November 3, 2012 Chief Sam Speciale BBPD 403 Highland Ave Bradenton Beach, Florida 34217 Chief Sam Speciale, I am responding to your letter dated October 29, 2012 in your request for the 3 items. Our concern is that when I spoke with you on October 26, 2012 asking you if you had watched the Dr. Phil show since it is an open investigation in your department you responded by saying "no, you don't watch those shows and that you were no longer on the case". Since you are no longer on the case I will not be submitting those requested items to you or the BBPD. Two of the items your department had in your possession and they were not handled properly then. Your letter of request did not show any cc'd recipients. Are you the only person making this request? You stated you were no longer on this case. If the Florida Department of Law enforcement needs the requested items we will consider providing those items to the agents assigned to the case under certain conditions. Those conditions are that the requested items & information is not to be shared with you or any other employee of the BBPD. Additionally that we have the names and credentials of the agents we are releasing the items/information to. I did call you on Thursday November 1, 2012 with questions and concerns and my call was not returned. Sincerely, Kelly Osborn Cc: Gretl Plessinger Cc: Mayor Shaugnessy Note: For reference is the attached certified letter I received and signed for on November 3, 2012