Stacey Garrett Koju (til-'1) Bis-6350 Phone 687-2204 Fax skoju?honeiawxom l't'liruuly I3. Sharon linen ticuln iltittrd hut .\iicntton: . \leiropoiitatt Hoard til'l?ttl'ilic Izdtteutton ?oil; lh'ansl'ord cutie IX Re: Rex iv? of Policies and Procedures Report and Recommendations mini-t tit-:vr MENT Dear Hoard lembers: We mutlt?l like to thank you for entrusting us to review the iV?Ietropolitan Nashville Public Schools or the "l)istrict") Policies, Procedures and Practices regarding, l?itle VI. 'l'itle \'ll and Title lX claims and investigations as well as other legal matters that are unique to educatitmal institutirms such as During the course of our review. we examined ail current Board policies relating to. employment issues as well as a random selection of investigatory tiles representing investigations conducted by the MNPS Human Resources Department that took place over the last several years. As requested. we also met with and interviewed over l?orty (40) stakeholders within MNPS. I. Privilege Issues What hollows is our report and recommendations related to the issues identi?ed in the Request for Proposal. As requested, we have delivered our report and recommendations to you in an attomey-client privileged document. We would like to point out that the Board of laducation Specifically requested this communication be sent as an attomey-client privileged document; therelore, the Board 01' Education would need: to vote to waive any privilege to this document. No individual Board of Education member should release or discuss the contents of this documentation to anyone without a lormal Board of Education vote waiving the attorney- clicnt privilege. However, realizing that this is outside our engagement in this matter. we would defer to your legal counsel?s advice regarding the privilege issue. Nonetheless, we would underscore the need for thoughtful deliberation and discussion before waiving the privilege, should you choose to do so. as it could waive all privilege associated with our review. ?ll Iininn Kiln-Hi Quit? \lnuhl.i la- r'ilu 'unlr-r Ntlulthilip 172'.) .. 1 3111111 11:11:23! [1 1111121111 11111-11 [31315121112 I allele 211'1' 111.111e1'. 211312111: 1112121. 11 eiehuled {ewe-111 1122211. 111131-11 current 11'1- i.1-1111111111.1 1211: 11111.11 :3 111111.111 peyltems 331121 others {211322; we, 2 111; .1111.- 1111312132 131122121: 5 punided 2.111 1111111111- 1:32 13121121311113] 5111-1111: e11111 111 1e {21111214232133 5 13132113135 re?ect hes-3t 3321.11 1.1211512 11:31-31:11. UT 1. 311'12331121131-1211112 1113211215 .111 1211. 11151. 5'15 1.11:22 i :1 1 \wu. 1'31111 \Vs: $3131.32 2211212152 2-: 1221. 133111132? 23212.2 111 .511 ?we? 1131111111 12-. 3'1: 1'11 '13 - 22"- 111,151.23 02 "12?12?3 Therefore we .121": 11111 231.211.1113 21 ehdnue 21ft 1111:! {h 13:15:11.! 1.13 1111. deedemmem 1.117111 {1511131111111 is. reqmred VH2 1.1.111? 2151.1. '12. 1' 222521;. 2.2311211 1:13:11 1121:% %21'311 '1 31-1111 1331311111211'3113 1"3?1 111213311111111152;111:112 1351.11.11 that "1:11:11: e'omphteel Tee-1111111? 51.1?2 11:117'1 the111~11 5153151112. 115.113 - - Review 02"1?352 Inve?tigations- 1.2.15 131' 131.151 1'3151313111113115 brought to light 11-1-3111 areas that can he. war in 31re1113?l113e and bring enmisleney 11:: 12111: 11135521041131. precess- ("3131' res/21:13} 1'52 i5; "121?11113225' 111:3 mahsmeney in the-W111; inhalawuoxm 31111:. 11111111131511 by 211172235 2121.11.12 11111511911013 "111121211 "11311121155223. 11131111. 112 2111': :mesleeaemsb use-d DiStriet? . 11151-111422 inmke? re e1f1z1 21313115 1m 1332151111115: summary 23.31'1115.and unwanejatmn 1.111552215115- 30:11:15. 2113111311.: nine 3 1111311gatmns 111111 not 111212241: 1.211551: doeumems at 1321-1211 1.1111131' 11) maintain 5111': 151511112121} 1111211 1.22.111 1.1311151. the: Board 01 2'2 dueanem has - . 1111311211: 1.11 112 11:1 The 12151111111111. 1.1112121132132213 wbh?fd 5215111.] 833612 11131111 11222311111111 11.3.1 1 221.111}. 1.311111111311'5 and 111132122155 225'p1121e1e3 11:1 11.11 1.1 111.11- 11121.31 112 1211'.- 1311 1e1e5 1.3-1: 1115.312 ?lmed 21.1 11 deta?ee. 11331151212 1'32- - 5151mm 1.3112111; 12323311113. 13-?2 eecmmnend- that 1211:5112. forms. 2311:: 1.151511 :15 51 helmewmh 2131'. 11312111111111.3113 Lumpleted b} MNPS 511522, We aehnemledg 11111111011111 1me~1t1eat11m5 1.11.11. 111.1231: 531171115: 1111211111151 3212121 11131111111111: we: reeummeud {hat 22711331: he ei5cd as 111.132.11.1' than at: rigid d1ree113e5 21:21 111113111111131131 Fm" amesnedmrs she-31121.2 113.1115 be: irce. tmmulate. their 1.35331 quesiietns 11111-111211 113.1211: 313111111. 2311.2 pattemx . "111115511130113 dim-111g- an ?we-3111311111131 2' .1111;on Investigator 2211.51. 31:21:; 11250 321.1521111.0115151enev 211 11111115113115 ??32.85. and dueememed 11111-1111; T01 11131251155111.3115 W1: 5:331: 1131-1211111 mvestagdemm when: thee-"32f; 1111211111111 handwn?en 12111135 that new dated and 1.1155 wry. 1132211211 22" not 1mpo~131hle 122.121.11.11112111. 11-1111 11111111311312 those 1112105323121 when they 113131-13 ?gated .. pameularly enneermm, as many 12.111135 {hep-.1501) .whe) 1.131111321325112 ?3171 investtgahcn 1.1121355" - 2.3"th "-?28Ur 1311113131111 21'. is 11131121311211.5211. the. down-1321711317?. 1311121]: :3 {11.151311 has M11222 The". 111121.111: 12.1 121-1215311313 511,11 decantems 33.115 5151:: mudent 111'; 53.112611112321125 and hdnd?mm" 033511211 docur's'aehlduwt 111111111151. 1mm mmesse?; m, - "Lump 211111511111 21.511111131113111] ??22 80mg fume-3rd the-11. deteumemb 112111112121 he, signed and 11151233122221.2215.- .1. 1.. 111. 11111111111111 131' 1.31 1111111111] 11 1'3 1 . .. g3. .1311}. {1233 3.11 331.1. ?331 ?321.131.? ?11 . 1313;}? I If:11??_ "31.131131 333333333 3333 3333333 33333333 33333333 3333 .3315; 131.3!" "333-3, 11E if?, i, 33131? 331. $1.35 $111'13111113111132 [131' 33111113 131$th 1111.11. ?3.1.3133. if; g} .- 333'" 3" 3.3. 3'33 3533 333' 333-3 3,33131i11131111. .. 333.33733533731331133- 3131 1111. 11:3 11111 1.121.: .111 11111111111 5.1.1 111Ia11'11'111111111 3.31/1. . 3333 333333335133113331 3'11: 11111111I1133'd 111111 1.1311111. 1111:11'i'1: 111111.31 1.3111111.- 111 11-: 111.111. 1I111 1.1.11.1 1.11:1! 311. 1111111111. 1111111111, 1111111111111 1p1L111?1L111~3m '1'111 13.1": 3.11.1111..'111'11'1111111 11311111111 -- - . . . . . .. 111 1.111% 1: 33333333 317' 111111111111111I Ihdl 1131,1711 11111. 11111111151111}: 11.1 1111111111.; 131111111 11111111113 311.11. 11.1 111 1:111. 11111.1; ?1111:1131 1111.11 1.111131311111131 3.11.111 1.11 I111. :11 .1111 1111111111111 (mic: 1311' 11.111.11.111. 1111'! .11: 111.111 1.111 .1111: 31333 13313:: 33 33 .13? 1131.11. 51111111, 11 3:11: 1.1411 1:311 11.11 11111111111131.1133 11311111 . m. .111 11111-171: 11.1.1.1: 11.11.1111 11:11: 1111: 11111131 11:111.. 1.1111111131113111 and 111 11.111311 .111; 3.11.1 1111. .I 111131-11 1113111111 I1: 111111.. 11.1 11.1111I1 I111 [11111.1 1:111. 21 11111131111111.111111 {11.111111 11.11;: 1:15;. .11111111111111'1111111 111111.111. 111 11.111311 11.11 11111111122111.1111 .11 11:1 1111:: 11131111111 1.11111 1.11.111 I11 11,111] 1311111 [112111111 I 33; .-- Lmnioms 211111.33 1112131 1.11 3111391 111.11: 11111.11111111111] 1'11. 11121111111 1111111.? .111111111 1311111111111: 01.111111: 1.1.1 111.. 1111:111ga111111 it- 11131311111 IhuI 1.11113}qu 111.11.. 111111311 1.11 11111111311111.113113 11:13.1 111.111 p11} 111111211151: 11d; \111111Ialc11 111111111. 11.11 11112 11111111111111: 1'11 11.111111.? 11} 13111131131131: 111.111.3111}: 1.1.1.1. 1111' 1111141111111 1111 ?121.11? 1111911 1111111111 311111 1111- h131' 81111111111111 Imam-11.1 (1.11.11: Amaniated 49 SI 111111.21 1111.11 111'. (11.111111111113111 111 . 131.1111. 1111111111111 I 11.131111111111111 11:11.er shall b1. 1.111. . 1' 11111112 1111: 1212111111: 33113313351 11111111111111.2131? its 1.161111111111111 Ihc: ?In; 5&11111113 1'11. I I 1151 111111 1515' 155*?0 5} Ni. 5?15 ?f _4 1, W1: 11111 51 11-1 11.1151 1-111;- 1111 111111 1111115?111 @11511-11-2111-1113 55555 . . --. .5: . - . $1511.11. *1 wii?g?: ?53 $1.51, 551'1 ?5155; 3115?? I I it?? 25? .- .. . .. 111111111115115 11111111111111.1111? :11 3*I111111g11 (?rii?cat 1111111111111 1:111:51 11111551111911 -- 8-1.: 11151111 1111i 1111 :17 111'": 1111.1111255 11111555111131? - 11.111115 11.1. 1111111111 111111112111 1111111111111 111??! 5111111 P5d__ 11.1- 1 1- 1:11. 115 1111 11111111511.111151111111111 111111.. 51113111. 5111? 11'111111115111. 151111111. 15111 ?3.11111? 1511;. 11.11.11.511. I 1.1.2.11 11511111111111 111 55111111 11111:? ?51-55-97?. 111 511111.11111511- 111111 1151111111 1111111111151 1.: 111:? 1511. 5115?1157?5111 1 11 1 11:11 511111 1'15 51111 1311 111355111 ?5151.11: 51:1- 151' 11.111111111515113 1:111:1155111511?11 31-? . . :1111 11.1. 111 1.1111115 111111111111 11?: 111:1:111111111111111111 55:1 11:51.11? 1111.11151511-151- 1? 1111:? 511111111115 ?15?15?8 1114:1131): 1511;: {11.11.1111 111 11.111111211111111. 111.111.511.111 1:1: 1:111:15 1:111: 51111.11 '11-'11 1511.11.11 121111 1111111115 thipuuienw 1:15 11111 11111111111331: 12111515511555 511 11-11 1111.. 1.511151. 1111111 1111.11 ?115 1.11511: 11.11511: 13: 1.1.11: 111.111.1215 131111151 1.11. 1:1- 51:11; .1. 1113-1: 5 17155 11:11 1111111 1113111311111: 1111111111 131:: paid {hair lull 111111111 11.111511: 11111:: 1:11? 1:51:: 11111111111111" ?111111.111?: ?111*:11. 111.111. 11111111111 11111111111111 31111111111111: 01:11:11.1; 111321111. 11111.- 111551?111 .11 1. 1111111111151: 1111: 11111.5 I 11.111111111111111 that 11:11:11. 5.11: 11111.11 111151 51:15 111111 11111111.. 7 1.11111. .11 1:1 1311.11.13 13.11 II. 1111 l?X??H?ClngiOI?i 121511.11 111111161 1511.111 151:. 111111;. 11-1'1111. 13111pi111L1. 1111111111-11111151311111111 1111115111111 {1111 I11. 11.11.1511. 115 1511;; :11: 1:111:11?: 55211131111113. 31111112113111111 ?1?11 :1 15111111111611 13111311111113 1'11 13111111311 1115111111111111111137I131111: 111-1131111311: 1-11: 1 '11 1111 111111111115 5111? 1.51an 115 11111111111111 the. 11111311111? (1t 111.511.11.111. 1511111111 113111111111 :11 51:11:11. 11-: if 11113131 1.11 11.111.511.11? I 1111151111. 1511:; 111.1101: and 1111: 11.1-1111111 5111711111.. 111111111. 111-. 1111.1?. 1111:} 1:11: 1:11 55} 111131.11-111111111 151.111.1111 1111111 11111111111311 by 1511.. I 1.111111131111111:- 115 5.111111111111211? 53111311111. 11.111111111111111 1311111111111; 1131 11111111111: 80111.1} 11111311111111 11111111111 11:1 111111 17111111111111. ?11 111111.111. 11111121111211} ?1111111 111111111: 31:11:11: has 111111.111 11111111. 1111151 1511111 1111111111.. 11111.! 1111111111111 11 11111111? ?1.131111 11111111111111.1111?: 11.1111: Haggardmg, mu 35111011111111.111113111311 11:1 1111p111d 1111111121111 p111: 1111511.! ?11111111111511.1111- 22.22.222.222 Om 22.00122222212212222022 222-- 22212 22.22.: 22 that 22222222222222.2222 2212222222322122222 2.22 2222.2! 2222 2hr: 1223232222222 2222 r2." 3 (?52322; 32121L11L22 2222222222. 12:22 32.22:. 2222 21222 ?2.22 - 3:222 22' 3 7227722 722 22222222022222.22 22.2.2? 1222:2222 - 3 22 22.22- 22:22 .2:22222.22_ 522.33- r225, .22 222 22222 2222222. 222 2222' 222222 .7727 2?2: 232 ?333332 - 12-22237 2222222222222 3'3 33. 27 2 22222222222322 .2 22222222222212 233212 (2711221: 1277) 7222 222222232 ?2'22 22-222. 222122 22:22 3.722 222 222.22.. 22.22.2222 222222.22222122222222 22.222222222222222 2222i 73-3.. 22 :7 727-722 2772 277727272 3 722222.22l222212 322' 2:2 2.12.222 2222222 22222 2222222322 222.222. 2:22.222 222.: 333?- 222223?. 2.22.22. 2:32. 222.2 122222222212 2:322? 2222222122222 2222222222, 2327 22322222222272? 27722 _f ?7-77 7 777' 7 777227 777' 737-7 32772122122. 2.121212222222211 1212222222222 2:22 2.222222622222222 i 222 22.222222; 2222. 1222212222 22.2122 {2222222222222122?2222 121222.221222. F22: 7- 22.22 22222227 222.2. 2222222 2.22:- 212122.: . 2.222.232. 2.22.2.2 2.222222 2.2.2 22222222 .1322- 1122222; 221222322222 22222.22. 2122?: {232.1272 2222.222: 222d 22 222232. 2 222272.222 2.22 222.22 22222.22. 2122.2121222222242222 22222222122 22222222 32222222.? .2- 72an2222 2:22.2232222227 . 3 22222222.: 2hr; 22126222922222 2232.21.22.22: 1:322:33 22.22 $22.22;} 222.22.? .222222-222?222 222 2.2.2.2222 221' 222222122222, 222221222222 'lH? 2222;);22222152 2222222 22:22 2222 c2222222222222222;5711 7- 7222. .3737 :22 2222222222.: 22.22327522;; 222222222222 2222222:- 2222222222252.222221222 7222222722.: 22.212223322232222122?11 222022122122 22,212.22 remind 252222222221 22222222224222222 22.2.2222}; 222-27?- 32? 22.2.1232? 2.2222222 23222232222232: 22222.2 b.2222 21222222112222222 22.222.222.222: 23221222222322 22222.22: 222232.79 3 72.222232222222222 2.21222 13224222122252 Act 2 22112227 222 22- 122.2 222.12. 2212222212222.? 2221221222 722222222227 12:22:31.; 22.2 7'2 7?2 2 22221222222, .2272- 222222 22222222: 32522222222 1222222222. 2212.222 222 2-221 22222222222222222 2222' 222212222: :3 222222. 22:2 22.221.22.222 222222 than" 222pu2212~202 222222 "[2222 22222222222 {41.232223221222222 2.2222222222222222. 22.2 21222222222 3'3 22222. 222.2 2222212210225 22222221222223.12wdcd 2222.22222222. 2122:2222 12.22.1222 - - -- - -- - -- 3 3 Training Needed fur T222222: ?21222! 222121 (1221291232222; 1222 22.222222222222222 3 . 22.2 22 2.222222212222222 77772792272227 22222. had 222112. 2122.3 [2322123. 2221122221 2232212122. 2222 222322 ?20 2.2.2222 5__m2222d.2222r 2222122221 222222.32222221022 2222222222.. 2222' all 232222202222 22122.2 2222221211 be Mahdi: 222227222222221'2 2222221112 [21 22222221222. 222.2222 22:: b2: 2222322222221 2222-2122. 2222231222? 2.22 2222212 (2222.22 22222 2.21" 2.22.2 the 2222221222 221 222322- 31$ 113511. :1 11111 11113111: 1111:1111 (1:31: . 12:13:33.1? ?1121:: 111:3- 18:21:11: ::11111 1311::111139: :13: ?1:11: 3* 11::1 1mm 313:. 11133111.: knit-1:131" 11:31:: 13:13::3311: 3:31:31 w: :1 11:11: 111:. {:1111111 1) 1:31. 1111:1311 1.11:3:1131m1: 1111-51: 1:1 31.11110 11:1; 1.313. 3:111: 1.12:7 1 111:: 11:11-11:11 11::3'31101111: 131 ?111 11310110119111 1: 11:31:: 1:32.: .. 3. 5' a; 111:: 11:. 131' 1111: ::mwm amen: unplanm 111:: dawn: 1 3:11:11 1:11:11 :31 ::31?111?12111112111031 madman": :11113113111: . - 1 ?gnaw: 3:111:11 W1 111:3 1111's: 10:: 1110:1111. 11:11:: 1:11 1:11.11: ?1:33:11": 1:3: 1:311:21? 1:11:12 manual: :31 111:3 :1 1 21.1111 111:. 1111311113 13101313153, 13: 11311131131113112: 1"11:. 11:11:?: 131:1?: 51111113341 1111; :31 and 10131111111111: :13 :13: :111111111341 39:13:1111143 1151:: 11:13:11: and 11:13 131131: 11111131111111.4111?: .13 '31::3311-11 7- 13 ?315,118: and Cancer-:3: With 1111: Huang i?rmcas 1:113:34. 1131111: prmupdh 111111 wmmumw ::1punn1cndent: 1:11:13 11::1: and 11:11: 1111111,: 111:: 11:31:: 11:11:11111311311131?1 111:. 1:111:11: pumam 11:1: am}: mad 111:. 13:32:11 111111: 1:111 11:11:11:d 1:31.111: 3131311121111: :11: 11:1: 1511:: 1:13: ::1111 1: 13:11:: :31 11:31:11, :1111::..d by 1.13:: 111331111: Dwannunt Sam: :31 manna: "-_ifj 11:1: and 2:11:11; pinceas 11:11:11 01.11:: Lemma: 21:13:: (11:31:13.:1 111 '3 111:. prmupdl: w: :pukc' Wuh 111111 1:31:11: 111:}: 1311:1121 331%me 1111.]: 11:11:11,, muttnmaj-dd?um 1:31:11: 11.111113: 11:: 17111113113111: 111m 11:31:: :11. 111:: 21131311: _Entsj $1111.13: 111:: 1:1 ::.mml ::wamwn: 11:11:31?: ample: 11:: 1:11 1.11:: 11:3 1:11: 1:11: 11:1: 13:11:31,131 mdmalw 11:31.1 13:11:: 111:. unreal. magmd 13:11:13: pampemw 1131:1141: 11:11:13: :11 prim 4 14441441444 4441144444 19444441414441 14.444.144.444 I I 4.11 444444 144444 4414,, 444441 . 44444.1 1444;: 44414. 4444444 .43 144?4?4?4" 41111 ?41141 1144414. 411 4444 444444 444 4444 4444 44444: 444 1'44 4'41: :44444'444 1444 4'4 4 4.44.4 41341144444.44441 w444444144444; 44144144":- 4114444413} ?41.414. 4144441414 1134.41 14.1 1114414114 441" 4 .. .. . 441444244 5114.114 14444444?: 44414 44444141444143111'1?14414344 44144.4"? .11 1?91: 44:41-41:44: 4444;, 4444.14 444 4.444.444.43- 1444444444 14444444444444. 44444.1 44:44.44 .44.. 1'4 44 4144. 4444444444444 44444314343444.4441 4:134 514114.441 141-1411 144.4" '4 444.44 444 44.444 441.44.144.74 44444494444444. 14:41.1 1744 4144414444. 4'41 4:444:14 44 L1?w 14444444144441414 44144144, 41444144. 11444.44 4:441 144444414- H4ri_g 444 4444414344444444444411'4 144411444 4.414444444444144 411444 144.44 43?" 1.111444. I 4.4 14411?.44444p1.444.444 4.41 11144441114441.244441 14444444441 4.444.144.4444 4.44 4444. 4.3444444 4.44- . 44:44-44:44: 1 ;44444-44141' 44.414444. 1144': {444144.444 arid 14:44; '4 44.1.4444. 41.4.4. 3.444 (4'44 444.44.44.41 database: 1112.41 4144': 41:41:41 1434-14141?. 4144.41: . . 1 144444444444 4114.41 4444 44:4:41444141 14410444444114.4444 414444}: 44434241 44: 1.44: 444144.41 44414.4 444144.41 41' I 4441444444 444 444414.: 14:4 14441414440414 44114.4 411' er44p1444444c444 ?14144.4 4:44 114444 44444444 1144.44. 4' 44.4 4.44444"44.4.444444 4:14.44. 44': 444444444:4.411b14. 24441144344. 44443441441 43.410444 44444.1 4.444444444444444. 444.411 4444.444 4.44 21:14.4, 3 1.44414. 4417'- 4444444443 111 844me 11414414114444 (44441441444144, 14: 144344444 4411-4.4441444: 1144: 44441434414 441 1144. 14mm: 14414.4 1314444. 444434 1144. 4444444444.: 44444441144 44444.1 .44 41 .44 444444. - .. 4444. 4344414 44444 144.431.4414. .444 4144.. 1144444444 1114444414444 44441444 4444.. 44.441344444414414. 14:44 444444 144414. 1.4.4.1? 441' 444441144444 614441444 44444441444441} 14.444.114.45 4344111 regatd 14:4 44114.44. 444441 4444144444. 4:14.444: 4444341444 4:4. I '41? 14414. 44444444.. 441 114 4.4444 14': 4114413441411 14: 11445 114444. 41 444144.44 444 1 145.1%, - . 44444.1 1444441414. .4444 .4pp1444444444'4 {444444.444 4.44 444414.41 44144344: 11. 44:14:34.: 114444 1144': 4444443444444 441 . 4441444441444 4144.. 1444.14 4.44 3444444144.: 4114444144444 441.. 4144144.: 444411 14344144444441441114444 444414414114 1444444444131 5, 11441444444444.4444 11444144.: 414.444 (4444:4444: 441144.; 4.4444434? 44441414434444 14.4 hpw?h 1'1, (144.44.14.41 114.44 44441 144444 4444;410:4344 444144.414] 1:44: .- 3" 11444.4 4144.44.44.45. 4'44 14.4441 4.4444. 441 1144.: 44444141444444.4444 44.44pm I I 41414444: 114444 1444444441 444411444441 444444 4444:4449: [4414441414441 1444 144.: 41441 1344.4, 414.444.4444 4444 44441444441414: 44444444114444 1444' prmupdl 4444.1 4.444414. 444441. 4441;461:441; .13-: "171131-11 33 11111 11.1 111111111 1113 1111!; 13 I II 11.! 11131._ 133.1II I 1311 I333: 3. I I I 1 11313 3111 11: 33'1113111311311111 .I- 1. 13131 111 33' I1 1 1111311. 1-1l :11 I 11111111 ?33313313 33 311111111- 11111113111 [)11111111311. :11; - '3 131111311111111 131111 1113111111113 Immnmu? in 11111-111 1122111?: 111': 1'11 1:313 . 93' 1 111111121151 1113111 11111111111. 111 1311 111,11 - 11;. 13111 11II1111113 11111111113 1111. 1111111111111: 113' :1 I11'1113111hn'1. 111331111 1311': 3311.. 1 1111,1113 311111. 11111111111111: .111- 1111111' 1111111 1111 31113111 1:13 1,111.31 1.1131131 111111111 311:111111111111311111 11131111111111!? upmaaed 131111 3111111 11611: 1111;311:1311: f3; :1 111. 1.1111131 1.1.1 11.311111] 3'1: 1.11: {11 p11?: 11- 1111131111' 311 1311 13311311111111? 1131' 1111111 11.1 . 111 1311: 1311111 1:1 I1112111311n: 111111 3311111 11.111.311.11 3111111111311. 11.131111131111111 3111.1. 111.3 111111111131 11111:? 31111113135; pungdun. 11.111313 in 51111111111111 1111311111: :3 11,111,311: 1,1, 111.13 1:13 3-11 1111 31 1111131 ?13111111113111: 111311111 3111110111111: ?113 1111111: 1111.111 1'11 1.1111: 11131131, :1 11:1 11: 11.111.1111111 3:71: 111111 1:111 1111.111: rumlar 111111 1311113131: 1111131311113 11:1 11113111 111 31111 1' 1131311. 13331111111111 1111?} 11.51 171111111pr - .1 B, 3 0111-11111 -. 3311: 13111113711111.3111 1132111 1.11411111ch 11.11.11. 111111111111 agardmz 31211.1( 1.13 1:1 11:11:11 111p11r1111111'x and 1311:: 11111111111111.11111111 Dag-1111111111: 1111. 1011111111111 1'5 11111131111111 prmupdla. and 1311:3111 11111111111111.1111? 51:11.33 This 1.0111111111111331101?1 11.1111. 111111171 121-13" 131111.113 311d pmwdurus agardmg 11111131151 2,111.31 1111 1111111131111: .11II?j??-fj' {11111111131111 but ?13313 rewarding: 111111413 day [31111111131 agardmg 111113111111 111111 1111;111:111: ?3.3.1.1111 131.11. 111. 11111111111111 Indicakd 13111.1 1311.11: W111: numeral 1111.12111101 111 1111111111 13113.. 111111.131"! 111111 11:1? 1311.1 17131111. 111: 1131311111011 has; but: 11:) 11.11;; 3311131 . I 13:11:11 1111131: 11113131111115 happen?d 1111111111g ?12131 131311131113 11nd Lhar. 31161111111 12111.11 111113111: 1311. Human 33111101111135 Dmartma?? Th1. 11111111111111 11113111311133, 11nd 11111111131: of 3161111111111111111111111 pmblem related 1111311. 1133' 5222222 2112 11 11 :2 1. 2:2 2.217211 2. 3 .1 - 21211 2.: . 12 221.7." 21-12:. 121. 12112221'2722'22211111' 211222222222. 22222 21222222 1.2? . 12 1 1.1.1222 222.122 221122 11.1.2222 22 2 21222.1 1212:2111 22 -. 22. 22222222122122 2:21 2221 122121212121 21.222212211221212 51:3; 2 2222222221 22221121212. {22. 1111222112212. 1.112- 11,122.. 2:11: 1222.22. 221 2.221211121221222111212 22.21:- f-g 2'2 1211222 212 2: 2:11 12.2111 111 1.01112112111C1 221121.11 222.22 22.222.22.12 12:2 - 2221212221. '22 1.21111121112122121111111 1122222222121 .2211. {112.222.2222 1'22: 2222:1122": 222:; 2111 21.112211221211212 121. 1-1122 2212:111 ?22123211123211.1222 .22.. 12.22.2112 ?222122 2222: 32191122211212?: 222.121.121.222 2.121121112112323 111211 1.0211221 11122122 1112.222: 2.22222. 1:122 2.2 2.2 1 1.121222 12.22.! 222211121 11.223011111161221 212.22 ?1112--? 222111211 22122211223222 2.31272211112111 . {1113151131 21113 1112-11 :30Li1dl 02.21.22 1112;: 221221213 121221 122.113 22.22211 222122222122 .4. 22 2.2 212.. \211211111xtr11221222 2221-21 1122.6 2121122112112123122 12; 22.. 21-2122- 22921212-222: 2112. 22122121221122; 222. 22:22:11. 1.2.1 110111. 21221213112212.1232? 111111 1122122132? 15212231.. 22:33:31; 222.221 2222.: 22112 12.122221122223111 22111 1:11.. 21211121111 11 11221 11211112231131: 22:22 1112. 2212322? ?1.11.222212223221111211'2 22211112122222 - . .. . . .. . . . . tim- ?1 I 13222222122212 P1112 52:21.12: 22222121222 2.222.222 212121122 2221222211 222: 112121221 112111112. 11211 11112122223212, 2111221221 211122.212 222 2222222222 221221 222122.112p121 122.2111 1111: pay 22.2111. that 12: {1121111212. 1112222222 121 2112 11:21:12.1 1 2.125 22212111112. 221.122.1121 11212221112112 22111222212131 that 2 '1 22-21 12212 2:21 1122: 212222 22.22211: 12.22 prmupdl b22221 1:211 thelr 1.211222211121321 2221-21" 213222 1221222. 1122.12 222211 12.2.22 22211222121222: 2.112211 11.222 1.2121 1111111 2121123222. 22.21.2111 W212. mg 22.2 111212112: 2222.2" 1.121 22222 222121222 .2121 12111222212 .12. 212 22211211121 1.2-1: 221212221221 13122; 222.22: 212.22 1.1212211 2221112222 21.11.1122 221112.21'112 1112. p2} 2231112 221122221 2.221. 1112 211 11211121 1I11: 111111: ?13113 1112a aIc. XII-11111: 11111 11.1 11213111111111.1011 1111i 11111.1c11111rc a 111.1di1 1.13111. 1I1511'1'i1'1 1311111I1131c1 3111I1 11.30.1111 1.1111I112j 1:11.13 1.1.1l1 1.31:2 11.111111111111111 1111111cd1a111 C11111i11131 11 131111111 1Ic11: 11111111. :11 1111111111111. 11: 11.11213: 1111:: 11111111311 134111 1111.: 11111111.. 11121111 11.11111: than the 11.1135 5:1:1'1Ic 1'11 '11 11:11:13 1111': 11111111111. 11.1111 1.111.: I113ii111 j111i1I .. 111-131 1-11.11-I1.1 11133111111111, hhnuld 1113 11111111111111] 1:111:11 1.1131111111111111. 1:1:11111i131: 1-:l11111I11 I11: I11111113I11 511111 1.1111111I1a1'111 with 1:111: p33 113-313 11.5: 111111 1h $111.11 113 I11 1.111 11Il111111'11' 11 111.1311111111111113. 1:311:15 I313: VII 1111117111113. 5 Ti 3.11ng f11i'01'Di31'11iSSaI (if 1113131111313 Resources -- Talent btratem - -- - - .. I 111.1113 11,111.11 .15I111I 31111111111 11111111313 1Cg211di11g the. HLIinI'san Rcamircc'; {31111111111111 and 11111111111111: 111th II11 11111110313131 13itI111111c1-113cpti111'1 111111111 1:111:11. 1131.111! 111 111 1311111 {1112111 1'11 the ?11111.11: Ream: 111. 111111110111 expresscd to 1.11: that 1.21113111111: 8111': 1:31.11 1:11 111111111111 111110111111 ?111211131 at 1.111117121111313 diviqivc. 11191111331111. {and 111 111111 1111-1131. 11.111111111311111 I 1?133111 this 1111111101111 the 312111131 '10] 11:11:13 1133116111111: 1:111: 17111156115115. 111 all 111 1I111Ise when: 111: interviewed 1111131111 0f the Human (1111311111111. Dcpar-mcm 111111111111: 5 1111113111111: 15'. 11111 in the education 111131111. and the 13111111113613 5 {11111111113 1111111 1311.13111ah1111 131111 subordinates is. ineffecticv ~With Such 1.1. consistent 1111111111 1111111111 1113:: 1111111 1.1.1.11 1.1.1: believe 131111111 he 11311155 Sif i1 ?21115 I11 address this 1111111111 thmiamh :11111 111th 111111.1d11'au1111 1.11111 1:11.113 respect 101 this. person 111 cure 1111.- 1111311111; 1111112111: 1cchr1: 11:1. 3'11I1'1Ic3911c31. and 131:}: 1.11 111mmu1111..111011 1.36 wauid 11.111111111111111 that. Dr ciihcr 11311111111111 11.113. 131111110311. 111 31nd Ih1s 11111311113136 for ?h?thcr training In 111111.111: that cmpicwe 1.1111111131211101: 1.111115; and ahil it3 10 11.10311 131;: II with others 11111110311: - _Ihi 15'. 111111111 111311.: .1111111'111I15hed thmugh I- Ihis cancihdes 1711.11 111111 11.18.1133 11:1 1111111111 1111111131111 311111-- 3131111111 111111113 1115 the Human 1113301111111 Dcpa1't111c11t a1 VNPS We 311111111 Iii-{c 111 111111: 1111.1 11.11.1113: .11: haw: b13131: tasked with a 1"c'1ie33 10 11131111111111 1.113.315: that 11131111 111111101 111113111 111 1111 11111: 1111111113 1:11.11 1611 1:11 pQIicics and 11100111111135 and 0111 interview 11f 11101131 11.1113 111.1111?: 111,111.11 1-11. 1113111113 21113 111113111101121113 negative 01'11101111311111111 121111111101 I13 13111131031111 \1'13111111 111.31 1111.11 111 1.111; pmhues and 11111111111115. 11111-1?: changed with the 111111 adminlatmtuna 1-1.1: 11: 11111111111311 I [1111-1111 1111131. Changes 111 11101131111183 and 110111.111: Were 1101 ?11131135. 10111111111111.11111 1111131311 11111- 1111111111111 111 1:31.1311111: In I Hunk Hm [in n'rgnm?lp! in lhix survive lilr WC will he available to mmuur wLn?ni In lx?vpnl'l :llh' to maintain attomey- (blunt I?m {Mic that l?sf'illt'fi. \w rcqucs'l ?ml ?1an having questions related to {hr Ram? mu! cuntm?l counsel to discuss thnse implications prior la \?nnlarnmj mm ..'1uccy Qill Samuel L. Jackson Jumcs A. ('rumlin, Jr. h! i any {kr' .