MONIQUE CHARLENE TILLMAN
and ERIC BRANCH,

JARED WILLIAMS and THE CITY OF
TACOMA,

case DocUment 150. Filed 03/22/18 Page 1 of 3

1 - HONORABLERONALD 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT 
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON
AT TACOMA

CASE NO. C16-5794 RBL.
VERDICT FORM

Plaintiffs,
v.

Defendants.

 

 

 

 

We, the jury, answer the questions submitted by the Court as follows:

1.

Do you ?nd that Of?cer Williams violated Monique Tillman?s constitutional rights by
using excessive force on May 24, 2014?

Yes!

Do you ?nd that Of?cer Williams violated Monique Tillman?s constitutional rights by
unreasonably seizing her on May 24, 2014? 

Yes 

If you answered ?Yes? to Question 1 or 2, proceed to Questions 3, 4, and 5; If you
answered ?No to both Questions 1 and 2, proceed to Question 6.

No

No



Do you ?nd that Chief Ramsdell rati?ed Of?cer Williams? deprivation of Monique
Tillman?s constitutional rights? .

Yes 

No

VERDICT FORM 1

 

 

Document 150 Filed 03/22/18 Page 2 of3 I

4. Do you ?nd that the Tacoma Police "Department?s of?cial policy, practice, or custom was 
the moving force behind the deprivation of Monique Tillman?s constitutional rights?

No 
. 5. Do you ?nd that the Tacoma Police Department?s failure to adeqLiately train Of?cer

- Williams Was the? moving force behindthe deprivation of Monique Tillman?s -
constitutional rightsyou ?nd that Of?cer Williams falsely imprisoned Monique Tillman on May 24,
2014?

Yes 

7. Do you ?nd that Of?cer Williams maliciously prosecuted Monique Tillman?

No);

If you answered ?Yes? to any of the questions above, proceed to Question 8. If you
answered ?No to all of the questions above, proceed to Question 10.

I -Yes_

Yes

No

Yes 

8. What do you ?nd to be the amount of Monique Tillman?s damages?
3; an 
AnswerQuestion 9 only if you answered ?Yes? to Question 1 or 2. If you
answered ?No to Questions I and 2, skip Question 9 and proceed to Question
1 0.
9. Do you award punitive damages to Monique Tillman?



If yes, in what amount?

Yes 



 

10. Do you ?nd that Of?cer Williams violated Eric Branch?s constitutional rights by
unreasonably seizing him on May 24, 2014? 7

Yes 

11. Do you ?nd that Of?cer Williams falsely imprisoned Eric Branch on May 24, 2014?

Yes 

VERDICT FORM - 2

No



No

 

 

., Case Document 150 Filed 03/22/18 Page 3 of 3

If you answered ?Yes? to Question 10 or 1 1, proceed to Question 12. If you answered 

?No to Questions 10 and I 1, sign and date the verdict form and noti?/ the clerk.

_12. What do you ?nd to be the amount of Eric Branch?s damages?

Is I 6011' COO

Answer Question 13 only if you answered "?Yes to Question 10. If you answered
?No to Question 10,"skip Question? 13, sign and date the verdict form and notify
the clerk 

13. Do you award punitive damages to Eric Branch?

Yes No 

If yes, in what amount?



 

Sign and date the verdict form and notify the clerk.

Dated this Edgy of March, 2018.

 

VERDICT FORM - 3