Suits Filed - Texas v. Federal Government Case Name Filed Status/Closed 6/13/2008 4/18/2017 Water Transfer Rule 3/22/2010 10/24/2011 FERC rule- intrastate natural gas pipelines- daily internet posts on business activities DC 2/16/2010 9/7/2010 10/15/2013 Endangerment Finding (Consolidated 10-1182 & 10-1041) Florida, et al. v. U.S. Dep’t of Health & Human Services (11th Cir. 11-11021 & 11-11067 consolidated) 3/23/2010 6/28/2012 Healthcare Lawsuit- Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act TX Oil & Gas Assn., et al v. EPA Cir. 10-60459) (5th 6/11/2010 3/15/2013 Coalition for Responsible Regulation v. EPA Cir. 10-1092) (DC 7/7/2010 10/15/2013 7/26/2010 8/27/2012 6/1/2010 8/2/2010 6/23/2014 8/11/2010 11/8/2010 8/23/2010 7/20/2012 9/23/2010 5/18/2011 12/12/2010 2/21/2014 PCP (TX Pollution Control Project Standard Permit) (Consolidated w/ other cases in 5th Cir. under 10-60891) 12/15/2011 2/14/2011 12/20/2010 5/22/2015 GHG SIP (Consolidated in 5th under lead case no. 11-1037) EPA’s PM2.5 Rule (Particulate Matter <2.5) 12/30/2010 5/4/2011 5/4/2015 3/14/2011 12/18/2012 7/19/2011 12/3/2013 Catskill Mountains v. EPA, No. 08-cv-5606108430 1 S.D.N.V. (2nd Cir. 14-1823) TX Pipeline Assn. & RR Comm. v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission ( FERC) No. 10-60066 (5th Cir.) Case Information OCC/Experts OAG Case No. Experts/OCC Salary/Overhead Travel/Other Total 123381808 $ 4,317.36 $ 200.00 $ 4,517.36 103182101 SG: 103234381 $ 17,719.03 $ 1,280.60 $ 18,999.63 103202909 SG: 103203253 $ 275,281.18 $ 35,000.00 $ 32,940.40 $ 343,221.58 103204673 $ 6,823.61 $ 20,000.00 $ 13,698.04 $ 40,521.65 Approval and Promulgation of Implementation Plans; Revisions to New Source Review (NSR) State Implementation Plan (SIP); Modification of Existing Qualified Facilities Program and Definitions; Final Rule) (consolidated in 5th Cir. Under lead case 10-60459) Tailpipe Rule (consolidated DC Cir. with 10-1192 under lead case no. 10-1092) 103199584 $ 48,429.24 $ 1,345.63 $ 49,774.87 103202917 $ 1,987.04 $ 450.00 $ 2,437.04 Flexible Permits (consolidated in 5th Cir. under lead case 10-60614) Tailoring & Timing Rule (consolidated with 10-1222 (timing); lead case no. 10-1073 (tailoring)) Sued to overturn drilling moratorium following Deepwater Horizon 103202941 $ 40,216.70 $ 1,317.54 $ 41,534.24 103202925 103202958 $ 3,190.06 $ 450.00 $ 3,640.06 103209557 $ 14,082.92 $ 1,151.53 $ 15,234.45 SO2 Rule: Primary Nat’l Ambient Air Quality Standard for SO2 (+ other states) (Consolidated with 10-1259 under lead case no. 10-1252) Doggett Amend.-Federal funding for education 103211181 $ 33,246.70 $ 470.80 $ 33,717.50 103217790 $ 5,455.01 $ 650.00 $ 6,105.01 103231049 113264055 113264055-A 103219945 $ 81,664.60 $ 2,490.39 $ 84,154.99 $ 25,074.53 $ 200.00 $ 25,274.53 103238952 $ 13,683.14 $ 14.68 $ 13,697.82 113239552 $ 27,284.75 $ - $ 27,284.75 113251920 $ 9,258.90 $ 450.00 $ 9,708.90 113277438 $ 304,283.60 $ 93,764.32 $ 919,579.51 2 Coalition for Responsible Regulation v. EPA Cir. 09-1322 3 4 5 Expert: Bracewell & Giuliani (Pro #1023357) OCC: Bancroft 2011-302-0441 (Pro #1100441) (cost share agreement w/ FL) 6 TX, et al v. EPA 7 (5th Cir. 10-60614) Coalition for Responsible Regulation v. EPA (DC Cir. 10-1073) 8 TX, Perry, Patterson v. U.S. Department of Interior, et.al 9 Nat’l Environ. Dept. Assn’s Clean Air Project v. EPA (DC Cir. 10-1252) 10 TX, Perry v. U.S. Department of Education 11 (5th Cir. 10-60793) TX v. EPA (Luminant Generation Co., et al v. EPA) (5th Cir. 10-60891) 12 TX v. EPA (Utility Air Regulatory Group v. EPA) (DC 13 Cir. 11-1037) TX v. EPA 14 (DC Cir. 10-1415) TX, Perry, et al v. EPA (DC Cir. 11-1128) 15 TX v. EPA (5th Cir. 11-60158) Pending 16 TX v. Holder (No. 1:11-cv-1303_RMC) 17 GHG FIP Rule and Final GHG FIP Rule (Federal Implementation Plan) (consolidated with another case under lead case no. 11-1128) SB 7 (Texas Senate Bill 7- TX rules and regulations- air quality, implementation plans) (consolidated in 5th circuit with PCP Standard Permit case (10-60891) under lead case 11-30158) Redistricting Pre-clearance Expert: Rivkin (Baker Hostetler) (OCC #2010302-0245) OCC: Bartlit Beck: 2012302-0154 (Pro # 1232339) Experts: Alford (Pro # 1125533) Stevenson (Pro #1126218) $ 521,531.59 Suits Filed - Texas v. Federal Government TX v. EPA (EME Homer City Generation) (DC Cir. 11-1302) 9/20/2011 7/28/2015 CSAPR (Cross-State Air Pollution Rule) (Consolidated with 11-1338 under lead case no. 11-1302) TX v. Holder (No. 1:12-cv-00128-RMC (D.D.C.)) 1/23/2012 8/27/2013 Voter ID 18 OCCs: Bartlit Beck (2012-302-0203 (Pro #1232453)) 113282438 113288815 113288484 113285142 113283568 SG: 113293393 123308686 $ 585,242.14 $ 1,185,387.26 25,159.15 $ $ 642,738.89 24,140.77 $ 609,382.91 $ 147,274.92 $ 1,975,401.07 $ 450.00 $ $ - $ Bancroft (2013-302-0415 (Pro #1339654)) Experts: Shaw (Pro #1232446) Blank (Pro #1232461) Sager (Pro #1232677) 19 TX, TCEQ v. EPA 20 (12-60128) Nebraska, et al v. US Health & Human Services 21 (No. 4:12-cv-03035-CRZ (USDC, Nebraska) TX v. Sebelius; US Health & Human Services (USDC, W.D. Tex.-Waco Div) 22 TX, TCEQ v. EPA (12-1185) 2/23/2012 10/29/2015 TX Implementation Plan-Infrastructure and Interstate Transport Requirements (PSDGHGSIP) Healthcare coverage conflicting w/ moral and religious beliefs 123313629 $ 2/23/2012 8/6/2013 No OAG Case # $ 3/16/2012 Voluntary Dismissal 1/9/13 Pending Women’s Health Program (Planned Parenthood funding) 123320715 SG: 123324683 $ 338,063.94 $ 20,093.07 $ 358,157.01 $ 39,209.75 $ 450.00 $ 39,659.75 7/19/2012 3/7/13 6/2/2015 $ 24,222.41 $ 900.00 $ 25,122.41 TX, TCEQ v. EPA 8/6/2012 (12-1344, consolidated w/ 12-1342) TX, TCEQ v. EPA (12-60621, consolidated w/ 12-60617) TX, RRC, TCEQ v. EPA 10/15/2012 (In Re: EPA’s Final rule on Oil & Gas Sector) (12-1405, 12-1417) STATE NATIONAL BANK OF BIG SPRING ET AL v. 2/13/2013 GEITHNER ET AL., Case No. 1:12-cv-01032, in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia (consolidated with 13-5248) TX & LA v. Crabtree, et al (Nat’l Marine Fisheries, NOAA, 4/22/2013 US Dept. Of Commerce) OK, et al v. EPA. 7/16/2013 Case No. 5:2013-cv-00726 United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma STATES OF NORTH DAKOTA, SOUTH DAKOTA, NEVADA 9/12/2013 AND TEXAS v. EPA Case No. 1:13-cv-00109-CSM, in the United States District Court for the Southwest District of Oklahoma Sierra Club v. McCarthy, N.D. Ca. 3:2013-cv-03953 9/26/2013 Pending Wise County Ozone Designation (consolidated w/ Mississippi Commission on Environmental Quality v. EPA, 12-1309) (consolidated w/ 12-1312) TX’s Regional Haze Plan 123325235 123325235-A 123325235-B 123324113 123325243 123342495 123342495-A 123348302 123348302-A $ 21,733.18 $ 900.00 $ 22,633.18 4/16/2012 MATS Rule (Mercury and air Toxics Standards) (consolidated with White Stallion Energy Center v. EPA (12-1100), Utility Air (121166)) 23 TX, TCEQ v. EPA (12-1316) 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Sierra Club v. EPA, DC Cir 13-1262 TX v. EEOC, Case No. 5:13-cv-00255-C, in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, 33 Lubbock Division 11/4/2013 11/4/2013 - 25,609.15 - Voluntary Dismissal 1/17/2013 Pending EPA’s Final Rule on Oil & Gas Sector (Green Pollution Rule) 123359689 $ 4,997.89 $ 450.00 $ 5,447.89 Challenges Title II of Dodd-Frank 153560669 $ 61.15 $ - $ 61.15 5/31/2013 Red Snapper Fishing Rule 133394262 $ 95,155.26 $ 1,322.21 $ 96,477.47 12/18/2013 Clean Air Act Regional Haze Program documents FOIA request 133433540 133450833 $ 565.42 $ 1,616.27 $ 2,181.69 Pending National Ambient Air Quality Standards regulation 133431486 $ 28,789.64 $ 2,465.95 $ 31,255.59 Pending Failure to designate areas as attaining or not attaining or unclassifiable for SO2 NAAQs SO2 Air Quality Designations, 78 FR 47191 Hiring of felons 133450833 $ 357.22 $ 1,616.27 $ 1,973.49 133461392 133441931 $ $ 227.96 162,509.56 $ 1,910.47 $ $ 227.96 164,420.03 Pending Pending Suits Filed - Texas v. Federal Government Texas, et al v. Jeh Johnson, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al, Case No. 1:14-cv-00254, in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas, 34 Brownsville Division State of Texas vs. USA, US Department of Labor, et al., Civil Action No. 7:15-cv-56 in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Wichita Falls 35 Division Luminant v. EPA, D.C. Cir. No. 15-1301 36 In re: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' and U.S. EPA's Proposed Rules Defining 'Waters of the U.S.', S.D. Tex. (Galveston 3:15-cv-00612); (6th Cir, 15-3853); (U.S.S.C. 37 16-299) Texas, et al v. U.S. Health & Human Services Commission, No. 7:15-cv-00151-O, N.D. Tex. (Wichita 38 Falls) $ 55,042.02 $ 817,523.59 25,371.30 $ 2,870.29 $ 28,241.59 $ 34,266.22 $ 1,135.84 $ 35,402.06 $ 167,011.77 $ 1,400.00 $ 175,868.41 CX4530672064 CX6172807045 $ 177,121.47 $ 13,585.00 $ 190,706.47 153580600 153576236 $ 174,255.92 $ 18,357.97 $ 192,613.89 CX5036931572 CX5663221972 $ 7,671.87 $ 2,897.00 $ 10,568.87 Red River land dispute CX1260025395 $ 267,466.87 $ 5,242.88 $ 272,709.75 Review of National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Ozone CX7949535144 $ 25,276.15 $ 470.00 $ 25,746.15 Regional Haze CX1607310318 CX5225941469 CX6314100007 $ 150,575.79 $ 3,380.35 $ 153,956.14 $ 86,382.92 $ 5,350.97 $ 91,733.89 CX7261562976 CX9580305457 CX7934729921 CX1380066793 $ 242,931.21 $ 5,504.81 $ 248,436.02 $ 12,034.00 $ $ 12,034.00 CX7283206502 CX0861731359 CX3619154615 CX7745685377 $ 98,202.88 $ 1,171.72 $ 99,374.60 $ 12,013.71 $ 1,659.75 $ 13,673.46 CX0390168219 $ CX0649336566 $ 49,805.40 CX4930853546 $ CX8122926031 CX4408150746 CX3579265516 12/3/2014 Voluntary Dismissal 9/5/2017 Immigration reform 3/18/2015 Withdrawn Same-sex marriage/FMLA 7/10/2015 Pending Disapproval of SSM Affirmative Defense 6/29/2015 7/16/2015 Pending EPA & Army COE rule on Waters of the United States 10/22/2015 Pending Obamacare Medicaid tax Texas, et. al v. Environmental Protection Agency, No. 15- 10/23/2015 1363, D.C. Cir.; Texas, et. al v. Environmental Protection Agency, No. 15-1399, D.C. Circuit Pending Challenge of EPA's Clean Power Plan under section 111(d) carbon rule for existing sources, and EPA's Greenhouse Gas Emissions rule under section 111(b) - carbon rule for new sources. Syrian refugee case 39 Texas Health and Human Services Commissioner v. 12/2/2015 United States Department of State, et. al, 3:15-cv-0385140 N, N.D. Tex. (Dallas) Texas v. Bureau of Land Management, 7:15-cv-00162-O, 11/18/2015 41 N.D. Tex. (Wichita Falls) Texas v. EPA, No. 15-1494 (consolidated with Murray 12/23/2015 Energy Corporation v. EPA, U.S. Court of Appeals , DC Circuit Case No. 15-1385, 15-1392, 15-1490 & 15-1491). 42 Texas v. EPA, No. 16-60118, 5th Cir. 2/29/2016 43 National Federation of Independent Business v. Perez, 5/10/2016 44 5:16-cv-00066-C, N.D. Tex. (Lubbock) Harrold ISD & Texas v. United States of America, 5/25/2016 Department of Education, Department of Justice, 7:1645 cv-00054-O Texas v. EPA, No. 16-1257, US Ct of Appeals, DC Circuit 7/28/2016 Voluntary Dismissal 10/11/2016 11/7/2017 Pending 3/22/2017 Pending Voluntary Dismissal 3/3/17 Pending 46 Franciscan Alliance, Specialty Physicians Of Illinois & Texas, et al v. Burwell, Department of Health & Human 47 Services, 7:16-cv-00108-O Texas, et al v. United States Department of Labor, et al, 48 4:16-cv-00731 Texas, et al v. National Telecommunications and Information Administration, et al, 3:16-cv-00274 49 TCEQ v. United States Environmental Protection Agency; Case 16-60670 (US Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit) 50 Michigan v. Environmental Protection Agency, No. 161204, US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit (consolidated with Murray Energy Corp. v. EPA , No. 1651 1127) Texas, et al v. Dept of the Interior, National Marine Fisheries Service, et al, 1:16-cv-00593, US District Court, 52 Southern District of Alabama In re: Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (DC Circuit) Case 1653 1428 (consolidated into 16-1406) Intervension motion and memoranda to support on Persuader Rule. Department of Education 'Significant Guidance' to school districts regarding Title IX and Title XII. Challenge of EPA's final rule, Oil and Natural Gas Sector: Emission Standards for New, Reconstructed, and Modified Sources Regarding implementation of new rule interpreting the definition of 'sex' within the Affordable Care Act. 8/23/2016 Pending 9/20/2016 Pending 9/28/2016 10/11/2016 Voluntary Dismissal 10/17/2016 Pending 6/24/2016 Pending 11/29/2016 Pending Regarding the Federal Government's plan to abandon NTIA's option rights under its contract with ICANN, cancel its agreement with Verisign, etc. Approval and Promulgation of Air Quality Implementation Plans; Texas; Interstate Transport of Air Pollution for the 2008 Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standards Regarding EPA's Supplemental Finding that it is appropriate and necessary to regulate hazardous air pollutants from Coal- and OilFired Electric Utility Stream Generating Units; Final Rule; 81 Fed Register 24419, published April 25, 2016. Definition of 'critical habitats' under the Endangered Species Act 12/20/2016 Pending Cross-State Air Pollution Rule Update for the 2008 Ozone NAAQS Overtime Rule Welch Consulting, Ltd. OCC: Vinson & Elkins: 2015-35-0141 143551836 $ 752,491.57 153571518 $ 113264055 113264055-A 153582622 - $ $ 9,990.00 7,456.64 - $ - $ $ 744.00 $ 50,549.40 3,053.51 $ 3,053.51 $ 22,290.94 $ 22,290.94 $ 11,988.41 $ 12,738.41 $ 750.00 - Suits Filed - Texas v. Federal Government Texas Dept of Criminal Justice v. United States Food and Drug Administration, 3:17-cv-00001, US District Court, Southern District of Texas 1/3/2017 Pending Delay of state's importation of thiopental sodium CX4477672110 $ 6,458.87 $ 490.00 $ 388,073.64 Stream Protection Rule DX5737435560 $ 3,861.04 $ - $ 3,861.04 Protection of Visibility Rule CX1311877988 $ 7,414.17 $ 500.00 $ 7,914.17 Pending Air Quality Designations for the 2010 Sulfur Dioxide Primary National Ambient Air Quality Standard CX2290241943 $ 47,345.93 $ 2,761.74 $ 50,107.67 Pending Violations of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act CX3502079256 $ 114,969.56 $ 2,734.15 $ 117,703.71 Pending Challenge of DOT interim final rule concerning "Pipeline Safety: Safety of Underground National Gas Storage Facilities" CX7798864938 $ 15,314.68 $ 750.00 $ 16,064.68 Pending Challenge of the "Methane Waste Prevention Rule" CX4289005249 $ 24,670.53 $ 700.00 $ 25,370.53 Pending Indian Child Welfare Act CX2844956409 $ 28,887.70 $ 449.30 $ 29,337.00 54 Texas, et al v. Department of the Interior, Office of 1/17/2017 Surface Mining Reclamation & Enforcement, 1:17-cv55 00108 (US District Court for DC) Texas v. United States Environmental Protection 1/18/2017 56 Agency, 17-1021 (DC Cir.) Texas & TCEQ v. United States Environmental Protection 2/13/2017 Agency; Case 17-60088 (US Ct of Appeals 5th Cir) 57 Texas v. United States Department of Energy (US Ct of 3/14/2017 58 Appeals 5th Cir) Texas Railroad Commission v. United States Dept of 3/17/2017 Transportation, 17-60189 (5th Cir.) 59 Texas, et al v. US Dept of Interior, US Bureau of Land 3/21/2017 Mgmt, 2:16-cv-00285-SWS (consolidated with 2:16-cv00280-SWS) US District Ct for the District of Wyoming 60 Brackeen & Texas v. US Dept of Interior, et al, 4:17-cv10/25/2017 61 00868-O Voluntary Dismissal 04/02/17 Pending Benjamin L. England & Assoc, LLC OCC 2015-696-0019 Alston & Bird, LLP OCC 2015-696-0121 $ $ 381,124.77 5,992,814.69 $ 1,617,841.89 $ 482,411.65 $ 8,093,068.23