.21 Spmaf 441.5.Metm Parkway. Suite-1.10

 

- . Fart Myers,. FL 3-3915

Investigationa vspmattaSMIwestig atip?nmpm



 

REPURT THE NDENT INVESTIGATIQN OF
CHERAINA COMPLAINTS

prepared far
SCHEJOL IQARD

cam BER 15, 2-919

.. - - 

 

 

?as. - - ?1nr?

 

F: I SWInvestigations?nam

21..
112'.

Tam-.3 31333333-

Engagement?and 3130,33 I --

Emestigativewarkglann. sin-j?i-llidtli inc-i LIiujst-il?lirutiplniimxn ivi aunt-19?? iigadoulq 3 3 Iii.

2. 1223133333 .313 Whit-31313233!

BI 33.13;; .3. Lu?; 
G6 nua-

charaj?a BanerI'I illi'ii?ik??lil' .J IC '3

dBf-f Mat-"t3byw. i. 11931113 i
C1 Dr Curtia BDWden I'ilf?lgl?ll'l?th n1?! 

12. A1232 

Summary-31153313333333 1113311133 3111331 .

?yemiew 6.6569235111an 'l 
11122281331211 221116le 379 r! rarrtru-s-e we an" 431-1 '1 

33 3.2-.

gi?1l'155

A. Relevant-events 333331332323 33312. . 12
1.1113311333 333331331313 23333:? 3 33r33n3! phone 
2.313.311st 31333333333 12333383 pr3m3t?33 .. . 1'2
3 1331333315 2131 2333311 3233 33y . .. .. .. .. 
3233 302d 3233' . .. 24
2. 13x13 3333133 .24
2. 1333333.: .3 calendar requesfs 331.133 Gunnern?Aut?in? 2212 
7.. 
2-. makes 32311323 3331133313 about female 22"
2. textWith 313133- December 25 221.2 -..- . .22
10-. Mauitsby 3 wmment ?Make y3w1333 January 2012 
21.1213211332 3323 23113131253133.1213 3111123 adanuary 
?233131133 331. 21231133" March 12 2212 .132
13- 2131111313? 3233 233331? 131333131333I333n33 3.133313 2312 

2. 23311333311333.- 33333133 3231' April Bonner3h3r33 33333133 With 233ker - April 2 2.2
M3ult3by13?<ts Banner 313'?" A321 12.. 2212.. 
2333313133313 with 233333 333 Bowden A331 12 
323.3 231-133 1113 33331133rd April 23 2012 

Banner 313313 2313333 and Zucker May 2. 



Bawde? 33113 3333*; 13333323 333135331313- April 22.2212; .45
Banner 3333 3113333 1131333 33 3331133?- April 2-2 201.2. .42-
23333 13113 Zuc'kar that 233333 31-13 331: 23233 up~ May.? 7 



. . 

9-. 5911919 199919 with H9r9999 19 11919911 3999ur99s May- 10 .5-1
19.119911121919119 5011,1191 1119 investigatian 111111 pr9999d und9r $191191; .75

M93115 . 54
11 1999911991199 stoma-111119919 119111911 HMay 15. 2519 
12119195199 191999 19999 91? 9111191991 9999191911 Maw? 2919. . 
13. 99nn9119p9119 17.2019 May

19 91119 . ?-99
14. 59195911 919919 W111 59999149 discuss 9919919191919999919-3199 2(1

2515 

15 5191199: shares 1199 91199th 99999919 Liam'pia? May 2019 .53
15'. 5911919 535515 13.15.5111 and Gardner :91 SCITR 951999. ~M9y 213.. 2919 .53-
T1. 3131131151? '??t?tacts 2159151? M3y21 261g?. in -.4 a: nu Mari-1m hm: suns?!

15.H9r9y99119 HaraydamMay 32. .. 55
19' 1339999qu119119 1119991199599 prncedures 22 2915 23-.

3519.. - . 
'29. 59.19999 prepares M9m9r9959m r9: P91991191 Equity 5919919191 May

32. 5.5
21. 5911171911199 99mp191ntw31h1119 55513 M99132. 2315 .55
22?. 5.9113591' 919919999 91191119d 191395. 945-1 5650 M93125 2515 
23. 59999199999999 1.119 99mp 91nt procedure M9923 2519. .. :975
24. 51355 9111949 B99k9r 9199111 [91.19119 records 1999991m M9924 2519 .79
25.999119191191919 9199119 9199999 9991 91999411199 34 2519 
25.951199191191919 111991191111 59999:? M93: 24. ;2-91. 
27- 599991' 99119919 999119119911911 9991919th Harayda 11193124.?!

25193 
25. 5535- 31199719919 lame-r 9119 99119919199 919999999 May 24;


29.149919 statemsant 19 1999995 1119-1124- 2919 ?.75
55.. 59999119 1911 91.1599 .. 
31-. 35513 9911919999 1.19 9119111191 1919911991199 - M93: 25 2919 .75
32 3911991599191 1999:9199 5Wl' 9?gagem9n~t~ ~3999 -.4 .. .75
33. 51911191 receives 99.9199 159111199919 19399?- 49:19 19 _..791
34 59Wd9n $959939: 99199119919 11111119199119.1937? Jur19113 2019. 
3551911191: 19991999 59999119 EEOC: 43119199 June '17. .51
35.99mtr491r919r9 99991.19 91991199 99x19t9199~ L919 1.7 

37.591.114.99 919999 311991191331 ran-96191191999199[9999499915. ..52
35-. 399999 94919 39991 999919 9191991991: 19 9919999441199 13. 2919953
39.. 59111191. Gardner. 9119 139991 .919 seen 1199199 11.111911449991191 15

.. "'55
49. 39witan 9939 5W1 19 199999 1-919 (19199 .9 1919?5991191: 15 2919 
4-1. 5991191 r9999 new atlegatuans 1.11 19999999919591.115911?9 1999999"

399991: 17?. 2315 99999129 2019 -. 
42 5911991." 59.991 9913101199 999999199 1119 1919911991199? August 25 5

. 7

2919* '1'i1ff ?Elf-m1?: an? 

VI.

1111.

f?hsewatj?ns?l a. hi13u'. lira-Q; cant 11911-307? i ll I'itl'll'! r: i-?l I 89+! 331-"

319.9331. 33.3.- TWTT 9119319 99. 1211-19 . .99:
laveStigat'orY a??ciugians? 1 ii: .34.. :Lc-viisr 3113-: 3.13. an hen 11?1?} 11 a 1 11 rid-1?88

.A. T119193 is 9uffi91991 9111119119919 9991:1999-11191 319111M99119by? 9911991111
1191999911. 11119191119 99111191191111.11191119 9199199 .9 1199119 11119311
.3. 3 .3 ?.389

F1 THATA 193? 91189119111 Avid?nm 11:1 99111-11119 {that .1913} {11191111st 8119939an 19
39199919 993911191 Gharaina 99111191191 19119911111:- 1191? H. . .. .. .89

13. T9919. .19 91191919111: 9111119111193 1:9 991191.199 that Dr. TTd?d 81111119911 9 99119119
111999 9 9111119191919 1311 1119 91911-19119 191113119 19 111911111111: 91111 911911111919111
9991999 99.111191991911119 911991199] 11919991119111. 119911.19 1119.111: 911vir9n9191113
3919119121911. 9111.3 Threatening 

13. T991919 9111111919111 9111991199 19 11999199911191.131999 Haven-1919919 99119119
91911911 9 99991199111 91111-9 
99.9.1999 30111129? '9 199511119 9? 99111.19] 11999911119119 99911911119131 91119191111199
retal?atmn 9nd 1hr9aten1ng 311911991912? ..9.-3

E. T119119 19 1119111T13l91?11 9111991199 111 99111111199 1119.3 r1119 131911191 91991111111191.3311
99911191 611919199 8911:1193 139999 91?1? 1191? 19993991911, and 99119913. 3.. 

F. 111919 19 11911331919111 9vlc19n99 11:1 9911911199 111911119 SCHA 111911911 911 
111191912191 1:9!9 111' 3119. 111911919 under 95.8

G- Th9r9 19 Insufficient evidence 31:1 991198.199 that I11. T1199 891119911 3 19911991:
111-9161119119 1119 999119 9f 3119 11199911991199 constitulee: 11919991119111 91?
1919119111111 .. .. . 98

.. 11135

A. T319 131911191 (3911113191111 9199991119 9999 1191111119 19nt1919 11911119911
diso?mma?an 999911 911 disparate 99911119111 91-19 91?9ch111911911 based 1:111 . 
991111.191 11919991119111: 91 111191119 .. .1 1:19

B. T119 1311911191 99119199 11191 919191.11 9111131911999 1mm sexual harassment 1119991199

911919111 1919991111199 far 1999111119 and investiga1ing 1.1911111191919191

2 T2 9:199 1191? 111911199 39. 999911? 1: 9191119199 13191111911an 1919119119r1 T92-

. T119 13191111211 9.999 17191119119 9 9199999111 1.11999 19 91191119 that 91.119111191191019

91111 911991199913: 119199111191 91:9 119111911911 prap9r 11191119119 for Investigaimg
91991111119911911 11919991119111 91191 11191911911911 99111111911119 11111191 155911113! 2. T291832
E. T119 139111193 91199 1191 9-9119 9 39199911 commumcated 111939991 1111? 19911911111119 1:9

H.163

1:1. 1:1

fRepDrl: aft-he lndep?n-dent luve-s?ga?mn

a? Chieraizna Banner?s Camptaints

L- fEnQ?Q?mentand $?ape bfl??s?g??tiam

an May?zlh [219193, Manse! Earth-e gamma Emmy 3cm": Billiard Basra?).
prayi?ibnally ?mtalned'l Sproat Werkpiagae fiwla?iilga?ans to a??duct' an;
ill-clap?an?ie?t?utsid? I?ve?tigati?n' Cherainaf B??het?g (glaanngf') 
Superint?nden?fl?hief Bp?em?ng timer Jeff? {?Mauitsby?l sexually "harmed--
her. created a. ?hastila wark ?nvir'anmshit am? retaliated: aygi'nst ham 9n May 28,. 529.19.,
EchmliB'Q-ard tou?Sel. ?rthur Hardy (?Hardy?' ??cm?d-SWI that. Banner ?led a'aeparat?-
cigli'?plaint against. lithe aupe?ht?ndenh Ta?di? Buwdan anal 'thg Eat-Lily
'Gaqrdfimtm, Ai? H?arayda {?Hafaydia?*j allagl?ng sekua?l and raniafl ?iscr?i'mlriatiamfahd ather-
l?pmprie?ea ?71 the Sch-ml Blat?rict?s handling. gaff the .invas?ga?hn 9f Banner-?s? dalma?
agailzst Maull$hy9l Q?udUtf? at, 2:119; the Selihgl? Bqard. engagement far
lava-s?gaie all gl?irns.

an Smack Beard. auiharlzed ta expand Its Jamaal; ailment:
inalacl? an inve?s?g?atl?nl?ta E'swd'en?js ?cnuems that the 
Assaczlation GT i'rlf?rfereet will: Elsi-?nals tomplal?nt- against .B?mgn-
and Elf-11a Ban-mfg new allega'i'ians 9f 'hustile walk a?uiranr?ent and; retaliation fig-amt

lumen and 1313' mistrial. 

 

E?ga'?emmt at 3W1 was-?p?mv?lslunal until it by masch?iol Bma'r?d an Ailing 3:11.9-
1

Th3 exhibits previ?ded the framework far we investigation:

Exhibit *1 a? E-on'n'er'a May 23-19 Equity complaini- alle'ging ?discrimina?cm aha
re?t?gifia?an by 39mm and. Hara?yda in t?i?le'iir handli?g raf Hanna?s ab'mptaint agaihst
Mau??sby.

Ex?ihl'f: 2 "smartefa June 3319 Charge alleging Semal hara?sm?j?tt
wart, enmms?mant and: raaliatien by Maults?y.

'Exhih? 3 andeinfs August 13, 26129- Eater asking ta- :i?vastigage the extent
is: whi?h' gem Was: Rimmed in mmptaint against Bavarian

Exhihit 4' Latter dated August 127, 2919 mam S?n?efs mung-.31 ?mgeming new
til-aims 33f harassment, hast'il? Wart: em m?ment am retaliatim by 59mm and Miriam- tn-

?f?e District

it: Investigative-Warkwm

d??uel'oped ?Its -lnsias-tigattve Warkpla? ijndepend?h?y withaut direction 
:ir?e?er'e?ce frum?any Diisfri?tempt?ysesar Sahel-59am margihea Th3 we pergt?d
?th ?Wf ?zz- mr'widing ?rmly access. 11:9 reauested and it? current rparson'n??l;
Salami; w?hes??s?nt amp?layad by the matriet' 2313;: mpgamted Zia-thus! investigation;

SW3 .alsci LI??Zefd the: as Niasse?f Bylin? digital cia?a i?re?sics ?rm til-Extract 
massages; {rem {?auiisby?s buaineSE ?red persunal? Syil??t :?rmid?ed SW1 with. a
PDF 131* taxi snmmu?iaa?ma exahangied biatween. and Samar;- du?ag the time
"Emma- July. 8, 2S1 3f ?th??ugh Emilia, 1'01 53-. Syiiat phatag?raphad- the: Emnjis, '6."th and

ph?ib?grap?ha tha?i gna- mi appear in the PDR 5W: 'E?r?pa't??d thie: feats-r exfr?acfecl {mm

Mau?sby?s phbne with the texts that the $6.505 extracted Tram Ben ner?s 'Ph?ne? far ?We
Same ?aw-a- permi-

As-=-cpntamplatad at the :GiifSet-f at the mvastiga?on. delivered. this: report tn the
Dis?tricrt through Baa-rd The District c?d: mat watticipa-te in :def?i?mining: {Tia mutant

0? this: Q?hfa repjo?.

?tness-.99 Intewiawed 2'
3W1 i?tew?i?wed the ?lming indivlagalg;
Name Ensl?dn Ea gags)

Tia?i- Beaker :?bf?munfaa?bns- Blrac?ar' 7130,2019


 

i?haminal?unn?r 2313112013?
super?intehd?at; A . . 
GhiEf'Eparaiting?f?cer QZIQIENQ-

ems "$31341? Euwdsn ?npe?ntande?i W1 
518/26?! ?3
EM 5112019

Cara] Brown: 7i3912949-
Mike; {3.0 warm Assls?tant Sul??e?nt?nd?ht. 
Barry- E?uhi? Byzaeutma Direcior; SEE A 919I29-19

dad? E?mas A?fihg? Aggie-?at Superi?nten?den? Cihlef' 771553019
Qiperatingg smar-

Rth'eSI-Ses re?fe'ri??eii fa hi; their last- ?a?ma?s? thr?ti?g?aut ?thg email-Mr th? Inves?'gatit?n :Reppri?. in this
re?nm t?ef?a??nc? :39 mags; te?timnny-Is graf?ti-333! 1336: 75-15!- name: g?tha wi?h?essaan?i?a yam; ?um?gr 1n the
pt?wHere-the ices?'mariy; appears. Emma"! mnasias?wnrie .mt?ru'im?? ramming mm; Ba??a?s 919/2919
in?ame?.- f2; this raped as? {Winner ?1le. mama; 951111139 intar?aw ls?mf?rencg?ed 
-Lemp??s~ Simf?mfewlawrts rerer?nged as {Lame 

Executive Effector. Fa?i?fi?sr Manning.
co?struc?an

Kathy Ebaggh ?f?tmar Lang Range Planning Hiram:- ?#21291 9
Tim Ems Elatrict' Ghi?f. 
Swinger SONIA: SIM-29199
5mm. Gray Qh?fai?'a Banner *5 friend? 81212013
At- ?ar?ayd?a ?mpbyae 'Retation?a and Equity Wit-@2619

Lama Kingsle?y- Gh?tngaaden?iijn 721212319:
Witter

Scat Lam?pe MaiStant supeitintenctent. ?shiaf 77'! Exam-
??amti?g?ff?cer 

91132-019.

Qaralyn [913.5611 431?? Mault-sby?s- friend 312323.19:

Sup??ri?i?rtd?nt, Shtef ?pera?ng Sit-?1 $2919
Effice:

Lindsay 5am} .A?irniuistra?ve. Assistant fas-Ags'istant 7'315129?m
.
Ezhiszcademzc Wiser
Flay Sprirgkta Eke'ct?ive Elimg'tbr, Human Eli/26,19
Li?da?Termina .Admz?tstratlv? ?up?a?n?tehdant 7tm2m
Kathy T?t?pki??s Adm?t?tstrative Agatstartt In School Enard 7:1 $12619
B?dQEtte vzteglar what-l B?ard Member 81312619-
Gamline mm ??h?al mam/lame: 711612919
At the begmning-?t inter?ews?. infomted the witness? whit WEE .?m?taye?

by the Bist?ct thatfhey had a ditty-ta 1?me mbperata the. Investigation by laminating ail

55551155511111}: 51151 11555555.?? 8W1 51155 11511111151551 

55151151155 55511-151. 5155155555 1511' 555511155 1515555111151, 51' 151' 5511155551155 15 111-5

15555115511511 of 5 55155151111. 11155555 15.555 151355511 tinder 551111 and E115 11115Ni5w5 11151-5

5555151511: and 5.5115551315515531 .5 55111115551155

1.3255115151115115 511113151155 125111515156

811111-5155 555511155 55 511511555555 15 5551111151115 2511.51 511151 5111115111155 11151511515

12151155 11-15 15115511551155, 11711555111115.1131 5111551111515; 1151115 25555151555121 111 11115? 15115511951155

5151151551 15515111:



?rganiZatio'nal 511555

2? 13155153155 5551115515 1.551111551551151 151555111115}


5
5.

J55 555515115115- 111155115553 11.555555 5nd B55555)

5515551151 1115515515555 1115511555; 1151551115. 555' 555.1151)-

1555511551155 11155 1151511115. 15 5551515111115 5551551 [15111555. 51155155;
harass-51171511151151 1151511511511

555 5:1" 555551511115 51511 1151:151' E5 5111/ 1551'-

5511551 E55151 131531511 2.511711 8.5115155 51551 11555551115111 5.1111 d55um5?515
55151115115 11151121175!

8511551. 35551 P511511 2,32 91551151155555?- 15255515115! 5155115511115 5551.
55555151115 1515155 15115 51515111

515515555155511555118155551 135515?15151?Fr555d 11.15 5'55-55551'5551555151552

15 115 1115515

 

3 3W3 155m: 55 acknowleglge 111555 155151515515; 11111111 155 111555115551 511151512555 51" :55 5151551 1111115 551551;! 15 51115
15551111511115 5.1155 1551151111155 1155 115155515511551155 15 5551515515111 111511155511551155 5555555.

5

1i}. Dismimlna??n Qam?laintfarr? and daeuments-rala?fed- 11011-9. history

1'1?1ncummts; b5! Earmar- in?lutjiri'g Jan-1313. narrative (3f events and
samplea- galen?iar;

inf. the of the?thir?-i??lmr af?green- awn-mg. buifdi?ng-?ln 
Landings

?le for {03.11923 upswi?sqr :pcs?ition

1'iinWelEn.'$ ?le and his ?nmiine :M-ev??fS-related' ta Ban?r1513. aamplainf

135175352 rayda's ratated my E?hnzer-?s. ?amplain?t including-his gnat?s
.afthe' May 1-D, 2519 metmgand pedlna'ent ama'il?vex?hanjg?ies-

16, Text; message's: ?bemeen Maui?tsby and Bonner-du?m fine-time. perind My
23-13 and Ap?l 26119 iharuding {he D?ec?em leer. 2?5, 2013- viidea. and the
Marc-h 16. 2913 tame amt minarli?nk

:1 ?Sa-ra??ta" mm Siberiffits Repair}; fallawlrag: Emmefs ln?iaii
c?mniainm may: 22, .2619-

[3:11:33er after Bari-her was Jntewiewe? and
text maisages were ?r?fri?ikad. am May 24.4 231$

13 Emails- EEiWeen Beek?r and .

.26. ?baaf?arme?s in?ame-w mango nnMay 24., 261151

.31? Aga?iclasg vidam and-Minutes: at? 561100] 'Bnardm??tings

22. Media stat?menfs Issued by the an May 124. 211.19. and June 18:,
2019 and emails ?iactfm?nts mated ta th?ir?rapa'fa?nn and madame

23, Media acmms. ml?e??ma 'iwestiga?nh

24-. ?Gamma pravfd'ed by Lempe insilu??ng emails to and? Tm Lama anti
Sanger

25; pmvitiecl .hy .Ziergler imam: her~handwrit1?n notes {mm May
.22} 2am and 23': vnisgmafl Tram Samar art-June 41, 263191

26; Bom?enis better 1% Mauif'stgy $13ch ~th ma admm?tra?iza leave. a?aeathie
June 2029

gz?xhibit Hanna?s M33524. 23-19 complain? under Fall-by 2.32 mugging
race; anti sax discrihiinaiin? and teta'l'i?ti'oh {and Hafayda
it": ?chair hand?ng Banner?s Gamma-int against Mault??by,

28.5i?xmhit - Homer?s -June- 111, 20:19 EEOC marge allegi?gf' sexuai-
haragsment, basins-mark eavi'ram?erit and-retaiiati?n by Mault?bjila

QQEExhihi't 1'2 .. Bpwd??s August 213.19 Ie?er asking 3W1 ta imastigate-
Whether had a $913 its?: B??n?eriamt?giiaim agai?st Baw?en,

39;.Exhibi? 4i: Samaria E?fiipi?aint. allegi?'g additional glai?m-s- a? 

has-tile. mark aimiirsmmerit and retaliation by Bi 3 an and {331-va in the

 

?strict asrd?s?rlb'ed in an august 2112619 ?fa-"tier fr?'m Bun?ier?s ?gu?sel;

a .anneduras 

The fmbW?tng pandas. pracadmeg and-wd?s causid ered- relevant
it: the: layestiga?an:

1. Sahepl? Ewart! Pane}: 2.765 wBtillyl?g md? Haifa-semen: Jim-U i8)- ?aming-

 3mm! Beard Fancy 2312.1 (rev.
wens; {?Pb?cy 

3. Erhjatt'ryew?sp?iieant Student Precedure (??'iscrimina??rt i?emplaint
?Freeware";

4. Sammie gammy (tEmptoyee Hen-dhmk?)

5.951515 af?rnfessmnat?end act- ef the" 811mm Haiti 
by the 133mg! lear? Qf?Sarasata Enemy

6' (Ride at? Frafessionai Enticing: :er the Ed matter} Profeseibn in Florida-

m. gummy; 9f Governing Law

In emdhic??hg the investigation; 5W1 eiansidered the legal ?framewgrk far Bennett?s
nmglaints undetbath {warm and state tagw. Emmi; 1 ?mner?alleg?elethzatt the??istriet-
weer-in?amed against hemmed tin he; ge'hder (female) am! 53395 51:1 531' race mid color-
?(At?ean Amer-teen); In Exhibit ?-Z?Bmm?ri alleges that she was eexuetly harassed by
Maultebyy that she was subieet-te ?51 waf?e workenvi?mnment arid that ?he was subject t5
.untaiw?ul' ?retatiati?ri. tn. ?Exhibit? Benri?r (swim-s that EDWden-?e 1'49questE that the-scape of
the Limiewg rattan be: expanded-t5 in?gire inm?g??e?s relationship Withth a grandad?
e: he?stite warts: anvire-nmani fated subjected her in f?fther urtianulszretal'ia?m.

Ar-gbrief-euewe?w cfthegeven?rig {aw tweet:

Titta ?f?ih?'EMI Righte Act-9f 1:964 and-the Fiarida em: Rights Act whee en

nam??leyer {tem- dISmtm'ln-atfh'g ega?in?t an empleyee based tan certain weighted

ahara'?teristics Which malady: sex, calm? anti raw, Pauling 232 and? P315133: 2371'} are
.rsunsisfent With the fader?ai and state ram.

Unlawfuzt ?fscrimma?fim cats preseint'ine tre'iatme?ht? is the:
"type {if {discrimination- that ta mans-tad when ari- ?laims she was treated
different?iv "fmmg??ther siimiia-?y situate-d In the: farms-,- aandi?bns ari? priv?ajgas'
n?empl?oyme?t?beaause she'- bala??g?s toga .??t?b?dgmup; r?n Exhibit 1 Samar rafi?s?a a
dlslaarate iwatment claim wan she alleges 1th ma Bist?rif?s mishandled his?? 2'39wa
and h?s?il?-Wa? ?nsiimnma n?t ?ail-11$, Barium is ithat??th?
because she Es ?an Airman American and Is; w?ma?, Enwd?en and Harayd?a remanded
difF?eren?y ta her camplai?nts a?d? ?amed h?r- teas favcxrabiy-fhah they. WW 5! white; man
under'ih? same. ?ircumtanma

Unlawful? discriminaiiam nan was; fake- the farm of- saxual harassment Sexual-
:?ar?ssmenta?an churs 11193 maatfm nia??pstile weirk emzi-mnm?n? Agexua?y
hastile mark axistg wha?- unwelmme game!- advjama?; req U?s?c?f?r sexual-
favarsg-saxqany abusive a? Mgar?fanguagay mt st??ra verbai. ?vl?'ual ?21: gn?hysleaf?:mndu?t-
unre?sara?bly interfere with an emptoye? Wrath iaerfarmame-?r @69an an, 'infim-Igjia?ng,
??sfile 5r ??e?aiw Wm: ?n?ranm?nt Ta establi?? saxu?a?i HarESSment pursuanfta
fed-era! and. Fl?ciridjsi 'an under a hastite war]: ??-vimnmehi alarm an emplay?? must:
?1.3an strata that; she was. subjectad ta unimiui harassmant (3)1119, haras?S?ient'was
based 1:315 sex; am 51hr: ham ssmzenf was $u??ciian?y=smere 5r pawaaiva as waiter-the:
team at {if empkagment ?r'?raaie an abusive Working emifanmenf. Awark

enVironment- is; mane- ii-kgly'ia he tangidared; basing when it {waives the; can?uz? at" a.

ssupa-Mmr {mat-351332 supervisor is in a 13113111011 where he 1:1 aha 11; more ?rmly tabs ab?a
11:1 affect Elia-191mg aha mndi?ans 1211?? a subardin-ate?s amiilaymem;

Ian determi?ing whether :3 11119111 {environment is .hasti-?Ie, Gamma is 5111319311 bath
rgbjeg?vely and: s?bjeqtlv?ly, lbjactmely', 11:12 11.131111111131- camplafina? 111" 111-1131 be severe 1:11"
aramaeiva ?n?ugh that? at. =1?asc1na?bfe person 11111111111111111111113111mm$ 11E usivai The-1111111151191
must 3131:: be subfemhteiy 1111311191 in rather ward-s, the wmpiatning empluyee 111.1131.
11131111111311.3111. 1111115113 perceived the; 11211111115133: 111131111; at? abusive. in: Exhibit-:2; 18011111111
15- :ja?lliaging ?nai 11113111191211 sem??y harassed har 11111121 mat?. he mam-3d a 1111:1111:
an?r?nmenf.

"?Ra?taliafion'i" 13 another farm :11? discrimination-1 Kataliatib? 91:11qu When an
em?l?yer 121!? its "agents 
1:111:11:st practices fgtbi??an' by Title Vi} 131? because she ?led a Eam'plain?t areasieted with
1.11 pa-r?ielpat?gi 111 an invasiigatlpn. T1: grave unlaMuil must-sham
that her 13111115111193 aatl?lty Was the Gauge.- nf the empiayer'a adverse .aa?ant In
Exhibit 2.1 Banner is: 3111391113" {11-31 the 3.151111%. acting 1111111th BdeE?- and
Hara?jr'daf 11:11:11: adv?rse 3121111115 agai?gt?-er bagause she. mmpiained :abbut Mau?sby. 1?11
Exhibit? B?mner isgiaimirig that Mamisby in?r?icigaiedsand rat-1111511611 again-$11131 lag-111111311-
she threatewd and ultimateiy 15:11:11 u?f?ptain 31517111111111 harassment, r1 Eng-11115114..
Samar is. claiming the. that 93121111121911 1111111131 rataliat?d aggihgt her: by Euggestihg that he;
with retires-Eata?ves 9f the SOFA we1% Busplsifaug: and needed 110' ha

investig?ied-

W..- .lniradu?iap Principal. Wit?esses
A. Bxhezain'a Emmet

Banner is a: fo?y?n?ewearaold Afr-mama: grim female and mingle mother
a? gamer startedrwafkinig f?r'fhe {rt .ZS'?ptember 20:15 an a?minisira?va
tat 1113 o?f? Ema E. Emitter Elementary 15%an In. July Earmar-
Was: gamma-Ed 1a. ?begaai?m af?dmim?tratiire ?55181an I11 Watkihg far Lama, Wm was
then gaming as 1111311131 ?p?rating r11: Supe?hte?dent B?hn?r
war-lied 113.1 $11313: Lempe until he retired in July 3313'? Banner began-warking far Ma ul?s?by
after he? ?tmR-wer $21 $013..

Emmet: is gassi?ect as {a ?grin?dan?al? amp?laye'e; Garr?dentia'l employees are

   

ampiby whiz are exalu?ad Tram ih? Di'stricf?. Ma bargaining units dueta1ha-=nature of
their 'pa?'ltiu r15.

E5111 11:11:11 EME. Lam [:13 mmpletazd a wriit?n petfarmanm evaluation far Emma;
3:1 Whi?hhe gaVe tanner ihza highes'i 111:3" :catagories. In th'a
maiuatiqn 13:13sz stated; smart, hardworking 311:1 ?ianaci-ggxs; 5115 has an
incredibly mama] mmhi'na?a? 13f skills. Emma "fha?t with pew-g skills. aimi- yen: name a
?ery ram $Up?f?i?f?..dh my mln?gf??eieargfaun?h'ags mama-111m- ap-art They are: 'a-d-ge?p
53km set? that she is Willirig 1:9 1133 ft}- p'u?h ?the; .envalapenf hear ink} de?cri'p?tion, Iayaity, like
1 mm never experienxzafdi a sinta?arfa; respe?t far maple. and 11--vision far wha she is and
where? aha Wana?s. taiaad?gs ?as??biad fU?h-sr Lempe'saw' himself a1 Emma?s
me'mi?n Lem-g? air-1 caur?g?ed and. 333131311 B??ne?h her affarfs to ?rar?ate WHEN he-W?as

by 1113 'E?tst?ci and even after he fatirsd.

 

When Lempa retireci in July 2918;; gamer hag-am reparti?gr- lie} hi3 
Ma'ufta??by. Banner answered .Mazu?j?sby?s? 1311mm; mainzt?airiaial his. ac'?iilend'ar, arganizad and
a?an?ad maeti'ngs, seamed Ha an as?sistant {9?1115rampamnanaMan?lmhy
aimi- perfanngd*u;her duties as: assig mad Mailer" baga? reportihg '10 ?zumas.
as?wa Interim-13(30- asn-Jun? 2.31.39?. ?amers 'Is Initiated ?m?a the.? 0004s of?ce
ah the: awhing buiil?lzj'g in rtEIEr Landinga ?emniexg

Ban-him has never been the Sub'jant: 01? a harassment car discriminatim nampia'i'nt.
Ba?n?r Hist! net :mmplafn =01? Woflgpila'ce?haraasma?t m" dfs?rii?i?a?an p?ar in the events-

degcribed' if? the Haitian.

B. JBffIMau?s? by

Hamish? is 2a ??y-?vafyiearamd Ei?nglefhlack mare. Echqaf 35:13:96. 
Mau?sby to July; 131?? 8 under a:_aria-
year swig-?am, it: May mama Sphool 3:53:56 zapprlewe?d a fanEWai anau?aby?g maggot
far {he 29219120263613691 year. Befgte? he Ema-m Wark far ?ght; District 
as {fue- 26f Bu??iness aria Ewmmic: far Sammie; taunt?

As. 'Mauitstay: gupa??ses the fan-Hawks; Hum-5n
Reaouraes. a; Nutr?inn, ?ames, Fanning f5; canatrusa?nn-, 

rafts-ma?a: Teahncriggya any! Safety man-nabs: gi?ip?c?y 3mm. The

{amm- is J?c?f?d an the rains: ?mwf {ha-gram awnihg-building at ?113 Landings..-

Cl? ?May 24,. n?i?e was th??g??d it: Ram-1E? In the "bite- .aw?i?g
Wilding ET. {ha Landihgs? Man G?thIn?uad tr?! perfehr'm His usual-d?u?as: as 1309' after

?the physical m1acatfon. InaI-udings regular attendance at meetir?ig?s 9n ?the third ?aw of the

12-

green awning blinding where Hanna's of?ae-was 'iiacamd.. On June. 21629 Manitsby
was placed an: 31 Paid administtat?ive have :11" abae'mfz? pending the 9f 
:inv?s?g a?am

Mammy is?tified that he has never mag??2 2? "he mm a 

harassment qr diag?m?ina?w the EVERE?-addras??xedl? 111132 

Gurtis ?Tadd?iBamI:??-

E?wden Is :13 f??y-Eii?ht-yearnol? rn'agt?iad White male. Startedwarkihg at.
the DZ?trictzi-HEOO? wharf. he was a?nbi?ted Di?recta?r 5? the Sarasafa (gaunt? 
Jammie. He later baa-Elma Exacu?w master {if 351126351: Teuh?if?al ?611,292. in
Navamber' 2616- 'Baw?eri was a'elected as the Eaperintand?ent' ta Succ?ed mfirlhg.
'Eugerintendenf Lari White Bewden wanna-"ed {he duties Superin?tandent In: Mart-5h
20-17.. in Faint-mar); 22192113: Gahmgl ?Bmard' apprwe?da 1.12%? ?mpinymant agreementfor
.Bpwdew?zatbegan Fabruaw 2L1, 2619 arid ?h?dE?L-Dn any 376. 2023 Batman reparts tame
swan: Egar?d. assingrit superintengien?s- Maintain-lg: {he} GOO 
Eamnf ?awzienfs amaze is an the WW ?Harm of the green; swing 2211;211:153. at the"-
L?n?i?gsa

andan has: ?eet-1. 1112- sabject 6f? Ee'x'ua'i ?ara?ssme'm eiaims: before am! after his
azpp?lmtm?ni a3: Swarm-Tandem; Baf?e the Salim] Erhard selected Batman as

the? mare: gamma?! ?utsi'de .c?u?S?l ta'c?a??uet: an investigatim mtg-
Miriam that B?wd?n asexual-2 h?af??e?i ?Sagan Farres?t 21 fewer mack-13221

Su?caast Technical 391E693 and. that-Bawda? {crsa?tada- hastilza wail: 

 

Lather-aislstanat SQ ?p?ii?ehdents are La ukaihgsl?y; Chief ma Clem]; ?f?car ?hd? haircut-am, til-?e?
"Ema-22a: Gf?'c'?h

:13

dlser'imin atianmr arad rafaliate??if against Lyna Jlmiriez-Ruiz (?Jimipez-Ruizf??z an Asgista-nt-
Erireqtor If the. Euncmast Tedh?-?mal ?ail?age? The udfsid?e i?mstigator submitted 3 7355976
an Gabby-4. 2m *3 Wash] Reparf?} finding F??m?fsa?aga?ana in be ?incmc?mive? and
finding meime'z??niiz ?55 claims Qf :hastiie wark ?nx?mnmantisexual: and
rataliaticn-tc: be 

After beaming B?wden has been the $ubject {if we: EEGC
charge-5 ?led. by 17mm; Ruiz, In [?acember 2131.7, dimi'naz- Ruiz ?led ?harge
571 '1 7171-3791113, in whieh she alleged-{him Ema-en: and Jimmez-Ruiz.? augervisdr retaliated
again?t her far making Quad faith sa-xual harassment qumamta The ??h?ai gram:
retained an but-side affair-1&3! Mahard Blyiston?. fa cah?uata? nutside investigation a?
imam?mix? retalia?cm sump?iaihtjs, {h a Fabruani 1% .2613 repart, Ewart")?
Gandu?ed that $173 refaiiatim ali?g?a'tians 393m Hawd?n ?Ware" "LI?f?uM?d?
The EEGG iSsued a. right-ta sue;- {atterm 77ng 17 W13.

(?g-Jung 1-4, 2613 f??d BEBE: Iii-range 5?14?201:B?f332f? In: which aha:
gilt-agar am?'?g gther- min-95, that BaW?en-asexually harassed hail-3'1 July 2:315 mama-1
Bawclen' and aiming-Ruff supervci?aar canti?ued ta retaliate 393mg:- her 'aitEr Bawden
:beczame ?uparEntender-i The EEQE I?aued a right til} we la?er manage $1,113.,

Jimmy?Ruiz has maimed it: pursue hair claims again-atthe Sahml Beard based
an attegatigns that she was the victim at Bpm'en?a sgxual harasgmenti hastile? wark
gmiira [Imam arid? feta-Simian, a$ we" as anther 61711113,. in- a iawsuit ?led 'in-iederal caurt ma
c.3537 Smieds-Sm?oaf Egan? af-Sarasofa G?y?iy, 3:1 ban?lng? in. ihe

F?d?ral District Quart far the Mld?fe Bi?t?ct nf?FiQ?dE

ill-

Alf?ed Haray'da'
Harayd?a is 2a: black. male; Haraydia :STa?rftad marking. for the-
District in: 261-11.; He cur-re ml? sawesa? the Relati?ns andiEqLISity 

Awarding; in. Harayda's ?escr?iptim- he is required in pa r?'c'i'pjat'ei- in personnel:

rdiecimnjs: in munit?rand: ?ivansee all {awestigatians far the .E?striia't

and: it? serve as Eng-DistrictEq-mty Ba?r?l?at?r,

The lis?crimlna?m ?emplaint Frb?edures state's that thia- Equity ?aardinator is:
requnsibJ? far men-itqririg? i?he Haiti-erg. c'amp?anca With Faderaf and state 're?gulat'iens?
relating ta. xiv.? ?ghts, disefimlna?an and hfarasmeni; The Equity Gaairainatqr is alm-
far Guardina?rig msp?nags ampfai?nt?.

Harayda ta" Sprinkiei Emcu?iva Director af Human Resources. Harayda?s

af?ce Is l?cated an the first flagr- maroon building-at {he :Land'in?gg.

ii; Summary-1% Evidence and Findings-331* Fact

This sgc?an 91" ?the: Rgprart is. :h'rgke?. dawn i?tc ?iwcr :secfi?ns. The ?rst Swim

mavens Wants?that mantredzb?for? April '91, $019 (the! ?ats: "the first received mike

that Hannah-ad canaams Th5 secondsercgtiar; swam-wanki-

?ih?at 933.91;er after April 19.. 203-19. Each Segiion. Sis. divifci?ed? in-?tb taping. When. the"

tapics are presented Scimie, teams maid not be addres?ed sequential-y

?ecause the matte?ra deyc?bed presa?ted mm .as' a pa'ttam of sanctum rather than. a:

?fs?nct eveht 3231*- ?bc??sa use mule-f recent! th? 6:1.th eVenTs a?currad?

 

5 Th? Praagduria Wanda mad t9 Ir??lfhme?t was? 1.72; ?1113 Dist??l E?mpfai?f Premadu?e. was
reward-m an Patina; ?lms rammi? in- 21318;


 it'hr? radiant that" ma?ars were disputed, made t3? fact using a
prepandemnce the -.evidence steward; {in making ?ndings af?ict, SWI congider the
nradib?i?tyafw?itnas?es. in making eans??ider?d fa?ars 
as; wh?thefr a w?ness' ?testimany was mrmbor?ated by Either evidence; whether the
testimnng-was ?tausibiee and .maaona'bla- undiar the circumstanC?S; the ?tness-
haa-ihra? mains. anti know ?ber: facts abautwmah ?haalshe testified an?wheihar
the Mi?fe?ss mad? m?ir'aidistary ctr- statements.? in making. ?rej ib??ty'
?eiermf?ations: 3130.. yam Histmiy, psi-3331311; bias. and? m?ve to:

fall the-truth.

A, 'Relievant ?ven?-?u?mrring baf?e ?p?l :95. 2019

52a Banners persanagl PHGEIE

ganja. 9:31? ?ts: criticsal magma fn' this i?vas?ga?an carries fram fha 83-1. text
:messagessthanged hem-em arid thei-rpermna]; malt" p?hane?s during-
izha: 151m paria? dilly 7.281% thmugh?p?l 55,- MBU'?sby was assigned: a; ?ll 13:2:an-
far ?iatriimi: business, but he prefer?ed ta iext Banner Using- persanal .ae'll ramme-
acceur?. axpi-?alned ??at'bef?re his .a?iciai'stari ?ate- :B-gnner scam a twig his
parse'anal' .nu'rirstsar.? .50 jib-73631119 a ?fh?abit? fa? him: is text her fram his gamma! ml! 9mm
gammy: did an}: use; .h13=personai cell: to text ether {Hakim
Buamr Lita" mat have a Bifst?di assigned net! phnne; as. she
recafw?d all- texts her eel! 

Mau?shy admiiterf manna-313x19 ha ?i?h??g'ed w?h- 36!:an Were part- ?ers?janai

anti m?rbuaimag Mauitaby ?aiSuacknaMed-ged he". ahaukf have usedhls

1e;

District phone fer mistriet bueln?ese Hawaiian Meulfeby did mt bellWe that his text.
communicating- w??h Be?n?er meted emf ?ie?riet were. {Mau?lteby 5131.? 
{Estifie?e that he mi think. his ?text eemmu-niceticzns with Bonner were unweleeme.
sexually effene?lve- er etbemiiee inepprepriate when bieWee in The een'text their friendly
ane?iexieg reatienshie-{Meuliehy 6e 

.Bfeenerife?lt ?e?ieisi?ee in the texts made-
fher feet ?F'unebquriable?! but ehe Seemed?" meling (Benn-er 57). (he. {he taxis
became mere ?frequent em; persene'i; Banners discon?ort increased it} the: peter She
became .dieguefed are even ?reman-ed {Banner Banner ieetifled that 
mix-ts ma?a heaed Bonner had a beecr'et 
{Heme-r 91}. Samar eheWe?- same e?f Maulieby'e {ex-ts: te her- friends-r een?dentes-en?
mee'rkere end .eeniempereneeue abused her.
In her Interview; Brenner iden??ed the Speci?c text eemmuereatiehe wiih Meqlisby that
truebfed her {he must. These Speci?c-text exehan'gee are deec'r'ibeci in further deta? fate:
in 

SWI ?med? the feliewin'gj ebeewetiens after-exemmleg. the ?re?y ef text. exehengee.
Many ef the ie'xt. exchanges bene?ted eu?fs?e heme Many bf'ibe e?erheuts text;
were Initiated by Hamish? late ?at: night, mating ?weekeih'de and ever
belideybreeke Meet Nil-13.163123, sent euteid?ewerkim heme-dirt not imbibe. matters that
bemd be reaeenably viewed as relating- te ?ietrie? mault'eby did net-g think: his
texts were E?apgareertaie er? ?exually effie?eiye- {Mee?eby-SB. 19L Sweet: and Seeker-
iesfi?ed fhet. they feub?i Meeltsm?s {Side to be i?apl'?reprifate. but t?'ey did but think.- any

were sexual? in nature (Semen beet?)



?SWI-disagrees with Maulisw, Homer: and B'ee?keri'??pinkm {ems-
wera not sexua?y Wansive. ??ds 1113*: mg {reggae-hay, timing and pf
Walfaby?g taxis stalwart B?nner?s niaimS: {hat-shame; ?ubja?ted. ha that
were :rm?t my inappmp?ata; "they-ware sexuaiiy uffensiye and. intimidating espggiglly in
{he eta-mam =91? a team 
ma?iiamd ta Rama?s: peragpt?ionsexua?y has?le Was-k-



Maul-{shy discourages: Samara. pram 5151321-

!t is ?ndisput'ecf that .Banner wanted in? pms'ue pramntianaf mpmumxm in the
Ifatri?t; :rsibnmar biaims that ?lmed. her anamptata again pmm??oha; The
disputad issues are mam-t; and. t9 whatext?nt, iriEa-tarl'riterfere With Satan-erg
a?empta Lin ?bita in a -pr?szmn?hri..-

Lamp-a khew?fhat ?ie it: have arr-waning ?x mate-summisor
in iha G?p?rtme'nt ?empe encouraged Harmer it: apply far the?. :pnsitibn
mania-became: av?il?hfef Ban n?mbtam??d her-Elia]. anemia ?ers'?rial timaih meter
12:3 gamma-the jab? Had Emmy been?ff?d far the feats" sup?rvisgarpasii?an she-maid
have mseived a $14f55'3 infaraase in [mar?annual gamma.

B'G?riersubmi?ed. an-appltaat?nrrfar the mute '9upawi?'ar'pasitiqh n? May 
mag-r testi?ed that an July-?16. 291:3. the she met- Mauiisby and harm he
amaziwa ?ied work. she ins-Id him that she- had app?li'ec?i fai- me: ma?a superv?i?sormsi?cn-

(Ba?mr 22}. Banner ??stifiie?d ihat when cgn?rmed that the .rgu't?eg sape'rvisar

 

5 The. in}; ?es Grimm: for mum 'gun'a'rvls'ar lists. the pomsgicin of a '?alld=Fterida Cummarttai Driver's, Ligensa with
mass: ae?ndagsament as one ?f-?thje quali?cations-far theft-am

1a-

pnsithn was under his chaff: an? Bamm?di Ma'ulis'by mm 30111131 $he=?a?ld 11111113111119
11313 1939111153 hanmde??ahmi? ?ayin har b?rfent-pmitioma m-ake'hir? 
Maui?tsl?y 1131-1511 Making 1:111: Statement that. B??ner 111111111133 11:; him. Maultisby said
1116 tu- hire? tha? mute Supervisor was made 'pri?arto his. employment? {Ma nit-swas-
Ham-Jen 13111111111 rev-auras :indi?ata 11131 3111111151 ih-ieNieWed' for the- pasi?ma 1:111 July
26. $3319?, $3Verai days after with th?- District

Bannef was dl?apwi?te? aha: lear?ad Samsone? else ma aaie'?ted 111111.11
mute- supervise? position, Banner was 13111131159 ?aha .wha was
Sal-acted 1:11:11 net: have; a 091,. 'Bcen'sa; B-mnier testified that 111m. ?i'ring decision was
EH?D'ufl??da Mlult?sh! reminded: Banner-111a: he 161d he '-was_ 1191 mm '10 a?llaw-ihe
Bi-r'ectcr is; him her {char- Sam-1511231111121! that'Mau?sby triad:-
her 311131111111 her that he writ-11d 991119115: 1.111333111111111 lie-Ram 1113;111:111 getting
11131111 {Harmer 34136.). When Emmet?triedtaexpiain 1111111111111st ?at 
gm. 11:21?- 3121532,. 11211111115511 said that Beswdar: maid let him give {151 a raise ff he?W??thv
(Ba-mar 34:35}; Ban-mar itesti?ed mat: singe- she- swat] 11611131519 1m 11131111311111 She
1331211535961 an interest inseverai oilaer-p?si?onsj 1.111111111119115 .p?sitionin? Faun-Ribs, Flam-1mg
3'1 C-??atms?en-ahd 111 Human Briana-163$; chevgn 313111131 did nat'aig'tuallx 11151111191113
aim-251* .pasitic'ms b?ca use she W??ld n?tall'aw- her 1a 39am.

11131111151111 d?nied having anyfh-ing in ?air-WEE). Emmet 111% being Selem?d as Mum
supewlsor p?siti'an. Maialfsb?y tES-?fiad thaf-he tried fa wit a raise for. ?Bnn??ir". but he was
bin-med by iHuma? Resign-raga testi??d 111131. 119 -never-1?r?a?tenfe?d' 16111111111151
11111 1137111112: 21113; .acti??s 1316919111: 3911531115111 taking another?jab. Alffhaug? Mau?sby

wanf?d Banger IQ remain as his administrative assi'ste'sjrijt,i 112 am 11151: as anything {in

19

discourage her advarixceimeht, {eati?ea' that it-Was Ban ner's ??cisidn- ?at ita appiy.
far .pih?r p??itin?s. because aha di?rj't ainy?neelse 419' wqu Tar (Mammal??-
?23am. ta Bo?n?r itoid himafhe mam-way shiaiwnuld leave ?af-pa?ition
Was if was. :ablsa in r?pla?ce Baring-With his farmer administrative. 
sarasotacaum 23};

There is Ma?a-giant. madame "ta .?tIppo?-a ?nch?rtg that Mau-Ji?byi?fer?red With. 1'31?
prevented Banner from getting the mute supeniisor izubn SWPS- myiew {if the hiring ?le;
that that ?rms; cemmi?ga? lava highar rating?- ata- 
?an?date after; It 115;. passible that. the Transpar?tat-lon 'D'irectar Wha, was an?: if? fbui'
members art the hiring cummi?eg gaveamner Iawarnumer?icm; rating-because he was
thil??need by ?Maulisby, ?ewever, there is; i?su?mierrt Evide?ee it; Make that factual?
??n?ingz?

Evian if Mann/shy 13w rim- interfere with Banner-s promcitibn it: mite- sup?n?sor ear-
any gar. the-9mm :pasi?gns m. 'Whiah she amassed Ian. 'Iniertest, the: greater weight if the,
m?dEnCe .supperts a ?n?clirtg. that rapeatedly mid ?Bizarre? and. anther District
em?pleyees "th?tihai wemd b?iunk Hahn?s-rig attempts ?e waniied ta- keep?
1161" as his; administfa?Ve aSs?iSfant "Fm: {ith?r a?mfm?stra'?ve assistants! Tami?inss and
Saba testifi?d that. On $everalmsasimns may ?aa?r?d Maul'tsby fell '39 nine-r {Hat he 
not lat ha? 193% {Saba 216-4 8, ?Fan-?liking Kingsley testified that Saba and'?mner
cam-E'- ta .tser is: nummain about. attempts. if: hints}: Emma's caraa-r

a?v?a?a?ment in the ?istrim; ??g?slay gave 'Bcw?en. a; mags up abcut B?nner'a

 

3 The Transp'art?tl?n ?lrecwr Wasn?ot {nmruiewa?m he mighg?r empinye'd ?v?tha mst?nt.


 

'E?mpiai?t? amt ecu-Id mt ran-all When. that conversation mic-mad ?(Kingsley 1'74?
24-3

Lemme; and" Hammer stayed in class: camaat after Lempe's retirement: (Lenipa 
Way were friends;, and Banner :riei'iecf an Lempa far amine and fur valicfatipn .of 1-733:
swarms i-(Lampe Hanna: tald: Lame {hat- Mauilisby W?uld nat- rather itie'aue take-
a'nnt?er martian In- the Hattie: (130mm 2?9, Lamps; 2323),. Lama a?w?dlaa ?a valunt?azy-
mentm fa Manna-.333. Lamps. whenever he mafia-rim: encauraged
Mau?sby t9: 13p ink: Banners- patent-Ea? and?iqpmm?fa {L?mr?g 
Lamga pmicfad a mp5? Fe'hruaw 34, 201:9'Ema'ii? he it: Mau?sby
?lming a mentumhip lunch. In the; Lia-rape reminded. Maui?sby?ihat Banner "has
paten?al. way 339.3313 her 3113331313134"

The greaterwa'g'ht?f maavidewa suppants. fhe ?nding that Maulisby discouraged
Banner mm iea?i?g her :p?nsi'tibn as his administra?ye assistant 3: pursuia .athar
3335331133123 in the mam-.3; arm-(1733333331131! was, frustrated with 11353333612
'suppant; The greafgar weight 393 thesavid?me ?1.30 suppo?s .51 3113139 1511.33 mt
pas?ians- [33631132 ?he rea?ahably by wauid black her 3mm.

9.331 mg the lab,

3 Mauligby rapraaentsp??rat Idwda?h-is ?his bag?

Samar ile$t??ed that Mammy tighsta?fl'ybr?ag'g'eq that Bowden-Was- his friend and
33.93 maid get Bawds?- tn anything Mammy wanted {Bci?r'mer?? Mauliaby
piat?urie's Elf he and ?Bawd?en aagiallzl?g. auia?ide (83336: Banner?

qute a narra?vE-in Which aha deagrihedhow Ma?ltaby axp-Ialne? his retatibn'shm With the

21

Schaial Imam. Hamid Banner that he Knew nftha?ahnal' Baard members fhaBm?
Was JEde-enfs. 5:233; they :3.an tell me w??tia dfil ?int. Ebwden 15 going; Etc). preterit ma,?
Samar-asked Mamt?byww ??edad'?liiana?s as he had ?ai- br?eEn. with the. District-lying
Waugh-Lit: E29 thinking-3mm how-ta gei'raut-af trauma. replied; ?Wu have {a be
,grep?ar?a?"; Manna-{by ?eld Bizarre: he didn?t have anything tn Warm 95mm As 1mg aa-
Bawden Was theta-i W319i: was 3an ?becgusge ?itha?f was high-m". manner believed fha?t?i'
?a?iiaby'had tha ability to. get Hawaiian in aa- Whatever he wantiad him mm ingfu?ding
terminating ?lm?tars (Briana;- ?13648}.

mm? Mtnassas 3190 ?Rated mule! in?u?nce Bdwdenks dariisianm
Mia feierred'ib Emela? ,as-?his my?; Ehaugh- fastl??d 1113*;
?ag; was an Understanding ?when he says my. bay; {hat what 
Expect beca?semd? reamiie?h'if? 155 there? {Ehiaugh 41, 99430;? Ebaugh said that
exit-2n Sher as ?a tin-emu Would' amt tan- Bpmiden mat aha (Ezbaugh) was :haviing-drf?cumes
waking-with Mault?sby because aha haw alas-a EtaWden was ti: Mauitsiby (Ebaugh


3.3an ?Framing and" Lemgae i?s?fled?chat Maulisby a?en? referred {a Enwden as 3mg-
bay" {Saba-36'. 'an?ki?s 3&34, Lemm- M. E?arLIgh @341}; When Lamp'e W33 mania-ring
may tamed ahwt his role as assistant Mauitshy?ta'ld Lamps- that!
his jab dasc?ptia?' WEIS simple. 113 protract'the superinien?eni; Miault?by midi Lama "that's.
my my; 1 961? in- take tare a? my bay? ?(Lempa 39:43). Lamps testi?ed that Hanna tram
hli? Sh? was cancer?ed abaut belt-13 a part ?f iihe t?am masti?ga??g her

mmtaiaini. ?anner' {hanght' if- E'm'raen ahd Have this ?my hay? she

22. 

(Banner) were 'rtevei'r?get a fair shake. 'Lempe-theught Banners. cortcejrn's were legitimate,-


Bewden teetified that he never ?knewthet Menlteby referred 1e ihim? (?-Mdeh) as
?his: best" tint? flute-meeting with Bah-net. lit the. Apr'it 12, ?201:9:meeting;
Eenner tutti :Bewdenthat Meetteby bragged me regute?r East's that?he end Sumter: Were
frienee, that 'Buween?weutd take gave- at? mm Matthew) and that the? bath. had. se?eeh
what's-backs Stewart was e?urprlejeti ta hear that ?uze'eet the
term ?my hey"' Maulteby prevbuely"teolt te?ensewmn gemstone etse-?ueed that
"term. Meel'tsby theught ?te tree at the term we 3 racial elur?(B?uwden 3940-, 
Bewden testi?ed that Mau'ttetty must have ewerteted their 

Matthew testi?ed-that-he did, ?atten Aethers- that did he ever im pty? that 
some exereiee undue in?uenee eve: amen {Mammy 32) amet?teby edema-my ?en?ied
ever reterr?mg to E:eth_en- as this heft. Meutteby eats! that heart Meir-see Mariam?male he
?eets the term te he extremely.? tier-'egetery amt that he newer nee
thatrte?h {Maulteby 32433;

SW1 {tie net matte ?eeing-e ehetjt the extent at the pereenet 'retetienehtp between

Bewcten emit 'Mauttehv er Me?lt?ahy?s ebi?ty te ihfleenc'e- Bereri's ct?eitijsa,?icinu?s?T

'HeweVeIf. EWE Wesebte tcs'. ehtrtelude- that the greater weight ef the etiidettce Su?l?txrtedl

the-eehel'ueten that me?y Distriet empteyeese inelud'ihg ere-me. reesenettly helteved that:
Matthew tied. a. panama] friendly rel'etienghip-WJth Bewden eateide tat-warm that Bw?en
had back and the-f Matthew has. able te- ie?ue?nee Bewd?enis hereon?el

.Etecis'fbne.

.23

4 Maui-tab? mm so?d-nf?ce: diam wa?ugust 20w

pliaris to remade] his hisaffinl?alstartdate', HE
midiBonnerzhe Wanted fa replace ?laWihd-?mira?- af?ae ?-aarwi't? a solid dam. Banner tried
ta :d'iscaurag? :B?n?n?r hid Maulishy-fha?i 134mg behirta infused .dbarsmn- b1?
unaamforta bla- fear wcm?en. $he ?pIai?Ed-ih?t afha'r ?ad?mm331rat0'r3hava?v?h??ws in ?thait?
nf?s?e- drama bgca?u-se it mamahaa transparenay and discourage; mg permp?m Of
.iniimida??n .{Ban?ar 51453;); Mammy tai?lv [away that pe'cple- Were may; :a-hd may .di?n?t
need-2m see What he was doing it? ?ts ?9151??ch {Banner 53-543; Mau?sby migrati- ??tha new:
amt Whert the solid dam was dam-area. 'Bm?erzsent it. back, Maulteby rendered ftTh'e
Saiid affine was; .ins?ta?ejd an Aug" List- ?419.

Ma?a-by mat-ma that he mag-aired 1a" scjilid af?i?e am? Fascia-use he ha-ntf?ifas-
.mn?dantial? infarma?m and. ha did" but want :em anti-tennis; hr aha diairac?nn thaw-Miriam
{Magliaby 523. mat Edhnar was agpnged: it? his desisio?n ici-
replaea-ma ?amhep?ausash'e wanted id- ?pm?taqt him fmm- making an actuation
of?harassment 512-53 '?i??ilssed Bahner?s 64:13am because 
(mau?ahy) ms alwayaj- very ma?a-Irma? and his behavior had mas/err been quajstian?ed?

(Maulisby .513).

5. Ma rinsing/*5 taxts int-coma parsanal Ausumn 26-13-

81: mar testi?ed that-51m afihe ?rst Egg-that made her unmmf?rtabie wag thra Ext
With-?113 wing Emmi that Mau?sw sent her a: 5:223 an August: 242,: 21:13. Whit? .3-
after he, started at the Bisir'ict (Banner ?81?821 Same-r mapa?dgu, tn.- the

13The rm May 1112619
24-

eme'ji by eSkih'g Mammy what wee Wang-c reputed: ?l miseygu MS: Raina-e?
Be??er tuae elect distumed by: item. With crying, emails that: Mauitsby sent her 4311.
S'epi?mber 2131418 when Banner Iitild him- ehe might; mat; be in- the affine when he:
retardant. imam- a meeting. Mauitsby did mi? thi?k them was anything Improper er sexually
anggestitle ahuutihie teXE's. and hie use if nryi?g em (Sits;- =Hexiee??ed?matwa$ aim 
enmmuntaate. to. Egan's-r that. he had tam-gear]: he: fee feast at the day (Mammy-seen

Emitter testified that"; she was Emmett-ed: ?y the ?9th Mammy-513mm Sememher 3,
29%" at 1:91.25 jamswhieh had 110- dialztigue Inlet. en emejt With aiset at ages leeway arena-cr-
{Bertram 3M1). Btu-hm}: fart Elke Maultahy Was: leaking at heir: Bonner did net respond.
maulie-by said that the text with, the, eyes emoji Medea- te be tenaid aired in thacarrtextef
their Earlier text cgmmuniea?bns about. a talented Meat; basketball Mayer. Mauilt?sby
tastified that he Smith?s eyes tame}: taxatennarsafe an tackn?wle?gment that he recognized
the master was wanted. Mautisby?id ?at-thigh leaner wattle be=-offendee 
.frtanelyftextat wiz?pm (tummy-3264;.

Ermine;- testi?ed that Shexwas alga- bnthere? by a: te?gthy fair Exchange- that
?Mauits'by initiated ram sun?ga'y ?ecemb??r' arms, at 7:31? pm {Banner v7.49; 
sitar-ted the eenvarsagicm With they" testi?ed he kissy faded Emails; receiving a
reaper-137$; swltahed ta the rapt-r:- uf?vt?ha Relieve game. Banner tried ta; anti the.
amalgamation at RM pm with the eommenti ?yam have 3 agent! ?eeing?; hid 
maimed. with a. series a? taste beginning; .et ?#155. pm: ?t lave yeti Remain?. ?Veg: knew I
Ignite. yam Ms Raina}: ?Jim j?u?i kiddie; This "Righ??t
Hemmer requnded at $558? pm with emej?ts: filmed by the te?xt: ?I?m ever it far 

IMat-Jlteb? cen?n?ed- it: text Bonner; N: 55193. rim the texts-d: "Ms, Raine. :i'm eating! [We

2?3

yeu; Fm over ?Let Boenei replied new you ep?eraiemwliey ever- But
.1 knew ire-er kind!" Hemmer testified that she was {adhered by ?ew the 250719;
text exchange started as asfriendiy cenvereetien? arid-ifher?i 'te Iii-ire;

MEL-i?e?by testified that in the December-913mm mid-mitersatiori was simply him
F?zezz-ing?? Ben-ear after hie ieiem, theReicieie?. beef her'team, the Pirates, He ehareiifeized
the eemereetien es bemg ?ifFie kind ??iet'f?e?n??s have after foeibeii game {Meu?e?y 66?
3934 ?Meiiltehy testi?ed- that he di? Fie"? use :the farm ?me" fa.- ernee any beuntieries; he
used it in newer that he. said: 15 eemmei'i in ?the? Af?ne r?i Amerieen mite-re {M'euiteby 
Ma?ui?eby tee??ed the! hew-ee trying it?! cemmun?ieete :th at there weuid be he ?ar?d? feeijinge
ever-the ga-me'when i?ey returned 'te Work the maxi day 

:Mau-lt'sb-y'e ee?ytexge in Eeneer serve as: preef eat Mealteby? began 
trie- b'eumia?ee the?! sheet-d exisi between a: supervieer and me eubar?di??eie mm the very
beginning inf-hie employment- Wiih iherfe?isiriet. Banner did: netiutexther
Hemmer. the greater weight 61* the ewdefnee euppons a ?nding that Be?iier did} net
weieeme the text :comrnuni.eatie?s.- There was nailegitimate business-reasen-fer Maulteby
in text- Benner ebeei matters at Fer-him te eend iexte. that meld reasonably be

'ititerpreied as an exgre'ssi?on 0f pereeneiia?ee?m.

M?u?sby?e ealerider 20?13

Bennie; began having GQHGEMS ebuui' Meeit?eby'e Werk;-ethie immediately-
a?er he eteriet?n the peei?ti'on Fer example, Beer?Ser- iE?stifie?i thei- Meniisby eften
asked .EIb?nEr {e [albeit eff time. {in his. eelendar fer fake events $th es 

(Banner Banner minke .?Meu'itetiy made 1113 fake $3 the Hive

25-

 

Wank} ?at-be,- charged it: Manna-W's rparsanal? a?osgum {Barrier 116; 
Lamps", Ebaug'?i and that she was {rati?ed ask-Edi her ft:
galen?ar rim aexlatm?-thatvrher?id mial?an ma?e?d (King?sfay 
Ewan-33469,. Salad 14;, Lem?e-gg?irmed that'iihe practice Banner ?gsc?ibsd was

inapprap?ate {Lempe 4541);.

attire
I??nier about the way Mauifsby {mined at her,

and: that aha started antiefi?g hars??if up at (Bah?n?er' 4208.); Eb'augh: cprrabc'rated
Banner?s featimciny. Ebaugh describad haw 'Ma?u?isby reacted to {ma-13f Banner?s. ?-Lff?ts
{ay- her up and drawn. Ebasjgh :?bsenz?ed ?aw wax-{Er time, Ham-er Very
guardati Err her Inieraatians: With maulf'?by {31:19:th 34) Han?ar hag'ari ?mssi'n?g mer?
c?n?ema?veiy, She-dici- natwan?a-?shaw mama: am: she si?arlr?dsweajring a Big sweater
every ?ag. Benn-er ?0in - Ebaugh that She changed her-walk attire becausa 

on name-ms" and lanka made. her" {Ebaugih 19-22, 333%

Hamish}? makes. affansiv? comments about fan-121.4 Emplayaes 1-9

Banner teamed mat Mammy made Unwelmme ??xuai gamma-ms abwt diner
female empiaye?s m?i?bui?d fa Banne?s 
nhargjedi en?ranme?t Same -of time, Eam?e ?ts are Ethbit.

3-. Senna. mime-mare- specific anci natable gamma rits tare summarize? ?aiawi.

 

9? was mable t?n-sietexmine the speci?? ?utes-{hat made tha a1; ege? aca mme?ts 345411354 in. "mi?
Shaman af?theirepurt?



 

Mauitshy did mt get alum with! ?ne: af The f?male directors in that Facli?lea,
Planning Gangtruc?on Department. Mamtst?t?td Bumsar that he Was grainy 1'0 get rid
.af' 1116?. 'MauEtSb?y said: ?Lima-k aft-ha, wanna never Tm? Her. Sham {Samar 
Magiishy ?amed making the comment Be that he ?ever taiks that Wayfa .Ifadias.
and he may ma?a the sommefnt ih?i Batm?r describ?d 3mm:
Wit?assm. Ira-ducking Dumas. camb?mad The fag: that" Mammy arid ??le female directm
r333 had, it is undisputed that the female ?ifectar?s ,mntract was mt] rewazwed for the
EDIQIEGZQ llamas- teattfited that 1153. net- Maalisby, made the 
whit}?! was based, in part mi the dimctar's inability to adapt it: waking with. Mammali-
(mums Tham- was nu mmass Wm cautd warre?mate that made?t?e-
statemang? that he ?wczu I451 mi the fem-ale airman

Ban ner said made;- inappxap?ajte qammenta his: her .abnu-t ansfharfema-Ie
direct'or- whit: Mam-s by ihht Was? ?irtihg With him; Ember tea-we?d i?at- Mail??by said
am. Rama ?fair-me arm Ram whiz: she J's-megsmg Fm afba??fiinthe bani, mm have

her ass mifmlai?ng the: wait.? {Banner In his interview Mau'l'fsby a?kriOWI?dged this

"par?m?lar Tamale glitector asked him-ta lit-Inch; 151d: gamer be 616 natwaht ta he

.610?9?u3?1ihih?famale dimmer. Mhu?sw gait} am} Euhherjnked the siiua?im
Hamver, Mammy adamantly denied making me vcg'mmanii that Bram-er to him
1 91,193), ?1 don?t ?talk that way- in Tram caf ladieaf? {Mault?sby 1033-); here mire 
witnesms 1a The 

Banner said Mauitsby- mad: in?pp?ap?ate commants about annther? 'f?n?ala-
ampitzyee wh?t-?sxmessed an int?are?ln tramferring mane GT the d??artmants Maultaby

Bannar testified-that -Wuitsby ref?rried its the female ampiaye?e's =13:st and

23

said he muid mt hire her. Mault?aby said he, maid; get in 1m-iibi?because ha wauidnit ba-
abla tn ggnizrcii himself ifis'he' warkedxih- ?ne-wink Mauitsby-
recalleddiiawssing the: empibye?e With Eanngrand?ialling Haunt-2r ?th 113 Waui? ?at put
mun-acne in a mafia-n- where they. ntiuizi ?at? be successful}, 'b?f adaman?y
.deniedfmaking aria? ?c?rmments-gaibcu?he femaleammayeei?s physicaiuajppearange imam
hi3. Inability to ?entmi himself amunid 1044 2653;; "Pilate mm m- Mir-3.35335
in) the namersatian.

Saba ang? 'Tamkins tastif-Lied that they were unnamf?rtable Writ-Wing aquari-
Mault?by amt 'Bennlaris- af?ne. Saba-did warlike:

iht M?ultsw sailed her by a pet name {Saba 13); Tamkins; mama administrative.

assistant can the mini item waa 31356 bamareeiiby the fact Manlisby gave all tha- female-

ni?kha?i?fas Make-ti?
wamen ?tn awake: arf??d his ego (Tilinki?s 1'8. 3-21 Saba 1345}. Saba-and Tumk?ins
Elsa ici-distange Mauli?by (Saint: 1142-; Tcmki-?i?z: Tami?ins :festifia?-
that 'Mauiifsby?fs inapamyriate behaving .?as it. ta Barman had a.
neg-aim effect 3cm ?ue thirdu?mdr e?vir??me?i ?T?mk-ins 

There are no witn?s?es Tic?: narrahbsate Ean??fi? Spiacific: acceun'ts Bf 'Mauiisby's
.a?xu?illy a?en?ive abuuif female Mauiisby'g
,aiieged sexua?wharged Gammant's aimut- atherf?mala wileagu'es the
pattern 91" behavior that exhii?ited in His di?act int?mctions with anti In his tax-i
with Baf?er. The; great?r weight 5f evid?nce is sufficient it: supp?rt?

.ai- Iaas?tih? genera-I ?nding iiaat M?auligby: made" sexual ihe-Wa?miac? abeui:

2,9

 famafe ?-Mpirayefes intha pras?ence :31? Banner and Either amp?bye?s that amt-d be

ableGIiver parc?lved as urtwe'lwme. sexua?y a?en'siva and hw?Ia.

maul-??5103: "sends I?x't: w] :11 1251;: 2313
an Hammer 25, 2am at, 12:58 am sent Rama: 3 Ext; ?Y?ur buy is.
jamming tonight" with a V?I?la? ailip. laminar read-me text ?Withmi?t VIEWIEQ the video and
rash-awed Wham- Emnerwaitched the? ?iefeij Iat?thaft day'sha was disgusted, It
igr'dIfIiizult. in discern? what is dapf?ted If! the? vida? because- the lpicmre and 1135-
ima?uge'sane unsteady.- Haws/ea it appeared Ia? Banner that teak me widen at
hi; Was lnthe and-Ia: mau?abyg i3 singing, "'ryuur man Ea Flame: t?night.?
??au can?: alas) heari'MaUItsby?s- mica saying ?I?m hat g?i?gifa Show 3th What I am doing? I
am Just .g?ing It: Ian: (Banner 6335:}; Banner Saki HIE mags gave bar an "inky:
feQII-hg." She Wan-wad- why Ma UIIsb'y? was: thinking about he? anal why he, ?lmiegi himself
In early m?rm?g mug: oh" Christ-mas telling he? Fie- waul??t shew h'ar what Pia wi?as.
daring {Emmet 
?amine-r discussed. We Vj?EQ-Wi?th Gray, ?Sfa?bn._ ??aming and-Ehai?h (Biann?'r 32?
m. Banner carted Saba ma?a? aftershe feceive? mum-{am Saba-testi?ed
that Eaan'?r was ?upseti mad and aha-Gym" {Sam-223.! Emma-Emma Tami?ns?e Widen
when. she retumadt?i?m Gh?stmaa break}; Banner t?i? Tammi; she couldn?t n?damtan?
?1113; her was wank: send "thrisIma-s ??mikt?s 225m
Hanna:- mid Ebaugh' 3139:.th vldatzb a?'d Ih?? shqwed Isa: tha-
vi?en in F?ebruarj- 2mg {(Ebaligih 4748?}. Ebadgh. tiestifled thaiI B?n?er said she ten

??amed? that vi?gm 

313

 

 

Maulisby canti?r?med: tai- text ?ver Ina {abristmas break-1. Em SLI-ndayi.
Decem?er- 2013 sf 12:38. pm 'taxfe?d Bonner: ?Hay Ms. Raina"; 33.6mm!?
replied; *H'ey?there'siru. Haws it gating?'Mau'lt'sb'yvtexted Swinger-again 2:1 6:07 pm: "Wham
{he-party at?? ?ii K?qw 3mg; ham 

Ma uliisby expramd Ehriatmas in ith?- acre-Maxi of his we break
maxim-fining With Banner- amt et?el?r animus, He?s: anti Banner j?k?gd
that this? was his mt year D'l?strict and hex-mum knaw wh at ta tics-inn. with a brig:
weak: (Managing Hem; spent Ehrfa'tma's in his heme-atom 5f" wnterhaven.
Flariga. :Maul-ISbiy? @1154; "that Vida? 9f hiimae?lat sink: in name marinara said
the alimen- {Ii-d Mt s?ow hitrrti?a?ci?ng; The; camera was ?pninmd at the ?ag? i4?!
stasififi?d that-m th? Vida! he was: trying ?ro' ileft Ma?a: mm? ?rst he Was
11ng and wing: we? {manltsiby Mammy a?ml?t-tad that ha- was arln'k'ing When: he
12:12:31; the. mgr-ea. and that have exercised ?batt?r judgment" as 
.B'Dnn?r iata r'ai night Hawaiian tamer than $113 timing; {if text. met mt Think
1113 text am! attd?o Ware :iiwapprepr?ata gnawing Taflatfa?ah?ip- bounda?as inm- ha and:
ig??p?nerhad E?afabiis?ed?; (Mammy 

.It is undisp?teci malt Sent; Banh?r a. text In. the a'a?y marrying hams if
a Vid?n- he tank at a-ni'ghielub In W?mrhaV?n-I The mam apeaks
fer IISQIE The {If fh? avide??e stamp-ms;? a ?nding. thai M?uf?sby?s
B?ece?mbar 25-, .2019 taxi: and widen-were Ina'ppqu?ate 1n- ?mi?g and a?nieni. It Is
u?djsp umdz?thatfaannaera? diaturbad by the i?xt ?end videm Banner- was wasnnahte in

we: belief thatfha Text anti vidieo were sexual?? 

31

 

s-ummant new ?Make yam 13ml?: January 2619

Banner 'tas??a'd thatshe- was-d'l'sguatad by a Eammen't made? id 3131? whanv
slursL game: in musk: {cm January 2:319 camp-mining af? .3 ram-"g "Rage. ?Mault-sby?a' ?ammant
was: ?Call: year- bay and him m-makeynur $311113: 32.33); Later {hat ?ay;
Bimner semi. ?ab? Were in? Mauitsby?? af?ne. mad Banner $310.5 What? he
said ?b?uti ?i?i {aura far her knee pain. ?ame: his eomment
{a Saba. said ss?i?ed Vary pr??d of his clam remark. sabb-
mz?rwb?raiad Banners: tastimanyi Saba said Mammy was. acting "kg. 3 i?ayeariold.
Eam- wal?kad? taut {if "his affiee (Saba 33-34}. Maulfsb'y adamantly denied that ?e made
the. samm?ents. that Homer and Saba attribute in him {Managing t! 3'53! 07)?

?nda smners account: madam it: be m?rf??fa?l?. Maul?tsw
rapeat?d the eminent in. Saba's presanee; The sexua??y ?ff?n?ive and.

degrading-ta Banner "arid- warmer: in general,

asks Bann?rm feel his gum - Jaauary 2019?

egalendar raferen?ed a Jamar? 1&21?21?39 meating With Haward Eat: in.
Magitab? ?irt-?33, B?nm?r testified mat Kafz was Mau?lisby's tailorfBanner Banner
wag in Twisting? n?iaa whan Maulisby aummbned her ta fhe r?estr?o'm Wham?: Kat-z Was
?tting-him Witha aust'nm jacket: Mauligbyhaid th'esbathra?m dam mango he squid m?dei
the jacket fer Barman Bonner? return?di to Tnmk?afg affine ??ly-ta?haye M'auitSby ammen
her agaim Mauitsby was trying; an a cusfom shirt. Mafu?sby- ?aked Ban??r'm $63! the
shirt iBQ?r-uer 95?93). asked has: haw it: {git-against ha? skin 913;;

3.23

Tamkins-afm ramemiae'red ihe day the tailor name thaw-fine fit Maulisby with
custom mamas. Tamkins heard Mau?lt?hy askEcnnEr-m-?ame feal his navy shim: (Tdmkihs
?Hawkins s?awi Benn'ar ?gm heard him insi's?t that ahe?t?ucl? his
shirt {T??mkms 62). ?g hp aim weaned fh?e? ?lm-gaming 3'th heard: Ma tilt-Shy
gallant it: Banner? to sbme=fgeel his, shirt; Saba gaw Banner reluctan?y much 
shirtsleexi? (Saba 26-4-3}

acknawladge?? thai; hi5 {fa?m same. 10 his wine several! il'mes. Mau?sby
Said he ?way? has aakezi Ban?ar What Sim-1319mm .sf his alut?hmg se?lactia? because
marital? ?had minim tart a?ew det'a?? imaginable?: i'aa??ad he might have
asked far B?nn??a G?i'?ia?l?f {the tennis-as? a Shirt, bathe was notsure if he was Wearing
the shirt- ?gr Whether me shirt Wag-an, his ti?'sik When he argked far hr apinian mau?sby'
3436p mainstay ?it? his? Ehlr?akhis ca?dg?twas-I?approp?at?.

'Fhe. great?r weight g? the. evidamse an p?parts the: ?nding that film event ?murraq as?
'BQ-?ner' deacri'beda. Maui?by was ?at f?ftt?t?tha?ng m?tri'af Easiness When he $ummaned
Bonner in ?a?ieiipaia in: and: acmm??f cm his austcirin ata?t?lngismmitsb?s l?naiste'nge ihat
his admh?strmive fiaei ma. fabric: of his new-amt: was- i?tjapprapr?rate and multi-

reas-unabjy be i?t?gprated as-a saxual'lnn'aendx?,

fian?wiisby i?xts ?samba 18, 2M

Sarina! testi?ed that aha had a ?We 1?
March. 201-9 saverat days. bafm? sminghr?ak, The mustarsa?on Wit-Erna?! 3? a?a?ad
event in me Tmn-gportatibn. D'eparimah't? ihat M'aults?yh?? 3333? Zia "mm-3&3-

Mau?ahy was irriiatfed. H?e-tpi?' Banner-he d?ldn?ft ?a've iima?'a'r ihig ?shit". Ha 

$3

why .peo?le muldn?tstay silent, Bonn-emhalle?ged She said maple nut-3d 
report misconduntf and advac?aie {far ihamaelxtesn Banner than tald: -s:he- was
going f0 begin him because she was si?k {sf-ma? stuff ha-
saiet. ?tmner mati?ad that. in tha. context a? this mam'eirszaitiicjvrir Mammy- said: ?Yam-.kmw
What: they: say if] ihe sweet. '?Snitch??c get Stitches". Rama? walked gut 6f the meeting
mm at Earls-m nah-1m ant {33mm 6446?}.

sent Bonner a text on Ma'mh- 26-19 at? ?1 1:43 am ?aring- spring brgak
and within a. ?aw trays :af?itheir mnversatio? in Mau?sby?s? af?ne, The text Wag ?Stitches:
get" sti?e-ism? with a?ijnk tafa tweet fram an article Wertd? w?h the byfine: 
sen-Ear {eader m? Saar}: A?icak get/lemma parry was. arrayed If! ?aameatim WW 3 ?igh-
pm?ie. gamma! assassinaffan"?? (gamer articla dammed the;-
=mtafia asfyl? murder afa Smith A?'lcan?a??bian w?hu amasad palm-eat carrupr??n in. a public:
pmjegt Hahn?!" was- dumbf?uhd?d; $he :rag?e? by taxi:- ?Lmaq?; ?nd-?Lula
tamer testified that. 5119 sent {hat Magi 15? response when she ?le: 11% knew haw to. renly
tame texts (aannarem?x

Banner Was:- i?fimi??aied by March 20:19 taxis. SHE-W35 afraid thatjf'
she reparted rte-might activat? What $1113 garc?Ma-d as Ia: t?r?att. Banner was.
?afra'l? she might get dammed m? ?red; maven WarS?. {physically hum She :mnta?t'ed; ?at?
muggy [433?; Saba testi?ed that Banner mid bar abbut the "witches"; gar s?ich?s"
Enumeration with sheared fall?w up text .129 satin. Ban?er
awed Saba What: am th??gm?n?e text me'anxand?wh?fhe?r Emmi iw?? ?Sup-passed ta?f?ar?

for ha!? {Saba 23624.): 3.311515? .3130 ?it-.3 text-with Ebaugh and; Lamp?

 

'Ia?agsume?ihat "sfeitchestget stitches? was a. and 1:11:31; tee-say- "snitches get-s?tchesf?


34

(Eb?augh 58-59; LemFie 501-52), L?empe ?testified-?that Eb?ner'ball'ed hfmsoonia?ar she got.
1112 -.fext. Lamps; resammen?ed Banner bomber The. Human Ra'sburbes Dbpairtment
?r dependmg fan =?her1avel ref camarn (Lampa 151)..

Mama-fab}; teb??ed- that he set-1:1; the. Marbh 1-8, 21:11 9' tax: in the can-text 51? a
m??rs?bon ih-at be had with Banner Earlier thaf Bam? day. Theiiebb?vgrsa?gn W35
35:31:93 Inca] situa?m untreiated tut-"he was rib? abb'pera?hg with
Huthuritffes. Mault??by said he 31.111 Ianner glmiulitana?ubly Said; "fsnitbhtes 9&1; stitbbe?" and
starred 'laUQthg iMauhsby 83L Ma?mitsby said he $8.111;- anner'the ?yb'e?rlinkitn?the amate-
bebause it part-aimed 1.13 the: kind bf snitcibbs- gal. a?tahes. situatibn mat mayjbkad- abbui
ea?EEr 82586..)

in big- haw anner the Manih 178, 2131 9'
tar-was baht it; retaliafe against Her Wh?n: Ewan" had but yet made a compi?aint against
him. 131d .th rabbit Harmer Ever .ergg?asting that she was: 9:11:19- tin-131mb him:
(be. farms?! him.) {Mab?sby Maul-1313;; he. had mat Samar ha?g
any n?mp?l?aiht ashram ?his. mam: aimi- maiden; tutti him. aha-111 Bantu-abs-
Ammarns' in a me?ting amprz? 232.. 291a: 123-139}.

'M?mitsby testifiedwafha't Bb?nar never In?iczat?d that she was affendmf by any 01"?
than? in'tabrbc?bns. re?ned 1b the .fb?f that Ean??f an g'atha?ri?ng it:
cel?brate- his.- bifthd Ely-on March 153212119 ?31938), aiso 1:91:11ng an
5.. 2619?text ?bril Ember attachingfa mute-bf Banner and-hers?n aim-family 


greater weight of ritb?e EVid?nce Hubpart?a iha ?nding that Maubsby the:

March Ebn?e?n bib :aftamiath Bf a ba?versation they had about reporting

35E

workplace miscm?duct at the District Undtar the ?imumstanaas, it was raasunable far
Banner Infa?rpmt Maultsb?y?-s text its- mean t?at ha w?muld refaliate arid passibl?y- even

?a use he: phys?i?cial harm if aha abaut hi3 misconduct.

1?3; wars "Bianca?g??amiaf assistan'c? .-.- Ap?g'ah 2619

B?nn?r dammed Savanna! sifuati??s Wham nifferyed it? prm?de fi?'amzial
ass?is?t?aht?? It) E'a?mmr?s mm Cline ef- ma- b?grs mesa during: a danmrs??on in which Brarmer
Was {ailing Maultaby {hat-?rm wa nted- pmmai?bn at; aha ?nals: aahieve ?financlaf stability
and pmMe-fw her am. Manna-by 'f?ld Hammer nut it? let ?erp?d? $51: 131; ?g way, Bonner
maimed that Ma'uitsby ?uid her ?never let yam mangiz with-am anything. if he needs
something, yau acme ta me and twin gaze-31911 athe ma?e?y" {Banner EBannerwa?
affehded by maulf?by's affah Harmer 1:016.? .maylisby fha'i' {lid mt Mat is dei??nci agn-
hrtm. She was-faught-mwa?: fg-What yew want {Samar 

E??riar aim abim? aim! that Mia-11mm; ?an-[mar m1: Apt?? :44. 2019 when
she: wasreff-w?rk crating for Ear sick;- sun; In his 129%, :l'sz'lau?sw ag?k'ed haw Beggar-ifs. gan-

wa's' ?eelf?g and if 511$ made-id When Banner ram-led that" she mi need

a??hi?g, Maulisby- texted ?Elf? {hat Mamba. admit heattatg in let ring know? ?We agreed:

{a that?" ?sl ?knaw yay?.. Banner testi?ed. mat she. thaughi {hat Mann-shy was mfer?ng had:

was his ?rearms a?a?r-m give her mug)? far her Son; Bgnrier testified that-She mama ?axier

ask- Maulisby-fi?r anything T??y were 

Mammy admits maths ?ame! to phi-amide ?'nandlal Ei??l??tance Emmet-?3: 
MauEtsby did inaf think his affers. ?f {Mahdi-?a! suppa?r wars- inappmp?at?; he th?iughi ha

was simply being gan'emus. M?thst-iecall?d ithE day Bunny was mm in m?ka a

3E

I

decision am whether in Sign her Sign 'gp- fora apart and whethia'r she -.aaufd 'a?ardvta 15:15;
the mammary equipma?i: testified: 10M :31? the .aitrwi'stic yankew'sity cf my
.1. said it: f?ha-ki-d?wants tr; :piay {at him play;- am?? if"
we mad tit) gea't? him som?baseball?ashms, fg?tball? meats, Whatevm 'thja case; might hag.
innit {at that 1539? the mam gran 21:52:31: ie't fh'e my? ?MaU1ishy- 33:34); said
'Batzmeraditl'mt mact?ta his Aqffer rather {Harm say Some'th'i?gr?ka she 
Mau'iisby did ?at. thin-k his. mnduct was ignar'aprapirtaie;

alt is mndiapu?d that Mauitsiayi d??r'ed to presume ?n?armi?il assistance- to Banner ta
hail: mirth ha! Bani There are time?s. Wh?ri a; Supe'Wisur?a afar {@r?nanaia?l?a?gi?tancamight
be aansid?red an act: :31" evens lf-?l mars-gm. Wafer-the.- airewnstances
af Egn?ar?s, haigf?t?n?dmnnems war Mau?sby?s behamr. if was; weasanable?r 
332% af?nded by his 1t;- ?xar?ise. gonimi

war 1th person-a} 

Rel agar-1i Marita manning afterAprill 9, 26159

Bonn-Bf ?ares cameras chker ?mm-9, 29.19

April 2319- atar?ted' as a very 132d ?ay fill" ??nni?en Hamish}? 
seminar "that his ?fsnnar admini?tra?'va assiatiani wag-aging in ?brin? 1'0ka fur him so he
would may am Banner appfy far a: supiar?fsa'r ??sition in 
nape: rtm'ent n- the m?f?i?g aways); 2019?, o?nnar a?ke?d ?.Mia?lfahy gimme" ?lm-Lemma
far the mansl?gm; Emilie: ?Eestlfiiegd f??t ?h Ef?i?il?d It}, .impansgand said: ?mat ain?t
gang ?She.? airft ?aming: aver" {Ba??ef 11:16}. Saba Merriam i511-

Hanna? she wasn?t gaging and she Mara him laugh {Saba 18-41931. Saba said-

=37

that when am my left Mault?sw's; af?ne. ?a?znar Was unaha?racieristically quiet- and wan-?m
{Babe 199; Saba and Bums? zltn'c'zk a walk wanting? maid raga'i'n her canipnsura (Baht:


Ltaterthat mqming, Biannerrsitappednhy Tammy n?iee' an her way ma mae?n-g. :i'rfr-
the Ttahsportation Madman: zuck?r? was in TamEins af?e'e. maker na?md that
gamer was: upset. ka?r- asikeda?nnejr What-Was: ma?a - (B?nbar 1314 Emma 29?31,
Zuck?r 13"134}. B-?nma?r? tam Zmieer that ghe- was mi guingttaget the she wanted
in the Tmn?pm'?atit?n ?epa?ment .Zu?ka'r ?ugg?sted ?that Bantam "enlist tl'?i? suppar?' 6f
Mauitsby (Boring:- 1:311); Tan-114mg t?l? .Z?akarfha? Mama-by wcsuld' mfl?at Brenner
[gave her as? his administrama assist-am; Tomk?insj yrad?'e?d ?'cpnnar uper?: :1.th
Zui?kei?, and Banner dict gamma? TUE. Tb?ikfns Emits-r thatthe?
??a?dgates ?p?aned". and she fauna Herself-felling Ext-1&3? sabtgui many ?Lhe prablems
E?h? had Wurking far 1-62). i?q?nar aha net-fer intanded 
tal?i 3111mm In. authn?iy a?bau? Mammy,- ?amar *mt??de?d to fake it 31192 guruld- get
anathiar?asi?ar?Bonner 1.3.2),

Samar tald Eu eke: mt; Let: her: i?e?avga??r pasi?an f?l-advan?eig
(B?nngr 1034:1504, Tem?kin?- 314-323). {Banner also mid fucker that, sent her
,Ina'ipprapriate text messages; Alt?nugjh Ban Her gird mat shawZucker any ??he texts, she
?eld Zugkarthat Mammby giant her the "Enjichea-gei siitghag" isx?t whifsh Heme: took asa-

'threaft{l71E3?nn?er 

 

?3 {tucker trjufd not recall Whetl?: er the ?531.12 afthe prnmati?n wai??lscussad- at the Agra 2519 meeting-era later
631% {gather 13).
33

 ir?caltad. that gamer talked gen?k?lly ab?ut ?M?u?-sby {sending her
teams? maker ramembered Hanna? talking abbult the whim;- 251m
?@11st semi ?aim-WW Eh-i?Stmas mmni?grizu?k?r 1W).

THE .thrx?e-partias the April :92 gamersa?gn (?Barman .Zuckejr and hati-
sligh?y different "recolIeCfiW?E Eff the $137135 Haw?en it is ?learihia? Bonner
?isclagad? miscanduct: Shy Maui-?shy. whlah- if $133,:qu 'I?acl .30 sexuai ?ara'ssment and:
hastivla W'Vli'?f?ime?t 'al?aiims. Th3 three Wit-1165393 were: a?lsd- ao?siste'nt i? mailing.
th at B?n?nier did at wa nt 119- {apart-her Wa- ?onnar gait} 34mm 11w 3
$1086" personal .rela?anship'w'i??h MaL?tsva. am! What Madam referr?d it? Bawd?an as 
b13131? {BWhner 105:1 65' Tnmkins ?33' Edgar 14); The Ham-efsation $de With 
tg?lling Banner-mt she WW it: 

She 'wa ?Id W?s-?19? {Banner 1QW..TQH1 kit-13 Zueker 143

Mia Husky texts Hannah "mas 5114??: April 12, 1230.19,

an. April 1.2, 291' ~fiylh'g canfEre-nc'e In san- Frantiscm
and Bah-nah me- amthzer ?aring" faYQV?r in Manta; Bonnjiar
fegpon?ed that She Was glad he maid iext beb?umshe needed him ts: anSW?r some
Warkvrelated Questi?n?; {Banner 523:, A: 9:241 am i?i?a?ted ?lming text
'EXGhanga;

Maulisby; Way- 

?Eanher; "Nagv?fi nifthark.mlbteddg-ym mgm-m? signedwamrs

f?r the ma?a #34? need in: ?g plasmid??

Mault-sb'y: you?da?i?"

3:9

 What??

"Miss maze?:



Mammy; 

The mm mm Aaug?hf MAUHSW her.
if" say EH5 missed Wm when she was Wing A: AA: Impurtani wa?fwrelated? .Enfarmatim-


MAAHAW ?fFe'vrAd faring; 2.919 MAu'Itsby
tagti?ad that he "sad term IA pil?ural- SAHSEA Warring the affine in. general. 
IA- FIAAfcul-ar. :Maunshy Aaid? ha lust? linking with. Banner- but that he Auiakry


TEA gf?afef might A AA-AViden??e? ADAMS Andra-A {hat Bann??r reas-anabw'
imArpz-AteA text as; an? m: ?is i?iapproijrfat?- a?empts in get her 

AcEnAwa-dge AA AA. had A Algae Aersari-Ai' AAIAt'iAns?h'l'p.

3A mgets withi?u?k??r? B?wde? 29-19
A321 23191 Zuck?erm?t WIAA BAwden-ir: his- that
hAA?rd reports that Mauitsby was {A?mida??ig AA E?pl?ga?; 

wanted Emits? t0 identify the. ampiqyee camp'lained Abm? Manits?y and tn-giv?e- Aim

 

3?3 T?ere? As same Assam the d'a't'ei the meeting. AccuArAA Zuck?r?thaughmhe occurred an April A
2MB {make} 14} Buwfren said the mating ?amed an April 12 or Ap?i 15, 2mg {:BAw?en 21:33) 3AA _graa'tar
Weight the evrdance A finding tha'tthe mAAtIrig Acmrre'd An Apr! I 12 2.6.19. as A: by Aanne?r
er testified thar the mating Accurrad an the AMA Aay- that 5AM her Aha" miss 
111}

AD

s'pa?i?c ??tail's, .Zucicer Was reluctant 1m identify; ihe campl?ina??t gr praw?ide detaila
because Banner di?? net want?ie be identi?ed Quaker? 1.5, Barman 31412}.

11353 undisputed ihiai Zaczkar iia'?: fh?e meeting.- it; BMde?ia l?cafe Banner:
luckier anccuraged Banner tn come {award :a-nci r?lay; her sancerns direstly ta. Hawaiian;
.Zn?kerinld Bunny she :??adad? taitust 12:3 owden andi'that Zuck?r help=- her u?ile?s?s
Brahma-19rd him (5mm; amni? hair eipa?g?nc?a with Maul'?sby g2mzakar' it {is also
undisputed that ?annel? did :nnt initia?ei the April 12, 201$? meeting!- gasket ajppmached?
?Banana? id request thaf $hejciln her in B'owdenEs- a?i?ee, and 89mm ralucta??y agreed
{Banner 07a?1?09); Ramadan testi??edz?aaf "he was surprised fa leam that Bg?ngierwas the
c?mpifal?ing 

Ema-m the Apfil 1&2, 2019 meeting by asking Ban?er? WW 1.5116 had mat.
brought? her ganger?zis Bar-"mar Explained. that 'Maulfsw hats! {area'fajd' a
Distrint Wide im?mss'ion that Eewde? and ware Eta-sea- friends; thnar said:
Matilis'by referred ta EWden as ?his; ?bag? {Banner Bh?naraXplalne?- that there was
aim-a Bistriet we perception wm?d support Mau??byFs ireaommend?ations
ta 1arm1nate- (Banner Emma: 161:1 B?wden that 53-316}. did want 16
talk-him all-the d?tails? at tier experiancas with (Hanna:- 1.1.2).

"IF-here 13 same 635mm; mar exactly whai Smiles? ?emmumcated ta Human if: tha-
April. .2019 mee?ng; Nu me tack Ema-3;. Bah-ngr-aaid she ism-id "Hawaii-in ihat Mg?tuitsby
sent her fnappmp?ate texts. she sh?Wed Hawdaen the "mlag me' fekts-rthat sentr-
Eatii'er ?1131 day (amine: ?111-112); Banner aim 136k! Bawd'er?i abdu-t the maversaticns-
she? hael: with Mammy where he said; 13nlt?hesget$?tdhes1 and the-imit- mat fu'll'ewed.

?Banner :?nmmuniaated 1a B?wd'en he: mhcam that if M?uli?by Maniac! that Bonner

4:1-

repbrted him it; sameone in eleeihelriizy-E Maul-'tsby- freight- ?activate? the threat {Ban-rm: 113?
315} Emmet: alsozmi? Brave-(den thatiridaulelbyemade the} ail-?lament ab'aut gifting "her My?
"?32ng pain (Banner 1214);.

Ban-Her fegtified that teller; ?ngeiene Apr?! 12' meeting that she felt like
Mauitsby was making her steal time by asking? her tel: Mack but: ffmes-e?an his 'be?llfendar for
?atmates. events.? vspeei?qally. alked Banner ?in ??landar fa Ice ?ashram felt:
times. Wham he ms 'laaving welt-Fe legally! (sea Would elici- not taunt as ?his gamma} lime
(Brink-1?s; *1 eta-1:1} Mail fill: 13'3an elf Enliallatlon
of ii .sali?d af?ne delelr-iil regime th?-windiiw?etl ?ail? (Bun?er 

Iglwder?e 'testifiedf'tha?t in the Apr?ii 21319- ?ma'etinge Samar initial film that. Mammy
walked fear-pramfin? fattfe-wp?l?vi-Ebf p-iisitt?an. She mar?ianld Magusbyis-il?ile
lime. Heisman iecau'ed Eli-felt?. Banner $32.36. s?m?thinij- abauf heif- bei?ng. abi? it: ?apand an
calendar, but Belwden laid Bannei didmat flit-him that Ma. u?lt?by' used?a 
ward iar that ha" asked? tel Galendar meetings #424751;

"Emmett: aakn?wladga? that Bon?er {twee-saw iaxts in tha-? April 1?2,
2M9 meeting, However, Q't? the {impression- that =Buri1?3r did 
texts were Manama; She will: teqnsidered them till he ?fi'mmature"? an?! "stup?idi', Emma-
recaiied that ?atmateshilwed him the ?miss me." text that lent ?51, that marlin-g
{hwdiln salsa}, Bow-dens net ask Brianne? in shell? him othei? text's: lie a?su?lad- the
April 2 text alchange was repe?s?e'nfattvg texts. ?awed was remain
fhaf'BQl??af ?fe} hilt? say-Vanyt?f?g in the-April 12. 211.19meetin'gabilutfaeling 

?t intimidated. He testified thatiaumar Was noiyea?ifrai?d' Site inidz?Bmde?n she

41

mm?hanwe the ?situatian: with Banner?ald she did: ?atwantia file a comp?lain?
{Hamlen 412-471).

Zuckse?r' ?esti?ed that her m-empw if im- twigs ?'istjgussad in :i?fe April 1-2; 261.9
meeting; werefuzzy" (EUGKEF 1&1. gasker..recalleci t?atBonnermt?e towdan EhatMauItghy
Emmet 'tbl?-and?n about-Mammy drd?ring a guild-6351?; Zuckar
maid =nat mmeniber if ?ame? talked a?aut .?ie taxis er sham feaiing har?Ssed 
in?mldata? Quaker ?uakar recalled Bawdan ?aking. Banner what aha; war-stad-
hi'm: tits.- and Emma: wagging; ?male? it stajpi" {Zil?ktar lucky-was dis-appdinte'd
Bonner shared; "bits: 91? 1112111393? with Buwden in ma April 12, 363:9. mat-?ag, 1351*
instanca, Eon-near did. nut i911 Bowda? ala'cmt the wicked (maker 22); A?ar'tha
th?eeti'ngzuckeraskad ?brin?r Why she- diid'r?t?i ieil Qawden everything; Bonner repzlia? Wt:
she ?aw wa?t t?eQ?V? any hat-Whaie-fhgan? {Eunkar 

Thai sweater might at? that .suppajrta the: that the infhrimimin that
Earmar- dracloaed 1163::de in th?a?p?i =1 a feasonahle-
admhiWatar in pasi??n t? abncl?udath?t Eahnarwas alive-aging that the EEG:
had angug?d i? canduczt, Whi?ah? tftma, waufd amistituta aamat harassment and h?S?lE
wad: en?r?amarit The Qf'?afer weight Hf "the evieii?rree- also. ihe ??df?g that
Re?ner described cam-Jud:- that shauld have biased a raa?analala admini?t-tst?rm 
that Banner mm eoncerned- that she would Suf?xes: retalia?an. if Mauitsby {hat ?he
miseandut?.

B?n?n-en anti 'Zunker had ?iff'erem ramlfecti?ns ?sh aw the Apr]! 1-21-2613
me??ng senda?dn ierms? 13f niexf's?tem, that hswauird

fall-aw up With Bdnn??r within-Mi waeks {Banner 115% Banner ihej m?eti?g wfl?n iha'

Erhpressian thatBowden? Whuid mam haruconcams tart-he Human Resources ?epar'tment
{Satirist She eif?u ?ihat Bhwdeh was going to tail! Margit-$133119 r?plaee
him ahIf?i affine dam, Bah ne'r did 110% exp?c'f Ema-en .fh. 1e?! 'Mamls?hy ahaut iha mn'chms
isha raESed In the: April 1.2, 2319 meeting. Samar? did? hat aufha?ze-B?wdrantn shareihe
specifies her mmyaihts with 1111 1 

de testified 'fhai: ?t?atre?ms- a 1162f: hf haGkI-and?fart? wlth: Banner the-Ami! 172;
.2019 maeti?fg as-tawhmhaf ?bw?en "some: ia?ll; ta her name;
2mm .?Eis?efeg?i?a? that Bah-her said aha-Was mamas and afraid hf what wbui?d hagpen
if Bah-mien abn?t hat? specific allegationa (Zuchhr 2%251, Emma: said she,
was a single parent wha juai haught a Mum and she Was; Cancarned abdut [?ing her
ihb ?(?anker Bhwcien was acer'tairr that Harmer saitimataiy agreed 'that
an at E'Q?nl'fef'S Siafed game-ms wl?r- Mauitghy {Same-n: 41 

?ha?gteatat Weigh-E hf: the evl??enie? suhph?s :a ?nding: fhat Bh?her did not ham err
expect ta tel! {hat sshe ??mplaihad Labauf him ar?f'or ngz?ien fa Share
the gpaai?ez-datail?s (if her ?llega?tions. reasonable .?dm?iniStrato?r In Bowdan?isspcis'i?t?ihn
.shouli'd haw-app-Paciatad me. sensitivity hf'tha?SitU?tiona?n?he nature 61? Banners
it. was inappropriata far 'B'ciwci?en h: 13"" 31;:qu Eu?nn?r?h- Specific
allegations camhlaihi '?iithhut hm cansant {if hhf?ra- any inv?stigzatibn- was

.umd?rfakeh!

4; Mault?by u'ffers his hards??p?l 231:.522319
Banner tastified ?that ha, .Acimihist?ra?ve Ageisiant?s ?ay, tried to give

Banner his hradit 63rd an she herself tanned ?cketsi her wgu'l'd. mat take

44

the ?md?if card, affer Mada her u?mamfa?r'table (Banner 1119-51 20231. Mammy
had E?ffaltitent .r?etzallea?on 0f Ad??nistr'atiye Assistants- Day. Mzauitsby ?EEStifie?e? ?that he
bought Banner 6 may With :5 @1533 bi?li? if! "it aid-autism itald B?nne?r ft: {15.9 Tth? ?ash

in my tickets far ah warming ?ancert {Mamt'aigsy 52:65)

laymen tails 'Nlaultaby aisau-?e Banu?r?s mmplainis aA-gar? 

121's u??disputad that anden caliad' M3 Elisha-time his affige Aprii. 526?. 21919." and
that he mid ale-gut Ea?nef?s a?agxa??en?sv :Beiwde?n ?eg?tl??d that ha inl?? {5255:111st
[simmer :mmpiained about his 'i?xts, E?wden iu?l? Mault?by. mat Banner-"shiawed him
the April 231.53 ?111155- me?? text. taxGhangey; ?IaWden talc! that ha was
"'ciiaappo'i?tedg MadlESbyi-s. Behavibr 311:!? that the: text messaging. needed {a cease-
i?i?ife?diateily {Hawaian 474.593; anden :91ch ?Mault?gby that fnmgard His rala?anjship
wlt? Banner needed tn ?e ?rmly pmfa'ssianal and that it was up ta Manna-.133: ta sai-
amamla?as?te brim galaxies With 211-15:- Rawalenr ?at-ad that Misgultaby
not agent: undafrs?tand Why me. textihg-was sau't cf b-uu-n-ds ("Esme-m 

in; the Aprii'??. mfg-meeting ~Bn?z?len alga-#616? Magma-4y that Emmer- cla'imad that
i?tarfaged with her a?emptg it gal: ?t?e ram?j pgsiti?n. Mauitaby
?ani?e? the ali'egatiam talc! B'El?d?l?i? that ?ne {cute Suip?em'em?r? ?nes;
befare hams hired Max:155? that Bonner mid him
Maultg?y .braggeu abmi his ?'tgandly relationship wifh :Bawde'n and ?amed Bawden was.
?his; bay? (Bower: Misti), and aaid thatfh? mum gamer 1139mm.

term ?hay?! :beca us? be {mad if racially o?ansivie {Bowen 50.)

Meutteby testi?ed fh'a-f he Was ""abeelu'tely e'hecked? when he was called Shire
Bewden'e affine-en April 2-6. 2619 {?Me-uiteby 138459)? Bewdeh talked in Meulteby ebgeut
the 1555519,. In perimeter the 5pm 1-2, 25-19 ?miee me? 1e22, ?ew-hem! tried it: eXplain the
'51? the text exchange ?to Bewdee. in e?e. end, "Mau?eby agreed. step elf-2w
:cemmuniee?ene With Beer?ier :(Mreulteby e145). testi?ed {hat Sew-en. die net
teal. ?lm. that hem-er eraimae that he eeked. her he eiae'e- ?etitieus .evehfs en. hie calendar
(Mauliehw'm;

that he rheughtmat he successfuily resume Benher?e 
5y- inferme?y meeting with Me [15555 en April 265. 21019; Edema een?rmed that Meeitsw
steeped textine Banner after the meeting. 5er5 Memehy?e ef?ee deer wee replaced
(Bowen Zu?eker 35). .Maeulteby. else week; he April 25 251.9- meeting we the
em! :5 the issues {Maui-they 45-55;.

Beg-?ner Wee she learned-thief semen-mu :16th Jte Human 
efterthe April hut inetea? went in: his Widen-ct? Meelieby ta grate him-tithe ?heeae
up? an .her-allegatiens (Helene? sBenher-eelled- Lempe its: geth'ee 5651512. 3519.
hard Lemee that-she was emeernsed that human 15h! Maui'teby abet-1i her allegatiene
hefe'leehy?ev?eetiget?ienwes Undertaker?! Lemhe teld-Be?nerthat heeharedhereeheem

that; her ??mpfamtsito Max:555}; {.Lempe? 5455;}.

events "deleted on ?eulteby?s eaie?dare 5pm 29, 2619
Banner testi?ed mete: her k?emedg'e. naming happened after-the Ami! 1-2., 2515-
meefing w?h' ewes-n end Zueker. an April 22, 25619 Harmer .dieeovered that events en

Mamie-Wei eater-rear describea ae ?echoei-eis?s" had been sighted, even the echoel visits

he

Mau?itsby- {had- attan?ed {Banner Banner amid she and wary:
the nnly ?nes wh?- had to 

testified ih'af?he "Eii?imgt raca?? dieletinga gmup ?FB-?wlem? Sari his Galentiar
af'te?r maApri-i 264, 2619 mee?ng wim Human {Ma?uit'shy 53') Msault?by gait}. he. di? rant?
Emma: man?: Harmer raiS?d ?g?aema abauffthe way he; ?atan?ara? Wen-t5- uh?? 'fhe date he.
wag ??gew'i?wed by SW1 auknmmedged-thaif Eta-a h-d: Emmet-were
the mix; [maple who. had amass ta his ?alendar.

asked the 1T Rana m1 indetermina Whether events were deleted
Maults?by?s: ?alerndar timing the" ?rs-1.6 perl?ad-Apr? 25 thraug-h Apr? 33! '29-'15; 2:1de
sci. wha deleted mam. me. 'le Departmenf fatal ether may mule! m: ashram. tha-
ini?arm-atiqn requested, The IT Dem-Emu; iinfmmazd ihat they tried to ret?ave the:
fram Archive Manager and. Mi?rasaftf Exchange ?tenant Tha IT aepamem
Hiram ggnaultad. supportfservieas-W?a wu?rm?d ithaiftaf'endar? de?le?onswere ?at
am?iveti.

acknqu'JEdg?s the pass?ibi?ty fhat Mauifeby-m sameane- acting an 3113- behalf
defame! gammy-item's Etc; gum up eVi'deiaceih'aEhis galiaridar {minded appaintmerits for
fal?? meats; Hameven, with-mg having any Enable 'farens'ic, Widen-ca ta sappart this

them}; ma e'?de?c?e is f??u?ici?m ta allaw SWI to make $3611 afaetual ?nding af'?j?is time.

7.. Burmarta?a Zuck?e?hat a'am?en: did mt-fa?aw up:? May 7.5 we:
Lama testified. that he fadeived a ?all? fribm Euake?r an Ap?t ih Whit-in
maker tars], him: a?nui ?amers Zuak?r turd Lamp? sh? waui? an 3:134an

withi? her pDWe'r? 1011919 Bon?e'ij, They bath acknaWIedged-?that there were {imitations an



What ?3.12 as; a 75mm: ?Bqard m?emhar, Zucke'r mild Lamps that she :(Zuckam
halieved and?en wan-rd Ultimately-dc: the-right thing (Lamp-e 

an May 20.19,, Eugker mapped my B?n?er?s affine-m ask har haw she-was..- ?ning
gB-annar 1'28), Ban?aft?l? 2mm that sh?dici m1: think an?en hadsdg?e-anything- aim
irs?sUIt 9f ftha April: '12; 23349- meetan-(Bdnner +281); ?Zucikar mid Howie-11 we Mum aim-Lire
that Bowde? up: ?lthnugh {haze It; game: un??r?a?ihtyin the ?meli?ne,
F: was pmbabl'y? during that ..m-eating that Eran-Her sh?W?d 'Zuakar the Ghrlatm?as
'iexf- amt sitsniticiaeS get with hyperunmmha H?eWs a mule an.

this H'S'sassin'ei??r?h {?ne .W'ih?i?istleblawwi? Siam?! ?fiiqai

18. Banmrmeats Mm Eowden anazunka'r May-:3, 209:9

Zu?k??r met? With BQWden rgn- may-a, .Ei?l'liai?t?t 11E: him that the S'it?ati?? With
Mattltaby arid ?amer- was? we: rags-"man they imaght (Eu-(mar 3E5, E?w?ien 53,53}! zucker
:E?aked? Burma: in gain-the mast-ing- so ashe mum ?ll Bawdan ?i?i?a??yg It was
6L: ?59 1th mae?n?g that} Ban new .Iearhedthat' Bowden- already met? wl??h' Ma ul?ts by mum-r1!
25:6; ?319? anti thai BoWde r1- tam Ephner?s .spagi?c allegations: {Banner 139.-
1313. Banner "tald Bawdm that she was more about?the ih??at ?aw {hat
Maiui'bey knew abdut mn?a?inis (Banner 136-1391}. B?n?er teati?ed- fh?al 511$ gird mt"
share any-newahfarm?an tha- May-25;! 2m mating. Banner-said she hadaimiadvtqid
'Bewd?en abm?i the thyeai?ning ?fsnifche?sg?t stitches?? iteki-a Hawaen aSked her if ?ns-had
Witt-1233.333- ancE widening. Benny t??ti??d that}? She taint Hawaiian sh? did mt want it":

pmmde any, Marie detail. ng?ge?fnad: gbg?i BoWdEh? sf?e'ndly 

 

?Thaw-$550111: mime-parity In the-data Bawd'en meeting'wit'h .zucket and an?ian aae?zm'gid
an a May 2:319 famien =52} hm: ?ame; was: c?rtajn: that thi-E mg??ng accurra? an May 18,. 29159.

:38

wifh Maulfsiay if there; was. going {a be an. "Enigma! investig aticn (Banner 132-4333. Banner
?testi?e?d {baa Bquen said the? nest-stag was 'er Emmet it: go ta Human Resourcea

'andga?has ?egallec?w a? me May a, 2019 meeting. Biawden said he
was hy't?e, ?new? infama?b? 'Ba?-?er {Emailed Em may $2 ?2319? ?Bawd'?n 
3:3de militia it the May 8.. .266]? {ha ha mew 'ahnu-t-
the "snitches get. mite-he's? "text at that Brim-11a? was =fE?W?an
5:44}, B?awde? Asaid- ?e struggled with ?anner's- ?Emailing; Human-21:51:16? 
how a text that Mauitsby sent in Mat-ah caul?' he ??nsl?er?ed- r?ia?atfanff Mam?x?by {1&1 mat
{if 'E?nner's G?m?lalnt u?n?sl- Ami} 26:1 2019.- an Eli-53) BEWden teS??ed ?cha?t he
:a?lso strugg?led" With the fact. 1113? Banner was just ?aw telli'?g him Eben-it wants that
grim thair ?rst me?etihg Apr? 192. 261-9 {EBowden .54;

Human testi?ed that if was; na?c until-?rs May 3. gamma-seizing 1113+. B?n?erietd him
widen; itwasma first 
newnent th at he Would nat?i?etl a: nartain attracfi?e-fema?le wn?k in hike; diegarimetithmause
Mutant: be a'xtj?ct?d 2m himsetf mama. her. Emma 56-58}. BOWde'n alm-
iea??e? that: May 81 201-9 Was tha ?rst time he leamedj that Banner- was upset war a
Mault?by made. about net wan??g Bz?riherfs and? ?tr; 1:10: Withafut anything at?
{:h?stmas 1330.3 use aha did Imam t?eg'ti?fied Ere :cauld?n?t un?erstan?d why
Emma Waui'd take ?ange at what mund?d- in Film is; be a?er by Maulisby
'(an?erzi Sta-31).

the May am meeting was var-y .fmgira??g 

felt Samar-was ?aming him harstary? in "bi-ts a Nd ?aws: B-owden tasii?ed that she wauld

49

have :raanted differently had. Banner 'F'E'V?ated' t??ls infarmatien. in their" first mae?ti?g?
(Bhwdan 

It is undisputed cm- May- Ema-33mm: tutti Banner t?a?t she. neededita register
her ?omplafnt wiih the Human Rasaumas ??pa?mahi ?owdgn ?foere?l- ta" acnamgany
miner m. a meeting in Harayda's. wither It also .uarxzziisputed mm Emmet expressed 'I?ar-
adriaer?s abaut gairrgm?uman Rasoumes Eep'arfment bemuse that:depa?meni?rapmts
"to B?Wd?n assur?d Bann??rfhat Har'ayd-a wagid ?at {Bummer a'ny'i'mastiga?an;
he wag-Hid just-waste: It. Inwae?n Would he Entitled
ta u?la? mpfes?niatlan at this type a? meeting. Hawaiian macawe 3:535:13 was 
con?den?al Jempiayaa, she: did. rm]; haw the right um?m f?presar?a'ti?n, Buwci?n taint
Banner she waawemme ta Erma-a friend in" mating in HR {Bowden "59460).

Bawden festi?ed that by the end May 2-019 ma??hfg: he ganged thai fie
had established with. Emma? (Buwden 53.560). Bonner-dimgr?ei 8m
t3 hav?. se?bus reserva?iionis- .a?aut how anderi- had handled he: w?cams
haw may multi- bre-?addres-sed in the future.

?xis undispu?ad mm: we?; time- rtafifhe Maya, meeting. if net befare, anaen
had actual kmwtadga that??nna?r was all?aging that'Maui?by assent harjnappm?ria'te Ems,
maths sent her ihe video. himself earls/mi-Ehristmas withing? thafh? sent. her?th'ei'?xf
aiming 'f?snitehes get stitGheai and i?ataahner h'aa fears; that maid retailatie.
against her. Under? the ?mums?tanc?s; a .reascinable administrator 's'huglc'i haxfe- realized
that "Hammers :aliegatians. raisied garliaus ?amerns 0f: Sena} harass-imam, ??stile WDFK

envimnment and retaliatim.



.9f Ean?ervm?ats ma:- Harayaa in Human ?'asaura?ea may EDM-

B?awcian aa?ad Harayda mamas? 20-19 fa fall mm that ?he was ?ning to bring-
Bah?eft?a Hai?ayaa?a- g?ah-sa te?'?im ahaataanaamaahe had-ahaut 
aandmtu human an! ant share-any details-with Harayda. Ii is aadis paf'ea mat th'fa was
the; first time that Harayda arr anyane raise fa: Hama?n Rasouraes knew that ?ame!" had
mares-had aanaemaabaut:Mauitabyfa aanduat tharayaa 3940)..

'lanrsar arranged mama ha? friend; Kaisha?ray telephaniaally Wand.

the. meeting with Harasr?da. Hawaan- acaompaniea Banner- ta me human T??eur??s

tarifanenae rum ta maat with ,Hariayda, hawden mania brief ihan je?'ihe

mam. Thase atta-Taadiag aha meetinghad different ?impreasian?a- af?w'?atl 
Eama??tas??ed that she gaze Harayda the same summary-aha g?a?xla Bawdam

Samar men-fian'hd ?sex-nail harassment", "has-tire Waf?e anaimnmema ball-3g ?hale! hack

{ram and "it'lzraatanlag?" taxi: as (Banner- 1?36433}, Ea?aar acid

Ha mafia ihat aha aha ahaamfartahie with ma matter hang {matiiaatad mama"?

be?asa (if structure-and-tha-alase. harshest-Ia!? rala?anahm batman Mahlta?by

and?awcfem Banaar taa??ad ahati Harayda said. hat homema- and that ha
wa?ald magma-mead an batsiae i?haatiga?on, mi; that Human wautd unimaialy?dacide
wha?ier'tha i??ves?ga?an Waulti ha haad'tad: Ihta?rn?falty or Emma-11y. .Harayda? .di'dz?at give-

Eamer-aopiaao?f any? policies but: ha ha tell her ihat he; did ant think af

 

1?3 Gav has SpathEar-?al?m am has a ?agraa in HE Bevelqm?ant .5le has mark-alas an H?'manaaer
and (Gray :51; 
5-1

sexual ha?r??smerit and?hastile wart: envim'nmeri? fail H'nd-ertha Equity palms! 
mm. 

Banner staid Hatayda asked her :Ifshe. hadi damment's, She told him she had a
written dia?la?ue; of Events ?smumentg aha mlfected far her persQn-ai man-ar-w .Hairayd?a
did. nut ask Hanna far fhe dnwments but he did fall her that Ea?ntar'wbul?. ?ventuai-ly
have d?cwments an .i?veg?gafcn 'Eannier left the 
the? next step Waul?d' be a gph?na gall fram an nuist?ga "141442;.

Gray? rectil'laction n? 1119 May 1D, 2319' me?tin'g. was similar ta E-un?arfs.
in Gray; amaner?ml? Hamyda ?ag ?lming; that made 
abaut'othar-am pinyaeg wt?hgiear .siaxual nv??mes?. thatmade 
n?t af?r ?ppu?un?i?s far Emma? 16 za??anca: that M'aulis?by 156 Homer?
fraqu?rtt and f??'apprap?a?ta taxis Eh?luding 3' men 91? himself" early Christmas 
an?- that Maul-tab? saint Banner a threatening text ?switches get; S?f?hi?s? Wifh a hm?l'ink
after 3933113: told Mammy that she laugh: ??zi raped him; 

?3an Emilee! Hara-ydra .sulgg?esti?g that Banner g6 ate the mike if She fen:
Harayda .3139 'S'?ild?ah? {hat Bartn'er?s mi?pfaint was;
Jase: abaut sigma! ?l?scrimmation and? mate sexual iharasiismieint and i?vs?le smirking
-e?Vimnmenf; Harayda said ha wank! need tn-eanault wifh E?wden, but that Wait-sally the
Distri-r? assem-bieid an i?fernal team" it: ?anda? an imr?stigaiian- (?Gray Gray
testifi?d i?ai 3? this mini; she Tate-?amed hersalf Mfume donziIersatipn 'by amassing h?r
mncams abut-start. intern?al?.liw.?stigatio? at Emma's; Harayda- refs-pended that

an "em-ma! ?aves-tigatian might be a? mare apprapriate '?pfi?fl given Mauitsby?s :pas'iti'orz:

5'2

(Grayma?? H-araydasaici 115-61513 mat- need fm'm gunner-at this paint;
hesaid he wanna-fallow up: w?i-?ch Ben mar after sheakin?g wifh B'ciwden Ef?gy 

Haray?a testified ?that B-bnnersegme? hesita??t'ie share ?etall? With him in the May
111; 201% meeting. Banner third Harayda :th'ajt ?rst-she Wanted ?tie: .und'arsfa?a haw 't?a
iriyes?gsa?ya ?prngess- wax-dd warbs?arayda recalled ?agging several bpti'??s in?ilud?i??-
an investigation mn?uafed by Human a3: ih?e ?depa?mem head", an ?mves?tigatian
.congiugted by an: investigative nr ?Magihly ?ev??n an external Ibize?igatm
{?bre-1W3 ame??l; Haraydta ?that gt the. end bf gilt: May 1b. 20?! 9- meeting he was.
Barinet?? nom?la-int' ghauld be mv?s??gated bade-r ?biiby 2.3721th-
Equity 9:211:33?) :thh Bullying ma Harassmerit pc?iby. Haray?d?a testified-that
he Bannerth-at the May 2519 m'e??ng Was 'Intmduetary but eventua'lly?i?she wauid
weed ta prayide dabbi?ents. Banner ?ta-I'd lat-mayday she. had it all in ?tri?ing; and. {hatishe
wautd give him d??umetits after she-T knew haw the; District was gains; ta hahdi?a the
Investigatfm (Harajydza 

Harayda tpakhandwri?g? miss, af?ne-May meet-i r19; 1  rthis mfg-3 Harayda listed
the ?lming aspects 0f Eq??er?s camlai?t?: ?hastife' Work: Enyim'hma?t. ?eld'nbaok?am
Aadvanabmant; verbal :sexual hwass?man?i: in?irec?ylwrectly.. ihreafa?m- ?ahayjbr,
s?itbhes get stitches whistteshlawer, reporting t?i?g?s not ?ght. embea I'ncid'am at mark?
{Haray?a Banner gave;- Harayda same amen far $113 ?bananas get stitches" Mt
She mm them me 5132;: fallaw'ea mny?rba?an in which she: told; Mau?sby that pacpie
fpjee ta: raiaa?tf?ings 1113f ar? wrang; {Haifayda 45) H??ar?ayda r?z?bllad Babbler?:
telling him- that the "witches: get stitches" text had been sent several baf?e and

ihat naming. had ?appe?na?cf 11;: her sinba (Harayda 533::

53

Hamyda phaned Egan/den a?er't?a May 11121319 ?meeting With Eewd?en
wa nted?ta 1mm If Banner hat! Faduceci [Tar c?ampla'int wd?rig. Ham-ma mid .andaja.
that Bonner said shra- mum give him Sumethirig an Mayi13y2?119Whem he. told?hgr haw.
{Eta invas??at?ian was going-i6: be handled (Harayda 54}.

The gt?eaiar weight jaf the eyiagnaa sapggsarts a fin?irxg H131 a reasonable
admhaisi?rator in 'Hara'yda's position wank! ersca?gmza that if-th?a-ma?ers ra'pmte?'ibyi Bonner
in the May 19:, 26139meati?g.weretme, they adult; suppm a timing that Miauitsby sawing?):
harassed Banner. ma; hescrea'ted? a ?tmtii?gwo?g envl'mnma'nta?c?i ?that and

retaliated. against Bum-er,

Harayda tells 3611119? Investilatipn- pmnee?dsun?ef 27.232 -
May '15} 2019'-

:ioW?i?n maid-e the: decisl?q? {hat the ?istrict wm?a-?Qanduat i?he inw?tiga?on Bridal"
"P?iliny 1772 after mna'ulting with Harayela {Sweden 1.46}. Bowen-am deakfad that. he
maid same gin ma as the a? mantra-:1 affine"
admf?is?tra?am Brawler! assumed he Was fh? m?S-t ap?rqpri?ata repr?s??ta?v? 
'ihaug'h an EXecutlve dimmer camel have served in ihaf pn'si'?an {anw?a? 154455}.

On May 1% 2919. Hafayda Wain-Bid Banner 159 teli matrict was going is:
hand-1?9 her camp'la?int und'?r P611631 .232..- H?aray?a ink} .3'pn'n?er ?that she maid nem?l ta
meat win a t?f??e-member Inv?stigaiive cummf?a? {hat Would be f?rme? the
Enlacrimin?a?m camp'faii?i: Pmtcad um 'Hairayda Elie man-them ?fth ainim?tig'ati?n
team: Bawden? wauldi same- as the mantra] affine and: mad investigates;

Last-1am Era-gt F?n?ipal B?aker Middle ?chual wou'ldtbe the: achoulwbased

54

admin-i?etreter. Gem] Lieh en, Dimmer hf Purchaeln'g meld be: the when! district
aemtnietreter (Hareyde 58-660. thh'er 146447}, Hareyda explained Banner that.
Lichen and-Frau were selected ?heeahee may were 1161: iHJMautebye chain-:31? eammaine.
Harayde ieetified that he theeg?ht Earn-TE? was ?ne with the eempee?i?en e?he nemmittee-
(Heireyde ?arayde-eehed Banner ?t she nae In writing he mule pass cal-1m
the cemm?iee'. fez Herayd a Stinger eaie-ehe mule-get him. something but the
119% eehwhen 

heme; testi?ed thetshe. die. mt- preth?iee it- give anything .In-wrlti'eg te- Haraycte'in
their May 13.36159 phene hail. She- re?a?ed reminding-Herayea that he said he Wee-?Id

hiring: an external. Ih?egtighter. Beh?ar arso? talc} ?Har'aiy?fa than she ere net

underetan? why the: invas?tiga?'on was gpraeeadiirag tinder regency Q-JQ?Z-when her-eemplaint

was. sexual. meager-hem and easing wee-leg eneiremnent. net. $5.5,me discriminant:
(Sewer 144-}.

gamete pf ihe "May 2919 phane ea" is credible. Banner sent

?Heray?e-ah-emai! afte?r?ihe-phene Baf?n whieh she- mate; am enmfelfebile=with an

in?ame!- alevest'iga?eh ef the repertl?g structure The human TESOUFEBS: rewrite-
directiy ii; the eceueedi and. i. hams wee-stated the-persona} reletmhehlp the has
etatfed it; me he?iweeh? he and Mr, heedem? Bonner- stated she Understoee the lead-
Wheelie he eellihg her: but she had rha'de her- f'e?rmei an May 
233-9.. hen-her said ehe' die net H'n-dersfand? Why-she needed return- ?a eecpn? time ta-
reiell her state been-e? eleov eempleihed eheu? The District?s ?eley' 'Ih f?ePeneing ?fe h?i?
caneerne. Banner reminded Bareyda that this was an ongoing matter that she ?rst

'reper'ied te fhe District en Ap?t 9.2013;

'35

 

Harayda replied fig-felting her-thatshe was requireri ?9 make. an
af?rgial r?epurt with. git-area; tim?a arid; speci?c ?'c'?nc'ems; Ha-f?yda said. he .dfciinot consider
?113 May 1 EL. 213419 mating-as the "?fgrma?] Cam?f?l?i?? Addressing Ramada mncarn-?s ab?ut
the: int?m?al. invasztigatian. Harayda Hated;? Elan game yam bath scehari?s m: we
@3319?ingzeiha:Jav??tiga?tim i gi?rfi- agrge' Jean tha renal-1mg iprme' as far the chain 
'??Wajver IS atated On Friday and agai? have any 
ar any gather ?aring; th'a that yam cauld cani??t met

Emma: 1651mm ?that ?ne @xperfenced a falte?blowtj- panic: attaak 9:1 May "15, 2&?19.
because afihe-sireas aha Was linden. Ba?nner?iestified Eaten?e felt Hm worst-
fears were being .raaliZE-d. $149 feared She. was wing-ta 1:359. her jab and her hauaje. And
as 50); Banner
?ali'ad. 7m sick-9h May 16. 29-1-9;

The a ?ndmg that that an? 33?- $3919 and
again. 32n- May? 2949*. Bgnner infari?ad Har?ayda that aha di? neat think an intern'a?i'
"investig?atian .m?f h-ercomplajnts mam $291. mistake.- fair; apprw?ate at? ?rnel?mnumamus
rgason$,. She dig! 7th thimk'it Was-65135131182 1336211353- 1519? mmposi?on- me 
i??ludefd ?h?a sham 9f (Human regoums reports in Mault'sbv rimm-
directly in EWCIEUJF and bacause 131? the Mesa relaticnship- batsmen iha lead
invas?gatm .?EaWde?) 5mg! ?rm ac?used- .{Mammby}. Banner did mi think it was. fair ?im-
Ehe W?a?ts ?aw ?eing- asked it: put h-ennemaiaini in wn?ting after aha .hati: verbally repuried'
her c?mpfainis ta Districf administrator?s. seve?rai time's. Ham-tier did his?: Eta-frag. this
imma?ga?m sh?ufd be canducted under Failing? because: 35% was rm making a;

sexual diacrimi?a?nsn complaint, gamer sham?I?d he :n?n?uc?t?'d

56

 

by an extrema} Inve?siigator as ?Har?ayda had prmiausl'y ank?bwledged; Banner did? 111319:
thir?aK the Eis??ict haci-handt??i her 121mm: taint 111 art expeditin 1:3 manner Sinai-'3 she.- had ?mf
mpm'ad It an Ami! 2319 Despite Samar-'5- Gla'arijr ataf?d abjedl?ans, the BistrICt

'meeded with Its gated far 1% 'im?s?gatian

1'1; .b-amn??tee is na??ed M?y 176; .2019

{fin May ?21211?9 Harayda and Lleh?n as mem bers-
caf the Westigatlon Gama-jittee? :Bian'??er war; natmpl?ed. on the: email. Haray?a i'ninrmed
{maimba?rs i?hat nt as Red 115 ls bf 1116?- ummrafafnf
at i?i?g?E at? which 112113 3115- Wauld be. grepar?d? id answer the:
gamma-rs. questians? .H-?ar?yd?a 1113.156 fhat the. paling: aid allbw Far verbal repb?ing
but that he :(Harayd'a) thvught 11159 mmn?tiee Esau-Id a??ommhda?te? Bonn'??'a raquest as
{any as she: Mada-stood that she might need T?'be Interw?md {again lithe had


The May 126-, 2919 email! I?gan?fie?: ?ann?fs Emmi-verbal Elam-hams {as .mpo??d to
Him an May it}, 2019) as fallaws: ?hastily? work. held back; Wm
advancgmi?nt, sexual VErbaI harassment in?i't?c?y. thraatenl?g ?eha??f; WhistIEbIbWIrig:
camer?a taxi messagas af- i?apprapria?ce and asked 191:1th ?lothing?i, The
email inaarpprated ?emezmts 1:;me Biscr?imina?pn (:pr?pl?int Pmmdure;

Emma!? in Sick; m1 May-21, 2019, Th? Investigatinn gamma magma-was
gmedul'ad it; met an May 22 201-9.. E=ew?enwasmnceraed. that Banner mum mi". get
her writte? ??mp?laint' him by time 151'? 1:13 Iirst-E?iHVestigat-im tgmm?tee meeting.

'Baw?en testified that he timid {hat f?e invesjtigatlon timid 11(31- mast

un?iiess. ihere was a r1: ?ompiaintand that Harayd The-May

122;. 261-19 meeting-6f the investiga??a? man?j?li?d;

1:2. Harayda m?i?se?s Issue affph?ysiaal s??p?ar??a?on - May ?ma?a

a?-May 1271,3231 Q. Harayda. sent an email ta Erawden asking whether fhaynugght-tci
'?m?j_ve the person. r?u?ng Harayda? iasti?fied that 119 Was thihking smut
Mavi?g?qnner even th'n ?gh? she never ?asked ?ta ?be? rainwatedmarayda 64466). ngden
tastifi?ti mat? ha call?d H-mayda i? it: iha email.. Emmi-an i?id H-arayda ?g ?inught
timy shwid waif for Bun-her tr; provide ap?ci?'e inf?rmai?on before making any; r?lO?Ei?O?
?dze'cisians (B-amden 59). ii is. uh?i?p??a?d that the District did. nut ?ake? any? e?n?a 

geparat?- Boninar anti? .Maul'tsby m?i May 29193;

??aauef Rpm-?ts gamma for her {abysmal Safety? May ?if, 2619 19!
201-9

feam 9f retaliati?n by Mault'sb'y escalat?d?ftar the District-
advisad- ham? ih? ?dve?iigatio?- pian. Emile? testi?ed that she, started back; an:
her canveisatiqn with ?Ma?i?sby?a?d ?is text Farming tr: ?isnitches gfet stifche?". {in May
at, 4:16: pm, Banner 3th an ?mail ta Harayda mfg-rm in the Mault?byf? tweet
want-tha- Whi-gtleblaw?r hailing kiH'e'ch: Banner Wrgta:

?i was sent a text ?357 the aagysa? ra? ?95:th ?ve?t sh?wi?g Elw- eff:

'Migh 3.3 claady reg-1am. i?im ?a?fzai?ed abEifJ!? a man!

against my?fa Had-{hie life a??y?rm Shauid?FDLE Harman :af Law

Enfamamani amd the tie nozi?i?'ea? Which appears? .td: threaten my?fe-

.58-

mung with my Ghiidmm It displays the imam afa whis?ebfawer being Wed.

far my We and f?e safety afmy mama. 1 mile :a aware-aid 

and a mirage student.- Man? mink army ch?dmn being; wirhauf f?elrma?ven

Ara gag-pursuing this anger (Sexual Haraa?menf Tf?a 7? claim} at just

?iscritm?ation? Because I wag sexuaiarhazzassed; marking a hz??fila

war-king; Enviranmeni and fhf'an'f?n?d :ti?l?it he: 1333. friends mf?f ma, Wh?- are

gazing ta-siick ibgefherta-?en?t; and W193i?! mam be-atir?sk. grease WW1:

me} raf'y?dr dam'siQn-z I was arse Md mat me maimed {ms afready?bem

fnfann?d, bafare- this Evastfga?m $393411. Sir, has W?s investigatiam been

aria {he a?bchE-d dafn'g {ha ?tw?stigaiian??

Ha rayda- did cansult With ??rihkla ?r IaW?en baf?e replyingte: Eanmr?a email
(Sprinkle 46}. In his Friday, May am emait $331013? sent at #259 pm, Haraycia Riki
Beam? ?e was ?dammed"; 'Haray?a said h? th?ug-Ea-t B?nner'was mfmiable With 1139'
marge 9f the ?i?nvestigatian. He afs? .statc'ad?? ?it was-=- my un?azrsfanding that ma
whistlebicwer'masaaggs' was'fr-om? a martin gran raga 562-11" sam?ihi?ng '15; (rewiring maria
maki?g wt: f?el '?irieiatenad; ?ncburage-ywi?m mama:IaWi?hfofn?ne?" Ha?rayd?
maul-u?ed?gthe email by Stating-ma ha mum ilEt 113$- Ieader ?if that: .iny?stigatia? ?an abdut-
Emma's gamma.

H?rayda testifis?d he did. an: halieve mat Banner wcauld actua'?y mutant Iawi
enfamementi. ihought :she was. jm-st wanting in he: May EDT-E emaIL Haray?ia did
mt mink :the mised; matters of hnmedtatg m??em :b?cau?a {112% ?Snit?h?s get

stl?ehas? faxt was Sent-?bre than? a manih baf?e. {Harayda 

59"

 

 

H'a?zitayda testi?ed ?that he called 155?de en the evening .of May 29-19.. Herayda
reed er e?mm'erize? "?anner?eemeila-ahd 'hler?pghse lie her-ethane. Harayda maimed that?
?he effectively eonveyed tn "Sheridan that Emma heel eepressed: eence?r?h?js 'ab'?ut her
ehyeiealr saiety enema ?llves efgher-ehiielreni?erayda Herayda 21mm: Eewdeh him

he respondecf ?te'EenherTe Bewden eeidu he mega: Harewafss peepense ms

Bew?en?e' recollecfien ef whee-EH'areyde eonyeyEd "he him 'hnih?e evening-GT May 
2-019 was hi?erent Then Herayea?s. amen- {e?s?fied {hat Haraydfa teld him he"
Banner canted: fewerifomement. hut Herayida never sci meye?d ht: ?him {he
message met Banner feared fer her the and. the Hike: of her chil?'r'en (Bewden 116431 
.Ezewzieniera?fied that his responeje fa: Hare'yda: -Weulizf have wee-different {We bEIie-Ved?

Banner was in: fear fa: her life, Bewderi=I$aid eat {if he? knew Re?ne: feared: for her safety/,1.

he weutd have. [waived law an'fhrqeriient by Galilee them directly- if Banner mt

.{BewdEn ?3'68 ?rt-lee).

"Fhe greaterweightef ?hetevide a ?eeing that May 17, 2mg.
Hereyde and {Emcee rrbeth knew erase havean?-that?ennerhad reageneble
and preSehi? fear fer her yhyei'cal safety and ihe? eatety- is? {her family member's. Harayda
and QQWden eheuf?-het have. beeneurprfeedmate-armer-?ed e; reper't with he 
:Me?y' 22,. 29:19 'th'atwas the Herayda reeom mended: ihatiBonner

take If She-few ihree?teneda

'14, Bawden mlete wee Bonnertu dise'uee complaint May 

2919



.It is uneieputed thatemenea?sd teenner to a meeting ih- ?in his. ef?ce en May- 30.
2111 9. and thee Tie-frame .?ttended?the meetings-es emit-11333.- B-e?nen. seamen and Temihe
gave eenflietihg? creamed.
Hawaiian testified that he celled "the emanating so hemeld-Qet Banner fie-understand:-
?er repqrting respg?ei?bilities easier Paley 2.752.. Hamish -?aci<hewmged that he was
summer?sterile.anemia the; meeting heea use he shamed {a gait- Eenn?e'r he 'fe'lIEW the
precedure (Bew?eh Bee-idem Smear H185 Eliecrin?i?a?en seam-perm farm :fhethte.
lieiriet utilizes. Sewage read the sachet?1 shares that "the Adm'itntefreter eheuld
meeurage- the eompiainfng; ampieyee e3.- eemptate the farm. Beraetofd B'enn'er That he
was enmmaging hertz: emerge the Gempwin-t farm net; lie-{Beween}
weeid we required he .re?luee 1th wept-amt te- Writing (Bewdee 72 
eem?meere E-en'ner rajISIrigxea-memeeb?uf?ne fermat-ef the; Gemplaiht fem whieh- had a.
hex te whack fer ?discriminati?enh but net fer: "ee'xeei harassment" er 'fhugfilre were
anvimement?. Eewden. tale Quarter he theu?ht .Bnnhe?r's compra?im Sheui?d be
ebaraete?rized as '?haraasmenf' but mt- ?sexual harassmeef'i Banner ?eteegreed w?h
Bewden; She" repeatae?Mau-?ebye cemmen'tatjout making her-waned! BOWd'en said he
had net mare that earn?mni'before Heiesti?ed that he Banner-
-cor?tinued Eta gteehlm ihiferh?atioe in bits; {Beihden 7435)? .aneen heldBehher
she eeuid raw-save Early ieewefk en. her .Cempteiht form: Awarding: 11e- Beween; Ber-111m said
she mule submit {he wri??h farm the foliewmg humming, May 21;- 35119

 

Hewett- aehnewledged'thal; his Ineis?c'e?ee {hat hemat- pm??a a mean cemptain?t 2-1; 2319' mflicted-
we}: weat?myda mid-the i?ve?g??e? nemt?itteh jaw-1115 May 1913 email. In them? 16, 2619 nma?i .wa myea
said he tale Benn-er that. she could jestbengherdecemanfah?ee bathe ?'?rSt mees?gatinn uemmitjtee meeting

rath er 1:.h an-fmng 3 Written eer?piaini hmf?ew?m 77-131.

51

Bonner tai-stifIEd "th-ai?s?e i?f?fd? mas-n: In f?e May-2052:1919 mating that she: wauld
maperate Ir} invesf-tigati?n but than? she had: mi: Inte'n?an p?hmpleting a farm tha?- aid.
mat I?t he: campialni {Banner 16513-163)! a?nner? sexma'ined my Ear allegaiia'ns did next
track. me ??mralaint ?arm; manner alas: told Einwnien about, a situaii?n that?! an
May 29319} that made her Wither- ques'tibn ?the cibjiectiiglty? 5f the nummE?-?ae; Banner
tam E-awcizen said she wasri'n' Maui'faby?? af?ne when he 1?35" from Ernst. STIR:
af'tih-e mambers a?zhe'fnvest?rga?mra V?Frastwas 
3531315 ?t whiz is he wanmd ta fannt?ai?}. iB'anar Said she did neat fthi-rik ?be Jar-1
abj?mfiua ihuaatigatar because. she was having diia'lague with Niauft?shy abuuf an
emplayae: :I'ntihe same maiti?n 35 Banner. Bonner tastified that reapandfed fa
her manner-11$ ?y stating that ?ame:- did-net g?t? ta pick ith? Am?mhers 0f ih'e investigation
{Emmet 

The {greater weight cf evidence supp?a?a a ?nding- f'thaf in May 29;, 20-13:-
Bon?fer ?iras?tly-- in?amed Bawdert that She had qngo?i?g Bantams With the
invas?glt?ian prams-433 a?dgthat' she waui?d'twt campfete i116" farm because she

cilia ?at- think it ?t?harga?eggaitigna

5 Bgnnerrs ?area has aligning scanti?erns with Lamti'e - May 

Banner Ia?kad its ?Lempa fair a?viceand validation-Of her ?ngering con?rms abou?
the District?s handlm came? Gampiajintj?lgemp??). May 20, 29-19 aft-6:18 pm, Eon mar
?famardadtm Whips: theaa?r?a?ij aha-sent Hara'yda axpfe?sing {meems met the {Meat
ta [Ear HIE.- and her children?s IWHS Lempe .ies?fi?ed .tha'f ha was ??commg inamaaingi?y-

cememeci aEbgut Hanna, "s?pecl??alry Winn-was. 'f??resan??g Eh'e?r; th had her back when

152?

 

 

ghe: Was atwa'rtg wha: was sitting at the: table. wit? harWhen- she was meeting wiefh 'Tadd
Bawden and fathers, raga- ma .ja?swerm thataues?an was usher-afar? 10.). Lemme
pha?gd?u?in ant: Gardner t9 asked 'ihem if ih?ywauld- ba willing tin talkm Banner? ?net
ti: ?gment ?eribmjgast as; a Marci, somabudy?wm at: mid give her?aditiae $er
the: perspecti?xie (if thin-s2 whd- represent eu?p?layees? {Lei-ripe 113 '1 may agreed. Lamina
eaii?d Banner. Lame-told. Bonn-ex ta cal! ?ardher ?ne-mm In. his secand intewlaw.
Lemp'e arr-igha??all? Stated that ?ha was: {he 'impetua-far?onner?? mam {2&me and

Gardner or: May 2:11 9 (Lamas 11:22)

?16. Banner meet; [Sabin anti Gard tier a?f af?a'es May 2:119

Banner-m?tmm Whiz: and Gar??eratfthe F'ff 1A amass Banner
said she Used ?Ehe meeting $119 did r113? ask Gardner 116 did anything: ?n
her said Bubin and Gar?n?i?gave hahelp her draft Exhibit ?1 far Exhibit 2-:
(Some:- ilil 

finisi?-Hnd?ardn?r?s rm?il?ctinn ofthe' May 20; Was ?an?i?terat ?1th
?onrief?s {main Gardner mostly alumni
her ex?p??e?ws- Wifh Mault's?y and vary. if any? abmit haw ma Die-Mamas: handling
he: camplaints (Gardner @191 27L. {aardner amid mt regal! if Banner; discus-sad gain?g
it; the 5:336. G-ar?f?er testi?e? that she did. '?af wt?a?i this: Harald: riba'ne to--alartih:am
ta .th 8056 remit, Gamma: was gain-SEW; tn:- ?the fact thai- Banner- was leaking. far

media a?e??m :Eisa?fdrzer 27-).

 graater- weight at the Widean supper-ts a fi?ding that the SGNA 621 mi- help
33.31213? any-dacuma?ts so? ad?s? hat ?n hat comma-Ms (Grafd?er 35?38) The: any
I adsvic? that Dub-Err anti: 63 rd net? gave Shana in 239.? May- meeting was it: g?f a
?aw6r 334., Gardner 3'15}. The; SGITA did; nut maxim Banner wuh any 

assistanae- away far any 131' hear legal expenses; 14-15., Eaf??ar 35).

Egonn?rmmacts ?egiera may 21-. 21:: 1-9

Lemtae'aisa :re-c?mmendedihat Burma? reach mitt: Zia-91m: Sauna: nailed Zl?agrer
and left: several mtmmails. Cir: Maya-1.2912 around 51:15 12m, Zieagler returned Banners-
ca?il.- B-annar mid Ziagler that Mammy sent her tam that ware" emf
{Ziggy 15). Banner med mgwards ??a?xual hara?sme?t" and ?hastfle war}:
envir?nmenf?in ?escrib?i?g M?u?sb? camiu?t if: ilteer ?iagiar gum-151a Ziegler
ih?at she L?wnar) had. imaged a-namp'l'aint awash-:3 was mmerne? ?'bauti haw Exams being
handi?gt by the mist-?at; Banner- ital-cf ?Ziegler aha was sweep-?ed .ahgut {ha abj?eatmiy 6f
the :iWe?s?gatlim given the algae relatia'nship'b?ivveen anti 29Man (Ziegler M.-
Barium 525:1} asked 'Zi?gler if; she {naught gh?a (Bb??ar) zs'h?uid go tr: ?ne. 31.233.
Ziegler Haiti -'Banner ihatsh?a was n??a a??fney; bsut?f Sumner felt thatthe're was any kindi
{iffhmafZiegler-$212311? she ghguEei {waive [aw e?f?ra?mjent {Qatar 16).

an: May 2?1; Earmarqund a pm. Eiegler uatled Hardy its:- will him 5mm: the. phone
sa-m?rsafion with, ?u?nri?r. Ziegler tat-d- Har?gr- that. her main wag-tern was that it. appeared
26mg n?t?lng ta addre?ann??f's Scam-[318E112 Hiar?y f?i?kzm?lerh? W??i?i

fallaw up with Harayd? ta B?sur'? pmi?i?s Wea?e being f9lkowed12feglaf1220; 22).

E4

 Hardy tea?lle Hareyd'a ?may 9'

. Hearth celled Eager en they 201E at ?8:45 am ehditeld her that the hat} epok-en
with the: heme and they were meeting fewerd with: erased?ures .(ll?egl?er Hereyda
?ees net-recall: mirth-t; phene chit hem Hardy. Herey?de said he was net aware that
henner ee?ed?hiegler the nightbefete, EQWEISH tee'ti?'ed thethe hid. anthem that Banner

cail?di?a Ema WEMh-ertt?eween he).

Homer quee?ehe Investigative procedures; ?they 32, ante-a {may 231.2959-

?h Maya, hilt-9,. Benher ?tented-email 1e" Hareyda e't 50:113- amt-*1 whisk she: the
?lth" ebeut the May 2.3129 gphene, canvereatienhetmehFreet?end Me read-e
her further queetien- the ebieh?ifity Of the ihveetfletien: earn mhtee. Banner Wft'hE: ?When
a team is being assembled that may not have thelabi?ty-te remain ?lthy- ohjee?ve time to
'h'hreehel? bias eymeetjhi?es tewethe eehicuier set :ef (Le. a superviieer
whale being- challenged by: her administrative assistant, Investigating 
eueewieefr preetiees. erid'hehe?eteere hemg celled trite-tweaking? by

the administrative assistant}; I believe I eheuld have the rightte veiee meme;

2m Between [amperee Meme?anew re: Feteh?el Equity Gemp'ia'ihi n-Ma'y 

29ft?

(in May 22-, ZEN-9L, Between asked: hermihe ta: eheck'whh- lot-leer 113 See i??ehe here
the Gempl'eted the Camplal?t fem When Terrhiine taper-ted that: Gamer he: he:

eempJeted GempIeint? fetmi awash-deemed he used-ed intake immediate act-inn to- eat-

65,

 

?mnner?s mncems in writing per Pa?- nf the. 'Biscrimim?m {implant Procedure
(scam-en ?17Mi'fsy.

?33mM3yk222, 2m 9 prepared amemoran?um ta Haray'da .arat?iie? F?ien?al;
Euuiw E?maiainf 135mm testified that he Was ~th ln??gn?e?? by
3-minute *?tQ?prapara {his Mammal um (Ema-n Bergman. te$ti?ed iihat ha did net know
that ?Bonner Shad. .?h?tiaatad a award mem?er' 'thf? night.- bafere he prepared The:
Memdrand um (Baw?en he: tad-apendentliy afrivediat {he dad?s-ion 1:5- pn?pare
the Memnran'dam ?ecaujs?e afghis?gmwing fimly samplete
me d?l?arimina?dn farm was hamp?ring his. effa?t?s ta farm ?an in
{it} a pmgaer investigation. testi?ed that at all times h?E fried tn cumin-$1 if??
investigation ?byth-e buck" (Ema-en 

Ehe Mammandum, 313mm iejant?i'ed the fa?cwmg as anaemia; that Emma
?r?ught its his. aften?o?ni Mann-shy blaming at ?ah?ytmg he: a. .pmmatian ?asaed mm
needing her 3: his ?gment ?pzzsii?m; sewing 39mm What?she cans'ider?ad tag-be
inappmp?ate text asking Bannarif-s?e-migsed 

making sataiemants- abdut his ability-ta make ?amt ?air-mes"; :1 ?timi?at-?Ing

'?iia Erector a? Leadership Davelapmenti? Maults-by's buy gifts; fair 'B?n?sf?s sari;

Mault?sby?s 133:: massage {?sn'it?cg?es gef stit??es?) was anattempt
fr; ham, anti abaut nt? wanting: {at female emplayee 1:9 mm
in their division because she: Was a?raciive and he cauld- Hilli- himse? atau?d
?rst.

hr ih? Mem?randumi Iawd?en Mate: ?Aifhnugh ME. Banger has riot; speci?cally

rm'fu?aed ta-a?amp?e?te the mmp?laiht farm. her Inact'io?n in ?ning sa b6- cansidered a tie;

sa-

 

fast? rsfusal.? ?aws-sn- shat'hs c'nnfsidere? Bunny is have ??rs fasta" missed, to
submit form bscsussit had Eases he iosk 
is minim-1i??s?arsesii?ithfbe ihstihs?rs wan-id ins rs stampisint ?les! and ii:
had been three days May 20, Enigmestmg Where: Sh? p-wmised ?is submit: the
Gsmpijafini farm ?n {May .21., 1201-9- 823.:

B-owd?sn. ?rst his Mem?rsn?um dis rim same sf the waiters.
that answer appar?ri?y- discus-Sad wiih Haraycia is Emir May if}, 2919 meeting (3::de
?ag-7 Eswgian zit-the. .tims [is piss-area ss 2619;?,
his was sat aware; that Baa-mar Was silaging {has Mammy seinsliy Harassed: has; that
made; E?s-rimr muss his that William assisted ?sst?s wefk
envirsnment, that Maul?tsby engagsd is thrusat?ning b?havisr sf that Manna-by .ask?d.
Rasher is} make. ?eticius amiss his. naien?ar {.30de W531 

-:Biowdisn hand classiest this Memsraridum t9? may. 22:; 2mg swan-d:
11mm At 3: 1-5 pm Vii'a'rayda ss?t an Email is Basset? mashing thus '??emsrand?ms is. his
email; 'Hsrayda: said: Bunnarthsit Sawsen'ihad asked her ke?puii her assassins
i?'WFi??Qi? ??lsr- afsmiaissmpiaint ithst the. washed Memsrsi?d?um was
stt?rn'pit is reams Banners. ssmpiaint to ssr' District 
Harsy'as stated: must ask. ysurwishss-ts?is-a {miss sump-laint. san {at me
:ksqw-lysu?sten?ass by Friday. May 24. 2319"" {ii?a?raydzs 83?35). Ham-ma testified shat
he srbitrsriiy selectssi {his M's'y? 24,. 20311.3, deadline sesame has wasted in mass 
With-{he 

Besiden?s testimssy that its dis hat knew that had alleged sexual

harassment, hastile work assignment, resa?siis? and 1h fastening behavisr as sin/is? 22.



 

3019.215 not aredi?bla Th3 greater might of the erv-idan?e: a ?nding that Banner
pravidad: ?Eciwden mm suf?nien-t Wama?un? in the; Atari 2:119 meeting. it: 35.399351: {hat
she was: r'a king Bantams- uf?s-axuzaf harassment, mama $19.:er Env'imn want and 
Bunny thaws-? gating cameras what:- she? p-?ersona?y mat'wflt?h lawd?n 511'. May-
a, 201$ and May-226,. 267$: ?n May- 51%- 2319- Ha r?yda sent- fan: mail to: the zinves_?91_atipn
mam mien int-graded Hamster-t which urearly states?; iha?t Bann?r- had raised ampl?ints df
sexuai harasamem, 'h?stile sum anviir?nment. threats-ruling behaviorahd whistl?btowmg.
Tha greater waigf? "of the also supperts afiadmg mat-arms time-Bowden-
prepared the Mamam?dumzhe knew-that Bunnerbellav?d thamauf?sby?s 'thf?a?t had risen
in the ppint that she was mw in fear 1491* her life a?'d {he safa-ty {if her children; This
minim-Ge aisa suggests that at ?ay-e. tin-1.3 she grap?red B?w?en knew

:t?at Harayda recami??ndad Harmer mutant loch! iaw enforcement.

21. Bq?ne'r ?-l?s-mm?lai?t with the 13650 May 252", 2.919

Banner agntacted the an May 24313? at 4:32 :pm; ti: ?le? a {implant-aim
threateneii her ha sent-the ?FSnimhes stitcheswiaxt scan. 1.5-, 20159
and ?ashed {he lihk; ii) t?E-?ew Yb'rk- Times Warm airtime, about the arrest ui?a ??ut?h
M??an pali?tician ?st fh? minder ijf a Whistla?ihl?il?f?'r. Bonner E?ti?ed that she ?'fe?di ?the
-.eampi?a?int becaus? she 1=h?nght Maultahy?at threat was ?eriqu?. and she wan?e?d there 2&0:
be (a F?mard 61? ?fits. thr?at, Bonner: ?lm: ta criminat mamas againSt

Manna-by, if puss?ible {Bah-?air 
22. Banner menses she ?ied rap-or: With 3050 -.--. 2.019

E3

 

(in. May 2'34 3619 at 3:51 am; Banner sent-an amaili ti: .himafh'a'tr
aha fullawad his advice. by Qantadlhg faw enforcement. In the: amt} Banner-mm:
am a little met met them are my ?r??adwas In piece it; prefect?-
vemplayee's when .ihre?ts- an? made irr- f?e canf?xf the wamplace: We
Ingmar; What? mam?: Mam! threats Wax-social media, {Ext
6? verbafh ?at-f?s- dis?ewiianingf?knaw thatrfhe?ne are n?tsim?arpmfec?bns-
in pfaw that can be ,amzsistean?y dapiayad far-empfaye?e?s. 1'
maaf! when Du gamer? fig-"caved fan-em.? fram sermapna wh?mi wired the
9mm! With ?see you amund? and'h?- parasme'd the Wardi?gyas a threat there
was sp?eci?E? m?t?m-t?af was taken-0n?; behalf ?y'tha Shard. Law
enforcemgant was {Wm-fad; and if app??red QE 5- pm??dura Ir?" pia??.
.anfar?u?ate?? if" app?ars ?th-a?t ihiagmca'ss is-?atah? that aII-e'mpfayees {am
p?vy tag HE in my ?1,356 When we empt?yefs? mamas {he ?lm 13?th
iampiayI?eht'f?mat?,
Harayda 'tasti??d that his: talc! E?w?an abnut Hanna?s May BBS).

Harayda alsg- dia?ussad Hanna?s. safi?ty ?amems with Scaty?l? Palicge Ems.

Hmyafa ream-fad? mat Eric-rs 2km him; that if maid be hast if gamer fep?rted her safety

apnce'ms mm. law ?nf?r?amant au?mri?e? (Harayda 

Ems. recanad the conversa?an With Haray?az Hamyda told- En?qs that Samar fel?i
th-r?e?t?rzed by rang uf?MauIts-by texts and that-she-?ad game m? was 90mg in
mm he: sancerns. Engas it Was ap?rc?p?ate far the 3:180 it: im??stlgate the
tag-arts. Ennis teatifi?ti h? midi- Harayd'a??that it wnuld be a can?ict (if ?interest

far the Sahara] Patina ta investigate a gi?im against because Ennis was. In

5.9"

Maultehy?e chain af ?nes else SCSQ weu?ld be In a better ipeeifiert
It?; i?nve etigete because the pence c?d? nut have the Tmeneic nape billties tn?: dammed-?
tame. after the cahttersatim With Harayda, Ems halted Captain We!$h. the Criminal.
"lmiee?tiga'tie?s?. il'urjeau Gammancfer at the 8080-. Ernest tale Welsh that a :Dietrict
empieyee .atl'leged that? a?he was thteate?ned-hy {befits} EMS-1.13161: himtha?he-GGQ WES

in his chem- {if Enrae eel-ted" Weigh tie-take the ease. (122136525342).

23 a?enner-ques?ts?e the eemlaint prernedute May 23. 23.219
Uri. May-23. 26-19 at 16:5? ram, Beater feenten' email be Herayd?a" in response th-
teceiv'ing. the Metnnre?dum. hammer reited tn shatter: at the Emitting and

which eta-tee thet- ?rei repbri'ing of haresy?ehtiie h?neidered- an

?i?eiei means hf" tenet-ting ah act. he the. email Bonny-else reiterated that the istr?icit

Eumpliaint farm-that ehe hetiebeert asked te-mmpizeie [?'urstxent ta Foliey?z?z Hid metham-
heme t?-sheck ftithasiile werkenvireement harassment-end sexual 
fHatayda- responded te-len-ner?e-emaii at 3:135 hm. He rem'i'hd'ed Behsner2thet-the
District was handling her under Petite? 2.221. H?eteyde explained. that sexual
harassment is either?nma?a? based.engend-erleexsosgem-let c?dt?d cane-ck thetbuxerehe
:56qu that: initiate GempI-eihti?etin witheute?eeki?ng-e be}; ?arayda ales stated: ?Wyatt wit-3h
file eemp'leint- Under.2.?m= Bullying'the?n there is. me that dines not fall

under my :respenelhility?.

24. SESQ emails Beaker attent'puhii; recycle request-m may 24.2919

70

 

21119 at 10:41 am Breaker received re ?heads. hem Kaitlyn
Perez (*Perezfm :Pttbiie?fnferm-e?nn ??ieerferfhe 5680 Pete: ferwerid'ed ta Beaker the
Herein! ?rihune?'eamey 23:23:31.9pubtie records rquest farthe agate-st Jef?
Meelteby. the (360? at the scheme! by his .aseiefantf'; in her email Perez-said the
5.030. meld be. releasing their repert-te the Hamid Trihe?eeiith?in the. 
The entail {'aie'e attached the: repel-l: that the $080 empered magma
Banners May 3252:, 2-019 eemeiel?nt.

After Eeadihg ?Perez? emaii, Seeker tried uneueeneefully to: ?ne! met-?at
admi?lefretore. Meulteby was the first. .edmingietratar ehe heated; Beeker ehqwed
?the 5336 ?po?t ?Eeeker 23-2335 Seeker eeid Mag-1155b? etade? Shaking; he
*?bl?iadei?e?? Beekerehd Matthew eVent?L-ieii?eunct Sprinkle-end
they were: able te reach ?Bewden by eho??ei Bewden said he wee eh hie way he the
Len?iege arid: that he meld; meet them sprinkle?seffiee- '(Beeker- Sta-3?1)

Whe? Eew?en Ferrived' En agrinl?te?ez effiee- manna lunchtime. Bee-her b?efe'd
Bewden- en the minutiae. B?ewden asked mealtehy same enes?e?e ennui- the text
messages. reiererieeid In the repent, Maulteb-y said that; h'e-wgaen't ever: ewe if he
Meant fer the ?enitehee get SfiiGhES'z'ta? in go it}: gentler. Matthew defended 
?ete?ng. that the SC-SO report cemetudec?i there was He. ertmi?nal wrengdeing {Beaker 33a?
34.), Between tale M-jeulteby?thet he heededt'e leave. decided haw 

reepen? Tattle? $356 renew

.25 meet he disease next steps May {24, 2619'

71

 

B'awd-en, Baakier. Haray?-a and ?S?pr?in'kle? mat in disgusa the, next stapsi :?prinkle-
{3601711131911 ded that ?re Brisiriat mmze Tamara, with 58?] external inf-vestig?atiia? lnsta?a? 1531?
an infernal Investiga?an?-aammiitee 123dean 89; Eamiar} agraem Hardy
?untaf??ad? Vicki Spraat ia? see if maid bat able ta ?anduat an [Wag-Elga?dn 1mg; an:
admi?ia?trfafive: aQS'iSt?ant?s ?lleg'at'ionis- at? mn?wci bvih? 13961

"Baring meeting's??tha 20,19, an?xen. and 
decided" 'th at maui?sbys his U113 53' ?prin He {heated a vaqa?t- af?ge;
apri?ni?e ii?fnrr?g? . his uf?ce W?uld ha r?lo?afed? to a. different mummy in" me.
La n-?ings (?p?fn Rig 59-511}. Bawden went With Ma to gath?rhis- ?errsonai 'beiizi?gings.
and big-walked Manifest? in. his car (B?oWd?en 8843329),

Homer: lasti?egt mat he ma?efhe d?e?kion's Ito hire. an nuts-?e Jinves?gamr' and fa:
reiocate Maul?tsby?g grime, He? testi?ed that: his da?is?icns were emf driven by Izhe fast that

fh?e media- had been alertecl'i. Rainier, far Saw?ej? the real. ?game;- changer? in the some

gr frag invesiiga?on was Pthar?gli?ti? that Bonner had aatua?y-ane ta fin-E 3:156);

anuen t?s??edl that ?ema?s $uf?axi$9dih3i Emma? (in?amed $689 hen-auger Harmer
d?wnplayed her smegma af?rm]? f?th?i? prim 

When "Bidw?aj? ?retumad fr?m: escar?ng Mauitsby 1113 $5317. met w?h
sprinkl?, B?eker anti Ha?rayda. B??wden bid Beaker "that ha (-Bbwdent} had;- pravleus'
meetinga with Samar in which she; alsblosed E?m?ms amt-1t. iax?t massages
arid miner behaviar. Bowden $130" tedd- Ba?ker that Hariayda had baan

watkf?g with ?gamer to.- corivart What: was mfgl?aliy a verbal nom?laini- rink: a wri?ten



mmrilainf the mam; equity 351-32).

3'2-

an?eni $pri?nkiai.? 'Beek?r and Harayda discussed haw the ?iistrict' shaui'd-
ream-m ta the fa?t ?that the. HWaid Tribune maid likeiy ;[3Ubl.i5h a aim-ab?ut Bahhg'r?a
altaga?nng. Maker Bowman decided: that {ha Dist?cf should issue a media
statement. {and?n Hawaien 'thaizg??i -it: maid be t1: Issue a
media sta'tementhefdreme Harald Tribu navsmfes {Beaker 45:43);

Buying [313mm administrati?in ?aweloped B?mmunicatian atrategy"
(Beaker Beaker initia?y drafted the: media; statement?- ta annaunee that ?is District;
made. at?! 1m"! aimuf Manually; am! that spar protecoh; magi-?2
Suparini?ndant ?uwmentecl the tum! admplamt in writingf'. Later'tha?t afternam Beaker
ramsed the media staiemant t9 fnaluii?e a 
ma?a a Wt?i?? ream abrau'i ?aw ma lama? ma} cmgiaknf had been handled. by {313.

.Snpariiritendie?t and by the uma? R?soumes Bap'arb?eni {Beaker 

23.; Administratars i??atwi'thBunn?P??ma? 724-: 2519?

After District adm?nistraiors mada?thavdesiaians 19 hits an extarna? inwg?g?t??r 
P?lacate add in issue a media- statema'nt "if-?33? nailed Emmi" EE '?m?mwm
nanimnce mam. Seaman; Sp-?fim?i Harayda and Be?ker? Wefesxeat?d at 
iabl??g. Beaker i?ici Banner she was a 9W mferri'?g EE thaf trig-ire was a
.puh?n 19:05:63 TEQLIESE in: he: mime 1331-?? 3'31me ambushed ham
aa??d. mtg: a- mating Einn? wi?hf a ?tabla fun taf highwfankingi ?er?a?w?i?l? 
.Beeker shamed Bonner fi?lE?i imae?a-Sftaier?en?hl ?fsfri?tmannegf [3.3149 in adva?ce if
an? madiiaarep?rta ?in the meeti?g Bu?n?m?i? tat-he was ?at aware maths-r repair-t E3

was a gaubs?c- record (Ewen B?ekerfasti?ed thatian?ner was upset Bonner

3'3

?g

saint she was a private and this was met .eomethl?g She i-nicended it: go pu'biie
(B'Eeker 49- ~52, Harayda 

the same meetingaennerwas infer-med. man. the :?i-striet weuid be swimhim it:
an euteide investigation ene that Mauit?by?s? amaze meld: be. remcated whiie the
investigatian wee ?eeing. Banner wee ?eld that they had net mtg-ed eat "hew me
effem hay-te? ?ay affine epefatiens {Bewden 9-1-7925}; Harmer mist the
a?r?l?ihtratore that ehe had net [manned The: fa mile of the aituation. .Bewgllet?r, wef?'enner
she; could iejave werk early. Eh ateii? herfemin-w?at was 90'an on (Hera?yda 67$.

After diem?ie?smg Ber-men Bewden and Ha'rayda met separately with line ether
administrativa assistanta ta infantry-1 them that: a?eempiaihthad been made, that Times geihge
2th be. hand-led by .311 euteide investigate? and that effice Was Being maveri-
dwing-me investigatihm lewden asked them net? tetelk ebe?tt?s? 'e?uatien; (Bowen. .93?
29711

.37. Banner: delive're- dise?r?ina?eh eampia?ief te-IHarayda: 6-2ng 24; 301%

After meeting-Wife administratere i? ihecenfe?rence ream; Eamerhended Hetayda
:he?r cerepialet e?egii?hg met Bowden end: Hereyaa diacrim?ineted againet her in their
handling of her harassment eemp?leiht? {Exhibit Hefaycla gave. the. (tenement in
'Bewden aseumihg the easement Bonner handed him was Beh?ef-?s Gamer-aim. farm
alleging. that Maulteby hex-new harassed her; When Bewe?e read Exhibit 4n he realized-
th?et eemelemt; was net directed at Maulieby.. Rather the Cemjelamt (Eithihiij 
weir-aims: Runner?s allega?ens that?: Seeder} and the human Reeaurces Dapair'tmem
her in their'?ahd?ng ef: her templeint {?Bewen H-agrayde

mew-3;.

Y4-

 

After reviewing Pulley-2:22 and cansul?ng? Hardy! Bawden?acided thai. the $615160!
Ina-rd needed: ta. dad-?e haw the maria-should .handili? Exhibit-.1. angden EEek?r
aboLItJLh-e new campl'a'int ?x?ibit seeker than "revised ma Mediastaieme?i to: include
that ?f?llani??f E?f?e ?f?rmar wrift?n c?m?l?ai?t 151v ?fe Earne- empl?ayee. "aha LIE the way if": Whieh
the. i?i?a? Bra! campi'aint. ?as been Bec?aus? the a?mpiai?'t is in regard 1:2 the"
mil-ram aft-he Superintendamz and ?umain :rESBLImas--depazrtmant 1119than beard-wilt

-.determl?e a plan far? regain-ma" (B e?ker' 5&54}:

?6313 I?t'ervi?Wa Ban ?air (and extracts-iextmassages May 21319

SGSQ-Befeg?va- Ben glaubra?a ("Lu?bta?d?) .ph'o?ed Banner .ciri May. '23 nil-?May 2%
Lubm?nnt?l?d 'Eian-rierihat he had been assignedbe?r hai?-se and He waded Miner raturn,
it; the 86,813 it: pravicte additidna! [nf?m?fiom (E??fler 161-162), Emmet mada- an
return May 223, 2015:

3122111317 amperate? Wifh me 863:? Harmer sufi'mdarsd her imam; inf: th??
3cm tr: 12mm than: if: extract ?w?d??ndg-?fi?af?a?t Sh??j gave ?aw-am
st'at?ment- that was videefaped'z A?erer?viewi?g vi?z?afars?eci =i?ieWiBW,
finds that? the i?fermatie? Banner ?pir'a'ivided it: me 3030 In. her sworn: statement was

ma infamgation aha piovfded 

.29. Madia-stammEnt-iis res-eased ?Wabash 2mg
Human placed'individua: salts it) Bgard-members tar give them a ma?a; up ?befare-
the ma?a: statement went nut. Them??iastafemeniww news 'Gu?ets $5.333

rim at?! Maya, 2019.;

30?. Banner-?5 jab duties. .ahan'g'ag after May 724, 36-1-9-

Digtriht admimStra??s .met with. Bantam May. 24, 2mm fh'ey ?itf mt tell
h?ar if ?r Elm Ber-job duties 'waufd azha?'g?e as Team?; cif 'Mauligby?? af?ae T?i??ati??a ?ver-
the Weekarid; famine: talked? ta Tam?ksi?ins and Sam. Tbmkin? ?atd Barther that She-L
'th?rstoad that Tex-mine; was-gazing in} take-gver?as? radrnin'lstra?ve agaistan?t}.

May 28. same. at 75:43 am Banner sent} an email: tut Harayda, anden. and

--Sp?in?d? underfh? subject: Duty Ghanga's.? In the .?ma?il -Bon.r1afrecjuiafatad; an;
zagyv-m?dr?minm in har'pnsiti'on as a; result af?ne being- relQCafEEL

WIN warm ?94?th mil-1&3: Cam?HW?-mytiu?es Manges?.- mail? so

Whafam ?my new? la still ham-die @3113 as 2913 ta

fig-3:66:31, and What? if {2113:1933 ha v9 bean made Why ware Mayan?

gambituni'aat?d Witt: ma du??g am meeting on Friday, but: 
communicatea with-129115391165 baa-?are being raviewadt:by me??

Bawden reap-ended it; ane?s email g?riaemingdutyehanges at. 9:09 am an May
28., 2613 in an email mw?ch ?e named .Mauits?byt. Ki?ng?iey am? Term-he; BaWdengtafed

$1132 they Ware still farmuta?t-ing mania an h?w ti: npara?fe dark-19 ?ie- ?that;
Mauitsby has been ta work fhmuigh Termine 15m: .ciari?al supp?rt. am? that
Ear-{per might he able t9 assist King'siey ?n sum? zpzrajec?is? Bitumen afso abhn?wladg?d
that ha hang-red Maui?tsby'g raquest to disseminate lumen-2%. Ma?a to hi5 emit and

calendar 191493;.?

 

?7'Enw?i3n ta??r??d that? Maui?b?l called 11mm may 211:; access in [?315 m1 ?n that: he
rammed a if! at 1315 ?dmfn'isfrati?e fatsks'he mass i gr. gag: ten-Te li?awd?? 

335?

 

was ?ps?tthat-shezhaa been Stripped ?11? h'afi?fjab c?uti'aa Shetas?fiad: ?lie-It
like I ma bai-ng ?nished far fEPQr??g "anti kingl. (if iis-mata'a? the aeqzuati?un, wher?aa?.
Wag (Banin?r319i33; Bower did nut its
ewham aha was sun-masci taught {laminar 1939194}; Banner did mt have en'ouuh work
ta dz). She testi?ed that aha fail-Ike ?ne 5f th'ase peogjle What Wars :iastgn ?wril-wmm
:fom" (Bonnier ?1.93)

But-mar ablated her ?ngaing ?shamans W?i?th-herfi?iends and ??n?da?tes; Bah?fer? fart!
{?at she was? fruatt?at?d ithat in: ?ne in tali'g?ad ti: hat-dlr?ctly
abeut he: ?ew rare {Ebaugh $113.71); 353%." ?tutti Saba that me wauld father ?ay 
and nut get $316 tha r: {6 mm and do. ham-?g (Saba 413} Saba that
gt?i?l npthave-enpug? snark ta keep her-busy (E?aha 43).

Bowdmimgughi he acted transferring Ba?ner?s du?tes ta Term-the;
Ha maimed that ha wag hesitanm rea'ss'igh mar-warm surname :le'lse. Wind 1531?:
Bonner-'5 pay-was. mat affe?jted, E?wd?rii testified that he ?i?ixmt ihi?k?ln?nefr n'tai ?ailing
engagh mark-maid {B?WQel'i 

Emner was aisp genes-aimed that ?he wauld ran Maulteiby after his ?f?ca
wag reheated begaigsa mauitaby came to the ihlrd-??m far 
?331111353! was"- 213:: ?untried ab-?cauf Ink: Human mauitsby a?e? asked lumas. at
?Ems- it; Encampany? him WHEN- he its ?le ?uff-t5} Mai?; ?ne 01? these t?'?si 
:tald .En-as that he was ??is'apgninted that Emma}: Wm was frien? and a ca??dan?a?l
employee wou?l?- m?ak? a scam plain-it against mm {Erma 

?211 June 4. 951 ?ower-left a. wine-4m}! far Ziegler, in the vnicamai?l, lama? s?i?

at ?116 Ethan! award Was' han?l?i?g 119? ?pmplaint! she mam-ad Zziag'IE-r it: be aware



 

 

91?- her arguing cameras Banner told ziegjler wart aha had. been ?Mpgef cf her regular
rgshanaib?t?ea and that she no hanger? had specific jab dut'iea Banner tale? Ziegler ma
relacatian was: .imPac?nge har mare Ethan Mauligaby Evan-it?wgh aha was the Victim Banner
c1111: inc? u?dersitand What made hie: gituatian airfarentfram any athar admin-f?frat?jr, ?tea char
Zi?gzler r?tu?med ?Ban-nar?g Banner that she ramgaited her

.ca?ic?t?s and .app'r?biaie'd her bf'lng??g Term .a'daitfohal in?rm-31mm ,ziegler ibl?d Hardy

abgut 23125;).

:It is ?-nd?spuied; mat- the unify ska}: me- Dl?s't?rst 1961i: 16: address. B?nn?a?s safety-
:aennem?s during: tha time.- frame? May 241.2019. thruugh? June 2619 was ta: mam
Maul?t?byi?? phys-iaal af?ee ta Elm?Ether building.- Enos tastified that ?the Santana] 13.911693
Hepartmen't Was mt askadj ta take any st?pa ensure 111.6" parti'es-mre- .and-
Were safe. me canveyed 33333163151519 GE him {51135 33412}: B?wtlagn test'l?ecr
that- ha did mint 1(an that. Banner gantihued-w her: physical ?afety after
111131.411is foigg? was! f?i??ated an Mai/241 20-159. (Bawden 

The meaty weight a? ma air-5163:1133 a. finding {hat Egan hers dq?as. as

administrative a?ssi?tant after Mauitshy?s Ef?c? wag relegated; glmaugh

Homer's. way was ?at affegt?d, 2113:? :i?paspa?sibili?ee! were d-Emfi?ished: made.

Buwderi am! aware ?that 511%?- 1:115? ?at like ihat ?herjbb: Ghana-gm:
she felt she was the am being isoiatedf while. nnti?med it: his jab as.
usual: 51179 was a?r?aid bananas: manifest)? 31:11.1 had-unfettered amass ta 1113111de ?aw

wh?r'e: liem?cewas I?aata?;
3?1 563 t??cliu?eis its $131111 3! invas?ga?un - may 23* 2319

13-

{Sn may 28, 20-19 the 36130 inf?med Banner that may were waging. their file after
reviewmg; the Evidence. ca?l-uded mat the- ?mra-at' Simmer :mpartad was: ham
arming! In naturei The. 55380 alap gnntaafed to: advise him afithe 
38}

?amrding ta the ?epqr?t finalize-d ?an May inthe.
3.11 prpfe?mI-zntal repert was it: the, smut-Pam Department?W?ihei-r awn fevi?w
slime Chet: apgear?d hair's: .amzrred ?rm their awn mmpus'es and cancem? Sarastjta
County 3mm; Hazard pambnnal?. The Sabina! F?liea Espadmiemdid not tak?: a?y??ariher
3:126:31: after raceway the sail Hie Enos said that the Sat-1901 Felice

Qap?artme?t?id nut mwi??either?f?I?a $086 r?pads (Fines 26,: 35.7):

Sch?? Baa rd apbmvesSWI?g-i 41-, 29139

Hardy?- annaa?naed that th? Ilatri'tizit? :Eeceivad Wig: campl?i?t?a made by an 
undar'the- Distris?s Equity puiifcii?afs at the June4, 2-6319 Schism: Baard meeting. mammal:
[3:11am authn?zadthe District-1:3 retain-5W! ta?inyestigate both .qampIaints, (Exhibit 1 and-

m?-trittweceiv?s gg?ie? afl'q?a?lisby?? {mats -?--June 9m; 2M 9:

Qt: dune Y2. 291:9, Perez, sent an; email ta {Beaker infarming her {hat the $6363
'Enirestigatfanms Glaser} and a?abhing a ?g?y zaf the} .8030 Supplememal report. an June
161i 23.1.9, Bg?ek?iw?nt fo? thia 368019 pisk HE: 363 ?me that-the; QBEQ

Extiiaated mm Bar-1mm phoina an iM-a?y- 2-4, 127015) At'??wcl?n?s requgat. Ee?ker reviawe'd

7'39

 

the 631 text messages (.Baekaer 31-2-85} The-greater weight af the evidenrza- guppy: 1115 the

?ndilng mat District admf?l?s?tra?tars-naver asked Hanna-HG see texts;

34-. B?wden and 399%? f?vi?w texts with June i3. 2:315

Beaker anti Human met with Mau??hy an June 291.9 E: mwlew'fhe 1926:3333:
they Were-preservgd .cjm persona! phanet. Eaeker: testified that fhe ravi?w was
Undertakan tn Mammy had pfeserved the texts. They alsc we: ?ied it; sae'ihe
tam-#3133, arid phat?us sit-11:3 they were mt diaplay?e?d ran {the previded-by the 
Bawdert,. Beaker am! rammed ail 6f the waits.

Bmwdan testi?ed that in his review a? ?413 "@315, he (B?Wden) d?i? :nza't find anyifhi?g
that led: him in bail?ve mat fMau?sby-was engaging- In behavlar-that can]?! reasgnany-be
hiareeived by Esmer- as: semi ?arassmant :51? ?513 .creatian- 9f 3 ma?a wark an?mnm?en?t
(Bawde? . BaWd?eir: Waugh: and B??h?r wer? bath in
?their message?s: haweu?r. Stamen- ac?mwredg?dshilaq?sby shim-16 ha'va b?-erts the {Sinai fa
get ??113 parameters in their communicatimns and' mlatians hip owd?n 

an?e??ddregs?d i?n June 13,_ facused an
the item: ihat {31.211133 the taxi magsage?s were sent-nutsii?e 26f abuz?i?ess hams, me at. highfz,
from Mau?sby?s pm?anaiphnna (Bee-Ice? 36-, ngda? 1144-1-15} Bawdan 35km 
ab?uHh-e Mammy-told Hawaiian; he did not
understand haw 36mm caum'??nd the text tabs: fhreatenihg, Mamisby said
his text Was ?ini?naec} ti: be a maple if! the Af??ca??nje?nfa'n cam?mmty

uma?y an Mark fhr?ug h- {aw anfercama?t 11-1-4 1.53}.

130

EEWEIEH arid-Beaker did 'ncjt?seem it) ariderstarid .31 1?9an
aokn?mfledgie that many-pf his feat-19 were 'i?gagzprep?aie {B?eker 3.6496,, 1?93?
51.1. did. natasejem 11:; un?eastand? trier gravity nf the sft?ati?am 'ln 

Emph-aSized that the 15330 fsund he dint! naming warm-rig: (Beek?r EMS).

.35.. Biatrigt raceiVes'. Banners EEGE ?ha?ga June 17 213?129"
EEGE- Gharge ?Exhib?2} En Ju?ei 16., 2019;. Bannar testi?ad that

ratfha?ugh she Eat ELEM: the narrative. In EXhlbiit 'thE-Gharg'e' carr?c?y r?a?eatah'er

claim ai'hat sexually hamss?d Ear and retaliated against hen. ?Eanner testified

that shie- pram-DUE)! fatal- B?w?m air-tel Haraycla 23mm all the inal?dan-tadiscussed in ihe

?harge gamer-[1f fur Eamm??t that 116',- Wauld mt the: {Bi?hn?r 1793-?

may. District admt?isiratfah hm: TEc?e?iV? tha- EEOC Shame- un?l M-Endayr. {lune 

Ems-(Harayda 12241333.;

ESE Admtnish'atqrs meet ta a?Ju ?ieii?, 2-012

?n M?nday'dune- 253951, matwvih $136an discuss- haw the? ?ilstrict
sh?uld meVe f?maf?d aft?r rEaEimhg the 'Gnr'rtplajini: Ew?en ?eld Sprinkle he. .dia
mat tht?k Maultsiay sun-1H b3: E?ac?va g? the allegations .3116! ?the investigation
Iowdentesti?ed that he made. the decision ta place-Mauksby on aleave of
raiagsenne after. seef?g far ih'e: ?5.31? ihe ?rst. :a?n aligga't?lan. 1'21.- fne- EEOC- Bha?rge' ihaf
Mault?sby usea graphic: S'Exual: lanQuagE and E??r raiding {he "taxi their

E??f?tly again War {he threearjay @5491).

 

IS The: ?n arr-awe in the Eh??rge was minted tar-13.12 EEOE Ewen-?tam after 
31

Bowden id?ntiffed the gpeci?c allagatioms. in the aharga that ware ?ew tn
him, Firs-t Euwden. testi?ed was? natm?ca'Lii?crusly aware-mm Mau?stzy had-allegedly
vawed ta- jg'et rid ari- ample-yea and ?had {gammenfad he Maid mg: hen Secnnd,
Bremen was?nataware the ali'egatiem that? 'tizl? Banner that? he was ?eas!-
ln bad." a?d maid havfe a particular *emplayee?a ?ass climbing 31:3 wall?, Thirc?l, ngden;
did hm kh?ew that. .M?uitsby mde a cbmmer?tt ?i?rectly't?q?a??ar ihaf her buy maid? ?wri-
was?; teamied. that: gf haikad .knaw? ti? t'?h'ras? three items an April; 16,2319,
he wmld?hav? immediately-glaced {in a leave ?ab-sends (Howrah 118-4181).

Dr: Jane. 17'. 7231.9 Sprinkle aghadi Haray?a it} prepare a. tatter- fm ?Emma?s
signature ?lacsi?g MEu-ltaby an an administrative: leava- uf absence (71311}; Haray?a
prapared the lzett?r. T?a letter is dated June 18.3619;

611 ihe .3ff?rna?z?- 13? June "2:319, B?v?d?h had :a meeting wft? 3am: it?: Which
?g infatm?g? her -that he was gn?i?g piace Maui??army an. .lEave?. They discussed ifh'?
maria-is strategy- and? fEha :?pr?para?an a? .anmihe'r media statement
{Beaker 52?941). Beaker bfegan mas-paring #513 media atatemen?t: and ?Talking' paints? f?r
?nm??nm it: addrassing the} sum: ?Board ?in {he June 18, ?2019meetmg :Eeakar
Wahied in answer that "Bewa?n?s taik?i?n?g- :wnsia'tentwith il?fE media staiemeni-
aha p?ianned 12:: release- ?aming. the guard mazeting' (Beaker 9.51}. Seeker mt

share the waft =6r?na?z?ead varsibh Inf-ma media statem'?nt wit-1'1 Banner (Beaker '1 ?334] 04),

B'owder-i pfaces maui?by admi?iatra??ve heave #Jmi-? TE 21MB
Hawaiian trialled Mauitaby an themar?ing {if June 26-19-1319? him he 

malt! rm? be presenting af?ne Schmi- .Bo?ardmeatihg that evening baggage tha??isf?qt

32'

renewed ?ame-He. Eharge writ-eh Maulieby :11? using graphic: segue!
language {Between 1215.122}, Bquen teld Maultebyte ge heme; hater that e?emeen
Sprinkle end Bewdieh phened Maulteby fb :fteu himihet-?he et?hfelly?hh a paid ?leave ef
absentee handing the hanclue?ion hf the ihueetige?tion. {Ehwtte'ih #22, M?eultsw 115-1713).

Serihhle testi?ed that hie-meet: Seemed alarmed and hheetl but eei?c'li he unhersteed;

{sprinkle 59)

3?13; .Bewdeh briefs Edam; media statement is releasede June 13, 3613.
A5 ~hart; ef the :SuperintehdehEehEmafke, Eewden preview en. update in: the.
Seheet Beard hn'the inVeetigetien?using thetelking pain-ts that Seeker prepared fe?rhfm;
re the June. 1th! 2619 Echoes}; Beard meeting. .361de eteted:
iefere t-eerzeieefe-Ihe the wentzfe sperm .e
ee?pfe .mhmehi?e ehh hedrESs thereuhnt?.epmhleihhthet has. been made by
eh empteyee made ageing Jeff mayhem the ?shed ?fhh?fet's? chief
Qperetfhg When wen?t yen to? knew- fhet I ?rst learned ef the initial
et-Ie?geifene In a meeting with the eemelefneht Ant! eerien was
iekfen re easeme- the ehneeme the? had been eemmuhihered
Felfew eh meetings Were efse heid mefeeifte?teeneme'tha??hh issues were
being addressed. he ea?y M354 ehefher meeting was held In Mish-
ae?ddi?'eneleliege?bhe were made. by fhe same hemptelhent. z?h eddi?eh ta
:hew-e?egetiehs a written canepieiht wee family made eheyt'me and
handlihgef?theueituatien. h-hecerhe

immeelateiy ep?areht heat see peteii?ee fewetigetioh wee needed it) manage

the sits atsgaiibns psi farth .41st WW dasurss?nfsifsn

mgardfiftg thesis c?na'stm wersr-brsag?r ts th? Wilda! district mats ?lsd

with {its $h'eriff?s ??itte. And ms mseivst?. Word that an EEOC

samsisint had sits been-?led.

In tota/im this s?sgsrioss are-muss swarm: than they were back in

April fasterda?m ?3130 teamed .Qti?slde inusstigatort?at it will be

make baf?e: a A?ps?zsbmit thsse Bantams {if

the severity affirms news?aga?sns and tits 

isvss?ga?sn; mso'?- the this msming Jeff 

tm Isa-vs- sffac?vs imm?diafsm He had alt-EM}! ?tter!

tern-raved tam Iris and ?rst; Was watt among staff wit-t

.-isis is Pisass ?sts {?at due 1% the 

Maids there ?lm swam? statutss in may the-ssh aatldisfsist mam

twists about the invss?gstion; We a?pm?f?fe yam

that-the 35mm Dts?ist 17596152 ssn?titis? this
mattsi: 

At the suits Ethos} Esardfmegeting Eowden summarised-that. he.
appointed its. the Acting chisf?psratingattest. as Junie 11$; 213.13 at 
:DiStriot titleassd the: mess stateme?t: Smitty Smasts Citi?f 
affissr sec? [sate

the visas ?fths ass 13, Stats. Esther-
BaWd??ni's resort is; the Board was misleading. Banner fh?ughi it was

disingenu?us far Bis-wasn? to suggest that ha. assisted it: plans cm a taste sf

'34

absence hazard on racemly?amuired ii?fcinnaftion. Ban-tier testified ihat?amien kn?w an
the Ecritiical 31mg befara he tankae?an {Banner 201?262).

?We greater-weight 11f- the ev'ide?ca syggest's mat B?wden 1111511 shaul'd have
mm thathis ramarks about-11113 investigation (as? rimmed abava} were mt amp-lately:
acdurata arid. amid be mi?sI?eadI?ngI t?pem?c?a?y, B'deen 01-13mm have 11mm that:
1113. Bis-trim: had ?uff taken Imma?iai? ?aps it: affective]? acid regs 'anuitsby?s aiIe'ged
?omtunt aft?r it was: ?nanced. in?ia?rif. The greater Weigh? 1111* the avidence sgpporta the
?ndalng 1.11:1 313111161 {biased 1I1e Eat-31m ?n mime- {if 1111131: 11? her specific: campliaints fang:

befare ?ma: de?isian was maria 111. place Maul?sbv a?iieave.

?39. {80:13:19 5; "Eardhen am? Du?bi?' are-awn haying [Ia-r111]: e- ?ugas?t' ?15, 2019?

Gardnermn?mer?n have some fet?einhmia an? text imitact with 301mm afterwa-
May 2E1 2-619 meeting at 11113 ESSCITA suffig?; ?ardhar said. she Was just. Ghecking ?311-
?B?ia?tie'r'is mllbeing. ?311 Augxwt 14, 2.1119! ?Gardner Etant a 1er 211561151 11111- If
everything; 111351311331. Emma; r?pliadm C5316 net?s; ?9th ?Th3; imesfigatidn is gg?ing 
me. have Eaten a mile .uvgmhelmed by things?g, I113: hay?? Gardner tried - to massure?
311111131: Gaming 19113: Samar-1111; twe?st?igation 111111115 be war sqqn. Qardngar invited
Samar-1:11 haw Innsb- With her and 'Dubi? 4:111 Aug U31 ?1 53,1 Banner 
?Tha?fsza-i 4mg r?ady? 1:1 give tip-andj'ustacrewfhis. Saunds?ggad?i i?ardner 59-32}.

Banner mat Gardner and sDuhI'n far Iuheh --at ?ametrics ragtaura?tat 1213315113 1111
:Auguat 35, 2319.. They Iii-d 11-111 diwass any sans-511% Iaimr relations tapics. The

:samer?eatibn was mag?g 321.34,; Bubi'n While Iheyware- having

as

 

 

Imam tgwe ampioyees, Cum-carat! and Ham 33% ism-ed at *5 Hal-3W E?h?e ?9
The were tab-[es waved at embanged gr?e?ngs (Gardner 3344, Eon-mar
sraa'ted: E31933. mama wither fable. amid Eaverhear ma .a?ther'zs
mHE/?fsation facmcaran 15}

Mar-lunar: rat Qemetrios, carci?zran-attenc?edan Assistam; Superihtendenfm?e?ng-
A: the ?rst! 31? the mma??ng. Gamma-n mentin?ad fha?t? she! saw-BMW? having; ?lL-I??h mm
Gardner ahd Sabin; ?11 333mm mid tia- E?armrans than: Emma's. a. mn?den'?al- ampl?ye?ei
Min-Id behavi?g lunch With Unim Iaad?ershlip while the Dis-trim was Eta: ?ne mid?te at
negbiia?ms 1-7-13}, The mitt: day, August 16, 202159;. Samar: ?916 Gam?ran
that he! was "Saving ask that th? scape inf the investiga??n ha? Expanded ?d?t?'Emme

what wig-the .U?itm played in. Runner?s. complaints. (ti-iamran: 15-21%

40. .?aWdeh asks. 1'13 i?q'uiria ?31359 Quinn?s raise @3135; ?g 201$

Em August. 161. 313?er Emma awaited Je?'er art Whit}?! he QQEBTEIEE Hardy
and the. sebum 13mm .. (exhibit uniting Elmer? andensaid that Banner ha??been seen
Juan-mag; ranch wlt? Gardner and. Dijbi? magma-15; 20.19.. 31:5de referenced the
Ballgame .BanQEEn-img?xgmament and that a matEnfg'h?ME'en a cch??en?ai?
tarnpleEE and, the :F?ite?ider?' and iEiji-Ect'or seemm' "E?ghiy units-Hal 
W??h review". Baw?an askedthat'the an E?guiiyinw.
Paige cf the 8Qfl-?A En ithe; armsa?om Ithaf were maria against him anti and
me?waiy Eating-xen- #:1533143 Shara her tori-cams $1;th Maul?sby'w?h him {Baw'd??iju Enwdah:

spe?i?c Epics thwg?t stigma he addressed in. the Expanded i?yas?ga?m.

 

cart-man is Assistant Sn?e??tanderit?f ECh'Iaf?Fl?anc?a! at?cer, Sim reports d??c?v Ham Sari is
?ne 'F?avmil: Si: :52er fur the 

3'5

 

 

 

Bunnamalges new 'allega't'io-n'a in f?spohse 'tn-Bowden?s ts?quest - Augzu??t
i7?, 29:19 . AH-?guathZD. 23:19

Amara-1?. 2.91519; Hanna?s ?mmsel, Safe emaiited a
latter SW1 ?ngli ?true Sch?pl Ewart] {Ex?ih? 4) il??fnml?g ith' that Eonnerwa-s ""SaddIhQ
a slain-a. a? mmIi?tiQn- and ha?tiia'Wq?kEnviro?rh?ni" al?ih?t the Sarasbia Gaunt}? 33mm
System, B?wde?n arid camera acting: c?m bar-131i. Eif?ckwe?il statedetihat amen};
August 5.31% :?Exhlh?it?j. seemed t6 suggest :a mnspir?QQy 1131mm
Banner and-ins 'Bfackwell stated that 'BaWden?3 letter requesting a prime mm the
rem?dnahlp "Banner and the ECU A had a. whining. effect? 931 Samar 'ia'?caua'e marrie-
associafed with the will haw avoid having, Bonner far feat: ?fhat may
will alsq-EJE r?t'aliat?ed against; The J?tter am stated ?im?anner ptanneel was a trait?
shim with this? EEGC ?tteging retaliatiqn and. hastlle wm?i agains?i Ema-en
and the. ?Strict.

August 123', 23129, Balm-Er filed "a new. tha?EE?G Blaming mane
wk envimnme'ht- a?d The allegati?n?s In Benn-aria EEOC. chatge are

ga'nsisteni wit?tha..ciaims Bauhaus? raised in thaAuguSt $2019 fatter;

42. Boha?l? Bqardlapprm'as Expanrding therifn?vestigatibnw August 26, 2.919

At the August 2H, 3' School Shara mating; Harri}; asked the scum Bea?rd? fer?
dirthim-?I c?rn .Bawdan? Banner"; ia-a'll? mpand {ha agape a? the invesfigafim The
semi. Baa?mi vated tn br?ade?n ?ngag?men't include. an ingestigatiqn inb-

Bbwdan?s SCITA 'influe?tad 6r 'lnt??ered Iwith ih?e i??r??Wgstigatidn {:Exhibit 3)

13?:

and Emits Emma's new aliagaiim?ns nihastile war-1k and .retaiiati?ogfi by Bowen

and the: Dis-triat- (Exhibit 

?43: Emmi glib-mite: arid Applicant B-iscrh?ina?o? anmpi?int" 
Maui-.1.- 26.; 213%
Gn- August :25. .2919? arid Hardy ah:

.

the alarm. that Emmi: was subjeaied Id addi?-?gma?l' {1531i} iv and af?liation ?as- a ream ?cif?
Miami requ?st i?hai pmh?- inta Banner? ?ammuniua??ns with the intim-
Auguat 26.2919 lettgr,. tBiacKW?ll :?al?n mad&- .3 "'whuiiy separatg and new retaliation and
Maine: wark zenvimnman?; claim" based, am the Jamaal: and several 3mm:
?amed? membara made ?aring .Einciicir after i113 EH. 2319' Seiiml Bcarti mafetirig;
ii?hese new ijlie?gatihiis have, :?eie?n data?jrmmed f0 be wraith The scape n?f SWPS:
Therafme, "this mport? doesi mt inciluizfe any findings is)? gammaiansas ta-
mmr?ents made at the August? 20', 201-9 mating ta sealants ?th'af: manned after tha

meeting

Vi. initaas?t'ig'ajt'ai?y 'Bm?lysibns.

After q?hside'r?ing ?the Sifidiemer and making of fad-1 1763311961
carmlusisbns using a ?preponderance standard; 'T?e?ie mhclu?ons are
maker) dawn to address the specific madam a? mammal emp?layees as $th re?laia in
Swiss overall ?findings am the Bistriet's actions. it she uidi be 'thaf there 137m:

indivtduai Ell'a'biilty- under Titie Vii hr the Fl-Drida Civil Rights" Mt ":Wha? an emp?layaae

?3

angage?s in diaer?imi?'atmy mnduzit while asking; an an lemg?nyws behalf; ?ability is

imputed 13:: the: emglayer.

A, 'T?era is suf?ci?m Widens-a ta wnciude? that Jeff- M-aui'tshy- Emails!"
harassed-:Gherama Batman! and thaw? ?reaf?? a h??tile mm envimnment

Th5- ievldanca and ma ?ndi?ga EspEQially when VieW?d c?lleaftv?iy, ?upp?r?t the

tannins-fan mat Maults'by used sexually abusive: aria vulgar tanguage and -:angaged in

verbal, Visual, and physical m?d??t?tt?ara Bannerihat unrea'sgih?bly infaarfet?dwith her
w?rkperfarmame' anti whic? aisb created an :in?r?-Idafina hostile; and bffensiv? wank
envira?f?ent. fini?s? that a reasan?ble person In Banne?r?s Nation. (a?m?inis?atiir'e
Mammy-Mum; M?au?sbgwa madam t6 be m'stile and? ?at-131w zprartiiau'l'a?y given; his
mgi?nn? as her bus-s- and ?113 District?s ?1013; 'SWli'?nds that 'M-au'ftsb'y eagaged In sexual:
harrassmenLE-n? he stated a hastiie 'wark. Bn?imment ?in vialation at "Kimmy 2:13;} and
Emmy-2233 ?alga ?i?l?t?d the afi?i?rgeipias nf *P-r?f?agi??al 'Qandu?t fairJSuppaprt

Eta? by- faillng ta? remesant the. Eistriat In a past?ye and professional manner:

E, Them isrsuffiniant conclude" thatJeifE tr:

retaliat? agamg?t aha-aim 39:15:13? iarvrapvming hammer-.119.

?rst uge?dil?ia-tzihrasa ?sh?i'tchesgat stitches?! aim Banner gamma-Med that
she Was gearing. instant raport-ing him. fali?we? up w?h his "isriltdhe's 9&1 stitches?
text 118,126-19 whiqh a?a?c?hed 22 ?ights; a .di?sstur'bmg .naWsartisl?e about the: murtf?e
of awnis?ehlower tn Smith Afrksa; I-t'wag masanabie far Banner its: interpret 

ma?a!- and taxi- c?ommu?icati?ns. ta meain?m? amid-be. physical ?ghsiequence's if she?

39-

repartad him? it waaireasznnable far Banner-1:: b-ecbr??: mare dancemad: amat- he: gal-fay
leamm that Ma?lisl?y WW she c?mpI?ainaam B?wden.

Manna-by- Vic?ated Penny 279 in hi2 #3er anti Text "'snitoh?s get stitnha?f?
aammuni?a?ms? with agrarian Raiiw 2.70. f?rmme?i?g 
bullying: tithe!? "?m?lweasa Bullying i3: Madly ?e?ned under ?a?gy 2.7a to made.
"unWar?aat and repeatgti 'written.. ve'rb?a'lvar ?p?ygi?al ?hahaw'or including any?thmaien?ing;
inserigltim {31* Adahumaniixlng that IE aware ar-perv?asiva .3513th in ma?a- my.
i??midatihQ-j ?'?sme ?r affensiVEs-educa?m?al eh?ifir?t-imem Er m?f rims-lea!
harm 1?53 3?h05? mph-yea?. ?haying? fia?tuties madam mat is threatening er
M?f?id'atirigz,

M?ul?by?. .B'Gwdiem anti Htara'srda were? wring ta. d?iscbuni the $eria1usnes$ sf.
marsh ?13, 2mg taxi. Thafa?f {hat Emma!? had mat yet reamed 
misca?d-uct mi?se?a thia pariah Whai i8;- that-.a-reascnabla ?rmware-e: ?it-Bij?n?t?s
"lawman-gram #2356n'? Elly Egret-1% "a?a?cie and her $3632? written and wards; as
a threat that 55116 might he, paystcaily harmed-m the ?Emma if and When she rapurteu
Wacenduct. Bonner reasgngably iael?i?'v?ed that the; threat of. ma?a-rim was:

a?tii'raiied when: Mau??by warned-that Banner actually ma?a-campiairn?tsa about-11km

a: T??r?e is?suf?cia?ta?videm? it: ?b??lud?that; Di: ?Tania? Buwd?n?s .acti?ans-
waged a prim-m? WE In ?fe .letri?'t?s' failure 126 pr?mp?y arid 
address Runner?s: ?lavim's 5? s?xijal ?arassmieat, mastiie wart: anviranmant,

retaliatian, and thraat?ning behaving



Bmwden- 51: :me had a --du1y' '15 In discriminatin-
an? sexual haias?smem 115 21-150 had. :a duty under-63:13 61' Prufessiicn?l Evndust'f?r 1115
51115511311 Erafessian in such 53 Banner are; mutt-2:513:17
Tram s?xufal harassment. Bewaen'knewarsmawd' have know-111511116 13315111511151! a duty
under-1565M 51111 state-law 1:1 1111155119315 empiay??. ?gmlaints 51155111151harassment-and
15 take brain-pt and "51155113115 53113511115 aeti'am

8W1 5m 5151155 that 85:de 511 did r151take-prompmrappraamiatie steps :5 investigati?
Emma's anMp?laln?ts, "121111111111- 1212-51515115kar-m iB-awssian that mere- was ?5 15155115151.
5551;315:1111 agaihstMa-ults by 1111511155656 {his immediate attain-1151:1395 Ban-Idem was 111.19- 11151
administrator ?5 havezact?ual antics that 8511115: had serious rad-mama abgut the ?31303
5511111151.. (in: ril 1-21 2319'. 85111113511 pra-missd 35111151 51nd Zu?k?rfhat he? wauld 5151 an
the 11115195151155 and 951? bar's-1515 Hanna-r Within 1W6 weeks. 115115551, 1115 5111:: 55115::
B?owden ta??wm?m that mama-5k 951155 1115351011515 5- meeting- with 11.115111151193111: which:
1115 shared 1115112195113;- 51? [11151111515113 accuaar (Banner) 55 11151155; har- speaifi?c ajlle'gatibns
(which 3.511555 115121 5135511155115; 15515:: him 1151: 1:9 5115621536).- did 13511151113! 5r
@5551sz ?apartment, It 15113.1( 5 55.55115 me??ng 17-11115;th by
Easier May 5-, 2111-9 before amide-n ??cid?ed 15 fun: the {?atter- War 15 Ha man-
R??oumiefs ta- ma?agei Dr: May Bh?vczlen left 35111151 1113151155 1155915555 in-
rep?'at he: story 15 15153113311135 Biawden d?rd nativity b-riaf' Haraiyda (in his and May

311155111193 With gamer.

 

51' Bonn-12mm 5115515555! 115: cante?ras =15. maker. Asa 351155} 355551 1113131151; Zugkar had limited intake
5511551. ?unk-5r acted 51.313115911315111 under tha?mumstancesniucke;155k Bonmar?mmstiarns s?erlnu's by; $115-
ma??gr?ged 55555;th repart- ?e?mn??rm' directly-15 'tihesuner?inten de?nt. 15515515155 195111513511. herself-1:6
131-1511131115 an ?ni?entl?ea Employee ?ad ?5115,ng aha at 1:115 1:55 What?: 5am: 135111111311 
appm?i Baw?en duet-1.115211 cke'r. Gamma-1121911651 111:: W111: '8qu an arm 1.1111111, ar 15 5115115 that 355558.;
5551551115 

91

?I;t"was andenwha d?ecidad fhat-Bannar?s wacauld be invastigatad by an
iht?mal- investigation ma undar Pol Icy 2 .4722-1 misbyan ?UiSidE Bawd?an
appainted ?fmseif as. this il?ader fe?' the {investiga?gn committee.- gBawden sheuld have.
?raco'gni'zad that he shauld Riemann the investiga?an .{a?rhmi?eje anti egrta-inl'y 
n-eE an! as-fit?s-Iaad?n Bowen had-hat training? ?le-z: serve arm-2n investigation-
awrymiftee. H2 was mt independent at ragi?C?ived. by :othsr '?i?sgtnici: be
J?dapend?m, 32de ans! were :friends and were it: h?Ve Ea?hhi??m
backs. ngclen was .nnt-ubfactive qr gamma: by Biker listrim emplayeas it; be abjectiuei
Bowden-was Ea. patential Mthass. in tha inaveatigatiun bacausE hehad already dfaaussed
the matters under limemtga?an ?iractl?w?h Bonnerancj Mauliisby, Additiimnally; BaWdan
in}: a in Wading litigati?n inyalvmg alf?-Q?a?gns that he; ?Sammy harassed;
.an?i retaifa'ted againaf: a Eli-atria amp-layers,

Bbwd'e? aim-$31126 {m take, ?r??i?ta?d-E?ec?ve actiqn- ta ?pr?ieict the parties'fa this
i?ves?gat?ia?, is: preserve exii?f?i'eneai anti 1% {air-want ?ratal?iia??rm gimp-9123 tam-s: 123? {ha
Investigation. H215 kn?w abaut get Stit?h?si?t?ext 
ea?y? as May 2619. He knew that owner was ?amers-led ab?t? reta?liatinri. Ey'M'ay 
2019.- BaWden kha at fsh?ul? have kn-a-?wn t?hatf??r?me?r?had?expressed a pTESe?t fear-?r
he: safety arid the safety in? hf?r family._ ngeven. it ?02k. u??f May i242, 2319 far
lam/den it: fake: any steps. separate Emu-near and Maultgi?y;

Bowdxews: plan tu- @??irzze tapes-attentis after 'Mauitsby's ralshp??on left
awn-net: with Veg little work Eta dot and anti ma ta;- ivap?rt i3; Banner fighifuliyfen- 11KB aha
had been mapped of Her dutl?s while to perfarm his; M: as usual,

tawny alsd m?tinuad tn-faar-fcir her safety because had -'Uh?a?erect amass ta-

9'2

 

1313 third ?aor where she WDFKEG. 1=nt?rim Qp?ratibnal 1.3133 Bquse'd ?f'strict
?3 all-$9335 ?3 31?; 11- ad stem amt-Ema. against Ba mar in? retal?iaiim far but gamma: ning
am?? Sax-Um ?imlminatian ant] ratalratio-n, It was. ms:- mil June 1-3., 2619
that BQWci?m ?nally made-$116. ?atisim-t?: r?e?mwe Mau?sby'fram i116 mrkpia??e-?by 

him can?a Tfeaiva cf alias-ma.

E1. Them lg .s?uffigli?m evidenee to adntl?ude ?that?lfr?d .Harana?? mamas
.pigye? a seawdaw mtg- in =thg District'sifailura and zade-icg-Lfaieiy
Gh?e?rairia Baum-?3 maimg 5536:! ?hga'ras'shmn? h?g?le wart;
:?nvl'm?mezm rataliaticine. and ?amat?i?iaag behaving.

Beirare a?dregs'ing de?cienciea in Harayda?s ha'n?ll?ng tiff Samaria @?rr?ijpiai?t?-is
impurta ta mate that Haray'da .plgyed?a rala?v?ly rare in the Histt?iefs ia-
Bm-?mer?? Gumglaln'ts against Mau?sbya. Ll?? un'ai?s'p uifedi??i Hamel 3: did knoWabczut
Egan?n?eria aena?m?-A-baf?r?e Bowd'e'n hr?ught' Emmi- to the Human?as'?um?s am: an
May-113., 2:119; Evan than; Harayda EH6 mt backgraunei m? tannerisso?r?pjamt
bacauae E?Wda'? rigid ?at share the ?ll? hi$tn?y with. him. if is also B'n?l??p?ied fhatjt Was
Bowcf?n, mt Hmyda, Who ?ailed *the ski-?35? as far as dateimin?ing Whether th?
invastigaffqn- Wtiul?f be .?am?ed intar?ally a: externally; It; was 315:: E?wti?n why-
=dete??2?nted whether i113 twpiail?t-mui? be investigated under Pang}! 2.713 gr 12,322.; wha-
{same an the: invastigati?on b?r?m?iiae. and w?aih'ar Bonner Was {Equirad'w submit
:a writtan citscriminatiun claim farm Qbefcre; being T?mwl?wael by the investigation

cam-mime? Bawden, mt Hawaii was. mama-.15: respon?iilafar deciding whether?intg?m

93-

magmas Wmuld be iak?n: dusting; the i'nvest?lgatim and the specifics: :31? Emma. jab-
ass?ignme?tia??er Miau?sby was placed ma- Jamie,

Nanetheieissi reccgnizas- the at? Hawycia?b role: As the 3?Emp:layea
?ela?ans Admsimstramn Harajytia :s??cruld have a geared wanking Knawl?d?ga a?f- t'h'a law,
twat-r.F paltt?es, sand ?rmwares that gnvern iamplay?ee; ?a?d'uct. He is if! be 
subject. matte]? expert ci'm f?e infarpretatian and implemanta?bn :n'f Bistri?t pagan-net
He ?13 ah?argad and nita?seeing? all 'i'?viastjgatiohs far? Itha District.

Hzarayda was {as {a address Bn??er'? {ungai?g
can?ems a??r May TEL 21:31:79. Unfa-rtunately, Harayda?s wmmuninaflanfs with Emma are
nbt'a m?md?l'm?: clarity. lt-iaz?Bastha- undiarstand why-Ian?er?wauld be; manned by Harayd afar
may ?153: "261-9: phcne barf anncpuvneirng. invezst'igat'iian Hf :har maid
.mne?d under Pulley 21.552 With Roman slanting; ag the lead investigatar' ET the. intamali
investigation Samar-was caning?! ?bacauge calyx-days before,- (i?i?'ue May (to!
.2959 meeti?g}, She warmer) and C??ray explaiinad to. Hara'yda the many F?asms why

Bonner was. net s?n??r?iable, With an internai fwe??a? Banner am?! Graytes'ti?ed? that
?Har?ayida adknuWi??ged; Bat-mfg smegma, rim May 23139 and said he Awamd-
recammvan?f an. [haependar-tt, external lnv?eatiga'tid?n; in an email Vs?nt anaran "May
22351-9, Haraydasdr?sawwed that Fianna? had n?ne?rnssabaut the? investigaiiah
gmagess: "?fa-u mid me? y?u'wara camfcmablie?wnh the inVeStigationf

H'aray?ta ale-a gav? Ber-1:13! ?gn?a?di?tom in?armation an mamas When and what
E??ner ta dc: ta presentshemmiplaints. B?fn??r iefttha meeting; a?'is?ay- 2m
w?h this; um tier-standing ihat snehad giv?? Harayda a naug? ii?farrnatfmfar F1311 than mead

with me i?vestigati?n. and that aha? did net- need. ta? present anything in writing until later!

94-

   
 



  

momma-10w

mun-mm 
non-mus mums-lumen". 

    



hum--em
.m --
mural-u madman.

1960mm mam. um

    

v- maid 

1 first: 411mm ham
11"" MIMIAllah-mud.

mudwu: 
MinuthJao-m 

Ann-&lt;