.. _ _. _._ _.. Sheri L. Wainscott i i From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Robbie Ferris Tuesday, November 17, 2015 3:45 PM Keith R. Powell HCS contracts Bookl.xlsx Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Keith, All the needed sign offs are still coming in from our team but I think we're very close to being checked off. I do have one revision request. We would like to bill for pre-construction ,proposal development and schematic design. The breakdown is in the attachment but the total is $5,504,430.00. We are actually in DD so I think billing for SD is very reasonable, What do you think? Robbie { ~~~~~ Z~ h'..'. C 41 1 1 1 L' 1 5 Robert W. Ferris, AIA, REFP, LEED AP CEO/President 333 Fayetteville Street, Suite 225 Raleigh, NC 27601 Cell: 919.610.2251 Fax; 919,573,6355 rferrisC~sfla.biz www.sfla.biz 1 PAPR - 004453 Firstfloor Proposl Dev Pre construction estimating and bidding A&E-Schematic design 3 4 1 2 5 $ 253,187.00 $ 250,165.00 $ 260,035.00 $ 206,721.00 $ 231,417.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 126,OOQ.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 750,840.00 $ 741,878.00 $ 771,147.00 $ 722,760.00 $ 685,280.OQ totals $ 1,201,525.00 $ 630,000.00 $ 3,672,405.00 $ 5,504,430.00 PAPR - 004454 Sheri L. Wainscott From: Sent: To: Subject: Keith R. Powell Tuesday, November 17, 2015 4:11 PM Robbie Ferris RE: HCS contracts Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Completed Categories: Red Category There is a clause about this in my draft, but I had no amounts. I only used $500K as the "catch up" billing allowable (per project) simply because I heard you say near the end of the competition that you had about $2.5M invested, but if the concept is the same I don't see a big difference in using your enclosed figures if HC5 concurs. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halligan.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-snail inay contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to exai7iine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. if you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. From: Robbie Ferris [mailto:RFerris@sfla.biz] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 3:45 PM To: Keith R. Powell Subject: HC5 contracts Keith, All the needed sign offs are still coming in from our team but I think we're very close to being checked off. I do have one revision request. We would like to bill for pre-construction ,proposal development and schematic design. The breakdown is in the attachment but the total is $5,504,430.00. We are actually in DD so I think billing for SD is very reasonable. What do you think? Robbie Robert W. Ferris, AIA, REFP, LEED AP CEO/President 333 Fayetteville Street, Suite 225 Raleigh, WC 27601 Celt: 919.610.2251 Fax: 919.573.6355 rferrisC~sfla.biz www.sfla.biz 1 PAPR - 004455 Sheri L. Wainscott From: Sent: To: Subject: Clark, Brad Tuesday, November 17, 2015 5:31 PM Keith R. Powell; Robbie Ferris RE: HCS ~ Exhibit B Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Keith, Can you please send me the Causes of Loss Form referenced in the Builders Risk Coverage Form and all applicable endorsements/exclusions? I would like to review the excluded perils as the policy wording in the attachments you send provides very limited coverage for the exposure. Thank you, Brad Clarl<, CIC Vice President BB&T Insurance Services 4309 Emperor Blvd., Suite 300 Durham, NC 27703 919.281.4545 Direct 678.612.7403 Cell brad.clarl<@bbandt.com mailcode: 120-80-01-15 From: Keith R. Powell [mailto:kpowell@childs-halligan.nefi] Sent: November 17, 2015 1:22 PM To: Robbie Ferris Cc: Clark, Brad Subject: RE: HCS ~ ExhibiC B Here are the forms, The BR policy talks about "your" property, but the IRF won't let HCS name a nongovernment entity as an insured or loss payee. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.chiIds-halligan.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-avail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the aCcompanyfng material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. From: Robbie Ferris f_mailto:RFerris(a~sfla.biz] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 12:22 PM To: Keith R. Powell PAPR - 004456 Cc: Clark, Brad (Brad.Clark(~BBandT.com) Subject: FW: HCS ~ Exhibit B Keith, Apparently our insurance company sent mean email about this a few days ago thatInever sent yau. Sorry!! Feel free to call Brad directly to discuss his concerns. Robbie Robbie/Mike, After reviewing this updated draft, I still see the same potential problem areas as previously outlined. There are some significant gaps in the protection of First Floor and subcontractors with the language used for Builder's Risl< coverage, specifically: • • • • design-Builder and subcontractors of all tiers should have insured status on the Builder's Risl< policy in order to ensure your interests are protected. HCS should agree to waive subrogation against First Floor and subcontractors of all tiers for losses covered by the Builder's Risk policy. This waiver will prevent HCS' insurer from seeking subrogation against First Floor's or a subcontractor's GLcoverage if a contractor caused damage to the project. The contract states that HC5 has the responsibility to pay losses not covered by deductibles, but the contract does not state anything regarding excluded perils, inadequate limits, or property not covered. These can all be significant exposures. Other areas as outlined in the attached "Builder's Risk Considerations". Additional Insured status is still referenced for Pollution Liability coverage even though that coverage is not required by HCS. I recommend striking this language since First Floor is not required to carry Pollution Liability by HCS. As discussed previously, BB&T still recommends that you purchase Pollution Liability coverage to protect First Floor. Thanl~s, Brad Clark, CIC Vice President BB&T Insurance Services 4309 Emperor Blvd., Suite 300 Durham, NC 27703 919.281.4545 Direct 678.612.7403 Cell brad.clarl<@bbandt.com m a ilco d e: 120-80-01-15 From: Peeples, Kenneth Sent: November 17, 2015 10:30 AM To: Blanchard, Kathy; Clark, Brad Subject: Fwd: Hcs Ken Peeples 919-2$1-4510 office 919-215-9779 cell z PAPR - 004457 Via ii'hone Begin forwarded message: From: Robbie Ferris Date: November 17, 2015 at 9:55:52 AM EST To:lVancy Zablud , Mike Wawrzynialc , Aaron Thomas , Mike Richter Subject: Fwd: Hcs Guys, See attached exhibit B in the email from Keith Powell. Robbie Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From:. "Keith R. Powell" Date: November 17, 2015 at 9:47:32 AM EST To: "Robbie Ferris (RFerris ,sfla.biz)" , "Ara Heinz (AHeinzna~horrvcountvschools.net)" , John Gardner , Kenneth Generette , "rni~evCcr~,hoixycountyschools.iiet" Cc: "William F. Halligan" Subject: RE: Hcs Robbie & HCS folks: Ex B updated draft attached for review &comment. Waiting nn HCS comments on 141 and Ex A. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.Childs-halli ~an.coin (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. On Nov 17, 2015, at 7:43 AM, Robbie Ferris wrote: I Date: November 17, 201S at 9:55:52 AM EST To: Nancy Zablud , "I~enneth J. Peeples" , Aaron Thomas , Mike Richter Subject: Fwd: Hcs Guys, See attached e~ibit B in the email from Keith Powell Robbie Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: Frorn: "Keith R. Powell" Date: November 17, 2015 at 9:47:32 AM EST To: "Robbie Ferris (RFerrisna,sfla.biz)" , Marlc Wolfe , "Ara Heinz (AHeinz(c~,horr~c untvschools.net)" , John Gardner , Kenneth Generette , PAPR - 004462 "rrnaxey a,horrvcountXschools.uet" Cc: "William F. Halligan" Subject: RE: Hcs Robbie & HCS folks: Ex B updated draft attached for review &comment. Waiting on HCS comments on 141 and Ex A. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halli ~an,com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. On Nov 17, 2015, at 7:43 AM, Robbie Ferris Wednesday, November 18, 2015 10:04 AM Keith R. Poweil hcs draw request.xlsx hcs draw request.xlsx Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Keith, I should have put the names on the schools. See the new attachment. Also I made a $10,000 typo on the Myrtle beach MS that I send you last might. This version is corrected. The amount in this spreadsheet aligns with our schedule of values so hopefully these amounts will be ok with you but if not we could round it to 1,100,000 per school. Rounding just means we would have to re do the schedule of values and it would get a little messy with subs. am planning on being at HCS at 3 to sign everything unless I hear otherwise from you. Robbie ~~~~~ .L h'v'C. II I IA c7} Robert W. Ferris, AIA, REFP, LEED AP CEO/President 333 FayeCCeville Skreet, Suite 225 Raleigh, NC 276Q1 Cell: 919.b10.2251 fax; 919, 573.6355 rferrisC~sfla.biz www.sfla.biz 1 PAPR - 004464 Firstfloor Proposl Dev Pre construction estimating and bidding A&E-Schematic design Socastee ES Socastee MS tota Is Myrtle beach MS Carolina forest St James Inter 260,035.00 $ 206,721.00 $ 250,165.00 $ 231,417.00 $ 1,201,525.00 $ 253,187.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 126,000.QO $ 126,000.00 $ 630,000.00 $ 126,000.00 $ 771,147.00 $ 722,760.00 $ 760,840.00 $ 741,878.00 $ 686,280.00 $ 3,682,905.00 $ 1,118,043.00 $ 1,157,182.00 $ 1,055,481.00 $ $ 1,043,697.00 $ 5,514,430.00 1,140,027.00 $ PAPR - 004465 Sheri L. Wainscott From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Keith R. Powell Wednesday, November 18, 2015 10:14 AM Robbie Ferris Re: hcs draw request.xlsx image001jpg Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Thanks. Discussing all (finally) with HCS today. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halli~an.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. On Nov 18, 2015, at 10:04 AM, Robbie Ferris wrote: Keith, I should have put the names on the schools. See the new attachment. Also I made a $10,000 typo on the Myrtle beach MS that I send you last might. This version is corrected. The amount in this spreadsheet aligns with our schedule of values so hopefully these amounts will be ok with you but if not we could round it to 1,100,000 per school. Rounding just means we would have to re do the schedule of values and it would get a little messy with subs. am planning on being at HCS at 3 to sign everything unless I hear otherwise from you. Robbie Robert W. Ferris, AIA, REFP, LEED AP CE~lPresident 333 Fayetteville Street, Suite 225 Raleigh, NC 27601 Celt: 919.b10.2251 Fax: 919.573.6355 rferrisCsfla. biz www.sfta. biz i PAPR - 004466 PAPR - 004467 Sheri L. Wainscott Fram: Sent: To: Subject: Robbie Ferris Wednesday, November 18, 2015 12:27 PM Keith R. Powell RE: HCS contracts Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Great, the 2.5 mil was sfla internal cost and it did not include consultants or estimators. It was my SD fee for architectural only. __ From: Keith R. Powell [mailto:kpowellCa>childs-halligan.net] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 4:11 PM To: Robbie Ferris Subject: RE: NCS contracts _ There is a clause about this in my draft, but I had no amounts. I only used $500K as the "catch up" billing allowable (per project) simply because I heard you say near the end of the competition that you had about $2.5M invested, but if the concept is the same I don't see a big difference in using your enclosed figures if HCS concurs. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halligan.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. From: Robbie Ferris [mailto:RFerris@sfla.biz] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 3:45 PM To: Keith R. Powell Subject: HCS contracts Keith, All the needed sign offs are still coming in from our team but I think we're very close to being checked off. I do have one revision request. We would like to bill for pre-construction ,proposal development and schematic design. The breakdown is in the attachment but the total is $5,504,430.00. We are actually in DD so I think billing for SD is very reasonable. What do you think? Robbie ~~~ :~. i [: I1 I 1 •t f: 1 .~ ~. PAPR - 004468 Robert W. Ferris, AIA, REFP, LEED AP CEO/President 333 FayetCeville 5treel, Suite 2Z5 Raleigh, NC 27601 Cell: 919.610.2251 Fax: 919.573.6355 rferris~sfla. biz www.sfla.biz PAPR - 004469 Sheri L. Wainscott From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Keith R. Powell Wednesday, November 18, 2015 12:56 PM Clark, Brad (Brad.C~ark@BBandT.com) (Brad.Clark@BBandT.com); Robbie Ferris (RFerris@sfla.biz) FW; HCS ~ Exhibit B Architect Fees Limitations.pdf; Builder's Risk Policy Info.pdf; Causes of Loss Earthquake.pdfi Causes of Loss.pdf; Endorsement Clauses - Certificates.pdf; Flood Insurance.pdf; SC Changes - Valuation.pdf Importance: High Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged Categories: Red Category Attached info for your use. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halligan.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosahle and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. From: Ara Heinz [mailto:AHeinz@horrycountyschools.net] Sent: Wednesday, November 18, 2015 12:40 PM To: Keith R. Powell Subject: RE: HCS ~ Exhibit B Mr. Powell, Sorry for the delay. In a mtg this morning and dr's appt right after. Let me Know if you need anything else. Regards, ~t 4'a~ Ara Heinz ~ ProcurementS~rvices~ ~xP: 843J48S-6930 Horry County Schools ~ 335 four Mile Rd. ~ Conway, SC 29526 VJebsite: Procurement.horrycountyschools.net R,_;~ Ibry Cp.n'y SrM~M From: Keith R. Powell [mailto:kpowell@childs-halli~an.net] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 6:39 PM To: Ara Heinz Subject: Fwd: HCS ~ Exhibit B PAPR - 004470 Ara -can you get your irf policy to me? Y know you sent two excerpts in the summer but the insurance agent for ffep needs to see it all. Thanks. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.chi lds-halli gan.com (803)254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. Tf you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. Begin forwarded message: Frorn: "Clark, Brad" Date: November 17, 2015 at 5:30:59 PM EST To: "Keith R. Powell" , Robbie Ferris Subject: RE: HCS ~ Exhibit B Keith, Can you please send me the Causes of Loss Form referenced in the Builders Risk Coverage Form and all applicable endorsements/exclusions? I would like to review the excluded perils as the policy wording in the attachments you send provides very limited coverage for the exposure. Thank you, Brad Clarl<, CIC Vice President BB&T Insurance Services 4309 Emperor Blvd., Suite 30~ Durham, NC 27703 919.281,4545 Direct 678,612.7403 Cell brad.clark@bbandt.com ma ilcode: 120-80-01-15 From: Keith R. Powell [mailto:kpowellC~childs-halligan.net] Sent: November 17, 2015 1:22 PM To: Robbie Ferris Cc: Clark, Brad Subject: RE: HCS ~ Exhibit B Here are the forms. The BR policy talks about "your" property, but the IRF won't let HC5 name a nongovernment entity as an insured or loss payee. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. Columbia, South Carolina www.childs-halligan,com PAPR - 004471 (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to examine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by teleF~hone as fisted above immediately. From: Robbie Ferris [mailto:RFerrisCa~sfla.biz] Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2015 12:22 PM To: Keith R. Pov~iell Cc: Clark, Brad (Brad.Clark(~BBandT.com) Subject: FW: HCS ~ Exhibit B Keith, Apparently our insura~7ce company sent me an email about this a few days ago that Z never sertit you. Sorry!i Feel free to call Brad directly to discuss his concerns. Robbie Robbie/Mike, After reviewing this updated draft, I still see the same potential problem areas as previously outlined. There are some significant gaps in the protection of First Floor and subcontractors with the language used for Builder's Risk coverage, specifically: • • • • Design-Builder and subcontractors of all tiers should have insured status on the Builder's Risk policy in order to ensure your interests are protected, HCS should agree to waive subrogation against First Floor and subcontractors of all tiers for losses covered by the Builder's Rislc policy. This waiver will prevent HCS' insurer from seeking subrogation against First Floor's or a subcontractor's GL coverage if a contractor caused damage to the project. The contract states that HCS has the responsibility to pay losses not covered by deductibles, but the contract does not state anything regarding excluded perils, inadequate limits, or property not covered:.These can all be significant exposures. Other areas as outlined in the attached "Builder's Risl< Considerations". Additional Insured status is still referenced for Pollution Liability coverage even though that coverage is not required by HCS. I recommend striking this language since First Floor is not required to carry Pollution Liability by HCS. As discussed previously, BB&T still recommends that you purchase Pollution Liability coverage to protect First Floor. Thanks, Brad Clark, CIC Vice President BB&T Insurance Services 4309 Emperor Blvd., Suite 300 Durham, NC 27703 919.281.4545 Direct 678.612.7403 Cell brad.clarlc@bbandt.com mailcode: 120-80-01-15 PAPR - 004472 From: Peeples, Kenneth Sent: November 17, 2015 10:30 AM To: Blanchard, Kathy; Clark, Brad Subject: Fwd: Hcs Ken Peeples 919-281-4510 office 919-215-9779 cell Via iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Robbie Ferris , "Kenneth J. Peeples" , Aaron Thomas , Mike Richter Subject: Fwd: Hcs Guys, See attached exhibit B in the email from Keith Powell. Robbie Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Keith R. Powell" Date: November 17, 2015 at 9:47:32 AM EST To: "Robbie Ferris (RFerris e,sfla.biz)" , Mark Wolfe , "Ara Heinz (AHeinz(a,honycountyscliools.net)" , John Gardner , Kenneth Generette KGenerette(a~horrvcountvschools.net>, "rinaxey~a~horr,~countyschools.net" Cc: "William F. Halligan" Subject: RE: Hcs Robbie & HCS folks: Ex B updated draft attached fox review &comment. Waiting on HCS comments on 141 and Ex A. Keith R. Powell Childs &Halligan, P.A. PAPR - 004473 Columbia, South Caxolina www.childs-halli an.com (803) 254-4035 NOTICE: This e-mail may contain information that is personal and confidential, non-disclosable and protected by attorney-client privilege. If you have received this e-mail in error, this does not constitute permission to exannine, copy or distribute the accompanying material. If you receive this message in error, please notify us by telephone as listed above immediately. On Nov 17, 2015, at 7:43 AM, Robbie Ferris