0
0
0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 1 of 11

1234563721468394
46938194 1 43 
7 43
 
 345636
946 238194 1 43
 3 6229   
21
3
3
        0         0  !" !#$0   0 )00
)00
0
0 %&0
)0 *%*+0 ,-*./0!.&00)123  312440
0
)00
'     (0 &0'    00
)0
0

 86 3
3
 !"0!5'$0-6*708888809:;0.<088888888888888888888888888888$00=1>$0?@./0
,./7*9AB:-*./0.<0 6B*%A7-0 @A,*:+-;0 ?/9*/C$0   D70EF 6B*%A7-GH0 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0
 ./-AI@-$0*-0*705 "   "0:70<.++.J7)0
1&K "A<A/9:/-0'*++*:I0 &0'6*-A0EF'6*-AGH0*70*/0,./-AI@-0.<0-6*70 .?B-D705B9AB0.<0
L?+;01$00=1>0E-6A0FL?+;01$00=1>05B9ABGH&0
0&K '6*-A0*705 "   "0-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0M;011)N>0@&I&0./0-6A0
7A,./90M?7*/A7709:;0<.++.J*/C0A/-B;0.<0-6*70.B9AB&00 .B0A%AB;07?M7AO?A/-09:;0-6:-0'6*-A0<:*+70-.0
,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB$06A076:++0@:;0:0<*/A0.<0PN==&==0@AB09:;0-.0-6A0/*-A90 -:-A70
"*7-B*,-0 .?B-0<.B0-6A0 :7-AB/0"*7-B*,-0.<0 A//7;+%:/*:&000
Q&K /+A770:/90?/-*+0'6*-A0,.I@+*A70J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB$0:/;0M:/R$0<*/:/,*:+$0
.B0MB.RAB:CA0*/7-*-?-*./0.B0.-6AB0@AB7./0.B0A/-*-;06.+9*/C0:/;0<?/97$07A,?B*-*A7$0.B0.-6AB0:77A-70*/0
-6A0/:IA0.<$0<.B0-6A0MA/A<*-0.<$0.B0?/9AB0-6A09*BA,-0.B0*/9*BA,-0,./-B.+0.<0'6*-A$076:++06.+90:/90
BA-:*/0J*-6*/0-6A*B0,./-B.+0:/90@B.6*M*-0-6A0J*-69B:J:+$0BAI.%:+$0-B:/7<AB$0.B0.-6AB09*7@.7:+0.<0:/;0
7?,60<?/970.B0.-6AB0:77A-70.<0'6*-A&000
S&K /+A770:/90?/-*+0'6*-A0,.I@+*A70J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB$0'6*-A076:++0MA0
@B.6*M*-A90<B.I0I:R*/C0:/;0/./3IA9*,:+0AT@A/9*-?BA70*/0AT,A770.<0PN==0J*-6.?-0 .?B-0:@@B.%:+&0
0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 2 of 11

N&K  70:07:/,-*./$0'6*-A076:++0@:;0-.0 6B*%A7-0*-70<AA70:/90,.7-70*/0,.//A,-*./0J*-60-6A0
@BA@:B:-*./$0<*+*/C$0:/90@?B7?*-0.<0-6A0 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0 ./-AI@-&00 6B*%A7-076:++07?MI*-0:0
"A,+:B:-*./0.<0 .?/7A+0 AA70:/90 .7-70J*-6*/0-A/0E1=H09:;70.<0-6*705B9AB$0:/90'6*-A076:++0@:;0-.0
 6B*%A7-0*-70<AA70:/90,.7-70J*-6*/0-A/0E1=H09:;70.<0-6A0<*+*/C0.<0-6A0"A,+:B:-*./0.<0 .?/7A+0 AA70
:/90 .7-7&0
U&K '6*-A0I:;0:@@+;0-.0-6A0 .?B-0-.0I.9*<;0-6A0-ABI70.<0-6*705B9AB0*/0-6A0A%A/-0.<0:0
IA9*,:+0/A,A77*-;0.B0IA9*,:+06:B976*@&0
V 0   0 5   )0
0
0
8888888888888888888888888888888888880
V 5" $0L&0 0
0

0

0

00

 0
0
0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 3 of 11

1234563721468394
46938194 1 43 
7 43
 
 345636
946 238194 1 43
 3 6229   
21
3
3
        0         0  !" !#$0   0 )00
)00
0
0 %&0
)0 *%*+0 ,-*./0!.&00)123  312440
0
)00
'     (0 &0'    00
)0
0
45 1 694W936X6 Y62  3X
41
23 
 3 
246X 43
 6B*%A7-0 @A,*:+-;0 ?/9*/C$0   0EF 6B*%A7-GH0BA7@A,-<?++;0I.%A70-6*70 .?B-0-.06.+90
'*++*:I0 &0'6*-A0*/0,./-AI@-0.<0 .?B-0<.B0<:*+?BA0-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0 .?B-D70L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0
,./<*BI*/C0-6A0 IABCA/,;0 BM*-B:-.BD70*/-AB*I0:J:B90.<0AIABCA/,;0BA+*A<0M;0A/-AB*/C0:/05B9AB0
*/0-6A0<.BI0@B.@.7A9&00 /07?@@.B-0-6ABA.<$0 6B*%A7-0BA+*A70?@./0:/90*/,.B@.B:-A70M;0BA<ABA/,A0-6A0
:,,.I@:/;*/C0(AI.B:/9?I0.<0 :J&0
 A7@A,-<?++;07?MI*--A9$00
0
Z7Z0 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA00 0 0 0
 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA0
 B*,0 &0 AA9$0 7O?*BA0
 5[0 5       "0   0
0===0(:BRA-0 -BAA-\0=-60 +..B0
 6*+:9A+@6*:$0  01>1=Q0
E01NH00>>302NS0
E01NH00>>301N=0E<:,7*I*+AH0
]^^_`abcdef_`egh`ijbd^eklbmino^cepqariasteuuve
0
":-A9)00L?+;0>$00=1>00
e

0

 0
0
0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 4 of 11

1234563721468394
46938194 1 43 
7 43
 
 345636
946 238194 1 43
 3 6229   
21
3
3
        0         0  !" !#$0   0 )00
)00
0
0 %&0
)0 *%*+0 ,-*./0!.&00)123  312440
0
)00
'     (0 &0'    00
)0
0
45 1 694W93X6X
 
287X3
 3 
w312397  
 43
 314933
6X6 Y62  3X
41
23 
 3 
246X 43
3
3  6B*%A7-0 @A,*:+-;0 ?/9*/C$0   0EF 6B*%A7-GH07?MI*-70-6*70IAI.B:/9?I0.<0+:J0*/0
7?@@.B-0.<0*-70 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0 ./-AI@-$0J6*,607AAR70-.06.+90'*++*:I0 &0'6*-A0EF'6*-AGH0
*/0,./-AI@-0.<0 .?B-0MA,:?7A0'6*-A06:70<:*+A90-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0 .?B-D70L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0
,./<*BI*/C0-6A0 IABCA/,;0 BM*-B:-.BD70*/-AB*I0:J:B90.<0AIABCA/,;0BA+*A<0E   0!.&00NH0E-6A0
FL?+;01$00=1>05B9ABGH&0
1x3 y
 zY 
7283
283 6 6 
243 
 490
 6B*%A7-0:/90'6*-A0:BA0@:B-*A70-.0:/0 CBAAIA/-0J6ABAM;$0*/0"A,AIMAB00=1U$0 6B*%A7-0
@B.%*9A90'6*-A0J*-60:0PN==$===0:9%:/,A0./06*70@.-A/-*:+0BA,.%AB;0*/0-6A0!  0 ./,?77*./0
 *-*C:-*./&00 AA0 CBAAIA/-0E   0!.&013Q$0 T6*M*-0 H&00'6*-A06:70<:*+A90-.06./.B0-6A*B0
 CBAAIA/-&00 .09:-A$09A7@*-A06:%*/C0-6A0?7A0:/90A/{.;IA/-0.<0 6B*%A7-D70:9%:/,A0<.B0I.BA0-6:/0
-J.0:/90:06:+<0;A:B70:/90BA,A*%*/C0:0PQ&N0I*++*./0:J:B90*/0-6A0!  0 ./,?77*./0 *-*C:-*./0
-B*CCAB*/C06*70@:;IA/-0.M+*C:-*./7$0'6*-A06:70/.-0@:*90 6B*%A7-0:/;-6*/C&00
 6A0I:--AB0MA<.BA0-6A0 .?B-0BA+:-A70-.0:/0*/{?/,-*./0*77?A90M;0 IABCA/,;0 BM*-B:-.B0 ./&0
 -A@6A/0 &0 +:--0E A-&H0:/90,./<*BIA90*/0-6A0 .?B-D70L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB\/:IA+;$0:/0*/{?/,-*./0
9*BA,-*/C0-6:-0'6*-A0A7,B.J0<?/970@A/9*/C0BA7.+?-*./0.<0-6A0:BM*-B:-*./0./0-6A0IAB*-7&005/0L?/A0S$0
0=1>$0L?9CA0 +:--0*77?A90:0"A-ABI*/:-*./0:/90 J:B90E-6A0F"A-ABI*/:-*./GH0:/90:/0 /-AB*I0
 J:B90.<0 IABCA/,;0 A+*A<0E-6A0F J:B9GH0<*/9*/C0-6:-0F-6ABA0*70:07-B./C0+*RA+*6..90-6:-0
  6B*%A7-}0J*++0@BA%:*+0./0-6A0IAB*-70.<0-6*70,:7A0:/90-6:-0 6B*%A7-D70 CBAAIA/-0J*-60 '6*-A}0J*++0
0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 5 of 11

MA0A/<.B,A90@?B7?:/-0-.0-6A0-ABI70,./-:*/A90-6ABA*/&G0E   0!.&001$0 T6*M*-0V0:-014H&00 ?B-6AB$0
L?9CA0 +:--0AT@+:*/A9$0 6B*%A7-0F6:709AI./7-B:-A90:0BA:+0+*RA+*6..90-6:-0-6A07A--+AIA/-0<?/970
9*7-B*M?-A90-.0(B&0'6*-A0:BA0*/09:/CAB0.<0MA*/C09*77*@:-A9$0*<0/.-0:+BA:9;09*77*@:-A9$07?,60-6:-0
  6B*%A7-}0J*++0MA0?/:M+A$0*<07?,,A77<?+0./0-6A0IAB*-7$0-.0,.++A,-0-6A0I./A;0.JA90*-0@?B7?:/-0-.0-6A0
 CBAAIA/-&G00 9&00 ,,.B9*/C+;$0L?9CA0 +:--0*77?A90-6A0 J:B9$09*BA,-*/C0'6*-A0-.0A7,B.J0
P1$0N=$===0F*/-.0-6A0-B?7-0:,,.?/-0.<06*70:--.B/A;$0 .MAB-0 &0'..9$0 7O&0~0@A/9*/C0:/907?M{A,-0
-.0:0 */:+0 J:B9$0<?B-6AB0.B9AB0.<0-6A0:BM*-B:-.B$0.B0JB*--A/0:CBAAIA/-07*C/A90M;0-6A0@:B-*A7&G00
E   0!.&001$0 T6*M*-0 H&000
'6*-A09*90/.-0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0 J:B90:/9$0./0L?/A011$00=1>$0'6*-AD70,.?/7A+0,./<*BIA90
-6:-0'6*-A0,./-A7-A90-6A0 J:B90:/90   D70:?-6.B*-;0-.0*77?A0*-&00 ,,.B9*/C+;$0 6B*%A7-0<*+A90:/0
 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0-.0 ./<*BI0 BM*-B:-*./0 J:B9$07AAR*/C0-.0,./<*BI0-6A0 J:B90:70JA++0:70-.0
,.I@A+0:BM*-B:-*./&00E   0!.&001H&00 /0BA7@./7A$0'6*-A07.?C6-0-.0%:,:-A0-6A0 J:B9&00E   0!.&0
0SH&005/0L?+;01$00=1>$0-6A0 .?B-0,./<*BIA90-6A0 J:B90:/909A/*A90'6*-AD70:@@+*,:-*./0-.0%:,:-A0
*/0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&00E   0!.&00NH&000
5/0L?+;00$00=1>$0 6B*%A7-0JB.-A0-.0'6*-AD70:--.B/A;0BAO?A7-*/C0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0L?+;0
1$00=1>05B9AB0M;0/.0+:-AB0-6:/0-6A0,+.7A0.<0M?7*/A770./0L?+;0N$00=1>&00 .09:-A$0'6*-A06:70/.-0
,.I@+*A90J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0M;0A7,B.J*/C0P1$0N=$===&==0*/06*70:--.B/A;D70-B?7-0:,,.?/-$0
/.B06:706*70:--.B/A;0@B.%*9A90,./<*BI:-*./0-6:-0'6*-A06:707.0,.I@+*A90.B0-6:-0'6*-A0J*++0,.I@+;0
*<0:<<.B9A90:99*-*./:+0-*IA&0
11x3 
 Y7X6243
 6A0 .?B-076.?+906.+90'6*-A0*/0,*%*+0,./-AI@-0:/90*77?A0:@@B.@B*:-A07:/,-*./70MA,:?7A0*-0
*70?/9*7@?-A90-6:-0E1H0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0AT*7-70:/90*70%:+*9$0E0H0'6*-A$0-6B.?C606*70,.?/7A+$0
6:90/.-*,A0.<0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0?@./0*-70*77?:/,A$0:/90EQH0'6*-A06:70<:*+A90-.0,.I@+;0J*-60
-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0M;0A7,B.J*/C0-6A0<?/9709*BA,-A9&0
0

0

00

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 6 of 11

 .?B-70A/{.;0F*/6ABA/-0@.JAB0-.0A/<.B,A0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A*B0+:J<?+0.B9AB70-6B.?C60
,*%*+0,./-AI@-&G00 @:++./A0%&0/*-A90 -:-A7$0S>Q0& &00UN$004U0E1>>=H&00 *%*+0,./-AI@-07:/,-*./70
:BA0@A/:+-*A70F9A7*C/A90-.0,.I@A+0<?-?BA0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60:0,.?B-0.B9AB&G0 /-D+0 /*./$0 /*-A90
(*/A0'.BRAB70.<0 I&0%&0V:CJA++$0N100 & &0201$02040E1>>SH&00 6A7A07:/,-*./707AB%A0-J.0
@?B@.7A7)0F./A0,.AB,*%A0:/90-6A0.-6AB0,.I@A/7:-.B;&G00 :BB*70%&0 *-;0.<0 6*+:&$0S40 &Q901Q11$0
1Q020EQ90 *B&01>>NH0E,*-*/C0V:CJA++$0N100& &020220>H&00 .AB,*%A07:/,-*./70:*I0F-.0,.AB,A0-6A0
9A<A/9:/-0*/-.0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0,.?B-D70.B9AB0:/90-.0,.I@A/7:-A0<.B0+.77A707?7-:*/A90M;0-6A0
9*7.MA9*A/,A&G00(,"./:+9D70 .B@&0%&0 *,-.B;0 /%A7-IA/-7$04040 &09020$0240EQ90 *B&01>2SH&00 6*70
*/,+?9A70:?-6.B*-;0-.0*I@B*7./0-6A0,./-AI/.B0F*/9A<*/*-A+;0?/-*+06A0,.I@+*A70J*-60:/0:<<*BI:-*%A0
,.II:/9&G00 6:9J*,R0%&0L:/A,R:$0Q100 &Q90N>4$0U=20EQ90 *B&00==0H0E*I@B*7./*/C0:--.B/A;0<.B0
;A:B70<.B0,*%*+0,./-AI@-0.<0.B9AB0-.0@:;$0,*-*/C0#.I@AB70%&0V?,RD70 -.%A0€0 :/CA0 .&$00010& &0
S12$0SS00E1>11HH&00 .I@A/7:-.B;07:/,-*./70FI:RA0BA@:B:-*./0-.0-6A0*/{?BA90@:B-;0:/90BA7-.BA0-6A0
@:B-*A70-.0-6A0@.7*-*./0-6A;0J.?+906:%A06A+906:90-6A0*/{?/,-*./0MAA/0.MA;A9&G00 A/-?B;0010 A:+0
 7-:-A0 .B@&0%&0"*#A//:B.0 A:+0 7-:-A$0 /,&$0!.&0   & &=13>4>$00==00' 010UUQ1$0:-0Q0E &"&0
 :&0L:/&0Q1$00==0H&0
 .0A7-:M+*760,./-AI@-$0:0I.%:/-0I?7-0@B.%A0M;0,+A:B0:/90,./%*/,*/C0A%*9A/,A)00FE1H0-6:-0
:0%:+*90.B9AB0.<0-6A0,.?B-0AT*7-A9‚0E0H0-6:-0-6A09A<A/9:/-706:90R/.J+A9CA0.<0-6A0.B9AB‚0:/90EQH0-6:-0
-6A09A<A/9:/-709*7.MA;A90-6A0.B9AB&G00(:B76:R0%&0 BA:9JA++$0N>N0 &Q90S42$0S2N0EQ90 *B&00==>H0
E:<<*BI*/C0.B9AB0.<0,./-AI@-0<.B0%*.+:-*./0.<0*/{?/,-*./H&00 709A-:*+A90MA+.J$0,./-AI@-0*70
:@@B.@B*:-A0M:7A90?@./0'6*-AD70<:*+?BA0-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&00 ƒ„…†$0-6A0L?+;01$0
0=1>05B9AB0*70%:+*9$0,.9*<;*/C0L?9CA0 +:--D70 J:B90:70:/05B9AB0.<0-6A0 .?B-&009‡ˆ‰Š‹$0-6B.?C60
6*70,.?/7A+$0'6*-A06:90R/.J+A9CA0.<0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&004Œƒ„‹$0*-0*70?/9*7@?-A90-6:-0'6*-A0
6:70<:*+A90-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0M;0A7,B.J*/C0-6A0<?/9709*BA,-A9&00 6A0 .?B-0
0

0

Q0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 7 of 11

I?7-06.+90'6*-A0*/0,./-AI@-0-.0,.I@A+0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0:/90-.0@B.-A,-0
 6B*%A7-0<B.I0-6A0B*7R0.<09*77*@:-*./0@A/9*/C0BA7.+?-*./0.<0-6A0:BM*-B:-*./0./0-6A0IAB*-7&00

x3 4Œ‡3Ž3‘’3“”‘•3
„‹‡„31…3 –ƒ‹x3
 6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0*70:0%:+*90:/90M*/9*/C05B9AB0-6:-0,./<*BIA90-6A0 J:B90M;0
CB:/-*/C0 6B*%A7-D70 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0-.0 ./<*BI&000
 /0.B9AB0,./<*BI*/C0:/0:BM*-B:-*./0:J:B90F76:++06:%A0-6A07:IA0<.B,A0:/90A<<A,-$0*/0:++0
BA7@A,-7$0:7$0:/90MA07?M{A,-0-.0:++0-6A0@B.%*7*./70.<0+:J0BA+:-*/C0-.$0:0{?9CIA/-0*/0:/0:,-*./‚0:/90*-0
I:;0MA0A/<.B,A90:70*<0*-06:90MAA/0BA/9ABA90*/0:/0:,-*./0*/0-6A0,.?B-0*/0J6*,60*-0*70A/-ABA9&G0>0
& & & &0—01Q‚0".I?7$0 /,&0%&0":%*73#*.%*/:˜˜.0 ./7-&0 .&$0!.&0   & &01=31UNS$00=110' 0
QUUUS2N$0:-0U0E &"&0 :&0 ?C&000$00=11H0E6.+9*/C0-6:-0:0{?9CIA/-0,./<*BI*/C0:/0:BM*-B:-*./0
:J:B90F76:++06:%A0-6A07:IA0<.B,A0:/90A<<A,-G0:70:0{?9CIA/-0A/-ABA90M;0-6A0 .?B-H‚0 B?7-AA70.<0
!AJ0 .BR0 *-;0"*7-&0 .?/,*+0.<0 :B@A/-AB70 A/7*./0 ?/90%&0#:+J:;0"A%&0 .B@&$0!.&01>0   &0
0420E   H$00=1>0' 01NU441Q$0:-0S0E &"&!& &0 @B&01=$00=1>H0E6.+9*/C0-6:-0F :}/0.B9AB0
,./<*BI*/C0:/0:BM*-B:-*./0:J:B90*70-.0MA0™9.,RA-A90:70*<0*-0J:70BA/9ABA90*/0:/0:,-*./$D0:/90™6:%A0
-6A07:IA0<.B,A0:/90A<<A,-G0:70:0{?9CIA/-0BA/9ABA90M;0-6A0 .?B-H0EO?.-*/C0>0& & &0—01QH&000
F .?B-70-B:9*-*./:++;06:%A0MB.:90@.JAB70-.0A/<.B,A0-6A*B0.J/0,.II:/97\*<0:0,.?B-0
,://.-0A/<.B,A0*-70.J/0B?+A70:/90.B9AB7$0*-0*70@.JAB+A77&G0 ++A/05BC:/0 .&0%&0#:+:/-*05BC:/0
V?*+9AB7$0 /,&$0!.&0   &0 &02>34UQU$01>>10' 012QSQ0$0:-000E &"&0 :&0 A@-&010$01>>1H&00
 ,,.B9*/C+;$0:<-AB0,./<*BI*/C0:/0:BM*-B:-*./0:J:B90*/0:/0.B9AB$0:0 .?B-0,:/0A/<.B,A0-6A0.B9AB$0
:/90-6A0?/9AB+;*/C0:J:B9$0*<0./A0@:B-;0<:*+70-.0,.I@+;&00 AA0*9&0
 ABA$0-6ABA0,:/0MA0/.09*7@?-A0-6:-0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0*70%:+*90:/90-6:-0*-0,.9*<*A90-6A0
BA+*A<0,./-:*/A90*/0L?9CA0 +:--D70 J:B90:70:/05B9AB0.<0-6*70 .?B-&00'6*-A06:90:/0.@@.B-?/*-;0-.0
.@@.7A0 6B*%A7-D70 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0-.0 ./<*BI0:/909*907.&00 /0<:,-$0'6*-A07.?C6-0-.0%:,:-A0-6A0
0

0

S0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 8 of 11

 J:B90./0CB.?/970-6:-0-6*70 .?B-0BA{A,-A90*/0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&00 6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0*70
%:+*90:/90'6*-A0I?7-0,.I@+;0J*-60*-&00 M7A/-0,.I@+*:/,A$06A076.?+90MA06A+90*/0,./-AI@-&00
yx3 wŒƒ†‡35–‹3zŠ‰š‡‹›‡3
œ34Œ‡3Ž3‘’3“”‘•3
„‹‡„x03
'6*-A06:706:90R/.J+A9CA0.<0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB07*/,A0*-70*77?:/,A&00 6A0 .?B-0*77?A90
-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0-6B.?C60-6A0 .?B-D70 :7A0(:/:CAIA/-Z +A,-B./*,0 :7A0 *+A70E (Z   H0
7;7-AI&00 --.B/A;0'..9$0'6*-AD70,.?/7A+$0*70:0BAC*7-ABA90?7AB0.<0-6A0 (Z   07;7-AI0:70
A%*9A/,A90M;06*70A+A,-B./*,0<*+*/C0.<0'6*-AD705@@.7*-*./0-.0 6B*%A7-D70 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0-.0
 ./<*BI&00E   0!.&00QH&00 6ABA<.BA$0?@./0-6A0<*+*/C0.<0:/;09.,?IA/-0*/0-6*70:,-*./$0*/,+?9*/C0-6A0
L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB$0 --.B/A;0'..90BA,A*%A90*IIA9*:-A0/.-*<*,:-*./0.<0-6A0<*+*/C0%*:0A3I:*+&00
!.-*,A0-.0 --.B/A;0'..9$0:70'6*-AD70:CA/-$0,./7-*-?-A70/.-*,A0-.0'6*-A&000
 ABA$0-6A0 .?B-07AB%A90-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0./0 --.B/A;0'..90-6B.?C60-6A0 (Z   0
7;7-AI0,./7*7-A/-0J*-60 ?+A0SEMHE1H0.<0-6A0 A9AB:+0 ?+A70.<0 *%*+0 B.,A9?BA$0J6*,60@B.%*9A70-6:-0
F *}<0:0@:B-;0*70BA@BA7A/-A90M;0:/0:--.B/A;$07AB%*,A0?/9AB0-6*70B?+A0I?7-0MA0I:9A0./0-6A0:--.B/A;0
?/+A770-6A0,.?B-0.B9AB707AB%*,A0./0-6A0@:B-;&G00 ,,.B9*/C+;$0'6*-A0J:707AB%A90J*-6$0:/906:90
R/.J+A9CA0.<$0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0J6A/0 --.B/A;0'..90BA,A*%A90-6A05B9AB0./0L?+;01$00=1>&00
 A7-0-6ABA0MA0:/;09.?M-$0./0L?+;00$00=1>$0 6B*%A7-D70,.?/7A+0*/,+?9A90:0,.@;0.<0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>0
5B9AB0*/06*709AI:/90-.0 --.B/A;0'..90<.B0,.I@+*:/,A&00"A7@*-A0,+A:B0/.-*,A0.<0-6A0L?+;01$00=1>0
5B9AB$0'6*-A06:70<:*+A90-.0,.I@+;0:/906:70C*%A/0/.0*/9*,:-*./0-6:-06A0J*++0,.I@+;0*<0:<<.B9A90
:99*-*./:+0-*IA&00 ./-AI@-0*70-6A0:@@B.@B*:-A0BAIA9;0?/9AB0-6A0,*B,?I7-:/,A7&0
 x3 wŒƒ†‡35–…3 –ƒ‡‹3†‰3 ‰ž3wƒ†Œ34Œ‡3Ž3‘’3“”‘•3
„‹‡„x0
 709A-:*+A90:M.%A$0'6*-A06:70<:*+A90-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0M;09A@.7*-*/C0
P1$0N=$===&==0*/-.0A7,B.J0J*-606*70:--.B/A;0@A/9*/C0BA7.+?-*./0.<0-6A0@:B-*A7D09*7@?-A0./0-6A0
IAB*-7&00 +-6.?C60'6*-AD70,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0 J:B90J:70+./C0.%AB9?A0:-0-6A0-*IA0.<0-6A0L?+;0
0

0

N0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 9 of 11

1$00=1>05B9AB$0 6B*%A7-0:<<.B9A906*I0?/-*+0L?+;0N$00=1>0-.0,.I@+;&00 -0*70/.J0L?+;0>$00=1>0:/90
'6*-A07-*++06:70/.-0,.I@+*A9$0/.B06:706A0*/9*,:-A90:/0*/-A/-*./0-.0,.I@+;0J*-60:99*-*./:+0-*IA&00000
8x3  ‰‡„ˆƒŸ‡39–Šˆ†ƒ‰Š…3
„‡3
žž„‰ž„ƒ–†‡x0
 6B*%A7-07AAR70-.0*/%.RA0-6A0 .?B-D70,./-AI@-0@.JAB70-.0@B.I@-0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0
L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&00 6A0 6*B90 *B,?*-06:70I:9A0,+A:B0-6:-0-6A0 .?B-06:70J*9A09*7,BA-*./0*/0
<:76*./*/C0:0,*%*+0,./-AI@-0BAIA9;&0 AA0"A+:J:BA0 :++A;0 *-*˜A/7D0 .?/,*+0<.B0 +A:/0 *B0%&0
 .I&0.<0 :&$0U420 &090S4=$0S420EQ90 *B&01>20H&000
L?9CA0 +:--0*77?A90AIABCA/,;0BA+*A<0*/0-6A0?/9AB+;*/C0:BM*-B:-*./0M:7A90./0-6A0+*RA+*6..90
-6:-0'6*-A0J.?+909*77*@:-A0-6A0<?/970*/0,./-B.%AB7;0MA<.BA0:09A,*7*./0./0-6A0IAB*-7&00 6*70 .?B-0
,./<*BIA90-6A0 J:B9&00 M7A/-0ATAB,*7A0.<0-6A0 .?B-D70,./-AI@-0@.JAB7$0'6*-A0J*++0,./-*/?A0-.0
*C/.BA0L?9CA0 +:--D70 J:B90:/90-6*70 .?B-D70L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB$0AT@.7*/C0 6B*%A7-0-.0-6A0%AB;0
B*7R0.<09*77*@:-*./0-6:-0@B.I@-A90-6A0AIABCA/,;0BA+*A<0*/0-6A0<*B7-0*/7-:/,A&00 6B*%A7-0BAO?A7-70-6:-0
-6A0 .?B-0*I@.7A0,.AB,*%A07:/,-*./70-.0<.B,A0,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB0:/90-6A/$0*<0
'6*-A0,./-*/?A706*709*7.MA9*A/,A$0*I@B*7./0'6*-A0?/-*+06A0,.I@+*A7&000
 *B7-$0 6B*%A7-0BAO?A7-70-6:-0-6A0 .?B-0*I@.7A0:0<*/A0.<0PN==&==0@AB09:;0<.B0A:,609:;0.<0
'6*-AD70/./3,.I@+*:/,A&00 AA0 ++:0 :-AB/:,R0%&0VB?,A0 &0 +*A/$0A-0:+&$0 *%*+0 ,-*./0!.&01S3
004N$0 ,6*++AB$0L&0E &"&0 :&0 @B*+004$00=14H0E*I@.7*/C0:0<*/A0.<0P0N=&==0@AB09:;0<.B0A:,609:;0.<0
/./,.I@+*:/,A0J*-60:07A--+AIA/-0:CBAAIA/-H&00 A,./9$0 6B*%A7-0BAO?A7-70-6:-0-6A0 .?B-0<BAA˜A0
'6*-AD70:,,.?/-70:/90BA7-B*,-0/./3IA9*,:+0AT@A/9*-?BA70:/9Z.B0-B:/7<AB70.<0I.BA0-6:/0PN==0
:M7A/-0,.?B-0:@@B.%:+0?/+A770:/90?/-*+0'6*-A0,.I@+*A70J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&00 6*70
7:/,-*./0*70JA++0J*-6*/0-6A0 .?B-D709*7,BA-*./0-.0<:76*./0:/0:@@B.@B*:-A0,./-AI@-0BAIA9;0:/90
,.?+90@B.I@-0'6*-A0-.0,.I@+;0J*-60-6A0L?+;01$00=1>05B9AB&0

0

0

U0

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 10 of 11

6x3  ‰ž‡Š…–†‰„39–Šˆ†ƒ‰Š…3
„‡3
žž„‰ž„ƒ–†‡x3
 6B*%A7-0BAO?A7-70-6:-0-6A0 .?B-0.B9AB0'6*-A0-.0@:;0 6B*%A7-D70:--.B/A;70<AA70:/90,.7-70*/0
,.//A,-*./0J*-60-6*70I.-*./0:70:0,.I@A/7:-.B;07:/,-*./&00 6A0 .?B-06:70-6A0@.JAB0-.0A/-AB0BA+*A<0
-.0BA7-.BA0-6A0@:B-*A70-.0-6A0@.7*-*./0-6A;0J.?+906:%A06A+90*<0'6*-A06:90.MA;A90-6A0L?+;01$00=1>0
5B9AB&00 AA0 :B9*./A-$0   0%&0(A9/A-0 A:+-6,:BA0 A,67&$0 /,&$01SU0 &0 ?@@&0Q90U41$0U>00E &"&0
 :&00=1NH0E6.+9*/C0-6:-0,.I@A/7:-.B;07:/,-*./70:BA0:%:*+:M+A0*/0,*%*+0,./-AI@-0@B.,AA9*/C70J6A/0
-6A0:J:B90.<0:--.B/A;7D0<AA70,:/0BA7-.BA0-6A0*/{?BA90@:B-;0-.0-6A0@.7*-*./0*-0J.?+906:%A0.,,?@*A90
6:90-6A0,./-AI/.B0,.I@+*A90J*-60-6A0 .?B-0.B9AB0*/0O?A7-*./H&00 ABA$0 6B*%A7-0J.?+906:%A0/.-0
6:%A0*/,?BBA90-6A0<AA70:/90,.7-70BA+:-*/C0-.0-6A0 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0 ./-AI@-0M?-0<.B0'6*-AD70
<:*+?BA0-.0,.I@+;&00 6ABA<.BA$0 6B*%A7-0BAO?A7-70-6:-0-6A0 .?B-0.B9AB0'6*-A0-.0@:;0 6B*%A7-D70<AA70
:/90,.7-70:70:0,.I@A/7:-.B;07:/,-*./&0
111x3  
2  791
23
 .B0-6A0<.BAC.*/C0BA:7./7$0 6B*%A7-0BA7@A,-<?++;0BAO?A7-70-6:-0-6A0 .?B-0CB:/-0*-70
 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0 ./-AI@-0:/90A/-AB0:/05B9AB0*/0-6A0<.BI0@B.@.7A9&0
 A7@A,-<?++;07?MI*--A9$00
0
Z7Z0 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA00 0 0 0
 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA0
 B*,0 &0 AA9$0 7O?*BA0
 5[0 5       "0   0
0===0(:BRA-0 -BAA-\0=-60 +..B0
 6*+:9A+@6*:$0  01>1=Q0
E01NH00>>302NS0
E01NH00>>301N=0E<:,7*I*+AH0
]^^_`abcdef_`e¡onia^iffee
0 0
":-A9)0L?+;0>$00=1>0

0

0

40

 0

Case 2:18-cv-01877-AB Document 26 Filed 07/09/19 Page 11 of 11

1234563721468394
46938194 1 43 
7 43
 
 345636
946 238194 1 43
 3 6229   
21
3
3
        0         0  !" !#$0   $0 )00
0)00
)0 *%*+0 ,-*./0!.&00)123  312440
0 %&0
)00
0
)0
'     (0 &0'    $00
0
 6 41 1 
463
 396  1 63
 06ABAM;0,AB-*<;0-6:-0./0-6A0>-609:;0.<0L?+;$00=1>$0 0,:?7A90-6A0 IABCA/,;0(.-*./0<.B0
 ./-AI@-0-.0MA0<*+A90J*-60-6A0 .?B-0%*:0-6A0 .?B-D70A+A,-B./*,0<*+*/C07;7-AI0J6*,60@B.%*9A70
/.-*,A0-.0:++0,.?/7A+0.<0BA,.B9$0*/,+?9*/C)0
 .MAB-0'..9$0 7O?*BA0
'..90 :J0 *I*-A90
U20!.B-60 *C60 -BAA-0
V?*+9*/C0V$0 ?*-A00=00
!AJ0 +M:/;$056*.0SQ=NS0
]^^_`abcdef_`e¢iooin£e¤¥e¢hi^be
e
Z7Z0 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA00 0 0 0
 A-AB0 &0V?,R+A;$0 7O?*BA0
 B*,0 &0 AA9$0 7O?*BA0
 5[0 5       "0   0
0===0(:BRA-0 -BAA-\0=-60 +..B0
 6*+:9A+@6*:$0  01>1=Q0
E01NH00>>302NS0
E01NH00>>301N=0E<:,7*I*+AH0
]^^_`abcdef_`egh`ijbd^eklbmino^cepqariasteuuv0

0

0

20