EDMUND G. BROWN JR. GOVERNOR MARK S. GHILARDUCCI DIRECTOR VIA EMAIL ONLY: willparrish2016@gmail.com October 30, 2017 Will Parrish Investigative Journalist Willparrish2016@gmail.com Subject: September 1, 2017 Request for Public Records Dear Mr. Parrish: Please find the attached bates stamped documents, “PARRISH PRA_000286 to 000352” in response to your September 1, 2017 Public Records Act request. Certain information contained within the attached response has been redacted pursuant to Government Code section 6254(f) and is information related to ongoing criminal investigations. A record of intelligence from the Federal Bureau of Investigation that was identified as responsive to your request was exempted from disclosure pursuant to Government Code section 6254(f). The documents provided herein along with the responsive documents provided to you on October 16, 2017, satisfy your September 1, 2017 Public Records Act request. Cal OES considers your September 1, 2017 request for documents closed. Of course, should you have any questions, please contact me at (916) 845-8972 or by email at pra@caloes.ca.gov. Sincerely, Amanda De Alba Attorney, Office of Legal Affairs cc: Alex Pal, Assistant Chief Counsel 3650 SCHRIEVER AVENUE, MATHER, CA 95655 (916) 845 - 8972 TELEPHONE (916) 845 - 8389 FAX CALIFORNIA STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER, STAC NORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER, NCRIC JUNE 19, 20,17 1 PARRISH CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE PARRISH STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER STAC The-Bottom" Lih i-Wefjassess cInti- -fdscist (Antifo) and right-wing extremIst InteractIons In California have escalated' In wolence throughout the last 15 months. weapons used in four California :?New'publlc calls by Antifa extremists advocatmg for u'p'porters to bring firearms PARRISH CALIFORNIA STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER STAC CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER NCRIC 7' - Hate Crime Overview otalreported hate crimes in California? largest Cltle; V14 2% In 2016 atecrImeS based on race, ethnicity, religion, gender S?exua 'rI'eintatIon (CaIIfornIa hate crime code) ate crImeS trendIng towards first baCk- to- back Increase ears as of late 2016 but less than 2007 8; 2001 ?gures PARRISH . . 7 . . LIEORNIA-STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER, STAC . ,0 HERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER NCRIC Ext remist' Threathli; PARRISH I ALIFQRNIA STATE THREAT CENTER STAC ORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER NCRIC ".CaIIfornIa Escalation In AntI Right- -Wing Extremist VIolence II extremiSt activities are well?clocumenteij,? Viole?ntclaishes a re typical and. have escalated over thellast'15mo'nths? in metropolita n' areas and smallerc?ities ounter?p retests and co?opting lawful protest Sc, from outside cities, possfibly'cthetstates PARRISH rg? White Knights in California aw. enforcement nio?tified of rally days 'prior sta 12 -a?rii_rests Grow, uef?htifas-Iswarmed the 'Klah members PARRISH Organized by the TradItIonaIIst WOrker Party Goil'den State Skmheads nedkyyieeksinadvance with permit AntIfa/CoaIItIon to Defend Affirmative Action, is? m. :lntegratlon and Immigrant Rights and Fight for ma?tm 19-9? :EquaIIty By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) counter pretest 7stabengsat east 9? Injuries PARRISH 7 . -. PARRISH NCLASSIFI PROTEST THE IN. N6 NC) snaacmma 9 AM JUNE 26 ., STATE WEST STEPS 1-315 10?? St. I St. (Nazi Rally begins at 12 pm) 1' PARRISH CALIFORNIA STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER STAC . NORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER, NCRIC PIggybackIngactIVIst Organized events Doxxmg-wmay lead tq violehce or threats IVIemesand trO . ing PotentIalDDOS attacks FaISEflags and fa se informat'io COmm-On?Online Tactisz, PARRISH CALIFORNIA STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER STAC 7- - .3- NORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER NCRIC Outlook are ;IIker to contmue to See these nteractIOns Involve escalated violent f5 jadgmg from recent Antifa public aIIs foraggresswe tactics and the Success Of these tactics. nIne extremlst and Communist PARRISH 1 .i'fgf OFFICIAL LLSE ONLY 2} 7 ALIFORNIA STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER, STAC -. NORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE NCRIC A Key TakeawayS tungn?rearms tO events suggests we will continue to see these? te"d__ Violent tactics - .. . . PARRISH STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER STAC ORTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE CENTER NCRIC PARRISH OFFICIAL USE ONLY JOINT INTELLIGENCE BULLETIN 26 June 2017 California: Escalation in Anti-Fascist, Right?Wing Extremist Violence VIOlent Clashes between left- and rIght-wmg extremists in CalIfornIa in the last 16 months reflect Ideological rIvalrIes tracmg back- to the 1930s in Europe and the United States We assess that anti-fascist (Antifa) and right-wing extremist interactions in California have escalated in violence throughout the last 16 months, judging from a State Threat Assessment Center (STAC) and Northern California Regional Intelligence Center (NCRIC) review of incidents and open- source reports from February 2016-May 2017. Weapons used at a February 2016 clash included a flag pole, two-by-fours, and a knife, while at a separate incident four months later police discovered an abandoned firearm. 1'2 Public calls by Antifa extremists earlier this year advocating for supporters to bring firearms to events points to possible further escalation. 3? - Antifa and right-wing violent clashes in California have largely occurred in metropolitan areas like Sacramento, Berkeley and Anaheim. Based on arrest reports, the number of individuals attending rallies and counter-protests, and media intervieWs with attendees suggests that some individuals probably are traveling to these events from outside cities and possibly other states.?6 - (U) The first incident reviewed from the last 16 months involved a Ku Kiux Klan rally at Pearson Park in Anaheim on 27 February 2016. Several dozen Antifa extremists initiated an altercation with the Klansmen that led to multiple injuries and three stabbings.7 Seven Antifas were charged with assault, battery, or resisting arrest. Five Klansmen were later released without charges, according to press reports.8'9 (U) Fascist salute at Berkeley rally (U) Source: itsgolngdown.org - - (U) On 26 June 2016, the white nationalist extremist group the Traditionalist Worker held an event with the Golden State SkinheadsUSPER infront ofthe Sacramento State Capitol where they encountered Antifa extremists, resulting in a clash involving knives, bottles, bricks, and . chunks of concrete.??11 A firearm was found abandoned (U) Antifascits mspiay ?ag during counter~protest on the ground where the melee broke out, according to (U) Source= itsgoingdown- org the Sacramento Police Department};13 - (U) In response to UC BerkeleyUSPER cancelling a 1 February 2017 appearance by former BreitbartUSPER editor Milo Yiannopoulos because of violence attributed to Antifa activists, right- w?ing groups held two events in Berkeley In the name of free speech. Both resulted in violent clashes when Antifa THE STAC AND NCRIC JOINT INTELLIGENCE BULLETIN PROVIDES COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF OR UPDATES OF EXISTING, INTELLIGENCE ISSUESWARNING: This document Is the exclusive property ofthe California State Threat Assessment Center (STAC) and Northern California Regional Intelligence Center (NCRIC) and is OFFICIAL USE ONLY It contains information that may be exempt from public release under the California Public Records Act (Govt. Code Sec. 6250, etseqn) It is to be controlled, stored, handled, transmitted, distributed and disposed of in accordance with STAC policy relating to information and Is not to be released to the public, the media, or other personnel who do not have a valid need- to- know without prior approval of an authorized STAC official. OFFICIAL USE ONLY PARRISH Form UNCLAS8EFIEDHFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY extremists showed up. At a rally held on 4 March 2017, Antifa and right?wing (extremists clashed . again, leading to several injuries and ten arrests. This time, authorities confiscated metal pipes, bats, bricks, and protective gear?such as helmets, shin guards, and industrial respirators?from multiple attendees, according to multiple media reports.15'16'17 - At a subsequent event on 15 April 2017, clashes broke out between individuals and groups representing a wide array of ideologies, including Antifa and right-wing individuals using fascist salutes and white nationalist symbology.18 Pepper spray, fireworks, knives, stun guns and poles were used or confiscated during theclash, highlighting additional violent tactics being used during clashes.19 We assess that Antifa and right-wing extremists are leveraging photos and videos from violent clashes by featuring them increasingly in online prOpaganda campaigns to garner support, recruit, and mobilize followers for future events. - Anti-fascist organizations such as By Any Means Necessary took a prominent role in the April UC'Berkeley clashes, and the June 2016 clashes in Sacramento?uses social media and its website to mobilize anti-fascist collectives for counter-protests.20 994W - Right-wing extremist groups like the u) Traditibnalistokers Party poster Traditionalist Worker Party use their website and social (U) Source: FacebookUSPE" media platforms to post propaganda, recruit, and promote rallies across the United States, including for the June 2016 rally at the State Capitol in" Sacramento.21 7- Social media and online activities provide centralized platforms for extremist groups to communicate and promote events, extending the amount of time supporters have to plan for mobilization and travel. Based on recent Antifa public calls for the use of aggressive tactics and the perceived success of these tactics we are likely to continue to see Antifa and right-wing extremist interactions at rallies and counter-protests that involve escalated violent tactics. Radical elements within Antifa are now calling for more aggressive tactics afterthe most recent violent clash in April 2017 in Berkeley, according to press reporting and online forums. 22'? They are calling for suppOrters to bring firearms to events, apply for concealed carry permits, and obtain combat training.24 - Antifa and right-wing groups? social media sites and websites often promote videos and imagery of violent clashes, suggesting they believe that using tactics is a successful way of promoting and defending their extremist narratives. OFFICIAL USE ONLY Form PARRISH OFFICIAL USE ONLY (U) ADMINISTRATIVE NOTE (U) For comments or questions related to the content Or dissemination of this document, please contact the STAC at (916)636 2900 or STACQcaloes. ca. gov. (U) TRACKED BY (U) HSEC 8.1 (U) STAC KEY INTELLIGENCE QUESTIONS (U) KIQ 2.3; KIQ 4.3 (U) FEEDBACK (U) The STAC encourages your feedback using the survey found at (U) ENDNOTES 1 (U) Online Newspaper Article; James Queally; Los Angeles Times; ?Ku Klux Klan rally In Anaheim erupts In violence; 3 are stabbed and 13 arrested?; 29 February 2 (U) Online Newspaper Article; Joseph Serna; Los Angeles Times; ?Nee-Nazis did n't start the violence at state Capitol, police say?; 27 June 2016; 3 (U) Internet Site; Mac Salvo; Vessel Training, Better Equipment, Antifa Prepares for War After Berkeley BeatDown?; accessed on 24 April 2017 (U) Internet Site; Frances Dinkelspiel and Natalie Orenstein; Berkeleyside; 17 April 2017; http: berkeleyside. com/2017/O4/17/exactlv~ turned- downtown- berkelev? battlefield- april 15/ Internet Site; Shane Bauer; MotherJones; Went Behind the Front Lines With the Far-Right Agitators Who Invaded Berkeley?; 18 April 2017; http: motheriones. com/poiitics/2017/04/far? right- whlte- s?upremacists- berkelev protests antifa-trump/ Internet Site; Nixie; Berkely Police Department; 17 April 2017; "Police Release Names of Civic Park Arrestees"; ld=1888726 7 (U) Online Newspaper Article; James Queally; Los Angeles Times; "Ku [