Shrix're #1 item 331581 Type: .SMEIMMS Conversation Start Eate: March 5. 2018 1 3:15:38 PM EST End Date: March 5, 2918 3:23:25 PM EST phone Number: PG. Harry Biack Chat ?uccaunt: Harry Bias}: {811553}: hi, did you meet with Neville Pinto today, or was he here is meei with John? 1} want to make sure we?re an aligned. sinee i had meeting with him last week to Uptawn innovation Cerridor Hm 5am {mam Harry Biack (89.48}? Meeting was suppesad 10 be about the Richard Spencer visit ta UC, bu: baiieve it was canceted. PIS. i saw Pinto walking out of city hail. was East curious if he met with you, or it was a meeting w! Crantey? um 3m: {mar-1; Harry Biack (SMSP Let me ?nd out PACE. (SMSP l?li just cal? Craniey -- i? must have been a meeting with him if it wasn?t with you HUI 3-5? '1 3" no sweat just trying to slay informed Harry Black {+1282} ISMSP Wilt still {anew?up <4 coo? 13:05 13:06 13:25: 13:28 13:2? 13:28 13:28 13:29 Item EB: Type: S?ari 9am: End Bate: Phone Number: Chat Account: 3?161-$ SMSIMMS Canversation March 3. 2018 6:1 9:1? PM EST March 8, 2018 9:0?:22 PM EST Christopher Smitherman .: Wendeii Yaung Harry Black Rocky Mara David Mann Chn?s Seeibach Greg Landsman Amy Murray John Stanley Tamaya Denard 4 Sieve Megane 4: Jeff Pastor at Christopher Smiiherman <4 SMSP, Harry. Black 1? {$338322 Wendeil Wang {5:915 pr! ockv Mar: Jeff Pastor {Emma lamaya Gerrard (8M8 Chris Seeibach SMSP. 9mg Landsman (SEES PIS. ?r (Swap, Jenn Uraniey (SWEEP. Steve Meaerie Amy Munay ?a (SMSP. David Mann (8M8): Harry Black (5543p At approximately 424-5 pm. unis evening the City received ward 18:19 Assisiarzi Poiice Chief David Baiiey has agreed to amicabw part ways with the Cincinnati Felice Department. {thank him far hia many years of dedicated service to the ci?izeas 01? Cincinnati and wish him nothing but the has; in big future endaavcrs. it is expecied that ibis wil! be consummated sametime tomorrow morni?g. Aithough the Law Departme?t has and w?tinue is hanc?e this matter: both the Chief and I are engaged with them. Assuming 1th all goes well it?: {116 meming, the Chief and confer on mad steps with respaci ta inking the vacancy. In that this is an active personnel matten {he Administraticm has no: pmvided any communications to the media. What yen are seeing and hearing is originating {ram 3 source ether ihen the Administratian. W11: keep you posted 85 necessary. Christopher Smither?man - lam disappo?nied with these decisions? i undersiand the 18:52 manager has the power 10 make parserme! decisions by Char-{er but it wouid have been a better decisicn 10 wafer. 1 am considering my options as one member of councii on how to respand. This decision {miy strengthens my conviction that an Executive May-tar Form (If is the right direction for Cincinnati? The manager shouEd expiain how a vacancy would be ?ned if the city is engaged in a separation agreement. The city has expiairzed to the pubiic we are suffering {mm a ?na?czal crisis and ids not see doubts paying far the same position. I wnuld mink City Council wnuid need it) approve an Ordinance. 1 have aiways been very suppc?we of the City Manager but do not agree with this decision. Vice Mayor Wendeii Young 4+ 3 think it [510:3 soon to jump to canclusiuns on this matter. i 19:16 prefer ta anew the City Manager the latitude afforded him by our charter arid support him uniess evidence shows that we Shmaidri?t, I haven?t seen that evidence yet. My {exi message {31095 I101 jump is: any conciusicnis). 11513193 a fact {hat I do not Elke haw ihia; 18 being handied? The charter a?erds council oversight too? Rs. stated above 1 am reviewing my options. 1 am very aware of the Charter Wendell Ynung H151 1 mink it is prudent 10 review your ?piiQ?Q, Ycu may be privy ta i?formaiion i dan?t have? This is aeriainiy handied better than {he dismissai of farmer chief ?lackweii. i can?t figure out whaz is wrong wiih leaving. Perhaps you can hem me see? what l?m missing Sma?rherman ?-1512 SMSP Members of commit were premded ?pubiic? detailed informaiien {mm {he Manager an the wagons ihe manager made his decision. do not think 1 can heip you see what you are not seeing. Rocky Mar: 4 Th3 Manager has asked {hat 1 share the foiiowing with you. As 20:3? thig is an ongoing legal maiier yet 10 b8 fina?zedi the manage; and the chief are pursuing {he recommended terms and conditiens as recommended by the Law department. Th?rs forum perhaps is. :10: the: most appropriaie to be discussing {his matter in that it i3 an angsi?ng #egal matier. As such. I wauld advise you further hare. Wanda Ii 3:1; - 8M 3 if: Good advice; Thank. you. Item ID: Type: Siari Date: End Bate: Phone ?umber: Chat Account: 37?160 SMSIMMS Conversalion March 8. 2018 6:53:06 PM EST March 3, 2018 6:53:35 PM EST Chris Seelbach hm}! Murray 53.6. Cmntev s: .Chrislapher Smilherman Wenoen mung Tamaya Demand Dam Mann ?1 Hefty Black ?4 Jeff Pastor Rocky Mex: a Chris Seeibach <4 Chrisiopher Smitherman Jeff Pastor '01 (SMSP. Harry Biack In (swap. Wemezi Ycung (SMSP. PEG. SMSP, Jenn uraniey a (SMSP. Tamaya {Jenarci c+ (EMS .Amy ?may a David Mann Rocky Mara 4+ th53? (8M8 i agree with Vicw?ayor Smitherman an how shis was handied. Very disappoin?ng item :33: Type: Start {3318: End Date: Phone Number: Chat Account: 31?1290 SMSIMMS Conversation March 8, 2018 7:02:00 PM Mamh 8, 2018 10:20:18 PM EST Harry Black ?2 Harry Biask (Wisp, PS. ?154 (31913? (SMSP Can me in 730 Harry Stack 0k. sm?therman and seeibach are ?ying to make an issue ever ihe Bailey matter PB. (SMSP I tamed your persenai can saying not to taxi back line group thread 3f needed, I think a direct phone much better Harry {Nani-v OK, when? Let me ca? you at YBO. No need to reply before then. in shim, think a direct cat! to Smitherman, mostiy ?ust to hear him out is po??caiiy sman far you 10 do. 91'? fit: 0k Oy way. 568an {1131 part a? Sm?thermen's response is he believes we shouid do away With the of Ciiy Managaar 39:92? 18:93 19.04? aiingeiher! Harry Black Crazy (83318? Arid n01 happening! Harry Biack Urgent 29:0? 20:0? 20:20 22:20 item H): Type: Sitar: Bate: End Sate: E?honc Number: Chat 371201 Conversafion March 9. 2018 9:28:22 AM EST March 9; 2018 11:00:23 AM EST 53.8, Harry Biack Harry Bfack (8543)? Harry Biack Staniey is meeting wiih Cauncil members. Trying to get 5 vntes to take me cm 19.6.44 (SMSP Moi going to happen Just la?ded - . 2.2m mini?; iihink you'li ceme- {hm this in a strengthened position (13kt! Any update on Mann? ?a Haw Black Spoke with him, but not sure where he 13 HQ. ?3533 Wisp Seminels now making was to Gounod in support of you as we?. Everyone springing to assign. Like i said, you?ii come {hm this beater {ban yen started. Harry Black ?1 Thank yaw. 09:2? 09:30 08:30 139133 18:28 10:2? :06 item 313; Type: Start Daie: Ead Bate: Phane ??mber: Chat Account: 3Y1684 SMSIMMS Conversazion March 9. 2018 2:53:33 PM EST March 9, 2018 7:05:43 PM EST RC3. Hairy Biack 4: PIS. *3 (MMSF. Harry Biatk <4 Harry mack (MMSP Harry {Elsie-k ?a (SMSP Met with Mayor a 2:00. Gave ultimatum that i resign 0? he 74:53 initiate a smear campaign against me PG. <1 [3:3 NOT resign. Can can back in a bit. John a?empting a smear ??5230 campaign destroy him The cammunity and. a council maiority are with yam $5150 my. Peupie for you big time. John 6093:??! have the wales 15:33 And a smear campaign will sings him. not you 15:33 caii in a bit ?35:33 4mm Harry 853% 4+ ($314.3? 0% "i 5.33 9.8. <4 if Craniey dirt at you through the Enquirer! having Chief 181??; on record being is great but i think having Rocky suppiy a quote from a community ieader {33? NAACP accusing of attempt to siander you as a black ieader is 3130 good, habit of vengefulness etc .. Agree 8:22 Thai. trams from get (30 importani item EB: Type: Size: Custadian. Direct ?3amn? ED: ms Hash: Emage 3Y1T10 PNG image "2?55 KB (?3,695 bytes} PG Siktenfeid 531.585 G453d?0?358216f8?299?04b371 E3510 Verizon iit?i3 AM tooeew Tweet RS. Sitteet?eie @PGSitteriield Let?s all take 8 deep breath and do what am fellow citizens expect us to do: avoid unnecessary fighting: be respectful at all constituents, and work together to move our city forward. 96. Sittenfeict @PGSitteeleld The positions of Police Chief and City Manager are difficult, complicated jobs; cur current Chief and Manager do them well, and they have my support. all VIEW WEET Ni": ?22m It): ?We: Start Date: End Date: Phane Rumbas?: Chat Accauni: Conversation March 12. 2818 3:56:32 AM EDT march 32. 2018 553:?! PM EDT Harry 8339?: Harry B?ack PG. {8:24:35}: presuming you saw this: Thanks for be?ng conciliaiory with Seeibach; if we can get a quick 3rd and 41h person pub?ciy supportive. while only Smiihermar: is publiciy against you cm the other s?de, win he in geod shape Btw, 231351 caned the Chief direciiy, and he reiierated to me he is in your corner, and believes ihai if you go. he'il be the next to go Harry 8188}: (8:938); Thank youi PAS. 5m} . i believe ynu wit: have 4 Cbunciimembers pubi-iciy summing you by tomorrow; zen) pubiicly against - i} after that, I donbias on you from there with the ether 5 anything new? 2 - 81334: Gail when yau can 08.58 08:5? 18:11 at. 413 Li 18:35 ?3:43 ?ub? item ?E?ype: Start State: E?d ?3319: Phone Number: Chat ?sccauni: size: Custad?an: Sires: Fawn: IE3: Recipient Gaunt: Viaibie Recipient Gaunt: Messag? Count: ?595 Hash: Message Hash: ?r?ginai v?ew 1 page SMSIMMS Conversaiion March 32. 2018 1:05:29 PM EDT March 12.20181:13:55 PM EDT {3.13. '4 Marx PIS. Rack}! Men: (map ?306 bytes PG Sitienfeid 530550 2 2 3 dabe?831?54 QET?OaBEfc?3b1eg??1 592330f56?8d286364 338980236681 1 Harry Biack A: (SMSP, Harry Black a FYL apparently Smiiherman on WLW now 13:06 8?3} can?t listen. but perhaps worm someone from year camp 13:96 doing 89 i {?315. {d 1 . Rocky Marx <4 25133681620 (SMSP Thanks 13118 item m: ?rype: mart Sate; End Bate: Phane hivmber: C?at Account 3?1689 Conversation March 13. 201-8 11:49:23? AM EDT March13.2013 8:57:30 PM EDT 9.6. Harry Biack P13. Harry Eiack ?1 (SMSP Harry Biank H1202 {Smsp Call me We heard from Greg. Dcesn?t summit faring 0r buyout The 5 01' us remain Sogether Harry Biack m? 034, the mayor made statemeni i was not a part of it 9.8. ?+1513 Chambers very iikely wmpleteiy packed with you: supporters tomorrow Harry Black (3553]; Call me Ca? me KG. (4151?- Jusi tried you back 11:49 1?:31 17:32 17:34 18:56 23:5? {tam IE): WW: Star?: Date: End ?3326: Phane ?umber: aha: Acctaum: 31?1592 SMSIMMS Conversaiion March 16. 2018 8:59:98 AM EDT March ?16. 2013 2:46:51 PM EDT 9.6. 4: Harry Black PKG. Harry ?iack 4+ Harry Biack (saris): Just saw him. Looks bad. Den'i mink he can take another week 0: two of ihis PG. 0: (map i?m sure. He?s creaied a personal he}: for himseif. And ?ankly the more he attacks you, the be?er you 190k Hm Harry Biack {Sims}; Agree PIE, <4 again, strongw advise against personnet changes at this time public epinion 0n your side AA ie'adership in the community never mare cohesive ihan in defense of you Harry Biatsk (SMSP Gteet RS. <4 Letter to madia from Council Majmily: March 1'6, 2018 Dear Mayor Stanley City Manager Black. Members the Pubtic. and Members cf the Media: We have waiched this unfortunate saga unfold in recent days. and fee! sirongiy that it is new on us the Councii Majo?ty - it: bring order and a {an pmcess {a ihis siluation. To be clears anyone who wishe$ to bring forward cameras or report miscanduct musl feet safe and camfortable doing so. We activety want your voice to be head. We: 81:30 behave strongiy in due process. No cme?s name a: z'epulauon shouid be iarmshed without there 08:59 09:30 {19:30 69:34 09:35 09:86 091313 ?14146 HIM-36 Eyeing ciear evidence (beyond jusi "he said. she said?) as wail as a fair uppaduniiy for ma indis?daai i0 respond. We share the serious cancers": of arganizaii?ons Eike Urban Leagua? Commun?y Action Aganay, mack Agenda, Natia?a? ?ciim Neiwerk. 8:395: Limiter} From. am when; that pres-em bahaviar is back {ms clock cm rage reiatims ?n cmcinnah; we n81 abei the mienuona! denigratim?i of aneiher biac?c tea-53m in communi?y. We aisa tic; mi supper: {arcing ihe ?axpayers in pay out cf their awn Qackais for wha? is currently a maker: {eiai?anshia We be?eva there are much teatim- ?mmediaie ?ex: steps. Firsi. this ailuaiim cieariy mus? be :59? pantie?i296 and taken cm: of the hands of mega most direc?y Era; ?ne ?09 01 war: merefaw, we are wiring far the appointment an Guiside Special (lounge! (appoinied by a majnriiy sf Ciiy Comma}, 0:31:36! and investigaie Ehe cameras raisad by the wagon any and 35 camienfac?uag {he City Manager. arad testimuny from city emgioyees or any c?her directly involved siakeheiders. This Speciat Caunsei win then wriie a repcari a; be submiited 10 City Cauncii for our review. A: the same: iime, we are ca?ing far a cease-?re betwean ihe Maym and City Managen during which they bath agree it} say math?ng mere can ?ne whim: and to {?30113 0n the C?Ey?s wark. During this ceaae?re, Cmmcii bring in a pm barter: m?diamr to privaieiy heip?ihe Mayer anti Manager navigate their raia?ms?hip and {aim-n is getting things dame far the citizens {2f Cincinnaii. Lasi?y, during 1mg 583322316, we 03% far no persisting! manages. Cou?czi wiil contra! this process as it animals. and if the need and dessre fa: what the Mayor has canned a ?paws ma!" remains, then Ceuncii W?ii matrot the iimei date, and lacaiion of such a ma?a! meeting. Became 01? {he significan? imerast {mm taxman-set} member-s of the community? such a speciain-caiied meeting. would mm: in ma even?ng. be heia? ms: in the community, and be pasted wiih at ?8331 mm weeks name: to the whim. We 300k Tammi} {a can)! heads prevaaiing. mesa issues i it; former City we love Sinceieiy. Tamaya Seward Sitteniaid Greg Yga?g Seeibach Stem EB: Type: Star! ?ats: End ?ats: Phene ?amber: {that ?ccount; 37.5563 SMSIMMS Ccnversation March 39. 2018 10:3?:26 AM EST March 19. 2016 10:38:23 AM EDT Harry Eiack Harry mack 4+ Yea see mis: Apgxareniiy, Smiihefman and Faster wouldn'i vote fur 10.38 terminatim f-md 6cm? we n: ihe ?pub?c iriai? item if): Type: Start Sate: End Ema: Phone Number: Chat Accaunt: 371?? Conversation March 13. 201.3 10:3?t49 AM March 19. 2018 AM EDT ?arry Eiack ?202 Hamj Stack Ni?s mm; mama. Stem ID: Type: $ize: ?ustediari: ?iresi ?arem its: $595 Hash: Image PNG image 813 KB {832,825 bytes) PG Silieafeid 531610 1 get Verizon LTE 16:38 AM @3 E?E?i?o L3 "tweet Cherie Wetterieh @ChrieCinciBiz There isn?t majerity support t9 fire him, includlhg Smithermen and Pastel; who eppase termination. Smithermah also lust said he opposes the concept by the maer at writing a report and calling Witnesses. Magic Wands @Christine ltv?ende @ChrisCinciBiz Fire him and use his original contract severance. Lots cheaper. 3/19/18; AM .31.. "f Tr: a; a Magic Wands Mm Mt It?s: a Shame Ruth Black Shrive- - #2 item Tyge: Siart Date: End Date: Chai Account; 458d 29 Conversaiion March 5, 2013 PM EST March 5. 2618 ?:53:31 PM EST Dwight {Message}: 4 PE {owner} Wanda?! Young? a fame amass? Dwight Tillers? a; Chas $ee?bacGreg Landsman' *1 (Want . 3 . . i gut a'caiitoda'y from Sheiia names Howard who is a realm and attended the meeting {he Realism iasi week. After the m?eiing, Jeff Berding address {he group to pitch FC and mid the group that i was causing the trauma in the W851 End and that 3 was gaging people- ma may {a dmrupi meetings. And Men the qua stion was, ask?ed Wham was the money coming from, he laid them the heait zap". My board chair asked me to share ?this with yaw. Slam: React Read: Magma was mgutmg item ID: Type: Start Bate: End Date: {that ?ccouni: 415321 Chat Conversatio? March 6. 2618 8:33:37 AM EST March 6. 2018 8:21:26 PM EST (Message? Dwighi Tiliery (EMessage)> (iMessageP. RS. 953$ War- That: ?niu?s afar fresh ?ns 5!?me "comm; iMessabe: P?r?nipants: 4. RG {owner-'3 4 Dwigh? Txlkury' if .- I 3 -I {uwnezj a; .. .. .. . by the way. i start the conversation w! Harry to?ay. HI get deep in it with him. but i think we?! be okay regarding :he Genie: f; Siam: Sam mma: 3mm mass Pumas; 3- 3mm: 3.25:2th 8119.55 Source ?ie? {335 9x?212? DC (Tabla? messaga chat. 5:26: 22133621 32 Dying) WEB-15 1321. .Wmm Wes i think it aims at 6 omen-k and it's a dinner conversation abbui FaBiBm. Sharpton will he {he keynom ape aken i1! speak with {3:5pr and see what we can wad: nut but if we sfari a six. than think it?s ?ne if you team: it ?15. Just trying {a keep fyou in the leap. By the Way i-did speak in Harry regardinglmonies {hat we were suppnsedverygood canversaiion and was very reassuring iha! Eavembing win he ail rig m. He apoke ?ighly oi you. and seems tn understand more mere abqul whai {Stanley is up to esneciaity as It {glazes {a Ea?n?s to gei rid 9f chief isaacs and possibly tum as wail. i shared with them that you are 199% hahind him 59 don?i think ihat'$ going to ghappen. 3 _2 E?isc ?here is an event on Aprii 14 a Satur?ay iunchean by orgaqizetion cailwamen?s aiti?ame. jhis is a group at in?uentiai biack women 5 if} the cammuniiy and i would iike very much for you and yourwn?e a passibie in be my guass (5 [win he bee of two, memes, i?ii 931 mm j_ minima?on in you as weii. sums: R?ad i {Deli-45nd: 31832016 is 16 2G and: 315:2916 memo may: as: anuraz. ?ia: Pia-fa db {stiez message. han?lal ch31. Slza? 2261:5211: bytes} mama 4 19:6.) '3 ail sounds great. giad you connected With Harry as wail. he?! be with us on this. Status: Sam Ene? 3:12-57 PM arc-5:. Rand: $51637 FMIUT =51 ESDume ma: RC: ?3 . {Table mesaaga, chat SIZE 220??62113 bytes} gmwmam 4 - {Dwight Wary) Shaina: Read 8.21:26 PM was; gum; mums 5-21 25 mm": 15-5} Item EB: Type: Star? Babe: End Sate: Chai ?ncoum: 416331 Chat Canversa?a? March 7, 2018 3:85:29 PM EST March 7. 2018 9:09:32 PM EST RS. 4+ (iMeasage}>. Dwight Ti?ery (Message): 055935393)?, RG. Dwight ??513 :ifxriessageh I siili am so Gama-sec! how John aperaies as at": executim Mayer. wag jusi reading abeui {he partnership with the Ciiy and the chamber to ere-airs this o?ice a? immigration where Steve D?ehaus and another person win Eead i3. Bid The Councii mie on monies for this office? And of course everyone knows that Craniey and {he Dreihauses Or {hick as thieves. This man has rewarded many of his aromas that he makes 8055 Cox tack like chiid?s 9135:, This rea?y needs :0 stop it's just a shame and we need {a dc; sameihing about keeping him cut of running the city. know Landsman and Eennard wefe ioeking at creating an of?ce {3f righis which ceufd co'niain and inspectcr General to 100k at whai is going on in ciiy governmeni as we? as the po??ciens. There has to be some way 3199 ihis maniae. And by the way, nebody?s asked bid nut {his immigraiian u?ice. SO frusirating Great gob teday 20:65 {3-38. (iiviessagep We siuck tegether wai}: i was pmud! N02 sure if you saw when 3 20:8? barked dawn Grams?2y and told him nut in put words in cur or the community's mouth Uw lg hi i ii iery s? Heard abm? i1 and {maple were s?nging your praise, Jahn is '14 a hairy and everybody knows it bui for too Song peopie have simpiy I31 him have his way, Today you am! a message that {here?s a new sheri? in town and yam guys area?: going {a iake it anymore. Proud of ycu .L. Thanks fer an the ongoing heip and guidance. i?Ii aiso inward {mu an emai: (it: be kepi private) that i semi to the group who had been marking toward ioday?s Quicnme on this Specific iegisia?on. (31 OK, ?150. Reap in mind {hat the some? makes me miss. not Jon. Yau guys are in charge yet gvsi have so take it back from J?hn item if}: Typa: Start Date: End Date: Chat ?ccou?t: 457F264 Chat Conversation March 8201612125217 PM EST March 8, 2018 12:50:12 EST PKG. (iMassagej>. Dwight Timer? Denard <4 {iMessagap {iMessagel>. Tamaya Dwight Wit-try (Message? Goad morning. As i took at the committees of council, I noticed 12:2!) that health :3 stiit tn the budget committee. The reason why it?s there is because I asked Grants}; during eur honeymoan to gut it under Winbum. i have never gxatten the 36mg that Mann is a fan at the center. But more impodantty i think the wart?; we do which is 313051 heaith dispa rittesfhealth equity absctuteiy fits within Dannard's committee? What. woutd be the easiest way to shift it under Denaard? Ptease tat me know as we are interested in presenting I work to that committee prtor to the budget process. We do need a ttiendty and understanding committee chair for us to present caur work team Let me know how you want it; handle this. PG. <4 (iivtassage}> personatty support haatih being in Tamaya?s ccmmiuee. it 12:2? woutd take a motion suppo?ed by a majority. if we were t0 go dawn that mute, Tamaya wcuid have to talk it that with Mann. 1 have rm idea if he'd want. to keep it {31? Dwight "t itiery {Message}: HE: spoke in the past as if he did. Another! way we coutd go at 12:50 this is not say anything and we came ink) her aommiilee fer presentaticns because our wark iS heaith equity. The heaith department was actuaity undar the budget cammittee as wait. 80 maybe the best thing to do is tet steeping dogs tie and see if he has a reaction And even if he has a reacticn, Tamaya cam 38)! that it?s the kind at issue that could be invoked committees. tjust don?t trust Mann these days especia?y his retaticnship with Stanley item Type: Start Date: End Qate: Chat Accourst: 416346 Che: Camersation March 9, 2818 6:19:91 AM EST March 9. 2018 7:51:58 PM EST RS. (iMessageh Dwigm Tinery (iMessage)> RG. PG <+1513 :iMeswge}> I?m hopping on 73(33m ?ight. if avaiiabze before ihen, give 31 cal! Dwighi (Messagep PG ijust goi off a? the phone with Landsman and he will be fine. However, Black is going to have to work with him and Seetbach to gs: their support. Whatever-36:31; can do to help lead and mediate those make the difference, We are still meeting a: ?ve today to discuss next steps if any. I understacd Landsman?s matings aboz? ?iack as you know and shared wiih him that he hasn?t been my biggesi champion but we stili need him in ihai and Greg says he has no Went to Sign anything {a get rid 9f the manager. B?ac?< has ta give Landsman and Seeibach love and than we mil have a powerfui coilaiicn? think that's very very passible, Biack shouid be ceiling you if he hasn?t aiready within a few minutes? Jusi had a meeting with Cranley and Craniay threatened him if he didn?i reaign. Cfaniey knews ynu have the power now and we've got to make {horse members to ?eld Iighi Cmniey promisad is run a smear campaign against the manager if- he didn?t resign. Landsman and Seelbach has to k?ow what is a: siake here new, This city could mew up any moment. 4+ (ifv?ressagejlr Spoke IE3 him. Tait! him councii and aommuni?qx have his back and he must not bow 10 the threat Ti?ef}? (Nassagep Right but he seemed mail}! shaken and i don? wani him to wind up quitting and we didn?: see Gaming. i never heard him sound so shaken before. He even a$ked me whai should he do has been typ'zcal of Harry but 1 mid him absoimefy {in no? resign. {'ii keep you posted aboui the 5 attack meeting in the community but W3 craniey is reatly doing what Trump does and he is rea?y up {he ramat Issues this commumiy Oi 06:?9 13:52 15:0? 18:0? 18:0? 16:73 course; he's working behind the scenes tn keep hi5 hands dean. i meniioned to you about putting on the baiiet a race}! provisim. i wander if that maid make John back away. can be dang and i think he vmuid be reca?ed. Yaur reacticm i0 Craniey?s caii. Pasior {hinks it?s about the Chief W34 and the femaie foicer. See what yet; can ?83m. We had a 9006 meeting bui don'i want to wind up with egg on our face. G. <4 (iMessage}> W213i cal? from Cranley? 19334 Asking far resignaiion? 193:35 Or same phcne gait? 19:35 Dwigh! Titlery (ihf?essagep Yes it's (warms: news. 19:35 PG. (Message); mink it?s an insane overraach 19:36 This frame is fr; ??FuiESEzeRe nderiizlipq 19:3? Dwighi a {if?essagep Not sure what Craniey has but he's meeting with Pastor and i assume other Ccunciimembers 10 get Han}! to reaign 30hr: hasn?t even reached tn me once, WhiCh :8 ?813an But Pastor wzii ream: back {a you We just need keep Greg 652 Chris. which i behave we can. And they're good for haw. Wight Tiilmyr H15 Yes, But Paslor is suggesting {hat the chief is in 5mm kind of 193% sexual affair wiih the lady {mime officer. Pastor Wan?l be Specific-:- but he said that Jam showed up at his house uaa?nounced and mid 01:: some infarmaiion a'bcxut Mack and the chief. it?s all or: the news and in the papers. Landsman wiil be zeaving {Own Sunday. I did speak wi?lh Biack aka: our meeimg and tom him to hoid ?ght, Thomas, Young, Hiimn? Mailnry are strang. You need (0 pian out whai Jabs: is pedaiing around with the Omar counciimembers. RC5. of ?Message? Have heard rumer of possibie affair. but no one seems 1c: have 192458 any proof, Did 93510: say what John revaeied between Black andisaac? Hi try dig up whal they?re peddiing and came; wt ether 19:5{3 CGu?Gil members Dwighi Tillery (iMessageJ> Na bul he wouid Uni}! intimate that wauid ever infermaiion he 153:5?! had was more absut the Chief. You. may want to contact Bias}: and ask him If there's anything that you new {a imam (EMessage}?2 wm do. 19:51 Ham Type: Ska: Susiedim: Eir?ct Parent {Pupficaiesz was Hash: Emage 415343 JPEG image 389 KB {398.458 by?es; PG Sittenfelci Q1mac-N?8D?edb?f556?40e480t335 35 at Verizon LTE a me are e- a geeasjiir in a day of high or; at City Airman? erican groups began to organize to back Slack Among them are the Sentinel Police Aeaociatiorr, a group of black police off; cere; the Cincinnati chapter: of the NAACP, and the Biaeit Agenda} a group led by form er Cincinnati Mayor Dwight Tiliery, who now runs a nonmpro?t community health. group in. recent years, members of these groups have become outraged at what th ey believe is a succession of smear campaigns against biack ieaders, which include former police chief ie?rey Blacitweii, err?Councilman Chariie Winme and former Metropolitan Sewer District director Torry Parrott. Item 45?265 ?E?ype: Chat Canversa?on Start Date: March 9. 2018'6:40:40 PM EST End ?ake: March 9, 2018 6:40:46 PM EST Chat gamum: PEG. :4 {iMessage}>, Tamaya Denard (iMassageia Dwight ?Emery 4+ (Message? FAG (if?essage)? 8f03f?gfcraniey~ 18: 4 #529249? gnPa vi 848-9603: ?em if): 45?:265 Type: PNG image Size: 5 KB (5.969 bytes) Custo?ian: PG Sitienield Eifeci Parent EB: 553741 Dup?caies: 188 5565 Hash: 33m369228b361538f1 9?51b43b451ei image $33859?? Mg} i . Egg ma Ewan? $38. mx km wza swam mm? ?mmumomaam 335 "gmww?mmw ?mam ?wank Em: Rem it}: Twig: Start Pirate: End ?ake: Chat Acceunt: 416358 Chat Canversatton March it}, 2838- ?:40:33 AM EST March 10. 201810:41:00 AM EST Dwight Yiliery {Message-3:. P.G. message)? {iMessage)>, Dwight <4 (ihz?zossogop Hoio to bother you and even have to ooal with this on my 0?:620 birthday today but Jon is throwing ouoryihiog ho coo against oiaok to get him to step down. Unless {how's some very visibio suppori from the oounoii aod secondarily, the biaok community. i?m 3?:an that Eiaok mighi got weary in me next few days and step down, You need {0 think aboui homing a specioi session of oounoii and dooi with John for the way in which is aitaokiog hiook ?moi {his is not ihe process of addreosing about {he manager and so? up a oommiitoo to take a iook at those aliegoiionsi in lion of or io addition so, for a press conference with some mack ieadozo and have a very oirong staiomont about the. attack in tho ootorizaiion that Jon is creating. That {his is not the way in which to deal with an employee of {he Commit. ?foo guys can?: sit on the sideline; what Cranioy white Croniey is hammering away at you: top ompioyeo. John suppoSodly to have a tape whore. biaok coiled Creme-y was cussing about white ano black and they: is the tape that he is piano is: out out more, Winbom toio. me aboutthat iasi night but I don'i care if he did make commoois about racism in the prooioma in this communay that does not entitie Cronloy to wage a smear campaign against him as he said he would, i think Harry wit! hoid or: bu: you guys have got to say something Monday or Tuosday but it you don?: he very wen may pack his bags and leave. 1 think it wooio be the worst ?ning for'him to do as John has already has ionohod his attack. According to Winburn gotten John is going to drop crap on mock un?t ho ieavoo. Bu! the is the man that ho stop E1 and i?m in the process of against {he managor? Bot oi course Cranfoy undorstands tha? he can?t win that way he knows he doesn't have 8 votes. This is what is irying to do but you can come back io lown and taik aboui a process to addressed any of those grievances and this way you take away Jon?s to continue to aiiacic the manager, if he does oominoo did everybody 5863 that is Craniey who is the rogue beer. Be sure and text Biaok i?li give him some sense that we are there. He's got :0 fool ionoiy in the next few days. Coo you call me? impooani strategy 09:01 Jus! spoke with Black and he?s oomfortabio With you guys not 13:88 doing aoyihiog so {aka my suggestion o? the iabie? ?oad??achmem ?ZF?EEQ?BQESaR1inpatoed??zcmem 5381 i ?tem 4163615 ?We: PNG image Size: 9 KB (9,934 bytes) PG Sittenfeid ?treat Pawn: in: 539729 ?uplicates: 198 @9195 Hash: Emage $??12225?~33?5~?3??w3 item if}: Type: Size: {maediam Eirec? Parent in: FAQS ?ash: image 41636? JPEG image 23 KB {23,881 bytes} Siitenfeid 539?29 1484a931 59h?035394 be? 51% tit ett t'f e3? tier-21 ED: 4584 76 Type: JPEG image Size: 203 KB {207,899 bytes} Custodian: PG Sittem'eld birem? Parent ff): 554201 5305 Hash: f352b25?abf3251c3236980?4 ?eb24et tmege RG. Sittenfelo @QG-Sittenfeld The positions of Police Chief and City Manager are difficult, complicated jobs; our current Chief and Manager do them well, and they have my support. some 11:10 AM item i9: Type: Size: eusiodian; Qimct Paratz? $35 Hash: image an'f/o'. sum man; fig:- 458MB PNG image 768 KB by?esj PG Sittenfeld 554283 er Verizon LTE tantra PM at Tweet . ee. Sittertteld Let?s all take a deep breath and do what am fellow Citizens expect US to do: aveid unnecessary fighting, be respectful of all constituents! and work together to move eur city ferward. PE. Sittenfeic! @eGSittameld The positions of Police Chief and City Manager are difficult, complicated jobs; our current Chief and Manager do them well, and they have my support. "ii-:13 AM it: AC rt"? Rem ii}: W235: Size: Custodian: Bites: Parent it}: ms ?agh: Wage 458482 PNG image was KB (784,944 bytes) PG Sittenfeid 5542033? at Verizon LTE 12:43 are a 98% "Meet OK {It Sittertteid 3:1; @PGSit?lenield Lastly, we are fortunate te live in a city which is almost equally and peepie of calm. We must. be certain: that reaped: and eepertunity are also equai. 53.6. Sittettfeie @PGSittez?xieid i?m more than willing to bring ail interested and cencemed individuals and groups together to werk toward a productive resolution. 3ft 5:8; 13:1 are: if! TWEET .- Siam Type: mart Date: Ems Hate: (that account: 4527269 Chat Conversa?a? Match 12. 2018 $208135 AM Em? March 12, 2018 18:53:44 Mai EDT RS. (Messagep? Tamaya Canard *9 Ti?ery 4+ {Message}? (Messagep, Dwighi RS. <4 (Message): So?iihorman now oponiy oarrying John?s water: Q.oomfsiory!3 W81 1 2.5.".94557 ?it?sz?a?z??j?z?L38534.32: Fm doubtfu! ihere?s some smoking 9qu or Joho wouid used airoady, And Harry says there?s not, Dwighz Tiilory (message): OK so now we go after Smitherman and the contracts his brothers go?ien. i Biook when he says there is no smoking gun. Thio is a collaborative offer: to take the man the man down and we have to fight back and we have to go after {he atiies of John who is aiiacking the manager. Tat}: with Wendel} East night our goo! is to have a cohvorsai?on today to have a major press conference in the biaok community. it?s nice if Bsaok ovoid 9945 as. some very oonfi?oniiai information aboui Craniey?s behavior. i have the investigator at channo! 12 poised to go and do the story. Sitianfi'eid this is atmost Biaokwoii over again and this community wilt no: stand for it Fm ieliing you ihat this go up in smoke it John Cominoes against btaok. Far too many biaok poopio in this community are still angry about how biaokweli was treated over: though ?mo manager had a hand in it. But they are wilting to out that aside to fight John. Creoloy is not iikod in the black community it is the hon-dint of {oiks that he?s given oonirao?s to but no one has gotten mom than his brother. And oven if there is nothing anything Wiih his brother it?s a dear relationship bemoan them. I have some 1o the: position now that this is aboui Creme? being in {here with the and the wanting to have thezr way with their own chief, As you may know, Saturday morning Cran?ey issued a sialemeni saying that he in the petite poiice chief were cool bu! {not was just a pioy so he doesn?t get accused of trying to get rid of {he chiei. Crafiy bastard 09:08 09:08 Dramas: tetd me yesterday that EH01 Isaac?s report of bad 09:4? behavior on me City Miamige?s pad wouici be a part of the he putting togeiher in get Biaek can as welt. I ?nn?t know if lhai's We ?3833? IBwighi Tiilery (Mess-agar OK 50 this begins make me feai that {he bays in the Poiice {39:53 Department has samething over the chief and they are. ieveraging that up against black? When do dom?i think yoa can watt another day to {am 10 1353:; nor Ken the manager we need know what this bay is Wing to da. Chief is 99mg come clean and. how 603.5 he report an ?anks behavia?r. {don?t get the! but that?s what Jehn- came out Saiurday and said he SQ it supper-as ihe chief $0 1 am warried {hat the ch?ei has made '3 deal wan John in be against bzack arid ihat?s reeiiy mt gunna be 909d, But he's a for)! becauseonce Black is gone he? game. But they may haw same inform'atiah 13231 We hoiding over the chief?s head as. i just catie? the Chief and he tote: me direc?y Shat he abseluteiy 19:09 stands with Harry, deSpite w?haiever miners might be swirling, and thai he believes if Haw gels imminaied. thai ha (the Chief) be the EBXI to go Dwight a Very Quad :0 know; I think Jahn shau?d be cat! be calied out an 10:11 tying 0n the c?i?f and others 10 get things his way. This is a se?rieus ma?a: and ha should not be conducting his awn investigaticn. Again Hhi?k yen guys can get ahead 01? by put?ng tugether a praisess that The sound} wmwis and insist on the mayor start canduciing his own individual investigation because I'm sure it is quite timid dialing if he 33 sailing peopie Misting their arms 16 give ia'siimon'y. This is absoiuleiy and he needs :0 be caiied out can it ASAP Hem if): ?fype: Start Gate: End ?ags-r Chat Account: 4183378 Chat Conversation March 13. 2018 1:53:34 PM EDT March 13. 2018 6:56:24 PM EDT RB. (Nessa-amp. Dwight Tiliery ?pg?iitememggmatmcm {if?essage}? Dwigm Tiilery (iMessage)> The rumors are ?ying wiidiy. The am}; thing have 10 say is {had '1 3:53 Slack shouid not be able in pa! of us {3111 there fighting fur him and than wand. away with a pocket ms of money. if he goes. is: him go withwt any severance package, And 0:311:59. if he does get?, men King Craniey E5 cm me thwne and you guys wit! stilt have 10 538231 with him. for aimost 4 years. Th?s is many shameiuf and there sheuici be Great pressure can ?ack to stay at Seast for the next year or twn. We realiy can?t a?nrd to give Craniey a win on {his omen Also, i?m fearfuf that Wendet! win simply 98 his own way which wits weaker: the coliisioa and your ability gain the ieadership 0f ihe Councilt Rape you guys can tatk him Entu staying. PG. (Message)? I?ve aiready {aid him direcHy. if ha walks, i?m a no Vote an any 13,54 severance package Dwight Tiilery (iMe$sage)> Greaiz Is he mail}; considering it? Winbum is saying that Pastor 14:00 said that you had agree? 10 at eight month severance package. Tait Chariie {$36 rm! believe Eh Wet! you got a braid {119 ?ne with the eiharsl This is reaily awful if he turns his back or: yon guys and the black ccmmunity in particuiar. i?m told that Craniey is asked Black it} reach {301:0 Cramey?s biack iaadership friends it: support a saverance. Sittenfeld we are reafiy Gaming with a neat in Craniey. You guys; have got {a put! lageiher and take controi, Begin ta Change the wines of the cguncii. Yeah, I think yau have t9 get in the bailie with the {?ber counciimembers that a: it least supportive to g?ve a concerted effo? to black ihai he?s win be summed but if he ieaves he 9c: witheut yau guys approving a severance package. Like it not, Jehn is gaing is {same you until you knock him out. He has {.301 to be in charge a? werything? AH powerfui but ccunciimembers have {a start going after him. and cammenting on his behavier. That happens an the time when we. ware an Cauncii. When everyth?ng is siteni from the council it makes .3th even mare in cemroi. This is an age by iha! bay As I ieoked at {his entire situation, the issue of white officers net 14:45? wanting in: work with a chief wha is black is a very very serious pmbiem and ii rea?y demands sonnet} it: ada'ress it. The more 1 go over of this informatim we keep to recognize that piaque said the white n?z?cers didn?t wan! ii} wcr?t for Black chief. don?t think counsei can i9: ihis be swept 9:1er {he mg. Rdditiana?y haw dare the maycr want is far this man and you guys nee? 10 ga after ihe maycr. There is a need for ieadership here Can me very important i?m Enid by a reiiabie sources that ?Amy %5 mi in favor 3f getting rid of ?ne manager. 1 got this Mark Vander Laan and wha got it from Aiex Hem EB: Tygze: Start am: End. Gate: Chat ?ccaumt 41638? Chai Conversation March14.2018 6:21:12 Pm March 14. 2018 ?:08:32 PM EDT HG. Dwighi Wiery (453355599)? (Mes-53983}, PAS. Wight Tliiery [ifv?essagep i read what Cranley is daing ihai setting up meetings in bear 18:21 peopie is lambaste the manager. Sitten?efd yen guys have 901 to take contmi a? ibis. John has no auihority to do whai he's doing. Yam 915:: may reccmmend thai Bfack shauid get an aiiomey as we}! because John is creatz?ng a house working piece for Bla ck. Ynu guys have got 319 range cm AM. 1 mix :9 you fasi week about se?ing up a process Setting John know ihat he can do his awn investigatiorz put his own siuff {agether and then came 10 the city Cauacii {a accapi it. If you guys don?t do something to push back or: John and he gets his way by having empieyees give a2: of this crap iha?hey might say against black, Harry probably ieave? Ynu guys of go: ta see miss I mean i i 3:35! 6931?! understand the silaace. You knew if Harry zeaves it win not be enough far you guys {0 sii mere arid say wait we had a bat}. We supported zhat's no! support. if yau supper: him yea guys med to 901:: banks againai John. Haw can yaw go in empiayees empioyees and get ihem to testify againsi their bass. Don?t you see what?a wrang with this PIS. <4 (itx?easagep of marge - having his bank means having his back. the 5 39:05 members suppo?ing him are having a cat! En the next day is sari thmugh ihe strategy? and d?scusxs a g?oinz fetter making it ciear we win no? aiiow Kangaroo Ccu? ?wight (if?easagep 80 gram: new and Biack is abuut to take a iegai step against 39:6? John ihat you?ll realiy enje'y ., {Massage}; Must spoke to Harry; he?s Canferring wiih me on a1! this. Dom warm we're not $351 sitting back Wm m: Yype: Star? Date: Date: Chat 45?623 62131 Conversation Match 15, 2013 4:43:20 Pm EDT March 15, 2013 5:44:33 EDT Wendell Young *3 (iMassage)>, RG1 Tiitery (Message? (Messagep, Dwight Dwight {iMesaage)> Spake is Joe Maiiory 10 see if we couid [mid a press 18x18 conference ihis evening t0 indicate that {his is m! a good move iamnrrow to have such a meeting and waiting {he manager an irai! as it WEE: {Skew resuit and civii diaturbance.- You guys can use that as a reascm cf net doing it ?at the in the black community bring more harm than good it?s a easy one aabody can prove or disapprove it. Yet; got its supper? mac}: and ferget about the media. For years {tom new it?ii be a different conversation We?deii Yaung H098 the press conference happens. it?s a 900:! move. 1?:13 Dwighi ?E?i?ery? (iMassage)> 8:11 whal you guys do. Black 5311?: going to have peapie 1?;16 iras'h him and i don't biame him. You guys are s??l tetting Jon run the Show, 86 you got five varies and Biack {eaves anyway Because he gut {rash 30 ?385er any pub?c forum Wendeit \?aung {iiviessageb agree. We have to be a lot more visibie with our su?pori for 1?:19 Harry. We?ne having a conference 03?: tomoyrow. At miwimum. we need to heid our own press conference in supper? of Harry. P8 are you on beard? Dwight ??ery 4+ (ir?essagap Press conference wiil take piace {may at 6 -- ..: Gated. Maybe we councii members can herald a press conference tomorrow or ever the weekend. 5% (Message )2 Veal support cantmiting pracess and backing Harryfrum tonighi Saturday afternoon. Wendell: Tamaya Chris a?d have a 130:3m caf! iammow i0 finaiize cansensus on various ideas, which we can release soon after if Tamaya doesn't or can?. ailend iomorrcw. ii?ii be just Smithermen, Murmy, Pastor and Mann no! enough for quorum Owighi Tliiery (Message)? What time is the cauncii meeting being caiied PG. {ir?essageb 10453m Wanda?! Young (iMessage)> i won?t? be there it}? special sessicn. i?m not a member of Smiihemzan?s cammiitee. PEG, (iMessage)> when 5101 repiying quicmy to texts it?s because on phone Dwight 3 liiery <4 {ifa?essageir- was anything happened :omormw 9.8. (iMessage)> Ne Dwight (Message)? 0k Wendell Yeung :24 (ir?essagep Not withoui a quemm HG. ?3 (EMBSSEQG 31*- 17:42 1?:42 1?:42 1?:43 1?:43 1?:44 1?:44 HEM item m: Type: Stari Sate:- End Bate: Chat .?sccount: ?313394 Chat Conversatinn March 15, 2018 8:23:04 AM EDT Marsh 16, 2018 3:23:19 PM EDT ?14' (iMessage3>, Dwigh: Tiltery {iMessage)> Dwigh; (ifz?essagep Just heard that Pavia Christiansen of {he ad team is asking for 08:23 healihgap coniract. This is so Cranley shame! 9 Vii be ashamed {If it 50 0:5an yaursaif a news cutie-t. But we're about {eady to wage a campaign against him and wiil see how they Sike it, Pramise yea it wan?i be pretty, Ycu can say to Craniey {he biack community is cm plug and 08:23 needles so got ta make sure the Manager is treated fairiy Just spake is: window and we have a new idea. Why deem": {18:23 council appeinied a special mange: ta iook inta the issues that mam that Drama}: is waging against black. and write a repart and submitted to muncii. This does {we things one :2 {ages away from this man being put an a pubiic {rows} and S?klenfieid idcn?t {twink mam gazing so bode well far you and ethars either. Secondly Curt couid receive. the iea?moay and and privateiy and be abie to determine the isuihfuiness of what the charges are out or ailegations being made against them the manager. Jam wants this a pubiic speciasie do not piay ink: that 30 you. guys can put {onward a (nation that you wit; retain a speciai special (30112189! to receive the aliegations made by the mayar in his witnesses befnre the Special ccunsei and wili write up a repart to that This" wiH keep blaak ievei with a sense 01? of integrity and decency Just 923! the ward that Craniey is going {a now {he tech biack as 13:59 being a raging aicoholin. 1 mum {ext Black and told him don?t warry about it many peopia in the society a! suffedng {rem substance abuse but yam must them that you?re seeking and getting heip. Yam saw this coming St) reassuring him. Sitten?eld i see no reason far him to Ieave now since John has . ?crashed him so badiy. Piease keep him calm am! 111th hold an because ?the damage is already been dime so why ieave; We are standing wiih you PG. <4 {Message}: {after that'sjust gone out in media; 15:18 March 16. 2018 Dear Mayor Craniey, City Manager Black, Members 01' the Pubiic. and Members of the Media: We have Watched his unfariunafe saga unfo?d in recent days, arid feel 8731:?? is new on us - {he Ceuncii Majerity bring wafer and a fair process if) ibis situaiiczn. Tc: be dear, anyone who wishes 10 bring forward concerns or report miscm?uc? must feet safe arid camfm?tabie doing so. We ac?veiy wa??t your voice is be heard; We aiso beiieva strongiy in due process. No game?s name gr reputation show he {amished wiiham there being cigar evidence (beymd just ?he said? she said") as; wei? as a fair Bypanuniiy ior that individuai 20 respenci. We share the serious concern 0f organizations like the Urban League. Cammunity ?ction Agency, NAACP. Black Agenda, Natianai Ao?on Network, Slack United Ham. and Others 2113: present behavior is roiling back the ciock on race. in Cinci?na?; we wili no: abet the imeniimai denigra?on cf anather black {eader in em community, We 32:50 do not sugapm {arcing ih? taxpayers is pay (3111 of their own packets for whai is curreniiy a bmken rela?anship. We beiieva mere are much be?er immediaie nexi steps, ?rst, this situation steady mus: be de? poii?cized and taker: outcf the hands of most direcz?y in me fog of war: Therefore. we are caning for ihe appoinimam or an outside Special Counsei [appainied by a majerity a? City Councii). to ceiieci and investiga?e ihe cameras famed by the Mayer, any and counterefacsuais {mm the City Manager, and iesiimony erm empicyees (if my aihar directiy inmiveci azakehmders. This Speciai Caunsai win than write a report to be submitted to City Cauncii for our review, A1 ihe same iime, we ara for a ceasefire between the Mayor and City Manager, during which baih agree is say nothing meme on the subject and focus on the City?s werk. Durmg this seasefire? Emmi} wiil bring it; a pm 230m mediawr to privateiy hetp the Mayer and Manager navigate their relationship am return :0 getting things dame far the citimns of Cincinnati. Lasiiy, during zhis ceasefire, we ca? far rm persanniel Changes. Commit wii: contra} this pram?ass as it unfofds, and if ihe need and desire fa: what ihe Mayor has caiteci a "pubiic trim? warming.z then Council wit! control the time. date. and ?ocaiion of such a speciai meeting. Became a: the g?grzi?cant interest {mm concerned members the community, such a specia?y-calied meeting wauid occur in the eveniposiad with 31 ieasi We wee-ks 210609 to the pab?c We took forward to can: Reads i?ese issues being praperiy addresse?, and everyone ge?ing back. it; work far {he c?y we have! Sincerely, Tamaya Dennard Greg Landsman Wander! Young Chris 86331330?) Dwigm Tziiery (iMeSsageP Great PG. {iMessage)> appreciate your help and input as always Dwight Tiziery (Message): This is a very impuriant step 96? (iMessage)> yes, don?t worry we weren?t going to give up cantroii if the 5 of us hang together, and the African~American ieadership in the commanity hangs together. we can 90 in a very goat! direction 55:19 15:19 15:?0 35:23 15:23 item Wise: Siart Grate: ?nd bate: Chat Accaum; 45%}24 Chal Conversatian Marc-h 16'. 2818 9:15:43 AM March 15. 2818 8:15:43 AM Dwigh! Merv (iMessageJa Wendeil Yanng EKG, {ife?iessagep (iMessagQP. Dwighs Tisisry <4 {ik?essagap Gcod morning. z?m meeting with an investigative reporter on 09:15 Sunday who is very inierested in Cran?ey's centres! sieering a?d other cqrrupi behavior. Can anyone give me information thai might be heipfuf over the phene? Of ceurse; Year is protect. l?m meeiing with him Sunday. Thanks ?em 213: Type: Start Date: End Date: Shai ?ccaun?: 457625 Chat Conversatiun March 17. PM FEET March 1?,2018 5:4?r30 PM EDT Wendaif Young {ih?iessage}: {iMessage}> (Message? might Dwight (iMe?sage'j> Word is Biack has resigned. True or not true 15:? PKG. (Message);- Tied up currentiy 30 can?t iaik. He just caiied, said he?s going 10 16:29 sign paperwork fer a ?1.3 year buycui and force a vnie from Couacii. I reaf?rmed in: him I?d be a "No" vete: Fm n01 forcing the taxpayers 10 pay exira because two grew men have had a failing nut and because John is trying to'maka his Zife misarabte. Harry wants in be Manager. just mi under curreni My remedy weuid be change the werk canditions and dan'i anew me smear campaign. But to be mean takes; 5 yes votes to finaiize me package. 16:30 Dwight (iMessagep agree. We go after Graniey and itwili be nasty. I 18:32 reaity appreciaze you standing I think that everybody else will be ihere but i hear that Landsm'an tends it) be week. He cannot {at this happen. What city manager maid want to some to the 033; if we Eet {his happen. We have got to pm the heat on Craniey Wendel! Yaung (fix?essage): Lei?s tear him up! 1?:88 Dw?ght Titiery Wes-sage); Yes meeiing at 2 Marc} af?ce and we'? decide from there 3?;19 Wendeii Young {l-tx?essageir? Nailing 3&2. Tamerrew? 117110 {Eimght Meg-sage)? Netting?? 1 2 .11 Wendei? Young; (iiv?seasage); Oops! Meeting at 2 iamormw? Dwigh?: Ti?lery (J- (Massage? Yes. Don't agree to anything. He hung us om an this issue $0 mitt-1e mezherfucker gt: wiih as We money as po?ible. I know y?u may be at the play but win keep you informed as to what is going to be dene. i think we ready '10 hit the sireets Wen?eii Yaung 15 (Messageh l?m firmly against the buyout. He geis what his contract calls for. Nothing more! Signing off now? Call you tomarmw. Dwight Tiller}: 42+ {ifv?aessagep 0k 1?.?43 ?f?:46 1?:46 item Yype: Start Date: End 53%: that ?ccaum: 4??625 Chat Conversation March 18. 2018 9:07:28 AM EDT March 18. 2018 9:0?:26 AM EDT Dwigm (iMessage}>, Wendett Young (1- P.G. {iMessaga)> (iMessage)>. Dwight Ttizery (in?esszagep Goad Naming: Biack may be gone bui Creme}; wi? some after 09:0? The Heaiih Gap by getting the new ma?ager to $trucfure our contract that 58% us up far faiiure. I'm very concerned abcmt ihis as he asked for our contract We?nesday in his of?ce press conference gust iasi week. He will continue to run City uniess yam guys insistthai he abides by the Ghana. Perhaps the special wunsei shauid cantinue to axial. to 393%: at haw the Of?ce of the Mayor and the manager is functioni?g. fhis person maid came back with a raped to We commit which may review John?s con?nucws interference with {he managers ef?ce. in ciher words taking pawer he doesn?t have and causing Chaos and possible corrupiion? This is aiso an impa?ant step for recruiting future managers. No (me come take the city managers job knowing that they wan't realiy have the to manage because you have a rogue mayor. In fact you could as?? this mini as {he primary reason to have a speciai counsei lock into the interactions of'the mayors of?ce and the city managers. Y?u guys have to raa?ze that cranley has Gene some seriaus damage to the office of the City manager and the ward travel a1? of the enmity. Harry Biack was Rem Type: Start Gate: End 3313: Chat ?ccount: 45762? Che! Comets-{ion March 19. 2018 9:59:38 AM EDT March 19, 2813 9:59:38 AM EDT "?ner? {iMBssage}>, Wendeii Young 01 53.6. 4+ {Message}> (Wesgagep. Dwigm (iMessage)> Mandamus aciion is a iegai remedy it: cause a gavemment (38:59 official or eieciive ?sh you to abide "by me iaw. i the charien John is trying to circumveni the {aw 1hraugh his gangsier iactics. But if you reiain an Aitorney, ii is iikeiy iha? they win cause Craniey E01oilowthe charge: in dismi5s?ng the 083,! manager. Jam having a meeiing w?h Kurp ai 11 and bring ihat up is him. item 33; Wave: Start ?ake: End Bate: Chat Acciounz: 416408 Chat Conversatian March ?59, 2033 6:40:22 PM March 19, 2018 9157339 PM PIG. (Mammy. Dwight 1?9!!er .?com {We sage):- {ih?essagela PE. mun-mm {Dwighi Tmsz-ry (il?a?essagep There be a meeiing at 2 o?ciock at Zhe boardroom tamorrow 18330 to laik abeui next steps bu: i'm giving you a heads up that we're: going to lake ibis my me streets and i win be heading it. i?m dune with the racism in this community and we cam migrate it anymore it's sad the: 1m iea?ership Dwight ieadei?ship won'i dc: a damn thing about it $0 we?il just go ahead and take ?t is the sireei and Eet?s see what happens {ram ?herafhanks for what you wera abie :0 da (323% me about proposed media?en. This is confidential 18 41:3 2?1; {iiv?iesszigaw gusi getting out of stuff, can can yau back Show}! 1910 Dwight Titian: '{ii?essagap Haw abuut 9. A1 Walnut Cum Lauda dinner. A150 1 think this can be a time that yin} guys mighf want to get other items if there is ustimazeiy mediation. i have ideas. Can yau taik? If 30, ?t call you on my heme phone because my cellphone is being charged. if n01 we can taik iomarrow. Ram 19: ?i?ype: Siar?f 33%: End Base; Chai 43.5?628 Chat Conversa?an March 22, 2018 3:19:45 AM March 22, 2018 8:19:45 AM EDT Dwight Tiliew (Messagep, Wende? Ycung PE. {massagep {ifv?essageh Dwight Titlery (ih?essage? Good manning. have a simple suggesiicm that might 2183:) with this currer? problem wiih Craniey. Sims: has some up wiih ai! Of these managemem issues retaiive to the-city managar, the caunci: should establish an aversight Gammi?ee that wit} be a piece where ihe manager can meet w?h 'ihis cammi?ae regarding management igsaas an a raguiar basis, This cammittee shouid be composed of 2ch members coumi?. the mayor, and city manager. This wiiz be a piace where Crankey can assert any ohalienges and pmbiems etc. regarding the manager. It Is also ?the piece where employees and o?hers can have their issues addressed especia?y since Cannon pass the so?caiied whistlebiawer ordinance yesierday?urreniiy, the uni}; person that has taken managemem over the manager has been Jam and we see haw weii that has Marked. Them is nothing within the charter prohibiting you guys from creatirsg sash a committee, {would put this in piace no matter whai, meaning whether Biack gees or siays. because wuncii has it: have a roie in working w?h the manager and esmcialiy when it {mines to personnel issues regarding him. This is aim a place that can be protaciien of biack or th? next city manager Jam running roughshod we! the city manager. "fhe manage:~ needs a buffer from Jehn. This be a ootiaborative workmg reiationship between me mayor and council. The mayor cou?d chair the committee but he wi? be an aqua! w?h the other members of the cammiitee. Thig is. very very important to have snmething tike this because otherwise there is no way to: address issues regarding the manager in a timeiy am} Fair way. 88:19 Rem Wm: $13111 ?33m: ?at? gate: mm Amount: 457F529 Chai Conversaiian March 24. 2318 6:44:03 Pm EDT March 24, 2018 27:38:?g PM Wendeii Vining {Message}? RGA Ti?ery {ifx?essagew (Message-)2 Dwight Bwighl (iMessage)> Just so yuu know guys, i have decided {hat} can no longer 18:44 work with Jae and Rabat Richardson This is bon?demfia! buti believe {hey are working ?ehind GUI backs wiih 3011:1403 sent Gut an email Thursday far putting {ageiher a ?151 things ihai we want if the manager is iet gen responded ht; {hem and told them that i dan?t even know why we as a community shouici benefit {ram this. man using. his job. And furthermcre, that convarsatien doesn?i heip keep Councitmembem Sirorsg. Biack Agenda no longer part of {he And besides? may were mostly my pimple anyway. Wander} Yaung <14 {iMess-age)> i understand. Grantey calied me this morning asking that Very 18:49 question. 1 tom him there: is nothing i want that can be negatiaied with Black ieaving as the desired outc?me? He asked for my advice. told him to give this? mess up and wafk away. He said he can?t {it} that. i do maps the ?ve of us stay 530119. is the aniy way to ram Jeh'n in and make our gavemmem operaie the way it shauid. I?m going anti! 11PM tonight. 13:49 Dwighi Tiifery Get it Bishep is agreement with us. These are same bad 18:51 930916 man and you got a watch as sweet mg 9.6. (iMeswgeP Thanks far update {Dwight i simiia?y toid Jenn eariier this 19:29 week, mate?s net some thing want or that he can do for me. it?s more abcut how government itseif works (or doesn't work}. As far? as i can 19H, the 5 of as remain strongly unified (though 1 Sim worry about other foiks trying is pick off Greg). i?ve got a fairiy ?135! day iomurrow, th?ugh? ccuici try it: talk than, ar am Monday. Dwighi Tiliery a (Message? 0k. i?m haping that Gregg wiit stay sirong. I get some feeiing 39:35 that he was pretty pissed the way John taiked to him last week. This guys a reai maniac. By the way did ycu see the iweei that Smitherman ?aaied aboui gazing back 19 ?wo~year ierm siar?ng 2019? Thought ii was interesting because it iosks ?lm he may want to run for mayor in 2019. He ceufd wind up being yam and Smitherman and John gets kaecked out Let?s discuss. i forget is mention the meme cf this guy in go around asking 19:3? yea guys-what he might officer ycau when he has not one vote. 80 yea see how bad things are new with him because he never get out of ihe way 0f the city manager at any ether manager. {zh?essagep exac?y Stem Type: $3311 ?ake: Emi Date: Fhone Nu mber: ?hai ?ecceunt: 3??22? Conversatian March PM EDT March 26.201810;21112 PM EDT Dwight ??ilery PKG. Wendeli ?muncg Tamaya Benarci Chris Swzbach reg Landsman <15134171550> Dwight (Stump, Chris Seelbach (SMSP, Greg Landsman (amp, Wanda}! Young ?a (SMSP, RG- c+ (SMSP, Tamaya {Jenard Dwighi Tillery (Sill-S)? Channel 5 called me this aflernooa for an interview regarding a Press stale-merit that Cranley released today in it) a recall provision E?al Young had expres3eci inleresl. in Craniey?s press release, he singled me om as leading the charge because he wouldn?t fire Qwens {ram the acting health commissioner pusltion he once held. ?rst of all, as you all knew the mayor has rm power in hire or ?re arty employees under the 80am sf Health. ihis fact. he caniinues use this against me and Ehe center 10 ?:10 the same thing he?s doing to the oily manager ~10 trash Bur reputation. Just fur the record. i do supper? a recall provitsion but in no way am i leading a charge. will :10: be bullied by wha continues to try to find ways in which to stop our fundl?g. 30hr: continues to break {he law by violating the charter. am letting you know ihati will take whatever Si?pS nee?l it: do to protect my repulaiion and the maker?s. I?m mi ioaking fer a public ?ght with Craniey bu: will not run {ram him. i will protect my reputation and the center which he has done everything to try and desiroy; i just wan: you guys it; know {hat (?we had enough 0f {his guy. his lies. and despicable behavicr. He canl?nuas l0 gun. for me at every turn trying at the same time that he?s a uic?lim. Me loo. This guy is the local Donald Trumpl through and through. - :23 item 4585M ??992: Chat Conversation Start Date: March 28, 2018 10:14:54 End 3319: March. 26, 2018 10:19:09 PM EDT {that Mcaunt: Dwight (Messagep, Chris Seeihach ?w (Message? Chris Seeibmh (ih??ssagep Dwight. If you think whai Jam Craniey say has any REM With mauyau dan?t know me, And i knew you do Dwighi Ti?ery N0 Chris I know he doesn'i have any credibility with you {31' the 22:18 oiher members. I just want you guys t0 that I have endareci I?m gci?g in take from ihis guy. By the way, congrats Chris. Thanks for your response. Chis Seemsch 4+ (Messagep t'm bopefui we can stick together 22119 {tern Type: Start Bate: ?nd Qate: Chat Accauni: 416413 Chat Conversaiion March 27, 2013 7:58:36 AM EDT March 2018 7.33:08 PM EDT PKG. (ih?essagak Dwight Tillery (Messagep (ihiessagep. Dwighi {Ems-sage}: 80 John is back to his usuai crazy sets? and getting the business community to pound Lance. Here?s an idea. why want to a? ?ves of yen in the calia?m issue a press statement condemning CraMey?S aciicms in having. the business community iargei Greg Landsman. This com 3183;: Gregg fee-i beam as {his may shi? pubifc attentim back on the We members 0f some?! and not just Landsman. Yam should also say it: 6:699 100%: haw 4mg Jon is framing yam and get?ng the business $0 pressum you iike this. A250 you shouid remind Gregg ?that he has presented aver}: sympazha?c image En the biack c?ammuniiy. Even if Harry goes, mare wi-? be majm marches and protests about this deaisian. Any ideas that yen mayhave from a commum?iy perspectiw, justiei me know. RS. {iixdessagap Up?age {whiie a?knowledging the! it ain't aver the fat. iady Sings): {he 5 cannon memhers have affirmed that we're siicking iageiher, and we Win be muting down the big {3131;01:1er Harry iomerrew DWIQN Tiilery (ih?essaQEI-?J Wow w?ai a greed thi?g 9G a (zi?v??asgageb yes, ii?s taken a heiiuva 10: of effort, and i appreciate what. yeu've done is yield this Guiceme, crossing {his threshcid win be a very important ?ning {omorraw :58 183?} 18.33 item if}: ?i?ype: Start Date: End Sate: Chat ?$15428 Chal Convarsaiion March 28. 2018 9:53:18 PM EDT March 28, 2018 30:57:35 PM EDT RC5. {Messagek Dwight Tiliery a ?pg?iitenmiaggma?mm (Message): (Message? 933. (message? Hey PG Craniey is about to start a race r?oi in this cemmuniiy. 21:53 We need it: have an emergency mee?ng to 6556355 this because by 989;}le are ready to 90 80 the street RG. ?Message? Just on! m" a dinnar. caii iomvrrow. Agreed, John is nuts to 2215?: go down the path he's taking about gaing dawn. i think Goad to inciude Greg and Tamaya in meei?ng. in addition ta me and Wende?, to keep group inciusive and cohesive. Taik to you tomorrow Dwight *3 (iMessage)> OK but Mack men are coming ingezher. He?s a racist and we 22:5? can?t iake ?this anymore. You guy's need to appaint speciat counset to take Craniey to com-L PG time has run out. You guys voted to keep Harry and you must {aka dras?c steps to pratect him. The biack community is an a power keg and 9:10?? it goes, no stopping it. As a dear friend. please heed my cancems. item Type: Start Bate: End mm: mm Acwmt: 416429 Canversaiion March 30, 2613 11:36:19 AM EDT March 30, 2918 12:48:02 PM EDT PAS- (Messagep. Dwight (Message? (Message? Dwighi Ti?ifev; <4 315136.5024402 (ih?essageb are yea aware that Ciamey. Smitherman are warking in put 3:36 sireng mayor on the balk?; PB. <4 (?fx?assage): I k?ow Smitharman is cooking up sorts of stuff. didn?t knew 11:45 Ora may was in on the strong mayor piece. by the way, ha? grand conversaiicms th both Harry-and 11:45 Wendeii this ramming. we?re ail in aiignment. Dw?ght Tiitery (Message): Great, He seat me an emait $352 nighi asking abwt having his 1315i} awn attorney. Don?t take ?gh?y what Smith'emmn and others are doing, ii wouid seem ihat if a strang were wouid be put in [3389? Grammy {Haggai a fresh stack and ccuzd run undenhe new system?What do you think abant the idea of putting 3 1331101 initiative to go back it: the system we had? i nndersiand that it would cause Creme-y term to and in November 201$ and he woutd have {9 ma again next year PKG. (Message? yes. we 3131: discussed him having his own aitomey. Which I 11:51 think is smart anti necessary Dwighi Ti?iery (Message)? (3k. 11:51 (lifx?essageju i'va talked is: Carp abaui the charter amendments and baiiot 11:5?: initiatives he?s researching whether 111301326 actuaiiy ?re-set the clack? not; he wasn?t sure, but seemed doubtfu! Rem i9: Type: $tar? Date: End Sage: Phat-w E??umber: (3th Muznunt: 377'223 SMSIMMS Canversation Harsh 36. 2018 7:30:00 PM EDT March 30. 2018 8:56:21 PM EDT Bwiahi Titian! <15134171550> Chris Seelhach Wendaii Young PB. 4 Tamaya Hanan: r: Greg Landsman Tamaya Canard Wendeil ?Emma Chris Seelbach Gteg Landsman (may. Dwight ?smsp, PKG. (swap Dwight Tiliery (w You guys reaily need to think about caning a specie! Prosecutor 39:30 10 {oak ink; the new ailegaticns made by the manager whiah are cz'iminai in nature. Yam can?t put the genie back in ?ne be?ts? Giher wordg you guys have get 10 mave femard or: this ii wit: make you 300k like you guys are not taki?g ihi$ seriously. Biack mid me eariie: this week {hat Cranley is wimp! east the neiwark is vast. Chris Seelbach 4+ ?f ihe City Managar, or anyone? has real evidence of an mega: 28:22 pay to may scheme ragarding Mayer Sranley, than this is bigger than a Specie} presecukzr. We {add the Manager fhai if Ms eviderace truiy exisis, he needs :0 contact the F85 Wenden Yaung <4 {think WE Read ice mam can this and we shoufd maniac: 1133 M324 Feds or 991 a speciai prosecutor. Haw do yam fee! abcut a press canference tamorrcw regarding ihis? ?wighi <24? (SMSP Just got off khe phane with Biack. He befieves that yam guys 20:43 have an obiigaticn to tack into Craniey?s behav?or as far as {he econcsmic deveiczpmeni situatian is Concerned. This is am just Harry?s probiem bu: the caunciis probiem when you have a mayor w?c ?5 invoived in economic develapment issuesx You guys shouid talk to Biack firsi and see whai he saying. He said it: me that the devetnpers are caliing his sia? when They don?t get their way. Then Cranley comes is him and saya his aim? is hoiding up 59 he is panning pressure an biack? You guys need 10 deai with arm, He further said ihai Craniey mid him he! he was going {0 do what me heii he wanted it: do with devetcpment because 1INS wilt be his {mum 39 mack needed 10 get. (mi his way?he crimi?az aspect af it take care of itsesf because i believe Biack is 90mg to give mare to {he FBI, Black need you guys to look into this ce?fii?ct between biack and Craniey over {he economic development deparimeni. This in anti 0? it?s seii is no: an issue but campizance with the city charier. Are you guys 90an to have in stand up in a very big big way. ?r?eu aisc go! a know we: 23155 is the tip of the iceberg there is just. tom much out {here about Cransey?s hands in deveinpmeni deals, You guys aiso have the capacity 10 go to the FBI to ask them to ink: the s?ua?cn. Wendeli Young 01- (SWEEP I agree. i0 hear back from Seeibach Sittenfeld. 20:56 Also wiil reach out to Demand. i think ihai?s i can contasi. Wit: ask ?ne at them 10 {each on? to Larzdman. We can't leave Harry hanging. He has given us a reason in act We can't just sit on this. item 2E): Wm: Star? ma?a: End gate: Qhat 4164432 Chat Canversaiion Apri! 4? 201$ 1:28:18 PM EDT Aptif 4. 2916 3:35:12 EDT 9,8. [Messag?? Dwight Tiitery {Messaga}? {iMessage}> $5 Dwighi Watery <4 (iMesaagej?: 0k what time? 0k. Have ya: been to health gap a?ics?? If nut, ii wauid be good to have you visit Let me knew either way. m; (iMessage}> just mm to talk 2th a few different xepics that we?ve aiready been. ctiscussing? but figure 81 parser; is best work? i have been to the Center?s office. bu! happy meet 31 either piaee ?ia?ghi ?tter}; <2 (iMessageP 0k Game on by the office as the staff would love to say heiio 13331 15:29 ?35:34 15:34 15:35 Item it}: Yype: Star! Bate: End gate: Chat Accaunt: 416453 Chat Cenversaiion April 5. 2518 5:25:59 PM EDT April 5. 2018 10:33:29 PM EDT <4 (ih?essageP. Dwight Titiery 4+ cgg.sitlenreza@gmasz.com {iMessagaP (iMessage}>. RG. WMEE ate} cross-refmenc?dm this Mae's-cantata i??essagg.? 3' {am-n2? ?3?ng ?ri?es?? .. .. i 3 313? (cm; i ia?mwmm? .i Sorry I hit qung key. Brass; gaggle fee! very passionaie abagi thatcammuaiiy and i think if win rea?y hurt yen: in a mayoral race. Secom?y. gii must 261% yea that afyou have a Jack persan who voiad the FC deal: he make wit: have a very very slrang ieg 11pm ih?a plank against you? We know j? pmbab?y not be szmema? but I have tasay this to- yam althaugh rm 3 We reguctantbut i keep feeiing this in my spirit and i?m; 5:132:an this with 319;: ton?dentiaiiy? dc: net count (mi Dennard. She is comir?ig an very strong in the mack cammunity and liked, Paiziics :5 959:3! unpredtciable and people do change war time. She impresses me as a person ihai has are-a! :1 ambition although it my {101 news-satay through her exterior. Yea wan: {a be on {he rigid maze cf {ha black communiiy on this especiafiy affer Jan has iat Us down so hadiy. Swiss: scams f?a: R623 msa?eac ?abia: message. handia. chm, Size: 22(962112 bytes) wm?iasmza ;Whimw You?re my {dead Would not animate an puhsiciy :f you gs in a differani direction. find because you are my friend, 2 wolgidn?i fee} oomfodabie in 510an ma? However i mu 6 iove tag see you be cn-itse side of the: pecpie?s ?hink mas Mi? reaily establish ycu in the mack cammumty far greater than supparting me my manager, Perm}, mack peopie need Same visebfe and Signi?cant Wins. 'Swmead a 52?s? {Magma Rm: ?Emma 5:52;? mauve-a; Sauna-a ?le: FAG '5 (Tam: messags. handfa, chat. Sii? M18 20:33:21 I think ynu?re making {he bigges: politi'cai gimsatairzre, Eliack community w?ii'tum Its black on you. They see yam no different {hen Cmniey may, . Stalusi?ew Da?wmdz?f??ms mama mum-e; Rand: #5131913 Saunas} ?ie: {Tahie mnxaage. handim chat, Size: 228752112123:an W53 mama-A?m?-?gmmnanmw. .3 (Web; mgr} My phone Was ringing off the back with text messages-and actual 125.115. Very broad speoirwn 0f peapie who Beiieve you are 'portyaying the bias}; cemmu?nuy. Them is m: passibie way thai yaw can make Quad with any asapadcaga for Mack people who-have suffered as a r3518; 50f haw we were Hagar} by urban {anewai? and new a soccer statiium. Many mack pecpfe are saying ghat they?ve given you their ?2165 bu; gw?n?n it {:nrmes dam to regatly hard'issues in favor of the bis-pk community. you do a song and dance; When white panama teii you what they want, you 155353;": and do what me}! ask. However, when bled: peopte ask for what may wani, whitewhites always they know what?s best for us, ifm sharing with am: what is be??ng said. igusi don?t think 291: gel the gravigy 0? {he damage Ehai wi? be dqne in mining that saccer stadium dam in the last b?st0ricai neighborhmd or black peopleXDu won?t be able {3 aveccome 21?55:w As you: friend and ccn?d an: piease don?t make this poii?cai mistake. smug: Rent: ,Sadmmd: warms 8.10 are Mame-a: Emmi-imam mm c- a; Steam Yype: Start Date: E116 Bate: Chat ?ccouni: Chat Conversatian. April 13, 2818 9:41:16 AM EDT Apr?i 13, 2018 13:45:58 Mei (Messagep. Dwight ??iiery <4 niggsittentei?mmaiimm (Message)? (ih?iassegeja PB. Dwigh?i Tiller}: <4 {zla?essagep Sunday, i will have an op-ed piece in the Enquirer which 1 09:41 have puts this whale ?lling in perspective. i am deeply cancemed lhai yea? pasi?m an this will affeci future political .ambitlcn. Smilherman and cihers have been working hard 3% findinga way to have real negativa impact an you. The canversa?on deeg in the black cammuniiy is not very favorablg garlicularly in regards it: year position simply dcn?l knaw haw you will be able in overcome the oppasllion to year pasitim in regards in ibis mailer. I share this you as a faithful and icyal friend. i hnpe ihal yea can find a way to not support this siadium; truly believe that this will some back to hurl. you in ways you can't see new. RS. (Message? Thank you; Dwight, I?ll look forward is reading your column. 5 09:56 did my best to lay out my reasonsfn'r my gositian in great detail. greatly respecl yaur di??fengg in? amnion. The schoais piece was a non?negotiable far'me? and when that piece came together (along WI other aspects}. I believe in the Quad this propmal can defer the cammUniiy. i also understand that if lhis vole; 0r any ulnar vale. causes me to ml have a failure in public service, 1 can live wiih that as long as knaw i did what 3 believe {an be the right-thing. Shrive #3 mam Type: Start Date: Emi bate: Chat 458543 Chat Conversa?on March 15, 2813 10:3?:55 PM EDT Marsh 15, 2618 16131255 PM EDT Dem-k Bani-nan 4+ (55956533952113. P33- Seeibach (Message); {iMessageja Chris Derek Bauman (iMessage)> ?tmage-?i .Egg 23:3? 2mm If}: Yype: ?ize: Cusiodia?: Ema Farm: ?upiica?as: mm ?ash: image 458544 JPEG Image 286 gm (288.9% hyies) PG Siilenfeid 554216 9:3? ?it mitt tet i? tweet ?if @itendorawHeseBex Repiying to @ChrieCit?iciBiz When Noted fer the mayor in 2013A thought his critics were petty. in 2018, it seems his critics don?t hit him hard enough. i?m not an avid Black fan, but at least he is standing up to the mayor's bullying and nonsense. ?May we live in interesting times.? 3/15/18, 7:51 PM 2 Likes tit a; Tweet year reply #4 Shrive #5 Has Cranley said a singie thing abeut pedestrian safety? ?mu and have been wnrking on it for years. Another chiid hit today. He says nothing. Smitherman just new talking abcut it. Ynu think Jasnn Williams WEN reperi? on this? Shrive - ?6 Brian Shrive (note it is a keywora request} Reguest #1 To/From: Harry Black Date nge: 3/1/18 4/9/18 Tens, emails from personal account, Facebook/Twitter direct messages for the following 996999993 John Greeley, C, Cranley, or John; Christopher Smitherman, Chris Smitherman, or Smitherman; Race, racial tensions, race riots, powder keg; Fire, ?ring, termination, or resignation; John Curp, JC, or Carp; Whistleblower; Strip club, sex, or sexual harassment; Drugs, alcohol, alcoholic, addict, addiction, or intervention; Dan Hils, or Hils; and Center for Closing the Healthcare Gap, Healthcare Gap, Dwight Tillery, Tillery Responsive: See attached Reguest #2 To/From: David Mann Date Range: 1/1/19-3/14/19 Texts, emails from personal account, Facebook/Twitter direct messages for the following: 6 Smitherman; Funeral; Gang of Five; and Apology or apologize; Response: None Reg Best #1 Item IQ: 298416 Type: Conversation Start Date: March 2018 8:23:35 AM EST End Date: March 7, 2018 8:34:33 AM EST Phone Number: Wendeii Young <15134856759>, Harry Black <1513507??262>, Amy Murray <15132901196>, Chris Seilbaoh <1 51 33484329>, John Craniey <15135357643>, Christopher Smithermao <15136590774>, David Mann <15137034684>Jamaya Dennard <15134170743>, PE, Sittenfetd <15133652404>, 15135517500, Jeff Pastor <19375032614>, Rocky Merz ?5133681620:- Chat Account: Harry Biack <+15135077262 Wendel! Young ?15134856759 Christopher Smitherman <+15136590?74 (SMSP, Jeff Pastor <+19375032614 +15135517500 (8M8), Tamaya Demand <+15134170743 John Craniey <+1513535?643 P.G. Sittenfeld ?15133652404 Amy Murray ?15132901196 Chris Setibach ?15133484329 David Mann <+1513?034684 Rocky Merz <+15133681620 Size: 1 KB (1,089 bytes) Custodian: Greg Landsman nil-act Parent ID: 521552 Recipient Count: 11 Visibie Recipient 11 Count: Message Count: 2 Message Hash: ?3091 74c99c8300?1947900e840abb6453 Original View 1 page 19-? Harry Stack <+i51350737262 CPD: Last evening the Enquirer posted a story about a 08:23 standard internai CPD audit regarding overtime. This audit has not yet been completed by CPD, nor released and is not: something that-would ordinariiy come to my of?ce This audit initiative is a standard internai CPD administratiVe activity that is stiil in progress. The foot that the Enquirer has it in its current draft form to concerning, and reinforces my ongoing concern- rotated to a rogue eiement wtthin the Department that Seeks to be disruptive and insubordinate reietive to issue 5 and the reaiity that you have an African American Police Chief and City Manager. This rogue etement is corrupt. it ultimately may require the intervention of outside law enforcement to ferret out The Enquirer is oomplioit in this -behavior__ _Via an FYI, we wit] provide a copy of dooument with additional context. Wendeti Young ?15134856759 i' 08:34 item H3: 2299842 Type: SMSIMMS Conversation Start Date: Aprii 4, 2818 3:34:15 PM EDT End Date: Aprii 4, 2018 2:24:32 PM EDT Phone Number: Wendeil Young <15134856758>, Harry Biack <15135077282>, Tamara Harkavey <1513?022727>, Amy Murray <15132901196>, Chris Seitbach <15133484328>, Chrisiopher Smitherman ?51365807742 David Mann (15137034684). P.G. Sittenfetd <15383652404>, Jeff Pastor <183?5032814>, Rocky Merz <15133681820>, 15138488188 Chat Account: Harry Black ?15135077282 Wanda}! Young <+15134853?59 Tamara Harkavey Jeff Pastor <+19375032614 (SMSP, Christopher Smitherman +15136460186 (SMSL P.G. Sittenfeid (8848)}, Amy Murray <+15132901196 (SMSP, Chris Sellbach <+15133484329 Rocky Merz ?35133681620 (SMSP. David Mann <+15137034884 Size: 1 KB (1,287 bytes) Custodian: Greg Landsman Direct Parent iD: 521552 Recipient Count: 18 Visible Recipient '30 Count: Message Count: 3 M95 Hash: Message Hash: Original View 1 page 1 9?1 Harry Black <+151350?7262 i will be releasing the below Statement momentarily. Wanted to 13:34 share with you prior, ?This remains an unfortunate and regrettable situation for all involved Let me be clear, my instructions to staff have been to continue with business as usual As professionals we will continue. to get the Work of running the City done on behalf of our residents Visitors and commuters. While am the admit, and have theithere is always room for improvement 1 have no concerns about how have conducted myself as a profeseionei and am preud of the feeling we have enhievecl as a City Government Disappornungly; es this has new morphed into a quaSi-j?diClal exercise Including morn Video?taped testimony, have requested 20, be provaded the reguisite oatside legal representatlon as ?it relates to my role as City Manager Therefore this Is all i have to say et this time? Wendell Young ?15134856759 Tamara Harkavey <+15137022?27 Harry thank you for this heads up and all your championship of 14:24 usT item ID: 299444 Type: SMSIMMS Conversation Start Date: Aprii 5, 2013 10:27:44 AM EDT End Date: Aprii 5, 2018 11:13:48 AM EDT Phone hinmber: Chris Setibach <15133484329>, Wendei! Young <15134856?59>. Harry Biack c1513507?262>, Amy Murray <15132901196>, John Cranley <15135357643>, David Mann <15137034684>, Tamaya Dennard 15135517500, Jeff Pastor <19375032614>, Rocky Mex: <15133681620>, 15136460188 Chat Account: Harry Black Wendeil Young <+15134856?59 (SMSP, Chr?s Selihach <:+1513:3484329 (SMSP, Jeff Pastor <+193?5032614 +15135517500 (8M8), Tamaya Dennard ?15134170743 John Cranley <+15135357643 +15186460186 (8M8). Amy Murray <+15132901196 David Mann ?1513034684 Rocky Merz ?or-15133681620 Size: 1 KB (1,035 bytes} Custodian: Greg Landsman Direct Parent ID: 521552 Recipient Count: 10 Visibie Recipient 10 Count Message Count: 4 M05 Hash: Message Hash: Original View 1 page Chris Selibach <+15133484329 Manager. I'm in this "Sexuat Harassment training" and the. 10:27 presenter just played a video where the word was said and repeated severai times it made everyone incredibly I uncomfortabie and was completely inappropriate Whiie we need to talk about raciai discrimination this. was absoiuteiy not the right way to do it. Piease talk to HR who? is doing this presentation, ASAP. Harry Biack <+15135077262 win dot! - 70329 Thank you fen-bringing this to my attention. ispoke with HR and 10:59 they are'addreseing this issue. For- the subsequent trainings . they wilt remove the video including the offeneive language and repiace With other Vid80(5} that make the point they were trying to COHVGY . . . . . . . Wendeii Young <+15134856759 Hairy. 5' i: . I ?313 3 Reguest