Nott, Dave From: Spaugy, Mary Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 7:53 AM To: Krauss, Connie Cc: Brown, Karen; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Testimony for Attachments: Fw: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing Wednesday April 17th; County Executive llene Shapiro Testimony Connie- can you print these off and have an extra copy on hand in case something happens to the copy that I give Ilene? Thanks! Mary E. Spaugy Executive Assistant County of Summit, Executive Ilene Shapiro 175 South Main Street, 8th Floor Akron, Ohio 44308 Phone: 330.643.2520 Fax: 330.643.2507 County of Summit . The High Point af Ohio ILENE ?a Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 8:56 PM To: Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fw: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Attachments: Witness List Order Electric Generation Subcommitteedocx; Roetzel 81 Andress - Conference Room 81 Parking.docx; Electric Generation Subcommittee 8! Hearing Announcementdocx Mary- Please print for Ilene's trip to Columbus on Wednesday. Thank you! From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 5:05 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; larry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; CSIZMADIA, Christine Subject: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Hello Everyone, Attached please find the following information related to the Electric Generation Subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, April 17th: 1. Order of Proponent Hearing Witnesses 2. Location of Roetzel Andress Offices Parking the offices are open from 8:00 am - 4:00 pm for our Proponent Witnesses 3. Members of the Electric Generation Subcommittee 8: Hearing Announcement If you need any assistance, please don?t hesitate to call me. Thanks so much for your continued support. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330-436-2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Sana?aim. Baum. . mangana- la.? nun: .no wwnJim. 0633504.. mufuwh?mmb ummumd rut 7.31m Koaan HMS T. .wdwm?. 300, Emmy?m?a mm .303. r: . memru?h. Hum wmagmmi?. Oran, 03min.uo??qnoas?mmoumw m. ?m Humanm w. aunt}. -. ..-.mqjm up. $00.63.. 336%.. .u .5. .. 0.1.. "mm? 5an m?u wcm?mmu Em .Qmam:3 db)? bum.m.mmim.m.m_.. noE?wcmeES Bumm noEaacm mcmwumum Hanna no: Jaw - midnigw ?Emu . an. ?mm nm mum 41.09.? nojm?wcnmo: m" mcmu?m 4.13%. no: an: - nwm?ama? um m- m?mmu m. 0333 no: 33? .6236: I Hunwnmum ?n my.? a 33. 3.9.2? 593333 I. m. ammo; mammd - n33: .. .3me ?hum ?mm. Omx lluw (?tl?J?dll'lJ'l?i j? ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENERGY GENERATION SCHEDULE MEMBERS Duh Tim. Malian Agni-Ila Apail 17, 2019 Room 121 Duwnmad Manama Mann 2019 March 1a, 201! March 12, 2019 February 12. 2019 mm. Hal-rum) ?56 of RPrese ANNOUNCELENT 01" com DEETING COME: Energy and. Natural Resonant Subcommittee on Energy Generation CO-CHAES: Did: Stein. Mchnel J- O'Bria: hm: Wednesday April 17. 2019 TIME: ROOM: Room 121 AGENDA BILL 529E593 HILE H3 6 Rep Calleuder. Cleans Ohio Clean Air Program In Hearing Rep Wilkin Pending Roma-a1 Proponent Cc: House Clerk Committee M-bm Committee Clerk Speaker?s O??ioe Assistant Mqioaity Floor Leader's Of?ce Caucus Sta?? Bill Sponsor Legislative In?nna?on Systems LSC Press Room Minority Latin?: 05:: Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, let Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 BTC Broad 5? BLoad The 3hio Statenogse capital?? gcapEGhaPalS? (0 John FJ-Wolfe . Rich Street . nw Head . mom-9t 'l a Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 9:00 PM To: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David Shapiro, Ilene; Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie Subject: County Executive Ilene Shapiro Testimony Attachments: Ilene Shapiro Testimony on HB6.docx Murphy? Per my text, here is the testimony for County Executive Shapiro. Please review and make sure that everything is still accurate after I edited the draft that was sent yesterday. Other than that, everything should be in order for Wednesday on our end. My understanding is that you will ?le on our behalf. Thank you! Jason Ilene Shapiro, County Executive County of Summit, Ohio Testimony before the Ohio Energy 8: Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation Mr. Chairman, Vice Chairman and members of the House Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation, my name is Ilene Shapiro and I am the County Executive for Summit County. Thank you for the opportunity to address you all today. I am here to testify in support of H3 6, which would create the Ohio Clean Air Program to support clean forms of energy generation, including Ohio?s nuclear plants. After hearing from all of the pr0ponents of this legislation, I hope you will understand the importance of advancing this legislation and how vital these nuclear facilities are to the economy and environment of our great State. Specifically, I am here today to support this legislation because it will assist FirstEnergy Solutions with continuing to generate electricity from its nuclear facilities in the State. FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities support more than 4,300 jobs in all parts of Ohio, not just in the counties in which the plants are located. Each of those employees, their families, and their communities, including Summit County, are depending on this subcommittee to advance H3 6. Each employee represents a highly skilled worker who will be forced to find a job elsewhere, uproot their family, pull their children from our schools and drain our communities of tax revenue and business activities. In Summit County alone, over 300 employees are employed at FirstEnergy Solutions? Akron headquarters, all of which may face these dif?cult situations if H3 6 is not passed into law. For each of the 700 FirstEnergy Solutions? employees at the nuclear facilities and the 300 at the Akron headquarters, there will be many more jobs lost from vendors and service providers throughout the State who will shut their doors and move away if the plants close. In Summit County alone, FirstEnergy Solutions has spent more than $9 million over the past five years with 80 vendors. It will be incredibly dif?cult to fill the void left for those vendors if the nuclear facilities are prematurely shutdown. Our County and many Ohio counties also depend on the signi?cant tax revenue generated directly and indirectly by the FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities. The state of Ohio collects about $30 million from the two nuclear facilities. That does not account for the additional revenue generated for the state and localities from related vendors, property taxes, sales taxes, and hotel taxes. And, as you can imagine, with over 300 employees, FirstEnergy Solutions is one of our major income tax payers in Summit County. My economic development team is currently working with representatives from the City of Akron and the Greater Akron Chamber to keep FirstEnergy Solutions? headquarters in Summit County. We want to see this company and its employees succeed and we should all be encouraged by the fact that FirstEnergy Solutions is committed to staying and growing in Ohio. While we are working hard at the local level to ensure the company?s ongoing success in Summit County, we need the State to be a partner in these efforts. Through H3 6, the State will ensure that FirstEnergy Solutions will remain in the energy generation business, thereby keeping and growing jobs in Summit County and Ohio. Finally, as County Executive, support any effort to provide our communities with clean air and a healthy environment. FirstEnergy Solutions? zero-carbon nuclear facilities are critical to our state?s clean air future. These two plants are responsible for 90 percent of Ohio?s carbon-free electricity generation. Furthermore, the facilities? nuclear-generated electricity is available 24/7 and at affordable prices, which are two necessary ingredients to help attract businesses and investments into our community. We can choose to move forward with clean, reliable nuclear energy or remain in the past and become less competitive in an ever-changing economy. On behalf of Summit County and our more than 540,000 residents, I urge you to support this legislation and preserve jobs, communities, and Ohio?s carbon-free nuclear future. Thank you. Nott, Dave From: Spaugy, Mary Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:51 PM To: Dodson, Jason; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: RE: IMPORTANT UPDATE Hearing Room Changed Updated the calendar. From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:49 PM To: Spaugy, Mary Krauss, Connie Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fw: IMPORTANT UPDATE Hearing Room Changed FYI- Please see below. From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:45 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com: mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.ioyce@orrvilon.com; tiovce@local310.com; larry@ibew245.com; ibgrant@ocic.biz: CSIZMADIA, Christine Cc: Christopher Curry; Juan Cespedes; Grif?ng, David L. Subject: IMPORTANT UPDATE - Hearing Room Changed The Energy Generation Subcommittee hearing on H36 has changed. It will now be conducted in the House Finance Room 313. Murphy From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:41 PM To: llshapironummitohmet; idodson@summitoh.net; Jerry.Cirino@Iakecountyohiogo mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.ioyce@orrvilon.com; larryQibew245.com; ibgrant@ocic.biz: CSIZMADIA, Christine Cc: Christopher Curry Juan Cespedes ; Grif?ng, David L. rif?n dl firstener cor .com> Subject: Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wed 4/17 Hello Everyone, Chris Curry Dewey Square, will be sending you your final written testimony for the Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing tomorrow. Your testimony will be ?led with Chairman Dick Stein this evening and then 1 downloaded to the iPads of the (5) committee members in the morning. We will have hardcopies of your testimony to distribute to the committee in the unlikely event the technology fails. For most of you I would suggest going directly to the State House Meeting Room 121. Our team plans to depart from Roetzel Andress at 8:30 AM for the 9:00 AM hearing and remain there all day. Reminder For those of you traveling directly to the State House: If you park at the statehouse in the underground parking garage signage is good. Look for the statehouse signs. Then once inside find the rotunda. There are guards and posted guides at information desks allover. It is in the main statehouse building under the house chamber on the first floor. Look for the highway patrol security at the side door of the statehouse to identify the house side. Look for room 121. The doors are all marked. Should be fairly easy to find or ask the patrol. If you have any questions, please don?t hesitate to call me. When you arrive at the State House, please send me a text message. Thanks again and safe travels. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330-436-2726 Mobile 330?730-8964 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Spaugy, Mary Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:18 PM To: Dodson, Jason; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: RE: Final Testimony for Wednesday Ilene will print it off and swap them out. Thanks. From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:16 PM To: Spaugy, Mary Krauss, Connie Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fwd: Final Testimony for Wednesday All- just a small update to Ilene's testimony tomorrow. Can you please see that she gets Thank you! Sent via the Samsung Galaxy 89+, an 5G Evolution capable smartphone Original message From: Christopher Curry Date: 4/16/19 3:11 PM (GMT-05 :00) To: "Shapiro, Ilene" "Dodson, ason" Cc: "Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David Subject: Final Testimony for Wednesday County Executive Shapiro attached please find an updated version of your testimony for tomorrow. We made a slight change to the intro paragraph to recognize Chairman O?Brien. Reps. Stein and O?Brien are both co-chairs of the subcommittee. A conference room at Roetzel and Andress are available tomorrow before or after your testimony. Roetzel Andress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, let Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 Please let me know if you have any questions. -Ch ris Nott, Dave From: Krauss, Connie Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:20 PM To: Spaugy, Mary; Dodson, Jason; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: RE: Final Testimony for Wednesday I have also printed the newest copy so will have with me as well. Connie Krauss Director, Community and Economic Development County of Summit, Executive Ilene Shapiro 175 S. Main Street, Akron OH 44308 (0) 330?643-2396 330-703-1034 Canal; at" Sal. at: - he ?2.23: o! {if no lawns SHAH so . From: Spaugy, Mary Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:18 PM To: Dodson, Jason; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: RE: Final Testimony for Wednesday Ilene will print it off and swap them out. Thanks. From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:16 PM To: Spaugy, Mary Krauss, Connie Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fwd: Final Testimony for Wednesday All-just a small update to Ilene's testimony tomorrow. Can you please see that she gets Thank you! Sent via the Samsung Galaxy 89+, an 5G Evolution capable smartphone Original message From: Christopher Curry Date: 4/16/19 3:11 PM To: "Shapiro, Ilene" "Dodson, Jason" 1 Cc: "Montler, (Grif?ng, David Subject: Final Testimony for Wednesday County Executive Shapiro attached please find an updated version of your testimony for tomorrow. We made a slight change to the intro paragraph to recognize Chairman O?Brien. Reps. Stein and O?Brien are both co-chairs of the subcommittee. A conference room at Roetzel and Andress are available tomorrow before or after your testimony. Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, 21$t Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 Please let me know if you have any questions. -Chris Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 9:09 PM To: Dodson, Jason; Shapiro, Ilene; Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie Subject: RE: County Executive Ilene Shapiro Testimony Jason/ Ilene, Thanks so much for rearranging your schedules to be there on Wednesday. I will make sure the testimony is filed and that copies are made for the Energy Generation Subcommittee members. Murphy From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 9:00 PM To: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Shapiro, Ilene Spaugy, Mary Krauss, Connie Subject: County Executive Ilene Shapiro Testimony Murphy? Per my text, here is the testimony for County Executive Shapiro. Please review and make sure that everything is still accurate after I edited the draft that was sent yesterday. Other than that, everything should be in order for Wednesday on our end. My understanding is that you will ?le on our behalf. Thank you! Jason The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 15, 2019 10:53 AM To: edklco@northperry.org; ronaldeyoun9974 @gmail.com; rregovich@cityofwillowick.com; MRantaIa@lcport.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; perrycouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler; ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Slauterbeck; Jamie Beier; Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co); Guy Parmigian; Keeton, Cajon; Miller, Scott; Hal Hawk; Beth Hannam; Jill Simpson; Matthew Mackowiak; ilshapiro@aol.com; Shapiro, Ilene; par5@akronohio.gov; thegeorgegoup@aol.com; Phillips, Aaron (yahoo.com) Cc: Grif?ng, David 'Christopher Curry'; 'Jonathan Drobis'; Zele, Wendy Rosebrock, Hans D'Arcy, Sean Subject: RE: ACTION REQUIRED HB 6 Update Hello Everyone, Update on Sub HB 6 The Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee will be meeting today at'2:00 pm and members will cast votes to accept Sub H8 6. We understand that on Wednesday, July the Committee will vote to move HB 6 to the full Senate. The full Senate will then vote on H8 6 at 1:30 pm during their scheduled Session. We are encouraging all supportive stakeholders to attend the Senate Session on Wednesday. It is our last chance to demonstrate support for HB 6 and influence members to vote for its passage. We?re suggesting that our supporters arrive by 12:30 pm. Any questions, please don?t hesitate to call me. Thanks, Murphy Montler 330-730?8964 From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 8, 2019 10:08 AM To: edklco@northperry.org; ronaIdeyoung974@gmail.com; rregovich@cityofwillowickcom; thompsonj@perry- Iake.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; La rry.Greene@lakecountyohiogov; Joe.Busher@Ia kecountyohiogov; jagessic@gmail.com; perrycouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Slauterbeck Jamie Beier Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co Guy Parmigian Keeton, Cajon Miller, Scott Hal Hawk Beth Hannam Jill Simpson Matthew Mackowiak ilshapiro@aol.com; llshapiro@summitoh.net; par5@akronohio.gov; thegeorgegoup@aol.com; surehousepastor@yahoo.com Cc: Griffing, David L. 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. D'Arcy, Sean Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Update Thank you for your continued leadership in Columbus to advocate for H8 6 and engaging your constituents to do the same. We are on the final stretch and now more than ever we need to flood our elected officials with a strong message of support for H3 6. Update H8 6 currently sits in the Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee chaired by Senator Steve Wilson. Since being introduced in the Senate, a sub bill to H3 6 was created and 57 amendments have been offered by Proponents, Opponents and Interested Parties for the Committee to consider. From recent discussions with Senate Leadership, we understand that H3 6 will be voted on by the full Senate no later than Wednesday, July 1 While no Senate Energy 8: Public Utilities Committee hearings are scheduled this week, please understand that much is happening behind the scenes and the process could be accelerated with little notice. We will keep you informed as new information becomes available. How can you help? There are only (8) business days remaining to have our voices heard before this important vote. We need eveEyone (family, friends 8: neighbors) to make calls ?y and throughout the weekend. Attached is a list of all Ohio Senators with phone numbers and email addresses. Please focus on calling and emailing the highlighted Senators who are in leadership or on the committee that is considering H3 6. We?ve also pasted the contact information for the highest priority Senators below especially Senators Obhof Wilson. The messages to support H8 6 should be very short and sweet: 1. Start the call email off with a strong message of appreciation for their hard work working extended hours and weekends to get this done 2. Be direct and ask the Senator to please support H3 6 because it protects 4300 Ohio jobs and strengthens Ohio?s energy future If you are not able to talk to a stajf)r person, please leave a message urging the Senator to support H3 6. Thank you for your help! Murphy Montler 330-730-8964 President Larry Obhof (614) 466-7505 Sen. Steve Wilson (614) 466-9737 Sen. Robert McColley (614) 466-8150 Sen. Sandra Williams (614) 466-4857 Sen. Andrew Brenner (614) 466-8086 Sen. Dave Burke (614) 466-8049 Sen. Hearcel Craig (614) 466-5131 Sen. Matt Dolan (614) 466?8056 Sen. John Eklund (614) 644-7718 Sen. Frank Hoagland (614) 466-6508 Sen. Matt Huffman (614) 466-7584 Sen. Sean O'Brien (614) 466-7182 Sen. Bob Peterson (614) 466-8156 Sen. Michael Rulli (614) 466-8285 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 22, 2019 8:17 AM To: edklco@northperry.org; ronaldeyoun9974 @gmail.com; rregovich@cityofwillowick.com; jmcdonald@perryfire.info; MRantala@lcport.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; perrycouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler; ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Slauterbeck; Jamie Beier; Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co); Guy Parmigian; Keeton, Cajon; Miller, Scott; Hal Hawk; Beth Hannam; Jill Simpson; Matthew Mackowiak; ilshapiro@aol.com; Shapiro, Ilene; par5@akronohio.gov; thegeorgegoup@aol.com; Phillips, Aaron (yahoo.com) Cc: Griffing, David 'Christopher Curry'; 'Jonathan Drobis?; Zele, Wendy Rosebrock, Hans D'Arcy, Sean; Bailey, Joel D. Subject: RE: ACTION REQUIRED H8 6 Senate Vote Good Morning Everyone, It is our understanding that the Ohio House of Representatives will hold a special session tomorrow, Tuesday, July 23rd, at 11:00 am, to vote on 6. Please help us ?ll the House Chambers to demonstrate support for passage of H86. Murphy From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, July 16, 2019 9:55 AM To: edklco@northperry.org; ronaldeyoung974@gmail.com; thompsonj@perry- lake.org; MRantala@lcport.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; La rry.Greene @lakecountyohio.gov; Joe.Busher@lakecountyohio.gov; jagessic@gmail.com; perrycouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Slauterbeck Jamie Beier Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co Guy Parmigian Keeton, Cajon Miller, Scott Hal Hawk Beth Hannam Jill Simpson Matthew Mackowiak ilshapiro@aol.com; llshapiro@summitoh.net; par5@akronohio.gov; thegeorgegoup@aol.com; surehousepastor@yahoo.com Cc: Grif?ng, David L. 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. D'Arcy, Sean Bailey, Joel D. Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Ohio Senate Session Details please help us fill the Senate Chambers with supporters Date: Wednesday, July 1:30 pm Location: Ohio State House - 1 Capitol Square, Columbus, OH 43215 1 Suggested arrival time: Noon Other note: Enter the State House from the 3'd Street entrance Supporter Meeting Location: Ladies? Gallery Room (main floor) security can direct you there (see the map below) State Capital Contact: Murphy Montler (FES) 330-730-8964 Long 31'. E. i-Eyu'u're miing by carsuggest day parkingat the PM Long s: a . Renaissance Hotel - 5n 3rd :2 Columbus,OI-I 4321s in} lop Kitchen . 8. Cocktaiis - E. leolw . lime: Dorsntowt -: 1311? 5? I: Starbucks SuperChci . Breakfast 8 More The Leveque Tower Residences {1 if I If you Have employees travelling" Ev l; The phio Statehouse bus, unload at the State House 3e - Historical! New Street entrance. The address is 1 1 an 3r audio toms 5! Capitol Square, ?qu mime.3 DH g. - 43215 :7 92 My mnbile nu mber is {330: T30- Capitol Square Review ?1 896-! . (I150 mm ma BLVNEIS mt mummu an: From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2019 12:34 PM To: 'edklco@northperry.org' 'ronaIdeyoungQ74@gmail.com' 'MRantala@lcport.org' 'kstonebrook75@gmail.com' 'jagessic@gmail.com' 'dphillips@ibew673.org' 'mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Mark Coppeler' 'ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Rhonda Slauterbeck' 'Jamie Beier' 'Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co' 'Guy Parmigian' armi ian 'Keeton, Cajon' 'Miller, Scott' Cc: Griffing, David L. 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. 'D'Arcy, Sean' Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Hello Everyone, The next scheduled Senate session is Wednesday, July 17th, at 1:30 pm. It continues to be our understanding that the Senate will vote on H3 6 during this session. Until we hear otherwise, our plan is to mobilize people to the state house for the Senate vote. Please help us fill the Senate chambers with supporters. I would suggest having people arrive no later than 12:30 pm. If anything changes, I will notify you immediately. Thanks, Murphy Montler 330?730-8964 From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 8, 2019 10:08 AM To: ed klco@northperrv.org: Jerrv.Cirino@la kecountyohiogov: ronaIdevoun3974@gmail.com; rregovich@citvofwiliowick.com; thom psoni@nerry- lake.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; Joe.Busher@lakecountvohiogov: iagessicngailcom: dphillips@ibew673.org: mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Sla uterbeck ; 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. D'Arcy, Sean Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Update Thank you for your continued leadership in Columbus to advocate for H8 6 and engaging your constituents to do the same. We are on the ?nal stretch and now more than ever we need to flood our elected of?cials with a strong message of support for H3 6. Update H8 6 currently sits in the Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee chaired by Senator Steve Wilson. Since being introduced in the Senate, a sub bill to H3 6 was created and 5 7 amendments have been offered by Proponents, Opponents and Interested Parties for the Committee to consider. From recent discussions with Senate Leadership, we understand that H8 6 will be voted on by the full Senate no later than Wednesday, July 1 While no Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee hearings are scheduled this week, please understand that much is happening behind the 4 scenes and the process could be accelerated with little notice. We will keep you informed as new information becomes available. How can you help? There are only (8) business days remaining to have our voices heard before this important vote. We need evemone (family, friends neighbors) to make calls and throughout the weekend. Attached is a list of all Ohio Senators with phone numbers and email addresses. Please focus on calling and emailing the highlighted Senators who are in leadership or on the committee that is considering HB 6. We?ve also pasted the contact information for the highest priority Senators below eSpeciaIIy Senators Obhof Wilson. The messages to support H8 6 should be very short and sweet: 1. Start the call 8: email off with a strong message of appreciation for their hard work? working extended hours and weekends to get this done 2. Be direct and ask the Senator to please support H3 6 because it protects 4300 Ohio jobs and strengthens Ohio?s energy future If you are not able to talk to a sta?? person, please leave a message urging the Senator to support H8 6. Thank you for your help! Murphy Montler 330-730-8964 President Larry Obhof (614) 466?7505 Sen. Steve Wilson (614) 466-9737 Sen. Robert McColley (614) 466-8150 Sen. Sandra Williams (614)466-4857 Sen. Andrew Brenner (614) 466-8086 Sen. Dave Burke (614)466-8049 Sen. Hearcel Craig (614) 466-5131 Sen. Matt Dolan (614) 466-8056 Sen. John Eklund (614) 644?7718 Sen. Frank Hoagland (614) 466-6508 Sen. Matt Huffman (614) 466-7584 Sen. Sean O'Brien (614) 466-7182 Sen. Bob Peterson (614) 466-8156 Sen. Michael Rulli (614) 466-8285 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or capying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 8:17 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; mJoyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; arry@ibew245.com; CSIZMADIA, Christine Subject: Parking at the State House For those of you traveling directly to the State House: If you park at the statehouse in the underground parking garage signage is good. Look for the statehouse signs. Then once inside ?nd the rotunda. There are guards and posted guides at information desks all over. It is in the main statehouse building under the house chamber on the ?rst floor. Look for the highway patrol security at the side door of the statehouse to identify the house side. Look for room 121. The doors are all marked. Should be fairly easy to ?nd or ask the patrol. From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 5:06 PM To: ilshapiro@summitoh.net; jdodson@summitoh.net; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; Iarry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; CSIZMADIA, Christine Subject: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Hello Everyone, Attached please find the following information related to the Electric Generation Subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, April 17th: 1. Order of Proponent Hearing Witnesses 2. Location of Roetzel Andress Offices Parking? the offices are open from 8:00 am ?4:00 pm for our Preponent Witnesses 3. Members of the Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing Announcement If you need any assistance, please don?t hesitate to call me. Thanks so much for your continued support. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330-43 6-2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:45 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; mJoyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; Iarry@ibew245.com; CSIZMADIA, Christine Cc: Christopher Curry; Juan Cespedes; Griffing, David L. Subject: IMPORTANT UPDATE - Hearing Room Changed The Energy Generation Subcommittee hearing on H86 has changed. It will now be conducted in the House Finance Room 313. Murphy From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:41 PM To: Ilshapiro@summitoh.net; jdodson@summitoh.net; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; larry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; CSIZMADIA, Christine Cc: Christopher Curry Sent: Monday, July 1, 2019 10:02 AM To: Shapiro, Ilene Cc: DeVille, Daniel Gardner, Kirk W. Subject: H3 6 Press Release Attachments: 7 1 19 HBG Release Ilene, Enjoy your time in Italy. Attached is the press release on H8 6. It all comes down to July 17th Thanks so much for your continued support. Let?s catch up when you get back. Would love to hear about your trip. Murphy The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or cepying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. FirstEnergy A 341 White Pond Drive Solutions Ala?on,0H44320 FIRSTENERGY SOLUTIONS CORP. Company is pleased with progress and outlook on H36 AKRON, Ohio, July 1, 2019 FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. applauds the progress on H36 and is thankful for the effort legislators have demonstrated in crafting a bill that prevents the premature closure of the state?s two nuclear facilities. FES is pleased with the consensus forming to take action to avoid the loss of 90% of Ohio?s carbon-free generation, 4,300 direct and indirect family?sustaining jobs and substantial tax revenue. The company appreciates the hard work, support and commitment of House Speaker Householder, Senate President Obhof and Governor DeWine to work toward final passage of H36 on July 17. While FES is optimistic about the outcome for H36, the company remains unable to purchase the fuel required for Davis-Besse?s next refueling cycle without the certainty of critical legislative support. We remain on path for a safe deactivation and decommissioning. Should we receive the long-term certainty that comes with an af?rmative vote within this timeframe, we will immediately reevaluate our options. Given the expectation that the legislation will be passed in the coming weeks, we have communicated our commitment to doing everything possible to accommodate this process, which will come with increased financial burden associated with missing the June 30th fuel purchasing deadline for Davis-Besse. FES, its subsidiaries and FENOC voluntarily filed for bankruptcy on March 31, 2018 in order to facilitate an orderly financial and operational restructuring. The case is proceeding in the US. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Ohio, in Akron. if Media Contact: Sitrick And Company: 212-573-6100 Tom Becker: Torn Becker@sitrick.com Brenda Adrian: badrian@sitrick.com Angela Pruitt: @ruitt@sitrick.com Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:16 PM To: Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fwd: Final Testimony for Wednesday Attachments: Ilene Shapiro Testimony FINAL 4 17 19.pdf All- just a small update to Ilene's testimony tomorrow. Can you please see that she gets Thank you! Sent Via the Samsung Galaxy 89+, an 5G Evolution capable smartphone Original message From: Christopher Curry Date: 4/16/19 3:11 PM To: "Shapiro, Ilene" "Dodson, Jason" Cc: "Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David Subject: Final Testimony for Wednesday County Executive Shapiro attached please find an updated version of your testimony for tomorrow. We made a slight change to the intro paragraph to recognize Chairman O?Brien. Reps. Stein and O?Brien are both co?chairs of the subcommittee. A conference room at Roetzel and Andress are available tomorrow before or after your testimony. Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, 215t Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 Please let me know if you have any questions. -Chris Ilene Shapiro, County Executive County of Summit, Ohio Testimony before the Ohio Energy 8: Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation Chairman Stein, Chairman O?Brien and members of the House Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation, my name is Ilene Shapiro and I am the County Executive for Summit County. Thank you for the opportunity to address you all today. I am here to testify in support of H3 6, which would create the Ohio Clean Air Program to support clean forms of energy generation, including Ohio?s nuclear plants. After hearing from all of the proponents of this legislation, I hope you will understand the importance of advancing this legislation and how vital these nuclear facilities are to the economy and environment of our great State. Specifically, I am here today to support this legislation because it will assist FirstEnergy Solutions with continuing to generate electricity from its nuclear facilities in the State. FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities support more than 4,300 jobs in all parts of Ohio, not just in the counties in which the plants are located. Each of those employees, their families, and their communities, including Summit County, are depending on this subcommittee to advance H3 6. Each employee represents a highly skilled worker who will be forced to find a job elsewhere, uproot their family, pull their children from our schools and drain our communities of tax revenue and business activities. In Summit County alone, over 300 employees are employed at FirstEnergy Solutions? Akron headquarters, all of which may face these dif?cult situations if H3 6 is not passed into law. For each of the 700 FirstEnergy Solutions? employees at the nuclear facilities and the 300 at the Akron headquarters, there will be many more jobs lost from vendors and service providers throughout the State who will shut their doors and move away if the plants close. In Summit County alone, FirstEnergy Solutions has spent more than $9 million over the past five years with 80 vendors. It will be incredibly difficult to fill the void left for those vendors if the nuclear facilities are prematurely shutdown. Our County and many Ohio counties also depend on the significant tax revenue generated directly and indirectly by the FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities. The state of Ohio collects about $30 million from the two nuclear facilities. That does not account for the additional revenue generated for the state and localities from related vendors, property taxes, sales taxes, and hotel taxes. And, as you can imagine, with over 300 employees, FirstEnergy Solutions is one of our major income tax payers in Summit County. My economic development team is currently working with representatives from the City of Akron and the Greater Akron Chamber to keep FirstEnergy Solutions? headquarters in Summit County. We want to see this company and its employees succeed and we should all be encouraged by the fact that FirstEnergy Solutions is committed to staying and growing in Ohio. While we are working hard at the local level to ensure the company?s ongoing success in Summit County, we need the State to be a partner in these efforts. Through H3 6, the State will ensure that FirstEnergy Solutions will remain in the energy generation business, thereby keeping and growing jobs in Summit County and Ohio. Finally, as County Executive, support any effort to provide our communities with clean air and a healthy environment. FirstEnergy Solutions? zero-carbon nuclear facilities are critical to our state?s clean air future. These two plants are responsible for 90 percent of Ohio?s carbon-free electricity generation. Furthermore, the facilities? nuclear?generated electricity is available 24/7 and at affordable prices, which are two necessary ingredients to help attract businesses and investments into our community. We can choose to move forward with clean, reliable nuclear energy or remain in the past and become less competitive in an ever-changing economy. On behalf of Summit County and our more than 540,000 residents, I urge you to support this legislation and preserve jobs, communities, and Ohio?s carbon-free nuclear future. Thank you. Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:49 PM To: Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fw: IMPORTANT UPDATE Hearing Room Changed FYI- Please see below. From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:45 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; larry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; Christine Cc: Christopher Curry; Juan Cespedes; Griffing, David L. Subject: IMPORTANT UPDATE - Hearing Room Changed The Energy Generation Subcommittee hearing on H86 has changed. It will now be conducted in the House Finance Room 313. Murphy From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:41 PM To: llshapiro@summitoh.net; jdodson@summitoh.net; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; larry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; Christine Cc: Christopher Curry Juan Cespedes Grif?ng, David L. Subject: Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wed 4/17 Hello Everyone, Chris Curry Dewey Square, will be sending you your ?nal written testimony for the Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing tomorrow. Your testimony will be ?led with Chairman Dick Stein this evening and then downloaded to the iPads of the (5) committee members in the morning. We will have hardcopies of your testimony to distribute to the committee in the unlikely event the technology fails. For most of you I would suggest going directly to the State House Meeting Room 121. Our team plans to depart from Roetzel Andress at 8:30 AM for the 9:00 AM hearing and remain there all day. Reminder For those of you traveling directly to the State House: If you park at the statehouse in the underground parking garage signage is good. Look for the Statehouse signs. Then once inside find the rotunda. There are guards and posted guides at information desks allover. It is in the main statehouse building under the house chamber on the first floor. Look for the highway patrol security at the side door of the Statehouse to identify the house side. Look for room 121. The doors are all marked. Should be fairly easy to find or ask the patrol. If you have any questions, please don?t hesitate to call me. When you arrive at the State House, please send me a text message. Thanks again and safe travels. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330?436-2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 montlerm @firstenergycorp.com The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and confidential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 8:56 PM To: Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie; Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Fw: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Attachments: Witness List Order - Electric Generation Subcommitteedocx; Roetzel 81 Andress - Conference Room 81 Parking.docx; Electric Generation Subcommittee a: Hearing Announcementdocx Mary- Please print for Ilene's trip to Columbus on Wednesday. Thank you! From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 5:05 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; larry@ibew245.com; jbgrant@ocic.biz; CSIZMADIA, Christine Subject: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Hello Everyone, Attached please find the following information related to the Electric Generation Subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, April 17th: l" Order of Proponent Hearing Witnesses 2. Location of Roetzel Andress Offices 8: Parking ?the offices are open from 8:00 am 4:00 pm for our Proponent Witnesses 3. Members of the Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing Announcement If you need any assistance, please don?t hesitate to call me. Thanks so much for your continued support. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330-436-2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 montlerm @firstenergycorp.com I?l The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. I qt I . It] . -.-I :1 In I 3: Jr l?'63.II. n, VJ In ..-, Er: l'r~21it191Ila-..- .: -. .. :lull .--. I_Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, let Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 warn Bageile a? St .233; Rawe?ront 91? i Eunns? 9 Park BIC Broad 3? 19' Broad st The Ohio Stat?house 51 can? {331?} d. u: 9 a oap?a? 0 .- Bmad St 1% ?13 fig oakcosu 9 I state at a E. Genoa?arl; chapei 51 John F. 9'10le . . golumbus 51 ommons H- Rich Street ?93 mama ow Head 'f 1? I H1 mtz' I.I nl-?I RI 11., il ['Jr-l-I IF. ll ill ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENERGY GENERATION SCIIEDULE Dill Time Location Round: April 1152019 Roan 121 HEARINGS March 25, 2019 March 19, 2019 March 12. 2019 February 12, 2019 CEMENT OF COMTEE MEETING COMMTTEE: Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Energy Generation CEO-CHAIRS: Dick Stein, Michael O?Brien DATE: Wednesday. Apxil 7. 2019 TM: 9:00 AM ROOM: Room 121 AGENDA BILL 511331115 H3 6 Rep Callender. Creates Ohio Clean Air Plug-em 1:1 Hearing Rep Wilkin Pending Reta-ml Proponent Cc: House Clerk Committee Members Committee Clerk Speaker's O?ice Assistant Majority Floor Leader?s O?ce Caucus Sta?' Bill Sponsor LSC Minority Leader's O?ice Legislative Information Systems Press Room Nott, Dave From: Christopher Curry Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:11 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason Cc: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Subject: Final Testimony for Wednesday Attachments: Ilene Shapiro Testimony FINAL 4 17 19.pdf County Executive Shapiro attached please find an updated version of your testimony for tomorrow. We made a slight change to the intro paragraph to recognize Chairman O?Brien. Reps. Stein and O?Brien are both co-chairs of the subcommittee. A conference room at Roetzel and Andress are available tomorrow before or after your testimony. Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, 215t Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 Please let me know if you have any questions. -Chris Ilene Shapiro, County Executive County of Summit, Ohio Testimony before the Ohio Energy Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation Chairman Stein, Chairman O?Brien and members of the House Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation, my name is Ilene Shapiro and I am the County Executive for Summit County. Thank you for the opportunity to address you all today. I am here to testify in support of H3 6, which would create the Ohio Clean Air Program to support clean forms of energy generation, including Ohio?s nuclear plants. After hearing from all of the proponents of this legislation, I hope you will understand the importance of advancing this legislation and how vital these nuclear facilities are to the economy and environment of our great State. Specifically, lam here today to support this legislation because it will assist FirstEnergy Solutions with continuing to generate electricity from its nuclear facilities in the State. FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities support more than 4,300 jobs in all parts of Ohio, not just in the counties in which the plants are located. Each of those employees, their families, and their communities, including Summit County, are depending on this subcommittee to advance H3 6. Each employee represents a highly skilled worker who will be forced to find a job elsewhere, uproot their family, pull their children from our schools and drain our communities of tax revenue and business activities. In Summit County alone, over 300 employees are employed at FirstEnergy Solutions? Akron headquarters, all of which may face these dif?cult situations if H3 6 is not passed into law. For each of the 700 FirstEnergy Solutions? employees at the nuclear facilities and the 300 at the Akron headquarters, there will be many more jobs lost from vendors and service providers throughout the State who will shut their doors and move away if the plants close. in Summit County alone, FirstEnergy Solutions has spent more than $9 million over the past five years with 80 vendors. It will be incredibly difficult to fill the void left for those vendors if the nuclear facilities are prematurely shutdown. Our County and many Ohio counties also depend on the significant tax revenue generated directly and indirectly by the FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities. The state of Ohio collects about $30 million from the two nuclear facilities. That does not account for the additional revenue generated for the state and localities from related vendors, property taxes, sales taxes, and hotel taxes. And, as you can imagine, with over 300 employees, FirstEnergy Solutions is one of our major income tax payers in Summit County. My economic development team is currently working with representatives from the City of Akron and the Greater Akron Chamber to keep FirstEnergy Solutions? headquarters in Summit County. We want to see this company and its employees succeed and we should all be encouraged by the fact that FirstEnergy Solutions is committed to staying and growing in Ohio. While we are working hard at the local level to ensure the company?s ongoing success in Summit County, we need the State to be a partner in these efforts. Through H8 6, the State will ensure that FirstEnergy Solutions will remain in the energy generation business, thereby keeping and growing jobs in Summit County and Ohio. Finally, as County Executive, support any effort to provide our communities with clean air and a healthy environment. FirstEnergy Solutions? zero-carbon nuclearfacilities are critical to our state?s clean air future. These two plants are responsible for 90 percent of Ohio?s carbon-free electricity generation. Furthermore, the facilities? nuclear-generated electricity is available 24/7 and at affordable prices, which are two necessary ingredients to help attract businesses and investments into our community. We can choose to move forward with clean, reliable nuclear energy or remain in the past and become less competitive in an ever-changing economy. On behalf of Summit County and our more than 540,000 residents, I urge you to support this legislation and preserve jobs, communities, and Ohio?s carbon-free nuclear future. Thank you. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:41 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; m.joyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; arry@ibew245.com; CSIZMADIA, Christine Cc: Christopher Curry; Juan Cespedes; Griffing, David L. Subject: Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wed 4/17 Hello Everyone, Chris Curry Dewey Square, will be sending you your final written testimony for the Energy Generation Subcommittee Hearing tomorrow. Your testimony will be ?led with Chairman Dick Stein this evening and then downloaded to the iPads of the (5) committee members in the morning. We will have hardcopies of your testimony to distribute to the committee in the unlikely event the technology fails. For most of you I would suggest going directly to the State House Meeting Room 121. Our team plans to depart from Roetzel Andress at 8:30 AM for the 9:00 AM hearing and remain there all day. Reminder For those of you traveling directly to the State House: If you park at the statehouse in the underground parking garage signage is good. Look for the Statehouse signs. Then once inside find the rotunda. There are guards and posted guides at information desks allover. It is in the main storehouse building under the house chamber on the Look for the highway patrol security at the side door of the statehouse to identify the house side. Look for room 121. The doors are all marked. Should be fairly easy to find or ask the patrol. If you have any questions, please don?t hesitate to call me. When you arrive at the State House, please send me a text message. Thanks again and safe travels. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330-436-2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent 1 responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 5:06 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene; Dodson, Jason; dean.murphy@brattle.com; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; mJoyce@orrvilon.com; tjoyce@local310.com; Christine Subject: Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing - Wednesday April 17th Attachments: Witness List Order - Electric Generation Subcommitteedocx; Roetzel 8L Andress - Conference Room 81 Parking.docx,' Electric Generation Subcommittee 8t Hearing Announcementdocx Hello Everyone, Attached please find the following information related to the Electric Generation Subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, April 17th: 1. Order of Proponent Hearing Witnesses 2. Location of Roetzel Andress Offices Parking the offices are open from 8:00 am ?4:00 pm for our Preponent Witnesses 3. Members of the Electric Generation Subcommittee Hearing Announcement If you need any assistance, please don?t hesitate to call me. Thanks so much for your continued support. Murphy Murphy Montler 341 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH Office 330?436?2726 Mobile 330-730-8964 montleer?rstenergycorp.com The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. I.) ?l-l tll?iftilI'd, .133 (Iii: EH .1, illr??IiIlia a I I [1 'lI'I-It"3-1 . ll I a I :I[1:-..L 1-- Roetzel And ress 41 South High Street, Huntington Center, let Floor, Columbus, OH 43215 Parking Double Tree Downtown Columbus 50 Front St, Columbus, OH 43215 St dp' Elmwas63?} m"51 9 gamete . 433' Riverfront :1 ?z . .. ad Capt (in) or 35:0 2 The 3h?: Statehgse r; CapBroad (.0 0031? mm a Genoa Park 5? ?2 chapelg a: El John F. Wolfe ?t . golumbus Town 5?t f; ommons Rich Street 05?? 5? i ow Head If.? f??'rr'q "(fir-airur . .1 f'fr Ir I How Irf'l?. (?unmn II M- I l'l'il?w'i .?'lil I?x ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENERGY GENERATION SCHEDULE MEMBERS Dn- ?ne Location Agenda Apn'l 17, 2019 09:00 AM Room 121 Dmmfum HEARINGS . meme! .1. Brian O'Brlen (D) Bandage March 23, 2019 cn-cnar March 2019 March 12, 2019 February 12, 2019 w. Home: (D) 90056 RapreSe . at). ?is" ANNOUNCEMENT OF comm COMMIITIEE: Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Energy Generation Dick Stein. Meheel J. O?Brien. DATE: Wednesday. April 1'7. 2019 TIMI 9:00 AM ROOM: Room 121 AGENDA BILL enema 11113; 51131115 HR 6 Rep Cellender, Creates Ohio CleenAir Program Hearing Rep Wilkins- Pending Referral Propment Cc: House Clerk Committee Maribel: Committee Cluk Speaker's O?ce Assistant Majority Floor Leader's Of?ce Caucus Su?? Bill Sponsor Legislative In?nmn?on Systems LSC Press Room Minority Leader's O?iee Nott, Dave From: Dodson, Jason Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 9:00 PM To: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David Shapiro, Ilene; Spaugy, Mary; Krauss, Connie Subject: County Executive Ilene Shapiro Testimony Attachments: Ilene Shapiro Testimony on H36.docx Murphy- Per my text, here is the testimony for County Executive Shapiro. Please review and make sure that everything is still accurate after I edited the draft that was sent yesterday. Other than that, everything should be in order for Wednesday on our end. My understanding is that you will ?le on our behalf. Thank you! Jason Ilene Shapiro, County Executive County of Summit, Ohio Testimony before the Ohio Energy 8: Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation Mr. Chairman, Vice Chairman and members of the House Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee on Generation, my name is Ilene Shapiro and I am the County Executive for Summit County. Thank you for the opportunity to address you all today. I am here to testify in support of H3 6, which would create the Ohio Clean Air Program to support clean forms of energy generation, including Ohio?s nuclear plants. After hearing from all of the proponents of this legislation, I hope you will understand the importance of advancing this legislation and how vital these nuclear facilities are to the economy and environment of our great State. Speci?cally, I am here today to support this legislation because it will assist FirstEnergy Solutions with continuing to generate electricity from its nuclear facilities in the State. FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities support more than 4,300 jobs in all parts of Ohio, not just in the counties in which the plants are located. Each of those employees, their families, and their communities, including Summit County, are depending on this subcommittee to advance HB 6. Each employee represents a highly skilled worker who will be forced to find a job elsewhere, uproot their family, pull their children from our schools and drain our communities of tax revenue and business activities. In Summit County alone, over 300 employees are employed at FirstEnergy Solutions? Akron headquarters, all of which may face these difficult situations if H3 6 is not passed into law. For each of the 700 FirstEnergy Solutions? employees at the nuclear facilities and the 300 at the Akron headquarters, there will be many more jobs lost from vendors and service providers throughout the State who will shut their doors and move away if the plants close. In Summit County alone, FirstEnergy Solutions has spent more than $9 million over the past five years with 80 vendors. It will be incredibly dif?cult to ?ll the void left for those vendors if the nuclear facilities are prematurely shutdown. Our County and many Ohio counties also depend on the signi?cant tax revenue generated directly and indirectly by the FirstEnergy Solutions? nuclear facilities. The state of Ohio collects about $30 million from the two nuclear facilities. That does not account for the additional revenue generated for the state and localities from related vendors, property taxes, sales taxes, and hotel taxes. And, as you can imagine, with over 300 employees, FirstEnergy Solutions is one of our major income tax payers in Summit County. My economic development team is currently working with representatives from the City of Akron and the Greater Akron Chamber to keep FirstEnergy Solutions? headquarters in Summit County. We want to see this company and its employees succeed and we should all be encouraged by the fact that FirstEnergy Solutions is committed to staying and growing in Ohio. While we are working hard at the local level to ensure the company?s ongoing success in Summit County, we need the State to be a partner in these efforts. Through H3 6, the State will ensure that FirstEnergy Solutions will remain in the energy generation business, thereby keeping and growing jobs in Summit County and Ohio. Finally, as County Executive, support any effort to provide our communities with clean air and a healthy environment. FirstEnergy Solutions? zero-carbon nuclear facilities are critical to our state?s clean air future. These two plants are responsible for 90 percent of Ohio?s carbon-free electricity generation. Furthermore, the facilities? nuclear-generated electricity is available 24/7 and at affordable prices, which are two necessary ingredients to help attract businesses and investments into our community. We can choose to move forward with clean, reliable nuclear energy or remain in the past and become less competitive in an ever-changing economy. On behalf of Summit County and our more than 540,000 residents, I urge you to support this legislation and preserve jobs, communities, and Ohio?s carbon-free nuclear future. Thank you. Nott, Dave From: janiceelaineoakley@yahoo.com Sent: Friday, April 19, 2019 2:32 PM To: Shapiro, Ilene Subject: Another environmental issue Ilene, I heard your testimony before the House Energy Generation committee this week. Like you, I want to save the uclear plants on Lake Erie- perhaps not for the same reason as you. I am passionate about climate change. And, as a Democrat, I hope you are too. I'm convinced that the only way we are going to quickly decarbonize the wor 1d is with nuclear energy. I'm reading a great book on the subject (A Bright Future- reviewed in the NYT: //gccOl c20f7f1 1 5642e1 1 e3 e08d6 c4f5474d%7C777 Sa6aacb264e0c8 a600??84261 3af2%7C0%7C1 691 29550773 which I am recommending to all my environmental friends- especially those who are scared to death of nuclear power. Anyway, the experts give us a very few years to turn around our energy production from fossil fuels. Wind and solar are great, although intermittant, but they can't move the needle quickly enough- maybe 100- 150 years or so. The problem is with HB6. I am in touch with the energy expert at Ohio Environmental Council- Trish Demeter 15642e1 le3e08d604f5474d%7C7775a6aa OEC advises that there are terrible things in this bill. I believe it was written by First Energy because it sounds like it is good for clean energy but it, instead, hel ps coal and gas and hurts wind and solar. It is a very technical bill. I don't think the technicalities can be explain ed easilly to most people? I just know the general problems. That's why I rely on Trish to do the analyses and ex plain it to me. But, I have read enough to know that what she says is true- backed up by all the information abou the politics of the issue? all the money that First Energy has contributed to Householder and other Republicans. It is my wish that you could add an addendum to your testimony? that you have problems with the non- nuclear aspects of this bill- and then you can tell Householder that you could help him get the votes of Summit Co. Democratic legislators which he needs? (he's about 20 votes short in his Republican caucus in the House) in return for ?xing this bill. I don't expect you to know all the intracacies of the bill but Trish could help you. Here's her last email to me and Denise Woods and Steve Cochran and Tom Collins- (energy chair for Sierra Cl from Summit County. Jan Oakley Sagamore Hills 330-468-2488 Talking points on HB 6 Apr 18 at 1:53 PM Trish Demeter To: oakley janice Here are topline summaries of provisions in the bill, and impact if passed. We have heard there will likely be OPPONENT testimony in a hearing on Tuesday, April 23. If you know anyone that would be willing to show up at the next hearing on this bill (to demonstrate strong opposition) or provide testimony, please let me know if you think there would be interest and I can follow up with details once they are ?rmed up. Thanks so much! Impact of HB 6: Would INCREASE Ohio's carbon footprint because the bill proposes to do away with Ohio's RPS and EERS which together are reducing Ohio's reliance on coal ?red power plants. These policies are slated to reduce Ohio?s annual carbon pollution by about 10 million tons between 2017 and 2029?equivalent to avoiding emissions from the annual electricity consumption of 1 million homes. Dials back investment in cost-saving energy ef?ciency. Ohio's EERS had delivered over $4.5 billion in energy savings to Ohioans' utility bills since 2009. HB 6 proposes to dismantle this policy, leaving a lot of untapped energy ef?ciency potential on the table. Puts Ohio jobs at risk: Over 112,000 Ohioans are employed in the clean energy sector.The 80,000 Ohioans employed in the energy ef?ciency sector stand to be impacted the most. Impacts Ohioans? health: Due to rollback of Ohio?s RPS and EERS, the legislation would forgo the projected health bene?ts that these standards provide - prevention of over 44,000 asthma attacks, 2,400 asthma-related emergency room Visits, 4,400 heart attacks and over 2,800 premature deaths attributable to coal?plant pollution. Summary: House Bill 6, as introduced, proposes a new ?Ohio Clean Air Program,? which would create new subsidies for Ohio?s two nuclear power plants?Davis Besse and Perry Station - as well as coal and natural gas power plants. Despite claims that renewable energy projects would qualify to receive a portion of the new subsidies, the bill creates so many exclusions that no wind and solar projects are effectively disquali?ed. At the same time, the legislation proposes an effective repeal of Ohio?s Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) and Energy Ef?ciency Resource Standard (EERS). These two policies have delivered millions in bill savings to customers, reduced carbon emissions ?om the power sector signi?cantly, and generated new jobs and new tax revenue for Ohio. Primary provisions: Effectively eliminates Ohio?s Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) and Energy Ef?ciency Resource Standard (EERS) by exempting all customers from the riders that support utility compliance with these standards, essentially de-?Jnding the standards. Establishes new surcharges imposed on all Ohio customers of electric distribution utilities that would generate approximately $300 million annually. Estimated breakdown: $125M/yr from residential; $130M/yr from commercial; $45 million/annually from industrial. Creates a new ?Ohio Clean Air Program,? a new state program that would disburse subsidies to quali?ed ?clean air resources,? (nuclear) and ?reduced emissions resources? (essentially, coal plants that have upgraded pollution controls). While the bill proponents claim that renewables would qualify for new subsidies, the de?nitions create so many exclusions for what kinds of renewables could qualify that essentially no renewable project existing now or in the future would be able to qualify. Funds would be administered by the Ohio Air Quality Development Authority (OAQDA), to which the bill pr0poses to add four members of the Ohio General Assembly to the authority which would be appointed by the majority and minority leaders in each chamber. Establishes maximum caps on surcharges: $2.50 a month for residential customers, $20 for commercial customers, $250 a month for industrial customers, and $2,500 for very large users. Trish Demeter Vice President of Policy - Energy Ohio Environmental Council Ohio Environmental Council Action Fund 1145 Chesapeake Avenue, Suite 1, Columbus, 43212 (614) 487-5829 direct Nott, Dave From: Sent: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Tuesday, July 16, 2019 9:55 AM To: edklco@northperry.org; ronaldeyoun9974 @gmail.com; rregovich@cityofwilIowick.com; jmcdonald@perryfire.info; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; Joe.Busher@lakecountyohiogov; jagessic@gmail.com; perrycouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler; ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us; Rhonda Slauterbeck; Jamie Beier; Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co); Guy Parmigian; Keeton, Cajon; Miller, Scott; Hal Hawk; Beth Hannam; Jill Simpson; Matthew Mackowiak; ilshapiro@aol.com; Shapiro, Ilene; par5@akronohio.gov; thegeorgegoup@aol.com; Phillips, Aaron (yahoo.com) Griffing, David 'Christopher Curry'; 'Jonathan Drobis'; Zele, Wendy Rosebrock, Hans D'Arcy, Sean; Bailey, Joel D. ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Cc: Subject: Ohio Senate Session Details please help us ?ll the Senate Chambers with supporters Date: Wednesday, July 1:30 pm Location: Ohio State House 1 Capitol Square, Columbus, OH 43215 Suggested arrival time: Noon Other note: Enter the State House from the 3rd Street entrance Supporter Meeting Location: Ladies? Gallery Room (main floor) security can direct you there (see the map below) State Capital Contact: Murphy Montler (FES) 330-730-8964 I *2 ?1'43 at "r - 5?1 L. ~43: if you're traveimg by car, i wautd St i suggest day parking at the 35,3. Long S, g; 3 Renaissance Hotel - 50 3rd ColumbusThe Leveque Tower Residences 3? ll "you Have employees ire ?am i' The Origin Stalehcmse bus, unload at the State House 3" IE at with Street entrance. we address is 1 art 5 audio touts Capitol Square, Columbus, DH LP 43215 IS My mobile number is {330: 895i a? Capitol Square Review A .6 A - Ill-11- HSQOHEILVLS When you arrive It tha ma SUNNEIS I'T?l?l' asthma From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2019 12:34 PM To: 'edklco@northperry.org' 'ronaldeyoun3974@gmail.com' 'jmcdonald@perryfire.info' 'MRantaIa@lcport.org' 'kstonebrook75@gmail.com' 'jagessic@gmail.com' 'dphillips@ibew673.org' 'mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Mark Coppeler' 'ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Rhonda Slauterbeck' 'Jamie Beier' 'Petersen, Fred (Ottawa (30' 'Guy Parmigian' 'Keeton, Cajon' 'Miller, Scott' 'Hal Hawk' 'Beth Hannam' 'Jill Simpson' 'Matthew Mackowiak' 'ilshapiro@aol.com' 'llshapiro@summitoh.net' 'par5@akronohio.gov' 2 'thegeorgegoup@aol.com' 'surehousepastor@yahoo.com' Cc: Griffing, David L. 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. 'D'Arcy, Sean' Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Hello Everyone, The next scheduled Senate session is Wednesday, July 17th, at 1:30 pm. It continues to be our understanding that the Senate will vote on H3 6 during this session. Until we hear otherwise, our plan is to mobilize people to the state house for the Senate vote. Please help us fill the Senate chambers with supporters. I would suggest having people arrive no later than 12:30 pm. If anything changes, I will notify you immediately. Thanks, Murphy Montler 330?730-8964 From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 8, 2019 10:08 AM To: ed klco@northperry.o rg: Jerry.Cirino@la kecountyohiogov; ronaIdevoung974@gmail.com; rregovich@cityofwillowick.com; thompsoni@perry- Iake.org: MRantala@Icport.org: kstonebrook75@email.com: La rry.Greene@la kecountvohiogov; Joe.Busher@lakecountvohiogov; jagessic@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org: mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us: Mark Coppeler ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us: Rhonda Slauterbeck Jamie Beier Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co Guy Parmigian Keeton, Cajon Miller, Scott Subject: RE: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Good Morning Everyone, It is our understanding that the Ohio House of Representatives will hold a special session tomorrow, Tuesday, July 23rd, at 11:00 am, to vote on HB 6. Please help us ?ll the House Chambers to demonstrate support for passage of H86. Murphy From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Tuesday, July 16, 2019 9:55 AM To: edklco@northperrv.org: ronaIdevoung974@gmail.com: mdonald@perrvfire.info; thompsoni@perry- lake.org: MRantaia@icport.org; kstonebrook75@gmail.com; La rrv.G reene@la kecountvohiogov: Joe.Busher@Ia kecou ntyohiogov; iagessic@gmail.com; perrvcouncilmanrick@gmail.com: dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us: Mark Coppeler ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us: Rhonda Slauterbeck Jamie Beier Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co Guy Parmigian Keeton, Cajon Miller, Scott Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Senate Vote Ohio Senate Session Details please help us ?ll the Senate Chambers with supporters Date: Wednesday, July 1:30 pm Location: Ohio State House - 1 Capitol Square, Columbus, OH 43215 Suggested arrival time: Noon Other note: Enter the State House from the 3rd Street entrance Supporter Meeting Location: Ladies? Gallery Room (main floor) - security can direct you there (see the map below) State Capital Contact: Murphy Montler (FES) 330-730-8964 St L?ng 51' If wu're traue?ling by car. i would St '73" 5? suggest clay parking at the Low a: i Renaissance Hate] - 50 3rd a; Columbus, an ?3215 10p Kitchen E1 a; Cocktails E. WM ?5 DOW 5? - Supef Chi}? .5 The Leveque Breakfast 3. More ?3 Tower Residences i ?3 IE van Have employees tra?mg by The Dhio Statehouse - bus, unload at the State House ping with Street entrance- The address is 1 MES -. - Capital Square. Columbus, DH :1 3% 43215 3 . i - My muhiie number is (3301 HB- 9 Capitol Square Review "$3954 11 I I EIJNVILIA 1.8 . I. a 313N515 fir-r1- SLVNES From: Montler, Murphy (Grif?ng, David L.) Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2019 12:34 PM To: 'edklco@northperry.org' 'ronaldeyoungg74@gmail.com' 'MRantaIa@lcport.org' 'kstonebrook75@gmail.com' 'jagessic@gmail.com' 'dphillips@ibew673.org' 'mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Mark Coppeler' 'ddouglas@co.ottawa.oh.us' 'Rhonda Slauterbeck' 'Jamie Beier' 'Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co' 'Guy Parmigian' 'Keeton, Cajon? 'Miller, Scott' Cc: Griffing, David L. 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. 'D'Arcy, Sean? Subject: ACTION REQUIRED H3 6 Senate Vote Hello Everyone, The next scheduled Senate session is Wednesday, July 17th, at 1:30 pm. It continues to be our understanding that the Senate will vote on H8 6 during this session. Until we hear otherwise, our plan is to mobilize people to the state house for the Senate vote. Please help us fill the Senate chambers with supporters. I would suggest having people arrive no later than 12:30 pm. If anything changes, I will notify you immediately. Thanks, Murphy Montler 330-730?8964 From: Montler, Murphy (Griffing, David L.) Sent: Monday, July 8, 2019 10:08 AM To: edklco@ north perry.org; Jerry.Cirino@la kecountvohiogov: ronaldevoungQ74@gmail.com: rregovich@citvofwillowickcom; thompsoni@Derry- ake.org; MRantala@lcport.org: kstonebrook75@gmail.com; La rry.Greene@Iakecountyohio.gov: Joe.Busher@la kecountyohiogov: jagessic@email.com: perrvcouncilmanrick@gmail.com; dphillips@ibew673.org; mstahl@co.ottawa.oh.us; Mark Coppeler ddouelas@co.ottawa.oh.us: Rhonda Slauterbeck Jamie Beier rant ocic.biz>; Petersen, Fred (Ottawa Co Guy Parmigian Keeton, Cajon Miller, Scott ; 'Christopher Curry' 'Jonathan Drobis' Zele, Wendy F. Rosebrock, Hans D. D'Arcy, Sean Subject: ACTION REQUIRED - H3 6 Update Thank you for your continued leadership in Columbus to advocate for H3 6 and engaging your constituents to do the same. We are on the final stretch and now more than ever we need to flood our elected of?cials with a strong message of support for H3 6. Update H3 6 currently sits in the Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee chaired by Senator Steve Wilson. Since being introduced in the Senate, a sub bill to H3 6 was created and 57 amendments have been offered by Proponents, Opponents and Interested Parties for the Committee to consider. From recent discussions with Senate Leadership, we understand that H8 6 will be voted on by the full Senate no later than Wednesday, July While no Senate Energy Public Utilities Committee hearings are scheduled this week, please understand that much is happening behind the 6 scenes and the process could be accelerated with little notice. We will keep you informed as new information becomes available. How can you help? There are only (8) business days remaining to have our voices heard before this important vote. We need evemone (family, friends neighbors) to make calls my and throughout the weekend. Attached is a list of all Ohio Senators with phone numbers and email addresses. Please focus on calling and emailing the highlighted Senators who are in leadership or on the committee that is considering HB 6. We?ve also pasted the contact information for the highest priority Senators below especially Senators Obhof 8: Wilson. The messages to support HB 6 should be very short and sweet: 1. Start the call 8: email off with a strong message of appreciation for their hard work - working extended hours and weekends to get this done 2. Be direct and ask the Senator to please support H3 6 because it protects 4300 Ohio jobs and strengthens Ohio's energy future If you are not able to talk to a staff person, please leave a message urging the Senator to support H8 6. Thank you for your help! Murphy Montler 330-730-8964 President Larry Obhof (614) 466-7505 Sen. Steve Wilson (614)466-9737 Sen. Robert McCoIIey (614) 466-8150 Sen. Sandra Williams (614) 466-4857 Sen. Andrew Brenner (614) 466?8086 Sen. Dave Burke (614) 466-8049 Sen. Hearcel Craig (614)466-5131 Sen. Matt Dolan (614) 466-8056 Sen. John Eklund (614) 644-7718 Sen. Frank Hoagland (614)466-6508 Sen. Matt Huffman (614) 466-7584 Sen. Sean O'Brien (614) 466-7182 Sen. Bob Peterson (614) 466-8156 Sen. Michael Rulli (614) 466?8285 The information contained in this message is intended only for the personal and con?dential use of the recipient(s) named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby noti?ed that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately, and delete the original message. Nott, Dave From: Crain's Akron Business Sent: Friday, May 24, 2019 8:31 AM To: Shapiro, Ilene Subject: A deeper look at the NFL draft in Cleveland Nuclear bailout bill moves forward in Ohio House Cleveland Fed sets policy summit Akron working to be ?age?friendly? Having trouble viewing this email? See the online version PEOPLE ON THE MOVE New hire? Promotion? Board appointment? announce YOUR BIG NEWS In CLEVELAND BUSINESS Akron Daily l-i. ll'llU Locations, economic impact, costs, clearing up misconceptions a deeper look at Cleveland hosting the 2021 NFL draft Events of this magnitude bring a lot of talk about economic impact, generate plenty of questions about who gets what and inspire a ton of snark from the Twitter trolls. With that in mind, let's try to clear up some of the contusion. READ MORE m?m Nuclear bailout bill clears Ohio House committee From the Columbus Dispatch: A revised bill that would shore up the state?s two nuclear power plants along with two coal-?red power plants cleared an Ohio House committee Thursday, May 23, along party lines. READ MORE rm - FEEJ?-Tdmeuce FIN THE WITHOUT EVER LEAVING THE OFFICE. KNOW EMAIL NEWSLETTERS _ub5crihe ?ur FREE Nuclear bailout bill shows how big money can be put to work in the Ohio Statehouse From Clevelandcom: From well-placed campaign contributions, to lobbyist-engineered testimony, to millions of dollars in mysteriously funded TV and radio ads, the effort to get the state legislature to pass a bill bailing out two nuclear plants owned by a former irstEnergy subsidiary is a textbook example of how big money can be used to in?uence public policy in Ohio. READ MORE Ohio energy ?ght has Koch, environmentalists on same side From Bloomberg: The Sierra Club and billionaire Charles Koch have found at least one thing to agree on: They hate Ohio's plan to take away renewable power subsidies and give them to coal and nuclear plants. READ MORE Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland sets policy summit focused on 'connecting people and places to opportunity' The summit takes place June 19-21 in Cincinnati. Raj Chetty, a Harvard economist, will provide a keynote address on Thursday, June 20, titled 2 'Improving Equality of Opportunity: New Insights from Big Data.? Lael Brainard, a Fed governor, and Cleveland Fed CEO Loretta J. Mester also are among the speakers. READ MORE Akron gets intentional on helping seniors From the Akron Beacon Journal: A team of local elders launched a ?ve-year plan Thursday, May 23, to make Akron a place where everyone ages in good health and comfort. The 'age? ?'iendly' designation recognized by the World Health Organization and certi?ed by the AARP is an inclusive attempt to make sidewalks wider and install ramps so baby-strollers and wheelchairs alike can get by, to create hassle-?ee transportation options, to help residents live without fear in safer communities or to implement other initiatives that bene?t seniors by making the city better for everyone. READ MORE Bar owner pleads guilty to charges of wire and mail fraud A Macedonia man who claimed to be a ?nancial planner in the business of ?nancing loans to rehabilitate commercial property has been sentenced to more than six years in prison for swindling three elderly people out of nearly $575,000. READ MORE m?m Ohio Sen. Rob Portman urges quick agreement with China to stop trade war From the Columbus Dispatch: Warning that the trade war with China 'is causing pain for our farmers (and) our workers,? Sen. Rob Portman called on the Trump administration to quickly reach a new trade agreement with Beijing. In a speech on the Senate ?oor late Wednesday, May 22, the Ohio Republican said while he wants the administration 'to hang tough' in negotiations with China, the tariffs imposed by the United States on Chinese imports combined with tariffs levied by China on American exports are damaging the economy. READ MORE I- From Ford to Nissan: 38,000 job cuts and counting at carmakers From Bloomberg: As global auto sales slow after a decade of growth, carmakers are girding for a deeper downturn by slashing payrolls. READ MORE ?m Off the Clock: Things to do in and around Akron through May 28 i From Crain's Akron Business: Live music at Rock the Lock, an Akron RubberDucks homestand, Farmers Market, Memorial Day Flea in Hartville, Reggae Fest Cleveland, Rockin' Fore the Kids in Cuyahoga Falls and more make this week's list. READ MORE m?m Keeping life 100 after a century in the world More people are living to age 100, according The Wall Street Journal, which explores the advantages as well as the limitations of hitting that mark and includes comments from a Clevelander who has made the most of her extended lifespan. Plus, Jones Day keeps getting paid (a lot) by the Republican Party, Cleveland moves up a bit in a ranking of cities with the best parks, an ice cream brand from New York makes a push into Ohio, and READ MORE I'm-m Meijer starts home delivery service at Stow, other Northeast Ohio stores From the Akron Beacon Journal: Meij er said it is offering a discount on the annual Meij er Home Delivery service price to $49 through June 4; the regular price is $99. The annual membership allows for no fees on all orders of more than $35; the company levies a $7 ?at fee on orders under $35. Meij er is partnering with intemet delivery company Shipt to provide the home delivery service. READ MORE m?m Uncertainty over Ohio's ?lm tax credit leaves 3 Bedford movie studio project in the lurch - Plans for Dakar Studios, an estimated $30 million to $40 million project for a Hollywood-inspired ?lm studio and production campus, have faced several setbacks. The latest revolves around the unclear fate of Ohio's Motion Picture Tax Credit. READ MORE Clinic takes aim at Canton?s feral cat problem From the Canton Repository: Director Laura Groves said a designated wing at AlterClinic and an additional veterinarian will roughly double the number of trapped cats accepted. That should be good news for frustrated residents in the city?s southwestern Ward 5, where Councihnan Robert Fisher has arranged for a local feral cat expert to begin a Trap, Neuter, Return program. Cats are humanely trapped and altered before being returned to their territory with an identifying notch on their left ear. READ MORE l-?m U.S. opens antitrust probe of real estate brokerage industry READ MORE rm Event: Young Professionals Network Leadership Luncheon 11:30 a.m.-1 pm. Wednesday, May 29; Mustard Seed Cafe, Highland Square, 867 W. Market St, Akron. The speaker is Gregg Mervis, president and CEO of the Akron/Summit Convention and Visitors Bureau. READ MORE l-m- BSCRIBE TO DAY ?11.1. 1n SLIBECRJHI-I CONNECT WITH US (9 2. 7.. 5:3; ELEE. I32: mi: 5.Hum: :35; he .E