BILL HASLAM STATE OF TENNESSEE CANDICE MCQUEEN GOVERNOR DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION COMMISSIONER NINTH FLOOR, ANDREW JOHNSON TOWER 710 JAMES ROBERTSON PARKWAY NASHVILLE, TN 37243-0375 November 29, 2018 Director Shawn Joseph Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools 2601 Bransford Avenue Nashville, TN 37204 Dear Director Joseph, Since 2012, Tennessee has identified its lowest performing 5 percent of schools and awarded grants to districts and schools to implement plans for turnaround. As we developed our continuum of intervention and support for our lowest performing schools in our state Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) plan, much of what we have learned is embedded in our model. First and foremost, we know that improving low-performing schools is challenging work and requires additional capacity, funding, and opportunity to innovate. Tennessee’s theory of action is an evidence-based one that will guide the priorities for the state’s turnaround efforts. Tennessee’s system of performance management for Priority and Comprehensive Support and Improvement (CSI) schools will continue to operate through our school improvement continuum and be supported by the Office of School Improvement (OSI). The continuum defines three tracks of intervention for Priority and CSI schools identified for multiple factors. In guidance released earlier this year, the department outlined that 2017-18 TNReady data would not be used to identify schools for the 2018 Priority list. The department also released additional information regarding Priority school designations this summer. These documents explain that schools named to the 2018 Priority school list would continue on the intervention tracks designated following the 2016-17 school year. The information below provides additional detail around the specifics of intervention track decisions for the 2018-19 school year. Alpha Track: For 2018-19, only the schools designated as Alpha track last year that still appear on the 2018 Priority list will be designated as Alpha track. Schools will continue in the specific intervention that was designated for them last year. There will be an annual proof point at the end of the 2018-19 school year where progress will be evaluated, and it will be determined whether the schools remain Alpha, change interventions, or move to the Beta track. For 2019-20 and beyond, Alpha track will include Priority schools that have been identified on the two most recent Priority Lists and have earned a composite TVAAS score of 3 or less in the two most recent years. These schools are eligible for the state-led intervention by the Achievement School District (ASD). Schools in the Alpha track are reviewed based on feeder pattern, success rank/rate, graduation rate, and other relevant indicators to determine whether Alpha 1 or Alpha 2 is the more appropriate track of intervention. Schools identified as Alpha 1 will begin planning for ASD intervention. Schools identified as Alpha 2 will implement a specific intervention as determined by the Commissioner which may include district-led charter conversion, continuing a current intervention, closure, shared governance, or ASD planning. Office of the Commissioner • 710 James Robertson Parkway • Nashville, TN 37243 Tel: (615) 253-2593 • tn.gov/education Beta Track: For 2018-19, only the schools designated as Beta track last year that still appear on the 2018 Priority list will be designated as Beta track. There will be an annual proof point at the end of the 2018-19 school year where progress will be evaluated and it will be determined whether the schools remain on the Beta track or move to the Alpha track and become eligible for the ASD. For 2019-20 and beyond, Beta track will include Priority schools that have been identified on the two most recent Priority lists and demonstrate evidence of improvement or progress. These schools are not immediately eligible for the ASD and will work in partnership with TDOE to ensure that the plan for intervention is appropriate based on identified need and level of evidence. Delta Track: The following schools will be classified as Delta track: • Priority schools that have been identified on one Priority list. • Schools identified on the Comprehensive Support and Improvement (CSI) schools list, that are not also identified on the 2018 Priority list, and have not previously been identified as a Priority school will be placed on the Delta track. These schools will undergo a rigorous school improvement planning process and will implement new, district-led, evidence-based interventions. These schools are not immediately eligible for the ASD. Delta Plus Track: The following schools will be classified as Delta Plus track for the 2018-19 school year: • Schools that were identified for the first time on the 2015 Priority list and classified as Delta track schools for 2017-18 that also appear on the 2018 Priority list. • Schools that were previously identified on the 2012 or 2015 Priority lists but exited and now appear on the 2018 Priority list. • Schools identified on the CSI list, that are not also identified on the 2018 Priority list but have previously identified as a Priority school on either the 2012 or 2015 Priority lists. Delta Plus schools will also undergo a rigorous planning process and implement district-led, evidence-based interventions. Following the 2018-19 school year there will be an annual proof point for Delta Plus track schools, at which time, progress will evaluated, and the school will move to either the Beta or Alpha tracks. The current Priority and CSI schools in Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools will be on the following intervention tracks for the 2018-19 school year. Priority School / CSI School Intervention Track Alex Green Elementary Delta Amqui Elementary Delta Antioch Middle Delta Moses McKissack Middle Delta Bellshire Elementary Delta Buena Vista Elementary Delta Plus Caldwell Elementary / Ida B. Wells Delta Cumberland Elementary Delta Plus Gra-Mar Middle Delta Plus Haynes Middle Delta Jere Baxter Middle Delta Plus Joelton Middle Delta Plus Robert E. Lilliard Elementary Delta Office of the Commissioner • 710 James Robertson Parkway • Nashville, TN 37243 Tel: (615) 253-2593 • tn.gov/education Maplewood High Delta McMurray Middle Delta Rosebank Elementary Delta Robert Churchwell Elementary Delta Plus Madison Middle Delta Plus Tom Joy Elementary Delta Warner Elementary Delta Whites Creek High Delta Wright Middle Delta The Cohn Learning Center Delta Plus The Office of School Improvement will continue to provide support via grant opportunities and other professional learning resources, like the upcoming Turnaround Principal Cohort. When student achievement data is released in Summer 2019, each school’s status and/or intervention track will be re-assessed and a new intervention track may be determined. We appreciate your district’s efforts to provide support and resources for improving outcomes for Priority and CSI school students and look forward to partnering with you in these efforts. Please feel free to reach out to our executive director, Ginnae Harley (Ginnae.Harley@tn.gov), of the Office of School Improvement with any questions you might have. Sincerely, Dr. Candice McQueen Commissioner of Education Office of the Commissioner • 710 James Robertson Parkway • Nashville, TN 37243 Tel: (615) 253-2593 • tn.gov/education