FILED The Honorable Timothy A. Bradshaw 2019 for Hearing: April 26. 2019 at 1:30 pm. KING COUNTY Oral Argument Scheduled SUPERIOR COURT CLERK CASE 18-2-14942?8 SEA SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING JAMES EGAN, individually. Plaintiff, v. CITY OF SEATTLE, a Washington municipal corporation, Defendant. ARTHUR WEST, Plaintiff, v. SEATTLE CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF SEATTLE, LISA HERBOLD. BRUCE IIARRELL, KSHAMA SAWANT, ROB JOHNSON. DEBORA JUAREZ, MIKE SALLY BAGSHAW, TERESA MOSQUEDA, LORENA GONZALEZ. Defendants. ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - I NO. 18?2?14942-8 SEA (Consolidated) I 0RD GRANTING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT Peter 5. Holmes Seattle Cit) Attorne} 7(ll 51h Avenue. Suite 2050 Seattle. WA 98104-7007 (20(3) 684-8200 Li.) U1 THIS MATTER came before the Court on Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment (the "Motion"), and the Court having considered: (D (0) Defendants' Motion; Declaration of Sally Bagshaw; Declaration of Lorena Gonzalez; Declaration of Bruce Harrell and the exhibits thereto; Declaration of Lisa Herbold; Declaration of Rob Johnson; Declaration of Debora Juarez; Declaration of Teresa Mosqueda; Declaration of Mike O?Brien; Declaration of Gabriella Sanders and the exhibits thereto; Appendix of non?Washington Authorities in support of Defendants? Motion; Plaintiff West?s Reply in Opposition to Defendants? Motion; Defendants" Reply; Declaration of Stephanie Formas; and Supplemental Declaration of Gabriella Sanders; and being familiar with the ?les and pleadings in this matter, and having heard oral argument from counsel on April 26. 2019, is fully advised. NOW, THEREFORE, the Court rules as follows: Defendants? Motion for Summary Judgment is hereby GRANTED, and Plaintiff Arthur West?s claims herein and his Second Amended Complaint are dismissed with prejudice. IT lsso DERED. 4k DATED thiwm April 2019. LT Honorable imothyAf. Bradshavg Peter S. ORDER FOR Scuttle Cit} Allorm?} SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 2 70] 51h Avenue. Suite 2050 WA 98l0-l-7097 1206) 684-8200 Ix) La) PRESENTED BY: Peter S. Holmes Seattle City Attorney By s/Peter S. Holmes Peter S. Holmes, WSBA #15787 Gary Smith, WSBA #29718 Assistant City Attorney Seattle City Attorney?s Of?ce 701 Fifth Ave., Suite 2050 Seattle, WA 98104 Telephone: (206) 684-8200 Email: pete.holmes@seattle.gov Email: gary.smith@seattle.gov SAVITT BRUCE WILLEY LLP By s/David N. Bruce David N. Bruce, WSBA #15237 Stephen C. Willey, WSBA #24499 Michele L. Stephen, WSBA #39458 1425 Fourth Avenue Suite 800 Seattle, Washington 98101-2272 Telephone: 206.749.0500 Facsimile: 206.749.0600 Email: Email: Email: Attorneys for Defendants ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 3 Peter 8. Holmes Scuttle Cit} 701 5th Avenue. Suite 2050 Scuttle. WA 98104-7097 (20(1) 68-1-3200