,?i'f'ifh,

a; 1.5% naps. RTMEHT
Gil-ma ?ab-I) Duputy (?erttmissinnen Legal Matters
93? em ?ne Peliee Piasa. Rnnru 14th}:

New 't?nrlt. H?t" itittfit't

Fehruary 2. Ztilt}

Attn: Leeai Department
intlti Ampitheatre Parkway
Mt?iuntain View. vanes

Re: DWI L'hee lipeints Pested te Willi: Mehile Applieatien

Under the Visinn Zern initiative. New ?r'nrli {?ity is endeavnring tn eliminate
trat??e fatalities hy rnad ennditinns. ereating. safe passages t'nr pedestrians and
hieyeiists. and wherein: laws tn enennrage driving. Paraninunt tn the 
nt? this initiative is the New ?r'nrlt {?ity Pnliee Department?s ent?nreement nt' the
Driving. While impaired laws. The is signit?teaht resnurees tn
DWI enfnreement. ineluding the use nt?vehieie eheekpnints the eity.

This letter serves tn pat ynu nn nntiee that the H?t?l?D has heenme aware that the
Waite Mnhiie applieatinn. a enmmunity-driven navigatinn applieatinn nwned hy
finngle eurrentiy permits the puhlie tn repnn DWI eheeltpnints thrnaghnut New
?t?nrlr. ['ity and map these lneatinns en the applieatinn.

?eenrdingly. we demand that fitsigle upnn nt? this letter.
immediately remnve this funetinn t'rnm the Waste applieatinn. Further. the H?r?l?D
requests that ti'inngle take every preeautinn tn ensure that data nt' H?t?l?D
DWI eheehp-nints. nr any ether suhstarttiaily similar data. is net uplnaded nr pnsted at a
future time nn the Waste Mnhiie applieatinn. gt'sigie.entn. ISharpie Maps. nr any nther
assneiated internetrwehsites. nr weh pnrtals and platinum under {inngle its
partners?. nr at'?liates? 

individuals the lneatinns nt" DWI eheehp-nints may he engaging in
eriminai ennduet sinee sueh aetinns enuld he intentinnai attempts tn prevent and-"nr impair
the administratinn nt" the DWI laws and ether relevant eriminal and traf?c laws. The
pnsting nt'sueh int't'irmatinn t?nr ptihiie ennsuruptiert is sihee it serves In
aid impaired and intnsieated drivers tn evade eheelipnints and enenurage reekiess driving.
Revealing the lneatinn nt' eh eekpnints puts thnse drivers. their passengers. and the general
puhlie at rislt.

New ?r'nrit ['in has a eeru tuleranee peliey fur metnrists engage in reckless
eunduct that endangers public safety. The 1arill pursue all legal remedies tn preyent
the eentinued pasting at this irrespansihle and dangereus and will enlist the
eueperatinn nf nur ether law ent?ercetnent partners and felleur agencies tn assist in this


This letter is put intended as an eshaustiye statement at uur pnsitien in this matter
and shall he canstrued as an at" any fact. as a 1araiyer at" any ut?
the City 's legal rights and remedies. all nt" 1which are hereby espresst reserved.

Sincerely.

Ann Frunty
ductingr Deputy ['nmrnissiuner
Legal Matters