Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1035 Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 MICHAEL M. MADDIGAN (SBN 163450) HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP 1999 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 1400 Los Angeles, CA 90067 Telephone: (310) 785-4727 Facsimile: (310) 785-4601 Email: michael.maddigan@hoganlovells.com 5 6 Attorney for M.M.M. Plaintiffs 7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 9 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 10 SAN DIEGO DIVISION 11 12 13 M.M.M., on behalf of his minor child, J.M.A., et al., 14 Honorable Dana M. Sabraw Plaintiffs, 15 v. 16 Jefferson Beauregard Sessions, III, Attorney General of the United States, et al., 17 Case No. 3:18-cv-1832-DMS 18 Defendant. 19 20 Case No. 3:18-cv-428-DMS Ms. L, et al., Honorable Dana M. Sabraw 21 Plaintiff, 22 23 24 25 v. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al., PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Defendant. 26 27 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1036 Page 2 of 6 1 TO ALL DEFENDANTS AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: 2 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT, Plaintiffs in the above-caption cases 3 will, and hereby do, seek relief from the Court through an emergency motion, to be 4 heard and decided by the Court at the earliest time convenient for the Court. 5 Through this emergency motion, Plaintiffs seek to enforce the government’s 6 promises and commitments to this Court without waiting for final approval of the 7 settlement agreement in this matter. The government now is reneging on those 8 promises and commitments, and, in doing so, is causing severe prejudice to 9 Plaintiffs that should be remedied immediately. 10 Given Defendants’ prior representations on this issue, and the harm that 11 further delay will cause to detained class members, Plaintiffs respectfully ask the 12 Court to order the government to proceed with implementing the parties’ settlement 13 agreement and order any other relief the Court deems appropriate. 14 Plaintiffs’ motion will be based upon this notice of motion and motion, the 15 attached memorandum of points and authorities, and all the Court’s files and 16 records in this action. 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES -2- PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1037 Page 3 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP /s/ Michael Maddigan Michael Maddigan (Cal. Bar No. 163450) 1999 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 1400 Los Angeles, CA 90067 Telephone: (310) 785-4727 Facsimile: (310) 785-4601 michael.maddigan@hoganlovells.com Justin W. Bernick* Zachary W. Best* T. Clark Weymouth* 555 Thirteenth Street, NW Washington, DC 20004 Telephone: (202) 637-5600 Facsimile: (202) 637-5910 justin.bernick@hoganlovells.com t.weymouth@hoganlovells.com zachary.best@hoganlovells.com Oliver J. Armas* Ira M. Feinberg (Cal. Bar No. 064066) 875 Third Avenue New York, NY 10022 Telephone: (212) 918-3000 Facsimile: (212) 918-3100 oliver.armas@hoganlovells.com ira.feinberg@hoganlovells.com Katherine A. Nelson* 1601 Wewatta Street, Suite 900 Denver, CO 80202 Telephone: (303) 899-7300 Facsimile: (303) 899-7333 katherine.nelson@hoganlovells.com 23 Haley K. Costello Essig* Park Place II, Ninth Floor 7930 Jones Branch Drive McLean, VA 22102-3302 Telephone: (703) 610-6100 Facsimile: (703) 610-6200 haley.essig@hoganlovells.com 24 *Admitted pro hac vice 25 Class Counsel for Child Class 21 22 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES October 10, 2018 Aaron M. Olsen Haeggquist and Eck LLP 225 Broadway, Ste 2050 San Diego, CA 92101 phone: 619.342.8000 PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY -3MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1038 Page 4 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES fax: 619.342.7878 aarono@haelaw.com Wilson G. Barmeyer** EVERSHEDS SUTHERLAND (US) LLP 700 Sixth Street NW, Suite 700 Washington, DC 20001 (202) 383-0100 (202) 637-3593 (facsimile) wilsonbarmeyer@evershedssutherland.com John H. Fleming** EVERSHEDS SUTHERLAND (US) LLP 999 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 2300 Atlanta, GA 30309 (404) 853-8000 (404) 853-8806 (facsimile) johnfleming@eversheds-sutherland.com Sirine Shebaya** Johnathan Smith** MUSLIM ADVOCATES P.O. Box 34440 Washington, D.C. 20043 (202) 897-2622 (202) 508-1007 (facsimile) sirine@muslimadvocates.org johnathan@muslimadvocates.org Simon Y. Sandoval-Moshenberg** Sophia Gregg** LEGAL AID JUSTICE CENTER 6066 Leesburg Pike, Suite 520 Falls Church, VA 22041 (703) 778-3450 (703) 778-3454 (facsimile) simon@justice4all.org sophia@justice4all.org ** Pro hac vice admission applications forthcoming Class Counsel for Parent Class Lee Gelernt Judy Rabinovitz Anand Balakrishnan Stephen Kang Spencer Amdur Daniel Galindo AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY -4MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1039 Page 5 of 6 1 6 125 Broad St. 18th Floor New York, NY 10004 T: (212) 549-2660 F: (212) 549-2654 lgelernt@aclu.org jrabinovitz@aclu.org abalakrishnan@aclu.org skang@aclu.org samdur@aclu.org dgalindo@aclu.org 7 Class Counsel For Removed Parents 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES -5- PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1040 Page 6 of 6 1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 2 3 I hereby certify that I filed the foregoing NOTICE OF MOTION AND 4 EMERGENCY 5 SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, with the Clerk of the Court through the ECF 6 system on October 10, 2018. This system provided a copy to and effected service 7 of this document on all parties. 8 Dated: 9 10 MOTION October 10, 2018 TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP By: 11 /s/ Michael Maddigan Michael Maddigan Attorneys for Plaintiff 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES -6- PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF EMERGENCY MOTION AND MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1041 Page 1 of 27 " . ! / 0 $)&'(-1 ! 2 $ 7 ,,=, 5 3 4A546=4> " 78 9:,4- - )9;*<=> 6?94 $'-@ 4 4 :7A544C C //&&$$--11 **++((DD'')*-%$* F; ;EA4=B??AF? C F?E:;4A.F;GG?@;5H:7@;5A734AA=.E7F 9 97<54I 87< JKJKJKL A;?59?88= MM NOPQRSMTQUQRTMSPTQVPWQMWXNVQM TXNQYRVOMSPTQVPWQMXZMWU[PZXVOPUM TUOMSPR\XMSP]PTPXOM M . . . =4 7. &C$+DE3D$+&%D _. . . > 4> 97 ;5A .^>4:;A8 78 :?= F?57< E:?AG> "; A;?59?88=> M 757<;^A4 ;5; . ;^<;` M 3. _ 9 489874<<5=47I5 !4 045;46<<;4A@ 7;<8G 9 : 44 = 5 =?7?954=G> 9 ;> 94=> 49 ;A.> 4845G;59. M ";=4 7. &C$+DE3D'%+D =. > 49 ;A.> 757<;^A4 ;5; . ;^<;` A;?59?88> aRaXVUOSNaM XZM bXP OQTM UOSM UNQYXVP QP RT M P OM 3. TRaRV\ROWmM NbbXVQMXZMcdef ghf iij kl aXQP XOM QXM . VRnNP VRMPab[RaROQUQP XOM 5 87. < EFF? 4F4@5<9;> 94?79 5; A;.>5G "6=97F= XZMTRQQ[RaROQM U\VRRaROQM 4845G;59. M 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 M ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1042 Page 2 of 27 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 A;?59?88= 8?A4 9:?= 4F4<@45EI F79?75 ?5 A?@:9 78 ; G?=96<^?5@ G434A7BF459 75 opqrpqqstruvropqrwuxyotrzyqs{ {}~yr~zzyu€~sruvropqrz~yo{qtrtqoosq q}or~yqq q}o‚rr 5 =:7<9> 9:4 @734<5F459 ?5G?E;94G 97G;I 9:;9 ?9 ?5945G= 97 @7^;Eƒ 75 ?9= E7FF?9F459 „F;G4 97 ^79: A;?59?88= ;5G 9:?= "76<9 „97 ?FBA4F459 9:4 =499A4F459 ;@<44F459 B %-$+> ?5 <4=B75=4 97 B7?594G …64=9?75= 8<7F 9:4 "76<9> E765=4A 87< 4845G;59= <4B<4=4594G 9:;9 9:4 @734<5F459 †uxs‡rˆqor u€{}‰r~}‡rŠq{}r{ zsq q}o{}ropqr~yqq q}or†{opuxor†~{o{}rvuyr 8?5;A ;BB<73;AC QYRMWXNVQ‹ ƒ;I. 5G 9:45 `:;9 ;^769 9:4 ?G4; 78 =9;<9?5@ 57`. 9 = 4 4 F= 9 7 F4 9 : ; 9 9 : 4 3 ; = 9 F; Œ 7 < ? 9 I 7 8 J K L Ž KE A ; = = F4 F^ 4 < = ; 5 G JJJ =G= < 77E54E44G . 9 :4L ‘ELA’;“== ?”=• –EL‘4“<9L?8‘?—4˜G‘L>˜ ;™<š4‘ L—@›— 7?5œ@ 97 ^4 75^7;< : GE A;4;5 ? 4 ; G I 9 GG4 ;; 7 8 E A; =;=5 E 4B<9B?87?< 7 3 9;:A? 7 8> 9 :A4A = 4 9 9 A 4 F4 5 9 ; 5 5 7 9 ? E 4 G 7 9 7 ^ Œ 4 4 ; A 5 ƒ `? ; BLB–A–I¡ 97L ‘;“ L3¡– 4˜ ?L˜8 —;‘5šI–.˜ L ‘žŸ  LL  ‘ ‘ L ‘ L  “ “ š — Ÿ • —©‘ª–«˜¤¬L­—®« Ÿ ­LŸ°̄±“²‘ªL³«š´² —¥µ–«L¶‘“L›—‘L¦“˜L¦Ÿ—•L—’’˜“¥—•KLL§š—‘L›“£• L‘š–L ¨ aV· L›– 76L<¢ “94£5• 9;L9™?–3‘4L¡“ 3?¥4` `7 6L‘AšG ^.4 9:;9 L ‘šŸ¹ML‘Tš QR¸UVQ‹#7 —`7 ‘L‘š6—AG‘L Œ6L—=9’ =’;˜I“ ’6?˜8<  — :‘G–77L5— 7EŸ<7 >F4 Ÿ ™ L “ Ÿ „? 8 ;?=9 7G57 47=9: E47 F; FII ;`4 994 5^9 I 7 6 ƒ 5 7 `> ; 5 ? FB 4 G ? F4 5 9 7 < = 7 < 9 7 8 ; < 4 `? = op~orour06 opq9r ºFI ux y:o7tBr~4o o?q=} o`? {u9}:r {vF7 r†q r y„I q~s{7»6q r{ƒo5¼7`> ;= `?9: 79:4< BA;5= `4 = 9 : ;3B44 ; B7B6<=7AI3 4^G6 ? 9< E 7 ?›– =945L›“ 9 `? 9L:›— 7Ÿ6‘L<‘ G 4=‘?L<™4– 9 7 F7 3. 4 9 :‘L?5@L—= L 4 ½ G ? 9 ? 9 7 G 4 £ •   “ L ¾ £ ‘ L ¡“ ¥  Ÿ ™  ¦ L  ™““ L’•—Ÿ¤L›–Lš“£• L™–‘L¡“¥Ÿ™K ½. $( ;9 ,D$- /4FB:;=?= ;GG4G1. :4"76<9 9:45 to~oq‡rop~orˆopqrz~yo{qtruxporour qor u€{}¿‰r~}‡rop~orˆouropqrqÀoq}o I76 E;5 ?G459?8I BA;?59?88= „E:?AG<45 ;5G B;<459= „`:7 `;59 97 @49 =9;<94G `?9: 9:4 3; ‘š—‘L›–L“£™š‘L‘“L‘—˜‘L‘š—‘L˜™š‘L—›—œ. . . —Ÿ L‘š–ŸL™–‘L‘š–L’˜“¢–L™“Ÿ™‚‰rr KL;9 $- /4FB:;=?= ;GG4G1. :4 "76<9 ;A=7?5G?E;94‡rop~or{or†~}oq‡ropqrz~yo{qtrourˆ{€qr~r D%D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1043 Page 3 of 27 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 =9;96= ;= 97 9:4 3; %'-> `:;9434< 9:4I F?@:9 ^4 65G4< 9:4 B<7B7=4G =499A4F459> =7 9:;9 9:4 "76<9 ;5G 9:4 B6^A?E E;5 ƒ44B 9<;Eƒ 78 9:4 z~yo{qtrqvvuyotr~}‡rzyuyqttr†{opryqtzqºorouropqtqr~tsx rºs~{ t‚‰rr K;9 $$Á ––L —•“L K;9 $' /"76<9 ?5…6? 9:4 "76<9 /;5G A;?59?88=1 EA4; %-$+. :;9 4DF;?A to~oq‡rop~orˆÂoÃpqru€qy} q}or{trx}‡qyo~Ë{}rour { zsq q}oropqrz~yo{qtr~yqq q}or{}r~ººuy‡~}ºqr†{opropqºuxyotroq}o~o{€qr~zzyu€~sr ~oropqrs~torto~oxtrºu}vqyq}ºq‚‰rr ½. $). Ìqvq}‡~}otrºux}tqs~sturto~oq‡ÍrˆÎtropqr @734<5F459 ?G459?8?4= ?5G?3?G6;A= 97 ^4 B<7E4==4G 65G4< 9:4 G?884<459 B<73?=?75= 78 9:4 ;@<44F459> ;5G =9;<9= 97 F734 9:7=4 B<7E4==4= 87<`; ?9?= ?FB7<9;59 9:;9 `4 ƒ57` . . . `:?E: B;<459= ;5G E:?AG<45 `?=: 97 B6<=64 9:4 B<7E4==4= =49 87<9: ?5 9:4 ;@<44F459> =7 9:;9 9:4<4 ?= A?ƒ4`?=4 57 65544G4G G4A;I ?5 45;^A?5@ 9:7=4 EA;== q Šqytrour u€qrvuy†~y‡‚‰rr K A;?59?88= :;34 <4A?4G 6B75 9:?= <4B<4=459;9?75 734< 9:4 A;=9 =434<;A `44ƒ=> ;= G4=E 9:4 @734<5F459 :;= G754 ;5 ;^769D8;E4. 0I 4DF;?A 97G;I> Ìqvq}‡~}otr E765=4A =9;94G 9:;9 9:4 @734<5F459 `?AA Ÿ“‘F734 87<`; 9:4 @734<5F459 ?= 579 F73?5@ 87<`; ?5EA6G?5@ 9:4 F7<4 9:;5 )- G49;?54G B;<459= ;5G E:?AG<45 A;?59?88= :;34 ?G459?8?4G =7 8;< ;= `;59?5@ 97 =9; I ?5 9:4 5?94 G 9; 94= ;5G D&D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1044 Page 4 of 27 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 ?537ƒ4 9:4 =499A4F459 B<7E4G6<4=. AA 78 9:4=4 B;<459= :;34 =?@54G 9:4 E76<9D ;BB<734G 579?E4 ;5G `;?34< 87 ;5G 9:4?< 5;F4= ;5G 4½4E694G 87 ;5G 434 9:4 "76<9 :;= ;A=7 4FB:;=?Ð4G 9:;9 B;<459= ;5G E:?AG<45 =:76AG <4E4?34 9:4 B<7E4G6<4= 769A?54G ?5 9:4 ;@<44F459 B 9:4=4 8;F?A?4= =:76AG :;34 <4E4?34G G64 B<7E4== `:45 9:4I8?<=9 E<7==4G 9:4 ^7 9:4I=6884<4G ?5945=4 9<;6F; G64 ouropqru€qy} q}otr{ssq~srtqz~y~o{u}rzus{º¿r~}‡ropqr~yqr}u†rtxvvqy{}ropyuxpr F759:= 78 B<7A75@4G> 6554E4==; 579 =?½ 7< F7<4 `44ƒ= 8<7F 57`. :4 @734<5F459 =9;94G 97G;I9:;9 ?FBA4F459?5@ 9:4 =499A4F459 B 434 ;5G E:77=4 97 ;EE4B9 <4F73;A <;9:4< 9:;5 `;?9 ?5 G49459?75 87< 9:4?< ;=IA6F EA;?F= 97 ^4 :4; Œ6=9 A;=9 `44ƒ A;?59?88= 579?8?4G 9:4 @734<5F459 9:;9 734< '- G49;?54G 8;F?A?4=G4E?G4G 97 ;EE4B9 <4F73;A „ ?5=94;G 78 <4E4?34 G 64 B<7E4== „^ 4E;6=4 9:4I D'D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1045 Page 5 of 27 =?FBAI E76AG 579 `;?9 ?5 G49459?75 ;5I A75@4<. Ñ:?A4 9:;9 ƒ?5G 78 <4=6A9 F;I ^4 uzo{ ~srvyu ropqru€qy} q}otrzqytzqºo{€q> ?9 G484;9= 9:4 B6 9:4 z~yo{qtrtqoosq q}o¿r~}‡rop{trwuxyotruy‡qyry~}o{}r~roq zuy~yryqtoy~{}{}ruy‡qy‚rrÊor {trºu zsqoqsr~oru‡‡tr†{oprop{trwuxyotr‡qt{yqrvuyr~rtusxo{u}rop~ort†{vosryqtus€qtr Ïs~{}o{vvtrºs~{ t‚ Òpqru€qy} q}otryq€qyt~sr{tr ~‡4 `7<=4 ^I 9:4 8;E9 9:;9 ?9 B<4Œ6G?E4= A;?59?88=> `:7 <4A?4G 75 ?9 ?5 F6A9?BA4 `;I= 734< 9:4 A4;=9 =434<;A `44ƒ=. 7< 4½;FBA4> Ïs~{}o{vvtrz~o{q}osrousqy~oq‡ropqru€qy} q}otrx}}qºqtt~yr‡qs~ruvropqr B<4A?F?5; 75 4B94F^4< $,. :4 @734<5F459 9:45 ?5=?=94G75 F6A9?BA4 <765G= 78 F?57 ?5EA6G?5@ ; 56F^4< 78 4G?9= ?5 9:4 =4E75G ;5G 9:? A;?59?88= E76AG 579 8?A4 9:4 F79?75 87< B<4A?F?5; ;5G :;G 97 B6=: ^;Eƒ 9:4 B<7B7=4G G;94 78 9:4 8;?<54== :4; 9:4 8;F?A?4= `:7 ;A<4;GI =?@54G 9:4 579?E4 ;5G `;?34< 87 ;5G 9:4 :; A;?59?88= <4=B4E986AAI ;=ƒ 9:4 "76<9 97 7 %-$+ 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 YX\UOM[X]R[[TMNTM[[b Ô ? ÔLEJ ¢4šA— ; –•LJ—  @ ;5™ —ŸL L L : ; G G ? /$"; A,. 0; <4 5 7 . 7$8) &9:'4( - 19;<=> 6?94 $'-- , , 3 6 4 7 =4 5 @544A4C =/>& " ,+-(-)D'**%* 4 A B : 7 $ 1 * F? ;EE=:?;F? 4C /G&G$?-@1; *5+H: (D'7)@-;$5A734AA=.E7F 4AA.F; _Ö; 6=E9:?5; <Ñ. 04 04 <5?=E9ƒÕÕ I Ñ. . ;<ƒ?< 9Ñ4 I9:F7 6<94:4Õ9> Ñ (Ñ; ( ("A : 4 4 5 9 =:B?:57@5947C5 />% " %)-&-*-D'()-- 4 A 4 % 1 Œ6;=E9?=5?F? A<45C ?/E%ƒ-H: %1 )7&@*;5D(A7,3$4-AA=.E7F . ^ 4 9Ð.̀4 ;E:I;F7 3 45$64--%% 4 ` #7 # 4 :7A544C C/ %/%$$%%1 1, ,$$++DD&&$----- 7A;?EA34=4B? 6?94 ,-- $ 4 )-95:$34 4Ñ4 9 9 <7> 5" +--&%-1 %+,,D*&-- 4 A 4 B : 4 C / & ƒ;;9E:=4?F? +,,7D@*;&5&A&734AA=.E7F 9 ? 4AA579 = =A?7@7Õ< *,;& 42 = 0<%;%5$E-:% < ?3-4% E 4 ; D & & 4 :7A544C C/ */*--&&1 1) )$$--DD))%$---- :;;AEA44=IB?F? .4==?@H:7@;5A734AA=.E7F Õ GF?994G ’˜“Lš—¢L¥¢–L ؕ—Lؓ£Ÿ–•L¦“˜Lؚ• Lؕ—L ; <47@5@ … . A =54G5 Eƒ ; 6 ? = 9 ; % %;(5 0< 74@;G7`; I> , %94$ -%$-( ? > " B:754C )$,.&' %.+--- D)D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1047 Page 7 of 27 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 8;;;½<7C 5)7$H: ,.&';%4A.*;`. +*E+7F Ñ? A=75 !. 0;< F4I / 4<ÕÕ 2 1 *Ñ; --= :??5½@9:97 59>< 4 " 49 Ñ> $6?94 *-% //%%--%%11 &)+&&*DD-&$(-,-& /8;E=?F?A41 `? =69A:=47<5A^;5;E ! :9<4&4- &9-<4,49 > 6?94 %&-//''--''11 ++((&&DD++-+---) /8;E=?F?A41 Œ7:58A4F?5@H434<=:4G=D=69:4 %- . %* ". /G83;7E=E?;F? A4.71 <@ =Œ7?<:?554;HF6 = A ? F; 9 4 = 9:;5HF6=A?F;G37E;94=.7<@ ?7F7 5; #. 4@;@5ÕGÕ73;AD 7=:45^4<@ÕÕ B : ? !< ! " " ) -;)AA)= ": 446=<^E 6:<> @_2 ?ƒ 4 > 6 ? 94 (%- % % ' $ //**--&&11 ****++DD&&''((-' /8;E=?F?A41 ==?7F7 B:?5;HŒ HŒ66==99??EE44'';;AAAA..77<<@@ Õ87Õ< 9٘ š—5¢@L¥¢–L;GF?==?75 ;BBA?E;9?75= :E“7LF? ؕ—Lؓ£Ÿ–•L¦“˜Lٗ˜–Ÿ‘Lؕ—L 4 A4^ , # $)----' C / % $ % 1 D % ) A@C4 /A%4$<5%91H; ('E,AD6%.)7(<@' Œ;<^;;^A?;5ƒ7<3?=?:9Ð5H; EA6E.7A6<@.7 <@ ; 5 H; ==ƒ;FG ;5@6H; EAE6A.67.<7@<@ < H; G@;A?5G7H;EA6.7<@ ؕ—Lؓ£Ÿ–•Lړ˜Lۖ¡“¥– Lٗ˜–Ÿ‘L M D+D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1049 Page 9 of 27 WRVQPZPWUQRMXZMTRV]PWRM :4<4^I E4<9?8I 9:;9 8?A4G 9:4 87<4@7?5@ ÏÜÎÊÝÒÊÞÞßr ! "# à ! > `?9: 9:4 "A4<ƒ 78 9:4 "76<9 9:<76@: 9:4 " =I=94F 75 E97^4< $-> %-$+. :?= =I=94F B<73?G4G ; E7BI 97 ;5G 4884E94G =4<3?E4 78 9:?= G7E6F459 75 ;AA B;<9?4=. 94GC E97^4< $-> %-$+ ; ! 2 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 0IC á =:á ; ? E ; :;4GAG ; GG?@;5 ? E 4 A ? @ ; 5 997<54I= 87< A;?59?88 D,D ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1050 Page 10 of 27 JKJKJK¤L“ŸL”–š—•¦L“¦LšL¡Ÿ“˜L¢š• ¤LâKJKžK¤L–‘L—•KL¥KL▦¦–˜“ŸL㖗£˜–™—˜ L 䖍“Ÿ¤L¤Lž‘‘“˜Ÿ–œL喟–˜—•L“¦L‘š–L某‘– L䑗‘–¤L–‘L—•K çèéfêfhjlhëlcdefghfiijklçìçíîçgïðlìëhfëglhëlíçñòfíçl Pab[RaROQUQPXOMXZMTRQQ[RaROQMU\VRRaROQ QUó[RMXZMWXOQROQTM MM Rôõö÷öø Sùúûüýþø b01ý2 <;5=E"7 ¥ %KL-Ø3 $+ 9;96= $( $$D%( 5 J DF; $) 4B94F^4< %-> %97-$ _+. 04 <5?E?Aƒ 8<7F . 94`;<9 %)D%* 01234561786695 66 3 1 48 953 5 61953428689 D$-D - ! "# Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1051 Page 11 of 27 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 567898 4 4 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1052 Page 12 of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ase 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1053 Page 13 of 27 $% ! ( "00 "# / ( 0&% $"((@> '%# 0(" ''> ("$ ( / (** #/ # "- ! #P +/ & ! 0#%. $ 38 Q, @)%##%"R- ! ,# @ % #3R 43 6& 6'6(7% %# '%# ' " > !$% ! ,"# - !P+ %!"+'#!'" + $& )+0% "'' #" *)* * " / -#% " ' !.P% + ! ( $ / " % )0 + % +' #)"% SR (4 : 4 ! " % ,"!& / % - $ 86677 "(!% "00 "# /> ..T "!'$ '&" # ' @,# + ) ( ) ! 5 #@- - $ !R!P-P+ + !P+ $.""#$%R( * $ ) #& ( (- # -! P +! P+ !, #( ! % !)&" #)*" @@" -# - ! P!+P + #" S" *$ &! -/ ( !#P-+ !P+ / (( #*% ! "*0 #- !P+ UVWXYXZ[\] ^_`a[b ; Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1054 Page 14 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q cdefghijklfmdnhokpehdfqfophgdrlfcistiuvipfwxlfyzw{fqfy w}fs~u~    t€ifmnip %+ 8; % $"( "#- $"! %+ 34$56784*!+ (+ 5 #! ! +!+ ** /#" % " $ ! %*! '%#$ * ‚ % '%# ! " ! $% ' # $ + t€ifmkƒpt /%% "' # %% + & ! ! . / !")#",+ &"5 " *) # %' "00 "#" $ ! &" *@ $% # #%%* 0 @ /"5 * + ( * # " & "* ! '%# ,&% &"5 % & ( + '%# & /%5 # * - '%# ' " !- &"5 *!+ '") " - *#+ ! ,"# + '%# *!+ (+ 0(" ''! *#+ / ( # + $ 0(" ''! *!+ ( 5@+ ***- *#+ ) ! " *#+ ) # $R+ '%# & #/&- % %' & , @%#R $"! !- *! & (( #- *#+ # S $& + % & %#" $"! & # "# "00 "#" $ ! '#%* *!+ !& )"@" " *#+ )"#* @ #+ & "(!% &"5 & '%((%, / "* !> *#+ " "* ! /( #- *!+ $"#%( & (( #- *#+ ."$R *$)# - " *#+ / (( #*%- & R- ! "*0 #+ &"5 * !! " @% „ %R"@+ & "# / % 0#% ! ! , , (( "!! * - , & &" - ( 0 %' $% ! (+ & ( ?! /% "& " " / # /& % & !! !+ ( ?! ! "# ' #! , & & 0#%0%! ! ( * 5%(5 / ***- *!+ (+- " & %#" 0(" ''!- "(( %' &%! 5 "(!+ " 0 #&"0! $" ! "# % " 0#%$ #"( ( 5 ( ' #! + # $ 5 " ( # '#%* *!+ , !! " *!+ /(@ % ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 †‡ˆ‰Š‰‹ŒŽ ‘’Œ“ 7 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1055 Page 15 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q ) &"(' %' & $" &%( $ $&"# ! $%** @ ! #5 $ !- & "#$& %$ ! %' , @%#R- '%# $ # " %' & $& ( # ,&% *"@ '"(( , & & *** $("!!+ & @ "# $" / &" " @ ! ( * ,% ( ' #! &"5 % 5%(5 $("!! $ # ' $" % " "00#%5"( 0 #! " % # ( 8;+ &" ! *! $%## $ % * + !% / !! &" ,% ( ) & ' #! P ! % !- & ! ! ( * ,% ( &"5 % /% &#% /& " 0#%0%! $("!! $ # ' $" % " ! ( * - "* $%## $ „ " &" ,% ( & 0#%5 99 up~fvipehm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”•–—˜—™š›œ žŸ š› Q Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1056 Page 16 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3…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t€ifmkƒpt @ !+ *#+ ! ,"# - "!! * @% "/# + up~fcti¡dpt @ !- @% # &% %#+ & R & "00#%0# " "00#%"$& ! '%# @% # &% %# % # " %# # "'' #* / &" & # ( 8;- @% R %,- "$$ 0 / & - @% R %, & ! 0 (" $("!! " . ! $% ' #* / &" & # ( 8; $# # " "# !" !' . ! % *"R $( "# &" & ! ! " ) / ! ( * " # !%(5 ! & # /& ! " $(" *! "! ! " & "/# * + ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 ¢£¤¥¦¥§¨©ª «¬­®¨¯ : Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1057 Page 17 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3…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t€ifmkƒpt "/# , & &" + & R *%5 / "! P $R(@ "! 0%!! )( " %# #(@ '"!& % ! & ,"@ % /%, &- %' $% #! - & %00%# @ '%# " @ 0% "( $("!! * *) # % %). $ " % ) & "# # # ( 8;+ ) ! *! % * &" & 99 ,&" ,% ( 0#%0%! ! &" *"@ ) 0# '%# $% ! ( % * " $% ' # " ! )* % & $% # " .% *% % " %# # " # !! / & ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 °±²³́³µ¶·¸ ¹º»¼¶½ … Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1058 Page 18 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q # ( 8; !! !+ !% & R ,&" &" ,% ( $%*0"!! ! " 0#%0%! $("!! $ # ' $" % " !! "((@ "00#%5"( %' & ! ( * ! ). $ % " %00%# @ '%# " @% % %). $ " % ) & "# + % @% "/# „ up~fcti¡dpt & /%5 # * & R! &" &" ! " "00#%0# " "00#%"$&- @% # &% %#+ " ,% ( & R , !&% ( % &" S0 % !(@+ " &" !% ! ( R @% # &% %# ! 5 ! % / !%* & / )# ' ) . ! $%5 #! &%! R @ !! !- & # ( 8; !! !- " "00#%5"(- 0#%0%! $("!! $ # ' - " % !%* & / 5 #@ (")%#" %# ( / &@- . ! !%* & / ! '' $ + t€ifmkƒpt @ !+ & R ,&" ?! *0%# " ! & 0#%$ !!- !% & %00%# @ % ) & "# ' & # ! !%* % ,&% ! /% / % %). $ + $% $ 0 ,% ( !"@ &" & 0#%0%! ! ( * 99 & ! "# *@ " 5 %)! #5" % !- , &% & ) ' %' " @% &"5 / " %). $ % + ) "00 "#! &" / 5 & .% ! )* !! % & ! ! " 5 #@ " ( - , (( &% /& % 0#%0%!"( &" 5%(5 ! *" @- *" @ ! "R &%( #!+ " '#%* & $% # ?! # " / %' & 0#%0%! ! ( * "00 "#! S$ (( + "* 5 #@ *0# !! , & & " ( %' & 0%$R "# "! &" "# $%5 # 0 / % & 0"# $ ("# $ #$ *! " $ ! &" * /& ) 0# ! % 0"# $ ("# 0"# ! " ¾%# $& ( # + " & 0#%5 / '%# & 0#%$ !! ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 ¿ÀÁÂÃÂÄÅÆÇ ÈÉÊËÅÌ 4 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1059 Page 19 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3…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„ ,% ( @% ) ! R / % $% &" %5 *) # A * '#"* "! , / $(%! # % &" " „ ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 ÍÎÏÐÑÐÒÓÔÕ Ö×ØÙÓÚ A Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1060 Page 20 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q up~fcti¡dpt @% # &% %#- % ? & R " $ ! % ! *" % &" + *@ / !! ! &" , ,% ( ! * ("#(@ $% 99 @% R %,- , &"5 % ! ,&" & !%( $ %# / #"( *"@ $ % & # - ) $% ( 5 #@ , (( ) &" , * /& ! R- @% R %,- *%# * % . ! *"R ! # & # ! % !# 0 % % & % /% / *0( * " % %' & 0# ( * "#@ . $ % + %)5 % !(@ &" ! " ,"@! % - !% &%0 ' ((@ , , (( &"5 " ! / ' $" "*% %' # !%( % )@ &" * - @% # &% %#+ ) % ? & R , &"5 " @ !%# %' ' # & # $ ! % '#%* & /%5 # * "! % ! 0#%$ !! ! %# ,& # & /! ! " + t€ifmkƒpt %R"@+ " & ,&" ")% & " %' ! "# / %,+ ! *! % * &" & 5"! *".%# @ %' *!+ (+ $("!! * *) #! " *** $("!! * *) #!- % $ & $("!! ! $ # ' - "# /% / % ) % )%"# " # " @ % 0#%$ + ! 0%!! )( % ! "# # /& ","@„ & " %' $("!! $ # ' $" % " ' "( "00#%5"( %' & ! ( * " " % $ " %00%# @ % %). $ # "((@- & R- , (( "00(@ % " 5 #@ !*"(( &" ' ( %' 0% "( $("!! * *) #!- ' " @+ " ! *! % * &" & 0#%$ !! $% ( / #,"@ !%% # #" & # &" (" #- " % &"5 % ," '%# ' "( "00#%5"(+ ,&" ,% ( & /%5 # * ?! 5 , ) „ up~fcti¡dpt @% # &% %#- % # " 5 5 , ,% ( ) &" & R &" &" ! "00#%0# " " , $% ( / ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 ÛÜÝÞßÞàáâã äåæçèé 36 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1061 Page 21 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q *%5 / % & !+ ,% ( . ! !"@ ' % $%* 99 ' % ! $%* % *@ " % - @% R %,- " *0 * %# !%# %' " # "!% % & #, ! - *"@ , )# / &" % & $% # ?! " % ' , # "( T „ ) *@ &%0 ! , & *%! 99 @% R %,- "! , & % & # 0(" ! , &"5 "00#%5 $% ! ! , & % # ! # % *%5 & /! S0 % !(@ ) %# #(@- , ,% ( ," % . ! / *%5 /+ ' ! " /%% 0(" - , !&% ( / *%5 /+ t€ifmkƒpt *#+ ) # $R- % @% "/# „ up~fvipehm @% # &% %#- & ! ! . ! ) # $R '%# & *** 0(" ''!+ , "/# , & &" + t€ifmkƒpt %R"@+ !% % &" - ,% ( $( % *"R " @ %# #! ) . ! 5 & 0"# !- % " * 9" 9$% ' # )"! !- ! "# & 0#%$ !! , & & " &" & $% # - $% $ 0 - "00#%5 ! & ! ( * + %' $% #! # ! #5 / ' "( #* " % )"! % " @ %). $ % &" * /& ) *" - ) $% $ 0 & 0"# ! % /& % / *%5 /+ " % & S @% $" '@ 0(" ''! 99 $& ( # " 0"# ! 99 ,&% ," % / ! "# , & & 5"# % ! 0#%$ /! # 8;Q %# 876- &" , % /& % ! "# &" # /& ","@+ " , (( ( "5 % & 0"# ! % * " $% ' # " '@ &%! 5 "(!- " & / & 0#%$ !! /% /+ ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 êëìíîíïðñò óôõö÷ð 33 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1062 Page 22 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q , , (( "(!% 99 "! , /% "(% / , (( "!R &" & ! 0#%$ !! ) #%(( % & ! " ! # 0%# - !% &" # / & ! , R(@ ! " ! # 0%# & 0"# ! $" $( " ! " ! % & ! 0#%0%! ! ( * " '@ & 0"# ! " & $& ( # + " / 5 " ! " ! "! % & 5"# % ! 0#%$ /! # 8;Q876- ,&" 5 # & @ * /& ) # & 0#%0%! ! ( * - !% &" & $% # " & 0 )( $ $" R 0 #"$R %' & 0"# !? ''%# ! " 0#%/# !! , & # !0 $ % & ! "!@( * $(" *!+ "# & # " @ % & # &% /& ! % & ! 0#%0%! ! ( * „ % & #, ! , , (( *%5 % & .% ! " ! # 0%# + & " ,% ( ) &" % & 0#%0%! ! ( * & 0"# ! , (( ! )* !%* & / % & $% # )@ S & #! "@- ;>66 0+*+- %# !%% #- % " .% *% % " %# # '%# $("!! $ # ' $" % " "00#%5"( %' & ! ( * + " @ & / (! „ up~fcti¡dpt @% # &% %#- % &"5 % P ! % % & !+ & #% ! (' ! 99 "! @% R %,- & "00#%5"( %' & "/# * ,% ( 99 ,% ( - "! ! " !- ( ' & #% ! ('+ ! @% # % /% / '%#,"# , & & "/# * &" & #% ,% ( ) ( ' "! % '%(R! &" # "$& & "00#%0# " 0% & 0#%$ !! ,& # & @ $" # # % & # $% #@ %' %# / „ %# &%, ,% ( @% ! & #% "! ) / "'' $ )@ & ! 99 )@ & ! R %' " 0# ( * "#@ ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 øùúûüûýþ01 234566 38 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1063 Page 23 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q "00#%5"( %# & # $ 5 % 0#%$ # & 0(" „ t€ifmkƒpt & R- "! & 0"# ! 0#%0%! - $" ) ( ' "00#%0# " $"! !+ " & R & ,"@ , !$ !! " & "# / %# ,% "/% ! &" & 0"# ! $% ( ! *0(@ * " $% ' # " '@ ,# / '%# $ # " "* 5 "(! " ( ' / %' & #% !% &" &%! 0 #!% ! $% ( ) # ' & # &%* $% #@ %# # *%5 - ,&" 5 # & $"! *"@ ) + ,% ( ? &" ) "00#%0# " „ up~fcti¡dpt & R &" ?! 99 & R- @% # &% %# &" &" *"@ ) " ,%#R")( "00#%"$& '%# & ! 0# ( * "#@ 0 $ + "* #! " / &" @% # &% %# ! ! // ! / &" & 0"# ! ,% ( ) ")( % !"@- %R"@ 99 @% R %,- & @ ,% ( $%** $" "*% /! & *! (5 ! ' & @ "/# &" !%* )% @ 99 @% R %,- &" #% ,"! ( ' "! % &" 0 #!% & @ $% ( & 0#%$ , & # 0" # " % %# ,&" 5 # & "00#%0# " 0" & !- %# ,% ( @% ," & 5 "(! )#% /& % & $% # &%! $"! !„ t€ifmkƒpt & '%#* #- !% &" & 0"# ! ! *0(@ ,%#R &#% /& " '@ &%! 5 "(!- " & "((%, & * % ) # 0" # " , &% ' # & # $% # 5%(5 * + % @% "/# - *#+ ) # $R„ up~fvipehm %- @% # &% %#+ "* !0 "R /"/" - '%# & *** 0(" ''!- " , (( ( & *!+ (+ " ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 789 3; Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1064 Page 24 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q %#" 0(" ''! S0(" ' & @ &"5 " '' # 5 ,+ ) '#%* % # 0 #!0 $ 5 - % $ " $& ( # $ 5 ! & 0#%$ !! # & ! "/# * " & @ &"5 % %). $ % ! % & ! ( * - & , !&% ( *%5 '%#,"# + " ' & # ! ( ! # *%5"(- & & #% !&% ( ) ( ' "! % &" 5 "(+ &" ,% ( ) % # 0%! % + t€ifmkƒpt %R"@+ *#+ / ( # - % @% "/# „ up~fjinipet @ !- @% # &% %#+ t€ifmkƒpt " - ! *!+ !& )"@" %# *#+ )"#* @ #% @% "/# % ) &"(' %' & %#"„ up~fvdpuirip @ !+ & ! ! *#+ )"#* @ #- @% # &% %#+ &" R @% + @ !- , "/# "! , ((+ " , , (( % * " $% ' # , & & /%5 # * - "/# % *%5 / & ! '%#,"# "! S0 % !(@ "! 0%!! )( " / / & 0#%$ !! /% /+ % 0"# %' & "/# * ! % "((%, & '"* ( ! % &"5 $% ! ( & 0#%$ !!- " !% 99 " , % ? 99 , , (( % ) ,%#R / , & & ! "R &%( #! % ! ' , $" #@ % $%%# " &" + " !% , , (( % !0 "R , & & /%5 # * ")% &%, P $R(@ , $" *%5 '%#,"# , & & 0#%$ !!+ t€ifmkƒpt %R"@+ 5 #@ /%% + & . ! " P ! % % & / #"( * ( + % $% ! ( &"5 " " %' &%, (% / & ! 0#%$ !! ! /% / % ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 !"#$ 37 Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1065 Page 25 of 27 3 8 ; 7 Q : … 4 A 36 33 38 3; 37 3Q 3: 3… 34 3A 86 83 88 8; 87 8Q "R „ !% ( ?! "!! * ) ! $"! !$ "# %- 5 #@ & / /% ! !*%% &(@+ , / ! "# # /& %,+ 8;Q- 876 & "# /! " "(( %' & & /! &" "# $% *0(" & 0#%0%! ! ( * "# *%5 / '' $ (@ " '#%* & "#( ! 0%!! )( " ‚ ,&" % ! & ! * ( (%%R ( R „ % ! " @% R %,„ "!! * & # ! /% / % ) '' # * '#"* ! 0 / % & @0 %' & "# / &" ! 5%(5 + up~fcti¡dpt & R &" ! # /& - @% # &% %#+ !%* '%(R! !%* "# "! , (( ) P S0 % !- % & # '%(R! ,&%- '%# S"*0( - *"@ ) /% / % 876 0#%$ /! , (( "R " ) %' " (% / # $% #! - @% R %,- ,% ( ) & S0 $ " % + ,&" $" !"@ ! ' & /%5 # * ! (%%R / % *"R ! # &" - @% R %,- ,& # 5 # $" - @% R %,- *"R ! # &" & /! *%5 !, ' (@- ," ! % R 0 " @ % &" " *"R ! # &" 5 #@ & / ! *%5 / "!- @% R %, S0 % !(@ "! & @ $" + ' $" / *%# $("# @ % * / $" % !%@% # &% %#+ t€ifmkƒpt & R ! '" # % !"@ &" , & !%* *"@ . ! ) " *" # %' , R!- , & % & #!- 0"# $ ("#(@ , & 876 & "# /!- *"@ ) *% &!„ up~fcti¡dpt & R !%- @% # &% %#- @ !+ &" !% ! # /& + ! 0 *) # 37- 8634 %&'()(*+,- ./012, Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1066 Page 26 of 27 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 45678793:;3 <=>?@?ABCD EFGHIC Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-1 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1067 Page 27 of 27 KLMNOPQRSTRUVPWX YUZ[\ wLxN\ ‡Z\ ”S\ w›œLSN\ ]^_`ab^cd]ef^^dghdijklmdn]ef^^hgh]^_`ab^opqrfshtfuv yzpbqra{cd]_ ^_}~_bd€cd€‚dƒ„‚d…† ˆ_b‰Še‹cdŒpq^Š‰dhŽd__dg__b‰^Ždˆ_q^cd‘aezab{dhŽd’‰a‰rdˆaa‹bŠqz‰a‰Žd“_}Š‰tcdŒfz‰ _{}fp^zcdyhdjab‹Žd]^_ z_‰d•a‰tŽd] _‰e_bd’}rpbŽd–a‰Š_dgaŠ‰rfŽdŒpr{d—a~Š‰fuŠ^˜Žd ]Š}f‰d]a‰rfua™†fqz_‰~_btŽdˆab}_{_bcdŠqf‰Žd]ŠbŠ‰_d]z_~a{aŽd_u{cdŒ_‰‰Šš_bŽd “_‰^s_cd’ptpq^dijklmŽd—f~Š‰qcdŒ_ššb_{dijklmŽd“a~Ša‰cd]abazdˆdijklm †††ž†qhddšff`™p Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦§ §§ ¨©¤§ª «¤¬¢­¤¢®§£̄§¡¢°¤¬®±²¢̄ª§® §¯­³¥¤­¤¢®§®©¤§³±¬®¤̄£´§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®§¢̄§±µµ ¬°±¢µ¤§¶¯®©§®©¤§µ ¡¬®£́§®¤¢®±®¯«¤§±³³¬ «±¥§ ±®§®©¤§¥±£®§£®±®¡£§µ ¢·¤¬¤¢µ¤¸§§Ÿ ¡¥°§¹ ¡§³¥¤±£¤§¥¤®§¡£§²¢ ¶§±£§£  ¢§±£§³ ££º̄¥¤§© ¶§¹ ¡§³¥±¢§® §¯­³¥¤­¤¢®§®©¤§¶±¯«¤¬§ ³¬ «£̄ ̄¢§¢̄§³±¬±ª¬±³©§»§ ·§®©¤§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®§ ¢§¹ ¡¬§¤¢°¼§§½¾±¬±ª¬±³©§»§³¬ «°̄¤£§®©±®§¿ÀÁÂÃħµ ¡¢£¤¥Å§ÀÂÀÂÀ§µ ¡¢£¤¥Å§ ¬§ ÆÇÈɧµ ¡¢£¤¥§­±¹§°̄¤¢®¯·¹§µ¥±££§­¤­º¤¬£§¶© §¶£̄©§® §¶±¯«¤§®©¤§³¬ µ¤°¡¬¤£§°¤£µ¬º̄¤°§©¤¬¤¢̄§±¢°§º¤§³¬ ­³®¥¹§¬¤­ «¤°§ ® §®©¤¯¬§µ ¡¢®¬¹§ ·§ ¬ª̄¢̄Åʧ±¢°§¯®§³¬ «°̄¤£§®©±®§³¥±¢̄®¯··£´§µ ¡¢£¤¥§¿¶¥̄¥§³¬ ­³®¥¹§°¤«¤¥ ³§±§³¬ µ¤££§· ¬§ º®±¢̄¢̄ª§±¢°§ ° µ¡­¤¢®¢̄ª§£¡µ©§±§µ© µ̄¤§®©¬ ¡ª©§±§²¢ ¶¢̄ª§±¢°§« ¥¡¢®±¬¹§¶±¯«¤¬Ȩ̂˧§Ì£§®©¤§ª «¤¬¢­¤¢®§°̄¤¢®¯·¤̄£§¢̄°¯«°̄¡±¥£§® §º¤§ ³¬ µ¤££¤°§¡¢°¤¬§®©¤§°¯··¤¬¤¢®§³¬ «£̄ ̄¢£§ ·§®©¤§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®Å§±¢°§£®±¬®£§® §­ «¤§®© £¤§³¬ µ¤££¤£§· ¬¶±¬°Å§¯®§£̄§¯­³ ¬®±¢®§ ®©±®§¶¤§²¢ ¶§ÌÍ̾§º ®©¦§½±Ë§¶©µ̄©§³±¬¤¢®£§±¢°§µ©¥̄°¬¤¢§° §¢ ®§¶±¢®§® §­ «¤§· ¬¶±¬°§¡¢°¤¬§®©¤§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®Î±¢°§ ¢̄£®¤±°§¶£̄©§® §¶±¯«¤§®© £¤§¬ª̄©®£§±¢°§¬¤®¡¬¢§® §®©¤¯¬§ŸÏÏΣ §®©±®§¶¤§° §¢ ®§¢̄±°«¤¬®¤¢®¥¹§³¡®§®©¤­§¢̄§±§³¬ µ¤££§®©±®§ ¶ ¡¥°§£¥ ¶§° ¶¢§®©¤¯¬§°¤£¯¬¤§® §¬¤®¡¬¢§® §®©¤¯¬§ŸÏÏЧ±¢°§½ºË§¶©µ̄©§³±¬¤¢®£§±¢°§µ©¥̄°¬¤¢§¶£̄©§® §³¡¬£¡¤§®©¤§³¬ µ¤££¤£§ £¤®§· ¬®©§¢̄§®©¤§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®Å§£ §®©±®§®©¤¬¤§£̄§¥̄²¤¶£̄¤§¢ §¡¢¢¤¤°¤°§°¤¥±¹§¢̄§¤¢±º¥̄¢ª§®© £¤§µ¥±££§­¤­º¤¬£§® §­ «¤§ · ¬¶±¬°¸§§Ÿ±¢§¹ ¡§³¥¤±£¤§µ ¢·¯¬­§®©±®§£¡µ©§±§³¬ µ¤££§£̄§º¤¢̄ª§°¤«¤¥ ³¤°Å§±¢°§¥¤®§¡£§²¢ ¶§¶©¤¢§¶¤§µ±¢§¤Ñ³¤µ®§®©±®§¹ ¡§ ¶¥̄¥§º¤§±º¥¤§® §µ ¢·¯¬­§½³¤¬©±³£§ ¢§±§¬ ¥¥̄¢ª§º±££̄˧¶©¤®©¤¬§¢̄°¯«°̄¡±¥§µ¥±££§­¤­º¤¬£§¶£̄©§¤¯®©¤¬§® §¶±¯«¤§®©¤¯¬§¬ª̄©®£§ ¬§ ® §³¬ µ¤¤°§¡¢°¤¬§®©¤§±ª¬¤¤­¤¢®¼§ § ¨©±¢²§¹ ¡¸§ ÒÓÔÕÖÕ×ØÙÚÛØØØØØØØØØØØÜÝÞßØàáØ J Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-2 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1068 Page 1 of 2 1 2 3 4 MICHAEL M. MADDIGAN (SBN 163450) HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP 1999 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 1400 Los Angeles, CA 90067 Telephone: (310) 785-4727 Facsimile: (310) 785-4601 Email: michael.maddigan@hoganlovells.com 5 6 Attorney for M.M.M. Plaintiffs 7 8 9 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 10 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 11 SAN DIEGO DIVISION 12 13 14 M.M.M., on behalf of his minor child, J.M.A., et al., 15 Honorable Dana M. Sabraw Plaintiffs, 16 v. 17 Jefferson Beauregard Sessions, III, Attorney General of the United States, et al., 18 Case No. 3:18-cv-1832-DMS 19 Defendants. 20 21 Case No. 3:18-cv-428-DMS Ms. L, et al., Honorable Dana M. Sabraw 22 Plaintiff, 23 24 25 26 27 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES v. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al., Defendant. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS’ EMERGENCY MOTION TO REQUIRE IMPLEMENTATION OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Case 3:18-cv-01832-DMS-MDD Document 77-2 Filed 10/10/18 PageID.1069 Page 2 of 2 1 Upon consideration of Plaintiffs’ Emergency Motion to Require 2 Implementation of Settlement Agreement, it is hereby ORDERED that Defendants 3 implement the terms of the parties’ settlement agreement immediately, prior to final 4 approval, for class members who execute the notice and waiver form approved by 5 the Court. 6 7 IT IS SO ORDERED. 8 9 DATED:_________________ 10 ______________________________ 11 The Hon. Judge Dana Sabraw 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 H OGAN L OVEL LS US LLP ATTO RNEY S AT LAW LOS A NG EL ES -2-