Schedule of Documents Freedom Of Information Request FOI 156/111/2018 Ken Foxe Record Date Description of Grant Refuse Number pages and Reason 1 07/03/2018 Correspondence DJE/Taoiseach 1 Partial Grant 537(1) 1A 07/03/2018 Correspondence to DE 1 Refuse S. 2(a) and S. 35(1)(a) 3. 37(1) and (2) 2 27/2/2018 Internal Emaii Correspondence Crime Division 2 Partial Grant 537(1) 3 09/02/2018 internal Email Crime Division/Press Office 3 Partial Grant 3. 37(1) 4 09/02/2018 internal Email Correspondence between Crime 4 Grant Division 81 Unit 5 08/02/2018 Internal Email Crime revised date 7 Partiai Grant S. 37(1) 6 08/02/2018 Internal Email Crime/ letter cert 2 1? Partial Grant schedules 5. s. 37(1) 7 07/02/2018 Internal Email Crime /FOI/Email from A65 4 Partial Grant 537(1) S. 26/01/2018 Correspondence Grant 20/01/2018 internal email re:Press Query Partial Grant 537(1) 10 20/01/2018 internal emails re: Press Query 5 Partial Grant 5. 37(1) 11 29/11/2017- Correspondence letter and schedules 15 Grant 16/01/2018 12 29/11/2017 Correspondence 1 Grant 13 02/03/2016 Emaiis Schedule Nationai Archives 12 Grant Annmarie Cowley From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 05 April 2018 13:12 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: Letter of Request Attachments: Signed i think this is the last one! From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 07 March 203.8 09:40 To: Subject: FW: Letter of Request From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 07 March 2018 09:30 To: mamkeenan@taoiseacheovie Cc: Peter X. Mullan ; Niall A Colgan Aisling M. Brennan Rosemary X. King Subject: FW: Letter of Request i?li Mary, Further to our recent conversation, please find attached written confirmation fro that the release ofthe transcripts ofthe Kerry Babies Tribunal would cause distres If you need anything further, please contact me. Regards Ben Ben Ryan Crime Division Department of Justice 8L Equality 94 St. Stephen?s Green D02 FDYO 608710 External: +353 (1) 6028710 Annmarie Cowley From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 06 April 2018 135242 To: Annmarie Cowley Cc: Niall A Colgan; Gerard P. Madden Subject: 7' if Annmarie, This is the first of probably many emails about the decision to withhold the Kerry Babies transcripts fro the National Archives, for the FDI. We will need to redact the names of the non-Departmental people Invoived, as well as the email addresses. Regards Ben From: Peter X. Mullan Sent: 27 February 2018 15:12 To: Ben P. Ryan Subject' FOR FILE Peter Peter Mullan Assistant Secretary 1 Crime and Security Directorate Department oflustice and Equality 94 St. Stephen?s Green Dublin 2 D02 FD70 i+353 1 502 332.7%83 oxmullan@iustice.ie Designated Public Of? a egulation of Lobbying Act 2015 see From: Peter X. Mullan Sent: 27 Februa 2018 1 5:08 To: Conon Still no word back from Attorney Genera l?s office, Please 5 tract below from National Archives Act, we have strongly opposed the release on the basis th 4 indicated to me that the release of the transcripts would ca use distress tow. Departme ofAn Taoiseach has indicated that they will need confirmation of same in writing om arrive-h or her representative. l'd be grateful if you could forward a short letter fro "hat effect, I?m available to take call at any stage, hopefully word soon from Attorney?s office Regards Peter Peter Mullan Assistant Secretary Crime and Security Directorate Department ofJustice and Equalit 94 St. Stephen's Green Dublin 2 1 D02 F070 94853 1 602 8327 ?g gxmullan@iustice.ie Designated Public Of?cial under the Regulation of Lobbying Act 2015 see 'trirwwiohb ?in Lie From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 27 February 2018 14:18 To: Peter X. Mullan Subject: Kerry Babies and National Archives Peter; As discussed in relation to the retention of the transcripts of the Tribunal, we sought an exemption under section 8(4) ofthe National Archives Act which provides as follows: (4) An officer of a Department of State authorised for the of this subsection may, with the consent of an officer of the Department of the aoiseach so authorised (except in relation to records of the Department of the Taoiseach), certifyh in relation to particular Departmental records, or a particular class or classes of Departmental records prescribed in accordance with .S'ubsecticm (I I), which are more than 30 years old and are speci?ed in the certi?cate? that to make them available for inspection by the publicise? (ti) would be contrary to the public interest? or would or might constitute a breach of statutory duty, or a 'breach of good faith on the ground that they contain information supplied in con?dence, or would or might cause distress or danger to living persons on the ground that they contain ii?i?t?ormation about individuals, or would or might be likely to lead to an action for damages for defamation. Annmarie Cowley From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 06 April 2018 133:07 To: Annmarie Cowiey Subject: FW: Kerry Babies transcripts From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 09 February 201812219 To: Claim Daly Cc: Oonagh B. McPhiHips Peter X. Mullen Niall A ('Joigan Gerard P. Madden PressOfficeSts-tt Sarah M. Kavenagh Conor A. Cieary Lise X. Howard SecGenOt?ce Subject: RE: Kerry Babies transcripts Cairn, Pieese see our proposed reply below to the other Kerry Babies press query {from Maeve Sheenan). Regards Ben ?As the Department ofiustice 63? Equality has revio 51 stated, and following further discussions with her representative, we consider the privacy of be paramount in any consideration relating to the release of these transcripts. Following the announcement of the SCRT review into the death of "Baby John? in 1984, An Garcia Si?ochana has requested that the Department retain the transcripts in full, as they may need to refer to details in the transcripts as part of their ongoing investigations. The Department will continue to engage with the National Archives to ensure ?Quest fo privacy can be respected, and that/fin Garda Siochana can be facilitated with access to the transcripts to assist them in their enquiries. Section 8(4) of the National Archives Act 1985 allows the Department to refuse access tofiles in circumstances Where the release of the files would or might cause distress to iiving persons. it is quite evidenrfrorn conversations Wihjresentatives that the release of the transcripts would cause her considerable distress. in all the circumstances, the Department is not in a position, at this time, to grant you the access to the files you have requested. We would also point out that this Tribunal was widely reported on in books and newspapers of the time, and in the years that followed, which would potentially contain much of detail you are see/ring.? From: Colm Daly Sent: 08 February 2018 18:16 To: Ben P. Ryan Subject: RE: kerry babies transcripts Cheers ben From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 08 February 2018 18:14 To: Colm Daly ; Niall A Colgan Subject: Re: kerry babies transcripts Colm, lill have a reply for you in the morning on it. There were developments today. Regards Ben From: Colm Daly Date: 8 February 2018 at 18:12:30 GMT To: Niall A Colgan Cc: Ben P. Ryan Subject: FW: kerry babies transcripts Hi Niali, just a gentle nudge on this one when you get a chance From: Colm Daly Sent: 07 February 2018 12:00 To: Ben P. Ryan Cc: Niall A Colgan Peter X. Mullan ; PressOtficeStatf Subject: kerry babies HI Ben, another query on the Kerry babies case, whenever you get a chance to consider Just checking in with you to ask if the Department of Justice taken a decision on whether it is going to release the transcripts of the tribunal of inquiry on the Kerry Babies case to the National Archives? Many thanks Maeve Sheehan Sunday independent 087 61?1325 R?ga Colm Daly Press Of?ce Dept of Justice 51 St Stephens Green Dublin 2 01 6028358 Annmarie Cowley From: Sent: To: Subject: From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 09 February 2018 08:54 BEi?i P. Ryan 06 April 2018 13:04- Annmarie Cowley FW: Retaining files over 30 years old To: Rosemary X. King Aisling M. Brennan Cc: Niall A iIolgan Gerard P. Madden <8 PMadden@iustiee.ie> Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Hi Rosemary and Aisling, I sent those papers over to D/?i?aoiseach yesterday afternoon with the correct date or: them. i have a press query asking whether the Department has made a decision on whether or not to reiease the to the Archives. Given that i am waiting for a response from D/Taoiseach in reiatiori to the use of Section is it appropriate at this stage to say that we have made a decision. or is it more accurately described as a recommendation to D/Taoiseach? Thanks Ben Ben Ryan Crime Division Department otiustice Equality 94 St. Stephen?s Green D02 FD70 608710 External: +353 (1) 5028710 From: Rosemary X. King Sent: 08 February 2018 13:17 To: Ben P. Ryan Cc: Aisling Ni. Brennan Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Ben, Thank you for your email. 1 think there was a mistake in today?s date. .2017 was put down instead of 2018. Can this be changed and the review date? Otherwise it might look like you are trying to backdate it. I see in Aisling?s email that she recommended Section 8 4 if you intend to go with this you will need to make that adjustment. The example i had sent was for Section 8 4 Kind regards, Rosemary Rosemary King Archivist Department oflustice 8: Equality 51 St. Stephen?s Green, Dublin 2 From: Ben P. Ryan Date: 8 February 2018 at 12:32:05 GMT To: Aisling M. Brennan Cc: Niall A Colgan Annmarie Cowley Richard Healy Rosemary X. King Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Aisling, As discussed, please find attached cover letter and certificate which lam sending over to D/Taoiseach now. Regarcis Ben Ben Ryan Crime Division Department ofJustice 8: Equality 94"St. Stephen?s Green D02 F070 608710 External: +353 (1) 5028710 From: Aisling M. Brennan Sent: 08 February 2018 09:41 To: Ben P. Ryan Niall A Colgan Subject: FW: Retaining files over 30 years old Ben, Niall, The attached certificate must be completed by your Division and signed off by Ben. it seems that the roost applicable section is Please note that you cannot use multiple sections on the certificate, only one. Please forward a copy of the certificate to as when you are sending it to D/Taoiseach. Regards, Aisling. From: Rosemary X. King Sent: 08 February 2018 09:36 To: Aisling M. Brennan Subject: Retaining files over 30 years old Aisling, Please ?nd attached template for retaining a file under section 8 (4) would or might cause distress or danger to living persons if necessary this can be changed to any ofthe following section 8(2) allows for retention of records in regular use in a Department of State section 8(4) allows for the withholding of records from public inspection if release ofthe records would involve a breach of statutory duty would be contrary to the public interest would or might cause distress or danger to living persons The following needs to be filled in a description of file after 'Records referred to above:' a The name and signature of Certifying Officer 9 the name of the Division 9 the date and review date (five years from the date). A copy should then be sent to Mary Keenan, Consenting Officer, Department of the Taoiseach. if approved it will be signed and returned to the Certifying Officer. The fileis) will need to be reviewed again in five years. Kind regards, Rosemary Rosemary King I Archivist Department of Justio Equality, 51 St Stephen's Green, Dublin 2, DOZHK52 t: +353?l?6028264?l rxking@justice.ie i Annmarie Cowley c, From: Ben P. Ryan .Sent: 06 April 2018 13:03 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: Retaining files over 30 years old Attachments: scanned-20180208144643.pdi? scanned-20180208144622.pdi From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 08 i??ebruary 2018 14:56 To: Rosemary X. King Cc: Aisling M. Brennan Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Rosemary, Apoiogies re the date i have amended the hard copies (attached) and will send them over to D/Taoiseaeh new. (i still haven?t got used to putting in 2018 yet!) i think is the more appropriate section in this instance. Regards Ben From: Rosemary X. King Sent: 08 February 2018 13:17 To: Ben P. Ryan an iustice.ie> Cc: Aisling M. Brennan Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Ben, Thank you for your email. i think there was a mistake in today?s date. 2017 was put down instead of 2018. Can this be changed and the review date? Otherwise it might look like you are trying to backdate it. I see in Aisling?s email that she recommended Section 8 4 if you intend to go with this you will need to make that adjustment. The example I had sent was for Section 8 4 Kind regards, Rosemary Rosemary King Archivist Department ofJustice Equality 51 St. Stephen?s Green, Dublin 2 From: Ben P. Ryan Date: 8 February 2018 at 12:32:05 GMT To: Aisling M. Brennan Cc: Niall A Colgan Annmarie Cowley Richard Healy Rosemary X. King Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Aisiing, As discussed, please find attached cover letter and certificate which i am sending ever to D/Taoiseach HOW. Regards Ben Ben Ryan Crime Division Department ofJustice 8c Equality 94, St. Stephen?s Green D02 F070 VOIP: 608710 External: +353 (1) 6028710 From: Aisling M. Brennan Sent: 08 February 2018 09:4Ii To: Ben P. Ryan Niall A Colgan Subject: FW: Retaining files over 30 years old Sen, Niall, The attached certificate must be completed by your Division and signed oft by Ben. it seems t3": at the most applicable section is Please note that you cannot use multiple sections on the certificate, only one. Please forward a copy ofthe certificate to us when you are sending it to D/Taoiseach. Regards, Aisling. From: Rosemary X. King Sent: 08 February 2018 09:36 To: Aisling M. Brennan Subject: Retaining files over 30 years old Aisling, Please find attached template for retaining a file under section 8 (4) would or might cause distress or danger to living persons if necessary this can be changed to any of the following section 8(2) allows for retention of records in regular use in a Department of State section 8(4) allows for the withholding of records from public inspection if release of the records would involve a breach of statutory duty would be contrary to the public interest would or might cause distress or danger to living persons The following needs to be ?lled in a description of file after ?Records referred to above:' a The name and signature of Certifying Of?cer 9 the name ofthe Division the date and review date (five years from the date). A copy should then be sent to Mary Keenan: Consenting Officer, Department ofthe Taoiseach. if approved it will be signed and returned to the Certifying Of?cer. The fileie) will need to be reviewed again in ?ve years. Kind regards, Rosemary Rosemary King I Archivist 5 Department of Justic Equality; 51 St Stephen's Green, Dublin 2, t: +353?1?6028264? rxkinq@justice.ie 13F 3:222 ;?2Ci? 3:22.22 94 St. Stephen?s Green Dublin 2 Facsuin?iir?ax: {01) 661 5461 .2222 notes 222.2 agile c322 212.2 94? Faiche Stiobhnn Bails Arise Clint}: 2 602 8262 Riomhphoist/e?maii: info@justice.ie Mary Consenting Officer, Department of the Taoiseach, Government Built?iings? Dublin 2. National Archives Act, 1988, Regulations, 2938 RETENTIQN WITHHOLDING FROM PUBLIC 02?2?" RECORDS 22?29 SECTIQN 8(4) Files relating to ?Ken? Babies5 Dear Ms. Keenan, i am writing to you in the context of the above issue. The ?les in question relate to the Kerry Babies issue and the attached certificate sets out the View of the Department of Justice and Equality that to release the papers concerned at this time would cause distress to This View is based ?on comments made bWugh her representatives that her primary concern is to maintain her privacy and the ter or Justice and Equality has indicated publicly that he intends to respect this request to the maximum extent possible. i enclose the following documents: 2 Certificate 2 Spreadsheet of records listing the files containing the Tribunal trans-ciipts Spreadsheet of records listing other Ken'y Babies files 22 The Department of Justice and Equality?s response to recent media requests to release the papers 22 Correspondence with the Serious Crime Review Team in An Garda Siochana outlining their request to have access to the files to assist their ongoing investigation. Itmst that 1:116: eac?asad is in 0rd ?grfiiter information. sincerely :3 ?m?ya? {kittii??ug ?f??er Principai Cm?; @2213 Ewgsion- 53!; T: 6028710 6: bpryan@justice.ie am. but 3. bu?e?: 13138.?rm-?14 is contact me Law. 0111:": you Z??qeiil?? any l3 3?23 Ci ,3 Ema! 22,22; 2222222422,! mi 22322:, 22222:" 2,522.2; cemeiommnma 5.7 Faiche 52 St. Stephenis Green Bari/9 Athd Ciiath 2 Dublin ,2 Tel/eafdn: (01) 502 8202 Telephone; {02) 602 8202 Rfomhphoisi': info justice. is Email: {6 National Archives Act, 1986, Regulations, 1988 RETENTION OR WITHHOLDING FROM PUBLIC INSPECTION OF DEPARTMENTAL RECORDS PURSUANT TO SECTION 8(4) Form for use by Certifying Officers CERTIFICATE I hereby certify, pursuant to section 8(4) of the National Archives Act, 1986, that to make the record described below in the attached schedule available for public inspection would or miqht cause distress or dander to living persons Records referred to above: I Sieitifying Officer Department of Justice and Equality ?ivieicr; Date: 1,223 2 Review date: CONSENT consent to the making of this certificate. Consenting Officer, Department of the Date: Review date: Annmarie Cowley From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 06 April 2018 13:03 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: Retaining files over 30 years old Attachments: scanned?20180208095704pdf; Kerry Babies - archive letterdoc From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 08 February 20181.2:32 To: Aisling M. Brennan Cc: Niall A Colgan Annmarie Cowley Richard Healy Rosemary X. King Subject: RE: Retaining files over 30 years old Aisling, As discussed, please find attached cover letter and certificate which i am sending over to D/Taoiseach new. Regards Ben Ben Ryan Crime Division Department ofJustice 8: Equality 94 St. Stephen?s Green 002 F070 608710 External: +353 6028710 From: Aisling M. Brennan Sent: 08 February 2018 09:41 To: Ben P. Ryan ; Niall A Colgan Subject: FW: Retaining files over 30 years old Ben, Niall, The attached certificate must be completed by your Division and signed off by Ben. it seems that the most applicable section is Please note that you cannot use multiple sections on the certificate, only one. Please forward a copy of the certi?cate to us when you are sending it to D/Taoiseacb. Regards, Aisling. From: Rosemary K. King Sent: 08 February 2018 09:36 To: Aisling M. Brennan Cc: Ben P. Ryan Gerard P. Madden Peter X. Mullen Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: Kerry Babies Case Tribunal Transcripts Hi Aisling, I believe Ben has been speaking to you about this previously. i would refer you to the emails below from Gerard Madden in Crime Division and the response from? in AGS. - .. You will see in Ger?s email he states: ?As instructed, the copies of the Tribunal transcripts will not be sent to the National Archives until we have your permission to do so. They will remain in Crime Division where they will be available to you and your team at any time.? re-spancls also note the current position in Ielation to the retention of the Tribunal tI anscripts and thank yea for acceding to my meanest.? In light of those conversations, and following requests from a journalist to grant her access to the Transcripts, we are seeking to rely on Section 8(2) of the National Archives Act 1986 in refusing access to the transcripts. We will also be seeking to rely on Section 8(4llcl of- the Act in that the release of these documents would or might cause distress to a living person, nam A number of discussions have been had WiLh ntative who has stated in no uncertain terms that the release of the transcripts, or any reopening of the Tribunal In public, would cause her great distress We note in relation to section 8(4) that there is a quuirement that the withholding of docs under that section signed off by a Departmental officer and by an authorised officer In the Department of Taciseach Do yOu approach Taoiseach?s directly In relation to getting sign off as required or do you have details of who we should be in contact with? . Thanks for yoUr help with this, if you need any further information just let me know. Kind Regards, Niall Colgan Crime Division Dept. of Justice and Equality 94 St. Stephens Green Dublin 2 Email: nacolganQiusticeJe 'Ph Dept: +353 1 602 .8715 Ph Mobile- From: Gillian X. Gilleran Sent: 07 February 2018 15:58 To: Ben P. Ryan Niall A Colgan an .'ustice.ie> Subject: FW: Kerry Babies Case - Tribunal Material. Gillian Gilleran Crime Division Department efju'stice and Equality 94 St; Stephen's Green, Dublin 2, D02 FD 70, Ireland. 1P 60871.4 mm: - Using the 6 digit number saves money. 6534-6028714 - - From:. V, Sent: 13 January 2018 16:34 To: Gerard P. Madden Ben P. Ryan Gillian X. Gilleran Subject: RE: Kerry Babies Case Tribunal Material. Mr. Gerard Madden Crime Division Department of Justice 8: Equality 94 St. Stephen?s Green Dublin 2 Gerard, Re: Kerry Babies Case Tribunal Material Thank you for your email (attached) and associated word attachments in relation to the Kerry Babies Tribunal. i note the centents of your email and acknowledge the two (2) PDFs detailing the files i took posseSSion of from the Department on the 16?h January 2018: - any changes to these word documents will be notified in due course. I also note the current position in relation to the retention of the Tribunal transcripts and thank you for acceding to my request. have noted thatltook possession of these? - . - .M. ., from Mr. Ben Ryan, Principal Officer, at approximately 5.30pm on the 16*? January 2018 and these?mhave been retained in the possession of An Garcia Siocha?na while preliminary enquiries are being carried out in respect of their relevance to the current review of the Kerry Babies case, being undertaken by G?ardai within the Kerry Division in conjunction with the Serious Crime Review Team, Garcia National Bureau of Criminal investigation. For your recercls was assigned in my work at the Department on the 16th January 2018 by my colleagues." be are both also? attached to. the Serious Crime Review Team. if i can be of any further assistance to you in this matter, please do not hesitate to Contact me. Yours Sincerely, . .Bein?LlS Crime Review Team, 1211 ll?'?Sl?ig?tiOu. Serious Crime Operations, 2 1111;0qu Square, Dublin 2 I DUES PINK). Sent: 16 January 2018 18. ?47 Cc: Ben P. Ryan Gille?ran Subject: Kerry Babies Case - Tribunal Material. and As requested, pleaSe find Word attachments listing the contents of the archive boxes held in Crime Division in relation to the Kerry Babies Tribunal. if you need to make changes to these documents, we?d appreciate if you could please track the cha nge's/add comments etc, so we can compare to our originals docs if required. The PDFs are scans of what you and. your team. were working on this evening. They detail the ?les that you took away and are now no longer in the possession of the Department. As instructed, the copies of the Tribunal transcripts will not be sent to the National Archives until we have your permission to do so. They will remain in Crime Division where they will be available to you and yoor team at any time. If we can be of any further assistance 'to you, please do not hesitate to contact us. Our details are as follow: Ben Ryan, (PO) - Tel: 602 8710. Ger Madden, (HEO) "Tel: 6028717. Gillian Gilleran, (HEO) -Te_l: 502 8714. Kind regards Gerard Madden I Crime Division Department of?Jus'tice 8: Equality, 94 St Stephen's Green, Dublin 2 (DOZFD7D) IRELANDJ (IP 608717 Think lP - using the 6 digit IP?Phan?e number satires mane .) 9353416028717 ggm-addenQiusticeJe a, If - 1. 415mm? Is he haghaidh an duine 116 an ointitis er a b'hfuil sf di'rithe, ages 16 haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis sin amhai'n, a bhea?aite'ar an fhaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh 36 go bhfuil abhar faoi r?-n agus/n? faoi phribhl?id inti. Toitfr?nisctear aon atarchur n6 leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfazisn?is seo, aOn ?s?iid eile a bhaint aisti n6 aon ghniomh a dh?anamh at a hiontaoibh, ag daoine n6 ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir be.a1taithe.Ma fuair tit 6 seo tri dhearmad, t?igh. 1 dteagmh?il leis" an seolt?ir, 16 do tho?, agus series an t-?bhar as aon riomhaire. Is' 6 beertas na Roi?nne D11 agus Cirt ages Comhionannais, na nOi?'gi 3 agus na nGniomhaire-achtai a ?saideann s-ei'rbhi-si TF na Rcinne seoladh abhair chol?il a dhicheadu. Mas rud go measann to gut abhar col?il at? san abhar ata sa teachtaireaoht sec is ceart duit dul i dteagmhail leis an seoltdir laithreach agus le chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of the Departn?ien-t of Justice and Equality and the Agencies and Of?ces using its IT services to disallow the sending of offensive material. Should you consider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also Faisn?don eintiteas sin a bh?lil a sheoladh uirthi, agus do siud amhain, agus d'fh?adfadh abhar rt?lnda agus/ no abhar faoi phribhl?id a bheith iniata. Toirmisctear aon atarchur no leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is sec, aon ?said eile a bhaint aisti no acn ghniornh a dh?anamh at a hiontaoibh, ag daoine no ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beartaithe. Mas tri bhott?in a hair t? sec, coir sc?ala ch'uig an secltoir le do thoil agu's, series an t?abhar d'aon riomhaire. Is 6 poiasai An Gharda Sicchana seoladh abhair. choluil a dhichead?, agus mas doigh Ieat gur abhar col?il ata sa teachtaireacht sec ba cheart duit dul i dteagmh?il leis an Seoltoir agus 1e. laithreach. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissen?nation or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of An Garcia Siochana to disallow the sending of offensive material and should you censider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact both the sender and postmaster@garda.ie immediately. Annmarie Cowley From: . Annmarie Cowley Sent: 26 January 2018?15:50 To: 'Helen Hewson? Subject: RE: Kerry Baby Tribunal transcripts Helen You might give me a call in relation to this. Many Thanks Annmarie Annmarie Cowley Crime Division Crime Security Directorate Department of Justice Equality I 94 St. Stephen's Green, D02 FD70, Dublin 2, Ireland Internal VOIP 60 8349 - TbinkIP - using the 6 digit IPnumbct saves money +353-1-602-8349 IE axcowley@justice.ie From: Helen Hewson Sent: 19 January 2018 16:47 To: Annmarie Cowley Cc: Mary Mackey Killian Downing Subject: Kerry Baby Tribunal transcripts Ms Annmarie Cowley crime Division Dear Annmarie, My colleague Mary Mackey is on leave at present. However, she has told me that you had phoned her to say that the Department is going to hold on to the Kerry Baby Tribunal transcripts (that you had originally intended to transfer to the National Archives for release to the public, under the accession number 2016/10). There is no problem with this, however I would advise that the proper paperwork should be completed in order for the Department to fulfil its obligations under the National Archives Act. Records that are over 30-years old that are worthy of permanent preservation (in this case, the transcripts), must either be: Transferred to the National Archives and released to the public under Section 8(1) of the National Archives Act, using the appropriate certi?cate signed by the Departmental Certifying Officer 0r 0 Kept within the creating department and withheld from public inspection closed) under a certi?cate signed by a Departmental Certifying Of?cer and the Consenting Officer in the Department of the Taoiseach (citing one or more reasons under Section 8(4) of the National Archives Act for doing so) Or 0 Retained in the creating department under a certificate to retain the records under Section 8(2) of the National Archives Act. This certificate must be signed by the Departmental Certifying Of?cer but does not require the countersignature of the Consenting Officer. This is because although the department is retainihg the records, the public theoretically still has a right to access the records in the department they are not being withheld or closed) NA Act, section 8(4) allows for the withholding of records from public inspection if release of the records 0 would involve a breach of statutory duty 0 would be contrary to the public interest 0 would or might cause distress or danger to living persons NA Act, section 8(2) allows for retention of 30-year old records which despite their age: 0 are still in regular use in a Department of State or 0 such records if transferred, would seriously interfere with the administration ofthe Department. I would therefore recommend that the Department completes the certificates (and associated schedules of records) as appropriate. If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me. lam attaching some notes and a template Certi?cate to retain records under Section 8(2) of the National Archives Act. Best wishes, Helen Hewson Helen He wson Keeper Archives Government Services National Archives Bishop Street, Dublin 8 008 DF85 Email: hhewson@nationalarchives.ie Tel: +353 (0)1 4072 318 u? an t?eolas sa riomhphost seo faoi rL?m, chomh maith le gach comhad eta ceangailte leis, agus i gcomhair Usaid an duine no an chorais a bhfuil s? dirithe air amh?in. Ma fhaigheann to an riomhphost seo tra? bhot?n, cuir sc?al chugainn ag info@nationalarchives.ie The information in this email, and any attachments transmitted with it, are confidential and are meant for the intended recipient only. if you receive this message in error, please notify us via info@nationalarchives.ie Annmarie Cowle From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 06 April 2018 12:51 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case From: Sarah M. Kavanagh Sent: 20 January 2018 13:35 To: Ben P. Ryan Peter X. Mullan Oonagh B. McPhillips Andrew Payne Cc: PressOfficeStaff Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Yes, that's fine with me. Thanks much all. ~1?s . I - .. From: Andrew Payne Date: 20 January 2018 at 13:23:13 GMT To: Peter X. Mullan Ben P. Ryan Oonagh B. McPhillips Cc: PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Thanks all, Sarah - are you ok with this? Andrew in at '1 uni?'2 In 4131? . wavy-MW? ww-?w- urn-h u-A rr?uru? -- 'w?WI'I?r?n I1 From: Peter X. Mullan Date: 20 January 2018 at 13:12:50 GMT To: Oonagh B. McPhillips Ben P. Ryan an 'ustice.ie> Cc: PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case l?m good with this. nun?In 1" - 'v *Hm'm'w nT- From: Oonagh B. McPhillips Date: 20 January 2018 at 13:10:30 GMT To: Ben P. Ryan Peter X. Mullan Cc: PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Let say the following. The Dept is mindful of the rights of access of the public, academics and the media to this source material (which was held in public and widely reported at the time) but has to be equally mindful of the need to deal sensitively with the issue bearing in mind the National Archives Act provides for withholding material if its release would cause distress to any living person an-egal representative has repeatedly asked for her privacy to be respected. The Dept will consult further with relevant parties including colleagues in the National Archives office before arriving at any final decision in relation to the material. From: Peter X. Mullan Date: 20 January 2018 at 13:54:16 To: Ben P. Ryan Oonagh B. McPhillips Cc: PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case All ?has relied that any decision that respect her privacy at this stage would be greatly appreciated Can" we reflect that in a statement How about mindful that drafting is not my' forte ?The Department accepts that the Press has tights of access as provided bylaw to all documents held by Government Departments however in this case the De artment has been asked by her legal representative at this time to respect the privacy obhich it intends to do. The issue of lawful access can be revisited later at a suitable'time and in the hope that this issue will be dealt with sensitively by all involved. Peter ., - 1.. I . ., From: Oonagh B. McPhillips Date: 20 January 2018 at 12:14:33 GMT To: Peter X. Mullan Ben P. Ryan an 'ustice.ie> Cc: Sarah M. Kavanagh , PressOfficeStaff Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case I?d be a bit reluctant to put him under time pressure on a sensitive issue like this just to cover us. lf_he" doesn?t come back let?s quote from the Archives Act as per Ben?s mail earlier and say we intend to consult with- through her rep and the National Archives before coming to a final decision in the matter. From: Peter X. Mullan Date: 20 January 2018 at 12:56:37 To: Niall A Colgan Oonagh B. McPhillips Ben P. Ryan Andrew Payne Colm Daly Gerard P. Madden PressOf?ceStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case - mm? [1 From: Oonagh B. McPhillips Date: 20 January 2018 at 11:43:42 GMT To: Gerard P. Madden Ben P. Ryan PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Niall A Colgan Peter X. Mullan Colm Daly 'ustice.ie>, Andrew Payne Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Folks I fully agree with the approach to consider this through the lens equest for privacy - I understand the concern about the perception but in this instance we need to continue to do the right thing even if it's misrepresented. If it?s possible to reach her solr as Sarah?s suggests that'd be helpful but that be along the lines of we propose not to release - even if that?s not possible we should hold the line. This is a tricky issue and not best suited to resolution over email at speed in response to a press query. lt be borne in mind there is in any event sufficient material in books and newspapers of the time. Thanks Oonagh ?it-hm u? From: Sarah M. Kavanagh Date: 20 January 2018 at 12:28:14 To: Peter X. Mullan Andrew Payne Niall A Colgan PressOf?ceStaff Oonagh B. McPhillips Colm Daly Gerard P. Madden Ben P. Ryan an 'ustice.ie> Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Hi Ben, I agree absolutely with you re the number one priority beingmhe difficulty is that this is highly likely to be misrepresented in media as the state seeking to protect itself and therefore may at be sustainable. So as a precaution I thought the option of consulting with gal adviser explaining our approach seeking a view would be I am assuming her lawyer will endorse the ?approach as it is consistent with previous statements regarding privacy. Best wishes, Sarah From: Ben P. Ryan an 'ustice.ie> Date: 20 January 2018 at 09:52:11 GMT To: Niall A Colgan Sarah M. Kavanagh PressOfficeStaff Oonagh B. McPhillips Peter X. Mullan Colm Daly Andrew Payne Gerard P. Madden Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Sarah, That is one possibility. I still think our duty to respect the expressed wish for privacy froMutweighs the need to keep a journalist happy. I think the first paragraph of the following article is relevant in this regard. Ive-gerry-o?carroll-owew The State was highly insensitive needs this process and I think it's not too late to start doing the right thing now. We are going to have further discussions with the National Archives on Monday. There are two parts of section 8 of the relevant Act (National Archives Act 1986) which come into play here. Section 8(2) relates to files which can be retained in the Department as they are required in connection with our administration and transferring them would seriously interfere with our work. This is accurate in relation to the current situation - the SCRT in AGS has asked us to keep the files for now so that they have easy access to them for their ongoing investigation. This approach would allow us to grant access to journalists but if we go down this route, I recommend that it should take place after we have identified the parts of the ?les th-would prefer us not to release. Which leads into section 8(4) - this section allows us to refuse access to files where doing so would cause distress to living persons. To use this section, we would need the relevant official in D/Taoisea ch to counter sign the decision. We will discuss the appropriateness of these two sections with the National Archives on Monday and provide more details at that stage. Regards Ben From: Sarah M. Kavanagh Date: 20 January 2018 at 00:41:20 GMT To: Niall A Colgan Gerard P. Madden Andrew Payne Peter X. Mullan PressOf?ceStaff Ben P. Ryan Colm Daly 'ustice.ie> Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Peter, Ben, Apologies for late reply. Perhaps best solution might be to release what is being sought subject to consultation w.egal representative in the context of her request for privacy? . .. kind regards, Sarah 43?" g. - From: Ben P. Ryan Date: 19 January 2018 at 22:59:28 GMT To: PressOf?ceStaff Niall A Colgan Gerard P. Madden Sarah M. Kavanagh Peter X. Mullan Colm Daly Andrew Payne ne 'ustice.ie> Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Peter, I drafted this before Colm sent on the media request, which set out the parts of the transcripts she is looking for, which are all the parts directly-relatin ?anscripts, so that draft was overtaken by events. We are entitled to refuse release to the National Archives where it would cause distress to any living person. Regards Ben lgq? va?. From: Peter X. Mullan Date: 19 January 2018 at 22:06:09 GMT To: Andrew Payne Colm Daly Gerard P. Madden Niall A Colgan PressOf?ceStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Ben P. Ryan Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Andrew This was an earlier version suggested by Ben. I was happy with. I think we should go with it. Can you run by Sarah please? Perhaps not changed earlier for a reason. Peter Draft We cannot facilitate unlimited access to the transcripts at present for logistical reasons, but we are happy to provide access to any specific parts of it that she is interestedin if she can identify what parts she wants access to. However, this has to be viewed through the lens 0 . quest for privacy and we will not release any parts of it at present which would compromise her reqUes?t for privacy. xii-uh- I?m? an . ?r in From: Andrew Payne ne 'ustice.ie> Date: 19 January 2018 at 20:51:04 GMT To: Colm Daly Subject: Fw: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case All, Please see below. Kind regards, Andrew Andrew Payne Press Of?cer Press Communications Of?ce Department of Justice and Equality 51 St Stephen's Green Dublin 2 I D02 HK52 axpame@justice.iel (+353) (1) 6028328; Fomarded by Andrew on 19/01/2018 20:50 From: maeve sheehan To: Andrew Payne 'ustice.ie>, Date: 19101.!2018 20:49 Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Thanks Andrew but seriously, the Department is withholding the release of the transcripts? These are records of a public tribunal that should have been released into the National Archive in 2015 and which the National Archive is expecting in the coming weeks. So can I take it that the Department is going to refuse to release the transcripts to the National Archive too? On 19 January 2018 at 20:40, Andrew Payne wrote: Maeve, The Department is very conscious I I est for privacy. In this context we believe it would not be approprlate to provide release of the information requested at this time. Kind regards, Andrew Andrew Payne Press Of?cer Press Communications Of?ce Department of Justice and Equality 51 St Stephen's Green Dublin 2 D02 HK52 (1) 6028328' From: maeve sheehan [mailtozmaevesh?lmailcom] Sent: 19 January a. . To: Colm Daly Cathal X. Redmond CXRedmond@iustice.ie> Subject: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Hi Colm, Thanks for your help for taking up my query, which Cathal was looking into yesterday. I'm hoping to get access to the transcripts of the Tribunal chaired by Judge Kevin on the Kerry Babies case. I'm told that the transcripts are with the Department of Justice and due shortly to be released to the National Archive. I don't need to access the whole document - just some transcripts from the days in wMas cross-examined. Is it possible to scan or photograph decuments? Many thanks Maeve Sheehan Sunday Independent 087 6171325 Is 1e haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis ar a bhfuil si dirithe, agus 1e haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an ?iaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh s? go bhfuil abhar faoi run agus/no faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarchur no leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, aon usaid eile a bhaint aisti no aon ghniomh a dh?anamh ar a hiontaoibh, ag daoine no ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beartaithe. Ma fuair hi 6 seo tri dhearmad, t?igh i dteagmh?il leis an seoltoir, 1e do thoil, agus scrios an t-abhar as aon riomhaire. Is 6 beartas na Roinne agus Cirt agus Comhionannais, na nOi?gi agus na nGniomhaireachtai a usaideann seirbhisi TF na Roinne seoladh abhair choluil a dhichead?. Mas rud go measann tu gur abhar col?il ata san abhar ata sa teachtaireacht seo is ceart duit dul i dteagmhail leis an seoltoir laithreaeh agus le mailminder[ag justice.ie chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of the Department of Justice and Equality and the Agencies and Of?ces using its IT services to disallow the sending of offensive material Should you consider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also Annmarie Cowley From: Ben P. Ryan Sent: 06 April 2018 12:51 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: FW: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case From: Oonagh B. McPhiIIips Sent: 20 January 2018 14:43 To: Peter X. Mullan PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Andrew Payne Ben P. Ryan Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case It?s fine but just add to the end it intends to do when making a decision in the matter. A final decision has not yet been takenFrom: Andrew Payne Date: 20 January 2018 at 15:38:12 To: Sarah M. Kavanagh Peter X. Mullan , PressOfficeStaff Ben P. Ryan Oonagh B. McPhilIips Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Thanks Peter, That looks good to me. Sarah/Oonagh - any ova? .7 unu- ?urn-lav . - ?mm. ?a n-wu- . wme a mum. ?mew-.4. m. .L ., From: Ben P. Ryan Date: 20 January 2018 at 14:33:56 GMT To: Oonagh B. McPhillips Peter X. Mullan Andrew Payne PressOfficeStaff Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Peter, That looks fine to me. Regards Ben I .. .. - From: Peter X. Mullen Date: 20 January 2018 at 14:31:25 GMT To: Andrew Payne PressOfficeStaff Ben P. Ryan Oonagh B. McPhillips Sarah M. Kavanagh Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case How about. The Department has been in contact wi? gal representative in relation to the release of the transcripts and has been asked at this time to respect the privacy -vhich it intends to do. From: Andrew Payne Date: 20 January 2018 at 14:24:54 GMT To: P'ressOfficeStaff Peter X. Mullan Ben P. Ryan Ognagh B. McPhiilips Sarah M. Kavanagh <5MKavanaghQiusticeJe> Subject: Fwd: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case All, More from Maeve Sheehan. A From: maeve sheehan Date: 20 January 2018 at 14:14:08 GMT To: Andrew Payne Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kerry Babies case Thanks for getting back to me, Andrew. This is a. highly unusual decision. My understanding is that the Department has not been asked to withhold the transcripts by any of the parties. May I ask whether the Minister has requested that they be withheld? On .20 January 2018 at 14:03, Andrew Payne wrote: Maeve, The Department is mindful of the rights of access of the public, academics and the media to this source material (which was held in public and widely reported at the time) but has to be equally mindful ofthe need to deal sensitively with the issue bearing in mind the National Archives Act 2 provides for withholdi 'f its release would cause distress to any living person a al representative has repeatedly asked 5 for her privacy to be respected. The Department will consult further with relevant parties including colleagues? In the National Archives of?ce before arriving at any final decision in relation to the material. Kind regards, Andrew I Andrew Payne Press Officer Press Communications Office Department - ofJustice and Equality 51 St Stephen's Green Dublin 2 D02 HK52 *axpayne@iustice.ie I (+353) (1) 6028328 From: maeve sheehan To: AndrewX Payne 7 Date: 19/01/2018 20: 49 Subject: Re: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of inquiry on Kerry Babies case Thanks Andrew but seriously, the Department is withholding the release of the transcripts? These are records of a public tribunal that should have been released into the National Archive in 2015 and which the National Archive is expecting in the coming weeks. So can i take it that the Department is going to refuse to release the transcripts to the National 1 Archive too? On 19 January 2018 at 20:40, Andrew Payne wrote: Maeve, The Department is very conscious uest for privacy. In this context we believe it would not be appropriate to provide release of the information requested at this time. Kind regards, Andrew Andrew Payne Press Officer Press 8: Communications Of?ce I Department ofJustice and Equality 51 St Stephen's Green Dublin 2 D02 HK52 I axpavne@iustice.ie (+353) 6028328; From: maeve sheehan [mailtozmaevesh@gmail.com] Sent: 19 January 2018 15:52 To: Colm Daly Cathal X. Redmond CXRedmond@iustice.ie> Subject: press query: transcripts of Tribunal of inquiry on Kerry Babies case Hi Colm, Thanks for your help for taking up my query, which Cathal was looking into yesterday. l'm hoping to get access to the transcripts of the Tribunal chaired by Judge Kevin on the Kerry Babies case. I'm told that the transcripts are with the Department of Justice and due shortly to be released to the National Archive. I don't need to access the whole document -just some transcripts from the days in whic cross-examined. Is it possible to scan or photograph documents? Many thanks Maeve Sheehan Sundaylndependent 087 6171325 ls le haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis er a bhfuil si dirithe, agus le haghaidh an duine no an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an fhaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh s? go bhfuil ?bhar faoi run agus/no faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarchur no leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, aon L'Isaid eile a bhaint aisti no aon ghniomh a dh?anamh er a hiontaoibh, ag daoine no ag eintitis seacha's an faighteoir beartaithe. Ma fuair tu seo trl? dhearmad, t?igh i dteagmhail leis an seoltoir, le do thoil, agus series an t-abhar as aon riomhaire. ls beartas na Roinne Dli agus Cirt agus Comhionannais, na nOifI?gi agus na nGniomhaireachtai a us?ideann seirbhisi TF na Roinne seoladh abhair choluil a dhicheadL'i. Mas rud go measann tu gur abhar coluil ata? san ?bhar at? sa teachtaireacht sea is ceart duit dul i dteagmh?il leis an seolt?ir l?ithreach agus le chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of the Department ofJustice and Equality and the Agencies and Offices using its lT services to disallow the sending of 4 offensive material. Should you consider that the material Contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also mailminder [at]iustice.ie. ls le haghaidh an duine no an eintitis er a bhfuil si dirithe, agus le haghaidh an duine no an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an fhaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh s? go bhfuil a?bhar faoi rL?In agus/n6 faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarc-hur no leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, . aon usaid eile a bhaint aisti no aon ghniomh a dh?anamh er a hiontaoibh, ag daoine no ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beartaithe. fuair tL?i seo tri dhearmad, t?igh i dteagmh?il leis an seolt?ir, Ie do thoil, agus scrios an t-a?ubhar as aon riomhaire. ls beartas na Roinne Dli agus Cirt agus Comhlonannais, na nOifigi agus na nGniomhaireachtai a us?ideann seirbhisiTF na Roinne seoladh abhair cholL'iil a dhicheadli. Mas rud go measann tu gur abhar coluil at? san ?bhar ata sa teachtaireacht sea is ceart duit dul i dteagmh?il leis an seolt?ir l?ithreach agus le mailminder[ag]iusticeie chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy ofthe Department of Justice and Equality and the Agencies and Offices using its IT services to disallow the sending of offensive material. Should you consider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also mailminderlat]iustice.ie. Annmarie )5 Cowley From: Mary Mackey Sent: 16 January 2018 07:45 To: Annmarie Cowley Cc: Helen Hewson Subject: RE: 2016/10: JUS Crime transfer: Kerry Babies Tribunal Dear Annmarie We take files at any time! Kind regards, Mary Mary Mackey Senior Archivist National Archives Bishop Street Dublin 8 01 4072 361 mmackev@nationalarohives.ie From: Annmarie Cowley Sent: 15 January 2018 17:10 To: Mary Mackey Subject: RE: 2016/ 10: JUS Crime transfer: Kerry Babies Tribunal Mary Can I ask you is there a specific date for the next intake offiles Also I understand that a letter to appoint Ben Ryan as a Certifying Officer has issued. Annmarie Cowley Crime Division Crime 8.: Security Directorate I Department of Justice Equality 94 St. Stephen's Green, D02 FD70, Dublin 2, Ireland Internal VOIP 60 8349 - Thrill: IP - usrhg the 6 digit IP number saves money +353?1?602?8349 axcowleijjusticeJe From: Mary Mackey Sent: 06 December 2017 12:38 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: RE: 2016/10: JUS Crime transfer: Kerry Babies Tribunal Dear Annmarie When are you transferring these records? Thanks, Mary Mary Mackey Senior Archivist National Archives Bishop Street Dublin 8 01 4072 361 mmackey@nationalarchives.ie From: Annmarie Cowley Sent: 29 November 2017 14:36 To: Mary Mackey Subject: RE: 2016/10: .IUS Crime transfer: Kerry Babies Tribunal Thanks Mary. Will be in touch. Annmarie Cowley I Crime Division Crime 8: Security Directorate I Department of Justice 8; Equality 94 St. Stephen's Green, D02 FD70, Dublin 2, Ireland Internal VOIP 60 8349 T11in 11? - using the 6 digit IPnumbet saves money E: +353-1?602?8349 axcowley@jnstice.ie From: Mary Mackey Sent: 29 November 2017 13:41 To: Annmarie Cowley Subject: 2016/10: JUS Crime transfer: Kerry Babies Tribunal Dear Annemarie attach our Excel transfer template in which i have filled most of the columns for you. You can copy and paste the description columns into the template, but can you put the dates in the format DD as in my example in 2016/ 10/1. Your description of the documents does not include the title of the Tribunal, can you include this? The Certificate of Transfer should be to release the documents on 2 January 2018 and should be signed by a Certifying Officer. Ben Ryan is not on our list of Certifying Officers. include the text for a letter (on headed pa per) if you would like Ben Ryan to be appointed. The Certificate of Transfer should also be sent to us on headed paper. Let me know ifl can be of further assistance. Kind regards, Mary Mary Mackey Senior Archivist National Archives Bishop Street Dublin 8 01 4072 361 mmackev?nationalarchives.ie From: Annmarie Cowley [mailtozAXcowlev@iusticeie] Sent: 29 November 2017 13:18 To: Mary Mackey Subject: Mary This is a draft letter? so this has to be reviewed and signed off and a date agreed (hopefully I have used the right template). I am sending this to you for observations on the schedule which follows the letter. Let me know if you have any suggestions to the schedule on how to send over the copies. Thank you so much for your assistance with this. Annmarie Cowley I Crime Division I Crime 8: Security Directorate Department of Justice Equality 94 St. Stephen's Green, D02 FD70, Dublin 2, Ireland Internal VOIP 60 8349 - Think IP - using the 6 digit IP number saves money +353-1-602?8349 1 gcowley@justice.ie Is 1e haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis er a bhfuil si dirithe, agus le haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an ?iaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh 36 go bhfuil abhar faoi run agus/n6 faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarchur n6 leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, aon us?id eile a bhaint aisti n6 aon ghniomh a dh?anamh at a hiontaoibh, ag daoine n6 ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beaitaithe. Ma fuair 6 seo tri dhearmad, t?ighi dteagmhail leis an seolt?ir, 1e do thoil, agus scrios an t-abhar as aon riomhaire. Is 6 beartas na Roinne Dli agus Cirt agus Cornhionannais, na nOi?gi agus na nGniomhaireachtai a usaideann seirbhisi TF na Roinne seoladh abhair chol?il a dhichead?. Mas rud go measann tt?l gur abhar coluil ata san abhar ata sa teachtaireacht seo is ceart duit dul i dteagmhail leis an seolt?ir laithreach agus 1e chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/ or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of the Department of Justice and Equality and the Agencies and Of?ces using its IT services to disallow the sending of offensive material. Should you consider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also Ev! n- . um. .w-u wu- an lw-lu-I Ta an t-eolas sa riomhphost seo faoi run, chomh maith le gach comhad ata? ceangailte leis, agus i gcomhair usa?id an dulne no an Chorals a bhfuil s? dirithe air amhain. fhaigheann to an riomhphost sec tri bhotL?in, cuir sc?al chugainn ag info@nationalarchives.ie The information in this email, and any attachments transmitted with it, are confidential and are meant for the intended recipient only. if you receive this message in error, please notify us via info@nationalarchives.ie Is 1e haghaidh an duine n6 an eintitis er a bhfuil si dirithe, agus 1e haghaidh an duine no an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an ?iaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh s? go bhfuil abhar faoi run agus/n6 faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarchur n6 leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, aon usaid eile a bhaint aisti n6 aon ghniomh a dh?anamh er a hiontaoibh, ag daoine n6 ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beartaithe. Ma fuair tn seo tri dhearmad, t?igh i dteagmhail leis an seolt?ir, 1e do thoil, agus series an t??bhar as aon riomhaire. Is 6 beartas na Roinne Dli agus Cirt agus Comhionannais, na nOi?gi 3 Department of Justice and Equalitv Crime 1 Division Reference Original Original reference code type Series Title Scope and Content Date Date (year Date (year Extent Creator Code Reference only early) only late) code - 201611011 Original departmental number Crime Division 7 Jan 1985 1985 1985 1 volume Department of 201611012 Originai departmental number Crime Division I 1985 1985 1 volume Diximent of 201611013 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dis;::ment of 201611014 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disint?ment of 201611015 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Di??ment of 201611016 Original departmental number Crime Division i 1985 1985 1 volume of 201611017 Original departmental number Crime Division i 1985 1985 1 volume of 201611018 Original departmental number Crime Division 1 1985 1985 1 volume of 201611019 Original departmental number Crime Division 5 I 1985 1985 1 volume Department of 2016110110 IOriginaI departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110111 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110112 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgg:ment of 2016110113 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 201 6110114 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume_ Disggriment of 2016110115 Original departmental number Crime Division I 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110116 IOriginal departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110117 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume ?IJDuestt?ment of 2016110118 Original departmental number Crime Division 1 1985 1985 1 volume_ gigament of 2016110119 Original departmental number Crime Division 1L 1985 1985 1 volume ?Dte?rr?tament of Justice 201 611 0120 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Department of 2016110121 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dii?ment of 2016110122 Original departmental number Crime Division 1 1985 1985 1 volume Di?gment of 2016110123 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dl?leiachment of 2016110124 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1935 1 volume 31:2:ment of 2016110125 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110126 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110127 Original departmental number Crime Division . 1985 1985 1 volume Disggr?tement of 2016110128 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110129 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110130 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dii?ment of 2016110131 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dii?ment of 2016110132 Original departmental number Crime Division 1 I 1985 1985 1 volume a??ment of 2016110133 Original departmental number Crime Division 1 1985 1985 1 volume Duefacret?ment of 2016110134 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2015110135 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume" gigglement of 2016110136 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110137 Original departmentaT number Crime Division 1985! 1985 1 volume of 2016110138 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Di?::ment of 2016110139 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Sigriment of 2016110140 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Diggiment of 2016110141 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume D:?::ment of 2016110142 Original departmental numberTCrime Division 7 7? 1985 1985 1 volume alignement of 2016110143 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of Justice 201611 014-4 Justice Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Department of 2016110145 Original departmental number Crime Division? 1985 1985 1 volume bisg?memr" 2016110146 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disggr?ment of 2016110147 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume a??ment of 2016110148 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Duesgacr?ment of 2016110149 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110150 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985T 1985 1 volume Disgrriment of 2016110151 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Duespl?ment of 2016110152 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Di??ment of 2016110153 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Diigment of 2016110154 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disggriment of 2016110155 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume aggriment of 2016110156 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume giggiment of 2016110157 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dij?ment of 2016110158 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Di??ment of 2016110159 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Diggiment of - 2016110160 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110161 Original departmental number?Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110162 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgg:ment of 2016110163 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disg?ment of 2016110164 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Duesggret?ment of 2016110165 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dueitrr?tament of 2016110166 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of_ 2016110167 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgrriment of 2016110168 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Department of 2016110169 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume JDi?:ment of 2016110170 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume D?Je?rr?tament of 2016110171 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dij::ment of 2016110172 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110173 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110174 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume of 2016110175 Originat departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgg?ment of 2016110176 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgr:ment of 2016110177 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Sigriment of 2016110178 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgg:ment of 2016110179 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Disgr:ment of 2016110180 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Diigment of 2016110181 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume D?Je?frfment of 2016110182 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Dispgriment of 2016110183 Original departmental number Crime Division 1985 1985 1 volume Di?::ment of Justice TRANSFER OF DEPARTMENTAL RECORDS TO THE NATIONAL ARCHIVES RELEASE OF DEPARTMENTAL RECORDS TO PUBLIC INSPECTION Form for use by Certifying Officers and officers working under the supervision of Certifying Officers CERTIFICATE I hereby certify that the records in the attached Schedule are in order for transfer to the National Archives and may be made available for public inSpection on December 2017. Records referred to above: 2016/10/1-83: Files relating to Transcripts of the Tralee Tribunal Inquiry (Kerry Babies Case) January-June 1985. Ben Ryan Principal Of?cer Crime Division Department ofJustice and Equality Date: December, 2017 Reference Code Original Reference code Title Date 201 6/10/1 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 1 07-Jan?85 201 6/1 0/2 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 2 08-Jan-85 2016/10/3 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 3 09-Jan-85 201 6/10/4 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 4 10~Jan~85 201 6/10/5 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 5 11/01/1985 2016/10/6 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 6 14-Jan-85 2016/10/7 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 7 15?Jan?85 2016/10/8 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 8 16?Jan?85 201 6/1 0/9 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 9 17-Jan-85 201 6/1 0/1 0 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 10 18-Jan-85 201 6/10/1 1 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 11 21-Jan?85 2016/10/12 72/10/1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 12 22?Jan-85 201 6/1 0/1 3 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 13 23-Jan-85 201 6/10/14 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 14 24-Jan-85 2016/1 0/15 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 15 28?Jan?85 2016/10/1 6 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 16 29?Jan-85 201 6/1 0/17 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 1? 30-Jan-85 2016/1 0/18 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 18 31-Jan-85 201 6/1 0/1 9 72l10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 19 01-Feb-85 201 6/1 0/20 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 20 04-Feb-85 201 6/10/21 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 21 05-Feb-85 201 6/1 0/22 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 22 06-Feb-85 201 6/1 0/23 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 23 07-Feb-85 201 6/1 (3/24 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 24 08-Feb-85 2016110125 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 25 11-Feb?85 201 6/1 0/26 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 26 12-Feb-85 201 6/10/27 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 27 13-Feb-85 201 6/1 0/28 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 28 14-Feb?85 201 6/10/29 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 29 15-Feb-85 2016/10/30 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry 18?Feb-85 before Mr. Justice Book 30 2016/10/31 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 31 19-Feb?85 2016/1 0/32 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 32 20-Feb-85 2016/10/33 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 33 21?Feb-85 2016/10/34 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 34 22-Feb?85 2016/10/35 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 35 27-Feb-85 2016/1 0/36 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 36 28-Feb-85 2016/10/37 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 37 01-Mar-85 201 6/10/38 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 38 05?Mar-85 201 6/1 0/39 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 39 06-Mar-85 201 6/1 0I40 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 40 07-Mar?85 201 6/1 0/41 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 41 08-Mar-85 201 6/1 0/42 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 42 11-Mar-85 201 6/10/43 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 43 12?Mar-85 2016/10/44 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 44 13-Mar-85 2016/10/45 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 45 14-Mar-85 201 6/1 0/46 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 46 15-Mar-85 201 6/10/47 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 47 19?Mar-85 2016/1 0148 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 48 20-Mar-85 201 6/1 0/49 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 49 21-Mar-85 2016/10/50 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 50 22~Mar?85 2016/10/51 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 51 25-Mar-85 201 6/1 0/52 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 52 26?Mar-85 201 6/1 0/ 53 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 53 27-Mar?85 201 6/1 0/54 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 54 28?Mar-85 2016/10/55 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 55 29-Mar?85 201 6/1 0/ 56 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry 15-Apru85 before Mr. Justice Book 56 201 6/1 0/57 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 57 16?Apr-85 2016? 0/58 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 58 17-Apr-85 2016/10/59 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 59 18-Apr-85 201 6/10/60 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 60 19-Apr-85 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 61 22?Apr-85 201 6/1 0/62 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 62 23?Apr?85 2016l10I63 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 63 24-Apr-85 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 64 25-Apr-85 2016I10I65 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 65 26-Apr-85 201 6/10/66 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 66 29?Apr-85 201 6/1 0I67 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 67 30-Apr-85 201 6/10/68 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 68 01?May-85 2016/10/69 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 69 02-May-85 201 6/1 0/70 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 70 07-May-85 2016/10/71 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 71 08-May-85 201 6/1 0/72 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 72 09-May-85 201 6/1 0/73 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 73 10-May-85 2016/10/74 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 74 13-May-85 2016/10/75 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 75 14?May?85 201 6/10/76 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 76 15-May-85 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 77 20~Mayv85 201 6/1 0/78 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 78 10-Jun-85 201 6/1 0/79 72/ 10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 79 11-Jun-85 2016/10/80 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 80 12?Jun?85 2016/10/81 72/ 10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry 13?Jun-85 before Mr. Justice Book 81 2016/10/82 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the 14?Jun-85 Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 82 2016/10/83 72/10/182 Tribunal of Inquiry, Transcript of 28-Dec-84 Proceedings Held before Mr. Justice in the High Court, Dublin 2.24"" Annmarie Cowley From: Annmarie Cowley Sent: 29 November 2017 12:58 To: 'mmackey@nationalarchives.ie' Cc: Richard Healy Mary, hi Annmarie here from Crime Division. Rosemary King is off at the moment and Ijust wanted to run something past you. We are preparing a number of boxes of transcripts relating to the Kerry Babies which we hope to send over to the National Archives. We have copies of the transcripts and I had a look through the manual which you gave to us at the training course and it says that ?permission is not required to destroy duplicate records or printed material". Before I put these aside for shredding I wanted to ensure that this is the case? Thanks Annmarie Annmarie Cowley Crime Division Crime Security Directorate Department of Justice Equality 94 St. Stephen's Green, D02 FD70, Dublin 2, Ireland Internal VOIP 60 8349 - Think IP - using the 6 digit IP number saves money i: +353-1-602-8349 axcowley@justice.ie trnp_2994419018125005609 Page 1 of; RE: Transfer of Records to the National Archives: Transcripts of Kerry Babies Tribunal hearings From: Gillian X. Gilieran To: Helen Hewson Cc: Mail In; Patrick J. Clancy; Richard Healy; Sinead M. Hessian Download: Message; Hi Helen, Thank you for your email. We believe that the books are those that were given to the barristers each day of the trail. We cannot say if they are the master records or if they are one of a set of original copies. if you could send the blank excel listing template it would be greatly appreciated. Kind regards, Gillian Gillian Gilleranl Crime 1 Division Department of Justice and Equality 94- St. Stephen's Green, Dublin 2. Tel: +353-1?60287 14- Email: From: Helen Hewson To: ?Patrick J. Clancy" Cc: "F0i@justice.ie" "Sinead M. Hessian" "Gillian X. Giileran" Richard Healy Date: 0810312016 15:11 Subject: RE: Transfer of Records to the Nationai Archives: Transcripts of Kerry Babies Tribunal hearings Dear Patrick, Thanks for your email. Sorry for the delay in replying - I have been on leave and am only catching up with my correspondence now. I have assigned the National Archives accession number of 2016/10 to the records. This means that each ?le (or book) should be numbered 2016/10/1; 2016/10/2; 2016/10/3 etc. Can you let me know if these are the original (Le. master) records of the Tribunal hearings or if they are sim ply copies of the books of transcripts held by Justice? This is an important distinction that needs to be made four our descriptive purposes (and also in your signed Certi?cate of Transfer that should accompany the records). Please also let me know if you need a blank Excel listing template, as the ?les must be listed in accordance with our template and instructions. i will arrange for 25 archival boxes to be left at our ground floor reception area in Bishop Street where they can be collected at your convenience, from 10am tomorrow. All the best, Helen Helen Hewson Keeper Records Acquisition and Service Development National Archives Bishop Street, Dublin 8 008 DF85 Email: Tel: +353 (0)1 4072 318 03/04/201 8 tmp_2994419018125005609 Page 2 of 2 Original From: Patrick]. Clancy Sent: 02 March 2016 16:35 To: Helen Hewson Cc: F0l@justice.ie; Sinead M. Hession; Gillian X. Gilleran; Richard Healy Subject: Transfer of Records to the National Archives Importance: High Good afternoon Helen, Patrick Clancy (Crime 1 Division) in the Department ofJustice and Equality here, We wish to transfer a number of ?les to the National Archives. They are transcripts of the Tralee Tribunal held in 1985 commonly referred to in the media as the "Kerry Babies Tribunal". Please ?nd attached records we propose to release. i believe you have to furnish us with a National Archives Reference Number to aid the recording of the ?les? Also, can we please be provided with 25 of the official National Archive boxes to store the ?les when sending them to yourselves in the National Archives? Any queries, do not hesitate to contact me. (See attached file: Records to be transferred to the National Archivespdf) Regards, Patrick Clancy Crime 1 Division 94 St Stephen's Green Dublin 2 (01) 6028349 ls le haghaidh an duine no an eintitis er a bhfuil si dlrithe, agus le haghaidh an duine no an eintitis sin amhain, a bheartaitear an fhaisn?is a tarchuireadh agus f?adfaidh s? go bhfuil abhar faoi rL?m agus/n? faoi phribhl?id inti. Toirmisctear aon atarchur n6 leathadh a dh?anamh ar an bhfaisn?is seo, aon ds?id eile a bhaint aisti no? aon ghniomh a dh?anamh ar a hiontaoibh, ag daoine no ag eintitis seachas an faighteoir beartaithe. Ma fuair tu seo tn? dhearmad, t?igh i dteagmh?il leis an seoltoir, le do thoil, agus scrios an t-a'bhar as aon rr?omhaire. is beartas na Roinne Dli agus Cirt agus Comhionannais, na nOifigi agus na nGniomhaireachtaI? a Lis?ideann seirbhl'siTF na Roinne seoladh abhair choluil a dhi?cheadd. Mas rud go measann t? gur ?bhar coldil ata san a'bhar ata sa teachtaireacht see is ceart duit dul i dteagmhail leis an seolt?ir laithreach agus le chomh maith. The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain con?dential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. It is the policy of the Department of Justice and Equality and the Agencies and Offices using its lT services to disallow the sending of offensive material. Should you consider that the material contained in this message is offensive you should contact the sender immediately and also ://doj &cs. . . 03/04/201 8 from Crime 1 Division Department of Justice and Equality Schedule of ?les to be released to the National Archives Of?ce Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 18 March, 2016 National Original Description Dates Archives Reference Reference Number Number 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 anuary,l 985" Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 1 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 8 January, 1 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 2 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 9 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 3 72/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 10 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 4 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 11 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 5 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 6 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 January,1985 Kw before Mr. Justice Lyn_c_h_. Book 7 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 16 January,l 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 8 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 17 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 9 72/ 10/ 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 18 January, 1 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 10 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. *2?1January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 11 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 22 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 12 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 23 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 13 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 24 .January,1985w4 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 14 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 28 January,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 15 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 29 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 16 '72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 30 anuary,1985 7 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 17 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 31 January, 1985 National i bl?igitml Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 25 Description Dates?? Archives Reference Reference Number Number 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 1 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 19_ 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, ralee, Co. 4 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 20 r{2/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 5 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 21 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 6 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 22 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 23 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 8 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 24 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 11 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 25 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 12 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 26 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 13 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 27 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 28 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 15 ebruary,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book29 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 18 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 39_ 72/10/182 ralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 19 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 31 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 20 February,1985_ Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 32 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 21 February,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 33 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 22 February, 1 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 34 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 27 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 35 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 5 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 21 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 6 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 22 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 23 72/10/182 'Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 8 February, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 24 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 11 February,l985 . h. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 40 (Held at Dublin Castle) ??onat Original Description Dates Archives Reference Reference Number Number 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 12 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 26 72/ 10/ 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 13 ebruary,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 27 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 15 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 29 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 18 February,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 3g 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 19 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 31 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 20 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 32 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 21 February,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 33 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 22 February,1985 - Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 34 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 27 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 35 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 28 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 36 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 1 March,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 37 (Held at Dublin Castle) '72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 6 March,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 39 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 28 Febraury,l 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 36 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 1 March,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 37 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 5 March,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 38 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 6 March,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 39 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 ralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 March,1985 National Archives Reference Number Original Reference Number Description whates 75/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 41 (Held at Dublin Castle) 8 March,1985 72/10/182 1; Tralee Tribunal rield at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 42 (Held at Dublin Castle) 11 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 43 (Held at Dublin Castle) 1 2 March, 1 985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 44 (Held at Dublin Castle) 13 March, 1935 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 45 (Held at Dublin Castle) 14 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 46 (Held at Dublin Castle) 15 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 47 (Held at Dublin Castle) 19 March,198.5 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 48 (Held at Dublin Castle) 20 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 49 (Held at Dublin Castle) 21 M'arch,1935 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 50 (Held at Dublin Castle) 22 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 51 (Held at Dublin Castle) 25 Maroh,l 985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 52 (Held at Dublin Castle) 26 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 53 (Held at Dublin Castle) 26 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held in? the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 54 (Held at Dublin Castle) 28 March,1985_ 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 55 (Held at Dublin Castle) 29 March,1985 National Archives Reference __Number Original Reference Number Description Dates 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 56 (Held at Dublin Castle) ,7 15 April,l985 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 57 (Held at Dublin Castle) 16 April,1985 72/10/182 . Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, ralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 58 (Held at Dublin Castle) 17 Apri1,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 59 (Held at Dublin Castle) 13 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 60 (Held at Dublin Castle) 19 Apri1,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 61 (Held at Dublin Castle) 22 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 62 (Held at Dublin Castle) 23 April,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 63 (Held at Dublin Castle) 24 April, 1 985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 64 (Held at Dublin Castle) 25 April,f?85 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 65 (Held at Dublin Castle) 26 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 66 (Held at Dublin Castle) 29 April,1985 72/10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 67 (Held at Dublin Castle) 30 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 68 (Held at Dublin Castle) 1 May,1985 72/ 10/ 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 69 (Held at Dublin Castle) 2 May,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 70 (Held at Dublin Castle) 7 May,1985 National Archives Reference Number Original Reference Number Description Dates 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 71 (Held at Dublin Castle) . 72/10/182 8 May,1985 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 72 (Held at Dublin Castle) 9 May,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 73 (Held at Dublin Castle) 10 May,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 74 (Held at Dublin Castle) 13 May,l985 72/10/1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 75 (Held at Dublin Castle) 14 May,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 76 (Held at Dublin Castle) 15 May,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 77 (Held at Dublin Castle) 20 May,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 7 8 (Held at Dublin Castle) 10 June, 1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 79 (Held at Dublin Castle) 11 June,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 80 (Held at Dublin Castle) 12 June,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 81 (Held at Dublin Castle) 13 June,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 82 (Held at Dublin Castle) 14 June,1985 72710/182 Tribunal of Inquiry. Transcript of Proceedings Held before Mr. Justice in the High Court, Dublin 28 72/10/182 Tribunal of Inquiry. Transcript of Proceedings Held before Mr. Justice in the High Court, Dublin 28 December,1984 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 20 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee: Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 28 4 February,1985 14 February,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 16 National Original Description Dates Archives Reference Reference Number Number 72/1 Oil 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 5 March,l 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 38 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 5 March, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 38 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/1 0/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 13 June,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 81 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 June,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 82 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 1 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 8 anuary,1 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 2 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 9 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 3 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 10 January,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 4 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 11 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 5 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 anuary,1 98S Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 6 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 15 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 7 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 16 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 8 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 17 anuary,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 9 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 18 anuary,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 10 72/ 10/ I 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 21 anuary,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 11 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 22 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 12 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, ralce, Co. 23 January, 1 9'83? Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 13 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 24 anuary,1 985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 14 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 28 January,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 15 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 29 anuary,l985?_ National Archives Reference Number Original Reference Number Description Dates 72/1 01182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 17 30 January, 1985 I 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 18 31 January, 1985 52/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 19 1 72/10/ 182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 40 (Held at Dublin Castle) 7 March,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 41 (Held at Dublin Castle) 8 March,l985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 42 (Held at Dublin Castle) 11 March,1985 72/10/182 Trale'e Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 43 (Held at Dublin Castle) 12 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Keny before Mr. Justice Book 45 (Held at Dublin Castle) 14 March, 1 985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 46 (Held at Dublin Castle) 15 March, 1 985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 47 (Held at Dublin Castle) 1911712?ch,1985 ?1 72/1 0/1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 48 (Held at Dublin Castle) 20 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 49 (Held at Dublin Castle) 21 March,l985 72/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 50 (Held at Dublin Castle) 22 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. usticc Book 50 (Held at Dublin Castle) 25 March,1985_ 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 52 (Held at Dublin Castle) 26 March,1985 72/10/182 Dublin Castle) Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 53 (Held at 27 March,1985 National Archives Reference Number Original Reference Number Description Dates 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 54 (Held at Dublin Castle) 28 March,l985 m. 72/10/132 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 55 (Held at Dublin Castle) 29 March,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at ?the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 56 (Held at Dublin Castle) 15 Apri1,l985 72/10/182 Tralce Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co- Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 57 (Held at Dublin Castle) 16 April,l985 72/10/18'2? Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 58 (Held at Dublin Castle) 17 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 5 9 (Held at Dublin Castle) 13 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 60 (Held at Dublin Castle) 19 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 61 (Held at Dublin Castle) 22 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 62 (Held at Dublin Castle) 23 April,l985 72/1 0/1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tral ee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 63 (Held at Dublin Castle) 24 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralce Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 64 (Held at Dublin Castle) 25 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 65 (Held at Dublin Castle) 26 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. . Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 66 (Held at Dublin Castle) 29 April,1?85 mun??v- nu.? 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 67 (Held at Dublin Castle) 30 April,1985 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 68 (Held at Dublin Castle) 1 May,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 80 (Held at Dublin Castle) National Original Description Dates. Archives Reference Reference Number ?Number 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 2 May,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 69 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 7 May,l985 1, Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 70 (Held. at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 8 May,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 71 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 13 May,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 74 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 14 May,1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 75 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/ 10/ 1 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 20 May,l985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 77 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 10 June, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 78 (Held at Dublin Castle) - 72/10/182 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 11 June, 1985 Kerry before Mr. Justice Book 79 (Held at Dublin Castle) 72/ 10/ 82 Tralee Tribunal Held at the Courthouse, Tralee, Co. 12 June, 1985