Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 1 of 107 PagelD #21309 EXHIBIT Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 2 of 107 PageID #:1310 Transcript of the Testimony of GLENN EVANS Date: March 16, 2015 Case: RITA KING VS. GLENN EVANS, ET AL. TOOMEY REPORTING Phone: 312-853-0648 Fax: 312-853-9705 Email: toomeyrep@sbcglobal.net Internet: http://www.toomeyreporting.com/ Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 3 of 107 PageID #:1311 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION RITA KING, Plaintiff, vs. GLENN EVANS, et al., Defendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) No. 13 C 1937 This is the deposition of GLENN EVANS, called by the Plaintiff for examination, taken pursuant to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for the United States District Courts pertaining to the taking of depositions, taken before PEGGY A. ANDERSON, a Certified Shorthand Reporter of the State of Illinois, at 30 North LaSalle Street, Suite 900, Chicago, Illinois, on March 16, 2015, at 11:20 a.m. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 4 of 107 PageID #:1312 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 2 (Pages 2 to 5) Page 2 1 2 A P P E A R A N C E S: 5 6 WITNESS GLENN EVANS 3 4 5 6 Appeared on behalf of the Plaintiff; 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. MORRISSEY: 19 20 21 22 23 24 MARKED PAGE PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 1 21 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 2 (not marked.) PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 3 22 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 4 (not attached) 38 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT NO. 5 39 ****** Page 3 1 2 A P P E A R A N C E S: THE LAW OFFICES OF: CITY OF CHICAGO FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS LITIGATION DIVISION BY: MS. CARLA MADELEINE KUPE-ARION 30 North LaSalle Street Suite 900 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 744-5106 carla.kupearion@cityofchicago.org 3 4 5 6 7 8 Appeared on behalf of the Defendant, City of Chicago; 9 10 11 THE LAW OFFICES OF: MS. LAURA J. MORASK 12 BY: MS. LAURA J. MORASK 713 West Devon Avenue Park Ridge, Illinois 60068 (847) 696-7185 LAURA@LAURALAW.ORG 13 14 15 and 16 THE LAW OFFICES OF: MR. TIMOTHY M. BLACK BY: MR. TIMOTHY M. BLACK 713 West Devon Avenue Park Ridge, Illinois 60068 (262) 745-2837 timothyblack@gmail.com Appeared on behalf of the Defendant, Glenn Evans, in his criminal case, People of the State of Illinois vs. Glenn Evans, Case No. 14 CR 16367. 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 . 12-51 EXHIBITS 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 THE LAW OFFICES OF: CITY OF CHICAGO FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS LITIGATION DIVISION BY: MS. TIFFANY Y. HARRIS 30 North LaSalle Street Suite 900 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 744-7684 tiffany.harris@cityofchicago.org Appeared on behalf of the individual defendants: Glenn Evans, D.T. Clifford, R.A. Sutton, K.L. Rodgers, Wilfredo Lapitan, and Lloyd Gray. 10 PAGE 2 7 8 9 INDEX 1 THE LAW OFFICES OF: THOMAS G. MORRISSEY BY: MR. THOMAS G. MORRISSEY MR. PATRICK MORRISSEY 10249 South Western Avenue Chicago, Illinois 60643 (773) 233-7900 tgmlaw@amertech.net 3 4 Page 4 Page 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 19 12 21 13 13 14 16 15 2 16 11 16 16 16 22 16 2 17 7 17 13 17 18 17 23 17 4 18 8 18 12 18 17 18 23 18 4 19 10 19 17 19 23 19 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 5 of 107 PageID #:1313 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 3 (Pages 6 to 9) Page 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 4 20 10 20 15 20 23 20 19 21 1 22 7 22 7 23 11 23 15 23 21 23 2 24 9 24 14 24 21 24 2 25 7 25 12 25 19 25 2 26 8 26 12 26 Page 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 4 32 9 32 13 32 18 32 21 32 1 33 4 33 7 33 11 33 18 33 22 33 2 34 6 34 10 34 15 34 19 34 24 34 5 35 10 35 16 35 21 35 3 36 Page 7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 19 26 12 27 16 27 19 27 22 27 2 28 6 28 10 28 14 28 21 28 4 29 9 29 13 29 19 29 1 30 5 30 9 30 12 30 17 30 22 30 5 31 13 31 Page 9 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 13 36 22 36 4 37 8 37 12 37 21 37 3 38 10 38 24 38 10 39 19 39 11 40 20 40 5 41 10 41 17 41 7 42 20 42 24 42 4 43 9 43 21 43 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 6 of 107 PageID #:1314 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 4 (Pages 10 to 13) Page 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFIED QUESTIONS LINE PAGE 9 44 20 44 6 45 18 45 3 46 13 46 23 47 7 47 13 47 18 47 4 48 8 48 12 48 17 48 6 49 11 49 15 49 20 49 5 50 17 50 Page 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: You can't give a nod of the head or say uh-huh or whatever because the court reporter will not be able to have a complete record; do you understand that? THE WITNESS: Yes. MR. MORRISSEY: If at any time during this deposition you don't understand one of my questions, please stop me and I will attempt to rephrase it; do you understand? THE WITNESS: Yes. WHEREUPON: GLENN EVANS, called as a witness herein, having been first duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows: DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are you under any type of medication as you sit here today? A On the advice of my attorney, I am invoking my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q To the extent that -- For how long -- Page 11 1 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 (WHEREUPON, the witness was first duly sworn.) MR. MORRISSEY: This is the discovery deposition of Commander Evans taken pursuant to notice and the Fede 6 Civil Procedure. The deposition has been continued several times by the attorneys for the City and Mr. Evans. Mr. Evans, before we get started, have you ever been deposed before? THE WITNESS: Yes. MR. MORRISSEY: So you understand the general rules in regards to a discovery deposition, correct? THE WITNESS: I don't understand the phrase "general rules." MR. MORRISSEY: Well, All right, let me explain it. In a deposition, I'm going to ask you a series of questions, and you are going to have to answer orally so that the court reporter can take down your responses. Do you understand that? THE WITNESS: Yes. Page 13 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Are you currently employed by the Chicago Police Department? A Yes. Q How long have you been with the Chicago Police Department? A Since 1986. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm going to ask to certify the first question in regards to whether or not you're under any type of medication as you sit here today. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q And I understand your invoking your Fifth Amendment privilege; is that correct? A Yes. MR. MORRISSEY: So we will certify that question for the Court. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When did you first become employed by the Chicago Police Department? A July 1986. Q **** When you first became employed by the Chicago Police Department, were you required to go to a training academy? A On the advice of my attorney, I TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 7 of 107 PageID #:1315 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 5 (Pages 14 to 17) Page 14 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: Again, we are going to certify that question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Where were you first employed as a -Strike that. Were you ever sworn in as a member of the Chicago Police Department? A Yes. Q And what month and what year were you sworn in as a member of the Chicago Police Department? A July 1986. Q **** After you became a sworn member of the Chicago Police Department, where were you assigned as a Chicago police officer? A On the advice of my attorney, I'm invoking my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: We will certify the question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q For what period of time were you a patrol officer with the Chicago Police Department? Page 16 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Did you ever have the position with the Chicago Police Department as an officer? MS. HARRIS: Objection, vague. Go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** For what period of time were you a police officer with the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** At any period of time when you were a sworn member of the Chicago Police Department, were you promoted to any other position as a detective? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you ever have a position as a sergeant in the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I Page 15 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Could you be more specific? What do you mean? Q For what period of time were you a -Strike that. When you first were sworn in as a Chicago Police -- as a member of the Chicago Police Department, what was your position? A Probationary police officer. Q And after you completed your probationary period with the Chicago Police Department, what rank did you obtain? Do you understand the question? A No, I don't. Q Was there a probationary period that you served with the Chicago Police Department? A Yes. Q **** How long was that period for? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: Again, we will certify that question. Each time the deponent seeks to assert a Fifth Amendment privilege, we are going to certify the questions for the -- either the district court or the magistrate. Page 17 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you ever -- For how long a period of time were you a sergeant with the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you ever get promoted to the position of a lieutenant with the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Were you ever assigned to the 6th Police Department in the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you at any point in time ever a watch commander while assigned to the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you working on April 10, 2011 as a lieutenant with the Chicago Police TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 8 of 107 PageID #:1316 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 6 (Pages 18 to 21) Page 18 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011, were you on duty between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m.? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you know a police officer by the name of Sutton? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011, was a Police Officer Clifford working in the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Was there a police officer by the name of Officer Rodgers assigned to the 6th District and working on April 10th, 2011 at approximately 10:30 a.m.? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011, did you have occasion to see a person by the name of Page 20 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 11th, 2011 in the lockup facility at approximately 10:30 a.m. in the morning, did you have any physical contact with the Plaintiff, Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011, did you approve as the watch commander a probable cause for the arrest of Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you have any contact, physical contact, with Rita King -A On the -Q -- on -- Let me finish my question -on April 10th, 2011 in the lockup facility in the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you served with a complaint in this lawsuit filed by Rita King? Page 19 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On or about April 10th, 2011, at approximately 10:20 in the morning, were you present in the lockup facility at the 6th Police District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** At about 10:20 or thereafter on the morning of April 10th, 2011, were you in the presence of Ms. King and Officer Clifford, Officer Rodgers and Officer Sutton in the lockup facility at the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On or about April 10th, 2011 at 10:20 a.m. in the morning, did you enter the lockup facility and speak with the Plaintiff in this case, Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Prior to April 10th, 2011, did you know an individual by the name of Rita Page 21 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. (WHEREUPON, Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 1 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q I'm showing you what has been marked as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 1. It's Defendant Evans' Answer to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories. I would ask you to take a look at that document for a moment. MR. MORRISSEY: Let's go outside for a second. (WHEREUPON, a short break was had.) (WHEREUPON, the record was read as requested.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Mr. Evans, have you had an opportunity to review Plaintiff's Exhibit 1 which is Defendant Evans' Answers to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 9 of 107 PageID #:1317 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 7 (Pages 22 to 25) Page 22 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q **** I would ask you to turn to the final page of Defendant Evans' Answers to the First Set of Interrogatories, and I would ask you whether or not that is your signature? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** I would ask you in regards to Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 1, are those your answers that you prepared in regards to litigation in Rita King versus Glenn Evans? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: So what are we on, 1? I think we're only on 1, right? All right, we are on 2, so make it 3. (WHEREUPON, Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 3 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Showing you, Mr. Evans, which has been marked as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 3, it's a document which states Defendant's Answers to Affirmative Defenses Jury Demand in Response to Plaintiff's Amended complaint. I Page 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you served or were your attorneys -- are you -- Strike that. Are you represented by any attorneys in a case brought by Rita King in regards to an incident which occurred on April 10th, 2011? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you spoken to any attorneys in regards to an incident in regards to a complaint filed by Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you served with a -- were you or were your attorneys served with an Amended Complaint brought by Rita King in regards to an incident which occurred on April 10th, 2011? A On the advice of my attorneys, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Mr. Evans, is there a city agency, to your knowledge, called the Independent Police Review Authority? A On the advice of my attorney, I Page 23 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 would ask you to -- and it was filed as Document Number 30 on June 28th, 2013. I would ask you to take a look at this document. It's right here. It's Number 3. MS. MORASK: It's this one. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Have you had an opportunity to review Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 3? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Mr. Evans, were you ever served as a defendant in a case brought by Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On your behalf, did attorneys file an initial Answer to a Complaint filed by Rita King in regards to an incident which occurred on April 10th, 2011? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** My question is did you respond at any point to a lawsuit brought by Rita King in the form of an Answer to the Complaint? A On the advice of my attorney, I Page 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On November 7th, 2013, did you give a statement to a Linda Franco in regards to a citizen complaint filed by Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you appear in the office of Linda Franco on November 7th, 2013 in regards to a citizen complaint filed by Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you give a statement to Ms. Franco on November 7th, 2013 in regards to Ms. Rita King's allegation that you used excessive force against her on April 10th, 2011? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you intend to testify at the trial brought by Rita King in regards to allegations that on April 10th, 2011, you used excessive force on her in the lockup room in the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 10 of 107 PageID #:1318 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 8 (Pages 26 to 29) Page 26 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you discussed the incident with either Officer Sutton, Officer Clifford or Officer Rodgers in regards to the allegations brought by Rita King in this federal lawsuit? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011, did you give any verbal commands to Rita King? A On the advice of the attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Is it your position that on April 10th, 2011 in the lockup at the 6th District, Rita King refused to respond to your verbal commands to submit to being photographed? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Tell me what reasonable force you used against Rita King on April 10th, 2011 in order for her to submit to being fingerprinted and photographed in the lockup in the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I Page 28 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you ever work as a security officer in a roller rink? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you ever receive any graduate degree or education? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you received any awards from the city of Chicago? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** When you were promoted as a police officer to the level of sergeant, did you -- were you interviewed prior to receiving that promotion by any member of the command staff? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** When you were promoted to a lieutenant position in the Chicago Police department, did you take an examination to become a -- to qualify to take the position of Page 27 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q Where did you go to high school? A Excuse me? Q Where did you go to high school? A Could you be more specific? Q Did you attend freshman year of high school? A Yes. Q Did you graduate from a high school in the United States? A Yes. Q **** Where did you graduate -- What high school did you graduate from? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you attend college? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did you graduate from college? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you live in the city of Chicago? A On the advice of my attorney, I Page 29 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 lieutenant? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you ever been subject to a citizen complaint for the use of excessive force? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you ever been disciplined for using excessive force against any citizen? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you had any conversations with the mayor of Chicago in regards to your position as a lieutenant or a commander in the Chicago Police department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Has the superintendent of the police, Mr. McCarthy, had any conversations with you in regards to prior citizens' complaints in regards to excessive force? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 11 of 107 PageID #:1319 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 9 (Pages 30 to 33) Page 30 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q **** Who is the current superintendent of police? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Are you still being paid by the city of Chicago as a police officer? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Are you employed currently? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you been terminated -- has your employment been terminated in the last two years? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Give me your general duties and obligations as a member of the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Prior to being promoted to the lieutenant, as a lieutenant of the Chicago Police Department, did you undergo any Page 32 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 an objection on the record. You can answer. A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What were your duties as -- Are you still a commander with the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What are the responsibilities of a commander with the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On April 10th, 2011 what were your responsibilities as the watch commander that morning? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you have any assets? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you have any bank accounts currently? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Page 31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 psychological evaluation? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to provide testimony. Q **** After citizen complaints have been filed against you, has the police department ever required you to undergo a psychological evaluation to determine whether or not you were fit to be a member of the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** When you were promoted to the level of lieutenant in the Chicago Police Department, was there ever, to your knowledge, any review of the prior citizen complaints that have been filed against you for the use of excessive force prior to promoting you? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question, also objection, it's speculative and, objection, competence by the City. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q You could answer. She's just putting Page 33 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q **** Do you own any real property? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you have any stocks or bonds? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you have any judgments against you? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you ever been disciplined by the Chicago Police Department for the -A On the -Q Let me finish my question -- based upon the use of excessive force? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you ever been involved in a civil litigation, in any civil litigation? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Were you ever a defendant in Logan versus Evans, 97 C 8816? A On the advice of my attorney, I TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 12 of 107 PageID #:1320 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 10 (Pages 34 to 37) Page 34 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In regards to Logan versus Evans, were you a defendant or were you not? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Jones versus Ector, 98 C 5576, were you a defendant in that action? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment Right not to testify. Q **** In Randall verus the Superintendent of the City of Chicago, 2000 C 299, were you named as a defendant in that lawsuit? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Hall versus the City of Chicago, 2000 C 5490, were you a defendant? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Simmons versus City of Chicago, 2008 C 2769, were you a defendant in that lawsuit? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Richardson versus City of Page 36 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Is there any reason why you're unable to sit for this deposition and answer questions today? MS. HARRIS: Objection, mischaracterizes the testimony and evidence in this case. You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Is there any physical reason why you're unable to testify today? MS. HARRIS: Objection, mischaracterizes the testimony and evidence in this case. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** When you were promoted to commander, did you have any discussions with then Superintendent McCarthy about prior Page 35 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Chicago, 2008 C 4824, were you named as a defendant? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Evans versus Williams and Fudge, Inc., 2008 C 6919, were you a party in that lawsuit? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Misher, M-i-s-h-e-r, versus unknown Chicago Police Officers, 2010 C 1753, were you named as a defendant in that litigation? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In Byars, B-y-a-r-s, versus Evans 13 C 923, were you named as a defendant in those actions? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** In the above-listed lawsuits, were you ever disciplined by the city of Chicago as a result of any of those actions brought by plaintiffs? Page 37 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 lawsuits or citizen complaints? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Has the city of Chicago ever disciplined you for the use of excessive force? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What is your monthly gross income, sir? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What investigation did you do prior to responding to Plaintiff's interrogatories, first set of interrogatories? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q Did you review any police reports -A On the advice of my attorney -Q I've got to finish my question here. A Okay, sir. Q **** You jumped the gun here. On April 10, 2011, did you review any police reports prepared by Officer Clifford or Officer Sutton in regards to the arrest of Rita King? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 13 of 107 PageID #:1321 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 11 (Pages 38 to 41) Page 38 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What is a Tactical Response Report with the Chicago Police Department -Strike that. Let me ask you a question. Are you familiar with a form called a Tactical Response Report? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** On or after April 10th, 2011, why did you not prepare a Tactical Response Report in regards to your contact with Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we take a two-minute break here. (WHEREUPON, a short break was had.) (WHEREUPON, Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 4 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** I'm showing you what has been Page 40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 attorneys 03170 through 3172. Mr. Evans, does the Chicago Police Department have general procedures or orders that are followed by members of the Chicago Police Department? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question, objection competency. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, let me rephrase the question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are there written procedures that outline the duties and responsibilities of members of the Chicago Police Department? MS. KUPE-ARION: Same objection by the City. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** What type of written orders are issued by the Chicago Police Department? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question and competence as well. Page 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 marked as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 4. It's a Tactical Response Report by the Chicago Police Department. I would ask you to take a look at that form for a moment; and for the record, apparently it's a two-page form. Mr. Evans, is this a form that's used by the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Specifically, in April of 2010, did the city of Chicago have a form called a Tactical Response Report? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. (WHEREUPON, Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 5 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** I'm showing you what is marked as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 5. The form is captioned Detention Facilities General Procedures and Responsibilities, Special Order SO6-01-02. I would ask you to take a look at this document that's been Bates stamped by your Page 41 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Looking at Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 5, is this a written order of the Chicago Police Department? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Does the City of Chicago Police Department have written procedures and guidelines involving screening and monitoring sick or injured or emotionally challenged arrestees? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** If Rita King was not cooperative in the lockup in the 6th District on April 10th, 2011, why was she not placed into a lockup facility -MS. HARRIS: Objection, form. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q -- prior to being fingerprinted and photographed? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 14 of 107 PageID #:1322 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 12 (Pages 42 to 45) Page 42 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, speculation, foundation, competence. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** If a person is suffering from a psychological illness such as a bipolar disorder, are there written procedures in regards to processing such an arrestee by the Chicago Police Department? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, speculation, foundation, competence. MS. KUPE-ARION: The City joins in those objections. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Where is the 6th Police District located in the city of Chicago? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** How many lockup cells are there Page 44 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 force? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, speculation, foundation, competence. MS. KUPE-ARION: City joins. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** As a commander with the Chicago Police Department, are officers disciplined if they are found to -- found to have used excessive force on citizens? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, speculation, foundation, competence. MS. KUPE-ARION: City joins. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** As a sergeant, have you ever disciplined a member of the Chicago Police Department when you found or determined that the person -- that a police officer had used excessive force? Page 43 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 in the lockup area of the 6th District? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** How would answering the question in regards to how many lockups are in the 6th District impact your Fifth Amendment rights? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Are there procedures or policies within the Chicago Police Department for processing arrestees who are high or intoxicated on illegal street drugs? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, speculation, foundation, competence. MS. KUPE-ARION: The City joins in those objections. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are there any procedures within the Chicago Police Department to discharge a member of the police department who receives frequent citizen complaints about excessive Page 45 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MS. HARRIS: Objection, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** As a lieutenant, have you ever disciplined or caused charges to be brought against a police officer -MS. HARRIS: Objection, relevance. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q -- in regards to the use of excessive force? MS. HARRIS: Objection, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** As a lieutenant, have you ever disciplined a member of the Chicago Police Department if you found or believed that they had used excessive force against a citizen? MS. HARRIS: Objection, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 15 of 107 PageID #:1323 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 13 (Pages 46 to 49) Page 46 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** As a commander, have you ever disciplined or caused a review of a police officer or a lieutenant or a sergeant who you believe had used excessive force against a citizen? MS. HARRIS: Objection, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are you aware of the City of Chicago's Police Department ever disciplining a police officer, sergeant or lieutenant accused of using excessive force against a citizen? MS. HARRIS: Objection, vague, overly broad, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** What is IPRA to your knowledge? MS. HARRIS: Objection, competence, Page 48 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Did Rita King on April 10, 2011 strike you? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Did Rita King ever kick you on April 10, 2011? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Have you ever given any statement to anybody in regards to allegations in regards to Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** At what point -- Assuming you gave a statement to the Illinois -- or the Independent Police Review Authority in November of 2013 in regards to allegations by Rita King, at what point did you decide that you would no longer give statements in regards to Ms. King's allegation? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, Page 47 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 speculation, foundation. MS. KUPE-ARION: City joins. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Have you ever given a statement to the Independent Police Review Association? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm sorry. Let me rephrase that. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Have you ever been requested to give a statement to the Independent Police Review Authority of the City of Chicago? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** What is your understanding as a member of the Chicago Police force of the term "excessive force"? MS. HARRIS: Objection, speculation, foundation, competence, form. MS. KUPE-ARION: City joins. BY THE WITNESS: Page 49 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 harassing. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Do you agree that you have previously answered the complaint brought by Rita King? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Do you agree that you also filed an answer to Rita King's Amended Complaint? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Furthermore, you gave a statement in regards to Rita King's allegation in November of 2013, correct? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. Q **** Are you denying that in November of 2013 that you gave a statement to the Independent Police Review Authority? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, harassing. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 16 of 107 PageID #:1324 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 14 (Pages 50 to 53) Page 50 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are you aware that if the jury returns a verdict in regards to punitive damages in this case, that the city is not going to indemnify you in regards to this -any damages awarded for punitive damages? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form. MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question. BY THE WITNESS: A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q **** Are you going to testify at trial that you're financially unable to pay any punitive damages which may or may not be entered against you by a jury? A On the advice of my attorney, I invoke my Fifth Amendment right not to testify. MR. MORRISSEY: I have nothing further. All the questions in this Page 52 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: You can bring whatever motions -MS. HARRIS: It's not an argument, Counsel. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, I'm just -MS. HARRIS: I'm putting what I -MR. MORRISSEY: You can put whatever you want. MS. HARRIS: -- intend to do on the record. I understand you object. That's your position. We are not going to argue about it. Everyone is just putting their position on the record. That's all this is. MR. MORRISSEY: Mr. Evans, your lawyer is going to advise you. You have the right when this transcript is transcribed, and it will be transcribed, to review the transcript of today's proceeding or you have the option of relying on the court reporter to take down accurately your responses to my questions. It's up to you. MS. HARRIS: We are going to reserve. MR. MORRISSEY: All right. Page 51 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 deposition in which Mr. Evans has invoked his Fifth Amendment privilege I'm certifying for the Court and will bring this before the Court at the earliest time period. MS. KUPE-ARION: And for the City, the City is reserving, for the record, definitely reserving the right to recall Commander Evans should the privilege amendment no longer apply. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, to the extent that Commander Evans is taking the Fifth Amendment, we are certainly not going to be prejudiced at trial if all of a sudden Commander Evans decides that he's now decided that he's going to waive his Fifth Amendment privilege. So that certainly would put us at a great disadvantage but anyway, that's for the Court to decide. MS. HARRIS: On behalf of Glenn Evans, we will be seeking to have the deposition subject to a protective order and we'll be bringing the proper motions before the Court. Page 53 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 FURTHER DEPONENT SAITH NOT..... TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 17 of 107 PageID #:1325 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 15 (Pages 54 to 56) Page 56 Page 54 1 2 3 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION RITA KING, ) ) 4 Plaintiff, ) ) 5 vs. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 ) No. 13 C 1937 ) GLENN EVANS, et al., ) ) Defendants. ) I, GLENN EVANS, being first duly sworn, on oath, say that I am the deponent in the aforesaid deposition, that I have read the foregoing transcript of my deposition, consisting of pages 1-54 inclusive, taken at the aforesaid time and place and that the foregoing is a true and correct transcript of my testimony so given. ____________________________ GLENN EVANS SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO me before this ________ day of ___________________, A.D. 2015. _________________________ Notary Public 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I do hereunto set my hand at Chicago, Illinois, this _______ day of ____________________, 2015. ______________________________________ Peggy A. Anderson Certified Shorthand Reporter License No. 084-003813 Page 55 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 STATE OF ILLINOIS ) ) ss: COUNTY OF C O O K ) I, Peggy A. Anderson, a Certified Shorthand Reporter in the State of Illinois do hereby certify: That previous to the commencement of the examination of the witness, the witness was duly sworn to testify the whole truth concerning the matters herein; That the foregoing deposition transcript was reported stenographically by me, was thereafter reduced to typewriting under my personal direction, and constitutes a true record of the testimony given and the proceedings had; That the said deposition was taken before me at the time and place specified; That the said deposition was adjourned as stated herein; That I am not a relative or employee or attorney or counsel, nor a relative or employee of such attorney or counsel for any of the parties hereto, nor interested directly or indirectly in the outcome of this action. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 18 of 107 PageID #:1326 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 57 A able 12:3 abovelisted 35:21 academy 13:23 accounts 32:21 accurately 52:21 accused 46:15 action 34:7 55:24 actions 35:18,23 adjourned 55:19 advice 12:21 13:24 14:16 15:17 16:8 16:14,20,24 17:5 17:10,16,21 18:2 18:6,10,15,21 19:2,8,15,21 20:2 20:8,13,21 21:1 21:23 22:5,11 23:9,13,19,24 24:7,12,19,24 25:5,10,17,24 26:6,10,17,24 27:14,17,20,24 28:4,8,12,19 29:2 29:7,11,17,23 30:3,7,10,15,20 31:2,11 32:2,7,11 32:16,19,23 33:2 33:5,9,16,20,24 34:4,8,13,17,22 35:3,8,14,19 36:1 36:10,19 37:2,6 37:10,15,18 38:1 38:8,14 39:8,13 40:17 41:2,8,15 42:4,17,22 43:2,7 43:18 44:6,17 45:3,15,24 46:10 46:20 47:4,16 48:1,6,10,15 49:3 49:9,13,18 50:2 50:14,21 advise 52:16 affirmative 22:23 aforesaid 54:11,14 agency 24:22 agree 49:6,11 ahead 16:6 al 1:6 54:6 allegation 25:14 48:23 49:16 allegations 25:21 26:4 48:13,20 amended 22:24 24:16 49:12 amendment 12:22 13:13 14:1,17 15:18,21 16:9,15 16:21 17:1,6,11 17:17,22 18:3,7 18:11,16,22 19:3 19:9,16,22 20:3,9 20:14,22 21:2,24 22:6,12 23:10,14 23:20 24:1,8,13 24:20 25:1,6,11 25:18 26:1,7,11 26:18 27:1,15,18 27:21 28:1,5,9,13 28:20 29:3,8,12 29:18,24 30:4,8 30:11,16,21 31:3 31:12 32:3,8,12 32:17,20,24 33:3 33:6,10,17,21 34:1,5,9,14,18,23 35:4,9,15,20 36:2 36:11,20 37:3,7 37:11,16 38:2,9 38:15 39:9,14 40:18 41:3,9,16 42:5,18,23 43:3,6 43:8,19 44:7,18 45:4,16 46:1,11 46:21 47:5,17 48:2,7,11,16 49:4 49:10,14,19 50:3 50:15,22 51:2,10 51:13,17 amertech 2:6 anderson 1:14 55:3 56:8 answer 11:21 21:9 23:16,23 31:24 32:1 36:4,8 49:12 answered 49:7 answering 43:4 answers 21:21 22:2 22:9,23 anybody 48:13 anyway 51:19 apparently 39:5 appear 25:7 appeared 2:7,16 3:8,21 apply 51:10 approve 20:11 approximately 18:20 19:5 20:5 april 17:23 18:4,12 18:19,23 19:4,11 19:17,23 20:4,10 20:19 23:18 24:6 24:18 25:15,21 26:8,13,20 32:13 37:22 38:10 39:10 41:18 48:4,9 area 43:1 argue 52:11 argument 52:3 arrest 20:12 37:24 arrestee 42:10 arrestees 41:14 43:11 assert 15:21 assets 32:18 assigned 14:15 17:13,19 18:18 association 47:8 assuming 48:17 attached 4:12 attempt 12:10 attend 27:6,16 attorney 12:21 13:24 14:16 15:17 16:8,14,20,24 17:5,10,16,21 18:2,6,10,15,21 19:2,8,15,21 20:2 20:8,13,21 21:1 21:23 22:5,11 23:9,13,19,24 24:7,12,24 25:5 25:10,17,24 26:6 26:10,17,24 27:14 27:17,20,24 28:4 28:8,12,19 29:2,7 29:11,17,23 30:3 30:7,10,15,20 31:2,11 32:2,7,11 32:16,19,23 33:2 33:5,9,16,20,24 34:4,8,13,17,22 35:3,8,14,19 36:1 36:10,19 37:2,6 37:10,15,18 38:1 38:8,14 39:8,13 40:17 41:2,8,15 42:4,17,22 43:2,7 43:18 44:6,17 45:3,15,24 46:10 46:20 47:4,16 48:1,6,10,15 49:3 49:9,13,18 50:2 50:14,21 55:21,22 attorneys 11:8 23:15 24:3,4,9,15 24:19 40:1 authority 24:23 47:15 48:19 49:22 avenue 2:5 3:13,18 awarded 50:9 awards 28:10 aware 46:13 50:5 B b 4:6 bank 32:21 based 33:14 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 bates 39:24 behalf 2:7,16 3:8 3:21 23:15 51:20 believe 46:6 believed 45:20 bipolar 42:8 black 3:17,18 bonds 33:4 break 21:15 38:17 38:18 bring 51:3 52:1 bringing 51:23 broad 46:18 brought 23:12,22 24:5,16 25:20 26:5 35:24 45:7 49:7 byars 35:16,16 C c 1:5 2:1 3:1 5:1 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 10:1 12:17 33:23 34:6 34:11,16,20 35:1 35:6,11,17 54:5 55:2 called 1:10 12:14 24:22 38:6 39:11 cant 12:1 captioned 39:21 carla 3:5,7 case 3:22,23 19:20 23:12 24:5 36:8 36:17 50:7 cause 20:11 caused 45:7 46:4 cells 42:24 certainly 51:13,17 certified 1:14 55:3 56:9 certify 13:8,15 14:3 14:19 15:20,22 55:5 certifying 51:3 challenged 41:13 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 19 of 107 PageID #:1327 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 58 charges 45:7 chicago 1:16 2:5,10 2:13 3:3,6,9 13:1 13:5,19,22 14:7 14:10,14,15,23 15:5,5,9,14 16:3 16:12,17,23 17:4 17:8,14,24 27:23 28:11,22 29:14,16 30:6,18,23 31:10 31:14 32:5,10 33:12 34:11,16,20 35:1,11,23 37:4 38:4 39:2,7,11 40:2,4,13,21 41:7 41:10 42:11,21 43:10,22 44:9,21 45:19 47:15,19 56:2 chicagos 46:14 citizen 25:4,9 29:5 29:10 31:5,16 37:1 43:24 45:21 46:7,16 citizens 29:21 44:12 city 2:10 3:3,9 11:8 24:21 27:22 28:11 30:6 31:22 34:11 34:15,19,24 35:22 37:4 39:11 40:15 41:10 42:14,21 43:15 44:4,15 46:13 47:2,15,23 50:7 51:6,7 cityofchicago 2:15 3:7 civil 1:11 2:10 3:3 11:5 33:19,19 clifford 2:17 18:13 19:12 26:3 37:23 college 27:16,19 com 3:20 command 28:17 commander 11:4 17:19 20:11 29:15 32:5,10,14 36:23 44:9 46:3 51:9,12 51:15 commands 26:9,15 commencement 55:6 competence 31:21 40:23 42:2,13 43:14 44:3,14 46:24 47:22 competency 40:7 complaint 20:23 22:24 23:16,23 24:11,16 25:4,9 29:5 49:7,12 complaints 29:22 31:5,16 37:1 43:24 complete 12:4 completed 15:8 concerning 55:9 consisting 54:13 constitutes 55:13 contact 20:6,15,16 38:12 continued 11:7 conversations 29:13,20 cooperative 41:17 correct 11:15 13:13 49:17 54:15 counsel 52:4 55:21 55:22 county 55:2 court 1:1 11:22 12:3 13:16 15:24 51:3,4,19,24 52:21 54:1 courts 1:12 cr 3:23 criminal 3:22 current 30:1 currently 13:1 30:9 32:22 D d 2:17 4:1 5:1 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 10:1 12:17 54:21 damages 50:7,9,9 50:19 day 54:20 56:2 decide 48:21 51:19 decided 51:16 decides 51:15 defendant 3:9,21 21:9,21 22:2 23:12 33:22 34:3 34:7,12,16,20 35:2,12,17 defendants 1:7 2:16 22:22 54:7 defenses 22:23 definitely 51:8 degree 28:7 demand 22:23 denying 49:20 department 13:2,5 13:19,22 14:7,11 14:14,24 15:6,10 15:14 16:3,13,18 16:23 17:4,9,14 17:15 18:1 28:23 29:16 30:19,24 31:7,10,15 32:6 32:10 33:12 38:4 39:3,7 40:3,5,13 40:21 41:7,11 42:11 43:10,22,23 44:10,22 45:20 46:14 deponent 15:21 53:3 54:10 deposed 11:11 deposition 1:9 11:4 11:7,15,19 12:8 36:4 51:1,22 54:11,12 55:10,16 55:18 depositions 1:13 detective 16:19 detention 39:21 determine 31:8 determined 44:22 devon 3:13,18 direct 4:3 direction 55:13 directly 55:23 disadvantage 51:18 discharge 43:22 disciplined 29:9 33:11 35:22 37:5 44:10,21 45:7,19 46:4 disciplining 46:14 discovery 11:3,14 discussed 26:2 discussions 36:23 disorder 42:9 district 1:1,1,12 15:23 17:20 18:14 18:19 19:7,14 20:20 25:23 26:14 26:23 41:18 42:20 43:1,6 54:1,1 division 1:2 2:11 3:4 54:2 document 21:11 22:22 23:2,3 39:24 dont 11:16 12:8 15:12 38:16 drugs 43:12 duly 11:2 12:15 54:9 55:8 duties 30:17 32:4 40:12 duty 18:5 12:17 earliest 51:4 eastern 1:2 54:2 ector 34:6 education 28:7 either 15:23 26:3 emotionally 41:13 employed 13:1,18 13:21 14:5 30:9 employee 55:20,22 employment 30:13 enter 19:18 entered 50:20 et 1:6 54:6 evaluation 31:1,8 evans 1:6,9 2:17 3:21,23 4:2 11:4,9 11:10 12:13 21:9 21:19,21 22:2,10 22:20 23:11 24:21 33:23 34:3 35:5 35:17 39:6 40:2 51:1,9,12,15,21 52:15 54:6,9,18 evidence 36:7,16 examination 1:10 4:3 28:23 55:7 examined 12:15 excessive 25:15,22 29:5,10,22 31:18 33:15 37:5 43:24 44:12,24 45:11,21 46:6,16 47:20 excuse 27:3 exhibit 4:9,10,11 4:12,13 21:4,8,20 22:8,17,21 23:8 38:21 39:1,16,20 41:5 explain 11:19 extent 12:24 51:11 E e 2:1,1 3:1,1 4:1,6 F 5:1,1,1 6:1,1,1 7:1 7:1,1 8:1,1,1 9:1,1 f 5:1 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 9:1 10:1,1,1 12:17 10:1 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 20 of 107 PageID #:1328 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 59 facilities 39:21 facility 19:6,14,19 20:5,19 41:20 familiar 38:6 fede 11:5 federal 1:11 2:10 3:3 26:5 fifth 12:22 13:13 14:1,17 15:18,21 16:9,15,21 17:1,6 17:11,17,22 18:3 18:7,11,16,22 19:3,9,16,22 20:3 20:9,14,22 21:2 21:24 22:6,12 23:10,14,20 24:1 24:8,13,20 25:1,6 25:11,18 26:1,7 26:11,18 27:1,15 27:18,21 28:1,5,9 28:13,20 29:3,8 29:12,18,24 30:4 30:8,11,16,21 31:3,12 32:3,8,12 32:17,20,24 33:3 33:6,10,17,21 34:1,5,9,14,18,23 35:4,9,15,20 36:2 36:11,20 37:3,7 37:11,16 38:2,9 38:15 39:9,14 40:18 41:3,9,16 42:5,18,23 43:3,6 43:8,19 44:7,18 45:4,16 46:1,11 46:21 47:5,17 48:2,7,11,16 49:4 49:10,14,19 50:3 50:15,22 51:2,12 51:16 file 23:16 filed 20:24 23:1,16 24:11 25:4,9 31:6 31:17 49:11 final 22:2 financially 50:18 fingerprinted 26:22 41:23 finish 20:18 33:14 37:19 first 11:2 12:14 13:8,18,21 14:5 15:4 21:9,22 22:3 37:14 54:9 fit 31:9 followed 40:4 follows 12:16 force 25:15,22 26:19 29:6,10,22 31:18 33:15 37:5 44:1,12,24 45:12 45:21 46:6,16 47:19,20 foregoing 54:12,15 55:10 form 23:23 31:20 38:6 39:4,5,6,11 39:20 40:7,23 41:21 42:1,12 43:13 44:2,13 47:9,22 48:24 49:23 50:10,12 found 44:11,11,22 45:20 foundation 42:2,13 43:14 44:3,14 47:1,22 franco 25:3,8,13 frequent 43:24 freshman 27:6 fudge 35:6 further 50:24 53:3 furthermore 49:15 G g 2:3,4 general 11:14,17 30:17 39:21 40:3 give 12:1 25:3,12 26:9 30:17 47:14 48:22 given 47:7 48:12 54:16 55:14 glenn 1:6,9 2:17 3:21,23 4:2 12:13 22:10 51:20 54:6 54:9,18 gmail 3:20 go 13:23 16:5 21:12 27:2,4 going 11:19,21 13:7 14:2 15:22 50:8 50:17 51:13,16 52:11,16,23 graduate 27:9,12 27:13,19 28:7 gray 2:18 great 51:18 gross 37:8 guidelines 41:12 gun 37:21 22:18 38:22 39:17 illegal 43:12 illinois 1:1,15,16 2:5,13 3:6,13,19 3:23 48:18 54:1 55:1,4 56:2 illness 42:8 im 11:19 13:7 14:16 21:7 38:24 39:19 47:10 51:2 52:5,6 impact 43:6 incident 23:17 24:6 24:10,17 26:2 inclusive 54:13 income 37:9 indemnify 50:8 independent 24:23 47:8,14 48:19 49:22 indirectly 55:24 individual 2:16 H 19:24 h 4:6 initial 23:16 hall 34:15 injured 41:13 hand 56:2 intend 25:19 52:9 harassing 49:1,24 interested 55:23 harris 2:12,15 16:5 interrogatories 36:6,15 41:21 21:10,22 22:3 42:1,12 43:13 37:14,14 44:2,13 45:1,9,13 interviewed 28:16 45:22 46:8,17,24 intoxicated 43:12 47:9,21 48:24 investigation 37:12 49:23 50:10 51:20 invoke 14:1 15:18 52:3,6,9,23 16:9,15,21 17:1,6 head 12:2 17:11,17,22 18:3 hereto 55:23 18:7,11,16,22 hereunto 56:1 19:3,9,16,22 20:3 hes 51:15,16 20:9,14,22 21:2 high 27:2,4,6,9,13 21:24 22:6,12 43:11 23:10,14,20 24:1 hours 18:5 24:8,13,20 25:1,6 25:11,18 26:1,7 I 26:11,18 27:1,15 identification 21:5 27:18,21 28:1,5,9 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 28:13,20 29:3,8 29:12,18,24 30:4 30:8,11,16,21 31:3,12 32:3,8,12 32:17,20,24 33:3 33:6,10,17,21 34:1,5,9,14,18,23 35:4,9,15,20 36:2 36:11,20 37:3,7 37:11,16 38:2,9 38:15 39:9,14 40:18 41:3,9,16 42:5,18,23 43:3,8 43:19 44:7,18 45:4,16 46:1,11 46:21 47:5,17 48:2,7,11,16 49:4 49:10,14,19 50:3 50:15,22 invoked 51:1 invoking 12:22 13:12 14:17 involved 33:18 involving 41:12 ipra 46:23 issued 40:21 ive 37:19 J j 3:11,12 joins 42:14 43:15 44:4,15 47:2,23 jones 34:6 judgments 33:7 july 13:20 14:12 jumped 37:21 june 23:2 jury 22:23 50:5,20 K k 2:17 55:2 kick 48:8 king 1:3 19:1,12,20 20:1,7,12,16,24 22:10 23:12,17,22 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 21 of 107 PageID #:1329 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 60 24:5,11,16 25:4,9 25:20 26:5,9,14 26:20 37:24 38:13 41:17 48:4,8,14 48:20 49:8 54:3 kings 25:14 48:22 49:12,16 know 18:8 19:24 knowledge 24:22 31:15 46:23 kupearion 3:5,7 31:19 40:6,14,22 42:14 43:15 44:4 44:15 47:2,23 50:11 51:6 20:5,19 25:22 morrissey 2:3,4,4 26:13,22 41:18,19 4:4 11:3,13,18 42:24 43:1 12:1,7,18 13:7,11 lockups 43:5 13:15,17 14:2,4 logan 33:23 34:2 14:19,21 15:19 long 12:24 13:4 16:1,10 17:12 15:16 17:2 21:6,12,18 22:13 longer 48:22 51:10 22:19 23:6 31:23 look 21:11 23:3 36:12,21 38:16,23 39:3,23 39:18 40:8,10,19 looking 41:5 41:4,22 42:6,19 43:20 44:8,19 M 45:5,10,17 46:2 m 1:17 3:17,18 46:12,22 47:6,10 12:17 18:5,5,20 47:12 48:3 49:5 19:18 20:5 50:4,16,23 51:11 L madeleine 3:5 52:1,5,7,15,24 l 2:17 magistrate 15:24 motions 51:23 52:2 lapitan 2:18 march 1:16 N lasalle 1:15 2:12 marked 4:8,10 21:4 3:5 21:7 22:17,21 n 2:1 3:1 4:1 5:1 laura 3:11,12,14 38:21 39:1,16,19 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 lauralaw 3:14 matters 55:9 10:1 12:17,17 law 2:2,9 3:2,11,16 mayor 29:14 name 18:9,18,24 lawsuit 20:24 23:22 mccarthy 29:20 19:24 26:5 34:12,21 36:24 named 34:12 35:1 35:7 mean 15:2 35:12,17 lawsuits 35:21 37:1 medication 12:20 net 2:6 lawyer 52:16 13:10 nod 12:1 level 28:15 31:14 member 14:7,10,13 north 1:15 2:12 3:5 license 56:10 15:5 16:17 28:17 northern 1:1 54:1 lieutenant 17:8,24 30:18 31:9 43:23 notary 54:22 28:22 29:1,15 44:21 45:19 47:19 notice 11:5 30:23,23 31:14 members 40:4,13 november 25:2,8 45:6,18 46:5,15 mischaracterizes 25:13 48:19 49:17 linda 25:3,8 36:7,16 49:20 line 5:2 6:2 7:2 8:2 misher 35:10,10 number 21:8 22:8 9:2 10:2 moment 21:11 39:4 22:21 23:2,4,8 litigation 2:11 3:4 monitoring 41:12 39:1,20 41:6 22:10 33:19,19 month 14:9 O 35:13 monthly 37:8 o 5:1 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 live 27:22 morask 3:11,12 10:1 12:17 55:2,2 lloyd 2:18 23:5 oath 54:10 located 42:21 morning 19:5,11 lockup 19:6,14,19 19:18 20:6 32:15 object 52:10 objection 16:5 31:19,20,21 32:1 36:6,15 40:6,7,14 40:22 41:21 42:1 42:12 43:13 44:2 44:13 45:1,9,13 45:22 46:8,17,24 47:9,21 48:24 49:23 50:10,11 objections 42:15 43:16 obligations 30:18 obtain 15:10 occasion 18:24 occurred 23:18 24:6,17 office 25:7 officer 14:15,23 15:7 16:4,12 18:8 18:13,17,18 19:12 19:13,13 26:3,3,4 28:3,15 30:6 37:23,23 44:23 45:8 46:5,15 officers 35:11 44:10 offices 2:2,9 3:2,11 3:16 okay 37:20 opportunity 21:20 23:7 option 52:20 orally 11:21 order 26:21 39:22 41:6 51:22 orders 40:3,20 org 2:15 3:7,14 outcome 55:24 outline 40:12 outside 21:12 overly 46:17 P p 2:1,1 3:1,1 page 4:1,8 5:2 6:2 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 7:2 8:2 9:2 10:2 22:2 pages 54:13 paid 30:5 park 3:13,19 parties 55:23 party 35:6 patrick 2:4 patrol 14:23 pay 50:18 peggy 1:14 55:3 56:8 people 3:22 period 14:22 15:3,9 15:13,16 16:11,16 17:3 51:5 person 18:24 42:7 44:23 personal 55:13 pertaining 1:12 photographed 26:16,22 41:24 phrase 11:17 physical 20:6,16 36:13 place 54:14 55:17 placed 41:19 plaintiff 1:4,10 2:8 19:19 20:7 54:4 plaintiffs 4:9,10,11 4:12,13 21:3,8,9 21:20,22 22:8,16 22:21,24 23:8 35:24 37:13 38:20 39:1,15,20 41:5 please 12:9 point 17:18 23:22 48:17,21 police 13:2,5,19,22 14:7,10,14,15,23 15:5,6,7,9,14 16:3 16:12,12,17,23 17:4,9,14,14,24 18:8,13,17 19:7 24:23 28:15,22 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 22 of 107 PageID #:1330 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 61 29:16,20 30:2,6 30:18,24 31:6,10 31:14 32:5,10 33:12 35:11 37:17 37:22 38:4 39:2,7 40:2,5,13,21 41:7 41:10 42:11,20 43:10,22,23 44:10 44:21,23 45:8,19 46:4,14,15 47:8 47:14,19 48:19 49:22 policies 43:9 position 15:6 16:2 16:19,22 17:8 26:12 28:22,24 29:15 52:11,13 prejudiced 51:14 prepare 38:11 prepared 22:9 37:23 presence 19:12 present 19:6 previous 55:6 previously 49:7 prior 19:23 28:16 29:21 30:22 31:16 31:18 36:24 37:13 41:23 privilege 13:13 15:22 51:2,9,17 probable 20:11 probationary 15:7 15:9,13 procedure 1:11 11:5 procedures 39:22 40:3,11 41:11 42:9 43:9,21 proceeding 52:19 proceedings 55:15 processing 42:10 43:11 promoted 16:18 17:7 28:14,21 52:10,13 55:14 reduced 55:12 refused 26:14 regards 11:14 13:8 22:7,9 23:17 24:5 24:10,10,17 25:3 25:8,13,20 26:4 29:14,21,22 34:2 37:24 38:12 42:10 43:5 45:11 48:13 48:14,20,22 49:16 50:6,8 relative 55:20,21 relevance 45:1,9,13 45:22 46:8,18 relying 52:20 Q rephrase 12:10 qualify 28:24 40:8 47:11 question 13:8,16 report 38:4,7,12 14:3,20 15:11,20 39:2,12 20:18 23:21 31:20 reported 55:11 33:14 37:19 38:5 reporter 1:14 40:7,9,23 43:4 11:22 12:3 52:21 50:12 55:4 56:9 questions 11:20 reports 37:17,23 12:9 15:23 36:5 represented 24:4 50:24 52:22 requested 21:17 47:13 R required 13:23 r 2:1,17 3:1 5:1 6:1 31:7 7:1 8:1 9:1 10:1 reserve 52:23 12:17 reserving 51:7,8 randall 34:10 respond 23:21 rank 15:10 26:14 read 21:17 54:11 responding 37:13 real 33:1 response 22:24 reason 36:3,13 38:3,7,11 39:2,12 reasonable 26:19 responses 11:23 recall 51:8 52:22 receive 28:6 responsibilities received 28:10 32:9,14 39:22 receives 43:23 40:12 receiving 28:16 result 35:23 record 12:4 21:16 returns 50:6 32:1 39:4 51:7 review 21:20 23:8 30:22 31:13 36:22 promoting 31:18 promotion 28:17 proper 51:23 property 33:1 protective 51:22 provide 31:3 psychological 31:1 31:8 42:8 public 54:22 punitive 50:6,9,19 pursuant 1:11 11:5 put 51:18 52:7 putting 31:24 52:6 52:12 24:23 31:16 37:17 37:22 46:4 47:8 47:15 48:19 49:22 52:19 richardson 34:24 ridge 3:13,19 right 11:18 12:22 14:1,17 15:18 16:9,15,21 17:1,6 17:11,17,22 18:3 18:7,11,16,22 19:3,9,16,22 20:3 20:9,14,22 21:2 21:24 22:6,12,14 22:14 23:4,10,14 23:20 24:1,8,13 24:20 25:1,6,11 25:18 26:1,7,11 26:18 27:1,15,18 27:21 28:1,5,9,13 28:20 29:3,8,12 29:18,24 30:4,8 30:11,16,21 31:3 31:12 32:3,8,12 32:17,20,24 33:3 33:6,10,17,21 34:1,5,9,14,18,23 35:4,9,15,20 36:2 36:11,20 37:3,7 37:11,16 38:2,9 38:15 39:9,14 40:18 41:3,9,16 42:5,18,23 43:3,8 43:19 44:7,18 45:4,16 46:1,11 46:21 47:5,17 48:2,7,11,16 49:4 49:10,14,19 50:3 50:15,22 51:8 52:17,24 rights 2:10 3:3 43:6 rink 28:3 rita 1:3 19:1,20,24 20:7,12,16,24 22:10 23:12,17,22 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 24:5,11,16 25:4,9 25:14,20 26:5,9 26:14,20 37:24 38:12 41:17 48:4 48:8,14,20 49:8 49:12,16 54:3 rodgers 2:17 18:18 19:13 26:4 roller 28:3 room 25:22 rules 1:11 11:14,17 S s 2:1 3:1 4:6 5:1,1 6:1,1 7:1,1 8:1,1 9:1,1 10:1,1 saith 53:3 school 27:2,4,7,9 27:13 screening 41:12 second 21:13 security 28:2 see 18:24 seeking 51:21 seeks 15:21 sergeant 16:23 17:3 28:15 44:20 46:5,15 series 11:20 served 15:14 20:23 23:11 24:2,14,15 set 21:10,22 22:3 37:14 56:1 shes 31:24 short 21:14 38:18 shorthand 1:14 55:4 56:9 showing 21:7 22:20 38:24 39:19 sick 41:13 signature 22:4 simmons 34:19 sir 37:9,20 sit 12:20 13:10 36:4 so60102 39:23 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 23 of 107 PageID #:1331 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 62 sorry 47:10 south 2:5 speak 19:19 special 39:22 specific 15:1 27:5 specifically 39:10 specified 55:17 speculation 42:2,13 43:14 44:3,14 47:1,21 speculative 31:21 spoken 24:9 ss 55:1 staff 28:18 stamped 39:24 started 11:10 state 1:15 3:22 55:1 55:4 stated 55:19 statement 25:3,12 47:7,14 48:13,18 49:16,21 statements 48:22 states 1:1,12 22:22 27:10 54:1 stenographically 55:11 stocks 33:4 stop 12:9 street 1:15 2:12 3:5 43:12 strike 14:6 15:4 24:3 38:5 48:5 subject 29:4 51:22 submit 26:15,21 subscribed 54:19 sudden 51:14 suffering 42:7 suite 1:16 2:13 3:6 superintendent 29:19 30:2 34:10 36:24 sutton 2:17 18:9 19:13 26:3 37:24 sworn 11:2 12:15 14:6,10,13 15:4 16:17 54:10,19 55:8 38:15 39:9,14 40:18 41:3,9,16 42:5,18,23 43:3,8 43:19 44:7,18 T 45:4,16 46:1,11 t 2:17 4:6 5:1,1 6:1 46:21 47:5,17 6:1 7:1,1 8:1,1 48:2,7,11,16 49:4 9:1,1 10:1,1 12:17 49:10,14,19 50:3 12:17 50:15,17,22 55:8 tactical 38:3,7,11 testimony 31:4 39:2,12 36:7,16 54:16 take 11:22 21:11 55:14 23:3 28:23,24 tgmlaw 2:6 38:16 39:3,23 thats 39:6,24 51:19 52:21 52:10,13 taken 1:10,13 11:4 think 22:14 54:13 55:16 thomas 2:3,4 tell 26:19 tiffany 2:12,15 term 47:19 time 12:7 14:22 terminated 30:12 15:3,20 16:11,16 30:13 17:3,18 51:4 testified 12:15 54:14 55:17 testify 12:23 14:1 times 11:8 14:18 15:18 16:9 timothy 3:17,18 16:15,21 17:1,6 timothyblack 3:20 17:11,17,22 18:3 today 12:20 13:10 18:7,11,16,22 36:5,14 19:3,9,16,22 20:3 todays 52:19 20:9,14,22 21:2 training 13:23 21:24 22:6,12 transcribed 52:18 23:10,14,20 24:1 52:18 24:8,13,20 25:1,6 transcript 52:17,19 25:11,18,19 26:1 54:12,15 55:11 26:7,11,18 27:1 trial 25:20 50:18 27:15,18,21 28:1 51:14 28:5,9,13,20 29:3 true 54:15 55:13 29:8,12,18,24 truth 55:8 30:4,8,11,16,21 turn 22:1 31:12 32:3,8,12 two 30:13 32:17,20,24 33:3 twominute 38:17 33:6,10,17,21 twopage 39:5 34:1,5,9,14,18,23 type 12:19 13:9 35:4,9,15,20 36:2 40:20 36:11,14,20 37:3 typewriting 55:12 37:7,11,16 38:2,9 U u 5:1 6:1 7:1 8:1 9:1 10:1 uhhuh 12:2 unable 36:4,14 50:18 undergo 30:24 31:7 understand 11:13 11:16,23 12:5,8 12:10 13:12 15:11 52:10 understanding 47:18 united 1:1,12 27:10 54:1 unknown 35:11 use 29:5 31:17 33:15 37:5 45:11 V vague 16:5 46:17 verbal 26:9,15 verdict 50:6 versus 22:10 33:23 34:2,6,15,19,24 35:5,10,16 verus 34:10 vs 1:5 3:23 54:5 W waive 51:16 want 52:8 watch 17:19 20:11 32:14 west 3:13,18 western 2:5 whereof 56:1 wilfredo 2:18 williams 35:5 witness 4:1 11:1,12 11:16,24 12:6,11 12:14 16:7 36:9 36:18 40:16 41:1 42:3,16 43:17 44:5,16 45:2,14 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 45:23 46:9,19 47:3,24 49:2 50:1 50:13 55:7,7 56:1 work 28:2 working 17:23 18:13,19 written 40:11,20 41:6,11 42:9 X x 4:1,6 12:17 Y y 2:12 year 14:9 27:6 years 30:14 youre 13:9 36:3,14 50:18 Z 0 00 18:5,5 03170 40:1 084003813 56:10 1 1 4:9 6:8 7:17 8:8 21:4,8,20 22:8,13 22:14 10 5:22 6:4 7:10 8:16,21 9:10,12 9:17 17:23 18:20 19:5,10,18 20:5 37:22 48:4,9 10249 2:5 10th 18:4,12,19,23 19:4,11,17,23 20:10,19 23:18 24:6,18 25:15,21 26:8,13,20 32:13 38:10 41:18 11 1:17 5:8 6:11 8:11 9:14 10:18 18:5 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 24 of 107 PageID #:1332 GLENN EVANS March 16, 2015 Page 63 11th 20:4 12 5:3,18 6:20,24 7:4,20 9:7 10:15 1251 4:4 13 1:5 5:4,5,13 7:15 7:24 8:5 9:3 10:8 10:11 35:17 54:5 14 3:23 5:5 6:16 7:11 15 5:6 6:5,12 8:17 10:19 154 54:13 16 1:16 5:6,7,8,9,9 5:10 7:5 8:22 16367 3:23 17 5:11,12,13,14,15 5:19,23 7:21 9:18 10:16,22 1753 35:11 18 5:14,16,17,18,19 5:20 8:6,12 10:6 10:12 19 5:3,21,22,23,24 6:7,21 7:3,6,16 8:18 9:13 1937 1:5 54:5 1986 13:6,20 14:12 48:4,9 2013 23:2 25:2,8,13 48:20 49:17,21 2015 1:16 54:21 56:3 21 4:9 5:4 6:7,13,17 7:12 8:7,23 9:8,24 22 4:11 5:10 6:8,9 7:7,22 8:13 9:4 23 5:15,20,24 6:6 6:10,11,12,13 10:9 2337900 2:6 24 6:14,15,16,17 8:19 9:11,21 25 6:18,19,20,21 26 6:22,23,24 7:3 262 3:19 27 7:4,5,6,7 2769 34:20 28 7:8,9,10,11,12 28th 23:2 29 7:13,14,15,16 299 34:11 3 3 4:11 8:24 9:9 10:7 22:15,17,21 23:4 2 23:8 2 4:10 5:7,11 6:14 30 1:15 2:12 3:5 6:18,22 7:8 8:14 7:17,18,19,20,21 22:15 7:22 18:20 20:5 20 1:17 6:3,4,5,6 23:2 9:15,20 10:4,20 31 7:23,24 19:5,10,18 312 2:14 3:7 2000 34:11,16 3172 40:1 2008 34:20 35:1,6 32 8:3,4,5,6,7 2010 35:11 39:10 33 8:8,9,10,11,12 2011 17:24 18:4,12 8:13 18:19,23 19:4,11 34 8:14,15,16,17,18 19:17,23 20:4,10 8:19 20:19 23:18 24:6 35 8:20,21,22,23 24:18 25:16,21 36 8:24 9:3,4 26:8,13,20 32:13 37 9:5,6,7,8 37:22 38:10 41:19 38 4:12 9:9,10,11 39 4:13 9:12,13 4 4 4:12 5:16,21 6:3 7:13 8:3,9 9:5,22 10:13 38:21 39:1 40 9:14,15 41 9:16,17,18 42 9:19,20,21 43 9:22,23,24 44 10:3,4 45 10:5,6 46 10:7,8 47 10:9,10,11,12 48 10:13,14,15,16 4824 35:1 49 10:17,18,19,20 7447684 2:14 7452837 3:19 773 2:6 7th 25:2,8,13 8 8 5:17 6:23 9:6 10:14 18:5 847 3:14 8816 33:23 9 9 6:15 7:14,19 8:4 9:23 10:3 900 1:16 2:13 3:6 923 35:17 97 33:23 98 34:6 5 5 4:13 7:18,23 8:20 9:16 10:21 39:16 39:20 41:6 50 10:21,22 5490 34:16 5576 34:6 6 6 7:9 8:15 10:5,17 11:5 60068 3:13,19 60602 2:13 3:6 60643 2:5 6919 35:6 6967185 3:14 6th 17:14,20 18:13 18:18 19:6,14 20:20 25:23 26:13 26:23 41:18 42:20 43:1,5 7 7 5:12 6:9,10,19 8:10 9:19 10:10 713 3:13,18 7445106 3:7 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 25 of 107 PageID #:1333 Transcript of the Testimony of GLENN EVANS Date: February 29, 2016 Case: RITA KING VS. GLENN EVANS, ET AL. TOOMEY REPORTING Phone: 312-853-0648 Fax: 312-853-9705 Email: toomeyrep@sbcglobal.net Internet: http://www.toomeyreporting.com/ Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 26 of 107 PageID #:1334 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION RITA KING, Plaintiff, vs. GLENN EVANS, et al., Defendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) No. 13 C 1937 This is the deposition of GLENN EVANS, called by the Plaintiff for examination, taken pursuant to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for the United States District Courts pertaining to the taking of depositions, taken before PEGGY A. ANDERSON, a Certified Shorthand Reporter of the State of Illinois, at 10150 South Western Avenue, Chicago, Illinois, on February 29, 2016 at 1:15 p.m. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 27 of 107 PageID #:1335 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 2 (Pages 2 to 5) Page 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 A P P E A R A N C E S: WITNESS 11 12 13 14 GLENN EVANS 3 4 5 6 Appeared on behalf of the Plaintiff; 15 Appeared on behalf of the individual defendants: Glenn Evans, D.T. Clifford, R.A. Sutton, K.L. Rodgers, Wilfredo Lapitan, and Lloyd Gray. 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. MORRISSEY: MARKED EVANS EXHIBIT NO. 1 EVANS EXHIBIT NO. 2 EVANS EXHIBIT NO. 3 EVANS EXHIBIT NO. 4 EVANS EXHIBIT NO. 5 A P P E A R A N C E S: THE LAW OFFICES OF: CITY OF CHICAGO FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS LITIGATION DIVISION BY: MS. CARLA MADELEINE KUPE-ARION 30 North LaSalle Street Suite 900 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 744-5106 carla.kupearion@cityofchicago.org 3 4 5 6 7 8 Appeared on behalf of the Defendant, City of Chicago; 9 10 11 THE LAW OFFICES OF: QUINTAIROS, PRIETO, WOOD & BOYER, P.A. BY: MR. KENNETH BATTLE MR. ANTHONY L. SCHUMANN 233 South Wacker Drive 70th Floor Chicago, Illinois 60606 (312) 566-0040 kenneth.battle@qpwblaw.com Appeared on behalf of the Defendant, Glenn Evans. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 . PAGE 41 56 62 67 128 ****** Page 3 1 2 5-212 EXHIBITS 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 THE LAW OFFICES OF: CITY OF CHICAGO FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS LITIGATION DIVISION BY: MS. TIFFANY Y. HARRIS 30 North LaSalle Street Suite 900 Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 744-7684 tiffany.harris@cityofchicago.org 16 PAGE 2 7 10 INDEX 1 THE LAW OFFICES OF: THOMAS G. MORRISSEY BY: MR. PATRICK MORRISSEY MR. THOMAS G. MORRISSEY 10150 South Western Avenue Chicago, Illinois 60643 (773) 233-7900 patrickmorrissey1920@gmail.com 8 9 Page 4 Page 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 (WHEREUPON, the witness was first duly sworn.) MR. MORRISSEY: This is the continuation of the deposition of Glenn Evans taken pursuant to the order of the Court. My name is Pat Morrissey. I represent Rita King. WHEREUPON: GLENN EVANS, called as a witness herein, having been first duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows: DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Please state your name for the record? A Glenn Evans. Q Are you currently employed? A Yes. Q Where do you work? A City of Chicago. Q What is your title? A Commander. Q What are you the commander of? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 28 of 107 PageID #:1336 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 3 (Pages 6 to 9) Page 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Police department. Q Do you have an assignment? A Yes. Q Where are you assigned? A Headquarters. Q How long have you been a commander assigned to headquarters? A Since August 2014. Q What are your responsibilities as a commander assigned to headquarters? A Administrative. Q Are you texting your attorney at the moment? MR. BATTLE: Objection. BY THE WITNESS: A We're discussing -MR. BATTLE: That's privileged information. BY THE WITNESS: A -- privileged information. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q I didn't ask what you texted your attorney. I asked you whether you sent your attorney a text? Page 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q But under the rules, you cannot take a break if I have a question pending; is that understood? MR. BATTLE: We'll stipulate. Keep going. BY THE WITNESS: A Yes. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Is that understood? A I'm stipulating to what my attorney stated. Q As a commander assigned to headquarters, what are your responsibilities? A Administrative function. Right now, on leave. Q How long have you been on leave for? A Since August 2014. Q Since August of 2014, do you report periodically to headquarters? A I'm on leave now, but yes, I did. Q What does it mean that you're on leave? A It means I'm not on active duty. Q Are you currently being paid by the Page 7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A No, I didn't send him a text, and it's still privileged information. MR. BATTLE: Let's move on, Pat. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Well, Mr. Evans, I ask that if there's a question pending that you don't communicate with your attorney via telephone, okay? MR. BATTLE: We are not communicating about a question. BY THE WITNESS: A We're not communicating about anything. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, when I ask you questions, I'm going to ask that you answer them orally, okay? A I'm intelligent enough to articulate my response. Q If you want to take a break after I ask a question and you answer it, you can do so, okay? A I'll take a break when I need to, yes. Page 9 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 city of Chicago? A Yes. Q Are you making -- being compensated at the rate of a commander presently? A No. Q What is your compensation currently? A I don't know offhand. Q Do you receive a periodic paycheck from the Chicago Police Department? A Not a paycheck, no. Q Do you receive any form of monetary compensation presently from the city of Chicago? A Yes. Q And is that -- and why do you receive compensation periodically from the city? A You would have to ask them. That's an operational -- that's an operation, not administrative. Q Do you receive a check from payroll from the city of Chicago presently? A A paycheck? Q Correct. A No. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 29 of 107 PageID #:1337 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 4 (Pages 10 to 13) Page 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q When did you stop receiving a paycheck from the city? A Don't recall. Q Was it sometime on or around August of 2014? A Don't recall. Q What did you review in preparation for today's deposition? A Numerous documents and news articles. Q Tell me what documents you reviewed. A Numerous police reports, case reports. Q Tell me exactly which police reports and case reports you reviewed. A I can't tell you exactly. Q Where did you review these documents? A I can't tell you that exactly. Q When did you review these documents? A Intermittently between -- I guess between the inception of this case and now. Q Did you review police reports relating to Rita King? A I'm sorry? Q Did you review police reports Page 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 accurately gauge based on those reports. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Prior to your assignments at headquarters, where were you assigned? A Harrison and Kedzie. Q Where is -- Strike that. Is that a district? A Yes. Q What's the district number? A 11. Q Tell me the months when you were assigned to the 11th District as a commander? A The months I was assigned? Q Correct. A Don't recall directly, maybe between March to August 2014. Q Why were you transferred in August of 2014 to headquarters? A Why was I transferred? Q Correct. A Because the superintendent transferred me there. Q Did you have a conversation with the superintendent why you were transferred to Page 11 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 relating to Rita King? A Some of the reports, yes. Q Did you review your CR files? A Some of the reports, yes. Q Tell me what CR files you reviewed in preparation for today's deposition? A I cannot tell you that. Q What news reports did you review in preparation for today's deposition? A The one that sticks out in my mind is an article from the Daily Beast that your office submitted saying I'm Chicago's dirtiest cop. Outside of that, I don't recall the rest. Q How many CR files are you aware of that you are involved with? A Don't know offhand. Q Is there anything that can refresh your memory about how many times you've been -you've had citizen complaints of misconduct? MR. BATTLE: Throughout his career? MR. MORRISSEY: Correct. BY THE WITNESS: A No, because a lot of those are not correct. So there's no real way I can really Page 13 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 headquarters? A Pretty much, no. Q Were you relieved of your police powers at that point? A Yes. Q Why were you relieved of your police powers? A Because a pending criminal charge. Q What were you charged with? A I was charged with -- I was falsely charged with aggravated battery and official misconduct with a quote on falsely. Q Why do you say you were falsely charged? A Because the allegations were untrue. Q What were the allegations? A The allegations were aggravated battery and official misconduct. Q Do you recall the facts and circumstances surrounding those charges? A There were no facts in that charge. They were all false. Q Well, what were the false factual charges, to your recollection? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 30 of 107 PageID #:1338 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 5 (Pages 14 to 17) Page 14 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A There is no such thing as a false and factual charge. That's an oxymoron. Can you restate that? Q Were you charged with putting a gun down a suspect's throat? A Yes. MR. BATTLE: Objection to relevance. It has nothing to do with this case at all. It has nothing to do with even the Monell claims. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q You can answer the question. MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A Yes. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q And was that suspect's DNA found on your gun? MR. BATTLE: Same objection to relevance. It has nothing to do with this case. It is completely irrelevant. It has nothing to do with the Monell claims at all. Page 16 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 it into my ear like your father is doing into your ear and then I'll object? We'll be here all night. MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. THE WITNESS: That works for me. MR. SCHUMANN: I'm still waiting for the rule. MR. MORRISSEY: It's not my deposition. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q You can answer, Mr. Evans. MR. SCHUMANN: I'm still waiting on the rule. MR. BATTLE: There's no rule that says that, Counsel. Did you know that? THE WITNESS: If there's no rule, am I obligated to answer? MR. BATTLE: You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A Restate the question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was your -- Was the suspect's DNA found on the gun, your gun, that caused -A Based upon the lies -- Page 15 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. SCHUMANN: It's also not calculated to lead to relevant information. MR. MORRISSEY: Let's not -- During this deposition, I would ask that only one attorney for Mr. Evans make the objections, okay? MR. BATTLE: You can ask. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, under the rules, only one attorney should be representing, making speaking objections. MR. SCHUMANN: What rule is that? MS. HARRIS: And just for the record, we represent the other defendants. Every attorney here has a right to make an objection. Ms. Kupe-Arion is here for the city. BY THE WITNESS: A These are all of my attorneys, so I'm going to be taking their advice and their counsel. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm going to ask that only one attorney for Mr. Evans make objections. MR. BATTLE: Do you want him to speak Page 17 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Let me ask the questions. MR. BATTLE: Hold on. Just hold on. THE WITNESS: All right. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, was that suspect's DNA found on the barrel of your gun that caused you to be reassigned from the 11th District to police department headquarters, to your knowledge? A I don't know what kind of evidence they found on there. A lot of it was falsified evidence and contrived evidence. So I couldn't answer that. Q Did you have a conversation with Superintendent McCarthy prior to your reassignment to police department headquarters? A Did I have a conversation with him? Q Correct. A I've had multiple conversations with the superintendent. Q I'm asking specifically when you were transferred from the 11th District to police department headquarters? A I've had multiple conversations with TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 31 of 107 PageID #:1339 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 6 (Pages 18 to 21) Page 18 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 him. Q Regarding why you were transferred? A Why I was transferred from the 3rd District to the 11th District? Q From the 11th District to police department headquarters? A No, he didn't give me a specific -that I can recall, we didn't have a specific conversation regarding that, not that I can recall. Q What did the superintendent tell you about your reassignment? A He said that I was stripped and charged, and I had to go to headquarters; and that's the extent of the conversation that I can recall. Q Who were you reporting to when you went to headquarters as a commander? A Who was I reporting to? Q Correct. A Report to the office of the first deputy. Q And who was the first deputy? A It was Alfonzo Wysinger at the time. Page 20 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A For the police department, no. Q Why not? A Because I was told not to carry a weapon. Q Who told you not to carry a weapon? A That was a written directive by the police department. Q Did the written directive say why you were not allowed to carry a firearm? A Yes, due to the charges that were falsely brought against me. Q The charges were terminated in your favor, correct? A The charges were not terminated. The charges were found -- I was found not guilty on all nine charges. Q Did you request to have the ability -Strike that. Do you presently -- Strike that. Do you presently hold the rank of lieutenant? A That's my career service rank, yes. Q Have you ever had a conversation with Mr. Escalante regarding -- Strike that. How long have you worked for the Page 19 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Mr. Evans, do you presently report to First Deputy Wysinger? MR. BATTLE: Do you understand that question? BY THE WITNESS: A Do I presently report to him? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Correct. A No. Q Who do you presently report to? A I report to the office of the first deputy. Q And who is the first deputy presently? A The office of the first deputy would be Escalante. Q Mr. Evans, have you asked Chief Escalante to be reinstated as a commander? A Not as of yet, no. Q Are you eligible -- Do you have police powers presently? A No. Q Do you have the ability to carry a weapon presently? Page 21 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 police department? A I'm sorry? Q How long have you worked for the Chicago Police Department? A How long have I worked for the Chicago Police Department? Since July of '86. Q When you were the commander of the 11th District, to your knowledge, did any citizens file a complaint against you? A I have not been served with any complaints regarding the 11th District. Q As a commander in the 11th District, did you participate in the Command Channel Review of CR files? MR. BATTLE: Of other police officers? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Correct. A Yes. Q As the commander of the 11th District, tell me your responsibilities as a participant in the Command Channel Review of another officer's CR file. A That's a convoluted question. I TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 32 of 107 PageID #:1340 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 7 (Pages 22 to 25) Page 22 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 can't respond to that. You'll have to simplify it. Q When you were the commander of the 11th District, were you provided any training about how to conduct a Command Channel Review? A Did I provide any training? Q I asked you were provided any training by the city of Chicago Police Department regarding how to conduct a Command Channel Review of another officer's CR file? A Are you saying as a commander of the 11th District, was I provided any training? Q Correct. A As a commander in the 11th District? Q Correct. A No, just as the commander of the 11th District. Q Describe what training you have had regarding a Command Channel Review of another police officer's CR file? A That's a broad question, and I really don't know how to answer that. Q Did you have any formal training where a superior officer told you about how you Page 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 directives relating to how long you as a commander would have to review and make a recommendation on a CR file of another officer? A That's another multifaceted question that I have problems comprehending. Q After you receive a CR file from IPRA, what would you do? A I'd review it. Q And how long would it typically take you to review the CR file? A It depends. Q Would there be a time limit where you would have to make a decision based on your review of a CR file? A I'm going to say that there is a time limit to every report that requires your action. Q After that time period expired, what would you do? A After that time limit expired -- I couldn't answer that because I always completed my -- To my recollection, I always completed my investigations in a timely manner. Q When you were the commander of the Page 23 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 as a commander would participate in a Command Channel Review of another police officer? A You make these convoluted extraneous questions that I cannot articulate because you lump multiple queries into one string-on question; because I cannot answer those, you'll have to condense them in a fashion that I can answer those questions. Q When you were the commander of the 11th District, what would you do if you received a CR file from IPRA where a recommendation for discipline was made? A I would review it. Q Would there be a time period where you would have to complete your review of the sustained CR finding? A There's a time period that you have to -- Generally, there's a time period to everything that comes across your desk. Q As a commander, how much time would IPRA provide you to review a CR that they deemed a sustained finding? A IPRA doesn't issue me directives. Q Does the city of Chicago issue you Page 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 11th District, on average per month, how many CR files would you review? A I couldn't tell you that. It varies. Q Can you give me a range? A No. Q What were your responsibilities as a commander in the 11th District? A Ensure, manage police, public safety and police responses to a geographic area. Q Prior to working in the 11th District, where were you assigned? A Prior to working in the 111th district? Q Correct. A The 3rd District. Q Where is the 3rd District? A Physically? Q Correct. A 7100 South Cottage Grove -- 7030 South Cottage Grove -- or 7040 South Cottage Grove. Q How long were you the commander of the 3rd District? A I was the commander of the 3rd TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 33 of 107 PageID #:1341 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 8 (Pages 26 to 29) Page 26 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 District from August, I believe, 2012 to -- I don't really recall. I think March of 2014. That's just a guesstimate like most of my responses are, so don't hold me to those. Q You understand you're under oath today, correct? A That's exactly why -- which is why I'm not going to lie. I'm going to tell you the truth as I recall. Q What were your responsibilities as commander in the 3rd District? A The same as they were for the 11th District. Q And when you were commander of the 3rd District, did you participate in the Command Channel Review? A Did I participate in the Command Channel Review? Q Of CR files, yes. A Yes. Q Prior to your assignment in the 3rd District, what was your position? A Prior to my assignment to the 3rd District? Page 28 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q When were you interviewed by the superintendent? A Sir, I don't recall. Q Where did the interview occur? MR. BATTLE: You said where? MR. MORRISSEY: Yeah. BY THE WITNESS: A I think it was in his office. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q And who was the superintendent? A That would be Superintendent McCarthy. Q Who was present during this conversation with you and Superintendent McCarthy? A Who was present in that office? I don't know. People were walking in and out of that office, so I couldn't tell you who was in there during the entire duration of the interview. Q Other than you and Superintendent McCarthy, can you tell me anybody else who was present during this conversation? A I don't remember at this point. Page 27 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Correct. A I was a lieutenant in the 6th District. Q Tell me time periods when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District? A Roughly, and don't hold me to this because my memory isn't what it used to be, I'm going to say from maybe May, June 2006 to approximately August 2012. Q Did you request to be promoted to commander? A Did I request a promotion to commander? Q Correct. A Not that I recall. Q Do you know if a commanding officer recommended you, the superintendent's office, to be commander? A To be honest, I don't know how that process went. Q Were you interviewed prior to your promotion to commander by the superintendent of police? A Yes. Page 29 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Do you recall what was discussed during this interview? A I have very, very, very, very vague recollections. Q Tell me about what you do remember. A He asked me about the command position, would I be willing to take it and I think he gave me a brief overview of what his expectations were. Q What were his expectations? A Manage the district, address crime conditions and manage the district. Q Did you have a conversation with Superintendent McCarthy regarding the number of times you have been complained about by other citizens for using excessive force? A No, I don't recall having any conversations. It possibly could have happened, but I don't recall. I'm not going to say yes or no. I just don't recall at this point. Q Is there anything that could refresh your memory whether you had a conversation with Superintendent McCarthy about allegations by TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 34 of 107 PageID #:1342 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 9 (Pages 30 to 33) Page 30 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 other citizens that you used excessive force? A A transcript of our conversation or tape recording or a videotape recorder. Q Do you know whether the conversation was recorded? A I don't know. I doubt it. I don't recall. I don't know what goes on in his office. I don't know anything he's got, if anything. Q And this conversation would have occurred before August of 2012? A Yes. Q Do you know whether it was the summertime in 2012 when this conversation occurred? A Was it the summertime in 2012? Q Correct. A I don't recall when the conversation was. Q How long after this conversation were you promoted to commander? A I don't recall. I don't recall the timeframe. Q When you had this conversation with Page 32 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Is that an acronym you use in the police department? A Yes. Q What is that referred to as? A Within the Chicago Police Department, it would be the Internal Affairs Division. Q Do you know who presently is the commander of IAD? A There's a commander of IAD. Do I know presently who is commander of IAD? Q Correct. A There's two commanders in IAD. Q Tell me who the commanders are. A One is Robert Klinus (phonetic). The other is Brendan Deenihan. Q Do you know whether IAD conducts reviews of officers' CR files? A I have never been assigned to IAD, so I cannot advise you as to their protocols. Q I'm not asking what the protocol is. I'm asking, to your knowledge, do you know whether IAD reviews CR files? MR. BATTLE: That's exactly what you're asking him. Page 31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Superintendent McCarthy regarding a promotion, had you been named as a defendant in lawsuits arising from your work as a police officer? A Had I been named prior to the conversation with McCarthy? Q Correct. A Yes. Q All right, how many times were you named as a defendant? A I don't recall. Q More than one? A I don't recall, possibly. Q Is there anything that would refresh your memory about how many times you had been named as a defendant prior to this conversation you had with Superintendent McCarthy? A If the documentation is correct, it would but there's a lot of erroneous documentation out there. So I can't answer yes or no to that. Q Do you know whether IAD -- I'll rephrase. What is IAD? A That depends on what context you're talking in. Those are acronyms. Page 33 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A I'm going to stand by my previous response. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Well, you can state it again. A Well, I'm going to stand by my previous response. I was never assigned to IAD, and I cannot tell you what their protocol is. Q Prior to your promotion to commander, do you know whether IAD ever conducted any investigation into you? A That's a broad question. I don't know what you mean, did they conduct any investigation. It depends. Q Regarding allegations of misconduct by you. A Prior to my promotion, yes. Q Tell me about the circumstances where you're aware that IAD conducted an investigation on you? A I cannot tell you about any particular circumstances because I don't have a recollection of all of them. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 35 of 107 PageID #:1343 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 10 (Pages 34 to 37) Page 34 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q How were you made aware when IAD investigated you for allegations of misconduct? A They would request an interview or they'd request that I submit a report. Q Do you know whether IAD ever recommended disciplinary charges against you? A Within what timeframe? Q During your entire time with the police department? A Yes, probably. Q Do you know how many times? A No, I don't. Q Do you know what type of discipline IAD -A No, I don't recall. Q Let me ask the question, Mr. Evans. MR. BATTLE: Hold on one second. You don't have to raise your voice, Counsel. THE WITNESS: Yeah, you're real disrespectful. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know what discipline IAD recommended for you? A It varied. Page 36 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Prior to me saying that, were you aware that IPRA conducted an investigation -had an open investigation regarding Rita King? A Yes. I know they had an open investigation. Q How do you know? A You just said it. Q Prior to me saying it, were you aware that Rita King caused IPRA to open an investigation based on allegations of misconduct by you? A I don't know if Rita King caused it because sometimes attorneys and other personnel will encourage her. So I don't know what Rita King caused. Q Are you aware that IPRA recommended that you be suspended 15 days? MR. BATTLE: Objection, asked and answered. Are we going to go over every question twice? BY THE WITNESS: A I'm going to stand by my last response. Page 35 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Tell me what it varied on. A It depends. Same type of discipline they recommend for everybody. It can go from no violation noted to discharge. Q To your knowledge, did IAD ever recommend that you be suspended? A Yes, probably. Q How many times? A I can't tell you. Q Do you recall why they recommended you be suspended? A Once again, you're asking me to make a determination about the policy and practices of IAD, which I am not equipped to make. Q Are you aware that there's an open IPRA file based on allegations that you used excessive force on Rita King? A Yes. Q Are you aware that originally they recommended that you be suspended 15 days? A No, I didn't know that. Q How did you become aware that IPRA has an open investigation on you? A You just said it. Page 37 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Can you answer the question? A I'm going to go by my last response. I answered your question. Q Unless your attorney advises you not to -MR. BATTLE: He just answered your question, Counsel. You may not like the answer, but he just answered your question. MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: Please don't raise your voice. MR. BATTLE: Counsel -MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: Please don't raise your voice. MR. BATTLE: Your attorney just indicated that this is going to be me and him. So if he's going to be the one representing Rita King, then I'm going to be the one representing Glenn Evans. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, then I ask -MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: I'm an attorney of -MR. BATTLE: And when I asked him not to raise his voice, he continued to raise TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 36 of 107 PageID #:1344 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 11 (Pages 38 to 41) Page 38 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 his. So I'm going to continue to raise mine. Now, we can all quiet down together. THE WITNESS: And I'm going to follow the advice of my counsel. MR. BATTLE: Hold on. I'm sorry? MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: I'm going to ask you not to raise your voice in my office. MR. BATTLE: And I don't mind you being involved with respect to this deposition. Similarly, your co-counsel shouldn't mind my co-counsel being involved. Now, we're going all be involved or we're not. He can speak for himself and tell me not to raise my voice. MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: I'm just raising an objection to your conduct in raising your voice and screaming at my co-counsel. MR. BATTLE: And for the record -MR. THOMAS MORRISSEY: I'm not intervening in the question of Mr. Evans at all. MR. BATTLE: Fair enough. Your Page 40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, are you aware that during the Command Channel Review, the recommendation from IPRA about your 15-day suspension was sent back to IPRA? A No, I don't. Q Do you know the status of the IPRA investigation relating to allegations of misconduct by you to Ms. King? A No. Q Before we got into this discussion, I was asking you about times when you've been suspended by the police department. Do you remember me asking those questions? A Yes. Q And I believe you said you didn't recall how many times you had been suspended as a member of the police department? A That's correct. Q If I show you some CR files, would that refresh your memory about the circumstances and the number of times you have been suspended by the police department? A Well, seeing how a lot of them are Page 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 objection is duly noted. So hopefully we won't mind if my co-counsel has an opportunity to object as well. MR. MORRISSEY: That's not how this is going to go. I'm going to continue asking the questions. You can continue making the objections. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, are you aware that -MR. BATTLE: I do want to make one thing for the record, Counsel. When he answers your question, if he says that I stand by my previous response to your question, I think that's a fair answer to your question. You may not like it, but I think that's fair and I think he has a right to do that. MR. MORRISSEY: Well, the objection would be asked and answered. Typically the deponent answers again. MR. BATTLE: He says I stand by my last answer. I think that's a fair answer. MR. MORRISSEY: All right. MR. BATTLE: Okay, go ahead. Page 41 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 incorrect and erroneous, they might not. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we mark this as Exhibit 1. (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 1 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, I'm showing you what's been marked as Exhibit 1, which is a CR file. It's a sustained CR file. Why don't you take a moment to look at this. Let me know when you are ready to answer questions about it. MR. BATTLE: Do you want him to take a look at the whole thing? MR. MORRISSEY: Sure. THE WITNESS: Yeah, I'll look at the whole thing (indicating). MR. BATTLE: Answer his question first, and then we can take a break if we need to. THE WITNESS: Okay. MR. BATTLE: Counsel, do you have general questions or something specific to a page? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 37 of 107 PageID #:1345 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 12 (Pages 42 to 45) Page 42 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: Well, do you want me to start asking the questions? MR. BATTLE: Okay, go ahead. He's going to ask you a question. THE WITNESS: Okay, I'm going to take notes first. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, prior to today, did you have an opportunity to review this CR file? A Not in its entirety. Q Which portions of the CR file have you reviewed? A Vaguely the front page. Let me see, a partially blurred out front page from the 18th of January, second page from 18 January, which is partially blurred out, another partially blurred out page, that would be page 3, another partially blurred out page I would think would be page 4, another partially blurred out page, which is page, I don't know, 7 but it's got Attachment 31, another blurred out page which is another Attachment 31. It looks like each one of these pages have partially obliterated print or blurred out. So Page 44 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 just make sure we get an understanding. You and I are going to do the objecting? MR. MORRISSEY: Correct. MR. BATTLE: Are you sure? MR. MORRISSEY: I don't have to repeat myself. I said yes. MR. BATTLE: You ask him to repeat himself all the time, Counsel. I'm just making sure. With respect to the objection, what we are objecting to is just the age of this report. It's irrelevant. It's 22 years old when the actions took place, and it's wholly and completely not calculated to lead to anything discoverable. It's just an abuse of the discovery process basically. MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Does this Exhibit 1 reflect that you were originally recommended a 30-day suspension without options? MR. BATTLE: Same objection. Also, the report speaks for itself. Page 43 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 it's hard for me to really decipher as to the entire contents of this report. Q When did you review these documents? A Just now. Q Prior to coming here today, have you seen this document? A No, I haven't. Q From looking at this Exhibit 1, does it reflect that you -- IPRA originally recommended that you be provided a 30-day suspension without options? MR. SCHUMANN: I'm going to object. MR. MORRISSEY: We already agreed to have one attorney for Mr. Evans make the objections. MR. BATTLE: Excuse me. No, we didn't agree on that, and I think you're -Never mind. Hold on a second. BY THE WITNESS: A I cannot read and I cannot decipher this, so I cannot respond. MR. SCHUMANN: Glenn. THE WITNESS: I'm sorry. MR. BATTLE: So moving forward, let's Page 45 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A From what I can decipher, and that's not much, I can see -- I can barely see -- I could see 30 days and I can't see much else on this. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Well, after 30 days bold without options; do you see that on the second page? A No. Okay, on the second page I see that. Q What does that mean "without options," to your understanding? A That means that you don't have any options to use discretionary time. You just have to take the whole suspension. Q Do you recall in January of '95 being recommended to have a suspension for 30 days without options? A Based on that report, yes. Q What caused you to be suspended for 30 days? A IPRA's incompetence and OPS' incompetence. Q Can you elaborate more? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 38 of 107 PageID #:1346 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 13 (Pages 46 to 49) Page 46 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A They made a mistake investigating that case. They made a bunch of errors investigating that case. In fact, to my recollection, I'm going to say that the investigator in this case was subsequently terminated for child molestation, and I cannot determine -- I cannot decipher a lot of this but a lot of this is incorrect. A lot of this is erroneous and let me see. They even got my name misspelled on one page. So a lot of this is rife with errors and whatcha call it. Q You don't have to give me back the exhibit. A Okay. Q Why don't we go to the fourth page of Exhibit 1, which is a Summary Report and the Subject, Complaint Register Investigation Number is 211641, and above that number, it says Sustained; do you see that? A Yes. Q And there's an allegation at the bottom of the page, and your name is in the middle of the page as the accused officer; do you see that? Page 48 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A I vaguely remember. There's some parts of this I remember, and that's because how bad the investigation was and the investigator. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q What do you recall about these allegations? A That due to all of the -- due to the errors and the issues with the investigator that they had knocked this down from a 30 to 15-day suspension. Q Do you recall the allegations from Mr. Williams on August 27th, 1994? A Do I recall them? Q Correct. A You mean prior to getting here? Q I'm asking you whether you have any recollection of August 27th, 1994 and the allegation Mr. Williams has against you? A Do I have any recollection -- any independent recollection outside of this document? Q Sure. Page 47 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Yes. Q And under the allegation box, it talks about Mr. Williams' alleged that on 27 August '94, you physically abused him by striking him about his body, struck him on his head with a gun, kicked and punched him and maced him. It is further alleged that Officer Evans pointed a gun at two subjects telling them to, quote, get the fuck back or I will kill you; do you see that? A Yes. Q Do you recall those allegations being made against you in 1994? MR. BATTLE: I'm just going to make the same running objection to the relevancy of these documents. They're stale. They're old. They're more than 20 years old. They have nothing to do with the Monell claims, the underlying claim that Rita King has against Mr. Evans, which we haven't gotten to as of yet. And I think it's wholly an abuse of the discovery process. You can answer, if you remember. Page 49 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A No, just which I see here. Q It seems like you do have some independent recollection about how poor the investigation was by OPS, correct? A I can look at it and recall how bad it is. Q Other than the actual report, which a portion of it is in front of you, do you have any other recollection about how poor this investigation or investigator was? A Not that I can recall but not at this time, but I do recall how bad this investigation was. Q How do you know the investigator was charged with child molestation? A It was in the paper. Q And who was the OPS investigator? A According to this, it was William O'Neil. Q In your experience as a member of the police department, did OPS conduct poor investigations routinely? A Yes. Q Tell me why you base that -- you have TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 39 of 107 PageID #:1347 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 14 (Pages 50 to 53) Page 50 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 that opinion? A I have the opinion like I have anything else, predicated on experience and observation. It doesn't necessarily mean my assessment is correct. That's just my opinion. Q Have you talked with other members of the police department about how poor OPS was at investigating allegations of misconduct? A You mean specifically or generally or what do you mean? Q Well, let's talk about generally. Have you had general conversations with other members of the department about how poor OPS was at conducting investigations? A Yes. Q Who did you talk with? A I don't recall, thousands of them. Q When you say thousands of them -A Thousands of officers that I have encountered over my career. We've had talks about it. Q OPS evolved into IPRA, correct? A If you want to call it evolving, yes. Q Would you agree that it transformed Page 52 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Why do you say they had a lot of problematic investigations? A Just based on the volume of the -based on the investigations and the limited knowledge and the limited information I have regarding quite a few investigations, and I mean a limited, a cursory knowledge of what I have, I think that OPS, just like any other agency, has room for improvement. Q Did you talk to other members of the department about how you thought IPRA had a lot of problems with investigating police officers? A Did I talk to any member of who? Q The police department regarding your view that IPRA, at times, would conduct lousy investigations? MR. BATTLE: Regarding his personal opinion? BY THE WITNESS: A Informally, regarding my personal opinion, informally, I have done that, yes. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did you ever talk with people from the 6th District about how lousy IPRA was with Page 51 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 into IPRA? A I mean, it was operationally changed in IPRA. I don't know what you mean by evolved and transformed, but it was an operational change to my recollection. Q To your knowledge, was IPRA an improvement from OPS? A I am not in a position to make that determination if it was an improvement or not. Q Do you have an opinion that IPRA conducted poor investigations of police officers for allegations of misconduct? MR. BATTLE: Police officers in general or him? MR. MORRISSEY: Police officers in general. BY THE WITNESS: A Do I have an opinion? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Correct. A I have an opinion that they have problematic investigations. They have some good ones, and they have a lot of problematic ones, just like anything else. Page 53 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 conducting investigations? A That's a big broad question. I can't answer that. Q Is there anything that would refresh your memory whether you had conversations with people from the 6th District regarding the incompetence of IPRA at times? A Tape-recorded or documented reports? Q I'm not talking about tape-recorded. I'm asking whether you -A I know what you're not talking about. Despite my gender, I am quite intelligent. Not my gender, I'm sorry, my race. I am quite intelligent. I know that you might have a problem with that, but I am and my response is I cannot recall making any comment to the 6th District personnel regarding these investigations as we sit here. Q When you worked in the 6th District, did you have the opinion that IPRA at times conducted lousy investigations of police officers? A What do you mean did I have the opinion? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 40 of 107 PageID #:1348 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 15 (Pages 54 to 57) Page 54 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Well, you said that, at times, IPRA had a lot of problems with investigating police officers, correct? A I said IPRA has operational challenges and a lot of problems. Investigations -- a lot of their problems -Investigations were problematic. Just like any other profession, you have got some real good ones, and they've got some real bad ones, just like any other profession. Q Getting back to the CR that's marked as Exhibit 1, do you recall the suspension being reduced from 30 days to 15? A Yes. Q Why was it reduced? A Because of the problems inherent in this investigation. Q Did you agree to a 15-day suspension? A Did I agree to it? Q Correct. A That was pretty much out of my hands. They told me that was the way it was going to go. Q Did you have an attorney represent Page 56 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Prior to this CR, tell me the other times when you were suspended as a member of the department? A I don't recall. Q Do you recall being suspended on multiple times in early 1990? A No. It's possible but I don't recall. MR. MORRISSEY: I have a document which is marked FCRL 5848 all the way up to 5852 and it's from April of '92. I'm going to mark it as Exhibit 2. (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 2 was marked for identification.) MR. BATTLE: Are you planning on asking questions about this? MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. MR. BATTLE: All right, I'll just make a running objection to this exhibit and any questions about it as being almost 24 years old, stale, irrelevant, has no bearing on this case, the underlying claims against Glenn Evans from Rita King or the Page 55 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 you during this CR investigation? A I believe I had union representation. I don't recall an attorney. Q Did you have the ability to appeal the 15-day suspension to the police board? MR. BATTLE: Do you understand the question? BY THE WITNESS: A I don't believe that -- I don't recall having that option at that time. You're talking about 20-something years ago. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was this the first time you were suspended from the police department? A No. Q Was this the last time you were suspended from the police department? A No. Q And from looking at the first page of Exhibit 1, does it reflect that the suspension occurred around March of 1995? A No. Q When were you suspended? A I don't recall. Page 57 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 underlying Monell claims. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Sir, do you see this document marked Exhibit 2, which the first page looks like an IAD April 8, '92 memo? A I see a document that's partially obscured. My name and the contents and the text are partially obscured on the first page, and the bottom paragraph I guess that's -- my name is partially obscured. My star is partially obscured. The violations are partially obscured. The word suspended is partially obscured, and that's on the first page. Q All right. What is Rule 6? A I don't know. I would have to review the rules. Q Do you know whether there is a Chicago Police Department Rule 6? A Do I know that one exists? Q Yes. A Possibly. Q Do you know what it is? A Once again, I'm going to say I'll TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 41 of 107 PageID #:1349 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 16 (Pages 58 to 61) Page 58 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 have to review it. Q Why don't we look at the fourth page where it says there's an Allegation Number 1 sustained against you when you were in the 6th District for violation of Rule 6; do you see that? MR. BATTLE: Where exactly are you pointing? MR. MORRISSEY: Under the Findings. BY THE WITNESS: A Once again, it's partially blocked out and everything is hard to read. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you see where it says 04 June, 1991? MR. BATTLE: Do you see it? THE WITNESS: See how mine is all blanked out and everything. MR. BATTLE: Counsel, his copy is not a good copy. MR. MORRISSEY: I believe the city Bates stamped them and watermarked -MR. BATTLE: My copy is actually better than his copy is what I'm saying to Page 60 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 entire context of this suspension. It's possible. Q Do you know whether this was the first time you were suspended as a member of the police department? A I don't recall. Don't remember, don't recall. Q So far, we have talked about Exhibit 1, which was the 15-day suspension, and Exhibit 2 which reflects a two-day suspension. Do you recall any other suspensions as a member of the police department? A Do I recall them offhand? Q Correct. A No, but I see some reports that can refresh my recollection. MR. BATTLE: Are you finished with this one? MR. MORRISSEY: Sure. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall an incident from May of 1992 where you were alleged to have failed to follow proper police department procedures involving the handling and inventorying of Page 59 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 you. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't you look -MR. BATTLE: Do you want him to look at my copy? MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. MR. BATTLE: Do you want to re-ask your question just so we have got something on the record? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q In the Finding section, it says that you violated Rule 6 because you failed to appear to testify; do you see that? A Yes. Q And it has a date of 04 June 1991; do you see that? A Yeah, that's approximately, what, that's almost 20, 25 years ago. I see it. Q And it reports that you were suspended for two days, correct? A Yes. Q Do you remember being suspended as a result of failing to appear in court in June of 1991? A It's possible, but I don't recall the Page 61 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 property recovered at the scene of a homicide? MR. BATTLE: Objection, irrelevant and not reasonably calculated to lead to discoverable evidence. It's stale and has no burying on this case at all or the underlying allegations Ms. King has against Mr. Evans or the Monell claims against the city of Chicago. BY THE WITNESS: A No. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Have you ever been disciplined for using profanity as a member of the police department? MR. BATTLE: Ever? BY THE WITNESS: A You mean ever? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Yeah. A It's possible. Q Do you recall ever being disciplined for using profanity? A I don't recall but it's possible. Q Do you know what Department Rule 8 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 42 of 107 PageID #:1350 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 17 (Pages 62 to 65) Page 62 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 is? A No, not offhand. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we mark this Exhibit 3. (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 3 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q I'm showing you what's marked Exhibit 3, which is a CR that dates to -- or a Suspension Notification is the first page from 16 October 1992? MR. BATTLE: Counsel, I will just make a running objection now with respect to relevance. The questions you may ask are not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. This is discovery abuse, harassing in nature and none of this information will be admitted at trial. Go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A I can recall this incident now that I read it. Now that I can read it and I have a very clear copy for once, I can recall this. Page 64 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q And you recall that being the allegation that you said to this court clerk, correct? A Based on the report that you gave me, yes. Q And did you have an attorney when you had these allegations against you? A Not that I can recall. I doubt it. Q Were you entitled to an attorney under your police union rules? A Entitled to representation. Q Do you know whether you had representation? A I don't recall if I had representation or not. Q And based on these allegations, you were suspended for one day? A Let me see. Yes. Give me a minute. Q Sir, are you currently married? A Am I currently married? Q Correct. A No. Q Have you been married before? A Yes. Page 63 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q It says that there was an incident on 16 March 1992; is that right? A That's correct. Q What happened that day relating to this CR? A What happened that day? Well, I went to court, and I was alleged to have used foul language; and it was an allegation brought against me. Q Do you know who brought that allegation against you? A Do I know her personally? Q Do you know who made the allegation that you used profanity? A It was a court clerk. Q Do you personally know this individual? A No. Q And there's an allegation that you said, quote, this is bullshit. This case has been going on for two fucking years. I'm sick of it, correct? A Okay. Page 65 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q How many times have you been married? A Once. Q Do you know whether your ex-wife or your estranged wife caused a CR to initiate against you? MR. BATTLE: Objection. BY THE WITNESS: A Do I recall? BY MR. MORRISSEY: A Correct. MR. BATTLE: There's so many objections here. Let me start with that being irrelevant, marital privilege and for safety concerns. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm not asking what the conversation was. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q I'm asking do you know whether there was a CR initiated by your estranged wife? A I don't have an estranged wife. Q Well, at the time. A What do you mean "at the time"? Q At one time, you were married, correct? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 43 of 107 PageID #:1351 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 18 (Pages 66 to 69) Page 66 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Yes. Q And at the time, you were a member of the police department, correct? A Yes. Q Were you ever notified that your wife at the time initiated a CR with the Chicago Police Department relating to allegations of misconduct by you? A Was I ever notified? Q Correct. A Yeah, probably. Q Were you notified what the allegations were by that woman? A I don't recall. Q How were you notified? A I don't recall that either. Q Do you know whether you had representation with this CR? A I don't remember. MR. BATTLE: What do you mean by "representation"? MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we mark this as Exhibit 4. Page 68 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. BATTLE: Do you want to switch with the ones you gave me? MR. MORRISSEY: Sure, why don't we do that. MR. BATTLE: I'm going to hold onto the actual one and remind me to give it to you. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we switch the marking, too. MR. BATTLE: What do you mean by "switch the marking"? Mark that one Number 4? MR. MORRISSEY: Right. (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 4 was remarked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, do you recall that around June of 1993, a CR was initiated based on allegations that you threatened to come to Detroit to kill Deliliah Evans? A Do I recall this information? Q Correct. A No, I don't recall it. I just recall Page 67 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 4 was marked for identification.) MR. BATTLE: When you say "representation," are you speaking of legal representation? MR. MORRISSEY: Or union representation. MR. BATTLE: Right, you should clarify just in case. THE WITNESS: Yeah, because I keep getting confused because he keeps commingling legal and union. I get confused. I'm not that bright. MR. BATTLE: See how that copy looks? BY THE WITNESS: A Once again, the copy that I received, Exhibit Number 4, is partially obscured, page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, all 8 pages are obscured. I can barely make them out. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Well, part of the reason why it's somewhat difficult to read is because the City watermarked it confidential. Page 69 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 this -- from what I see on this document. Q Were you ever contacted by the police department in the summer of 1993 regarding allegations that you threatened Deliliah Evans? A Was I contacted by the police department? That's a broad question. Q What was your assignment in August of 1993 with the police department? A Let me see. I was, according to this report, and none and these reports have -- are rife with errors. A lot of these reports are erroneous and rife with errors; but according to this report, I was assigned to the 3rd District. Q Who was your commanding officer during that time? A There is no commanding officer in the district. There was a commander and there was a watch commander and then there's a lieutenant as an acting commander -- an acting watch commander rather. There is no commanding officer. Q Do you remember who your commander was? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 44 of 107 PageID #:1352 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 19 (Pages 70 to 73) Page 70 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A The commander at that time I'm going to say was Hubert Holton. THE REPORTER: Hubert Holton? THE WITNESS: Holton, H-o-l-t-o-n. BY THE WITNESS: A And that's to the best of my recollection. I'm not going to take a perjury because I misspoke. I'm just giving the information that's the best I can recall. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall having a conversation with Commander Holton around the summer of 1993 regarding allegations made by Deliliah Evans? A No. Q Who is Deliliah Evans? A I'm going to assert my rights under the Marital Privilege Act, and I'm not going to answer that under advice of my counsel. Q Is Delilah Evans your ex-wife? A I'm going to assert my privileges under marital privileges, and I'm going to abide by counsel. MR. MORRISSEY: I don't believe it's a valid privilege. Page 72 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When was your divorce finalized? A I don't remember. Q Why don't we look to the sixth page of Exhibit 4 which appears to be a statement that you gave to OPS in August of '93. If you want to go back to page 6630, I believe that's the start of the statement. In looking at that page, does it reflect that you gave a statement on August 19, 1993 to an investigator from OPS? A Yes. Q The second page of the statement, your first answer reflects that your statement to OPS is not being given voluntarily but under duress; do you see that? A According to this document, yes. Q Why do you make that statement that you're not giving the statement voluntarily to OPS? A Standard -- a standard statement that was given when -- that's the standard statement given when we give queries to internal affairs or IAD. It's just a standardized response. Page 71 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A Well, I can't help what you believe or disbelieve. MR. BATTLE: He's talking to me. THE WITNESS: I'm sorry. MR. BATTLE: What's the objection, Counsel? MR. MORRISSEY: I don't believe there is a privilege about whether this individual -- It's not a communication. It's -- The question is whether Delilah Evans is the former wife of the deponent. I believe that would be public information. MR. BATTLE: I believe you're right. It would be public information. So why are we arguing about it? MR. MORRISSEY: Well, because I think it's improper for the deponent to invoke a privilege. (WHEREUPON, the witness and his counsel had a discussion off the record.) BY THE WITNESS: A Okay, yes. Page 73 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Did anybody tell you to give that standardized response? A Did anybody tell me? That's a standardized response. Nobody had to tell me. Q Were you telling the truth when you gave the statement? A I tell the truth on all sworn statements. Each and every one. Q Are you aware that the Chicago Police Department is currently under an investigation by the Justice Department? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. MR. BATTLE: I'll join. MS. HARRIS: Join. BY THE WITNESS: A Could you be more specific? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Yeah. Are you familiar with the United States Department of Justice? A Yes. Q Are you aware that, at times, they investigate police departments or law enforcement agencies? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 45 of 107 PageID #:1353 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 20 (Pages 74 to 77) Page 74 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A And attorneys too, yes. Q Are you aware that the Department of Justice is currently conducting an investigation into the Chicago Police Department? MS. KUPE-ARION: I renew my objection to relevance. MR. BATTLE: I join. It's not reasonably calculated to lead to discoverable evidence. Lack of foundation, so on so forth. MS. HARRIS: Join. THE WITNESS: Respond? MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. You can respond, if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A The information I got is from the media, which is rife with misstatements, lies, innuendos, exaggerations. So if you're asking me that predicated on information you got from the media, I don't trust any the responses of the media, especially the Daily Beast. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Have you been contacted by any Page 76 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 lieutenant in the 6th District, where were you assigned in the police department? MR. BATTLE: You said before the 6th District? MR. MORRISSEY: Yeah. BY THE WITNESS: A Assigned to the 5th District. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q In what capacity? A As a sergeant. Q Did you take an exam to be promoted to lieutenant? A Yes. Q Was it a written exam? A Yes. Q Did you pass the written exam? A Yes. Q In addition to being promoted by taking a test, is there another way to be promoted from a sergeant to a lieutenant, to your knowledge? A You have to take a written exam to get promoted to be promoted from sergeant to lieutenant and from PO to lieutenant -- I mean, Page 75 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 investigator from the Department of Justice to give a statement? A No. MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the scope of that question and relevance as well. BY THE WITNESS: A I mean -MR. BATTLE: No, he didn't ask anything else. MS. HARRIS: Join. MS. KUPE-ARION: I can't instruct your client, but I don't think that would be proper to ask him anything regarding his pending investigation with the DOJ. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Other than the Exhibit Number 4 regarding the alleged misconduct that was initiated by Delilah Evans by the Chicago Police Department, are you aware of any other allegations by Delilah Evans of misconduct by you? A No, not that I recall. Q Prior to your position as a Page 77 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 PO to sergeant. You have to take a written examination. That's one of the criteria. Q Are you aware of any other criteria to make those promotions? MR. BATTLE: You are asking about his personal knowledge, correct? He's not a -MR. MORRISSEY: Correct. MR. BATTLE: Okay, go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A If you are referring to my personal knowledge, my personal knowledge is you have to take an examination to get promoted or you get appointed. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q As a commander, have you ever recommended that a person be promoted from a sergeant to lieutenant? A Have I recommended? Q Correct. A It's possible. Q How did you go about doing that? A Could you be more specific as to -What do you mean, how did I do it? Q Well, you said that, at times, you TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 46 of 107 PageID #:1354 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 21 (Pages 78 to 81) Page 78 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 have recommended somebody to be promoted from a sergeant to a lieutenant, correct? A At times I did, yes. Q How did go about making that recommendation to the police department? A In writing. Q To what office within the police department would you deliver that written recommendation for an individual to be promoted from sergeant to lieutenant? A There's not a specific office. It's a process. Q Tell me about the process. MR. BATTLE: Objection. Man, this is irrelevant and has nothing to do with this case at all. Go ahead, man, tell him the process. BY THE WITNESS: A I am not overly I don't want to say familiar because of the time passage in which I did it. The policies and procedures at that time changed. What I did was I take a name based on information received and submit it up the chain of command. Page 80 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 that. As a commander, you, at times, would make a written request for somebody under your command to be promoted, correct? A Every commander does, yes. Q How frequently would you do that? A I don't know. I couldn't tell you. It was infrequent. Depends upon whether they're going to make promotions. Q How were you made aware as commander that it was time for promotions in the department? A Via written notification. Q Who would they come from? A City of Chicago. Q Would it be the superintendent's office? A Might be the supervisor's office, might be human resources. I'm not overly acclimated with that process. Q When you were a commander, you participated in that process, right? A Infrequently. Q When you mean "infrequently," what do you mean? Page 79 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know whether the chain of command ever accepted any of your suggestions for an individual to be promoted? A I don't know. Q What would you look for when you were making a recommendation for someone to be promoted? A What do I look for? Q Correct. A I don't know what that means, what do you look for? Q Are there certain qualities or characteristics that you look for when making a decision whether to request a police department to promote an individual? A Any particular qualities or anything of that nature, I followed the parameters of the department's edicts. Q Do you have any discretion regarding those parameters? A What do you mean? Do I deviate from them? Q What would you look for -- strike Page 81 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A It means whenever I get sent memos of documents regarding promotional opportunities and I'm assigned to submit somebody in consideration for a promotion, I follow the department's edicts, and I do so. THE REPORTER: You follow the department's what? THE WITNESS: Edicts, e-d-i-c-t-s. Edicts, edicts, I don't know. I flunked English. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q As a commander, did you have access to the police department's CLEAR system? A Yes. Q As a commander, could you use the CLEAR system to determine how many CR files an officer under your command had? A Internal affairs has that. Q I'm asking could you, as a commander, identify that information? A That information is fed through internal affairs. Q So you did not have access to that information, correct? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 47 of 107 PageID #:1355 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 22 (Pages 82 to 85) Page 82 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A It goes to internal affairs. Q Could you request internal affairs provide you with a number of CRs that an officer under your command had? MR. BATTLE: Objection, speculation, go ahead. You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A I can request it, but I generally don't recall that being the process. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Before you made a decision to request in writing that an officer under your command be promoted, would you have an interview with that candidate? A Do I interview them? Q Correct. A Yeah, depends. Q What would it depend on? A It depended on what the department states the policy and procedures are regarding submitting individuals' names for nomination. Q And, at times, did the department require you to conduct an interview with a candidate? Page 84 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 command had ten CR allegations, would that disqualify that candidate? MR. BATTLE: Objection, speculation, incomplete hypothetical, irrelevant. It does not lead to discoverable evidence in this case, and I have no idea on Earth why you are asking that question. MS. KUPE-ARION: And also competence since Mr. Evans is not being produced as a (30(b)(6) witness to speak on behalf of CPD procedures. MS. HARRIS: And I'll join in that objection, too, to the extent it would affect the other defendants in the case. BY THE WITNESS: A You'll have to repeat that question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Assuming there was a period when you were delegated a task of a commander to recommend some people under your command for a promotion. A Okay, that's one part. Q If you were aware that that candidate had ten allegations of misconduct, CR files, Page 83 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 A I don't recall what the directives 2 are. I would have to review the directives, 3 parameters and then I can answer that. 4 Q Did you ever interview somebody 5 before you decided to make a written 6 notification to the superintendent or the HR 7 department for that person to be promoted? 8 A Did I personally make a -- Did I 9 interview someone to see if they are a good or 10 viable candidate for promotion? 11 Q Correct. 12 A Yes. 13 Q Would you take notes based on your 14 interview? 15 A I'm going to say no. 16 Q What would you look for in a 17 candidate that you would request to be 18 promoted? 19 A There are certain performance and 20 behavior dimensions that were outlined in promotional announcements and notifications. I 21 22 adhere to those standards, and that's what I 23 look for. 24 Q If a member of the department of your Page 85 would that, based on your assessment, disqualify the person for a promotion? MR. BATTLE: Same objection. MS. KUPE-ARION: I renew my objection. MS. HARRIS: Same objection. BY THE WITNESS: A Because complaints by themselves don't constitute disciplinary action, and that's what you're commingling. You're commingling disciplinary action with complaints, and a lot of complaints are erroneous, invalid, done for political or retaliatory purposes or done to harass working officers. I take everything into account. I take the negative and the positive into account. I don't discount anybody because of complaints, but I don't discount anybody because they have an outstanding personnel or an award history as well. You have to balance everything. So I take everything into consideration. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 48 of 107 PageID #:1356 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 23 (Pages 86 to 89) Page 86 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q For approximately what period of time were you a sergeant assigned to the 5th District? A I'm going to say, to the best of my recollection, and don't hold me to this, December maybe 2003, 2003 maybe to May or -May 2016 -- May 2006. 2006, I'm sorry. Q And you already testified, I believe, that you took a test to be promoted from sergeant to lieutenant? A Yes. Q In addition to that test, did you have an interview with your commander prior to your promotion? A That's a vague question. Interview as to regards to what? Q In regards to your promotion or potential promotion from sergeant to lieutenant. A You would even have to be more specific than that. My commander, because of my work ethic and productivity, would task me to perform certain deployments and functions. Page 88 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Not that I can recall, no. Q Same question for your deputy chief. A Not that I can recall. Q When you were a sergeant assigned to the 5th District, were you ever suspended? MR. BATTLE: Objection, relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A I don't recall ever being suspended as a sergeant. It's entirely possible, but I don't recall. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When you were a lieutenant assigned to the 6th District, who was your commander? A I had multiple commanders. Q Can you tell me them? A One was John Doty, D-o-t-y; another commander was Eddie Johnson, common spelling; third commander, Eric Carter, common spelling. Q During that period, who was your deputy chief? A I don't recall but I'm going to guess Dana Alexander and/or Eugene Williams and possibly Tina Skahill, S-k-a-h-i-l-l. Q As lieutenant in the 6th District, to Page 87 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 He would directly come to me and ask me to deploy my personnel in a most advantageous fashion; and based on his input and his direction, I would do so. So in terms of direct personnel matters, I've had numerous conversations with my commander and my deputy chief at that time. Q Tell me when you were the sergeant in the 5th District who your commander and deputy chief were? A The commander of the 5th District at that time was Syd Kelly. The deputy chief was Michael Shields. Q When you were a sergeant in the 5th District, did you ever receive any citizen complaints of excessive force? MR. BATTLE: Objection to relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A I don't remember. It's entirely possible. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did you ever have a conversation with Commander Kelly during that period regarding allegations of excessive force by citizens? Page 89 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 your knowledge, were you ever -- did you ever receive a citizen complaint alleging excessive force? A Yes. Q How many do you recall receiving? A I don't recall. Q More than one? A Possibly. Q Other than excessive force, do you recall ever receiving a citizen complaint -Strike that. Do you know whether IAD investigated you when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District? A Yes. Q Under what circumstance did IAD investigate you, to your knowledge, when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District? A To the best of my recollection, I believe it was one investigation regarding a narcotics investigation I did at a residence. They did the investigation, and to the best of my recollection, they determined that like much -- in a lot these investigations TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 49 of 107 PageID #:1357 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 24 (Pages 90 to 93) Page 90 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 that the individual had lied, falsified evidence and hid his identity and misrepresented facts to the department, so they unfounded it. Q What were the circumstances regarding that IAD by that citizen? A It was a narcotics complaint, multiple complaints of narcotics into a residential area. Q And what misconduct was alleged against you? A I don't absolutely recall. It could be possible regarding the lack of a search warrant, but I don't recall. Q Did you discuss that IAD investigation with any of your commanders in the 6th District? A Did I discuss it? It's possible but I don't recall. Q Did you discuss that IAD investigation with any of the deputy chiefs when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District? A I'm fairly sure I didn't. Q Regarding that at least one Page 92 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 issues that they do not concur with, indicate that they do not concur with the findings or the investigation. Q When you were a commander, did you ever not concur with findings from IPRA? A Yes. Q Did it happen more than once? A I'm going to say yes. Q More than five times? A I don't know how many times exactly. Q As you sit here today, do you recall any times when you reviewed an IPRA investigation and decided not to concur with the finding? A That I personally reviewed the IPRA investigation? Q Correct. A Yes. Q Can you give me what you remember about that assessment? A The assessment and investigation, if I did not concur, and this is just standard across the board, that the findings were incorrect or the investigation was flawed in my Page 91 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 allegation of excessive force when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District, did you have a conversation regarding those allegations with any of your commanders? A I'm sorry. Could you repeat that? Q You said you recall at least one allegation of excessive force by a citizen when you were a lieutenant in the 6th District. The question is did you have a conversation regarding that allegation with any of your commanders? A I'm going to say that if there's an ongoing investigation, the commanders would be prohibited from discussing that in order to retain the integrity of the investigation. Q How would you know what the commander is prohibited from talking with you about while it's ongoing. A Because I was a commander. Q And what is your understanding of what a commander is prohibited from doing when there's an ongoing CR investigation? A That they're supposed to let the investigation go unimpeded; and if there's Page 93 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 estimation or that the investigation was flawed, the findings were incorrect. Q Do you recall the factual allegations against that officer when you decided to not concur with the IPRA findings? A Not as we sit here. If I get the records and I review them, I can be in a better position to refer to that -- to defer to that. I'm sorry. Q Prior to being a sergeant in the 5th District, what was your position? A Police officer. Q And from what years were you a police officer? A From July 1986 to I'm going to say July 1998. Q And after July of '98, what was your position? A I was a sergeant. Q Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe you testified you were a sergeant in the 5th District from December of '03 to May of '06? A That's correct. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 50 of 107 PageID #:1358 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 25 (Pages 94 to 97) Page 94 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Prior to December of 2003, what was your title with the police department? A Sergeant. Q Where were you assigned? A Public housing. Q From what years and months were you assigned to public housing? A Approximately July 1999 to -- July 1999 to December 2003. It might have been 2002. I don't know. I mean, I'll have to review my records. Q During the time when you were a sergeant in public housing, are you aware of any IAD investigations against you? A IAD investigations against me? Q Correct. A You're not made aware of all investigations. It's possible, but I don't recall any IAD investigations against me. Q During that same period when you were a sergeant in public housing, are you aware of any citizen complaints against you relating to excessive force? A From 1998 -- I'm sorry, in public Page 96 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q As a police officer from July of 1996 to about July of '98 or '99, tell me the various assignments you've had. A As a police officer? Q Correct. A 6th District, at least twice; 3rd District, public housing. That's it. Q When you held the rank of police officer, are you aware of any IAD investigations against you? A Any IAD investigations? Q Correct. A Yes, a couple, I think that I can recall, a couple that I can recall. Q Tell me what you recall about those few IAD investigations? A I know that the IAD investigations came back either exonerated or not sustained or some unfounded. I don't recall anything behind that. Q Do you recall any factual allegations against you? A Any factual allegations? Q Correct. Page 95 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 housing, excessive force? Q Yeah. A Yes, but -- yes, but I don't recall the particulars. Q Do you recall how many times you were a recipient of a complaint of excessive force starting in public housing? A No. Q More than once? A It was more than once. Q More than two times? A It was probably more than two times. Q Three? A I think that's stretching it. I'm not sure. Q Were you disciplined as a result of those CR investigations? A As a sergeant? Q Correct. A No. Q When you were a sergeant in public housing, were you ever suspended? A As a sergeant in public housing, no, not that I can recall. Page 97 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Factual allegations is not a real good way to put it because -- I don't know what you mean by factual allegations. Do you mean did they have a basis to lodge a complaint or basis to sustain a complaint? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q I'm asking do you recall -- I will rephrase the question. What's the difference between an IAD investigation and a citizen complaint of excessive force? A IPRA and it's precursor or its predecessor, I'm sorry, OPS, investigates verbal abuse and excessive force; and internal affairs is tasked with just about all other allegations with the exception of summary punishment, which is tasked by the immediate supervisor, tasked to the immediate supervisor. Q Are IAD investigations initiated internally within the CPD? A Are -- I'm sorry? Q Are IAD investigations initiated internally by a member of the CPD. MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, competence since Mr. Evans is not being TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 51 of 107 PageID #:1359 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 26 (Pages 98 to 101) Page 98 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 produced on behalf of the city and cannot give any testimony in regards to policies of the police department. MR. BATTLE: I will join in that objection. MS. HARRIS: I'll join. MR. BATTLE: Glenn, you can answer as best you can, based on your personal knowledge. BY THE WITNESS: A I never was assigned to IAD and there was never any policy making or implementation at that level, so I can't speak to that. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When you were a police officer from July of '86 to either July of '98 or '99, are you aware of any citizen complaints of either verbal abuse or excessive force by you? A Yes. MR. BATTLE: Objection, we already went through that just a few seconds ago. BY THE WITNESS: A Yeah, you just showed me a report. Page 100 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A It's Willibrord Catholic. THE REPORTER: It's what? Just say it. (WHEREUPON, the witness wrote down the name of the school.) THE WITNESS: Now, aren't you glad I'm not saying it? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did you go on to college? A Yes. Q Where did you attend college? A I went to multiple colleges. Q Tell me the first college you went to. A I can't tell you the first college I went to. I went to multiple colleges at once, City College, University of Illinois Chicago, Chicago State. Q Did you ever receive a degree? A Yes. Q What did you receive your degree in? A In liberal arts. Q From which university? Page 99 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q How many allegations of abuse, to your knowledge, were made against you during that period? A I don't know. Q More than one? A I don't know, possibly. I'm going to say yes. Q When did you enter the training academy? MR. BATTLE: Oh, Jesus. BY THE WITNESS: A July of 1986 to, I believe, November 1986. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Where did you attend high school? A Where did I go to high school? Q Correct. A I went to a high school on the south side of Chicago. Q Do you recall the name of the high school? A Yes. Q What is it? Page 101 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A From Western Illinois. Q Which year? A 1986. Q What year did you graduate high school? A What year did I graduate high school? Q Correct. A 1980. Q Did you ever serve in the military? A No, not full time, no. Q Well, did you ever serve in the reserves? A Yes. Q From what year did you serve in the reserves? A July 1989 to, I think, I'm going to say sometime 1994. I don't recall the month. Q Which reserves did you serve in? A I was in the coast guard reserves. Q Did you receive a discharge? A As far as I know. Q Tell me what discharge you were given by the coast guard? A It was inactive ready reserve, and it TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 52 of 107 PageID #:1360 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 27 (Pages 102 to 105) Page 102 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 was -- I believe it was -- It was an honorable or whatcha call it? I'm going to say it was an honorable discharge because I never was -- had any adverse affect on my career. I don't have my records, so I can't answer all of that. Q Between 1980 and 1986, were you employed? A 1980 and 1986? Q Correct, prior to you joining the Chicago Police Department? A Yes. Q Where did you work? A I'm sorry? Q Where did you work? A From 1980 to 1986 prior to joining the police department? Q Yes. A University of Illinois, I believe. Q What did you do for the university? A I did manual labor, and I did patient transport. Q Are you familiar with the term of pressure point technique? A Am I familiar with the term pressure Page 104 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A On a citizen's head? That's just such a broad question. I don't really know how to address that. Q Do you recall receiving any training regarding physical control measures in the academy during July of '86 to November of '86 to use on an arrestee's head or face? A On an arrestee's head or face? We learned multiple overall physical control measures. Q Describe the multiple physical control measures you learned to apply to a person's face? A Including pressure point, and we also learned how to use holding and restraint, and we're also taught to control a person's head to minimize conflict. Q Describe the pressure point technique you were taught in the academy to apply to a person's face? A What do you mean describe it? There's multiple techniques they taught us to use. Q Was there any technique they taught Page 103 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 point technique, yes. Q Did you learn the pressure point technique when you were in the academy from July of 1986 to November of 1986? A You mean a specific pressure point technique? Q Correct. A There weren't specific pressure point techniques. We learned a variety of control measures. Q What types of control measures did you learn when you were in the academy from July of '86 to November of '86? A Physical control methods. Q Did you have a class on physical control measures? A Did we have a class? We had multiple classes. Q You had multiple classes on physical control measures? A Yes. Q Tell me what techniques you were taught during that period relating to using a physical control measure on a citizen's head. Page 105 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 you to use to a person's nose? A There were techniques to use to a person's head that included the nose region, yes. Q Describe how you were taught that pressure point technique to the nose? A By physical demonstration. Q Can you verbally describe it? A There are multiple because it's a fast-paced class. There are multiple modes of instruction that we were given, and it depended on situational concerns. It depends on the person if the person is combative, noncompliant or an assailant. Q Tell me about the techniques you've learned for a noncompliant individual? A Noncomplaint, it depends on the level of noncompliance. You want me to give you a static answer, and I can't give you a static answer because pain control and compliance are all situational. It depends on what the situation is, the level of threat and the level of noncompliance and other factors. Q Have you ever been accused of TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 53 of 107 PageID #:1361 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 28 (Pages 106 to 109) Page 106 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 misconduct to an arrestee in a lockup? A Yes. Q More than once, right? A More than once, I don't recall. It's possible. I'm going to say yes. Q And would that be other than Ms. King's allegation against you? A Okay, that's what threw me off. Yes, there might have been one other besides Ms. King. Q What other -- Describe the other allegation you're aware of of misconduct in the lockup. A The allegation of misconduct in the lockup was that an individual claimed and in doing so, once again, he lied and exaggerated and falsified the account by claiming that I improperly Tasered him. Q Where did this individual say you improperly Tasered him? A I believe in the groin and in the posterior. Q Were you disciplined for that allegation? Page 108 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Halsted. Q Is that the same location where you allegedly abused Ms. King? A Where I was falsely accused of abusing Ms. King, that's correct. Q When you were a police officer, were you also accused of kicking an arrestee in the groin? MR. BATTLE: Do you want to give us some time or some reference? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall an alleged incident that occurred on 27 March of 1993 -A '93? Q -- where you allegedly, as a police officer, kicked an individual in the groin, and the individual's name was Anthony Harris? A No, I don't. MR. BATTLE: Objection. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall an incident that allegedly occurred on May 11th, 1994 where you allegedly struck a woman by the name of Jennifer Thomas in her left eye? Page 107 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A No. Q Do you recall what year that allegation was? A Oh, my goodness, maybe 2007. I'm not really sure. Q Did that individual sue you? MR. SCHUMANN: I'm sorry. Did you say 2007? THE WITNESS: I'm sorry, 2007. BY THE WITNESS: A Yes, he did. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall that individual's name? A I think his last name was Simmons. Q Do you know whether that case settled? A To my recollection, it did. Q And you were a lieutenant at the time, correct? A Yes. Q Was that in the 6th District? A Yes. Q Where is the 6th District? A The physical structure is 78th and Page 109 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. BATTLE: Objection to relevance. BY THE WITNESS: A No. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you recall during that CR investigation, OPS required you to be photographed? MR. BATTLE: Objection, same. BY THE WITNESS: A No, I don't. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Have you ever shot anybody while on duty? MR. BATTLE: Objection to relevance, case-by-case basis. There is no allegations of gun play involved in this case at all. Go ahead and answer, if you remember. BY THE WITNESS: A An individual that fought me, injured my hand and tried to wrestle my gun from me and also went to threaten his girlfriend with a gun and fought me in the stairwell, if that's the individual you're referring to and that same TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 54 of 107 PageID #:1362 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 29 (Pages 110 to 113) Page 110 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 individual subsequently shot two people, killed one and brain damaged a second one, I absolutely did shoot him. Q Other than that incident, have you ever shot anybody or anyone as a member of the police department? A Second situation where an individual that threatened his girlfriend to shoot her when I was an officer, and he got into a big fight with me and, once again, that individual tried to take my gun, in fact, he did at one point and disarmed me, I shot him, too. Q Have you ever shot at a citizen's dog? A Yes, I did. Q When did that occur? A I don't recall. A few times I shot vicious animals. Q Do you know whether CR investigations were opened as a result of those instances? A No, I don't recall. Q Do you recall being sued by Joshua Lott? A I'm sorry? Page 112 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. BATTLE: Wait. BY THE WITNESS: A My attorney -MR. BATTLE: Stop talking. THE WITNESS: Okay, no problem. MR. BATTLE: You're getting into dangerous territory in terms of attorney-client privilege. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm not asking who his -- I'm asking who was his attorney prior to you coming in. MR. BATTLE: Right, what does that have to do with this case? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was Eric Palles your attorney -MR. BATTLE: Counsel, don't instruct -Don't talk to my client when I'm talking to you. I don't think that's appropriate. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm the one asking questions. I'm not being noticed here. MR. BATTLE: I just asked him to go off the record so you and I can have a conversation about it. Do you really want me to go on the record with that? Page 111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Do you recall being sued by Joshua Lott in federal court? A Yes. Q And the incident occurred or allegedly occurred in May of 2012, correct? A Yes. Q Do you recall what the allegations were against you? A I never was served with allegations. Q Do you know whether you were represented in that case? A I never was served with allegations. Q Who was your attorney prior to Mr. Battle stepping in for you? MR. BATTLE: In what case? BY THE WITNESS: A In what case? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q In this case. A In what case is that? MR. BATTLE: You're talking about the Rita King case? MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection -- Page 113 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. MR. BATTLE: You want to do that on the record? MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. MR. BATTLE: Because I think that question you're asking him is abusive, harassing, and if he understands who's representing him, that's fine. I think that's a question you can actually find out if you look at the court docket and see what appearances have been filed for him periodically throughout time. That's an unfair question. You're abusing the discovery process and I don't appreciate -- I was trying to do this off the record. I'm going to instruct him not to answer that question. You can take that to Judge Gilbert or call him if you'd like. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Sir, are you taking your attorney's advice regarding that question? A I'm taking his advice and he made the absolute right call and I back him up, and I'm TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 55 of 107 PageID #:1363 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 30 (Pages 114 to 117) Page 114 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 not answering that question. MR. SCHUMANN: Excuse me. What's the relevance of this question? MR. MORRISSEY: I'm not answering questions about -MR. SCHUMANN: What's the relevancy of the question? I'm asking as an attorney of record? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did you have an attorney in the Joshua Lott matter? A City of Chicago. Q And did Eric Palles represent you in that case? MS. HARRIS: I'm going to object to the relevance of this. MR. BATTLE: I'm getting ready to call the judge. Go ahead with your objection. I've got to find the judge's phone number on this. MS. HARRIS: I'm making an objection. I don't understand how this is relevant, how it leads to discoverable evidence. I believe it's harassing, argumentative and Page 116 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. SCHUMANN: If you can explain to me what the relevance is or how this leads to some part of your complaint, I would be willing to listen. MR. MORRISSEY: We have a Monell allegation against the city. I prefer to move forward with this deposition. MS. KUPE-ARION: If you are raising this under scope of Monell, then it really has no -- what's the -- there is no relevance or connection between who represented him at what point in his cases. MR. MORRISSEY: Mr. Battle, what are you going to have your client do? MR. BATTLE: Do we need to have the judge referee this one? MR. MORRISSEY: I don't understand what the issue is. MR. BATTLE: Right, you probably don't, but you're asking my client who his attorneys are in various cases, and that's of record. Do you want me to call the judge to referee? MR. MORRISSEY: I don't understand Page 115 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 badgering the witness. THE WITNESS: That's all he's been doing. MS. KUPE-ARION: The City joins. MR. MORRISSEY: Mr. Battle, are you telling your client not to answer? MR. SCHUMANN: You're needlessly prolonging the dep -MR. MORRISSEY: Well, I thought we already talked about Mr. Battle -MR. SCHUMANN: Yeah, well, we're not now. It is also needlessly -- and you still haven't given me a rule. So if you give me a rule, I'll abide by any rule; but you are needlessly prolonging the deposition by asking a witness who his attorney is in past cases when they are of record. Who his attorney is has no relevance to this litigation or can lead to anything relevant to this litigation. MR. MORRISSEY: When your client -MR. SCHUMANN: Excuse me. Excuse me. MR. MORRISSEY: Go ahead. Page 117 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 why that is privileged. MR. BATTLE: Do you want me to call the judge so he can referee that question? MR. MORRISSEY: I don't believe that's necessary. MR. BATTLE: I believe you're totally off base with this. That's just like me asking Rita King who her cousin is who has nothing to do with the case, Counsel. MR. MORRISSEY: Judge Gilbert said if there are any issues to bring it before him in writing. MR. BATTLE: I think we can call him right now so we can -MR. SCHUMANN: But before that, we're supposed to have a 37 -MR. MORRISSEY: All right, let me -MR. SCHUMANN: We can do this right here. All you have to do is explain to us what the relevancy is or how this is to lead to relevant evidence based upon what is in the complaint that you filed or any answer or affirmative defense -MR. MORRISSEY: All right, we already TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 56 of 107 PageID #:1364 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 31 (Pages 118 to 121) Page 118 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 agreed that one -THE REPORTER: I'm sorry. You have to -MR. SCHUMANN: I would like my answer -question as an attorney of record -- I mean, my question answered as an attorney of record and we can move on. You are slowing this deposition up. We can move on if you can state for the record to us so we can advise our client how this is relevant or how it leads to discoverable information in this case. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm not being deposed here. Why don't we move on. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Mr. Evans, Joshua Lott sued you, right? A Joshua Lott filed a lawsuit against numerous members of the police department of which I was one. Q And you gave a deposition in that case, right? A It's possible. I don't recall giving a deposition. Page 120 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 my counsel, and I'll stand on it in court. I'm making that comment against the advice of my counsel, and I'll stand on it in court. Q In what capacity were you working when you allegedly engaged in misconduct against Mr. Lott? A Against Mr. Lott the liar, I was a lieutenant. Q And what were you doing that day? A I was assigned to NATO. Q And was Mr. Lott a photo journalist that day? A I don't know what he was. He's a liar and if he's a photo journalist, he's a lying one. MR. BATTLE: Just answer the question. THE WITNESS: Well, I got to call it like I see it. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Were you working in the capacity as a lieutenant at NATO that day? A Yes. THE WITNESS: I'm sorry, but enough Page 119 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q We were talking about the allegations that Mr. Lott had against you, correct? A I never was served with allegations by Mr. Lott who was a big liar by the way, and I'll put that on the record. Q Why -A Because he made a bunch of false allegations, and it was pushed by his counsel so he could get a settlement. He lied, and I'm going to put that on the record. Mr. Lott lied. Q What are Mr. Lott's allegations, based on your knowledge? A Based on my knowledge, any allegation that Mr. Lott alleged, Number 1, physical misconduct relative to physical contact with him is an out and out lie. Number 2, any allegations Mr. Lott alleged stating that I ignored police misconduct in my presence, he brought that to attention, is another lie. He's a liar; and if his counsel pushed it, they're lying too and I stand on it. And that didn't come from my counsel. I'm making this comment against the advice of Page 121 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 is enough of the lies. MR. BATTLE: Okay. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know whether that case settled? A To my recollection, it did. Q Was that recent? A It depends on what you claim is recent. Q When do you recall the case settling? A I don't know. I was never formally notified. Q We also talked about Mr. Simmons' complaint against you; is that correct? A That's correct. Q Do you recall what allegations Mr. Simmons had against you? A I think I had answered that, but I will answer it again. He stated that I had Tasered him in his groin and his buttocks area. Q Did you settle that case? A I didn't settle anything. It's not up to me to settle anything. Q Is there another case with a Rennie TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 57 of 107 PageID #:1365 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 32 (Pages 122 to 125) Page 122 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Simmons, a city water inspector? A Is there another case? Q Correct, that you're involved with. A There was another case. Q So there's two Simmons cases, correct? A That's correct. Q And the Rennie Simmons, R-e-n-n-i-e, Simmons case, those allegations by Mr. Simmons occurred in July of 2006, correct? Mr. Evans, I have a question pending. MR. BATTLE: I got it, counsel. I got it, counsel. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Excuse me -MR. BATTLE: Hold on. I got it. BY THE WITNESS: A Can I talk to him for one second? MR. BATTLE: No, no, no. You got to answer this question and then we can take a break. BY THE WITNESS: A Repeat it again. MR. BATTLE: I got this, Counsel. Page 124 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 had a -- I get these moments where I have some lucidity and I wanted to -MR. BATTLE: Okay. THE WITNESS: But we'll talk later. MR. BATTLE: Yep. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Is there anything that would prevent you from testifying truthfully today? Are you on any medications that would impair your ability to testify truthfully? A I testify truthfully every time I'm under oath, unlike Mr. Lott. Q Do you recall what the allegations by Mr. Rennie Simmons were against you? MR. BATTLE: Is that a man or a woman? THE WITNESS: That's a man and his name is Rennie, not Rennie, Rennie. MR. BATTLE: I'm sorry to interrupt. Go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A I never was served with any allegations of misconduct relative to Mr. Simmons' case. I never was served. Page 123 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 THE WITNESS: You know, can I take a break? MR. BATTLE: You've got to answer the question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q You have to answer the question first. A No problem. MR. BATTLE: Yeah, go ahead repeat the question. BY THE WITNESS: A Can you repeat it again? MR. MORRISSEY: Will you repeat it? MR. BATTLE: He wants her to read it. (WHEREUPON, the record was read as requested.) BY THE WITNESS: A That depends on what do you mean by "allegations"? MR. MORRISSEY: Do you want to take a break now? THE WITNESS: No, let's go. MR. BATTLE: Are you good? THE WITNESS: Yeah, I'm good. I just Page 125 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q But you recall there being allegations against you by Mr. Simmons? A I was never served with any allegations of misconduct by Mr. Simmons. Q I'm not asking you whether you were served any papers. I'm asking whether you have any knowledge of any allegations brought against you for misconduct? A No, not that -- By Mr. Simmons, no. Q You testified in court against Mr. Simmons, correct? A Yes, I did. Q And were you testifying truthfully when you testified in court? A I testify truthfully at all of my court appearances. Q What do you recall happening between you and Mr. Simmons in July of 2006? MR. BATTLE: Objection, relevance, outside the scope, not reasonably calculated to lead to discoverable evidence. Are we ever going to get to Rita King? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 58 of 107 PageID #:1366 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 33 (Pages 126 to 129) Page 126 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A I'm going to give you the best of my recollection. Mr. Simmons approached my property, which was vacant and still is vacant with a real nasty attitude and demeanor. He wanted to take a picture of the building, and I gave him the okay. Then I told him if he had a water sticker about -- that he wanted to post on the building. I said you can give it to me and I'll take the service. He screamed and cursed at me and was very arrogant and belligerent. I ordered him off my property. We got into an argument. I called 911 on him because he was being abusive and confrontational. He went to his vehicle to the best of my recollection. He came and took a picture and I took a picture of him with my cell phone. His words and I don't know the absolute correct verbiage he used, his words were I got something for your smart ass. He ran to the trunk of his vehicle and took out a wrench or a pipe or something of that nature. I tackled him. I took him to the Page 128 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 it again. There was -- I don't know if there was a complaint lodged officially, but I believe that he did lodge some kind of complaint, and it was unfounded. MR. MORRISSEY: Why don't we mark this -- Are we on 5? THE REPORTER: Yes. (WHEREUPON, Evans Exhibit No. 5 was marked for identification.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Sir, I'm showing you what has been marked as Exhibit 5, which is your set of Answers to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories, which I believe you verified in December of 2013. Do you see your signature on the last page of that document? A Yes. And this is a clear copy, so I can see all of this. Q Do you recall preparing this document? A Do I recall preparing it? I didn't prepare this document per se. Q Prior to signing or attaching your Page 127 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 ground. I held him for the police. He was arrested and charged with battery, but he should have been charged with aggravated assault. It was my information that because he stated that he was connected to political figures, figures in this ward here, the 19th Ward, figures in the 21st Ward and figures in the 8th Ward and some other political figures that he was not going to -he was going to escape punishment for his actions. He subsequently secured the services, I believe, of Mr. Pinchum who is also a political icon, and the case was dismissed and found not guilty. I believe the judge in that case admonished us both for acting like children, which we were because we could have acted a lot better. He took the case, sued and got a settlement. Q Do you know whether there was any CR investigation by IPRA as a result of that incident? A I just answered it, but I will answer Page 129 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 signature to the last page, did you review the answers? A Yes. Q And was it on or about December 9th, 2013? A Yes. Q Did you review this document prior to coming here to testify? A Cursory review, yes. Q Based on your cursory review, is there any answer that you would like to change? MR. BATTLE: Take your time. BY THE WITNESS: A There probably are answers that I would like to change but not at this time. Going forward and reviewing this a little bit further when I get a chance to review this with counsel, there probably are items I would like to change and modify. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Which answer would you like to change? Let me rephrase. Strike that question. Did you have the ability to modify these answers before you signed it? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 59 of 107 PageID #:1367 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 34 (Pages 130 to 133) Page 130 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A I'm sorry? Q Did you have a chance to modify -A No. Q Why not? A I don't know what you mean "why not." Q Why don't we look at Question Number 7. Have you had an opportunity to read Question Number 7 in Exhibit Number 5? A Yes. Q And in response to that question, do you list the lawsuits where you have been named a defendant or a plaintiff? A I see the matters listing where I was either the plaintiff or the defendant, yes. Q Would you like to modify this answer? A Yes. Q All right. How would you like to modify this answer? A Address the broadness, the burdensome, the lack of foundation and the additional information required in regards to each of these complaints. Q Is there any additional lawsuit that you would like to add where you were either a Page 132 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Yes, it's possible. Q Which ones are they? A I don't know offhand because I haven't been served with a couple of them, but I'm fairly sure there's one or two out there. Q Did Ricky Williams sue you? MR. BATTLE: Jesus, really? Objection, I think you know the basis. Go ahead and answer his question. BY THE WITNESS: A Yes. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Were you served that complaint? A I believe so, yes. Q Are you aware of the names of any other lawsuits that are not listed on this answer? MR. BATTLE: Same objection that this is a matter of public record. We've answered this question three times. His interrogatory answers were from December of 2013, two years and three months ago. You've had ample -MR. MORRISSEY: Well, his attorney -- Page 131 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 defendant or a plaintiff? MR. BATTLE: I'm going to object on the grounds that the lawsuits that Mr. Evans is involved in or has been involved in are a matter of public record. It's a waste of time to be going through this. Go ahead and answer, if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A That's just -- There's no reason why I would like to -- or dislike to add any question (sic). I don't have to lie and obscure any adversary information against me. I just want this record to be accurate and complete; and based on this current configuration, it's neither accurate nor complete. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q All right. Are there any additional lawsuits that have not been included in the answer to Number 7? A I'm sorry? Q Are there any lawsuits that you're aware of that have not been included in answer to Number 7? Page 133 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. BATTLE: Can I finish with my objection? You've had ample opportunity to review the public record to determine if there are any other lawsuits that you would like to ask about that could have been added to this. MR. MORRISSEY: I believe his attorney has an obligation to supplement discovery responses, but that's another issue. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q For the answer in Number 7, which lawsuits were you named a plaintiff, based on your understanding? A I guess the ones with my name on them. Q So tell me which lawsuit you were the plaintiff? A That I was the plaintiff? Q Yeah. A The one that predicates Williams versus Fudge, Incorporated (sic). Q Any other ones? A No, then -- Like I said, this is not TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 60 of 107 PageID #:1368 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 35 (Pages 134 to 137) Page 134 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 a complete list. So I couldn't tell you at this point. Q Have you ever met Mayor Emanuel? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. MR. BATTLE: I'll join. MS. HARRIS: Join. MR. BATTLE: He said have you ever met Mayor Emanuel? BY THE WITNESS: A Yes. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q How many times have you met with Mayer Emanuel? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. MR. BATTLE: Same. MS. HARRIS: Join. BY THE WITNESS: A What do you mean, formally or informally. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Well, let's first go through the formal meetings. Page 136 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A I don't understand that question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q After criminal charges were brought against you, did you ever have a conversation with Mayer Emanuel? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. MS. HARRIS: Join. MR. BATTLE: Yeah, this is going way too far. Counsel, I've given you a lot, a lot of leeway with respect to your questions about 25-year-old CRs and so on and so forth, but you're going way beyond the expanse of Monell claims or any claims that Rita King may possibly have against my client. I think you are borderline abusing the discovery process in this deposition. I read through the transcript of your original deposition, and it looked like you were on track with just getting to the brunt of -- the meat of this case. I haven't heard you mention anything about April of 2011 yet, and we've been in here Page 135 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A I don't recall how many times I met him formally. Q How many times have you met informally with the mayor? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. MS. HARRIS: Join. BY THE WITNESS: A I don't recall. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Have you ever had a meeting with Mayor Emanuel regarding your responsibilities as a member of the police department? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. Objection, form of the question. MS. HARRIS: Join. MR. BATTLE: And foundation. Go ahead, Glenn. You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A I really don't understand that question. MR. BATTLE: Tell him you don't understand the question. Page 137 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 for two and a half hours. I mean, this is getting ridiculous. Go ahead and restate your question so he can respond. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you remember my question? A I believe your question was did I meet with the mayor regarding -- or after the falsified, contrived, perjured criminal charges that were placed again me. The answer is no. Q Under what circumstances would you have a formal meeting with Mayor Emanuel prior to the criminal charges being brought against you? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question, relevance. MS. HARRIS: Join. MR. BATTLE: Let's lay some foundation. Are you speaking of as his time as commander? as his time as a lieutenant? his time as a police officer? You have no foundation to your question. So that's my objection to foundation. If you lay a proper foundation, maybe we can get in and out of here. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 61 of 107 PageID #:1369 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 36 (Pages 138 to 141) Page 138 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: Well, if the deponent has a problem with my question -MR. BATTLE: I have a problem with the question, Counsel. Are you going to lay a proper foundation or do you want me to -- Do you want to go through this the hard way? MR. MORRISSEY: I would rather just see if the witness can answer the question. You've made your objection. MR. BATTLE: Fair enough. Go ahead and see if you can answer the question. BY THE WITNESS: A I met with -- or I had contact with the mayor. I wouldn't characterize them as meetings because I don't recall ever having a formal meeting with him. We met at events and we met at social functions regarding public safety. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Have you ever had a conversation with Mayer Emanuel regarding IPRA? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance. Page 140 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 there is for attorneys, physicians, politicians, 19th Ward personnel. MR. MORRISSEY: Let's take a break. (WHEREUPON, a short break was had.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know Officer Kevin Rodgers? A Do I know an officer who? Q Kevin Rodgers? A Yes. Q Is he retired presently? A I don't know what the status is. Q In April of 2011, did you work with Officer Rodgers? A We were assigned to the same district. Q That would be the 6th District? A Yes. Q What was his assignment during that period? MR. BATTLE: His assignment or -BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Officer Rodgers' assignment during that period? Page 139 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MS. HARRIS: Join. 1 MR. BATTLE: Same. 2 BY THE WITNESS: 3 4 A I don't recall having any conversation with the mayor regarding IPRA. In 5 6 fact, I'm going to say, at this point, no, I 7 didn't. BY MR. MORRISSEY: 8 Q Did you ever have any conversation 9 with Mayer Emanuel regarding the code of 10 silence in the police department? 11 MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, relevance 12 and this is really getting at being 13 harassing, not just to the deponent but 14 also the mayor of the city. 15 MS. HARRIS: I'm going to object, 16 assumes facts not in evidence, foundation. 17 MR. BATTLE: And I'm going to object 18 to foundation. 19 THE WITNESS: Answer? 20 MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. 21 BY THE WITNESS: 22 23 A I don't believe there is a code of 24 silence in the police department, no more than Page 141 A To my recollection, he had multiple assignments. Q What do you recall his assignments were? A Patrol and lockup. Q In April of 2011, what were the responsibilities of a lockup keeper in the 6th District? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection, competence. MS. HARRIS: I'll join. MR. BATTLE: And he's not a (30(b)(6) witness. You're asking him for his personal knowledge, correct? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q All of these questions, sir, are based on your personal knowledge. A Personal knowledge? Manage lockup operations and manage the prisoners. Q Would the lockup keeper in the 6th District have a post? A Have a what? Q Have a post. A A stationary post? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 62 of 107 PageID #:1370 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 37 (Pages 142 to 145) Page 142 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Correct. A No. Q Would that individual have a designated desk? A A designated desk? Q Correct. A I don't know what designated desk -I don't know how to answer that. I wouldn't -I don't know how to answer that. MR. BATTLE: So ask him to rephrase the question because usually that helps. BY THE WITNESS: A Yeah, could you rephrase that? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was there a desk in the 6th District lockup in April of 2011? A There's multiple desks in the lockup, 6th District lockup. Q How many desks? A I don't recall but at least two, two or three. I don't know if you call them desks, more like work stations. Q Would each work station have a computer? Page 144 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A I have been out of that district going on five years, so I don't recall at this point. Q Do you know whether that camera was operational? A I have been out of that district five years. I don't recall at this point. Q If equipment was not operational in the 6th District, to your knowledge, would there be records generated to reflect that information? A As a matter of policy, I believe so. Q What is that log called? A I'm sorry? Q Based on your understanding of the policy at the time, how would the 6th District make a record that equipment was not operational? A Various ways. You can notify the command office or equipment and supplies or our IT section depending upon the nature of the outage and the damage. Q If a surveillance camera was not operational in April of 2011, to your Page 143 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A I don't recall. Some do. Some don't. Q Did each work station have a telephone? A I don't recall if each work station has a telephone. Q In April of 2011, to your knowledge, did the 6th District lockup have a camera? A Yes. Q Where was the camera located? A The camera was in the processing area, I believe. Q To your knowledge, what was the purpose of that camera? A Photograph prisoners. Photograph processed individuals. I don't want to call them prisoners. Photograph processed individuals. Q Was there a surveillance camera in the lockup of the 6th District in April of 2011, to your knowledge? A I'm going to say possibly. Q Where was that surveillance camera possibly located? Page 145 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 knowledge, who would you report that to? A It depends on the nature of the outage. If it was a physical nature, it would be general services. If it was a technical nature, it would be IT -- I mean, a software-based database issue. Q When you were assigned to the 6th District, did you ever patrol with Officer Rodgers? A Not that I can recall, no. It's possible we have been on the street; but in terms of patrolling together, you mean working together or being out in the district at the same time being on the street at the same time. Q What about in the same car with Officer Rodgers patrolling the streets? A No, no. Q When you were a lieutenant in the 6th District, did you ever work lockup? A Lockup duties were a part of my function. Q As a lieutenant in the 6th District, what would you do in the lockup? A Check the facility, check the TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 63 of 107 PageID #:1371 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 38 (Pages 146 to 149) Page 146 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 operations and monitor prisoners. Q In April of 2011, did the 6th District lock up female arrestees? A Yes. Q Where in the 6th District would the CPD lock up female arrestees? A I'm sorry? Q What part of the -- Strike that. In April of 2011, where in the 6th District would female arrestees be locked up? A Why would they be locked up? Q Where would they be locked up? A In the facilities, in the general prisoner processing facilities. Q In April of 2011, would the 6th District house female arrestees overnight in the 6th District? A It depends on operational needs. I don't know if they get overnight as a policy, so I can't answer that. Q In April of 2011, did you work with Officer Sutton? A We were assigned to the same watch temporarily. Page 148 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MR. MORRISSEY: Training officer. MR. BATTLE: A training officer. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was Officer Sutton a training officer in April of 2011? MS. HARRIS: I'm going to object on foundation, speculation and form. MR. BATTLE: You can answer, if you know. BY THE WITNESS: A I don't know, a formal training officer or informal training officer. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q What's the difference between a formal and informal training officer? MS. HARRIS: Objection, foundation, speculation. MS. KUPE-ARION: And competence as a (30(b)(6) witness, for not being one. MR. BATTLE: And I'll join in those objections. Go ahead and answer, if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A If she was designated as a field Page 147 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Which watch was that? A I believe it was the second watch. Q What hours of the second watch? A They varied. Q Can you give me the range? A From approximately 4:00 o'clock in the morning until 6:00 o'clock in the afternoon, early evening. Q Did you ever patrol with Officer Sutton? A No. Q To your recollection, what were Officer Sutton's duties in April of 2011? MS. HARRIS: I'm going to object on speculation, foundation. BY THE WITNESS: A I believe she was assigned to a beat car on that day. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Was she a training officer in April of 2011? MR. BATTLE: What's that? MS. HARRIS: Counsel, what did you say? Page 149 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 training officer, she would be a formal training officer. If she was not designated, she would be an acting or a temporary field training officer. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know an officer by the name of Clifford? A No, I don't know him personally. Q Did you supervise Officer Clifford in April of 2011? A I supervised an entire watch, and I would say he's one of them. Q On April 10th, 2011, were you the watch commander in the 6th District? A I was the acting watch commander. Q What were your responsibilities as the acting watch commander? A Managed the duties of subordinate personnel. Q As a lieutenant in the 6th District, how frequently would you act as the watch commander? A You have to give me a baseline to formulate a response on. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 64 of 107 PageID #:1372 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 39 (Pages 150 to 153) Page 150 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Did it occur once a week? A It varied. Q On April 10th, 2011, were you familiar with how to function in the capacity as the acting watch commander in the 6th District? A Yes. Q In April of 2011, to your knowledge, were there any general orders or special orders regarding how department members should interact with arrestees known to have mental illness? MR. BATTLE: Basing that on your personal knowledge, go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A There were directives that addressed that, I believe. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q After April of 2011, are you aware of a CPD general order relating to that issue? A That's kind of broad, could you be a little bit more specific. Q What's the difference between a GO and a directive? Page 152 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q What did it vary on? A There's written directives. There's on-the-job training, there's video directives and there was a combination of all three in addition to classroom didactic. Q In April of 2011, were you aware of any training by the CPD with how to interact with an arrestee in the department, in the police department, known to have mental illness? MR. BATTLE: I'm going to object to that. You have characterized mental health issues or mentally ill persons, but that's rather vague and overly broad and it doesn't really -- There's no real definition of it. You could be schizophrenic. You could be psychotic. You could be borderline, you know, PTSD. There's no real definition of that type of person. So we're not sure exactly what you're targeting. MR. MORRISSEY: Okay. MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. You can Page 151 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A A GO is an acronym. A directive is a standing order dispersed through an organization. Q Is there any difference to your knowledge -- based on your knowledge between a general order and a directive? A General order is, by nature, a directive but not all directives are general orders. Q What CPD directive was in effect in April of 2011 relating to arrestees with mental illness? A Sir, I would have to review the order in order to formulate a correct response. Q Are you familiar with the training that CPD members had in April of 2011 when they encountered an arrestee with mental illness? MS. KUPE-ARION: Based on his own knowledge? MR. MORRISSEY: Yes. BY THE WITNESS: A Speaking on my own knowledge and not the city of Chicago department policy, it varied. Page 153 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 answer, if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A I concur with counsel. If you're talking about mental illness within the capacity of an aberration, you have individuals with attention deficit disorders, you've got gifted individuals and you've got other individuals that have high levels of interface interaction with those of emotional intelligence, and you've got those that have a deficit in those cognitive skills. So you have to be more specific as to that training. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Were you given training about how a department member would interact with people with those various mental illnesses differently? A If you could be more specific with the mental illness, I would be in a better position to answer it, I believe. Q Well, did the city give you training about circumstances where you would treat certain individuals differently with mental illness than other individuals? TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 65 of 107 PageID #:1373 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 40 (Pages 154 to 157) Page 154 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A The city is not in a position in my estimation to train me as a psychologist or psychiatrist. I don't think that's a response I can formulate. Q Do you remember giving a statement to IPRA relating to your involvement with Rita King? A Yes. Q When was the last time you reviewed that statement? A I did a cursory review of it a couple of days ago but nothing in depth. Q Have you ever reviewed that statement in depth? A No. Q Did you have an attorney present when you gave that statement? A No. Q Did you have the option to have one? A Did I have the option to have an attorney at that time? In the command level, essentially, no, you don't get an attorney. Q Who told you you didn't have the ability to have an attorney present? Page 156 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 cursory review. BY THE WITNESS: A I would have to review the statement in order to make that determination. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Were you provided the opportunity to review the statement after you gave the statement to IPRA? A You mean directly there? Q Correct. A No. Q Are you aware that the statement was written up by a court reporter? A If that's what you have in your hand, I would assume it was. Q Do you remember on April 10th, 2011 Officer Sutton asking you to come to lock up to assist with Ms. King? A I don't recall who asked me to come to the lockup to assist with Ms. King. I really don't recall. Q Would you agree your memory was more fresh when you gave the statement to IPRA than it is today relating to the incidents with Page 155 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A It's based on if you retain your union status as a lieutenant and pay the requisite dues, the union from which you received your appointment would give you an attorney but; if you didn't, then they wouldn't. Q Could you have paid out of pocket to retain a lawyer to represent you during that statement? A I could have. Q Would you agree that you gave the statement on November 7, 2013 to Investigator Franko? A I would have to review the documents. Q When you gave that statement, were you telling the truth? A I tell the truth in all of my sworn statements whether court or administrative hearings. I stand by what I say. Q Is there anything in your statement that you would like to change? MR. BATTLE: Objection, do you want him to review the entire statement and then ask that question? He said he gave it a Page 157 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Ms. King? MR. BATTLE: Related to the questions as in that statement? BY THE WITNESS: A Are you saying that the statement -my recollection was better at the time I gave that statement than it is now? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Correct. A No, I'm going to say that because of the relative innocuous events, when I mean innocuous, I'm not downplaying the severity of her alleged injuries that did not occur at my hand. I'm just saying that in the totality because I do not recall all of the minutia of that statement at that time or the statement I gave to IPRA. I do not recall all of the -all of the -- the entire incident. I just have a salient recollection. Q Do you remember being asked these questions and giving these answers, Question: On 10 April 2011, Ms. Rita King was arrested by Officers Roslyn Sutton and Dennis Clifford and transported into the 6th District station. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 66 of 107 PageID #:1374 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 41 (Pages 158 to 161) Page 158 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Please tell me the circumstances regarding your initial contact with Ms. King while in the 6th District station. Answer: I went to the lockup because the officer stated that she was drunk or high and had mental issues, and they were having problems processing her and controlling her. Question: So both officers talked with you? Answer: Yes. Question: Officer Sutton? Answer: Primarily Officer Sutton but both of them pretty much echoed each other's statements and assessments. Do you remember being asked those questions and giving those answers? MR. BATTLE: I'm going to object because it's improper impeaching. MR. MORRISSEY: I'm not impeaching him. MR. BATTLE: Yeah, you're not impeaching him. You're asking him -MR. MORRISSEY: It's -MR. BATTLE: Let me finish my objection, Counsel. You wonder why I talk over you and I raise my voice. That's why. Page 160 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 objection. MR. BATTLE: That's what I'm trying to do, but you stopped me. MR. MORRISSEY: Are you going to instruct your client not to answer? MR. BATTLE: I'm going to make my objection. MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. MR. BATTLE: Do you want me to do that first before you finish? MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. That's fine. MR. BATTLE: Can I make it now? MR. MORRISSEY: You can do whatever you want. MR. BATTLE: I object because I think that's improperly impeaching. I think you're trying to get him to verify a statement that he's already verified and indicated that it was truthful, and I think that that's an improper question and it doesn't have foundation. MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. MR. BATTLE: That's all I wanted to Page 159 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 I'm trying to make an objection. Whether you agree with it or not, I understand. MR. MORRISSEY: I never asked him a question to impeach him. I asked him whether he -- It's not impeachment. MR. SCHUMANN: So what is it? MR. MORRISSEY: What is it? MR. SCHUMANN: Yeah. MR. MORRISSEY: It's a statement by a party. MR. SCHUMANN: Yeah, but you have the statement in your hands. MR. BATTLE: So the statement speaks for itself. MR. SCHUMANN: So why are you asking him about the statement? MR. MORRISSEY: Because I'm asking him whether he was asked those questions and gave those answers. That's my only question. MR. BATTLE: Right, do you understand that that's an improper question for a deposition? MR. MORRISSEY: You can make that Page 161 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 do. MR. MORRISSEY: That's fine. MR. BATTLE: You can answer, if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A That's my recollection. If I made a statement to IPRA and I signed the statement or I agreed to it, I stand by the content of my responses, each and every one; but if you're going to ask me do I have a better recollection then as I do now, and I'm going to tell you I don't recall the incident any better now than I did then. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q The only question was do you recall being asked those questions and giving those answers to IPRA? A Those specific questions, no, I don't recall being asked those specific questions. Q Would you like me to show you the transcript where you were asked those questions and you gave those answers? A Yeah, I'm not denying it but I have given lots of statements, and I don't recall TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 67 of 107 PageID #:1375 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 42 (Pages 162 to 165) Page 162 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 each and every one. Q Did Officer Sutton tell you Ms. King was either high, drunk or had mental issues? A That's the information I got from both of them. Q Where did both of these officers tell you that information? A What do you mean "where"? In the 6th District police station. Q Correct. Where in the 6th District? A I don't recall exactly where. It might have been in an office, might have been in the hallway, might have been in the lockup area. Might have been in the processing area, might have been a combination of all four. I don't recall specifically where. Q Did either Officer Sutton or Officer Clifford tell you why they were having problems processing and controlling Ms. King in the lockup? A Did they tell me why they were having problems processing her? Q Correct. A I guess due to -- Page 164 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 the room. BY THE WITNESS: A Possibly. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q What do you remember either Officer Sutton or Clifford telling you about their efforts to encourage Ms. King to cooperate in the lockup? A I don't recall the entire context of the conversation. It was just a general conversation. They brought her in the lockup, tried to process her. She wasn't cooperating. Q Did either Officer Sutton or Clifford tell you how long Ms. King had been in the lockup and was not cooperating? A I don't recall if they did. It's entirely possible. Q Is there anything that could refresh your memory about that issue? A You can present me with any documents regarding that specific incident. I'll do my best. Q Did you take any notes after Officer Sutton or Clifford approached you? Page 163 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q I'm not asking you to guess. I'm asking did they -- did Officer Sutton -A I was responding to your question. If you want to be -MR. BATTLE: Just answer his question. BY THE WITNESS: A -- rude about it, I'll -- Okay, repeat your question. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did either Officer Sutton or Officer Clifford tell you -A I don't remember. Q -- why they were having problems processing and controlling Ms. King in the lockup? A I don't remember. Q Did either Officer Sutton or Clifford tell you the efforts they made to encourage Ms. King to cooperate in the lockup? MR. BATTLE: You're talking about prior to? MR. MORRISSEY: Prior to coming in. MR. BATTLE: Prior to you going in Page 165 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Did I take any notes? Q Correct. A Not that I can recall. Q Did you have an office in the 6th District in April of 2011? A The watch commander had an office, and I was working out of there. Q Where is the watch commander's office? A Inside the 6th District station. Q Where specifically in the 6th District? A First floor, south end of the building. Q Where within that building is the lockup area in the 6th District? A South end of the building. Q Based on your experience -A First floor. Q How far is the watch commander's office from the lockup in 6th District? A Are you talking about the lockup facility? Across the hall. I don't know the exact square footage. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 68 of 107 PageID #:1376 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 43 (Pages 166 to 169) Page 166 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q How long would it take you in April of 2011 to walk from the watch commander's office to the lockup? A It depends, generally within a minute. Q When you were first approached by Officer Clifford, did he tell you whether Ms. King was being physically abusive? A I don't recall any conversation or any contact I had with Mr. Clifford, Officer Clifford, at this time. Q And would the same answer be true for Officer Sutton at this time? A I don't recall the specifics of the conversation, just the generalities. Q And does that generality include the fact that there was an arrestee in the lockup that was either drunk, high or had mental illness and there were problems processing and controlling her? A I'm going to say that was factual. Q Did Officer Sutton or Clifford tell you how they were having problems controlling Ms. King in the lockup? Page 168 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 and they're prohibited by law and department policy, and they can't search. It depends on the legalities and nature of the stop. Q Did either Officer Clifford or Officer Sutton tell you they were fearful for their safety when you were initially approached by them? A Fearful for his safety? They had apprehensions about engaging her. Q Did they tell you they had apprehensions about engaging Ms. King in the lockup when you were initially approached by them? A Yes. Q What did they tell you specifically? A I can't tell you specifically. That was five years ago. Q Did they explain their apprehensions about engaging Ms. King? A They gave me the generalities regarding their apprehensions, but I observed her behavior for myself. Q Did either Officer Sutton or Clifford tell you Ms. King was crying in the lockup? Page 167 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Specifically? Q Specifically. A I guess overall physically handcuffing and physically handling -- I misspoke. Physically handling and handcuffing. Q Did they tell you whether Ms. King was handcuffed in the 6th District lockup? A Don't recall that. Q Are arrestees typically handcuffed when they are in the lockup being processed? A It depends on the circumstances. Q Under what circumstances would he or she be handcuffed? A The level of combativeness or the inherent threat to the officers or other prisoners. Q Are arrestees typically searched before they are brought into the 6th District lockup for processing? A Yes. Q And that search would include a search for weapons, correct? A It depends on the circumstances of the search. Some of the searches are intrusive Page 169 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Both of them I think at one point said she was engaging in behavior which entailed, at one point, crying. Q Was your district short on staff that day? A That's really not a question I can answer because it all depends on operational needs. Q As you sit here today, do you recall any operational needs that day that strained your staff? A I'm going to say that the district was ensconced within one of the highest crime -THE REPORTER: Was what? MR. BATTLE: Ensconced. THE WITNESS: E-n -THE REPORTER: I got it. THE WITNESS: I've been to college. I can help. BY THE WITNESS: A During that time, during that frame -During that frame of time, we had significant issues with public violence and that in order to address the public violence, I made the TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 69 of 107 PageID #:1377 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 44 (Pages 170 to 173) Page 170 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 effort to ensure adequate manpower and coverage to our affected areas in order to mitigate the violence. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Prior to April 10 of 2011, had you ever encountered Ms. King before? A I'm going to say yes. Q How many times prior to April 10, 2011 did you encounter Ms. King? A To the best of my recollection, a minimum of three times. Q Can you tell me the first time you encountered her? A I can't recall the first time I encountered her. I don't recall. Q The second time? A I can tell you previous occasions. I can't give you the first, second or third time. Q Tell me -- Explain your recollection of the encounters you have had with Ms. King prior to April 10, 2011? A There were at least one or two occasions where I observed her outside on the street engaging in acts of suspected Page 172 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Do you know whether Ms. King's name was on any of those lists? A I don't know. Don't recall. Q After April 10, 2011, did you ever encounter Ms. King? A If I did, I don't recall. Q Do you know whether Ms. King smoked cigarettes in April of 2011? A I don't know what her habits were in terms of smoking. Q Did you ever observe her associate with your officers smoking? A I don't recall her socializing with any officers smoking. I don't recall that. Q Prior to Officers Sutton or Clifford approaching you on April 10th, 2011, did you know whether Ms. King was in custody in your district? A No. Q As the acting watch commander -Strike that. Did either Officers Sutton or Clifford tell you that they had Rita King in your lockup? MR. BATTLE: At what point? Page 171 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 prostitution. There was another time where she was frequently a guest of our lobby, and she would stay there and sleep and frequent during times of inclement weather. Q Do you recall whether that was in 2011 when you observed Mr. -- Ms. King on the streets engaging in alleged acts of prostitution? A I don't recall the exact dates and times. Q Would your district allow people to come in and get out of the cold? A Absolutely. Q Was there a specific area in the district where people could congregate to get out of the cold? A A specific area, they pretty much had free rein over the public area of the lobby. Q Did your district record the names of who stayed at times in the public area of the district? A For those who were seeking permanent or long-term shelter, I believe they did. Page 173 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When they initially approached you. A When they initially approached me? Q Yes. A You mean did they name her by name? Q Correct. A Not that I could recall. It's possible. Q Prior to April 10, 2011, did you know Ms. King had mental illness? A Depending upon what your definition of mental illness is, I would have to ask you for clarification. Q Well, did you use the term "mental issues" when you gave a statement to IPRA? A That's entirely possible. I would have to review my IPRA statement. Q What do you mean by "mental issues" when you use it? A That's pretty much like I inferred earlier. It's a pretty broad standard. It could be somebody with a high level of intelligence, high level of emotional intelligence. It could be somebody with TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 70 of 107 PageID #:1378 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 45 (Pages 174 to 177) Page 174 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 bipolar manic depressive. It could be somebody who is suicidal. It could be somebody with dyslexia. Q On the one or two occasions where you observed Ms. King prior to April 10, 2011, did you think she had mental issues? MR. BATTLE: Objection. That mischaracterizes his testimony. Go ahead and answer. BY THE WITNESS: A She previously -- I didn't think she had anything until she told me. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Prior to April 10th, 2011, did she ever tell you that she had mental issues? A When I stopped her on the street, she made comments that she had mental health issues among her substance abuse and her general unlawfulness, which she sometimes masked her unlawfulness with the pretense of it being mental health issues. Q When you stopped Ms. King on the streets, did you arrest her? A Did I arrest Ms. King? Page 176 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 streets and reported to have mental health issues along with other concerns like substance abuse problems, correct? A She had other concerns like she was breaking the law, being belligerent, being confrontational and being uncooperative. Q Did she explain the mental health issues that she suffered from that day? A She said I'm bipolar depressive, but I got other things going. Q That's bipolar depressive? A She said she was bipolar and manic. Q Manic depressive? A She said bipolar and manic. She was all over the place. I believe the one time I contacted her, she was involved in some kind of confrontation and she was agitated based on that confrontation. Q Do you know whether any officer did a search of her when she was engaged by the CPD? MR. BATTLE: At which time? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q At the time when you were present and she was stopped on the street. Page 175 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Correct. A No. Q Did you review her identification card when you stopped her on the streets prior to April 10, 2011? A No. That would have been for a subordinate officer to do. It's entirely possible that one was done, but I don't recall. Q Were you in the same vehicle as a subordinate officer? A I don't recall if I was in a vehicle with a subordinate officer or not. Q Do you know whether the subordinate officer created a contact card? A I know that she's had contact cards previously done on her. Q Have you ever been present when an officer or a member of the CPD generated a contact card for Ms. King? A On her specifically, I cannot recall being present when anybody did a field contact card on Ms. King. Q So you were present on at least one occasion when Ms. King was stopped on the Page 177 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A I would have to review department records to make that determination. Q Was she acting crazy during that time? A I wouldn't -- Define "crazy." Q So what else do you recall when you stopped Ms. King prior to April of 20 -- April 10, 2011 when she reported that she was bipolar and manic? A There was a couple of times I think I had encounters with her. A couple of times she was in the station where we keep her and feed her and take care of her and keep her off the street. Then she would get confrontational with other patrons and homeless individuals, then she would be ejected. Q So prior to April 10, 2011, there was more than one occasion when Ms. King was asked to leave the 6th District because she was being confrontational while she was seeking services? A She wasn't seeking services. She was seeking shelter; and I mean seeking shelter, I'm talking about a place to sleep and hang out. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 71 of 107 PageID #:1379 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 46 (Pages 178 to 181) Page 178 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q So prior to April 10, 2011, there were multiple times when Ms. King was asked to leave the 6th District when she was seeking shelter because she was confrontational? A No, you're making it sound like we threw her out because she was confrontational. She had other issues. She wasn't seeking shelter. She already had shelter. She was being confrontational and impairing the operational needs in the facility, security and the security of patrons and the security of other individuals seeking services as well. That being said, that's why she asked to be ejected, and I'm not talking about just ejected. She had the option of getting in the wagon and getting mental health treatment if we transported her there; and she would decline and storm out the station on her own. Q And this occurred more than once prior to April 10, 2011? A I'm going to say to the best of my recollection, yes, it did. Q More than two times? A I don't know exactly because I didn't Page 180 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 shelter. She was laying in the lobby sleeping or getting into conflicts in the station. Q So you knew prior to April 10, 2011 she had been in the 6th District as a free person sleeping in the lobby? A Yes. Q Did you ever observe her being asked to leave by members of the department in the 6th District prior to April 10th, 2011? A I believe I might have been there on one occasion, but she was there so regularly. It's hard to discern that information. Q When she was asked to leave on the possible one occasion when she was in the 6th District, did she self-report to members of the 6th District that she was bipolar and manic? A Every time she indicated those issues in my presence, we said we'll take you to Jackson Park Hospital, and she would decline. She would storm out the station. Q Would she be banned from the station permanently? A No. Q Did you observe Ms. King engage in Page 179 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 focus on Ms. King per se. So I don't know absolutely everything or every situation every circumstance. I just have a cursory recollection of Ms. King hanging around the station and Ms. King pursuant to this event right here. Q But prior to April 10th, 2011 you knew her name? A I knew her name? Q Correct, is that fair to say? A Did I know her entire name? I'm going to say I did know her first name. I don't know if I knew her entire name. Q And it was in your presence that she was asked to leave the 6th District prior to April 10, 2011 because she was being confrontational? A No, that was not in my presence. That was information that I received from officers regularly assigned to the desk. Q Were you ever present when Ms. King was in the 6th District seeking shelter prior to April 10, 2011? A I seen her -- She wasn't seeking Page 181 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 prostitution prior to April 10, 2011? A Suspected prostitution, yes. Q Do you recall -- What do you recall from that suspected prostitution? A She was standing on the corner or on the street sometimes with minimum garb flagging down vehicles occupied by solitary males. Q Did you have the ability to arrest her during that time? A And charge her with soliciting, yes. Q And you decided against charging her? A Yes. Q Why? A Because, Number 1, it's discretion. Number 2, I consider a lot of prostitution to be more of a victimization, a self-victimization, as opposed to an overt criminal act. Number 3, she had substantive mental health issues that outweighed the need for directed enforcement. We can make a determination if -- We can make a determination to bypass charging and direct people to mental health services, but they have to agree for the most part. Q So after you were approached by TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 72 of 107 PageID #:1380 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 47 (Pages 182 to 185) Page 182 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 either Officer Sutton or Clifford, how soon did you go into the lockup? A I don't know all of the specifics, maybe within a couple of minutes. Q And when you walked into the lockup, where was Ms. King positioned? A To the best of my recollection, she was on the bench sitting down; and then she'd stand up and then she'd walk around for a bit and then she would sit back down. Q When you first stepped into the lockup, was Officer Rodgers present? A I couldn't tell you. I can't recall if he was present or not. Q When you stepped into the lockup, was Officer Sutton present in the lockup? A I'm going to say, yes. Q When you first stepped into the lockup, was Officer Rodgers -- was Officer Clifford present in the lockup? A It's possible, but I don't recall what Clifford looks like. Q When you stepped foot in the lockup on April 10, 2011, did you immediately Page 184 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 BY THE WITNESS: A Could you rephrase that, please? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q All right. I'm going to -- Do you remember being asked these questions and giving these answers when you gave your statement to IPRA, Question: Okay, so what is the protocol if someone comes back there into the lockup area and they are refusing to cooperate? Answer: What I usually do -- What we usually do is we try to persuade them to cooperate. Eventually, they do. If they do not cooperate by -- generally by the tour of the duty or by the time that the relieving watch commander comes on, we note that in our records and let the relieving watch commander know that this person will not be fingerprinted or photographed, so we have to hold them over; but during the tour of duty, if they allow us to fingerprint and photograph them, then we just process them. We get a lot of people that initially don't want to cooperate; but when they calm down, they subsequently do. Do you remember being asked those Page 183 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 recognize the arrestee was Rita King? A Did I immediately recognize her from the lobby, yes. From being in the lobby and getting shelter and us feeding her and taking care of her and giving her shelter, I recall her being in the 6th District lockup, yes. Q When you first saw Ms. King, was she crying? A She was -- To the best of my recollection, she was crying and she was yelling and then she was screaming and then she was argumentative. Q In April of 2011, was there a protocol at the 6th District if somebody is in the lockup and they are refusing to cooperate? MR. BATTLE: Objection, incomplete hypothetical. MS. HARRIS: I will join in that. MR. BATTLE: Do you understand what he's asking? THE WITNESS: No. MR. BATTLE: You need to ask him to rephrase. Page 185 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 questions and giving those answers? BY THE WITNESS: A You characterized that as a protocol when it's pretty much an operational -- you said it's a 6th District protocol, but it's not a 6th District protocol. It's a department-wide procedure. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you remember being asked those questions and giving those answers when you gave a statement to IPRA? A I would have to look at my IPRA statement in order to refresh my recollection. Q If I showed you that question and answer, would you be able to answer that question? I'm from Page 390 and Line 7 down to Line 22. And my question is were you asked those questions and did you give those answers when you gave a statement to IPRA? A Yeah, that's a very badly worded question, what is the protocol if someone comes back there in the lockup area and they're refusing to cooperate? There is no set TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 73 of 107 PageID #:1381 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 48 (Pages 186 to 189) Page 186 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 protocol. The general orders are -Q Well, Mr. Evans -MR. BATTLE: Objection. Allow him to finish the question (sic) and then you can -MR. MORRISSEY: He's not being responsive. MR. BATTLE: You can clarify and say it wasn't responsive, but you do have to allow him an opportunity to finish his answer. MR. MORRISSEY: But the question was -MR. BATTLE: I understand the question. If he's not responsive, you can ask him to clarify, but you do have to give every witness an opportunity to answer your question. MR. MORRISSEY: I don't believe that's normal protocol. You can ask him on your examination of Mr. Evans. MR. BATTLE: Okay, listen. I don't know if you have ever tried a case but the protocol -MR. MORRISSEY: I've tried several Page 188 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 general orders are a misnomer. The general orders are not a hard and fast rule. They provide a basis, guideline and parameter for operational procedure within the police department. Just because -- You can deviate from department directives as long as you have a justified reason for doing so. You have to look at the spirit of the incident as opposed to the letter of the law relevant to implementing a lot of those department orders. The department orders are a guideline and nothing more. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Why don't we go back to the question I had, and I can read this portion and the only question is were you asked these questions and did you provide these answers? Do you want me to reread the question? A No, I'm going to, just for expeditious' sake, I'm going to say based on the documentation in your hand, those are my responses to the best of my recollection. Q Did you review Officer Rodgers' deposition transcript prior to coming here Page 187 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 cases. MR. BATTLE: Okay, well, I've tried a bunch more than several. The protocol typically is you have to allow him to answer your question whether it's a deposition or whether it's at a trial proceeding. If he doesn't answer properly, you can turn around and go back in and say, listen, that was not responsive. Here's my question. However, if he doesn't start off the way you want him to, you can't cut him off at the point of a deposition and cut off and say that's not what I want you to say. That is very improper. That's very improper. MR. MORRISSEY: Let's see what the client has to say. MR. BATTLE: Finish your answer. BY THE WITNESS: A There is no district protocol. There is a citywide or police department-wide operational procedure, and it's predicated upon the edicts of the general orders, and the Page 189 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 today to testify? A No. Q Have you ever reviewed his deposition testimony in this case? A No. Q Have you reviewed Officer Clifford's deposition testimony prior to coming here today to testify? A No. Q Did I ask you about Sutton's deposition testimony yet? A No, you didn't. Q Have you reviewed her deposition testimony prior to coming here today? A No. Q Are you aware that each of those officers -- Well, I think just Sutton and Clifford gave a statement to IPRA. Did you review their statement to IPRA? A No. Q Is the general protocol in the 6th District if a female arrestee is brought there that your officers when you worked there in April of 2011 would fingerprint them, process TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 74 of 107 PageID #:1382 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 49 (Pages 190 to 193) Page 190 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 them and then send them to the 5th District, which would be Area 2? A What do you mean, is that a general protocol? It depends on the circumstances. Sometimes females are processed in the 6th District. Sometimes they are sent to 111th Street. Q And is 111th Street the 5th District? A It's an area-wide facility, yes. Q And do they have female-designated lockups? A Yes. Q Where in the 6th District is there a secure area to place a female arrestee? A Within the physical facility of the 6th District lockup? Q Correct. A They are separated rooms and separated -- rooms separated and you can place a female arrestee in one of those separated processing rooms. Q And when a female arrestee is placed in one of those rooms, is she generally handcuffed to a ring on the wall? Page 192 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A To the best of my recollection, I asked him what was going on and what's wrong with her. Q Did Officer Clifford respond to you? A I think both of the officers responded. Q And is this the second conversation you had with these two officers? A I don't recall how many conversations I've had. I might have had multiple smaller conversations on the way to the lockup. Q What did the officers say when you asked what's going on? MS. HARRIS: Objection, form, vague. Go ahead. THE WITNESS: Answer? MS. HARRIS: You can answer. MR. BATTLE: You can answer. BY THE WITNESS: A What did they say in regards to Ms. King's behavior. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q What did they say in response to your question when you arrived in the lockup and Page 191 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Yes. Sometimes she is. Sometimes she isn't. It depends on her risk factors and her cooperativeness. Q On April 10, 2011, do you know whether those rooms were occupied in the morning? A Some of them were occupied, I believe. I don't recall. Some of them weren't. Q When you arrived in the lockup and you observed Ms. King there, did you have a conversation with Officer Clifford regarding the arrestee? A A specific conversation? Q Correct. A Not that I can recall, not a specific conversation. Q Did you have a general conversation with Officer Clifford when you immediately arrived in the 6th District lockup and saw Ms. King? A I asked him a question or two, and he responded. Q What did you ask Officer Clifford? Page 193 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 said what's going on? A In a general search, she was uncooperative, high on narcotics mostly and acting irrational. Q Do you know specifically who gave you that response? A No, I don't. Q When you entered the lockup and you first observed Ms. King, do you know who responded to your question what's wrong with her? A That was five years ago. I don't recall all of the minute details of that exchange. Q Did any officer present in the lockup explain to you when you arrived the steps they took to encourage Ms. King to cooperate? A They said they tried to get her to submit to fingerprinting and photograph her. Q Who gave you that response? A Multiple officers. Q Can you tell me which ones? A Once again, five-year window, I cannot be specific as to -- but both of them TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 75 of 107 PageID #:1383 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 50 (Pages 194 to 197) Page 194 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 were pretty much echoing the sentiments of the other. Q Was Officer Rodgers also echoing this message? A I think Officer Rodgers was standing nearby. I don't recall any verbal exchange that he and I had. Q Did Officer Clifford or Sutton tell you how long they tried to encourage Ms. King to submit to photographs and fingerprints? A I don't remember. Q Did either Officer Clinton or Sutton explain to you the efforts they took to encourage Ms. King to submit to photographs and fingerprints? A We had a very quick, brief and concise and fluid exchange due to the irrational and erratic behavior exhibited by Ms. King. We had an expeditious exchange because she was posing a threat and she was obstructing the operations of the facility. So we didn't have a long, drawn-out-Monday-morningtype conversation with each other. It was very Page 196 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 If they told me, and they probably did, but I don't recall. I do not recall at this time. Q When you entered the lockup, did you immediately approach Ms. King? A No, I talked to the officers first. Q And how long did that conversation take? A Very quick. Maybe less than a minute. Q And we've already discussed the content of the conversations, correct? A Yes. Q After this quick conversation with the officers, did you immediately approach Ms. King? A Immediately? I would say I approached her after we spoke. Q When you spoke to Officer Clifford and Sutton, how far away was Ms. King? A I don't recall the exact distance. Q Was it more than five feet away? A I'm going to say it depends because we are moving around the facility and so is she, so that varied. Page 195 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 quick, very brief, very concise. Q So the answer to my question, is it fair to say, you don't recall if Officer Sutton or Clifford told you the actions they took to encourage Ms. King to submit to photographs and fingerprints? MR. BATTLE: Objection. He just answered the question. BY THE WITNESS: A Both of them pretty much corroborated each of their accounts. They both said the same thing. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q But do you recall Sutton or Clifford telling you what steps each of them took to encourage Ms. King to submit to photographs and fingerprints? MR. BATTLE: Objection, asked and answered. BY THE WITNESS: A What specific steps? BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Correct. A No, I don't recall specific steps. Page 197 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Did you observe Ms. King when you had this conversation with Officer Sutton and Clifford? A I observed her, yes. Q And was she crying? A She was -- To my recollection, she would cry for a minute, and then she would get hostile; and then she would get agitated. She was displaying a variety of emotions. Q When you approached Ms. King, did you observe what Officer Sutton and Clifford did? A They were standing nearby. Q So did they approach Ms. King with you after this brief conversation? A No. Q When you initially approached Ms. King, how many feet were you from her body? A When I initially approached her, it varied, maybe three to five feet. I'm going to say under three feet, to the best of my recollection. Q And when you initially approached Ms. King, where was Officer Sutton? A I cannot tell you exactly where Officer Sutton was at this time. This was five TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 76 of 107 PageID #:1384 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 51 (Pages 198 to 201) Page 198 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 years ago. Q Where was Officer Clifford when you initially approached Ms. King? A I couldn't tell you where Officer Clifford was at this point. It was five years ago. In fact, I don't even remember what Officer Clifford looks like. Q Where was Officer Rodgers? A To the best of my recollection, Officer Rodgers may have been either at a work station or in the general area. Q When you approached Ms. King, did you ask her why she was crying? A I asked her why she was acting so irrational. Q Did she respond to your question? A She responded to some of them. A lot of her responses were incoherent, and she screamed and yelled and was agitated. So if you want me to say she gave a direct measure calm response, no, she did not. Q But she did respond to your question? A She didn't respond to all of my questions, no. Page 200 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 operational, feasible, for us to go in there process her as quickly as we can and get her out of our control. Do you remember being asked those questions and giving those answers to the IPRA investigator? A Yes, I remember that line of questioning. Q When you said we made a determination that because of her mental state and her admission that she was under narcotics that you wanted to get her out of the lockup as soon as possible, who were you referring to? A I was referring to Rita King. Q But you said "we made a determination," right? I can show you what you said. A Yeah, if I said that we made a determination, and that's my actual IPRA statement because a lot of them are rife with errors and partial information, if I said it and that's the IPRA statement that I gave, then I stand by any statement I gave to IPRA. Q Well, I'll show you. It's marked at Page 199 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Do you remember being asked these questions and giving these answers to the IPRA investigator, Question: And did she say why she was crying? Answer: Yeah, because she was mad at her boyfriend and she didn't want to go to jail, and then she said she was high on cocaine. She said she was high on cocaine. She had a fight with her boyfriend, and all she wanted to do was go home, and she was just crying and caterwauling and carrying on. Question: Okay, what did you do? Answer: Eventually, we made a determination that because of her mental state, because of her admission that she was under narcotics, the influence of narcotics, that because she had some mental issues -- Question: She said that? Answer: That's what she said. Question: Okay. Answer: We did not want to keep her in the lockup because there was a liability with it. So we tried to get her up, process her, get her out as quick as we can because we did not want to put her in the lockup especially for minor offenses like this and keep them locked up for a prolonged period of time. It's just more Page 201 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 393 and it's like 22 where you said "we made the determination;" do you see that? A Yes. Q Who were you referring to when you said "we"? Was that Officer Clifford and Sutton? A It was probably Officer Clifford, Sutton and Rodgers. Q And you also said that we did not want to keep her in the lockup because there's a liability with it? A That's correct. Q What did you mean by that? A Liability means that she poses a physical threat not only to the officers but she poses a physical threat to other arrestees and individuals -- arrestees and staff in the lockup as well. She's liable to physically attack them and anybody else in that District. So it was a risk management move. Q And you will agree that she was arrested for a minor offense? A I don't consider -- I'm going to consider that since it was a simple assault and TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 77 of 107 PageID #:1385 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 52 (Pages 202 to 205) Page 202 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 I forget what the other charge was, but they were two relatively minor offenses. Minor, I mean, they are not felony offenses. Q Did you make physical contact with Ms. King in the lockup on April 10, 2011? A Yes. Q How long after you first walked into the 6th District lockup did you make physical contact with Ms. King? And I'm talking about the time period. A I don't recall the time period. Q Do you recall whether it was a long time or a short time? A That's all relative. Q Do you know whether more than ten minutes passed between the time you walked into the 6th District lockup and the time you made physical contact with Ms. King? MR. BATTLE: Objection, speculation. You're asking him to guess. Go ahead and answer if you can. BY THE WITNESS: A Sir, I don't recall the exact timeframe I made physical contact with Page 204 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Q Where was Officer Clifford when you made contact with Ms. King? MS. HARRIS: Objection -A I don't remember exactly -MR. BATTLE: Hold on. Let her object. MS. HARRIS: I just want to object on vague and form. Go ahead. THE WITNESS: I'm sorry. MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. You can answer now. BY THE WITNESS: A I don't recall exactly where Officer Clifford was. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know where Officer Sutton was when you made physical contact with Ms. King? MS. HARRIS: Objection, vague, form, go ahead. MR. BATTLE: Go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A The only thing I could say was they were both in the same proximity. As to exactly where they were standing or where they were Page 203 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Ms. King. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q After you made physical contact with Ms. King, did she agree to be fingerprinted? A I'm sorry? Q After you made physical contact with Ms. King, did she agree to be fingerprinted and photographed? A That's a question -- It depends on what you mean by physical contact and the ensuing timeframe. Q Did you make physical contact more than one time on April 10, 2011 in the 6th District lockup with Ms. King's body? A I made numerous contacts, both attempted and actual. Q And after you made the numerous contacts with Ms. King, did she get fingerprinted and photographed? A I stated I made numerous attempts of contact with Ms. King, both actual and attempted. And after that process commenced, she subsequently agreed to be fingerprinted and photographed. Page 205 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 posted, I can't tell you. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Do you know where Officer Rodgers was when you made physical contact with Ms. King? A In the 6th District -MS. HARRIS: Objection, vague, form. Go ahead. THE WITNESS: I'm sorry. MS. HARRIS: Okay, go on. MR. BATTLE: I kind of anticipated those coming. Go ahead. BY THE WITNESS: A In the 6th District lockup. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q Did Officer Clifford assist you when you made physical contact with Rita King? A I don't recall what Officer Clifford looked like. So I can't really answer that question. Q Do you recall whether Officer Sutton assisted you when you made physical contact with Ms. King? A If you're saying assist in terms of a police presence and -- a police presence, yes. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 78 of 107 PageID #:1386 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 53 (Pages 206 to 209) Page 206 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 They provided a police presence and security, so I'm going to say yes. Q Did you observe Officer Sutton make physical contact with Ms. King? A Physical contact? I believe at one point she walked her over, but I don't recall anything outside of that. Q Where did she walk Ms. King over to? A I think she helped us walk Ms. King over to the -- I think she helped us walk Ms. King over to either the fingerprint or the photographing, the booking photo machine. Q Was that after you made physical contact with Ms. King? A I was making physical contact with Ms. King during the time that -- during, to and up to that time I walked her to the processing area, and that contact was both actual and attempted. Q Did you make physical contact on April 10, 2011 to Ms. King's head? A Yes. Q Did you also make physical contact to her arms? Page 208 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 screams, lucidity, crying and that would just be an ongoing cycle. Q During or after you used force to Ms. King, did she ever tell you that you caused her pain? A Did she tell me directly that I caused her pain? Q Correct. A No, she did not. Q In addition to Officer Sutton, Clifford and Rodgers, was there any other member of the police department present in the lockup when you approached Ms. King? A I don't recall. I don't believe so. Q When did you make the determination that after Ms. King was photographed and fingerprinted, she would be released from custody? A I don't know the exact timeframe in which I made that determination. Q Was it before or after you went to the lockup? A I'm sorry. Was it -Q Was it before or after you went to Page 207 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A Yes. MR. BATTLE: Let's take a break for one second. Your question is done, right? MR. MORRISSEY: Yeah. (WHEREUPON, a short break was had.) BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When you used physical force to Ms. King's head, was she crying? A She was acting irrational and engaging in -- She was crying prior to and afterwards. Q And is it fair to say during she was also crying? A You mean during? Q During the use of force to her head? A Entirely possible. I know she was acting really irrational during the entire process. Q And when you used physical force to her head, was she also screaming? A What do you mean was she screaming? She was screaming throughout the entire experience. Her behavior was intermittent, Page 209 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 the lockup and approached Ms. King? A I don't know. I'm going to say it had to be sometime afterwards. Q Why did you make a decision to release Ms. King? A It wasn't a felony offense. She was not wanted on a warrant. Her fingerprints were clear. There were no pending investigative alerts or any other reason to detain her. She was known to us. So if we had to bring her back into custody, we would pretty much know where to find her or she would find us; and because there was probably some incipient or ongoing public violence in that district, in order to minimize the downtime of my personnel, I made that determination. Q Do you know what a TRR is? A If that's the acronym for a Tactical Response Report, yes. Q Did you complete a TRR after you used force on Ms. King? A I don't know if you want to -- if that constitutes a force per se but, no, I did not do a TRR after my physical contact with TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 79 of 107 PageID #:1387 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 54 (Pages 210 to 213) Page 210 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 22 23 24 Ms. King. Q Did you create any report that you engaged Ms. King in the 6th District lockup on April 10, 2011? A Not that I can recall, no. Q Do you know whether any officer present in the lockup, Sutton, Clifford or Rodgers -- Strike that. Did you tell the IPRA investigator in November of 2013 that Ms. King was not acting like an active resisting arrestee when she was in the 6th District lockup? A Yes. Q What is an active resisting arrestee? A Active resisting is she engages in physical -- She engages or demonstrates physical behavior which constitutes or can be construed as a threat. Q Were you present when Ms. King was ph 21 A I don't recall if I was. I don't think so. It's possible but I don't recall being there. Q What do you next recall that day? Page 212 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A When I reported to him, he was chief of patrol. Q Is chief of patrol responsible for all of the districts? MS. KUPE-ARION: Objection to the form of the question and competence as well. BY THE WITNESS: A The chief of patrol is the primary law enforcement entity or primary law enforcement authority for Chicago Police Department patrol division. BY MR. MORRISSEY: Q When you were commander, do you know how many officers were assigned to the patrol division? A No, I don't. Q Is it the majority of the CPD officers? A Yes, that's safe to say. MR. MORRISSEY: I have nothing further. MR. BATTLE: Anybody have anything? MS. HARRIS: No. Page 211 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 A What do I next recall that day? Q Correct. A Leaving the lockup, performing the rest of my duties as an acting watch commander and reporting off duty. Q After Ms. King was photographed and fingerprinted, do you know whether she was escorted by one of the officers to a room and secured to a ring? A I don't -- I will say that that would be the procedure that we do. I don't know which officer did it, if any officer did it. I don't know which officer did it, but I'm going to say some officer did escort and maintain a presence with her. Q Do you know Chief Gulliford? A Yes. Q Did you report to him? A At that time? Q Not at that time but after this time. A A couple of years down the line, I reported to him. Q What was Chief Gulliford -- what was his title when you reported to him? Page 213 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 MS. KUPE-ARION: No. MR. BATTLE: I don't think I have anything to clarify. Just for the record, Pat, you know he's not taking the Fifth on anything, correct? You've asked all the questions you have for him? MR. MORRISSEY: I thought you told me he wasn't going to answer questions about his financial condition. MR. BATTLE: Right, that's the only portion. Everything else he's -- I mean, he's not pleading the Fifth as to the financial portion. He's just not answering questions that you and I are disagreeing on. MR. MORRISSEY: You told me earlier that he wouldn't be answering questions about his assets and net worth, right? MR. BATTLE: Yes. You understand that that's -- you understand why -- what I'm saying is that's not based on him pleading the Fifth Amendment. I'm saying that's based on the Court's previous order that you and I have discussed earlier TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 80 of 107 PageID #:1388 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 55 (Pages 214 to 217) Page 214 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 today. We have a fundamental disagreement about that. I think we can go back before the Judge and figure out what that disagreement is at the next status. It has nothing to do with him pleading the Fifth. It has more to do with we think that the Judge said do that 90 days out from trial; and since we don't have a trial date, that's why we're not talking about that. But all the questions you have with respect to pleading the Fifth as to the factual background, I want to make sure you've exhausted everything because he's not going to plead the Fifth at all at trial. MR. MORRISSEY: Do you want me to ask more questions? MR. BATTLE: I do not want you to ask any more questions. I just want to make sure you don't have any more questions. MR. SCHUMANN: The point is we don't want to see either later in a motion or later on down the line to a particular Page 216 1 2 3 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION RITA KING, Plaintiff, question he's taking the Fifth. We are giving you an opportunity to ask all questions however you want to do it, either here or submit it in an interrogatory later, but he is not taking the Fifth at this point. MR. BATTLE: And for the record, I think you have exhausted every question you can possibly ask this guy. MR. MORRISSEY: No, I'm done. MR. BATTLE: You're done? MR. MORRISSEY: Yeah. MR. BATTLE: Show signature is reserved. All right, we're good. MR. MORRISSEY: All right, thanks. FURTHER DEPONENT SAITH NOT..... ) ) 5 vs. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 ) No. 13 C 1937 ) GLENN EVANS, et al., ) ) Defendants. ) I, GLENN EVANS, being first duly sworn, on oath, say that I am the deponent in the aforesaid deposition, that I have read the foregoing transcript of my deposition, consisting of pages 1-216 inclusive, taken at the aforesaid time and place and that the foregoing is a true and correct transcript of my testimony so given. ____________________________ GLENN EVANS 18 19 20 21 22 SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO me before this ________ day of ___________________, A.D. 2016. _________________________ Notary Public 23 24 Page 215 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 ) ) 4 Page 217 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 STATE OF ILLINOIS ) ) ss: COUNTY OF C O O K ) I, Peggy A. Anderson, a Certified Shorthand Reporter in the State of Illinois do hereby certify: That previous to the commencement of the examination of the witness, the witness was duly sworn to testify the whole truth concerning the matters herein; That the foregoing deposition transcript was reported stenographically by me, was thereafter reduced to typewriting under my personal direction, and constitutes a true record of the testimony given and the proceedings had; That the said deposition was taken before me at the time and place specified; That the said deposition was adjourned as stated herein; That I am not a relative or employee or attorney or counsel, nor a relative or employee of such attorney or counsel for any of the parties hereto, nor interested directly or indirectly in the outcome of this action. TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 81 of 107 PageID #:1389 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 56 (Page 218) Page 218 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I do hereunto set my hand at Chicago, Illinois, this _______ day of ____________________, 2016. ______________________________________ Peggy A. Anderson Certified Shorthand Reporter License No. 084-003813 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 82 of 107 PageID #:1390 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 219 A aberration 153:5 abide 70:22 115:14 ability 19:23 20:17 55:4 124:10 129:23 154:24 181:8 able 185:15 absolute 113:24 126:20 absolutely 90:12 110:3 171:14 179:2 abuse 44:15 47:22 62:18 97:13 98:18 99:2 174:18 176:3 abused 47:4 108:3 abusing 108:5 113:14 136:17 abusive 113:6 126:15 166:8 academy 99:10 103:3,12 104:6,19 accepted 79:3 access 81:12,23 acclimated 80:19 account 85:16,18 106:17 accounts 195:11 accurate 131:13,15 accurately 12:1 accused 46:23 105:24 108:4,7 acronym 32:1 151:1 209:18 acronyms 31:24 act 70:17 149:21 181:17 acted 127:18 acting 69:20,20 127:17 149:3,15 149:17 150:5 172:20 177:3 193:4 198:14 207:10,18 210:10 211:4 action 24:17 85:9 85:11 217:24 actions 44:12 127:11 195:4 active 8:23 210:11 210:14,15 acts 170:24 171:8 actual 49:7 68:6 200:19 203:16,21 206:18 add 130:24 131:10 added 133:6 addition 76:18 86:13 152:6 208:10 additional 130:21 130:23 131:18 address 29:11 104:3 130:19 169:24 addressed 150:16 adequate 170:1 adhere 83:22 adjourned 217:19 administrative 6:11 8:14 9:19 155:18 admissible 62:17 admission 199:14 200:11 admitted 62:19 admonished 127:17 advantageous 87:3 adversary 131:12 adverse 102:4 advice 15:19 38:4 70:18 113:22,23 119:24 120:2 advise 32:19 118:10 advises 37:5 affairs 32:6 72:23 81:18,22 82:1,2 97:14 affect 84:14 102:4 affirmative 117:23 aforesaid 216:11 216:14 afternoon 147:8 age 44:11 agencies 73:24 agency 52:9 aggravated 13:11 13:17 127:4 agitated 176:17 197:7 198:19 ago 55:11 59:17 98:21 132:22 154:12 168:17 193:12 198:1,6 agree 43:17 50:24 54:18,19 155:11 156:22 159:2 181:23 201:21 203:4,7 agreed 43:13 118:1 161:8 203:23 ahead 14:13 39:24 42:3 62:20 74:14 77:8 78:16 82:6 109:17 114:18 115:24 123:9 124:20 131:7 132:9 135:19 137:2 138:11 139:21 148:21 150:14 152:24 174:8 192:15 202:20 204:8,10 204:19,20 205:7 205:11 al 1:6 216:6 alerts 209:9 alexander 88:22 alfonzo 18:24 allegation 46:21 47:2 48:20 58:3 63:9,12,14,20 16:18 17:13 22:22 64:2 91:1,7,10 23:6,8 24:21 106:7,12,14,24 31:19 37:2,9 107:3 116:6 39:14,22,22 41:12 119:14 41:18 47:23 53:3 allegations 13:15 70:18 72:14 82:6 13:16,17 29:24 83:3 98:7 102:5 33:16 34:2 35:16 105:19,20 109:17 36:10 40:8 47:12 113:17 115:6 48:8,13 50:8 117:23 118:4 51:12 61:6 64:7 120:16 121:19 64:16 66:7,13 122:20 123:3,6 68:20 69:4 70:13 127:24 129:11,21 75:21 84:1,24 130:15,18 131:7 87:24 91:3 93:3 131:20,23 132:9 96:21,23 97:1,3 132:17 133:12 97:15 99:2 109:16 135:19 137:9 111:7,9,12 119:1 138:9,12 139:20 119:3,8,12,18 142:8,9 146:20 121:16 122:9 148:8,21 153:1,20 123:19 124:13,23 158:4,9,10 160:5 125:3,5,8 161:3 163:5 alleged 47:3,7 166:12 169:7 60:22 63:8 75:18 174:9 184:10 90:10 108:12 185:15,15 186:10 119:15,18 157:13 186:16 187:5,8,19 171:8 192:16,17,18 allegedly 108:3,15 195:2 199:4,11,17 108:22,23 111:5 199:18 202:21 120:5 204:11 205:18 alleging 89:2 213:8 allow 171:12 answered 36:19 184:19 186:3,9 37:4,7,9 39:19 187:4 118:6 121:18 allowed 20:9 127:24 132:20 amendment 213:22 195:8,19 ample 132:23 answering 114:1,4 133:2 213:13,17 anderson 1:14 answers 39:12,20 217:3 218:8 128:14 129:2,14 animals 110:18 129:24 132:21 announcements 157:21 158:14 83:21 159:19 161:17,22 answer 7:16,21 184:6 185:1,10,19 14:12,14 16:11,17 188:17 199:2 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 83 of 107 PageID #:1391 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 220 200:5 anthony 3:13 108:17 anticipated 205:10 anybody 28:22 73:1,3 85:18,19 109:12 110:5 175:21 201:19 212:23 appeal 55:4 appear 59:12,22 appearances 113:11 125:17 appeared 2:7,15 3:8,17 appears 72:5 apply 104:12,19 appointed 77:13 appointment 155:4 appreciate 113:15 apprehensions 168:9,11,18,21 approach 196:4,14 197:12 approached 126:3 164:24 166:6 168:6,12 173:2,3 181:24 196:17 197:9,15,17,21 198:3,12 208:13 209:1 approaching 172:16 appropriate 112:18 approximately 27:9 59:16 86:2 94:8 147:6 april 56:11 57:5 136:24 140:13 141:6 142:16 143:7,20 144:24 146:2,9,15,21 147:13,20 148:5 149:10,13 150:3,8 150:19 151:11,16 152:7 156:16 157:22 165:5 166:1 170:5,8,21 172:4,8,16 173:9 174:5,14 175:5 177:7,7,17 178:1 178:20 179:7,16 179:23 180:3,9 181:1 182:24 183:13 189:24 191:4 202:5 203:13 206:21 210:4 area 25:9 90:9 121:20 143:12 162:14,14 165:16 171:15,18,19,21 184:9 185:23 190:2,14 198:11 206:18 areas 170:2 areawide 190:9 arent 100:7 arguing 71:16 argument 126:14 argumentative 114:24 183:12 arising 31:3 arms 206:24 arrest 174:23,24 181:8 arrested 127:2 157:22 201:22 arrestee 106:1 108:7 151:17 152:9 166:17 183:1 189:22 190:14,20,22 191:13 210:11,14 arrestees 104:7,8 146:3,6,10,16 150:11 151:11 167:9,17 201:16 201:17 arrived 191:10,20 192:24 193:16 arrogant 126:11 article 11:11 articles 10:9 articulate 7:18 23:4 arts 100:23 asked 6:23 19:17 22:7 29:6 36:18 37:23 39:19 112:21 156:19 157:20 158:13 159:3,4,18 161:16 161:19,21 177:18 178:2,13 179:15 180:7,13 184:5,24 185:9,18 188:16 191:22 192:2,13 195:18 198:14 199:1 200:4 213:5 asking 17:21 32:20 32:21,24 35:12 39:6 40:12,14 42:2 48:18 53:10 56:17 65:15,18 74:19 77:5 81:19 84:7 97:7 112:9 112:10,19 113:6 114:7 115:16 116:20 117:8 125:6,7 141:13 156:17 158:20 159:15,17 163:1,2 183:20 202:20 ass 126:21 assailant 105:14 assault 127:4 201:24 assert 70:16,20 assessment 50:5 85:1 92:20,21 assessments 158:12 assets 213:18 assigned 6:4,7,10 8:12 12:4,12,13 25:11 32:18 33:7 69:13 76:2,7 81:3 86:3 88:4,12 94:4 94:7 98:11 120:10 140:15 145:7 146:23 147:17 179:20 212:15 assignment 6:2 26:21,23 69:7 140:19,21,23 assignments 12:3 96:3 141:2,3 assist 156:18,20 205:15,23 assisted 205:21 associate 172:11 assume 156:15 assumes 139:17 assuming 84:18 attaching 128:24 attachment 42:21 42:22 attack 201:19 attempted 203:16 203:22 206:19 attempts 203:20 attend 99:16 100:12 attention 119:20 153:6 attitude 126:5 attorney 6:12,23,24 7:7 8:10 15:5,9,14 15:22 37:5,15,22 43:14 54:24 55:3 64:6,9 111:13 112:3,10,15 114:7 114:10 115:17,19 118:5,6 132:24 133:8 154:16,21 154:22,24 155:5 217:21,22 attorneyclient 112:8 attorneys 15:18 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 36:13 74:1 113:21 116:21 140:1 august 6:8 8:17,18 10:4 12:16,17 26:1 27:9 30:11 47:4 48:14,19 69:7 72:6,10 authority 212:11 avenue 1:16 2:5 average 25:1 award 85:21 aware 11:14 33:20 34:1 35:15,19,22 36:2,8,16 39:9 40:2 73:9,22 74:2 75:20 77:3 80:9 84:23 94:13,17,21 96:9 98:17 106:12 131:23 132:15 150:19 152:7 156:12 189:16 B b 4:6 84:10 141:12 148:19 back 40:5 46:12 47:9 54:11 72:7 96:18 113:24 182:10 184:8 185:23 187:9 188:14 209:11 214:2 background 214:13 bad 48:4 49:5,12 54:9 badgering 115:1 badly 185:21 balance 85:21 banned 180:21 barely 45:3 67:20 barrel 17:6 base 49:24 117:7 based 12:1 16:24 24:13 35:16 36:10 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 84 of 107 PageID #:1392 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 221 45:19 52:3,4 64:4 64:16 68:19 78:23 83:13 85:1 87:3 98:8 117:21 119:13,14 129:10 131:14 133:13 141:17 144:15 151:5,18 155:1 165:18 176:17 188:20 213:21,23 baseline 149:23 basically 44:16 basing 150:13 basis 97:4,5 109:15 132:8 188:3 bates 58:22 battery 13:11,18 127:3 battle 3:13,16 6:14 6:17 7:3,9 8:4 11:20 14:7,13,20 15:7,24 16:14,18 17:2 19:3 21:15 28:5 32:23 34:17 36:18 37:7,12,15 37:23 38:5,9,20 38:24 39:10,21,24 41:13,18,22 42:3 43:16,24 44:4,7 44:22 47:14 51:13 52:17 55:6 56:16 56:19 58:7,16,19 58:23 59:3,6 60:17 61:2,15 62:13 65:6,11 66:20 67:4,9,15 68:1,5,10 71:4,6 71:14 73:14 74:8 74:14 75:9 76:3 77:5,8 78:14 82:5 84:3 85:3 87:17 88:6 98:4,7,20 99:11 108:9,19 109:1,8,14 111:14 111:15,21 112:1,4 112:6,12,16,21 113:2,5 114:17 115:5,10 116:13 116:15,19 117:2,6 117:13 120:16 121:2 122:12,16 122:19,24 123:3,9 123:14,23 124:3,5 124:15,19 125:20 129:12 131:2 132:7,18 133:1 134:6,8,17 135:18 135:23 136:10 137:17 138:3,11 139:2,18,21 140:21 141:12 142:10 147:22 148:2,8,20 150:13 152:12,24 155:22 157:2 158:15,19 158:22 159:13,21 160:2,6,9,13,16 160:24 161:3 163:5,21,24 169:15 172:24 174:7 176:21 183:16,19,22 186:3,7,13,21 187:2,19 192:18 195:7,18 202:19 204:5,10,20 205:10 207:2 212:23 213:2,10 213:19 214:19 215:7,11,13 bearing 56:23 beast 11:11 74:22 beat 147:17 behalf 2:7,15 3:8 3:17 84:10 98:1 behavior 83:20 168:22 169:2 192:21 194:18 207:24 210:17 believe 26:1 40:16 55:2,9 58:21 70:23 71:2,8,13 71:14 72:7 86:9 89:20 93:21 99:13 102:1,18 106:21 114:24 117:4,6 127:13,16 128:3 128:15 132:14 133:7 137:6 139:23 143:12 144:12 147:2,17 150:17 153:20 171:24 176:15 180:10 186:18 191:8 206:5 208:14 belligerent 126:12 176:5 bench 182:8 best 70:6,9 86:5 89:19,23 98:8 126:2,17 164:22 170:10 178:21 182:7 183:9 188:22 192:1 197:19 198:9 better 58:24 93:7 127:19 153:19 157:6 161:10,12 beyond 136:14 big 53:2 110:9 119:4 bipolar 174:1 176:9,11,12,14 177:8 180:16 bit 129:16 150:22 182:9 blanked 58:18 blocked 58:11 blurred 42:14,16 42:17,18,20,21,24 board 55:5 92:23 body 47:5 197:16 203:14 bold 45:7 booking 206:12 borderline 136:17 152:19 bottom 46:22 57:9 box 47:2 boyer 3:12 boyfriend 199:5,8 brain 110:2 break 7:20,23 8:2 41:19 122:21 123:2,21 140:3,5 207:2,6 breaking 176:5 brendan 32:15 brief 29:8 194:16 195:1 197:13 bright 67:14 bring 117:11 209:10 broad 22:21 33:13 53:2 69:6 104:2 150:21 152:15 173:21 broadness 130:19 brought 20:11 63:9 63:11 119:20 125:8 136:4 137:12 164:11 167:18 189:22 brunt 136:22 building 126:6,9 165:14,15,17 bullshit 63:21 bunch 46:2 119:7 187:3 burdensome 130:20 burying 61:5 buttocks 121:20 bypass 181:21 C c 1:5 2:1 3:1 5:13 216:5 217:2 calculated 15:2 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 44:14 61:3 62:16 74:9 125:22 call 46:11 50:23 102:2 113:19,24 114:18 116:22 117:2,13 120:18 142:21 143:16 called 1:10 5:10 126:14 144:13 calm 184:23 198:21 camera 143:8,10 143:11,14,19,23 144:4,23 candidate 82:14,24 83:10,17 84:2,23 cant 10:15,17 22:1 31:19 35:9 45:4 53:2 71:2 75:12 98:13 100:16 102:5 105:19 146:20 168:2,16 170:14,18 182:13 187:12 205:1,18 capacity 76:9 120:4 120:21 150:4 153:5 car 145:15 147:18 card 175:4,14,19 175:22 cards 175:15 care 177:13 183:5 career 11:20 20:21 50:20 102:4 carla 3:5,7 carry 19:23 20:3,5 20:9 carrying 199:10 carter 88:18 case 10:11,14,20 14:8,22 46:2,3,5 56:23 61:5 63:21 67:10 78:16 84:6 84:14 107:15 109:17 111:11,15 111:17,19,20,22 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 85 of 107 PageID #:1393 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 222 112:13 114:14 117:9 118:12,22 121:4,10,21,24 122:2,4,9 124:24 127:14,16,19 136:22 186:22 189:4 casebycase 109:15 cases 115:17 116:12,21 122:5 187:1 caterwauling 199:10 catholic 100:1 caused 16:23 17:6 36:9,12,15 45:20 65:4 208:4,7 cell 126:19 certain 79:13 83:19 86:24 153:23 certified 1:14 217:3 218:9 certify 217:5 chain 78:24 79:2 challenges 54:5 chance 129:17 130:2 change 51:5 129:11 129:15,19,22 155:21 changed 51:2 78:22 channel 21:13,22 22:5,10,19 23:2 26:16,18 40:3 characteristics 79:14 characterize 138:15 characterized 152:13 185:3 charge 13:8,21 14:2 181:10 202:1 charged 13:9,10,11 13:14 14:4 18:14 49:15 127:2,3 charges 13:20,24 20:10,12,14,15,16 34:6 136:4 137:8 137:12 charging 181:11,21 check 9:20 145:24 145:24 chicago 1:16 2:5,10 2:13 3:3,6,9,15 5:21 9:1,9,13,21 21:4,6 22:8 23:24 32:5 57:19 61:8 66:6 73:9 74:4 75:19 80:14 99:20 100:18,19 102:10 114:12 151:23 212:11 218:2 chicagos 11:12 chief 19:17 87:7,10 87:12 88:2,20 211:16,23 212:1,3 212:9 chiefs 90:21 child 46:6 49:15 children 127:17 cigarettes 172:8 circumstance 89:16 179:3 circumstances 13:20 33:19,23 40:22 90:5 137:10 153:22 158:1 167:11,12,23 190:4 citizen 11:19 87:15 89:2,10 90:6 91:7 94:22 97:9 98:17 citizens 21:9 29:16 30:1 87:24 103:24 104:1 110:13 city 2:10 3:3,9 5:21 9:1,12,16,21 10:2 15:16 22:8 23:24 58:21 61:8 67:23 80:14 98:1 100:18 114:12 115:4 116:6 122:1 139:15 151:23 153:21 154:1 cityofchicago 2:14 3:7 citywide 187:22 civil 1:11 2:10 3:3 claim 47:19 121:8 claimed 106:15 claiming 106:17 claims 14:10,23 47:19 56:23 57:1 61:7 136:15,15 clarification 173:13 clarify 67:10 186:7 186:15 213:3 class 103:15,17 105:10 classes 103:18,19 classroom 152:6 clear 62:24 81:13 81:16 128:18 209:8 clerk 63:16 64:2 client 75:13 112:17 115:6,22 116:14 116:20 118:10 136:17 160:5 187:18 clifford 2:16 149:7 149:9 157:23 162:18 163:12,18 164:6,13,24 166:7 166:10,11,22 168:4,23 172:15 172:22 182:1,20 182:22 189:18 191:12,19,24 192:4 194:8 195:4 195:14 196:18 197:2,10 198:2,5 198:7 201:5,7 204:1,14 205:15 205:17 208:11 210:7 cliffords 189:6 clinton 194:12 coast 101:19,23 cocaine 199:7,7 cocounsel 38:11,12 38:19 39:2 code 139:10,23 cognitive 153:11 cold 171:13,17 college 100:10,12 100:14,16,18 169:18 colleges 100:13,17 com 2:6 3:16 combative 105:13 combativeness 167:14 combination 152:5 162:15 come 68:20 80:13 87:1 119:23 156:17,19 171:13 comes 23:19 184:8 184:15 185:22 coming 43:5 112:11 129:8 163:23 188:24 189:7,14 205:11 command 21:13,22 22:5,9,19 23:1 26:16,17 29:6 40:3 78:24 79:3 80:3 81:17 82:4 82:12 84:1,20 144:20 154:21 commander 5:23 5:24 6:6,10 8:12 9:4 12:12 18:18 19:18 21:7,12,20 22:3,11,14,16 23:1,9,20 24:2,24 25:7,22,24 26:11 26:14 27:11,13,18 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 27:22 30:21 32:8 32:9,10 33:10 69:18,19,20,21,23 70:1,12 77:15 80:1,4,9,20 81:12 81:15,19 84:19 86:14,22 87:7,9 87:11,23 88:13,17 88:18 91:16,19,21 92:4 137:19 149:14,15,17,22 150:5 165:6 172:20 184:15,16 211:4 212:14 commanders 32:12 32:13 88:14 90:16 91:4,11,13 165:8 165:20 166:2 commanding 27:16 69:15,17,21 commenced 203:22 commencement 217:6 comment 53:16 119:24 120:2 comments 174:17 commingling 67:13 85:10,11 common 88:17,18 communicate 7:7 communicating 7:9 7:12 communication 71:10 compensated 9:3 compensation 9:6 9:12,16 competence 84:8 97:24 141:10 148:18 212:6 complained 29:15 complaint 21:9 46:17 89:2,10 90:7 95:6 97:4,5 97:10 116:3 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 86 of 107 PageID #:1394 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 223 117:22 121:14 128:2,4 132:13 complaints 11:19 21:11 85:8,12,12 85:19 87:16 90:8 94:22 98:17 130:22 complete 23:15 131:14,16 134:1 209:20 completed 24:21 24:22 completely 14:22 44:13 compliance 105:20 comprehending 24:5 computer 142:24 concerning 217:9 concerns 65:14 105:12 176:2,4 concise 194:17 195:1 concur 92:1,2,5,13 92:22 93:5 153:3 condense 23:7 condition 213:9 conditions 29:12 conduct 22:5,9 33:14 38:17 49:21 52:15 82:23 conducted 33:11 33:20 36:2 51:11 53:21 conducting 50:14 53:1 74:3 conducts 32:16 confidential 67:24 configuration 131:15 conflict 104:17 conflicts 180:2 confrontation 176:17,18 confrontational 126:16 176:6 177:14,20 178:4,6 178:9 179:17 confused 67:12,14 congregate 171:16 connected 127:5 connection 116:11 consider 181:15 201:23,24 consideration 81:4 85:23 consisting 216:13 constitute 85:9 constitutes 209:23 210:17 217:13 construed 210:18 contact 119:16 138:14 158:2 166:10 175:14,15 175:19,21 202:4,9 202:18,24 203:3,6 203:10,12,21 204:2,17 205:4,16 205:21 206:4,5,14 206:15,18,20,23 209:24 contacted 69:2,5 74:24 176:16 contacts 203:15,18 content 161:8 196:11 contents 43:2 57:7 context 31:23 60:1 164:9 continuation 5:4 continue 38:1 39:5 39:6 continued 37:24 contrived 17:12 137:8 control 103:9,11,14 103:16,20,24 104:5,9,12,16 105:20 200:3 controlling 158:7 162:19 163:15 166:20,23 conversation 12:23 17:14,17 18:9,15 20:22 28:14,23 29:13,23 30:2,4 30:10,14,18,20,24 31:5,15 65:16 70:11 87:22 91:3 91:9 112:23 136:5 138:21 139:5,9 164:10,11 166:9 166:15 191:12,14 191:17,18 192:7 194:24 196:6,13 197:2,13 conversations 17:19,24 29:18 50:12 53:5 87:6 192:9,11 196:11 convoluted 21:24 23:3 cooperate 163:20 164:7 183:15 184:9,12,13,22 185:24 193:17 cooperating 164:12 164:15 cooperativeness 191:3 cop 11:13 copy 58:19,20,23 58:24 59:4 62:24 67:15,17 128:18 corner 181:5 correct 9:23 11:21 11:24 12:14,20 17:18 18:20 19:8 20:13 21:18 22:13 22:15 25:14,18 26:6 27:1,14 30:17 31:6,17 32:11 40:19 44:3 48:16 49:4 50:5 50:22 51:20 54:3 54:20 59:19 60:14 63:4,23 64:3,21 65:10,24 66:3,10 68:23 77:6,7,19 78:2 79:10 80:3 81:24 82:16 83:11 92:17 93:20,24 94:16 95:19 96:5 96:12,24 99:18 101:7 102:9 103:7 107:19 108:5 111:5 119:2 121:14,15 122:3,6 122:7,10 125:12 126:20 141:14 142:1,6 151:14 156:10 157:9 162:10,23 165:2 167:22 173:6 175:1 176:3 179:10 190:17 191:15 195:23 196:11 201:12 208:8 211:2 213:5 216:15 corroborated 195:10 cottage 25:19,20,20 couldnt 17:12 24:21 25:3 28:18 80:6 134:1 182:13 198:4 counsel 15:20 16:15 34:18 37:8 37:12 38:4 39:11 41:22 44:8 58:19 62:13 70:18,22 71:7,21 112:16 117:9 119:8,21,23 120:1,3 122:12,13 122:24 129:18 136:11 138:4 147:23 153:3 158:23 217:21,22 county 217:2 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 couple 96:13,14 132:4 154:11 177:10,11 182:4 211:21 court 1:1 5:6 59:22 63:8,16 64:2 111:2 113:10 120:1,3 125:11,15 125:17 155:18 156:13 216:1 courts 1:12 213:23 cousin 117:8 coverage 170:1 cpd 84:10 97:19,22 146:6 150:20 151:10,16 152:8 175:18 176:20 212:18 cr 11:3,5,14 21:14 21:23 22:10,20 23:11,16,21 24:3 24:6,10,14 25:2 26:19 32:17,22 40:20 41:9,10 42:9,11 54:11 55:1 56:1 62:10 63:6 65:4,19 66:6 66:18 68:19 81:16 84:1,24 91:22 95:17 109:5 110:19 127:21 crazy 177:3,5 create 210:2 created 175:14 crime 29:11 169:13 criminal 13:8 136:4 137:8,12 181:17 criteria 77:2,3 crs 82:3 136:13 cry 197:6 crying 168:24 169:3 183:8,10 197:4 198:13 199:4,10 207:9,11 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 87 of 107 PageID #:1395 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 224 207:14 208:1 current 131:14 currently 5:18 8:24 9:6 64:19,20 73:10 74:3 cursed 126:11 cursory 52:7 129:9 129:10 154:11 156:1 179:3 custody 172:17 208:18 209:11 cut 187:12,13 cycle 208:2 decline 178:17 180:19 deemed 23:22 deenihan 32:15 defendant 3:9,17 31:2,9,15 130:12 130:14 131:1 defendants 1:7 2:16 15:13 84:14 216:7 defense 117:23 defer 93:8 deficit 153:6,11 define 177:5 D definition 152:17 d 2:16 4:1 5:13 152:20 173:11 216:21 degree 100:20,22 daily 11:11 74:22 delegated 84:19 damage 144:22 delilah 70:19 71:11 damaged 110:2 75:19,21 dana 88:22 deliliah 68:21 69:4 dangerous 112:7 70:13,15 database 145:6 deliver 78:8 date 59:14 214:9 demeanor 126:5 dates 62:10 171:10 demonstrates day 63:5,7 64:17 210:16 120:9,12,22 demonstration 147:18 169:5,10 105:7 176:8 210:24 dennis 157:23 211:1 216:20 denying 161:23 218:2 dep 115:8 days 35:20 36:17 department 6:1 9:9 45:4,7,17,21 17:8,16,23 18:6 54:13 59:19 20:1,7 21:1,4,6 154:12 214:8 22:9 32:2,5 34:9 december 86:7 40:13,18,23 49:21 93:22 94:1,9 50:7,13 52:11,14 128:16 129:4 55:14,17 56:3 132:21 57:19 60:5,12,23 decided 83:5 92:13 61:14,24 66:3,7 93:4 181:11 69:3,6,8 73:10,11 decipher 43:1,20 73:20 74:2,5 75:1 45:2 46:7 75:20 76:2 78:5,8 decision 24:13 79:15 80:11 82:19 79:15 82:11 209:4 82:22 83:7,24 90:3 94:2 98:3 102:10,16 110:6 118:19 135:13 139:11,24 150:10 151:23 152:9,10 153:15 168:1 177:1 180:8 188:5 188:6,11,11 208:12 212:12 departments 73:23 79:19 81:5,7,13 departmentwide 185:6 187:22 depend 82:18 depended 82:19 105:11 depending 144:21 173:11 depends 24:11 31:23 33:15 35:2 80:7 82:17 105:12 105:17,21 121:8 123:18 145:2 146:18 166:4 167:11,23 168:2 169:7 190:4 191:2 196:22 203:9 deploy 87:2 deployments 86:24 deponent 39:20 71:12,18 138:1 139:14 215:17 216:10 deposed 118:13 deposition 1:9 5:4 10:8 11:6,9 15:4 16:9 38:11 115:16 116:7 118:8,21,24 136:18,20 159:23 187:6,13 188:24 189:3,7,11,13 216:11,12 217:10 217:16,18 depositions 1:13 depressive 174:1 176:9,11,13 depth 154:12,14 deputy 18:22,23 19:2,12,13,15 87:7,9,12 88:2,20 90:21 describe 22:18 104:11,18,21 105:5,8 106:11 designated 142:4,5 142:7 148:24 149:2 desk 23:19 142:4,5 142:7,15 179:20 desks 142:17,19,21 despite 53:12 details 193:13 detain 209:9 determination 35:13 51:9 156:4 177:2 181:20,21 199:12 200:9,16 200:19 201:2 208:15,20 209:16 determine 46:7 81:16 133:3 determined 89:23 detroit 68:21 deviate 79:22 188:6 didactic 152:6 didnt 6:22 7:1 18:7 18:8 35:21 40:16 43:17 75:9 90:23 119:23 121:22 128:22 139:7 154:23 155:5 174:11 178:24 189:12 194:23 198:23 199:5 difference 97:8 148:14 150:23 151:4 differently 153:17 153:23 difficult 67:23 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 dimensions 83:20 direct 4:3 87:5 181:21 198:20 directed 181:19 direction 87:4 217:13 directive 20:6,8 150:24 151:1,6,8 151:10 directives 23:23 24:1 83:1,2 150:16 151:8 152:3,4 188:6 directly 12:15 87:1 156:9 208:6 217:23 dirtiest 11:12 disagreeing 213:14 disagreement 214:1,4 disarmed 110:12 disbelieve 71:3 discern 180:12 discharge 35:4 101:20,22 102:3 disciplinary 34:6 85:9,11 discipline 23:12 34:13,22 35:2 disciplined 61:12 61:21 95:16 106:23 discount 85:18,19 discoverable 44:15 61:4 74:10 84:5 114:23 118:11 125:22 discovery 44:16 47:22 62:17,18 113:14 133:9 136:18 discretion 79:20 181:14 discretionary 45:14 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 88 of 107 PageID #:1396 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 225 discuss 90:15,18,20 discussed 29:1 196:10 213:24 discussing 6:16 91:14 discussion 40:11 71:22 dislike 131:10 dismissed 127:14 disorders 153:6 dispersed 151:2 displaying 197:8 disqualify 84:2 85:2 disrespectful 34:20 distance 196:20 district 1:1,1,12 12:7,9,12 17:7,22 18:4,4,5 21:8,11 21:12,21 22:4,12 22:14,17 23:10 25:1,7,11,13,15 25:16,23 26:1,11 26:13,15,22,24 27:3,5 29:11,12 52:24 53:6,17,19 58:5 69:14,18 76:1,4,7 86:4 87:9 87:11,15 88:5,13 88:24 89:14,18 90:17,22 91:2,8 93:11,22 96:6,7 107:21,23 140:16 140:17 141:8,21 142:15,18 143:8 143:20 144:1,6,9 144:16 145:8,13 145:19,22 146:3,5 146:9,16,17 149:14,20 150:6 157:24 158:3 162:9,10 165:5,10 165:12,16,21 167:7,18 169:4,12 171:12,16,20,22 172:18 177:19 178:3 179:15,22 180:4,9,15,16 183:6,14 185:5,6 187:21 189:22 190:1,6,8,13,16 191:20 201:19 202:8,17 203:14 205:5,13 209:14 210:3,12 216:1,1 districts 212:4 division 1:2 2:11 3:4 32:6 212:12 212:16 216:2 divorce 72:2 dna 14:18 16:22 17:5 docket 113:11 document 43:6 48:23 56:9 57:3,6 69:1 72:17 128:17 128:21,23 129:7 documentation 31:17,19 188:21 documented 53:8 documents 10:9,10 10:16,18 43:3 47:16 81:2 155:14 164:20 doesnt 23:23 50:4 152:16 160:22 187:8,11 dog 110:14 doing 16:1 77:21 91:21 106:16 115:3 120:9 188:7 doj 75:15 dont 7:6 9:7 10:3,6 11:13,16 12:15 17:10 22:22 26:2 26:4 27:6,19 28:3 28:17,24 29:17,19 29:20 30:6,6,7,8 30:18,22,22 31:10 31:12 33:13,23 34:12,15,18 36:12 36:14 37:10,13 38:9 40:6 41:2,10 42:20 44:5 45:13 46:12,15 50:17 51:3 55:3,9,9,24 56:4,7 57:16 58:2 59:2,24 60:6,6,7 61:23 62:3 64:14 65:20 66:14,16,19 66:22 68:3,8,24 70:23 71:8 72:3,4 74:21 75:13 78:19 79:5,11 80:6 81:9 82:9 83:1 85:9,18 85:19 86:6 87:19 88:8,10,21 89:6 90:12,14,19 92:10 94:10,18 95:3 96:19 97:2 99:5,7 101:17 102:4 104:2 106:4 108:18 109:10 110:17,21 112:16 112:17,18 113:15 114:22 116:17,20 116:24 117:4 118:14,23 120:13 121:11 126:19 128:1,5 130:5,6 131:11 132:3 135:1,9,21,23 136:2 138:16 139:4,23 140:12 142:7,8,9,20,21 143:1,2,5,16 144:2,7 146:19 148:11 149:8 154:3,22 156:19 156:21 161:12,18 161:24 162:11,16 163:13,17 164:9 164:16 165:23 166:9,14 167:8 170:15 171:10 172:3,3,6,9,13,14 175:8,11 178:24 179:1,13 182:3,21 184:22 186:18,21 188:14 191:8 192:9 193:7,12 194:6,11 195:3,24 196:2,20 198:6 201:23 202:11,23 204:4,13 205:17 206:6 208:14,14 208:19 209:2,22 210:20,20,22 211:10,11,13 212:17 213:2 214:8,21,22 doty 88:16,16 doubt 30:6 64:8 downplaying 157:12 downtime 209:15 drawnoutmonda... 194:23 drive 3:14 drunk 158:5 162:3 166:18 due 20:10 48:9,9 162:24 194:17 dues 155:3 duly 5:2,11 39:1 216:9 217:8 duration 28:19 duress 72:16 duties 145:20 147:13 149:18 211:4 duty 8:23 109:13 184:14,19 211:5 dyslexia 174:3 E e 2:1,1 3:1,1 4:1,6 5:13,13 ear 16:1,2 earlier 173:21 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 213:16,24 early 56:6 147:8 earth 84:6 eastern 1:2 216:2 echoed 158:11 echoing 194:1,3 eddie 88:17 edicts 79:19 81:5,8 81:8,9,9 187:24 effect 151:10 effort 170:1 efforts 163:19 164:7 194:13 either 66:16 96:18 98:16,17 130:14 130:24 162:3,17 163:11,18 164:5 164:13 166:18 168:4,23 172:21 182:1 194:12 198:10 206:11 214:23 215:3 ejected 177:16 178:14,15 elaborate 45:24 eligible 19:20 emanuel 134:3,9,14 135:12 136:6 137:11 138:22 139:10 emotional 153:9 173:23 emotions 197:8 employed 5:18 102:7 employee 217:20 217:22 en 169:16 encounter 170:9 172:5 encountered 50:20 151:17 170:6,13 170:15 encounters 170:20 177:11 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 89 of 107 PageID #:1397 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 226 encourage 36:14 163:19 164:7 193:17 194:9,14 195:5,16 enforcement 73:24 181:19 212:10,11 engage 180:24 engaged 120:5 176:20 210:3 engages 210:15,16 engaging 168:9,11 168:19 169:2 170:24 171:8 207:11 english 81:10 ensconced 169:13 169:15 ensuing 203:11 ensure 25:8 170:1 entailed 169:3 enter 99:9 entered 193:8 196:3 entire 28:19 34:8 43:2 60:1 149:11 155:23 157:18 164:9 179:11,13 207:18,23 entirely 87:19 88:9 164:17 173:16 175:7 207:17 entirety 42:10 entitled 64:9,11 entity 212:10 equipment 144:8 144:17,20 equipped 35:14 eric 88:18 112:15 114:13 erratic 194:18 erroneous 31:18 41:1 46:9 69:12 85:13 errors 46:2,11 48:10 69:11,12 200:21 escalante 19:16,18 20:23 escape 127:10 escort 211:14 escorted 211:8 especially 74:22 199:22 essentially 154:22 estimation 93:1 154:2 estranged 65:4,19 65:20 et 1:6 216:6 ethic 86:23 eugene 88:22 evans 1:6,9 2:16 3:17 4:2,9,10,11 4:12,13 5:5,9,17 7:5,15 15:5,22 16:11 17:5 19:1 19:17 34:16 37:19 38:22 39:9 40:2 41:4,8 42:8 43:14 47:8,20 56:13,24 61:7 62:5 67:1 68:14,18,21 69:4 70:13,15,19 71:12 75:19,21 84:9 97:24 118:16 122:10 128:8 131:4 186:2,20 216:6,9,18 evening 147:8 event 179:5 events 138:17 157:11 eventually 184:12 199:12 everybody 35:3 evidence 17:10,12 17:12 61:4 62:17 74:10 84:5 90:2 114:23 117:21 125:23 139:17 evolved 50:22 51:3 evolving 50:23 exact 165:24 171:10 196:20 202:23 208:19 exactly 10:13,15,17 26:7 32:23 58:7 92:10 152:21 162:11 178:24 197:23 204:4,13 204:23 exaggerated 106:16 exaggerations 74:19 exam 76:11,14,16 76:22 examination 1:10 4:3 77:2,12 186:20 217:7 examined 5:11 exception 97:15 excessive 29:16 30:1 35:17 87:16 87:24 89:2,9 91:1 91:7 94:23 95:1,6 97:10,13 98:18 exchange 193:14 194:6,17,20 excuse 43:16 114:2 115:23,23 122:15 exhausted 214:14 215:8 exhibit 4:9,10,11 4:12,13 41:3,4,9 43:8 44:19 46:13 46:16 54:12 55:20 56:12,13,20 57:4 60:8,9 62:4,5,9 66:23 67:1,18 68:14 72:5 75:17 128:8,13 130:8 exhibited 194:18 exists 57:20 exonerated 96:18 expanse 136:15 expectations 29:9 29:10 expeditious 188:20 194:20 experience 49:20 50:3 165:18 207:24 expired 24:18,20 explain 116:1 117:19 168:18 170:19 176:7 193:16 194:13 extent 18:15 84:13 extraneous 23:3 exwife 65:3 70:19 eye 108:24 F face 104:7,8,13,20 facilities 146:13,14 facility 145:24 165:23 178:10 190:9,15 194:22 196:23 fact 46:3 110:11 139:6 166:17 198:6 factors 105:23 191:2 facts 13:19,21 90:3 139:17 factual 13:23 14:2 93:3 96:21,23 97:1,3 166:21 214:13 failed 59:11 60:22 failing 59:22 fair 38:24 39:14,16 39:22 138:11 179:10 195:3 207:13 fairly 90:23 132:5 false 13:22,23 14:1 119:7 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 falsely 13:10,12,13 20:11 108:4 falsified 17:11 90:1 106:17 137:8 familiar 73:19 78:20 102:22,24 150:4 151:15 far 60:8 101:21 136:11 165:20 196:19 fashion 23:7 87:3 fast 188:3 fastpaced 105:10 father 16:1 favor 20:13 fcrl 56:10 fearful 168:5,8 feasible 200:1 february 1:16 fed 81:21 federal 1:11 2:10 3:3 111:2 feed 177:12 feeding 183:4 feet 196:21 197:16 197:18,19 felony 202:3 209:6 female 146:3,6,10 146:16 189:22 190:14,20,22 femaledesignated 190:10 females 190:5 field 148:24 149:3 175:21 fifth 213:4,12,22 214:6,12,15 215:1 215:5 fight 110:10 199:8 figure 214:3 figures 127:6,6,7,8 127:9 file 21:9,23 22:10 22:20 23:11 24:3 24:6,10,14 35:16 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 90 of 107 PageID #:1398 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 227 41:9,10 42:9,11 filed 113:12 117:22 118:18 files 11:3,5,14 21:14 25:2 26:19 32:17,22 40:20 81:16 84:24 finalized 72:2 financial 213:9,13 find 113:10 114:19 209:12,12 finding 23:16,22 59:10 92:14 findings 58:9 92:2 92:5,23 93:2,5 fine 16:4 44:17 113:8 160:8,11,12 160:23 161:2 fingerprint 184:20 189:24 206:11 fingerprinted 184:17 203:4,7,19 203:23 208:17 211:7 fingerprinting 193:19 fingerprints 194:10 194:15 195:6,17 209:7 finish 133:1 158:22 160:10 186:4,9 187:19 finished 60:17 firearm 20:9 first 5:2,10 18:21 18:23 19:2,11,13 19:15 41:19 42:6 55:13,19 57:4,8 57:13 60:4 62:11 72:14 100:14,16 123:7 128:14 134:23 160:10 165:13,19 166:6 170:12,14,18 179:12 182:11,18 183:7 193:9 196:5 202:7 216:9 five 92:9 144:2,6 168:17 193:12 196:21 197:18,24 198:5 fiveyear 193:23 flagging 181:6 flawed 92:24 93:2 floor 3:14 165:13 165:19 fluid 194:17 flunked 81:9 focus 179:1 follow 38:3 60:23 81:4,6 followed 79:18 follows 5:12 foot 182:23 footage 165:24 force 29:16 30:1 35:17 87:16,24 89:3,9 91:1,7 94:23 95:1,6 97:10,13 98:18 207:8,16,20 208:3 209:21,23 foregoing 216:12 216:15 217:10 forget 202:1 form 9:11 135:15 137:15 148:7 192:14 204:8,18 205:6 212:6 formal 22:23 134:24 137:11 138:17 148:11,15 149:1 formally 121:11 134:20 135:2 former 71:12 formulate 149:24 151:14 154:4 forth 74:11 136:14 forward 43:24 116:7 129:16 fought 109:20,23 foul 63:8 found 14:18 16:23 17:6,11 20:15,15 127:15 foundation 74:10 130:20 135:18 137:18,21,22,23 138:5 139:17,19 147:15 148:7,16 160:22 four 162:15 fourth 46:15 58:2 frame 169:21,22 franko 155:13 free 171:19 180:4 frequent 171:4 frequently 80:5 149:21 171:3 fresh 156:23 front 42:13,14 49:8 fuck 47:9 fucking 63:22 fudge 133:22 full 101:10 function 8:14 145:21 150:4 functions 86:24 138:18 fundamental 214:1 further 47:7 129:17 212:22 215:17 G g 2:3,4 garb 181:6 gauge 12:1 gender 53:12,13 general 41:23 50:12 51:14,16 145:4 146:13 150:9,20 151:6,7 151:8 164:10 174:18 186:1 187:24 188:1,2 189:21 190:3 191:18 193:2 198:11 generalities 166:15 168:20 generality 166:16 generally 23:18 50:9,11 82:8 166:4 184:13 190:23 generated 144:10 175:18 geographic 25:9 getting 48:17 54:11 67:12 112:6 114:17 136:21 137:2 139:13 178:15,16 180:2 183:4 gifted 153:7 gilbert 113:19 117:10 girlfriend 109:22 110:8 give 18:7 25:4 46:12 64:18 68:6 72:23 73:1 75:2 92:19 98:2 105:18 105:19 108:9 115:14 126:2,9 147:5 149:23 153:21 155:4 170:18 185:19 186:15 given 72:15,22,23 101:22 105:11 115:13 136:11 153:14 161:24 216:16 217:14 giving 70:8 72:19 118:23 154:5 157:21 158:13 161:16 183:5 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 184:5 185:1,10 199:2 200:5 215:2 glad 100:7 glenn 1:6,9 2:16 3:17 4:2 5:4,9,17 37:19 43:22 56:24 98:7 135:19 216:6 216:9,18 gmail 2:6 go 14:13 18:14 35:3 36:19 37:3 39:5 39:24 42:3 46:15 54:23 62:20 72:7 74:14 77:8,21 78:4,16 82:6 91:24 99:17 100:10 109:17 112:21,24 114:18 115:24 123:9,22 124:20 131:7 132:8 134:23 135:18 137:2 138:6,11 139:21 148:21 150:14,23 151:1 152:24 174:8 182:2 187:9 188:14 192:15 199:5,9 200:1 202:20 204:8,10 204:19,20 205:7,9 205:11 214:2 goes 30:7 82:1 going 7:16 8:5 15:19,21 24:15 26:8,8 27:8 29:19 33:2,6 36:19,22 37:3,16,17,18 38:1,3,6,13 39:5,5 42:4,5 43:12 44:2 46:4 47:14 54:22 56:11 57:24 63:22 68:5 70:1,7,16,17 70:20,21 80:8 83:15 86:5 88:21 91:12 92:8 93:15 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 91 of 107 PageID #:1399 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 228 99:7 101:16 102:2 106:5 113:17 114:15 116:14 119:10 125:23 126:2 127:9,10 129:16 131:2,6 136:10,14 138:4 139:6,16,18 143:22 144:2 147:14 148:6 152:12 157:10 158:15 160:4,6 161:10,11 163:24 166:21 169:12 170:7 176:10 178:21 179:12 182:17 184:4 188:19,20 192:2 192:13 193:1 196:22 197:18 201:23 206:2 209:2 211:13 213:8 214:15 good 51:23 54:8 58:20 83:9 97:2 123:23,24 215:14 goodness 107:4 gotten 47:21 graduate 101:4,6 gray 2:18 groin 106:21 108:8 108:16 121:20 ground 127:1 grounds 131:3 grove 25:19,20,21 guard 101:19,23 guess 10:19 57:9 88:21 133:15 162:24 163:1 167:3 202:20 guesstimate 26:3 guest 171:3 guideline 188:3,12 guilty 20:15 127:15 gulliford 211:16,23 gun 14:4,19 16:23 16:23 17:6 47:6,8 109:16,21,22 110:11 guy 215:9 148:16 183:18 192:14,17 204:3,7 204:18 205:6,9 212:24 harrison 12:5 havent 43:7 47:21 H 115:13 132:4 h 4:6 136:23 habits 172:9 head 47:6 103:24 half 137:1 104:1,7,8,16 hall 165:23 105:3 206:21 hallway 162:13 207:9,16,21 halsted 108:1 headquarters 6:5,7 hand 109:21 6:10 8:13,19 12:4 156:14 157:14 12:18 13:1 17:8 188:21 218:2 17:16,23 18:6,14 handcuffed 167:7,9 18:18 167:13 190:24 health 152:13 handcuffing 167:4 174:17,21 176:1,7 167:5 178:16 181:18,22 handling 60:24 heard 136:23 167:4,5 hearings 155:19 hands 54:21 159:12 held 96:8 127:1 hang 177:23 help 71:2 169:19 hanging 179:4 helped 206:9,10 happen 92:7 helps 142:11 happened 29:19 heres 187:10 63:5,7 hereto 217:23 happening 125:18 hereunto 218:1 harass 85:14 hes 30:8 37:17 42:3 harassing 62:18 71:4 77:6 115:2 113:7 114:24 119:21 120:13,14 139:14 120:14 141:12 hard 43:1 58:12 149:12 160:19 138:7 180:12 183:20 186:5,14 188:2 213:4,11,12,13 harris 2:12,14 214:14 215:1 15:12 73:15 74:12 hid 90:2 75:11 84:12 85:6 high 99:16,17,19 98:6 108:17 99:21 101:4,6 114:15,21 134:7 153:8 158:5 162:3 134:18 135:7,17 166:18 173:22,23 136:9 137:16 193:3 199:6,7 139:1,16 141:11 highest 169:13 147:14,23 148:6 history 85:21 hold 17:2,2 20:19 26:4 27:6 34:17 38:5 43:18 68:5 86:6 122:16 184:18 204:5 holding 104:15 holton 70:2,3,4,4 70:12 home 199:9 homeless 177:15 homicide 61:1 honest 27:19 honorable 102:1,3 hopefully 39:1 hospital 180:19 hostile 197:7 hours 137:1 147:3 house 146:16 housing 94:5,7,13 94:21 95:1,7,22 95:23 96:7 hr 83:6 hubert 70:2,3 human 80:18 hypothetical 84:4 183:17 identity 90:2 ignored 119:19 ill 7:23 16:2 31:21 41:16 56:19 57:24 73:14 84:12 94:10 98:6 115:14 119:5 120:1,3 126:10 134:6 141:11 148:20 152:14 163:8 164:21 200:24 illinois 1:1,15,16 2:5,13 3:6,15 100:18 101:1 102:18 216:1 217:1,4 218:2 illness 150:12 151:12,17 152:11 153:4,19,24 166:19 173:10,12 illnesses 153:16 im 7:16,18 8:10,20 8:23 10:23 11:12 15:18,21 16:6,12 17:21 21:2 24:15 26:8,8 27:7 29:19 32:20,21 33:2,6 I 36:22 37:3,18,21 iad 31:21,22 32:8,9 38:1,3,5,6,16,21 32:10,12,16,18,22 39:5 41:8 42:5 33:8,11,20 34:1,5 43:12,23 44:8 34:14,22 35:5,14 46:4 47:14 48:18 57:5 72:24 89:12 53:9,10,13 56:11 89:16 90:6,15,20 57:24 58:24 62:9 94:14,15,19 96:9 63:22 65:15,18 96:11,16,17 97:9 67:14 68:5 70:1,7 97:18,21 98:11 70:8,16,17,20,21 icon 127:14 71:5 80:18 81:3 id 24:8 81:19 83:15 86:5 idea 84:6 86:8 88:21 90:23 identification 41:6 91:5,12 92:8 93:9 56:15 62:7 67:3 93:15,20 94:24 68:16 128:10 95:14 97:7,12,20 175:3 99:7 100:8 101:16 identify 81:20 102:2,13 106:5 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 92 of 107 PageID #:1400 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 229 107:4,7,9 110:24 112:9,10,17,19,20 113:16,23,24 114:4,7,15,17,21 118:2,13 119:9,24 120:1,24 123:24 124:11,19 125:6,7 126:2 128:12 130:1 131:2,21 132:5 139:6,16,18 143:22 144:14 146:7 147:14 148:6 152:12 157:10,12,14 158:15,17 159:1 159:17 160:2,6 161:11,23 163:1,1 166:21 169:12 170:7 176:9 177:23 178:14,21 179:11 182:17 184:4 185:16 188:19,20 196:22 197:18 201:23 202:9 203:5 204:9 205:8 206:2 208:23 209:2 211:13 213:21,22 215:10 immediate 97:16 97:17 immediately 182:24 183:2 191:19 196:4,14 196:16 impair 124:9 impairing 178:9 impeach 159:4 impeaching 158:16 158:17,20 160:17 impeachment 159:5 implementation 98:12 implementing 188:10 improper 71:18 158:16 159:22 160:21 187:15,16 improperly 106:18 106:20 160:17 improvement 51:7 51:9 52:9 inactive 101:24 inception 10:20 incident 60:21 62:22 63:2 108:12 108:21 110:4 111:4 127:23 157:18 161:12 164:21 188:9 incidents 156:24 incipient 209:13 inclement 171:5 include 166:16 167:21 included 105:3 131:19,23 including 104:14 inclusive 216:13 incoherent 198:18 incompetence 45:22,23 53:7 incomplete 84:4 183:16 incorporated 133:22 incorrect 41:1 46:8 92:24 93:2 independent 48:22 49:3 indicate 92:1 indicated 37:16 160:20 180:17 indicating 41:17 indirectly 217:24 individual 2:16 63:18 71:10 78:9 79:4,16 90:1 105:16 106:15,19 107:6 108:16 109:20,24 110:1,7 110:10 142:3 individuals 82:21 107:13 108:17 143:16,18 153:5,7 153:8,23,24 177:15 178:12 201:17 inferred 173:20 influence 199:15 informal 148:12,15 informally 52:20 52:21 134:21 135:4 information 6:18 6:20 7:2 15:2 52:5 62:19 68:22 70:9 71:13,15 74:17,20 78:23 81:20,21,24 118:11 127:4 130:21 131:12 144:11 162:4,7 179:19 180:12 200:21 infrequent 80:7 infrequently 80:22 80:23 inherent 54:16 167:15 initial 158:2 initially 168:6,12 173:2,3 184:22 197:15,17,21 198:3 initiate 65:4 initiated 65:19 66:6 68:19 75:19 97:18 97:21 injured 109:20 injuries 157:13 innocuous 157:11 157:12 innuendos 74:19 input 87:3 inside 165:10 inspector 122:1 instances 110:20 instruct 75:12 112:16 113:17 160:5 instruction 105:11 integrity 91:15 intelligence 153:10 173:23,24 intelligent 7:18 53:12,14 interact 150:11 152:8 153:15 interaction 153:9 interested 217:23 interface 153:8 intermittent 207:24 intermittently 10:19 internal 32:6 72:23 81:18,22 82:1,2 97:13 internally 97:19,22 interrogatories 128:15 interrogatory 132:21 215:4 interrupt 124:19 intervening 38:22 interview 28:4,20 29:2 34:3 82:13 82:15,23 83:4,9 83:14 86:14,16 interviewed 27:21 28:1 intrusive 167:24 invalid 85:13 inventorying 60:24 investigate 73:23 89:17 investigated 34:2 89:12 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 investigates 97:12 investigating 46:1 46:3 50:8 52:12 54:2 investigation 33:12 33:15,21 35:23 36:2,3,5,10 40:8 46:17 48:4 49:4 49:10,13 54:17 55:1 73:10 74:4 75:15 89:20,21,22 90:16,21 91:13,15 91:22,24 92:3,13 92:16,21,24 93:1 97:9 109:6 127:22 investigations 24:23 49:22 50:14 51:11,22 52:2,4,6 52:16 53:1,18,21 54:6,7 89:24 94:14,15,18,19 95:17 96:10,11,16 96:17 97:18,21 110:19 investigative 209:8 investigator 46:5 48:5,10 49:10,14 49:17 72:11 75:1 155:12 199:3 200:6 210:9 invoke 71:18 involved 11:15 38:10,13,13 109:16 122:3 131:4,5 176:16 involvement 154:6 involving 60:24 ipra 23:11,21,23 24:7 35:16,22 36:2,9,16 40:4,5,7 43:9 50:22 51:1,3 51:6,10 52:11,15 52:24 53:7,20 54:1,4 92:5,12,15 93:5 97:11 127:22 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 93 of 107 PageID #:1401 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 230 138:22 139:5 154:6 156:8,23 157:17 161:7,17 173:15,17 184:7 185:11,12,20 189:18,19 199:2 200:5,19,22,23 210:9 ipras 45:22 irrational 193:4 194:18 198:15 207:10,18 irrelevant 14:22 44:11 56:22 61:2 65:13 78:15 84:4 isnt 27:7 191:2 issue 23:23,24 116:18 133:10 145:6 150:20 164:19 issues 48:10 92:1 117:11 152:14 158:6 162:3 169:23 173:15,18 174:6,15,17,21 176:2,8 178:7 180:17 181:18 199:16 items 129:18 ive 17:19,24 87:6 114:19 136:11 169:18 186:24 187:2 192:10 98:4,6 134:6,7,18 135:7,17 136:9 137:16 139:1 141:11 148:20 183:18 joining 102:9,15 joins 115:4 joshua 110:22 111:1 114:11 118:16,18 journalist 120:11 120:14 judge 113:18 114:18 116:16,23 117:3,10 127:16 214:3,7 judges 114:19 july 21:6 93:15,16 93:17 94:8,8 96:1 96:2 98:16,16 99:13 101:16 103:4,13 104:6 122:10 125:19 june 27:8 58:14 59:14,22 68:19 justice 73:11,20 74:3 75:1 justified 188:7 K k 2:17 217:2 kedzie 12:5 keep 8:4 67:11 177:12,13 199:18 J 199:23 201:10 jackson 180:19 keeper 141:7,20 jail 199:6 keeps 67:12 january 42:15,15 kelly 87:12,23 45:16 kenneth 3:13,16 jennifer 108:24 kevin 140:7,9 jesus 99:11 132:7 kicked 47:6 108:16 john 88:16 kicking 108:7 johnson 88:17 kill 47:10 68:21 join 73:14,15 74:8 killed 110:1 74:12 75:11 84:12 kind 17:10 128:3 150:21 176:16 knocked 48:11 205:10 know 9:7 11:16 king 1:3 5:7 10:22 16:15 17:10 22:22 11:1 35:17 36:3,9 27:16,19 28:17 36:12,15 37:18 30:4,6,7,8,13 40:9 47:20 56:24 31:21 32:7,10,16 61:6 106:10 108:3 32:21 33:11,14 108:5 111:22 34:5,11,13,22 117:8 125:24 35:21 36:4,6,12 136:16 154:7 36:14 40:7 41:11 156:18,20 157:1 42:20 49:14 51:3 157:22 158:2 53:11,14 57:16,18 162:2,19 163:15 57:20,23 60:3 163:20 164:7,14 61:24 63:11,13,14 166:8,24 167:6 63:17 64:12 65:3 168:11,19,24 65:18 66:17 79:2 170:6,9,20 171:7 79:5,11 80:6 81:9 172:5,7,17,22 89:12 91:16 92:10 173:10 174:5,22 94:10 96:17 97:2 174:24 175:19,22 99:5,7 101:21 175:24 177:7,18 104:2 107:15 178:2 179:1,4,5 110:19 111:10 179:21 180:24 120:13 121:4,11 182:6 183:1,7 123:1 126:19 191:11,21 193:9 127:21 128:1 193:17 194:9,14 130:5 132:3,8 194:19 195:5,16 140:7,8,12 142:7 196:4,15,19 197:1 142:8,9,21 144:4 197:9,12,16,22 146:19 148:9,11 198:3,12 200:14 149:6,8 152:19 202:5,9,18 203:1 165:23 172:1,3,7 203:4,7,18,21 172:9,17 173:9 204:2,17 205:4,16 175:13,15 176:19 205:22 206:4,8,9 178:24 179:1,11 206:11,14,16 179:12,13 182:3 208:4,13,16 209:1 184:17 186:22 209:5,21 210:1,3 191:4 193:5,9 210:10,19 211:6 202:15 204:16 216:3 205:3 207:17 kings 106:7 172:1 208:19 209:2,11 192:21 203:14 209:17,22 210:6 206:21 207:9 211:7,11,13,16 klinus 32:14 212:14 213:4 knew 179:8,9,13 knowledge 17:9 180:3 21:8 32:21 35:5 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 51:6 52:5,7 76:21 77:6,11,11 89:1 89:17 98:9 99:3 119:13,14 125:8 141:14,17,18 143:7,13,21 144:9 145:1 150:8,14 151:5,5,19,22 known 150:11 152:10 209:10 kupearion 3:5,7 15:15 73:12 74:6 75:4,12 84:8 85:4 97:23 111:24 115:4 116:8 134:4 134:15 135:5,14 136:7 137:14 138:23 139:12 141:9 148:18 151:18 212:5 213:1 L l 2:17 3:13 labor 102:20 lack 74:10 90:13 130:20 language 63:9 lapitan 2:17 lasalle 2:12 3:5 law 2:2,9 3:2,11 73:23 168:1 176:5 188:9 212:10,10 lawsuit 118:18 130:23 133:17 lawsuits 31:2 130:11 131:3,19 131:22 132:16 133:4,13 lawyer 155:8 lay 137:17,23 138:5 laying 180:1 lead 15:2 44:14 61:3 62:16 74:9 84:5 115:20 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 94 of 107 PageID #:1402 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 231 117:21 125:22 leads 114:23 116:2 118:11 learn 103:2,12 learned 103:9 104:9,12,15 105:16 leave 8:15,16,20,22 177:19 178:3 179:15 180:8,13 leaving 211:3 leeway 136:12 left 108:24 legal 67:5,13 legalities 168:3 letter 188:9 level 98:13 105:17 105:22,22 154:21 167:14 173:22,23 levels 153:8 liability 199:19 201:11,14 liable 201:18 liar 119:4,21 120:7 120:14 liberal 100:23 license 218:10 lie 26:8 119:17,20 131:11 lied 90:1 106:16 119:9,11 lies 16:24 74:18 121:1 lieutenant 20:20 27:2,5 69:19 76:1 76:12,20,24,24 77:17 78:2,10 86:11,20 88:12,24 89:13,18 90:22 91:2,8 107:18 120:8,22 137:20 145:18,22 149:20 155:2 limit 24:12,16,20 limited 52:4,5,7 line 185:16,17 200:7 211:21 214:24 list 130:11 134:1 listed 132:16 listen 116:4 186:21 187:10 listing 130:13 lists 172:2 litigation 2:11 3:4 115:20,21 little 129:16 150:22 lloyd 2:18 lobby 171:3,19 180:1,5 183:3,3 located 143:10,24 location 108:2 lock 146:3,6 156:17 locked 146:10,11 146:12 199:23 lockup 106:1,13,15 141:5,7,18,20 142:16,17,18 143:8,20 145:19 145:20,23 156:20 158:4 162:13,20 163:16,20 164:8 164:11,15 165:16 165:21,22 166:3 166:17,24 167:7 167:10,19 168:12 168:24 172:23 182:2,5,12,15,16 182:19,20,23 183:6,15 184:8 185:23 190:16 191:10,20 192:11 192:24 193:8,15 196:3 199:19,22 200:12 201:10,18 202:5,8,17 203:14 205:13 208:13,22 209:1 210:3,7,12 211:3 lockups 190:11 lodge 97:4 128:3 lodged 128:2 log 144:13 long 6:6 8:16 20:24 21:3,5 24:1,9 25:22 30:20 164:14 166:1 188:6 194:9,23 196:6 202:7,12 longterm 171:24 look 41:11,14,16 49:5 58:2 59:2,3 72:4 79:6,9,12,14 79:24 83:16,23 113:10 130:6 185:12 188:8 looked 136:20 205:18 looking 43:8 55:19 72:9 looks 42:23 57:4 67:15 182:22 198:7 lot 11:23 17:11 31:18 40:24 46:7 46:8,8,10 51:23 52:1,11 54:2,5,6 69:11 85:12 89:24 127:18 136:11,12 181:15 184:21 188:10 198:17 200:20 lots 161:24 lott 110:23 111:2 114:11 118:16,18 119:2,4,10,15,18 120:6,7,11 124:12 lotts 119:12 lousy 52:15,24 53:21 lucidity 124:2 208:1 lump 23:5 lying 119:22 120:15 M m 1:17 5:13 maced 47:7 machine 206:12 mad 199:5 madeleine 3:5 maintain 211:14 majority 212:18 making 9:3 15:10 39:7 44:9 53:16 78:4 79:7,14 98:12 114:21 119:24 120:2 178:5 206:15 males 181:7 man 78:14,16 124:15,17 manage 25:8 29:11 29:12 141:18,19 managed 149:18 management 201:20 manic 174:1 176:12,13,14 177:9 180:16 manner 24:23 manpower 170:1 manual 102:20 march 12:16 26:2 55:21 63:3 108:13 marital 65:13 70:17,21 mark 41:2 56:12 62:3 66:22 68:11 128:5 marked 4:8 41:5,9 54:11 56:10,14 57:3 62:6,9 67:2 128:9,13 200:24 marking 68:9,11 married 64:19,20 64:23 65:1,23 masked 174:19 matter 114:11 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 131:5 132:19 144:12 matters 87:6 130:13 217:9 mayer 134:14 136:6 138:22 139:10 mayor 134:3,9 135:4,12 137:7,11 138:15 139:5,15 mccarthy 17:15 28:12,15,22 29:14 29:24 31:1,5,16 mean 8:21 33:14 45:11 48:17 50:4 50:9,10 51:2,3 52:7 53:23 61:17 65:22 66:20 68:10 75:8 76:24 77:23 79:22 80:23,24 94:10 97:3,3 103:5 104:21 118:6 123:18 130:5 134:20 137:1 145:5,12 156:9 157:11 162:8 173:5,18 177:22 190:3 201:13 202:3 203:10 207:15,22 213:11 means 8:23 45:13 79:11 81:1 201:14 measure 103:24 198:20 measures 103:10 103:11,16,20 104:5,10,12 meat 136:22 media 74:18,21,22 medications 124:9 meet 137:7 meeting 135:11 137:11 138:17 meetings 134:24 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 95 of 107 PageID #:1403 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 232 138:16 member 40:18 49:20 52:13 56:2 60:4,11 61:13 66:2 83:24 97:22 110:5 135:13 153:15 175:18 208:12 members 50:6,13 52:10 118:19 150:10 151:16 180:8,15 memo 57:5 memory 11:18 27:7 29:23 31:14 40:21 53:5 156:22 164:19 memos 81:1 mental 150:11 151:11,17 152:10 152:13 153:4,16 153:19,23 158:6 162:3 166:18 173:10,12,14,18 174:6,15,17,21 176:1,7 178:16 181:18,22 199:13 199:16 200:10 mentally 152:14 mention 136:23 message 194:4 met 134:3,9,13 135:1,3 138:14,17 138:18 methods 103:14 michael 87:13 middle 46:23 military 101:9 mind 11:10 38:9,12 39:2 43:18 mine 38:2 58:17 minimize 104:17 209:15 minimum 170:11 181:6 minor 199:22 morrissey 2:3,4,4 201:22 202:2,2 4:4 5:3,6,14 6:21 minute 64:18 166:5 7:4,14 8:8 11:21 193:13 196:9 12:2 14:11,17 197:6 15:3,8,21 16:4,8 minutes 182:4 16:10,21 17:4 202:16 19:7 21:17 28:6,9 minutia 157:15 33:4 34:21 37:1 mischaracterizes 37:10,13,20,21 174:8 38:6,16,21 39:4,8 misconduct 11:19 39:18,23 40:1 13:12,18 33:16 41:2,7,15 42:1,7 34:2 36:11 40:9 43:13 44:3,5,17 50:8 51:12 66:8 44:18 45:6 48:6 75:18,21 84:24 51:15,19 52:22 90:10 106:1,12,14 55:12 56:9,18 119:16,19 120:5 57:2 58:9,13,21 124:23 125:5,9 59:2,5,9 60:19,20 misnomer 188:1 61:11,18 62:3,8 misrepresented 63:1 65:9,15,17 90:3 66:22 67:7,21 misspelled 46:10 68:3,8,13,17 misspoke 70:8 70:10,23 71:8,17 167:5 72:1 73:18 74:23 misstatements 75:16 76:5,8 77:7 74:18 77:14 79:1 81:11 mistake 46:1 82:10 84:17 86:1 mitigate 170:2 87:21 88:11 97:6 modes 105:10 98:14 99:1,15 modify 129:19,23 100:9 107:12 130:2,15,18 108:11,20 109:4 molestation 46:6 109:11 111:18,23 49:15 112:9,14,19 113:1 moment 6:13 41:11 113:4,20 114:4,9 moments 124:1 115:5,9,22,24 monell 14:9,23 116:5,13,17,24 47:19 57:1 61:7 117:4,10,17,24 116:5,9 136:15 118:13,15 120:20 monetary 9:11 121:3 122:14 monitor 146:1 123:5,13,20 124:6 month 25:1 101:17 125:1 128:5,11 months 12:11,13 129:20 131:17 94:6 132:22 132:12,24 133:7 morning 147:7 133:11 134:12,22 191:6 135:10 136:3 108:23 124:18 133:15 149:6 172:1 173:5,5 179:8,9,11,12,13 named 31:2,4,9,15 130:11 133:13 names 82:21 132:15 171:20 narcotics 89:21 90:7,8 193:3 199:14,15 200:11 nasty 126:5 nato 120:10,22 nature 62:18 79:18 126:24 144:21 145:2,3,5 151:7 168:3 nearby 194:6 197:11 necessarily 50:4 necessary 117:5 need 7:23 41:20 116:15 181:19 183:22 needlessly 115:7,12 115:15 needs 146:18 169:8 169:10 178:10 negative 85:17 neither 131:15 net 213:18 never 32:18 33:7 43:18 98:11,12 102:3 111:9,12 119:3 121:11 124:22,24 125:4 159:3 news 10:9 11:8 N night 16:3 n 2:1 3:1 4:1 5:13 nine 20:16 5:13 nomination 82:21 name 5:6,15 46:10 noncomplaint 46:22 57:7,10 105:17 78:22 99:21 100:5 noncompliance 107:13,14 108:17 105:18,23 137:4 138:1,8,20 139:8 140:3,6,22 141:15 142:14 147:19 148:1,3,13 149:5 150:18 151:20 152:1,23 153:13 156:5 157:8 158:17,21 159:3,7,9,17,24 160:4,8,11,14,23 161:2,14 163:10 163:23 164:4 170:4 173:1 174:13 176:22 184:3 185:8 186:5 186:11,18,24 187:17 188:13 192:22 195:13,22 203:2 204:15 205:2,14 207:4,7 212:13,21 213:7 213:16 214:17 215:10,12,15 motion 214:23 move 7:3 116:7 118:7,8,14 201:20 moving 43:24 196:23 multifaceted 24:4 multiple 17:19,24 23:5 56:6 88:14 90:8 100:13,17 103:17,19 104:9 104:11,22 105:9 105:10 141:1 142:17 178:2 192:10 193:21 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 96 of 107 PageID #:1404 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 233 14:20 15:15 36:18 38:17 39:1,18 44:10,22 47:15 56:20 61:2 62:14 65:6 71:6 73:12 74:6 75:4 78:14 82:5 84:3,13 85:3 85:5,6 87:17 88:6 97:23 98:5,20 108:19 109:1,8,14 111:24 114:19,21 125:20 132:8,18 133:2 134:4,15 135:5,14,15 136:7 137:14,22 138:10 138:23 139:12 141:9 148:16 155:22 158:23 159:1 160:1,7 174:7 183:16 186:3 192:14 195:7,18 202:19 204:3,18 205:6 212:5 objections 15:5,10 15:23 39:7 43:15 65:12 148:21 obligated 16:17 obligation 133:8 obliterated 42:24 obscure 131:12 obscured 57:7,8,10 57:11,12,13 67:18 O 67:20 o 5:13 217:2,2 observation 50:4 oath 26:5 124:12 observe 172:11 216:10 180:7,24 197:1,10 object 16:2 39:3 206:3 43:12 114:15 observed 168:21 131:2 139:16,18 170:23 171:7 147:14 148:6 174:5 191:11 152:12 158:15 193:9 197:3 160:16 204:6,7 obstructing 194:22 objecting 44:2,10 occasion 175:24 objection 6:14 14:7 177:18 180:11,14 noncompliant 105:13,16 normal 186:19 north 2:12 3:5 northern 1:1 216:1 nose 105:1,3,6 notary 216:22 note 184:15 noted 35:4 39:1 notes 42:6 83:13 164:23 165:1 noticed 112:20 notification 62:11 80:12 83:6 notifications 83:21 notified 66:5,9,12 66:15 121:12 notify 144:19 november 99:13 103:4,13 104:6 155:12 210:10 number 12:9 29:14 40:22 46:18,18 58:3 67:18 68:11 75:17 82:3 114:20 119:15,17 130:6,8 130:8 131:20,24 133:12 181:14,15 181:17 numerous 10:9,11 87:6 118:19 203:15,17,20 occasions 170:17 170:23 174:4 occupied 181:7 191:5,7 occur 28:4 110:16 150:1 157:13 occurred 30:11,15 55:21 108:13,22 111:4,5 122:10 178:19 oclock 147:6,7 october 62:12 offense 201:22 209:6 offenses 199:23 202:2,3 offhand 9:7 11:16 60:13 62:2 132:3 office 11:12 18:21 19:11,15 27:17 28:8,16,18 30:8 38:8 78:7,11 80:16,17 144:20 162:12 165:4,6,9 165:21 166:3 officer 22:24 23:2 24:3 27:16 31:3 46:23 47:7 69:15 69:17,22 81:17 82:4,12 93:4,12 93:14 96:1,4,9 98:15 108:6,16 110:9 137:20 140:7,8,14,23 145:8,16 146:22 147:9,13,20 148:1 148:2,4,4,12,12 148:15 149:1,2,4 149:6,9 156:17 158:5,9,10 162:2 162:17,17 163:2 163:11,11,18 164:5,13,23 166:7 166:10,13,22 168:4,5,23 175:7 175:10,12,14,18 176:19 182:1,12 182:16,19,19 188:23 189:6 191:12,19,24 192:4 193:15 194:3,5,8,12 195:3 196:18 197:2,10,22,24 198:2,4,7,8,10 201:5,7 204:1,13 204:16 205:3,15 205:17,20 206:3 208:10 210:6 211:12,12,13,14 officers 21:16,23 22:10,20 32:17 50:19 51:12,13,15 52:12 53:22 54:3 85:15 157:23 158:8 162:6 167:15 172:12,14 172:15,21 179:20 189:17,23 192:5,8 192:12 193:21 196:5,14 201:15 211:8 212:15,19 offices 2:2,9 3:2,11 official 13:11,18 officially 128:2 oh 99:11 107:4 okay 7:8,17,22 15:6 39:24 41:21 42:3 42:5 45:9 46:14 63:24 71:24 77:8 84:22 106:8 112:5 121:2 124:3 126:7 152:23 163:8 184:7 186:21 187:2 199:11,17 205:9 old 44:12 47:17,18 56:22 once 35:12 57:24 58:11 62:24 65:2 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 67:17 92:7 95:9 95:10 100:17 106:3,4,16 110:10 150:1 178:19 193:23 oneil 49:19 ones 51:23,24 54:9 54:9 68:2 132:2 133:15,23 193:22 ongoing 91:13,18 91:22 208:2 209:14 onthejob 152:4 open 35:15,23 36:3 36:4,9 opened 110:20 operation 9:18 operational 9:18 51:4 54:4 144:5,8 144:18,24 146:18 169:7,10 178:10 185:4 187:23 188:4 200:1 operationally 51:2 operations 141:19 146:1 194:22 opinion 50:1,2,5 51:10,18,21 52:18 52:21 53:20,24 opportunities 81:2 opportunity 39:3 42:9 130:7 133:2 156:6 186:9,16 215:2 opposed 181:17 188:9 ops 45:22 49:4,17 49:21 50:7,13,22 51:7 52:8 72:6,11 72:15,20 97:12 109:6 option 55:10 154:19,20 178:15 options 43:11 44:21 45:8,12,14 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 97 of 107 PageID #:1405 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 234 62:11 67:18 72:4 72:7,9,13 128:17 129:1 185:16 pages 42:23 67:19 216:13 paid 8:24 155:7 pain 105:20 208:5 208:7 palles 112:15 114:13 paper 49:16 papers 125:7 paragraph 57:9 parameter 188:4 parameters 79:18 79:21 83:3 park 180:19 part 67:22 84:22 116:3 145:20 146:8 181:23 partial 200:21 partially 42:14,16 42:17,18,19,24 57:6,8,10,11,12 57:13 58:11 67:18 participant 21:22 participate 21:13 23:1 26:15,17 participated 80:21 particular 33:23 79:17 214:24 particulars 95:4 parties 217:23 parts 48:3 party 159:10 pass 76:16 P passage 78:20 p 1:17 2:1,1 3:1,1 passed 202:16 3:12 pat 5:6 7:3 213:4 page 4:1,8 41:24 patient 102:20 42:13,14,15,17,17 patrick 2:4 42:18,19,20,20,22 patrickmorrissey... 45:8,9 46:10,15 2:6 46:22,23 55:19 patrol 141:5 145:8 57:4,8,14 58:2 147:9 212:2,3,9 45:18 orally 7:16 order 5:5 91:14 150:20 151:2,6,7 151:13,14 156:4 169:23 170:2 185:13 209:15 213:23 ordered 126:13 orders 150:9,9 151:9 186:1 187:24 188:1,2,11 188:11 org 2:14 3:7 organization 151:3 original 136:20 originally 35:19 43:9 44:20 outage 144:22 145:3 outcome 217:24 outlined 83:20 outside 11:13 48:22 125:21 170:23 206:7 outstanding 85:20 outweighed 181:19 overall 104:9 167:3 overly 78:19 80:18 152:15 overnight 146:16 146:19 overt 181:17 overview 29:8 oxymoron 14:2 212:12,15 patrolling 145:12 145:16 patrons 177:15 178:11 pay 155:2 paycheck 9:8,10,22 10:2 payroll 9:20 peggy 1:14 217:3 218:8 pending 7:6 8:2 13:8 75:15 122:11 209:8 people 28:17 52:23 53:6 84:20 110:1 153:15 171:12,16 181:22 184:21 perform 86:24 performance 83:19 performing 211:3 period 23:14,17,18 24:18 84:18 86:2 87:23 88:19 94:20 99:4 103:23 140:20,24 199:24 202:10,11 periodic 9:8 periodically 8:19 9:16 113:12 periods 27:4 perjured 137:8 perjury 70:7 permanent 171:23 permanently 180:22 person 77:16 83:7 85:2 105:13,13 152:21 180:5 184:17 personal 52:17,20 77:6,10,11 98:8 141:14,17,18 150:14 217:13 personally 63:13 63:17 83:8 92:15 149:8 personnel 36:13 53:17 85:20 87:2 87:5 140:2 149:19 209:15 persons 104:13,16 104:20 105:1,3 152:14 persuade 184:11 pertaining 1:12 ph 210:20 phone 114:20 126:19 phonetic 32:14 photo 120:11,14 206:12 photograph 143:15 143:15,17 184:20 193:19 photographed 109:7 184:18 203:8,19,24 208:16 211:6 photographing 206:12 photographs 194:10,14 195:5 195:16 physical 103:14,15 103:19,24 104:5,9 104:11 105:7 107:24 119:15,16 145:3 190:15 201:15,16 202:4,8 202:18,24 203:3,6 203:10,12 204:17 205:4,16,21 206:4 206:5,13,15,20,23 207:8,20 209:24 210:16,17 physically 25:17 47:4 166:8 167:3 167:4,5 201:18 physicians 140:1 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 picture 126:6,18,18 pinchum 127:13 pipe 126:23 place 44:13 176:15 177:23 190:14,19 216:14 217:17 placed 137:9 190:22 plaintiff 1:4,10 2:8 130:12,14 131:1 133:13,18,19 216:4 plaintiffs 128:14 planning 56:16 play 109:16 plead 214:15 pleading 213:12,22 214:6,12 please 5:15 37:10 37:13 158:1 184:2 po 76:24 77:1 pocket 155:7 point 13:4 28:24 29:21 102:23 103:1,2,5,8 104:14,18 105:6 110:12 116:12 134:2 139:6 144:3 144:7 169:1,3 172:24 187:13 198:5 206:6 214:22 215:6 pointed 47:8 pointing 58:8 police 6:1 9:9 10:11 10:13,21,24 13:3 13:6 17:8,16,22 18:5 19:21 20:1,7 21:1,4,6,15 22:8 22:20 23:2 25:8,9 27:23 31:3 32:2,5 34:9 40:13,18,23 49:21 50:7 51:11 51:13,15 52:12,14 53:21 54:2 55:5 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 98 of 107 PageID #:1406 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 235 55:14,17 57:19 60:5,12,23 61:13 64:10 66:3,7 69:2 69:5,8 73:9,23 74:4 75:20 76:2 78:5,7 79:15 81:13 93:12,13 94:2 96:1,4,8 98:3 98:15 102:10,16 108:6,15 110:6 118:19 119:19 127:1 135:13 137:20 139:11,24 152:10 162:9 187:22 188:5 205:24,24 206:1 208:12 212:11 policies 78:21 98:2 policy 35:13 82:20 98:12 144:12,16 146:19 151:23 168:2 political 85:13 127:6,9,14 politicians 140:2 poor 49:3,9,21 50:7 50:13 51:11 portion 49:8 188:15 213:11,13 portions 42:11 poses 201:14,16 posing 194:21 position 26:22 29:7 51:8 75:24 93:8 93:11,18 153:20 154:1 positioned 182:6 positive 85:17 possible 56:7 59:24 60:2 61:20,23 77:20 87:20 88:9 90:13,18 94:18 106:5 118:23 132:1 145:11 164:17 173:8,16 175:8 180:14 182:21 200:13 207:17 210:22 possibly 29:18 31:12 57:22 88:23 89:8 99:7 136:16 143:22,24 164:3 215:9 post 126:8 141:21 141:23,24 posted 205:1 posterior 106:22 potential 86:19 powers 13:4,7 19:21 practices 35:13 precursor 97:11 predecessor 97:12 predicated 50:3 74:20 187:23 predicates 133:21 prefer 116:6 preparation 10:7 11:6,9 prepare 128:23 preparing 128:20 128:22 presence 119:19 179:14,18 180:18 205:24,24 206:1 211:15 present 28:13,16 28:23 154:16,24 164:20 175:17,21 175:23 176:23 179:21 182:12,14 182:16,20 193:15 208:12 210:7,19 presently 9:4,12,21 19:1,6,10,14,21 19:24 20:18,19 32:7,10 140:11 pressure 102:23,24 103:2,5,8 104:14 104:18 105:6 pretense 174:20 pretty 13:2 54:21 158:11 171:18 173:20,21 185:4 194:1 195:10 209:11 prevent 124:7 previous 33:2,7 39:13 170:17 213:23 217:6 previously 174:11 175:16 prieto 3:11 primarily 158:10 primary 212:9,10 print 42:24 prior 12:3 17:15 25:10,12 26:21,23 27:21 31:4,15 33:10,18 36:1,8 42:8 43:5 48:17 56:1 75:24 86:14 93:10 94:1 102:9 102:15 111:13 112:11 128:24 129:7 137:11 163:22,23,24 170:5,8,21 172:15 173:9 174:5,14 175:4 177:7,17 178:1,20 179:7,15 179:22 180:3,9 181:1 188:24 189:7,14 207:11 prisoner 146:14 prisoners 141:19 143:15,17 146:1 167:16 privilege 65:13 70:17,24 71:9,19 112:8 privileged 6:17,20 7:2 117:1 privileges 70:20,21 probably 34:10 35:7 66:11 95:12 116:19 129:14,18 196:1 201:7 209:13 problem 53:15 112:5 123:8 138:2 138:3 problematic 51:22 51:23 52:2 54:7 problems 24:5 52:12 54:2,5,6,16 158:7 162:18,22 163:14 166:19,23 176:3 procedure 1:11 185:7 187:23 188:4 211:11 procedures 60:23 78:21 82:20 84:11 proceeding 187:7 proceedings 217:15 process 27:20 44:16 47:23 78:12 78:13,17 80:19,21 82:9 113:15 136:18 164:12 184:21 189:24 199:20 200:2 203:22 207:19 processed 143:16 143:17 167:10 190:5 processing 143:11 146:14 158:7 162:14,19,22 163:15 166:19 167:19 190:21 206:17 produced 84:9 98:1 productivity 86:23 profanity 61:13,22 63:15 profession 54:8,10 prohibited 91:14 91:17,21 168:1 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 prolonged 199:24 prolonging 115:8 115:15 promote 79:16 promoted 27:10 30:21 76:11,18,20 76:23,23 77:12,16 78:1,9 79:4,8 80:3 82:13 83:7,18 86:10 promotion 27:12 27:22 31:1 33:10 33:18 81:4 83:10 84:21 85:2 86:15 86:18,19 promotional 81:2 83:21 promotions 77:4 80:8,10 proper 60:23 75:14 137:23 138:5 properly 187:8 property 61:1 126:4,13 prostitution 171:1 171:9 181:1,2,4 181:15 protocol 32:20 33:8 183:14 184:7 185:3,5,6,22 186:1,19,23 187:3 187:21 189:21 190:4 protocols 32:19 provide 22:6 23:21 82:3 188:3,17 provided 22:4,7,12 43:10 156:6 206:1 proximity 204:23 psychiatrist 154:3 psychologist 154:2 psychotic 152:18 ptsd 152:19 public 25:8 71:13 71:15 94:5,7,13 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 99 of 107 PageID #:1407 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 236 94:21,24 95:7,21 95:23 96:7 131:5 132:19 133:3 138:18 169:23,24 171:19,21 209:14 216:22 punched 47:6 punishment 97:16 127:10 purpose 143:14 purposes 85:14 pursuant 1:11 5:5 179:5 pushed 119:8,21 put 97:2 119:5,10 199:22 putting 14:4 157:21 158:8,9 159:4,20,22 160:21 161:15 163:3,6,9 169:6 184:7 185:14,16 185:18,22 186:4 186:11,14,17 187:5,11 188:14 188:16,18 191:22 192:24 193:10 195:2,8 198:16,22 199:3,11,16,17 203:9 205:19 207:3 212:6 215:1 215:8 questioning 200:8 questions 7:15 17:1 23:4,8 39:6 40:14 Q 41:12,23 42:2 qpwblaw 3:16 56:17,21 62:15 qualities 79:13,17 112:20 114:5 queries 23:5 72:23 136:13 141:16 question 7:6,10,21 157:2,21 158:13 8:2 14:12 16:20 159:18 161:16,18 19:4 21:24 22:21 161:19,21 184:5 23:6 24:4 33:13 185:1,10,19 34:16 36:20 37:2 188:16 198:24 37:4,8,9 38:22 199:2 200:5 213:6 39:12,14,15 41:18 213:8,14,17 42:4 53:2 55:7 214:11,18,20,21 59:7 69:6 71:11 215:3 75:5 84:7,16 quick 194:16 195:1 86:16 88:2 91:9 196:8,13 199:21 97:8 104:2 113:6 quickly 200:2 113:9,13,18,22 quiet 38:2 114:1,3,7 117:3 quintairos 3:11 118:5,6 120:17 quite 52:6 53:12,13 122:11,20 123:4,6 quote 13:12 47:9 123:10 129:23 63:21 130:6,8,10 131:11 R 132:9,20 135:16 135:22,24 136:2 r 2:1,17 3:1 5:13 137:3,5,6,15,21 race 53:13 138:2,4,9,12 raise 34:18 37:11 142:11 155:24 37:14,24,24 38:1 38:7,15 158:24 59:24 60:6,7,11 raising 38:17,18 60:13,21 61:21,23 116:8 62:22,24 64:1,8 ran 126:22 64:14 65:8 66:14 range 25:4 147:5 66:16 68:18,22,24 rank 20:19,21 96:8 68:24 70:9,11 rate 9:4 75:23 82:9 83:1 read 43:20 58:12 88:1,3,8,10,21 62:23,23 67:23 89:5,6,10 90:12 123:14,16 130:7 90:14,19 91:6 136:19 188:15 92:11 93:3 94:19 216:11 95:3,5,24 96:14 ready 41:12 101:24 96:14,15,19,21 114:17 97:7 99:21 101:17 real 11:24 34:19 104:4 106:4 107:2 54:8,9 97:1 126:5 107:13 108:12,21 152:16,20 109:5 110:17,21 really 11:24 22:21 110:22 111:1,7 26:2 43:1 104:2 118:23 121:10,16 107:5 112:23 124:13 125:2,18 116:9 132:7 128:20,22 135:1,9 135:21 139:13 138:16 139:4 152:16 156:21 141:3 142:20 169:6 205:18 143:1,5 144:2,7 207:18 145:10 156:19,21 reask 59:6 157:15,17 161:12 reason 67:22 131:9 161:15,19,24 188:7 209:9 162:11,16 164:9 reasonably 61:3 164:16 165:3 62:16 74:9 125:21 166:9,14 167:8 reassigned 17:7 169:9 170:14,15 reassignment 171:6,10 172:3,6 17:16 18:12 172:13,14 173:7 recall 10:3,6 11:13 175:8,11,20 177:6 12:15 13:19 18:8 181:3,3 182:13,21 18:10,16 26:2,9 183:5 191:8,16 27:15 28:3 29:1 192:9 193:13 29:17,19,20 30:7 194:6 195:3,14,24 30:18,22,22 31:10 196:2,2,20 202:11 31:12 34:15 35:10 202:12,23 204:13 40:17 45:16 47:12 205:17,20 206:6 48:7,13,15 49:5 208:14 210:5,20 49:11,12 50:17 210:22,24 211:1 53:16 54:12 55:3 receive 9:8,11,15 55:10,24 56:4,5,8 9:20 24:6 87:15 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 89:2 100:20,22 101:20 received 23:11 67:17 78:23 155:4 179:19 receiving 10:1 89:5 89:10 104:4 recipient 95:6 recognize 183:1,2 recollection 13:24 24:22 33:24 46:4 48:19,21,22 49:3 49:9 51:5 60:16 70:7 86:6 89:19 89:23 107:17 121:6 126:3,17 141:1 147:12 157:6,19 161:6,10 170:10,19 178:22 179:4 182:7 183:10 185:13 188:22 192:1 197:5,20 198:9 recollections 29:4 recommend 35:3,6 84:20 recommendation 23:12 24:3 40:3 78:5,9 79:7 recommended 27:17 34:6,23 35:10,20 36:16 43:10 44:20 45:17 77:16,18 78:1 record 5:16 15:12 38:20 39:11 59:8 71:22 112:22,24 113:3,16 114:8 115:18 116:22 118:5,7,9 119:5 119:10 123:15 131:5,13 132:19 133:3 144:17 171:20 213:3 215:7 217:14 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 100 of 107 PageID #:1408 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 237 recorded 30:5 recorder 30:3 recording 30:3 records 93:7 94:11 102:5 144:10 177:2 184:16 recovered 61:1 reduced 54:13,15 217:12 refer 93:8 referee 116:16,23 117:3 reference 108:10 referred 32:4 referring 77:10 109:24 200:13,14 201:4 reflect 43:9 44:19 55:20 72:10 144:10 reflects 60:10 72:14 refresh 11:17 29:22 31:13 40:21 53:4 60:16 164:18 185:13 refusing 183:15 184:9 185:24 regarding 18:2,9 20:23 21:11 22:9 22:19 29:14 31:1 33:16 36:3 52:6 52:14,17,20 53:6 53:17 69:3 70:13 75:14,18 79:20 81:2 82:20 87:23 89:20 90:5,13,24 91:3,10 104:5 113:22 135:12 137:7 138:18,22 139:5,10 150:10 158:1 164:21 168:21 191:12 regards 86:17,18 98:2 130:21 192:20 region 105:3 register 46:17 regularly 179:20 180:11 rein 171:19 reinstated 19:18 related 157:2 relating 10:22 11:1 24:1 40:8 63:5 66:7 94:22 103:23 150:20 151:11 154:6 156:24 relative 119:16 124:23 157:11 202:14 217:20,21 relatively 202:2 release 209:5 released 208:17 relevance 14:7,21 62:15 73:13 74:7 75:5 87:17 88:6 109:1,14 114:3,16 115:20 116:2,11 125:20 134:5,16 135:6,15 136:8 137:15 138:24 139:12 relevancy 47:15 114:6 117:20 relevant 15:2 114:22 115:21 117:21 118:10 188:10 relieved 13:3,6 relieving 184:14,16 remarked 68:15 remember 28:24 29:5 40:14 47:23 48:2,3 59:21 60:6 66:19 69:23 72:3 87:19 92:19 109:18 137:5 154:5 156:16 157:20 158:12 163:13,17 164:5 184:5,24 185:9 194:11 198:6 199:1 200:4,7 204:4 remind 68:6 renew 74:6 85:4 rennie 121:24 122:8,8 124:14,18 124:18,18 repeat 44:6,7 84:16 91:5 122:23 123:9 123:12,13 163:9 rephrase 31:22 97:8 129:22 142:10,13 183:23 184:2 report 8:18 18:21 19:1,6,10,11 24:16 34:4 43:2 44:11,23 45:19 46:16 49:7 64:4 69:10,13 98:23 145:1 209:19 210:2 211:18 reported 176:1 177:8 211:22,24 212:1 217:11 reporter 1:14 70:3 81:6 100:2 118:2 128:7 156:13 169:14,17 217:4 218:9 reporting 18:17,19 211:5 reports 10:11,12,13 10:14,21,24 11:2 11:4,8 12:1 53:8 59:18 60:15 69:10 69:11 represent 5:7 15:13 54:24 114:13 155:8 representation 55:2 64:11,13,15 66:18,21 67:5,6,8 represented 111:11 116:12 representing 15:10 37:18,19 113:8 request 20:17 27:10,12 34:3,4 79:15 80:2 82:2,8 82:11 83:17 requested 123:16 require 82:23 required 109:6 130:21 requires 24:16 requisite 155:3 reread 188:18 reserve 101:24 reserved 215:14 reserves 101:12,15 101:18,19 residence 89:21 residential 90:9 resisting 210:11,14 210:15 resources 80:18 respect 38:10 44:9 62:14 136:12 214:12 respond 22:1 43:21 74:13,15 137:3 192:4 198:16,22 198:23 responded 191:23 192:6 193:10 198:17 responding 163:3 response 7:19 33:3 33:7 36:23 37:3 39:13 53:15 72:24 73:2,4 130:10 149:24 151:14 154:3 192:23 193:6,20 198:21 209:19 responses 25:9 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 26:4 74:21 133:9 161:9 188:22 198:18 responsibilities 6:9 8:13 21:21 25:6 26:10 135:12 141:7 149:16 responsible 212:3 responsive 186:6,8 186:14 187:10 rest 11:13 211:4 restate 14:3 16:20 137:2 restraint 104:15 result 59:22 95:16 110:20 127:22 retain 91:15 155:1 155:8 retaliatory 85:14 retired 140:11 review 10:7,16,18 10:21,24 11:3,8 21:14,22 22:5,10 22:19 23:2,13,15 23:21 24:2,8,10 24:14 25:2 26:16 26:18 40:3 42:9 43:3 57:16 58:1 83:2 93:7 94:11 129:1,7,9,10,17 133:3 151:13 154:11 155:14,23 156:1,3,7 173:17 175:3 177:1 188:23 189:19 reviewed 10:10,14 11:5 42:12 92:12 92:15 154:9,13 189:3,6,13 reviewing 129:16 reviews 32:17,22 ricky 132:6 ridiculous 137:2 rife 46:11 69:11,12 74:18 200:20 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 101 of 107 PageID #:1409 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 238 right 8:14 15:14 17:3 31:8 39:17 39:23 56:19 57:15 63:3 67:9 68:13 71:14 80:21 106:3 112:12 113:24 116:19 117:14,17 117:18,24 118:17 118:22 130:17 131:18 159:21 179:6 184:4 200:16 207:3 213:10,18 215:14 215:15 rights 2:10 3:3 70:16 ring 190:24 211:9 risk 191:2 201:20 rita 1:3 5:7 10:22 11:1 35:17 36:3,9 36:12,14 37:18 47:20 56:24 111:22 117:8 125:23 136:16 154:6 157:22 172:22 183:1 200:14 205:16 216:3 robert 32:14 rodgers 2:17 140:7 140:9,14,23 145:9 145:16 182:12,19 188:23 194:3,5 198:8,10 201:8 205:3 208:11 210:8 room 52:9 164:1 211:8 rooms 190:18,19 190:21,23 191:5 roslyn 157:23 roughly 27:6 routinely 49:22 rude 163:8 rule 15:11 16:7,13 16:14,16 57:15,19 207:23 58:5 59:11 61:24 screams 208:1 115:13,14,14 se 128:23 179:1 188:3 209:23 rules 1:11 8:1 15:9 search 90:13 57:17 64:10 167:21,22,24 running 47:15 168:2 176:20 56:20 62:14 193:2 searched 167:17 S searches 167:24 s 2:1 3:1 4:6 second 34:17 42:15 safe 212:20 43:18 45:8,9 safety 25:8 65:14 72:13 110:2,7 138:19 168:6,8 122:18 147:2,3 saith 215:17 170:16,18 192:7 sake 188:20 207:3 salient 157:19 seconds 98:21 saw 183:7 191:20 section 59:10 saying 11:12 22:11 144:21 36:1,8 58:24 secure 190:14 100:8 157:5,14 secured 127:12 205:23 213:21,22 211:9 says 16:15 39:12,21 security 178:10,11 46:19 58:3,14 178:11 206:1 59:10 63:2 see 42:13 45:3,3,4,4 scene 61:1 45:8,9 46:9,19,24 schizophrenic 47:10 49:1 57:3,6 152:18 58:5,14,16,17 school 99:16,17,19 59:12,15,17 60:15 99:22 100:6 101:5 64:18 67:15 69:1 101:6 69:9 72:16 83:9 schumann 3:13 113:11 120:19 15:1,11 16:6,12 128:16,19 130:13 43:12,22 107:7 138:9,12 187:17 114:2,6 115:7,11 201:2 214:23 115:23 116:1 seeing 40:24 117:15,18 118:4 seeking 171:23 159:6,8,11,15 177:20,21,22,22 214:22 178:3,7,12 179:22 scope 75:5 116:9 179:24 125:21 seen 43:6 179:24 screamed 126:10 selfreport 180:15 198:19 selfvictimization screaming 38:18 181:16 183:11 207:21,22 send 7:1 190:1 sent 6:23 40:4 81:1 190:6 sentiments 194:1 separated 190:18 190:19,19,20 sergeant 76:10,20 76:23 77:1,17 78:2,10 86:3,11 86:19 87:8,14 88:4,9 93:10,19 93:21 94:3,13,21 95:18,21,23 serve 101:9,11,14 101:18 served 21:10 111:9 111:12 119:3 124:22,24 125:4,7 132:4,13 service 20:21 126:10 services 127:12 145:4 177:20,21 178:12 181:22 set 128:13,14 185:24 218:1 settle 121:21,22,23 settled 107:16 121:5 settlement 119:9 127:20 settling 121:10 severity 157:12 shed 182:8,9 shelter 171:24 177:22,22 178:4,8 178:8 179:22 180:1 183:4,5 shes 175:15 201:18 shields 87:13 shoot 110:3,8 short 140:4 169:4 202:13 207:5 shorthand 1:14 217:4 218:9 shot 109:12 110:1,5 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 110:12,13,17 shouldnt 38:12 show 40:20 161:20 200:16,24 215:13 showed 98:23 185:14 showing 41:8 62:9 128:12 sic 131:11 133:22 186:4 sick 63:22 side 99:20 signature 128:16 129:1 215:13 signed 129:24 161:7 significant 169:22 signing 128:24 silence 139:11,24 similarly 38:11 simmons 107:14 121:13,17 122:1,5 122:8,9,9 124:14 124:24 125:3,5,10 125:12,19 126:3 simple 201:24 simplify 22:1 sir 28:3 57:3 64:19 113:21 128:12 141:16 151:13 202:23 sit 53:18 92:11 93:6 169:9 182:10 sitting 182:8 situation 105:22 110:7 179:2 situational 105:12 105:21 sixth 72:4 skahill 88:23,23 skills 153:11 sleep 171:4 177:23 sleeping 180:1,5 slowing 118:8 smaller 192:10 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 102 of 107 PageID #:1410 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 239 smart 126:21 smoked 172:7 smoking 172:10,12 172:14 social 138:18 socializing 172:13 softwarebased 145:6 soliciting 181:10 solitary 181:7 somebody 78:1 80:2 81:3 83:4 173:22,24 174:1,2 183:14 somewhat 67:23 soon 182:1 200:12 sorry 10:23 21:2 38:5 43:23 53:13 71:5 86:8 91:5 93:9 94:24 97:12 97:20 102:13 107:7,9 110:24 118:2 120:24 124:19 130:1 131:21 144:14 146:7 203:5 204:9 205:8 208:23 sound 178:5 south 1:15 2:5 3:14 25:19,20,20 99:19 165:13,17 speak 15:24 38:14 84:10 98:13 speaking 15:10 67:5 137:18 151:22 speaks 44:23 159:13 special 150:9 specific 18:7,8 41:23 73:17 77:22 78:11 86:22 103:5 103:8 150:22 153:12,18 161:18 161:19 164:21 171:15,18 191:14 191:16 193:24 195:21,24 specifically 17:21 50:9 162:16 165:11 167:1,2 168:15,16 175:20 193:5 specifics 166:14 182:3 specified 217:17 speculation 82:5 84:3 147:15 148:7 148:17 202:19 spelling 88:17,18 spirit 188:8 spoke 196:17,18 square 165:24 ss 217:1 staff 169:4,11 201:17 stairwell 109:23 stale 47:16 56:22 61:4 stamped 58:22 stand 33:2,6 36:22 39:13,21 119:22 120:1,3 155:19 161:8 182:9 200:23 standard 72:21,21 72:22 92:22 173:21 standardized 72:24 73:2,4 standards 83:22 standing 151:2 181:5 194:5 197:11 204:24 star 57:10 start 42:2 65:12 72:8 187:11 starting 95:7 state 1:15 5:15 33:5 100:19 118:9 199:13 200:10 217:1,4 stated 8:11 121:19 127:5 158:5 203:20 217:19 statement 72:5,8 72:10,13,14,18,19 72:21,22 73:6 75:2 154:5,10,13 154:17 155:9,12 155:15,20,23 156:3,7,8,12,23 157:3,5,7,16,16 159:9,12,13,16 160:19 161:7,7 173:15,17 184:6 185:11,13,20 189:18,19 200:20 200:22,23 statements 73:8 155:18 158:12 161:24 states 1:1,12 73:20 82:20 216:1 static 105:19,19 stating 119:18 station 142:23 143:3,5 157:24 158:3 162:9 165:10 177:12 178:18 179:5 180:2,20,21 198:11 stationary 141:24 stations 142:22 status 40:7 140:12 155:2 214:4 stay 171:4 stayed 171:21 stenographically 217:11 stepped 182:11,15 182:18,23 stepping 111:14 steps 193:16 195:15,21,24 sticker 126:8 sticks 11:10 stipulate 8:4 stipulating 8:10 stop 10:1 112:4 168:3 stopped 160:3 174:16,22 175:4 175:24 176:24 177:7 storm 178:18 180:20 strained 169:10 street 2:12 3:5 145:11,14 170:24 174:16 176:24 177:14 181:6 190:7,8 streets 145:16 171:8 174:23 175:4 176:1 stretching 95:14 strike 12:6 20:18 20:18,23 79:24 89:11 129:22 146:8 172:21 210:8 striking 47:5 stringon 23:5 stripped 18:13 struck 47:5 108:23 structure 107:24 subject 46:17 subjects 47:8 submit 34:4 78:23 81:3 193:19 194:10,14 195:5 195:16 215:4 submitted 11:12 submitting 82:21 subordinate 149:18 175:7,10,12,13 subscribed 216:19 subsequently 46:5 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 110:1 127:12 184:23 203:23 substance 174:18 176:2 substantive 181:18 sue 107:6 132:6 sued 110:22 111:1 118:16 127:19 suffered 176:8 suggestions 79:3 suicidal 174:2 suite 2:13 3:6 summary 46:16 97:15 summer 69:3 70:12 summertime 30:14 30:16 superintendent 12:21,24 17:15,20 18:11 27:22 28:2 28:10,11,14,21 29:14,24 31:1,16 83:6 superintendents 27:17 80:15 superior 22:24 supervise 149:9 supervised 149:11 supervisor 97:17 97:17 supervisors 80:17 supplement 133:8 supplies 144:20 supposed 91:23 117:16 sure 41:15 44:1,4,9 48:24 60:19 68:3 90:23 95:15 107:5 132:5 152:21 214:13,21 surrounding 13:20 surveillance 143:19 143:23 144:23 suspected 170:24 181:2,4 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 103 of 107 PageID #:1411 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 240 suspects 14:5,18 16:22 17:5 suspended 35:6,11 35:20 36:17 40:13 40:17,23 45:20 55:14,17,23 56:2 56:5 57:12 59:19 59:21 60:4 64:17 88:5,8 95:22 suspension 40:4 43:11 44:20 45:15 45:17 48:12 54:12 54:18 55:5,20 60:1,9,10 62:11 suspensions 60:11 sustain 97:5 sustained 23:16,22 41:10 46:19 58:4 96:18 sutton 2:17 146:22 147:10 148:4 156:17 157:23 158:10,10 162:2 162:17 163:2,11 163:18 164:6,13 164:24 166:13,22 168:5,23 172:15 172:21 182:1,16 189:17 194:8,12 195:3,14 196:19 197:2,10,22,24 201:6,8 204:16 205:20 206:3 208:10 210:7 suttons 147:13 189:10 switch 68:1,8,11 sworn 5:2,11 73:7 155:17 216:10,19 217:8 syd 87:12 system 81:13,16 T t 2:16 4:6 5:13,13 tackled 126:24 tactical 209:18 take 7:20,23 8:1 24:9 29:7 41:10 41:13,19 42:5 45:15 70:7 76:11 76:22 77:1,12 78:22 83:13 85:16 85:17,22 110:11 113:18 122:20 123:1,20 126:6,10 129:12 140:3 164:23 165:1 166:1 177:13 180:18 196:7 207:2 taken 1:10,13 5:5 216:13 217:16 talk 50:11,16 52:10 52:13,23 112:17 122:18 124:4 158:23 talked 50:6 60:8 115:10 121:13 158:8 196:5 talking 31:24 53:9 53:11 55:11 71:4 91:17 111:21 112:4,17 119:1 153:4 163:21 165:22 177:23 178:14 202:9 214:10 talks 47:3 50:20 tape 30:3 taperecorded 53:8 53:9 targeting 152:22 tasered 106:18,20 121:20 task 84:19 86:23 tasked 97:14,16,17 taught 103:23 104:16,19,22,24 105:5 technical 145:4 technique 102:23 103:1,3,6 104:18 104:24 105:6 techniques 103:9 103:22 104:22 105:2,15 telephone 7:7 143:4,6 tell 10:10,13,15,17 11:5,7 12:11 18:11 21:21 25:3 26:8 27:4 28:18 28:22 29:5 32:13 33:8,19,22 35:1,9 38:15 49:24 56:1 73:1,3,4,7 78:13 78:16 80:6 87:8 88:15 96:2,15 100:14,16 101:22 103:22 105:15 133:17 134:1 135:23 155:17 158:1 161:11 162:2,6,18,21 163:12,19 164:14 166:7,22 167:6 168:5,10,15,16,24 170:12,17,19 172:22 174:15 182:13 193:22 194:8 197:23 198:4 205:1 208:4 208:6 210:9 telling 47:8 73:5 115:6 155:16 164:6 195:15 temporarily 146:24 temporary 149:3 ten 84:1,24 202:15 term 102:22,24 173:14 terminated 20:12 20:14 46:6 terms 87:5 112:7 145:12 172:10 205:23 territory 112:7 test 76:19 86:10,13 testified 5:11 86:9 93:21 125:11,15 testify 59:12 124:10,11 125:16 129:8 189:1,8 217:8 testifying 124:8 125:14 testimony 98:2 174:8 189:4,7,11 189:14 216:16 217:14 text 6:24 7:1 57:8 texted 6:22 texting 6:12 thanks 215:15 thats 6:17 9:17,18 14:2 16:4 18:15 20:21 21:24 22:21 24:4 26:3,7 32:23 33:13 39:4,14,16 39:22 40:19 44:17 45:2 48:3 50:5 53:2 54:11 57:6,9 57:13 59:16,17 63:4 69:6 70:6,9 72:7,22 73:3 77:2 83:22 84:22 85:10 86:16 93:24 95:14 96:7 104:1 106:8 108:5 109:23 112:18 113:8,9,13 115:2 116:21 117:5,7 121:15 122:7 124:17 131:9 133:9 137:22 150:21 152:14 154:3 156:14 158:24 159:19,22 160:2,8 160:11,11,17,21 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 160:23,24 161:2,6 162:4 169:6 173:16,20 176:11 178:13 185:21 186:19 187:14,15 199:17 200:19,22 201:12 202:14 203:9 209:18 212:20 213:10,20 213:21,23 214:9 theres 7:6 11:24 16:14,16 23:17,18 31:18 32:9,12 35:15 46:21 48:2 58:3 63:20 65:11 69:19 78:11 91:12 91:22,24 104:22 122:5 131:9 132:5 142:17 152:3,3,4 152:16,20 201:10 theyre 47:16,17,17 80:8 91:23 119:22 168:1 185:23 theyve 54:9 thing 14:1 39:11 41:14,17 195:12 204:22 things 176:10 think 26:2 28:8 29:8 39:14,16,16 39:22 42:19 43:17 47:21 52:8 71:17 75:13 95:14 96:13 101:16 107:14 112:18 113:5,9 117:13 121:18 132:8 136:17 154:3 160:16,17 160:20 169:1 174:6,11 177:10 189:17 192:5 194:5 206:9,10 210:22 213:2 214:2,7 215:8 third 88:18 170:18 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 104 of 107 PageID #:1412 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 241 thomas 2:3,4 37:10 37:13,21 38:6,16 38:21 108:24 thought 52:11 115:9 213:7 thousands 50:17,18 50:19 threat 105:22 167:15 194:21 201:15,16 210:18 threaten 109:22 threatened 68:20 69:4 110:8 three 95:13 132:20 132:22 142:21 152:5 170:11 197:18,19 threw 106:8 178:6 throat 14:5 tiffany 2:12,14 time 18:24 23:14 23:17,18,20 24:12 24:15,18,20 27:4 34:8 44:8 45:14 49:12 55:10,13,16 60:4 65:21,22,23 66:2,6 69:16 70:1 78:20,22 80:10 86:2 87:7,12 94:12 101:10 107:19 108:10 113:12 124:11 129:12,15 131:6 137:19,19,20 144:16 145:14,14 154:9,21 157:6,16 166:11,13 169:21 169:22 170:12,14 170:16,18 171:2 176:15,21,23 177:4 180:17 181:9 184:14 196:2 197:24 199:24 202:10,11 202:13,13,16,17 203:13 206:16,17 211:19,20,20 216:14 217:17 timeframe 30:23 34:7 202:24 203:11 208:19 timely 24:23 times 11:18 29:15 31:8,14 34:11 35:8 40:12,17,22 52:15 53:7,20 54:1 56:2,6 65:1 73:22 77:24 78:3 80:1 82:22 92:9 92:10,12 95:5,11 95:12 110:17 132:20 134:13 135:1,3 170:8,11 171:4,11,21 177:10,11 178:2 178:23 tina 88:23 title 5:22 94:2 211:24 today 26:6 42:8 43:5 92:11 124:8 156:24 169:9 189:1,7,14 214:1 todays 10:8 11:6,9 told 20:3,5 22:24 54:22 126:7 154:23 174:12 195:4 196:1 213:7 213:16 totality 157:14 totally 117:6 tour 184:13,19 track 136:21 train 154:2 training 22:4,6,8 22:12,18,23 99:9 104:4 147:20 148:1,2,4,11,12 148:15 149:1,2,4 151:15 152:4,8 153:12,14,21 transcript 30:2 136:19 161:21 188:24 216:12,15 217:11 transferred 12:17 12:19,22,24 17:22 18:2,3 transformed 50:24 51:4 transport 102:21 transported 157:24 178:17 treat 153:22 treatment 178:16 trial 62:20 187:6 214:8,9,16 tried 109:21 110:11 164:12 186:22,24 187:2 193:18 194:9 199:20 trr 209:17,20,24 true 166:12 216:15 217:13 trunk 126:22 trust 74:21 truth 26:9 73:5,7 155:16,17 217:8 truthful 160:20 truthfully 124:8,10 124:11 125:14,16 try 184:11 trying 113:16 159:1 160:2,18 turn 187:9 twice 36:20 96:6 two 32:12 47:8 59:19 63:22 95:11 95:12 110:1 122:5 132:5,22 137:1 142:20,20 170:22 174:4 178:23 191:22 192:8 202:2 twoday 60:10 type 34:13 35:2 152:20 194:24 types 103:11 typewriting 217:12 typically 24:9 39:19 167:9,17 187:4 vacant 126:4,4 vague 29:3 86:16 152:15 192:14 204:8,18 205:6 vaguely 42:13 48:2 valid 70:24 varied 34:24 35:1 147:4 150:2 U 151:24 196:24 uncooperative 197:18 176:6 193:3 varies 25:3 underlying 47:19 variety 103:9 197:8 56:23 57:1 61:6 various 96:3 understand 19:3 116:21 144:19 26:5 55:6 114:22 153:16 116:17,24 135:21 vary 152:2 135:24 136:2 vehicle 126:16,22 159:2,21 183:19 175:9,11 186:13 213:19,20 vehicles 181:7 understanding verbal 97:13 98:18 44:1 45:12 91:20 194:6 133:14 144:15 verbally 105:8 understands 113:7 verbiage 126:20 understood 8:3,9 verified 128:15 unfair 113:13 160:19 unfounded 90:4 verify 160:18 96:19 128:4 versus 133:22 unimpeded 91:24 viable 83:10 union 55:2 64:10 vicious 110:18 67:7,13 155:2,3 victimization united 1:1,12 73:20 181:16 216:1 video 152:4 university 100:18 videotape 30:3 100:24 102:18,19 view 52:15 unlawfulness violated 59:11 174:19,20 violation 35:4 58:5 untrue 13:15 violations 57:11 use 32:1 45:14 violence 169:23,24 81:15 104:7,15,23 170:3 209:14 105:1,2 173:14,19 voice 34:18 37:11 207:16 37:14,24 38:7,15 usually 142:11 38:18 158:24 184:10,11 volume 52:3 voluntarily 72:15 V 72:19 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 105 of 107 PageID #:1413 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 242 vs 1:5 216:5 146:23 147:1,2,3 149:11,14,15,17 W 149:21 150:5 wacker 3:14 165:6,8,20 166:2 wagon 178:16 172:20 184:15,16 wait 112:1 211:4 waiting 16:6,12 water 122:1 126:8 walk 166:2 182:9 watermarked 206:8,9,10 58:22 67:24 walked 182:5 202:7 way 11:24 54:22 202:16 206:6,17 56:10 76:19 97:2 walking 28:17 119:4 136:10,14 wall 190:24 138:7 187:12 want 7:20 15:24 192:11 39:10 41:13 42:1 ways 144:19 50:23 59:3,6 68:1 weapon 19:24 20:4 72:7 78:19 105:18 20:5 108:9 112:23 weapons 167:22 113:2 116:22 weather 171:5 117:2 123:20 week 150:1 131:13 138:5,6 went 18:18 27:20 143:16 155:22 63:7 98:21 99:19 160:9,15 163:4 100:13,14,17,17 184:22 187:12,14 109:22 126:16 188:17 198:20 158:4 208:21,24 199:5,18,21 western 1:15 2:5 201:10 204:7 101:1 209:22 214:13,17 weve 50:20 132:19 214:19,20,23 136:24 196:10 215:3 whatcha 46:11 wanted 124:2 126:6 102:2 126:8 160:24 whats 12:9 41:8 199:9 200:12 62:9 71:6 97:8 209:7 114:2,6 116:10 wants 123:14 147:22 148:14 ward 127:6,7,7,8 150:23 192:2,13 140:2 193:1,10 warrant 90:14 whereof 218:1 209:7 wholly 44:13 47:22 wasnt 164:12 whos 113:7 177:21 178:7 wife 65:4,19,20 179:24 186:8 66:5 71:12 209:6 213:8 wilfredo 2:17 waste 131:6 william 49:18 watch 69:19,20 williams 47:3 48:14 48:20 88:22 132:6 133:21 willibrord 100:1 willing 29:7 116:4 window 193:23 witness 4:1 5:1,10 6:15,19 7:11 8:6 11:22 14:15 15:17 16:5,16,19 17:3 19:5 28:7 33:1 34:19 36:21 38:3 41:16,21 42:5 43:19,23 45:1 48:1 51:17 52:19 55:8 58:10,17 61:9,16 62:21 65:7 67:11,16 70:4,5 71:1,5,20 71:23 73:16 74:13 74:16 75:7 76:6 77:9 78:18 81:8 82:7 84:10,15 85:7 87:18 88:7 98:10,22 99:12 100:4,7 107:9,10 109:2,9,19 111:16 112:2,5 115:1,2 115:16 120:18,24 122:17,22 123:1 123:11,17,22,24 124:4,17,21 126:1 129:13 131:8 132:10 134:10,19 135:8,20 136:1 138:9,13 139:3,20 139:22 141:13 142:12 147:16 148:10,19,23 150:15 151:21 153:2 156:2 157:4 161:5 163:7 164:2 169:16,18,20 174:10 183:21 184:1 185:2 186:16 187:20 192:16,19 195:9 195:20 202:22 204:9,12,21 205:8 205:12 212:8 217:7,7 218:1 woman 66:13 108:23 124:16 wonder 158:23 wont 39:2 wood 3:12 word 57:12 worded 185:21 words 126:19,20 work 5:20 31:3 86:23 102:12,14 140:13 142:22,23 143:3,5 145:19 146:21 198:10 worked 20:24 21:3 21:5 53:19 189:23 working 25:10,12 85:14 120:4,21 145:12 165:7 works 16:5 worth 213:18 wouldnt 138:15 142:8 155:6 177:5 213:17 wrench 126:23 wrestle 109:21 writing 78:6 82:12 117:12 written 20:6,8 76:14,16,22 77:1 78:8 80:2,12 83:5 152:3 156:13 wrong 93:20 192:2 193:10 wrote 100:5 wysinger 18:24 19:2 X x 4:1,6 5:13 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Y y 2:12 yeah 28:6 34:19 41:16 59:16 61:19 66:11 67:11 73:19 76:5 82:17 95:2 98:23 115:11 123:9,24 133:20 136:10 142:13 158:19 159:8,11 161:23 185:21 199:4 200:18 207:4 215:12 year 101:2,4,6,14 107:2 years 44:12 47:17 55:11 56:22 59:17 63:22 93:13 94:6 132:22 144:2,7 168:17 193:12 198:1,5 211:21 yelled 198:19 yelling 183:11 yep 124:5 youd 113:19 youll 22:1 23:6 84:16 youre 8:21 26:5 31:23 32:24 33:20 34:19 35:12 43:17 53:11 55:10 71:14 72:19 74:19 85:10 85:10 94:17 106:12 109:24 111:21 112:6 113:6,14 115:7 116:20 117:6 122:3 131:22 136:14 141:13 152:22 153:3 158:19,20 160:18 161:9 163:21 178:5 202:20 205:23 215:11 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 106 of 107 PageID #:1414 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 243 youve 11:18,19 40:12 96:3 105:15 123:3 132:23 133:2 138:10 153:6,7,10 213:5 214:14 1216 216:13 128 4:13 13 1:5 216:5 15 1:17 35:20 36:17 54:13 15day 40:4 48:12 54:18 55:5 60:9 Z 16 62:12 63:3 18 42:15 0 18th 42:15 00 147:6,7 19 72:10 03 93:22 1937 1:5 216:5 04 58:14 59:14 1980 101:8 102:6,8 06 93:23 102:15 084003813 218:10 1986 93:15 99:13 99:14 101:3 102:6 1 102:8,15 103:4,4 1 1:17 4:9 41:3,5,9 1989 101:16 43:8 44:19 46:16 1990 56:6 54:12 55:20 58:3 1991 58:15 59:14 60:8 67:19 119:15 59:23 181:14 1992 60:22 62:12 10 157:22 170:5,8 63:3 170:21 172:4 1993 68:19 69:3,8 173:9 174:5 175:5 70:12 72:11 177:7,17 178:1,20 108:13 179:16,23 180:3 1994 47:13 48:14 181:1 182:24 48:19 101:17 191:4 202:5 108:22 203:13 206:21 1995 55:21 210:4 1996 96:1 10150 1:15 2:5 1998 93:16 94:24 10th 149:13 150:3 1999 94:8,9 156:16 172:16 19th 127:7 140:2 174:14 179:7 180:9 2 11 12:10 2 4:10 56:12,14 111th 25:12 190:6 57:4 60:9 67:19 190:8 119:17 181:15 11th 12:12 17:7,22 190:2 18:4,5 21:8,11,12 20 47:17 59:17 21:20 22:4,12,14 177:7 22:16 23:10 25:1 2002 94:10 25:7,10 26:12 2003 86:7,7 94:1,9 108:22 2006 27:8 86:8,8 122:10 125:19 2007 107:4,8,9 2011 136:24 140:13 141:6 142:16 143:7,21 144:24 146:2,9,15,21 147:13,21 148:5 149:10,13 150:3,8 150:19 151:11,16 152:7 156:16 157:22 165:5 166:2 170:5,9,21 171:7 172:4,8,16 173:9 174:5,14 175:5 177:8,17 178:1,20 179:7,16 179:23 180:3,9 181:1 182:24 183:13 189:24 191:4 202:5 203:13 206:21 210:4 2012 26:1 27:9 30:11,14,16 111:5 2013 128:16 129:5 132:22 155:12 210:10 2014 6:8 8:17,18 10:5 12:16,18 26:2 2016 1:16 86:8 216:21 218:3 20something 55:11 21 210:20 211641 46:18 21st 127:7 22 44:12 185:17 201:1 233 3:14 2337900 2:6 24 56:22 25 59:17 25yearold 136:13 27 47:3 108:13 27th 48:14,19 29 1:16 60602 2:13 3:6 60606 3:15 3 60643 2:5 3 4:11 42:18 62:4,6 62 4:11 62:10 67:19 6630 72:7 181:17 67 4:12 30 2:12 3:5 45:4,7 6th 27:2,5 52:24 45:17,21 48:11 53:6,16,19 58:4 54:13 84:10 76:1,3 88:13,24 141:12 148:19 89:13,18 90:17,22 30day 43:10 44:20 91:2,8 96:6 31 42:21,22 107:21,23 140:17 312 2:14 3:7,15 141:7,20 142:15 37 117:16 142:18 143:8,20 390 185:16 144:9,16 145:7,18 393 201:1 145:22 146:2,5,9 3rd 18:3 25:15,16 146:15,17 149:14 25:23,24 26:11,15 149:20 150:5 26:21,23 69:13 157:24 158:2 96:6 162:8,10 165:4,10 165:11,16,21 4 167:7,18 177:19 4 4:12 42:19 66:23 178:3 179:15,22 67:2,18,19 68:12 180:4,9,14,16 68:15 72:5 75:17 183:6,14 185:5,6 147:6 189:21 190:5,13 41 4:9 190:16 191:20 202:8,17 203:14 5 205:5,13 210:3,12 5 4:13 67:19 128:6 128:9,13 130:8 7 5212 4:4 7 42:21 67:19 130:7 56 4:10 130:8 131:20,24 5660040 3:15 133:12 155:12 5848 56:10 185:16 5852 56:11 7030 25:19 5th 76:7 86:3 87:9 7040 25:20 87:11,14 88:5 70th 3:14 93:10,22 190:1,8 7100 25:19 7445106 3:7 6 7447684 2:14 6 57:15,19 58:5 773 2:6 59:11 67:19 84:10 78th 107:24 141:12 147:7 148:19 8 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648 Case: 1:13-cv-01937 Document #: 182-6 Filed: 03/11/16 Page 107 of 107 PageID #:1415 GLENN EVANS February 29, 2016 Page 244 8 57:5 61:24 67:19 67:19 86 21:6 98:16 103:13,13 104:6,6 8th 127:8 9 90 214:7 900 2:13 3:6 911 126:14 92 56:11 57:5 93 72:6 108:14 94 47:4 95 45:16 98 93:17 96:2 98:16 99 96:2 98:16 9th 129:4 TOOMEY REPORTING 312-853-0648