KING com: r424 r? . s; No Hearing Set Hon. Judge Bradshaw IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY ARTHUR WEST, plaintiff, Vs. SEATTLE CITY COUNCIL, et al, defendants. No. 18-2-1494278 (consolidated) NOTICE OF APPEAL Comes now plaintiff/appellant West and respectfully provides notice of his intent to appeal, to Division I of the Court of Appeals, the following Orders; (1.) the Order of the Trial Court of April 26, 2019, granting Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment and dismissing West's claims regarding Violations 42.30; (2.) the Order of the Trial Court of May 9, 2019 denying Plaintiff? 5 Motion for Summary Judgment; and (3.) the Order of the Trial Court of May 9, 2019, denying Plaintiff?s CR 56(t) Motion. The City was represented by Pete Holmes and Bruce Wiley. 1 NOTICE OF APPEAL Arthur West 128 State Ave. NE #1497 Olympia, Washington 98501 Plaintiff West acted on his own behalf. Appellant West seeks: (1.) An Order of the Appellate Court vacating the Orders designated above. (2.) An Order of Remand to the Trial Court with instructions to ?nd that the defendants violated the OPMA and to to enter judgment for the plaintiff on all cw A HUR WEST claims in the Amended Complaint. Done May 9, 2019, in Olympia, Washington. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1, Arthur West, certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that I caused to be served a copy of Appellant?s Notie of Appeal to the parties, electronically, by email on or about May 9, 2019, to the addresses listed as followszl Peter S. Holmes, WSBA #15787 Gary Smith, WSBA #29718 Michael K. Ryan, WSBA #3209ISeattle Attorney?s Of?ce 701 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 98104 michaelryan?seattlegov David N. Bruce, WSBA #15237 Stephen C. Willey, WSBA #24499 Michele L. Stephen, WSBA #39458 1425 Fourth Avenue, Suite 800 Seattle, WA 98101 2 Arthur West NOTICE 126 state Ave. NE #1497 OF APPEAL Olympia, Washington 98561 20 2] 22 23 24 The Honorable Timothy A. Bradshaw Noted for Hearing: April 26, 2019 at 1:30 p.m. Oral Argumem Scheduled SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING JAMES EGAN, individually, Plaintiff, V. CITY OF SEATTLE, a Washington municipal corporation, Defendant. (Consolidated) JUDGMENT ARTHUR WEST, Plaintiff, V. SEATTLE CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF SEATTLE, LISA HERBOLD, BRUCE HARRELL, KSHAMA SAWANT, ROB JOHNSON. DEBORA JUAREZ, MIKE SALLY BAGSHAW. TERESA MOSQUEDA. LORENA GONZALEZ, Defendants. ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT -l NO. 18-2?14942-8 SEA 0RD GRANTING MOTION FOR SUMMARY Peter 8. Holmes Seattle City Attorney 70] 51h Avenue. Suite 2050 Seattle. WA 98 [04-7097 (206) (134-8200 Ix.) 20 2] 22 23 THIS MATTER came before the Court on Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment (the ?Motion"), and the Court having considered: Defendants' Motion; Declaration ofSally Bagshaw; Declaration of Lorena Gonzalez; Declaration of Bruce Harrell and the exhibits thereto; Declaration of Lisa Herbold; (0 Declaration of Rob Johnson; Declaration of Debora Juarez; Declaration of Teresa Mosqueda; Declaration ol?Mike O?Brien; 0) Declaration of Gabriella Sanders and the exhibits thereto; Appendix of non?Washington Authorities in support of Defendants? Motion; (1) Plaintiff West?s Reply in Opposition to Defendants? Motion; Defendants? Reply; Declaration of Stephanie Formas; and (0) Supplemental Declaration of Gabriella Sanders; and being familiar with the files and pleadings in this matter, and having heard oral argument from counsel on April 26. 2019. is fully advised. NOW, THEREFORE, the Court rules as follows: Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment is hereby GRANTED, and Plaintiff Arthur West?s claims herein and his Second Amended Complaint are dismissed with prejudice. IT DERED. Mfotx?y xi" 8 ash-L DATED thisfzg?iof April 201 Th; Honorable Ti1\iiothy A. Bradsha Peter 5. Holmes ORDER MOTION FOR Seattle City Attorney SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 2 51h Avenue. Sutte 2(l5t) Seattle. WA 98 [0-1-7007 (20(1) IQ b) PRESENTED BY: Peter S. Holmes Seattle City Attorney By s/Peler S. Holmes Peter S. Holmes, WSBA #15787 Gary Smith, WSBA #29718 Assistant City Attorney Seattle City Attorney?s Of?ce 701 Fifth Ave., Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 98104 Telephone: (206) 684-8200 Email: pete.holmes@seattle.gov Email: gary.smith@seattle.gpv SAVITT BRUCE WILLEY LLP By s/David N. Bruce David N. Bruce, WSBA #15237 Stephen C. Willey, WSBA #24499 Michele L. Stephen, WSBA #39458 1425 Fourth Avenue Suite 800 Seattle, Washington 98101-2272 Telephone: 206.749.0500 Facsimile: 206.749.0600 Email: Email: Email: Attorneysfor Defendants ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 3 Peter 8. Holmes Seattle City Attorney 70 51h Avenue. Suite 2050 Seattle. WA 98104-7097 (20(1) 684-8201) The Honorable Timothy A. Bradshaw SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING JAMES EGAN, individualiy, Plaintiff, v. CITY OF SEATTLE, a Washington munic?pal corporation, Defcn?am. N0. ARTHUR WEST, Plaintiff, v. SEATTLE CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF SEATTLE, LISA HERBOLD, BRUCE HARRELL, KSHAMA SAWANT, ROB JOHNSON, DEBORA JUARBZ, MIKE SALLY BAGSHAW, TERESA MOSQUBDA, LORENA GONZALEZ, Defendants. ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT I SEA (Consoiidated) ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT Pem- S. Hatches Sam: City $130136)? ?70! 5th Avenue, Suite 2050 Scenic, WA {206) 684-3200 (C) (H) (0) THIS MATTER came before the Court on Piaintiff West?s Motion for Partiai Summary Judgment (the ?Motion?), and the Court having considered: Piaintiff?s Motion, and exhibits; Plaintiff West?s Declaration and Transcript Excerpts (see Sub No. 140); Plaintiff West?s Appendix of Out of State Authorities; Defendants? Opposition; Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment (see Sub No. 125); Deciaration of? Saily Bagshaw (see Sub No. Declaration of Lorena Gonz?lez (see Sub No. 127); Declaration of Bruce Harrell and the exhibits thereto (see Sub No. 128); Declaration of Lisa Herbold (see Sub No. 129); Declaration of Rob John?on (see Sub No. 130); Declaration of Debora Juarez (522 Sub No. 131); Declaration of Teresa Mosqueda (see Sub No. i32); Declaration of Mike O?Brien (see Sub No. 133); Declaration of Gabriella Sanders and the exhibits thereto (see Sub No. 134); Appendices of non?Washington Authorities in support of Defendants? Motion for Summary judgment and in Opposition to Piainti?? West?s Motion; and Plaintiff West?s Reply, and exhibits; Plaintiff West?s Reply in Opposition, and exhibits. and being familiar with the ?les and pleadings in this matter, and having heard oral argument from counsel on April 26, 2019, is fully advised. ii NOW, THEREFORE, the Court rules as foilows: Plaintiff West?s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment is hereby DENIED. IS SO ORDERED. ii Peters. Holmes ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF MOTION FOR Seattle City Attorney PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 2 70? 3959 Seams, WA 98104-7097 684-8209 33? DATED this 0 1 day of May, 2019. Peter S. Holmes Seattle City Attorney By s/Pez?er S. Hotmes Peter 8. Holmes, WSBA #15787 Gary Smith, WSBA #29718 Assistant City Attorney 863211: City Attomey?s Of?ce 701 Fifth Ave., Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 98104 Telephone: (206) 684-8200 Emait: EmaiI: gaggmithfi?gg?lggov SAVITT BRUCE WILLEY LLP stavid N. Bruce By David N. Bruce, WSBA #15237 Stephen C. Wiilcy, WSBA #24499 Michel: L. Stephen, WSBA #39458 1425 Fourth Avcnue Suite 800 Scattie, Washington 98101?2272 Tc1cphone: 206.749.0500 Facsim?c: 206.749.0600 Emaii: (1 me Emaii: Email: Atromeysfor Defendants 91W ARTHUR WEST Plaintiff ORDER DENYING PLA TNTIFF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 3 Chjlonombl? Timofhy A. Bradshaw PRESENTED BY: Put! S. Holmes Sam: tty Attorney 701 SL1: Avenue, Sum: 2050 Seame. WA 981033097 (206) 684-8200 The Honorable Timothy A. Bradshaw SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING JAMES EGAN, individually, Plaintiff, v. CITY OF SEATTLE, a Washington municipal corporation, Defendant. NO. (Conso?dated) ARTHUR WEST, Plaintiff, v. SEATTLE CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF SEATTLE, HERBOLD, BRUCE HARRELL, KSHAMA SAWANT, ROB JOHNSON, DEBORA JUAREZ, MIKE SALLY BAGSHAW, TERESA MOSQUEDA, LORENA GONZALEZ, Defendants? ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF CR 560?) MOTION . I 18~2-l4942-8 SEA ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF CR 56(1) MOTION was. Rotates Scam: City Attorney 703 511'! Suite 211150 Sank, WA 381344097 (266) THIS MATTER cam: before the Court on Plaintiff West?s CR 560) Motion (the ?Motion?), and the Court having considered: (3) Plaintiff? Malian; Dcfendants? Opposition; Declaration of Gabriella Sanders and the exhibits thereto; and Plaintiff West?s Reply (?Plaintiff West?s Declaration in support of CR 560) Motion?); and being familiar with the ?les and pleadings in this matter, and having heard oral argument from counsel on April 26, 2019, is fully advised. NOW, THEREFORE, the Court rules as follows: Plaintiff West?s CR 560?) Motion is hereby DENIED. IT IS SO ORDERED. 44A DATED this 31 day ofMay, 2019. Honorable Timothy A. Bradshaw . Peters. Holmes ORDER DENY ENG PLAINTIFF CR 56m MOTION Seattle Cny Axiom - 2 70! 51h Avenue, Sum: 2050 Sank, WA 982643097 {20? 68%3?269 PRESENTED BY: Peter S. Holmes Seattle City Attorney By s/Peter S. Holmes Peter S. Holmes, WSBA #15787 Gary Smith, WSBA #29718 Assistant City Attorney Seattle City Attorney?s Of?ce 701 Fi?h Ave., Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 98104 Telephone: (206) 684-8200 Email: goggholmesf?iseanloggy Email: garrsmiths?scamggov BRUCE WILLEY s/David N. Bruce By David N. Bruce, WSBA #1523? Stephen C. Willey, WSBA #24499 Michele L. Stephen, WSBA #39458 1425 Fourth Avenue Suite 800 Seattle, Washington 98101 -2272 Telephonc: 206.749.0500 Facsimile: 206.749.0600 Email: Email: Email: WLL .c Attorneys for Defendants ARTHUR WEST Plaintiff ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF CR 56(1) MOTION - 3 Peter 5. Holmes Seattle City Attorney 701 501 Avenue, Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 981043097 (206) 684-8200