and eat really healthy. However. l~larden‘s Mr. to has access she that Mr' Harden's Ms. Sievwright reported that she has acoess to have the Sievwright reported if get any food. food. Ms. to get móney to the money not have he did did not if he 4, Septembe¡ 4, on September that on additionallyreported Ms. Sievwright account. monitor the would addhionally reported that and Ms. Sievwrlght bank account bank account and woutd mónitoi the account. event. at the he that was time the event' out he was at the taken during that time not did the she see but during out money tãken Harden any Mr. paid, but she did not see 2015, Mr. Harden got paid, 2015, Ms' 2l 2015. Ms. August 21, on August slïEd on that started binge that week binge two week on aa two was on Ms. Mr. Harden Harden was that Mr. reported that Sievwright reported '2015'about Ms. Sievwright that and 2015 argued they about 24, argued about they that and or home her on August at 24,2015 Harden August was Mr. stated that Sievwright thai Mr. Harden was at her home on or about Sievwright statJd text message on August or about about August on or to Mr. l-larden by text spoke l? l-larden by event. festival the last-spok. to him Sievwright last Ms. Sicvwright event. Ms. going the festival to ñir àoiñg Yi. Ms. Sicvwright worst the binge yet. yet. was Ms. Sievwright this that felt binge She binge worst about their and talked about relationship. în. f"n itrrt this binge was the their relationship. 25, iOli""n¿t"U,u¿ il, 2015 accessed his stated that she his bank bank she accessed binge. She number because Harden’s She stated.that Mr. this binge. blocked she of this that becausc of number Harden's Mr. reported ,rp*rO that she btocked broke he then Wednesday, was by and 20):? by wednesday, broke 28, on Friday, that he Augtlst 28,ialS and then he was Friday, August gotten paid paid on account and he had had gotten and noticed noticed that acoounr Brothers, Hardcn’s supervisor at Toll Toll Brothers, learned supervisor at through Mr. Hardcn's Ms. eventually 20l 5. learied_thrãugh.Mr. Sicvwright 2, September ieptember Z,z0lS, Ms. Sievwr-ight eventually this binge, Prior to home. j sent and was drunk and was sent home' Prior to this binge, August 31, 20¡ drunk I--larden showed 3 t, 2015 on hugust work on up to work Scott, showed ui-to rhat Mr. Mr. Harden Scott, that that reported Ms. Mr' Sievwright repoded that Mr. binge in July. Ms. Sievwright in July. had one mid-May and Harden had one binge thcn another i¡lother binge Mr. Harden and then ¡n miO-uay uinse i11 Mr, would do he itself to do drugs, drugs, he would do to do if the presented itself the presented opportunity while at festival, but opportunity Harden prefened alcohol, atcohoÏ, but while ai the festival, if the iar¿en preferred them. them. Counselíng in ln from Markell Markel I Counseling Ed d te from named Eddie therapist named was seeing seerng aa therapist Ms. that Mr. Mr Harden H arden was added that Sievwright added M s Sievwright went on Harden Mr. Fridays that \rye nt on Fridays She abuse. Harden coho] Mr reported al his that with dea I with his co hol abuse S h e reported to help he lp deal Morganville, Jersey to New Jersey Morganvi le, New other Mr Harden, with Mr. tssues with health issues other health of before l(I1ow ofany times four not know d id not about sh e did they broke went and broke up. She be fore s about four time and Reporting Reporring Detective DANIEL JÍl. J BOZZA BOZ7.A JR. DANIEL J Signature Reporting Detsct¡ve Signature Reporting Detective ' ,6 . “bate Drte of of Report Report 09/I0/2015 09/r0/20r5 Supervisor Signahrre Supervisor Signature teâ fl4e/É (_6Q=Q¢f__,__.,,,Bé_ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0026 0026 Filed 08/04/16 Page 28 of 100 PageID: l.vLTJB Document 62-1 62 1 Filed Page D. 1063 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB ()l'l"l('1" ('ot \'l'\ ’R().\il-‘,('l l()l{'s () "l~‘ ('l7, .\l()\\l()l l'llo\1.( t ‘ "()R'.\ l ll ('()l‘\' ‘\ \to\ \l()t ' ‘ll @ ',''l j li \ . Casett Cæe# page Page 2of2 ' , IA.“ OHS-00172 r 5-00172 cf Promis Gavel# Promis Gavclfl his afïns would feel hisiarms. not feel could not he could her that that he te I her td tell he wou was withd rawl ng from the alcohol, a lcoho t, he from the but when he he was recal I that that when did recall but did and life his of reported that Mr. Mr most of his ife and reported that for most problem for an alcohol alcohol problem had an Ms. has had Harden has believed that Mr Harden Ms. Sievwright Sievwright believedthatMr. abuse. alcohol from 50 died at Harden’s father had died at 50 f¡om alcohol abuse. Harden's fatherhad withdrawing .__...;:a ‘ ‘— ‘ — ‘ _._-_ 2014 and then moved nroved shc then and she t 3'2014 on .lnnc June I3. dating on startecl dating h¡¡d stztrted Ms. Harden had reported that and Mr. Mr. Harden that she shc and Sievwright reportecl Ms. Sievwrip,ht l:larden never Mr. that She never I{arden New reported lvft' that Garwood, Ncw Jersey. Jemey. She reported Brtmeh on Scptember to September I, ?.(ll4, frorn Garwood, 2014, from Long Branclùn to Long house he would llarden was he would ll‘Mr. her house often. at her staying at over not staying was not but I'tardón the Mr. just If into stay moved oflen. wouldjust over home, str¡y would moved into the lrome, but well he was Harden Mr. doing when that well he added doing was his grandmother’s Sievwright addccl that when Mr. l-lanleu Ms. Sievwright Belmar. Ms. house in in Belmar. grandmot¡er,s house stay at his stay at he drinking' was drinking. if he was stay if welcome to let him him stay not let would not was she would but she her, but stay with with her, to stay was welcome into would get into stated he he was when he he wotrld She stated drinking. She annoying, when was drinking. Ms. as annoying Harden as Mr. Harden desoribed .Mr. ñievwright described Ms. Sievwright intense. would so get so intense' that she She reported because hc would get of him becausehe scared ofhim be searetl shõ would would he reporred thai childísh. She very childish. act vcry your face and act face and alien. Ms. human or alien' Ms' really hurnan ol an was really if she was asked ifshe One and asked iievwright and to Ms. Ms. Sicvwright close to Flarden got close time Mr. Mr. Harden lnhis One time which would hallueinate, was sponsor said he sâid was his which Harden withdrawing waiwithdrawing he would hatlucinate, Sicvwright Mr. Harden was thãt when when Mr. rcported that Sicvwrighr reported that he her told l-rlnrden Mr. where time he described told her that a then Harden to experience. someone to Sievwright then described a time where Mr. Ms. Sievwright experience. Ms. typical fi. someon" typical for that the her that the told her Ms. Harden told beer reported thatMr. Sievwright reported that Mr. Harden control can. a was the remote Ms. Sievwright can. a beer thought was control tirãught the remote hallucinations him. for him. were scary for hallucinations were to say want to not want did not she did said she she said beoause she Ms. statement, because formal statement, provide aa formal Sievwright did to provide did not not want want to Ms. Sievwright Harden on Mr. about pâper. anythingnegative anything negative about Mr. Harden on paper. Investigation to Continue. Continue. Investigation to Reporting Detective Reporting Detective _ JR. DANIEL BOZZA,IR. DANIEL JJ BOZZA _ Reporting Signature Dctective Signature Reporting Detective g 79.6 @fu"6 Date Report of Report Dato of 09/10/2015 09/10¿015 Supervisor Signature Supcrvisor Signature /‘£5952 z ufitaé m6 /fæÞ* Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0027 0027 Filed 08/04/16 Page 29 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1064 ' 'l ( (11"\'1'\ l'R().\l1('l"l'()R'.\'(H-'I«'l(' { \l()\\ ()l \lo\\l()llll(otYl\l'lì()sl-(tl()lì'sol'l'l(l' @ ."j Unit File ## 2, 2, Unit G115-0(VJV17_2 cIlS-00t72 l Unit (}l~'.Nl4. (/\t. NVl'.S‘l.'ltiA_TlON l., l' ‘.11’./Hl)"\" .’ .' 1’:,'\)'i'(r'ì' ___ ‘ _ V "' ‘ oll Gavel ## 3. 3 'rmni.s 4. AgencY(s) Case Agency(s) 4. Case "Team: Page I i 7. ' 6.N.J.S. .s. Rulportell Date Dãfe 3!. Time 09/05/20151a:19 091051281516:19 REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW ofCrin11: 9. Locntion of 9. Locntifi NJ 0773]; 0773 HOWBLL, NJ NJ HOWELL, 1017 HOWELL, NJ t33, HOWELL, STA TE Htc¡.¡w A Y #33, l0l 7 STATEHIGHWAY l.8.lncident Date & & Time Time S.lncident Date EL _ _ ' __ _ 10. Crime: Incident // Crime: Reporting Incident Person Reporting 10. Person L Person 11. I 1" Suspect(s) Suspect(s) I2. Info(s): 12. Person Info(s): 14. Victim(s) 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s): 15. Person Person Info(s): ;— Address(s) 13. Address(s): A I6. Address(s): 16. Address(s): — ‘ I 8. 17. ProPefY: Missing Property: 17. Stolen Srolen I/ Missing Weapon Used: \\lll{\ll\l Office this Office provide this Department provide Police Department Tor¡/nsh p Police Howell Township thc Howell On requested the September ber 5, 2t I 5 II requested 5, 2015. {)r about about Septem On or incident. this to video incident. this MVR and pertaining to lng with transmissi ons, and MVR video pertai n radio transmissions, cal ls, radio 9 I I calls, reports, 911 any and and all all reports, with any u'ith an an audio audio ofÏice with this Office supplied this Department supplied Police Department 2015, the Howell Township Police On Howell Township 7,2015,the september 7, or about abour September on or from video and audio footage from footage video containing audio and (7) discs discs cónüaining seven (7) und seven disc transmissions, and radio transmissions, calls, radio 9l I calls, containing 911 disc containing discs and original discs discs all eight of the original made and the eight (8) (8) discs was A units. all of MVR working vehicle *ur'*ude copy seven (7) patrol patrol vehicle MVR units. A working seven (7) Office. "opy County Prosecutor's Office' County Prosecutor’s Monmouth at the the Monmouth vault at were logged evidencê vault main evidence the main into the fÀgiäa into *.tr all with all Office with this Office supplied this D-epartment supplied Police Department Township Police On Howell Township the Howell 2015, the 8, 2015, September 8, about September or about On or file. this in included All file' are to the reports are included in this incident. All reports the incident. pertaining io reports feports pertaining Investigation to continue. continue. Investigation to Detective‘ Reporting Reporting Detective 7 1 JR. DANIEL BOz'Z^ilì DÄNIELJJ BOZZA Reporting Sígnature Detectivc Signature Reporting Detective S_ ,6 @fu"6 R-0-port» D1111: rrl lìcporl l)utc ul‘ 09/23/2015 tJ9t23t20l5 Signature Supervisor Supervisor Signature r-rÆk* arå¿c, /’(£e£¢,__,_,*._. Prosecutor's File File 0028 0028 Prosecutor's Filed 08/04/16 Page 30 of 100 PageID: JB Page D: 1065 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed (‘()Ut\" ‘\'PROSIC(_TliT(‘)R’S oI'-lìI(Ill IVION l)llos¡Ì(lLjT'oll's (JFFICI7. Nlot:-rlI c()tlN'l'\ N,to\ l\*l()l7T l .‘\/.'/’/‘/.l:‘.‘t// lll l't)ilI \t l'l'l t'.\ll \/-l," \ I I! /t‘/:/‘/}/t’/ @ 4" .-' (_J'_l=_l‘fl-j!'L§_/}L_l_T‘g' VEST1Gj\'TlON i}.iVESIICA 4. 4. Case Agency(s) Cæe Agency(s) " _ _ _ _ _._ .. __ __, _ V _ J '”"5,N_J,s] 6. N.J.S. "‘ 5,Crime 5, Crime POLICYREVIEW REVIEW 3. Gavel ## 3. Promis Gavel - 2. 2. Unit File .6 G“5'00172 ct l5-00172 l, Unit Page Page lof2 ‘ ' _ 7. ’ 9. i.ncafionofCrime of Crime 1017 NJ 07731; 0773 I ; NJ HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, HOWELL, NJ STATE HIGHWAY HICHWAY #33, I O I 7 STATE ’ ttrpurirrt nrrtr.-.s2rim’c' Date 09/05/2_o15_16:19__ 09/05/2015 ló:19 8.lncidentDate&Timc S.lncideof Date & Tíme __ _ ‘ Reporting Incidentl Crime: s): I2. Person_Infol Person Info(s)l I L Suspect(s) l5.Pcrson‘Inf_o(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Pcrson Info(s): Viotim(s): l7Eto en Missing Propcényzr Propcrty: Stolen // Missing 10. 10, Person Person Reporting Incident / Críme: Addl'¢SS(5)_¥ l6.Address(s;:t6, Address(s): H '1 13. Addrcss(s)l 12. _ hr 14. I “:0” - H 7 T 17. \ \Rl{ \ Il\ ' " 18.WeaponUst:d: 18. Weapon - _ l. notified Unit were were notified The Crime Unit Bias Crime and Bias Responsibility and Professíonal Responsibility Office Professional Prosecufor's Office The Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's located at Latvian New Society, Priedaine the occurred l0l7 which at Jersey located at 1017 death Society, l.atvian an Jersey New Priedaine in-custody regarding the occurred at which regarding en ¡n-custody death for 911 service for call a of result a This a as was New a 9l I call for service Howell for response State a of Jersey. a result #33, Township, was as This Highway Townshipo New Jersey. SAte HiÈhway #33,Howell incident occurred occurred The incident event. The the event. at the by security security at detained by persón that (CFS) pertaining was being being detained (CFS) pðrtaining to that was to aa disorderly disorderly person 2015. 5, on Saturday, September on Saturday, September 5,2015. investigation. with taking this investigation' lI was to assist regarding this witnesses regarding potential witnesses taking formal fiom potential formal statements staternents from was assigned assist with assignod to Ricciardi Pamela Detective Office Prosecutor’s Ricciardi and and Monmouth Pamela of this the Detective County course Office investigation Prosesutor's County During During thã course of this investigãtion Monmouth from: formal statement take 1I were to a assigned were assigned to take a formal statement from: Patrick Troy, 195 Riviera Drive, Brick NJ 08724, D.O.B T social security number PatrickTroy,l95RivieraDrive,BrickNJa8724,D.o.BGsocialsecuritynumber 10 hours. start hours. 2110 time of of 21 an ending ending time with an hours, with was 2000 2000 hours, time of his formal formal statement statement was of his start time The — The of the the Howell Howell II was Antunez of Christian Antunez Sergeant Christian with Detective Detective Sergeant formal statement statement with assigned to was then then assigned to take take aa formal from: Police Department Township Township Police Department from: I -l'hc Detective Brian -tne Brian Office f)etective II was Prosecutor's Office was then with Monmouth Monmouth County statement with formal statement to take take aa formal then assigned ass¡gned to -County Prosecutor’s number security number Priscilla social security D.O.B — social Baker, 77 07725, 13.0.1; Falls, NJ NJ 07725, Street, Tinton Tinton Falls, 77 Pcaclt Peaoh Slruut. Prisci la Baker, hours. of2300 time with an 2145 cmling hours, formal 230t time ofltt.-r statement was of start cnding lime with an start time of her formal staternent was 2145 hours, Weisbrot from: Weisbrot from: social number _ I security number Brian social security D.O.B I 08859, D.O.B Parlin, NJ NJ 08859, Kenneth Avenue, 32 Kenneth Avenue, Parlin, Brian Toth, Toth, 32 hours 0140 of on time 6, September with 2400 an ending hours on September 6, was his formal hours, time of statement 0140 The start of ending time Thc start time of his formal statement was 2400 hours, with an should be it is 2015, September 5, statement formal the September listed September it should be noted date be on should the 5,2015, 2015. It September 2015. It should be noted the date listed on the formal staternent is 2015, based 6, on the the time time stamp. stamp. bascd on 6,2A15, _ Daniel Bozza Bozza and andlI Detective Daniel On Office Detective 2015, Monmouth Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor’s Monmouth County 23,2015, Wednesday, September September 23, On Wednesday, statements to from: from take formal were _a_s_s_igt_1cd to take_formal ‘were A gnt»i.ture7 Reporti ng>I‘)Ifem-.cth' —eSiSignahrre nçoning etective Reporting Þelective Reporting Detective DANIEL DANIEL NEWMAN NETVMAN L. {J¿ÃA M T ‘Date Report" Date of ofReport 10/08/2015 10/08/2015 _ _, __ _ ___ J _____a_ _Supcrvisor Signature Supcrvisor SigTature / z :,,4,,a(_ råó 4Æ-4-* _._. Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0029 0029 , - - - -TJB Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 31 of 100 PagelD: 1066 ,1 "mm 1/ \mMImvm (m (ll'l'll'lf Ema Pmmix 0mm Ryan Edgar, social security numbey - The sum time ofhis formal sutemcm was 096 hours. with an ending lime of [08 houls. Jammy Hoffman--4 no.5 -- mm mm numbcr - - The sum time ufhis rormnr Stan-men! was 1339 hours, with an cnding xime of1427 hours. Joseph wm, .B -- mm murky number-- The sum lime cfhis formal was 1806 hours, with an ending time 0(1903 hours, 1 Copies oflhe aforementioned statements are attached 10 [his file. Inveslignliun to continue. REpming Ewan: 7 Du]: 'oTxmm-x' 7 SfimEml swan": Mgra 1&4: DANIEL NEWMAN Prosecutor's File 0030 Filed 08/04/16 Page 32 of 100 PageID: C ase 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3215-cv 08043 BRM_TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1067 Case - - — - ()l;1,'l( I ( ot .\'l\ \ I \ l’R().\I’.('l"l'()R'.\' llll()sl.( t tol{'\ ()l5 " (’ -‘. \l()\\l()l lll (’()I‘ \t()\\l()t ill @ _\ unit 2. 2.U G115-00172 6Il5-00172 1. l. Unit Unit (it-;NF.RAl. ri»I\1_r-,js_1;tg_:_p.'i"1oN Case Agency(s) 4. AgencY(s) 4. Case l J‘ / . Page 1 l:\'.'' fz 1‘. /H lii ;‘< 1 tl:ii ¡1¡t:. o!3 Gavcl # J v _ _ _ one & Time 7. ?. Rcponed Date & Reponed 6. 6. N.J.S. N.J.S. 5. 5. Crime REVIEW POLICY POLICYREVIEW 9. Location l.ocption nt'(ir'nnt0773 tl NJ 07731; HO!trELL, NJ NJ HOWELL, 1017 HOWELL, NJ #33, HOWELL, HTCI{WAY #33, STA1E HIGHWAY IOI? STATE 09/05/2015 16:19_ 091051201516:19 8.Incident one & ßL Time S.Incident _ Reporting.Tncident /—Crime: 10. 10. Person Person Reporting Incident / Crime: 11. 11. Suspect(s) Suspect(s) 12. Info(s)l Person Info(s): 12. Person 13. Address(s): 13. Address(s): l4.VVictim(s): 14. Victim(s): 15. Info(s)l Person Info(s): t 5. Person 16. Address(s): 16. Address(s): Property: 18. t8. Weapon Used: 17. Missing ProPcriY: Stolcn I/ Missing 17, Stolen \\l(li\ll\l which death which in-custodY death an in-custody au was regafd rng an not ified regarding was notified B ur€au c nm€ Bure Bias Crime The and Bias Responsi bility and The Professional Professional Responsibility Howell Township, #33, State Township, Howell 1017 3, Highway cated at Latvian S oc iety lo at I 0 I 7 State HighwaY #3 located occurred J ersey Lawian Society, New Jersey Prieda lne, New at the the Priedaine, occumed at to a disorderly disorderly service pertaining (cF S) S ) pertain lng to a for servl ce (CF callll for 9 I 1 ca for aâ 911 This was New resu t of of aa response for as it result was as Jersey This N ew Jersey. event. the at detained by security security ât the event. being detain ed by that was was bemg person that Latvian Society, New Jersey sooioty' Priedaine, New the Priedaine, Jersey Latvian responded to to the approximately 5:30pm, 5:30pm,.II responded On September at appr.oximatety 5, 2015, 2015, at september 5, on several informed l by was arrival, by several was informcd New I Upon arrival, Jersey. upon Howell #33, Howeíl Township, rownsrrip, Nåw Jersey. located Highway i$, st"t" Hijú*uf at 1017 r0r7 State rocated at to a 9 call responded to-a 9l II call members ofthc t hat memb"tt dcpartment responded of ihe department police Police Department Howell the Township of members ú;rû";;iúrat members of the Howellrownship DOB: Harden, Timothy as identified DoB: Harden' ividual was Timothy ind as disoiderly individual was identifïed For The disorderly person. The disorderiy p"tron. for aa disorderly service for for service and officers began to take was strugg ling to restrain Mr. Harden arrived security When patrols _ __w¡"" "t,ot*änivedsecuritywassirugglingtorestrainMr.Hardenandofficersbegantotske liandcuffcd, but was handcuffed, but eventually was the päioåm."rs' and eventually control and to resist police officers‘ control Mr. Harden the scene. i.ririil* continued to over I{ardon continued scene. Mr. over the I-larden‘s of Mr. because the scene Harden's lied to of Mr' ca were called to the scene because combative. Howell EMTs were Township EMTs would Howeil Township to be be combative. continue to woüld continue Mr' scene' Mr. on scene, Howell were on Once EMTs were mouth. his around Township EMTs Howell Township Once he and bleeding was mouth. his extreme behavior and he was bleeding around extreme behavior to have would he Harden Mr. have to he would determined that was determincd transpon Mr' t{arden and itit was to transport that to be combative to be continue to Harden combative and would contínue Harden would before but they the sedation, utilize they the doctor to utilize the sedation, but before doctor to approval from ALS Unit from the MONOC ALs gotãpptãoul had get be sedated. unit had The MoNoc sedared. The be Jersey was Harden to Jersey Mr. transported to then transported was then became Harden Harden unresponsive. Mr. Mr. could sedation, Mr. HardeñU..äm" unresponsìve. the sedation, administer the could administer dead. he where Center where he was pronounced dead' was pronounced Shore Medical Center Uniu"rsity Medical ihor. University was volunteering I larden was Mr. I{ardcn at that Mr. volunteering at mined that was deter dctermined it was witnesses it of potential potential witnesses ' ‘hrough sanvasses of various eanvasses Through various John wife of the is whom John of Baker, riscilla the wife P is whom owned by Priscilla Baker, over in was owncd by ttrat was tent that in aa tent the night over the night staycd the and had had stayed cvent and the event the tent of the tent Mr. Harden inside of remembered seeing she I{arden inside Hi: it seeing Mr. stated Halter Mrs. remembered she event. ofthe that founder stated Mahujan Mahajan aa founder of the evcni Mrs. Baker the indicated that in the stay in not stay Baker indicated did not that she she did the tent. in the was in Mrs. Baker tent. Mrs. believe ânyone not believe else was anyone else the did not prior and and did night prior the night tent owned by owned by the tent for the obtained aa Consent Searoh for to Search else to to ti"V Consent to for anyone else stay in. i". II obtained had set that she set it it up for tent, she had tent, thât the of Antunez Christian the of Antunez Detective if and sergeant christian witnessed Ly by mysc and Detective Sergeant myrelf signed and prisoi[a and witnesseá Baker, which Priscilla Baker, was signod which was Prosecutor's Office, Monmouth Office' County the Monrnouth County Proseoutorns Louis Zuppa of the Zrpp" of Police Ðepartment. Department. Detective D"t".ti;; Éuií Howell Township Township Police Howell only items items ofcvidcntiary The only items I value. The no and rccovcrec gakei of evidentiary value. Baker Mrs. items owned by ând recouorol'rro and by Mrs. tent owned the tent searched the and Ir searched items. loose small other and items' some loose small other blan chap-stick small ket; chap-stick and some were a of the located a small blanket; tent were the tent inside of located inside —lieporting betective Tipotring Detective BOZZA JR. DANIEL JJBOT'7'AJR, DANIEL >Rep—o:.i ng Detective Signature Detcctive Signature Reportrng ‘'5 —_I Date RePort of Report Date of 09/['7/2015 09/17/2fl1s Supervisor S.ignature Supervisor Signature tå¿ ,q{#./i:* taé. ncse<2¢,.~—-re Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0031 0031 Pmmis Guveltt i then secured from the scene and responded to the Howell Township Police Department. 0n same date at approximately 7:50pm, Brian Weisbmt of th: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office, and i took a typed statement from Brandon Keith Cruz, DOB: -- surrounding the incident lhal had occurred involving Timothy Harden. It should be noled thal Cruz the sccurity worker the! was punched in the fan: by 'l'imuthy Harden and is the for the Griffin Security ML 0111': six (6) page statement started at approximately 7:53pm and concluded at approximately 9:12pm. Mr. Cruz's slalemem concluded William incidem. Refer the sulemenl of anlldan CHM, September 5,2015 at 7:53pm for complete details. On the same date nl approximately 9:40pm. Detective Ruben onenzi, of the Howell Township Police Department, and I lack is typed statement from John Russell Smidr lr., DOB: surrounding the incident that had occurred involving Timothy Hntden. Mr. Smith is a per diem EMT with the Howell Township Police Department and responded to the scene. Mr. Smith's five is) page statetnent started at approximately 9:44pm and concluded at approximately 10:45pm. Mr. Smith's statement concluded without incident. Refer to the statement ofiohn Russell Smith in, dated September 5, wt 5 at 9'44pm for complete delsils. 0n the same date at appmximalely 11:40pm. Detective Pamela Ricciatdi ofthe Monmouth County Pmsaculor's nmce, and arrived alqnar, Newlersey to make a death nolificalian to Timothy Harden's next oflrin, Mary Green. DOE: lt should he noted that iI was requested that a uniformed emcer from the Belmar ice Department he on scene during the notification. While notifying Ms. Green osthe death of her grandson, Timothy Harden, Ms Green complained of chest pain. Ms. Green indicated dtat she did not wish to go to the hospital. but did agree to let EMS personnel examine her in her home. Ms, Green's vitals checked well and she again declined going to the hospital. During the course cfthe meeting with Ms. Green, the stated that Mr. Harden her house on Thursday, September3,2015, to go to the cvenL She stated that Mr. Harden was acting faraway heforc he left and was complaining ora pain on his right side by his ribs. Ms. Green unaware ofany medicaliun that Mr. Harden was taking. Sheaddod that his doctor was Dr. Bill Hayot in Ocean Township. Ms. Green stated that Mr. Harden's girlfriend from Long Branch was sending him to some doctor every Friday, whom she thought was a it should he noted that Ms. Green did not know Mr, Hardcn's girlfriend's name. Ms. Green indicated that Mr. Hardcn's girlfriend kicked him out and and that is why he was living with her. Ms Green reported that she thoaytt Mr. Harden was stoning to get bi-polnr like his mother. Sh: stated that he would go on and on then would just want to he alone. Ms. Green also indicated that Mr. Harden-s mother was Schizophrenic. She said that she wuuld tell Mr, Harden somcthing and he would hear iI completely ditterent titan what she told him. Ms. Green stated that Mr. Harden did not use steroids, but he did drink alcohol a lot. Ms. Green also reported that she was unaware crany drug use hy Mr. Harden. Ms. Green stated that she thought that Mr. Hardcn needed mental help and attempted to get him to go to Jersey Shore University Medical Center prior to him leaving for the event. Mr. Harden refused to go and told his grandmothor that he did not have his identification card his girlfriend had it. Ms. Green informed him that he lost his identification card a ycnrago. Green informed as that Mr, Harden has a sis Theresa M. Harden Taylor. that lives in Brick, pate oikepfi Supervisor sign-tote departing lxtotaivc Retaining Detective'sigoatute DANIEL liozu m. 09/I7/1Ill5 Prosecuior's File 0032 Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 34 of 100 PagelD: 1069 I (ll meis Gwen Cue>> Tdew' J'sEe'y'end slep sister. Melissa Barns, lives in New Egypl. New Jersey I then enrnnelerl mick Township Police senreh rnl- Then: M. Harden \c resnhs nl llre Mal eh prnvirled Dolls" and an ol -- Brick, NJ. uriek 'l l'olicc dispaluhcil nn onieor to Ms, Taylor's home will wus guing lo have the ne enll from Ms. rhinily cull .ne mm: arrived. Appmxilnalcly ininules hirer. recciwd leiepho 'l aylur. Ms. 'l'aylnr informed pass of her hrolher, Harden. Ms. Taylor slalorl that Mr. Harden Wu: reeling from a break up when he worn in lhe eoneen event. Ms. Taylor added the: she was lo Mr, Harden via messag: lhe day prior. She also sutad Mr. Harden would drink, inn did not really do drugs. bul she knew dings were pal-l orhis life. Ms. Taylor also ihat ier. Hardan Iliad lhe opponllnity dc drugs al the evenl thal he would hav: 9:30am, I responded so |hc Medionl laxrnniner's wick. NJ, for lhe ol Harden. 0n the lcphune call Theresa M. llardcn Taylor. Ms. Taylor was inquiring llbnul when the aulopsy would he Hiking piers and how she on gel her brother's body back. i inslruoled Ms. Tnyiur le inl'nmr lhe funeral home that her brother is al the Middlesex ('nunly Medical 5 (mice and mm lhey will arrange for lhe transfer. Ms. Taylor lhen asked about had happened lo because she was awakened from her sleep rind did run recull \vllal lnId in her she niglu before. Ms. Taylor informed lhdi rhe Howell Township Poliee nerd responding in a call for servi in [he oohcerl evenl for disorderly person nner Mr. llurden a security guurd eurnhelne. Police arrived on scene and Mr. Harden became combative toward Ihe officers. EMS was callcd lo the seen: and determined Mr. Harden would need to be sedated so he could be transported for medical mention. MONOC was nlse on scene and had chained authority to adminisur the scdaiiorl; howevzr, Mr. Harden unresponsive rind was lhen to Jersey Shore Universily Mediehl Ms, Tnylul' rhen asked gave her hrud-lcr too much scdulion. I then clarified will! Ms. Taylor Illa! MONOC was unable to give him 1h: sedation because he had becom: unresponsiv: bsfom Ihey adminislzred Ill: satiation. 0n Seprernher n, 20l5. in appraximulciy umee. locnled mo Livingslon Ave, 53m: dale, al appmxilnnleiy imam. received 1: Examine!' lnvesrig ion (cl eonrinuc, Repaninx Del-min; lispomng fieleelwesigh-lnr'e DANIEL nnzz>>. m. Xfwme V9/I7l10l5 a: Prosecutor's File 0033 Filed 08/04/16 Page 35 of 100 PageID: C ase 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3215-cv 08043 BRM_TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1070 Case - - — - ol''ljl('l ('()t \'' '\' .\l()\.\l()l"I'lI \ l l ’R().\'lC('l"I"()R'S l'll()sl ( l'lolì's ()l“I" (‘l-'. \l()\\l()t l ll (‘HI @ .i,.' ‘ "I.l. vim Unit HOMICIDE/FATAL DE/TATAL M_vc 4. Case Agency(s) Agency(s) Tam? 5. ‘ '_" DEATH INVESTIGAÎION DEATH INVESTIGATION 2; Page Page lo/4 r,i lt, am j I it .1 )', M in. .t'( )i'l l'/ ./‘(H-.':” 3 Pmrnis (invl if Unit File itä 2. Unit HMI5-00177 HM I 5.00t ?? _, _ _ _ _ H _ _ _ _ _H ""(IN.1.s. N.r.s ' ' ' T‘ " lS.lncidunIl):IIc&Time‘ & Time nate&'I'IJF i7.‘I'tep—orTed Reported Date & 09/05/2015 14:52 0910512015 14:52 tl9!tI5I2(Il5 l4:52 l4:32 09/05/20I5 l6:15 09/05/2015 I6:l5 - _ _ ' 9. I.ocnIimIol‘Crimt M g _ 1-‘ 07728i I017 NJ 07728; FREEHOLD. NJ NJ.33 FREEHOLD. IOIT NJ-33 Crime: I0. lncident I/ Crime Reporting Incident 10, Person Person Reporting l:\dCll'€SS(5): H — — Person lnfo(s): I2. lnfo(s): I 2, Person ll. Susp€ct(s) I l. Suspectts) E — — I3. I 3, Address(s): ’ _ Victim(s): 14. Victimts): I). I). HARDEN. HARDEN. TIMOTHY! TIMOTHY J ‘HIS. lnfo(s): Pcrson lntbtsl: 15. Person MALE: sEX:MALET Iooo,f DOB; sax; I). ssN: _ t). SSN: RACE: CAUCASIAN; MCE: CAUCASIAN; _ - A I7. hoPertY: Missing Property: 17. Stolen Stolen // Missing I8. t8. I6. Address(s): 16. Addressts): BAYVIEW AVE. 0?719 NJ' 0'I7I9 BELMAR. NJ. AVE. BELMAR. I). I201 l20l BAYVIEW t), Weapon Used: \\l{l{\ll\l CountY Clancy of of the the Monmouth Monmouth County M ichaelClancY Sgt' Michael bY Sgt. 2015. this assigned by was assigned detective was this detective On 5.2015. SePtem ber 5. Saturday, September On Saturday. had been Harden Harden. Itl1 was that Harden had been learned that was learned Timothy Harden. of Timothy death of Prosecutor‘s the death investigate the to investigate Office, to Prosecutor's Office, Latvian prope rty, Society Priedaine Priedaine property, Jersey Latvian Society New Jersey place at the New concert which at the taking place was taking which was attending multi-day concert attending aa multi-day Howell Twp' Police Police that Howell Twp. advised that been advised further been Twp., NJ. had further NJ' II had located HowellTwp', 33, Howell Highway 33, State Highway at l0l7 l0l7 State located at that and security on offìcers on complaint. and that security officers disorderly person complaint. to aa disorderly had been due to dispatched area due to the the area ispatched to been d Department Department had the of notification, Harden, who time of the notification, at the the time was at identified as who was TimothY Harden. as Timothy scene had detained the the individual, individual, identifìed scene had detained pronounced deceased. pronounced deceased. officers of the Howell Twp. met with priedaine grounds. several officers of the Howell rwp' with several and met grounds. and the Priedaine to the Therefore, respond€d to detective responded this detective Therefore, this 33. was learned officers that Howell Howell officers learned that It was Route 33' It to Route adjacent to located adjacent area located the area Police secured the had secured who had Department who Police Department white male of the the white male control of maintain control to maintain attempting to were attempting who were oflicers who arrived security officers the security and relieved relieved the scene and on scene arrived on Police Howell Twp. Police subsequently' Howell Twp' and subsequently, security officers officers and both security resist¡ng both consistently resisting subject. was consistently who was subject, who the in handcuffing successful the subject. subject' officers were handcuffing in rwp. officers were successful Howell Twp. subsequentty, Howell efforts. Subsequently. Department offioers, efforts. Department officers’ Therefore, medical emergency medical Officcrs' Therefore' emergency Police Officers. Twp' Police Howell Twp. with Howell combâtive with be combative to be However, aontinugd to Harden continued However, Harden behavior extreme continued Harden‘s behavior to extreme Due thereafter. soon thereafter. Due to Harden's çont¡nued arrived soon and arrived scene, and to the the scene, sailed to personnel were called personnet were were ALS were MoNoc ALS of MONOC paramedics of ambulance in question, paramedics an in question, him $/as in and safely in an ambulanoe was abilityto to transport transport him safely the ability and the received and for Harden transpon received sedate and to transport paramedics requested approval to sedate Harden for requested approval summoned well. Paramedics as well. anived as and arrived summoned and Before unresponsive' Before of became unresponsive. Harden became administration the sedative, Harden the sedative. to the adminisffation of the that prior to However, prior approval, However, thal approval. his maintained and about. his and maintained and moving been had been yelling yelling and moving about' Harden had that Harden iterated that was iterated becoming unresponsive, itit was becoming unresponsive, in I-larden was distress, that once it officers. However, was obvious obvious that Harden was in distress' it was However, once with officers. to breatheand communicate with abilityto breathe and communicate abitity Shore University Medical Center to Jersey was transported transported to Jersey shore university Medical center he was and he commenced and life-saving immediatety commenced efforts immediately life-saving efforts hours. l6l4 hours. at 1614 Yousef at Dr. Yousef by Dr. where he was later pronounced deceased by pronounced deceased where he was later Office Professional Responsibility Unit and Professional Responsibility of the Proscculor's Office County Prosecutor’s Detective Monmouth County the Monmouth Bozzaof Daniel Bozza Detective Daniel investigation conduct the investigation well, to conductthe as well,_to the fairgrounds as to the resPonded to unit, responded same unit, the same of the Sgt. Santorso la of Rocco Santorsola sgl' Rocco Unit and Reportir-IE_Detective Rcporting Detcctive PAMELARICCIARDI PAMELA RICCTARD¡ Reponing Detective Signature Signature Teportñtõetcctive )£l/{if Hbt fi^,q .g.M0 w of Report Date Report Dat€ of lII24/20I5 ttnil2ols 1 Signature _Supervisor Tupèruisor Signature /*4rø % /& I M.W;6 Prosecutor's File 0034 Prosecuto/s File 0034 Filed 08/04/16 Page 36 of 100 PageID: M-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1071 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB - - - @ ()l"l“l(‘ '. I .\l()\\l()l l'l{o\l ( I lol{'sol'l.'l( ot \I\ ’R()Sl-".(‘l" ‘()l{'.\ \t()\\l()t 'l' l lll(('()l‘\' 'Y ,,,. L; .. / ti:, ,/t.t',; 3“ ,,', 11.ì( ) /v':’ l\, H ! .-‘H. . caseat Casc# _ Page 2of4 Promis Cavcl# Promis oavem 5-00 I 77 HM HM ll5-00177 Newman ofthesameunit short time-later,‘ of the same unit Det. Danie lNewman i_ce custody? ‘regarding time later, Det._Daniel A short police custody. A while in in p—ol death while the death regarding the 1:- _ further details. details. reports for for further to their their reports refer to responded Please refer assist. Please to assist. responded to to responded to also responded Bureau also of the Services Bureau Technical Services Det. and Technical Forensic and Counfy Forensic the Monmouth Monmouth County Zuppaof Louis Zuppa Det. Louis Crimes Office Prosecutor’s Major Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Major Crimes memorialize of the the Monmouth County Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot of Det. Brian scene, Det. the scene. memorialize the well. as the with assist investigation to Bureau responded to assist with the investigation as well' Bureau responded is known known to to him. him' Harden is Tirnothy Harden that Timothy was learned tearned that After Mahajan, itit was John Mahajan, event coordinator, coordinator, John with event speaking with After speaking located which on was in tent a had He was overnight located on which event. Harden stayed overnight ¡n a tenf multi-day event. He had stayed help out out at at the the multi-day to help volunteered to Harden volunteered the to event prior to the event priscilla Baker, Harden just prior witnessed Hardenjust she had had witnessed the that she indicated that Baker, indicated wife, Priscilla grounds. Mahajan’s Mahajan's wife, the grounds. with a could investigators and Harden with a written written fonnal formal with Mr. provide investigators which intervention with Mr. Harden and could provide security intervention precipitated security which precipitated and after Before doing so. so, and after Headquarters. Before doing Police Headquarters. statement. to Howell Howell Police respond to to respond was asked asked to she was Therefore, she statement. Therefore, and she her husband, and provided she provided to and signed signed in belonged to she and her husband, she confirming had slept slept in belonged that Harden Harden had tent that that the the tent confirming that detectives provide detectives with with that could provide evidence thatcould consent for for any evidence shelter for investigators to the temporary temporary shelter to search search the for investigators conscnt Detectives Please see have he passed away. Please see Detectives information why he may have passed away. or why manner or in such such aa manner behaved in Harden behaved why Harden information why information. fin-ther for and Bozza‘s rcpofts for further information. Zuppa's reports Bozza's and Zuppa‘s 'fwp, Police Newman. obtained obtained with Det. Det, Newman. and with Police Headquarters HeadquaÉers and to Howell Howell Twp. responded to Subsequently, detective responded this detective Subsequentty, this Police was Howell the Department. Twp. is was who Department. Police Patrick by from employed statement from Patrick Troy. Troy, a Troy, who is employed by the HowellTwp. a formal formalstatement indicated He call. initial the to in his his responded to the initial call. He indicated in identified as that responded Emergency Medical Technician's that Medical Technician’s the Emergency of the as one one of identified noted he that Priedaine. the arriving, at Upon intoxicated he noted that aniving, to Upon he an that sworn dispatched to an intoxicated person at the Priedaine. was dispatched statement, that he was sworn statement. The adult male. male. The an adult as an officers described as four who was was described patient who there attempting of the the patient were gain control control of to gain there were four officers âttempting to that continued the down Troy face on ground. described ground. Troy that continued as identified being the was as male subsequently identified as Harden, Harden, was described as being face down on male subsequefrtly officer fourth was the and controlling midsection, and the fiourth officer was controlling two his midsection, one was was at at his while one his shoulders. shoulders. while hotding his were holding two officers officers were them and back securing them his behind on them them securing handcuffed ties on Harden zip ties had zip feet. Harden was feet had his feet the was handcuffed behind his back and his patient,s feet. the patient’s officers the at blood yelling repeatedly spitting blood at the officers repeatedly yelling was spitting and was combative and Harden as as very combative together. Troy described described Harden together. Troy and provide and face to provide his blood had He attempting to Troy die. partner were were attempting his partner that on his face and Troy and his going to to die. He had blood on was going he was that he behavior. continued Harden’s due to medical successft¡l due to Harden's cont¡nued behavior. not successful were not patient. However. they were However. they to the the patient. service to medical service summoned and and were summoned paramedics were behavior, paramedics continued that Harden's behavior. of Harden’s the extreme extreme nature nature of because of the Troy that becauseof Troy continued of efforts officers the and to behavior and the efforts of offìcers to Harden's behavior arrived details of of Harden’s scene. Troy’s provided fitrther further details statement provided Troy's statement on scene. arrived on which to investigators. in his which description to investigators. was explicit explicit in his description Troy was on them. them. Troy blood on keep spitting blood from spitting Harden from kcep Harden indicated further He to restricted. cont¡nued to that Harden continued Harden’s time indicated thatHarden was that airway at further indicated no time was Harden's airway restricted. He indicated that at no breathe. around. move around. yell. spit. and move spit, and breathe, yell. personnel emergency personnel Íansport, emergency for transport, provide aa sedative sedative for Once to provide sought authorization authorization to and sought paramedics arrived anived and Once paramedics thathe was immediately indicated placed on on aa Troy indicated that he was immediately placed observed the breathing. Troy and stopped stopped breathing. catm and patient became became calm the patient observed Howell EMTs EMTs with the the Howell and CPR paramedic stayed stayed with A paramedic commenced. A CPR commenced. stretcher, removed. and were removed. his handcuffs handcuffs were stretcher, his the that ambulance so the drove medical to the entire transport Officer drove the ambulance so that the medical Police Officer Howell Police hospital, and and aa Howell the hospital. during transport to the entire during the the turned medical to over was Harden the to the Once at over mcdical turned Harden. of was hospital. their care of Harden. Once at the hospital. Harden professionals cont¡nue their care could continue professionals could details. there. Please staff for further further details. Troy for of Patrick Patrick Troy statement of the statement sce the Please see staffthere. o_l‘ Report ‘Supervisor Signature ve Signature Date Signature Dale Reporting Dhetecti Detective Reporting Dcttrdive . PAMELARICCIARDI PAMELA RICCIARDI W #tt o fiÅ^( .g.M0 n/24/2015 ttn4noß T /^&qrc #r f wwig Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0035 0035 Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 37 of 100 PagelD: 1072 \itt\\itii lIl( til i'ittistti pm .. . . Jg/t 7 7 case>> leelit Soon the'reaher, undersigned then obtained a tormsl statement trom security amoer. DanielCastitlo. Castillo had been requested to respond to Howell Twp. Police Headquarters to provide a statement to detectives. Castillo indicated that he worked security for Grimn's Security. although he had not been scheduled to work on September Castillo indicated that he received text from his boss that they needed extra people at the event and was requested to respond. Therefore. Castillo responded and arrived at approximately 1500 hours. He was directed to a specific location to park his car and teamed at that time that there was a security situation that he was needed tor. He was directed Io where security guards were attempting to subdue an adult male. He recognized one orthe other Griffin Security guards as Brandon Cruz. When Cruz saw Castillo. he told him that he couldn't hold the individual dawn anymore and needed relisr. Castillo then sat on the subject's arm and held his head down. At this time, Cruz remarked to be earerut atthe blood that was an the subJect's tace as he was spitting blood. Castillo indicated that as he sat on his arm. he held the subject's neclt and race to be positioned away iront him. He informed otncets that despite having all oihis weighton the subject'sarrn. he was still able to liti Castillo up otrthe ground with one arm. Castillo proceeded to remain in this position until the police arrived which he estimated to be approximately htiecn minutes. Castillo described the subject's behavior as completely out orcontrol. He was speaking. but was not making any sense according to Castillo. He stated that he was soaking wet with sweat. crying. and apologizing to his (uthetas well. Castillo continued that once the police arrived on scene. each oftlie security officers were removad from detaining the individual. and the police took over. Castillo continued that one oftlle security guards that he did not know remarked that the subject had been acting out all day. Cnstillo remained at the scene for several minutes. He indicated that he observed as th: police took control of the subject. During that time, Castillo indicated that he never witnessed the police strike the male or use any weapons on him. Please refer to Castillo's stntement fur funlter details Following the stateInEnI ofCastillo. Del. Bow and the undorsigncd traveled to the next ofkin's msidence to make notification. Mary T. Glenn been idmlified as th: deceascd's grandmother. It was leflmed that she lived at Theretore, these detectives met with uniformed ort'tcets ot the neither Police Depanrnent. Officers were very familiar with Timothy Harden and his tamiiy. one to the nature ofour visit. Belmar omcersoontacted Ms. Green's neighbor. Beth Rotchrord or-- to stay with her while officers spoke with her. EMS was also summoned to the rcsidence to check on her well- being, however, Green declined treatment. Mary Green continued that she was Timothy Harden-s grandmother and next ofkin. as his parents were deceased. Green indicated that the last timc she saw her grandson was on Thursday. September 2, ml 5. She stated that he had heen acting strange and complained atpain on the right side othis stomach. His doctor is Dr. Hayet in Ocean, She believed Harden to he receiving care at the behest orhis previous girltriertd with whom he used to live. However, she believed him to have stopped seeking counseling since Harden and his girlfriend broke up she could not provide his girltriend's name. When questioned turther with regard to problems. Green admitted that she believed him to he bipolar and indicated that Reporting DetsZitre 7 PAMELARICCIARDI <Filed 08/04/16 Page 38 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1073 3:15-cv-080_43_-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed \l()\\'l()l" II ('()l'\'l'\’ ’l{().\l*_( ‘I ' ()R'.\ 0 -I-' ('l-'. @ " I If .:.m-. 2-:1./-u/..'x Caself Cose# _ I page Page .l o!1 Promis Gavelii Gavel# Promis HMl5-00l77 HMtS-00177 ved_<:—ondi tio_n,M he wanted perceived cond ition. rh percei for this he lp for Harden? to seek s€ek help wanted him h tm to She illness. S mental illness.‘ from rnentid suffered from also suffered mother also Harden mother I s and Ms. stay with w ith to stay agreed to Rotch ford agreed M s. Rotchford Green was information and the information but for the was thanked thanked for unsucc€ssful. Green was unsuccessful. she was but she Harden’s better. felt better. she felt unfil she grandmother until Harden's grandmother Sievewright. girlfriend, Melissa Melissa Sievewright. and the g. 2015. with Harden‘s Harden's girlfriend. met with undersigncd met the undersigned Det. Bozza Bozzaand September 2015. Det. Septernber 8. of her knowledge information of Timothy Timothy and regarding knowledge her with provide information regarding investigalors and provide Sievewrightagreed to speak speak with investigators Sievewright agreed to she that conftmted and Office and Prosecutor's Office and confirmed that she and Harden. County Prosecutor’s Monmouth County the Monmouth to the responded to Sievewright responded Harden. Sievewright indicated abuse. Sievewright alcohol his of because indicated Sievewright broken had abuse. Harden recentty because of his alcohol They had broken up recently dating. They been dating. had been Harden had but had also spent time relationship' their relationship. I during their about for time apart apart during been had Harden and she dating that that she and Harden had been dating for about I year. but had also spent On on scared of him when he and she on drinking would become become scared of him when he she would binges and drinking binges would go on Sievewright explained that Harden Harden would exptained that Sievewright of money. that when when he he investigators that informed investigators She informed money. She did he ran ran out out of binge until until he to binge would continue continue to He would did so. so, He able feel his be to not would and hallucinate would he discontinued her that that he would hallucinate and would not be able to feel his to her would explain explain to he would drinking, he discontinued drinking, Harden thought occasion. Harden thought one occasion. On one example. On provided an an example. and provided for him him and arms. frightening for was fiightening that it it was told her her that He told arms. He indicated about Sievewright asked When that drugs, Sievewright indicated that that can. When asked about drugs. beer can. was aa beer the television television was for the control for remote control that the the remote alcohol. to addiction was his really well. to alcohol. do However, would was really he as addiction if drugs as well. However. his were available, available, he would do drugs if they they were binges. She She have binges. to have him to to get he continued continued to however, he addiction. however, get help for his his addiction. help for Sievewright convinced him had convinced Sievewright had and would bank account online his to had she and would access because account bank was binging indicated binging because she had âccess to his online when he he was she knew knew when that she indicated that midst that on was in he was in the the midst occasion. he bars and this occasion. from on this deductions was aware aware that the She was observe sfores, She liquors stores. observe the deductions from bars and liquors of binge. ofaa binge. that She indicated indicated that statement. She investigators with typewritten statement. with aa typewritten When provide investigators to provide declined to Sievewright declined asked, Sievewright When asked, to want did she formally speak poorly not poorly she didn’t information, she did not want to formally speak while this information, with this providing detectives detectives with mind providing didn,t mind white she see Det. the building. Det. Bozza’s Bozza's time for her Please see thanked building. Please left the then left was and she she then about Sievewright was thanked for her time and Harden. Sievewright about Harden. additional information. information. report for additional repol for testing' toxicological testing. and toxicological autopsy and The the autopsy of the pending the investigation isis pending the results results of The investigation Reporting Detecl¡ve neporting Detective - PAMELA P,AMELA RICCIARDI RICCIARDI Reporting Si gnature neporting Detective Dercctive Signature ‘W HALE .g..}w. #tbo > Repon Date of Report Date of 11/24/2015 ttn4n0l5 SupervisorSignature Supcrvisor Signaturc @..,,f,5-5 % /rt f ¢_‘/,*,trc Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0037 0037 Case 315 cv OQOAE-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 39 of 100 PagelD: 1074 1 Univ FII: a (II PRHNI (l IHRNUH Uni! igmsxupm 7 mum-pm) 5705'}: <Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 40 of 100 PagelD: 1075 l" m. i Unit 2 ti trileti GII -m|12 77777 7 .. 7" 4 (As: o. 1.5 7 llenonctt Date time POLICYREVEW . arms/2m: Idflr 7A 7_ 7_ .tion olCrirne STATE Hl GNWAV m. HOWELL. NJ HOWELL. NJ 0773 In. linen Repcning incident mime: . I3. ll, suspeoltl lz Person lntolsl: T4. Wuimtsi: ls. Person lti. Andreasist TlTWeapon lined ii. Stoien iMittin; Pmpeny: On Saturday September 5. ms at approximately 5:30 PM Detective Sergeant Michael Clancy orthe Monmouth County Prosecutor's office Major Crimes Bureau Issigned me to respond to the Howell Township Police Department located in Howell. NJ to assist with an death i arrived al the Howell Township Police nepanment at approximately 6:45 PM and was subsequently bricreo by Detective pamela or the Monmouth County Prosecutor's omco Major Crimes Bureau and Detective Daniel Newman or the Monmouth County Proseculor's omee Prafcssional Responsibility amt Elias Crime Bureau regarding the circumstances surrounding this investigation. 1 was infmmed that the incident being investigated occurred during the "Soupcr Groove Music Festival." held at the Priedaine New Jersey Latviltl Society lootted at 1017 State Highway 23. Howell Townshi ,Nl. The deceased was identified as being Timothy J. H.nlen._ -- beimar. NJ. DOB: -- AI approximately 3 PM. Detective Daniel Bozza of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's omcee Professional Responsibility and Bias Crime Bureau and interviewed and obtained a six to) page typewritten statement from Brandon Keith cm. Sayrevilie. telephone numbcr in reference to this investigation. The statement was obtained at the Howell Township Police Department, was employed as a Sacurily Guard for Griffin Security at the time of the incident. For additional information. please refer to the statement Al 9:3? PM. Dulcclive Ricciurdi oflhc Mul'lmoutlt Prosecutor's Office-7 Major Cr'mcs Bureau and interviewed and obluirlcd five (5) page ly written statement from Daniel Castillo,-- Brick. NJ. DOB: "umber bi" "fume In lhis investigation. The statement was obtained at the Howell Township Police Daniel was as I Security Gulrd for Griffin Security at the lime incidml. For informalimt, please refer to the statement. On Sunday, September 6, 20|5 at approximately i :00 AM, Detective Daniel Newman of the 5 Crime Bureau and I interviewed and County Proseculur's Office . Professional Responsi lIily and Bia oblaincd a seven (7) n.Ea typewritten statement from Brian rant, Purl" NJ 08859. -- and cellular telephone number DOB home telephone number lteponintnelectlve Reponineueteuivesign-tnre Danoixopm WEISHROT 52/ (rafflf a [u Inn-mus WWEG Prosecutor's File 0039 Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 41 of 100 PagelD: 1076 redraw: to this investigation 'The statement was obtained at the Howellewnship Police Department lir'lan was employed as a Security Guard for Grimn Security at the time incident. For additional information, please refer to the statement. On Tuesday, September a. 2015 at approximately 5:30 PM, Detective Rosendc Perez cf the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 7 Professional Responsibility and Bias Ctilnc llutciul anti I traveled to - Lukehurst. NJ for the purpose of meeting with Andrew J. Nari rm. were made with Ne for Detective Perez and to travel to his restdence and transpon him to the Lakehurst Police Department in reference to this investigation. Mri Neri was subsequently transported to tile Lakehurst Police Department in the rear ufmy County issued vehicle without incident, At so it PM. Detective Rnsendo Perez and interviewed and obtained an eleven (1 I) page 'tcm Andrew J. Neri -- Lakehurst. Ni tum, DDB: -- telephone min reference to this investigation The statement was obtained at the lecllursl Police 1 was employed as a Security Gourd with Griffin Security on the date cfthe incident. For additional information, please refer to the statement. it should be noted that at the conclusion of the statement. Detective Perez and transported Mr. Nert back to his residence located at 304 Maple Street. LakehursL NJ without incident On Thursday. September l7, ZUIS at approtimately 9:47 AM. Detective Daniel 80123 of the Monmouth County Frusecutot's orftoe Professional Responsibility and Crime Bureau and interviewed and obtained at van i7 Rug: typewritten statement from John A. Bree._ M-wt. PA 19010. no numbcr_ in reference to this investigation. The statement was obtained It the Monmouth County Prusccular's Office located in Freehold. NJ. John WIS a participant in a band (Nik Greely and the Operators) playing at the Pt-iedaine on the date of the incident. For additional information, please refer to the statement. On Tuesday. September 22. ZOIS at approximately 9:29 AM. Detective Daniel 39223 or the Monmouth County Office 7 Professional Responsibilily and Bias Ctimc Bureau and and obtained a seven (7) age typewritten stulcmcil in loseili East Brunswick. NJ 08m. DOB number in reference to this tnvesttgultum The slulunienl was obtained at the Monmouth Cfluuly Prosecutor's othce located In Freehold Nib Joseph is employed as a Paramedic with MONOC and responded to the Priedaine on the dot: of the incident and assisted in treating Timothy Harden. For additional information. please refer to the statement. For detriled information pertainmg to this investigation. pl use refer to the reports prepared by the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Responsi lity and alas Crime Bureau, case it Glis- 00172. Nothing furtherto report at this time. "Supervisor signature Teporttn. Deirotive Reporting Detective start-trite 'nnte afflict? BRMN WEISIIOT a} (rat/~4- a tu "(4&th Prosecutor's File 0040 Filed 08/04/16 Page 42 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BB_M-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1077 \I( )\ \IlHwllll (T H \'l‘\. l’R(JSl'.( il ''l'( )R'.\ UI" "l( ll‘. @ V: l.' , I‘. ‘I 2.it File## ' 1. l. Unit Unit FN 5-00l97 FNt5.00t97 rouausics s 4. 4. Case Agency(s) Case Agency(s) _ _ 5. 5. Crime" 3. __ >_ DEATH DEATH INVESTIGATION TNVESTICATION 9. 9. Location ol'L'rinIL' l0l7 07728: NJ 07728; RT-33 FREEHOLD. FREEHOLD. NJ IOIT RT-33 ,_ _ /iCrime: _ j__ l _ _ _ _ I‘rniis Gavel ii 7:: _ _ _ .3 6. NJ.J.S ‘ Page IIof4 0f4 jl _.',_'I I"; I,'f 7. 7. 'i?.cp(i‘rt.I?t::_§z_' -Time Date & Time 12:15 I0/I5/20_I5 l0/t512015 12:15 _ T ___, _ _ iL—iricidcI1( & ‘I‘iu_Ie' Date & 8. lncidcnt Date 09/05/2015 00;00 09/05/2015 00:00 T _ A _ '’ T _ I0. lncidcnl /Crimc: Reporting Incident 10, Person Penon Reporting Address(s): lnl‘o(s): J]. I I. Su_spect(s) Suspect(s) W a _ 13. 13, Address(s): I2. Person lnfo(s): 12. Person —_ I5. Percon lnfo(s): 15. Person lnfo(s)r DOB: I). SSN: Doa: RACE: CAUCASIAN; RÀCE: CAUCASIAN; I4. Victim(s): 14, Victim(s): — l).SSN:Il I). I). HARDEN. HARDEN. TIMOTHY JJ TIMOTHY Property: W‘ I7. Missing ProPertY: Stolen I/ Missing 17. Stolen \ \l{l( \ I l\ sex: MALE; sEX:M,{LE; 2 f ' I I6. Address(s): Address(s): ló. 07719 IZUI BAYVIEW NJ,07719 l). AVE, BELMAR. BELMAR. NJ, BAYVIEW AVE, t). I20l ll"!-.»\:’eaptIn USIJIJIV Uscd: >— # _ ~~~~ __ 1?- I ASSIGNMENT: ASSIGNMENT: Monmouth County County the Monmouth contacted the On 2015, the Deparlment contacted Police Department Township Police Howell Township the Howell 5,2015, On September September 5, Monmouth the from assistance for A County Monmouth death the County prosecutor's Office Prosecutor's request for assistance from investigation. A request regarding aa death investigation. Office regarding for made examination Scene was Crime Unit. Services Bureau. Technical and for examination made Forensic prosecutorns Office. Prosecutor’s Office. ForensiJ and Technical Services Bureau, Crime Scene Unit. was Clancy, of the Michael Clancy, of the Sergeant Michael and l6l5 hours, hours, Sergeant At approximately approximately 16l5 victim, At scene and and victim. the scene of the documentation of and documentation stated that the Howell and contacted me Crimes Bureau, Prosecutor’s Office, Monmouth Major Crimes Bureau, contacted me and stated that the Howell Office, Major County Prosecutor's Monmouth County Route 33, l0l7 Route to respond Society, 1017 33, Latvian Society, Priedaine Latvian to the the Priedaine respond to Township was requested requested to bepartment was Potice Department Township Police identified later as control of with out Timothy subject, an as Timothy assist later identified to New subject, security guards control out of Howell. guards with an Jersey, secur¡ty to assist Jersey, Ñew Howell. were attempting attempt¡ng to who were to offìcers who responding officers Harden. with the the responding not cooperate coop€rate with Harden did did not that Mr. Mr. Harden was advised adviied that Harden. If was Aid the First that to stated responded involved. of Aid responded the Clancy the First to Sergeant for stated that Harden Mr. Clancy safety Sergeant everyone secure involved. of the safety for s€cure Mr. Harden Center where he Medical was Shore to Harden Mr. University Center where he was and Jersey Medical priedaine University Priedaine the Shore transported to Jersey Society Mr. Harden transported and Society the pronounced pronounced deceased. deceased. Officer at Jersey met with with Officer and met Center and At Medical Center hours, II arrived University Medical Shore University Jersey Shore arrived at 1700 hours, At approximately approximately 1700 Mr. Harden. Officer with standing by Howell Township by with Mr. Harden. ofäcer was standing Sean Township Police who was Department who Police Department of the ttrcHowett MacD'onatd of Sean MacDonald Dr. 1614 at deceased hours, by Harden Youssef; of of Jersey Jersey Shore Shore Dr. Youssef, was that Mr. by stated hours, pronounced MacDonald at 16l4 pronounced deceased MacDonald stated that Mr. Harden was Elan Canon EOS 7D a documented utilizing Harden Canon Elan Mr. a EOS 7D was Center. photographically Medical utilizing documented photographically University University Mcdical Center. Mr. Harden was the at were the of All unit. developed flash EXII images 580 were developed with Canon at the in the images a of All unit. digital conjunction w¡th a Canon 5S0 EXI¡ flash digital camera. in conjunction "rrrrru. and forensic forensic hard hard disc and prãsecutor's Office, on aa compact compact disc and retained retained on Monmouth Unit. and Scene Unit. Crime Scene County Office, Crime County Prosecutor’s Mãnmouth Mr. collected Harden’s then I details. additional for Photo Mr. Uniform collected Harden's then the I Report details. drive. appended Uniform Photo Report for additional to tire appended Refer to drive. Refer approximately At approximately underwear. At black colored colored underwear. shorts and and black pair of colored shorts black colored of black of aa pair clothing which consisted consisie¿ of clothing which Priedaine the to and Society. Center Medical Sociery. responded Priedaine Shore jersey the 1810 Úniversify Medical Center and responded to left Jersey Shore University lBl0 hours, hõurs, II left arrival, I met Rocco Santorsola, Santorsolq Sergeant Rocco met with w¡rh Sergeant At Upon arrival, scene. Upon on scene. arrived on hours, II arrived 830 hours, At approximately approximately 1830 Prosecutor's Monmouth the of County Bozza Daniel Prosecutor s Office, offi C€t Detective and Detective Newman and Detective Daniel Bozza of the Monmouth County Danie Newman, Detective Daniel Monmouth the of Ricciardi Pamela Detective County Monm outh County Professional was Detective Pam el a R icciard of the Also on on scene scene was Unit. Also Responsibi ¡ry Unit. Professional Responsibility Police Howell the of Township members several and Pol tce Department. Bureau Department. Crimes ip Townsh Howel of the Prosecutor’s several mem bers Office, Major and B ureau Crimes aJor M o ffi co, Prosecutor's the crime Yellgyv tape was was as Ricciardi scene c flme scene were lead lllVC5lig_a_l0I'S. Detective Y e llow assigned Bozza lead as thc were Ricciard and éDetective and Detective Bozza ‘T SupervisoI7Signature Dale o—fReport Signature Detective Supcrvisor Signature of Report Detective Date Reporting Repo¡ting Detective Signature Reporting Detectivc Reporting H __ " ’ LOUISZUPPA IT}IJIS ZUPPA » g mt. sÉ Ú*". røz 3!,.¡6,4-#,«;,7 I0/15/20l5 r0/t5/2015 5° {),'__(3. D*l)-@ Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0041 0041 Filed 08/04/16 Page 43 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1078 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed @ @ l'R().\‘l-‘_('l’ l‘()R'H in-‘I-‘t('I-‘. ( ()l Viv \l()\\l()l \ l\'I'll()sl \t()\\t()t 'l‘lI l'¡l ('()l "rIrt’/' ,!t //-r //'2/4 ll',,,,t ìi i;:,t,t)ìii Cascill Casc# Page 2af4 Fromis Pmmis Gaveltl Cavel# FN FN II 5-00197 5.00 197 parking lot the incidentincident lot where where the the parking in the raff¡c in utilized off any any vehicularfland vehicular and pedestr¡an traffic and block off down and*block to shut shut down utilized to information was occurred. provided: preliminary information was provided: following preliminary The following occurr€d, The —pedestrian SYNOPSIS: SYNOPSIS: two day celebrating its its event celebrating day event 2015, the On was hosting hosting aa two Society was Latvian Society Priedaine Latvian the Priedaine 5,2015, On September Seplemb er 5, of the tents. in Organizers the camping invited of the on to Organizers Attendees sleeping grounds, tents. were camping grounds, sleeping in stay the stay on organization. invited to were Attendees organization. Harden Mr. was overall and security. vehicle with Harden was assist to Mr. parking security. parking overall event and personnel security with vehicle personnel employed to assist security evãnt employed and acting acting to himself himselfand observed parking lot talking to lot talking walking around entrance parking by security main entrance the main around the staffwalking security staff observed'by needed if he to see Mr. with Harden, checking any to staff needed see if he The to speak checking attempted Harden, Mr. security with abnormally. to speak abnormalty. The sicurity staff aUempted the of and one security guards. combative guards. became Harden Mr. punched that advised the security I punched of assistance. one was and combative became assistance. t was adviscà that Mr. Hãrden The Howell Police Township Police restrain Mr. no success. HowellTownship Additional success. The attempted to harden with with no personnel att€mpted security personnel Mr. harden to restrain Additionalsecuriry and scene and aa on scene anived on officers arrived uniformed officers Several uniformed assistance. Several Department additionat assistance. for additional was contacted contacted for Department was Harden Mr. was on the advised spitting l officers. and the was Harden Mr. was spitting on the the between ensued Harden Mr. the was advised struggle strúggle ensued between Mr. Harden and the oflicers. t with it Mr. on unsuccessful hood but sock were placing placing with it on Mr. a who officers spit were unsuccessful protective deployed a protective spit sock hood but ultimately deployed ofliðers who ultimately oleoresin issued utilized his officers capsicum of the that received department capsicum one Information issued oleoresin was Harden. department Harden. Information was ieceived that one of the officers utilized his to the the scene. scene. After After aa to respond respond.to requested to and requested was contacted contactcd and during Aid was First Aid Township First Howell Township struggle. Howell during the the struggle. have be would sedated to to Harden Mr. that determined it and secured was Harden have to be sedated to Mr. would was lengthystruggle, lengtñy struggte, Mr. Harden was secured and it was determined that Mr, Harden administer the could aid first Before sedation, Center. Medical Shore him could administer the sedation, to safely University Medical Center. Before first aid transport him to Jersey Jersey Shore University safãyirunspõrt where he and was Center where he Medical Center Harden became unresponsive Mr. Shore University University Medical Jersey Shore to Jersey was transported transponed to unresponsive and Mr. Hardenbecame in involved the who staff were and directly officers the advised that involved deceased. I in the security was was advised that the officers and security staff who were directly pronounced deceased. I was was pronounced Police Howell the incident Township Police Headquarters. Headquarters. presently at at the HowellTownship were presently incident were SCEEE: SCENE: the main was located into the the Priedaine Priedaine entrance into The main entrance north of of the located north parking area event was used for for the the event area used The main main parking temporarily utilized utilized to was temporarily to area that that was field // grass area paved lot, was aa large large field lot. itit was Society. parking area was not not aa paved area was The parking Society. The brush. As and trees heavy surrounded The heavy was overgrown brush. large vehicles. area by As trees and oYergrown large parking by surrounded parking was guest's area The park gr".f'r vehicles. park the túe Observed on on occurred. Observed incident occurred. the incident stated placed around where the the area area where around the was placed yellow crime scene tape tape was crime scene earlier, yellow stated earlier, dust a a mask, used and protective both of gloves, protective new protective medical gloves, a dust mask, waste protective a the consisting was and used both new ground of waste consisting the ground was medical documented The scene utilizing aa photogtaphically documented utilizing a non-rebreather was photographically scene was mask, The protective and a non-rebreather mask. hood, and protective spit sock hood, spit sock All ofthe unit. flash EXll 580 were images with Canon a in All of the images were unit. EOS 7D flash Elan conjunction Cation EXll camera, 5S0 digital with a Canon in conjunction b"non Elan EOS 7D digital retained disc and on a Scene Unit, Crime Office. compact Prosecutor's Monmouth on a compact disc retained the and at Unit, Scene County Crime Office. developed developed at the Monmouth County Prosecutor's details. It should be additional for Photo Uniform the Report Refer to details' lt should drive. be hard additional forensic for and Report appended Photo and foiensic hard drive. Refer to the appended Uniform forensic the for utilized investigation. the camera was that same known known that the same câmera was utilized for the forensic investigation. familiar with was familiar with Mr. event, was Mr. the event, planning the II was with planning who assisted assisted with Baker, who Ms. Priscilla Priscilla Baker, that Ms. was advised advised that and she the event at Harden Mr. was volunteering that team eve¡t gave the and the advised at she Harden. investigating team that Mr. Harden was volunleering Ms. Baker Baker advised the investigating Harden, Ms. filled out by Ms. Ms. Baker. Baker. authorizing authorizing out by was fÌlled Search fonn form was Mr. to Search A Consent Consent to tent. A her tent. permission to to utilize utilize her Harden permission Mr. Harden I900 Ms. hours, At tent. of her search conduct approximately a to 1900 hours, Ms. Baker Baker of the members team to conduct a search of her tcnt. At approximately investigative team the investigative members of exterior and tent’s interior. the documented I her tent. exterior and to interior. escorted photographically documented the tent's and me me to her tent. I photographically Boiza and Detective Bozza escorted Detective of evidential was retained value was retained from from evidential value In tent. Nothing Nothíng of of the the tent. the interior interior of searched the Baker,II searched presence of of Ms. Ms, Baker, the presence In the information. fiirther for form Search Consent to the Refer to information. of the tent. fr¡nher search for the appended Search form to Consent the appended Refer to tent. the search of the that were the incident were‘ in the_incident were involved in were involved the s_ecurity_guardss that of the that two two of learned that Detectiv_e_ Bozzs learned Detective Bozza_ ‘Reporting ReportinB Detective Dctective zurm LOUIS LOUIS ZI.IPPA Dale Dato ol‘_Repor1 ofRepoñ Reporting Detective Detective Signature Si gnature Reporting gut Úr'.r. Acþ .,dg°w_, 3lrn at 4 /4.7 tøz to/ts/zois I 0/15/t015 _ Supervisor Signature Supervisor Signature {)9__ lt¡-@ 0*- {),‘@° Prosecutor's File 0042 Prosecutor's File 0042 Filed 08/04/16 Page 44 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1079 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed ()¡.1'l( l' Y i' {().\ 7.( lt ‘l'()R'.\ ()l .\' .\'l()\.7\II)l" ' l l()lì'\ ()I“ "I(' ". \ l\'l'l{()sl.( \l()\\l()t lll (( (H @ ’/l'/ /4 ii 1 .-"R" i( i.;! /'4 i,t) ,.,i !; /2‘! .,/,/,, ' Cascti Casc# FN 5-00197 FN Ir 5-00197 page Page 30/4 3of4 Promis Promis Gavelfl 6avel# and I responded lo the the additional add itiona responded to at aa secondary Bozza ând Detective Bozza parki ng area. working a rea. Detective secondary parking working at who Toth to with Mr. agreed Bozza Detective Toth who to be agreed be Toth. briefly Brian spoke with Mr located and parking parki ng area arca and located Brian Toth. Detecti ve Bozza spoke briefly that advised he who Toth was Mr. documented I adv sed that he was who Toth the of photog raph ically docu mented Mr part of the investigation. invest igation I photographically photographed âs part photographed as deta ils. additional details. for additional Repon for Ph oto Report not Un form Photo appended Uniform the appended Refer to to the lnc ident. Refer the incident. d un ng the not injured nJu red during currently on cu rrently on scene scene Mr. Neri Neri agreed agreed to to be be Neri. Mr. Detective Andrew Neri. with Andrew spoke with and briefly briefly spoke then located located and Bozza then Detective Bozza advised who he that Neri Mr. documented was as part of photographically documented Mr. Neri who advised that he was investigation. II photographically photographed of the the investigation. photographed as details. the appended for additional additional details. Photo Report Report for not Uniform Photo appended Uniform to the incident. Refer Refer to the incident. during the inluróO during not injured POLICE DEPARTMENT: H()WF.l..L POLICE DEPART$ÞNT: HOWELL of the the investigative investigative Members of At Department. Members Police Department. the Howell Howelt Police at the 1930 hours, hours, II arrived arrived at At approximately approximately I930 The incident. in the involved officers following and following the incident. The 1 in the that guards security involved team guards officers and photograph te.r requested r.qu"ntld that I piotograph the security documented: were : photographically security guards were photograph ical ly documented security guards _ 1. D.O.B f Cruz, D.O.B. I. Brandon Brandon Cruz, 2. Castillo, 13.0.13. D.O.B 2. Daniel Daniel Castillo, ‘ in the under his his Iefi left eye by by the face face under punched_in While he was was punched that he advised that Mr. Cruz Cruz advised Mr. Cruz, CruA Mr. photographing Mr. While photographing Cruz’s Mr. documented I face, Mr' Cruz's face, restrain. a photographically scale, to documented the Utilizing a scalen I photographically ãttempting to restrain. Utilizing he was was attempting subjeot he the subject specifically his left Iefr eye. under his area under the area specifically the The documented: photographically documented: to be be photographically agreed to officers agreed The following following officers #644 1. Conaty, badge badgø#644 Jim Conaty, L Jim #647 2. Bonner, badge badge#647 2. Vincent Vincent Bonner, 3. Murphy, badge #643 badge #643 3. Daniel DanielMurPhY, 4. badge #645 #645 Migdon, badge 4. Michael Michael Migdon, 5. #654 badge #654 Austin, badge Nicholas Austin, 5. Nicholas the incident. incident. Officer during the Officer capsicum during It oleoresin capsicum his oleoresin Conaty deployed deployed his Officer Conaty that Officer teamed that It was was learned and retained as his from belt, photographed, removed photographed, and duty retained as belt, oleoresin duty was voluntarily removed from his Conaty’s capsicum was voluntarily Conaty,s oleoresin capsicum evidence. evidence. belt duty belt Conaty's duty I5-0577-5-4 from Officer Officer Conaty’s capsicum fiom oleoresin capsicum brand oleoresin RED brand SABRE RED 15-0577-5-4 SABRE asked if had sustained sustained any if they they had the officers, offtcers, II asked documenting the photographically documenting Additionally, while photographically Additionally, while None of officers documented. be could None of the their the officers incident so the incident result of photographically dooumented, injuries could be photographically as a so their inþries injuries äithe a resulr injuries as incident. the that they involved they were were injured during the incident. injured during me that advised me involved advised ..l Reporting Detective Reporting Detective LOUIS ZUFPA LOUIS ZUPPA gnature Reporting Detective Signature Reporting Detective S ELM aw Þl"Ì¿o',à i 3!..¡ç4øt .1 /57 Date Report Date of ofRepon lo/ls/zols t0nsl20l5 Supervisor Sigtrture Supewisor Signature. [EA 5‘ {),__ 0*f\¡-@ ‘ ‘ I Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0043 0043 Filed 08/04/16 Page 45 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1080 'l'()ll"s ()I"I“I( l". ()l''l"l('l' ‘l ' ‘()R'S 'R( )S '(('t ( ()l VIN" \l()\.\'lUl" Yl \' l¡lì.()sl \l()\\l()t lllII ('()I @ l/-.'/l .‘!'\/Ilt 'l«' -’/I r,rr,'r'\ ¡ii ',ll'.'' Ii IX’/.."v Casefl Casc# page Poge 4of4 4 of4 Promis Gavellt Promis Gavcl# l5-OOI97 FN FN15.00197 deposited items into Prosecutor’s Office and into following items the Monmouth and deposited the following II then to lhe Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office then responded responded to Vault: Evidence Unit’s Forensic the Temporary Evidence Vault: the Forensic Unit's Temporary County SUMC colored shorts victim at at JJSUMC 15-0577-5-1 from victim removed from shor.ts removed Black colored 15-0577-5-l Black at JSUMC JSUMC victim at 15-0577-5-2 from victim removed from underuear removed cotored underwear Black colored l5-0577-5-2 Black black colored colored pocket of victim's black of Victim’s right pocket from right 15-0577-5-3 removed from lighter, removed brand lighter, BIC brand Red colored colored BIC ts-0577-5-3 Red shorts JSUMC at JSUMC shorts at beh duty belt Conaty's duty capsicum from Officer Conaty’s from Officer 15-0577-5-4 oleoresin capsicum brand oleoresin RED brand SABRE RED lS-0577-S-4 SABRE postmoñem the postmortem attended the and II attended Bozza and Detective Bozza 2015, at approximately 1000 On hours, Detective 1000 hours, 6,2015,a1approximately September 6, On September Diane Karluk Dr. conducted by at the the was conducted by Dr. Diane Karluk at examination was examination postmortem examination the postmortem tlarden. The Timothy Harden. of Timothy examination of Karluk’s Dr. at the examination, of various at Dr. Karluk's Office. examination, stages the Examiner's of During Medical stages various During Middlesex office. County Middlesex County Meãical Examiner's that the evidence. Dr. additional items advised that the Karluk advised Dr' Karluk of evidence. items of cotlecred additional and collected direction, the victim victim and photographed the àirrrt¡o", II photographed will be The details. further for report Karluk’s be The reportwill Dr. details' Refer to further report for death of report were Kartuk's pending. Dr. and to pending. manner Refer cause unå runn.r-of death were *u* date. later file at a the case to appended appended to the case file at a later date. placed into into the the examination, placed postmortem examination, of evidence the postmortem during the The collected during were collected evidence were items of following items The following for secured and labeled transport: collection fortransport: evidence secured envelopes. and appropriate virgin evidence collection envelopes. labeled appropriate virgin received at I5-0577-5-5 autopsy at autopsy card, received FTA card, Victim's FTA ß-a577-5-s Victim’s at autopsy autopsy received at 15-0577-5-6 fingerprints, received and right right fingerprints, leff and Victim's lefi 15-0577-5-6 Victim’s County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Monmouth County the Monmouth in the was secured secured in same day, Later evidence was listed evidence the above above listed day, the this same Later this Vault. Evidence Forensic Unit’s Office Temporary Evidence Vault. Unit's Temporary OfTice Forensic County Monmouth County to the the Monmouth was delivered delivered to investigation was 2015, all this investigation On October to this relared to evidence related all evidence 15,Z0lS, October 15, On Monmouth the County Refer to appended Monrnouth County for safekeeping. Refer to the appended prosecutor's Office Main Evidence Vault Prosecutor’s Vault for safekeeping. Office Main Evidence further assistance requested. assistance requested. no further was no Prosecutor’s prosecutor,s Office There was Receipt. There Evidence Receipt. office Evidence Reporting Detective @i4Detective LOUIS ZUPPA LOUIS zurm _' Repomng Signature Dctective Signature Rcpoding Detective E»: ü*.^" Þ;Ë 890% raz 3þ.6ç 4 ((37 at Date Report of Roport Date of 10/15/2015 l0/l5/20ls §upervisor Signature Suþcnvisor §ignatuT: [jkq-5‘ 09” û*l)*@ Prosecutor's File 0044 0044 Prosecuto/s File Filed 08/04/16 Page 46 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1081 3:15-cv-08r043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed UNIFORM TTNIFORTT ._. pnoro REPORT PHOTO REPORT . ._. . FN #215-00197 FN#:1Þ00197 Harden SUBJECT: Timothy ImolhyHardcn SUBJECT: JURISDICTION: Townshrp Honell Township JURISDICTION: Howell DATE DATE PHOTOGRAPHED: PHOTOGRAPHEOI 9/6/15 9/6/1 5 INCIDENT: Dr6lh Investigation lnv€stigatlon INCIOËNT; Death SERIAL #: CDIDVD CDiDVD SERTAL ti 00001797490 00001797490 MEDIA DIGITAL TYPE(S)J DIGITAL MEDIA TYPE(S): TOTAL lft{AGEs: 0142 ÎOTAL IMAGES: 0142 PROCESSING FTSU PROCESSING POINT: POINT: MCPO MCPO I-TSU CAMERA MAKBMODEL: CANON CANON ELAN ELAN EOS EOS 7D 70 DIGITAL DIGITAL CAtvlÊRA MAKEIMODEL: FLASH/CAMERASHUTTER/APERTURE: VARIED FLASHICAMERA SHUTTERYAPERTURE: VARIED EXII FLASH FLASH CANON 580 FI¡SH UNIT UNIT FLASH MAKE/MODEL: liAXËr[,tODEL: CANON 580 EXll LENS LENGTH: VARIED VARIED FOCAL LENGTH; LENS FOCAL INCIDENT DATE: 9/511 INCIDENT DATE: 9/5/155 EXII FLASH CONDITIONS: INDOORS WEATHERILIGHTING FTASH UNIT UNIT INDOORS I/ CANON CANON 580 580 EXll WEATÞ ERÂIGHTING CONDITIONS: IMAGE IMAGE NUMBER NUMSER PHOTO PI{OTO DESCRIPTION DESCRÍPTION ' I -0090 IMG_0(IO rMG*0001-0090 IMG_0091-0142 rMG 0091-0142 (‘_A__I_3_ HOTOGRAPH DEEIETINQISHOWING. ') TIMOTHY IIARDEN'S AUTOPSY TIMOT}fi' HARDF.N’S AU'TOPSY ._ Overalls ol'victinr Overalls ofvictim Photographs of Dr. Kurluk Karluk the direction directíon oI'Dr. Photographs taken t¿ken at at the EXHIB]T /ryc P,tI ¿17- 1

t DATË. LC_.__ _'°.69.E_? 1. 93'‘ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's F Iee 0045 0045 Filed 08/04/16 Page 47 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1082 UNIFORM UNIFORÛT REPORT PHOTO PHOîO RTPiORT Howell Township JURISDICTION: TownshiP JURISDIGTION: Hottoll Hanion SUBJECT: TimothYHadan SURIECT: Tlmolhy #115-00197 FN FN#:1540197 g5/15 INCIDENT DATE: 9/5/15 INCIDENT DATE: DATEPHOTOGRAPHED: 9/115 ÖAfE PHOTOGRAPHED: 9/5/15 INCIDENT: lnì/tsti€stion Ot.th Investigation ItICIDENT: Death CDIDVD #: 00003437901 0(X)03437901 CD/D\D SERIAL SËRIAL #: MEDIA DIGITAL TYPE(S): DIGITAL MEOIA TYPE(S): 90 TOTAL TOTAL IMAGES: II AGES 90 PROCESSING FTSU ifCPO IWSU PO{NT; MCPO PROCESSING POINT: CAMERA 7D DIGITAL EOS 7D DIGITAL ELAN EOS CANON ELAN iAXÉ/MOOEL: CANON CAMÉRA MAKEIMODEL: SHUTTERIAPERTURE: VARIED FLASH/CAMERA VARIED FI-ASIUCAMERA SHUTTËFVAPËRTURE: FLASH UNÍT 5ô0 EXII EXU FLASH F áSH UNIT CANON 530 ITAKEÄ ODEL: CANON FLASH MAKE/MODEL: LENS VARIED LENGTH: VARIED FOCAL LENGTH: LENS FOCAL UNIT INDOORS /I CANON WEATHER/LIGHTING FLASH UNll EXll FLASH 580 EXII CANON 580 CONDInol{s: INoOORS wEATHER/tlCHTlt¡G CONDITTONS: IMAGE r[tAoE NUMBER NUMBER pHoro DESCRIPTION PHOTO oEscRlpTloN CA PHQLQERAPH 9I.5P'°T.'NG’§’iQW'NCi_-J _ IMG_0001-0020 tMG_000¡-0020 IMG_0021-0033 IMC_0021-0033 IMG_0034-0047 IMG_003+0047 IMG_0048-0057 tMG_0048-0057 IMG_0058-0067 rMc_00584067 IMG_0068-0080 tMG_0068-00t0 IMG_0081-0090 IM6_00E1-0090 RTMENT DEPA HOWELL PARTMENT POI HOWELL POLICE Officer Brandon Security Cruz Brandon Cruz Securiry Officer Castillo Daniel Officer Castillo Security Daniel Security Oflicer police Officer O.C. Police beh and and O.C. duty belt Conaty I/ Ofiiccr Conaty's duty Ofticcr Conaty’s Jim Conaty öflicer Jim Police Vinccnt Bonner Bonncr Police Ofiicer Officcr Vincent Officer Police Daniel Murphy MurPhY Police Offrcer Daniel Police Migdon Michsel Migdon Policc Officer Officcr Michael Austin Nicholas Officer Police Polícc Officer Nichol¡s Austin CASE JACKET JACKÊT LOCATION CO/DVD; CASE OF ORIGINAL ORIC IÛ{L CDIDVD: LOC¡lTlOl.l OF JACKET LOCATION Of OF PI-IOTOGRAPHSICONTACTSHEET: CASE N1/r/gr; te /t.r/tr PAGE: PAGE: 11 OF 1 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0046 0046 Filed 08/04/16 Page 48 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1083 UNIFORM UT{IFORM PHOTO RÞPORT PHOTO REPORT 2 — JURISDICTION: Hoûell Township Townsh¡P JURISÞlCTlON: Howell SUBJECT: Hardon Ilmolhy Harden SUBJECT: Timothy FN FN #:15-00197 l:1540197 .- INCIDENT INCIDENT DATE‘ DATE' 9/5/15 9/å/15 975/155 DATE PI.IOTOGRAPHED: 95/1 DATE PHOTOGRAPHED: INCIDENT: Dsalh lnvostigatlon Oeath lnvesligatlon INCIDENT: CDIDVD #i 00001797474 04001797474 SERIAL #2 CD/DVD SERIAL MEDIA DIGITÀL MÊD A TYPE(S): TYPE(S): DIGITAL TOTAL 10f llüqËEs: 101 TOTAL IMAGES: PROCESSING FTSU MCPo FTSU P0INT: MCPO PROCESSING POINT: CAMERA 7D DIGITAL DIGITAL EI-AN EOS EOS 7D CANON ELAN i¡IAKFJMODEL: CANON CAMERA MAKEIMODEL: FLASHICAMERA VARIED SIiUTTËR/APÊRTURÉ VARIED FI.ASIVCAMERA SHUTTERIAPERTURE: FLASH UNIT FLASH UNIT EXII FLASH 580 EXII FI.ASH MAKEIMODEL: MAKE/IIOOEI: CANON CANON 580 LENS VARIED FOCAL LENGTH: LENGTH: VARIED LENS FOCAL EXII FLASH CANON 580 WEATHER/LIGHTING FLASH UNIT UI'¿IT 580 EXII OUTOOORS I/ CANON CONDIlIot.¡s: OUTDOORS YVEATTIER/I,IGHïNG CONDITIONS‘. IMAGE IiÍAGË NUMBER NUMBER PHOTO DESCRIPTION PHOTO DESCRIPTION SCENE SCENE IMG_0001-0031 IMG_0001-0011 IMG_0032-0056 IM0_0032-005ó IMG_0057-0079 rMG_0057-0079 IMG_0080-0090 tMc_00E0-0090 IMG_0091-0101 ¡MC_0091-0101 (‘A PI-IOTO_G_RAPH DEPICT NC_3l_SHO}N NG...') ” of parkirtg Overalls parking lot scene lot // scene Ovcrafls of medical waste / Scene wsste / medicsl Scene Search Ms. Consent Baker's lent Ms. Priscilla Priscilla BaI¢r,url l etc.) ¡umbcr etc.) MIl¢e.color,sizt-,mudel nu (Le. No. No. I5-0577-5-I ts-0511 -5-l viclim nl at JSUMC JSUMC Black colored ñom victim rcmoved fmm ¡ho¡t¡ removed colorcd shons I5-0577-5-2 t5-0517-5-2 at JSUMC victim ¡t JSUMC from victim am æmovcd fmm ¡urdøwc¡r nemoved colo¡td underwear Blrck colored I5-0577-5-3 ts4571-5-3 colored shons at JSUMC colored BIC brand lighter. removed from right pocket of victim's black Red RcdcolorcrlBlCbørdlightcr,ranovcdfromrightpockctofvictimbbltckcolomd6hofs¡tJSUMC 5>0577-5-4 ts.057?.54 bclt dury bcll cìon¡ty's duty brand oleorain olliccr (‘.onaIy's fTom Omcer capsicum finm SABRE ofcortsin crprcunr RED brud SABRE RED I5-0577-5-5 r5-0577-5-5 II uulupsy attlopsy Victim's I-‘TA surd, ICI.‘t‘IVL‘d touetvcrl rt l'l'Å curd, Victirrr's I5-0577-5-6 t5-0577-5-6 ct uuuapsy ¡lut()Pr-) rccrlitcd ul \"icl m'.\ tìngcrprllìts, rucciwd nght fingerpnnLs. lcll and und nghl \rictrnfr lull LOUIS Delivered by .- ZUPPA. LOUIS ÐcllvæodbY: Pr1nrName Pdnt Neme §èv{ It ‘-1 I’: ,b Dale:W /J:/5 fJ'/r" om .- 9/ao/2015 Mum Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0049 0049 Filed 08/04/16 Page 51 of 100 PageID: :£1ase3;15.-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Page D: 1086 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed MONMOUTH Office County Prosecutor's Progecutot's Office fllONi¡IOUTH County EVIDENCE EVIDENCE RECEIPT RECEIPT Ð I l Case Caso lnfonnation lnformavon County County MONMOUTH MONMOUTH Submlt COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH MONMOUÍHCOUNTY õuÞmltAgoncy PROSECUTOR PROSËCUTOR Munlolpallty TWP iltunlolpallty HOWELL HOWELt TWP Case Case Number N umber Information I nfotmøtlon IIWIPD Cùr ## 1-_ _f_»i >15-D01_7_7 lnvrPD Cue 77 /1_5-397i15‘ t1b.39715 PGICSI Ca¡ot Case 0 i_________‘PG/CSI Log Log infonnation lnformatÍon # Evidence 15-0577 Evldence Property Property # 15-0577 Unlt Unlt QENERAL INVESTIGATION Incident Date 8: Time 00:00 09/05/2016 lncldent Dato & T¡mo _ _ _ _ 7 _ _ _ _ _ _ i_ J, _ __ Batch Batch # # Incident lncldont Offense OñanBs Incldant LocåUon lncld6nt Location M Evidence Evidcncc llem llcnr Cuicgory Crlcgory . úl¿o did cunluining uilîl video iluJio and iltttf urnliu ipliuu: one cu,t¡.t¡ilittE mvr utt¿ ¿lvú nb culcgury: l¡¡'iuf duacl d r!cri¡rliutt: qürtll it¡: i brim-I" tlvtl quanliiy: cÍ1380 fy¡ tlwi no recovered recovered velriclc number 09. is biohnzurd: lto boltzgefinrrn njji 'lMl.‘EIIi bonncr's /mrrai vlncenl iJanm'r's ¡unrol s¿hìcle uanbe¡ 09. ig biolr¡zcrdl Aumo/WDFO ‘V ArJnro/v¡D110 . ‘ l.'.\ l'i-lG( R\ Dli() rA t.1.0(tR :Al Di( /\" DEO tmdìo vld¿n rmrl ßt,d muiio trrlf virlrm dutl rnnmin conloh, Imvr orr( dud uh fîrim-gory: hrlef de crrlnflnn one q nÍ ntitv: l hrlofdeerriptinnz dtd qlmniitv: teqôrv (Ml date rd: no biohazn & is t$ patrol date & 22. w:ln'cIe tro recovered rccovercd rd: an.rrin's z¡ ts oha 22, bi niclmias palrol t'chicle øhstln rmlage_/ram o_[fl oll nlcholos , ,\ AUUIUI iUbU AUUIUi I‘ who 77 _l_2 '5_n5 t-fi577.1.2 ‘ ’ _ Þc6rlJd tIlþ.ruIion, (Evidên€. Typc) I ; _ _ __ _ or y Evidcncclmncnie Evideucc Itc,rt Ctlcgot'Y [MD r"l'¡‘I I i-ui;I H ’ T " _ _ Defendants Defendants licm llcm Tm ' ' _ Unit §§_i;i_i_Efx_AV __>iN\iE5>Ti\3is‘i'@ .GÉ.1-'€E4!i.l!y!9llür,IiÛÌt 0000 09/05/'20i5 incident 20 i 5 00'0Û & Time Tinre 091t5i Date 8lncldent Dale Numb" Numbcr ' "— —"—" ' ‘Ea — " _‘_n_l_c && Iirnc: 09/07'/20155 00:00 CATF1GOR\’:Alli)l()I‘\r‘im3O CA oil¿ titl¿o utnlìo rurtIvi1lr'n ,l^'r umlin ¡lul ('nnIrn'niu_q aantnínìug nn-r hticf d¡r¡¡i ¡rlinrt nm- IfI'rI =uhh rnlrgnryr qtsnt¡ly: l hrioifliwcrlpiinnz tlv¡l qimnriiyz cûlcgnrY; Ilvrl no is hiolmznrd: 28. number rccolc¡'ed I-chirle Ito recovered rd ATÍI 28. ìs bioh nuilter rv.hìdc conar_yjr’spatrol foorngzflarrioflijarrres cortaAt Jr's Pnrnl {ront _ __ _ V __ _ ____ ____ __ _ _ _ __ __ “U1-‘U Aumul AtruturvllJbu 1.4 '3l-Ui U)” / /-l-4 . I _ _ dale 8: time: limc: 09/07/2015 00:00 Oil\':.«\UDIONI D ICU CATEG CA vkleo ond video nlvt audio audio and dltd containing contnlning mvr briefdescrlptlon: on¿ dvd -ml) ul:-gory: dwl descrlptlon: on: qurnllty: 1I brief ¡htrl quantity: no blohnzard: is rccovcrcd 31. number no recovered vehicle blob¡zsrd: It nnntber 31, daniei rnurplry'spaIroi pãlrol v¿hlcle of]? nurpltyts faamgefrain ol\ danlel Me 8: time: 09/07/2015 5 00:00 r:An:<;onv:A1Ioio/viom ttitl¿o orrd video atullo and nn'r amllo co¡ttqlt l,tg mvr dvtl containing orte dvd brlcf description: sub category: dcscription: one q u¡nll ty: i brief dvtl quantity: cetcßory: divd Ito relrlcic number 07. is biohzunrd: no oflf lreatlrer from oJr. hcalher .sr:In:rbiu.rln"spurruir¿hlcle muúc¡ 07. is biohnz¡rd: date Sr rccovcrcd d¡tc & iirnc: 09/07.-C20155 00:00 CA'l’[~‘.GOR\':M Di0l\’lDl-20 video audio and øud vldeo lion: one tfll,Í audio cou!ølnîng mvr otte dud dvtl containin uanli :1I brief dwl qu¡nl¡tY: sill) cal: descrlption: 11 : dvtl brlef descri c8 recovered no is 05. number rccovered no ls blohrr¡rdl weg pofiol vehlcle uumber 05. off olï s8L lhotnøs wegpatroi lillit & & lime: l¡nte¡ 09/07/20lS 00:00 __ ____' _ _ AUDIO/VIDEO AUDIÚ/VIÜEO 5"0577'l'5 I 5"057i-l -5 — -6 15-05774 t5-0577-l-6 Aumo/VIDEO AUDIO¡/IDEÔ 15-0577-1'7 ß-a577-l-7 AUDIO/VIDEO AUDIOTVIDEO IS-0577-l-8 154577-l-8 AUDIO/VIDEO AUDIO/VIDEO Property bY: Delivered by: Property Delivered bY: Property Received by: Property Received footage faoragejeagrr s;-It. rhontrym , R 3:‘ A E __ biohfizard: velilrlcie CATI~‘.GORY:AUDlONlDE() 911 callr calls ol9lI autllo of the audio dlg1 containing the oile disc dcscriPtion i one ub category: dvd bricf description: quantityr 1I brief dvd quantity: dntc & time: 09/07/M15 00:00 inn! n0 rccovcrui radio rrurrsnrlssions. is ls lziuhmunrd: no L. /A-’gfi:.Tz:i:::r; 4"‘, t. ií , Signature Srgnature Date: Date: BOZZA, JR. DANIEL JJ JR‘ BAZZJ', DANIEL 09/17/2015 13:52 0911712015 13:52 _ Frini Fti¡tl Name liann /.;' ./. - 00:00 timc: Date: Date: GAUGHRAN. JOHN GAUGHRAN. JOHN ., 7 — 09/17/2015 13:52 0911712015 13:52 ?—————_.§ - Print Name Print Name Page of 1 Page 11 of 1 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0051 0051 Filed 08/04/16 Page 53 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1088 MONMOUTH Office County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office MONMOUTH County RECEIPT EVIDENCE RECEIPT EVIDENCE Case Cese Information lnlormation Submit COUNTY MÛNMOUi-H COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH Submit Agency TWP Municipality Municípality HOWELL HOWELLTWP County fvIONMOUTH County MONMOUTH PROSECUTOR PROSËCUTOR Case f{umôer lnformation Case Numberlnformation _97_‘i_5 f G 15-0O1_f{g~I_1”§>;_Zi ç11 5-001'731U--.3J:u-1! lnvIPD Case lnv/PD Case# FGlCSiCase# PG/CSI Case # // Log Log Information lnformatton Evidence Properly Ptopet'ty ii# Evlcler:ce UN‘ Unlt Incldenl & Time lncldent Date Date 3. Tíme ~"mh:r. ___V _iii_:r§ZjV 5-0577 _F_3_E.fl-’*Ul‘{\£§§I.i_.CiE\T_‘ 9.._N., ffi I ffi09/o5r2oT5"6o:oo _7 _ 4 _ 7r~=v°rr'='«55"rv'51‘>'°“°" E "“dc .; ltem Cotcgory Elidcncc . _ A_____ _7 _ __ -_ 0377 2 1 [3 t 5.0577-2-l _ V ___ W Defendants Ðefendants Item Item Nrrmbcr _ _ _ __ ._ ' _ Batch Båtch It# '“°'d°'“°"°"5° lnc¡dont Oftense Incident Locallon lncldent Locarron E0UCJ'”EV*EW POTICY FEVIEW ___ ‘____ ‘_ __ __ _ 1 _ - 1017 STATE HIGHWAY 233. HOWELL, NJ . _ Lil tót _rjowE#NJo77_ar HOWELL, ________ _ hfqfm¡tior, ebdv dcßribÈ llcscrlpdon Pi-‘5¢ jlP“°" Ssit¡ tù¡nb.r, t{¡tc, I'lodcl. ct( i c. ¡nt _, lrd¡tþlfGd@ Contact/Recovered Contâct / Recovere¡l by b¡' __ _ (‘ATEGOR (.-¡\TUGOR V:/\UDI()l\’IDi-‘.0 Vr  l ll)l(l/1{ nRf} 3 telephone rclePhone description: 1disc containing cot,tu¡,¿¡ng 3 I- disc sub quantitS': 1I brief brieftlcscrlption: cd andla audlo quantity: sub category: cstegor'!'¡ ed d: lrurr all lunllallip lriul¡r¿r¡,.l: pulice rlrirpuu/I. lìtputú, 3.5ir biuir:u..~u ¢.unm:I5rrlir»ir.r tørushìp puliuc gruun uml øul lut'úl tthll)t ¿Íct:tt L4Í can ¿ell /may rutn'¿ß.ilhrlt Imn 09/21/20155 00:00 recovered 0A:00 rccovarcd (late tletc 8r & time: ümtt 0îf2l/201 AUDIO/V1DEO AUDIOTVIDEO _ _ Dcb¡l€d lEvidcrce Typc) _._;§___A__ 2- Mu r¡¿ _#_ _ __ $9‘ :'”“'-="§"';-lg6 //“5",3,'.-"...”77*‘5/' 2/ Property Delivered Delivered by: bY: Property _ -' "'_,/+____,. Signature Signatura " _ Property bY: Recelved by: PropeÉy Received - Date: Date: BOZZA. JR. DANIEL JJ JR. ïOZZA, DANIEL 09/22/2015 13:48 0912212015 13:48 _-—— . . ._.- .-»—_—_ _. _ [1 t' (/ /;///’/__..~ I Print Nême Pr¡nt Name BARNER. JEFFREY BARNËR. JEFFREY 09/22/2015 13148 09122ì2015 13:48 Date: Dale: V Slyrraiura _ _ _ _ H‘ Prinl Pt'i;tl l‘~J.:r.'na îla:na Page 11 of of 11 Pago Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0052 0052 3:15-cv-08043-I3RM-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 54 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1089 MONMOUTH Office Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor’s MONMOUTH County EVIDENCE RECEIPT EVIDENCE RECEIPT c'a§o—Ifi6rmatran" 1- Case Case Numberlnformation Number I nformation lnv/PD /1 5-397 I5 .§—;'49_715 case ## §l_1>_‘._i:Qi_II172_/1_’ lnv/PD Case PGICS Case# PG/CSI Case # I Log lnformation Log Information ______ Evidellce Ptr.rperty # # Evide¡tce Propeily Unlt Urìlt Incident & Tlme lncldent Date Date &Time 15-057? 5,0577 1 _ _ PROSECUTOR PROSECUTOR _ __ _> ___ AV _____ ‘ Balchfl Batch # Incident lncident Offense Offense Incident Locatlon lncident Location _ 00:00 09/05/2015 09/05/t015 00:0û __.5___________________l _ Defendants Ðefendants E\,;dc; 3 W’ Categor¡' ltcm C Evidcncc mm (Evidcnce __ I7-3-2 “-03 r 5.()5??.3-2 - . ‘k ‘ “'03 ' N‘ t-i-0s7i"3-3 ., i , _ _ I , _. I trlskc, Contact/Recovered Contnct / Rccoïercd L»by [lodtl .tc Ltütlv dðrloa t[v orqhþ[( _ CATEGORY:IIllSCEI.L!\NE0I.IS ìu) ts biuI1uLmI; no ¡r¡¿¡Åt' rlscd an .\'cr:m:. is quantity: 2 ln‘IcI dcscriplluu: nvo- ¢'.\'r:ru;:Ic H95 Inuslw (.‘A' ‘EC0I{Y:l\lISC ‘2I.l..4\NE0US CA nn Is hlnhnznrd: rrrrçl' lç hlnhnz¡rd: øn qunnlliy: JI brief dutrlplion: nm- 4-xnmplr mrglml mark _ . . MISCELLANEOUS NIfSCELLANEOUS _ l¡füo¡lioÊ Dcscri Ption Pl'5\""l-M0" c S.úl Nsnbc¡. __§ _ I.A'\'ICt)l'.< (.‘A'l'I-TQOII\’:MIS(‘IiI ('A )t t.4 urremprerl to ¿n to be be used usul on thut was lptts ttÍl't"tþr¿d uus* mm description: oneo,tXrgat nruxk euonryle o.\ygeu one- example quantity: b¡'ief rlcscription: n¡ity¡ 1,l brief want. is ¡s lIiulnu‘.ur1.I:Mu Ml5_('{:L'L"fl“b0US \“ _ DclsilcJ Ty6) tvIISCELLANHT)US __ .. _V . .- -__, lww MISCELLANEOUS MISCÊLLANEOUS I . ,__ _ . I5-0577-3-I I i.0577-3-l . 0 ___" ‘V _# fl)_g fl___V_‘__ STATE HIGI-KW/\Y I333 HOWELL LL NJ 10177 STA NJ _oH0W_E -L;M9773l HOW ELL. NJ '17731 _ ___,____ _ ___ __ __ i__ '7 F.5EI~II§RA_l. lNVESTIGA1'lOM_ __. _ ‘ " Submit COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH MONMOUIH COUNTY Subm¡tAgoncy IWP Municipality l1OWEtt lwP Munloipality HOWELL County MONMOUTH County MONMOUTH mm llcm ~"'-b~ Nu m bor ‘ E " _ ?'— _ _ ‘ad’ — -'‘~*-' Property by: Dellvered by. Properly Delivered I (_~— I" K ' '7 1 - — — —- xi 7/” :3 -.::-- 'V"""¢'~' y'/t',, ’, .r I r(:C , ‘/2 /-* Ill ïi__,/I0/’ =""‘ ‘I . o _ ,, 09/23/2015 15:35 09/2312015 15:35 Date: Date: GAUGHRAN. JOHN GAUGHRAN, JOHN a/ Signature Signaiure 9/23/2 015 1535 00912312015 15:35 - Print Natne Ptitú Name S/gnafune Slgnaturc Property bY: Rcc€¡ved by: Property Received Date. Date: BOZA, JR. DANIEL JJ JR. BaZZA, DANIEL _ .. , _._.- .-._____ F,-1'...‘ .’/um: Page of 11 Page 11 of Prosecutor's File 0053 0053 Prosecutor's File Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 55 of 100 PageID: 1090 Otfice MONMOUTH Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor’s MONMOUTH County EVIDENCE RECEIPT EVIDENCE RECEIPT -ase /ri$rnia!/on -ase County MONMOUTH MONMOUTH County Submit COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH MONMOUTH COUNTY SubmltAgoncy PROSECUTOR PROSECUTOR Municlpality HOWELLTWP Information Case N umber I nformetî on Cese Number nvlPD /15-39715 Gtf5.00172 /15-39715 Câse 8# gI15-00172 lnv/PD Case case # PG/CSI # g_/ PGICSI Case Log lnformatìon Log Information L Evidence ProPertY if# Evlrtence Properiy Un t Unit Incident & Time Time Date 8 lncldent Date t5l? ___ rf_€_£f_' _‘_f__7_ __f;l;Nifi»_’\_ iN\_‘_ E_STlQA' U ;=vN s q¡¡e n¡l Nvesr cô1¡o_N_ I t _ ‘ I 09/05/2015 00:00 09/05/201 5 00:00 _ ‘_ __ ___v_ _ Batch Eatclr 39# Offense Incident lncident Offense Incident Location lncldent Location i_____________ POLICYY R§ll _E_\4_y' _v_v REVI _________ T î¡l---' - 1017 STATE HIGHW.hY -‘:11 HPIWELL NJ HOWEI-L_i:1;'_0@_ o7731 HOWELL, ‘ __ __ _ _ _‘__ ____ 0 __ __ _ .__ _ , _ _ _r Defendants Ðefendants _ "cm Ifcm mber N" Numhcr Evidence Itcnr Category Category Eridcnce Item 0577-4 1 15 l5-057?4-l MISLELLANEUUS lvllSu'ELLAl.lE0US _ _ "‘ DescrlPtion p°5°'_iplion Þrtûilrd lnfornolion, i c S.rial Numbtr, M¡tc 'Ev'*°== T¡"¡c) lÊvldcncc Wm by b¡' rlcücl, "° dc ‘ r.‘A'I‘l-LGr)R\':A l5CEl.L-\P€EOl. S . . _ N conmcl Contûct I/ Recovered Recovered °"""fflT.’?'2?fTl9?;'53‘-"T,’f“.'l"i.'f'."..'.”i.§T..°.‘é."' . . I ! DET. DANIEL DET. DANIEL i\‘E\‘.'MAI\' ¡\E\¡.r1,'lAì.t l,l,usl¡ ""/he lh¿ (lttÍrl I l{r II In-iclfllescriplionz enuqle mask hr'iel desu'i¡ liott: example "uh unIegor_v: olh¿t (m/.vcu/lnueaus)qunulllyz c¡t legor'-Y: 0/I/er þnìscalloueor rsJ n-.m\'erL-ti: u lmre /Izmlel newnlrm ed rrìfÓ\'€f((l: : zlul. hcre \'.l ¿8rnuil hInh:r/.:u't : I1-cm Im n h_\ is il¿t. fuulel nmrli. h¡ rll'cd tn) I'fC¡ hlohr zurtl cpl! tplt uusk, is & time: tlmer 09/15/2015 00:00 ’!UI1'£‘”IIl'[J.pU}l-1.‘!ffEfllll'u'lHEfHrccmercd dale & land" _ __ I ti 1 ,2" _ _...‘.___/ ¡ t I I lrY: Property Property Delivered Delivered by: ,¡ I ’ nr ..,} "._ —s_ I_:_.:""' t: -2.f; - ;-' -, Signature Signsfure b¡l: Hroperty Recê¡ved by: droperty Received ‘J0 ’__ff‘§ C'l;.-yak’;-5 -.‘.,. -.. Date: Date: NEWMAN, DANIEL NEWMAN, DANIEL » 09/25/2015 14:17 0912512015 14:17 __ . - _._—__.-,.- _ _..._ » .. - Print Prínt Name Nama Date: Date: GAUGHRAN, JOHN JOþIN GAUGHRAN, __ _ 09/25/2015 14i17 09t2512015 14:17 _____V__ L P.-‘En.’ Nam: Page Page 11 of1 of 1 Prosecutor's File 0054 0054 Prosecutor's File 3:15-cv-08043-BR_M-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 56 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1091 MONMOUTH Office Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor's MONMOUTH County EVIDENCE RECEIPT EVIDENCE RECEIPT Case lnformation Casë Infonnation County IVIONMOUTH County MONMOUTH Submit COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH MONMOUTH COUNTY SubmitAgency PROSECUTOR FROSECUTOR TWP Municlpallty HoWEtLTWP Municipallty HOWELL Information Case atÍ on N u ntber lnfornt Case Number lnv/PD /15-39715 Case # # HM15-O_Q1_7_’7 HM15-00177 /I5-39715” lnv/PD Case PGlCSlCase# PG/CSI Câse # / __ __ __ _ _ __€ _ __ __ Evidence 5:7_ ProÞertv ## I_E-_t.' 15.0577 s;ldence Property Unit __GENEfiAL_[tiVEST GAT@________ -"GENERA-L !\yÊs-TtçÁLlo!-"OS/0520f5-00ñõ Incident Oate 8. 8. Time Time 09/05/2015 00:00 tncident Date unit I _> ____ Log lnformatlon Log Information ______ _>______ -- _> Batch Batch ## Incident Offensa lncldent Offense Incident lncldent Location Locst¡on 4__ 4 _ __ POLICY POLICY REV EW_____ 1:33 HFJWEH NJ 1017 17 STATE HIGHWAY _ > __ _ __ HOWELL-_NJ_0_7??a1 HÔWÊLL. NJ o7731 __ ____ > __.__ ltem .“em nfonmtion,li)ec§:r :Pl'f1?nl:>er,Mike,Mad¢l,elc COMM‘ Contûct I/ Rccowrcd llccovercd Dcscriptlon N u In her fiutgber Cstegory ltem Caugory Evidencc “em Evidence. (Ev¡drßc Ty”) Typ.) I5-0577-3-] l5-0577-l-l MISCELIANIFOUS lvllSCFl-l.ANf Ot,S CA't‘EGOR\':t\IISCELIANEOUS CA be used on rryß dßtntrtcil to he nseil an e.\-urupte 0.13-gen t,nsk that ll,tt( Wtl.1'tII/t.’m])It‘l/I0 o)Ð'geil mask otre- exunqle quantity: descrl prl on: mrertR r¡liryl II brief brlef dgscriplionz l5‘0577'3'2 t5-0577-3-2 MISCELLANEOUS MIScELLANE0US_ «fut:tfi$:(;'$‘i::fItfifiEl:h:;:Ef;?0l:l§.L't Imtlt! -,., “~03 ' "'1 -3 r i-üii7-3-3 <1: Mm‘LLLANLUUb l\,1lscËLt,\Ncuus 15-05774“ t5-05774-t MISCELLANEOUS MISCELLANEOUS . , Delailcd Drtôilcd lnfomlior, ic Scti¡l Nunb.t, Àhk., lvlodcl, in detail p¡otùittd wags: ncrpg¡ !¡ dcqil Clearly ¡nv ptolubited Clc¡¡lv describe dc¡cibc lnv ‘fwdflm 1 , . 1'£.'£flr.'. is ¡s by by Êtc _ :IIolt:t7.tu'd: Im two- ('.‘ATliGOR\': \IlS(‘l-Zl.l.ANEOUF tro 1:95 mask: l¡ bluhuzn rd: no wasks used on scene. ls _ qtnunllly: I hrlcf dcscrlplitm: oue- e.\'umph' sttrglcal mn.tA‘_ ;_b o utznrt. :no CA‘l‘EGOR\':I\~llSCF2l.LANEOUS c.{Tscõn11lì¡¡EdELL.{NEoÌ.rs ,,the. nusß ”rIte exouryIe /ttusk dcscr.lptlon,' exatttple cub category: quântiÐ.i 1I brief bricf description: (niscellanao'tJ,,, quantity: olher (mlxcellancous) *r.go'y' other recovered: where dtmlel newman :det. b 'uu recot'ered: recovered F1100!/"5 ìt'hcre no biohnzard: is ttmusk. da,!l!t,tt:Tt'rran 3’ P ís biohrzard: ,t¿ reõo"crcri byt det, 'riri;;iãt,iott. 00:00 09/25/2015 00:00 Iron-ell & time: ¡lmu 09/25/10!; útae 8; rccoycred date tlcpadurctrl recovered \ov.el! nyp. itto, police øolíc¿ department . . I _ __ I _ _ Defendants Ðefendants _ __ DET. DET. DANIEL DANIËL NEWMAN NËWMAN __ ____ _ _ _ - 5 ,f by: Property Delivered bY: Property Delivered I L Proper1yReceIved bY: Property Receivod by: - 5- - " -' 75;. -/’ GAUGHRAN, JOHt'l GAUGHRAN, JOHN “ _ . _jignature !,_... -9ignaluro -ãa — ’ 11/05/2015 09:01 11/05/2015 09:01 __.._ ____;;_:'_‘_,_;,.-; /,6: _ Date: Date: _ "I /:ig.I?s':."=.-'- Print Name Prlnl Name R. BOZZA, DANIELJJ JJR. BOZZA, DANIEL ' D ate. Date: - 09-01 11/o5/2015 I1/05/2015Ú9:01 . .1’-’.'r"n!.’.’a.'n-.= Page of II Page 11 of Prosecutor's File 0055 0055 Prosecuto/s File Filed 08/04/16 Page 57 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1092 MONMOUTH Office County Prosecutor’s MONMOUTH County Prosecutor's Office RECEIPT EVIDENCE EVIDENCE RECEIPT _Case lntormatton Case Information Case Case NumberInformation N u mber I nform atio n ## Unit Unlt Incldent E Tlme llmê lncldont Date Date 8 IE-G577 1E.i577 ___?__‘_____w_._ I5-0577-3-I l5-0i77-3"r MISCELLANEOUS ¡!llSCËLLANEOUS ls-057134 ls-0571.3^2 NHSCEUANEOUS I\,f ISCELLÂNEOUS M[SCELLANEOUs ÀfISCELLANEOUS _ . 3 r‘ —v=..=—:.4 I-. DI:n._,I......_y :I.'F.. '1; L.y Prct:í1! Deli:*i9J .; . . _ __§ _ I # i___ _ Dcscription p"'"iI".i°" 5:rl3l ì'urÉ.t, lirrilld r '"""'t’.:'£j_':{ . , l¡fJm:nor. i _ . I tdr¿ : , .. t:Jil. . _ ___ C°“"‘“/ Conlact / Recovered Rtcovcred by b.r, “° êlc is biohnzard: l¡0 bioh¡zard; mi 2 ht'G tt95 nnsks used on ou scene. ¡c¿¿¿. is FATFGORY:i\‘IISCELLAI\'EOl'S c{TF:GOR\'riltlSCEtL NEO['S Is biohnznrd: rlo qunnmv: runntitr.: If brlcfdescriptinn: brlcfdcscrlnlion: rmtonc- t'_\'flIII[}’(.'.TIlfg’Cfl,"I{l.\"\' evnmnlcs¡tnlcal ¡¡tnskls biohtznrdl no LSCATEGOR\ CEI. LANEOUSquunlity: / brierdescrimion: evample uotk category: ':MlS(miscellaneous) DET. DET, DANIEL DANIËL NEWMAN NE\ùT4AN - — ii ffiHovÆLL-rJJ-_--- CÅTEGOR Ì': ¡}IISCE I,LANEOUS ub c¡lcgory: other olttêt (ruisrrllã,teo,,rt quttr li$': I bricf descriplionz cuample mask "Ihe rub "lhe hood" tthcrc recovered: rccolcrctll uctt,rltrr¡ where recovcred by: by: (let. ilet, rlnniel laníel mswnum hoor!" spit tuosk ls l¡ blohaznrdz lo recovered spll nmsk. bfoh¡z¡rd: no 00:00 09/25/2015 & Iawell my}. r¿covt¡'cd dale d¡lc & time: llm.: 09/2!/2011 00:00 hor¡'cll htn golice nolìce tlzpurmmtt tl¿nudatnl rcco\':rcd L/I —--- '0"/' />_%'(_,__’____:_;,_, "¿:'c/ v .->r>¿ . ‘ " Property Received by: by: Property Received —_ \I ___ _ \TEG0RY:.\IISCELLANEOl7S C C,\TEGORl':ììItSCELL\¡iEOLrS qullunntifr': nnlity: 2 bricfdcscription: bri¡fdcs¿rinlio¡t ho'0- cmmple &ûntÐl¿ n95 lHI1!I(.\‘MJ£d 4-1 150577 t5-0577-4"1 .. __ __ POLICY POLICY REVIEW REVIE'û' 1017' STATE HIGHWAY #33 HOWELL NJ NJ 07731 __I-IQ\LE_ _.L l1qWq-LL-!!-qZr"3l* no Ion on scene. sc¿ne, is is biohaurd: biohezt¡tt¡ uo M1°L‘H‘LANhUU° MIùLËLLANLUI-JS . _ CATEGOR‘r':.\llSCI5LLANI£OLIS CATEC()R\'; ll ISCI¡Ll-l¡ifiOLrS be used t,'ñs artempred to be us¿tl qunnfity: ntlenryted In qu0otib': It brief nosk that lhßl was ouè- awnnple e,couple o.\1!een ost'qet mask brlcf description: descrlptionz om:- b'UD77‘3-J ti-ú5 i 7-J -j . 4 4-.----__ Batch ## Bâtch lncldant lncldenl Offense Offcnse Incldenl lncldent Locallon Locåtlon I I . ___ _ 09/05/2015 09/05/2015 00:00 00:00 EvIdum:c Er4dcncc Iicm Ilcm Category Cafcgoq' lE\'inaIc: Eü€cÊ rype» lypcr V_ _ _V_ Number liumbcr . _ __GENERAL I¡¡VESÎIGATION GENERAL INVESTIGATION Defendants Dafondants . __ - _ lnformatlon Log Information I Log Evidence Evldence Property Property FROSECUTOR FROSECUTOR . /15-39715 InvIPD lnv/PD Case Cesâ ## HM15-00177 HM15-00177/15-39715 PG/CSI Cðse # # I PG/CSI Case "Om Itcm MONMOUTH COUNTY Subm tAgency COUNTY Submlt Ag€noy MONMOUTH HOWELLTWP Munlclpallty Munlclpallty HOWELL TWP county County MONMOUTH MONMOUTH I‘ ) « /I S:gn.=.!».rr9 " '5' .Il‘\ 1II..LJuI\. DL4LL:-‘I, -‘-"I ÐúZZÅ. ù,'.1 llËL i .i;-. ""-“~' ' =3 Daie: "—‘ IJdI&. ‘ II I/05f20l5 l/t5;2ú 15 I1‘5-‘. I 1:54 . Pm! Name Pin! l\lene . is BARNER. JEFFREY BARI,IER, JEFFREY ignalurs Print líañe Prìnt Name Date: 1110512015 11:54 11:54 Date: 11/05/2015 Page Fage I¡ o! of II 0056 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0056 3:15-cv-08043-_BRM-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 58 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1093 MONMOUTH Office County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office MONMOUTH County EVIDENCE RECEIPT EVIDENCE RECEIPT ‘—' " tíon Casetion ' " ' ’ Case lnlorntatlon N untber Information Case Number invIPD HM15-6A177 ¡15-39715 lnv/PD Case# Casô # HM175_-0__0_177/15-3971_§. PG/CS! Casø # _I¡ PG/CSI Case# Log lnformation Log Information Evidence Property Propcrty ## _1S-G577 11'c577 Évldence -õEñEMIIÑVESfIéIIIQ:j Unit _.§‘_5Nfl»°:.E. '*\/§TLGi\.T HCL-‘i__ UnÌt 09/05/2015 00:00 Incident & Time Tim€ -õ9ñ540ß-00''00 Date 8. lncident Date b__ __ 4 ___ __ _ _ T__ ___ . _______“ ___ T “___ . ____ _ _ M Batch Bâtch 3# '"°ide'“ orrèrìsÊ lncide¡¡t 0”=‘m5"= Location Incident Location lncldent _ _ __h ____ _ 4 E;3_L.'E"’_.Rfl’.l!5.'~_‘s’ _ 1017 NJ STA TE HtGHW.¢.Y 1233. I-tOWl':LL. NJ 1017 STATE t:i_J_077_3i _HOWELL. 0773. HOWELL. r'rJ .-.-- __ V __&_ _ lDescriptlon _c)¢5¢ _' iPN0" SdillNùnbcr, Mlli€, Mod.l, .lc Contactl Rrcoveled Contâct/ Recovered i5-0577-3-1 t5-0577-3"1 MISCELLANEOUS M¡SCELLANEOLIS that was ns¿d an on be used ¡o be tt'as attempted ßile"tqßtl Io description: aneu-t¡'gen na$ thut eta mptt u.\ygenm1rsA' - [ I.'tlIlif_\': øtte- ewunplu tir,r: 1,l brief brlcf dêE'jt'iptionl MISCELLANEOUS t¿flSCELL¡\NEOUS ('.‘ATE(i() W.'i\IISCELLANEOIIS V:il1 IJ biulm2:n'rI: no brief tlcscripflon: nvu- emuy.-/v H95 u95 mask: ntosks user! qu A'r:;'m'. is qllrmlityz 2? l¡rlcf CATI-IGOR\’:MISCELIANEOIIS _l_5'(_)§77'3'3 I MISCELLMEOUS lr4lSCELLÀn"EOUS , Clc,. lv rr ____________ __ < _ _V_ _ __ __ __ _ ______ __ D.r¡rt¿d _____A o7731 ..H0!ViL-_ELJ.9_77_31___ HOWELL. o____._ n°i°'.1P"°" Oxct'lPlfott l¡f,ìmi{m r t lai¡l Numb¿r ClÐl! .l.¡Jrt! ¡,¡ !!vlú.li¡s,l _A_> __ ., __ T. _. _ _ MU _-_. _.._ y . -_ ... CU"““i‘/ Cu¡¡l¡lct / R°m"°rNl h!' Itccor,cretl by m rYtld.l- al. ¡Vrl-.' ~ i¡' _ _ ; vcn _,,_._ — _ 5:' DE :'ßozzA o[2';":lE]‘ DET. D¿\NtEl, __ _______ _ _ ’ -;::.‘;~.-._,,..~._‘ ' _..:.'L% 4 I - K _ y ' ‘-:"§!§7n’a!ure Property by: Recelved by: Property Received __ _ ____ . Delivered by: Property bi": Prcperfr' Delivcred I ______ _ __ __ t¡ __ ____ _ P0LlI.‘.‘r' REVIEW 101? STATE HIGHWRY #33. HOWELL. HOWELL. NJ "t4¡ 'l¡"il 'r\' 'EGOR\‘:liL.ECTRONlCSlHOUSEI-IOLDAPPLIANCES crs one blur/nmnmc cellphone Will! I hml qunnmy: sub .lascr¡pll0n¡o,t¿tluanenlltcccllphotewitlt br.Gl descriplmn: cellphone category: cet!phoncqwntity:f rrtraatogory, ELECTRONICS/HOUSEHOL EHOL Imz'i:0!-10IfiMJ68!94.! ICS/}IOUS ELESTRON hiolî'1rd: umdcl: c650u, iutct:0!l0lt1t0368ttlt isls hiohnznrd: mblvur msc. brmld: -NIH.‘ írunit: harem, ¡niiìtË¡rc¡'c,ac' b'occlti nnilc!: €650", LS D D MJPHANL ¡\PPl.lANCb.S ratrìevilfranprÌstillu^ rccot'crtú; rctriemlfrulllpriscillu \t'll{rc rccovurcd: ua bua{l where i,tuitt buzzu ilet. zI.:m'n.'I ¡'ccor'crcd by: b¡'z Met. r¿ recovered 13:20 10/05/2015 & lime: tlmc; I 0/0 5f20 I 5 I I 2 0 &!o u ttt!) rccovcrcrl llnle î os t &foumi)_recovereL /Ikzr(fomyI n'cevemt Iasl nk¿N la u wl In !¡lc & , __ _______ W_____ ti _§__ Batch?! Batch # Incldenl Offense lncldent Offense lncldent Location lncldent Location ____,_,,_, tEvSdenceT\-rm I E\idrcr 1r'm t _ _ _ ..____ _ ___ ___ l1\'idcucc Cntrgory lìriricncc llcm lrcm Cmegory 15.n,<77-6-! I 5-nS??-6. ! L_____ - ___ Defendants Dêfendents ‘__ W __ __ _;_ _______ “NH Iler¡r Number ìVumhcr Submit COUI'¡TY lviOFllvlOUTH COUNTY Agency MONMOUTH Submit Agency PROSECIJTOR PÊOSECIJTOR Munlclpality TV'r41 HOWELT TWP Munlclp¡rlity HOWELL Case l¡t[ot ntatio¡t Nunúer Infounation Case Number .’lff-I'1'J}’1:'» lnvlPD 1 5.00177 1 I Case ## lnv/PD Case PGICSlCase# PG/CSI Gase # /____V___ Log lnformatîon Log Information Evidence Proporly ftI _1_§_0_!_:fl Ev¡doncê Propeny GE!-!ER:’~L INVESTIG-\T O ~I Unll Unlt 09/05/2015 lncldent 8. Tlme 09/051201 5 00:00 00:00 lncld€nt Date Date & Tlme ___ “ — P H “ f I . V-1 \ BOZZA, JR. DP,NiEL J JR. POZZ^¡., DANIEL ', Dale: Datê: 10/os.'2o15 13:20 1()/0GJ2019 13:26 Dale Date 1OI06l2015 13:26 10/06120,15 13:26 Print Nane Pdnt Name 3 .r'..a.mrurc 2;}: !;'i _: v#' V BARNER. JËFFREY BARNER, JEFFREY _ Print Nane Print Name Page Pâge 11 of1 of f Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0059 0059 flm4&BRM-TJB Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Filed 08/04/16 Page 61 of 100 PageID: Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1096 » y._J&tA:Q$\ln%wL1a¢;uKr ., .-I, {l . w ,- EVIDENCE/PROPERTY RECE PT EVTDENCE/PROPERTY RECEIPT I - MIDDLESEX OFFICE FXAMINER'S OFFICE MIDDLESEX COUNTY COUNTY MEDICAL MEDICAL EXAMlNER'S AVE. LIVINGSTON 1490 1490 LIVINGSTON AVE. 08902 NORTH ERUNSWICK, BRUNSWICK, NJ NJ 08902 NORTH 732-745-3190 732-745-319A .. EVIDENCE/PROPERTYRELEASED TO: RÊI€ASED TO: DECEDENT/OWNER NTORMATION : DECEDÉI{T/OWNER INFORMATION: I NAME: TIMOTHY HARDEN, HARDEN,TIMOTHY 13-15-0970 13-15-0970 AGENCY: A6gNCY: DR KARLUK/CM CITY: CIIY: (orn fkj Pros cm/far: Of-Fm () ‘P1 oumwm Court I ADDRESS: a00nEss: el6l2aß ZIP: zrP: FATE: 5TÀTT: PHONE PHONE N0: NO: AGENCY NO: CASE NO: AGENCY CASE F771} Cafb a-r a / :3 /—(l'-‘! ,L .‘ INVENTORY I r-'/YL/‘.r1..”IL,_:L _-___£1;-:11]! F.-"»_' -_ .. -.. _- 5 _____,______ , _, _ . .__ __-.—._.. .. I ~$ I I PRINT Fnttl o> Lneuuc LñEIUIL 1 RECEIVED BY: 8Y: RICCIVED nsuuquasneo BY¡ RELII{QUEIIED av: srçf{Afpnf S §NA' 'UR A772 l./ /¿at*t S ¢i‘Ng"URE PRINT Slci¡ATutE P¡ITIT 9A1’! PAlr + 1...“; I/"/l f îYl l.,r,.t,t Zuøa ÐtL¿,L¿u"* ;I/,,// f , zugg OR?!‘ 714112‘ Çlt"lt4 _ I b 'l'ime Time __ 'l'ime Time I !st r)/a C I l’/A _ Prosecutor's File 0061 0061 Prosecuto/s File Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 63 of 100 Pagellq: 1098 COUNTY UNIFORM RECEIPT DEFENDANT INFORMATION JPY NAMEIV ADDRESS, JPY AGENCY INFORMATION AGENCY Monmoum Caunly Pmsecuwr's Office ADDRESS 1512 JersevaIIe Ave Flaehold' Hm ZIP 7 N0. PHONE NO INVEST Del. Dame! Bazzs RACE: SEX: CODEFENDANTS, AGENCY CASE NO 91500172 CRIME DATE 09/05/2015 REASON FOR SUBMISSION (DWNERNICTIM) NAME Twnolhy Harden (Deceasde I GRAND JUHV BeImar NJ TRIAL (SENT. DATE I PHONE NO: OTHER INVENTORV ITEM QTY. DESCRIPTION 4% I Ina, Mm Maia] 4' Inna omeogfimeg-l/r; WM 91.; [Lee Paw/A meg amt .3 WM 7/7/15) CHECK HERE IF ADDITIONAL INVENTORY LIST ATTACHED HELINQUISHED BV RECEIVED EY rummI Prosecutor's File 0062 Filed 08/04/16 Page 64 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1099 CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL NMS Labs NMS Labs åNMS 3701 3701 Welsh \ô/elsh Road, Road, PO PO Box Bor 433A. 4334, Willow lMllow Grove. Grove, PA PA 19090-0437 19090-O437 Phone: (215) 657-4900 (215)657-2972 Phone: (215) Fa¡c (215)657-2972 657-d900 Fax e-mall: nms@nms abs.com emall: nms@nmslabs.e¡m RobertA. RobertA. Middleberg, Míddleberg, PhD, PhD, F-ABl-‘r, DABCC-TC, Laboratory D¡rôclor F-AtsFT, DABCC-TC. Laboratory Director Supplemental Report Supplemental Repon Patient Name Patlent Nama Patlent '° lD Report Report Issued l¡sued 12/14/2015 1211412015 09:59 09:69 Last Issued Last Report Report lrsued 11/01/2015 111ü/2A15 09:58 09:58 Chain Y Age 38 Age 38 Y Gender Gsnder w°"‘°"d°' Workordar To: '10174 To: 10174 Monmouth Medical Examiner Monmouth County County Medical Examíner 300 Halls Mills Mills Rd 300 Halls Rd - 2nd 2nd Floor Floor HARDEN, TIMOTHY HARDEN, TIMOTHY ° 13-15-0970 11881850 DOB Not Given DOB Not Given Male Male 153735“ 1.5¿ ?¿L¿ T Page Page 1I of of88 — Freehold, Freehold, NJ NJ 07728 A7728 M? Positive Findings: Posltlve Flndlngs: K:-I Qnmimund Compound Result Result Ethanol Ethanol 113 113 0.113 0.113 Blood (BAC) Goncentretlon (BAC) Blood Alcohol Alcohol concentration Naioxone Neloxono 11-Hydroxy Delta€ THC TllC l1-Hyûory Delta-9 Delta-9 THC D€ t .9 THC Benzoylecgonine Benzoytccgpnlne Creatlnine (Vitreous Fluld) Creatlnlne (Wtnour Fluld) Sodium Fluld) Sodlum (Vitreous {Vltreour Fluld) Potassium (Vitreous Fluld) Potrrelum Mfrour Fluld) Chloride (Vitreous Fluld) Chlo¡ldc (Vltreous Fluld) Urea Nitrogen (Vitreous (Vltmous Fluld) Fluld) Urua Nltogen cocaine Metabolites Cocelne /I lletebolltos canneblnolds Csnnablnoldr Creatlnlne Creallnlne Testosterone Têttoúsrone units Ito¡¡Ê mgldL mg/dl mL 9/100 9ú100 rnL ngImL nglmL ngImL nglmL ngImL ngrmL ngImL nglmL mgIdL rñgrdL Positive Poslüve 1.0 t.0 1.7 1.7 150 150 0.95 0.95 mmoIIL mmoUL 137 137 10 10 122 122 12 "t2 mmoIiL mmol/L mmollL mmoUL Presump Por Prerump Poe Presump Prssump Poe PoB Epltestosterone Epltertoeterone TestosteroneI Ratlo Ep¡têttotterona Ratio TGûþttrrone, Epltestosterone 522.7 622.7 48 48 4.0 4.0 12 12 mgIdL mgldL ngImL nglml ngImL ng/mL mglL mS/L ngImL ng/mL ngImL nglmL MiIl:‘D$_5.D.I. .l:l2fl ilatrix Source O01 Femoral Blood 001 'Femoral Blood Femoral Blood 001 Blood 00r - Femonl Blood O01 Femoral Blood 001 - Femoral 001 Femoral Blood Bood 001 - Femoral O01 Femo¡al Blood Blood 00r - Femoral 001 (xll - Femoral Femoral Blood Blood 002 Fluld vitÉor¡t Fluid o02 - Vitreous 002 Vltrcot¡s Fluld Fluld 042 - Vitreous 002 Fluld o02 - Vitreous Vit¡souc Fluld 002 Fluld 002 - Vitreous Vltrsous Fluid 002 Vitreous Fluld Fluld 0a2 -Mtreoue 003 Urlne 0lr3 - Urine 003 (Xt3 - Urine Urlne 003 Urlne 003 - Urlne 003 Urlne 003 - Urlne 003 Urlne 003 . Urine 003 Urlne 003 - Urlne - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Detailed Findinge See Findings action for additional infonnation sect¡on for addilional information See Detailed Testing Requeated: Tectrng Requested: Analysis Code Analyrlr Code 1919FL 1919F1 8050U 8050u B0528 80528 OB B21 82108 8756B 87568 9306U s306u 95668 95668 Description tÞscrlPtlon and Glucose Electrolytes Fluid (Forensic) PEnel (Vitreous), Glucose Panel Electrolytes ãnd Mtreous), Fluid Add-on (6-MAM Postmortem (6-{IIAM Quantification Quantification Urlne Screen ScreenAddon Postmortem Toxicology Toxleology - Urine only) only) Blood (Forensic) Postmortem (Foronsic) Expanded, Blood Toxicology - Expanded, Postmortem Toxicology Substances Novel (NPS) Psychoactive Substancês (NPS) Screen Blood Screen 2, 2, Blood Novel Psychoac{ive Screen Substances 1, Novel (NPS) Blood (NPS) 1, Blood Psychoactive Scraen Substances Novel Psychoactíve - - Anabolic Urine Steroids Screen. Anabolic Steroids Screen. Urine Postmortem (Add-On), Screen (Add-On). Slntheüc Cannabinolds Cannabinolds Screen Toxlcology - Synthetic Postmortem Toxicology Blood Blood - Specimens Recalved: Spcolmenc Received: ID Tube/Contalner lD Tubelcontainer Volume! Volume/ Mass ilett 001 vlrhtte Plastic PlÍlsflc Container contalnor 001 White 20 20 mL mL Collection Collocüon Daterrime Datommo Not ('tv€n NOf Given Source Matrix ilatrix Source Miscellaneous tllscellansous Information lnformaüon Femoral tslooo Femoral Blood v.16 v.16 Prosecutor's File 0063 0063 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 65 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1100 NM &år\MS CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL Workorder Workorder Chain Chain Patient Patient ID lD , ' ' I 15272629 15272629 11881850 1 1 881 850 13-15-0970 1 3-1 5-0970 V Page Page 2 2 of of88 ID TubelContalner lD Tube/Container Voiumel Volume/ Mass ll¡3s NotGlvan‘ Not Givên 002 002 White whnB Plastic Plastic Container mL Çontalner 1.75 1.75 mL 003 35 mL Clear Plastic Contalner 35 003 Clear Plastíc Container mL Miscellaneous lllscallaneous Matrix Matrlx Source Source Collection Collectlon Daterrlme tlatelTlme ‘ Not Not Given Given “ Vltl'eOLlS Vitr€ous Fluid Fluld ' Information lnformatlon '-’ ‘ Urine Urine All All sample volumesôveights are approx¡mations, sample volumes/weights are approximations. 09/11/2015. Specimens Spec¡mens received recelved on on 09/11/2016. Detailed Flndlngs: Detalled Findings: Analysis Commonts Analycle and and comments Units Unlte Result Result 113 mgIdL mg/dL 113 Ethanol mL 0.113 g/100 0.113 BloodAtcohol 9/100 mL Concentration (BAC) Concentration (BAC) Positive Naloxone ng/mL nglmL Positive Naloxone ng/mL 11-Hydroxy ng/mL 1.0 Delta-9 THC 1l-Hydroxy Delta-9 THC 1.0 1.7 THC Delta~9 nglmL 1.7 ng/mL Daft¡a-9 THC ngImL Benzoylecgonine ng/ml 150 Beruoylecgonine 150 Confirmed Ethanol rnS/dl Confirmed mg/dL Ethanol 0.95 Creatinine mgIdL Fluid) (Vitreous mg/dl 0.95 Crealinine Mreous Fluid) mmoi/L Sodium mmol/L 137 Fluid) 137 Sodium (\/itreous Mtreous Fluid) mmol/L Potassium (Vitreous Fluid) 1O mrnollL Fluid) 10 Potassium (Vitreous mmol/L Ch on'de Mtreous '122 mmol/L Fluid) 122 Chloride Mtreous Fluid) Glucose Detected mg/dL mg/dL (Vitreous Fluid) None Detected Fluid) None Gtucose (\/itreous mg/dL Urea mgldl 12 Nifogen (Vitreous Urea Nitrogen Mfeous 12 Fluid) Fluid) Pos ng/mL Cocainel ng/rnL Presump Pos Metabolites Presump Cocaine / Metabolites Ethanol Blood Alcohol Rpt. Rpt. Source Umlt Specimen Speclmen Source 001 10 Femoral Blood Blood 10 001 - Femoral Blood Femoral 001 0.010 Femoral Blood 0.010 001 1.0 Blood 001 - Femoral Femoral Blood 1.0 001 Femoral 001 1.0 Blood 1.0 001 - Femoral Blood 0.50 (þ1 - Femoral Blood Femoral Blood 0.50 001 Blood Femoral 001 50 00'l - Femolal Blood 50 001 10 Blood 001 - Femoral Femoral Blood 10 002 - Vitreous 0.050 Fluid Vitreous Fluid 0.050 002 Vitreous Fluid 002 80 Fluid @2 -Mtreous 80 1.0 Fluid Vitreous Fluid 002 - Vitreous 1.0 002 002 - Vitreous 70 Fluid Wreous Fluid 002 70 002 35 Fluid Vrtreous Fluid 002 - Vitreous 35 Vitreous Fluid 3.0 Fluid 0O2'Vitraous 3.0 002 150 Urine 003' Urine 150 003 umlt - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Analysis Analysls By By GC Headspace HeadspaceG0 Headspace GC Headspace GC LCITOF-MS LC/TOF-MS LC—MS/MS LC-MS/MS LC-MS/MS LC-MS/MS GC/MS GC/MS Headspace H€adspace GC GC Colorimetry Colorimetry Chemistry Chemistry Analyzer Analyzer Chemistry Chemistry Analyzer Analyzer Chemistry Chêmlstry Analyzer Anelyzer Chemistry Chemistry Analyzer Analyzer Chemistry Chemistry Analyzer AnalYzer EiA EIA gs GC/MS is recommended. recommendêd. GC/MS is This such as tochnlque such by a a more more definitive definltive technique Confrmallon by screen. Confimiailon Thls test test is fs an an unconfirmed unconfirmed screen. EIA Urine 003 20 EIA Pos Urine ngImL 003 Cannabinoids 20 Presump ng/ml Cannabinoids Presump Poe recommended. is GC/MS such as definitive technique Confirmation more a is recommended. screen. unconfirmed GC/MS testis This such as by an unconfirmed screen. ConlTrmation by a more dafinÍtive technlqua This test ís an Calorimetry 100 Colorimetry 522.7 003 - Urine Ufinê mg/L Creatinine 100 003 mg/L 522.7 Creatinine LC-MS/MS Urine 003 2.0 LC'MS/MS 48 Urlne ng/mL 003 Testosterone 2.O ng/mL Æ Testosterone LC-MS/MS LC-MS/MS 003 - Urine Urine ngImL 2.0 003 ng/mL 2.0 Epltestosterone 4.0 Epitestosterone 4.0 LC-MS/MS Urine 003 LC-Ms/Ms 12 003 - Urine TestosteroneI 12 - - - — Tsstosterone / - Epitestosterone Ratlo Epítestosterone Ratio reveal any poûltlve findings of flndlngr of any positive dld not notreveal Other cubmltted did epeclmen(s) submitted of the the speclmen(e) examlnaíon of flndlngs, examination ¡bove findings, tñe above other than than the Summary. in the outlined accompanyingAnalysis Summrry. Anrlysls procedures by procedures outllned ln the accompenylng toxicologicalsignificance toxlcotoglcrl slgnlllcance bÍ Reference Comments: Reference Comments: 1. 11-Hydroxy Blood: (Acnive Metabolite) Femoral Blood: THC (Active Metâþolite) - Femoral Dalta-9 THC 11-Hydroxy Delta-9 1. - (THC) the lhe active active of tetrahydrocannabinol têbahydrocannab¡nol (THC) metabolite of 11-Hydroxy intermediate metabolite THC is is an an active ac{ive intermediate Delt+9 THC 11-Hydrory Delta-9 after smoking. smokìng' THC levels levels after peak levels: 10% of than 10% of THC Less than component levels; Less Usual peak marijuana. Usual of marijuana. comóoneni of v.16 v.16 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0064 0064 Filed 08/04/16 Page 66 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed P ID: 1101 6.6 offl 100 PageID: MS &&l.,lMS CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL Workorder Workorder Chain Chain Patient Patlent to lD . !_ 15272629 15272629 11881850 1 1 881 850 13-15-0970 13-15-0970 i I 2 Page Page 3 3 of of I8 Reference Comments: Referunce Comrnents: 2. Benzoylecgonine Benzoylecgonine (Cocaine product) _ Femoral Blood: (Cocaine Degradation Degradation Product) 2. - Femoraf Blood; Benzoylecgonine Benzo-ylecgonine is metabolite and is an an inactive inadive metabolite and chemical chernical breakdown Cocaine is DEA breakdown product product of a DËA of cocaine. cocaine. cocaine is a schedule central nervous schedule itll controlled conl¡olled c€ntral nervous stimulant st¡mulänt drug. drug. Effects Ereas following iollowing cocaine cocalne use euphoria. use can can include lnclude euphoria, excitement. excitement, restlessness. restlessness, risk taking, sleep risk taklng, steep disturbance. disturuaãcu, and mental and physical ano aggression. A period oi A period of rnentat physical and fatigue follow the þtigue and use of ånd somnolence sotnnolencs follow the excitant-stimulant "ttiãision, the ùse eflectrs wear of cocaine off. bcalne after afrer ihe exciãnt+timulant ersae wáaion Benzoylecgonlnehas hall»lileof Eenzoylecgonlne hours. The has aa half-life of 6 6 to to 10 10-lnulq. rne average concentration in averatô blood g06 benzoylecgonineconcentration oìãóo banzoytecgonine in 906 impaired was 1280 '1280 ngImL lmpelred drivers 5 - 17600 drivers-was ng/ml (range (range.S blood concentrations t76oo ngfmL). in Benzoyleogonine ng/nl), Ëãruãirecgontne blood pãtient* concentrations in patients admitted to an for room admltted to ân emergency related rñø¡,å¡ medical complaints emergency room rc,i cocaine 1280 nglmatsol coãatne-relabd ngImL (SD 1290 comÈräinË were we¡,a reao rzso ngImL) ns/mL). Benzoyiecgonlne concentrations Eonzoylecg_onine oral administration concentrations in plasm3.following following orat ¡n plasma of cocaine over 6 days. adminiítrãT¡on of2 gtdaioräoi* of 2 g/day ou";ü;Ë:"" - = averaged ng/mL. The average blood averaged 4900 4900 ndry!,-Th9 37 ócaine cocaine retateo blood benzoyiecgonine related fatalities benzoyldponine concentration was concentration in inã7 fatalitlài'was 7900 nglmL (range (range 700 7900 ng/ml 700 - 31000 91000 nglml.) ng/ml). - 3. Cannablnolds - Urine: 3. Cannablnoids Urine: Cannabinoids Cannabinoids are derived from aro chemical chemical compounds compounds aeri.v{ plant Cannabis from the lhe plant (marijuana), including Cannabls sativa sativa (marijuana). íncluding active aclive components. compon€nts, chemical chêmicalcongeners congeners and is the principal and metabolites. metabollles. Delta-9—TetrahydrocannabinoI DBlta-'+Tetrahydrrrcannabinà (THC) active ís'ihó ffr:lCl frincilalaøive component. component. - 4. 4. This This result result derives presumptíve test. derive-s from from a to cross-reactivity a presumptive test, which whích may be be subject subject to cross-reactivity with with non-cannabinoid non-cannablnold related test ls is necessary refated compounds. to confirm cornpounds. Asecond Asecond test necessary to coriñrm the presence of theþresence of cannabinoidrelated cannabinoid related compounds. compounds. Chloride (Vitreous Chloride Fluid) - Vitreous Vltreous Fluid: Fluid: ffireous Fluid) Normal: Normal: 105 105 - 135 l3S mmol/L mmol/L - - 5. 5. Cocaine Cocaine I/ Metabolites Metebolites - Urine: Urine: Cocaine Cocaine is is a a central central nervous nervous system system stimulant stimulant and and drug drug of of abuse. - abuse. This a presumptive test. This result result derives d€r¡ves from Êom.a test, which which may be be subject subjed to to cross-reactivity cross-reâd¡vlty with with non-cocaine non-cocaine related related compounds. to confinn the presence compounds. A A second second test test is cocaine related is necessary nec¿ssary to presence of confirm thà of cocaine related compounds. compounds. 6. Creatinine - Urine: 6, Creatinine Urine: U.S. Population U.S. Poputation (10th (l0th - 90th percentiles, median) 90h percentiles, medfan) All participants: 335 AJlparticípants: 335 - 2370 2920 mgIL. mg/L, median (n=22,245) median 1180 11BO (n=22.245) Males: Males: 495 495 - 2540 2540 mg/L, mg/l, median rnedian 1370 (n=10,6fb) 1320 (n=10,610) Females: 2170 mg/L. gg4 (n=11.635) Females: 273 273-2170 mg/L, median median 994 (n=il,6Oi5) 7. Creatinine 7. Creatinine (Vitreous (Vrtreous Fluid) Fluid) - Vitreous Mtreous Fluid: Fluid: Nonnal: Normal; 0.6 0.6 - 1.3 1.3 mg/dL mgtdL Delta-9 8. THC (Actíve ingredient 8. Delte-g THC (Active Marijuana) - Femoral lngrêdient of of Marijuana) Femoral Blood: Blood: - - - - - - - - Marijuana Maríjuana_ is is a a DEA DEA Schedule Scfredule iI halluclnogen. halluclnogen. Phannacologicaliy. Pharmacologicslly, itit has has depressant depressant and and reality reality distorting distorting effects. effects. Collectively. Collectivel¡ the the chemical are known chemícal compounds compounds that thãt comprise comprlse marijuana marijúanaäre known as as Cannabinoids. Cannabinoids.' Delta-9-THC pdnciple psychoactive Delta-9THC is ls the fhe. principle psychoactive ingredient marijuanamashlsh. itlt rapidly lngrêdlÉnt of of manþana/hashlsh. repidly leaves leaves the blood, even the blood. even below detectable during failing to within sev-oral during smoking, smoking,.fallirrg several hours. totelow deteciable levels levels within HCC) is the hours. Delta-9-carboxy-THC Delta-9äróoxy.THo (T the [rHGC)'is to one inacl¡vÊ m6tãbolito of delta-9-THC and of THC THC and and may be day or be detected detscted for for up up lo one day or more rnore in in blood. blood. Both eótn ¿eÈ-+fHb and THCC may be present may be THCC present substantially substenüally longer fonger in ln chronic chronic users. ijsers. THC concentrations THC concentrgtions]nin blood usually about blotil. are are usually sbout one-hall one-half of of serumlplasma serum/plasrna concentrations. peak levels concentrstions. Usual Usual peak levels in in 1.75% or serum serum for for 1.75% 9 minutes or 3.55% cigarettes: 50 to 3.55% THC THC marijuana ngimL at maríjuana cigarattes: 60 - 270 270 ngiml at 6 minutes after I to g afler beginning beginning smoking. 6moklng, decreasing decroasíng to ngfmL by less than to less than 55 ng/mL by 2 2 hrs. hrs" 9. Epitestosterone Epilestosterone (4-androsten-l7alpha-ol-$one) - Urine: Urine; Epitestosterone anabolic androg€nic Epitestosterone is that is an endogenous endogenous anaþolic androgenic steroid is an prohibited by st€roid that ¡s prohibited by the 2010 World the 2010 World Anti-Doping Ant¡-Doplng Code recommends additional Code when wl¡en administered administered exogenousiy. exogenously. WADA W,ADA recommends additionat testing testing of of any airy total total epitestosterone epitestosterone concentration concentration greater than ng/mL. than 200 200 ng/mL, 10. (EthylAlcohol) Alcohol) - Femoral 10. Ethanol Ethanol (Ethyl Femorat Blood: Blood: inactive metabolite - 9. (4—androsten—1Yalpha-cl-3-one) — - Ethylalcohol (ethanol, drinking dnnking alcohol) Ethyl ãfcohol (ethanof, alcohol) is depressant and as is a a central centraf nervous nervous system system depressant and can cân cause cãuse effects effecls such such as impairedjudgment. impairod judgment, reduced coordination. Ethanol reduced alertness aler:lness and and impaired impaired muscular muscular-coordinai¡on. product of Ëthanol can can also also be be a a product of '¡e decomposition alcohol concentrations decomposit¡on or concentrations (BAC) or degradation degradation of biological samples The of biologicalsamples The blood blood alcohol (BAC) can can be expressed expressBd as as aa whole whole number mgIdL or number with with the the units of mg/dL units of or as a decimal dedmsl number as a number with with units unlls of of g/100 mL which which is ls 9/100 mL wlv. For equivalent equ¡valent to to % Vowlv. mgldL equals For example, øxample, a a BAC BAC of of 85 85 mg/dl equals 0.085 0.085 g/100 mL or or 0.085% 0.085% w/v wlv of of ethanol. ethanol. 9/100 mL 16 v. v,16 Prosecutor's Prosecuto/s File File 0065 0065 Filed 08/04/16 Page 67 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1102 kN À¡{MS CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL Workorder Workorder Chain Chaln Patient Patlent ID lD _ 15272629 15272629 11881850 11 881 850 13-15-0970 I 3-1 5-0970 1 Page Page 4 4 of of 8I Reference Reference Comments: Commentg: 11. 11. Glucose Glucose (Wreous (Vitreous Fluid) Fluid) - \/treous Vitreous Fluid: Fluid: Normal: <200 mg/dL Normal: <200 mg/dL — Postmortem vitreous glucose concentrations Postmortem v¡treous glucose concentrations >200 mg/dL mg/dl are are associated associated with with hyperglycemia. hyperglycemia. Sinoe postmortem vitreous glucose concentrations SincÊ poslmol"tem and in vllreous glucose rapidly after concentrations decline decline rapidly añor death death both both in in vivo vivo and in vitro, vitro, care care should of results. vitreous glucose should be be taken in the been noted traken in tho interpretation interpretation of glucose for resulls. Stability Stability of of vilieoús for up to to 30 30 days days has noted has Þeen when specimens by NMS by NMS Labs Lebs when speclmens are are maintained (-20°C). malnhined frozen trozen ZO"C¡. 12. Blood: (Narcan@) - Femoral 12. Naloxone Naloxone (Narcan®) Femoral Blood: Naloxone narcotic is effects of Naloxone ls a a narcotic antagonist antagonist used used to to counter count€r the ths central central nervous nsrvous system systom depression depresslon effec{s of opioids, opioids, including depression. including respiratory deprassion. itlt is is also also used used for for the lhe diagnosis diagnosis of of suspected susþeaed acute opioid overdosage. overdosage. acuto opioid çspirqlory Naloxone is available mg/mL solution Naloxone is available as as a a 0.4 0.4 mg/mL parenteral injection. solution of of the the hydrochloride hydrochloride for injecion. br parenteral - Naloxone is in combinationwith treatment of Naloxone also available ls also availaHe ln e¡rnbination with buprenorphine [Suboxone®) for buprenorphine (Subo No No Flmarms Flrearms Discharge Dlschargo tnhnttonal I Intentional Rcc¡oenta¡ E Accmmal n Canine 3 I rd hl Sex mg§ (check-a’l that uppty) Realsted pollce ofllcer Reslsled police ofilcer control control officer or Physical Physlcaf threat/attadt threaUattack on or another on offcer anolher E Yes Yes Kllled Killed A N/A 1/ Compliance Gompllance hold holcl Handsltlats Hends/ñst8 7‘ Klckalfeel Klcks/Ëel EI I Chemlcallnatural Ch€rnlc¡Unalural agent agent Strlkeluse obþd Stdlcl/use baton belon or or other olhor object E 3 Injured lnjur€d change‘ Gh8fgeE 0 unoer the ttre Influence lnfruence fJ Under fl Kllled Klll6d No No Uniform Unlform Yes Yes 77 Stop Other (apegL) (check all that apply) Hream FllBarmg D,sc,,,,ge Dlscharg€ mtenuom rnþnt¡onat Accldemal flRob"nt.t D E Numberof Fired Numbor of Shaw Shot3 Flred Number°' Numbor of Hus Hlts (Use (Use UNK unknorvn) UNK If lf unknown) I _ met more than two aubJ_o_cta In th1lI_ FORCE REPORTS. thlr lncldent. attarch rtlrch addltlonal rddltlon¡l USE USE OF OF FORCE #4:/j_ ( /ú^{f#éfl 183768/2015 Datc: 09/08/2015 h 9 reviewed promfiy address (SUPERVISOR) any issues issues as as they (SUPERVISOR, II hereby utd have haw promptly addnss any fâey may may L and completeness conpldanøss and høúby certify this Use al Force Fone report rcpoil for lor accuracy accunoy and ætlìty thatl that I hah nvldved this Use of ecommendations to modifypolicy;apply remedial training beyondwhat can be to policy interpretation. training. weapons or equipment or discipline. RRewnmenddícrl,stonoditypdlcy:applyranedialtninlngbdyoñwhatcanbe pertain paftainlopolbyittlorpntdìwr,tnining,weepnsorequipnent,udisciplirc. be thoroughlydocumented and performed by me. to wit: modify policy; change weapons, equipment or tactics; or applydiscipline beyond my capabilities shall pe¡lo¡nadbyme,towlt:modilypol@:ohangewapws,equlpmrûortactlæ;orrylydiæiplinebeyondmyeapaôi/iilras sâollôellproughlydæunentedand ._ . of commandto the Chief of Palice._ forwarded Police, clnln oî ænnand tolhs Chielof thmygh thechain tu*zrdúthrowhlhe Prtnt PrlnÍ supo 1s7or~Narne:/Lg’ flm _ zsî _ ‘ lsupo ;o j:f;fl> - - 712010 l Prosecutor's File 0072 0072 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1109 Page 74 of 100 PageID: HOWELL HOWELL TOWNSHIP TOWNSHIP POLICE POLICE DEPARTMENT DEPARTIIENT USE USE OF OF FORCE FORCE REPORT REPORT A. A. Incident lncldent Information lnformatlon Date Time 9/8/2015 st8t2015 1452 1452 Tvos of lnddeflt .T.Y& Crime In ln Progress Progmos [-l0dme I Day Br Week Location rucroeur NUMBER pRtËDAlNEn-ATVtAN socrerv SATURDAY 1017 RT RT 33. 33, PRIEDAINEILATVIAN 5.3971 5 SAÏURDAY 1017 SOCTETY 1 15-39715 Other Ottrer Dispute Dlsgne Domestic oomestc I spedty) DISORQERLY PEi3_SONlASSAL£T LT B. Officer lnfonnation lnformation .1 Other Name (L¡st, First, Middle) Name (Last. Flrst, Mtddle) Badge B.dgo # f AUSTIN, AUSTIN, NICHOLAS NICHOLAS Rank RânK PATROLMAN PATROLMAN Race Race Sex Sex 654 654 Duty Duty Assignment Ae8lgnmenl Suspicious Swpldous Person Pereon M M Injured lnJurcd Age Age W W Yeare YðarB at of Service Süvlca PATROL PATROL TratflcStop aop flrramc 27 27 On-Duty On-Duty 2.5 2.5 W W STATUS ' ' :~ (check all that apply) t Thraalenedlattecired Threalcned/attaclcd otfioer oficer or or anotherwith another wttñ blunt blunt objed obJed Threatenedlattacked Tìrsalenod/stt cfted otiicer oflloêr or or anotharwith anothor wllh knifeloutting knlfcúcuílnS object obþcf Threatenedlattacked Ttroslanod/altacted otticar oficor or anolhcr wflh motor or anotherwith motor vehicle vehlcle 0ttrgr_(SP8 '«'“Y) C2. c2, Subject 22 Sex Ssx E > YES YES NO NO _l n Flmams Discharge Flrearms Dbcñarge lnt"r,u*rt D lmemma, I k Awdemal n "r"nt.l Number Number 01 of Shots Shotr Hmd Flred Numberof ‘S Numberof HI Hlts (Use ”"k"°w") (Uee UNK UNK Iflf unknovrn¡ —‘ . hi a Threatened/attacked ottioer or fhrp¡tened/att¡cl(êd ofrcðr or anotherwith anolhor nlür blunt blunl object obJcd Threatened/attacked knlte/cutting object Thrcdcnod/sttd(od otticer oficer or or anotherwith amther wth knllê/cútlng objed Tirraatenedlattached TùrÊalened/attr(fted ottioer oftcer or or another another with wlû motor motor vehicle whlde Threatened Th¡eeterpd otficar ofioor or or anotherwith anolhor wlth tireann frroarm Fired at otticer another or Flrêd åt olÍcor or anolhsr other qrt"rtro"alrl (epegiy) E ff _ > Weapon Wcapon Injured lnjuf€d ' Killed K¡fled (.;nårgeg °"“'“°° A"°"°" An6s¡Êd Under the rnrluence unOertte tnlþonce that apply) §umgg1;s_Ama_rg (check (droc* all sll that spply) Reaisted ottloer control police poÍce Reslsted olllcer confol i__ Physical threat/attack Phrßlcal thruauattacft on on otiicer oficâr or ¡nolher or another _ Age Age Race Rece Condition (specify) oln"r Un**l0ondtüon (epeclfy] Ij OtherUnusual __ I Killed Killed Other Olher (specify) Name (Last, First, Nånc (Last. Flrst, Middle) Mlddle) E injured lnjured (check all that apply) apply) 3 Threatened otiicer or another with ThÉalenêd olïcêr or anoll¡er wlth firearm ffrcarm Fired Flßd at åt otiioer oficer or or another rnothêr I i / Compliance compllanco hold hold Handslfisis Handsfisle Kicks/feet KIcllÍrst Chemicallnatural Chanlcallnalural agent agent Strikeluse Strlke/use baton baton or or other othtr object object Canine Canlrp thnaatlattackon another Physical Phlrlcâlthrçat/atlack o¡ ottioer oficor or or ¡ndher Weapon w88pon NO NO A N/A NO _ oe otiioer Redsted pollca ofreer control control _ 38 38 r°"°'9°‘ chåfgBs ""°“°" rurgEted I under me MENTAL STATUS the mauenoe lnfrr¡ence ALTERED ALTERED MENTAL flunc"r Other Unu¡u¡l Condition (Bpoclfy) Condltion (specify) flomr Unusual Age ABC M M I YES LYES YES YES Race Rsco Sex Sox HARDEN, HARDEN, TIMOTHY TIMOTHY NO NO Uniform Unlfum C1. the subject of the use oi torco by_the ct Stfiriect 1I (List only the thê person who t#ro was was thê otñcer listed the officer llrtêd In ln Section 8.) Name (Lårt, First. Nanc (Last. FlËt, Middle) Mlddlo) I Killed Kllled NO NO Compliance Comdlancè hold hold Handalfiats Handofigl¡ Klokallaet Klckdfo€l Chemicallneturat agent ChsnlcsUnatural aosnt Strikeiuse Strke/use baton brton or other object or other oblecd Canine Canlno (check all that apply) u F,,ea,.ms Dlschame V Fhearms Dl3cha196 E I ,mem,m, htenttonal mldema, R.t¿.rrttt Number Numbêr of of Show Shots Wed Fked N um ber of of HRS Hlls Number (Use UNK (Ute if unknown) unknwvn) UNK if —- Other (specify) onert¡pecrvl lfthlaotflcarused tarcpygainat more molu th¡n twa subjects In ln this incident, attach additJor_1_r_ _t_USE OF FORCE REPORTS. t_han two Signature: ut*'";bJ4 /U ' -'G s* ,l Date: Dale: 4/ 37/ / 3 4/u/r1- ,_ I hefo}qmlíty by certify that (SUPERVISOR) that II have hws reviewed nvte*ed this thls Use Farca report Uso at ol Force ßwt for accuracyand compIete_nE and hey?promptly address any issues as theymay fSU.PF{W,S?.el { he pertain or equipment, pûøin to plicy interpretation, to modify to policy interynldior., training, training beyond lralning, weapons weryns or potlicy; apply equipmnt, or or discipline. dtsdplìne, R R eoommendations eænnonddions io ndìly policy,‘ ranitdiattninlng byond what what can õan be tn Wty remedial performed by me, to wit: modify pollcx change weapons, equipment or tactics; or apply dlsclpline beyondmy capabilities be thoroughlydocumented and shall úallbathororAhlytlocumentedand Yíomad!.Ynerlowil;modttyrrllktrchangevaapws,orytpmntortac'tics;orapplydtsclplinebeyondnycapaOildiós forwarded l a¡ded thm hougþ thechain lùe ¡ 1dn command o{ ænnnand to ta the ffi e Chief Chief of of Police. Pdìce. Print our Name: mnt Supe ÐsDoM8or Ndne: ''""o*ff"'*rr4 _ 97“? /¡/&fr*, #aq 7-M;r A/at/LT/~ Supe Wt’ Slsrnatwcr ' 7/2010 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0073 0073 Filed 08/04/16 Page 75 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1110 HOWELL TOWNSHIP POLICE HOWELL TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT DEPARTMENT A. Incident lnfomtation A. lncldentlnformatlon [F09/05/2015 a-te 14:52 14:52 Time Tlme Daþ __ I Day Day ofweek of Week Saturday Saturday 09/05/2015 T "£2Lit'&i9sol is Tvos of lncldont Crime In iñ Progress Prograse Ecifrne USE FORCE REPORT USE OF OF FORCE REPORT Domestic flDomo*ic Location INCIDENT NUMBER 1017 1017 Rt. Rt. 33 33 15-39715 15-39715 Other Dtspute Dispute Traffic Stop Suspicious Person flTrafffc $usplcious Person Stop [ f]ohor Disordorly i:erso_n/Assault Person/Assault 3 0",e,(sped,y) Eloher t¡peat¡ Disorderiy B. Offlcor Offlcer Infomtatlon Name (Last, Flret, Middle) Namo (Lerrt.Tiret. Mlddle) Migdon, Michael Michael Migdon, Rank Rank Patrolman Patrolman I sedge: B8dge I Sex Sgx 645 645 Duty Duty Assignment AeElgnmenl W W lnlureo lnJurEd 32 32 77 Yes Yes Sex s€x (Lesl, I M M Under the Influence E lhe lniuence [Junoer W W NO No I Other Unusual (specify) Alta,-ed MentalStatus Unueual Condition Coridillon (spectfy) Mental Status E]or¡". i (check all that apply) I RBSIHBU poÍce ofticer Reslctsd POHOG ofncor control control 38 38 . U : fl I I ttthio olfloor used to . ‘ Age Age n Fl,-ea”-nu Discharge Flroarms Dlscharge 3 I 3 E Intenuonal hrenfionat Accldemal tuo¡oental Number Fired Number 0' of Show Shots Firerl Number Number of of Hm Hlls , —- (Use (Use UNK UNK If lf ”"k"°w") unknoun) weapon woapon Charges Charges Compliance Compllance hold hold 3 Handslflats Hard¡/ñets Ktckslteet Klckstfeel Chernlcai/natural agent Ch€mlceUnalural sgsnt Strikeluse Stdke/use baton beton or olher object or other objêd Canine Csr{ne ü J Omfltspeciiyi r injured ¡nJured 1 Killed Klllsd Firearms F¡rêarmB Diswame Dlscfisrge N n Imenuom n Aocmnm lntenllonal Accldental Numb from ber of of Shots Fired Number FhËd Num "5 er of Numbor of Hllõ " (Use ”"k”°w") (Use UNK UNK lf ur{monn) -—*— " motr than fü¡n two lso subjects In ln this incident _t_a3tach addttlgnal USE OF FORCE REPORTS. Ellnat more S gna .'?7"‘«~ "'*Wáw"r _, a .' " icheck 3" "151 HPPM D > T t Race Raco Arrested Anêst6d No No Yes Yes Othcr ispeclly) L_ other sex Sox Under unu", the ttn" mflumoe lnllr¡¡ncs Other (sp€cfy) Of'"t Unusual Unusual Condition Cqdtflon (apectty) §_i.ti2i£t2i'_l5_Ai.':i.LQtt§(Check 8" Wit apply) Roaistad polce officar R€slstod police oftcer control conùol Physical Physlcål throatlattadt lhrsâüaltsct on on otitcer omcôr or or another another _i ‘t'hreatenedlattacl’ _I 7/201 0 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0074 0074 Filed 08/04/16 Page 76 of 100 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed PageID: 1111 1Q0iPage D: HOWELL HOWELL TOWNSHIP TOWNSHIP POLICE POLICE DEPARTMENT DEPARTMENT USE USE OF OF FORCE FORCE REPORT REPORT A. Incident lncident Information «j... Date Dato Week Day Dey at olwêeft Time Tlme 09/05/2015 14:52 14.52 09/05/2015‘ (‘grime Tvpo of lnddenl IVE. ln Progress Progress l-JCdme In ,o.,,e,(sEBdD., Elot¡er tsDeurul ' ' Location L0c0tlon Saturday Saturday Domestic D Other Dispute f¡Domesüc -—_ Badge Bâdge # # Vincent Bonner, Bonner, Vincent Rank Rar* C1. c1 Duly Etrly Assignment Asülgnment Sax gox On-Duty On-Duty N I Killed K¡ll0d NO NO NO NO Uniform Unlform YES YES YES YES W W Ch‘"9°3 Çnårges A"°"'“°d Arfestôd Weapon Weapon Age Aoe Race Raco M M NO NO 38 38 I other Unusual NO Unusual Condition (sæotfy) Altered Condltlon (specify) Altered Mental Mental Status Status Elou'rt NO ' ;.v. .- n.- (drool; all that apply) r‘ ntt r Reatsted ./ Compliance pol¡cê otiioer Roolstod police oficer control confol Compllance hold hold I Physical threatlatlaokon oflloer or another Phlrslcâl thr€ât/atlack on ofrcar or anolhsr Handalfiats Hå¡(l3ffisb Threatanedlattacked another with or blunt Klckslfeel ThrÞetrnod/attsc*od otticer object ofioor or snolher lltth blur[ objed Klck¡ltuet Threatenedlattacked Threaten€d/att¡cted otltoer Chernlcellnatural olllcor or or another anolhef with wllh kniteloutting krúb/ct"úflng object obJed ClrrnlcaUnalrral agent egenl hi Threatenedlaltadted Throetcned/altacfted ottioer ofÍcsr or or another another with wllh motor vðhlcle motor vehicle Threatened ThrÞatenêd otticer offccr or or another anolher Mth lrfth fireann lïrearm Fired Flred at at ottioer oftcsr or or another enotler n D E Strtkeluse baton D Canln€ EI Canine Ammed Anêsled Suizieotlafiaiiana(check Uubl"ct's Ápllons (chedr all apply) lhat apply] a[ that Restated polloe officer Resletgd police ollcsr control control Physical Physhal threatlattaok tlreaUattack on on ottioer or another oflcor or anofro¡ J Injured lnjurad Killed Klll€d Chem” Charg€g mmm lcheck all that apply) Compliance Cornpllance hold hold Fnemms Fhoarms Discharge Dkcturge L3 Threatenedlattacked blunt object Threalaned/dtad Þ iflf this thl¡ officer used torc r Raoe Raco I Numberof Show Fired Numbor tfShots Flred Number Nurnber °f of H": Hlts (U‘° (Use UNK UNK " lf ””k"°‘”") unknom) Stflk€/lrgo baton or or other obJóct olher object Sex Sex Killed KiIed NO NO n Firearm Flream¡ Dmhmge D E Other Other (opacity) injured hJured YES YES (check all that apply) I; E Name (L^ssl, First. Nam€ (Last. Flrat, Middle) Mlddc) , I was C2. c2. Subject 22 1 Injured lnþred 27 27 torce by the Slfllject.’ I1 (List only the thê person who we3 the sugiecl of of the use of the uie; of lorca the otticer ofrcer listed llsted In ln Section 8.) L_ Other(specify) . Stop Age Age W W 77 iHARDEN, HARDEN, TIMOTHY TIMOTHY Under the influence lnllu€nce flunoc, the w Race Rece M M Years Yeañ¡ of of Service Sew¡cô Name (Last, First. Namê (Last, Flrst, Middle) Mldtlle) I Sex Sex 647 647 PATROLMAN PATROL PATROLMAN PATROL I flfrafftc Ofticerlnformation B. B. I #15-39715 #15-39715 Susplciors Person Person I Suspicious floúrerDtspuro DISORDERLY DISORDËRLY PERSON/ASSAULT PERSON / ASSAULT Nam€ I INCIDENT NUMBER 1017 1017 Rt.33 Rt.33 tr Handsltists Hand$ñ8ts Kickalfeet Kick¡/ftet Chemicallnatural CÌnmlcal/nalural agent agent Strikeluse batch Strlke/u3ê baton or 6lher object of other obþd Canine Canlne Q o,¡.r (specify) f] Other tsr¡sdty) E E lmenuonm tntendon¡t Accldenm Acctdentet Number Number of Shotg Fired of Shots Fketl Numb" of Numbor of HR’ l-lits (Use (Uee UNK UNK "lf ""k"°w") unknotìít) 4 t galnat mo_ro than th¡n two aubiggtg in ln thtg thl¡ tnclden n_t_tach additional USE OF FORCE REPORTS. .â6r r v¢é¢’7 Dale: 09/03/2015 09/08/2015 of Force (SUPERVISOR) It hereby and have promptly address any issues as theymay henby certify caüly thatI ¡wiewaó lhìs Use thal I have hava reviewedthis llse of Fonø report report for for accuracy accuncy and aø completeness lo ISUP€RI4SOfi, pertain pedaln to pdlcy interpretation, to policy lnterpretatü, training. tralnlng, weapons uupus or e{¡ulpnent, or beyondwhat or equipment‘, u discipline. dlsctpline, R R ecommendallans sæmmendalions to to modifypolicy; tttúlly policy; apply apply remedial remdlat training tnining-beyond whdt can õan be b performed prfuned by or tactics; plicy; change by me. me, to to wit *ft modity nodtty policy; ahanç weapons, weapns, equipment laotias; or equipnod u or applydiscipline aply disaipline beyond byond my ny capabilities eapaim¡es shall *aA be U thoroughly thoroughti documented dæunsntú and and I forwarded the chain the Chlalat fü*âtdo¡l through ,ht hþg ol command connend to lotln Qldef ol Poly. Pollæ 9þþ at Print Supervi Name: . .- /4»=‘— /»44.e7~/.3 \] #239 z3s SumM/«V e: C29 . I’ 7/2010 Prosecutor's File 0075 Prosecutor's File 0075 Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 77 of 100 PagelD: 1112 Howell Township Police Department number Printed: 05/05/2015 ma: owns/2015 0-11 m" an) n. on Antian 15-35715 us: 911 magnum pmou cell Take cam. apr. memes nenevnn Lacuna/Adam" HEB) soclmv 7 101.7 RT 33 Party muted By 09/05/2015 1901 660 Ell. Heather Schaminskx lemma me, mam, mu: . -- . cm" GROVE, NJ 07756 ullEnck Number- me . sax: Party snared By: 09/05/2015 1943 660 Heather Mama Party: ma, 9121512114.); :7 - -- mm mes, NJ 07721 causack "umber: -- me: Sex: :2 Parry Entered By 09/u5/2axs 1944 sea 7 12:1. Heather schaxbinski Involved Party: mm: mm mmuzw a M'uumolN-n Calla-ck Number: -- me: Sex; Party annexed By: mus/2m 1515 550 A Pt), neezher acnerblnexs xnvelvea Party: umz, 3mm Mm nee: Sax: may Enterad By: owns/ms 1m an m. "Either senermnm Involved nucm Joann>> A A name, Mr n7731 mum mum: -- a cex sex: :1 any Enzaud By: ns/ns/ms 1950 can 9:1. neamer sanermnekl Involved Party: Mums, Izmnu a -- 7 aluminum, mr 11215 Cellaecx Number: Race: sex: :1 Party unrated By: us/ns/nms 15:2 660 Ptl. Haithel scherhinlkl mowed perry. spasm>>; mum" - . am" move, we D7755 unnaack met: mace: w: sneezed ny: aJ/os/zms 202: "a Ptl. Hut)": Scnaxbiniki znvazvea Barty: annex - runml mes. 0772: mun-ck nuance . Race: a sex: 05/05/2015 nun sso -- m. Hemm scherbinaki mm .- annex llacn: ex: Entamfl a (wins/mus ans ssa - Ptl: Kenn-er schermneu Invalvud vexey: EMILIUBaml rm; cum-ck mar: -- has: Sex: Putty Entured Hy: ns/ns/zms 2031 can - vu. Head-e: Invelvad any: NERI. ANDREI I: -- - WT, In can: unanck Number: Rana: :1 sex annexed By: as/os/zoxs an): em m. Heather sch-xbinnki Involvcd Party: m'rmi-- - sum, M723 callalck mneer: lung: 0 se Entcxed ny- as/ns/zaxs 2035 560 7 pt), ngther schexbinaki mey: mm, mm -- Pun", 09955 culls-ck Numb9:1: Jung. cuneey. Jr map-14:55:17 And-15:41:55 Uni-22:41:21 xv: . nu: Dania) Jr. Dinp>>1l masmmv eugenmm Bus um: nugdus'luv luring-15 uzun m: - En. Vincent Hanna: nun-nevus Enrbu 57:0 And-15mm; m: as 12:1. meme) nigum Buzz-14:58:09 Amelsmem enraezzmm EMS unxt- 198564,:1155 ins Page 1 m. {gate Prosecutor's File 0076 Filed 08/04/16 Page 78 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1113 Howell Howell Township Townshíp Police Police Department Department Call CaLl- Number Numbcr Printed: Prlnt,ed: 09/05/2015 09/05/201,5 Page: Page: 2 2 Clrd-16:04:05 Disp-14:58:13 Disp-l4:58:13 Enrt-15:00:25 EnrL,-15r00¡25 Arvd-15:09:40 Arvd-15:09r40 Clrd-16:04¡05 :32 InSrvce—22:17:32 Hosp-16:14:39 Hoap-16:14339 Clrflosp-22:17 Clrllo8p-22:17r32 Insrvce-22 tl'l t32 654 654 - Ptl. PEI. Nicholas Nlcholas Austin Àustín Disp—15:04:04 DÍsP-15:O4¡04 Enrt-15:04:05 Clrd-2224L 12 B¡l¡t-15:04:05 Arvd-15:05:50 Arvd-l5:05¡50 Clrd—22:41:12 ID: ID: - Unit: EMS EIIIS Unlt¡ MDICB-Medics MEDICB.Medfcs Disp-15:24:01 DJ.sp-15:24:01 Enrt-15:25:39 Enrb-15!25:39 Arvd-15:30:41 .Arvd-15:30¡41 C1rd—16:04:09 CIrd-16:04:09 :20 InSrvce—l9:41:20 Hosp-16:14:37 Hosp-16 ! 1¡t;3? C1rHosp—19:41 CIrHoEp-19 I 41:20 fngrvce-19 ¡ 41:20 238 238 - Sgt. sgt. Thomas Thoñas Weg ¡{eg ID: ID¡ - Disp—l5:24:17 Dlêp-15 ¿24217 Bnrt-15:24:18 Enrb-15:211:18 Arvd-15:38:10 An¡d-15:38¡10 650 650 - Ptl. Ptl. Thomas Thofias Poznanski Poznanski ' Disp-15:30:13 Disp-ls:30r13 Enrt415:30:16 Àrvd-15:36:40 Clrd—16:42:49 EnrÈ:15!30!16 Arvd-15:36:40 Clrd-16242:49 ID: 660 Heather Ptl. rD: 660 ' Ptl. lfeather scherbinski Scherbingki Enrt-15:31:22 Arvd—15:36:41 Disp-15:31:18 Disp-].s:31:18 Enrb-15:31:22 Arvd-15:36:4L Clrd-16:42:45 Clrd-16:{2:45 245 ID: Sgt. Peter ID¡ 245 - SgË. Feter Kuppler Kuppler Disp-15:31:31 Ðisp-1533L!3L Enrt—l5:31:34 BnrE-15¡31:34 ArVd—15:46:03 Arvd-15:46:03 C1rd—20:40:46 Clrd-2o:40:46 ID: 662 - Ptl. Sean Macdonald ID: 662 PEl. Sean l{aedonald Disp-15:31:43 Dfsp-ls:31:43 Enrt-15:31:44 Clrd-l9r24:48 Enrb-15:31:44 AIVG-15:34:43 Ar¿d-15:34r43 Clrd-19:24:48 ID: 655 ID¡ PÈ1., Ryan Lowe 655 - Ptl. Lor¡te Clrd-15:26:28 Arvd-15:37:20 Disp-15:37:17 Dlsp-15r37¡17 Arvd-ls:37:20 clrd-19:26:28 ID: 663 ID: 663 - Daniel Danlel scherbinski Scherþinsk1 Clrd-16:37:28 Arvd-15:46:48 Disp-15:46:44 Dlep-1s:46r{{ Àrvd-15:46:48 cl-rd-16!37!28 ID: 604 ID: 504 - Det. Deb. Robert Robert Ortenzi Orhenzi Arvd-17:10:01 Disp-16:45:07 Enrt-16:51¡41 .Arvd-l?:10¡01 Disp-16r{5:0? Enrt-16:51:41 Christian Antunez 243 ID: TD¡ 243 - Sgt. Sgt, Chrlsb,ian.ã¡rtunez Disp-16:45:13 Dlsp-16r45!13 Enrt-16:51:38 Àrvd-1?:09!52 Enrt-16:51:38 Arvd-17:09:52 ID: 660 TD: Ileather Scherbinski Scherbinekl 660 - Ptl. Ptl., Heather Arvd—16:47:O2 nisp—16:46:s9 Clrd-19:06:53 Disp-16:46:59 Àrvd-16 r47¡ O2 Clrd-19:06:53 ID: 198 ÌD: 198 - Det. Deb. Christopher ChrisEopher Nagy t{agiy Arvd-17:10:11 Disp-17:10:07 Dlap-l? I 1O:07 Arvd-l7: 1O r 11 Narrative: Donovan 09/05/2015 NarrabLve: co¡Íú. opr. 09 OS/?OLS 1455 1r¡55 Comm. Opr. Thomas Tbon¡r Dorovâ¡ Îlm Security Tim. Tim holdt.ng aa subject down by by the bhe name name of of, Tim. Securfty is ie holding subjêct down became lnfluence be under under the the influence became very ven¡ hostile think he he may may be hoscile they think ID: IDr - ~ - — — — - - — - of unk substance. They are requesting to anyone. Caller is Eleni 1 weapons :: i"#'::oiå'lii;'31'Ë"ïi:'ïrEïååi'ffHtiu"'" or Narrative: Narratlve: a - injuries ' 09/05/2015 09/A5/2OlÊ 1529 1529 Comm. åny Bordfeld Bordf€Id Co¡rn. Opt. o¡lr. Amy patl,enb patrol paErol requesting to sedate aedabe the èhe patient nredlcs to requesËlng medics Narrative: t{arratlve: 09/05/2015 a9/0512015 1617 opr. Amy A$y Bordfeld Eorû!êlal 1617 comm. C@r, Opr. office wa6 was notified 1602 hours prosecueors offl.ce rnaJor crimes crimes nouffied for f,or major L6o2 hours prosecutors contact to Èo conÈacè 238 238 Narrative: l{arrativef Narrative: llarratlve: Modified üodlfled By: 09/05/2015 qpr. Any å¡!y nordleld 09/o5/20t5 1617 16X7 Con. com. Opr. 8orûtcld advises be enroute enroube wtll be thaE himself hlmsclf and several det det will advlses that and several shortly Éhort.ly 243 2{3 09/05/2015 Tbonrt Neg 09/05/20l'5 2123 2123 Sgt. 9En. Thomas tfag 09/05/2015 2239 Sgt. agt-. Thomas tbourt Weg 9lêg O9IOS/2015 2233 643) The (6t4, 654, 647' and and 643) 643, 647, fol.lorlng officers off{cers (644, 654¡ 645, tt¡e following to the etiÈh aa responded sEaff with s€curity staff Fríedalne to to assist a8Éist security reaponded Èo bhe Priedaine an unknown of an unknown patron they prbron ïas under lnfluênce of under the tlre influence bellevcd was Èhey believed substance was acting substânce and and ras actlng unruly. yOA, Belmar, Harden (38 (38 YQA, Timothy bhe security cecurfty B€lrnar, NU)res1sted Nû) rê8f8Èed the Tfmothy Hard€n to officers pollce gaiD control to police of him hlm prior control of offlcers attempt åÈtsmlrt, to !o gain Prlor also resisted arrival. contrgl upon Ôff,lcers control llowell officers reefsted Howell arrlval. Harden Harden algo their on location. locaEfon' At At' were on a¡rd Medics Medics were bhelr arrival. xowell EMS Eltts and ¿rrlval. Howell and unresponsive. some He unresPongLve. He polnb, Harden unconsdiouã ând became unconscious aome point, Harden became deceased. was ¡16uuc where sh€rs he wae pronounced deceaeed. he was waa transported Eianaporhþd to Eo JSUMC ño8'ñ reports gee the See for further. further. #238 þhe "OF" rep0rt6 for *238 To Incident: Refer Refer To fncident: 15'39715j9E 15-39?15-OF Prosecutor's File 0077 0077 Prosecuto/s File Filed 08/04/16 Page 79 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1114 oxman STATEMENT STATEMENT ¿ ~O°'J\1cx:.n>LN_¢, O~oe\)c._,r‘'3§:5-— 3 4 5 6 ? I STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: Patrolman Patrolman Nicholas Nicholas Austin Austin ADDRESS ADDRESS & & TELEPHONE TELEPHONE NO: NO: 300 300 Old Old Tavern Tavem Road Road New Howell, New Jersey 07731 07731 9 .- i0 'I DATE DATE & & PLACE PLACE OF OF BIRTH: BIRTH: .2 5 ,4 . Brooklyn. Brooklyn" New New York York SOCIAL SOCIAL SECURITY SECURI' Y NUMBER: NUMBER; — TAKEN TAKEN AT: AT: Monmouth Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor’s Office 132 132 Jerseyville Jerseyville Avenue Avenue 74 Freehold. F'reehold, New New Jersey Jersey 07728-23 07728-2374 QUESTIONED BY: QIJESIIONED BY: Detective Detective Daniel Daniel Bozza Bozza Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Monnrouth Courrt,v Prosecutor's Office O I fìcc Wl'l'NESS1§D \,VI'I'NL.SSTïD BY: BY: Detective Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Perez Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor‘s Prosecutor's Office Offi ce 5 6 G:.r5a;,3H- . i8 r9 !0 !l t2 t1 ' t5 Darren Darren M. M. Gelber, Celber, Esq. Esq, for Attorney Attorney for Nicholas Nicholas Austin Austin 16 l7 t8 :9 ,TYPED TYPEDBY: BY; Rose Rose Gulino Gulino Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's OtÏce Prosecutor'.s Office DATE DATE & & TIME: TIME: 2015; 3:29 Monday, Monday, November November 30. P.M 30.2015; 3:29 P.M. rû il t2 'J t4 i-5 i6 t7 t8 íg t0 il t2 r3 j4 Patrolman Patrolman Nicholas Nicholas Austin, Austin, II am am Detective Bozza of the Monmouth Detective Daniel Daniel Bozza of the Morrmouth County Counry Prosecutor’s Office and is here Detective Rosendo Perez of Prosecutor's Offìce and present here is Detective Rosendo Perez of the the same same office. office. Ittt is is our questions regarding our duty duty to to ask ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the circumstances sumounding the the incident incidc.nt which which occurred occurrcd at at Pricdiane Priodiane located located at at 1017 l0l7 Route Route 33, 33, Freehold. Fleehold. New New Jersey Jersey involving involving Timothy Tinrothy Harden 2015. have on Follow we 5, September questions Harden on September 5,2015. Specifically, up questions regarding Specifically, we have fbllow up regarding the the before Timothy moments just before momenfs just Timothy Harden Harden stopped stopped breathing. breathing. 'l'his statement This and accord, statement must given of must be be aa voluntary voluntary one, given own free free will will and accord, without wíthout of your own threats in of Court what used that be Law. or a promises, knowing any threats or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of'Law. r5 lc rryCFO ,t{ßf,¡r" ¢o78 Filed 08/04/16 Page 80 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1115 \oxu.I:mN I . J 4 5 6 7 I 9 ,0 rl i2 ,J '4 l5 r6 t7 t8 i9 !0 !I I t3 !4 t5 t6 t7 t8 ,.9 t0 I t2 t3 t4 t5 l6 t7 r8 t9 t0 il t2 t3 .>4O?op a a a a 63 €>.~O§ ?>o Statement Stalement of of Patrolman Patrolman Nicholas Nicholas Austin Austin Page Page22 of4 of 4 Are Are you willing gíve aa voluntary willing to to give voluntary statement statement at at this this time? time? Yes. Yes. What is your age? age? 'ühat is 27. 27. What What is is your occupation? occupation? Police Officer. Police Officer. What What is formal education? is your formal education? A justice. A bachelor’s bachelor's degree degree in in criminal criminal justice. Are Are you married? married? Yes. Yes. Can Cari you read, read, write write and and understand understand the the English Language? English Language? Yes. Yes. How positioned moments How was Timothy Harden unresponsive? was Timothy Harden positioned he became became unresponsive? nloments before before he Face Faoe down down on stomach, his back. on his his stomach, hands were were cuffed cuffed behind behind his his hands his back. When: your position position in Mr. Harden Harden became was your to Timothy Timothy Harden when Mr. becanre Where was in relation! Harden when relationl to a. unresponsive? unresponsivei A II was his torso region, like like the the back in his buttock region, back of of was on on the lower left left side of his body near torso in his buttock the lower side of his body near his his his thighs/quads. thighs/quads. a. Please positioned at in detail Please describe describe in detail how was positioned at this this time? time? how your body body was A II was on each each leg. one hand hand on leg. his legs, legs, one was on and my hands much on on his on my knees knees and hands were were pretty much a Prior positioned? where were were you positioned? Timothy Harden Harden becomingunresponsive, becoming unresponsive, where Prior to to Timothy A of Exactly hand on each of on each position II described one hand was on knees, one Exactly in above. II was on my knees, in the the same same position described above. his the back of legs. the back of his legs. M a f,r l5 Fflecutofis 79 File 9079 d".utor's File 08/04116 Filed 08/04/16 Page 81 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1116 Statement of Patrolman Statement of Patrolman Nicholas Nicholas Austin Austin ot‘4 Page Page 33 of4 1I 2L 33 44 55 66 77 8I 99 00 -.1 'la .2 IL :3 i3 :4 !4 15 '5 :6 i6 7 8I 3:9 i9 Q. At the moments At any point poinl in in the or when m.oments leading leading up to became unresponsive to or when Mr, Mr. Harden Harden became unrespo¡sive did did you put your body on Mr. body weight weight on Mr. Harden? Harden? A. A No. No. Q. a At At any point point in in the the. moments leading leading up up to to or or when when Mr. Mr. Harden Harden become become unresponsive unresponsive did did strike Mr. you strike Mr. Harden? Harden? A. No. No. Q. At At any point point leading leading up to to or when Mr. or when Mr. Harden Harden become become unresponsive, unresponsive, did did you restrict restrict Mr. Mr. Harden’s means? Harden's airways airways by by any means? A. A No. No. Q. a Did Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments leading leading up or when up to, or became when Timothy Tinrothy Harden Harden became Mr. unresponsive, Harden’s unresponsive, restrict restrict Mr. Harden's airway? airway? A. No. No. Q. Did Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments moments leading to, or leading up up to, or when when Timothy Timothy Harden llarden became became utilize their unresponsive, unresponsive, utilize their body body weight Mr. Harden’s chest? weight to to put pressure on on Mr. Harden,s chest? A. No. No. Q. a Did Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments momenfs leading leading up up to, or or when when Timothy Timothy Harden Harde¡r became became unresponsive, unresponsive, utilizetheir utilize their body Mr. Harden’s on neck? body weight weight to put to put pressure on Mr. Harden's neck? A. A. No. No, Q. a. Did Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments moments leadint leading 6 uup P to to or or when when Timothy Timofhy Harden Harden became becanre strike Mr. unresponsive, unresponsive, strike Mr. Harden? Harden? :0 !0 21 \ ” ,¿ 23 l3 14 l4 25 !5 26 t6 t1 :7 28 !8 ,.9 !9 I0 r0 ll I 52 t2 I3 t3 i4 t4 is t5 I6 ló :7 t7 58 }E l9 t9 l0 ,0 it I j2 l2 l3 13 in lâ is t5 _ A. A No. No, Q. a From From your position were were you able able to to see see if if anyone was was striking striking him him or or using using their body their body restrain Mr. weight Harden? weight to to restrain Mr. Harden? A. A From a clear From where where II was was II had actions and had a clear view view of of the the other other officers officers and theiractio¡rs and their and II didn’t didn,t see see anyone do anyone strike or obstruct strike or or use to his use body body weight/pressure weighlpressure or do anything an¡hing to obstruct his airway. airway, Q a Upon upon your arrival arrival at at the the scene, did did you observe observe any injuries injuries to to Mr. Mr. Harden? Harden? A. A. Yes. Yes. Prosec&W' § 'or"aa* P File File p080 080 Filed 08/04/16 Page 82 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1117 Statement Statement ofPatrolman of Patrolman Nicholas Nicholas Austin Austin Page Page 44 of4 of 4 I 2 a Can describe in please describe Can you please in detail detail the the injury injury you observed observed on on Mr. Mr. Harden Harden upon your arrival? anival? A. Inoticed I noticed ajelly a jelly like like bloody bloody mucus mucus on on Harden’s Harden's face face in in the the area area of of his his nose nose and and mouth. mouth. 3 4 Break Break 3:39 3:39 // Resume Resume 3:40 3:40 6 7 8 a Is statement at anything else Is there there anything else you would would like like to add to to add to your statement at this time? this time? A. No. No. 9 i0 rl t2 TYPING p.M. TYPING CONCLUDED CONCLUDED - DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: Monday, Monday, November Novenrber 30, 30. 2015, 2015, 3:41 3:41 P.M. ,4 — i5 ,6 STATEMENT STATEMENT REVIEW REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE 1 i8 II have of 44 pages; each have read read this this statement statemenl consisting consistíng of each page bears bears my nry initials initials including including any corrections initialed in and II certify conections initialed in my own handwriting; nty own handwriting; and certify that that the the facts facts contained corrtaincd herein herein are are l9 JO true. true. l1 r l¡ M-,o7/,;_ t- I T¿l\o 3:cn{,n, DATEANDTIME; DATE AND TIMË: rl ho / tç t4 ){ Y E ”4>”‘:L .I3atrol i ,an-4l‘~J're}io asAu3t_'9,'ás !6 gm t7 r8 Patrol t9 t0 n las -‘ /’ ,z A /,, /Ob Cpflfir, Esq Darren Darren M. M, Esq for Nicholas Attomey Attomey for Nicholas Austin Austin ,J t4 ‘ , t5 P“. t6 t7 ‘~-—‘‘_ t8 9 t0 il 12 t3 t,l t,\ _’ VE ,— ,;___f, Detective Dani ‘; :17" :#_ ~ . /' —-’ . Sozzz-1 -3411/LL19 Monmouth Morunouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office tce ¡l <ç Detective Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Perez Monmouth Monmouth County County .Prosecutor's ffice Prosecutor's File Prosecutor's File p081 81 Filed 08/04/16 Page 83 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed _P_age _[_): 1118 II STATEMENT STA.TEMENT a 2--— 33 44 55 6 6 77 8I 99 :0 r0 1I 22 33 .4 .4 5) 6 '6 77 88 ,9 .9 10 l0 ll I 32 t2 23 t3 24 \. 1435 15 16 !6 ,.7 17 38 l8 t9 t9 to t0 ilII $2 i2 l3 t3 I4 t4 :5 i5 :6 i6 t7 t7 18 l8 '.9 i9 to t0 ll il I2 I2 13 ti 14 f4 15 ¡.r I6 ló STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: Patrolman Bonner Patrolman Vincent Vincent Bonner ADDRESS NO: 300 ADDRESS & & TELEPHONE TELEPHONE NO: 300 Old Old Tavern Tavern Road Road New Howell. Jersey 07731 Howell. Neu'Jersev 07731 DATE DATE & & PLACE PLACE or OF BIRTH: BIRTH: r— SOCIAL SOCIAL SECURITY SECIJRITY NUMBER: NUMBER: _ Lakewood, New Jersey Jersey Lakewood, New . AKËN AT: TAKEN AT: Monmouth Prosecutoros Office Oflice Monnroutlr Count) Count¡ Prosecutor’s Avenue I32 I 32 Jerseyvillc Jersel,vil lc Avenue Freehold, Freehold, Nevt Neu Jersey .ls¡ssy 07728-2374 07728-2374 QUESTIONED BY: QUESTIONED BY: Detective Bozz-¿t Defectile Daniel Daniel Bozza Ot'tice Monmouth It4onnrouth CoLmt\ Crlunt\ Prosectttor’.~: Prttseculot's Ollìcc WITNESSED WITNESSED BY: BY: Lieutenant Singer Eric Singer Lieutenant Eric Oftice Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Monnlouth Countv Prosecl¡tur's Ol]ice Charles Charles Uliano, Uliano, Esq. Esq. Attorney Bonner, Attomey for for Vincent Vincent Bonner, TYPED TYPED BY: BY: Rose Rose Gulino Culino Monmouth Ofïice Proseculor's Office County Prosecutor's Monnroulh County DATE DATE & & TIME: TIME: Friday, P,M. 2Al5; 3:01 November 20, 2Q, 2015; 3 :0 I P.M. Friday, November Patrolman the Monmouth of the lvfonnrouth County Daniel Bozza Bozza of County Patrolman Vincent Vincent Bonner, Bonner, II am am Detective l)etective Daniel of office. the it Lieutenant Eric is same and here Prosecutor’s Office Singer is our our Prosecutor's Office and present present here is Lieutenant Eric Singer of the same office. lt is the incident which circumstances the ask to duty you questions questions regarding surroundirìg the incident u,hich duty to ask you regarding the circu¡nstances surrounding occurred Jersey involving Neu'.fersey involving Timothy Timothy occuned at located at at 1017 1017 Route Route 33. 33. Freehold, Freehold, New at Priediane Priediane located Harden on September 5, 2015. Specifically. questitins regarding rcualding the u'e have up questions thc havo follow lbllon up Harden on September 5,2015. Spccifically. we before Harden moments breathing. just Timothy stopped moments before Timothy Hardcn stop¡red breathing. and accord, own free. This rvithout r¡ill and free vtill accord. without given of of your ow'rt volunt{rry one, This statement onc, given statement must nlust be be aa voluntary Luw. of used in Court be that a kl10\’\ what or may in a Court tll'[.ar¿,. promises, you nra¡' be used say prornises, what sây mg knou lng that any threats threats or g EXHIBIT EXHIBIT /»7cfl° frcpo 55' ãil _____ , Prosecutorg File 0D82 p,o"ecviiîl{rit" 2 ?”§3>'.O’"Qp, of Filed 08/04/16 Page 84 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1119 I 2 3 4 6 7 I 9 0 I 2 3 4 5 6 1 8 9 l0 ll !: t3 l4 l5 t6 t7 t8 a Are a voluntary gir,'c a Are you willing willíng to to give voluntary statement statenlent at al this this time? tilne? A. Yes. Yes. a What What is is your age? age? A. 27. 27. a. rvVhat is What is your occupation‘? occupation? A. Police Policc Officer‘. Ol'ficer. o What formal education? What is is your fbrnral education? A, Associates Associates Degree. l)egree. a Are Arc you married’? marrícd? A, Yes. Yes, a. Can Can you read, read, write wrile and understand the and understand tho English English Language? Languagc? A. Yes. Yes. a. How positioneri moments was Timothy unrespottsivc? How was Tirnothy Harden nro¡rren(s before before he he became became unresponsive? Harden positioned A. He He was was laying on his his stomach, his hands were handcuffed his back. back. luying on stonraoh, his hancls were handcuffed behind behind his a. Where to Timothy your position position in when Mr. Harden became was your Mr. Harden becanre Where was in relation relation to Tirnothy Harden Harden when l9 t0 lt t2 i3 II was was down down by by his his feet. feet. a. in detail Can at Mr. please describe l-eet? positioned at Harden's feet? describe ín Mr, Harden's detail how how you positioned Can you please A. to My hands wel'e somewhere somL'where close close lo hands were hands holding holding his Íbet down. down, My was kneeling. with my his feet II was kneeling. with nr¡, hands feet. his his Íbet. a where were Prior unresponsive, where yotr positioned? positioned? were you }larden becoming Timothy Harden beconring utrresponsive, Prior to to Timothy A. Same prior question. question. as the the prior Same location lc¡cation as i6 l7 t8 r9 t0 H 12 unresponsive? unresponsive? A, t4 t5 Statement Statement of of Patrolman Patrolman Vincent Vincellt Bonner Bonner Page Page 22 of oî 55 13 l¿ l5 Pr P )083 r's File F¡le t 3083 Filed 08/04/16 Page Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Pag 85 of 100 PageID: 1120 Statement Statemelrt of of Patrolman Patrr.llnran Vincent Vi¡rcent Bonner Bonlrer Page Page 33 ors of5 While While you were were restraining restraiuing Mr. Mr. Harden Hartlen by by his his feet, feet, did onto Mr. did you put your body bo.us)_°,UbwN I Statement of Patrolman Statenlent of Palrolman Vincent Vincent Bonner Bonnel. Page Page 5s of5 ors Q. a. Is Is there there anything a'ything else add to else you would would like like to to add to your statement sratement at at this this time? time? A. A, No. No. 2 J 4 5 TYPING TYPING CONCLUDED CONCLUDED - DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: Friday, p,M. Friday, November 2015, 3:17 P.M. November 20. 20.201s,3:17 6 — 7 I STATEMENT STATEMENT REVIEW REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE SiGNATTJRE 9 0 II have have read read this tlris statement .statement consistirrg consisting of of 55 , pages; each each page bears bears my initials initials including including initialed in any corrections correctio¡rs initialed own and I my that the in own handwriting; handwriting; and I.ertify certify that the facts facts contained conlained herein are herein are true. lrlre, I 2 J 4 T1ME:%_./«_;__’_ 5 /Q57?‘/_ 5/ DATEAND DATE AND TIME: 6 7 __ .8 I . _/ 10 9 _v/r ,-' / ' 2 ; (,»} ' / , ¢ Patrolman rtllnla¡r Vincent Villccnt liolllte: otìndr -+— !l l: l3 l4 ' .__ !6 t7 .— -———-~——-,-- - , . .4 -~«~ — ¿1 /+-l'-¿ -,:,_.-Clmrles Uliano, Uliano, Esq. E.-q Attorney Attorney for for Vincent Vincent Bonner Bonner . t5 .r— /1 ¿t s// 7;32 .,._ _ , . l8 t9 3.65 t0 Z‘. tl t2 x 1...,“ I Bozza zrnicllB<>zza Coulrty Prosecutor's Office t3 t4 t5 t6 l7 r8 County Prosecutor's OtTice Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0086 6 Filed 08/04/16 Page 88 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1123 SSTATEÑIENT TATEMENT A ¿ J3 44 55 66 77 I8 99 :0 t0 II 22 :3 :J :4 :4 55 66 77 .8 .8 99 20 l0 1 ,') 12 2? ll 34--— I'a-,.5 £5 :6 t6 ,.7 £7 I 28 r8 ,.9 29 I0 t0 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF OF:: ADDRESS ADDRESS & & TELEPHONE TELEPHONE NO: NO: 300 300 Old Otd Tavern Tavem Road Road New Howell, Howell, New Jersey Jersey 07731 07731 — DATE DATE & & PLACE PLACE or OF BIRTH: BIRTH: - SOCIAL SOCIAL SECURITY SECTJRITY NUMBER: NUMBER: - :9 i9 to t0 Il il I2 12 I3 li I4 l4 I5 t5 ltl t(r Point Point Pleasant, Pleasant, New Nerv Jersey .lersey TAKEN AT: TAKEN AT: Monmouth Office Monmouth County Cúunt)' Prosecutor’s P"roseçutor's Otïìce 132 Avenue I 32 Jerseyville Jerseyville Averruc Freehold, Irreehold, Neu Neu Jersey .Iersey 07728-2374 07728-2374 QUESTIONED BY: QUESTIONED BY: Detective Detective Daniel Daniel Bozza Bozza Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office Office WITNESSED V/ITNESSED BY: BY: Lieutenant Singer Lieutenant Eric Eric Singer Monmouth County Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office Office Richard Richard Incremona, Inoremon4 Esq. Esq. Attorney Conaty, Jr. Attomey for Patolman James for Patrolman James Conaty, Jr TYPEDBY: ].YI'ËD BY; Rose Rose Gulino Culino Monmouth Mo¡lmouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Office DATE DATE & & TIME: TIME: 2015; 12:16 Friday, Friday, November November 20, 20.2A15; l2:ló P.M. P.M. IIII I2 t2 I3 l3 I4 t4 I5 t5 I6 t6 I7 ,l 18 t8 Patrolman Conaty, Jr. Patrolman James Ja¡nes Conaty, Jr Patrolman the Monmouth Jr., 1J am Patrolman James James Conaty, Conafy, Jr., Detective Daniel Da¡riel Bozza Bozza of or' thc lllonmoullr County am Detective Count¡' Prosecutor’s the Lieutenant Eric of oI'1ice. It sznne Prosecutor's Office Singer Office and and present here here is rhe sallre is Lieutenant Eric Singer of otiìce. It isis our ot¡r ask to the circumstances the duty surrounding you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident duty to ask you questions regarding incident nhich lhich occurred involving Timothy occured at at Priediane Priediane located located at at 1017 1017 Route Route 33, 33, Freehold, Freehold, New New Jersey Jerse¡'invoh'ing Tinrothy Harden 2015. Specifically, Harden on on September September 5, questions regarding r.r'c have 5,2015, Specifically. we rcgarding the have follow follow up up questions the moments breathing. moments just before stopped before Timothy Timothy Harden breathing. Harden sbpped This ()ne, given rvíll and This statement gil'en of anrJ accord, accorcl. without u'ithout statement must voluntâry one, o\\n free free will must be be aa voluntary of your mm any threats promises, knowing threats or hc used of Lav». or promises, knorving that vrhat you say sûy may r¡sed in in ata Court Court of Lau. that what rnay he r77C P O rosecutor's rosecu tor's F F I187@087 7 ©.>4o_p unresponsive? unr es¡ronsive? .4. Kneeling to his his left left arm. arrn Kneeling next next to a, Please your hands placed on [he time Please describe in detail Hardert at at the tinre he descrihe in detail where where your hands were were placed on Mr. Mr. Harden he became unresponsive? hccanre unresportsive? A. II don’t arm. of his left left arm. it was was one one or but II had had hold hold ofhis don't rememberif rernember if it or both both ofmy of my hands hands but a, Prior Timothy Harden positioned? where were \À'ere you positioned? Prior to Harden becomingunresponsive, bccornirrg unresponsive, where to Tinroth¡ Filed 08/04/16 Page 89 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed PagelD: 1124 I 2 -t 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 I 2 J 4 5 6 7 :8 ,9 t0 lt t t3 ,.4 ,-5 r6 t7 l8 t9 t0 'J t4 Are Are you willing willing to give aa voluntary to give voluntary statement time? statenlent at at this this time? A, Yes. Yes. a What What is is your age? age? A 30 30 a What is What is your occupation? occupation? A. Police Police Officer. Officer. a. What education? What is is your formal forrnal educatioll? A, (lollege. College. a Are Are you married? married? A. Yes. Yes. a Can reud, write write and understand the Carr you read, a¡d understand the English Language? English Language? A. Yes. Yes. a. How How was was Timothy positioned moments unresponsive? Timothy Harden he became becams unresponsive‘? Harden positioned mornents before before he A. handcuffed behind Lying Lying on on his his stomach, stonrach, he he was was handculfed his back. back. behind his a, Where your position position in Where was was your in relations relations to whcn Mr. Mr. Harden Harclcn became Harden when hccanlc to Timothy Timolhy Harden t5 t6 t7 ;8 t9 t0 il l2 t3 Page Page 2z am of t a. lt lz Statement James C Statenrent of'Patrolman r., of'Patrolnralr Janres onaty, JJr,, Conaty, A. II was two of hands on of my hands on his with one one or or two his was kneeling in the the dirt where he he was was laying, kneeling in dirt next next to to where laying, with of him in anticipation left or arm in grip irr placed on tnoving or anticipation of him moving was placed in aa grip left arm. arm. My My hand hand was on his his left lcft arm times done several earlier. he had as resisting resisting as he had done several times enrlier. lJ Fit? 1088I Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Fi C 9 Filed 08/04/16 Page 90 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed PagelD: _1_;_25 1125 oxm.:_\°g]cUAwN "‘O\0JcU-.59:I_3o°', _ Statement Conaty, Jr., Stalenlent of of Patrolman Patrolnralr James Jar¡es Corraty, Jr., Page Page 33 of of44 a While you were Whíle were restraining restraining Mr. Mr. Harden IJarden by left arm with your hand by his his left arm with hand or or hands, hands, did did you Harden? put your body body weight weight onto onto Mr. Mr. Harden? A, No. No, a. At At the the time tinle that that Mr. Mr. Harden becalne unresponsive placing your body Harden became were you placing unresponsive were body weight weight on on his left other of his with other hands of arm or or body his left arm or any other part of his body with your hands or any other part part of your body? hody? A. No, only part of No, the the only of my body body that with his lrands. that had had contact contact with were my hand hand or or hands. his were a. At poíltt in At any point in the the moments nrorne¡rts leading to or whelr Mr. become unresponsive up to leading up or when Mr. Harden Harden become urrresponsive did did strike Mr. Harden? you strikc Mr. Hanlen? I ') 3 ^ 5 6 7 I 9 0 I 2 v-r~wm—o\:5«'GEC3,. 5 4 A. 5 6 As As documented docunrented in in my nry report, report, II struck him twice struggle. but but at at the the moments struck him twice earlier in the the struggle, moments earlier in the time him. strike to he I did at became or not leading Ieading up to or at the time he bccame unresponsive, unresponsive, I did not strike him. a. At to or point leading At any point leading up to or when when Mr. Harden become did you restrict restrict Mr. Mr. Harden unresponsive, did become unresponsive, Mr. Harden’s means? airways by Harde¡r's airways by any means? t0 A, No. No ,.: a. Did became Did you observe observe anyone in when Timothy Timothy Harden Harclen became in the the moments moments leading leading up up to, or or when restrict Mr. Harden’s unresponsive, umesponsive, restrict Mr. Harden's airway? airway? A. No. No. a. Did or when you observe Timothy Harden Did you when Timothy l{arden become observe anyone in in the the moments moments leading leading up up to, or become their utilize Harden’s chest? Mr. unresponsive, weight to unresponsive, utilize their body put pressure on body weight to put on Mr. Harden's chest? A. No. No. a. Did you observe when Timothy Harden became Did you Tintothy Harden became observe anyone in in the up to, too or or when the moments nronrents leading leading up unresponsive, neck? pressurc on Harden's neck? on Mr. Mr. Harden’s unresponsive, utilizetheir utilize their body body weight weight to to put pressure A. No. No. 7 :8 9 I !3 t4 l5 !6 t7 :8 !9 t0 II l2 ¡3 _. t4 J5 I6 t7 a. t8 t9 t0 A, him. No, No, no no one one struck struck him. a. or using From see if striking him using their position were him or their body body you position you able to see if anyone was was striking From you were you able to restrain Mr. Harden? to weight weight to restrain Mr. Harden? A. Yes, could see. Yes, II could see. H t2 l3 lt l5 Did or when Timothy Harden Harden became leading up to or when Timothy became Did you observe observe anyone in the moments moments leading up to in the unresponsive, unresponsive, strike strike Mr. Mr, Harden? Harden? 7c, Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File bo89I Filed 08/04/16 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed 08/Q4/16 Page 91 of 100 PageID: Page D: 1126 Statement Stateme¡tt of of Patrolman Patrolman James James Conaty, Conaty, In, Jr., Page Page 44 of of44 ¡ a a Upon did you observe upon your arrival arrival at at the the scene, did observe any injuries injuries to to Mr. Mr. Harden? Ilarden? A. Yes, Yes, as as documented documented in in my report. report. 3 4 5 Break Break 12:35P.M. l2;35P.M. Detective Detective Bozza Boz-zn exits... exits,.. returns 12:37 l2:37 6 7 8 I 0 a. Is Is there there anything anything else else you would would like like to to add adtl to your statement to your stâtement at at this this time? time? A. No. No. I 1 J 4 5 TYPING TYPING CONCLUDED CONCLUDED - DATE DATE AND 2015. 12:38 AND TIME: TIME: Friday. Friday, November Novenrber 20, z0,z}ts. l2:38 P.M. P.M. — 6 t7 I 9 t0 I STATEMENT STATEMEN REVIEW REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE II have 4 pages; have read read this this statement statement consisting consisting of pâges; each of 4 each page bears bears my rny initials initials including including corrections any corrections initialed I initialed in that the facts contained in my own own handwriting; certify handwriting; and and I certify th;rt the facts containecl herein herein are are true. true. t' !3 ,.4 !5 DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: /1/2_a j_3__/gg[g;._.__ ?: 2o t6 t7 »' I’ Palm & t2 t3 '1 4 -- man James. t0 il . Janiesfinmtg d l8 19 M t4 t5 2 1/ 'fii:ren10na,, Esq. Esq. t6 t7 r8 r9 t0 il uth County Prosecutor's Office T2 l3 l.' t5 i.,i15uTc}?uniEic t.,i Eric sing?” Singer my Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office OfTice gtD090 FII Prosecutor's Prosecuto ," rr{) 90 of Filed 08/04/16 Page 92 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1127 «P-wt~.>—o\ixu:cr I STATEMENT STATEMENT J 4 { 6 7 I -o\:un.L,‘3fic'>5g°{h -— STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: ADDRESS ADDRESS & & TELEPHONE TELEPHONE NO: NO: 300 300 Old Old Tavern Tavern Road Road y 07731 0773r crsc 9 l0 t1 t '') DATE& DATE & PLACE PLACE OF OF BIRTH: BIRTH: .J ,4 ,5 U-J:'.IN—o\$«,EC3{;" Patrolman r. Patrolman Daniel Daniel Murphy, Murphy, JJr. SOCIAL SOCIAL SECURITYNUMBER: SECURITY NUMBER 6 — Scottsdale, Arizona Scottsdale, Arizona — t7 :8 TAKEN TAKEN AT: AT: Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor' s Office Offi ce Avenue I32 132 Jerseyville Jerseyville Avenue 74 Freehold, Jersey 07728-23 Freehold, New New Jersey 07728-2374 QUESTIONED BY: QUESTIONED BY: Detectix Detectir es Daniel Bozza Daniel Bozza Monmouth Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Office County Prosecutor’s WITNESSED WITNESSED BY: BY: Detective Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Perez Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Office Monmouth County Prosecutor’s r9 ,0 )l l2 t3 ,u t5 t6 l7 Robert Robert A. Honcker, Jr., A. Honcker, Jr,, Esq. Esq. Attorney for Daniel Daniel Murphy, Murphy, Jr. Jr Attorney for :8 ,.9 t0 il t') TYPED TYPED BY: BY: Rose Rose Gulino Gulino Office Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office DATE DATE & & TIME: TIME: 2015; 10:55 Friday, 20,2015; A.M. Friday, November November 20, l0;55 A.M. Ì3 -.—_, t4 t5 t6 t7 t8 t9 l0 lt t2 t3 Patrolman Daniel Patrolman Daniel Murphy, Bozza of Muqphy, Jr., Jr., II am Daniel Bozza of the the Monmouth Monmouth County County am Detective Detective Daniel the of Prosecutor’s Office office. is Perez and Detective Rosendo here same present Prosecutor's Office and here is Detective Rosendo Perez of the same office. It It isis the incident ask the circumstances to which our questions regarding our duty dutl' to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding surrounding the incident which occurred Jersey involving involving Timothy Timothy occurred at at Priediane Priediane located New.lersey located at at 1017 l0l7 Route Route 33, 33, Freehold, Freehold, New Harden 2015. Specifically, questions regarding regarding the Harden on on September we have follow up up questions Specifically, we have follow the September 5, 5,2015. before Harden moments just breathing. stopped just Timothy brcathing. moments befbre Timothy Harden stopped I4 t5 I t2¿ Pe P r.oQo{òn', File qo91 I C 1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 93 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1128 Statement Jr. Statenrent of of Patrolman Patrolman Daniel Daniel Murphy, Murphy,.Tr of 44 Page Page 2z of This This statement statement must must be and accord, be aa voluntary voluntary one, given of one, given of your own own free free will will and accord, without without that what any threats threats or be used in promises, knowing Court or promises, of a knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law. Law. l 2 J 4 a Are Are you willing willing to give aa voluntary to give voluntary statement statement at at this this time? time? A. Yes. Yes, a What your age? lVhat is is your age? A 29. 29. a When What is is your occupation? occupation? A, Police Police Officer. Officer, a. What education? V/hat is is your formal formal education? A. Completed Completed some some college. coliege. a. Are Are you married? married? A. Yes. Yes. a Can the English Can you read, read, write write and and understand understand the English Language? Language? A. Yes. Yes. a. How How was was Timothy Timothy Harden positioned moments Harden positioned moments before before he he became became unresponsive? unresponsive? A. He was laying He was laying on on his his stomach stomach with with his his hands hands handcuffed handcuffed behindhis behind his back. back. a. Where Where was was your position position in in relations relations to to Timothy Timothy Harden llarden moments moments before hefore and and when when Mr. Mr, Harden Harden became became unresponsive? unresponsive? A. II was was kneeling kneeling next next to to his his right right hip. hip. a. Please Please describe, describe, in in detail, detail, how how your body body A. II was was kneeling kneeling at at his his right right hip. hip, facing facing toward toward him, him, holding holding his his wrist wrist and and forearm. forearm. a Please Please describe describe in in detail detail where where your hands placed on hands were were placed on Mr. Mr. Harden? Harden? A. II was was holding holding his his wrist wrist and and forearm, forearm, with with both both my hands. hands, 5 6 I I i0 i 2 J 4 { 6 ., I '9 l0 ll t? t, t4 l5 !6 t7 !8 !9 t0 il t2 i3 t4 t5 t6 t7 t8 was was positioned positioned at at this this time? time? i9 t0 ll 12 t3 l4 t5 Pros or File File E )092 092 P rosh#r\ - Filed 08/04/16 Page 94 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Paqe D: 1129 Statement Statement of of Patrolman Patrolman Daniel Daniel Murphy, Murphy, Jr. Jr of4 Page Page 33 of4 I ) a At point in did At any point the moments in the moments leading leading up to or up to or when when Mr. Mr. Harden I{arden became became unresponsive unresponsive did you put your body how body weight weight onto onto Mr. Mr. Harden? Harden? If so, can please describe If so, can you please describe in in detail detail how and and where where on on his his body body you applied applied your weight? weight? A. No, No, II wasn’t pushing on wasn't pushing on him him or or put any body body weight weight on on him. him. Only Only when when he he was was combative combative did I on his did I put my weight weight on on his his wrist wrist and and forearm forearm which which was was located located on his lower lower back. back. J 4 5 6 7 a, At did point in At any point in the the moments moments leading leading up to or up to or when Mr. Harden when Mr. Harden become become Unresponsive Uruesponsive did strike Mr. Harden? you strike Mr. Harden? A, No. No. a. At point leading At any trrty point leading up to to or when Mr. you restrict or when Harden become become unresponsive, Mr. Harden unresponsive. did did you restricl Mr. Mr Harden’s Ifarden's airways airways by by any any means? means? 6 A. No. No. 8 a. Did Did you observe Timothy Harden observe anyone in in the the moments moments leading to, or leading up to, or when when Timothy Harden became became Harden"s Mr. unresponsive, airway? unresponsive, restrict restrict Mr. Harden's airway? A, No. No a. Did or when Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments moments leading leading up to, or when Timothy Timothy Harden Harden become become utilize their chest? Harden’s Mr. to on unresponsive, unresponsive, utilize their body weight to put pressure on Mr. Harden's chest? body weight A. No. No a Did or when Did you observe observe anyone in in the the moments when Timothy moments leading leading up to, or Timothy Harden Harden became became utilizetheir Harden’s neck? unresponsive, utilize their body unresponsive, body weight weight to to put pressure on on Mr. Mr. Harden's neck? A No. No. a Did Did you observe observe anyone in the moments moments leading wllen Timothy in the leading up up to to or or when Timothy Harden Harden became became unresponsive, unresponsive, strike strike Mr. Mr. Harden? Harden? A. No. No. a. Upon arrival at Upon your arrival at the the scene, did Harden? did you observe observe any injuries injuries to to Mr. Mr. Harden? A. II observed coming from observed mucus mucus like like blood blood coming fiom his his nose. nose. I 9 0 'l 2 4 5 9 !0 ll \: 13 14 ,.5 t6 t7 l8 t9 t0 il._. t2 i3 t4 r5 t6 t7 t8 t9 t0 1¡ 12 t3 \. t4 f5 \\- ‘(W/bx Pro‘s’ecutor's File Fire I 3093 093 ,Tr"m,s Filed 08/04/16 Page Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed P 95 of 100 PageID: 1130 Statement Statenrcnt of of Patrolman Patrolman Daniel Daniel Murphy, Murphy, Jr. Jr Page Page 4t of4 of + Break Break 11:07 I l:A7 a.m. a.m. through through 11:13 l1:13 I a.m. a,m. 2 3 a Is statement at is there there anything anything else else you would would like like to your staternent to add to your add to at this tirne? this time? A No. No. 4 5 6 7 I 9 ft I 2 5 4 TYPING IYPIN¡G CONCLUDED CONCLUDED - DATE 2015, 11:14 DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: Friday, Friday, November 2a.20rs, November 20, l l:14 A.M. A.M. — 5 6 7 STATEMENT AND SIGNATURE S]'ATEMENT REVIEW REVIEW AND SIGNATURE 8 I l0 \ II have of 44 pages; each statement consisting have read read this this statement consisting of *rch page bears bears my initials inilials including including any corrections initialed in I and facts contained that the corrections initíaled handwriting; certify my in own handwriting; a¡rd i certify that the facts contnincd herein herein are are true. tnrr:. l? IJ !4 r( DATE DATE AND AND TIME-' TiME: t6 _'1.]—i3('_). I"}‘.’1_"JS_.. _ .l_._l:‘-(.l. .r.‘f‘~ l7 no l8 t l9 4%. :,...._ Pzr ‘olmnn Dame] Daniel í0 n 3x. _._ra,cs-L:\)<»\*~°3" \ urph)’, j2- Jr. ,Jr ‘—3t_‘_\_U\Jv(__\k i\11-lcrr-t'1 yo 01-31.: \‘:_L__ tV\;.\Q,' c"r-.,eJ‘r«.'-— ùñ--r,tL- t2 t3 t4 t5 t6 Detecti Monm uth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Offi ce t7 t rlS i8 i9 f0 il Detectix-/e Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor‘ ()l'1icc Prosecutor's File 3094 Prosecutor's File Case Document 62-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 96 of 100 PagelD: 1131 STATEMENT 3 4 5 STATEMENT OF: Patricia White 6 7 ADDRESS Kc TELEPHONE NO: -- Whiting, Jersey 08759 9 10 PLACE OF BIRTH: 12 Brouklyn, New York 14 SOCIAL smunnv -- 15 16 TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 17 132 Jet'seyville Avcnue is Preetmld, New Jersey 07728 19 20 QUESTIONED BY: Daniel Bow 21 Monmouth County Pmsecular's Office 22 WITNESSED BY: Detective Dave D'Amicu Monmouth County Prosecutor's 011122 25 26 TYPED BY: Rebecca Winston 27 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 2t 29 DATE TIME: November 5, 2015 4:41 PM 30 31 32 Patricia White, I urn Detective Daniel Bum of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 31 and present here is Detective Dave D'Amico of the same oifice. It is our duty to ask you 34 questions regarding the circumstances surmunding the incident which occurred on 35 Priediane located at 1017 Route 33, Freehold. New Jersey involving Timothy Harden on )6 September 5.20151 37 38 39 This stutemcnt must be a voluntary onn, given or your own free will and accord, without 40 any fluent: or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law. 41 47 43 Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at this time? le Prosecutor's File d095 Filed 08/04/16 Page 97 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1132 O\Do)aU:J-Lul. Statement Statement of of Patricia Patricia White White 2 Page Page2 What What is is your age? age? I 2 51. 51. 4 5 A F;-K What What is is your occupation? occupation? 6 7 Teacher. Teacher. 9 What What is is your formal formal education? education? I _.l0 ll ll 12 t2 l3 l4 l5 l5 l6 ¡6 17 t7 18 t8 I9 t9 20 20 21 2l 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 3] 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 43 43 4.) 4¡ Master’s Master's Degree. Degree. Are Are you married? married? No. No. Can Can you read, read, write write and and understand understand the the English English Language? Language? Yes. Yes. Calling your attention Calling your attention to to the the circumstances circumstances surrounding surrounding the the incident incident which which occurred occuned on o¡t Priediane located at 1017 Route New 33, Freehold, Priediane located al l0l7 Route 33, Freehold, New Jersey Jersey involving involving Timothy Tímothy Harden Harden on on September 2015, please September 5, please tell 5,2A15, tell us us in in your own own words words what what knowledge knowledge you have have of of this this incident. incident. On concert festival, On Friday, Friday, II drove drove to to the the Priediane Priediane to to go to to the the concert festival, Soupergroove. Soupergroove. II got there there in the afternoon I and basketball early court in the early afternoon and I parked parked my camper on on aa basketball court in in the the back back and and was was asked to the top in the asked to move move my truck truck to to the field by top field the entrance entrance of participated in by the of the the society. society. II participated the festival the first band see festival Friday around Friday evening. evening. II woke woke up Saturday Safurday morning, moming, went went out out to to see the first band around 10 and during of the 10 AM AM and during that that time, gentleman in time, II noticed noticed the question dancing the gentleman in question dancing in in front front of the At first he and then he started was the erratically. stage front of the stage erratically. At first he was dancing dancing and then he started running running across across the front of the stage stage on on the the concrete, doing doing diving diving somersaults somersaults into into the the concrete, concrete, hitting his head hitting his head on on the the and concrete the concrete. for least at concrete and also ten also walking walking on on his his hands hands on on the concrete. II would would say say fbr at least ten 10:50 AM, minutes, AM, he minutes, if if not not longer. longer. Later announcement. Later on on at at about about 10:50 he asked an announcement. asked to to make make an The made announcement had confused no sense. a confi.¡sed look The announcement made absolutely absolutely no sense. Everybody Everybody had a look on on their their face. said He the effect of to face, He said something something to the effect of “Everyone needs aa hug hug sometimes”, "Everyone needs sometimes", “Big "Big guys cry” absolutely remember cry" itit was was really really weird. weird. At At the the end, end, II absolutely him saying you in remember him saying “I’ll "l'll see see you in Miami.” and walked the stairs main towards the Miami." He He walked walked off off stage stage and walked up up the stairs towards the main building buildíng up towards That’s the until aa little little while parking lot. towards the the front front parking lot. That's the last last II saw saw of of him him until while later. later. Then Then at at that the band I back one or point, the band played played maybe that point, maybe one or two two more more songs. I went went back to to my camper, then then another another band was coming band was coming on on about about an hour later. later. Before an hour Before they came on, II walked walked up they came main the ask about to parking lot society main parking relocating lot towards towards the the entrance entrance of about relocating my car. of the society to ask car. II was was between the check in and two I individual tents that at was standing an standing in asking in between the two check in tents and I was asking an individual at that tent tent if if II could location. The I to woman was talk to was change parking location. The woman I was talking could change my parking talking to was waiting waiting to lalk to to another another woman woman who who was was on on the the other other side side of tent, closer closer to of the the tent, to the the entrance, entrance, who who II heard heard tn_ueh4’l\,f w /U /u Prosecutor's File I 3096 Prosecutor's File F3aige D: Filed 08/04/16 Page 98 of 100 PageID: 1133 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Statement Statement of of Patricia Patricia White White Page Page 33 I 2 4 5 6 7 I 9 discussing discussing that that they they had had to to call police because call the the police because this this one one guy needed needed medical medical attention attention and At that and looked and I and had had gotten completely completely out saw out of of control. point,II turned control. At that point, tumed and looked and I saw who who I the appeared saw on appeared to dancing to be be the guy the same sarne stage, on I saw dancing on the stage, ground with on the the ground with four people four people kneeling kneeling next next to to him, him, all all around around him. him. Nobody Nobody else was around people that else was around the the four four people that were were the to I on assumed that ground, to me at that on the ground, me I assumed that it it looked looked like like there there was was aa medical medical issue issue at point that point and they somewhat under control. They and they had had it it somewhat under control. They said it was park my car said it was okay for me me to to park okay for car down I walked towards I turned and back saw a down below below and and as police as I walked towards my car, caÍ, I turned back and saw a police car pulling car pulling into the society into the the entrance entrance to to the society and and II saw saw an an ambulance ambulance right it, Later right behind behind it. Later on, II noticed noticed officers some police officers walking some police walking around around through through the the festival. festival. l0 1t t2 l3 t4 t5 l6 l7 I8 r9 20 21 2t 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3l 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 42 Can describe what please describe Can you please what type type of of event event this this was? was? It’s It's aa music music festival festival where where they have between they have playing, from between twenty and thirty thirty bands twenty and bands playing, from about about 10AM about to 3AM the in it’s music. constant It’s morning 1OAM in morning, common in the the morning to about 3AM in the morning, it's constant music. It's common for for The name people people who who attend attend this this event event to to camp out out here. here. The name of of the the event is Soupergroove. event is Soupergroove. Can stated was please describe Can you please describe the previously stated the male male who who you previously was acting acting erratically? enatically? He Hç was was white, white, very muscular, probably 5’l1ish, muscular, probably 5'llish, blonde blonde hair hair almost almost like surfer out, like aa surfer cut, not not He had white tan. shorts long do long hair, hair, tan. He had on on white shorts and no shirt. and no shirt. II believe believe he he was was barefoot barefoot and and II do remember outside his remember seeing seeing his his underwear underwear outside his shorts. shorts. Do Do you remember remember the the exact exact time time you first first remember remember seeing this individual? individual? seeing this The The first fïrst time time II saw saw him him was was about about 10:30AM l0:304M when when II saw saw him him run run across across the the front front of the of the stage. stâge. You previously described You previously described his his behavior behavior as as erratic. enatic. What What did did you mean mean by by that? that? In past II had In the the past had seen seen him him at at other other events events where where there there was music and was music antl II had had never never seen seen him hím dance he extreme that as him his I as was head moming. I thought dance as extreme as he was dancing dancing that morning. thought him hitting hitting his head on on the the concrete concrete while whiie doing doing the the somersaults, somersaults, the the handstands handstands on the concrete, concrete, II remember remember on the that had thinking thinking that that that painful. It had to to be be extremely exlremely painful. It seemed erratic to to me seemed erratic me and and out out of of the the I had for that who ordinary, seen somebody especially ordinary, for previously for anybody, anybody, but but especially for somebody that I had seen previously who never never had had done done something something like like this. this, Do as a Do you recall resall ifthis íf this individual individual received received any injuries injuries as a result result of of this this erratic behavíor? erratic behavior? thought II would was would have have thought he he must must have head pretty hard. have hit hit his his head hard. II did did not not see blood, II was see any blood, close not what to kind of but there see not close enough enough to see what kind of injuries injuries were were resulting were aa few resulting but there were few times times where landed. extremely harsh where it it looked looked extemely harsh the the way he had landed. he had 43 4l Prosecutor's File C 097 I7 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 99 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1134 Statement Statement of of Patricia Patricia White White Page Page 44 1I 2a 3 44 5{ 66 77 8 99 II What What exactly exactly did did he he hit hit his his head head on? on? /it It It was was a a concrete concrete patio palio surface. surface. Thick, Thick, hard hard concrete. concrete. ) Did Did you notice notice ifthis if this individual individual was with anyone else was with else at at the time? the time? At him or At this this time, time, he he seemed seemed to to not not have have anyone with with him or around around him him that that knew knew him him personally. personally. I Q} Do Do you recall recall hearing anyone call hearing anyone call this this individual individual by by his his name? name? A No. No. 14 l4 15 l5 Q Do at this Do you know know what what his his role role was was at this event? event? 16 l6 17 17 18 t8 I9 t9 20 2A 2] 2t it II believe some official believe on on Friday Friday night night he was working he was working in in some officiat capacity capacity but but II was was not not introduced him in that to I’m I that think not manner. but I sure introduced to him in that manner. I'm not exactly exactly sure why why I think that but I thought thought he he was was working working sort sort of of as as a a bouncer bouncer or or some some sort sort of security on of security on Friday Friday night. night. So So on on Saturday, Saturday, when when he asked to thought itit was he asked an announcement to make make an announcement II really going to really thought was going to be be security security related so related even erratically. even though though he he had had been been acting acting so enatically. 10 l0 11 ll 12 l2 13 13 L, What your initial What was was your initial reactionwhen reaction when he he made made the announcement? the announcement? A II was was thinking, thinking II can’t can't understand understand what what he he is is talking talking about, doesn't make about, this this doesn’t make sense. sense. II looked to what other see else had confiised were a Iooked around people around to see what other people were thinking, thinking, everyone else had a confused look. look. After he made the the even some kind After he nade the statement, statement, even the singer sínger made made some kind of of comment comment about about it it really really not He was not making making sense. He confused as was confused as well. well. Q Can Can you please please explain explain exactly exactly what what he he said said while while on on stage? stage? 23 23 24 24 25 2S 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 J.t 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 31 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 42 42 43 43 4.) 4¡ *We all “We all need need a a hug hug sometime”, sometime.", “Big cry", and "Big men men cry”, &nd “See in Miami.” Miami." "See you in Are Are you aware ¿rware ifthis place in if this event event was was taken taken place in Miami Miami in in the the very near near future? future? No. No. 0 Other than what recall if you’ve already Otherthan whatyou've yourecall already stated, can you stated, can if this this individual individual said anything else said anything else that would remember from that day? that you would remember from that day? A II do do not not remember remember anything anything else. else. Q Can Can you describe describe his his behaviorafier behavior after exiting exiting the the stage? stage? A He He seemed be calmly secmed to to be calmly walking the event. walking up the the stairs stairs towards towards the the entrance entrance of of the event. *’ V or's Prosecu r's File File P (3098 Filed 08/04/16 Page 100 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 62-1 Filed Page D: 1135 Statement Statement of of Patricia Patricia White White Page Page 5s 1I 27 3J 44 5{ 66 77 8 99 to l0 ll 12 12 13 I3 14 l4 IS t5 16 l6 17 t7 18 t8 19 l9 (3. DO who said “This guy \À/as of control was out DO you recall recall who said "This control and and now out of now he really needs needs help”? he really help"? /it It lead person at It was was aa younger woman tryoman that that II don’t don't know k¡ow who who was was acting acting as as the the lead at the the time time at at the I don’t know entrance. her her. about name or the entrance. I don't know her name or anything an¡hing aboul her. Qt When surrounded by When you next next saw saw this this individual individual lying ground surrounded lying on on the the ground by what what you described described four to describe what he can him, was people kneeling four people kneeling next please next to him, can you please describe what he was doing? doing? as as I A He seemed to at all. I{e seemed to be be just laying laying there. there. II didn’t see much didn't see much movement movernent at all. II didn’t didn't see see aa struggle. struggle. ll Q‘ Can of the you please please describe Can you describe the people who the location location of were kneeling the four four people who were kneeling next next to to the the individual? individual? A There There were were two two by his legs, legs, his pointed towards by his his legs legs were were pointed towards me. me. One One person by by each each am, arm, of his not were him. I on to next they they were not on top atms, they top of his arms, they were were just kneeling kneeling next to him, I was was only only able able to to see between the see the the four four individuals’ individuals' backs. backs, II was was between the two two entrance entrance tents, tents, facing facing towards towards the the and he entrance, entrance, and he was was behind behind me, behind behind the the second tent with second tent with his his feet feet towards towartls the the entrance, entrance, where the bushes next that from the are next to to where highway. the bushes are that separate separate from the highway. 21 2l U Do Do you know know any of people who of the the four four people who were werç kneeling kneeling next to him? him? next to 25 2J 24 24 t{ 25 It No. No. () At time, did At that that time, did you witness witness any police police involvement involvement at at all? all? A No. No. 0 At At any time, did you witness políce involvement? tinre, did witness any police involvement? A II saw attention. Later, police car pull up but saw the the police paying much car pull point II wasn’t but at at that much attention. that point \4¡asn't paying Later, II saw saw them around the but do it had with him. to festival, walking them walking around the festival, but it had nothing nothing to do with him. 0 During During the the incident, íncident, did anyone physically did you witness physically restrain wítness anyone indívidual? restrain the the individual? ft No. No. 0 When individual? When were $/ere you made made aware that something something had this individual? aware that had happened happened to to this A It It was was after passed away. after the the festival festival II had had found found out out he he passed what II saw, those away. After Afrer what those same friends had told he that for taken the to me friends hâd told me that he was was being being taken to the hospital hospital for aa drug drug overdose. overdose. 20 20 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 35 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 42 42 43 43 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File (5099 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 3 of 100 PageID: 1140 2 A 3 a 5 STATEMENT OF. David Mahaj an a 7 ADDRESS 34 TELEPHONE N0: -- 9 Balamown, New Jersey 07724 0 H: 2 DATE a PLACE OF BIRTH: 3 Boston, Massachusetts 4 SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: -- 7 TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Pt'oseculot"s Office 3 132 Jerseyville Avenue .9 Freehold. 'ew Jersey 07728--23 74 E0 '1 QUESTIONED Detective Daniel Bow :2 Munmuutlt Cunt") Prosecutor's Office 54" WITNESSED BY Detective Brian Weisbml l5 Monmouth County Prosecutor's office GBP6 17 TYPED HY: Ruse Gulino 28 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office [9 i DATE TIME: Oclubcr Z6, 2015;0114 ll l2 !1 Band Mahajan, 1 am Detective Daniel Bozza of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's 14 Office and present here is Detective Brian Weishrat of Ihe same office. It is our duty to ask is yuu questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incidenl "hich occurred at 16 Priediane located al 1017 Route 33, Freehold. New Jersey involving Timothy Harden 0n [7 September 5' 2015. 43 [9 to this statement must be a voluntary one. given ut'yuur own free will and accord, wilhout it any threats or promises knowing that what yuu say may be used in Conn of Law. i2 I3 Q. Are you willing to give a voluntary sum-menu at this time? in A Yes EXHIB m6 #0 'rosecutonsffile (1102 Filed 08/04/16 Page 4 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1141 f-. Statement Statement of of David David C. C. Mahajan Mahajan o\1uJ>.wN_ 2 of Page Page2 of77 I ,) o What is What is your age? age? A. 37. 37. a. What What is is your occupation? occupation? A. Sales. Sales. a. What What is is your formal formal education? education? A. BA BA in írr Communication. Communication. a Are Are you married? married? A. No. No. a. Can and understand understand the Can you read, read, write write and the English English Language‘? Language? A. Yes. Yes. ) 4 “°‘\lO~U:4>wN._o 5 6 7 8 9 '0 rl y\)._Oo°l'L;‘-5K’~:g 2 ) 4 5 6 1 r8 €»“'vT:35.;,-’—_c 9 !0 ll t'. a. ,.3 ,.4 l5 t6 t7 t8 t9 t0 it t¿ t3 t4 i5 t6 t7 i8 i9 t0 il 17 r3 t, A at Priediane Calling Calling your attention attention to to the the incident which occurred at 1017 incident which occuned at Priediane located located at 1017 Route Route 33. 33. New Freehold, Freehold, New Jersey please tell Jersey involving 2015, please involving Timothy on September 5, 2015, tell us l'imolhy Harden Harden on September 5, us in in your own own words what knowledge words what knowledge you have have of this incident. incident. of this II arrived anived at Timothy Harden Harden workingparking. working parking. at the the site around 1I:30a.m. Friday, and and saw site around I 1:30a.m. on on Friday, saw Timothy II said hello him thanked him for caught up for said hello we we caught for aa little little II thanked for coming coming and and working working and and then thcn went went to to "1wo members work work myself. to 5pm myself. Two members of the work informed me around 44 to 5pm on of the work crew crew informed me around on Friday Friday that that and Timothy Timotlry Harden Harden was was acting thai, II saw was groping groping aa woman. woman. After saw Tim acting crazy and and was Tim and Aftcr that, told he is told him him to to chill fbstival. II saw for five chill out out hc is working working and and representing the festival. saw him him for five minutes representing the minutes walked tell he tried and him don’t do to tell hjrn to to stop âway. ¿rrd tried to stop or don't drink drink or clean, he walkcd away. or don’t or donot do anything, anything, clean, Tim was at Then II went was alerted Then went back back to work and and in moruing II was alerted again again that that Tim at the the front fì'ont 1o work in the the morning held front and down I Tim detained. walked the down to saw being by gate gate being gale and saw Tirn being held down by five being cletaincd. I walked down to the front gate five 'l irn and six to some were some were people .sorlìe were security, to Tim to six people security, some were just staff/crew, walked up to and said stafT/crew, II walked said it’s all he was yelling yelling all it's Dave or hear hear what what II was Dave Mnlmjan, Malrajan, your friend, friend, he he did not reoognizæ: t-rìe or did not he said it’s these pr.,pi. ul" me. kept people off get-theæ kept saying was get it's Dave Dave Mahajan Maha.ian he he kept kef,t saying was adrrfJáíä ofTof me. Al‘tcr){ struggling he started spewing it blood and staned spewing it on on struggling and and that is when his mouth lilouth full full of of blood and he that is when II noticed noticed his for break free to Tim about I and that’s when back. I saw everybody struggling to break free for about everybody and that's whe¡l I stepped s{epped back. I saw Tim struggling and that five roughly ten ten ofticers police arrived oflìcers came came arrived on scene, About About roughly five minutes that is is when when the thc police on scene. minutes and '['im and and tried out was resisting resisting and and police cars detain him. FIe was of their their police and surrounded tried to to detain him. He out of cars and surroundcd Tim would forced his his hand T'he officers officers forced hand out would not move his to be be handcuffed. handcuffed. The out not move hís arm arm behind behind his his back back to ambulance five After minutes cuffed. his hands and after of an tries a they got his hancls cuffed, After five minutes an ambulance and after a couple couple of rries they later II saw off my view. arrived and the stretcher stretcher being being put Tim on on the minutes laier saw Tim blocked off view, Five Five minutes arrived and blocked work. and went into went back back to to work. the ambulance. ambulance. That That is is when when II left left and into the rccog11i;§, 'i_i§ t5 Prosecutor's';Ei,le 103 Prosecutor'{F¿ilA $103 Filed 08/04/16 Page 5 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1142 Statement of Statement of David David C. C. Mahajan Mahajan ?>r.O_ a How How do do you know know timothy timothy Harden? l{arden? A. Through Through mutual mutual friends, friends, through through high high school school years. a. Prior Prior to to the the incident incident when when was was your last contact with Jast contact with Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? A. II seen Ocean Township seen him him at at Wegman’s Wegman's in in Ocean three to Township Route to four four weeks Route 35 35 I’d I'd say three weeks before befure the festival. the festival. O a Can please describe Cart you please describe your relationship relationship with with Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? A, II knew a fall krrcw him years. We him through through mutual mutual high high school school friends frie¡rds for for many years. We had had a fall out out toward toward end of the school and I didn’t him after with affiliate that. didn’t the end of high high school and I didn't affiliate myself myself'with him any more more after that. II didn't like him like him much afler our fall out passing we much after our fall out and and didn’t didn't speak speak with much, only only in in passing we would with him him much, would say hello. hello, a Can day of please describe Cìan you please describe Timothy Timothy Harden incident? Harden on on the the day of the the incident? A He He was w-as 6’3”, pounds, pure muscle, 6'3", 185 200 pounds, 185 to to 200 muscle, blonde blonde hair, hair, blue blue eyes, big big nose, no no shirt shirt on, on. He of had from recall. shorts what I a on pair sweaty. sweaty. FIe had on a pair of shorts from what i recall. a Can please describe Can you please describe Timothy Timothy I-larden’s interactions with security Harden's behavior during his his interactions security behavior during and officers the of the incident? on guards police day guards and police officers on the day of the incident? A. Out of incoherent, didn’t Out of control, control, incoherent, didn't recognize recognize me, acting crazy acting crazy. a, When at the When you you initially restrainecl can initially arrived arrived at the location that Timothy l{arden was was being location that Timothy Harden being restrained can describe how the and individuals other were please describe how the security you please guards and other individuals were re.straining restmining him? security guards him? A. II anived arrived to Tim being guy on to see see Tim down by there was was one one guy being held held down by five five to to six six guys and and there on each each limb The that his and behind him with neck. his around one arms guard security guy guard limb and one hehind him with his arms around his neck. The security that was was Tim did until tried behind Tim have Tim’s abdomen his around not behind Tim did not have his legs to break legs wrapped wrappcd around Tim's abdomen until Tim tried to break free security guard guard wrapped Tim. free and and that’s that's when when the wrapped his around Tim. the security his legs legs around a During restrained how was being being restrained how long Duríng your time time at at the the location location that long did did that Timothy Timothy Harden Harden was the and him? individuals restrain other guard and other individr¡als restrain him? the security security guard I 2 3 ^ 5 6 7 8 9 0 I 2 J 4 _5 6 7 8 I Page Page 33 of of77 t0 Ìl t: ,.3 !4 ,5 ,.6 ,.7 ]8 l9 i0 il t2 r3 t4 i5 t6 i7 t8 t9 A. t0 lt t2 until the About police came police took came and then the the police and then took About five five minutes. minutes, They down until the police They had had him him held held down over. over. a. to the guards'? During Timothy Harden the security security guards‘? was Timothy During this this time time was Harden saying anything to saying anything t3 t l5 Prosecutorsfiibe, 104 Prosecutoiqøth C 104 C Filed 08/04/16 Page 6 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1143 Statement of David Statement of David C. C. Mahajan Mahajan O\LJi.!>t)ru_co°'U‘p” Page Page 44 of of77 [\)._ A. Timothy yelling “get was yelling "get these Harden was these guys off off of Timothy Harden of me.” me." 3 a During guards and did the the security interactions between Timothy Harden Harden did security During the the interactions the security and Timothy between the security guards guards say anything guards anything to to Timothy? Timothy? A. Yes. saying, stop yourself, guards were to free free yourself, stop trying trying to were saying, on me, me, and and stop Yes. The The guards stop spitting spitting blood blood on harder this on you’re you're only yourself, only making making this harder on yourself. a. Can guard that and holding please describe Harden and holcling that was was behind Timothy Harden the security security guard behind Timothy Can you please describe the him around his neck? him around his neck? A. 5’l() wearing aa hat hat II believe. believe. shirt on, brown brown hair, hair, wearing 5' 10 Ii believe, believe, short, shoft, stocky had a a red red security stocky had security shirt a between the guards and During observe did you observe the interaction and Timothy Tinrothy Harden Harden did During the interaction between the security security guards strike security guards guards strike Timothy? any security Timothy? A. No. No, a. During guards and did you observe observe Harden did Timothy Harden During the the interaction interaction between between the and Timothy the security sccurity guards security guards guards restrict any security restrict Timothy’s airway? Timothy's airway? A, No. No. a. Can Timothy Harden? Harden? please describe police officers were restraining how the officers were restraining Timothy the police Can you please describe how I 2 4 5 6 7 E 9 0 I :a;5=.z-,o¢\« 2 J 4 5 6 '7 r8 9 l0 ll l. :J t4 t< )_t t6 A. 18 t9 í0 GECSR il t2 .—_V,-"Kr>Noxi i3 i4 II saw otficers turned tumed Tim The officers Tim for security. security. The ten officers and take take over over for saw roughly roughly ten offìcers surround surround Tim Tim and calf the Tim’s knee his had his officer One on stomach. rest of of the the police officer bad put his knee on Tim's calf the rest his stomach. One police sure his officers arms. The his arms. legs, back, back, pretty sure The his shoulder, shoulder, legs, were just holding holding him him down, down, on officers were on his officers held tightly tightly by were being treing held by to release release his his arms arms that that were resisting and Tim to to stop stop resisting and to officers told told Tim after three and two his or release Tim would his chest. underneath not himself arms finally after two or three and finally himself underneath his chest, Tim would not release his arms times grab his pull it arm and and pull to grab his arm place his he had had to it his back to place hands behind behind his back he asking Tim Tim to his hands times of of asking out out to to handcuff handcuff Tim. Tim. over to over on on to ,.7 a. observe any you observe did you Harden did During police officers the police officers and and Timothy Timothy Harden between the interaction between During interaction strike officers police police officers strike Timothy? Timothy? A. No. No. a. you observe did you observe any Harden did During police officers and Timothy Timothy Harden the police officers and between the interaction between During interaction police aírway? Tinrothy's airway? police officers restrict Timothy’s officers restrict A. No. No r5 t6 it J8 t9 t0 lt t2 T3 1" l5 Prosecutor'§iE'il'e~ 0105 ( 105 Prosecutor'#iù* Filed 08/04/16 Page 7 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1144 Statement Statenrelrt ofDavid of David C. C, Mahajan Mahajan Page Page 55 of of 77 I 2 a. 3 4 5 A. 6 7 8 9 0 ¡ ') 3 4 5 6 7 8 During During interaction interaction between police officers between the the police officers anything to anything police officers? to the the police offrcers? A. He Hc a. Can officers during Cart you please please describe describe the tlte demeanor denleanor of police officers of the thc police the incident‘? during the incident? A. and they Helpful. Helpful. They They came came and tliey restrained him, they restrained him, did their they did thcir job. a. At any or do point during any point At during the the festival, festival, did did you observe observe or do you have have any information information whether whethcr or or not Timothy Harden not'lìmothy l{arden utilized utilízed any drugs? drugs? *.C?>- r0 of me. yelling yetling get these thcse guys off off of nre. II did did not he was not see see anything anything but but II assumed assumed based based on on his when II saw his behavior behavior when him after saw him aftei'he was groping groping woman woman initially weird. initially and and visited visited with with him hirn he he was was acting acting strange, strâuge, he he did did look look weird. sweaty sweaty and would not not listen and would listen to you are to me. told him me. II told him you working this are working this festival, festival, whatever whatever you’re you're doing doing stop stop now. now. He walked away from He walked from me me and and II walked walked back back to to work. work. a. What on the Vhat was was your role role at at the the festival festival on the day day of of the the incident? incident? A. II'm ’m Jeff in the Jeff Mahajan’s Mahajan's little little brother, brother, he he is is the thc creator/founder creator/foundcr of the festival, and my role of the festival, and role ín the festival is whatever needs be festival is whatever needs to to be done, done, security, security. parking, parking, fire protection and fìre protection and video video I t4 l5 U,->t\)—OoIu.;C§'_" was rr,¿rs and Harden did and Timothy Timothy Harden did Timothy Timothy say A !3 16 No No security security was was just restraining restraining him hinl with with their police came their bodies bodies and and hands and when when police hands and came II didn’t Tim. didn't notice restraining notice any weapons used used in in restraining Tim. a, 9 lt Did or police guards or Did you observe observe any security security guards police officers utilize any weapons while officers utilize while they they were were interacting Timothy? interacting with with Timothy? t-7 18 t9 production. production. t0 il t2 a Did you have guards and Did you have any you were any concerns concerns when when you were observing the security police obscrving the security guards and police offlcers with Tim of the the incident? officers interacting interacting with Tim on on the day day of the inoident? A. II was people's lives was concerned concerned for lives and for people’s and not not just my own, that Tim, Tim, if if he he broke o\¡/n, II felt felt that broke free free from he that would do or someone worse. security f¡om security that he would injure injure someone or do something sornething worse, a, At the incident point during At any point during the incident did about Tim did you hear Tim being being injured hear Tim Tim complaining complaining about injured in in any way? way? A. No. No. a. Did incident? Did you observe photograph or record the the incident? observe any individuals individuals either video record either photograph or video A. Not Not that that II saw, II didn’t didn't see see anyone. anyone. i3 t4 t5 i6 ,l i8 ig r0 il I2 t3 f. l5U' Prosecutor';F_ile 106 Prosecutor'gf i!ç 13106 Filed 08/04/16 Page 8 of 100 Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed 100£age PageID: 1145 Statement David C. Statement of ofDavid C. Mahajan Mahajan Page Page 6 6 of af 77 I 2 3 4 a 5 6 7 I 9 0 I 2 3 4 5 ,6 7 I I What What were were the the reasons reasons why you had why you had walked walked away away from from the the area area where where Tim Tim was was being being restrained? restrained? A Tim spewing blood Tim was w¿s spewing blood on on the guards and the security security guards police arrived and that when police that is is when arrived shortly shortly thereafter and I walked thereafter and I walked away feeling feeling Tim Tim would would be be detained detained appropriately. appropriately. a Did on any individuals spit blood Did you observe observe Tim Tim spit blood on individuals during during the rhe incident? incidenr? A. Yes. Yes. the the same same security guard II described security guard prior questioning. described in questioning. in my prior a. Is Is there tirere anything anything else else you would would like like to to add add to to your statement statement at at this this time? time? A, Yes, didn’t Yes. tim tim was was there there on on his his own own accord doing well accord doing well for for himself, himself, working working hard hard and and Ii didn't ?>@.O think of his possibilities this think in in all all possibilities f.his would woulcl happen. happen. II wasn’t wasn't even even notified passing until notified of his passing until to Sunday Sunday morning 12pm. morning 11:30am I l:30am to l2pm. l0 ll \: ,.3 !4 !5 !6 l7 t8 t9 r0 ll t2 r3 t4 t5 t6 t7 l8 t9 t0 ll 12 t3 l. t5 \ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File C 3107 107 Filed 08/04/16 Page 9 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1146 ‘O%\iL)1J>o.[_©3x'"hud Statement David C. Statement of ofDavid C. Mahajan Mahajan 7 of 7 Page PageT of7 I 2 3 4 5 a. Is statement at Is there there anything anything else else you would like to would like to add add to to your statement at this this time? time? A No. No. 6 7 I 9 0 I TYPING CONCLUDED --DATE DATE AND TYPING CONCLTJDED 2015, 7:03 AND TIME: TIME: October Ocrober 26, 26,2015, 7:03 PM. P.M —- 2 3 5'~L7-EC3v<“—‘:at.2 4 STATEMENT STAI-EMENI- REVIEW REVIE1V AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE c J 6 - 8 I — c> !0 I II haxe hare read read this this statement statçinent consisting consistíng of pages; each each page bears of 77 pâges; rny initials bears my initials including including corrections initialed in any corrections initialed in my own owrr handwriting; handwriting; and that the certify that the facts contained and Ii certify facts contained herein herein are are true. true, DATE DATE AND TIME AND TIME:_ g;a[z_a//_;._ —,_,-,_,#,L. -t;l g_ I !3 l4 E-?' livid C. fliiajan nñ;ac.l,faffi- l5 t6 A-F -1 ' ,-7 l8 t9 ,0 t¡ t¿ i3 t4 l5 t6 Detective 707..-/a Detective Darfiér Da 9r¡ Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Office 45/fa? A&l-",o Detective Detective Brian Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot Momnouth Monrnouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Offi ce Prosecutor's File Prosecutor's File 0108 108 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 10 of 100 PagelD: 1147 u" STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: Christine Brown ADDRESS TELEPHONE NO: --Neptune City, NJ 07753 DATE At PLACE OF mam -- Santa Ana' California SOCIAL SECURITY - TAKEN Monmnulh Count) Prosecutors Office 133 Jerseyville Avenue Flaehold, New Jersey 07728 QUESFIONED BY: Dclt'cliVe Dania] Bozza Monmoulh Counly Plosecuml's Office WITNESSED BY: Deleclive Brian Weisbmt Munmuulh County Pmseculm's Office TYPED BY: Autumn Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office DATE l4 TIME: Oclobcr 16, 2015 1:34 p.m. Chxisline Brown. I am Detective Daniel Bozzli of '11: Monmouth Caunty Pmseculor's Office and present here is Brian Weisbrol of the same office. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the. circumstances surmunding the incident that occurred at the Prledianc localcd at 1017 Rt 33, Freehold. NJ involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2015' This must be a voluntary one, given of your own free will and accord. Without any threats or pmmises, knowing [hat what you say may be used in a Court of Law. Are you willing to give a volmllazy statemenl at this lime? Yes. EXHIBIT map 0 i a rosecgfie Q1119 Filed 08/04/16 Page 11 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1148 Statement Christine Brown Statement of of Christine Brown Date: October 2015 Date: October 16, 16,2015 Page Page 22 a, What is your age? age? TVhat is A. 52. 52. a, What What is is your occupation? occupation? A. Accountant. Accountant. a. What What is is your formal formal education? education? A. Bachelor’s Bachelor's Degree, Degree, Monmouth Monmouth University. University. a Are y'ou married? Are you mar¡ied? A. No. No, a. Can y'ou read, Can you read, write write and and understand understand the the English English Language? Language? A. Yes. Yes. a the incident incident that Calling Calling your attention attention to to the that occurred oocurred at at the the Priediane located at at 1017 1017 Rt. Priediane located Rt. 33, 33, Freehold, 2015, please F'reehold, NJ NJ involving involving Timothy please tell Timothy Harden Harden on on September September 5, in your own 5,2075, tell us us in own words words what what knowledge knowledge you have have of incident. of this this incident. I 2 3 4 5 6 ? 8 9 r0 :l 1 IJ '.4 .5 i6 t8 t9 l0 t2 t3 r,4 :5 A. ,.6 t1 r8 t9 t0 lt t¿ l3 t4 i5 Earlier the day, late moming morning or in the Earlier in day,late close to or noon noon time, time, Ii noticed dancing close the stage noticed Tim Tim dancing to the stage his without shirt it isn’t dance for to on. without his shirt on, Although people to dance there, Although it isn't tutcommon there, Tim urcommon for people Tim was was air guitar, dancing guitar, one dancing very intensely intensely and and doing doing air one foot foot up, hopping backwards. hopping backwards. t6 t7 t8 t9 t0 ll l', I l4 II was was there there at at the the music music festival festival camping. camping. And And II was camp site was at at my camp site and and somewhere somewhere 2 between who II later p.m. and between 2 p.m. p,m. II heard and 3:30 3:30 p.m. hea¡d aa woman, who later learned learned her name was her name was Kat, Kat, View because blocked yelling, was yelling, get off off him, him, leave by leave him him alone. up alone, And And II stood was my stood up because view blocked by aa vehicle. And I what who himself introduced to saw was me a gentleman earlier, vehicle. And what I saw was a gentleman who íntroduced himself to me earlier, as as Tim. Tim, And I him familiarface from and other Groove’s local as a recognized him as a familiar face from past And I recognized past Souper Souper Groove's and other local music music events. off and sweating as events. II noticed noticed that that Tim Tim had had his his shirt shirt off and was was sweating if he he had been involved as if had been involved in in around notice of some other not the him. There people some sort physical activity. sorl of of physical people activity. II did notice other any did not of the around him. There were no hands were definitely definitely no hands on him and on him and his hands weren’t weren't on else. He He was was standing his hands on anybody anybody else. standing himself. So I about. who the woman was up right. by yelling about. However, up right. by himsclf. So I am unsure who the woman am unsure was yelling However, II distinctly remember seeing distinctly remember seeing Tim. Tim. a, A. Can please describe Can you please describe Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? He well kept, tsut he He had had short, short. well blondish hair. height. But kept, blondish hair. II think think he’s he's like, like, average height. he was was muscular Nice incredibly be close close to incredibly muscular Nice features. features. II think, think, blue He appeared appeared to to be eyes. He to my blue eyes. oldest oldest son’s son's age, who who is is 34. 34. \ Prosecutor's"F-II Prosecuto . 0 V110 10 Filed 08/04/16 Page 12 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1149 Statement Statement of of Christine Ch¡istine Brown Brown Date: 2015 Date: October October 16, 16,2015 Page Page:3 I a. Where Where on grounds, was on the the festival festival grounds, was your campsite carnpsite located? located? A. The car camping the RV The right right hand hand side side of of the the car camping area, in grounds, alongside in the the back back of the grounds, alongside of of the of the RV 2 5 4 5 6 7 I parking. parking. a. At At any any time time during during the the festival, you observe festival, did did you guards interacting observe any any security security guards interacting with with Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? A No. No. a At At any time during any time during the the festival, you observe festival, did did you observe any any Police Police Officers Officers interacting interacting with with 'l'imothy Harden? Timothy Harden? A. No. No. a. At At any time, you observe time. did did you observe Timothy Timothy Harden Harden or or receive receive any any information information about about Timothy Timothy Harden substances? utilizing illegal Harden utilizíng any illegal substances? A. II did take any illegal did not not see see him him take illegal substances; substances; however, however. friends friends had had mentioned mentioned that that he he had had indicated that and he for on drugs was more ildicated that looking that he he was was on drugs. drugs and that he was looking for more drugs. a. Have contact with Fiave you had prior contact had any prior with Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? A. II can’t can't exactly exactly recall recall where where and and when, when, but but he he is is aa familiar familiar face. recall Tim face. II recall Tim being being at at the the Groove in the Souper working security. Souper Groove in the past, past, working security. a. At point during At any point during the the festival, festival, did did you observe observe Timothy Timotþ Harden inappropriately or Harden acting acting inappropriately or in his well or in aa way that that you were safety -being? were concerned concerned for -being? for his safety or well 9 t0 ,t ) ,'3 i4 ¡5 r6 t7 t8 t9 :0 i t, t3 14 !5 !6 t1 t8 ,.9 '0 II t7 A. Other didn’t notice Other than than dancing dancing with with aa higher intensity than people were higher intensity than most most people were dancing, dancing, II didn't notice that of anything anything that was was out out of the people there the ordinary. ordinary. Most Most people are filled filled with with aa lot of zeal. there are lot of zeal, t3 t4 r5 t6 t7 t8 l9 l0 I t2 t' t4 Prosecutor's Prosecutor' Ie 0111 111 Filed 08/04/16 Page 13 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1150 Statement of Christine Brown Ch¡istine Brown Statement of 2015 Date: October 16, Date: October 16,2Al5 Page Page 4t I a, Is time? at this this time? to add add to to your statement statement at there anything would like like to Is there anything you would A. No. No. 2 3 4 5 6 7 I October 16, TYPIN G CONCLUDED l:58 p.m. 16. 2015 2015 1:58 TIME: Octobsr DATE AND TIME: TYPING CONCLUDED - DATEAND — 9 r0 I 2 -t 4 {5 STATEMENTREVIEW STA'TEMENI REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE of 44 pages; each II have including initials including bears my initials each page bears thís statement read this statement consisting consisting of have read facts contained thatthe I and initialed in corrections own certify that the facts contained any conections initialed in my own handwriting; handwriting; ancl I certify herein herein are are true. true. :ó i7 :8 0 DATEANDTIME: DATE AND TIME: !0 ?:01 ‘°i"3i_'rl3’_ Q:0’ i(,>~or\ en^ It" I !2 t3 Christine Elrown !4 ,.5 l6 l7 !8 t9 r0 ll t2 r3 t4 r5 Detective Dan Momnouth Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor's Office Monmouth County Q“ 4:6 “OJrLi-+ *tq< Detective Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot Detective Brian 4 Momnouth County Prosecutor's Prosocutor's Office Office Monmouth County r6 t7 t8 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 01 0 12 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 14 of 100 PagelD: 1151 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: Christy Meyer ADDRESS TELEPHONE N0: -- Brick, NJ 08724 DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: - Syracuse, NY SOCIAL SECURITY -- TAKEN AT: Monmouth Counly Prosecutor's Office 132 Jerseyvill: Ave. Freehold, NJ 07728 QUESTIONED BY: Detective Daniel 1301le Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Detective Brlan Monmoulh County Prosecutor's Office TYPED Marianne Capo Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office DATE 86 TIME: October 15, 2015 5:19 am, Ms. Meyer, I am Detective Daniel Bow of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office and present here is Detective Brim Weisbrot ofthe same ofi'loe. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident that occurred at the Priediane located at 1017 Route 334 Freehold, New Jersey involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2m 1 This statement must be a Voluntary one. given of your own free will and accord. without any threats or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law. Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at this time? Yes Prosecutor'smm.' D113 Filed 08/04/16 Page 15 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1152 ©VO0\lLI.b-)J'—‘D]>r @.>O?~_o J‘-“:5ro'.xa3~, a What age? is your age? What is J A. 3377 a. What occupation? is your occupation? What is A. Bookkeeper Bookkeepen a. What education? formal education? is your formal What is A. Masters Phoenix University of of Phoenix from University Masters from a. married? Are Are )'(ILl ¡'r'u married? A. Yes Yes a. and understand Can Language? English Language? the English write and understand the read, write Can you read, A. Yes Yes a. at 1017 1017 Route Route located at Priediane located at the the Priediane Calling that occurred occu¡red at to the the incident incident that attention to Calling your attention tell Harden 2015, 5, please on please us in in September tell us New 5.2tI5, Timothy 33, involving Timothy Harden on Septemher Jersey involving Frðehold, New Jersey 33, Freehold, 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 il i2 .3 4 5 —r6 - .7 i8 t9 .':- r0 ll _ O\UI-#93 ,.3 l4 r5 !6 coax: ,.7 r8 t0 t¡—- t2 t3 t4 i5 t6 t7 t8 i9 l0 il 12 l3 t. l5 Page Page 2z I , !9 Statement MeYer ChristY Meyer of Christy Statement of A. of this íncident. this incident. have of words what what knowledge knowledge you have your own onn words Jeff Mahajan Mahajan as me by by Jeff as aa II was to me brought to Tim was was brought and Tim gate manager on on Friday Friday and front gâte was the the front of the to the entrance at stand instructed to then gate Tim gate for the front of the to was volunteer entrance at the gate. Tim was then instructed to stand volunteer for the front gate. 2 about hours for front the on worked Tim tables. direct gate tables. Tim worked the front gate for about 2 hours on up to to the the front front gate traffic up direct traffic volunteer bracelet and It did bracelet his volunteer changed his morning. II changed Friday until Saturday Saturday morning. not see see him him again again until did not Friday and within left 55 or he and he on the was in Friday stand within instructed him same left or 10 to he l0 and a¡rd place place on Friday was he the sanre and instructed him to stand in and received lunch have a 1:30 to about Priediane left I there. and received of lunch a minutes go have p.m. to standing there. I left Priediane about 1:30 minutes of standing the front II at there that a 3:15 was and 3 gate. problem gate. Emillus between the front call Casey Emillus between 3 and 3:15 that there was a problem at call from from Casey the of Tim one that security guards said she and she said that Tim punched what the punched one of the security guards asked problem was was and the problem her what asked her and she did said I -1 and 9-] call she said said and call yet and face that call in the make that were you make -1 I said did they gonna 9-l and call in the face and they were and she if was her asked I okay 9-1-1. call to the was Maltis okay and she everyone was if making the call to 9-l-1. I asked her yes Lenny Lenny Maltis was making blood face of his bit little on had a the that did said guard, had a little bit of blood on his face security guard, yes. She Brandon, the security She did say that Brandon, said yes. back would said I point when I time come that that point At fine. when II At that he but was the festival. festival. At to the back to come would said I that time I was fine. At but he and what going on on and then then II was going know what was him know to let let him Mahajan to hung Jeff Mahajan called Jeff and II called with her her and up with hung up the gate front gate off at at the front returned dropped off was dropped p.m. II was 3:45 p.m. grounds around around 3:45 festival grounds to the the festival back to returneã back front down the shut to needed if asked we gate and gate tables down the front front the to and walked up to the front gate tables and asked if we needed to shut ¿urd II walked down some tape in in the the tree tree staff the caution caution tape of the and some of pulled down point II pulled at that that point So at toid me rne no. no. So my søff told and in the Tim was vehicles. already the from in the traffic was abeady direct Tim lines our to emergency vehicles. the from away away lines io direct our traffic back. I When after minutes 15 about left got ambulance the and I back' When arrived I after when minutes ambulance 15 about left ambulance when I arrived and the ambulance gate the front front gate behind the tree line line behind there were II arrived along the the tree standing along police offlcers officers standing few police rnrre aa few arrived there in the he ambulance, think was makes which me in in ambulance, tables view, which makes me think he was the not in my m1' view, was not but Tim im was tables but after minutes 15 left when got there. there. they after II got 15 minutes left especially when they especially Prosecutddgilf-Tie Prosecu t&Affie 00l114 14 Filed 08/04/16 Page 16 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1153 \lO-LJi$a):_.éo‘nUI;btQ I 2 3 4 5 6 8 9 0 ,t 2 Statement Christy Meyer Meyer of Christy Statement of Page Page 33 a .3’ A. .>#O?0 encounters withTim? with Tim? Prior previous encounters had any previous have you had this years festival festival have to this Prior to A. No. No. a. Tim? with Tim? conversations with have any conversations did you have During or Saturday Sahuday did either Friday Friday or During either A. J O\o1~.u_;t,“"5'° '.O?’0>63 .5 6 "u‘=r<5c:ait7.*-— a. :8 '9 l0 was it it for for that was but that candy but man candy On being my man him being around about about him quickly joked around we quickly l.riday we On Friday he that’s said and married I’m said I and kiss for that's a asked he he me and said then married and I'm I said and Saturday Friday Friday and then-Sarui¿ày he asked rne for a kiss when he and II said he went went to to that's when and that’s said yes and he said and he okay and are you okay okay kiss and said are want aa kiss okay iI just want his spot. his spot. guards interacting interacting with with At security guards observe any security did you observe Saturday did point in in time during Saturday time during At any point Tim? Tim? A. No. No. a. with Tim? police officers l'im? interacting with At officers interacting see any police did you see point in time on on Saturday Saturday did in time Ar any point A. Nope. ìrtope. a. scene? see on on scene? When did you see ambulances did festival how how many ambulances the festival back at at the arrived back V'hen you arrived A. One. One. a. Where that ambulance? the location location of of thatambulance? was the Where was A. parallel to Parallel behind the tenfsfil¡ry line behindthe to the tree line the tree a. did you observe pull into into that that ambulances pull After other ambulances observe any other at the the festival festival did back at anived back After you arrived location? location? .3’ A. No. No. a. or in in way that that inappropriately or At. acting inappropriately Tim acting observe Tim during the did you observe point during the festival festival did At any point for his his well well being? being? you were were concerned concemed for A. No. No. l1 t hair. no chest chest hair. beard, no no beard, to have curly, no hair, curly, Well personality, blonde blonde hair, nice personality, have aa nice built, seemed seemed to Well built, on and shorts. and shorts. Saturday shirt on his volunteer volunteer shirt he had had his Saturday he a. '4 t7 Could Timothy Hardin? Hardin? describe Timothy please describe Could you please -t3 t4 rs t6 t1 t8 t-9 t0 ti t2 t3 t4 I5 t6 t7 i8 r9 r0 ll T2 tents_(:((,n-P 61:Ütkkn+S.Cd51 it _kVH.S 13 I' le 0115 Prosecutor‘ 0 15 Prosecuto ,.'0,Wiàr Filed 08/04/16 Page 17 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1154 o~O<:\l'LnAuzt)._°]U‘pmN fizaojsxr):—.~_ I Statement Christy Meyer MeYer of Christy Statement of Page Page 44 a. been using using any had been did you receive Tim had that Tim the festival indicating that information indicating receive any information During the festival did During alcohol? drugs or consuming alcohol? or consuming drugs A. Not no. Not really, reaily, no. a. lefi the Where festival? the festival? time you left during the the time travel to to during did you travel Where did A. home and and get my going to to go home II went was going and II was lunch and area to to get lunch Pleasant area the Point Point Pleasant back to to the went back 2 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 0 kids cleaned up. kids cleaned I '2 a, statement? Is add to to your statement? like to to add else you would would like there anything anything else Is there J A. II feel loss. family's loss. for his his family’s feei very sorry for V_. .4 _<, 5 2015 5:39 p.m, 5:39 p.m. TYPTNG 15,2015 October 15, TIME: October DATE AND TIME: CONCLUDED - DATEAND TYPING CONCLUDED — :6 7 :8 I-:_. . .9 !0 t1 : at» ,? ©\°x)Lh STATEMENT SIGNATURE AND SIGNATURE REVIEW AND STATEMENT REVIEW each page bears including this statement initials including II have bears my initials of 44 pages; each consisting of statement consisting read this have read contained facts the that I and certify that the facts contained ha:rdwriting; and I certify own handwriting; in my own corrections initialed initialed in any corrections herein true. are true. herein are l4 t_5 16 l1 TIME: DATE DATE AND AND TIME l8 5.:ñ _I0'@/_)f) )o t0 il Christy Meyer Christy Meyer t2 i3 t4 t5 l6 t8 t9 l0 il 12 t3 . /3! ‘ l)cleL'ivc Daniel Bozza Daniel Bozza Monmouth Office Prosecutor's Office County Prosecutor’s Monmouth County 10¢ l- ‘ti/‘re? *,rq Detective Weisbrot ve Brian Brian Weisbrot Monmouth County Office Prosecutor's Office Monmouth County Prosecutor’s st t. Prosecutor's File 16 Prosecutor's File 0116 C Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 18 of 100 PagelD: 1155 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: Tina Pinelli ADDRESS a TELEPHONE N0: -- Ocean Grove, NJ 07756 DATE 8c PLACE OF BIRTH: - Neptune NJ SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: -- TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Proseculur's Office 132 Jerseyyillc Ave NJ [17728 QUESTIONED HY: Delectiv: Danicl Bozza Monmouth Count} Prosecutor's Ollioe W1 TNESSED BY: Delectiw Btian Monmnulh County Prosecutor's Omce BY. Mariam: Capa Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office DATE. 54 TIME: October 5, 2015 4:09 pm. Ms. !'ine11i. Em Detective Daniel 13on ofrhe Munmoulh Cnumy Prosetulur'a 0mm; and her: is Detective Brian Welsbrut of the same office. It is our duty to asl. you questions regarding the circumstances surroundi the incident that occurred at the Priudiane located at 1017 Rt 33. Freehold, New Jersey involving Timolhy Harden on September 5, 2015. This statement must be a voluntary one, given of your own free vull and accord. wilhuul any threats or promises, knowing that what you say may he used in a Conn at Law Are you willing to give a voluntary sratement at this time? Yes I am Prosecutor'l'fil'fo 17 Filed 08/04/16 Page 19 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1156 _.a\or~u:;>mt°,cMA .0>rO?C'o:; Page Page 2z a What age? is your age? What is A 33 JJ a What occupation? is your occupation? What is A Student Student a education? What formal education? is your formal What is A Junior University. Monmouth University. in college, Junior in college, Monmouth a married? Are you married? Are.\,ou A Divorced f)ivorced .7 a Can Language? the English English Language? understand the write and and understand read. write Can you read. i8 ,9 A Yes Yes I 2 J 4 5 6 7 8 I 'v~‘N-Ooe\Icu.Ef_j,§:5b; .il-_ t0 2 3 '4 - ~- 5 ió :0 ,,1 O\Uu-Ab.) a 1. t3 !4 !5 ,.6 \} 17 Ì8 ,.9 t0 —-._ Statement Pinelli Tina Pinelli of Tina Statement of ll t2 t3 t4 l5 t6 t7 t8 t9 t0 lr T2 l3 A occurred at at 1017 1017 Rt Rt 33. 33. located at the Priediane Priedianc located at the that occurred Calling incident that the incident atrention to to the Calling your attention tell in 2015 us Harden on please tell us in 5, 2015 please Freehold, September 5, Tinrothy Harden on September involving Timothy Jersey involving New Jersey Freehold, New incident. this of have what words knowledge íncident, you have of this yaur own words what knowledge your own of the the event. event. Ben Ben So coordinator of the volunteer volunteer coordinator from the received aa text text from morning II received So Thursday Thursday morning also I Tim who volunteer picked was another Harding. picked up Bleefield, pick up another volunteer who was Tim Harding. I also me to to pick asking me Bleefield, asking his Tim at I with. grandmothefs friends I grandmother's that volunteer was another picked at his Joe Tim up picked I with. Duffy, friends that I was volunteer another Duffy, Joe was very house good spirits. spirits. he he was vcry in good seemed in He seemed then. He hinr before before then. never met met him in Belmar. Belmar. II had had never house in there When we the we event. for set Priediane to got got the we there wc he went to When begin nice, up f'or tlre event. nice, he went to the Priediane to begin set up Tim tents or out while set little After helped we camp. f inr helped immediately started working. working. Afler aa little while we set up out tents or camp. immediately started didn’t he said he and bring needed he if sleep him asked I with bring gear to to sleep tent help didn't he he said help and needcd setup. if he him my I asked tent setup. with worked with I Tim So work. back morning to then Friday went and with first worked the there I we Tim moming Friday So night work. there the first night and then we went back to know that for vehicles Tim things the front was time you this at things and checking know that for gate. Tim was chesking vehir:les again and this time at the front gate. again in and in. He was good spirits cars I and in guiding cars in. lle was in good spirits and he weren't he was just guiding the festival festival and I wasjust atlowed in the weren't allowed when in weren’t that once later passing him I with. passing when night work weren't fun to in saw again once was night that later lrinr again with. I saw to work rvas fun before II went time before went the last last time saw him him the a.m. when when 1I saw working probably almost almost 55 a.m. was probably no more. more. It It was working no he seemed like and cheerful was and He talk. small was make We seetned like he was bed. aud happy to becl. \l/e just make smalt talk. lle was happy and cheerful to Daniel were and Hickman, When influence. me the boyfriend. Hickman, were maybe drunk or or under under the influelrcc. When nre and my boyfriend. Daniel maybe drunk did not. not. II went went to no we we did to We said said no or mollys. rnollys, We ketamine or walking rve had had any ketamine off he asked if if we waiking off he asked be work at to I late. was I supposed at that. while after to be work little supposed slept morning bed was I Saturday late. a I slept morning bed a little while after that. Saturday canlp II overheard overheard around work from fiom camp to work 7. On On my way to like 2. till more more like there till but didn’t didn't get there around 1I but Tim with where that earlier incident day been had an there that T'inr wltere he with he volunteers other saying that there had been an incident earlier that day other volunfeers saying had and traffic to into and they the had lrighvrav and got into traffic and they hatl to onto thc highway festival onto of the out of the festival to run run out had tried tried to I Prosecu 0 Fi 18 0 118 Filed 08/04/16 Page 20 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1157 o\1u.x>mD,°J‘&_N 'Iina Pinelli Statement of Pinelli of Tina Statement 3 Page Page 3 "babysitting" him hinr the the calm sort of of “babysitting” were sort that they they were said that get him in. They They said him back back in. to get and try to calnl him him and he had that There rumors were else make he had that the to of rumors happened. rest nothing else happened. There were sure nothing moming to make sure rest of the moming cocaine but anything never saw saw anything btlt II never LSD or or cocaine like LSD possibly taken drugs like taken drugs stayed and possibly all night night and stayed up all when I hour ’/2 saw for there and front was the saw the the maybe I to when I went Vzhour maybe for there gate gate and was front actually happen. to the actually happen, I went front the towards They Tim gate. gate. the cart coming with front They staff and the pursuing towards golf staff and security security with the golf cart pursuing Tim coming golf cart cart was was The golf wrestled him down. down. The keep him him and and keep ground and to calm calm him and tried tried to the ground fo the wrestled him hím to hired was who one security Brandon was named and the of driven by Ben bouncer named Bra¡rdon who was hired security was one of the one one bouncer Ben and driven by didn’t and he his and anns legs move to he didn't and legs he Tim anns them. his was trying get tnove get up kept up and struggling, to kept trying them. Tim was struggling, he had couple minutes that Brandon Brandon had minutes that want to after aa couple noticed after his back. on his back. II noticed He was was on stay down. down. He to stay h The from. \ it where Icouldn’t was coming t-shirt. blood his the a see where it was coniing from. The tgåçål5 g$t the on his t-shirt. I couldn't see a lot lot of of blood on tat first until police e{fices ttliat f ¡rsl staff f-ew emcee were aa few There were on for police arrived. arrived. There minutes until for aa couple couple minutes went on staff went the scene scene a few approached the officers approached The officers later. The minutes later. responded few minutes came a an ambulance ambulance came responded and and an Tim hold down and to the same staff. the trying thing for Ti¡n down were took to hold and and doing over trying They aná took over for the staff. They were doing the same thing while little for 'fhis went This a on still maybe down. He calm ten went on for a little while maybe ten struggling. was stitl struggling. ger him get to calm dow¡1. He was him to able wasn’t I minutes whole time, time, II was was the whole view this this the to View working so so I wasn't able to was still still working estimated. II was minutes estimated. little while over by by Tim Tim and back and and forth. pulled from cntrance over fronl the the entrance the ambulance whilc the ambutance pulled Atter aa little fofh. After back and in where were we the tents and Tim checking between wc were checking in what wlrere on. tents was They parked between Tim a¡id the going on. They parked what was going could but if not handcuffs see tie with the ambulance behind walk officers zip guests. II saw guests. saw officers walk behind the anlbulance with zip tie handcuffs but could nol see if ambulance the notice but ambulance the into them put Tim see thell'r Tim into the anlbulallce bttt tlotice the alttbulance they didn't see were used. used. Ii didn’t they were this At while. after yellow and forth they were back trp the a to put up the yellow staning to point they were starting rocking while. At this point rocking back and forrh afier a left ambulance the and minutes few another After the crime. of off the block lell and the ambttlaltce scene to nlinutes tape tape to block otTthe scelle of the crinre. Afler another few it because leave was asked to ptivate told I were but private showed was 12 News also they were asked to leave because it was up but I was told they also News 12 showed up 1 ") J 4 5 6 7 I 9 ' i0 I 2 t3 Otn“-‘Gf~3"5:'—§‘L.h-u)t\—_.$ox]°klJ \4 :5 .. .:_o; - ._r6 i8 :9 l0 ll :- property. \3 l4 t5 a. ,.6 l7 A. t8 !9 t0 il a. t2 'J A. t4 t5 ró tt A. t0 ll—- he had shoes I’m think he had shoes believe. II think have on on shorts shorts II believe. did have he did o¡r but but he had no no shirt shirt on sure he he had I'm pretty sure He seemed blue sort blonde muscular hair, He 100%. but build, eyes. He sort I’m eyes. seemed not was tall, hair, blue on blonde build, muscular was lall, on but I'm not 100%, He wasn’t down. He of it. he like out calming know was bit little calming down. of wasn't of it. He a was out panicked you know like he conflused, a little bit panicked of confused, Can scene? incident scene? view of of the the incident please describe describe your view Can you please guard that that was was in II pretty much in the the maybe aa bouncer security guard or security bouncer or view besides besides maybe clear view had aa clear much had able to I and no see was between us longer the ambulance until him able to see pulled between us and I was no longer way wrestling wrestling him until the ambulance pulled way' Tim officers, the officers. Tim and and the mentioned by of Brandon? Brandon? Can name of the name by the guard you mentioned please describe security guard the security describe the Can you please a. r8 r9 Can incitlcnt? the incident? the day of the day of Hardin on on the please describe Tinrothy Hardin descríbe Timothy Clan you please I skin toned toned and and he he He medium skin Spanish, medium maybe Spanish, wanna say maybe to tall. tall. II wanna average to tall average He as as muscular, muscular, tall that the had the one which shirt was had he bald one that had the the a security shaved was had yellow which or head, shirt a yellow security a he had head, had a shaved or bald blood on it. it. blood on t2 l3 l. l5 Prosecut P S C 119 1 19 Filed 08/04/16 Page 21 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1158 Statement Pinelli Statenrent ofTina of 'Iina Pinelli Page Page 44 lI 2,) 3 44 55 () event personnel did you hear incident did personnel guard or or event At security guard hear any security point in the incident in time tilne during during the At any point Hardin? to Timothy anything say anything to Timothy Hardin? A. A calm down, need you to II heard it, we we need to fighting it, stop fighting down, stop slay down, down, stay police officers saying calm the police officers saying heard the the think don’t I guards said security guards said relax, of things. things. I don't think the security sorts of down, those those sorts to stay we need need you to stay down, relax, we anything. anything. 6 6 7 8I 99 ,0 0 1I 22 '33 44 5 =6 :6 71 8 r8 9 >0 t0 I -i!ri Q. a incident did police officers officers the police to either either the anything to During Timothy Hardin Hardin say anything did you hear hear Timothy the incident During the or the guards? security guards? the security or A. No No II did did not. not. Q a you observe any security security observe any Hardin did did yott guards interaction Tinrothy Hardin During with Timothy inreraction with the security security guards During the Hardin? strike Mr. guard guard slrike Mr. Flardin? A. i-Hatter:-‘ witness any strikes II did that Sffi of that or anything anything of kicks or strikes or or kicks did not not witness Q. a At police include any police to include strike anybody anybody to witness Tim Tim strike poin{ during incident did did you witness At any point during the the incident officer or guards? security guards? otlicer or security A. A No by Brandon Brandon that that Tim Tim afterwards by was told told afterwards No II did although II was ¡lot witness witness Tim Tim strike strike anyone although did not blood Brandon’s there on is was that back and Tim had and he him struck had struck on why was Brandon's blood there is why that had slruck him and he had struck Tinr back and his and and Brandon shirt. the incident. by the incídent, shook up by looked shook not his Brandon looked said it it was blood and and not shirt. He Ile said was Tim’s Tim's blood Q0 At individuals? Tim spit spit on on any individuals? point during witness Tim did you witness during the the incident incident did At any point A did not. No No II did not. Qa the incident At Timothy Hardin? police officers strike Timothy Hardin? officers strike point during observe any police during the incident did did you observe At any point A. and elbows II didn’t push him him down. down. to push elbows to punch himjust forearms and fhem punch him just using using forearms didn't see see them Q. did you At guards or security security guards police officers you observe officers or any police point during observe any incident did during the the incident At any any point in restrict Hardin’s way? airway Timothy way? any restríct Timothy Hardin's airway in A. did not. II did not. 2;; 14 t4 25 t5 !6 !6 t7 27 !8 !8 39 !9 SO t0 ll il I2 l2 33 IJ 14 t4 15 t5 ;6 i6 u - I w I €Þ l7 l7 l8 IE l9 t9 l0 t0 ll t¡ l2 t2 l3 t3 /we? Prosecutor's F¡le Prosecutor's File (i120 20 ( 1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 22 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1159 of Tina Statement Tina Pinelli Pinelli Statement of Page Page 55 I a 2 anyone? anyone? 4 was II didn’t seeing who who was me without without seeing frorn behind behind me hear from directing it it but but II did did hear see someone someone directing didn't see here. of out these need this to we need to get off, we Basically it people out of here. Basically get these people it speaking to block block this off, we need need to speaking we the didn’t to want scene. seemed like see people they people see the scene. want to they didn't seemed like 5 6 7 I —-o~\:.n4L>m At while they weapons while they were were police officers any weapons you observe use any any police point did offrcers use did you observe âny At any any point interacting Tim? with Tim? interacting with 9 i0 ]I 2 driveway next You nsxt to to the the driveway the tent tent location from from the moved its íts location that the the ambulance ambulance moved You stated staled that there to directed move this ambulance and yourself between by yourself was was this ambulance directed to move there by Hardin and Timothy Hardin between Timothy A. A Not rhat II noticed, noticed, no. no. Nol that a How wère interacting interacting with with police officers who were officers who you describe the police would you describe the the demeanor demeanor of of the How would Tim? Tim? ”:J_ IJ _5.-‘°“\"3,-‘4>~' G"-'S:?>5»T.a3ts 5 ó _ 1 control the yelling commands They by yelling co¡nrnands yelling in the situation situation by to control They were were yelling in their their commands commands trying trying to .8 like commands. stay down down those sort of dowlt, calm calm down, down, stay those sort of commands. like get down, i9 t0 ll a Pleuse police officer? officer? the police describe Tim’s Tim's behavior behavior in of the Pleirse describe in the the presence of l. ,.3 A ,"4 l5 !6 !7 !8 t9 a It He was police showed he was was with with security. secwity. I-le was not not up when when he as before before the the police showed up lt was was the the same same as kind of of confused. out He seemed it, still was to scared, down, trying it, kind calming get of scared, up, seemed confused. He was out of calming down, still trying to get up, confused, panicing. panicing. confused, of being Did in any way? way? Did you hear hear Tim Tim complain complain of being injured injured in in all No No II never heard him him say anything all of of this. this. never heard anything in r0 n"' t2 I3 t4 t5 16 t7 t8 r9 t0 il t2 t3 I t5 Prosec or's Fi Pro r's Fi C 121 121 Filed 08/04/16 Page 23 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1160 O\LI—A»Jr)._<3go%]°hbF I Statement Statenrent of of Tina Tina Pinelli Pinelii Page Page 66 Is Is there anything else else you would would like add to to your statement? there anything like to to add statement? a 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 I i0 I ~°=‘c3toa." fine and Just go for would be be fine and just go Just that that when when the the ambulance that he he would for aa ambulance left left II had had assumed assumed that when until evaluation. didn’t he know mental I passed away until Monday boyfriend told mental evaluation. I didn't know he passed Monday when my boyfriend told festival had wasn’t the me. tour. This This confused confused me, He He had waited waited to to tell rne so too upset upset during during the festival tour. lell me so II wasn't too what he me healthy at me because because II didn’t at the the time time of didn't understand understand what he could could die die from. from. He He seemed seemed healthy of incident incident. the had been the and in until spirits really good the incident and had been in really good spirits up until the incident. Is would like Is there anything else else you would there anything like to to add add to to your statement? statement? No. No. 2 TYPINGCONCLUDED 5, 2015 4:45 4:45 p.m. TYPINC CONCLUDED - DATEAND DATE AND TIME: TIME: __October _October5,2015 — / iq 5:\.E§‘]_G'C,"a-—v~u 5 t6 t7 i8 .t9 _ t0 STATEMENTREVIEW S"I'ATEMENT REVIE \\/ AND AND SIGNATURE S ]QNATURE II have have read read this this statement sfatement consisting each page bears initials including including consisting of of 66 pages; each bears my initials corrections initialed in facts and thatthe I contained own handwriting; certify any corrections initialed in my own handwriting; and I certify that the fncts contrincd herein hercin are are true. truc. ,r, t. {J LiV1g_‘i’_“‘ ß15 I3 rs - 4--Et ' t3 l4 DATE DArF AND AND TIME: rlME ,.5 ' ,.6 !7 l8 Tina Tina Pinelli Pinelli t9 t0 il— \\ t2 )J t4 t5 t6 t7 t8 tg t0 il /<_ 5% %s _ _,. Dole‘ V€’i’.)£ll‘llCi Bozza Bozza Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office Office WW #tf< /)^nú-"L "C771 Detective Detective Brian Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Monmu.:I)_ Statement of Hoffman Jeremy Hoffman Statement of Jeremy Date: 23, 2015 2015 September 23, Date: September Page Page 33 we wanted and went and we wanted to to to my partner and over to went back back over approximately minute then then hung hung up and approximately aa minute be able to to truck the evaluate back of of the truck to be able to evaluate on the the back him on patient on and put him get the on the the stretcher stretcher and the patient him and EMS Department and EMS Poiice Department the Police helping the giving him was helping prior to the sedation. him the sedation. Ii was to giving him better, better, prior the rolled As rolled the patient stretcher while the they patient over, rolled the patient. As they by they rolled the patient. by holding holding the stretcher while they The was the immediately patient was immediately someone patient was non responsive. responsive. The patient was non that the patient stated that someone stated was The back. his the on patient transferred to meaning patient was then then brought brought into into stretcher, upright, The back. meaning on his to upright, the stretcher, transferred in cardiac the that was determined it and him patient which was next to the patient was was ca¡diac in the truck, that right the truck, which was right next to him and it was determined arrest as noted noted in in the the ALS interventions, interventions, as our ALS with our along with in the the truck, truck, along initiated in arrest and and CPR CPR was was initiated the When off removed handcuffs chart. patient. When II were removed off the patient. middle of of the the code, code, handcuffs were In the the middle chart. In don’t his breath. hreath. II don't on his w'.as a of alcohol alcohol on attempted patient, there srnell of a strong there was strong smell the patient, to intubate intubate the attempted to .cl-wage. Due recall f)ue to 1o my high high myæJmrgÆ. have to to check check my heart beat. beat. II would would have rcr.all if if we we reestablished rccstablished aa heart C^o-t-1G don’t recall. of volume 1 volume of work, work, I don't recall. I 2 t 4 5 6 7 I I IO il C"‘c\r“fi® 12 l3 Ii called which were medications, which were for medications, orders for further orders and received received further control doctor doctor and called my medical rnedical control Center. Medical him Shore and to then rendered University we Jersey Center. Medical transported rendered a¡rd then rve transported him to Jersey Shore University l4 l5 O«knJ>-L;.rQ:5$§)°B‘c,{\"St r6 11 l8co t9 a Who \\¡ho is is Kevin Kevin Donnolly? Dorurolly?  He our control deployment and resource deployment and oversees resource center supervisors. He oversees control center supervisors. He He is is one one of of our the have control conducted MONOC center. the ability to listen listen to operations conducted by to the the They have the ability to by the MONOC control center. They ofrerations obtain that calls He has has access access to to that information. information. He and obtain call take take themselves themselves and coming in in and and can can call catls coming infonnation. all the CAD information. all the CAD ‘ 1l' 7 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 LAJ)ap.‘g >»O_3/Q a how long patient became unresponsive long were became unresponsive Approximately the patient scene before before the were you on on scene ;\pproximately hr:w A It It could could not not have have been been more more than than 55 minutes. minutes. Q, Can patient',) provide aa physical physical description the patient‘? please provide of the description of Clan you please A, 3t 32 33 34 AahumJ-O\o] a. Can patient's demeanor? please describe demeanor? desoribe the the patient’s Can you please A. He yelling aggressively aggressively but but II get out. him yelling remember him to get out, II remember around trying trying to squirming around He was was squirming couldn’t was. out what what it it was. couldn't make make out a. spitting or to spit patient spitting spit blood or attempting attempting to blood During the patient on scene, did did you observe observe the During your time time on around him? that at was at anyone anyone that was around him? A. No No J) 36 37 38 39 40 4l 4. Ai). 6 foot. He wearing shorts. shorts. No was only only wearing No He was muscula¡. He and ó White, muscular. He looked looked between between 5’l0 5'10 and foot, White, blood from he had his believe I from head to toe. in mud covered shirt. He coming was coming he from had blood his shirt. FIe was covered in mud from head to toe, I believe chart. reference have would I to don’t remember I nose. specifically. I would have to referense my chart. nose. I don't remember specifically. 44A Prosecuto Prosecu \\ ,‘~ s S FII . 25 0 125 Filed 08/04/16 Page 27 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1164 Statement Statement of of Jeremy Jeremy Hoffman Hoffman Date: 2015 23, September Date: September 23, 201 5 Page Page 44 I a Was Was there there anything anything that would have patient's airway? that would have obstructed obstmcted the the patient’s airway? A Not Not that that II could could see, see, no. no. He He only had mud mud on on his only had his face. face. a When tl1e or your you arrived When you you or your partner arrived on were you paftner instructed park the on scene, were instructed by by anyone to to park ambulance in certain location? a ambulance in a certain location? A No, No, we we were were not. 2 3 4 { 6 7 I 9 When you arrived When you arrived on on scene, approximately approximately how how many Howell Howell Township Township Police Police Officers Officers scene? were were on on scene? l0 il l2 A IJ 14 t5 a l6 t7 r8 t9 A. ?( ), a. 23 24 l There Officers. ldon’t probably between There was was probably between 88 and and 10 10 Howell Township Police Police Officers. Howell Township I don't recall recall how how Police Officers the down. many many Police Officers were were holding patient down. holding the patient Can Offlcers’ actions you please please describe Can you describe the the Police Police Officers' were controlling controlling the actions while while they they were the patient? patient? They They had had him him handcuffed handcuffed behind behind his his back back and and they him by the limbs. limbs. They they had had him by the 1'hey weren’t weren't on on of the but his limbs. hands That It all. were was on. was patient, top they holding patient, top of the but they were holding his lirnbs, It was hands on. That was all. During scene, did During your time time on on scene, did you hear Howell Township hear any any members members of of the the Howell Township Police Police Department patient? Departrnent talking talking to to the the patient? AI 2‘-Jot off the top call the irot offthe top of of my head, head, II got there there and to call walked away right away to the doctor. doctor. and walked away right 'l patient’s patient's airway? airway? 3C A, No. No JI -i 25 26 27 28 29 32 33 34 36 a Did you observe Did you observe any any member member of Howell Township Police Department Department utilize of the the Howell Township Police utilize any control the to weapons to control the patient? patient? A. No. No 38 39 40 Did 'l'ownship Police you observe Did you observe any any member member of of the the Howell Howell Township Department strike Police Department strike the the patient? patient? No. No. 35 37 Did of the you observe Díd you observe any any member member of the Howell Howell Township Township Police Police Department Department obstruct obstruct the the 1l 1l ( Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File (( 3126 126 Filed 08/04/16 Page 28 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1165 =:9._‘°"U\4'-JN—oa1xt.nz>wr~_ Statement of Statement Jeremy Hoffman of Jeremy Hoffman Date: 2015 23, September Dater September 23, 2015 Page Page 5s the event interacting During frorn the event interacting your time Security Guards Guards from During your time on on scene, did did you observe observe any Security withthe patient? with the patient? I J J No. No. 4 { Did Township Police or the the Howell Howell Township Police team or of the the Security Security team Did you render render first first aid aid to member of to any member ó Department? Department? 7 I 9 A No. No. a rMlc did Who a result call for for service? sen'ice? of this this call did you notify as a of the the outcome outcome of notify as result of 10 II t2 l4 II notified what happened happened regarding regarding the nctified operations told her her what the operatio¡ls manager, Donna Dorura Furkey Furkey and and told for while be tied the a situation and at that to we were going to possibly hospital for a while for for clean possibly be tied up at the hospital situation and that we were going clean t5 up. l3 16 l7 t8 T9 Did actions after your partner’s Did you document partner's actions this call call for for service? service? document you and and your after this Yes. patient care Yes, Electronic Electronic patient care reporting. reporting. ),!' 22 7) 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 1'1 ,!.6 M 29 30 30 31 3l 3') _-12 33 33 J./ 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 4l 4t 4?‘ 47 l¿ Prosecuto Prosecu e d127 0 27 Filed 08/04/16 Page 29 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1166 O\Lnb.)[_©o°]“J'ku ‘ t Statement Jeremy Hoffman Hoffman of Jeremy Statement of Date: 23, 2015 201.5 Date: September Sepf ember 23, Page Page 66 a add to Is to add at thistime? this time? statement at would like like to to your statement Is there there anything anything you would A No. No. 2 J 4 5 6 7 I I t0 ll 12 23. 2015 2:27 TYPING 2:27 P.M. P.M September23.2015 AND TIME: TIME: September TYPING CONCLUDED DATE AND CONCLUDED - DATE — STATEMENT REVIËW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE ST,{TEMENT REVIEW t4 II have consisting of initials including including any each page bears hears my initials this statement of 66 pages; each have read read this statement consisting facts thatthe I and corrections contained herein herein are are certify that the facts contained initialed in in my own own handwriting; handwriting; and I certify corrections initialed l5 true. true. l3 l6 t7 l8 l9 TIME: DATE DATE AND AND TIME: ¿11 .‘/ 9_j_’; /3'f * i) 22 22 23 24 2'l 23 2J 26 26 Zt 28 28 29 29 30 30 3] 3l 32 32 33 34 34 35 Prosecutor's Office ianiel Newman Detectiii Detecti Newman — - Monmouth Prosecutor's Office Offi ce Monmouth County County Prosecutor's 36 3ó 37 i8 Prosecutor's ( 28 Prosecutor's File File 0128 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 30 of 100 PagelD: 1167 2 A l\ 3 5 STATEMENT OF: Ryan Edgar 7 ADDRESS l5 TELEPHONE N0: _Ealomown, NJ 07724 3 9 in DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: in Monmouth Medical Center Long Branch, NJ II 13 SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: - 14 IS TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's ornoe 16 132 Jeroeyville Avenue Freehold. New Jersey 07723 13 QUESTIONED BY: Daniel Bum 2n Monmoulh Counly Prosecutor's Offioe 1| 2: WITNESSED BY: Detective Daniel Newman 2' Monmouth Counly Prosecutor's Office 2' 25 26 TYPED BY: Autumn 'rymesko 27 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 23 29 DATE TIME: September 23, 2015 9:45 AM. 30 3! 32 Ryan Edgar, am Detective Daniel Buzz: of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's 0mm and 33 present her: is Detective Daniel Newman of the same office. It is our duty to ask you 35 questions regarding the circumstanccs surrounding the incident that occurred at the 35 Priediane located at 1017 Rt. 33, Freehold, NJ involving Timothy Harden on Seplember 5, so 2015. 37 Jr This statemcnl must be a voluntary one, given of your own free will and accord, without :9 any threats or promises, knowing that whal you say may he used in a Coun of Law. 40 42 Are you willing to give a voluntary statemcm at this time? 43 A Yes. 1 EXHIBIT 4o a MC- 9/20 Prosecutor's File 0 29 Filed 08/04/16 Page 31 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1168 ou—-._,e~i\ua4smN._°]‘: Statement Edgar of Ryan Ryan Edgar Statement of Date: 23, 2Al 5 Date: September September 23, 2015 2 Page Page2 (‘it I ¿ 34. 34. 3 4 What is your occupation? TVhat is occupation? 5 6 Stay home father/ father/ Construction. Construction. Stay at at home 7 I What formal education? education? is your formal What is 9 "‘l0 High High School. School. ll l2 Q l3 t4 l6 Q t7 l8 l9 >\o occurred at l0l7 Rt. at 1017 located at Rt. 33. 33. Calling Priediane located your attention at the the Priediane to the the incident incident that that occurred attention to Calling your in tell us Harden NJ 2015, Freehold, please tell us in your own September 5,5, 2015, please own on September Freehold, NJ involving involving Timothy Timotþ Harden on words have of of this this incident. incident, words what what knowledge knowledge you have ') 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 11 ',i Can Language? the English English Language? write and and understand understand the Can you read, read, write Yes. Yes. 2^ 44 44 Are manied? Are you married? Yes. Yes. l5 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 31 38 38 39 39 40 40 4 4t 4'.‘ 4: What yow age? ís your age? What is 15(r 1» 2 w L! Groove Music II arrived approximately 10 at the 5rl'approximately September 5"‘ l0 Festival on on Saturday, Saturday, September the Souper Music Festival arrived at Souper Groove with to I Erin and with was two sons. help a.m. shuttle staff the shuttle staff volunteeríng to help with the wife, Erin and my two sons. I was volunteering a.m. with my wife, equipment mming band equipment camping equipment and also also shuttling shuttling band handicapped patrons and equipment for for handicapped moving camping -) Si the maitt-est-atrami the near tent I at hack and forth. had set near playground playground near the mainçf,atcand gotten my up near the at tent back and lbrth. I had sel Michael in past my tent and and had had Mr. drove past my tent Mr. with, drove volunteering with, who II was Johnstone, who was volunteering Michael Johnstone, for needed if he Michael asked me I of his the Harden in cart. seat golf cart. I asked Michael if he needed me for any work work pass€nger seat of his golf in the passenger detail. wife and and my youngest son son point, Mr. Mr. Harden Ha¡den saw saw my wife no. At At which which point, detail, He He responded responded no. be and how to she that vision there, her that he had was told inside a going going be there, and to how tent, that she was vision my inside my tent, told her that he had a she was awesome it very odd. odd, My My friend friend Michael, Michael, found very which II found fìnally there, there, which it was was that that she was finally awesome his rolled his nodded Mr. to head, Harden, without as if if to to tell tell anything to upset upset Mr. Harden, nodded his head, rolled his eyes as without saying saying anything Mr. his Harden. me on Mr. Harden. was keeping that Michael Michael was keeping his eye on is up with with this this guy and and that me something something is ( Then together after after that golf cart see them them together didn't see that the golf cart and and II didn’t with Mr. in the left with Mr. Harden Harden in Then Michael Michael left him had Harden across Mr. that told he Michael I jumped time but the me jumped next get across him to to get saw Michael he told me that Mr. Harden had but the next time I saw out premises, across ran off the premises, across off the and Mr. Mr. Harden Harden ran was driving cart that that Michel Michel was driving and the golf cart out of of the route that II knew knew was thing that was the only only thing of hours, hours, the couple of For the the next next couple the woods. woods. For route 33 and into into the 33 and I 3 was Around Harden. Mr. for o’clock, walking family 2:30, that my walking were I was farnily looking people were looking for Mr. Ha¡den, Around 2:30,3 o'clock, that people back sitter. She baby sitter. She was was the baby to the sonos to could take take my son’s parking lot wife could lot so so that that my wife to the the parking back to for the sitter had We site. a the and kids for for originally had a sitter for the kids going going to meet me me at at the camp site. We originally to come come back back and meet was aa little little atmosphere was bring them the atmosphere because the Saturday, earlier because them aa little little earlier to bring we decided decided to Saturday, but but we Prosecutofige Prosecutor's O 130 30 Filed 08/04/16 Page 32 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1169 Statement Ryan Edgar Edgar of Ryan Statement of Date: 23, September 201 5 Date: Septemb er 23, 2015 -“*’N¢>~oa\1su.;:<_ Page Page 33 year, and and everyone everyone was previous year, was the previous there were were the as there crazy. There There weren’t as many families families as $azy, weren't as off the So and there and around, running a was property. property. roaming So II drinking partying and there was a guy roaming around, running off the drinking and partying He of Bleefeld. Ben friend a was and I the lot part of the was the parking lot and I saw saw my friend Ben Bleefeld. He was a part to the parking was on on my way to into the back him festival to to brought him back into the festival and brought the highway highway and that found found Mr. Mr. Harden Harden down down the group that him. had to Ben and what he went where calm out him to happened to down, happened to him. Ben figure had went and what try get try to get him to calm down, figure out where he asked the car. car. Ben Ben said, to the kids to said, walking my kids I'm walking said no. no. I’m which II said if II was was leaving, leaving, to to which asked me me if I 2 3 4 5 6 _., please you're done. please come done. come find find me me when when you’re I went back II walked back into into the the festival, festival, good bye to my wife and and went my wife bye to walked my kids kids to to the car, said said good the car, and He I to Johnstone. I Michael assisting work, where across came moving where I came across Michael Johnstone. He and I got to work, assisting campers moving their man named named Ian, by aa man [an, II told by were then then told We were equipment to their camp sites. sites, We camping equipment to their their camping needed think he don’t we were were needed out out that we the employees, employees, that one of of the he was was one know his last name, name, II think don't know his last of in front tü/hen Mr. Harden carts there two arrived When front. were out parked we front, golf Mr, golf parked in front of Harden carts we arrived out front, there were two fror¡t. our golf Guards. We and by aa girl golf cart end of the line park our cart at at the the end of the line girl to to park were told We were told by and two two Security Security tuards. made that the were aware of Mr. parked the golf cart, cart, we we wete made aware that Mr. we parked carts to to block the scene. scene. As As we of carts block the front the the of the had face, Harden one by working girls by the out, girls the front grabbed working face, flipped completely grabbed one of the had completely flipped out, Harden and guard came came up point, aa security up to to stop stop ground. At security guard At which which point, her into into the the ground. to throw throw her and tried tried to Guard face. The in the the him and he Security responded guard in the face. The Security Guard responded by by punched the security security guard him and he punched and that struggle was the struggle punching was set set was to to understand understand the punching Mr. is how how II was the face face and that is Mr. Harden Harden in in the I l0 l¡ l2 l3 ~o\:3§'CB"“$°‘, t4 r—-n ONUI l5 l6 t7 l8 t9 off. off^ 2î . 2 )7 23 24 Munro 25 26 27 wuaChmvc-\.2 )_'S '4-‘5IJ:«wuL.->o\e1 28 29 30 31. 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 4? 4*‘ ¿l- 44 ¿o{hoç aÞ arms. Mr. Guard on Mr. on When Harden was Mr. Harden was on got there, Mr. Harden’s Harden's arms. there was was one one Security Secwity Guard When II got there, there hard time Guards The a were with them. his having a hard time Security Guards were having he was was struggling struggling with them. The Security his back back and and he with his his arms. arms. He keeping ground. Mr. lifting the the guys up with He was lifting on the the ground. Mr. Harden Ha¡den was keeping Mr. lvfr. Harden Harden on this He at wasn’t and Harden was Mr. point. anything point. was saying really this kicking. at bucking He was was bucking and kicking, Mr. Harden wasn't really saying anything and saying, get off off me. me. He screaming and yelling. Mr. He would just screaming saying, get would roaring and Harden was was roaring and yelling. Mr. Harden but he that told him calm visibly, you could could tell respond calm, but visibly, tell was calm, insisting that he was respond if to calm down, down, insisting if you told him to he approached Mr. nose. II approached point that had blood his nose. Mr. blood on on his that Mr. Mr. Harden Harden had he was was not. not, II noticed this point noticed at at this him that hand on Harden, down and and breathe. breathe. to calm calm down that he needed to and told told him he needed Harden, put my hand on his his knee knee and in he because but couldn’t was off of a he wanted know I That to we panic us him, and get off of him, but we couldn't because he was in a panic and That I know he wanted us to get the that about 55 minutes. minutes. He He was rvas for about to do do the the trick trick for way. This This seemed seemed to tryas on on the way. that help help was he was on there was was somebody somebody on breathing, good job and that there and that doing aa good was telling telling him him that was doing breathing, II was that he informed and that the front me over the And then of came the one working informed gate, gate, me girls over and came that way. And then one of the girls working the front the way. the poirrto Mr. looked at at me me right Mr. Harden Harden looked right At that that point, be there there in in about about 10 10 minutes. minutes. At the Police Police would would be in shit." And And then this breathing breathing shit.” then he he I'm done done with with this this. Pm in the eye and the eye and screamed, screamed, “Fuck "Fuck this. threw he his kicked point, II caught legs at at his legs legs because because he just threw his legs caught his me in in the the chest. chest. At At which kicked me which point, he his while I and was around his I legs, was holding arms extremely me. was legs his legs, he extremely wrapped while I was holding my arms around his legs and me. I wrapped There wasn’t violent. him down holding him down to to the was holding the point where calmed down. down. II was where he he calmed wasn't any point violent. There able almost He to was had I he to but pull his his ground keep readjusting. readjusting. He was almost abie to pull ground but he was was moving moving me. me. I had to keep down to to readjust would have have to readjust to get me to legs grip. He to his hís ankles ankles and and II would He would would get me down legs out out of of my grip. Harden Mr. that around was hold. better and his knees time, to back saying a was Right Mr. Harden saying that time, get Right around get get back to his knees and a better hold. up. Me Me and fucked up. and the you had this is is fucked the things my back, back, this had my Jay Z, thought you things like, like, help help me me Jay Z, II thought he but calm Mr. Harden that down, kept insisting Guards that he he Security insisting that Mr. Harden calm down, but he kept ínsisting that kept insisting Security Guards kept a minute. was. There was for a minute. There was a a let up up for wouldn't let time. He He wouldn’t violent the the whole whole time. But he he was was violent was. But ‘£2 3L Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0 131 31 Filed 08/04/16 Page 33 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1170 Statement of Ryan Ryan Edgar Edgar Statement of Date: 23, September 201 5 Date: September 23, 2015 N-O\oe)uAL.:_ Page Page 44 around the was there there trying trying to to sworm Mahajan was Dave Mahajan the staff. Iike the staff. Dave people around whole time, time, like the whole of people sworTn of started then to And listen. as Tim wouldn’t but him down calm people to Tim talk people to to as started to then get him to calm down but Tim wouldn't listen, And talk to Tim to get I Guards. the for two took Police the Police Security helped over when the disperse a¡rived, the Police took over for the two Security Guards. I helped disperse when the Police arrived, roll Harden Mr. onto Police the and informed informed stop resisting resisting and he stop insisted that that he They insisted chest. They his chest. roll Mr. Harden onto his the Police that Harden Mr. handcuffs. in him insisting kept that to Harden Mr. were kept ínsisting that he he going Mr, Harden they put going in handcuffs. him to Mr. Harden that they were his let them hands would not He Police. with the put he but them his hands was was struggling wíth the Police. He would not let calm, but he was struggling was calm, behind and tightening tightening of him him and off of to buck buck everyone off trying to kep trying Mr. Harden Harden kept back. And And Mr. behind his his back. would have or times several to they told him resisting The Police whole his stop or fhey wouid have resisting body times to stop several up. The Police told him his whole body up. because to were head use turn they going to warned Then force. going me were to use they to use because away they to use force. Then they wamed me to tum my head did it but the of sound the heard absolutely turned head nothing I mace. to mace, but it did absolutely nothing to away, heard the sound of the mace, mace. I turned my head away, deter struggling, Harden from from struggling. deter Mr. Mr. Harden I 2 J 4 5 6 7 I ._ 9 l0 ~.»C3§'o\:G‘E [\Jl7K)Ik‘°2\lOU-Amie 1l t2 Officer arrived me that that he he would told me would me. He He told point, another and relieved relieved me. Shortly arrived and after that that point, another Officer Shortly after show ambulance the and I he relieved saw minutes after me for few I take a stayed for a few minutes after he relieved me and I saw the ambulance show up over. f stayed take over. and see that Then II was was just Police. Then the Police. with the wâs still still struggling struggling with oould see that Mr. Mr. Harden Harden was and II could should that all told we Guards the us and the just over Security we should all that told us by entry standing Guards way the Seourity by entry and the standing over That end of the their was now. it because scene let Police take was and the to over T'hat was end of now. the disperse disperse and to let the Police take over because it was their scene involvement. my involvement, t3 l4 15 l6 -l7 _. t8 19 Have previous Souper events? Groove events? attending any previous Souper Groove I'{ave you attending 2o 22 23 24 25 ‘Jnbok»w-~.\2§3£’$BS8 26 27 28 29 30 3l 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 4? > >/O Yes. previous September. The previous September. Yes. The Have Harden prior interactions Mr. Harden interactions with with Mr. Have you had had any prior No. yeâr, but not sure. sure, passing the previous year, but I’m I'm not the previous seen him him in in passing No. II might might have have seen Prior Harden? personal relationship with Timothy Timothy Harden‘? relationship with have any personal this incident, incident, did did you have to this Prior to No. No. Can of the the incident? incident? day of please describe on the the day describe Mr. Mr. Harden Harden on Can you please and exhausted. No dehydrated and exhausted, was dehydrated like he he was Looked like Visibly sweaty. sweaty. Looked No shirt. shirt. No No shoes. shoes. Visibly tcll he could You foot. Laborcd was athletic. athlefic, stocky, about about 66 foot. You could tcll he was movçmcnts, He was just stocky. Labored movements. He was Very Very muscular. muscular. Can with the the Security Security to the the incident incident with you please please describe Harden's behavior behavior prior to desuibe Mr. Mr. Harden’s Can you Guards? Gua¡ds? planet. You could look look at You could at Strange. another planet. dazed, on on another He was was completely Very strange. strange. He completely dazed, Strange. Very out. He was tell were him and he wasn’t spaced saying. out. anything hearing anything you were saying' He was spaced him and tell he wasn't hearing J:4 b A44 Kt Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File d 132 32 Filed 08/04/16 Page 34 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1171 Statement of Statement of Ryan Ryan Edgar Edgar Date: 23, 2015 2015 Date: September September 23, Page Page 5s (J. I Who is Who is Michael Michael Johnstone Johnstone and and how how do do you know know him? him? t He’s years. We probably about play in He's been friend of mine since about 18 18 years. We used used to been aa friend of mine since High High School, School, probably to play in another band I for know he EMT and He was an a company, He was band together. together. I k¡ow he was an EMT and a dispatcher dispatcher for another company. was just just working working the the event, event, helping helping out out with ever¡hing. with everything. 3 a a 4 5 6 Who Ben Bleefeld do you know Who is is Ben Bleefeld and and how how do krow him? him? 7 I II went played in went to to High High School School with with him we all same music music scene. scene. I’ve I've known him and and we all played in the the same known him him for for about about 18 18 years. 9 t0 _.nF. Who Who is is Ian lan and and how how do do you know know him? him? t2 t3 II don’t don't really really know know Ian. lan. That That was was the the first first time time meeting meeting him. him. l4 l5 Can please describe Can you please describe Ian? lan? l6 17 He Caucasian. That’s He had had aa beard. Rather large beard. Rather large beard beard the the day About 66 foot. foot. Caucasian. day of of the the event. event. About That's about it. about it. l8 t9 2þ 2 C Do Do you know know the the two two Security Sccurity Guards incident with Harden? involved in in the the incident with Mr. Mr. Harden? Guards involved > No. No. O Can describe the please desøibe Can you please the two two Security Security Guards? Guards? > Rather Rather large. large. They They were were wearing wearing red red shirts. wanna say say one one of them was shirts. II wanna of them was African African American and Caucasian. think of them had think I I one was American and one was Caucasian. I think one gloves on. one of them had gloves on. I think they they were were wearing hats. No wearing hats. No marks marks or or scars scars that could see. that II could see. )) 23 24 2S 26 27 28 29 30 During During your time time at at the the scene scene when when Security Security Guards Guards were were interacting with Mr. Mr. Harden, interacting with Harden, did did observe strike Guards other Mr. Harden? or Security Guards or other personnel you observe any Security personnel strike Mr. Harden? 3t 32 33 Yes. Yes. The The two two Security Security Guards Guards who who were restraining Mr. M¡. Harden Harden by by the the arms were restraining arms were were trying trying to to 3+' get get him him to to calm calm down down and and stop stop resisting. resisting. When Wren he didn't, they they would would drop drop elbows elbows around he didn’t, around 35- his his shoulder shoulder region. region. 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 0 During During your time time at at the the scene when Security was interacting Mr. Harden, Harden, did scene when Security was interacting with with Mr. did you observe Guards other restrict Harden’s Mr. or Security airway? personnel personnel observe Security Guards or other restrict Mr, Harden's airway? II didn’t region, pushing didn't see see it it but pushing on his shoulders but they they were on that on his shoulders and were focused focused on that region, and chest, chest, trying to keep ground. trying to keep his his back back on on the the ground. 4. qL [(2 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0 H33 33 Filed 08/04/16 Page 35 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1172 ‘'5’S32\U-I.\>:"o~‘“iu.4:,N_ Statement Edgar of Ryan Ryan Edgar Íitatement of Date: 23, 2015 2Al 5 Date : September September 23, Page Page 66 I Q. Guards involved Do were equipped equipped with with this incident incident were involved in in this ycru know the Security Security Guards k¡ow if if the Do you batons? or handcuffs, mace, handcuffs, mace, or batons? A. No. thal II was was aware aware of. of. Not that No. Not 7 3 4 5 Were Cuards? the Security Security Guards? at any of of the spitting at was spitting to see if Mr. Mr. Harden Harden was able to see if Were you able 6 7 Yes. He was Guard!-. The The one os_e___a_t __t_he Security Security Guards. one allhe from his his_ n, blood that that was was leaking leaki from was spitting blood Yes. He ¡qsç hit with about left Harden’s Mr. being that Guards complained was being hit with arm, about holding complainèd Security 's left Mr, Harden olding Guards that was h Security the his left left arm. arm, the blood blood on on his 8 9 10 ll Do his nose nose to to bleed? injury on bleecl? that caused caused his face that on his his face the injury received the Mr. Harden Harden received how Mr. Do you know know how t2 rl II was Mr. Harden I-larden became him, Mr. became Guards approached approachcd him, when the that when the Security Security Guards was told told by Michael that by Michael returned the Guard to and the Guard in the punch Security face, punch a returned thc to violent, punðhrd a Security Security Guard in the fäcã, and the Security Guard viotent, punched Harden’s Mr. nose how was understand I how is to face. That bleeding. Harden’s Mr. came to understarrd how Mr. Hardenos nose was bleeding. Mr, Harden's face. That is how I came l4 t5 l6 t7 l8 i9 Q. to 20 II would Police arrived. arrived. the Police until the legs, until on his his legs, from 15 20 minutes minutes on l5 to would estimate estinrate anywhere anywhere front 20 ,, 22 23 ¿J 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 2'l 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 "t', 33 33 34 J{ 35 35 36 JO 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 4? 4? with Mr. Mr. Harden? Harden? physical interaction Approximately interaction with how long long was was your physical Approxintately how Q. of your physical Did Harden? with Mr. Mr. Harden? physical interaction interaction with a result result of receive any injuries ir{uries as as a Did you receive But mostly, mostly, II minor bruising. bruising. But Nothing which caused caused minor chest, which kick to to the the chest, took aa kick Nothing major. major. II took noticed. especially wipe, My My shoulders, shoulders, were completely completely wipe. that my shoulders shoulders were especially the the next next day, day, that noliced, Harden Mr. from all stomach and knees sore tight. were holding tight. Mr, Harden from holding knees and stomach were all sore C; Did as a injuries? of your injuries? a result result of rnedical attention attention as Did you receive receive any medical No. No. c Do thc scene? scene? responded to to the know what what Police Police agency responded Do you know > II believe was Howell. Howell. believe it it was on scene? scene? anived on Approximately Township Police Police Officers Officers arrived how many Howell Howell Township Approximately how of my involvement. involvement. end of at the the end anived at Initially, Officer arrived a third third Officer believe a 2. And And then tlren II believe Initially, it it was was 2. tell couldn’t I After that, After that, I couldn't tell you. remain on on scene? scene? did you remain Ollcers relieved relieved you, did Approximately the initial initial Officers after the how long long after Approximately how Maybe minutes. Maybe 55 minutes. site. And the camp site. into the left to back into to go back And then then II left 44 44 File Prosecutor's Pro File 00 134 34 Filed 08/04/16 Page 36 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1173 “rq._,°"*‘’N'-O~ou\r;st.: I 2 J 4 5 6 7 I 9 "n l0 L2 I3 l4 l5 I6 t? axon: l8 t9 20 22 22 23 23 24 1Å 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 Statement Edgar of Ryan Ryan Edgar Statenrent of Date: 20I' 5 September 23, 23, 2015 l)ate: September Page Page 7t (J. describe what Can you please Offìcers took took to to control control Police Ofticers Township Police please describe the Howell Howell Township what actions actions the Can Mr. were relieved? relieved? Harden after after you were Mr. Harden After restraining his his the Officer Offìcer restraining see the away, II could could see walked away, me, II walked Officer relieved relieved me, After the the Police Police Officer handcuffs. One had the had Officers two other The who took for applied the handcuffs. One had aa legs. over for me. me. The other two Officers had applied legs, who took over both had knee had their their arms arms on on Mr. Mr. they both back. And And they Harden's lower lower back. control Mr. Mr. Harden’s to control knee just to could tell that there and I the him shoulders was Harden‘s leaving to on tell you could that there ground. ground, leaving and keep I was Harden's shoulders to keep him on the was get in in there. there. going on EMT couldn’t the EMT couldn't get was still still aa struggle struggle going on because because the Can Police Officers Officers were were Township Police Howell Township please describe verbal commands commands the the Howell Can you please describe what what verbal of incident? this the Harden Mr. course during giving incident? giving Mr. Harden during the course of this resisting. Even telling him stop resisting. Even to stop hinr to They whole thing, thing, telling were constantly throughout the the whole I'hc.v were constantly throughout was. though wasn't resisting he clearly clearly was. insisted he when he he insisted he wasn’t resisting when tlrough he Howell Township were interacting interacting During Police Officers Officers were the Howell I'ownship Police the scene when the During your time time at at the scene when Harden’s Mr. restrict Police Officers did observe with airway? Harden, ditl you obsen'e any Police Officers restrict Mr. Harden's airway? with Mr. Mr. Harden, wrist to II only at one Harden's head hcad while whilu' back side side ofMr. of Mr. Harden’s point, an to the the back his wrist saw at one point, Of'ficer put his only saw an Officer with the the much it same But the handcuffs was to on. Security were they put the handcufl's on. But it was nruch the sante with the Securit¡' trying to put lhey rvere trying Guards trying to fo keep keep Mr. point was were just trying Mr. was they they were in, all all It could tell from from my vantage vantage point Cuards and and in, could tell Harden’s ground. Harden's shoulders shoulders on on the the ground. Did Harden? Mr. Harden? strike Mr. Police Officers Officers strike Did you observe observe any Howell Howell Township Township Police Yes. Elbows to the giving They were were giving resisting. They tell him hirn to to stop stop resisting. To tell back region. region. To Yes. Elbows to the shoulders, shoulders. back resist. would and whenever he elbow shots the shoulders little him to try resist. would and whenever he hin: little elbow shots to the shoulders Officers? at the Were Police Officers? the Howell Howell Police Mr. Harden Harden was was spitting spitting at Were you able able to to see see if if Mr. No. No. Were aid? was rendered first aid? see if if Mr. Mr. Harden Harden was rendered first able to to see Were you able No. point. gone by that point. been gone by that had already already been No. It had Officers that were on Can that were Police Officers on Township Police Howell Township please describe of the the Howell the demeanor describe the demeanor of Can you please scene incident? during this this incident? scene during of The were insistent tried to to get control control of They tried jumped right resist. They not resist. that he he not insistent that right in. in. And And they they were The jumped him main Their was concern 'fhe the of out Guards The getting getting were the him Security way. Their main concern \ryas Security Guards were ouf of the way. the scene. scene. restrained anybody. hurt anybody. that Mr. Mr. Harden Harden couldn’t couldn't hurt so that restrained so /6" Qa, Prosecutor's File 0 135 35 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 37 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1174 .'\-3Psi—:_.D~Oo\Jg4;-w,_c°I‘LhN Statement of Ryan Statement of Ryan Edgar Edgar Date: Date: September September 23, 2015 23, 2015 Page Page 8a At Mr. Harden, point during with Mr. Harden, did At any point interaction with did Howell Township Polioe Officer’s Officer's interaction during the the Howell Township Police Police utilize Officer weapons? any you observe observe Police Officer utilize any weapons? »I_. ) 3 Just just restraining Just mace. arms and and hands. hands, mace. Nothing with their arms Nothing else. else. They were just him withtheir They were restraining him 4 5 6 a 7 At you observe point in observe anyone At any point in time the incident, did you time while while you were were at at the the scene scene of of the incident, did anyone the ambulance relocate it’s to directing position? directing the ambulance to relocate it's position? 8 No. No. I t0 il l2 l3 l4 l5 l6 t7 l8 t9 a Is Is there there anything anything you would at this this time? time? like to to add add to to your statement statement at would like A II feel a tragedy. everybody involved. feel terrible. terrible. lt’s l1's a tragedy. II feel for everybody involved, II feel feel bad bad for for the the guy who feel bad bad for who lost his and for the watched it all who and tried him It’s to life, help happen. people Iost his iife, and for the people who tried to help him and watched it all happen. It's aa terrible terrible situation situation Is else you would Is there there anything anything else would like like to to your statement at this this time? time? to add add to statement at No. No. 2(.1 l\) 22 l\)IJ IL .) TYPING 23, 2015 11:08 TYPING CONCLUDED CONCLUDED * DATE DATE AND TIME: September Septembcr?3,2DIl ll:08 A.M. A.M AND TIME: — 23 24 25 26 t1 28 to STATEMENTREVIEW STATEMENT REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE II have have read read this this statement statement consisting consisting of of 88 pages; each bears my initials initials including including any each page bears corrections initialed in conections initíaled in my own facts contained contained herein own handwriting; handwriting; and and II certify certify that that the the facts herein are are true. true. 30 3l DATE AND TIME: tl 23 A{\ 3'2 — JJ 34 35 36 -BInJ:mu 37 38 39 Detectíve Mo.nmouth Prosecutor's Offïce 40 4t 42 Detecti 44 44 Newman Monmouth Monm Stage Hand. Stage Hand. 6 7 What education? formal education? is your formal What is 9 Some college. Some college. I l0 Are married? Are you married? n t2 r3 t4 l5 r6 t7 t8 l9 20 *Q.>C No. No. Can Language? English Language? the English write and and understand understand the read, write Can you read, Yes. Yes. attention to 1017 Route at 1017 Route Priediane located at at the the Priedianelocated Culling that occurred occurred at incident that to the the incident Calling your attention can 2015, 5, Harden on you New September c¿rn 5, 2015, Freehold. Timothy involving on 33, Jersey September Harden 33, Freehold. New Jersey involving Tinrothy this incident. incident. ofthis have of please words what what knowledge knowledge you have please tell in your own own words tell us us in 5» *tlt-fit 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 2'.1 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3r 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 4’! 41 45 45 cf'I'ofld\’ 45 /. (ffcao( Aât L While attention that that one one to my attention it came came to festival it Soupe{rooæ festival at the the Suupergromrc an organizer organizer at working as as an While working said that attention. needed and some erratic They Harden Tim They of said was that acting volunteers, some attention. our and needed ematic of our volunteers, Tim Harden was acting a yoga instructor who had had left Ieft he instructor who specifically a staff, specifically getting aggressive female staff, aggressive with with female he was was getting staff members. female other that to to act continued he with the frustrated situation, he co¡rtinued to act that way to other female staff members. frustrateá with the situation, conclusion After to the the conclusion came to briefly and Johnstone came to Michael Michael Johnstone and talking talking to him briefly with him meeting with Affer meeting shirtless off the and Tim had festival. run grounds from the escorted grounds be he had shirlless to that the off and run Tinr had festival. from the that he had to be escorted He the ride was to for airport. running a 33 He was route shoeless running asking airport' across to the ride stopping cars, asking for a shoeless across route 33 stopping cars, was able is Chris, Chris, was able to to name is his name of Tim’s, Tim's, his through property and an acquaintance peoples'property then an acquaintance of and then through peoples’ Priscilla while site his Mahajan to his camp site while we, Priscilla Maha.ian and and I, l. bring back to brought him him back back. Chris Chris brought him back. bring him could be Before the him to arrangements to make hospital. started could to arrangements be bring Befcre the hospital. arrangements to him started to make arrangernents to bring Tim again. few minutes it was made it ltlinutes of After aa few of again. After lost'l'im Chris had had lost that Chris brought to to my attention attention that was brought made the In few their a site campsite in found eating their grapes. grapes. In tlre canrpsite a f'ew searching stranger's camp site eating was found in aa stranger’s he was searching he Quietly II lured hirn away form feet lured him lbrm her baby. baby. Quietly wo¡narr with Tim was was aa sleeping sleeping woman with her from Tim feet away from At this Tim ofthe him area. out point hand to the took him Chris point while At this the area. Tim get of the by out to him campsite the campsite while Cluis took him by the hand break them able to headlock. was him in a I Chris tackled apart and violent to break them apart became was able putting became violenf and tackled Chris putting him in a headlock. campsite and and the campsite and the path between the between the to the the path people taking taking him him to from the the people get Tim Tim away from and get and him fencing down pul up fencin-g and do do odd odd area. II was help put having him help by having Tim down by parking was able able to calm Tim parking area. to calm he started feely with with me getting touchy touchy feely me and started getting He started again. He erratic again. to act act erratic work until until he started to and end end work earlier. him I in look with him looked a gave I’ve at the he earlier. him how eyes my saw in look a saying saying how he saw the way I've lo<¡ked at him with .l he startedaa the Gatorade, While Gatorades. drinking two and had Gatorade, he started the us grab us two Gatorades. While drinking hug someone grab trug an¿ had someone from He from ran and me. drink his ran down threw ¡ne to to acting if he were in in danger, danger, threw down his drink and ran from me. He ran fiom me as if he were acting as him and the escort hand to the him take able I to he where was by escort him and to the hand the him by to a stopped able take yard was neighbor’s I yard he stopped where a neighbor's guards, II think think one one front security guards, two security had two Johnstone had Michael Jolmstone While on on the the way Michael a¡ea. While front gate area. /17 ø Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0 “I38 38 Filed 08/04/16 Page 40 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1177 b-'t3o\c1ux.:L2_ Statement Benjamin Bleefeld Bleefeld of Benjamin Statement of of6 Page Page 3: orø the front out of gate, we got him we got us to front gate, him out proceeded to follow us to the to follow Brian, they of them them was was named named was was Brian, they proceeded small talk. of Tim, small where he’d Discussed where he'd gone guard started talk. Discussed talking to to Tim, started talking the way, way, the the security securify guard of the decided I to at that of someone and if he to nature, get get school, things to someone played at that that sports and things of that nature, I decided to school, if he played sports Tim started someone’s could I Before attention, call ambulance. again to get someone's attention, Tim again started point point to call an an ambulance. Before I could gst The security guard trying trying to security guard acting him. The to paranoid as was attacking attacking him. something was as if if someone or something acting paranoid somcone or face. in the him Tim Tim and his him hand calm Security guard on punched guard down, Security punched in the face. him put Tim Tim his hand on and calm him down, tackled occasionally elbowing elbowing him and ground held and occasionally to restrain restrain him down trying trying to held him him down tackled Tim Tim to to the the ground Another called side of his face. We 911. him the left guard and volunteets, and some some volunteers, security guard him on on the left side of his face. TVe called 9l t. Another security held down. A goers from from the festival goers the view view of of festival the golf cart blocking the A golf was moved moved blocking held him him down. cart was with off the their II blocked which time area Until incident. the arrived cars. at they with their off the area cars. police blocked time they incident. Until the police arrived at which as festival were the other with left situation deal the just to police getting police responsibilitiesjust getting as were teft the situation to deal with the other festival responsibilities there. there. I 1 3 4 5 6 8 .-_ 9 l0 ll l2 l3 l4 l4 l5 l6 ló 17 t7 18 18 19 t9 0. Have prior interactionwith Timothy Harden? Harden? Have you had interaction with Timothy had any prior Q drunk was Yes. was acting little drunk He got aa little acting like like as aa patron. He attended the the festival festival last last year as Yes. He He had had attended before an day before this this years few times times aa day with him him aa few an “asshole” nothin g crazy. had worked worked with 'oasshole" but but nothing çrazy. II had event as he set up for for the festival. event as he helped helped set the festival. describe Can please describe Timothy Timothy Harden? Harden? Can you please 20 :i out aa lot. Tim worked out pounds well he worked as if if he well built built as lot. 250/260 pounds Tim was 6'2"1 6’3" 6'3" about about 250/260 was about about 6’2”/ and demeanor. blue Blonde a hair, pleasant pleasant hair, de.meanor. eyes Blonde blue and a anti)? #1 (:,¢;,.;.-JJC.l’estiva1? 6% the been associated have How =e How long long have you been associated wìth rn, u1i,l.1å*"J'rr#*rutt it 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3t 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 4A 41 41 42 42 4') 4'1 with Four manager. am aa founder, and operations operations manager. Four years, II am founder, musician musician and At make any any mention point in mention of the incident incident did did anyone make in time time during during the the day day of of At any any point of the Timothy Harden taking Timothy Harden taking any narcotics? narcotics? A they saw one said said they saw him him take people made he must have but but no no one take must have A lot lot of of people made statements saying he statements saying anything. anything. 0 Please you would he was was under have though though he under the why you lvould have the Timothy's behavior behavior and Please describe describe Timothy’s and why of influence narcotics? influence of narcotics? He were under having conversations conversations he was was having paranoid as frorn above; above; he if he attack from He was was acting acting paranoid as if he were under attack there. that and not to to were people sky people to that to the were not there. the sky and What give the was being that he he was physically to the impression being impression that Timothy Harden Harden doing doing physically to give What was was Timothy attacked from above? from above? attacked He cover. ducking. looking looking upward was ducking. trying to to find upward trying find cover, He was .t. /42 lu Prosecutor's 139 File C( 139 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 41 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1178 O"\'t—-‘nvy_.\0lUI.hvJ )_c©°¢‘o“§L’t I I Statement Benjamin Bleefeld Bleefeld of Benjamin Statement of Page of66 Page 44 of Q. J his elbow elbow aa few jabbed him with his few face with guard jabbed the face in the Yes, him in Tim aa security restraining Tim security guard while restraining Yes, while face. in the that the it times, got punched punched in the face. guard that got security guard was the security times, it was 4 5 6 Can Tim? strike Tim? witnessed strike guard that please describe that you witnessed describe the the security security guard Can you please 7 E He tattoos, he about 5’ 5' 9” 9" and and was was a little would say about goatee, tattoos, he was was built, built, II would shaved head, head, a little goatee, He had had aa shaved wearing Gri4*tfrsccurity' shirt. shirt. red (-}1=i££i=ti1-security wearing aa red I l0 I'-'-- cell G‘ ¿+è,çç".^ ll l3 t6 °-5 ‘—'{>4I:wL,;.g‘"“-l>0No\aiuA5 l7 l8 l9 20 WMN 2l P 23 24 25 26 2'Ì 28 29 30 3I 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 g, yd Tim, did guards interacting with Tim, did you interacting with During you witnessed the security security guards time that that you witnessed the the time During the Tim’s restrict airway? observe personnel restrict Tim's airway? guards or or any âny personnel security guards observe any security 12 t4 I5 Tim, did with Tim, did you guards interacting interacting with you witnessed the security security guards During time that that you witnessed the the time During the Tim? strike observe personnel strike Tim? guards or or any personnel security guards observe any security /\ guard had pull him him had to to pull ground, the the security security guard Yes, get him the ground, him to to the trying to to get during the the struggle struggle trying Yes, during that was the It same the punched security guard him was down neck guard punched to to the that was ground. It w¿s the same security by get him down to the ground. by the neck to get in face. in the the face. describe how ground by his neck? Please neck? by his the ground to the guard was Tim down down to was taking taking Tim how the the security security guard Please describe The headlock from from the the side, side, arm like like aa headlock grabbed Tim inside of of his his arm guard grabbed the inside Tim with with the security guard The security Tim. of rolled the and him to on top ground of Tim. ground top dropped rolled on to the and him dropped that you witnessed with Tim, Tim, did did you hear hear guards interacting interacting with During security guards witnessed the the security time that the time During the Tim? the guards say anything anything to to Tim? the security security guards different forms. In many different forms. that In Yes, basically that and basically struggling and stop moving, moving, stop stop struggling down, stop calm down, Yes, calm Tim, did with Tim, did you any guards interacting interacting with During the security security guards time that that you witnessed witnessed the During the the time else? the or to Tim hear guards anyone security else? guards anything anyone or say the to security anything hear Tim was saying he was not stop, stop, he saying it it but he he did Cid not I'll stop; Yes, stop you’re stop; but you're hurting please stop hurting me, l’l1 stop, please said stop, Yes, said but fighting. but continued continued fighting. What him? restrain him? guards were to restrain were trying trying to security guards Tim's actions actions whilethe while the security were Tim’s What were and fight He to try and fight ground and and continuing continuing to guards off the ground off the security guards the security was kicking, kicking, lifting lifting the He was them. them. 39 40 m. 4l 42 43 d 43<2» Prosfiors ,or&o P r's File File 0140 140 Filed 08/04/16 Page 42 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1179 \-IN—._,Ol‘.A-I:LaJ)u—cg°¢,_h l' 7 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 il Statement of Benjamin Statement of Benjamin Bleefeld Bleefeld Page Page 55 of6 of6 Q. Can guards? the security please describe with the security guards? Can you please describe Tim’s Tim's demeanor demeanor during during his his interaction interaction with He life. fighting for for his his life. He looked looked scared. He looked looked like was fighting scared. He like he he was How arrive did police arrive How long long after after police did you remain remain on scene? on the the scene? About minutes. About five five minutes. Did Timothy Harden the incident? police offlcers during the incident? with'Iimothy Harden during Did you observe officers interacting interacting with observe any police t2 direction but Not see any interaction. interaction. directly. II saw didn't see Not directly. saw them them run run over over in in that but II didn’t that direction I3 t4 t5 Did pull into event? Did you observe observe any ambulances ambulances pull into the the event? l6 l7 r8 t9 '0 2A i' ;. 23 24 back to Yes, pull in it was was heading heading directly directly towards towards the Yes, II saw saw it as II was to the the festival festival it the it pull in as was walking walking back site of the incident. site of the inoident. at this Is else you would this time? time? Is there there anything like to to add add to statement at anything else would like to your statement observed the Yes. quickly to police worked to put out out an an incident incident Yes. From what II observed the security and police worked quickly From what security and their work. I feel them both that and commend that could have much I been on worse that could have been much worse and I cornmend them both on their work, I feel that both both the was aa danger Tim was danger to police walked to both both the security security and situation. Tim and police walked into into aa very dangerous dangerous situation. himself himself and and others everyone handled handled it accordingly. others and and that that everyone it accordingly. 25 26 27 28 29 30 3t 32 33 34 35 36 JI 38 39 40 4l 42 41 .t 45 Proseggfis 0‘ s File File 41 Filed 08/04/16 Page 43 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1180 _kJw._,-O\Dl<.n:;L,)[Qo°‘U“hJ’ Statement of of Benjamin Benjarnin Bleefeld Bleefeld Statement Page Page 66 of of66 'l 7 3 4 5 Is this time? time? at this statement at like to to add add to to your statement else you would would like there anything anything else Is there No. No. 6 7 I 2015; 9:15 TYPING P'M' 9:15 PM. 22,2015; Septembet 22, TIME: September DATE AND TIME: TYPING CONCLUDED CONCLUDED - DATEAND — 9 l0 l1 l2 STATEMENT SITNATURE REVIEW AND AND SIGNATURE STATEMENT REVIEW l3 t4 l5 II have initials including including bears my initials each page bears consisting of of 66 pages; each statement consisting have read read this this statement facts the that and contained certify that the facts contained handwiting; and II certify in my own own handwriting; any corrections initialed in corrections initialed herein hereín are are true. kue. l6 l7 DATE AND TIME: TIME: DATE AND e? ___._,a»« 2 t8 l9 20 21 feld 23 24 24 1q 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 LHUuJ.:K>QvIm‘3 30 3t 32 33 34 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Offïce 331 Q Q ¡ rSJ L‘§3--~ I Detective Rosendo Perez Rosendo Perejz Prosecutor's Momnouth cc County Prosecutor's ( ll‘: ce County Monmouth 35 Prosecutor's File 0142 C 42 Prosecutor's File Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 44 of 100 PagelD: 1181 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: Michael Johnstonc ADDRESS TELEPHONE N0: -- Belmur, New Jersey [0 1] DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: -- 12 Mnnmoulh Medical Center I3 tr SOCIAL SECURITYNUMBER: - "HombuN ts It: AKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 17 132 Jerseyville Avenue l8 Freehold. New Jersey 0772872374 lg 20 QUESTIDNED BY: Delecfive Daniel Bozza 21 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office WITNESSED BY: Detective Rosendo Perez 24 Mnnmoutlt County Prosecutor's Office 15 26 TYPED BY: Rose Gullno 27 Monmouth County Prosecumr's Office 23 29 DATE Tuesday, September 22. ZOIS: 6:40 RM. so 3| 32 Michael Johnstone, I am Detective Danicl Bozza of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's 33 Office and present here is Detective Rosendu Perez of the same office. It is our duty to ask 34 yr"! questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident that occurred at the 35 Priediane located at 1017 Route 33. Freehold, New Jersey involving Timothy Harden on 36 September 5, 20l5l 37 38 This statement must be a voluntary one. given of your own free will and mid, withuut 39 any thrcals Or promises. knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law. 40 42 Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at this time? 41 44 Yes. My What is your age? EXHIBIT a MCPO Prosecutor's @713 Filed 08/04/16 Page 45 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1182 ~Nm._,°\'‘“:"8O0lcnJ>u )._ Statement of Michael Michael Johnstone Staternent of Johnstone Page Page22 of7 ofT I ., 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 33. JJ. What is is your occupation? occupation? lVhat Solar Solar engineer. engineer. What What is formal education? education? is your formal l0 Trade. Trade. 12 Are Are you married? manied? ll l3 l4 No. No. l5 t6 Can English Language? Language? Can you read, read, write write and and understand understand the the English l7 l8 l9 Yes. Yes, 2A 2t l 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 3J 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 42 42 43 43 45 45 Calling your attention located at at 1017 the Priediane Priediane located l0l7 Route Route Calling your to the that occurred occu¡red at at the attention to the incident incident that Harden New can on 5, 2015, 33, September 5,2415, can you involving Timothy Timothy Harden on September 33, Freehold, Freehold, New Jersey Jersey involving please please tell this incident. incident. have of of this tell us us in in your own what knowledge knowledge you have own words words what II originally was volunteering at the the Soupergroove Soupergtoove Event. Event. II was was originally under under the the assumption that II was volunteering at assumption that to there ifthere be medical sober and to was a patron and if there was any medical emergencies respond to to them them and there to be a sober patron emergencies to respond and deal previous certification in EMT EMT 2001-2010. 2001-2010. certification in with them them to to the the best of my rny abilities, abilities, II had had aa previous deal with best of II was was aa volunteer gate and the front was berating front gate and may was told told that that there that was berating patrons at at the there was volunteer that told that I I front have instructor the at was a believe, by gate. possibly groped yoga gate. have possibly groped a I was told that by I believe, Leni Leni at instructor at the front at who informed Phil festival Ladue I the and the front into went me across came gate. I went into the festival and came across Phil Ladue who informed me who who the front gate. control and the who was pointed to pointed him to me, he him out out to he pointed the person was was who bit out out of of control and pointed was acting to acting aa bit Tim Tim Harden previous years festivals Soupergroove and festivals of of Soupergroove Tim Harden. from previous and II Harden. II had had known known Tim Harden from remember prior. II approached Tirn, we quite aa bit approached Tim, the year prior. we had had mutual remember Tim Tim was was drinking drinking quite mutual bit the and he into him in to and I manner a so friends, agreed to get ínto my golf my golf friends, and so I approached approached him in a friendly friendly manner and he agreed cart. It seeing golf cart from stage stage to to stage the golf cart between, stage seeing cart, It was was at at this this time time we we started drive the between, from started to to drive the going on. was aware on. Tim Tim was awâre of that were were going of self, self, time time the different different music music and and different different activities activities that normal skin he had I and noted that color, slight perspiration, good respiration place only and place I noted that he only had slight perspíration, good skin color, normal respiration him and asked me rate. grabbed my poinl when with him and he he grabbed if II wanted wanted to to dance dance with when Tim me if rate. At At one one point Tim asked snuck kind of I noticed I and the him arm to an area pulse rate rate and area at at the tent tent stage stage and I noticed I kínd ofsnuck aa pulse and arm to escort escort him to to an seemed to noticed normal limits. limits. Within pulse and Within the and seemed to be be within within normal the noticed he he had had aa strong strong radial radial pulse had Dave in sat interactions of Tim in at cart some Mahajan golf point having point had Dave Mahajan sat my cart at some in interactions of having Tim in my Tim had was in Dave informed informed that that Tim had taken and Dave passenger seat in viewing viewing distance distance and taken seat while while tim tim was two experience with with LSD Tim had had experience LSD not told me me that that Tim not at around 8:00a.m. Dave Dave told tabs of of LSD LSD at around 8:0Oa.m. two tabs Tim in calm environment time II knew the in aa calm environment this time knew to to keep keep'Iim LSD he he had had taken. taken. It It was was at at this the hippie hippie LSD and the festival festival and peaking so w'e continued to travel travel throughout throughout the and so we continued to and that that II felt felt he he may be be peaking the main Tim 12:45 at At different the we were events. stage area, approximately stage area, seeing Tim seeing the different events. At approximately 12:45 we \¡/ere at the main :3“ /’ Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 144 44 Filed 08/04/16 Page 46 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1183 o=.:8_,\1xus.L>n~_,U“wN I 2 3 4 5 6 7 I I l0 II l2 13 l4 l5 t6 l7 t8 l9xo 20 1' - ;; 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 42 42 41° 4i 45 45 of Michael Statement Michael Johnstone Johnstone Statement of Page of77 Page 33 of and had had no no instances instances him and golf cart watching him dancing in my golf cart watching the side was off off to to the side in dancing and and II was He cart. in was to next while slightly my golf cart. He was slightly me in my volunteer sat sat next to me A volunteer he was was with with me. me. A while he him think I said that I to his don’t know I name. black him hair, to I think I said that curly glasses, long glasses, his name, overweight, don't know I hair, long black curly overweight, and him in his to the LSD of effects from the down be keep Tim this is at and to keep him in hís coming the LSD of point may be coming down from the effects Tim is at this point have him in him but to follow to minutes not fifteen for the radar so next or necessarily radar for the next fifteen minutes o¡ so not to necessarily follow him but to have him in eye shot with Tim Tim II had had been been interaction with minute interaction During the the 45 45 minute was okay. okay. During to make sure Tim Tim was shot to make sure few to and him him a drink cigarettes of to keep bottles water to cigarettes hydrate to few keep keep and a him hydrate given to him gíven him keep him bottles of water to d¡ink escorting bands him to with escorting bands to duties with gate to to continue continue my duties went back back to to the the front front gate him calm. calm, II then then went I minutes about ten Within saw unload their and needed where to park and unload their equipment. equipment. Within about ten minutes I saw where they they needed to park Tim a fast the end cart to to the end of of the the my golf cart pace. II drove drove my fast pace. 33 at af a Tim heading heading toward toward Route Route 33 the festival. into The back Tim to convince come I Priediane. to at was the festival. into The back trying come driveway Tim to I was trying to convince driveway at Priediane. no shoes, whole only been shorts, no shoes, no no wearing aa shorts, been wearing he had had only Tim he was interacting with Tim whole time time II was intþracting with and viewed Tim believe me as a authorityfigure I this socks. At possible authority figure and shin, point I believe Tim viewed me as a possible no socks. At this point shirt, no and he do to made woman and he started started to to got to to find find my woman going to to do whatever II got the comment to do do whatever made the comment Ii going the lot of main west other in the attendants West. The 33 down Route parking parking lot west the run of main parking other parking in the attendants run down Route 33 West. The radioed that entrance yards. Then people's yards. in people’s Then was running running in 33 and and was had run run across across route route 33 that Tim Tim had entrance radioed Route 33 down toward Tim that main was the radioed attendant’s running the gait that Tim was running down Route 33 toward parking attendant's radioed the main gait the parking Route drives aa mid mid 90s who drives 90s Chris who named Chris Tim's friends friends named one of Route 33 33 business business apparently apparently one of Tim’s Tim convinced in to toward driven had full size Tim, get get Tim to convinced in towa¡d Tim, Chevy, pick powder pick up powder blue up had driven blue Chevy, full size the basketball net and festival near into the Tim back Chris drove truck and Chris’s parked parked the basketball near net Chris's truck and Chris drove Tim back into the festival and trail with Tim sitting area. with aa group area/near the the trail the basketball basketball area/near near the area. II then then noticed noticed Tim sitting calmly calmly near of people. else, II encountered encountered parking and whatever else, alrd whatever people. As to deal deal with with the the band band parking drove away to As II drove of of the exhaust the felt she that as had to and she Priscilla me though golf exhaust the golf explained though the of Mahajan as me that she felt to Priscilla Mahajan and she had explained that Priscilla that time at to I for Tim’s have been carts explained a that at that paranoia. trigger to Priscilla time carts may have been a trigger for Tim's paranoia. I explained Tim viewed going to be of of much much help help to to be to the the not going was not an authorityfigure authority figure and and that that II was Tim viewed me me as as an Tim to Chris on that situation. planning on bring bring Tim to the was planning the had then then informed informed me ms that Ch¡is was Priscilla had situation. Priscilla be Tim to Chris that to was coercion under the Medical Centrastate Center bringing going going be bringing to Tim was to that Ch¡is under the coercion CentraState Medical Center he felt how the need intervals random certain Tim at This is because the was he felt stating how the need the airport. airport. This is because Tim was stating at certain random intervals to present when when II was was talking talking airport to was also also present get to Dave Mahajan Mahajan was to an an airport to find find his his lady. lady. Dave to get in the sit Dave to with seat if if Chris Ctuis was was to Dave to sit in the passenger seat suggested to Priscilla Mahajan Mahajan and and II had had suggested with Priscilla the of truck. It out from Tim to Tim the take pick to jumping piek up the of truck. hospital going prevent out It prevent going to to Tim from to take Tim to the hospital and returned the situation left to that at had I bench three seat was a point and retumed my pick point the situation to Ieft up. wâs a three seat bench up. I had at that and unload to load duties At approximately approximately efficiently. At getting them unload efficiently. parking vans vans and load and and getting them to of parking dutíes of had infonned she and Christie 1:30 me that Meyers, she had informed me that toward the was driving driving toward the main main gate and Christie Meyers, 1:30 II was him “this get him out to get that we we got to out of of she said said that and she guy" had in the the festival festíval and 'othis guy” had tackled tackled somebody somebody in was was were present here. present at that were at the the with the the bands bands that gate and to the the front front gate and II finished finished with back to here. II went went back the main trail down and and Tim she that was meant then I driving time. assumíng that she meant Tim and was driving down the main kail and was then assuming time. I was the trail Ben had had aa very came Bleefield. Ben Ben Bleefield. with Ben Route 33 33 with toward Route trail toward Tim walking walking up the carne across across Tim and suggestion was was made nervous made the trail trail and aa suggestion on the to them them on next to stopped next about him. him. So So It stopped nervous look look about trail. I the the down on to stepped and in ride the were for Tim we cart gas to going trail. I stepped on the going go golf down the to for Tim to ride in the golf cart a¡d we were wait and then instead of hold tell to started and Tim then to me the of cart on, instead wait and then of stop, hold of the golf cart and Tim then started to tell me to stop, the climb front of the to over he of cart the side proceeded to climb over the front of the climbing out passenger side of the cart he proceeded out of of the the passenger climbing offered Tim out. Ben cart cigarette, Ben Ben went went to to Tim aa cigarette, then offered Ben then wheel to to get out, the steering steering wheel cart on on top of of the random then and a came his Ben to own went Tim’s camper cigarette a random câmper came light then and cigarette, cigarefte light own light Tim's cigarette, Ben went to light his point Tim then back back handed handed the the Tim then this point which at at this walking up to Ben's lighter lighter which to Ben to ask ask to to use use Ben’s walking Ben to Q 3325 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File I 145 Filed 08/04/16 Page 47 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1184 .-\~:o.—__o\be:ut>LN"<5‘¢°,4;U I 2 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 l0 il t2 13 l4 t5 t6 l7 l8 t9 2A 2l 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 77 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 42 42 43 43 t ohnstone of Michael Statement Michael JJohnstone Statement of Page Page 44 of oî77 aggressively and and Ben Ben said, said, Tim, Tim, camper aggressively towards the the camper caInper’s to walk walk towards and started started to shoulder and camper's shoulder main the and to to decided I this So at gate get gate get here. it’s clam and Tim go the main over point to to point down, I decided okay over here. So at this Tim clam down, it's okay of the for Harden handle Tim safety to of the everyone. come a security guards guards to come handle Tim Harden for the safety of everyone. paid security couple of the paid a couple one of of the the members members II told problems with with one gate we were having having problems security guards guards at we were the main main gate at the tolósecurity back the down the drove I him out. guards said security and down the trail trail there guards back security okay, point the I drove they point him out. there and they said okay, Tim and to were cart off talking and Tim the and Ben I left were talking to Tim where got and guards my Security got cart off where I Ieft Tim and Ben and the Security guards then gate toward Route 33. 33. toward Route main gate toward the the main walking toward then walking that Tim Tim was was in in no no It handled that been handled again been had again the situation that II felt felt the situation had at this this time time that It was was at this I at came of the hands in it point and that distress point was professional. at medical I at this came point and it was in the hands of professional. medical distress at that point of mine park the to park the vans vans and and how to going to across to show show how was going Edgar who who II was mine Ryan Ryan Edgar an associate associate of across an and I children was to have to I going do because going was what I was pick to and my up pick children on going Sunday to going to have was I Sunday do because on what to gate explaining explaining to to front gate to to the the front down to Ryan down was driving driving Ryan for aa few few hours. hours. II was leave for to have have to to leave dust noticed cloud when a the we large of how the details to vans him large dust cloud noticed a park the vans when we briefly the details of how to park him very briefly guards two security security guards by two ground being being restrained restrained by being was on the ground Tim was on the Tim. Tim kicked up up by by Tim. being kicked the off 200 Tim security guard over an and I each guard pound was saw pound off the lifting seourþ one on 200 an over arm, was lifting Tim ârm, and I saw each one on and there blood was nose underneathTim’s blood then I It saw with was and there was blood one arm. nose Tim's ground gtound with one arm. It was tlen I saw blood underneath front gate, II don’t don't at the the front on guard. II was was asked by someone someone at asked by of the the security security guard. the left left shoulder shoulder of on the the block view of kind of Tim to in front cart remember from golf cart in front of Tim to kind of block the view from park my golf please park who, to remember who, to please Tim was where Tim by the security restrained by the security being restrained was being to where people had run n¡n over over to people buying buying tickets. tickets. Ryan Ryan had poh, such as where’s where's JZ JZ at, such as al, and and guards, at that that point, statements at guards, Tim random statements Tim was was saying saying very random breath” and down at calm Tim, “breath him just been had Tim, such just Tim, breath" and so Ryan at calm down telling him "breath Tim, Ryan had been telling such so kicked in his then And shit. this of Ryan said sick I’m Edgar had one point Tim breathing shit, And then kicked Ryan Edgar in his Tim had said I'm sick of this breathing one point Tim’s extremities the lower chest. and crouched crouched extemities and grabbed the half of of Tim's lower half point Ryan Ryan grabbed at that ttrat point chest. Which Which at back in the air with with chest in his Tim’s with Ryan’s the fetal in down back in the air with an legs an Ryan's with position chest down in the fetal position with Tim's legs in his Tim’s that with that noticed had restraining I restrain Tim’s legs even Ryan to Tim's legs that attempt legs. I had noticed that even with Ryan restraining attempt to restrain Tim's legs. of Tim break free whatever trying to in fear fear of Tim causing causing and in free and to break he was was trying movement Tim Tim had had he little movement whatever little and put Tim's knees knees and above Tim’s hands just above placed both of my my hands Ryan both of ir{ury II then then placed Ryan any more more injury and did notice Tim’s movement. came up and what what II Mahajan came notice Dave Dave Mahajan on them to limit limit Tim's movement. II did pressure on them to At that Tim’s torso area. one and he him restrain on was point to point At that was an area. one guess w¿ls an attempt attempt to restrain him and he was on Tim's torso guess had he walked him with another had arrived following officer police one immediately immediately following him he had walked up II police officer had anived with another one told police officer offtcer had had then then told told the police LSD the he had had taken taken LSD was acting acting aggressively aggressively he him this this guy was told him that officer arrived had first The his mike that on. officer make was the police to sure police that officer arived had first The was on, police the police offïcer to make sure that his mike left Tim’s and the to kneeled next ear then and twice least Tim at told to then Tim's left ear and tire resisting at least twice and then kneeled next to stop resisting then told Tim to stop Tim I believe warned twice then And knee. his head with Tim’s side of officer struck of Tim's head with his knee. And then warned Tim I believe twice ofÏicer struck the the side still restraining was still restraining that was wamed everyone that they officer warned going to the officer then the they were were going to spray him him and and then I had that Which noticed at Tim. to point then their and watch Tim point to had at that I noticed Which proceeded spray proceeded to Tim. Tim to watch their eyes and then them directed into and ambulance the walked to I arrived had over ambulance the that directed them into an and an that the ambulance had arrived I walked over to the ambulance directed I them moved had I After Tim. to have where access Tim area they'd have easy access to Tim. After I had them directed I moved to Tim where they’d closes to area closes see the at the they relieved relieved the the as they officers as gate. II did the officers did see parked it main gate. the main it over over at my my car car and and parked Tim turned his to over on the ambulance before and they Tim over came, turned on to his they right Ryan, guards security the ambulance security guards and Ryan, right before the directed ambulance I Afier him. cuff to again I believe and stomach ambulance the were directed again going they stomach and I believe they were going to cufT him, After I and II did the from the anything fiirther. walked away from the further. II walked witness anything did not not witness handled and the situation situ¿tion seemed seemed handled situation the festival. festival. to the and back back to situation and 45 45 /” Prosecutor's File Prosecutor's File 146 Filed 08/04/16 Page 48 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1185 -‘Qkl-—.,ad_G\OPoUe°N—o~Ln\1uc.;>:ng_ Statement Statement of of Michael Michael Johnstone Johnstone Page Page 55 of of?7 Q I 2 He or no no shoes, shoes, no no socks. with no He was was wearing wearing either either dark blue, or or black black shorts shorts with no shirt shirt or socks. He He dark blue, was late 30s. eyes, mid mid to to late 30s. was well well over over 6ó feet feet tall, blonde hair, hair, blue blue eyes, tall, very muscular, muscular, blonde 4 5 Q 6 7 '—‘Iu->. I l0 t2 r3 what do In question you described your response to taking aa “hippie LSD'what In your to the the initial initial question described Tim Tim as as taking "hippie LSD” do LSD”? you mean mean by by “hippie "hippie LSD"? l4 l5 t6 The is much much stronger stronger than The way way it was explained is that hippie tab tab of LSD is it was explained to me is that aa hippie of LSD than aa to me of traditional tab LSD. haditional tâb of LSD. 17 t8 t9 During guards interacting did you witness interacting with with Tim Tim did During the the time time that that you observed witness observed the the security security guards strike other Tim? or security guards personnel guards personnel any security strike Tim? or other 20 ?, II believethat lifting the guard off ground while security while the Tim was off the the ground believe that when when Tim was lifting one security the security the one security guard arm the guard guard was guard may have elbowed Tim Tim on was restraining restraining Tim’s the security have elbowed Tim's left left arm security guard on the the left left of his side with short a jab. jaw jab. side of his with a short 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3I During guards interacting interacting with with Tim Tim did did you witness During the time that that you observed witness the time observed the the security security guards or other airway? guards or any security security guards personnel restrict Tim's airway? rest¡ict Tim’s other personnel No, was on while Tim on his restriction of his arm arm while Tim was his back. saw no no restriction air way only restraining his back. No, II saw of the the air only restraining observed the During guards interacting with Tim Tim did did you hear During the the security security guards interacting with the time time that that you observed hear Tim? to security guards anything guards say any security anything to Tim? 32 ?j 33 JJ 34 34 35 35 the police Not police were guards when asked if if the Tim, II only of the when II asked Not to to Tim, only remember remember one the security security guards were one of said II hope called, going to getting really to be be able able to to hold hope so tired, I’m not going hold him called, they they said so I’m I'm getting I'm not him really tired, 36 36 4') 42 described Tim “peaking” in During question you described as "peaking" in reference reference During your response to Tim as to your initial initial question his of what does mean? LSD to peaking mean? to his ingesting ingesting of LSD what does peaking if you ingest That period of LSD has has a a period ingest LSD, That was was my assumption assumption thathe that he was was “peaking” LSD, LSD of 88 to to "peakingo'if that’s 8 10 hours of those 10 hours and when to in themiddle of I0 hours of hallucinating hallucinating and in the'middle part of those 8 to 10 hours that's when the the hallucination noon time 8am at at noon time is halluc.ination is is the the most most severe was told he took took it it at a t 8am is when when severe and and since since II was told he itit would would be pcak. be at at it’s it's peak. 9 1t 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 Can please describe the incident? Can you please describe Timothy Timothy Harden Harden on the day day of of the incident? on the much much longer. longer. 0 with Tim During guards interacting Tim did did you hear interacting with time that that you observed observed the the security During the the time security guards hear Tim Tim saying saying anything? anything? Random gibberish talk help me; he and where’s where's his his niggas JZ come come help he also also Random gibberish talk about JZ, and niggas at, JZ about JZ, ^t, random statements. the from He grunting grunting from the struggle. yelling aggressively aggressively random statements. struggle. He was was yelling was was ar 45 45 /s:¢g. Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File C 147 Filed 08/04/16 Page 49 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1186 ‘‘QI-—Aua._,°\“J'4=-aI>okxiu.:nt~_ Not directly, discerning. yelling at no one one discerning. was yelling at no he was Not dírectly, he it Did weapons? utilize any weapons? police officers officers utilize observe any police Did you observe I 1 5 4 5 6 7 I 9 'l0 —‘ ohnstone Statement Michael JJohnstone of Michael Statement of Page o177 Page 66 of did you witness witness Tim did with Tim interacting with police officers officers interacting the police During observed the that you observed the time time that During the Tim? police officer strike Tim? officer strike any police police struck struck of the the police The one of when one earlier when mentioned earlier when II mentioned physical strike sâw was was when strike II saw only physical The only knee. his head with the in Tim Tim in the head with his knee. did you witness witness Tim did with Tim interacting with police officers offtcers interacting During the police observed the that you observed the time time that During the restrict Tim’s officer airway? police officer restrict Tim's airway? any police ll contact to There observed. that II observed. neck that to the the neck was no no direct direct contact There was t2 hear the the did you hear Tim did with Tim interacting with police officers offîcers interacting During the police observed the time that that you observed the time During the Tim? to ofticer’s police police officer's saying saying anything anfihing to Tim? l3 t4 l5 ló t7 l8 19 ‘G 20 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3t 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 4A 41 4t 42 42 42 47 and warned him. spray him. going to to spray were going they were twice that that they least twice Stop at least him at warned him resisting and Stop resisting did you hear hear Tim Tim Tim did with Tim police officers interacting with officers interacting During the police observed the the time that you observed time that During the police officers? saying offïcers? to the the police anything to saying anything Tim’s head to him on Tim's head his knee knee on Just prior to him using using his officer prior initial officer the initial Tim the they sprayed sprayed Tim when they Just when it him as witness a not I did but flash using weapon. stick as had it a or a either him using large flash light light but I did not witness night stick or alarge either had aa night Can demeanor? please describe office¡'s demeanor? desuibe the the ofticer’s Can you please one had though any one intention of of hurting hurting had any intention as though Very seem as professional. It It didn’t didn't seem and professional. Very calm calm and Tim Tim Did it to? to? directed it the area area you directed from the ambulance move move from the ambulance Did you observe observe the No. No. 2001/2010, during during Earlier in from 2001/2010, Certified from EMT Certified were EMT your narrative mentioned you were narrative you mentioned in your Earlier EMT an as this event acting officiaily as an EMT this event were were you actingofficially II was capacity. in no no official ofhcial capacity. was there there in 4 45 45 /4 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File d 148 48 Filed 08/04/16 Page 50 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1187 O1t\J—-_.\l’LI-bhié—©%tJ.§;a[) I 2 3 ohnstone Statement of Michael JJohnstone of Michael Statement of7 7 Page Page I ot t Is time? at this this time? statement at to your statement add to would like like to to add else you would anlthing else Is there there anything No. No. 4 5 6 7 8 I ?‘l0 Il 8:00 P.M. 2015; 8:00 TYPINGCONCLUDED P.M. 22,2015; Septembet 22, TIME: September DATE AND TIME: TYPING CONCLUDED * DATEAND * l2 l3 14 l5 t6 t7 r8 .eW SIGNATURE STATEMENT AND SICNATURE REVIEW AND STATEMENT REVIEW including II have initials including bears my initials consisting of each page bears of 77 pages; each this statement statement consisting have read read this facts contained thatthe and I initialed in certify corrections own handwriting; facts contained the any corrections initialed in my own handwriting; and I certify that herein herein are are true. true. t9 :l IQQkUnbgl 2o' DATE AND TIME: 23 24 25 26 Mi 27 27 28 28 Johnstone 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 34 35 36 36 37 37 38 [)<.'.tecli\' * . mel BI-)ZZ-8Bazza &4é Monmouth Offìce County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Monmouth County vr Detective Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Perez Office Monmouth County Prosecutor Office Pro Monmouth County 39 39 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0149 0 49 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 51 of 100 PagelD: 1188 <<459'STATEMENT STATEMENT or: Joseph Zimmerman ADDRESS TELEPHONE NO: -- East Brunswick, NJ 08816 C: DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: Livingston, NJ SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: - TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 132 Avenu: Freehold, New Jersey 07728 QUESTIONED BY: Detective Danicl Buzza Monmouth Counly Prosecutor's Office WIT NESSED BY: Detective Brian Weisbmt Monmouth County Prusaculor's Office TYPED BY: Autumn Monmouth County Office DATE September 22, 2015 9:29 AM. Joseph Zimmerman, I am Detective Daniel B0222 of tile Monmuulh Counly Pmsecutnr's Office and present here is Detective Brian Weisbrol of the same office, It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances sunounding the incident Ihat occurred at the Priediane [ucaled at 1017 R1. Freehold. NJ involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2015. This statement must be a voluntary onc. given of your own free will and accord, without any threats or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law, Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at this time? Yes. EXHIBIT 7 Prosecutor'@ 50 Filed 08/04/16 Page 52 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1189 o>I;r-u—.hayqc\m.>t)zr t2 13 t4 l5 16 l7 t8 $\DOlUu.§h3)_ t9 2^ 2. 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3l 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 4? >- 28. 28. >9 A Paramedic Paramedic for for MONOC. MONOC. (3 What formal education? education? is your formal What is What occupation? What is is your occupation? Certificate County College. College. Degree from from Union Certificate Degree Union County > >C >0 a 0 Are Are you married? maníed? No. No. Can English Language? the English Language? read, write write and understand the and understand Can you read, Yes. Yes. attention to at 1017 1017 Rt. Rt. 33, Calling located at 33, the Priediane Priediane located to the the incident that occurred occurred at at the incident that Calling your attention in tell us Harden NJ on 2015, please Freehold, please tell us in your own own 5,2015, Timothy Ha¡den on September Freehold, NJ involving involving Timothy September 5, words incident. of this this incident. what knowledge knowledge you have have of words what On to respond respond to call to radio call to the the received aa radio Hoffinan and and II received day, my partner, Jeremy Jeremy Hoffman On that that day, the contact control to advised We location for mentioned were a problem. We were advised to contact the control psychiatric problem. mentioned location for a psychiatric center, partner contacted was driving. driving, He because II was contacted them them because He My partner which is is our our dispatch dispatch center. center. My center, which with the assistance behavioral that the Police advised our were on scene was requesting the with behavioral assistance requesting our Police on were scene was advised that the They stated that the the patient patient stated that patient on to be be sedated. sedated. They who needed needed to emergency of the the patient on location location who emergency of the location in to route went location. From and we combative was there, we went in route to the location and and fighting on on location. From there, was combative and fighting arrived who directed directed us greeted by Police Officer, Offìcer, who us Howell Police were greeted by aa Howell that incident. incident, We We were anived at at that towards the patient. patient. towards the Once as well well as as Howell Howell Department, as Township Police Police Department, we noticed on scene, sc€ne, we noticed Howell Howell Township Once on the of Howell Officer Police Township gf,eetcd by by an an Officer of the Howell Police was greeted EMS Division. Division. II directly directly was Township EMS and needed combative and to altered the stated that who was needed patient and to be be patient and combative Department, was altered that the stated Department, who medical command for contacted he with discussion sedated. After a medical command partner, quick partner, for he contacted my sedated. After a quick discussion with my patient. of the the patient. the direction direction of towards the possible possible orders turned my attention attention towards then turned orders for for sedation. sedation, II then him of could All I was his see stomach. The that he he ground, on on his stomach. All I could see of him was that patient was was found found on on the the ground, The patient and there in handcuffs his behind were hands in his covered back, were placed and dirt, was placed there in handcufß were back, were behind his in dirt, hands was covered his where Ii was the patient. was standing, sunding, II could could to where patient. Due Due to multiple surrounding the on location, location, surrounding Officers on multiple Officers down. chest from his half of the the lower observe patient, from his chest down. only only observe the lower half of the patient, .D4, Prosecutorélgfig D151 Prosecuto,.'(ùA) ( 151 Filed 08/04/16 Page 53 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1190 Statement of of Joseph Joseph Zimmerman Zimmerman Statement Date: 22, September 201 5 Date: September 22, 2015 Page Page:3 0O\Io-.v«4:uy_) II advised Support) crew, from Howell is the the ambulance ambulance from Howell (Basic Life which is crew, which the BLS BLS (Basic Life Support) advised the in him the could stretcher the the assess to we so on the stretoher so we could assess him in the back Township, back of of the the place the patient patient on Township, to place the of towards back ambulance. patient towards the back of the the we moved moved the the patient beìng done, done, we ambulance. As As that that was was being that the noticed was and ambulance. When showing agonal patient patient approached was showing agonal partner partner noticed that the my ambulance. When approached and and which indicated stops beating beating and respirations, heart stops possible cardiac or when when your heart cardiac arrest, arrest, or indicated possible respirations, which aren’t breathing on own. you aren't breathing on your own. I 2 3 4 5 6 ,I Once pulse and via mechanical mechanical pulse and confirmed via we confirmed back of ambulance, we Once we we were were in of the the ambulance, in the the back his and not did have on was own. not cardiac that the breathing a pulse and was not breathing on his own. patient did not have a pulse cardiac monitor, monitor, that the patient CPR arrived at point up until the time tíme we we arrived at the the hospital hospital From that until the initiated immediately. that point CPR was was initiated immediately. From Cardiac CPR and and care (Advanced Cardiac Life Life Support) Support) to the and ACLS ACLS (Advanced was transferred the ER ER staff, staff, CPR and care was transfened to protocols protocols were continued. were continued. I I 10 l0 ll II 12 )2 I3 l3 14 l4 15 I5 I6 r6 17 1? 18 l8 I9 t9 2!‘ 2ß i'1x": 1a 22 23 23 a It’s It's aa little liule more more than than 2 2 years. What position at yourposition is your at MONOC? MONOC? What is A Care Paramedic. My Paramedic. My technical is MobileIntensive Mobile Intensive Care technical title title is a Did for his position? receive training Did you receive training for his position? Yes. Yes. 24 24 25 25 Could Care Paramedic Pa¡amedic with with Intcnsive Care please describe duties and roles as as aa Mobile Mobile Intensive describe you duties and roles Could you please MONOC? MONOC? 26 26 27 27 28 28 Some is fimctional functional on on aa daily daily equipment is that my my equipment responsibilities are are ensuring ensuring that Some of of my job responsibilities certifications all of I have have do basis. I to job. I have all of my certifications up up to to date, date, adequate supplies supplies to do my job. basis. I have adequate properly ambulance is is properly making that my ambulance sure that have to rnake sure expire or to make none expire or lapse. lapse. II have making sure sure none our medications medications are that our are not running problems. II have to ensure not have to ensure that and functions fr.mctions without without problems. running and is it to On for a be and basis, use. job provide to daily my provide appropriate for use. On a daíly basis, it is to expired expired and appear to be appropriate advanced setting, patients in hospital setting. to patients in the the pre hospital life support support to advanced life 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4t 4? 42 4 How with MONOC? MONOC? How long long have have you been been employed employed with <0 Please of the the incident? incident? the day day of to on on the were assigned assigned to which MONOC vehicle you were Please identify identify which MONOC vehicle .> We also 204. was also 204, number was our unit unit number an ambulance. ambulance. And And our which is is an were in in vehicle vehicle 204, 204, which We were ‘.0 Who that day? day? your medical doctor on on that command doctor was your medical command Who was .> A. Without physicians that that we we use The physicians use as as remember. The can't remember. the chart, chart, II can’t to reference reference the being able able to Without being Medical Israel Center. Beth Newark in medical command are are emergency physicians in Newark Beth Israel Medical Center. room physicians emergency room medical command 44 44 Prosecutor's Prosecutol, @0152 @c 52 Filed 08/04/16 Page 54 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1191 Om_.,\l(JI-&LA.) ~s_©o°9‘nbt Statement Zimmerman of Joseph Joseph Zimmerman Statement of Date: 22, September 201 5 Date: September 22, 2015 Page Page 4a Can the scene? scene? please describe patient that located at at the that was was located Can you please describe the the patient I 2 A 3 4 What observe the on scene? scene? patient doing while while you were were on What did did you observe the patient 5 6 A 7 I ._ 9 1l Not Not to to my knowledge. knowledge. a ambulance in When particular area‘? in any particular park the area? the ambulance to park When you arrived on scene, were were you directed directed to aríved on t5 No. No. l6 “"’*-‘°No\mt\Jc:.~a:mq_¢°)‘U&wS .>0?rQ t7 l8 ac a I9 2î [¿g1 .,', 23 24 25 26 27 28 -PI‘3:14lumL.2wi_-)ql>,'M;—oxcq 29 30 a 3¡ 32 33 34 a J) 36 3'. 38 39 42 At yor¡r partner pâJtner directed point in directed to to relocate relocate or your were you or At any any point in time while you were were on on scene, were time while your ambulance? ambulance? No. No. in scene, you were were met at the the scene, met a:rival at description of the incident, that upon arrival In your description of the incident, you stated stated that combative. What by What did patient was and combative. was altered altered and did he he that stated that the the patient hy aa Police Políce Officer Officer that stated that altered? mean by mean by altered? does Altered patíent does that the the patient Meaníng that mental status; status; Meaning to aa neurological neurological state state of of altered altered mental Altered refers refers to not behaviors. with typical typical behaviors. in aa manner manner congruent congruent with not appear appear to to be be acting acting in Approximately the incident? incident? the scene of the how long long were were you at at the scene of Approximately how Without 25 minutes. minutes. 20 to to 25 approximately 20 would say approximately Without referring refening to to the chaf directly, directly, II would the chart observe? When you arrived on scene, how did you observe? arrived on Police Officers Offrcers did how many Police When what II recall, 7. From that were were Police Officers Offïcers that Approximately it was was approximately approximately 55 Police From what recall, it Approximately 7. restrain the to patient. attempting attempting to restrain the patient. 0 a the Police How cers restraining patient? restraining the the patient‘? Officers How were were the Police Offi A. Officer at on scene. II can’t recall seeing seeing II Officer at the the only recall scene. II only Officer on to the the actions actions of of every Officer can't speak speak to in the hold his hands to place. patient or piace. patient using shoulder, in patient’s patient's right right arm, using his hands to hold the right shoulder, or right 40 4t Q::> A t3 l4 CH’ OM» ?o'»{\>( From his shoulders shoulders from with his from movement with rocking movement From what what,I recall,/the ,r#tfrffi patient wus making aa rocking situation. free of the break be left in what to to an to attempt situation. right appeared free of the break right what be an attempt to left to in appeared to Have patient? previous interactions with this this patient? ever had had any previous interactions with Have you ever t0 t2 From pounds. 180-200 pounds. approximately 180-200 weighing approximately tall Caucasian Caucasian male male weighing what II recall, recall, he he was was aa tall From what 4. 44 Q; Prosecutor's Prosecutor's ' 0:153 c 53 Filed 08/04/16 Page 55 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1192 oh—I-£> a._\«.n4>wr_V,°O‘UbN o:> Statement of Joseph Statement of Joseph Zimmerman Zimmerman Date: Date: September September 22, 22, 2015 201 5 Page Page 5s a anything to patient? to the the patient? During Police Officers Officers say anything During your time on scene, did did you hear hear the the Police time on > A Not ¡ecall, that II can can recall. Not that a to either either the patient say anything to the Police Police During you hear say anything your time hea¡ the the patient During your time on on scene, scene, did did you A Not Not that that II can can recall. recall. l0 a patient? the patient‘? strike the During Officers strike your time Police Officers During your time on did you observe observe any Police on scene, did l2 A No. No. a Did weapons while while they they utilize any any weapons you observe scene utilize Offìcers on on scene Did you observe any any Police Police Officers the with interacting with the patient? patíenl? interacting A No. No. a observe the At anyone? patient spit at anyone? point during spit at the incident the patient At any point during the incident did did you observe A. No. No. a Officers restrict observe any During the airway airway of restrict the scene, did of the the did you observe any Police Police Officers During your time time on on scene, patient? patient? A. No. No. a Were patient?' your partner to the the patient?‘ partner able administer the the sedation sedation to Were you or to administer or your able to A obtained orders No. so because we obtained the time time we orders realized in in between between the No. We were not not able to do do so because we we realized We were able to in '*nt the cardiac that was the do time and the possible moved, so was possible being was in cardiac patient was being moved, that the to do so and the ti¡ne the patient .S'D« ‘\'D do -to so, so '\-l~ ånest, S0 r+ t,Uu$ dc: rÅrUS (\O\arrest‘ f\gt l 2 3 4 5 6 Officers Officers or or medical medical staff‘? staff? 1 8 I ll 13 t4 t5 "l)>—-aA3\O I ló t7 l8 19 2ß wmroxnus-4:8 !\ 2 I22 x.) I\) 23 24 2s 26 'J>.l\?A-L‘©»uOwlg:kV.JIj4 27 28 29 30 3l (\€,(‘,€-S"; (L0-bl t\¿LeSS¿o0¿,[ 32 33 Did your treatment patient? the patient? Did you document document your treatment of of the 34 3s 36 A. II personally was the the authorof author of partner, Jeremy Hoffrnan, was Jeremy Hoffman, personally did document anything. an¡hing. My My partner, did not not document the the Patient Patient Care Care Report. Report. .l scene? Did patient while were on on scene? while you were with the interacting with the patient Secruity Guards Guards interacting Did you observe observe any Security A. Not recall. that II recall. Not that 3',l 38 39 40 41 were were 42 A4 Prosecutor's Prosecutor, Pile P U 154 154 Filed 08/04/16 Page 56 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1193 °"“'‘\IOU-4:ust>.— Statement of Statement of Joseph Joseph Zimmennan Zimmerman Date: Date: September 22, 2015 201 5 September 22, 6 Page Page 6 How interacting with who were were interacting with the How would would you describe describe the demeanor of the Police Police Officers Officers who the the demeanor of the I (LpmwJI«>LAt\-—Qo°]‘h§Blr.x)_, patient? patient? 2 3 Q?) and wa(L and in — W(l ¢i2I/corned Si'I_Y, waste it was that they professionalism and was they showed II woqþ-.,say, it vras in no was my opinion no showed nothing nothing but but professionalism opinion rhat the were interacting patient. patient. watc$#íderned with with how how tlicy they were interacting with the with Is there Ihcre anylhing like to ls anything you would at this this time? to add statement at time? would likc add to to your statement A 6 7 No. No. I 9 "‘l0 ll 12 TYPING 22, 2015 10:11 10:11 A.M. A.M. CONCLUDED - DATEAND TYPING CONCLUDED DATE AND TIME: September22,2015 TIME: September l3 —— t4 l5 STATEMENT REVIEW AND STATEMENT REVIEW AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE 16 l7 t9 II have initials including have read bears my rny initials including any read this this statement statement consisting consisting of each page bears of 66 pages; each facts initialed corrections in that the and I herein are contained herein corections initialed in my own certify that the facts contained own handwriting; handwriting; and I certify are 2^ true. true. r8 >»o ~ ),N 23 DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: 24 t)4 ZZ ZPtå 6” I075? fl\7%iL{\"5 l,Õl:7 25 26 2'.1 28 29 30 3I ,___._ 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 _ -r="-'7" ~ , _ /?6 elective a ve Du Monmouli County Prosecutor's County Prosecutor's Office Ofïice ' ' þt7 Q/r/vgi û*M/ ti? Detective Detective BriTan.Weisbrot Brian Weisbrot 2 Z Monmouth County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Monmouth County Offi ce 4t 4? File 0155 Prosecutor's 155 Prosecutor's File Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 57 of 100 PagelD: 1194 whether.>> 40' STATEMENT STATEMENT 01": Joseph Wocio ADDRESS TELEPHONE N0: -- icksuu New Jersey 08527 J1 machete New Jersey SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Offioc 132 Jerseyville Avenue Freehold, New Jersey 07728-2374 DATE Kc PLACE OF BIRTH: QUESTIONED BY: Dflefln'e Daniel Bozza Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office WITNESSED BY: Detective Daniel Newman Monmoulh County Prosecutor's Office TYPED BY: Rose Gulino Monmoulh County Prosecutor's Office DATE Kc TIME: Monday, September 21, 2015; 6:06 RM. Joseph Wocio, I am Detective Daniel Bozza oflhe Monmoulh County Prosecutor's Office and present here is Detective Daniel Newman of the same office. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident that occurred ul the Priediane located at l017 Route 33. Freehold, New Jersey involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2015, This statement must be a voluntary one, given of your own free will and accent without any threats or promises. knqwing that what you say may be used in a Court of Law. Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at [his time? sxmarr Prosecutor's File 0 56 Filed 08/04/16 Page 58 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1195 %*-"93;—._\IO§4D-La l}u_.$J“h>"k)‘ I of Joseph Statement Joseph Wocio Wocio Statement of Page Page 2z of7 otl (.1 2 24. 24. 4 What \iVhat is occupation? is your occupation? 5 6 Powerwashing Powerwashing 7 8 What is your formal education? What is formal education? I l0 Graduate college and vocational school. school. of vocational two years of of college and two high school, school, three three years of Graduate from from high ll t2 Are Are you married? maníed? l3 l4 No. No. t5 16 >-bJ§«l>&U2L)u.pg,;-'-C'rO 28 29 30 3l 32 JJ 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 Abel} 41 > described? just .iust described? No, No, II do do not. not. involyed Can described? incident you just described? in the the incident guards involved in please describe describe the the security security guards Can you please I I53. 0 I45,’ ,-. r ,.ll The 'fhe one full tattoos tattoos sleeves two full sleeves had two and had set and bot(heavy set guard was five/nine, bcrltlfheavy was about about five/nine, security guard one security dark skinned, second one one was short black arms. The black on heavy set, set, dark skinned, short tall, heavy over 66 feet feet tall, was over The second both arms. on both withred back the said that on shirts lettering. had both hair. lettering. “security” with red on the back yellow yellow "security" They that said shirts hair. They both had happen? During did anything else significant signifïcant happen? anything else shift did During your shift Yes. Yes, 42 Can this date? date? on this was significant significant on that was please describe what else else happened happened that describe what Can you please 43 1:.4 towards the The commotion, of commotion. and a a bunch bunch of woods and the woods guards running running off ofitowards security guards The security &45(II ,f_I'~Vr 4 -t'"' Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 00 158 58 Filed 08/04/16 Page 60 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1197 "mro_.°‘U3'-90O\olI>Lnts.)_ I Statement Wocio of Joseph Joseph Wocio Statement of Page of77 Page 44 of Q. 2 Yes. Yes. 3 4 5 Q. 6 I guards were doing were doing the security security guards From what the see what standing, were to see able to were you able were standing, where you were From where after the woods? woods? ran towards towards the they ran after they 9 "‘l0 ll No view. blocking my view. were blocking all the the cars cars were not, all No II could could not, l2 l3 able to guards were were doing? doing? security guards what the the security From hear what to hear were you able wore standing standing were where you were From where l4 l5 “calm the then that’s that's and then stop" and relax, stop” relax, relax, II heard fuck down, down, relax, the fuck guards say say "calm the security security guards heard the heard I didn’t after that anything. and after when that, and after that I didn't heard anything. heard the the bang bang after that, when II heard r6 -oxca t'1 l8 saying “calm fuck down, down, the fuck guards saying "calm the security guards hear the the security Approximately did you hear what time time did Approximately what relax, stop?" relax, stop?” t9 20 21 girlû'iend got Because my girlfriend It 3:00pm. Because and 3:00pm. 2:00pm and of 2:00pm the hours hours of been between between the have been to have It had had to it and work after work and it happened after she right after she and came happened right of work out right after the concert concert right to the came to 2:00 and at 2:00 out of work at arrived. anived. 2 23 Nix) 24 25 o'calm the relax, down, relax, fuck down, the fuck yelling “calm Can you please guards were were yelling please tell if the the security security guards me if tell me Can 26 stop?” stop?" 27 28 Yes, hear otherwise. otherwise. to hear be able able to Yes, II wouldn't wouldnnt be 29 30 just one or was yelling? Were one yelling? it just yelling or was it guards yelling security guards Were both both security 3l J¿ different voices. voices. two different It like two sound like it didn’t didn't sound which one, it not sure sure which f 'm not It was was just one, I’m 33 34 35 -‘NOko Q. 36 38 40 4l 42 at? two security able to yelling at? Were guards were were yelling security guards the two to see see who who the Were you able No. No. 37 39 woods? the woods? Do towards the guards were running towards were running security guards why the the security know why Do you know No, moment. the moment. at the didn't know know at No, II didn’t 7 mw~4oxu-.mwrq_Q\°,c‘UA{3 "—;I>-~J.l»:Ls described earlier? Were earlier? guards you described security guards the same same security they the Were they Q-. physical altercation altercation with with able to in aa physical Were with in guards were were involved involved with security guards to see if the the security see if Were you able anyone? anyone? able to No to see. see. wasn't able No II wasn’t 43 ¿ J:45on Prosecutor‘; F-îre Ol o 59 s9 Prosecutàr! file Filed 08/04/16 Page 61 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1198 —-O\DolsLIJ:.y[_) Statement Wocio Statement of of' Joseph Joseph Wocio Page Page 55 of7 of7 down, relax, relax, yelling “calm the fuck fuck down, guards yelling Approximately "câlm the were the the security security guards how long long were Approximately how relax, stop?” relax, stop?" I ) 3 lasted 20/30 II only seconds, then thump and the bang bang or or thump and II then II heard heard the 20130 seconds, it once, once, it it lasted heard him him say it only heard showed didn’t the cops showed up. that and and then then the anlthing else else after after that hear anything didn't hear 4 5 6 n O. 8 Rik:-4»u—_“©\O°lKI1.hL;)[ I The than 15 15 it it didn’t didn't take take later no no more more than ten minutes minutes later police arrived to ten five to about maybe maybe five The first first police anived about then several other showed ambulance the of minutes later to a up up then several other there, long get there, a couple couple of minutes later the ambulance showed long to get officers anived, officers arrived. ~il—._- l0 12 t3 14 (.1. l5 Were subject that that security security the unknown unknown subject police had with the had with see any interaction interaction the the police able to to see Were you able with? was was dealing dealing with? l8 l9 20 No the whole whoie police vehicles were blocking blocking the and ambulance ambulance were the police all the vehicles and No because because all 2', area a¡ea with with their their vehicles. vehicles, ¿ 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 arrived on Do on scene? scens? ambulances arrived how many ambulances Do you know know how II want two. more than than two. three, II know know there there was was more want to tCI say three, 27 27 did they When go directly directly to to where where the they go the pulling into area did into the the area ambulances pulling the ambulances observed the When you observed 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3r 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 security guards were were initially? initially? security guards past the they backed booth area, they backed ticket booth the ticket They the grass past and drove drove on on the pulled in in the the driveway driveway and They pulled where on. into the was going on. everything was going area where everything into the area Were subject? the unknown unknown subject? police were to the were saying saying to what the the police able to to hear hea¡ what Were you able No, police say anything. the police anything. hear the No, II didn’t didnot hear 36 JO 45 45 Do on the the scene? scene? police department showed up on what police department showed know what Do you know II don't don’t know. know. l6 t7 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 43 43 guards the security security guards heard the first heard when you first Approximately between when time lapsed lapsed between how much much time Approximately how arrived? until the at yelling police arrived? yelling at someone someone until the police left the From time you left the area area did to the the time did the woods woods to run towards towards the security run time that that you saw saw security the time From the the unknown hear anything? subject you hear the unknown subject say anything? No. No, Q. occurred? incident occurred? this incident where this Approximately from where were you from how far far away were Approximately how II would good with with distance. distance. not good I'm not 200 feet, feet, but but I’m more than than 200 no more would say no )\\:~.J \,'J Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 00 160 60 Filed 08/04/16 Page 62 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1199 _‘?\}I)-—A._.ox,\i2:L»q'5°,‘UmN Statement Wocio of Joseph Joseph Wocio Statement of Page otl7 Page 6ø of I 2 Were able to to Were you able 4 6 7 ambulances on and the scene? on scene? police and the ambulances the police were the Approximately how long long were Approximately how premises. They They were were the premises. around the walking around 6:00 walking They at approximately approximately 6:00 left at there when when II left were there They were what were know doing. I don’t they their note with around doing. were they pads, know what pads, I don't walking watking around with their note I I l0 ll l2 Were propcrly? left the the property? ambulances left the ambulances if any of of the able to to see see if Wcre you able l3 14 went into ambulances or into the the left, II went or police because II left, No leave because police officers officers leave any ambulances see any No Ii didn’t didn't see hours. about two for festival in the 1 festival. was festival. I was in the festival for about two hours, l5 16 t7 arrived? police anived? the police after the incident after this incident to observe observe this able to Approximately were you able long were how long Approximately how l8 19 But when when II was was band. But About see aa band. to see the festival festival to went into into the then II went and then to 30 30 minutes minutes and About 20 20 to and took me to came officers the of festival me one the my up into to and took leave to go into the festival one of the officers came up going going to to leave to go 20 2t 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 32 33 33 if incident? of this this incident? result of as aa result to anyone as rendered to was rendered aid was if first first aid couldn't see see was was reason II couldn’t The reason No see the open. The door open. ambulance door the ambulance of the of one one of the back back of did see buf II did No but and out. in of traffic lot there coming a lot of traffrc coming in and out' plus there was was a by the the cars, plus was blocked blocked by my view was rny view 5 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 see see information. information. 0. guards that that were were initially initially After two security security guards the two to the speak to see or or speak police arrived, did you see arrived, did the police After the this incident? in involved involved in this incident? some woman, woman, with some did not guard walk walk away with No security guard the one one security saw the but II saw speak to to them them but not speak No II did and the commotion after the police showing That left. police I showing was after up minutes and the that two commotion was that was two minutes after I left. That was after the them. with communicate didn’t and II didn't communicate with them. and \ ‘\ \ \ 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4l 42 42 43 43 45 45 \ ''.tv Prosecutgr's Prosecutor's File File 0 M511 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 63 of 100 PagelD: 1200 Slaiement of Joseph Wocio Page 7 of1 1 I Is there anyvhing else you would like to add to your slalement a! this limeTYPING CONCLUDED -- DATE AND TIME: Scplembex 21, 2015; 7:03 P.M. l3 :4 15 STATEMENT REVIEW AND SIGNATURE I6 17 Ihave xead this statement consisting of 7 pages; each page bears my initials including Is any corrections initialed in my own handwriting; and I certify that the {acts containad 19 herein are true. 20 2V 2: DATE AND TIMEDell: 34 Monmoulh Cum Prosecutor's Office 35 as :7 [#203, 33 De cclivc icl Newman 39 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 40 Prosecutor's File 0162 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 64 of 100 PagelD: 1201 at. A STATEMENT STATEMENT 01-" Philip Ladue ADDRESS TELEPHONE HOWell, NJ 07731 C: DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: 10 sort Cit), NY SOCIAL secumry NUMBER: -- Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office TAK EN AT: 132 Jerseyvill: Freehold. New Jerse) 07723 QUESTIONED BY: Detective Daniel Bozza Monmouth County Prosccutor's Olfioe BY: Detective Rosendn Perez Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office TYPED BY: Autumn Tymesko Monmouth County Prosecutor's omCe DATE TIME: September 21, 2015 10:31 A.M. Philip Ladue, I am Delecttve Daniel Buzza oflhe Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office and pmsenl here is Detective Rosendo Perez of the same office. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances sun'aunding the incident that occurred at [he Priediane located at 1017 Rt. 33, Freehold, NJ involving Timolhy Harden on September 5, 2015' This statement must be 11 voluntary one. given of your Own fret will um! accord. wilhuul any threats or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Court nit rm. Are you willing to glVe a voluntary statement at this time? Yes. Prosecutor's File 0 163 Filed 08/04/16 Page 65 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1202 Statement Ladue of Philip Philip Ladue Statement of Date: 21, September 20I 5 I)ate: Septe¡nber 2l, 2015 Page Page 2z a What is your age? age? What is A 28. 28. I 2 4 What What is is your occupation? occupation? 5 6 7 A Hand Stage Stage Hand o rù/hat is What education? formal education? is your formal A Some College College. Broome Broomc Community Conrmunity College Conrmunit¡' College, Some Community 8 9 l0 ¡l 12 married? Are Are you .v.,ou man'ied? t3 14 l5 A No. Nrl. t6 t7 a Can Language? the English English Language? write and and understand Can you read, read, write understand the A Yes. Ycs. l8 19 2ß a 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3t 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 4l) 41 4?. A at 1017 lAlT Rt. Rt. 33, located at 33, at the the Priedianc Priedianc located Calling occurred at to the incident that tliat occurred attention to the incident Calling your attention in tell us Harden 2015, please Freehold. please tell us in your own own 5,2015, September 5, on September NJ involving involving Timothy Timothy Harden on Freehold. NJ words incident. have of of this what knowledge kneiwledge you have this incident. words what Around with an an individual. individual. problent with having aa problem were having we were that we was notified by radio radio that a.m. II was notified by Around l0 l0 a.m. tell his could You He Mr. Harden. which attention erratically. You could tell his attention was acting acting erratically. which turned out to to be be Mr. Harden. He was turned out His attention would at one wouldn’t he thing. Tim different. sort would was His attention stay of, would thing. at one stay wouldn't go he go Tim was so¡'t oi would different. and Tim check his and on Johnstone Mr. come it supervise a¡ld check was Tim ott move. ltis just just move. lt was requesting requesting Mr. Johnstone come and supervise Johnstone Mr. didn’t Mr. or l behavior. see his about make observations welfare and welfare and make observations about his behavior. I ditJn't see Mr. Jolrnstone or Mr. Harden with Mr. Mr. Johnstone, Johnstone, was with in¡ was Then 'fT im that. Then hour after after that. minutes to to an an hour 40 minutes Harden for for another another 40 while for to him a Johnstone was Mr. his with in cart. around watching while a to be for be with with him watching golf was riding golf Johnslone cart. Mr. riding around with in his him calm. him and him and keep keep him calm. jobs, After giving Tim Tim other other.iob.s, started giving Bleefeld started Johnstone and and Benjamin Benjamin Bleefeld Mr, Johnstone After about an hour, hour, Mr. about an for went about That on Tim an to fence. like for occupied. went on about a keep That an just occupied. temporary Tirn putting fence. to keep likc putting up up a temporary the front the Tim to drove by of highway gate about hour gate hour. After the that. by highway an somebody the front up to hour. After about an hour of that. somebody drove Tim Seine volunteers palking and in the the parking t'olu¡lteers in 33. Sonre point. Tim l-le ran rau across highway 33. olTì He across highway that point. Ti¡n ran ran off. at that and at ask them ride few to cars lot for aa ridc going back and stopped stopped aa few cars to ask thenl for back and and forth forth and that he he was was going lot reported reported that about 20 for Tim to minutes saw Tim for about 20 minutes nobody saw Then nobody sense, Then didn't make make any sense. the airport, airpof. which which didn’t to the little bit and then for calm a Tim after was back he that. fairly then and bit and then II over. ran for a little calm Right and then he ran hack over. Right after that. Tim was fairly check him. The Tim on to to went the from that the on him. heard The security company went fo Tim to check heard that the supervisor supervisor fiom the security Tim that off set shoulder. behind Tim and Unfortunately, that set Tim off and supervisor went his shoulder. Unfortunately, a¡rd touched touched his went behind Tirn and supervisor the of the that rest that at told I point, face. the in was the the point, rest of the he at that that guard security told guard was punched fbce. I in the he punched the security -fq ‘Mt Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0164 164 Filed 08/04/16 Page 66 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1203 Statement Ladue of Philip Philip Ladue Statenrent of Date: September 21, 21, 2015 2015 Date: September LI-'[\.)n—3‘;x °“h>l_ Page Page:3 that he he called called Bleefeld that Mr. Bleefeld by Mr. told by was told him. II was restrained him. guards, total, restrained guards, Ii think was 55 total, thínk there there was I the it was an assault. assault. was an because it the Police Police because 2 on the the first tent tent on the first to the next to that point, At standing next was standing gate. II was front gate. to the the front up to point, II come come up At that of the One were down. him guards guards of were the of saw the Tim, holding holding him down. One guãrds on driveway. on top of Tim, the guards driveway. II sarv The head. Tim’s arms and and legs. of his arms legs. back in the their forearm holding his were holding rest were The rest Tim's head. using of in the back using thlir fbrearnr After about 10 him. with the and about 10 After guards him. the off guards with moving Tim could You the ground see moving ground and nroving Youiould see Tim moving off the blocked The cars Police 6 cars. there was my cars At arrived. first. The blocked nry Police the I5 cars. to niinutes, the Police ãrrived. At first. there was 6 Police to l5 minutes, of 10 l0 Police Police cars. cars. total of probably aa total view. cars came. probably Potice cars additional Police minutes, additional view. Within Within aa few few minutes, walk the I saw guards few within away. minutes, but guards walk a away. couldn’t saw the I this I At see minutes, anything a few within point, but point, I couldn't see anything At this Á 5 6 7 I 9 IO ¡I The ambulance the Police. in. maybe maybe backed in, ambtrlance backed The Police. The quick after after the fairly quick arrived fairly Thc ambulance ambulance arrived restrained on a stretcher, Tim, I was saw The thing I saw was Tim, restrained on a stretclrer, about next thing was. The next where Tim Tim was. from where 20 feet feet from abt¡ut 20 the brief being restraints. soft an ambulance. anrbulance. II gave aa brief with into an padded straps, meaning being put into padded straps, wittr soft restraints. meaning the it. and that was Officer to statement an statement to an Offìcer and that was it. 12 13 l4 l5 l6 t7 Q 0 l8 Sson f''rf; f 3o, we Event? Groove role for th r What was Event? Groove your was role lbr tlreütçqn What .:{.4 ~(- V :-i , Property Supervisor Maintenance Supervisor Pr.operly Maintenance r9 for was supplying supplying audio audio prior, II was year. Two Two years prior, this year. for this 20 systems the festival. fbstival. for the systerns for 7) Can y 23 24 25 DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME IL)// 3' o I 5; q¡tr :í qm ¡ 26 27 28 it 4o?_‘6?;‘Q»'_\_.___. 4gi;r.» Ladue Pliilip 29 P 30 3I 32 )J 34 35 16 37 .18 39 40 41 l’)etec:—iivc I)‘ ' ozza ozza Monmouth County Prosecutor's Monmouth County Proseculor's Office OfÍì ce -. r (SJ. i)cIcclivc Rosendo Rosendo Perez Perez Monmouth Monnrouth County County l’ros(.-culo 42 +.í Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0167 167 Case 3:15-c Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 69 of 100 PagelD: 1206 1 STATEMENT 3 4 5 STATEMENT OF: Casey Emilius 7 ADDRESS TELEPHONE N0: NJ 07418 8 Red Bank. NJ 07701 9 C: to DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: l3 Patterson, NJ is I4 SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: - |5 I6 TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Oflicc )7 I 12 Jetseyville Avenue IR Freehold. Ne" Jerset 07728 tq 20 QUESTIONED BM Detective Daniel anza :1 Lulillt) Prosecuwr's Office WITNESSED BY: Detective Rnsendc Fercz 24 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Ot'live 25 26 27 BY: Autumn zx Monmouth County Prosecutor's Oflice 19 30 "Arr TIME: 17' 2015 5:22 pm. ll 12 33 Case) Emilius. I am Daniel 50123 of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 34 and present here is Detective Rusendu Percz of the same office, It is our duty to ask 35 questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incidenl that occurred at the 16 Pricdt'anc located at 1017 Rt. 33, NJ involving Timothy Hardcn on Sementber 5. 17 2015. 35 39 This statement must be 3 Voluntary onet given of yuur own free will accord. "ilhaui 4t: any threats or promises. knowing that what you set) may be used in a Court ofLatt 41 42 43 Are you Willing to give a stntemem at this time? 41 A Yest 4n 1 1 'Prosecutor's File 0168 Filed 08/04/16 Page 70 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1207 Statement Statentent of of Casey Casey Emilius Emilius Date: 2015 Date: September Septcmbe¡' 17, i 7,2A15 Page Page 22 a What What is age? is your age? A 26. 26. I 2 3 4 What What is is your occupation? occupation? 5 6 Conference Conference planner. planner, 7 I I l0 lt t2 t3 a >0 What V/hat is is your formal formal education? education? A Bachelors Bachelors in in Marketing. Marketing. O a Are you married? Arc vor¡ nrarried? A t\ No. No. a Can read, write Can you read, write and and understand understand the Languagc? the English English Language? l\ Yes. Ycs. l4 t5 16 l7 I8 t9 the Priedianc the incident Calling located at at 1017 l0l7 Rt. Calling your attention attention to to the Priediane located Rt. 33, incident that thal occurred at the 33, occur¡'ed at tell in Freehold, please tell us Freehold. NJ NJ involving 2015. please us irr your own involving Timothy on September 5, 2015. Timothy Harden Harden on Septenrber 5, own words words what what knowledge knowledge you have ol'this incident. have ofthis incident. In.‘ 2 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3I 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 4I A II was front gate, working the was working gate, managing on site ticket sales. salcs. My and on site ticket the front nranaging will tvill call call and My, cash their responsibilities checking people’s rcsponsibilities include and distributing people's on-line sales or taking their cash and distribuling include checking on-line sales or taking wrist cars. At or weekcnd day or wrist bands check the thc cars. bands for for either passcs. ., We We have have security security check either day At weekend passes. 'lirn the front to Tim 10 was am. on brought approximately Saturday, September 5'l', gale for approximately 10 â.m. on Saturday, ieptenrber was hrought to the front gate l'or disorderly yelling on disorderly conduct. was yelling on the conduct. II didn't lre was the camp see it it but what II heard. heard, he canlp didn't see but from lrom what grounds grounds where people were normal. He [{e took took an where people Tim was was normal. a¡r were sleeping. My interaction interaction with with Tim sleeping. My then walked and the do 22 this.” ate to Approximately apple. said. going away. apple going away. Approximately apple. said. ‘‘I’m then walked the apple ancl to do this"" ate "I'm the the otlicer hours time restrained Tim I and next was later, saw security him, by being hours later, the next time I saw him, Tinr was being restrained by the securit.l' oflicer and Stone Pony. another worker’s name tlre Stone at the Pony. II another worker. worker. II believe is lan lan and and works works at believe the the other other worker's nanre is but don‘t officer"s name. the security securit¡' don't recall recall the the security sporadically, but the securitl,of'fìcer's Tinr fought lbught back back sporadically, name. Tim control until the officer under seemed had it and Tim have handled to professionally until the Police Police officer seemed fo have handled it profèssionally and had l'im under control ambulance An control. took arrived. And arrived. the Police then. once pulled i¡r and arrived. And then, once the Police an'ived. they and they took control. An a¡rtbulance pulled in ambulance shaking blocked approximately 22 for approxinrately m-"- view. view. About shakirrg for blocked my About 22 hours hours later, saw the the ambulance later, II saw minutes. then the pulled away. nrinutes. The a¡nbulance pulled away. The shaking shaking stopped, stopped. and the ambulance and then 5"‘, a When Whe¡r Tim Tinl was v¡as being please describe desmibe how ltow he guards. can can you please he was was restrained by by the being restrained security guards, the security being being restrained? restrained? .t- A 44 44 Tim otlicer had across Tim’s Tim's shoulder fcrrearm across shoulder had his his forearm Tirn was was laying laying face fhce down dc¡wn and and the s,:curitv orl'icer the security blades. blades. 1 ) ‘Pr ecutor's ;å""," r's File File 0169 169 Filed 08/04/16 Page 71 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1208 .\o:I’_-u~$E§3,mO‘UAwN .I_ ) 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 At you witness ditt you witness Harden. did Tinrothy Harden, point in with Timothy interaction with At any point in time time during duritrg security’s securiry's interaction obstructed? Timothy’s airway being Tinrothy's airway being obstructed? At witness Timothy did you witness Tirnothy point during Harden, did witir Timothy Timothy Harden, interaction with At any trny point during security’s security's interaction officer? assault a security assault a security officer? l6 t7 ’\Jv—I._a _LnJU[oQegas~ »_aes: l8 19 2l z 22 23 24 t< 26 27 28 29 30 34 No. No. t2 l3 JJ At did you see see them them strike strike or or Harden, did Timothy Harden, with Timothy At any time time during during security’s security's interaction interaction with hit Timothy? Timothy? hit No. Nc¡. t4 _l5 3l Page Page 3I l0 ll 32 of Casey Statement Casey Emilius Enrilius Statement of Date: September 17, 17, 2015 2015 Date: September around while legs around while being his legs heing mostly his flailing mostly II didn't. didn't. The only thing thing II saw him Tim Tim flailing The only saw him restrained. restrained. how did the scene When at the scene and fo¡ security, security, how over for did to take take over and began began to anived at When Police Police Officers Offìcer.s arrived Police Officers retrain Harden? Timothy Police OflÌcers retrain Tinrothy Harden? Officers. II just II did the Police Police Officers. and the physical transfer between security security and the physical control between did not not see see the transfer of of control certain and knew were over seeing the the Officers rerncmber seeing Officers don't remember knew they can't say for and don’t they were over there. there. II can’t for certain Tim. physicallytouching physically touching Tim. When arrived on the area immediately area and and immediately into the it drive When the did it drive directly directly into the ambulance ambulance anived scelìe, did on scene, front of view? park park in your in front of view? view. They Yes. fro¡rt of never moved. moved. Yes. Right Right in in front They never of my view. anything? During l{arden saying saying anything? the incident, incident, do recall Timothy Timolhy Harden During the do you recall No. No. saying anything‘? arrything? During the Police Officers Officers saying hearing any Police the incident, incident, do cio you recall During recall hearing 35 36 3t 38 39 40 Ah No. No. Officers arrived? During anived? Police Officers During the the incident, incident, do do you recall recall how how many Police II recall recall approximately 17 at once. approximately 17 at once. 4t 4. .¡ A44A ’ 0. Qc Prosecutor's 170 Prosecutor's File File 3170 Filed 08/04/16 Page 72 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1209 Statement Casey Emilius Statenrent of of Casey Emilius Date: Date: September September 17, 17, 2015 2015 Page Page 44 Vboxtu-n.N_, a I 2 A. 3 ^ 5 6 "°;\Ic7un:$§'5 a 8 A 9 l0 II 12 t3 Can of the please describe day of incident? tlre incident? Can you please describe Timothy Timothy Harden Harden on on the the day and II believe Tim shorts and believe in in the probably 6’4. good shape. on shorts the Harden probably 6'4. In He had had on Tim Harden In very shape. He very good He he time second shirtless. he the came was don’t remember I was morning up. He was slightly slightly morning he was shirtless. I dolt't remember the second tinre he came up. red in the red in the face face and sweating. and sweating. Prior the incident, did you have Timothy Harden? Harden? with'fi¡nothy to the fhe day interaction with Prior to day of of the incident, did have any interaction II saw 7:30. 8:00 8:00 4th at at approximately approximately 7:30, saw him hinr check check in in at at the the front front gate on on Friday, Friday, September September 4"‘ at him 10:30 I Tim and blanket. small saw a was approximately a again at approxinrately carrying bag p.nr, Tim was carrying a small bag and a blanket. I saw him again 10:30 p.m. about them with Dave with conversation short and had a p.m, with Dave Mahajan. nothing in in p.m. Mahajan. and had a short conversation with thenr about nothing Small talk. particular. talk. Small ¡rarticular. _. a What demeanor during Timothy Harden with Timothy Harden on was Timothy Wlral was interaction with on Timothy Harden’s Harden's demeanor during the thc interaction 2015? 4, September Seplentber 4,2015? A He He seemed scc¡ned totally normal. totally normal. .2-l9— a Prior Prior to to the thc interaction interactio¡r on on September September Timothy Timothy Harden‘? Harden? A II knew garbage, but but II never never had knew him prior, where cleatt up garbage, him from the year prior, where he volunteerecl to to clean had from the he volunteered 2 the events. conversation with him between him did and to not corrversation with him and did not see see or speak to irim between the 2 events. or speak t4 t5 l6 t7 I8 2' 2 22 23 24 25 a 26 27 2rl a At time during anyone mention did you hear hear anyone point in the incident, nrention At any point incident, did in tinre during the incident or or after afier the the incident that Harden narcotics? had taken that Timothy Timothy Harden had taken any narcotics? A Before time, there v/as an an implication implication over there was over the tsefore Tim Tim was was brought the brought up to to the the front front gate the the first first time, the lines radio Tim acid of that influence the under somethingalong was o{ he radio that T'im was under the influence of acid by he is by saying saying something along the lines of, is was that Tim tripping mentioned that yelling. II overheard Tim was someone mentioned tripping and where someone and yelling. conversat¡on where overheard aa conversation was scmi-normal yelling with him him was scmi-normal yelling about interaction with But my interaction about combat to Miami. Miami, But combat and and flying flying to do this. I’m him to besides the and going taking saying, be.sides him taking the apple apple and saying, I'm going to do tltis. 3l 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 At move to point in vehicles to to move to block block the At any point in time time during instruct any vehicles during the the incident, did you instruct the incident, did view view from from the scene? the scene? No. No. 32 33 :1 ¡r A 29 30 other interactions 4"‘, you had have you interactions have had with with what other 411'" what (BREAK (BREAK TAKEN TAKEN AT AT 5:52 5:52 P.M.) P.M.) (RETURN (RETURN FROM FROM BREAK 5:59 P.M.) P.M.) BREAK 5:59 41 41 I 44 (-1 (^' '2 ) PrbsQ:utor' s rb.É.utor, P File File 0171 171 Filed 08/04/16 Page 73 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1210 A"-I—._l"’t\°‘OL)u.v;[_ Statement of Casey Emilius Statenrent ofCasey Emilius 2015 Date: Septenrber 17, 1 7, 201 5 Date: September Page Page 55 a Can please describe by “tripping”? describc what what you mean mean by Can you please "tripping"? A II would acid, which psychecfelic .A psychedelic is aa drug. drug. A which is influence of of acid, would say someone who who is is under under the the influence say someone narcotic. mind altering nlind altering narcotic, a Have past? previous Super events in in the the past? worked previous Groove events Hare you worked Super Groove I 2 3 4 5 6 7 A 8 a-—In._ 9 l0 1I 'Ihe last Yes. gate. II am good fiont gate. am good at the lhe front years. The last 2, 2, at all 44 years. worked at the festival festival all Yes, II have have worked at the I 6 her met about her I’ve known friends with Priscilla years. I ntet her at probably about 6 years. at Mahajan. Iove known her probably friends with Priscilla Mahajan. Groove. of founder of Super Jeff Maha_ian’s Monmouth. Super Croove. who is is the the founder She is Maha.ian's wife, wife, who Monmouth. She is Jeff a In ever been hec¡r an an issue issue with witb has there there ever years that you have Groove, has worked Super Srrper Groove, I¡l the the 44 years that you have worked narcotic? attendees type of usirrg acid acid or of narcotic? aftcndces using or any other othel type A +—w;a2.+1d4u4_ut). We very family It's been been aa very family problem like like this. this. It’s ¡iever, ever ever had had aa problem We have hâve never, ++*lu¡¿-+a¡-r¡o. a event? Do year's evr'nt? at this this year’s served at bevcrages being served Do you know klrow if if there there were alcoholic beveragesbeing were any alcoholic A No. No, +n:vr: fv)<" *rtre' u)t:‘.YTi vuSti nor. a Were yeal's event? event? this year’s to this Were attendees attendees allowed alcoholic beverages beverages to allowed to to bring bring alcoholic A No. glass bottles of alcohol. alcollol. bottles of few glass searched all confiscate aa few No. Security Security searched all cars cars and and did díd confiscate ai Are we need need to to speak if we speâli to event if to this event provide additional about this Are you willing willing to to provide additional information information about you again? again? Al Yes. Yes. al like to Is this time? time? anything you would statentent at at this would like add to to your statement Is there to add there an¡hing 33 A. 34 "i extended period Tim period of dusty parking for an an exlendecl of time. tirne. parking lot lot for down in in aa very hot, hot, and and very ver"v dusty Tim was was face face down 12 t3 ,~o%\l°‘U l4 ¡5 I6 t7 t8 t9 20 20 : 22 ?3 24 ts 26 27 28 29 30 3t )Z No.»ce ¡Jo. - c É, friendly fricrrdly event. event. — CtgE 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 4? { 44 ,'- --'-==-\ ij¿Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0172 172 Filed 08/04/16 Page 74 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1211 Statement Statenrent of of Casey Casey Emilius Emilius Date: 2015 17, Date: September 17, 2Al5 Septentber Page Page e6 Is add to Is there there anything at this time? anything else else you would would like statement at this time? like to to add to your statement I 2 No. No. 3 4 5 6 7 TYPING AND TIME: 6:10 P.M. TYPING CONCLUDED 17, 2015 3015 6:10 P.M. Septenrber 17, CONCLUDED- DATE DATEAND TIME: September 8 — 9 r0 STATEMENTREVIEW STATEMËNT REV]EW AND AND SIGNATURE SIGNAT'LIRE II t2 II have initials including havc read read this this statement state¡nent consisting consisting of bears my rny initials inclucling any each page bears of 66 pages; each arry facts in corrections initialed that the and I are certify that the fhcts contained corucctions initialcd in my co¡ttained herein hcrein are nry own ou,n handwriting; handwriting; and I certífy t3 l4 l5 true. true. t6 t7 l8 t9 DATEAND TIME: DATE AND TIME: 2n _‘3_y lf] )4] _5_* S, .?>,)tr1 -\ 22 ¿t 24 25 26 27 28 to 30 3t 32 34 35 . '-. -ì:'x it Dctccul-i_ve ve iii. iozza Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Office Offi ce ._§t_Q..“£&.y_/{%/ , rf( l)ct‘c-ctivc Rosendo Perez Monmouth Monmouth County County Prosecutor's tliuc 3ó .)l 38 Prosecutor's 173 File 3173 Prosecutor's File Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 75 of 100 PagelD: 1212 A F. 3 4 5 STATEMENT or: Jeffrey Mahajan 5 7 ADDRESS TELEPHONE NO: Timon Falls, NJ 07724 3.x 9 a) 10 DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: 3 1 ll Indianapolis. IN 12 1: 50cm. SECURITY NUMBER: 14 15 TAKEN AT: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Is 132 Avenue Freehold. New Jersey 07722 Is QUESIJONED BY: Daniel Balm 20 Munmoulh Cuunl) Office 3] :7 wnNEseED BY: I)clc n: anacndu Pexez Monmouth County Prosecumr's Office BY: Autumn Tymesko Monmomh Coum) Prosccmor's Office DATE :2 TIME: Seplember 17, 2015 3.40 pm 34) Jamey Muhajan, I am Delecn've Daniel Buzzu or Ilu' Comm Promunm Ufficc and prexem here is Deteclivc Rosendo Percz om: same office. ix nur dul) to ask 32 33 ynu quesliuns regarding the circumstances surrounding the incidcm (hal uccu \1 a! alu- Fn'ediane labeled at [017 RL 33. involving Timmh) liardcn on Sc J. 35 2015. 35 37 This sxalemem musl be voluntary mu: given of )cur own lice "ill and nccord. 33 any (hm-nu prnn-ixes, knowing that what )ou say my be used in Court uf Law. 39 40 4| (2 An: you willing to give a volumary at (his time? :2 >13 A Yes 44 Prosecutor's File 0174 Filed 08/04/16 Page 76 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1213 Statement Statement of of Jeffrey .leffrey Mahajan Mahajan Date: 2015 Date: September Seplenrber 17, l7 ,2()15 Page Page 22 Q What What is is your age? age? A 39. 39. Q What What is is your occupation? occupation? A Musician/Teacher Musicianffeacher Q What is your formal What is formal education? education? A BA University. Masters Morunouth University. of Music. Music BA from from Monmouth fiom 'Berk-e-icy Htelvy College College of Masters from Q Are Alt you married? nlarried? A Yes. Yes. Q Can and understand rvrite antl Can you read, write undg'stand the the English Language? Ënglish Language? .'¡rou read, A YCS. Yes. Q attention to Calling your attention locatcd at at 1017 1017 Rt. Calling your Priediane located occurred at at the the Priediane Rt. 33, 1o the the incident incident that that occurred 33, tell in NJ us Harden on 2015, Freehold, 5, please tell us in your own .Fieehold, NJ involving involving Timothy own Timothy Harden on September Septenrber 5, 2015, please 1I 22 33 44 55 66 77 88 9I 10 l0 tII1 l2 t2 13 l3 14 t4 15 I5 16 r6 17 t'1 18 Itt 19 r9 22 !L 24 24 A 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 4., Ð 28 ‘ 29 29 30 :ì0 3t 3l 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 3(.I /95 .ì(r D 37 )t ")t\m 38 38 39 39 40 40 [I 41 4t 4,‘ .l^ 3" î CN-\ à 14??‘ 1* . . { 44 14 fir/w:_). Page Page 5s I Q 2 3 4 q A 6 II don’t when II was was there. there. moved when there. Nobody Nobody moved was there. anrbulances moved since II was don't think think the nroved since the ambulances see Timothy At you see did you Tinrotlty the incident, incident, did point in of the you were scene of wcre at the scene in time time while while you at the At any point ambulance? outside ofthe Harden Harden outside of the ambulance? 7 8 I 10 l0 ll II 12 12 I3 ¡3 14 I{ I5 l5 16 ,6 17 t7 18 l8 19 t9 At you hear did you hear anyone anyone incident, did point in you were of the the incident, were at the scene scene of in time at the At any any point time while while you request the ambulances ambulances to to be be moved? rnoved? request the Not day. Not that thal day. After the sollre form had taken takerr some f.-.'-.7.7. Detective Detectirre Rosendo Rosen Monmouth ce Prosecutor' Jffice County Prosecutor’ Monnrouth County 36 37 38 Prosecutor's File Prosecutor's File b179 179 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 81 of 100 PagelD: 1218 STATEMENT OF, ADDRESS TELEPHONE NO: DATE 6'4 PLACE OF BIRTH. SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: AT: QUESTIUNIED BY: BY TYPED BY: DATF. 8: TIME: John A. Bree, urn Ddeclive Daniel Haas of 111: Monmouth County l'rnsecumh OIfite and pr>>;cm hare ls Detective Brian Weishml of the same amcc. ll is nur duly u: ask )'Lm questions mgarding (he circumsmces surrounding the incidem [hm occurred at Illc Priedianc {named a! 1017 Rt. 33. chhuld, NJ involving Timothy Harden on Sepxemlwr 5. 2015. This smemem must be a volunlary one, giwn of your own free win and accurd. wilhuul an) "rats or promises, knowing 111m wha! you say may he used in 21 Conn on", John A. Bree .an Mawr, PA 19010 New York Munmoufll Cuunly Prosecutor's 011in 13: Jrracyvill: in tune Freehold, New Jams; 07728 DeIccm'e Daniel Bum Monmouth Conn!) Proacculor's Orifice Dueclhe Brian Weisbml Coumy Pmseculor's orna- Autumn Tymesku Monmuulh County Prusecmor's omce Scplember 17, 2015 9:47 a.m. Are you wilhng to give a voluntary smlemcnl m: lime? Yen. EXHIBIT fig: A Prosecutorfilzm 0180 Filed 08/04/16 Page 82 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1219 Statement of John .lohn A. A. Bree Bree Statenrent of 2015 Date: 17, September Date: September I 7,2015 \oex~u.gt,_N Page Page 2z What What is is your age‘? age? ¡ ') 27. 27. 3 4 What is your occupation? occupation? What is 5 ó "*-‘4._\IO'U~J—u:No 8 9 Q education? What What is is your formal formal education? Q‘ Arts. in Graduate from College fionl U tl Arts in Philadelphia. Philade lnhia. College Craduate ‘= A t3 N W vi.‘ tul. \)/Lvl {L. tf^' th "f 'o' married? Are Arc you ¡narrierJ? l0 ll t2 l3 l4 l5 t6 l7 I8 l8 l9 ?f 1., 23 24 25 2(t 11 28 )a 30 3t 32 33 34. 35 36 37 38 39 4A 4l .t? (,*.þ;'/)=‘-7;") J /, ',/ '/ w0'i£ u ,-u. L i\»\ ¡U. *¿ ¡. \," d Iplay years, _"-' r-.\'> 10 or or 11 I 1 years, I play music music for for about about l0 7 "&— (C ./' ~ 4 _ ' '1 I No. No, 0- and understand Can Language? write and the English English Language? understand the Can you read, read, write Yes. Yes. incident that at 1017 l0l7 Rt. Iocatccl at ll1. 33, 33, Calling Priediane located at the the Priediane occurred at that occurred Calling your attention attention to to the the incident in tell us Freehold, please tell us in your own owu 5, 2015, 2015, please on September Septenrber 5, Timothy Harden Harden on NJ involving involving Timothy Freehold. NJ words incident. words what have of this incident. what knowledge knowledge you have of this about 10:45 II showed set was was scheduled schedtrlecl Saturday, September Our set 5'l'. Our September 5"‘. there at on Saturday, showed up there at about l0:45 a.m. a.m. on at would as for ll:45 or or so probably, starting startirrg at 11:45 so as say probably, stage, II would say And II was was on on the the stage, for 12:00 12:00 noon. noon, And seemed He He the around Tim I first when That well. happy. saw grounds. was seenred grounds. happy. walking He He the walking around well. That was when I firsl saw Tim our set and Tim was Tinl was set started started and was up then our So then talking to to others others as as well. well. So tatking to himself. talking was talking t—A©ox‘“kU,_ I ) J 4 5 6 7 "“-‘4 8 9 l0 l1 l2 I3 N)»-_.,‘DO: l4 t5 l6 t7 l8 l9 20 ; a') 23 24 l5 26 27 28 29 30 3I 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 Statement of John A. A. Bree Statement oflohn Bree Date: I 7. 2015 2015 Date: September Sepfember 17, Page Page.t4 after having no no fun. lun. He like, having He to just like, fun to frotn having having fun wenl from is when when his his mood nioocl went spoke, is afìer he he spoke, it and awkward was a It was awkward and it was a little know and looked little bit bit you know mumbling. It was and started started mumbling. looked sad, sad, you off but to tell would and he’s get we because get people stage to off so people but stage typically tell huge would intimidating we typically intimidating because he's so huge and Had he because speaking. II would would have have said said calmly just let calnrly on speaking. kept on he kept let him hir¡ talk. talk. Had because of his size, size, we we just of his who is in that off. need to Somebody it’s it’s to him, that get off. Somebody who is in something like, set, you need to get like, it's cool, cool, it's our our set, him, something to state, to confront. confront. they are are not not someone someone you should should try to state, they witness any guards interacting interacting with with security guards you witness atry security During parkíng lot, lot, did did you During the incident in in the the parking the incident Tim? T'im? II saw was cleaning and he he was cleaning ¡he tents tents and and the guard standing the drive drive way and standing in between the in between saw the the one one guard with Tim. didn‘t I interacting his left side. blood of off But. see guards intl'râcting with Tim. securily guards blood of off his left side. But. I didn't see any security and/or EMTS EMTs say you hear Ollìccrs and/or sa¡' the Police Police Oflicers During hear the parking lot. did you incident in the parking lot. did During the the incident in the anything‘? anything? II can't can’t say that thc EMTS [MTs were wcre trying artd the trying but the the cops and conversatio¡l but that II can can recall recall their theír exact exact conversation much It all about was the Tim the easiest in tind to to basically. pretty ambulance, pletty nrttch It was all ahout basically. get ambulance, to tind the easiest way to Tim in the and the Tim to the them into to hospital. ambulance thcrn trying trying fo get Tim into the a¡nbulance and to the hospital. At place Tint Tinr in in aa choke choke hold hold Officcrs place Police Officers point during during the incident, did did you see see any Police At any point the incident, airway? or restrict his his airway? or restrict No. norntally do do to would normally to hold hold stuff they they would doing the the same sanre stuff seemed like like the the cops cops were were doing No. itIt seemed someone someone down. down. At f inr? point during striking Tim? Officers striking witness any Police Police Officers At any an1,'point the incident. incídent. did did you witness during the No. saw them get(ing free. free. It It seemed from getting seemed him from to keep keep him trying to No. Ijust I just saw them holding holding Tim Tim down, down, trying Tim that knew not sure I’m that I like far Tim and like, was on exactly so knew that Tim drugs, sure guess not exactly that like, I'm like Tim was so far gone and on drugs, I where he what was. was happening what was luppening or or where he was. strike any At guards or security guards includíng security individuals, including or point. did you observe any individuals, observe Tim A{ any any point. did you Tim strike Police Officers? Police Officers? No. No. or Police Did at any guards or Police Officers? Officers? security guards including security individuals, including Tim spit any individuals, Did you observe observe Tim spit at No. see a blood. guard aflerwards covered in in blood. afterwards covered a security security guard No. But Birt II did did see 41 4?. J /5 _/i Pro'se6Jtor's 183 Prciseóutor's File File 0183 Filed 08/04/16 Page 85 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1222 \)°"§”‘O'IchU-.l:wt~ Statement A. Bree Bree of John A. Statement ofJohn 2015 Date: 17, Date: September Septernber 17, 2015 Page Page 5-i while they interacting with were interacting with Did they were utilize any weapons while Police Officers Officers utilize observe any Police Did you observe Tim? Tim? I 7 3 A No. No. a describe the incident? the incident? How during the Of'ficers during of the Police Officers demeanor ofthePolice the demeanor would you describe How would A gelting up off from getting Tim from The ofï' to keep keep Tim trying to were trying They were were calm lìrm. They calnl but but fimi. Police Officers Officers were The Police 4 5 6 7 I 9 t0 ¡l a l?. 'u._, 13 14 l5 t6 l7 t8 ¡9 ?(\ 22 'r') 23 23 24 24 25 1< A >o 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 4] 4t 4? 4? how the rvith Tim Tinr during during the the Please interacted with Officers interacted the Police Police Officers of how observations of Please describe describe your observations incident? incident? his torso were on on his torso and and Tim Officers were Police Officers The Police his stomach. ground, on stonraclr. The on his laying on olr the the ground. T'inr was was laying it looked that like the could I see I where From was. I looked could where it like from his that thc see. sec I could I was. *'here legs Fronr where I could see. his legs from down. him Officers Police were holding Police Officers were holdi¡rg him down. a the ground? ground? get off What ofl'the to get was able able to if Tim Tirn was have happened happened if think would would have What do do you think A got in wlro got in his his way. II think anybody who probably hurt hurt anybody and probably off and and ran ran and would have have took took off think that that he lle would Qr Offìcers? Can the Police Police Officers? of the the presence of please describe behavior in the Tinr's behaviorin describe Tin1’s Can you please A 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3t 32 32 33 33 34 34 the ground. the ground. seemed like he had llad no like he no idea idea Tim And itit seenred help. And fbr help. hollering for He kept kept hollering was out of control. control. He Ti¡n was out of I could see Tim moving. how was of much actually couldn’t I c<¡uld I too see the the where was. I couldn't see see too much of how Tim was actually nroving, where he he was. it’s calm down, ok, stop Police Officers down, calm down, it's ok, stop stay down, saying, stay again, saying, over again, and over tike, over over and Police OffÌcers like, moving. would not not listen. lislen, moving. Tim Tim would witnessed the describe where the incident incidcnt in in the the Can you witnessed when you standing when were standing please describe where you were Can you please parking parking lot? lot? . l AI Q, Aj and Tim Tim had the cops and II was that the had would say that and II would Corvette and dad's Corvette back of of my dad’s at the the back was standing standing at The Corvette Corvette. of the was front the from feet al to to 77 feel from the fronl of the Corvette. The Corvette was at than maybe, maybe, 55 to to be be no no more more than of first cars. the row in route 33, the of cars. and lot was row front car the first facing in the 33, route facing parking was gate parking car gate lot and the the front Was way? ín any way? obstructed in view of of this this incident incident obstructed Was your view could see see the the Police Police II was partially obstructed. ohstructed' II could was partially car, so nly view view was so my was looking over the the car, looking over Tim’s head here could I see Tim. Tinr's The Tim. see was blocking head here knees car their I could Officers Tim. over on Officers on their knees over Tim. The car was blocking couldn’t I Tim’s But see Police. the resist to couldn't see down he and But I Tim's was and Íying to resist the Police. as he was trying t¡ere, up up and down as and there, whole whole body. body. 44 44 ,.,.JL Prosecutor's Prosecútor's File File 184 84 Filed 08/04/16 Page 86 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1223 Statement A, Bree Bree Slate¡ne¡lt oflohn of John A. Date: September Date: Septenrber 17,2015 17, 2015 l\)._©ox]°U‘hL”tQ' Page Page ó6 Did incident location? at the the incident iocalion? persorurel and/or arrive at medical personnel and/or ambulances ambulances arrive Did you observe observe any medical I 2 II saw saw what Tinr, along over Tim, along side side the standi¡lg over the what was I{e was was standing was either either an an EMT EMT or or aa Paramedic. Paramedic. He 2 with showed EMTs ambulance the And time actual there. up with 2 EMTs or cops then, short after, the actual ambulance showed up or cops there. And then, shoñ tinre after, Paramedics, I'm not Paranredics. I’m not sure. sure. J 4 5 6 How How many many ambulances ambulances did did you 8 *‘:lh— l0 When parked? $¡hen the where it it parked? amhulance arrived recall where the ambulance anived on on scene, do do you recall lt f\)—-,_.:>oe1u; the incident at locatiun? at the incident location? II believe that II only bclieve that only saw saw 1. I. 9 l2 t3la.) The parked right trccs, and attcl parked the trees, pulled in. hctweeÍì the right in, in in between The ambulance anrbulance came carne in in the rhe driveway antl it it pulled driveway and Tim. to had behind where the second close to access tent. behind the sccond tent. close enough enough to where they they had easy access to'l'inr. t4 t5 see see t7 At pcrsonnel to nledical personnel instruct medical point in hear anyone instruct to in time incident, did did you hear At any point tine during during the the incident, the ambulance? relocate relocate the ambulance? l8 t9 No. Not that that II can can remember. renrentber. No. Not 16 2A ()1 Q 22 23 At bcirrg injured you hear of being iniured in poínt during in any during the Tim complaining conrplaining of At any any point incident, did did you hcar Tim the incident, way? way? No. No. 2.4 ?5 2b Q video record Did the incident? incident? record the photograph and/or observe any individuals individuals either either photograph and/or video Did you observe 11 l8 29 30 3I '17 33 34 35 3() 37 38 39 No. No. Is tirne? your statement at this this time? there anything Is there would like like to add to statentent at anything you would to add to your shame that lt’s opinion, it’sjusI it's jttst aa sltanlc rny opinion. Frorn my tlr¿rt to handle state. From ff 's hard hard to handle someone who is is in in that that state. someone who what to him. I’ve bunch of seen Tim this and to happens on a people Tírr, was, on a bunch of drugs drugs and this happened happened to him. I've seen what happens to people calm 'in’ai1”.7fltered state. seen people attempts to t;ometimes attempts to calnl and sometimes people in before and in this this state state before state, I’ve I've seen them know, really. really. are futile, futile. so tell: res not. You just never never know, them are not. You '(x\‘l\=x\\"3 ‘ )3.‘ t,,hoI) / .t0 ,fl {? 4.1 in C . [5 < ,, ,t:i" Prosecutor‘ Prosecuto s e 0 185 85 Filed 08/04/16 Page 87 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1224 Statement A. Bree Bree John A. of John Siarement of 2015 Date: 17, Date: September Septernber 17, 201 5 Page Page 77 Is time? this time? at this yottr statement statement at add to to your to add would like like to else you would there anything Is there anything else I 2 t A No. No. 4 5 6 7 I "‘:“ 2015 11:14 a.m TYPINGCONCLUDED i l:14 a.m. 17,2015 September 17, TIME: September DATE AND TIME: TYPING CONCLUDED - DATEAND — 9 l0 '~3—-vpAo_a.,'2~omqQ il l2 STATEMENTREVIEW SICNATI¡RE AND SIGNATURE STATFMËNT REVIËW AND t4 inclttding any II have read this att¡' rtry initials initials including bears my pages: each each page bears consisting of of' 77 pages; have read this statement statement consisting contained herein facts the that and I corrections are certify that the facts contairted herein are owr handwriting: handwliting: and I certify initialed in in my own cçrrections initialed l5 true. true. t3 t6 17 t8 l9 DATE AND TIME: TIME: DATE AND '_l_f,_;"l 7/ 35’l-> tl' 2»). (llr{ 57il"r" l I‘t../ L1 _c _ 1(\ N MLAJ:-utq 4 K .,1 . ’H 23 26 27 28 :9 .r .i il 32 l3 34 l5 J ..a_._._).__._ _ Johl.,4. Bree 24 25 3 ( ') -r..'...' « (/14.-_W -7 "7 H. In "> . .7;æ- Dz§fi~lTBozza Detective Detective Bozza Prosecutor's Monmouth County Office County Prosecutor's Office Monmouth ,\ ii/jag *ttt l.—)1:tcciivc Brian Weisbrot Brian Weisbrot Monmouth Offi ce Proseculor's Office County Prosecutor's Mo¡rmouth County 36 37 38 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0186 186 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 88 of 100 PagelD: 1225 mammawnSTATEMENT OF: Andrew J. Nen ADDRESS TELEPHONE N0: -- Lakehutsl, NJ 03733 DATE 5; PLACE OF BIRTH: Jackson, NJ SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: TAKEN AT: Lakchurst Palioe Department 530 Union Avenue Lakehuust, NJ QUESTIONED BY: Detective Blian Weisbrot Monmouth County Pmsecu'm's Office WITNESSED BY: Deleeuve Roscndo Perez Monmoulh Coumy Pmseculor's Office TYPED BY: Incquclmc 1: ya" Monmonrn ('ounty Prosecular's Office DATE TIME: Tuesday, Seplembel s, 2015; 6:13 PM Andrew J. Nari, 1 am Detective Brim Weisbrol of die Monmouth County Pmseculor's 01110: and presenl here is Detective Rosa-Ado Perez of the same nmuc. It is our duty to ask you questions rcgurding the circumstanoes surmunding the incident HIM murmd El Priediunc located at 1017 Rt. 33, Freehold, NJ 1nvolv1ng 'l'imolhy Harden on September 5, 2015' van cf your own free will and accord, This must be a voluntary unc, gi that you say may be used in withoul any llmcals or promises, knowing Courl of Law. Are you willing u: give a valumary slalcmen! a! this time? Yes. EXHIBIT _23_ Prosecutors File 0187 Filed 08/04/16 Page 89 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1226 “”"°‘~IO\ua4:.>z, 1 L 3 Statement Neri J. Neri of Andrew Andrew J. Statement of 2 Page Page2 a A. 4 5 *-0N3I\)v—»".‘_°VDc\ra;K$“ 6 7 a. A. 8 I l0 1t l2 l3 14 l5 l6 l7 ''5->F*"-rF‘WANw>—ou~.)u\;°”Lamwnr t8 t9 20 2t t2 a A. a. A. 0. A. a. 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 35 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4r 42 43 r4 45 A. What your age? age? What is is your 33 33 What occupation? What is is your occupation? car detailing. Toms River, detailing. Securities; Central River, car Auto in in Toms Security Central Auto At Griffin Griffrn Securities; Security At What education? is your formal formal education? What is High Graduate School Graduate High School Are ma¡ried? Are you married? No No Can Language? the English English Language? and understand understand the read, write write and Can you read, Yes. Yes. at the located at at the Priediane Priediane located occurred at that occurred Calling incident that the incident to the attention to Calling your attention 2015. Can 5, Harden on September Can 5,2015' 1017 Timothy Harden on September involving Timothy NJ involving nt. 33, ¡¡, Freehold, Freehold, NJ 1017 Rt. have of what incident? words this incident? in of this own us knowledge you have what knowledge own words your you please please tell us in tell Souper Groove Groove at the the Souper regular day day at II work aregular having a were having we were Security, we work for for Grifiin Crifün Security, make to vehicles sure is which searching to make sure Howell. II was Festival my job which is searching vehicles doing myjob wai doing in Howell. Festival in and came someone We called, told thatthere were callsd' someone carne and told drugs. We were glass bottles or drugs. bottles or were no no glass that there were and of disturbance one a and making one of a little, that disturbance there a was that acting was makíng up us a little, q us that lhere was Ely epy that was acting behind following were out we just so the man behind following ther were workers wc was the escorting t¡e workers there#was escorting the mar¡ out so approached the ticket booth the ticket out of hand didn’t get him making we approached as we and as get outof hand and he didn't su¡e he making sure him Foü because and vehicles the they again and because they in to searching searching the vehicles again back to had gone back sectiãrU II had in the the section, was an eye on as II was him and and as just keep keep an on him were to just had to still, II had him out õut still, escorting him were escorting other security the guy guard wrestling wrestling the vehicles II saw security guard the other searching Brandon, the saw Brandon, the-vehicles searching the he was to over and ran help.and was he what to doing and ran over to helpgnd ground so wps doing stopped whatJ wws so II stopped to the the grõund arm and the guy's II grabbed guy's right rightarm and down him grabbcd the to keep trying tryingîo keep him ¿own # wrist his and right his grabbed his rigtt-wrist grabbed knee bicep on and right back it and bicep his right placed pulled pútt"ã it back andplaced my knee on to fight. He fight. He continued-to ac.frrally continued and ancl he he actually ground and the ground to the ttanat to *y 2Z hands it with with my held it and held Brandon was and down his arm was to Brandon best keep his arm down and was did my bestto keep to II did *d so lifting me *" and was lifting him down other his until the the Police Police arm and down until down his on keep him him, and keep otherarm his weight him, putting putting his weight down on and to continued he fight him and fight down, to to continued While he keep arrived. we were him down, trying arrived. Whileïe were trying to keep he might’ve bit his his might've bit like he mouth like his mouth fro- his struggled bleeding from was bleeding free, he he was to get free, sûuggled to that he At blood us. point on his point and he that At at wipe his blood on usus and wipe to spit spit at us tongue kept trying ürying to and he hã kept tonfrie and and he down it and kept his of better grip kept it down and he kept a better tried arm and kept grip of his arm got ä so ÍI got again so ti¡ing me me again triø lifting couldn’t hold to able were it down we there. II couldn't it there. I to hold it resist but able to were as we got finally got it down trying trying to resist Uù as f finally I positioned, I was was was positioned, body was wây my body the way" see of the point because because of by that that point face by hir face *" his ' Prosecutor' s”‘é‘1 Prosecutor'r*l"J e C 188 1 88 Filed 08/04/16 Page 90 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1227 Statement of Andrew Statement of Andrew J. J. Neri Neri Page Page 33 '~/1#L3I\)u—I "°“-‘=W >~—o\ea1¢. 2 ~co\rxv.2=u,g_°;'‘-—»« @.>rO?0 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 IO I1 12 13 l4 "'->$‘E3i§l5«°.£’aS;,1éNmM~w t5 l6 17 l8 l9 .N 2A 21 ,'2 23 a. How employed with Griffin Security? Security? with Griffin How long long have have you been been employed A. A little over A little over22 years. a. What Security? job title yourjob grflin Security? is your Wl¡at is title with with griffin A. Security. Security. a. Do other than with field otherthanwith the Security Security field in the experience working working in Do you have have any other other experience Griffin Security? Criffin Securíty? A. No. No. a. Griffin Securities Please of this this the night night of on the Securities on yoru responsibilities with Griffin describe your responsibilities with Please describe 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3I 32 5) 34 35 36 37 A. 38 39 40 4t .5, 4,4 incident. incident. AJJ A¡/ subs 1 vs gln.ss for any ille.gal (_I,l:tss lmttlt-..«;, illx.-mil srrhs¡4r¿¡¡5 hottles, My cn¡s for to search search cars responsibilities was was just to My responsibilities ould haw.-. then ant us now bci an be.i.rg a presence, every checking every noqg{d thenlåF?ould have us a presence, chccking rvristbatcls and it floating. ould sec security irrr*,ffi"all it floating. jus so walking sce securÍry walking around arouua¡,.ÈtsoGtffiulä Wl"lSl )all($ 1'3‘; tl1crc,%call A _ a. What Saturday on Saturday to work work on assigned to were assigned the name name of facility that that you were is the of the What is the facility 5, 2015? September September 5,2015? A. The Latvian Society in in Howell, Howell, NJ. NJ. Latvian Society The 42 43 facing who had had come come see who down. II didn’t didn't see was holding facing away away from from him him as as II was holding his his arm arm down. his hold tried to and he it but of another legs our was one down guards and he tried to hold his legs down up but it was another one of ou¡ security security guards calm him and that who seemed down to calm him down tried to point, somebody him, tried at that point, know him, and at to know somebody who seemed to and him down down aa to help us hold hold him grabbed the help us and tried tried to guys other actually grabbed the guys other leg leg and and he he actually continued to to still he and held him down little that At struggle we more. struggle to to point little more. At that point we held him down and he still continued there came over the until the arrived. When they got there they came over get get up until the police police finally police arrived. When the police finally got and him and one at a time get amt until right arm until they they helped us his right get off held onto onto his and II just held and helped offhim us one atatime the When handcufi" the able his back and behind on. to they got were got the get they get get get When handcuffon. able the to behind his back and were handcuff on his get his to get were able able to his left left got up and the other officers were other otficers handcuffon right wrist, wrist, II got and the his right stomach to his him onto rolled behind The officers him. over arm behind him. The police get the the police officers rolled him over onto his stomach to get arm officers rolled left put the they put the him afier after they rolled him police officers left handcuff handcuff on believe the the police on him. him. II believe tie II withthe handcuff officer I another zip things, plastic on. saw plastic things, zìptie approach right ttre with approach right handcuffon. I saw another of;Frcer back walked and had I them didn’t did because with what see back gotten up and walked didn't see what they they did with them because I had gotten towards an ambulance with the the a¡rived with had arrived ambulance had Afrer that, First Aid, Aid, an towards the the cars. cars. Afler that, the the First have didn’t asked injuries and and asked police police and we didn't have any injuries looked over to make make sure sure we and they they looked over us us to the officers of One the tired from if I and OK were struggle. we was just the fine, officers One of just if we were OK and I was fine, tired from the struggle. asked what that II told told thing that spoke to the same same thing told him him the to me me and what happened happened and and II told spoke and asked what I didn’t and the see Afler back I cars to else you. After that, that, I went searching the ca¡s and I didn't see what else you. went back to searching happened. happened. 45 ñ Prosecutor's 189 File 0189 Prosecu tor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 91 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1228 °“\lOU1-J>u.:tQ_ Statement Statement of of Andrew And¡ew J. J. Neri Neri Page Page 44 a. ?A. >r.O I ", 3 a. Have you received to disruptive disruptive relating to Security relating frorn Griffin Griffin Security training from received any training Have of events? these individuals at t¡.pes of events? individuals at these types 7 A. 'We were told to escort of the or off premises and and if if they they We the premises offof out or individuals out disruptive individuals were told to escort disruptive sense. common and to the call use make to to sense. sure police cortmon violent, get get violent, to make sure to call the police and to use >l0 —l a. Does assist you in in to assist protective equipment equipment to provide you with with any protective Security provide Does Grifiin Griffin Security duties? your duties? your A. No all. nothing at at all. No nothing a. A. employee? Are a security security employee? as a clearly identiS you as uniforms that that clearlyidentify issued any uniforms Are you issued H-5#U~>'oJlaW3wu.)lo;ym_gL”nqokqsexiNm-:Aq.°$\]a;) /.°>0E 4 5 6 I I l1 t2 t3 14 l5 t6 ._ 17 l8 t9 2A 2l at the the Were t-shirts at Secwity t-shirts personnel wearing Griffin Security wearing Griffin the other other security secu¡ity personnel and the Were you and incident? time time of of the the incident? A. Yes t-shirts. Grifnn t-shirts. we were were all all wearing wcaring Griffin Yes we a. how many at the the Latvian Latvian Do working at were working employees were Security employees many Griflin Grifün Security know how Do you know 2015? on 5, September Society Septemb er 5, 2015? on Society A. started getting showed up when getting busier. It busier. we started when we 2 others others showed then 2 and II and and then It was was Brandon Brandon and all 4 of us II believe together. were 4 of us all together. believe there there were a. 'Whatwere names? What were the tåe names? A. last names. narnes. II believeit their last know their don't know myself. II don’t and myself. Brandon and Dave, Brian, Brizur, Brandon was Dave, believe it was a. at this this event? event? Were services at providing security security services companies providing other security security companies there any other Were there A. No. No. a. Society making making How Latvian Society at the the Latvian was an an individual individual at that there was were you notified notified thatthere I{ow were disturbance? a a disturba¡rce? A. Griffin Security Security II was not aa Griffin lhere, not workers there, the festival festival workers by one one of of the was notified notified by Ian. his I think was name employee. I think his name was lan. employee. 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3l 32 3J 34 36 37 38 39 40 41 -B4531fib-lt\3 42 43 and big big Yes front and or yellow on the the front Security on yellow t-shirts Griffin Security that say Griffin red or t-shirts that we have have red Yes we back. the letters on on the back. Ietters “Security” "Security" a. 22 23 35 'What event was taking place 2015? What 5,2415? on September Septembet 5, Society on at the the Latvian Latvian Society event was taking place at Souper F'estival. Groove Music Music Festival. Souper Groove 44 Prosecutor's r's File File ( 1190 190 Filed 08/04/16 Page 92 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1229 Statement J. Neri Neri Andrew J. Statement of of Andrew Page Page 5s “°\UIALnw_. oxu-.>wq_“é’\"3§fi'5,jl;7asr8$ a individual Where were an individual that there was was an informed thatthere were informed located when when you were were you located Where disturbance? creating creating aa disturbance? A. II was set up. tent set ofüce tent the box box ofiice have the where they they have entrance, where at the the front front entrance, was at a. How disturbance? a disturbance? creating a was creating somebody was informed that that somebody How were were you informed A. One was an an there was golf cart said that that there and said cart and on aa golf came up on workers came of the the festival festival workers One of he out. that make to sure wanted and got disturbance out. individual he a that they wanted to rnake sure creating a disturbance and they individual creating a. creating Who an individual individual creating was an there was that there informed that were informed was with when you were lVho was with you when disturbance? a a disturbance? I I 3 4 °¢\}O'.nAt,)_ 5 6 7 8 I t0 lt t2 t3 l4 A. l5 t6 t'l l8 t9 20 2t'_' -¿2 23 24 25 26 a. the individual individual Who with the contact with to make make contact employee to Security employee Griffin Security was the first Griffin Who was the first who disturbance? the disturbance? who was was creating creating the A. Brandon one. the first first one. Brandon was was the a. Do distu¡bance? the disturbance? creating the who was was creating the individual individual who Do you know know the A. No. No. a. the creating the Did individual creating the individual with the contact with had any contact meet or or have have you had Did you ever ever meet occasions? disturbance on prior prior any occasions? disturbance on A. No. No. a. Please dishrbance. the disturbance. creating the who was was creating the individual individual who describe the Please describe GPO? 27 28 UJul.:)13 29 30 3l 32 33 A. 34 4=w~53“£:’&‘, 35 36 37 when you when when doing when What the disturbance distrnbance doing was creating creating the that was was the the individual individual that What was were him? about him? were notified notified about A. Festival employee, who the tJre escorted out know who He don't know employee, II don’t by aa Festival out by was being He was being escorted 3E 4t -5P was at 6”2. He was built at least least he was White would say he so II would built so He was 6"1,6"2. probably like like 6”1, White male, male, probably shoes shirt or had no He hair. shorter on and 250 lbs. Dirty and probably Blonde shorter hair. He had no shirt or shoes on Dirty Blonde probably 200, 200,2501bs. shorts. blue he II believe was wearing shorts. believe he was wearing blue a, 39 40 another security Brandon. don't Griffin' II don’t of Griffin. employee of security employee is another Brandon is Brandon. Brandon last Brandon’s know name. last name. know Brandon's Just me and . Just me and employee was. employee was. 42 43 44 Prosectkais P File File 0191 191 Filed 08/04/16 Page 93 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1230 J. Neri of Andrew Statement Neri Andrew J. Siatement of Page Page 6a II 2LI 35 44 55 66 77 88 99 10 10 ll 11 12 12 13 l3 14 l4 I5 r5 16 t6 17 t7 18 t8 19 l9 20 20 21 2l 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 Q. a. A. A. a. A. A. that you time that at the the time demeanor at Please and demeanor actions and the individuals individuals actions describe the Please describe festival? the of out escorted him observed being escorted out of the festival? observed him being was he was how he about how things about saying things was saying He was lot. He He talking aa lot. then but but talking calm then being calm was being He was he was everything he was pick up everything couldn't pick beach, he babbling, II couldn’t was babbling, walking on he was on aibeach, walking At that point he out. him he that point who was walking ou! .At the him man to he was saying, talking to the t* *ho was walking was talking ,"yingit. that. like acid something that' like or like sounded like seemed \ryas on on like acid or somethíng he was like he but it it sounded OK but ,"ärãà OK at the Was event? the event? served at being served alcohol being Was alcohol see him him didn't see but II didn’t with red cups but a¡ound withred Yes people walking walking around saw people so. II saw think so. Yes II think him. on him' alcohol on smell alcohol didn't smell drinking and It didn’t alcohol and drinking alcohol Q. a. creating the disturbance? the disturbance? individual creating Did the individual approach the Brandon approach observe Brandon Did you observe A. A. walking started walking who started one who the one was the Brandon was Yes to him. him. Brandon walk up to Brandon walk saw Brandon Ycs II saw out. him walking out. who already was him walking the other with him perion who was already out with the other person him out Q. a. he was was while he change while demeanor change At individuals demeanor ihe individuals observe the point did did you observe At any point A. A. Q. a. being out? escorted out? being escorted to stay. him heard him had heard stay. II had wantedto seemed like he wanted Yes upse! he getting upset, was getting he was like he he seemed Yes he him to wrestling was Brandon to him knew was I wrestling thing-I knew was Brandon was talking the next nãxt thing and the them and with them talking with point' at that that point. the cars at the cars checking the still checking gróund. II was was still the ground. that at that individual at this individual and this Brandon and from Brandon were you from Approximately how far far away were Approximately how time? time? A. A. II was far' not too too far. yards away, away, not 4 yards was about about 4 Q. a. the to the individual to the individual wrestling the What Brandon wrestling noticed Brandon when you noticed do when did you do What did ground? ground? A. A. him. to help help him. a¡rd tried üied to II stopped over and ran over and ran doing and was doing what II was stopped what 36 36 Q. a. Brandon' assist Brandon. to assist arrived to when you arrived Please demeanor when individuals demeanor describe the individuals Please describethe 37 37 38 38 A. A. 34 34 35 35 39 39 40 40 41 41 42 42 of him, there him, there get get off offof that point. Brandon to telling Brandon was telling He was very angry at point. He He was at that He was 10 struggling, a lot, He screaming struggling, lot, was much talking wasn’t too just cursing. cursing. He was just screaming a talking just too much wasn,t was he was break got his arms down he his arms to He when we got free, when trying grunting. kept tryfuig to break free, grunting- He kept -do* him to had pin we pin him then and uni just t. had his with we hit legs um us to then and kicking trying t ying to triius with his legs and tcking-and down. down. 43 43 44 M Prosec&or' s '"r")il', P File 192 File C 192 Filed 08/04/16 Page 94 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1231 Statement of Neri of Andrew Andrew JJ. Neri Statement . Page Page 7t 1 a. 2 J 4 A. 5 6 I 9 t0 actions that the Please control the to control trying to was trying as he he was took as that Brandon the actions Brandon took clesc¡ibe the Please describe individual? individual? on top down keep him him down He to keep chest to of his his chest top of body on to lay lay his his body grabbed his his arm arm and and tried tried to He grabbed face individuals the to while arm. Brandon keep the individuals face trytog to keep was trying grabbed his Brandon was his other other arm. whiie II grabbed and were we yelling and back to stop. more yelling at stop. him from at him him to were spitting and we turning from him tuming back and spitting more him from so turned head his his forearm to to used him so he he away Brandon from keep try to keep his head turned Brandon used his forearm to try down and his arm focused I on of time keeping the wouldn’t was focused on keeping his arm down and my spit. Most Most of the time I was wouldn't spit. on him. weight him. weight on a. strike any employees Griffin with Griffin Did employees with punch or or strike the individual individual punch Did you observe observe the l3 l4 l5 A. see it. didn't see it. Brandon face but but II didn’t the face in the punched him him in individual punched that the individual told me rne thatthe Brandon told t6 a. part of his body? body? observe Brandon of his Did on any part individual on punch or the individual strike the or strike Brandon punch Did you observe t7 l8 l9 A. No. No a. A. incident? the incident? Did point during during the or punch at any point the individual punch the individual at strike or ever strike Did you ever 11 lz 20 2t t', 23 24 25 a. 26 27 28 33 34 37 38 39 40 4l place? Where take place? did thisincident this incident take Society did at the the Latvian LaWian Society Where at a. A. 44 45 the was the It was iot of of dirt. dirt. It a lot At was a grass/dirt area, there was area" there the grass/dirt entrance on on the front entrance the front At the tent. ofiice the box near vendor/artists parking area area near the box oflice tent' vendor/artists parking place on? on? What took place íncident took the incident ground surface that the surface that was the the ground What was It and dirt. dirt. It was was grass and a. this during this Brandon during Did and Brandon assist you and personnel assist Grififin Security Security personnel Did any other other Griffin incident? incident? A. to get Brian had had get his legs. Brian his legs. Yes. himto tell him Brandon tell and II heard heard Brandon Dave showed showed up and Yes. Dave showed had Brian if Bdan hatl showed up. up' see if stayed didn't see cars. II didn’t the cars. checking the stayed checking 42 43 arrived? arrived? a. A. 35 36 police the police before the How individual before the individual control the finally control people did take to to finally did it it take How many many people Griffin arrived, 33 Griffin police arrived, It believethere the police until the down until people to him down to keep keep him was 4 4 people believe there was muscular is Brandon a lmow. don’t pretty I muscular 1 and is a Brandon know. don't Security employees I person i and Secgrity employees from moving. moving' him from keeping him person and was having touble keeping person and he he was having trouble 29 32 weight all my weight using all No. was using down- II was arm down. barely strong his arm to keep keep his enough to strong enough No. II was was barely his down. arm just to just to keep keep his arm down. A. 30 3t Security? Security? Prosecum NJ Prosecu File File 00 193 93 Filed 08/04/16 Page 95 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1232 Statement J. Neri of Andrew Andrcw J. Neri Stafement of Page Page 8s 11 2t 33 44 5 5 66 7 8 9 I I 10 t0 11 1t 12 12 13 13 14 14 15 I5 16 16 17 t7 18 l8 19 l9 20 2A 2] 21 22 ')) 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3l 32 32 33 5J 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 Q. a. arrive? to arrive? police department department to Approximately the police it take take for for the how long long did did it Approximately how A. A. I’m forever. it was was forever. It seemed seemed like like it su¡e. It I'm not not sure. Q. a. see arrive? arríve? did you see Approximately police officers officers did many police how many Approximately how A. A. about 5. I’m 5. think about of thetotal tl¡e total but but II think su¡e of I'm not not sure Q. a. how the the with the Please interasted with police officers officers interacted the police of how observations of describe your observations Please describe disturbance. the who individual was creating individual who was creating the disturbance. A. A. and to quit to quit When downand to stay stay down him to got there them telling telling him police got heard them there II heard the police When the roll him to and were his trying arm roll him they to trying were grabbed They and they grabbed arm fighting. resisting, his stop resisting, stop fighting. They heard I him. an handcuff could back his behind his an so I heard and they arm over handcuffhim. could get his árm behind his back so they over and get One ever did. did- One officer if he he ever know if don't know him but but II don’t spraying him something about about spraying say¡ng something officer saying his to baton used the officer The get get it his arm arm come out. officer out. The officer used the baton to heard it come used a a baton, batorU II heard officer used it to used he locked so his get get arm his backbecausehe it to behind was used so he keeping locked his arm keeping was he behind his back because leverage pull it to pull it back. back. leverage to Q. a. who was was Did individual who the individual punch or or strike strike the police officers ofücers punch of the the police observe any of Did you observe disturbance? the creating creating the disturbance? A. A. being struck. someone was No stnrck. was being like someone thuds. It It sounded sounded like but II did did hear hea¡ thuds. No but Q. a. políce officers? ofliccrs? Did the police of the punch any of or punch strike or the individual individuat strike observe the Did you observe A. A. No. contact' see any contact. didn't see but II didn’t saw the the struggle snuggle but heard and and saw No. Just Just heard Q. a. the individual. individualrestrain the Can to restrain baton to the baton utilizing the was utilizing who was the ofiicer officer who Can you describe describe the A. A. No. No. Q. a. the baton? baton? Did \¡vith the the individual individual with strike the see that that Officer ever see officer strike Did you ever A. A. No. No. Q. a. the police saying to What individual? to the the individual? police ofiicers officers saying hearthe did you hear What did A. A. arms keep your arms II just heard quit fighting, fighting, keep quit struggling, struggling, quit to quit them telling telling him him to heard them him. this to would behind repeat this to him' quit resisting. They would repeat båck, quit resisting. They behind your back, 41 41 42 42 43 43 44 44 45 45 Prosecuidrlsi File 94 le((0194 Prosecu "J, 1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 96 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1233 Statement of Andrew Andrew J. J. Neri Neri Statement of Page Page 9I a. A. I 2 3 4 5 6 He babbling He was was babbling was. He he clearly but he clearly was. saying thathe that he wasn’t wasn't resisting resisting but He was was saying could that I The l‘ ldn’l us W( 1' thing that I could understand '0 understand incohcrcnlly_ only thing g incohcrcrrf Iy. çpqldn't cqt‘1 hiS.W-qrd¡çut. suit. The only putting his resisting by was arms behind behind his his his arms by not not puttiog was that that há{tâ}Ft r.*iäftlfTff't*sJrcsistine he was officers the struggling were him, not telling very back, wä struggting anything doing he trim, back, not Aäiü anything tË officers were teäing l1(!'il\"I‘§J-lira! l'CSiSi,lB!l££,_,M?f:! hard. hard. 7 8 a" or any Security or During with Griffin Griffin Security employees with the incident incident did did you observe Duríng the observe any employees neck area? the individuals around their officers arms or hands, neck area? legs individuals police place their hands, aïms or legs around the police ofücers place l2 l3 A. No that. see anything like that. No II didn’t didn't see anything like t4 a or any GrifEn Security Security or During with Griffin employees with incident did did you observe observe any employees During the the incident head? his face of or in the the strike individual area officers police punch or police officers punch or strike the individual in the area of his face or head? t7 A. didn’t see No see anything tl¡at. anything like like that. No II didn't l8 l9 a. Do from? bleeding from‘? individual was was bleeding where the the individual Do you know know where I t0 ll l5 t6 2t A. a. Do the incident? incident? to the police department respond to to respond department to Do you know know who who contacted contacted the the police ,),, 23 24 25 26 A. 28 a. At what point point did on the the scene? scene? arrive on At what did EMS EMS arrive A. get off II believe able to to get was able off When II was up. When police showed showed up. the police when the they showed showed up when believe they there. the was already already thereambulance was the individual individual the the ambulance a. individual who Did creating the the was creating who was the individual treating the crew treating tlre ambulance ambulance crew Did you observe observe the disturbance? disturbance? A. No the rest. police handle handle the rest. let the the police away and and let al¡eady walked walked away that. II had had already didn't see see that. No II didn’t a. Were incident? of this this incident? Security employees as a a result result of injured as Griffin Security employees injured Were any Griffin 30 3t 32 JJ 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4l 42 it was No police the police someone say the employees. II heard heard someone the festival No II think was one one of of the festival employees. think it their tleir way. were were on on 27 29 spit ingf}.A . . 'b'å-It It he was was sprttrnq¡r. his mouthbecause mouth because he from his to me me like like he he was was bleeding bleeding from It looked looked to thought the struggle. stn:ggle. he bithis bit his tongue tongue during durÍng the thougfrt he 20 43 Did incident? the incident? police officers during the officers during to the individual say anything anything to the police the individual Did the A. clothes said they No on our our clothes individual's blood on had the the individual’sblood We had were fine. fi¡e. We everybody said they were No everybody from what and that’s that's what face and the face was hit hit in in the spitting. Brandon that he was told me me thathe from him Brandon told him spitting. whole the started ttring. started the whole thing. 44 Prosecutm‘ ,"or""ubìù: P File File 3195 95 Filed 08/04/16 Page 97 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1234 ©\o®lO'J‘IDxLA[QnI Statement J. Neri Neri of Andrew Andrew J. Statement of Page 10 Page 10 a. 2 t 4 A. 5 6 7 8 l3 14 t4 15 l5 16 l6 17 l7 18 18 19 19 20 2A 21 2t 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 ‘ No knew he he was him and and II knew was to him talking to heard him him talking who it it was, II just heard No II have have no no idea idea who tell him the heard I holding kicking. I heard him tell the stopped kicking. leg because the individual individual stopped holding his his leg because the individual embarrassment. an embarrassment. was being being an he was individual to to stop stop because because he a or ailments At during the the ailments during of any injuries injuries or complain of point did did the the individual individual complain At any point incident? incident? A. He just kept No struggling. kepl struggling. iqiuries. He about any injuries. didn't say or or complain complain about No he he didn’t a. an ambulance? Did place in ambulance? in an being place the individual individual being Did you observe observe the A. No that. No II didn't didn't see see that. a. incident? Did the incident? videotaping the or videotaping photographs or taking photographs any individuals individuals taking observe any Did you observe A. No, No,II didn’t didn't see see anyrhinh,\f a. statement at Is time? this time? at this this statement to add add to to this want to ls there anything else else you want there anything 9 ul0 -— ll ll 12 t2 or the Can police fhe police Security or by Griffin Griffin Security ernployed by the individual not employed identiff the individual not Can you identify individuals the in assisted that legs? holding legs? department department tl¡at assisted in holding the individuals A. anytl1in%)\‘.k¿$rdf [;¢’Cl'\‘\°v-\7 this more more We made this which made this happen happen which like this incident like ever have have an an incident normally don’t don't ever We normally doors. or wristbands watching of to checking checking wristbands or watching doors. II I'm used used to cause Pm struggle cause of aa difficult difficult struggle wasn’t that. like that. prepared for for something something like wasn't prepared Pr,.o,ñ,or, osgdtitofis P File 196 File C 196 Filed 08/04/16 Page 98 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1235 -t9’-‘F:Apn—a._3,\OAxUJ.Kc—U.o;‘¢°5\]‘_hu,tQ I Statement of Andrew Andrew J. Neri Statement of J. Neri Page Page 11 1l Q. a. Is time? this time? at this to add to this this statement statement at else you want want to add to Is there there anything anyttring else A. A. No. No. 2 3 4 5 6 7 I I-‘>r— 9 l0 II 12 13 TIME: 'l"uesda_\y'. TYPING ti. 2015; 2015; 8:27 8:27 PM Plvl I'uesda,v. September Septenrber 8. I'YPINCi CON(_‘LUDi:‘D CONL'I-UDED - DA'l'l: DA'I'L AND AND'I'IMh, — S'l'A'l‘l:“Ml:‘N'l’ AND Sl(:‘NA'l'URt S'l'A l'lrMIrN I Ri:'Vll:W RHVIbW AND S¡CNA'¡ URL, each page bears of 11 Ihave initials bears my initials l1 pages; eachpage I have read read this this statement statement consisting consisting of and I that in initialed corrections certify own handwriting; certiff and I that the including the including any conections initialed in my own handuriting; herein facts contained true. are facts contained herein are true. 14 l5 ló l7 t8 l9 ‘?gJPgg;\_§\_~_‘j*,1_ DATE DATE AND AND TIME: TIME: 20 I02tu.. 22 22 23 23 33 24 25 26 26 27 )1 28 28 29 29 30 31 3l 32 32 33 33 ndrcw J. J eri f4 fir/:Q~ r /:74 _>___m_ __ 7_ __ _ _ Detective Detective Brian Brian Weishrul Monmouth Office Monmouth County County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office ;Q ,q.-._,.__ ry?'' -’__ Detective Perez Detective Rosendo Rosendo Perez Monmouth Office Monmouth County County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor's Office _ ProsecL‘,ÞÍil,'" 1?l§r's Prosec File 0197 197 Case Document 63-1 Filed 08/04/16 Page 99 of 100 PagelD: 1236 STATEMENT CASE #2 15-39715 STATEMENT OF: BRIAN TOTH ADDRESS: PARLIN NJ 08859 PHONE: CELL: DOB: SSH: TAKEN AT: HOWELL TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT TAKEN NY: BET. DANIEL NEWMAN BRIAN WEISBROT- KONMOUTH COUNTY OFFICE TYPED BY: MRS. HIKKELSON WUTIVE POLICE SECRETARY DATE THEE: SEPTEMBER 5, 2015 12:00 AM Brian, l'm Det. Daniel Newman and this is Det. Brian Weisbrot of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office and here with us is Mrs. Mikkelson, a secretary for the Howell Police Department. As you know, this department is currently investigating an incident that occurred at Priediane, 1017 Route 33, Freehold NJ in which we believe you have some information. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding this incident As such, you are here today to relate this information and to describe in your own words and as best as you can the events which you witnessed. However, prior to maldng any statements, I would like to inform you that this statement may be used in a Court of Law and as such, should be the tnAth to the best of your knowledge Q. Do you understand everything I've just explained to you? Yes A. Q. Are you giving this statement voluntarily and of your own free will? A Yes EXHIBIT i Wefa 74 [3'21" Prosecutor's File 0195 Filed 08/04/16 Page 100 of 100 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-1 Filed Page D: 1237 STATEMENT BRIAN TOTH TOTH OF: BRIAN STATEMENT OF: Q. a A. A 2 Do language? the English English language? understand the write and and understand read, write Do you read, Yes Yes How in school? school? progressed in Q. have you progressed far have How far a. School A graduate. High graduate. A. High School Q. a A A. How old are are you? How old 22 22 Q. a. Are married? Are you married? Q. A. ltlfhere? Are employed? Where? Are you emploYed? Yes NJ Township NJ \lt/all Township Tech LLC, LLC, Wall Log Tech am Log Yes II am Q. a. Tech? How Log Tech? been employed employed by Log have you been long have How long A hired. A month—justrecently month-just recently got hired. A. A. A. A. A. A. No No witnessed which you witnessed Can events which the events words the own words Q. in your own tell us us in Can you tell A. 5, Priediane on the 2015? September 5, 2015? at occurred which of the on September incident of the incident which occurred at the Priediane Priediane. at was Griffin for Security at Priediane. II was A. security for Griffîn security r¡¡as working security A. II was bottles or paraphernalia glass bottles or paraphernalia for any glass vehicies for working checking vehicles working my post checking to looked he from okay from the be okay lot, When II see he looked to be parking to the parking Tim walking walking up to see Tim When didn’t he look see on closer closer look he didnt see where but on gooa distance, distance, but was a* good was, II was where II was, the of behind one jeeps He thejeeps lost. like it of of out alright. looked óut of it like iost. He goes behind one He just looked alright. He check to check there. that security guard, was cruz, another another security Brandon Cruz, BuÚd, goes up to that was there. Brandon Tim When and Tim everything. he’s when if is on see if he's alright a¡d everything. he is doing doing see see how how he on him, see and punches notices he overreacted overreacted and just punches him he to him up to coming up Brandon coming notices Brandon natural which know with aa natural I don’t eye. Brandon, with Brandon, eye. t áon;t knou¡ which eye. tJre eye. in the Brandon, in what From where. know where. From what II saw, reaction, punches him don't know back. II don’t him back. against \¡/ere leaning against when on another another vehicle, they were to check check on up to when II went went up struggling was to take take looked like the Brandon was struggling to like Brandon it looked and it Jeep and of the the Jeep the back back of the to Tim When gets the finally gets to him. detain to the him ground to detain him. When Tim to the giound him down down to last his know name, don’t don't know his last nâJne, security guard, ground, another security ground, Andrew, And.rew, another srtrd, IIhim. Bra¡rdon with Brandon that point, Brandon detaining assist At that him. At runs to assist Brandon with ou", to *r, over Tim was the fighting and Andrew other, Tim was fighting arm and was was holding the other, Andrew was an arm was holding an kicks, get loose, loose, throwing kicks, to get it could to he could that he best that the best doing the it off, off, doing the from else event, Then someone could. Then someone else from the he could. whatever he squirming, ã-oing whatever squirming, doing Andrew ar¡d Andrew Brandon and Grifiin if Brandon of see if to see up to not catne up part of A¡mn Security, came ,råt a part was. this who was He was know " help needed don't know who this person was. He anything. II don’t or anything. help or needed He came Priediane. He just ca¡ne at Priediane. event at the event wãs hosting the that was part of the crew crew that of the need if they if they or if to they see help or need help over Andrew to see if and Andrew Brandon and if Brandon see if to see ôver to {CTI}ßl.:- Prosecutor's File 0199 0199 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 1 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1238 STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: BRIAN BRIAN TOTH TOTH J needed vehicles, searching vehicles, still doing doing my my duty searching back'up. After I'm still needed back—up. After that, I’m buddies and after to that me came help your buddies out, shortly sâys go shortly after that guy came up to me and says n-ln over over to to go meaning that and and II run He tells tells me me that the crew crew from security. He meaning the from security. it looked that was from them out. But to on, going see it looked ever5rthing that was going help them out. But from everything see to go help like the most most part, for the control for under control had everything everything under like Brandon Brandon and and Andrew Andrew had Ptrt, in them in meanwhile, assist them help assist up help come up these two two other otÌ¡er gentlemen come meanwhile, these told assist me to assist told me detaining gentlemen that came up to that came Tim. One One of the two two gentlemen detaining Tim. of the Brandon and started He of Tim’s. he friend that helping was a family friend of Tim's, He started helping Brandon and that he wâ.s a family Andrew the was taking taking place, the everything was hoiding his down. While While everything Andrew by by holding his legs legs down. calm down, you’re and his friends on come Tim, you're were security and his friends were saying saying come on Tim, calm down, him calm. to Tim like Tim poínt, it it seemed seemed like trying overreacting, get get At one one point, him calm. At overreacting, to he of nowhere over when out instructions, was when out of nowhere he over was calm, calm, relaxed, relaxed, following with arms Andrew and Brandon started reacted they while they a.rms while lifting Andrew with and Brandon reacted again, started again, where know don’t I Andrew him. Brandon and held are guys. I don't know where big guys. held hirn. Brandon and AndreÌff are pretty big to control. Tim’s security Another security control. Another he was was tough to Tim's strength came from, but but he strength came Tim since Tim was detain to for he over came help Tim was guard guard working working for Griffin, GrifÏin, he came over to help detain Tim since including me, security guards, including were now now 44 security very control. There There were very tough tough to to control. friends. 2 Tim’s Tim. to addition In detain Shortly to there trying to detain Tim. In addition to Tim's 2 friends. Shortly after, there arrives on scene. Police was that arrived. Howell Police Department ¿frrives on scene. was an an officer officer that arrived. Howell Howell The Tim was to prevent put gloves on on to officer put Police officer Tim was bleeding. bleeding. The Howell Police Howell several Police getting any pathogens. Shortly after, after, several Howell Police borne pathogens. blood borne any blood else to told gloves officer officers The arrived. first scene put on gloves to everyone else officers arrived. The first officer on scene told everyone over. on took over. in and and took came in officer on scene came on scene was bleeding. The first first officer as Tim Tim was bleeding. The on as What relax and and down, relax calm down, are here, here, calm Tim, listen listen the the police are What he he said to Tim, said to The first scene. other officers on 2 that come of everything nature. 2 other officers come on scene. The frrst everything of that nature. Brandon officer scene on there and from from there replaces Tim down, and in holding Tim officer on scene Brandon in down for out and in would other officer holding Tim on, on, every other ofnîcer would step in and swap out for holding down Tim incident whole was in this role and friends. officers with the was My incident whole security this role in with the securit¡r officers and friends. to whole time time The whole if needed. needed. The back-up if and provide additional additional back—up to stand stand by and and officers slowly the and were his they is Tim taking as over, slowly and on back, they were and as the oflicers Tim is on his his he As stomach. side, on his was right him rolled onto calmly calmiy rolled him over over onto his stomach. As he was on his right side, there Before the the one arm was cuffed. Before and cuffed. back and behínd his his back was put behind that was there v¡as one arm that out he starts his is again. Tim first is flipping side, He on his side, he starts flipping out again. He cuffed, as as Tim is on first arm a¡rn is cuffed, I’m leave me off alone, off. He them to was is alone, I'm get me saying me; off me; leave fight trying saying was to them off. He is for my life. relax. and relax. calm down down and to calm him to fighting for are telling him officers are life. The The officers ambulance the noticed I advice. their to Tim not And ambulance was the noticed responding I to their advice. And Tim was not responding afterwards. II stood Brandon said until Brandon little bit, until watched aa little stood there there and and watched afterwards. We Griffin went over over all went it. We all them handle handle it. let them here, let the cops are are here, Griffin Security, Security, the to make out checked and entrance the Port-A-John to make the to by the entrance and checked everyone out to the Port-A-John by on blood on had blood sure Brandon had okay. At noticed Brandon At this was okay. this time, II noticed sure everyone was said he Brandon bruises. and for cuts other each checked We shirt. said his he Brandon his shirt. We checked each other for cuts and bruises. him. at him. blood at he was cause he was spitting blood Tim cause got the from Tim the blood blood on on his his shirt shirt from said were and each they other about were went Then said we everyone checking each other and everyone Then we went about BILT ßKr Prosecutor's File 0200 0200 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 2 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1239 STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: BRIAN TOTH BRIAN TOTH 4 all went when we we did say when okay Brandon did positions. Brandon to our and we we all went back back to our positions. okay and from the that rocked that dude that punch meaning were from the me, that gathered that that dude rocked me, were gathered Tim Tim was was aa solid solid punch. Q. A. How Security? Griffrn Security? with Griffin employed with How long have you been been employed long have since II want to May. want to say sqy since May. Q. a. What at Griffin your job title title at Griflin Security? Security? What is is your Security gua¡d. Security guard. A. A. A. A. job responsibility SecuriQr on on Q. Griffin Security with Griffin your job responsibility with describe your Please describe 0. Please 2015? 5, September 5, 2015? September A. was aa no no that was glass bottles, bottles, that for any glass to check vehicles for was to check vehicles A. My duty was paraphernalia. go, and for paraphernalia. go, and check check for describe Tim? Can please describe Tim? Can you please blond A. wouid shorts, II would black shorts, short black hâir, wearing just short A. White White male, blond hair, muscular. he 6’ 1” was 6’ built, about he 2”; was body muscular. / type built, he was say he was about 6' 1" f 6' 2"; body Q. a. Tim? Can to Tim? please tell attention to tell me me what what drew drew your attention Can you please he vehicles, he the little He the vehicles, between the little lot, between was walking walking up through the He was watched I all there. looked tl¡ere. I just watched was all he was like he seern like didnt seem looked lost, spaced spaced out, didn’t vehicles. back and to bit went him for little around turned around searching vehicles. II turned him for aa little bit and went back to searching Brandon could see I and I could see Brandon Tim and again towards Tim saw Brandon Brandon walking towards again and and saw where and Tim. Tim was a was there there was a Tim was approaching walking and where Tim approaching Tim. Tim just kept walking to Brandon was that trying It the that tryíng to rear. was was appeared that Bra¡rdon facing Jeep It appeared rear. the Jeep that was Tim punches ‘s attention punches Brandon. Bra¡rdon. get Tim out of of nowhere, nowhere, Tim and out Tim's attention and Q. A. A. A. Q. a. Can you can you he punched after he behavior after please please describe Tim's behavior describe Tim’s Brandon? Brandon? to fight fight ready to was ready He was control. He of control. out of he was was out he hit hit Brandon, he A. After After he based on another for his punch, based on his was going for another punch, he was like he anyone. He looked looked like anyone. He that was hear couldn’t I anything his that was He arms. stance. was flailing his arms. I couldn't hear sta¡rce. He was flailing Brandon said or away. too far fa¡ away. by was too being or Tim. Tim. II was by Brandon said being A. What incident? this incident? in this was your involvement involvement in What was if back needed there to was not not needed. II was It was assist, provide up if needed. needed. It back was there to assist, It control. Tim was was under under control. It appeared that Tim appeared that Q. A. A. A. Q. A. and Tim? Tim? Brandon and from Brandon Approximately were you from how far far were Approximately how Q. A. Tim? Prior with Tim’? contact with had any contact have you had Prior to to this this incident, have A. A. about 100 100 feet. feet. would say about II would KY0’ ,KÍLT Prosecutor's File 0201 0201 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 3 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1240 STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: BRIAN BRIá.N TOTH TOTH A. A. Negative. Negative. 5 None None what what so ever. so ever. Can please describe the two two other other and the Can you please describe how how the the security security guards and assisted the people people who who assisted the security hold Tim Tím down? down? security guards hold A Yes. was one one there was One was was on on one on the other arm, there Yes. One one arm, a-rm, guard on the other Q. A. A. friend on his holding both securit¡r friend holding legs, the another security both legs, the other other on his waist, and another waist, and his waist. on was guard guârd lvas on his waist. strike Tim did you At guards strike Tim while he you see he At any time, did see any security guards on the was ground? was orr the ground? A. A. No No Q. a. Tim being being held Approximately held poiice arrived was Tim Approximately how arrived was how long before before police on ground? on the the ground? A. A. Anywhere between 55 to to 10 10 minutes. Anywhere between minutes. Q. A. Q. on the the scene? scene? Approximately police officers were on officers were Approximately how Howell police how many Howell a. 8-10. I’m not A. good amount. it was Approximately 8-iO. A. I'm not sure, but but it was a a good amount. Approximately Could see what they arrived arrived after they police officers doing after were doing Couid you see what the the police officers were with Tim? on scene on scene with Tim? A. and Security and Griflin Security from Griffin were taking over the the scene scene from A. Yes, Yes, they were taking over him detained. Tim’s friends. two Keeping Tim's two friends. Keeping hirn detained, Q. a. Police officers Q. detained officers detained you please describe Howell Police describe how how the the Howell Can you A. Can Tim? Tim? A. side to to cuff cuff his right side onto his rolled him him onto A. As \ryas on his back, they rolled As Tim Tim was on his back, they Tim was started Tim him. As again. Tim was him. As they were were rolling him, Tim started resisting again. officers the his not his other to arm allowing body, to cuff cuff officers to tight keeping the not to his keepíng his other arm loose. to in other He the an attempt to get loose' arm. He kept squirming in an the other arm. Howell Police Police the Howell Approximately long did you observe observe the how long did you Approximately how with Tim? department interact interact with Tim? Q. a. A. A. Give minutes. Give or or take, take, 33 minutes. Q. 0. Tim? Were of Tim? control of able to to get control the Howell Howell Police Police officers officers able Were the Yes, they werö. they were. A. A. Could Police Township Police Q. Howell Township the Howell said by the hear anythingbeing anything being said Could you hear 0. Tim? officer to officer to Tim? Tim would A. would go you. And And Tim to help heip you. here to we're here Yes, calm calm down, relax, we’re A. Yes, of One could hear I of state resisting. into Tim's One of Tim’s a stop rage again, again, I could hear stop resisting. into a state of rage do What friends The Howell Howell you're told. told. The what you’re was saying, saying, stop stop fighting them, do friends was KT Me 0202 Prosecutor's Prosecutor, $$1r0, Filed 08/04/16 Page 4 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1241 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: BRIAN BRIAN TOTH TOTH 6 Police down and you will you don’t calm down Police told told Tim Tim you get seriously hurt don't calm and will get hurt if if you relax. relax. Was Q. know from so, do from Was there there any ambulance scene, and if so, do you know on scene, and if ambulance on A. where? where? A. There was ambulance. I’m it was would say, it was A. There was an arr ambulance. I'm not not sure, but if if Ii would sure, but Howell Howell Township. Township. Q. a Do Do you know know how how many ambulances? ambulances? I’m not sure No, I'm No, not sure Q. a. Were you able Tim? to see rendered to to Tim? Were able to see first first aid aid being being rendered II did not. did not. A. A. A A. any member During you see member of of During the the course course of did you see any of this this incident, did Griffin Tim's airway? airway? obstruct Tim’s Griflin Security or the Howell Police Department obstruct Security or the Howell Police Department Q. a. A A. . No No on scene Q. scene Approximately how Police officers officers on the Howell Howell Police Approximately how long were were the A. with with Tim? Tim? the time A. got Tim detained Tim detained A. From From the time the the first until they got lîrst officer officer arrived arrived until and 5 minutes, before 3 to was settled. settled. and cuffed, 3 everything was to 5 before everything Q. 0 A. A, add to Is statement? to add to this this statement? Is there anything further further you Wish wish to there anything No No Q a. have you give Have give you to to you to have made to been made Have any threats threats or or promises been this this statement? statement? A. A. No No Q 0. of this given the be given the you will will be Upon completion of this statement statement you Upon completion and make statement read this necessarS¡ any necessary opportunity to read this statement and make any opportunity to After deletions. corrections making any additions, making After and/or additions, corrections and/or deletions. and deletions corrections knowing and/or deletions and knowing necessary necessâfy additions, additions, corrections and/or and of best the to be truth knowledge this the to statement knowledge and your of this statement to be the truth to the best then this will accord and will sign free you then sign this given your own giverr of of your c¡wn free will and accord will you A. A. statement? statement? Yes Yes K/Zr ¿í¿l* 0203 Prosecutor's File 0203 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 5 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1242 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: 7 BRIAN BRJAN TOTH TOTH II have page bears bears my pages, each each page of 77 pages, read this statement consisting consisting of have read this statement and initials initíals, own handwriting and initials, my own in my initíals including any any corrections corrections in true. herein contained facts and I that are the and I certify that the facts contained herein are true. COMPLETED AT STATEMENT AM AT 1:40 1:4O AM STATEMENT COIIPLE'îÞD <%Z."M7 '-~ ‘ / BRIAN TOTH BRIAT{ TOTH , 7/ lo: IM1‘. 1)‘Afi1EL NEWMAN I{EWl[Ail MONMOUTH orrlcE PRosE(culoR's OFFICE t[o!{tfiouÎH COUNTY cott¡rTY PROSECUTOR'S /Dy(«Cm BRIAN WTISBROT BRIAI{ WEISBROT MONMOUTI-I OFFICE PROSECÜTOR'S OFFICE COT'TTTY PROSECUTOR’S MOITIûOUîH COUNTY BICT 8ff Prosecutor's File 0204 0204 Prosecutor's File Case Document 63-2 Filed 08/04/16 Page 6 of 69 PagelD: 1243 STATEMENT CASE 15-397 [5 STATEMENT OF: PRISCILLA BAKER ADDRESS: FALLS NJ 07725 PHONE: CELL: DOB: SSN: TAKEN AT: HOWELL TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT TAKEN BY: DET. DANIEL NEWMAN-MONMOUTII COUNTY OFFICE SGT. CHRISTIAN BY: MR8. MIKKELBOII EXECUTIVE POLICE SECRETARY DATE TIME: 5, 2015 9:45 PM Priscilla, as I'm Del. Daniel Newman of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's cum: and here with us is Det. Sgt. Christian Antunez of the Howell Township Police Department and here with us is Mrs. Mikkelson, a secretary for this department. As you know, this department is Currently investigating an incident that occurred at Priediane, 1017 Route 33, Freehold NJ in which we believe you have some information. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding this incident. As such, you are here today to relate this information and to describe in your own words and as best as you can the events which you witnessed. However, prior to making any statements, I would like to inform you that this statement may be used in a Court of Law and as such, should be the truth to the best of your knowledge. 0- Do you understand everything We just explained to you? Yes A Q. Are you giving this statement voluntarily and of your own free will? A Yes EXHIBIT W0 - osecutor's File 6&5 Filed 08/04/16 Page 7 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1244 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: PRISCILLA PR¡SCILLA BAKER BAKER 22 Q. a. A. Do understand the Do you read, read, write write and the English language? language? and understand Yes Yes Q. 0. How How far progressed in far have have you progressed in school? schooi? Associates Nursing Associates Degree Degree in in Q. a. What What is is your age? age? IIam28 am 28 Q. a. Are Are you married? married? Yes, Yes, II am am Q. 0. Where Where do do you work? work? II work Comfor at work at Comfor Care in Red Care in Red Bank Bank NJ NJ A A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. Q. a. A. A How How long have have you been been employed? employed? Since Since May 2015. 2015. events which Q. which you witnessed witnessed Can you tell tell us us in in your own the events own words words the A. Can 2015? of the incident which occurred the Priediane at on 5, September 2Ol5? of the incident which occurred at the Priedia¡re on September and LLP A. are we are A. My part of Groove LLP and we My husband husband and of Super Super Groove and II are are part Priediane. music event at husband, My hosting aa 33 day camping and and music event at Priediane. My Tim from Jeff Dave Mahajan, knew school 10 from school LO Jeff Mahajan Mahaja¡r and and his his brother, Dave knew Tim *,5l,W 'YSPve-rtl,l there and Dave assaulted About was Tim there 1fi—3a=ear»3—ago, years ago. was aa years ago. About {+pare--ago, Tim assaulted Dave and front flAQrs falling to the the front falling out year's event, Tim Tim came carne to out of of their friendship. At their friendship. At last last year’s '&qCI a volunteer. gate and from make things things right from offered to to be and offered be a volunteer. He He wanted wanted to to make the as well well as with as helping helping with the past so so Jeff Jeff allowed allowed him him to to work work cleanup crew as cleanup crew This work. of did lot and He a some was heavy year lifting. helpful This work. very a lot of some heavy lifting. He was heþful and did Jeff invited him to Friday, ali day day Friday, worked all Jelf to come come back He worked invited him back and and help. help. He but cordial also He clean and was cars. intermittently helping clean park but also cordial was very and cars. He and break drink take lot of time in Jeff asked him the to a spent aa lot of time in the sun sun so so Jeff asked him to take a break and drink a Tim near near the 5th, II saw saw Tim the a lot lot of of water. water. This This afternoon, today Sept4ember Sept4ember 5”‘, this cart At a and red He time, area. vending area. He was was very sweaty. At this time, a golf cart very red and sweaty. loud started and heard backfire. I a Tim witnessed Tim this point, II witnessed very At this started and I heard a loud backfire. At and said down ducked He and startled. become jump up and instantly become very startled. He ducked down and said at. At this time, time, At this very loudly are shot at. being shot are we we under under attack. And am am II being attack. And front the towards he behind cars gate. It began running down, he began down, ducking behind cars towards the front gate. front gate, saw per their and their protocol, and gate, checking cars, as as per saw security at at the the front of out sorts Tim the of saw one acting officers, Brandon, very very out of sorts Brandon, saw Tim one of the security oflîcers, like and acting very paranoid. was acting acting like paranoid. He He was He was was acting and very disoriented. disoriented. He he out and trying to to protect was trying he was Like he he was was being shot shot out and irrational. irrational. Like under himself. am II phrase 22 times, we under attack, am He repeated the times, are are we himself. He the phrase he was was being around; he yelling this. was looking iooking around; this. He shot? He He was was yelling He was being shot? rd] vpdrfi. ago9?} '%- pf?’ ew Prosecutor's 0206 Prosecutor's File Fi le 0206 Filed 08/04/16 Page 8 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1245 STATEMENT BAKER STATEMENT OF: OF: PRISCILLA PRTSCILLA BAI(ER J continually okay, continually searching-very is okay, searching-very paranoid. paranoid. II said everything is said everything acted as everything is everythÍng he didn’t is fine, no you. He as if if he didn't no one one is is here here to to harm He acted harm you. hear hear me me or or he he wasn’t wasn't comprehending, comprehending, like was in world. My My like he he was in another another world. first first thought traumatic thought was was that that this this looked looked like he was iike he was reliving aa past traumatic event. At poirrt, he to get event. At this this point, he was beginning to was ducking behind behind cars, cars, and and beginning close to close to the tree line Brandon, the the tree line near near the this time, time, Brandon, the the road, Route 33. At At this Route 33. with closed in the a was face, officer, him, security approached approached was punched in the face, with a closed the upper left fist, fist, by by Tim, Tim, in in the time, 22 other other cheek bone this time, left cheek area. At At this bone area. his back officers him and them Brandon on came over. security officers c¿une over. Brandon and them got him on his back on security on the the ground to one to subdue subdue him. him. One one shoulder; shoulder; one One security officer officer had had one had the other had the down. AA other shoulder shoulder with their forearms him down. with their forearms flat flat holding him third third officer drove up in in officer had had his volunteer drove his legs legs flat flat down. down. At At this this point, aa volunteer view the from if block and needed cart to to a assist, a golf cart to assist, if they they needed anything, anything, and to block the view from could see incoming stepped back incoming guest. At feet and and could see At this this time, II stepped 5O feet back about about 50 his Tim of He their to out was flailing actively trying get out of tåeir grip. arms, Tim grip. He was flailing his arms, trying to get not shaking his his head, head, trying to intensely. II could not to release release his his legs legs very very intensely. hear did Tim. distinct from I hear lot words of a just mumbling the hear any distinct words a lot of mumbling from Tim. I díd hear the officers security officers say please stay down. see Tim Tim was could see was down. At At this this point II could red and Ðleni Maltas, Maltas, very red and sweaty and member, Eleni and II alerted alerted a a front front gate staff staff member, to state to situation where is aa hostile hostile where there there is to call call 911 911 and and to state that that we we have have aa situation involved. in case case hostility in involved. II wanted there was was hostility wanted them them to know that that there to know his for concerned could I sedative administer. they safety they could bring aa sedative to to administer. I was was concerned for his safety would and of there. She to me dispatch right they reported everyone would dispatch and of everyone there. She reported to me vehicles 4 3 I’m later to 15 minutes or away. away. I'm going to say roughly 15 minutes later 3 or 4 police vehicles arrived cars and and of their their cars a¡rived on on the scene from out of the scene Howell Police. Police. They got out from Howell Tim the 10 was this to15 to situation. ran see flailing rninutes, Tim was flailing ran to see the situation. During this 1O to15 minutes, around out of grip. His non-stop, actively arms were v/ere His arms to jump out around non-stop, actively trying trylng to of their their grip. of break their out to his head his chest-like was flailing, flailing, his chest-like trying to break out of their fiailing, his head was flailing, event grip. grip. At for the the event At this this point, II was the arriving arriving guests for was concerned concerned that tJrat the in the and 12 would the the News and van scene see possibly get in the way, so so and the News L2 vart would see the scene and possibly we the view view even even car to block the had one one of of the the staff their car to block we had staff members members drive drive their more. through see just through could see bit closer and II could more. At At this this point, II got aa little iittle bit closer and the fists come or 44 times, times, about 33 or cart window, II could see 2 2 fists come down down about the golf cart couid see cart could the because was contact I but not blocking see goif cart was blocking my but I could not see any contact because the golf view. a zip tte restraint restraint zíp tie looked like like a view. II saw saw one one police officer what looked officer bring what 5 About it. with done what did I the not to see was area. over over to the area. I did not see what was done with it. About 5 minutes ambulance arrived later, the to escape. escape. II the ambulance arrived and Tim was was still still actively actively trying to and Tim 3 security officers and at could officers that point 3 see the offîcers, 3-4 3-4 officers, at that could see the officers, officers, and around to take take tr¡¡ing to were trying officers were him. II could could see see that the police officers around him. that the control their 3 him. The officers of control were relinquishing security of control of him. The 3 officers were relinquishing their control of him a stretcher and aa bag bag stretcher and police. At At this out a to the this point EMS EMS brought out him to the police. officers backed and where to where backed up to to the scene. And a:rd went went over over to the scene. And the the security security officers check his and shirt his that blood had I Brandon II was. was saw that Brandon had blood on on his shirt and his cheek was was. I saw man man We tr, Prosecutor's File 0207 0207 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 9 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1246 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: PRISCILLA. PRISCILLA BAKER Bâ.KDR 4 The blood clean shirt. blood becoming becoming very puffy. puffy. II got him him ice, ice, wipes wipes and and aa clean shirt. The had Tim’s nose B-Harieltmrnisra —)(had come come from from Tim's nose and and mouth, Brandon Brandon stated. stated. Frandsr-afso + gm: l* Cyui {— the this At stretcher statedr-that-perhaps —’l’im‘-had-bifliis"tongue. e. At this point the stretcher lq)was was next stepped back next to him and to him and II stepped ma-ke sure sure the back from from the the scene scene to to make the ' €/ _ W crowd be an crowd was was controlled controlled and and that that there there would alternate exit exit route route for would be an alternate for the the event goer's ears event goer’s police cars as the main as the main entrance several police entrance was was blocked blocked by several vehicles officers were vehicles and and the the ambulance. ambulance. At At this this point, the the officers were asking asking who who he he was was with, II stated stated he proceeded to he was was alone alone and the 44 officers offîcers proceeded to enter enter and the the the festival grounds. So festival grounds. So at at this this point II went back to went back to check check on on my staff. Q. 0 Do Do you know know Tim’s Tim's last last name? name? No No II don’t don't A. A. Q. A. Can Can you describe describe Tim? Tim? About 6’ 3” 6’ 4" broad receding About 6'3" 6'4' broad shouldered, very muscular muscular build, receding shouldered, very Red in hairline, hairline, reddish reddish brown brown hair. He was hair. Red the face and sweaty. in the face and sweaty. He was sunburned. sunburned. A. A. Can during the past few you describe Can you few days? describe his his demeanor demeanor during the past days? the few During the past few days, he help. To to help. he was was very intensely ready ready to To talk told about how husband the event was. me grandiosely My grandiosely great talk about how the event was. My husband told me about Tim has about Tim, Tim, that in the moment that in the past, Tim intense at at one one moment has been been very intense his be loose best wanted the to next moment a seemingly seemingly like cannon, his like a loose ca.nnon, the next moment wanted to be best Q. a. A. A. friend. friend. Q. a. A. A. Did Tim? Did your husband, Jeff, tell tell you how how he he knew knew Tim? Yes, my husband’s him when when {‘X’ 1:. husba¡ld's brother, Dave, Dave, went went to to school scirool with with him r( and when had out were a they they were younger and they ago when .e¿va(u they had a falling out about-1-6-years atlouffi&1¡ears ago t5' \tt{t Tim assaulted Dave. Tim assaulted Dave. (W C.‘ '^3o ' ‘I Q. you know Do you if Tim alcohol and/or know if Tim was was under of alcohol under the the influence influerrce of 0. Do drugs? drugs? A. A. II do do not. He had shorts, not, He had empty hands. hands. No No shirt. Just shorts. shirt. Just military background? military background? A. A. Q. a Do Do you know if Tim Tim had had any know if II do do not. not. Q. A. Do Tim had you know Do you any know if Tim had any if condition? condition? A. No No II was was not not aware aware of of any diagnosis. diagnosis. psychological prior prior medical/ medical/psychological A. ll? ff/ Prosecutor's File 0208 0208 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 10 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1247 STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: PRISCILLA PRISCILL/I, BAKER BAKER 5 Q. A. Who Who is is Brandon Brandon and him? and how how do know him? do you know A. officer for Griffin Security. And A. Brandon Brandon is is aa security officer Griffin And was was helping for Security. check all into maintain safe environment. and the event a cars check all cars coming coming into the event and maintain a safe environment. II did did not not know know him him prior to hired Griffin to this this event. event. We We hired Griffin Security and and Brandon of the officers. was one Brandon was one of the officers. Q. A. Was any type of Was Brandon Brandon in in arry of uniform? uniform? A. shirt with Griffin Security Yes, he with the A. Yes, he was was wearing wearing a the emblem emblem a yellow Griffin Security shirt the front and the back. on on the back. on the front and Security Securitv on Q. A. Do officers were security ofhcers that assisted assisted Do you know who the were that know who other two the other two security Brandon subduing Tim? Brandon in in subduing Tim? A. I don't know their A. I don't know their names, Griffin Security narnes, but were both both Griffin but they were officers in Griffin as well Security t-shirts, but were red. red. officers as but theirs theirs were well in Griffin Security How Did How many people were cart backfired? backfired? Did were present when when the the golf cart else his cart the initial reaction to see anyone ânyone else see his initial reaction to the golf cart backfiring? backfiring? lüy'e were A. so I’m the main A. We of the main stage, so I'm were near near the the vending area at the the top of area at if reacted. not but sure one no not sure íf anyone anyone saw, but no one reacted. Q. a. Q. A. A. A. How the vending area How far far was was the Route 33? 33? area from from Route About About 200 2OO yards. Q. A. How How did did Tim Tirn end end up near near Route Route 33? 33? A. A. Tim started between down between Tim speed, ducking down started running with with lightning speed, himself all to cars, covering cars, looking all around, paranoid, trying to protect himself by covering his himself. and ears himself, shielding blocking his ears and shielding himself, blocking himself. Q. after you alert guârd to behavior after to Tim’s Tim's behavior Did you alert Brandon Brandon the the security guard 0. Did the backfired? cart the golf cart backfired? A. cars where where between cars A. No, Tim was No, II didn't tell Brandon. Brandon. Tim was ducking between didn't tell behavior odd Tim’s noticed Brandon I Brandon believe and was working and I believe Brandon noticed Tim's odd behavior Brandon was working and concerned where that point where Tim. ItIt was was at at that a¡rd became became concemed and and approached approached Tim. 2 and Brandon then Tim Brandon and in the other punched Brandon in the face, Tim punched face, and then Bra¡rdon and 2 other the the 3 in him and hold, by over point by point the security got hold, got 3 guards ran him in the securify guards over ran and shoulders and shouiders and legs. legs. Q. a. Were safety? Were you concerned concerned for for your safety? those around A. No, around and those safety and No, II was about Tim’s Tim's safety A. was more more concerned concerned about him. lr i rtt wr Prosecutor's File 0209 0209 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 11 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1248 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: PRISCILLA PRISCILLA BAKER BAKER 6 security prior to Q. to the the security the How long long was was Tim combative with with the Tim actively actively combative A. How police arrival? arrival? A. A. II would would say 15 15 minutes. minutes. How actively combative police arrived? arrived? the police How long long was was Tim Tim actively combative after after the the that I felt little A. 20 to more. a minutes, the police poiice maybe tJ.at I felt a little more. A. At At least least 15 to 20 maybe 15 their do were there and to job, were were the they \¡¡ere the going to do their job, they were there and they they were going and they professionals professionals and would do their job. they would do their Q. A, At Q. to see see if if Tim Tim able to were you able At any time time during this this entire entire incident, were A. restricted? was airway airway was restricted? A. to see could hear hear But II could was rest.ricted. restricted. But see if if the A. II was was not abie to the airway not able airway was him him mumbling and moving mumbling and moving about. about. Q. 0 A. A, Did Did you hear t}re police saying saying anything? anything? hear the II did not. did not. Q a. Were police? by the the police? was handcuffed handcuffed by TV'ere you able able to to see see if if Tim Tim was A. A. II was was not. not. Earlier Were restraint. Were tie restraint. you described np tie described aa zip Earlier in in your statement statement you Tim? used if the on Tim? was used on you able to see able to see if the zip zip tie tie restraint restraint was A. I not. was A. I was not. Q A. a Were Q. ambulance? placed into into an an ambulance? Were you able able to to see see Tim Tim being being placed A. stretcher to or transfer the did the A. to the the stretcher to the stretcher not see see tl:e transfer to the stretcher or the A. II did not ambulance. ambulance. A. A. Q. a. Do incident? of the the incident? know of of any video video recording recording of Do you know No. No. Q. a. Do this witnessed this have witnessed who may may have anyone else you know else who know of of anyone Do you incident? incident? A. in guests Everyone staff checking in police. The The staff there talked to the the police. Ðveryone there talked to but their knew maintaining on maintaining was on focus was on, but their focus something g2iirQ_4/;i7$ /L/’/ /Z/r/~03 / DEVI". m£m’EL TYEWMATTNEWMAN- PRISCILLA BAI{ER BAKER 03 MONMOUTH OFFICE MO!¡MOUTH COUNTY COT'I{TY PROSECU'I‘OR’S PROSÞCUTOR'S OrF'ICE DET. Prosecutor's File 0212 0212 Prosecutor's File Case Documen163-2 Filed 08/04/16 Page 14 of 69 PageID: 1251 mqombumiSTATEMENT STATEMENT OF: ADDRESS 31, TELEPHONE N0: DATE Kc PLACE OF BIRTH: SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: TAKEN AT: QUESTIONED BY: WITNESSED BY: TYPED BY: DATE TIME: John Russell smith, 1 am Detective Daniel Bozza of the Monmoulh County Prosecutor's Office and present hem is Detective Robert Onenzi of the Howell Township Police Department. It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incidenl that occurmd at the Priediane located at 1017 R1. 33, Freehold, NJ involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2015' This slalemen! must be a voluntary one, given of you! own free will and award, without any Ihrems or promises, knowing that what you say may be used in a Conn ofLaw. Are you willing to give a volunlary statement at this time? Yes John Russell Smith, Jr. Howell NJ 0773] :31 .111 Howell Township Police Dcparlmem 300 Old Tavem Road Howell, NJ 07728 Detective Daniel Bozza Monmouth Coumy Prosecutor's Office DaleCtive Robert Onenzi Howell Township Police Department I ucqueline Ryan Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Satmday, September 5, 2015, 9:44 PM Prosecutor's File 0213 Filed 08/04/16 Page 15 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1252 Smith, Jr. Statement Jr. John Russell Russell Smith, of John Statement of ‘°\lO/I«>'~rJ)._ °\lOUI-BJ.)>—S I 2 3 5 6 7 I 9 t0 1t Page Page 22 a A. a. A. a. A. 12 13 l4 l5 L4>-3:Jnz.q._It¢\o°w,U,a§aut:JumN; a. A. 16 17 18 l9 20 2l“' "t') a. ,4.. a. 23 24 25 26 27 2E 29 30 3l 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45Ln A. What age? is your age? What is 46 46 rühat is What is your occupation? occupation? Howell Township PD Full Township PD forHowell EMT for part time time EMT Dock Builder, Builder, part Full time time Dock What your formal education? is your formal education? What is High college some college High School, School, some Are married? Are you married? Yes Yes Can Language? English Language? the English and understand understand the read, write write and Can you read, Yes. Yes. the surrounding the circumstances surrounding It tlre circumstances questions regarding regarding the to ask ask you questions is our oru duty duty to It is NJ Rt. 1017 Freehold, at 33, located Priediane Freehold, NJ the Rt. 33, occurred that at incident incident that o*urr"ã at the Priediane located at 1017 in tell us Can 2015. please your 5,2015. Can you please tell us in Timothy Harden involving September 5, Harden on on September involving Timothy incident? this of have words what incidcnt? own knowledge you this of have own words what knowledge possibly of aa possibly at approximately report of on radio We for report 14:58 for approximately 14:58 radío at dispatched on were dispatched We were nded and I and res Patrick Troy I res¡onded and intoxicated subject partner Patrick Troy and subject at My parfner Priediane. My at the the Priecliane. intoxicated arrival we Upon our arrived ou¡ anival we observedlþolice later. Upon 10 minutes minutes later. approximately 10 a¡rived approximately another to us, II don’t don't the into lot, West pefson came came up to officer parking running \l/est into the parking lot, another person ofücer running where for was by looking that were we was by where the that for said and he who know was and said thåt ttre person that we were looking know who heias in which to direction best the then us officer was the He then gave us the best direction in which to to. He police officer was running running to. the police of the one Brandon Cruz, I them. At closest to point I saw saw Brandon Cruz, one of the that point At that to ihem. get get our a¡nbula¡¡ce closest ãur ambulance disheveled in state, he a were arms were was his arms who state, his was there, disheveled security people who was there. he was in a iecurity people if there asked me He dirt. in covered was if there was clothes me his and were asked in blood covered covered in biood and his clothes were covered in dirt. He me a and minute, him of give off blood I.said give me a minute, anything clean the the blood off of him and Isaid that could could clean had that anything II had ambulance got out in, the walked parked out walked I itit and and got back parked to I’ll ir¡ pulled ambulance pulled the right you. get right back to you. I I'liget his stomach, he’s on the found his stomach, on where prone we patient, he's around a car parked car where we found the patient, arorind alarked that point polioe officers are officers are 4 or or 55 police point either either 4 at ihat handcuffed, actively He has has at fighting. He actively fighting. handcuffed, around his flexcuffs of had a also He pair of flex cuffs a¡ound his getting up. up. He also had a pair trying irom getting him from to keep keep him t¡ying to he was at kick blood at to spitting blood everybody, was spitting he he was activelytrying ankles, kick everybody, *nãs, he was actively,.yine io him calm to down, was trying Officer dowrU calm^him to Migdon had he nose. trying a was bloody nose. Of1ìcer Migdon everybody, everybody, he had a tiooây Officer his had right arm, Officer officer lefi his right Murphy had Officer cãnaty had his Ieft arm, officer Mu¡phy had his officer Conaty waist trying to trying to his waist and his knees and his knees Bonner was between between his Austin was legs, Officer Officer Austin his legs, had his Bonner had life. for dear on holding on for dear life. was holding everybody was like everybody gîound and looked like it looked keep and it the ground on the him on keep him Officer restrained. him to Migdon Officer Migdon keep restrained. that were him It keep struggling to was they apparent that they were struggling It was apparent observcsfiblice _ //,File Prosecutor's 0 14 Prosecuto s File 0214 Filed 08/04/16 Page 16 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1253 Statement of Statement John Russell Russell Smith, Smith, Jr. Jr. of John Page Page 33 1I 22 3J 44 5{ 66 77 8I 99 10 10 11 II 12 12 13 I3 14 l4 15 l5 16 t6 17 l7 18 I8 19 l9 20 20 21 2t 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 3t 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 40 40 41 41 42 42 43 43 44 44 45 45 continuously unintelligible words, words, in an an unintelligible continuously tried tried to answer in to talk talk to to him him and and he he would would answer at make he one he talk but he didn’t able what to was was point sense, at point saying one any he he was able to talk but what he was saying didn't make him not and I’m die I’m was we you’re telling you're not gonna die, gonna die and we kept was saying kept telling him sayíng I'm gonna die, I'm gonna Officer Migdon gonna die him listen you. Officer telling him listen you gonna was telling die we’re we're trying trying to Migdon was to help help you. have give you I'll give get you help said I’ll and Tim Tim said have to to calm calm down, down, we’re we're trying help and tying to to get he was somebody spit at that he was help and noticed that somebody to to fucking he spit at the the Officer. Office¡. II noticed fucking help and he The 8 of us he’s he he’s and are was sweating. red, massively us are massively sweating sweating and he was flushed, flushed, he's red, he's sweating. The 8 of the stretcher and onto the ofl‘ to figure trying ground and onto the stretcher get him tryrng fo figure out out how how to him offthe ground to best best get without to do do was w¿u put an an Ninitially tried tried to Nwithout hurting hurting him or anybody anybody else. What we we initially him or else. What from That him 95 mask on his it’s dust mask us. to over a spitting face, prevent 95 mask over his face, it's a dust mask to prevent him from spitting on us. That the seconds until took his was it across across the dragged it was successful successful for for 10 face and and dragged 10 seconds until he he took his face that he Oflicer his and mask with ground. got that a¡rd we gound. Officer Murphy we Murphy had equipment, he got had a a spit spit mask with his equipment, able to were yelling he's still still yelling were able to put that entire time time he’s tl¡at over mouth and face. The The entire over his his mouth and face. still fighting we was unintelligibly. periods of of violence violence were unintelligibly. At were At this this time time we was still the periods fighting but but the like less almost have intense would less and then he a and period for rest period less intense and less frequent for frequent and then he would have almost like a rest like 10 this 2 lighting again. this II like During;a} 10 or or 20 20 seconds and then again. Durin seconds and then he would start start lighling he would don’t donnt know we know exactly exactly when from MONOCûtrt¡sc we wlrcn we requested the the ALS Unit from we requested ALS Unit be able We that weren’t him to restrain were to hoping going during going transport. hoping weren't to be able to resffain him during transport. We were that on his they to roll they would would be be able able to we tried tried to roll him to sedate his stomach, stomacþ we him sedate him. him. He’s I{e's still still on onto we tried side, the got his onto his his side, side he he got his knees knees up the second sccond that on his his side tried to him on that we to roll roll him and and tried point tried to At this ttris point his stomach. to stand stand up requiring requiring us us to to roll back on on his stomach. At roll him him back ALS is other is and the Joe one one Jeremy Zimmerman, arrives, II know is Jeremy ALS arrives, know the other one the one is Joe Zimmerman, the and II the situation don’t know what his last is and assess name immediately don't know what his last name is and they and they immediately assess the situation and that Tim be needed sedated and one to them, II don’t agreed that Tim needed to be sedated and recall who who made agreed made a ofthem, don't recall one of a doctor requesting to the phone phone call point II witnessed witnessed Patrolman Patrolma¡r call to the doctor requesting sedation. At this this point sedation. At Bonner Bonner was leg and holding his right leg and Tim was holding left leg leg and Tim's right his left and Pat Troy was was holding holding Tim’s Tim Pat Troy able lift his of them to off 2 the while the onto were was hanging legs ground was able to lift his legs offthe ground whiletl¡e 2 of them were hanging onto him. him. The in The reason reason that particular instance Bonner is that II mention because Ofiicer Officer Bonner mention that that particular is because is in inst¿nce is and lbs 280 is 6’0” estimation lbs and probably 6’5” my estimation probably and it 275lbs Pat Troy Troy is 600" and 280 lbs and 6'5" and and 275 and Pat it do that. was Jeremy informed informed Joe Joe that was remarkable remarkable that that Tim physically do that. Jeremy Tim was was able able to to physically that 2 later of they good for sta¡ted to to ready they were were good for 22 now now and Zimmerman started ready Joe Zimmerman and2later of Adavan. Adavan. Joe the started to drugs, this point II started ca¡diac monitor, started to to dry the cardiac rnonitor, Jeremy this point dry Jeremy started to ready the drugs, ready the leads off the offthe upper body body of on him. him. At Tim so of Tim so they they can can put the cardiac monitor leads on At the cardiacmonitor that Conaty or point II don’t that point said is is he don't know know if or Officer Ofücer Murphy Murphy said he if itit was was Ofiicer Officer Conaty breathing? placed breathing? We not. We We placed that he was was not. We rolled rolled him and it him over over and it was was apparent appârent thathe the in him him in the and his him cot reeves on a back of him in the reeves on his back, placed him on of the back, placed the on a cot and put him in the back had ambulance. Inside pulse, we ambulance. no pulse, we Inside the the ambulance ambulance we that he had no we ascertained ascertained thathe airway, he immediately was initially initially immediately started get an he was started CPR. CPR. Jeremy Jeremy tried tried to to get an airway, him unsuccessful around and because of the that blood was mucus on his his face, u¡rsuccessful because of the blood and mucus tÏat was around him on face, we we his in IV started able suction that Zimmerman Joe to an out. were leg. Jeremy were able to suction that out. Joe Zimmerman started an IV in his leg. Jeremy was was successfixl drugs ALS ALS gave him him what drugs successful in in obtaining an airway, airway, II don’t know what obtaining an don't know but continued got a pulse back, pulse rate CPR. We continued but we we got we stopped stopped CPR. a pulse back, had had a a pulse rate of of 68, 68, we 'We to to ventilatehim then declined necessitating the the ventilate him using using a bag mask, rate then declined necessitating a bag mask, his his heart heart rate hospital and resumption continuing with with CPR, resumption of and continuing CPR" CPR. We heading to to the the hospital of CPR. We started sta¡ted heading code room arriving into the the code room at arriving approximately approximately 10 him into at 10 minutes minutes later. latcr. We We wheeled wheeled him M()N()(%-‘rfitsc /3 5 Prosecutor's File 0215 15 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 17 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1254 Statement of John John Russell Russell Smith, Jr Statement of Smith, Jr. 4 Page Page + Jersey wait by to wait by Ofiicer Offrcer asked to over CPR. We were were asked Jersey Shore, Shore, the the hospital hospital staff staff took took over CPR. We back cleared to McDonald until Office said come the Prosecutor’s we were to the the McDonald until the Prosecutor's Office said we were cleared to come back to assist him could if Police to roll roll us if we we could assist him to Zuppa asked asked us Police Headquarters. Headquarters. Detective Detective Lou Lou Zuppa him in doing assisted him him in doing so pictures of his back. We assisted so could take back. We him to his side side so so he he could take pictures of his to his and then instructed he return to to us headquarters. and then he instrucæd us to retum to headquarters. 1I 2) 33 44 55 66 77 8I 99 10 t0 11ll 12 t2 13 l3 14 14 15 15 16 t6 17 17 18 18 19 t9 20 20 21 2t 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 35 36 36 37 37 38 38 39 39 Q. a. How a per—diem per-diem EMT the Howell Howell employed as EMT with with the How long long have have you been been employed as a PD? Township Townshíp PD? A. A. rü/all Township. II thinkit’s diem in Township. in Wall think it's 66 years but but I’ve I've also also worked worked per diem a. Have Have you had had any training training to to become become an an EMT? EMT? A. A. Yes practical and and written written passed boththe had the Yes I’ve I've had the required required EMT course and and passed both the practical EM'I course examination. examination. Q. a. At recall him him Harden do do you recall time during during your interaction with Timothy Timothy Harden At any time interaction with saying ffiying anythingspecifically? anything specifi cally? A. A. Several and he he stated stated fuck fuck take and Several times asked Tim did you take times Ofiicer Officer Mignon Mignon asked Tim what what did he said times Several and and he sense. no was you and he was talking gibberish and making you talking gibberish making no sense. Several times he said said it die”. A “I’m said “I a he said going to but he it in in a to die". can't breathe” breathe" but A couple couple of of times he said times he "I can’t "I'm going times flick_off me” several loud and perfectly and perfectly loud several times and tle fiickoffme" and clear clear voice, voice, he he said said “get "get the would us. often and to spit spit at at us. would curse curse often and then then he he would would try to Q. a. Can you please please physically physically describe describe Timothy? Timothy? Can you A. A. He Caucasian, balding muscular. balding and and very muscular. between 5’8, He was was between 5'8, 66 feet tall, white white or or CaucasiarL feet tall, addition In had arms. He and a developed upper he had had developed arms. In addition he very developed He had aveÍy upper body body and very developed He barefoot. and shirtless and was muscular he and calves very muscular thighs was shirtless and barefoot. He was thíghs and calves and he was somewhere and underwear underwea¡ pounds. He wearing shirts shirts and He was was wearing somewhere between between 200 200 and and 225 225 pounds. all thathe that had. and was and that was all that he had. Q. a. You said II can’t what was was the the and clear voice, what clear voice, stated thathe that he said can't breathe breathe in in aa loud loud and You stated significance significance of tbat? of that? A. A. In breathe and and they can't breathe they that they they can’t ln my experience experience normally normally when when somebody somebody says that is voice issued there quiet and are and it’s it's are truly tmly having having some some type type of of respiratory respiratory issued there voice is very quiet sometime with Tim. case withTim. was not not the the case sometime difficult difficult to and this this was to hear hea¡ them them and 40 40 41 4t 42 42 43 43 44 44 /2A D Prosecu P rosecufoor's r's File File 0216 0 16 Filed 08/04/16 Page 18 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1255 Statement St¿tement of of John John Russell Russell Smith, Jr. Smith, Jr. Page Page 55 II 22 31 44 55 66 7 7 8 I 9I 10 t0 III1 12 l2 13 l3 14 14 15 l5 16 t6 17 17 18 t8 19 I9 20 20 21 2t 22 22 23 23 24 24 25 25 Q. a Can please describe Can you please your encounter describe Timothy Harden's behavior encounter with Timothy Harden’s behavior during during your with him? him? A. A. He and physically of bontrol. control. He out of psychotic and He was was acting acting psychotic physically out periods of have periods He would would have of violent outbursts followed of he short calmness while rested violent outbursts followed by periods of catmness while he rested followed by short periods followed another violent outburst. immediately immediately by by another violent outburst. Q a. Is Is there there anything an¡hing else else you want want to to add this statement at this this time? time? add to to this statement at A. A. just resisting Everybody Everybody was was trying trying to to help help Tim Tim but was just everybody. but he he was resisting everybody. Q a. Is there anything you want Is there anything else else you time? want to to add add this at this this time? this statement statement at A A. No. No. lI YPING YPINç CONCLLJDHJ CONCLLJIJhD - DA ANI) llMl:: l)A II itl: AND I llviF.: Saturda_\‘. Se¡rfenrLrer 5. l{J:45 PM Sarurda¡,. September 5. ?.()l5: l[] I 5: lU:45 PM — = { '. l:i\ll:\ I Rl:-.\ Itl:\ ll-_V\ ll:\\ AND 5l(¡i\;\ Il It'l{1. ¡\Nll .\l(u’\.-\ 5 ) lL\A II l::\ll-.i\l II have have read read this this statement sfaûement consisting initials consisting of bears my initials of 55 pages; each each page bears I in and thatthe own including certify handwriting; including any corrections corrections initialed I my initialed in own handwriting; and c€rtit'that the facts contained herein true. are facts contained herein are true. 26 Rlvx { :1» M$3 5;3? 27 2E békntg'-‘ORG E a% DATE AND EE TIME: 29 LAJUo-TsKDu-34:.ai3 ,- \ /9 J.’ Ly/it/*-tf.\~ ‘Th/lit liusscl Srnithilr. / /' 30 31 "3 I 32 - Smith, Jr. JJ 34 b4$M>u.'-tonxa:1° 35 36 37 38 39 ~.‘__,,_ —» **-.--..::> ——-'-"‘-"‘_}- ~".'.7._{;»:// _ .» , ' , _,_’—;:/‘K-7’ -Héfictivc Dani 2711"" Dani Monmouth Monmouth County County Pro. culor‘ss Offlce Office 40 4t 42 J:43Lu A444:- bert Ortenzi Howell Howell Township Township Police Police Department Department Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0217 217 Case Document 63-2 Filed 08/04/16 Page 19 of 69 PageID: 1256 r; rout." rucwawm UN O'qumm;mu_ STATEMENT STATEMENT OF ADDRESS KL TELEPHONE NO: DATE PLACE OF BIRTH: SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: TAKEN AT: QUESTIONED BY: WITNESSED EY: TYPED BY: DATE TIME: Daniel Castillo Brink, New Jersey Howrn Tuwnship Police Drparumm Detective Pamela Ricciardi Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office Detective Brian Weisbmt Monmouth Caunty Prosecutor's Office Lsuxu Blasucci Monmouth County Prosecutm's Office Septemba' 5, 2015; 9:39 p.111. Daniel Casfillo, 1 am Detective Pumela Rjodardi of the Manmouth County Prosecutor's Office and present here is Dmcfive Brian Waishrot ofthe same office. 11 is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances the incident, which crowned Priediane mum at 1017 Rome 33, Freehold. New Jersey This statement must be a voluntary one, given of your own free will and accmd, without any threats or prm'niscx, knowing 111:! what you say may be used in Court ofLaw. Are you willing to give a voluntary statement at this time? Ya What is your age? Thirty sevm What is your occupation7 EXHIBIT 5 m6 Pe' JL Prosecutor's File 0218 Filed 08/04/16 Page 20 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1257 Statement Staternent of of Daniel Daniel Castillo Castillo Page Page 2z I A. Security for Operation Operation Supervisor Security Supervisor Action Action Logistic Iogistic and and Security for G1iffin’s G¡iffin's Security a. What your formal is your What is fomlal education? education? A. High School High School a. Are Are you married? ma¡ried? A. No No a. Can Can you read, read, write and understand write and understrnd the the English English Language? Language? A. Yes Yes 7 3 4 5 6 7 I 9 l0 tl t2 t3 l4 t5 t6 a. t7 t8 , r9 ¡0 ¡l ,) A. 13 !4 !5 !6 l7 :8 l9 ¡0 il t¿ i3 i4 i5 ;6 ,8 ,9 .0 .1 a ,3 .4 5 at Priediane at 1017 1017 Route Calling located at your attention Priediane located Route 33 attention to 33 Calling your to the the incident incident which which occurred occurred at have what of words in New in tell please tell us knowledge you have of in Freehold, Freehold, New Jersey Jersey , please own words what knowledge us in your own this this incident. incide,nt. '.0?>* © II work my boss boss who text from from my who said said worlc, II got aa text work for for Grifiin Griffi¡ Security. scheduled to to work, Securíty. II wasn’t wasn't scheduled I three And at went Priediane. needed work at concert extra to they o'clock. people to work aa concert at Priediane. And I went at th¡ee o’clock. they needed cxtra people When were receiving receiving the the cars, she girls that parking to she cars and a¡rd were IVhe¡r II got there, there, one of the were parking ûo cars one of the girls that were said and have section the showed where to and a to me you guys you guys pointed and said park pointed section have a park to the showed me and me me where to of this Griffin on situation. So three walked I and there I see Security top over top guys on of this guy situation. So I walked over there and I see three Griffin Security and guard, because he wasn’t wasn't wearing wearing aa because he and someone someone else else who securify guard, who II don’t don't think think was rvas aa security told Cruz Brandon Griffin me that to them, that h h ee thcre close thean, Brandon Cn¡z told me Griffin Security Security shirt. close to shirt. So So when when II get there told He to sit his me his take couldn’t hold and for on to me place. me place. told to He sit on couldn't t¿ke his his anymore hold the the guy down me to down anJrmore and for He the and were blood the hold head careful and his be with and was coming. arm cops were coming. He was arm and hold his head and be careful with the blood and the cops could sit sit on on his laying that II could his arm so that arm his wrist wrist so on his his back hand on on his layrng on back face face up, Brandon had his his hand Brandon had held "his face face and his and my and on his on his face and held his face away put my lefi right hand hand on and then then put left hand my right hand on his neck neck and from ann and and holding his arm weight on on his holding all my weight couldn't split on me. Even with with all from me me so so he he couldn’t split blood blood on m€. Even that like him until the held I him his he with lift able arm. to one me was face, police him by by his face, he was able to lift me up with one ann. I held him like that until the police was completely showed completely out He was minutes. He out for fifteen fiftesri minutes. showed up. think II was that for up. II think was holding him like holding him like that of of control. conhol. a. How Secutiry? have you been with Griffin Griffin Secutiry? How long long have been employed ernployed with A. Two months, little more. Two months, maybe maþe aa little more. a. What your job title is your title with Griffin Security? What is with Griffin Security? A. Security. Security. a. Please Security. responsibilities at Griffin Security. Please describe describe your responsibilities at Griffin Prosecutor' 0219 \(- Prosecuto r'sFile 0219 Filed 08/04/16 Page 21 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1258 Statement Staternent of of Daniel Daniel Castillo Castillo Page Page 33 1i 22 33 A. A. It what we us what we need places and need to depends on on the the event. event. We a:rd they tell us to do. It depends show up to to the the places they tell do. We show Crowd Crowd control control and and search ca¡s is were doing today. sea¡ch the tbe cars is what what we we were doing today. a. And performing security And how long have functions? how long have you been been performing security functions‘? A. A. II did did it ít for for two two years when when II used live in Argentina. used to to live in Argentina. Q. a. observed interaction Please with the interaction with the Griffin you observed Griffin individuals demeanor Please describe describe the the individuals derneaûor that that you A. A. of him. and The was speaking speaking and him. He He was offof The main he was stand up and us all main thing thing he was trying tying to to stand and to to get us all off dad. I’m kill are wasn’t to These going They are going sorry dad. They wasn't making trying to kill me. making any sense. me. I'm sorry sense. These guys are are trying wet. He to was soaking soaking wet. was crying. crying. II was He was was to send send me me to to jail. He He was was very sweaf¡/, the the he he was vqy very sweaty, didn’t I want and touch to the didn’t he I terrified because and have was bloody want to gloves didn't touch gloves and I the my terrified because I didn't have and he was bloody 44 55 66 7 8 99 I to t0 ll tl 12 l2 I3 t3 14 T4 15 t5 16 r6 [7 t7 18 t8 I9 l9 10 l0 :1 !t ,-2 12 t-3 :3 14 t4 25 !5 t6 !6 57 t7 :8 l8 39 t9 I0 i0 ;1;1 i2 ;2 i3 ;3 .4 ,4 «5 ,5 .6 ,6 .7n .8 ,8 99 -0 .0 .1.1 -2 2 33 4 4 55 Security guards. Security guards. blood. blood. a. What police arrived? What did did you do once the the police a¡rived? do once A. A. As one we police were were taking taking getting off and the the police police arrived, off of him and As the tle police of him one by by one we were arrived, one were getting off of him could I told shoulder and Brandon over. because the the over. Brandon tapped me I could get off of him because ny shoulder and told me tapped me me on on my don’t want on to spit him to spit blood police want him blood on police were face. II don't I'm holding were here here and ând II told told him him no, I’m holding his his face. his has the II And him then told let arm. And bite or me Brandon me. me going, his cop again, going, has arm. the And him me or bite me. And then Brandon told me again, Iet off him. jumped jumped offhim. Q. a. Who this individual? guards helping iudividual? restain this Who were were the the other other security security guards heþing you restrain A. Brandon and then then someone guards. II don’t names and someone know their their names don't know Brandon Cruz Cnn and anð two two Griffin Griffin Security Security guards. shirt. have didn’t a I don’t thinkworks Griffin becausehe who for else, else, who I don't think works for Griffin because he didn't have a shirt. a. Do was? the individual acting the the way he he was? Do you know know the individual was was acting A. A. said he The one one guy was all day. No, guards said day. The was up all acting up other security he was was acting one of of the the other security guards No, but but one acting up all working all day. day. eight am the¡e since sínce eight am and and said said he he was was acting working there Q. a. Were individual? this individual? with this in any way with with your interactions interactions with Were in in you injured injured in A. A. No. dirt. in the the dirt. my knees knees in from being being on Just aa little iittle bit bit red red on on my knees knees from on my No. Just Q. a. Do past? in the the past? prior contract with him in contract withhim or have have you had had any prior Do you know know the the individual individual or A. A. N o. No. Q. a. What police arrived? after the the police arived? What happenened happenened afier '\>°~/Q“ Prosecutor's File 0220 0220 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 22 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1259 Statement St¿tement of Castillo of Daniel Daniel Castillo Page Page 44 A. I .' ) a. Did them put him Did you see see thsm handcuffs? him in in handcuffs? A. able to Yes. police and and stand stand up, the police to break ûee from from the was turning break free Yes. When When he he was turning he he was was almost almost able able to back. He his behind him left was had his arm was one they his right right they had him by by one arm, his lefr atm lryâs behind his back. He was able to put his officers of used the One the off hand ground. One of the officers used aa black biack push himself him and hand underneath underneath him and push bimseif off the ground. stick and put it to bring bring his and was was able able to his right right right arm his right arm and stick that that he he opened opened up and it underneath underneath his the the to the went when his And behind underneathhim back. arm back, from to arm the back, the cops arm from underneath him to behind his back. And when the amr went to the handcuffs handcuffs on. kept get worse they put the gonna get on. worse and and then then they kept screaming screamurg to to him him calm calm down, down, it’s it's gonna the We left area it. And we can get police got it. We left the a¡ea so so we can get point, Brandon the police And at that point, told me me let’s let's go, the at that Brandon told further but I I him the stretcher Later cleaned was saw on away. away. I further but was cleaned up. up. Later I saw him on the stretchsr a. Can Can you describe describe the the individual? individual? A. He black shorts, was wearing wearing black shorts, no no He was stong. He He was was white, white, muscular, muscular, tan, unshaven, unshaven, extremely exkemely strong. five. about shirt. his would He was shirt, He would say forty five. sayhis was about forty a. stafi’ strike the Do were holding? holding? the man man you were time observe security staffshike Do you at at any time obserr¡e any security 4 5 6 7 I 9 t0 u l2 t3 l4 t5 t6 t7 t8 :9 l0 !1 t) t3 ,.4 !5 t6 arm so so he The he would would turn his arm turn police who he twisted tr¡¡isted his The police who was was right me holding his arm, he rigbt behind behind me holding his be face down. to over over to be face down. ?>*.0@ A. No. No. a. Did on the the subject? subject? use any weapons on police officers hit, kick kick or or use any police officers hit, Did you at at any time time observe obsen,e any A. The police No. the wrestling get him during the wrestling control, during under control, policc we to get him under tyrng to No. The we wresting wresting with with him him trying left Then them. we from feet of black roll small II saw right after aftcr away from them. Then we left right can roll a a couple couple of feet away saw aa small btack spray sprey can l7 that. that. l8 t,9 ;0 il a. IL ,3 ,4 .5 A. Do \Ã/ere holding holding while you were or illness illness while of any injuries injuries or if the Do you recall recall if the subject subject complained complained of him down? him down? jail. Then He was No. he would would calm going back Then he calm to jail. back to I'm going Sorry dad, dad, I’m No. He talking nonsense. nonsense. Sony was talking with air and the one arm in lifted and then he off would me and catch down us I'm guard and then he lifted me in the air with one arm and I’m down a¡d would catsh us off guard 235 pounds. 235 pounds. 6 7 I 9 0 I 2 3 4 5 ^(y Þ* Prosecutor's 0221 Prosecutor's File File 0221 Filed 08/04/16 Page 23 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1260 Statement of Castillo Statement of Daniel Daniel Castillo Page Page 55 I t 4 5 Q. a. Is there anything staternent? Is there anything else to your statement? else you would would like like to to add add to A. A. No. No. 6 7 I 9 t0 l¡ t2 t3 L4 t5 TYPINGCONCLUDED DATEAND 2015; 10:40 10:40 p.m. 15, 2015; TYPING CONCLUDED -DATE TIME: September Septernber 15, AND TIME: — l6 t7 t8 t9 t0 !I !2 STATEMENT STATEMENT REVIEW AND SIGNATURE SIGNATURE REVIEW AND II have including bears my initials initials including have read this statement statefüent consisting each page bears read this consisting of of 55 pages; each facts the that contained I and certify handwriting; facts contained that the I certifu any corrections corections initialed ínitialed in in my own and own handwriting; herein herein are truo. are true. t3 ,-4 ¿5 t6 !7 DATE AND TIME: DATE AND TIME: _Zg/S A_/9:/fl944 A t8 t9 t0 Daniel Castillo Castillo t1 J2 t3 t4 í5 i6 ï7 i8 ig t0 il .t PM cciardi: Detective Pain ela Detective P Ricciardi ela ‘R5 Monmouth Prosecutor’s Count Office Monmouth Prosecutor's Office flt û Detective Detective Brian Brian Weisbrot Weisbrot Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Prosecutor' s Office Offi ce Monmouth County ,3 Prosecutor's 0222 File 0222 Prosecutor's File Case Document 63-2 Filed 08/04/16 Page 24 of 69 PageID: 1261 STATEMENT CASE it: 15-39715 STATEMENT 0F: PATRICK TROY ADDRESS: BRICK NJ 03724 PHONE: CELL: DOB: 55": TAKEN AT: HOWELL TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT TAKEN BY: BET. 11mm. NEWMAN PAM EICCIARDI TYPED MRS. MIKKELSON EXECUTIVE POLICE SECRETARY DATE TIME: SEPTEMBER 5, 2015 8:00 PM Patrick, I'm Det, Daniel Newman of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Ofl'ice and Detl Pam Riceiardi of the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office and here with us is Mikkelson, a secretary for this department As you know, this department is currently investigating an incident of a that occurred at Priediane 1017 Route 33 Freehold NJ 07728 in which we believe you have some information it is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding this incident. As such, you are here today to relate this information and ta describe in your own words and as best as you can the events which you witnessed. However, prior to making any smtements, i would like to inform you that this statement may be used in a Court of Law and as such, should be the truth to the best of your knowledge. Do you understand everything I've just explained to you? Yes A Q. Are you giving this statement voluntarily and of your own free will? A Yes Do you read, write and understand the English language? Yes EXHIB i 0 .13-- Prosecutor's File' T0223 Filed 08/04/16 Page 25 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1262 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: Q. 0. A. A. Q. a. PATRICK TROY PATRICK TROY How progressed in fa¡ have in school? school? How far have you progressed Some college Some college Patrick, Patríck, what what is is your age? age? A A. 27 27 q. A. A. Are married? Are you married? Yes Yes Q. a. where do where do you work? work? Howell EMT Howell Township Police Police Department EMT Q. a. How How long? long? 22 1/2 L/2 years A A. A, A 2) Can which you witnessed witnessed the events Can you tell tell us in your own words the events which us in own words 2015? Priediane of the the incident which occurred 5, at on September 5, 2015? of the incident which occurred at the Priediane on September intoxicated A. A. During my my shift today II was was dispatcheclto dispatche{.1?.et, shift today an intoxicated person ai°i°i\r"all‘EJ)iie Howell Police call Route 33. at on Police PI'lCCllaI'lC, Upon other Howell call at Priediane, on Route 33. Upon arrivallö¡ie other of control our officer there officers to other 4 patient, get control of our patient, officer there were were 4 other officers trying tq¡ing to get in the The on which adult white male. was ground an was laying in patient the patient laying on was which was an adult white male. The The Priediane. was of the lot the dirt entrance a parking lot right at a dirt parking at the entrance of tJ:e Priediane. The patient was order for of him control of 4 with him in in order for laying face get control face down down with 4 officers to get officers trying to know their don’t I but the officers to I us provide patient care. recognized the offîcers but I don't know their us to provide care, I recognized There’s officers his 2 names. at the the mid mid holding officer at one officer his shoulders, names. There's 2 officers shoulders, one before arrived that officer The section officer his and feet. at just an officer at his feet. Ttre oflicer that a:rived before us us section and an then was patient. The The patient was then assisted assisted the the officer the feet feet of of the ttre patient. officer at at the handcuffed The ankles. The his ankles. patient had ties on on his behind his had zip ties handcuffed behind back. The The patient his back. at the officers and and spitting blood patient was the police officers was very combative and spitting blood at combative and of relaxation relaxation kept repeating had periods of repeating “I’m die." The The patient had "I'm gonna die.” where he would stop fighting we noticed noticed this point we periods. At At this where he would fighting for for short short periods. his all blood had over he be had what to or a face. nose, or had blood all over his face. appeared to be a bloody bloody nose, he had what appeared It that time. time. After After from at at that the blood was coming coming from was hard to tell tell where where the blood was It was hard to for a an officer we because he he a mask mask because us for combative he officer asked asked us we saw saw how how combative he was, an is which was basically aa mask which is basically was spitting blood. an N-95 N-95 mask blood. II went went and and got an police The police surgical officers. The gave the of the the police officers. one of the mask mask to to one surgical mask. mask. II gave his head officer mask on on patient. The rubbing his head on patient was was rubbing the mask The patient officer put the on the the patient, which he mask the off, to his the and shoulders which he get the ground and his shoulders attempting attempting to get the mask John did badge Smith, badge in doing. this time time my partner, John Smith, did succeed succeed in doing. During this for EMS Police Howell #967 who also works for was paramedics. calling paramedics. for #967 who also works for Howell PoLice EMs was to sedate We safely we could could safely so we him so sedate him were going to to have have them them attempt to We were there and was no combative This he was was as was no way there ar¡d transport him. very combative him. This was as he was combative be to continued The him. could we safely transport him. The patient continued to be combative we could safely Q. a, F52‘ Prosecutor's ozz¿ Prosecutor, rPuf 0224 Filed 08/04/16 Page 26 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1263 STATEMENT STATEMENT OF: OF: PATRICKTROY PATRICK TROY J and if we to see see if we me to officers asked asked me and spit blood at at the the officers. offìcers. One One of of the the officers spit blood mask. And had mask. and another of So I went grabbed an olq¡gen mask. A,nd had another type a¡r oxygen t¡4pe of mask. So I went and grabbed continue that could he II pulled the non—re-breather off so bag to get air air continue to he could the non-re-breather off so that mask that in on in and The officers successful out. not as in and out. The officers were were not successful in getting that mask on as and combative still the He his head. was was spitting patient moving and still combative was moving his head. He was the blood. he went went car and in his and he blood. One the officers his car of the officers said sajd he had aa spit mask mask in One of he had his had realized officers had it. of the At retrieve this to one gloves gloves point, had his had realized one of the officers to retrieve it. At this the control in I and to assisted ripped and I assisted in attempting to control the patient by putting my leg himself him from from hurting himself leg on on his legs in in the the area area of of his his calf calf to to prevent him his legs and returned mask else. The the officer for who went or or anyone else. The officer who went for the spit spit mask returned and put it who officer the the As soon as on came patient. had tipped ripped gloves came it on the patient. As soon as the offlicer who had had the officer off new I the because on back, I got up off tl.e patient because the officer had on new gloves. The The minute. to seconds a 30 lasted of which calmness minute. patient had a periods to 3O seconds had of calmness which lasted stated “I’m of the going to die." At to die.” At During each "I'm going each of the calm calm periods, the the patient stated he Because was feel his did was no we compromised. he was point airway Because point ainvay wâs no did we feel his compromised. paramedics have have moving The paramedics moving around around and and breathing,yelling breathing, yelling and and spitting. spitting. The I’m not 2 has which Medic Unit arrived now on paramedics. 208, I'm not paramedics. scene, 2 has which now a.rrived on scene, Medic Unit noticed medics The combative. still of their The sure names. was sure of their names. The patient was still combative. The medics noticed how heard and II heard patíent was combative the was and medic walked walked away and how combative the patient and one one medic clearance to doctor call the tell he his to his that was to his tell his partner that he was going to call the doctor to get clearance to The Howell sedate EMS is safely transport. Police EMS is Howell Police patient in in order sedate the the patient order to to safely transport. The an Narcan beside or authorized administer not to Epi pen. not authonzed to administer medication, beside Narcan or an doctor we the patient Shortly we noticed noticed the medical doctor Shortty after the phone call call to the medical after the to the which At he calm not point the was as was again. the was not breathing as he was being calm again. At which point handcuffs his \rere patient promptly put put on patient was and his har¡dcuffs were the stretcher was promptly on the stretcher and removed and patíents care care and the patients removed but the zip zip ties were not not compromising compromising the but the ties were secured the were was secured ieft on this point the patient was were left on and CPR was was started. At this and CPR started. At IV an their The medics in the ambulance. treatment, put IV line line in in ân began their in the ambulance. The medics After CPR. while and connected we were were doing doing CPR. After a¡rd connected him him to to aa cardiac ca¡diac monitor monitor while we with the and all one started that we was in our our transport medic in vrith one medic all that was sta¡ted and we began the while the with a ambulance ambulance, while my Police officer ambulance with Howell Police officer driving the ambulance, a Howell The the the medic worked I and on patient. ambulance medic ambulance partner, partner, I and the medic worked on the The medic to followed Shore Jersey Shore patient was The patient transported to Jersey was transported foliowed behind behind us. us. The the CPR Center. Medical continued We transport, during the transport, University University Medicat Center. We continued CPR 1 minute for did regain pulses for approximately / no breathing. We approximately 1 minute/no breathing. We patient did The for the breathe mask valve to patient. were a patient. The bag using breathing were a breathing bag valve mask to breathe for the of the the rest of the rest for the patient lost continued for pulses again wâ.s continued and CPR lost pulses again and CPR was The was the trauma taken into The patient was bay. was The patient bay. transport. transport. The patient was taken into the trauma over. and the transferred staff took took over. transferred to to aa hospital bed and the hospital staff hospital bed Q. a. Can patient? physically describe describe the the patient? Can you physically Prosecutor's?i1‘€ Prosecutorrfn6 0225 0225 Filed 08/04/16 Page 27 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1264 STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT OF: PATRICKTROY PATRICK TROY 4 A. about in A. He He was was aa white notice his white male, male, about in his did not not notice his hair hair his 30’s, 30's, II did He muscular. him and 250 about lbs. at just color, by looking at him about 250 lbs. and very muscular. He was by was about about 5’ 5' 11”, 11", but but he was laying down. not notice notice any tattoos tattoos or or he was down. II did did not he shirt in dark covered dirt. He soars no was as no was shorts, scars as he was covered in dirt. He was wearing no shirt no wearing dark shoes shoes or or socks. socks. Q. 0. A. A. Approximately Approximately how how long on scene before you transported? long were were you on scene before 40 minutes. Approximately Approximately 4O minutes. Earlier as being your statement, patient as yoü described Earlier in in your the patient being statement, you described the combative of calmness. combative and how many times times and moments moments of Approximately how calmness. Approximately did this behavior did this behavior occur occur while while you were on scene? were on scene? and calm. A. combative and didn’t count was combative calm. It[t A. II didn't count how how many times times he he was times lost that I count. so happened happened so many times that I lost count. Q. a. combativeness, was Q. was he During his he his intervals of calmness calmness and intervals of and combativeness, 0. During always always continuously continuously breathing? breathing? A. continually yelling I’m I'm A. Yes, Yes, he he was was because because he he was was spitting blood, blood, continually going going to feet. to die, moving his torso torso and and feet. moving his his head side to head side to side side and and moving moving his down, During the going up up and and down, the times times of of calmness, calmness, his was still still going his back back was in die he to and breathing breathing heavily and he was an angry was still still saying saying I’m I'm going to die in an voice. voice. Q. a. At patient's the patient’s observe the At any point while while you were were on scene did did you observe on scene airway airway being being restricted? restricted? A. not No, A. No, not by anyone. Did as to way? patient as this way? was behaving behaving this Did you question the the patient to why he he was him talk to to The officers II was unable Police to. were and was unable to. The Poiice officers were trying to talk to him and die. II to he that he was going saying kept get get him die. to he was him to to calm calm down. down. All he saying that All those didn’t and he the took answer heard officers ask him if he hea¡d the ofÏicers ask him if he took anything anything and he didn't answer those Q. a. A. A. questions. questions. Can were you physically ofnicers were physically describe Police officers the Howell Howell Police describe how how the Can you the controlling patient? controlling the patient? how remember A. him A. II don’t remember how each officer was was physically holding him don't each officer officer each One on their hands either with down. But it was or legs. One officer on each down. But it was either with hands or their legs. eventually 22 at one at shoulder; there at there were were eventually wâ.s one at his his mid mid section section and and there there was his lower his iower legs. legs. Q. a. Can please describe you please describe how how the the Can you him officers down? were holding officers were holding him down? Q. A. patient was while the the was acting while Prosecugrg Prosecu8G File Fite 0226 0226 Filed 08/04/16 Page 28 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1265 OF: STATEMENTOF: STATEMENT A. A. The The TROY PATRICK PATRICKTROY 5 with 55 police patient patient was was very very combative police officers combative even even \Ã/ith officers attempting to to control control him. him. Q. you hear While the the officers officers were were holding the tJ:e patient down, could could you hear A. While what the officers the to were what the officers were saying patient? saying to the patient? A. A. All All the the officers officers said said to to him that II remember officers were him that remember is is that that the the officers were calm to of we’re And to times a telling him down; him to calm down; we're trying you. And a couple tryrng to help help you. couple of asking asking him him what what he he took took or or did take anything. did he he take anything. Q. a A. A. Did Did you ever ever witness patient? witness anyone strike the patient? strike the No No Q. A. Did you witness Did you witness anyone anyone other than the the Howell Police officers officers other than Howell Police attempting attempting to to control control the patient? the patient? A. A. II did did not not witness witness it. it. II didn’t with the didn't see see anyone with the patient besides besides the the Howell Howell Police Police officer. offücer. We Police officers officers by We were directed to the Howell Howell Police were directed to the by the and who inside the were security guards, driveway the security guards, who were right they right inside the driveway and they immediately immediately directed parking lot. directed us to the front area lot. us to the front area of of the the parking Did Did you inquire as as to the injury that that was to how how the sustained the was the patient sustained bleeding? bleeding? A. do that A. II was part of was unable unable to to do that as that would have been been part of my as that would have assessment. assessment. Q. 0. Q. Why paramedics called? Why were were the the paramedics called? A. A. So the safely assess A. So the patient could could be we could assess and be sedated sedated so so that that we could safely and treat treat his his injuries. injuries. Q. you see Did you see any when II a-ny life—threatening life-threatening injuries on on the the patient when 0. Did arrived or the entire incident? or during the entire incident? A. rü/as any A. II did did not not see see anything that could lead me to believe there was anything that could lead me to believe there life—threateninginjury. life -threatening injury. Do authorizationwas Do you know, or was or have have personal knowledge, that that authorizalion treatment? the for granted to patient to the the paramedics to patient to sedate for treatment? sedate the A. A. II can’t can't answer ånswcr that for sure. that for sure. II don't don't know. know. Q. A. How you estimate breathing How long would would you was not not breathing the patient was estimate that that the before determination was before a a determination was made made to CPR? to administer administer CPR? A. that we 30 seconds he wasn’t wasn't A- ItIt was was less less than noticed that that he than 30 seconds that we noticed breathing. We did aa pulse check We did started CPR. CPR. check and and started Q. a. Prosecut<£' :File pror".uti'lr¡r" 0227 0227 Filed 08/04/16 Page 29 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1266 STATEMENT OF: STATEMENT OF: PATRICK TROY PATRTCK TROY 6 Q. a Is Is there there anything anything further wish to this statement? statement? further you wish to add add to to this No No Q. a. Have Have any threats threats this statement? this statement? No No A A. A A. Q. a. A. A. promises been you give give have you or promises to have been made made to to you to or Upon given the Upon completion you will completion of be given of this will be the this statement statement you this make read and statement opportunity necessarJ¡ any opportunity to a:ry necessary to read this statement and make additions, additions, corrections making any corrections and/or andlor deletions. deletions. After After making and deletions corrections additions, and/or necessary necessa.r¡¡ additions, corrections and/or deletions and knowing this this statement statement to knowledge and to be the truth be the truth to to the the best best of of your knowledge and then will will this free and accord own given sign given of your you you your tJ:en sign of thís own free will and accord will statement? statement? Yes Yes II have read this page bears have read pages, each bears my this statement statement consisting of each page of 66 pages, initials and own initials, handwriting initials including any and any corrections corrections in in my own my and I that the facts herein contained true. are and i certify certify that the facts contained herein are true. COMPLETED AT STATEMENT AT 9:10 9:1O PM PM STATDIilEM COIilPLEtED A/s12ZJ¢—»€~/3 _g "/y’ PAT ex 1120? rm DET. DE.T. DANIEL I¡A¡IIEL NEWMAN ITEW*[A}¡ Dari’/2”"’V3‘“‘ Rrccmnzif Def‘?. PAM PAM RICCIARDI Prosecutorfs File Prosecuffis File 0228 0228 Case Document 63-2 Filed 08/04/16 Page 30 of 69 PageID: 1267 EXHIBIT STATEMENT ADDRESS 3: TELEPHONE NO: -- Su rcvillc NJ 9 -- 10 1 DATE .2 PLACE OF BIRTH: YOHX. SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: -- 16 TAKEN AT: vaell Township Pulice Depam'nent I 2 3 4 5 STATEMENT OF: Brandon Keith Cniz 6 7 a [7 300 Old Tavern Road '3 Howell, 07728 19 20 QUESTIONED BY: Deteclive Daniel E0712 21 Monmouth Counly Prosecutor's Office 22 23 WITNESSED BY: Detective Brian Weisbmt V44 Monmouth Cnunty Prosecutor's Office 15 26 TYPED BY: Jacqueline Ryan 27 Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office 23 29 DATE TIME: Saturday, September 5, 2015, 7:53 PM 30 3| Branden Keith Cruz, I am Detective Daniel Bozza of [he Monmoulh Cuumy Prosecutor's Office and present here is Detective Brian Weishmt of the same 33 office It is our duty to ask you questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident that occurred at the Pdediane located at 1017 Rt, 33, Freehold, NJ involving Timothy Harden on September 5, 2015. This statement must be a voluntary one, given of your own free will and accord, 37 38 without any threats or promises, lmuwing that what you say may be used in a 39 Court 01' Law. 441 4' 42 Q. Are ycu willing to give a Voluntary statement at this time? 4: A. Yes. Prosecutor's W5 0229 Filed 08/04/16 Page 31 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1268 M"‘°\lOLn.:mtq qaxLnAt.um—-o~e\1g§i)'‘32";°>GI_, Statement Statement of of Brandon Brandon Keith Cruz Keith Cruz 2 Page Pagez I a What your age? is your What is age? J A. 3355 a. What is your occupation? What is occupation? A. for Griffin Griffin Security. Security. Currently diem for basis but but work work per diem on aa full full time time basis Currently unemployed unemployed on a. What education? What is is your formal formal education? A. High High School School a. Are Are you married? marned? A. No No 17 a. Can Language? English Language? read, write the English Can you read, write and and understand understand the l8 l9 A. Yes Yes II can. can. ) 4 5 6 7 8 9 t0 u l2 l3 14 I5 l6 20 2t a. 12 ‘-flwmuoatq ¿3 24 this incident? you have ofthis incident? have of 25 26 27 28 29 30 3l 32 A-hLn.u:—m.tx,;~>_°t 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 42 43 44 ¡ ~..5 duty to to ask ask you is our our duty Calling It is circumstances regarding regarding It attention to to the the circumstances Calting your attention that occurred incident the the circumstances at questions regarding surounding the incident that occu¡red at questions regarding the circumstances surrounding the Timothy Harden Ha¡den on on involving Timothy Freehold, NJ NJ involving Priediane located at 1017 l0t7 Rt. Rt. 33, 33, Freehold, the Priediane Iocated at 2015. Can knowledge what knowledge words what September please tell own words us in in your own tell us 5,2015. Can you please September 5, A. w 9”’ vclyplcs algeiti the front entrance. Some hired to to screen We were hircd the in the timo in Some time at the fî'ont entrance. We were screon vehiçles at for asked and down .<:ccurity"s in cart aftemnon came a sccurity's asked gentleman for gentleman down and in al$Tfd cart came aftemoon a escort sottleone assistance. go. II got someone and OK let’s let's go. said OK and II said to escort only word assist¿nce. His His only word was was to with a the security and the into guard golf cart along with a security guard proceeded up the driveway driveway along into the golf cart and proceeded Andrew gentleman being being saw the the gentleman of the the hill hill II saw to the the top top of Neeri. As As we we came ca¡ne to Andrew Neeri. of the escorted the person II was was was the took it it as as this this was festival. II took the festival. esco¡ted by another worker of by anotherworker there was no his own he however on assist to was was no walking with, there power, coming coming to assíst with, however he was walking on his own 20 walked and cart the exited that time I approximately 20 golf cart and walked approximately given. At support At that time I exited the golf support given. feet We entered entered exit. We the exit. gentlemen as toward the walking out out toward were walking as they they were feet behind tlre gentlemen behind the and Andrew I the walked both and into the back cars, through And¡ew I and the they parkingarea through walked back into the parking'area and they both back to where we walked were working we were lhem bothin both in kept them working in s¡ea. II kept ficld area. the open field in the walked back to where the road. closest to the exited area as they A few few i as parking area closest to the road. A fhey exited the parking treye shot shot jrreLiu*ele*rd and started shirt moments running ducking and running gentleman withoutthe without the shirt started ducking by thatthe that the gentleman went by moments went of the outside of around parking lot. ran up to to lot. II ran the parking the outside on the Ford Explorer Explorer on the vehicle, vehicle, a a Ford a¡ound the he vehicle and of the side the the vehicle and the met on and he passenger side of the vehicle gentleman on the passenger the vehicle and met the gentleman play to play we wanted wanted to immediately ask if if we began to to ask and began appearance and stopped on on my appearance immediately stopped of the worker other the think I all I love I of the worker absolutely, sports. the other replied úink rugby, sports. I love all replied absolutely, I I rugby, about Neptune festival remember don't remember High School, School, II don’t Neptune High asked him hiln something something about festival asked he duck was started squatting with frozen, to he squatting again, with flozen, immediately exactly what, he inrmediately started to duck agun, he was exactly what, Veye Y 65"’ Prosecutor's File ( J230 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 32 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1269 Brandon Keith Statement Keith Cruz Cruz Statement of ofBrandon °\l0'~I:-Auto. I 2 J 4 5 ‘°\lOxUn.k[g:So *°\to~u.4>e:i_"'-— 6 7 I 9 10 ll G-“Wits'Eg\5’l:3§8S°N*~on t2 t3 14 l5 t6 l7 l8 l9 20 2l 22 )3 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3t"‘ 32 JJ 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 42 A4: 43 44 t5 Page Page 3r extended out side' Then Then he he his to side. side to from side looking from he.was looking and hewas to his his side side and out to arms extended his arms and I side driver as the vehicle to of the the around‘ and as I darted rear driver side completely around'the rear of the vehicle to the darted completely get to he was to the the driver driver As II get the vehicle. vehicle. As followed a¡ound the back around was already coming back already coming followed he he and him face to around punched turned purched and I he around he and me him came comer to face rear around and I turned me he came around rear comer arould anns around in my þe wrapped my arms me left cheek. cheek. II wrapped face with in my left ha¡rd in right hand with his his right me in I wanted to of the the into him rear Explorer, turned I I wanted to and level chest at his torso his torso at chest level and i turned him into the rear of the Explorer, his I where is this and legs grabbed this and create point and this is where I grabbed his legs and at this point us at no distance distance between between us crearo no tried I to and then back his rolled he then on and side his I tried to him to and then back his on rolled then he just dropped arrd dropped him to his side so II proceeded use an an armbar to use armba¡ proceeded to mount got over over so leg never never got to subdue subdue him, hím, my leg him to mount him Andrew his other arm. grabbed grabbed to Andrew for and I grab his other arm. A¡drew on yelled for Andrew to grab his right amr and I yelled right arm on his this At this his resisting. At right arm stopped resisting. he stopped and he arm and arm, II continued his right to hold hold his continued to otheiarm, his other he what remember was don’t I but normal he in manner what was started he a remember don't I talking but manner point a norrnal point he started talking in gUy. At At some some big guy. he was was aa big because he him because saying, II was holding him concemed holding was more morc concerned iaying, his He was resist. started to curling he and his him was curling point again and he started to resist. He point something aggravated him again something aggravated to the off lift ground to Andrew and ground both myself to arms myself and Andrew to lift up off the was causing causing both amls which which was the forearm to force more to I forearm the touched to backs force put where proceeded more our proceeded to together. I where our backs touched together. kept my and II kept and his resisting and stopped resisting ground and he stopped and he it to to the the ground elbow and and forced forced it and his elbow him and again down. aggravated him hold again and Something his him chest arm to to hotd him down. Something aggravated on his arm chest weight weight on his to leg he was get his leg. he tryine to get g¡rmnast, he was trying like aa gymnast, all the tlre way way up like his legs legs all brings his he brings and times 3 2 around or this did he off of and then then times 2 or 3 head to him, me around around this did he push him, push me offof lny head to around my if asked they his Somebody they asked if know I legs. don’t who, grabbed Somebody legs. else, somebody else, I dón't know wüo, grabbed his somebody as calm calm as as the the should not as point he he was was not yes. At this point At this police and replied yes. the police and II replied call the should call I then and around he and he other times moving around and then I was moving sfrong and he was as strong h" was was not not as times and other -d saying II don’t be OK. to is but how many but know how rememberhim going don't know everything going be OK. to is rernember him saying everything and of actions calming those resisting and calming of him several resisting of there repeating actions were those p"rio{r of him repeating there were r"u"r"l periods noticed Daniel At some Castillo, Daniel Castillo, point II noticed down. soms point stòp. At y"iting for to stop. for him him to stâ¡ted yelling dor¡m. II started I that was the arm take him to I asked and on arrived and I asked him to take the arm that I was on another guardanived security guard another security sit this to Daniel on told I and this We to sit on exhausted. Daniel positions becauseI I told changed was positions and because I was exhausted. V/e changed back next take right and a I steps couple did. he right next what back is and that steps cotrple a arm get guy’s arm and that is what he did. I get up and take guy's noticed that and I face his and on blood noticed that that I there was and spit noticed and I to io Daniel baniel and I noticed that there was blood and spit on his face I also onto his of nose out people. blood he blowing blood out of his nose onto people' I also and blowing spitting blood blood and was spitting he was grab his to grab his jaw down blood proceeded to thatI had noticed then proceeded Daniel then arm. Daniel left arm. noticed that I ñad blood down my left blood spit on on him him getting blood spit and not getting was not so he he was him so from him face away away from his face to force force his and ear ear to 1I At one arrived. point the officer until point in At one and stayed in until the ofhcer arrived. position we we stayed the position was the and that that was to he and blood of lot proceeded advised him officer arrived, was aa lot of blood and he proceeded to put that there was him thatthere arrived Ilã¿v¡sed officer another officer to arrive a¡rive advised that officer to for another to wait wait for on wanted to he wanted gloves. He tl¡at he He advised his gloves. on his contact made he When in eye contact all made him he position. stayed we position. Whcn so before handcuffing him so we all stayed in before handcufling to able move. wasn‘t he but little move. resist more to started to the officer with to resist aa little more but he wasn't able he-sta¡ted ofücer he with the 2”‘ officer for the arrived the-2nd yelle.d for ofñcer oflicer another after officer yelled initial officer the initial and the Shortly anived and another officer Shortly after wrist his have could the scooted his wrist officers so have believeDaniel could I his of,ficers up the so grab gloves. I believe Daniel scooted g¡ab his gloves. immediate]y put my knee his slemtun stemum across his to resist knee across then he qtar(ed to and again, II immediately resist again, an¿ ttreohe At 5011]!) down. him point to poin{ somc in keep At his chest an attonrpt to kecp him down' put my rlffS across his o[est in an attempt t')V"'to took 1 then '171Þt:oput h:tndcul'fhim. ""ross could he him so roll him to roll he wanted officer said the officãr so he oould handcuffhim. I then took my wanted to said he the asked Daniel Daniel side' II asked and put it on the right side. his right knee ground along along his the ground at on it at chest a¡rd offhis chest knee ofi"his his him onto roll to and his onto his arm began took him roll I and stand to right began to and to arm slowly sta¡rd and I took his right to begin begin to slowly staged W Tì^' (i Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File ( 231 31 Filed 08/04/16 Page 33 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1270 Statement Keith Cruz Statement of of Brandon Brandon Keith Cruz Page Page 4a armbar becausehe point and at at this this point to resist resist and started to belly. put his an armbar because he started arm in in an his right belly. II put right arm the couldn’t I other see his II hear arm arm, I couldn't see the arm yelling for him to to release release his other arm, the ofiicers ofücers yelling for him hea¡ the arm up to because to the the bring his his ar¡ri to bring began to turned towards him. II began towards him. back was was turned because my back of hold the ofiicer take the then I and his back held it there right of and saw center hold of the right center of his back and held it there and then I saw the ofücer lake know how don’t back. I had and I released that I arm cornpletely back. I don't know how so I released and stepped stepped completely ann that I had so I 2 J 4 5 6 7 I 9 l0 ll t2 l3 t4 l5 ló 1'7 18 t9 20 2t 2 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3t 32 33 34 35 36 31 38 .>€@,p a. have you been How Security? with Griflin Gdffin Security? been employed employed with How long longhave A. On and off for 22years. years. Onandofffor a. What your job title is your Security? title with with Griffin Gdffin Security? What is A. Supervisor. Supervisor. a. Security? Please Griffin Security? with Griffin your responsibilities a Supervisor Supervisor with as a responsibilities as Please describe describe your A. @?>'.O client. As am We’re supervisor II a¡n security to As aa supervisor provides security to a a client. sect¡rity that that provides We're contracted conüacted security site and maintain and maintain on site point of the client client on responsible contact for for the of contact to be be the the point responsible to of staff. supervision ofmy my staff. supervision a. How performing security fi.rnctions? security functions? been performing long have have you been How long A. for 15 On 15 years. O¡r and and ofi offfor a. what was was his When demeânor? his demeanor? Mr. Harden Harden what initially contacted contacted Mr. first initially lVhen you first A. and appeared appeared to He be calm. calm. to be cigarette and smoking aa cigarette was walking walking and and smoking He was a. do you recall recall You stated ducking around Explorer do the Ford Explorer around theFord &ganducking that lvfr. Harden Harden began You stated thatMr. behavior? this initiated have could that behavior? anythinghappening anything happening that could have initiated thís A. II don't don’t know. know 39 40 4t 2. II saw officers were can of of pepper saw the the can than2. more than many but there was more therc but there was many offîcers were there I and this there is scene advised I and pulled out my guys pulled come I and scene is there my guys this spray spray come out and I advised the all walked and lot of the side that all We on way up the the the stayed on that side of the parking parking lot and walked all away. away. We all stayed because there the to scene unable of the see of view I out driveway was unable to see the scene because there scene. I was driveway out of view of the scene. several car and was and several I't officers officers car golf carts, the 15‘ was the vehicle, II believeit believe it was many golf carts, 1I vehicle, was many also couldn’t was because I was anything becauseI hear anything patrons and couldn't hear the tent. workers under tent. II also and workers under the ambulance thenI and an saw officers far from the were More arriving too scene. an ambulance too far fiom the scen€. More officers were ariving ar¡d then I saw arrive. At and II scene and on the t}te scene pararnedics on point II looked the paramedics looked up and and saw saw the At some anive. some point don’t got there. there. when they they got don't recall recall when 42 43 14 {DH/’ þv\.-- (i Prosecutor's File ( 2322 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 34 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1271 Brandon Keith Statement Keith Cruz Crue of Brandon Statement of Page 5s Page \1OU-I:Lul. a. would you how would During he hit hit you how after he your interactions Harden after with Mr. Mr. Harden interactions with During your his behavior? describe describe his behavior? A. aggressive. He and aggressive. strong and to extremely extremely strong calm to from being being calm erratic. He He went wrnt from He was was erratic. a. Do was? he was? acting the the way he know why why Mr. I{arden was was acting Do you know Mr. Harden A. and enatio erratic behavior II don't don’t know. he was was on would say he on behavior II would upon his his strength strength and Based upon know. Based of some drug. some type type of drug. I 2 J 4 o\.1xu4~t,;N_° 5 6 7 E u3m's.§S’E;fig‘¢lLtk_wN,M 9 10 t1 t2 I3 14 l5 l6 1',l l8 l9 20 2l 1,2 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 a. Can Mr. Harden? describe Mr. Harden? Can you describe E1’ A. 225 lbs., extremely White that we time that we At the the time probably 6’2, muscula¡. At extremely muscular. 6'2,225 bs, White male, male, probably hair blonde short clean found shaven, short blonde hair shorts on, clean shaven, him he he only only had had shorts found him a. Can punched you. Harden punched please describe how Mr. Mr. Harden describe how Can you please A. It left cheek. cheek. a right right hook to my left hook to It was was a a. Did sustain any injuries Harden? Mr. Harden? with Mr. interaction with injuries from from your interaction Did you sustain A. Slight bruising left cheek. cheek. to the the left Slight bruising to a. Did left cheek‘? cheek? to your left itjury to for the the injury medical treatment treatment for require any medical Did you require A. No. No. a. Have you ever Hmden? prior contact with Mr. Harden? contact withMr. ever had had any prior Have ?’r.O>»/_ A. 3t 32 33 34 a. Did attending to Harden? to Mr. Mr. Harden? personnel attending observe the the EMS EMS personnel Did you observe A. the ambulance. a¡nbulance. into the and put into Only raised and being raised he was stretcher being when he was on on the the stretcher Only when a. andlor speaking and/or was he he speaking Mr. Harden Ha¡den was During interaction \¡/ith Mr. tåe course cou¡se of of your interactionwith During the statements? making any statements? making A. OK. That’s that II thing that Yes. the only only thing That's the going to be OK. to be is going of everything everything is Those words words of Yes. Those him saying. remember saying. rememberhim 35 36 37 38 39 40 4t 42 in. He He was was working in. parking area ws were were working area we Early the parking walking the morning he he was was walking this morning Early this with. in contact he that came to he contaot with. in everybody was came he talking extremelyfiiendly, that everybody to talking friendly, he was extremely Before never met met him. him. today II never Before today A43 14 4*.45 fibux þv1/- Prosecutor's 33 File 0 233 Prosecutor's File Filed 08/04/16 Page 35 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1272 u.:>LN_°\,o‘UAw Brandon Keith Statement Keith Cruz Cruz ofBrandon Statemcnt of Page Page 6o I a. Is time? at this this time? statement at this statement to add add to to this else you want want to Is there tlere anything anything else 3 A. A. No. No. ) 4 5 6 7 '_‘"“ I 9 §gK3-l~.)N_, 10 II 12 13 l4 '-‘C>\DOe)o 15 ¡6 t7 l8 2015; 9:15 PM 9: I 5 PM 5,2A15; l'YPlN(j Septernber 5, Saturday. September AND ''l1 IME: lMË: Saturday. DA l'H AND CONCLUDED - DATE I'YPINC CONCLUDED — EVIEW S‘lAll:'Ml:'N'l S I A I EME,NI R REVIHW AND URË. ANIJ Sl(J'NA'l SIGNA'I UR}; of 66 pages; each initials bears my initials II have each page bears consisting of this statement read this statement consisting bave read that the I and certify in handwriting; initialed own corrections including including any corrections initialed in my own handw¡iting; and I certifr that the facts true. herein are are true. facts contained contained herein t9 20 2t 1',t DATEAND DATE AND TIME: TIME: 0/1 - 5-’ Tot5" Ç- 1°‘? ' "'31 0t1 1lz ‘M 23 24 fee “":;:r,_._cn 25 26 Iirandon Brandon Keith Cruz 27 28 I 29 30 U.3t ) u. us32to LAJUQKlt__“ __ '- W” ” i ” SUl‘I’Ll-ZMENTINGOFFICER SUTFLEMI'N'TING Otr'Ff CER _'f'_' ._ ___‘____ __:_ “W ___w "___: ’____'_ ' SIçNATURE __QF‘FlCERS Otr'FICE.RS SIGNATURE APPRQVING OFFICER-SIGNATURE OFTTCER SIGNATURE _' ‘ __ __ w __’ " A H: _4A_ 77 -— ,:;: '§hu:avfMEr~?!t4'£iiEii\ZE -1 ':..-1‘ The—§owe11 requesting an" an 9-1-1 call call requesting Twp. Police Cenber récé{3éa”; re ceiwed. a 3:1-1 ConumraLcatLons Center Pol"lce Comunications Howell Tvqp, The õr¡nknov¡n influence the be under to that was for a ambulance for of an an “unknown a subject eubject that was believed bel lewed to lre under the lnfluence of arnbulance nhoslíIe.r Officers Ptl . Nicholas Nieholas substance" ,James Conaty Conaty Jr. #644, Ptl. Officers James and was acting "hostile." was acting subsÈancen and 'fr. #644, Ptl. and Vincent #647, Bonner Ptl. Michael Austin Daníel PtL, Michael Migdon Mígdon #645, #645. Ft,l. vínceat Bot ner #64'l' a¡d Ptl. Daniel .1ustin #654, #654, Ptl. was dispatched arrived on as dispatched as PbliÇe EMS EMS unit unit was lwp- Police Murphy HoweLl Twpon scene. The Howell sÇene. The Murphy #643 #643 arrlved. well. well". d9ecurity is ls dtspatch¡ "Security from HTPD HTPD dispatch: original call details debai.J.s from caLl- had had the the following followiag call origínal call Tim. Tim of the name holding dowtt by tåe :rame of Tím, Tím súbject down hoTdlag aa subject became the influence lnfluence very hostile he may may be be under under the bhey think hoøt!"Ie they think he became very 10-18. a substance. unk are ‘of requesting weapono No weapons of aa unk subsåance. They ar€ requestl.ng a 70'78. No or CaJ.Ter is Eleni — anyone. Caller ls Eleni to anyone. or injuries lnJurles to The Íhe nMedícer for on "Medics" for updaÈe on an update regì¡eebíng an were requesting scene were Upon Èhe officers officers on öB scene learníng the Upon learning realized the I as location this as well, to to I reaLized the I $re11' as fsedation as respond began thig locaÈíon purposest I began to reopond to eedation purposes; the first aid made on was This initial escalated. the had flrgt ald request situation made on was requeet obviously situaÈíon had obvíousJ-y escalated, Thj-g inj-tíal channel by an an EMT. BflI . cha¡.nel by 1520 Hrs. r 1.520 Hrs.: staff, securíty staff, officers, security içloweli Officers, v¡ere the aforemènbÍoned Howell Upon bhere were the aforementioned arrival-, there Upon my my arrival, the in field; There coming were location. fieLd; coming parking Medics and Lhe people on parking in Howell EMS, were.people There on location. l{owe1l m{S, and, Medics CPR ambulance'and was the in being The was the male event. and CPR wae being to ambuJ-ance subject and the r¡as ín The male going going the ewent. subJect to and performed. on scene: scerre: officers on from officers the following following from I learned the gecuriLy) were l-ater eubjecb, later ¡nale subject, (Gríffin Security) to escort aa male attempting to Security were attempting staff (Griffin SecuriLy staff of One the from t'he staff sbaff properby" OrIe of the identified as (llge:38 W/M), f^l/M), frsecuEr' s‘ ‘File’ F¡le O§40 0240 Prosecutor's Filed 08/04/16 Page 42 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1279 Department Howell HoweLl Township Police Department lownehip Police NARRATIVE ,TR ,JÀMËS CONATY, CONÀTY' JR ¡ÍARRATI FOR FOf. PTL. PTL. JAMES Ref: Ref: 15-397l5—OF 1-5-39715-OF 09/O7/2015 A9/07/20Ls 09/08/2015 09/08/20L5 Approved: .Approved: 09/O8/2015 O9/a8/20:-5 Entered: htered: Modified: llodified: Page: Page: 22 Entry Íп 644 i.030 644 EnÈry ID: 644 ModLfíed ID: fD: 6441 1016 Modified 239 Àpprowal ID: I.Ðt 239 1355 Approval @ 1030 @ @ @ 1016 @ @ 1355 incredible weight to body weight my entire entire body to strength for ft took took my for someone of his his size. size. It incredibl-e strength someone of which made and control Harden's shirtless Harden one arm. was profusely sweating profusely which arm. Harden was shirbless and control Hardenrs one and strain continued difficult to control He him to of. attempt t.o keep control of, He continued to sCrain and åtLempb to him extremely difficult Eo keep himself free. hís back back however however pull behind his pull himself free. Harden his hands Harden was was ordered hands behind ordered to to place his he in the spray in the with OC OC spray harder from from my Harden with my control. sprayed Harden he pulled harder control. II then then sprayed said he he continued what facial said however “I'm done" Harden despite region. said he continued he reglon. what done" facial Harden said "rtm however to had no no effect effect on on pull his OC had was clear the OC his arm my control. clear the to actively actively pull arm from from my control. It It was his to due his back Unable his behind to Harden. overwhelming arms Harden. Unable to manipulate hie armË behind his back due to his overwhelmÍng his chest wiLh my my knee. knee. strength of his chest with side of was forced forced to him in in the to strike strike him the right rÍght side strenglh IT was it and pulled This pulled it under pulted his under his his arm free had no effect and his arm free and no effect and he he successfully successfully pulled This had I was if he determine to no torso. Having possessed k¡eapons, I was weapons, any any opportunity Having opportuniLy if he no eorso. to delermine strike the stomach. II was forced to strike forced to the was forced to retrieve retrieve his from under l¡is stomach. his hands hands from under his forced to with face his of his side of the which was knee. only exposed part parb of his body my knee. right síde of his face wibh my body which was bhe right This control of of his his in gaining control again had no effect. strike again had no Ptl. Austin Ausbin assisted assisted in This strike effect. Ptl. Austin Ptl. Migdon, PLI. Austin and arm with and point in in time time Ptl. Pt1. MÍgdon, baton. At bhis point Lhe expandable baton. At this arm wÍth the secured Harden in Harden. was eventually Bonner Ptl. handcuffing began secured assisting Harden was.eventually assisting Harden. in handcuffíng Ptl. Bonner with of sweat sweat on on his his the amount amount of a¡rd the Ðue to to his his incredible incredible strength strenglh and my handcuffs. handcuffs. Due with my officers four with took do several seconds to it presentbody even with four officers present. so. even body it t,ook several seconds lô do so, calmed down down securing him Harden calmed his side. was laid side. Harden him in in handcuffs, handcuffs, he he was 1aíd on on his other for each check to on stood We and Harden for oLher disengaged momentarily. up to check on each Harden and stood up momenlarily. We a large blob stuck st,uck thick bloody blob injuries. poinE in ).arge thick It was thíE point in time noticed a ínjuries. It was at at this Lime II noticed the had Before blood on and blood to opporbunity we had t,hê opportunity pant leg on my shirt. Before we leg and my uniform uniform shirt. to my my right pant and kick to violently, It rt feet violently. his feet kick his up, he he began to to flail flail his his body body and sit Harden Harden up, to sit his to would he him. his under feet get he to get Fearing was would he to his trying get get appeared to his feet under himappeared he was or run feet run our position, or from our on Rt.33, was only feet feet from run into inlo traffic traffíc on Rt.33, which whích was and run feet and forced to were we himself lot active or someone the into eLse, wê were fÕrced to hurting himself or someone else, into the actiwe parking lot hurting him and secure restrain him and him, restrain prompted officers Lo engage engage him, further. Harden him further. Harden prompted officers to secure him I on his was forced forced to legs I was to his legs place zip the cuffs cuffs on on his legs. While cuffs on hÍs legs. While placing the zip cuffs him from and to his head spitting of hair the back of Harden’s ahold take on spitting stop him from and to sËop take ahold of Harden's hair on the back of his head noticed again noticed blowing While doing so II again doÍng so on officers. thíck bloody mucus officers. While the thick ûucus on blowíng the and still severe His incredible Harden’s our was still severe and hampering our strength. His sweating sweatíng was Harden, s incred.ible strength. control and hÌmself hr:rt ing himself. ability resL'rai n him him from from hurting lo control abi l i ty to anri restrain After Àfter scene after Howell were advised advised of They were of Pll. Murphy. Murphy. They after Ptl. EMS then arrived on on scene PD EMS then arrived Twp. PD HoweÌl Twp. for a formulated and assessed Harden transport a the as he he plan for a transport as we formulated a plan situatíon, assessed Harden and we the situation, so Harden could on his doing so Harden While doing car. While transporced on in aa patrol car. be transported stomach in not be his stomach could not A continued direction. A our direction. mucus in in our fIail violently bloody mucus to flail violenLly and and spit spít bloody continued to was was placed over Harden was respiratory mask stop the the spitting. spicting. Harden to stop mask was his face face to over his into the dirt. face his the face his in mask from rubbing t.he successful face ínto dÍrt. by his successfuJ in removing the mask from his face by I #w4—~ mu "-1". _ F-’ros_ecutor' 'i e_ f)2zi1 Prosecutor'ss'FFile 0241 E Filed 08/04/16 Page 43 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1280 Howell Howell Ref: Ref r 33 CONATY, JR NARRATIVE dråMES CONÀT1¡, NARRåTIVE FOR fOR PTL. PTIr. JAMES 'fR 15-39715—OF L5-397L5 -OF 09/0'7/2015 09/07/20L5 09/08/2015 09/08/20L5 Approved: J\pproved I 09/O8/2015 o9/08/2oLs Entered: Entered: Modified: ModÍfied: Page: Pager Township Ðepartment Police Department Townehip Police Entry 644 rD: 644 Entry ID: X030 644 fDl. 644 Modified ID: 1016 Modified 239 ÍDz 239 Approval ID: 1355 Approval @ @ 1030 @ @ 1016 @ @ 1355 f1ai1 to flail began to he began transport he for the transport to himself, would he it where injure the to hirnself, appeared would point uncontrollably he poinl where appeared to the it uncontrollably shouldersdislocating one of his of his his shoulders. own bones one of one of or d.íslocating bones or specifically his own by breaking one specifically by and tensed, he him flexed, While and tensed, his restraining f lexed, own He trancport. While restraíning him he He delayed hj.s or','n transport. break the would he it where the Lhe to screamed poÍnt where ít appeared appeared he would break r:ncontrollably, Eo the point screamed uncontrollably, fits of requiring restraints rage requiring was in. of rage bebween fits alternaLed between his was in, Harden Harden alternated restrainLs his the of himself free to his restraínts to officers ttre restraints intervention of attempts free stop himself to by his attempts by to stop officers intervention outnumbered the of fits the noted be outnumbered the should rage calm. It relative of of tage and fíts the periods of relative calm. It should be noted and periods of calm. moments moments of calm. ín remained in time II remained A llt this this time on Harden. Harden. At and placed on was retrieved ret-riewed and mask was A spit mask Medics MONOC incident. the of conclusion MONOC the Medics until left Harden’s of arm incidentof Lhe control control of Harden,s left arm unEiL the conclusion Several minutes Harden. sedate to able be minuÈes Several learned I after were may be able lo sed.ate Harden. were requested afLer f learned, they may and sit'uation and later of the the situation were advised They were advised of scene. They orr scene. arrived on Medics arrived Iater Medics and violent still which was and and deamnor attitude, Harden's violenb which was stiIl acknowledged and attiEude, s deamnor Harden' acknowledg,ed. his make and transport to ease sedative LransporE for his made a A was make and to ease request for a sedative unpredictable. unpredicta.ble. À request vras made contact made medics the of one conEact medics made The medics for the agreed. scene. on of safer One safer for everyone on scene, The medics agreed. then medic That sedative. of the then use a authorized medic who That with on call call doctor the on doctor who authorized the use of a sedatiwewith the sedative. the be to It preppin.g the sedative' It Came who appeared t.o be prepping wiLh his his partner who spoke with and spoke back and came back in this At point point breathing. had Harden in At this noticed time that stopped this we breabhing. at sLopped was had we noticed Harden time that was at thjs just' seconds should be seconds thaE just noted that be noted time It should gtríp on arm. It lefc arm. on Harden's Hardenrs left loose grip had aa loose time II had restraints. the in and had been he struggling the restraints, breathing in prior he had been breathing and in the EMS HTPÐ EMS the HTPD Harden and loaded loaded in the stretcher stretcher and on the was immediately immedíateIy placed on Itarden was and Kuppler#245 Sgt. aid. Kuppler#245 rendered Sgt. Medics and and Sgt. EMT’s Weg#238, where Weglt238, ambulance Sgt. rendered aid. ambufance where EMT,s and Medics then transported EMS arrived scene. on then transporEed officers then additional EMS and <>n scene. pabrol officers then arrived and additional patrol was Officer was PrÕsecutor's Officer Harden County Prosecutor's Monmouth County Jersey Shore Center. Monmouth Medical Center. to,tersey Shore Medical Harden to and Ptl. Bonner, Ptl. Murphy, Ptl. and Bonner, Ptl' Migdon, Pt1. Murphy, summoned Myself, Pt.1. Mígdon, later responded. responded. Myself, and later summoned and We were cleared. officers additional ptl , Austin Ptl. the additional of f icer:s clear:ed. We were af t.er the secured the the scene ecene after Austin secured to and the from relieved scene responded bo Headquarters. lfeadquarterslater responded and Jater relíeved. from the Fcene officers' other officers’ t-he other on the further on for further See reports for and" supplemental reports See attached attached paperwork and vehicle #28. MVR recording was involvements. in vehicle #28' wâs generated in Än &fi/R inwolvements. An Whenever we we attempted attempted Whenever to move môve him him for the 644 644 _ “hm” ' W" Pgs lle> Prosecutor's File 62112 0242 Filed 08/04/16 Page 44 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1281 Page: Page: Township Departmenb PolÍce Department Townshíp Police Howell HoweJ.l 1 1 FOR DET. SUPPLEMENTAL ORTENZT ROBERT oarenzr DET. ROBERT NÀRRå.ITTVE TOR STTPPLEMEIf,TÀT, NARRATIVE l5—397lS—OF Rem Ref¡ l-5-397L5-OF Entry 604 lD: 604 Enhry ID: Modified 243 LD¡ 243 Modtf,ted ID: Approval 243 ID: 243 Àpproval ID: 09/06/2015 09/06/2075 @@ 0002 0002 10/21/2015 1026 IO/2L/20L5 @@ 1026 Approved: 1t26 LO/2L/2ALS @@ 1026 Àpproved: 10/21/2015 Entered: Enbered: Modified: ModLfíed: _"__ A §!iL?i'' cÀl,L mrrsru-:Pori_rr«:_n DÁTE _ _ _' Ti " _.—”_ ' ‘.'s‘i'I _Ti.i»;T\_1_Er§3r/xi"fii-zi-rifii‘ h "_ '_<,-iE‘>~397Is, I _§9/' ¢is72oT5 09/051201s . _ _ _ __ " ._ _ _ , __ _ __ c _ __ Z __ _"" "T "' W—' ____ LOCATION LOCATION ' ciiiifii/"INCIDENT " ’ CRIME/¡NCIDENT NEWCRIME/INCIDENIIFCHAYSGED. NEW CRIME/ INCIDENT IF CHANGED NAME (NEW/l_F CHANCED} __VICT1M VICTIM NAME INEW/TF CHANGEp__)____ V1£TllLAD_DR_ESLNEW/1F£1'_l.ANGED)_____ vrcnM ADDRDSS (NEIV/IF CHANGID) ._ _ _ L ACCUSED CHAN GED) Á,DDR"ESS (NEIV/IF CHANGED) ACCUSED ADDR,ES_S_(lflE_W/IF __§UPPLEMEl-*l'l'lNGOFFICER OFT'ICER _ _ A APPROVING oFFic_§g_siGNA'ry_nn __ ___, _p 7” l __ -_ _ Z _ _ 91 _ A - _ ll {K -ìi4. /å _ approxirnately_1558hrs. .. _ ___ _ E} ,/ z~:m§«'.A_?_r’_Ii"_Li.._ ' _ ____ _ -t, )--¿2 __ _‘ H 4 ert;0rt __g__':gg.j Ortçú Dotdl¡bert __ "S __ ___» _ __j_ _-,.. , , “"- ' ___ T " SIGNATURE OFILCERS OFFICERS Sl€3:1,‘.lé._TlJ_R1t3,,_~ __ _ ___ ___ A __ __ _ACCUSED_EA.ME ACCUSED NAME (NEWIIF CHANGED) .,_ _ "J "___: ' ____ _ . '_ _- __ DSgt. call from from DSgt, 2015 at teiephone call On uty, II received received aa telephone off dduty, while off at approximately 1558hrs. while Septernber 5, On September 5,2015 with assist regarding male an investigation investigation regarding aa male police headquarters to assist with an to police headquarters to respond to advising me Antunez advising me to to respond Christian Antunez , Christian while and with personnel who security J. Harden persorurel whiie was identified later police fighting security as police and with subject, Timotþ J. Harde¡¡ who was fighting subject, later identified as Timothy that Mr. said thatMr. DSgt. Antunez Antunez said NJ). DSgt. Howell, NJ). (1017 Rt. Rt. 33 33 Howell, attending the Predaine Predaine (1017 at the type of of music music concert concert at some type attending some Det. Nagy was also also ChristopherNagywas Harden performed. Det. Christopher being performed. unresponsive and was being CPR was and CPR unconscious and and unresponsive became unconscious Harden became the to scene. responding respoûding to the scene. .-_.,. .____._--____- ,. _ Antunez who the following: follou"ing: me of of the II responded who advised advised me gt. Anlunez and met mst with wÍth DS DSgt. to Police Police Headquarters Headquarters and responded to stated The caller caller stated the P¡edâine. The At at thePredaine. subject at diso¡derly subject dispatch received reference to to aa disorderly in reference a call call in received a ,{t l452hrs. 14j2hrs. dispatch 'When back “Then back arrived they back up upmore back up. that subject. When pahols arrived they requested rø¿uested more security was sitting When patrols on the the subject. sitting on that securify and unit requested EMS Police responded Howell requested The control. of and still out the unit responded Twp. arrived was EMS subject was still out of control. The Howell Twp, Police arrived the subject went into into "advanced crisis". subsequently went the subject subject subsequently and the the scene to the scene and responded to Paramedics responded crisis". Paramedics paramedics paramedics for foi,'advaoced cardiac the hospital. at the hospital. pronounoed dead dead at was later later pronounced and was arrest and cardiac arrest Sgt. Police Sgt. Howell Police with Howell we met met with where we the Predaine Predaine where to the DSgt. andlI immediatelyresponded immediatelyresponded to A.ntunez and DSgl. Antunez Crimes Unit. Prosecutor's Major Office, Monmouth of the Crimes UnitMajor Ricciardi County Detective Pamela Ofñce, and Prosecutor's Thomas County Monmouth of the Weg Thomas Weg and Detective Pamela Ricciardi Unit will Professional Responsibilities Prosecutor's Ollice, Unit will Monmouth thatthe Responsibilities advised Det. County Prosccutor's Office, Pr'fI1:*£Vm1~INÀ¡{E AIiE>:>_ " H y (NEW/IF CITANGED} VICTIM .àDDRESS (NEW/I§”CHANGED) _YICTIM;ADDRESS (NEW/TF CHA¡TGED) AccUsED_§AMs ACCUSED NÀIIIE_£§§W/IF_CHANGEDl (NEW/ÏF gHANoEn[ CHjINGED) .âDDRESS (NEW/Is ÀccugEÐ ADDRESS flaccussp -SUfPLEMENTING SUPPLEIIEMTTNG _" ___ __ _ __ ____ _ _ __m_ ______ _ ___ __ Ptl. Ptl-. __ ‘ __> '7‘; _ _yw __ Daniel_Murphy ,Ir. Ðaníe1 MurPhY Jr. 7asr:u?hns,tsicNAwvi‘»?“s“f%‘;r4,;:4;.;i OFI'ICERS STGNÀTT'RE ,/4 g¥?*(g/1.t‘;-.__» OFFICER OFFTCER I _ is i‘ ___ SIGNå.TURE .A.FPRCI1':TNG OFFTCER _APPROVI1fI_(:‘w___C)Fl:‘_' ICER SIGI§é'l'.‘_Ul?E “ ___V_ ,7-—Z’,:_(4_,,, _ 4 ;_ _ __ NARR.ATI\rE over relayed over L45Ohrs dispatch relayed 5, 2015 201-5 at at approximately 1450hrs September 5, Harden identified as Timothy later Harden a person, later identifiêd as disorderLy person, a disorderly at an an event event security staff staff at by securíty (W/M/38/Belmar), down by he1'd down (W/M/3g/Belmar) , who who was was being held also was Rt.33). Dispatch (1017 also Latvian was Priedaine (10L7 the at the Priedaine Latvian Society located Rt.33). located at unknown of an influence the under advised possibly under the influence of an unknown harden was was possibly that' harden advised that Ptl. Bonner #647, PtI. Bonner #ø+1, Ptl-. substance. Ptl. Migdon Migd.on #645, Conat.y #644, #645, Ptl. PLl. Conaty #A+A, Ptl. substance. Ptl. Howell well as as the Police Austin localion, as well as Howell Police to the location, responded to and II then bhen responded Austin #654 #654 and On On the of. radia of the radio EMS. EMS. the Howell Howell followed the While Headguarters II followed Police Headquarters from Howell Howell Police en route rouLe from While en who was on Ptl. Bonner, the was on location, who neared I As B<>nner, ambulance. PLl. EMS police EMS ambuLance. As I neared the location, Police use style single single use (vinyl , zip tie tie sbyle cuffs (vinyl, paj-r of flex cuffs of flex requested aa pair scerre requested cuffs not flex to due not cuffs This flex to due response restraints). my response This request request expedited my restraints). and is uncooperative and the unless extremely uncooperaLive often required unless the subject is exEremely often being required of handcuffs. just the handcuffs. use of unable the use the just with the restrained with be restrained to be unable to scene proceeded to to and immediately proceeded cuffs and flex cuffs my flex retrieved my agival II retrieved Upon Upon arrival Austin Ptl. were and Bonner Ptl. were Ptl. Austín Ptl' Ptl. and where Bonner Migdon, the Ptt. Conaty, area Pt1: Migdon, Conaty, PLl. the area where to the proximity bo the restrain Harden. close proximity in close was in The location location was liarden. The struggling to restrain s¿ruggling to time. this at traffic which had this time. (Rt.33). at heavy (Rt.33), heawy traffic whÍch had highway highway pai-r or observed him or wearing aa pair be wearing to only be him to I and. observed Harden and therr approached Harden f then At the in stature. muscular At the and lean be to in stature' Harden very muscular very shorts. appeared to be lean and shorts. Harden appeared ’ _ I M‘ l‘ I _,_J Proskec 0245 Prosecutor's File 0245 Filed 08/04/16 Page 47 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1284 128_4 Howell Howe11 Township Police Departmenb Police Department Township Page: Pagez 22 SUPPLEMENTAL J'&. MURf'ffy JR. ÐÀNIEL MURPHY PrIJ. DANIEL SUPPLE¡{ENrÀI¡ NARRATIVE r,OR PTL. NARRATM FOR 15-39715-OF Ref: Ref,: J-5*397L5-OF Entered: 1Q27 Entered: 09/0'7/2015 09/07/20Ls @@ 1027 Modified: 09/a8/29L5 @@ 1031 1031 Modlfl"ed: 09/08/2015 Approved: .trpproved.: 09/08/2015 09/A8/20L5 @@ 1355 1"355 Entry rD: 643 643 Entry ID: ID: Modified 643 Modified IÐ: 643 Approval rD: 239 Àpproval. ID: 239 stomach. He he was time He was was hi s sLomach. ón his and laying la ying on bac and handcuffed behind hiss back was handcuffed LTmÉt-ïe in his an and and violently body in an attempt attempt actively and twisting his body his legs legs and twisting kicking his violenLl-y kicking actively free of our conlrol. Due immediately be immediately to be he needed needed to Due to bo Harden's Harden's violent violen! behavior, he to time this at it His actions made restrained. further to obtain obbain further Lime impossible at, bhis restraÍned. His actions made Ít to what led that was circumstances j-nformation regarding the information what up up to was previous led the previous circumstances Lhat currently currently occurring. With Bonner and and Pt1. Bonner Hardents legs, Ptl. Pt1. Migdon Migdon restraining restraining Harden's help from from Ptl. With help for done I fear that that was done for fear This was in the the flex flex cuffs. cuffs. This able to to secure secure them them in were able I were Harden nearby run into into nearby and run control and our control to break break free free of of our would be be able Harden would abte to innocent the of himself bystanders further or byst,anders innocent traffic, injuring of the any any highway or further injuring himself traffic, highway festival. the attending f atLendíng t.he estival. Howell Harden's legs. securing Harden’s shortly after after securing arrived shortly Pol-ice EMS EMS arrived Howell Police After brief period of of for aa brief down for calmed down secured, he he calmed legs were were secured, After Harden's Harden's legs and date of birth. time. birth. hís name name and date of to obtain obtain his him and and was was able able to with him spoke with time. II spoke was under under the t,he he was to what whaL he questions as However, as to woul-d not answer any any questions not answer Harden would Hov,/ever, Harden While medical speaking from if of he a episode. influence speakíng was While or suffering episode. a medical if was suffering from he influence of or blood with mucolrs-like blood coagrulated, mucous—like appeared. to to be be coagulated, what appeared observed what with him him II observed be to He profusely. sweating his also from profusely. nose. appeared be sweaLj.ng to hanging hanging from his nose. He also appeared EMS but EMS personnel but to EMS respondted to He responded speakJ-ng with wíth Harden. Harden. He aleo began speaking EMS also combative became without once and in provocatíon, once again became combative and and without provocation, Ínstanb and in an an instant and exclaimed again started kicking and sbarLed kicking aín't happening!” He again happening!" He shít ain't exclaímed “This "This shit I then side. his himself hold of of thrashing his lifting himself onto onto his side. I then grabbed aa hold his body, hody, lifting himself or and Harden's hurLing himself or getting up up and hurting keep him from getting to keep hj.m from righb arm arm to Harden,s right one arm arm due due others on scene. Harden's one resLrain Harden’s weighL restrain full- body body weight took my rny full scene, It It took others on and his unnatural to strength. extraordinary strength. and exEraordinary to his unr¡atural to transport also attempted We backboard to reeves backboard on aa reeves Harden on to place Harden abt,empted to We also behavior combative intermittent his to due however behavíor the him to combative hospital, however due to his inbermíttent him to the hospital, not this possible. this was was not possible. short period of asked Harden time. II asked of time. for aa shorb agaín calmed calmed down down for once again Harden once it however this location”, in reside “I iE was which stated was he however he where lived, location", in bhis he which reside stated he lived, where "I was information subsequently This in lived Belmar. he that found was subsequentlY later information rhis he i-n Belmar. líved Later found that relayed to dispatch. relayed to priscj-l1-a Baker Baker (W/F/28) I $/r/Ze) who witness Priscilla one of of the the witness with one spoke with I then bhen spoke caused which sound Harden make cart heard a caused Harden she a which that advised “pop” sound golf cart make a "pop" advised that she heard a golf zone”. in “war he a like react to reacL like he was was in a "war zoÍLe", to (w/M/35'lsayrevílLe) ' who who I also cruz (W/M/35/Sayreville), guard Brandon Brandon Cruz spoke with wíth security securíty guard also spoke T he that advised was He his face. ice to of he was that a advised the was at He bag face. time, holding hís to of ice was a bag the time, aL stat^ed that that He stated f estival. He called the festival. f rom the escort Harden away from t,o escort Harden away area to the area to the called to he was Harden, confront to vehicle he was behind Harden, from a the corner turned confront he when bo vehicle a behind the from corner when he Lurned him. face the in by him. bY punched face punched in the to strike officers to strike officers and and break break free of our control. """ I‘ I’ if ‘ I ' ’i34rose_<:utor' ‘l; e—02;16 0246 Prosecutor's sFile Filed 08/04/16 Page 48 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1285 "Howell DeparLment PoI j.ce Department TownshiP Police ffowell Township Page: Page: 33 MltRPIry JR. DAI{IEL MURPHY SUPPLEMENTAL PTIr' DANIEL rOR PTL. I{ÃRR.ATM FOR SûPPÍJBMENTJ{JI NARRATIVE 'IR' 15-39715-OF Ref: Ref: l-5-39715-OF Entered: r¿nbered: 09/07/2015 @ Ag /A7 /2015 @ 09/08/2015 09/08/20L5 @@ Approved: 09/08/20L5 @@ Approwed: 09/08/2015 Modified: Modífiedr Entry 643 IÐ: 643 Entry ID: Modified 643 IÐ: 643 ModifÍed ID: 1027 IO27 1031. ¡.031 1355 1355 Approval I'D: J\pprowal ID: 239 239 attempt,ing again attempting once again over to to himm once due to Harden due to Harden back over then called cal.led back officers location that at back officers Once control. locatÍon officer control. Once back at that to from officer free from to break break free at, blood/saliva at to furth er spitting spitt,ing blood/saliva for a from further llarden from were looking to stop stop Harden way way a for were borne blood unknown the to due borne blood in close proximíty due to the unknown them close proximity anyone ín as anyone as well well as them as that diseases contracted. communicable have contracted. and he may have that' he diseases pathogens paLhogens and communicable breathable (loose fitting and breathable rnesh and fitting mesh I mask {1oose spit mask retrieved aa spit then retrieved I then a used biological be as to constructed a bíologícal used as hood be material specifically cor¡strircted to material hood specifically Ptl. to Harden. Harden. PL1' returned to and returned contaminant patrol vehicle vehicl.e and my patrol from my filt,er) from contamínant filter) furt'her from further him from mask on to prevent him Harden .as to on Harden_as spit mask the spit Migdon and II placed the Migdon and and patrol patrol EMS and' the personnel in personnel area, byst.anders in the area, EMS spitting at bystanders saliva/blood at spíttíng saliva/blood officers. officers. to started to rage started of rage fit of in aa fit Harden and in resistive and again became became resistive Harden again extreme strength his the and the to his extreme strength and Due to arms. Due and arms. tighten/flex/strain his body body and tighten/ fJ:ex/átr¿in his in fear I was as arm his fear of in f was control right as took of I arTr his right of his body control flexing tight tijfrt flexing od his body I Look handcuffs and ultimately our control. that t,he handcuf fs and ultimately our control. free from f rom the break free would break fre would tirãt he multiple body multiple his body the handcuffs, at released his and released Harden flexed, pulling aL the handcuffs, and Harden flexed, pulling was Harden arm. his still was still of right Harden control maintain arm' his right to I of times atiempted ão maintain control as ï attempted times as EMS one At of. point control EMS poinL to one hard At and of' was keep control profusely sweatíäg anA was hard to keep profuseLy sweating grip on his on his get aa better better grip to get off to dry Harden on scene Harden off Lo ary personnel or, scerrã attempted to i"r"orrr,*i I I was was then body. eecured, him secured, keep him to keep ríghl arm arm to s right in contact with and Harden yelling and stated stated began calm. yelling he was when loosened Harden calm. was grip he however when my however loosened my torso Harden’s monitored Lorso Harden's I continually however monitored not could breathe, conbinually he I that however that he could noe ùrãatire, audible his with símulcaneously wíth his audible and contracL simultaneously and contract expand and it to to expand observed it and observed and continued yelling. yelLing' talking also He and talking breathing. breabhing. He also continued “I'm taking off!” is ft is off'!" It ye1led r\I/m At he yelled Harden he with Harden whí"Le with one point while At one statement. this unknown what by this statementwhat he he meant meant by unknown believed to my experíence II believed and experience traíníng and It my training due to thab due noted that be noted sbould be It should initial The substance. initía1 The intoxicating of an influence stlbstance. the under be intsoxicatíng to an harden harden bo be r.urder tbe influence of appearance appearance statements/behaviors/physical Harden's and caller's statement and Hardenr s stabements/behaviors/phyeicaL callerrs statement led me what conclusíon. are thís conclusion. me to to this led are what our to our reËponded to As they responded scene' As on scene. MONOC arrived on subseguenbly arrived Medícs subsequently MONOC Medics himself free to his twist hímsel-f and free kick body to to body his twisL and once began kick again Harden location locatÍon Harden Õnce "gáín began to maintain control of Harden's upper helped. maintain control of Harden's of atsõ helped EMT Smith Smitn also control. EMT our control. of our while awaiting Medics this awaiLíng Medics maintained position whil-e position and he this as he fought torso fought and rnaintained area as torso area to hímto sedate sedate him. scissors in tc> in order order to cuf f scissors f ]ex cuff Lo retrieve retrieve flex I Migdon to Ptl. Migdon ad.vised Ptl. then advised f then the to hospital. hospítal" Lransported to the was transported Harden was remove after Harden restraints after remove the bhe restraints Harden' sedate Harden. t() sedate permission to granted. permission one then granted was then Medics was of the the Medics one of to shoulders Harden’s to roll roll noticed I shoulders this of advised Harden's after noticed I Shortly after being ad.vised of tñis I immediately him breathing. f immediately detected breathing' and no times him longer two backwards det,ecled backwards two t'imes and no was Harden was medical personnel on scene. scene' Harden personnel on notified and meãical officers and other officers notified other he was and removed was mask he was and The back. remowed his spit was mask to turned spit subsequently subseguently turned to his back. The I remained Harden/ remained in contact with Harden’s I - um 70*. I my H. _ I W - Prosecut0r' s—Fi e Prosecutor's File 024-17 0247 Filed 08/04/16 Page 49 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1286 Howell HowelL Township Police Department Pol-ice Department Page: Page; 44 SUPPLEMNTAL I{['RPEY JR. üR. rOR PTL. PTt. DANIEL DAITIEL MURPHY SttPPIJ&fE¡lTÀL NARRATIVE IfÀRRÀÎIVE FOR 15-39715-OF Ref: Ref:15-39715-OF Entered: Enrered¡ 1027 09/07/2015 09/a?/20L5 @ ø LO27 Modified: Modified: 09/08/2015 09/O8/20L5 @ @ 1031 1031 @ 1355 Approved: Àpproved: O9/O8/2015 1355 09/OS/2OLS @ Entry 643 Entry ID: XD¡ 643 Modified ID¡ 643 643 ldodif,ied ID: Approval 239 .ßpproval ID: I,Dz 239 efforts. for life Medic personnel forLs l_f e saving saving ef persönne lforI over to to on on scene’fiMQ scene EMS and and Medlc II then which informalion which witness information then helped helped secure and gather witness the scene scene and secure the Bureau. Detective the to turned over was ultimately Bureau. bhe Detective turned over to ú/as ult,imat,ely For involvelnent offícer's involvement other patrol officer's For further further information informalÍon regarding other their related see see theír relat,ed reports. incident. The thís incident. during this M\m. in in vehicle vehicle #31 wâ.s utilized utílized during The MVR *3L was turned turaed over "i3.ros<-::‘c:u"tor' 0248 Prosecutor'ss File File 0248 Filed 08/04/16 Page 50 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1287 61?ZO___§l!:l.§.J01n39$°-!d_ 6Þ20_ -p]ltJ tl9fl?e99ld_ * Page: Pager 11 Þepartment Howell Police Department TownshiP Pollce HoweII Township — . e ~ -- . , .,._ SCI-IERBINSKI NSKI HßJil'f TTER SCHSRBÍ FrIl HEATHER FOR PTL. SUPPLEMENTAL I'¡,C.RRÀTIVB FOR SUPPI¡EIISNTÃL NARRATIVE 15-397l5~OF Ref: Ref¡ L5-39715-OF 650 ID: 660 Entry ID: Modlfled ID: 660 660 Modified, ID: emery 09/07/2015 Entered: @ 1826 L826 Entered: 09 /07 /zOLs @ 1846 @ 09/07/2015 Modified: 1846 @ Mod.:Lfied: oe /07 /20L5 1355 @ 1355 Approved: 09 /08/20L5 @ Approved: 09/08/2015 Approval 239 IÐt 239 Àpproval ID: so:-Pl.F.':_v'w::3§"K!.REP0RT"' REPORT _"__ __r.s.:;.9fi'Is_._ ‘f.’_;__ _"f."_ _j‘axxI;¢"““"“” CALL# ’_"_'____._. j_ if '1 __.___ _, :)_';h'EiiEroRn;n DÀTER.EPORTED A ' 7-09/05/2015‘ 9/05/zlI5 " t A Z 4'" " _ ,..._ " ‘ _ __ , _____V_,‘__,__________ _,,__ ___ LOCATION LOCATION cnmnu E/ INCIDENT INCIDENT _. __ OFFICERSsIGNA1y1g:________A__,__V._ SIGNATURE .TURE APPROVING OFFlCERSlGNA'[:U_1_1_’_F_3__ :_-__ If. '"_ _ , 7 ;_ _ __ 4 _ , ,_ ., ________, ,_ _: 7 __ _ _ _ _ __ ,_ _ _ y) . ___ _ E77-_I1ea1l.:er .‘.'-iclggrliimki _, ._ _ .,__.,W , .. ___,__._..._ __ ._,i}§_ _"__?.___ _,-. ___fl - -___ _.--_ __ _ __N_r3_' 3.B_A.'1fl’_§—:M NÀRRÂ'I'ryE .- " _ ,_____ W1 "___ vxcrm NAME NA Qimv/1:«'c:i_mNc1~:n) VICTIM YICTIM ADDRESS ADDNESS (Now/ii-'ci1AN(;1-11)) ACCUSED NAME _(13,1~j.}_\gr_I_I-jcrmNr:Er>;____H CRA ÂCCUSEDN.{ME ADDRESS (NEW/II" Cl1AN(.‘F.l)) kACC_USED .SUPP1.EMENTlNG01{1j‘1CERrg SUPPI.BMENTING OFFICER E. k_____ _ _ CI{AN(;ED __NEWCR1ME/INCIDENTIF NEW CRIME / INC'IDENT IT CHANGED .'__—:_" M.‘ ,'f:-’_?._’__'_:'__i.;..E.-.... ,..* — _ .. the Crime at the #238 requested requested II record record the Crime Scene Sccne Log Log the Priedaine. Priedaíne. Sgt. Sgt Weg Weg #238 On call ¡t Person call Disorderly Person to aa Disorderly responded to On September Scptember 5, 20tS II responded 5, 2015 for this incident. íncidcnl, The The log is as as follows: follows: for this log is Ptl. #654 recorded Ptl. Austin Austin #654 recorded the the following: following: Exit: 1849 hrs hrs r Detective Exit: 1849 ßntercd: ---Detective Pam Pam Ricciardi Badge #60: #ó0: Entered: Ricci¡rdi - Badge Entered: ChiefKudrlck - Budge 1702 hrs hrs r ChiefKudrick Exit: 1702 hrs Exit: 1652 hrs Entered: 1652 #230: Badge #230: Exit: 185.‘) Entered: >I hrs 1859 hrs hrs Erit: Sgt. Antunez1702 hrs [ntcrcdl 1702 Sgt. Antunez - Badge Badge #243: #2d!: Entered: hrs 1859 hrs r Detective Exit: 1859 l¡rs Exit: t7l0 hrs [ntered: 1710 Detective Bozza Bonz - Badge #196 Badgc #196 hrs Exit: Entered: hrs 1853 hrs Exit: 1853 ¡ Detective l?14 hrs Entered; 1714 Detectiv¡ Nagy #l9E Nagy - Badge Badge #198 v - I - I - ’ - II entered following: the following: entered the thc scene began scribing scribing the sccnc and and began 1859 hrs hrs Exit: Entered: H. Scherbinski Badge #660 E¡it¡ 1859hrs t Ptl. 1723hrs Í{ntcrod: 1723 Ptl.H.Scherþinski-Badge#660 1731 hrs 1848 hrs hrs hrs Exit: , Sgt. Exitl 1848 Entered: t73I SgL Rocco Badge #153 #153 Entered: Rocco Santorsola Santorsola - Badge hrs Exit: hrs t Kevin 1853 hrs Exit: 1853 l742hrs Kcvin McGovern (Attorney) Entered: ßntsred: 1742 McGovern (Attorney) hrs II Sarmite l74E l¡rs hrs Exit: Exit¡ 1748 1746 hrs Entered: 1746 Sarmite Leja Leja (Property Manager) Manager) Entered: It Ptl. #643 Badge Ptl. Murphy Murphy - Badge l/643 v Ptl. Conaty Conety - Badge Badge #644 f1644 ') Ptl. Ptl. Ptl. Migdon Badge #645 Migdon - Badge #645 II Ptl. Bonner Badge #647 Ptl.Bonner-Badgcf647 Exit: hrs 1755 hrs r Ptl. Exit: 1755 Ptl. Austin Austin - Badge Bndge #654 #ó54 hrs Exit: Entered: hrs , Lt. Eritl 1859 1859 hrs lSll hrs Badge #237 Lt. Rizzu Rizzo -Badge Entered: 1811 #231 Entered: hrs 1849 hrs t Detective Dxitr 1849 t8l8 hrs hrs Exit: Badge #203 Detcctive Newman Entcred: 1818 Newman -Badged203 Entered: D, Pt]. 1859 hrs hrs hrs Exit: Exit: 1859 1830 hrs Badge #662 Enteretl; 1830 Ptl. MacDonald MacDonald -Badge#662 hrs 1859 hrs Exit: 1831 Entered: Lou hrs 1859 Zuppa (Forensics) tou Zuppa (Forensics) Entered: I83l hrs f,xit: I - I ~ I - - I - - I I - - I - — Filed 08/04/16 Page 51 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1288 Howell Police TowrrshJ-p Police Howell Township Page: Page: 11- Department Department SUPPLEMENTAL IYTGDO¡T FOR PTL. MTCHATL monom SUPPLEMÉ¡iÛÀI NARRATIVE NÀRX.âTT1rE FOR PTI,. MICHAEL 15-39'7l5—OF Ref: Ref:15-397L5*OF 645 Entry Entry ID: ID: 645 645 ID: Modified 645 Moilified ID: Approval Àppraval ID: ID: 239 239 Entered: Entered: O9/07/2015 09/o7 /20j-5 @ @ 1027 J.027 @ 09/08/2015 09/08/20L5 @ 1002 1002 Approved: Àpproved: 09/08/2015 09/O8/20L5 an@ 1355 1"355 Modified: Modlfied: '_ H _ ,_ A u 13-3El_5 13-3971s _ CALL” CALLfl DATE "“7T“ I f"'fl.E:9“_TL';._“ _;j REPORTED ._ . LOCATION LOCATION _E‘i“”E”NC’”fifi CRIMI/INCÍDENT ÍNCIDENT [F IF cm_r~_icr«:_1_q_ J_’ ji_EW gyms; CRIME / INCIDENT NE1V I H Z" w/I¡ _y_Icrt1~_4A_nIJ_I3}:s_s(I:'_i§~';Ii;s;mz4<:_Ism___ VICTIMADDRESS _Ac§UsED NÂME (NEW/i_i-‘ cit/iN(:i~:n) ÁCCUSED NAME ACCUSED ÂT}I}RESS A_r_)_iJ_<§.ss (Nij‘._\VlQI}_‘_f‘li:\N(IF3p_)__ ' H ' __ ' 4 . __ _ A '— ': , _ Jqh [LI -_.. —' __ H _»_ __- _ ' ' :" _‘_:f_ _f______ __ __ _ '_ ‘ __ _ N pfl_ Pfl. Michael Michael Mggdon SUPPLEMENTING OFT'ICIR SUPPLEMENTING OFFICER _0FEl_CE.EiSiGNATURE STGNATURE , APPROVINGorrltrnnsicwptjyns 0rFI(:[,R .5¡GNÂ'r'{.tRE _ g_ _ T ./___ __4g_E’?__M _ _ NAR! _ ___VDis__<_)rder_ly iierson/Assau_it#_ Person/Assault 7_ NAME imzxvrnr-'ciiAm':m)j HIVICTXM NAME ct i _ 09/9sLéq1s t9105/2015 5 I H _ ____“""'""." ‘_' §uP_‘riZs_im:'N'rAi»m»v RIIPORTED V 654 654 654 654 239 239 ' ‘ l . .. _ _.___ __ —_ ' " , ___,_ #__._ _g__ i A _ __"____‘_ A LOCATION LOCATTON _ciuMa/g1i_.~ic1DENT INCIDENT 'Df>i§ur_derTy§qgo?i/Assauit_' ult ' ""'4 ’ a NEW CRIIMEIlNCIDl?;ij]:[lfCH:}NGED / CHÂNGED NEW CßIME \7IcTxM NAME (NEW/IF C_[ CIl_A ivc.-i-_:i)_;_ VICTIMN.A-ME vxcrmAnnnassgyicw/iirciiANgt¢igi_ vIcTrM ADDRESS (N ¡:1{7r Ir CIIANCI'D} ACCUSEDNAME Gigi_J)__v NAME (l‘iP;3XV/lI~‘__CHAi‘s' .A.CCTJSED ßEw/I}'' CHANG (NËwll F CI-I/_t_NG_‘ED)_ ÂDDRESS Lmw/m CIIANGND) ___z;\CQUSED AccusED A_DigR_Ess _ V _ ' __ g ___ ___V __ g SUPPLEMENTING oiinciini OFFICER SUPPLIMPNTING _OFFICERSS§!‘_i_/_tfll§Ij‘._V______7 OFFICERS SlGN,,t't'U ¡{¡: _ Timothy_[-larden_ Harden _. _ _ Z _ _ —___ __:.‘g "*____z _ _ _ _ __ M g____ ' ' __ __ _ ______ __ _ _______g__ _ _ __ T _ _ _ __ i Pil. _ __»*fl'B@9_Fi:I.CER STGNAIU&E-. AppRovrNc oFFICER SfGN_AT_LI8E _ _ -..._ - . _> . _. __ Namifiiiva NARRATIVE _' ._ .___ _' '4 ______,.._, disorderly On reference to to aa disorderly in reference Society, in Latv¡an Society, at 1017 33, Priedaine/NJ Priedaine/NJ Latvian responded to to aa call call at Route 33, On 9/5/2015, 9/5/2Aß, II responded 1017 Route (w/m/3ï/selmar! was was being being held held down down Jerson. Harden (w/m/38/Belmar) as Timothy Timothy Harden advised that the subject, subJect, later later identified fdentified as Dispatch notes notes advised that the )erson. Dispatch vehicle in 22. MVR recorded on MVR in vehicle 22. and they substance. The an unknown incident was The incident was recorded on they felt was on felt that that he he was on än unknown substance. JV ly security secur¡ty and guards were. security guards the security were. arrival, II was of where where the point¡ng me in the the direction dírection of me in Upon was waived waived down down by by event event staff stâff pointing Upon my arr¡val, due to mic his MVR retrieve not to advised Ptl. me I As #644 my on his >tl. scene. was )tl, Conaty MVR mic due to approached, Ptl. Contaty Contãty advised rne to retriêve already ôn scene. As I approached, Conäty #644 was already Harden because well was as as bleeding. gloves charged gloves Jeing was bleeding. because Harden )e¡ng charged as well as returned to Ptl. Migdon Ptl. advised Ptl. As scene. II advised arriving on on scene. also arriving #647 were were also Ptl. Bonner Bonner #647 to my vehicle, vehicle, Ptl. Migdon #645 and Ptl. #645 and As II returned Harden had the where placed returned to placed guards had Harden security guards gloves as viigdon bleeding. II then as well well due due to to Harden Harden bleeding. then returned to where the security Vtigdon to to get gloves of his his body. different from down Harden noticed the I po¡nts of the body. II also also were holding iown on guards ground. I noticed the security security guãrds were holding Harden down from different points lown on the ground. Harden that noticed I was very like bloody toticed and mouth. mouth, I also also noticed that Harden was jelly like nose and hís nose face in in the the area area of of his mucus on Hardens face bloody mucus on Hardens toticed aa jelly the started what on information struggle ascertain unable Ptl. and to I in and large nuscular large in stature. Conaty and I were were unable to ascertain any information on what started the struggle stature. Ptl. Conaty ïuscular and involvement with first their active clue to at the ’rom with Harden. Harden. guards security physicaf involvement 'rom the security guards at first due to their active physical one of or one Ptl. Conaty hímself or harming himself of the him from from harming the keep him to keep in an an attempt to Hardens arms arms in Conaty was was attempting attemptíng to to secure secure Hardens Ptl, his chest in underneath his Information). Harden arms underneath his chest ín Jfficers was tucking tuck¡ng his arms Harden was (see Ptl. further information). Conaty's report report for for further Ptl- Conaty's involved (see rfficers involved to in baton an gain control attempt monadnock utilized then control ofhis detained. I of his right expandable to gain right resist being being detained. I then utilized my monadnock expandable baton in an attempt to resist ¡ttempt to in the crease of as aa arm in used the the baton baton as then used of his elbow. II then his elbow. the crease placed it Hardens right ríght arm and placed it underneath underneath Hardens my baton baton and back it to he bring behind his attempted back, his arm ’ulcrum arm was was behind his back, he attempted to bring it back Once his his arm to turn turn his towards his his back. back. Once was able able to arm towards and was 'ulcrum and the landed and of on amount of öf baton The to the the amount chest. out ground In due to hlm due zowards his grlp of him tn front front of slipped out of my rny grip and landed on rhe ground hi$ chest. The baton slipped arm. took lrm. II took ;owards his right right arm me secure secure his arrn helped me Bonner helped grab onto hís wrist and Ptl. Ptl. Bonner wrist and onto his to grab aerspirationcoming body. II was able to from Hardens Hardens body. was able :erspiration coming from unbelievable had Harden that noticed I further for information). ptl. unbelievable Ptl. Bonners cuffs and (see place him report for further ínformation). I noticed that Harden had Bonners report in hand hand cuffs (see hlm in rnd place also attempting attempt¡ng to with was also to still to Harden was and his back. back. Harden was behind his fight attempting secured behind his hands ;trength even with with his hands secured ;trength and was still attempting to fight with even secured flex also were Hardens by legs Hardens unexplainable strength, officers while _ W’ WT T i A ‘ V PlProsecutor's :-OSGCU-tC-)V "S File_ 0253 File 0553 Filed 08/04/16 Page 55 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1292 Howell Howell Police Department Township DeparLment rorrnship PoLíce Page: Pager 22 PTL. NICHOLAS SUPPLEMENTAL ÀUSrIN l'OR PfI¡. NICHOLAS AUSTIN SUFFLEì{ENTAÍ, NARRATIVE NARRÀTIVE FOR 15~39715~OF Ref: Ref:15-39715-OF Entered: Fntered,: 09/07/2015 ]-027 09/07/zo'J-S @ @ 1027 Modified: 09/08/2075 @ L001 Modlfled; 09/08/2015 @ 1001 Approved: åpproved: 09/08/2015 O9/08/2atS @ 1355 @ 1355 Entry ID: IÞ: 654 654 554 Modified ID: 654 Modified ID: Approval 239 ÍDt 239 Ìlpproval ID: :uffs.' luffs to find At pert¡nent information information from point that from him. him. II out pertinent that officers tried to that time, time, Harden Harden calmed cafmed himself himself to to the the point fínd out At that officers tried "i had stated Harden him. with find involvement what substances Harden attempted pr¡or to to f¡nd out out what substances Harden had ingested prior our involvement w¡th him. Harden stated "l had aa to our ¡ttempted to had ingested zaste was unable to determine determine (unknown word)" about it." it." II was unable to "Then II felt felt bad father's (unknown then continued bad about of my father's word)" twice, twíce, then contínued to to say ”Then :aste of after listening to the A/hat said he the audio recording several several times. times. Harden said he tasted tasted after listening to audío recording ¿vhat Harden being At täg was was hanging hanging point Harden that my name name tag officers. II noticed noticed that this point Harden was was secured anU båing controlled controlfed by by other other officers. At this secured and else at stab some uniform. ifelt and thatthis be could someone or would me or someone else at some point off point if possíbfy stab me potentially be an if an issue issue and could possibly :ff my uniform. lfelt that thís would potentially then I inside the car. continued and resist. to l returned vehicle secured to 4arden approached patrol nametag patrol approached car. lthen my the {arden continued to res¡st. I returned to my vehícle and secured my nametag inside moments of him being Due to to him being ;ecurity guards to of calmness. calmness. Due Harden had had moments to assess that Harden ¡ecurity guards assess their their well well being. being. Let Let it it be be noted noted that officers released zontrolled ground. Harden compliance holds Harden would then, would then, on the the ground. remaíned on holds as he himself himself remained released compllance it appeared appeared he as it :ontrolled offícers himself else from or him officers have to and would to hurting anyone struggle keep or begin struggle himself anyone again efse by by from hurting Jnpredictably, .rnpredictably, begin struggle again and offìcers would have tô struggle to keep him Jslng holds. .rsfng compliance complíance holds. He stated iI noticed guard holding happened. He stated that what happened. that to explain expfain what ice to asked him hím to one security security guard holdíng aa bag bag of to his his face. face, iI asked noticed one of ice said The and the in" turned and Harden he corner ”called to security guard went guard as Harden, swung. we was 'ìe was "calléd ín" and as he went to approach sald he he approach Harden, Harden turned the corner and swung, The security continued staff to The him.” of else "took then on him the then explain to continued "everybody top tap” got staff to expf ground" good ground" The ain good of him." else on top got ”a the then then him tap" to "took "everybody "a ",ot :hat yelling at peopfe at other other people he was golf cart They said said he was yelling war zone. zone. They the "pop" he was of aa golf cart and and reacted reacted like like he was in in aa war heard the Harden heard :hat Harden "pop" of their condition to the assess #643 scared and like Ptl. also down guards was a security guards their condition approached Murphy baby. :o to assess :o get down and was scared like a baby. Ptl. Murphy #643 also approached the security and an attempt (reference Ptl. report for for more more information). information). Murphy's report obtaín more Ptl. Murphy's to obtain information about about Harden more information Harden (reference in an attempt to ¡nd in After over condition, II returned Harden. iI took took over that were subduing Harden. guards condition, were subduing to the the officers offìcers that the security security guards returned to assessing the After assessing order from to him in movements Hardens control to keep half lower his While of Hardens :ontroiling attempting to control Hardens movements in order to keep him from body. Whíle attempting :ontrolling Hardens lower half of his body. were attempting that while be noted his side. roll Let he able to was on âttempting to to control himself, control his hls 1urting while several officers were side. noted that several officers Let it ít be lurting hlmself, he was able to roll on his and side tried his rolled to Harden on control. On break out tuck novements, occasions, Harden rolled on his side and tried to tuck still able On several several occasions, he was was still able to to break out of of our our control, Tovements, he could where control we to Harden a able return Officers to stand to under him position were 1is an as position could controf where we legs under him as an attempt attempt to stand up. up, Officers were able to return Harden to a ris legs an and in factors With such parking lot time. our 1im as lot with wíth an location, being near ín an an occupied occupied parking highway and location, near aa major factors our major highway every time. With belng tim such as Harden from was critical getting up. event, for us from getting to keep keep Harden crit¡cal for us to it was :vent, it yelled Let well as as yelled and struggled struggled as as well our commands to disobey disobey our commands and Harden continued continued to entire encounter, encóunter, Harden it be during the the entire Let it noted during be noted well Officers and as EMS as well as EMS turned turned breathing. Officers as stoppecl breathing. Murphy noticed that Harden Harden stopped Ptl. Murphy noticed that tlltimately, Ptl. throughout, Ultimately, ancJ screamed screamecl throughout. and Howell EMS MONOC to cared Harden and him stretcher. by back was immediately his Harden on a and MCINOC onto by Howell ËMS to placed cared placed immedíately was Harden hlrn on a stretcher. Harden onto his back and Medics already on tn scene. scene. that were were already Medics that N A ._ — 7‘ ___ _ — ‘— » Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0254 } Filed 08/04/16 Page 56 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1293 Howell Departmerrt Police Department Howell Tonhship Townshíp Polite Page: Page: 13- gEåN MACDONALD SUPPLEMENTAL NARRATIVE PTIr. SEAN I'ÍACDONAIJD f'OR PTL. NARRåTM FOR SUPPIEÀIEñIAI, Ref: 15-3971-5-CIF Refr 15-39715—OF 09/07/2015 2027 a9/07/20L5 @@ 2027 09/07/2015 2035 @ 2035 a9/07/2al-5 (9 Approved: 1355 Jlpproved: O9/08/2015 09/08/2015 @@ 1355 Entry rD¿ 662 662 Entry ID: ID: Modified 662 Modífied rD; 662 Approval 239 ID: 239 Approval ID: Entered: E¡rbered: Modified: Modífied: .jK3L}3'!§i‘fI!i'!‘_. AL ’ cAiLL#__V_ # BATE REPORTED TE RE1""__ _ _ _____ _ ___ !_N __M_._‘__ __ __ ____»_ _e«_c9UsEDNAMEi~EWfiF<:IIAN<:I-:u)_ ACCUSEDNAME by _ _ f)ì _;s<>cu~:§w&,mmsmncwuyggruwcsrzni EDADDRESS SUi j}fLEh_d;fi‘;N_I‘lNG OFFICERWV OFFICAR SUPI'LEMENTINC __ W , SIGNATURE _Al_‘l’_l_{()}f]_l§iG OI-‘F'l(,‘l2RSIGNATURE__ _ ____________ ___4___ _ __ __ _ __ __ __ . _? _ , __ " ' I Z__ ___ _ _________ VICTIM NGED) cHÂNG 14CTIM ADDRESS~(Nl«‘.W/IFCHA 'oFFIcERssIG~»uURE TURE OFFICER,S M "_ ; .. ___.f;,__ ___,___.__ Ptl. Ptl. Sea;1J\_r1acdonald Se¡aMacdonald -1%?~/.z;;,4.{-cZ.E§;;______, pt; ___g»:. " NA-RRAIIVI5 I ' __ ’ ___ _ ' ___}" _y _._ later subject later obscrved Ir subject on scene sc€Íe II observed Whilc on person.. While dlsorderlY Person On report of: ofr disorderly loc¡tion for for aa report to the the above above location responded to On 09/05/2015 09/0512015 II responded [was ambulance. ofthe back the in Medics advised by by Sgt. Sgt' and I was advised Aid First treated Howell ofthe ¡mbulancc. the b¡ck Harden in Medics and ll First,{id my identified being (W/m/38) as Howe Timothy (flmß8) lrcrtcd belng identifïed es Timothy ll¡rden Medical and Harden Mr. Harden. pcrsonol Mr. pcrsonol to tended Medics Medícal and and Aid Hardcn First Mr. while in Harden. JSMC to l\lrto ambulen ce the rmbut¡nce to JSMC in Neptune drive tbe Neptunc wh ilc First Aid and Medics tended Kuppler lo drive Kupplcr to were incident withoul incident to JSMC JSMC without wcre transported transported to ,0 W __ _____ , . _ ___, ___ in the tl¡e trauma trauma room room by in stood by notilied' II stood rden was sgt Wcg wcg was w¡s notified. by Dr. Dr' Youssef. Youssef' Sgt. While hours by nt 1614 1614 hours pronounced at was pronounced Mr' H: H¡rden hospítel Mr. rt the the hospital while at II was finished M.C.P.0 was Afte r was finished identification for w¡s location would be to M.C.P.O purposes. Àfter M.C-P.0 that identifïcatior after iesponding to my locetion for ¡dvise.ATE7i§P0RTE9 DATE REPORTßD _ "CRIME/INCIDENT‘ __’f_l;Z__’_ CRIME/TNCIDENT NEW NEW c;g_r_ME/mc1D§NTmcH'Angrg CRIME i INCIDENT fF CHANGED " _ Entry Entry ID: ID: 235 238 Modified Modifi.ed ID: rD: 237 237 Approval ID: ID: 237 23'l NAM!-J (NEW/IF VICTIM NAME (NEWIF C_[l_A_NGE]})_______ VICTIM CHANGED) VICTIM â-DDRESS ADDRESS (NEW/IFCHANGED) (NnW/I¡' CI{^NcEÐ) vrcTrM _ __ _ V__ _ p___”" V _ _ __ p . _ '_"' _ ‘ '— " __ _fi_ __ _ H _ _v_ _ ““ _ _ p __V__ _ _ _5gt_-Th°m5s"i’_V§i__, Stt. Thomas l{eg 3:5?‘ &.-I_*,. l¡ð¡H-ù:r SiiÈi _ _ —_ '- __ _ ' H > ____ _ '__f_*;_‘ ‘ii’ ' __ _ Z " *_> _ (NEW/III CIIÂNGI]D) ACC_USED NAME (NEW/IFCHANGEDJ ACCUSED NAME (NElry/TF CHANGED) A.1_:C_' C_USED ADDRESS ÂCCUSED ADDRESS (NEW/IF CEANGED) @FEEB.i. SUPPI,EMENTING OFFICER OFFICERSSIGNATURE OF.FICETUS SIGNATURE ‘A APPROVING APPROVING 0FFxcERsI(;NA_TyRIz OFFICER _:‘:___p_ __99/9512313 a9/051201s W .,___ l_"_._" _ ___ " ' - _ _i:_i—._.__:.....-_'_;._____._.,_.._V __ ______ ' 4193'] .m’~,__ Nafifi.A'ITfl:" ' __________ _ V _ _ I ___i;.,._,_;; '_f:,__ '“'__ The call requesting für¡,. Police Ttre Howell Horcell Twp. requestlng an Pol ce Communications Communlcabione Center Center received receíved aa 9-1-1 9-1-1 call an for ambulance anbulance for aa subject eubJect that of an that was belleved to be under tshe influence lnfluence of an nras believed to be u:eder the "unknown substance" ihostile.t Officers Jr. #644, and was was acting asting "hostile." ôfficerg James Jãmea Conaty Conaty,Tr. 'unkåo*n gubst,ancer and Nicholas Ptl. Austin Vincent Ptl. Bonner Ptl. Michael Ptl.. NtcboLae Àusttn #654, M{gdon #645, #654, PtI. Michael Migdon *643, Pbl. Vlace:rÈ Boãnec #647, and unit was Twp. Police Danle1 Murphy PtL. Daniel and Ptl. Murpby #643 EMS r¡niÈ, arrfved on The Howell Police EMS was Howell Trv¡r, #643 arrived on scene. scene. The well. as dispatched dlspatched as well. __ _ _~ H áseeurlty is original cal"I had original call had the foJ.lowing call the following cal-l- details from HTPD HTPD dispatch: dispalct¡: "Security detailE from Ls down the a Tim. Tim of name subject holding holdlng a øubJecÈ dowa by hy Þ/le name of Ttm. Tlm became vety hostile hoaílTe they think beeame very think he he may may be lnflueace be under under the the influence unk of substance. No weapons 10-18. a are a of a unk subetanee. They They are requesting weaponl reguelclng a 70-L8, I[o or to anyone. or injuries ínJurles to anyone. Caller CaJ.Ter is ls Eleni EIen! — The The DMedicer for officers on Upon update on Upon learning learning the the off,Lsers an update on "Medics" for oE scene 6cene were were requesting reguestlng an sedation location I to this as as to well, pur?oees; began purposes; respond realized the sedat,lon the f began to respond to tbls location ae weIl, aE fI realized had obviously escalated. situation the first was made on the flrsb aid made on situatlo¡ had eacalated. This initlal request request was aid This initial channel an EMT. EMt. by an channeL by 1520 Hrs.:: l-520 Hrs. Howell Officers, Upon officers, security securíty staff, eÈaff, Ilpon my my arrival, arriwal, there bhere were were the tl-e aforementioned aforementfoaed ÌIoweLl Howell field; peoBle parking parkLng in the ftel-d; HowelL EMS, EMS, and and Medics ln the Medicg on on location. LocatÍon. There r{ere people Tlrere were and going male subject going to coming b,o the the event. Ln the the ambulance ambulance and and. CPR CPR was coming a:rd event. The was in was The rnale su.bject was being beiag performed. fol-Lowlng from scene; I learned thê following from officers off{cers on on scene: I learned the escort a (Griffin Security) Security staff subject., later ¡na1e subject, later to escorb a male etaff (Griffin attemphlng to SecurJ-ty) were were attempting of One the identified from (Àge:38 W/M), property. One of the the staff Êtaff as Timothy TÍmothy Harden ldentifled as Harden (Age:38 W/M), from the propertymembers on his hLs him to bo check check on was struck ÊLruck in dn the the face approached him me¡nbers was face by by him hl.rn as as they approached It other was he hostile to be was as patrons. reported status, as he was reported ft wae report,ed by other reporbed to be acting acbíng hoetile by statue, 62-68 Prosecutor's Prosecutor's File File 0258 Filed 08/04/16 Page 60 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1297 Howell Howe1l Township Tor+rnship Police Pol-ice Department Deparbment Page: Page: 2 2 SUPPLEMENTAL THOMAS WEG STIPPÍJEITENTÀL NARRATIVE NÀRRATIVE FOR FOR SGT. I'IEG SGT. ltgoldAg Ref:l5—39715~OF nerr L5-39715-OF Entry 238 Eotry ID: fD: 236 Modified ID: Modified. Í,Dt 237 237 Approval Àp¡rroval ID: 237 ÍD; 237 Entered: Eatered¡ 09/05/2015 09/O5/20L5 @@ 2123 2L28 Modified: ldodffíed: 09/05/2015 09/05/20L5 @@ 2310 2310 Approved: .rpproved; 09/OS/2015 09/os/zoLS @@ 2310 z3t-O nhostile0 and by blreae security staff by these_security Ebaff members, members, that that Harden under the Harden was was "hostile" believed under and beliewed the runknortu influence “unknown substance." an inf}uence of of an sul¡stance.rr Officers told Offlcers me that t<¡Id me strength" gaio that Harden llarden displayed díspLayed "super etrenglhr and Ehey could could not not gain êrld they 'super control of him to for first be aid Harden's to Due administered. conbrol of hlm in ln attempts atbempts for fJ.rst, aid to be administered. Due to Hardents refusal refusal to to calm calm his hls demeanor demeanor and and his bo acknowledge acknowledge officers‘ coÍrnande, hLs refusal refusal to offlcere¡ commands, confrontation with the use they Harden, Èhey became became involved involved in phsyical" confrontation in aa phsyical to include lncLude the wilh Hatrden, to uee of to gain control of him. Ptl. and Migdon Ultimately, of 0C OC spray, spray, in 1n attempts atternpte to control of hím. UltlmaEely, PtL. Mtgilon and Ptl. Ptl , Bonner that Borurer were were able abLe to to place handcuffs handcuffs on wag reported teportêd me rne that on him. hlm. Additionally, AdclftJ-ona1ly, it it was Harden that and felt officers placing placing Hardea continued continued to to act acü violent violent in in handcuffs handcuffs and officere feLt that Harden's so that Hardenrs feet feet in in flex flex cuffs cutfs might medical. attention attention might control hlm enough côatroL him eaough so üba.t medical could to him himself. from injuring could be be rendered prevent rendered and prevent, and to bo him, himeeLf. Ï¡irr, as ag well welL as íajurfng as to him from his kick with continued Although to feet/legs, Àlthougb his bls hands hande were were now noÌ{ secured, witb hle feet,/J.egs, secured, Harden k{ck Harden contínued to which medical personnel preventedmedical furtber prevented whích further perEon¡rel to Bonner and and Ptl. Ptl. tend to him. Ptl. Ptt. Bonner to tend bo him. but this Murphy placed pLaced the the flex fLex cuffs on cuffs on his legs but liüt1e effect effêct on on his Lhig had had little olirr¡p, n he was controlling him. point while hlm. At conErolJ"lng ¡lt one one polnt ground, Harden n¡ent "limp," whLLe Ï¡e the ground, Hardên went was on on the medical aid unconscious, and unresponsive. unresponsfve. It uncoDgcloua, and to include include CPR fb was aj.d to was at CPR at this thLg time, medlca]was vas rendered readered to to him. hl-m. Upon Ugon learning Learning this thle information, ínformation, and gbaËementã. and detectives detect,lves for for statements. After gebtlng aa medical Äfter getting medLcal M.C.P.O. M.C.F.O. be be contacted. eonÈacEed. of the None l{one of bhe I I contacted coãt,acÈed Det. Deb. Sgt. request,êd ID and requested .F,r¡tunez and fD Êgb. Antunez update while requested rÀ/ere on whlle EMS EMS and ldedice were on scene, Êcene, II requested and Medics responding reeponding officers, ia this officera, EMS, physicalty injured in t,hj.s ã1rlS, Medics ïrerê physically t'Iedícsr were not did in the face was want any punched ln tbe f,ace dld not want was punched altercation. The security officer aLtercatíon. The offícer who ¡sho medical assistance. ¡nedi.cal asgistance. scene and Sgt. called me me while Clancy called that he he would would be be Sgt. Clancy v¡aÉ at whlle II was ae the Ëbe êcenê and advised advíÊed that Unit" ¡Professional standards and "Professional the sending detectives, ID, det,ecblves, ID, and notifying from the nobifying the standards UnlEfi from bhe prosecutor's prosecuEorts office. office, I contact with wlth Capt. Capt. Pilecki I made made contact Pll-ecki while srhíl.e Kudrick and Chief Martin. Lt. Chief, Kudríck and Irt. Martln. and requested on scene bím to to notify nobífy reguesbed him scene and on 1644 with at JSUMC rfSûMC with able to Àtacdonald who wag at L644 Hrs.: Hrs. t II was wag able to make wlro was make contact contact. with PtL. Macdonald wiEh Ptl. at 1614 Macdonald Ptl. deceased told that Harden. Harden Hrs. me was pronounced pronounced at 1614 Harden. PbL. ldacdonald toLd me thah Harden ïraE Hrs. deceaeed JSUMC. Ptl. by !f.c.P.O. would by Dr. from M.C.P.O. fron,JSII! C. IÐ from wouLd Youseef from Ptl. Macdonald was advised advised that that ID Dr. Youssef Macdouald was be be responding his location. Location, respondJ-ng to Ëo his 1648 1648 Hrs.: Hre.: Det. Det. M.C.P.O. arrived (}n scene. Sgt. scene. Pamela Ricciardi frÕm lt.C.P.o. Sgt. Pamela Rfcclardi from arrlved on ,feremy Hoffman lloffman thLg event event were were Jeremy scer¡e during this The Paramedice that The MONOC thab were wêre on MONOC Paramedics on #3787 and Joseph Zimmerman zin¡nerman #3706. #3706. #3787 and scene 'IoeeBh The Þol"ice EMS EM,g Tbe Howell lIowell Police John R. personnel Troy and personnel were Sn,ltlt. and .foha R. Smith. were Patrick Pabrick 'Troy 1731 Sgt. Santorsola 1731 Hrs.z Det. Sgt. arrived Hre. r Det. Santersola arrived H—m#-M'_ Z _ on scene. scene. on V #4 Z i ' Pir'osecutor's Prosecutor's File F¡le 0250 0259 Filed 08/04/16 Page 61 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1298 fi36el1—Toinship ÊowelL Torrnshíp Police Pol.iae Department Departmeut Page: Fage: gor. THOMAS guPBf,EtlEt{'ltår¿ NARRATIVE SUPPLEMENTAL TEottaE wna wB€ NAaaÀTrvE ron roR SGT. 3 3 15-39715-OF Rafi REf:15-39715-OF Entered: e,þêrêdr 09/05/2015 A9/A5/2075 @ A 2128 2128 Modified: l{odlfl-ed¡ 09/05/2015 09/AEl20L5 @ 2310 @ 2310 Approved: À¡¡prov6d, 09/05/2015 091O5120L5 0 & 2310 231.0 _ Entry El¡try ID: 238 IDI 238 Modified l,lodlfled ID: Î,D¡ 237 237 Approval ÍD¿ Approwal ID: 237 231 1800‘Hra.: Medicai Examiners dféfeéis t Exe. t Andrew Taylor from from the tha t{cdfaal cers cofigéeted information related this to case. requested reque8ted lafo¡matlon related to thig caaê. me me anEf_ 1900 Hra.: If cleared X.900 Hrs.: cleared the the scene. eoene. r åLl are approximate. approxlmate. Note: ûIote All times tímes are Prosecutor's Prosecutor's Ffié File 0260 0260 Filed 08/04/16 Page 62 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1299 L L L (. Ç)rJ Office Examiner Medical Examiner of the the Medical Office of 1490 .A'venue Livingston Avenue 1490 Livingston North Brunswick, 08902 NJ 08902 North Brunswick, NJ AUTOPSY REPORT OT'AUTOPSY REPORT OF DECEDENT Timotþ HARDEN, Timothy NAME: HARDEN, DECEDENT NAME: 9/6/2015 DATE EXAMINATION: 9/6/2015 DATE OF oF EXAMINATION: CASE 13-15-A970 #: 13-15-0970 cASE #: TIME: TIME: 10:05 A'M' 10:05 AM. and Louis the of the Louis Zuppa zuppa of Bozza and Daniel Bozza PERSONS Detectives Daniel AT EXAMINATION: EXAMINATION: Detectives PRESENT AT PERSONS PRESENT 228 Local P.B.A. Howell of Chris Detective I'ocal228 and P.B.A. Nagy Office Prosecutor’s Howell of Monmouth Nagy Chris County Prosecutor's Offrce and Detective Monmouth County PATHOLOGICAL DIAGNOSES: CLINICAL DIAGNOSES: AND CLINICAL PATHOLOGICAL AND delirium excited I.I. Drug induced øxcited delirium Drug induced guard of security security guard attack of unprovoked attack A. behavior with unprovoked combative behaviorwith agitated, and and combative Disoriented, agitated, A. Disoiiented, blood in (see detected (see postmortem blood B. THC detected in postmortem delt¿-9 THC and delta—9 ethanol, and Benzoylecgorrln", ethanol, B. Benzoylecgonine, Toxicology Report) Toxicology Report) and police guard_s.an-d-políce to manual C. by security sccurity guards restraint by forcible restraint manual forcible C. Subjected Subjecte{L hehind cul'l'cd with hands with restrained with ankles restrained back, ankles pla;d by D. position wittr hands cuffed behind back, police in prone position in prone by police D. Placed officers and manually head, over mask flex placed over head, and officers manually cuffs, pepper spray spit mask placed applied, spit spray applied, flex cuffs, violent struggling cuffed limbs while cuffed force to episodic during struggling while violent epiiodic applying applying fórce to tim¡s duång D in described in while occurred death D Sudden E. position in E. Sudden death occured while in position described neck, acute II. acute ofneck, ir{uries of impact injuries Blunt impact il. Blunt muscles and stemocleidomastoid left A. and stemohyoid sternohyoid muscles Contusions, sternocleidomastoÍd left A. Contusions, without or obstruction obstruction instability or airway instability B. cartilage, without airway Fracture, right of thyroid thyroid cartilage, hom of right superior superior horn B, Fracfure, consciousness of loss without neck of consciousness Witness of C. compression without loss reports of neck compression C. Witness reports sudden death death prior to to sudden D. minute prior one minute until one restralnt until tlroughout restraint D. Vocalizing Vocalizing throughout III. hemonhages Conjunctival hemorrhages III. Conjunctival exposure restraints, exposure agaírrst restraints, straining against Possible possible A. violent straining compression, violent etiologies neck compression, inciude neck etiologies include A. and blunt to imPact blunt impact spray, and to pepper PePPer spray, acute of IV. head, acute iqiuries of head, impact injuries IV. Blunt Blunt impact lips, and A. and scalp scalp face,lips, and abrasions, abrasions, face, Contusions and A. Contusions acute and of shoulders, torso Blunt V. acute injuries shoulders, and impact V. Blunt impact iqjuries of torso back chest, right and back testis, and right testis, A. shoulders, chest, confusions, shoulders, Abrasions and/or contusions, Ã. Abrasionsand/or 8"‘ rib B. right 8û rib B. Fracture, Fracture, right acute of Blunt VI. injuries impact extremities, acute of extremities, injuries impact Blunt Vi. and legs legs hand, and A. right hand, wrists, right contusions, arms, wrists, and contusions, A. Abrasions Abrasions and disorder member) VII. family (per (per member) family Bipolar disorder VII. Bipolar SEAL NOT RAISED SEAL \ryITHOUT RAISED NOT OFFICIAL OFFICIAL WITHOUT f72cpA ¿>Ð I Filed 08/04/16 Page 63 of 69 PageID: Case 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB 3:15-cv-08043-BRM-TJB Document 63-2 Filed Page D: 1300 L. LLUJ L 13150970 13150970 Q J 22 HARDEN, Tirnothy HAR-DEN, Timothy OPINION: OPINION: and manner the cause a¡rd to thc of clcallt: clealh: nran¡tcr of as.to opirúon as arr opinion The to forming forming an reviewed prior to were reviewed items were following items The following :ìi:" Clare Report, EMS Prehospital Police Carc Report' llowell Prelrospital EMS Incident Police Report, Howell Department Incident Repãn, IlÀwell Police Department Township Police Howell Township llowcll Township police oflicers, ofücers, Torvnslri¡r palice statelnents 0off l{owell Report, statements Ocean Monmouth Care Report, Hospital Patient Care Service Patient Monmouth Ocean Hospital Service Service Ocean Hospital Monmouth Service l{ospital technicians, police Department Howell mcãical tcchnicians' Monmouflt Ocezut Department emergency medical Township Police Howell Township officer Police Department Township Police Department officcr I-lowcll Township witnesscs, Iiowell civilial witnesses, guards, and a¡d civilian privatc security security guards, paramedics, paramedics, private and calls 911 Dcpartnrent 911 calls and Police Department Tbwnship Police audio r"co,di,,gr, and auclio of Howell Horvell Township recordings, audio car video recordings of auclio recordings video and car Howell and deceased ofthc the dcccascd and l-Iorvell grandmother-of the grandmother betrveer:r the Jalls between radio phone calls of phone recordings of ar¡dio recordings trmsmissions, audio radio transmissions, while at of at deceascd wlúle the deceased the of photographs of the ,"",r", photographs Police Dcpartinent dispatch, photographs Township l)epallnent clispatch, 1'owns¡ip policc fnotogruptrs of the scene, involved officers and police ofticers involved of the guards-and police security guards the security Center, photographs prt"tãgt"plts of Jersey Meclical Ccnter, Un.iversity Medical Shore University Jcrsey Shore of Shore of Jersey Jersey Shore department the from deparfnent emergency records medical emergency and in deceased, and me¿í"äl rr"ã.áu from the the deceased, restraining the in restraining University Center. Medical Center. University Medical lvhen, without without state when, agitated state outdoor concert disoriented, agitated in aa disoriented, event in 38 year old an was This concert event an outcloor at an was at man old in T¡is 3g striking by responded by striking the face. reportedly resporr