Case 1:17-cv-00877-MMS Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page 1 of 6 In the United States Court of Federal Claims No. 17-877 C Filed: October 22, 2019 COMMON GROUND HEALTHCARE COOPERATIVE, on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated RULE 54(b) JUDGMENT v. THE UNITED STATES Pursuant to the court’s Opinion and Order, filed February 15, 2019, granting plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment and denying defendant’s motion to dismiss; and Order, filed October 22, 2019, directing the entry of judgment under Rule 54(b), there being no just reason for delay, IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED this date, pursuant to Rule 58, that judgment is entered for the cost-sharing reduction (CSR) class in the amount of $1,587,108,397.81, with the CSR class members entitled to the amounts set forth in the attached table. Plaintiff is entitled to costs. Lisa L. Reyes Clerk of Court By: s/ Debra L. Samler Deputy Clerk NOTE: As to appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, 60 days from this date, see RCFC 58.1, re number of copies and listing of all plaintiffs. Filing fee is $505.00. Case Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page 2 of 6 2017Damages .. 2017+20180amages . CLASS ACTION ISSUERS 77606 AMERIHEALTH HMO, INC. 3,047,605.42 3,047,605.42 91762 INS COMPANY OF NEW JERSEY 32,618,681.42 32,618,681.42 86584 ASPIRUS ARISE HEALTH PLAN OF WJSCONSIN, INC. 5 2,019,112.83 5,721,342.44 23 7,740,455.27 32536 ATRIO HEALTH PLANS, INC. 744,629.96 744,629.96 60536 AVERA HEALTH PLANS, INC. 9,586,878.41 9,586,878.41 15287 BLUE CROSS 81 BLUE SHIELD OF RHODE ISLAND 2,384,359.45 4,095,632.21 6,479,991.66 46944 BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF ALABAMA 18558 BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF KANSAS, INC. 32,292,758.48 32,292,75848 26065 BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF SOUTH CAROLINA 7,429,833.05 124,625,47903 132,055,312.08 27811 BLUECROSS BLUESHEELD KANSAS SOLUTIONS, INC. 5 4,440,640.38 4,440,640.38 BOSTON MEDICAL CENTER HEALTH PLAN, INC. 82569 BOSTON MEDICAL CENTER HEALTHNET PLAN 5 15,402,807.36 $4,854,071.27 70,256,878.63 70285 SERVICE BLUE SHIELD OF CALIFORNIA 3,555,835.11 155,399,758.50 158,955,593.61 45127 CAPITAL ADVANTAGE ASSURANCE COMPANY 43,610.93 12,570,291.68 12,613,902.61 28137 CAREFIRST BLUECHOICE, INC. 418,513.76 22,856,588.53 23,275,102.29 86052 .CAREFIRST BLUECHOECE, INC. 32,233.00 32,233.00 10207 CAREFERST BLUECHOTCE, INC. 335,195.47 1,324,970.10 1,660,165.57 45532 .CAREFIRST OF MARYLAND, INC. 528,650.22 1,814,032.42 2,342,682.64 77552 SCARESOURCE 3,622,711.49 26,162,878.94 29,785,590.43 54192 ICARESOURCE INDIANA, INC. 1,732,023.65 24,030,047.16 25,762,070.81 45636 CARESOURCE KENTUCKY CO. 4,303,746.23 17,716,337.86 22,020,084.09 50328 RCE WEST VIRGINIA c0. 5 89,800.35 5 4,816,047.85 4,905,848.20 Case Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page 3 Of 6 201703919394: ZOIBDamages 1?17 +201809mages 94788 5 5,018.48 5 39,551.94 5 44,570.42 14630 COMMUNITY HEALTH PLAN 5 426,521.77 5 20,086,027.47 5 2051254924 47579 CHINESE COMMUNITY HEALTH PLAN 72034 CHRISTUS HEALTH PLAN 5 680,352.03 5 680,352.03 66252 CHRISTUS HEALTH PLAN 5 121,354.15 5 12,174,529.60 5 12,295,883.75 87416 COMMON GROUND HEALTHCARE COOPERATIVE 5 10,542,927.12 5 46,286,304.63 5 56,829,231.75 18581 COMMUNITY HEALTH PLAN OF WASHINGTON 27,437.69 5 27,437.69 38345 DEAN HEALTH PLAN 5 4,955,476.60 5 11,102,317.80 5 66699 DENVER HEALTH MEDICAL PLAN, INC 5 6,063.52 5 413,674.24 5 419,737.76 78124 EXCELLUS HEALTH PLAN, INC. 5 15,291.35 5 238,299.05 5 253,590.40 88806 FALLON COMMUNITY HEALTH PLAN, INC. 5 26,283.75 5 3,496,255.83 5 3,522,539.58 63312 FRIDAY HEALTH PLANS 5 200,244.19 5 1,785,778.01 5 1,986,022.20 22444 GEISINGER HEALTH PLAN 5 18,448,47336 5 18,448,47336 34102 GROUP HEALTH PLAN, INC. 5 78,756.48 5 754,533.00 5 833,289.48 40308 GROUP HOSPITALIZATION AND MEDICAL SERVICES INC. 5 669,613.84 5 698,846.25 5 1,368,460.09 GROUP HOSPITALIZATION AND MEDICAL SERVICES, 78079 INC. 5 90.00 5 34,777.41 5 34,867.41 GROUP HDSPITALIZATION AND MEDICAL SERVICES, 94084 INC. 5 389,536.09 5 395,647.98 5 785,184.07 91058 GUNDERSEN HEALTH PLAN, INC. 5 160,545.91 5 160,545.91 18350 HAWAII MEDICAL SERVICE ASSOCIATION 5 4,024,958.29 5 4,024,958.29 36194 HEALTH FIRST COMMERCIAL PLANS, INC. 5 2,817,386.96 5 2,817,386.96 95865 HEALTH PLAN OF NEVADA, INC. 5 1037319440 5 1037319440 20173 HEALTHPARTNERS INSURANCE COMPANY 5 1,037,501.77 5 1,037,501.77 19636 HMO LOUISIANA, INC. 5 33,165.59 5 43,202,480.58 5 43,235,646.17 3.1609 INDEPENDENCE BLUE CROSS (QCC :Ns. CO.) 5 2,267,519.74 510,062,712.51 5 12,330,232.25 21032 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OF COLO. 5 13,489,220.40 5 13,489,220.40 89-942 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OP GEORGIA 5 156,398.60 5 $1,089,026.15 5 51,245,424.75 Case Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page 4 of 6 201704188 2017+20180amaa KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OF THE MID- 90296 ATLANTIC STATES, INC. 63,371.39 26,513,262.17 26,576,633.56 95185 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OF THE ATLANTIC STATES, INC. 61,701.69 38,056,818.93 38,118,520.62 94506 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OF THE MID- ATLANTIC STATES, INC. 1,224.78 55,430.36 56,655.14 80473 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN OF WASHINGTON 1,110,167.97 10,307,941.21 11,418,109.18 60612 KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, INC. 24,215.34 3,511,518.83 3,535,734.17 40513 FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, INC. 261,138.16 64,873,62899 65,134,767.15 71287 KAISER FOUNDATION OF THE NW 9 14,310.27 5 7,964,082.28 7,978,392.55 23371 KAISER FOUNDATION OF THE NW 5 404,267.71 5 2,391,083.25 2,795,350.96 33871 KEYSTONE HEALTH PLAN EAST, ENC 34,872,091.13 34,872,091.13 38498 LIFEWISE HEALTH PLAN OF WA 976,334.93 4,986,181.98 5,962,516.91 LOUISIANA HEALTH SERVICE 97176 COMPANY, BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF LOUISIANA 40,501.02 1,949,070.66 1,989,571.68 58594 MERIDIAN HEALTH PLAN OF MICHIGAN, INC. 262,197.21 $1,349,340.00 1,611,537.21 11177 METROPLUS HEALTH PLAN 25,454.56 305,038.90 330,493.46 73331 MINUTEMAN HEALTH, INC 287,589.87 287,589.87 61163 MINUTEMAN HEALTH, INC 5 1,067,484.30 6 1,067,484.30 39424 MODA HEALTH PLAN, INC. 11,020,016.97 11,020,016.97 56184 MVP HEALTH PLAN, INC. 463,460.26 659,118.21 1,122,578.47 77566 EMVP HEALTH PLAN, INC. 406,386.81 4,770,789.34 5,177,176.15 81413 NETWORK HEALTH PLAN 457,083.57 1,863,260.62 2,320,344.19 93091VNEW MEXICO HEALTH CONNECTIONS 19,320.61 7,783,770.57 7,803,091.18 20507 OPTIMA HEALTH PLAN 4,455,124.77 45,519,92154 49,975,04631 23818 OSCAR GARDEN STATE TNSURANCE CORPORATION 5 1,670,792.24 1,670,792.24 Case Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page 5 Of 6 2mm zoxsomg zouzolsnma 10544 OSCAR HEALTH PLAN OE CALEFORNIA 2,868,234.47 2,868,234.47 23552 OSCAR INSURANCE COMPANY 5 7,251,042.10 7,251,042.10 20069 OSCAR INSURANCE COMPANY 1,332,495.62 $4,108,574.53 55,441,070.15 74289 .OSCAR INSURANCE CORPORATION 218,943.45 5 218,943.45 45845 OSCAR INSURANCE CORPORATION OE OHIO 3,073,467.50 3,073,467.50 60597 PACIFICSOURCE HEALTH PLANS 68,888.81 68,888.81 10091 PACIFICSOURCE HEALTH PLANS 2,855,185.77 2,855,185.77 23603 PACIFICSOURCE HEALTH PLANS 3,049,818.66 3,049,818.66 74313 PARAMOUNTINSURANCE COMPANY 536,850.12 536,850.12 60829 PHYSICIANS HEALTH PLAN 160,115.21 2,115,273.52 2,275,388.73 49831 PREMERA BLUE CROSS 1,139,974.36 6,956,926.22 8,096,900.58 38344 PREMERA BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF ALASKA 11,054,226.50 11,054,226.50 26734 PREMIER HEALTH PLAN, INC. 485,870.13 485,870.13 29698 PRIORITY HEALTH 9,497,198.62 14,592,689.48 24,089,888.10 37392 PROMINENCE HEALTHEIRST OF TEXAS, INC. 61,820.56 61,820.56 56707 PROVIDENCE HEALTH PLAN 18,003,012.55 18,003,012.55 38166 HEALTH PLAN OF WISCONSIN, INC. 5 313,857.88 19,853,798.12 20,167,656.00 26002 SELECTHEALTH 4,414,757.46 11,834,181.55 16,248,939.01 68781 SELECTHEALTH 16,341,918.82 90,677,77704 107,019,69586 26539 SHA, LLC 09A FIRSTCARE HEALTH PLANS 8,505,436.22 8,505,436.22 92499 SHARP HEALTH PLAN 25,312.75 4,197,709.69 4,223,022.44 52664 SUMMA INSURANCE COMPANY, INC. 21,128.56 1,676,637.09 1,697,765.65 59763 TUFTS HEALTH PUBLIC PLANS INC. 8,370,566.22 45,034,657.98 $3,405,224.20 85736 UCARE MENNESOTA 95,369.42 1,088,402.29 1,183,771.71 54235 UNITEOHEALTHCARE OF NEW YORK, INC. 18,557.38 88,123.67 106,681.05 38599 UNITEDHEALTHCARE OF THE MID-ATLANTIC INC 280,357.81 280,357.81 37833 UNITY HEALTH PLANS INSURANCE CORPORATION 2,589,106.18 12,506,806.19 15,095,912.37 42261 UNIVERSITY OF UTAH HEALTH INSURANCE PLANS 945,062.42 5 15,025,86494 15,970,927.36 Document 72 Filed 10/22/19 Page6of6 Case 1 16322 UPMC HEALTH OPTIONS, INC. 2018 Mg I 2,329,917.99 $8,669,887.09 40,999,805.08 75293 USABLE MUTUAL COMPANY 1,790,505.66 21,905,92113: 23,696,43279 67243 VANTAGE HEALTH PLAN, 2,019,226.88 2,019,226.88 93689 WESTERN HEALTH ADVANTAGE Mini/>01 2,796,242.31 2,796,242.31 1,587,108,397.81 5 131,172,069.27 2017mm '10 1,455,936,32854 7025113 1'