CHRISTOPHER M. C.APOZZI A ATTORNEY AT LAW.PC June 20, 2018 The Honorable Norman A. Krumenacker, III Supervising Judge of the 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury Cambria County Court of Common Pleas Cambria County Courthouse 200 South Center Street Ebensburg, PA 15931 Re: 40TH Statewide investigating Grand Jury -Response of Stephen E. Jeselnick Dear Judge Krumenacker: Stephen E. Jeselnick did not ever sexuallyprey on or a victimize child engage in child abuse, or sexually assault an adult and the assertions in Report. No. 1 to the contrary are categorically untrue. - Mr. Jeselnick is responding to Report No. 1 for three reasons. Initially, Mr. Jeselnick unequivocally denies that he did what he is accused of doing. He is innocent and the only possible reasons for the assertions of fact and the conclusions made in Report No. I are insufficient (i) investigative rigor and inquisitiveness, (ii) false testimony to Grand Jury or statements to the Diocese of Erie or (iii) mistaken identification. It is essential the Grand Jurors, the Court, the prosecuting agency and the public know this. - Mr. Jeselnick also calls for Pennsylvania to afford the full panoply of due process rights to private individuals who are the subject of adverse grand jury or other governmental reports. The Pennsylvania Constitution embraces in its very first Article the right to "enjoy(} and defend}} life and liberty, of acquiring, possessing and protecting reputation, and of pursuing happiness" and to protect these rights through "due course of law". Pa. Coast. Art 1 § 1 (Inherent Rights ofMankind) and 11 (Courts to be Open; Suits Against the Commonwealth). In cases like this one, where the Commonwealth infringes on core constitutionahights, the law should provide private citizens with the tools necessary to respond to these infringements. Due process should allow something much, much more than just the opportunity to author a response to heinous allegations 'and have it appended to an 800 -page plus report which bears the imprimatur of a grand jury, this Court and the Office of Attorney General. Due process demands access to the materials and testimony submitted by the Commonwealth to the Grand Jury, the materials collected by the prosecution in its investigation and the prosecution should be required to prove at a contested hearing even when liberty is not at stake whether there is enough evidence to brand a private individual a sexual deviant and child abuser. - - Finally, this response is as a matter of law, practicality, and principle, the only course of action open to Mr. Jeselnick to defend his reputation and vindicate his rights to enjoy life and pursue happiness. vvww.ancapozzilaw.corn . P: 412.471.1648 F: 412.592.0340 chrisecmcapozzilaw.com Pittsburgh: 100 Ross Street, Suite 340, Pittsburgh, PA 15219 Butler: 20120 Route 19, Gigliotti Plaza, Suite 208 Cranberry TWP, PA 16066 44 June 20, 2018 Page 2 - A. The Allegations Concerning Mr. Jeselnick are Fundamentally Flawed Mr. Jeselnick served as an ordained Priest of the Roman. Catholic Church from 1977 to He ministered to civilians in several parishes and in the United States Air Force ("USAF") where he served in various domestic and overseas posts. 2014. Mr. Jeselnick is accused of victimizing adults and sexually preying on children. These things did not happen. These things are not true. The primary problem with Report NO. 1 is not just false allegations and erroneous conclusions; the problem is it reveals a complete lack of investigative rigor or inquisitiveness and does not reflects that even a modicum of fairness was afforded to Mr. Jeselnick. Report No. 1 states [a] review of the Diocese's files on Jeselnick reflected no abuse of children under the age of 18. . . . Jeselnick's file only listed two known victims and both were over the age of legal adulthood. 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury - Report No. 1, p. 102. This did not occur. The sum and substance of the inquiry into the issue was to review the files of the Diocese of Erie. .There is no mention of testimony on this issue; there is no mention of an effort to look beyond the records of the Diocese'of Erie and speak with the authors of the documents included in the files produced by the Diocese; and, there is no indication that an Office of Attorney General investigator conducted interviews and reported back to the grand Jury. Report No. 1 also does not state when, where' or what occurred; or, when and to whom it was first reported. In other words, there is zero corroboration of these assertions. Absent this basic information, it is not possible for Mr. Jeselnick to respond other than to state he didn't victimize anyone or prey on anyone, adult or child. Report No. 1 also states 111444* !'oilditrIg, oral, and a rtite. ifttolt's*httititi stoned it St tiid mogoo. a1 lolii6.01.0atioay:000.1. 0101`PirktiOncethhadtlh weal*" PloP.Pi tlfelitotallicee e 400141 00? 09,419-141.440 efitly dOtit au l?xy ttiel*WYP*11014. ti* joffiiitinv.o414Ktigttrs,to *pier 140 for. WOO*. 108E0/m114ft* violate day. this OW dittos ttieD4.6 This also did not occur. 45 June 20, 2018 Page 3 It is not disputed Mr. Jeselnick resided at and ministered to the Roman Catholic community of St. Brigid in Meadville, Pennsylvania in the late 1970s. The remaining allegations not only reveal an inadequate investigation, but are also subject to direct rebuttal. Report No. 1 asserts Mr. Jeselnick would become intoxicated. This is not true. Mr. Jeselnick drank little, if any, alcohol in the 1970s. Addiction ran in his family and as a result, he was acutely aware of the negative impact alcohol could have on lives and very cautious about using it. Just as importantly, we do not know what, if any, evidence was presented to corroborate this allegatiOn from other witnesses who knew Mr. Jeselnick? If no such evidence was presented, why was it not presented? Was no effort made to ferret it out? Or, would it have been inconvenient and contrary to the narrative of unrelenting depravity presented in Report No.1? Report No. 1 alleges some of these events occurred at a parish employee's home. This is not true. Mr. Jeselnick regularly. visited members of the St. Brigicl'S community in their homes and shared meals with parishioners 'on many occasions. He never became intoxicated while visiting anyone's home whether an employee or a parishioner. He also does not have a memory of ever having dinner at a parish employee's home who hail both sons and daughter& Further, what if any corroborating evidence was developed and, if not, why not? Was there an effort to talk with neighbors, aunts, uncles, about whether Mr. Jeselnick or cousins and other parish eMploYees at the other priests frequented the home? Was there an effort to talk with other priests who were assigned to the parish? Report No. 1 mentions a "previously unidentified Deacon?! It appears he has now been identified. So, who is hp? Did he testify? What did he say? If he did not testify, was he interviewed and, if so, what did he say? If he was not interviewed, why not? If he is deceased, is there corroboration from the Diocese or Parish that this person served as Deacon at St. Brigid's during the time Mr. Jeselnick resided *ere? Is there evidence he visited a parishioner or parish employee's home with Mr. Jeselnick? Were the Deacon's wife and children interviewed about these allegations? Report No. 1 does not state the circumstances of Mr. Jeselnick's identification as the perpetrator. These events are supposed to have occurred 40-years ago and memory is not just notoriously, unreliable, it changes, it fades and it is malleable.' So, when was he identified? Where was he identified? How was Lawence S. Kubie, M.D., Implicationsfor Legal Procedure of the Fallibility of I-1;mm Memory, 109 University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 59 (1959); Ken Eisold, Ph.D., Unreliable Memory: Why memory's 2012 ., 12, can we do about Psychology and what Today, March unreliable, Elizabeth Loftus, Ildw (https://wwwpsTchologytoday.comIusiblog/hidden-motIvey/201203/unreliable-memorv); . June 2013 memoir, Ted Talk, is your reliable (httpi:/1www.tedcomitalltdelizabeth lea's thefietion of memory)(Exhibit C); and, Erica Hayasaki, How many 1. - 46 June 20, 2018 Page 4 he identified? Was the. identification process sufficiently robust to withstand scrutiny? Re-port No. 1 does not reference testimony from or interviews of any other priest stationed at, any person employed at or a single parishioner of St. Brigid's during the time Mt Jeselnick resided there. Were any of these people called to testify or interviewed? If so, what did they have to say? If not, why did they not testify or why were they not interviewed? Report No. 1 does not address the 40 -year delay in reporting. Why did three men and theirs sisters, all of whom seem to have vivid memories of absolute horrific events, wait 40-years to say *something? And, why did they come forward in 2017? The circumstances of Mr. Jeselnick's identification are especially important because he did not do what'he has been accused of doing. SO, either the testimony presented to the Grand Jury was not truthful or this is a case .of mistaken identification. Absent answers to these questions and others, Mr. Jeselnick is left shadowboxing and no one can win a shadow boxing match. Repbrt No. 1 also states No record of this family's abuse were located in the Diocesan files. When they did. come forward [in 2017], the Diocese direeted them to ;the Crawford CoUnty District Attorney's Office. . . . . [l]t was only after a family member reached out to ,a local newspaper reporter that they were referred to the Office of Attorney General. It is unbelievable that in 2017, 15 years after.the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal broke in the Boston Globe. and the publication of the "Charter for the Protection of Young Children and Young Pdople" was adopted, the Diocese of Brie brushed off a claim of sexual assault by one of its priests. It is equally unbelievable that in 2017 a family came forward to a reporter for a newspaper with a horrific story- of serial sexual abuse by a Roman Cathelic priest and no article was published. Yet, an Internet search using 'Bing®, Google® and Yahoo!® did not reveal' a single newspaper *article' about Mr. Jeselnick in 2017 or 2018. The lack of skepticism by the investigators or an explanation for how and why they were able to overcome this skepticism is astonishing. of 18, memories are your' Fake?, The Atlantic, November (htips://lirmy.theatlantic.comThealthiarchlve/2013/11/how-manv-of-your-memories-are-jake/281558). . 2013 2 Betrayal -The Crisis in the Catholic Church, Investigative Staff of the Boston Globe, Little Brow' and. Company, May 2002. 47 ' June 20, 2018 Page 5 Further, Report No. 1 states "it is unclear when [Mr. Jeselnick] officially retired." It is anything but unclear when he retired. On July 12, 2010, Donald W. Trautman, Bishop of the Diocese of Erie wrote Dear Fr. Jeselnick, .57-eye I understand that you retired as a full Air Force Colonel. I congratulate you on that high recognition by the United States Air Force. You are a retired priest of the Diocese of Erie with the faculties of that diocese. I pray you will enjoy your retirement ye4rs. Best Wishes, . Fraternally yours in Christ, Pernial.44 rreutemean, Most Rev. Donald W. Trautman, STD, SSL Bishop dale Exhibit :B (Letter from.Bishop Trautman re Retiremmt, July 12, 20103. The fact that this detail was not known to the Grand Jury or known but omitted from Report No. 1 is deeply troubling, particularly in light of the fact the Grand Jury learned from a review of the files of the Diocese of Erie that Mr. Jeselpick's faculties as priest of the Diocese of Erie were revoked by Bishop Persico in 2014. This omission alone underscores the utter paucity of meaningful investigation and analysis as it relates to Mr. Jeselnick and suggests that none of the conclusions concerning his conduct should be credited. 2. Report No. .1 Does Not Reflect Even a Modicum of Fairness to Mr. Jeselnick Mr. Jeselnick, unlike the Bishops of the various Dioceses in. Pennsylvania, was not invited (or subpoenaed) to appear before the Grand July or given the opportunity make a written submission and, therefore, neither the Grand Jury nor the Court could know he denies these allegation& The fundamental Constitutional rights at issue here -the inherent rights of mankind and due process mandate that the investigators obtain independent corroboration of the allegations or at least attempt to do so and also include the results of thiS aspect of the investigation in their report. - The Grand Jury. did have and could not have had the opportunity to evaluate and consider the issues Mr. Jesehtick has raised about the quality of the investigation or weigh the 3 The term "faculties" refeis to permission given to a priest by his diocesan bishop or religious superior, legally permitting him to Perform the Sacraments. 48 June 20, 2018 Page 6 countervailing evidence he may have presented. For instance, any problems with the identification procedure, the substance of the identification and the lack of corroboration of the evidence presented. The Grand Jug did not kn.ow he denies these allegations or that in the late 1970s he did not ever drink to the point of intoxication. Finally, the Grand Jury may not know of his many years of service to the USAF, where he attained the rank of Colonel and earned many commendations before being discharged honorably. Exhibit A (Letter from USAF re Retirement and DD-214s), It also may not know of his many years of faithful service to the Church.or the high-regard in which Bishop Trautman held him. Exhibit B. Finally, it may not know of the respect and love his family and friends have for him and: him for them. These are all'facts that are directly relevatit to an assessment of Whether he victimized and preyed on others. B. The Procedural Due Process Problems With Grand Jury Reports Concerning Private: Citizens Mr. Jeselnick noes not hold eleeted ofce, he is not a public official and this matte does not concern the public fisc. For these reasons, his conduct is not the proper subject of a grand jury report, or at least not the proper subject of a report where he is not accorded a much more vigorous version of due process. The scope of grand jury reporting has historically..been limited to persons in government service and general conditions in a community. Comment has been made upon the nnfairneSs of such repOrts, particnlarly as they affect any public official. However, we should bear in mind that the great protect& of our democracy, Thomas Jefferson, declared that: "When a man assumes a public trust, he should. consider himself es public prOperty." Morpl theologians approve public criticism of public officials as being in the public good, although they ..conderan such criticism of individuals' not haVing public responsibilities: . Noah Weinsteilkand William Shaw, Grand Jury Reports -A Safeguard of Democracy, 1962:2 Washington University Law Review 203. (January 1962)(citations omitted). Although, the subject of Report No. 1 may. be of some public interest, the public's Interest is no greater than an individual's core Constitutional rights to enjoy and defend life and liberty, of acquiring, possessing and protecting reputation, and of puisuing happiness. Where the Government elects to infringe on these rights, an individual should be afforded more process than the law presently permit's. In other cases, the Office of Attorney recognized state due process rights where there was no statutory directive to do so. In the Report to the Attorney General on the Investigation of Gerald A. Sandusky ("Moulton Report"); the Office of Attorney General embraCed that state government report critical of unindictedfoimer government. due process required aspects ea 49 June 20, 2018 Page 7 officials that "might reasonably be understood to adversely affect [their] reputation" be disclosed so that the subject might be able to adequately respond to them prior to publication: . In addition, after the report has been submitted . . . certain persons will be provided an opportunity to review those portions of the report that pertain to them and to respond prior to publication. In the leading case of Simon v Commonwealth, the Pennsylvania Crime Commission had published a report (about organized crime in the "bingo industry") that had a potential negative effect on the plaintiff's reputation. In Simon, the Commonwealth Court recognized a state constitutional right to reputation and held that the Commission's failure to provide plaintiff with advance notice of its criticisms an opportunity to respond before publication violated plaintiff's state due process rights. The Sfmai case, while not elaborating on precisely what process is required, appears to mandate that persons referenced a govcernm9nt report be provided: (1) those aspects of the report that might reasonably be Understdod to aave.fsely affect their reputation, and (2) an opportUnity to respond prior -to publication. In connection with Our submission of the report to Judge Krwnenacker, we are seeking his authorization td provide notice and an opportunity to respond to persons who fall underthe Simon decision. Moulton Report pp. -1142. The Grand Any Act itself provides .for certain process in the context of a Grand Jury Report. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 4552(e) (Authorization of Response by Non-Indicted Subject). This process is not, however, sufficient to vindicate the rights of private citizen whose rights to enjoy life, protect their reputation and pursue happiness is being impaired by the Governinent. An elementary and fundamental requirement of due process in any proceeding which is to be accorded finality is notice reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise interested. parties of the pendency of the action and =afford them an oppOrtuni0 to present their objections. The notice must be of such nature as to reasonably convey the required information, and it must afford a reasonable tune for those interested to make their . . . appeara.nce. Herder Spring Hunting Club v Keller, 143 A.3d 358, 376 (Pa. 2016) (quoting Mullane v Central Ranover Bank 4 Trust Co., 339 U.S. 306 (1950))(emphasis added). The opportunity to author a denial and rebuttal is not an opportimity present an objection, an objection by definition - in a legal Context presents a prospect of prevailing on the objection before the court. It is important not just pay homage to the principal of due process but also recC0-47e the process due is not the same in every circumstance. 50 Jim 20, 2018 -Page 8. . Due process is a flexible concept which "varies with the particialar situation." Ascertaining what process is due entails a balancing of three considerations: (1) the private interest affected by the governmental action; (2) the risk of an erroneous deprivation together with the value of additional or substitute safeguards; and (3) the state interest involved, inclUding the administrative burden the additional or Substitute procedural requirements would impose on the state. The central demands of due process are notice and an "opportunity to be heard at a meaningful time and in a meaningful manner." 2018 WL 2075562, *4 (Pa. 2018)(emphasis added)(citations Bundy v. Wetzel, 7-- A.3d omitted); see JRv. Department of Hyinan Services, 170 A.3d 575 (Pa.Cinwlth. 2017) (placing teacher's name on -sexual abuse registry without a hearing violated due process); Pennsylvanio Bar. Association v. Corn., 607 A.2d 850 (Pa.onwlth. 1992) (placing attorneys on motor vehicle frand index without notice or a hearing violated procedural and substantive due process). It is also essential to recognize that individuals.who confront inclusion on the Department of Human Services ChildLine and Abuse Registry or the SORNA Registry are afforded the complete panoply of due process rights (notice, a hearing; discovery, cross-exarninatkin, subpoena the opportunity to present evidence) before suffering this indignity. Mr. Jeselnick, on other hand, has been .branded by the Government with these same labels sexual deviant, child abuser and criminal without being accorded any of those rights. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania has irreparably damaged his reputation and impaired his enjoyment of life, as well as his pursuit of happiness, without according him any meaningful due process of law. This is not right. This is not justice. - - Mr. Jeselnick requests the Court accept this response to Report No. 1 and enter an Order directing that it be appended to Report No. 1 and in the event the Office of Attorney General elects to distribute copies of Report No, 1 or post it on theinternet that it also distribute a copy oktiAis response and post it on. the Internet. Your attention to this matter is appreciated. Ve C truly yours, s oph pozzi cMC/tiiit Attachments 51 DEPARTMENT OFTHE AIR FORCE HEADQUARTERS UNITED STATES .AIR FORCE WASHINGTON DC 20330-1000 RESERVE ORDER EL - 1881 17 FEB 2011 c01.)Esitiocx STEPHEN 4 . EFFECTIVEONTHE.DATE RETIRED, YOU ARE AUTHORIZED RETIRED PAY PER. TITLE 10. UNITED; STATES CODE. SECTION 12731 AND PLACED ONTHE VSAF WI:ROUST; *TIRED RESERVE SECTION ZB AND ENTITLED TO UNITED STATES UNIFORMED.SERVICES IDENTIFICATION CARD, DP FORM 2, (RETIRED) (BLUE) . DATE ROAR DATE OF DIR.* 20 APR 20I I ; GRADE FOR RETIRED PAY (HIGHEST GRADE SATISFACTORILY 21) HIT, 1951 COI: . . . SEIVITS PEA TITLE 10 SECTION GRADE PLACED ON USAF ' YEARS: **D 11Si* CUL 24 i270 MONTHS: DAYS: .22. .10 . SERVICE FOR BASIC FAY YEARS: MONTHS SERVICE PER TITLE 1.9 IBC DAYS gq Pc SECTION 12733 15.73 .19 REMARKS . 1.0 USC A. 12732 ACM 20104A1p0S7 . APPLY TO THE NEAREST MILITARY INSTA4A.TION NOE. ONS.COFY OF:04 ORDERTO.140TAIN DDrORPI 1111 AMMO SI**SUNIFORMUSEAVICAPPKIVICA1104 PAM .#.6100WOLF YOU 1173. 'UNIFORMEDiPt1919c4T101,1"-#91targv11.00gtAP.-PDXYcO B, moo) DEPEN. - . . . , . . mibilii.R.144014419 .4Et4i4WITH PAY PRIOR TO ME 601Vtri;9opipAii7, 60173 BIRTHDAY. MPAPRWP VFPL7fig BE FITS BY.oRnintoOrfE SECRETARY or *AIR. FORCE DFFigAL OsuuB03014 . PPRAA-NOING RO PRP.Wit.Ag P.M** to* koAcg SEitv4 C41044:04-14tit, 53 " DEPARTMENT 01 THEM FoRCE 1,v9aumpatimilEsErtiefePEOotioacensa HQ.ARKAWITH6760 PLACE itENVEi. 0.4? 80280-4066 17 -Feb -I I 4.10430* 04** g).F4E.I4`4M104F-sit etkodp bear*L.***thc *. I am pleased to inform you gmtio4 name will be placed on the Air Fora; Retired List, effective 20 Apr 11. Ofkiiri.440, you may obtain tit9 t9Fol 2 (R0001114 On crafter rour Uniformed Sdrviged ki044449ii *64 OT01#10giqur current identification 4c04tildiah411 c4PY§00* *1314 (for any Order *131 vw.mi'ittary cam or Uniformed Services telephone Id*" 4.:(41104.040401*64i14 . 64aaikk9i:.10000nligOli410afil!atiaa n year area OJmted Steles Government or these ,*jihak are giaDD Form 1173, and_P.P40kaCard, should accompany You when you o tarn your tdenttfic tion have ain ly mernirers must be enrolled in :-: 0.0s1.94*st If* are b tat 460449.6.0.01":4100. mailmgyour.40110.40,146040.04.41.the FOkandID section of*AtinstaliOdOifor 0011.$71101100. At age applicable www . you your to Tii041kg 11011k1Mieroo; so that youcan obtainthe Information most 000you .aorta, are highly *omitted to TRICARE!* loggini into *elfviebsite at contact Yotir pay *punt is Being established at the DefenseFinanecaa4 tic:CA=64 Service-Cleveland Center. Any questionsconcerning refired `pay should fiediiectiii to U S miltt*Retirenieg Fay, P.O., Box 7130, London KY 4.0742:400, PFAS-CPI.Ptit 14100-421-1.04 .flase.MitifYPPAS-cti1?9440.9b49:skiktfoite address. Approximately 14101. 03.109:4akaaP4aaiaat ati*tOilfidiatt, statement showing tr**00, deductions, and netpay, ba050 tO bi DFAS,;o4t0:- Thereafter, a statement will ba forwarded to you when thiti r b4i0-9 . tit* " . personnel record will. Your have at& Dewier, CO 80280. tIORPO.toitia 0604*o:ill . nutiatehted ilk.regaidig 1496.625;0102: You have our hest wishes'for the flame. Altaghwit: letirid Pay Pick! (2) the - Reserve Personnel Center, 6760 2. Irvingt your frialteiiiiiotinelitiord o yourrititinialit, please call ' CA Ait THIS IS Ail IRV:Well oaf? molls ANstragruttliT!E9R. ' CERTIFICATE OF RELEASE OR DISCHARGE . t -t FROM ACTIVE DUTY . . . . 2. DEPARTMENT% coneoNENT AND BRANCH AralTilinEr-RgdAF RESERVE'ONUE.,TERKILVATE, : 7,2.11.AgEoF ENTRY.INT9 ACTIVE DUTY Arrant DuBois PA 'Ceilmadolnrines Si: IASTIAITY ASSIGNMENT AND MAJOR COMMAND Fie ANY/BC 00 Lb. STATION WHERE SEPARATED Peterson AFB 00 (IISAFt) S. COMMAND TO - and stata* or avnpfeta-` Acatis Not 1i. PRIMARY SPECKLTY'lList wv.wiy. Use aMtIonai sp periods of pneorrooro rats 052R8*z.* Chaplain AiNone! 10. SGU COVERAGE 'TRANSFERRED Antopi!t: $ Other. and_Yeats bombers atid *kV kW . peers, the 9 12..IIECORD OF SERVICE months. Ca Month s 41 . Dati Eritssid AD Ibis PetIod II; Eine-film tate TVs Petid . . , . ;, ; ' Nor Active Sevics -0, ;*"."*: - ..; . . : &hike . . Nei Asthet Sendai TisliPerlad 4. :Total . . . ' : kEffeáWeDateá1PrGradi 13. DECORATIONS;241DALS, BADGES; CITATIONS AND MIGN RIERONS AWARDED OR APHORIZED: AF.90*01.-40.:iii#14010 with 2 devices; AP Longevity device, A Training Ribbon, 16411*-e-414..g.ei001 T.nlir.B.1.1kbiii: Nat AF Difenno MIVRairg FETF:l.kTF3P4 Minqn 141n: neither ofr tiWki.and *Web an..01?!.FekaPOted) Service lAlaiia'SitiVicV Awiq4. with 2441,:-4F..Jq*7!***411 9ntitindini :104 (SEE .n.WARKg), . .. kOn1r.011.PffjOer.144aol;::.7*mOci, eh'96.; Chaplain l'7ofilifill.3141 tiontinOVY Ocinr'se, I weie*; Oct 93';' Interim Chaplain Clek*rse, :t iseeici. :44 bi i Conks!, 4 week, Oct: go,, (SEE B.Ektikte)... Catholicatiapia.4Pi*Ofestifonal. ' Ar.f!I GlignielnEP TO POST4gliall 1586. ElidrATIOWIL PlOGItiaa tapimetwo DDFqr =PUKE *rap gar= PENT& sposmaysm an ,-,141;1 No X ' is& 9:11904. Ecivii*ViT . . 11,* ' X : . .. . I IS. OATS ACCRUF.DI.F.A1/2 IPAID I MI; ArtIcliwiTE. DESDAL MIMS AID TREATIENT WWI MAUS moffp SEPARATION SrEG . atIOATE yes. mgmBER4. . 55 X CAIITIOWNOTTO BRAISED FOR IDENTIFICATION PURPOSES .. Pits 1SAH ImPoRTAur RicCIRD. . CERTIFICATE . . ANYALTERAMMUNS DtrADRAWM OID SAFES/JAM:AT. : . pf mgt.f4sE'oit DISCHARGE FROM AdTiVE DUTY. - . ' ' ' . . 1.3 NA (Deal:' AVX42..i044:I 4..V.LLY".0 ' 4% 2. , DEPARIMBIT, COMPIMDINTRNO ORANGE . "JESEA ' 00)18:4L4Y_Vk-.4t..i. AIR FORCE-ANGUS ,-.1?060.44:}i.VoiAt*P 4.0.kta `...10.-.rt .. u mph t tf: 411:wilt ' ,44-14.,14.P.ArYleWEWMAMM Ntro,.._ gf444,71-,,,34.!4;f4 sP7.VIA,Pfli:44*.wo.t. t...k...11.tekttlifett . ft.SPa tY44....1;iitiekiii ..... :7.4 Ts. PLACE OF Many INTO ACTIVE DUTY BALTIMORE MD DA. BALI1MORE MD - Ii. 19! P914;011E/AGE ' AMOUNT: EISO.1300 FRVAARYSFECIALTY (Li# arrnber, ilia add pars and months In OE RECORD OF SERVICE . - - . ft b. slimintau DATE:ansiNaPP t wgrAcTlyggAavic4Tills Mop VIVTgarcEl P.,TIVE SIRFE - : , : -. ' i.TaTgPmaR timcnim SERVICE L, FORPRIPWKE :' :- - . . : ,. : . . . . . - 100*(4.1eibte.g..K! al:44W SQUADRONOFFICER .til612118 SCHOOL, ..: (BEFORa --.." .7;.. JAN 1S96i AIR 20QE) COMMAND -STAFF Opkr.,gqz;;-jOINT.fileFW ;994 JAN ' ':- .. -::. -... :. ' : : . ' - service'04 An*, fa*: gOsaiSiiiiiiMeitil, Sciii*OAsii§e,rvi Mea4.9fobai wikon 10'01*n sOiitO Pti*Y, AF ' ':' ' ' ' .. .. -.' .:.- '; ". Ributilgiiipilliairkili ,' ' : . ' , - - . ... . - ,, - '1) . -.. ' - "latr . wnsiie..- . . , I ,* t' ..., It IC ... ri . 4' iii A f. . 1 I' N It. 'r 14 .t... VD .- .4. , -in m 0 1-A5,pi lr ' . gi/P.-4110410..- -c4- ,. ' r . ' .."..:.. J - 4;--- . 4 15 *VW « Ai -ks ,, 42,' -.." A C ii - 4_ "' '-' ' I" WA -i.,?.1- `k.ex.\ ... -1 - '114)-4' - . '' ' 4 - : . ' '- ,:., --. -,-.`- ,'..__ . . ' : %'''' . 2 `i :4 -3; . sy,..$ ' 4.12. ". 1% te.! ,;1 : .x . .. 1 YES . Ir -7.?..ii ..i.k ." .i7+7 -N-l; .K0 . ' ... ' - RO ... . -: :- - T.I.- .r. 1'2. 1 ::.--,, 1 .,-3 .--= , .4 , --r. s t..;-13,. e' .., Vill.t.ti'l,. 41S.,,,....s/".W..A.1 t'4° X YES IV -1-t,t.... 'wc,,,.*. YES - t1 al'fid: .; = . - ' : . ,...*:-;.qd ..-1,. ' :...': .9 .0pt ''.-A x . - .4'---'5 , 1" '-' -,,, ,.-- .r.:, f - ,.A . -Rt... .-t .. - ' ,...r ,. 1 " .. . . , . 111/ASER WAS FRO viDED COMPLETE DENTAL EXAMINATION ANO ALL APFROPRIATE DetrALsERvicps AND TRBATNIRITSTDIN IN 'WTI. 1211101! TO I! BeARgIqu - *YE - -' . - -.. ... mitligisregiAMM-!6-1 .4itikeitiit*-0Mit*Ectt :T, 4'-' _ - r. ,..e .-igiikkilL 4911. it. loo4 ;111: Pip `.40 4, ,:, ,i.zsr at. . .41-; I 4,- 7)rtt rem tv 41 * *`" 6Alt1 -* vn - --1.** ,,,,c ft*. *Y. 2v. Cr.14;1 MO , . 15a.mEmeER cotrotlimixo To FosT?InErNAm ERA yFP502.1! P!!geallY004511sMtiqqPftell !. -! .: : kyttfwspliotictftiAoympoRwaxy441.9...,ir::-: . - . - ' - - - ' . ' . im, . Award fultica op* kgekeiieri,INOIlatirDifitiso Service Medal with 1 . Ng* 44. cOinekiiiiililykOiliiith 4 pii Mat' W640 bilis-kilo:Dim Lira 1a. . Of F.EfTlYN PATE W PAY (*A0g ' .: , rtiOWN ka4:%125ittal Imuy4Ryzpucopy poulA6 t Tp.70*.qt neck5:; t!tlnreyttil !NIA* . 711- Media:foils Sgivico. WM with 1 hilt lea[aludetiNr Puce . DAy.s Acr.Rup VMS) : 1 Slintfit:ZilAS4 . --?agOkV ealt,Ottig 0.0.0104.T1. 13. DECORATICNE3,AEDALS,BADGES, CITATIONS AND CANIPAIDN DIEBitiNs AmMRDED ORAUTHDRIZED fAIMISAIM*4.Mits, . ' If. . t2001.:**-41WW -$VIdial zittrftlig 14 ftfM:i 0 '4 .1010,V -,4)141..--om 44 top.: 4v, '..:; gififii,VAO. . ' . . 0 - MWRENS) VEMKS) . 431FAIIMERP."711.1.3,PM0P. . . .. " * - soda* JAS **Mkina/spAtfaXy IWO= and Ow kirolvIng patio4s c1 dna canoe yews.) 52R3, CHAPLAIN: - ' . .... . . b. STATION INNERESEPARATIT BALTIMORE Cl? ma MARYLAND AND HO (PIGS) A COMMAND TO INRICH TRANSFERRED MG, Male of MafyIaniI (ITYYMAIDO) M/A 'b.'. NOMEOF RECORD itrarg oF EIMO (r-lyarld AI* orcomFANt imIlms; ffkAA*1) ma ;AST DUTY ASSIGNMENT:AND MAJOR com ' RESERVE 081.10ATION TERMINATION DATE . . DIAMIER.-: ' ' . --;a ' 7Z...s. . 11s. :144., ., ...y. --7,. ' ' .12.Z, . . '' 4L4 ,,. ' 4 '... - - 3. ... 1 . .,_,-...-7,1; r - .:11.. -L..: zl.:,--."- fuJi,,- nd X. :2-L- .-' ' kl i 1 . .0 ' - riiVoluitVor impineg -, ..z. g VI tlN.111.104i "..?,,..*2.... I'A 14 SW A, ii .." ,...6 . . 4,6' 12:. . . .. .::.-..-r.--.7 2'.7---;---TP5.-- = " ..marir.,W,a . --.......44#3101: AW1/4%1.711.41141141r.' 71e-cAlzkagiit if' Ei0 000:14S4Auriliteitio;413:200 ' Ii% -Asa II' . "' - ' MJECRI y, *I.Ma 24,F44/ 4'-' ...v.:Jr.:sax er, PREvloqs !ERRS is OBSOLETE 56 --- -1- ....7.;.-772" - ,,......4 ...A. to& 10.7: ' _js. g,_ --1n. ,:i,Fq- '''' ' ,...--j, ...s 0 .l. 4,4), c'.:." 1tgobEk4 OSOTION.. NOT TO OS.tiSED FOR IOENOFICATION PURPOSE - AN't /43131.XNNIN tN MiAENOF1r Tem Is IW IMP.SRTANT.NSCORD. THIS asfalumisiy- CqttilcATE OF 0.ELOsii*alioioitiGEERDmADim#Dui* JESCIOr le:Odell't . f,11.4_ ... .. vol. ..yitzrzo. iMT.74-k>of wkartlfs-17 -: to,4 eii-IS:54101.A.4afifthriV:C (441.,1,e.44s4r6..ay . -...z'A:..zZ-11' AYak tI i jeolgoE411311.14s. DATE Of sism ITYYVANTO) EmATEcrft. . 1 '0A fAttmso.dre0:1,:fArg - .DEPARTIAENT, comPcitioymo IMAticli 4.x../ip FpFtc,g-mpus ptir2:14fj4--.4tiisp,,..; 2. 11904NagifiS a. PLACE of swim Sirs ACTIVE DUTY DALTIMDR MD . la. LAST DuTy ASSIGUIEINT Nip MAJOR COMMAND D. MARYLAND ANG.1-10 (NOS) DALTIM0)3E CTY MD L ' COMMAND TOWHICH TRANSFERRED .410e.Oltagg)400 . . STATION *PEKE SWARM!) spa -,..--- - . .- las ppooD *tom Atotlita . . OW% b SEPARATION PATE ThisVINNON ' itiW.S4ki cNgriAllVE4WITETOS MKT. ; tklakteatOlgtitei Z1 -5M;.4.1 '. ItginglaikWig atiRai4h1.$ ftTPPII;PVCMINAI.M.VP ileAVIA .r.:_11V914.4 033.VcVMOWT-T , ' d!.r,f4:FR/POPliViiEgYICE ',WNW i*ViCE . . _..-- - : ... .. - . . .. i /hail data; Siiiiii if &it*, &ki* K01641 War!BWTertritliFliqeINVe!fiedaNIWOit.ieS24. - 00 MO 4iiiiiii - .: - '....'..: -.., - .. , . ; , titOiftiViSTV,31112.-1 --. 149(141W4,14 -1..4*mg. , 1431.441INYJNINCATKIN Irmo! AV! Pan* frMt!*ind.nx51111070!te - .: . .pplrynETNAlliarpur,arofw,A,Ifitr4cimpb.RAN . - - . . ' . . , . . ... - - - - . - . 'Wei 1_:- -{, oca... 4.41:,' nw 1 .. 7.. ' e ...ti. ' A - . .... X' ..' . 11 ilk" .- s.iF' , - , cri. v- -rt* rl-r- _ , r_ ' '.41 - --N- ....i.. - OA '''-- ;$-, . J:,._ . , -rn, c -.-4. 1, ' ' . . - '-` m k.,:k41,7 00 4000:.* 1 - = ..iL'i .. '4. A. 4 4 % 1-a. I k. et ..14 40.1r4i s or: : i 1.= Is ...' q4 'Phaa 41.0i # - , 4121 ' zw- '- ' ,,,----,-,--711-Ar ...7-iiii. MY _ : WT'.." :IT.*.lk , 7 r.:, ' I !.'44-.;.:'-.... e :i -.: ' -'.-.Th .PRESNSIS WM411:110E1361= 57 " a 14, C _ :VI; . ' 0.< 1r' ' 11",-'''0.. . , ,,r_cy'-,, , - ; ) I.; int -v;:.4 44;--.-,,Lt- f- --,14-.. ' .-41.` ..-.1--t j'k-- 47-----...-7fr.- - ..,.- ifac 'T.0'...,,,'-'. -- -5, 'i---, , - . 4401, Iwitielf4grisastrai.' . *.a....-"Wi - = 1- - . .' - 4 -1- -.1.--4. g -,,,,,t- .,..1,..'israf%7:if,-4 .1.47" ,- ";'' -.41 .. IAA . i . - . ,,- 6. J.2 .. .1.0e ., .., : ?-''' 4- `4 L'Art . - x - a47.- ,,,,,, 4 i ',' " i - 1 -, , ' ..) ' 74 .,,....) Ai 't.N.-va. .glqZ' ,, .-7-- Tr,FP lit-:11,00 - -, -. , _ .. 7,--77--4,...--779-=-,-7- , .Wtre auMearo. {him*.s",t: . - I , .10 '4- .. . i.' IppX ' , 00.; .: ES - 1:%.,.1 _. , 16,AbATIO'7-11:1: . VtPini"11 . - von:044 ' itiNfnah ipivcsk-ti a.-....a.iveso... .. - ,. nil . '- -I ,,a: ) - e ilte, 4.-T." 1 " `-'7- .,.. a - , -001......,IxFed.irtqnsty , - ' . - - NO - . . . Wc131 --...., '' *om.' . isememaist mugwump To .- -,.. .. .., - ez..: -:: ..- -...bi'lligig1044GRAPuxrgORgoimymigt : - , '-! . ... .. if..p4y3 mmwep LEAVE ' - - T, MrEMEIERINAS rvtovrdio comnor Dean EXAMINATION AMI) ALL APPROPiyqk .. 0 .' 'CIFNTIM-IEfofFEIANP.T.f.if4TREtfr v.17411014 DANT Mr? irn? )3EPAR.Friow ' ' rid d"t' '',...14-= 12. -c., *-- -..-,, : . SQUADRON OFFICES SCHOOL (BEFORE ZIOS). AM 11i96. AIR 2005). COMMAND STAFF COLLEGE JOINT' (BEFORE ?Ns), I .PAID7- M: Fekt045**;t474 1tf*i- : II-Prg.CR.E PMEPFPAY GRADE - RIEBONS AWARDED OR AUTHOW203 Mirpo/fur glitwwww) :' . MOrtIo04Ol Sainiti With oak leaf AlrFoita ... ehdaUon 'Midst *41 11 oak teat 00igrkliF Outstanding Unit . ' tilliorpf Waal wki ward Expo ' *II"' ' : s-OgA.SS.syRE- .. IA .DEIARATIUMI, INEDAISAIADOSLCITATIO__NS-ANIk_.PAMPSIAN ,:t -- lq.. Sal COVERAGE ED pNe Asourna250,000 ' . .... Yoram MOnnis(s) . DAYS) 12. mooRDoFSERINCE _44 pme grime) AD spickilY. I.fsI additbinsIsped*orstatheis indOw iarming 5283, CHAPLAIN, i ;;:lijfirt ... , - - N - - . . . - perrodschheinIxorro il- , er ' A its* 4r4;osip411 addrassN Mown) ' . II. pi:,num serscuaay pm whoa& uresfloyearx andmoos ir; " c MYY,02.90 NMI - e_ ,-, . --, --. , b. HOME 'OF RECO !ID ATTI.IRE 9! F11:firr (My arrd BALTIMORE MD ' - ,,,- . ,- ,'I E. SESERNg - 4_,. -4`,J,''' s ;- --...-.,-,, - =,..-, i,.-.--,:n.4-40.aar.= 'I. A a -17, t 111,1-7. rz,otip,.... :,_ - -t44 31,17A, -,---). CAUION: N61.110 BEN& TN OPPOSES . RECOD. IS . . ' - - - - cix11F.c.47E-orAPLE4WeR womR4@ ; -'.' -2' - " : *il''''',-.1.1f-. i7/ 4..if '. -..--,- - 7 ' ,_1:0:2"---- -72/---,.. .- -L-1:.:..: I . ..;LJ_2 - " AMP* Ig trADARA FROM ACTIVE DUTY " -" ' - . . tf.6.,41,%11,7 11: 74 1:',-:j ...1.2:.71t--7: i5,--i -?..r-T1',1-.--1F-i7: 7-.,';' -7 V ,.-_, ANY . ' ' '7-71 ra.r ie OF IINTOT INTO ACTIVE PUTT - Z ' 4.. i .1 ' S. VAT OF ilitItY 0111101,100 - 1 A N ' `''' ' T rrivoiiii4 NONE i.h.nipiug.9F.P gEcon ' .14430 woe/Aft AT T1 . . . . BALTIMORE JPsii..- um p ' ' pm commAiro . .. "NMFAT iuyo ACC WING' iiird !OR* TRAN/FlOggp 175 L TY- . - CONUVIANOTO , . ' . - - 6: sTATioN -...-. - . IL EGU coymm - ' ' Sri". 7i.MMAN.7 , . 'AMOUNT: . ... . . 17, RECORD PF isElPiKR V. .1 . .5. itt4ORE MD . upMA*yspfcuLiY11.4.40nW fi 4Pgdalt.:4 .1.1it..?If*falial.41atahi MAIMS 84 otkowfiyilatoosir 00183 rigs' xgrAFA MSAP 8 . tiATit prism ' I t mop - bigiihoot lEcTrifiStENCI IOW WOO ' 110PLE tilli : . IIIIS MOO grnigsfoR.e*s . .012/136' OODYS . itTF411.116t.ACTOSSOIVIC1 4.-70Tmlnol in:icon:tom* . . 1.1r a:' - -- AWL 00i AM; ,SWVOLV4 ØF WA IA 0 . . . %.1n! :f t t - ; . toiativipti*c70sTAE-10.494." e - t.; ' " ; tiTomATEW-Fge,. 58 - ""4. Yip.k.Lalli: . Doom VIANINATIoVIND TO BOIT4U;$141VO4AND-INMINEFfrWrfilifte90AY0 15,17A11 DD famit' 0-4**44.144. 14imitrroymocATimir0.*-0-#40?- ' TOIPt1:1Wg - t. - OVW/ At i ..VV, I Wi 5 :701.4., itiit111/1-111/./i/t//iY/t11./1// f' Alan* ii...:EmzuvaltourrAvotpm -744tE07.05TIOWIIEDikit!MgEs....qtkrioNSPI?. cANIVAIN 11113505s*PUIPO.OR AYTHO.f!ZP (00:04.04i14.4 TR, LS Vfift :014 ixarigov TioN MIA - : -" -1:(!r"7-4-t, .00 *-446 -7-- Ifik :41& ir crr .yo es uszo fok IV* p ,7771,' ! 777" -, i L--7, ::17 S ., --w T 'T 5.Mf.,,-o) =4; r . t: t' TI -,, ---4 - - 1.:.7 TT? - I, . , ::j 2._ c: 7,i,-rs; IA 1 ca 'alitiveyiNT . T , 4 .' -1-- D : ,7.-T!Tfr.,!_Ti.;::'41.,U1:(':_,/,''.',..)..;.73 J i I. DATE Of NOM irfIrMNpq ....... 4001 ROUlliVit4P RD ... . . . . ,. WG ' A. I 170 WING !:COMMAND TO 11111I1q! TIONSPERNED . .: . . . : - . . . . . STP414TED . 11# . . Saki BAIiiiMORE MD . NON 31 r':Pfr. , . - ., '1. NESENK0.111114719N. ..., ./4971004509 'NONE BALTIMORE 1,P7,12.187102 PALTITORtbil),. SWIG!. IiIIME *ST 7 ... MqN.MaNT ANN !AMP; COMMAND' . . 71+ . , ;. - clig.iitr.AFE, oFitax40 434 DISCHARGE MOM ACTIVE . . ARV AtTERV*SaniejtRAR-ED AREAS THIS IS AR IMPORTANT' RECORD. . PuRposES . . . . .1 - :40410PRT:. , 11, PRIMARY SPECIArry. jUst maty4 tgeardartfrii *IlliCitUil ijseWiy. ite'#iitkitstifitkAt its6k# iii4 &at invkiwaik* cf tifse aim .S2R3 . magi, : .&WIMP .. 12MCO.RD. OFAIIIMcg . . , :- , , , , A.-telEIRITIRM ids rills taloa Ir. SEPAIW.HOI.I *DVS Tlas Paw, . OWLS , 0 Me 00DYS !- .4 . * - ..-. ' .--. " ,i ;,,, (r.., .' DAY - 4 .'. , r_t7i, L Itstikttti AVIA saVies .1 f7f3 !.'..i .. . ' . Fzi,:f7,--7,r = 77,,im: -tour Agin gimes TOM 141100 ,11/111/111/1/1//I BiZal LZWi; L.-1L' ) ,-;. --Li..i,-__'-:-7:I'L.i:i=L-1')i :*:.* . ' . . ppaireAm . *3.-1*C9MT.1010,41EDALS, BANB.-arATioNs NO4.°IIS *AVM!. OR VTNONIZEO '''(41*#419.4k114 ;::. :Am i ' ..W/4 T# j-i'llig- ''W/0 ..., ow iou : ' . -_.; `.'itilei.001.V44) :AO., NONE '4.. jOV: ..i: it . : ".,g *hs0 .. :. ' :A4P,A - ' . . . ...y4i,...0.#,..._.. -iii ii- .:2 . . . - - - . *!**-..miN44;41#1 tfotiAtAtit4isTANcE PROD MBE41014ff .. . 7;i --': BEA rrigm ism - ...- .,:-..::: , :-. -ii.*vt.:. f,Iiii*EitTasfit4iitiiiiiitibiEfititifAitiCiliitOmoiikatiAttikiiiiiiiii14 IM 7 " b....... "-..-..)41Mat4P1.11510Mc!IREAMIEHTYnYktit4N0as:PRI0A194.401Rig!04 iiiii :lt.: iiiiiZAtiti:-:.1- ; Mg 0 . . . /////i/1/1/,//iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit y : . : // i.I.// ii /I/ / /ft/ / i / i i // V.L 10/74V:Iiii 4 -'01;(11%,:mPiki. AEi 10. PPli.;: 41kfl'.*Yo.:.015..i :00 'Vf/S ...0%.91. Wij. '.Oltto i ' . ..; ,., .,2_, . ".-'71,--Z,7i:-.'.: . ir: '-/=Tie* PAY mat .1 104IIITIAAY F.DUCAT/IMPurse Otis! iiiiKirlOck. al4lillOki*f" . -...'..- . : = . . ,. . . . - . ;. . . ,:e4r MEMBER PREVIOUS 59 .- . I DioceseErie giox10397 Tennsglifrania... 165140397 office af the tisk), July 12 2916 §t9Ptief E. 4PsfiniCk ,"tA* Dear - - 11A-tita' I :understand that ypi; halm :retired aegfull 10*.F.ocoe Colonel. I congratiiiata you on thathigh recognition bythe'United :Statet Air' Force: .You are a retired Ole* of the plocese of Erie with the faculties of that dioc00; I pray that you will 011011.04r retirement years. Best wishes.' Fraternally yours in Christ, Most Rev- DonaY4 W. Trautman, STD, S_SL Bishop of Erie enclosures 61