SUMMARY REPORT- SUBJECT: COMPLAINT REGISTE CHICAGO POLICE DEPARTMENT INSTRUCTIONS: INVESTIGATION NO.: 306953-Sustained SUBMIT ORIGINAL AND 3 COPIES IF ASSIGNED TO SAME UNIT AS ACCUSED. SUBMIT ORIGINAL AND 4 COPIES IF NOT ASSIGNED TO SAME UNIT ASACCUSEO. DATE OF REPORT 7 November 2006 T0: SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE ATTENTION ADMINISTRATOR IN CHAR l] ASSISTANT DEPUTY SUPE GE. OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS RINTENDENT. INTERNAL AFFAIRS DIVISION FROM - NAME RANK STAR No. SOCIAL SEC. No UNIT ASSIGN. Veronica Mesaengar lnv. 234 113 REFERENCE Nos. (LIST ALI. RELATED OR. 0.3.. I.R.. INVENTORY Nos. ETC.. PERTINENT To THIS INVESTIGATION RD 8, HL 553434. 0336 #05144?121 ADDRESS OF INCIDENT DATE OF - TIME BEAT OF INCIDENT LOOATION 12149 S. Loomis 12 Jul 05 2130 24 17 NAME RANK STAR N0. socIAI. SEONO. EMPL UNIT mm. 1. EVANS. Glenn Lt 443 006 2. a. A SEXIRACE D.O.B. DATE OF APPOINTMENT DUTY STATUS (TIME OF INCIDENTDUTY OFF DUTY SWORN I: CIVILIAN I a. Plivmm Mm? CHARGES COURT BRANCH a. DATE COMO :3 cans NAME STATE TELEPHOIE SEXIRACE D.0.B.JAGE Him RE I I. II II SEXIRACE 01 I 3 DDND. 5 canCOMPLAINANTE. worms. WITNESSES. I I fl" SEE PAGE 2 m? I (I CPD-44.1123 CR. "a 306953 OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PGZ WITNESSES: con?t ALLEGATIONS: The complaint was received at the Of?ce of Professional Standards on 13 July 2005, at l510 hours, via the PAX by Intake Aide Denise Stewart, from Sgt. Karen Popp. The complamant, ?lleged that on 12 July 2005, at approximately 2130 hours, in the vicinity 12149 S. Loomis, on the street, the accused, Lt. Glenn Evans, Star #443: l) physically abused her by grabbing her by the arms and pulling her; 2) dragged her on the ground; 3) threw unknown objects at her vehicle causing damage; and 4) verbally abused her. OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 Date Initiated: 13 July 2005 Date Closed: 03 November 2006 Suspense Time: 101 Days Net Elapsed Time: 377 Days Approved: OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. PG3 #306953 EVIDENCEIATTACHMENTS: 1) Complaint Against a Department Member 1A) Con?ict Certi?cation Form 2) Initiation Report 3) To/From Report, Inv. Goodwin, Re: Appointment Scheduled With Complainant 4) Canvass Report 5) Witness Interview Report, - 6) Witness Interview Report, 7) Complainant Interview ort 8) Sworn Af?davit, 9) Consent For Juvenile Interview 10) Witness Interview Repo 11) OEMC Recorded Voice Transmissions Request 12) Request for Evidence Photographs 13) Domestic Battery Case Report, RD 481227 l4-l4A) Event Query 15) OEMC Tape 16) To/From Report, Inv. Messenger, Re: 911 Tape Transcription To/From Report, Supv. Stoutenborough, Re: Court Information 18) Emergency Order of Protection 19) Disposition Order 20) To/From Report, Supv. Stoutenborough, Re: Noti?cation to IAD to Serve OP 21-22) To/From Report, Sgt. West, Re: Order of Protection on Sgt. Glenn Evans 23) FAX Cover Sheet, Supv. Stoutenborough 24) Criminal Order of Protection 25) Noti?cation of Order of Protection, RD 553434 26) To/From Report, Supv. Stoutenborough, Re: Order of Protection Served to Accused 27) Domestic Battery Case Report, RD 28) Case Supplementary Report, RD 29) Case Supplementary Report, RD 30) To/From Report, Inv. Messenger, Re: Court Sheet 31) To/From Report, Inv. Messenger, Re: Personal Visit 32) To/From Report, Inv. Bowens, Re: Court Sheet 33-33A) Photographs of Complainant 34-34C) Photographs of Complainant?s Vehicle 35) Request For Identi?cation Photographs - ?No Record on File" 36) Computer Printout of Court Information 36A) Certi?ed Statement of Conviction/DiSposition OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 P04 37) CLEAR Data Warehouse Victim Search 38) Request For Time Extension 39) To/From Report, Inv. Veronica Messenger, Re: Information From Complainant 40) Request For Accused Statement 41) Noti?cation of Allegations/Administrative Proceedings Rights, Lt. Glenn Evans 42) Request to Secure Counsel, Lt. Glenn Evans 43) Statement of Accused, Lt. Glenn Evans 44) Accused Subject of a. Case Report Form 45) hivestigator?s Case Log OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PGS INVESTIGATION: Lieutenant Michael Stev s, in his initiation re ort, related that on 13 July 2005, the came to court at 51st and Wentworth and requested a warrant who is now Lt. Glenn Evans). for Bette Sgt. Glenn Evans lat on 12 Jul 2005 their sci was missing from a roximately 0 tours until 1900 hoursh residence located a arm. Lt. Evans yelled for the arms and pulled her away sustained bruises on tor arms as a result of this incident. She then called 91 but left the scene before the police arrived. (Att. During an in-person interview on 14 July 2005, the complainant, related that she has known Lt. Ole Evans or thirteen years and they have ?orid Lt. Evans? relationship ende in . Att. On 12 July 2005 recoived a call at work stating thi- had not shown up for summer day camp. lB?: work, called Lt. Evans, and told him that was missing. The two of them went to Park Forest, Illinois and looked fol? They also contacted the Park Forest Police Department. Later that Lt. a and-riswered the telephone? told hiy?iat he and into a ?ght and y. He decided not to go 0 summer house from Park: Forest. Once Lt. Evans once, he arrived and insisted on making a police report agains?for batter against told him she did not think that was necessary. Lt. Evans said that he was oin ar Forest Police Department. said that was going as well. ot in the front passenger seat an inside the rear seat of Lt. Ev lwenty~one~year~old son come and do it.? campand wa to hi. learned the-was res: got vehicle. Lt. Evans stood outside the vehicle talking to his Lt. Evans tolt ?Get her out of my fuckin exited the vehicle and tol to come wi and Lt. Evans said, ?Get our hands offmy fuclo'n plied, Lt. Evans then abbed by both orearms near the elbows and ulled her ?52] on the ground on her left knee. When Lt. Evans pulled fell to the ground and Lt. Evans accidentally stepped on his ankle. s-up on the ground and attempted to comfort him. Lt. Evans grabbed an unknown part of her body and dragged her in the street a few feet. Lt. Evan yelled, ?Glenn, let OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PG6 -was also ms 11 Lt. Evans awa . got up ?om the ground, went to her car and called 911. ?approached ve 'ele and asked her not to call the police and said he would calm his father down then asked her to leave. made a three point turn in her vehicle to leave, and Lt. Evans threw an unknown 0 ject at her vehicle and struck it. He then threw something else as she was driving away and struck her car again. Paid she didn?t notice the dents on her vehicle the night of the incident (Tuesday) ecause it was dark outside. She said she did not drive her vehicle the following the day and did not notice the damage until Thursday. reported that she sustained a bruise on her left forearm, a scratch on her right leg, a bruise and soreness to her left knee, and atom shirt as a result of this incident. She did not receive medical treatment. (Att. On 22 July 2005 _obtained an Emergency Order of Protection against Lt. Evans. On 19 December 2005, a two-year Plenary Order was entered against Lt. Evans. (Atts. #1 8,19,24,2 6,36). The 911 tape indicates that on 12 July 2005, at 2051 hours? called ?'om her cell phone and reg ice, due to an altercation with her son?s father, Glenn Ev . call taker asked if Lt. Evans had hit her or put his hands on her. responded, ?Yeah, I don?t want to press (Atts. #14,15,16). Case Report ?led by?ndicates that on 13 July 2005, at 1430 hours walked into the 002"td district station to obtain a warrant against Lt. Evans. eported that their son had been missing for several hours the day before. Dining a discussion with Lt. Evans about the situation, he grabbed -by the arms, knocked her to the ground, dragged her on the ground and tore her shirt. (Att. The Domestic Batt vans also ?led a Domestic Battery Case Report on 13 Jul 05, at 0115 hours, against for the same incident that occurred on 12 Jul 05. No charges were ?led against (Atts. #27-28). According to Forensic Services, there were no photographs on ?le relative to this incident. (Att. submitted personal photographs reportedly taken of her on 12 July 2005. The photos reveal her blouse/top hanging off her left shoulder. No injuries are visible. She also submitted photographs of her vehicle taken on 14 July 2005. The photos reveal dents on the right front side panel of the vehicle. (Atts. 34-34C). During an in-person interview of the? OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PG7 - he stated that he has a good relationship with related essentially the same account of the incident Lt. Evans told his older brothe-?Get that where out of my car? once ere seated inside Lt. Evans? vehicle. said Lt. Evans ?getting madder and madder and more and more im atient.? Lt. Evans then pulle? by her arm and the shoulder of her dress. dabbed- and Lt. Evans sat ?Get your hands off my fucking son!? said his parents were lling and screaming at each other, but ever cursed at Lt. Evans aid Lt. Evans was cursing a lot and ullin on ed up falling on ground and his ankle was stepped on. tried to comfol Lt. Evans then push and she was on the ground too. Lt. a few inches her car while she was on the und. drove and jumped on Lt. Evans? back? pleaded witl . got inside her vehicle and began driving away. own objec then threw a second object at the vehicle and hit it again. He used both of his hands and banged on the front of the vehicle as ove away. The next door neighbor?came outside and said, ?Be cool Glenn. Don?t do something that you?ll regret." (Att. During a canvass of the area of incident, two witnesses were located and interviewed. (Art. Witness Frelated that on 12 July 2005, early in the day, she had received a phone call from . vans instructing her to have his son stay at her house if he arri ed at Lt. Evans? home and no one was there. (Att. At a x? 30 homs?eard arguing and went outside. She saw Lt. Evans an going. Lt. Evans was upset becausF had been missin and walked from Park opened a car cor and askedFIgnother to get out the Evans grab, drag, or have any 13 cal contact with off in her truck, and Lt. Evans drove away wi She sai drove in his car. (Att. . During an in-person interview of witness_ she related that she was inside her bedroom when she heard people arguing outside. She looked out the window and saw a boy, a grandmother, a father and a mother. The father was yelling, ?Nobody?s gonna hurt my son again!? The mother got in the father's car with the boy and the father got inside and began yelling for her to get out the car. The grandmother grabbed her son. Patton said she never saw the father grab or touch the mother. The mother got inside her white vehicle and sat. The father began yelling again-aid she has lived on the block for ?ve years. She did not know the names of the people involved. (Att. Attempts to interview- and-were unsuccessful. (Atts. #31, 45). OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PG8 During a formal statement taken on 3 November 2006, the accused, Lt. Glenn Evans, (formally Sgt. Glenn Evans) related that he was involved in a relationship with-for one year. (Att. It was his decision to end the re] in 1994. Once Lt. Evans learned tha- was at his residence, he spoke with the telephone and old him that he ran away because he was tired of his friend beating him up. . vans said he became very angry because he discovered the who is approximately 5? 10" well over 200 pounds, had been physically abusin and on for a year an did nothing to stop it. Lt. Evans explained that he was also distraught becaus ad walked nineteen miles through five different high crime suburbs before he arrived at Lt. Evans? home. Lt. Evans continued that once he went to his residence where-was, he told him to et in the ey could go to the police stati battery case report against ?irt in the hem passenger seat. and said she was going too. Lt. Evans tothen exited the front seat and got into the back seat. . vans epeatedly tol?o get out of the car, and she refused. Lt. Evans? oldest son noticed the commotion and Lt. Evans asked him to ge the vehicle, opened the Four of his car front passenger Mylo pullm . gan crying and Lt. Evans bbed by her cl arm and attemp 0 remove her grasp ?-om -grLat. Evans lost his grasp ecause she was ?ailing her arms and striking him. The three of them became intertwined and fell to the ground. leg or ankle and he cried out in pain. Lt. Evans managed to and told her to get away ?'om his car front of his went to her vehicle and got inside. A piece of piece 0 ry was on the ground. Lt. Evans picked those items and she almost struck him with her vehicle as she drove away. Lt. Evans said is ends to push himself away from her vehicle to avoid being hit. Lt. Evans an ant to the Park Forest Police Department to ?le a police report agains- Lt. Evans denied that he verbally andfor physically abuse? during this incident. He also denied that he threw objects at her vehicle to in entlona cause damage. Lt. Evans added that he was named as the offender in a Criminal Damage to Property Complaint, and that he was ordered by the court to pay monetary restitution. (Art. On 19 Dec 05, the Domestic Battery and Criminal Damage to Property charges were ?Nolle Prosequi? in Branch 60. The Plenary Order of Protection was extended until 17 Dec 07. (Arts. #3 6, 36A). OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 P09 On 07 Apr 06-1-1 a voice mail message con?rming that the charges were drapped against Lt. Evans. She added that he was ordered by the court to pay $490.00 restitution for the damage to her vehicle. (Att. #3 9). OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 PGIO CONCLUSION: The Reporting Investigator recomme Not Sustained for Allegations #1 and 2 that Lt. Evans physically shimmy grabbing her and knocking her to the and then dragged her on the ground. Lt. Evans described his physical contact with as grabbing and puilin her arm a eatedly asked her to get out of his vehi 1e re?ised. Wimesse?enied that Lt. Evans grabbed ?ocked her to the ound the her, or had any physical contact with her. The credibility of the witnesses is questionable since vans himself We had physio contact wr . Although ersion of the events, it is undetermined if Lt. Evans? contact with rose to the level of excessive force. mends a ?nding of Sustained for Allegatlon #3 that ehicle causing damage. There is a preponderance of claim that Lt. Evans threw unknown objects and struck her vehicle. too aphs of her vehicle, which revealed damage, and submitted them two days following the incident. corroborated his mother?s account of Lt. Evans hitting her vehicle with unknown objects. Furthermore, Lt. The Reporting Investi ater re Lt. Evans threw objects a vehicle. Evans adimid that he was ordered by the court to pay restitution for the damage to The Reporting luvs cmmends a ?nding of Sustained for Allegation #4 that Lt. Evans verbally abused statement that he never directed any profanity or derogatory owar is not believable. Lt. Evans, by his own admission, related how angry he was about the situation. Further, his profanity was witnessed by his own son. tated that Lt. Evans told his older brother, ?Get that whore out of my ?Get your hands off my fucking that his car? and then to Dad ?was cursing a urmg this incident. OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS C.R. #306953 1 FINDINGS: Accused: Allegation #1 Allegation #2 Allegation #3 Allegation #4 Lieutenant Glenn Evans, Star #443, Unit 006 Not Sustained Not Sustained Sustained Violation of Rule 2, ?Any action or conduct which impedes the Department?s efforts to achieVe its policy and goals or brings discredit upon the Department,? in that on 12 In approximately 2130 hours, in the vicinity of Lt. Evans, Star #443, Unit 006, did brini discre ep out by throwing objects at vehicle causing damage, during a domestic altercation outside the residence. Sustained Violation of Rule 9, ?Engaging in any unjusti?ed verbal or physical altercation with any person, While on or off duty,? in th 12 Jul 20 approximately 2130 hours, in the vicinity o? Lt. Glenn Evans, Star engage in an unjust: ed verbal altercation wt and verbally abused her by referring to her as a ore and telling her words to the e?ect, ?Take your hands off my flleng son!"